Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1999-06-28MINUTES CITY COUNCIUREDEVELOPMENT AGENCY CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH ADJOURNED REGULAR MEETING MONDAY, JUNE 28, 1999 7:30 A.M. - 9:00 A.M. - Pacific Courtyard Pavilion Waterfront Hotel, 21100 Pacific Coast Highway Huntington Beach, California, 92648 5:00 P.M. — (Closed Session) and 6:00 P.M. — (Open Session) - Council Chamber Civic Center, 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, California 92648 7:30 A.M. — Pacific Courtyard Pavilion CALL CITY COUNCIUREDEVELOPMENT AGENCY ADJOURNED REGULAR MEETING TO ORDER TO MEET JOINTLY WITH THE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TASK FORCE MEETING The meeting was called to order at 8:00 AM by the Mayor. CITY COUNCIUREDEVELOPMENT AGENCY ROLL CALL Present: Bauer, Garofalo, Green, Dettloff, Harman, Sullivan Absent: Julien Mayor Green requested that all participants introduce themselves. LIST OF MEETING PARTICIPANTS Tom Parkinson, Business Development Director Boeing Company John Given CIM Group, LLC Carol Runzel, Assistant Project Manager Economic Development Gus Duran, Housing & Rehabilitation Manager Economic Development Khanh Nguyen, Permit & Plan Check Manager Building & Safety Department Avi Shemesh CIM Group, LLC Bob Beardsley Public Works Director David C. Biggs Economic Development Director John Reekstin Administrative Services Director Ron Hagan Community Services Director 557 06/28/99 — Council/Agency Minutes --- Page 2 Jerome M. Bame, Attorney Jerome M. Bame Law Offices Eli Naffah, Development Specialist Economic Development Department Ron Lowenberg Chief of Police Carol Freeman, Chief Executive Officer Columbia Huntington Beach Hospital Kenneth Yglesias, Ed.D., President Golden Vilest College Richard Zamboni, President The Zamboni Company John Tillotson JT Development Diane Baker, President Huntington Beach Visitors & Conference Bureau Ken Bourguignon, President Dotken Engineering Ed Laird, President Coatings Resource Corporation Jim McLaughlin Tarbell Realtors Tom Adams Tiodize Company Chuck Schied Finance Board Todd Laplante Prime Properties Scott Field, Deputy Attorney City Attorney's Office Ray Silver, City Administrator City of Huntington Beach Deon Lewis, District Director Assemblyman Scott Baugh's Office Shari Friedenrich City Treasurer Jim Lamb, Project Manager Economic Development Department Joyce Riddell, CCE Huntington Beach Chamber of Commerce Duane Dishno, Superintendent Huntington Beach City School District Haydee Tillotson JT Development Curt Stalder, Senior Vice President Lee & Associates Steve Bone, President Robert Mayer Corporation Bruce Bearer, Senior Vice President Sares Regis Group Stephanie Metzler The Gas Company Jerry Dominguez, Regional Manager Southern California Edison Coy Baugh Pacific Care Bob Goodmanson C. B, Commercial Real Estate PRESENTATION REGARDING NEW DEVELOPMENT & WORLD TRADE AT THE PORT OF LONG BEACH (120.25) Mayor Green introduced Yvonne Avila, Director of Communications for the Port of Long Beach, who addressed new developments and world trade at the Port of Long Beach. The Port of Long Beach, which is the largest port in the United States, has a significant impact on the local economy as it affects all of our businesses and different aspects of our daily lives. 558 06/28/99 — Council/Agency Minutes — Page 3 Ms. Avila is also Vice President of the Foreign Trade Association of Southern California and President-elect of the International Business Association, She presented a portfolio that includes the following handouts: The Port of Long Beach: Economic Impact The Port of Long Beach: 1998 Annual Report— Moving On, Staying Ahead Ms. Avila presented a slide report entitled, The Port of Long Beach: The successes, the Challenges, the Future, which has the following titles: Commodities Moved Through Long Beach The Challenge: Escalating Trade Port Container Growth 1998 Top U. S. Containerports 1998 Top World Containerports Why We Have Grown The Impact of Larger Ships The Impact of lntermodalism Regional Demand National Demand The Intermodal Advantage Other Reasons for Our Success Relationship with City Government Relationship with State Government Port of Long Beach Organization How We Respond to Growth: We Expand New Hanjin Terminal Economic Impact of Construction The Next Step Naval Construction Impact Further Landfill Infrastructure Improvements Accommodating Trains Adding New Tracks Grade Separations Alameda Corridor Alameda Corridor Design (2 slides) Alameda Corridor Construction Next Phase of Construction Alameda Corridor Funding Our Future Growth = Prosperity Long-term Projections Economic Impact of Future Growth Unknown influences 1997 vs. 1998 Container Growth Other Unknown Factors Our Goal The Port of Long Beach Ms. Avila elaborated on how port container growth has risen 150% since 1990. She stated that the Port of Long Beach surpassed the Port of Los Angeles five years ago. The Port of Long Beach, which rates at 4, rivals even the Port of Los Angeles at 3.7, as being the top U. S. 559 06/28/99 — Council/Agency Minutes — Page 4 containerport in 1998. For the same year at the international level, the ports of Long Beach and Los Angeles collectively rate at 7.5, with Singapore leading the world at 15.1. Intermodalism is the method of movement used: Each ship that leaves the Port of Long Beach carries 5000-plus containers, requiring deeper water and more storage. In order for the Port of Long Beach to meet its regional shipping demands, one-half of ail Long Beach cargo must stay in the area and be moved by truck carrier, and to meet its national demands, one-half of all Long Beach cargo must move east of the Rockies. The timetable for freight to leave Long Beach and arrive in Chicago is three to four days, and in New York, it is five to six days. A brief question and answer period followed, at which time Ms. Avila brought up a transportation study alternative to using the 710 freeway and avoiding the truck problem, which would be to use an on -deck rail system on the Henry Ford. Both the Long Beach and Los Angeles ports would be paying for this alternate route. (CITY COUNCILIREDEVELOPMENT AGENCY) UPDATE ON CURRENT AND PLANNED DEVELOPMENTS FOR THE HILTON OCEAN GRAND AND WATERFRONT BEACH RESORTS A presentation was made by Steve Bone, President. Steve Bone pointed out that the site of the interim -use pavillion (outlined by the green fence) has the same square footage — 3.5 acres — as the HAton site of the Third Hotel, which will have 150 parking spaces. It will take four to six years to be built, and the purpose of the Third Hotel is as yet unknown. He also gave an update that the Pacific Grand Resort, which is slated for a ground -breaking ceremony in the fall, is scheduled for completion around April, 2001. It is anticipated to generate $2 to $3 million yearly in Transient Occupancy Tax revenue to the city, not including increment tax. It will have 520 rooms, 24,000 square feet of space, and two resorts. Steve Bone expressed his gratitude and that of the Mayer family to all levels at City Hall for the entitlements they received. A discussion was held regarding construction and signing of the contracts, at which time Counciimember Bauer asked how we can coordinate different modes of transportation to converge on the city and thus promote business. Steve Bone suggested that the city contact organizations at the regional and local levels to accomplish this. PUBLIC COMMENTS There were no persons present to address Council regarding the closed session items scheduled on the agenda. RECESS OF COUNCIL/AGENCY MEETING: To 5:00 p.m., in the Council Chambers, 2000 Main Street, to reconvene this City Council/Redevelopment Agency meeting to consider closed session items. 560 06/28/99 — CouncillAgency Minutes — Page 5 5:00 P.M. — RECONVENE CITY COUNCILIREDEVELOPM ENT AGENCY MEETING — COUNCIL CHAMBER CITY COUNCIUREDEVELOPMENT AGENCY ROLL CALL Present, Bauer, Garofalo, Green, Dettloff, Harman, Sullivan (arrived at 5:10 PM) Absent: None PUBLIC COMMENTS REGARDING CLOSED SESSION AGENDA ITEMS There were no persons present to address Council regarding the closed session items scheduled on the agenda. MOTION TO RECESS TO CLOSED SESSION — APPROVED (120.80) A motion was made by Harman, second Bauer to recess to closed session on the following items. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Julien, Green, Dettloff, Harman NOES: None ABSENT: Bauer, Garofalo and Sullivan out of the room. Closed session — City Council pursuant to Government Code Section 54957.6 to meet with its designated representatives William Osness, Personnel Director, and Daniel Cassidy, Esquire, Liebert, Cassidy and Frierson, regarding labor relations matters - meet and confer with the following employee organizations: MSOA, POA, PMA, MEA, MEO, HBFA and SCLEA. (120.80) 1 Closed session — City Council pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9(c) (Based on existing facts and circumstances, the legislative body of the local agency has decided to initiate or is deciding whether to initiate litigation.) Number of Potential Cases 1. Subject: City of Huntington Beach v. Kemper Insurance Companies. (120.80) Closed session — City Council pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9(a) to confer with its attorney regarding pending litigation which has been initiated formally and to which the city is a party. The title of the litigation is Russell v. Frazier, et al., - Orange County Superior Court Case No. 792562. Subject: Russell v. Frazier, et al. (120.80) 6:00 P.M. -- RECONVENE CITY COUNCILIREDEVELOPMENT AGENCY Present: Bauer, Garofalo, Green, Dettloff, Harman, Sullivan Absent None CITY ATTORNEY REPORT The Deputy City Attorney reported on the following actions taken by the City Council in closed session as required by law (Government Code §54957.1(a)(3)(b)). 561 06128/99 -- Council/Agency Minutes — Page 6 (CITY COUNCIL) REPORT OF ACTION TAKEN AT CLOSED SESSION OF MARCH 15, 1999 REGARDING DEFERRED COMPENSATION PROGRAM — SALE OF REAL PROPERTY LOCATED AT 13947 IRIS DRIVE TO RAUL AND ALICIA RODRIGUEZ (120.80) At its March 15, 1999 closed session, the City Council authorized the City Administrator to sell the city employee's trust property held in the city's Deferred Compensation Plan, and located at 13947 Iris Drive, Fontana, California, to Raul and Alicia Rodriguez for not less than $53,500 cash. On April 29, 1999, escrow for the property closed and the title transferred to the Rodriguezes, who paid $60,000 for the property. After paying off the First Trust Deed and the costs of closing, the city (as trustor) netted $25,871.45. (CITY COUNCIL) REPORT OF ACTION TAKEN AT CLOSED SESSAN OF JUNE 21, 1999 REGARDING TALBERT & BEACH V. CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH -- U.S. DISTRICT COURT CASE NO. SACV 96-969 AHS; 9T" CIR. 97-55619 (120,80) On Monday, June 21, 1999, the City Council convened in closed session to discuss the matter of Talbert & Beach v. City of Huntington Beach, U.S. District Court Case No. SACV 96-969 AHS; V' Cir. 97-55619. City Council gave its approval to settle this case and authorized the Mayor to sign the Settlement Agreement and the City Clerk to attest to it The Council voted as follows: 7 Ayes; 0 Nos; 0 Abstentions. CITY CLERK ANNOUNCES LATE COMMUNICATIONS WHICH PERTAIN TO ITEMS ON THE AGENDA Pursuant to the Brown Act, the City Clerk announced the following late communications regarding agenda items that had been received following the distribution of the agenda: Slide show presentation from the Assistant City Administrator dated June 28, 1999 entitled, Bolsa Chica June 28, 1999 Presentation to the Huntington Beach City Council. Communication from Congressman Norm Dicks and Senator Barbara Boxer to Bruce Babbitt, Secretary of the Interior, dated November 20, 1998 regarding the appraisal of the Bolsa Chica mesa. Communication from Eileen Murphy, 201 215t Street, Huntington Beach dated June 28, 1999 in opposition to the proposed pre -annexation agreement of the Bolsa Chica including the Mesa development project. Communication from the Amigas de Bolsa Chica dated June 28, 1999 providing statements of the members. Communication from the United States Department of Interior, Fish and Wildlife Service in response to the letter from Congressman Norm Dicks and Senator Barbara Boxer regarding the appraisal of the Bolsa Chica Mesa. Communication from Huntington Beach Tomorrow dated June 28, 1999 signed by Bob Wiinchell, President. 562 06/28/99 — CouncillAgency Minutes — Page 7 PUBLIC COMMENTS TOM LIVENGOOD, representative of Amigos de Bolsa Chica, expressed his disappointment that none of the environmental issues on the 117 item, council adopted list of negotiation points were included in the draft agreement. He disagreed with page 4 of the staff's report that environmental issues specific to development of the mesa are left to the Coastal Commission and the county. He believes that Hearthside Home's agreement to become a willing seller is very positive, and urged City Council to continue pre -annexation negotiations with the goal to include the previously specified environmental impact issues. LINDA MOON, Vice President of Amigos de Bolsa Chica, was concerned that representation of the city by the Coastal Commission and the County to obtain approval of the Local Coastal Permit "muzzles" the city. She stated that the City Council has the fundamental fiduciary duty, and that the city cannot legally bargain away this responsibility. She strongly opposed any agreement between the City and Hearthside Homes that limits the city's ability to advocate appropriate environmental protections on behalf of the citizens of Huntington Beach. TERRY DOLTON, representative of Amigos de Bolsa Chica, supported the inclusion of an option to purchase the mesa in the pre -annexation agreement, but pointed out some critical flaws: one, that the agreement can be terminated by anyone, and two, that the option is too short — one year's time. He stated that the point of the problem is that there must have a willing seller, and that there is no reason that the option cannot be open-ended. He also mentioned that to assure that the width is sufficient, and that title to a 100 foot wide bluff buffer area from the top of the mesa will be transferred to the city, provision for an irrevocable offer of dedication should be part of the pre -annexation agreement. He believes that there is no need for anything to be deferred. DAVID CARLBERG, President of Amigos de Bolsa Chica, stated that the Amigos have long opposed the concept of piece -meal planning, which makes it difficult to assess the overall environmental impact of a project. He stated that Hearthside has proposed to phase the annexation of Bolsa Chica, starting with a parcel of approximately 350 homes, about one-third of the maximum number of units proposed. He stated that this means two additional phases are to be annexed in the future. Mr. Carlberg informed Council he would like to see the whole picture, not fragments of it. CHUCK SCHIED, stated that it is impossible for the City Council to approve/di sapprove a pre - annexation agreement thirty days from tonight; that certain Orange County agreements are required, not "best efforts" by the developer. The developer is putting conditions that must be completed by .July 28, 1999, prior to the time that the evidence is submitted to the Public Utilities Commission on August 4, 1999. He believes that the PUC will be satisfied to wait, that we are going down a path where a document will magically appear, and that the public won't have time to review and comment. He stated that as in the past, Council in recent years has regretted "rushes to judgement," and cited specifically the Holly-Seacliff Development Agreement of November 1990. BOB TRAVER, Huntington Beach resident and Chairman of the Board of the Chamber of Commerce, stated his organization's support of a pre -annexation agreement of the Warner- Mesa/Bolsa Chica Wetlands with Hearthside Homes, which will provide an additional $15 million above and beyond the current Orange County development agreement. He stated that this money will provide funds for a new water reservoir, an upgraded fire station, and other infrastructure improvements. He informed Council it will provide 1100 acres of restored wetland, parks and trails, much needed housing, and millions in economic development. He stated his support of continuing the process that allows for annexation by August 1, 1999. 563 06/28/99 — Council/Agency Minutes — Page 8 ART AVILES, 23-year Huntington Beach resident, endorsed the Warner Mesa and preservation of the Bolsa Chica. He stated that his service on the Finance Board has made him aware of the condition and need for a solution for infrastructure improvements, and that Hearthside Homes will bring in $12-1 5 million for the water reservoir and fire station. He stated that side benefits include housing, an increased base for revenue, and more jobs. Mr. Aviles urged City Council to accept the staff recommendations. VICTOR LEIPZIG, informed Council that he supports staff negotiations, but like the Amigos de Bolsa Chica group, he is concerned, with the same flaws they mention in the pre -annexation agreement with Hearthside Homes. He also mentioned another weakness, which is not environmental, and referred to item 7, page 6 of the staff report relative to plan check fees. He pointed out that the document is a bi-fateral agreement between the city and Hearthside Homes, but that the statement sounds like a county commitment that neither side can make. He believes that the process is going in the right direction, but it is not possible to complete in one month. DEAN ALBRIGHT, referred to a tour he took to Lake Havasu and the Deemer Plant in Yorba Linda, where he learned about over -chlorination: how the city water co -mingles with regular well water. He believes that to put in a new reservoir in Edwards Hills is a duplication, and that there is no need for an additional reservoir in the Bolsa Chica. He suggested that a bargaining point could be to expend money in the Peck Reservoir and to build homes on that property. He stated that one year would be needed to accomplish this and gave the date of June 1, 2001. EILEEN MURPHY, member of the Board of Directors of the Bolsa Chica Land Trust, congratulated the city staff for getting Hearthside Homes to agree to be a willing seller. She urged Council to vote against the conditions the developer has added to the agreement, and named the three that are most objectionable: 1) that the city adopt a resolution of intent to annex and initiate annexation of the Bolsa Chica including the Mesa Development project; 2) that Hearthside Homes has given the city an option to buy the land by June 1, 2000 with no time extensions; and 3) that the option terminates if any litigation is filed challenging the pre - annexation agreement, annexation, Local Coastal Permit, or other discretionary approvals required for the Balsa Chica Development project. PAUL HORGAN, President of the Bolsa Chica Land Trust, reiterated some of the concerns of the other members. He referred to the proposed annexation of the Balsa Chica Mesa, not the Warner Mesa, which does not exist. He stated that the City Council, for a considerable length of time, has advocated the acquisition of open space, and hoped that it does not withdraw from that process. He presented the option of a reasonable time and fair price, and no conditions that unduly restrict the City Council's discretion relative to development of the project. He congratulated staff for achieving the recognition by the Hearthside Homes that it is a willing seller, and urged City Council to reject the agreement and go back for a realistic option. BOB WINCHELL, Huntington Beach resident, spoke on behalf of Huntington Beach Tomorrow, and distributed a five page summary to Council. He stated that it is too short a time to absorb material on such a complex issue, and that it has been seven months since the last meeting. He stated the citizens need to be involved and provide input, and to be confronted with a document three days or so, or over the weekend, on which the city needs to apprise and to comment, is not sufficient time and is poor planning. He urged that Council look at the material which is insufficient, misleading, and inaccurate. Earlier in the meeting, the City Clerk had announced this Late Communication from Bob \Afinchell; a report that will be made available in her office for public review. 564 06128/99 — Council/Agency Minutes -- Page 9 HARRIET WEIDER, former County Supervisor and 30-year Huntington Beach resident, discussed the subject of time, a quarter of a century, in which the city has been concerned with the Bolsa Chica Mesa_ She referred to the Amigos de Bolsa Chica as the voice of the environmental community, and thanked Mayor Green and Councilwoman Dettloff for their leadership in this issue. She stated that the cost of the project would pay for administrative costs over a lifetime, with the thousands of public hearings that have been held, and that the process used for obstruction and delay is not democratic. She stated that it is time for the city to annex this property and be in control. BOLSA CHICA ISSUES FOR CITY COUNCIL CONSIDERATION (CITY COUNCIL) ACCEPTED AND FILED STAFF RESPONSES TO THE 117 BOLSA CHICA ISSUES FOR CONSIDERATION IN PRE -ANNEXATION NEGOTIATIONS WITH HEARTHSIDE HOMES, AND DIRECTED STAFF WITH RESPECT TO CONTINUED NEGOTIATIONS & TO PREPARE AN UPDATED COSTIBENEFITS ANALYSIS (440.60) The City Council considered a communication from Assistant City Administrator Fallon and Planning Director Zelefsky transmitting responses to the 117 Bolsa Chica Issues submitted by the City Council for consideration in pre -annexation negotiations with Hearthside Homes. In addition to receiving and filing those responses, staff requests that the City Council provide further direction with respect to continued pre -annexation negotiations with Hearthside Homes. Staff presented a series of Power Point slides, which highlights the following: Assistant City Administrator Melanie Fallon recapped on slides #1-6 the findings, actions, and Council direction since June 20, 1998 on the Bolsa Chica. Outside Legal Counsel Ron Van Blarcom from Van Blarcom, Liebold, McClendon and Mann summarized with slides #7-8 the status of the application to the Public Utilities Commission and the Appellate Court decision relative to the Local Coastal Permit. Planning Director Howard Zelefsky itemized on slides #9-13 the seven categories of the responses to the 117 Bolsa Chica issues. Ron Van Blarcon described on slides #14-22 the conceptual deal points relating to the negotiating process with Hearthside Homes. Discussion followed centering on contamination, especially of the linear park that is an option to purchase, and the Wintersburg Channel; and on the county's plan checkipermit fees process. Staff introduced Harry Huggins, Acquisitions Coordinator, County of Orange, who spoke on the county's practice of accepting only clean land, especially unencumbered of oil. In response to questions regarding hazardous chemicals, Fire Chief Dolder commented on related activities, and on the new fire station. Assistant City Administrator Fallon responded to Councilmember Harmon's concerns about contaminated storm drains by stating that storm drain mitigation has not been addressed in this draft agreement, and would require a separate application process and Local Coastal Permit. A motion was made by Garofalo second Julien to accept and file only specifically designated responses to the 117 Bolsa Chica Issues for consideration in pre -annexation negotiations with Hearthside Homes except for those given in writing by the City Council to Assistant City Administrator Fallon within a one -week time frame from this meeting. 565 06/28/99 — Council/Agency Minutes — Page 10 Staff was given direction by City Council to continue negotiation of a pre -annexation agreement in accordance with the conceptual terms summarized in the Request for Council Action dated June 28, 1999, and concerns expressed by the City Council at this meeting, and to prepare an updated analysis of the cost/benefits to City from annexation based on entering a pre - annexation agreement. Further, staff was directed to agendize the afore mentioned items for an adjourned meeting to be held on a date to be determined by the staff and the property owner. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Julien, Bauer, Garofalo, Green, Dettloff, Harman Sullivan NOES: None ABSENT: None (CITY COUNCIL) AUTHORIZED THE APPROPRIATION OF $125,000 FOR EXPENSES (PROFESSIONAL SERVICES) RELATED TO THE POTENTIAL ANNEXATION OF THE BOLSA CHICA -- (PRE -ANNEXATION NEGOTIATIONS WITH HEARTHSIDE HOMES) (320.45) The City Council considered a communication from the Assistant City Administrator informing Council that in order to continue its pre -annexation negotiations with Hearthside Homes, staff is requesting an appropriation of $125,000 to provide for necessary professional services. A motion was made by Green second Garofalo to appropriate $125,000 from unreserved, undesignated General Fund balance to the following accounts: (1) $80,000 to the City Attorney's Legal Services account, and (2) $45,000 to the Planning Department's Contractual Services account. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Julien, Bauer, Garofalo, Green, Dettloff, Harman Sullivan NOES: None ABSENT: None (CITY COUNCIL) APPROVED AN AMENDMENT TO PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT WITH MNA CONSULTING FOR BOLSA CHICA ANNEXATION CONSULTING SERVICES -- APPROVED MODIFICATION TO INSURANCE REQUIREMENTS (600.10) Communication from the Assistant City Administrator transmitting an Amendment to the Agreement with MNA Consulting for the continued provision of consulting services relating to the potential annexation of the Bolsa Chica. A motion was made by Dettloff second Garofalo to approve an amendment to the contract between the City of Huntington Beach and MNA Consulting for consulting services relating to the potential annexation of the Bolsa Chica for an amount not to exceed $30,000; and to approve a waiver from the City's zero professional liability insurance deductible amount for MNA Consulting as recommended by the Settlement Committee. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Julien, Bauer, Garofalo, Green, Dettloff, Harman Sullivan NOES: None ABSENT: None 566 06/28/99 — Council/Agency Minutes — Page 11 COUNCIUAGENCY ADJOURNMENT - CITY COUNCILIREDEVELOPMENT AGENCY A motion was made to adjourn the adjourned regular meetings of the City Council and the Redevelopment Agency of the City of Huntington Beach to Tuesday, July 6, 1999, at 5:00 p.m., in Room B-8, Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California.. ATTEST: C!ity ClerkiCGZerk City Clerk and ex-officio Clerk of the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach and Clerk of the Redevelopment Agency of the City of Huntington Beach, California 1� &Ve-- Mayor/Chairman 567