Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutTransparency in Negotiations - City Council Session, June 29 O O N `O a � O • U � � � rUi � � a O Item 1. - I HB _1_ 7d -ti o U cr, .m C7 bk M ° c� L Q O > C b°k J m b°k U N dC3a� 4 CU ° L CU o° o u O F- > > > HB -z- Item 1. - 2 ED CO O X 0 L r^ Qco 00 N O Go M LI7 V1 M N s CA L Cl] r y O m � C ^ `Y Q C/3 +� ¢ y Ci3 ID C CL3 O Ci3 o M co L-Licm a Q ^ o E W C Q — U O] C o _^ ^ _^ c cu C N CZ d O Q Qom] cm m CO /O L S � -� Li ii co m co C 'o Q 131 o U L C C C m CO Co .0 C7 y13 ? EU C/] O �""' — C C Q J ❑.3 Q C CO � .U EM CU C U Q CoU3 E o ? w o � v7 CE3 w Z 4 C � o w o w Q o O — o w CU Q cn L o E Q E _v4 cuM co CU E D �- 3/ C L CU L E a CM C W m E 07 cu +� M aD CU W o ro E cmo' Ca co — L E CU — — _ -CO CD CO CU .— CU N 'U Cm O] Cll L C Lr-r C C U U CL7 L L C Co: M C CO M O m L CO C C7 m d d S LL C%3 Z ' L3 O Item 1. - 3 CU r..� cn �^ CU U73 � U � — M M U C C O O O C M N CU 4. C C w C O] O \,V Zg: a] N G] } C L EU Cc > m o - � W U C S �y �- LL .— C .0 C M C ��+ C L w Q] a E C3 CU � � ccu o L E w m E E o c W U-3 o a r `o m CD U vl cu " E co L s" CD •r-I M .C C �-1 CU CM CQ C C :,4 L3 � •S � � m E La o a = M _> X v� m R C3 E L � cn > � m a o cu �_ +L-� } ro — b�0 _ s y — Ll > - ryMCC�3 L L CUU C E C —Ca d c Fes- Q, s h C i"-"j H m � .e oa �, O] o OM E M3 CU CU a3 CU C r� •X v3 O o = � m c o = W L C O fA CUL N m C/J a a d V] U CC 1--d U L CC C� C C U_ O C O] C_7 C_ d C� U C d L E " o °' C3 E C C L y = C LL, /gel� a E U � c ::- c N fO cm CU O Z U d fv% � � U HB -4- Item 1. - 4 � o G� C +� CO CO ^� coo C-3CU C C d ... ►--i L E 0.0 �o a C M3 O] -F- G S' L d O O] L = C C 4 C o C a _ 64-- E cu z ` m .b o M cu O] o w, U U b coC o W C C3 O �i U L m � CD •> > O m C CACL cu T _ S y U H C,03 CU z o CU an sm C CO O] �"0 p V] Q O CU C 0 CU � L ■� p c� a- CU W j v� C � � U U c = > s C �' C CO w o c m ■� O — o c m C CU C3 CU 0 C a v m Y/ M C/7 a M cm �- �" o CU Lo — [p L �--' L L O7 C >, O .� fq C M3 O O O] [9 L M/\ } U C r n L3 CU L v Item 1. - 5�= Q HB -5- g U) % o ® 2 n 2 \ F § ƒ E n m > % ƒ % -_ '7 2 >1 CU e cu � � (D ƒ g a § 2 3 ; 0 E \ - .> S ¢ 2 2 ƒ a $ u # & CD- 2 0 _ � c o ( / b � 2 E 3 7 0 % 0 cu CDk r ƒ CD % \ / / E 2 ,0- cm ® 2 2CQU r / [ 0 22 � 2 E \ 8 q 2 / U A § & 0 (n ; � ) 2 2 0 2 : 3 u § a2 § g � / E 2 Q c 2 Q \ \ 2 .2 o f .y § � E ) 2 F@ 2 0 / o "01 \ 4 a 2 k 0 � U { u ` ° cu cu ° 2 a)m 2 3 0 a) t a a / z f \ .cc CCU ° 2 0 � 2 .( 2 O o E E E 2 cr \ \ / % R / g A % 2 / / $ U .E R .HB -6- - Item t - 6 2 � .t � ' � � 0 0 3 7 _ -0 > mo CD U5 � : m -a k 2 E 2 % 0 k c 2 2 / � � .> o m o 0 CD � k_ k � �CL � � 2 - R E Ccu \ 0 7 § o ocu O cu § 2 k o 2 2 c 3 2 k � cu 2 0 0 k 0 2 cn q / cm cu cu � CD CD � � cu � 7 7 � ` E 0 R e o 2 > k EcM 22 e m = 0 � 2 @ a- 2 .0 � § o c ® 0 m Fn -= o m ( 2 7 2 2 .7 2 2 k 2 0 m � \ k � 0 � § 2 c > E o U E k � U 2 ) § a x 0- CD 0@ E � � 2 0 % = ( ? � 2 k E o $ 2 & § .c ¢ a O o � � K `� o 0- 2 0 E = m C) 2 : R = D 0 o � 2 S � o 2 la) 2 2 © § © v 2 0- R u J - ® a) cn / = > a) \ - § 7 9 CD- E 2 z 2 @ 5 . Item I m - Ems_ , 0 U Cu r/ LLJ u � J O U U CLI m _ C C L co C C Cll Q u_ C77 = CO C_ Cp C/] Cn C/] Ly Q p U = _ C J CC] r C t L> V3 d coo CM U C4 C co LFM _ CU . Q Q ClJ U C > _�' LL VJ C U CL] co C = C C1 CM C cm L U ro L CO U C� = o _ U w cu Cn cu Lo ECU v CL3 CE3C -= CL] Cz C M CU - cE 1/3 O O C3 C,3 C3 _ ° c 3 ry C w _ Cn L- L U C 1 U C/] L C U C C3 �� C y� Q CD U C S L-Li ? CU M: = 3 CO p U C �w +' cn �- — CL) c3 CU v� O CU C3 m rn -' U L C- U � CO lu coo CZ L C C C/] ZC3 C C ` U CD co CU C7 C77 + m CS a] = m dH ti = � � 4� CM C3 - = CU E cu Z C U L3 � � ❑� V a rn c C/7 Cn a .ca .PO E Cn I Q O G C C CA .0 co C/] U CL] C'0 " L O N L . CD _ 3 CU Q M L C L CD Cb U = C ,� d CCM �[7 a, C13 CL] L C CUL = - C3 -C3 CT] co L3 L _ CO cu p o C3C/3 CO C U C/7 U CC Q. CL] �C U = L U C C M C3 C3 C U + �- 7 = C v co Ecm == � E �"� Cz -� E c-3 Ll U CO O = Q7 C1 G L L La r�� a�+-� U C/] � U = = �v] O W U U (n U U W LL C.-7 C CL] _ 4� ¢ = E m L.L > Item 1. - 8 V1 _ O C � y cm S a3 O L c E ru�^ 7 m o I� > v L_ a Vcm OL O co [U CO C cu > CA CU w--i M C CU C- C- CD C O O 3 CDr- y r--� E. L OL ca� CM ED C = M C_ O y C -Q p \ CU y C3 U L U C co O CD w--r O CA CM L L O CO y O O C d d d L G� O O CM- O L C L C 3 O L O_ C.] + CA C O C/] � > L L C CU E o � o Co L d] ry-� rO+ cu M L N O p > C C 3cm E o CU V }� C L1 C1 C] 0_ C / U O U m _O Cn r--' O C. v7 O r-- M yO+ M U CU 0 CU CD C VF CL] L CM CU 4~ CMEL3>- U G C L L L2 V � O � � an �_ > Cu L N M O L 7tt —M L y CD M Ca .v' 3 � .� c o� pL c L C L 7 �' y 0 o CT c _ o 0 O _ CO CCD CA •V] O CU U p C O L z `= = m 0 y c a > v � 03 + cm ED CA U d y V o > s Cu > . L o M L �• -M Q CUJ C/J •— Z cm_ co W y LLJ CU O y O L �' M C,3 U O_ H G _ BOO.] C U O O7 L O C D_ d J O co O `� L L O C/J s - = U O O C O' CU C3 CM M v -M CM N CU CM U O U C CD y C y .L0 0 �) E OL- p L O7 C O Q C CO � M U CE3 ~ O -ccE a O > Item 1. - 9 xs-9- L/1 CO ED . ,..� o Ctl 1^ s E _ r �J _ _ cm L C U -' m U C3G m C �°' = m .E o m m U ti � CM J L L� r7 C +--' C y -= t a3 m C C C O cn Q m U Q C3 m m = v3 U C y L CO,m, CDaj C3o •m U m m > U d C CM C3. m Q E a] m C3 y a7 a O U m = LCU M U U O C C/] U M C IM N m yTi L a7 ?� U rC- C3U yco �+ C3 cu °' E O � U ' L m ". _ _ — m y CUm L I C C d W Crm L = n Q Z a] L L C V] L C m " E CL3 cfl 3 C L - E C = CU r — m 47 =_ m ~ CO C13 a7 0� ti vi E m v v " m M C— L > M CD E E cm L a, m c a m m U CU .L r--� L = = O cncu CU +U+ a] CD Q = U m L U CU U L] > ._ cm L m y C m >? O �' C3- 03 m L W L m mDo cu L L C3m E � m m = _ D" D7 C L y= m VJ C m a3 y a] CM a m > > m mCO � U C3 CU �� E U L7 C C L] U � x > > xs-i0- Item 1. - 10 un E y L p7 Cl]L ►� A O_ > 3 tip-. L1 y C1 L o tf �' E C3L_ C3C3 =' OCj O] U CU = E U C M3 y = CM C17 Ca C d E3 o c E a m t o Cl] C L L C/] ^ O7 CU [1] cli p O C L > C CA [9 O C C y O7 p OCU M CO M = y CO C3O O] L U p U M y O C M ., U O ++ L Co CO y>i CL O] C- _ U O7 O- CO ++ C ED O O C S ■M U > C U CU L C CD O _C M y L L3 r� C3 C L O y C3p U C C 3 .y U U S > 0.7 > [7 � C .p m C E p y C CO y C y O O W CO 'L [fl C17 M3 Cp y coy y W o CU c U CL3 03 m W L C CO E an _ C3 > C C s O] [U •CD C > p VJ Co L R O f > C3 CU C3 U a �+ CG L7 L p C 'C U r U-� C- N HOC y y C3 = L O.] C3 C m > D C3Ll O] y C3.0 L]Ca ,Q, w � CU o o f v y m 4.1 co w n C3- U m G] E ED U CM y O] CA CyM3 0 CA M u L _ .E C C O C= C -M M D y � M L �C C.6 ED L > >• CA C3CO N c _ o L . C3 C3- co E S m m E _C a \ E O O = L CLl _ �--' L `7 L CD 7 r L U C ED rtp+ OO _ = M M p -m L Cu mCO CL CU I o = d .� w e M E c 03 m o 3 E a", = _ c v E co W e p o m .E c y cO z +J +- L m an C L7 m Q o E o LLJ C3L m C r3 `Y •� C3 m Cn O p_ z Q3 Cc L U E [� z = C3 CD w U C3C3m V CL3c pr3C �03 an 2 C1 CO 3 U U 1�1 J L L Item 1. - 11 HB -11- u_ b Va w YO$Erm S $ xr' mc mN 0 n Y •a J '_ m�ubc�- m _ Vpmn °eva 4R� ca 3^'ti N� � y`mc -" P�5 • N . OP$£ •'G �ZS$ P m CYO$S �LN Y {J �LC =T �F � v OO 3C TSOZf ° co .£v ecu 3, �.. m _ EJp Z•t m m vmmLL � ccU m ycu b5 L^ a� meoefici r`\/yJ�./m,� O E�Yv.o°�9£°wu Y�m� e�' �KSo.�u 6Tiv€mc➢o 0 c o fi x 8u$ ° _�' [� O$n$p�no`mc�i r$$mo $w �u m=" .�J0vc'-m^Lcffio0^b4 E " pEmc£=T 3mn Ov 2E3fdMU Ivafi-cSio •U 9 h L S C=S m S SZ O O -rJ fi L • C` O N � C O 3 a V �'5' u p a4hl nb `-gc Tiofi NL eYi--o o'Sa Z L J L ° m a 3 0 m U Y.S m� m 0 t 6 z a. d S tY m U$ 3 u•i f T - 4 q O " ED N ri To z 00 VS 2 T V C £ L $mm °� N Y C (fin - fig S a V a S L c b N mL�m e6�L Ck' C SLv° • nm am emm c :� 0n mam2'm m ec w=€ P Mm.Op �m w m m cm Eo $ P r, e m$ �ZS_ c�y�{ cgv 2_,eu ��u .q OL 6 ?Vj£ccC 6 ccp b 6�j JL OJ �" m " C�U O L VG U a- y O V 6_9 b 8 r� C U 6 m m m L o$ Y Q Y T • ow LL �` 1f C Y r/� C '({ p •m O U�.� Q. E J ? Y C N 0 6 LT c C E r�'L d g C Y• O U Y u� >- mco �+� cc fiv •v• pp Ulbcuags�LV UQf Em� ��� m Oi g . m' mm = �Q[�3$ b a Cqa° emm cL ! 00. w VtSV Obm V UUTC C�$ L. -•J�$ E CC- P�£ • Y TY pG O SL O gV • y pyymoa mc5 wn- n$Z' fiEsm'_ YCL_ E U � cQ � E. Q�V uKc UJ`.mc 'm v' mEU nE O1m as n$S 'mfi N am D 0 $ 8i o f oC c T _Day u b �j' N m T L $y L� 2."O O O • U > EI G Q C n D Sm $ � VOQ E V 9 9 • Z'D- � O NL$ LT T `yN ONTO mcvUo " vo$ `"2'4`- m m fie$£ $U£ P � _ Z' m 9 PLCJ O p C mFp OI Y E j D LO O O me fiOli °N.O ISOm�� P `j O ]$ P O •- gV V u3L�9 rTL O •~ n� f $ m ° EiE • N a£- T8 n m �� °Caa CL � E mmv7� N N pe •-E3£t m$ b mN mmE mLOp mv . fian'm T b-.k OFC � � y.� -p ., w CC rE0 " y vopy c m- € m 6G0 suT F E E u c � c na � omN $3 -mEv $� Oa a `m^ m naL/q�� mc Luppc fifi S mu- `��£$V u u- $ $N m C C.Y - S N Q':J p V �1 m Y Y_ m 6` •9 N U Is a.0 Y.r m • ' fi n O . fi �OrN$2fi� occcoc�- L� -D ao'cc c Sc @fi$m cm g m °n uu£afi �' • eLm$ �Efi Zc m�m°�i$ CIO" 7�bl 44LvTu' $rn c'S 5$P-q` OGm w 9 N a" U u Ly um E m U a£ UwoUc w'v £m°1$£e$Uweu £Cogg ALfiY° P e C• . c = • m o m 4 m n m L• c.fi Em m � € L c 9 6 Y • L 'L" p 00 v�pe8F 1 _E E 'goy 'm Ec °v $Sg 3 $c 3HL� `Vg�X �w��.C�_ Lmu�uN Qn rwL. �mn°E£e=cVam fi ••Y$u amm r�.`fi[[G m cs� •'y qa��mm�o �a$gO) m m£" 53F�gN am_`T mSb$ E ` • c I�: w'm E�P•E,na`-�$ofi mOr $ pmj . Z$ oE fi ca . W rVPCm co y�m9 Ya �E YV _ V NcO Y c C b VO mCO no E u and HID OUE m um-; mm nfi c a • m$Qa nvbyc c cS ¢o au m�mc�m Eusk yl OLe �duU3=r$ �» c UnQv ❑ 6v$ uc _�"0O •Qn`_.o Gqfiu°T=fiL ew $•oc �.m`C[° euD T"i Or- ISy=VU 9EqqCD mw Cng Ra u Cl tr "Y� £• P a .EO 000 0 fi Joaa Oo Myy 'o' a',: C �1 •mE u $'E tll Ica OT" t6 .. d2S$m. xZ R ° fimnaY ` Oymn y n & 'w vE�w �t y5 .p 3w � ° ` C t N-am5'm 5 a 7 $ u L 9$ �VQm m _a$$ q O�' nm`u � c M y 7oc£ tQ Nam'SL% w8m o'T' o V m IO m m' 7yV ag me fig C E 9i3 C dis '1 E V T,l° 3uuw N o y W b C S ��c�LS£ r 0 ` c5 c ur ° 7��e Ow . D££Dsu❑ ILO£• 3 no?B .21m 100. 0592 C xa -12- Item 1. - 12 C U v o m > rn O 2.4yELn Ti oEc ciw W v'u Y 2 C U O.°r 2 W C_ 2 V m E U c W W a w cS y.°- W a W O = 1O Q'cy cL E W ovm L8i Uv ui E cq�maa ,�av c c o E— E > p 4 a ; C L N 'C o f .10 N N N AIL C p C C U m W a? cv" o._ JL° c.kc �icc-. .VTOL w° oc = na °L� W u m vEz: Jo W ym mom._ .c � v o cc.- y of meyN VUm `m m n.« c r 'o c c o c c y n c' m'H v .o v w wyodO� J �.m—m €a« oJ�'ui wt'wJd a� 6 O�yOmH E7 c u v W yv myL' Qmc nmM " v.F_ c vO WL v O. HORN aEa50 ¢ m 0EEa as E«m 3u 0vy � 2 Oo f E 2Qc-cX c.0 N t L CC C qj W W W w W O C a' W O L y 4� E y G x H CO j fO Z. pI 0) m WUO `� O C=.L.. IC m 0 - N m a p r m O 42 O L C W W y 0 a O N C N.C. Ol N W U ,O` C O C= ° W a op y o m" g E= o v p�0 To v °ma c o c Npp�� 5 Q �'�2 i° >= cu W gL 9 0 m W U N O C go O m �j W W ° O O W E 5 0 W C W ° W 2 vA maO1i'ckm - m L'co We S,v�yv O > E Oav > JSmE Zc W a O2 UoS m°: m Uoo `o Znu Q>n WUo 0m2 u n W C m W W a m e v 0 ;om NS m ` a c 00E Sgrn»c �`L'3 .a m �aNAd 0 � y O N pC O E E m C .� 0 0 MC 0 N U J m a`J m C N L N L 4- W.O NmN.0 y N c0 L C W E O a y 6 N G y U W C N O N« O N M u C C m y C O 0 yy ryary .U= a a = C 6y ^L W 0oamv �0 W OV-OC U 7 W y U W W N N ° ° f C V a L W W N C O W T W O 0 O O C .�L y J m m C C O W C y C O S O-WO J -°W-m O U W O 'u0 m `o U >5 cicu W `o cc oov ma U�oc unW vvL U U� V N °'oO UmC NUCC 0O)=« Wm�-.BO>>C 'OL WCjUCNCm �OW W 50 y mp C O � J_ OEC O-' W Q vp� v'm �Evam mca wa'c o.v .cc Eam moa c E oU L W{..1 L o L v c � v JJavv ° m' co c m"62c`c m o w CFcQ HE.^ UO o� c vim— cmomEU nE cmma� a'o,.. W o V1 W m r ° yC O LWy a mo C Sv TC cTC Cv imW N.-aWW c30—m V $ 9 m — Ud cmt` L C O C Cfl TcoOWm EcWJc 0Lcmy m oU L Sc O« 0« mO La ° STN C O ° m 1 m N N« E C 0 W 6C- C O W E �Loyv CW Evx LOC WJ = aJ O — EE ° cOv y- 0ma ° y U NE0 o v.- y oML Eo v— v �V'CLmCC1 3LOO Uf�y.cF.yJ- myLC NLC(p«TacVi LmuWi DW7 c' (5 v cc� Ct� C�a WWy �m NC C � d v' Qvm Qo C'm L-V`c v E: E W vL« c_T8a m ° cav v y m m mL a. c E Jamo ° a Q OCmW O m a — o. �O c ° E Gmm@CWOTNO a W C C JL�y TWOC Wbla O WC m > m U E � a nC m O > ° cm ccro0 vcWV n. T= O CvyOW3W I wW oU c c vcCE c£ ErvcZE C U7v - m �0 c w �mU Uu Uu$ d0 U - o mna $a c m O� tCO c°i O c u�p�3�m0 OO l€epp vm a�m _vCD� � yyJ aCoo rnyo cm0 Oc F Oc mmA C«�iaAa'0NO LW tiv-aa.mrnCdEo.. L'EmUcmJ 1mrmv�-w $c #m M y 5C 0 C Wm C 0 u E ov O� m L«WJvEd'a'�QaU«m`vyciO a v— v c m- C- 1 W °OE C ° 2OC °2mNNO W v L OIC W E_ >am N cm c rnm ° WEE� oo ` a v � E 0 Es m - ,c Q GL Wo a o LE e wov W v E oc Mc E c a G aW O - U° mc c E m c ucE u 8EcEw v c E oNN. :cc u v a vO v o O iv m cm o Eo o O-o v o `v m oo v W E oN.= m mn o a ov 'FWO c MWso mcm m m �Ock t faU Ln = nc uU a¢ l1� nW -£ cOQQ w anavE. N n€-—um ► O O u m c N u « «7Wcc E of ^ £Oma > dc 5c'$ _ m - ocup oc v 0 o C m do C 0 cOrn� 'zC, Oo ° y�c E Ca o v W m = a a C m ' TEyM2 m Rca Oo"vSvE x x v Wu WZ rnmac OZi m n j o ' a`aa E W� aa° d C (4 mo omowm Ucv O ° ocO U nEaE uEjEM 2co o > v oa�7 UUW m E ' 1 E W C $ O Cw 0 rn• mOh m mccm U6 M AM G mU'namo3m 8a ()09a 0 v 5E ° ° vE Item 1. - 13 HB -13- Esparza, Patty From: Dombo, Johanna Sent: Friday, June 26, 2015 3:46 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: COIN -The Study Session Monday, June 29th From:Gino J. Bruno [mailto:gbrunoC@socal.rr.com] Sent: Friday,June 26, 2015 3:35 PM To:CITY COUNCIL Cc:Wilson, Fred; Gates, Michael Subject: COIN -The Study Session Monday,June 29th TO: CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS When you review the Agenda for the important City Council Study Session set for this Monday evening (televised, Channel 3 at 6:00 pm) [see, http://records.surfcity- hb orQ/sirepub/pubmtgframe aspx?meetid=479&doctvpe=agendal you will notice off to the right is a link to the a PDF document titled, "Transparency in Negotiations" presumably drafted by staff for whom the City Manager (Fred Wilson) is responsible. [See, http://records.surfcity- hb.orq/sirepub/cache/16/5vmngr32]mfklzirzfdihvp/392862406262015023959317 PDFI That document reads, in part, "Proposed decision (June 16, 2015) in OCEA vs. County of Orange found the County of Orange violated provisions of MMBA [Meyers-Milias-Brown Act— Government Code Sections 3500 et seq.] and PERB [Public Employment Relations Board] regulations. This action effectively requires the County of Orange to rescind sections of their COIN ordinance related to public disclosure of financial analysis of initial offers and disclosure of offers and counteroffers due to the fact that the County did not Meet and Confer with affected bargaining units prior to imposition." This paragraph clearly is intended to intimidate and frighten Council members into believing that COIN as adopted by the County of Orange has been FINALLY ADJUDICATED as being in violation of the Government Code Sections cited above. In fact, if true, this reference simply describes a possible finding by an unelected governmental Board, which does NOT have the force or effect of any judgment or decree by any court of law, with jurisdiction, ruling on the merits of any case filed with any court. I would urge Council members to question carefully those who advocate this PERB tentative ruling (if indeed there is such a ruling —there is no specific matter cited in the Staff report, such that it can be verified or read in context), as being the settled 'law" on the subject, or indeed even being persuasive_ The Government Code requirements of"meet and confer' may be totally compatible with COIN if drafted properly. And I am confident that our new City Attorney, Michael Gates, will cause such an ordinance to be crafted and drafted thoughtfully, carefully and in compliance with the applicable provisions of the Government Code. I urge all Council members to move forward with COIN . . . SUPPLEMENTAL Gino J. Bruno COMMUNICATION Huntington Beach Meeting Date. 1 Agenda Item No. �V