Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
Bolsa View Park - Ominipoint Communications, Inc. - T-Mobile
® City of Huntington Beach r 2000 Main Street ® Huntington Beach, CA 92648 ® OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK ® JOAN L. FLYNN CITY CLERK NOTICE OF ACTION September 7, 2010 Monica Moretta Sequoia Deployment Services, Inc. One Venture, Suite 200 Irvine, CA 92618 SUBJECT: Request to revoke Wireless Permit No. 2007-041 and related administrative approval for a wireless communications facility at 5741 Brighton Drive (Bolsa View Park) APPLICANT: Monica Moretta, Sequoia Deployment Services, Inc One Venture, Suite 200, Irvine, CA 92618 LOCATION: 5741 Brighton Drive (Bolsa View Park) DATE OF ACTION: August 30, 2010 On Monday, August 30, 2010, the Huntington Beach City Council held a public hearing and took administrative action to revoke Wireless Permit No 2007-041 and related administrative approval for a wireless communications facility located at 5741 Brighton Drive (Bolsa View Park) Attached to this letter are the Findings for Revocation of Wireless Permit No 2007-041 — Bolsa View Park, and the August 30, 20-10, City Council Action Agenda If you have any questions, please contact Andrew Gonzales, the project planner, at AGonzales(a-Surfclty-hb org or (714) 374-1547 or the Planning and Building Department Zoning Counter at (714) 536-5271 Sincerely, n L Flynn, CMC City Clerk Attachment Findings for Revocation—Wireless Permit No 2007-041 August 30, 2010 Action Agenda c T-Mobile USA, 3 imperial Promenade, Santa Ana, CA 92707 Scott Hess, Director of Planning and Budding Andrew Gonzales, Associate Planner Scott Field, Assistant City Attorney Sister Cities Anlo, Japan • Wartakere, New Zealand (Telephone.714-536-5227) ATTACHMENT NO. 'I FINDINGS FOR REVOCATION WIRELESS PERMIT NO. 2007-041 FINDINGS FOR REVOCATION —WIRELESS PERMIT NO. 2007-041: 1 Wireless Permit No 2007-041 for the construction of a wireless communications facility consisting of a 51 ft 7 in high broadleaf monopole and ancillary support equipment within an underground vault was conditionally approved based upon erroneous and misleading information The applicant cited on the wireless permit application dated July 25, 2007, that the subject site is needed to eliminate an existing service gap Based upon a service gap analysis dated August 16, 2010, the wireless application misrepresents the degree of the gap in existing service Since the applicant provided misleading and erroneous propagation maps the application is revoked 2 T-Mobile stated in its August 7, 2007 submittal of "La13157 Coverage Objective" that the Bolsa View Park antenna was to provide residential coverage in the area surrounding the Park The accompanying "Actual Drive test" showed complete "outdoor" coverage, but gaps in their "indoor" and "in-vehicle" coverage Both of these representations were misleading or false 3. In 2009, according to T-Mobile's own web-based coverage map, it was offering uninterrupted "best" coverage throughout the areas of Harbour View and Bolsa View Parks This coverage map suggests either that there are no coverage deficiencies in either area, or more likely, that T-Mobile does not consider gaps in "in-house" coverage to be significant 4 As of August 2010, T-Mobile's web-based coverage map shows a minimum of"Good" and in some areas, Very Good or Excellent service around Harbour View and Bolsa View Attachment 1 1 5 While T-Mobile has indicated in its Bolsa View coverage map that the surrounding areas have signal strength from -91 dBm ("Outdoor") to -76 dBm, ("In Building"), these terms are meaningless, because there are no federal rules that establish minimum signal strengths for a particular area Equally importantly, actual call service does not correspond with these signal strengths 6 The need for this Project is minimal The purpose of the Bolsa View antenna is primarily to allow residential customers to replace landline telephone service with exclusively mobile telephone service The project is not designed for dense commercial or industrial area, or to cover highway service Within a quarter-mile radius from the Park, there are approximately 216 residential units at an average of 2 74 persons per household unit, provides a population size of 592 residents Based on the relatively low demand for this project, there is no service gap in the vicinity of the Bolsa View Project 7 Further, absent the representations from T-Mobile that there was a significant gap in mobile telephone coverage, the Planning Department would have exercised its discretion to require a public hearing to determine whether to issue a conditional use permit to site an antenna in a community park Had a public hearing been conducted, the City would have had the opportunity to receive public testimony on the compatibility of the monopole with the surrounding Park. It is reasonable to conclude that the receipt of that testimony would have led to the denial of the application 8 The Permit should be revoked pursuant to Huntington Beach Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance Section 249 06 because (i) there was a discontinuance of the exercise of the entitlement granted by the Permit for in excess of twelve consecutive months (Section 249 06 D(3)), and (ii) the failure to exercise such rights constitutes a violation of the terms or conditions of approval of the Permit (Id) Contrary to the suggestion in the Staff Report submitted in advance of the August 30, 2010 public hearing, the applicant failed to comply Attachment 1 2 with the conditions imposed on the face of Permit No 2007-041, and specifically the condition that the rights conferred by said permit be exercised within one year Specifically the Permit states that it shall become null and void unless exercised within one year of the date of final approval or such extension of time as may be granted by the Director pursuant to a written request submitted to the Planning Department a minimum 30 days prior to the expiration date The City Council finds and determines that no written request for an extension was made and that no extension was ever granted Moreover, the Council finds and determines that T-Mobile did not obtain a license to use the Park site until January 20, 2009—one year and five months after issuance of the Permit. Consequently, the City Council finds and determines that Permit 2007-0041 was neither timely exercised nor extended, and hence is null and void The City Council further finds that the fact the applicant may have been working with City Staff, and negotiating terms for permission to use the property in question is irrelevant to the determination that no request to extend the Permit was made and that no such extension was granted The situation is no different than if the applicant were trying to negotiate a lease on private property for the installation of the facility in question and failed to come to satisfactory terms prior to the entitlements purportedly conveyed by the Permit having expired The Council specifically disagrees with and rejects as factually and legally incorrect the statements in the Staff Report to the effect that (1) no violation of the Permit's terms occurred or that no conditions of its approval were violated, and (2) the "lengthy discontinuance for over two years" which occurred before the applicant attempted to use the rights purportedly conveyed by the Permit is somehow excused because such delay was due to ongoing negotiations between the applicant and City Staff 9 Wireless Permit No 2007-041 was issued in violation of Ordinance Municipal Code, and hence was void when issued and/or should be revoked, because Paragraph E 9 of Section 3 of Ordinance No 3766 states that "Any wireless communication facility to be placed Attachment 1 3 over, within, on, or beneath City property shall obtain a lease or franchise from the City prior to applying for a Wireless Permit and an administrative or conditional use permit" 1n violation of this Ordinance language, T-Mobile obtained a license, not a lease or franchise for the placement of the tower on City property, and, T-Mobile applied for its Wireless Permit in July 2007, a year and a half before it obtained its License, rather than doing so after a lease or franchise is obtained as required by the City's Zoning Code. Moreover, City Staff was not authorized to administratively issue the Permit in question without complying with the forgoing provisions of the City's Municipal Code 10 The City Council may not be bound by the above noted errors of City Staff in issuing the Permit in violation of the City's laws and Ordinances (despite assertions by T-Mobile that the doctrine of estoppel and similar theories should apply), as the purported injustice done to the applicant (of which the City Council finds none to exist by virtue of the applicant's unclean hands in connection with the application demonstrated by its misrepresentation of facts in its application) is outweighed by the harm to the public that will occur if the Permit is not revoked Notably, the residents of the community have a protectable property and personal interest in maintaining the character of the area as established by comprehensive and carefully considered zoning plans in order to promote orderly physical development of the district and the City (See, e g, Golden Gate Water Ski Club v County of Contra Costa (2008) 165 Cal App 4th 249, 259 ) Attachment 14 A C TION MAYOR Monday, August 30, 2010 AND CITY COUNCIL CATHY GREEN CITY COUNCIL, REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY Mayor and PUBLIC FINANCING AUTHORITY JILL HARDY GIL COERPER Mayor Pro Tem Councilmember CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH KEITH BOHR DEVIN DwYER 1909 2009 Councdmember Councdmember a 5:00 PM - SPECIAL MEETING JOE CARCHIO DON HANSEN Council Chambers - 2000 Main Street Councilmember Councilmember Huntington Beach, CA 92646 http:ltww rU.surfcit t-hb.org CALL TO ORDER— 5:02 PM ROLL CALL Carchio, Coerper, Hardy, Green, Bohr, Dwyer, Hansen All Present PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE ANNOUNCEMENT OF LATE COMMUNICATION City Clerk Joan L. Flynn announced Late Communications: 8 (#1 & #2) Motion to adjourn to Closed Session on following item- 5:03 PM Reconvene Special Meeting— 5:47 PM PUBLIC COMMENTS PERTAINING TO SPECIAL MEETING ITEM(S) 24 Speakers PUBLIC HEARING Opened#a and#2 concurrently 1. Request to revoke Wireless Permit No. 2007-042 and related administrative approval for a wireless communications facility located at 16600 Saybrook Lane (Harbour View Park) Staff Recommended Action: Motion to, Revoke Wireless Permit No 2007-042 and administrative approval with findings of revocation Approved as amended to accept additional findings for revocation to -1- Permit No. 2007-04Z items #1, #l5 and#6 as submitted by Patrick Munoz of Rutan and Tucker. Approved 6-1 (Hansen no) 2. Request to revoke !Wireless Permit No. 2007-041 and related administrative approval for a wireless communications facility located at 5741 Brighton Drive (Eolsa View Park) Staff Recommended Action: Motion to. Revoke Wireless Permit No. 2007-041 and administrative approval with findings of revocation Approved 6-1 (Hansen no) COUNCILMEMBER COMMENTS (Not Agendiized) ADJOURNMENT— 8:19 PM Adjournment to Tuesday, September 07, 2010, at 4 00 PM in Room B-8, Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California INTERNET ACCESS TO CITY COUNCIUREDEVELOPMENT AGENCY/PUBLIC FINANCING AUTHORITY AGENDA AND STAFF REPORT MATERIAL IS AVAILABLE PRIOR TO CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS AT httP., .surfcity hb.orc� -2- PROOF OF SERVICE OF PAPERS STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ORANGE ) I am employed in the County of Orange, State of California. I am over the age of 18 and not a party to the within action; my business address is 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, CA 92648. Pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure § 1094.6, on September 8, 2010, 1 served the foregoing documents(s) described as: Notice of Action regarding a request to revoke Wireless permit No. 2007-041 and related administrative approval for a wireless communications facility at 5741 Brighton Drive (Bolsa View Park) on the interested parties in this action by placing a true copy thereof in a sealed envelope addressed as follows: 10 Auto Dealers —See label list a. [X] BY MAIL -- I caused such envelope to be deposited in the mail at Huntington Beach, California. I am "readily familiar" with the firm's practice of collection and processing correspondence for mailing. It is deposited with U.S. Postal Service on that same day in the ordinary course of business, with postage thereon fully prepaid. I am aware that, on motion of a party served, service is presumed invalid if postal cancellation date or postage meter date is more than 1 day after date of deposit for mailing in the affidavit. b. [ ] BY MAIL -- By depositing a true copy thereof in a sealed envelope with postage thereon fully prepaid in the United States mail at Huntington Beach, California, addressed to the address shown above. c. [ ] BY DELIVERY BY HAND to the office of the addressee. d. [ ] BY PERSONAL DELIVERY to the person(s) named above. e. [ ] BY FAX TRANSMISSION to No. I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on September 8, 2010, at Huntington Beach, California. ni ol jety City CI g1followup/appeal/!!proof of service letter!l.doc Council/Agency Meeting Held Deferred/Continued to �Ap rove �ndit� ally rove ❑ Renied i Cf 's Si n ture Council Meeting Date August 30, 2010 Department ID Number PL 10-021 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION SUBMITTED TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members SUBMITTED BY: Fred A Wilson, City Administrator PREPARED BY: Scott Hess, AICP, Director of Planning and Building Jennifer McGrath, City Attorney SUBJECT: Request to revoke Wireless Permit No 2007-041 and related administrative approval for a wireless communications facility located at 5741 Brighton Drive (Bolsa View Park) Statement of Issue: Transmitted for City Council consideration is a request to affirm or revoke Wireless Permit No 2007-041 and the related administrative approval for a wireless communications facility at Bolsa View Park pursuant to Huntington Beach Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance (HBZSO) Section 249 06 The application represents a request to construct a wireless communications facility consisting of a 51 ft 7 in high broadleaf monopole and ancillary support equipment located within an underground vault at 5741 Brighton Drive (north side of Brighton Drive, between Whitford Lane and Crestmoor Lane) Planning Staff is recommending revocation of the Wireless Permit and administrative approval (issuance of building permits) Financial Impact: Not applicable Recommended Action: STAFF RECOMMENDATION Motion to "Revoke Wireless Permit No 2007-041 and administrative approval with findings of revocation (ATTACHMENT NO 1) " Alternative Action(s): The City Council may make the following alternative motion(s) "Affirm Wireless Permit No 2007-041 and administrative approval with findings of approval." Items 2e - Page 1 REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTION MEETING DATE: 8/30/2010 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: PL 10-021 Analysis: A PROJECT PROPOSAL On September 7, 2007, the Department of Planning and Building approved Wireless Permit No 07-041, allowing T-Mobile to install a faux-tree mobile telephone antenna at Bolsa View Park subject-to a building permit On April 1, 2009, building permits were issued for construction of the Bolsa View and the related Harbour View antennas In applying for the permit, T-Mobile represented the construction cost was $80,000 for Bolsa View When construction at Harbour View began in April 2009, the adjacent neighbors objected In response, the City asked T-Mobile to voluntarily halt construction until the matter could be discussed with the residents at a City Council meeting T-Mobile agreed Then, at a subsequent meeting with City representatives, T-Mobile stated that each antenna would cost about $200,000 to build Once T-Mobile revealed the total construction value, the City informed T-Mobile of Section 612 of the City Charter, which states in pFertinent part "[N]o structure costing more than $100,000 00 may be built on or in any park or beach or portion thereof unless authorized by the affirmative votes of at least a majority of the total membership of the City Council and by the affirmative vote of at least a majority of the electors voting on such proposition at a general or special election at which such proposition is submitted " The City informed T-Mobile that since the total construction costs for each antenna exceeded $100,000 00, voter approval was required before T-Mobile could build the antennas In response, T-Mobile filed suit in Federal District Court on May 27, 2009 The case is entitled Omnipoint CommunIcatlons, Inc (T-Mobile) v City of Hunt►ngton Beach, United States District Court Case No CV09-3777 T-Mobile alleged that the Federal Telecommunications Act (the "TCA"), specifically 47 USC §§ 253 and 332(c)(7), preempted (i e , invalidated) the voter approval requirement of Section 612 To resolve this issued, T- Mobile and the City filed motions requesting a Court ruling on this issue On July 9, 2010, the District Court issued an Order denying the City's motion and granting T- Mobile's in part The Court found that the voter approval requirement violates the TCA requirement that cities act on applications for mobile telephone antennas within a "reasonable period of time," and that any denial "be in writing and supported by substantial evidence contained in a written record " The Court then ordered the City Council to reconsider its decision regarding the antennas, stating "[T]he Court notes that the City Council did not have all the facts at the time it initially approved the permits In particular, Plaintiff did not provide the required information accurately on the forms (for example, that the projects cost as much as [$]200,000) The City Council was also apparently unaware of the distaste of the citizens for the antennas, especially within an elementary school And of course, the City Council was not aware that Measure C cannot be relied on as basis for its decision Therefore, while Measure C cannot be used as reason for denial of Item 2. - Page 2 REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTION MEETING DATE: 8/30/2010 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: PL 10-021 applications, the Court cannot at this time order the city to allow the construction to resume In this light, the city must be given the chance to either grant the permits or articulate in writing the bases of denial in a way that comports with the Act " The Court allowed 60 days, until September 7, 2010, for the City to either approve or deny the antennas. T-Mobile objected to the Court Order remanding the permits for further City Council consideration by way of a motion for reconsideration, which the District Court denied on August 9, 2010 The Court explained that "the City has so far not brought any authority to this Court's attention that suggests the City cannot revoke licenses after they are already issued for some valid legal reason that does not violate the Telecommunication Act " Consequently, the Court stated that the City was permitted to consider if-the permits should be revoked in light of the "new facts that have come to light since the permits were issued " Some of the new facts the Court identified were that- (i) the cost of construction was more than $200,000 per antenna, (ii) the projects were immensely unpopular with the residents, and (iii) voter approval under Section 612 was unavailable In response to the Court Order, the City initiated review of Wireless Permit No 2007-042 to affirm or revoke the application and the administrative approval for the construction of a wireless communication facility at Bolsa View Park B BACKGROUND The Bolsa View antenna was approved at the time Ordinance No 3766 was in effect This was a temporary ordinance that permitted processing antennas until the new zoning regulations that are now contained as Zoning Code Section 230 96 were adopted. Like the current regulations, T-Mobile was required to submit a Wireless Permit Application that "demonstrate[s] that the antenna is located in the least obtrusive location feasible so as to eliminate any gap in service " There were two critical parts of the procedure under Ordinance No 3766 (now under Section 230 96) for seeking an entitlement for a wireless antenna Section 3 C and Section 3 D Section 3 C identified the circumstances where the Planning and Building Director may administratively approve an antenna These include where the antenna is completely "stealth" and where the antenna is in a non-residential zone and is designed to be architecturally compatible with surrounding buildings and land uses by incorporating stealth techniques (Sec 3 C 1 to Ord No 3766 ) The Wireless Permit requirement is contained at Section 3 D of Ordinance No 3766, and requires that the applicant submit a Wireless Permit Application that "demonstrate[s] that the antenna is located in the least obtrusive location feasible so as to eliminate any gap in service " The purpose of this information is to determine the necessity of locating the antenna in the proposed location, especially because under Federal law, a court may reverse a City permit denial if the mobile telephone provider has a "significant gap in coverage" and there is no other feasible alternative site (teen 2. - Page 3 REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTION MEETING DATE: 8/30/2010 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: PL 10-021 Pursuant to these requirements, on July 24, 2007, T-Mobile submitted a wireless permit application for the construction of a 51 ft high stealth wireless communications facility designed as a broadleaf palm tree monopole with ancillary support equipment located in a below grade vault T-Mobile then submitted a technical coverage report, entitled "LA 13256 and LA13157 RF Technical Report" on August 7, 2007, strongly indicating that there was-a significant gap in mobile telephone coverage in the vicinity of the proposed antenna Given this representation, the Planning and Building Department exercised its discretion to not require a public hearing to determine whether to issue a conditional use permit, but instead approved the wireless permit on August 14, 2007 As mentioned above, the Planning and Building Department's discretion to administratively approve such permits is limited to two circumstances First, administrative approval is available where the antenna is completely "stealth " Such stealth facilities must be enclosed within the building envelope Mono-trees are not completely stealth Instead, the Planning and Building Department found, based upon photo simulations, that the antenna was designed to be architecturally compatible with surrounding buildings and land uses by incorporating "stealth techniques " (Sec 3.0 1 to Ord No 3766 ) Faux trees are such a technique On August 2, 2010, the City Council directed staff to reevaluate the wireless permit as permitted by the July 9, 2010 Court Order Accordingly, a public hearing notice to consider permit revocation HBZSO Section 249 was mailed to surrounding property owners, with the hearing set for August 30, 2010 C STAFF ANALYSIS AND RECOMMENDATION HBZSO Section 249 06 authorizes revocation of discretionary permits Although such hearings are normally conducted by the Planning Commission, given the time constraints of the Court Order, the matter is being presented directly to the Council The grounds outlined in the HBZSO for revocation are 1. That the permit was issued on the basis of erroneous or misleading information or misrepresentation, 2 That the terms or conditions of approval of the permit have been violated or that other laws or provisions have been violated, or 3 That there has been a discontinuance of the exercise of the entitlement granted by the permit for twelve consecutive months There is no evidence that any terms or conditions of approval have been violated Also, while there was a lengthy discontinuance for over two years, that delay was due to the ongoing negotiations between T-Mobile and City Staff regarding the Site License Agreements However, there is substantial evidence that T-Mobile misrepresented the facts regarding the need for the antenna when it submitted its application The primary purpose of the wireless communication facility is to increase the existing radio frequency (RF) signal level in an existing coverage area In the "La13157 Coverage Objective" provided by T-Mobile in its August 7, 2007 submittal, the Coverage Objective was Item 2® a Page 4 REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTION MEETING DATE: 8/30/2010 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: PL 10-021 to provide residential coverage surrounding Bolsa View Park The accompanying "Actual Drive test" showed complete "outdoor" and "in-vehicle" coverage, but gaps in their "indoor" coverage During the course of the litigation between the City and T-Mobile, the City retained the services of Kramer Firm, Inc , to analyze the coverage surrounding both Park sites (Attachment 6 ) From that Report the City learned, first, that according to T-Mobile's web- based coverage map shows uninterrupted "best" coverage throughout the areas of Harbour View and Bolsa View Parks This coverage map suggests either that there are no coverage deficiencies in either area, or more likely, that T-Mobile does not consider gaps in in-house coverage to be significant Second, while T-Mobile has indicated in its Bolsa View coverage map that the surrounding areas have signal strength from -91 dBm ("Outdoor") to -76 dBm, ("In Building"), these terms are meaningless because there are no federal rules that establish minimum signal strengths for a particular area Rather, wireless carriers independently, arbitrarily, and diversely assign signal strength goals, claiming a significant-gap in coverage when it suits their purpose To obtain more information on this issue, the City again retained Kramer Firm, Inc , to determine coverage according to actual mobile telephone calls, and not signal strength The analysis (Attachment No 7) begins by noting that as of August 2010, T-Mobile's web-based coverage map shows a minimum of "Good" and in some areas, Very Good or Excellent service around Harbour View and Bolsa View (It should be noted that the web service portrays all levels of service in shades of green, which makes it difficult to distinguish between Good and Excellent service ) To verify the accuracy of the web-based coverage maps, the consultant made a series of phone calls on T-Mobile's service in the designated coverage area around both Parks (Report, pp 9-16 ) Generally, the service was "excellent," with some exceptions The Report concludes that the web-base coverage maps are accurate Mr Kramer also suggested that the City evaluate the need for this project based upon the number of persons it will serve According to T-Mobile's own objectives, the purpose of the Harbour View antenna is primarily to allow residential customers to replace landline telephone service with exclusively mobile telephone service The project is not designed for a dense commercial or industrial area, or to cover highway service The site is adjacent to single-family residences to the north, south, east and west Within a quarter-mile radius from the Park, there are approximately 216 residential units at an average of 2 74 persons per household unit, provides a population size of 592 residents There is no major through street within this residential area In other words, the demand for this project is relatively low, strongly suggesting that there is no service gap in the vicinity of the Bolsa View Project D CONCLUSION Section 24906 authorizes revocation of a permit where it was issued on the basis of erroneous or misleading information or misrepresentation In this case, T-Mobile's August 7, 2007 submittal represented that there was a significant gap in mobile telephone coverage This statement was false T-Mobile's own web-based maps indicate at least good coverage in the area of Bolsa View Park The actual telephone calls made by the Kramer Firm, Inc , Item 2. - Page 5 REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTION MEETING DATE: 8/30/2010 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: PL 10-021 indicate that excellent phone service is provided at significantly weaker signal strengths than T-Mobile's coverage maps and drive tests predict Further, absent the representations from T-Mobile that there was a significant gap in mobile telephone coverage, the Planning and Building Department would have exercised its discretion to require a public hearing to determine whether to issue a conditional use permit to site an antenna in a community park adjacent Had a public hearing been conducted, the City may have had the opportunity to receive public testimony on the compatibility of the monopole with the surrounding Park It is reasonable to conclude that the receipt of that testimony would have led to the denial of the application Given the erroneous and misleading information T-Mobile submitted, Staff recommends revocation of Wireless Permit No 2007-041 and administrative approval based upon the findings of revocation Environmental Status: The proposed project is Categorically Exempt pursuant to Section 15303 of the California Environmental Quality Act, because the project consists of the installation of a wireless communications facility and ancillary support equipment on a site zoned for such use and not involving the use of hazardous substances where all necessary public services and facilities are available and the surrounding area in not environmentally sensitive Attachment(s): o ® a 1 Su ested Findings for Revocation —Wireless Permit No 07-041 2 Applicable zoning provisions — HBZSO Section 249 06 and Ordinance No 3766 3 Wireless Permit Application, dated 7/24/07 and LA 13256 and LA13157 RF Technical Report, submitted 8/7/07 4 Notice of Action, 9/7/07 5 Kramer Declaration, 8/3/09 Personal Coverage Check for Huntington Beach 6 PKramer Firm's Preliminary Report Regarding Radio Frequency coverage Matters At and Around Harbour View Park and Bolsa View Park, dated August 2010 7 Court Order, 7/9/10 8 Court Order, 8/9/10 item 2m - Page 6 ATTACHMENT # 1 ATTACHMENT NO. 1 FINDINGS FOR REVOCATION WIRELESS PERMIT NO. 2007-041 — BOLSA VIEW PARK SUGGESTED FINDINGS FOR REVOCATION — WIRELESS PERMIT NO. 2007- 041: 1 Wireless Permit No 2007-041 for the construction of a wireless communications facility consisting of a 51 ft 7 in high broadleaf monopole and ancillary support equipment within an underground vault was conditionally approved based upon erroneous and misleading information The applicant cited on the wireless permit application dated July 25, 2007, that the subject site is needed to eliminate an existing service gap Based upon a service gap analysis dated August 16, 2010, the wireless application misrepresents the degree of the gap in existing service Since the applicant provided misleading and erroneous propagation maps the—application is revoked 2 T-Mobile stated in its August 7, 2007 submittal of "La13-157 Coverage Objective" that the Bolsa View Park antenna was to provide residential coverage in the area surrounding the Park The accompanying "Actual Drive test" showed complete "outdoor" coverage, but gaps in their "indoor" and "in- vehicle" coverage Both of these representations were misleading or false 3 In 2009, according to T-Mobile's own web-based coverage map, it was offering uninterrupted "best" coverage throughout the areas of Harbour View and Bolsa View Parks This coverage map suggests either that there are no coverage deficiencies in either area, or more likely, that T-Mobile does not consider gaps in "in-house" coverage to be significant 4 As of August 2010, T-Mobile's web-based coverage map shows a minimum of "Good" and in some areas, "Very Good" or "Excellent" service around Harbour View and Bolsa View 5 While T-Mobile has indicated in its Bosla View coverage map that the surrounding areas have signal strength from -91 dBm ("Outdoor") to -76 dBm ("In Building"), these terms area meaningless, because there are no federal rules that establish minimum signal strengths for a particular area Equally important, actual call service does not correspond with these signal strengths 6 The need for this Project is minimal The purpose of the Bolsa View antenna is primarily to allow residential customers to replace landline telephone service with exclusively mobile telephone service The project is not designed for dense commercial or industrial areas, or to cover highway service Within a quarter-mile radius from the Park, there are approximately 216 residential units at an average of 2 74 persons per household unit, provides a population size of 592 residents Based on the relatively low Item 2. - Page 8 demand for this project, there is no service gap in the vicinity of the Bolsa View Project 7 Further, absent the representations from T-Mobile that there was a significant gap in mobile telephone coverage, the Planning and Building Department would have exercised its discretion to require a public hearing to determine whether to issue a conditional use permit to site an antenna in a community park Had a public hearing been conducted, the City would have had the opportunity to receive public testimony on the compatibility of the monopole with the surrounding Park It is reasonable to conclude that the receipt of that testimony would have led to the denial of the application Item 20 a Page 9 ATTACHMENT #2 ram* F s. . grY 4 >rafoce> `e1 t t k 3 T ;oer3r Rkrxf"Sb r w s �J' Sections: 24902 Permits, Licenses, Certificates, and Approvals 24904 Enforcement Responsibilities 24906 Revocation of Discretionary Permits 24908 Enforcement Penalties 24910 Abatement-Procedure 24912 Lien Procedure 249.02 Permits, Licenses, Certificates,and Approvals Any permit, license, certificate, or approval granted in conflict with-any provision of this code shall be void All uses for which permits are issued or approvals granted shall remain in compliance with the ordinance code and evidence of failure to remain in compliance shall be deemed grounds for permit revocation. The cost of issuing permits and of enforcing compliance with the requirements and conditions of zoning permits, conditional use permits, and other discretionary approvals may be recovered through charges or fees in connection with issuance of such permits, as established by resolution of the City Council 249.04 Enforcement Responsibilities The Director shall enforce all provisions of this ordinance code and shall have responsibility for revocation of discretionary permits, as provided in Section 249.06. 249.06 Revocation of Discretionary Permits A Duties of Director Upon determination by the Director that there are reasonable grounds for revocation of conditional use permits,variance, development plan approval, or other discretionary approval authorized by this code, a revocation hearing shall be set before the original hearing body. B. Notice and Public Heanniz Notice shall be given in the same manner required for a public hearing to consider approval If no notice is required for the permit, none shall be required for the revocation hearing. C. Hearin The Planning Commission or Zoning Administrator shall hear testimony of City staff and the owner of the use or structure for which the permit was granted, if present. At a public hearing,the testimony of any other interested person shall also be heard A public hearing may be continued to a specific date, time,and place without additional public notice. Chapter 249 249-1 10/3/94 Item 2. m Page 11 D Required Findings. The Planning Commission or Zoning Administrator shall revoke the permit upon making one or more of the following findings: 1. That the permit was issued on the basis of erroneous or misleading information or misrepresentation, 2. That the terms or conditions of approval of the permit have been violated or that other laws or provisions have been violated, 3 That there has been a discontinuance of the exercise of the entitlement granted by the permit for twelve consecutive months E Decision and Notice Within ten days of the conclusion of the hearing, the Planning Commission or Zoning Administrator shall render a decision and the Director shall mail notice of the decision to the owner of the use or structure for which the permit was issued and to any other person who has filed a written request for such notice F Effective Date, Appeals. A decision to revoke a discretionary permit shall become final ten days after the date of the decision, unless appealed G Rights Cumulative The City's right to revoke a discretionary permit, as provided in this section, shall be cumulative to any other remedy allowed by law 249.08 Enforcement Penalties Each violation of the zoning and subdivision ordinances may be alternatively enforced as follows Each method set forth herein is not intended to be mutually exclusive and does not prevent concurrent or consecutive methods being used to achieve compliance against continuing violations Each and every twenty-four(24)hour period any such violations exist constitutes a separate offense. A. Misdemeanor Infraction. Any person violating any of the provisions or failing to comply with any of the mandatory requirements of Titles 20-25 of this code may be prosecuted for a misdemeanor or an infraction Written citations for misdemeanors may be issued by police officers or code enforcement officers All citations issued under this chapter shall be delivered to the City Attorney who shall have the prosecutory discretion as to the filing of a misdemeanor complaint with the court as required by California Penal Code Section 853 6 Any person convicted of a misdemeanor under the provisions of this chapter shall be punished by a fine not to exceed five hundred dollars($500 00)or imprisonment for a term not to exceed six(6)months,or both fine and imprisonment Any person convicted of an infraction shall be punished by a fine not to exceed five hundred dollars($500 00) B Civil Action. The City Attorney at the request of the City Council may institute an action in any court of competent jurisdiction to restrain, enjoin or abate the condition(s) found to be in violation of the provisions of Titles 20-25 of this code, as provided by law Chapter 249 249-2 10/3/94 Item 2® a Page 12 C. Payment of any fine or penalty shall not relieve a person, firm. or corporation from the responsibility of correcting the condition consisting of the violation. 249.10 Abatement Procedure A. Notification of Violations. Whenever the Director determines that any property within the City is being maintained contrary to the provisions of this ordinance code,the Director shall give written notice("Notice to Abate")to the owner, sent by certified mail to his Iast known address,stating the section(s)or standards being-violated. Such notice shall set forth a reasonable time limit, in no event less than seven days, for correcting the violation(s)- B. Administrative Hearing to Correct Violations. In the event said owner shall fail,neglect or refuse to comply with the "Notice to Abate,"the Director shall require the Zoning Administrator to conduct an administrative hearing to ascertain whether abatement should be required. C. Notice of Hearing. Notice of said hearing shall be mailed to the owner not less than ten days before the time fixed for hearing Failure of any person to receive notice shall not affect the validity of the abatement proceedings hereunder. D. Administrative Hearing. At the time stated in the notice, the Zoning Administrator shall hear and consider all relevant evidence,objections or protests and shall receive testimony relative to such alleged zoning violation and to the proposed eviction or relocation of an illegal use or the rehabilitation, repair, removal or demolition of an illegal structures Said hearing may be continued from time to time. If the Zoning Administrator finds that a zoning violation does exist and there is sufficient cause to evict or relocate an illegal use or rehabilitate,demolish, remove or repair an illegal structure,the Zoning Administrator shall prepare findings and an order specifying the nature of the violation,the method(s)of abatement and the time within which the work shall be commenced and completed. The order shall include reference to the right of appeal set forth in subsection(F)below. A copy of the findings and order shall be mailed to the property owner by certified mail. In addition,a copy of the findings and order shall be forthwith conspicuously posted on the property E. Procedure, No Appeal. In the absence of-any appeal,the illegal use shall be discontinued or property shall be rehabilitated,repaired, removed,or demolished in the manner and means specifically set forth in the order of abatement. In the event the owner fails to abate the violation as ordered,the Zoning Administrator shall cause the same to be abated by city employees or private contract The costs shall be billed to the owner The Zoning Administrator is expressly authorized to enter upon said property for such procedure. F. Appeal Procedure,Hearing by City Council. The owner may appeal the Zoning Administrator's findings and order to the City Council by filing an appeal with the City Clerk within seven days of the date of the Zoning Administrator's decision The appeal shall contain 1. A specific identification of the subject property 2 The names and addresses of the appellants, Chapter 249 249-3 10/3/94 Item ZD - Page 13 3. A statement of appellant's legal interest in the subject property, 4. A statement in ordinary and concise language of the specific order or action protested and the grounds for appeal,together with all material facts in support thereof, 5. The date and signature of all appellants; and 6. The verification of at least one appellant as to the truth of the matters stated in-the appeal. As soon as practicable after receiving the appeal,the City Clerk shall set a date for the Council to hear the appeal,which date shall be not less than seven days nor more than 30 days from the date the appeal was filed. The-City Clerk shall mail each appellant written notice of the time and the place of the hearing at least five days prior to the date of the hearing. Continuances of the hearing may be granted by the Council on request of the owner for good cause shown, or on the Council's own motion. G Decision by Council Upon the conclusion of the hearing,the Council shall determine whether any use or structure on the property or any part thereof, as maintained, constitutes a zoning violation. If the Council so finds, the Council shall adopt a resolution declaring such a violation, setting forth its findings and ordering the abatement of the same by having the illegal use evicted or relocated or the illegal structure rehabilitated, repaired, removed, or demolished in the manner and means specifically set forth in the resolution. The resolution shall set forth the time within which such work shall be-completed by the owner, in no event less than 30 days The decision and order of the Council shall be final H Notice of Order to Abate A copy of the resolution of the Council ordering the abatement of such violation shall be sent by certified mail to the property owner(s) Upon abatement in full by the owner, the proceedings hereunder shall terminate. I Abatement by City If such nuisance is not abated as ordered within the prescribed abatement period,the Director shall cause the same to be abated by City employees or private contract. The Director is expressly authorized to enter upon said property for such purposes. The cost,including incidental expenses,of abating the violation shall be billed to the owner and shall become due and payable 30 days thereafter The term "incidental expenses" shall include, but not be limited to,personnel costs,both direct and indirect; costs incurred in documenting the violation;the actual expenses and costs of the City in the preparation of notices, specifications and contracts, and in inspecting the work; and the costs of printing and mailing required hereunder. J. Limitation of Filing Judicial Action. Any action appealing the Council's decision and order shall be commenced within 30 days of the date of mailing the decision. K. Demolition. No illegal structure shall be found to be a zoning violation and ordered demolished unless the order is based on competent sworn testimony Chapter 249 249-4 10/3/94 Item 2. - Page 14 and it is found that in fairness and injustice there is no way other than demolition reasonable to correct such violation L. Recorded Notice of Intent to Demolish Required A copy of any order or resolution requiring abatement by demolition shall be recorded with the County Recorder. 249.12 Lien Procedure A. Record of Cost of Abatement. The Director shall keep an account of the cost, including incidental expenses, of abating zoning-violation on each separate lot or parcel of land where the work is done by the City and shall render an itemized report in writing to the City Council showing the cost of abatement, including the cost of eviction or-relocation of illegal uses or rehabilitation, demolition, or repair of illegal structures, including any salvage value relating thereto;provided that before said report is submitted to the City Council, a copy of the same shall be posted for at least five days upon the lot or parcel where the violation occurs,together with a notice of the time when said report shall be heard by the City Council for confirmation A copy of said report and notice shall be served upon the property owner(s)at least five days prior to submitting it to the City_Council Proof of posting and service shall be made by affidavit filed with the City Clerk B. Assessment Lien The total cost for abating a zoning violation,as so confirmed by the City Council, shall constitute a special assessment against the respective lot or parcel of land to which it relates,and upon recordation in the Office of the County Recorder of a Notice of Lien, as so made and confirmed, shall constitute a lien on said property for the amount of such assessment After such confirmation and recordation, a certified copy of the Council's decision shall be filed with the County Auditor-Controller on or before August 1 of each year,whereupon it shall be the duty of said Auditor-Controller to add the amounts of the respective assessments to the next regular tax bills levied against said respective lots and parcels of land for municipal purposes and thereafter said amount shall be collected at the same time and in the same manner as ordinary municipal taxes are collected, and shall be subject to the same penalties and the same procedure and sale in case of delinquency as provided for ordinary municipal taxes. All laws applicable to the levy, collection and enforcement of municipal taxes shall be applicable to such special assessment In the alternative,after recordation, such lien may be foreclosed by judicial or other sale in the manner and means provided by law. Chapter 249 249-5 10/3/94 Items 2. - Page 15 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 58-7 Filer! 05/06/10 Page 40 of 123 ORDINANCE NO 3766 AN INTERIM ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH ESTABLISHING A TEMPORARY MORATORIUM ON THE INSTALLATION OF WIRELESS TELECOMMUNICATION FACILITIES INCLUDING THOSE IN THE PUBLIC RIGHT OF WAY AND DECLARING THE URGENCY THEREOF,TO TAKE EFFECT IMMEDIATELY The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach does hereby ordain as follows. SECTION 1. The Moratonum on installation of wireless facilities Iocated in the public right-of-way,which the City adopted pursuant to Ordinance No. 3748 and extended through March 18, 2007 pursuant to City Resolution No.2006-62,is now extended for one year,throngs March 18,2008 SECTION 2 A Findings and Purpose. The City Council finds and declares. 1. In September 2002, the City Council adopted Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance Section 230 96 pertaining to wireless communication facilities and requiring that all wireless communication facilities comply with the requirements and guidelines set forth in Section 230.96 (hereinafter,the "Wireless Ordinance"). The purpose of the Wireless Ordinance included regulation of the location and design of wireless facilities for the protection of public safety, general welfare, and quality of life in the City of Huntington Beach. 2. Until the City received an application from Verizon in 2005, the City had never received an application to install a wireless facility in the public right-of-way. All such facilities had been located on private property. When the City denied the application,Verizon sued in 2006 3. In 2005, the 9t' Circuit Court of Appeals issued a ruling in Metro PCF, Inc, v City and County of San Francisco, 400 F.3d 715 (91h Cir 2005)that clarified the standards that apply with respect to regulations for wireless telecommunication facilities, especially as they relate to the requirement that such regulations not discriminate in allowing nor have the effect of prohibiting the provision of personal wireless services 4. On September 18, ?006, the Cahfarnia Supreme Court, in the case entitled Sprint Telephone PCS v County of San Diego, agreed to determine whether,pursuant to Public Utility Code Section 7901 give wireless communication providers the right to erect antennas in the public right-of-way, and (Pub. Util. Code sections 7901, 1 8122 39 Item 2. a Page 16 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 58-7 Filed 05/06/10 Page 41 of 123 Ordinance No 3766 7901.1) apply to wireless telecommunications providers, and whether Section 7901.1(a), which gives local governments the right to control the "time,place and manner in which roads . . are accessed," permit the City to regulates the aesthetics of cellular telecommunications towers erected in the public nght-of- way. 5 In light of these decisions by the State and Federal courts,the City needs to refine and develop new regulations relating to placement of wireless telecommunications facilities throughout the City, which regulations include provisions relating to the design and aesthetics of such facilities, including regulations that allow for the approval of applications for wireless facilities in the public right-of-way while the scope of the City's authority is uncertain due to the pending Supreme Court decision in the Sprint case 6. Accordingly, on August 7,2006, the City adopted Ordinance No. 3748, imposing a 45-day moratorium on the approval of any wireless communications services within the public right of way, so that the City could adopt new regulations consistent with State and Federal law("the Moratorium"). The Moratorium was later extended by six months pursuant to City Resolution No 2006-62, and is now set to expire--on March 18,2007. The purpose of the Moratorium is to ensure that all no future wireless telecommunications facilities may be installed, constructed or modified that might create or result in: i. -Land use incompatibilities; ii. Visual and aesthetic blight or view interference due to excessive size, height,or absence of camouflaging; iii. Traffic and pedestrian safety hazards due to unsafe location of poles, towers, equipment cabinets or other materials or construction,particularly in PROW locations, iv. Reduced property values; v. Operational conflicts with other land use or facilities authorized or existing on the same or neighboring sites;or vi Deterioration in the quality of life in a particular community or neighborhood. 7. During the Moratorium, the City has made substantial progress in developing appropr.ate regulations relating to the installation of all wireless facilities within the City that are consistent with the requirements of State and Federal law However, final regulations are not yet ready for review and recommendation by the City Planning Commission, and consideration and adoption by the City 2 8122 40 Item 2. a Page 17 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 58-7 Filed 05/06/10 Page 42 of 123 QrdmanceNo 3766 -Council_ There are pending applications on file with the City for the installation of wireless facilities. The City fully recognizes its responsibilities under the Federal Telecommunications Act of 1996 to not unreasonably delay installation of wireless facilities. Accordingly, the City Council will extend the current Moratorium and expand it to include all wireless facilities in the City, subject to providing interim regulations to allow the development of such facilities on private property or other public property and in the public right-of-way pending the adoption of final regulations The City believes, however, that a temporary moratorium is in the best interests of the City and its residents in order to assure that irreversible development activity does not occur that would harm the public health,safety or welfare. B. Applicability The provisions of this ordinance shaII apply to all facilities within the City used for or associated with the transmission or reception of wireless communications services (including personal communication, cellular and paging) and including, without limitation, antenna, masts, poles, towers, conduits, cables, structures, buildings, additions to existing antenna, masts,—poles, towers, structures or buildings (the "Facilities"), which Facilities shall be subject to all of the provisions as set forth below unless otherwise specified in this ordinance, notwithstanding any other regulations of the City C. Moratorium 1. The City adopts a Moratorium on the installation or modification of Facilities within all other locations in the City not in the public right-of-way. This Moratorium shall extend for 45 days,through April 16,2007 2. Together, the Moratoriums described in Subsections 1 and 2 are intended to prohibit issuance of permits for such Facilities, except pursuant to the terms and conditions of Section 3 below. [The City may continue to process such applications during the term of the moratorium; however, any new standards for such Facilities and the permitting thereof which are adopted during the moratorium and are effective at the expiration of the moratorium shall nevertheless apply to such an application. To the extent applicable, any time limits relative to the processing and action upon permit applications for any and all Facilities are tolled during the term of the moratorium D. Exceptions. The provisions of this ordinance shall not apply to: 1 Government owned and operated communications Facilities and/or existing emergency medical care provider owned and operated communications Facilities, or new Facilities in the same location as existing Facilities, which are required to 3 8122 41 Item 2. a Page 18 Case 2-09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 58-7 Filed 05/06/10- Page 43 of 123 0-dinance No 3766 repair, replace, maintain or enhance such existing Facilities, provided such Facilities are to be used primarily to protect public health, safety and welfare, as determined by the Director of Public Works. E CEQA Exemption. The City Council finds that, regarding the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), there is no possibility that the adoption of this ordinance may have a significant adverse effect on the environment (CEQA Guideline 15061 (b)(3))because this ordinance will reduce the possibility of such effects by limiting the range and intensity of new uses possible in the areas it covers. F. Effective Date. This ordinance is declared to be an urgency ordinance measure adopted pursuant to the provisions of Government Code Section 65858. As -et forth in the findings above, this ordinance is necessary for preserving the public safety, peace, health and welfare. Accordingly, upon adoption by a four-fifths vote of the City Council,this ordinance shall take effect immediately. SECTION 3 Notwithstanding the provisions of Section 1 and Section 2, the City will continue to process for all applications pursuant to this Section 3 to encourage and facilitate wireless communications throughout the City, while preventing visual clutter by locating wireless communication facilities where they are invisible to pedestrians, and co-located with other facilities. The City will process applications for all wireless facilities to be erected, located, or modified within the City of Huntington Beach on or following the date of this ordinance so long as the applicant complies with the regulations set forth in this Section 3 regarding location, placement, construction, modification and design, which regulations are necessary to protect the public safety, general welfare, and quality of life in the City of Huntington Beach. All applications, and subsequent approval thereof, must comply with the regulations included in this Section 3 as well as all existing ordinances of the City of Huntington Beach, including those may be adopted by the City Council subsequent to the adoption of this ordinance,as the same may be amended from time to time. A. Definitions. For the purpose of this Section 3,the following definitions for the following terms shall apply: 1 Accessary Structure. Any structure or equipment that is to be located ancillary to an antenna or antennas in the establishment and operation of a wireless communication facility 2 Co-Location or Co-Located. The location of multiple antennas which are either owned or operated by more than one service provider at a single location and mounted to a common supporting structure,wall or building. 3. Completely Stealth Facility. Any stealth facility that has been designed to completely screen all aspects of the facility including appurtenances and equipment from public view. Examples of completely stealth facilities m ty include,but are not limited to architecturally screened roof-mounted antennas, fagade mounted antennas treated as architectural elements to blend with the existing building,flagpoles,church steeples,fire towers,and light standards. 4 8122 42 Item 2. - Page 19 Case 2:09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 58-7 Filed 05/06/10 Page 44 of 123 Ordinance No 3766 4. Ground Mounted Facility. Any wireless antenna that is axed to a pole,tower or other freestanding structure that is specifically constructed for the purpose of supporting an antenna_ 5. Microwave Communication. The transmission or reception of radio commumcation at frequencies of a microwave signal(generally,in the 3 GHz to 300 GHz frequency spectrum). 6 Pre-existing;Wireless Facility Any wireless communication facility for which a building permit or conditional use permit has been properly issued prior to the effective date of this ordinance, including permitted facilities that have not yet been constructed so long as such approval is current and not expired. 7. Roof Mounted. Any wireless antenna directly attached or affixed to the roof of an existing building,water tank,tower or structure other than a telecommunicat.-n; tower. 8. Stealth Facility or Technique Any wireless communication facility,which is designed to blend into the surrounding environment,typically,one that is architecturally integrated into a building or other-concealing structure. 9. Utility Mounted Any wireless antenna mounted-to an existing above-ground structure specifically designed and originally installed to support utilities such as but not limited to electrical power lines,cable television lines,telephone Iines, non-commercial wireless service antennas,radio antennas,street lighting, recreational facility lighting,or any other utility which meets the purpose and intent of this definition 10. Wall Mounted Any wireless antenna mounted on any vertical or nearly vertical surface of a building or other existing structure that is not specifically constructed for the purpose of supporting an antenna(including the exterior walls of a building,an existing parapet,the side of a water tank,the face of a church steeple, or the side of a freestanding sign)such that the highest point of the antenna structure is at an elevation equal to or lower than the highest point of the surface on which it is mounted. 1 I. Wireless Communication Facility or Facility. An antenna structure and any appurtenant facilities or equipment that transmits electronic waves or is used for the transmission or receipt of signals that are used in connection with the provision of wireless communication service,including,but not liruited to digital, cellular and radio service. B. Applicability. All wireless communication facilities which are erected, located,or modified within the City of Huntington Beach shall comply with these interim regulations,provided that: I. All facilities for which building permits were issued prior to the effective date of this Ordinance,shall be exempt from this Ordinance. 2. Any facility,which is subject to a previously approved and valid conditional use permit,may be modified within the scope of the applicable permit without complying with these regulations and guidelines. 5 8122 43 Item 2. e Page 20 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 58-7 Filed 05/06/10 Page 45 of 123 Ordmance No 3766 3. Any antenna structure that is one meter(39 37 inches)or less in diameter and is designed to receive direct broadcast satellite service,including direct-to-home satellite service for television purposes,as defined by Section 207 of the- Telecommunication Act of 1996,Title 47 of the Code of Federal Regulations,and any interpretive decisions thereof issued by the Federal Communications Commission(FCC) 4 Any antenna structure that is two meters(78.74 inches)or less in diameter located in commercial or industrial zones and is designed to transnut or receive radio communication by satellite antenna. 5. Any antenna structure that is one meter(39.37 inches)or less in diameter or diagonal measurement and is designed to receive Multipoint Distribution Service, provided that no part of the antenna-structure extends more than five(5)feet above the principle building on the same lot 6. Any antenna structure that is designed to receive radio broadcast transmission. 7. Any antenna structure used by authorized amateur radio stations licensed by the FCC_ C Permit Required. 1 Administrative approval by the Director may be granted for proposed wireless communication facilities(including but not limited to ground mounted,co-located, wall,roof,or utility mounted)that are. a. Co-located with approved facilities at existing heights or comply with the base district height limit for modified facilities,and are compatible with surrounding buildings and land uses by incorporating stealth techniques;or b Completely stealth facilities and that comply with the base district height Iimit;or c Facilities in non-residential districts that are in compliance with the maximum building height permitted within the zoning district;and i. Screened from view and not visible from beyond the boundaries of the site at eye level(six feet);or ii. Substantially integrated with the architecture of the existing building or structure to which it is to be mounted;or iii Designed to be architecturally compatible with surrounding buildings and land uses by incorporating stealth techniques. 2. Following Department approval of a Wireless P: niit Application,a Conditional Use Permit by the Zoning Administrator shall be required for all proposed wireless communication facilities(including but not limited to ground mounted,co-located, wall,roof or utility mounted)that are: 6 8122 44 Item 2e - Page 21 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 58-7 Filed 05/06/10 Pagqe 46 of 123 Ordinance No. 3766 b Visible from beyond the boundaries of the site at eye level(six feet); or c Not substantially integrated with the architecture of the existing building or structure to which it is to be mounted;or d. Not designed to be architecturally compatible with surrounding buildings and land uses,or 3 As a condition of the Conditional Use Permit,the Zoning Administrator shall minimize significant adverse impacts to public visual resources by incorporating one or more of the following into project design and construction a. Stealth installations, b. Co-location and locating facilities within existing building envelopes, c Minimizing visual prominence through colonzation or landscaping, d. Removal or replacement of facilities that become obsolete. 4 Design review shall be required for any wireless communication facilities located in redevelopment areas,on public right-of-ways,in OS-PR and PS zones,in areas subject to specific plans,on or within 300 feet of a residential district,and in areas designated by the City Council. Design review is not required for wireless communication facilities that comply with subsection 1. D. Wireless Permit Required No wireless communication facility shall be installed anywhere in the City,without approval of a Wireless Permit by the Director The applicant shall submit a Wireless Permit Application and demonstrate that the antenna is Iocated in the least obtrusive location feasible so as to eliminate any gap in service.The applicant shall also provide documentation that demonstrates the following: -- 1. Existing gaps in coverage,and the radius of area from which an antenna may be located to eliminate the gap in coverage. 2. Compatibility with the surrounding environment or that the facilities are architecturally integrated into a structure. 3. Screening or camouflaging by existing or proposed topography,vegetation,buildings or other structures as measured from beyond the boundaries of the site at eye level (six feet). 4. Massing and location of the proposed facility are consistent with surrounding strictures and zoning districts. 5. No portion of a wireless communication facility shall project over property lines 7 8122 45 Item 20 - Page 22 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 58-7 Filed 05/06110 Page 47 of 123 Ordinance No 3766 5. No portion of a wireless communication facility shall project over property lines. 6. Interference- To eliminate interference the following provisions shall be required for all wireless communication facilities regardless of size: a. Prior to issuance of a building permit,the applicant must submit the following information to the Police Department for review: i All transmit and receive frequencies; ii Effective Radiated Power(ERP); iii Antenna height above ground,and iv. Antenna pattern,both horizontal and vertical(E Plane and H Plane). b. At all times,other than during the 24-hour cure period,the applicant shall cc,j ' with all FCC-standards and regulations regarding interference and the assigiiwIIIL of the use of the radio frequency spectrum. The applicant shall not prevent the City of Huntington Beach or the countywide system from having adequate spectrum capacity on the City's 800 MHz voice and data radio frequency systems. The applicant shall cease operation of any facility causing interference with the City's facilities immediately upon the expiration of the 24-hour cure period until the cause of the interference is eliminated. c. Before activating its facility,the applicant shall submit to the Police and Fire Departments a post-installation test to confirm that the facility does not interfere with the City of Huntington Beach Public Safety radio equipment. The Communications Division of the Orange County Sheriffs Department or Division-approved contractor at the expense of the applicant shall conduct this test This post-installation testing process shall be repeated for every proposed frequency addition and/or change to confirm the intent of the"frequency planning"process has been met. d. The applicant shall provide to the Planning Department a single point of contact (including name and telephone number)in its Engineering and Maintenance Departments to whom all interference problems may be reported to insure continuity on all interference issues. The contact person shall resolve all interference complaints within 24 hours of being notified. e. The applicant shall insure that lessee or other user(s)shall comply with the teens and conditions of this permit,and shall be responsible for the failure of any lessee or other users under the control of the applicant to comply. E. Facility Standards. The following standards apply to all wireless communication facilities: 1. Aesthetics a. Facility: All screening used in conjunction with a wall or roof mounted facility shall be compatible with the architecture of the building or other structure to which it is mounted,including color,texture and materials. All ground mounted facilities shall be designed to blend into the surrounding environment,or architecturally integrated into a building or other concealing structure. 8 8122 46 Item 2. - Page 23 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 58-7 Filed 05/06/10 Page 48 of 123 Ordmance No.3766 b. Equipment/Accessory Structures. All equipment associated with the operation of the facility,including but not limited to transmission cables,shall be screened in a manner that complies with the development standards of the zoning district in which such equipment is located. Screening materials and support structures housing equipment shall be architecturally compatible with surrounding structures by duplicating materials and design in a manner as practical as possible If chain link is used,then it must be vinyl coated and not include barbed wire. c. General Provisions- All Wireless Communication Facilities shall comply with the Huntington Beach Urban Design Guidelines. 2. Building Codes: To ensure the structural integrity of wireless communication facilities,the owners of a facility shall ensure that it is maintained in compliance with standards contained in applicable state or local building codes and the applicable standards for facilities that are published by the Electronic Industries Association,as amended from time to time 3. Conditions of Approval Acceptance of conditions by the applicant and property owner shall be ensured by recordation of the conditions on the property title. 4. Federal Requirements. All Wireless Communication Facilities must meet or exceed current standards and regulations of the FCC,and any other agency of the state or federal government with the authority to regulate wireless communication facilities 5. Lightinir: All outside lighting shall be directed to prevent"spillage"onto adjacent properties,unless required by the FAA or other applicable authority,and shall be shown on the site plan and elevations- 6 Maintenance: All facilities and appurtenant equipment,including landscaping,shall be maintained to remain consistent with the original appearance of the facility. Ground mounted facilities shall be covered with anti-graffiti coating. 7. Monitoring: For all wireless communication facilities,the applicant shalt provide a copy of the lease agreement between the property owner and the applicant prior to the issuance of a building permit. 8. Signs• The facility shall not bear any signs or advertising devices other than certification,warning,or other required seals of signage. 9. Facilities on Public Property. Any wireless communication facility to be placed over, within,on or beneath City property shall obtain a lease or franchise from the City prior to applying for a Wireless Permit and an administrative or conditional use permit 10. Landscaping: Landscape planting,irrigation and hardscape improvements may be imposed depending on the location,the projected vehicular traffic,the impact on existing facilities and landscape areas,and the visibility of the proposed facility. Submittal of complete iandscape and architectural plans for review and approval by the Directors of Public Works and Planning shall be required. 9 8122 47 Item 20 - Page 24 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 58-7 Filed-0--5106110 Page 49 of 123 Ordinance No 3766 l l. Utilitv Agreement: If the proposed facility will require electrical power or any other utility services to the site,the applicant will be required to furnish the City's Real Estate Services Manager,either a drafted utility franchise agreement between the City of Huntington Beach and the applicant to place those lines in the public right-of-way, or a written statement from the utility company who will be supplying the power or other services,that they accept all responsibility for those lines in the public right-of- way 12 Facilities in the Public Right-of-Way- Any wireless communication facility to be placed over,on or beneath the public-right-of-way shall comply with the following standards- a Any wireless communication facilities to be constructed on or beneath the-public right-of-way must obtain an encroachment permits from the City and the applicant must provide documentation demonstrating that the applicant is a franchised telephone corporation exempt from local franchise requirements b All equipment associated with the operation of a facility,including but not limiter'to cabinets,transmission cables but excepting antennas,shall be placed underground in those portions of the street,sidewalks and public rights-of-way where cable television,telephone or electric lines are underground. At no time shall equipment be placed underground without appropriate conduit. c. The City Engineer shall approve the location and method of construction of all facilities located within public nghts-of-way and the installation of facilities within the public nghts-of-way must comply with to Title 12 of the Huntington Beach Municipal Code,as the same may be amended from time to time. d. All wireless communication facilities shall be subject to applicable City permit and inspection fees,including,but not limited to,those pertaining to encroachment permits,administrative or conditional use permits,and all applicable fees. (3568-9l02) e. Any wireless communication facility installed,used or maintained within the public rights-of-way shall be removed or relocated when made necessary by any "project." For purposes of this section,project shall mean any lawful change of grade,alignment or width of any public right-of-way,including but not limited to, the construction of any subway or viaduct that the City may initiate either through itself,or any redevelopment agency,community facility district,assessment district,area of benefit,reimbursement agreement or generally applicable impact fee program. (3568-9l02) £ If the facility is attached to a utility pole,the facility shall be removed,at no cost- to the City,if the utility pole is removed pursuant to an undergrounding project. g. The service provider shall enter into a franchise agreement with the City. As of March 17,2007,the California Supreme Court,in the case entitled Sprint Telephony PCS v County of San Diego,will determine whether California Public Utilities Code §7901 grants a state-wide franchise to use the public rights-of-way for the purpose of installation of wireless communications facilities. Pending resolution of this legal question,any applicant seeking to use the public right-of- 10 8122 48 Rein 2e - Page 25 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 58-7 Filed 05/0S/10 Page 50 of 123 Ordinance No.3766 way must enter into a City franchise to install wireless communications facilities. The franchise shall provide that the franchise fee payments shall be refunded to the applicant and the franchise become null and void if and when the California Supreme Court establishes that the provider has a state-wide franchise to install a wireless communications facility in the public right-of-way. 13 Facility Removal. a Wireless communication facilities affecting the public view and/or located in areas designated water Recreation,Conservation,Parks and Shoreline shall be removed within six(6)months of termination of use and the site restored to its natural state. b. Cessation of Operation- Within thirty(30)calendar days of cessation of operations of any wireless communication facility approved under this section, the operator shall notify the Planning Department in writing. The facility shall be deemed abandoned pursuant to the following sections unless: 1. The City has determined that the operator has resumed operation of the wireless communication facility within six(6)months of the notice,or 2. The City has received written notification of a transfer of wireless communication operators c. Abandonment: A facility that is inoperative or unused for a period of six(6) continuous months shall be deemed abandoned. Written notice of the City's determination of abandonment shall be provided to the operator of the facility and the owner(s)of the premises upon which the facility is located. Such notice may be delivered in person,or mailed to the address(es) stated on the facility permit application,and shall be deemed abandoned at the time delivered or placed in the mail. (3568-9/02) d. Removal of Abandoned Facility. The operator of the facility and the owner(s)of the property on which it is located,shall within thirty(30)calendar days after notice of abandonment is given either(1)remove the facility and restore the premises,or(2)provide the Planning Department with written objection to the City's deternunahon of abandonment Any such objection shall include evidence that the facility was in use during the relevant six-(6)month period and that it is presently operational. The Director shall review all evidence,determine whether or not the facility was properly deemed abandoned,and provide the operator notice of its determination. e. Removal by City: At any time after thirty-one(31)calendar days following the notice of abandonment,or immediately following a notice of determination by the Director,if applicable,the City may remove the abandoned facility and/or repair any and all damage to the premises as necessary to be in compliance with applicable codes The City may,but shall not be required to,store the removed facility(or any part thereof). The owner of ttie premises upon which the abandoned facility was located,and all prior operators of the facility, shall be jointly liable for the entire cost of such removal,repair,restoration and/or storage, and shall remit payment to the City promptly after demand thereof is made. The 11 8122 49 Item 2. - Page 26 Case 2.09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 58-7 Flied 05/06/10 Page 51 of 123 Ordinance No 3766 City may,in lieu of storing the removed facility,convert it to the City's use,sell it,or dispose of it in any manner deemed appropriate by the City. SECTION 4. If any section, subsection, sentence, clause, or phrase of this ordinance is for any reason held to be invalid or unconstitutional by a decision of any court of competent Jurisdiction, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions-of this ordinance The City Council hereby declares that-it would have passed this ordinance and each and every section, subsection, sentence, clause, or phrase, not declared invalid or unconstitutional without regard to whether any portion of the ordinance would be subsequently declared invalid or unconstitutional. SECTION 5 The City Clerk shall cause this ordinance to be posted in three places designated by City Council pursuant to City Charter Section 500(c)and published by title with a brief summary at least once within fifteen(15)days after its adoption in a newspaper of general circulation, published in the County of Orange and circulated in the City, in accordance with Section 36933-of the California Government Code; shall certify to the adoption of this ordinance and shall cause a certified copy of this ordinance, together with proof of publication, to be filed in the Office of the Clerk of this City PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at a regular meeting thereof held on the 5th day of March ,2007 Jygt a®e p@� a ATTEST: - APPROVED AS TO FORM: Of_/1J,9 W) City Clerk Z• �tyttomey REVIEWED AND APPROVED. INITIATED AND APPROVED- I' City Adodnistrator ity Attorney 12 8I22 50 item 20 - Page 27 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 58-7 Filed 05/06/10 Page 52 of 123 Urgency Ord.No.3766 STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH ) 1,JOAN L.FLYNN,the duly elected,qualified City Clerk of the -City of Huntington Beach,and ex-officio Clerk of the City Council of said Cit,. hereby certify that the whole number of members of the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach is seven;that the foregoing ordinance was read to said City Council at a regular meeting thereof held on the 5th day of]March,2007 and was passed and adopted by at least five affirmative votes of said City Council. AYES: Bohr,Carchio,Cook,Coerper,Green,Hansen, Hardy NOES: None ABSENT: None The foregoing instrument is a correct copy of the original on file In this office. ABSTAIN: None ur� 1� ►—R--�— y erk and Ex-o icio Cltrk of ffW_aFt Council of the City of Huntington Beach, California I,JOAN L FLYNN,CITY CLERK of the City of By_ - Deputy Huntington Beach and ex-officio Clerk of the City g 4 Council,do hereby certify that a synopsis ofthis R tl��fJ ordinance has been published in the Huntington Beach f Fountain Valley Independent on March is.2007 In accordance with the City Charter of said City City Clerk and ex-offieio Clerk Joan L.Flygn,City Clerk of the City Council of the City IddA 1W Dcvu!x Ct Clerk of Huntington Beach,California 51 Item 2e - Page 28 ATTACHMENT #3 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH WIRELESS PERMIT APPLICATION FORM This form is designed to elicit required technical Information in support of an application for a new or modified permit (generally, the "Permit") for a wireless site within the City of Huntington Beach This application is a mandatory element of the application process No application for a new wireless site Permit or for a modification of an existing wireless site Permit shall be considered for determination of completeness until this form and required attachments are provided to the City of Huntington Beach Every page of this form, including this page, must be completed and submitted to the City of Huntington Beach, and each page must be signed and/or initialed where indicated Questions about this form or the required information to be provided should be directed to the City Planner assigned to your project or to the Director of Planning at(714) 536-5271 for the City of Huntington Beach You are advised to be familiar with the City's Municipal Code and Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance, which establishes standards and guidelines for the installation of wireless communications facilities in the City of Huntington Beach <Continue to next page> i I f 06-595/9174 3l30/07 i Page 1 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here MM I I I Item 2. m Page 30 1 00- Applicant Information 101 Project Address 5741 Briahton Dr Huntinaton Beach CA 1 02 Project Assessors Parcel 163-213-01 Number Omnipoint Communications, Inc a subsidiary 1 03 Name of Applicant of T-Mobile USA, inc ( T-Mobile) 1 04 Name of Property Owner city of Huntington Beach 1 05 Applicant is _Owner XX Owner's representative Other 1 06 Applicant's Address Line 1 3 Imperial Promenade, Santa Ana-CA 92707 Agent Representative for T-Mobile 1 07 Applicant's Address Line 2 One venture Suite 200 Trvi ne CA 9261 s 1 08 Applicant's Address Line 3 109 Applicants Address Line 4 Please contact 1 10 Applicant's Phone number 714 850 2414 Monica Morelia Phone No 949 241 0175 1 11 Applicant's Mobile number 949 350 5376 Fax No 949 753 7203 monica moretta @ sequoia-ds com 1 12 Applicant's Fax number 714 850 6630 1 Applicant Representative 1 13 Applicant's Email address Toe thompson@T-Mobile com If Applicant is the Property Owner and the name and contact information above is the same, initial here and proceed to 3 01 <Continue to next page> 06-595/9174 3/30/07 Page 2 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here MM Item 2e a Page 31 200 Project Owner Information 201 Disclose the Names, Addresses, contact persons, and telephone numbers for all Project Owners (use additional sheets if required and mark as "Attachment 2 01") Omnipoint Communications, Inc a subsidiary 202 Project Owner Name (i a-, carrier or licensee) of T-Mobile USA, Inc ( T-Mobile) 2 03 Address (line 1) 3 Imperial Promenade, Santa Ana CA 92707 204 Address (line 2) one venture, Suite 200 2 05 City Irvine State CA Zip 92618 206 Contact Person Name Monica Moretta 2.07 Contact Person's telephone numberlextension 949 241 0175 2 08 If the Applicant is not the project owner, attach a letter of agency appointing the Applicant as representative of the Project-Owner(s) in connection with this application Designate the letter of agency as "Attachment 2 08" Initial here MM if Attachment 2 08 is attached to this application, and continue to300 2 09 If the Applicant is not the property owner, attach a letter of agency appointing the Applicant as representative of the Property Owner in connection with this application Designate the letter of-agency as "Attachment 2 09" Initial here MM if Attachment 2 09 is attached to this application, and continue to 3 00 <Continue to next page> i 06-595/9174 3130/07 Page 3 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here MM i i Item 2. - Page 32 300 Project Purpose 301 Justification, Provide a non-technical narrative, accompanied by written documentation where appropriate, which explains the purpose(srof the proposed Project 302 Indicate whether the dominant purpose of the Project is to add additional network capacity, to increase existing signal level, or to provide new radio frequency coverage (check only one) Add network capacity without adding significant new RF coverage area XX Increase the existing RF signal level in an existing coverage area Provide new radio frequency coverage in a significant area not already served by existing radio frequency coverage by the same Owner or affiliated entity (such as a roaming agreement with an affiliated entity for a cellular or PCS carrier) Other 303 If the answer in 4 02 is not"Other" proceed to 5 00 304 Attach a statement fully and expansively describing the "Other" dominant purpose of this project Designate this attachment, "Attachment 4 04" Initial here to indicate that Attachment 4 04 is attached to this application <Continue to next page> I i i l 06-595!9174 3/30/07 ' Page 4 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here mm ! i I i Item 2. - Page 33 400 Radio Frequency Coverage Maps 401 Where a licensee intends to provide radio frequency geographic coverage to a defined area from the Project(including applicants in the cellular, PCS, broadcast, ESMR/SMR categories), the coverage maps and information requested below are required attachments All others proceed to 7 00. For the coverage maps required here, the following mandatory requirements apply 1 The size of each submitted map must be no smaller than 8 5" by 11 and all maps must be of the same physical size, scale, and depict the same geographic area Include major streets and street names on each map All maps must share a common color scheme 2. If the FCC rules for any proposed radio service define a minimum radio frequency signal-strength level, that level must be shown on the map in a color easily distinguishable from the base paper or transparency layer, and adequately identified by RF level and map color or gradient in the map legend If no minimum signal level is defined by the FCC rules you must indicate that in the legend of each RF coverage map You may show other RF signal level(s) on the map so long as they are adequately identified by objective RF level and map color or gradient in the map legend 3 RF coverage maps with labels such as, "In-Budding" "In-Car" and "Outdoor" or referencing a link budget without corresponding signal strengths in units of "dBm"will be rejected 4 Where the City of Huntington Beach determines that one or more submitted maps are inadequate, it reserves the right to require that one or more supplemental maps with greater or different detail be submitted 402 Map of existing RF coverage within the City of Huntington Beach on the same network, if any (if none, so state) This map should not depict any RF signal coverage to be provided by the Project Designate this map "Attachment 6 02" Initial here min to indicate that Attachment 6 02 is attached to this application 4 03. Map of RF coverage to be provided only by the Project This map should not depict any RF coverage provided by any other existing or proposed wireless sites Designate this map"Attachment 6 03". Initial here mm to indicate that Attachment 6 03 is attached to this application 404 Map of RF coverage to be provided by the Project and by other wireless sites on the same network should the Project be approved Designate this map "Attachment 6 04" Initial here mm to indicate that Attachment 6 04 is attached to this application <Continue to next page> 06-595/9174 3/30107 Page 5 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here mm Item 2. - Page 34 500 Project Photographs and Photo Simulations 501 Where an Applicant proposes to construct or modify a wireless site, the Applicant shall submit pre-project photographs, and photo simulations showing the project after completion of construction, all consistent with the following standards I . -Minimum size of each photograph and photo simulation must be 8 5" by 11" (portrait or landscape orientation), 2 All elements of the project as proposed by the Applicant must be shown in one or more close-in photo simulations 3. The overall project as proposed by the Applicant must be shown in five or more -area photos and photo simulations Photos and photo simulation views must, at a minimum, be taken from widely scattered positions separated by an angle -of no greater than 72 degrees from any other photo location 4. -For each photograph and photo simulation, show on an area map the location and perspective angle of each photograph and photo simulation in relationship -to the Project location 5. All 'before' and after photos and photo simulations must be of the same scale For example, do not place a smaller'before' photo in a box on the same page as a large 'after' photo simulation The number of site photos, and photo simulations, and the actual or simulated camera location of these photos and photo simulations are subject to City of Huntington Beach determination The Applicant must submit photos and photo simulations consistent with these instructions, and be prepared to provide additional photos and photo simulations should they be requested by the City of Huntington Beach <Continue to next page> 06-595/9174 3/30107 Page 6 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here MM Item 2. a Page 35 600 Candidate Sites 6,01 For applicants in the cellular, PCS, broadcast, ESMR/SMR categories, and others as requested by the City of Huntington Beach,the information requested in-Section 8 is required All others proceed to 9 00 602 Has the Applicant or Owner or anyone working on behalf of the Applicant or Owner secured or attempted to secure any leases or lease-options or similar formal-or informal agreements in connection with this project for any sites other than the candidate site identified at 1 01 and 1 02? Yes No 603 If the answer to 8 02 is NO, proceed to 8 05 604 Provide the physical address of each such other location, and provide an expansive technical explanation as to why each such other site was disfavored over the Project Site Designate this attachment"Attachment 8 04" Initial here to indicate that Attachment 8 04 is attached to this application 605 Considering this proposed site, is it the one and only one location within or without the City of Huntington Beach that can possibly meet the objectives of the project? xx Yes No 606 If the answer to 8 05 is NO, proceed to 9 00 607 Provide a technically expansive and detailed explanation supported as required by comprehensive radio frequency data fully describing why the proposed site is the one and only one location within or without the City of Huntington Beach that can possibly meet the radio frequency objectives of the project Explain, in exact and expansive technical detail, all of the objectives of this project Designate this attachment, "Attachment 8 07" Initial here MM to indicate that Attachment 8 07 is attached to this application <Continue to next page> 05-595/9174 3/30/07 Page 7 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here MM Item 2e - Page 36 700 Identification of Key Persons 7 01 Identify by name, title, company affiliation, work address, telephone number and extension, and email address the key person or persons most knowledgeable regarding 7 10 (1) The site selection for the proposed project, including alternatives, 711 Name Monica Moretta 7 12 Title Agent Representative 7 13 Company Affiliation Sequoia Deployment Services, Inc 7 14 Work Address one Venture, Suite 200 Irvine, CA 92618 7 15 Telephone/ Ext 949 241 0175 7 16 Email Address mon>ca more-taouaalinta-rid rom 720 (2) The radio frequency engineering of the proposed project, 721 Name Jose Pena 722 Title RF Engineer 7.23 Company Affiliation T-Mobile 724 Work Address 3 imperial Promenade Santa Ana, CA 92707 725 Telephone/Ext 310 279 9925 726 Email Address Pena, Jose [Jose Pena@T-Mobile com] 7.30 (3) Rejection of other candidate sites evaluated, if any, 7 31 Name Jose Pena 732 Title RF Engineer 733 Company Affiliation T-Mobil e 734 Work Address 3 I=erial Promenade Santa Ana CA 92707 7 35 Telephone/Ext 310 279 9925 7.36 Email Address Pena Tnsp [7nsP PPna(@T-Mnhi 1 P_rnm] 740 (4) Approval of the selection of the proposed site identified in this project 7.41 Name Joe Thompson & Duan Dao 742 Title zoning Manager 743 Company Affiliation 1-mobif. 744 Work Address I Tmnerlal Promenade Santa Ana (A 92707 745 Telephone/ Ext 714 sso 2414 746 Email Address 3oe thompson@T-Mobile com 7 5 If more than one person is/was involved in any of the four functions identified in this section, attach a separate sheet providing the same information for each additional person, and identifying which function or functions are/were performed by each additional person Designate this attachment"Attachment 7 5" Initial here to indicate that the information above is complete and there is no Attachment 7 5, or initial here to indicate that Attachment 7 5 is attached to this application <Continue to next page> 0&595/9174 3/30/07 Page 8 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here MM Item 2m m Page 37 8.00 Form Certification 801 The undersigned certifies on behalf of itself and the Applicant that the answers pro ide re#rue an_d complete to the best of the undersigned's knowledge Agent Representative Sig Title Mo rilc�a monica moretta@sequoia-ds com Print Name Email Address Sequoia Deployment Services, Inc on behave of T-Mobile 949 241 0175 Print Company Name, Telephone Number/extension D7 -�2 Date Sig ed <Stop Here End of Form> 06-595/9174 3/30107 Page 9 of 9 Applicant Must initial Here MM Item 20 a Page 38 LA13156 and LA13157 RF Technical Report 4� 7 0 Overview °v The FCC license required T-Mobile to build a wireless network that will provide the best network performance to customers as possible. Also, the FCC license required T- Mobile to put up a wireless network in accordance with the Federal Communication Commission requirements and under the compliance of Federal, State and local mandates laws. The goals of the network performance are to provide best quality, lowest level of blocking, easy access to the network and continuous drop-free connections. Also, the site will operate below the radio frequency emission limits set forth by the Federal Communication Commission. T-Mobile is proposing a site installation located at 16600 Saybrook Avenue, Huntington Beach, CA 92649 and at 5741 Brighton Drive, Huntington Beach, CA 92649 with an effort to adhere all the requirements set by FCC, Federal, State and local mandates. � T Site Details Slete Details : Site ID : LA13156A Site Name : Huntington Harbor Garden Park Site Address: 16600 Saybrook Avenue, Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Site Design: Palm Tree Site ID : LA13157B Site Name : Bolsa View Park Site Address: 5741 Brighton Drive, Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Site Design: Palm Tree r �D ° Guidelines used o The following guidelines were used to determine the best candidate for site LA13156A and LA13157A: 1 . Site Visit — Visual assessment of the area to search for viable candidates based on location, structure height, topography, lease area, etc. 2. Propagation Analysis — T-Mobile USA uses a prediction tool, known as Asset, to project the expected coverage of the new cell site. 3. Drive Test Data — T-Mobile USA uses real-time data collected from the field to determine the need of an additional site. � ,• � + �' " + ��. �� � spy y A l ,'CF �W- + '177 r gy C4, C M ji�"z A, 42 J, t ltv, ol A,k;s,o 4 "If rj- Ri- 4Yvl'-1 111, i4iAZS 4 " " , a W. Ai Kv JAN vi U41 ft nZIt" 4" 01 fi — 'WRil Ji ,t,g, 4ksi ez -2 F =,r txt r ' f a9 Mas rv',. ��.dry, l 1 �A 46oT if S"k '+k Y4 .ti a 'Lto R tlg1 ! "ro' ,. ; .` .. - ��hf� {�1' ,A.q4 f ✓,�Y,t.Cs$`E } � ''` x 4.'�: � I SS B • .� � fraa�r n-ttxt,...'a^m^txr.�xu�tat�tr�k� �4'�wt� ,..,' a���F`rc'w " �9��t�r___-haw� '`�Y`',v�,:w r � • • i • r r ..�. ~ ell irpar^g- � �:� � 'F,� ♦ f ''4!3f ,5 �..��'s - 1 '�vtr$�� '� [ .E., n sd,� p {{� t� rf �.Y�fi j' , �.,�7+��'. „� ,�+''rp�!"�'T� .,: f +� J i,�r ,.•� M.- ., v 4s1' e* « �� r k� P� ^'iS r4 '�` P .,,� a i �tt �A�� � r an,�'. S f"y'p 5 �`w�`�+ >•:.'S t'wt ��5 5 �' � s � "^, r1.av S�t� d �sJ�r t n4�EiCt'�S,�.t 21 1y+ [ J y ) § 7 t �•�"{ m4}s i�goo£ 3 Existing sites • 1 7iF P�y"F° ;�yb�'2 C 1 �` `.•k �° � p L V ( �! y F�v E<. �' o ( ^ ,�' M1}�" Riy �'�a �''t',K �'fd,•t. r�bg '»w �� r 't i '�` �(� �. s F L i, S .A cant provide enough � • r • LA13136A is being rt.�Jrry' �•r ai E �' g «�i.: sJ +gr l' • 7�yt e •7 * a proposed to • ' installed in HuntingtonGarden park to "'s� �+'� � �� ,- +�, �� �yy�� �`x'�y,�A [�4 � •"43 Ir +� ads �1 4 provide needed coverage as well as a �.s,=r3 ?4 trR rf-9 •��l S'.:,t ` L,v'� bt 5 balance • • r with existing 4 .., R'itlT'fi.' 7, d 44�tYn 'dfbMl' r' 11 Proposed site location ;i .. symmetrical with existing • ��• � r � ��� t't' G 3 1 t �`'s, � �� L4 # ', i kn'('�,L�"t 5 sites hence required �:.5 l i.',`ya,t`a-2'� ' r �y z s d P i S y' it •Yn :� �, _q �t icoverage : � ��'' �� S, � x +� r"tr �a r�+yt jnr + ��"'' 4� 4�u f�^ a• �,%a , aa,�•��� �"�,�6� �.-: s :'� .,,�t%� , ,.y. v .��ak•.� <; � �,�;G i�=,i"�'u`,��.b �� r��u"�t:::s�.aa t.,�'9�>• to �a �F� s> :�.�:,,. � .;tr. �° 6��e J � ��'.�` °�,'� , a� .;:;'�< .• q ,F�i �s.. ° ,1 ��t .. 3d$ :t 1ct. �i s , .,. �. ;. .r.• w g,.,�-n,Ly�{ ,�.: �.:�yl,�t+'s '�z� hy�2. �� x f�;� �3t„���+z. � r a',-�, Covers with the site 2 5 Prediction plot shows that the Site can be move here but its all residential current proposed sites will meet the desired coverage , objective. This also shows a balance coverage with existing sites. A02207ANP � Site can also be move towards north however, the area is all ,. residential no place to install the site. Huntington Harbor park is the only option for this �xAa2osoA � site. 0256 MVIS ALA v Outdoor In Vehicle In Budding `< r � ��a8✓� :!xw p,�e�x�d n �, vA,�rE �av'<.p ;��, �,»..'�;,'",a w s. `.�. n� � ,r��F,�}. . ���"Ja�r .,,� `� '� U1 ..... ..... For i'vs.4� Al",-",'A T. nq pm-M-0- A f5 'Af AM;1.4 xt, �F:;#! "''Z61": A,q'. gq 4 7.1 vA IN NMI dkor '03 tit rry '-wof A Mu4 mv }4 6T WO A Mon 1 om� A q�' v RES, p LA13157 Actual Drive test DMA's Showing T Coverage it Or 95A Weak coverage on this A02,463 area (low on In vehicle and In Building Coverage) 0285-3t A- Proposed site location is symmetrical with existing sites hence required he coverage objective is 02089 meet. Area is all residential no other place we can install the site that will provide balance coverage with existing sites. Coveiage Letjend Outdoor In Vehicle In Building N$ Mel M 114 wr fD Coverage Map with the proposed site LA1 3157A Prediction plot shows that the J current proposed sites will "LAM" meet the desired coverage ",d"02853A &,""Wir Df wl I., t t I objective. This also shows the I _J �hvaft Or Ueo C" balance coverage with existing a Dr MAR", s _J ites. Dr r V Proposed site location is 0*Or _J . . 11 surrounded by residential area. & �111,ada rig Bolsa View Park is the only option for this site. —D Brien Do Z )2 gl-ovetagrgle Legend Outdoor In Vehicle In Building Cy rIs°,1T "'Y_- � � YS ro brassitur .,S, wr �s 4- �y sr° - its - r m�4�,' , p u Heil AvNy Attachment a 011 Current Coverage without LA13157A t� p �� � ALA1315G t�q e �p �4 Ora(T m fie Dr tta rl b� o Dr n n o� w s s �A02463A �� o m 4 S1t1U5 C0 „'�LA028X3S" .�`��� r � J a Aladdin Or y (= a} r s >,$`{��` y i 5 ra �3'` r- J 0 CD j I i Warner Ava', 0 , , , CID j 25 G4enstone Or t/7 '�{tr ut y ,� �tii,` su'a��4� kywµ'f � ' �r i q Or fU �i X r, r rji Q Q JG3T`��.n ,� � , 2Ipty�n +J'' � {� I l�tr tt1 Armada Or A ' C gin,, w �� *a�=' "Arfo'�►e`��!`Or &� Dr 3 � rD0 � °V �iA13157' F r uN ; ?�' a O g a: • v 1x wa: ;x G adU r' W mr LA02089A v Balmoral Dr o a (DIrta Ln e .( 't,•"� '� ,,t 't, "�ST�•z�t Rta y"�,E�p ,r t" nk / r �r Ns tt . 3 s 2Y . '+�ifp5,_!� S e1v�,rk '�•q�t D (D y � ,, �a,,°�,,,,,`` Mz�ax , �61 M a t�r m` S 2rk r f�,s , �� � � Utop C ' '�, + �5'� LA02543A � �� AveA A n RT C1r G `17 ' t y•�''``^fy "�,; '"? `4 ',�„a�Y. w''w'�t9 ,x, „t ,£445(xnb w.+� "' t�,t ' z. C �,iT'Ira' «axm�j(rxt,Ti�"s,„! , � + ,,.h�n��w,�z,�,�'"P,�4 ds�i 5'� �'E 4"_ ,°(" s`Y ;,,�r t r`y° �;�.;, rr< tNt � t t ,, k r a 'xr,*^ 3 n f,ty� ;ice,.x5.,� ya i hL y`k R}+ d qK ° 9,°n na P'"` s�.r'" ask �; ,rv„ 9z'x- �fc�,*' +r"x.�`°' .7rd'. ,m„ "t"r•qY /d"n; ?,;,r ,,;. t r` , r^ m �, f 2, - 3`s°�, ':x� .w , ",,k, Nnr r k ",, �r 0�` qr r „y �dv,• �... r" „ �' Mon ri� • :Y a° .t "+e wJ n �6`, .,4 % ` �c'}" *g7o` 0, 'k T`��� �,p ,'��*�,� 'd' �s�i'�1 r�a �' a,��' Ste, �" e;e rs. , tr,�,^.;o w���u v^�F 'h'�'�,,•'`:�:, .���" �• •t�s'�`•1'`.`+�i �7eut(e AV $rtw tit ? , 'A' .�" ��`A�-t, d�i`A b•w �s�Y,E' i t � en o{ Coverage rS�Legend e f.�``� �., "s. f 2"r 5♦ �`�o-4( +! 4 �`' >;'T f. a" ��'� SY �&,. �T`*+^<�a+s'S,�"�,�`x+i i €� 0 '; .41'S..�� s'.w�,�< �'+d�`t;^ 1 ° This information property of T Mobile USA Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed Any other use or distribution of this Outdoor(-91 dbm) information is strictly prohibited This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors which may change without notice It may include locations with limited or no coverage Our maps do not guarantee service availability Even within a coverage area there are several factors such as network changes traffic volume service outages In Vehicle(-84 dbm) technical limitations signal strength your equipment terrain structures weather and other conditions that may interfere with actual service quality and availability including the ability to make receive and maintain calls In Building(-76 dbm) M r J Co �fd6 .C o via vista Cir�� `a ro r brass) ur -c j cc�s � %c uL CE " 0 9 Hell Ave Attachment 4 03� �p Coverage for LA13157A F m° Cr grantotd DALA13156 Arena C. Dr ; m w Cori ;, 7 T 'de Cir o o Sandy Dr Brightfield Clr A nette Clr BrarT ( m co Dale Dr t U) p c Barracuda Chariotta Dr Do le Dr Z> o c b�\\O _ �tu�c _o LAO 4 Acorn Dr n n Eft w ...i w Q' ro 2 63A r - o ® r p �LA02864 /(''�� r` n U T to / `'�� �4Yn 4 M �. \ G� C Li.'4r �'� "� ,a;"''z-\f� �� _ n o to n/ SOU USrIz "� > t31 4�,,," mC' mes Cir / S Dun ar Dr $`Y, ALAWiS3 wxa � 0 c � � < Galn Ave Aladdin Dr t d; , �,' J o m c Q Belsita Curtis Cir c z , ti-,��Warner Aves Ave "� - ` _� �'� _ *> > ° �o Q _ Cedar Ave 9� OF%rx. �� ` r Ghent DrrF � w m �'' e�� c ; , , Athena Dr o o a� �� O _t,as Mil."Nr CJ m � m G � 'i/,Glenston �t � ,r -0 ro c Co c �' o Cory o m X Wagon CU n Ct3 _l Q �o d ¢ A1CW`QC w a o Burton Dr tiM k ,^°Arada Dr > > > z w r whead Dr 31 m a w Belva Dr E c LA13157 3 -a r r � 0t ter o LA02089A 4 w ��� ma xy i �dA _ a 11 ` Harriman Ave �r a`"�t� ��,f!�,J�l_wp�s�,✓^"r�,ra1rt' o \ m1A02267A tw Taylor Dr iys, +�,a, �t ��r,a�,'�1=a�,�^t i�i+� n•auK*��y'y ��(4� P,;,.s A �qt` (,/j_'^y", i�..ht�"� � N f, ��; CDc Albs t cp Elli Ave C40543A AUtOpark Dr � �z ,, Brook Corral Clr nett-n m Overlo � a Ca c m c Ambe fi � v c 0 Pta���os Cat S'i�i co Q c n e, Mon rl Q (n 4Wd Road G_arfie Ave Brentwoot Coverage Legend nv ,Cv Ashbun. This information property or T Mobile USA Inc is confidential and is intended soiey for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed Any other use or distribution of this l Outdoor(-91 dbm) information is strictly prohibited This map predicts and approximates our wireless uoverage area outdoors which may change without notice It may include locations with limited or no coverage Our maps do not guarantee service availability Even within a coverage area there are several factors such as network changes traffic volume service outages In Vehicle(-84 dbm) technical limitations signal strength your equipment terrain structures weather and other conditions that may interfere with actual service quality and availability including the ability to make receive and maintain calls In Building(76 dbm) _ - P _ tSrassf ;ivtPra` !,gx C0 F,s3 �j�rr u Hell Av Current Coverage with LA13157A {F , Attachment 4 04 t)ALA13156 _� � .txi �h C� s ,�, �� �ll a, ao D2a DrCir m rl0tta Dr g b <� 0 m LA02463A V` O LA0286FD 4 °-# � E, co _ a �wt,v,Sv Wn ®LA02853 " " NAM,, CD Aladdin Dr t " ? a� rr -Warner AveY," c Ghent D "brc 1 n o U Ryt 14 r m N Q U QlenStOt1 l�� r qa fi« r C �' as'' J r U W ^sv" rn�td�`� as,, °'�"tAx`Y,11 ( *8'., LAL , ..,w�. ,v�z Ct n>3'�iat�=` y,�,k�" s�,F ��e ��', ♦ �^", -'', -.afr2+<` tip_ s.;� , �',',kz�-k a'.t 2 '� K C: 0 i �^k',P'` p��6 Q � � 6 Q '✓ J BUrtO� t, �p1 �',,, y } 'RtFr x r� zYt3 IJ11flCbr D > C nwdr '" 3 Whead Dr ' Dr .0 1315 — va` ;r` LA7 r �' LA02089A Balmoral Dr o ` O r e ;3t s'y 4 0226 A�'t ' '�" CD < �a: LA02543A Ave A o 4v�35w ''a{ CirL RJ " ` � ,l4 C C m C , p aim! Will ql 4u .{°j ". �.s "t v '5�;>. >,� r {5.: �'•a$y> @ '��i,F, Man rl ' � SlerltlYO - rvt� z tam t 3Ce AVM= Coverage Legend y tlbtrria, , t' ' This information property of T Mobile USA Inc is confidential and is intended coley for the use of the individual or entity to whom itis addressed Any other use or distribution of this ," ;' Outdoor(-91 dbm) ° information is strictly prohibited This map prpdicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors which may change without notice It may include locations with limited or no coverage Our maps do not guarantee service availability Even withm a coverage area there are several factors such as network changes traffic volume service outages In Vehicle(-84 dbm) technical limitations signal strength your equpmpnt terrain structures weather and other conditions that may interfere with actual service quality and availability including the ability to make receive and maintain calls In Budding(76 dbm) Amm, U rt fD 0 L S fD 3 " 5 6 A All, �e n CT , , r uDlTZD i I lu- ATTACHMENT #4 City of Huntington Beach 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 9x : 5 DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING Phone 536-5271 Fax 374-1540 NOTICE OF ACTION September 7, 2007 SUBJECT: WIRELESS PERMIT NO. 07-041 (OMNIPOINT COMMUNICATIONS) APPLICANT: Monica Moretta, One Venture, Suite 200, Irvine, CA 92618 PROPERTY OWNER: City of Huntington Beach REQUEST: To permit the- installation of a wireless communication facility within an approximately 51 ft 7 in high broadleaf monopole and underground vault LOCATION: 5741 Brighton Drive, Huntington Beach, CA 92649 DATE OF ACTION: September 7, 2007 Dear Applicant On September 7, 2007, the Department of Planning of the City of Huntington Beach conditionally approved your request for a wireless permit Your request as submitted may be submitted for building plan check subject to the conditions of approval Attached to this letter are the conditions of approval for your application Please be advised that the Department of Planning reviews the conceptual plan as a basic request for entitlement of the use applied for and there may be additional requirements prior to issuance of building permits It is recommended that you immediately pursue completion of the conditions of approval and address all requirements of the Huntington Beach Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance in order to expedite the processing/completion of your project. The conceptual plan should not be construed as a precise plan, reflecting conformance to all Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance requirements Under the provisions of the Huntington Beach Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance, the action taken by the Department of Planning is final unless an appeal is filed to the Planning Commission by you or by an interested party A person desiring to appeal the decision shall file a written notice of appeal to the Secretary of the Planning Commission within ten calendar days of the date of the Department of Planning's action The notice of appeal shall include the name and address of the appellant, the decision being appealed, and the grounds for the appeal A filing fee of $494 shall also accompany the notice of appeal Said appeal must be in Item 2. - Page 54 Wireless Permit No 07-04 Page 2 of 3 writing and must set forth in detail the action and grounds by which the applicant or interested party deems himself aggrieved The last day for filing an appeal and paying the filing fee for the above noted application is Monday, September 17, 2007 at 5 00 p m If you have any questions, please contact Andrew Gonzales, Assistant Planner at (714) 374- 1547 (email. agonzales@surfcity-hb org) or the Department of Planning Information Counter at (714) 536-5271 Sincerely, Scott Hess, Director of Planning by- Andrew Gonzale Assistant Planner Attachment Conditions of Approval—Wireless Permit No 07-041 c Herb Fauland,Acting Planning Manager Jason Kelley, Associate Planner Kelle Fritzal, Real Estate Services Project File G\Gonzales\Zoning letter\Bolsa View Park(Wireless Permit No 07-041)doc Item 20 - Page 55 Wireless Permit No 07-041 Page 3 of 3 ATTACHMENT NO. 1 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL-WIRELESS PERMIT NO. 07-041: 1 The site plan, elevations, and photo simulations received and dated July 25, 2007, shall be the conceptually approved layout. 2 Prior to submittal for building permits conditions of approval shall be printed verbatim on one of the first three pages of all the working drawing sets used for issuance of building permits (architectural, structural, electrical, mechanical and plumbing) and shall be referenced in the sheet index The minimum font size utilized for printed text shall be 12 point 3 Prior to the issuance of building permits the applicant shall provide evidence of an approved franchise agreement with the City-of-Huntington Beach INDEMNIFICATION AND HOLD HARMLESS CONDITION: The owner of the property which is-the subject of this project and the project applicant if different from the property owner, and each of their heirs, successors and assigns, shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless--the City of Huntington Beach and its agents, officers, and employees from any claim, action or--proceedings, liability cost, including attorney's fees and costs against the City or its agents, officers or employees, to attack, set aside, void or annul any approval of the City, including but not limited to any approval granted by the City Council, Planning Commission, Design Review Board, or Planning Department concerning this project The City shall promptly notify the applicant of any claim, action or proceeding and should cooperate fully in the defense thereof INFORMATION ON SPECIFIC CODE REQUIREMENTS: 1 The applicant and/or applicant's representative shall be responsible for ensuring the accuracy of all plans and information submitted to the City for review and approval. 2 Wireless Permit No 07-041 shall not become effective until the ten-calendar day appeal period has elapsed 3 Wireless Permit No 07-041 shall become null and void unless exercised within one year of the date of final approval or such extension of time as may be granted by the Director pursuant to a written request submitted to the Planning Department a minimum 30 days prior to the expiration date 4 The development shall comply with all applicable provisions of the Municipal Code, Building Department, and Fire Department as well as applicable local, State and Federal Fire Codes, Ordinances, and standards, except as noted herein G\Gonzales\Zornng Letter\Bolsa View Park(Wireless Permit No 07-041)doc Item 2® - Page 56 ATTACHMENT #5 I JENNIFER McGRATH, City Attorney SB 179917 2 SCOTT F. FIELD, Assistant City Attorney SB 105709 P 0. Box 190, 2000 Main Street 3 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 '714) 536-5555 4 AXX (714) 374-1590 Email s ield@surfcity-hb org 5 Attorneys for Defendant, 6 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 7 8 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - 9 CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA - 10 11 OMNIPOINT COMMUNICATIONS CASE NO CV09-3777 RGK (SSx) 12 INC , A Delaware corporation - 13 DECLARATION OF JONATHAN L. Plaintiff, KRAMER, FILED IN OPPOSITION 14 TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR 15 V. PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION 16 17 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA, Date August 31, 2009 18 Time 9.00 a in - 19 Defendant Dept : Roybal Courtroom 850 20 Judge Hon R. Gary Klausner 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 1 DECLARATION OF JONATHAN L KRAMER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION Item 2. m Page 58 1 I, Jonathan L Kramer, declare: 2 1. My statement of qualifications is hereto as Exhibit 1 1 2. Unless otherwise indicated, I know the following of my own personal 4 knowledge, and if called as a witness in this action, I could and would testify -- 5 competently to these facts under oath. 6 3 References in this Declaration to "the City" mean the City of - 'T Huntington Beach, California, which is the Defendant in this matter References 8 herein to "Orampoint" and "T-Mobile" refer to the Plaintiff in this matter 91 4 In the "Declaration of Joe Thompson in Support of Plaintiff's Motion 10- for Preliminary Injunction" dated July 61h, 2009 (hereinafter, the "Thompson - I L- Declaration"), Mr Thompson declares that "[t]he proposed sites at Harbour View 12- Park and Bolsa View Park are necessary for filling a significant gap in T-Mobile's 13 coverage, which has been caused by local demand " Thompson Decl. 15 14 However, in the balance of the Thompson Declaration, he fails to identify any 15 specific area or areas within the City that comprise the alleged significant gap 16 5 T-Mobile has identified the "coverage objective" for the Harbour View 17 Park site as being three areas, all within about 3,100 feet of the proposed site. 18 Those areas are shown in a document submitted by T-Mobile to the City entitled, 19 "Lal3156 Coverage Objective", which I have attached hereto as Exhibit 2 20 6. T-Mobile has identified the "coverage objective" for the Bolsa View 21 Park site as being a single area all within about 1,300 feet of the proposed site 22 Those areas are shown in a document submitted by T-Mobile to the City entitled, 23 "La 13157 Coverage Objective", which I have attached hereto as Exhibit 3 24 7 1 have reviewed T-Mobile's `Current Coverage' map, provided to the 25 City in connection with its application for a use permit to construct the Harbour 26 View Park site That map, which I attach hereto as Exhibit 4, visually depicts T- 27 Mobile's current coverage in the areas of the City surrounding both the Harbour 28 2 DECLARATION OF JONATHAN L KRAMER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION Item 2. a Page 59 I View Park and Bolsa View Park sites That map indicates that T-Mobile has 2 uninterrupted coverage throughout the areas of the City surrounding both the 3 Harbour View Park and Bolsa View Park sites, including the three target areas 4 identified by T-Mobile in Exhibit 2, and the single target area identified by T- 5 Mobile in Exhibit 3. 6 8 In Exhibit 4 attached hereto, T-Mobile has included a "Coverage 7 Legend" at the lower right corner of the page. In that legend, T-Mobile has 8 assigned three colors to represent specific signal strengths, and to which they have 9 also added names (i e , gray color represents a signal strength of-91 dBm, which 10 T-Mobile calls "Outdoor", yellow color represents a signal strength of-84 dBm, 11 which T-Mobile calls "In Vehicle", and green color represents a signal strength of 12 -76 dBm, which T-Mobile calls "In Building",) 13 9 There is no FCC rule that applies to these signal strength levels, nor is 14 there any industry-wide accepted standard regarding the relation of a specific 15 signal strength to a specific level of service. As a radio frequency engineer and 16 planner reviewing T-Mobile's and other wireless carriers' planning applications on 17 behalf of governments in California and elsewhere, I am personally aware of the 18 wide variances in these labels and what they purport to mean In my experience, a 19 signal strength labeled `in building' for one carrier can be considered `in vehicle' 20 to another wireless carrier using the same frequency band and transmission 21 protocols Even the labels assigned by T-Mobile to its map attached hereto as 22 Exhibit 4 are arbitrary For example, in a 2008 coverage map submitted by T- 23 Mobile to the City of Thousand Oaks, California for a proposed site in that city at 24 3260 Pioneer Avenue, T-Mobile uses different colors, signal strength levels, and 25 labels to portray its signal coverage (r e , white color represents a signal strength of 26 less than or equal to -I 10 dBm, which T-Mobile calls "Poor", yellow color 27 represents a signal strength of less than or equal to -84 dBm, which T-Mobile calls 28 3 DECLARATION OF JONATHAN L KRAMER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION Item 2e - Page 60 i 1 "Fair"; and green color represents a signal strength of less than or equal to -76 2 dBm, which T-Mobile calls "good") T-Mobile's coverage map for Thousand 3 Oaks is attached as Exhibit 5 hereto. In a 2009 permit application to the City of 4 Irvine, California, AT&T Mobility (which uses the same frequency band and 5 transmission protocols as T-Mobile) for a new wireless site at the intersection of 6 the I-405 Freeway and Culver Boulevard submitted a signal coverage map with its 7 own color, signal strength, and label scheme (i.e., purple color represents a signal 8 strength of less than or equal to -120 dBm, which AT&T calls "Poor"; red color 9 represents a signal strength of less than or equal to -1-04 dBm, which AT&T calls 10 "Marginal", yellow color represents a signal strength-of less than or equal to -92 11 dBm, which AT&T calls "On Street", blue color represents a signal strength of less 12 than or equal to -82 dBm, which AT&T calls "In-vehicle", and green color 13 represents a signal strength of less than or equal to -74 dBm, which AT&T calls 14 "In-building") AT&T's coverage map for its I-405/Culver Boulevard site is 15 attached as Exhibit 6 hereto 16 10 There being no FCC rule that controls the signal strength for a 17 particular area, and given that each wireless carrier independently, arbitrarily, and 18 diversely assigns its own signal strength goals (which, as already shown vary from 19 wireless carrier to wireless carrier, and also can vary within the same wireless 20 carrier from location to location), any wireless carrier can claim that a significant 21 gap in its own coverage exists merely `by changing the numbers' to show that the 22 signal strength goal arbitrarily assigned to a particular area by that wireless carrier 23 is not achieved by its present signal coverage. 24 11 As with the signal strength variances between wireless carriers (and 25 within a particular wireless carrier by area), wireless carriers also assign 26 themselves their own network capacity goals (i e , acceptable percentage of 27 dropped calls, failed hand-offs between wireless sites, etc.) There is no FCC rule 28 4 DECLARATION OF JONATHAN L KRAMER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION Item 20 - Page 61 I regarding a specific network rating for capacity, nor is there any industry-wide 2 standard for this parameter 3 12 1 have also reviewed T-Mobile's on line coverage map at its web site, 4 (Personal Coverage Check - Cell phone coverage Maps for your calling coverage 5 and service coverage areas, http.//www t-mobile com/coverage/pcc aspx (last 6 visited Aug_2, 2009) which also depicts that T-Mobile has uninterrupted "Best" 7 coverage throughout the areas of the City surrounding both the Harbour View Park 8 and Bolsa View Park sites I have attached that web page print-out as Exhibit 7 9 hereto That map also confirms that that T-Mobile has uninterrupted coverage 10 throughout the areas of the City surrounding both the Harbour View Park and l I Bolsa View Park sites, including the three target areas identified by T-Mobite in 12 Exhibits 2 and 3 attached hereto 13 13 Mr Thompson states that "the proposed sites at Harbour View Park and 14 Bolsa View Park are the only feasible options for closing the gap If T-Mobile is 15 forced to relocate to alternative sites, the gap could only be partially closed, at 16 best " Thompson Decl , ¶6 As Mr Thompson has not defined the claimed 17 significant gap around either of the proposed sites, he also has not provided any 18 information regarding the alleged impact on coverage were T-Mobile to move 19 either proposed site to a location other than in the parks 20 14 Given that T-Mobile own documents (Exhibits 4 and 7, attached hereto) 21 show that there is no gap in T-Mobile's coverage around either Harbour View Park 22 or the Bolsa View Park, there is no gap in its coverage—much less a significant 23 gap—to close 24 15. Thus if T-Mobile were to relocate the two sites, there would be no gap 25 in its coverage—much less a significant gap—either closed or created 26 16. Within a quarter-mile of Harbour View Park is a commercial shopping 27 center bounded by Boardwalk Drive and Saybrook Lane to the northwest, and 28 5 DECLARATION OF JONATHAN L KRAMER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAIN TIFF'S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION item 2e a Page 62 I Algonquin Street and Davenport Drive to the southeast. I have personally visited 2 that shopping center and found that it already has a cell site operated by Sprint 3 Nextel. This shopping center is within one of the three areas identified by T- 4 Mobile in Exhibit 2 This appears to be a viable alternative candidate site to at least 5 the Harbour View Park site 6 17 In conclusion, my opinions are (1) on T-Mobile's own "Personal 7 Coverage Check" web page, it represents that its coverage throughout the areas 8 sourronding both Harbour View Park and Bolsa View Park is its "Best", (2) that 9 there are no gaps, much less significant gaps, in T-Mobile's coverage around either 10 Harbour View Park or Bolsa View Park, (3) therefore moving either site would 11 neither create nor close any gap in T-Mobile's coverage around either site, and (4) 12 that there is no FCC standard, industry standard, or even mtra-company 13 consistency in assigning signal strengths and their meanings, or network capacity 14 requirements, thus wireless carriers are free to independently and arbitrarily set 15 them to whatever levels they see fit for any particular purpose 16 17 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States that 18 the foregoing is true and correct, executed in Los Angeles, California this 3rd day 19 of August, 2009 20 21 22 C)JtO-NATHAN KRAMER 23 24 25 26 27 28 6 DECLARATION OF JONATHAN L KRAMER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION Item 2. - Page 63 LIST OF EXHIBITS TO THE DECLARATION OF JONATHAN L. FRAMER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION Exhibit 1. Jonathan L Kramer's Statement of Qualifications; and Exhibit 2. La13156 Coverage Objective Map (Harbour View Park), and Exhibit 3- La13157 Coverage Objective Map (Bolsa View Park), and Exhibit 4 T-Mobile's Current Coverage Map; and Exhibit 5 T-Mobile's Coverage Map Submitted to the City of Thousand Oaks (3260 Pioneer Avenue Project) Exhibit 6 AT&T Mobility's Coverage Map Submitted to the City of Irvine (I405/Culver Boulevard Project) Exhibit 7 T-Mobile's Web Site Map of Coverage Surrounding Harbour View Park and Bolsa View Park 7 Item 2. e Page 64 EXHIBIT 1 TO THE DECLARATION OF JONATHAN L. FRAMER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION 8 Item 2. e Page 65 Jonathan L Kramer,J D Principal Kramer Firm,Inc Los Angeles, CA 90025 2006—Present Principal, Kramer Telecom Law Firm, P C (Los Angeles,CA) 1999—Present Principal, Kramer Firm, Inc (Los Angeles, CA) 1987— 1999 President, Communications Support Corp (El Toro, CA, Los Angeles, CA) 1984— 1987 Owner, Communicable Consultants (El Toro, CA) 1982— 1984 Technical Manager, later Regional Technical Manager, Storer Communications (Southern California Region) (Laguna Niguel, CA) 1982— 1982 Engineering Manager, Western Cable Services, Inc (Ventura, CA) 1979— 1982 System Engineer, Warner Cable of Malibu (Malibu, CA) 1978— 1979 Self employed (Malibu, California) 1976— 1978 Field Technician, Motorola Communications & Electronics Area F Project Management (California,Nevada, Arizona,New Mexico) 1971 — 1972 Rovafone of Los Angeles (Woodland Hills, CA) Admitted as an Attorney by the State Bar of California (CA SBN 244074) (2006) Admitted as an Attorney by the United States District Court,Central District of California (2006) Attorney member, Federal Communications Bar Association (2006) Attorney member, International Municipal Lawyers Association (2006) Attorney member, Los Angeles County Bai Association(2006) Licensed by the Federal Communications Commission General Radiotelephone Operator License, with Ship Radar and Broadcast endorsements, Previously licensed as a Second Class Radio Telephone Operator, Sept 1975, First Class Radiotelephone Operator,Nov 1977, General Radiotelephone Operator License,June 1987, Global Maritime Distress and Safety System Operator/Maintamer License.with Ship Radar Endorsement, Restricted Radiotelephone licensee, Amateur radio operator since November 1970 currently licensed as an Extra Class operator(W6JLK), Licensed by the California Contractors State License Board for low voltage communications (Class C7) License No 433113. Licensed since 1982 Life member of the American Radio Relay League, ARRL book ai ticle author and review editor on cable television RF interfei ence matters, Appointed Volunteer Counsel of the ARRL Former wireless technology advisor to and testifying expert before the FCC State& Local Government Advisory Committee Co-author, co-editor of"A Local Government Official's Guide to Transmitting Antenna RF Emission Safety Rules, Procedures, and Practical Guidance", a wireless technology advisory to local governments based on OET Bulletin 65 published by the FCC, Spring 2000 (see http //www FCC gov/oet/rfsafety) Former Chairperson, International Right of Way Association Wireless Committee PAGr 1 9 -- Item 2. - Page 66 Former National Board of Dii ectors member,National Association of Telecommunications Officers and Advisors (NATOA), an affiliate of the National League of Cities (Terms -1997-2000, 1992-1994) Former Co-chair of the Joint Task Force on Technical Standards Committee, appointed by NATOA, National League of Cities, and US Conference of Mayors to develop the national technical standards for cable television systems adopted by the FCC in February 1992 NATOA's only twice-honored Member of the Year(1997 and 1991) Executive Committee Board Member, State Bar of California,Public Law Section (2008-2011) President and current Board of Directors member, States of California and Nevada Chapter of NATOA (SCAN NATOA) (2006-2008), founding member of that Chapter Chapter President 2009-2010 Former Co-chair of National Technical Standards committee appointed by NATOA,National League of Cities, and US Conference of Mayors to develop the national technical standardized testing manual to determine compliance with the FCC rules Fellow Member of Society of Cable Telecommunication Engineei s,United Kingdom society(FSCTE designation) Senior Member of Society of Cable Telecommunications Engineers, United States society(SCTE-US) SCTE-US Senior Member since April 1993, member since 1981 Certified as a Broadband Transport Specialist(BTS designation) by the SCTE-US Certified as a Broadband Distribution Specialist(BDS designation)by the SCTE-US Certified as a Broadband Premises Specialist(BPS designation)by the SCTE-US Member, SCTE's Loyal Order of the 704 (Membership restricted to recognized cable engineers with a minimum of 30 years in CATV engineering experience) Co-Chair, SCTE's WG7 Committee developing standardized cable TV industry interpretations to the National Electrical Code Member, Society of Broadcast Engineers(member since 2008) Awarded recognition as a"Certified Broadcast Technologist"by the Society of Broadcast Engineers Awarded iecogmtion as a"Public Safety Radio Teclnician" by the Association of Public-Safety Communications Officials—International,Inc (APCO) Elected Life Member, American Radio Relay League (member since 1971) Witness before the FCC's State & Local Government Advisory Committee on OET 65,March 2000 Witness before the FCC in Cable TV re-regulation hearings, March 1990,representing NATOA, et al PAGE 2 10 Item 2. a Page 67 Testifying expert witness in federal and state court cases regarding cable television technology, and federal and state court cases regarding wireless technology Technology speaker at every NATOA National Conference from 1988 to 2000, and 2002 to 2004, Technology speaker at many regional and local NATOA and SCAN NATOA meetings Communications technology speaker at Society of Cable Telecommunications Engineers conferences, and cable industry conferences Published author of book and magazine articles on communications technology, plant safety, construction and administration Cable system engineering and technical management experience six years before forming Kramer Firm, Inc , Chief Technician,Technical Manager, Regional Engineer Former Field Engineering Representative for Motorola Communications and Electronics, Area F Program Management team—Areas of experience include miciowave radio, baseband RF and audio, digital signaling, UHF and VHF two-way radio (including high stability Simulcast®radio operations), telephony, and command and control communications Juns Doctor Degree cum laude,Abraham Lincoln University School of Law, Los Angeles(2001) Undergraduate education at CSUN,UCLA, LATTC, and WLAC, AS Degree in Radio Communications (with honors), Los Angeles Trade Technical College Volunteer VIP Mentors (2007-Present) Member of the VIP Mentors So Cal Steering Committee <Balance of page intentionally left blank> PAGE 3 1 Item 2. m Page 68 The following is a partial list of the nearly 600 governments and agencies which have relied upon Mr Kramer's broadband and/or radio-telecommunications advice as a telecommunications engineer since 1984 Selected Federal Agencies National Associations States Federal Communications-Commission U S Navy, San Diego, CA U S Department of Justice United States Conference of Mayors National Association of Telecommunications National Association of Counties Officers and Advisors National League of Cities Soc of Cable Telecommunications Engineers State of Michigan Public Utilities United States Attorney Commission United States Army, Ft Irwin, CA St of Conn Dept of Public Utility Control U S Marine Corps,Twentynine Palms, CA Connecticut Siting Council U S Marine Corps, San Diego, CA League of-California Cities U S Navy, Monterey, CA Selected Local Governments Aiken County, SC Columbia Heights, MN Half Moon Bay, CA Alcoa,Tennessee Corona, CA Hermosa Beach, CA Anaheim, CA Cypress, CA Hesperia, CA Avon, Ohio Darien, Illinois Hidden Hills, CA Austin, Texas Davis, California Highland Park, Illinois Azusa, CA Denver, CO Hoffman Estates, Illinois Barrington, IL Deerfield Beach,Florida Homewood, Alabama Bellbiook, Ohio Diamond Bar, CA Homewood, Illinois Bellflower, CA Downers Grove,Illinois Indian Wells, CA Berkeley,-CA Duarte. CA Irvine, CA Beverly Hills, CA Dubuque, IL Kettering, Ohio Big Bear Lake, CA Eagan, Minnesota Lacy,WA Birmingham, AL Eastchester,New York Lake County, Illinois Blount County,Tennessee Elburn, IL Lake County, Indiana Bronxville, New York Elk Grove Village, IIlinois La Mesa, CA Buffalo Grove, Illinois Escondido, CA La Quinta, CA Butte County, California Federal Way, WA Laguna Beach, CA Calabasas, CA Flora, Illinois Livermore, CA Canandaigua, NY Fort Wayne,Indiana Lompoc,CA Canton, Michigan Franklin, Kentucky Los Alamos, CA Capitola, CA Fremont, CA Los Altos, CA Centerville, Ohio Fullerton, CA Los Angeles, CA Chelan, Washington Garden Grove, CA Los Angeles County, CA Chico, CA Gardena, CA Lynchburg, Virginia Chino, CA Germantown, Ohio Malibu, CA Chula Vista, CA Glendale, CA Maryville, Tennessee Cleveland Heights, MN Glen Ellyn, Illinois Merced, CA Colton, CA Greew rile, Illinois Merrillville,Indiana PAGE 4 12 Item 2. a Page 69 Miamisburg, Ohio Portland, Oregon Sistersville,West Virginia Modesto, CA Poway, CA Solon, Ohio Monterey County, CA Port Townsend, WA Spokane,Washington Moreno Valley, CA Redondo Beach, CA Sprmgboro, Ohio Mount Carmel, Illinois Rialto, CA St Charles,IL Mount Prospect, Illinois Richmond, CA St Louis, Missouri Mountain View, CA Riverside, CA Sutter County, California Munster,Indiana_ Rochester,-Minnesota Thousand Oaks, CA New Martinsville,WV Rolling Meadows, Illinois Thurston County, WA New Orleans, Louisiana Roseville, Minnesota Tipp City, Ohio Newport Beach, CA San Bernardino County, CA Torrance,CA Newton Falls, Ohio San Clemente, CA Troy, Ohio Niles, IL San Diego County,CA Tuckahoe,New York North Aurora, IL San Francisco, CA Tucson, Arizona Oakwood, Ohio San Juan Capistrano, CA Tumwater,WA Ojai, CA San Luis Obispo, CA Tustin, CA Olean,New York San Luis Obispo County, CA Victoria,Texas Olympia, WA San Marcos, CA Walnut Creek, California Opelika,Alabama Santa Ana, CA West Allis, Wisconsin Orange County, CA Santa Barbara County, CA West Carrollton, Ohio Oxnard, CA Santa Clara, CA West Covina, CA Paducah, KY Santa Cruz, CA West Frankfort, Illinois Paris, Illinois Santa Cruz County,CA West Milton, Ohio_ Park Forest, Illinois San Diego, CA West Hollywood, CA Peoria County,Illinois San Diego County, CA Wheaton,Illinois Piqua, Ohio Santa Maria, CA White Plains, New Yoik Pleasanton, CA Santa Monica, CA Willamette, Illinois Plymouth, Michigan Simi Valley, CA Yorba Linda, CA <Balance of page intentionally left blank> PAGi 5 13 Item 2e a Page 70 Selected Lectures - Universities, Colleges,School Districts University of Alabama Pepperdme University Orange Coast College Rancho Santiago College Centralia School District Oxnard Union School District USC Annenberg School of Communications Litization Where Jonathan Kramer Served as an Testcfyin2 or Noll-Testifying Ex-pert (Wireless Communications) Armstrong/McEachron v Cazcom MetroPCS v City and County of San Francisco Bay Area Cellular v City and County of San Francisco Sprint v City of Palos Verdes Estates Sprint v City of La Canada Flmtndge AT&T Wireless v City-of San Diego Sprint v City of Palos Verdes Estates Nextel v City of San Diego AT&T Wireless ,, City of Carlsbad Omnipomt v Garden City, Michigan GTE Mobilenet v City and County of San Francisco Illinois RSA 3 v Peoria County (Wired Communications) Newpath Networks v City of Irvine NextG v City of Huntington Beach Adelphia Cable v City of Thousand Oaks Malencon v Cox Communications Schaff Dev Group v S E Fla Cable, Inc , dba Adelphia Cable Playboy Enterprises v United States Jones Intercable v City of Chula Vista Sierra East Television v Westar Cable Booth American v US D B Cable v Kalma Busk Selected Professional Organization Lectures Association for Community Media Thomas& Betts Power and Grounding Council (2004 Keynote speaker) International Municipal Lawyers Association Splint Wireless International Right of Way Association (Multiple Meetings) PAGr 6 14 Item 20 - Page 71 Washington Association of Cities NATOA National Conference (Multiple Meetings) NATOA So Cal and Nevada Chapter(Multiple Meetings) NATOA Illinois Chapter NATOA Minnesota Chapter NATOA Texas Chapter Society of Cable Telecommunications Engineers(National and local chapters, multiple Meetings) Personal Communications Industry Association (Multiple Meetings) Law Seminars International (Multiple Seminars) Center for the International Legal Studies (Salzburg, Austria) Leibowitz &Associates Florida Telecommunications Conference (2003, 2004, 2005) PAW:7 15 item 2® - Page 72 EXHIBIT 2 TO THE DECLARATION OF JONATHAN L. K AMER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION 16 Item 20 - Page 73 �t 4Yr,��Z7 a i" �r'C�.,�°AI ! _ �N'�.z�tlaays.�+ • • • ! • �.� • i F ��° ta•s' .E w i-+-�''rlf� v e, 4 �^'S� �n �a„ a .n vwr � ;� � �r�y;: 's' ^• a f > ,.�'�. q esiw. .. .i, ir.�: �+ - �"' 4 •? '�•� { �� � "��� ' � sir p•�. .,, ` � +� S �A¢ '.� 3& ,a7 t I. fi •v '.s •rti._ 1'iEue• +w"L - ,' il:_ •�' ar,1y"„�.yrr�.k: t �y�yeA.s:. ".r s • ! • ��#..� �^8.:_, '�;IMr a � �' i � r}�� �fry,#n '� • Y e(Y y'' ».� �•,� '� �I «�. '! • ro '7k w � a � 7,.,y A "a S'? M � o rr 1.� ,.� r:2r r P � � 'p "�J. � ,�y. - • ••• I• • - An hil 1; 1 ar+k#y.,� *'• '. • • • • k y( r M 1 '� ..i+',�.� � s�.r f.._ ,'fr"f�'", `��.� 'i+ � • �+.� r• R� .� .y �z "" � I4(a ,,'a"•r�,� • • •.. r � - 7fo6", � 4 - •." M twz ""..�., rww�,� y �'`,i t *,�:' 'M :1� ���'�� � �� fit' _ - • • f PTS P_ ;,.r Ibw w'� A ;�� , _.� i�e'� r �,'� f�y, � ' _•M ,Nr�i, S A�gya r 4 ,fi �t�f5"s i ,�,t 7{ _ �...._ � 1� r � r i« i y"aml. 8✓r ' " > s l t� t �? EXHIBIT 3 TO THE DECLARATION OF JONATHAN I.,KRAMER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION 18 Item 2, - Page 75 E r. .�i�v Dw.~� � "`' > ���k�� � a�'qtx�"'��^'��,�'i^�'�'' ir�'xxr""',�'�.$1f„�sse„'�,�,v,��'2 c'' • • • • 1 � • A'A° "f .YiF'�yp`r .t:L�N`! � � ��� 'h'��Y is a � � � �'' -r,�rr4d a%ii�Yc>'�„gE^•"+uren ` �du�'Ki�s,`�Y?&i41�,y,1�'� �. y µ � A��a wx'•' ,� � "-` kYy � .. �� "m°� t y£ Flo ,• IP r sir � t x 6 EXHIBIT 4 TO THE DECLARATION OF JONATHAN L. KRAMER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION 20 Item 2. - Page 77 �A fD T Current Coverage Without LA1 3156A Nugge, Forrestal Ln Skylab Rd Connec g Road & Bolsa Ave IVAD -4 2326W 00 ARI 0 > Signal 1 0 town. w :�rQr q �11A rd Dr I A6 06( I n Dr n A CD Blu ay 10 0- Hooker Dr 0 .MR IT) — q S Fl 0 Montego Dr Alderport Dr 0 2 Z) Edi geAve " LI'AO2207A & Aruba Cir Capi�trano Dr 7- is . > Bl esails Dr IT11150 Amaz61w C3� Rancho Del R Pit 'k 10A Pair Angelipa Dr to A 1 06,, Dab 7! Atha[I nW, Abbott Dr A 4 AR C, tit r "111111� ,,, VA &LA131% :3 U)fi I V' W U A ettO Cir 9� U3 =r 0 Brad Dr coo 0206( red PAU24M j Gild Cir !'�wx�g M024 'i aw Cl( r N�F' Am'�&MK06 Ahe V1 L* 4 ro &LA62$53 #o Dr Aladdin Dr 4 �W E 0 M:A02585 eat E wo 05 RS > < &1V Q n 3 ja Dr 044,w?,f, RAP.', ALA13157 22 2 0 '0 sewteld U1 v LA02267A%�'4, L- 2 43A111 (I> T 6 Cres 4 Coverage Legend Outdoor l,9ldbin) This information property of I mobile uSA Inc v,ionfideriltal and is irllPilded coley for the Lisp of the indwirlijal or entity to whom 11 is addressed Any other use r3rdistribution of this Informal,on,s stripy prohibited This map PrPdLtS and approximates Out MWP%q coverage area uvidoors which may change without notice 11 may inclv&locations with limited or tV no roverage Our AIRPS do not LjUaMntpe service availability f-v-n within e aw rage arr, t1iirejrP sevPrdl tasters sorh as network changes rrAffic volonif, gorvire milages In Vehide(84 dbm) technical limitations signal strenom your Pciurpment irirain -oirurwr—S —Athef aro other wridiliuns that may interterp with artual service quality and wriflabilify itirludinq the I ability to mat,- rel;ewr, ano m*,wrnrlin rang f �il Building( 76dbin) IF Wc! EXHIBIT 5 TO THE DECLARATION OF JONATHAN Le KRAMER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS LOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION 22 Item 20 m Page 79 � � t t Ill E P � �+• � x e � 4 . �,���Jpay�' h'i�n�� • / 1���sr����g�,S*��,w�sw�+�r^� S:G.. • .� �'ns����x�silk., +m r � �p '� t� •: a • � w&F1'�4 ,� � ¢".tanb� �7AI f ' G°`Wkv. A�Y h `1.N t,.A��y;-r"ya�F r",C,� ?� 8i�t�,y e w • � � �' a s� ��,�t .�t�?� h t�rE e til'�Fr %A°"�r.s esi .��,� F " � �tis .. 'k+` �> t r, 1 1 } x rtar iv�.j � a rsi,yt;t 6 �.}, ° y.✓`.' d� Fgw�atya.1's•e pit sa, ,vy X. � r rA <15 a '4ib'`� !s.` 3t„ 'f,., n............j ..'� 3 '" �, ,y,r�� F r � 'i# �, 7 x �a r':S}z'',r'"9x 1 d� �` 5`4,.3.E,•;� '�'?3;z a ) s yy xY a :, • �k bn,. rr y n t of das 4'- • .. iwS'Fa?,fi �w�^ r"Illf r"� r�u�,.'` xfi�^�ry �x �Yf �. 3�����fg'�cwk„� � •' ����{���€„ 2�„gip ; �,, �;��' �»,��,» ���' - , • '.. 1 EXIBIT 5 TO THE DECLARATION OF JONATHAN L. ICRAMER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION 24 Item 2. - Page 81 �S , 1 aN. � `' t `"" C ,d #^ a � �, 'y?{ r.hl >�" ;,r�xu i') N� ,d3 t :#v�as`?7:,�k.�' �' .,a r.E• s�l`,:F.. a:.,�tC: ! r:.,4-' ,�-� a., � �`' Ys• ,u f�34.�9' �" v �':2 � .F7i$.r��r,.Y,� t to..`ta +yo- �H a.a••y7 ,yr .'� wt" nt �' •�5.�. .: #^ .,.,, � „ •a'" �� ;`. xi` ;it...Yk9 .fix r�":.�.1a+*Y. 'f,�,r�X i:Ti vt,:y '' !>.: rrYY��Tak 1"',.;`..r+ �.a.y.�Y r.i',g'i �.'�. l.s"tsr .. x "� x, A U ::._ .K, �. ..i . � 't I I t S Y�•wi,( Y'-ryx:�J �..A'f; 'v� � .�'.+ �^�. ..i °be fd�. r�,r�{" �"rt, � � ." ,�.d'k $ $IRl °4irh y4 �ro �'•rt` � .w'�� mda •9f,,,,.+; 1ad�F.1'^' v, �`�� `vd� ��i' ''!� ,a> ,� " � � wvr���4.�,"ryy1�+ t• .�Naa� .�rzr, •��Sat fr .;i.. �t # { ��:PJ ,.'�, are . �.:4'^kjs.: e 'i-'8 f:�.(• X� '� ��' ,�' �''.1 gar. �;>� �,:i.3t:•�3„' F �„ Gr rxd � ,� a;��a.,a 4 v ,:yi# x ''�,-r� �� 4 W.r a"5 t�' "� .,z e 1� y{4T,�fi �� � +a: �"ri �-k" r -.� �' � �k �� r ��' ei�t a q� L�� 4� ,�� +,,'��•��,, 'es � '; ^' \r �- # �`' .A'sti+s.r,r .ie t,f"� �!.� t � ''rYr >�✓£ � �� r tfr.'��" s 'fl bz � rL; r'e a'� y�,�+^" .� K i.m '� .�+". yt?x• a! pt,i rr< "n rw na.cf 'ti t s4�B'f.� ty ++�� +j ,r4v`�J,� M?A l �'�n � ���� Gr ,Y:+r � y,Y,Ar �uet',�n �i i'a� ^:�� ?^� "yn'� 'Y'�,yh,��+� �" h`• a:,s u i � � �a t R t„ <s �'?'kSS a ao. v' d'•` f , '�,'� .ifi.k ���.z' � {�. '�"''"' .{r .� 3 �$.{:"4�`tti.r1�v "5•'Pi a�`u '� .�,� ���f F i v n, ++� �` �✓� + e 1.•y ,�. ^�",�"�,'" _-S R�ss� �; � a >v� r J +f"�.:;rq r�,.# �,' k '�,�"b� �".:"r �,�y r i� .�:+vy� k ,",r°bA+ �+) �+ '1 r .� a s _x.� •.9 Yr k .3 er � a 4 rr �sh r{ ,< Tt 4��� yw _frr..wRa4 l �` IN '�tt•.s�'^r'< 'h'. r4.- a 5 ' �'"sJ',lS,' "' ' 3.. y *�',�'" y tn' 't� tt-e#t " , ",'ir i Y ?•; y t�i,� i° ,in4J.:5. 5�' - a-K•.mGx, a �w a� 1�'rz�' 5"t`�s9�M1, ��� 1tFr +; � ..�{ „r ��? zm?^ 2? � n»S..�Ro4z�+r� s�'�,h, �v;' ,.» •sl ?��f hA�4�jr-M^"���'�n��� ,'.i' e J 1��k �{� '.'�,e ' �g�t� '�h�k �."� 1, �1�1. qa �" �r Aq i r � i;� • �� q "'' '� Y, ` 1,.�,�2 N a$"... -..y h^�M1 �}�. ' '."'y , #v�'�a ' �� f y -.�T J k'y '�WP ,. �. ." , � to ,te� m3'. �S",ak�'�?q� �� 6+^,« 4 �b 4"•. �''s'M,#��} ''f 1'',4 1��1 i,JY2. �" �r•^�' �,�';` @,. i$ ��.�, �•r �ri��`� ,��:ix, �,�. r ,��x4 et r�s: � 4xt�u'7. -r~k ,€ at 1 2 � z ?'t '�, �'• n s{ fir, .,f �+��t Tr k � � >,{1 ems.� �' � S�"P;-$ n a.� .�n r a'(• t x.' i�!y�+ . g4,pk�,�,�Y'... 'k ' - i' �b '.y �, .J � z'�U',o ,.t t� #. •'tM u: by"�•,'€ ,;2y .:>j'.� '.°,iS• �wlrr r� $'`�9v� i�;'a::( s 2R c�.., "... � t. ti. � l ;,,Y ��.� � i4 I� rw 45vP a�4 {�'�3�" �a �,'� � '•�"z fir!-¢ ql� �..:e. " �'m' .�a.t o �'''{4 + ii 4�1„ni €F!;?7 .22+� "� s4.i#4.a. ;� fi. �''�, '+�. ,•)'y r�'.�§� ��:;3 nf�r k.����. . w+"tS,'-". R. '""' °, aa..s t�'ms.~~y� z,i;wr�a s�i�:e'�,i'�•>„, �' i�'�"`'� 1� L.:,vr� � �"a_, s�aa.tM1 � m...;�`st�r S ��-k.::.. �'' ',�,��j,� k �.,,.L "` �'b,;+f�.dK ,��°t�,,y'tN' 4 r' ".k .� '�.1":."o � •'.��hi ':2')" : +'.�,�� �� j..�`/i r '�.� s�_.�.+.r. .. ' J4:: •q :'. `:J ..»hKt"� .:.y� h ., h� ;L!a5'il' 3.s- ¢ �3 t s. � r br 'u�',"'�� �., ,�+rtir.• `'.-. �.W,. .tik..a.,.. .. F, -�'Y`1'`�..:�'�'�t�E'a 3'�y J 7.f 4 tx`".tk �a' i '�,.z `.'`ra'• .�a�^c"P ¢A t.m� -r- fr i; ra � y..,t e�, 3;.�}%e Sri "� ;�,. � i a y s r Viz, .u.»L f r #Ct' �+ "", 4R i T�.. •�2'�+�' kti. l,Fr q,n, r .�^S 3y.Y sy;e4t.: $„ri s.���`�}... "�` •.,r�y �� `�r�.� .,3'� .f 4 � f� f,�k��� 5, ).� "._�a�'i 1 1 5.� f P x�i.. �-� �":.� � . ,� z, F ems?' �. +. M r s'J r ;'<� T a �':�r s�da ,y � 7 stM1 t , , a '� y;,•,. rP k .'• ., S. stYi > v z r 2 v�T + s• i '�,* �.T,�„ _:_ ":� :"'�'A''ar; ;�¢.• y�.,� �' ,�°i�aF.k'.} �"s�{' ,..v,F�� s'"!�r`'W °*,���ti�, } 51 w (., 'd .. %t: �, -•,>,c� �"�.,�yanL £�'� � --Fr j'I�,, 4' 3�1. S2E'�'��CH�•,f;)S y j' '�,4 34 %Y � t�'a y ti �"�E ns'�u "�'m r�,-�,�r w. o f 5:�.5 a 1 .. +c �..z� i>�� t• A �' ''.� � �� y� � � 4 '".c M av,x:hl,tt4s y, �, 1 T S' i>•'�y�t r� r1k'}aid r- r t• � '��i>k^- .:T t: s .. r y �r .:45k• Y s a � _ r '��� ,Y #'tSd�y : � t'f;J' �,/ ?<4� t�.N, x. "Ci' 31. C�:. •.�`�• ,. Y. �. "r � � �' � �4;.x �' !���+��' �?$� 9L 'i r� 'R wr 22 ••� '.,.. - ,� :{ '� 1"F_ 3� ,': a ,."' s �-� 4 + g My �ay fs c Pv r ,� 3 ,. :.. 7{�(»� �qi -� t�i r#3 -"r� � �'� ,*'Sv 'apt } 3 ' Y »E.q`y� p ,#.ti � ��a�`k )e a�?� "�l ��ti�i�v 't,•y�!'r'., �`}v r .,i rR �„ � r�1 �d�'iSrFf J�"cm7Y ga �,s...�.14�j4 tkr�".•� '.S: i n .. {l 4 :� x• " 1F 54 67es ..,� `�.• l �'' 1 tt.1��:5[,4"�.�...t Y f V��� � x Y�W f/ R 3 �J +� "..> s �'- y r:. ,•. ,....qx� .. t,- -.•. t>q',.� <d`t`•' e fa �^' **ww x7 p`x. :.0 '.�.. 3' ti+� , n .�r �f � r sus ox xr ,i"w ik<.,. 33'' a �{'�;�..�'sc a•� a -:~a -. rs s,.,,53 � 1 � 4, f'� t'< ' 5 r '1§�'t :,5�' k'�5�,. 2::. �9 �� �u i � :a,�; ���:.�nA.� tw"�ty`�CS' ,��4� y sn �;.C��� ,✓jL{'+� `y� '',, a tUb,%�a�p#�y�,z :�.,. i} a`v,' � � ! , ���{{fia ,�e;� fI •.: ,e,r3,.. f k�y��,,�. a ,7;. ,se�S:x. �v�+4 ,,�esp 2 'FY' ," ,+ z, S �,. rcd :�..�.. .�+�:it,.: ...' .,,,a+, #„ t:'e .,.. � "54-i `�''{� ?iu,�•'' «a�21,' i'k� 3.<.'. 1L?.�`a',' .r..:�j�.�..,d v-�n,�'iG^t r,�q'a3x.Fy�e} ��r�,�'�,•y' fr�y+d..•t>.Y ^^ iy...ac• k 2 s. '�Y`+R•L�' 'i".rv',w,G k i rt� �"',"C 7 �xat:>ns�x p �,��:+.•.. � ',i's .�,� 4 :.� �i,:� >`�`1? x Yd�; q if ,r,N.,ii.3 F"C#',� F4 1 k e .E y }A a.♦�',- � `�.0�5.,,..Y �'�', �ii�ti ~r� ;aY�k�t " � �'�.� � �E x a,�kr�r ,°r4,� i� �,�Sw,�` ,,}'" �.,�>w?��u��,c"�"f�'r�=x�Y,� Saas�����`�� "i��>^ r.�i'i�k.a ;ram•, x• a # .yn1 dry.` s�wr s � k'kd�7aru � � � , w, y fl ' at y; � .�."'"ar^���'e' -�'C+ � �q>yira r�S". ,��, <s, r `r, �"• `% #t���s�'xdx��,n at � .�,� �y� ""� � r.�r+ �r �+��.< 1• ^-'j� is €.r {� t �, a..�s..r:-K�,f s ` �, kv�s}�k A�t����r� ,z n,� akr Y �t i r# a� e�E urh� »>' „x a�� + .4 .,!, eYi�'2;'q?,:� is i bt'1WN Y w•84:wt��.Kf,5,, 14�,ff� 4],,� `1 yy ru.vs ,33 '� y a t '.nf"'�"� ,1,` t�)) F 9F r� ;��+., }:�'gr� I id':'}y4 '��y,�' E A/�, �y� }C� R ���,X•yY �'� ��,.M1S,.�. y.'� � "f� �5+• y fY�G 1 �"� �! � 3 a rph}+e P1 m �< k�7^v"�s• ���'y !va's J- 1hr tta '�.e,w 3 '7 r�s s}r?,,'.yr,,±,.,^}�d'''TM •�"� � � '�6 t 1f+ 4 15t5b� F a +r��° '���> � A��a<' fie, �+�',"�:: •�x •ia� •'��"a A. ±� r h��. ,�;, r,x ,+ t �i.1a"# °Xr` ,r ^ EXHIBIT 7 TO THE DECLARATION OF JONATHAN L. KRAMER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION 26 Item 2. e Page 83 Personal Coverage Check-Cell phone coverage Maps for yotir calling co http//www t mobile com/coverage/pcc aspx EngfshIEspaW Locabom Change Location(Store Locator t W Cart - - - ;Mobile-. MyT-Mobile Phone# password forgot password?) register, Home>Coverage>Personal Coverage Check Personal Coverage Check Letm more Check if T-Mobile coverage is right for you with Personal Coverage Check Street Intersection ex Broadway and W 148th Street city - -- State Zip clear Voice Coverage i Data Coverage • Prepaid and FlexPay coverage map> Learn more aboutT-Mobile's expanded coverage Signal Strength Best Good fair None Zoom N'In a a t wE S j4f Et Zoo m N oat 7 Please zoom in to see street level coverage details for the areas where you live,work,and play >�Piint Map Legend X Address Location 0 T Mobile HotSpot L Display s 4 T Mobile Roaming Coverage 4a Roaming HotSpot (Additional charges apply) Find a T-Mobile HotSpot> 21 1 of 2 8/2/2009 2 19 PM Item 2. - Page 84 Personal Coverage Check-Cell ply coverage Maps for your calling co hrip/Iwww t mobile cotn/coveragelpcc aspx About T-Mobile USA(Contact Us I Store Locator I Order Status I Return Policy Jobs f Press(Site Map T Mobile I otSpot Packages (Prepaid I Affiliates f OM a Stare SMness Public Safety/9-1-1 (T-Nbbtle Internabonal I_Langtiage Assistance Terms&Condrtioris I Term of Use 1 Privacy Policy I Privacy Resources I 02002-2009 T Mobile USA,Inc 28 2 of 2 812/2009 2 19 PM Item 2. m Page 85 Case 2:09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 22-2 Filed 08/03/2009 Page 1 of 9 EXHIBIT 4 TO T IIE DECLARATION OF JONATHAN L. KRAMER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION 20 Item 2. - Page 86 o I sa Ssve,"" Attachment 4 02 Current Coverage Without LA13156A e\ Skylab Rd Forrestal Ln Connect Road T 0 131 N m Bolsa Ave 4 ILL 0 A02326 0 CD > signal Rdrown =r , 3 55 rd Or `N' ll) it 206( co lbion Or (OD dN 4 10 Btu jay Orp, -4 19, 0 AQ2093 T, �(L Hooker Or -4 01/1, 0 N 03 Montego Or Alderpqr!Or Ed r ger Ave LCA02207A Aruba Cir,Capistrano Or -j > Bloesails Or Amazc ,-�,N. A Rancho Del R�, A68AI 3 An . ur ru (n z:r S, m 0 Par Sin Alham C gall Yo Abbott Or A V1. A I LAI r 6 1:3- An Otte Cir 0 a) J, Brad Or 0 C r Gildre( Clir fit, r3 -0 View CD m A o Dr LAM3, Aladdin Dr E P4 C) f- a , t IV , P� a 2 '5 e < 0 15 R7 Q 0 > CD -J m 0 CL A m Ln n Ave, 00 22 0 A f'Crest' a CD 4 Coverage Legend i ON A� h — (0 This information property of f Mobile 1113A Inc is confidential and is intended solPy for lhF use of the individual of firitily to whomit is addressed Any other use or distribution of this Outdoor(91 dbm) information is s0irtly prohibited I his snap predios and approximates our wjrp'pgs rovetage area uutdoors which may change without notice it may incitop lorations with limi,ed or no coverage Our maps do not quarantee sfirvice,availability IF,—,—thin a roverage ir-,i sh-e are several faCION ,Urh as network changes traffic VOIL-firse %em,re outage, in vehicle(84 doors? OvA technical limitations signal strength your equipment ifrrmn tirm-tur,,is weather art)olliar rcin(lityis that may interterp with actual service quality and availability inrludpnq tha ability 10 make receNe and mammin calls In Building(76dbrn) A A- 111 Case 2:09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 22-2 Filed 08/03/2009 Page 3 of 9 EXHIBIT 5 TO THE DECLARATION OF JONATHAN L. KRAMER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION 22 Item 2. - Page 88 M!I U L--J C-1 Lo 1 U A A-M,tf t N I t-al Loll,q,, 4:=�:v_UiVITIR AiN" VW� -—- --------- Case 2.09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 22-2 Filed 08/03/2009 Page 5 of 9 EXHIBIT 6 TO THE DECLARATION OF JONATHAN L. I(RAME IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION 24 Item 2. - Page 90 0 16 4 f Cs fzxisth e 0 Cng sitt CD 117* 1 11 7-�OW 11 7-f9V/ 117-fGW ry 4 Cn (n 0 0 0 C R CID :3 -n CD C. CIO C) C) 95 In vehicle Level(dBm)>-82 0 n Street Level(dB m)>-92 (a Marginal Level(dB m)>--104 (D Pow Level(dB m)>—120 —7-' 77- 117�1W 11 7tOW 11 7-49'v,/ 11 7-48W IN ism ran Case 2:09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 22-2 Filed 08/03/2009 Page 7 of 9 EXHIBIT 7 TO THE DECLARATION OF JONATHAN L. KRAMER IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION 26 Item 2. a Page 92 Personal Coverage Check-Cell phone coverage Maps for your caUmg co.. b tp.//www t mobile com/coveragelpcc=aspx Case 2:09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 22-2 Filed 08/03/2009 Page 8 of 9 English{Espafiol Location Change Location{Store Locator { Cart ;8: - -Mobile. MyT-Mobile PRo-# password Im forgot password?> register> Moore)Coverage•Personal Coverage Check Persona! Coverage Check Leah more Check it T-Mobile coverage is right for you with Personal Coverage Check Street Interseilion ex Broadway mro vv 148m Street city - --- --- State -- cleat infern.afieno) voice coverage Data Coverage Ca Prepaid and ReWay coverage map> Learn more about T-Mobile's e)panded coverage> Signal Strength Best Good Farr None, I zoom ' In 5 9 HRJ 1 ..I l E _a ! Zoom out 7 y ` `S ' Please zoom it to see street level coverage details for the areas where you live,work,and play. Q Pnnt Map Legend X Address Location 4 T M obrle How 0 Display T Mobile Pbarrrng CoAyage * fbarrmg HotW (Additional charges apply) Find a T-Mobile HDtSpot> 27 1 of 2 8/2/2009 2 19 PM Item 2. - Page 93 Personal Coverage Check-Cell plane coverage Maps for your calling co ltttp//www-t-mobile coni/coverage/pcc aspx Case 2.09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Down ent-22-2 Filed 08/03/2009 Page 9 of 9 About T-IUobde USA I Cordact Us I Store Locator I Order Status I tetum Policy I Jobs I Press I Site Map T-Mobile RASpot I Packs I Prepaid I Af dates I Own a Store I Business Pubic Safety/9-1-1 `T Mobile International I Language Assistance Term&Conditions I Terms of Use I Primacy Poky I Primacy Pbsourcm I CM-2M T-MoWe USA.Inc za 2 of 2 8/2/2009 2 19 PM Item 2e - Page 94 ATTACHMENT #6 Consultant's Preliminary Report Regarding Radio Frequency Coverage Matters At and Around Harbour View Park and Bolsa View Park in the City of Huntington Beach, California Prepared by K Jonathan L Kramer President Kramer Firm, Inc August 2010 Kramer Firm Inc Telecommunications Technology Counsel for Government Agencies and Private Institutions Since 1984 www KramerFirm com Main Office Kramer aDKramerFirm com Tel+1(310)473 9900 Fax+1(310)473 5900 Suite 306 2001 S Barrington Avenue Los Angeles California 90025-5379 Item 20 - Page 96 1. Introduction T-Mobile, a Personal Communications Service (PCS) provider of mobile telephone services in the City of Huntington Beach ("City"),has claimed that its service coverage is deficient in the areas surrounding the City's Har- bor View Park("HVP") and Bolsa View Park(`BVP") lix pj Up�nyrs �. `fix� a^ 5�� ✓' � r ty��N.j Y�5'�� Harbour View Park The Harbour View Park area is mixed-used in nature The uses include sin- gle family residential, mobile homes, school/park, and commercial From a traffic flow perspective, travel is to and through the area Kramer Firm Inc Page 2 Item 2. - Page 97 MEW, ft '.j IF p'- ' Io* 4 ko w l J V a"g 1 , 41 A "A 4� ORR", A., Bolsa View Park The Bolsa View Park area is single family residential use in nature From a traffic flow perspective, this is an isolated area that is a destination area ra- ther than one traveled through to reach other areas Kramer Firm Inc Page 3 Item 2. - Page 98 2. T-Mobile's Intended and Claimed Existing Coverage in the HVP and 13VP Areas T-Mobile has identified its coverage objective for the HVP site as being three areas, all within about 3,100 feet of its proposed site Those areas are shown in a document submitted by T-Mobile to the City entitled, "La 13156 Coverage Objective " That map is reproduced below 3 Proposed Site LA03568 has t Sector A arm to provide �` ,_ • t residential coverage towards fhe area of F3;€I a Avenue Saybrook lam a �� - �s� � � all the may to Humboldt r — � drive and mistral avencir 2 Sector B a€€n to provide residential,&commercial r coverage on Algonquin Street and Doardwalk er ., r �� , s drive ' R a 3 Sector C aim to provide z 'ter residential and � g Commercial rovera+ge on Davenport and Barona h KK lane ffi3 w. sv T-Mobile's current (August, 2010) online Personal Coverage Check map for the HVP area is reproduced below Kramer Firm Inc Page 4 Item 2e - Page 99 Signal Strength Excellent Ve Good Good Moderate Partner None ,,1 '11a Based on outdoor coverage-indoor and in-car coverage can vary Click here for detailed desrnotinns Zcoom In LILI It � Zaam .� Out V� �S Please zoom in to see street level coverage details for the areas where you live,work, and play. MAP INFORMATION Maps approximate anticipated coverage outdoors, which vanes by location, may include limited or no coverage areas,and do not guarantee service availability Within coverage areas,network changes,traf- fic volume, outages, technical limitations, signal strength, your equipment, obstructions, weather and other condi- tions may interfere with service quality and availability Portions of the maps include networks operated by our roaming partners,we are not responsible for their performance 3G Coverage requires a 3G device Devices not pur- chased from T-Mobile or an authorized dealer may not work on our network T-Mobile to T-Mobile calls are directly dialed between T-Mobile devices while on the T-Mobile USA network(and not roaming in the US or international- ly), voicemail and other T-Mobile service numbers not included -Roaming Nationwide roaming refers to usage while on a roaming partner's network within coverage area,currently not available for webConnectTm data plans In- ternational roaming incurs additional charges and refers to usage outside of the US 850 Roaming Coverage requires a multi-band device Certain devices and features will not work when roaming Ask a sales representative or visit www t-mobile com/morecoverage for more information If you travel outside of coverage areas,your device will not work Kramer Firm Inc Page 5 Item 2. - Page 100 T-Mobile has identified its coverage objective for the Bolsa Vie-wPark site as being a single area all within about 1,300 feet of the proposed site Those areas are shown in a document submitted by T-Mobile to the City entitled, "La13157 Coverage Objective That map Ts-reproduced below tA M Proposed Site LA03568 has 3 sector,All sector u�afirt to improved residential coverage on this area 4� 'M 3N 4z T-Mobile's current (August, 20 10) online Personal Coverage Check map for the BVP area is reproduced below Kramer Firm Inc Page 6 Item 2. - Page 101 Signal Strength Excellent 'Very Good Good Moderate Partner None Based on outdoor coverage indoor and in-car coverage can vary t C lie.k here for detailed de�cniEia3ns Zoom In I TT Zoom Out w d � r s — Please zoom in to see street level coverage details for the areas where you live,work, and play. MAP INFORMATION Maps approximate anticipated coverage outdoors, which varies by location, may include limited or no coverage areas,and do not guarantee service availability Within coverage areas,network changes,traf- fic volume, outages, technical limitations, signal strength, your equipment, obstructions, weather and other condi- tions may interfere with service quality and availability Portions of the maps include networks operated by our roaming partners,we are not responsible for their performance 3G Coverage requires a 3G device Devices not pur- chased from T-Mobile or an authorized dealer may not work on our network T-Mobile to T-Mobile calls are directly dialed between T-Mobile devices while on the T-Mobile USA network(and not roaming in the US or international- ly), voicemail and other T-Mobile service numbers not included Roaming Nationwide roaming refers to usage while on a roaming partner's network within coverage area,currently not available for webConnectTm data plans In- ternational roaming incurs additional charges and refers to usage outside of the US 850 Roaming Coverage requires a multi-band device Certain devices and features will not work when roaming Ask a sales representative or visit www t-mobile com/morecoverage for more information If you travel outside of coverage areas,your device will not work Kramer Firm Inc Page 7 Item 2. - Page 102 For both the HVP and BVP areas, T-Mobile's personal coverage check maps show at least"Good" anticipated coverage outdoors. 3. Preliminary Signal Availability Determination To evaluate, on a preliminary basis, the availability of T-Mobile's wireless telephone service in the areas of HVP and BVP, Kramer Firm conducted an outgoing-call survey in both areas The purpose of the evaluation was to determine whether T-Mobile's service, as would be utilized by a wireless telephone subscriber, was consistent with the personal coverage check maps published on T-Mobile's web site For this evaluation we utilized a newly-purchased(in July, 2010)Nokia 5230 handset activated on the T-Mobile network. For identification purposes, the wireless handset used bears the following serial numbers IMEI 359341034808043 and IMSI 310260366534240 sDate Time rcom- BVP Eat Eon Address Location -RSSi Faeld toy Office to A pleted or � '� ��u .�dBm 'Office � °�Field H_VP Quality Quantity 7/12/2010 247 Yes HVP N33 W118 Harbour View Park Community Building front -97 Excellent Excellent 43 255 03 232 door 7/12/2010 251 Yes HVP N33 W118 Harbour View Park Center Part of Community -98 Excellent Excellent 43 255 03 232 Building 7/12/2010 258 Yes HVP N33 W118 4343 Pickwick Circle Harbour View Elementary 43 256 03 138 School-right by front door in covered breezeway 7/12/2010 301 Yes HVP N33 W118 4343 Pickwick Circle Harbour View Elementary -87 Excellent Excellent 43 256 03 138 School-Sidewalk by park- ing lot between the handi- capped parking sign Kramer Firm Inc Page 8 Item 2. - Page 103 Date -� Time Com- 8VP Lat Eon 4 � Address� Location �" � k RSSI Field to- 'office to pleted or dBm Office Fields HVP °` Al. Quality Quantity 7/12/2010 306 Yes HVP N33 W118 4343 Pickwick Circle Harbour view elementary -101 Excellent Excellent 43 264 03 086 school-inside bungalow 37 7/12/2010 3 12 Yes HVP N33 W118 Harbour View Park Adjacent to the proposed -86 Excellent Excellent 43 294 03 212 cell site 7/12/2010 323 Yes HVP N33 W118 16700 Saybrook Harbour Lights Resort -101 Excellent Excellent 43 165 03 178 Lane Rental Office-center of rental office 7/12/2010 338 Yes HVP 7/12/2010 339 Yes HVP N33 43 35 W118 16875 Algonquin -112 1 03-090 Street 7/12/2010 343 Yes HVP N33 W118 16821 Algonquin St outside Trader Joes in -99 Excellent Excellent 43 G36 03 070 courtyard 7/12/2010 347 Yes HVP N33 W118 16821 Algonquin St inside Trader Joes in cen- -110 Excellent Excellent 43 036 03 070 ter of building 7/12/2010 400 Yes HVP N33 W118 Northwest Corner of Sims -83 Excellent Excellent 43 138 02 894 Street and Pearce Street- outdoors 7/12/2010 407 Yes HVP N33 W118 17131 Sandra Lee -87 Excellent Excellent 42 784 02 942 Lane 7/12/2010 428 Yes HVP N33 W118 16757 Bolero Lane -105 43 126 03 691 7/12/2010 440 Yes HVP N33 W118 17031 Bolero Lane Outdoors in front -104 Excellent Excellent 42 863 03 618 7/12/2010 450 Yes HVP N33 W118 Harbour Mobile Center of courtyard mov- -105 Breaking Excellent 43 442 03 230 Home Estates Club- ing inside up some house-16400 Say- brook Lane 7/12/2010 459 Yes HVP N33 W118 Harbour Mobile empty space 127 -99 Excellent Excellent 43 449 03 229 Home Estates Club- house-16400 Say- brook Lane 7/12/2010 5 11 Yes HVP N33 W118 Monterey Lane At entry to Rancho Del Rey -98 Excellent Excellent 43 604 03 159 (private street) Unit 3-outside in vehicle 7/12/2010 523 Yes HVP N33 W118 3997 Mistral Drive outside on the street -87 Excellent Excellent 43 499 03 566 8/5/2010 1055 No HVP N33 43 15 W118 4343 Pickwick Circle Inside Harbour View Ele- no 030705 mentary School sig- nal 8/5/2010 1100 Yes HVP N33 43 15 W118 4343 Pickwick Circle Front parking lot of Har- -95 Excellent Excellent 030705 bour View Elementary School 8/5/2010 11 16 Yes HVP N33 W118 4302 Pickwick Circle Apartment complex on a -101 Excellent Breaking 43 1328 03 12 78 stairwell off the first floor up a little 8/5/2010 No HVP N33 W118 4302 Pickwick Circle In building 43 13 28 03 12 78 Kramer Firm Inc Page 9 Item 2® - Page 104 Damem Comb BVP. Lai Lawn r' Address` y Locat+ctn � ✓3RSS{ I �Ieio' y C}fficu' � pleted �o� yam" a `, c#f#m Office Ftd HVP �c ,,mow Qua{tty f, Quair 8/5/2010 1128 Yes HVP N33 W118 Diablo Circle and -105 Excellent Excellent 43 04 01 03 25 02 Edgewater Ln 8/5/2010 1136 Yes HVP N33 W118 16901 Bolero Lane Intersection of Finisterre -101 Excellent Excellent 42 57 53 03 38 92 Drive and Bolero Lane 8/5/2010 1141 Yes HVP N33 W118 16732 Bolero Ln -98 Excellent Excellent 43 08 17 03 39 78 8/5/2010 1149 Yes HVP N33 W118 16612 Nalu Circle car port -109— Excellent Excellent 43 13 64 03 33 70 8/5/2010 1153 Yes HVP N33 W118 16691 Baruna Lane Corner of Baruna Lane and -ill Excellent Excellent 43 08 49 03 34 73 Sea Witch Lane 8/5/2010 1157 Yes HVP N33 W118 16821 Sea Witch Corner of Sea Witch Lane -105 Excellent Excellent 43 02 36 03 38 14 Lane and Kamaln Dr 8/5/2010 1203 Yes HVP N33 W118 17052 Baruna Lane Corner of Sirius Drive and -102 Excellent Excellent 42-51 95 03 31 38 Baruna Lane 8/5/2010 1207 Yes HVP N33 W118 3922 Finisterre Corner of Sea Witch Lane -100 Excellent Excellent 42 58 15 03 36 51 Drive and Finisterre Drive 8/5/2010 1214 Yes HVP N33 W118 16781 Bolero Lane inside garage of residence -105 Excellent Excellent 43 06 08 03 43 05 8/5/2010 1222 Yes HVP N33 W118 16955 Edgewater -102 Excellent Excellent 42 54 19 03 26 79 Lane 8/5/2010 1231 Yes, HVP N33 W118 17076 Edgewater inside on 2nd floor of -111 good good but 42 49 09 03 15 61 Lane home under construction initial (walls are up,finishing call did interior design) not con- nect 8/5/2010 1239 Yes HVP N33 W118- 17188 Courtney Corner of Courtney Lane -103 Excellent Excellent 42 43 69 03 09 99 Lane and Edgewater Lane 8/5/2010 1247 HVP N33 W118 16992 Davenport Intersection of Davenport -94 Excellent Excellent 42 56 05 03 03 29 Drive Drive and Courtney Lane 8/5/2010 1256 Yes HVP N33 43 02 W 118 16821 Algonquin St inside of Trader Joes -98 Excellent Excellent 0304 8/5/2010 135 Yes HVP N33 W 118 16883 Algonquin inside Great Wok Restau- -105 43 00 02 03 05 40 Street rant 8/5/2010 153 Yes HVP N33 W118 16712 Saybrook outside building on side- -937 Excellent Excellent 43 08 05 0309 Lane walk 8/5/2010 No HVP 16712 Saybrook Ln parking garage under apartment building Kramer Firm Inc Page 10 Item 2. - Page 105 Date `s Times Corn- 3VP Cat Lon r'Address s Locat�o9 `,, RSSI sFieidt* 'S f#ic to p eted or; - - u damp' Offlc- Feic3r_j-� HVP ` Y CRual�ty, Qu'ntits/� 8/5/2010_ 157 Yes HVP N33 W118 16781 Phelps Lane Corner of Sdhman Drive -110 (dropp 43 05 65 03 21 67 and Phelps ed call) 8/5/2010 159 Yes HVP N33 W118 16781 Phelps Lane Corner of Silliman Drive -102 Excellent Excellent 43 05 65 03 21 67 and Phelps 8/5/2010 203 Yes HVP N33 43 15 W118 4111 Morning Star outside be- Excellent Excellent 0324 Drive twe en- 94 and -104 8/5/2010 212 Yes HVP (call was droppe d) 8/512010 212 Yes HVP N33 W118 17085 Eastport Corner of Fairfield Circle -97 Excellent Excellent 42 54 19 03 12 7 Drive and Eastport Drive 8/5/2010 2 16 Yes HVP N33 W118 16951 Windsor on top of a little rise -98 Excellent Excellent 33 42 56 03 1943 Drive 8/5/2010 223 Yes HVP N33 W118 16701 Dolores under carport at rear of -98 Excellent Excellent 33 43 10 02 573 Street apartment 8/5/2010 227 Yes HVP N33 W118 16621 Dolores under 2 story apartment -98 Excellent Excellent 43 14 18 0258 17 Street building overhang 8/5/2010 235 Yes HVP N33 W118 4676 Pinecrest alley behind house,2 story -102 Excellent Excellent 43 03 3 02 54 2 Circle apartment building 8/5/2010 238 Yes HVP N33 W 118 4662 Milo Drive 2 story apt building, -93 Excellent Excellent 43 01 6 02 49 7 parked in front overhang 8/5/2010 241 Yes HVP N33 W118 16862 Blanton inside apartment single -98 Excellent Excellent 43 00 8 0247 9 Street story garage,Corner of Milo Drive and Blanton Street 8/5/2010 249 Yes HVP N33 W118 upper Corner of sector C -91 Excellent Excellent 43 14 8 0244 9 at the Corner of Prairie Drive and Lynn Lane 8/5/2010 253 Yes HVP N33 W118 16691 Blanton under carport overhang -98 Excellent Excellent 43 10 3 02 52 0 Street 8/5/2010 258 Yes HVP N33 W118 16684 Sims Street underneath parking -82 Excellent Excellent 42 59 06 02 SO 1 area/alley/overhang,2 story apartment building 8/5/2010 303 Yes HVP N33 W118 16912 Sims Street inside underground park- -102 Excellent Excellent 42 58 13 0252 3 ing structure of apartment complex Kramer Firm Inc Page I I Item 2. a Page 106 ID`at-e _ Time Com -BVP ''Lat Tvptow Address % X Location � 3°'� RSSI 4�Field to bf�ee=to ' dBm Office Fretd� n ,pleted or e,, ,�" �' 3 ,, HVPF n °� _ s v t2uat tyQua€ttify°� 8/5/2010 308 Yes HVP N33 W118 17121 Sandra Lee Corner of O'Ryan Drive F 83 Excellent Excellent 42 47 7 02 56 7 Lane and Sandra Lee Land 8/5/2010 No HVP N33 W118 3 Seaview Lane Large Mobile home park 43 25 0 03 15 1 8/5/2010 319 Yes HVP N33 W118 3 Seaview Lane Large Mobile home park -111 Excellent Excellent 43 25 0 03 15 1 8/5/2010 326 Yes HVP N33 W118 17 Starboard Drive in front of Mobile home -101 Excellent Excellent 43 22 38 03 10 6 8/5/2010 329 Yes 42 Blue Water Ln bottom edge of large (call Mobile home park that was — encompasses most of droppe sector A d) - 8/5/2010 332 Yes HVP N33 W118 42 Blue Water Ln bottom edge of large -105 Excellent Excellent 43 25 8 03 04 75 Mobile home park that encompasses most of sector A 8/5/2010 335 Yes HVP N33 W118 121 Harbour Lane Mobile home park -104 Excellent Excellent 43 27 0 03 09 8 8/5/2010 341 Yes HVP N33 W118 16222 Monterey Mobile park -106 Excellent Excellent 43 33 4 03 08 14 Lane 8/5/2010 344 Yes HVP N33 W118 16222 Monterey Mobile park space#210 -100 Excellent Excellent 43 30 7 03 15 0 Lane 8/5/2010 348 Yes HVP N33 W118 16222 Monterey Mobile space#191 -98 Excellent Excellent 43 29 4 03 12 9 Lane to- 105 8/5/2010 No 16222 Monterey Mobile space#116 Lane 8/5/2010 No 16222 Monterey Mobile space#116 Lane 8/5/2010 No 16222 Monterey Mobile space#116 Lane 8/5/2010 355 Yes HVP N33 W118 16222 Monterey Mobile space#116 -101 good good 43 28 6 03 08 6 Lane 8/5/2010 400 Yes HVP N33 W118 16222 Monterey Mobile space#95,back -101 Excellent Excellent 43 30 9 03 01 35 Lane Corner of park 8/5/2010 No 16222 Monterey Mobile space#56,north Lane End of park 8/5/2010 402 Yes HVP N33 W118 16222 Monterey Mobile space#56,north -105 Excellent Excellent 43 34 5 03 01 85 Lane End of park 8/5/2010 No 16222 Monterey Mobile space#20,upper Lane Corner of park 8/5/2010 407 Yes HVP N33 W118 16222 Monterey Mobile space#20,upper -101 Excellent Excellent 43 398 03 01 5 Lane Corner of park Kramer Firm Inc Page 12 Item 2. - Page 107 Date :4une �,Comf , BVPqi Lat Lon Address � *y Location Et"�Sh Field to Office to p _ , pieted or k � v� - d6m° Office Field„ �• 4 % '5 EHVP�a'' 4 Quaf€ty Civant4, 8/5/2010 412 Yes HVP N33� W118 16222 Monterey unit 3,Mobile space#273, -102 Excellent Excellent 43 40 66 03 09 45 Lane across the highway to the west 8/5/2010 428 Yes HVP N33 W118 16192 Wayfarer Humboldt island -108 Static Static 43 36 97 03 34 0 Lane 8/5/2010 434 Yes HVP N33 W118 16301 Niantic Circle house at End of street -98 Excellent Excellent 43 30 5 03 39 45 to- 100 8/5/2010 437 Yes HVP N33 W118 16418 Ladona Circle Humboldt island -99 Excellent Excellent 43 24 4 03 44 82 8/6/2010 911 Yes BVP N33 W118 5652 Brighton Drive directly across from park -99 Excellent Excellent 42 13 9 01 46 8 8/6/2010 914 Yes BVP N33 W118 17941 Shoreham Intersection of Berkshire -91 Excellent Excellent 42 06 2 0151 1 Lane Drive and Shoreham Lane to - 99 8/6/2010 917 Yes BVP N33 W118 18041 Starmont Intersection of Berkshire -90 Excellent Excellent 42 00 98 0144 14 Lane Drive and Starmont(dead end against oil field) 8/6/2010 921 Yes BVP N33 W118 5762 Woodboro Intersection of Woodboro -94 Excellent Excellent 42 07 7 01 40 7 Drive Drive and Bolton Circle 8/6/2010 924 Yes BVP N33 W118 179162 Wellbank Intersection of Woodboro -95 Excellent Excellent 42 05 17 0127 25 Lane and Wellbank Lane 8/6/2010 927 Yes BVP N33 W118 17932 Portside Middle of court,just off of -98 Excellent Excellent 42 07 8 01 33 5 Circle Lancefield Dr 8/6/2010 —9 29 Yes BVP N33 W118 17902 Oldglen Lane Intersection of Lancefield -98 Excellent Excellent 42 08 4 01 36 7 drive and Oldglen Lane 8/6/2010 934 Yes BVP N33 W118 5711 Woodboro Intersection of Woodboro -98 Excellent Excellent 42 09 4 0143 5 Drive Drive and Whitford Lane 8/6/2010 936 Yes BVP N33 W118 5831 Padua Drive -101 Excellent Excellent 42 1095 01 35 05 8/6/2010 938 Yes BVP N33 W118 5952 Padua Drive Intersection of Padua -99 Excellent Excellent 42 10 83 01 27 62 Drive and Wrightwood Lane 8/6/2010 941 Yes BVP N33 W118 5901 Terrier Drive -98 Excellent Excellent 42 1362 01 30 23 8/6/2010 944 No BVP N33 W118 5771 Terrier Drive Intersection of Misty Lane 42 1216 01 39 2 and Terrier Drive 8/6/2010 944 Yes BVP N33 W118 5771 Terrier Drive Intersection of Misty Lane -91 Excellent Excellent 42 12 16 0139 2 and Terrier Drive 8/6/2010 947 Yes BVP N33 W118 5822 Pinon Drive -99 Excellent Excellent 42 161 01 36 0 8/6/2010 950 Yes BVP N33 W118 5902 Raphael Drive -101 Excellent Excellent 42 188 01 30 35 Kramer Firm Inc Page 13 Item 2. - Page 108 Date rime Corn- BVP L8t jLon Address Location t TJR5S1 Field to off,ceto pleted or in Office Field � liVP � ; Quality Quantity 8/6/2010 953 Yes BVP N33 W118 5772 Raphael Drive Intersection of Raphael -93 Excellent Excellent 42 18 72 01 39 21 Drive and Misty Lane 8/6/2010 955 Yes BVP N33 W118 5792 Lourdes Drive -99 Excellent Excellent 42 21 24 01 37 44 8/6/2010 958 Yes BVP N33 W118 5912 Lourdes Drive -95 Excellent Excellent 42 21 32 01 29 58 8/6/2010 1001 Yes -BVP N33 W118 17601 Griffith Circle End of Griffith Circle -93 Excellent Excellent -42 24 10 01 24 00 8/6/2010 1004 Yes BVP -N33 W118 5791 Price Drive Price Drive and De Long -100 Excellent Excellent 42 27 85 01 37 11 Circle 8/6/2010 1006 Yes BVP N33 W118 17592 Misty Lane Intersection of Serene -85 Excellent Excellent 2-24 75 01 39 84 Drive and Misty Lane 8/6/2010 1009 Yes BVP -N33 W118 17502 Montbury -92 Excellent Excellent -42 28 38 01 42 61 Circle 8/6/2010 1011 Yes BVP N33 W118 0 5672 Serene Drive Intersection of Serene -102 Excellent Excellent 42 24 75 1 45 25 Drive and Burlock Circle 8/6/2010 1013 Yes BVP N33 W118 7522 Woodfern Intersection of Mossvale -88 Excellent Excellent 42 27 74 01 49 27 Lane Circle and Woodfern Lane 8/6/2010 1016 Yes BVP N33 W118 5502 Mossvale End of Mossvale Drive -102 Excellent Excellent 42 27 52 01 55 95 Circle 8/6/2010 1020 No BVP End of Serene Drive 8/6/2010 1020 No BVP End of Serene Drive 8/6/2010 1020 No BVP End of Serene Drive 8/6/2010 1020 No BVP - End of Serene Drive 8/6/2010 1020 No BVP End of Serene Drive 8/6/2010 1020 Yes BVP N33 W118 5552 Serene Drive about 100 yards from End -109 Excellent Excellent 42 25 17 01 53 33 of Serene Drive 8/6/2010 1023 Yes BVP _N33 W118 5622 Ridgebury Intersection of Ridgebury -99 Excellent Excellent 42 22 45 01 48 46 Drive Drive and Crustmore Lane 8/6/2010 1025 Yes BVP N33 W118 47642 Helenbrook Intersection of Helenbrook -101 Excellent Excellent 42 21 49 01 43 40 Lane Lane and Windcroft Drive 8/6/2010 1027 Yes BVP N33 W118 17712 Helenbrook Intersection of Helenbrook -102 Excellent Excellent 42 16 93 01 42 35 Lane Lane and Larkmont Drive 8/6/2010 1030 Yes BVP N33 W118 17672 Stanfield End of Stanfield Circle -85 Excellent Excellent 42 19 35 01 45 75 Circle 8/6/2010 1033 Yes BVP N33 W118 5642 Larkmont Intersection of Larkmont -104 Excellent Excellent 42 17 61 01 47 95 Drive Drive and Crestmore Lane Kramer Firm Inc Page 14 Item 2. m Page 109 Date time Com- r BVP Last Lan Addr"ess °Location RSSf` Fieldto Office to pleted or dBm Offii:0� %Field HVP k Quality Quantity 8/6/2010 1035 Yes BVP N33 W118 5552 Maryport Intersection of Maryport -98 Excellent Excellent 42 14 13 01 51 89 Drive Drive and Crestmoore Lane 8/6/2010 1037 Yes BVP N33 W118 17892 Shoreham Intersection of Maryport -97 Excellent Excellent 42 10 27 01 47 96 Lane Drive and Shoreham Lane 8/6/2010 1039 Yes BVP N33 W118 5581 Selkirk Drive Intersection of Denvale -90 Excellent Excellent 42 09 87 0152 19 Circle and Selkirk drive 8/6/2010 1041 Yes BVP N33 W118 17852 Alfawn Circle -94 Excellent Excellent 42 1219 0157 22 8/6/2010 1043 Yes BVP N33 W118 17822 Falkirk Lane End of Falkirk Lane -90 Excellent Excellent 42 12 89 01 59 72 8/6/2010 1046 Yes BVP N33 W118 17741 Falkirk Lane Corner of Falkirk Lane and -90 Excellent Excellent 42 16 06 01 56 94 Maryport Drive 8/6/2010 1048 Yes BVP N33 W118 17621 Falkirk Lane near Intersection of Rid- -93 Excellent Excellent 42 22 37 01 54 90 gebury Drive and Falkirk Lane 8/6/2010 1050 Yes BVP N33 W118 17671 Amberton Intersection of Helmside -97 Excellent Excellent 42 20 18 01 52 33 Lane Drive and Amberton Lane 8/6/2010 1053 Yes BVP N33 W118 5602 Ludlow Circle End of Ludlow Circle -93 Excellent Excellent 42 1676 01 49 89 8/6/2010 1058 Yes BVP N33 W118 5692 Grimsby Drive -91 Excellent Excellent 42 06 79 01 45 20 8/6/2010 1100 Yes BVP N33 W118 18012 Starmont Intersection of Grimsby -99 Excellent Excellent 42 03 09 01 39 88 Lane and Starmont Lane 8/6/2010 1104 Yes BVP N33 W118 5821 Woodboro -105 Breaking Breaking 42 04 32 01 35 45 Drive up up 8/6/2010 11 12 Yes BVP N33 W118 5482 Bankton Drive Intersection of Rainglen -94 Excellent Excellent 42 19 84 01 59 43 Lane and Bankton Drive 8/6/2010 1116 Yes BVP N 33 N118 End of Graham Street -94 Excellent Excellent 42 14 64 0201 78 where it dead ends along fire trail 8/6/2010 1151 Yes HVP N33 W118 17002 Manna Bay Intersection of Marina Bay -102 Excellent Excellent 42 53 92 0351 80 Drive Drive and Coral Cay Lane 8/6/2010 11 53 Yes HVP N33 W118 17056 Marina Bay -97 Minor Minor 42 52 93 03 45 39 Drive static static 8/6/2010 1155 Yes HVP N33 W118 16956 Coral Cay -102 Excellent Excellent 42 57 22 03 49 86 Lane 8/6/2010 1157 Yes HVP N33 W118 16872 Coray Cay -92 Excellent Excellent 43 01 38 0349 17 Lane Kramer Firm Inc Page 15 Item 2. - Page 110 DS e Time g Com-a HVP Lat ton ,Addr ss Location RSSI Fre'pdto �Offic t& d leted� or h ,� s d8m Office Field' IN LA HVP ` ; _s tua)Aty ,,gitant 8/6/2010 1159 Yes HVP N33 W118 16782 Coral Cay -105 Excellent Excellent 43 05 73-- 03 51 06 Lane 8/6/2010 1200 Yes HVP N33 W118 16682 Coray Cay -94 Excellent Excellent 431119 03 53 03 Lane 8/6/2010 1201 Yes -HVP N33 W118 16632 Coral Cay -91 Excellent Excellent 43 13 65 03 54 16 Lane 8/6/2010 1203 Yes HVP N33 W118 3565 Courtside -95— Excellent Excellent 43 08 90 03 56 33 Circle Kramer Firm's evaluation of the consumer call experience information col- lected and reported above is that T-Mobile's Personal Coverage Check-maps for-both the HVP and BVP areas accurately portrays the expected coverage as stated by T-Mobile, specifically that the Maps approximate anticipated coverage outdoors, which varies by location, may include limited or no coverage areas, and do not guarantee service availability. Within coverage areas, network changes, traffic volume, outages, technical limitations, signal strength, your equipment, ob- structions, weather and other conditions may interfere with service quality and availability There is no reasonable expectation that every wireless telephone will work in every location and within every structure of every type all of the time This reality is properly reflected in T-Mobile's own disclaimer, reproduced in part above, on its Personal Coverage Check map pages Kramer Firm Inc Page 16 Item 20 - Page 111 4. Potential Alternative Sites Harbour View Park Area The most apparent alternative site for the present HVP site is at the Hunting- ton Harbor Mall Shopping Center, located at the intersection of Algonquin and Davenport Drive This shopping center has a roof-mounted Sprint Nextel cell site on the south building From a design standpoint, to achieve signal coverage, a clock tower or bell tower element of approximately 50 feet in height would be needed This height would allow T-Mobile's antennas to `look over' the top of the multi- dwelling units to the north, and would also provide collocation opportunities for other wireless carriers Another alternative would be to place T-Mobile's transmission and antenna equipment in two to four right-of-way sites along the several of the more traveled roads in the area including Sunset Way East, Heil Avenue, Edinger Avenue, Warner Avenue, and Bolsa Chica Street Bolsa View Park Area Unlike the Harbour View Park area, the Bolsa View Park area does not fea- ture any nearby commercial areas, thus the alternative would be to place T- Mobile's transmission and antenna equipment in one or two right-of-way sites, most likely along the access roads such as Talbert Avenue and Graham Street Kramer Firm Inc Page 17 Item 2. - Page 112 Kramer Firm Inc Page 18 Item 2. - Page 113 5. Additional Comments T-Mobile's coverage maps submitted to the City have changed over time, as has its online Personal Coverage Check maps These `moving targets' make it unclear as to what T-Mobile wishes to accomplish with the wireless sites proposed for the HVP and BVP areas Even though T-Mobile coverage exists outdoors in both areas, as shown on its Personal Coverage Check maps, and verified by our consumer perspec- tive call testing, there will also be varying levels of in-building service availability to consumers Radio frequency signals to not stop at walls or windows Signal penetration into buildings will be affected by the construc- tion materials used in each building, the type of glass anti-reflective coating used (if any), and the location within each building where calls may be at- tempted I do not believe that T-Mobile has submitted any information into the record regarding any actual in-building tests they may (or may not) have performed in either the HVP or BVP areas The statement of qualifications for the author of this report is attached Kramer Firm Inc Page 19 Item 2e - Page 114 Jonathan L. Framer, Esq. FSCTE,BTS,BPS,BDS,CBT Principal Attorney—Kramer Telecom Law Firm,P C Principal Technologist—Kramer Firm,Inc 2001 S Barrington Avenue, Suite 306—Los Angeles, CA 90025 TelecomLawFirm com/KramerFirm com 2006—Present Principal Attorney, Kramer Telecom Law Firm,P C (Los Angeles, CA) 1999—Present Principal Consultant, Kramer Firm, Inc (Los Angeles, CA) 1987— 1999 President, Communications Support-Corp (El Toro,CA,Los Angeles, CA) 1984— 1987 Owner,Communicable Consultants (El Toro, CA) 1982— 1984 Technical Manager, later Regional Technical Manager, Storer Communications (Southern California Region)(Laguna Niguel,CA) 1982—1982 Engineering Manager,Western Cable Services, Inc (Ventura, CA) 1979— 1982 System Engineer, Warner Cable of Malibu(Malibu, CA) 1978— 1979 Self employed radio telecommunications engineer(Malibu, California) 1976— 1978 Field Technician, Motorola Communications &Electronics Area F Project Management(California,Nevada,Arizona,New Mexico) 1971 — 1972 Rovafone of Los Angeles (Woodland Hills, CA) Admitted as an Attorney by the State Bar of California(SBN 244074) Admitted as an Attorney by the United States District Court, Central District of California Attorney Member,Federal Communications Bar Association Attorney Member, International Municipal Lawyers Association Attorney Member,Los Angeles County Bar Association Attorney Member, Second Life Bar Association- Licensed by the Federal Communications Commission General Radiotelephone Operator License,with Ship Radar and Broadcast endorsements, Previously licensed as a Second Class Radio Telephone Operator, Sept 1975, First Class Radiotelephone Operator,Nov 1977, General Radiotelephone Operator License,June 1987, Global Maritime Distress and Safety System Operator/Maintainer License, with Ship Radar Endorsement, Restricted Radiotelephone licensee,Amateur radio operator since November 1970 currently licensed as an Extra Class operator Licensed by the California Contractors State License Board for low voltage communications(Class C7) Li- cense No 433113 Licensed since 1982 Life member of the American Radio Relay League,ARRL book article author and review editor on cable tel- evision RF interference matters, Appointed Volunteer Counsel of the ARRL Former wireless technology advisor to and testifying expert before the FCC State &Local Government Advi- sory Committee Statement of Qualifications Jonathan L Kramer—Page 1 Item 2. - Page 'I'I5 Co-author, co-editor of"A Local Government Official's Guide to Transmitting Antenna RF Emission Safety- Rules, Procedures,and Practical Guidance", a wireless technology advisory to local governments based on OET Bulletin 65 published by the FCC, Spring 2000 (download from http//www FCC gov/oet/rfsafety) Former Chairperson,International Right of Way Association Wireless Committee Former National Board of Directors member,National Association of Telecommunications Officers and Ad- visors (NATOA),an affiliate of the National League of Cities(Terms. 1997-2000, 1992-1994) Former Co-chair of the Joint Task Force on Technical Standards Committee, appointed by NATOA,National League of Cities,and US Conference of Mayors to develop the national technical standards for cable televi- sion systems adopted by the FCC in February 1992 NATOA's only twice-honored Member of the Year(1997 and 1991) Executive Committee Board Member, State Bar of California,Public Law Section(2008-20-1-1) Immediate Past President, States of California and Nevada Chapterof NATOA(SCAN NATOA) (2006- 2008), founding member of that Chapter Chapter President 2009-2010 Charter Member, California Wireless Association (CALWA) Former Co-chair of National Technical Standards committee appointed by NATOA,National League of Ci- ties, and US Conference of Mayors to develop the national technical standardized testing manual to determine compliance with the FCC rules Fellow Member of Society of Cable Telecommunication Engineers, United Kingdom society (FSCTE desig- nation) Senior Member of Society of Cable Telecommunications Engineers, United States society (SCTE-US) SCTE-US Senior Member since April 1993, member since 1981 Certified as a Broadband Transport Specialist(BTS designation)by the SCTE-US Certified as a Broadband Distribution Specialist(BDS designation)by the SCTE-US Certified as a Broadband Premises Specialist(BPS designation)by the SCTE-US Member, SCTE's Loyal Order of the 704(Membership restricted to recognized cable engineers with a mini- mum of 30 years in CATV engineering experience) Co-Chair, SCTE's WG7 Committee developing standardized cable TV industry interpretations to the Nation- al Electrical Code Member, Society of Broadcast Engineers (member since 2008) Awarded recognition as a"Certified Broadcast Technologist"by the Society of Broadcast Engineers (2009) Statement of Qualifications Jonathan L Kramer—Page 2 Item Zm m Page 116 Awarded recognition as a"Public Safety Radio Technician"by the Association of Public-Safety Communica- tions Officials—International,Inc (APCO) Elected Life Member,—American Radio Relay League(member since 1971) Witness before the FCC's State&Local Government Advisory Committee on OET 65,March 2000 Witness before the FCC in Cable TV re-regulation hearings,March 1990,representing NATOA, et al Testifying expert witness in federal and state court cases regarding cable television technology,and federal and state court cases regarding wireless technology Technology speaker at every NATOA National Conference from 1988 to 2000, and 2002 to 2004,Technolo- gy speaker at many regional and local NATOA and SCAN NATOA meetings Communications technology speaker at Society of Cable Telecommunications Engineers conferences,and cable industry conferences Published author of book and magazine articles on communications technology,plant safety, construction and administration Cable system engineering and technical management experience six years before forming Kramer Firm, Inc , Chief Technician, Technical Manager, Regional Engineer Former Field Engineering Representative for Motorola Communications and Electronics, Area F Program Management team Areas of experience include microwave radio,baseband RF and audio, digital signal- ing, UHF and VHF two-way radio (including high stability Simulcast®radio operations),telephony, and command and control communications Juris Doctor Degree cum laude,Abraham Lincoln University School of Law, Los Angeles (2001) LL M I T Law and Telecommunications Law candidate,University of Strathclyde(2012) Undergraduate education at CSUN, UCLA, LATTC,and WLAC, AS Degree in Radio Communications (with honors),Los Angeles Trade Technical College The following is a ap rtial list of the nearly 600 governments and agencies which have relied upon Mr Kramer's broadband and/or radio-telecommunications advice as a telecommunications technology advisor/inspector since 1984,and/or as an attorney since 2006 Selected Federal Agencies-National Associations—States—Local Agencies Federal Communications Commission U S Marine Corps,Twentynme Palms, CA U S Department of Justice U S Marine Corps, San Diego, CA National Association of Telecommunica- U S Navy,Monterey, CA tions Officers and Advisors U S Navy, San Diego, CA Soc of Cable Telecom Engineers U S Navy,Lemoore, CA United States Army, Ft Irwin, CA United States Conference of Mayors Statement of Qualifications Jonathan L Kramer—Page 3 Item 2. - Page 117 National Association of Counties Connecticut Siting Council National League of Cities League of California Cities State of Michigan PUC Los Angeles Police Department State of Connecticut DPUC Otay Water District Las Virgines School District Selected Local Governments and Government Associations Addison, IL Capitola, CA Dyer,IN Hanover Park, IL Aiken County, SC Carol Stream, IL E Haven, CT Hartland, CT Albany, CA Carson, CA Eagan,MN Hermosa Beach, CA Albuquerque,NM Cedar Lake, IN East-Granby, CT Hesperia,CA Alcoa, TN Centerville, OH East Windsor, CT Hidden Hills, CA Aliso Viejo, CA Cerritos, CA Eastchester,NY Highland Park,IL Anaheim, CA Chelan, WA Easton,CT Highland,CA Apache Jet,AZ Cheshire, CT El-Monte, CA Highland,IN Arcadia, CA Chester, CT Elburn, IL Hillsborough, CA Aurora, IL Chico, CA Elk Grove Village, IL Hinsdale,IL Austin, Texas Chino Hills,CA Elmhurst,IL Hobart, IL Avon, OH Chino, CA Encinitas,CA Hoffman Estates, IL Azusa, CA Chula Vista, CA Enfield,CT Hollywood,FL Baldwin Park, CA Clarendon Hills, IL Escondido, CA Homewood, AL Barrington, IL Cleveland Heights, OH Essex, CT Homewood, IL Bartlett, IL Clinton, CT Fairfax, CA Huntington Beach, CA Bellbrook, OH Colchester, CT Federal Way, WA Immokale Resv ,, FL Bellflower, CA Colton, CA Flora,Illinois Indian Wells, CA Bellingham, WA Columbia Heights,MN Fort Wayne, IN Irvine,CA Berkeley, CA Commerce, CA Franklin, CT Itasca, IL Beverly Hills, CA Concord, CA Franklin,KY Kettering,OH Big Bear Lake, CA Cornwall, CT Fremont, CA Killingworth, CT Big Cypress Resv ,,FL Corona, CA Fullerton,CA King Co,WA Birmingham,AL Culver City,CA Galena, IL La Canada Flintridge, CA Bloomingdale, IL Cypress, CA Garden Grove, CA La Grange,IL Blount County,TN Darien, CT Gardena, CA La Habra Heights, CA Bolingbrook,IL Darien, IL Germantown, OH La Mesa, CA Bozrah, CT Davis, CA Glen Ellyn, IL La Puente, CA Branford, CT Decatur, AL Glendale Heights, IL La Quetta, CA Brentwood, CA Deep River, CT Glendale,CA Lacy, WA Brighton Resv ,,FL Deerfield Beach, FL Glenwood,IL Laguna Beach, CA Bronxville,NY Denver, CO Goleta, CA Laguna Niguel, CA Buena Park, CA Diamond Bar, CA Goshen, CT Lake County, IL Buffalo Grove, IL Downers Grove, IL Granby, CT Lake County,IN Burr Ridge, IL Duarte, CA Greenville, IL Lake Station, IN Butte County, CA Dublin, CA Greenwich, CT Lemont, IL Calabasas, CA Dubuque, IA Griffith, IN Lisbon, CT Calimesa, CA DuPage County,IL Guilford, CT Lisle,IL Canandaigua,NY Durango, CO Haddam,CT Litchfield, CT Canton, MN Durham, CT Half Moon Bay, CA Live Oak,TX Statement of Qualifications Jonathan L Kramer— Page 4 Item 2. e Page 118 Livermore, CA Norwalk, CT San Diego County, CA Ventura County, CA Lombard,IL Norwich, CT San Diego, CA Victoria, TX Lompoc, CA Oak Brook,IL San Francisco, CA Villa Park, CA Lone Tree, CO Oak Park,IL San Juan Capistrano, CA Villa Park, IL Longmont, CO Oakbrook Terrace, IL San Luis Obispo Co , CA Virginia Beach,VA Long Beach,CA Oakwood,OH San Luis Obispo, CA Wallingford, CT Los Alamos, CA Ojai, CA San Marcos, CA Walnut Creek, CA Los Altos, CA Old Saybrook, CT San Rafael, CA Walnut, CA Los Angeles Co,CA Olean,New York Santa Ana, CA Warren, CT Los Angeles, CA Olympia,WA Santa Barbara Co , CA Warrenville, IL Louisville, CO Opelika,AL Santa Clara, CA Waterbury, CT Loveland, CO Orange CO ,CA Santa Clarita, CA Waterford,MI Lowell, IN Orange, CA Santa Cruz Co , CA Watertown, CT Lynchburg, VA Oxnard, CA Santa Cruz, CA Wayne, IL Madison,CT Paducah,KY Santa Maria, CA West Allis,WI Malibu, CA Palm Springs, CA Santa Monica, CA West Carrollton, OH Manhattan Beach, CA Palos Verdes Est , CA Schaumburg, IL West Chicago, IL Maryville,TN Paris, IL Schererville, IN West Covina, CA Mentor, OH Park Forest,IL Seattle,WA West Frankfort, IL Merced, CA Pasadena, CA Simi Valley, CA West Hollywood, CA Meriden, CT Peoria County,IL Sistersville,WV West Milton, OH Merrillville, IN Philadelphia,PA Solana Beach, CA West Palm Beach,FL Miamisburg, OH Piqua, OH Solon, OH Westbrook, CT Middlebury,CT Placentia,CA Somers, CT Westmont,IL Milpitas, CA Plymouth, CT Southington, CT Weston, CT Mmooka, IL Plymouth,MI Spokane,WA Westport, CT Mission Viejo,CA Port Townsend,WA Sprmgboro, OH Wheaton, IL Modesto, CA Portland, OR St Charles, IL White Plains,NY Monterey CO, CA Portola Valley, CA St John,IN Willowbrook, IL Moreno Valley, CA Poway, CA St Louis,MO Wilmette, IL Morris, CT Preston, CT Stafford, CT Wilton, CT Mount Carmel,IL Prospect, CT Suffield, CT Windsor Locks, CT Mount Orab, OH Redding, CT Sugar Grove, IL Winfield, IL Mount Prospect,IL Redondo Beach, CA Sunnyvale, CA Wolcott, CT Mountain View, CA Rialto,CA Sutter Co, CA Wood Dale,IL Munster, IN Richmond,CA Temecula, CA Woodridge,IL Naperville,IL Riverside, CA Thousand Oaks, CA Yorba Linda, CA New Canaan, CT Rochester,MN Thurston County, WA New Martinsville,WV Rolling Hills Estates, CA Tiburon, CA New Orleans,LA Rolling Meadows,IL Tipp City, OH Newport Beach, CA Roselle,IL Torrance,CA Newton Falls, OH Roseville,MN Torrington, CT Niles,IL Salem,IL Troy,OH No Aurora,IL San Antonio, TX Tuckahoe,NY No Branford,CT Santa Barbara Co , CA Tucson,AZ No Haven, CT San Bernardino, CA Tumwater,WA Norfolk, VA San Bernardino Co , CA Tustin, CA North Aurora, IL San Clemente, CA Union, CT Statement of Qualifications Jonathan L Kramer—Page 5 Item 2. o Page 119 Litigation Where Jonathan Kramer Served as a Testifyinz or Non-Testifytnz Expert, or as a Trial Consultant (Wireless Communications) T-Mobile v City of Los Angeles(Retained by City) T-Mobile v City of Albuquerque (Retained by City) T-Mobile v City of Huntington Beach(Retained by City) Armstrong/McEachron v Cazcom (Retained by Armstrong) MetroPCS v City and County of San Francisco(Retained by City) Bay Area Cellular v City and County of San Francisco (Retained by City) Sprint v City of Palos Verdes Estates (Retained by City) Sprint v City of La Canada Flmtridge(Retained by City) AT&T Wireless v City of San Diego(Retained by City) Nextel v City of San Diego (Retained by City) AT&T Wireless v City of Carlsbad(Retained by City) Omnipomt v Garden City, Michigan(Retained by City) GTE Mobilenet v City and County of San Francisco (Retained by City) Illinois RSA 3 v Peoria County-(Retained by County) (Wired Communications) Qwest v City of Santa Fe (Retained by City) NewPath Networks v City of Davis (Retained by City) Marcus Cable Associates v City of Glendale(Retained by City) Evergreen v San Diego Gas &Electric, et al(Retained by Evergreen) NextG Networks v City of Huntington Beach(Retained by City) NewPath Networks v City of Irvine(Retained by City) Adelphia Cable v City of Thousand Oaks (Retained by City) Malencon v Cox Communications(Retained by Malencon) Schaff Dev Group v S E Fla Cable, Inc , dba Adelphia Cable (Retained by Schaff) Qwest v City of Berkeley(Retained by City) Playboy Enterprises v United States (Retained by FCC, Department of Justice) Jones Intercable v City of Chula Vista(Retained by City) Sierra East Television v Westar Cable(Retained by Sierra East) Booth American v United States (Retained by Department of Justice) D B Cable v Kalma Busk(Retained by Kalma Busk) Published Articles by Jonathan L. Kramer A Practical Guide to Radio Frequency Emissions Safety State Bar of California 2009 Radio Frequency Emissions Safety— NATOA 2009 A Practical and Practice Guide Use a Cell Phone Jammer and Get Jammed Up With the FCC Ezmearticles com 2008 Your California Cable TV Company Missed an Appomtment9 Ezmearticles com 2008 The Law Protects Cable TV Subscribers Statement of Qualifications Jonathan L Kramer—Page 6 Item 20 - Page 120 A Modern Game of Hide and Seek AGL Magazine 2007 Give Me Your Bond Communications 2007 Technology Magazine Picture Quality in the Digital World. A lost Science? NATOA Journal 2007 Effective Management of a Cable TV Rebuild/Upgrade NACO County News 2004 in Your Community Leveling the Playing Field for Cable TV Public Management 2003 Franchise Renewals Magazine A_Local Government Official's Guide to Transmitting Federal Communications 2000 Antenna RF Emission Safety Commission Rules,Procedures;-and Practical Guidance Selected Lectures- Universities, Colleges, School Districts USC Annenberg School of Communications University of Alabama Pepperdme University Orange Coast College Rancho Santiago College Centralia School District Oxnard Union School District Selected Lectures—Legal,Industry,and Professional Organizations Speaking Engagement Name Conference Year Major Issues in WiMAX Tower Leases and Zoning Lorman Education Services 2010 Recent Wireless-Siting Developments Amer.Plan Assoc O C Chptr 2010 Educational Seminar Panel California Wireless Association 2010 Current Issues in Cell Tower Leasing Lorman Educational Services 2010 Educational Seminar Panel California Wireless Association 2010 Technology Solutions for Small Law Firms Provisors LLP Conference 2009 Major Issues in WiMAX Tower Leases and Zoning Lorman Education Services 2009 Current Issues in Cell Tower Leasing Lorman Education Services 2009 Statement of Qualifications Jonathan L Kramer—Page 7 Item 2e - Page 121 Speaking Engagement Name Conference Year Top Tech Topics for a Law Practice State Bar of California Annual Conference 2009 "I'm from the Government [Planning Department] Amateur Radio Club of 2009 and I'm here to help you" El Cajon The National Electrical Code Why comply SCTE Live Learning 2009 DTV Transition Last Steps SCTE Live Learning 2009 "Tower Siting Getting to Win/Win for Localities California Wireless Association 2009 and for Carriers" Telecom 101 What Every Practioner Should Know State Bar of California Section 2009 Education Institute Secret Life of PDA Ethical Considerations State Bar of California Section 2009 Education Institute Cable TV Law Update- Cable Television Unra- Pennsylvania Bar Institute 2008 veled Wireless Telecommunications Law Update Current Lorman Education Services 2008 Issues in Cell Tower Regulation Automated Photo Red Light Enforcement Users Los Angeles Police Department 2008 Group "I'm From the Government(Planning Department) Palomar(California)ARC 2008 and I'm Here to Help You" Meeting "Surfin'Telecommunication Choices A New SCAN NATOA Annual Confe- 2008 World, A New Direction" rence FCC Regulations Regarding Cable TV SCTE Show Me Chapter 2008 Mobile Security and Ethical Issues for Attorneys State Bar of California Annual 2008 Conference "I'm From the Government (Planning Department) ARRL Southwest Division 2007 and I'm Here to Help You" Conference Statement of Qualifications Jonathan L Kramer—Page 8 Item 20 m Page 122 Speaking Engagement Name Conference Year AT&T Project Lightspeed League of California Cities Pol- 2007 icy Conference- Right of Way Furniture SCAN NATOA Annual Confe- 2007 rence Wild Wired(and Wireless)West State Bar of California Annual 2007 Conference Wireless telecommunications planning APA National Conference 2006 Wireless and Wired Telecommunications Law Up- League of California Cities City 2006 date Attorneys Section Conference Wireless Case Mock Hearing PCIA Annual Conference 2006 PEG Programming Alliance for Community Media 2005 Wireless Siting 101 Association of Environmental 2005 Professionals - Orange County Chapter A Sea Change in Wireless Siting California APA Conference 2005 Cable TV and Wireless Regulation and Law Update Florida Cable and Telecommu- 2005 nications Law Local Govern- ment Workshop Emerging and Competing Broadband Technology NATOA National Conference 2005 "Future of Cable Television" SCAN NATOA Annual Confe- 2005 rence Wireless Siting Planning A Government Perspec- APA-Regional Planning Con- 2004 tive ference Cable TV Regulation Local, State,and Federal City of Kent(WA) Cable TV 2004 Regulation Conference Telecommunications Law Update City Attorneys Association of 2004 San Diego County Cable TV and Wireless Regulation and Law Update Florida Cable and Telecommu- 2004 nications Law Local Govern- ment Workshop Statement of Qualifications Jonathan L Kramer—Page 9 Item 2. a Page 123 Speaking Engagement Name Conference Year Telecommunications Safety Code Violations A IMLA Annual Conference 2004 Field Guide for Attorneys Keynote Lecture on Telecommunications Groun- Thomas&Betts Power And 2004 ding Grounding Council Meeting Cable TV and Wireless Regulation and Law Update Florida Cable and Telecommu- 2003 nications Law Local Govern- ment Workshop How to Get A Wireless Tower Siting Permit Appli- IRWA Chapter 1 Conference 2003 cation Denied) Maximizing Wireless Resources NATOA Annual Conference 2003 Right of Way Considerations for Local Govern- Law Seminars International - 2002 ments Early Stage Due Diligence Technology Considerations When Bad Things Happen to Good Cable Systems- Center for International Legal 2002 Studies International Info Tech, Media, and Telecom Law Con- ference New FCC Technical Standards NCTA Education Conference 2002 Hiding Cell Phone Sites In Plain Sight NATOA 2001 Annual Confe- 2001 Now you see `um now you don't rence Wireless Siting Policy Issues and Practical Solu- Law Seminars International- 2001 tions -A Municipal View The Third Annual Conference on Local Telecommunications Infrastructure Cable TV Regulation NATOA Annual Conference 2000 Cable TV Regulation NATOA Annual Conference 1999 Cable TV Regulation NATOA Annual Conference 1998 Cable TV Regulation NATOA Annual Conference 1997 Cable TV Regulation NATOA Annual Conference 1996 Cable TV Regulation NATOA Annual Conference 1995 Statement of Qualifications Jonathan L Kramer—Page 10 Item 2. m Page 124 Speaking Engagement Name Conference Year Cable TV Regulation NATOA Annual Conference —1994 Cable TV Regulation NATOA Annual Conference 1993 Cable TV Regulation NATOA Annual Conference 1992 Cable TV Regulation NATOA Annual Conference 1991 Cable TV Regulation NATOA Annual Conference 1990 Cable TV Regulation NATOA Annual Conference 1989 Cable TV Regulation Michigan NATOA Conference 1987 Statement of Qualifications Jonathan L Kramer—Page 11 Item 2. e Page 125 ATTACHMENT #7 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 107 Filed 07/09/10 Page 1 of 4 Page ID #.3134 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA CIVIL MINUTES- GENERAL "rouse? CV 09-03777-RGK (SSx) ;; yate July 9,2010 � , �> '.>i k OMNIPOINT COMMUNICATIONS,INC. v. CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, et �'rse ? R GARY KLAUSNER, U S DISTRICT JUDGE KK, Sharon L Williams Not Reported Deputy Clerk Court Reporter/Recorder Attorneys Present for Plaintiffs Attorneys Present for Defendants Not Present Not Present Proceedings: (IN CHAMBERS)Order re Plaintiff's and Defendants' Cross Motions for Summary Judgment(DE 43 and DE 58) I. INTRODUCTION Plaintiff T-Mobile West Corporation("Plaintiff") Is a provider of wireless telecommunications services Plaintiff alleges that Defendants the City of Huntington Beach(the city)and the City Council(collectively, "Defendants")have violated the Telecommunications Act of 1996("TCA,"or the"Act")by preventing Plaintiff from constructing two wireless communication antennas within the city limits.Before the Court is Plaintiff's and Defendants' cross Motions for Partial Summary Judgment The Court consolidates the Motions for the purpose of this Order.For the reasons stated below,the Court DENIES Defendants'Motion for Partial Summary Judgment and GRANTS Plaintiff's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment,subject to the limitations set forth in detail below II. FACTUAL BACKGROUND Although each party describes the fact from its own point of view,the Court need not verify all factual details for the purpose of this Order The following facts are alleged by both parties in their respective motions for summary Judgment(and are similar to those the Court relied on in ruling on Defendant's Motion to Dismiss and Plaintiff's Application for Preliminary Injunction) The Court need only rely on these undisputed facts: On July 24,2007,Plaintiff submitted two applications to the city seeking authorization to construct two "monopalm wireless telecommunications facilities"("antennas")within the city limits at 16600 Saybrook Lane in Harbour View Park("Harbour View")and 5741 Brighton Drive("Brighton') The City Council approved the permit applications on August 14 and September 7,2007 Since the antennas were to be located on land that belongs to the city,Plaintiff and the city negotiated and entered into two Site License Agreements for each antenna locations,according to which the city agreed to allow Plaintiff place the antennas on the City's land in return for certain contractual considerations and subject to certain contractual limitations,none of which are relevant to the issues before this Court on this Motion The parties finalized and signed the Site License Agreement on or about January 20,2009,at a publicly noticed hearing,during which the City Council unanimously approved the agreement by a vote of 7 to 0 CV-90(10/08) CIVIL MINUTES-GENFRAL Pagel of 4 Item 2. - Page 127 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 107 Filed 07/09/10 Page 2 of 4 Page ID# 3135 In addition to obtaining permits for the wireless antennas and entering into the Site License Agreements, the city required Plaintiff to obtain building construction permits for each facility("building permits").The application form for the building permits prompted Plaintiff to report"total construction value"for each site Without seeking clarification as to what comprised"total construction value"or the purpose of the inquiry, Plaintiff reported$80,000 00 on each form The city approved the building permits,and Plaintiff began construction of the Harbour View site antenna About 2 weeks after Plaintiff had started building the Harbour View site antenna, a number of local residents appeared at the construction site and objected to the project It appears that most of those citizens were concerned with the environmental effect of the antenna,especially since an elementary school is located near the Harbour View location.Eventually,the objections gave way to serious protests,and the residents physically obstructed Plaintiffs access to the construction site with their bodies and vehicles.Faced with fierce—and apparently unexpected—opposition from the residents,the city asked Plaintiff to voluntarily halt construction until the matter could be discussed with the residents at a City Council meeting Plaintiff agreed. On April 23,2009,the city held a public hearing,which Plaintiff as well as about 200 residents of the city attended During the meeting,the residents' objections grew even more intense, and the residents did not allow Plaintiff's representatives to voice their opinion Again,the parties agreed to halt the construction project to give the City Council and the residents some time to deal with the controversy The parties met on the following day This time,the city representatives asked about the total construction cost of the two antennas Plaintiff responded that each antenna would cost about$200,000 00 to build According to Plaintiff,this figure includes all construction costs for the antenna whereas the$80,000 00"total construction value"figure reported on the building permit form does not The parties dispute the difference between"total construction cost"and"total construction value,"but the difference is immaterial to the Court's decision on this Motion Once Plaintiff revealed the total construction value,the city informed Plaintiff of the existence of Measure C for the first time Measure C is codified as Section 612 of the City Charter (Yamaguchi Decl Ex A} It states in pertinent part, [No]structure costing more than$100,000 00 may be built on or in any park or beach or potion thereof unless authorized by the affirmative votes of at least a majority of the total membership of the City Council and by the affirmative vote of at least a majority of the electors voting on such proposition at a general or special election at which such proposition is submitted The city informed Plaintiff that since the total construction cost for the two antennas exceeds$100,000 00,the city was unable to authorize the construction of the antennas Instead,the city required Plaintiff to obtain voter approval before building the antennas In order for Plaintiff to satisfy the requirements of Measure C, Plaintiff must either finance a special election at costs exceeding$200,000 00 or wart until the next general election to put the construction of the two antennas up for a vote for a small fee ' On April 27,2009,the city held another City Council meeting to discuss"the status of the License Agreement with [Plaintiff]"(Yamaguchi Decl Ex G at 18 )Twenty-one residents spoke against the construction of the antenna at the Harbour View location during the public comment period of the meeting The majority of comments reflect concerns with the environmental effects of the antennas on the residents in general and the health of the children who attend the local elementary school nearby in particular At the meeting,the City Council voted—once again unanimously—to"renegotiate the existing license agreement with [Plaintiff] "Plaintiff has not been allowed to resume construction of the antennas since then. III. JUDICIAL STANDARD iThe cost of obtaining voter approval is also in dispute Plaintiff argues that in addition to the cost of putting the issue up for a vote,it has to incur significant campaign expenditures Defendants disagree.The Court need not resolve the issue for the purpose of this Order CV-90(10/08) CIVIL MINUTES-GENERAL Page 2 of 4 Item 20 a Page 128 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 107 Filed-07/09110 Page 3 of 4 Page-ID #.3136 Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56(c),summary judgment is proper only where"the pleadings,the discovery and disclosure materials on file,and any affidavits show that there is no genuine issue as to any material fact and that the [moving party]is entitled to judgment as a matter of law"Fed R Civ P 56(c) Upon such showing,the court may grant summary judgment"on all or part of the claim"Fed R-Civ P 56(a)-(b) To prevail on a summary judgment motion,the moving party must show that there are no triable issues of material fact as to matters upon which it has the burden of proof at trial See Celotex Corp v Catrett,477 U.S 317,325(1986).On issues where the moving party does not have the burden of proof at trial,the moving party is required only to show that there is an absence of evidence to support the non- moving party's case See id at 326 To defeat a summary judgment motion,the non-moving party may not merely rely on its pleadings or on conclusory statements Fed R Civ.P 56(e) Nor may the non-moving party merely attack or discredit the moving party's evidence Nat'I Union Fire Ins Co v Argonaut Ins Co,701 F 2d 95, 97(9th-Cir 1983) The non-moving party must affirmatively present specific admissible evidence sufficient to create a genuine issue of material fact for trial See Celotex Corp,477 U S.at 324 IV. DISCUSSION To the extent that Measure C frustrates congressional intent by impeding the substantive requirements of the Act,it is preempted In particular,the Act requires that local governments process an application for permit to install a wireless antenna within a"reasonable period"and explain the reasons for denial of an application"in writing"that is"supported by substantial evidence"47 U S C. §(e)(7)(B)(u)-(ni) Plaintiff submitted two applications for wireless antennas in July 2007 It has been more then three years,therefore, since Plaintiff has applied for the permits,and to this date,Plaintiff has not been given a definitive answer on whether it may or may not build the antennas Defendant argues that Plaintiff must submit the matter for the vote of the electorate and depending on the outcome,it will be given a definitive answer on its applications Yet the proposed election will not provide"substantial evidence""in writing"as to why the permits may be denied.Measure C provides that the voters shall decide whether any building that costs more than$100,000 is to be built on public land The city has made no showing,however,that the cost of the construction project has any relevance here In this light, even if the voters reject the antennas,the result of the election will not give this Court any means to determine what"substantial evidence"supports Plaintiff's decision The Court notes that the fundamental problem here is not whether the city conducts an election or not The problem is that there are no clear and relevant decision making criteria to guide award or denial of permits that would flow from the vote of the people For example,an ordinance that simply states that the City Council shall vote at on construction projects that cost more than$100,000—without any explanation as to how the project cost should have any bearing on grant or denial of permit—will not likely satisfy the "substantial evidence"requirement of the Act Therefore,because there is no showing that the result of the Measure C election can provide substantial reasons for why the permits may be denied,there is no good reasons to prolong the processing of Plaintiff's permits Of course,the city council may hold advisory elections Oust as it may conduct surveys, take polls, or receive comments)as long as the process does not impede acting on a permit application within a reasonable time or violate other substantive requirements of the Act But it would not be reasonable to delay Plaintiff's applications for much longer in this particular case Plaintiff is entitled to a decision on the permits within a reasonable time At the same time,the Court notes that the City Council did not have all the facts at the time it initially approved the permits In particular,Plaintiff did not provide the required information accurately on the forms (for example,that the projects cost as much as 200,000) The City Council was also apparently unaware of the distaste of the citizens for the antennas, especially within an elementary school And of course,the City Council was not aware that Measure C cannot be relied on as basis for its decision Therefore,while Measure CV-90(10/08) CIVIL MINUTES-GENERAL Page 3 of4 (teen 2e e Page 129 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 107 Filed 07/09/10 Page 4 of 4 Page ID #3137 C cannot be used as reason for denial of applications,the Court cannot at this time order the city to allow the construction to resume In this light,the city must be given a chance to either grant the-permits or articulate in writing the bases of denial in a way that comports with the Act This will serve two purposes First, it will allow the city to make a decision in light of new facts and developments in this case Second,it will allow this Court to evaluate the city's decision on a complete record(in case the city denies the applications),which will include the city's reasons for denial in writing V. CONCLUSION For the reasons stated above,the Court DENIES the city's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment and GRANTS Plaintiff's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment as detailed above The Court orders the city to either approve the two projects at issue within 60 days from the date this order is entered on the docket or submit its reasons for denial to the Court in writing The Court VACATES all current dates and schedules and sets a new trial date for November 9,2010 and pretrial conference for October 25,2010. Should Plaintiff refuse to accept the city's reasons for denial-ef applications(in case the city denies the applications), Plaintiff shall file its objections with the Court,inform of a second motion for summary judgment,no later than 10 court days after the day the city's decision-is submitted to the Court in writing Opposition and Reply to said motion shall be due according to the applicable local rules IT IS SO ORDERED. Initials of Preparer slw CV-90(10/08) CIVIL MINUTES-GENERAL Page 4 of 4 Item 2® o Page 130 ATTACHMENT #8 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 113 Filed 08/09/10 Page 1 of 2 Page ID #3204 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA CIVIL MINUTES-GENERAL Cs No. CV 09-03777-RGK (SSx) 'Date August 9, 2010 Tle OMNIPOINT COMMUNICATIONS,INC. v CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEA CH, et al. Present:The R GARY KLAUSNER, US DISTRICT JUDGE ,l onorable Sharon L. Williams Not Reported Deputy Clerk Court Reporter/Recorder Attorneys Present for Plaintiffs Attorneys Present for Defendants Not Present Not Present Proceedings: (IN CHAMBERS) Order re Plaintiff's Ex Parte Application for Reconsideration (DE 108) Plaintiff T-Mobile has tiled an e\ paite application, asking this Court to ieconsider its Order on Parties' cross summary Judgment motions in part In particular, T-Mobile argues that the Court erred in giving the City Council the opportunity to announce whether it intends to issue two wireless antenna permits to T-Mobile, in light of the Court's recent ruling on summary Judgment T-Mobile points to arguments made by the City to the effect that the only condition to approving the antennas was voter approval pursuant to Measure C Since this last impediment to construction of the antennas is removed by the Court's summary Judgment order, T-Mobile argues that it should be allowed to construct the antennas without any further delay The Court disagrees As the Court already stated in its summary Judgment order, there are new facts that have surfaced after the permits were approved For example, the City was unaware at the time that the antennaa cost mole than $200,000 to build, that the projects were immensely unpopular with the residents, and that the City Council cannot lawfully put the matter to vote Of course, prior to the Court's Oidei that prohibited reliance on Measure C, the City took the position that it could not allow the permits because of Measure C, even though other requirements might have been met But the City has so far not brought any authority to this Court's attention that suggests the City cannot revoke licenses after they are already issued for some valid legal reason that does not violate the Telecommunication Act. The Court must note that it does not suggest that the City may or may not lawfully deny the permits at this stage Should the permits be denied, T-Mobile will have the opportunity (as again already stated in the Court's Order) to challenge the denial of permits At that point,T-Mobile may argue, if it so CV-90(10/08) (iVILMINUTES-GENERAL Page I of2 Item 2e - Page 132 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 113 Filed 08/09/10 Page 2 of 2 Page 1D # 3205 desires, that the City isjudicially estopped from revoking the permits,or that the permit denial violates the Telecommunications Act. There is no showing, however, that T-Mobile is entitled to the reinstatement of the permits on an expedite basis.Therefore, T-Mobile's ex parte application is DENIED. IT IS SO ORDERED. Initials of Preparer slw CV-90(10/08) CIVIL MINUTES-GENERAL Page 2 of 2 Item 2. - Page 133 COMMUNICATIONS REGARDING AUGUST 30, 2010 SPECIAL MEETING AGENDA ITEM: CELL PHONE TOWERS Item 2. a Page 134 Esparza, Patty From: Flynn, Joan Sent: Wednesday, August 04, 2010 2 46 PM o: Esparza, Patty Subject: FW Cell tower at Harbor View From: lisa@vealz.com [madto:lisa@vealz.com] Sent: Wednesday, August 04, 2010 2:43 PM To: Flynn,-Joan Subject: Cell tower at Harbor View As a concerned parent I am urging you to stop the cell tower from being installed at Harbour View Elementary School. My pre-school aged children will be attending that school in the next few years. There is so much research out there stating how dangerous it is to be within 500 feet of these towers. Children being so small absorb even more of the radiation and have an even greater change of health and behavior issues. The ONLY groups that feel the towers are safe are people who wiH-make money off of the towers. Please, please do not force our neighborhood to have to send our children to private schools or to move elsewhere. There has got to be a better location for this tower- maybe a gas station, shopping center, or even a street light. Thank you so much for taking this issue so seriously._I'm sure you have seen the location of the proposed tower- it is honestly a five year olds ball throw away from where they will spend 8 hours a day for 180 days of the year. Thank you very much- Lisa Veal 3716 Montego Drive iunt►ngton Beach CA 92649 i Item 2e - Page 135 Esparza, Patty. From: Flynn, Joan Sent: Thursday,August 05, 2010 7 45 AM To: Esparza, Patty Subject: Fw call tower Joan L Flynn, CIVIC Huntington Beach City Clerk From: lvallefuoco@aol.com <Ivallefuoco@aol.com> To: Flynn,Joan Cc: CITY COUNCIL Sent: Thu Aug 05 07:42:25 2010 Subject: call tower To Whom To May Concern, I'm not able to make the meeting today but I would like to voice my opinion on the cell tower issue I know there are studies saying that a cell tower that close to developing minds in harmful and then there are studies saying that it will not affect the children My question to the council and who ever else decides the placement of the tower is Why would you take a chance on our children? Is a little extra money for the city and better phone reception worth the possibility of harming our children Im sure there is a better location than right in the middle of a school/park If you must have the tower, find a place where G large number of growing minds aren't meeting on a daily to be educated and the future of our country Thank you, Dave and Lisa Bayley Emma 4yrs old Ryan 23 months olld i Item 20 m Page 136 Esparza, Patty From: Flynn, Joan Sent: Wednesday, August 04, 2010 2 47 PM ro: Esparza, Patty Subject: FW Aug 5, 2010 City Council Meeting-Cell Towers From: larsondj@verizon.net [mailto:larsondl@verizon.net] Sent: Wednesday, August 04, 2010 11:36 AM To: Flynn,Joan Cc: CITY COUNCIL Subject: Aug 5, 2010 City Council Meeting - Cell Towers Hello Joan, I am pleased that Resolution 2010-53 has been placed on the November 2nd ballot allowing Huntington Beach citizens to vote on public park use according to our 1990 "Measure C". As you know,Measure C requires that any structure proposed for our public parks or beaches and valued at greater than$100,000 must be voted on by the citizens as well as the City Council. At issue are cell towers proposed for Harbour View Park(adjacent to Harbour View Elementary School) and Bolsa View Park which are to the north-and east of Bolsa Chica Wetlands respectively. According to the T-Mobile website's coverage page,both park locations currently have "Good" Signal Strength defined as "You will likely be able to place calls outdoor, in a car, and occasionally indoors". The signal trength definitions for "Excellent", "Very Good" and "Good" all have the same coverage definitions for outdoors and in vehicle, and degradation of coverage relates to indoors. "Excellent" indoor coverage is defined as "in most homes/many buildings(depends upon structure composition and your location within)". "Very Good" indoor coverage is defined as "in many homes/some buildings(depends upon structure composition and your location within)" _ The lowest level of coverage is "Moderate" which is defined as "You should usually be able to place calls outdoors,occasionally in a car, but only sometimes indoors". Wireless emergency 911 calls are already being covered in both park areas. The FCC's Basic 911 rules require that wireless providers "transmit all 911 calls to a Public Safety Answering Point(PSAP),regardless of whether the caller subscribes to the provider's service or not". The 'Wireless Communications and Public Safety Act of 1999'has been in effect since October 26, 1999. (http//www.fcc gov/cgb/consumerfacts/wireless911 srvc.html) AT&T's websrte coverage page currently shows the "Best" (highest)Voice Coverage levels for both park locations. Sprinfs coverage map shows "Best" signal strength for Harbour View Park and "Fair" signal strength for Bolsa View Park. Both of Sprint's signal level descriptions include "You should generally receive a signal strength sufficient to make calls outdoors". Verizon Wireless'coverage page shows solid coverage over both park areas but does not display coverage gradients. Therefore, Harbour View and Bolsa View Parks are blanketed with cell coverage by at least four wireless carriers so emergency 911 calls are not an issue I do not want cell towers in my neighborhood parks. If these cell towers are needed,please consider other locations. urge Huntington Beach citizens to vote "NO" on Resolution 2010-53 and PRESERVE OUR PARKS! Respectfully, i Item 2. - Page 137 / r e f / � 1 • � r r ' 4 '7177 tr Y I Esparza, Patty From: Stephenson, Johanna lent: Tuesday,August 24, 2010 2 45 PM o: Esparza, Patty Subject: FW Cell Tower-Public Hearing-Mon, Aug 30 Patty: Since Pat Dapkus isn't here anymore to forward these to you, I thought maybe I should. I'm at Johanna's desk this week while she is in Hawaii. Kay From: sweetsilver [mailto:sweetsilver@juno.com] Sent: Tuesday,August 24, 2010 11:16 AM To: larsondj@verizon.net Cc: CITY COUNCIL Subject: RE: Cell Tower- Public Hearing - Mon, Aug 30 Please do not allow cell tower construction based upon fraudulent or illegally acquired permits Please extend the geographical notice requirement so that more residents must be notified before a cell tower can be considered. Many thanks. Dana Drake ®bama Urges Homeowners to Refinance If you owe under$729k you probably qualify for Obama's Refi Program ,eeRefinanceRates com 1 Item 20 - Page 139 COMMUNICATIONS REGARDING AUGUST 30, 2010 SPECIAL MEETING AGENDA ITEM: CELL PHONE TOWERS Esparza, Patty From: Flynn, Joan Sent: Wednesday, August 04, 2010 2 46 PM To: Esparza, Patty Subject: FW Cell tower at Harbor View From: lisa@vealz.com [mailto.lisa@vealz.com] Sent: Wednesday, August 04, 2010 2:43 PM To: Flynn, Joan Subject: Cell tower at Harbor View As a concerned parent I am urging you to stop the cell tower from being installed at Harbour View Elementary School My pre-school aged children will be attending that school in the next few years. There is so much research out there stating how dangerous it is to be within 500 feet of these towers Children being so small absorb even more of the radiation and have an even greater change of health and behavior issues. The ONLY groups that feel the towers are safe are people who will make money off of the towers. Please, please do not force our neighborhood to have to send our children to private schools or to move elsewhere. There has got to be a better location for this tower- maybe a gas station, shopping center, or even a street light Thank you so much for taking this issue so seriously I'm sure you have seen the location of the proposed tower- it is honestly a five year olds ball throw away from where they will spend 8 hours a day for 180 days of the year Thank you very much- Lisa Veal 3716 Montego Drive Huntington Beach CA 92649 1 Esparza, Patty From: Flynn, Joan Sent: Thursday, August 05, 2010 7 45 AM To: Esparza, Patty Subject: Fw call tower Joan L Flynn, CIVIC Huntington Beach City Clerk From. Ivallefuoco@aol.com <Ivallefuoco@aol.com> To: Flynn, Joan Cc: CITY COUNCIL Sent:. Thu Aug 05 07:42.25 2010 Subject: call tower To Whom To May Concern, I'm not able to make the meeting today but I would like to voice my opinion on the cell tower issue I know there are studies saying that a cell tower that close to developing minds in harmful and then there are studies saying that it will not affect the children My question to the council and who ever else decides the placement of the tower is Why would you take a chance on our children? Is a little extra money for the city and better phone reception worth the possibility of harming our children Im sure there is a better location than right in the middle of a school/park If you must have the tower, find a place where a large number of growing minds aren't meeting on a daily to be educated and the future of our country Thank you, Dave and Lisa Bayley Emma 4yrs old Ryan 23 months olld 1 Esparza, Patty From: Flynn, Joan Sent Wednesday, August 04, 2010 2 47 PM To. Esparza, Patty Subject FW Aug 5, 2010 City Council Meeting -Cell Towers From: larsondj@venzon net [mailto.larsondl@verizon net] Sent: Wednesday, August 04, 2010 11.36 AM To: Flynn, Joan Cc: CITY COUNCIL Subject: Aug 5, 2010 City Council Meeting - Cell Towers Hello Joan, I am pleased that Resolution 2010-53 has been placed on the November 2nd ballot allowing Huntington Beach citizens to vote on public park use according to our 1990 "Measure C" As you know, Measure C requires that any structure proposed for our public parks or beaches and valued at greater than $100,000 must be voted on by the citizens as well as the City Council At issue are cell towers proposed for Harbour View Park (adjacent to Harbour View Elementary School) and Bolsa View Park which are to the north and east of Bolsa Chica Wetlands respectively According to the T-Mobile website's coverage page, both park locations currently have "Good" Signal Strength defined as "You will likely be able to place calls outdoor, in a car, and occasionally indoors" The signal strength definitions for "Excellent", "Very Good" and "Good" all have the same coverage definitions for outdoors and in vehicle, and degradation of coverage relates to indoors "Excellent" indoor coverage is defined as "in most homes/many buildings (depends upon structure composition and your location within)" "Very Good" indoor coverage is defined as "in many homes/some buildmgs(depends upon structure composition and your location within)" The lowest level of coverage is "Moderate" which is defined as "You should usually be able to place calls outdoors, occasionally in a car, but only sometimes indoors" Wireless emergency 911 calls are already being covered in both park areas The FCC's Basic 911 rules require that wireless providers "transmit all 911 calls to a Public Safety Answering Point(PSAP), regardless of whether the caller subscribes to the provider's service or not" The 'Wireless Communications and Public Safety Act of 1999'has been in effect since October 26, 1999. (http://www fcc gov/cpb/consumerfacts/wireless911 srvc html) AT&T's website coverage page currently shows the "Best" (highest) Voice Coverage levels for both park locations Sprint's coverage map shows "Best" signal strength for Harbour View Park and "Fair" signal strength for Bolsa View Park Both of Sprint's signal level descriptions include "You should generally receive a signal strength sufficient to make calls outdoors" Verizon Wireless' coverage page shows solid coverage over both park areas but does not display coverage gradients Therefore, Harbour View and Bolsa View Parks are blanketed with cell coverage by at least four wireless carriers so emergency 911 calls are not an issue I do not want cell towers in my neighborhood parks If these cell towers are needed, please consider other locations I urge Huntington Beach citizens to vote "NO" on Resolution 2010-53 and PRESERVE OUR PARKS I Respectfully, i Dianne Larson 2 ,.., �,.: _,,, r � � J � ', � .� ., . � lti � � � j ! � / � / i J i / � � !' � ' � � � � � � 1 / / � � - ( � i � � � �, � � � �: -� i � / � , , � � � / w � �' / � / , . , � , , / ' i j j J / �, i ;i / ,I `/ f � J �' ' � z � � � � � � s -� � f � � .� � � � � , � � � ./ /, i , � r i '� i � ' ,: `� �., - - - - ♦ i r Esparza, Patty From: Stephenson, Johanna Sent: Tuesday, August 24, 2010 2 45 PM To: Esparza, Patty Subject: FW Cell Tower- Public Hearing - Mon, Aug 30 Patty: Since Pat Dapkus isn't here anymore to forward these to you, I thought maybe I should. I'm at Johanna's desk this week while she is in Hawaii Kay From: sweetsdver [mailto.sweetsilver@juno.com] Sent: Tuesday, August 24, 2010 11.16 AM To: larsondj@verizon net Cc: CITY COUNCIL Subject: RE: Cell Tower - Public Hearing - Mon, Aug 30 Please do not allow cell tower construction based upon fraudulent or illegally acquired permits Please extend the geographical notice requirement so that more residents must be notified before a cell tower can be considered Many thanks Dana Drake ®bama Urges Homeowners to Refinance If you owe under$729k you probably qualify for Obama's Refi Program SeeRefinanceRates com i Huntington Beach Independent has been adjudged a newspaper of general circulation in Huntington Beach and Orange County by Decree of the Superior Court of Orange County, State of California, under date of Aug 24, 1994,case A50479 PROOF OF PUBLICATION STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ) SS. COUNTY OF ORANGE ) I am the Citizen of the United States and a resident of the County aforesaid, I am over NONCE OFPUBUCH the age of eighteen years, and not a party BEFORE THE CRY COUNCROFTHE to or interested in the below entitled matter CITY OFHUNTINOTONMACH NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that on Monday, I I am a principal clerk of the HUNTINGTON August 30,2010,at 500 p m in the City Council Chambers, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, BEACH INDEPENDENT, a newspaper of the City Council will hold a public hearing on the following planning and zoning items general circulation printed and published in ❑1 HARBOUR VIEW PARK CELL TOWER LAND USE ENTITLEMENTS the City of Huntington Beach, County of Applicant: City of Huntington Beach Request: Determine whether to affirm or reverse the Orange, State of California, and the wireless Permit and administrative approval for a wireless communications facility at Harbour attached Notice is a true and complete copy View Park Location- 16600 Saybrook Lane, 1 92649(east side of Saybrook Lane,south of Heil as was printed and published on the Avenue)Project Planner Andrew Gonzales ❑ 2 BOLSA VIEW PARK CELL TOWER LAND following date(s) USE ENTITLEMENTS Applicant City of Huntington Beach Request: Determine whether to affirm or reverse the Wireless Permit and administrative approval for a wireless communications facility at Boise View Park Location. 5641 Brighton Drive, 92649 (north side of Brighton Drive between Whitford Lane and Crestmoor Lane) Project Planner Andrew Gonzales NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that Items#1 and#2 August 19, 2010 the California Environmental Quality Actvisvons of ON FILE A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Planning and Budding Department, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public A copy of the staff report will be available to interested Parties at the City Clerk's Office on Thursday, August 19,2010 ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend or I declare, under penalty of perjury, that the evde cervfor aoor against thenvons applicationbmit as foregoing is true and correct outlined above If you challenge the City Council's action in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at, or prior to, the public hearing if there are any Executed on Au ust 19 2010 further questions please call the Planning and g Budding Department at(714)1536-5271 and refer the above items Dire at Costa Mesa, California mcations to the City Clerkct your written commu• Joan L Flynn,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach ^ 2000 Main Street,2nd Floor Huntington Beach,California 92648 (714)536-5227 iL/fZ. CtyClerkAgenda surfcty-hb org Signature Published Huntington each Independent Au- gust 19,2010 083-887 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that on Monday, August 30, 2010, at 5 00 p m in the, City Council Chambers, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, the City Council will hold a public hearing on the following planning and zoning items ❑ 1 HARBOUR VIEW PARK CELL TOWER LAND USE ENTITLEMENTS Applicant: City of Huntington Beach Request: Determine whether to affirm or revoke, pursuant to Huntington Beach Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance Section 249 06, the Wireless Permit and administrative approval for a wireless communications facility at Harbour View Park Location: 16600 Saybrook Lane, 92649 (east side of Saybrook Lane, south of Heil Avenue) Project Planner: Andrew Gonzales ❑ 2 BOLSA VIEW PARK CELL TOWER LAND USE ENTITLEMENTS Applicant: City of Huntington Beach Request: Determine whether to affirm or revoke, ,pursuant to Huntington Beach Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance Section 249 06,the Wireless Permit and administrative approval for a wireless communications facility at Bolsa View Park Location: 5641 Brighton Drive, 92649 (north side of Brighton Drive between Whitford Lane and Crestmoor Lane) Project Planner: Andrew Gonzales NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that Items #1 and #2 are categorically exempt from the provisions of the 9 Y California Environmental Quality Act ON FILE A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Planning and Building'Department, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public �- copy--of-tl`----- I-be ,available=to_mterested partiesat the-City Clerk's Office on Thursday,_August-19, 201 ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions orsubmit-evidence for or against the application as outlined above If you challenge the City Council's action in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at, or prior to, the public hearing , If there are any further questions please call the Planning and Building Department at (714) 536-5271 and refer to the above items Direct your written communications to the City Clerk Joan L Flynn, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street, 2nd Floor Huntington Beach, California 92648 (714) 536-5227 CityClerkAgenda@surf-hb org Esparza, Patty From- Gonzales, Andrew Sent: Thursday, August 19, 2010 4 10 PM To- Esparza, Patty Subject RE Cell phone staff report Pa:t : Nt The City Attorney has an outside consultant reviewing the report and making any necessary changes Oncewword from the consultant I will have the report delivered Andrew Gonzales, Associate Planner City of Huntington Beach Planning & Building Department 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Office-714 374 1547 Fax-714 374 1540 agonzales(aD-surfcity-hb ora Please consider the environment before printing this message w � - From: Esparza, Patty Sent: Thursday, August 19, 2010 4.09 PM To: Gonzales, Andrew Subject: Cell phone staff report HI Andres — Has the staff report for the above been delivered to our office yet? Thx Patty Esparza, CHIC Senior Deputy City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 714-536-5260 kw-4 please think of trees before you print 1 CITY COUNCIUREDEVELOPIVIENT AGENCY PUBLIC HEARING REQUEST SUBJECT: bDUSA Vlryy 'Pr4AV- 4 RA"_W1- Vloy-4 IOAw-14- 6am.-T0WQZ LAyAo use D'f TrT DEPARTMENT. P1..AWNI Gi A A b V l coo l h& MEETING DATE: bl aO f to CONTACT: A QRl%ly Gow-2-nL647 PHONE: (314) 344 —1947 NIA YES NO Is the notice attached? Do the Heading and Closing of Notice reflect City Council(and/or Redevelopment Agency)hearing? ( ) ( ) ( ) Are the date,day and time of the public hearing correct? If an appeal, is the appelcant's name included in the notice? If Coastal Development Permit,does the notice include appeal language? Is there an Environmental Status to be approved by Council? { ) ( ) ( ) Is a map attached for publication? Is a larger ad required? Size ( ) ( ) ()0 Is the verification statement attached indicating the source and accuracy of the mailing list? Are the applicant's name and address part of the mailing labels? Are the appellant's name and address part of the mailing labels? If Coastal Development Permit,is the Coastal Commission part of the mailing labels? If Coastal Development Permit,are the Resident labels attached? (X) ( ) ( ) Is the33343 report attached? (Economic Development Dept.items only) Please complete the following: I. Minimum days from publication to hearing date 4 2. Number of times to be published 1 3. Number of days between publications W �- NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that on Monday, August 30, 2010, at 5 00 p m in the City Council Chambers, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, the City Council will hold a public hearing on the following planning and zoning items ❑ 1 HARBOUR VIEW PARK CELL TOWER LAND USE ENTITLEMENTS Applicant: City of Huntington Beach Request: Determine whether to affirm or reverse the Wireless Permit and administrative approval for a wireless communications facility at Harbour View Park Location: 16600 Saybrook Lane, 92649 (east side of Saybrook Lane, south of Heil Avenue) Project Planner: Andrew Gonzales ❑ 2 BOL,SA VIEW PARK CELL TOWER LAND USE ENTITLEMENTS Applicant: City of Huntington Beach Request: Determine whether to affirm or reverse the Wireless Permit and administrative approval for a wireless communications facility at Bolsa View Park Location: 5641 Brighton Drive, 92649 (north side of Brighton Drive between Whitford Lane and Crestmoor Lane) Project Planner: Andrew Gonzales NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that Items#1 and#2 are categorically exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act ON FILE A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Planning and Budding Department, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public A copy 'of the staff report will be available to interested parties at the City Clerk's Office on Thursday, August 19, 2010 ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above If you challenge the City Council's action in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at, or prior to, the public hearing I If there are any further questions please call the Planning and Budding Department at (714) 536-5271 and'refer to the above items Direct your written communications to the City Clerk Joan L Flynn, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street, 2nd Floor Huntington Beach, California 92648 (714) 536-5227 CityClerkAgenda@surfcity-hb org 1301-Ge\ V ICVV PA)a-!�- 09 L9/09 L9®tiany acne algitedwoa ww L9 x ww gZ fewao;ep a#a*13 9130 1ADI 1 :u to Of'- t-H 091.9/09L9@ AjaAy gJIM algifedwoo„8/g Z x u L azis label 163-202-17 163-202-16 f Owner/Occupant Cook Gene M Petit Family Limited Partnership 17671 Amberton Ln 17661 Amberton Ln 3480 Pacific Coast Hwy I Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4802 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4802 Ventura,CA 93001-9718 163-202-15 163-202-14 163-202-13 Nyssen Michael J &Julie A Menning Mark A Megill Roby Franklin &Melody G 17681 Amberton Ln 17691 Amberton Ln 17701 Amberton Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4802 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4802 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4803 i 163-202-12 163-202-11 163-202-10 Gross Randy D/Occupant Wetlandview Trust Mcconnell Of Marquez Family Trust 17711 Amberton Ln 17721 Amberton Ln 17731 Amberton Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4803 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4803 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4803 163-202-09 ;163-203-13 '163-203-14 Yagi Wallace S Stange Daniel J/Occupant Bodul Robert J 17751 Amberton Ln 17752 Amberton Ln 17762 Amberton Ln Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4803 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4804 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4804 163-203-15 163-241-03 163-241-04 Kondo Robert K Swingle Richard A Skorheim David P&Laurie A 17772 Amberton Ln 17881 Bolton Cir 17882 Bolton Cir Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4804 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4901 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4901 163-241-02 163-241-01 163-211-OS Hazard Family Trust/Occupant Allen Michael &Cynthia Pariseau Chad &Patricia Trust 17891 Bolton Cir 17901 Bolton Cir 5622 Brighton Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4901 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4901 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4806 163-211-06 Owner/Occupant 163-211-07 Gentry April Asenath 5642 Brighton Dr Prohaska Daniel R 200 Oceangate#845 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4806 5652 Brighton Dr Long Beach,CA 90802-4352 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4806 163-211-16 163-211-17 163-214-15 Blood Thomas R Snell Robert Davis Laurence R 17811 Cardiff Cir 17821 Cardiff Cir 17822 Cardiff Cir Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4807 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4807 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4807 163-211-14 Owner/Occupant 163-211-13 Lodder Alice 17832 Cardiff Cir Kidd Everett Jackson Jr Po Box 2060 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4807 17842 Cardiff Cir Huntington Beach,CA 92647-0060 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4807 163-204-26 163-204-25 163-204-24 Moore Richard Kenneth Richards Wendy S Living Trust Losoya F&J Family Trust/Occupant 17672 Crestmoor Ln 17682 Crestmoor Ln 17692 Crestmoor Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4800 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4800 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4800 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 0516018160 Etinuette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Avery 05160/8160 0918/09l Manysane algiledwoa ww L9 x ww g Z lewJOI ap a lanbg3 PUBLIC HEARIN �.%%v liledwoo«8/9 Zx G azis lagelMAILING LABELS G Labels\Labels\Public Hearing Cannery Hamilton Properties,LLC j Chnstopher Herre,Branch Sequoia Develop ervices Inc Ascon Landfill Site c/o Tamara Zei Department of Transporh ,District 12 One Pointe Drive,Suite 320 3337 Michelson Drive mte 380 CO/ Moretta Brea,CA 92821 Irvine,CA 92612 enture,Suite 2®0 Irvine,CA 92618 Building Industry oc of South Calif Matrix ronmental 17744 Sky Park n le,Suite 170 6701 nter Drive West#900 T-Mobile/Omnipoint Communications Irvine,CA 9 4 Los Angeles,CA 90045 3 Imperial Promenade Attn.Elyse minada,Govt Affairs Asst Atm.Shawn Gauer,Senior Planner Santa Ana,CA 92707 Nossaman LLP Q2 Nossaman LLP Nossaman LLP �p John J. Flynn, 111, Esq. j Scott N.Yamaguchi, Esq. Benjamin Z Rubin, Esq. 18101 Van Karmen Ave,Suite 1800 18101 Van Karmen Ave,Suite 1800 18101 Van Karmen Ave,Suite 1800 Irvine,CA 92612-01777 Irvine,CA 92612-01777 Irvine,CA 92612-01777 Sequoia Deployment Services Inc. C/O Monica Moretta One Venture, Suite 200 Irvine,CA 92618 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 — � 0918/0919 ,Slang sane algiledwon ww L9 x ww gZ lewaol ap allanbil3 � PUBLIC HEARING N'tul v®%W#,F" giledwos„8/9 Z x«l azis lagel �o MAILING LABELS G-Labels\Labels\Pubhc Hearing Jan HB Coastal Communities Assoc 3 Huntington Valley Little League 47 HB Field Hockey* 47 David Guido Joel Groth Manilal Padluar 143 E Meats Avenue P O Box 5111 17782 Metzler Dr Orange,CA 92865 Huntington Beach,CA 92615 Hunt I ington Beach,CA 92647 Downtown Business Associ Lion 44 AYSO Region 143 47 HB Pop Warner Football** Mr Steve Damels Commissioner Phillip Hice Paul Loflm 200 Main Street#106 5552 Harold Place P.O Box 5066 Huntington Beach,CA 2648 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92615 Downtown Resid nts Association 45 Fountain Valley Pony Baseball* 47 North HB Soccer Club 47 Ms Mane St G rmain Chris Mahoney President George Mittoit 505 Alabama 21212 Shaw Lane 18601 Newland Street,#94 Huntington ach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Chairpers n 46 H B Jr.All-American Football** 47 Rob(wood Little League 47 Gabriel o/Tongva Tribal Council Randy Wooten DonalCardona PO Bo 693 P.O Box 2245 P O Box 1384 San G briel,CA 91778 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Ju eno Band of Mission Indians 46 Huntington Beach Soccer League* 4 Seaview Little League 47 gachemen Nation Felipe Zapata Brian ISemmelroth 1411 La Matanza Street 18442 Steep Lane,#3 P O Box 5305 San Juan Capistrano,CA 92675-2625 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach CA 92615 South Coast Soccer Club** 47 Ocean View Lod �e League \./ Westminster Village HOA 48 President Martin Bannon Phil Shearer,President 5200 Blackpool Road 8921 Crescent Drive 18141 Brentwell Circle Westminster, CA 92683 Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 West Co Family YMCA* 47 South HB Girls Fast Pitch Softball** 47 Gary Brown 49 Michael Turner Frank LoGrasso Coastkeepers 2100 Main Street 9432 AM Circle 3151 Airway Ave Suite -110 Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Costa Mesa,CA 9266 Regional Environmental Officer for gi ffi r r C 50 Fort Irwin 50 Fort Hunter- ett 50 Western Region Environ Office Lt Col.Paul D Cramer Mr Peter bin US Air Force Director of Public Works Nat'l.Tr Cntr Director f Public Works 333 Market Street Suite 625 P O Box 105097 Comb Support Training Center San Francisco CA 94105-2 Fort Irwin CA 92310 B790 St P s RFTA Dublin CA 945680 Sheila Donovan 50 Patrick Chris ctor 50 Gold Coast Extreme Community P s&Liaison Coordinator Westem Regi nvrronmentai Office Rick Bauer-President `Vf US Navy US Marine rps Building 1164 205011 Surburbia Lane 1220 Pac c Highway Box 55 6 Huntington Beach,CA 92646 San o CA 92132-5190 C Pendleton CA 92055-5246 South Coast Bayern Futbol Club 4 California Futbol Club 47 District 62 Challenger Division 47 Marisa Pena Hector Aguilar Gail Harder 22222 Eucalyptus Lane 10571 Davitaur 17961I Scotia Circle Lake Forest,CA 92630 Garden Grove,CA 92843 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 r Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 PUBLIC H£JA jP1 fiaan cane a iledwoo ww Lg x WillgZ lewaof ap aaa*13 MAILING LABELS G iabets\Labels\Public Hean a 4�� 9 a"�qi}edw0o«8/g Z x«1 aZIS label California Coastal Commission 25 Clark Hampton Sally Graham 39 Theresa Henry Westminster School District ! Meadowlark Area South Coast Area Office 14121 Cedarwood Avenue 5161 Gelding Circle 200 Oceangate, 10th Floor Westminster CA 92683 Huntington Beach,CA 92649 Long Beach,CA 92802-430 California Coastal Co scion 25 Stephen Ritter Cheryle Browning 39 South Coast Area O ce HB Union High School Disnct Meadowlark Area 200 Oceangate,10 Floor 5832 Bolsa Avenue 16771 Roosevelt Lane Long Beach,CA 2802-4302 Huntington Beach,CA 92649 Huntington Beach,CA 9264 Chris Herre 26 ® 7 Hearthside Homes 40 Caltrans D trict 12 6 Executive Circle,Suet 250 3337 Mi elson Drive,Suite 380 Irvine,CA 92614 Irvine, A 92612-1699 Di r ctor 27 Goldenwest College 35 Bolsa Chica Land rust 41 al Solid Waste Enf Agy Attu Fred Owens 5200'IWarner Av nue,Ste 108 C Health Care Agency 15744 Goldenwest St Huntington Be ,CA 92649 O Box 355 Huntington Beach CA 92647 Santa Ana,CA 92702 New Growth Coordinator 28 OC County Harbors,Be 36 Bolsa Chic Land Trust 41 Huntington Beach Post Office and Parks Dept Evani Hen ,President 6771 Warner Ave P.O Box 4048 1812 Port iffin Place Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Santa Ana,CA 92702 048 Newport each,CA 92660 Marc Ecker l 2 Bella Terra Mall 37 Fountain Valley Elem School Dist Atm Pat Rogers- ude 10055 Slater Avenue 7777 Edinger Av #300 Fountain Valley CA 92708 Huntington Bea CA 92647 Dr_Gary Rutherford,Super 0 Country View states HOA 38 OC uutation District 42 HB City Elementary School Dist Carrie Thom 108 Ellis Avenue 20451 Cratmer Lane 6642 Trotter nve Fo tain Valley CA 92708 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington each CA 92648 David Perry \30J Country new Estates HOA 38 Pendegraft,Plant Manager 42 HB City Elementary School Dist v Gerald hapman Huntington Beach,LLC 20451 Crauner Lane 6742 S re Circle 21 30 Newland Street Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Hun on Beach CA 92648 H tnngton Beach CA 92646 Richard Loy 42 H gton Beach Girls Softball* 47 A SO Region 56 47 9062 Kahuhu Drive Erickson mnusstoner John Gray Huntington Beach CA 646 P. Box 3943 9 ZZISmokey Carcle H tmgton Beach,CA 92605-3943 H tington Beach,CA 92646 1 2 R 47 SO Re on 55 47 John Ely 4 YSO Region 117 gn 22102 ckport Lane ohn Almanza ssioner Russ Marlow Hun gton Beach CA 92646 9961 Bushard St tyni 11 Brentwell Circle Fountain Valley,CA 92708 ington Beach,CA 92647 0 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible aver Avery 05160/8160 fulA aaAe a 1 edwoa ww L9 x ww gZ;ewaol ap allentiq bol p view MAILING LABELS G Labels\Labe][APub t Hearing Jan ® 4qIIudwoo«8/5 Z x,,j.azis lagel wP'D'4—Off{l . . President 1 Huntington Harbor POA 10 j Sue Johnson 16 H B Chamber of Commerce P O Box 791 19671 Quiet Bay Lane 19891 Beach Blvd,Ste 140 j I Sunset Beach,CA 90742 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Dave Stefatudes 2 Kirsten Berg 13 Orange County Assoc of Realtors 18870 Kithira Circle 25552 La Paz Road j Hunington B)ea CA 92648 Laguna Hills,CA 92653 � 90//I President 3 Jeffrey M Oderman 12 Pa c Coast Archaeological 18 Amigos De Bolsa Cluca RUTAN&TUCKER,LLP ety,Inc P O Box 1563 611 Anton Blvd,1411,Floor O Box 10926 Huntington Beach CA 92647 Costa Mesa CA 92626-1950 Costa Mesa,CA 92627 Atta 'Jane Gothold Sunset Beach Community Assoc 4 Pres,H B His Society 13 Director 19 Pat Thies,President j C/O Newland House Museum O_C Ping&Dev Services Dept. PO Box 215 19820 Beach Blvd P O Box 4048 Sunset Beach,CA 90742-0215 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 SantajAna,CA 92702-4048 President 5 Barbara Haynes 14 Bryan Speegle 19 Huntington Beach Tomorrow Historic Resources B and Chair O C(Resources&Develop Mgt Dept PO Box 865 19341 Worchester ane P.O (Box 4048 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Bea ,CA 92646 Santa IAna,CA 92702-4048 Julie Vandermost 6 Council o Aging 15 Planning Director 20 131A-OC 1706 O ge Ave City of Costa Mesa 17744 Sky Park Circle,#170 Hun gton Beach,CA 92648 P O ,Box 1200 Irvine CA 92614-4441 Costa Mesa,CA 92628-1200 Richard Spicer 7 Jeff Metzel 16 Planning Director 21 SCAG Seachff HOA City of Fountain Valley 818 West 7th, 12th Floor 19391 Shady Harbor Circle 10200 Slater Ave Los Angeles,CA 90017 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Fountain Valley,CA 92708 Jean Knnbrell 8 John Roe 16 Planning Director 22 c/o E T.l Corral 100 Seachff HOA City of Newport Beach 20292 Eastwood Cir 19382 Surfdale Lane P O Box 1768 Huntington Beach,CA 9 6 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Newport Beach,CA 92663-8915 Robert Smith 9 Lou Mannone 16 Planning Director 23 Environmental and Chair Seachff HOA City of Westminster 21352 Yarmo Lane 19821 Ocean Bluff Circle 8200 Westminster Blvd. Huntington each,CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92648 Westminster,CA 92683 P1 Director 24 Ocean View School District 38 HB Hampton HOA 38 City Seal Beach Attu Cindy Pulfer,Admm Services Progressive Community Mgmt. 211 ghth St 17200 Pmehurst Lane 27405 Puerta Real,#300 Se Beach,CA 90740 Huntington Beach CA 92647 Mission Viejo,CA 92691 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible With Avery05160/8160 j biauette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 09L8/0915®IWAV oane elggPdwoo ww L9 x ww 9Z teuuof ep a4anb►t3 0919/0914@)tiaAy q}►m alggedwoo„9/g Z x,,f az►s lapel 163-215-01 163-214-04 163-214-03 Fusca Robert J Tymchak W A&L Living 2010 Trust ! Lockard Lawrence M 5712 Woodboro Dr 5721 Woodboro Dr 5731 Woodboro Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4950 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4949 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4949 163-212-06 Lambert Edward J&Louise H/Occupant 17872 Shoreham Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4838 j I ,I i I --3o label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 65160/8160 ® Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 09I 8/0919®tiany cane algiiedu,os u,ua Lg x uaua 5z Jeu,aoJ ap attanbg3 091.8/0919®tiany q}im algifedwos„g/g Z x u G azis lagei 163-015-03 163-013-28 163-015-04 lida William A Jr& Karen Sue Soto Michael S Cole Herbert A&Barbara 5792 Termer Dr 5811 Terrier Dr 5812 Termer Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4944 ! Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4945 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4946 163-013-27 '163-015-05 163-013-26 Nelson Gregory P Baker George R&Karen Lillard David M &Rachel 5821 Terrier Dr 5822 Terrier Dr 5831 Termer Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4945 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4946 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4945 I 163-015-06 �'163-213-02 163-212-15 Lawton Harvey P lii Wuerfel Timothy Dale Jr Sato Kathryn K 5832 Terrier Dr 17812 Whitford Ln 17932 Portside Cir Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4946 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4847 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4931 Owner/Occupant -163-213-03 163-212-14 17821 Whitford Ln Zamora Nick&Bonnie Tracy Norman C&Margaret B Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4846 17822 Whitford Ln 17831 Whitford Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4847 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4846 163-212-13 -163-213-04 -163-212-12 Mullin Stephen James Cadden Edward F&Terry L Alexanian James K&Sandra L 17841 Whitford Ln 17842 Whitford Ln 17152 Frimi Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4846 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4847 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4511 Owner/Occupant -163-213-05 163-212-11 17851 Whitford Ln Schilling Michael C&Sandra Mc Croiry Mary M Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4846 17852 Whitford Ln 17861 Whitford Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4864 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4846 163-212-10 163-212-09 163-212-08 Dugan Kevin J &Carrol/Occupant Beam David R&Peggy M Keenan Family Trust 17871 Whitford Ln 17881 Whitford Ln 17891 Whitford Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4846 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4846 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4846 163-231-08 163-204-02 163-204-03 Doering William L Carlton Family Trust Hertz Lisa Trust 17901 Whitford Ln 5642 Windcroft Dr 5652 Windcroft Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4851 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4857 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4857 163-204-04 163-204-05 163-204-06 Jaspers Stephanie J Bradford Steven&Jayne Ter-kasarian Katchair John 5662 Windcroft Dr 5672 Windcroft Dr 5682 Windcroft Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4857 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4857 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4857 163-204-07 163-204-08 163-214-05 Summer Sieglinde MMarengo Paul B lsti Michel &Pedouth Alhsonl Family Living Trust 5692 Windcroft Dr 5702 Windcroft Dr 5711 Woodboro Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4857 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4857 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4949 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 ® Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 09 L8/09I•g®Many aane algqedwoo ww L9 x ww 9Z VU01 ap auo*13 O— 0 ��V 09 L8/09 L5®tiany glim algqedwoo«8/9 Z x,,L ezis loge) G 1 163-222-20 163-222-19 ( 163-222-18 Newfield Deflons C March Howard S GremeI Robert F&Wendy S 5591 Selkirk Dr 5611 Selkirk Dr 5621 Selkirk Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4830 ' Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4831 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4831 '`163-211-08 `163-212-01 163-211-09 Kinnison Mel A Jr Minard Donald E/Occupant i Bethards Robert&Diane A 17811 Shoreham Ln 17822 Shoreham Ln 17831 Shoreham Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4837 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4838 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4837 '-163-212-02 ''163-211-10 -163-212-03 Obert Donald W Dudley Philip S Johnson Byron Lee 17832 Shoreham Ln 17841 Shoreham Ln 17842 Shoreham Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4838 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4837 ! Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4838 163-211-11 163-212-04 163-211-12 Rasmussen William D Kuyper Truce M i Gauldiri Daniel J &Susan M 17851 Shoreham Ln 17852 Shoreham Ln 17861 Shoreham Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4837 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4838 i Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4837 I 163-212-05 163-212-07 163-231-07 Doke Gregory& Mary Haas William H Dolton Terry A 17862 Shoreham Ln 17882 Shoreham Ln 17892 Shoreham Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4838 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4838 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4838 163-204-18 163-204-19- -163-204-17 Johnson Jeffery L& Kerry E Westergard Chris Waddell Bob R 17672 Stanfield Cir 17681 Stanfield Cir 17682 Stanfield Cir Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4861 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4862 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4861 163-204-20 -163-204-16 163-204-21 Silva Francis Eugene Kan Ming Min &Sue Yuan Kriha Michael T&Mary Jane 17691 Stanfield Cir 17692 Stanfield Cir 17701 Stanfield Cir Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4862 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4861 i Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4862 163-204-15 163-204-22 163-204-14 Ando Linda K Mc Mackin Robert Strout Michael D&Kambra 17702 Stanfield Cir 17771 Stanfield Cir 17712 Stanfield Cir Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4861 Huntington Beach Ca 92,92649 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4861 163-013-31 163-015-01 163-013-30 Lillard Michael D& Diane C HJalmer John F& Mary K Beer Karol K 5771 Terrier Dr 5772 Terrier Dr Po Box 1359 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4943 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4944 Yucca Valley,CA 92286-1359 Owner/Occupant 163-015-02 163-013-29 5781 Terrier Dr Dolan Scott F Smole Anthony BAmole Margot Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4943 5782 Terrier Dr 5791 Terrier Dr Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4944 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4943 label size 1"x 2 5J8"compatible with Avery 5160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 C � `7"�// 09 L8/09 L5@ fueAV aaAe alg4edwoa ww L9 x ww 9Z lewaol ap attanbi13 ,/O © 09G8/09L9®AGaAy glim elgiledwoo„8/5 Z x«L ozis loge) so 3 Owner/Occupant 163-013-05 163-0i1-06 5821 Pinon Dr BonnettJene R&Kim May Torres'Ernie Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4927 5822 Pinon Dr 5831 Pinon Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4928 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4927 163-013-06 163-172-31 (Owner/Occupant Hayward Daryll Frank&Yvonne Renee Brandvold Anne 5771 Raphael Dr 5832 Pinon Dr 16835 Algonquin St#214 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4935 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4928 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3810 I 163-173-01 Owner/Occupant 1 163-172-30 Luyks Leo John 5772 Raphael Dr Powell,Christina A/Occupant 6522 Montoya Cir Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4936 5781 Raphael Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92647-6633 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4935 163-173-02 163-172-29 163-173-03 Coffee Arthur G Pollard Larry Richard Jr&Chiun Judy I Riola Michael &Toni Jo 5782 Raphael Dr 5791 Raphael Dr 5792 Raphael Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4936 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4935 j Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4936 I 163-172-28 163-173-04 Owner/Occupant Shirran Marie Louise Vollmger David J 5812 Raphael Dr 5811 Raphael Dr 44379 Royal Lytham Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4938 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4937 Indio,CA 92201-2789 163-173-05 163-173-06 163-184-06 Hill Adam Lawrence&Crista Kathleen Dingwall Robert E Suzuki Ronald M 5822 Raphael Dr 5832 Raphael Dr 5602 Ridgebury Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4938 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4938 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4828 163-184-07 163-184-08 Owner/Occupant Self Jeffrey V& Bonnie L Williams Michael T 5622 Ridgebury Dr 5612 Ridgebury Dr 20932 Shellfish Ln ! Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4828 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4828 Huntington Beach,CA 92648-5260 163-222-27 163-222-26 163-222-25 Unbedacht Ronald W Nguyen John P&Lily H Flaherty James R 5521 Selkirk Dr 5531 Selkirk Dr 4362 E Ludlow Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4830 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4830 Phoenix,AZ 85032-5803 Owner/Occupant 163-222-24 163-222-23 5541 Selkirk Dr Williams Family Trust Kohatsu Mitsugu Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4830 5551 Selkirk Dr 3 Shadduck Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4830 Irvine,CA 92620-3226 Owner/Occupant 163-222-22 163-222-21 5561 Selkirk Dr Ferguson Stephen P&Tanya K Logginsi Philip C&Kimberly A Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4830 5571 Selkirk Dr 5581 Selkirk Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4830 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4830 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 em Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 — 09 G8/0q l.96 MaAV oaAe a1giledwo3 ww L9 x ww c,Z tewiol_ap eRenbil3 o —/U 0%8/09G5®faeAV giim 9lg4edwo3„8/5 Z x,,[azis lagel t3 163-012-07 163-012-08 / 163-012-09 Pagter Steven S&Paige L Kibler Patrick K White Richard Raleigh&Barbara 17791 Misty Ln 17801 Misty Ln Schwitz Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4915 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4916 17811 Misty Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4916 -163-012-10 163-214-01 Owner/Occupant Andersen Jerry A Stuart Douglas T 5722 Padua Dr 17821 Misty Ln Po Box 1773 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4920 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4916 Carlisle, PA 17013-2896 -163-214-02 -163-016-01 163-016-02 Vodovoz Erwin Weaver Charles F&Laurel L Calvert�Thomas M 5732 Padua Dr 5742 Padua Dr 1423 Evening Shade Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4920 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4920 Prescott,AZ 86305-6432 Owner/Occupant 163-016-03 163-015-31 5752 Padua Dr Richter Robert C Riddle Charles H &Eva R Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4920 5762 Padua Dr 5771 Padua Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4920 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4919 163-016-04 163-015-30 163-016-05 Stephenson Edward B Glenwright Tristan E& Dianne S Walsh Brian D 5772 Padua Dr 5781 Padua Dr 5782 Padua Dr Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4920 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4919 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4920 -163-015-29 -163-016-06 "163-015-28 Wolf Kenneth R& Kimberly B Puffpaff Louis R&Mane Reading Roger D Trust 5791 Padua Dr 5792 Padua Dr 5811 Padua Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4919 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4920 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4921 163-015-27 163-011-01 163-013-01 Carnes Family Trust Gibbs Michael&Tracy Toppen Sandy&Michael 5821 Padua Dr 5771 Pinon Dr 5772 Pinon Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4921 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4925 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4926 163-011-02 163-013-02 163-011-03 Brittain Dune H Perreault J A Vandiver Ronald E&Lore G 5781 Pinon Dr 5782 Pinon Dr 5791 Pinon Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4925 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4926 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4925 163-013-03 Owner/Occupant 163-01111-04 Borren Stanley E 5792 Pinon Dr Bozich iWilliam Frank Po Box 1345 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4926 3558 Windspun Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92647-1345 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2025 Owner/Occupant 163-013-04 163-0111-05 5811 Pinon Dr Walker Peter E Ballestracci Harry&Joseph Jr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4927 5812 Pinon Dr 535 Avenida Buenos Aires Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4928 San Clemente,CA 92672-2464 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 — / 091.8/091.9®NaAy aaAe algitedwoo ww Lg x ww 5Z}ewao}ap a8anbrf3 091.8/0915®Nagy gfim alg1jedwoo„8/9 Z x„l_azis lapel 163-222-04 Owner/Occupant ! 163-222-05 Summer Sieglmde M 5512 Maryport Dr Quach Hung 5692 Wmdcroft Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4821 4613 Dlubonnet Ave Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4857 Rosemead,CA 91770-1284 Owner/Occupant 163-222-06 163-222-07 5522 Maryport Dr Nelson Dennis W Gotz William C&Kathleen R Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4821 5532 Maryport Dr 5542 Maryport Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4821 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4821 163-222-08 163-222-09 163-222-10 Conrad Neil A Gill Louis E Liggan Stuart M 5552 Maryport Dr 5562 Maryport Dr 5572 Maryport Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4821 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4821 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4821 163-222-11 163-222-12 163-222-13 Tolton Clarke Smith Brodmann Garry&Jenifer Cobos Robert 5582 Maryport Dr 5592 Maryport Dr 5602 Maryport Dr Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4821 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4821 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4822 163-222-14 163-222-15 163-222-16 Barr Randall H & Linde A Rasmussen Casey APing Candyce R Ervin Kathleen A 5612 Maryport Dr 5622 Maryport Dr 5632 Maryport Dr Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4822 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4822 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4822 163-171-02 Owner/Occupant 163-171-03 Meeks William Dewane 17651 Misty Ln Lan Le6Kofei&Chin-chih C 47985 Twin Pines Rd Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4913 2129 Mendocino St Banning,CA 92220-9676 Fullerton, CA 92831-1237 Owner/Occupant 163-171-04 163-171-05 17661 Misty Ln Deangelis Riccardo&Adrienne Owen Russell James It Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4913 17681 Misty Ln 17691 Misty Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4913 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4913 163-171-06 163-171-07 163-012-01 Rosen Greg L& Kirsten N Henson Vincent&Andrea Dang Richard 17701 Misty Ln 17711 Misty Ln 17721 Misty Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4915 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4915 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4915 163-012-02 Owner/Occupant 163-012-03 Susman Stan J 17731 Misty Ln Smith Jason 1882 Parkcrest Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4915 17741 Misty Ln Costa Mesa,CA 92627-4533 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4915 163-012-04 163-012-05 163-012-06 Larthrope Jerry& Daren Bradley William M Le Doux Linda 17751 Misty Ln 17761 Misty Ln 17771 Misty Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4915 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4915 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4915 I label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 L// 0918/09 G9®tiany 3em algitedwoo ww L9 x ww 5Z}ewaol ap Manbi}3 09L8/09G9®IGanV gjfm alggiadwoo u8/5 Z x,,G azis lagel 163-202-19 Owner/Occupant 1 163-203-03 Nelson Terry D Nelson Family 5591 Helmside Dr I ' I Smith Robert T&Margaret 6921 Derby Cir Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4815 ! 5592 Helmside Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92648-1564 ' Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4816 I 163-202-20 163-203-02 , 163-202-21 Wyrick Paul R&Cheryl R 11 Gallego Lennis L/Occupant Nagel Paul A 5601 Helmside Dr 5602 Helmside Dr ' 5611 Helmside Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4817 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4818 ! Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4817 163-203-01 Owner/Occupant 163-205-27 Marchese Frank P 5612 Helmside Dr ' Arnall Derek WHungerford Joan K 6312 E 5th St Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4818 5642 Larkmont Dr Long Beach, CA 90803-2112 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4863 163-205-26 163-205-25 163-205-24 Sanghvi Sarjula M SurvivorsSurvivors Hertz Steven C&Karen S Hicks Family Trust 5652 Larkmont Dr 5662 Larkmont Dr i 5672 Larkmont Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4863 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4863 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4863 163-205-23 Owner/Occupant 163-205-22 Horio Yoshiko S 5682 Larkmont Dr Doumanian Gregory&Carrie 9552 Henderson Way Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4863 5692 Larkmont Dr Villa Park,CA 92861-2826 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4863 163-205-21 163-205-20 163-205-19 Idnarn Naresh J & 1 Y Trust Oborny Debra B/Occupant Alvarez Mary Ann 5702 Larkmont Dr 5712 Larkmont Dr 5722 Larkmont Dr Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4863 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4863 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4863 163-205-18 163-172-01 163-172-02 Sylla Werner Molden Mark R&Patricia L Gillespie Christine 5732 Larkmont Dr 5772 Lourdes Dr 5782 Lourdes Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4863 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4906 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4906 163-203-12 163-203-05 163-203-11 Laughlin K S Living Trust Jackson Gordon S Woody David F 5572 Ludlow Cir 5581 Ludlow Cir 5582 Ludlow Cir i Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4819 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4819 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4819 163-203-06 163-203-10 163-203-07 Grafton John C Pearson Donald D Metzel Robert JDowens Denise Patricia 5591 Ludlow Cir 5592 Ludlow Cir 5601 Ludlow Cir Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4819 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4819 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4819 163-203-09 163-203-08 163-222-03 Oppenheim Jay Pluznick Victor L Dereszynski Michael F/Occupant 5602 Ludlow Cir 5611 Ludlow Cir 5502 Maryport Dr Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4819 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-4819 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4821 I label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 65160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec AveN 05160/8160 09t8/09t9®Many sane algitedwoo will L9 x Will 9Z}ew101 ap 0:40nbit3 Ar/3 //js 0%q/09 t5®[u9Ay gm algitedwoo,,8/9 Z x.,t azis lagel 163-204-23 163-203-19 163-203-18 Herman Eugene HermanFamily Trust j Pollard Thomas j Smith-ward Elizabeth M 17702 Crestmoor Ln 17761 Crestmoor Ln 17771 Crestmoor Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4809 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4808 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4808 I 163-211-04 163-203-17 163-211-03 Anderson Grace Lois Kenyon Richard R ; Jones Bobbie L 17772 Crestmoor Ln 17781 Crestmoor Ln 17782 Crestmoor Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4809 j Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4808 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4809 I 163-203-16 i_Owner/Occupant 163-211-02 Jeliick Trust 17791 Crestmoor Ln Banaag Antonio V 19691 Elmcrest Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4808 6222 Pacemont Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92646-3100 Huntington Beach,CA 92648-1089 17792 Crestmoor Ln 163-211-01 163-202-05 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4809 Burge George Robert Jr Cianciabella Henry 17802 Crestmoor Ln 17702 Falkirk Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4855 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4813 163-202-06 163-202-07 163-202-08 Di Luzio Fred &Ann Turner Thomas W&Shirly D Vasina Pavel A 17712 Falkirk Ln 17722 Falkirk Ln 17742 Falkirk Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4813 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4813 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4813 163-205-11 '163-205-12 Owner/,Occupant Dawson Mary R Rylander Kimberly L 17662 Helenbrook Ln 17652 Helenbrook Ln 24232 Creekside Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4859 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4859 Newhall, CA 91321-3943 163-204-09 163-205-13 163-204-10 Foglesong Curtis L Hsu lames Yao-jen Goldman Steve &Catherine 17671 Helenbrook Ln 17672 Helenbrook Ln 17681 Helenbrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4860 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4859 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4860 163-205-14 163-204-11 163-205-15 Mullens Family Trust Pritchard Robert W& Nancy R Robertson Dennis&Tani 17682 Helenbrook Ln 17691 Helenbrook Ln 17692 Helenbrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4859 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4860 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4859 163-204-12 163-205-16 163-204-13 Salz Andrew Living Trust Cahill Richard & Kris Marie Halverson Dale H Jr&Christine B 17701 Helenbrook Ln 17702 Helenbrook Ln 17711 Helenbrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4860 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4859 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4860 163-205-17 163-202-18 163-203-04 Small Donald W Briggs Armond 1 Wojcik John Bill 17712 Helenbrook Ln 5581 Helmside Dr 5582 Helmside Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4859 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4815 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-4816 I label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery°5160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 -rtitit-II iV—LJIY2_ _Y( olgqudwoa ww L9 x ww qZ}euuo}ap attanbgi W to pq— O Lf�L- 09t9/09190 AJaAtf QA olggsdwo3 u9/9 Z x.,t ez!s label Harbour Lights 178-630-02 178-630-02 2600 Nutwood Ave#10 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Fullerton,CA 92831-3145 16701 Algonquin St Unit 302 1670f Algonquin St Unit 303 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3351 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3351 i i 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16701 Algonquin St Unit 304 16701 Algonquin St Unit 305 16701IAlgonquin St Unit 306 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3351 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3351 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3351 _ 1 � 178-630-02 178-630-02 i 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16701 Algonquin St Unit 307 16701 Algonquin St Unit 308 167011AIgonquin St Unit 309 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3351 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3351 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3351 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16701 Algonquin St Unit 310 16701 Algonquin St Unit 311 16701 Algonquin St Unit 312 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3351 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3351 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3351 I 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner Occupant 16701 Algonquin St Unit 314 16701 Algonquin St Unit 315 16701'iAlgonquin St Unit 316 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3351 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3351 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3351 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16701 Algonquin St Unit 317 16701 Algonquin St Unit 318 16701 Algonquin St Unit 319 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3351 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3351 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-33S1 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner�Occupant 16701 Algonquin St Unit 320 16701 Algonquin St Unit 101 16701 Algonquin St Unit 102 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3351 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16701 Algonquin St Unit 103 16701 Algonquin St Unit 104 16701 'Algonquin St Unit 105 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16701 Algonquin St Unit 106 16701 Algonquin St Unit 107 16701 Algonquin St Unit 108 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16701 Algonquin St Unit 109 16701 Algonquin St Unit 110 16701 Algonquin St Unit 111 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 GM Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery05160/8160 �� 0918/09! A.19AVvaane algiledwoa Will L9 x Will 5Z iemof ap apa*13 BLIC HEARING N�1Vb'®��► i1udwoa„8/5 Z x I.azis lagel O MAILING LABELS G Labels\Labels\Public Hearing Jaa CanneryHamilton Pro rnes, LC Chr istopherrre Branch of Pe Sequoia Deployment Services Inc. Ascon Landfill Site c/o T ara Zeier DeTranspo on,Distract 12 C/O Monica Morena One Pointe Drive,Slut 20 333 D ,Suite 380Brea,CA 92821 Iry One Venture,Suite 200 Irvine,CA 92618 Buildmg I stry Assoc of South Calif Maental17744 Park Circle,Suite 170 670ve West#900 T-Mobile/Omnipoint Communications Irvin ,CA 92614 Los Angeles,CA 90045 3 Imperial Promenade Attn.Elyse Sminada,Govt Affairs Asst Attu Shawn Gauer,Senior Planner Santa Ana,CA 92707 Nossaman LLP 110 Nossaman LLP Nossaman LLP John J. Flynn,III, Esq. Scott N.Yamaguchi, Esq Benjamin Z.Rubin,Esq. 18101 Van Karmen Ave,Suite 1800 18101 Van Karmen Ave,Suite 1800 18101 Van Karmen Ave,Suite 1800 Irvine,CA 92612-01777 Irvine,CA 92612-01777 Irvine,CA 92612-01777 I , I li label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 09 t8/0914®tiany oanu algiledwoo ww L9 x ww 5Z luwio;ep allanbil3 p��0 �� PUBLIC HEARING NCO&� N411Ltlw03«8/9 Z x«1 azis lapel (J MAILING LABELS G Labels\Labels\Pubhc Hearing Janu I HB Coastal Communities Assoc 431 Huntington Valley Little League 47 HB Field Hockey* 47 David Guido Joel Groth Mandal Padluar 143 E Meats Avenue P O Box 5111 17782 Metzler Dr Orange,CA 92865 Huntington Beach,CA 92615 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Downtown Business Associatio 44 AYSO Region 143 47 HB Pop Warner Football** 47 Mr Steve Daniels Commissioner Phillip Rice Paul Lo&n 200 Main Street#106 5552 Harold Place P O.Box 5066 Huntington Beach,CA 92 8 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92615 Downtown Residers Association 45 Fountain Valley Pony Baseball* 47 North HB Soccer Club 47 Ms Mane St.Ge Chris Mahoney President George Mitton 505 Alabama 21212 Shaw Lane 18601 Newland Street,#94 Huntington Bea ,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Chairperso 46 H B Jr All-American Football** 47 Robinwood Little League 47 Gabrielen /Tongva Tribal Council Randy Wooten Dona Cardona PO Box 93 P.O Box 2245 P O Box 1384 San Ga riel,CA 91778 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Ju eno Band of Mission Indians 46 Huntington Beach Soccer League* 47 Seaview Little League A lachemen Nation Felipe Zapata Brian Semnmelroth 411 La Matanza Street 18442 Steep Lane,#3 P O Box 5305 San Juan Capistrano,CA 92675-2625 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach CA 92615 South Coast Soccer Club** 47 Ocean View Little League 47 Westminster Village HOA 48 President Martin Bannon Phil Shearer,President 5200 Blackpool Road i 8921 Crescent Drive 18141 Brentwell Circle Westminster, CA Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 West Co Family YMCA* 47 South HB Girls Fast Pitch Softball** 47 Gary Brown 49 Michael Turner Frank LoGrasso Coastkeepers 2100 Main Street 9432 Alu Circle 3151 Airway Ave Suite F-110 Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Costa Mesa,CA 92663 Regional Environmental Officer for Calif 50 Fort Irwin 5 Fort Hunter-Liggett 50 Western Region Environ Office Lt Col.Paul D Cramer Mr Peter Rubin US Air Force Director of Public Works Nat'l T Cntr Director of Public 333 Market Street Suite 625 P O Box 105097 Combat Su raining Center San Francisco CA 94105- 6 Fort Irwin CA 92310 B790 5 t Parks RFrA Dublin CA %80 Sheila Donovan 50 Patrick Chris Director 50 Gold Coast Extreme 47 Commumty s&Lawson Coordinator Wester on Environmental Office Rick Bauer-President US Na US M e Corps Building 1164 20501 Surburbma Lane 1220 acific Highway Bo 55246 Huntington Beach,CA 92646 S Diego CA 92132-5190 amp Pendleton CA 92055-5246 South Coast Bayern Futbol Club �4 California Futbol Club 47 District 62 Challenger Division 47 Manssa Pena Hector Aguilar Gail Harder 22222 Eucalyptus Lane 10571 Davmtaur 17961 Scotia Circle Lake Forest,CA 92630 Garden Grove,CA 92843 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 0516018160 biauette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 Puscic AG1 1 aA acne a iladwoo uw L9 x wu gZ 1pulol ap ap anbq nW �iledwoo«8/9 Z x,,L azis labelMAILING LABELS G Labels\Labels\Public Heanngja California Coastal Commission 25 i Clark Hampton 32 Sally Graham 39 Theresa Henry Westminster School District Meadowlark Area South Coast Area Office 1 14121 Cedarwood Avenue 5161 Gelding Circle 200 Oceangate,loth Floor Westminster CA 92683 Huntington Beach,CA 92649 Long Beach,CA 92802-4302 California Coastal Co Sion 25 Stephen Ritter 33 Cheryle Browning 9 South Coast Area Offi HB Union High School Disnct Meadowlark Area 200 Oceangate,loth oor 5832 Bolsa Avenue j 16771 Roosevelt Lane Long Beach,CA 9 02-4302 Huntington Beach,CA 92649 Huntington Beach,CA 92649 II Chris Herre 26 G Hearthside Homes 40 Caltraiis ct 12 6 Executive Circle,Suite 250 3337 Mic lson Drive,Suite 380 ��� �Q Irvine,CA 92614 Irvine, 92612-1699 Di ctor 27 i Goldenwest College V Bolsa Chica Land Trust 41 cal Solid Waste Enf Agy Attu Fred Owens 5200 Warner Avenue, 108 C Health Care Agency 15744 Goldenwest St Huntington Beach,C 92649 P O Box 355 Huntington Beach CA 92647 Santa Ana,CA 92702 New Growth Coordinator 28 OC County Harbors,Beach O Bolsa Cluca Land rust 41 Huntington Beach Post Office and Parks Dept Evan Henry,Pr tdent 6771 Warner Ave P O_ Box 4048 1812 Port Ti Place Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Santa Ana,CA 92702-4048 Newport Beac ,CA 92660 Marc Ecker 29 Bella Terra Mall 37 Fountain Valley Elem School Dist Attn Pat Rogers-Laude 10055 Slater Avenue 7777 Edinger Ave # Fountain Valley CA 92708 Huntington CA 92647 Dr Gary Rutherford,Super 30 Country View Estates A 38 OC S tatton District 42 HB City Elementary School Dist Carne Thomas 10844 s Avenue 20451 Crauner Lane 6642 Trotter Drive Foun ain Valley CA 92708 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beac CA 92648 David Perry 3� Country tew Estates HOA 38 c Pendegraft,Plant Manager 42 HB City Elementary School Dist Geral Chapman S Huntington Beach,LLC 20451 Cratmer Lane 674 Shire Circle 1730 Newland Street Huntington Beach,CA 92648 ntmgton Beach CA 92648 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Richard Loy 42 Huntington Beach Girls Softball* 47 AYSO Region 56 9062 Kabuli Drive Mike Erickson Comimsstoner John Gray Huntington Beach CA 9 46 P O Box 3943 9522 Smokey Crude Huntington Beach,CA 92605-3943 Huntington Beach,CA 92646 John Ely 42 AYSO Region 117 AYSO Region 55 47 22102 Roc ort Lane John Almanza Commissioner Russ Marlow Huntin n Beach CA 92646 19961 Bushard St 18111 Brentwell Circle Fountain Valley,CA 92708 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiauette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Avery 05160/8160 PUBuc HUM nee n n �UJP1 ww L9 x Ww 9Z fawaof ap aganbI13 41-NRftUP- �l MAILING LABELS G Labels\Labels\Public Hearing Jan ® q}edwoo„g/g Z x«1 azis lagal w D — President Huntington Harbor POA 10 Sue Johnson 16 H B Chamber of Commerce P O Box 791 19671 Quiet Bay Lane 19891 Beach Blvd,Ste 140 Sunset Beach,CA 90742 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 926 Dave Stefamdes 2 Kirsten Berg 13 Orange County oc of Realtors 18870 Kithira Circle 25552 La Paz ad Hunginton Beach,CA 92648 Laguna Hills, A 92653 Presid t 3 Jeffrey M.Oderman 12 Pacific Coast Archaeological 18 Arm s De Bolsa Cluca RUTAN&TUCKER,LLP Society,Inc P .Box 1563 611 Anton Blvd,14a'Floor P.O Box 10926 tington Beach,CA 92647 Costa Mesa CA 92626-1950 Costa Mesa,CA 92627 Attu-Jane Gothold Sunset Beach Community Assoc O4 Pres,H B Hist Society 13 Director 19 Pat Thies,President C/O Newland House Museum O C Plug&Dev Servic s Dept. PO Box 215 19820 Beach Blvd P O Box 4048 Sunset Beach,CA 90742-0215 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Santa Ana,CA 9270 48 President 5 Barbara Haynes 14 Bryan Speegle 19 Huntington Beach Tomorrow historic Resources Board C air O C Resources& evelop Mgt Dept. PO Box 865 19341 Worchester Lane P O Box 4048 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92 46 Santa Ana,CA 92 02AD48 Julie Vandermost 6 Council on Aging 15 Planning Direct r 20 BIA-OC 1706 Orange Ave Gty of Costa esa 17744 Sky Park Circle,#17 Huntington Beach,C 92648 P O.Box 12 Irvine CA 92614-4441 Costa Mesa, A 92628-1200 Richard Spicer 7 Jeff Metzel 16 Planning D ector 21 SCAG Seachff HOA City of Fo taro Valley 818 West 7th,12th oor 19391 Shady H or Circle 10200 Sla r Ave Los Angeles,CA 9 017 Huntington Be ch,CA 92648 Fountam alley,CA 92708 Jean Kunbrell 8 John Roe 16 Plannin Director 22 c/o E.T.I al 100 Seachff H A City of ewport Beach 20292 Eas od Cir 19382 S ale Lane P O x 1768 Huntingto Beach,CA 92646 Huntm n Beach,CA 92648 Newp rt Beach,CA 92663-8915 Robe Smith 9 Lou annone 16 PI - g Director 23 Ravi nmental Board Chair Sea ff HOA City,of Westminster 213 Yarmouth Lane 198 Ocean Bluff Circle 8 Westminster Blvd Hu tington Beach,CA 92646 H tington Beach CA 92648 W tminster,CA 92683 lanning Director 24 can View School District 38 Hampton HOA 38 City of Seal Beach tm Cindy Pulfer,Admire Services rogressive Community Mgmt. 211 Eighth St 7200 Pinehurst Lane 7405 Puerta Real,#300 Seal Beach,CA 90740 Huntington Beach CA 92647 ssion Viejo,CA 92691 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 0918/091g®1u9nv sane algitedwos ww L9 x ww 9Z iewaof ap 9119 13 �� 0918/09Lg®fu9Ay ylim algifedwos„g/g Z x«L azis loge) 800-560-49 ;800-560-53 800-560-57 Owner/Occupant ;Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 49 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 53 116400 Saybrook Ln Unit 57 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2263 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2264 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2264 l 800-560-06 M0-560-61 891-570-62 Owner/Occupant !Owner/Occupant ;Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 6 1 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 61 116400 Saybrook Ln Unit 62 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2259 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2264 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2264 (800-560-63 800-560-65 800-560-66 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 63 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 65 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 66 j Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2264 'Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 800-560-68 r800-560-73 800-560-76 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 68 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 73 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 76 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 800-560-77 800-560-78 800-560-79 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 77 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 78 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 79 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 !Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 800-560-08 800-560-80 800-560-84 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 8 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 80 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 84 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2259 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 800-560-85 800-560-87 800-560-88 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 85 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 87 '16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 88 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 800-560-91 800-560-93 800-560-94 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 91 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 93 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 94 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 800-560-95 800-560-96 800-560-98 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 95 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 96 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 98 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2267 891-570-99 Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 99 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2267 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 am Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery/95160/8160 GeJ�O —0 feh, 0918/09L90 A1any oam algijPdwoo Will L9 x Will 9Z1e111101 ap 0:4mbi}3 0918/0915e tiaAy glim elgiledwoo,,8/9 Z x«l ozis loge) Owner/Occupant (178-631-52 Owner/Occupant '16625 Algonquin St ;Gosin Robert F 116631 Algonquin St Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3270 !Po Box 519 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3270 'Shasta,CA 96087-0519 I ' 178-631-51 1178-631-50 ;178-631-49 Merritt Jack G !Ruettgers Daniel W Malkin Arthur&L Family Trust 16635 Algonquin St I765 Ocean View Ave#b �28326 Ridgefalls Ct �Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3270 (Monrovia,CA 91016-2483 Rancho Palos Verdes, CA 90275-3237 (Owner/Occupant 1178-631-48 (178-631-47 16645 Algonquin St IGeisbauer John Paul/Occupant iKent John AHacker-kent Kathleen C (Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3270 116651 Algonquin St 116655 Algonquin St Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3269 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3269 178-631-46 178-631-45 178-631-44 !Neubauer Gilbert Litten Barbara A !,Revak Laura Joan j 16661 Algonquin St ;16665 Algonquin St �1808 Lake St Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3269 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3269 'Huntington Beach,CA 92648-3164 178-631-54 891-571-27 800-561-28 Glaze Karen Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16621 Algonquin St 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 127 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 128 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3270 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2269 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2269 ,800-560-14 800-560-15 800-560-18 Owner/Occupant 'Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 14 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 15 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 18 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2260 ;Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2260 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2260 ,800-560-02 800-560-21 800-560-24 ,Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 2 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 21 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 24 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2259 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2261 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2261 800-560-26 800-560-29 800-560-03 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 26 '16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 29 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 3 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2261 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2261 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2259 800-560-38 891-570-39 800-560-04 'Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant ,16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 38 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 39 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 4 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2262 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2262 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2259 800-560-40 800-560-46 891-570-47 'Owner/occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 40 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 46 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 47 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2263 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2263 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2263 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etmuette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Avery 05160/8160 09L8/09L9®ha9AV oaAe algijMwoo Will L9 x Will 9Z lewaol ap aga*13 0 , —/U 09L9/09L5@),GaAV Minn alggedwoo«9/5 Z x,,[azis lagel 178-631-04 1 178-631-05 178-631-06 Von Kleinsmid Kristen iMc Clane Rene ;Coyne Anthony 1&Lisa L 4441 Sea Harbour Dr �4445 Sea Harbour Dr 116801 Phelps Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3151 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3151 lHuntington Beach,CA 92649-3048 Owner/Occupant 1 178-631-07 Owner/Occupant 4451 Sea Harbour Dr Plechas Michal 1 4455 Sea Harbour Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3151 11913 E 17th St#110Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3151 Santa Ana,CA 92705-8627 r 178-631-08 178-631-09 i178-631-10 Schwartz Jean R ;Edwards Jacqueline L �Wold Michael E 14461 Sea Harbour Dr 4465 Sea Harbour Dr '6146 Eaglecrest Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3152 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3152 Huntington Beach,CA 92648-5548 I 'Owner/Occupant 178-631-11 178-631-12 4471 Sea Harbour Dr Kinowski Adam J &Kirsten L Tabar Shamiram Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3152 4475 Sea Harbour Dr 4481 Sea Harbour Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3152 'Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3152 178-631-13 178-631-14 Owner/Occupant Merz Amy Strode Kathleen M 4491 Sea Harbour Dr 4485 Sea Harbour Dr 254 S Glassell St Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3152 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3152 -Orange,CA 92866-1918 178-631-33 178-631-34 178-631-35 !Johnson Thomas G Candelaria Patricia A Westmoreland Wesley/Occupant 16621 Castaway Ln 16625 Castaway Ln 16631 Castaway Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3153 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3153 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3153 178-631-36 178-631-37 178-631-38 Marilley lames A Huck Judith A Lee Norman 16635 Castaway Ln 16641 Castaway Ln 16645 Castaway Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3153 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3153 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3154 178-631-39 Owner/Occupant 178-631-40 Becker Christa E 16651 Castaway Ln Ferguson Patricia 1715 La Golondrina Ave Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3154 16655 Castaway Ln Alhambra,CA 91803-2706 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3154 178-631-41 178-631-42 Owner/Occupant Campagna Michael Brandt Diethelm B 16665 Castaway Ln 16661 Castaway Ln 16498 El Hito Ct Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3154 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3154 Pacific Palisades,CA 90272-2338 178-631-43 Owner/Occupant 178-631-53 Tomchak James 16671 Castaway Ln Ronay George W 6450 W 82nd St Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3154 8035 Nardian Way Los Angeles,CA 90045-2884 Los Angeles,CA 90045-2545 a label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiouette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 GJ PD 4�L 09 L8/09 L5®/uany oane algiledwoa ww L9 x ww 9Z lewaol op 9g9043 09L8/09 L5@ fu9Ay UhM alggedwo3«g/5 Z x,,L azis lagel 178-601-06 178-601-05 178-601-04 Howe Jade Erik ! (Huss Donald L Whitener Gary L&Ana P 16451 Wimbledon Ln 116453 Wimbledon Ln 16201 Wayfarer Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2149 178-601-03 178-601-02 (178-601-01 Mc Holm William D Jr Lynch Jay A �Buysse Angela 16457 Wimbledon Ln �16459 Wimbledon Ln 17230 Mineral Park Ave Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 , 'Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 !Las Vegas, NV 89179-1233 i � I Owner/Occupant 478-631-15 478-631-16 16461 Wimbledon Ln % IBurress Steven Ray&Dee Ann V ,Duffis Kevin A&Marjorie H Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 I 4396 Sea Harbour Dr 4402 Sea Harbour Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3149 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3149 178-631-17 ;Owner/Occupant �178-631-18 Sockerson Amber Nadine 14406 Sea Harbour Dr IMc Graw Stephanie Adams 18625 Park Ridge Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3149 15621 Sunflower Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92648-6806 Huntington Beach,CA 92647-2920 I ' �Owne r/Occupant 178-631-19 178-631-20 14412 Sea Harbour Dr Wallace Lawrence A Trust Smith Edward 1 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3149 �4416 Sea Harbour Dr 16831 Sea Witch Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3149 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3056 Owner/Occupant 178-631-21 '178-631-22 4422 Sea Harbour Dr Obrien Robert A Traskell Family Trust Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3149 4426 Sea Harbour Dr '4432 Sea Harbour Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3149 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3150 i 178-631-23 '178-631-24 178-631-25 Sowels Theresa West Scott D&Jocelyn S Brennan Donald E&Marlene R 4436 Sea Harbour Dr 4442 Sea Harbour Dr 4446 Sea Harbour Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3150 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3150 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3150 178-631-26 178-631-27 178-631-28 Murphy Edward J &Dorine G Antenuca Dominick F& Nancy C -Tejeda Hilarto Albert&Anna Viola 14452 Sea Harbour Dr 4456 Sea Harbour Dr 4462 Sea Harbour Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3150 'Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3150 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3150 i 178-631-29 Owner/Occupant 178-631-30 Mercado Tracy Lynn 4476 Sea Harbour Dr Reed Marilyn A/Occupant 16312 Magellan Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3207 4482 Sea Harbour Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92647-3527 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3207 178-631-01 178-631-02 178-631-03 Zirney Edward Jack Jr Albini Diane Gail & Peter G Moffett Rebecca Reid/Occupant 4425 Sea Harbour Dr 4431 Sea Harbour Dr 4435 Sea Harbour Dr Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3151 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3151 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3151 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiouette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Avery 05160/8160 0918/09L9®IG9Ad oane elgi;edwoa ww L9 x ww 9Z}ewaol ap attanbq :�o /0 091.8/0915®IG9AV gjim alggedwoo„S/g Z x„l ozis lapel a 178-601-33 178-601-34 'Owner/occupant Davis Randal&Susan I Lee Chee Tat 116369 Wimbledon Ln 16367 Wimbledon Ln ! Po Box 3781 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2188 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2188 Costa Mesa,CA 92628-3781 I i 178-601-35 178-601-27 178-601-26 Applebaum Trust Moyer Ronald C L Watson Inc 16371 Wimbledon Ln 16391 Wimbledon Ln 16393 Wimbledon Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2188 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2188 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2188 i'178-601-25 '178-601-21 Owner/Occupant Simpson Clay F i Gill Michael J &Meliscent R i 16397 Wimbledon Ln 16395 Wimbledon Ln 1354 E Altadena Dr i Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2188 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2188 Altadena,CA 91001-2046 178-601-20 ,178-601-19 Owner/Occupant Brown Bryan F I Goulding Stanford G 16411 Wimbledon Ln , 16401 Wimbledon Ln ! 38180 Del Webb Blvd#32 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 ' Palm Desert,CA 92211-1256 178-601-18 178-601-17 178-601-22 Clark Janice E Rowlette Charles G Ardia Jean E 16413 Wimbledon Ln 16415 Wimbledon Ln 16417 Wimbledon Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 178-601-23 178-601-24 Owner/Occupant Schultz Daniel I/Occupant Merrill David W 16421 Wimbledon Ln 16419 Wimbledon Ln ' 1697 W Lisbon St Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 Upland, CA 91784-7458 178-601-16 178-601-15 178-601-14 Howe Jade E Nanney-wong Kam Mie Gregg Charles R&V M Trust 16431 Wimbledon Ln 16433 Wimbledon Ln 16435 Wimbledon Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 178-601-13 Owner/Occupant 178-601-12 Broken Leg LandDevelopment 16437 Wimbledon Ln Pieratt Anita 16431 Barnstable Cir Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 ' 16439 Wimbledon Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2114 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 178-601-11 178-601-10 178-601-09 Dean Jerry S&Dana D Gordon Norman W Bradeson Brian J 16441 Wimbledon Ln 16443 Wimbledon Ln 16445 Wimbledon Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 178-601-08 178-601-07 Owner/Occupant Fenner Patsy Lou Carlson &A Benchay Lee S 16449 Wimbledon Ln 16447 Wimbledon Ln 1821 Wilshire Blvd#230 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2111 Santa Monica,CA 90403-5679 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 85160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 0918/D91-9®tinny Dane aiqitEdmoo Will Lg x Will gZ teuaaoJ ap 0anbit3 D 0918/091g®tiany gjIm alggedwoa„g/g Z x„l ozis lagel 178-630-02 ( 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 'i Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 218 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 219 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 220 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant i 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 301 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 302 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 303 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 ; Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 178-630-02 '178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 304 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 305 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 306 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 'Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 307 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 308 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 309 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 310 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 311 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 312 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 314 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 315 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 316 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 317 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 318 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 319 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 178-630-02 178-601-38 178-601-37 Owner/Occupant Budd James H &Denyce M Saslow Norman H 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 320 16351 Wimbledon Ln 16353 Wimbledon Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2188 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2188 178-601-36 178-601-32 178-601-31 Pycior Sharon Ann Bassett H G&K J Trust Keefer Richard B 16355 Wimbledon Ln 16357 Wimbledon Ln 16359 Wimbledon Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2188 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2188 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2188 178-601-30 178-601-29 178-601-28 Bayless Bruce C Gottlieb Edwyn H Arcuri Family Trust A 16361 Wimbledon Ln 16363 Wimbledon Ln 16365 Wimbledon Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2188 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2188 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2188 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 09L9/09Lg®haany oane olgifedwoo ww L9 x ww gZ;ewaof ap attanbit3 r'--30/O 091.9/091.g®AGaAV glim olgW11103�0/9 Z x„L azis lagel 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 106 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 107 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 108 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 178-630-02 178-630-02 ( 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 109 1 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 110 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 111 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 ; Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 ( 178-630-02 178-630-02 "178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 112 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 114 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 115 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant ! Owner/Occupant 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 116 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 117 ! 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 119 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 120 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 201 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 202 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 203 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 204 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 205 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 206 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 207 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 208 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 209 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 210 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 211 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 212 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 214 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 215 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 216 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 217 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3120 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 0516018160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 It)/0,0 -e� /09!9®tiany Dane algitetlwoo ww Lg x ww gZ leuuoJ ap a}lanbg3 Og l8/Og lg®tiaAb qVm elggedwoo.8/g Z x,,t ozis loge! am 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16742 Saybrook Ln 16743 Saybrook Ln ; 16744 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16745 Saybrook Ln 16746 Saybrook Ln 16747 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant ; Owner/Occupant 16748 Saybrook Ln 16749 Saybrook Ln 16750 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16751 Saybrook Ln 16752 Saybrook Ln 16753 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16754 Saybrook Ln 16755 Saybrook Ln 16756 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 178-630-02 178-353-18 178-353-19 Owner/Occupant Ragan Scott A&Heidi A Bellis Ann By-pass 16757 Saybrook Ln 4211 Silliman Dr Po Box 1064 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3058 Cedar Glen,CA 92321-1064 Owner/Occupant 178-353-20 178-353-21 4221 Silliman Dr Shapiro Joseph S Carroll Wallace L&Karen M Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3058 4231 Silliman Dr 4241 Silliman Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3058 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3058 178-353-22 178-353-23 178-354-02 Pickett Family Trust Vigil Patrick&Jodi Talbert Suzanne M 4251 Silliman Dr 4261 Silliman Dr 4262 Silliman Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3058 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3058 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3059 178-354-01 178-630-02 178-630-02 Hall Thomas Eugene&Sandra Lea Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4272 Silliman Dr 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 101 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 102 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3059 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 103 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 104 16792 Talisman Ln Unit 105 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3118 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiauette de format 25 mm x 67 mm comoatible avec Avery 85160/8160 09 L8/0915®tiany oane algitedwoo ww L9 x ww gZ 1awJo}ap a)Aanbil3 d -3 v—/O a 09L8/09Lg®ti9ny glim algiledwoa„919 Z x„L azis lagel 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 j Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16712 Saybrook Ln 16713 Saybrook Ln 16714 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 ! Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16715 Saybrook Ln ! 16716 Saybrook Ln 1 16717 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant ; Owner/Occupant 16718 Saybrook Ln 16719 Saybrook Ln 16720 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16721 Saybrook Ln 16722 Saybrook Ln 16723 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16724 Saybrook Ln 16725 Saybrook Ln 16726 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16727 Saybrook Ln 16728 Saybrook Ln 16729 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16730 Saybrook Ln 16731 Saybrook Ln 16732 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16733 Saybrook Ln 16734 Saybrook Ln 16735 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16736 Saybrook Ln 16737 Saybrook Ln 16738 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16739 Saybrook Ln 16740 Saybrook Ln 16741 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 (,J�D ;Z- -Z)V2,�091.9/09L9®tiany oane alggEdwoa ww L9 x ww 9Z lewaol ap 098013 �,31J -�/G 0p l8/0919®fdoAy gjim alggedwoa„8/9 Z x„L azis lapel 891-570-07 (891-570-70 891-579-12 Pena Anthony F 1 Burke Carol A Shopfner Jerry G 16400 Saybrook Ln#7 16400 Saybrook Ln#70 j 16400 Saybrook Ln#71 I Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2259 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 I 891-570-72 ;891-570-74 891-570-75 Huber Alicia J/tr Liebzeit Frances D Howland G Darlene 16400 Saybrook Ln#72 16400 Saybrook Ln#74 16400 Saybrook Ln#75 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 891-570-81 Owner/Occupant 891-570-82 Kelly Levonne K ; 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 81 Mcdowell Dennis L 3713 E Marble Peak PI Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 16400 Saybrook Ln#82 Tucson,AZ 85718-2330 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 891-570-83 (891-579-13 Owner/Occupant Adams Family Lawson Gerald DVernetta 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 86 16400 Saybrook Ln#83 16711 Carousel Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 ! Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2119 891-570-89 891-570-09 891-570-90 Tomchick Joseph M Roen Jay T Schmitt Lloyd & Margaret 16400 Saybrook Ln #89 16400 Saybrook Ln #9 16400 Saybrook Ln#90 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2259 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 891-570-92 Owner/Occupant 891-570-97 Advantage Homes 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 92 Haskin Francis L 12640 Beach Blvd Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 16400 Saybrook Ln#97 Stanton, CA 90680-4008 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2277 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16700 Saybrook Ln 16701 Saybrook Ln 16702 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3129 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16703 Saybrook Ln 16704 Saybrook Ln 16705 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3115 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16706 Saybrook Ln 16707 Saybrook Ln 16708 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16709 Saybrook Ln 16710 Saybrook Ln 16711 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 09L8/09Lgo fdaAV oane algiledwoo ww Lg x ww gZ leuuol op auanbil3 _3 09L8/09Lg®tiaAV glim olgiledwoo„g/5 Z x„L ezis lapel ' 891-570-31 ( 891-570-32 891-570-33 Gray Donald W Miller Dennis J Lawyer Family 16400 Saybrook Ln#31 16400 Saybrook Ln#32 16400 Saybrook Ln#33 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2261 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2261 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2262 '891-570-34 891-570-35 891-570-36 Montgomery Beverly/Occupant Thompson Loretta J Hernandez Ramon 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 34 16400 Saybrook Ln#35 16400 Saybrook Ln#36 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2262 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2262 j ; Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2262 II (`891-570-37 %Owner/Occupant 891-570-41 Auw Pierre E 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 37 Barbour Fred J j 1837 Pacific Coast Hwy#229 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2262 16400 Saybrook Ln#41 Hermosa Beach, CA 90254-3160 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2263 891-570-42 891-570-43 891-579-07 Bagramian Family ! Lance Judyth Kessloff Janice M 16400 Saybrook Ln#42 16400 Saybrook Ln#43 16400 Saybrook Ln#44 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2263 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2263 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2263 891-570-45 891-570-48 Owner/Occupant Strom Steven R Price Richard L&Doris L 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 48 16400 Saybrook Ln #45 1404 N Nobhill Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2263 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2263 Azusa, CA 91702-1521 891-579-08 891-570-50 891-570-51 Asplen Olga Heffner Lorna C/Occupant Mellevold George A 16400 Saybrook Ln#5 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 50 2241 Via Puerta#a Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2259 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2264 Laguna Woods,CA 92637-2115 Owner/Occupant 891-570-52 891-570-54 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 51 Uyema Judy Hisako Jacobson Wesley&Judy Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2264 16400 Saybrook Ln#52 Po Box 5072 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2264 Garden Grove, CA 92846-0072 Owner/Occupant 891-579-11 891-570-56 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 54 Eubanks Helen F Logue Albert Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2264 16400 Saybrook Ln#55 16400 Saybrook Ln#56 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2264 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2264 891-570-58 891-570-59 891-570-60 Towers David Giordano Carolyn Barr Barbara L 16400 Saybrook Ln #58 16400 Saybrook Ln#59 16400 Saybrook Ln#60 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2277 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2264 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2264 891-570-64 891-570-67 891-570-69 Crain Richard L Danks Mary Sophie Jones Kenneth F 16400 Saybrook Ln #64 16400 Saybrook Ln#67 16400 Saybrook Ln#69 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2264 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 am Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 /,c>',0 —0 0918/091g®AaAV oane olgiledwoo ww L9 x ww gZ feu,uoJ ap aganbi;3 f —3c) —l0 ogtg/091g®fGaAV 4}inn olgiledwoo u8/g Z x„t ozis lagel 891-571-22 '891-570-01 '800-561-00 Kinney George&Alice Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln#122 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 1 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 100 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2269 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2259 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2267 I 800-561-02 891-579-04 891-571-07 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 1 Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 102 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 103 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 107 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2267 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2267 1 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2268 i '800-561-08 891-571-11 800-561-12 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 108 ! 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 111 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 112 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2268 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2268 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2268 '891-571-13 800-561-15 800-561-19 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 113 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 115 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 119 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2268 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2268 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2269 800-560-12 800-561-23 800-561-24 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 12 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 123 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 124 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2260 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2269 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2269 891-571-25 800-561-26 891-571-29 Owner/Occupant 1 Owner/Occupant Robles Robert 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 125 % 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 126 16400 Saybrook Ln#129 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2269 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2269 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2269 '891-570-13 891-571-30 891-570-16 Gill Joyce M Klein Marilyn E Close Kathleen/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln#13 16400 Saybrook Ln#130 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 16 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2260 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2269 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2260 891-570-17 891-570-19 891-570-20 Evelyn L Kaplow Hhme Homeowners Assoc Heim Dru 16400 Saybrook Ln#17 16400 Saybrook Ln 16400 Saybrook Ln#20 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2260 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2277 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2260 891-579-10 891-579-15 891-570-25 Gordon Sharon RVogel Robert F Cooley Jan A Schutz Sharon K 16400 Saybrook Ln#22 16400 Saybrook Ln#23 16400 Saybrook Ln#sp25 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2261 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2261 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2277 891-579-16 891-570-28 891-570-30 Dino Juanito G Hawley Judith A Goebel George A/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln#27 16400 Saybrook Ln#28 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 30 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2261 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2261 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2261 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 091e/091,5®lGanV oane algifetlwoa ww L9 x Will 9Z}ewiol ap a#anbq of_3ci Ogle/0915®tianV yjim alggetlwoo ug/5 Z x,.l azis lagel 178-353-03 \i 1 178-352-19 178-353-02 Nadel ArthurOkrent Valerie A 1 Jarvis Lloyd M &Corrine M ! Lahti Stephen C 4232 Pierson Dr 4241 Pierson Dr j 4242 Pierson Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3051 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3050 1 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3051 178-353-01 178-601-63 178-601-62 Lords John Vincent Liddle Keith G Munson Carl L 4252 Pierson Dr 4156 Racquet Club Dr 4162 Racquet Club Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3051 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2108 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2108 li 178-601-61 178-601-60 178-601-59 Davidson James Emmeline Family Trust Ellis Douglas Lee 4166 Racquet Club Dr 4172 Racquet Club Dr 4176 Racquet Club Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2108 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2108 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2108 178-601-58 178-601-57 178-601-56 Peavy Garrett D Wallace Darrel G Trust 1 Howard Lora Lee 4182 Racquet Club Dr 4186 Racquet Club Dr ! 4192 Racquet Club Dr 1 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2108 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2108 1 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2108 178-601-55 178-601-54 178-011-16 Hartman Eric S Binckes Thomas F Houser Bros Co 4196 Racquet Club Dr 4202 Racquet Club Dr 17610 Beach Blvd#32 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2108 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2108 Huntington Beach,CA 92647-6876 891-579-03 Owner/Occupant 891-579-14 Maier Gunther 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 10 Hermes H Richard 18561 Florida St#3009 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2259 16400 Saybrook Ln#101 Huntington Beach,CA 92648-6047 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2267 891-571-04 891-571-05 891-571-06 Barnes Arthur M Campbell Ronald E Briscoe Carol J 16400 Saybrook Ln#104 16400 Saybrook Ln#105 16400 Saybrook Ln#106 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2267 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2267 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2267 891-579-09 891-570-11 891-579-05 Cook Howard W Shaw Don A/Occupant Scollon Gary 16400 Saybrook Ln#109 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 11 16400 Saybrook Ln#110 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2268 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2260 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2268 891-571-14 891-571-16 891-571-17 Jacobs William F Koo Zoltan B Jackson David L 16400 Saybrook Ln#114 16400 Saybrook Ln #116 16400 Saybrook Ln#117 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2268 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2268 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2268 891-571-18 891-571-20 891-579-01 Perez William G Miller Family Levy Charles 16400 Saybrook Ln#118 16400 Saybrook Ln#120 16400 Saybrook Ln#121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2268 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2269 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2269 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery/55160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 09L8/09Lg@ MaAV sane alggedwos ww L9 x ww gZ lewaol ap aganbil3 �. �U _/O 09L8/0919@ tiaAV u3im algiledwoa„8/9 Z x«l azis label ° 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant % Owner/Occupant j Owner/Occupant 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 302 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 303 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 304 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 ! i Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 I 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 305 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 306 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 307 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 11�178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 308 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 309 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 310 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 ! Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 '178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 311 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 312 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 314 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 I 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 315 43S2 Pickwick Cir Unit 316 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 317 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 318 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 319 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 320 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 178-352-12 178-352-13 178-352-14 Camacho Yery E Garr Philip R Correia William! &Vanessa E 4171 Pierson Dr 4181 Pierson Dr 4191 Pierson Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3050 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3050 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3050 178-353-07 178-3S2-15 178-353-06 Kreeger Kent L&Teresa W Shunmugavel Palanichamy Schreiber Alien 4192 Pierson Dr 4201 Pierson Dr 16835 Algonquin St#232 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3000 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-30SO Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3810 Owner/Occupant 178-352-16 178-353-05 4202 Pierson Dr Hanson Derek Nguyen Ngoc-phuong! Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3051 4211 Pierson Dr 4212 Pierson Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3050 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3051 178-352-17 178-353-04 178-352-18 Madan Ramesh K MadanTrut Karidakis Nicholas G Fields Madeline Glavinic 4221 Pierson Dr 4222 Pierson Dr 4231 Pierson Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-30SO Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3051 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3050 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 �f U 9L '`0 ?/ 0918/0919®ti9ny oaAL,algitedwoa WW L9 x uaw 9Z tewaof ap MA90113 �► U /� Op L8/09L56 fWAV ytim alggedwos,,S/5 Z x,,L azis lagel • 178-630-02 !178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 110 ! 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 111 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 112 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3124 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3124 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3124 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 114 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 115 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 116 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3124 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3124 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3124 178-630-02 178-630-02 !178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant j 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 117 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 118 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 119 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3124 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3124 ! Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3124 ' I 178-630-02 '178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant j 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 120 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 201 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 202 j Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3124 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3125 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3125 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 203 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 204 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 205 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3125 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3125 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3125 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 206 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 207 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 208 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3125 i Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3125 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3125 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 209 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 210 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 211 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3125 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3125 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 212 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 214 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 215 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 216 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 217 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 218 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 219 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 220 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 301 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3126 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3126 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 09 L9/09Lg®tiaAV oeAE alggedwoo wW L9 x ww gZ lewaol ap atta0113 4 0%0/0%9@® JaAV gjim algiledwoo,,9/9 Z x«l azis lagel a :�U —/Q • 178-630-02 178-630-02 j 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant j Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 301 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 302 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 303 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 j Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant I Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 304 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 305 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 306 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 I � 178-630-02 ( 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 307 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 308 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 309 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 1 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 310 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 311 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 312 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3123 1 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 314 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 315 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 316 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 317 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 318 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 319 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3123 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 178-630-02 178-761-02 School Ocean View District Owner/Occupant School Ocean View District 4343 Pickwick Cir 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 320 17200 Pinehurst lane Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3108 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3123 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 101 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 102 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 103 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3124 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3124 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3124 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 104 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 105 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 106 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3124 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3124 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3124 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 107 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 108 4352 Pickwick Cir Unit 109 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3124 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3124 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3124 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 f900 ;- —,to V2__� 09L8/0915®NaAV sanz olgileduaoa uaw L9 x ww gZ tewaoj ap atta*13 0918/091.5®Aj9AV utim 9lgi;edw03„g/5 Z x«L azis label ° 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 109 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 110 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 111 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 1 j 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 112 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 114 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 115 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 178-630-02 178-630-02 ( 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 116 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 117 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 118 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 t , 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 119 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 120 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 201 i Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 202 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 203 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 204 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 205 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 206 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 207 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 208 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 209 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 210 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 211 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 212 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 214 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 215 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 216 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 217 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3123 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 218 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 219 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 220 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3123 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 T Q j/2' 0918/091-5®tiany oane algitedwoo WillL9 x tuw 9Z lewaof ap attanbi13 p�-�v w 09L8/09 L9®tiany gtim algitedwoo u8/9 Z x„G ezis lagel Q 931-400-07 931-400-08 931-400-09 Murray Kodee Alonso Frank E j Ludwick Lanny E 16463 Harbour Ln 16459 Harbour Ln 1 1005 12th St Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2103 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2103 Huntington Beach,CA 92648-3414 i Owner/Occupant 931-400-10 931-400-11 16455 Harbour Ln Fryback Dennis G &Judith C j Andino Richard M Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2103 16451 Harbour Ln 1 664 Kalanipuu St Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2103 Honolulu,HI 96825-2421 Owner/Occupant 931-400-12 (931-400-13 16443 Harbour Ln Decollibus Angelo Bessette Dean E Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2103 16439 Harbour Ln 16435 Harbour Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2103 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2103 931-400-14 178-391-25 178-392-04 Maggio Jim &Karen E Thorne Ralph Dennis/Occupant Mc Entee Michael 16431 Harbour Ln 4141 Morning Star Dr ! 4142 Morning Star Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2103 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3011 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3012 178-391-26 178-392-05 178-391-27 Kawaguchi Ken & K Living Trust Petrusan Nela Reeser Robert Bruce/Occupant 4151 Morning Star Dr 4162 Morning Star Dr 4171 Morning Star Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3011 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3012 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3011 178-392-06 178-391-28 178-392-07 Short William G Opdahl Richard Raemer Michael&Amber 4172 Morning Star Dr 4181 Morning Star Dr 4182 Morning Star Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3012 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3011 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3012 178-392-08 178-392-09 178-392-10 Clements James MKohurt-clements Kelner Richard W Larson Barbara Van Ness Carie A 4202 Morning Star Dr 4232 Morning Star Dr 4192 Morning Star Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3013 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3013 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3012 178-392-11 178-630-02 178-630-02 Larson Barbara Van Ness Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4232 Morning Star Dr 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 101 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 102 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3013 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 103 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 104 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 105 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3121 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 106 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 107 4302 Pickwick Cir Unit 108 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3121 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 fm Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 09G8/09G9@ tianV sane elgitedwoo ww L9 x uau19Z fe111a01 ap auanbg3 D -3 C) 09L9/0919®tianV u}inn alggedwoo«8/5 Z x„I.azis lagel O ° 178-352-02 178-351-16- 1 , 178-352-01 - Mitchell Samuel T Bucci Bruno&Carmen C 1 Schaefer Paula ABlodgett Allen E 4232 Calhoun Dr j 4241 Calhoun Dr I ' 4242 Calhoun Dr j Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3038 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3037 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3038 178-601-39 Owner/Occupant 178-601-40 Weiser Irving B 1 4165 Davis Cup Dr i Jebbia Felix Joseph Po Box 822 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2101 4171 Davis Cup Dr Westminster,CA 92684-0822 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2101 I j 178-601-41 178-601-42 178-601-43 Harriman Allan L Harriman Allan I Roche Michael JSurvivors Trust 4181 Davis Cup Dr 4181 Davis Cup Dr 4185 Davis Cup Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2101 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2101 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2101 178-601-44 '178-601-45 178-601-46 Risher Robert R Jr Freer Lynn Dawson Dons Maxine 4191 Davis Cup Dr 4195 Davis Cup Dr 14201 Davis Cup Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2101 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2101 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2101 178-601-53 178-601-52 Owner/Occupant Free Calvin & Pamela A Sjaholm Shirley J 16387 Forest Hills Ln 16381 Forest Hills Ln 2101 Echo Park Ave Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2102 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2102 Los Angeles,CA 90026-1941 178-601-51 Owner/Occupant 178-601-50 Mullaney Robert A 16391 Forest Hills Ln Lupton Philip S/Occupant 3421 Venture Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2102 16397 Forest Hills Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2533 Huntington Beach, CA 178-601-49 178-601-48 Owner/Occupant Buchanan James R Jr& Lone A Chang Dennis W&Mina 16407 Forest Hills Ln 16401 Forest Hills Ln 1055 W 7th St#2800 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2102 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2102 Los Angeles,CA 90017-2554 178-601-47 931-400-01 931-400-02 Simmons George K Daniels L B&C R Living Trust Kang Bong Rim 16411 Forest Hills Ln 16491 Harbour Ln 3293 Gardenia Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2102 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2103 Yorba Linda,CA 92886-1885 Owner/Occupant 931-400-03 931-400-04 16483 Harbour Ln Paden Christine Crott Roger C Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2103 16479 Harbour Ln 16475 Harbour Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2103 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2103 931-400-05 Owner/Occupant 931-400-06 Bank Union California Harriman Family 16471 Harbour Ln Hanst Living Trust Po Box 13495 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2103 16467 Harbour Ln Arlington,TX 76094-0495 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2103 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 05160/8160 Etiauette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 85160/8160 �jtJjU �el li 091.9/09Ls.tinny anA¢9lgi1Ldwo3 ww L9 x ww 9Z IMoJ ap allanbit3 09L8/0915@/GaAy q mn algiledwoa,,8/9 Z x„f azis logel Owner/Occupant 178-392-18 178-351-07 4152 Branford Dr Ratelle Raymond M &Catherine B Heineman T M &J M Living Trust j Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3034 4161 Branford Dr 13 Hidden Crest Way Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3033 Laguna Niguel,CA 92677-4912 Owner/Occupant 178-392-17 178-351-06 4162 Branford Dr Persons James M Lam Alvin W/Occupant Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3034 4171 Branford Dr 4172 Branford Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3033 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3034 !`178-392-16 178-351-05 178-392-15 Byelick Roger A Eliot Lance B&Annette D Vogel Martin D& Kathryn J 4181 Branford Dr 4182 Branford Dr 4191 Branford Dr Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3033 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3034 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3033 ' 178-351-04 } ' 178-392-14 178-351-03 Kerney Cornelius V Jr& Barbara L Segundo Diego Hinds Justin 4192 Branford Dr 4201 Branford Dr 4202 Branford Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3034 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3035 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3036 178-351-02 178-392-13 178-392-12 Marquis Robert A Thomason Marlene Sullivan William Mark&Sheryl 4212 Branford Dr 4221 Branford Dr 4231 Branford Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3036 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3035 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3035 178-351-01 178-351-10 Owner/Occupant Phantumabamrung Paul&Annalisa Early Billie 4161 Calhoun Dr 4232 Branford Dr Po Box 330 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3037 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3036 Seal Beach,CA 90740-0330 178-351-11 178-352-08 Owner/Occupant Sanchez Lenora Rayhan Syrus 4172 Calhoun Dr 4171 Calhoun Dr 3612 Venture Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3038 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3037 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2538 178-352-07 178-351-12 178-352-06 Carlson Craig M & Marjorie M Parikh Isabella Cecilia Robertson Lawrence J 4182 Calhoun Dr 4191 Calhoun Dr 4192 Calhoun Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3038 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3037 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3038 178-352-05 178-351-13 178-352-04 Ressia Carlos Jr Lee Jay WFukami Sumina Creasey Lori 4202 Calhoun Dr 4211 Calhoun Dr 4212 Calhoun Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3038 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3037 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3038 178-351-14 178-352-03 178-351-15 De Dubovay Mark&Barbara Christian Nina Sanders Avies Irene 4221 Calhoun Dr 4222 Calhoun Dr 4231 Calhoun Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3037 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3038 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3037 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery 0516018160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 mm compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 0918/09L5.tiaAy oane algiledwoa ww Lg x ww 5Z leullof op allanbil3 �C) 99ENIM w 09 L8/0915o tiaAy glim alggedwoa„8/9 Z x„L azis lagel 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant j 16701 Algonquin St Unit 112 16701 Algonquin St Unit 114 16701 Algonquin St Unit 115 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3349 j Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 i 178-630-02 , 178-630-02 178-630-02 jOwner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16701 Algonquin St Unit 116 ' 16701 Algonquin St Unit 117 16701 Algonquin St Unit 118 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16701 Algonquin St Unit 119 16701 Algonquin St Unit 120 16701 Algonquin St Unit 201 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 'A78-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16701 Algonquin St Unit 202 16701 Algonquin St Unit 203 ;16701 Algonquin St Unit 204 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3349 I 178-630-02 '178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16701 Algonquin St Unit 205 16701 Algonquin St Unit 206 16701 Algonquin St Unit 207 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16701 Algonquin St Unit 208 16701 Algonquin St Unit 209 16701 Algonquin St Unit 210 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3349 '178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16701 Algonquin St Unit 211 16701 Algonquin St Unit 212 16701 Algonquin St Unit 214 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3309 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3309 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3309 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 'Owner/occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16701 Algonquin St Unit 215 16701 Algonquin St Unit 216 16701 Algonquin St Unit 217 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3309 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3309 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3351 178-630-02 178-630-02 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 16701 Algonquin St Unit 218 16701 Algonquin St Unit 219 16701 Algonquin St Unit 220 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3351 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3351 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3351 178-630-02 178-392-19 178-351-08 Owner/Occupant Studer Jeffrey P&Jeannine M S+chting Trust 16701 Algonquin St Unit 301 4151 Branford Dr Po Box 40354 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3351 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3033 Downey,CA 90239-1354 label size 1"x 2 5/8"compatible with Avery/55160/8160 Etiquette de format 25 mm x 67 min compatible avec Avery 05160/8160 ATTORNEYS AT LAW Vk NOSSAMANLLP 18101 Von Karman Avenue Suite 1800 Irvine,CA 92612 T 949 833 7800 F 949 833 7878 VIA HAND DELIVERY John J Flynn III D 949 477 7634 lflynn@nossaman corn Refer To File# 290297-0250 August 30, 2010 Mayor Cathy Green and Members of the City Council City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Re: 'T-Mobile's City-Approved Permits and Site License Agreements (Harbour View and Bolsa View Parks) Dear Mayor Green and Members of the Council Submitted herewith for tonight's hearing is the Supplemental Declaration of Daniel Wang and the Declaration of Mark McDiarmid V ry truly yo rs, John J Flynn III of Nossaman LLP JJF/rrg cc Jennifer McGrath, Esq (via email) Scott Field, Esq (via email) 301620_1 DOC nossaman com 1 2 3 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA 4 5 6 7 DECLARATION OF MARK 8 MCDIARMID 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 1 1, Mark McDiarmid, declare: 2 1. I am a national Director of RF/RAN Systems for T-Mobile USA, Inc. ("T- 3 Mobile"). I supervise T-Mobile's Corporate Radio Frequency engineering staff. I submit 4 this declaration in support of the application for approval of the installation of a federally 5 licensed personal wireless facility. I have personal knowledge of the facts set forth 6 below, and, if called as a witness, I could and would competently testify thereto. 7 2. The purpose of this declaration is to detail the technical comparisons 8 between T-Mobile's system design propagation maps ("Propagation Maps") and Personal 9 Coverage Check maps ("PCC Maps") 10 3. I am a qualified radio frequency engineer. I have been trained to identify 11 gaps in reliable service in personal wireless service communications systems and to 12 assess the ability of proposed antenna sites to remedy gaps in signal coverage and 13 capacity within a network of compatible facilities. I have extensive training and 14 experience with respect to T-Mobile's wireless system and technologies, as detailed by 15 my curriculum vitae, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit 1. 16 4. I have nineteen (19)years experience designing, implementing and 17 operating wireless networks, specifically Global System for Mobile communications 18 technology ("GSM") and Universal Mobile Telecommunications System ("UMTS") 19 based networks. 20 PROPAGATION MAWS 21 5. T-Mobile routinely provides Propagation Maps to local governments to 22 support the need to locate and construct a new personal wireless service facility, 23 commonly known as a "cell site," to remedy a significant gap in reliable service. 24 Propagation Maps demonstrate the radio frequency ("RF") coverage that can be expected 25 over a geographic area based on certain assumptions. These assumptions include, 26 without limitation, factors such as: the frequency of the RF signal; the height of the 27 antennas above local terrain; the signal gain due to the directional nature of the antennas; 28 the terrain over which the RF signals are being broadcast; and the strength of the RF i I signals. Propagation Maps predict the RF signal strength over geographic areas on a 2 map; they do not measure the actual signal strength that occurs at that particular point on 3 a map. 4 6. Typically, T-Mobile's engineers or RF engineers working on T-Mobile's 5 behalf produce several Propagation Maps to support a permit application for a new cell 6 site. A first Propagation Map is produced to demonstrate T-Mobile's predicted RF 7 coverage over a given geographic area based on the existing "on air" cell sites T-Mobile 8 operates in the area. A second Propagation Map is produced to demonstrate the predicted 9 RF coverage from the proposed cell site location. 10 7. Currently, T-Mobile utilizes Enterprise Asset software to produce its 11 Propagation Maps. Enterprise Asset software is a digital predictive modeling tool that 12 identifies areas where reliable coverage will exist and where it will not. Digital 13 predictive modeling tools attempt to match a model of the propagation environment to 14 known measurements in an area. 15 8. The digital predictive modeling tool employed by T-Mobile for the 16 Propagation Maps uses advanced digital terrain and environmental databases and 17 calculations to produce an accurate estimation of the wireless signal strength typically 18 over a 25 meter square, also known as a bin. 19 9. The digital predictive modeling tool uses the European Cooperation in the 20 Field of Scientific and Technical Research Subgroup on Propagation (Cost 231) Model. 21 This is an extended version of the industry standard Okumura-Hasa model. In other 22 words, T-Mobile's digital predictive modeling tool is based upon industry-accepted RF 23 signal prediction calculations. 24 10. Propagation Maps demonstrate specific wireless signal strength levels 25 necessary to provide reliable wireless service either within a vehicle or within a building 26 pursuant to T-Mobile's design criteria in a given area. Because wireless signals are 27 attenuated by the materials that make up a vehicle or building, stronger signals are 28 required to provide reliable wireless service within a vehicle than outdoors. Likewise, 2 I stronger wireless signals are required to provide reliable wireless service within a 2 building than within a vehicle. T-Mobile's RF design standard for the signal strength 3 necessary to provide reliable in-vehicle, residential in-building or commercial in-building 4 wireless service is based upon exact scientific and statistical analyses T-Mobile's design 5 standard is -84 dBm signal strength for reliable in-vehicle 2G coverage, -76 dBm for 6 reliable residential in-building 2G coverage and-70 dBm for reliable commercial in- 7 building 2G coverage. On-street coverage thresholds are not used by T-Mobile RF 8 engineers in the design of the T-Mobile network as such moderate levels of coverage are 9 not deemed reliable for purposes of remedying significant gap in service to T-Mobile's 10 customers. 11 11. Overall, the Propagation Maps produced by T-Mobile using the Enterprise 12 Asset software and presented to local governments are highly reliable for the purpose of 13 demonstrating T-Mobile's existing wireless service and the need for a proposed new cell 14 site at a given location. The Propagation Maps may in some instances be verified and/or 15 further tuned to be more accurate by using actual signal strength field measurements 16 collected during a drive test 17 PCC MAPS 18 12. Personal Coverage Check is T-Mobile's web-based tool that customers can 19 use to estimate the wireless coverage available from existing T-Mobile cell sites for 20 specific outdoor locations within T-Mobile's nationwide network. T-Mobile provides 21 PCC Maps to assist its customers and potential customers in making informed decisions 22 on whether a T-Mobile service plan provides the type of coverage quality they are 23 seeking in the area(s) where they need it. Sales representatives use PCC Maps at the 24 point of sale to provide the customer with an estimated view of coverage prior to making 25 a purchase. 26 13. The Federal Communications Commission has noted that "T-Mobile was the 27 first nationwide provider to differentiate its service through the addition of an interactive 28 `Personal Coverage Check' feature to its website that enables customers to check the 3 I quality of network coverage where they live before they purchase the service." See 2 Implementation of Section 6002(b) of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1993, 3 Annual Report and Analysis of Competitive Market Conditions with Respect to 4 Commercial Mobile Services, Thirteenth Report, WT Docket No. 08-27, DA 09-54, ¶ 163 5 (rel. Jan. 16, 2009). 6 14. The PCC Maps, while attempting to approximate T-Mobile's wireless 7 coverage area, do not take into consideration factors such as network changes, call traffic 8 volume, technical limitations, handset capabilities, terrain, structures, foliage, weather, 9 and other conditions that may interfere with actual service at any point in time to the 10 same detailed extent as the Propagation Maps. 11 15. The foregoing PCC Map limitations are expressly detailed on T-Mobile's 12 website with the following disclaimer: 13 "MAP INFORMATION: Maps approximate anticipated coverage 14 outdoors, which vanes by location, may include limited or no 15 coverage areas, and do not guarantee service availability. 16 Within coverage areas, network changes, traffic volume, 17 outages, technical limitations, signal strength, your equipment, 18 obstructions, weather and other conditions may interfere with 19 service quality and availability. Portions of the maps include 20 networks operated by our roaming partners; we are not 21 responsible for their. 3G Coverage requires a 3G device. 22 Devices not purchased from T-Mobile or an authorized dealer 23 may not work on our network. T-Mobile to T-Mobile calls are 24 directly dialed between T-Mobile devices while on the T- 25 Mobile USA network (and not roaming in the US or 26 internationally; voicemail and other T-Mobile service numbers 27 not included. Roaming: Nationwide roaming refers to usage 28 while on a roaming partner's network within coverage area; 4 1 currently not available for webConnectTM data plans. 2 International roaming incurs additional charges and refers to 3 usage outside of the US. 850 Roaming Coverage requires a 4 multi-band device. Certain devices and features will not work 5 when roaming Ask a sales representative or visit www.t- 6 inobile.comhnorecoverage for more information. If you travel 7 outside of coverage areas, your device will not work." 8 16. While PCC Maps are innovative tools for T-Mobile consumers to use in 9 making choices about how to meet wireless service needs, these maps are not as detailed 10 as the Propagation Maps that T-Mobile uses to plan network integrity and expansion 1 i based on technical product and application advancements and consumer demand. The 12 moderate levels of coverage shown on T-Mobile's PCC maps equate to on-street 13 coverage and are not deemed reliable service for T-Mobile's customers for use within 14 vehicles or buildings. 15 PROPAGATION MAPS COMPARED TO PCC MAPS 16 17. As detailed above, Propagation Maps are intended to demonstrate T- 17 Mobile's existing and proposed reliable wireless coverage for purposes of establishing 18 the need for a cell site necessary to remedy a significant gap in reliable wireless service 19 within vehicles or buildings in a given area. In contrast, PCC Maps are intended to assist 20 prospective purchasers of T-Mobile's wireless service plans and demonstrate T-Mobile's 21 wireless signal quality outdoors. 22 18. The PCC Maps and the Propagation Maps are generated using the same 23 general predictive modeling tool. However, for ease of use by consumers, the PCC Maps 24 use a 100 meter bin size (rather than a more detailed 25 meter bin size generally used for 25 the preparation of the Propagation Maps) and are "smoothed," thereby creating visual 26 differences in the coverage design thresholds. "Smoothing" is a process necessary to 27 speed up web presentation and improve the presentation quality of the maps for sales 28 information purposes. The result of using a 100 meter bin size and smoothing is that the 5 I PCC Maps do not show the precision and depth of detail of the Propagation Maps. 2 19. Smoothing is the act of filtering a grad by calculating the numeric values of 3 every bin to be the average of its neighboring bins. Smoothing averages out the data an 4 the grid to provide a high-level or more relative representation of the data, resulting in 5 more generalized signal level contours. The PCC Maps are smoothed by using a nine (9) 6 square bin grid resulting in more generalized signal level contours that are less detailed 7 than the Propagation Maps, but that are believed to be much easier to visualize by the 8 average consumer. The more generalized PCC Maps are also better capable of being 9 presented to the consumer on T-Mobile's website due to graphic and web speed 10 limitations. 11 20 By way of analogy, the PCC Maps are akin to a 300dpi digital photograph 12 while the detailed Propagation Maps are akin to a 1200dpi digital photograph which 13 provides more clarity and detail. 14 21. Comparing PCC Maps to the Propagation Maps that T-Mobile engineers 15 provide to local governments in support of new cell site permit applications is like 16 comparing apples and oranges. They are designed for and serve different purposes. The 17 PCC Maps and the Propagation Maps do not attempt to demonstrate the same levels of 18 wireless service and are not based on the same signal level criteria. For example, as 19 noted above the PCC maps show moderate levels of coverage that relate to on-street 20 coverage levels only, which are not deemed reliable wireless service for T-Mobile users 21 within a vehicle or building and are thus not relevant to T-Mobile's system design or to 22 the remedying of significant gaps an reliable service. PCC and Propagation maps are also 23 based on different average bin sizes and smoothing processes that result in differing 24 visual presentations of reliable coverage areas. PCC Maps provide less detail than 25 Propagation Maps, which are far more detailed and accurate an predicting a specific RF 26 signal strength at a given location. It as simply a mistake to use a PCC Map to suggest 27 that T-Mobile does not need a new cell site at a particular location. 28 22. T-Mobile's voluntary attempt to provide greater information to its 6 I consumers through the PCC Maps should not be used in any way whatsoever to 2 undermine the credibility or accuracy of the Propagation Maps 3 23. In determining whether T-Mobile has reliable in-vehicle or in-building 4 wireless service in a given area, only the Propagation Maps, and not the PCC Maps, 5 should be consulted and relied upon 6 7 8 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America 9 that the foregoing is true and correct, executed in Bellevue, WA, this day of 10 August 2010. 11 12 aw 2J 13 MARK MCDIARMID 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 2 EXMIB� I'T 1 3 cv 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 8 CURRICULUM VITAE OF MARK MCDJAI2MID Director,RF/RAN Systems Engineering for T-Mobile USA, Inc. 12920 SE 38th Street,Bellevue, WA 98006 Mark McDiarmid has 19 years of international wireless industry experience,with knowledge of radio system engineering, business planning and business development. Currently, Mark is employed in the capacity of Director of RF/RAN Systems Engineering by T-Mobile USA, a provider of personal communications services in the US wireless telecom industry. Mark has played a key role in the development,deployment and optimization of several major networks in Europe,North America and New Zealand 'Through broad experience gained on domestic and international projects, Mark has accumulated a well-rounded business skill set that includes enterprise leadership,team management, advanced technology evaluation,business planning,communications and senior leadership liaison skills. Radio System Design and Optimization: Mark has 17 years of experience managing teams of RF engineers to deliver plans for coverage enhancements.capacity upgrades and coverage extensions.These projects required establishing procedures and standards for RIT coverage and interference-mitigation drive testing and design verification. Maik has implemented and managed several cellular system optimization campaigns: including Quality of Seivice problem diagnosis, corrective action planning and impact assessment surveys."These projects required training engineers on optimization techniques,processes and program management As recently as 2007,Mark had responsibility for the optimization of T-Mobile USA's national 3G High Speed Data launch RF Propagation Modeling and Prediction: Mark has gained extensive experience of RF propagation modeling,measurement data collection and integration Mark has managed several programs to improve the prediction accuracy of coverage prediction tools for several national carriers.These programs have enabled greater predictive accuracy for coverage planning, capacity and interference assessment. Business Planning and Valuation Modeling: Mark has over 17 years experience of modeling the cost of new wireless technology deployments, capacity upgrades and coverage enhancements IIe has held responsibility for business planning tool development for several large wireless system deployments including those implemented by Hutchison Orange Ltd . BellSouth Corp., Encompass Inc. , Iowa Wireless Inc.and T-Mobile USA Mark specializes in the development of spectrum valuation models for use in spectrum acquisition activities. Wireless Data Technology: Mark's experience includes planning packet and circuit based wireless data overlays in 2G and 3G cellular systems and designing and developing CAD tools to predict likely throughput and data channel performance. EXHIBIT 1 —PAGE 8 a 2 3 4 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA 5 6 7 SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF DANIEL WANG 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF DANIEL WANG i 1 I, Daniel Wang, declare: 2 1. I am the RF Engineering Manager for T-Mobile USA, Inc. ("T-Mobile") in 3 the Los Angeles/Orange County market ("LA/OC Market"). I submit this supplemental 4 declaration in support of T-Mobile's existing permits and approvals for two stealth 5 wireless telecommunications facilities proposed to be located in Harbour View Park and 6 Bolsa View Park, City of Huntington Beach, California. I have personal knowledge of 7 the facts set forth below, and, if called as a witness, I could and would competently 8 testify thereto. 9 2. I am a qualified radio frequency engineer, and I have over 11 years of 10 experience designing, operating, monitoring and optimizing wireless networks. I have 11 been trained to identify gaps in reliable service in personal wireless service 12 communications systems and to assess the ability of proposed antenna sites to remedy 13 gaps in signal coverage and capacity within a network of compatible facilities. I have 14 specific training, experience and education in the design of advanced digital wireless 15 networks, including the Second Generation ("2G")network based on GSM technology, 16 as well as GPRS and EDGE technologies. 17 3. T-Mobile has established design criteria so that its wireless network will 18 provide reliable wireless service to its customers,whether those customers are on the 19 street, in a vehicle, or in a building. Providing reliable service to T-Mobile's customers 20 in residential buildings is critical to providing the quality of wireless service that 21 customers demand so that T-Mobile can successfully compete with other wireless 22 providers, such as Sprint PCS, AT&T Wireless,MetroPCS and Verizon Wireless. 23 4. Wireless signal strength is measured on a logarithmic power scale 24 referenced to 1 milli-watt of power. A signal strength level less than 1 milli-watt is 25 expressed as a negative. The smaller the negative dBm number,the stronger the signal. 26 For example, -76dBm is a stronger signal level than -84dBm. 27 5. T-Mobile has scientifically determined the strength of the wireless signal 28 ("signal strength")necessary to provide reliable coverage. With respect to in-building I SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF DANIEL WANG I residential coverage, because wireless signals are attenuated(i.e., degraded or partially 2 blocked)by obstructions such as trees, automobile windows, automobile sheet metal, and 3 building materials such as wood, brick and metal, a wireless signal must be of sufficient 4 strength in the ambient environment(i.e., outdoors, with no obstructions)to reliably 5 penetrate into buildings. T-Mobile's system requires an ambient signal level of-76dBm 6 to provide reliable in-building residential coverage. 7 6. To successfully provide reliable in-building residential coverage, a T-Mobile 8 customer should be able to place or receive a call on the ground floor of a building that is 9 three stories or less in height successfully across 95% of the site's coverage area. In- 10 building residential coverage is the mid-level of coverage within T-Mobile's network. I I In-building residential coverage is targeted for residential areas and low-rise commercial 12 districts with building heights of three stories or less. (This type of coverage will 13 typically provide reliable coverage over the majority of the cell coverage area;however 14 in some areas, and specifically at the outer geographic boundaries of the cell sites' 15 coverage area, coverage will be restricted only to rooms with windows and will likely 16 lead to customer dissatisfaction if customers try to place or receive a call inside a 17 windowless room, cellar or emergency shelter.) It is essential for T-Mobile to provide 18 this 95% level of coverage in the residential areas surrounding the Site. 19 7. T-Mobile's design criteria for wireless facilities reflects a business judgment 20 that 100% reliability is an unrealistic goal at this time due to financial, technical and 21 environmental constraints, as discussed above. A 95% level of reliability Is consistent 22 with the level of service provided by T-Mobile's competitors. Providing service at this 23 level allows T-Mobile to satisfy customers' demands and compete on an equal footing 24 with competitors serving this market. 25 8. To achieve the 95%reliable design goal, maximum path loss values are 26 derived on the basis of T-Mobile's technology and the basic nature of the area served. 27 Path Ioss means the level of degradation of a T-Mobile signal from the point at which the 28 signal leaves the T-Mobile antenna site to the point at which it reaches the T-Mobile 2 SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF DANIEL WANG . l I customer's mobile device or telephone. The equation is expressed as follows: In- 2 building coverage=Receiver Sensitivity+Body Loss+In Building Loss with Standard 3 Deviation +Fade Margin. 4 The appropriate signal strength planning levels are shown in the table below: 5 Level of Service MS (Rx Sensitivity) Fade Margin and Planning Level 6 Losses 7 In-Vehicle -102dBm 17.6 -84.4 dBm 8 In-Building -102dBm 26.0 -76.0 dBm 9 (residential) 10 Outdoor -102dBm 11.0 -91 dBm 11 12 9. These were the standards used for delineation of the predicated coverage 13 shown on the propagation maps submitted to the City by T-Mobile on August 27, 2010. 14 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America 15 that the foregoing is true and correct. 16 17 DATED: August 30, 2010 18 19 Daniel Wang 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 3 SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF DANIEL WANG RECEIVED FROM AS PUBLIC RECO FOR COUNCIL M OF CITY CLERK OFFICE JOAN L FLYW CITY CLERK August 30, 2010 Special Meeting of the Huntington Ffi NOSSAMAN ALP Beach City Council re Approved, Issued and Council-Reaffirmed Wireless and Building Permits nossaman.com TONIGHT'S HEARING VIOLATES LOCAL LAW Under the plain and unambiguous language of the City's code , "a revocation hearing shall be set before the original hearing body. " ( Huntington Beach Zoning Code section 294 . 06 , subd . A. ) History of Permits and Approvals 6 T-Mobile submits wireless permit applications in July 2007 City requests additional propagation maps indicating RF signal strengths and additional photosimulations T-Mobile submits additional materials requested by the City in August 2007, thereby submitting everything required by City Resolution No. 3766 City approves wireless permits in August and September 2007 In January 2009, City Council unanimously approves Site License Agreements In April 2009, City ministerally approves and issues building permits Commencement of Construction and Public Opposition On or about April 6 , 2009 , T-Mobile commences construction of the Harbour View facility After approximately two weeks of construction , residents , complaining about possible harmful effects of radio frequency emissions , physically obstruct construction activities at the site Reaffirmation of Permits and Approvals On July 6 , 2009 , the City Council meets in closed session and unanimously affirms the validity of T- Mobile's wireless permits , building permits , and Site License Agreements . Second Reaffirmation of Permits and Approvals On July 23, 2009, the City Attorney, under the express direction of the City Council, sends T-Mobile a letter confirming the validity of T-Mobile's wireless permits, building permits, and site license agreements, stating: Despite the protests, the City continues to recognize the validity of the Site License and the Wireless Permits. However, it was immediately after the protests that the City learned that the construction costs exceeded $100,000. The City now is obligated to enforce Section 612. Consequently, by way of a separate memorandum to the Building Department, I have directed that both building permits be suspended until voter approval can be obtained. If and when [T-Mobile] obtains voter approval, the suspension will be lifted, and [T-Mobile] may construct the towers. Court Strikes Down Measure C On July 9 , 2010 , the United States District Court for the Central District of California holds that Measure C , as applied to wireless telecommunications facilities , is preempted by the federal Telecommunications Act of 1996 . City Admits Revocation Unlawful On July 20 , 2010 , the City Attorney admits , at a special meeting of the City Council , that there is no state or local law , code provision , or regulation that authorizes revocation of T- Mobile's administratively approved permits . - } 1 Alleged Ground for Revocation The City' s proposed findings state that revocation is proper because T- Mobile submitted misleading or erroneous propagation maps . � r+' k,+'� tl+ � .. t t '- � �# t� Propagation Maps Showing Current Coverage y d E' y ..rw41T R i 3 °'sT�•fi -�— +j Current Lo erage Wilboul LA17156A94010 �� patl y y Cu rent Coverage w0%out lAf 715]A A 5 ] 6 Mobile ° Y. s G r . • hwbile 9 �p emi,w a mew as a i @o„e nA- �" � € A�weaeo+�a a �� E ae. - • .:.eve $ 9 i § ss d "''� e = �•, s rmmo-. A .uuen . r �.^�' `�;.vraein r. � T R s m a5 0 ca. ua amw 3> eK 5 INIWP n p Yt M r11Nle _ _ 11q.� COVMigY I!(BVW aM'y eMt�V� nYlrngwYMew Wree4eM.gWOrbY WYVY.bFOwre:tlrtlh,YnvYrgr J i �mva H,Yl abrr:Mnrr WrYreYYrrgrereYnvelrrYvgY.egrgraMsaw art iWi Pww N�rul wr.nwYarrn.rF.rwr.awr+nww.rrar.Ya��rirenewserars 'gawb4n+rtranwwgrr ve�wu+naur wsws/au.regr.rabry Y.MYq.sreYwtfa.YenAsewwwweawYTR4rwnaM. bMMMM UvgMA�rr Mi.e��FFrwribwJq.eYYq.FYtrar�i nYe1rY1M41 :r'Tr.nrYwmq�narYe•rr.r..Yrrrwrr.rwaaweV..r.Y irw'"Titan+nA�gwawnrr..w-rwar.r.rwr.<rurr.rwwsr..r q►bwq�wrF -b.+.s>� Fb+arYwr -nupo-]ari-- Signal Strengths Recorded by Jonathan Kramer alp . n CC.w+ n.hnn .1351 O,Ne..c 4..e am ore<. pu.11N O✓.ntlN )/a3/2030 ub .a «33 110 343 PIckwlck Cl•cl .r1.w.4nvrnary O +wl:ena ac.l:. ' ♦3.3H 03.OB6 I :na4.bu.yNPw 3m� >nz/-Sovo 3:iz Y.+ «.•bp,•V4w P.•k aN.wnt co me P.pPP..e - .ww.t .wl .3.2W O>1235 II Y.. )/13/z010 3:23 .a 16>OO S.Yb•ook w/k10nY N.+eN - O .a14nt ul a>. W130 . �r.i omo )nzno.o xis )ns/mio 3:]P 3s s3s ias>sawnwY.n -v32 a .. wile ipszv asen...ln s< e.)..e..so.+In I.n! .w4 �so35 .ow w�nv..e V.W.10 M> INO NH3 6031 M10an9u1n 5t cIn c.n- -]l0 taul4n< E.c•Ilmf 3.0>6 3.0>p <.•of b...In,, >/12/t010 •AO V N39 W313 e•P,Sun. -BB np14M E.WI.n! 3.130 O].09. Ser..l..Me P..•u 5twa- >/13/SOm N33 i>i>l5ene•.lw 14n! .u14n 02.PC3 )n: aas s)s)aN...a.n. -los )/ivmvo ,w .. rive m3v aN.•n..n. a,.taow.In<.Pn: - .F.II.M 4n 12.863 0.91 10 >/1]/]D1O .BO .+ V Wll6 Mob14 w•ry+.e MPV- -iM kln9 Ev<NNnt .<03 Oi.3.30 .a Clutr nOlN�c Paam. vvv:pvo sn r4.m,.•n.pWl. ,noN aP.<•vz> .=.B.n. wIwnt 3.a9 031S2B E iOCOP yv- rc p+R Yry 7/.W...0 5:31 .+ II 1 • .call.n< vu14In 3.6p. 09158 IRlr.w aa.e.e, nle3-eueNe.In MYcle 7n2/]mo .z3 H3>Ml.v.l on.,. ,n.le.on aF..<•... > E.cN t .w14 B/5/m10 .NP N334H.15 -216 43PI—IlkO Iw FIB .O nt.ry schoNV aIB- 0/s/m10 11A0 N334 3.15 W1lH Plckvlck0 - -95 ¢aMlen< E.0 14M .O lwur VIewIFJ.ImvnaW, s noN B/s/mvo A. Ym PNk.wnk n•<.. .P.,...,en.eP...m..pn• - o .w1.M ♦3.13.39 09.13.>8 I•w.11 eN eF.fl•a[,bp. N. N. 110 ll0]01&tw1e4 CIrcY nW11Jlp Erroneous Population Figures The population data in the proposed findings are based on a quarter-mile radius , which is substantially smaller than the coverage area . When the actual coverage area is considered , the affected population for Harbour View is 13 , 264 , and for Bolsa View is 6 , 163 . Representations Made by the City Under Penalty of Perjury "[T] he City may grant the permit regardless of whether a `gap in coverage exists' or whether the proposed location is not `the least obtrusive location feasible . "' ( Decl . of Jason Kelley ¶ 11 . ) + ��,"kF I'Y: 'tE. ' `��'" r,.i,!1a{ r.,K. _ ,r; ict p_ i' iF tcLl " sy !9: ' 1➢1931 INS[ Representations Made by the City Under Penalty of Perjury "Wireless Permit Nos . 07-042 and 07-041 were issued to T-Mobile for the Harbour View and Bolsa View Park sites because both antennas were designed to be architecturally compatible with surrounding land uses by incorporating stealth techniques ." ( Decl . of Jason Kelley ¶ 15 . ) Representations Made by the City Under Penalty of Perjury "Regardless of the existence of a coverage gap or less obtrusive alternative, under Section IC of Ordinance No. 3766, the Planning Director may administratively approve antennas that are: . . . (c) `Facilities in non-residential districts that are in compliance with the maximum building height permitted within the zoning district; and . . . (iii) `Designed to be architecturally compatible with surrounding buildings and land uses by incorporating stealth techniques."' (Decl . of Jason Kelley ¶ 12.) "Section 3.C. 1 .c.iii did apply, because the antennas were located in a non-residential zoning district (open space — Park & Recreation) and designed to resemble a palm tree and broadleaf tree." (Decl. of Jason Kelley ¶ 18.) Representations Made by the City Under Penalty of Perjury Out of 84 applications approved from September 2002 through March 1 , 2010, "[f]orty-eight (48) of the applications were approved administratively without a public hearing because the facilities were determined to be compatible with the surrounding structures and land uses by incorporating stealth techniques ." (Decl . of Jason Kelley ¶ 21 .) Reliability of Propagation Maps "In most cases, when we are looking at proposed coverage from a carrier, they are looking at computer projections of their coverage. That is a fairly traditional way of demonstrating current and planned and coverage." (Jonathan Kramer, May 19, 2009, City of Thousand Oaks City Council Meeting) "[T]ypically those maps have a legend at the bottom that says that the coverage is not guaranteed. I have seen many of these maps that are offered up by the stores, and they are part of the sales tools. Whether they are completely and absolutely accurate for every portion of the country they depict? I think that may answer is simply, based on the technical maps that I have reviewed, the ones that have come in and the quality of the types of maps that we get through the planning process are of higher reliability." (Jonathan Kramer, May 19, 2009, City of Thousand Oaks City Council Meeting) Conclusion I . T-Mobile accurately reported the predicted signal strength levels at the time the permit applications were processed . The City was satisfied that the applications were accurate and complete and therefore issued the permits. -y The Kramer Report records signal strength levels that are consistent with those provided by T-Mobile to the City. Mr. Kramer simply reaches different conclusions. The PCC Maps are irrelevant: they described outdoor coverage only, and they are not inconsistent with T-Mobile's propagation maps. ti ® �"-3D� AT5TRNEYS AT LAW rfi NOSSAMA NLLP 18101 Von Karman Avenue Suite 1800 Irvine,CA 92612 T 949 833 7800 F 949 833 7878 VIA HAND DELIVERY John J Flynn III D 949 477 7634 lflynn@nossaman com Refer To File# 290297-0250 August 27, 2010 Mayor Cathy Green and Members of the City Council City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Re: T-Mobile's City-Approved Permits and Site License Agreements (Harbour View and Bolsa View Parks) Dear Mayor Green and Members of the Council As you know, this law firm represents T-Mobile West Corporation in its continuing efforts to build two badly-needed stealth telecommunications facilities at Harbour View Park and Bolsa View Park in Huntington Beach, California Despite having already approved and issued all necessary permits and approvals for these facilities, the City now appears poised, more than three years after issuing the wireless permits, and more than one year after reaffirming their validity, to reconsider and rescind T-Mobile's permits at an August 30, 2010 City Council meeting At this stage, any stated grounds for reversing the permits would be transparently pretextual The entire proceeding planned by the City is both unfair and unlawful The judicial remand order on which the City purports to base its authority for reconsideration is without the support of law; the City Attorney, Jennifer McGrath, has already advised the undersigned that the staff, without even waiting to hear from T-Mobile, will recommend "reversal" of T-Mobile's permits, the City has had T-Mobile's applications for wireless permits (which resulted in approved permits) for more than three years, and has had all of the information provided by T- Mobile in support of its motion for preliminary injunction for much more than a year, the District Court in T-Mobile West Corp v City of Huntington Beach issued its Order on July 9, 2010 Yet we have been advised that the staff report will not be available until Friday, August 27, 2010, one business day before the August 30 "hearing" The City's procedure not only lacks any legal foundation, it potentially violates T-Mobile's right to both procedural and substantive due process, as guaranteed by both the United States and California Constitutions, enforceable by means of section 1983 of the federal Civil Rights Act T-Mobile has appealed the District Court's July 9, 2010 Order Therefore, any action taken by the City under the claimed authority of that Order is, as already stated,without any 301412_7 DOC nossaman corn R Mayor Cathy Green and Members of .�e City Council August 27,2010 Page 2 rn legal basis T-Mobile submits this letter and any additional evidence under protest, without waiving its challenge to the legality of the Court's July 9, 2010 Order, or to the unlawful procedure planned by the City for reconsideration of T-Mobile's permits The same conditions apply to T-Mobile's appearance at the August 30 hearing, and any presentation made at the hearing 1. THE FACTS ARE UNDISPUTED AND THE LAW IS CLEAR: RECONSIDERATION IS IMPROPER. A. Any Action Taken by the City Will Be Untimely. As the City Council is aware, the City administratively approved the wireless permits in August and September 2007, and the building permits in April 2009 The City Council unanimously approved the Site License Agreements in January 2009 Under the City's Code, anyone who wanted to challenge the validity of the wireless permits, including any member of the City Council, had ten days to seek administrative appellate review (Huntington Beach Zoning Code §§ 248 16, 248 24, 248 28 ) No such administrative appeals were taken Further, no lawsuits were filed to challenge the issuance of the permits (Gov Code, §§ 65009(c)(1) and 65901(a) [establishing 90-day statute of limitations for challenging permits] ) Thus, any attempt by the City Council to reconsider T-Mobile's permits at this late date is improper under the City's Code, and prohibited by state law The City Council is fully aware of this legal reality, as both the City Council and City Attorney conceded at the July 20, 2010 City Council meeting that there is no authority under state or local law to reconsider or revoke the administrative approvals T-Mobile applied for the wireless permits more than three years ago, the City granted both The federal Telecommunications Act of 1996 ("Telecom Act") mandates that State and local governments "act on a request for authorization to place, construct, or modify personal wireless service facilities within a reasonable period of time " (47 U S C § 332(c)(7)(13)(n) ) In 2009, the Federal Communications Commission ruled that, under the Telecom Act, a presumptive "reasonable time" to act on an application is 90 days for a proposed collocation facility and 150 days for all other types of facilities (In the Matter of Petition for Declaratory Ruling to Clarify Provisions of Section 332(c)(7)(B) (2009) 24 F C C R 13994, 13995 ) Thus, any action taken by the City at the August 30, 2010 hearing will be unreasonably delayed, and therefore violates section 332(c)(7)(13)(n) of the Telecom Act (E g, Sprint Spectrum L P v Town of Farmington (D Conn. 1997) 1997 U S. Dist LEXIS 15832, at pp *18-19, Sprint Spectrum L P v Jefferson County (N D. Ala 1997) 984 F Supp 1457, 1468- 1469 ) B. The City Has Twice Reaffirmed the Validity of the Permits and Approvals. Since July 6, 2009, long after the City Council became aware of the objections of some residents, and long after the City Council had invoked Measure C on the basis of T-Mobile's cost estimates, the City twice reaffirmed the validity of the permits and approvals Specifically, as recited in the July 31, 2009 declaration of City Attorney Jennifer McGrath, a declaration signed 301412_7 DOC Mayor Cathy Green and Members of Me City Council August 27,2010 Page 3 rh under penalty of perjury, on July 6, 2009, the City Council met in closed session and "unanimously affirmed the validity of T-Mobile's Wireless Permits, building permits, and Site License Agreements " The City Attorney, under the express direction of the City Council, reaffirmed the validity of T-Mobile's permits and approvals a second time in a July 23, 2009 letter, stating Despite the protests, the City continues to recognize the validity of the Site Licenses and the Wireless Permits However, it was immediately after the protests that the City learned that the construction costs exceeded $100,000 The City now is obligated to enforce Section 612 Consequently, by way of a separate memorandum to the Building Department, I have directed that both building permits be suspended until voter approval can be obtained If and when Omnipoint obtains voter approval, the suspensions will be lifted, and Omnipoint may construct the towers (Emphasis added) Given this history, any attempt by the City to justify the reconsideration of T-Mobile's permits not only rings hollow, it is contrary to state law (Eg, 59 Ops Cal Atty Gen 123, 128 (1976) [explaining that "factual determinations are conclusive and binding, and that (a public agency) has no jurisdiction or authority to reopen the matter"], Congregation Etz Chaim v City of Los Angeles (9th Cir 2004) 371 F 3d 1122, 1123-1125 [city estopped from revoking permit] ) C. T-Mobile Has a Vested Right to Construct the Facility. The City is estopped from reconsidering the permits and approvals because T-Mobile has a vested right to construct the Harbour View facility Following the City's issuance of the building permits, T-Mobile commenced substantial work at the Harbour View site, including excavation and grading, construction and installation of a vault, and installation of a concrete base for the facility T-Mobile also placed numerous orders for necessary equipment and materials, investing more than $200,000 in construction related costs Thus, because T-Mobile has performed substantial work and incurred substantial liabilities, it has obtained a vested right to construct the Harbour View facility (E g, San Diego Reg'l Comm'n v See the Sea, Ltd (1973) 9 Cal 3d 888 [developer obtained vested right because he performed substantial work and "spent $79,000 in construction, also incurring finance charges"], Griffin v County of Marin (1958) 157 Cal App 2d 507, 508-511 [developer obtained vested right because he "employed a contractor with a bulldozer who cleaned off the surface of the ground and at one end of the property leveled off a high area"], Kissinger v Los Angeles (1958) 161 Cal App 2d 454, 463 [developer obtained vested right because "expended the sum of$2,300 in work done"] ) Given this vested right, state law prohibits the City from either reconsidering or rescinding T-Mobile's permits and/or approvals at the August 30, 2010 hearing 301412_7 DOC Mayor Cathy Green and Members of use City Council August 27,2010 Page 4 ra 2. THE FEDERAL TELECOMMUNICATIONS ACT OF 1996 PROHIBITS THE CITY FROM TAKING ANY ACTION TO RESCIND T-MOBILE'S PERMITS. A. Any Attempt to Justify the Rescission of T-Mobile's Permits Will Be Pretextual, and Therefore Unlawful. After issuing all necessary permits for the facilities,the City invoked Measure C in an effort to block their construction and appease members of the public who opposed their installation because of fears over the perceived health effects of radio frequency emissions The City made this position clear when Deputy City Administrator Bob Hall stated in his May 11, 2009 letter that "[i]t is the desire of the City of Huntington Beach to get this area returned to the pre-construction condition as soon as possible to reassure to the neighbors that no cell tower will be installed at this location " Since the District Court invalidated the application of Measure C, the City has indicated that it will submit a second pretextual argument in an attempt to block the construction of the facilities However, any argument concocted by the City at this late date (or any other) in an effort to support the rescission of T-Mobile's permits is prohibited by section 332(c)(7)(B)(iv) of the Telecom Act (E g, Cal RSA No 4 v Madera County (E D Cal 2003) 332 F Supp 2d 1291, 1311 [rejecting complaints about property values because pretextual], Cellular Tel Co v Town of Oyster Bay(E D N Y 1998) 1999 U S Dist LEXIS 21500, at pp *13-15 [rejecting purported findings regarding "safety concerns, air quality and the general welfare" because pretextual] ) B. Post Hoe Justifications Are Prohibited. Besides the prohibition in section 332(c)(7)(B)(iv), because the City failed to assert any justification other than Measure C for suspending T-Mobile's permits, it is estopped to present new arguments in an effort to further delay the construction of the facilities (See, e g Preferred Sates, LLC v Troup County (1 Ith Cir 2002)296 F 3d 1210, 1220, fn 10 ["Appellants may not rely on rationalizations constructed after the fact"], Nextel of N Y, Inc v City of Mount Vernon (S D N Y 2005) 362 F Supp 2d 336, 342 [denial could not be based on impacts not mentioned during the initial administrative process] ) C. The City Cannot Rely on Zoning Code Section 241.10.A to Rescind T- Mobile's Permits. On July 26, 2010, we received a letter from Deputy City Attorney Scott Field stating that the City Council "will consider whether there are alternative sites available to T-Mobile that would better meet the land use criteria of Zoning Code Section 241 10 A for issuing conditional use permits " However, for the reasons explained in Section E below, under Resolution No 3766, the only applicable local law in place at the time T-Mobile's wireless permits were approved by the City, a conditional use permit was not required Thus, any attempt by the City to rescind T-Mobile's permits based on the requirements of Section 241 10 A will violate the Telecom Act (E g, Verizon Wireless (VAW) LLC v Douglas County(D Kan 2008) 544 301412_7 DOC Mayor Cathy Green and Members of we City Council August 27,2010 Page 5 F Supp 2d 1218, 1246, Group EMF, Inc v Coweta County (N D Ga 1999) 131 F Supp 2d 1335, 1343 ) D. The City Cannot Rely on a New Ordinance to Rescind T-Mobile's Permits. T-Mobile's permits were granted under City Ordinance No 3766, the City cannot rely on a later enacted zoning code in an effort to deny T-Mobile's already-issued permits (See, e g, Huntington Beach Zoning Code § 230 96 C 1 ) E. A Rescission of T-Mobile's Permits Will Lack the Support of Substantial Evidence. City Senior Planner Jason Kelley, in a declaration signed under penalty of perjury, testified that City Resolution No 3766 authorizes the Planning Director to administratively approve "the [wireless] permit regardless of whether a `gap in coverage exists' or whether the proposed location is not `the least obtrusive location feasible "' Moreovet, Mr Kelley explained in his declaration Regardless of the existence of a coverage gap or less obtrusive alternative, under Section 3 C of Ordinance No 3766, the Planning Director may administratively approve antennas that are (a) Co- located with other antennas, (b) "Completely stealth facilities and that comply with the base district height limit," or (c) "Facilities in non-residential districts that are in compliance with the maximum building height permitted within the zoning district, and (i) "Screened from view and not visible from beyond the boundaries of the site at eye level (six feet), (ii) "Substantially integrated with the architecture of the existing building or structure to which it is to be mounted," or(in) "Designed to be architecturally compatible with surrounding building and land used by incorporating stealth techniques " Finally, Mr. Kelley explained, consistent with the above, that"Section 3 C 1 c ill did apply, because the antennas were located in a non-residential zoning district . , [and] they were screened from view, and designed to be architecturally compatible with surrounding land uses by incorporating stealth techniques within the meaning of Section 3 C 1 c iii of Ordinance No 3766 " Thus, as stated by the City's representative under the penalty of perjury, T-Mobile's facilities complied with the requirements of City Ordinance No 3766 Accordingly, any attempt by the City to rescind T-Mobile's permits based on alternatives, gap or aesthetics will be without substantial evidence, and therefore violate section 332(c)(7)(B)(iii) of the Telecom Act (See MetroPCS, Inc v City & County of San Francisco (9th Cir 2005) 400 F 3d 715, 725 [a decision cannot be supported by substantial evidence if it is not "authorized by applicable local regulations"], T-Mobile Central, LLC v Unified Govt of Wyandotte County(IOth Cir 2008) 546 301412_7 DOC Mayor Cathy Green and Members of use City Council August 27,2010 Page 6 rh F 3d 1299, 1308 [holding that because finding was not required by the local wireless ordinance it could not provide substantial evidence to support the denial] ) The scope of the District Court's July 9, 2010 Order also precludes the City from attempting to reverse T-Mobile's permits based on a finding relating to alternatives, gap or aesthetics The scope of the Order limits the City's reconsideration because it specifies the "new" facts for reconsideration- (i) "that the projects cost as much as 200,000", (11) "the distaste of the citizens for the antennas", and (in) that Measure C cannot be relied on" As an initial matter, T-Mobile notes that"project costs" are immaterial to the issuance of wireless permits, as there is nothing in City Resolution No 3766 requiring the disclosures of project costs Thus, "project costs" cannot provide a legitimate basis for rescinding T-Mobile's wireless permits (MetroPCS, Inc v City & County of San Francisco, supra, 400 F 3d at p 725, T-Mobile Central, LLC v Unified Govt of Wyandotte County, supra, 546 F 3d at p 1308 ) As for the building permits, those are ministerial in nature, and there is nothing in the City's Code that authorizes the City Council to review such permits or deny them based on a cost estimate Therefore, the cost of construction cannot serve as a basis for rescinding the building permits (Ibid) For the reasons explained above, the "distaste of the citizens for the antennas" also cannot provide substantial evidence for rescinding T-Mobile's permits (E g, 47 U S C § 332(c)(7)(B)(iv), Cal RSA No 4 v Madera County, supra, 332 F Supp 2d at p 1311 ) Finally, the fact that the City was not aware that Measure C could not be invoked cannot provide substantial evidence for rescinding T-Mobile's permits, as the City twice reaffirmed the validity of the permits after invoking Measure C Moreover, because the City approved the permits prior to invoking Measure C, the fact that Measure C cannot be invoked now is immaterial to their validity T-Mobile also notes that because the issue of whether Measure C applies or does not apply is a determination that is not made, under the City's Charter,until after all permits are issued, it is clearly not a criterion that is relevant to the decision of whether to issue the permits Accordingly, as none of the three purportedly "new" facts justify rescission, any action by the City purporting to rescind T-Mobile's permits will lack the support of substantial evidence F. Rescinding T-Mobile's Permits Will Result in an Effective Prohibition of Service. Even if the City were to consider the issues of significant gap and alternatives, the evidence submitted by T-Mobile, during both the judicial and administrative proceedings, demonstrates a significant gap in service and a lack of available and feasible alternatives This unavoidable conclusion is further buttressed by the Declaration of Daniel Wang, which is enclosed herewith Accordingly, any attempt by the City to rescind T-Mobile's permits will result in an effective prohibition of service, in violation of section 332(c)(7)(B)(i)(II) of the Telecom Act 301412_7 DOC Mayor Cathy Green and Members of the City Council August 27,2010 Page 7 rh As T-Mobile has already demonstrated, wireless telephone service is not only a staple of American life, it is essential to both public safety and public welfare and convenience T-Mobile therefore has a critical need for reliable in-building and in-vehicle coverage According to the Federal Communications Commission ("FCC"), nearly every American carries a wireless device. (Implementation of Section 6002(b) of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1993, Annual Report and Analysis of Competitive Mkt Conditions With Respect to Commercial Mobile Services, Thirteenth Report(2009) 24 F C C R 6185, 6292-93, 228 ("Thirteenth Annual Report") ) Today, more people subscribe to wireless telephone service than to traditional landlmes in the United States (Howard A Shelanski,Adjusting Regulation to Competition Toward a New Model for U S Telecommunications Policy(2007) 24 Yale J on Reg 55, 70) Approximately 60% of all Americans, and "virtually everyone in the United States between 15 and 69 has a wireless phone " (Thirteenth Annual Report, supra, 24 F C C R at p 6292, ¶ 228 ) For many Americans, wireless services have become an indispensable replacement for traditional landline telephones In 2003 the number of"wireless only" households represented roughly three percent of the total (Id at p 6293, � 229 ) A survey released by the Center for Disease Control and Prevention estimated that by the end of 2009 the number of wireless-only households had increased to 24 5%, more than eight times greater than the percentage reported in 2003, and 14 9% of American homes that have landlmes now receive all or almost all calls on their wireless telephones (Dep't of Health & Human Services Center for Disease Control & Prevention, Wireless Substitution Early Release of Estimates from the National Health Interview Survey, June - December 2009 available at http //www cdc gov/nchs/data/nhis/ earlyrelease/wireless201005 htm [last visited Aug 6, 2010] ) For Americans living in wireless-only homes and those outside their homes, cell phones are often their sole lifeline in emergencies Public safety agencies estimate that approximately 50% of the emergency 911 ("E-911") calls they receive daily are placed from cell phones (FCC Consumer Facts Wireless 911 Services available at http //www fcc g�ov/cgb/consumerfacts/ wireless911 srvc html [last visited Aug 6, 2010] ) The FCC estimates that more than a quarter of a million E-911 calls are placed from cell phones every day (In re Petition ofAss'n of Public- Safety Commc'ns Officials-Int'1, Inc for a Declaratory Ruling re Wireless E911 Location Accuracy Requirements (2007) 22 F C C R 20105, 20114 ) Thus, T-Mobile has both a right and an obligation to build its network without unnecessary delay Further, as demonstrated by the evidence submitted by T-Mobile, there is a need for the facilities at issue, as over 5.855 E911 calls were received from the areas immediately adjacent to the proposed facilities in the month of July alone The City should therefore reaffirm T-Mobile's permits so that it may fill the significant gap in service to T-Mobile's customers in Huntington Beach In T-Mobile USA, Inc v City ofAnacortes (9th Cir 2009), 572 F 3d 987, 998, the Ninth Circuit held that when a provider makes a prima facie showing that the proposed facility is the least intrusive means of filling a significant gap, the government cannot simply reject the provider's evidence Instead, the government must show that there are potentially available and technologically feasible alternatives In this case, the City did not even attempt to demonstrate the existence of available and technologically feasible alternatives prior to issuance of the 301412_7 DOC Mayor Cathy Green and Members of me City Council August 27,2010 Page 8 rn wireless permits And, as demonstrated above, the City's current efforts to reverse T-Mobile's permits constitute no more than unlawful post hoc rationalizations, which are precluded by law The propagation maps submitted by T-Mobile in support of its permit applications, during the judicial proceedings, and most recently enclosed herewith, demonstrate that there is a significant gap in both in-vehicle and in-home coverage in the areas of Huntington Beach to be served by the Harbour View and Bolsa View sites (E g, Metro PCS, Inc v City & County of San Francisco (N D Cal 2006) 2006 WL 1699580, at p *10 [a gap in a provider's in-home coverage that consists of more than a few isolated pockets of inadequate in-home coverage suffices to show a significant gap exists] ) The significance of the gap is further confirmed by the E-911 data, population data, and "dropped call" data submitted to the City herewith, as Exhibits 1, 2, 3, 8 and 9 (E g, T-Mobile Central, LLC v Unified Govt of Wyandotte County, supra, 546 F 3d at p 1309, Cellular Tel Co v Zoning Bd of Adjustment of Harrington Park (D N J 2000) 90 F Supp 2d 557, 565 ) When, while T-Mobile's permit applications were under consideration, the City requested additional information pertaining to the coverage gap, T- Mobile provided all the information requested by the City The City, on that basis, found that T- Mobile fully complied with the requirements of Resolution No 3766, and issued the permits T-Mobile submits herewith the application materials that had previously been submitted by T-Mobile, which resulted in a determination by the City that T-Mobile had fully satisfied the City's wireless ordinance, on that basis, the City granted the wireless permits for both the Harbour View Park and Bolsa View Park facilities In addition, when the City contended during the federal lawsuit that there were alternatives to the Harbour View site (the City having earlier determined that the site was the least obtrusive available), T-Mobile provided to the Court and to the City the Declaration of Michael Getaneh, a T-Mobile radio frequency expert, along with numerous exhibits, confirming the significant gap in T-Mobile's coverage, and demonstrating the inability of the sites proposed by the City and its consultant, Jonathan Kramer, to satisfy the coverage need Along with the Getaneh Declaration and exhibits, T-Mobile submits herewith Exhibits 21 and 22, which provide a further explanation of why Harbour View and Bolsa View are the least obtrusive alternatives available The City has proposed no other alternative sites, available and feasible or otherwise The record of this proceeding begins with T-Mobile's original applications for the Bolsa View and Harbour View sites, submitted on or about July 24, 2007 In addition to this letter, the record includes all of the materials T-Mobile has provided to the City regarding the facilities, including the materials provided during the prior administrative proceedings, and the judicial proceedings in T-Mobile West Corp v City of Huntington Beach, copies of which are with the City These materials must be made a part of the administrative record and considered at the reconsideration hearing scheduled for August 30 As far as Bolsa View Park is concerned, there are likewise no available and feasible alternatives, and the City at no time prior to the issuance of T-Mobile's wireless permits, or during the federal litigation, suggested otherwise The search ring for the Bolsa View site is relatively small, and includes only residential properties Two shopping center sites and a golf club site very tentatively suggested by the City Attorney cannot satisfy the coverage need, as confirmed by reference to Exhibits 18-20, propagation maps showing the predicted coverage 301412_7 DOC Mayor Cathy Green and Members of..,e City Council August 27,2010 Page 9 from those sites In addition to failing to satisfy the coverage objective, all of the City's suggestions are highly speculative, as there is no indication of a willing landlord, the likelihood of City approval, whether the City's Code permits the placement of a facility at the locations, or whether the sites are "constructible" As for the issue of least intrusive means,when a provider submits evidence demonstrating that a good faith effort has been made to identify and evaluate less intrusive alternatives, as T-Mobile did in this case, a local agency cannot simply choose to disbelieve the provider's evidence (E g, New Cingular Wireless PCS LLC v Town of Stow (D Mass 2009) 2009 U S Dist LEXIS 58837, at p *25 ) Instead, in order to overcome the provider's showing, competent evidence must be submitted demonstrating either that the provider did not explore the options identified (T-Mobile South, LLC v Coweta County (N D Ga 2009) 2009 U S Dist LEXIS 17067, at pp *22-23), or that other specific, potentially available and technologically feasible alternatives exist (T-Mobile USA, Inc v City ofAnacortes, supra, 572 F 3d at p 998 ) As demonstrated above, after reviewing a number of candidate locations, T-Mobile determined that the proposed sites are the only available and feasible locations given the constraints of the City's Code and other development restrictions imposed by the City on telecommunications facilities, e g , a 125-foot residential setback restriction (e g , CUP App No 09-015) To date, the City has failed to identify a single feasible and available location Accordingly, any action by the City Council purporting to rescind T-Mobile's permits is prohibited by section 332(c)(7)(B)(i)(11) of the Telecom Act 3. BY RECONSIDERING T-MOBILE'S PERMITS, THE CITY WAIVES ANY RIGHT TO CHALLENGE THE INVALIDATION OF MEASURE C. But for the District Court's determination that Measure C cannot be lawfully applied to T-Mobile's permits, the Court would not have issued the remand order Thus, the invalidation of Measure C is a necessary predicate for the City's reconsideration of the permits The City itself has affirmed that reality in its opposition to T-Mobile's recent ex parte application for reconsideration Accordingly, should the City choose to go forward with a rehearing, the City will, as a matter of logical necessity, impliedly affirm the District Court's finding on Measure C, and waive any right to appeal the District Court's invalidation thereof 4. CONCLUSION. The current situation is truly regrettable T-Mobile applied to the City more than three years ago for wireless permits to better serve T-Mobile's customers living in and travelling through Huntington Beach The City granted both permits, after finding that T-Mobile complied with all of the applicable laws of the City Even after the commencement of the federal litigation,the City Council itself reaffirmed the validity of those permits T-Mobile has postponed for far too long the installation of the facilities necessary to serve its customers There is no legal authority whatever for the City's reconsideration and reversal of T-Mobile's permits, and T-Mobile sincerely hopes that the members of the City Council will not give in to the 301412_7 DOC Mayor Cathy Green and Members o� ,ie City Council August 27,2010 Page 10 political pressures of the moment, and take the only action that is right, legal and just reaffirmation of T-Mobile's permits,just as the City Council did more than a year ago Thank you for your consideration of our letter XFlynn of Nossaman LLP JJF/rrg cc Jennifer McGrath, Esq (via email) Scott Field, Esq (via email) 3014127 DOC a- SEQUOIA DOCUMENT TRANSMITTAL COVER SHEET City of Huntington Beach Monica Moretta Department Planning Agent Representative Case Planner To be Determined Sequoia Deployment Services, Inc. on behave of T-Mobile. City of Huntington Beach July 20,, 2007 l: :C{to ll'ry '.OLIIIbRnI Vi ff Mr•.:F nIWRIE APN: 178-761-01 T-Mobile LA13156-A Huntington Harbor Garden Club Park P! Wireless Permit Application Attached please find the following items: Quantity Title 1 Check fol 449 for Planning Fees. 1 One Application for Wireless Permit Application. 1 One Letter of Authorization. 1 One Copy of Agent Authorization. 1 One Project Description. I One Site Justification. I One Set of Pictures of the Site. 1 Set of Propagation Maps including RF Report 3 Set of Photo Simulations. 3 Sets of Complete Plans, I One Set of Plans reduced to 8 1•2 x 11. •,orrvco,•v.r :x The attached items are being submitted to the City of Huntington Beach lot an Application Lot a Wireless Permit Application on behalf of Omnipoint Communication. Inc. a subsidiary of T-Mobile USA, Inc. (T-Mobile). Please contact: Monica Moretta at 19491 241.0175 or monlca.moretta'-,sequoia dsom regarding this application. Thank you. Monica Moretta One venture. Suite 200 Irvine. CA 926IS TELEPHONE:949.241 0175 014E VENTURE. SUITE 200, IRVINE. CA 92618 TELEPHONE: 949.753.7200 EXHIBIT A WMb FOW 2467 I VENTURE STE 200 1901 VM Ve n i• AIM IRVINE.CA 92618 $1tl� SEQUOIA (949)753 7200 inaro.CA 9261� 162411220 .. 7/19/7007_ 1AV TO THE )RDEP OF __ ci1T� nfof Hitntingfrin Raach `� "149 00 One Hundred Fn4-Ninpand DD/100_................................................................................... DOLLARS City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach CA 92648 - -- - -- IEMO SR000433 LA13157B Wireless Facility Permit '013 2467ill 1: 1 2 2000 2 4 71: 20 16 594 18 2 ' CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH WIRELESS PERMIT APPLICATION FORM I C:S °Orni I< neaq is r*.[ I i-C,•ne,: !, r. ''_d :n`c: .:.c11 .'.: .1 iljll: K :. j t . _ ;t nevi or modified p: rw^. tgererally vl• . Pe_r . it foi a ;;veless cr.:. :•. r i ❑., ritintmolon Beach l NE application is a m.andaloiy element of the application process No application for a new wireless site Permit or for a modification of an existing wireless site Pei niit shall be considered for determination of completeness until this form and required attachments are provided to the City of Huntington Bear,h Every page of this form including this paue must he completed and sohnitted to ,he City of Huntington Beach and each page must be signed and/or initialed where Indicated :hiestlons about this login of the requlied inforniauon to be provided shoulu the dfiecled to the City Plannef assigned to your project or to the Director of Planning at(714) 536 5271 for the City of Huntington Beach You are advised to be familiar with the City s Municipal Code and Zoning ana Subdivision nrdinsnre which establishes standards and guidelines for the Installation of vfueless communications facilities in the City of Huntington Beacr :Continue to next page, - Applicant Must Initial Here 1 ?0 Applicant Information Nu�nbrr r44oir t 04 Name cf Property Owner I U Applicant is _ O:•mer —Owner s representative 011iet 1 05 Applicants Address I me 1 - .. t 6� Atoll--grit s Address Lir- 2 ,-,-- 1 08 Applicant's Address Line 3 1 09 Applicants Address Line 4 Pleas*•comae; - - 1 10 Applicant s Phone number _ h1�auca Mere!la Phone No +.I?2.11 Pt 7° Fa.Nu 94C. 753 7'CQ8 t I 1 Applicants Mobilern.mber _ _. _ — rtvv,¢r m+,reva< nni-.vam u,-v.r...,,,pi.,.a ' 12 Applicant F Fax number t 13 Applicants Email address If Applicant is the Property Owner and the narre ano contact information above is the same, initial here_ and proceed to 3 01 <Continue to next page> Page 2 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here Project Owner Information Uiso.x� ine Names Addresses i.c:ntau oerons a,d telephone numbe-s I;,, air I inlr,,t Owre,s ruse addnionat shp�ls f r,-rn:"en and r7l, ; as Atta::hr ie•s F,Oje CT Oxo•er Name U E. caii,er.i irenseai 204 Address Itrne 2j 205 City -_ State lip 2 06 Contact Person Name V% C entact Person s telephone numbenextersion 208 If the Applicant is not the project owner attach a letter of agency appointing the Applicant as representative of the Project Owner(s) in connection with Vu application Designate the letter of agency as -Attachment 2 08' Initial here if Attachment 2 06 is attached to this application and connnue to 3 00 2 09 if the Applicant is not the property owner attach a letter of agency apporntina the F.ppi cant as representative of the Property Owner in connection with this application Designate the letter of agency as Attachment 2 09* Initial here 6 Attachment ? 09 is attached to this application and -critinue to 3 00 Conhnue to next page• ... " 9 Applicant Must Initial Here. _ A Project Purpose _ r..sbtical cif f'r;;::;x- a na; alive acconipameo uy written cur.erri at vt ter- ahprriptlate wai. eY titans life of it of the rl-jt'.ccp[1 Indicate whelner the dommar.t purpo=_e o` ti c Proles is tc and additional nctwor, apac ty Ic hcrease. existing a: iw, ;,r :c prowde ilea radio Ir(=quenc) o'Vw agir ,check Only one) __. Add network capacity without adding significant new RP coverage area Int.rease the exrstng RF signal revel in an existing coverage area Provide new radio frequency coverage to a significant area not already served by existing radio frequency coverage by the same Owner or afhhalea entity (stlrh as a ruanung agreement with an affiliated entity for a cellular or PCS carrier) Other 303 It the answer in 4 02 is not Other' proceed to 5 00 1:4 :iilact) a statement fully and expancn;ely describing !he Other dominant purpose of this proleca Designate this attachment. Attachment 4 04 nrtai here to indicate that Attachment 4 04 is attached to this application 'Continue tc next page> r'-„ . 4 ;! Applicant Must Initial Here 'J Radio Frequency Coverage Maps a uceace a;alas tc pu�ioe menu heq.,ency geograc•nit,coverage to a defined area from the Pl Ojecl ihrCluduuj app6"anis in Iho cellular PC tri•adcaet FSI\'1P'Sf.1,R cateaci es 1^e ccvcray- end 1n'c"r etiRh re.,Ie_teo t.el"v. alE ,eI.:oed atlachments All oth<rs proceed to 7 ::0 c' r..'i/r"qc 'itct 1'...','] Lie 1'1,- :JI. VXIn 'I3-Ti:.!. (11jWJt,,WCr :S .I[::,, I The size of each submitted map must be no smaller than 8 5 by 1 F and all maps must be of the same physical size scale and depict the same geographic area Include major streets anrt sired names On each map All maps must share a ccmmcn color scherne If the FCC rules for any proposed radio service define a mmnnum rwiro frequency slgral strength level that level must be shown on the map in a odor easily distinguishable from the base paper or transparency layer. and adequately Identified by RF level and map color or gradient m the map legend If no minimum signal level is defined by the FCC rules you must indicate that in the legend of each RF coverage map You may show other RF signal level(s) on the map so long as they are adequately identified by objective RF level and map color or gradient in the map legend RF coverage maps with labels such as In BuildingIn Car and Outdoor cr referenona a link budget without come<ooitomc signal strengti-s in tinits ^f oBm will be relecteU •i Where the City of Huntington Beach determines that one or more submitted maps are inadequate it reserves the naht to require ?hat one of more supplemental maps with greater or different detail be submitted ,102 Map of existing RF coverage within the City of Huntington Beach on the same network if any (if none so state) T-his map should not depict any RF signal coverage to be provided by the Project Designate this map Aliachnient 6 02 Initial here :* to militate that Attachment 6 02 Is attached to this application 403 Map of RF coverage to be provided only uy the Project This map should not depict any RF coverage provided by any other existing of proposed wireless sites Designate this map Attachment 6 03 Initial here to Indicate that Attachment 6 03 is attached to this application 404 Map of RF coverage to Le provided by the Project and by other wireless sites on the same network should the Project he approved Designate this map Attachment 6 04 Initial hele to Ind,cate that Attachment 6 04 is attached to this apckCahn". Continue to next page% h95 4114l'0:7 Page 5 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here Project Photographs and Photo Simulations 1•' lVh :e ar f:pi•6Cani orgposes I. cons:ri:-: -,r "rPT."r a *irF'1es5 sre !tie i%l:D ..a:'t '! f I, t Is snc r,.Ino I'le crg;E;! ;hey _,. ceno•�. o'�on5lruCp_n all .,on> ch-nt r.ilii ti!r irr,;,;.iuu siarrJdn;, i1Le ai eaCh pi a! Sin!l:l�; Cl' n..;5; Irr_ �t '• i ; i 1 (pcniait or landscape onenlatior). All elernents of the project as proposed by the .Applicant must be shown in one or mere close-in photo simulations The overall project as proposed by the Aofdirant must be shown in five or mare area photos and photo sim Ulatign5 Ph'OIOs and phalo slnwlatwn viaws mllsl a! a n- nun lri. be lakes from vncjely scattered positions separated uy an angle of no greater than 72 degrees from any ott:et photo location For each photograph and photo simulation show on an at ea map the location and perspective angle of each photograph and photo simulation in relationship In the Project lo.c.ajior All before and after photos and photo sfmWahons must be of the same scale For exampie 09 not place a smaller before photo in a box on the same page a5 a large after photo siniuiatron t he number of site photos and photo simulations and the actual or simulated camera location of these photos and photo simulations are subject to City of Huntington Beach de!erminatior) The Applicant must s.ibnut photos and photo simulations consistent w tih these instructions. and be prepared to provide additional photos and photo ssmulations should they be requested by the City of Huntington Beach Continue to next page Page 6 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here Candidate Sites : f ur appucat s :;; lire �c.iular f'i.S hroaucast ESIv1R,AMR calegones ar,:! owers as requesteo Icy the C itv of Kirvirlgtcn P=-ar:' :. I las the =•.r.f ,:ard LI Gwner ; ; anyone v.c,rr.;::e �:t ucna�: C•� Ine Applicant c, Ov.: ae:..reQ Cr atien-ptea t(. SejJ'e any iease5 (:r IEaTe-Gpllcns o! Shills; foulla. !.r informal agreements in connection with this project for any sites other than the candidate site Identified at 1 01 and 1 029 Yes No 03 If the answer to 8 02 Is NO proceed to 8 ')L +; Oa Provide the physical address of each such other location and p,owde. an expansive technical explanation as to why each such other site was disfavored over the Prol,rd Site Pesm^ate this altachmeut Attachment E C1. IRIUal here _ to indicate that Attachment o Oc Is attached to this applicahr,l- u US Considering this proposed site. is it the one and only one location within or without the Cady of Huntington Beach that can posslbfy meet the objectives of the project" Yes No b6 if the answer to e 05 is NO proceed to 9 00 r, C Provloe a technically expansive and delalled explanation suopcned as lequrred t,.y comprehensive radio frequency data fully describing why the proposed site is the one and only one location within or without the City of Huntington Beach that can possibly meet the radio frequency objectives of the project Explain, in exact and expansive technical detan all of the objectives of this project Designate this attachment Attachment 8 07 Initial here to indicate that Attachment b 07 is attached to this application. <Contmue to next page> --SY? bva srwr�r Page 7 of 9 Applicant(dust Initial Here _ 0 Identification of Key Persons tf.. I .n; Gqe selection la !h; OMr"-,Sao Na•'le TIME 13 Company Affiliation - - 7 14 Work Address .:.. 1E Telephone I Ext - Email Address. 7 20 •.7) The radio freruency engineering of the proposed piaect Name -- --- ----- 7 2? Title 7 23 Company Affiliation __-- 7 24 Work Address 7 -5 Telephone /Ext - s 26 Email Address �1 Releclion of other candidate sites evalualea. it any Name Title Company Affiliation -- 7 34 Work Address 7 35 Telephone/Ext i6 Emal Address ,_-_----�-�,--- -- . 40 141 Appieval of the selection of the proposed site Identified in this project 41 Name 43 Company Art I.ation 44 Work Address t 45 Telephone / Ext 746 Email Address If more than one person is/was involved in any of the fovn functions identified in this section, attach a separate sheet providing the same information for each additional person and identifying which function or functions are!were performed by each additional person Designate this attachment Attachment i 5` Initial here to indicate that the information above is complete and there is no Attachment 7 5, or initial here to indicate that Attachment 7 5 is attached to his application. - <Connnue to next nape- Page 8 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here Form Certification WJ,i ilgi t.i c,.:':e- e:F:Co' .,• d5cn a:,.: u'.r. lr.pn,:aci In2t Ine a:'$V.c:s I r•iv ded Vyercrare;t:.ii n"i c;'Of nCI- I:: J! IL. unaersiyned s F.ngwledge /,reyl Title Frint Name T Fina,l Address riv Compan� �Name ielepnonF Numbenexten'ion Date SIOPCI 'Stop Here End of Forme Cite of Huntington Beach 2000 MAIN STREE CALIFORNIA 9264P 'r I)P11 W-1 \It N t )l I I I I\III Ili.\ 1-1.0i'mi- N I nnccb I I-1.4,AY, A;y' ncAu.I,q a1,of 1, >-t, a_ l a, I-1413-S 11S- ILauwX 1"14)S36.g:12 IJ, a Inga•nal I'nnnrna�k. i I" I lo,a RL: Lcnel III au1110Ti/,Jinn u, aui,lnil :at ::pph;alioli Inc l nditi nr:l I i'rrntil tor.l1!ulnl ,ItCI �nuslsc I-Drls;t IN ico I;mk (\I-I Iirlghllnl I11. I I"Ill)(Ior I.I; I I I:n'hout \ Ic%% Park 1,\\ w 1161 and 1�:Mllooll) ileac \1r Ih,-nq',o:l I his Irnrt LI:011, I -\II,Nic. I N V Inc prrini,,wn t,• aci as ItLcnt ❑,; Ihr 1111r purpose' of nlakirlL ::m and all ,q,hlicaliom ncrc<s:.r\ to acyuin prrnnts !I, :"'mmunic;a inn Izcilip\ :it the aho\ententione.iloc;nanl,. Plc,1.rheamilerIh:n ,ou Mid \onlclientundertakeIhlsende,nl,I .0 %oul (mvi risk. .\n\ Mid all cI,<l and c\pcmrs e-Ilh %otrr pursue of the,r penrltl, is t von sole c�epensc. I his •rant of ,author)/anion der, not in an% %%a\ impl% that a pernml>I \till Ile gramcd he the I'it\. nor dons it impl\ in any %%a\ than an agreement %till he reached lhr lease or license o1 this I:tcilit\ hom the I it% I urther. the I•ilr is not directl\ stating nor iulpl\ing I,\ \)title of Ilhis authori/alion the I-Mohile hill permission or Ihr Iccal right Ili lease or sublease this lacilil\ of add additional \tireless carriers to the site tlllcelel\. rllee I'IIt/;II v/ Ucput\ I)irrrinl. I .nnomic I)r%clopnlcnl Krum kctl I1:1\I,11), llllll:'IICI I ,ll.11ll:n l% v PROJECT DESCRIPTION FOR y. LA1 3156-A HUNTINGTON HARBOR GARDEN CLUB PARK Si CZ[J o l l\ 16600 SAYBROOK. HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 APN: 178-761-01 Ofolopnuu (nmmunual tons. Inc. a subsidiary of T le, pile USA. It,( . IT "(diner [)[Opuses W construct. upefate and maintain a wifeless leleconnnrfnicatfons facility rnnsisting of twelve 021 panel antenna, in three Of sec 1nrn. two (2) 61`5 antennas, six (61 BTS t •!e;on.n uerir atirrr equipment cabinets. coaxial (able Ions from the antennas to the BTS. and power and Telco utility connections. In older to completely conceal the wireless facility the panel antennas will be attached to a new fifty five 1551 foot monopalm and two twenty fise 051 live palm lives. The equipment (,,[)fuels will be located in a lease area 1n a underground vault. No utility apparatus will be lusted above ground. All utilities for the project will be routed underground. This location also provides tot easy maintenance access floor Saybrook Lane and Heil Avenue. the coverage objective of the site is primarily the residential neighborhoods located to the ninth ,south and west of the intersection Saybtook Lane and Talisman Lane. This area adfefs d lack of coverage. resulting in poor service for T Mobile's custmners and limited wireless t elecornmunicat ions service options for the residents and visitors to the area. T-Mobite underwent a search tot potential site locations that included properties along Saybrook ln. and Heil Ave. T Mobile approached the Ocean View School District regarding Harhur View l.lementaty, however they declined any deals with wueless carriers. T Mobile's also considered (,race Lutheran Scholl, but this location is too far from the ling center and to close to an .existing site. The search was limited to these areas because they provide the only potentially :one able st, locatiuns in the sea[h area The plopelly also provided an opportunity to locate the monopalm approximately three hundred 000) feet from residential zoned property. The ,ty code preference for disguising the facility and aesthetically integfated into then surroundings determined the site location and design. The properties within other parts of the ,earth area ware ruled out du their zoning (PS B RL I speufically surrounded this site locanon. T Mobile was also limited fit where the facility could be sited in relationship in other nearby facilities in the area (surrounding facilities are shown nn the RF propagation maps included with this application) which limited the ability of the site to be located at the intersection of Saybrook Lane and Heil Ave. Street the proposed site is currently developed as a park with a existing mature landscaping. The surrounding area of Huntington Harbor Garden Club Park is rharacteitzed by mature palm flees and thus a monopalm is not an uncommonly seen part of the landscape. The property is completely developed and encompasses the necessary infrastructure to serve both the existing =.nd proposed facilities. The prupuxrd wuelvss facility will be located lu the east of the park and will not block access into the site of site circulation. Existing access is adequate in serving the parking needs during maintenance visits. The proposed facility will not impact potential dr:elupment in the surrounding area. The proposed lo(alion was selected based !)n Urt willuigaess of the City of Huntington Beach Iu allow the installation on the property. and based on the compatibility of the surrounding area with the proposed wireless telecommunications facility and the fact that this is the tallest point on the property. The proposed project wilt be unoccupied and only require a single maintenance visit per month The project will make negligible noise that is most often less Via[ the ambfrot noise level of file area surrounding the equlpnfent. In fart. the BTS radio equipment will be fit an underground vault and will not be visible to file general public. wireless facilities are passive in nature and have been located fit all zoning districts without ❑npacting proper tv values. 1 SITE JUSTIFICATION STUDY FOR •, ' LA1 31 56-A HUNTINGTON HARBOR GARDEN CLUB PARK S C(�(101 A 16600 SAYBROOK. HutoINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 APN: 178-761-01 Omnipoint Communications. Inc. a subsidiary of T Mobile USA. Inc. ( i Mobile( selected the proposed location for a needed wireless facility as It was the best (Ocation available lot the facility when considering the needs of the network. land use patterns in the area. willingness of the landlord to enter into a lease for the facility, and the zoning code requirements of the City of Huntington Beach. The facility is needed to correct a hole in network coverage created by the local demand on the existing network. As the number of users of the network increases the coverage area of existing sites decreases creating areas where it is difficult to make a call or keep a call connected. The area surrounding the proposed site, approximately at the intersection of Saybrook Lane and Heil Drive. suffers from this situation. This intersection and surroundings became the target search area for the facility. The facility will increase signal strength and the network capacity in and surrounding the neighborhood adjacent to the site to better serve the communications needs of the residents, workers and visitors in the City of Huntington Beach. Radio frequency propagation maps shows the existing coverage and the modeled coverage after installation of the facility at the proposed height are attached. Approval of the facility at the proposed height provides the needed coverage for the surrounding neighborhood. providing a high quality signal for both indoor and outdoor users of the network. The proposed site is zoned OS_PR-Parks and Recreation Subdistrict. All adjacent land uses are zoned mostly residential and public/semipublic. In fact, the land use pattern to the north, south and west is all residential, However, the property to the east is zoned PS, and currently developed as Harbor View Elementary School. The alternative candidates were ruled out due to the lack of interest to lease space in their properties or will not satisfy T-Mobile's coverage objective. T-Mobile's first choice was to attached antennas to the existing ball field light at Harbor Elementary School, however they rejected T-Mobile's offer and ruled out this location. The current location is best suited for the facility as it offers space for the equipment and antennas, when considering zoning restrictions and design compatibility and offers the best opportunity to screen the installation from public view through the use of screening. Ail equipment is proposed to be rn a underground vault and hidden from public views. This equipment location was selected as the space available created did not altered the pedestrian circulation patterns or character of the existing development. The proposed facility is an unmanned telecommunications facility and has no habitable or occupied space. The facility will operate (transmit and receive calls) 24 hours per day for residents and visitors of Huntington Beach. The facility has no "employees" or "customers" per se. Customer use does not require any access to the facility and only periodic maintenance is performed on the facility (approximately one ro SITE JUSTIFICATION STUDY FOR ( LA1 31 56-A HUNTINGTON HARBOR GARDEN CLUB PARK 16600 SAYBROOK. HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 AP14: 178-761-01 hour per month.I Existing streets, acres drives, and circulation patterns a,e adequate to serve the project and will not he inrpac Led b> Lh� prOjecl. i few r � .alb.`-. y..♦ AA w � . Itrig _ �♦Mid �� _ _ i Odom as y n 1 W - u,I I _ •. y � T � J Vitw LOOKIMr,SOUTH EA( Vit l c t•4'� 4y i cti F. VIFW $puns W.sr 9.; 11 „. ■u{ zS i gmW m --fir ' \r it fPO�'STTf tnlll Pic Nne TF WE i �..` . - y • -1Fa- :. c 44 ",AN VIEW Or THE CITt --- __�— �'.�tR• � ..F �R.si� � - � 1 ,rjr V; •1 —'•�� ' .• �'?• �'y'��^�'/�Vim. L.: �> �! Ih. l'Ipil�u•K 11'Il� lt�l: l..A l;�l.�li;\ Ill \'I IN"i11 I\ IL11;L� � l'I.1 It l'.\Itl: h )( )(-)I A I lilil 11 I}UltKl tt tli III ill Ntrrnx BV\1'11, CA W,,; I' APNX 1 ," lNl nl r-- I I I I- 1 V � . - s +�a � x :�� ��, e:^ 4��' � A �?�` '.� ..� .k ry .. �F.� ice: `,;, , „ '1� .jai- - •..: ,. �� .. w ;a t'.t .� �> �I11. I'Il��l�u•h \1'II� F��I: I. �I:ilali,\ {II \fl\G'III\ IL\Rlb II71�.\I:I�I''•. S FOWOIn �;rllll:vv hI:��I,I; III •�. i i'<�:I� r. CI. \� IL ('.\ sr�l; IY 1I'\ !; ;GI ul Pow!c T 7� l I � 1 Ir i a� Site location view from the pai I f ripIj- 1 f Y Tr♦ i t I Current Coverage Without LA13156A ALA' A�2;l,A 1 LA02093A LA02207A LA02060A Lncz49sn LAO2463A m LA02009A LA0226]A Coverage Ley c d i Proposed Coverage with LA13156A Ai m ,r . LA023 I I A LAoz.. 1 r LA02093A LA02207A LA02010A IA0219 A L.A02463A 1_A0:009A LA02267A - rncave Coverage Lrn� r• '��t IPIUmt.Nv1U ryrpl!f1Ym1 M1bJr"bSA 4Kr5Mr1/MIpINr.I1:11K1151ML•IrtW]titllFy mlllM rr�..rA 1Nr•IPfI�\IINI.Ir..\�ntr!V 1p\tll�ll:rl.t �..I<I N..;�.�I ryr;�'1.,.. �.;.�. .. ..Ir.-. tlm llrOn rs 94CIN NIOItldIP[I 1rY[p1TU MP�CI$dr 61 TNOrunm ltP\1rW hrlPks]'[uvMdtF'Ana Mr!liJtlr4.'x mTY O•.r1nq•M.IF UnI nol¢•' p m:ry'n . 10Vmaw I],II m.'1(I$(b nnl(11r.11 JI11Pr'S NVKP.IYdrlTlp itY 1 vU r1 mINIr T CevW NF-TfP.il.llxett•drp$(•vM.111.Ir in la ....:M1 r1ti rv•t'nnrh�M1TI'r lr'\ IIAr' I rr 11C.11 M rNN:llmm $rQ.4 i11PMlm yIINI.....rl .—. inr rl!'1.•:Ir"I "O, wP TtM•r.:Ir r;l(HNrrl i rr1Y 111N,IN.II mTr�IIIr.rN.n.nrtY:\ rrl V•r.i::. ":.\N': �I�LIV in mw4r. rr..Ir ...t.'............r Coverage for Candidate LAI3156A LA02026A� / \ LA02541A LA02207A LA02060A LA02495A LA02;63n A:A'l 1A02069A LA02267A i eroseae Coverage Legend i LA13156 and LA13157 RF Technical Report M Overview The FCC license required T-Mobile to build a wireless network that will provide the best network performance to customers as possible. Also, the FCC license required T- Mobile to put up a wireless network in accordance with the Federal Communication Commission requirements and under the compliance of Federal, State and local mandates laws. The goals of the network performance are to provide best quality, lowest level of blocking, easy access to the network and continuous drop-free connections. Also, the site will operate below the radio frequency emission limits set forth by the Federal Communication Commission. T-Mobile is proposing a site installation located at 16600 Saybrook Avenue, Huntington Beach, CA 92649 and at 5741 Brighton Drive, Huntington Beach, CA 92649 with an effort to adhere all the requirements set by FCC, Federal, State and local mandates. wpm W�_ ■ Site Details Site Details : Site ID : LA13156A Site Name : Huntington Harbor Garden Park Site Address: 16600 Saybrook Avenue, Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Site Design: Palm Tree Site ID : LA13157B Site Name : Bolsa View Park Site Address: 5741 Brighton Drive, Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Site Design: Palm Tree Guidelines used The following guidelines were used to determine the best candidate for site LA13156A and LA13157A: 1 . Site Visit — Visual assessment of the area to search for viable candidates based on location, structure height, topography, lease area. etc. 2. Propagation Analysis — T-Mobile USA uses a prediction tool. known as Asset, to project the expected coverage of the new cell site. 3. Drive Test Data — T-Mobile USA uses real-time data collected from the field to determine the need of an additional site. JW �k La13156 Coverage Objective - - -`_ i �!•sty rrpgrt `tr _ _ = Proposed Site LA03568 has 3 �.s•..yc.,` Gabl -rQ[.-�ta•+ - w sector. . _ �• c a Kin (irti t, Sector A aim to provide residential coverage chi M, p.. 14 r6 towards the area of Hail Q ' _ Ma 9a { ' pa» o Avenue. Saybrook lane. all the way to Humboldt drive and mistral avenue. `'. a -a• i . to r 2. Sector B aim to provide .ti Ct�'4 �HacMr _..�5' _ ,r '=„ z _,_, r _ '• • S Qah residential & commercial ti rJ1p }? 77coverage on Algonquin -pow , -} t "^ ~': - Street and Boardwalk drive F , 3. Sector C aim to provide `.',`�`� w _ .-.� „�.+•-yl •� ' 1 � _-, residential and .� s t . ✓: r ,fir �+. �• Ba iacude �ti qk commercial coverage on CL If :•`3� Davenport and Barona `� ,• . Ijam � _- - ��Fr — lane. V nerAve_. a�.. Cy �#:••a.•.wY i r � Orr. —E 9 - a A � ` � LA13156 Actual Drive test Data's Showing Weak Coverage a. - € Weak coverage on this - LK area (low on In vehicle and y r rav a '-� In Building Coverage) a 1,&& CA h�, 7r}A J - �`� .,. � .Ghyry}Cit . v. i'•id ;•7 ¢{+rancho Dot RE}t• _ .. , �e - __----_— i X .. ,; = ::.�, Existing sites LA02093A. LA02060A and LA02463A ,V it ` '"' cant provide enough P w _. �T $ ��Fernrullc coverage hence LA13136A is being cr 1 f proposed to be installed in �aao oa^ ,�; .% D �.• $ _ r ��,tt� . �.�� narCtt*fl, h Huntington Garden park to r 1s • ...F -,�. o provide the needed coverage as well as a 1 balance coverage with existing sites. °•�•SN� �- Proposed site location is J. symmetrical with existing a� $ <'. �� r, on sites hence required In vonic�e r...a . J 4 coverage objective is meet Coverage Map with the proposed site LA13156A — Prediction plot shows that the j Site can be move here but its all residential a current proposed sites will meet the desired coverage objective. Lao20�1A I ' This also shows a balance ` coverage with existing sites. A02207A Site can also be move towards ? north however, the area is all residential no place to install the site. Huntington Harbor �• park is the only option for this `+ LA02060A site. LA0246"A. I-nvelage Legend �— � i Oin<boi In"eMde In Building _ 4 y In if cm off 4 3 - i i• j Q�� • .m, { r.� a'�� Q O \ 0 Q_ o fD o n O l Oµ N N q a < vU O (A O a D m D r 3 N O N W � O n N y' N pp m aim O N S :3 y Ol '�• d. N °-' 3 w LA13157 Actual Drive test Data's Showing Weak Coverage 5atmv C 1 nrgmnew earcatxrda Lq d r-- — --uf0 i U =LAO.l9:A• —M �ta;l�to +o i * .� c �° Weak coverage on this L L•Au_246lA �' area (low on In vehicle ?' �x �'' t. and In Building Coverage) (� lSenilvvnh Or' ` (4 � , �• t- �� ----- s j�' Athena D e a �.� �> Gl c«�0r Proposed site location is . t . .9 . ---C �,...,;° ,: ;y _: ►1oesDr g ;,,_ symmetrical with existing 1 �¢ ,e s * 'AACDrf = n $ sites hence required .10 "he = _ coverage objective is �;.. , LAo+089A meet. 1 t • aeuw,ta Ln � � ' HammArea is all residential no other place we can install 1 the site that will provide Y balance coverage with �• I-overage Legend ~� ` ' Ka. existing sites. .•.KIP " a s" LAO?517A � _ J 6 ♦ A- t o-,venlne .., -- -- — - - - k4% - . .p _ '44d-KOad Coverage Map with the proposed site LA13157A a aw •�.. k - bra C Dr Prediction plot shows that the current proposed sites will meet the desired coverage v'inler Al •. - �' , l�, r. 5 a objective. This also shows the ,.. 1[• 'y R - C l '. „ ,v •, �„ n�A '' Y i J ; j balance coverage with existing i j! U ,�•,,D. aC, sites. a ` ^ ` ='°�' r Proposed site location is surrounded by residential area. e•• :,, r• Bolsa View Park is the only option for this site. - - A CONCLUSION L A 1315 6A 16600 Saybrook lane Huntington Beach, ( A 1121,44 .,, 1 uoatiun Proposed View I *' T-Mobile USA Sequoia Deployment Svc ` ' •.r lugmndl I'n mlru.uL III]. \,.Wt r Sntlo ,111) 4 ="• `.Iu1.1 \n.l l \''__U- nlnr I .\9!6171 - - - Applicant Contact �' I'lugngaplrir Cimulalbn.Ymvidwl QI: ~- LA 1315 6A 10600 Saybrook Lane Huntington Beach,CA 92634 wS is I1lcalum Proposed View 2 cie., am.•,: w ,Y - „ T-Mobile USA Sequoia Deployment Svc 1 Impon.d R"enrood. 1 h1r\rnlun•, �ndr _'11n ' tiAn6� -Asia, l A'I'-11- IH nlr. l A 9�1.I7f zaps _ _. I-L 7i.0 .' II IfI 'Lly. l.11 Ili-11 `' p/{ 4p�llicanl Conlact 19wfnnm1htt linwlatm.,P,,,,id,-d It,. Exlslln �� DBEAMI .• . .:.: .. . LA 1315 6A 1 h660 Saybrook Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92649 r r •�� • a - / l Loralion Propose View ; Ile 1. T-Mobile USA Sequoia Deployment Svc I Inlpl•n.11 1'runu•n.11lr (Inr\'rnnu r. tiudr !I III ti.mla Ana, (:A'1 70- Inlnr, l 44!I�I7; R.i -1 1'14 i(I-�11111 4J9 '-I I III"11 Appli(ant (Contact - f M...sograplri. Cioudalion.I4ur.Arvl H,: DREAMT LA1315 6A tl,t,tht sa brook Lanc Huntin tun f3eaa'h,CA 92639 j t m alinn -- __ _ 4. View J T-Mobile USA Sequoia Deployment Svc I bnl,rne l'u.nirn.0 llnr h•nlun•. 1unr 9lu Appli,and Conlaal I•luau�,uphi, SimuLninn.PravdrJ Nc: ;7 ;w�, Exlattn ,. LA 1315 6A 16611f1 Saybrook Lane fitintin lon Reach, CA 92649 e l.a___._ '� � r a•�-._ate a A ', aim 4 1 S t e L11/:JIIOn 1 . _ - I ' PraPoti/• View i T-Mobile USA Sequoia Deployment Svc Impelidl l'unnrndd'• flnr\vWtnv. SmIc 2110 ldlll.i :\nd, f \'1!'ll�' n uu� 1 A'14il FS S • ��I�L 71'rl l '.II IO 4-1'b .'.l 1-111 -'(1 . Applicant Contact *' � �� � ��� I'humg�apM1i! tiimulafiun.I'mridrcl flr: OREAMI DATErim Rl/10/al CMI CNGNETR Co. DRAWN BY uC Cn[GKLD BT 1PC MY d+E KSGR•RDA IT, � wn>nR soMn mA LA13156AR„I.n,.NAPIR.R�;K� + R7/2a/N acuD 2RK RIBRNTK w PROPR NIY iIDN HUNTINGTON HARBOR PARK �1. 16600 SAYBROOK LANE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 "N"`I"SANTA N 9'7"� ANA C CAA 57707 SCOPE OF WORK APPROVALS CODE COMPLIANCE SHEET INDEX � A THIS U AN LIBAANNED TELECOMMINGTON9 SITE FOR T,AOBILE CONSISTING OF AILNQRK AND fMiEAV1S SHALL BE PERFORMED ANDINSTµ,EOWITN T'1 TITLE SHEET IMTALUTION OF AN UM VAULT i EQUIPMENT CABINETS TIE CURREM BOTTOM OF THE FOLLOWING CODES AS ADOPTED BY iNE LOCAL GOVERNING AUTHORITIES HOMING IN TNEBE PLANS IS TO INOTALLAT10N pf�ANTlNNAS MOWTEU IOANlW A10NI2PAW N U 0A BSCONBTRUEO TOPCAMITWORKNOTCONFOWMTOWSECODES COAX CABLE RUNS FROM 7N EQUIPMENT TO PANEL ANTENNAS CONBmUCTE _ _ _ 1 CAUFORNIA AOMINISTRATIVE COW(WCL TILES 21 A 2S) A 200A ELECTRICAL.A TELEPHONE SERVICE TO EOMPMEN1 t Cµ1FWINM BUILDING CODE]00+CBC REAL ESTATE O CAUFCRNA NBC—CODE 200'CMG -- ,CALIFORNIA PLUMBING CODE 2L101 Cw S CAUFO RMA ELECTRIC CODE 1004 CEC /+-1 SITE SURVEY ZONING, _ _ _ - _- BANSUELA4 LIFESAFETY CODE WPM1011BIT y 7 CRY I R COUNTY ORDINW CCQ AND BUILDING CODES ANTENNA SCHEDULE RFENGNEER - - - -- C-2 SITE SURVEY _ A-1 SITE PLAN,NOTES GDAR CANE PER NE1W0R" PROJECT DATA SECTOR MEMON A2 WTH TOPOf LE CA" LENGTH OWif •r r -rr Ir ANTENNA ANTENNA TL 5T (AGT soPROPERTY OVMFR _ __ - __ _ __ A-Z ENLARGED SITE PLAN a •• • - APPLICANT CIVIL CNOINCER EQUIPMENT(ANTENNA LAYOUT A NORTH 0 4— 7IL' 10 711 low.T�ORE "05MCDG.CDNNELL DESIGNRT ST LLC MIBC _ _ ___ DINPERIAt PROMENADE SURENW NIS MAGRTIUR COURT STE/B0 ORHutNrt B BOUTHFAST ,2p' ,I,� TO-0 ,C 7N CONTACT KKE NOOW.GELAND CONT C JOE`�E;AGM A-3 ELEVATIONS PHONE(T14)lSD-24W PHONE(NB):God O C SOUTHWEST 2N ,I.B. TT-0• +D TIR UTILITY CONTACTS CUFNTS REPRESENTATIVE SURVEYOR -- - - -- -- - - ONE VENTURE SURE 200 BM WIZE SURVEYONO MINE GS26% EEECTpiC COMPANY SCE CONTACT MCN1G MdiETTA CiOB AMESA.AV 92SUITEKI IBB.O&YBIIQOR WlE PHONE(8+012„A1175 OFFK:E.(I+,�SS/1a6/ iELEPIPNLCPMPANY _ YR9ZQN 1 FAx R„)6E,Cass �^ MW]WTONBFACN EMNL MOMGMDNEtiAO]NRiq.NAeND PROPERTY OWNCRI OTYON HUNTNOTONSEACH S -- - -- - 2000LWN ST SIRUCTgp-C-.EERINO TO 150 C0OCONNELLOESIJIGROUP LLC -� -- HUNTINGTON BEACH CA IRW, 1665 MAC ARTKO COURT STE ABD CONYACT DID NEWFORTBEACH CA WM -- -- - - - - -- PHONE 714-MV71 CONTACT VAN COt- R AVE PHONE INS)2516B07 ww..[[�� • IW110MAK ZONEHEIGHT,S WR HunTiNCiDN—SON SUBMITTAL RECORD BDF NN LANDSCAPE-7% ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING RIN SETBACKS 25 ALL SIDES OW CDATE OU.CONNELL DESIGN ONTgW LIG vIL N+vAd NEIL AVEI ISSUER.198 REVIEW ANO 9w-KNT _ 06 0 • FROM(E)kESOENTMI , .VACARTHIACOLRIT M.00 /3/94 COMPLIANCE LAI]15BA _T JSUED ig S48LSA TTK _ 0$/_IAL • CONPLNNCE CONTAANEWPOCT DAN CWPFNELL TBEACH SO mT TK MCWRHOASE D19TflICT PHONE(WB)]ST�BSO] RAW VINO ISSUED FOR SUBNITµ - _ _ Q7110/07 HR27DPIPUBLICSAFETV ANTENNA INSTALLATION mNER AVE ISSUED.FOR SUBNTTAL 07/20/07 INIENIENENCESWUY N ADdINA SOUPRE FEET OF LEASL ARG ASSESOR5 PARCEL NWBER NI BB00 SAYBKOOt LANE HVNGTON BEACH CA 926A9 SO n IM7 I-0, COUNTY Of ORANGE TOMNC PROPERTY NECµ DESCRIPIgN �'PPE' _ ah PLEASE BEE SURVEY ON C•1 SHEETFUN iKIL - e EXISTING OCCUPANCY ADA CwPLuMC(DAL DESCRIPTION To.SHCR NM TOT APPLICABLE FDR UDC".I 1+ VICINITY MAP acLrANa cv ssI w mN ME 0 cok$muo"). Rs T-1 REV, wTE/ST, REVAxW OE9ORIPTIW� N., gBUED FGf[REVIEYI SEE SHEET C-2 FOR OETA9.S Dvp n �11- 4�101 \ APR T70-701.02 \EArsnNc euc fyot �[ `♦ SITE ACOMITION/PIA CRASS ` SITE OMIDFR O ' �i POR BAST I/2,SW I/4, - w a`\ \ SEC20 TSS,R 19Y'/, S P M - �— / e DWERIAL MOMIDIADE,SURE IKO \ s, ,_♦,� � 4A SANTA ANA,LA 107M . ^ , ' 141CNE (TI/)550-2KV RDI CODIWTEA � `\ , � � �[` Ac. "$ SURV[TLR �ma0[ JaU I10tl N `\ MA or,clruot I Ions,>r+ R \\ �NAo,I"croons ro Mp is R[RE n[muV uswc sl PARCEL M/1P � �,� --� 4/A IE 1=EL AS.10 OP3�MCfMRA AM0 pRlrldl M[{ 9E/30 A p� x PRCC50N SORRAR[ OR PO51 04ESSiNG A N P [ BASIS OF SpPoNGS LAND BUR% 6NC BA MAP' Inf rc ElL Nr«s..exooR N K—w Pave s. \(C� „m�>� GS rP[R vARt[L W' xR 9e/]0 RCCgf05 0i ORANOC `\ it y'L' 9M17 [ -P \ a / 6101) \ APPROVAL% 6[ \ \ \\ TITLE RCPORi IOENi1fICh1s0r1 V / .A. «Ass. APPROVRD By, RYEWS DATE/ [ANO[LRP IPcxowR R[cun or,rr.c R[Pmtl / \ `\ `\ SRE ACO i /, I 7CMIG EASEMLM NOTES / ' \ \ Va& APH 178-75- [PE[ KC 10f t1ILE R(PORI) INIL CO CT J \ \ unlITT m uoR� AssEsSOWs IDENTF%71TR]N \ i '\ \ / �p i LONlT r" «ANR.cow,.A.. ne-rn,-o fRAC f NU n360 E �T�' ARE'L LEGEND. LA13156A SNN "A]6 KRES PFR OMN4E EOwfY ASS[SSOR K AII C6M[$R MIN SUER WIS CM PARK nr o,rr wR PM4 CPo CGtREIE 1 \ / [oc [ar«mxcRErz -- SCNCM HARK .EEE PAAw.T , \ Y\ SITE AGORM �icrA eEucn WRR bN o6 rn rM[xRoxAxt / \ `c / 1"00 SAYBROOK LN lWr IWAD uG Axo tK oe<..xxev eE+cx W,R,w w A ra[ !•, {DMTINGTON OEACN,CA 12Fn SMRu ON 1I4CR 9CN PFKn Jz LRNNi[paLpwucl[uAn 0 Mk fA60rA / 8 P4 Pur4 m AREA Ct[vA1Kry )IS rill Ae YI [RAVpee) WEE RV lNL rQy SWEXT TITLE S\R SRxS Arm W[x(A � rc rDP a O.w V LEGAL DESCRPTIOW % Pui - M�uww[Nt Rr rr REP«r, A / y[ q TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY A PORimN Of NE W.[S/OWRIER Or SE.1-10 ll,x KNC[ II ASNm>S e[„ ESI i p a F [drlR r f II sm.CW Of MR L SATE 01[KxMNA ' GWpR6'0 n2 p R.avC WKRNNLAr PUi InrPEN R fOlYO MpRN[xi m )it W[IMF! I Wa RAI4r Got"RTC GATT011E OF sLTNEY g YArrrOl[ / / r IAGA6A 0VP OAI E" ARRA,. Ro66 Q ARx[Wt , ,Jlr' SNEEi IAREER SI SEE SHEET C-2 FOR TE DETAILS I OF 2 C-�, 1 REV DATMT UVMW DWMSMP M mp ISWfD I0R tM6+ FMORS M' STAR j Q� - 1 1 t �w•ss. \ ��: I $M K sf[ION/MAIM 1 w ss �--v II [ 1 ♦ i SITE NAUD[F, 1 T-17C61LF USA 1 � WA 3 IP4EWAL r'ROTre6ADE,51ATL noo 1 lC 1 v�y ;M 4 �v I SWA AMS CA-LM7 I I [ s .R _ oPr I LEDFMD. PACK,(TM)MO-24M I ' AILKVErm 1 Av"A,Or WkK VA rMel ICCmmu V WAv COWPER I a PAAEYCYI m SfDF 21 ' A II.. .Y0 i�i_ 1 4 1 M !M xroA.wr \ 1 uw ua A,D Isc HAM LAAO SU�RVEYIKC dt MAPPING I I 3 1 \ sUr a.F.rN a9tA ItE a oAo .en o x P o II w n\ �MNNE IOf• `\ �Y PAIY IRf[ KLL YEruYDl1 9IAAr xALPI, E Aswu n APo AIG,L AI Lor Ma APPAWW 6T WM" MT[ u,s»w IIYAomo. � I \ rwNo uKYI SITF AAA, 1 CCNc,[r[ [Pf NAP,ANI 7LRAAK YI um.11 liar INTMOM"T, T VfIGIT7 GRM, w/.ss TLG4 e / I \ oxr IM.RR PGb S[TF 1179, wU„'LA13156A / w - I�Itf iLN WAR WREN U FA% ,, t N♦ vCPMPNv r 16W SATDRMX LN P KWK: CL. ---- RMTINGTON MACH,CA VW WEFT ME 1 TOPOGRAPNIL SURVEY 1% IMF I'a. IN ml iH1AM14G E/P [K Y71-01 Li1G 14ME, EFASN OT, DATF, 11 1 It 1 LAMMA DVP 04MM SKET NATM " ` \r SEE SHEET C-1 FOR SOUNDARV AND TITLE INFO 2 OF 2 C—2 MTE YVWnf ]e2mH] 11 ]IRH1prl tlAi aPAM6 MRRR3 M4 R WbRiLD q 10 Q WlY]urpi0 G tA1�N MIrR Rv AR 1u w HM fANIAn mY K AmWAWE RNL 4 CIVIL ENGINEER CDC UKWi YA'S q OflWmmlr QxtuA[R pWt RID R rmlti YI l RbWtpgRmsRleeR`�i r em¢w•C¢ m�¢¢�K AM a rus Amu mr Qr¢X R•PU N NRtO¢rLR R x wRw m4agi DRAWN HY w ] W 4 @CR u M19 bLL flap x ItR'nnT IRS u IIM 116,TAIL! Hg1p H allmmLTmcnQ W M MOXRW upr At I®lYY N r6umR Mop rRAIL]Q.¢NY4 F K INWgFIItKw¢t N 16RL MIIIO YYFI Dwl R AIMIO Op K 6Wf06r 6 MIXY N PlmalY ! YAWR)Hla N N OgNmu W m O fm¢1¢RQO�W AY[IrM 16 bNA¢b 4YbIR vmrWMN N mO N m0�`��F x Y¢WAA]aQt/aWi W R¢R[AI mmtlp QWrt aWRaW m wR CXECNEO By .IPC m t¢I bqE MAR W WN nW lava �Y IWAQ 6F bt.m mO1C WRIRA!9wl ul apt 0.m ml WE I01 uIAR N 4 MItMI Au9H6 p Wu W W164¢Qi f0A iR IWat eNA 4 QIIM A m tYpNW6 Y 1HAl Aa b M p Ra1FYWR IL 4 W1¢ltl Q III®s aleN VR[p•Rl NaYY[a HYRD ml�Y MY RMSMJNS yrIOpp�1 ply {yp¢�Iq Obl W Q 1W011 fYIA1[Y MWYpui R PI1R HIM tM M t¢WIgY tlAIRL a Omx EYIWNYY IIWIAKfIHpH mR NE IR.VAI N[MEpM1 RtlAi4N 14QW¢W DbW[F11A 4[R1RfufIE M¢wYFK AQ6AlAmF II, n9ptQ KHNm¢NIIp KQYG[01mYC¢iAulYl l¢Y Y¢IWbM av ra wrnnur n IpAU u Ym]bOq 7rW R meMq]IertP ro wAee u w wob[rm mW WAIq My R OI60 W AM HEIWOW AY A IM N6WW R YR YT 111f 11.Ym u WHu 9pO MY q RGRt 6M a mYH1Yl R I IpOu 6 vIOL qFm WI WI ANCI RE 4 ARlpp 1M yi tOul[YLL 4 w PMMR F mBR TNpY.Ilt N A91W W Ytrll@fOWP Y RgIEMW p AYHR M Y1F11 H IIpOH RWl alb M OAw:RpF Y MAY A a eYmf•Rt OpF[II. rubmRO p M RMIM mYMR N 4 A¢MlmP6 pNMM(WI[ ! Y6/I!/YF RAHD IM NIRCIIA fM A. KRap RIMIMM�m[t Mt1[pm RMT 7W/R AA tlQm tW A¢ HrommYFM�Rbmt/f¢T fORQ fglRYAYAO IpFM0)eMCAA ].4OIeA Y¢nQ YA1M;NR1¢¢,ro 7melat,ea ae4 b Mlri Wa m AIA rIYR b M rnlorom p Mt a Y]IYbAHe F M Q¢dYlmbr IL M tA¢]MYw IOvu N¢a Nt b¢mRxe F mnolc ma fLL AI RIHIi p M RaI pYn¢Pool MWOt[YMN vtpN¢A YNM a M _ ¢rYrt Rum ImY Awa!RWWL M Y1pAp N Y¢6]rLAR[m YRmA A[]a AMMHA AaAq rotml eAdc M Yu q•Ile OI IAH6 p s NI Y atrtt M x tAIIR+m W WM x Rr[MrA R(RMA Itp b M YI/IY/YI atum nit •.c MRKWYUIT 1Q 4mauOMp YMe[g1 MIQR)aW1E I HImIC�fRM�MAt Yp6ARY6MNWRYM¢M[R(,YOQAINIp �I!•aa¢gNpLLfu6l rp l®yrl®tMmlW4MF UR'RYAIc �q�•vRpM��N �RY'HOq Cgml u pbYs OY[T IAIAv p 4 P[IA Nllw!N rt•IIO AA b NY p M WC v¢ p]/Y uY0 Wa[tl I]6 f W/m/YI R6Ym Iell]uMN14 Lal mYgmw�OEaWmYE 9Wl[]D q0e rAF Gel REAlpIal HW01 uRWY m Al IB/[Im lambA m M ImAum R InY0YM4 tWln6 Di.owt R m n�H M rtygPllAf p K QM OW[a161 b IWtR q¢AWL 4 PRCPRICTWtY INfGRWt101 >at4p w aa]¢p smM6 u AMWea IeYN Ras[ IIppT em bQ a wal Y Asebx]•ax tAtC CmIMDtt 7Y[If N HAM It maKlu H[a lWt[R NIH pmAA]u M•MI m rAali meL Rt$ •oH IW YYs Axn a A M mrNbY V u•w moon AWRMa nal M YwgmNp Ira+i aaWo[ta m•p]al[Mw 4 WrPw]pap00•rMa¢CAC AWDOatlb RiaHt M Dotl HIDa.HL 1¢ON'M 10(Yiu lu 4»O¢ YRrM03 RNl[ A p m R!FM ODOt¢QAmG1a A6 irY N R[pMF IIOIR N Y[M IYH q M Imor¢ rail u L NA rRryS]OL \ \ I •ml(¢•�f0�tlt m0.a4v� ¢tlNT nr L�YAmtR7 �, .bA.� SECTOR ''C'/ '+wYm ma.M¢aA.L. \ � 7 I``+ .ZRUa LL n ]IMPERIAL PRDMMME SUIE 11D0 11 SAN 1A ANA CA 93707 p�� ��CtlpHDA 1w11 lNo]Yln LQ,AII4Yq G �--- ••OR.]aYt¢Ca tRQWIrtpR. _ _ ---NW—uS -------- up A I,Ic _ It to _ /� ¢ • /� � --—-iaviAr,Xi- m-e' __—_-_____ � coy IXPYH¢ YA A a I Loin SECTOR 'A ¢0 z ¢Y] ' rYYAIo I.IMtL I I wewWli 1 ���� I I •,y .� ,_ ——'Ti Apal.Rc fLL AWlom r1/AI I I rmaN F�• r, a •. It A I 1 — _ I I I Yi y ( uL HvNp.GrOX 1Wt60R PMN 1 �- LAI 3156A I LroW7 /7 I SECTOR 'B' xl ANTENNA INSTAAT10N l ,zoa SI YQAQ—] I 1 L NUMINCTDN BFACN CA 12616 I / CWXTY Oi ORNIGE N'Fl.RTt nR 711E PLAN SITE p[NELOP[MFM N01ES � M4f•IXRR A-1 SITE PLAN SITE DEVELOPEMENT NOTES +' SECTOR 'A' WE .—I OR CIVIL ENMEER CDC mNwN w aC CRCCKED Ir iC Y RCN9NN9 r Mt[ >JQrtU. Tp19)p t_1a91[ } P}/tf/rP mitr.a11 awana tx ' j3 Mbee ryyy Iap MI9.Mt IaY01wa I r0�1V01dYlA n4.00u 1 7 A9'ERIAL PRDMEN 51ARW II SANTA ANA CA CA 9I707 nomv r-cme m � t nelEn u onart.RasRl Q 1 j L A 9xe,7 rT b I NgaR Y 'fR aY g r11DRA I I �pT rrrs as 7 L- is :M�urt SCCTOR 'C' SECTOR 00 240 120' +� I �DArImI s _� i�r}` ANTENNA LAYOUT 2 W)Roc sal Ss nr.uAa,.c. •.r. a' c�e �. LEt Ili l.eaE.al NO `� `S ` m� ' e•Yro,1ctt},a Nr)+I1 C " I I 1 I I Yr w9.4T )F)®I_Ril m� I I e.Im D Darn,RRW q C P9 aa1ssw9� , 7 I ��mp aor11R ' J w IQ I fuf MUN INDiDN NNtRDR PARK i uulsa art n.c aAw wo TENru u+siwunoN / � I AUM9IDTDN 9CdEN G 92W9 / �\ coualT or wwlu. Arw.mT /�I RnPrm r-as)t we NrKr I: : (CI m I tR�� m PrR)C7 ENIARDE EwA 91i[P1.1N t wa9an uK1L901w-/ AM Gmur r0+w RO TN DRauIR mra PI..uY A-2 EQUIPMENT LAYOUT Egg MMIM 13 ENLARGED SITE PLAN MtC or/wNl OR ENpNCCR CDC ORAwM Br uC RlOpsm 14ea[aA6 NrpaR (.M @0.160R6 roar y rNiC.b C1ICCIRa DY PC R"IMNS 100ti1 t-tR4[and rw i�� (.IP aPPt]SCroO mU RV WR IXXwnd F r eA•ttNa RT1D tq bRrebra to Nramm r r[ar(m d Nw brrrrly K�l � hr � e)/wN)roaN tM wbiut fA � yq r ' P IETAq�INfglWigN !AWE RAM a I ( W 4 tivq Mat n E b e +I x {{I JL L O 1 p R6� 1 AN PROYCNAOL SUIE I100 SNTA ; ANA.CA 92707 Ir I MtOa�f tYy�e 1 i 7 .�N t"T i 1 I ( •<R.VM RmrM[ ' j i �tmwla a.9R I{�I ItM1 vain ro am 4 -. I 1111 I rM vA.r Naa robin NNurm. M r.t veRr h � I i " abroc m M NRa u cNam.a F =Dr Iv and 4 M RId 1O ma.x RNa r atm� Ir r.NORTH ELEVATION r 2 EAST ELEVATION 7 <-��-'—� ��` ,�' tea+ RnRn oa anoaR1� .mr®w+vrtRn— mNsnr.Nr Nnbuo r-wea rNn aap.Ir Noa+R r-19a(Ib6 annRs p M aax]tatetb Ima1 � (.]a anca]aclm rw.1 no®�rnu rr r R+t woam r Imu m�.a ur 1ar�R 9.4,� _ a 1 IRP� ar 4111. I I n } II n I 14i cc b y }� N rwl NA97 v } I I � I I I I q nax 4 < bx]A"�A.rwcroN ww9Da PAaa aRra r ,. Y Ia.ram uumaa i' an.mir10�.w II Rr near ro tabu ,�II aR Ir2 M ORRI Ra� 1 I ueo[ [ I f RIBON yQ I NRENNAINSTA ATi — —— w eur raa90 sn*9Rabt.uxE HVNTIKTDN BEACH,CA 929.9 �F rrc rb M xw Ia o4ma[ COUNTY Of OUNCE OsaR p bR�oerm[et I aecn p apart nnrtl�� } .vti.me tR.w®r.�vu�r QI In wxrl m tnwa Reba9 r-m�[war—_� _ rm[ EllVA1gN5 Ir to I n 4•] n SOUTH ELEVATION ib 2 WEST ELEVATION 2 m� „-J CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH WIRELESS PERMIT APPLICATION FORM This form is designed to elicit required technical information in support of an application for a new or modified permit (generally the "Permit") for a wireless site within the City of Huntington Beach This application is a mandatory element of the application process No application for a new wireless site Permit or for a modification of an existing wireless site Permit shall be considered for determination of completeness until this form and required attachments are provided to the City of Huntington Beach Every page of this form, including this page, must be completed and submitted to the City of Huntington Beach, and each page must be signed and/or initialed where indicated Questions about this form or the required information to be provided should be directed to the City Planner assigned to your project or to the Director of Planning at (714) 536-5271 for the City of Huntington Beach You are advised to be familiar with the City's Municipal Code and Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance, which establishes standards and guidelines for the installation of wireless communications facilities in the City of Huntington Beach <Continue to next paae> i 06-59519174 3/30/07 I Page 1 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here MM ! I EXHIBIT B 1 00 Applicant Information 1 01 Project Address 5741 Brighton Dr Huntington Beach CA 1 02 Project Assessors Parcel 163-213-01 Number Omnipoint Communications, Inc a subsidiary 1 03 Name of Applicant of T-Mobile USA, Inc ( T-Mobile) 1 04 Name of Property Owner City of Huntington Beach 1 05 Applicant is _Owner XX Owner's representative _ Other 1 06 Applicant's Address Line 1 3 Imperial Promenade, Santa Ana CA 92707 Agent Representative for T-Mobile 1 07 Applicant's Address Line 2 one venture, suite 200. Irvine CA 92618 1 08 Applicant's Address Line 3 1 09 Applicants Address Line 4 1 10 Applicant's Phone number 714 850 2414 1 11 Applicant's Mobile number 949 350 S376 1 12 Applicant's Fax number 714 850 6630 1 13 Applicant's Email address 3oe thompson@T-Mobile com If Applicant is the Property Owner and the name and contact information above is the same, initial here and proceed to 3 01 <Continue to next page> 06-595/9174 3/30/07 Page 2 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here MM 200 Project Owner Information 201 Disclose the Names, Addresses, contact persons, and telephone numbers for all Project Owners (use additional sheets if required and mark as "Attachment 2 01") Omnipoint Communications, Inc a subsidiary 202 Project Owner Name (i e , carrier or licensee) of T-Mobile USA, Inc ( T-Mobile) 203 Address (line 1) 3 Imperial Promenade, Santa Ana CA 92707 204 Address (line 2) One venture, Suite 200 2 05 City Irvine State CA Zip 92618 2 06 Contact Person Name Monica Moretta 2 07 Contact Person's telephone number/extension 949 241 017s 2 08 If the Applicant is not the project owner, attach a letter of agency appointing the Applicant as representative of the Project Owner(s) in connection with this application Designate the letter of agency as "Attachment 2 08" Initial here MM if Attachment 2 08 is attached to this application, and continue to 3 00 209 If the Applicant is not the property owner, attach a letter of agency appointing the Applicant as representative of the Property Owner in connection with this application Designate the letter of agency as "Attachment 2 09" Initial here MM if Attachment 2 09 is attached to this application, and continue to300 <Continue to next page> 06-595/9174 3/30/07 Page 3 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here MM 300 Project Purpose 301 Justification Provide a non-technical narrative, accompanied by written documentation where appropriate, which explains the purpose(s) of the proposed Project 302 Indicate whether the dominant purpose of the Project is to add additional network capacity, to increase existing signal level, or to provide new radio frequency coverage (check only one) Add network capacity without adding significant new RF coverage area XX Increase the existing RF signal level in an existing coverage area Provide new radio frequency coverage in a significant area not already served by existing radio frequency coverage by the same Owner or affiliated entity (such as a roaming agreement with an affiliated entity for a cellular or PCS carrier) Other 303 If the answer in 4 02 is not "Other" proceed to 5 00 304 Attach a statement fully and expansively describing the"Other" dominant purpose of this project Designate this attachment, "Attachment 4 04" Initial here to indicate that Attachment 4 04 is attached to this application <Continue to next page> I i I i 06-595/9174 3/30/07 I Page 4 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here MM i I 400 Radio Frequency Coverage !Maps 401 Where a licensee intends to provide radio frequency geographic coverage to a defined area from the Project (including applicants in the cellular, PCS, broadcast, ESMR/SMR categories), the coverage maps and information requested below are required attachments All others proceed to 7 00 For the coverage maps required here, the following mandatory requirements apply 1 The size of each submitted map must be no smaller than 8 5" by 11",and all maps must be of the same physical size, scale, and depict the same geographic area Include major streets and street names on each map All maps must share a common color scheme 2 If the FCC rules for any proposed radio service define a minimum radio frequency signal strength level, that level must be shown on the map in a color easily distinguishable from the base paper or transparency layer, and adequately identified by RF level and map color or gradient in the map legend If no minimum signal level is defined by the FCC rules you must indicate that in the legend of each RF coverage map You may show other RF signal level(s) on the map so long as they are adequately identified by objective RF level and map color or gradient in the map legend 3. RF coverage maps with labels such as, "In-Building" "In-Car" and "Outdoor" or referencing a link budget without corresponding signal strengths in units of "dBm"will be rejected 4. Where the City of Huntington Beach determines that one or more submitted maps are inadequate, it reserves the right to require that one or more supplemental maps with greater or different detail be submitted 402 Map of existing RF coverage within the City of Huntington Beach on the same network, if any (if none, so state) This map should not depict any RF signal coverage to be provided by the Project Designate this map"Attachment 6 02" Initial here mm to indicate that Attachment 6 02 is attached to this application 403 Map of RF coverage to be provided only by the Project This map should not depict any RF coverage provided by any other existing or proposed wireless sites Designate this map "Attachment 6 03" Initial here MM to indicate that Attachment 6 03 is attached to this application 404 Map of RF coverage to be provided by the Project and by other wireless sites on the same network should the Project be approved Designate this map "Attachment 6 04" Initial here MM to indicate that Attachment 6 04 is attached to this application <Continue to next page> 06-595/9174 3130/07 Page 5 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here MM 500 Project Photographs and Photo Simulations 501 Where an Applicant proposes to construct or modify a wireless site, the Applicant shall submit pre-project photographs, and photo simulations showing the project after completion of construction, all consistent with the following standards 1 Minimum size of each photograph and photo simulation must be 8 5' by 11' (portrait or landscape orientation), 2 All elements of the project as proposed by the Applicant must be shown in one or more close-in photo simulations 3 The overall project as proposed by the Applicant must be shown in five or more area photos and photo simulations Photos and photo simulation views must, at a minimum, be taken from widely scattered positions separated by an angle of no greater than 72 degrees from any other photo location 4. For each photograph and photo simulation, show on an area map the location and perspective angle of each photograph and photo simulation in relationship to the Project location S. All 'before' and after photos and photo simulations must be of the same scale For example, do not place a smaller'before' photo in a box on the same page as a large 'after' photo simulation The number of site photos, and photo simulations, and the actual or simulated camera location of these photos and photo simulations are subject to City of Huntington Beach determination The Applicant must submit photos and photo simulations consistent with these instructions, and be prepared to provide additional photos and photo simulations should they be requested by the City of Huntington Beach <Continue to next page> 06-595 1 9174 MOW Page 6 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here MM 600 Candidate Sites 601 For applicants in the cellular, PCS, broadcast, ESMR/SMR categories, and others as requested by the City of Huntington Beach, the information requested in Section 8 is required All others proceed to 9 00 602 Has the Applicant or Owner or anyone working on behalf of the Applicant or Owner secured or attempted to secure any leases or lease-options or similar formal or informal agreements in connection with this project for any sites other than the candidate site identified at 1 01 and 1 02? Yes No 603 If the answer to 8 02 is NO, proceed to 8 05 604 Provide the physical address of each such other location, and provide an expansive technical explanation as to why each such other site was disfavored over the Project Site Designate this attachment"Attachment 8 04" Initial here to indicate that Attachment 8 04 is attached to this application 605 Considering this proposed site, is it the one and only one location within or without the City of Huntington Beach that can possibly meet the objectives of the project? xx Yes No 606 If the answer to 8 05 is NO, proceed to 9 00 607 Provide a technically expansive and detailed explanation supported as required by comprehensive radio frequency data fully describing why the proposed site is the one and only one location within or without the City of Huntington Beach that can possibly meet the radio frequency objectives of the project Explain, in exact and expansive technical detail, all of the objectives of this project Designate this attachment, "Attachment 8 07' Initial here MM to indicate that Attachment 8 07 is attached to this application <Continue to next page> 06-595/9174 3/30/07 Page 7 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here MIA 700 Identification of Key Persons 701 Identify by name, title, company affiliation, work address, telephone number and extension, and email address the key person or persons most knowledgeable regarding 7 10 (1) The site selection for the proposed project, including alternatives, 7 11 Name Monica Moretta 7 12 Title Agent Representative 7 13 Company Affiliation Sequoia Deployment Services, Inc 7 14 Work Address one venture, Suite 200 Irvine, CA 92618 7 15 Telephone/ Ext 949 241 0175 7 16 Email Address mnni ra moretta@sPauni a-ds.com 720 (2) The radio frequency engineering of the proposed project, 7 21 Name Jose Pena 722 Title RF Engineer 723 Company Affiliation T-Mobile 724 Work Address 3 Imperial Promenade Santa Ana, CA 92707 725 Telephone/ Ext 310 279 9925 726 Email Address Pena, Jose [Jose Pena@T-Mobile com] 730 (3) Rejection of other candidate sites evaluated, if any, 7 31 Name Jose Pena 732 Title RF Engineer 733 Company Affiliation T-Mob,1 e 734 Work Address 3 I=eri al Promenade Santa Ana. CA 92707 735 Telephone/ Ext 310 279 9925 736 Email Address Pena 7ngp [JogP Pena anT-Mnhi 1 P cnm] 740 (4) Approval of the selection of the proposed site identified in this project 741 Name Joe Thompson & Duan Dao 742 Title zoning Manager 743 Company Affiliation T-Mobi 1 e 744 Work Address 3 Imperial Promenade Santa Ana CA 92707 745 Telephone/Ext 714 850 2414 746 Email Address Toe thompson@T-Mobile com 7 5 If more than one person is/was involved in any of the four functions identified in this section, attach a separate sheet providing the same information for each additional person, and identifying which function or functions are/were performed by each additional person Designate this attachment"Attachment 7 5" Initial here to indicate that the information above is complete and there is no Attachment 7 5, or initial here to indicate that Attachment 7 5 is attached to this application <Continue to next page> 06-595/9174 3/30/07 Page 8 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here MM 800 Form Certification 801 The undersigned certifies on behalf of itself and the Applicant that the answers provided here are true and complete to the best of the undersigned's knowledge Agent Representative Signature Title Monica Moretta monica moretta@sequoia-ds com Print Name Email Address Sequoia Deployment Services, Inc on behave of T-Mobile 949 241 0175 Print Company Name Telephone Number/extension Date Signed <Stop Here End of Form> 06-595/9174 3/30/07 Page 9 of 9 Applicant Must Initial Here MM PROJECT DESCRIPTIGII, rOR tEPNrL0,k LA13157-B BOLSA VIEW PARK E�--JOlA 5741 BRIGHTON DR. ENT.-R�IC HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 APN: 163-213-01 Omnipoint Communications, Inc a subsidiary of T-Mobile USA, Inc (T-Mobile) proposes to construct, operate and maintain a wireless telecommunications facility consisting of twelve (12) panel antennas in three (3) sectors, two (2) GPS antennas, eight (8) BTS telecommunication equipment cabinets, coaxial cable runs from the antennas to the BTS, and power and Telco utility connections In order to completely conceal the wireless facility the panel antennas will be attached to a new fifty one foot and seven inches (51'-7") broadleaf tree. The radio equipment cabinets will be in a underground vault and hidden from public views No utility apparatus will be located above ground. All utilities for the project will be routed underground. This location also provides for easy maintenance access from Brighton Drive The coverage objective of the site is primarily the single family residential neighborhoods located to the north, south, east and west of the site location This area suffers a lack of coverage, resulting in poor service for T-Mobile's customers and limited wireless telecommunications service options for the residents and visitors to the area. T-Mobile underwent a search for potential site locations that included properties along Springdale and South Slater Avenue T-Mobile approach the City of Huntington Beach regarding Bolsa Park, since this is one of the few properties zoned Open Space (O-S) and agreed to have a wireless facility in their property The alternative sites were ruled out due to lack of space to locate the facility and related equipment T-Mobile also consider the public right of way as a viable candidate, however the existing moratorium extended until 2008 determined the proposed site location. The search was limited to these areas because they provide the only potentially zone- able site locations in the search area and allow T-Mobile to disguised the facility from public views. The city code preference for a aesthetically integrated into their surroundings determined the site location and design The properties within other parts of the search area were ruled out do their height restrictions (RL) residential low density T-Mobile was also limited in where the facility could be sited in relationship to other nearby facilities in the area (surrounding facilities are shown on the RF propagation maps included with this application) which limited the ability of the site to be located at Brighton Drive. The proposed site is currently developed as a public park with an existing mature landscape and by locating T-Mobile's facility at this location the antennas and the equipment are satisfactory screened The property is completely developed and encompasses the necessary infrastructure to serve both the existing and proposed facilities. The proposed wireless facility will be located in the southern area of Bolsa Park and will not block access into the site or site pedestrian circulation. Existing access is adequate in serving the parking needs during maintenance visits The proposed facility will not impact potential development in the surrounding area. The proposed location was selected based on the willingness of the City of Huntington Beach to allow the installation on the property, and based on the compatibility of the surrounding area with the proposed wireless telecommumcations facility and the fact that this is the tallest point on the property considering the existing mature landscaping. The proposed project will be unoccupied and only require a single maintenance visit per month. The project will make negligible noise that is most often less than the ambient noise level of the area surrounding the equipment In fact, the BTS radio equipment will be in an underground vault will not be visible to the general public Wireless facilities are passive in nature and have been located in all zoning districts without impacting property values 1 SITE JUSTIFICATION S, ODY FOR E LA13157-B BOLSA VIEW PARK S E Q 01 A 5741 BRIGHTON DR. LIE rL JY,, T R�I� , IN, HUNTINGTON BEACH , CALIFORNIA 92649 APN: 163-211-02 Omnipoint Communications, Inc. a subsidiary of T-Mobile USA, Inc. (T-Mobile) selected the proposed location for a needed wireless facility as it was the best location available for the facility when considering the needs of the network, land use patterns in the area, willingness of the landlord to enter into a lease for the facility, and the zoning code requirements of the City of Huntington Beach. The facility is needed to correct a hole in network coverage created by the local demand on the existing network. As the number of users of the network increases the coverage area of existing sites decreases creating areas where it is difficult to make a call or keep a call connected. The area surrounding the proposed site, approximately at the intersection of Springdale St. and Slater Ave, suffers from this situation. The southwest portion of this intersection and surroundings became the target search area for the facility. The facility will increase signal strength and the network capacity in and surrounding the neighborhood adjacent to the site to better serve the communications needs of the residents, workers and visitors in the City of Huntington Beach. Radio-frequency propagation maps showing the existing coverage and the modeled coverage after installation of the facility at the proposed height are attached. Approval of the facility at the proposed height provides the needed coverage for the surrounding neighborhood, providing a high quality signal for both indoor and outdoor users of the network. The proposed site is zoned CIS_PR-Parks and Recreation Subdistrict. All adjacent land uses are zoned residential. In fact, the land use pattern to the north, south, east and west is all zoned Residential Low Density (RL). The alternative candidates were ruled our for code restriction ( moratorium) to the lower height allowed in residential zoned properties. T-Mobile's first choice was to attached antennas to an existing Southern California Pole in the public right of way, however the lower height and topography barriers ( i.e. trees) ruled out this location. The current location is best suited for the facility as it offers space for the equipment and antennas on the park, when considering zoning restrictions and design compatibility and offers the best opportunity to screen the installation from public view through the use of screening. All equipment is proposed to be in a underground vault and hidden from public views. This equipment location was selected as the space available created did not altered the pedestrian circulation patterns or character of the existing development. The proposed facility is an unmanned telecommunications facility and has no habitable or occupied space. The facility will operate (transmit and receive calls) 24 hours per day for residents and visitors of Huntington Beach. The facility has no "employees" or "customers" per se. Customer use does not require any access to the facility and only periodic maintenance is performed on the facility (approximately one hour per month.) Existing streets, access drives, and circulation patterns are adequate to serve the project and will not be impacted by the project. City of Huntingtoneach _ WiuJWi«uliilJuiwLLlii[Wu.«YliJiLuJuw{JUWuiW3iuiJfuiHluufYitJuuuu.JiJi({(uuWiWi{u..wiJ{W t91Wu4uuuu.iJ.iWUWLIJ••.Wu4uuuuJiJ1 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 �EeU 1901 F0 � DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT Director (714)536-5582 Redevelopment (714)526-5582 Fax (714)375-5087 Housing (714)536-5542 July 11,2007 Mr Joe Thompson T-Mobile,USA, Inc 3 Imperial Promenade, I Ith Floor Santa, CA 92707 RE Letter of authorization to submit an application for a Conditional Use Permit for cellular sites Situs(s) Bolsa View Park(NEC Brighton Dr/Crestmoor Ln) Harbour View Park(SW of Heil and Saybrook) Dear Mr Thompson This letter grants T-Mobile,USA,Inc permission to act as agent for the sole purpose of making any and all applications necessary to acquire permits to construct a communication facility at the abovementioned locations Please be aware that you and your client undertake this endeavor at your own risk Any and all cost and expenses associated with your pursuit of these permits is at your sole expense This grant of authorization does not in any way imply that a permit(s)will be granted by the City, nor does it imply in any way that an agreement will be reached for lease or license of this facility from the City Further,the City is not directly stating nor implying by virtue of this authorization the T-Mobile has permission or the legal right to lease or sublease this facility or add additional wireless carriers to the site Sincerely, Kellee Frrtzal Deputy Director, Economic Development cc. Tina Krause, Real Estate Services David Dominguez, Community Services • • • • • ,Mobile • LA13156 and LA13157 RF Technical Report . Vogl� • • • • • - Nloh I 1 E' • Overview The FCC license required T-Mobile to build a wireless network that will provide the best network performance to customers as possible. Also, the FCC license required T- Mobile to put up a wireless network in accordance with the Federal Communication Commission requirements and under the compliance of Federal, State and local mandates laws. The goals of the network performance are to provide best quality, lowest level of blocking, easy access to the network and continuous drop-free connections. Also, the site will operate below the radio frequency emission limits set forth by the Federal Communication Commission. T-Mobile is proposing a site installation located at 16600 Saybrook Avenue, Huntington Beach, CA 92649 and at 5741 Brighton Drive, Huntington Beach, CA 92649 with an effort to adhere all the requirements set by FCC, Federal, State and local mandates. A T Site Details Site Details : Site ID : LA13156A Site Name : Huntington Harbor Garden Park Site Address: 16600 Saybrook Avenue, Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Site Design: Palm Tree Site ID : LA13157B Site Name : Bolsa View Park Site Address: 5741 Brighton Drive, Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Site Design: Palm Tree At Guidelines used The following guidelines were used to determine the best candidate for site LA13156A and LA13157A: 1 . Site Visit — Visual assessment of the area to search for viable candidates based on location, structure height, topography, lease area, etc. 2. Propagation Analysis — T-Mobile USA uses a prediction tool, known as Asset, to project the expected coverage of the new cell site. 3. Drive Test Data — T-Mobile USA uses real-time data collected from the field to determine the need of an additional site. __ Y• L i,�a iii'���•'ti�� \ �y R ,r'%�y 'p �Q r. 1 ♦), .� l�. f �� i111� * • .�r ) ,I •_�"�._ eta i ' ` " 1 { �j•: i v� f ltf. . .. \ W.� � • F LA13156 Actual Drive test Data's Showing Weak 1 Coverage Weak coverage on this Ln02e93A area (low on In vehicle and r a., s r , , In Building Coverage) x. Existing sites LA02093A, LA02060A and LA02463A cant provide enough rcoverage hence LA13136A is being 13 �D proposed to be installed in Huntington Garden park to provide the needed LAO i 463A_..,, coverage as well as a balance coverage with 71 existing sites. Coveiage Legend J th D Proposed site location is OLtdor symmetrical with existing In Vehicle sites hence required V; —m In Buil coverage objective is ding . � meet T Coverage Map with the proposed site LA13156A Site can be move here but its all residential Prediction plot shows that the current proposed sites will meet the desired coverage objective. o2093A This also shows a balance coverage with existing sites. 02207A Site can also be move towards north however, the area is all residential no place to install �LA13156 the site. Huntington Harbor park is the only option for this LA02060A site. �IA02864 LAU2463A ALA Coverage Legend Outdoor In Vehicle - In Building ALA131 r CD 0 tan) CO Im LO • 1 T LA13157 Actual Drive test Data's Showing Weak Coverage help ari B qr A . iaLA02195A "' ^ _. Weak coverage on this 02*' area (low on In vehicle and In Building Coverage) A0285.-3 l3w` ,� -' - i � 5 C < it Proposed site location is e _ e � � 5 ` D ., Q symmetrical with existing j D' S I sites hence required 3A 57 whe w' coverage objective is �) - 02089A meet. Area is all residential no other place we can install the site that will provide balance coverage with <I existing sites. '' iAozsua' .I Coverage Legend Outdoor In Vehicle - In Building w T Coverage Map with the proposed site LA13157A u v" I°Dr Brac Dr 0 , Prediction plot shows that the current proposed sites will meet the desired coverage c�O win Dr h'"°rAEA028538 5 7 5 objective. This also shows the Avcrlh Dr lreg° balance coverage with existing a ■ �`• 5 �a sites. lensb g pqy pr aot■ a W-110 g �g a � a ° � surrounded by residential area. Armada Dr = Bolsa View Park is the only wncad Dr 3 option for this site. Dracn Dr r C r- � ¢O a Coverage Legend) Outdoor 2 W In Vehicle - In Building WS TL moll T CONCLUSION ■ Proposed site location for LA13156A and LA13157B was chosen based on the coverage requirements aimed to better serve the customer and provide the best quality service . qw� e - , Custumer Complaint @ Personal Coverage Check I Amn7s Signal Rd 1 G Iway Cir �, C Alley = ,Y o E, o LA334.aXa 3 Pa 'dge Cir 3 'V� y, 3 i�/ _ rf 3. D w ovewoo T r r c S Q q p �PRy,O 17VC Cross Dr o' ■ QOjcme\ec I _ �SysterLAMA Bravata Dr Dominica Cir roort Dr "to S Q D'OGNL N �• ii y :' y. DC q�a� NSC'NL ■A Auci'WNSONL Castle Dr e Qr`- 207 U .oNSGNL ArI&Cir sC,r Chase♦D�r 5 ■ Cheryl Dr, m Py0 ♦ G, S L. °� SS-A o' M ♦ v -5 Hilo Ci ryc' N ONL1► w =♦ `—° ICC' t RVO Q 3 A9Uari NSGNL c c C$ T -f 9� o us.Dr A 3 Margari*1* ODNSGNliNLCC t0 D rn off' n S? ♦ -Y 3 Angelina Dr A r U �° ICC. �, p 9 Pcae q neCir^ 2i°'1a tenrGreO j OAS+��eyC'■ o� 3 BVQi Vista Cir ? PVO x� , @ N GNL� Brassi C r o r a = m jN�N'ML �' DCT M r 0 ryyr e�C. y c�N�Cro.� eC. w Cr S m Dr n ■ d ' Lan Ci ��d ♦ vo Uc rl DC m 4 q' r� o dam n. P '^V0 DC o Femhil+Cir 9Po De n N:NL U C:;. {ocd Dr NNP.V.OIL N- Arena C' NSGNL Midiron it By Corfside !)jSGNL N -N N ,NL 5 Sand �r 3 Brigt�[lield Cir n �. Cir o ♦ o y ,o,PVO NSGNL m -m Dale D o in ti DC-�rlotta PVQ D le �`LA02060p')i._ o Co 01 in c Barracuda .� U�► _ r R Ica' c Pro ;' n A•NSGNL GNL r ,\ 9� NSGNL w ♦ m m Ch4bne)c ♦ t r -° 3 of DCO c, �O AN $ �_ a NC SCRY �NSGNL s c DCt N?lEVL °' fs cPVO � LsA02e53D 0'r w S AN ♦ James C J Dunbar Dt'F Pendleton�Drr Aladdin DrCypls Cir ♦ o* ♦ Patos A w 2 �� r o 'P qOe 74L a ¢ o�� 5. o U o r Glenstone Dr E'', 5 coU a' Poi Legend ■ DC-Dropped Can \Ooee Oc oCONV -o o' "i ICC-Call Setup Failure P zs 3 �? Mccarth ♦ NC-No Coverage ANSGNL-No Signal �� .ttiOc &I - Plnon Dr Arrow ♦ PVQ-Poor Voice Quality Uac C 9bron D ♦ PCC-Personal Coverage Check \aAN \U r Q �a6 Lancefield Dr c o,. woodboro Dr shr^ S� e01 Bellfield Ln Amnqv Ave Custumer Complaint @ Personal Coverage Check T Signal Rd 1 G IWay Cir 5, C ci Alley = -ry O E o L.M3498Xa 3 Pa idge Clr 3.VS w g d 3. m W ovewoodgr r r- c � c O 2PByp �FYG, Cross Dr Pd r W c90 dine\et SysterLiA209,0 7 Pe r Bravais Dr Dominica Cir roort Dr 11 GNL o ,� _ .4• ,?Q •9�0. NSGNL WA Auc�!g �' Castle Dr Qr`—zt1L'A�12 DC 207 '�' U Nr4GNL o Arr�Cir asc Chase♦per c gC �N PyO + G J` 2 y F -o m 1} C� Che I D w ♦ �. o o �' v 5 Hilo Ci ry c'r N ANIL Q o Aquarius Dr N N GNL Margarita� mNSGNliNisCC N u�65 ,O 0o A n + 9. S Angelina Dr A t V VO t09. 'E D Qsa nee �enrure S ��sy+�ieyp o�� g " BVO�Vista Cir PVO : N GNLr Brass, C r °en Or v Co/ e a d N WNCNEfL 2 DC r C9 y y 6 NC�.� C. S m im Dr ■ Lan o Ci `L �d C%� ii C/", '� o IV DC- p Fernhillf,.ir 9P 2� ion C`t 4 U n. Arena CPbb'^VG \5� De NSGNL U C;;, rd Ot NNPV-OIL W V� Midiron it NSGNfo NSGNL= - d +GNL Bri 1lffield Cir o ♦� r dy, . Cortside Cir f�NIL A o Sandy'tr PVD NSGNL �6 FAO hAj mo w Dale Dr♦' t\Ot o o Barracuda ♦rio0a w D le c '(NmbU j 8 Pv0 y� _� AcorNSGNL N GNL r++ 0% NSGNL o�i -+ �; of D(� C,^h 2463 _ y 1 �! r + a NS`NL T ' o o ¢ NC CP-VG' �NSGNb \ � i c DC NYRNL a cPV• LA02859D G 5tttu t +- J James C J Dunbar DI'f' PendletonmDr c k c , a � e AIBd M / \m Dr C%Iis Cir z c +d gdo o * c Los Patos Avf 9�o f 7 VL v a o U o r Glenstone Dr E' i5 m a Poi Legend ep< ■ DC-Dropped Call P\\5\0� �od,C o MCCarth '-i ICC-Call Setup Failure 0 ♦ NC-No Coverage ♦ NSGNL-No Signal pp� .two 9 Qry Pinon Dr Arrow c♦ PVQ-Poor Voice Quality �c hron ♦ PCC-Personal Coverage Check 3 U Dr' ��m �°i Lancefield Dr �c a^shi to Dr s Bellfield Ln f SITE PHOTO SIMULATIONS Site location ana Photo-vantage Map ' Date: 06/14106 � 1 r ► . Site: LA13157 Bolsa Park 5741 Brighton Dr. Huntington Beach, CA 93649 Applicant: T-Mobile 3 Imperial Promenade, Suite 1100 Santa Ana, CA 92707 oq 0, Contact: Erika Montano Sequoia Deployment Services, Inc. One Venture, Suite 200 Irvine, CA 92618 5 (949) 266-4403 Prepared by: Adrian Culici ' Graphic Detail Prod. rn (323) 359-3326 T l: AWL Photo-sinulation Existing Proposed panel antennas mounted on broadleaf monopole with proposed landscaping at base and meter pedestal - View 1 Looking north from Shoreham Ln. toward subject site. MlIW �t=�► Date: 06/14/06 Address: 5741 Brighton Dr. C•. Site Id:LA13157 Bolsa Park Huntington Beach, CA 93649 mxann li= ,v Wo-simulation Existing Proposed panel antennas mounted un broadleaf monopole with proposed 99e View 2 ,s Looking east from Brighton Dr. toward subject site. r., Date: 06/14/06 Address: 5741 Brighton Dr. T W �e Site Id: LA 13157 Boisa Park Huntington Beach, CA 93649 ire..'y'MA`a - ice'"• b.,:i/a Photo-SWU180010 Existhig Proposed panel antennas mounted on broadleaf monopole with proposed landscaping and 1IIB♦'M,Ped"W View 3 Looking west from Brighton Dr. toward subject site. Date: 06114106 Address: 5741 Brighton Dr. T -•..G� Site Id:LA 13157 Bolsa Park Huntington Beach, CA 93649 ® ® ■ ® M b I ®� uxs PHcrAREoYer o i e CONMELL E]ION GqO F LLC SiTE NUMBER: L_A13157B .CITY: HUNTiNGTON BEACH CONSUI2, AOBR SITE NAME: BOL.SA PARK COUNTY: ORANGE SEQUOIA SITE TYPE: RAW LAND JURISDICTION: HUNTINGTON BEACH DI.,1.Iwi 5r.nl No D5 D[P9EL vnNAg1 eESn PROJECT SUMMARY SHEETINDEX SITE ADDRESS VICINITY MAP ° R'E(J 11-II.M.CCNTAfi. 7 06/21/Oa HFI viNARr [Sx So SA P.Rs cM)F YNtlx0T0 B[KH Sn_E7 NUMBER OFSCRIPitON. a eRra W CONTK [HDrILK( nu41nGT0x BEKH G 9Ma9 .NO.R (I1.)336-!!aa r'r (11 Iqt[Sr[Ci S D)/70/D] rDOS IC B APE LEASE AREA 2002 LEGAL OESLRI✓LION SEE C-1 APN 163-211-02 ZONING OS n R 'DDF A HB i110e 15-1 TOIN)R`,wx 4 1umy I uASrwuw SrOx[nlCtni 15—III AU—:E COS IE5 B-t f0°OUu9N1[LIC SUY.IEv ux..n Nwc[TLCa54 C I cO c 0 ib 96]T4ur HIeC{[]]CYwrIUKC COOwPU] ��] (II CxINlfEO<I r 9U A-] (2 [L[vAtONa xB Ib 96.CBtI 4r(Iv IMERr[RENCI STUOv An.lHCD IP 91EN Irs. 5 .[ewl.xgvcWx wnc Swi..rl+G 2ro> R[.gE"Ex1ATxE wwc 111 / ' cwnrwu[TIVER MNw.IA nKiKn:°�v i)I.Y eso-ixla rvrl Mwfui w SREINFORMAItlN Pppr[CI WNK[t[ DNH]WD0Nu4 (9.t)K]0 t•al]I �R01 fly{DE0.1RI'll`Qf, .R�r[D,,HE [xl,l[5 LA 13157 B H[ RO'M Ex w,-wuMlE 5uuwlw calxErs Ixsrot.w VNRRCROA I'[OUr.u[N1 vNRi Iw I[.Mx Of.NEx EDM e9o.dw ..,K awer«)"I'l—o"x+]°,"lTDH / P DJECTAREA BOLSA PARE( eunnmD suuMARr_wp x .x ).ul. oCCu.lw.—31-— —I.E.![ICCOMNIIIGTKN 110 XY g S)51 eRIDMON OR Bu0.dx C�N.0 v x (Z)DENOTES SHEET REOURED FOR 7ONNE AND P[ Nc Susu,nA. j XUNIINGTON BFACX CA 9]4R tTAMq - 4 CONSULTING TEAM APPROVALS SAC/iDMN4/PCRMITTIN.. AR[HrE57_ k CNGINEERNL " r0 GRIND..q1[S xE9EE.A"CET.ND TIC WCS[DOCuw1 11 ANO SCWOv D[ WHI 1[RKCCS rx: WxnlLL�SrW CROUP " m[C Tr.[ .IRUCIDA T9 w [[l E S NC CDr.R9ut]Ox DACRIe[D CANE 4[41NR[Su0[2. a]e u.r .V9[ 1 LL C HIRE-sl 4I CONSIRCCigN DD:17 M ARC AIDS[l 10.1' B. HE LOGE AC A 971 S SUITC.]0 BURDI.K OI.A1IMCNI NN.NY CHNGCS 4N0 OOIFIGIOxf [v WT IwP05[ m e LH C 92560 lw.p[D(RIi°.9w5yNrg05(Oulx. �+B60 PRINT NAME SGNATURE DAU rAA (9a91 153-6e31 WNR11.1 A[Covxgl LANDLORD $UWET [l[CTRrur Eur.nt[e B[Rl WI[Su9VLMNG COD CONNfII 00544 DROOP lSC PRECON MGR COSIA EP C.MIS + NMFORI BEACH G 12560 is OENELOP MC91 pf+'Ar KE)a)S5I-ISRI __ ;lc c1 SHEET TITLE C(11a)95+- w owT 1— (II.)2K .1 CON51 MER PRO]ELT MDR - TITLE SHEET SN R ENGINEER APPLICABLE CODES POWER a TELCO UTILITY CONTACTS (Kr'gMu o prMNSI-Id COVE POWER Ifico, RF ENGINEER +u awAao 10.1 Sc[ .u61 INxORU SNCWVCN 0[ CRMK1 IleRr CWwe(.IAx 1e0 eHEST NUNB[W OPERATIONS "=1/CIl-o1N7 F ur[9Ar[Y•DDC xrP._1DI .pNC w0x[ w erw coo[CoUt q� AO Wi E{CCWK ot SAC REP 8 drx."/coww+ooNwcr. REV DATE/87 REYISCN DFYZmCN COORDNATES ® ASSESSOR S 1DEN11J3CATIDN LED DESCRIPTWN I DE ISSUED fir REVIEW 1 I Ov 11'T" ]3.I I.DO N OF.vG[[DuxM1 bnry Ibl-il]_01 LRFudxCODRCC[ICOI Or IXGC REPoPi)c qUv an 11 Ile l.f.a if ARE f uAD 11"OCOD[riC COOR11111*111 CSI.fiu5xC0 ugvG BDIALnR[ xtt ii gGUGC 6iAlC Or G� mA Sr6IAru �uxxL LxAU[ •C6[x G ACC`rvP[PS.wd wcni[Cw 11.1—El PLR OR-11 1-1.55[5 Ox vRwc.1 CIIRANI n1-0[D N1 0.,0c5 r.4C5 Ip suRvry cP.D[Pac wv sonrAP O PSs aO<C.s vc « u [ / N r PCCDANC Or AAA 1-11 w B£NCN WR% BASIS OF BUJrIND4 617E OF SURVEY I in[CCMCALN[Or pRiLnTOry DRR[RLiHC rwP fp �6 C b 0[vGn wRr a w,r Jo>P1A / x[[T PFRo�`ca«c[ACM b 1 v B 3,5/1e 1] SnOvv s..*1-I'll `L.0 I I ECNCN U—IrD E RAR/ Dads M R n[ 010— >]NENC nu Rx SITE ACLVISRIDI/PLANVE4 M TREE RCPDRI IDENRFlUTIDN ELE-101 b , (—.11 (PC_4-11T Or MLE ACPUPI) �-.J ra / / CASENFNT NDTES CPSRT/ (PFvO«L R(CDP1 Or Tr L[A J r SITE BUILDCR / I APR 183-2O5-E 7l-itOt10F1 APR 163-205-27 -" WL- 1 APR IW-012-0] TPROMEE USA cp.ss. R rxp Do ca, ` 3 RIPERIAL PROn£NADE SUITE IIDO SANTA ANA CA 47/07 ;A nr 'di uEn wuL PHONE (714)W 24CO _ 1 S—EYOR SEE SHEET C-2 FOR DETAIL 1 APN 163-012-Od 91 HAND sR�\ I 0.P N 1i7-213-0i I I� ,x D ,♦ 1 LAND SURYEhNC 4 MAPPWC ,RAss TFtAC F I5 -22 Mle DAB 015/Id—GG �sssL� LOT UG `I— c oxcRErE wA.X cuss I cess 1 APR 18.1-012-05 >• o.m. 9Ca 1 ig APPPJVAU AppROMD ET, NRIAL7 WTE —'r/.LC., C A¢OOEtc® E �IINIXLRD iCNIND, LEGEND.. �[:-v .�' Or APN 16-012.00 RF 3Bn 9As,CJP y,CQJRI opa D I- r<cR+ss __ �� 197ER40NCECT, 1. eAD'D L 4\ 'K LU w r UTIIRT CIIDR, [0E ,lC[IfiCH B01 _I`\ `R a • vJ, to 6 Lx L I CONST MR nDIE D MCP[TE vc D h� � �� fn S r vp9.91Cw O u,soW RVVOr I PROJECT EtiR rG rvnix[O 9•PIt RLuA1R4ukR M([4DA NP XRR(TD[[ I -Iham, ._�R lae]I R3••Sw 4r•'/ `' L _ 57F INP I I Al.163-012 07 BRF NAME, o Do- AP H 160-213-02 LA 13157 RX RNrR.AxXD,t — BOLSA PARK 'Pc iD�^or weeE �I1I �IS -- -- ` l ,WLNi 1 $ —�- srtE ADDLEbp 5141 BRIGHTCH OR d uATD Jt ` I APN 183-Itl-00 APR 163 D12 08 HUNTINGTCN BEACH,LA Vw Csrrm a<ax A.0 =n I a r tm,x0 rMuu[u, ICI' ; SHOT TIFLE h vxR mx IwI[ - �J 51RR1 DWI - -- .ARP TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY a r.J(P euvL APR fE3 I-. APR 163-012-09 I I DRAMIIy'WFP k DII DNS W71E, DRAW OT DATE Lre)T-tl � I IAOHI FT [irwGKK SHEET NtA'1BETL, '-----�--- 1 OF 2 C—i SEE SHEET C 2 FOR SITE DETAILS DATF/BT1 REVnIW VMMPTILN I a/tt a♦ ISSUED FOR R $I!H IEGENn. BB[1 B+Sx(BxU muPl f➢P 917E Afg1N�lrNN/RAM'ER (m G[tirec��em n—i..� [IX [M4 V UwtNf I ID III) v PI ro I E DI+Q La+55 • w u xrAf ra ,-�G .�40•u n lu_v1 w.is O SW Saxe v+o�xef V CiwP rc ra(r a+v suE[ � .ro RPn x,I 11'E P DER x+tR v(ttx �A Btf<P M4I(ExR[IAwt 1 IT e s[x[P wx nat T-nCBILE USA S1w'— 3 MERIAL PRCMENADE,SUITE 1100 SANTA ANA CA-0707 e v+rt4 v.lx P404E.(714)E50 2100 C—E+[v fRASi S+xD �j'µZ i•jyjy�x v }Ff { LAAO Sl')RIET"Zl.0A *NC m u[s+c n AR xx h D �ea• ROVAlS� NDLOAPM ED BTU OIfTlAtS DATf. U D' a Y= ¶' ¢ 917E AGO ifk 2 n— n w ZMW.., o cRrzW INTEID'AiffGi. VTIuTT COLR qA "'� CG6T 11+R .4 1\11 ROJKT FGR SRC IIfQ LDamw+P[ 5f1E NARK A.ae a.s= LA13157 60LSA PARK 917E ADDRESS zTI �;�'' 5741 BRIGHTON OR HUNTING.TON BEACH CA R7649 TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY w nl I DRY r \ DRAWIW.INFO, —-—-—- q+G NV1F I DRUM m PATE (ARI. TT PL/LerDG SLEET NUMER ' SEE SHEET C-7 FOR BOUNDARY AND TITLE INFO 2 OF 2 C—2 0° ru4s vavAnco er � COMMCLL OEEIOM OROVP LLC �j. �`\\ I CO4EULTINO CROUPi e..oa Mx,e2 2D6 b Tf1d1W Mx tOJ N6a S E QU O 1 A M , Y Avx xo-oc-I � ` w.r, NY PATe� EecnivnoN.—er 4 A!6°p' 1 nE/US/06 °ep((iyiNA�+ ESr I 1 06/71.°G vpCl�uiNA�+ (cE — OT/i0/of loot ZDS AC 10.YOQ- Mx bT wr� x !--- � W-oma - \ APH1M11'072'. ErtEi RORYATION LA13157B BOLSA PARK r.mnao vaua�rm4v�� � Ar vn.o uo_ — 1DM 183-20re NUNn4oTONe 4 BTANP APM 76Y1D-00 APM E}OQ-0 SECTOR 'B �120' -— — i I \ Arx+�2o-a SPA V"_a SECTOR � I ENEn rrrLE 240 SITE PLAN �✓ ENEA xUYBER® SCALE 1 O O® SITE PLAN RxSlD v/C ro.a vip.R � _ uVWxuN[xG1d°a MN� � ul[ i°o �_.mcm�qa.[t .ti� PUN6IPE.�fO Br / `uK SECTOR 'n O' � CONNELL DESIGN OaOVP LLC I1 �/'-rPowSt°wnl�,�c [� i°x CONGYLnu E CZU O I A REL I/ L.�,�_�//1 ob/2, ,,t-1u1N.kY CSn t 0/t/O6 VNCLiN 10 Ern I SECTOP C' \ Ic..°>o,----- r 240 SECTOR B GREINFOaL1AT10N ,k1zo' LA13157B BOLSA PARK V .xo ealcllrouca �� Nuxrwmou eFACN c.xxwr .MEET ME ANTENNA & EQUIPMENT LAYOUT .pBM 6NEEi NVMBEa ENLARGED SITE PLAN 'lIA En A-2 c ••ewve��>v,�m•v�':Iwnw.°".:r,� •xws0 I;I°v oQ�`I,.mnnn 5 m�` �U L 11 -U -- - - uN�P a U o � y CONNEIL DERION GROUP,LLC 71 U U w,wD N•.R.D I ri n rll ml Uo tlo o Riga+ f u�f� �ro �u�u ✓ y i CONS-ND GROUlollP IU u,U a0Y[' ur C SSSf o U I oUUU <� � ;: r.,R��.R•Rw�.PI�I ., g - �,� , ,"�' j�, ' I" ; _ SEQUOIA .•oaoR°,,nu wnl\\\ •.NaxD II �I a •n•Nu;r� ` F�t � 9p' `iIF^ fNl� �F *iFn lx+l aul �I v \ ) O6,)I/06 DREIiui l,q, fin .11 till [Rsux wLR \ atl l[a•a(RSw ra.vn b,nt . xc J 07,2C/07 IOJi)OS JDL SOUTH ELEVATION /ec^C p ply 1 EAST ELEVATION /ec6 E p p�e 2 DDtN,,,I,D,.N.I, wDx:tD I xN•,N t•w,I,�•t,l'!H�, �CIi 1,ilrnn�Nttuns ru anal � I u�.x•+ � n •11 y y 11 \ OU I SITE INfORIMTNIN LA13157B t BOLSA PARK ern eRIDNroN D0. 0 � Y NU TQV M 9 f 3 N11N0 eE1,C 4)M Ul,on •N.®� p00 ' (1 F4 a n.ury p� F � S n waRSlf W, V!/ I lx�n�..R xlNrxr°xR I � . iNEEf mLe wN«R I mw<Nnr YN w / tD�:i+R1°irs` •aae I•wr. ..umt• _ `�n'liw sl•nn nxnN J •wart•n R xDm wD,. l ELEVATIONS NORTH ELEVATION 3 WEST ELEVATION gL�IE p 7_17 4 A_3 /6•7-0 0 a e E U01A W1, U°PLO1toENI SEh\,Ik-E� I1. DOCUMENT TRANSMITTAL COVER SHEET TO FROM City of Huntington Beach Monica Moretta Jill Ann Arabe Agent Representative Department Planning Sequoia Deployment Services, Inc. on behave of T-Mobile. COMPANY DATE City of Huntington Beach August 6, 2007 SITE IDENTIFIER ADDITIONAL REFERENCE NUMBER- APN: 178-761-01 T-Mobile LA13156-A Huntington Harbor Garden Club Park RE Re-submittal material for Wireless Permit Application No. 07-042 Attached please find the following items: Quantity Title 1 Set of Propagation Maps including Dbm Units 1 Sets of Complete Plans. 1 One Set of Plans reduced to 8 '/z x 11. NOTES/COMMENTS Ms. Arabe: The attached items are being submitted to the City of Huntington Beach for an Application for a Wireless Permit Application No. 07-042 on behalf of Omnipoint Communication, Inc. a subsidiary of T-Mobile USA, Inc. (T-Mobite). Please contact: Monica Moretta at (949) 241.0175 or monica.moretta@sequoia-ds corn regarding this application. Thank you, Monica Moretta Land Use Planner lE fit LA Market EQ_Q0IA 9 fs.PYlflw'..E.Y Cs 74 One Venture,Suite 200 Irvine,CA 92618 TELEPtioNE.949.241-0175 EXHIBIT C ONE VENTURE, SUITE 200, IRVINE, CA 9261& TELEPHONE: 949.753.7200 FACSIMILE- 949.753.7203 iJ51.`s t�G'it 4i.tL'1 cs T'S ti4SsE"k'i jY"�l't C-KL:,:f.Y{"T��.'�S Page I of I Monica Moretta From Arabe, Jill[JArabe@surfaty-hb org] Sent Thursday, August 02,2007 4 23 PM To Monica Moretta Subject: Wireless Permit Application No 07-042 Monica— I am writing to you in regards to the Wireless Permit Application at 16600 Saybrook, Huntington Beach t have reviewed your application and have concerns that need to be addressed I The RF coverage maps do not list corresponding signal strengths in units of"dBm" as stated per the application criteria Please revise them to reflect these requirements 2 Please designate your maps with the appropriate labels, such as"attachment 6 03", etc Without proper designation, I cannot distinguish the proper attachments 3 Please dimension the plans with exact measurements exclude+ symbols The height of the wireless communication facility(monopalm)is suitable, not to exceed an overall height of 55 ft In order to finish processing the application, please resubmit revisions If you have questions, please let me know jilt Ann Arr-a.�e Planning.Aide City of Huntmgton Beach (E)JArabe@surfcity-hb org (P)714 374 5357 8/6/2007 AIC r Rai P� IL[N.xN[TR CM PI-_- py+s'q CI CCxcD er I-c ffiffimaFF � aC IL P r .IR' rT RM91—Osc+mn n Wulf)/Ilr/Ot RA to TR a�eNlnu LA13156A ,AmAroa w N INO W I HUNTINGTON HARBOR P �n��. - I•��. -- 16600 SAYBROOK LANE IUFERIAI PRMENADC SUITL 1100 HLNMGTON BEACH, CA 92649 SANTA AhA CA 931`07 SCOPE OF WORK APPROVALS CODE COMPLIANCE SHEET INDEX uI iMere AH UNMM1Nm fE.E - 51TDfbRT+IOAAeCOM) NO DP 9a3TALLAiION lYF AN lM7 VAUITA tO111PA1EN1 CA01Ni1'9 All CURRENT MAIONSO AIW.LOLOWIn CCEOANDIMATAUEO WITP THE rLURRYMfO?IONS OfTHEfdAIMPN0000F11bApOPTEOBY T'1 TITLE SHEET INSTALLATIONOP A ANiSNNM iAODNT=TO A NON MONOPALM TN4lOCAl pPLBRNNO AUfHARTRe-0 NOtMINO PN iNE4e PIANA p TO Rt717%Q��--- '.�5 ont[ esornmaysoTeP[annThowrNorcvNPonnra to n'cae Locra COAX OAatR M1NOPRW IRiNMTSMT1b MMEL.AXiEMNT LOILRTTaICi1DN -„ t G[IROWPAAgMIN10TR "CODd IINCA TIREb MAb) A 900A ELOCTRIdAk A TtI.V ONO AEMCI TO gWrKNT ?CAIPORNIR.AUAOIM CODA E Etl0 S CALIPGRNIA MPCiLVPCA W DD MOP C, REAL ESTATE _.. A CALIFORNIA R9Ct CCD O 2004 CPC a<Ntrn a GLIPORNIA Et.ECTa1C CAGE MOI CCC aO(TyICCkW" RDINARE7TC0OaU'mNOPPea? C-1 SITE SURVEY T CRYI COUNTYbRdNANCCS ANO dUM1DINO CODER ANTENNA SCHEDULE C 2 SITE SURVEY R PROJECT DATA A 1 SITE PLAN,NOTES tbN" A'"; P ML eeecTm SIRISfTLT/ AEINMILETNOCIl116 l ta�IHRl_l Y NIriYMRX ...... _..... __ _._, .clu+e er > t�anm+ ANTAAAITS) (tS5 PROPERTVwrt.2a _ _.r_- lftI d CML ENGINEER A•2 ENLARGED SITE PLAN& A NORN 0' AY-0a TDPrr to AR T.MOdILE COGLONNELLDC91M CROUP I._C EQUIPMENT I ANTENNA LAYOUT Mist — �_ a IMPERAIRROMEHAD[SURE PIW 4pa MAEARRNn COURT ATe'. "- YNITAANACANa?TET N PORT0—G CAa:aM A 3 ELEVATIONS ^ 00VTHGSt 1N ap-0' iOC 10 Ta` CONTACT KLLU NDOELANO pNTAC'i JOE COwIELL MICK r-)S`O?Kao PHOVe IRt9)9'M-.610 r mvmwEeT mw 1ae To'0' to Tro UTILITY CONTACTS _ CLIENrs•_ ---------'-" i DR a INC LR%0 OE ARE sufTE ZOO 9 !OURUEVONO IRVMf CAY?d10 maENRWAYAVE SUREKI CbHTAr'r MONM MDRPTTA COSTA MESA G RAn aar P EN94tia �teaEa AARIICOKINIF 7EREP°lQblr gOMRANS YLTU2Ct1,.. - ..- -- PEAR(wrytm.Tam IYr1cE plKladT PNt(/t<I 6a)fuR \/\ EMAILL NONir/uLPpRRTAt[rWub mn PROPrn1Y OPt IT11-0!.A CM Of HUNTRIOTCN REACH 1MOAMO'st STRUCTURAL ENGINffRI"I PO ton Cd1GVhN0Lt gEa10NOPCST LAC. COHL)NTACiTg1 BEACH G9NM8 IEWPcq 11CAO"Ww BTEJp CONTACT idO NCSN'Oc'CAN GdMM P1KAVf N16fSd?Tt COMAET OAN CFINNCLI WA NR CAE Afl+1Y59. O 7I 151M01 KS 9T]MAA,ZOT2 Hfl[Wi AW SUBMITTAL RECORD SOP WON LANDSCAPE•1% RFLTECM MdNT?1 NRIIVhRNCiON MARROP PARK MIN WSAM"WAL SIDES pOa xwo0. 416 AM - t IEELRp.FGR NAIIFYL.M1At AkAtMRR /kP/7p NTLIL e101,"AsYiruCOMMANDOMAARRELEe91N 0p0"CocmlE l ftc—RouPLL.0 "" tAlslsrs as Iaaa MAGMTNURCA COIWT alE{aa -- — - PHDW I EEACN wo, .m wit _ �5 � • 100 WITH PASSE OISmcT CONTAOT PAN CONNELL MN WID - rL pB1110.J9R.EM9M1TfA1__ gFJTQ/A7 . NeslO Eowla+mw,Rm ProNf(EKa1 TRsata: ArRtxua INnuunGN 4 a.)SSlIFq fDa]I117r41[TN. aTfEO/g7 INYFPERTIIOE RTINW tOrttN PtAAmIHO yfAAUeNtR _ ____ ^NAi1Pb P11NO CATRAcOK—1 tT SOUAar PPPT Cr.rATr ARTY. ASSLSORS PARCEL NUMACR, 4U'411N;TQPA OEACH CA 9.EI9 ,C ----- -- ---�- y--- M W PT 17WO Ot LOLNPY CF ORANGE yC} WNt& . PR DLI aI" r roR oampLim ' RII2 SN:STMETINGH OgCUANCY ADA COMPUKNCC, N/A NOT APPUCAALO FMUSc 1 t0t MAP 111 — VICINITY A �-µ� - ` - -�- OCCUPN+'Y CPASAInWONl Tr t Or CONRLRUCTION, wR'IAA!°- �♦ / I 0.N nAt$IeT RNiDKN DL`4RTTI:A1 I 1 ObP 9><JtD r1R4 0.lnIN SEE SHEET C-2 FOR DETAILS- oaf ,�\ ♦. I / \ / / ArrT Acaualrin)r'wa+�f ccax nc axG 1 .lo' O '\ ♦ `K\,r ."� ♦♦\ �� A `c+um \\ti �Mr' e ,/` I T ` POR £AST U2 SW U4, T-MCM E tbA `r SGC2d, T 6S, t 11'N,SD M y� '� ✓ 3 Mmu PWIWwe,w t nm SAKrA AV,CA'VM ♦ x n ./ n. 'p�, �.. + i Pg",(7M)NA-24W eooltDRutar ® '� ♦♦ \ 1 t s ,, ;I �tf'� slavmae wa 403 omax we•Ry4+n wenenrMNentu unlw t) PARCEL.MAP A I!Crw�Mtt AnR ara Aecnmu MD CRtoun pvw OOM) yy� i w•� / ' ff%T ♦ '}, / fmiKN 6OI iwMI,fW toff fM1DCcfmNA / ' 'ff1 ,'�\ I� of •a wip Raw wit or flum"E81 .( �� �\' J •� / lh f7 2NtJC G D:rkf PYIY(, MC OpIDmon n'GWWII LN ACf1A AAOrn-I, I ♦ �'•I'(n . R /� / K VSH k YM40.LLN MO laNO amran n AAvgt `,`� 1�.\ 44 (:%Ff4, �°4qf ^,�\+`^mDm� y/�l\F ro'> tIM ROPM WITIKAWN ( \ ^ •G'r.!D �'MTIW®m NRUII" oRR IMnmmf ALODFl 0•mu'r—t) / ♦♦� \� \ f�tf �^ STc Alai r/ / r \ ♦ ♦ t "la A v� IGNNO� "DOW mm. f 7 `♦ 0. APR f78-0151-01 " RFC UtLrIY ASSCMRI IOOWCAMN �. / \ `\ // 1 C"T MOR. o AMM Oglhrtf AFk f1DIM-41 ( TRACT NO WHO j e � Pit nw� \ \1^� MS 200/ 6- W / D cWYf km sMi. +cRn M onwwG Coln"Mu" "I'R ' �GM LIMMMll�, \� \ ,`X % N LA13156A \�'� �' � iOk 1 (�RD61 U P9 ol arum rA ` `� \ , } p �7tN fUOD( tl f�Yi[a4'a�KWIn y s"ADDU M K[4[f1Np1 NNW'W w• H DA[ArtRAt ( g .na•�LDl tWt eto IM ii(M DAl'BROGK ltt no•wnA IA,>Wow OIDAV+ma YMt'm4 01'W. PPPrNo 'nr,Ay'"AµA��l / HU4iIt4GtON BFACN,G g2GM LN Kll JIM ticM.11 IA NPUR Wf0la'w Y11 rGF f{STGf01TI1 M�I4 14 • W GllYAtaM I I O nm AM%I OAW ) a0l IMA{Ak \ �' s\w fray Rn.esen \/ � ^ J� \ Wur Tfttt. ^ LmAL DCwwnm maa r�NaC4"cc ( r ^^ "m"of TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY tmamra Rm m a ma cowl x WWAVAf A kfR�OM Or M pA1tTGR�f A/041N]4 ^0�ONfM UK fCAEl /I 7 foRrrDI1R D FDUM, 71 wCSI W G OaY OR IMYtN01oN AfIQ±,COURh d oPArlr< Al[OF CM7RMMu. ! WyAIRNi + ,A / / � GR.WrrY.WnA KCGtllM DI G9YPl OOm.AraFIN 1%AT fI1DICAF, h ml � /t tu1R of wMVFti t fMt mdLMf fp 401 a / ) � / CYY.MKt1E DRAM m� GSiE� VMKLE oft14}ON T:1 hlo NfMT r° 'Jt✓aT"Imm /t lf' 1 SEE SHEET C 2 FOR SITE DETMLS 2 C 1 I an. wTcnr aavw>N wxaWrrx leweo FM aev12Y M0RMN6 BTAR oRI ram\ '�" r ~ ` Hues, ,ate � cRmene SITE A!/J/ISIT124/PLAKWR lCntb •10 1 ' I Lpn,it � j�j�� ��/i� I C nfrx,� I tC,i,, wnss i slTe eulttx% ;+ -roMLE usa r,+° ? "�•• a 3 IMPERIAL/90GT mum,OufrE 1100 s wTA MR,a 1001 PWMS (714)850-24M r..nx-ircn wavEra+ BNA ly rnk ru r rrr+,Lm IwR II I I 1�k'" • / \S �` [��x tt�a�rtramstt[ ®e 1 RA':�^'1 nLalrnez� / \, .�a c a�R Rn,oe„ !�,• �x _ern wRvr,lnc a�Ma�NI"I� I A¢ � ey'y" YJiA59 ( �\mx S \ a ,� ��y Jlen A>lur nKlpe.ann r, X M"DER APPRnV A "TWA, PPM.y[D m� wTo jG / I \ ° r\\\ i m rtxlre L*cl m "[Anl+xO,w.nnT Yaro Ctt I f \�� • roalJ M.UKFI SITE Am, 11 v f R R2NMI tm, p{ ,N¢QfiD — sl µII I y ,i \` w.® wwx,e are UrKJrY C= 1 �,!1•�\ ORnes. I Plm.[LT nSR -w , ` 1 •LRAx, y� �� ,,E as E LA13156A t 166W 9A EACM,C IN ' x •��K��-- +narrlrwraa eEAcu,cn awan ;7 F ) \ ! TOPOGRAPqIC SURVEY CFNYIw I— NUT 11 �,I ISM M TII la��I n a,c rune wAr11 m' wTe ,R t ` I iZ IAeau, uvP uin/a NUT tatjz. SEE SHEET C 1 FOR BOUNDARY AND TITLE INFO 2 OF 2 C DArtf oRra/c. � Hry�I�gl�g I(y4{ DML LwaNEEP 'M N.RI tor\M N WDOCI6H a aaar[atN n nwsTMl nt1 vnOV°IMnn q4 Rotr'�-o P tM w Weui nwwrn w+XM'S TwL F t K,y1p� Iw �K Am DHaI Wei R)nRf E \ PIIIYI. wlbn LL 4D[ne m!C Mx lalDwaat Ae RAM`of FOI m nRml nE allitt a�K k)u�a wn P�iPS il�vi wgDf i�a'.h k°EnMCmI - 1 fRM a R°iRtM�pNnggK�a�RpNp[(L,DVgRlnaaN/'f�G O1'N MIOMWA aRpnµM�\p\ DnANN OY tA^ a R tHi oa+n a uaLw Ru HIDa M n\rvlit uo R 41Rf IRt t•![I AR°OAOw 1)ala°6\Hpt[Aal R Ia1W1ID qn`+0.FKVNRY% Aq NfAfR I1 W[a4oR 101 F agA4/.O R�Rrt Aa4w KI fi H RMl9 T IW%nl ivnM1tl•w avN Ne tAWv wM qv w[aF n nvwxr^tnev'T circeEo BY .41' nvsfifv Nef,R4 M•mIl R K A\HnR1IDDtNl1 n0 LLRaL ..i[FAL C1MI k,YO\D W 1}a CaWrti MD01 alatt • 1Wa'CM1Nd lrvnm arftl'ml F[nwl Nn m4A[�vra.vT R KMMIa4ltMnemL IMWIm YD[E neF 1[ll•[lal alli HDinIRlHl1L'NtS S N a019a!n[DR ItE•D61Hn aYend [ONIa r IM[A eq NYAO HP[b.P11P6me fnl HIliDHL DbU Ia IlGlet a n ILL faLLR F.RTJ F RNnn t['A[wI IT NNxem NaAa Nn L1tim nin dl\M.n01N ANtCIf1 WDAar6 R ICV aaa DSFgr Rf�1$HNC A. M'aq F4/a llln nE ndFxRn NUID aRamara a[AkavutalnR KEriDDV[w mNa+w rRwm RalaencRrnx )Ft drH»aLt[aNxL�6ntaDl[nonaE avu RHMn41HIt AgWL ---___ a�aD3l RaNgalMml z a M 11E IDOI�RI (,1(a 1[RRAa10 t FFOann NYY>04p q 11I[R4 F MD{m H aRYan R t ,A®Fwl a M FagAum a M 01aR aMwan m RHl IW_Np Iato1 rt! [ry y w� ?fattaro� 0�°A'mtx'N1 aDla Ro W.u+mEnA°Itm au nt Pwam n new Hnwv sort fi I[w t°rmna a RaA nu NMID a DataN Nan nrt n[Im�lu aw n Imcxa m 1 aIDu naroR eru rw H°I rlur tx wi xma°nw N-P[.E w) gwAa F amAa mnn.gl.w muf m ANMn/aOER R DDMLIRf v wnnt ` PwL H RHa\r Roca mD n[ti9\o av[<accrn 9[i aamn%fcANa Amrovm n at aRA4 Dlk4Rmt MO iLL Na'�r�mt WrNtD.1 daR at/D/PL rTulll,GI 11in.'Rh N t K[INpeODMM1HI OaJ16 M)Na•tW yfF�LL��((HttDiI[Iap n yyMMM� Raax vlwm n il[pm.no«wryu tgmN qu w AwNim,q n M saNAAooA {. LLaRM NL�Ey IA°U'falPbnaAM na nd•an)p1AgnR•tntm M'M1IF%W MmMUammp WARLAtAiIDR MO')E IMMLWn n MaVtl Rtwm[ID A11DanHAHHmnonYCilit Gal nimA mmfa n�g 'a6Blh H M R Ruv7x.D4aq NEN4 oaAe HtwirAn rtvwi HD!ligm�nywl�MaM[IgMp�K Ne laai n°&q pSN to w'M1K Inge u4gp aR a Harv.*D Fgpa tg9Yn 1(Aa wnl n9 Cl WM tt a IB M RmAX � 7r.^la m r[Mt M RD-noxWSAf W[nt rn1 m n[ n[/>e/e>csm ru 9.wemAl o M MII A M Ypa/D•�gIpIKI��IA�L�,\�Lp��1�qia�C•aT[M�N1M)_ _?wm, a aHFRnn.nCW w1nL A#0.M:!}3 N91Mu°nD IWTM DgUf onN Vr>AuuK[4Wuve\ e I�ttLnaitw6 0iW tao'!bY a Ai HHltil VI1nL W� A AVI•A K)n•aH AG 6m R fH1R Am Caala6 F naE rH 41a IEagI YI tlYM owea5.'LL 1qW 1HI1nID N1AaNUL na i°fRa aai vx[n\aaD a 19HNw Frt rrom a Aw IFe Aw.q TmAi III�1Rl N4mm MOWK ao6RK WYIM iH1! Sri N1190 RMYrt4 wtRCal D\'LL DRW FL.l,Dl WttMDIAaIHI[gR,�pl DN E[.MA4610A 4I�MNU@M y IDIIIDe1Dll'MDEi. t H ID K M wTw9}.it a N[Ilai.fMNi.x n PMQt Mn I4A1 w Ih 4A N AM m wlnze)AorAY rH INt1R6 tr FSA�MY F.MYtM Haw YnI'9 lMa[.i WD btic a tl4gA H iGtlDVR,RI mPSCI Dlri4ilbw.!MAii MG IFxM 1\�IW,LiFa A T�GEF M[42/R RMIRCb?I LaI!NI I[t rMPS M96[DIa. �we ra[E 1 nt m..*wea wu rn.n wma wrwxnnv rral FMENgw fuzee wauwn. �• Rlgm wl wwR NA N.1twtorEnC 4N'uP ufAvd i1HI w[rNT n m M Ne W.tw.R C1 wa>fe Nn iaACN mI u>H6 W nenrnenu n wn 'qa Nn4 er Ntw r Dn[R n x mw-IN astix�x w�ALii�wu.u,iw'A nw.Iwi 9D61w WYe WRL[D r\ll6lu'M wn INmD n.SE IIWnw •YAInmRn re raw.ea / •M1 IaCO R[• r�Ic " 7T� SECTOR ItRNNr7 , L Ri NLOat "���if�°��'^ik 240° J ! 7 lua[NIu vaA a CA 270 Ioo - --- _ -- Y- ---- -" - - —_- -^- SA4 iA A4A CA Wi7o7 al � Y` `�i' � Mael[rortAlm to Mm tear Cat '� /� • TbDDsm hNnet nun rp4) ' _-—___—______---_--__ — tt - •--} -J �y � t `\ A' I I � � CDAW[ALL KDgep ' I`\i X i 'Kh�\ \\ ' I i _ \m+n•n.n a.rvwgcl t+.I SECTOP. \ m wAnc 11 0° I NAti n a.q-nn I .q - I1Y DiDlpllr'tM Mz k i Nt�wA)Hi.N�P-W L /z wwrry� nUh"n=ON twgon PAR( I� sira�..- I srt[,.wRa,Utt]InM J S('CTOR B i L� I I e � „['ALIEMUWIv_h1N°iuAroli 120° s rsacar La_ic f I1"'<NC(Dt OFetAlKO O 97E49 IV 0[OR/rvf i DDn { mL' srt, v sac D[rlo4uiui[wo�Es SITE A-1 PLAN,SITE r SECTOR 'A' MT- 0° — h,fI4CEA COI OfNWN�Y ry rfKfR DY JPL r� AEYISIONj In _.) C-) ___._'_'-"_'- --• - ..—eamr un '- -—__—_._—__ _____� >•rmio>�XJ4a.w a.,.<�,ro i'mfMzc�mal rrr..a..ne ,M1 �,.IN'L1C i � nn �I Rua //� faYR!!1-IOTt SSt.rMvt4 I P x--- � �- ` rmivlm l•YLYt R ��I�M,LLv lu�rt��' ' �y KL�;Vf��ai`„3e 3IUKMAL MCMEN C SIIT IIW �.7 Orr 77 \ ^ �•Y /�y uvX.cna .� < /_ro gl � <'f, � Im-7 rtn w.aac+ Lmnnna� \ \ I 4t SECTOR 'C' �, tiiQ>InD SECTOR �!240 120' \ „+� ANTENNA LAYOUT I s 7��� ` I Iremxn�nn anrtr Y XI4 rJa�w�m�tt��w-� �• �-i ; r �K V/14YV� ,A7Rip,iOMf All Obl'R,10.MlM ipnul� 1A � I a 4mN�i t.4 i i � k V._1-_`� h � 1 m`Hirin.rrnl t.rYo pna, _ � Raw UND 6D0(1 SA'r8N00K^NE i `�` H 1HJN11,4'iW RrACN P11., /' � DOu4ry OF OrtwcC IW ItW/ me CMA9GED SIIC pUN x � „fICXXA AYWr K�101 A�n,pL04tp,1i{ rr11 EOUIPMENT LAYOUT 3 ENLARGED SITE PLAN ., �� 1 rX�^NM1e A-G _ c+Fr wbrror ���- CNi In[IV[CN Cpf, rp pL.Wll 9T _ r Abf@0T CFAq.Atnrwl 1(1p -/iM6R OG�Me- cIFmm AY P. (1 bl}I{M4?4f16tl TJ[W e� 1 � FM I 5 OENSAO(9 r � twncwdAA °�Px �nA"�°'xu x� rt — y AMR-,, i47d ROPRi<IARY INFfIR4A tOl q .7 ansx4 �� I 31WM1u PRMNADEI SUM IN, y ni ��LLtlwLf y 4 �.y r � m SANTA ANA LA 927D7 "yil Mf,toUfx Mlut IA W3gfR �f l.� f yMb ID MDI i y 7 oJMA'lR RIRM'LL ( rVmw— r�LRB u axm uv.cm NORTH LLEVATION _` Z EAST ELEVATION S NlLL�._ RVar�Jnf Mri.lw�u,. 4 r+mnax a �e�a F h 1 (t k b ��� � � � a � ' [bra � y y `rt NVr�IttGFOn Iu/iRCP oAlac 1UWtR1 t[.nKu ' �f ,�y rm rnAno,. � ulslSen r+rsrnae z+m� n x.�x+n v+ml �{�H t <rc imT RF 111x1 IwtH '` I MY WYt NiM $ I 1 �AH IAIA �irAt1l{pypC - t M19}(C.� 1•� ��,,,� it A'RF MTiAIIAiIOtI w F �anAr10 SAYWII 42 IfR IlC gVQf _ N NI,M1NFtAN 9FAfN U 4RM0 l'(Ylr A OF OF4t 9F MCI � PA'Rgx l-WALL p11�- uM TT A84®t-M}IVMA'1It+��� 'aC 1b W11M U IaCM.R fAf931TpglC f�4WAr t qRj�-�` Tr 1 �Y CINATIDAS 80UTH ELEVATION 2 WEST ELEVATION 2 evis Ai Coverage for LA13156A Nugga� e�P goo day `' K Rd p� pat PJ2 0zFor restal Ln 9 � Road T MO bil e cLAD2326A y��9 � 3a�� 5 .0LA02 �' �� `�"'^�, i' „�.. Cutnberlan�ll)r a �`� Bis ,� ✓ ¢ y r "r „=„ Asa"•° Gir G Sig Rd *t °, E Y Br""own Car EL�OZ5�41(1 i�r ��ea��'a � � ' � S edford Dr Gay �rL�r0206 Ibon'Dr D A Bco ^x m c m Cente _, a Hooker,Dr p! Edh ger Ave + � < � � l Bitesalls Dr L +a w; " �, I' r Amazon Dr OA�>t P "Ir or: Macc�on +r s t =t `' nligbt or, Alhambra hambra or A4bott Dr, r °" "`~a�,r � ,� �' '�,� a`•��c, �' ti3, ,ra brad D r U LA6249QA r L Pao RKxw� 02463A�, .G`f U w fX ^�="d y' •''', ```'�N S"}; C'd�I�'y 'Z.;?F�'�L'a" 4aS'3� ,. Q` µ t - a �"t,�Y� k C U cBeISItO or � IT ,r ' klsle�7-' s iF F a y q Bt31fLA 2585 0 x ' <L 5"Y2e„ !y b3.� Belvaor Q "lnC ` n T` 4i �M >� — i LA 089A t �3 � t ,ti ti� arrtman Ave (7 rod. r r dk� ` LA�2267A ha c r� Connie D a for r Y LA021 p Alberta Dr LA 2sa3a �r Q� ° Arnberleaf r Crestwo n 4Wd Rood, Coverage Legend This Information property of T Mobile USA Inc is confidential and Is intended soley for the use of the individual or entity to whom it Is addressed Any other use or distribution of this Outdoor(•91dbm) Information Is strictly prohibited This map predict,and approximates our wireless coverago area outdoors,which may change without notice It may Include locations with limited or ; no coverage Our maps do not guarantee service availability Even within a coverage area,there are several factors,such as network changes,tratficvolume,service outages, In Vehicle(-84 dbm) technical limitations,signal strength your equipment terraln ,trLICIUrPS weather,and other conditions that may interfere with actual service quality and availability,including the ability to make,receive and maintain calls In Building(-76dbm) Case 2.09-cv-0377 :GK-SS Document 74-1 Filed 0: 3110 Page 2 of 11 1-' S EQU01A DOCUMENT TRANSMITTAL COVER SHEET i FPC4 City of Huntington Beach Monica Moretta -, Andrew Gonzales Agent Representative Assistant Planner Sequoia Deployment Services, Inc. Department Planning on behave of T-Mobile. COMPANY DATE' City of Huntington Beach August 30, 2007 <ITE IDENTIFIER ADDItIONAI REFERENCE NUMBER' APN: 163.213-01 T-Mobile LA13157-B Bolsa View Park RF'. Re-submittal material for Wireless Permit Application No. 2007.0041 Attached please find the following items: Quantity Title 1 Set of Propagation Maps including DBM Units 3 Sets of Revised Photo Simulations NOTES/(OMMENT$: Mr. Gonzales: The attached items are being submitted to the City of Huntington Beach for an Application for a Wireless Permit Application No. 2007-0041 on behalf of Omnipoint Communication, Inc. a subsidiary of T-Mobile USA, Inc. (T-Mobile). Please contact: Monica Moretta at (949) 241.0175 or monica.moretta@seouola-ds.com regarding this application. Thank you, Monica Moretta Land Use Planner IE & LA Market � It111il1T. One Venture, Suite 200 Irvine, CA 92618 TELEPHONE: 949.241-0175 EXHIBIT D ONE VENTURE. SUITE 200, RVINE, CA 92618 TELEPHONE: 949.753 7200 FACSIMILE. 949 753.7203 58 EXHIBIT 3 Case 2.09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 74-1 Foeo - uluunjeqc a "lore u, ° D, i. `0 Blanton St D " 3 ^ 3 x <c 0 p m 0 a L ❑ - n p - s Abalone Ln ` o cp rc D r 3 :. _ m ° o <D 9i ° o va Wry, p m CP l 1 172C7 - i ul mpaB e0//° d LQ>,lelra9 °�� Herbert n O 7 • ` DA j.ong Cir l y,el r - v • D F°ss n ? •• Almelo Ln M O m > • p - p .`: /a p ° D Ln ,. Aulumn Cir A m D c: o -- ulalebanIq ro Ojar Ln A ° n 0 C h JDJo- Coronado Ln Evergreen it - i Orkney Cr - p u n O 'OQ° ul lu,udylpraN m D Alta Vista Cir Frasereo n8 aauuo l u (, T :i j MamlealJ o N Brenhvell Or o W P N D Mytinger Ln g x. _ n m ul aD,o is t1 p = m nD blllal13 ❑ W O n S p p m _ i7 Academy Cir Oa w 1 SPreMp ul ouenwallV ° 3 a 90 - c", y9 Avdla Ln p Cobra Ln L,n (mil ,� cn ul Ma!A uaplo,, C 0 Via Espana Ln Argo dii < n =r "p El Nepal Ln rp ► y�n j Ambrose Due!': L'i a^V. ICep v e'aach view We = a a - u = Bel gnlalla Ln m en, d monr 3 3 - a u < n Ape, > ° D uosdu,izg o 7 m EXHIBIT 3 59 Ir /I.C-.mil.. s ,_ _ �- Y.G�Itf •.11 . ,1ytt „.v�, _, •. AtlacrlmCnl 4.03 Coverage for '_A13157A �,. At.ne - • fy Cnn p .tn, m rt ;wile C. :. ..,tt. . o• - .. "r Bana.ut:a "ha'Mrt:. �. Do le Dt 0 -V.o, Dt z CA02463A C1 m r S .. Ttar Dr Dtwbar Ili m y O o x :.aril Ave i - - • :tl A e\rL• I H co n T c el m i Be!s4r urt s m O� m o`� = e c •= o _ Cnren M, VJ.'7r, Av. �y :rtnSvr,�. " A l m g -. ,r✓ — `p�c n r c\\,c Ghent Dr ? w' LL Athena Dt c �o Pp ¢ c C < a c m m < GI, Or q� 3 r V _ A -O a O ? N U - e _ ro m � O q� a J Kelley Cir w c 00\ •p Armada Dr n Z ✓' ` G . Arrowhead Dr 0 Jac V Padua Dr > ;.ad2aaea H Balmoral Dr ' CO Talbert Avr, � y e F.S;, Belltield rlM' m Y w r' IIAt m W r `• r O p� U F r N AM67A m m ,, Qp� m raylrn Dr -- n 9� O m .1 R1. � fM I\. LA02543A i� `_Il: Ave A•dnt•�. - -. Q¢� _ B:;nai e� orr31 GI , pe'.l x,gnook Dr �T G - n ro O oil AVi` inA aVLe Aye Coverage Legend 4hn,t• � tnM„ .. i, . Aue:Or- nor• 2 o N 1 J f D, D � yr! n m Blanton St 3 m > CD cn r O O Abalone Lit -- c ,. Leseel - dory !ift,r' ul u9iag '7. -± �i/oo uO>ItEPa9 n�� Herbert ll D Cll De,.ong Cir M!El p G 3 S r%�1me10 Ln J r o o 0 D D v m s 0 Aulumn Cir 1p of I aµroaFaQ n m Ojai Ln m 0 n ch Coronado Ln Evergreen h - . oo Orkn=y C+r (t g OQ u I ju,"I'ik aH CO y Alfa Vista Cir Fraser Ln ul Aj n ' 3 a peoy 6L jDaL11103 uD maliucalo o o Brentwell Gr o n v a6io lS Mytinger Ln u n 0 w r= o i'D OuQu3 mm u'I m o dem o ACa yCir C, D IS spremP7 uI OUEPWEIIVe Y di,. 1i10>weri 0 od C - eC� ;� Q Cobra Ln O ' - - n ' mar Av,��, i „ o ! o u Ales � O l n .>�n;"Ij C .. Via Espar,-y Ln q.y0 C+r T 0 r El Nopal Ln -1—D R_ °i 0 Duel , any138 Ambrose Ln � � a o r m m < A`Sh'ora Cn o D :iaw Mbp a m 5 G) Beim,)4rnaha to z m d r 3 to - Apex Gr a D � o - < 'n 3 D ewe o t ,iosdureg o „�� EXHIBIT 3 61 T � 1 F 1 4 6y r *Art _ EXHIBIT 3 62 r� I I c� err nz Photo-sknidatlon fxkttkg ------- — W bo�.i lien n-•nopoo will,prapnsnd landscaping at base — and mler pede" / - R> f:Addess I,, t" L C, G 1 Sr/n ld .JA:loll/l4snn l':,- MminHU 1...4!�'I: %v O) W K .n I 1 I h_ v i 7 i Plmto simulation y ni:bruadicai .. W monopole will proposed landaping al base sc 1.�,��kiu: ,nlllh,u../ hrull �nLvl< lulr,uzl Huh/rr/�nr r Dale V nnro"<: y., i> olI r i ll 1. Photo-Owto �- - Exlstiq M,4,uia rd panel .1111cIl11aG 1140011ted Oil �. W broaflleal monopole ,. wlpU prop0600 Wldscs"at bats e. I V""' It'll, I �,.runl _ _- , M � � Photo simulation Exlstin9 .� a (O(N)tiC(I '''A' '•;=� ::� �""�" iantlscaping al base ' it i I r fn i anntu- um EXIS019 H Prnpovr:fl yanri I-� dnIU1MdY nR1UUICd I (y tHl hfOd(fll!dl niOiopolo with proposed MndscepkV and _f 1 UI l,rnllfu•< II[�i/hrnn Briylu"ll . •. . a;i'' Tj a w G 7' Dale G :rgli Address: :;7df t)npnrm,nr Sitr/ll. 1Af YS:FXNM+✓'RA Nuv+lrn•!!v+'!Af'+r-b ..1�'Ilt .'I tT J Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 26 Filed 08/17/2009 Page 1 of 12 1 JOHN J. FLYNN III (CA 76419) 2 jflynn@nossaman.com SCOTT N. YAMAGUCHI (CA 157472) 3 syamaguchl@nossaman.com 4 BENJAMIN Z RUBIN (CA 249630) brubin@nossaman.com 5 NOSSAMAN LLP 18101 Von Karman Avenue, Suite 1800 6 Irvine, CA 92612 7 Telephone- (949) 833-7800 Facsimile: (949) 833-7878 8 9 Attorneys for Plaintiff, 10 OMNIPOINT COMMUNICATIONS INC. 11 12 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 13 CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 14 15 OMNIPOINT COMMUNICATIONS Case No: CV09-3777 RGK (SSx) 16 INC., a Delaware corporation, DECLARATION OF MICHAEL 17 Plaintiff, GETANEH IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR 18 vs. PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION 19 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, a public entity organized and existing under Date: August . 2009 20 the laws of the State of California; Time: 9:00 a.m. 21 CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF Dept.: Roybal Courtroom 850 HUNTINGTON BEACH, [Hon. R. Gary Klausnerl 22 23 Defendants. 24 25 26 27 28 EXHIBIT E DECLARATION OF MICHAEL GETANEH IN SUPPORT OF PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 26 Filed 08/17/2009 Page 2 of 12 1 I, Michael Getaneh, declare. 2 1. I am the RF Engineering Manager for T-Mobile USA, Inc. ("T-Mobile") in 3 the Los Angeles/Orange County market ("LA/OC market") I submit this declaration in 4 support of T-Mobile's Motion for Preliminary Injunction. I have personal knowledge of 5 the facts set forth below, and, if called as a witness, I could and would competently 6 testify thereto. 7 2. I am a qualified radio frequency engineer. I have been trained to identify 8 gaps in reliable service in personal wireless service communications systems and to 9 assess the ability of proposed antenna sites to remedy gaps in signal coverage and 10 capacity within a network of compatible facilities. I have extensive training and 11 experience with respect to T-Mobile's wireless system and technologies, as detailed by 12 my curriculum vitae, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit 1 13 3. I have over ten (10) years experience designing, operating, monitoring and 14 optimizing wireless networks, including networks utilizing a Global System for Mobile 15 communications technology ("GSM"), General Packet Radio Service systems ("GPRS"), 16 Enhanced Data Rates for Global Evolution ("EDGE"), and Code Divisions Multiple 17 Access technology ("CDMA"). 18 4. While I have spent the last five (5) years as a T-Mobile employee, I worked 19 with a number of other wireless service providers before starting my tenure with T- 20 Mobile. For example, I have also worked for Cingular Wireless and AT&T Wireless. As 21 a result of this past employment, I am familiar with the systems and techniques that other 22 wireless providers use for identifying gaps in service and predicting coverage resulting 23 from proposed antenna locations. 24 5. T-Mobile routinely provides Propagation Maps to local governments to 25 demonstrate the need to locate and construct a new personal wireless service facility, 26 commonly known as a "cell site," to remedy a significant gap in reliable service. In this 27 regard, propagation Maps demonstrate the radio frequency ("RF") coverage that can be 28 expected over a geographic area based on certain assumptions These assumptions I DECLARATION OF MICHAEL GETANEH IN SUPPORT OF PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 26 Filed 08/17/2009 Page 3 of 12 1 include, without limitation, factors such as: the frequency of the RF signal, the height of 2 the antennas above local terrain; the signal gain due to the directional nature of the 3 antennas; the terrain over which the RF signals are being broadcast; and the strength of 4 the RF signals 5 6. Currently, T-Mobile utilizes Enterprise Asset software to produce its 6 Propagation Maps, based on my experience, Enterprise Asset is a common modeling tool 7 used within the industry. Enterprise Asset is a digital predictive modeling tool that 8 identifies areas where reliable coverage will exist and where it will not. Digital 9 predictive modeling tools attempt to match a model of the propagation environment to 10 known measurements in an area. In the past two years, significant strides have been 11 made in refining the accuracy and reliability of Enterprise Asset's predictions. As a 12 result, the Propagation Maps being produced today by T-Mobile are even more accurate 13 than they were two years ago. 14 7. As part of my responsibilities as an RF Engineering Manager, I oversee the 15 production of Propagation Maps for areas in the LA/OC market. Under my supervision, 16 T-Mobile recently produced a map depicting the current coverage for the area in and 17 around Harbour View Park, Huntington Beach, California. Attached hereto as Exhibit 2 18 is a true and correct copy of the recently produced Propagation Map depicting the current 19 coverage in and around Harbour View Park. As demonstrated in Exhibit 2, T-Mobile 20 has little to no in-vehicle coverage for the area in and around Harbour View Park, and no 21 in-building coverage for the area in and around Harbour View Park. 22 8. Because of the refinements to Enterprise Asset, Exhibit 2 is the most 23 accurate depiction to date of T-Mobile's current coverage for the area in and around 24 Harbour View Park As such, to the extent that Exhibit 2 differs from what was provided 25 to the City of Huntington Beach in 2007 (see e.g., Exhibit 4 attached to the Kramer 26 Declaration), it is a more accurate depiction of the current coverage. 27 9. The City of Huntington Beach contends, in the declarations of Bob Hall and 28 Jonathan Kramer, that there are alternatives to siting the proposed telecommunications 2 DECLARATION OF MICHAEL GETANEH IN SUPPORT OF PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 26 Filed 08/17/2009 Page 4 of 12 1 facility at Harbour View Park. Specifically, both Bob Hall and Jonathan Kramer assert 2 that, in addition to possibly siting a telecommunications facility at either a city fire station 3 located at Warner and Pacific Coast Highway (the "Fire Station"), or the Sunset Aquatic 4 Marina located at the west end of Edinger (the "Sunset Aquatic Marina"), T-Mobile 5 could site a facility at a shopping center located at Algonquin and Warner (the "Shopping 6 Center") that would satisfy its coverage needs. (Decl. of Bob Hall 19; Decl. of Jonathan 7 Kramer 116.) 8 10. Under my supervision, along with the Propagation Map depicting T- 9 Mobile's current coverage in and around Harbour View Park, T-Mobile recently 10 produced a set of propagation maps identifying the predicted coverage resulting from 11 siting a wireless facility at: (i) Harbour View Park (the proposed facility); (ii) the 12 Shopping Center; (Iii) the Fire Station; and (iv) the Sunset Aquatic Marina. Exhibit 3 is 13 a true and correct copy (all exhibits hereto are true and correct copies) of the recently 14 produced Propagation Map depicting the coverage predicted from placing the proposed 15 55-foot wireless facility at Harbour View Park. 16 11. Exhibit 4 is a Propagation Map depicting the coverage predicted from 17 placing a 75-foot wireless facility at the Shopping Center. 18 12. Exhibit 5 is a Propagation Map depicting the coverage predicted from 19 placing a 55-foot wireless facility at the Shopping Center. 20 13. Exhibit 6 is a Propagation Map depicting the coverage predicted from 21 placing a 40-foot wireless facility at the Shopping Center. 22 14. Exhibit 7 is a Propagation Map depicting the coverage predicted from 23 placing a 75-foot wireless facility at the Fire Station. 24 15. Exhibit S is a Propagation Map depicting the coverage predicted from 25 placing a 55-foot wireless facility at the Fire Station. 26 16. Exhibit 9 is a Propagation Map depicting the coverage predicted from 27 placing a 40-foot wireless facility at the Fire Station. 28 17. Exhibit 10 is a Propagation Map depicting the coverage predicted from 3 DECLARATION OF MICHAEL GETANEH IN SUPPORT OF PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 26 Filed 08/17/2009 Page 5 of 12 1 placing a 70-foot wireless facility at the Sunset Aquatic Marina 2 18. Exhibit 11 is a Propagation Map depicting the coverage predicted from 3 placing a 55-foot wireless facility at the Sunset Aquatic Marina. 4 19. Exhibit 12 is a Propagation Map depicting the coverage predicted from 5 placing a 40-foot wireless facility at the Sunset Aquatic Marina. 6 20. As demonstrated in Exhibit 2, there is a significant gap in T-Mobile's in- 7 building coverage for the area in and around Harbour View Park. Further, as 8 demonstrated by Exhibits 4-12, none of the proposed alternatives, all of which are highly 9 speculative in any event, including the Shopping Center alternative at an elevation of 75- 10 feet, would achieve T-Mobile's coverage objective (see Exhibit 2 to Kramer 11 Declaration). Therefore, based on the Propagation Maps, Harbour View Park is the least 12 intrusive alternative that will satisfy T-Mobile's coverage objective. 13 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America 14 that the foregoing is true and correct. 15 16 DATED: August 17, 2009 17 A 18 Michael Getaneh 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 4 DECLARATION OF MICHAEL GETANEH IN SUPPORT OF PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 26 Filed 08/17/2009 Page 6 of 12 Michael Getaneh Professional Profile 1d y('-ars)f experience in the design,performance monitoring,and system optimization of Ga�-M GPR)EDr;E and i,DI JA netvtorks for major wr,eless operators in the US and tl,e Netherlands T Mobile,AT&T Wireless,Cirgul-ir VVaeles; Sp,,,,,Fr US Indcpendent bVr(-Ies,One(l'OJ US Uovmed,Bell Atidniv,Mobile(kkrizon) Frontier Cellul.,•(Veruon) US Ccrdu,rr TOfort BV Experienced with Nokia Encsson and Lucent equipments .strong analytical and problem solving skills witn measurable aci,ieve erts in(,ustomcr qt alrty irnpiovemunts Highly driven corrin Acd independent flexible afid eNe(,t,vc team lender and team player Managed team of engineers and drive testers in detrvering rnarket launch ahead of schedule for Frontier Ce,luiar iVenz�tnt under a t,ressrve t n� lrr,F Successfully optimized and launched CDMA network:for Bell Atlantic NYNEX f lobite thenion)in New Y')rk Gity and Frontier Cellular(Vertzon)in Up State New York for the NiTA of Rochester Buffalo and Syracuse Evpofionr cal in sie'rvet rag ter hn,ral presentalrons to engineers as writ as marragnment,represented ented operators as RF subject matter oxprrt tt,r low-,g neanngs Prt)fessionati Expertence T-Mobile,Irvine,Ca J;I"'M)-P1e�pi,t RF Frtrgrc r,nq f4laftvxter T*Inij-L;A(-,(,) • SLKCFS5 1,I y ird Lrs Area Tn-PAarket spectrum reduct-on'requcncy plan execution • Manage the daily act,vitios of Evg,neers m the Design optimization and perfor narce of a CSNI LDGt a-d Of 11,, ntvtwv(rk%t•r Los Angeio,and Orange County(ever 1100)sites • r`h,6 ciosrir mth 7440 Sates Team in identifyEng areas of opportunity far improved et.storner adoit c n,, feduceo churn at d in nlei;aent,.usto,n r)ouild+ng solutions • Interact pith s,vitch Korn Group FOP'.),Area Pfoiect Manager and'tte West Regrcn Project M-ifiager;o that T 1 haivest executed on schedule market unrnrnitmf.�nts are met and acm rate represf—lahun of T%are der^rnmi ,coned 'And tr aJed in the Wle-Cl Region database • Effectively implemented a COW(Cell On Whe Ali for d special event on tune by work rig t'o-,C y z:r=t, -an': I ed5lr o n rtra�)#s Cnis� to fitly deliver high quality performance and continue to exceed set objectives for nay d'si(in,�c a;ea ;u 0o,3r1er5,)f 150'o MCJ tnrg( rx h eared) Awarded plaques for cxemp'ary performance in 0301)and r.J'06 • Instrumental in the st,cress Cif LAOC T-Mobdo Engineering Tram K hicvin(;lh-'ovof t dr,,p calf it ,A Arx-I t,y Telopl t a d,,ve try'rE 5oli, • Execute PSS t,aranretcr trials and imptenaented changes to imorcvc customer c°xt,rrience T-Mobile Inland Empire,Ca t'lov 2904-wun 200,) RF Erxq ri,er_tlobrle • Applied t P"t(,ptirnlzarlon pracliee4 and provided guidance to employees ciiid contractors to maintain and improve the q i aHy of trip nt'Mork in the Inland Empire Marke, • insrnimenrai rn marr to rw q ano,n,prov,ng the quality of T-Mobile customers in inland Ernuire ma6et after Califomm taxe ovor of T-Mobile lion,Cinqular in Jan 2005 LCC lnternational,Inc McLean,VA 1A 1996-`act 2004 Pnn,1pel Fityirt",;r C,)n,uitant'ci en f t,)e'd R"Ei�,,nei'r,ng 0ttreless netwoll,optimiza"on performance an't f n'wiir'gt frdn'-*'f W,V:f"'o,4 operators and equ,j,m(nt vendors GSM(5 Years) Project Manactetnetit • Trained managers and engineers on GStv4,GPRS,EDGE knovAedge Nok,a Irnolemcntatrons :,cst m'--Art practice,, call proccssing,trouble shooting,OSS tools and BSS Parameters monitor opt n,zc and utilize the spectrum efficiently • Planed project timeline and execute deliverables for GSM k-,ovaledge tians•cr to Cingu:w',Ni-eiess a,,d ATT`d S E-rj nee rs and Managers in Jacksonville Orlando Louisville and Evansville Eared Cl,ent u as well as the vti^dor s confiuence througia m_y work dedicat,on and knoavledge EXIIIBIT 1 —PAGE 5 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 26 Filed 08/17/2009 Page 7 of 12 • Supervised engineers'o achieve uClurxm(,,al of chant saiisl action and p>rxir";,k +gti<iirty JWOUt • I-,telac'Fd wftn crows-functional gra—ps<uch as Con traction Bite Acquisitio^ RF E%inee-i% Pio ect .Management tnd Legai departnientz to achieve be,I and e`,ment ri-sults�)i 'he Trent Prop lded covelace plats to Sales RF OptimizationtNetwork Performance • Optimized the GSM'GPRS net5vork through extensive drive test ana ysis and parametet mo&icatiors including frequency planning,re tune of BCCH KIC HSN MA,0,Handovet and Povver control setting~ etc to meet' exceed market nerformance objectives • Used Nokia Net Doctor Reports,BEAST,ana Nokia Data Warehouse Reports for performance analysis of KPIs • Detaried knowledge of GSM call processing Nokia UoS tcois and B3fJ patanirteis • Performed syotern mdc parameter audit on the GSM 3SS and mplernented changes to improve netwom performance • Analysed(,luster drive test data using Ef,csson's TErMS TC"rS Inv,sugation,GiMS software and tMapinfo • Tested features and recommend system wide pa,ameter settings RF Design • Designed sites for DCS-1&00 market w,nq Enc,sou Eq,riornenl sate N-;lneriardz, Rva ponsiDle for ,^,li aspects ci RF Lngineering design • Tuned propagation models foi d,ifertmt o io pholcgica, enviionme„ts and perIvIT ed RF nvttiork deli gn us ng CoHCAD a Lin,x hosed propagation r,r„ir tang soit.,an, • Appl,eo uest design standards n se e(,hr, iritenna tioe,, Bl S config,ir it i r 3,1,1 c,rnductcd f u location studies in achieving cost-effective outputs Clients Dngular'Alfeless JacKsolville FL lNUkia(SS Support} Jun 2J03-Apr 2004 AT&T,vir(4,,s KY rNokra BSS) '-et 200-Jun 2003 Teifort Bit( rri.tc�dmil Netherlands)(Ericsson KS) i ct 1gg3-Oct 2000 COMA[4 Years) Project Management • Led group of engineers ana DfrV�T,,J<=',il ii 10,1 ii• f,mviding train ng and tet,i,tr i 41(I,,;til in 0 It tht,t)ptirrwal On efforts of Syracuse Buffalo and RvIi,,,ter CDNIA WY f,'Hr;,ysi-,m Respon;it:e tot oet,,orl,peiforrnanre iss,.es and implementing uhn,iges for vanow,r lfent4 11irvuf1hout my tenter£ * Defined entrance and exit criteria tot acceplaole level of quality of service for market lriuncn n Frontier Cell tar �JE;nLJ`i} Prepaied and presented system performance reviews M, tie -1 111 at,the r_otrp,eGan of tnr, piolect that was accepted by the Director of Engineering and the Vi,i;Pre"idprit of Gperations * Led now site integration efforts in preparing site da,a fill and coordira,ing ,•,nth Network Operatior Equipment vi,ndoi and Emirneering Denartments for timely testing and efficient integration of 1140's rew sites into the exislinq ,)mwork RF OptimizationlNetwork Performance • Optimized PCCS and CDMA,'AtfIPS overlay mark+et5 indwfir g anti nna dumi tilt wait:h parameter changes such as neighbor's list powet settings search window:,elungs PN Offset Plan etc iv improve quality of servi[e • Performed switch database audit on Lucent Autorlex 10u0 switch s Executive Cellular Processor(ECP) • Identified maloi bottleneck of network ,,locking in life 5ESS sw tch related to shortage of Speech Handlers and recommended SCiutions to the Network Cperotions ind R,Manager • Mooitored daily service measurements and KPis usrtg Prospect and switch srripts • Performed capacity analysts and prepared channel t4me,,t expansion plan -Ali DSO allocations to the 'Lucent Nliniceil Microcell and Modcell for voice of d Grata cji,s • Coorcinaled and implemented IS-41 ;-ucenf Lucent Hard Handrifl between W);end Spnnt Connecticut New Yolk and Buffalo inafkets • Performed FOA integtation test,,in Syra,u,,c market for new soft,,v,vo and hardware,iligrades to Lucent Auiopler 1000 svNitch and cell sites RF Design * Tuned p(opagatron models and performed RF Neh:fork design using dt.ciBel Planter fo, iO * Conanctcd safety and heaitti standard tests and reports * Represented 14 Jr);is an RF subject rtattt,r expt.rt e)runcig I,vwinifs W w,ri favorable rer-ults Clients EXIIIFIIT 1 -PAGE 6 Case 2 09-cv-03777-RGK-SS Document 26 Filed 08/17/2009 Page 8 of 12 I S r,E lulu (Lyo,hcufg 'je)Lureiu GDMA VAPS Oven iy c'200 I•idcprnden'Wireless I),,( ((iv%(Sprint Pt S Affiliate Aloany,NY i Nov 2000-Oct 2002 Sprint PC";iRoche-fer NY)LU+,ent CDNIA Ju 1998-Oct 19f6 Front=cr C1J,)r(Venzon)(Rochester NY)Lu,-ert CDr�1A A(iPS(7aerfny May 1997 -Oct 1997 ne I Atl-�h( NYNEX r lohi e t'Anzon)(Ne,v York C,ty NY) Sep 1996 -Ma, 19 7 CompetLti_ve Benchmark • Cc Iccted data using LCC's EXP-2u?1,Collect 2000 LL-''UuJ and Aurst • Dost ProccssFu-nd analyzed data using CM and De3KCAT 2 B • Picpored d cf,npetitive�erchrnarki analysis wporl for LCC s cl,ent',tnet Compares networw VU(Le gUdtity Cdll W p t i,ir and droprcd calls fof various wireless operators incluaing Spurt P(,S i'e,ion AT&T Vireless flex,�l 'o o- Streani etc TANG Automation Inc New Orleans La Aug 19cio-inlay 1 J;d Systems Engineer • DesIgii-a '-L,perV,ory i,ontrol r,id Data AcgwiJion Ct ntiol Systi-rr, (SCA04) for W,,i,,r r,nd Waste, wxer ticatrwe"t (<nt, • nsf�.t d an,i 1,sted final dcsyis cEfore the products are shi peed to ci,ents • ',t'!1zed t 11`1 ',t tic line If e r{e^v,software fof the Jf°,I)n of V:,sto water(x otiol 5y t,"7iS Experience with Tools Software M,,(Afire i`Nord txcel,A(ce-, �orrzr Point rrolact N s,o) f,1,ip ri,o O',pice,.,rid Firr3nim f'i is RF Tools enc, c t,, H(Aiz,GSS Tcols NCx)a Node[tanager BTS Manager [race',iew o TENS investicatic, C-'1C,'D ,iEci i P:dn ier Ass+-t inven3G CIIAS Ac',x Analyzar Autopace ,Natchniarf,Prirpect HP Prot cann"I Cl Ix C-pt GCS r,'t tric<, Operating Systems tVinruows xP VVin.ovvs 2ui;C Unix D{Jw, Education E,, E1ErInca,t-ngineeting L niversrty of New(deans A f laay I -j,, Ptotessional Trarrninct T-Mobile E'te~tive S,pe .ory*,1a iagcmnt bl',11 S Fui,9a rf t,,itils Cverv,e;i and W„gnaling Uf.jTS r in',rfi,c,c rind R,N P,otocols and Procedure, EOi.,E'{,°kF Lngineers GSM and AMIR Perforn aiire Workshop t'Joik,ng and a,'mmng the pAlic to the Nth Degree Nokia EDGE Tw wmivyicii Di,m-,isrmmg and Planning Trace Jim,r '.c?ia WAS 2000,`,UI Lucent Technologies f,uf.A'iG 1x RF Desig,^E-ogineeii-g and Bast}Station Call Processing RF i,c rfcim anc enoi i(,r-ring of f,DfAA Systems C DNIA Rr Opimiization and Took Wireless Institute of LCC InIfcouction to GPRS GSNi DCS 183g Ciperat-ins and Piotoruls ,Introduction to Gualcurrint GOMA [)uect Scqusnce Spread Spe;truni I,troauction to Cellular Communicabona Antennas for Cellular and PCS Link BuJget Analysis Col CAD Introduction io i ihiTS T:-ne�tnal Rad,n Access(UTRA) RF Safety EXHIBIT 1 - 1'A(;L 7 " - Sigr Coverage Without HARBOUR VIEW '*'m l sr� 1 `y Par idge Cir g. m N 3 5 a m n ovewood Dr w r m r w W O cr a) d1, o et F 0 m q� SUNSET AQUATIC MARINA Penmen 020 w Bravata Dr Dominica Cir q Alderporl Dr pJ 9 w, Audr Ile Dr °s Chase Dr c G C) Qr ?w207 y Ct Windspun Dr Aruba Cir C. Uuani m Hilo CI Cherylc Dr. g` '��y A4uanus Or °— o` Margarita Dr m 3 o m n z o aa� c gnne n 11 Bd gas/ =' Angelina Dr m c �' m D I37 Cry^ �di°. n7ope0 �, °sid PyC. g Via Vista Cir r r ryh�r�`a ` CP C o �y9��'iC^/@cll� LL HARBOUR VIEW Cabana Or _� O Fernhill Cir N 2 ^ LA13156 Arena Cir F Bfatotd� Chadwick Dr m �S g Brightfield Cir = side Cv9. Fig io Cir San rn 0 Ch X E 2060A�i o 0 0 SHOPPIfjCENTER c _ Acorn Dr 7 ■ U t Q% c T O �' S a °� fair L 0246 �� 0 o in a C/� ra r Of � #AQ, U) 5f015 m c'f ar Dr v Y ar FIRE TATIONAladdin Dr l o Curtis Cir O Warner Ave Los Palos Ave o 2 3 a A r` ¢ mo P� Mo Glenstone Dr r\`o�� cc m�a��� Fi`49,1;hfil• Pir A n This information, property of T-Mobile USA. Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed. Any other use.or distribu Coverage Legend this information is strictly prohibited. This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors.which may change without notice. It may include locations i Outdoor (-91 dbm) limited or no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability. Even within a coverage area.there are several factors,such as. network changes,traffic volume. sr In Vehicle (-84dbm) outages.technical limitations.signal strength,your equipment.terrain,structures. weather,and other conditions that may interfere with actual service,quality.and availabil including the liability to make. receive. and maintain calls. I = In Building(-76 dbm) gigr Coverage for HARBOUR VIEW Iw m �ITO 1 5 Par idge Cir y m N m u ovewood Dr r rD r m m r 0 m O_ rS G) d° O a d i�c9 ` N SUNSET AQUATIC MARINA Pe(`meyt P _ 020 Bravata Dr Dominica Cir q Alderport Dr c 3 �O} Audr tle Dr r m V ind Aruba Cir °s Chase Dr c s Dr Oo Q 6� U o C7. Pun Joan' HiloCi Cherylc . 0 q o a Or � 'm S � 6` o �a 9uaous Or �' c arganta Dr c o y rn �, a � O n r S m (7 — E D D W o ° q - ha Dr m c c m m m e� nee C/^ Ve i Q Pca r r �di°. n��e0 J`' PyC. Via Vista Cir o V 0. �y� P°C�; ! FOy, G�i /PC,�,� BOUR VIEW Cabana Dr v ,a a Fernhill Cir F D m C Arena Cir 2�y Chadwick Or m c � sitle Cir m Say o Brighttield Cir = a m FI &5 n Ch X E 2060A�i o Sh OPPI C N rER c Acorn Dr Dr Uare p LA.0246 l y 0 SDf 'a a C LAO: to Sties m R at Dr Y air FIRE STATION Aladdin Dr Curtis Cir O` Warner Ave Los Pa Ave w m a`' c? a r Q -o a Q7°� l PQe h o o Glenstone Dr L) oc O c U 0e��v`O G..@rz9 Pir a °i.. This information,progeny of T-Mobile USA. Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed.Any other use,or distribu Coverage Legend this information is strictly prohibited. This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors.which may change without notice. It may include locations iI Outdoor (-91 dbm) limited or no coverage. Our maps do not guarantee service availability. Even within a coverage area,there are several factors,such as network changes.traffic volume.stl In Vehicle (-84dbm) outages,technical limitations,signal strength, your equipment,terrain,structures weather,and other conditions that may interfere with actual service,quality.and availabil including the liability to make, receive.and maintain calls. _ In Building(-76 dbm) Sigr Predicted Coverage with Alternate Option: SHOPPING CENTER @75 R lw m Par idge Cir g. 4 N 3 � m N ovewood Dr r r m > j O m v A 3 d9pP \ N SUNSET AQUATIC MARINA Pet`me�ct F _ 02 y Bravata Dr Dominica Cir y° Alderport Dr -Audit tie Di o p Qr 02207 v n Windspun Dr Aruba Cir °s�. Chase Dr J o -� o c o Y a N oanitaOr � m Hilo Cher I . c J 0` o 'yea AQuarrus Dry S o Margarita Dr m o y cy 00 oc q� n "9.°, = 1,5 `-Angelina Dr w c c E m n ae neCir^ e I,& d. s% x M c� m ° 2 m C7 Pc 6 odd rGre� O �s/d y0 o y Via Vista Cir o ,� a j7 �'�` �'° r v F %. 6/s LL Cabana °i 1 ry`'u a C;� Os/ a�, q HOUR VIEW Or v_> m Fernhill Cir .r 9� Ctt '� l 5� O oP m � Arena Cir F cD c� d Chadwick Dr �0`r � Btat Brightfield Cir side Cir Sam o T Figaro Charlotta Or 2O0 oo R 6X+7_ Acorn Or n Q ♦ �� y LA,02463A �� 1 E5;o5 m at Or N bar FIRE STATION Aladdin Or 0 Curtis Cir O` Warner Ave Los Palos Ave a a Oo� PQe n trt Glenstone Dr o m o� P\\5\o�e0 o�pc w F o 16VCN - c w 1 �� Bry9VP Pit V Coverage Legend This information,property of T-Mobile USA, Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed.Any other use.or distrtbu this information is strictly prohibited. This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors.which may change without notice. It may include locations r Outdoor (-91 dbm) limited or no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability. Even within a coverage area,there are several factors,such as:network changes,traffic volume. sr In Vehicle (-84dbm) outages,technical limitations.signal strength,your equipment,terrain,structures.weather. and other conditions that may interfere with actual service,quality, and availabil including the liability to make,receive,and maintain calls. = In Building(-76 dbm) sigr i Predicted Coverage with Alternate Option: SHOPPING CENTER @55 tt Iw�j� 1 ar edge Cir y. y 3 a s - m N ovew do Or > j 0 c Q A C d On o SUNSET AQUATIC MARINA Qentne�O�jAudr A020 3 a P T Bravata Or Dominica Cir Alderpon Or 9�a� tie Or Qr o 207 7 a IN Aruba Aruba Cir Cis, Chase Or c 00 3� , } Q yc Pun Dr ��ani Hiloheryl c or o f �� Aguanus pr ° 5 o Margarita Dr m m o in m y m a 0 0o gnno n, 6d �ldsi Angelina Or = v c 'o m m n Pcae Cir^ epiGre ��s� = w Via Vista Gr ? J 0 = m a _ 0 DP Or Q' db� CC ri o r I 1c a F /p. e Cabana D, L� rlh `a C) �S r� e, HARBOUR VIEW N v Fernhill Cir I. L� OP m` g� Arena Cir o m 21°j1 ,Q U C� Branford TS Chadwick Or = N 1r Sea o Brightfield Cir y 1� , Side Cir N Figaro Cir- E 2060A3 o R m ER ) a Charlotta Or c _ Acorn Or O 9 m no o 0 i ? L 24 1U Qt Cn SttrIl co m ar Or S a1r FI E ATION Aladdin Dr _ B Curtis Cir O Warner Ave Los Palo s Ave w m ac O n is Q' a C 0o PQe r o r ' M Glenstone Dr O t o) 0cr+ooaQf o Ba - N N �o Pir toimm"Ill.- V Coverage Legend This information,property of T-Mobile USA. Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed.Any other use.or claribu this information is strictly prohibited. This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors,which may change without notice. It may include locations r Outdoor (-91 dbm) limited or no coverage. Our maps do not guarantee service availability. Even within a coverage area,there are several factors.such as: network changes. traffic volume.sr In Vehicle (-84dbm) outages.technical limitations.signal strength, your equipment.terrain,structures,weather,and other conditions that may interfere with actual service, quality,and availabil including the liability to make, receive.and maintain calls. = In Building(-76 dbm) Case 2 09-cv-03777- '<-SS Document 26-2 Filed ( 7/2009 Page 1 of 8 1 JOHN J. FLYNN III (CA 76419) 2 jflynn@nossaman.com SCOTT N YAMAGUCHI (CA 157472) 3 syamaguchi@nossaman.com BENJAMIN Z RUBIN (CA 249630) 4 brubin@nossaman.com 5 NOSSAMAN LLP 18101 Von Karman Avenue, Suite 1800 6 Irvine, CA 92612 7 Telephone: (949) 833-7800 Facsinule: (949) 833-7878 8 9 Attorneys for Plaintiff, 10 OMNIPOINT COMMUNICATIONS INC. 11 12 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 13 CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 14 15 OMNIPOINT COMMUNICATIONS Case No CV09-3777 RGK (SSx) INC., a Delaware corporation, 16 EXHIBITS 6- 12 TO DECLARATION 17 Plaintiff, OF MICHAEL GETANEH IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF'S 18 vs. MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY 19 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, a INJUNCTION 20 public entity organized and existing under Date: August 31, 2009 the laws of the State of California; 21 CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF Time: 9:00 a.m. HUNTINGTON BEACH, Dept.: Roybal Courtroom 850 22 [Hon. R. Gary Klausnerl 23 Defendants. 24 25 26 27 28 EXHIBITS 6-12 TO DECLARATION OF MICHAEL GETANEH IN SUPPORT OF PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION -1 Slgr Predicted Coverage with Alternate Option: SHOPPING CENTER @40 it w r �= Par Doge Cir 4 m^ N m a 00 ovewood Dr m r m m > > O c CIA 0 A cu 4Audf cu ojcqc SUNSET AO IATIC MARINA t me 020 Bravata Dr Dominica Cir q� Alderporl Dr tleDr a,o Qr o 207 v o Vvincispun Aruba Cir °s� Chase Dr c O s _ Dr 7J ,/r, -C+ Hilo G F r 6 anrra Or m Jcc 0 5 0 �a Aquarius Or wo °- o Margarita Or m m o � a w v o° q� n 6 9a = °Angelina Dr w c m m ai z iL P°a¢ g neCrr Ada �P�yGreO Cd d0 Io via Vista Cir o M = _ P r ' 6/ �' a m J ^I r m k" /� e Cabana D 4y/ �iL, 0,; HARBOUR VIEW r rn o Fernhill Cir N 2� Ctt m p. LA 6 Arena Cir =_ 1l toed� Chadwick Or _ [V 2 r Btao K Brightfield Cir gl Sam o c �0 side Cir _ Flgaro Cir $. Charlotte A C� `� w T a otta Dr 2060 ER a :3 c _ Acorn Or o 0 1 9`' .D L no 244 .0 o U) StdUs m _ ar Dr co C N y b`r FIRE ATIONAIaddin Or Curtis Cir _ O` L Warner Ave Los Palos Ave m m m a o CV) Glenstone Dr O 0a�°odOr � i 0 � - N o 8, - Pir V Coverage Legend This information.property of T-Mobile USA. Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed.Any other use.or distribu this information is strictly prohibited. This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors.which may change without notice. It may include locations Outdoor (-91 dbm) limited or no coverage-Our maps do not guarantee service availability.Even within a coverage area,there are several factors,such as. network changes,traffic volume,se In Vehicle (-84dbm) outages.technical limitations. signal strength.your equipment.terrain, structures.weather.and other conditions that may interfere with actual service.quality, and availabif including the liability to make.receive,and maintain calls. I In Building(-76 dbm) -1 Sfgr Predicted Coverage with Alternate Option: FIRE STATION @ 75 it lw• ' m 1 9 H Per idge Cir 4. 3 00 lovewoGd Or 1- 1- m w c O cM o O A 0 C ale (P etet P o c - q� c° SUNSET AQUATIC MARINA ep� m 020 0) o d Bravata Or Dominica Cir q° Alderport Or P r tie Dr a� Audr o Qr 2207 m winds Aruba CIr °s Chase Or c N -, o C? c Pun Or C%, -� c Cheryl R y m -� Hilo Ci c o r y on Juanita pr y o � o ��a A4uarius Dr m 5 0`Margarita Dr m o y N o oo qnn n 3 B 9°, Angelina Or m c ro' m in t� Pcae eCir 4', eek�eo S odl°s'dS�05- o r10n Via Vista Cir � o m 0 = � � r P° r ro F or` 6iP LL Cabana Or ' O ' Z rl5 46 ` Cu �;�, o os9 �iC C,� HARBOUR VIEW rn oo Fernhill Cir I clicn ti ,Sr ` D ci C;^ totd lz LA13156 Arena Cir Chadwick Or N 2 �, 0ra� g Brightfield Cir 1 side Cir Figaro Cir u San a Charlotte Or` XE 2 m :3 SHOPPR CENTER Acorn Or o O r6TMqy 2463 =I Cir r a -0 JAO, V) ar Or m CO m m r y a� FI E in Or Curtis Clr O` 3 0 r Los Palos Ave m. aec t` 3 a moo` PQe r o^ c+) Glenstone Or o rp t c \eO�oodpi m F o ga iN c y @ri CID ga U ..� Coverage Legend This information, progeny of T-Mobile USA, Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed. Any other use.or distnbu this information is strictly prohibited. This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors.which may change without notice. It may include locations r Outdoor (-91dbm) limited or no coverage. Our maps do not guarantee service availability. Even within a coverage area.there are several factors, such as:network changes,traffic volume,sj In Vehicle (-84dbm) outages,technical limitations.signal strength, your equipment,terrain,structures.weather,and other conditions that may interfere with actual service.quality, and availabil including the liability To make. receive.and maintain calls. �- In Building(-76 dbm) Sl9r Predicted Coverage with Alternate Option: FIRE STATION @ 55 It Age Cir 9 m m 3 00 ovewood Or r m r m w m r O c d o a a o a P P 0 o CL r°�L � SUNSET AQUATIC MARINA ed(oeNe( m A020 P 1—eravata Dr Dominica Cir Alderpon Or� m 9�ar Audr " tie Or o Qr 2207 v m Winds Aruba Clr °s Chase Or c G c\l1 .� - o n c Pun Or Q'� c Cheryl � 6e ° o �� w Juanita Or m Hilo Ci S 0 5� o gym` A4uariUs Dr 9 o Margarita Or m Co o y N m C1 r = _ n =_ 10Argelina Or m c c m m ui n W t� Pcae� neCir 2/d Len10e J d'OS/ S/ab m Via Vista Cir : J 0 re V r5 6P� Di 'm �'°/ �6/eA C%^ LL y w U'° � Fos. �a� cr HARBOUR VIEW Cabana Or � m � Fernhill Cir I 3� Gil p '97 0 o co p m C' LA13156 Arena Cr m Zos O '� antotd Chadwick Or F N 0�r B i.- Brightfield Cir m side Cir o Figaro Cir N Saint a Charlotta Dr K ` 2060A� o ) c SHOPPIPJCENTER c _ Acorn Or W 'm c T no � o 0 � ° `� n a O Mair L 24 `U i o m `y Cr r a JAO,(n toC) > ar Or ma m rFI. E 10 •din DrCurtis CirLos Palos Ave 3 � o ch r Glenstone Or o ' w t _ � P��s�ocaOrv+o°aOt m � F o ga c? N Gam` O� c c 0aw`O G.t @rig Pir Coverage Legend This information, property of T-Mobile USA. Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed. Any other use or drstnbu this information is strictly prohibited. This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors.which may change without notice. It may include locations i Outdoor (-9ldbm) limited or no coverage. Our maps do not guarantee service availability. Even within a coverage area.there are several factors,such as:network changes.traffic volume.sr In Vehicle (-84dbm) outages.technical limitations,signal strength.your equipment,terrain, structures.weather,and other conditions that may interfere with actual service.quality and availabil including the liability to make, receive,and maintain calls. In Building(-76 dbm) i Sigr Predicted Coverage with Alternate Option: FIRE STATION @ 40 tt w ri Q n, dge Cir c °O ovewood Dr 0 r r m w to ' O cm LO t7 d� P 0 a 0L (P SUNSET AOILATIC MARINA �'01100to 20 e rn y Bravata Dr Dominica Cir .y'a Alderport Dr Audr " Ile Dr CD o Qr � 0 207 v n windspun Dr Aruba Cir 00 Chase Dr a C <� ye" o ` ^JyC, Juanita Or m Hilo G Cheryl J g CD �� o 'fix`` Aquarius Dr ° 5 0`Margarita Dr m m 0 oc qn n R ^a TAngelina Dr m c E ui > t� Pcae� neCir Ada Veo/`QO J ca�s,�s'P.�� o Via Vista Cir D ea r 0 � O 6/ �� LL W o y�r PQ HARBOUR VIEW Cabana Dr p. u) ' 9. a s; � _ (D Fernhill Cir T 9� CGr o 9q "� N ti ti p m C. LA13156 Arena Cir cp 2�e c� � rd Chadwick Or N r Branto �:Brightfield Cir N0 1 side Cir o Figaro Cir San o. Charlot to Dr ts: 2060A� o o SHOPPItiCENTER c c _ Acorn Dr c't O ti N 9 m c "n efle _ d O O min n ar Dr m 71 Y a FI E din Dr D Curtis Cir _ O` 0 t Los Palos Ave a t` a Oo� PQe o h ' tq Glenstone Dr o m o pps�O� 006 gacmOt O F l N V` 00 � tU �ct ��B Pir cc 0ox U nArti..1. Coverage Legend This information.property of T-Mobile USA. Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed.Any other use or distiibu this information is strictly prohibited. This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors,which may change without notice. It may include locations i Outdoor (-91 dbm) limited or no coverage. Our maps do not guarantee service availability. Even within a coverage area.there are several factors,such as network changes.traffic volume.s< In Vehicle (-84dbm) outages.technical limitations, signal strength.your equipment, terrain,structures.weather. and other conditions that may interfere with actual service.quality,and availabil including the liability to make.receive,and maintain calls. = In Building(-76 dbm) Predicted Coverage with Alternate Option: SUNSET AQUATIC MARINA @ 70 ft T ri asarn air Dovewood Dr co C ail Cir m O m to `O a m iT A O > > P 4. P G SUNS AQ Pei6t`e�ef Pd r p avata Dr Dominica Cir Alderport Dr ' N 900 Gables y Audr r Q 207 rdspun Dr Aruba Cir O` osC. Chase Dr 3 c '� Kon Dr 0 5 3� Dominguez Dr to .- m G 5 Hilo Cir Cheryl 0 Aquarius 9 T m M 0 '; Maui Cir C y a Or ih ?- y Margarita Dr 10 Oahu C KA— LL c soil Racquet Club Dr Angelina Dr 0 °�Ann 9a 8 r w Grp N Pca¢ 6� e Crf 'li � oi8 c ds sidyC. Davis Cup Df 3 G7 6i�` 5� o di0, O, f Mhp o Via Vista Cir 0 5 N Rr2bys �� PdC� ti Co��f�io�l� HunlingtonHarbo n Cabana Dr rn C S Os. C. HARBOUR VIEW o < �d 5 '� `9a ^ $tat Of Arena Cir Connec g Road E ,y� �� U �-.� 001dtn9 " LA13156 _ 2 ,�r 5 gfantotd a Cha m p ��r��� sitle ° n Brigl Cir O° Pearce o W Dale Dr a a„c U) 2o60A0,, o � SHOPPI!jCENTER c - Acorn d D N W Y 1 n m 5 -c' d 4,a 24 n m P a q"(00 nCcF 5 aC" i r Of a5 0 tx\r �� 2` Hermanson Cir m v FI E STATION -'Aladdin Or Curtis Cir p` o t c sraP C = ca �c i m a O N 3 N v Q 00� N 7 y 0 N r- U This intormation,property of T-Mobile USA. Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed.Any other use.or tlisin Coverage Legendbu this information is strictly prohibited.This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors,which may change without notice. It may include locations r Outdoor (-91dbm) limited or no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability. Even within a coverage area,there are several factors,such as:network changes,traffic volume,si In Vehicle (-84dbm) outages.technical limitations,signal strength,your equipment.terrain.structures,weather,and other conditions that may interfere with actual service,quality,and availabil including the liability to make,receive,and maintain calls. = In Building(-76 dbm) Predicted Coverage with Alternate Option: SUNSET AQUATIC MARINA @ 55 It (1 1 vr asant vlr Dovewood Or - cc) C jail Cir m fA a3 OOt o p > > P Cadcr. ILe9LP G SUNS a Peol"evef Fd Bravata Or Dominica Cir Alderport Or v ' o quo Gables N Audr N Q °s Chase Dr 3 c Kon Dr r 02207 G`�c� , indsPun Or Aruba Cir O C,� Cher I Dominguez Or C) 0 —c1 Hilo Cir y C- 0 o \`e Aquarius 9 s6 co .3 Maui Cir Oahu �aJ Or a9/ire GYC! ° Margarita Or M = o jL ❑ C;r Racquet Club Or w C7 ` qnn 9a Angelina Or ? W N P`ae `5`� ` e C? Lio° �Pnrear J �,75/d sic Davis Cup Or Harbor Mhp a Via Vista Cir c7 a N `L`O r r �'o m C0/ 61P Huntington 9 Cabana Or LD F7s/ rCi HARBOUR VIEW L�� + Cad 9� r Star of Arena Cir Connec g Road O F 2,5� ° c �� MorMn9ord O� LAt 3156 - G) Chad v ,o, r` Bra m '� C� Bright O � �A side Cir o o° Pearce $ LLI m Dale Or a Gharh 0206 AO, o j co SHOPPII CENTER c - Acorn[ U ■ lone D f p A. 2Q L; nG�r�� o a C„ is �ft�e of m� m c� r Stirus dim � 5 C) air �� c - Hermanson Cir m U FIRE S,ZATION laddip Dr o �y;;�Sa° Curtis Cir _ p` c O .. .� Cir W �a N 3 3o a �o N o in (0 r U I Coverage Legend This information,property of T-Mobile USA, Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed. Any other use.or distribu this information is strictly prohibited This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors.which may change without notice. It may include locations� Outdoor (-9l dbm) limited or no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability. Even within a coverage area.there are several factors.such as: network changes.traffic volume.si In Vehicle (-84dbm) outages.technical limitations.signal strength. your equipment.terrain. structures weather and other conditions that may interfere with actual service.quality,and availabil including the liability to make.receive.and maintain calls In Building(-76 dbm) Predicted Coverage with Alternate Option: SUNSET AQUATIC MARINA @ 40 It T 1 vi asani ur Dovewood Or - c0 C Jail Cir m c cn 00 v m � a � M A p > > P d dory° eke'Pit m 9Le G SUNSE perm r rn Bravata Dr Dominica Cir Alderport Dr ' 0 9dal Gables Audr N Aruba Clr r Q 007 Gwc\e Wr°ospun Dr p` odC Chase Dr 3 J D c Kon Dr Cheryl u. 5� MIN �c ,� Dominguez Dr m Hilo Cir `may Ts Fo f m Maui Cir S ` 0 �a` '4quarius Dr 9a91". SZ/1 � Margarita Dr Co -0 = Oahu � m nAaar LL 9 n dC¢ �' Racquet Club Dr u+ o A q� Angelina Dr n r n oae` oe Qir Vep/u edr� �s/di Davis Gup Or w n v L7 N Q- r ` �d/ re0 ° s/ C}�, r MhP o Via vista Cir Q US 6` 9 o a r -+ C db ton Harbor m � a N ` % %r � d�C y % /oc Hunting 9 Cabana Dr � L rL N Fi , /p. p HARBOUR VIEW r4 of LD�a Odd m s90 r Or Arena Cir Connec tg Road O F 21y� ��o m O C;y MorMn9odDn LA131E in - Gt ra N U Chad UO "` \5\ 6 o 'm - ^' Bright = p �0 1 side Cir 03 O o n X o p Pearce 0 m Dale Dr m C. � 20fj0A�. o ? m U SHOPPItiCENTER Acorn Y o I O r _°r J W 24 D mMa11a c. r r Ktt�en Du �P� m n d arc �� c Hermanson Cir m L) FI E STATION —°'Aladdip Dr o' hq/ Curtis Cir p` /0•e = mC O .� '� Cir N Q a mo�N U) 0) o Y) r6 r U Coverage Legend This information, property of T-Mobile USA. Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed. Any other use,or distribu this information is strictly prohibited. This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors.which may change without notice. It may include locations), Outdoor (-91 dbm) limited or no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability. Even within a coverage area,there are several factors,such as network changes,traffic volume. sr In Vehicle (-84dbm) outages,technical limitations, signal strength,your equipment.terrain,structures.weather.and other conditions that may interfere with actual service,quality,and avadabil including the liability to make,receive.and maintain calls. In Building(-76 dbm) 1 2 3 4 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA 5 6 7 DECLARATION OF DANIEL WANG 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 DECLARATION OF DANIEL WANG 1 I, Daniel Wang, declare: 2 1. I am the RF Engineering Manager for T-Mobile USA, Inc. ("T-Mobile") in 3 the Los Angeles/Orange County market ("LA/OC Market"). I submit this declaration in 4 support of T-Mobile's existing permits and approvals for two stealth wireless 5 telecommunications facilities proposed to be located in Harbour View Park and Bolsa 6 View Park, City of Huntington Beach, California. I have personal knowledge of the facts 7 set forth below, and, if called as a witness, I could and would competently testify thereto. 8 2. 1 am a qualified radio frequency engineer, and I have over 11 years of 9 experience designing, operating, monitoring and optimizing wireless networks. I have 10 been trained to identify gaps in reliable service in personal wireless service 11 communications systems and to assess the ability of proposed antenna sites to remedy 12 gaps in signal coverage and capacity within a network of compatible facilities. I have 13 specific training, experience and education in the design of advanced digital wireless 14 networks, including the Second Generation ("2G") network based on GSM technology, 15 as well as GPRS and EDGE technologies. 16 3. The ability of T-Mobile's customers to make an E911 call from a mobile 17 device is of critical importance to the health and safety of T-Mobile's customers and the 18 general public. Internal T-Mobile data, to which I have access in the performance of my 19 duties as RF Engineering Manager for the LA/OC Market, shows that in the month of 20 July there were 5,855 E911 calls made in the areas immediately adjacent to the proposed 21 sites (1,135 for Harbour View, and 4,720 for Bolsa View). Attached hereto as Exhibit 1 22 and 2 are true and correct summaries of the E911 caller data for the facilities immediately 23 adjacent to the coverage areas. 24 4. Moreover, providing quality in-building and in-vehicle voice and data 25 personal wireless services, with sufficient system capacity and high speed data rates, is 26 critical to T-Mobile's customers, and is essential to T-Mobile's competing effectively 27 with its functionally equivalent competitors. 28 5. Using MapInfo, a commercially available database that provides population I DECLARATION OF DANIEL WANG I estimates for defined geographic areas (in this case, the geographic area specified were 2 the coverage objectives for the two facilities), I was able to confirm that there are 3 approximately 19,427 additional residents in the coverage areas who could be served by 4 the proposed facilities (13,264 in the coverage area for Harbour View, and 6,163 in the 5 coverage area for Bolsa View). Attached as Exhibit 3 is a true and correct copy of the 6 map depicting the coverage objectives and population figures. 7 6. T-Mobile routinely provides Propagation Maps to local governments to 8 demonstrate the need to locate and construct a new personal wireless service facility, 9 commonly known as a "cell site," to remedy a significant gap in reliable service. In this 10 regard, Propagation Maps demonstrate the radio frequency ("RF") coverage that can be 11 expected over a geographic area based on certain assumptions. These assumptions 12 include, without limitation, factors such as: the frequency of the RF signal; the height of 13 the antennas above local terrain; the signal gain due to the directional nature of the 14 antennas; the terrain over which the RF signals are being broadcast; and the strength of 15 the RF signals. 16 7. Currently, T-Mobile utilizes Enterprise Asset software to produce its 17 Propagation Maps; Enterprise Asset is a digital predictive modeling tool that identifies 18 areas where reliable coverage will exist and where it will not. Digital predictive 19 modeling tools attempt to match a model of the propagation environment to known 20 measurements in an area. In the past few years, significant strides have been made in 21 refining the accuracy and reliability of Enterprise Asset's predictions. As a result, the 22 Propagation Maps being produced today by T-Mobile are even more accurate that they 23 were two years ago. 24 8. As part of my responsibilities as an RF Engineering Manager, I oversee the 25 production of candidate plots and Propagation Maps for areas in the LA/OC Market. 26 Under my supervision, T-Mobile has produced candidate plots depicting the ring center, 27 primary candidates, and alternative candidates for the coverage gap in and around 28 Harbour View Park and Bolsa View Park. The candidate plots are attached hereto as 2 DECLARATION OF DANIEL WANG I Exhibits 4 and 5. Under my supervision, T-Mobile also recently produced Propagation 2 Maps depicting T-Mobile's current coverage for the areas in and around Habour View 3 Park and Bolsa View Park. These Propagation Maps confirm that T-Mobile has 4 significant gaps in reliable service. The Propagation Maps are attached hereto as 5 Exhibits 6 and 7. 6 9. I also evaluated signal quality issues pertaining to services in the areas 7 surrounding the proposed sites. Attached hereto as Exhibits 8 and 9 are charts depicting 8 network performance data for the sites surrounding the proposed facilities for the month 9 of July. As demonstrated by the data, there are significant network performance issues 10 (dropped calls) in the areas surrounding the proposed sites (i.e., 3,621 dropped calls for 11 Harbour View, and 2,510 dropped calls for Bolsa View). Based on my review of the 12 Propagation Maps and accompanying materials and data, installation of the proposed 13 facilities will rectify the current network performance issues. 14 10. Under my supervision, along with the Propagation Maps depicting T- 15 Mobile's current coverage in and around Harbour View Park and Bolsa View Park, T- 16 Mobile recently prepared a set of Propagation Maps identifying the predicted coverage 17 resulting from siting a wireless facility at: (i) Harbour View Park; (ii) the Fire Station; 48 (iii) Grace Lutheran Church; (iv) Harbour Lights Apartments; (v) Harbour View 19 Elementary School; (vi) Huntington Harbour Mall; (vii) Bolsa View Park; (viii) Marine 20 View Middle School; (ix) the shopping center at 5972 Warner Avenue; (x) the shopping 21 center at 5885 Warner Avenue; and (xii) the Meadowlark Golf Club located at 16782 22 Graham Street. Exhibits 10-20 are true and correct copies of the recently prepared 23 Propagation Maps depicting the coverage predicted from placing a facility at the above 24 locations. 25 11. As demonstrated by Exhibits 11-15, none of the locations, all of which are 26 highly speculative (i.e., there has been no indication of a willing landlord, if a facility at 27 the location is permitted by the City's code, if the parties could reach an agreement, or if 28 it is a "constructable" site) in any event, would achieve T-Mobile's coverage objective, 3 DECLARATION OF DANIEL WANG I an objective that is completely satisfied by the proposed Habrour View facility. 2 1 Therefore, based on the Propagation Maps, Harbour View Park is the least intrusive 3 alternative that will satisfy T-Mobile's coverage objective. 4 12. As demonstrated by Exhibits 17-20, none of the locations, all of which are 5 highly speculative (i.e., there has been no indication of a willing landlord, if a facility at 6 the location is permitted by the City's code, if the parties could reach an agreement, or if 7 it is a"constructable" site) in any event, would achieve T-Mobile's coverage objective, 8 an objective that is completely satisfied by the proposed Bolsa View facility. Therefore, 9 based on the Propagation Maps, Bolsa View Park is the least intrusive alternative that 10 will satisfy T-Mobile's coverage objective. 11 13. As part of my responsibilities as RF Engineering Manager for the LA/OC 12 Market, I reviewed the alternatives analysis attached hereto as Exhibits 21 and 22, as 13 well as materials submitted by T-Mobile during the judicial proceedings in T-Mobile 14 West Corp. v. City of Huntington Beach, and the prior administrative proceedings with 15 the City, which, in combination, represent an accurate assessment of the reasons T- 16 Mobile ruled out various candidate locations. 17 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America 18 that the foregoing is true and correct. 19 20 DATED: August 26, 2010 21 22 Daniel Wang 23 24 25 26 27 28 4 DECLARATION OF DANIEL WANG E911 CALLS SURROUNDING LA13156 HARBOR VIEW from July 1, 2010 to July 31, 2010 SITE ID SECTOR E911 CALLS LA02060A A 117 LA02060A C 162 x LA02093A C 242 Ct7 y LA02463A C 216 LA02207A A 144 LA02463A A 254 TOTAL 1135 E911 CALLS SURROUNDING LA13157 BOLSA VIEW from July 1, 2010 to July 31, 2010 SITE ID SECTOR E911 CALLS LA02495A C 1039 LA02089A A 566 LA02089A C 531 t LA02543A C 490 .r LA02463A A 889 N LA02060A A 767 LA02207A C 438 TOTAL 4720 I L002207 L�A137I 5 LA�13156C LM2060 U 12"3 ' Population count =13264 LA02653 Population count =6163 LA13157B x �& CO 1221 y L002267 * The gray shade shows area L•P02643 where the new site will serve r LA13156 Harbour View Candidates L 1_<f` GTace Lutheran Church ^. 7 1J02040 f74' n WWI^' V c rtF Jj - 'T_ ID ^ r . •,� r H �r U��tt- rtr , _ _�� r llurtlr�gt�nH r ar_H II,• L10^yS4_ ; " W. r _ 1 Legend TY:In[rnw4n,prcpe[p MTt1Y•Ile Ypa,b;l:aM•I1n mll:lnknled[drib hwe ofbbWl•JdIJYadnl4b WCw1 r Ired.•ro ofnu[e.am[ m n: p On Air Sites IM:mmKM: alcl:PR 14111 LTiY:m�•I•If•IIU:Y♦la•I lchimY.:u nkfle::<azlyf mamtlarL Wltllp♦y GYry 11[YII MIa IJIq'IntlbklIXMw WMYwlkda - -oe[.f1e AlY toga dan:AYlvn4t:aJcf atllaldl1L�een'f11YnaCnerytara..1<Rat'[PYltl likrrJu]I YY:rrYM GlryIS,YrCeWkle RNh Wlgf[. Ring Center n: 4tlMcal Iled blare,tlYIVI:IrN h,pV e•IUI•l��enl.4rttln,auarr,'¢a1<I.ml al<l aMllxu IYllbq,'Ink[!R WAMW rlNIX.dVllk.dlll emIId001bbtlUON 11f .Y,nlp bp�Walecel'x,ml malmfncm:. _ � Nternate Candidate Primary Candidate Apnn , 1-A13157 Bolsa View Candidates t �� 1�L up:uic - hopping center t�i WD - i s'8�s oppin cart r " - 1 y' R AA ���•1••j{{1�;1 $� r c I K Marine Ylew Middle School• ��- +� �i• � "`� �' tm ar . 4 Legend 11Yr'Intn alm paph4.RN1111t V ' •Mllcrad la as'II In411. Ay[v ht RI Jim 161. 1 Illllrt.: l ryaxrtu t. II IN On.%IYi �Irvdaalcnl a ppiYYp'�!�]IYI .q prt•Ilcl afl yq II_mFr ail tl I <,x�aye a1ee�u11'�Ytl[h y Ivye IR In.-1111 yl Iu1rL al 11,11 4d l On Air Sites Iegieiape'oammr•IurrlWvaikt erJce anm 1114 ?.n�IlYnac �e`ata'IIx1Tae"reidro11•.Ila rcr _n c��ayel:lanc it crier IWe?�� 1 M Ring Center ea IIInl Olmt.LgrnllhNbrw,elJl enL2knaln.Ilu LAe �ralxi.ml h �111. 6L1y16lfrt tlb 4a urluTidl4rsYlaala•III�TInJUIIMM dpMY In✓ilr, ulu,atll antlln tali.'\ f` �� d� Alternate Candidate A�^ M Primary Candidate Oceanus Predicted Coverage Without Habour View Park )sy Ave o T �'°�` �Jl�e ■ nal Rd w E Sig Gi way Cir ci T Alley c)- O E °`LA334�8Xo. 3 a) 6Pa dge Cir �. s = M mm 3vewood Dr r D 3 a won r � Q o a Marina Vi ing Way �-e.-� 7 C rtmeLei P = System 093A t ti � ¢ 0 . Bravata Dr Dominica Cir q, Alderport Dr P -Edi �9 °a Aud r r Qr` �LA02207A ii °s Chase Dr =v 9° Aruba Cir C, 02 .. } y� p a Hilo Ci Che of o a r m Aquarius Or O m o_ rn D tLj J °6 A r q� �' o m E a •D rn aa� nneCir ?� �c'Oj asiP = CParqueDr o o �° l C i c Via Vista Cir w Grassi Cir ��� ° Cabana Dr ° S o r4 Spa i t o' s9 C Harbouf-Wiew Park m m Femhill Cir Langpo it L 1 ° Arena Cir o Jean .(3 C^ A nette Cir � Brightfield Cir �r ide Cir Do Is Cr �O o o m Date Dr J\\Ct Outrigger Cir Charlotte Dr m 2 SNP Acorn Dr Lao2660A p 5 w y y� LAo2 �� a Aria Ea S pt ° a m LA02853D Q SU\us Dr � Aladdin Dr Is CI Gershwi r dq ' Los Palos Ave a�0' Kenilworth D ¢ 0° P o :. Glenstone Dr E ` R W. m c m pc O o r Pwsco�e °°6Ot Moss Dr ga Bolsa View Park r f. Oac Coverage Legend This information,property of T-Mobile USA,Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed.Any other use or tlistribution of this information is strictly prohibited.This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors,which may cha ge wit ou otice. 1 ay include locations with limited or Outdoor no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability.Even within a coverage area,there are several factors,suc as: . mo k cha ges rabic volume service outages, In Vehicle technical limitations,signal strength,your equipment,terrain,structures,weather,and other conditions that may interfere with actual a ce qu Iry and availability inilutling the ability to make,receive,and maintain calls. In Building W Z2 w N J m 9^iy = a w Predicted Coverage Without Bolsa View Park 77ru _sDr — � o Th 1ps% = n7 o C Parque Dr1 Mobile ' o ill �sf y = m ? wm 8rassi Cir j Bridg D� UOid6ia �� ti o r Heil Ave Cabana Dr ° ❑ = o LA33421A n Fernhill Cir Lal Cir s Bonnie Orleft.24g Danube Or .c — o Jean Or Bisho '�r Ruth Or mc Arena Cir P c a Crandall Dr J 1 ide Cir o Brightfield Cir A nette Cir Y E Brad Or rm Dale Dr Ot Outrigger Cir rac ida 1 Charlotfa Dr Do le Dr A o m U ? 2 JX%3 Acorn Or c> c) North P y - 'Charlene Ci w ` U yG ? y @jra LA02463; rA .o Sout� c m a Cj ara�[ c.L'A028531) Dr _ m _ C J m i Gershwi of J o m U .c Belsito Fire Station = Curtis Cir O a y o S ° Cedar Ave Los Palos Ave _ me Kenilworth D uj m m v 3 y ti Athena Or o = ° N Le ° < �° pQ J < c U < 2) > rn o V m m < Glenstone Or E 'r m m S c d CJ on 00� t z a p o > n Cory Or m K Wag ��5t°° Moss Dr v Q J COL J Burton Sc+'V R 7 w ^t r- 0 Armada Or> > l w 0°c Bolsa View Park S mX 3 a elva Or 3 N ° Ci� PaduaOr m '� Balmoral Oro' �, LA02089A c w m C� Tal A gellfield Ln ,5 Ave r Ov U f v = 0' qb = N �L k° m O Taylor Or T�i LAe2267A °j`� �Aj� m I On tz a y °oOO mjAb Elli Ave Autopark Dr LA02543A A° �i�a Corral Cir G nett-n .m �r Overlook Dr V� c c Ar c J S 0 1 Q o W �Tu CoverageLegend � This information,property of T-Mobile USA,Inc is confidential and is intended soley for t,use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed.AgyJ¢theCusd,or distribution of-this information is strictly prohibited.This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverag�area outdoors,which may change without notice.It may include locations with limited oftnftlro0d Or Outdoor no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability.Even within a coverage area,ttLa are several factors,such as:network changes,trafficwolume,service outages, a- In Vehicle technical limitations,signal strength,your equipment,terrain,structures,weather,and other conditions that may I�edere with actual service,,gpu�ality.and arability,includiFpl�ury Cir C ability to make,receive,and maintain calls. pr a Q \ ge aye S In Building NETWORK PERFORMANCE SURROUNDING LA13156 HARBOUR VIEW from July 1, 2010 to July 31, 2010 SITE ID SECTOR DROPPED CALLS LA02060A A 182 LA02060A C 390 LA02093A C 948 LA02207A A 702 LA02463A A 655 Go LA02463A C 744 TOTAL 3,621 NETWORK PERFORMANCE SURROUNDING LA13157 BOLSA VIEW from July 1, 2010 to July 31, 2010 SITE ID SECTOR DROPPED CALLS LA02089A A 246 LA02089A C 51 LA02495A C 714 t� �! LA02543A A 811 x Cd LA02060A B 237 LA02207A C 171 LA02463A B 289 TOTAL 2,519 ' Ocea`u Predicted Coverage for Habour View Park >sy Ave Uo` T m a :. -- G way Cir, v P Alley -0 n c�' S o E coo�t Pa 'dge Cir LA334� xa 9 N m vewood Dr r B Albion All. Go r - mff C vin Cir �y r ,a R? a Marina Vi ing Way S LA02093A ~ soy. Bravata Dr Dominica Cir q Alderport Dr P ?q Aud Dr ' r ar Qr �LA02209A i� 8 9 Aruba Cir °s Chase Dr = "t 5 -ary Y m °y Cir. J Cheff�yl Dr. a Hilo Ci a m t a Aquarius Dr OE 5 - m o m > , 0 9� E > J ? mC Parque Dr Q 0nne ro c m r Brassi i Cir r is Vista Cir w d 0 ° �� y F'> ¢; Cabana Dr ❑ o z Fernhill Cir s9 f Harbour View Park Arena Cir 5 Langpo Cir Jean �r de Cir o Brighttield Cir A nette Cir k p m it Charlotta Dr Do le Dr y f = Acorn Dr n �„ LAo2060A o ° 'm w c,� °w a Aria Ea �ayr LA02463A w� 3 I r a a a m c LA02853D Stt\U50 'ro C� m Dunbar Dr � - Aladdin Dr r ` ` d0 ershwi Los Patos Ave Is CI IT i� Ken'ICllworth D Glenstone Dr E _ a Oc a p `` c - �0 °odOt F Moss Dry c Bolsa View Park r . Coverage Legend This information,property of T-Mobile USA.Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individual or entity to w om it is a istribution of this information is strictly prohibited.This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors,which may change without notice.It may include locations with limited or Outdoor no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability.Even within a coverage area,there are several factors,such as:network changes traXic volume service outages, In Vehicle technical limitations,signal strength,your equipment,terrain,structures,weather,and other conditions that may interfere with actual se 'ce quality antl availability incluEing the ability to make,receive,and maintain calls. In Building Signal Rd �° E � a Predicted Coverage for Fire Station c,) T 'Mobile e _ w LA33411 X o m Pa .idge Cir 3. .o, y 3 > D vewood Dr G) 12 3 ¢ Albion Dr R I w a' r Ca vin Cir D m a A a Marina Vil ing Way Hooker DI r °q ; ` Perimeter Rd o LA02003A U Caw y m Bravata Dr Dominica Cir q Alderport Dr E Audr e Dr a Qr -LA022U7A CDAruba Cir °19 Chase Dr c = Che n J m —I Hilo Ct A a t to Co & quarius Dr w n R o m D U q � q� _wo n 2 m Iv _ D D r rn e o qp/7e Cir Leo ea. dim = C Parque Dr o o QSa 5 �°ioP tu�e0! p �s��yC� o` 2 °n ? w y 2 r Brassi Cir ° z hr ti m F� i° ie LL o Heil Ave Cabana Dr = Langpor Cir ti 3�a ti c c s9 !�� C' o f Jean Dr r U � Arena Cir ide Cir c0 Brightfield Cir A nette Cir r �r o 0 0o Dale Dr buU Qt Outrigger Cir Charlptta Dr Do le Dr Ga = ZNm Acorn Dr o 0 1LA02060i4 �m w 4L' LA02463A o r T aita i s F ►j t a Ti' I f::: ,L2-A02853D aim. = DI- = m c Gershwi ann o J o Fi a Statilin L Curtis CI O a s c Kenilworth b > Los Patos Ave 6, I w LL Ath lip oo` Marine View Middle School 5 ` . U r Glenstone Dr 03 0 C y �� U 0 20\S' 001 5 o s ci Q 5Arma Arrowhead Dr m G, Padua Dr DocoBalm P V C c U Coverage Legend This information,property of T-Mobile USA,Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individual or en[iry to who It is atldressetl.Any other use or tlistribution of this information is strictly prohibited.This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors,which may change ithout notice.It ay Include locatio s wihi limited or _ _. Outdoor no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability.Even within a coverage area,there are several I—orsiss ch asInetwo changes traffic volume service outage In Vehicle technical limitations,signal strength,your equipment,terrain,structures,weather.and other conditions that may interfere with actual vice quality and availability including the ability to make,receive,and maintain calls. LA02267A In Building Predicted Coverage for Grace Lutheran Church c m IT er J �^ m Bolsa Ave o CO2530AoIAlexandria Dr Argosy Ave m Paris Cir Cant sCornell Dr r miignal Rd o m Brown Cir Hal G way mmercial Dr T U N° y n i C.) a o o a Pa LA33418X 3 3 N U CDw a Dunn Dr a w Albion Dr m Grace Lutheran Church = Ca vin Cir m Down m Bit jay Cir Marina Vii ing Way Hooker Dr Perimeter Rd o ylark D LA02093A Cav E LA13105A T y 3 Bravata Dr Dominica Cir q, Alderport Dr Aud ' Dr a m m 2zo7A v v Aruba Cir arOs Chase Dr c Hilo Ci Che y Aquarius Dr w m o Cny v m e = m Pca z`oo Lidv a �t4r eO e r 61 UlkEdgemont Dr"10/7 'a 1w c . mn Cir C Par ue Dr r m n m 8rassi Cir5 y Off 2 = LL o Heil Ave Cabana Dr ° 5. Lan o Cir o' LA3.21 A B< qy 15�a 1 O� ° °s90 rrCrr C' C Arena Cir o f gP Jean Dr 2e� �1J n `m Corrine Cir Rt ¢vay Dr Brightfield Cir A nette Cir � grad Dr ide Cir 03 Do le Dr o y ry n m w Dale Dr ID1 Outrigger Cir Bavacuda Charlotta Dr v r 2 SN Milo Dr Acorn Dr o tp' L•A02060A w w Charlene r U °w S a Aria East Mobile Estates c) r` r �. Md/r LA02463A `y 0 e a Ci far o N SOf -' a LA02853D c i Paul Cir Pa 5`7`u m �_? James Dr S �e Aladdin Dr m Gershwi m Q�1 = Curtis CI Kenilworth D > m 0 Los Patos Ave m w a' u- Athena Dr U J v rn Bat Glenstone Dr E -°0 10 0. A N -_.1p< a Coverage Legend This information,property of T-Mobile USA,Inc is confidential and is mtenda solay for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed.Any othe use,or distribution of this; Moss information is strictly prohibited.This map predicts and approximates our v el�acoverage a e outdoors which ay change without notice.It may includejocations with limited or Outdoor no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability.Even within a coverage aie,t are are several factors such as:network changes,traffic volume,serviceroutages. a v, n In Vehicle technical limitations,signal strength,your equipment,terrain,structures,weather,an tl other con liters Iha may iota ere with aqual service,quality,and availa6ilit�yyj includiSg the � _ ability to make,receive,and maintain calls. OrbC�- 6oisa View Park In Building m a Signal Rd — = -E Predicted Coverage for Harbour Lights Apartments T Mobile a ry LA33416X m n Pa idge Cir . •; y 3 > DI m Q w a vewood Dr r c) n Albion Dr M W r c 3 .,1 . Ca vinCir o A aA Marina Vi ing Way Hooker D 'Po' r �9 ) Perimeter Rd o Cav N E ^ m Bravata Dr Dominica Cir q Alderport Dr a jai Audrey DDr d Qr ZLA022U7A U P Aruba Cir osC^Chase Dr 5 Chem ? ep'y+ n v 5 Hilo Ci rYl Da j S Aquarius or 5 f , to ;Cn a M A o w D D , V 1 Anne Cir 6°' q/s x m o C Parque Dr 0 5 ° m m ' CD m y or E; = r BraS61 Cif ,z o^LI , r Heil Ave Cabana Dr 5 5. Lan Cir ry a C} 9 s/ O'� n m 9po o '� � p 9q �'" Arena Cir Jean Dr Vm C;, n ^0r ide Cir HarbogApartments Brightfield Cir A ette Cir Car 0 ��„ S n m co Dale Cir Charlotte Dr Do le Dr r�'" c Acorn Dr 0 o LAo2060/1 °' ' d are G d v 0 y '�• y r LA02463A ,.m O� p,r j t a F"' LA02853D Dr N ro O Ramp Aladdin Dr m l rershwi Brannen Dr -� M m m a cP Curtis ClCI Kenilworth D �t > m °' I d�9 Los Patos Ave .0 `a W IL Ath Le a �o Marine View Middle School 5 U Glenstone Dr • SSO o< CD a e oc0� 0 i5Arma, m�t� �p� G� Arrowhead Dr m Padua Dr P Va`a V gip° v Balm Coverage Legend This information,property of T-Mobile USA,Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individu'atrorientiwitoiwnomiiiiisTaaoressed.An other use or disug, on of this information is strictly prohibited.This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors,which may change Itheut otice.N may'nclude locations with limited or Outdoor no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability.Even within a coverage area.there are several lectors such as:nenvo changes Ira 'c volume service outages r � — technical limitations,signal strength,your equipment,terrain,structures,weather,and other conditions that may intertere with ac[ua sere ce uality antl availability including the U In Vehicle ability to make,receive,and maintain calls. - LA02267A = In Building Argosy Ave -fig Signal Rd Predicted Coverage for Harbour View Elementary School to T E (0) {1 Alley 0 T 'n ; s to 34 LA318X a w 3 E 0 r Pa 'dge Cir 3. .W y 3 g N m ' D D vewood Dr d a w Albion Or Ma GO `m r Ca vin Cir Q A a Marina Vi ing Way Hooker ci d 10 Perimeter Rd o LA02093A E Cav i w 0 Bravata Dr Dominica Cir q, Aiderport Or �y a Aud Or q L•A0220, U v m `~ Aruba Cir �i�4, , Chase Or J � a m �� a m Hilo Ci Che o. ? Aquarius Or p< <� m o D a m cam oc gnne Cir `e'r4l \Av�,00\0\ Parque Or s o ¢t 0 U m P eae °fir O Harbour View Elementary School m o x Brassf Cir �. cn S d m Langpo Cir o ti 2,y� f U 97C1 rena Cir � n Jean Dr C�J 0`c ide Cir Brightfield Cir A nette Cir m co Dale f in Charlotte Do le Dr Gat c CCUff�J Acorn Dr Or 0 0 LA02060A 'm T or are U °y w a; o LA02463A ti'v 0 A � Sof ` F. c :7 r.::;: LA02853D c co St1lu _m n Dr m S ti 00 Gershwi Biannen Dr.-`' `ot o `� p�P Ramp Aladdin Or Curtis CI O d " w d�9 Los Palos Ave n `amc, Kenilworth D w i ¢ Oo Marine View Middle School 5 CJ Glenstone Or • A H Of m iJ G) O o > ` P\\5`o�go�Of J c Arma v� c. vI, Arrowhead Or m Padua Or P o° Coverage Legend This information,property of T-Mobile USA,Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addresse .An other use,or distribution of this information is strictly prohibited.This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors,which may change without notice.It may include loons with limited or Outdoor no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability.Even within a coverage area,there are several factors such as: etwork changes vaffic volume,service outages, technical limitations,signal strength,your equipment,terrain,structures,weather,and other conditions that may interfere with a Gal service quality an tl availability inclUding t8e a In VehlCle 9 ability to make,receive,and maintain calls. In Building Y L/CO226, � d Signal Rd _ E Predicted Coverage for Huntington Harbour Mail _ T °MOblll� n LA3341 X o w Pa idge Cir :3 w. ^ 3 '3��— - oil 2 rn m ¢ w a vewood Dr r m ` B Albion Dr d) a) r Q c Ce vin Cir m v ro a Marina Vil ing Way Hooker D% On °q Perimeter Rd o LA02093a E Cav T i m Bravata Dr Dominica Cir q Alderport Dr Q 3 a °°r Aud Dr - Q° 02207A v g ° Aruba Cir °s Chase Dr C S o n r OIL - Che Hilo Ci a t v m a Aquarius Or f Co o to a m '9i H Q n y r' y am oc An°e Cir 2� �e°r ' ed� ipie = i�' m C Parque Dr o m' m' Pc 0 di° °reQ �, os��yc. o` 2 y 'T to `m _ Brassi Cir z P,c j 6�s �GfO/e�� LL HeilAve Cabana Dr O £ Langpo Cir Jean Dr Arena r19 5` Devon Ott �.° '9,C .c Arena Cir stir _ Brightfield Cir At nette Cir ide Cir o Oat C�1 oO r m m Dale Dr Chadotfa Dr Do le Dr ? - �fUmbHuntington Harbour Mall Acorn Dr m NA02060A w a U d 0 r 0r r 5D = 7'i .F: :- LA02853U m C Sid t _m _ Dr e� Ramp Aladdin Dr rn l 'C Gershwi a 0, 0 � o Curtis CI Kenilworth D sd,q Los Patos Ave is w lL Ath Marine View Middle School 5 . U Glenstone Dr N r S�o((e �D< p0 00 is o a r 6a c� n iSArma �c�� Arrowhead Dr ' Pat G pY c Padua Dr 01 ab Balm Coverage Legend This information,property of T-Mobile USA,Inc is confidential and is intended coley for the use of the individual or entity to w o it's atltlressetl.Any other use or tlistribution of this information is strictly prohibited.This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors,whit may cha ge ithout notice. may i clutle locations with Ilmited or Outdoor no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability.Even within a coverage area,there are several facto s such as:ne changes traffic volume service outages In Vehicle technical limitations,signal strength,your equipment,terrain,structures,weather,and other conditions that may interfere with actual service quality antl availability Intl tling the _ - abilirytomake,receive,and maintain calls. LA02267A In Building U) ,y Q _My 14 IS Dr I, 0 j to 0 0 ' 4 aSiP = ° C Parque Dr w Predicted Coverage for Bolsa View Park Mont Dr Au ° r r m ° Brassi Cir Brid r ' F'C°rp.ld6ia L' g Heil Ave Cabana Dr ° > > 0 5 o LA33421A g si �C. L rn n m Fernhill Cir Langpo Cir Bonnie Dr Danube Dr U9�C,/' Arena Cir o Jean Dr ? Bishop6r Ruth Dr m c _ Y N vE ide Cir o Brightfield Cir A nette Cir Cran Brad DDrr O m W Dale Dr V% Outrigger Cir CharlOtta Dr Do le Dr iro ' n t ° g 0 �U\\ r0 LA02495A U r 2 SN Acorn Dr ct 0 Sul ene 7; d/rd LA02463i4 ,2� S . S U 0 rj\tN`'�t _� Q_ Dr L•A02E53U c UD o J - 5 m c Gershwi 2 rr o S m t Belsito Fire Station 3 Curtis ClO m d v r o Cedar Ave m c Kenilworth D > non ' 6 ° d7 Los Patios Ave m h Lu m m v y LL Athena Dr ° o ° d °e a mo a a' S _ U < o >0 o v m f Glenstone Dr E m �° r c 5 to to Cn V on pc m a O > n Cory Dr c m =, x Wag < o m - m e m POy\o� �oodt7 Moss Dr a s 5 N -' a Burton 6a ° m w F q U Armada Dr y ¢ m Bolsa Yiew Park y- m 3 elva Dr y a Dr ' to v U Balmoral Dro O LA02089A Bel d Ln c w m m�% at ' A H c ? Q L) Ave °yCO s ' LA02267A \a�rp O - Taylor Dr a On, O �OOa .r m Alb Elli Ave Auiopaf D' 5 Br LA02543A a<\-n .m orral Cir G n •� Over l J v F'o 5 Amb C Of \aR`dos Tu Coverage Legend This information,property of T-Mobile USA,Inc is confidential and is intended soley for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed.Agylo treeruse,or distribution of_this information is strictly prohibited.This map predicts and approximates our wireless cover agearea outdoors,which may change without notice.It may include locations with limitetl or�nh'VOOd Dr Outdoor no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability.Even within a coverage area,th a are several factors,such as:network changes,traA�csvolume,service outages, In Vehicle technical limitations,signal strength,your equipment,terrain,structures,weather,and other conditions that may rterfere with actual service,quality,and availability.including'.itCeUry Cir C ability to make,receive,and maintain calls. N� erd� Ta Q 9 ,oca �$ In Building Y TAl iLA3i475Z4'�_ � �ata Dr Dominica Cir q Alderport Dr zm G; n Dr Aruba Cir sc Chase Dr A Predicted Coverage for Marine View Middle School T n �Iobil a m Hilo Ci a Dr - m ° C s c o ed.q'a� = a d w w E ° a v r- J G) Auburn r to c kP/ = o C Parque Dr n S o Lai m Edgemont Dr Qt`a LL o Heil Ave Cabana Dr °� (�7 17 BraOsi Cir Bridgewat r Dr w w Alhan �s fC �: o, Fernhill Cir Langpo it S LA33421A Bonnie Dr L nube Dr c Arena Cir U Jean Dr -5 c Corrine Cir Ruth Dr _� de Cir o Brightfield Cir A nette Cir g m .� n m m Dale Dr 0 outrigger tta Dr Do le Dr Brad Dr >y r TNm t Outri er Cir Charlo° a w b,3\\ LA02495A U m Acorn Dr o o U NortFl e. yc ? ti/8/rd LA02463A mU s c m O a ,� `T F. LA020'53U OI c $ Q,a Sinus ,� c� m �e = n c Gershwi a rn ' o m c U a Belsito Fire Station z Curtis CI O` a`) , m 9 - ° t Cedar Ave c Kenilworth > v, ° ' m a 3 .- Los Patos Ave m w in .6 m U �a :• LL Athena Dr ° ° D Q Oo Marine View Middle School C m L) rn > O U p Q U 0 Ote o c Cory Dr 5 c m ? x Wagon Pp5�O�e Nto r, a c, J :r; Burton lap 2S Armada Dr> a' m Arrow %head Dr elva Dr N as'c a c 4 Padua Dr m w y P Ga m 2J Balmoral Dro �, LA02089/1 m m 1 ert BelNield Ln � ,� w � Pli: ? O � v n Ave S Inlet Dr cc tis O Taylor Dr In LA02267A O\ales °/phi R Ontarl Elli Ave AutoPatkOf Alb 'LA0243A Br 5 •� Overl orral Cir c c c Amb 1 Coverage Legend This information,property of T-Mobile USA,Inc is confidential and is intended soley or the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed.Any other use,o is h utio of this information is strictly prohibited.This map predicts and approximates our wireless coveiaga area outdoors,which may change without notice.It may include locatio s wi h li is or Of Outdoor no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability.Even within a coverage area,there are several factors,such as:network changes,traffic volume,service o tages, amtt°s technical limitations,signal strength,your equipment,terrain,structures,weather,an other conditions that may interfere with actual service,quality,and availability, In Vehicle g gy� ty, ry,inclutligg�ihe ability to make,receive,and maintain calls. 4Wd Road Brentwood Dr In Building .��� c c t ai ; — ^ — )r 11 � y rn o o Scenario Dr = Predicted Coverage for The a shopping o_pping center @ 5972 Warner Avenue t Dr T � ■M�bl1 F.m a C Parque Or d 0 t m $ m o v_ to r Brassi Cir z C'� ti a Heil Ave Cabana Dr m O 2 c7 r E $7 e�%i c d Fernhill Cir Langpo r o ' LA33a21A Bonnie Dr o J. Dent s90 Oi c Arena Cir Jean Or Bishop'& A r � c m p. P in Ruth Dr a �L N m Chadwick Dr Midiron it x 0 A netts Cir Crandall Dr e Cir �O o Brighttield Cir Brad Or 4 Dale Dr \\ov U) o Ira to Dr r a LA02495A m 5 w SNmcU �' Cnarle Acorn Or ci The shopping center @59Z2 Warner Avenue o N a T. o m LA02463A a S P g _ r ° a ¢ TI,w&Df a LA02853e US < ' Q a I Dr m Saint Paul Cir $1° ¢S - 3 Jame e' �, Ramp Aladdin Or Curtis CI O` a y ci Cedar Avr Warner Ave c Los Palos Ave g� Q X) i5 3 y` � a °�D ;• a Athena Or U or e < P m Dorita Dr c o v Kirklund Cir a c N Glenstone Dr -+ � :? c � m rn� U < m e S Cory Or 0 g0 t w v o• o to Crista Palma Or Ppe�O�Ba�od�� c U ZSundanceCir w BSitno 6�°1z' o [�Armada Or —as m Y 0 -'s U` Arrowhead Or 2rj elva Dr a A U, Padua Or L U Balmoral Oro O It' 2089'A�BfI 8ellrieki Ln ,c m c' a Av 00 o m 2 a °y" rodan LA02267A- A� �0// p h�ry Danto s , ~ G`` EIII Ave Autopa*Dc �p�g LA02543A Ln orral Cir G ngt m •� Overt c c P Coverage Legend This information,property of T-Mobile USA,Incfidential and is intended soley-for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed.Any other use,or distribution of t is �amt�05 Ctt information is strictly prohibited.This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors,which may change without notice.It may include locations with lilnitetl or Outdoor no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability.Even within a coverage area, here are several factors,such as:network changes,traffic4vo�uJr,et� ice outages, In Vehicle technical limitations,signal strength,your equipment.terrain,structures,weather,and other conditions that may interfere with actual service,quality,and availability,including the BlBntwOOtl Dr ability to make,receive.and maintain calls. PJg Ashbu In Building �`cti e�,o ry Cir _ p q. � °' o 0 Scenario Or x Predicted Coverage for The shopping center @ 5885 Warner Avenue c 'bA, asl�oy = o C Parque Dr n d ;o-��- - - - ......t Dr ■ • s! p. [T 5 2 v, m r Brassi Cir .z Mobi1F� h F�C°1� !°C�' w Heil Ave Cabana Dr � r Lan9P m o it LA33421A Bonnie Or Da o s94 O�� c ill Cir Arena Cir ° Jean Or r Bishop'& '� _ w Chadwick Or Midiron it Ruth Or^ m c e Cir Crandall Or a e Cir o � Brightfield Cir m Brad Or c m m Dale Or t in o m CharlOtta Or r ' r m' o �030011\� c o Acorn Or LA02495A w o o c m n m a The shopping center @5885 Warner Avenue i5 w v y o in LA02463A 1� o m O1 -`I m o n sell"Ot m a Tiar$Dr c Dr LA02853U - Saint Paul Cir _ 3 '- J • y Q J p Ramp Aladdin Or Curtis Cl O ? m U Cedar Av ° Warner Ave c Los Patos Ave m� 0 w m o �De ¢ O°`a ' PQ rm a c t`` Athena Dr v rn > o iU Kirklund Cir ¢ Glenstone Or CU c c Cox U c O Q 5 Cory Or o �. x O t r, o q Crista Palma Or c m py °� Lo0�0 v a Sundance Cir I Burt gs Q S Mccarthy Or - m w Re no 4:�` O� v Armada Dry < Y c elva Or V. O~ Arrowhead Or 3 `mf `a� U�� Padua Or 0o bd a m ` Balmoral Or o Q O C c U OLA02089A Ln x a m eC' T rt BeiNield '• r O -o U Av o, m v 5 Q L7vec n" LA02267A � �m �% anto �, Ell "o'I •A02543AOvert orral Cir G c This information,prop erty of T-Mobile USA,Inc is confidential and is intended soleyl for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed.Any other use,or distriburan of t.s sot Coverage Legend information is strictly prohibited.This map predicts and approximates our wireless cove'r'age area outdoors,which may change without notice.It may include locations withlhmitetl or Outdoor I no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability.Even within a coverage area there are several factors,such as:network changes,tra0ic vojuyei se ice out es, technical limitations,signal strength.your equipment,terrain,structures,weather,and other, conditions that may interfere with actual service,quality,and availability,includ nn the Brentwood Dr, In Vehicle ability to make,receive.and maintain calls. In Building Ashbury Cir 6 9,as = n � ,0 Scenario Dr = Predicted Coverage for Meadowlark Golf Clu� m` Edgemont Dr T 'Mobill d� /s = S C Pardue Dr m r c �s l = H s v o m r Brassi Cir .� o m > > j 9¢,fC6/sec t` 3 Heil Ave Cabana DrCj) ernhill Langpo Cir ' o LA334421A Bonnie Dr Dent Arena Cir >. r Bishop x r w Chadwick Dr idiron it �'y° a Ruth Dr J in Brightfield Cir ¢> f`- Crandall Dr m y Ye Cir o o Meadowlark Golf Club Brad Dr r m' n s Dale Dr \\� ° in Charlotta Dr U LA02495A c ins ° r- 2 ,�rUnt 01 'OV c Acorn Dr it Shields Dr m T ? O U .. y r p o LA02463A FF ci- a W T' r- r LA02850D SU1U5D C) a Dr i. c rn o _ 0 o J Ramp Aladdin Dr Curtis CI O ? _ c q� ° a r J o L Cedar Ar �o Warner Ave B Los Palos Ave d m� n w 0 0 o m U 3 f ti M c U_ Athena Dr o ❑ o q, As < m° Pp r° J < c U _< 2) > U m c o w Kirklund Cir < R Glenstone Dr E r c to x U � i5 a O o > Cory Dr ' coo 3 ` Ot m (a Crista Palma Dr m 5 00i trto� x o a Sundance Cir J y Bu ga c� Mccarthy Dr m w tj`� O� o a Armada Dr n > Reyno c <Ze Ap° vs �� Arrowhead Dr X 3 eIva Dr ' vac Padua Dr m 0) ` Balmoral Dr o P 6`D °O to 0 1 A 89'A U c = T4gert y m � m Belltield Ln s m m %� C = 0 a0 �U! m • AV � 5 IW n �o'y vc odor A02267A 0 poi \a0 phi Danfoi ark or Elli Ave Autop c Ppp\el LA026 3A -i •� orral Cir G net -0 Overl c m c J V F c A • — This information,property of T-Mobile USA,Inc is confidential and is intended soleyJor the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed.Any other use,or distribu Ion of 1 s tamrf°e C'Ir Coverage Legend information is strictly prohibited.This map predicts and approximates our wireless coverage area outdoors,which may change without notice.It may include locations with limited or Outdoor no coverage.Our maps do not guarantee service availability.Even within a coverage ear a there are several factors,such as:network changes,traffic4vo`ur�ef,sMice outages, + In Vehicle technical limitations,signal strength,your equipment,terrain,structures,weather,and other conditions that may interfere with actual service,quality,and availability,including the Brentwood D ability to make,receive,and maintain calls. P40 = In Building Ashbury Cir Re: LA 13156 (Harbour View Park) Alternative Site Analysis (1) Harbour View Light Apartments (4351 Boardwalk Drive, Huntington Beach). We sent a letter of interest to the property owner on August 13, 2007, using address information obtained by way of tax records We received no response to our August 13 attempt On August 31, 2007, we sent another letter to the property owner, again with no response Our RF engineers took a second look at the feasibility of this location and determined that, taking into account existing topography, and tree and building locations, a minimum 50-foot height would be required for the antenna The apartment building has a height of 33 feet In other words, the antenna required for satisfaction of the coverage objective, would exceed the height of the building by 17 feet (2) Grace Lutheran Church (5172 McFadden Avenue, Huntington Beach). Our RF engineers determined that the church location is too far outside the search range and therefore will not satisfy the coverage objective To be more specific, the edge of the search ring extends 1/4 mile from the center of the ring The church is located approximately 1/2 mile beyond the edge of the ring, and, therefore 3/4 of a mile from the ring center At that location, an operating facility cannot satisfy the coverage need Finally. even if T-Mobile were to build at this location, it would be too close to an existing site (located near the corner of Graham and Edinger), and will interfere with the existing site because of overlapping signals (3) Harbour View Elementary School (4343 Pickwick Circle, Huntington Beach). We contacted the school district on August 13, 2007. There were a number of phone conversations with representatives of the school district, which resulted in the district"s advising T-Mobile that it was not interested on any terms in a facility located at the elementary school In fact, the principal of the school later publically opposed the project to be located at Harbour View Park (4) Fire Station (3831 Warner Avenue, Huntington Beach). The fire station property is located approximately three miles away from the edge of search ring, which means that a facility located there would have to be a minimum of 70 feet tall from grade, which would exceed the height limitations imposed by the City's code (§ 230 96(B)(1a) ) EXHIBIT 21 (5) Huntington Harbor Mall (16821 Algonquin, Huntington Beach). While this location at one point seemed feasible, when the property owner was confronted by protesters and picket lines in front of Trader Joe's, Trader Joe's advised the property owner that they did not want the wireless facility on the roof of the Trader Joe portion of the Mall The property owner then backed out of lease negotiations and advised she was no longer interested While the City continues to push for a site located at the mall, the City has provided T-Mobile no more than speculation Re: Bolsa View Park (1) Marine View Middle School (5682 Tilburg Drive, Huntington Beach) T-Mobile sent a letter of interest to the school in April of 2006 The principal contacted the school district and was advised that the district had no current wireless siting policy and was therefore not interested in negotiating a lease for the proposed site EXHIBIT 22 it Wireless Permit Nos. 2007-041 & 2007- 42 Bolsa View Park & Harbour View Park Wireless Communication Facilities Applicant: T-Mobile USA Location: 5641 Brighton ®rive & 16600 Saybrook Lane i August 30, 2010 Council Consideration Wireless Permit No. 07-041: • Affirm or revoke wireless permit and related administrative approval allowing the installation of a 51 ft 7 in high broadleaf monopole and ancillary support equipment within an underground vault at Bolsa View Park Wireless Permit No. 07-042: • Affirm or revoke wireless permit and related administrative approval allowing the installation of a 55 ft high monopalm and ancillary support equipment within an underground vault at Harbour View Park i i Project Location Bolsa View Park: • Approximately 2 7 acre neighborhood park • Sited within an existing single-family Subjec`S,`e ,�' neighborhood with residences located to north, south, east, and west f No major streets within neighborhood area a Approximately 216 residential units at an t ' average population size of 592 residents within % mile of park U Project Location C®nt'd = I Harbour View Park: "= Approximately 4 acre neighborhood park . • Sited within an existing single-family and Subject Site multi-family residential neighborhood Adjacent to Harbour View Elementary school Approximately 611 residential units at an average population size of 1,375 residents within a %< mile radius from park i 2 �f Project History Hoesa View Park Wireless Permit No. 07-041 approved based on the following: - Least obtrusive and only location in meeting project objectives - Eliminate a significant gap in mobile telephone coverage - Compatible with surrounding area by incorporating stealth design techniques - Compliance with the development standards of the HBZSO (i e , land use, minimum setbacks, maximum height) Project History Cont'd Harbour View Park Wireless Permit No. 07-042 approved based on the following: - Least obtrusive and only location in meeting project objectives - Eliminate a significant gap in mobile telephone coverage - Compatible with surrounding area by incorporating stealth design techniques - Compliance with the development standards of the HBZSO (i e , land use, minimum setbacks, maximum height) 3 i I Project History Cont'd • April 1, 2009 - Building permits issued for both Bolsa View and Harbour View antennas with construction halted in the same month due to concerns raised by surrounding residents - April 23, 2009— Public meeting held before the City Council to receive public testimony from residents - On April 24, 2009— City determined pursuant to Measure C that the project will require voter approval • May 27, 2009 — T-Mobile filed lawsuit against the City declaring that the Federal Telecommunications Act (TCA) Preempts Measure C I - -'I Project History Cont'd - July 9, 2010 — District Court supports T-Mobile claim that voter approval requirement violates TCA Court orders the City with the following - Act on wireless facilities within a reasonable period of time - All actions to be in writing and supported by substantial evidence • City ordered to reconsider the wireless permit applications and either approve or deny T-Mobile's applications by September 7, 2010. 4 i i Project Analysis ■ City contracted services of Kramer Firm, Inc to analyze the wireless permit applications The report concluded the following 1 No significant coverage deficiencies exist in each area based upon an onsite signal strength survey 2 Wireless carriers arbitrarily assign signal strengths because no federal rules exist establishing minimum baselines s Alternative sites exist that can meet the project objectives • HBZSO Section 249 06 authorizes revocation on the basis of erroneous or misleading information ' Conclusion 1 Recommending revocation of the wireless permits based upon the following: Bolsa View Park — No significant gap in telephone service based on T- Mobile's web-based maps and Kramer's signal strength survey — Radio frequency maps arbitrarily assign signal strengths — No significant service gap exists because the project serves a small population area 5 Conclusion Cont'd Harbour View Park - No significant gap in telephone service based on T- 1 Mobile's web-based maps and Kramer's signal strength survey - Radio frequency maps arbitrarily assign signal strengths - No significant service gap exists because the project serves a small population area - Alternative less obtrusive locations exist that can meet the objectives of the project 6 Esgarza, Patty From Surf City Pipeline [noreply@user govoutreach com] Sent: Thursday, August 26, 2010 10 43 PM To: CITY COUNCIL, agendaalerts@surfcity-hb org Subject. Surf City Pipeline Comment on an Agenda Item (notification) Request# 6285 from the Government Outreach System has been assigned to Johanna Stephenson. Request type: Comment Request area: City Council - Comment on an Agenda Item Citizen name: Lori Burrett Description: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members, I look forward to the public hearing August 30th and support the city administrator's recommendations to deny the permits for the Bolsa View and Harbour View T-mobile towers I was a pleasantly surprised to find out that in 2006 the Huntington Beach Council signed a 45 day moratorium that was extended to 6 months in order for the city to adopt new regulations regarding cell tower placement mainly for PROW locations. The actions of the past still ring true today In light of the recent activity surrounding cell towers propagation that our city has experienced and the release of new health data streaming in, this may be a critical time to review those same guidelines and update our current zoning polices Realizing that our current city council is still tied to the FCC regulations but we can do more and based on the recent lawsuits we need to do more Just to quote the past council intent regarding Ordinance No 3748, "The City believes, however, that a temporary moratorium is in the best interests of the City and its residents in order to assure that irreversible development activity does not occur that would harm the public health, safety or welfare " It is as true today as it was then. Please revoke the permits for the two towers and then pursue a moratorium to make changes to our current zoning and processes in regards to cell towers sites. Join the change that hundreds of cities are making to lead the way for a healthier and safer environment for all We can live in a new high tech world and still make the responsible placements of these towers a priority Respectfully, Lori Ann Burrett Harbour View Parent Expected Close Date: 08/27/2010 Click here to access the request Note This message is for notification purposes only Please do not reply to this email Email replies are not monitored and will be ignored Esparza, Pa From: Surf City Pipeline [noreply@user govoutreach com] Sent: Monday, August 30, 2010 11 01 AM To: CITY COUNCIL, agendaalerts@surfcity-hb org Subject: Surf City Pipeline Comment on an Agenda Item (notification) Request# 6309 from the Government Outreach System has been assigned to Johanna Stephenson. Request type: Comment Request area: City Council - Comment on an Agenda Item Citizen name: Lori Burrett Description: Hello Attorney McGrath, Honorable Mayor& City Council, I am one of the parents and residents that will be attending the meeting on Monday and speaking regarding safety issues concerning the towers In lieu of time constraints I want to bring to your attention via this communication that while an Environmental Study was not required we may have an environmental concern regarding a group of Herons that nest less than 1,000 feet away from the Harbour View proposed site This group of Herons is nesting in a cluster of trees at the intersection of Saybrook& Humboldt The California Coastal Commission pointed out that those Herons are protected, but that the city of Huntington Beach has authority under the Coastal Element Guidelines which outline protecting Marine Life and Birds amongst other regulations I bring this to your attention as we do not feel that this has been done If you need reports for studies regarding the impact of cell towers on the birds I would be happy to provide that along with photos of this nesting a rea Respectfully, Lori Burrett Lori Burrett Expected Close Date: 08/31/2010 Click here to access the request Note This message is for notification purposes only Please do not reply to this email Email replies are not monitored and will be ignored Y J0 �V ZA-7Z--- 6M"na-"J1 &1Wd") Ross, Rebecca From: Surf City Pipeline [noreply@user govoutreach corn] Sent- Monday, August 30, 2010 10 59 AM To Ross, Rebecca Subject Surf City Pipeline Notification of Changed Topic for Request# 6261 Request#6261 from the Government Outreach System has been assigned to Caren li errera. Request type: Comment Request area: City Clerk - All Reassigned Inquiries to City Clerk Citizen name: David Parikh Description: Hi, I just wanted to let you know that everyone seems concerned about the cellphone tower that will be put in Harbour View Park There is concern about children's safety and devaluation or property values Expected Close Date: 09/08/2010 Click here to access the request Note This message is for notification purposes only Please do not reply to this email Email replies are not monitored and will be ignored V1301JO /0 t4`7c� Ross, Rebecca From: Surf City Pipeline [noreply@user govoutreach corn] Sent: Monday, August 30, 2010 10 57 AM To: Ross, Rebecca Subject: Surf City Pipeline Notification of Changed Topic for Request# 6302 Request# 6302 from the Government Outreach System has been assigned to Caren Ferrera. Request type: Comment Request area: City Clerk - All Reassigned Inquiries to City Clerk Citizen name: Heather Jordan Description: I am unable to attend the Meeting Monday August 30th , but want to voice my opposition in regard to the T-Mobil Cell Tower proposed to be placed near Harbour View Elementary School I am a resident of HB with a child whom will be attending Harbour View Elementary School and I am vehemently apposed to this proposal Thank you for concidermg my, and every other citizens, oppmion on this matter. Expected Close Date: 09/13/2010 Click here to access the request Note This message is for notification purposes only Please do not reply to this email Email replies are not monitored and will be ignored gab-0 Esparza, Patty From Surf City Pipeline [noreply@user govoutreach com] Sent: Monday, August 30, 2010 1 46 PM To: CITY COUNCIL, agendaalerts@surfcity-hb org Subject: Surf City Pipeline Comment on an Agenda Item (notification) Request# 6312 from the Government Outreach System has been assigned to Johanna Stephenson. Request type: Comment Request area: City Council - Comment on an Agenda Item Citizen name: Barbara Sterbentz Description: Although we won't be able to attend the meeting this evening please know that we are very upset about the possibility of a cell tower at the park near our school our children attend Please consider us present at the meeting when you hopefully revoke the permits Thank you for your consideration The Sterbentz and Brooks Families Expected Close Date: 08/31/2010 Click here to access the request Note This message is for notification purposes only Please do not reply to this email Email replies are not monitored and will be ignored 1 Esparza, Patty From: Surf City Pipeline [noreply@user govoutreach com] Sent: Monday, August 30, 2010 2 00 PM To: CITY COUNCIL, agendaalerts@surfcity-hb org Subject: Surf City Pipeline Comment on an Agenda Item (notification) Request# 6315 from the Government Outreach System has been assigned to Johanna Stephenson. Request type: Comment Request area: City Council - Comment on an Agenda Item Citizen name: Ana Youngsma Description: RE August 30, 20010 Special Meeting 5 OOpm My name is Ana Youngsma, I'm a resident and business owner in the City of Huntington Beach I also have two children who attend Harbour View Elementary I'm writing to express my concern about T-Mobile's continued efforts to install a cell tower in Harbour View Park. I am against this and strongly urge the City Council to revoke Wireless Permit No 2007-042 and related administrative approval for a wireless communications facility located at 16600 Saybrook Lane (Harbour View Park) I feel that a cell tower would ruin the natural beauty and environment at Harbour View Park and Harbour View School. Furthermore, I'm concerned about the health and safety issues related to the cell tower and its close proximity to Harbour View School, Park,playgrounds, fields and nearby residents Sincerely, Ana Youngsma Expected Close Date: 08/31/2010 Click here to access the request Note This message is for notification purposes only Please do not reply to this email Email replies are not monitored and will be ignored. oh o/d C-Off j i RECEIVED FROM AS PUBLIC RE D R &P TING / OF 1 GI < Huntington Beach City Council Meeting JOAN YNN �JERK August 30, 2010 REVOKE mm PERMITS Mayor Green and City Council Members Please REVOKE the Wireless Permits and Administrative Approvals for the proposed T-Mobile cell towers at Harbour View and Bolsa View Parks Measure C • Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance 249 06 "D", Finding #1, says that the wireless permit shall be revoked if it "was issued on the basis of erroneous or misleading information or misrepresentation" • T-Mobile marketing material (printed 2008, acquired Sept 2009 at Community United Methodist Church) "How new sites are selected" section states that"Zoning specialists ensure that all local zoning, permitting and building codes, plus all state and federal regulations, can be complied with at a location " (emphasis added) • "Measure C" is in our City Codes It was voted in by residents to protect our public parks and beaches Projects costing over$100,000 must be approved by both the City Council and the voters • T-Mobile's applications were submitted to the City with false costs of less than $100,000 The City, acting on what it believed to be true and valid information, granted the Wireless Permits and Administrative Approvals for these proposed cell towers. • Based on T-Mobile's documented business practices, and their history of submitting erroneous andfalseinformati—on,-it is-rev opinion that T-Mobiee was aware of Measure C, and intentionally misrepresented the cost of these cell towers in order to avoid the required Measure C vote • The Reguired Finding #1 that the permit "was issued on the basis of erroneous or misleading information or misrepresentation" has been met, and is sufficient grounds for revoking these fraudulently acquired permits. Dianne Larson Page 1 Huntington Beach City Council Meeting August 30, 2010 Wireless Emergency 9-1-1 calls • T-Mobile marketing flyer (printed 2009, acquired Sept 2009 at Community United Methodist Church) states "For basic 9-1-1 services, carriers are required to transmit all 9-1-1 calls to a public safety answering point" • But T-Mobile omitted the most important phrase in the FCC's Basic 911 rule— "regardless of whether the caller subscribes to the provider's service or not." (http.//www fcc gov/cgb/consumerfacts/wireless911 srvc html) • Website Wireless Coverage Maps for T-Mobile, AT&T, Sprint and Verizon Wireless all show adequate coverage in both Park areas • I tested the wireless coverage at both parks with my t-mobile phone and found sufficient coverage • Harbour View and Bolsa View Parks are blanketed with cell coverage from at least 4 wireless carriers • Emergency 911 calls are NOT an issue I urge you to REVOKE the Wireless Permits and Administrative Approvals for the proposed T-Mobile cell towers at Harbour View and Balsa View Parks Respectfully, Dianne Larson Huntington Beach resident Dianne Larson Page 2 RECEIVED AS PUBLIC RECORD V�CC��NCIL MEETING OF CITY CLERWOFFICE JM L.FLYNN,CITY CLERK �z �7%,�� 17"' r, M AD 6", j C*4 ,C;, g, �7e q U" 'Es �10 ppra t &A Iowa "global i1sal- [rittitute- f __,, ,ne_,,1ai..aest1- rof es' -s' "i [mernb "rs,,,h i p-organ ization',TQr�' , ona el; e� - -an ptai se r 1wi ch ----t,h,r 6 U au -1 th �q S�l apt 'rs I h t w or 'I d -towe rs,-- T h e I n stit u t e -'s potlight"e& 1`hels�ue of cell'' Ot", --t air-m va I u e- '' ho andj -he�� t Arket' V�, me- and S,, 11 t6w r: ou e a cated,�,its me, beh�'th;iit- a ce, u, imlact 'tau se_',,`, A",'d'e c-` ri'_,a"s` e-i n ,-home,,,val'ue,,. raisali nstit'pte.,o 'g) (ww,,w.a p p, Z1. 44" The rtf�ritiv3£Work =an5 this= sub� t a�s,rd�i#rie by �Dr� �-Sa n' �►�d ; ��h® �®roc ude�d� that media F tt� Iron t� Kt, pt0ftla healtht zar s', o�� � u � � s ,, >,tm _[celuiarohoq _ tpyers {a� e arid. ate n asl-has -spread" concerns, among t h e ,,p,u,b l --re s-u i v n g,`"in,increased, r sy�stance -to��s t es, .n ear, c os Atovve a� =ram- ' Pzrsente decreas�,es ~Srrite®r�ed en thy study {, �_—emu — �Ra r a from -2_�ta,. 20% wit -,the fr rota m bv n-' , Y y �. 9 , p g -rra-tow rd,�;,,the'' h"� ig haver- ra�� a th�� ' lose' th ,, ,r� ��� tyo I$r U t o d Y s ar , can we afford th's - s.,�'_ ,.� a �� ��-- � �,��— ti— a �:u >�°a— �--=` •� _ — � r — „,�� — a _ he , ,e , �� ,� � � �I �f�Frr� � ess .� to®; � ' raltr,s 'm � �toi h s That .■SFis l I r rid I icensees rr u t a{r r� s l0 a erria.I ct ; etha�t r fect t < � - "� i��,.,. err"` ® ' ® va l �$4 r : d�e,s r i I r t of h -p ro e�rty '. cl � r� =y knv ut �tndwot�®rasa ' s x fF � r �Y - = o- . . nd"'4 _ s Frrc undin rit :m i s, � r� hf ud es ga i�sa n c�e s�� . 'and �z� - �i r� ��° �a a s���that: al I ,e r�" _c � _ al °°� iwss ,r= _'� �g .P _ - _ �, "MAWS i, �' ti. Aca �- AS MW u wg c�tn�ca�ra� OF- 20 / CITY MERK MICE ` JQW L fLW87.qTY CIHU( Let's use this as an opportunity for change. s Revoke the permits • Move forward with a process for RESPONSIBLE PLACEMENT OF CELL TOWERS,, of a a M moratorium is needed to study the tissue please enact one. Please do not recommend other potential locations that are in any residential areas prior to the study being completed . Become part of the change movement to update the FCC Section 704 of the 1996 Telecommunications Act ( CA) regarding 'environmental effects Safety & Aesthetics Commercial cell towers are a Pe fire hazard and safety risk . In adaition they do not align w 11 i th the beauty ol our ID neighborhood parks and res 'idential areas . Yes, they can and do catch on f 007-monopole in Las Vegas catches 2009- "Welder's torch ignited fire fire during routine retrofitting. tower which weakened structure. Al � d a P�+'d� sa.a� s t " �.,� JJ4 o-dF #�:.�" $ - "�y�"as '��—��.• ati Sew 6 Ainy sign warning child or resident "Beyond nt: Radio Frequency fields at this site y exceed rules for human exposer." or "Do stop in front "does not belong in any park or residential area. A Ali, CAUTION e 9 ., " �.' % � *` 4t> °y�^'� „ k.—I �I �} �*�s u�� ,p r*a � � w ,:.tea "� •r �`„� _ y3'�� ;`4��3. sui i,�<o"*ua�n,e *a„nk'i }� SITE NAME:, tM4tf A ,�. & .. p r F _ 'u { � � y '�%a.k7.'.✓y5�•."v h o t Sunset-Beech Not Required ° " Beyond this point:"� � � ,� ;* w°b, FC,C,,RE+CISTRATi0N NUMBER. � Radio frequency lieldslat� this site . _ � 'may exceer9CG�rules,i�or 'human= Y �` L7R4EAS1►VG�ItFORMATIO `, �', tN CAUSE C? E(V# R �N'C 93iPoser. ' nm a ` �� ',77j282=-"?4$3 ??= =1:$-+t 9 ? a `for yow"r sa#tey `obey a 1,_pc► ,tei3 "signs°b TIC-ST ' $?'7-St= UV► �2 :`and site u�c3elrnes,tier wor cae�g�xin - „r 140 TRESPASSING L' �1' �?IaX 'iVx y °* r�QUe11Qy BQ{/ir4l►t[1i1 $:> xk'' �hiMt.ni .ro,aue hti+tcse"u4*u1°com(w+:, arrv`r+ad A,�,x �a. .»�roa.e?an��ewr F i Itw-4.OK F��±1k�1`Y.df1 1OR'9 O WCY ..� ft*41 p#��rtt]0`�abt�ile�yi'mW'sDiF'�5l'(kx`'9J#L) N * ^' A* x,�. yr+t�rrit�exs Grp.y�r7rt�; �.xresr+Fr�� #x`a�ct xat{yrtifte i M,A� OW } tw 00M*0%M* tpR �F1MeEF .irY+dk Vi%�Y �'sy�'ar��YiM4MNR, r ��� � '`c, f,' �� wf � ��,��t�y''�9"�"y� „3� .. � ��x����A�1:,.:,�c.�x�� kG �.'k'�4i �'= i �• �Ys ,/ .... `^���'��'r t"'"�yyyG.'�' �f +5 1 ��'� �t`�ii 4."M�{ *�"r �� t��r..�., � i�►lP,�'- �� l •+�+� fir.. *�1K�, `�1'�� a„ s i. t u� "� �'•i •"2.r�i,r ( =�``��r,`� r _ a '� �, �4�"� -�"�}' °'�'�!1�. / x4 ��•. r .� a�� °fir" �:. ~�����' 1 , '�•.� »may. �� �' +'�£ ',�'[ K,'D, ��y� _ ti:.�'� r�,�' ;.,we;�.r7�� a z�w s < a s t x What we want to see in our parks ! JL _ 1 i A F �A xY �,�.�> f, ,M fWp�+P► rt,v.. f f r t{ { S+ t sf This is what we do not want to sere in our parks and residential neighborhoods ! t _ � t a+ � Ninth Circuit Upholds The Right 4f Local Agencies To Regulate Wireless Telecommuni... Page 1 of 2 J Print_ ant . Grcuit Upholds The Right Of Focal Agencies To Regulate Wireless Telecommunication acillties Based Aesthetics Written by John_w Lam November 5,2009 California.cities and counties throughout the state were victorious following the Ninth Circuit's decision in Sprint PCS v. City of Palos Verdes Estates.[1] 4n October 14,2009,the Court upheld the City of Palos Verdes Estates' authority to deny City permits for the construction of a wireless telecommunications tower on the basis of adverse aesthetic impacts. Specifically,the Court held that the City's decision based solely on adverse aesthetic impacts did not violate the federal Telecommunications Act of 1996 nor California state law codified under the Public Utilities Code{"PUC")Sections 7901 and 7901.1. This decision is significant for counties and cities throughout California which,over the last decade, have run head-on into legal and political road blocks in their attempts to balance the public need for reliable and ubiquitous telecommunications service on the one hand,and on the other hand,a city's and county's need to maintain local control over the time,place and manner in which they are erected so as to preserve the general welfare of the community. In this case, Sprint PCS challenged the City of Palos Verdes Estates' ("City")wireless telecommunications ordinance which authorized the City to consider aesthetic factors in denying or approving the construction of wireless telecommunication towers in City rights-of-way. The ordinance allowed the City to consider such factors as height of tower,proximity to residential structures,nature of uses of nearby properties,surrounding topography,and the surrounding tree coverage and foliage. Until now,telecommunications companies had argued that PUC Sections 7901 and 7901.1 prohibited cities from denying them access to city rights-of-way on aesthetic grounds. First,telecommunications companies argued that PUC Section 7901 granted them the right to construct towers anywhere along the rights-of-way so long as its use did not"incommode"or otherwise inconvenience,annoy,or subject to discomfort the public use of the road or highway. Secondly,telecommunications companies argued that cities could Only exercise"reasonable controls as to time,place and manner"in which telecommunication companies used the public rights-of-way and that aesthetic grounds were not reasonable controls under PUC Section 7901.1. In considering these issues,the Court reasoned that cities are given broad,general authority to regulate on aesthetic grounds from the"police powers"authority granted under the California Constitution. Specifically,the Court held that adverse aesthetic impacts caused by the installation of a wireless telecommunications tower at a location that was a scenic,residential area did in fact incommode the http://publicceo.com/index.php/local-goN,emments/15 1-local-govermnents-pubUcceo-exclu... 8/30/2010 Ninth Circuit Upholds The Right Of Local Agencies To Regulate Wireless Telecommuni... Page 2 of 2 public's use of the road or highway. The Court reasoned that a visually displeasing telecommunications tower in the middle of a picturesque street or highway would adversely impact one's ability to enjoy travelling along such picturesque street or highway. Equally important,the Court held that aesthetic regulations are valid time,place,and manner restrictions under PUC Section 7901.1. The Court noted that telecommunication companies can "access a city's rights-of-way in aesthetically benign and aesthetically offensive ways"and therefore"it is within a city's authority to permit the former and not the latter." Nevertheless,the Court stressed that cities must still support their decisions to deny based on aesthetic grounds,by showing the decision is supported by"substantial evidence."Substantial evidence is such relevant evidence as a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support a conclusion. Moreover.a city's ordinance could still be found invalid if it effectively prohibits the provision of wireless service. In light of this case,cities and counties should take inventory of their local zoning ordinances regulating wireless telecommunication towers to determine whether they are adequate to properly regulate the future proliferation of wireless towers within their communities. As always,Alvarez-Glasrnan & Colvin's goal is to keep its clients abreast o,f'recent developments in the law. Should you like codes®,f'these casesfurther eWlanation,or have any further questions, please contact John W. Lam by phone at(562) 699-5500,or by a-mail at jlanz ;�lczavfrrmcom. [1] Sprint PCS Assets,L.L.C.v. City of Palos Verdes Estates,No. 05-56106(Oct. 14,2009). http://publicceo.com/index.php/local-goverm cents/151-local-governments-publicceo-exclu... 8/30/2010 FOR PUBLICATION UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT SPRINT PCS ASSETS, L.L.C., a Delaware limited liability company, wholly-owned by Sprint Telephony PCS, LP, a Delaware limited partnership, Plaint Appellee, V. CITY OF PALOS VERDES ESTATES, a California municipality; CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALOS VERDES ESTATES, Its governing body; JOSEPH SHERwooD, in his No. 45-56106 official capacity as Mayor Pro Tem of the City of Palos Verdes D.C. Estates; JOHN FLOOD, in his official CV-03-0 3825-AHS capacity as Councilmember of the OPINION City of Palos Verdes Estates; RoSEmARY HumpmmY, in her official capacity as Councilmember of the City of Palos Verdes Estates; DwioHT ABBOTT, in his official capacity as Councilmember of the City of Palos Verdes Estates; JAws F. ClooDHART, in his official capacity as Councilmember of the City of Palos Verdes Estates, Defendants-Appellants. Appeal from the United States District Court for the Central District of California Alicemarie H. Stotler, District Judge, Presiding 14535 14536 SPRINT PCS ASSETS v. PALos VnDES ESTATES Argued and Submitted July 6, 2009—Pasadena, California Filed October 14, 2009 Before: Barry 0. Silverman, Kim McLane Wardlaw, and Jay S. Bybee, Circuit Judges. Opinion by Judge Wardlaw 14538 SpmT PCS ASSETS v. PALos VERDEs EsTATEs COUNSEL Scott J. Grossberg, Richard R. Clouse, Amy R. von Kelsch- Berk, and Angelica A. Arias of Cihigoyenetche, Grossberg & Clouse,Ranco Cucamonga,California,and Daniel P.Barer of Pollak,Vida&Fisher, Los Angeles, California, for the appel- lants. John J. Flynn III, Gregory W. Sanders, and N[ichael W. Shonafelt of Nossaman, Guthner, Knox & Elliott, LLP, Irwwne, California, for the appellee. SPRINT PCS AssETs v. PALos VExnEs EnATEs 14539 OPINION WARDLAW, Circuit Judge: The City of Palos Verdes Estates("City")appeals the grant of summary judgment in favor of Sprint PCS Assets, L.L.C. ("Sprint"). We must decide whether the district court erred in concluding that the City violated the Telecommunications Act of 1996 C TCA"),Pub. L. No. 104-104, 110 Stat. 56(codified as amended in various sections of U.S.C. titles 15, 18, and 47), when it denied Sprint permission to construct two wire- less telecommunications facilities in the City's public rights- of-way. Specifically, we must decide (1) whether the City's denial is supported by substantial evidence, as required by 47 U.S.C. §332(c)(7)(B)(iii), and (2) whether the City's denial constitutes a prohibition on the provision of wireless service in violation of 47 U.S.C. §§253(a) and 332(c)(7)(B)(i)(II). Because the City's denial is supported by substantial evi- dence, and because disputed issues of material fact preclude a finding that the decision amounted to a prohibition on the provision of wireless service, we reverse and remand. I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND The City is a planned community, about a quarter of which consists of public rights-of-way that were designed not only to serve the City's transportation needs, but also to contribute to its aesthetic appeal. In 2002 and 2003, Sprint applied for permits to construct wireless telecommunications facilities ("WCF")in the City's public rights-of-way.The City granted eight permit applications but denied two others,which are at issue in this appeal. One of the proposed WCFs would be con- structed on Via Azalea, a narrow residential street, and the other would be constructed on Via Valmonte, one of the four main entrances to the City. Sprint acknowledged that it already served four thousand customers in the City with its existing network but stated that the proposed WCFs were nonetheless needed to replace its existing infrastructure. RECEIVED MOM AS OF PUBLIC RECOR�FFOR O NCIL MEETIN CITY CLERK OFFICE JOAN L.FLYNN,CITY CLERK � Additional)Findings for Revocation: Wireless Permit 2007-042 The following findings are adopted by the City Council, in addition to those contained in the City's Staff report, as a basis for revoking Wireless Permit 2007-042. The City Council notes in adopting these additional findings that they demonstrate that the Permit should be revoked pursuant to HBZSO Section 249.06 because: (i)there was a discontinuance of the exercise of the entitlement granted by the Permit for in excess of twelve consecutive months (Section 249 06 D(3)); (ii)the failure to exercise such rights constitutes a violation of the terms or conditions of approval of the Permit (ibid), and the Permit was issued in violation of various laws as set forth below(Section 249.06 D(2)) The Council further declares that the following findings demonstrate that the Permit was void ab initio, and its issuance was an ultra vires act 1. Contrary to the suggestion in the staff report accompanying these findings, the applicant failed to comply with the conditions imposed on the face of Permit No. 20007-042, and specifically the condition that the rights (purportedly) conferred by said permit be exercised within one year. Specifically the Permits states that it shall become null and void unless exercised within one year of the date of final approval or such extension of time as may be granted by the Director pursuant to a written request submitted to the Planning Department a mimmum 30 days prior to the expiration date The City Council finds and determines that no written request for an extension was made and that no extension was ever granted Moreover,the Council finds and determines that T-Mobile did not obtain a license to use the Harbor View Park site until January 20, 2009—one year and five months after issuance of the Permit, and did not commence construction until several months following that date (and that the exercise of the entitlements conveyed by the permit were discontinued for over 2 years). Consequently,the City Council finds and determines that Permit 2007-0042 was neither timely exercised nor extended, and hence is null and void. The City Council further finds that the fact the applicant may have been working with City Staff, and negotiating terms for permission to use the property in question is irrelevant to the determination that no request to extend the Permit was made and that no such extension was granted. The situation is no different than if the applicant were trying to negotiate a lease on private property for the installation of the facility in question and failed to come to satisfactory terms prior to the entitlements purportedly conveyed by the Permit having expired. The Council Specifically disagrees with and rejects as factually and legally incorrect the statements in the staff report to the effect that: (1)no violation of the Permit's terms occurred or that no conditions of its approval were violated, and(2)the "lengthy discontinuance for over two years" which occurred before the applicant attempted to use the rights purportedly conveyed by the Permit is somehow excused because such delay was due to ongoing negotiations between the applicant and City Staff. 2. Wireless Permit No. 2007-042 was issued in violation of the City's Municipal Code, including specifically Zoning Code section 230.96(E)(2), and hence was void when issued and/or should be revoked, because City Staff did not have the legal authority to issue a permit administratively, and without a CUP since the Permit is for a facility 384/019854-0001 1116407 01 a08/30/10 that exceeds the maximum 45 foot height limit in the applicable OS-PR zone and for - -- --a facility visible fronrheyond the-boundaries-of the—site-at-eye revel. -- - - - - 3. Wireless Permit No. 2007-042 was issued in violation of the City's Municipal Code, including specifically Zoning Code section 230.96(E)(3), and hence was void when issued and/or should be revoked, because City Staff did not have the legal authority to issue the Permit without design review which was required since the facility is located in the OS-PR zone or within 300 feet of a residential district and since a CUP is required. 4. Wireless Permit No. 2007-042 was issued in violation of the City's Municipal Code, including specifically Zoning Code section 213.10 (which requires discretionary review by the Design Review Board of all projects within the applicable OS-PR zone or within 500 feet of a PS district), and hence was void when issued and/or should be revoked, because City Staff did not have the legal authority to administratively issue the Permit without requiring the applicable design review. 5. Wireless Permit No. 2007-042 was issued in violation of the City's Municipal Code, and hence was void when issued and/or should be revoked, because Zoning Code section 230.96(F)(9) states that "Any wireless communication facility to be placed over, within, on, or beneath City property shall obtain a lease or franchise from the City prior to applying for a Wireless Permit and an administrative or conditional use permit." In violation of this Ordinance language, T-Mobile obtained a license, not a lease or franchise for the placement of the tower on City property; and, T-Mobile applied for its Wireless Permit in August 2007, nearly a year and a half before it obtained its License, rather than doing so after a lease or franchise is obtained as required by the City's Zoning Code. Moreover, City Staff was not authorized to administratively issue the Permit in question without complying with the forgoing provisions of the City's Municipal Code. 6. The City Council may not be bound by the above noted errors of City Staff in issuing the Permit in violation of the City's laws and Ordinances (despite assertions by T- Mobile that the doctrine of estopple and similar theories should apply), as the purported injustice done to the applicant (of which the City Council finds none to exist by virtue of the applicant's unclean hands in connection with the application demonstrated by its misrepresentation of facts in its application) is outweighed by the harm to the public that will occur if the Permit is not revoked. Notably,the residents of the community have a protectable property and personal interest in maintaining the character of the area as established by comprehensive and carefully considered zoning plans in order to promote orderly physical development of the district and the City. (See, a g., Golden Gate Water Ski Club v County of Contra Costa(2008) 165 Cal.AppAth 249, 259 ) 7. Wireless Permit No. 2007-042 was issued in violation of State Law, and specifically the California Environmental Policy Act (CEQA), and hence was void when issued and/or should be revoked CEQA requires environmental review of all discretionary projects such as the issuance of the Permit in question, and further defines a project to 384/019854-0001 1116407 01 a08/30/10 -2- include "the issuance to a person of a lease, permit, license, certificate, or other entitlement -for use by one or—more -public-agencies." (Pull.- Resources-Code, § 21065(c), emphasis added.) In dereliction of CEQA, no environmental review was performed by City Staff when it improperly and without authorization administratively issued Permit No. 2007-042. 8. Contrary to the suggestion contained in the staff report accompanying the adoption of these findings, the City Council specifically finds and determines that the installation of the wireless facility in question is not categorically exempt from CEQA, that none of the following are categorically exempt from CEQA (and rather that all are subject to CEQA) and, further, that all of the following are part of a single project as defined by CEQA related to the wireless facility in question: (1) the issuance of the Permit, (2) the issuance of the License, (3) the issuance of a lease or franchise for a wireless facility on the City property in question, (4) the issuance of a CUP for a wireless facility and/or the administrative issuance of a wireless permit, and (5) the design review process required by the City's Municipal Code in connection with the issuance of a wireless permit. 3841019854-0001 1116407 01 a08/30/10 -3- Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use Entitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 - Notice of Public Hearing -- Bolsa'-View Cell Tower Land Use nn; City Clerk Entitlements — 8-30-10 - Agenda Item # 2 tington Beach 0 0) X. 912H16209982 ie City Clerk W M 3ox 190 ' e us +. +� 08/19/2010 ach, CA 92648 Uj U WIX *ailed Front 92648 US POST OE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 800-561-00 Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 100 Huntington B - " --`- 1 A NZXIE 9.27 DE 1 06 O9J2-Sj1O RETURN TO SENDER VACANT UNAELE T9 FORWARD MC: 92649019090 *2077-01422—.25-25 9264900190 l�ilt}I}1,lillyi71i1111'} t� }fi111�1�}li}1�1}➢!'1}31!)}}}}}�} � n, City Clerk 209932 ngton Beach 12 i16 ju e City Clerk ach CA 92648 LU �b8r'1r291 Wailed From 92.548 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING , _ 891-571-07 Owner/Occupant NO - 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 107 - Huntington Bea RETURN TO SENDER VACANT UNADi—E TO FORWARD MCI 92649019090 .20 7'7—014 a3—2 g—25 9264900190 ll}1}}},lil}11i}}�,}11}itill}},,ii}11}I,}11i}}liiii�!}}}}}1�1I each, CA 92648 98/19/2 10 Uj Im� Willed From 92648 LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING US POSTAGE a ' 891-570-34 o \� Montgomery Beverly/Occupant V 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 34 w-Huntington Beach,C1 Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use mn, city Cleri-ntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 itington Beach 13 W 012H16249932 he City Clerk � r n 0a414 Box 190 i--each, CA 92648 98 19��r�10 w� Mailed From 92648 CL IN Us PO LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 800-560-78 Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 78 0 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 NIXIE 927 DE 1 Do OS129J10 RETURN TO SENDER VACANT UNADLE TO FORWARD BC: 92649019090 *2077-01421-25-2S 9264800190 I)ili7D)I)ID]�iiDi311�4il3111I1D11�1�DlJS1197ii191I-I�)37JJ1tl� - in, City Clerk ington Beach _ e City Clerk $00.414 ;ox 190 ach, CA92648 8'193'2 3g; ' Mailed FnDm 92648 U-S POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 800-560-26 Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 26 m Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2261 h1`IXIE1 9'2`l C3E 1 Cats 00/12SY10 RETURN TO SENDER VACANT UNAOL.E TO FORWARD LAC: t9 640019090 *2O77—®1431—2S—Z5 4`a i t 64000190 -��Illil)IIIlIlt3)IDl�f.iEl.1��7_D 411#Il)DI)1��733�i JJ1.17J1).t�til ox 190 ach, CA 92648 W- 7 { e _S POSTA-G-E LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING _ 891-570-30 Goebel George A/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 30 4 Huntington Be Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use ynn, City ClerEntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 ,. •� 0,2HI6209932 itington Beach ` the City Clerk Box 190 • — fu teach, CA 92648 � 08i19!2019 W_ Mailed From 92648 CL US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 891-571-27 Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 127 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2269 NIXIE 927 OE 1 00 001251:10 RETURN TO SENDER VACANT UNADLE TO FORWARD SC: 92640019090 *2077-01420-2S-2S to $ 11 9226 000190 � Il7ai7 i�i��77t�ttj�Ir�Ij�7ttttt� �)�tt��)ta ilat� tlt�7�t�� mn, City Clerk „ 2 �629932 ltington Beach Uil he City Clerk � 1 Box 190 00 • 98'19I29 19 each, CA 92648 Lu _ Mailed From 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING IN 800-560-95 Owner/Occupant _ 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 95 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 RETURN TO SENDER VACANT UNIADL rya FORWARD MC: 92649019090 J*2077-0 i1429--p2-5-2$ 9-284Q00190 ��-i�)li l�-1!1'�717�77f�1i�3��773-Illl��ll3i1�-]77�Ilti�l7)17717J1 ington Beach p� ' ie City Clerk $00.414 lox 190 $ 06i1912010 :ach, CA 92648 •�� •• flailed From 92648 n CL Us POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 800-560-73 Owner/Occupant _ 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 73 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2265 Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use nn, City ClerlEntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 tington Beach a 90 ti 012H16209932 he City Clerk tu �' 3ox 190 L> $00.414 each, CA 92648 LU& 0 08119/2010 W Mailed From 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING Harbour Lights 2600 Nutwood Ave #10 Fullerton,CA 92831-3145 0 RETURN TO SST#i ej:t NOT DELZVERADLE AS ADDRESSED UNABLE TO FORWARD CC: 9MS490190so *2077-- OSOISQ- 24-:.2S inn, City Clerk itington Beach , :he City Clerk Box 190 O each, CA 92648 08` 01 19/201 Mailed Fmrn 92648 US' POST GE LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING ee - AYSO Region 117 - _ - John Ahnanza 19961 Bushacd St. Fountain Valley,CA 92708 RETURN TO SeNDER NO SUCH NUMDER UNABLE TO FORWARD MC: 92649019090 *190 r-- 081-S2- -2.2- 46 ;ox 190 m t fo 8'1 ;%u 1 !ach, CA 92648 ; , at �a���From 926 48 CL E: i -POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING e ee. e West Co-Family YMCA* Michael Turner / 2100 Main Street Huntington- - D I X I Notice of Public Hearing - Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use in, City Clerk Entitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 i - t12H�62�'9932 ngton Beach UJ ie City Clerk , $OOA14 lox 190 08/1911201G Jach, CA 92648 X ce 1W MaHed From, Q99A8 IL US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 891-570-35 Thompson Loretta 1 16400 Saybrook Ln#35 Huntington Beach CA 92649-2262 X 927 NFE 1 509I OO OO,r'21-/Io r FORWARD TIME EXP RTN TO SEND THOMPSON 'LORETTA J 18222 MONTEREY L.N SPC 76 HUNTINGTN aCH CA 92649-2234 i RETURN JTO SENDER j ynn, City Clerk ' 01 HF62 99 32 UJ �tington Beach - - the City Clerk Box 190 3each, CA 92648 iled From 2,648 E US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING _ 891-570-33 Lawyer Family 16400 Saybrook Ln#33 Huntington Be. ' X 927 NFE 1 9091 OU O9,/21j;j0r FORWARD TIME EXP RTN TO SEND LAWYER 429 EASTSIDE AVE SAN TA ANA CA 92701-4319 RETURN TO SENDER car s11 64 0J.90 I1)Ilil,lt)J11)J,ImIII,) )II„)J3J111,I),lll,)IJIJi�1J})J3l,�1 sox 19U - :ach, CA92648 � ,X RaRer From, 92648 _. LAB POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-354-01 f ® Hall Thomas Eugene&Sandra Lea 4272 Silliman Dr Huntington Beach, -*__927- _Nor- 1 __i �t9T 9� ca31�1l�U -- - Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Mower Land Use Entitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 nn, City Clerk Uj tington Beach Is ie Ci Clerk } 3ox 190 0 ,Bach, CA 92648 '� �Lwr a jz OS US PM , GE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING d 891-S70-37 Auw Pierre E w 1837 Pacific Coast Hwy#229 ' Hermosa Beach,CA 902S4-3160 FORWARD TIME EXR RTN TO SEND AUW*Fa l f--RRE 821 POCXEFULL-ER L N APT A ,� i tt jj kk RETURN-22 TO SENDER Qt pp tt kk tt ii l l "iG I1)1H)))iHitlH)1{7�1){/)!i)){)3PtJ)P{H71)HH1)ii)1�i))HS!)�1 ,nn, City Clerk ° . _ ` - _ 1_223 3 tington Beach 0 OR �a . he City Clerk Box 190 each, CA 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING . so Region 143 47 w _frmissionex Phillip Hice -:7,,;4552 Harold Place ^ J*HU "gion Beach, 1 x 927 NFE 1 7091 00 00/21 1 10 7 FORWARD TIME EXR RT}N TO SEND RICE 6771 TRASK AVE WESTMINSTER EA 92883-256e JJ RETURN]] TO SEDNDzR CC3 1v9 � `925 00190 It III II III Itill fill I III 11111]]111 3ox 190 3ach, CA 92648 '"Zi W it Uafled From 9264 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING _ 891-570-45 Strom Steven R 16400 Saybrook Ln#45 Huntington Beach CA 92649-2263 Notice of Public Hearing Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use +nn, City ClerF-ntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 012H129932 rtington Beach ems: he City Clerk Box 190 - each, CA 92648 r _ ailed From 92 8 POST-AGEUS LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING _ 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16706 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 NO SUCF 4 � ' ` _" 4 Notice of Public-Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use Entitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 nn, City Clerk _ 12H!620993 tington Beach ie City Clerk $00.414 ; 3ox 190 _ 08/19 20;6 aach, CA 92648 W �_ Nlaiied Fr��� 92648 —° o AUS POST-AGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING i 1 �• �w +� sue.r _ 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant v 16705 Saybrook Ln ' Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 SIJCvi il.r'�7P ,c -- 3S215= t;itlltt ��. �I=I[Il��fr ,t �k�Ilt,It�If �,E ,II� lrlllti �ls,;, nn, City Clerk - tin9 ton Beach ie CityClerk - ;' 14 3ox 190t 4 -. each, CA 92648 t S P CJ T.AG E LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant. e 16702 Saybrook Ln � - Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3115 ri�ti x S6s s. - NC SUC!9F, ` ;= -fill I4,I1-1-1,III=Ills�lil1.I.ttl,tlt... III-It. Iif-11.11IfItltl `F �. � , - ie City Clerk �_ 4_., 3ox 190 each, CA 92648 Lair xz _ _ 95T LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant ® 16746 Saybrook Ln ' Huntington Beach.cA 4?rA4—g997 Notice of Public Hearing - Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use nn, city cierEntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 tmu n{ T2 tington Beach a 1312Hit he City Clerk , Box 190 ' ; _ each, CA 92648 " =2 faa-w d From 92648 t> US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING C n 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16749 Saybrook Ln ---Huntington.Beach,CA 92649-3117 4; -- :� ;��. �_ `;, lrrrrrtll{t��rrr.tttrlt,[II1,rtrlllt[Irt,t[1[Ilr [lrrtlttlrl°r[[;1 ,inn, City Clerk aa t ,-09 itington Beach the City Clerk00- 414 Box 190 4 - teach, CA 92648 Ma fled z ; 926b_6 ` J POSTAGE. LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING r 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16714 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3115 �x�ra [s -' + tlt l It It' sl tt t, "I'll i[t { tr,i il{ t, { ! ilft [[ r [r I[rr r[ t [ 1 r [ 1[ rr r r Q ¢ - Bach, CA 92648 LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING s 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16727 Saybrook Ln Notice of Public Hearing - Bolsa-iew Cell Tower Land Use ,in, city clerk Entitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 612 H16209932 iington Beach iu ie City Clerk Sox 190 GO L- 08/1912010 :ach, CA 92648 Uj Mailed From 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16748 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649 3.1..17 . �t �y r.=, 4. ttl tf.t��lttrlltl3 rhl �lr#tlt!„tilt 111ttt,ittlltt,it,j its Ill F_ nn, City Clerk iington Beach o 0116_09932 ie City ClerkSox 1900 A 4 3ach, CA 92648 / '112616 MaH A From UPS POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PU LIC HEARING `h 178-630-WS 02 Owner/ ant 16792 Tali an Ln Unit 105 + Huntingt n Beach, CA 92649-3118 A ,: ��css�ot . ��.�,��� 111lllr�llll't'Ili'lttlll�Illlttl�lttttttt�lt�t�,ltltt�,tltltt��t :_ -14 :ach, CA 92648 " '1"12 f its IiWee room US P S 'E LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARIN 0 891-570-60 INN parr Barbara L %400 Sayb ok Ln#60 --:. antingtDJ Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use in, City ClerkEntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 :ington Beach af12-%1r20,c��f32 ie CityClerk — _ e w Sox 190 4 i � 08126/2010 :ach, CA 92648 W M M It cc Mailed From 92648 IL ` s POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING. -- Huntington Harbor POA P. O. Box 791 Sunset Beach,CA 90742 NXXIE 917 DE 1 00 09/01/10 RETURN TO SENDER ATTEMPTED — NOT KNOWN UNAMLE TO FORWARD DC: 9.2649019090 *.2800-01 1 75-01-07 so 1Il1!! lI�1,11>>liffli!llfllff!!lf111l1!!lll�;lIff]l7fl1lill! in, City Clerk ington Beach :• "y2 '` 0 u 2 to City Clerk $00� $ 414 cox 190 0 °, 9 2010 :ach, CA 92648 f a _ maned From 92648 POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING s •' 891-570-47 Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 47 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2263 RETURN TO SENDER VACANT 4elNAMLE TO FORWARD DC: 92640019090 *207j7-01439-25-25 C_:C3$$C.�1♦ ��������� �Il�If1)�f�f�)t!!�!l��lf�)��fffffl���I�I11�!!!�l�if��!)3fa�f1� !ach, CA 92648 0 sly! 20s0 Jk ��lea}ram ! 9204 OPOSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING owner/Occupant o 1,fi40a-Saybrook Ln Unit 48 L Eton Beach, CA 92649-2263 Notice of Public Wearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use nn, City ClerkEntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 tington Beach hj 012,416209932 ie City Clerk �5WW j - 4 each CA 92648 Mailed Frl),2010 92 648 IL US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING _ Huntington Beach Beach Girls Softball* 47 Mike Erickson w r P.O.Box 3943 _ :Huntington Beach C:A 920-5-3943 NIXIE 927 BE 1 091 911D RETURN RN To SENDER NOT DELIVERABLE AS ADDRESSED UNAMI-r- T8 FORWARD elc:jj j j j 3{t3 L }D9C{{i] xis jS 7jj?- jC} 4j tt om- 925- i \ -� -111�335)I SI3113l31)l1�3113.1�31tIi3111311)11)!l1711l11!!-!3!l111 ,nn, City Clerk tington Beach Uj he City Clerk Box 190 00, each, CA 92648 W d _W. -cm 9��48 _ S POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 891-570-41 Barbour Fred 1 " 16400 Saybrook Ln#41 Huntington Beac - RETURN To SENDER VACANT" UNAOLC TO FORWARD DC: 926#ii#tj�rf��.!3djj 90 *j}2t]j 77-#D1411`07- :S-25 9264900190 ��-y�}}it�1111131lI171�1l�11��-!)i!-3lI�1))SIi�I31I31lS11 l313 dill rc vn v�c�n Sox 190 = vi , each, CA 92648 W 31±9' 2 r g49 = 1 Maikedr.ul 92648 \i CL S POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 800-560-46 Owner/occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 46 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2263 Notice of Public Hearing = Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use ,nn, City Clerl-ntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 itington Beach ci2i�� 2�9 he City Clerk `m N 00.4 4 Box 190 2 vW each CA 92648 .g9261 Maiied From 92648 OS P S3A�G LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING ... Y 800-561-19 Owner/Occupant INS 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 119 Huntington Bey ^'�^4-?�fi9 NIXIS 912I 0C 1 00 O0,/2S1;10 RETURN To aENDE:R VACANT UNABLE TO FORWARD SC: 9254001909i0 -2077-01427-25-2S « i t1.9284 00 190 11i�29i.}Jt1i1�73i�lit�li171�)Jl)J3���t�lt��)),I�I�II-��t11)l�dll ,nn, City Clerk tington Beach , `�' 3p� _ he City Clerk Box 190 each, CA 92648 W .'eg g Maiied Prom 92648 US S) G LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING }: 800-560-38 Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 38 o Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2262 NXX1C 927 DC 1 60 06/25/10 RETURN TO SENDER VACANT UNABLE TO FORWARD BC: 92649019090 *2077-0143S-2S-2S 9264000190 11,1))))1)Il11J7)I!)11ti1111),) !l111)I,)llml,1)J:11 1))'I'll sox 190 ,ach, CA 92648 $ Mailed From 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 891-570-39 \ Owner/Occupant _ \v\ 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 39 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2262 w Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use nn, City ClerEntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 tington Beach ti 012H16209932 ie City Clerk 3ox 190 £y 0 $00 414 each, CA 92648 `� �• 6811912010 Uj Ce 4 Mailed From 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING _ 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant ` 16737 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92649-3117 NIXIE 927 DE 1 00 0012-111 RETURN TO SENDER NO SUCH NUMBER UNABLE TO FORWARD BC:i 92848019090 *2077-01590-2S-2' 925 300190 II)I1111111111)))Ilillitl)Ili),),)III)I)ill)!tl)Il,II)]1,31311 nn, City Clerk tington Beach ie City Clerk 14 3ox 190 r92130 3ach, CA 92648 are W Ce Wijed Frown 9264% a LIPORTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 0 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16754 Saybrook l-n Huntington Bea, NIXIE 927 DE :1 00 001 2S1 1O RETURN TO SENDER NO SUCH NUMBER UNABLE TO FORWARD BC: 92848019090 *2077-01712-25-2S §. 's0:.90 li,lili)1>I,IIl,lI),II))1)II,),,,,Ill,i„lll,)I11„Ilil,,,I,II ie wiry uierK Sox 190 414 a , � �.� � ��=f``' '_�'" -� )ach, CA 92648- Tr- ' a iws. .; ram. �;s LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING i Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 37 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2262 Notice of Public Hearing = Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use nn, City ClerkEntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 � 32 tington Beach _ O��H�6nn Ups ie City Clerk $00.414 3ox 190 each, CA 92648 LU t _ mailed From 92648 rs. US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 s wner/Occupant '16744 Saybrook Ln Huntington B NX_xIE 00 RETURN TO SENDER NO SUCH NUMEER UNAMLE TO FORWARO MC: {{02649019090 *2(a7{7- 679-2S-2.5. -- iaiwaeoz O:L90 1111)S}JIJIJI�iJ3).ti) lJJlJIIJIJ))l��lJl#)I-!}J1131JJ 9JJJllJll (nn, City Clerk itington Beach O R , E 012H 162 9932 he City Clerk Box 190 ;each, CA 92648 Wa W zdailed fir,rr: 92648- a S POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 800-560-57 Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 57 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2264 N ;f ie 921 DE I Oa OGY2-slio RETURN TO SENDER va4CANT UNFaOLE TO f6ORWARO yy��*a.�-��-ems Ca�'•'3k1Qt'� �$8 8 ��1 1 31D3)i17�111J711)111J)I)7)37JJ1111)11 dhill J J)MH J J)I)31 ;ox 190 0 8£19 201 Dach, CA 92648 q� tYaai$et�Fir 92648 i T TA LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 w Owner/Occupant 16745 Saybrool- J Huntingtnn RP; _ -- .-- • R Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use in, City Clerk Entitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 .ington Beach g - n���� � 99�2 Eul Ie City Clerk Sox 190 PON tu 6119/2016 GE ;ach, CA 92648 _ Mailed Frorr 92648 L� �OS`�A LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING _ 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant ` 16707 Saybrook Ln Huntington Be. NxxzM 927 OE 1 00 0812-51i0 RETURN TO SENDER N9 SUCH NUMBER UNABLE TO FORWARD 4e Kao;L g - I1)14}5}I711I1I}i!7}III} 1 1i1)}11 �1}1)3111i1 3 i}1.11))}}l)1.1 in, City Clerk ington Beach m 12Hif09932 - e City Clerk �ox 190 $00i ach, CA 92648414 08 19 20 10 rr 92648 POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Owner/Occupant ` 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit S1 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2264 NIX V. 927 CC 1 AGE OSY-.2-a✓i0 RETURN O SENDER VACANT UNABLE TO FORWARD 54000190 1.1111 till)dill'tltl)I.I.�Il�li'�)li#3!))��I3d)3�11� - ix . ix 190 J� 08/19/2.010 ich, CA 92648 mapes From, 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING i r � Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 54 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2264 Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use nn, City ClerkEntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 tington Beach 0 012H16209932 ae City Clerk �5 $00 4 3ox 190 ` try - 0�tt1 ='201 each, CA 92648 LU W Railed 92648 M te e.' US POSTAGE GE 04 _ LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING _ 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant. *704 Saybrook Ln -Huntington Beach, CA NIXIE 927 LSE 1 00 0012S110 RETURN TO SENDER NO SUCH NUMDER UNABLE TO FORWARD DC: S264€1019090 *2077-01678-25-25 at 0 1 9O Ilil,1,lli191111111111111711111IIt 11131]114111111It13111111 ... --- - ,nn, City Clerk L2 �,sT tington Beach c s he City Clerk P Box 190 00 $00.414 �. each, CA 92648 i 0 'a a `' f rJj?` ° 16 US _OSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PU LIC HEAR[ f r _ Owner/Occupant 17661 Misty Ln Huntington Beach,C 9 649-4913- NIXIE= 9227 OC 1 00 00/2-5110 RFTURN TO SENDER VACANT UNAMLE TO FORWARD CC: 92848019090 *20 77-01 460-2S-'2S 9264900190 1 I,11 111111111,1,11,111,1311,1„l l l l l,1,11)11,1,l)111 J,)1,11 I1 ;ox 190 !ach, CA 92648 _ Mailed From 92648 S POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 17792 estmoor Ln tin gt Beach;CA 92649-4809 Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use Entitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 nn, City Clerk tington Beach 92H 962t� ne City Clerk 12:5 $00.414 Sox 190 00 W F Q 08119r2010 each, CA 92648 Uj e W iiaiied From 92648 IL US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16755 Saybrook Lr Huntington Beach. N sxIE 927 0E— 1 RETURN TO SENDER NO SUCH NUMBER UNABLE TO FORWARD SC: yq926480:19090 *'2077-0157S-2S--26 •--a 0 J.9Oliii Jl)I�il)31fi),I ll�li J�1��3 i33ill��i_�:i-1��11JlilJ i-�.113.1)1 )1� 1n, City Clerk s> ington Beach a 182�,932 e City Clerk 00 a as pox 190 � J 119. . 2C?1-� !ach, CA 92648 4 1 $ W X rftiled r-yo m -025 48 US POS X.G EGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING e k 800-560-84 Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 84 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 N:rYTC 927 DE 1 00 09l25110 RETURN .TO SENDER VACANT UNABLE 7O FORWARD DC:++1192e49O19090 *2{077--0:1470-25-2-S 9264�JCr019O 11tt J�lidIJ11111h1111111M111111IIIJ11111.1111111111)11)11111 .ach, CA 92648 * 8 _ 0101 W{r 1'Aa?'ed 1' 92---548 us POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE;- PU7B C HEARING 178-630-02 Owner/Oc pant INS 1679 man Ln Unit 107 H "' '' Beach,C. -- - - Notice of Public Tearing — Bolsa View Dell Tower Land Use Entitlements — 8-30-10 Agenda Item # 2 -nn, City Clerk tington Beach 0 W 01216209932 he City Clerk Box 190 , to 08119/2010 each, CA 92648 aam spa " shed From 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 891-571-04 Barnes Arthur M 16400 Saybrook Ln#104 Huntington E RETURN TO SENDER VACANT UNABLE TO FORWARD \ CC: 92�M5j4j0019090 207]7-01446- i25-2S 92S4800190 J11J:7.7)�J�II.JJlll171J11)JIJJ177113JJJ)_J)IJJ.i3)1.1J7IJ1))11)J1JJ nn, City Clerk tington Beach CIOUJ ie City Clerk 414 3ox 190 - Bach, CA 92648 Uj 0 a `"' 19. ffi. 92543 US 'POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING ` 800-560-18 Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 18 w Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2260 N:TXIF- 9217 ot: 1 00 t 012.a}10 RETURN TO SENDER VACANT UNASLE TO FORWARD SC:: 9:26]4j0019)09j01i *207j7-- t41447-2s-25 264960190 lJ)l)7)7J7J)JJ1)i171.J117J7_ll Pi1177JJJ7li7JJ 17)J I17)ll))))I Jill 3ox 190 - - - - 10 C-6 il9712,01 3ach, CA 92648 W 0 W Ir iwaed From 92.648 n US POSTAGF LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING _ 178-630-02 w Owner/Occupant 16733 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,I -- '" Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use entitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 mn, City Cler _ 012H16209932 itington Beach UJ vas :he City Clerk tE as $00.414 Box 190 4 .00 08/19 2a010 each, CA 92648 _ Mailed Flom 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16740 Saybrook Ln � . � n�cnn Z117 Huntington Bea, ' z 927 OE 1 96 Qe12m./to RETURN TO :SENDER NO SUCH NUMOER UTbC GLE TO FORWARD SC::11 l92646019090 1Ij 1*12t07ttt7- 10+t47t10 --2L61-21 �_ -- ��E,g���� !itill�llrl111t)l11i�llli/lifairai�l�llFefle114illltllr)11��1t ynn, City Clerk ton Beach §»�16 j ' itin g the City Clerk _4, 14 Box 190 Go 92648 1� 0,8 19°=2 010 CA leach, � ag 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING �• \\ 800-560-76 VV Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 76 ® Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2265 NXXIC 0-27 IBC 1 Ott 0912SY10 RETURN TO SENDER VACANT UNAGLE 'ro FoRwARo MC: JJ 9.e^8�34(9019090 'k2077-01+444-2iS++-21S g-3 3* �lc0190 �13�il3ili11I1IIlllill111111 lilt?dll11111{1i IA)1111MIL11 ® Box 190 d $00.414- each, CA 92648 0 1 ' 0' ' MF Mailed Rom 9-2j 4 8- US POSTIAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING V 891 579-12 Sf gpfnE Jerry G 1 �WlbYrook Ln#71 - s: _ r" _ -Beach, Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa-View Cell,Tower Land Use Entitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 nn, City Clerk 112H162932 tington Beach � :- - ie City Clerk �5 00. 4 Sox 190 0 c�� 08119 f'20,10 aach, CA 92648 1j(a W It s#t Marled From 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 _Owner/occupant 16719 Saybrook Huntington Bea( NIXIE 927 9E 1 OS 001215110 RETURN TO SENDER NO SUCH NUMBER UNABLE TO .FORWARD SC: j9.2649019090 *2077-04705-26-21 !-1_flflltilll}1#11111111i11.1#-11ff11f111-111f11ff-f-ll#)fill 11111111 _,._.___�-__._..:.�.,e.:-�,.� _.... ___.... ,.m._--�:,��-t _ __.„.� � Vie.--�•---_ � „�---�--. _ ._ _.. t;>. ._._:_ F ,nn, City Clerk itington Beach 012H 16209932 he City Clerk - •`�• 3 Box 190 $00.414 each, CA 92648 081191 201u 23. sa'Ea1�e z^e;3p^y+� 9264.8 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16713 Saybrook' Huntington Beal NIXIE 927 0E 1 06 0817-15110 RETURN TO SENDER NO SUCH NUMBER UNAGLE TO FORWARD GC:, 92649019090 *2077—04704-26—21 . ' �?�� 111#i_>1111:1111111III Jill If11f1111 fill)Ili Jill 11f1111#111111111 . Box 190 V t o R z'19912010 each, CA 92648 Uj 0 W tL Maned From 92648 US POSTAGE s . LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16726 Saybrook Ln Huntington Be Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa-View Cell'Tower Land Use Entitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 ,nn, City Clerk tington Beach 0 _ 912H16299932 he City Clerk 0 .4 4 Box 190 €a la® M 0811992910 each, CA 92648 w yr 92648 Mailed Fron, OB POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 ® Owner/Occupant 16721 Saybrook Ln Huntington Bead "M*114 1 E 927 OE 1 98 09126110 RETURN O SENDER NO. SUC1-1 NUMSER UNABLE To roRwARO \. MC: 9.2649019090 *2077-04709-26--21 --- �����:�� i1,1��,�l�l�ll�E:1,ill,,i�11,,,,��ll)tl;lllsz�l�l�,l►,,;,,i�11 -in, City Clerk :ington Beach PM 12y1;2t�99« ie City Clerk t. E414 Sox 190:ach, CA 92648 �, -� 03,191201G POST Ma-ied From 92648 t LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 ` Owner/Occupant 16715 Saybrook L- Huntington Bead NIXIE 927 DE 1 OS 001`26110 RETURN TO SENDER NO SUCH NUMMER UNAGL:E TO rORWARO cc: 92S48019090 j*2077-0J47j07- ]26-21 ���� � � -��i�Illt�1�7l�1111i1��)1'41�fii)3t11�l1i#��711�}1f1-�Illlltff�� - � :)x 190 m- 8119'2�1J ach, CA 92648 cas d' a:W Maiied From 92648 M m = any Os POSTAGE `GE LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 INS Owner/Occupant 16716 Saybrook Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use Entitlements - 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 nn, City Clerk tington Beach 6 6 :? � 2 62 ie City Clerk $00.414 3ox 190 - �__ =?81 19 2010 each, CA 92648 Q:it a # Mailed From 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 0 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16711 Saybro6 Huntington Bey WEXXE 707 DE i as 061Q6110 RETURN TO SENOER NO SUCH NUMaCR UNABLE TO rORWARO tie CC: 92649019090 'k]207 j7-04 r 111-26-:21 i i, City Clerk . _T 1 2 99 igton Beach City Clerk _ mp t RA _ .ch, CA 92648 iPs a'asiej From bB 92648 LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING e 178-630-02 e Owner/Occupant - 16708 Saybrook Ln Huntington I NIXIV: W2 DE IRETURN TO SENDER NO SUCH NUMBER UNABLE TO P @RWARD MC: 92649019090 j�j j2 j077- j047-10-26-21 9264MV.��`� f}}�##}#I}Ii��#1i3t3!})1l#I�!#I!1}41!Ili}11Y}Iltll311ff}11�t1� ach CA 92648 .8 1 . s 92648 } _ Uo LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant _ 16724 Saybrook Ln Huntington Be I Notice of Public Hearing - Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use Entitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 mn City Clerk . W z t621 9 2 itington Beach j he City Clerk v _ 4 Box 190 - :each, CA 92648 a v, 1a; 16 $1'W Mailed From 92648 US O T I LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING e 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16757 Saybrook Huntington.Beac HXXIE a27 ESE I RETURN TO SENDER No SUCH NUMBER UNABLE To rCR1.ARD MC: 92640019090 *2077- 047:14-26- 21 9.2r� ��� !!}ltlilllli!li31lII!lIli}�llilili!l�11iI!!li)!ilii!!il}f1!}li I nn, City Clerk tington Beach (a �. 12H96 1993% ne CityU) , ®j s Clerk 00.E14 Sox 190 t3 to i— 18/19 20 n each, CA 92648 tu co W.1Z '�• e Mailed Frorrd 92648 US POST-AGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING I ® West Co.Family YMCA* 47 - Michael Turner 2100 Main Street Huntington Beach,CA 92 46 i 927 0E- -1 CICI O9j.�6�icy RETURN TO SENDER ATTEMPTED - NOT XHOWN ILAN.r.9DUC T01 F-ORWARD MC: 9:2640019090 1909- O61 56-.22-46 o !!it111Il1!}lllli!)I!!11l11lIi11i1!!IIl11!l,11lil1�!l11,11 1,!! DUA I:JV - e _ter _. vp each, CA 92648 9 19l2010 I, x to Mailed From 92648 OS POSTAGE. LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 ® Owner/Occupant 16718 Saybrook Ln Huntington Bea-'- n-ICAQ-Z11 S ' I i i Notice of Public Hearing - Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use Entitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 nn, City Clerk % 012# 8620932 tington Beach Uj M e1 �_ he City Clerk W '� M Box 190 o W�_ ,. 08/19 2010 each, CA 92648 _ Mauer Fiow, 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16731 Saybrook Ln Huntington Bea, RETURN TO SENDER NO SUCH NUMBER UNABLE TO FORWARD GC: ]92j64j80190 I90 -2ti777- 470.1-- i6-2r.1 11#ItJi#3JI AIM)11,##1Pl1 in, City Clerk {y E t ngton Beach 62-- e City Clerk ` ox 190 ach, CA 92648 ` ` 0" E LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant x 16750 Saybrook Ln Huntington Bea RETURN TO ',`ENDER NO SUCH NUMBER UNABLE TO FORWARD 0c: 92649019690J ]] ]l *}2077-0470 #- }26--21 ��� � {3!�!i_fill_31�ISYi�#,li!-tI#1�##Y1YY��Ii�Y11Ii#Y�Y�Y#}�####Y1lIl P m I 3ox 190 '0 0 � each, CA 926'48 �•� G'_R 2011"Q LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 -Owner/Occupant 16753 Saybrook L Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use nn, City ClerkEntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 tington Beach a 012H16209932 he City Clerk �5 0 0 .4 4 Box 190 y�c�. 08/19/2010 each, CA 92648 laa 1z�_ Pviailed From 92648 OS POST-AGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING South Coast Bayern Futbol Club - ic� Marisa Pena .22 222 Eucalyptus Lane Lake Forest,CA 92630 1 !7 f RETURN ..TC SE3�I7fl INSUFFICIENT ADDRESS Q Jill)111111111tllil)lti-1111I11 ti111111�711 1It11�11 1.1 r111�111 lynn, City Clerk 012H16209932 ntington Beach the City Clerk E . Box 190 081=: i00 Beach, CA 92648 Mailed Rom 926a8 US OST_A LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Owner/Occupant 16411 Wimbledon Ln Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2111 l ` w 3i I::ZE :a:;"7 5C i ta�J qi3!2�J 1� RETURN TO -SENDER vAcANT UNADLE TO FORWARD CC: 928+{ 9019{390 *C 17r7 17210..j21j --35 }Ill}ll }llilll}}}11j11}I1llJllil l}Irl7litl� _ 3ox 190 k 0.414 aach, CA 92648 =8/19 2 ,0 37, mailed a"'gts€l3 92648 USPO TAGS` LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING s 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16743 Saybrook I n Notice of.Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use Entitlements - 8-30-10.7 Agenda Item # 2 nn, City Clerk tington Beach a W a m 632H16209932 he City Clerk $00.414 Box 190 each, CA 92648 cn ' 08r'91291 J fibiied Frorn 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARINP AYSO Region 1 47 Commissio Phillip PI 5552 H d Place e Hun" gton Beach, CA 92647 X 927 N7E -1 709G Od 00/26/10 FORWARD TIME EXP RTN . TB SEND HIDE 6771 TRASK AVE WESTMINSTER CA 92603--25 O RETURN TO SENDER 92640 0.90 ,nn, City Clerk _ ;, 2 alr;_s6 L. 32 itington Beach he City Clerk F Box 190 $0098119 201 each, CA 92648 Uj W W itOaded Rom 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 ` Owner/Occupant 16739 Saybror', ' Huntington BE NIXIE 9:27 DE 1 OO 09/25/10 RETURN TO SENDER NO SUCH NUMBER UNABLE TO FORWARD BO: 92849019090 ..JJ *2077i -01719-2+5tt-•25 4190 iIIIJI))Illllli)llllll)ll}II1773l7'��}1}J)]7l1lI)Illil)111311 iox 7 yU F X ti)€.did--t d ,oa each, CA 92648 M W19.12010 7u W ' Mailed From 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING R South Coast Bayem Futbol Club ` Marissa Pena 22222 E} Notice-of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Ceil'Tower Land Use Entitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 ,nn, City Clerk tington Beach , . 012H16209932 Uj he City Clerk $00.4 4 t� Box 190 to 06:1912010 each, CA 92648 Mailed}=tors 92648 IL B POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 891-571-14 Jacobs William F e 16400 Saybrook Ln#114 Huntington Beach,'-A E 9217 DC 1' CEO 013I MS1 10 RETURN TO SENDER ATTEMPTED - NOT MNOWN UNAGLE TO FORWARD BC: 92649019090 *21 7-7- 049OS-23- 19 �aS A �. # 11}I}});I}I)II))11))II}}I)II)i)}1 dill I'll 1)))1)1))11.....I'll inn, City Clerk itington Beach Uj J - .-he City Clerk � 0 1 4 Box 190 -� each, CA 92648 s A5 V,2 -' 92648 US PCISTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 INS Owner/Occupant 16725 Saybrook Lv Huntington Beach, N I` 1E 927 DE 1 00 0012S110 - RETURN. TO SENDER NO SUCH NUMMER UNABLE TO. FORWARD 9C: 92648019690 *1909-08153-22-446 woo 190 11)l!},il}I)Jill}Ililli}1)!I}i))lull}Dill)}}1}li}ll}1,}illll sc vsiy vacs n ..a $' '3" U �, Sox 190 1- .9 $ '8 ! __:2 010 .ach, CA 92648 N-548 LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Dt-630-02 owner/Occupant + %717 Saybrook Ln Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use nn, City ClerkEntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 012H16209932 ington Beach UJ 0 ie City Clerk (� �� ' _ 3ox 190 W ,+. tz 08/19/2010 :ach, CA 92648 LU x cc mailed From 92648 IL US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING ' .• 800-560-98 Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 98 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2267 0 ADzXIE: 927 DE 1 08 CaF3�.2�J1C, RETURN TO SENDER VACANT UNABLE TO FORWARD OC: S264.9019090 *2077- 070S9-27-20 r3v1'S%S%N'A ll,l>>>>h]fill, 1>>jl,�l,11, ,nn, City Clerk 012H16209932 tington Beach he City Clerk a $00414 Sox 190 0 0 081/19/2010 each, CA 92648 LU _ Mailed From 92548 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 891-579-10 Gordon Sharon RVogel Robert F 16400 Saybrook Ln#22 Huntington &""�' I-^ OICAn Ile,, NzXXE 927 DE 1 00 08125/10 D RETURN TO SENDER ATTEMPTED - NOT XNOWN UNABLE TO FORWARD E3C. 92649019090 *2i77- C34 3i3s-23- 1�3 U `4194SW&M 11,1,�„1,1,Ils„1„Il,z1,11,„�„111,1„lla�,l,l>>li�„3,1,11 ie City Clerk $00.414 €� 3ox 190 0 rA 08/19 2010 each, CA 92648 ul $, f Mailed From 92648 O POSTAGE LEGAL NOT E - PUBLIC HEARING eM 178-630762 Owner Occupant 4352 ickwick Cir Unit 310 ® Hu ington Beach,CA 92649-3126 Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use ,nn, City ClerF—ntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 :` 012H16209932 tington Beach he City Clerk L2 5 - 0 .4 1 Box 190 Wis 11.- 0811912010 each, CA 92648 ��_ Mailed From 92648 CL ac' US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING r 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 167.09 Saybrook Lr Huntington Beach, NIXIE 927 DE 1 00 0912s7;Lb RETURN TO :SENDER INSUFFICIENT ADDRESS UNA®LE TO FORWARD MC: 9264001909fl *2077-01807-25-2s lli1rl1/1111 Jill Ill Jill 11111Y1i117I.11lllYll,YilllY� ll�)rlllll Inn, City Clerk itington BeachUj aiR. 1216299 � the City Clerk Box 190 0 0 W D- M 08/19/2010 beach, CA 92648 LLS W Mailed From, 92648 iz US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16703 Saybrook L Huntington Bead NI'Xlly 927 DE 1 00 00./2S110 RETURN TO SENDER INSUFFICIENT ADDRESS UNADl.-E TO :FORWARD 13Oi: +928490190j90 i *2077- j01ees-25-25 so190 111liY.Y7111111)1117311,71.1loll13i1111111l1.111I1 71i1illIJillIll VIGI l� 3ox 190 $00.414 O aach, CA 92648 �- M 08119/2010 X ffi� .ailed From 92648 U ? S AGE LEGAL NOTICE — PUB C HEARING i 178-630-02 Owner/Occup nt 4302 Pickwi Cir Unit 101 Huntingto Beach -A 4)F49-3121 Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use mn, City Clerk ntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 Y� itington Beach 012HI6209932 he City Clerk 14 Box 190 to 08119,=2010 .each, CA 92648 X OC Mailed From 92648 OS POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant .16751 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach, NIXIE Crt? 081 25l 10 RETURN TO :SENDER NO SUCH NUMDER UNAELE TO FORWARD DC: 92849019090 �ac^Or7—OA71:3-25- 2.5 in, City Clerk ington Beach ";* ti= , raa ;620 ? 2 ie City Clerk1 . Sox 190 IOU ;ach, CA 92648 LU(A � Paaaaed From 92648 'POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING _ 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16728 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach, NIXIE. 927 DE 1 00 0912s1 io RETURN TO SENDER INSUFFICIENT ADDRESS UNAGLC TO FORWARD DC: 92649019090 *201'7-01699-2S-2S e titry t ierK w ox190 ach, CA 92648 It itMaaed Frorn 92648IL „ v. O O I ACE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING i 178-353-06 Schreiber Allen 16835 Algonquin St#232 • Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3810 Notice of Public Hearing Bolsa View Cell Tower Land. Use inn, City Clerl-ntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 012H16209932 itington Beach UJ he City Clerk ': $00.414 Box 190 each, CA 92648 08.'19/2(}10 �_ Mailed From 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING. 0 178-630-02 owner/Occupant 16742 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,G NIXIM 927 SM IBg C1t l Sd�� RETURN TO SENDER NO SUCH NUMBER UNABLE TO FORWARD BC: 92640019090 *2077-01882-25-25 -- 93aLka 945b190 -11111ii.i1l1i.11lilt 11111)lilt 7)1)1111111i111)l):1311J-1�1)li}1:)11 in, City Clerk ington Beach 612H16209932 e City Clerk fi ° 00.4 tox 190 _ — !ach, CA 92648 08;'19/20 1 W W � ,� Mailed From 92648 gL S POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 0 •• - 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 0 16747 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach, ( A 17 NIXIE 927 OE 1 00 0912SI/16 RETURN TO SENDER NO- SUCH NUMBER UNABLE TO FORWARD DC:{ 92849019090 *20 7 7-01 680-2S--2S �d4blgo 111 III)11i1,1111}111}11131111ii1)11Hill)11111i1111111111)11111 ie City Clerk iox 190 00. 1 . ,ach, CA 92648 08;'19.'231 Mailed From 92648 U P-OST GE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 0 178-630-02 Owner Occupant 16710 Saybrook Ln Huntington Bea( Notice of Public Hearing Bolsa View-Cell Tower tand Use Entitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 nn, City Clerk �, "AWL 012H4620992 tington Beach ie City Clerk P ' ' 2 _ Sox 190 go 0819912010 each, CA 92648 LU vs x Mailed From 92648 ffi - US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING _ 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant .16741 Saybrook Ln °Huntington Bea NZXIE 927 DE i Q0 60i'25JiQ RETURN TO SENDER No SUCH NUTEBER UNABLE TO FORWARD BC: 9284801++909(6 ,nn, City Clerk itington Beach ; aY 012 I62099 2 he City Clerk Ua M Box 190 iz� . 1 each, CA 92648 08/19/2010 I Mailed From 92648 LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING US POSTAGE 'i 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16752 Saybrool Huntington Bea NSX.tE 927 DE 1 00 4812E710 RETURN TO SENDER NO SUCH NumeeR UNABLE . TO FORWARD BC: 92649019090 ��fl77-01CT4-��� -x5 0019ra I111�)„l;l111� ,llllll,1,lli,ii7,iil,)),)I),111!);11,,�„�,Il 3ox190 M T0811912010 each, CA 92648 aj U Ce ix Mailed From 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING _ 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant INN 16756 Saybrook Ln Huntington Bea, Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use nn, City ClerEntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 012H16209932 tington Beach no UJ he City Clerk $00.414 Box 190 y 08119120'10 each, CA 92648 Uj W t maiied From 92648 �' 14 Us POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16732 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach NIXTE 927 OE -1 flO 0012Sl10 RETURN TO SENDER NO .SUCH NUMMER UNAOLE TO FORWARD 9 i019fl 11d...IId.11.)11I))IIII)IIIJIIIII)II111J111111)111111111)I111 ynn, City Clerk itington Beach ; - 012H R-9099'32 the City Clerk ,- Box 190 $00.414 leach, CA 92648 ' e 06/19 1201 G LU N1.Rided From 92648 kS. l TAG LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16735 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beal N'lXXM 927 OE 1 CIO OG/2 /10 RETURN TO SENDER NO SUCH NUMOER UNAMLE To FoRWARo SC: 9264 j90;190)90 *20 77-016J71—2-5--2S @O190 I11171llllllll)l111)11t11111)7771)1113111111)11111711771111111 ie City Clerk M .119 _ t 3ox 190 :ach, CA 92648 i2 ii J waited-orn 92648 PF. US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING N 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16738 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach �' IIIAG_1117 -Notice of Public Hearing - Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use inn, City Clekntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 itington Beach 012H16209932 the City Clerk 14 Box 190 vai M 08/1912010 leach, CA 92648 €u v) _ X 2; mailed From 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING r _ 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16720 Saybrook Ln Hunting NIXIE 927 DE 1 Oct 08l2tild RETURN TO SENDER NO SUCH NUMOMR UNABLE TO FORWAR0 MC: 92648019090 *{j2{077-0115457-2S-25 .- --_- fWK sbi9® 11)111�3'111111111IIIII.11.1I)J11.31 III IIIlilt]1111111i11111111.11111 /nn, City Clerk ,� {12H1,-09932 rtington Beach €� :he City Clerk - R 0414 Box 190 each, CA 92648 W� '' r Ev 1" W Mailed From 92648 CL US POSTAGE r . LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 o Owner/Occupant _ .16723 Saybrook ' - Huntington Bea NIXIE 927 DE 1 00 O912A_J1ts RETURN 70 SENDER NO SUCH NUMSER UNADLE 7O FORWARD DC: J9264901++90j90 *207t7-j01668-2Srr-25 9413 a 90 1�)13331�1�3) )13i111�33�)I111))1)'1�211f�1))311�11.1�311I3�711 e City Clerk W.1$ -11 ;ox 190 Uj�sr 08/1912016 1ach, CA 92648 X VPlaiied From 92648 ae us. POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE- PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant .16729 SaybrookLn Huntington Bead Notice of Public Hearing' — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use City ClerFntitlements — 8-30-10 —Agenda Item # 2 itington Beach WM . f�'2H,62�?9932 he Ci ClerkBox 190 o� 1z 08/19/2010 each, CA 92648 9 X It� Mailed From 92648 � f US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-6 -02 ` .ner/ cupant 3JL � -Say rook �ngto Beac N1XIF- 9!27 0E- 1 aC 00./ 51:10 e: RETURN TO SENDER NO H NUMBER UN��tBLE�TO FORWARD BC: 92649019090 *1j 00-08162-22-45 0190 �il)�YI!l13:!)1l1.1t _!3)IInhI:1.)))�)9.)11 9�1:9►.)�19:i�i))):�liiSfl�)�� ---- - .... . -- - Inn, City Clerk �,12H162��99 rtington Beach :he City Clerk � �p - a Box 190 s� j � �8119r'201% ,each, CA 92648 M fe R' Mailed From 92648 0- - z US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 ® Owner/Occupant 16736 Saybrook Ln Huntington Be. N'S`.CtE 927 DE 1. Ot, 0012S110 RETURN TO ;SENDER NO SUCH NUMBER UNABLE TO FORWARD SC: jj 92848019090 ii *2077—i01665-2]5{{-25 95r4(�1 90 fll )l-31�.)�I-1�1i11311�ii�91�91)19A�II i133-�1i1lli ))!li)9i1�119 Sox 190 08119/2010 ,ach, CA 92648 co W_Ix wailed From 92648 US TAG LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 0 Owner/Occupant 16722 Saybrook Li Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use nn, City ClerkEntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 tington Beach 0 U) 0121116209932 ie City Clerk f0� ,- 3ox 190 .414 Bach, CA 92648 08119120/0 Mailed From 92648 IL US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Huntington Harbor POA P. O. Box 791 -:.Sunset Beach,CA 90742 NIXIE 917 DE i 00 08125J10 RETURN TO SENDER NOT DELIVERABLE AS ADDRESSED UNADLE TO FORWARD BC: 92640019090 '*2ei: 9-OA404-2S-07 9:254900190 mn, City Clerk a 2 s 25 99 2 (tington Beach rlad he City Clerk W 5 $00.414 Box 190 each, CA 92648 ul IX N :t`d From a 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant ` 16701 Saybrook Ln Huntington Beach,CA naq-3115 N'EX IE 927 t7E 1 00 0912S110 RETURN TO SENDER NO SUCH NUMDER UNADLE TO FORWARD DC: 92¢64001j9090 *2077-01 7 t16-.2.a-2S Box 190 each, CA 92648 � 1 � i_ Maned From 92648 � O IOS T O A LE L NOTI4Beach,C EARIN ® 800-5 Owner/Oc16400 SayHuntingto2261 Notice of Public Hearing (-&—l'sa View Cell"Tower Land se- ynn, City CleEntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 ntington Beach • 012H75209932 the City Clerk 12: 00 414 Box 190 ac 0811912010 leach, CA 92648 w U) _§ From 92648 U. US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 10 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2259 RETURN TO SENDER VACANT UNABLE TO FORWARD MC: 92649019690 *2077-01 41 9-2S-25 ems'@0190 ill 1111I)Ill)l fill)Ill d11111mliill -- - -- 77 l(till"1`1lifEEf<<11(if flltflMll(l(fit f(1`1( a-Zzozl : 0509T00ta9v6 :00 0 �-� 012H16209932 3b(dMLfOJ O;L :3-0tdNn UJ M e INVOIdA li� 00.4 14 . dM aW3S 01 Ntl(11:3ad Q U to�- 08/19/2010 d T Otp Lr,6 '31 XI Y luW. Mailed Fr3$aa 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 800-560-04 Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 4 Huntington Beach, CA 92649-2259 �����;��� . ���.��� IIIIIilr�I�IIIIIII�ItIltllrlftlll�ll►tll�tl�rll=IIlrfll�illll�I! 3 pity L iertc ..... .. ox 190 - 08/19/2010 ach, CA 92648 W M x ailed From 92548 C ae. 4 - US OSTAOE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 800-560-03 Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 3 ::9hantington Beach, CA 92649-2259 Notice of Public Hearing— Bolsa View Ce1I Tower Land-Use nn, City ClerFntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 tington Beach Cl W _ 012H16209932 le City Clerk j $00. 14 3ox 190 - us t- i • M 06i1912010 each, CA 92648 cu rn �•$ Mailed From 92648 Us POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING 0 800-561-08 4f /" Owner/Occupak Ln Unint t 108 16400 Saybroo Huntington Be NIXIE 927 OE 1 90 06Y 251 to RETURN TO SENDER VACANT UNABLE TO FORWARD bc: 92848019090 *2077-01424-25-23 — 92£4000190 Il��ttt,ltltlltatlt,lltal,)lttt,i��)Itlr.t�lt t{tltr��ttttt tll mn, City Clerk itington Beach ,' 012HI6209932 he City Clerk LU W Box 190IOU CO. each, CA 92648 '• "� ci19P201v r nailed rrcrd6P 92640 B B i_AGE LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING 891-571-13 Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook L- Huntington BeacF NIXIE 927 DE 1 00 0612S110 RETURN TO SENDER VACANT UNABLE TO rORWARD BC. 92649019090 *2077-0142S-2S-23 C3F `+3Tt3�11 92r. 0190 )�tjttttltlt��ttt�tt��ti�tl�ttitttl�ltllrlltttltittllttt,tltJl ingion tseacii ie City Clerk • •4 ' t� Sox 190 fu 081,11912010 each, CA 92648 Sat`W Mailed Frorn 99648 US KDSTA E LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING i 891-571-17 ® Jackson David L 16400 Saybrook Ln""' Notice of Public Hearing — Bolsa View Cell Tower Land Use n, city Clerk chEntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2,, w N• ngton Beach Entitlements � ' h 012±-i1620�932 ua City Clerk W 00. 14 ox 190 00 7, 08/19 2010 ach, CA 92648 a M Mailed From 02648 CL j US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING e 163-204-11 Pritchard Robert W& Nancy R 17691 Helenbrnr%L, i n Huntington Bei NIXIE 927 OC 1 00 09/01/10 RETURN TO SENDER NOT DELIVERABLE AS ADDRESSED UNABLE TO FORWARD BC: 92S49019090 *2177-0110S-28-IS \�' ° ' ' ����''��''� _ `����'� � li�i>>,�1,1�11���1��1l�►Ili►,,��,Ili�1��11„�l�I��I!>>i�►l�l! lotice of Pubiic--1 e4rir cg--Bolsa Vi W Cetl dower Land Use- ,nn, City ClerkEntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 tington Beach a � 0921 i1620}33 he City Clerk Box 190 J0 0811912010 each, CA 92648 iu coy )' Mailed From 92648 US POSTAGE EGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Owner/ ccupant 447 ea Harbour Dr ntington Beach,CA 92649-3207 'RIXIF 927 De 1 00 09t 3-5110 RCTURN TO SCNDCR VACANT UNABLE TO FORWARD ,. �?���ffi:d�+4 �CJ 117�3ii.i1i11113a11)9��t1�)!I))3t)}�1�i1))�Ilit�lil)!�}I)11f711 - ^Notice-of-Public Hearing"—' Bolsa View Cell-Tower Land Use nn, City Clergntitlements — 8-30-10 — Agenda Item # 2 tington Beach 0 M ` 012H16209932 1e City Clerk 55 _ r - 3ox 190 00 � �� �4 aach, CA 92648 U)11—s 0 08/19/2010 ILIW — { Mailed From 92648 US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 800-560-85 A Owner/Occupant �{' " ,.-•' 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 85 ® .' Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 iiil€ll€€ tllltii€€ €'Il' in, City Clerk ington Beach rm 012 162�?99 2 �ie City Clerk imm� . ,Sox 190 ' 08 19120 0 iach; CA 92648Mailed From 92648 a� US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 800-560-91 Owner/Occupant 16400 Saybrook Ln Unit 91 Huntington Beach,CA 92649-2266 ' VAC �3r��B��t cs�.�.,�� I€Illrrrlll€IIt€€I#€Irilirll€iililitt€i€€€€€'I'I€�!'€i11#€Iflll�i fie C ily ulul C Box 190 U)$A + to WiSli2010 each, CA 92648 w vs 1 leg _ Mailed From 92648 U. US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING •' 1 178-630 02 Owner/Occupant }` 16701 Algonquin St Unit 106 .° Huntington Beach, CA 92649-3349 If if CST 0013i7sp-1-S Tz" 6001io --i=40;51v.; 0s0GT0r."*%Zs 00 am 012H16209932 fj O� 01 0 $00-414 (a 08/1912010 go T 1.)V. z Z-1 6 31XIM !��.ailed From -02648 I-L US POSTAGE LEGAL NOTICE PUBLI AIRING M4 -Em NOTICE PU B 178-630-02 -4A Owner/Occupant 16701 Algonquin St 3 c Huntington Beach, 2 351 '-�t�QHL I i Sew..:4S If If M Ifff(Iff It 11(11( 11 1 Ift I I if I I I t I I III I III(I(1(11[It It os Too evs;:, TZ -60I0SO1 1 06j06TOevsze ZOO s UJ FY, P4- 012H16209932 ; r 0 0 A 4 L-,-3MWnN HOMS' ON MOON3S 01 W-1,1113d QrD E- 6 ZT., 114 U2- OD Liz 92648 OTIOZIOT 90, T- LEGAL NOTICE PUBLI*ARING US POS E AGE 178-630-02 Owner/Occupant 16701 Algonquin St P 3 Huntington2 351 1:1 H L I 1 9 2 S-4=9