Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
Conditional Exception 70-33 - Robert G. Johnson and William (12)
Affidavit of .eaAMff�o� ' •.tatC Of UtU��rLer'nla 0_0 Colll.f�' Ot Cmlttae 1 sy [ C I City of Huntltuton Beach ...J l.� , (� Ga7�CW Famuhar, being duly sworn wi Path, rwys That he Ise ��', ✓�G� t�� citisen of the United States, over tier age of twenty-one )cars. C j 7hat he Is the printer and pubtiaher of the Ifurtinglon lk-nch Newt. a %vekly newspaper of general circulation printed arul nub- Ushed to Huntington Beach. California iond rin-ulatcrl In the sail 4 County of Orange and elsewfiere and lxublishr4t for the dixwminallon Of kaat► Vul tither news of a general chmt:acter, and has n lxxva fibs sunscriplInn list of lw:ing sulmribers, and said pnlxr tins !►cen established. printed awl publishrol In the State of California, and County of Omnge for at least (mic ycnr next before the 1•s14iration of the fltat Insertion of this notirtr; and the mild newsi►almr is not devoted to tht• Intetncst of, or ptthiimhrrl Mr the entertainment of any particular riam, profession, lmdr• r•rtlling, rncc or denominntfon. or any number thereof. 'Ric lfuntingtun Bench New was ndjudicniml n Iry-nl newivnimrr• of general simulation by Judge Co. K. Scowo_•I in the Sulx•riur roar+ t8► 11�1. „ : • ,.r of Orange Monty, Chlih►rnin Augumt 27th, 1937 by onler No, A-5931 'Phrat th- 40APITIONAL FXCF' TI rya of which fire annexed is a printed rvrl+}•, w•ns pulilkhrrf In anlif new,• paper of least one luaus rNtttitri�t: : S e a�aru,a,t"' commencing from+ the _ 23 rd (fn) of e3pt lnbd r pt}, tsar, rf .Mrf r , IN ifi6 t%1a1-" � 19 1._... anti ending un thr _23rd day of . September 'w, ,�'•''+•t. •+ritrr�rX�4 AN utwiitti 't .r+t..�M':'ittal�.fti . Mi No "fat wlow"i, .i"�i� 'rww°w�ri' 19-21.. bath clays inciuslvr, arxf ax often during; mid 1►erirxi arm! ,•,.s,,,;� times of publication ar trAld lrnl>rr cans trtNlarly Irsunl, and iti the �w ,jtisllllA`�illi; regular art! entire issue of said pews-rpnl►er ptxxMr, anti not In a try,001 I, r ilw taAftfA 4��t'1x('i� �s•.� ` sUpnlettaen:, and scald txrtire was l►ubltcfx f ihrro•in on tine fo14►w•ini; r.i ;tart' or. +�'�1i dates, to-wit: •i�'�� 11, 19,71 . _.ter.. �rfiir •Y..+�.—:._ s'' C�'; Subar_ribed and aworn to beftim me thtit rind of /o Nota—,� Public r �V Ckataxr C:bunty, Ciliftxnla THWAS D. WrlLlE �� N.t.rr MCC.C41.1010.4 Orange Comatr My C99"'w4sVa Fro;t9s S+pMAor 11, 1174 s . N v ` t Kwi • � yye�t �� , Y � a � Y 4• N . rJ � � � • ' � ,. �, Year•' ± - , . n ' = . • • . Z ���'j yy�/��a'_•", ram.>� � _ a . of f;- `. �. .. !^ ,`�_`. - +•,r=` • i • � � L • t JOL J ♦.� 2•„ r�ifa - r. •- �,�sy.rw�-+ ,R•pt :�:.; aft" • IL•au k► •ti 4 • fir, ' September 8, 1971 THE 110VORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF i HUNTINGTO'N BEACH s Gentle;tten and Lady s We, the undersigned property owners , hereby request that you revoke Conditional Exception 70-33 granted September 2", 1970, and permit us to address you at the September ,�19712 mt4sting . Tho reason we request such action is because of the numeroupr and repetitious violation.,. of various City ordinances . when you granted the conditional exception, you specifically conditioned such grant stating that the use shall be terminateed. . . . upon viola- tion of any City or County ordinance. We originally opposed the granting of the Conditional Zxception, but have tried to live with it . Unfortunately, it is unlivable. The operator of the stable has been unable to live up to the laws it is impossible for him to do no. There are nightly violations of the noise ordinance 5541 (f) which occur when the hcree• become restless and kick the sides of their stalls . These stalls are constructed of metal arnJ wood so that the effect on us, they neighbors, is equivalent to the intermittent banging of the world 's largest tin drum. There are constant violations, at least during the daylight hours, of the dust ordinance 3132 . These violations are caused by the horses moving around in the dirt. The operator his attempted to alleviate the situation by spreading manure over the area and . wetting it down. We are now faced with, not only dirt and dust, but also vLaitations in our hones and yards of minute specks of horse manure, and we not only have a dust problem but also a sanitation and health problem. Where there are horses there is horse manure and when that* are fifty harsea, or no, there In an abundance of horse manure . And, of course, where there is horse manure there are flies, and fifty horses attract a lot of flies . r Page Two September B. 1971 City Ordinance! 4243 . 1h declares It a nuisance to stable core than two horses within 100 feet o: another 's dwelling house. One of the undersigned 's home is less than 100 feet from the stables that have been constructed on the conditional exception property. We have not mentioned the smell and what more can one say than fifty horses generate a lot of smell. We have not delved so far into more technical violations of the ordinance$ such as the non-maintenance of fences and the numerous trespasses that occur as a result therefrom. Nor have we bpoken of the economic drawbacks that we have incurred as a result of this conditional exception (see attached Letter from japan Machin- ery Corp. which speaks for itself) , but we have written from the human aspect. We have a right to enjoy our homes. We are unable to exercise that right fully because of the smell, the dirt, the flies, the manure, the noise and the trespassing of these horses . rt is intereeting to note that the stable is only operating at about 20% of capacity. What will happen when they stable is full? Please, gentlemen and lady, help us . Sincerely, l' Coe 17 A � �a . 1 PLA'�Eti -T HILLE:1 1 (RHODLS) + CYoen A rox. 1---.-� Aprox Ar rox 1 Pero �10; 1 Arra 1 Acro ' 1pro X. C• B . AVRA t 1prcx. 1 Acre to-GCS Ft. RIDING ` - AF2NA �.� I10NS .� STABLE_ PREV!'.L�1�G r� ' T%.ti�rANi M ST. VIVID l STABLE + ME 0 STABLE 0- B.L . GF3IJ M DEVEEMI i ,�. Aprox. BILLS GORDON 2 Acres WI.LLIM IS WRIGUT STIJ3LE S • Ap rox 2 Acres 1.01t GRE::R - 2 Aprox, HMINGION BEACH CD. r CRXSTAI, ST. ALD A. XWTZ, M.D. WTUM L UsawlM¢ Am& vNrwo"90OW nr •rl *00MAL ROAD • SUM 210 �crvroerT wurir, c�irow�„� ririo TVLMPNWW 44&SYSS Be: Mrs . 1103H Vrvra ' I For the +- • M past ..no - three . .r., . Vnvra Q tatee she has been exposed to large amounts of dust; stirred itp i'rorn a horsi corral biiilt naft door by a { neighbor. This troy possibly present a health ha%ard for Xrs . Vavra an sh;i states she coughs excessively and gets choking; spells dun to the pre^enco of dust 1n � her upper air. Fassagcr. t. Sincerely, dr D. A. Klo�-x TiD elm, 1 DAK/gm r 1 1 1 7 ... { 1 Apm Machinery Corpomflon 110bruar'y ! , 1971 Mr. Eiuce L. Greer . 19702 Stewart Street i Huntington Beach , Calif. 92640 + 0*&T Mr. Greer : ?lease be informed we have recently surveyed your Huntington beach property at the corner of Stewart E Ernest , which Japan Machinery Cor? . had proposed to lease to , purchase with anticipated construction of approximately 35 , 000 sq . ft . of warehouse facilities . The proposed improvement was to be utilized .for the purpose of conducting wholesale and retail new machine tool sales for the 11 western States . After visual survey *of said property , we find i,.Sait the location , with the proposed ;Freeway excess , would n et our needs adequately . However , we fur0ler find the adjacent property imaediatelr to Your north being utilized as a horse stable renders vour propert;•• totally undesirable for our needs as stated above , If in the near 'future this situation_ ma,v change with the removal of said undesirable conditions , we would again consider further negotiation; in this matter. Thank you in advance for your ,anticipated understanding . Yours very truly , J(PAN MACHINERY CORP . st ` l obertS . Aersby P esident RSB : eh II 7G15VARCELIF 51F?(SJ, PAAasIQUN�f,CA:.s►'fi�iNlA r,CT2? • IrLtPli&4 PWITIo� TO REXO1M CONDITMIAL aCEPTIOX 70-?J TO COUNC IlM AND CITY ADMINI STP.ATOR: 14e the undersigned property owners adjacent to the BILL "ILLIANS S'TABLESp located at 7021 Ernest St"etsHUntington Poncho California, jointly request that the conditional exception 70.-33 be revoked. The establishment of a large eormeroial borne stable in the midst of our properties creates a nuisance and is very disturbing to all of us, as permitted under the existing zones. Sime the ereatic o of said stable some ten ,,aekths ago, which is now operating aib about 25% of Its intended capa6l.4y of 190 to 200 horses, we demand the revoking action for the foll(mrirg reasons : 1. As tax pnying property owners$ us feel that its should not be forced to subsidize the Bill V-111.inme Stables vb1eh prodmaes little or no tnx aevenun to the city of Huntington Beach ; It has destroyed the value of o%tr property to such an extent that we ►znn not secure proper finnneing, tonants or develope:^a for our property, due to the proximity of the atnblee. 2. It has created a very undesirAble noise, dust, odor and fIT problem for us who Ara residentn in the Frees. 3 It has created a liability and trespassing problem for us as property ownera, and we have fenced and posted our property; both of which have been ignored. 4. This conditional exception 70-33 should nearer have been F anted because as surrounding property owners, we sere against from the plewing stage s,m if not orally, by letters on file. It also does ant meet the requircmnts of Article 983. 9832.19 9832.2 and S• 9832.3• Dated : AWUST , 1971. -07 We e Nam Lr.�.I . ■ ..�.w.wi� ■ � .ram ■ �Q/ i PETITION TO REVOKE CONDITIONAL MCEPTION 70-33 TO OOUNCILMEN AND CITY ADMIFISTRATOR : We the undersigned property owners adjacent to the BILL WILLIAMS STABLES, located at 7021 &nest Stueet ,fiUntington Beach , California , joi:Itly request that the conditional exemption 70-33 be revoked. The establishment of a large commercial horse stable in the midst of our properties crogtes a nuisance and £s very disturbing to all of us , as permitted under the existing zones. Since the croation of said stable some ten months ago, which is now operating ob ntout 25% or its intended capacity of 290 to 200 hormea, we doinand the ravoking action for the following reasons : As Lax paying property owners , we feel that we shoal: not bo forced to subsidize the Bill Williams Stables which producQs little or no tax revenue to the city of Huntington Beach; it has destroyed the valuo of our property to such sn extent that tiro can not secure proper financing , tenants or developers for our property, duo to the proximity of the atables. 2 It has created a very undesirable noise , dust, odor and fiy s � problem for us who are residents in the aroa. 3. It has created a linbilit,; and trespassing problem for as as property owners , and we have fenced and posted our property; both of which have been ignored . 4 . This conditional exception 70-33 should never have boon granted bocauae as surrounding property owners , we were against it from the planning stages ,m if not orally , by letters on file . It also does not most the requirements of Article 983. 9832. 1 , 9832 .2 and S. 9832.3. Dnted : AUGUST , 1971 . - �c �00t, Al I 1 MINUZ;;Cc, Co une 1 1 ('S, .;h:.•r _- �LhtinLtc;n Peuc!:, Callfcrn a Monday, Se pter;be r 21. , 1970 Mayor Shipley called th... regular mectir,6 o � tip City Col�zicil of the cit.. ... of f'Imtingt;on BeILCII to oT-aAl' zt N: 30 P. M. Thu Pledge of A'lc ;J ance eras givcn by e.11 pre t :A in the Co::nr.: '_1 CY.ar.' ROLL CALL )J Councilmen Present: Gibbs , ►,artle u. 'cCrri� -.�:n, ;l'reen, 14at:ney. Ccir,n. Shipley Cotu,.c,:*0•l.mer: Absent: None CITY EMPLOYEES AS50CIJ..TI0715 - MEISORAI-'TA OF uliDERSTA11))1110 Mayor Shipley called on the City Administrator to explain Vie actic--, which he belie w.9 she uld be taren ir, regard to the :.t`ri'02"f.,Un_'.G. of Und.3 standing concerning sa l arJes , f i•inge benefits , etc; 1•etai���': ;.he Ci;f i and the various employee n.ssociations . The City AdminIO ra.tor spoke regarding the I •c\,i.siuns c-:itained in the Netroranda of t ndc rs tend+.nr between the City and the hunting! on ..each. Fire Depaxtm:,It AGsoci.ation, Inc . , the Police Department Ascocin.ion and the Cit.,; Employees A.sociation . A rnoti.on war, made by Councilman Green to adopt those provisions cc tai:nec in the Memoranda of Understanding between :he City and said employee associations , but was wi whdrawn before being voted upon. Following discussion, on motion by Green, Council approved the Memoranda of Understanding between the City and the various emp! ogee: associp ticna . Including the across the hoard three-step salar« increase: and fringe benefits as rec:oranended . Nation c% :-ried . A motion war, made by Councilman Green to approve the MemorandaJ. ' r' Under- standing between the City and the Huntington 3,'Anch Fire Deocr;.m-nt Employes Association, Inc . , end the Huntington Peace: Police A..:vaip*_c-q exclusive of salary increase , and in the event segotiaLions go to tion, all conditions pr•-:viously npproved, wcijl;l bec`nh: void, and i;: accepted, the Septenber 1 , 1970 effective data and the thrce-atop ran;a salary increase hrov i s len wovid remain e:fe c ti✓e . ;Motion carried . CONSENT CALENDAR ( I'IS -3 rIFNOVEb 06 mot: on by Green , Council directed that the item pertaining to the app jintment of a m-,r.be r to the Boar:,' of Appeals be de i'e rred to a later date . Motion carried . COUREI i CALENDAR VIV-I•L.i APPfiO+�ED On moti.,ors by Me.tr ey, the foil.oving consent item were approved r*scou. mendit0 , by, ;olio :ollowiri, rc,11 call vote: 1MMNG - APPEAL - CONWITIQUAL, 'EXCEKIOPI 70-33 - AMOVED , i ��•3yar Shipley w.notuiee thaw this was the day anfA. our scat for a pub Iic heari;ig on an appeal filed by Mr. Bruce Green to the grant ing by the Planning Covmis:,ion of Conditional Exception No. 70•-33, to permit riding stables and associated uses to be located north of Ernest Avenue# approx matel;: 320 fret east of the centerline of aoldenwes t Street in the Ml-G Wight Industrial Dintrict, combined with oil production . The Clark infonted Council that all legal r•equi:rame.^ts for publication,, notification and posting had been met and that he had received no commmicat#i.ons or written protests to Conditional E-Oxception 70-33 or to the recomsendation of approval of the Manning Commiasion other than the letter of appeal. Mr. George Shibaua, Attorney, representing the appellant, addressed Council. and stated why he believed approval of said Conditional Exception xas not warranted. Mr. Bruce Careen, lf?92 Stewart, City, r.d,joining property owner, addressed Council and stated thr.t he believed the presence of riding stable€ on this property was detrimental to the surrounding arcs., and that the ; conditions stipulated by the Planning Commission were too varple to be effective . 3 Mr. Fred Tallman, 9452 Velardo Drives City, addressed Council and ro- � quested denial of Conditional. Exception No . 70•-33" Mr. Bill Williams , i0079 San Pablo Court , Fountain Valley, applicant, infot;ned Council of his propcscd plans for . the riding stablet; , an states: 1.hat prcc :utions :�ri.11 be taker to insure that the horses, cannot roam out:;ide the area, and rhs.t adequate fly control and sanitation measures will be provided . Councilmai, Coon stated that he did not feel Mhat proof of hr.rJjhiO had been demonstrated by 1.-2:e applicants , and d iscuss i LNn 1tia.- t.t ld by Council regarding the validity o f the hardship Issue . Mr. !pert Beck; representative of the Orange County licalth DerA-.rtre_,11t, stated that fly and sanitation proclem3 can On effectively ccntrolledj and that he has provided the: applicants with the Couvnty ordinances re- lating to same. Councilman Platney requested that the Attorney inves Lige.te the standard3 set forth by the County Health Je ca rtmznt for fly abntcsnc:n t and sani- tation, for possible adoption: by the City. Mr. A . C. Marion, resident, addressed Council , and stated that he !It the riding stables would be an asset to 4h` area. Air. Bob Johnson, 10007 Sparrow Avenue, Fountain Valley, co-developer of the property, addressed Council and gave r.:-asons why he believed that the Planning Commission 's approval of Conditional Exception No. 70-33 was .4ustified . There being no one further present to speak on the mat:ter•, and there Bing no further protests f.Lied, either oral or wri t;:Ln, she hearing alas closed by the Mayor. On spoon' k Or-on, Council suctelned the df.-Osion of the P nning ass► os3.on and"�Approved Condi;.iorr;il i.xceA�i`or: �'o . 70-33 , stiPulating thaw •uch Property shall L•,L terminate in f1ve; years , or utpon '.violation arty Cov y ord• or r ul + Notion 0 Publish �- "UC HEWNG SET pros to ards FOR: /....: .-.�-+ ----3-3 WTICY OF PUBLIC WRING 1 NOTICE IS HERESY GIVEN that a public hearing will bt held by the 1 CityCouncil of the City of Huntington beach, 1 , Huntington beach, at the hour of P.M. , or s moo.,. thereafter as possible, on the da• of , 1 , for the purpOGS of rom ideering g potitioo for ss+�oostl'm of asmutsooal 1x0*tiaa 70•33. pmteri 1970l peritting rldilog stables nd moo l,atid U&wg on Vzope ttp Joeated north of trrw�t wse t bpnxiaea►uly 320 ftet 000t of the omta+rliaa Of 80tjWN I t Sts+Mt ' i ja the Zito LL&bt Zndwkwial blatristo soabised rdth oil pwintlaos r i i t All interested persons are invited to attend said hearing and exp vsa their opinions for or against maid . Turtber information stay be obtained from the Office of the City fi Murk• 1 f1ATW: AWL CITY OF. HUNZ INrr'M ABAC11 h: city C1,e�s1OW tY a 1FAW A w is +, swa*er 29, 1971 City Council Huntington Beach, California RE: Bill Williams Stables Dear Sirs: I Would like to preface this letter by saying that as a boarder tit Bill Williams Stables I do have a vested interest in its continued operation. Also that I am sending the Williams a copy of thi: letter but am writing it without their prior knowledge or consent . First, I would like to connent on the character of the Williams family and the manner in which they have run their business and halve conscientiously tried to meet the complaints of the few surrounding neighbors. I have been a boarder at the stables since March 1971 . Ourinq that time I have repeatedly witnessed an attitude of "le:'s do more than is requited of us , regardless of cost" to win the acceptance of the neighborhood. As examples of this I cite the following actions : After objections were raised about riders on the property across the street from the stables Mr. Williams has been diligent ahout keeping not only his own boarders but horsemen from the surrounding stables off this property. There have never been any "wild" doss at the stables. However, In an effort to please the neighbors the Williams have found a new home for one of their dons, Keep their remaining animal tied, and require all boarders to keep their dnns an leashes while at the stable. Although the fly inspector has repeatedly assured the Williams that there are no flies breedinq on their property, they purchased costly chemicals and spray enuipment to kill flies on thc. ore+nisr.s . Fly bait has also been placed in all stalls and arnund the stable area. When the problem of standing water in the wash area arose the Wslliams had a cesseool installed, again at considerable cost, although the inspectors had only suggested, not required, them to do so. On the matter of dust bothering residents of the area (a fact which is open to debate cone. iderinq the prevailing wind conditions and the results of tests conducted by your own police department) i I chn only say Rr. Williams has been more than conscientious and de r , �i..rir.. s ; ,i 11y,s:�J 4Y'i✓�, ,. ,_.i• tii i'.. .,t s - e . 7 W. C. *rrrare 4 concerned, -for the last, tyre months, in addition to claffhq the arena on windy days, he has contirously soaked the area with water to a point that at least 60% of it is always under water and unusable to riders. '►'he remaining 40% is always wet and slippery. Needless to say, relativa.ly little riding hos been done in the arena for safety reasons , Ca;aing considerable Inconvience to boarders at times . I know that future plans for the arena call for complete sanding and the installation of a sprinkling system - the pipes for which are already cut and laid in the arena awaiting time to install them. It is also a standing stable rule that horses must be walked in the stable area , Recently Mr. Williams graveled and oiled the parking area to eliminate dust caused by cars entering and leaving the stables. As for noise generated by the stable I do not helieve, considering the area and surrounding land uses , that the horses are creatinn a public nuisance, I have been at the stable late at ninht on four occasions . I have never heard any prolonged noise from the horses. I have heard traffic noise from Goldenwest, oil dereks pumpinn, neighbors dogs barking, and large trucks entering and leaving the nearby truck yard. The Williams accept this noise as part of the price they must ray for choosing to live in this type neighborhood as opposed ` r o the standard residential conwnunit . Finally, throughout an almost daily harassment, the Williams family has refrained from any form of counter complaint or even verbal confrontation with the neighhors , Mr. Williams has also asked his boarders to follow this policy. this restraint is can nenrable considering the actions , outright lies , and verhal attacks some of these neighbors have resorted to in an effort to dislodge the Williams from their home and business. In all I only wish the neighbors arouna my residence were as friendly and as thoughtful of others as the Williams have been. I consider it a privilene for myself and my children to know and associate with them. In closing I would like to put forward a few thoughts for your consideration. As horsemen we do constitute a minority of the general population. flowever, I question whether we are any more a minority than golfers, mini bike enthusiasts, or surfers. Yet cities repeatedly provide and maintain facilities for these other sports , often with the tax funds of the malority population. I feel that now you have the ideal opportunity of providinq recreation for horsemen in an area where our sport cannot possibly offend the majority of other residents of Huntington Beach and ,vaa can do so without spending any city funds. I only hope that you do not let the unfounded complaints and harassment of a few families (primarily two) cause you to overlook the recreational needs - of many residents of Huntington Beach and the surrounding communities. Sipeer ly, ht�•v Mrs . David Marti n 13332 Barney Street Mei�brirnter, „Ch11i'rrtnla . ,t vjL��.i 4F 'R '.1''j I'45� �1 r, ^i�t•�'��• r �4c— � f ••< t • 1 . l v 01 SLs •�� J t7/ < ' a ,a+ of t STATE ,. 1 / .. I ' I,,+✓+` � wZ•� ^��r': COUTW V 0 1 0 0.Zi.'.10- t 1 K. MACH cI :'i: . •�; .,• ; . .. +• ;.-, �: . :�: .:� _ _ ,.,: a2:r;l-�r;? cif .;�.e,:�riti«. or Ofell 'I�.�_:.i: :iecorur" and 7 ;�<. ,L F .l� �. � .', �•r- ;': �.+, i=1� 3 .ltntile and i:;i2 .. �. '.r•. .`....':�:. '; . .• _ j.C: ., '_:�' , `. .._ ' _ .':;;'L . !'^na�..S,•tCP.i: 321:; or 2, �,.. ' f -?:a� •,'. '. r'•�: . � _ .• :: ,r. :•. : � : ' :1;2_ �:z: i?:i.ec, rro�-s.::{n� it OA V. <• li•�tj.r: thin 1 i -' �Jt fl� .^! r400� dog _ �>.00j L Y , MEMO= 1 I,� 1 At. I • J'�� r,� `��,`4 ;y K>. �f<i'{ i +.,.�, h + # i ' l{tiff y.�+' i i ,, N � . f„ �i�{ 2!�<ci �1 i.,� '1` � ^; J'� '1,' ' �r����`'u�6���a Il ,t.� •'� ,:� vc�, .A.-4�v�1 •�� �, Y�R:y��%YJ���:i. 1 �r i � r. r. S t r !� I 5 ;.� 'T1 +t.l•� I .r_,� a1'��, �rj•. � 3. ••v r .C,�d-+ � �}�` t fA~ t l' :,(e.l �1 tl r'. ,E �. �� +1 �[+ �,, aim �•1,<S +y� {7 `C. +4•r,S�• <�{t'��'� a , '�'•!�..t. „`nr ad4� �T� A .. ��.! ,. y J��f�t� �N, R � 1 t/ �l �I i .'w ��I, �j ;ri .Y.i ,f�+fn]i J .+. ` L' r.r � r� '!:�' .. �. :. P,j�' <_.,.I . ••1. r r. . r�.< �� Ott i+5 i . ).. I•.�y . �p f `�•4'.• ib,'�'�y� i•;'t ♦ Y { 1 S +y tt'. •F.15f..J.il.• r.,' :. r.r n 7.. r". .k.j �� tr ' r �k 4P �/��• f F�4 f' �., � �t� �' +~1 sj '• �. _.1'�:i' { %l:� '�v af:�.�A A"."< d •.� i? t� �> .r•1 �i <.i !iI i ,. '4 •RS'a{r .ie. ;:•�} •.,1" t 1n2,� a .'fit•, •_ _ �tLt' ». ±"CL' }3 � i`:k9.�C.i'i�a�. tlb!a;. ��frl"t{L�iltl6:r+'+d�rtlr°x,{t. :a.��.f�v;1CSCr•.YI 1 -. iJ J.,�! �jy .�`•\� `' �L�u.'t;� ..t5•f ., - Al ? .....;aidJ/�i:C S.c.,., '.i .- V•'Yi .i..•:�iSr�+;_ "4:i'Y t 4 ►�Lt .�:. • t �i d t �`� ,.!� 'R• ' t ��, . � �;°Y t�tY :. �� 1� '.. l,.Y'�. �E. � �t; ", it r`�• '4, ': f ,� ' !. r. .a i r F� �� I /ty -,.�..1i , ' i l�t i��,�i �,►t'" 3���`^t•'.r�.�,," -,� � ,.� 'r ��yt� .•;a'� � ',:'� :�,'�' •.i • +�.� c wr, �. -x . n�u.l' ,�5+'% iy"•�n' ` . 7S 1 r , t � l�Ffi��.'. 1 �..< iy:, ' �.� ,:fit. �� ::: � ,: •.r �✓.... .a .�. t '� ��:.,�. +,rv� ` V�e+ tt tl� �: =� � s'w �a ,}.;:4., �. �:' -..4 a�.+'•�1' c ,,,�� ^T`, ♦tea( f .t:, + .tf '�' F •.'�t rA .,;j"' { '�k�:���'h r S r� r+ • 1 "'''`IFS (4. r i t IJIC J //1 Aid ta JLL IF -Ufl AL Adz V,z eAl r / ^ t Y��fi��...�•�rrrw.r.. ' 1 r MI►+�.+w■+ram ,. ' ...w...i.lyl •t°Fi J YN-s�'11wNi% • 'Z-.Y- �V. •j r i, r r•, ram ¢ �{f , . �} �i7' ;,* �'r 1. •♦S it�,L r �- < i ;v��`��.y+;,''��c �,; �x�l•;j.oy'.� `i mull �QL�� z d�A — Ad:;:2 W. owzgd A;� od#A gi ..4� .. low WAIN&1D •-•r• -W OWN - - - =Eam + i'j ,�/,,�, a i r) ♦1t,1 it gTATE W GALITOMIZA) + } COUIITY OF ORANGE � I TO t TIM CITY OF A11N1'I?i OT011 BEACE ! AND ; TO WHOM ZT MAY C011Cr 1 { Wol tho undorniCned, boina duly qualified„ der*sed and over tho ago or 18 yoarog horoby roprosent ourselves as boina 3.n nood and favor of rotainine the prosont locations of � a •,lei THE BILL IMALIAld S .STABLE• mho duality of maintananco, high standard of ol�li•• newt aad tho conduct of oach omployoo, somber or partner ongaCed in thin Wainans) or th000 using the facilities of . L THE DILL j71LUMS STABLF, io of tho most enUent docorva and } i therefore to bo abovo roprouch and condemnation• s Via do horoby stato and doclare that this Stable sad tho location thoroof to bo a hoot necessary requirement mad oatabliehnent# beinC du:V approciatod and on©ontial to t�w needs and x7olfare itf tho undo.niCned and our fanilisel ' providue A Cood clean t7hoa000mo atmoophero for our Young poop is, Md*V proper ar.,•:4 conocionce uuporviaion uhilo at tho BIM JAW I STA XD locatod at 7021 most Ave.g Huntington Beach, Cilit'. ,R .•fit , + ' patod thin 18tb da Qf Sontetsber- 1q7L ny 00 .. r k f� •'iY i 1 �f{ t..,,' � , If .,�=A,�-r , 't rri 1 r ,;'DL ;4' t ..XL� : f�jti � r +F• ! > e L•P ;;. . , ,:, f:,;; ' ; +fit ��#� t .'-,•�•x '*� t j � . 4i ' ,• r . ILK + .�. (►�Ar ;,; ATTOU Aflil) ir!rxtiT13 t"sTXr." Poll ,rMat 1 l � •� 'Ole 'J 7 y2 u w / 7,S; f 1Ica,-�, d OW WAP ka r� l i I ! r� j, ow { t t 1 �. 77 ; 1 . rik& STATE OF CALIFOP IA) f COUIMY OF ORANGE � ►^0: THE CTTY OF 2EACit , AND r� -- 1,0 111n:�!• ltl Z' ! " n f�rtrs�T i,'.` , :}1',' :1. •(,•,1. r ��.: .".� , :i� : :2� c�L'� '� 7'.IaY�rl�'!�, dt?ros0d '::::, OVC: .i�' :1 "(- •i:"�• •�, :1 L UUT'GCZ'If?:3 ,ar> i b''1:1�; � :1 ':'�!` i : . :'): ) ; .•� `_;, .:i ' !:l 11 10C:1t4on of '�'�:,- ;:a� i. it•• 7: :' ,;•, ; ,.• ,,;..,,;,�,, , + ;�: :,' •i:z:inr:! �f r.1.c.a.T21�.- , ::•�: ,:�, �::' �tir�l ::: .??�: '. ?. " ,•�'',' •�r r�nr_lber n2• p.nrtner ' I1 ',,-c _n t.1:i nti;.. ;..'�.... , :• �:_`::,. ar:,._::ti ` il�` racilztiov of , i r orinent at.^arum mntj ' r �Jvo—I CA'c:L:1n:.�Or:• i ;'c t:�.1'(,.,� 'ia _',e•. _a:•c thzt a.tle 3lllt� ' t1:^ 1t7�"1i10:. '. .:'::'i'"` . �:� .:1 �:'` ..�, r:,E�'i2'f 1•�:C1',!j-r'C�1Cat rind ',^ .-' .:? �::.�:.. '�, _ �,- ?':? ;- ,?'2• . _ _ c r• . ;,� -3ntia1. t'o t;le ne,?dq ;i•/`1 . .•i �'_?i•1` 1 .:' t'.. �.^.'�.iri -:iE'. . �.'. : :)'.!�• .•'...1 �j(:f.�, prJ}r.Ldin COO i n�•; ?.-,� , ;1' at:-,,.'•_�::r,..,, 011- �.�.,.,r• noor1 C, under _ . c� �t ._ �T- .. .. � .,•r :-u:���'�•�.,:.c .. e -34, `.:hc nTT..L 71ILLTANS 1 a _ A B1,:;, ?'�C^.: i : ' ..!� , _', :r':-� 'tti ^. , 1I;, n f -t i Bemich,, Calif. t Uated this 131'.1 of -Septeamber, 1971 t; •r' i� BY•J.1 "i a_aD B e% CG 'In 1� y..,��d.� �r' drySr.:• 'ram''^ � �i�l �> •' �t i � r .; y � �Y F z} e� r, ` 1 r• t r �1 ,yti y{t y.s /�s Y „� t1 • r fs � �t� :5�'t �.��y a/,`{/.Y ii, • :Litt � a� }. I ,.`,.. r ` ` • ,. ' ' ��QO�tftttt.�d� , -�, 1 ' `r! .;C{aJ 1�< * `,�y, ��" '� a d'/ �;i ' 7.� td t 7 w `,4j` 'i �C 7 '`. I.�t�.'� 1 a9'�! 1 .�,• 111 't;• _ .. .} 1- t 7 .i�t 1!r r �t•r t(;r..l.�. it1�1 t !. ro c to c, lad 1.11 4.4 44 dF 'N9• QS- , k fir'*' [.k 1 �.!',Y i I t 1 4 k • -- t 1 t� A 1 1 i k i Ire , ( 1 •r! r ii ► Z? A, ! t At L.L! Jr low Y f - 411 A . • , '' .1f, 1� , `- -- .bob ._ � ._- .,. -sue �•a--�1i.1 ��. ��.•iv{ii\a Wfl���.: �+�� ti � �'yP'��+,'!�1 � ,;�1 •r.�r�I ,a�rr� . �4-�� �.:- S;:t «:�'t� 'Y! N,�+ �. K, '' +fir ��I �iMy►ti;����, 1 • r• / 11 j(elzoo' Aa r .� ZY, —�J '�• •i.. JK tr4-<.L�_.14 . . STY , ' wwrA i �, --- . . t ..�.�....4'..a`.�.�,^� -- %-s ��;`,.` 'S �,. ,�fir? ► � 11 ����...�.....� Ly Ir 44 low_ l� t �1~ ��! . 1l� •:\� - 1 i 1. .� �11'�,a'_�� � �� h � �\ 1�. f1 � wws..a'iM i ■r u. r.■�w�r t .r.r........ ' 3- 3 xfiegw �g L- a- o ,�!"i.�„' Tf:!'.' ��:�t7��!.rai�7rr.:�►��.r,',ij"`.T,!,'s �:".. ,- �.,.�..r: -. .•. ,��� .. - r .. ... . .. . ._ ,. . _ u In P .mot Lt A c--Ya►1e�Vic __ . • ririii.� +i■�a�.■.n�■w■.■�■r_ r+■ ■ •..■iq..r.�r����■i■rr_..wr ...�.++...�.�..r.��rw��li f i! if �-.��y�w��f.�i�.■ �rr.r r l^� �4 L'��irl-� �1 � ��_3i.rw��.�+iir i t l `1�17 r_ ��i f�.. r' \t a • ) ..r...+�w.�.�. ...........r...-.-.-- - - , 1 r ��..�air 'r - - '/..ur���. w�+.r.r���r..�..M■�r.�r++ r��M■�.�+i�•� i+■.���. ! r , Ir 1`t b, leeda ' 7 f �j • i 0.0 Ct • - L • �;:.�l.y .. .F:i .,':�. .,. .... ... .. :. l:lwt .....niy'Y...r�'.we...'.;�:.+'.•s.�,5•�T-.Si1•.�.a e! ."St'�'" s ` I t r r �11, , •' r r J ii°�rrT rM�i `�y '�'r t,V'^ir'f�i �ti 71,'i'Jtb .t it 201 "M CM Oro'xrINGT N MA= 1. AND } TC "::N IT MAY CONCMM i i No# tho underailMed, bong duly quue2=od d i e1 is"-I and over tho age of 18 yoara, hereby roprement ",;w*3,ww ee being in noo4 and favor of rot ining the "ant ]rooatieat of TEE BILL SMIXAMS STA.MX The quality of mad ntenanco# high standird of clesnUo ; noes, and tho conduct. of oach amploye®a member or pavrtaer or.;aged in thin businoao, or those using the facilities of TIM BIU ITILLIA14S STABLE in of tho noot audnent decoren m— d thoratoro to bo abova ropro:ach and cond&umatlone Wo do horoby atato and declare that this Stable OW the location thoroof to bo a zwot noceaaa:7 requizvomt =W entabli.ahmont, being duly approciated and amentW to the needs and velfare of the undersigned and our la mill eag pirOV16 ► img a gaod cloran wbolesona atmosphere for our young VO&p►1ei _ under proper and conecionce supervinfon rile at 20 W& i LIM ATE, located at 7021 Zment ♦arse , *=Ungtolft Dewhe CAltferniae i i a ► f 19?1 i low iL i r 3 * r .%.r st 't'ltl r •t f rt} ,',4 .c ,i • F: = .i '.'�v tr; ,.t.:` _'i''.�%.+ i`. St r '.r .'T1 ',:,". . .r =,r�S ` t �.�-- 0 .! t��! .4 v r.c. _•f. ..�i. ,iiJa ' 4'f t.1,•.^ �;.kr r `'�l,-T. ., ^ . . • 'L� r �, ( h; {{ .t '1. xt r � r4;Fww;I ii4. k' An UTFS Mai IM PW 4w, _ IBM P_4 ,► r .► ' ' r ` �' ``` ,: Js .+' . Rt,sr.;_� 7� S .. it•j i. w • -r4LJ��' � a �'' f�ti '{ i�,ir`" ;ice f+`,�i'�t'it 1 lrj-,""-RATX OF -M OMA) t {��,�L. ; ~} t.;• r,p t t �r ' �r Coul-ra of OnAt•ILM ) ', 1 t t t TO s THE CITY OF EMIT3 t=011 BRACE t • A?TD TO t'l 01-1 IT MAY CONCEMI 4 Woo tho undoroiGned, being duly qualified$ deed and over tho aGo of 18 yoaral haroby roproaont ourselves or , boiina in nood and favor of retaining tho pr000nt locatim of TIM BILL WILLIAMS STAULF.. ' The quality of maintonancel high atandard of clwtUow nana, and tho conduct, of each adployoe, rambor or partner onCaGod in thin buoinoanj or tho©s uainC the facilitioo of Tin'. BILL VILLIMIS STA13M is of th© moat eninont docor= and ' { thoroforo to bo abovo ,roproach and oondcanation. Via do horoby atato and declare that thin Stable and the location thereof to bo a toot•, nocesoary roquireaont and � eatabliahuont, bairC duly appreciated and oosential to tho nords and woltaro oS tho undorniTiod and our familioo' nrovidinr, a i Lro9d clown ;.hol000mo, atmoophoro for our young peoprlol under proper and conscionco ouporvision whilo at the BILL raLUMM a ABLE.g locatod riff 7021 Moat lwo. , MMUngton Beiach# Cd14 to r 'H tod thiz U ag S21AMbe r r 1 M � . j+ ! tri 1 i r Ft t '�,�►r(r .. j}` rt � G -C e "1 b .rF i�! .rn. 1 i � •s. t : '.Lr �i..ar li k! * i _'` `J;7�� �1• 'F t r. d :t- ' ! . - ��� ,,, t n it . til . .t4t�i . '{ ��o ., , X. ^;t' t ..; �t k.�. :y, i i - ' • �'��!'i,��,•y y • ������� t A`Jr�i �� �r,•yi ft'ky�k�',1 ' ."! . .. ..r.r*.�:} � i. ' r' ,r t r. yr,�•'if,'�i1ZTd�� f 'Lii'.._... i - _ _,,, _ .T^._{u_ - _ y.. —�1n,L `tt �.«t, � • 11 i I •• �' r • t �• A • * . VIA ORP RE?w r .• � n) r , •♦ / ice% Ii I�/� fi ♦Wwo lj r/ 4 mw All /; or �, .. . , .♦ UA po der i aMANEW CPIWIO �� /for f W, 3 r It a � .. ,� f 1 L l tIL t �d k7f r tl V•tt-tr�..,t 7i? 1, rlx�r�•. i'V �Y'y,, `�'�rt!It; •,tAa {'� ie;�, Rq �� r r Y` ���1�.1 •� M t r ?� t� �,.`�.t � f �� � � tr �.t�'�)i K+ ��� A� f � •' �i � .-� , •Ix j / Y- r ',t � •{.� � ,' +` f�� �,� stir . rftr f. - r yam. !e. f {• .� at. S f i 1 COUNTY Or ORANGE, ) � rA ; ' TO: 'Ill CITY Or Mill"I1ICTON BEACH 1 1 u Ou y cjua if'a T, Clepo:30di ' V� " o '_.�n ';,•;L. 1i,,»•_.tiJ' 2'Q1)'•C�Ca� O'.1�6�35S 'Cr I� �" r J � Y• Ib� � �� � 1 ' ``'i -61U .i:i :.�•i.' .. •�...� 1 .�,'r ., �1_ _ 1. 1+:1 iiV 1r11n � l-e-0401 t location Of { 1 1 o cicar•Zi- y :.:,mb,:r or partner _�'.lcilltclen Of ry• „ 7' r •T— * t •� '1 ,—,T -, � 1 . �r•r. � ' . '3C1�01•L1I'1 and .. .,.. _ . �Y. _ _ r.:• .. .�� .. •� �-�... ...1'.�. - _ _ .. + ... .. .. _ter � and t t;h^''• c•1:. : :• _ ;1_ ( i .' i_.'. _ ! .. . .. ;t:,,.' Our f-i-nilics, provi dy. _Itr- � •.- 7_. .. :. � '11 r:l:'.)� ..',l:�i. �:� �,:...i;i:;•.':.'l: rnl' �..�' �'G1.1I1;; p�:n?Jlei ! BILL ,� LLI�:.� LJ: ::�I,:: ? v .-,�; r•.:' .,t r,r�^ .-- rl�_,t Ave. , .Tuntin�ton lie n C A, Call L tI1 d Dated t?i:.c 1r3a•_of- t'�.g bor. I Jt it 4 ..... � .. ,.._ �If�'.;=:EiI� .l...-t.' u,+.ri�.[•ci- .c_ -.,fit, I .d i4•. IT"�.i}� 9 4 }r . ..� �4 r� i�,}11 k { 'ql... r � '�� s A •�j,;! � + r`''.i c�'•t..�,• tr+ .s '.bt1i r 1t��•' iy �i ,j� + 1T . tb.,: d3<•,� JA� rOf CA M�{.� / s r - r ', ,j L• I •+ y iJ�t A�`t;r i,. ., 'f,L �3� ���n<`�. t`.: � l ° '1 t{ I tl,ltl"!} f� ��11,'•�. 1 COU rtTY 0r. ORA:i Gr'-' ) �: _ TO: :I CT'r'� OF I_"J:i�!`Iit.rr'"i'l":� 13'a�;rl: + ' i '1t`1' 1: �C a�l:l.•.,,�{ `�:- C.`..i� t�� i.:.0 0.112J C•ii- i.r;L :�Q�IOGCi.{ � 1 Z tr'r. ^.^..i::it Qtir-.Q.IVr:G i1G I 4J(: a + t cat-on i ►�� ly t.l.i, :.•1:. .'. .l.��j. a da1d O1 ��.^.a::� i i a31Cj l:li:t wIi er } lej.a 1.� 1. V v iJ.-. ...� ...• • •. • - ,. � � � y t r �r I'1liL L�} iaL 1 . if�IJI.i.1i.:w rni.::T -. ,^r •, � C,i. '�L �7r`. 1 � '-.n�:c•a / ��'� + ��i�.n�.L�'ir1►on K' ff�� r1 ��\\ fyt4 :..t.evh, cal.-* _. Ui�•1.►�• i 11 1 i f Dated +'aic I t1i [1py of BY ADDRaS r - •';:•+,':•:*� .: ,� __�.� r L � �. _;. . .< ..+:.• .. l 1..�._..�s I�� !•r�t �.`m'l riEr � �.�f'si 3 im _ - k —— 1 �., t l � sag& k 66" 57 Ccoc/cv<lt:?�' W" dig A 1� I"Wa -m JMA- glow /-110AIr /Orp peal& .Af / bog a GdM MINNOW pop doli � I r aS 'F+ i } �i``.•' rS. r...i...�w�. ,_,+ ....,� crD#k .����� ! y✓ aft{ ` + .. ' �� [�- r �. iq a l mnr Or oAA = � ( TOt CITT OF FUNTINNOX UACH AND TO Ow IT KAT COnam • 1 7 J we, the uuadersigned, being duly qualitivAq delo"do sad av ar the age Of 1$ years, hereby repree sut oat"01TOS sa F being In need and favor of rotmining the present lrocatiox of � { M B= WILLIAMS STABLE. The quality of masntenanco, high standard of 01"0114* j nesse and this conduct of each employee) nmbw or partner szgagad in this buineact or thone using the facilities Of THE BILL ITMIM; STA is of the most eminent decorum sad therefore to be above reproach and con eanatiorw Wo do horoby atato and declare that this Stable and the location thereof to bo a moat neceaoary "RuirsEMt and o©tabliahment, being duly appreciated and essential to the needs and wolfare of the undorui=od and our familieSp PMT1dij II a pod clown wholeoomo atmosphere for our yoaag peoller U"w proper acid conesionce supervision while at the N11 Stable, located at 7021 Ernest Ave.$ MtntiASUx le W14 C&WO 16 X�/—dd&iA dr I r f I , ' .�•. ,1st"'�"`�� ,, 4 ,,'�• `, . $:" iIti.x �t�ct �,.,l!tii k �,r> �3,�" ,t. '}R� at„,ti. - y.� ��� t it„ ,K� .`t3+4,�� ��d,�,■ 1 ,�.1� #. • 3" .•;v 't r ,i., tYi,y :. �.;'i'1r� ieTo'!x•'ir`,rt t..iwy '.:+5'd. . xS i' cj;• ii {.r 7�� ♦{ i; "�� . �M ;F ,•4`.r,�►.�'..," . s s '�.. .. .-r�,� .+ •'� .:', ...+3 �'.� � s :tt w, ; Lli 4` �' ti ::q r C '• �'•.Z; '�j.,� �;=y?+:r� r-j�t�oj7,j�.,:«�"� � G� , '�� t"a'"`.:;'��rf�,i''.�w"�r� ' } l•1� Y'• '"� + ,' �fi�;;f.w�` r�, �� .r. nt. � �.,#�� ������►+1i•�u";i�, r�rti.',11`!t z 4 I - +S ` Y,�+'+•�� ..rcy� 3c a• 'x'. ._», ^ � 'r.i r �? s r. • .nww► w.r awt.r..w� .ty I ,w :1 f Si�sra r��lr l�7� ni'•..y r,':, Yr K..Ir r f'�i7 ys •i e��J�� . r } L i f�. �'l� � :ar x S -.f 1, , •c• !; .t ,, ! r`.a. y t�, •f 1�4. •,�i' •+ 'r S� •"iM ' � i 7 ,, , ' .`f', , _ `- It r,.��. v. } ti J oI Ta C"T or mrr�smir BLUM a; i r t L, Plo, tho undurois bo3tir du3,7gten,l,ltlad# d�taL� �� lrt i'1dt t t and ewe► tho aco of 28 yowet hweby z►eproo«at oarraol beinc in hood and favor Of rotalatne. the praire�t ME MM lY=AMSj ZTAULZO 2ho 7u&Uty of as intowwcog biGh stmward of clso a&. Ducat ozd tbo conduct of oach arplopoo, smbw or pwtuw r Onmvd in tldm buzinoaol or tbono uniuC the faca itioe of TW: MU VIUa&'Z STAMX iu of the mat emlawt doowm as ft. thoroforo to bo above reproach Aud coudowittion• :?o coo hor ab•} atato =d docUm that thic Stabto =4 tho lrocAtion thmwoof to be a :mot nocoa&W roquiramt sm4 Ou U-ohment« balm duly qppm.cWtod fmd on aatla'I. to tU noo& and iel faro of tho uaderadCnod apd our famMms jmvlAbw iaC a Clow aboleomo &txa o for au ymns moo• under ptOpar am COM010mr, a� s �awr��aa obthr a�el C r STAMM011 Wcated arty ?021 Entat Av%j NRt*j;4" s` •t � Lk'µ Y 4 AL M' rSit -: 1 V 7 t Jt • }e1►^.!t •I t ,. � � �, J,a' . ` "` :1•. ` -^a'1 iS�s' '' �� :�.� G• 4=".' ,' q ` r ��z rY }��` �'+, r.i .- ( i 1 � �.-t r ti�i. y�.�;+n*� ..� e;}.� " . .� �sr l r',.; s` x ,�� e` p 1 .. z� i` • [.?� � f Y •.�.�'•�/ ':1,i,5!��,''t tf � ��+v :Air ��,1 Jy Ci'� r a r •..y�� 1 1 'T� 't... >x T-i 'S,T,;1 ` jrl .is _�.�_�"d...L:'r�,r � � �s f '�.�n .. S��, r. ;' t ♦.. } 4 . .:�'� z:_xS++`��.1' !.� r u� "�P�G� ' '�ir�t3sa�•�4r.iRL�®. •rp! i L tr '_i i x �v z �r #! K L �:.�p I+rq•.tm .Tr. r r / 4- 0 YXQ QM r � lop) 101 OL bc, r- Ll -.)r 0 v _ 1 I ' r l 1 �f . •). yVG- A.,I „y'�„ �^' ' ' ► w►...riw I�.wr�i�r....��rw�+.�..w�� i.qr�rw.w.�.►. - i I LY --Z O r kid I a N A. - him-, -S), eA e- A'd P- - r /V T :2 ell ` 1 t . -. i ;.,,•yam r. I. i • i` .:. .N u t .�'�'1'71! � 'fir_ �.;h .'f 4�?J�+�i.`� .. . . _ �� .?w►�!:�e .. lts�•x.i_'� 'I rJ L^�.__,. �. y� y J.,� •ti.- 4�Ci. rz mono Pi of • `� ` , � ;/err 1 . 1�w its �:• ,� .� r � 1 •r M � f r.»m =Now r1rOn - t "so y 1 t ? _. trrAVAIPWNow am"Noft"W - f '• •rj� �' ' '' s t 77 del Ilsom 77- PIE lop- "MY I di ,IV • U � �'' ' � " ...L'7, 7)"T ......r I— oll- T, (% ` .� ' u i • �• i f+{ y,, . F 11♦ 1�' rJJ V• �J ,. S"t�i'�'s��V''�i� S•i. � ii,•.� T �, �.. - 4N: :.4`: ?„ ,t ..*i-r1 i+ 1 ( y i'rh a �.`�NSj,Tjy \5•, {� L�;� .ij' �, y �' , Ti` yf' '!r/ rr i f ,tt/a3•t� ri� '(: �r1►1 �• i; u I •'Ir' }-!- ��� r. + ,• a (1! / ♦ �J , ,; � ; i•,,;,#� ��i,] ♦�4 •-,F'�+, ti 1 ;%� f dry u> . � '� 1 , :t , ,.:�,� r , �)��. �c`!r!t. r �t�,,t��:����;r ;� r, f �/♦_;a" !?t.ie�t1 � J 1 ,�.i +'' ,�� rt (t-s ' ,� ...f J, -.j, fly,, ! ' I r ! hr ���'', 74'I" t t�,!��;; K jt- j �I II � { ♦ f • n 1 � ref {��Il �!�•ltNi /,t ' ail�"! �r�l�t r''t' S ,' I r'r �•, , fa .;r ' 'i �� i r � I i �1 ra �-E• -i � ft.� r 'P.: f. '4•�� :, .'ill t ,t, y• : t, i• ! ( '.s,l. �, h § �•+��r 1� ,A3�'A 'r� �}�����++"k�� �'TM,),fY���• F�'•�.Sftrt�lrilJ •', I�~1 S kl F'/i,��rjb F �.� •� r�' i. '� 1�, , r�' •.A t i' '• ( '���V I', I , 1 � ',1� • T 1., r p, i",I' s .r' t 1 f I i 1 , 1' ' ••' 1 Ills�A '�r1.J ♦ I;J , ,t`'f S ' '• .1 e'• r ,i� �. 1 •} coin Mr ORAME i' • �i.' i rYd'�� .-1 , r. ,r, , t � ' • c�rrx oir.,,�OTON DUCE 'TO 1'IIE To WWK IT HAT colic= Well the lmdereigmedg , bed gwlifiey� ileporid 1 be o! 1C� years here1W rep of ouree,lmm 'an ,. its need �tr►d �atvar o! retai6 the present, location at ? ;I J '�'TiE BYLL rlI=AMS STASGE• ' Tho quality of mainten maeft ' high ntaur3ard of 'a1w�13� y , • �soc�o and tho conalla t of each aa�plo�res�, raaa�bor or par" on a�od in f;hia buaineaog or those using the fated itie+m T BILL rlILLIAMS STltI3LT: iv of the moat eminant doco� MA 1 -a :�?.;t• thoxoforo to ba abova reproach and oondamnationo Via do horoby etato and dealor� that this Stable said •� tho location theroof to La a Don t POCOspary requirement 1 d ! octabliohmontp boing duly apprccia�tod and Ounential to tbq naed* i I .anal velfaro of Min undornigoed and our fM:L:Liemr px'otriding &pod cloan wholeoaao atntoaphero e'er our young paoplo0 wader ghila at the BILL CALL propor and c:onscionco ouperria ot� Ge Hunt�nCtOn fts4he 1 �ravet f �Th73LF� 1aca�od at 70� � � o t .� t � •'•. if ! i f�; - I f • y' � 11 1��(•I - I I, s'.i� I wi�l � rY'�. ;;d � ♦'�1t1 j,. r;. • ',. •, i LI ' �i,+fki�.![ t 'J' � a4J '. . . ! �� -- ------' - — -- —•Ir�a�.aLC's,y'�L�IICL'Lr'11i�� .�. ,-A��.1y1�� ,fie � _S,r'1,�;r.'� �•�• •R• � t.; ,i.. I ; ,f,,.,, ���M�1�•�..:'1�'r,�l' `rt''1�/w .�� ' `. I �� P ,y� • • ,� con nim v1 m l M� C. 1 , + \L pn � .., r ra.r\J-L . � I IV - /• Lf") IL '�' ' /f"/''1--� .�.. .� �.�% ,' '�. lad. ♦-�� . j* � I ,, ����, v / c- I a + L—On PIn f UA te, n C (;K7t Age del aug"Cob' wow '1 r �rr ` J _ L - , fe 4 i October 11 1971 i, CITY ! K QU TIM RCRORAME MYOR AND COUNOIL Op ? !fX CITY0 NTNCTON BXACR t Gentlemen and Lady Will you please read this letter of the Oct. 18 council meeting under new buainese. It wag stated by A. 0 , Marion at the Oat . 4, 101 ooiin- oil meeting that I was operating an illegal stable. �I have had six horses stabled on my , property. I, bava been under:..the Impression that , I ootild krep:animals; in-a�RA 261200 Thin feat has been no secret from the City Off ioialso" 441 I� s told it before'..the Planning *Comaieig" o on Conditional Bxoeption NO 70-33 ovw ayear Qo. ' a' over a. �Jwwa• gone by with out the City informing me 'that I was operating illegal►lt I have researched the RA Zoning r gu' lai tions and Y f iud that Under artiole 960 RA Distriot; d' 9601 animal enterprise on atnirercial basis in not permitted, to comply with i s` regulation 1, have given my ran-term 30 days notice@ As- of Nove, mbor 1971 I will be in full compliance with the RA ME regulative. ResndLat,fully yours, .go - C..._ Charles b. Pays 18?36 Golden hest, Huntington Beach My . i .r� '1.1� �L,i_�r.t +7��•'.�,wtrl'1'W�t�4r:s7W�it r �': 1 v 1 h�*�xx•w yr 4 �'"'r5 v r � • ti . ti: I r a/ : .r�� � - •���� fir. - it•:' .mow 'trr' �.�•=`.!�' r:'1� •T''•') r�11 v ,I ',tiro f ..}z• '-y. r:� t 1• .r tr • IV �rW« r �,_,.r���.�.� r•IHrr��,att'�f`t:{.•�:��J;`i~ I��;C.j�/`.�:....ti r' .'trite ri r �€ T�11,`.\F err.., •..•..1 .•••.• •... ... .. ... -..�. �-.r F� _. .. \ I ,� JJ �•{��+.ly'�.SyllFt'.�tr'.;;fe+IV�3i3P14{N�'� �. f� •'r 31a�• r•i } • I I 1 1 , h 1"_7�`+�;=i`rt:'1IR••M{rfl(• :1..'. . .. •^�T�+ _4vwM .�1 •� y`� . l� III f1'r� t. psi•• •1,'. � :' i. Il tr.r}} III •11 ' l! r i y 9 � 1 i; 1 s e l i r r B `!� r� t •�" k �k; 0 • afar:�,'I;,ts' � •,: `.-;. .- ri � � 1u•,� !t. 'a1, dvtj,lit---i I.Y.. � ��♦{t a ��' �lyy�/` �a�){ '�`� ids ����� � �� L s ..� T ra`M�`-^4- .�I�Mb+iM 1^�( i' � 11.r..`w. h L� � ��• � ���� Grp n T r u ^a ail t •....r.►w�•.v-Kn�P{�I.IMI � ._ : l�'ti': +1'r 1'l�' � 1� +,•r; J�x.{t It rf ! '• rlaj[t [�. �1 r 1,•, � �� + !r i .t t`t K lit:tti�• .H:ti ,� �'+�.. � •,�i, 1 1�' i y ,�i. �,1 a `I fi �} ..yr ICI •+l I:i y' �i v f t f+ ,! ,�f•. it .. J S , _ r 1 _ 1 r • June 26 1970 T 1 f A Mr. Bruce Greer 18792 Stmart Avenue ` Huntington 'Beach, California 92646 Dear We Greer: 1 We for in returning your chec AMC"= of #75.001 MAW p ea t Conditio tioa' 70-43, In h as CH 70-13 is to be r o P1a�ni,e Cmaiasioa, your appeal is pram so effect at thin ttw. If jou wish• io he t. failawigg the rwwwLas by the Planning stun, u may do •o at that time Sincerely your Paul C. Jones City Clark PCJ:wr i goes . INECEIPT FOA CERTIFIED MAIL--W } ,t KitT TO M l 1 Mr. Bruce Grk,-.i ct' 18792 Stewart Ave. CD ` 1 O,SUN.00 IV Com C) Huntington Beach, CA 92646 �0-1 �- Amu <, CD try fr. YNIt.►go fMMrr fo w.Mw+ t=��"/fo aMen. AMnnrM+w Only Y dw�rwf t�nrliri � F] Jot r.+ ❑ �s f h. firm an IMO ♦ (.Nw othr* d�►) F •..�......1...•,-*'.tr'a..►MNi;i4 1.1.1f/f���'rl.q.r+,.r.rr. »nay.�f.rr.4l�ifve•��.1;�.i.�1r1L'�w-Yh"�i''rtif�1.�1 rj„•S , i IY i Carr June. 24 , 1970 y. +' City Council C/O Mx. Paul Jones, City Clark Pe O. Box 190 Huntington Beach. Ca. 92646 RE i ca ,or APPM CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION ISO. 70-3 3 APPLICANTi G. ROBET" JOHNSON & WILLIAM C. WILLIAMS ' IDATE3 JUNE 16, 1970 t Gentlemen of the Councils I hereby appeal the Planning Comisaions decision, granting Y, Conditional Exception #70-33 , granted on June 16, 1970, can the following grounds : y 1. That the granting violated numerous City ordinances. In particular, a few of the violations are of Sections 9832. 2 , 9832.3 , and 9833. 2 . Further, that the proceedings were held in violation of proper notice according to City Ordinance Article 9876 3 . In addition, the finding of fact of the Staff Report ,was incorrect as to fact #29 #3 , and #4. That furthermore# the City violated their own requirements of dedications and im- provements of right of way in not requiring the same as the condition of approval . e truly y r , Bruce Gre r Appellant, w: Joining pro rty Owneraa"k ea ; cc a Mr. Richard Harlow 4-W Planning Caesna:.ssion ' f .y' rt, N5 J �. , 1 , jr i � _� , fir';►CIF � ;t' I� ,- ,'i� i R1�► ili r- I. -b P 1 Ir r L+ ' 1i� k ,,rc2�� > 1��}i ���^�-•,11� Y 7 .'^ 1� � I r"�:12�KL77�?i '! J���rl�l�,' �,�.� • ' [ 1 J •'};.3'k�S'�'I7"/ R•.'* ':tno V�"f1►4MMs. 1,FS of PC# fic a. • � � 1( S e r h M69 dais aw�t an ortb, lays: Tut he is a ' tatakek over,Ow s of twenty-ow yarn. .._�.---•�---- he LL the printer and pu6Udw`of the Hunts obi B eh , • ��L'Ll I1l' 4i1'Y C;OUr1C.t�' News, a weekly.arnVtper of general cimulathm printed ant! pub. ,�t 1 R U Z" ;4 lbhad In'w Huntington H"ch, c:%Wornla and circulated !n. the told r i ?, County of Oro w and el�ev►imv and publid" for the diasenshation of local and other news of a"serwil c!w► wtw, and has'a bona floe subscription gist, of paying subacrlbez% and said paper has bear► erstablLhc printed and published in the State of Calltornta. and ----- city r DIRK.,E- County:of Orange; for at kut one year next before the publk*U on of the first lnsr:rtlon of this notke; Imo the said newspaper is tot devoted to the Interest of, or published for the; entertainment of any parUcular class, profesakw4 trade, calllns, race or denomination. or any number thereot. F 7be HuntlWan li @OA News wad adNdkated a kW newspaper Of gerseral cfrc-alatlon by Judge G. It Scavel In the Superior Court of Oraare County, Calder t" August 770, 1937 by order No. A-5M1. That the _ NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING APPEAL 29 QRMTIXQ OF COKDITI9jNAL EXCEPTION 70-33 tit which the annexed M a printed copy. was pubIM W In mM aews- ' ,.1 7 paper at least On. 1 d a tiq yI corrnnencing from the 20th Any of AtMIKuiit ;• 19 Z.Q., and ww tt an tM _nth Im at Agga d t , 19-10, both days lwhuW*, and as often during Bald pedal and linage of pabikation as said paper ww regularly Mood, and In teed regular wd entire Lsa w of said wwspaper proper. and not in ■ suppk mt. add said notice was pub Jdwd Um*., on the follo aft dstea. to-wit: AuMU81 90, 1270 P -7 hkUmber subscribed and swam to before me O'. day at 1 . Jim alowct- ,7 _ - r Notary Public i7 Orraap Cc+unty. Caluarl" THOMAS D. WYLUE �''•' pQTMY PMIC • t,Ali►UNIttA ... OAAltitE t)0411Q'Y t My ConrM411011 Uxpirei Saps. 11, 1979 CITY C!. ft 'f t o sin C6 NLUAGM I'��'J, I�II�at ►� � Nuai,Afa •r.Ake t a►li wA" I P71 . 1 It P!1 Doar Mr. Killia w i � Tot arc bqWOby, Wtif lol t Ut Ills► rl isrs tros ym stab&so Qro is shoe a /� Mop 1ih asrsrp dsrrp I.A S• JhMAs i isM Yory tnaiv ysorsv l lopi�w�r 323-)M NWIIa Arty 100044 M W AW as Wmt an Ksa►ch M Council " : �nsc, y I �!4 �',,/ `+ t�'�:.f .• r . il' .-S..) .y.: r w� . �.•i/ i .,i. r - _- fir, . . ��rr�Cal���► 9�►T .. u y c Nr+ JeIft A. ThOwAs i 4"Inctem N"tA Qsiiram" 9264 .. Dar W. %twisso VIM" ar 1► umt, yap have entered, AM }pared a PUU4 arm an the &*rye,o oened by the unrleraippod. Im are t wsk+y notified to mom and deeiot from aq mW all we or this acreage. Fw-Uw,r, dram are tMereby., aotilirod to ware all mp#mnt, wood, rubbish and/o r debris that Irao boww-pUeM. an mW a oreasa, i.e. Garfield dtreot Additiai t lots 1762&4-46 elejt PI &M I&ta 23-2611 Block F. Very truly ymrM;, (mrb.) Tdrn M. Trors Telephone 3233509 WSJ Ie"ored Ytaih hAm Roomipt l oque4ed / oe &well Cit Council oc� lfiu�ti.e�t � Erl WMEWANEdW t�atdr 37 WnICK OF MLIC WAIUNC j ApIiAL r0 CW IrIft" Lm W33 WrICI 19 MM CIVINN that a public hearing will be hold by the City Council of the City of Huntington Reecho in the Covaeil Chamber of the Civic Center, Huntington beach, at the hour of 7300 P.M. , or as coon thereafter as possible, or y the tLt day of. iopC�■ber , 1970for the purpose of cons ideriC' wo ippowl to the gmtb* by thin MY ! l�M� Cr�Lrwwia� F oil CS 70..33g to p xult ridLm stables md w" to be Iftated worth of nowt Awerue. wppraeirwtoly 330 !t. wt of the rcetorllfts of aohdwa est =tle t is► thr iIS-0 Limit 1"Otrlol. Drtr"to aoahisw4 with oil psoduatiLao. A lgpl dace iptice to ao Wo io the ZLamni.c'm D wrtraaat Office. All lticereeted persons are invited to attend said heirl" mild expreas their opinions for or against •aid 1 to Q "*033• f'uyrther information may be obtained from the Of flee of the City <fJ. Clerk. DAM art U. 1970 � CITY OU MM I' awn XCqP'j0fA' (V lIMTINGTON KACH 10 0• sax ,. UV r,. ( ' n j,9 i.f!�la Lw.l tW 1 f i • La r_r�� V .....`ram ' ' ~' C AW OR 'AGENT- ..- J. MiM �i,t , ,� CO ISS'�GIV ACTION Oi4YE � air •ew A"wit F s Valhi;,, Calif. MA11AM ADMIS :(,.,. APP"O fi2-0 A COIW011`I�IALLY APON NO - -- _ C7DENIEO PlIfMlE a,l1a.� (MwIT""A " llranti�eaa►,�taeh Company a APP dLEo b YES 0 No tp110PERtY Dam CODICIL ACTION DATE 2110 Main Street. Muntingtom leach, California MAILMit) ADDRESS C:) SUSTAINED COMMISSION [ 3 A00MVED WN Colo OTHER THAN TO PERMIT C,h D�IWE D Riding stable and associated user to be located EFFECTIVE OATS vithto au MI-6 district. LOCATION OF PROPERTY (SIDE Of STREET, STREET NAME , DISTAKE FROM NEAREST AITER'SECTING STREET) North Ernes^ Street, approximately 320' east of the centerline of Goldenweat LEGAL. DESCRIPTION Street, City of Huntington Beach. The easterly 668 feet of the westerly 968 feet of the northerly 263 feet of the southwest one-quarter of the southwest one-quarter of Section 35r Township S South, Rattle 11 West, S.S.d.iM. , County of Orange, Cites of Huntington beach, California. JUSTIFICAMN - FILL. OUT COMPLETELY ( IF MORE SPACE IS REOUIRED ATTACH ACDITIONAL PAGES) A) YMAT ,EXCEFT'i6"L .- CIRCUMSTANCES APPLY TO THtS,,, PROPERTY (INCL.UDWG %.SIZE , SHOE , TOMNAPHY, ,.LOCATiDN OR SURROUNDINGS) THAT DEPRIVE THE SUBJECT PROPERTY OF PFhVILEGES.�,;ENJ0YE0 ON OTHER PROPERTIES IN THE VICN►ITY AND UNDER IDENTICAL ZONE CLASSIFICAT!M ? On*-quarter (1/4) of this property (1.12 ac`rea ±) will be taken by,the Route 1 ' Freeway (11/69 State Division of Highvay't< Preliminary Plara ali`^ e`dt,has been• rects"y planned. can ■ropertiesiin the vicinity and sub ect. , P,• property -• a . P y P properties 6 y under idttdeic l` sons. close ification are &Iso sub c o the Ce ti B) *LL ,TMIS "'CO MIT' EXCEPTION CO TIVA 1 I A GR 0P N� %VILEGf INCMMT'ENT WITH LMIITATK)US UM OTHER PROPERTIES IN THE VICINITY AND LOOM IDENTICAL 20K CLASSIPICATKM ? Singles wets have been allowed in the iaseediate area and al though these properties were Hot sotnd M-1 they are all raster-planned for industrial use. C) WHY IS, TKS UNOITMAL: EXCEPTION NECESSARY FOR ``HE PRESERVATION AND ENJOYMENT OF ONE OR MOlMi SUSSITANTIAL PROPERTY R:GHTS ? During this uncertain period prior to freeway right of way acquisition, a land ,Meer should have the right to receive incoce from his property. C1) ESTATE REASOM WHY THE GRANTING OF TM CONDMONAL EXCEPTION WILL , NOT BE �. MATERIALLY DETRIMENTAL TO TI1E PUBLIC WEI.FARE OR INJURIOUS TO PROPERTY IN THE SAME ME CLASSIFICATION. The area surrounding this property is ut,doveloped and im pstmaswat g-evelopmeat in anticipated in the near futitre. This property is locattd : a short distance south of the propoewd Central City Park and should provide a t;e+ded public service al:oving people to more fully j o t k-fi i l It A TY OWFAM OR AW T NI�f i M AAEII'T THE IFTACI 0 S UPPLEM MTAL SPMET MAT BE READ AND SIGNED SY THE APPL CMT 3 k w Nomflogt N Bud Ph lat" ce,44188ill 10.0. sox Ise CALWOANIA I. September 219 1970 TOV. ,MAYOR' AND''CITY Cc�1�It ! Pl''rr�ing Cowr►issian SUBJ1&CT: C0061' T"OU, L tT10*N NO . 70-33 - AFFM A'!": Doyle Miller, City Administrator Paul Jones , City Clerk Gentlemen: `� Transmitted herewitk is a report resaidint the Planing Cods sion's decisi•oo to .approw,rConditionai. R:arepridn No 70-33. The Plaiming Cos ission' s decision on this mtter 'd by George Shibata, attbreq, oa behalf of his cliiat, Irmo Greer, adjoining property Omar, 18792 Steuart Street, RmUngton Reach, CaUforuia. AAlicsnt: G.,- l abert Johison and Wilda C. Williams 10067 Sparrow Avemn Fcnmtain Valley, California � i Location: North side of Ernest Street., any" iaetely 320 feet east of golden met Street. !resent Zoe*: M1-0 Light Industrial District conbinsd with oil production. Master Plamfeda LiEhl. Industrial C���at: To permit riding stables sad assocUted uses. Hai "a riy,4n the ,a••.• 1 least: (in Sri*f� . ��w•w eves-.rrirrrrrrr •,_, TOMpo riry or, int tip use of property until 'right-of-way p r " is ricis plimrrd'. Siieilar ,noes are now in operation Mitt" this imnediatiE, area Mlrici are mu Pter Tanned for industrial use. Condosion Action: Approved upon the following conditions: 1 . Ernest Street shall be dediratod to City Standards. Improvements of Ernest Street shall be to Departwnt of Public Works re- quirewsnts. 2. The riding stable and accessory uses shall be Upt in a neat and clean scaer at all times and properly sprayed to heap dawn the fly hazard. 3. water shall be through the City of ikntiagton Beach's water system. 4. The property shall participate in the local drainage assessment dietrict. 5. Parking shall be provided at a ratio .&* do- termi ned by the Planing Department with proper oiling for dust control and a standard parking layout. 6. Section 4243. 1 of the Huntington Beech aediwce Code shall be complied with. 7. 50 per cent of the adjacent 52 acr*"S owned bar the oikwr of subject property shall be wade available for riding to persons using the riding stables. 8. A Conditlonal Exci�Ft ion No 70-33 shall, brcawt null and void on July 1 , 1975 or when any portion of the property is acquired for freeway purposes. Reasons given by the Planning Comission for their action: 1. This is a temporary use of the property that will termiivate July, 1975 or when the State acquires any portion of the property for freeway develops*nt . ROIL CALL VOTE: AYES: Slates , Bazil , Duke , Miller. NOES: Porter. ABSENT: Tom. Minority Report-, Comaaissioner Porter stated the following: 1 . The animals are objectionable to all but one adjacent property owner. 2. Conditions are such that this use poses & datrLment to health and general welfare , which is a requirement necessary to satisfy the dictates of the ordinance , 3. No conditions exist that wake this property 'diffoxiai t f ran adjacent . pame 1* in the, same arev. utter identical son ing. A principal requireeeat in showing hardship. Which has not beets downxtra.ted. Ih 1 Aridity aonl IaEo'ir itiaas Odor Shi,beii attorne re-, y� t�ssentiit, property o�WM§=1 in the area opposed the rest ou -b*Mlf .4f .prohperty ommra n ike Vavca p � 1036 Coldmi- ., ..., .:, .. .,., .* .. . .. tee we Street and, Eruct Greer, 1;792 Ste�rt' st t 0100 apposed ht.,. reque t. Bill Hartle , City Ragiaee comed the commiisio s that dedication of Ernst Street gill' be necessary at this time. ; lespectfully submitted, ' �.. K.A. Reynolds Secretary KAx/j I �I� �l1i11111111 Ili 111E illll�il li • WOW 4ftwmpmwmmmwm"p� IV RA M • y�PM INV Location: . 3 . . . jAFF itf: f cisT C'OMIT1014AL+LX EI- ION NO. JCI-33 Applicant; C. -Robert Johnson b Williar C. Williams Lktte: July 21 , 1970 The staff hos .,reviewed Conditional Exception No. 70- 33 and offers the following infonnntion for your conbideration: 1 . This application proposes to permit a riding stable end associated uses on property located on the north' side of Ernest St . , a pproximeady 320 ft . east of Goldenwest St . It consists of a 4 .0 acre parcel of land and in zoned MI-O . 7 . The application was originally heard by the Planning , Commission on June 16, 1970 , at which time the request was conditionally approved . Legal notices advertising the hearing were mailed as required by the Huntingt on Beach Ordima►nce Code ; however, due to an error in the assessor ' s av-ps, on file in the Planning Department, the .adjacent property owner to the north was not notified . ` The City Attorney ' s office informed the Planning Dep:rt- went that if the property owner would not waive his right for notification of the public hearing, a nr public hearing mould be required as the previous action was null and void . The property owner did not waive this right; therefore , this application has been reset + for public hearing . s . Surrounding properties c re . zoned M1-0 and vacant for the most pert with a few industrial uses south of the subject property and along Garfield Ave . There are a few non-conforming residences in the area and more spe- cifically, a dwelling inmediAtely south across Ernest Ave. and one north of the subject property . 4. A portion of the subject property is located within -.he freeway right-of-way and the applic nt proposes to operate and maintain a riding stable and associated uses , such as breaking corral , tack roo®, etc. , until tht freeway right-of-way is acquired. : A o. 5 . 'x'his applie Lion wob fi.'ied bea6!ase Atabie% arc not PlO mitted in any district within the City . However, It should be noted th t horbes ma+Y P be kept for p rivste . . enjoyment within any district, provided, they conform to the setbacks required in Article 424 of the Huntington Berch Ordinance Code , i r it should be noted that Section 4243. 1 requires that horses shall be stabled fifty feet from any street 11nQ and that such horse shall not be stabled wfth'in 100 ft. of any dwelling . 6. The oppl.cent proposes to sr. t'isfy an apparent demrond for this type of facility . If the Planning Commission concurs with the request and feels there is sufficient justification for approval , the staff offers the following conditions for your consideration: 1 . Ernest St. shall be dedicated to City Standards . Improvements of Ernest St . shall be to Department of Public Workb requirements . 2 . The riding stable and accessory uses sh::J.l be kept in a neat .end clean manner: at all times and pro- perly sprayed to keep down the fly hazard. 3 . water shall be through the City of Huntington 3each' s water system . 4. The property shall participate in the local drainage assessment district . 5. Parking stall be providad at a ratio as determined by the Planning Department with proper oiling for dust control and a standard parking layout. 6. Section 4243 . 1 of the Huntington beach Ordi;nrince t Code shall be complied with. 7 . Conditional Exception No . Ir 0-33 shell become null and void on July 1 , 1975 , when the freeway is precise planned or whichever is soonest. LAW OrFIG[! rEORGE SHIBATA IZr :��yrD CITY CL RK CI (i bt NU�111NG111 ErACII.CxIlF:. pleas 141CACH oouLtvwwp MUNiINGTON OWN,CAUPOINIA 92646 � rt�c�„oNc •��•eeer 1910 PUG 13 on 9 : .3 � August 12 , 1970 City Coun::l.1 jcja M.c. Paul Jonec , City Clerk P. 0. Box 190 Huntington Beach, California 92646 Re : NOTICE OF APPEAL CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 70-33 APPLICANT: G. ROBERT J0194SON & WILLIAM C. WILLIAMS DATED: June 16 , 1970 Gentlemen of the Council : I hereby appeal the Planning Commission ' s decision, granting j Conditional. Exception 470-33 , granted on June 16 , 1970, on behalf of my client, Bruce Greer, Joining Property Owner, 18792 Stewart Avenue, Huntington Beach, California, on the following grounds : ? . That the granting violated numerous City Ordinances. In particu:.ar , a few of the viol a tions are of Sections under Article 983. That there was a further violation of Code Section 4243. 1. 2 . Further , that the proceed.ingn were held in violation of proper notice according to City Ordinance Article 987. 3. In addition, the finding of fact of the Staff Report was incorrect as to fact #2, #3 , and 44. That furthe&more, the City violated their own requirements of dedications 1 and improvements of right of way in not requiring the same as condition of approval.. ery • ruly y rs, GS:va Qg . S ba�i� i t r a cc:: Mr. Richard Har' ow Plann{ng Coma'Assion , �'' �.�.., 0-*—} Enclosure: Check"for 175,,00 JS LAW OFFICE! G EORG E S H ! DATA 17905 •[ACM bOVL[VAIMp NVNfINOTON 19A Ml,CAU"NIA 92646 RECEI'1EQ T[LCp"ON[ "lot-srbi CITY UERK C17 " ItUM11MGTG��L�CH.C1LIf: .September 24 , 1970 1970 SEP 25 nH 9 2 3 City Council City of Huntington Beach c/o City Clerk P . 0 . Box 190 Huntington Beach, California 9?646 He : Notice of Appeal. to Superior Court Conditional Except ion Ila . 70-33 Applicant : Johnson i Williams Date : .June 16, 1574 � Gentlemen: Please be advised that my clients , the adjoining property owners , Greer, Vavra , etc . are going to appeal your decision made on Monday evening , Septumbet� 21 , 1970 , granting a use variance for a horse stable to the Superior Court . This is notice to you that; if there are any damages following from your issuance of this variance and building permit that the City may well stand to lose a considerable sum of money . We expect the City to take the appropriate action to mitigate any damages if the court rules in favor of my clients . Very , truly 'urs� `<<,, GEORGE SF{IBi A va cc : Johnson Williams Building Department Itmtington hencii 2110 1414 in St . r 06, 1 �7Q-3 Wtgfi. Bch. , Cal . 97ti4i. 0O f . Fairssaunt Road urbank , Ca lif.91501 Cbiltlaa B. Vavrn et al Q+uanl,in Tobin State Viv. of 111ghwAyb 16736 oldenwst St . P.Q . Box 307 P.C . Box 2.304 , Terw.Aenex Nntgr. llch. , Cal . 92647 Tres Pinos, Cali ( . 9 �017S Los Angeles , Cal . 90054 r�ttn; Sc: ff. QE sib A Getty Oil Co Huntington` cf� :,:, ; , . R. .'13.. s•t on P.O. sox 54050 3 - Done1d Weir I, Los•-lknaeles , Cal .90054 13692 Blnnche Ave . ''• r1�n rr�,�•� , CA1 .9zrr'. l Nun ton Beach Co. Standard Oil Co . William Landis Tog ieion 225 Bush St . 1180 S . Beverly Dr. 1 225 ' `xh St. San Francisco, Ca 1 . 94120 Los Angc:lv s , Cnl .90035 San nanitisco, Calif . Estelle C. Gilkeson Gladys Conrcd Ben l -: ?- . S. fryers 683 ark Rd . 124 alley Dr . 1 '47Q1 Van Buren St. Par , Cal . 05969 Palm Springs, Cal . 92262 Midwiy C1ty, Ca1 . 92665 Cla a Brooks Gelso Dispalntrr► Bank of America 1876 Mott-Smith Dr . 13426 Placid Dr . ',atl . ]"r . 6 Snv. Assoc . Hon a" , Hi . 96822 Whittier, Cal . 90605 -)32 1• . Colorado Blvd . 1'n stidenr , Cry 1 . 91101 ► Geoenner Helen Griffith t,t 1 f<•xncu. 'nc . i 807 St . Sec . Pacific Nr.tl .Bank + 350 Wilshire: Blvd . Hntgn. Bch. , s:a1 . 92646 Tax Division Los Angeles , Cal . 90005 Los Angeles , Cn1 . 9003- I Alai even Edward Rut-se II Irvin G. Greer 7514 rfield ,Ave . P.O. Box 697 .3626 Ocean Blvd . Nntr . Bch . , Cal . 926.46 Hntgn. Bch . , Col , 926=46 Corona- del MAr, C-it .92625 H8 Elementary School Til lus iii 1 k r i. linker Goeteb. 1W . ift,- St. 18692 Goldenwest �C . 610 Mein St. Ifntgn . fth. , Cal . 92646 Hatgn. Bch . , Cnl . 9264 ? Hntgn . Bch . , Cal . 92646 l(.h. Union high School gut;;:1 eese li^rry Cohen 1902 17th St. too ss 6450 01cott St . Ilntam�- llch. , Cal . 92646 Tu)unS* , Cal . 91042 Ort-we L. Greer U. K. 'Plavan • , G. ,�bapt Jahnso�n . Mi11,l C. Willis" 19792 Geldow*sk St - 26M'N. "gin St . 100 f 'Spa crawr Ave. fttam. Ach. ' Cal . 92647 5ainta Ana, Cal . 91701 r"t", viki l ey, call, L C 70-33 j • Me Tows ra 0*6rg a Shibsts, Atty. to 743 We 136th St. 17935 Beach Blvd G4 rdem, Cal .90247 Huntington Beach , CA 92646 Robbie Colters et n1 1999 Braoburn Altadena , Calif. 91001 Bel riffith A Chester 710 le Blvd LL11 Fie �aI4��93721 Charkes Sc . Martin su i 18 522 Ishire Blvd . 4 Los eles , Ce 1 . 90036 r Dar Otto 237 W. Jefferson Blvd . Los ales, U1 . 90007 eI Published Huntington Beach News Aug- + t?ubllshed Huntington Belch News ust 20, 2970. 1 July 9, 2970) NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING LEGAL NOTICE APPEAL TO QRANTING OF CONOITIONAL NOTICE OF PUBLIC HI[MING EXCEPTION NO. 7043 CONDITIONRL EXCEPTION NO. 7/-21 NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that a pub- NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that a lic hearing will be hzld by the City Coun- public herring will be held by the City cil of -the City of Huntington Beach, in Planning Commission of the City of the Council Chamber of the Civic Center, Huntington Beach for the purpose of Huntington Beach, at the hour of 7:30 considering a conditional exception to P.M., or as soon thereafter as possible, = permit riding stables and associated on Monday, the 21 st day of September. use: to be Iocstad north of Ernest Ave- 1970, for the purpose of considering an nue, apprmimataty 320 fL east of the appeal to the granting by the City Plan- centerlir+-n- of Goldenwest Street in the ning Commission of CE 70.33, to permit M1-0 Light Industrial district combined riding stables and associated uses to be with oil production. A fetal description located north of Emest Avenue, approx- is on file in the Planning Department imately 320 fL east of the centerline of Office. Gotdenwest Street in the MI-0 Light In- Said hearing will be hold at the how dust is District, combined with oil pro- of 7:00 P.M., on July 21, 1970, In the r I sEr ct. p 1 Council Chamber of the Civic_ Center. • ductioi. A begat description is on file in tho Punning Department Office. Huntington Beech, California. on Sth Street between ;plain Street and Orange All interested persons are invited to i Avenue. attend said hearing and express their All Interested persons are invited to opinions for or agahist said appeal to attend said hearing and express their CE 70.33. j opinions for or against the proposed Further information may be obtained i Conditional ExcepUort. from the Office of the City Clark. Further information may be obtained DATED: August 13, 1970. from the City Planning Departnrient• CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH Telephone No. Wfo-527L By: Paul C. Jones DATED this 9th day of July. 2970. City Clark CITY PLANNING COMMISSION By K. A. REYNOLDS Secretary ep.20 • �' f�