HomeMy WebLinkAboutConditional Exception 71-101 - J.M.C. Construction Company - l
= - Published Huntington Beach News Ian.
- 70. 1972.
LEGAL NOTICE
�,:".3 P1lbiteh�. l"lYMI A i>�xh Imes �ab�. . ; NOTICE OF PUBLIC NE&MiNG
CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION No. 71.111
APPEAL
.,APPEAL:_M_-A"*0VAL NOTICE 1S HEREBY GIVEN that a pub-
C=0M0#6AL EXCEMpN 71-101 i•+c hearing will be held by the City
Hunt-
NOTICE l8 HEREBY GIVEN that spub- Planning Commission of the City of Hunt-
tk hasrtng will be ftiald by the Cityengton beach for the purpose of con-
Gatrteil of tits City of Muntintton Besot, sidecing a Conditional Exception to allow
k- no Council Chscnber of the Civic the southeast cornet of a garage to en-
��, Huntingtonbeach, atthe hour of yard
2 ft. into the required Sit. side
�� R.�•. � � lDOn tharMft� " located a: 16::1 Carousel Lane in the
yard setback. The subject property is
_bW on kferrtdsy the bth day ofI�isrch �'?2, far the Durpoea of con- Ri Single Family Residence District, and
sidWn! an appew to Va apprwal by le¢alty described as La! 150, Tract No.
Ski.
e City Planning CommiWan, of Con-
ditional Exception 71-301, to allow ttta Said hearing will be held at ;he hours+snitltaltet comer ofa �e
toertCrDaCh of ':OQ P.M., on February 1, I972, in
2 ft. into tits required S ft. side yard the Council Chamber of the Civic Center,
• property is located Huntington Beach, Californian on Sth
s�back- Tom" • Street between Main Street and. Orange
at 1i74t Carousal Lane in this Ri Single Avenue.
Fancily Residence Distric% and lath► Alt interested persons are invited to
dewAbed as Lot 1. Tomat Noe SUL attend said hearing and express their
All Inta uslied persons are invited to opinions for or against the proposed
attand said hearing and mWeea their Cond-tional Exception.
Gonions for or eats t amd appeal. Further information may be obtained
FurUW informtlon may be obtained from the City Piannirg Department.
front the MGM Of the City Clerk. Telephone No. 536-5271.
DATEQ: 2I9l72 DATED this 20th day of January, 1972.
Gin OF M11TIN GTON BENCH CITY PUNNING COMMISSION
{ ft Paul C. *Nvas By K. A- Reynolds
Gib Clark Secretary
'�.�f.� a r -\, r�• [ �: ,.` ; is ..
Huntington Beach PINNNINg Commissiol
• ,
P.O. sox Ito CALIFORNIA AMU
March 6 , 1972
TO : !HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL
FROM : Planning Commission
RE : Conditional Exception No . 71 - 101 - APPEAL
A,rTN: David D. Rowlands , City Administrator
Paul Jonec , CIty Clerk
Gentlemen :
Transmitted herewith is a report on Conditional Exception
No . 71 . 101 , which was heard on an appeal to the Planning
Commission . The Hoard rf Zoning Adjustments originally
reviewed Conditional Exception 71 - 101 at their December 29 ,
1971 meeting and approved the request . Pursuant to
Section 9815 the Hoard ' s decision was reviewed by the
Planning Ommission on February 1 , 1972 at which time the
Commission affirmed the Board ' s decision . The Planning
Commission ' s decision has been appealed by Mr . Leo Linden,
a'wtting property owner .
�Vplicant : J . M . C . Construction Company
7072 Garfield Avenue
Huntington Reach , California
Location : 16741 Carousel Lune in the R1 Single Family
Residence District and legally described as
Lot 150 , Tract No . 5481 .
C . E. Request : To allow the southeast corner of a
garage to encroach 2 ft . into the
required 5 ft . side yard setback .
Reasons given by the a plicant : (In Brief )
irregular property lines created unusual difficulty in
plotting ; Also this lot is the only lot in Tract S481
where the propert? lines were not corrected prior to
subdivision . Furthermore , the adjacent prnpirty is
vacant .
Staff Recommendation : Sustain the Board of Zoning
Adjustient' s, deElsion and dehy the appeal .
planning Commission Action : Denial of the appeal .
Conditlonal exception No . 71 - 101
March 6 , 1072
Page No . 2
Reasons given b,: the Planning Commissior. for their action :
1 . The lot is irregular in size tend shapto with numerous
off - sets in the side property lines and has frontage
of only 28 f t .
2 . The request is only for a small triangular area at
one corner of the structure with an encroachment
of 2 ft . into the side property line .
3 . The hone has been constructed and a final inspection
approved by the City permitting occupancy of the home .
4 . The applicant filed this application to legalize the
encroachment on his own initiative .
f . Similar requests have peen granted within this general
rca in the past .
6 . Visual obstruction is no more than that of an archi -
tectural feature which could be constructed with the
same setback .
7 . Removal of this encroachment would remove one off- street
parking space .
ROLI. CALL VOTE :
AYES : Bazil , Porter , I:erins , Iliggins
NOES : Duke
ABSrLn: Slates , Boyle
Additional Ini,'%rma�tion_: •Cwo persons spoke in favor of
t e proposal . 'i':,o persons spoke in opposition .
Respectfully submitted ,
f01.
K. A . Reynolds
Secretary
KAR: sen
doom
. •� � �, is 1 •,
. . o R,l , ,Rl
I Ci
/ ti � 1 •
Rl
Rl RI
RI
CHANNEL
100,
� � ram. `��\ �,�,• l•
t•
Q
R1•
bA w t!~
A,
9CA1[ 1NWet
CONDITIONAL EXCEPTKIll 71--101 s
tb
RA K",
Affidavit of ft .,fication 04
autte of CbUfernia
County of Change S
City of ifurtUngton Beadt 1
George Farquhar, being duly sworn on With, nays,: That he is a
citizen of the United States, o%vr thin age of rttvnty-ones year*.
That he Is the printer and publisher of the Huntington 13ench
News, a weekly nrtvslmper of r!eneral circulmion printed and pub-
lished in lfunttngton Beach, California and cirvulatcvl in the %Alcl 1
County of Orange and elsra-here anti published for the tlk.comination
of locul and other news of a general chnracter, arul hat a twrut fig a
aubscri itiun list rd �,\
1 lxtying suhscrllmnw, and sold joiner has • .......___..__�
establishM, printed and publisbod in the State of California, nriti
County of Orangr, for at least one year next before the. puhliw•nihsi 3 _
of the first insertion of this notice; and the wild newslwtiier Is ne,t
devoted to the int2mst of, or published for the entertainment of nit%
lrarticular class, profession, trnde• (alling, mrv- or denwninntion. t)r
any number therrof. I
The ll-wrttinglon Beach New witz adjudicated a legit rx-A•simper
of general circu:ntion by Judge G K. Sc-wnrl In the Superior Cour• PWJ"OA l t Wo"Wol.
of Ornnge Cl msity, California August 27th 1937 by onfer No A-5931 it, �• ' '�3:;' ' rt
That the _- - — - -.APP AI. TO APPROVAL
CONT)ITiONAL F XO',PTION 71-10,1
OWWW
of which ttw anne?ced 1% a printnt vgiy, %4%% published in snid ne..• • Is .Yt#
NOWrss
wed
In per nt least tltl" Inoue
.t,mmencing front the 1 Lit clay twi Febrtlft ry
7 tt�;rwM
19_. 7'-_, atxl etdtnt; on the of FN h r q n ry ny.
M
19-7.?, Wth dnys inclusive., and ns often dutinit mid hct•icrl nrr.l
times of publicittion as ar:d palwr was, t.-sulerly ixsunl, and in the
reltttlar stki entire t.w..a of world lK•Nspnp.,•r prober, and not In a
supplement, anti wild rwrtirv- wns publinhotl themin on the folln%lnl;
tSate+. tn•wit� 1rMt C t#i�L ' -'�
J,,..,
Fr.b• 17 , 1 t ^' tilMf r>+
WJ"
�. �t t�tuttt-+�. Iw�n � ,
Sutrwwcritwd am sworn to brfwe me 110% , __1 Lll_ day of
FobruArev, tsa_7z�
Notary Public•
OrsnKe County, Califosmis
THOMA5 D. WYIIIE
ffi a .hi tt•'s; Pot c`c.a iyl• i •
�.:+tom.+,..-w.�.tyr�.r;rZ•...,•��. �.a,�.,�_�.-�
MW
LINDEN LABORATORIES , INC . SM grastw000r Uml.
for angekt, ca.9WM
(213)hi�•N131
MAy1J1ACT11�I1v0 '
CNeMl�ftt _
Februitry 701 , 1972
1 CLERh
kUh'rlMcr�h`EACN,CAJW1
Th« 11unurt.0310 Mttyur itnd C 1. ty Council.
City cal' Huntington Bunch 197�
Post Offico Box 190 I t 31
Huntington Burtch , CA 26 t8
Attention: Mr. Paul Jones
City Clark
Gen t I omen:
Enclosed herewith is rry c}ieck I'or $75 .00 for filing an appeal tat;ain-it.
the Fobrunry ] s t , 197" deck l.ntt of th/a City Planning Comml :+-t1 on,
Conditional. Exeel:tic,rt No . 71 - 101 . Some of the reasons t'or our appcyl
itra Stated ho1ow :
! Buildirtl; restrictions are established to insure equitable protection 1'or
the indivi.cff,ul and then community in matters of privacy, Access to lifht ,
ul.r , rind tte:tt.hotics . Tljese restrictions nre cstablitshed after consider-
able at-tidy and evaluation by many experts concerned with this community .
Theme restrictions ni-e eottriderod ton important to he left to the
discretion of the (ivurttgo indiviclufi l .
11untington ,Harbor is developed am a "platut-e-d" community. Thetse basic
l.ot ress tric ti.ono require special l adherence . We fool our rights have
barge vi.ulacecf by t1,e djsreAE;ard for %he 5 root air space between lot lime
and bui lding. Tito argument Out t "I built before you d1d" is not eta
acceptable and mut'l'icient roamon for art excoption. This certainly call
o.4tablirth a most: clartE;etrours precedence.
We sittc arely requost that you review our appeal most carefully, taking
.into, ronsidorution our right:~ and the right of the community to have
tfieir property- its planned.
Yours truly ,
4/9 , 77
• y• 7� Leo Linden
LL/cw
��it CJ�r"o�irr Awrtion Cur walift
� ' 1► Sr.zrlr^S I LlaCkt�i.►tr,
651 %'nnderer Im Nfandurer Ltt
. J�ttntitt};ttt Jscl� . 1'�t '�Zt d " ilutt !' in'; t!► 1',c:ll , +;:1 ; ',, 17
di.: 71 - 101
J \1 i:Onst . f:o , .1 R "'o.III s z
7071 Cir f eld 4vc► 1t16-,- 1 Carousel Ln tt�• � r+ •1 th St
Iiulitit' ; trt Ach , ('.It :2r,itp;+ ;t Ca 9 '• C' � )
�tr . i. . 1. • t ,;,, A ► ,'rl,omlr mr , Inc
1 (SS•1 IJ•,: c�;:ar Lit :; Sc;.i ;;i Isitir�• itive( '':ceMtt View '�t:}: (ti :;T
1 7n72 '.'.t , ner Ave
ftut� t i -' ' i � �,�.}; � ,� ..�1� 'ltt. :� lc` : , .s ..tU'� ��'• Y�11 � ,
lit nt ine to Id i ,
!Dirt:}tart' )taff Asst Ocslgii
C,)urtrigItt 5t tit ttt 'Av • of (lys
nit Ito t� l _)�i(11Q } A .`� s()� lTlg
Built . ,:arbour t;:nr;•
`��}w i�.1 rtiti♦ ,�v►► t A:.I',' 1 • •; fdor
!(llttiill� ttt i�t:i1 , �:.t ) 6•i'a !ti�•Vvrl '• ills , ('.1 902110
j hGL�,t "'.2 j u s I "al o Vl' t'.Jes l s t.l tes
L i tljon
'i 1~
161 ,* 2 ..t r:,l.tsul Lit I t,i•i - �1;1T1,t��rer 1.1t
I!u>;� i , t , `.,, , i•.1 n ,; .i ;;unt n 1 t, ';cit . c:�� �1 :(1•!"
'our ttivv Ln
1•rrri '1C 1 lili(1 • IMI!, i 11 ., tit
tEsih; �.•ttt+(�•rar Ln 145 S It id,;on Ave
tlulti : t !, i,c(s , !.ov. An;;rl +:s , 6 gone
J rl l:•� ' 1
Y It E :pan i c 1 s
; Ii712 'si%mdcrer Ln
,,,5671 n:tttdorac Lit (tuntih;; tn ilril , �� 926A7
f,un t hs? tit ►ic:h , Cm 9.647
S&M OF THE ACTION OF Co. COUNCIL.
Council Chamber, City Hall
Huntington Beach, California
Mayor McCracken called the regular meeting of the
City Counc 1 of the City of Huntington Reach to order at 4 : 30
o'clock P.M.
� Councilmen present : ZgCg, a. ri
Counc i l.twn Absent : hLp-Ley e '30 F .
yy y,yyy1 yyy,yyyyyy ,,• y..y�,,.�,.yryi,,��,yryrr�.y..iw.j+awl..y..�r+ytiy..,wyr.w,.wyr.in.
PUBLIC HEARING - APPEAL DENIED - CONDITIONAL, EXCEPTION 71.-101
*** k�1-kk•�•**���****�l•�k�IrlNit�1•�k�c***�r�k•�►r**11r*****�t�•�4�F�A•k�kk•h**itic
On motion by Green , Council sustained the decision of the Planning
Commission ; denied the appeal and granted Conditional Exception
s 71- 101 finding that a hardship does exist pursuant to Items ail ,
# 5 and #7 contained in the Planning Commission Report , as follows :
r ( 1) That the lot is irregular in size and shape with numerous
off-sets in the side property lines and has frontage of only 28
feet ; ( 5) that similar requests have been granted within this
general area in the past ; ( 7) rvmoval of this encroachment would
remove one off-street parking space , and further directed that the
two appeal fees totaling $150 be refunded to the appellant . The
motion was passed by the following vote !
AYES : Cocinc i lmen : Shipley , Bartlett , Gibbs , Green, Ma they , Coen ,
McCracken
c NOES : Counc i lawn : None
j ABSENT : Counc i 1 nett : Norte
On motion by Mrs Cne,y _the regular meeting of
j, she City Council of the City of Huntington Rench adjourned , at 11 : 08 PX
X .AWLV710t`XliJt*X by the following vote :
AYES : Shipley , Bertlett .Giblin Green ,Matney ,
Coen , McCracken Paul C . .Jones
t NOES : None City Clerk and ex-officio Clerk
i ABSENT : N!ins• of the City Council of the City
f� ATTEST : of Huntington Beach, California
-�..._ . C e orae C . McCracken ..,,_.._
1Ai.W l G . .J gn em.......w�^. _ Mayor
!:! ►:y Clerk
STATE OF CALTFORNIA )
County of Orange ) 38 :
City of Hcmt ington teach )
It PAUL C. JONES , the duly elected , qualified and acting City Clerk
of the City of Huntington Beach , California , do hereby certify that
the above and foregoing is a Prue and correct Statement of Action
of the Clay CounC11 of said City at their regular
meeting held on the 6 S. dory o f March 7
EWITNESS my hand and sea of the said City of- Nc+c- ting*on beach this
thv_�) h +ley of, March 19 72
City Clerk aril vx -officlo f- lerk
of the t'tty cif rile City
r of Hunt 1 :+Rt: ,,tr !leach, Cal J fornhl,a
1'w
do
Air pu t y -
. -.� .. •. .y ref ,y.
�r
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
TO F. B . !Arguello , Uirector of Finance March 9 , 1972
1
Frum Paul C . Jones , City Clerk fr. Fe Reimbursement
Attached hit.-rej:ith is a certified copv o2 Minute Action of the City
Council taken at the regular meeting of March 6 . 19?2 authorizing
and directing a refund of appeal fees, paid for appeals to both the
Cite Planning Commit%icYn and the Cit.: Cotincil in connection with
Conditional Exception No . 71- 101 •
��•• Tom' J• •1 .. '� •
RECEIPT � / 9' 0 7 4 26
ate Received From_ ZDate
z Address
G
z — Dollars $
z
For
�' A:Couflt jq)% DAiD
CAW LAM
V rAmy rAID
SKID$ �..af•,
I
BARD OF ZOMUG ADJUSTWNT5
ApPI.eGAT IOIII FOIL
.
OOWT101P E PTKM (WJMWE: )
FILM FEE 25-M AV,.Z&Z-0
CITY Or HWTINMN NEACH
�.4. am 190 w I'L G K 197 t
,•jam' � %�'� �'S's' - ,r��'
JJA.C. CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
wMOM APPLICANT OR AGENT ACT ON
Cj AF43%-J11t-0
Mv2072"rf�A enue . iuntin t2a Beach QC0WTKftLLV At440
MAILING ADORES$ 16- LO DES
(714) 14 2-5 a 2 7 X C�1MIT�IOAAtAi+M
Iwo 4�� .i.rya i.r... �.�wr+.�..�ri��r••f�wr D YU noW
4r, Leonard L. Lady WON WTKW DATE
pIlCIIIEII Y OM1Nf 14 FILE On -•-----
16711 Caroused Lane, ntinon Beach QSuSTA�O W�
�(u gt
jAW*WI
M41LING ADO'AESS g C3 KNIEd
_ M WITHOR MMN
TO PERMIT EFPE=IVE tAA'Y!
►Y 1��
The south east cc rnor of the ara;,e to
extend into the required S ft . side yard set back. Nis corner of garage
will only set 1:1tu side Yar•4 -' Ceet alid extend uack 50 incises .
LOCATION OF PW-FE RT Y (SIDE OF STREET, STREET NAME o DiSTiWWE FROM IIIEAREST
mTERSECTIw STREET)
16741 Carousal. Lane , duatington Beach . California
LEGAL OESCRIPTODN
ill '
ISO of Tract idol
T --J1lS IFIC�
FILL OUT :OMPLETELY ( IF MORE SPACE IS REOIIIREO ATTACH AMITI(INAL POISES )
A) WHAT EXCEPTIONAL CIRCUMSTANCES APPLY TO TOIIS &-RapFui r t tKsNr . SIZE , SHAPE
TOPMAPMY, LOCATK)N OA SLOWUNG. MIG3) THAT DEPRIVE THE SUBJELT RRO'ERTY OF
PINVIL OAS ENJOI'YIED ON OTHER PROPEIFTIES IN THE VICINITY AND UNDER IDENTICAL
ZM CLASSWICATIIN '
Irregular Frop,erty lines created unusual difficulty in plotting; &ISO
this lot is the only lot in Tract 5401 where the property lines were not
corrected prior to subdivision.
V WIL.L. rNfs CMITK)MIAL EXCEPMN CONSTITUTE A GRANT Of SPECIAL PR"WLLGF INCIMISTENT
MITM L.MTXrKM. UPON OTHER PROPERTIES 01 THE b;CWOTY AND (ODER ti)ENTICAL ?ONE
CL ASSIF1lJIMN 7
There have been similar variances granted in this tract in past .
CI WNV Is rW9 :OIr10 roi%&L EXCEPTS M OKCESSAW FOR THE NRI:SER*JAT10N AMU
EMJO'TMENT OF OW ON MORE SUE"OTIAL PpOPE'RYY RIG"' S r
Construction documents , Ei.Ald layout and inspection services wire )rendered is-
adequately through no fault of owner and house is now Einalled by, city and
0 heinv 11red in .
01 0WO IMSASONS WHY THE SHANTIIMi OF TON$ C0001110NAL rxcr.PT m Wn I wit nt
MAffSSALLV CEtRIMEMTAL TO THC PUBLAC WCLFAOK OR 01JUNW5 Trr P141" E F• T r Ie!
TI9 "a W K CLASOFCNM
W jaccnt • r.) -erty is tie:cant .
01
trAJYWOP
t�io'!"�►,'4I !11 OUT OW a an M& go, $Y t e, f Nary w:AwT