Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutConditional Exception 71-7 - A.L. Gindling Company - Real Es J 1 7 April 6, 3.971. A. L. Gindling Company 6303 Wilshirn Blvd. Los Angeles , CA 90048 Attention: A. L. Gindling Re : Appeal to CE 71-7 Dear Sir: Your representative, Mr, Earl. Garrawa a peared before the City Council on April 5, 1371, requesting reconsider- ation on the appeal filed by your Company,. Following considerable discussion, Council again rejected your eppeal. We are again returning your appeal fee is the amount of $75.00. Sincerely yours, Paul C. .Jones City Clark E1jc. Check 02112 A. L. Cindlifig A. L. G IND LING CM I PAN Y 6303 WILS111kE SOJLEVARD LOS ANCEL [S. CALIFOR141A 90018 651 . 2700 March 30, 971 IHonorable City Council City Hall Huntington Beach, California Re: Appeal from Conditional Exception 071-7 Gentlemen: I We wish to appeal from a decision is fhe above referenced case. `7e sent a letter and money for such an appeal, a copy of the letter' .Ad cheek are enclosed. The letter wan sent by mail and although sent before March 12, 1971, the deadline for appeal, it was received by you on r.arch 15, 1971. We were not informed that the $75. 00 fee was required, but hand- delivered it w1jen notified that it was required. n i ► the teckrdcal requirement of the � We hereby request that you waive i . q filing being received late and decide the case on its' merits. To be denied the continued use of the sign in question will work a severe hardship on our sales program. Thank you for your consideration. Very truly yours, A. L. GINDLING COMPANY A. L. Gindlin .�-,r..... ALG!kb ` I A. L. GINDUNG COMPANY 6303 WItSHIIt t4ULEYAID (03- ANGItIS, CALI /OIHIA 9004A 65I • 3700 ' March 11 , 1971 RECEIVED MAR 115 1971 Planning Department P. O. Box 194 Huntington Beach, California Subject: Conditional Exception No. 71-7 Gentlemen: We hereby appeal from the decision of the Planning C.:omt-mission in the above referenced case in which they disapproved the continued use of our sign at Bolsa and Edwards. I Our company built many hundreds of houses in the immediate area of Bolsa and Edwards. During the3 last three yearn we have gotten imams repossessions of these houses. Due to the: slow selling market, coupled with the tight money and credit situation, we were forced to rent these i repossessed hu-ises rather than sell them. Now that: the market has improved and financing is available, we are selling these rentals off as quickly .;9 the market will absorb them. Dublin Realty is the Hales agent. The sign under consideration is a very valuable and irnportaiit selling tool. 1t is tired only to st:'.1 the that we ourselves built and had rented. An soon as they are sold, v:o will remove the sign. To be deprived of tho use of the sign will be a hardship and greatly slow the Gelling of these rental houses that number approximately 250. The quicker they are sold the: getter for the neighticirs, the community, the city, and all partics concerned, since pemianont buyers are much more: desirable than renters or -acant houses. j We shall appreciate your onside.r.ation of our request to be: allowed to continue the :use of thin sign only for thesale of these: rental houar,e and only for the time it requires to rnarket them. Thank you. Very truly your*. A. L. GIN V'3 COMPANY A. 1.. Ginetlitt j�•LG/kb i 1 i March 17, 1971 ref i.nd 1 inS Company A. L. G � Y 6303 Wilshire Blvd. � Los Angeles , CA 9OD48 Attention: A. L. Gindling Company Dear_. Sir: , your letter of appeal to the Plannieng Commission's denial of Conditional Exeept;.on 71-7, a copy of which I am raturnirg to ou, was received 'An our office this morning• This matter was brought to my attention on Monday, March 15th by a reprdeen�- ative of the Planning Department, no having been recPtved in theft offi^.e that; morning. i Since the last day for legally filing an Appeal under Article 988 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Codes would have been Friday, Harch 12th at 5 :00 Y.M. , I brought the matter before t1le City Council at their Monday night meeting. Council direct- ad, by minute action, that she appeal be rejected as it had Failed to meet the requirements of the Ordinance Code . I am returning herewith, your check in the amount of $75.00 submitted sa a fee for filing such appotal and an exc cf th e e minutes of Morch 15th mevetina covertnig said COMMM action* Sincerely yours, PAU1 C. Jones city Clerk 1 FCJ:arw Ines. &T tYr OF THE hCTION OF CI,� ,outNC_ It. �C Alow Council Chamber, City HsLI Huntington Beach California MaUdAX , Mar 15 , 1971 Mayor I!W zampure M8to v called the regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach to order at 4: 30 o'clock P.M. Councilmen Present:: . Qltlet„ t l Gi Logy ,Coen' _ N - { Councilmen Absent: Gran , Shi21_ey,,,� ��_ Filing of Apneal - Conditional. Exception No . 71-7 - -D d ,?-���4-4 The City Clerk infurmed Council that on March 15, 1971, the Planning Commission received an appeal filed by A . L . Gindling , addressed to their department appealing their denial. of Conditional Exception No, 71-7 , and that the required appeal fee of $75 had been hand delivered shortly thereafter. He stated that the appeal had not been filed according to the requirements set forth in Article 988 of the HuntingtonM. Beach Ordinance Code , as the deadline ''or filing such appeal was 5 . 00 Friday , March 12, 1971 . The Clerk stated that he proposes to reject such appeal, ua acceptance of same could possibly set a pre-cc lent which would affect: all future appeals filed under this section of the ordinance code. ` The City Attorney and Planning Director informed Council that they con- {: curred wieh the City Clerk' s decision to - deny said apnesl . On motion by Matney , Council directed that the appeal filed by A . L. Gindling to the denial by the Plar.ning Commies ion of Conditional Exception ff No . 71.,7 be rejected, as the appellant had failed to meet the requ).retrents for filing same . Motion carried . On motion by_ Coen the regular meP ..ing of the City Council of the City of Huntingto:. Beach adjourned . XXgjV"WXXl1W to Monday, '~larch 22, 1971 at 7 :30 P.M. , Ed.:.soru High School Cafeteria , corner of Magnolia Street and Atlanta Avenue . Motion carried. Paul -C . Jonis ,y City Clerk and ex•officio Clerk of theCity Council of the City of Huntington Beach , California ATTEST: - Jerry A . Matney Paul C. Jones Mayor Pro Tempore .. �+ r.ranr� City Clerk STATE OF CALL ORNIA ) County of Grange City of Huntington Beach ) 19 PAUL C . JONESr : the duly elected, qualified and acting City Clerk :c of the City of Huntington Beach, California, o hereby certify that the above and foregoing is a true and correct Statement of Action of the' City Council of said City at their, regular nryee t ing held on the 15th day a March 1 . .....r.....�... .. W*w M.+.�.-..r..r....r.r..r:.... WITNESS, ,my hand and, seal of the said City of Huntih ion Beach this the 16th day, of March 1� City Clerk and ;f-off i.c:i.o Clerk of tt�e City Counc#.1 cif ' t7h . City of Htsltinkton beach, i;s�l.faxnia BY: .,..,..; _ orepnty .r " { , � �is '��■•+•• . � ` . , C•'0i1 1TIONAL EXCEPTION 71- 7 Ft L. Glndlinr; • e ; 'I'oday, 14arc14 15a he P1ann;.n Gonunis fan rec l,Vp,d an''x _r peal addressed tv their'. department appealing "diaa�iorovaY 'ioY. �:r�� ' �l�rnin�; Comm.1;'SIon of this coed f tiona l ex.cept ion . -' f Said letter of appeal di.d riot include' "a check In the atrsourit Qf $75 .00 which is the appeal fee .. CU ..-h check has not been. received at the time of my Coming to Article 9BP,. of the 11w7 tington Beach Ordinance Code states, `fiat appeal may be made to the Clty Clerk i'rc)m any dQc1~:;.ion, Bete,,-ta a.tion or requirements of the Planning Coziunis - slon by i'illr natEsc }he' dof In wr1tlr�� -with the City Clem F;it'r�;n 10 a ."'%' ar~_fi i, , ucb ddr_;,u Ion or Bete imination or requirement is made. f''t ', i ;i+.tip+;� t:1 ttio muter ,,:as wade b;; the Planr.;.nr�, Com;"Assion at ��....� thr{x'` ree;uler meeting held ,�e,rch ? . Article 088 also stioulates that the City Clem; ,Ball Save no ice oL any appeal to all pz•operty owners aIthir ?U:1 feet of any property `+ on ::hick an appeal to the City Council has be--n f1 led . To cover the ` expenjef; of such no:ice a $75, 00 :'::�� shall be paid by the appellant at the rime notice of Rupeal in f•_led . Ten days from the dale of the i"firinLng Cain.7iss ior: rjeetir:g ;could have expired at. the close of bus iries.s ( 5; 0C i'.Jf . ) ,-,n :Friday, March 12 . At no1:ir�c }ln th��� ac�rell,A'. cc•^:�� to tY,c: City t;?.er;: ' of x"ice o r _Pokt:n �111,ectly �tii t,h any of the staN of my orflce . i I nerd d.trac': ior: fro,,:, the Council :since tcy interpretation 0' the :�rrii.nar�r:�. cote v.o uld be t'h,t.t requiretrent fori 11 n►; theap�pec�l h::v : and pd'opc)-e to I,0t,,-c u °;%ich appeal . thic appeal 1.:•; alloved , it L :) apt tU -,L%t a r recedent which f:ilI affe(.A all future apperils filed under LhIs sect,Ion of the- code . r �,,,,.. i-• , Y f � era , l • ^. A I•, ' NG C GM P1tNY • QUtt /Ato • L'09 A1101193, �)�]I Wtt�NIRE R CAtlF01N1,4 90044 651 •2700 Marcl311, 197 ' RECEIVED MAR I .5 1971 Planning Department P. 0. Box 190 Huntington Beach,. California, Subject: Conditional Exception No. 71-7 G entlemon: We hereby appeal from the decision of the: Planning Cornmiasian in the ehov` referenced case in which they disapproved the continued use of our sign at Bolsa and Edwards, Our company built 1nany hundrsds of houses in the iyr,rnediate area of • Balsa and Edwards. During the last three years we have gotten mzny � E repossessions of these h-..- -iee. Due to the slow sel.ltng market, coupled with the tight money and' �.Zedlt situation, wt were forced to rent these: repossessed houses ,rather than sell them. Now that the market has improved and financing Is available, we are selling these rentals off as quickly as the market will absorb th;rn. Dublin Realty is the sales agent. The sign ,6ndocr consideration is a very valuable and important selling tool. It is used only to sell the houses that we ourselves buLlt and had rented. As soon as they ,tore sold, wa will remove the s.gnt, To be deprived of the ush of the sign will be a'-hardship and greatly alow the selling of these rental houses that number approximatAy 250. ''he quicker they are sold the batter for the neighbors, tho conamunity, v se city, and all partica concarned, since pamnsment boyers are much rnire `desirable than rentetra or vacant houses. We shall apprceSsta_ your coriside:ration of our, request to bo allowed to , continue the uac tittbis sign only for the sale "of these rental houses and only for the time if=egti'reb to market thel'nt: ►, Thazik you. 1r i r ,1 , ? + '. r ♦�t I .I t Ir " , - t �, r ri 7 Very y trulyours p t ,yMur s,'. t f �`i � i p .i S •t j' r t..` ',r'M `� \ t t 1 j,. ( Are •�,•, +! , t t` �1 •t r.rS( c y '.. � �,, y '♦ ,. .'.±`}7;►t.}� "�r�it'�rl� I + ,�/ `• b -.fllfSJ' Y,.r� t r •' ' + •a'L• �a• �llt i.� !.�V. i/� A�i � .. �i:i l a s4 , ttl. ; 1 .. .r 1 .r .{ r t y.l . 1 r. tr a v � r/�/1.� 1�� ^� . <�rai 1. ,:- �.,t � ! 'y' i t- ai ♦F 1 ' •. .i�, , t t , Yi'! , i ,} .�. litlAf .• i' f f,,. •5 a ? t. �� t 1?r� tl ,,• , ti 3 t :t r .. Ly Girldling F, Julr , +y t.. . a .•J , •, ,' ' J;• i yj� �f1�i '`(;,� la',�, a r tt s/ �/ 1. r t r .• • r �• r t 1, r ''� r s ds ,t • !_ ,, )M 4 •, , � ".4! i;jrR .• L t 9 f . , • .ter 1.• ,�,1npp•r r t ' +tom' ' tt_ ., {� PLANNING MI INISTRATION S. 9880 ARTICLE 988 APPEAL S. 9880 APPEAL ©tom PLICAW OR INTERESTED PARTIES. Appeal may be matte to the City Cuunci 1 from any decision, determination or requirements of the Planning Commission by filing notice thereof in writing with the City Clerk within ten ( 10) days after such decision or determination or requirement is matte. Such notice shall set forth in detail the action and grounds by and upon which the applicant or interested party deem himself aggrieved . (972 ) S.998_8_l1 CIIALLErtGE 8Y COUNCIL. The City Council or any member there- of may request n writing, without explanation, within the 10 day period for appeal , a hearing before the City Council to consider any decision or determination or requirement of the Planning Commission. ( 972 ) S. 9882 REPORT. The City Clerk shall report the filing of such no�lce to the Planning Commission and a written report, shall be submitted to the City Council by the Planning Commission or shall be represented at the hearing. The party r;hose decision, determination or requirement by the Planning Cominission is upon appeal , may Submit a written report to the City Council for consideration. (972 ) S. NOTICE. The City Clerk shall give notice of any *such appeal to all property owners within 300 feet of any property on which an appeal to the City Council has been filed. To cover the expenses of such notice a S75. 00 fee shall be paid by the appellant . This notice fee must be paid at the time notice of appeal is filed . Nothing in this section shall be construed to mean that a !'fling fee is necessary if the appeal is made by a mc::iber of the City Council. ( 1227) S. 9884 ACTION ON APPEAL. Said appeal shall be set, for hearing wIthin thirty 30) ttnys , or longer, i.f requested by appel- lant , from the time the matter is received dy the City Clerk, together with the neeeesary £ees. Upon the' hearing of said appeal , the City Council may nffirm, overrule or modify the decision appealed from and enter such order or orders as are in harmony with the spirit and purposes of applicable provisions of Division 9, with reasons stated Such disposition of the appe..1 by the City Council shall be made within sixty (GO ) days after the hearing and shall be final. ( 1230 ) �T y FANNING ADMINISTRATION S. 9880 ARTICLE 988 APPEAL S APPEAL BY APPLICANT OR INTMIESTED PARTIES . Appeal may be made to the City Council from any decision, determination or requirements of the Planning Commission by riling notice thereof in writing with the City Clerk within ten (10) days after such decision or determination or requirement is made. Such notice shall set forth in detail the action and grounds by and upon which the applicant or interested party deem himself aggrieved. (972 ) I 9881 CHALLENGE BY ` COUNCIL. The City Council or any member there- of may request in writing , without explanation , within the 10 day period for appeal , a hearing before the City Council to consider any decision or determination or requirement- of the Planning �I Commission. (972 ) °., 382 REPORT. The City Clerk shall report the filing of such no ice to the Planning Commission and a written report shall be submitted to tLe City Council by the Planning Commission or shall be represented at the hearing. The party whose decision , determination or requirement by the Planning Commission is upon appeal , may submit a written report to the City Council for consideration. (972) S. 9883 NOTICE. The City Clerk shall give notice of any 'such appeal �t'di1 property owners within '000 feet of any property on which an appeal t►. the City Council has been filed. To cover the expenses of such notice a S75.00 fce shall be paid by the appellant. This notice fee must he paid at the time notice of appeal Is filed. Nothing in this section shall be construed to mean that a filing fee is necessary if the appeal is made by a member of ttie City Council. . ( 1227 ) S. qms-I ACTION ON APPEAL. Said appeal shall be set for hearing within thirty .30) days , or longer , if requested by apnelr- lnnt , roin the time tt_e matter is received tty the City Clerk, together with tho necessi,%ry fees. Upon the hearing of said appeal , the City Council may affirm , overrule or modify the decision appealed from and enter such order or orders as are in harmony with the spirit And rarposes of applicable provisions of Division 9; with vensons stated. � Such disposition of the appeal by the City Council shall be made within sixty (60) days after the hearing and shall be final . (1230) A. GINDLING COMPANY 6903 WILSHIRE SOUtEVARO • toS ANGEt [S, CAL; rORNIA 90U4Sr� 700 1G� r�U RK March 11, 1971 MY MY i�.�F 10411111U N BEACH,CALIN, 1971 R 17 An : a 4 City Council P. 0. Box 190 Huntington Beach, Californi i. Subject: Conditional Exc--ptian No. 71-7 Gentlemen: We hereby appeal from the decision of the Planning Commisnion in the above referenced case In which they disapproved the continued use of our sign at Balsa an,' Adwards. Our company built many hundreds of houses in the immediate area of Bolsa and Edwards. During the last three years we have gotten many repossessions of these houses. Due to the slow selling market, coupled with the tight money and credit situation, we were forced to rent these repossessed houses rather than sell them, at the market has improved and financing is available we are � Now that iep Q ► selling these rentals off as quickly as the market will absorb them. Dublin Real is the sales agent. Realty fi The sign under consideration is a very valuable and important selling tool.. It is used only to sell the houses that we ourselves built and had rented. As soon as they are sold, we will remove the sign. To be deprived of the use of the sign will be a, hardship and greatly slow the selling of these rental houses that number approximately 250. The quicker they are sold the better far the neighbors, the community, the city, and all parties concerned, '::ince permanent buyers are much rnore desirable than renters or vacant houses. We shall appreciate your con3idexation of our request to be allowed to continue the use of this sign only for the.sale of these rental houses and only for the time it requires to market them. Thank you. Very truly yours, A. L. GINING COMPANY A. L. Ciro ng t• C( N IUT10PAL EXG£k"i' ON 71-7 J • ,. Today," Marchl5, t ho Plarinir�l, Cc�rrri r it)n received ari a.fspc.4al add reused to the•l r department appealing• d 1 sapp ro ve 1 by the Plan►4 ir1:3 Cor:M L z,i oii Of ttii. ; +.ond i.t '(,naI except Ion . Said 1c:tt;er of' appeal did r'lot; ln:lude a check in tt:e rrount oa ' 475. 00 ;which ,is ti:e appeal fee . su-1) check ha_, Y;cr Lean rt;cc.lved at the time of MY CUML1t to this 14L'e ng, hrtic:le 988 of tti•-: '.1mitingtcr. F?eacl: Ordinance Code state t}zmc appeal may be made to Lhe City Clerk from tiny decision, determ inatio.a! or requirements L-f. the P1,3rv�inb sion by filing notice thereof in W r.itinr wi lh the City C. erf. w-lthin 11) days after such decision or determinatton or re gui ri!ment is mom. rjetemiri7.�ion in the matter was made fly a4 • their rat,ula.r meeting held "•'arch 2 . Article r.? g also stipulates that, th•� C:ty C11%,*k sh"'1J. 1 Izi-v notice of any appeal to all property within 30" fee of L.-ny property on s•Mch an appeal to 11.-e City Councl_l has been filed To cover the exper.:>es of such now.ice a $75 .00 fee s."All be paid by the appellant at t tie time notice of ep��eal i5 filed . Ter, days, From the date of the Pl.annii, Con.*;isaival meeting Would !lnve— expired z;t the of bu3inec3 l5: CCU p.t-i. ) or,, Fviday, March 12- . At no time ha,, the appellant cwtle 7;0 the C,•i i:y Cle: ru st:at:en directly .r:i.th ;�r:y of the 0-1t .ff of sry Office . I. need direct;cn from the Council since vW ill torprettxtloll of the ordina.rcn code ,could lie that requiremen-s !'or f.i.?Ing 'the appeal h,,tve not been viet:, and 1 oropO:,-C to reject such appeal. . If this appeal is allowed , it is apt to set a p1•;;cer3ent 'rhir:h r '. ad under this se�:t .��n Of tVice' ecde . i 1.. r appeals n 1.. i all fut ure a . . .. feet pp , will � 'a _ ,r • , r.. 1 ,; .. 'tt •. ` .. •'fir;l r .A. L. GINDLING COMP-MY 6303 WILSHIRE GOU1tYARD LOS AH,71t1S, CAtI ►ORHIA f 0 0 4 1 b31 .27CC March 11, 1971 RECEIVED Planning epurtmc:nt. P. O. Bux 190 lluntinI;ton Beach, t; ,11fornia Subject:: Conditional Excerption No. '71 -7 Gentlemen: 1 We hereby appeal frorn t.hc decision of the Planning; Cc►n mh; sion in the 'a above referenced case +n which they disapproved the contimied izse of Our sign at. Balsa acid Edwards. Our company built many hundrads of houses in the immediate area of liulsa and Edwards,, During the last three years we have: g;ntten many repossetisions of these houses. Due to the: slvty selling; market., coupled r with the UO-.t money and credit situation. we %ere forced to rent these repossessed houses rather: than sell dir—m. No,.. that the marYet has improved and financing is available. we are selling rhesc rentals off as quickly au the niarket ivill absorb them. D':hlin Realty is the :jale s agent. [in under cmir;i dv ration is Rt very v•alu able and important sel,lir.g tool. It is used only to sell the houses that we: ouraelvRes h,ti [r. and had rented. As soon as they are, scald, Nve %vOl remove the sign. To be deprived of the u:;e: of the sign %will he a hardship and g;really a1mv the selling of these rental liom4e:s that mimher upproxitnatee;y 210. The. quicker I:hey art. suld the bctter for the; neighborm, the community, tbe city, and all parties concerned. since pie rtnanont huy ers are much tz1ore desirable than renter" or vacant houses. We shell appreciate your consideration of our request to be allowed to continue the rise of this sign only for the t%alc-• of these rental hutioes and arty for the time it requi rcas to trarkct %hem. 7 hank you. Vei-ry truly yours, - A. L, GIND 1\V COM t1J`f a A I,: . Ctitsili.�1 � A L i/k?.1