Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCUP 90-12/TT 14357/ND 90-23/GPA 90-3/ZC 90-23-Apprvd revi REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION March 18, 1991 Date Submitted to: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members Submitted by: Michael T. Uberuaga, City Administratorov Y Prepared b : Michael Adams, Director of Community Development P Subject: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-12 WITH SPECIAL PERMITS/ TENTATIVE TRACT MAP 14357/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 90-23 APPROVED BY CITY COUNCIL Consistent with Council Policy? Vyes [ ] New Policy or Exceptio 3, /P / Statement of Issue, Recommendation,Analysis, Funding Source,Alternative ctions,Attachments: I CITY CLERK STATEMENT OF ISSUE: Transmitted for your reconsideration is a 92-unit condominium/ townhome project submitted by the Redevelopment Agency and Bijan Sassounian. The original project, consisting of 135 condominiums, was reviewed by the City Council on appeal on November 5, 1990 . The Council overturned the Planning Commission' s approval and denied the project . On November 18, 1990, the Council reconsidered their previous action, and directed the applicant to work with staff to devise a new plan with reduced density and which would not be limited to senior residents . The applicant withdrew the original plan, and after working with staff, is submitting a revised plan for the Council ' s review and approval. RECOMMENDATION• Motion to: Approve the revised site plans, floor plans and elevations dated February 8, 1991, subject to the findings and conditions of approval as outlined in Attachment 1. . ANALYSIS: Background The project as originally approved by the Planning Commission on October 2, 1990, consisted of a 135 unit condominium complex on two sites, which totaled 4 . 5 gross acres . The sites were proposed to develop as one integrated complex, with a centrally located common recreation area. One 55 unit building was proposed on the north site and one 38 unit and one 42 unit building were proposed on the south site. Assigned secured parking for residents, as well as guest parking, was provided in a subterranean garage beneath each corresponding building. Plo 5/85 i The project as currently proposed consists of 50 stacked condominium units located on the northerly site, and 42 two-story townhomes on the southerly site. The common recreation area is located on the northerly site. The following sections address important issues as identified by the City Council, Planning Commission, and surrounding residents . 1. Density The overall project density has been reduced from 30 units per gross acre (135 units) to 20.4 units per gross acre (92 units) . This represents the middle range of the Medium-High Density Residential category. 2 . Building Type The previous plan was composed entirely of stacked condominium flats in two to three story structures . In order to increase compatibility with the single family homes to the south, .the applicant has revised the unit type on the southerly site to include only townhome buildings with tuck-under garages. There are 8 buildings, each composed of 5 to 6 townhomes . The structures are placed perpendicular to the street and the southerly property line, further reducing the appearance of building bulk from adjacent residences and the street . The northerly site still consists of stacked flats, however- the height and density have been decreased. 3 . Building Height- The applicant has. reduced the majority of the project to a maximum of 2 stories. On the northerly site, approximately one third of the structure is three stories, with the remainder at two stories. The three story elements allow for architectural variation, and are within the height limits called for by the zoning ordinance. Only two third-story units will face the existing residential development to the west . These are buffered, however, by an average 30 foot setback to the property line. The remaining third story units face Talbert Avenue and Joyful Lane. On the southerly site, all townhomes are a maximum of two stories in height. Each unit contains living area above a private, two-car, tuck/under garage. The applicant ' s previous plans had shown up to two thirds of the southerly site as three-story units. 4 . Building Setback The applicant ' s previous plans required a special permit to allow a 20 foot building setback along the southern most property line, adjacent to R1, single-family residences . This need resulted from the length and height of the condominium building. The proposed townhome buildings are located 40 feet from the R1 property line, and will not require a special permit for building setback. All other building setbacks for both the north and the south site will also meet or exceed maximum required setbacks, with the exception of the pool fencing and clubhouse as described below (Special Permits) . RCA 3-18-91 -2- (8885d) 5 . Affordable Housing A portion of proposed development is located on property currently owned by the City' s Redevelopment Agency. The developer has an Exclusive Right to Negotiate for the purchase of that property, and the Agency staff will continue in an effort to provide acceptable housing opportunities . Staff will investigate the possibility of providing financing opportunities for low and moderate income families as a condition of the sale of the property. 6 . Access/Parking The northerly site is accessed in the same location as on the previous plans . A central driveway along� Joyful Lane leads to the subterranean structure where all resident and guest parking for the north site is provided. All resident parking is secured behind gates . The southerly site is accessed from 4 driveways along Happy Drive. The driveways lead to attached 2-car garages for each unit, and to the open guest parking for the southerly site. 7. Special Permits The applicant is requesting seven special permits, four of which relate to the northerly site and were requested in conjunction with the previously proposed plans, and.. three of which relate to the southerly site and are necessitated by the reconfiguration to a townhome design.: The-special-permit requests are described below. A. North Site (condominiums) (1) To reduce side-by-side building separation from .55 feet to 20 feet . The northerly "building" is actually composed of 2 u-shaped structures . Section 9150. 9(d) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code requires 10 feet between side-by-side buildings, plus 5 feet for each dwelling unit in excess of two 'in either of the structures . Since each building is composed of 11 "stacks" of units, a total of 55 feet is required between the structures. Staff supports the special permit request because the U-shape of the buildings and the reduction of the building profile to mostly 2 stories meet the intent of the building separation requirement, which is to soften the building mass. The two structures are connected by a central elevator and essentially function as one building. RCA 3-18-91 -3- (8885d) (2) To allow a 75 foot average dimension for the main recreation area in lieu of 100 feet. Staff supports. this request because it allows the main recreation area to be centrally located between the north and south portions of the project . The applicant also meets the minimum required area by 5,722 square feet (total main recreation area - 15, 722 square feet) . The common open space areas (including landscape areas, courtyards, setbacks, etc. ) , exceeds the total common open space required by 4, 720 sq. ft. (total provided-59, 920 sq. ft. ) . (3) To allow a 7 to 10 foot front setback along Joyful Lane and the north side of Happy Drive in lieu of a minimum 15 foot setback for pool fencing and the common clubhouse building. The proposed special permit is for accessory uses only. The actual dwelling unit setback ranges from 20 feet to 70 feet. Staff supports the request because it allows the recreational area to be centrally located between the two sites, an because the recreation building, which is set back 10 feet, encroaches only along approximately 36% of that particular street frontage. The remaining encroachment consists of pool fencing. Staff is recommending that this fencing be of an open or see-through type, such as wrought iron, to reduce the impacts from the right-of-way. (4) To allow up to 12% ramp slope into the parking structure, in lieu of 10%. The applicant requires a steeper slope on the entry ramp into the parking structure because the parking aisles within the structure are level . Section 9605. 1(h) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code allows deviations for such items as ramp slope provided they will not adversely affect the safety, efficiency or appearance of the structure. The applicant has submitted a report from Linscott, Law, and Greenspan, Traffic Engineers, which includes recommendations for the ramp design to ensure safety. Staff supports the request based on the traffic engineers report that the proposal can provide for safe and efficient circulation. B. South Site (townhomes) (5) To allow all two-story buildings for the townhomes in lieu of requiring 1/3 of the units to be one story lower than the remainder of units in the structure. RCA 3-18-91 -4- (8885d) This requirement is intended to reduce building bulk by ensuring that at least one third of the units are not constructed to the maximum height of three stories. In this case, however, the applicant has already reduced the majority of the project to two stories, with only one third of the northerly site and none of the southerly site at three stories . Although all buildings on the southerly site are at a uniform height of 2 stories in lieu of providing one third of the units at one story, the applicant has met the intent of the code by insuring height compatibility with adjoining homes and complying with all other building bulk requirements . Staff therefore supports the request. (6) To allow drive aisle to abut garages for townhomes in lieu of providing 20 foot driveways for 50% of the townhomes. The intent of this section is to allow for additional parking on driveway pads for at least half the units. The applicant, however, has provided private, 2-car garages for each unit, as well as on-site guest parking. Given the number and arrangement of the units, staff feels these provisions to be adequate. (7) To allow a 28 foot wide access drive for the townhomes in lieu of a 48 foot wide drive within 100 feet of the street. This provision is intended to accommodate traffic and stacking area at the entry/exit of a project where the driveway intersects a public street. This area is primarily required for large projects using a single access point. The accessways that service the townhomes, however, are used only by 10 to 12 single family townhomes, and 4 to 6 guest spaces per drive. Therefore, staff feels that the proposed 28 foot wide standard driveways provide adequate access and the most efficient design. Conclusion In conclusion, staff supports the project as revised because it is compatible with surrounding residential development in terms of density, height, scale and architecture, and will complete the development of the neighborhood in the Talbert-Beach Redevelopment Area. It will also satisfy the State requirement for use of Redevelopment set-aside funds for affordable housing, and fulfill goals outlined in the Housing Element of the General Plan. RCA 3-18-91 -5- (8885d) ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS Pursuant to the environmental regulations in effect at this time, the Department of Community Development advertised draft Negative Declaration No. 90-23 for public review and comment 21 days prior to the Planning Commission' s action. No comments were received with regard to the proposed Negative Declaration. All proposed mitigation measures have been incorporated as conditions of approval on the project. Prior to any action on Conditional Use Permit No. 90-12 with Special Permits or Tentative Tract Map No. 14357, the City Council must review and approve Negative Declaration o. 90-23 . FUNDING SOURCE: Non applicable. ALTERNATIVE ACTION: The City Council may: 1. Request that the applicant work further with Staff to modify the proposed plans. 2 . Deny Negative Declaration No. 90-23, Conditional Use Permit No. 90-12 with Special Permits, and Tentative Tract 14357 . 3 . Refer the project back to the Planning Commission for review and recommendation. ATTACHMENTS. 1. Suggested Findings and Conditions of Approval. 2 . Revised project plans dated February 8, 1991. 3 . RCA dated November 5, 1990 . 4 . Planning Staff reports dated October 2, 1990 and September 5, 1990 . MTU:MA:LP: lp RCA 3-18-91 -6- (8885d) ATTACHMENT 1 FINDINGS AND CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-12 W/SPECIAL PERMITS TENTATIVE TRACT 14357 FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL - CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-12 : 1. The location, site layout, and design of the proposed 92 unit condominium/townhome project properly adapt the proposed structures to streets, driveways, and other adjacent structures and uses in a harmonious manner, because the setbacks have been increased to adjacent R1 property, the project is primarily 2-story, and the architecture has been modified to more closely reflect surrounding projects . 2 . The access to and parking for the proposed 92 unit condominium/ townhome complex does not create an undue traffic problem, because the parking structure has been shown to be safe and efficient and the surrounding streets have adequate capacity to accommodate the traffic generated. 3 . The planned residential development for 92 units does conform to the provisions contained in Article 915 except for the special permit requests, which improve the quality of the project (see Special Permit Findings for Approval) . 4 . The proposed 92 unit project will not be detrimental to the general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity; and property and improvements in the vicinity of such use or building, because the project is properly buffered from such uses by streets and setbacks, and has been reduced in scale and density to more closely reflect existing development in the vicinity. 5 . The proposed 92 unit condominium/townhome project will be compatible with the Huntington Beach General Plan and Zoning upon adoption of General Plan Amendment No. 90-3 and •Zone Change 90-3.. 'FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL - SPECIAL PERMITS: 1. The following special permits promote a better living environment by adapting the Planned Residential Development requirements to better suit the 92 unit condominium/townhome complex, which are compatible with the surrounding area: a. To allow a 7 to 10 foot front setback along Joyful Lane and the north side of Happy Drive in lieu of minimum 15 foot setback, for pool fencing and the common clubhouse building. b. To allow a 28 ' wide access drive to the townhomes in lieu of a 48 ' wide drive within 100 feet of a public street. c. To reduce side-by-side building separation for Building 1 from 55 feet to 20 feet . d. To allow all two story development for the townhomes in lieu of requiring one third of the units in each structure to be one story less . e. To allow an average dimension of 75 feet for the main recreation area in lieu of 100 feet. f . To allow up to 12% ramp slopes into the underground parking structures in lieu of a maximum 10% slope on ramps with no adjacent parking. g. To allow the access drives to the twonhomes to abut garages in lieu of requiring a 20 foot setback for 50% of the garages . 2 . The requested deviation for ramp slopes to the parking structure is acceptable because: a. A traffic study prepared by a traffic engineer has been submitted which documents the impacts of the request . b. The deviation will not adversely affect the circulation and safety of the site structure, use, or adjacent use. c. The deviation will result in' a more efficient circulation pattern and parking layout. d. The deviation will enhance ,the general appearance of the development and its surroundings by allowing all parking for the condominiums to be subterranean. e. The deviation will not be. detrimental to the general public health, safety, welfare or convenience, or injurious to property values in the vicinity. 4 . The requested special permits provide for maximum use of aesthetically pleasing types of architecture, landscaping, design and building layout, by allowing for efficient on-site circulation, buffering adjacent land uses, allowing for a centrally located recreation area, and increasing building compatibility with surrounding residential development. 5 . The requested special permits will not be detrimental to the general health, welfare, safety and convenience, nor detrimental or injurious to the value of property or improvements of the neighborhood or of the City in general. The special permit requests incorporated into the project design will reduce project impacts to adjacent properties. -2- (8865d) 6 . The requested special permits are consistent with the objectives of the Planned Residential Development standards in achieving a development adapted to the terrain and compatible with the surrounding environment. FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL - TENTATIVE TRACT NO. 14357: 1. The size, depth, frontage, street width, and other design features of the proposed subdivision for 92 condominium/townhome units are in compliance with the standard plans and specifications on file with the City as well as in compliance with the State Subdivision Map Act and the supplemental City Subdivision Ordinance. 2 . The analysis for General Plan Amendment No. 90-3 and Zone Change No. 90-3 has determined that this intensity of land use (Medium- High Density Residential - Maximum 25 units per gross acre) is appropriate for this site. 3 . The General Plan has set forth provisions for Medium-High Density Residential Development and affordable housing, as well as setting forth objectives for the implementation of this type of use. 4 . The site is relatively flat and physically suitable for the proposed density of 20 .4 units per gross acre. 5 . Tentative Tract No. - 14357 for a 92 unit condominium/townhome complex is consistent with-°the - goals and policies of the Huntington Beach General Plan. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL - CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-12 : 1. The site plan, floor plans, and elevations received and dated February 28, 1991, shall be the conceptually approved layout. 2. The sale of the Redevelopment Agency' s property to the applicant for inclusion in the project shall be contingent upon the applicant and/or agency providing a financing mechanism which makes available 20% of the units to families of low and moderate income. 3 . Prior to submittal for building permits, the applicant/owner shall complete the following: a. Submit three copies of the site plan to the Planning Division for addressing purposes. b. Depict all utility apparatus, such as but not limited to backflow devices and Edison transformers, on the site plan. They shall be prohibited in the front and exterior yard setbacks unless properly screened by landscaping or other method as approved by the Community Development Director. -3- (8865d) c. Floor plans shall depict natural gas and 220V electrical stubbed in at the location of clothes dryers; natural gas shall be stubbed in at the locations of cooking facilities, water heaters, and central heating units; and low-volume heads shall be used on all spigots and water faucets. d. If foil-type insulation is to be used, a fire retardant type shall be installed as approved by the Building Department and indicated on the floor plans . e. The structures on the subject property, whether attached or detached, shall be constructed in compliance with the State acoustical standards set forth for units that lie within the 60 CNEL contours of the property. Evidence of compliance shall consist of submittal of an acoustical analysis report, prepared under the supervision of a person experienced in the field of acoustical engineering, with the application for building permit(s) . f. Elevations shall depict colors and building materials as approved by the Design Review Board. g. All rooftop mechanical equipment shall be screened from any view. Said screening shall be architecturally compatible with the building in terms of materials and colors . If screening is not designed specifically into the building, a rooftop mechanical equipment plan must be submitted showing screening and must be approved. h. If outdoor lighting is included, energy savings lamps shall be used. All outside lighting shall be directed to prevent "spillage" onto adjacent properties and shall be noted on the site plan and elevations . i . A detailed soils analysis shall be prepared by a registered Soils Engineer. This analysis shall include on-site soil sampling and laboratory testing of materials to provide detailed recommendations regarding grading, chemical and fill properties, foundations, retaining walls, streets, and utilities . j . The Design Review Board shall review and approve the following: (a) The final building form, colors and materials . (b) Pool fencing shall be of wrought iron or other see-through material. k. The site plan or reference page shall include all conditions of approval imposed on the project printed verbatim. 1 . The final site plan shall note the location of 100 cubic feet of storage area per unit for condominiums. -4- (8865d) 4 . Prior to issuance of building permits, the applicant/owner shall complete the following: a. A Landscape Construction Set must be submitted to the Departments of Community Development and Public Works and must be approved. The Landscape Construction Set shall include a landscape plan prepared and signed by a State Licensed Landscape Architect and which includes all proposed/existing plant materials (location, type, size, quantity) , an irrigation plan, a grading plan, an approved site plan, and a copy of the entitlement conditions of approval . The landscape plans shall include intense landscape buffers, and shall be in conformance with Section 9608 and Article 915 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. The set must be approved by both departments prior to issuance of building permits . b. A grading plan shall be submitted to the Department of Public Works for review and it must be approved (by issuance of a grading permit) . A plan for silt control for all water runoff from the property during construction and initial operation of the project may be required if deemed necessary by the Director of Public Works . C. Hydrology and hydraulic studies shall be submitted for Public Works approval . d. All applicable Public Works fees shall be paid. e. Final Tract Map shall• be accepted by the City Council, recorded with the Orange County Recorder and a copy filed with the Department of Community Development. f . An interim parking and/or building materials storage plan shall be submitted to the Department of Community Development to assure adequate parking is available for employees, customers, contractors, etc. , during the project ' s construction phase. g. Prior to issuance of building permits, a water plan shall be submitted to the water department . The plan shall detail measures which the project shall implement to reduce peak hour water usage. 5 . The Public Works Department requirements are as follows : a. Private driveways shall be of radius-type construction, per Huntington Beach Standard 211 A and B. . 6 . Fire Department Requirements are as follows : a . An automatic fire sprinkler system shall be approved and installed pursuant to Fire Department regulations . Shop drawings to be submitted to and approved by Fire Department prior to installation. -5- (8865d) b. Service roads and fire lanes, as determined by the Fire Department, shall be posted and marked. C. Fire access lanes shall be maintained. If fire lane violations occur and the services of the Fire Department are required, the applicant will be liable for expenses incurred. d. Three fire hydrants shall be installed prior to combustible construction, and at locations specified by the Fire Department. e. The applicant shall meet all applicable local, State and Federal Fire Codes, Ordinances, and standards . f. A Class III wet standpipe system (combination) will be installed to comply with Huntington Beach Fire Department and Uniform Building Code standards. g. A fire alarm system will be installed to comply with Huntington Beach Fire Department and Uniform Fire Code standards. h. Fire extinguishers will be installed and located in areas to comply with Huntington Beach Fire Code standards . i . Elevators will be sized .to accommodate an ambulance gurney (Minimum 6 ' 8" wide by. 4 ' 3" deep, minimum 42" opening. j . Security- gates will be designed to _comply with Huntington Beach Fire -Department Standard No. 403 . k. Address numbers will be installed to comply with Huntington Beach Fire Code standards. 1 . Submit to Fire Department for approval a Fire Protection Plan containing requirements of Fire Department Specification No. 426. M. Applicant shall pay for "Opticom" traffic system at Beach and Talbert. 7. The development shall comply with all applicable provisions of the Ordinance Code, Building Division, and Fire Department . 8 . All building spoils, such as unusable lumber, wire, pipe, and other surplus or unusable material, shall be disposed of at an off-site facility equipped to handle them. 9 . Installation of required landscaping and irrigation systems shall be completed prior to final inspection. 10 . During construction, the applicant shall: a . Discontinue construction during second stage smog alerts . -6- (8865d) b. Wet down areas in the late morning and after work is completed for the day. C. Use low sulfur fuel ( .05% by weight) for construction equipment. 11. Construction shall be limited to Monday - Saturday 7: 00 AM to 8 : 00 PM. Construction shall be prohibited Sundays and Federal holidays. 12 . Should any cultural materials be encountered during the initial site survey or during grading and excavation activities, all activity shall cease and the archaeologist shall be obtained to determine the appropriate course of action. 13 . During cleaning, grading, earth moving or excavation, the applicant shall : a. Control fugitive dust by regular watering, paving construction roads, or other dust preventive measures . b. Maintain equipment engines in proper tune. 14 . Prior to initiation of construction, police and fire departments shall be notified and the departments shall be kept informed about duration.- and. extent .of construction throughout the process . 15 . Public Works.-Department shall provide alternate routes for traffic during. .the .construction .phase, if. necessary. Adequate signage shall. be provided _ to= warn moto:r.. vehicles,. bicyclists and pedestrians of construction. 16 . This conditional use permit and tentative tract shall not become effective until General Plan Amendment No. 90-3 and Zone Change No. 90-3 have been approved by the City Council and are in effect. 17. This conditional use permit shall become null and void unless exercised within one (1) year of the date of final approval, or such extension of time as may be granted by the Planning Commission pursuant to a written request submitted to the Planning Department a minimum 30 days prior to the expiration date. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL - TENTATIVE TRACT 14357: 1 . Tentative Tract Map No. 14357 shall be revised to reflect the project as shown on the site plans dated February 28, 1991. a. "Notes" shall be revised to reflect correct zoning and General Plan designation. 2 . At least 60 days prior to recordation of the final tract map, CC&R' s shall be submitted to and approved by the City Attorney and the Department of Community Development. The CC&R' s shall reflect the and maintenance of all common areas by the Homeowners ' Association. -7- (8865d) 3 . This tentative tract shall not become effective until General Plan Amendment No. 90-3 and Zone Change No. 90-3 have been approved by the City Council and are in effect. 4 . Any landscaping and enhanced pavement within the right-of-way shall be maintained by the Homeowners Association pursuant to an approved agreement with the. City Public Works Department 5 . On-site sewers shall be private. 6 . The water system shall be located in vehicular travel ways and dedicated to the City. 7. The developer will be responsible for the payment of the Water Master Plan fee. 8 . The developer will be responsible for the payment of the Traffic Impact fees at the time building permits are issued. 9 . The project shall accept all contributory drainage from properties to the south, which shall be accommodated through the site in a manner to the satisfaction of the Department of Public Works. 10 . Construct full Public Works improvements to the centerline of Talbert Avenue. 11. The on-site sewer and- water systems shall be shown on a City approved utility plan, showing all water services, fire hydrants, fire services, and backflow devices. 12 . Developer shall submit water system hydraulic calculations to ensure system adequacy and line sizing. 13 . The water system shall be looped, with no dead ends, and shall be installed per the Public Works Department ' s standards, ordinances, and policies. 14 . Developer shall dedicate vehicular access rights to the City except at access points approved by the City. -8- (8865d) r �. i PARKING SUMMARY: !%IflOd'ME , I la COVERAGE \ ..,»..E....Ir.ra.i n .n I r»r.w•eay. I \ Oe�ert 22 A A 16 . ww i x r Yv. ww w A •1 r e_aa n n err e_V. i ere var. a if. n BulumNa TYPE 1 wUNITS r Ld D II OPEN SB4CE ° �1 o�eweers Ue1T 0 AT DID n D m eer PIDOII Gels AT THIS LOrATIO ■lw._V.•Y V. 1Vi V. �1 PRIMARY lFG I ereeei �lr V. —— IOCI' {AIQAfB !f1 y NAPPY r r _ OWE BUILgNG TYPE "t.a 3 � —. '.� `.� -.3•'g:K`_:. "'^+T Fps.; `�A '� 3� � M lz -y�"i✓.. �k FAMILY REMIDERCM SITE SUMMARY: IMAM Yrrer K arA_M }�•--� . trs e 2 SIQlY BiPA/FXiS r.s. e.evK UNT UNIT 0 TIP FUDQI It ss IM�� ar�q»l Ot1 ROm THREE SIES Lm,W � wes" 0 wIivRN -atALTLsATBOTTOMFUXR O 'IY.Ca R I W . CIS L&ATn�ONLY rr e er�rur.� IrA.,CRY W r tl e p e C ITV TECHNICAL SITE PLAN SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W ENTERPRISES INC . 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 170 sumFrrliD DAM?MAR% _ VIIml HUNTING7ON BEACH,CA 92648 •Ri, DATE:ALO.l�'IE�.,'.o'Ie0 (714)960 5505 e cup Mumma CUI W621tc W.1 LLIe TALBERT AVENUE F PARKING SUMMARY: eaR�R.la.s RURsrR Tri rwr Mwr u� lays W t�lre — wr M rY�Y M ri/Y M1 ls�R1v � lire �� � p YOl�6� ti Y f J i ii i MAurr alwa L J L i L .i L i i r � r ti r ti r a 39 0 � A �c w4 TECHNICAL GARAGE PLAN SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A VIEW ENTERPRISE S IN C . 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 170 wwmeowTeSJUNE% • 2 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 RR SIM MM-AM IUM (714)960-5505 I zmv i1..—".,.. • CUP MUMRER:CUP MH2/ZC MNl 2AM1 � ��ir--. s---tea is'- '�' '�i�' '�;.-.• ,,,> j=%'i MIN {ai ...._ �f w� it -- FLOW aLV owmoi wr oan+o �I OB CK uv(nyo-�� �esr duo i Y WAVE ru i e r-J u. v PLAN A 933 SF. ao ewr. craw r0 amw c curt. TM i 4 m a CFM�o emar PLAN A LOFT A LOFT 1120SF. e o BUILDING TYPE 1 FLOOR PLAN SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W E NTERP RI S E S I N C 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 170 w.emaoon,ew..o HUNTINGTON BEACH.CA 92648 rrvlrlo�view n u weo 4 (714)960-5505 "0■1 " M64i cvr awEa,CUFrI +c e3 w l it s no m • na E83 • J �l _ 1 Leo 1 uo IIE�MORM ■ � IIIu.."am ■ G"Clow 0 -� -� uuu� i e:u�ua 01 :■.�fffriii■ :ff■rf�i�ii u►yr �>.■ I.■■ur.•��.4i ■... 1.... ��...■ Iffff If1V_ I■ff■I Ifff! �J I 0 is::iG■i �� 0 i�f:ii no ®r _ • ■ 70 PLAN 8 LOFT B LOFT 1260 S.F. I �.......� �.� I �i� u:�sy■irr■�1■I —= i uuufipi pl i ■ nffl... rf�.■m ■■ffff■i • BUILDING TYPE I ... . VILLAGESEA VIEW HUNTINMION i"iacv�,a rm1MG O \� olmo a m PLAN C 1250 IF. �i�i�i xra nrmuor . 71 1 11 n� I i r r i 1 I: PLAN D 1255 IF. BUILDING TYPE I FLOOR PLAN SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W -ENTERPRISES , I N C 2124 MAIN STREET,SUrrE 170 w,nm ona,1ua.e HUNTIN(T ON BEACH.CA 92648 6 (714)960.5305 N,RY�L N�IYlC�, 1M� T p 1Z • r! a a 't i r.a wort Q � BUILDING SEC TM BUHXING TYPE 1 SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W ENTERPRISES INC 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 170 n•rrtta•"TL HUNTINGT)N BEACH,CA 92648 aaawm wn 7 (714)960-5505 mmuma M IIIMala:C1N 4Lll O ].a+i t i I I I I 1 lI I I l ,S rl 9 yyFFm EXIIMM EIFRISH SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W ENTERPRISES INC 2124 MAIN STREET.WTTE I1n muwnNCIW REACH.G 926" fllll vl0.5105 O � � 0 I � my I I 1 1 nneaaa wa ay. I I I L�y out,= ♦__�_� I Ili I RIM.YAlIPi��0041 1515 SF. BUILDING TYPE 2 FLOOR PLAN SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W ENTERPRISES IN C 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 170 Harinruu n. 9 HUNTINGTON BEACH.CA 92649 •.rou u.n (714)%(1.5305 I I �r� � O I[ oil 11111irl 1 D v ,m I Q O m' A1M1�001 OKL 14{i. i I i �I I 11� Ills PLAN �T,1 2 BE000M neMeMr�2 16M SF. BUIUMM TYPE 2 FLOOR PLAN SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W ENTERPRISES IN C . 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 170 r.nrouun HUNTINGTON BEACH.CA 926" ors..wn-_ 10 (714)96LLS505 T — 00 wr I D r Y I 1 I ® 1 o„Do ,l 1 wuweow„e,rca ar I I I I I Jw o.Wm I I I I PLAN 3 :er�nooa MMK OOM 1800 SF. BUILDING TYPE 2 FLOOR PLAN SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W ENTERPRISES I N C 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 171) a rmrnu rc 11 HUNTINGTON BEACH.CA 92648 wvrrw an (714)%0.5505 ����•"� ,wxurr-..v�ixm-e� sr•, ar •:. R a ! _ rAme m �e 0 0 IT�1'Y SITE SECPIDN BUILDING TYPE 2 SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I EW ENTERPRISES , IN C . 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 170 SUIMFMD DATE HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 REVISM DATE: 12 (714)960-5505 me kwaER Ml- CUN"u"ftR:cup 1 ZlZC VLLl 3 ' I p 1 9 I it ,i i 1 1 i � i EU . 16 BUILDING TYPE 2 ELEVA7nV SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W ENT E R P RI S E S I N C 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE I70 1IUNTINGTON BEACH.CA 926" 13 (714)96L5505 C{{ It C s s I i i I 4 N --i )om I 8m AR 16 tl X"MNO TYPE 2 SITE SECTION SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W ENT E R P R ISE S I N C 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 1711 1IUNTINGIUN BEACH.CA 92648 ..�....,..,, 14 (714).Yt4F5505 �f REQUES-f FOR CITY COUNCL ACTION November 5, 1990 Date Submitted to: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members Submitted by: Michael T. Uberuaga, City Administrator Prepared by: Michael Adams, Director of Community Developmentoiv` Subject: APPEAL-CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 90-12 WITH SPECIAL PERMITS/ TENTATIVE TRACT 14357/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 90-23 Consistent with Council Policy? [ j Yes [ ] New Policy or Exception Statement of Issue, Recommendation, Analysis, Funding Source, Alternative Actions, Attachments: STATEMENT OF ISSUE• Transmitted for your consideration is an appeal of the Planning Commission' s approval of a 135 unit condominium complex in the Talbert-Beach Redevelopment area. Councilwoman Winchell appealed the action so that the project may be considered in conjunction with General Plan Amendment No . 90-3 and Zone Change No. 90-3 , which are also before the Council for action. RECOMMENDATION• Planning Commission and staff recommend the following motions : That the City Council A - "APPROVE NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 90-23" ; B - "APPROVE CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-12 WITH SPECIAL PERMITS, AND TENTATIVE TRACT NO. 14357 WITH FINDINGS AND CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL (OUTLINED IN ATTACHMENT #1) " Planning Commission Action, on October 2 , 1990: MOTION TO APPROVE NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 90-23 : AYES: Leipzig, Bourguignon, Shomaker, Ortega, Mountford. NOES: Kirkland ABSENT: Williams ABSTAIN: None MOTION TO APPROVE CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-12 WITH SPECIAL PERMITS: AYES: Leipzig, Bourguignon, Shomaker, Mountford NOES: Ortega, Kirkland ABSENT: Williams ABSTAIN: None P10 5/85 MOTION TO APPROVE TENTATIVE TRACT 1.4357: AYES: Leipzig, Bourguignon, Shomaker, Mountford NOES: Ortega, Kirkland ABSENT: Williams ABSTAIN: None ANALYSIS: APPLICANT: Huntington Beach Redevelopment Agency and Bijan Sassounian, Sea View Village. APPELLANT: Councilwoman Winchell PROJECT LOCATION: South side of Talbert Avenue west of Joyful Lane, and south of. Happy Drive between Jolly Lane and Joyful Lane. PROJECT DESCRIPTION: The proposed project consists of a 135 unit condominium complex on two sites, which total 5 .3 gross acres (see attached area map) . The sites are being developed as one integrated complex, with centrally located common recreation areas . One 55-unit building is located on the northerly portion of the site, and one 38-unit and one 42-unit building are located on the southerly site. The units are one and two bedroom flats, some of which incorporate dens or lofts . They range in size from .955 square feet to 1,355 square feet . The development is 50% three story and 50% two-story. The two-story e]iements are primarily located along the southernmost property line adjacent to the R1 development. Additional 2 story elements are clustered along the Talbert Avenue frontage, along the main recreation area, and along the westerly property lines of both parcels (also adjacent to residential) . The common recreation area includes a club house, a swimming pool, and barbecue facilities . A secondary recreation area on the southerly portion of the site between buildings 2 and 3 includes a spa. Assigned secured parking for unit owners and guests is provided in subterranean structures beneath each corresponding building. Five special permits are requested. A detailed description of each request and staff ' s analysis are contained in the attached Planning Commission Staff Report dated September 5, 1990. It should be noted that the need for a sixth special permit request relating to building bulk has been eliminated by project modifications . RCA 11/5/90 -2- (7456d) The proposed project density is 30 units per gross acre, and is therefore, dependent upon the concurrent General Plarr Amendment from Medium Density Residential to High Density Residential, and Zone Change from R4-SR, (Q)R2-PD, and R2-SR to R4-PD (High Density Residential-Planned Development) . ISSUES• At the first Planning Commission hearing on September 5, 1990, a number of concerns were raised by the Planning Commission and the public. These included: 1. The density of the proposed project . 2 . Setbacks, building heights, and landscaping along the southerly property line adjacent to R1 property. 3 . Deficiency in the number of required guest parking spaces beneath each building . 4 . Concerns that the affordable units would be for first-time buyers only, excluding seniors from the project . In response to these concerns, the applicant made several changes to the project, including reduction of unit count from 140 to 135, decreasing the number of three story elements in the overall project, thereby creating additional two-story elements , and providing a plan for intensified landscape buffers between the project and adjoining residential uses . The decrease in unit count and redistribution of one-bedroom and two-bedroom units allowed all guest parking and resident parking to be placed in the structure beneath its corresponding building. AFFORDABILITY• As part of the agreement between the developer and the Redevelopment Agency, the developer has agreed to make available 82 units for moderate income ,buyers . Specifically, sixteen units will benefit from first trusO. deeds through the Southern California Home Finance Authority' s single family bond _issue 1990 Series B, from which the Redevelopment Agency has purchased a commitment . These loans may be assumed by a qualified buyer or prepaid. In addition, all 82 - of the assisted units will benefit from a second trust deed loan made by the Agency from Housing set aside funds . These loans will bear five percent interest for a twenty year term, but payments will be deferred. If a unit is sold, the Agency will collect the principal and deferred interest, plus participate in 50 percent of the equity for the first five years and on a _declining basis in the sixth through twentieth years . All such income to the housing set aside fund must be used to further assist housing. RCA 11/5/90 -3- (7456d) This represents over two million dollars in Agency housing set aside funds committed to this project and will enable 52 of- the units to be affordable to households earning less that one hundred percent of the County' s median income ($49 , 100 . 00) while another 30 units will be affordable to households at just 107 percent of the median income ($52, 537 . 00) . The sales price of the affordable units will range from $155, 900 to $176, 900 . The price for market rate units will range from $189 , 900 to $205, 900 . The developer will offer the affordable units for the initial 120 days of the sale period exclusively to either first time buyers or senior citizens . Furthermore, at the end of this period, the Redevelopment Agency may purchase the option to keep these units available under these circumstances for another 120 days by paying the interest on the developer ' s loan. SUMMARY. Staff supports the proposed project because 1) the design of the project is compatible with the surrounding land uses, and completes the development of the neighborhood in the Talbert-Beach Redevelopment Area. 2) The project is in conformance with the standards and intent of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code for Planned Residential Developments . 3) It will provide assured affordable housing for first time buyers and senior citizens in the City of Huntington Beach, thereby fulfilling goals outlined in the Housing Element of the General Plan. 4) It will also help to satisfy the State requirement for use of Redevelopment set aside funds for affordable housing. 5) The project conforms with the Housing Element by providing a variety of housing types . ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Pursuant to the environmental regulations in effect at this time, the Department of Community Development advertised draft Negative Declaration No. 90-23 for public review and comment twenty-one (21) days prior . to the hearing. The Draft Negative Declaration is attached to this" report, and all proposed mitigation measures have been incorporated as conditions of approval on the project . Prior to any action on Conditional Use Permit 90-12 with Special Permits or Tentative Tract 14357, it is 'necessary for the Council to review and act on Negative Declaration No. 90-23 . FUNDING SOURCE: Non Applicable ALTERNATIVE ACTION: The City Council may deny Conditional Use Perinit No. 90-12 with Special Permits and Tentative Tract 14357 with findings . t RCA 11/5/90 -4- (7456d) C ATTACHMENTS 1. Findings and Conditions of Approval 2. Letter of Appeal 3 . Area Map. 4 . Planning Commission Staff report dated September 5, 1990 (includes Negative Declaration No. 90-23) . 5 . Planning Commission Staff report dated October 2, 1990 . MTU:MA:LP: lp fl P _ T RCA 11/5/90 -5- (7456d) huntington beach department of community development S'A F f REPORT TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: October 2, 1990 SUBJECT: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-12 WITH SPECIAL PERMITS/ TENTATIVE TRACT NO. 14357/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 90-23 (IN CONJUNCTION WITH GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT NO. 90-3 AND ZONE CHANGE NO. 90-3) APPLICANT: Redevelopment Agency/ EXISTING Bijan Sassounian ZONE: R2-SR (Senior 2124 Main Street, Ste. 170 Medium Density Residential) Huntington Beach, CA 92648 R4-SR (Senior High Density Residential) PROPERTY City of Huntington Beach (Q)R2-PD (Qualified Medium OWNER: Redevelopment Agency/ Residential with a Planned Sea View Village Community Suffix) 2124 Main Street, Ste. 170 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 PROPOSED ZONE: R4-PD (High Density Residential-Planned Development) REQUEST: 140 unit condominium with special permits, and 5 EXISTING GENERAL PLAN: lot subdivision for Medium Density Residential condominium purposes . and High Density Residential PROPOSED GENERAL PLAN: High Density Residential LOCATION: South side of Talbert Ave. , west of Joyful Lane; south EXISTING USE: Vacant of Happy Drive between Jolly Lane and Joyful Lane. ACREAGE: 5 . 1 acres (gross) 4 . 14 acres (net) 1. 0 SUGGESTED ACTION: Approve Negative Declaration No. 90-23, Conditional Use Permit No . 90-12 with Special Permits, and Tentative Tract 14357 with findings and suggested conditions of approval . Xftl A-F M-23C 2 . 0 GENERAL INFORMATION: The Planning Commission continued this item from the September 5 , 1990 meeting in order to allow the applicant to address concerns raised by the Planning Commission and the public. These included : 1. The density of the proposed project . 2 . Setbacks, building heights, and landscaping along the southerly property line adjacent to R1 property. 3 . Deficiency in the number of required guest parking spaces within each building . 4 . Concerns that the affordable units would be for first-time buyers only, excluding seniors from the project . In response to the action taken by the Commission, the applicant has met with staff several times, and proposes the following modifications to the site plan and affordable housing program. Building Heights The applicant has reduced a total of 50% of the project to two stories in height . All units that abut the R1 property to the south have been reduced to two stories and a maximum of 25 feet in height . Other two story portions of the project have been clustered around the Talbert Avenue frontage, the main recreation area, and the westerly property lines of both parcels (also abutting residential) . This modification represents an increase in two-story elements from 40% of the project as previously proposed to 50% of the project . Density As a result of the reduction in height, a total of 5 units have been removed. The project will now contain 135 units, for an overall density of 30 units per gross acre. Setbacks The Planning Commission expressed concern with the special permit request to reduce the setback along the R1 property, from 30 feet to an average of 20 feet to the building walls with a minimum of 10 feet 6 inches to the patio walls . The applicant has maintained the setbacks as originally proposed, and has provided figures illustrating the building setbacks and corresponding open space between the buildings and the property line . The figures compare the impacts of the applicant ' s proposal as compared to a typical R1-type development, similar to that on the adjoining property. Plan A (the proposed project) shows more available open space between the building face and the property line than Plan B (Single Family Homes) at the 30 foot and 40 foot setback Staff Report - 10/2/90 -2- (7295) lines . It should be noted that Plan A (proposed project) shows measurements from the building face, not from patio walls or decks , which project further into the setback areas . The figures are attached to this report . Landscaping The applicant has hired the architectural landscaping firm of Peridian to prepare a landscape plan for the site, which includes a densely planted buffer between the project and adjacent residences . A description of the proposed plant materials, their initial sizes at planting, and their growth rates are included in a descriptive sheet prepared by Peridian and attached to this report . A conceptual landscape plan will be displayed at the Planning Commission meeting on October 2, 1990 . Parking The Planning Commission had expressed concern that, although the required resident parking was provided on-site beneath each corresponding building, the on-site guest parking was unevenly distributed among the buildings . Due to the removal of five units from the project and the redistribution of one-bedroom and two-bedroom units, the required resident and guest parking is now fully provided in the structure beneath its corresponding building . The required and provided parking is now as follows : Bldg 1 Bldg 2 Bldg 3 Res . Guest Tot . Res . Guest Tot . Res . Guest Tot . Required 104 28 132 77 21 98 71 19 90 Provided 105 28 133 77 21 98 71 19 90 Difference +1 0 +1 0 0 0 0 0 0 Project Total Res . Guest Tot . Required 252 68 320 Provided 253 68 321 Difference +1 0 +1 Senior Housing The developer will offer 34 one-bedroom units and 48 two-bedroom units as affordable, for a total of 82 units (60% of the project) . The Planning commission expressed concern that the affordable units in the project should be available to senior citizens . To accommodate the Planning Commission' s concerns, the developer will offer the affordable units for the initial 120 days of the sale period exclusively to either first time buyers or senior citizens . Furthermore, at the end of this period, the Redevelopment Agency may purchase the option to keep these units available -under these circumstances for another 120 days by paying the interest on the developer ' s loan. Staff Report - 10/2/90 -3- (7295) Other basic terms of the developer ' s agreement with the Redevelopment Agency remain essentially the same. These are briefly outlined in the staff report dated September 5 , 1990 . 3 . 0 RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission approve Negative Declaration 90-23 Conditional Use Permit No . 90-12 with Special Permits, and Tentative Tract No. 14357 with the following findings and suggested conditions of approval : FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL - CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-12 : 1 . The location, site layout, and design of the proposed 135 unit condominium project properly adapts the proposed structures to streets , driveways, and other adjacent structures and uses in a harmonious manner. 2 . The access to and parking for the proposed 135 unit condominium complex does not create an undue traffic problem, because the parking structure has been shown to be safe and efficient and the surrounding streets have adequate capacity to accommodate the traffic generated. 3 . The planned residential development for 135 units does conform to the provisions contained in Article 915 except for the special permit requests, which improve the quality of the project (see Special Permit Findings for Approval) . 4 . The proposed 135 unit project will not be detrimental to the general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity; and property and improvements in the vicinity of such use or building, because the project is properly buffered from such uses by streets and setbacks . 5 . The proposed 135 unit condominium will be compatible with the Huntington Beach General Plan and Zoning upon adoption of General Plan Amendment No. 90-3 and Zone Change 90-3 . FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL - SPECIAL PERMITS: 1. The following special permits promote a better living environment by adapting the Planned Residential Development requirements to better suit the 135 unit condominium complex, which are compatible with the surrounding area: a . To allow a 7 to 10 foot front setback along Joyful Lane and the north side of Happy Drive in lieu of minimum 15 foot setback, for pool fencing and the common clubhouse building . b. To allow a minimum rear setback of 10 ' 6" with 20 foot average to the building face in lieu of a 30 foot setback along R1 zoned property. Staff Report - 10/2/90 -4- (7295) C. To reduce side-by-side building separation for Building 1 from 55 feet to 20 feet . d. To allow 50% of the project to be one story less than the remainder in lieu of requiring one third of the units in each structure to be one story less . e. To allow an average dimension of 75 feet for the main recreation area in lieu of 100 feet . f . To allow 15% to 20% ramp slopes into the underground parking structures in lieu of a maximum 10% slope on ramps with no adjacent parking, and maximum 5% slope on a 16 foot transition ramp at intersections with streets . 2 . The requested deviation for ramp slopes to the parking structure is acceptable because: a . A traffic study prepared by a traffic engineer has been submitted which documents the impacts of the request . b. The deviation will not adversely affect the circulation and safety of the site structure, use, or adjacent use. C. The deviation will result in a more efficient circulation pattern and parking layout . d. The deviation will enhance the general appearance of the development and its surroundings . e. The deviation will not be detrimental to the general public health, safety, welfare or convenience, or injurious to property values in the vicinity. 4 . The requested special permits provide for maximum use of aesthetically pleasing types of architecture, landscaping, design and building layout, by allowing for efficient on-site circulation, buffering adjacent land uses, and allowing for a centrally located recreation area. 5 . The requested special permits will not be detrimental to the .general health, welfare, safety and convenience, nor detrimental or injurious to the value of property or improvements of the neighborhood or of the City in general . The special permit requests incorporated into the project design will reduce project impacts to adjacent properties . 6 . The requested special permits are consistent with the objectives of the Planned Residential Development standards in achieving a development adapted to the terrain and compatible with the surrounding environment. Staff Report - 10/2/90 -5- (7295) t FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL - TENTATIVE TRACT NO. 14357 : 1 . The size, depth, frontage, street width, and other design features of the proposed 5 lot subdivision for 135 .condominium units are in compliance with the standard plans and specifications on file with the City as well as in compliance with the State Subdivision Map Act and the supplemental City Subdivision Ordinance. 2 . The analysis for General Plan Amendment No . 90-3 and Zone Change No . 90-3 has determined that this intensity of land use (High Density Residential - Maximum 35 units per gross acre) is appropriate for this site. 3 . The General Plan has set forth provisions for High Density Residential Development and affordable housing, as well as setting forth objectives for the implementation of this type of use. 4 . The site is relatively flat and physically suitable for the proposed density of 30 units per gross acre. 5 . Tentative Tract No . 14357 for a 135 unit condominium complex is consistent with the goals and policies of the Huntington Beach General Plan because it provides a means of affordable housing for first time homebuyers in Huntington Beach. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL - CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-12 : 1 . The site plan, floor plans, and elevations received and dated July 26, 1990, shall be the conceptually approved layout, with modifications to density, parking arrangement, and building heights as presented to the Planning Commission on October 2, 1990 . Final approval of building form, colors and materials shall be subject to review and approval by the Design Revi.ew Board. 2 . The developer shall offer 34 one-bedroom units and 48 two-bedroom units as affordable to moderate income buyers . During the initial 120 days of the sale period the affordable units shall be offered exclusively the either first- time buyers or senior citizens . At the end of this period, the Redevelopment Agency may purchase the option to keep these units available under these circumstances for another 120 days by paying the interest on the developer ' s loan. 3 . Prior to submittal for building permits, the applicant/owner shall complete the following : a. Submit three copies of the site plan to the Planning Division for addressing purposes . Staff Report - 10/2/90 -6- (7295) f b. Depict all utility apparatus, such as but not limited to backflow devices and Edison transformers, on the site plan. They shall be prohibited in the front and exterior yard setbacks unless properly screened by landscaping or other method as approved by the Community Development Director . C. Floor plans shall depict natural gas and 220V electrical stubbed in at the location of clothes dryers; natural gas shall be stubbed in at the locations of cooking facilities, water heaters, and central heating units; and low-volume heads shall be used on all spigots and water faucets . d. If foil-type insulation is to be used, a fire retardant type shall be installed as approved by the Building Department and indicated on the floor plans . e. The structures on the subject property, whether attached or detached, shall be constructed in compliance with the State acoustical standards set forth for units that lie within the 60 CNEL contours of the property. Evidence of compliance shall consist of submittal of an acoustical analysis report, prepared under the supervision of a person experienced in the field of acoustical engineering, with the application for building' permit(s) . f . Elevations shall depict colors and building materials as approved by the Design Review Board. g . All rooftop mechanical equipment shall be screened from any view. Said screening shall be architecturally compatible with the building in terms of materials and colors . If screening is not designed specifically into the building, a rooftop mechanical equipment plan must be submitted showing screening and must be approved. h. If outdoor lighting is included, energy savings lamps shall be used. All outside lighting shall be directed to prevent "spillage" onto adjacent properties and shall be noted on the site plan and elevations . i . A detailed soils analysis shall be prepared by a registered Soils Engineer . This analysis shall include on-site soil sampling and laboratory testing of materials to provide detailed recommendations regarding grading, chemical and fill properties, foundations, retaining walls, streets, and utilities . j . The Design Review Board shall review and approve the following : (a) The final building form, colors and materials . Staff Report - 10/2/90 -7- (7295) (b) Balconies along the southernmost property. (c) Pool fencing shall be of wrought iron or other see-through material . k. The site plan or reference page shall include all conditions of approval imposed on the project printed verbatim. 1 . The final site plan shall note the location of 100 cubic feet of storage area per unit . 4 . Prior to issuance of building permits , the applicant/owner shall complete the following : a . A Landscape Construction Set must be submitted to the Departments of Community Development and Public Works and must be approved. The Landscape Construction Set shall include a landscape plan prepared and signed by a State Licensed Landscape Architect and which includes all proposed/existing plant materials (location, type, size, quantity) , an irrigation plan, a grading plan, an approved site plan, and a copy of the entitlement conditions of approval . The landscape plans shall include intense landscape buffers as presented to the Planning Commission on October 2, 1990, and shall be in conformance with Section 9608 and Article 915 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. The set must be approved by both departments prior to issuance of building permits . Any existing mature trees that must be removed shall be replaced at a 2 to 1 ratio with minimum 36-inch box trees, which shall be incorporated into the project ' s landscape plan. b. A grading plan shall be submitted to the Department of Public Works for review and it must be approved (by issuance of a grading permit) . A plan for silt control for all water runoff from the property during construction and initial operation of the project may be required if deemed necessary by the Director of Public Works . C. Hydrology and hydraulic studies shall be submitted for Public Works approval . d. All applicable Public Works fees shall be paid . e. Final Tract Map shall be accepted by the City Council, recorded with the Orange County Recorder and a copy filed with the Department of Community Development . f . An interim parking and/or building materials storage plan shall be submitted to the Department of Community Development to assure adequate parking is available for employees, customers, contractors, etc. , during the project ' s construction phase. Staff Report - 10/2/90 -8- (7295) g . Prior to issuance of building permits, a water plan shall be submitted to the water department . The plan shall detail measures which the project shall implement to reduce peak hour water usage. 5 . The Public Works Department requirements are as follows : a . Private driveways shall be of radius-type construction, per Huntington Beach Standard 211 A and B. . 6 . Fire Department Requirements are as follows : a . An automatic fire sprinkler system shall be approved and installed pursuant to Fire Department regulations . Shop drawings to be. submitted to and approved by Fire Department prior to installation. b. Service roads and fire lanes, as determined by the Fire Department, shall be posted and marked. C. Fire access lanes shall be maintained. ' If fire lane violations occur and the services of the Fire Department are required, the applicant will be liable for expenses incurred. d. Three fire hydrants shall be installed prior to combustible construction, and at locations specified by the Fire Department . e. The applicant shall meet all applicable local, State and Federal Fire Codes, Ordinances , and standards . f . A Class III wet standpipe system (combination) will be installed to comply with Huntington Beach Fire Department and Uniform Building Code standards . g. A fire alarm system will be installed to comply with Huntington Beach Fire Department and Uniform Fire Code standards . h. Fire extinguishers will be installed and located in areas to comply with Huntington Beach Fire Code standards . i . Elevators will be sized to accommodate an ambulance gurney (Minimum 6 ' 8" wide by 4 ' 3" deep, minimum 42" opening. j . Security gates will be designed to comply with Huntington Beach Fire Department Standard No . 403 . k. Address numbers will be installed to comply with Huntington Beach Fire Code standards . 1 . Submit to Fire Department for approval a Fire Protection Plan containing requirements of Fire Department Specification No. 426 . Staff Report - 10/2/90 -9- (7295) M. Applicant shall pay for "Opticom" traffic system at Beach and Talbert . 7 . The development shall comply with all applicable provisions of the Ordinance Code, Building Division, and Fire Department . 8 . All building spoils, such as unusable lumber, wire, pipe, and other surplus or unusable material, shall be disposed of at . an off-site facility equipped to handle them. 9 . Installation of required landscaping and irrigation systems shall be completed prior to final inspection/within twelve (12) months . 10 . During construction, the applicant shall : a . Discontinue construction during second stage smog alerts . b. Wet down areas in the late morning and after work is completed for the day. C . Use low sulfur fuel ( . 05% by weight) for construction equipment . 11 . Construction+shall be limited to Monday - Saturday 7 : 00 AM to 8 : 00 PM. Construction shall be prohibited Sundays and Federal holidays . 12 . Should any cultural materials be encountered during the initial site survey or during grading and excavation activities, all activity shall cease and the archaeologist shall be obtained to determine the appropriate course of action. 13 . During cleaning, grading, earth moving or excavation, the applicant shall : a . Control fugitive .dust by regular watering, paving construction roads, or other dust preventive measures . b. Maintain equipment engines in proper tune. 14 . Prior to initiation of construction, police and fire departments shall be notified and the departments shall be kept informed about duration and extent of construction throughout the process . 15 . Public Works Department shall provide alternate routes for traffic during the construction phase, if necessary. Adequate signage shall be provided to warn motor vehicles, bicyclists and pedestrians of construction. 16 . This conditional use permit and tentative tract shall not become effective until General Plan Amendment No . 90-3 and Zone Change No. 90-3 have been approved by the City Council and are in effect . Staff Report - 10/2/90 -10- (7295) 17 . This conditional use permit shall become null and void unless exercised within one (1) year of the date of final approval , or such extension of time as, may be granted by the Planning Commission pursuant to a written request submitted to the Planning Department . a minimum 30 days prior to the expiration date. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL - TENTATIVE TRACT 14357: 1 . The tentative tract map received and dated July 26, 1990, shall be the approved layout with the following modifications : a . "Notes" shall be revised to reflect correct zoning and General Plan designation. 2 . At least 60 days prior to recordation of the final tract map, CC&R' s shall be submitted to and approved by the City Attorney and the Department of Community Development . The CC&R' s shall reflect the and maintenance of all common areas by the Homeowners ' Association. 3 . This tentative tract shall not become effective until General Plan Amendment No. 90-3 and Zone Change No. 90-3 have been approved by the City Council and are in effect . 4 . Landscaping and enhanced pavement within the right-of-way as shown on the approved site plan shall be maintained by the Homeowners Association pursuant to an approved agreement with the City Public Works Department 5 . On-site sewers shall be private. 6 . The water system shall be located in vehicular travel ways and dedicated to the City. 7. The developer will be responsible for the payment of the Water Master Plan fee, September, 1990 . 8 . The developer will be responsible for the payment of the Traffic Impact fees if in place at the time building permits are issued. 9 . The project shall accept all contributory drainage from properties to the south, which shall be accommodated through the site in a manner to the satisfaction of the Department of Public Works . 10 . Construct full Public Works improvements to the centerline of Talbert Avenue. 11. The on-site sewer and water systems shall be shown on a City approved utility plan, showing all water services, fire hydrants, fire services, , and backflow devices . Staff Report - 10/2/90 -11- (7295) 12 . Developer shall submit water system hydraulic calculations to ensure system adequacy and line sizing . 13 . The water system shall be looped, with no dead ends , and shall be installed per the Public Works Department ' s standards , ordinances, and policies . 14 . Developer shall dedicate vehicular access rights to the City except at access points approved by the City. 4 . 0 ALTERNATIVE ACTION: The Planning Commission may deny Conditional Use Permit No. 90-12 with Special Permits and Tentative Tract No . 14357 with findings . ATTACHMENTS: 1. Revised Site Plan depicting location of 2-story units, and revised parking calculations . 2 . Figures depicting setbacks-Plan A, Plan B 3 . Landscape description, Landscape plan and Section drawing showing landscaping at R1 property line 4 . Staff Report_dated September 5, 1990 HS:LP:kjl Staff Report - 10/2/90 -12- (7295) l' r --- ._._._._.—._.—._.--- .__—.—.—.--- .—._.—TALBERT�AVENUE _ _ Pl P2 �I C C 1 P A R KIAG SUPPA9T C C_ =II Q J •=•klm ns?1rAg: 03 \ ICS St 14.1G stilt. _L3 Guest Pcrdrg 132 B2 \ 3.:ilaiaa 2: \ �2 stanaara S:_!:S ^ _ A 'A T I Ylf 'wst Pori:ag ♦nv,-. RO1 C E�lip \ S3 3e>Jlrea 7fll ps II S:Iiainp S: S u REV IXIRY \ S:CNcrd St-!IS rry p A y3 Ga•s:Perking BA A \ 9?scau:roa E LDI ' e B2 I 1 Par—iroria�: i Bz Bz P S .I rarl,Swterr...11C...red Ilea.1 Si3 S[enGarO stalls B2 B2 13 Guest Stalls N I tSs Trov ilea BUILDING 1 { t 2 SS UNITS _ i 1 [aS7 Itracture/ p n Stall `+..r soacara tall mis D D.� . 'T 9 1L Guest stalls BI D 93 Pra Gen UNIT B2 AT 2ND AND SRD vl - 1 FLOORS ONLY AT THIS LOCATI _ .eat Structure/Bldg.S Q 1 21 Sta^aarV sells E'Sest Stalls t11 23'S �II� 9D Pravl Geo 41 PRIMARY.REC.ARE :1 PI I I I P9 Total stall.: 321 EI POti. Surplus: 1 �` I Visit Parallel Porkl 39 IBPI t ft A I r _ - •� Pn P _ -- P2. P23 Pzl P2D Pw I I I !d it PROJECT ENTRY 1' s �}. Pal i' it 6 NTR [ - - R B2 A A 82 I A A- Bi D D e, B, D'= }} D D D 1 40URT It RTYARD Sc'Ol1RT .,,Tun n io RD J 1 -<D ILDING D ==s D UILgNG A. A B2 D E SIKdE FAMILY RESIDENCE BUILDING 3 BUILDING 2 38 UNITS L 42 UNITS SUMMARY: Site Aree: ..S ecra:(gross) KEY 1.19 Derr.(net) Total LMltt:ISS Density: 30 D.Uduere 2SiORY ELEMENTS LOFT UNIT @ TOP FLOOR PLAT Ali: Plm � elan 1 etm z also 1 Totot THREE SI'ORIFS A II.DW.I l� 12 to a 25 A ton 1 1,Den.l ep 0 1 A 1 Il 1 astaay,t-ea 0 S 0 1 DECKS AT BOTTOM FLOOR 12 '1',W 2S '1 S SS THIS LOCATION ONLY 12 Loft 2 e,Den.2 e', 2 1 . 10 c 21,2W e 0 0 e D 2 e,'Be . _n ' SS .2 3e 135 on sc 1+•n TECHNICAL SITE PLAN adze Md3 mxi hwg SEA VIEW VILLAGE SEAVIE-W ENTERPRISES INC . _ 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 170 SUBMITTEDDATE 2MAR." ' HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 R�EZVISION Dpp1A1TES pAANUN(]11.IM 3 (714).960-5505 lOB6NUMBERV1119.I99 PEY,SED:P/TS/W CUP NUMBER:CUP W121ZC W 3 BUILDING SET BACK AND CORRESPONDING OPEN SPACE (in square footage) 20' Setback 30' Setback 40' Setback Plan A (proposed project) 8,000 11,184 12,892 Plan B (7 dwelling) 8,000 8,650 9,300 The above numbers do not reflect an additional 880 square feet of easement between property line and southerly residential fencing. PLAN A 40' - 2, - - - - - - - - 2' 2' 30' - - 5, 9 3 5 5,- 3 9' 5, 20' - - - - - - - ---- 0' EASEMENT 880[/1 400' PLAN B 54 10 50' 20' MIN N 0' 400' .AREA OF [ 1 _ (3.75) (3.75) = 14.0625[/] SEA VIEW VILLAGE 135 Condominiums The intent of the landscaping in the perimeter setbacks is to provide:a dense planted buffer between and a pleasant evergreen view from both the existing residenses aAd---_`1.- the proposed condominiums. A combination of trees and shrubs have been selected which will in a short tine:grow =-: into a continuous visual screen both at eye level - for the ground floor.reviews'_ as ; . well as at a height of 10' to 20', for the second floor views of both the homes"and the:" -` new condominiums. The proposed new perimeter wall will be six feet high concrete block-and will be.' covered with evergreen and flowering vines. Flowering vines will also be planted to-',, grow on existing walls. Trees and shrubs have been selected that are the same as or similar to existing adjacent plantings. All suggested trees and shrubs are evergreen and most are flowering. A brief description of each,with initial sizes and anticipated sizes after one year are listed below. Approximate spacings are shown on the plan. INITIAL PLANT DESCRIPTION SIZE 1 YEAR Bristane Box Fast growing tree with 24" box (Tristania Conferta) light green leaver and 10'-12'x4'5' 12'-14'x7'-8' interesting trunk. Drought tolerant. Red Ironbark Very fast growing tree 15 gallon (Eucalyptus siderorylon) with pink flowers and T-8'x2'-T 12'-14'x6'-7' dark reddish bark. Drought tolerant. -. . Silver Dollar. Gum Very fast growing tree 15 gallon with silver gray leaves. T-8'x2'-3' 12'-14'x6'-7' Drought tolerant. Leyland Cypress Extremely fast growing 15 gallon (Cupressocyparis conifer with. striking . 67-Tx2'-Y 10'-12'x4'-5' Leylandi) gray-green dense foliage 5 gallon Drought-:tolerant. 4-4-l/2'x1'-2' 8'-10'x3'-4' Carolina Cherry Fast growing shrub with 15 gallon glossy dark:green::dense`/ 51-67xT-Y 7'-8'x3'-4'. foliage Drought_aolerant. 4'-5'x1-1/2'=2' 6'-Tx3'=4' . Peridian Irvine Peridian Orlando::: Peridian San Diego 17848 Sky Park 625 Chancellor Drive Suite ioo 8553 Aero Drive, Suite zog Irvine,CA 92714 , Orlando'TL 3z8oq-.` San Diego,CA 9=I23 714.26i.5120/FAX74.25oA795 +67.857-06+/FAX:467.855.636o 61q.279.779I/FAX619.279.3010 7g�m' qw-a 711 wp- wz.o�-41pllmf-to mill 61 , - R ,Vr M1qb�z M! III , JII�'V7,I jo WF r mm 0 OW-1 �19 ILM INS ► OAM.—. 1111— 'ii ''� '? II�Q IVIIDIIII �Ii'lll ����II= ����1 1 IF NOV", 1A 1. Mmi (PT" 3to Ir i7. :1� - i.aC�y .;t�� � .(c.� ..:♦ f,F•fql - . -,�. • It. �y.i. ?=i_f i s,.qY 1;y•i s w-'> t'�w- r a:� q; =a r r?- riF� s F° r,a"z^ Wr t�9�'+ •" via �� r+.�..�.+..�.. ' -'•"Y'»1.�.ri�..- -'�--- "�0:'7" :.'i.'"` �.'��'.�..�.k:'~.".,:.A"----"-ryrtwtto.� �»:.=.i-,•c.�•. � 1,17 �er.�:,,•�e...i.�..•..,..�... -a�ao.ri�:r`.iz�o�--e.'--3+��..,�e.o.,, ..--.-o"�`+"' '_�.•"'�� '�. ��'�- -::._; �.. — • p�,�_`.f�' �� l 71�' � IIt_ .1 �:r=r- ■ �, ra, ■ z ► ,,. ::3i �y■�� �� � Q�/; .j�t• c I f x r: •'Y s �,�•�e. r '���r'�_ j. >ti�q'y'' ,�`-„'. �<`� '�`- � - /I'�'/ `Ilu, ��, ,.!' �/�—'�,,N'.�r�� *� .F R ► "`v<f►. .■I 'A 4 ti..u t y tir �c o l y U �lit Jill r i �_ m1111IIII� dCl ri i.� '' !�E �f a �I•, �nmgR i punllm �-�• �••�n101 RIn6�• '�.r "'� .'� ¢� ��.�,� IIE► `g 1. ogle��IU�-�• �?� . ���N�pp a� -x • �E. Ay'' y, 1 � ° V �+^ '_ .� �t ml,. II � .vtu�• is � �' t• �v� y. ���. i� T{ � �i � :� � �. /,�►� �_�•. 'I � t1— 1�5� � ��� ' � I tea.: ,��. .,� R� A C;.• I� �Imw_�' \Y,� �q< � •�h If .—� I�-� v „ 6 R b' ''l^i.cv7_4► (-..°i `r.�r..r•�!` ,�. .'� ® I 'V=r uA� �I IL '■'�Y1Mt>T� r1i` •�i�� 1 _� J �' r�� .:�,� �•-� �M� . ' . .o � �h 19��IIh IIIh°` R I�III�III Ill�lll`I'- _ '' `' Yqt{ {i' : r f�� r ■ t .:.i �i�' �1111n. Win ;, �• ;� c �'V t h,.� +► •�.. +.. :ic • i, !�` ' /'i��l��1I III '�I'• -1 pup ram: >sfs �y '.'�• �� •�,', "�,:-r . .� ��.�r =• � �� 'c.�► I� `�`7a r �P � R .�6 '� � r .Illh AIII �1 �/.;V �I• �, r v,._`.�;';:iF I '- r�i• _``1: +... u� � as 9a.,.S ��� �;�:, ... �' S F. � �'�!�d����►_- /�Il�u�D�I�lulf��������ww� /jet)`, �i ►� MEN Am na ■ �C'�� V `; v � i� I• '�l • r- II ��+�::�._a:. _��:.viio'a�'<=1 �Uv`>,��� S•80�� �'• i � �'�i-y �Y z'� �;�... 'S.. `�.__T� I�!IeI1���I0'j �� - �\® a'.�o�'��_ //�'/C1- /'�If�IrC �1 �. ELEVATOR BLDG. VERGREEN ACCENT TREES L�FOREGROUND (SEE PLAN FOR SPACING) EVERGREEN VERTICAL SCREEN TREES AS BUFFER J_T (SEE PLAN FOR SPACING) I ego MR DECK ? E 9 . PATK) IBE H.P. VG GRADE BEYOND ———— — —— _ — —— ———— SIX FOOT HIGH CONCRETE BLOCK WALL 4 COVERED WITH FLOWERING VINES - o GARAGE GARAGE I EVERGREEN SHRUBS AND FLOWERING GROUNDCOVERS Z O J a 20'-6" BUILDING 3(BUILDING 2 SIM.) m LANDSCAPE BUFFER EXISTING RI PROPERTY BUILDING 3 SECTION (BLD'G 2 SIM.) huntington beach department of community development STA f f REPORT TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: September 5, 1990 SUBJECT: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-12 WITH SPECIAL PERMITS/ TENTATIVE TRACT NO. 14357/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 90-23 (IN CONJUNCTION WITH GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT NO. 90-3 AND ZONE CHANGE NO. 90-3) APPLICANT: Redevelopment Agency/ EXISTING Bijan Sassounian ZONE: R2-SR (Senior 2124 Main Street, Ste. 170 Medium Density Residential) Huntington Beach, CA 92648 R4-SR (Senior High Density Residential) PROPERTY City of Huntington Beach (Q)R2-PD (Qualified Medium OWNER: Redevelopment Agency/ Residential with a Planned Sea View Village Community Suffix) 2124 Main Street, Ste. 170 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 PROPOSED ZONE: R4-PD (High Density Residential-Planned Development) REQUEST: 140 unit condominium with special permits, and 5 EXISTING GENERAL PLAN: lot subdivision for Medium Density Residential condominium purposes . and High Density Residential PROPOSED GENERAL PLAN: High Density Residential LOCATION: South side of Talbert Ave. , west of Joyful Lane;. south EXISTING USE: Vacant of Happy Drive between Jolly Lane and Joyful Lane. ACREAGE: 5 . 1 acres (gross) 4 . 14 acres (net) 1 . 0 SUGGESTED ACTION: Approve Negative Declaration No . 90-23, Conditional Use Permit No. 90-12 with Special Permits, and Tentative Tract 14357 with. findings and suggested conditions of approval . A-F M-23C 2 . 0 GENERAL INFORMATION: Conditional Use Permit No . 90-12 is a request by Seaview Village and the City of Huntington Beach Redevelopment Agency for a. 140 unit condominium complex, pursuant to Section 9150 . 1 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. Six special permit requests have been filed, as follows : 1 . To reduce the front yard setback along Joyful Lane and the north side of Happy Drive to a minimum of 7 feet for pool fencing, and 10 feet for an accessory building . Section 9150 . 7 requires a minimum 15 ' setback with an average of 20 ' . 2 . To reduce the rear setback along R1-zoned property to a minimum of 10 ' 6" for patio walls with an average of 20 feet to the building face. Section 9150 . 9 would require a 30 ' setback from R1-zoned property for this project . 3 . To reduce the side-by-side building separation for Building 1 to 20 feet . Section 9150 . 10(d) requires a minimum 55 feet for this project . 4 . To allow 40% of the total project to be one story less than the remainder--of the project . Section 9150 . 12 (c) requires that one third of the units in each multi-story structure be one story less than the remaining units in the structure. 5 . To allow an average dimension of 75 feet for the :main recreation area . Section 9150 . 14 (f) requires a 100 foot average dimension. 6 . To allow 15% 'to 20% ramp slopes into the parking structure. Section 9601. 6 requires a maximum 10% slope on ramps with no adjacent parking, and a 16 foot long transition ramp with a maximum 5% slope at intersections with a public street . Tentative Tract No . 14357 is a five lot subdivision to accommodate the construction of 140 condominiums . This conditional use permit and tentative tract map are contingent upon approval of General Plan -Amendment No . 90-3 and Zone Change 90-3 , which are being requested concurrently. The General Plan Amendment and Zone Change must be acted upon before any action on this request . 3 . 0 SURROUNDING LAND USE ZONING AND GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATIONS: North of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Medium Density Residential ZONE: R2 (Medium Density Residential) LAND USE: Mixed Office/Residential Staff Report - 9/5/90 -2- (6989d) East of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: General Commercial ZONE: C4 (Highway Commercial) LAND USE: Retail Center South of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Low Density Residential and General Commercial ZONE: R1 (Low Density Residential) and C4 (Highway Commercial) LAND USE: Single Family Homes , Vacant West of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Medium Density Residential and High Density Residential ZONE: Q-R2-PD (Qualified Medium Density Residential-Planned Development) and R4-SR (High Density Residential -Senior Residential) LAND USE: Residential Apartments and Condominiums 4 . 0 ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Pursuant to the environmental regulations in effect at this time, the Department of Community Development advertised draft Negative Declaration No . 90-23 for public review and comment twenty-one (21) days prior to the hearing. No comments, either verbal or written were received with regard to the proposed negative declaration. The Draft Negative Declaration is attached to this report, and all proposed mitigation measures have been incorporated as conditions of approval on the project . 5 . 0 COASTAL STATUS: Not applicable. 6 . 0 REDEVELOPMENT STATUS: The project is located in the Talbert-Beach Redevelopment Project Area . As part of the agreement between the developer and the Redevelopment Agency, the developer has agreed to make available 82 units for moderate income, first time buyers . The general provisions of this program .are discussed in the analysis section below. 7 . 0 SPECIFIC PLAN: Not applicable. 8 . 0 SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE: On July 26, 1990, the Subdivision Committee met to discuss Tentative Tract 14357 . Representatives of the Planning Commission, Fire Department , Public Works Department, and Community Development Department were present . The proposed conditions of approval were discussed, and are incorporated in the recommendation section of this report . The Committee expressed concern with the proposed parking plan, and recommended that : Staff Report - ,9/5/90 -3- (6989d) 1 . All resident parking be provided under its corresponding building . 2 . Guest parking should be located on-site, rather than on the street . 3 . No tandem parking should be considered. The architect has revised the plans to incorporate these suggestions . The Committee voted unanimously to recommend approval of Tentative Tract 14357 to the Planning Commission, noting that this recommendation did not necessarily reflect their concerns with the conditional use permit and site plan. 9 . 0 DESIGN REVIEW BOARD: The Design Review Board analyzed the proposed colors , materials, and building elevations on August 2, 1990 . The Board made suggestions to reduce the building bulk and soften roof profiles, but remained concerned with the overall form of the building and with the proposed Special Permits . The Board recommended that the Planning Commission impose a condition sending the elevations back to the Design Review Board for final approval of form, materials, and colors . 10 . 0 ISSUES AND ANALYSIS: Site History: On October 6, 1986, the City Council approved Zone Change No . 86-2, Conditional Use Permit No . 86-2 , and Negative Declaration No . 86-2 for the southerly portion of the subject site (south of Happy Drive between Joyful Lane & Jolly Lane) . A Zone Change from (Q)R2-PD to R2-SR and an 89-unit senior residential complex were approved, including a 50% density bonus for low and moderate income households . Several extensions of time were granted for the conditional use permit by the Planning Commission, however, no building permits were ever issued, and the approval expired on January 30, 1990 . Under the current zoning and General Plan designation on the site (including Senior Residential Suffixes) , a maximum of 125 units could be constructed. Project Description: The proposed project consists of a 140 unit condominium complex on two sites, which total 4 . 5 gross acres (see attached area map) . The sites are being developed as one integrated complex, with centrally located common recreation areas, and shared guest parking . One 60-unit building is proposed on the north site, and one 36-unit and one 44-unit building are proposed on the south site. The units are one and two bedroom flats, some of which incorporate dens or lofts . They range in size from 955 square feet to 1; 355 square feet . The development is primarily three story, with the portions of the project facing Talbert Avenue and facing the R1 Staff Report - 9/5/90 -4- (6989d) zoned property to the south being -limited to 2 story. The common recreation area includes a club house, a swimming pool, and barbecue facilities . A secondary recreation area includes a spa . Assigned secured parking for unit owners is provided in subterranean structures beneath the corresponding building. Guest parking i.s also provided in the underground structures, and is distributed throughout the project . The proposed project density is 31 . 1 units per gross acre, and is therefore, dependent upon the concurrent General Plan Amendment from Medium Density Residential to High Density Residential , and Zone Change from R4-SR, (Q)R2-PD, and R2-SR to R4-PD (High Density Residential-Planned Development) . The following is a zoning conformance chart which compares the project to the development standards of Article 915 (Planned Development) : SECTION ISSUE REQUIRED PROVIDED 9150 .4 Density (net+7 . 5%) units -(maximum) 35/ac (157) 31. 1/ac (140) bedrooms (maximum) 53/ac (238) 52 .4/ac (236) 9150 . 5 Max. Site Coverage 50 46 .4% (84 , 819 sf) (91, 258 sf) 9150 . 6 Maximum Height 35 ' to 35 ' to midline of midline of highest roof highest roof 9150 . 7 Front Setback 20 ' , or .Talbert-avg . 20 ' to 9150 . 8 Ext . Side Setback Min. 15 ' bldg . w/20 ' avg . *Joyful -7 ' to pool fence, 30 ' to bldg . .Happy (So . side) 15 ' - min. 20 ' avg . *Happy (No . side) 10 ' to rec. bldg. , 70 ' to bldg. 9150 . 8 Int. Side Setback 10 ' , or .West-12 ' to 33 ' 9150 . 9 Rear Setback if adjac. to . South (adj . to R1)-. R1, 10 ' + *1016" to patio, l ' per 2 . 5 ' avg. 20 ' to bldg. of bldg length over 25 ' (30 ' for Bldgs . 2 & 3) *Requires Special Permit Staff Report - 9/5/90 -5- (6989d) SECTION ISSUE REQUIRED PROVIDED 9150 . 10 Building Separation b) Rear-to-rear 20 ' +5 ' per 25 ' (Bldgs . 2 & 3) Story in excess of 1= 25 ' d) Side-to-side 10 ' +5 ' per *20 ' (Bldg . 1) unit in excess of 2 in either structure=55 ' g) Between unit 10 ' 32 ' and accessory bldg. h) Between unit 15 ' min. 15 ' to and unenclosed on-street parking parking 9150 . 12 Building Bulk a) Max. units 6 Max. A before Side-by-side building curves b) Front offset 4 ' per 2 Min. 4 ' offset units provided c) Height 1/3 of units *40% of project per structure is 2 story, 1 story less 60% 3, story 9150 . 13 Open Space a). Min. Sq. Footage 400 sf/unit 69 , 600 sf 56, 000 sf c) Private -ground lbr . Min. . sf and dim. met 200 sf for all units 10 ' m.d. -ground 2 br. 250 sf 10 'm.d. -upper 1 br 60 sf 6 ' m.d. -upper 2 br . 120 sf 6 ' m.d. *Requires Special Permit Staff Report - 9/5/90 -6- (6989d) SECTION ISSUE REQUIRED PROVIDED f) Max. enclosed 15% of open 1, 024 sf rec. area space=8,400sf g) 4 or more .no credit of no credit acre project site private for for private common space . 20 ' min. 20 ' min. dim. dim. for common open space 9150 . 14 Main Rec. Area f) Min Size 10, 000 sf 15 , 722 (primary) 50 'min. dim. plus 3 , 488 (sec . ) 100 ' avg . dim Total=19210 sf 50 'min. dim. , *75 ' avg. dim. 1) Amenities 2 Pool, Spa, Clubhouse Bar B Q 2) Location min. 20 ' min. 20 ' to unit from unit 3)Clubhouse Req'd min. 7 sf/ 1024 sf unit=980 sf 9150 . 15 Min F1 . Area 1 bdrm 650 sf 955 to 1120 sf 2 bdrm 900 sf 1110 to 1355 sf 9150 . 18 e) Storage Space 100 cubic ft . To be provided as condition of approval g) Trash Areas . w/in 200 ' Trash chutes within 200 ft . PROPOSED PARKING CODE 9601. 5 Stall Dimen. 9 ' x 19 ' 9 ' x 19 ' adjac. to walls 12 ' x 19 ' 12 ' x 19 ' Aisle Width 25 ' 25 ' *Requires Special Permit Staff Report - 9/5/90 -7- (6989d) SECTION ISSUE REQUIRED PROVIDED 9601 . 6 Parking Structures- Max. slopes Ramp w/o parking 10% *15% - 20% ingress/egress 16 ' long *16 20% transition w/5% max. slope 9602 .3 No . Spaces 1 brdm 1 . 5+ . 5/du=88 330 Total 2 brdm 2+ . 5/du =240 (see chart Total 328 below) The following chart addresses the on-site resident and guest parking provided on a building by building basis . Bldg . 1 Bldg. 2 Bldg . 3 Res . Guest . Tot . Res . Guest . Tot . Res . Guest . Tot . Required 109 30 139 82 22 104 67 18 85 Provided 110 24 134 84 14 98 70 28 98 Difference +1 -6 -5 +2 -8 -6 +3 +10 +13 Project Total Res . Guest . Tot . Required 258 70 328 Provided 264 66 330 Difference +6 -4 +2 As can be seen from this analysis, all required resident parking has been provided for each building, and the total number of spaces for the project has been met . However,' Buildings 1 and 2 are short 5 spaces and 6 spaces, respectively, for guest parking . Building 3 provides 13 extra guest spaces . Staff has determined that this layout is acceptable because the guest spaces for each building will be open and accessible to guests of any unit, and can be shared. There are also 39 on-street parking spaces available in front of the project along Happy Drive and Joyful Lane. * Requires Special Permit Staff Report - 9/5/90 -8- (6989d) Affordability: As part of the agreement between the developer and the Redevelopment Agency, the developer has agreed to make available 82 units for moderate income, first time buyers . Specifically, sixteen units will benefit from first trust deeds through the Southern California Home Finance Authority' s single family bond issue 1990 Series B, from which the Redevelopment Agency has purchased a commitment . These loans may be assumed by ,a qualified buyer or prepaid . In addition, all 82 of the assisted units will benefit from a second trust deed loan made by the Agency from Housing set aside funds . These loans will bear five percent interest for a twenty year term, but payments will be deferred. If a unit is sold, the Agency will collect the principal and deferred interest, plus participate in 50 percent of the equity for the first five years and on a declining basis in the sixth through twentieth years . All such income to the housing set aside fund must be used to further assist housing. This represents over two million dollars in Agency housing set aside funds committed to this project and will enable 52 'of the units 'to be affordable to households earning less that one hundred percent of the County' s median income ($49 , 100 . 00) while another 30 units will be affordable to households at just 107 percent of the median income ($52, 537 . 00) . The sales price of the affordable units will range from $155, 900. to $176, 900 . The price for market rate units will range from $189 , 900 to $205, 900 . The developer has also agreed to reinvest "excess profits" , as defined in the agreement, to assist higher income households in purchasing the larger units in the project . Special Permits : The following section describes the applicant ' s requested special permits, and staff ' s analysis of each. Section 9150 . 21 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code states that the Planning Commission may grant deviations from the provisions of the Planned Development section, in whole or in part, upon the following findings that the proposed development will : a. Promote better living environments; b. Provide better land . planning techniques with maximum use of aesthetically pleasing types of architecture, landscaping, site layout and design; c. Not be detrimental to the general health, welfare., safety and convenience, nor detrimental or injurious to the value of property or improvements of the neighborhood or of the city in general; d. Be consistent with the objectives of the planned residential development standards in achieving a development adopted to the terrain and compatible with the surrounding environment . Staff Report - 9/5/90 -9- (6989d) 1 . To allow a 7 to 10 foot front setback along Joyful Lane and the north side of Happy Drive in lieu of minimum 15 foot setback, for pool fencing and the common clubhouse building . The proposed special permit is for accessory structures only. The actual dwelling unit setback for all front/exterior side yard setbacks ranges from an average of 20 feet south of Happy Drive, to 70 feet north of Happy Drive. . Staff supports this special permit request because it allows the recreational area to be centrally located between the two sites, and because the recreation building, which is set back 10 feet, encroaches only along approximately 36% of that particular street frontage. The remaining encroachment consists of pool fencing . Staff is recommending that this fencing be of an open or see-through type, such as wrought iron, to reduce the impacts from the right-of-way. 2 . To allow a minimum rear setback of 10 ' 6" with 20 foot average to the building face in lieu of a 30 foot setback along R1 zoned property. This request applies along the southernmost property line, where the site abuts developed R1 property. The code requires a minimum setback. of 10 feet, plus one foot for every 2 . 5 feet of building length exceeding 25 feet . The maximum building length facing R1 is 75 feet, therefore, a 30 foot setback is required. To compensate for the reduced setback, the applicant has reduced the building height to 2 stories along most of the southerly property line . The only place that a 3 story structure will abut R1 property is in Building No. 2, for two unit lengths . However, the adjoining R1 structure is set back at least 30 feet from the property line on that side. Staff supports this request because the trade off for reduced number of stories along the property line renders the project sufficiently similar to the adjoining lower density residences as to be compatible. Staff is also recommending that balconies be railed with opaque material , in order to reduce views from second story units to the adjacent R1 property. 3 . To reduce side-by-side building separation for Building 1 from 55 feet to 20 feet . "Building 1" is actually composed of 2 U-shaped structures . Section 9150 . 9 (d) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code requires 10 feet between side-by-side buildings, plus 5 feet for each dwelling unit in excess of two in either of the structures . Since each building is composed of 11 "stacks" of units, a total of 55 feet is required between the structures . Staff supports this request because the U-shape of the buildings and the reduction of building profile along Tablert Avenue to two stories meets the . intent of the building separation requirement, which is to soften the building mass . The two structures are connected by a central elevator and essentially function as one building . Staff Report - 9/5/90 -10- (6989d) 4 . To allow 40% of the project to be one story less than the remainder in lieu of requiring one third of the units in each structure to be one story less . Staff supports this request because it allows the two story elements of the project to be clustered along the southerly property line adjoining R1 single family homes , and along Talbert Avenue. This configuration reduces impacts to the most sensitive adjacent land use and reduces the building profile along Talbert . However, it requires that two-story elements make up 23% of Building 1, 25% of Building 2, and 75% of Building 3 (40% of the total building mass) . Staff supports this request because the overall total number of 2 story units exceeds that required by code and the proposed configuration provides better visual buffers from adjoining properties and rights-of-way. 5 . To allow an average dimension of 75 feet for the main recreation area in lieu of 100 feet . Staff supports this request because it allows the main recreation area to be centrally located between the north and south portions of the project . The applicant also meets the minimum required dimension of... 50 feet, and exceeds the minimum required area by 5, 722 square 'feet (total main recreation area - 15, 722 square feet) . In addition, a secondary recreation area is provided totalling 3 ,488 square feet .. The common open space areas (including landscape areas, courtyards , setbacks, etc . ) , exceeds the total common open space required by 13 , 600 square feet (total provided - 69 , 600 square feet) . 6 . To allow 15% to 20% ramp slopes into the underground parking structures in lieu of a maximum 10% slope on ramps with no adjacent parking, and maximum 5% slope on a 16 foot transition ramp at intersections with streets . The applicant requires a steeper slope on the entry ramp into the garage because the parking aisles within the structure are level . Section 9605 . 1(h) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code allows the Planning Commission to grant deviations by special permit for such items as ramp slopes, based- on the following findings : a . A traffic study prepared by a traffic engineer has been submitted which documents the impacts of the request . b. The deviation will not adversely affect the circulation and safety of the site structure, use, or adjacent use. c. The deviation will result in a more efficient circulation pattern and parking layout . d. The deviation will enhance the general appearance of the development and its surroundings . Staff Report - 9/5/90 -11- (6989d) e. The deviation will not be detrimental to the general public health, safety, welfare or convenience, or injurious to property values in the vicinity. The applicant has submitted. a report from Linscott, Law & Greenspan, Traffic Engineers, which examines the circulation and ramp slopes . The report recommends slightly revised ramp profiles, 'which the applicant can meet without raising the height of the buildings . Staff supports the request based on the traffic engineers report that the proposal will provide for safe and efficient circulation. Compatibility with Rl : Staff has received phone calls from adjacent R1 homeowners who feel that the proposal will not be compatible with their residences . However, a combination of factors will reduce the impact of the proposed high density development . These include the reduction of height adjacent to R1 property to two stories when three stories are usually allowed, the average of 20 feet setback to the building face, and intensified landscaping . All parking will be subterranean, with access from existing streets . This should reduce traffic and noise impacts to a minimum. The main recreation area is separated from the R1 homes by Buildings 2 and 3 , and by Happy Drive. Summary: ' In conclusion, staff supports the proposed project because it will provide assured affordable housing for first time buyers in the City of Huntington Beach, thereby fulfilling goals outlined in the Housing Element of the General Plan. It will also help to satisfy the State requirement for use of Redevelopment set aside funds for affordable housing . The design of the project is compatible with the surrounding land uses, and completes the development of the neighborhood in the Talbert-Beach Redevelopment Area . The project is in conformance with the standards and intent of the Huntington Beach Ordinance code for Planned Residential Developments . 10 . 0 RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission approve Negative . ' Declaration 90-23 Conditional Use Permit No . 90-12 with Special Permits , and Tentative Tract No. 14357 with the following findings and suggested conditions of approval : FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL - CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-12 : 1 . The location, site layout, and design of the proposed 140 unit condominium project properly adapts the proposed structures to streets, driveways, and other adjacent structures and uses in a harmonious manner . _ T Staff Report - 9/5/90 -12- (6989d) 2 . The access to and parking for the proposed 140 unit condominium complex does not create an undue traffic problem, because the parking structure has been shown to be safe and efficient and the surrounding streets have adequate capacity to accommodate the traffic generated. 3 . The planned residential development for 140 units does conform to the provisions contained in Article 915 except for the special permit requests, which improve the quality of the project (see Special Permit Findings for Approval) . 4 . The proposed 140 unit project will not be detrimental to the general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity; and property and improvements in the vicinity of such use or building, because the project is properly buffered from such uses by streets and setbacks . 5 . The proposed 140 unit condominium will be compatible with the Huntington Beach General Plan and Zoning upon adoption of General Plan Amendment No . 90-3 and Zone Change 90-3 . FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL - SPECIAL PERMITS: 1 . The following special permits promote a better living environment by adapting the Planned Residential Development requirements to better suit the 140 unit condominium complex, which are compatible with the surrounding area : a . To allow a 7 to 10 foot front setback along Joyful Lane and the north side of Happy Drive in lieu of minimum 15 foot setback, for pool fencing and the common clubhouse building. b. To allow a minimum rear setback of 10 ' 6" with 20 foot average to the building face in lieu of a 30 foot setback along R1 zoned property. C . To reduce side-by-side building separation for Building 1 from 55 feet to 20 feet . d. To allow 40% of the project to be one story less than the remainder in lieu of -requiring one third of the units in each structure to be one story less . e. To allow an average dimension of 75 feet for the main recreation area in lieu of 100 feet . f . To allow 15% to 20% ramp slopes into the underground parking structures in lieu of a maximum 10% slope on ramps with no adjacent parking, and maximum 5% slope on a 16 foot transition ramp at intersections with streets . - t Staff Report - 9/5/90 -13- (6989d) 2 . The requested deviation for ramp slopes to the parking structure is acceptable because: a . A traffic study prepared by a traffic engineer has been submitted which documents the impacts of the request . b. The deviation will not adversely affect the circulation and safety of the site structure, use, or adjacent use. C . The deviation will result in a more efficient circulation pattern and parking layout . d. The deviation will enhance the general appearance of the development and its surroundings . e. The deviation will not be detrimental to the general public health, safety, welfare or convenience, or injurious to property values in the vicinity. 4 . The requested special permits provide for maximum use of aesthetically pleasing types of architecture, landscaping, design and building layout, by allowing for efficient on-site circulation, buffering adjacent land uses, and allowing for a centrally located recreation area . 5 . The requested special permits will not be detrimental to the general health, welfare, safety and convenience, nor detrimental or injurious to the value of property or improvements of the neighborhood or of the City in general . The special permit requests incorporated into the project design will reduce project impacts to adjacent properties . 6 . The requested special permits are consistent with the objectives of the Planned Residential Development standards in achieving a development adapted to the terrain and compatible with the surrounding environment. FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL - TENTATIVE TRACT NO. 14357: 1. The size, depth, frontage_ , street width, and other design features of the proposed 5 lot subdivision for 140 condominium units are in compliance with the standard plans and specifications on file with the City as well as in compliance with the State Subdivision Map Act and the supplemental City Subdivision Ordinance. Staff Report - 9/5/90 -14- (6989d) r 2 . The analysis for General Plan Amendment No. 90-3 and Zone Change No. 90-3 has determined that this intensity of land use (High Density Residential - Maximum 35 units per gross acre) is appropriate for this site. 3 . The General Plan has set forth provisions for High Density Residential Development and affordable housing, as well as setting forth objectives for the implementation of this type of use. 4 . The site is relatively flat and physically suitable for the proposed density of 31 . 1 units per gross acre. 5 . Tentative Tract No . 14357 for a 140 unit condominium complex is, consistent with the goals and policies of the Huntington Beach General Plan because it provides a means of affordable housing for first time homebuyers in Huntington Beach. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL - CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-12 : 1 . The site plan, floor plans, and elevations received and dated July 26, 1990, shall be the conceptually approved layout . Final approval of building form, colors and materials shall be subject to review anti approval by the Design Review Board. 2 . Prior to submittal for building permits, the applicant/owner shall complete the following: a . Submit three copies of the site plan to the Planning Division for addressing purposes . b. Depict all utility apparatus , such as but not limited to backflow devices and Edison transformers, on the site plan. They shall be prohibited in the front and exterior yard setbacks unless properly screened by landscaping or other method as approved by the Community Development Director. C. Floor plans shall depict natural gas and 220V electrical stubbed in at the location of clothes dryers; natural gas shall be stubbed in at the locations of cooking facilities, water heaters, and central heating units; and low-volume heads shall be used on all spigots and water faucets . d. If foil-type insulation is to be used, a fire retardant type shall be installed as approved by the Building Department and indicated on the floor plans . Staff Report - 9/5/90 -15- (6989d) e. The structures on the subject property, whether attached or detached, shall be constructed in compliance with the State acoustical standards set forth for units that lie within the 60 CNEL contours of the property. Evidence of compliance shall consist of submittal of an acoustical analysis report, prepared under the supervision of a person experienced in the field of acoustical engineering, with the application for building permit(s) . f . Elevations shall depict colors and building materials as approved by the Design Review Board. g . All rooftop mechanical equipment shall be screened from any view. Said screening shall be architecturally compatible with the building in terms of materials and colors . If screening is not designed specifically into the building, a rooftop mechanical equipment plan must be submitted showing screening and must be approved. h. If outdoor lighting is included, energy savings lamps shall be used. All outside lighting shall be directed to prevent "spillage" onto adjacent properties and shall be noted on the site plap and elevations . i . A detailed soils analysis shall be prepared by a registered Soils Engineer . This analysis shall include on-site soil sampling and laboratory testing of materials to provide detailed recommendations regarding grading, chemical and fill properties, foundations , retaining walls, streets, and utilities . j . The Design Review Board shall review and approve the following : (a) The final building form, colors and materials . (b) Balconies along the southernmost property. (c) Pool fencing shall be of wrought iron or other see-through material . k. The site plan or reference page shall include all conditions of approval imposed on the project printed verbatim. 1 . The final site plan shall note the location of 100 cubic feet of storage area per unit . 3 . Prior to issuance of building permits, the applicant/owner shall complete the following : a . A Landscape Construction Set must be submitted to the Departments -of Community Development and Public Works and must be approved. The Landscape Construction Set shall include a landscape plan prepared and signed by a State Licensed Landscape Architect and which includes all , Staff Report - 9/5/90 -16- (6989d) proposed/existing plant materials (location, type, size, quantity) , an. irrigation plan, a grading plan, an approved site plan, and a copy of the entitlement conditions of approval . The landscape plans shall be in conformance with Section 9608 and Article 915 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. The set must be approved by both departments prior to issuance of building permits . Any existing mature trees that must be removed shall be replaced at a 2 to 1 ratio with minimum 36-inch box trees, which shall be incorporated into the project ' s landscape plan. b. A grading plan shall be submitted to. the Department of Public Works for review and it must be approved (by issuance of a grading permit) . A plan for silt control for -;all water runoff from the property during construction and initial operation of the project may be required if deemed necessary by •the Director of Public Works . C . Hydrology and hydraulic studies shall be submitted for Public Works approval . d. All applicable Public Works fees shall be paid . e. Final Tract Map shall be accepted by the City Council, recorded with the Orange County Recorder and a copy filed with the Department of Community Development . f . An interim parking and/or building materials storage plan shall be submitted to the Department of Community Development to assure adequate parking is available for employees, customers, contractors, etc. , during the project ' s construction phase. g. Prior to issuance of building permits , a water plan shall be submitted to the water department . The plan shall detail measures which the project shall implement to reduce peak hour water usage. 4 . The Public Works Department requirements are as follows : a . Private driveways shall be of radius-type construction, per Huntington Beach Standard 211 A and B. . 5 . Fire Department Requirements are as follows : a. An automatic fire sprinkler system shall be approved and installed pursuant to Fire Department regulations . Shop drawings to be submitted to and approved by Fire Department prior to installation. b. Service roads and fire lanes, as determined by the Fire Department, shall be posted and marked. Staff Report - 9/5/90 -17- (6989d) C . Fire access lanes shall be maintained. If fire lane violations occur and the services of the Fire Department are required, the applicant will be liable for expenses incurred . d . Three fire hydrants shall be installed prior to combustible construction, and at locations specified by the Fire Department . e. The applicant shall meet all applicable local , State and Federal Fire Codes, Ordinances, and standards . f . A Class III wet standpipe system (combination) will be installed to comply with Huntington Beach Fire Department and Uniform Building Code standards . g . A fire alarm system will be installed to comply with Huntington Beach Fire Department and Uniform Fire Code standards . h. Fire extinguishers will be installed and located in areas to comply with Huntington Beach Fire Code standards . i . Elevators will be sized to accommodate an ambulance gurney (Minimu"m 6 ' 8" wide by 4 ' 3" deep, minimum 42" opening . j . Security gates will be designed to comply with Huntington Beach Fire Department Standard No . 403 . k. Address numbers. will be installed to comply with Huntington Beach Fire Code standards . 1 . Submit to Fire Department for approval a Fire Protection Plan containing requirements of Fire Department Specification No . 426 . M. Applicant shall pay for "Opticom" traffic system at Beach and Talbert . 6 . The development shall comply with all applicable provisions of the Ordinance Code, Building Division, and Fire Department . 7. All building spoils, such as unusable lumber, wire, pipe, and other surplus or unusable material, shall be disposed of at an off-site facility equipped to handle them. 8 . Installation of required landscaping and irrigation systems shall be completed prior to final inspection/within twelve (12) months . 9 . During construction, the applicant shall : a . Discontinue construction during second stage smog alerts . b. Wet down areas in the late morning and after work is completed for the day. Staff Report - 9/5/90 -18- (6989d) C. Use low sulfur fuel ( . 05% by weight) for construction equipment . 10 . Construction shall be limited to Monday - Saturday 7 : 00 AM to 8 : 00 PM. Construction shall be prohibited Sundays and Federal holidays . 11 . Should any cultural materials' be encountered during the initial site survey or during grading and excavation activities, all activity shall cease and the archaeologist shall be obtained to determine the appropriate course of action. 12 . During cleaning, grading, earth moving or excavation, the applicant shall : a . Control fugitive dust by regular watering, paving construction roads, or other dust preventive measures . b. Maintain equipment engines in proper tune. 13 . Prior to initiation of construction, police and fire departments shall be notified and the departments shall be kept informed about duration and extent of construction throughout the process . 14 . Public Works Department shall provide alternate routes for traffic during the construction phase, if necessary. Adequate signage shall be provided to warn motor vehicles, -bicyclists and pedestrians of construction. 15 . This conditional use permit and tentative tract shall not become effective until General. Plan Amendment No. 90-3 and Zone Change No . 90-3 have been approved by the City Council and are in effect . 16 . This conditional use permit shall become null and void unless exercised within one (1) year of the date of final approval, or such extension of time as may be granted by the Planning Commission pursuant to a written request submitted to the Planning Department a minimum 30 days prior to the expiration date . CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL - TENTATIVE TRACT 14357 : 1 . The tentative tract map received and dated July 26, 1990, shall be the approved layout with the following modifications : a . "Notes" shall be revised to reflect correct zoning and General Plan designation. 2 . At least 60 days prior to recordation of the final tract map, CC&R ' s shall be submitted to and approved by the City Attorney and the Department of Community Development . The CC&R' s shall reflect the and maintenance of all common areas by the Homeowners ' Association. Staff Report - 9/5/90 -19- (6989d) l 3 . This tentative tract shall not become effective until General Plan Amendment No . 90-3 and Zone Change No. 90-3 have been approved by the City Council and are in effect . 4 . Landscaping and enhanced pavement within the right-of-way as shown on the approved site plan shall be maintained by the Homeowners Association pursuant to an approved agreement with the City Public Works Department 5 . On-site sewers shall be private. 6 . The water system shall be located in vehicular travel ways and dedicated to the City. 7 . The developer will be responsible for the payment of the Water Master Plan fee, September, 1990 . 8 . The developer will be responsible for the payment of the Traffic Impact fees if in place at the time building permits are issued. 9 . The project shall accept -all contributory drainage from properties to the south, which shall be accommodated through the site in a manner to the satisfaction of the Department of Public Works . 10 . Construct full Public Works improvements to the centerline of Talbert Avenue. 11. The on-site sewer and water systems shall be shown on a City approved utility plan, showing all water services, fire hydrants , fire services, and backflow devices . 12 . Developer shall submit water system hydraulic calculations to ensure system adequacy and line sizing . 13 . The water system shall be looped, with no dead ends, and shall be installed per the Public Works Department ' s standards, ordinances, and policies . 14 . Developer shall dedicate vehicular access rights to the City except at access points approved by the City. 11 . 0 ALTERNATIVE ACTION: The Planning Commission may deny Conditional Use Permit No . 90-12 with Special Permits and Tentative Tract No. 14357 with findings . ATTACHMENTS: 1. Area map 2 . Negative Declaration 90-23 3 . Site plans, elevations, and floor plans dated July 26, 1990 4 . Tentative Tract No . 14357 dated July 26, 1990 5 . Report from Linscott, Law & Greenspan, Traffic Engineers 6 . Letter from Marc Andre Bock dated August 20 , 1990 HS:LP: kjl Staff Report - 9/5/90 -20- (6989d) Q8F J MI I_ RTY AVE�— N aM I4oa ,c R2 4 g¢� a°R3 QP a 'sjOP R I eELV. pl. " rc-� f!n = NEWMAN AVE _ 0 700DD + R2 990-C Ml-Co L MI ' 1B R2 .S E JUO. C. $ —I390 N.W`o' 2A9 OP RONALD DR. : - 3 M I 1.A I R 2 �• N. IYI 'R2-P0-Oti1000 '�.,.,. CD : R3 R3 -�r—���� t J' R2 u R2 C4 I c E EEE s.:..:' ` ! u r �-- J 17 : MI-CD M I I a oP; oP 8 , S P- I °(o)RA N < RI TALBERT r >NI-CD >o M ' --- -- RI - Ri — (D) MI MI-A c.7f.Q2-P �DO RI RI J JV� C 4 C F-E OL AIIrS AVE~ `A..- MI-C MI•A / R-.d I a.r. ..�s;... �.. . :,i RI R; RI VINESNi DC / 2 -Il- ' R4 N 2 SR I RI s.N,w cK ---- R� C 4 MI-CD :....;.:�,., ,. _,__;. .ltar-'.:_:--hip: ,� � _ .. ,Q � SIERI.INf. 4V1 NIK RI MI-A R4-SR RI: RI :. ^ = 0 1 CF-R max:, C2 RI RI RI a RI-PDM/ n U 3 ,+17K,AG ' z• � -' �•- Q KINER AVENUE KI NER AVE �' S; '-�-•1 a r.-a7NF EAnoR OR. m RI RI ••,_!.••'•.N.LIN ( V in 2 S2 20 -CD RI RI }nrL N OR LE C—L ' M I MI,. SD }V ONTARIO C 2 RI r7dl-y ,,rJ DR �i..__..- RI RI `; -RZa N RI RI RI J IRI�D•r'' _G` N R I _ Rz^ - NE,cR R I :;¢ DEWT CR, `JOUEBEC OR �,sus zes,n ;:•,:>,r::i .v.:i = MI R3 > "R3 R3 RI RI RI :,1(lGi�4GCDE=_: 4 R3 E ELLC CF-R +so ' o I a.- ,"^ �._.. ^ NOUNIJtn OR. n c ALBERTA pR f ^ C4 R3 .,.. � .... � 1, i P. MI CDL RI RI RI �RI �v R3 -'" f 7As3r :w L —J'\ - I R2 "ga RI MI o YUKON DR "RAN LRIi n DR ' C4o I �JIRI ' RI RI �• A..•'•�•-'! \�' a R3�.._—.. ..�R2 L 1 "�, •/"w GPA90-03/ZC90-03/CUP90-12 TT 143 57/ND90-23 HUNTiNGTON BEACH HUNTINGTON BEACH PLANNING DIVISION ti I If I I It, 77-1 Nr IL.I..USTRr11'IVE SITE PLAN SEA VIEW VILLAGE S F A V I E W ENTERPRISES INC . _I 3 hLilti tiI-H 1: .Stirni I70 IIUN I'IMMNd IIIiAG,I.c':\rla,at I i'�+1 rMrl l-�{ir 10 g„ __1 --- r� .gip �tN ,•it`2y# � A• , It I' 'L s 'x►�� •-� Z^4?f �� t� •, �,C��-^��.,� t � •�.�' .�i _ ,(`ilk s ,F � �t� P a \1 Rl \I. \ II:\\ II-1-I SI RATI I. s(I I: PI AN SEA VIEW VILLAGE > I: A � IF. w f f f: R11R11), s Ili. _—_—._.—._.—._---------.—.----—_ TALBFAT�VENUE I` lu IK. s)UNITS 111y1 !PARKING SUMMARY: D i ....�.....,...�... ,. „ � Te�wT UBLY:.DT,.D F- T„IS LOCwT nY'' I ��� I IV IM♦RY REC.wRE I ''" J,A ! 1 I HAPPY Cray -ae m—.4 .rb In i ry' Zi D D el w j Bx D o FUCGTYR D IL D D - UILpNG D D R, ■. D \ si..]e Fwri�r REsloE}cF: 36 LDING) BUIL-NG 7 M UNITS M UNITS SUMMARY: SITE AREA: 4.5 ACRES(GROSS) KEY 4.19 ACRES(NIM TOTAL UNITS:14) 2 STORY FJ.DAENTS - IOF r UNIT rn TOP FLCCR t DFNSITV: 51.1 D.U/ACRE THREE STURIFS PLAN NIX: DECKS AT WJrTUM FLOOR O PLAN TYPE 'F MIX COUNT THIS lllC-AfKN ONLY w-t Ie.DEB.ib - b iB.]TUDY.:b , .vr ]nlb n o Z I-V ro TECHNICAL SITE PLAN SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W ENTERPRISES I N C 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 170 suw,T]Eooue I...- ' 3 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 U,Te uc.1— (714)960-5505 %D�"�°u e `�1 CUI nUMBER CUI q,},T,(;q. TALBEKf AVENUE PARKING SUMMARY: - _ J! .I faw - j }J �♦-h P. GA 11" _ noyrs l �p'PI• 1 Y+.r+ i3 AI v1. r, .pO HY I unr one T ra T rl Ex. r s-1 iL I j 6 A PTvp _ - -- 1 TYP. C IUD TECHNICAL GARAGE PLAN SEA VIEW VILLAGE SEAVIEW ENTERPRISES INC 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 170 suWIITED MTef Iu Ero HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 evlsexw wm uc u.lvo 4 (714)960-5505 CUE M-9:CUE 4ILZC.0.1 FF, ._._.—.—.—.—._--.—._._-_._.--_--._.— TALBERTA VFH1E . ._ i 1 •\ ' II j i \ I 1, RE CREATION AREA OPEN ; SPACE SUMMMARY: 1 . Pr.rv,E•..wru If.!]]SF QI r H; I a OPEN SPACE SUMMARY: KEY: ussss� �Q a.....mr+-rmr• COMMON OPEN SPACE pVVwVlly resm}etvs RECREATION OPEN SPACE SITE COVERAGE: �_�y��_ "�rw ® .+a waEw .Ir nc�•cxEs uuu sE. IHUH sire CO"EIIwGE Isul•s!oa.•u]S SP. PW IDED CdEE,1DE e:u.}rorp:r ylrl. Rc Ilr Pmpir I}]•V. ]nnx srta n�ss N EWY PorP:r �1.•O]V OPEN SPACE PLAN f° SEA VIEW VILLAGE SEAVIEW ENTERPRISES INC 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 170 SUW RTED D,TE•IUNE< ' HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 9264.8 EEwso.wTE:wlc Is,w4 5 (714)960-5505 oer°iuwNe�X�H.[�« CUP NUMEEI:CUP r41LZC•0.. i I !I !'I :gL— T Boa„o I LINK; REORII pN(NO II __ I TY'NEN I. E. I. 5 I I PLAN A 955 S.F. R ___ � CPEN l'O EEIOw L O •TN _ I 'K f1CNEl {}—I I I EM TO E I � OPEN TO RELOw PLAN A LOFT A LOFT I I:x S.F. FLOOR PLAN SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W ENT ERP RI S E S I N C 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 170 suRameo o.ra+N,.a..o HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 REVISION CN'E:Y>r:.O.Iwo L (714)960.5505 cur»uNRE4 cur aulu w+ r"/ I li!E r+.w ca,op1o.T o�Nir c INo � i Ij el � r.HEAE THEr RCI.V ` "I � LlYirp B �BEOBLI � � I YwfT•EOl4 O o � _ wW 1 oIW I , 1 C as o a Ala BwtH \ B B,TH p 1 r L O �.77 Is �.I yFy' Hoot � iT}y --- ly I la. • I � li I II PLAN S, PLAN B2 11.. :10 SF. vi J OECCI ?� uvlee � =wSf OEMM I OpNl a B,TN Ll I B H O 010� O ewtH • O i O r pa EN ro EN BE �� L*.EN roBELOW PLAN B LOFT ® B LOFT ILO S.F. 1 B O FLOOR PLAN SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W ENTERPRISES , I N C 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 170 wwmeo p TE TUNE o ' HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92649 °.y,pBB�uB�Ewe uI B 7 (714)960.5505 w•E• cur NuurEB.ccr olvzc r�Y� ' �—��TooR'xca.�nrlu.Ar cnDUHL . � 1 IQ P I o» .BATH - ` BATH` i O PLAN C I.SD S.F. 19 I I CECB\\ LI"I1.1C.�—B \`\\ ST+r. br R »ASlE0.B b1001 1 I gvl!G '— — 10 »BATH G L I CR p <� r• R� III PLAN D II 1555 S.F. FLOOR PLAN SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W ENTERPRISES I N C 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 170 WITTEDDATE 1»AAW HUNTINGIION BEACH,CA 92648 RS.—,R'+BovTls.r•+o (714)960-5505 xu»BeR:w cuBxu»sec cur ou,u of i�•JJ t 1 L , _ _ I W � - t .� .t. t• r - YI .tom \v r T l f F 4 3 � f }•• } } 1 } T } a ij N a s 5 4 3 z £ F F % x fr 3 f h � � 3' 4< f M .�.§• 0}�.:Ix%tkl`C Y(TYM /p ems¢� '-'4�x} .P• � SEA: VTEW� V"1LLAGE � 'f H � hw•: M � L V y `H rr•:.. i $ ,'.. I e :, t CTy Jw d Y Y � Y � ;sue— � T� a �kaY I r: rc f�• 3 F � I 1 g Wit: 10: 5:.A i� it 4 - y. 4yrt tat: RV I`ta` SEA VIEW VILLAGE SE ,AVIEW ENTERPRISES INC . `I_I MAIN SIREF I.SUITF 17I) - I IUN IINGION 6F.ACI1.<'A"-'.h4N 9 tt tl ;. .t I °y al n ��1 .1 k a ✓n �z �` an i3. t Li p i p+ F�:.. It;� Y f•� �t si 68 3q M t d 31. Ylwai O 0 I N i 0 M � ' 9 1 0 d q I - 0 1 f J _ 1 f I i 'I � I JN �m Em — RFm P> EXTtiB[7R ELEVAT[7� SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V l E W ENTERPRISES I N C . 2124 MAIN TriauT.suah j 170 'j '' ',�—" -l�' IIUNTINUTUN BEACIL CA 92"11 11'";: J"' (714)%0.5503 t` i t 1 ( 11 1 1, S 1 �m EXTULK ELEWIN SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W ENTERPRISE S I N C 1111 MAIN STREET.SUITE 170 ;n HUNTINGTON BEACH.CA 9161E �.•�d�l�,)+ (714)960-5505 i, 'a i a u DI a � a 1 ■ i �I II A I bm EXTE112]t E;i.TM S. EA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W —ENT E R P R ISE S I N C 2124 MAIN STREET,SURE 170 H.... HUNTINQ7UlN BEACH.CA 92649 IGYV:fll;4:^� 15� (714)960-5503 1 1-- Y i o ' 0 1 I i A i N a E%TERICR UE%KTM SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W ENTERPRISES INC 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 1711 HUNTINUTUN BEACH,CA 9265 ISn (714)%0.5$05 I I =.• rj AL 10 -77 1 - I �._ _= p'I A.o _ v :I - — , •e I M RECREATTN.t.,LSTTA P N SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W E N T E R P R I S E S I N C 2124 MAIN STREET.SUITE I" HUNTING"BEACH.CA 12W 16 HAPPY DRIVE j f^ ej AM- - 7 - n I � v S f` I 9 p JOYFUL LANE m e f• f M f.y Z e — "—] 7 r I y g - - 1 .{I — C � 9 Z TECHNICAL DEGAS SEA VIEW VILLAGE S E A V I E W ENT E R P R ISE S I N C 2124 MAIN STREET,SUITE 170 warmau o.n..nnrw HUNTINOTON BEACH,CA 92648 9,'ti`ear,�Mr�.,.,,�Jr. 17 (714)960-5505 f (, MAP Mo. �01357 (r � �a2E� ' IT'MITI l�i'DI1V o vB ° ° 0 c�JEs LEGAL DESCRIPTION: 4° OWNER'S AUTHORIZATION: THAT PORTION OF TRACT NO. 172.IN THE CITY Oi HUNTWOTON BEACHI,' I HEREBY ALRMINIZE THE P�IEPMA1gN ANp FLING COUNTY Of ORANGE.STATE OF CALJFORNLI,AS SHOWN ON A ALAP OF THIS TENTATNE fyp RECORDED IN BOOK 12.PACES 21 AND 22.OF YISCELUHEOUS YAPS,IN 7ALBERi AVE. THE OFFICE OF THE COUNTY RECORDER OF SNO COUNTY.DESCRIBED AS ('� FOLLOWS: fI LOTS-107, 100. 113. 114. 112. 120. 125.126.131. 132. 137.138. SITE4( G L-12-1990 IA3. 144. I42.ANO ,50 Of BLOCK•A OF SAID TRACT. NUN UTE LOTS 5,6, 11. 12. 17. 18.23.24.29.30.35.36.41.42.47. 4a 53.54.-2.6O,55.66.71.72.77.78.83.84.a9.90.95. ENGINEER: 26..AND 101 TIROUGH 150.INCLUSIVE.OF BLOCK-6 OF SM0 TRACT. Q ffi MALL A FOREMAN.IHC. LOTS 1.2,3.].a.9. 13. 14. 15. 19.20.25,26,31.32.37. ad DR. 3170 REDHILL AVENUE 3e,4],71.45.49,50,51.55,56.3],61,62,6],6],dd.69, COSTA MESA CA 9262a-3428 J3,]4,]5. T9,b0.61,e2.e5.e6,67,66.91,92.93.94,97, ri1 (714)541-8777 103, 104. 105. 10e. 109.110. 111.112. 115. 116. 113 40. 141, 142.145. 127.( 40. 12e, OD 130.133. 134,WITH PREPARED UNDER THE SUPERVISION OF: 136,WESTERLY .00 142.F L L46. IN,AND Ha 39 ALL O WITH . THE OF SAID e.00'f[ET D<LOTS 21.27,33.AND 39 ALL OF BLOCK 'C OF SAID TRACT. EXCEPTING THEREFROM THE EASTERLY 16.00 FEET OF SNO LOTS et,88. ^/ 4, 1 , 1]0, IJ6, 2 b,AND l OF G C LOP(- OF - VIDINTTY MAP S TRACT. 112. +,e. 1N N ND TRACT. M.T.S. ES R.1\YARIAND R.C.C. 3292 DALE - OWNERS: -- -- -- -- 1. SEA VIEW MtLACE, TALBERT n- Lui AVENUE A CALIFORNIA GENERAL PARTNERSHIP ------- ----------_-n--- _-_-_-_ -•---- =7 2124 MAIN STREET.SUITE 170 _________- --__----- --_ NUNTINGTOn BEACH,CA92e48 (714)960-55p5 2. CITY OF HUNRNGToN BUCK - 20DO MAIN STREET _ 'I HUNTINGTON BEACH.CA 9264a I I 1 (714)960-8899 LEGEND I 3. PEOCVELOVMENi AGENCY. - I - I CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH _ I I -___ INDK•ATES EXISTING R/W 2000 MAIN STREET I t I I OR PROPERTY LINE (uMGTO 1HN BEACH,CA 926" SJ L*� --- INOIUTES CENTERUNE 714)536-5_2 I 1 I - INDICATES PROPOSED R/W 1`LQ.P. OR LOT UNE -•4. I EX:STI G CURB t CUTTER TM ff580 ;I -- -- EX15TINc STORM DRNN 536/'1-'3 MIA EXISTING SEWER LINE- EXISTING WATER LINE UNE fXXInwC ELLEP CAS E CONDUIT SUBDIVIDER: = I ry PROPOSED SEWER LINE PROPOSED WATER UNE •) I I W I•...,J,• 2f SERER MANHOLE SEA NEW EHTEPVR15E5,INC. 1 I I 2124 MAIN STREET.SUITE,70 'I I I l 1 -� 1 FIRE HYDRANT MUNTING ON BEACH.CA 92548 (714)960-55C5 c A PAD-34-.a� AREA TABUiAT10NS: LOT NO. NET ACRES UNITS 1_47 65 2 0.37 _ 8LX A i 11.G 44 TRI72 SIP ( r P 5 ,.D4 36 1?J2122 AU+I III PIW49.3 :/ 4 ,},Ap�a•3 =1 BOlM- TOTAL NET ACRES: 4.14 PROPOSED.__ TOTAL GROSS ACRES: 4.5 STORY Or r.wFNT 37.0 i TRAR_NO.B1VT �-�-1 GENERAL NOTES EASEMENT NOTE GRAPHIC SCALE 1.CAFE PREPARED: JUNE S. ION JOYFUL LANE MO HAPPY DRIVE ESTABUSHED 2.MU. 4.23 ACRES - B O4 Y EASEMENT DEEDS RECORDED AS ST.NO. 3. GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL 83-352375 DATED AUGUST 12. 1983 AND MST. 4. EXISTING 20NIHG: M1-A MO(0)R2-PO NO.87-WB429 GATED OCTOBER 30. 1987. ,01 5. PROPOSCD ZONING: Y1-A(0)RI-PO AND R4-SR(PppNG) OFFICIAL RECORDS OF ORANGE COUNTY. I Ie4R-p R 6. EXISTING USE;VACANT/SINGLE FAIRLY RESIDENCES 7. PROPOSED USE: MEDIUM/NIGH RESIDENTIAL B. NUMBER OF LOTS: 5 S.ADJACENT LAND USES: NORM: RESIOENNL/UGHT INDUSTRY EAST: COMMERCIAL S0.R\W R/W R/W SOUTH:RESIOENNL , WEST: RESIDENTIAL -- 10.ALL LOT CANES MO DIMENSIONS ARE APPROXIMATE A. II.TOPOGRAPHY PRO`AOED BY Cm 2-P.U.E. --1 2*P.U.E APcc C/AB 0.17' 0.17' I &G 0.17' , UTILITY PURVEYORS: PAVEMENT P<C �PAVEYEM I.WATER: CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH SIDEWALK SIDEWALK Gy. PCC�� 2.S CITY Of HUNTINGTON BEACH TYPICAL JECTION 3.STORYTORM DRAIN: CRY Of NUNTWGTOM BUCK E . 4.GAS: SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA GAS S.POWER: SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON TYPICAL SECTION TALBERT AVENUE JOYFUL LANE & HAPPY DRIVE 6.TELEPHONE: GENERAL TELEPHONE N.T.S. N.T.S. ].CABLE T.V.: PARAGON CABLE SERNCE - "SEA .VIEW CONDOMINIUM" J.N. 4193 -2(p-qo Office of the City Clerk did' City of-Huntingt on Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 .......... F 1:"J.chard TI.-lamp-i- -T 'A T-1 t. T I rU Office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 040% 04 04 0%A A 04 P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 159-271 --32 :1.f3,1.7:1. A JJ. e I T*1 9 &,�ff P.O.Box 19U Cj d F*J-'-:!-In I:) DT' (2. ,).6 4 TI- IW Office of the City Clerk -City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 ,_„ 933--27 '124 I"IuT•I't'.J.Tu:I't'.C)T'i Z:+r:, 9'A':'.64{3 Nit. Ilt�!!!!�!I,iltlllltil,tl,tltlt111ttt11111!!1!Iltttl City of Huntington Beach ! P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 1 :Lf32.''7 ' P<71 T'I(V i.(-;�w I...T-1 hl�.tT'rl::i.rlc� kc.)T'I I. '.),AC:I'i Sze�8� CALIFORNIA P.O.BOX 190 F " .1 quez.. Aj „ y ' :L t:3::.4.�:. 1::'<a r v:i.c:a w LT'! I"ILAT-1-t'.iSig't. a 92646 _ - -- _ -_ _•;�^ •ems-- J . - - _ -. -,..- Office of the City Clerk -- - -• .,_. . ! City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 4. `� { `,"�' Fl G 933-F) I I . Office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Beach wr -Y; P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 i.<:1m VI I..Isnc1 iss I.-Y'1 --- Office of the City Clerk city of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 i Eie ac::h , Ca 926-4F. �N X, +M1 I