The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutPublic Hearing-Overruled PC-Granted Appeal-CUP 90-14-Deni NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING APPEAL - CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-14 (Appeal of Planning Commission' s approval of the expansion of an existing liquor store into an existing adjacent facility) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who. wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE/TIME: Monday, November 5, 1990, 7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Conditional Use Permit No. 90-14 APPLICANT: Eldon W. Bagstad 4 F' APPELLANT: Councilman Wes Bannister LOCATION: 414 Pacific Coast Highway ZONE: Downtown Specific Plan - District 3 REQUEST: To permit the expansion of an existing liquor store located at 470 Pacific Coast Highway into the adjacent unit at 414 Pacific Coast Highway. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15301, Class 'l, of- the California- Environmental Quality Act . COASTAL STATUS: Exempt from the provisions of Article 989 pursuant to Section 989 . 5 .3 . 1 ON FILE: A copy of the propdsed request is on file in the Community Development' Department, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or, 'against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions please call Hal Simmons, Senior Planner, at 536-5271. Connie Brockway City Clerk (7490d) i ISL Legal Notice City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk �aG7oly �Y- ,c ` P. O.Box 190 PRESORT F s J.S.POSTAGE 9� Huntington Beach,CA 92648 r OCT 2 i '90�� s ?� 0.2 FIRS' � �_ _ to 024 S f �w� R ` 175444 ES0R'iS_ 1AS1.=140 CAL HUNT I NsV'I ON BEACI-1 CA 9264$ � J� - tttiC �tT ntlit:;FSs .`� p% ❑A TEMPTED, FIRST CLASS MAIL n lir.H WIN��E� Ht IN l INC TM SI ACH Nt1 i ��s��sss�s�s��:ss�ts��ss�s►�s�ssssii,tl,l:!{t,l�ssli �_. J 4& CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK t November 21, 1990 Eldon W. Bagstad 470 Pacific Coast Highway Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Dear Mr. Bagstad: The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at its regular meeting held November 19, 1990, denied with findings, your application relative to Conditional Use Permit No. 90-14 This is a final decision. You are hereby notified that pursuant to provisions of Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedures of the State of California you have ninety days from November 21, 1990, to apply to the courts for judicial review relative to the Conditional Use Permit. Please call this office if you.have any questions. Sincerely yours, Connie Brockway, CMC City Clerk CB:me Enclosure CC: City Attorney Community Development Director City Administrator 1051 K (Telephone: 714-536.5227) Title 1 WRIT OF MANDATE §. 1094.6 exhibits, all rejected exhibits in the possession of the local agency or its cornmission,_board, officer, or agent, all written evidence;`and any other papers in the case. W),•If the. pctitioner.files a request for tliv record ns specified in ctihdivisinn ((-) within 10 clays after the dale the decision becomes fi- nal as provided in subdivision (b); the' Bale within which a lietiticnt pursuant to Section 1094.5 cony he filed shall be extended to not later than the 30th, day following the date on which the record is- either personally delivered or-mailed to the petitioner.or his attorney of rec-. ord, if he has one. (e) As used in this-section, decision means adjudicatory admin- istrative decision made, after hearing, suspending, demoting, or dis- missing an officer or employee, revoking or denying an application for a permit or a license, or denying.an application for any retire- ment benefit or allowance. (f) In making a final decision as defined in subdivision (e), the local agency shall provide notice to the party that the time within which judicial review must be sought is governed by this section. As used in this subdivision, "party" means an officer or em- ployee who has been suspended, demoted or dismissed; a person whose permit or license has been revoked or whose application for a permit or license has been denied; or a person whose application for a retirement benefit or allowance has-been denied. (g) This section shall be applicable in a local agency only if the governing board thereof adopts an ordinance or resolution making this ,section applicable.... If such ordinance or resolution is adopted, the provisions of this section shall prevail over any conflicting provision in any otherwise applicable law relating to the subject matter. (Added by Stats.1976, c.276,p.581, § 1.) Forms See West's California Code Forms, Civil Procedure. Library References Administrative Lavv and rrocedurn C..7.8. Public. Administrative BodieA and C-722. Procedure § 193. Notes of Decisions In general I Ihnt public t:ntpinymont rnlutlons board Exhaustion of administrative remedies 2 hull cxclnsivo Juriedietion to determine whether the unfair practice clmrgem wore lustificd; Mud, in view of teachers' failure to cxhnnst 1hc►r ndministrative remedies - I. In general under Iho Itodda Acl. trial court erred in 8ehool board's ltnilnlnrul frvezing of _ grmiting writ of manduto to compol super- It•nclo:rs' snlnrh-s nfler hegioning of new iuloudent of districl and others to ruime school }•cnr,, while contrm•I iiegntintiuns snlarb•s of certain tenches. Ainndnt• Vul- were lum4ing,• i"•gnuhly wiis tm unfair 10•Y lw•onubiry Eduentors AHs'n %. \ewlin pruc.tiev in violution of the Ituddu Act so (1979) IG1 Cul,Itptr. 724, M G.A.3d 251. 675. y)11 § 1094.5 SPECIAL PROCEEDINGS Part 3 Note 378 n.nniled for new trial de no,,,. Prl•w•od ,. m3aed r,anl, i-:sioner hnd uu jurixdirlioll t'nlifornin (.'m•mpincnu•ut 111s. Aplit•111x Ild. nod did not doerntlm, nwrhs. Western Air (19711) 127 CA.Rlltr. 6-10, 57 C.A.31l 21), IJuex We. v-Sobieski (1(181) 1! Cal,itptr. 'Print court's Ju(Igntew d,•n)ing writ of 7111, 1M. C.A:_d 31R n(nndnte to cotmwl director of ngric•ttlturo leaet that letter discharging senior tyll- to set nxide him decision revnkiug petitinn- ist elrrk in t�ffice of eounl� clerk Muted er's license its aircraft pilot in haxinesx „f 11111t Kill' wax guilty lif utisconduct in re- pest control wax recerxed turd enxe re 11100119'pnhlie recurdx Irnnt 1ho files and ntnnded to trial court with directions to antlilating and xec•roing; them on various remand rase to director fur purpose of dates, whereas in hearing before county revonxideriug the penalty previously im- elvil xervil•o cotomimslon evidence was ill- posed, where it was found that some of troduced .onl.� ns to what took place on thu charges agninst. petitioner were not one of the dater, did not •require tile.. dis- snl,ported by evidence. Wingfield c. i riot court of appeal on nl,penl.from judg- Dircvlor of Agriculture (1972) 1113 Col. nlent Awordiug senior typi..,l clerk writ (if ltprr.e19,29 C.A.3d 209. mandnte, nftee reversing tho Judgment of Proceedi ig for revltcw of denial by vont- the superior court, to rentnnd the matter mixaloner of rnrpnrntlons of permit to to the couunixxion for re,•onsideration, rhnuge voting; rights of xhareholders where.. there nos n xialiLuilc of facts cur- would be rctnnnded to superior court for rounding removal of the d,-c•umenlx on all of the doles. 1'rstt v. Lu,; .kngelem Coon- tialevideomt whether there „•ns suht,tnu- ty Civil Service Continisaiou (1952) 2;38 tact evidence to support conuniseloltcr's I`:3d'3,1(13 C.A:Ld 11•i. budingr, where court improperly deter- § 1094.6. Judicial review; decisions of local (agencies; petition; filing; time; record; decision and Marty defined; or- dinance or resolution (a) Judicial review of any decision of a local agcnc.\•, other than school district, as the term local agency is defined in Section 54951 of the Government Code, or of ally commission, board, officer or agent th.. -cof, may be had pursuant to Section 1094.5 of this code only if the petition for writ;of mandate pursuant to such section is filed `,, ithin the time limits:specified in this section.. (b) Any such petition shall be filed not later than the 90th day following the date on which the decision becomes final. If there is no provision for reconsideration of the decision in any applicable provi- sion of any statute, charter, or rule, for the purposes of this section, the decisi�` is final on the date it is made. If there is such provision for reconsideration, the decision is final for the purposes of this sec- tion upon the expiration of the period during which such reconsidera- tion can be sought; provided, that if reconsideration is soclght pursu- ant to.any such provision the decision is final for the purposes of this section on the date that reconsideration is rejected. (c) The complete record of the proceedings shall Ix' prepared by Ille lo(.:,Il r1gellcy off its l't)llllllititiit)Il, board, officer, or i gent which inade the decision and shrill be delivered to the petitioner within 90 days ;after.he has filed'a written request therefor. The local agency may recover from the petitioner its actual costs for transcribing or otherwise preparing the record. Such record shall include the Iran- Script of thu proceedings, all pleadings, all notices and orders, any proposed decision by a hearing officer, the final decision, all admitted 674 1 5 Authorized to Publish Advertisements of all kinds including �l' S � �� /1Z11 ' public notices by Decree of the Superior Court of Orange County, California, Number A-6214, September 29, 1961, and f A-24831 June 11, 1963 STATE OF CALIFORNIA PUBLIC NOTICE County of Orange PUBLIICICE HE RFric' APPEAL-CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT I am a Citizen of the United States and a NO.90-14 (Appeal of Planning Commraslon's approval resident of the County. aforesaid; I am over the of thesexpansion of age of eighteen years and not a party to or an toetingli n store into an i existing adjacent interested in the below entitled matter. I am a facility principal cleric of the ORANGE COAST DAILY GIVEON'TICE that the Huntng IS HEREBY one f Beach City Council will hold'cil Chamber at the Hunt-PILOT, a newspaper of general circulation, a public hearing in the Coun- printed and published in the City of Costa Mesa, ington Beach Civic Center,) �2000 Main Street, Hunt- County of Orange, State of California, and that ington Beach, California, on N attached Notice is a true and complete copy as the date and at the time lid consider ns'o d below to receive and consider the statements of was printed and published in the Costa Mesa, all persons who wish to be heard relative to the appli- Newport Beach, Huntington Beach, Fountain cation described below. DATE/TIME:Monday,No- Valley, Irvine, the South Coast communities and ve per 5. 1990,7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER:( Laguna Beach issues of said newspaper to wit �COo'ditional Use Permit No., the ISSUe(S) Of. APPLICANT: Eldon W.I Bagstad APPELLANT: Councilman, Wes Bannister LOCATION: 414 Pacific) Coast Highway October 25 19^^>0 ZONE:Downtown Specific, Plan-District 3 REQUEST: To permit the expansion of an existing] .liquor store located at 470I Pacific Coast Highway into (the adjacent unit at 414 Pa- cific Coast Highway _ ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Categorically ex- empt pursuant to Section / 15301, Class 1, of the Cali • fornia Environmental Quality Act. COASTAL STATUS: ExJ empt from the provisions of Article 989 pursuant to Sec- tion 989.5.3.1 ON FILE:'A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Community Develop- ment Department, 2000 Main Street. Huntington Beach,California 92648,for inspection by the public. declare, under penalty ofperjury, that the I ALL INTERESTED PER- -SONS Y SONS are invited to attend ;said hearing foregoing is true and correct. and express 'opinions or submit evidence 'for or against the application tober as outlined above. If there O rJ 0 tare any further questions, c Executed on 11992 please call Hal Simmons, 'Senior Planner,at 536-5271. at Costa Mesa, California. Connie Brockway, city llerk, City of Huntington each Published Orange Coast Daily�rP41i of Om toberr 25,1:990 SI / attire �>Th=�i7+45 PROOF OF PUBLICATION ��' Itfo ✓ -�, � CITY CLERK CITY OF ___HUN:H iG1'111 r-ACH CALIF. elU _ �c� �20 �vvlJc 0 r2.0 1 &,I.L-'z C/&79 y vv ZZ V o`r7C.Ly O hc- 7Fka- (4;,ei0, rAL1S S*V oV—r- /t)o �ice- 70 yao, REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION November 5, 1990 Date Submitted to: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members Submitted by: Michael T. Uberuaga, City Administrator Prepared by: Michael Adams, Director of Community Development Subject: APPEAL TO PLANNING COMMISSION APPROVAL OF CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-14 Consistent with Council Policy? ] Yes [ ] New Policy or Exception Statement of Issue, Recommendation,Analysis, Funding Source, Alternative Actions, Attachments: STATEMENT OF ISSUE• On July 24, 1990, the Planning Commission approved Conditional Use Permit No. 90-14 for the expansion of an existing liquor store at 470 Pacific Coast Highway. Approval was conditioned upon the liquor store being designed as one store rather than two. Councilman Bannister has appealed the approval in order for the Council to further review the applicant ' s reasons for expansion. New information has also come to light regarding the Alcoholic Beverage Control Board ' s (ABC' s) - requirements for the liquor license. RECOMMENDATION• Motion to: "Uphold the appeal and deny Conditional Use Permit No. 90-14 with findings" : Planning Commission Action on July 2, 1990: THE PLANNING COMMISSION ON JULY 2, 1990, APPROVED CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-14, WITH FINDINGS AND CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: MOTION: Kirkland r�m SECOND: Ortega co AYES: Kirkland, Ortega, Mountford, Shomaker, Leipzig m NOES: Williams r'' Tea ABSENT: Bourguignon ABSTAIN: None c� T s PI O 5/85 ANALYSIS• Applicant: Eldon Bagstad Appellant: Councilman Wes Bannister Project Location: 414 Pacific Coast Highway Issues • Conditional Use Permit No. 90-14 is a request for expansion of an existing market/liquor store in District 3 of the Downtown Specific Plan. Liquor stores are a permitted use subject to approval of a conditional use permit pursuant to Section 4 . 5 . 01(b)L of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code (Downtown Specific Plan) . The applicant is requesting to expand his existing market/liquor store (El Don Liquor) located at 470 Pacific Coast Highway into the adjacent retail space located at 414 Pacific Coast Highway (currently occupied by a surfboard shop) . The expansion would increase the square footage of the market/liquor store from 1,422 square feet to 2, 044 square feet. The principle issue with this request is whether or not the applicant is expanding a liquor store, or creating a second liquor store adjacent to the existing one. The applicant ' s written narrative indicates that the intent is to expand rather than create a second store. The Planning Commission and staff, however, were concerned that the applicant' s plans did not depict a connection between the two stores. Since it was felt that two separate liquor stores side by side would not be desirable, the applicant was conditioned to provide a revised floor plan depicting one integrated liquor store. After the Planning Commission approved the request with the additional condition for integration of the uses, Councilman Bannister appealled the approval to further review whether one or two liquor stores were being proposed by the applicant. After the appeal had been filed, the applicant submitted a letter requesting continuance to November 5, 1990 as he would be out of town during the month of September and October. Staff honored his request in scheduling this item. RCA - 11/5/90 -2- (7590d) In the ensuing time, staff received a communication from the Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) regarding the requirements of the applicant ' s liquor license. That information is attached to this staff report. What the ABC has explained is that under their regulations, Mr. Bagstad is required to operate two separate and distinct businesses, with no direct public access between the two businesses for customers of either licensed premises . According to the documents, Mr. Bagstad signed his agreement to abide by that requirement. In summary, the ABC's requirements for Mr. Bagstad' s liquor license are in direct conflict with the staff and Planning Commission' s condition of approval for the project. Unless the City Council deletes the condition for integrating the uses, ABC will revoke Mr. Bagstad' s new liquor license. Since staff does not believe that two separate liquor stores located side by side are desirable, staff does not recommend that the condition be eliminated. Rather, in recognition of the insurmountable conflict with ABC' s requirements, staff recommends that the Planning Commission' s approval of this item be overturned and the application denied. FUNDING SOURCE: N/A ALTERNATIVE ACTION: 1. The City Council may deny the appeal and uphold the Planning Commission' s action of July 24, 1990, with all conditions intact. The ABC will then act to revoke the applicant' s second liquor license and the City' s approval will be met. 2. The City Council may deny the appeal and modify condition of approval number one and allow two separate liquor stores with no internal connection. ABC will then honor the second liquor license. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Findings for Denial of Conditional Use Permit No. 90-14 2 . Alcoholic Beverage Control ' s petition for Conditional License 3 . Letter from Eldon Bagstad dated August 30, 1990 4 . Letter of Appeal from Councilman Bannister 5 . Condition Letter dated July 26, 1990 6 . Staff Report dated July 24, 1990 MTU:MA: :kjl RCA - 11/5/90 -3- (7590d) ATTACHMENT NO, 1 FINDINGS FOR DENIAL - CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-14 : 1. The establishment of two liquor stores adjacent to each other will be detrimental to and not in keeping with other uses in the vicinity. 2 . The requirement that the two liquor stores be integrated into one store with internal access between the two is prohibited by the Department of Alcoholic Bevarage Control . 3 . The City' s desire for an integrated liquor store is an irreconcilable conflict with Alcoholic Bevarage Control ' s requirement for two separate liquor stores . (7590d-4) BEFORE Tl9E DEPARTMENT OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE CONTROL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA IN THE MATTER of T nE Application of' BAGSTAD, Eldon 414 Pacific Coast Highway Huntington Beach , CA 92648 FIIE REG. for the issuance of an Original Off-Sale General License under the Alcoholic Beverage Control Act. PETITION FOR CONDITIONAL LICENSE '^'HEr'.EAS , petitioner has filed an application forthe issuance of an Original Off-Sale General License ( Priority T23/1989 ) , for the above-mentioned premises ; and, WHEREAS , the applicant is currently licensed at 416 Pacific Coast Highway , Huntington Beach ; and, WHEREAS , the currently licensed premises at 416 Pacific Coast Highway , Huntington Beach) is located in the unit immediately adjacent to the north side of the applicant premises ; and, WHEREAS , the Department is concerned that the applicant premises will not be physically separated and operated independently of the the currently licensed premises at 416 Pacific Coast Highway; and , WHEREAS , without the restrictions stated below, issuance of the applied-for license would be contrary to the interest of the public welfare and morals , convenience or necessity, and. contrary to the ABC-521 , Issuance of Original and Intercounty Transfers of General Licenses , reviewed on 9-22-89 by the applicant and acknowledged by the applicant' s signature ; and , WHEREAS , the proposed premises and/or parking lot operated, in cor,,junct.i.on therewith are located within 100 feet of seven ( 7 ) residences ; and., Date : Cjf //— D Applicant/Petitioner flZ��d Witness : L('P,�CL�OX� , ABC-172 (4-78) ' BAG8T&D ' Eldon Page 2 414 Pacific Coast Bigb^/uy ' Huntington Beach , CA 92648 WBER8A8 , issuance of a license without the below described conditions would interfere with the quiet enjoyment of the property . by nearby residents and constitute grounds for the denial of' the d the provisions � Rule 8] 4 Chapter 1 Title 4 ' application uo er e lzrov n oon o u e . , ap er , e of the California Code of Regulations . NOW , THEREFORE, the undersigned petitioner does hereby petition for a conditional license as follovs , to-nit: 01 . There shall be no direct public aooeaa between the two bnaiueaaea for customers of either licensed premises . 02 . The applicant premises shall- maintain a separate cash register from that of the premises located at 416 Pacific Coast 8ig6pay, Huntington Beach . 03 . No alcoholic beverages shall be consumed on any property adjacent to the licensed premises under the control of the licensee . 04 . The petitioner shall be responsible for maintaining free of litter the area adjacent to the premises over which be has control . ' 05 . There 'shall be no coin-operated games maintained. upon the premises at any time . This petition for conditional license is made pursuant to the provisions of Sections 23800 through 23805 of the Business and Professions Code and will be carried forward in any transfer at the apl?liouot premises . Petitioner agrees to retain a copy of this petition on the premises at all times and will be prepared to produce it immediately upon the request of any peace offioer . The petitioner understands that any violation of the foregoing condition shall be grounds for suspension or re-vocation of the � � license . Date : It Appl1ouot/petitiougr Witness : / � _ _ DEPARTA,� J'T OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE COL.,,dOL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA Petition for Conditional License Under Sections 23816,--23817, 23820, 23821, 24070 and 23800-23805 of the Business and Professions Code THE UNDERSIGNED HEREBY APPLIES FOR THE LICENSE DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS: On-Sale General License 1. for Bona Fide Eating Place ORIGINAL OR INTERCOUNTY - (a) Special On-sale General ORIGINAL OR INTERCOUNTY 2 ORIGINAL . Off-Sale General License ORIGINAL OR INTERCOUNTY APPLICANT'S NAME: BAGSTAD, Eldon W. PREMISES ADDRESS: 414 Pacific Coast Hwy. , Huntington Beach, CA 92648 I, In addition to the terms and conditions to which he certified and agreed on Form ABC-213 and which are hereby incorpo- rated by reference as though set forth in full herein, applicant certifies further that: A. He has legal tenancy of the premises for which the application is filed and is entitled_to such legal tenancy for at least two years following the date of issuance of the license. B. The premises for which application is made are not actively licensed with the same type license nor does he hold any interest at these premises in a license of the same type surrendered under the provisions of Rule 65. C. Applicant for an on-sale general license for bona fide public eating place certifies that premises will be a bona fide eating place. D. Applicant for a special on-sale general license certifies that premises will be operated as a club as provided for in Section 23399.2 and 23037. E. Applicant for an off-sale general license certifies that premises will be open to the general public. A. The applicant herein petitions the Department of alcoholic Beverage Control to issue a license conditional upon the following restrictions: A. FOR A PERIOD OF TWO YEARS after the date of original issuance or intercounty transfer: 1. The license shall not be transferable from the licensee to any other person except as provided in Section 24071. and except when the Department determines that the transfer is necessary to prevent undue hardship. 2. No change in location for an original on-sale general or original off-sale general license will be permitted except for causes beyond the control of the applicant and approved by the Director. 3. The licensee shall not. directly or indirectly, enter into any negotiations or agreements respecting the sale or transfer of the license, unless the Department has determined that undue hardship exists beyond the control of the licensee. Economic difficulty shall not be considered a legitimate reason for permitting a change in owuership or location. 4. The controlling interest in the stock ownership of a corporate licensee shall not be, directly or indirectly, sold. transferred, or hypothecated unless the licensee be a corporation the stock of which is listed on a stock exchange in this State or in the City of New York, State of New York, or which is required by law to file periodic reports with the Securities and Exchange Commission. 5. An original on-sale general license or on-sale general license transferred intetcounty shall not be exchanged fora public premises license unless the applicant for the exchange can show that a substantial demand cannot otherwise be satisfied. B. FOR A PERIOD OF FIVE YEARS after original issuance or intetcounty transfer: 1. An original license shall not be transferable for a consideration in excess-or s6.000. 2. A license transferred intercounry cannot be retransferred thereafter for a consideration in excess of a10,000, or s6.000 if the license was originally issued within the past five years. C. The Petition for Conditional License will be retained upon the premises at all times so that it may be produced immediately upon the request of any peace officer. III. The applicant certifies that a violation of any of the foregoing conditions may be grounds for the suspension or revocation of the license. I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed at Santa Ana . California, this eleventh day of January + . 19 90 E?0J, SIGNATUR OF •PPLI 4NT1l1 'Cvs� I�VIOy70 4-rV 4) 3-7� /C,q c/� EC� - r: 1990 /? o • �Lx� /ya _ .. //_, / iOMM G, t7�� ( (plJ �2L� UNITY PLA:`•JN1,\1:' DIVISIOP4 qi v �=-S F6F 1�2_ r1l t— -( Lf- L,)AJT-1 t- -T��65- of 0 A-)T—N L' G�UJC-7-M �K� � �lG/ED , tt�r-vG �v 0 s,,v 04Pn010!Z—( L)I-J ,4-Ll VS G- POO. 9v-r Gc)&"T'1-1--- �}-'�C-�►J �U �I I-l-r� 1�-f'"C�,2r<tJ� `Z� �-,c>SW v`T� �-N� C�ut"3'cZ c�uS fl3r�3a=-` J4"Oe CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL COMMUNICATION HUNTINGTON BEACH To From — CONNIE BROCKWAY, City Clerk WES BANNISTER MICHAEL ADAMS, Director-Community Dev. Councilman Subject Appeal of Planning Commission Actions as to ate July 31, 1990 Special Sign Permit #90-5 and CUP #90-14 I wish to appeal the Planning Commission's denial of July 24, 1990 relative to Special Sign Permit #90-5, Campbell signage, I would like the opportunity to review the request for extenuating circumstances. Also, I would like to appeal the Planning Commission's action of the same date relative to Conditional Use Permit #90-14 (Bagstad), I feel it is necessary for a further review of the reasons of expansion by the applicant. WB:bb cc: City Administrator :t f •.., gym � C_jD j rn CD r i M m LCJ T, O Huntington Beach Planning Commission P.O. BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 July 26, 1990 Eldon W. Bagstad 470 Pacific Coast Highway Huntington Beach, CA 92648 SUBJECT: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-14 REOUEST: Permit expansion of existing liquor store at 470 Pacific Coast Hwy. into adjacent unit at 414 Pacific Coast Hwy. LOCATION: 414 Pacific Coast Hwy. DATE OF APPROVAL: July 24 , 1990 FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL : 1 . The expansion of alcohol sales for off-site consumption will not be detrimental to the general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity or property and improvements in the vicinity of such use or building since the use is consistent with the mixed use zoning designation and the past uses of the site. 2 . The granting of Conditional Use Permit No . 90-14 for alcohol sales for off-site consumption will not adversely affect the General Plan of the City of Huntington Beach. 3 . The proposal is consistent with the goals and objectives of the City' s General Plan and Land Use Map . The market/liquor store is a permitted use within the Mixed Use designation of the Land Use Element of the .General Plan. CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT'-,.vO. 90-14 Page Two CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL: 1 . A revised floor plan shall be submitted to the Department of Community Development depicting one integrated liquor store to prevent suites from being subdivided. 2 . The development shall comply with all applicable provisions of the Ordinance Code, Building Division, and Fire Department . 3 . All alcohol beverage control requirements shall be met prior to alcohol sales . 4 . All proposed signage and- exterior modifications shall be reviewed and approved by the Design Review Board. 5 . The Planning Commission reserves the right to revoke Conditional Use Permit No . 90-14 if any violation of these conditions or the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code occurs . I hereby certify that Conditional Use Permit No . 90-14 was approved by the Planning Commission of the City of Huntington Beach on July 24 , 1990, upon .the foregoing findings and conditions . This approval represents conceptual approval only; detailed plans must be submitted for review and the aforementioned conditions completed prior to final approval . Sincerely, Mike Adams , Secretary Planning Commission by: Ho rd Zelefsky P1 nning Director HZ : jr (6634d-6 , 7) Oi iiuritington beach department of community development x7%.. 5TA f f REPORT TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: JULY 24 , 1990 SUBJECT: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-14 APPLICANT: Eldon W. Bagstad DATE ACCEPTED: 470 Pacific Coast Highway April 20, 1990 Hunt . Beach, CA 92648 PROPERTY Eldon W. Bagstad MANDATORY PROCESSING DATE: OWNER: 470 Pacific Coast Highway Waived by applicant Hunt . Beach, CA 92648 REQUEST: Permit expansion of ZONE: Downtown Specific existing liquor store at Plan 470 Pacific Coast Hwy. into adjacent unit at GENERAL PLAN: Visitor 414 Pacific Coast Hwy. Serving Commercial LOCATION: 414 Pacific Coast Hwy. EXISTING USE: Retail Outlet (Surf Shop) ACREAGE: 5, 524 sq. ft . ( . 13 acre) 1 . 0 SUGGESTED ACTION: Approve Conditional Use Permit No. 90714 with findings and conditions of approval . 2 . 0 GENERAL INFORMATION: Conditional Use Permit No . 90-14 is a request for an expansion of an existing market/liquor store in District 3 of the Downtown Specific Plan. Liquor stores are a permitted use subject to the approval of a conditional use permit pursuant to Section 4 . 5 . 01(b)L of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code (Downtown Specific Plan) . A-FM-23C 3 . 0 SURROUNDING LAND USE, ZONING AND GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATIONS: Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Visitor Serving Commercial ZONE: Downtown Specific Plan - District 3 LAND USE: Retail/Office North of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Visitor Serving Commercial ZONE: Downtown Specific Plan - District 3 LAND USE: Public Parking East of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Visitor Serving Commercial ZONE: Downtown Specific Plan - District 3 LAND USE: Retail South of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Visitor Serving Commercial ZONE: Downtown Specific Plan - District 3 LAND USE: Retail West of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: . Recreation ZONE: Downtown Specific Plan - District 10 LAND USE: Public Beach 4 . 0 ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: The proposed project is categorically exempt pursuant to Class 1, Section 15301 of the California Environmental Quality Act . 5 . 0 COASTAL STATUS: Not applicable 6 . 0 REDEVELOPMENT STATUS: The subject site is within the Downtown Redevelopment Project Area . The site and the surrounding lots in this block have been the subject of development proposals and negotiations between the Redevelopment Agency and the applicant, as well as other development proponents . The Redevelopment Agency indicates it is currently negotiating for development of the block. Should negotiations be successfully concluded, development might occur as soon as next year . It is the applicant ' s opinion and staff ' s conclusion that approval of Conditional Use Permit No . 90-14 will not preclude the future redevelopment of this block. Staff Report - 7/24/90 -2- (6347d) 7 . 0 SPECIFIC PLAN: Conditional Use Permit No . 90-14 has been reviewed for conformance to applicable provisions of the Downtown Specific Plan. 8 . 0 SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE: Not applicable 9 . 0 ISSUES AND ANALYSIS: The applicant is requesting to expand his existing market/liquor store (El Don Liquor) located at 470 Pacific Coast Highway into the adjacent retail space located at 414 Pacific Coast Highway (currently occupied by a surfboard shop) . The expansion would increase the square footage of the market/liquor store from 1,422 square feet to 2, 844 square feet . The E1 Don Liquor building is a two story structure of approximately 5, 700 square feet . The first level is devoted to retail uses with the second level containing rental units . Total site area is approximately 5, 500 square feet with parking accessed through the alley to the rear . A total of five parking spaces are available. Pursuant to Section 4 . 2 . 01(d) of the Downtown Specific Plan a legal non-conforming use or structure is exempt from meeting current code requirements if "any building alteration, rehabilitation or facade improvement . .does not exceed ten (10) per cent expansion of existing floor area; does not increase the height; or result in an increase in permitted density" . The proposed expansion of the market/liquor store into the current surfboard outlet has been interpreted as a continuation of a retail use activity that has similar parking requirements . Therefore, no additional parking or in-lieu parking fees are required. The applicant has owned the property and operated the existing market/liquor store for the past seventeen (17) years . The .Alcoholic Beverage Control Office has no record of offenses . The Police Department has indicated that liquor related offenses in the beach area have shown an increase in the last two years; however, they have no specific concern with this applicant . 10 . 0 RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission approve Conditional Use Permit No . 90-14 with the following findings and conditions of approval . FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL: 1. The expansion of alcohol sales for off-site consumption will not be detrimental to the general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity or property and improvements in the vicinity of such use or building since the use is consistent with the mixed use -zoning designation and the past uses of the site. 2 . The granting of Conditional Use Permit No . 90-14 for alcohol sales for off-site consumption will not adversely affect the General Plan of the City of Huntington Beach. Staff Report - 7/24/90 -3- (6347d) 3 . The proposal is consistent with the goals and objectives of the City' s General Plan and Land Use Map. The market/liquor store is a permitted use within the Mixed Use designation of the Land Use Element of the General Plan. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL: 1 . The site plan, floor plans, and elevations received and dated July 9 , 1990 shall be the conceptually approved layout . 2 . The development shall comply with all applicable provisions of the Ordinance Code, Building Division, and Fire Department . 3 . All alcohol beverage control requirements shall be met prior to alcohol sales . 4 . All proposed signage and exterior modifications shall be reviewed and approved by the Design Review Board. 5 . The Planning Commission reserves the right to revoke Conditional Use Permit No . 90-14 if any violation of these conditions or the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code occurs . 11 . 0 ALTERNATIVE ACTION: The Planning Commission may deny Conditional Use Permit No . 90-14 with findings . ATTACHMENTS: 1 . Area map 2 . Letter from Keith Bohr dated July 17, 1990 3 . Site Plan/Floor Plan HS:PD: kjl Staff Report - 7/24/90 -4- (�6347d) 4 N �,-PECAN— i (n :..t,'lwi�,j,:l F9 1<T �•�r r� 2y�.asP J � 1 I ,�''r7;.-' ',41. �< C.o 1• $gyp �. �— DI a ' I k, 'i "•i' - yo c is �YTo14 o SAF —0 -200 O/ST9C DO W TOWN c T. ti ° / */o p�4, p oIDIST ICT � o poi p/S C/Fia Mo i Tp/oTky� "A T / 1 . 7 I i i I CUP90- 14 li HUNTINGTON BEACH II HUNTINGTON BEACH PLANNING DIVISION I I NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING APPEAL - CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-14 (Appeal of Planning Commission' s approval of the expansion of an existing liquor store into an existing adjacent facility) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE/TIME: Monday, November 5, 1990 , 7 : 00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Conditional Use Permit No . 90-14 APPLICANT: Eldon "W. Bagstad APPELLANT: Councilman Wes Bannister LOCATION: 414 Pacific Coast Highway ZONE: Downtown Specific Plan - District 3 REQUEST: To permit the expansion of an existing liquor store located at 470 Pacific Coast Highway into the adjacent unit at 414 Pacific Coast Highway. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15301, Class 1, of the California Environmental Quality Act . COASTAL STATUS: Exempt from the provisions of Article 989 pursuant to Section 989 . 5 .3 . 1 ON FILE: A copy 'of the proposed request is on file in the Community Development Department, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions please call Hal Simmons, Senior Planner, at 536-5271.. Connie Brockway City Clerk (7490d) • / 1 �4 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL COMMUNICATION HUNTINGTON BEACH To From - CONNIE BROCKWAY, City Clerk WES BANNISTER MICHAEL ADAMS, Director-Community Dev. Councilman Subject Appeal of Planning Commission Actions as to ate July 31, 1990 Special Sign Permit #90-5 and CUP #90-14 I wish to appeal the Planning Commission's denial of July 24, 1990 relative to Special Sign Permit #90-5, Campbell signage, I would like the opportunity to review the request for extenuating circumstances. Also, I would like to appeal the Planning Commission's action of the same date relative to ---� Conditional Use Permit #90-14 (Bagstad), I feel it is necessary for a further review of the reasons of expansion by the applicant. WB:bb cc: City Administrator :r :r m C..D <:�m p 'm T•• :7 r' C.D =n WV u 7�dgrvld 3-7 / ,(ZR � 1114C RECEI Oc>Cj Int(n) Sf AUG 1990 DEPARd �- 7 6 S`O COMMUNITY T MENT Or DEV[ LO?p,,,6:'JT PLANNING DIVISION -� v"JGfL !,_9DUZ Of o /0-17� v 1 /�i.�,v c►�l �` �fi�s rr�o,c�%Tt� d S�`rr� rn Bc7'L �" d►J /� y (-,o9AJ,n,(Z`C C�,'J !JS G- ��,-n r i d 0. 9v Can)S r D A-7�5 W O v L1 0 7"D b e, la�6 L&- 7� ,F�-��-nJ rf� '�N-� ��J f� 7b �vSc.J b`-rz.. �{-.>J� C�ut3•c�cyus �av rzs L) hz NOTICE OF APPEAL K TO: DATE... 1 ' REGARDING: f ,.,J �,�J /,( J� �Q _ /X Set for Public Hearing Kopy of Appeal Letter attached. LEGAL NOTICE AND A. P. MAILING LIST MUST BE RECEIVED IN THE CITY CLERK' S OFFICE 15 DAYS PRIOR TO THE PUBLIC HEARING. DATE Connie Brockway City Clerk - - . - _ I }C 4 y 2 X Y - - y - - - zl t J S Y 'Y, - f i S S S '..: .t C I £ - - - 1 P S al "::. L - - .:♦ - - ..- - - .-1..- - t 4.. .i - .. ._ a -- ::'- ;� —' x. i- -. .. .. -'- - + 3 G - • S. l - _. Y.)rJ - Y r3 - S '�--J ^f ?i--' .l�' Y'T I: M ff� .Y - - 5 zr W. r r. . - . :. _ c -- - f -i- L� t I S G ....,..;f. - - -,-;-.. :.s«. Y _ 3� r 1 - -:.-.- '..-. 1. ..... -. - .. -.. �. :._., -. ..-.-. . - .--. ..... ..- .,- -. _. .....: - _. , -.. _ .. _. - -- -.- -.i - - l �' .. - '.I.I.-.I.-..�. . .. - .. -. .. _ - . .. .. - :. - ,- - _ .... ...- ...- - f ' ... .- .. ..-. - -. .-,;— f .: Y y- . -. .. ..-'.. ... - .. .' .. - - ... ... - - ) .: .. .. ..-. - _ 1.-. --. - _ _ - . - :: - - . - - - - Legal Notice y City of Huntington Beach _ /';" 66"t_\ _ --- _ -_- Office of the City Clerk , l, F.\ __. I. 3 I.0iAm .InI I. 190 �' ; . P. 0. Box , R %E.. .. _ - CA R c' 11:_7 - ii Huntington Beach, s.-4*a:,,. _ "t "`' E' `` - ' S ; F. j Yfs !5 _ A(( �.1 . .... --------- --,. ._..---__1-------------- - + 1 . �.._E. __,; : .. - .t 0?�.....,° �?.... 'I _ Ch`):p# _ i 1ZE=WO1 :J I:_YNOIV 2,, 4 I �""" 5"I 8 QJ'. ::A 1\1 A'V f 'i t'`I '. , + t�}1 "' P t'? t1UN;y'i NGl ON 13[_AC11 t;A <,) G/I'`3 lit�.t i v' .' E.� ° i/ 7l`Y(� ' /1 f - 1 ;: Lt . �(� f!! V 'i i✓L!1� O0 Q.'a. FIRST CLASS MAIL � �� ,__ I � 1�1 T :, 1111NIINCION KA04 ii 1 t 7 1 1 :. 1ltltt„I,It11:7,jl,ill,lltl:i!i11,7,7117J11 Jttl I -. _.. N . .:: - :r .... f s . ..: ;r. .._.... _. .....,. ... ... ., .. ... .... .r... r. Ic rnS �. t..... .-,..... ..-.. - .. . .. t _a. .., .. ... .. ,e.!.. /IF. -_ .,,..v.... ...,,. ...... ..>.. .a .. . c... ...., .. :., ... .: 't F :S ... „. :. ' i';. f .. ':: - - 1 n1 77 ... ..._ t..:.._ .. a- .,. .. l ..l!Zi ... _.. _ t. t Y. x _;,. .. .. '......;:. 4 j 1. ..f . . - .. ... ..:.:: :.. ,. . .. ... .v.>.. ..: - .:::.... .. .-:: Lr kt1� :.... .. ... .. ., .. �''.. :. .. j'' .: .. ::. :�. d . .: .. ..... ..... .., . ... _ r .. _ ... .. ... .... .. .. , .. .. . ..... , ... ., .. .. '. . .-. I. ,;. 12 r ...._.._.'.r'-. . ..u:.,,.. 1. .: .. , .. ... .. ... ,: ....... .. .. I. .. v _ I. ........,.i. i,t: - - .,.r�:t::'... ..,,. I e :.. .. .: -: .'. ti f.. M1 1 yJ n t" Y .. :' r ,'�' L 1 {' { r } {,S Y '',, k 7 ;'. ` e .v., .. _ ..,, .... II t :', 1 .: .. :.. .r,r.. �:'.. ... '.' ._ r t i. .. .', .. .. .. ... ..,. .. .. . .... ,.,..r. _ ... .. ... .,. . .. ... - 5 \. . t t ,,..:., ::. ... . . ,:: ... :. 7 i :. `.:' ..5 _ . n.:: .. `��y .......... : V .,. ,.L '•.ir...• .,,. .. ,. . ." .... .. - :.,-. .. a.. .. ... r ur ,,fi .. . .. .. .. .. .. .. \`v : .. .. \ .... .:. .. ., :. { — ''r.. 1 .t .,. Y ^ -.-t...... .. .: .,_ -. . . :.. .. - _....—. • :.. Y. L F e al Notice 4 t City of Huntington Beach I ., .... �',6tot 1. — r t r Office of the City Clerk ,l Z i •j i 7 — . - .. , , � P O Box 190 i t.i 1 i<`f S ) '` :I1 i H t1 g n Beach CA 92648 i un s ..� . 'n t0 '� " i C '"'`` i a , t r .. If I.:;" y t 024-153-07 �/� Gary Mulligan D Man treet ,. &=; 10, "�1 .' Huntington Beams' ct3 G,.T y";v 027- r u. s4-. . -:- ,�,_ �� - wo - .., - - -..'!..- Cis y, .._w�•-+r .:r YL .+ti T ... 1` - ��:�#�i:. P-=:"Y -5...:.f.-11 :I^�'•:,:':�I4: J J�ti S � .... - 1 ' , 1 al A 5 j C Yk J- i i L l 1 < .-. .__--+-1 a,.-_ems-• v Y Legal Notice City of Huntington Beach UN Tom, Office of the City Clerk {_ CA 92648 ; ;:,T �� Huntington Beach, i to •' '' fly 110 f)2 s ; , . .. • .si RESORTS ;'11ASEX0 CAI._ - HUN T 11V( 1 ON 13F=ACH CA 9264; ►' FIRST CLASS MAIL HUN I INCTON!f ACH - (• I !• 1 I I �- Legal Notice City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P. O. Box 190 �' Huntington Beach,CA 92648 14 N., TILL' FRANK A t_F O Iu S O l�J 119 MAIN S1 � IIUNT I IuG V :::ACH CA 9264.F3 FIRST CLASS MAIL HLINIIN.rI1N PACH ,i NOTICE TO: THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT FROM: THE OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK THE AP LISTS FROM THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT FOR NOTIFICATION MAILINGS BY THE CITY CLERK MUST BE THE LATEST'AVAILABLE IN ACCORDANCE WITH DIVISION THBOC REOUIREWNTS. *** ***PL.EASE REMEMBER THAT THE LIST MAY HAVE CHANGED SINCE THE MAILING FOR THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING WAS SENT. DATE- TI5flATURE VERIFYING ADEQUACY OF LIST FROM LAST 'ASSESSOR'S ROLLS IN PLANNING DEPT. 5/90 DATE 1O. 2 SIPNATURE VERIFYING LIST HAS BEEN CHECKED WITH PLANNING DEPARTMENT'S 8/13/90 PARCEL MAPS 3� NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING APPEAL - CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-14 (Appeal of Planning Commission' s approval of the expansion of an existing liquor store into an existing adjacent facility) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE/TIME: Monday, November 5, 1990, 7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Conditional Use Permit No. 90-14 APPLICANT: Eldon W. Bagstad APPELLANT: Councilman Wes Bannister LOCATION: 414 Pacific Coast Highway ZONE: Downtown Specific Plan - District 3 REOUEST: To permit the expansion of an existing liquor store located at 470 Pacific Coast Highway into the adjacent unit at 414 Pacific Coast Highway. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15301, Class 1, of the California Environmental Quality Act. COASTAL STATUS: Exempt from the provisions of Article 989 pursuant to Section 989 . 5 .3 . 1 ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Community Development Department, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions please call Hal Simmons, Senior Planner, at 536-5271. Connie Brockway City Clerk (7490d) / o5 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING APPEAL - CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 90-14 (Appeal of Planning Commission' s approval of the expansion of an existing liquor store into an existing adjacent facility) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE/TIME: Monday, November 5, 1990, 7 : 00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Conditional Use Permit No. 90-14 APPLICANT: Eldon W. Bagstad APPELLANT: Councilman Wes Bannister LOCATION: 414 Pacific Coast Highway ZONE: Downtown Specific Plan - District 3 REQUEST: To permit the expansion of an existing liquor store located at 470 Pacific Coast Highway into the adjacent unit at 414 Pacific Coast Highway. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15301, Class 1, of the California Environmental Quality Act . COASTAL STATUS: Exempt from- the provisions of Article 989 pursuant to Section 989 . 5 .3 . 1 ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Community Development Department, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public . ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions please call Hal Simmons, Senior Planner, at 536-5271. Connie Brockway City Clerk (7490d) Prepared far-: j 024- 152-"0-1 :ltec nested b 024.... 1�,�._ 0? y : DI:-V CX ENERGY SL,ir�) , 7 V DI::V CX E:NE:IIGY Rep: 519 WAL_NL1T AV 3` b41 - S I TUS PI-ENDING - ir ****************** HUN r I NG1-ON 131:ACH CA 92648 NlJhll I NG1 Gv 13EACIi CA 92648 r � 024-152==03 024--152.--04 024 152--05 COAST OI L CX SOUTH AGI:N RE:DEVE:I.OP ME:NT - 13E:ACH R HUN1- I NGTON S t-rIJS PENDI NG S I TUS PE:NDI NG 24 501 WALNUT AV HUNT I NGTON BEACH CA 92648 HUNT I NGTON 131::ACH CA 92.648 HUN'I- I NGTON 13EACH CA 92648 i � 024-•152--10 024- 152- 1 " r 02�.... -Ic2- 12 _ � FRANK M. CRACCHIOL_0 131."ANCHE: A WOOD BLANCHE` A WOOD 19 712 QU I'E"r BAY L_N ` 2.01 5TH ST 201. 5TH ST -HUNT I NGTON BEACH, CA 92.648 HUN1- I NGTON 13E:ACH, CA 92648 HUNT I NGT-ON 13E:ACH, CA 92.648 '••• Dais,..-::a�;c7rs�x-:;:rs-=;..,�_,.._.,._ 'E 024-152-13 _ 1 024 152 4•, T93E "lOR L_ E:YNON RA. ! 13F:ACH' IIE:DE:VF: HUNTI NGTON ` 518 OCE:AN :AV j F'ME::N.I. AGENCY MUNTI NGTON BEACH CA 92648 j 2000 MAIN ST HUNT I NG"('OIV BEACH, CA 92648 *SEARCH COMPL_E_ I E_ : ' RECORDS READ: 10 RECORDS RETIJRNE:D: 10 '. COPYRIGHT TRW 1989 r Prepared for- : I 024-' 153 01 02-11.... 153-02 t- 1 Reques-ted by : 1 13E:OE:VE:1_OPMENI- AGENCY OF: t RE:DE:VE:I.OPMI:NI" AGE-NCY OF d Ftep : ' C I I"Y OF HUNT I NG*TON BE::ACH CITY OF HUNT I NGTON E3E:ACI-I 20/00 MAIN ST 2000 MAIN ST HUNTINGTON E3E:A Fil.1 N"E I luf.i rUl� f.3EA 024--153-03 ib 024-- 153--04 024-- 153--05 REDEVEt_0PM(:NT AGENCY Of= + lt, JAMES A LANE FtUNAt_U A MASf.: CITY Of: HUNT I NGTON 13EACH 1! 12'7 MAIN ST 123 MAIN ST • 2000 MA'I N ST j HUN"f I NG FUIV BEACH CA 92648 HL11V'I' I NC:TON E3E:ACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEA I 024--153--07 !. 024--153--08 024 ' 153-- 10 - SAV. HUNT I NG"Y0N Gz") sit. AHMAD H A13DE:L_MUT I t CITY OF- HUNT I NGTON 13E:AC 1 117 MAtN S"F- a C 29165`3 %JACK SURF::--N-'SPORT P O E30X 1910 HUNT 1 NGTON 13E:ACH CA 92648 II 1 13 MAIN S'l HIJN'r I NGTN 13CH, CAL_ 92648 hll.Jlu i I NGTON E3E:ACEi C - - - - - - - a, ':re•:l7 J..r i�.r�-� •-4---r�'"sr,,.�7 •,:. ./��c'-!;..+:;t' .:N r�' ..• �1: '', 's',- 3=c� -:it1!, ,J z.,_r� •rJvrol.n, ,�1. ,•9i'ttS.., r� :ve. .�,'?`•'•'.;4f 1 1 J=. / .,. „4 ^,r ri'o. .r•. '> ,r,.:.. ,.ri�' n •t�a sS / `'•^.i• i::^y.1 ,fit'... c, D•. .t. -.:.. 7, ',i .ti: -�. '•.4.. x. "� , ,? t #! Jai..�. tFi: ^ir'•:i`F r;•••- ,t 1'.- 4. i%: i ,�a,�,b'c. •ifi. d:'tti ., ::i#•: '.,r6.s, :'r`.;a 1. t .'},W.:•�:i'� + ,x. Lna{;'.'^cc .b.� �'! a ,A�. :d�?., a•„.ti.�:j"•'t„ es. .� ,.. :�> ..yy .;#•��,hi.wtf myt�:' .:�.. ,3.. t..: n ,.P�:: , {' .� :.i; 1.� :s!... ��• S:,r;r d.l,. ^44t' Srt t,, � r f;!:'�2V, ;'» �.$ ti•2 L:7i %!w, ,n,;,f%..."r` (:_' •':',5..'. 'f i�'-�;' 5 4 is c,+',�•r;Y: : i., !, r.' {i• , ,.) _I,'�i<,r, 'r >? t�,":;n 't .f�`y�v.; s�:'S..,,.;;;is� j.:•. ,t.• 5 ia�, � + ! (. .s=. r. 0 2 4---1153-1 -1 024 5 3--1 2 0 2 4 153 . 13 ELDON w EiAGs-rm) BEACH I? lILJNF I NG'TON AHMAD ABDI: l MLYT I 90-1 CATALINA AVE i 408 OCEAN AV 113 MAIN C-1- SEAL BEACH, CA 90740 I FILIN'TING-l"ON BEACH CA 92648 HUNT" ING-FON BEACH, CA 92648 024 153-14 fi I 024153--15 t 024-153 16 AHMAD NAMED ABDELMLJ'I I I AHMAD FIAMED ABDELMU"I"' I F?E0EVF__-[_OPMENI AGENCY OF 113 MAIN Sl i 113 MAIN ST C11-Y OF: HUN"l- INGTON BEACH HUNT I NG-rON BEACH, CA 92648 j HUN"'I' l NGTON BEACH, CA 92648 2000 MA N ST HUN"l- INGTON BEA LILL 024..- '15 3 9 0 24..- '15 3-1 0 2 4..-'15 3 18 ELEANOR J DF?APER Fl?ANK ALFONSO A F-I M A 1", 11 A IV]E 1) ARDEA-MUTI 121 MAIN ST I 119 MAIN Sl_ %,JACKS SU[?FBOAIlDS HUNT ING-l"N BCH, CAL 92648 I HUNT INGTON BEACH. CA 92648 -1 -13 MAIN S_F HUNT INGTON BEACH, CA 9 024-- 153--20 -+ *SEARCH C 0[A P L F__'T E AHMAD NAMED ABDELMUTt RECORDS READ: 18 %JACKS SURFBOARDS RECORDS RETURNED: 18 13- MA N ST COPYRIGH'I" TRW 1988 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA <J Prepared for- : 024 54 0 024..... 154 02 Wood Requested by : AGEN 1.1 E 1)E V E L 0 13 M I:.--NT L AGEN I4EDf:VEL_0PMF.NT x-o 1 Rep : 126 MAIN ST izij, -122 MAIN S-1- ta,rl HUNT INGTON BEACH CA 9?648 11UN1- ING"I"ON J3f:ACH CA 92,348 0?4 54--0 3 024- 154--04 0 24_ 154--05 -SORTS HASEKO CAL TS flES0141-5 HASEKO CAL R E RESOIl HASEKO CAL. �I, I 4-4-2---M-A+N-S-r' HUNT INGTON BEACH CA 92648 j H U N'T I N GT 0 N 13 1:A C H CA 92648 HUN1- ING"FON BEACH CA 92648 *SEARCH COM ly L 1:T F RECORDS R EAD: 5 CORDS RE:TURNED: COPYRIGHT TRW 1988 A- Prepared for :, 024-- 154-- 12 .1ES01"ll-S HASEKO CAL Requested by : Rep: 102 MAIN S'T HUNTI NG'TON BEACH CA 92648 Ti, ....... ....... *SEARCH COMI>[..E-F'F: : li IIECORDS READ: RE-CORDS O]TURNED: 1 )J COPYRIGHT TRW 1988* 024-- 154--13 Prepared for Requested by : RESORTS HASEKO CAL_ Rep: 300 OCEAN AV HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648 *SEARCH COMPLA:TE RECORDS READ: 1 RECORDS RETURNED: 1 COPYR16HT TRW '1988 Prepared for : Ok4 15016 Requesled by : STATE 01: CAL- IFORNIA DEP Rep: FxlE'AL_ ESTATE D I V 650 HOWE AVE SACRAMEXFO, CA 95825 .......... *SEARCH COMPt-ETE : RECORDS READ: 1 RECORDS RETURNED: -I COPYRIGHT TRW 1988 .... ........ Prepared for- : i 024-150-06 Requested by : BEACH C HUN"I' lNGTON Rep : HUNTI NGTN BCH CAL- 92648 *SEARCH COMPI-ETE : I. RECORDS READ: I RECORDS RE-'TURNED: 1 COPYRIGHT TRW -1988 Prepared for : 024--28114. Requested by : BEACH C HUNTINGTON Rep : crry CL_EF?K 21000 MAIN ST HUNT INGTON REACli, CA 9264 CUP 90-14 ADDRESSES (7536d) 024-152-01 024-154-01 024-154-02 Shirley Worthy Adel Zeidan Blanch Wood 801 - 13th Street 10220 Black River 201 - 5th Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Fountain Valley, CA 92708 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 024-153-07 024-154-03 024-154-05 Gary Mulligan Resorts Haseko Cal Resorts Haseko Cal 211 Main Street 222 - 5th Street 305 Walnut Avenue Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 024-154-04 Resorts Haseko Cal 222 - 5th Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Uf 40� - EIZ3 90 pi,,ners��P 12-I11 C, �'le j h C014v,. ev i Y , t l , t J 3 Legal Notice — City of Huntington Beach ) Office of the City Clerk P. O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 •Y �•\•) r v ._.!ti t�' w �''ti.tit;,=� ,% -• ,) _ _ 0 2'1 5 ; f�FNI:? 1 1\1G HUN F I NG 1-0N 131.-ACH CA 7)l - FIRST CLASS MAIL Fit IN nN(.rf)N of ACH --" Legal Notice City of Huntington Beach "- Office of the City Clerk P. O. Box 190 . . . !! Huntington Beach, CA 9264E i, _ G J(. o m l°�r soF o 0 2 ` 1)c_v Cx 1:::lu1:.11CY / S I ,.1.,U S P I::N I:) 11\1 G HUNIT I NG10N 13E:ACH CA 12648 FIRST HflnI IN5fACM CLASS MAIL •. - y-.:••'• -i_ -'viva-.ua�u. _a:d.uu4�Gi..'4m+..Ia�..J r-�.•._Y .�+..a�`_._._-1.�..r.'-"4iis+� is i r '1. •j: i 'i Legal Notice JCity of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P. O. BOX 190 r.,: a..._._.,. \HG I UAV Huntington Beach,CA 92648 P R S O IX -C _. ; n 0211..... "152'.... ,. f s�Jf N, MAS1- 0 1 1_ CX SOUTH C S I F U S P F"1<I D 11\1 G " J � F1UN1' 1 NG'T0N 13FACH CA 9264%�e I. FIRST CLASS MAIL HUNIIN(JON MACH _ �� - , i s"'i..t,<` - 'i ��-�rj/` fi �t fn „a 1Jr r'+�, ffrjS t` Y S 3 ( - : r• �-7.- 'Yr r 1:.i t . r b a,. vi. <L .' i 1. - :- .z �, 1 1 - 1 _ _ `s',,4"c o- _ w.a c t rt w.. -$• r 1 rr- i--. _-"r`-^ -{rs al.a 'r' _ J a�,y i"r �Y- tt_.s'a. S r .:�.r..- "'r•'+.z � -t- - - - s Et- r xrl -- „cy'F'N�t 1 Sir�!'-�-E- ' Y _F3f 1 - 4 _..s _ - �c f '4- K�^e.t Ca, , .. .;� :. �:.1^'ti$Y.:.:t-:.c - .rr.__ ' - r - ^t 1.. _ i-� - - t --'r" �.. -:3 x e t*— `4'��+ rx. _ i.},al rr 'i "- x ---,. r c�f C _ s-nt3 Y t i.-5 may{ -Y h -a�.�-. '� 4- ..r•S -R T` 'y" t},�`tV� al.�'`5::..:.::t'�:E_ tl .l T - -- }' i }- 'C �Z� t k'AI K- ,<- - L C�"S'Y74c _ t`T-. - iy+�.Y' id+' ::' '1 r <: -a. -tS- T _,,•-- a 7-••� y'S �' Y r 7 1l L f __1(- �' S se - F' t l,. -M- ...., c1s- - .`r- gr'.. K•-- -] > - - t - e ,.. r , T sic .t i -`uyY s- n - - -♦ _ _ F - m 9• s. r ;:, - s- - F. t � is- - - f� '+r w �_- Y �._ - - - -l.e. r - - - _ ii'" y y ( T J tt ... .--'.ii.•. �. ... r ... . - .. .,-. -.. w r �< - - 1 1 t- �. - .-E"Y - H .. _ .. _ ... „ .- -_ ..... ..... ... ."��. .•... .. - - .. _ C - .-..- - . -. .. _. ...- - --: .:: S .: - - - 1 -mow y f ti ' r = x t ._ - V S� - _ -(- _ r r .. .... - .. C .. - ,r _ _ t. . . :. ,-. - : - - . .. .. .. --. •,. .... . - _ _... . .: . . - _ - .. _ _ .. -_. - _. .. .._. .: .. :- ...- _ S. - .. _ ____ - _ - -.- _ .. - .f r. .. _ .. _ - r a _- ,_.. .r ,.t_.. :. . : - ...: - ¢ :. -.i T - }i r . J x _ - ' ` - -'s _ -s - - - _- r- , a .. _._ :: _ ,. -i _ _ _ _ F _: N fi .- - _ -- } < Legal Notice - City of Huntington Beac -' _ __ x�,'•_,a,° Office of the City Clerk rP t. -,� - P. O.Box 190 �4� "1 __ _-_ Huntington Beach, CA 92648 f w (q _ p - r, ..'F A + 1 ,3 .. %(k-K uJ .F 11 f r. t �. 1 - yip_•'�= 4 1J it 1 r I L-f_`. • T D 0 l . .... -I 5 0-" 'I li s,vE'dDE� 'TA..1.4- ( - CAL_ I F0RN I A 1)EP F�rnl2rdin R E.:A L E ' f A f F. U I V g Time Expired 65() !I. VdF- Ave ��® sncF ..NIF:::hlro, cA �� Ha ---- a. ��i' FIRST CLASS MAtL _- "'�'f IIII 1 11 111 1 1I IIIIIII I V I I I I 11{1111 I I 1111"l1' ""�^�' `' 1. r.... t'<S.r. i t ..'t'yy -ix �.-,�,. -.a .0-�u.�x* �' l" J +._= e 5 rs _ z `' e _ --j;,�•r!5t j ti,aim. - e,. - 9 .- r:,r..- s '.K��a Fy+,e `ems- t ..k 'Y's-•,,..0 y�ywt T t'_@_'' _ - r --e'�-" !. r kr�� a ;: tir �- •�.e •_.t.r,_.`fr,�c-s+ausx, ,` �` tt- K 7 - .- .Y .Act" .. .. ? _-I _ n:..._r a. _t.. _..::.3 _. ... .. _. .- - - y- Y _:, _ :�' ' 1 3 _S.tz £ E x t` - ! _ �. •ti - - .... -K T ...,' .. ....._..._ _.�._.., -v _. - .. .. - z ._... .� ...,-... wc. ..... - r .. .. . -._ -.o -., - .. Jl t __ - 1. { Sri. .t __.i , _ :r s r .-M.I` � -`, i�-.a ry e..: e''-.cr "s' t;"^ a a <s-,-.�� -rc _k ; - , s� - i� -' - 14. a rr .s... :�y s. xcr e tR l�s. t € �tt -f�� S 54c at _.ay�i. �tWl ?Y E r t i fL L ti ri c s 7 . -' - '.<; +- 3 ._ .. _ -. F 4 t E 1 < F ? ._. ..a _5� -- s -._ -.av ...r..._.i....r _ - .. - - -, r . �_ Legal Notice City of Huntington Beach . office of the City Clerk /`'"' o' _ . _ P. 0. Box 190 ' [ ~ ✓' -'- _ __ Huntington Beach,CA 92648 '= ' - - . 't;, qn�x a;: . w .r . --� �..:•. .e \mot-:.-._t G_. . . : . . _1 \ . �� ? 131: ACH R HUNT I NG-1 0hr1 ;'::,.. I t-� °::,, ... t 501 Vd t1 k..NI.J l A V �—._�°r;, `'I .: Fi U IV f f hI C t V 01�1 13 E:A C;Fi C` ztkp,�t�_" `t j / Ri';.`i ��, FIRST CL MAIL Nun IN(.rl IN 81ACN . i r