Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutSign Appeals - Special Sign Permit 87-18 - 18255 Beach Blvd Aufnorued to Pubnsn Ao►snrSer*,ents of all kin.s Onuudinp pubnt nobles by Drctrr of thr Superior Court of Qrangr County, Ge+Aorma, Number A-5214, dated 29 SoC+ember. 1961. rna A.?�LS�, ar•ed 11 June. 19W STATE OF CALIFORNIA County 31 Orange .,ae ho,t. •e..n,.ro�.....� M rw .n.e..w • r w r ao� w11k to pies cbkor"000 I am a Citizen of the United States and a resident of the County aforesaid; 1 am over the age of eighteen years. And not a party to or interested in the below j entitled matter. I am a principal clerk of the Orange ' Coast DAILY PILOT, with which is combined the NEWS-PRESS, a newspaper of general citculabon. printed and published in the City of Costa Mesa. County of Orange, Stale of California, and that a .,,..�.�. Notice of public Hearing i •Maflel[orPUNLIC MAN" • >. ..�' 7f which copy attached hereto is a true and complete NOttCE i-ME11911 copy, was printed and published in the Costa Mesa, is�at &A11� o�w,,�ee Irwr�q ir►1ta f�or+►- Newport Beach, Huntington Beach. Fountain Valley, �a1,Chrrrirrrr:st t11+ mvmv aft Cwft Irvine, the South Coast communities and Laguna ,�;M '�. Beach issues of said newspaper for one t T ) iiwMtln�i+ dbrlyd t+rafow fa rearlre Mr+l consowttve weeks to wit the issue(s) of 04 P! ra rr 10 hl fb ur V.I.ow.0"CrMied OMwr. . tlA . wnr>wl. Nrrn- M + October 20 t98ry pus E T•. ' se �,rwAaq MA Iit;.R RLICrIA�MIpTn�:'•1�C0 198 AFFULAN1:' wlrldlior TI10100111"COC1N�ii4TJ 198 �a�ilrffAr�+lurlt MtJPOSAU A/f1M1'of die dd of a ar lllww�r t98__ r k*s_awv4 o w4tts ^.'`" t98 ,aT�GN INTALj rAK 1 declare, under penalty of perjury, that the ON ITIi.E:A Wat 1114 foregoing is true and correct. ,,,, , corrrr�+r+t1r oowoarr�a IM win,. Executed on October 20 198 asows we WNW I* at Co la Mesa, Califor a. 1 I {i ww»d Nl�84W�o'rw0,. a��, } sorM+finr cr +hw e 1V Signatt,�e Vill City cwt.am milin etreef..sunw4wn�now. OrfNarw,for wrpmNa fM I � �N�11MTMCiTCI�C+AMC�N N "CIt�i.ClerM • _.�c�c?CL,�-.. ►-- p O r ai,ott�ha�e,pr�srroar cerw / OWVf PW 000.r 2D f 1! i PROOF OF PUCLICATtON � .. l e /r r I RECEIVE6 CITY CLERK RUNTINGICH r OF f fN.CALIF. �. OCT 31 1134 Ay '8o Eric Schmitt 5941 Brassie Cir . Huntington Beach, Ca. 92649 October 28, 1988 To the Huntington Beach City Council , In regard to the appeal for a special Sian permit (#!r 88--4) at 16471 Springdale, as; a concerned resident, I hope the Council will aeny the ?P.pe81 . The intersection at Springdale and Heil is very busy and is used by many Children from the St: Bonaventure school and local resident 's children, such as ours, to go to and from the park on that corner. The requested monument sign would greatly reduce visibility of drivers and pedestrians, is dangerous, and should not be allowed. Sincerely, �Qa Q IV1 ` 1 1 f REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION Date NovembeE_ 7",1 988 Submitted to: Honorable Mayor and City Council � Submitted by: Paul Cook, City Administrator Lam-Prepared by: Mike C. Adams, Acting Director, Community Development0# 1nA � rV Subject: APPEAL TO PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 88-4 Consistent with Council Policy? N1 Yes [ J New Policy or Exception Statement of lout, Recommendation,Analysis, Funding Source,Alternative Actions,Attachments: STAM2M QF I S SUE; Special Sign Parmit No.. 88-4 is a request by MCS Architectural Signs (applicant's representative) to permit a freestanding, multi-tenant monument sign at an existing retail center, in addition to existing wall signs. The Planning Commission denied the request on September 7, 1988. Windsor Financial Corporation, the owner of the center, subsequently appealed the decision based on their contention that the existing signage is not readily visible to motorists. $Ef.OM!►lIErIDATI011; t Planning CQmmigsion Actinn and Recommendation on Septgfter 7._ 198Q: ON MOTION BY BOURGUIGNON AND SECOND BY SLATES, Tt::" :'".ANNING } COMMISSION CONSIDERED APPROVAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PEII71T NO. 88-4, BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: Bourguignon, Slates, Silva NOES: Livengood, Ortega, Higgins ABSENT: Leipzig ABSTAIN: None ON MOTION BY LIVENGOOD AND SECOND BY HIGGINS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION DENIED SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 88-4 WITH FINDINGS, BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: Livengood, Higgins, Ortega, Silva NOES: Slates, Hourguignon I ABSENT: Leipzig J ABSTAIN: None r Ptd'M I ow rf EIND1096 FOR DENIAL: 1. Granting Special Sign Permit No. 88-4 for a monument sign with the multi-tenant copy in addition to existing tenant wall signs would constitute a special privilege inconsistent with limitations upon properties in the vicinity. 2. Exceptional circumstances do not apply that deprive the subject property of privileges enjoyed by o:her properties in the same zone claasifications. 3. The location and site layout plus the size of the existing building wall signage provide clear visibility of the tenant copy from public streets. The site is in a predominately r residential neighborhood and the use is neighborhood coma.arcial. Staff Recommendation Deny thu appeal and uphold the Planning Commission's denial of Special sign Permit No. 88-41 based on the above findings. +1141UY=: Applicant: MCS Architectural signs Appellant: Windsor Financial Corporation Location: 16471 Springdale Street The subject shopping Center is located on the northwest corner of Heil Avenue and Springdale Street, and consists of one building with seven retail suites. The other corners of the intersection contain single family residential to the southwest, a neighborhood park to the southeast, and a Church and school to the northeast. The existing wall signage at the center is permitted by Planned Sign Program No. 88-3, which allows each tenant one internally illuminated can sign, the area of which must comply with §9160.5 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. Special Sign Permit No. 88-4 is a request to permit two sign variances: 1) to allow a 35 square I feet, 7-foot high monument sign (including a 2-font base) , and 2) to allow the monument sign to include tenant copy for sir of the seven tenants plus center identification, in lieu of center identification only. A comparison of this roquest to §9610.5(B) of the Ordinance Code is provided in the following matrix: ;section Issue Permitted Proposed i 9610.5 0) Freestanding If wall signs, no Existing wall signs Monument Sign monument sign for for each tenant site with less than plus new monument a 400 ft. frontage. sign 7 ft. high, If no wall signs, area of 35 sq.ft. one monument sign 7 ft. high, max. 30 sq.ft. permitted RCA -- 11/7/88 -2- (1389d) Geetion IsSue F rg_mitted Proposed 9610.5(B) Sign Copy Limitod to center Conter identifi- or maJor tenant cation plus six identification tenants only. The appellant contends that the proposed monument sign with multi-tenant copy is necessary because the building is set back 100 i feet from the street. However, staff feels that with the existing 20 inch letters above each retail suite entrance, the tenant signage is very visible. The center is considered to be neighborhood commercial due to its size and location, and serves the surrounding neighborhoods. Most residents in the vicinity are aware that the center exists. Staff feels that a freestanding tenant sign would duplicate the existing signs permitted under Planned Sign Program No. 88-3. EBVIRDII�TAL STA7 : The proposal is exempt 515301, Class 1, from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act. Not applicable. A=UT E ACTION: As an alternative, the City Council may consider the following: 1) Approve a modification of the applicant's request to include a 7-foot high monument sign with an area of 25 square feet, located in the landscape planter and identifying only the center identification (no multi-tenant panels) and address, with findings and conditions of appr val (Attachment No. 5) ; 0 2) Approve the applicant's request to include a 7-foot high min ent sign with an area of 35. square feet, located in the landscape planter and identifying the center identification plus tenant panels, with findings and conditions of approval (Attachment No. 6) . ATTACHMENTS I. Area Map 2. Letter of Appeal dated September 13, 1988 3. Staff Report dated September 7, 1988 4 . Draft Planning Commission Minutes dated September 7, 1988 5. Findings and Conditions of Approval for Alternative Actions No. 1 6. Findings and Conditions of Approval for Alternative Actions No. 2 MA:LP:gbm RCA - 11/7/88 -3- (1389d) t t --•-- j m n� •. � J E 1 1 R1 sw�'w`w:—tti.Ny _���s___ .nra1 �._— C4Ri.Vw_�_' o. R • �� 1 RI � • �m � Ri R1 A ( ��J RI FI fll r R{ 1 RI � � u... co +1—J AI Rl .All o RI •• "• CF-E CF-Ei �- - - -tw,r- ., R, Rl , r.•u..�.a.u...l } n Rt � � l y1 .»•w"•»s f At R1 RI • a RI RI RI j R� it RI RI i RI s RI • Rt rw I R1 R Rt RI RI c. w .. • 1 b At RI • • Rl `1{ • RI RI R) L 1� k....o Jr ` �. :ra.,.. 1 ti °. r f ar t.w.rt { S RI R! RI RI ity At —� AI F PA �� RI -A RI R2 °R2 1 RI' P2 R=1 pt RI Ri P.3 c. =`RI Rl'FP2 R 1 ¢ A, t R t RI-FP2 t.- . .•�-t RI A ROS • 4 'Y CF-E At Ri --1�'..`-�j CF-R A RI RIFP2 i fittv.s..aw►wt.t •tu�ru: in _ tll r �tr .Rl fl! c AI-M t RI • AI At R{ RI At 1, � ... r R KIM R t � _�:IRelz A I t R I • Rj R06'01 r. RI .iw.i�:. r„ t r�+et�."o: i ' --...... . --- ► / = R!-FP2 � fll Rt Rl RI fll Rt I •►�••:i a; i.t ctrfir'" — • R IfPZ_ I R 1 At At RI win �- _ T.c I-i 4._. - � ... m 55� q- ! � WwTwr-r "UZI j H(1NTWGTON REACH PLANNING DIVISION i1 �GJ ism RECEIVED CITY CLERK Windsor Bnencial Corporation city of HUKTINGTr.q =F.t H,CALIF. September 13 , 1988 SEP 14 4 25 Pit '08 Cl.ty of Muntin9ton ©each 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Attne City Clark M Special Sign Parmit #88-4 16471 Springdale, Huntington Beach, CA Gentlemene On I;epLember 7, 1988, the Planning Staff of th" City of Funt:ington Beach denied our request for a variance of the monument sign at the above shopping cantor. We had requested a 50 square font sign showing tonant identification Copy, AS wall as center .identification. 'Phis request was supported by the fact that an impairment of visibility in created by surrounding buildings, the setbe+ck of the building itself , and building restrictions imprsed by the City of Huntington Beach. Denial of variance was based upon the assumption that the najority of consumer purchasing is done uy the surrounding neighborhood, and therefor© a means of identifying the individual store would be unnecessary. Howeveor, we presented visual documentation to verify that mottriots, who in fact conprise the M&Ijority of all small retail center purchasing, would be unable to identify any store while in tra!fie, except to slow down, creating a traffic hazard. As you know, the success of our tenants aB merchants depends upon their visibility to the publics and the tenants ' success, in turn, assures revenue success for the City of Huntington 6aach. in full consideration of tho above Pacts, and with all due J:espect to the Planning Staff of the City of Huntington Beach, Windsor Financial Corporation raquoats an appeal to the City Council on this issues, in the Moat expedient tiMa schadula ava_ ,,.ule. Sincerely, I` Craig Hoyt P=olect Manager CH/dd 1625S %tntura DouleVard, Suite 615, Encino, Califomia 91436 1818) mi-Ass; rahia.ton%:ncnn :-% t � STAf f huntington beach department of community development AEPORTT ._.. TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: September 7, 1988 SUBJECT: SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 88-4 APPLICANT: MCS Architectural Signs PATE ACCEPTED: 11691 Jewel, Suite A August 12, 1988 Garden Grove, CA 92640 MANDATORY PROCESSIN.Q DATE: 9L4tER: Windsor Financial Corp. October 12, 1988 16255 Ventura Blvd. Suite 615 Z9Sii: C2-FP2 (General Encino, CA 91436 Commercial-Floodplain 2) REQUEST: To permit a multi-tenant GENERAL PLAN: General monument sign. Commercial LOCATION; 16471 Springdale (northwest EX�IN_USE: Neighborhood corner Sprindale and Heil) Commercial Center 1 .9 SUGGESTED AC,,j�N; Deny Special Sign Permit No. 88-4 with findings. 2_-0 __GENERAL INFORMATION: Special Sign Permit No. 88-4 proposes two sign variances: (1) to permit a monument sign (7 feet high, with an area of 35 square feet) in addition to existing wall signage; and (2) allovy the monument sign, in addition to the center identification, to contain tenant copy identifying six of the seven tenants in the center. 3,0 SURROUNDING LAND LIST_ ZONING AND GENERAL. PLAN DESIGNATIONS: North..pf Subigct er ty: GENERAL ERA PLAN DESIGNATION. Low Density Residential 1 ) ZONE: R1-FP2 (Low Density Residential-Floodplain District 2) } LAND USE: Single Family Residential it i i A•PM-130 East of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Low Density Residential ZONE: R1 (Low Density Residential) LAND USE: Private School (St. Bor•aventure) West of SubjeCt Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: General Commercial ZONE: OP-FP2 (Office Professional-Floodplain District 2) LAND USE: Small office complex South gE Uhiggt property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Low Density Residential ZONE: R1--FP2 (Low Density Residential-- Floodplain District 2) and CF-R (Community Facilities-Recreation) LAND USE: Single Family Residential and Neighborhood Park 4 .0 EMMIROx NNTAL STATUB: The proposed project is exempt Class 1 Section 15301 from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act. 5,,,S —fMASTAL STATUS: Not applicable. 6.0 REDE!JELOPMENT ,STATUS: Not applicable. 7.0 SPECIFIC PLAN: Not applicable. 8.0 5118DLVI$ION COMMITTEE: Not applicable. 9.0 I, SUS ES AND ANALYSIS*- The subject site is located on the northwest corner of Neil and Springdale. The southwest corner of the intersection contains a j block wall and trees screening single family homes. The northeast corner contains landscaping and a fence screening a private school and the southeast corner contains a neighborhood park. The subject' center consists of one building containing seven retail suites each with existing wall signage permitted by Planned Sign Program No. ! 88--3 . The wall signs are 70 percent of each leasehold width in length (front of retail suite above door) and consist of 20 inch high letters. j Special Sign Permit No. 88-4 proposes to sign variances: (1) to permit a 7 foot high (including a 2 foot base) monument sign with an area of 35 square feet to be located in a landscape planter; and (2) allow the monument sign to include, in addition to the name of the center, tenant copy for six of the seven tenants in the center. A comparison of this request to Section 9610.5(B) of the Ordinance Code, is provided in the following matrix: Staff Report - 9/7/88 -2- (1189d) -AT"-AC 1A M e9T 3. ..3:.•lam iI Section ism permitted 1'S.Qg48 9610.5(R) Freestanding If wall signs, Monument Sign 7 ft. Monument Sign no monument sign high, area of 35 for site with less sq. ft. than a 400 it. frontage. If no wall signs, one monument sign 7 ft. high, max. 30 sq. ft. i permitted. Sign Copy Limited to center Center identifi- or major tenant cation and six identification tenants only. The applicant contends that the monument sign with multi-tenant copy in the landscape planter, within 12 feet of the property line, is necessary because the building is set back 100 feet from the street. With 20 inch letters above each retail suite entrance the tenant signage is very visible. With the exception of traffic traveling southbound on Springdale, approaching the center from the other three directions gives the motorist enough time to read the signage before entering the intersection. The center is considered neighborhood commercial because of its size and location. It serves the surrounding neighborhoods; most people in the vicinity are aware the center exists. The center's location and fact that the center's wall signs are highly visible to passing motorists formulates the conclusion that a freestanding sign would add duplication Lo the center's planned sign program. 10.0 RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission deny Special Sign Permit No. 88-4 with the following findings: FINDINGS FOR DENIAL: 1. Granting Special Sign Permit No. 88-4 for a monument sign with multi-tenant copy in addition to existing tenant wall signs would constitute a special privilege inconsistent with limitations upon properties in the vicinity. 2. Exceptional circumstances do not apply that deprive the subject property of privileges enjoyed by other properties in the same zone classifications. 3. The location and site layout plus the size of the existing building Wall signage provide clear visibility of the tenant copy, from public streets. Staff Report - 9/7/88 -3- (1189d) -1 ^ ALTERNATIVE ACTION: As an alternative, the Planning Commission may consider approving a 7 foot high monument sign with an area of 25 square feet to be located in the landscape planter (as proposed) identifying only the center identification and address, with findings and conditions of approval. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Area map 2. Site plat, and elevations dated August 2, 1988 j3 . Narrative ' SH:DTH:kla 1 i ^-MAC' �i Staff Report - 9/7/88 -4- (1189d) KI.uufJox • • i 161:A)'I(Ift:f_t:._: Nsi!l ;2i-u.•,liL -1.': — ER i ti t:I)Y:_ H.lr+tn.11..r,Ei itl, f t. �i�y�� �� •i 1WHAS GUIDE: •-•. tl TOTAL S)PE SQ. FT.:�0-5 Si 164t�7 1E4S5 tc-t63 IFq::I i6-t:. ♦1 PAF,KIK%'s REQ*D-. z2 j. _►'•.�� ° ti.•l?5 1�•;i,7, nl+' PARKING NRov'D.: _ '_ 984s' 37sf 137sf 737sf 737s[ 1474sf loll-3 w Z ♦-.r • ii PROPOSEv G.L.A.. 24%-%tf ALLUYAQLE SF FOR RE'tAIL: ilotir„it _ ALLOYABLE SF FOR FOOD'{ S+tIlatt •�. T'* .f '�'�' J ALLuY�BLE FOOD USES.=F!?_Lir�9t.lf - �� �`� c tr C [. TI t Tr•ir, I1 Si-it3 Fir Sfcr+ !I!!!) %M:'1�. �;• )ril}�() . r\r\. LEASING RESTRICTIONS: 44Irlo -Thm � Ti yor, nyar I^tia;fr I -Inn TOTAL MO. OF STORES:- 7 VFC APPROVAL (CONST.)l r T. +; DATES t1-17-P7 F4 REv1SlOtt NO.: (It 7-In-pr, El ter` � // �-/�f HIV t // 4 ♦{�{�1.4! � / \/]■ • �..— �— — — �i.:3�l��i .� —� 'i.f vim,..:('. _ 77' i 3 • T ' W - LJU L RIF0 i LLJF F 1 41 nFPn IDD CCNI C .,s f*ricGA e1�:-ra.7cMAU-Y WLLJPMJ -rl:i� r`waNwnlel�t9"�,ely, s C� �l g'�.._L,(, �l , _..; u • :� fov.aVE s.++eaT/v.aTnG. e'�I�IG.LeerJZ� T"n�ar� e.+►3R ��1.,,JfL'7� - '.-%:' ��=3 Z•� ;; ..►l.tl1't LQaLL=I�i tfr�t s a ANTa.UY.aIV.L fJ .LLH 17.a1 Q.aoXGOLJC. . Cpl&vr 1L� 7�1(. 2�SL. if2sJtt'ur2t��VrTl12�.i1.wLlC.t�Va:n�. •__• •;s �1 i cOLCe?�Z T aC NrfV�+JV /►":+DLb 't'2r.tiL, Ga�NTc2 l'lS� L'•/7�j vf'Y�ounL �--•;»�l.S v✓lrk •LK r'Lliy. ��r�c�taec�►�t�• wr.hTc . N.o. tccur25c�asr s t ,I '4 o L�lbnitrai�lrJi t�d•!n,[.� .s-s7wu:lt's. r' 1� 1 r � 1 44 r. .. rots csr.L �Lrr�u.•�+rrr T w•ANT - . cof•Y s•nPa•�� •-t r�►d .F .rsrC�.�F _ .. .- - ---. - _ _ .._ r � 'I s I I M •• •lfi ! • :+i:w � 1{'O Ol Caaw-lyt.-- • .t .. Ott TO o ITI - -f k•_�R�L:..�-��.-- -_-._. ..��__ is T 1 - T. - s T � I _ .i. _ � - _c' TJ I �� - � •�, wvy0`� rX ri :.. •taa�a.4+aa�.Tc-.+s G-LJar� -war:� ` ; :.. i EAST MLt_VP.':!QN s t t • i —u�+tt Hc(wtE i 1 i .Grp+ t+.+�t-� .,. ❑r.. Q �: "-: -: ;�; O} '--- '` vr+t t �• _--fi:'vR+:-�s:.a Windsor Fenianciul Corporation I June 8, 1988 City of Huntington Beach Planning Commission 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 RE: 21501 Srookhurst St. 16471 Springdain Ave. Dear Commissioners : It is our experience, as a developer of retail Shopping Conters in Southern California for t:le past seventeen years, that a monument center identification sign with more than two major tenants is highly necessary, considering the extreme visual impairment obstructing the view of the tenant buildings. Due to the 100 ' 00 setback from the property line, the only clear visabi: ity of the center tenant buildings is from within the parking facilities . Having a multi-tenant monument center identification sign at the property corners would enable all traffic to identify the center and tenants within 300 fact of the intersection. Thus reducing the hazard for traffic slowdown at the intersection in an attempt to locate a particular business. We look forward to your thoughtful consideration in granting our sign variances . S3ticerely, 9 c. }Fvyt Projects Manager f! CCH/dd 1 j i i,. A-rrAc. HEgr- 3 16255 Wntura Boulevard, Suite 615, Encino, California 91436 18181 981-6513 Cable:W1NMOR 4 . An entertainment permit shall be submitted and approved prior to the establishment of the live entertainment within the restaurant. 5. The proposed use shall comply with all applicable Fire and Building codes, including Chapter 33 of the Uniform Building Code. 6. The proposed live entertainment shall comply with Chapter 8.40 "Noises" of. the Huntington Beach Municipal Code. Should complaints be received regarding noises generated by the live entertainment, the Planning Commission reserves the right to require the applicant to mitigate the noise level. 7. This conditional use permit shall run with the applicant. 8 . The primary use of the building shall be dining and the sale of food. D&neing and live entertainment shall be a secondary use. 9. The Planning Commission reserves the right to revoke this j conditional use permit if any violation of these conditions or the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code occurs. i I C-6 SPECIAJi- SIGN PERMIT NO, 86-1 APPLYCANT: MCS ARC."ITECTURAL SIGNS Special Sign Permit No. 88-4 proposes two sign variances: (1) to permit a monument sign (7 feet high, with an area of 35 square feet) in addition to existing wall signage; and (2) allow the monument i sign, in addition to the center identification, to contain tenant copy identifying six of the seven tenants in the center. The center is located at 16471 Springdale (northwest corner of Springdale and Heil) . ENVIRONMENTAL $TAB: I The proposed project is exempt Class 1 Section 15301 from the provisions %,- the California Environmental Quality Act. izTAFF RED END LTION: Deny Special Sign Permit No. 88-4 with findings. i THE PUBLIC HEARING HAS OPENED 1 Craig C. Hoyt, applicant, spoke in support of the sign request. He said the monument sign was needed for better visibility for tenants in the existing center. ff PC Minutes 9/7/88 -12- (1252d) i 1 There were no other persons present to speak for or &gainsst the request and the public hearing was closed. A MOTION WAS MADE BY BOURGUIGNON, SECOND BY SLATES, TO APPROVE SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 88-4 WITH FINDINGS AND CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL, BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: Slates, Silva, Bourguignon NOES: Livengood, Ortega, Higgins ABSENT: Leipzig ABSTAIN: None �E=�QTE A MOTION WAS MADE BY LIVENGOOD, SECOND BY HIGGINS, TO DENY SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 88r-4 WITH FINDINGS, BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: Livengood, Silva, Ortega, Higgins NOES: Slates, Bourguignon ABSENT: Leipzig ABSTAIN: None MOTION PAMD FINDINGS FORDENIAL: 1. Granting Special Sign Permit No. 88-4 for a monument sign with multi-tenant copy in addition to existing tenant wall signs would constitute a special privilege inconsistent with limitations upon properties in the vicinity. 2. Exceptional circumstances do not apply that deprive the subject property of privileges enjoyed by other properties in the same zone classifications. 3. The location and site layout plus the size of the existing building wall signage provide clear visibility of the tenant { copy from public streets. The site is in a predominately residential neighborhood and the use is neighborhood commercial. C-7 E APPLICANT: MCS ARCHITECTURAL SIGNS Special Sign Permit No.g 88-5 proposes two sign variances. (1) to ' permit a monument sign (7 feet high with an area of 35 square feet) in addition to existing wall siignage; and (2) allow the monument sign, in addition to the center identification, to contain tenant copy identifying six of the seven tenants in the center. The center is located at 21501 Brookhursst (southwest corner of Brookhurst and Hamilton) . PC Minutes - 9/7/8e 4� i4meNTA4 -13- (1252d) ATTACHMENT NO. 5 ALTERNATIVE FINDINGS AND CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL FOR ALTERNATIVE NO. I EINDINGS FQR APPROVAL: 1. The proposed monument sign (seven feet in height with an area of 25 square feet) , with center identification and address only, will not have a detrimental effect: upon the general health, welfare and safety and convenience of persons residing or working in the neighborhood and is not detrimental to the value of the adjacent properties and improvements. 2. The location, site layout and design of the proposed monument sign properly adapts the proposed structure to streets, driveways, and adjacent structures and uses in a harmonious manner. The parcel is a corner lot and located on an arterial street. 3. The combination and relationship of one on the site are properly integrated, proposal use to another 9. The placement of the monument sign will not create traffic problems. 4 I CONDITIONS OFAPPROVAL: 1. The site plan and elevations received and dated August 2, 1988, shall be revised as follows. a. The proposed sign shall be revised to a maximum area of 25 square feet, and shall identify the center identification and address only. I� i f i (1389d) i • ATTACIM19T NO. 6 ALTERNATI FINDINGS AND COND►ITIONSrOF APPROVAL FOR ALTERNATIVE AO:�'2 i FINOINGS FOR APPRQygL; 1. The proposed monument sign (seven feet in height with an area of 35 square feet) , with center identification and tenant panels, will not have a detrimental effect upon the general health, welfare and safety and convenience of persons •:esiding or working in the neighborhood and is not detrimental to the value of the adjacent properties and improvements. 2. The location, site layout and design of the proposed monument sign properly adapts the proposed structure to streets, drivewa B and adjacent Y . structure and s uses in a harmonious manner. The parcel i p s a corner lot and located an an arterial street. 3. The combination and relationship of one proposed use to another on the site are properly integrated. 4. The placement of the monument sign will not create traffic problems. i =MJ'TIONS OF AEpj1QyAL; F r 1. The site plan and elevations received and dated August; 2, 1988, i shall be the conceptually approved layout. a. The proposed monument sign shall be architecturally compatible with the building in the center it identifies. ( I ' I (1389d) • Publish 10/20/88 c� NOTICE QF PURL_ IC Hr&UN ` APPEAL - EPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 88-4 NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. VATS; Monday, November 7, 1988 7:00 PM j SUBJ . Appeal - Special Sign Permit No. 88-4 APPLIChNT: KCS Architectural Signs AITELLNT: Windsor Financial Corporation j LOCA' N,: 16471 Springdale Street (Northwest corner of Springdale Street & Heil Avenue) MROSAT,: Appeal of the Planning Commission's denial of a request to permit a free-standing multi-tenant monument sign (7 feet high, 30 square feet) , in addition to existing wall signs. EffVIRQNMEffTA TUr2: Categorically exempt pursuant to §15301, Class I of the California Environmental Quality Act. ON Fes,$: A copy of the request and appeal are on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Main E Street, Huntington Beach, CA 92648 J ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and 1 express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. All applications, exhibits, and descriptions of this proposal are on file with the Office of tho City Clerk, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, for inspection by the public. HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL By: Connie Brockway City Clerk Phone (714) 536-5404 Dated 10/18/88 (1150d-5) ' USE•AL.L POINT PEN ONLY--/REss/IRMLY . �•� i CASH RECEIPT .!A me i r,ITY&HUNTINGTON BEACH : I0.M(TItiG)O4 M4CN {T�• + U6.6611•Cl Ty T11EASL UAC^CA In" 0[L pL*AL WATSON , MfCEIYEp � • . // ����� ' . � PROM �I•it A .1 •/!� L+•� __'1 � •. . r• t�' AppRElS f, 2-r J f✓'���.,T�M,TT I/f. '' r•` a ` i •' 1 r 1! ... _ r ( •mow t � ..]- '', . Pon 77 0140 AMOUNTRECLIYfp r • �• 1 CASH❑ •CMCCK AAA. �/• '` 11LCE1�EDRY ,7 ,a . era:,.«i�w'•�yY•...,w.+.,,. ACCOUNT AMOUNT ,rt`�4,,:� '.iJiL '•rd r � .. - ', •a• ter• _ �! •r •♦�••}.1 7. TOTAL 700 1 .war.. '. .'; .•'..'•'��1•I'�•�•^�.• • �. - .� . ,_ 'r. - .._ _,�.cc:�-fix.� �i . . 4 1 •ttrl+ .-....�.�f .,y., fir/• Mi .. •.•�.••.n...���,f;'.;.r� No. 465031 ! ISSUING DEFT. . �nCMS 88-856 ' { Ownership List 28 146-552-13 29 146-552-14 30 146-552-15 Kethryn Jones Christine Rose Singer James F Starnes 3601 Park Green Dr Richard Singer 5972 Langport Cir Corona Del Mar, CA 92625 2795 Ben Lomond Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Santa Barbara, CA 93105 31 146-552-16 32 146-552-17 33 146-552-18 Harris R Stutman Richard Charles Maier John E Jewett 5952 Langport Cir 5942 Langport Cir 5922 Langport Cir Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 34 146-552-19 35 146-552-20 John R Carabbe Care9o�y KAShtarl �},.- , 5912 Langport Cir 5902 Langport Cir Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 i i ' CMS 88-856 Windsor Financial Corp ( 6325 Van Nuys Blvd 16255 Ventura Blvd - #615 IVan Nuys, CA 91401 Encino, CA 91436 Att: Craig Hoyt i f � i 1 i f r•-�, G1S 88-856 Ownership List 1 146-283-36 2 146-283-40 3 146-283-35 Windsor Financial Corp Long Beach Medical Arts Bldg City of Huntington Beach 16255 Ventura Blvd , - 1045 Atlantic Ave City Hall Encino, CA 91436 Long Beach, CA 90813 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 A 146-283-45 5 146-283-46 6 146-283-47 Church Redeemer Lutheran Nicole Poucel Peter J Rossi 16351 Springdale St 5991 Brassie Cir 5981 Brassie Cir Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 97649 7 146-283-48 8 146-283-49 9 146-283-50 Michael W Burns James B Mackin Eric J Schmitt 5961 Brassie Cir 5951 Brassie Cir 5941 Brassie Cir Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 10 146-283-51 11 146-283-52 12 146-283-53 Carl S Lent Fnrokh Mirjahangir Nikolas A Bletsos 5921 Brassie Cir 5942 Brassie Cir 5952 Brassie Cir Huntingtan Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 i 13 146-283-54 14 146-283-55 15 146-283-56 Obie A Scott, Jr Wesley S Woodworth Segundino T Castillo 5962 Brassie Cir 5982 Brassie Cir 5991 Brassie Cir Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 16 146-,283--05 17 146-283-06 18 146•-283-07 Dean McMannus Richard F Lovejoy Leonard K Krause 16402 Fairway Lane 603 Vista Valinda 16422 Fairway Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92649 San Clemente, CA 92672 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 19 146-283-08 20 146-431-06,146-431-09 21 146-431-08 Stuart Maude Diocese of Orange Ed & Welfare Roman Cath Bishop of Orange 9146 E De Adalena 16400 Springdale St 16400 Springdale St Rosemead, CA 91770 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 �I 22 146-541-01 23 146-552-08 24 146-552-09 � City of Huntington Beach Jozsef Papak Norman R Campbell Tr P 0 Box 190 5891 Langport Cir 5901 Langport Cir Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Bench, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 25 146-552-10 26 146-552-11 27 146-552-12 Michael A Smith Monroe Perry Tho Dang Vu 5911 Langport Cir 5921 Langport Cir 7141 Langport Cir iuntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Win(Vor Ftnanctul Carpora(1on 16255 11111ura 11Ullll'Mrll.S1811!615. Cnttinu. Califontia 91436 In eT N tT I � V n � d U i ° a VI m Onofrio Pentolino 1ro4 14 G 16487 Springdale 43 to rn Huntington Beach, CA 92645 r C b m 11 F O Ln W r; L C C e .- 11'ntdaor flnanwtal C(►rptlrauun C 1F255 11vUun Ifuul�h�nl.tiuilr G1�. Enclnu ('aliL •nin 9143(i t I i Hassan Chehab 1605 Springdale Huntington Doach, CA 92645 L I tl. i N � U U d to i � o °i � ICnul(+t1r I•lnnnt�tn!Carptlra(tun W C c U ri r. 16255 Wntun Iluuhmard.-suite 615. litlt-(nu.California 91436 o to Itn m c I � r- 4j O � y ro v G wn C w @ Ngan Doan c ^ 16483 Springdale n Huntington Beach, CA 92645 .i M � 1 t Windsor Fin.mcial Corporalum 162SS Wntura liouletard. Suite 615. Emilio. Califotflia 91436 ti i i David Sullivan , DDS r 16473 Springdale 4 Huntington Beach, CA 92645 i i r t t i M l I 1 I Legal Notice City of Huntington Beech Of lice of till City Clerk P.0.Box 190 Huntington Beech,CA 92640 I 22 146-541-01 City of Huntington Bench P 0 Box 190 Huntington Bench, CA 92648 \ J FIRST CLASS MAIL C I Publish 10/20/88 N0110 OF MIL,IC NF.ARI$Q APPEAL - GPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 88-4 NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. ] $: Monday, November 7, 1988 ME: 7:00 PM SUBJECT' Appeal - Special Sign Permit No. 88-4 1 �,, MCS Architectural Signs ( ggPLLLANT: Windsor Financial Corporation I 1S28: 16471 Springdale Street (Northwest corner of Springdale Street S Neil Avenue) pRa1�S Appeal of the Planning Commission's denial of a request to permit a free-standing multi--tenant monument sign (7 feet high, 30 square feet) , in addition to existing wall signs. I ENYIAL STATUS: Categorically exempt pursuant to S15301, Class 1 of the California Environmental Quality Act. ON FILE: A copy of the request and appeal are on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Main Street, huntingtbn Beach, CA 92648 ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above:. All applications, exhibits, and descriptions of this proposal aria on file with the Office of the City Clark, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, for inspection by the public. HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL By: Cnnnie Brockway City Cleric Phone (714) 536-5404 Dated 10/1.'488 (1150d-5) Authorized 10 Publish AOvemsements of all kinds Including public notices by Decree of the SUpe1i01 Court at Orange County, - J California. Number A-621A. dated 29 September. 1961. and `'j A-24E31,doled I June. 1953 ( ' V 1 STATE or CALIFORNIA County of Orange PUaK Not"A0.01' .p cu.are p,1M HIb�M ./ 'MU1 ,P 1 ypnl i �1N 10 OK&Csk~w01F. I am a Citizen of the United States and a resident of PIIKIC NOTICE mo,nus of the County aforesaid; I ai;i over the age of eighteen PUSLICHEARING years; and not a party to or interested in the below APP PLAN TO ri1E ANHINq COAentitled matter. 1 am a principal clerk of the Orange I DENIAL Of SPECIALON - Coast DAILY PILOT, with which is combiner: the QINOO .1a11T I4 .ar1a , NEWS-PRESS, a newspaper of general circulation, oflthf, J"ll"oWn mooch printed and published in the City of Costa Mesa, olNO110Ec15 ir.EREBY GIVEN thAl the Huntiopton. County of Orange. State of California, and that a Beach Cily council win hold a"bloc hearing in the Coun., Notice of _,.. CA chamber, of its Hunt. ingion Reach Civic Center,; Public Hearing 2000 Main stiwt, Hunt I "Ion Dosch.CiGforn:a,an the date and of the tRne M• l dlcated tie'.**to►ecelva and of which copy attached hereto is a true and complete consider the statements of an poison&%ho VAsh to tm copy. was printed and published in the Costa Mesa, Mard raalive to the W16. 1 Callon diwAbed below. Newport peach, Hurilington Beach, Fountain Valley, is 9TE Monday, August Tife[:r.oa R:M. : Irvine, the South Coast communities and Laguna SUBJECT: 5,vo l one time a Pli mn No.BIT.1a .sign Beach issues of said newspaper for A P P fr- l CANT/APPELLANT: ,Rod f t 1*l�tic to wit the issue(s) of Viz CAT ptrjitMod s, , bouiavar0 font :olds of Beach Stimialwd, bourn of Taylor Biwa-Wilson Ford) i July a $ ZONE;PnOP CZicSAL io mwSian 198 gbctronic leader board sign' at a height Of 60 Met Iri Nu' of 15 feel with an arNb1400 13qubre l Gail eft In of To. 1913 iof 10 h fnnum��l�slpsn&)-i � IOwed tM tM pro��1. i � 198. ENVIgoNMENt�AL' STATUS. Ccegoricaat,sit- e-ppt Puleuant to S4i-:ien is711,Cian 11 of the En. 19 f3 wonmmtai quality Act,• ON ME. A copy of the prcposed request is on ws in Wit•Department- of Coo• 198 "Wn,iy Oevetow4r;t, 2M Main street, Hunl.ngton Bosch. CA 92640. for in, spectron tbryy the ppublic, ' 1 ALL INTERESTED PER.' SONS are invited to stiand I declare, under penalty of perjury, that the >a,d hearing and express' foregoing iS true and correct. gvir*on`ora"h""tevvenGel g 9 for Or against the sppk&14n, t+s oulurfw above. If Ihoris are any (urthm quattkin&, please Call t1Coll'tiou. As. Executed On Societe Planner, 'at July a , 198 A 536-52r 1. ' at Costs Mesa California. HUNTINGTON BEACH. cmr cIHrNCil1 eif Ana& 1111.we itwoKh city C16A. )- -e- Phone:1r141530.6m •} A. t,-114 11-1•t �(� Dated r/Snla Si nature PubGahsd Or Cast g Daily Poet July 6, %fla scaorr a PROOF OF PUBLICATION Is Aulhorlted to PubliSh Adverttsemanls of Sit kinds including public notices by Decree of the Supettor Court of Orange County. , California. Number A-6214, dated 29 September, 1961. and A-24931,dated 11 June, 1963 STAT14 OF CALIFORNIA County of Orange �.�y � I PWA WM to PCs Corr^^++w FIAILIC NOTICE ►� �� s and a resident of NOTICE,of 1 am aCitisen of the United State PUSLIC WAXING the'County aforesaid; I am over the ape of eighteen ApPFOFL THR years, and not a party to or interested In the below COMMISSION.$ . DENIAL Ofr.. entitled matter. I am a principal Cleric of the Orange SPECIAL 610N IERMitT . • ND.n.0 Coast DAILY PILOT, with which is combined the (Toaaowatrlah.. l fn etuea Ot 166e NEWS-PRESS, a newspaper of general circulation. MunlieSlen>feecA. ' ,. DreNuanae cad. .; printed and published in the City of Costa Mesa. ''NOTICE is HEREBY GIVEN thet the Huntington Beech city council will hold County of Orange. State of California, and that a rppuubtocrNerinpoui- PIlhl i t Flea.-4 g t�lonyBeach Civic inthecCentro. Notice of - 2`000 Matn street, Hur►t- inp1W Bonn.Caulorwa.bin the Cate end at tho time In- dtated below to root"and conslder the atelitrowla of of which copy attached hereto is a true and complete an perrton,who wish to be roved Iwo"to tits epFlr copy, was printed and published in the Costa Mesa, caw E,descri Wow. Newport Beach, Huntington Beach. Fountain Valley, M�cy"21. iQNTH M FR: Irvine, the South Coast communities and Laguna e al`vion ,Fortrut,No,+ Beach issues of said newspaper for one A• P':P >r CAMT/t%P"LLANIN A64 consecutive weeks to wit the issues)of ""�`""►'I1edia - a 1 14255 iie fDaet;tl tArVarr Gillet •NOo'.nl No" oQuillywo.,south (if Topw Den'.11'"Fonll ' 1 am-Ct icornnertksl);.t MOVE AL. To apow in March 10 198 8 "Oder hoard elpn 0 4 b".or 60 feet In Iqu M 1b M::'*On area of 400 pwf,. av To 198 tru+ri ftiti.btpet b fk in h o see I total n{Mfttrw of*gna at. 'Lisaeeyy ltfr tM pprro��tctt ? 11twir Dr�I1,tE,NTAI 198 STATWB: Categoncoy e.. renpt_ptKsuitrrt to Section 16211.tv"11 of the Call. i ftW"En►lrat"r+entat oualit! • 198____ Off FILL A;cap"of tits prtn)paed fate ast b txt rosin Vmv bet+aresent ot corn- . 198 may t)eYetepmen1. zoos Main $creel.:Huntlnpptan Beach.California 02648,fat in•Peclian the public. ALL .INT RESTED PER4 �( I declare, under enact of perjury, that the SON$are invited to attend y P r} •tit hea!inp and e.sress i foregoing is true and correct. 0111lo►+awbmuevidence g for or apeinet the amt-Canon ON ovtined above. It VW4 are any tutther q"%twA at 53 pleats call Pem Pollan,As•; March 10 198 R_ acsanl PiPi~ t1•!I?1. i Executed on NUNTINOTON •BACN at Costa Mesa, California. CITY cOVNCIL,br:Allots AL warrt:nrfd; city clerk, Phow.t7>h aapm t PubA&W orangp� Coast'Deily pilot March to,190 Signature Th528, t i � I PROOF OF PUBLICATION ; } REQU&T FOR CITY COUNUL ACTION Data march 211, 1988 Submitted to: Honorable Mayor and City Council Submitted by: Paul Cook, City A3ministrator�� -'' Prepared by: Douglas N. La Belle, Director, Community Developm t Subject: APPEAL OF PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL IGN PERMIT NO. 87--18 Consistent with Council Policy? Yes New Policy or Exception Statement of Issue, Recommendation,Analysis, Funding Source,Alternative Actions,Attachments: STAT MENT_ OF IS UE: Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 is a request for an auto dealer sign which exceeds the Sign Code, Section 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, in terms of height, sign area and number of signs allowed. The sign requested is an electronic reader board at a height of 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet with an area of approximately 254 square feet in lieu of 70 square feet. This sign will exceed the number of freestanding signs allowed for the use. The electronic reader board portion of this sign is not part of the request; it is the subject of Code Amendment No. 87-15 which is a request to amend the Sign Code to allow such signs. Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, Section 9610.7 regarding Special Sign Permits, states that "A special sign permit cannot be processed for those signs listed as prohibited in Section 9610.4 .0 Since the electronic reader board sign is a changeable copy sign, and flashes, pulsates and is intermittently lighted, it is a prohibited sign. The process to exclude them from the prohibited signs section of the code is a code amendment. Therefore, approval of Special Sign Permit. No. 87-18 may be granted to exceed height, area and number of signs but not for the electronic reader board portion of the sign without prior approval of Code Amendment No. 87-151. RECOMMENDATION: Planning Commissig2 BeCommendation and Action or, February 2. 1988: ON MOTION BY SCHUMACHER, SECOND BY HIGGINS, SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 87-18 WAS DENIED WITH FINDINGS, BY THE FOLLOWING 'VOTE: AYES: Pierce, Livengood, Silva, Leipzig, Schumacher, Higgins, Bourguignon NOES: None ABSEN'i. None ! ABSTAIN: None • PIO 4M4 FINDINGS FOR DENIAL: 1. Strict compliance with Section 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code (Sign Code) will not result in a substantial hardship to the applicant, because adequate signage with good visibility is ex±nting. 2. The proposeO 50 foot high, 300 square foot electronic reader board will predominate the surrounding area adversely affecting other signs in the area. 3 . The proposed 50 foot high, 300 square foot electronic reader board sign will be detrimental to properties located in the vicinity especially adjacent residential uses. 4 . The proposed 50 foot high, 300 square foot electronic reader board may be a hazardous distraction to traffic. 5. Granting of Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 for a 50 foot high, 300 square foot sign would constitute a special privilege inconsistent with limitations upon properties in the vicinity. 6. Exceptional circumstances do not apply that deprive the subject property of privileges enjoyed by other properties in the same zone classifications. Staff's recommendation is the same as the Planning Commission. i Applicant: Rod Wilson Electra--Media Location: 18255 Beach Boulevard (west side of Beach, south of. Taylor Drive) i Zone: C2 (Community Business District) General Plan: General Commercial I Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 for an electronic reader board at a height of 50 feet with approximately 254 square feet of area is being requested by the applicant to afford advertising flexibility neerled due to constant change in interest rates, factory rebates and cre-►tive financing in a constantly changing auto industry. According to Section 961 (Sign Code) the applicant is allowed one primary business identification freestanding sign fronting on Beach Boulevard. Although the existing signs on site ea•,eed the maximum allowable heights and areas, the number of signs meets code. Approval of Vpecial Sign Permit No. 87-18 would give the applicant one freestanding sign in addition to those allowed by Code, as outlined in the following matrix. For clarity, sign designations reference attached site plan and elevations. i RCA - 3/21/88 --2-- (0161d) { 1 A R I Maximum Allgwed by Code ERJZI na Propo,7Qd ZotaI Primary Business Identific Lion No. of Signs 1 fronting on 1 on Beach 1 on Beach 2 on Beach Beach and 1 fronting on Taylor Sign No. 1* Area 70 sq.ft. 132 sq.ft. Height 15 ft. 40 ft. New Sign* Area 254 sq.ft. 386 sq.ft. Height 50 ft, n/a ' Secondary Business I identification No. of Signs 2 fronting on 1 on Beach 1 on Beach Beach and 2 fronting on Taylor fign No. 2* Area 30 sq.ft. 60 sq.ft. Right 7 tom_ � ft, - Wall Signs No. of Signs* 2 (1 per 3 on Beach 3 on Beach frontage) trontage frontages Sign No. 3 Area 21 sq.ft. Sign No. 4 Area 32 sq.ft. Sign No. 5 j Area 123 sq.ft. ota Area 200 haft. 176 sq.ft. i I 1 RCA - 3/21/88 -3- (0161d) . I Maximum Allowgd by rod,--. Exi,tina �rbP4ser3 ;C4.�,1. p�ectional_ ,�ian� No. of Signs 4 (1 per 3 (1 not 3 entrance) located at entrance) Sign No. 6* Area 2 sq.ft. 14 sq.ft. Height 4 ft. 5 ft. Sign No. 7* Area 2 sq.ft. 12 sq. ft. Height 4 ft. 10 ft. Sign No. 8* Area 2 sq. ft. 24 sq.ft. Height 4 ft. 10 ft. *Non-conforming one of the major accomplishments of the recent sign code revision was to decrease the heights and areas of signage along the Beach Boulevard corridor to reduce visual clutter. Many auto dealers currently have nonconforming signs but as projects recycle into now uses or upgrade buildings, the signage along Beach Boulevard will become aesthetically more pleasing and lower profile. The proposed sign is 35 feet higher and 184 square feet larger than the maximum sign allowed by code. Circumstances do not exist which justify the need for such an excess. There is no visually--impairing landscaping ov large buildings near the location of the proposed sign. A sign at a rieight of 15 feet could be adequately seen by motorists passing from both directions on Beach Boulevard. Positioning of the sign at the proposed location w.:11 require landscape planter modification and may result in the loss of parking spaces. Single family 7esidences are located directly behind the auto dealer and across the street which will be negatively impacted by the lighting of such a sign at a height of 50 feet. Staff recommends denial of the special sign permit based on the fact that an electronic reader board at the proposed location may be a hazardous distraction to traffic. Motorists will slow to read the changing copy, taking their eyes off the road. Further discussion of the electronic reader board concept is contained in Code Amendment No. i 87-15. ENVI OMMENTAL STATUS: The proposed project is exempt Class 11 Section 15311 from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act. RCA -- 3l21188 -4- (0161d) I EEEnl31M sow: Not applicable. N RN TM ACTION: The City Council may continue Special Sign Permit pending approval of Code Amendment No. 87--15. ATTACf ANTS.: 1. Appeal letter dated February 11, 1988 Z. Planning Commission Staff Report dated February 2, 1988 DNL:PP:kla I I f RCA - 3/21/88 -5- (0161d) r, >' ' r.., ... (Ica) C;,2 1208 Poinsettia Ave. / Manhattan Beach, CA 90266 ; 213-379-51.19 eAK AP / ;cfiv r f �f" "9/V rV ry o-.c+,,zrT r� 1V �4`' I 1 49 exf Sly 'fLs�..r� 71-167 I f Aom.,,,.ccf U4•4 er rc, ,,,, Electranic Vicuat On Information Systems t Huntington beach department of community development _ '31Aff EPORT .r•rii�rr rr.rr TO: Planning Commission FROM: Cci=unity Development DATE: February 2, 1988 SUBJECT: SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 87--18 APPLICANT: Rod Wilson Eledtra-Media bAiuz- Ard"P�Fp: 1208 Poinsettia Aire. January 22, 1988 Manhattan Heach, Ca 90266 NANDA'TORy- jROCE56�N,G ?ATE gVNER: Wilson Ford March 22, 1988 18255 Beach Boulevard Hunt. Beach, CA 92647 20NE: C2 (CommUhity Business District) To allow an electronic reader board trim in %SAL PLAN: General excess of the Huntington Ccmmerciil Beach Ordinance Code. i�SISLN© .i]SE: Auto dealer MCKTIIOH: 18255 Beach Boulevard (Wils6ti Ford) (we8t tide of eebch, south of Taylor Drive) AC3F=: 6.3 acres Ij Deny Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 with findings. 2.0 Q&ff K"L INFORMATION: Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 is a request for an aut6 dealer sign which exceeds the Sign Code, Section 961 6£ the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, in terms of height, sigh axed afid number of signs allowed. The sign requested is an electronic reader board at a height of 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet with all area of approximately 400 square feet in lieu of 7f1 hie sign will exceed the number of freestandino. the use. The electronic reader boar ��'N� gn is not part of the request; it is the subject o. 87-15 which is a request to amend the Sign ions. Huntington Beach Ordinanca Code, Sect: Special Sign Permits, states that "A special sigr !ocessed for those signs listed as prohibited Since the electronic C' A-i►1Q3C . t awrrr..a+r..r.r•.�r•nr�r.��i Mr■�■r��r r��i i i - _ __ r.�+�.rwr�a I I�+ 1 1 �t • I SrAff Huntington beach department of community development ' REPORT TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: February 2, 1988 SUBJECT: SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 87-18 APPLICAU: Rod Wilson Electra-Media pAtrF. ACCEPTr - 1208 Poinsettia AVe. January 22, 1988 Manhatten Beach, Ca 90266 HANb& Q p C "BINQATE: OWNER: Wilson Ford March 22, 1988 10255 reach Boulevard Hunt:. Beach, CA 92647 zONE: C2 (Community Business District) REQUEST: To allow an electronic reader board sign in ('ENE AL PLAN: General excess of the Huntington Cummercidl Beach Ordinance Code. USE: Auto dealer LQCATION: 18255 Beach Boulevard (Wilson Ford) (went side of Beddh, south of Taylor Drive) ACREAGE. 6.3 acres 1.0 SUGGESIE12 Ar,110 : Deny Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 with findings. 2.9 GENERAL INFORMATI N: Special Sign Permit- No. 87-18 is a request for an auto dealer sign which exceeds the Sign Code, Section 961 of the flufifington Beach Ordinance Code, in terms of height, sign area abd numt,c.: of signs allowed. The sign requested is an electroni,: reader board at a height of 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet with an area of approximately 400 square feet in lieu of 70 square feet. This sign will exceed I` the number of freestanding signs allowed for the use. The electronic reader board portion of this sign is not part of the request; it is the subject of Code Amendment No. 87-15 which is a request to amend the Sign Code to allow such signs. Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, Section 9610.7 regardir:g Special Sign Permits, state, that "A special sign permit cannot be processed for those signs listed as prohibited in Section 9610:4 ." Since the electronic A-FM-23C ^' d 6.0 REQW-ELQi' NT ETATUS: The subject property is within the Beach Boulevard Redevelopment Survey Area. 7_. Q SSPECIErC PLAN: Not applicable. 8.0 SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE: Not applicable. 9 .9 IESUES AHD AN►LXSIS: Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 for an electronic reader board at a height of 50 feet with approximately 400 square feet of area is being requested by the applicant•, to afford advertising flexibility needed due to constant change `:3 intereft rates, factory rebates and creative financing in a constantly changing auto industry. According to Section 961 (Sign Code) the applicant is allowed one primary business identification freestanding sign fronting on Beach Boulevard. Although the existing signs on site exceed tho maximum allowable heights and areas, the number of signs meets code. Approval of Special Sign Permit Ho. 87-18 would give the applicant one freestanding sign in addition to those allewed by Code, as outlined in the following inatrix. For clarity, sign designations reference attached site plan and elevations. Maximum Allowed by CgAa Wzlinq prgposed TLotal Primary Business Idtntificatinn f No. of Signs 1 fronting on i on reach 1 on Beach 2 on Beach Beach and I • fronting or, Taylor Sign No. 1* Area 70 cq.ft. 132 sq. it. Height i5 ft. 40 ft. New Sign* Area 400 sq.ft. 532 sq.ft. Height 50 ft, n/a Secondary Business Identification No. of Signs 2 fronting on I on Beach 1 on Beach Beach and 2 fronting on Taylor Sign No. 2* Area 30 sq.ft. 60 sq.ft. -.kialght- 22 ft. j , Staff Report - 2i2/88 -3- (9947d) i I Maximum Allowed by Code Existing Proposed Total Wall Sians No. of Signs* 2 (1 per 3 on Beach 3 on beach frontage) f ronLage frontage ISign No. 3 Area 21 sq.ft. Sign No. 4 Area 32 sq.ft. Sign No. 5 Area 123 sq.ft. i Uotal Area 200 so- Ft. 3.26 sa.ft. p � onal Signs No. of Signs 4 (1 per 3 (1 not 3 entrance) located at entrance) Sign Fo. 6* Area 2 sq.fe. 14 sq.ft. Height 4 ft. 5 ft. Sigh No. 7* Area 2 sq.ft. 12 sq.ft. Height 4 ft. 10 ft. . Sign No. 8* 11 Area 2 sq.ft. 24 sq.ft. 4 Height 4 £t. 10 ft. *Non-conforming One of the major accomplishments of the recent sign code revision was to decrease the heights and areas of signage along the Beach Boulevard corridor to reduce visual clutter. Many auto dealers currently have nonconforming signs but as projects recycle into new uses or upgrade 4 buildings, the signage along Beach Boulevard will become aesthetically more pleasing and tower profile. The proposed sign is 35 feet higher and 330 square feet larger than the maximum sign allowed by code. Circumstances do not exist which justify the need for s.ch an excess. There is no visually-impairing landscaping or large buildings near the I location of the proposed sign. A sign at a height of 15 feet could be i adequately seen by motorists passing from both directions on Beach Boulevard. Positioning of the sign ; .- the proposed location will require landscape planter modification and may result in the loss of parking spaces. Single family residences are located directly behind the auto dealer and across the street which will be negatively ' ? impacted by the lighting of such a sign at a height of 50 feet. 1 Staff Report - 2/2/88 -4- (9947f,) i too) Staff recommends denial of the special sign permit based on the fact that. an electronic reader board at the proposed location may be a hazardous distraction to traffic. Motorists will slow to read the changing copy, taking their eyes off the road. Further discussion of the electronic reader board concept is contained in Code Amendment No. 87-15. Staff recommends denial of the request. As an alternative, the Planning Commission may continue Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 to allow staff time to prepare findings and conditions of approval based on the Planning Commission's action on Code Amendment No. 87-15. 10.0 RE!QQM ENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission deny Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 with the following findings: FINDINGS FOR DENS: 1. Strict compliance with Section 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code (Sign Code) will not result in n substantial hardship to the applicant, because adequate signage with good visibility is existing. 2. The proposed 50 foot high, 400 square foot electronic reader board will predominate the surrounding area adversely affecting --� other signs in the area. 3. The proposed 50 foot high, 400 square foot electronic reader board sign will be detrimental to properties located in the vicinity especially adjacent residential uses. 4. The proposed 50 foot high, 400 square foot electronic reader board may be a hazardous diatraction to traffic. 5. Granting of Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 for a 50 foot high, 400 square foot sign would constitute a special privilege inconsistent with limitations upon properties in the vicinity. 6. Exceptional circumstances do not apply that deprive the subject property of privileges enjoyed by other properties in the sane zone classifications. 11L.C ALTERNATIVE ACTION: Continue Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 pending the approval of Code j Amendment No. V-15 and direct staff to prepare findings and conditions for approval. Staff Report 2/2/88 -5- (9947d) I 1 �ACE�MENT$: 1. Area map 2. Site plan dated January 27, 1988 3 . Zlevations of existing signs 4 . :elevation of proposed sign dated November 24 , 1987 S. Letter from applicant dated December 17, 1987 i SH:PP:kla i I I 1 }i 1 I .y EStaff Report - 2/2/88 --6- (9947d) I 'tLR(Rt T I r ` ... . t r41 � n° IC 4 CF E RI ` L RI �• M SR MI—CD YR:: f`�' C4 :1 RI MI-ARI _ 1 CF-R RI Rr f?I-pp m I 1 RI RI S19R �•RI YRI ....- =RI YH. RI RI1 RI RI RI tti a - outrrc sa RI Ri Rs _ RI •; R3 Lw w R3 RI RI :.tu+rrn r �i �R r I 1 RRA ! RI RI C4 R3 RI B• .r " I ' lama* IYI� r �s i RI _ = lf3 r - Rj Rs R2 n • .� ---� R2 I 2 tR2:7+wt.'r RI ,$ _ \ r_r-- _ I -v RI ....��� \Mi .w R+2 -- - -- +.-` - -` -R33'-— -- !' C4f ! a n3 3 R3 . F3 — OA . 1• f + 1 43w R2• / �trT f 1. �t�t� `, n3 RZ HUNTUNGTON BEACH PLANNING DIVISION ■f - EXisTin> - �C� f- SJ�I✓�°p 11wT A ^y �s� gas' gyp' .u' _rA=3 l 4,00// e 7- A? s.+t t twi,Sni✓J F,r,,;siivJ 3 ofF/C E . ,�E, s�yN S 19 E��'sT,i*J Cooy i ,envIC� IK �• Y 1 s �ej I. i • • l J I I i i t I V ti. i FX145TI A 4 4f2M "i r1l, LI /V r ►�. IN r 3 0 I L i N F.tIA D i . t 1 y 4 11 i i 'I 1 { C11— rot- 4 { f IAN- ' 1 s vrcc A16 51 NS qk& :'k7l *(5 r I� w r i a, I 1 ON i I� GOt�1ir�U.C.R LL�' �"• —.-- GR7 C MTT1 R� I pHG mu frot•lr�. IZ r��wxNe�r-, r r�plNl�+ep iI�r>.>�c�•:ptut��.�.a�r illy-s. hail r�..�• �i j� �/ 1Vc v7 �:t /t.t. •lr•A Ili• Y, t P4dk1NG c.•s U �! CL t t D I • .W t an FM4 I 18205 B�I each Boulevard Huntington Beath, California 92648 * (714) 842-661! t1 Planning Department City of Huntington Heach ;"• - tiuntinaten Beach, Calif. " I • RE: Special Sign Permit Wilson Ford Sales • ••- ••" I t 10a. Due to the following conditions and circumstances we feel a special sign permit should be granted. Due to the constant change in our industry regarding interest rates, factory rebates, and creative financing, without a changeable sign we cannot compete. Also we cannot rely soley on Newspaper, radio and T.V. due to its expensive cost. (Our electronic readerboard would give us the flQxability we need. ) Other auto dealers in the area have larger :,igns and in some cases also include a changeable copy readerboard, which .is a special privelege. Other competitors in the surrounding communities are using electronic changeable readerboard signs to remain viable in a very competitive industry. With the multiple brands and makes we offer, we cannot properly advertise them to the people passing our dealership with a static non changeable sign. (This also holds true for properly advertising our Service, Parts, and Body Shop. 10b. We do not feel that thin request will grant a special privilege 4' inconsistent with normal limitations. I 10c. This request is necessary to be competitive and to grow and change with the industry. 10d. The granting of this request will not be materially detrimental to the public welfare due to the following: -the sign can be designed astetically to tie in and olend with the community. - the electronic readerboard can also display community and public service messages along with the time and temperature. - this type of sign is approved by the State Traffic Dent. Not to be a traffic hazard. f SincerLly, WILSON FORD SALES RA:es R ck Armstrong, Vice President 1• NOTICE QF PjtBuc HMINQ APPEAL TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 87-18 (To allow a sign in excess of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Ci-A c Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. i DATK/T.iME: Monday, March 21, 1988, 7:00 PM APPLICATION MOBER: Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 APPLICANT/ ' A ELLAu: Rod Wilson Electra-Media LOCATION: 18255 Beach Boulevard (west side of Beach Boulevard, south of Taylor Drive - Wilson Ford) ZONE: C2 (Commercial) REQUEST: To allow an electronic reader board sign at a height of 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet with an area of- 400 square feet in lieu of 70 square feat. Sign is in excess of total number of signs allowed for the project. ENVIRONMENTAL TA U$: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15311, Class 11 of the California Environmental Quality Act. ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Main Street, Huntington beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are ;any further questions please call Pam Posten, Assistant Planner at 536-5271. I � i � , i I f r'ec\ct Mb --� January 27, 1988 Huntington Beach Civic Center ! � 2000 Main Street 1 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 RE: Citizens, householder, and taxpayers against the approval of Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 and Code Amendment No. 87-15. ATTN: Mike Adams - Planning Conmission The below signed residence and taxpayers and owner of properties in the inmediate area of Wilson Ford Company, located at 18255 Beach Blvd., Huntington Beach, do herein wish to voice their opinion in unison AGAINST the issuance of a pzrmit to erect said sign under Special Sign Permit pip. 87-18 and ace definitely against modifying the Code Amendment. No. 87-15. The concerned below named citizens have met in group sessions, on and off since receiving these both notices and have viewed the on-site of Wilson Ford and find that the so called "electronic reader board" not necessary. If, you would take into consideration the motor vehicle traffic on Beach Blvd., which would be hindered by the distraction of this sign and would cause nare accidents. .rust stop and think, the Ford sign that is now there is visible from a two block surrounding area. Now envision a sign 50 fett in the air with 400 square feet of space, Which would light up a mile area, this we do not need. Inciting our feelings and denial of the changing of Code Amendwnt No. 87-15, we wish to state it is not necessary for any modification or changing at this tima. Let us not make Beach Blvd. and Automobile Row such as you have now on Harbor Blvd. in Costa Mesa. We thank you for taking the time to read this at your hearing and sincerely hope that our feelings and recommendations are adhered to. Respectfully, Name yAddress W am viamh off, ,Jr L 77 18341 Pammy Lane, H. . r � Helga Wamhoff 18341 Panmy Lane, H.B. ,3 N«me Address l , / • ^f L G"lam•/ I t) L� ����� ���f ��r � . GI�1.�v �y .�- -7 B �S Page 2 of z Petition Members of The Planning Commission, . �. Let this petition serve as community opposition to the granting of the special sign permit 187-18 which enables Wilson Ford to erect an electronic sign 50 feet in height with a 400 square foot mesFage board. Our position does not derive from an anti-commerce viewpoint . The right to advertise is historically linked to constitutional free speech. However, in an area zoned residential , the right to be free from advertisement is just as critical to protect . A sign, the magnitude of the proposed one, will be visible from many of our homes and back yards. This is not a political battle but a quality life issue . Members of the commission, ask yourself if you'd like to look out the window of your home and see a 400 square foot electronic advertisement for automobiles. The undersigned homecwners and residents urge you to protect our quality of homelife and retain the existing limitations on commercial advertising . Name Address 2. 3 . 4 . IL CIL- y 9. ici:"G �E'—�:!-cis. l � ? 'y:� /Lz i�`,,•.� �i �,�� 10. :Lt ut i ��� ,L7c, t�.c-l4i / .� Ca f n�N•rtt Li , f{• /.� . 12 . 1 ,l f��C t Z f A�'�'l Ev1 I/ 1 i Name Address �/ r'39 / /;1j1VA % /rJ /7�vt� 'r 14 . C f I r3 � / i f+lI if I.l/ 2-tJ H u NT C fit' 16 . 7 P/PlIP o ""� HI-3 17 . C 2cetlf"v /Oply/ Ohl Ak L�, 7 1, I H. 2 0 .&W ktA 4,r, 22 23. T 2 4�'} � ��� 26. let 27 l�1 , i�r ,� ' . �`75flc'1-i1�'�;'� t7 28. `. �,, �� 7 4js i 13L,,c I,px. ..� I � ►> C, 0� 29 . ff L /JN�-�r�- ��; / JJyl 7x4 /1% 61 33 . J 34 , r 111*4 T 38 . t i Name A d d r e s I I IT" 15) 39 . 41A A )A. rlA 4 0 c c 41 . cz 42 . 43 . )\,c 1-Y 44 . y1l) 46 . & TIt -get 52. 53. -L) 5 4 ors c h p n-4 < 5 6 L-0 57 . � 7tG rCt�G �� 1�>��L'� 58 . 59. HJ34 60. 1-71413 62. - / 63 . -14A-f 4- 64 ) Ay?C- 65 . LL�c 300' Owner list: M�, N S L Lelbu Corti. 9' -10-085 A/P 1142-462-06 OOY6 S. Magnolia Iohen 8++1aheim,Cn.92804 7852 Arbor (:ir. 142-481-04 llunLingtun lleach,Ca.92647 W.l:iller 141-481-05 932-10-036 16732 Bench Blvd. '1'.4'.11ven 1, R. II Dev. IlUntington Bench,Ca.92647 876': S'allport. Dr, 8071 Slater Ave,114 107-601-41 Hunt :IigLon Beach,Ca.92646 ilunt.ingLon lleach,Cn.92647 107-601-47 142-4(31-06.07 932-10-087 II.I1. Parelch H. Qureshi A.Hen iLes 8636 Product:.lon Ave. STI, 9921 Mammoth Dr. 7856 Arbor Cir. San Delgo,Cn.91121 Huntiagton lieach,f:a. 92640 HuntLllJltun iieacit,Cn.92647 107-691-20 142-481-08 932-10-om Nerio Art Masao I.Newman D.Bradfor•d 9340 Bolsa Ave. 16312 Hnndalay Mr. 1854 Boa Vjrta Cit... Wr8Lm1nister,Cn.92683 IluntingLott Beach,Ca.92649 Co--;La PirSa,Ca.92626 107-691-22 142-481-09 932•-10-oat) Ford Lensing Development R.Ilan 1).G111111 P.O. Box 43336 P.O. Box 6094 7841 Arbor fair. Detriot,Ml 48243 Huntington lieaclt,Ca. 91615 Iluntingt.nu Benclt,Ca.92647 142-181-05 142-481-14 932-IO-ww Humbly Co. N V D,Nydinget' R.Tinkham 16761 Viewpoint Lrt• 16372 Thames UN. 7832 Arbor Mr. Huntington Itrnch,Cu.92647 HunLinutoil lleaclt.(:n. 92(j47 Ilunlinl;tcrn Nt•nch,(:rt.92G47 142-462-Ub 142-481-12 932-10-0ol American Nowr•s Realty T.Bernnt7 .I.Resclike 27777 Frnnkl in Rd. 2914 E. la tells Ave.1203 7841) ,Arbor Cir. Southfield,lll 48034 Orange,Ca.92667 11unUngton Bench,Ca.92647 142-462-09 932--10-81 932-I0-092 ABKO XXXI11 Inc. 1).Bet—Luan'I .1.Pack I. P.O. Box 1910 12562 Vale SL. N2:1 24611 Via Rana DeLriotJ11 48289 Garden Crove.,Ca.92641 M Toro.C.t.92630 i 14;?-481-(I1 q3•,-1(t-tl!i2 931-111-(193 " A.Lane I,.Sre 1 r)' I..Conkv 1hM Green St..N4 252621 A l dea CL. t . 1;IU3 frry� tnneI,untinEtcn leach�Ca.92641t Mission �ciJu, a.c);?i�t1 Nuru'tlk,(:.n90GS0 i 142-4H1-U2 9"l"l.-1(t-tiK')G. 912-10-094 1) (1(:A . . ,Lot' Ihurrte Prop. 18201 lvary Vow;t 1,11. 7830 Atbot, Cir•, 8071 Stnt+!c 414U Nuntinl;ttrn Ncnch,t:a.'J:'Ir�,�l (hint I III,Ioil hc•nc If.C.,192f,41 linnt OW,(Ou 14-M•6.0r.92647 14�-481-(►'t 03 10-01tr, A.serrn q32-1 )-U'J3 16G PI..IacuD�;rtt C Anderson �i1 Peale 1.n. MIR Arbor Cir• N340 Euclid St. Ililntin�;tun 1tarh,Ga.9:'b4') Hunt int;ton IMach,C.aQ201,7 Evuntnilt Val Iey.Ca.92708 f i r w ' 932;10-129 932-10-140 t Asltlee Investments .1.RoSer►stinl • 2855 F. C.onst Hwy 2511 E. ,Inrntson St. Coronn Del Mar,Ca.92626 AnnheIM,Ca.92806 932-10-130 932-10-141 .l.Foremnn .1.11e 1 l er 1790 Crestmont. 111. 16721 Viewpoint Ln. �} Costa Mesn,C.a92627 Huntington 13c. ch,Ca.9ZG47 C 932-10-131 932-10-142 A.Degenhardt D.Lorenxen 13272 Whitney Cir, 16725 Viewpoint l.n. Westminister,(I.02683 lluntingt:on Reach,Ca.O2647 932-10-112 932-10-144 L.Fri sble M.GnIIoway 4531 Shnron Dr. 270 S. Solonmon Dr. Ln nlma,Cn.90623 Annheim,cn.92807 932-10-133 932-10-145 A.Deal? J.Fvnns 16691 Viewpolt►t Ln. 16731 Viewpoint, Ln. Huntington Rench,Ca.92647 Iluntington Reach.Ca.92647 932-10-134 932-10-146 Y.Perdue II.WrIght. 218 Main St. 16731 Viowpulnt 1.n. 11110ington 11cach,C.n92648 Iluntington ReacliXti.92647 932-10-135 932-10-147 M.11hler J.Sylvn 16695 Vlt'wpnlnt hn. 15392 Andnman 1,11. Ihrntingtnn Itench,Cn.92647 Iluntington 0ench,C.a92649 + 932-10-136 932-10-148 C.Oathout J.Wright 16697 Viewpoint 1,11. 16092 Wlndemeir Ln. Huntington lleach,Ca.h2647 Iluntington Reach,C.02647 932-10-017 D.77tarnton 16711 Viewpoint Lit. Huntington R(%nch.Cfj.()26/,7 9 1-3z-1( t 3K A.Lopez 6881 Yin Carona Ihrntingtoti 11ear.h,C.ao2647 932-10-1'11) Duarte Prop 11071 Slat.pr AVe. N135 Ihint ington R(mr-h,Cn.O.2647 r i ' 932-10-107 c32-)U-118 932-1c7-09G Coon Aliond ,S.Anzi'g803 Arbor Cir. .c6654 Arbor Cir. 17,530 Santa I)oningo Mr. Ilutttin ton ilench,Ca.92G47 Fountian Vnlley,Ca.9210E3 Iluntington Ilectclt,Cn.ct2647 5 't 932-10-10E1 932-10-119 932-10-097 C.Clootett I,.Flnrkus M.Shaffer 16656 Arbor Cir. 15261 Victoria Ln. 7807 Arbor Cir. lluntini;ton 1lcach,('a.9Zfi1i7 Iluntington Ocnch,Cn.92647 Huntington Beaclt,(..n92047 � I 932-10-109 9:12-10-120 932-10-098 'EBrendm1l 1).Behrendt M.Hesbit 16682Arbor Cir. 16658 Arbor Cir. 7832 Arbor Cir. c Huntin Lon,lteach,Ctt.92G47 Iluntington Beach,C.n92647 flunLington hench,Cn.)2(i47 932-10-0110 932-10-121 932-10-099 F.Flohamed S.F1nrLinez W.Coshowe 16651 Viewpoint Ln. 7825 Arbor Cir. 5082 Loyola Ave. Huntington neach,C.02647 Westminister,Ca.92683 Iluntington BCr1CIt,Cn. 92647 11()0 932.-10-111 932-10-122 932- 0- 932 0-11e C.Smitlt B.Uiesott K.D16080 Arbor Cir. 1GG53 Viewpoint Ln. Y.O. Box 3202 IlUntington BBach,C.c192G47 Iluntington Bench,Ca- 92647 I Manhattan Bench,Ca.90266 932-10-1U1 932-10-112 932-10-0123 932-10-10 C.Hopkins R.Cect I63H Ilehhle Beach Ur. 1029 We::L and Way 7811 ArborCir. c t;untn ?te,a,Cs.926.26 Iluntington Bench,(;n.92647 Hoffman Iistntcs,lL GI11 )4 932-10--102 r32-10-113 932-10-124 F.Isola fl.Uui;nn R.Lavigne 1667'l Arbor Cir. 16657 Vlewpuittt. Lit. 21172 ii.•tnCC wi. c Ilunttngton Ileach,Ca. 92G47 IlUntington Beach,C.a92G<i7 Iluntington Ileach,C.n)2647 932-10-103 932-10-0114 932-10-125 0.1lubbard F.Parks R.Cochran 8B21 Arcel Mr. 8332 Tyler Cir. 16671 Viewpoint Ln. IlUntington Beach,C.01647 IlUntington Ileach,Ca.92647 lfunLingLun Beach,Ca. 92647 I 932-10-104 932-10-115 932-10-126 Y.perdue R.Weiss h.11radley 7817 Arbor Cir• 18185 SmAn Adelln Cir. 16673 Viewpoint Ln. Huntington Beach,Cn.92647 Fountain Va11r.y,C.02708 IlunLIligttill Beach,Ca. 92647 932-10-105 c)32-10-116 932-10-127 FI.RuyC L.Arnold C.Col'oner 7801 Arbor Cir. 8926 Yuba River Ave. 16675 Viewpoint Im. ` ! Huntington neach,Cn.02647 Fountain Valley,('a.92708 11unt,n(;ton Bench,Ca. 92647 I 932-10-128 932-10-106 932-10-117 T.RoberLs 'P,Ckeren T.Kramer 7unr+ Arbor Cir. 16652 Arbor Cir. 19761 Caprice Dr ' ! Huntington Ikn01,Cn,92647 IWntin);tun Beach,Ca.92647 Yorha I.inda,Ca.9i6H6 I P.Strnnd /1tl4"'C. !212 Park St., furnrr Kin1308 Shadow Oak Ln. IfUntkgton Bench,Ca92648 18381 Pammy Ln. IVJ-043-02 Ihcntinfton Beach.C.i.92648 Malvern,PA 19355 159-043-012 159-271-66 J.Arimond S.Ekstedi Bank Of America 1827i- Pammy Ln, 7836 Connie Ur. Trust Real Estnte iluntingtcn Beach,Ca,92648 Huntington Be,ilch ,Ca.92648 P.O. Box 60564 159-043-03 159-271-01 Los Angeles ,Cn.90051 159-271-67 J,.Cummings P.Albert A & Ei Investments LTA 18291 Pommy Ln. 7842 Connie [,it. 15300 Ventura Blvd.0320 Huntington Bench,Ca.92648 Huntington french ,Ca.92648 Sherman Oakg,Ca.91403 159-043-04 159-271-02 930-401-434 A.Moosn O.Rosales 18301 Pammy Ln, 7846 Connie Ln. y Huntington nench,Cn.92648 Huntington flectclt ,Qi.92648 159-043-05 159-271-03 CY L.Aroonsakool R.Stullrech C� 18311 Pammy Ln, P.O. Box 1786 Huntington Banc It,Ca.92648 llcrntington Beach .Cn.9264H n 159-043-06 159-271-94 O.PoIcarel l l Y.Pnrk 18321 Pammy Ln, 18212 ,Shnt•un Ln. Huntington Bench ,(,*a.92648 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-271-1t5 159-043-07 ne L.Hn W.Namhaff y y 18341 Pammy 1,11, 18202 Shnron Ln. Huntington Bench,Cn.92648 Efuntingtou trench ,t;a.92648 159-043-08 159-271-06 P.Contreran 1 18351 Pammy Ln, J.Bact.ok Iluntington Brach,(*a.92648 18196 Shnron Ln. , 159-043-119 fhtntfrtgton Bench ,Cn.92648 159-271-07 A.NE3gret e I).Ling � t 18391 PlImmy I,n, 18205 Shnron Ln. [(unLington BE`i]Ch,(;7.9z(,t,sl Iluntington fleirh .Cn.�92648 159-043 10 159-271-61 W.7aleski Iluntlnytun Village 7560 Vnlley Vista 17171 Brach Blvd. Yucca Valley.l'a.92284 Iilntington 110rrch.0a.92647 159-043-11 1i9-171-63 1 300' Owner List A/P Ir159-031-01 '� Wilson } , .Belden 11 Taylor Ave. � .8302 Prtmmy Ln jr�.-fG=2J, Iluntington IJench,Cn.92648 HuntIlML011 IlercG C.n92648 157-351-02 159-U41-U5 � K.tic Scott Cencer 11.Horowitz 9440 Cormick P. Bruckner Jr. 18312 Pammy Ln. 440 Siskin Ave. 217 S. Violet Ln. Iluntington Beaclr,C.n92648 Fountain Va11ey,Cn.9270$ Orange,Ca.92669 159-U+l-Ub 157-493-01 157-352-05 i L.Byhower j 1 1 18222 Beach Blvd. + C.Mc Rae Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 8002 Taylor St. U.Gaiefski 157-493-02 i Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 18322 Pammy Ln. 157-352-06 Illlntingtorr Beach,Ca.92648 159-041-07 A.Ve Grout A.Tomol 10072 Overhill Ur. 11063 Tilton Mr. G.Gaskins Santa Ana,Ca.92705 Fountiin Valley,Cn.52708 I 18342 Pammy Ln. i 157-493-03 J 157-352-07 IlUntington Bench,Cn.92648 159-041-08 ' R.Marquin i 18202 Beach Blvd, I II.Abel 640 Via Lido Nord '18352briglrt 1157-493-0n Bench,(n.92fiG8 I Newport Ileach,Ca.9'1663 18352 Pammy Ln. 1�7-493-U4 159-031-01 Illlntingtorr Beach,Ca.92648 159-041-09 U.Le•Beau L.Nlcholsnn j 8452 Riner Ave. 419 El Modena P. Nartignoni Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 ! New;ort Beach,Ca.92663 ! 18362 Pammy I.n. 157-493-14 1 159-031-22 � HUntinKtorr 13e11ch,Cn.92648 159-041-(11 U 1".Fingdalerro 1'.Uay I 8062 Kiner St. I 1188 Hummingbird Ln. i G.Ilerst Corona,Cn.91720 18372 P.,mmy Ln. Huntington Bench,Cn.92648 15)r -031-24 ' IlUntington Ilench Ca.92648 157-493-15 j 159-041--11 i f Pf.Yanagas i ']',Parks I( 1510 N. State College Blvd, j 18252 Pammy Ln. I M.Gnngeml Analreim,Ca.I2806 I Huntington Bench,Ca.92648 18382 Pammy Ln. 157-341-01 159-041-01 11Untington Beach,Ca.92548 519-041-12 M.Plunkeby 2090I Pioneer Blvd. � F.Alvarez 20901 Pf,L'n.r Blvd. I 18262 Pammy I.n. F.Alvarez on Iluntingt Beach Ca. 12648 18392 Pnmmy I,n. 157-341-U2 I 59-04 I-(12 U3 ' r ! Nllntingtor) Ilcach,Cn.9264H i i 159-041-1:1 Muth 8001 Taylor Ave. C.Blnzej Iluntington Bencb,Cn.92648 18292 T 7812 ammy hnn Huni;ton heach,Ca.�)?Gt+B 7812 ntf Taylor Ave. 157-351-01 r Huntington ISench,C.a92648[51-U41-U4 159-043-01 f t CERTIFIED PROPERTY OWNERS' LIST AFFIDAVIT i I 1. hereby certify that the attached list ontains the names and addresses of all persons to whom all property is assessed as they appear on the latest available assessment roll of the County of Within the area described on the attached application and for a distance of three hundred -34,91 feet from the exterior boundaries of the property described on the attached application. I certify under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct . (Signed) Name : Address: 55.2�Easrn_.Ioar�uin_____ Yo rba Linda,Ca.92686 Phone No. (SDa£davt) i Publish 7/8/88 NOT CE OEPLhIC MRIN AgPE&L TO THE PLANNING CQ�MM1,$I0W S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGI PER [IT IQ. 87-It3 NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2030 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to by heard relative to the application described below. pA.TZ: Monday, August 15, 1988 TIME: 7:00 P.M. fiLffl-am: Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 APPLICANT/APPELLANT: Rod Wilson/Electra Media hQCA=: 18255 Beach Boulevard (west side of Beach Boulevard, south of Taylor Drive - Wilson Ford) ,M: C2 (Commercial) PROPOBA .: to allow an electronic reader board sign at a height of 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet with an area of 400 square feet in lieu of 70 square feet. Sign is in excess of total number of signs allowed for the project . ENVIROj NM--,ETA=: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section . 15311, Class 11 of the Environmental Quality Act. ON PILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 gain Street, Huntington Beach, CA 92648, for inspection by the public. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are i,�vited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there ar, any further questions, please call Scott Hess, Associate Planner, at 16-5271 HUNTINGTON BEACh 7Y COUNCIL By: Alicia M. We, north City Clerk Phone (714) 536-540:. Dated 7/5/89 NOTICE OF Ptn3 C H"ARTRr. APPEAL TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 87-18 (To allow a sign in excess of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code { NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City CounrAl will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. QA!l�TFl.T3�I Monday, March 21, 1988, 7:00 PM AP13LiCATI B NUMAER; Special Sign permit No. 87-j8 APPLICANT/ APP--PEr�T: Rod Wilson Electra-Media LAC&N: 18255 Beach Boulevard (west side of Beach Boulevard, south of Taylor Drive -- Wilson Ford) C2 (Commercial) B '�IIE To allow an electronic reader board sign at a height Of 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet with ar, area of 400 square feet in lieu of 70 square feet. Sign is in excess of total number of signs allowed for the project. ENVIRONME : Categorically exempt u rsuant to 15311, Class 11 cftheCaliforniasectian Environmental Quality Act. A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the puhlic. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as Outlined above. If. them are any further questions please call Pam Posten, Assistant Planner at 536-5271. Authorized In Publish Advertisements of all ands including public notices by Decree of the Superior Court of Orange County, California. Number A•6214, dated 29 September, 1961• and A-24831. deed 11 June. 1963 STATE OF CALIFORNIA County of Orange 0 &K 40144 •a..n•we to'"on Pl�lIC tiiZTICE Or Irre Amdowl 'r W A r PO.1 +0 OKe c0l�—«inn trance Code to abw eW- uor►le reader b*&da.,Tha furs I ani a Citizen of the United States and a resident of re reader boards o alYcou"r� reader boards for City Caun-; the County aforesaid; I am over the age of eighteen . E KGv n o M E N T A L years, and not a party to or interested in the below STATUS: ;uatnia Ee vile�:nia entitled matter. I am a principal clerk of the Orange °`oN F M.A aovr a tea; opose0 request M on tee to Coest DAILY PILOT, with which is combined the i�he peparn+aril a: com-1 moony pevslo�rnsn+..taro NEWS-PRESS, a newspaper of general circulation, stain bt►eet, lhrntlnplon 4&QrrAC If, printed and published in the City of Costa Mesa, WS•,actlonpyMerbf+c •,NTE:7i►e oontlrwed pub• County of Orangb. State of California, and that a pMcwh�O arift two W Notice cf public Hearing Eladrr room to 1"em� a�t�n ��1�.1t1ifN 47.11 -- BMT�•19♦re aolndulad for wtr>R,.ttfM.00ei�cr t.aer�• of which copy attached hereto is a true and complete M SL ere Mlvited to allefid copy, was printed and published in the Costa Mesa. Paid fwe 109,find'AOM evMrw Newport Beach, Huntington Teach, Fountain Valley, (� ooi mthe NPPVAk'^ p oulow &bow..1111W9 j Irvine, the South Coast communities and Laguna we,any 4`r°a1i011r- 'AKIC WTIrE , Ps to Dww Beach issues of said newspaper for i r i me Assistant' Renner %awwnn op consecutive weeks to wit the issue(s)of ' A ' ::_ ' MYI1TIiM�ToN SRC APPEAL CP-, ' tseAt TM MANN" oewe INNIAL OF-. Ir-_" Ooad June 9 .��_ 198_� t � y Deify gaol her 4:�fll6 ��11017 _fT78t leech OroinuKe tootoo allow elac ronls• read. 198 •rip�t:. is HEftell� #MTNclrrtyM thf t*MlMgton beach WE 198 wrbfie foarc N�ft hold ham March 2t1�1t U In the cou"a chenWt a1 the 'Huntington Seeoh Chic — 198 Nam'i�iriQt Beach.on �rrti'a,on tars data and a1 t1►s Calf- Ians tidicated below to re- 19 8 ce ve crud romida pro e1e1M merits W as persons *to wlah to be heard ratarlve 10 the appiCW" described I declare, under penalty of perjury, that the °20,I ;;IMonday. foregoing is true and correct. pubft hOSA p coonllnurrd open hom W2 rb11, APPLICAT1t)N NUMBER !Code MNndrrrent•C7.1S Executed on June 9 , 198 !.•APPLICANT:WiteonFord at Costa Mesa, California. octra~APPELLANT: - t3actra Arec'ts REQUEST. To `amend Ankle 961 (stprt Cods) of / lire Huntington Flsectr Ordl- Signal e PROOF OF PUBLICATION i r Author11e0 to Publish Adve►uWnerNs 01 ell k,nds mNud►nq cree Pubic notices by De of Ihq Supw,or Court Win gs ange Counly. CS11fornle. Number A•6214. dated 29 September. t901. Rnd A•I4871,doled 1/Jtne. 1963 • rl STATE OF CALIFORNIA ��►►++ 1 County of Orange .� � I am a Citizen of the United States and a resident of PIl6[iC MgrICE the County aforesaid. I am over the age of eighteen tMfsNOT"F years, M�� not a party to or Interested in the below APftftOFI rr. entitled matter. I am a principal clerk of the OrsrVe cor mso s r Coast DAILY PILOT, with which is combined the of AMNXNftM ; NEWS-PRESS. a newspaper of gewsl circulation. fn..— : I�M.q orMYwree' . printed and published in the City of Costa Mess, County of Orange. State of California, and that a NOT1C 4 N H Notice of n il= k Ts.�n g ar 893Y -- arvstr Met n,e Itu+► eaeeh cay eanxs r, = pipti.rw, rr,tftcagy id i CC111rnb�r it !IN ►M�nt. on aeea,t�.+c.1:erttrr of which copy attached hereto is a true and complete ° M,Oten aeeehc Ceafornte,an copy, was printed and published In the Costa Mena, `"`d11"and at no"""' id tlkate0 btsaw f0►eoslre and Newport Beach, Huntington 8eaeh, Fountain Valley. No of aorwwer aat«,wnu e+,pwprrs Uft MIA to be Irvine, the South Coast communities and Lafluna n++►h.te��'„'a appe• tatbn dMSYlloed 4abw, ti.. DATArTIMEI Monda . Beach Issues of said newspaper for one MotC6 21.19",IPArt,1 r APPUCATN)M NLIMa>E1l consecutive weeks to wit the Ism(s)of C -ftAM&Wm@MNa--_ AFFUCANf:Wolin lord% �MMMG-It"WNW 'REQUI1157- •Tb'emind M CI* pet (Mr Codo.01 March 9 No Ise $ COW" to �t,o�ntc % VIRONMENTA* . 198 MATH, IE>a mW from.the.' cepforpla Enrtron"*ntet� OrAct;.: r-, aN,FtIL-:A' d 1M 198 r Eton of nib Dersglxt.:2Wp , aAain rnn dit . nt4i too 198 N"CIL CasfatW Nue 9 for per the rJubfo.. .. SofurB age iinvil d to "Id 11001*19. Via fora t 1!!e Wks a Du1WWd.+b". d litre awa .Any,turtt,rr gastlortt, PMeN W Porn POI11M.As- 1 declare, under penalty of perjury, that the atstMtPlAM4M&1536-Q2,1;- foregoing is true and correct. or. Akle puew. f> t�p��1109mys' 'Executed onMarch 9 . 19$ T1i62T at Costa Mesa, California. - - Signature -� PROOF OF PUOUCATION I r''''1 Publish 6/9/88 N=IC_FE OF COM UMDD PUBLIC MUM BPPE�s� OF THE ELAMINra C4' ISSIDN'S DENT& OF COPE AMEhMMENT NQ 87--15 (To amend the Huntington Beach Zoning Ordinance to allow electronic reader boards) f NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing Continued open from Mafgh_ 28. 19'1 in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described t below. DATE/TIM Monday, June 20, 1988, 7:00 PM, - public hearing continued open from 3/28/88 APpLICATjQ$ k-ME : Code Amendment No. 87-•15 - (Appeal) AnpLICA1�T: Wilson Ford APPELUNT: Rod Wilson Electra Media gIQU,ST: To amend Article 961 (Sign Code) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code to allow electronic reader boards. The Planning Commission has reviewed a draft ordinance for the proposed electronic reader boards for City Council consideration. ISN-VIROMg S ►TUS: Exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act. ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, for inspection by the public: The continued public hearings on the two appeals filed by Rod Wilson, Electra Media, relative to Special Sign Permit 87-18 and Special Sign Permit 87-19 are schedule3 for the i July 5, 1988 Council Meeting. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions, please call Diana Blaisure, Assistant Planner at 536-5271. HUNTINGTON BEACH CI'PY COUNCIL By: Alicia M. Wentworth City Clerk Prone (714) 536-5405 Dated 6/7/88 I. 5 Publish 7/8/88 NQ1ICA OF CONTIMMD PUHLIQ_ $ING ARPM OE THE PLANNING CQMMIENSION'S DENIAL OF CODE MENDj NO 87--15 (To amend the Huntington Beach Zoning Ordinance to allow electronic reader boards) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing cgntinued_open from June 20. 1288 in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 ,Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. + � D1� / IME: Monday, July 18, 1988, 7:00 PM, - public hearing 4 { continued open from 6/20/88 gpPL 0 (gWWF.$: Code Amendment No. 87-15 - (Appeal) A11PL Wilson Ford Ak'pEh Rod Wilson Electra Media REO!ZS To amend Article 961 (Sign Code) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code to allow electronic reader boards. The Planning Commission has reviewed a draft ordinance . for the proposed electronic reader boards for City Council consideration. F,gVIBONMEMI, STATUS: Exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act. " ON A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, for inspection by the public The continued public hearings on the two appeals filed by Rod Wilson, Electra Media,. relative to Special Sign Permit 87-18 and Special Sign Permit 87-19 are scheduled as follows: (Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 on August 15, 1988) and (Special Sign Permit 87-19 on August 1, 1988) ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application an outlined above. If there are any further questions, please call Scott Hess, Assistant Planner at 536-5271. HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL By: Alicia M. Wentworth City Clerk Phone (714) 536-5405 Dated 7/5/88 t 4 1 n � NOTICE OF SMLL,jC—MrAEjM APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF CODE AMENDMENT NO. 87-15 (To amend the Huntington Beach Zoning Ordinance to allow electronic reader boards) i NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public heaping in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beacn, California, on the I date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the s application described below. i pATEITIME: Monday, March 21, 1988, 7:00 PM f ARPLICATION BER: Code Amendment No. 87-15 APPLICANT: Wilson Ford APPELLANT: Rod Wilson Electri Media REQUES : To amend Article 961 (Sign Code) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance to allow electronic reader boards. EWLTRONMENTAL STATUS: Exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act. ON ULE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Mat ;. Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions please call Pam Fasten, Assistant Planner at 536-5271. i a NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING AP?EAL TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 87-18 (To allow a sign in excess of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code) NOTICE IS HERESY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing ;n the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application de3cribed below. DATE/TIME: Monday, March 21, 1988, 7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 APPLICANT/ AEPELLANT: Rod Wilson Electra-Media LOCh=: 18255 Beach Boulevard (west side of perch Boulevard, south of Taylor Drive - Wilson Ford) Z=: C2 (Commercial) BEQUEST: To allow an electronic reader board sign at a height of 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet wit"! an area of 400 square feet in lieu of 70 square Sign is in excess of total number of signs ,jwed for the project. ENVIROM ENTAL STAB; Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15311 , Class 11 of the California Environmental Quality Act. ON FILE; A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions please call Pam Posten, Assistant Planner at 536-5271. i J QTICE OF PUBLIC "ARM APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF CODE AMENDMENT NO. 87-15 (To amend the Huntington Beach Zoning Ordinance to allow electronic reader boards) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. i DATE/TIME: Monday, March 21, 1988, 7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Code Amendment No. 87-1.5 APPLICANT: Wilson Ford flPOELLANT: Rod Wilson Electra Media REQUEST: To amend Article 961 (Sign Code) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance to allow electronic reader boards. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act. ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions please call Pam Posten, Assistant Planner at 536-5271. I 1 ORDINANCE NO. r'�'j�7`( -A AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH AMENDING THE HUNTINGTON BEACH ORDINANCE CODE SECTIONS 9610.4, 9610.51 9610.9 AND 9610.10 TO ALLOW ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNS The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach does ur.dain as follows: SECTION 1. Section 9610.4 (a)and (h) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to read as follows: 9610.4. Prohibited signs. The following signs are prohibited within the City of Huntington Beach: '( .(a) Flashing, moving, pulsating, or intermittently lighted signs, including searchlights; except electronic readerboards and public service signs such as those for time and temperature. (h) Changeable copy signs, except electronic readerboards or theatre marquees. SECTION 2. Section, 9610 .5 (Permitted Signs-Schedule) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to incorporate into the schedule the following specifications pertaining to electronic readerboards, (0) COMMERCIAL Use of Sign Type Maximum Maximum Maximum Number Area Per Height �..._ - Sign Electronic Readerboards (See Section 9610.9(d)for specifications) i SECTION 3. Section 1610.9 (Miscelloneous Provisions) of the Huntington Beach ordinance code is amended to incorporate the following: (d) Electronic Readerboards. Electronic readerboards may be permitted subject to the approval of a conditional use permit by the Planning commission, approval of a planned sign program according to the provisions of section 9610.6 and approval of the Design Review Board according to the provisions of Article 985. Approval of electronic readerboards shall be subject to the following standards: (1) Permitted signs. Electronic readerboards may be free standing or wall type signs. The maximum number of electronic readerboards shall be one per site. The maximum sign area which includes an electronic readerboard shall be two hundred (200) square feet. The total , sign area shall be limited to twice the size of the electronic readerboard portion of the sign. The maximum height of an electronic readerboard sign shall be thirty--five (35) feet and shall have a minimum ground clearance of ten (10) feet. The electronic readerboard shall have cylinders, a shade screen and a photocell for reducing the intensity of lighting at night. The maximum measurable light output of the electronic readerboard shall not exceed 50-foot candles at the property line. (2 ) Location re uirements. The minimum lot frontage of the parcel shall be two hundred (200 ) feet. Electronic readerboards shall be allowed only on parcels abutting a freeway and on parcels abutting Beach Boulevard, excluding the portion along Beach Boulevard designated as a landscape corridor south of Adams to Pacific Coast Highway The minimum distance between electronic readerboards shall be one hundred fifty (150) feet. The minimum distance from an electronic readerboard sign to any residence shall be one hundred fifty (150) feet. The minimum distance from an electronic readerboard to the interior property line shall be one hundred (100) feet. (3 ) other standards. In addition to the electronic readerboard sign, one monument sign, maximum of seven (7) feet in height and a maximum of fifty (50) square feet in sign area, may be permitted and all other signage shall be brought into -- 2 - Y conformance with the provisions of this article. The hours of operation of any electronic readerboard shall be limited to 6:30 am to 10:30 pm. At least 10% of the message time, or any percentage deemed necessary by the city for emergency conditions, shall be used for public service announcements. Messages on an electronic readerboard shall be no faster than one message every four seconds and the minimum interval between messages shall be at least one second. Continuous motion of messages is not permitted. Light intensity changes (other than between day and night uses) are not permitted. SECTION 4 . Section 9610.10 (Definitions) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance code is amended as follows: (15) Electronic Readerboard: A changeable message sign consisting of a matrix of lamps which are computer controlled. (16) Flashing or animated sign: A sign intermittently reflecting light, or which has any illumination which is not maintained constant in intensity, color or pattern, except electronic readerboards and those for time and temperature. .wt.� (17 ) Freestanding sign: (Text unchanged) (18) Grade: (Text unchanged) (19 ) Grand opening: (Text unchanged) (20) Ground level : (Text unchanged) (21) Height of sign: (Text unchanged) (22) indirect illumination: (Text unchanged) (23) Industrial center: (Text unchanged) (24 ) Interior illumination: (Text unchanged) (25 ) Item of information: (Text unchanged) (26) Land development project: Text unchanged) (27) Monument sign: Text unchanged) (28 ) Logo: (Text unchanged) (29) Nameplate sign: (Text unchanged) (30) Nonconfarminq_�si n: (Text unchanged) 3 _ r (31) open house sign: (Text unchanged) (32) Political sign: (Text unchanged) (33 ) Projecting sign: (Text unchanged) (34 ) Real estate sign: (Text unchanged) (35) Roof sign: (Text unchanged) (36 ) Sign: (Text unchanged) (37) Sign copy: (Text unchanged) (38) Sign structure: (Text unchanged) (39) Site: (Text unchanged) (40) Site (street) frontage: (Text unchanged) (41) Subdivision directional sign: (Text unchanged) (42) Supergraphic: (Text unchanged) (43) Temporary__ sign: (Text unchanged) (44 ) Trespassing sign: (Text unchanged) (45) Wall sign: (Te::t unchanged) (46) Window sign: (Text unchanged) PAGE END .j 1 :r log SECTION 5. This ordinance shall take effect thirty ' days after its passage. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Counc: ', of the City of Huntington Beach at a regular meeting thereof held on the day of , 1988. Mayor NTTEST: APPROVED AS TO FORM: IX City Clerk Cit A for ey 4t REVIEWED AND APPROVED: I TIATED AND APPROVED: , City Adihinistrator Direcitot of community D lopment I i be -- 5 a { ! il t ORDINANCE NO. C6`%7 l -B AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH AMENDING THE HUNTINGTON BEACH ORDINANCE CODE 1 SECTIONS 9610.41 9610.51 9610.9 AND 9610.10 TO ALLOW ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNS The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach does ordain as follows: SECTION 1. Section 9610 .4(a)and (h) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to read as follows: 9610.4 Prohibited signs. The following signs are prop bited within the City of Huntington Beach: (a) Flashing, moving, pulsating, or intermittently lighted signs, including searchlights; except electronic t.-- readerboards and public service signs such as those for time and temperature. (h) Changeable copy signs, except electronic readerboards or theatre marquees. SECTION 2. Sectiva 9610.5 (Permitted Signs-Schedule) of the Hutington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to incorporate into the schedule the following specifications P9 ertainin to electronic readerboards. (b) COMMERCIAL Use of Sign Type Maximum Maximum Maximum Number Area Per height Sign Electronic Readerboards (See Section 9610.9(d)for specifications) rs'.x `. .. ♦ .. ..1 ... Y.... .. l`.•�Iaatiij.C`':.�iSXY Sa,'"..i.l Y.`rt l.� ..��. SECTION 3 . Section 9610.9 (Miscellaneous Provisions) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to incorporate the following: (d) Electronic Readerboards. Electronic readerboards may be permitted subject• to the approval of a conditional use permit by the Planning Commission, approval of a planned sign program according to the provisions of section 9610 .6 and approval of the Design Review Board according to the provisions of Article 985. Approval of electronic readerboards shall be subject to the following standards: (1) Permitted signs. Electronic readerboards may be free standing or wall I type signs. The maximum number of electronic readerboards shall be one per site. The maximum sign area which includes an electronic readerboard shall be seventy (70) square feet. The total sign area shall be limited to twice the size of the electronic readerboard portion of the sign. The maximum height of an electronic readerboard sign shall be fifteen (15) feet. The electronic readerboard shall have cylinders, a ,J shade screen and a photocell for reducing the intensity of lighting at night. The maximum measurable light output of the electronic readerboard shall not exceed 50-foot candles at the property line. (2 ) Location Location requirements. The minimum lot frontage of the parcel shall be four hundred (400) feet. Electronic readerboards shall be allowed only on parcels abutting a freeway and on parcels abutting Beach Boulevard, excluding the portion along Beach Boulevard designated as a landscape corridor south of Adams to Pacific Coast Highway The minimum distance between electronic readerboards shall be one hundred fifty (15t ) feet. The minimum distance from an electronic readerboard sign to any residence shall be one hundred fifty (150) feet . The minimum distance from an electronic readerboard to the interior property line shall be one hundred (100 ) feet. (3) Other standards. In addition to the electronic readerboard sign, one monument sign, maximum of seven (7) feet in height and a maximum of fifty (50) square feet in sign area, may be permitted and all other signage shall be brought into 2 - conformance with the provisions of this article. The hours of operation of any electronic readerboard shall be limited to 6:30 am to 10:30 pm. At least 10% of the message time, or any percentage deemed necessary by the city for emergency conditions, shall be used for public service announcements. Messages on an electronic readerboard shall be no faster than one message every four seconds and the minimum interval between messages shall be at least one second. Continuovs motion of messages 1.3 not permitted. Light intensity changes (other than between day and I night uses) are not permitted. SECTION 4 . Sect•ion 9610. 10 (Definitions ) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended as follows: (15 ) Electronic Readerboard: A changeable message sign consisting of a matrix of lamps which are computer controlled. (16 ) Flashing or animated sign: A sign intermittently reflecting light, or which has any illumination which is not maintained constant in intensity, color or pattern, except electronic readerboards and those for time and j --, temperature. f wj ( 17 ) Freestanding sign: (Text unchanged) (18 ) Grade: (Text unchanged) (19 ) Grand opening: (Text unchanged) (20 ) Ground level: (Text unchanged) ( 21) Height of sign: (Text unchanged) (22 ) Indirect: illumination: (Text unchanged) (23) Industrial center : (Text unchanged) (24 ) Interior illumination: (Text unchanged) (25 ) Item of informatics: (Text unchanged) (26 ) Land development project: Text: unchanged) (27 ) Monument sign: Text unchanged) (26 ) Logo: (Text unchanged) i (29 ) Nameplate sign: (Text unchanged) (30 ) Nonconforming sign: (Text unchanged) i 377 _ t l (31) men house sign: (Text unchanged) (32) Political sign: (Text unchanged) (33) Projecting sue: (Text unchanged) (34) Real estate sign: (Text unchanged) (35) Roof sign: (Text unchanged) (36) jqn: (Text unchanged) 1 (37) Sign copy: (Text unchanged) (38) Sign structure: (Text unchanged) (39) Site: (Text unchanged) (40) Site (street) frontage: (Text unchanged) (41) Subdivision directional sign: (Text unchanged) (42) Su2ergra2hic: (Text unchanged) (43) Temporary sign: (Text unchanged) i (44 ) Trespassing sign: (Text unchanged) (45) Wall sign: (Text unchanged) (46) Window sign: (Text unchanged) i I PAGE END 4 SECTION 5. ThI4 ordinance shell take effect thirty days after its passage. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at a regular meeting thereof held on the day of , 1988. Mayor ATTEST: APPROVED AS TO FORM: City Clerk city Attpr ey G— -433 REVIEWED AND APPROVED: I�ITIATED AND APPROVED: -- f �Z� A4�4� " :� City Administrator Jttfc or of Community evelopment I i be 5 - y 110TICE OF EM11IC HEARING APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DEIIIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 87-19 (To allow a sign in excess of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will � Y hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE/TIME: Monday, March 21, 1988, 7:00 PM APPLIr,ATION NUMBER: Special Sign Permit No. 87-19 APPLICANT/ APPELLANT: Rod Wilson Electra-Media LQCATI!N: 16751 Beach Boulevard (west side of. Beach Boulevard, north of Terry Drive - Huntington AMC) IM: C2 (Commercial) REOTJEST: To allow an electronic reader board sign at a height of 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet with an area of 40C square feet in lieu of 70 square feet. Sign is in excess of total number of signs allowed for the project. ENVIRONMENTAL ST& : Categorically exempt pursuant to Section + 15311, Class 11 of the California Environmental Quality Act. ON' FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, For inspection by the public. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions please call Pam Posten, Assistant Planner at 536-5271. i l _ ..;wr Planning Comm. Recommendation (Legislative Draft) ORDINANCE NO. .&J - A AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON LEACH AMENDING THE HUNTINGTON BEACH ORDINANCE CODE SECTIONS 9610.4, 9610.51 9610.9 AND 9610.10 TO �J ALLOW ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNS i� The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach does ordain as follows: SECTION 1, Section 9610 .4 (a)and (h) of the Huntington leach Ordinance Code is amended to read as follows: 9610.4 Prohibited signs. The following signs are prohibited within the City of Huntington Beach: (a) Flashing, moving, pulsating, or interm.ttently lighted signs, including searchlightel except jj . �gugjc adethoar a jgj public service signs such as those for time and temperature. (h) Changeable copy signs, except &L&Sj=ic raadeLk&A&&gdSsoC theatre marquees. SECTION Z. Section 9610.5 (Permitted signs-Schedule) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to incorporate into the schedule the following specifications pertaining to electronic readerboards. (b) COMMERCIAL Use of Sign Type Maximum Maximum Maximum Number Area Per Height sign EZ ctten c B! derboar te 910 .9(dlfor soec is tip ,IQ / . 11 .. } . it 1 • • 1111 • 1 - • • • �� - � cll *. • 1 • • • j • : • • • • • • 1 ,s •U4 • • • 11 • • 1 . • • 1 1 if It 11 1 � - • • } • • . . . . � • - 1 • 1 - - � 11 , 11 11 Ill • e • �C 11t^i�7ia•JIR • • • r • - 1 - 1 • 1 . / - u u u • 1 1 - ! • 1 9- I1 . Il 11' • • 1 • • • 1 - • • • - 1 - 1 • • 1 • - 1 " i • • - 1 • c • • • • } • � • � c 1 • _ 1 II 1 p 11 • = 1 � • 11 = } • 1 _ • • ♦ • , • r • FI • ' / / • • 1 1 1 • • 1 • MM . • • • • 1 ■ • 1 } I r ■ 1 1 jtp;erg. standards_. �d li t i -t the p C P maw yej�L�%UA a n hiahtn �a max mu of T c� o &holler 9 ii o10t At oea f� deer,�ed necess_ U by t e c ty f� g n.( spaditions, shy .„c..e.�.�.s��� yna�.a�rz k&-=9 O r A 1 C �12 9 y, C Q P.12ctr2nic hall be Ro ter than one message ey jKy f2gL.sego ds and the minimum i nterval_ bPilwoon MP a0ps e nt n ous , on 0 Light s s t d. SECTION 4 . Section 9610.10 (Definitions) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended as follows: F& ic eadp A ch ng able , .JUALj;.S..t, _.P, iu +1'�s wh i cktr�,re co�ntx ,gd,� XX�X � Flashing or animated sign: A sign intermittently reelecting light, or which has any illumination which is not maintained constant in intensity, color or pattern, except gJAer.0 R �oaXdms and those for time and temperature. XX01 JUZ Freestanding sign: (Text unchanged) XXXX . Grade: (Text unchanged) Grand opening: (Text unchanged) XX81 Ground level: (Text unchanged) XZOX Height of sign: (Text unchanged) Indirect illumination: (Text unchanged) Industrial center: (Text unchanged) Interior illumination: (Text unchanged) ,Cx�X �t5•Z Item of information: (Text unchanged) Lana development project: Text unchanged) XXoX Lai Monument sign: Text unchanged) 3 �iZ7X .L � Lo o: (Text unchanged) Igo; Nameplate sign: (Text unchanged) lip; Nonconforming sign: (Text unchanged) M; open house sign: (Text unchanged) Ml Political sign: (Text unchanged) XXxX Project ng sign: (Text unchanged) ;( AI Real estate sign: (Text unchanged) XUX jam, Roof aign: (Text unchanged) sign: (Tex unchanged) Simon copy: (Text unchanged) Sign structure: (Text unchanged) , go; Site: (Text unchanged) Igo; Site (street) frontage: (Text unchanged) „AJJ Subdivision directional ei_gn: (Text unchanged) �.. supergraphic: (Text unchanged) loll Tem2orary sign: (Text unchanged) XX�7X �, Trespassing sign: (Text unchanged) XXXX Wall sign: (Text unchanged) Window sign: (Text unchanged) PAGE END i 1 00 } SECTIO14 5. This ordinance shall take effect thirty , days after its passage. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at a regular meeting thereof held on the ...._.__r_ day of , 1988. i Mayor ATTEST: APPROVED AS TO FORM: 7-� City Clerk REVIEWED AND APPROVED: ITIATED AND APPROVED: L City Administrator 9yor of Co munity `' evelopment ! ' r , , .�� be ' Planning Staff Recommendation (Legislative Draft) ORDINANCE NO. jR [jjj_ '-0 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH AMENDING THE HUNTINGTON BEACH ORDINANCE CODE SECTIONS 9610.41 9610.50 9610.9 AND 9610. 10 TO ff ALLOW ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNS 1 i The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach does ordain as follows: SECTION 1. Section 9610.4 (a)and (h) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to read as follows: 9610.4 -Prohibited si ns. The following signs are prohibited within the city of Huntington Beach: (a) Flashing, moving, pulsating, or intermittently lighted signs, including searchlights; except jlerstrgUL& public service signs such as those for time and temperature. (h). Changeable copy signs, X�iXd1� 1�d/JXfxX'1�1(X1� except gl.e-c ,r nib re d.�: oar s or theatre i marquees. l SECTION 2. Section 9610.5 (Permitted Signs-Schedule) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to . I incorporate into the ochedule the following specifications pertaining to electronic readerboards. (b) COMMERCIAL Use of Sign Type Maximum Maximum Maximum Number Area Per Height Sign tropic RRaQgr_,boair" �S�� :,°n 9 o p oniL _ 1 _ • II • - l1 •, ' • Illy - • 1 ? • • • • •_ [ 1 - � 1 1 II"i . ..- ll 1 u• • - ! - r - • • t 1 • 1 • • • • [ • [ _ . ! w - ' 1 1 • 1 • 1 1 i tll ' ! • 1 1 1 1I U • - JU MO. • U [ r ! • r • • tim r in additioo the e, c . 2oig readerboard siar�. Ono mcar t gr(,�a mttm gf skvep ill geet in height Ua as �off4 , rq +arg, facet in sign are__a._ mati_b_e &�n�nwrmi_t d and 1 other M ' ae shall b br ought int .... �1�. � ' ...,� nce XL j orbs... on 2L uY.Rustrureaderboard ° 1 At Least 10% of the gsi; etim ;, °,ter a_n. e, r�,�ce� t�LcUe ` Cjor gmgraLUX goad C 0 hg used Luz Rublic yirsQ anno ceme ts. &Msaa��es Rp ijil jjlect�onic "&rhnar�d, lhalll be no j faste an onSmen Age QMery four �8�„nd the,�mini terval betwe� ,ea, g,2gs, jhall be at least °ne sEconci. o.�om�s.vs�a Cohtin clip, motion of messages is not germ tted. -Qes ohe.: �en daX and SECTION 4 . Section 9610 . 10 (Definitions) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended as follows: RIR&Usoj� bZg i at s w c �r�omouter controlled., XX�X Flashing or animated sign: A sign intermittently ref.iecting light, or which has any illumination which is not maintained constant in intensity, color or pattern, except , . ectrcanf ,derbo rds and those for time and temperature. j Freestanding s_i4n: (Text unchanged) �(XpX Grade: (Text unchanged) I Grand opening: (Text unchanged) XX�a' Ground level: (Text unchanged) ,(,Zjdd Height of sign: (Text unchanged) .IxXX Indirect illumination: (Text unchanged) �XXX Jult Industrial center: (Text unchanged) �X1iX Interior illumination: (Text unchanged) ZZXX Item of information: (Text unchanged) ,IX�X Land developnent project: Text unchanged) Xxsy Monument sign: Te-,A unchanged) F_a )7 _ 3 Logo: (Text unchanged) ' � l Nameplate sign: (Text unchanged) Nonconforming si.grn,: (Text unchanged) AAOJ Open house sign: ('Text unchanged) Political sign: (Text unchanged ) IOU Projecting sign: (Text unchanged ) I'M Real estate sic),n: (Text unchanged) ,(M S„ Roo_[ sign: (Text unchanged) flo; Sign: (Text unchanged) MI Sign copy: (Text unchanged) IM Sian structure: (Text unchanged) I M Site: (Text unchanged) Site �ratreet ) frontage: (Text unchanged) Subdivision directional oj.rLt: ('Text unchanged) Supergraphic: (Text unchanged) Temporary sign: (Text unchanged) Trespassing sign: (Text unchanged) XK� Wall sign: (Text unchanged) Window sign: (Text unchanged) I PAGE END i I I F- a ;.-rvz SECTION 5 . This ordinance shall cake effect thirty 1� days after its passage. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of ffantington Beach at a regular meeting thereof held on the day of , 1988 . Mayor ' IATTEST: APPROVED AS TO FORM: City Clerk C�C Attgrney C _ra REVIEWED AND APPROVED: I ITIATED AND APPROVED: .003 City Administrator Dir or o ' Community tobevelopment } i j be r I � 5 - huntington beach department of community development STAff i FQORI TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: May 3, 1988 SUBJECT: CODE AMENDMENT NO. 87-15 ,I� CANT: Wilson Ford 18255 Beach Boulevard Hunt. Beach, CA 92647 Rod Wilson 1208 Poinsettia Avenue Manhattan Beach, CA 90266 (t$4UEST: To amend the Sign Code, Article 961, to allow electr..-nic readerboard signs . Staff recon.m.3nds the following: r•� (a) Reaffirm previous action and recommend to the City Council denial of Coda Amendment No. 87--15. (b) Review and recommend suggested criteria list to be included with . or0li snce should the City Council approve Code Amendment No. A'1--15 . 2,.0 -s&.mErAi-inrmgmUN: Code Amendment No. 87--15, a request to allow electronic readerboard signage by amending the list of prohibited signs in t~c.Ae Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, was denied by the Planning Commission with 1 findincas on February 2, 1988. The Planning Commission appointed a subcommittee to further study thu issue and look into the possibility of al)owina electronic readerboards in return for minimizing existing signage. The subcommittee met and drafted a list of possible restrictions which could be applied to electronic readerboards. The City Council on March 2G, 1988 (acting on an appeal of the Planning Commission's denial) continued the item to June 20, 1988, and referred the code amendment to the Planning Commission for evaluation and recommendation upon an alternative ordinance that would allow i electronic readerboards to certain location and design standards as recommended by the Planning Commission Subcommittee (Attachment No. 1) and Department of Public Work's (Attachment No. 2) . Also, at the City Council meeting, the Council requested further criteria for the code amendment as follows: A(Rk I .�►A A•F M.t9C (1) Req,iire photo cell for reducing intensity of lighting at night. (2) Maximum sign area should be 200 square feet. (3) All readerboard signs should conform with State regulations (CalTrans) . (4) Define what arterials would be appropriate. 3.0 ISSUUE$ AND ANALYSIS: � � Staff has polled all Orange County cities and found very few which allow electronic readerboard signage. There are a few existing non-conforming signs and others which have been allowed by variance. ', Some of these signs are located on surface streets. Generally,, the larger, taller signs are situated to attract freeway passers-by. 1 Staff has compiled a list of all the electronic signs in ©range � County and many outside of the County along with a locational reap. In addition, a slide show ha been piepared which clearly illuctratos the range of signage Huntington Beach would be open to should the proposed code amendment be approved. Staff continues to recommend denial of the code amendment for the same reasons stated in previous staff reports. Should the Planning Commission wish to recommend to the City Council a list of specific criteria for electronic readerboard aignage for a modified code amendment, staff has included a matrix comparing the subcommittee's recommended criteria with that of staff. The matrix includes issues which, it addressed, could mitigate safety and aesthetic concerns. � - However, approval of the proposed code amendment, even with strict � criteria, would allow electronic readerboard signage which could be I approved by special sign permit for signs in excess of the criteria. ! • ' f I The following is a comparison of the Planning Commission Subcommittee recommendation and staff's recommendation based upon surveys of other city requirements and what would be compatible within the City of Huntington Beach. CPI V � • Staff Report - 5/3/88 -2- (0512d) M 1 i COMPARISON MATRIX OLr RECOMMENDED �1 CRITERIA FOR ELECTRONYC RZADERBOARD SIGNAGE i Subcommittee Staff g .Reccgmmgndatign $%.'QMendation A. Entitlement for CUP/PSP CUP & PSP with Design processing ERB Review Hoard and Public Works approval B. Locational Limited to major: Limited to Beach Blvd. Criteria arterials except PCH (except landscape and landscape corridors corridor) and freeway (see Attachments 6 & 7) frontage C. Min. Lot Frontage 200 ft. Min. 400 ft.'* D. Min, distance to 150 ft. 150 ft. residential E. Min. distance to 1,00 ft. 100 ft. interior property lino F. Min. distance Greater than 200 ft. 150 ft. between ERR signs I G. max. 8 of ERB signs n/a One � per site H. Max. sign height 35 ft. with 10 ft. 15 ft.* min. ground clearance 1. Max. sign area 275 sq.ft. max. - 70 sq.ft.* sign area limitod to twice the ERB portions Council recomrrondation: max. 200 sq.ft. J. zntensity/Glare Cylinders, shade screen same and photocell for reducing intensity of lighting at night. ! K. Other signage All signage brought into All signage brought on-site conformance, max, into conformance* allowable wall signage reduced to 100 sq.ft. , temporary banners per- mitted for two 15-day periods. * Consistent with current Huntington Beach sign code requirements for all types of freestanding signs. **Ca1T.rans requirement n/a = not addressed Staff Repott - 5/3/88 -3- 0201(0512d) i Subcommittee Staff q�e gq�RlriN€115�.8Stl] Reed endation L. Message criteria 1. Message changes No faster than 1 message Same every 4 ssconds** 2. Min. interval 1 second** Same between Messages 3. Continuous Not permitted** Same motion 4. Light intensity Not permitted** Same ' changes (other than between day and night uses M. Hours of Operation n /a 8:00 AN-10:00 PM s N. Public Service n/a 10% of messages time Announcement or as deemed necessary by the City for emergency conditions. i . * Consititent :jith current Huntington Beach sign code requirements � for all types of freestanding signs. ** CalTrans requirement n/a R not addressed 4.0 RECOWZNDATION: Staff recommends the Zoliowing: (a) Reaffirm previous action and recommend to the City Council denial of code Amendment No. 87-15. (b) Review and recommend suggested criteria list to be included with ordinance should the City Council to approve Code Amendment No. 87-15. Staff Report - 5/3/88 -9- (0512d) '" ystr 1 y A_ TTACHME_ITS: 1. Planning, Commiss ion Subcommittee recommendations presented to City Council on March 28, 1988 2. Department of Public Work's Recommendation 3. ERB Signage Requirements by City 9 . Samples of Existing Electronic Readerboards in orange and Los Angeles Counties 5. Electronic Readerboard Signage Map 6. Map of arterials 7. Map of landscape corridors B. City Council minutes dated March 28, 1986 9. RCA dated March 21, 1988 10. Petition in Opposition to Code Amendment No. 87-15 and Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 11. CalTrans Criteria Submitted by Mr. Wilson SH:PP:kla f •A,Y i • Staff Report - 5/3/88 -5- (0512d) March 21 , 19SH Submitted to: Honorable Maynr and City council Submitted by: Planninq Commission Subcommittee: Electrical Reader Hoards / Prepared by: Kent M. Pierce, Subcommittee Chairman Subject: Code Amendment No. 87-15 STATEMENT OF ISSUE: I � On February 2, 1988 Planning Commission recommended denial of Code Amendment No. 87-15. Several Commissioners expressed a desire to explore -possible conditions which could permit and control electrical re?aac-r� oa`r3`3'ttfnv-. AAm`ofTon car"r i"ed c:_tabl is Ff ng a su6commr ttec 'to stb"dy""thc� i ssue anti make rvrumni•nd,at inns. The rol 1 owi nq me-mlivrs were appointed by the Chairman: i Kent M. Pierce, Planning Commissioner , Suhrommittev Chairman Victor Leipziq , Planninq Commission Chairman, member � Ken Bouqu i gnon , Planning Commissioner , mernbc?r Rod Wilson," Electra-Mpdia, member Eric P. Weber , Resident of Pammy Lane, member The Subcommittee met on Mare-h 1 , 198A and start issued minutes. Subsequently several members had second thouhtits or additional input. A second Subcommittee► meeting was held with all members present on March 15, 1988. 1 RECOMMENDAT;ONS: The following report/recommendations from the subcommittee were the result of mutual consent of the whole, PUT WERE NOT PRESENTED To, DISCUSSED, NOR APPROVED nY THE PLANNING COMMISSION. General Findings: It could be etrimt._ntal..to,_ businesses located in Huntington Beach not 1 a. t)ermi't signagr. (undi�r"sE ricl controls) incorporating ls) the new technology--and still emccrq'_inq technology---of electric reader hoard slgns that arts permitted in other jurisdictions. The subcommitLet, felt that by insistinq on the following conditions for allowing electric render board that the current sign blig:ttage on Beach Blvd. and other major arterials within the city would he vastly improved upon--as well as protecting the environment of adjacent residents. �--" 1 Gl.. The, sign cods• of the City of Huntington Beach may permit electrical reader board signs subject to the following :;puc•i ( ic conditions: 1 . ubtaininq it Conditional Use Permit and approval of a I'l.antiod Nigr Program. 1 . Maximum sign height limited to 35 feet with not less than 10 fvvt ground clearance. 1. Cylinders and shady_► screens shall be required to tnrnrnaizo glaro. 4. Minimum separation between reader board to residential pr upor t y of 150 I aret . . .1 . Mi n i main for f ront aqv of 200 (vot roqui red. Sign shall be loc�ited a minimum of 100 feet from the property line., 5 . Maximum sign area limited to twice the .electrical � rvador hoaro portion, not to exceed 176 sq. ft. total ( includes reader board dnd other signage) . � 0. Thi- appruvi-d Plan Sitin Program shall provide all other ;iynt; an sits► tilaal1 bc• brought Into conformance with sign rode includinq thy► number of signs. No freestanding signs shra l I ha- is l l owod in addition to reader board sign except ono l toot high monument sign. Reduce maximum allowable will signagv to 100 sy. it . and eliminate opportunity to have balloons, banners, and other temporary signage ► � (except that balloons, banners, and other temporary signage mdy tit? permittod for up to two fifteen day periods) . Also that if parking lot lighting spills onto adjacr-nt residential properties, it shall be hooded to prevent intrusion into adjacent residential properties. 7. Electrical reader board signs shall be limited to major artprials with the exception of Pacific Coast Highway, a svoniv highway dnd existing landscape corridors. ADDITIONAL HECQMMENUATIUNa: 1'hf- suUcommittee felt strongly that whatever the decision rr-garding electrical reader board signs the following code .ama-ndniont should bey made: 1 . Whenover a building permit is issued that would add � more than 10* to tr.,:� square footage of existing j improVoments, that a Plan sign Program shall be approved to bring oxintinq signagr up to current code. The above coupled wirh a strong enforcement policy of the ox i st i nq s i(tn c•udes will qo a tong wiry to end s.i qn Olight.agp. 1a� ��a i APRIL 28 . 1988 TO: PAN POSTEN i FROM: BRUCE H. GILM£P. SUBJECT.• CHANGEABLE MESSAGE SIGNS AFTER REVIEW OF THE MATERIAL4 FORWARDED AND, FIELD REVIEW OF .� SIMILAR INSTALLATIONS ELSEWHERE . THE FOLLOWING COMMENTS SEEM APPROPRIATE: 1 . THE ITEMS IN THE FIRST MEMORANDUM STILL PERTAIN. 2. TEE SUBJECT OF "GLARE" FROM THE DRIVER'S VIEWPOINT SHOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL CONSIDERATION. SPECIFICALLY, A MEASURABLE MAXIMUM LIGHT OUTPUT E. G. , 5 FOOTCANDLES, I SHOULD BE INCORPORATED INTO ANY REGULATION ADOPTED FOR THESE DEVICES . 3. THE TECHNICAL ABILITY TO ACCESS THE PUBLIC SERVICE MESSAGES IN "REAL TIME" , I .E. DISPLAY MESSAGES WHENEVER THE NEED IS PRESENT . SHOULD BE DEMONSTRATED AND PART OF THE REGULATIONS IMPOSED ON THE DEVISES INSTALLED . i PLEASE DON' T HESITATE TO CONTACT ME IF I CAN BE OF ANY ADDITIONAL ASSISTANCE . cc: LES EVANS JAMAL RAHIMI I I A7 EPARTMENT COtNMUNiCATIOIV INTER•D Pam Post�:n •From Bruce Gilmer To public works Planning - Suhlect I1luminated Signs Date January 27, 1988 . Changeable Messages In response to the submittal for a code amendment pertaining to the installation of changeable message electronic illuminated signs, the following comments are submitted ::or use in considera- tion of the amendment. From a traffic safety perspective, certain common sense resonsc_' Lions must be placed on such installations•. should address concerns regarding the following general categories: 1. Animation - designed to catch the viewers attention. 2 . Duration of Messa t of the message 9ete affording ewer adequate time to absorb the x 3• Between Message Interval - indicating a change. 4 • intensity of Illumination •- primarily a night time concern regarding distracting or blinding glare. Each of these categories present a potential for removing the drivers attention from the roadway. ' Each should therefore be " I the subject of the proposed code modification to provide i.he appropriate minimum or maximum value allowed, e.g. the message time less than five (5) shall not be displayed for a period of _ __ _ .. ._.._.. _ .__ _ . . . . . ' . seconds* . As we have discussed, other agencies have-developed codes and guidelines pertaining to, these signs: Using the experience 'of , those agencies, adoption of• ttie 'appropriate sections 'of those = codes for our situation on arterial . highwiys Would seem' to be 3' useful. I 'will bc� ,available 'to 'review any 'section t s) 'you would �j�' • :' propose, if such a review i.s ;needed. BHG:lw ` cc: Les Evans Jamal Rahimi ' - :.�:�• ' '�� '••.L.a.�.f,• •�l �•_�iy���.��tr��1►e�� w �i ~�S J �~it�1«•i••S���.a��'�.,,� t.Y� • � �� •"J r.. "IbD Jill♦ iC.Y:.w+ Q ' A• +r._, '`L� •ii�•• I�/ w1,`/+�}S.• r• ,�'� '���~*y'u ah+ • ��••1 ••`7,�i.�L�.J4�. �r//�J► .Z•t• .•.��.Y'�« • � k1.i•t'.jrt�r.t 7^Il'.•.•�`i•�1 • �:�i:T..� �.���. '�`;a��:.rr.�/�•..ti..i�..•�1�J�:T-y....� � V- }•..��% �• w' h. f ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNAGE REQUIREMENTS BY CITY ORANGE COUNTY ERB Signs Prohibited How ERB city by Code Existing Signs Aim.Per ;tte Anaheim No Anaheim Toyota Building Travel Lodge permits Pac-Tel Anaheim Hilton Anaheim Convention Center Embassy Suites Brea Yes None Buena Park Yes House of Imports Variance Costa Musa Yes Harbor Plaza Planned Sign Program Fairgrounds Not under City jurisdiction Cypress Yes None City Coancil Fountain Yes None --- Valley Fullerton No None CUP Garden Grove Yes Orange County Volvo Approved with condition: 1 message change/ 24 hour period Irvine Yes None Laguna Beach Yes None Design Review Board La Habra Yes None Variance/CUP La Palma Yes None City Council Los Alamitos Yes None Planned Sign Program Newport Beach No None --- Oraage No Rehabilitation Institute Design Review {_ Board 1 Placentia Yes None Variance .C2q { ELECTRONIC READERBQARD SIGNAGE REQUIREMENTS BY CITY (Continued) ERB Signs Now ERB Prohibited Sion perm tted �i�Y �� ^Ai�t.na Siam Variance San Clemente Yes None San Juan Yes None --r Capistrano Santa Variant© nta Ana Auto Canter Santa Ana Yea (Redevelopment Area) Beal Beach Yes None -_ Stanton Yes hone Variance Tustin Yes None --- .. Villa Park --- None Centennial Thrift & Loan Variance Westminster Yea Sunset Ford Variance E, t Variance ' None ,. Yorb a Linda Yea � . OuTfi l pE Q iCOLTNTX ERB Signs wow ERB ' Prohibited span Permitted r: city by�Qsls3 �x�mot•;na -Suns Arcadia Yes None --� Variance Carson No Cormier Chevrolet Building ITT Permit Carson Civic Center Exempt Compton Yes Auto Mall Redevelopment Area i Downey Yes Embassy Suites Public Service Sign Duarte No Duarte Toyota Architectural Duarte Suzuki Board approval L Mirada Yes Gateway Plaza Redevelopment La Agency � Age Y I ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNAGE REQUIREMENTS BY CITY (Continued) OUTSIDE QFANSE COUNTY ERB Signs Prohibited How ERB City by Cgdq Existing Signs, Sign Permitted Long Beach Long Beach Convention Center Monrovia Yes Auto Mall Variance Norwalk Yes Norwalk Toyota Sign Use Permit Ramada Inn (Variance) Pasadena No Pasadena Civic Center Building permit Hastings Ranch Shopping Nonconforming Center Santa Fe No, but Santa Fe Springs Plaza City-Funded limited to project 10 acre sites South Gate No Pete Ellis Dodge Non.-conforming Jeep/Eagle 4 r i i C_.. i SAMPLES OF EXISTING ELECTRONIC READERBOARDS IN 1 ORANGE AND LOS ANGELES COUNTIES give of Lines of Electronic Approximate Electronic ! �lIBDD&13 .Iccation Box Height Copy Centennial Thrift NEC Beach and 3' x 20' +* 30'-35' 1 & Loan Weet:minster 60 sq.ft. (Westminster) Sunset Ford* S. of Garden 7' x 35' CO' 3 Grove Blvd. 245 sq.ft. (west of Edwards) (Westminster) Orange County 1020 Garden 6' x 25' 35' 3 Volvo Grove Blvd. 125 sq.ft. SWC (Garden Grove Blvd. and Hrookhurst) (Garden Grove) �-1 Gateway Plaza* Valley View off 8' : 15' 50' 3 5 Freeway 120 sq.ft. (La Mirada) r House of Imports* 6862 .tanchester CO x 25' 30' 3 Beach Boulevard 200 sq.ft. and 5 Freeway (Buena Park) Santa Fe opringn Off 605 MI. 8' x 25' 45' 3 Shopping Center on Telegraph 200 sq.ft. (Santa Fe Springs) Norwalk Toyota 11530 Firestone 6' x 25' 40' 2 Blvd. (Norwalk) 150 sq.ft. Ramada Inn* 14299 Firestone 8' x 30' 93 ' 3 Boulevard off 240 sq.ft. 5 Freeway (Norwalk) •w 1 *Freeway visibility 1 Size of Lines of Electronic Approximate Electronic e� � ;ir► 8 Location Bos Height_ Cgoy Embassy Suites 8425 Firestone 6' x 18' 351 -40' 3 Blvd. (Downey) 108 sq.ft. Pete Ellis Dodge 5800 Firestone 5' x 25' 55 ' 3 Jeep/Eagle Blvd. (Firestone 125 sq.ft. exit off Long Beach Freeway) (South Gate) Cormier Chevr,.)let* Wilmington l 8' x 25' 110' 3 405 Freeway 200 sq.ft. j (Carson) ITT* Wilmington p 4 ' x 18' 45 ' 3 I 405 Freeway 72 sq.ft. (Carson) i Carlson Civic 701 E. Carson 6' a 18' 15 ' 3 Center (Carson) 108 sq.ft. Monument Anaheim Toyota* 1601 S. Anaheim 8' x 25' 50' 3 Blvd. (Harbor 200 sq.ft. exit off 5 Freeway) (Anaheim) Travel Lodge* 1221 S. Harbor 6' x 18' 30' 3 Blvd. (Harbor 108 sq.ft. exit off 5 Freeway) (Anaheim) Pac-Tel* (Harbor exit 5'x 21' 30' 2 off 5 Freeway) 105 sq.ft. (Anaheim) Anaheim Hilton 777 West 6' x 18 ' 25 '-30' 3 Ccrtvention Way 108 sq.ft. (Katella/Harbor) (Anaheim) Anaheim Convention 800 W. Katella 6' x 25' 35'-40 ' 3 Center (Katella/Harbor) 150 sq.ft. (Anaheim) t Embassy Suite* Glassel off 6 ' x 18' 50'-60' 3 ; 91 Freeway 108 sq.ft. *Freeway visibility Size of Lines of Electronic Approximate Electronic Sox H i_V t . C913Y Santa Ana Auto (Edinger Exit 5' x 17' 60' 3 Center* off 55 Freeway) 85 sq.ft. (Santa Ana) Orange County Fairgrounds* Fair/55 Freeway 5' x 20' 20' 2 (Costa Mesa) 100 sq.ft. Harbor Plaza 2300 Harbor 5' x 20' 30' 1 Boulevard 100 sq.ft. (Harbor/Wilson) (Costa Mesa) Compton Auto* Harbor Freeway 10' x 36' 85' 3 Plaza @ Artesia 360 sq.ft. (Compton) Pasadena Civic 300 E. Green 6' x 16' 15' 2 Center (Public (Green and Los 96 sq.ft. Monument Service Robles) Announcements (Pasadena) Hastings Ranch Rosemead/ 3' x 25' 40' 1 Shopping Center Foothill 75 sq.ft. (Pasadena) Duarte Toyota* (Buena Vista 7' x 36' 55 ' 3 Exit off 210 252 sq.ft. Freeway) (Duarte) Duarte Suzuki* (Buena Vista 7' x 30' 55 ' 3 Exit off 210 210 sq.ft. Freeway) (Duarte) Rehabilitation 1800 E. LaVeta 9 ' x 11, 30' 1 Institute (Tustin Blvd. 9 sq.ft. nor'-h of ?2 Freeway) (Orange) 1 *Freeway visibility . 34 1 Y Size of Lines of pads -- at�lgn Electronic Approximate Electronic Long Beach E. Ocean Convention Center 3oQ 300Blv n''a n/a n/a (Long Beach) *Freeway visibility i i t i i i i I i 1 r 7(. u 1 + • ., 1 {., tITIT •w.\P..t � a 1.l YDMr a ..th» J/IIMor. i yy�t I t 4 1...w ..,1. too C M4 ..�.- 11 / ..:.:+..• J��r• �J .,fitIt •1i!ajti ,,i Kam.Somommu / r 4n MT �i .• .Iwo' t-Y`L It ` Wwt/y. :T t l ab.,1t, �'4:. .;+ - -�-•�}- r Ls"i / w1'a/�l ..15t ^2''ii4 ..CAS.. �\'l' � tr,.r tt EMT I iR(Nl ��rq, �.�... ON& ` ""°' MI.rv1TM� l4„rf,4 � \ tOUM l �. M.14. M1410N rI Kt11&A .A.- ,.,• t 1 1 • 4�r,o.. �' �. Not 1 1„...Mf1 � 1 (j{ •- .t..+ l Nt r i ( / \i:i t �' •�r`� ..`.ate '"' �t CCU 1 AMA 1 Y \ + 1 HUNTINGTON I k BEACH �N M ITTwf.��t .I IC Ifs r\�1 ELECTRONIC READER BOARD S I GNAGE ! HUNTINGTON 8E4CH 104LIFORNIN Signs with freeway visibility PLANNING DIVISION ,Signs located on surface streets �4a ' i a 1 s ...,_.. CIRCULATION PLAN OF ARTERIAL i ,,_. .. •- /i STREETS AND HIGHWAYS J A.LIONED of oly fAt CL »I Rf.saut&4 N0436e-DEC i?.f976 LEGEND FREEWAY STREET C,; C-y ; r PRIMARY 3(3000 } �•..-: - . . -• - _ - SECONDARY MOM � t '�'•l NOTE faw ► t� arcut t•'t+ac W."C. ... I ro v ' i' � . J CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 'RANGE COUNTY CALIFORNIA Figure 3-6 �' �� 57 �,n wwsw�rw•.n./grlr■r � n.�nlr.■,..,�. - ur 1 rlrrriw+.rw��w.w• 1 � r •wl 1 ♦ �IIII\� 1 •MA 1 1 1 �• ' \A f Mw\ I • \ •'�� J 1r1\.i ♦ I lopLANDSCAPE CORRIDORS �� � • huntington beach planning department 1 r� MINUTES REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY eel Council Chamber, Civic Center j Huntington Beach, California Monday, March 28, 1988 A tape recording of this meeting is on file in the City Clerk's Office Chairman Erskine called the regular meeting of the Redevelopment Agency of the i City of Huntington Beach to order at 7 p.m. . I AGENCY ROLL CAL Present: Kel y, Green, Finley, Erskine, Mays, Winchell , Bannister Absent: Hone JOINT HE IhG OF THE CITY =MCI L AND RED.EVELOPNENT AGENCY Chairman Erskine announced that a joint meeting of the City Council and the Redevelopment Agency had been called. CaffIl...MLSALL Present: Kelly. Green, Finley, Erskine, Mays, Winchell , Bannister Absent: None • .M. Dave .SG suggested that the old Civic Center site (Townsquare) be utilized for undergro parking with a park on top. He informed Council he had gath•• eyed approximat 315 opinions during an informal survey that were over- whelmingly in favo f a park, rather than condominiums on that site. Barge Hilkovich and I Hatkins urged Council to preserve the Little glue Church and relocate it. Cp_un,lma0jDirpctQr Bannister !aft (City tnc 1) pUflLI YAEARING — APPE/4L M PLANNIkG CDF9iISS.xO#i S DENIAL QF CODE AMENDMENT 87-15 — REEERREQ�-PLANNIhIG 5L(XL"--- o ai_:_.I 4 HILSDN ECM NEDIA OM BEHALF OFAIM FORD The Mayor announced that this was the day and hour set for a public hearing continued open from March 21 , 1988, to consider an appeal flied by Rod Wilson, i Q ; ell) �� I ! Page 2 - Redevelopment Agency Minutes - 3/28/88 Electra Media, on behalf of Wilson Ford to the Planning Commission's denial of Code i al amend Article (SignCode) of the Huntington Beach Ordnance ode to allow electronic reader boards.Scott Hess, Associate Planner, presented a staff report. Kent Pigrce, reprpsentin4 the Planning Commission Sub-Committee, appointed to explore the possibility of the Code Amendment, reviewed their findings. He stated he believed the proposed Code Amendment would result in the clean-up of existing signs on Beach Boulevard. He recommended various conditions to be placed on electronic readerboards, that such signs be limited to certain arterial streets and that the present code be strongly enforced. RU YM, Vice President of Huntington Jeep Eagle, described the competition � between automobile dealers and described auto malls in other cities. He stated that his company is civic minded and mentioned youth organizations and community events which the company sponsors. He stated the company would pledge ten per cent of the message time for service messages, possibly emer- gency road information, at the discretion of the laity Council . .Bgd i l son, representing Electra Media, stated II at Wilson Ford and the AMC Company contracted with Electra Media tc' buy an electronic sign to compete with the competition of other automobile dealers in neighboring cities that have electronic signs. He stated that he had distributed to Council a fact sheet report addressing Planning Commission and staff's concerns. He reviewed the tact sheet and showed Council a lamp cylinder and Explained that its fur.r- _,� lion was to mitigate glare and halo effect from the sign. He showed Council a shade screen that would cut down on glare and spillage. He stated that the display contained a photo cell and would dim automatically at night. i Roc and Eris-+ kr stated their opposition to proposed Code amendment 87-15. There being no one present to speak further on the matter and there being no furthe- protests filed, either oral or written, the hearing was closed by the Mayor. Following discussion, a motion was made by Winchell , seconded by Erskine, to uphold the Planning Commission and deny Code Amendment 87-15 with findings for denial as set forth in the RCA dated March 21 , 1988. Following discussion, the motion was withdrawn. Following discussion, a motion was made by Winchell , seconded Erskine, to refer Code Amendment 87-15 to the Planning Commission for evaluation and recommendation upon an alternative ordinance that would allow electronic read- erboards subject to certain location and design standards numbers t through 8, as recommended by the"Minutes Commission Subcommittee and Department of Pub- lic Works in their Minutes of Subcommittee Meeting on Electrical Reader Hoards Tuesday, March 1 , 198811, adding #9 defining major arterials and where they appear, modifying #5 to read: "Maximum sign area limited to 200 square feet. . .", and requiring photo cells to dim the sign at dusk. The motion car- ried by the following roll call vote: - AYES: Green, Finley, Erskine. Mays, Winchell NOES: Kelly ABSENT: Bannister tout of the room) 640 Page 3 - Redevelopment Agency Minutes - 3/28/88 (City [Quft tj) a ILIC HIARING COTIBUM _01'fff_EQR 9n OAlf5 KITH R AoyFl2Ttc�►��t r APPEAL TO PLANNING GMI$5rnu'S_ 1&L.QE� i� _SIGN PE NILSON - BULL 7-18 - Rf1D The Mayor announced that this was the day and hour set for a public hearing continued open from March 21 , 1988, to consider an appeal filed by Rod Wilson, Electra Media, to the Planning Commission's denial of Special Sign Permit 87-18 which would allow an electronic reader board sign at a height of 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet with an area of 400 square feet in lieu of 70 square feet. fho proposed sign would be in excess of total number of signs allowed for the project. He stated that Council had been provided with copies of two peti- tions which had been submitted to the Planning Commission listing approxi- riately 75 signatures apposed to Special Sign Permit 87-18 included. The property is located at 10255 Beach Boulevard (on the west side of Beach Boulevard, south of Taylor Drive •• Wilson Ford) in the C-2 (Commercial Dis- trict) ROA_HWDn requested a continuance of the matter for ninety days. There being no one present to speak further on the matter and there being no further protests filed. either oral or written, the hearing was closed by the Mayor. A motion was made by Mays, .oLondetl by Kelly, to continue the public hearing open, with readvertisement, VOr rrinetY (lays to consider Special Sign Permit 87-18 based on findings for denial d% 54!t forth in the RCA dated March 21 , 1908. The motion carried by Z-he following roll call vote: AYES: Kelly, Green, Tinley, 11skirre, Mdys, Winchell NOES: None ABSENT: Bannister (out of the room; HEM tCi_____v rA„ i, l)L c �� FpR S`0_ DAYS NiTii Ri~AOVESF_ HILSON ELf,IBA MED�! �ISILI .5 PHIAL .QE' ECIAt SIGIf PtRPiIT 87 19 M5[M The Mayor announced that thls was the day and hour set for a public hearing continued open t'rom March 21 , 1988, to consider an appeal filed by Rod Wilson, Electra. Media, to the Planning Commission's denial of Special Sign Permit 87-19 which would allow an electronic reader board sign at a height of 50 feet In lieu of 15 feet with an area of 400 square feet in lieu of 70 square feet. The proposed sign would be in excess of total number of signs allowed for the project. The property is located at 16751 Beach Boulevard (west side of Beach Boulevard north of Terry DrivE -• tluntington AMC) Rod W11na requested that the issue be continued for ninety days. There being no one present to speak farther on the matter and there being nc further protests filed, either oral or written, the hearing was closed by the Mayor. i Dl�r ' Page 4 - RedevelupAent Agoncy Minutes - 3/28/88 A motion was made by Finley, seconded by Mays, to continue the public hearing ,...� open, with readvertisement, for ninety days to consider Special Sign Permit 87-19 based on findings set forth in the RCA dated March 21 . 1988. The motion carried by the following roll tail vote: AYES: Kelly, Green, Finley, Erskine, Mays, Winchell NOES: None ABSENT: Bannister (out of the room) silID&M_Qinnister rgturnel_ip._Jha_1 om. �j q "860 - l�EI� �- AMUIS1710N OF PROPERTY gY ENINEMI WrMSJHIK�Ik C PAR�GSTRUCTURE_.-- AP fQZJ-J43-12 APQ AP it024-143-1,Q $T MAIN-PIER.REMELMM PRO��5� The Mayor a ounced that this was the day and hour set for a public hearing to consider Res ution No. 5860 - "A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH DECLARIN THAT THE PUBLIC INTEREST AND NECESSITY REQUIRE ACQUISITION OF CERTAIN REAL P ERTY IN THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH FOR PUBLIC rVRPOSES. AND ' WTHORIZING THE CQUISITION OF SUCH PROPERTY BY EMINENT DOMAIN." (Property ; located on Olive b veen 5th and Main) The Deputy City Cler announced that all legal requirements for notification, and posting had been et, and that she had received a communication from Jim Koller regarding the ma ter. The City Administrator pr ented a staff report. Doug LaBelle, Deputy City A inistrator, Community Development, stated for the record: "The matter before a City this evening in the five actions for your consideration, five separate dministrative hearings, are city hearings on resolutions of necessity reIat a to the acquisition of property for parking facilities to be constructed in he second and third blocks of Main Street. The hearing this evening is for he owners of the real property in question only. Not a part of the considerat n this evening is the question of compen- sation since that subject is for t courts to ultimately decide at a later date should you adopt the resolutio s of necessity. The noticed hearings relate to the issues of the public, int est and necessity, the greatest public good and least private injury and the n cessity for the proposed project in question. "I have some general comments that I would 1 e to make relative to the matter that will apply to the five separate hearing that will be conducted follow- ing this. The five acquisitions in question ar needed for parking to be pro- vided in the downtown area public parking. For ublic facilities to be Con- structed both in the second block of Main Stre , bounded by Main, Third, Walnut and Olive; and in the third block of Main Street bounded by Main, Orange. Olive and 5th Street. In terms of the parka in our analysis, the areas selected provide for a natural pr:-jgression of rking in areas where surface parking presently exists. Clearly the need is there and the least impact will be suffered as a part of the acquisition of the properties." The Mayor opened the public hearing and stated that the law re ices that only 'r owners or their designated representatives, i .e. an attorney or ther agent of Z'� C� REQUEST OR CITY COUNCIL. /`45,o ION Data March 211 1988 Submitted to: Honorable Mayor and City Council Submitted by: Paul Cook, City Administrator e(— Prepared by: Douglas N. Lai Belle, Director, Community Development Subject: APPEAL OF PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF CODE AMENDMENT NO. 87--15 Consistent with Council Policy? ( J Yes New Policy or Exception _._..Stetemant of issue, Recommends tion,Analysis, Funding Source,Alternative Actions,Attachments: SMMIT OF IBM: } Code Amendment No. 87-15 is a request by the applicant to allow electronic reader boards by amending the list of prohibited signs in I the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, Section 9610.4(a)&(h) Lo exclude readerboards. This request is in conjunction with two requests for special sign permits (Special Sign Permit No. 87-16 and 87-19) for auto dealer signs along Beach Boulevard at a height of 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet with 200 square foot electronic reader boards (8 feet by 25 feet) . The total sign area proposed in 254 f aquare feet. RB.CS2MMgiriATIO E133ng nalm Recommendation and Actinn on r bruary 2. 1988: ON MOTION B: SCHUMACHER AND SECOND BY HIGGINS, CODE AMENDMENT NO. 87--15 ETAS DENIED WITH FINDINGS, BY THE .FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: Pierce, Livengood, Silva, Leipzig, Schumacher, Higgins NOES: Bourguignon ABSENT: None ABSTAIN: None FIND!,,NGS FOR DENIAL: 1. Since the Huntington Bo ach Ordinance Code, Section 961 (Sign Code) allows adequate opportunities for advertising through various types of signare, Code Amendment No. 87-15 to allow electronic reader board signs is not necessary for the preservation and enjoyment of substantial property rights. 2. Electronic reader board signs, if permitted by Code Amendment No. 87--15, will be incompatible with surrounding existing and proposed developments, especially residential land uses. !� O: PIO 4/84 3. Electronic reader board signs, if permitted by Code Amendment No. 87-15, will have the potential of creating a congestion and circulation hazard to passing motorists. Staff recommendaton is the same as the Planning Commission. Applin.ant: Wilscn Ford 18255 peach Boulevard Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Location: City-wide DISCU MN: Code Amendment No. 87-15 to amend Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, Section 9610.4, is being requested by the applicant to enable two requests to be acted upon for special sign permits for electronic reader boards in excess of sign code requirements (height* area and location criteria) . The City Attorney's office has indicated that a special sign permit may be granted for deviations to the maximum standards for signs but not to allow a sign (electronic reader board) that is expressly prohibited by ordinance (Section 9610.4) as stated in section 9610.7 as follows: -� "A special sign permit cannot be processed for those signu listed as prohibited in Section 9610.4" Section 9610.4 - prohibited signs includes: (a) Flashing, moving, pulsating, or intermittently lighted nigns, including searchlights; except public service siqns such as those for time and temperature. (h) Changeable copy signs, including electronic readerboards; except theatre marquees. The electronic reader boards proposed are approximately 8 feet by 25 feet (200 square feet) containing multiple lamps within a black background (see attachment) . They are computer controlled with the capability to generate multiple messages and characters. The Huntington Beach Sign Code recently underwent extensive review and amendment by the City Council, with input from the Planning Commission, Chamber of Commerce and other business and citizen groups. At that time a close look was taken at the signage on Beach Boulevard. The intent of the revised ordinance was to limit sign heights, reduce visual clutter and create a more aesthetically pleasing appearance to passing motorists. In reviewing the sign regulations for Beach Boulevard, it is important to note that many . y F Q. qq RCA - 3/21/88 --2- (0164d) i f of the changes relate to the increasing urban character of the street scene. With more development, the taller signs are not as visible. A sign within a motorists' direct cone of vision is going to be more readily seen and read. With today's smaller cars, too, the view through the windshield often cuts off the higher signs so that all that can be seen is the support pole. In the past, the freestanding signs of 50 to 60 feet were erected to attract motorists from miles away, but today's urban development is far too cluttered to allow for any effective communication of a message at this d;stancq. Approval of electronic reader boards with changing messages will increase the visual clutter rather than reduce it. Staff surveyed other cities in the Orange County and Los Angeles County areas and found electronic reader boards to be generally prohibited. Jurisdictions whose ordinances expressly prohibit them include Costa Mesa, Garden Grove, Irvine, Westminster, Orange, Buena Park, Compton, Pasadena, Arcadia, Stanton, Monrovia and the County of Orange. Four cities were found to have one or more electronic reader boards, most of which were allowed through a variance (or similar review) procedure. Carson, the only city with an ordinance which allows electronic reader boards, has specific requirements for this -type .of sign. A commonality of all existing electronic reader board signs investigated by staff is their proximity to a freeway with definite freeway visibility. Staff recommends that electronic reader boards not be allowed in �. Huntington Beach (especially on Beach Boulevard) due to the risk of hazardous distraction of motorists. It is recommended that the use of flashing, blinking, pulsating or intermittently lighted signage be reserved for public safety and driving messages to motorists. The use of flashing signage for advertising is visually demanding and may be confusing to drivers. These signs will increase the risk of hazards and may cause a slowing of traffic on arterial roadways such as Beach Boulevard. The traffic division of Public Works has reviewed the request and recommends restrictions be placed on such signage if approved to prevent them from being distractions to motorists (see Attachment No. 2 of the planning Commission staff report) . The Planning Commission denied the code amendment request due to concerns over increasing the visual clutter on Beach Boulevard and possibly throughout the City, impacting adjacent residents with light and glare frocn the large signs and allowing possible distractions to motorists. After their action, the Planning Commission appointed a subcommittee to further study the issue. They saw the possibility of allowing electronic readerboards in return for minimizing existing signage. The subcommittee met and drafted a list of possible restrictions which could be placed on electronic r.eaderboards should the Council wish to approve the code amendment. Their comments are forthcoming. F � � FICA - 3/21/88 -3- (0164d) I I i ENVIROMMUTAIL STATUS: The proposed project is exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act. IRJI,.GQURf.E Not applicable. A.MF NAT I_Y..S_AMMU: i The City Council may refer Code Amendment No. 87-15 to the Planning Commission for evaluation and recommendation upon an alternative Ordinance that would allow electronic readerboards subject to certain location and design standards as recommended by the Planning Commission Subcommittee and Department of Public Works (Attachment No. 2 of Planning Commission staff report dated February 2, 1988) . 1. Appeal letter d:t:d February 12, 1988 �. 2. Planning Commission staff report dated February 2, 1988 5- Mautes - subromnittee Meeting On Electrical Reader Boards - 3/l/88 DNL:PP:kla y ty� I .ti K 1 S .i SR r` .�l c f , RCA - 3/21/88 -4- (0164d) MINUTES SUBCOMMITTEE MEETING ON ELECTRICAL READER BOARDS TUESDAY, MARCH 1, 1988 Committee Members Present: Kant Pierce, Ken Bouguignon, Rod Wilson, Eric Weber Victor Leipzig (sttended last portion of meeting) Staff Present: Pam Posten, Scott Hess The Committee met and discussed allowing electrical readerboard signs in the City subject to specific criteria. Following is some suggested criteria: 1. Maximum aign height limited to 40 feet with not less than 10 � feet ground clearance. `• 2. Cylinders and shade screens shall be required to minimize glare. 3 . Minimum separation between readerboard to residential property of 150 feet. 4 . Minimum lot frontage of 200 fbet required. Sign shall be located a minimum of 100 feet from the property line. 5. Maximum sign area limited to 275 square feet (includes readerboard and other signage) . 6. Reduce maximum allowable wall signage to 100 square feet. 7. .All other signs on site shall be brought into conformance with sign code including the number of signs. No freestanding signs allowed in addition to reader board sign except one 7 foot high monument sign. 8 . Eliminate opportunity to have balloons, banners, and other temporary signage. PP:sds 0177d , �-� t s 1208 Poinsettia Ave. ! Manhattan Beach,CA 90266 / 213-379-5149 e"4 >a,<< w ' s ; ~r N C i 14"Il V Fox I� Gy,'G° .`'sue 1417/ A.,C/ 4- r� I L .r r /t/ 77 Ze 1,41e1(4 b I. / �-� I'o N A /r7.4! r � C-o tt..,.r'l��r4"/97�c itJ I NLINTINGTON BEACH ;} DEVELOPMENT SERVICES FF9 I I NO h. 0. Box I30 .._.,...._.__., Him''--,!cn Beach,CA 9264F F373 c,,,,. , ... 23 I ' n huntington beach department of community development STAf f _....�E P O R T ..__,..__....._._...� TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: February 2, 1988 SUBJECT: CODE AMENDMENT NO. 87--15 ApPLICAjQS: Wilson Ford D TFt ACC PIED: 18255 Beach Boulevard January 22, 1988 Hunt. Beach, CA 92647 MtlDAT-QRY PROCESSING DATE: ' REQ=: To amend the sign March 22, 1988 ordinance Article 961 to allow electronic reader boards. Lk- 1U GGE IED ACx.L4Ii: Deny Code Amendment No. 87-15 with findings. 2_,0-- ERAL INFORMATION: Code Amendment No. 87-15 is a request by the applicant to allow electronic reader boards by excluding such signs from the list of " prohibited signs in the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, Section 9610.4(a)&(h) . This request is in conjunction with two requests for special sign permits (Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 and 87-19) for auto dealer signs along Beach Boulevard at a height of 50 feet with 400 square foot electronic reader boards (8 feet by 25 feet) . 3 .0 EKYIRg=NTA STATU4: The proposed project is exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act. 4,0 COASTAL SIAIUS: Not applicable. 5,Q REDEMELOPMENJ STATUS: Not applicable. 620 SPECIFIC PLAN: Not applicable. ,Z,Q _SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE: Not applicable. IF A•FM43C 1 • f Code Amendment No. 87-15 to amend Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, Section 9610.4, is being requested by the applicant to enable two requests for special sign permits for electronic reader boards in excess of sign code requirements (height, area and location criteria) . The City Attorney's office has indicated that a special. sign permit may be granted for deviations to the maximum standards for signs but not to allow a sign (electronic reader board) that is expressly prohibited by ordinance (Section 9610.4) as stated in Section 9610.7. The electronic reader boards proposed are approximately 8 feet by 25 feet (400 square feet) containing multiple lamps within a black background (see attachment) . They are computer controlled with the capability to generate multiple i messages and characters. The Huntington Beach Sign Code recently underwent extensive review and amendment by the City Council, with input from the Planning Commission, Chamber of Commerce and other business and citizen groups. At that time a close look was taken at the signage on Beach Boulevard. The intent of the rP•-wised ordinance was to limit sign heights, reduce visual clutter and create a more aesthetically pleasing appearance to passing motorists. in reviewing the sign regulations for Beach Boulevard, it is important to note that many of the changes relate to the increasing urban character of the street scene. With more development, the taller signs are not as ^�. visible. A sign within a motorists' direct cone of vision is going to be more readily seen and read. With today's smaller cars, too, the view through the windshield often cuts off the higher signs so that all that can be seen is the support pole. In the past, the freestanding signs of 50 to 60 feet were erected to attract motorists from miles away, but today's urban development is far too cluttered to allow for any effective communication of a message at this distance. Approval of electronic reader boards with changing messages will increase the visual clutter rather than reduce 4t. II Staff surveyed other cities in the Orange County and Los Angeles County areas and found electronic reader boards to be generally prohibited. Jurisdictions whose ordinances expressly prohibit them include Costa Mesa, Garden Grove, Irvine, Westminster, Orange, Buena Park, Compton, Pasadena, Arcadia, Stanton, Monrovia and the County of orange. Four cities were found to have one or more electronic reader boards, most of which were allowed through a variance (or similar review) procedure. Carson, the only city with an ordinance which allows electronic reader boards, has specific requirements for this type of sign. A commonality of all existing electronic reader board signs investigated by staff is their proximity to a freeway with definite freeway visibility. cla so Staff Report - 2/2/88 -2- (9940d) Staff recommends that electronic reader boards not be allowed in Huntington Beach (especially on Beach Boulevard) due to the risk of -- hazardous distraction of motorists. it is also recommended that the use of flashing, blinking, pulsating or intermittently lighted signage be reserved for public safety and driving messages to motorists. The use of this type of signage for advertising is visually demanding and may be confusing to drivers. These signs will increase the risk of hazards and may cause a slowing of traffic on arterial roadways such as Beach Boulevard. The traffic division of Public Works has reviewed the request and recommends restrictions be placed on such signage if approved to prevent them from being distractions to motorists (see attached memo) . Staff is recommending denial of the request for Code Amendment No. 87-15. If the Planning Commission wishes to allow electronic reader boards in some form in the City of Huntington Beach staff recommends that this item be continued to allow Public Works and Community Development staff time to research and do traffic testing to determine restrictions to better regulate these signs and reduce their traffic hazard potentials. Attached to the report are such requirements that could be addressed in a code section allowing these signs . With a continuance, staff will research the suggested criteria as directed by the Planning Commission and determine which restrictions are appropriate to apply to electronic reader boards. Staff recommends that the Planning Commission deny Code Amendment No. 87-15 with the following findings: P 1 HiZId _ � fl1� 1 . Since the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, Section 961 (Sign 9 � 9 Code) allows adequate opportunities for advertising through various types of signage, Code Amendment No. 87-15 to allow electronic reader board signs is not necessary for the preservation and enjoyment of substantial property rights. 2. Electronic reader board signs, if permitted by Code Amendment No. 87-15, will be incompatible with surrounding existing and proposed developments, especially residential land uses. 3. Electronic reader board signs, if permitted by Code Amendment No. 87-15, will have the potential of creating a congestion and circulation hazard to passing motorists. Staff Report - 2/2/88 -3- (9940ti) i j 19 A ALTERNATIVE ACTION: The Planning Commission may continue Code Amendment No. 87-15 and V' direct staff to do the research and studies necessary to determine approprate code requirements for electronic reader boards. ATTACHMENTS: 1 . Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, Section 9610.4 (Prohibited Signs) 2. Suggested restrictions for electronic reader boards 3. Suggested amendment submitted by applicant 4 . Demo from Traffic Division, Public Worka 5. General Sign Information 6. Elevation of sign proposed contingent on approval of Code Amendment No. 87-15 SH:PP:kla i ,VV r i I 1 F St of f Report: - 2/2/88 -4 - (9940d) f 9610.4 in thi article. (c) Co trucrion signs as defined by this article. (d) No tre assing signs as defined by this article and posted a minimum one hundred ( 100) feet apart. (e) Window signs a defined by thiq article and restricted to A maximum of 20 perc t of the window area. ( 1 ) oil operations sig pursuant to Title 15 of the Huntington Beach municipal Co i (9) Political signs, provide they do not pose a traffic I I or safety hazard, are not erected m e than forty-five• (45) days prior to or removed more than fi een ( 15) days after an election. Permission from the property nor shall be secured prior to the placement of such signs. (Ur Ord. 2874, 13 Oct 86; Ord. 2832, 8/86) 1 9610.4 Prohibited signs. The following signa are ' prohlbitea wit n t e city-of Huntington Beach: f (a ) Flashinq, moving, pulsating, or intermittently lighted -.- signs. including searchlights; except public service signs such as these for time and temperature. (h) Sign; which conflict with any traffic control device iWe to color , word i ttcl, design, location, or illumination; or with the safe and efficient flow of traffic, both vehicular and peclesLr inn. (c) Animals Or human beings, live or simulated, utilized as signs . (d ) Loudspeakers; or signs which emit sound, odor, or visible matter . ( e ) Mechan ► o i movement signs. ( t ) Roof signs as defined by this article . (,; ) llro)ei.-t tr.q signs as clef ined by this article. ( h) Ch. rmt--al,ty copy signs, including electronic rt%adorboar-lsr except tlwatre ri3ryueets . V 4/87 i i 10.4 ( i ) Banners, ; lags, kites, pennants, or balloons, except it permitted as u.oporary signs pursuant to section 9610.9(a) . ( 1 ) Sig►►:c which constitute a nuisance or hazard due to Lheir intensity of light. (k ) Billboards or advertising structures, including any ott-site signs installed for the purpose of advertising a prot•- ect, subject or business unrelated to the premises upon which the sign is located, except subdivision directional signs pur- suant to section 9610.9(c) . ( 1 ) Signs which no longer identify a bona fide business conducted on the premises. such signs shall be removed by the owner of the sign within sixty (60) days of the business' closing date. (m) Portable signs including "A-frame" signs and those of a similar nature which are not permanently attached to the. ground or building. (n ) Vehicle signs, signs affixed to automobiles, trucks, trailers or other vehicles on private or public property for ^� the t►asic: purpo v of advertising, identifying, or providing direction Lo a use or activity not related to the lawful use of the vehicle for delivering metc:handise or rendering s%>rvices. �. Any such vehicles which have an their primary purpose ha serve .t:c a nonmoving sign display. (o) sigh:: on any public property or protecting within the public right-of --way, except these required by law, ano polit- ical signs. This section steal . not prohibit the placement of advertising panels on trash receptacles and bicycle racks in publicly-operated beaches aicd parks or an bus benches and transit shelters within public, rights-of-way, providea such facilities are placed in accordance with a franchise granted pursuant to the city charter . ( Urg . Ord. 2674 ; 11 Oct ab; Ord. 1834, 8/86) i 54 �- r i � . 1 ATTACHMENT NO. 2 SUGGESTED RESTRICTIONS FOR ELECTRONIC READER BOARD 1 . Minimum distance from residential. 2. Minimum distance from other electronic signs. 3. Sign height and area restrictions. 9 . Limit intensity of lighting. 5. Limit number of message changes per minute. 6. Establish minimum interval periods between messages. 7. Limit or restrict animation. 0. Limit hours of operation. 9 . Reduce other freestanding signage on-site per use. 10. Require a time allotment to be reserved for public service messages such as times, temperature and traffic conditions. il. Limit electronic boards to specific locations such as Beach Boulevard corridor or adjacent to the 405 freeway. i 12. Reryuire Public Works review and approval. 13. Require Design Review Board and Planning Commission approval through conditional use permit process. Cal Trans has adn7ted four criteria for electronic reader boards along state roadways. They are as follows; The proposed display will have no illumination which is in continuous motion or which appears to be in continuous motion. 2. The display message will not change at a rate faster than one message every four seconds. 3 . The interval between messages will not be less than one second. 4 . The intensity of illumination will not change. � I The City of Carson allows electronic reader boards subject to the following: 1 . Minimum 100 feet from residential. 2. Minimum 500 feet from othr electronic signs. 3 . Subject to height restriction in Sign Code (50 feet) . 4 . Requires written approval from City Engineer. i- I i v i i l 540 --777:- 1�'llfi I'umrollia Ave / Manhmmon Beach, CA 90266 / 213.379 149-; •. OP Goo ram• •r•rr sees •..• • • • • • seer C.V. AMENUS,y APPLICATION IN? following is a suggested amendment to Section 9610.4. Letter "h" to kx! climinated and letter "a" to read as follows: (a) Flashing, moving, pulsating, or intermittently lighted signs, including searchlights; except public service signs such .is those for time & temperature, and electrrnic changeable readert yards. i it •11 V• 1 Iv i, tt�lt CITY CW HUNTINGTON BEACH ; t INTER•DEPARTMINT COMMUNICATION '� 111NI1a1.TI1MY�f11 f � �/ ! l cl t''nn ilont 4•11 From Bruce G i l mo r t, I.Inn i nc, Public Works i Subject illuminaLeci Signs Date January 27, 1988 Changeable Messages l In response to Hie submittal for a code amendment pertaining U) the installation of changeable message electronic illuminated signs, the following comments are submitted for use in considera- tio" of the amendment. From a traffic safety perspective, certain common sense restric- tions must be placed on such installations. These restridtions should address concerns regarding the following general categories: 1 . Animation - designed to catch the viewers attention. 2. Dtirat icill of Message - affording the viewer adequate t. i my to absorb the text of the message. •-� .1 . ertwvv n Message Interval - indicating a change. 4 . Intensity of Illumination - primarily a night time concern regarding distracting or blinding glare. Each of these categories present a potential for removing the drivers attention from the roadway. Each should therefore be the subject of the proposed code modification to provide the appropriate minimum or maximum value allowed, e.g. the message shall not be displayed for a period of time less than five (5) seconds. As we have discussed, other agencies have developed codes and guidelines pertaining to these signs. Using the experience of those agencies, adoption of the appropriate sections of those codes for our situation on arterial highways would seem to be useful . I will be available to review any section(s) you would propose, if such a review is needed. dNG: lw cr: Les Evans Jamal Aahimi t i i I f PART 1 i HUMAN LIMITATIONS IN PERCEPTION I I To communicate, outdoor signing must register from a distance. when people are in motion. Failure to recognize the effect of a person's rate of motion upon the design consider• ations for an outdoor sign can result in an ineffective communication. The rate of motion is variable, however it may be subdivided into two broad categories: 1. Pedestrian 2. Vehicular The distance at which a sign must read is in part determined by the rate and type of motion. Pedestrian motion is characterized ty a wide range of variable sensory stimuli. These involve frequent focal points with many highly differentiated spaces and objects. Vehicular arteries are characterized by generally larger scale sensory stimuli consisting of free-flowing forms, widely spaced. Objects and spaces are more difficult to compre- hend from r vehicle than when one is a pedestrian. A definite difference exists between the perceptual processes of the driver and the ! pedestrian. Basically, it is one of involvement. Tests have conclusively demonstrated that there is little correlation between what one perceives as a driver and what one perceives as a pedestrian. i As published in liamilton and Thurston's Human Limitations in Automobile Driving. i there are five limitations that increasing speed imposes on man: f 1. Man's concentration increases. While stationery or walking, man's attention may be widely dispersed, but when moving in an automobile, he concentrates on those factors which are relevant to the driving experience, 2. The point of concentration recedes. As speed or motion increases, man's concentration is directed at a focal point increasingly further away. 3. Peripheral vision diminishes. As the eye concentrates on detail at a point of focus a great distance ahead, the angular field of vision shrinks. This shrink• ing process is a function of focusing distance, angle of vision, and distance of foreground detail. 4. Foreground detail fades increasingiY. While concentrating on more signifi• cant distant objects, man perceives foreground objects to be moving and increasingly blurred. 5. Space perception becomes impaired. With decreasing amounts of time to perceive objects changing, specific details are less noticeable, making spatial perception more difficult. It is evident then that design criteria for pedestrian oriented and motorist oriented signing should differ. As the rate of motion increases it becomes increasingly impor- tant that copy, including illustrations and symbols. be created specifically for out•of• doors and not merely rescaled from other media of communication. The safety of the motorist and his passengers can depend upon the clarity of messages conveyed by signs. 1 ^u.r• .... l' I.Kll.n.. r.•ut ,,,�... 1 1.1.1 •�� 1l,rylr. ....• Vl llrl 1► •f L nC .14 1 t I•Ir•.. !I.M 111•.f t.'{t .IP{ffMl 1. 111 Relatiofiship between focusing distance, angle of vision, and distavl. foreground detail at speeds of 40 mph, 50 mph, and 60 mph. The focusing point j, rrimmed here does not include the effect of preceding traffic. ti tom' +i VISUAL COMMUNICATION — RESEARCH PURPOSE j It is the intent of this section to provide an understanding of the factors which should be considered for an effective outdoor visual communication. Sample problems which utilize this research are included at the end of this section. Recommended typefaces, colors and design criteria for graphic symLols and logos are considered in the General Specifications section, which follows. OBJECTIVES { Research arks Inve-.-,tigations were conducted in an attempt to gain information pertaining to visual communication. Questions of primary interest were: 1. What is the effect of speed upon a motorist's comprehension of signs) i 2. What is the ratit) of sign size to the proximity of the roadway, i.e., how much better will a sign 20' from the road read than orie 35' away. 3. How large must a sign and its lettering be before it is deemed adequate under such varying conditioin as: a. The speed at which a motorist is traveling. b. The amount of information displayed. c. The location of the sign when it redirects the path of a motor � vehicle. I 4. What is the effect of various typefaces on the amount of Information that may be grasped? 5. How does letter size affect the time necessary to read a sign? 6. What is the relationship between color and: a. legibility b. visibility C. memory d. attention•rletting ea i I I 1 q �. SAMKE PROBLEM FOR A SIGN WITHIN THE DIRECT CONE OF VISION: Problem: A service Mition desires a sign to 6e oriented to motorists traveling 55 inph How trig should the letters be? Solution: Looking at the first graph we find that at 55 mph the driver's focal point is approximately 1600 ft. away. Looking at the second graph we find that a 33 inch letter is necessary to read t600 ft. •' 1 Not all signs can be within the driver's direct cone of vision. Traffic signs are fortunate in this respect and hence are seen quickly and easily without being distractive. The majority of highway oriented billboards and signs, however, are outside the motorist's direct cone of vision due to setback requirements and choices of location. These signs must be related to perpendicular distances from the roarsway, for their legibility requirements. Thy following sample problem illustrates the correct method to deter• mine the visual requirements for signs outside the motorist's direct cone of vision. V- f I f The Road Research Lalwiratory in England furnished a formula which relates the sideways displacement of a sign from thv driver's path as a result of studies con• ducted by them in 1962. The formula also considers the tirre taken to read A sign and its effect on the sire of the lettering necessary. It: 1 N = the number of names or words on a sign j X = height of lower-case letters in inches i I f H height of upper-case letters in inches Il 1 S = sideways displacement of the sign from the driver's path i in feet II V = driver's speed in m.p.h. That 1. Time to read a sign = N/3 4 2 sec. 2. Letter height formulas: X A w i (V) 0 (N + 6) 10 100 H - 4/3 x SAMPLE PROBLEM FOR A SIGN OUTSIDE THE DIRECT CONE OF 11ISION: Probli n: The Irvine Company wishes to locate a Planned Community Travel Direction sign along a highway. There will be A panels with the words "University of Calif.", "University Park", "Turtla Rock", and "Irvine Town Center". A ter foot setback r equireamt, must be oMerved. The speed limit is 55 mph. Nov big should the letter ir+g W? Solution: I f: N t 10 words V - 55 mph S - 10 ft. Then: X (S) + (V) a (N + 6) 10 1W X = 10 + (65 x 161 10 100 X 1 + (.55 x 16) Am: X 9.60 = lower cm letter height H - 4/3 x - 4/3 (9.80) Are: H « 13.6" ■ upper can Inter ht. .... THE PEDESTRIAN AND LETTER LEG1131LITY Although the experiments conducted on color and consnicuity directly relate to the pedestrian, the application cif the "c:onspicui!y principle" for the determination of "appropriate signing" would not prove very successful. The main problem which exists is that often the appropriate amount of area will not permit the appropriate letter height for legibility. That is, if the words on a sign are of great enough size to be legible, the appropriate sign area may be restrictive depending upon the color of the sign. There is a better approach for pedestrian oriented signing, an approach based an letter legibilities. Below is a chart relating the letter height of typefaces to legibility distances. This applies aUl to pedestrian signing. Legibility Distance Per Se_tles Inch of Loner Height ; Weak typefaces 33.0 ft. ASC' FTG9{I11KCkVr1- 2 Intermediate typefaces 42.5 ft. ABCDEFGHI)KLMNOPQRST 44 Sold typefaces 50.0 ft. ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPt1RS f'< . 1 Thus, knowing the distanre it sign must read, one can easily determine the iequire• ments for letter height. TIDE appropriate letter height, as considered by The Irvine ! Company, is 2,: times the requirement for legibility. �. SAMPLE PROBLEM FOR A PEDESTRIAN SIGN: Prr A tab sign is desired to be hung from the beams overhanging the front of a short. The words "Dotty'r Bakery" are to W placed on the tab sign. a. How high should the lettering be? b. How big should the sign be? Solution: a. Before utilizing the formulas for Pedestrian Oriented signs,jF g distance from which the Sian m� be read has to be determin , j Determine In this particular situation a visual limit is impssed bV the are Distance: ceding sign as illustrated. l_ 50r —_—___ ,I 1 The distance at which Dotty's sign first becomes visibl:s is at 50 feet away. i Dotty wants "Old Fashioned" letters to be used to convey the "home made" quality of her baked goods. Old Fashioned" letters are not'�s`legible as a block type- face but are stronger.'tharn a delicate script. Looking at thb Datmine etter egi -ty Table under Interm late ype•faces we find that one-inch high letters will be legible from 42.5 ft. g..�. away. This means that.lettering slightly less than 1% inch high will be legible at 50 feet. Multiplying the legibility height by two and one-half yields the appropriate letter height of approximately 3.1/8 inch. 2% x 1% inch 2 .. 1% = 2.1/2 inch + 'h x I% - 5/8 inch Appropriate Height 3.1/8 inch For Lettering ..� b. xnariparp bas lbg&n that the sign surface should befou� times the lettering area. The area of lettering in square inches is difficult to calculate unless it is mocked up in a rough sketch which relates the proper letter spacing and is then simply measured. This -eeornmended procedure. DOTTY 'S BAKERY I (4) x (lettering area) Sign area. I.e�ible typography is conducive to prolonging mention, Typelacas with fairly lliewy ark! uhiform strokes are most legible. .._.....r,._ 1No ma then twenty-five percent of the total ;gym should b.- covered by Win`at than num rs. ..—... ."',"""... In addition to aiding legibility, liberal negative spew, when enclosing the copy. etwise a target on which the viewer's eye an foam quickly. This is especially Important for glance legibility. f ' i a f 1 i ..-...._........ 7 aw PART II VISUAL COMMUNICATION GENERAL ASSUMPTIONS FOR INVESTIGATIONS 1. Signs, just as highways, should be designed and constructed for the Individual with poor vision, rather than for the average person. 2. 5 ns should be Oftsigned, constructed and placed far as t��+ Hence: s. Si n: rAu it gain an individual's attention but not be dillra2ting. b. -5 ns-inust be'reedable at a point'which permits a Nfflclent wornina time and distance for an fndwl a rticularl the motor s_Vs com�Oe_nce•„ -' 3. Pedestrian-oriented'and motorist-oriented ns have different critffa a VISIBILITY AND LEGIBILITY Legibility distance is about 85% of visibility d6tanee. A laboratory study showed that visibility and legibility are not independent. conditions which reduce legibility will proportionately reduce visibility. Legibility distance at night is generally only 88% of daytime legibility. This pro- portion varies depending upon color of lettering and background. lLETTER AND WORD LEGIBILITY a A comparison of lower case and capital letters yields the fact that lower case f letters have a slightly greater legibility distance. Capitals are seen more quickly, I but lower case letters can be read more rapidly -- a point to remember when pre. paring copy for motorist-oriented signs along highways and fr"ways. :+ In a study comparing glance legibility for block and rounded capital letters, it was found that rounded letters were recognized 8% betttr than the block setters. "Glance Legibility" is a minimum glance to see a target out of the five dagree '61 arc of clear seeing (hereinafter referred to as the "Direct Cone of Vision"). "Glance Legibility" requires from .6 to 1.0 second. F— A ,70 z I Inter letter spacing increases letter and word legibility. This is especially important to motorist-oriented signs. i The effect of stroke width definitely affects legibility, but is related to letter size and spacing. Generally, however, it should be noted that a stroke width one-fifth (1/5) the height of a letter yields excellent legibility. THE MOTORIST AND SIGNS In a study pertaining to reading characteristics, memory and attention value, it was i noted that: a. Witn five'(5) words or less in a head) ne, ninety percent (90%) of t e su leas correct y remembarad b. The:`'n�mbar'rif "thought units"-one signinfluences recall. When there were more than t_.ren mealaoes coommunicat;T'6n a"�i'ngle i s gn, recall decreased rapidly. The California Division of Highwayt now feels thit a total ot_thrae (3) Imes are t e MGM,m num er of lines s of inform tionTo—Fany Iven sign. Complex response times are longer than simple movement response:. Response time increases as a function of angular displacement from the direct line of vision, and as a function of the number of stimuli. i CONTROLLING THE VIEWER'S ATTENTION The attention jetting value of a stimulus is roughly proportional to the square root of the arse. (i.e., a 25 sq. ft. sign has only 5 time, the attention getting value of a 1 sq. ft. sign — not 25 times as greet.) After attention has been gained, it must be held momentarily. This m- p y Tiov"RWthe sign a degree of unity. Unity" raau is ram the interrction of -NMWnrous a ei ri n s. It should be,noted.that although fi tees, faces and bri ht'colors can in n t y a etrimenta to an overa u evades as these becam dominant a emsnt a—FRF—UnTo—rtunately the — at the XF= of the nsor's idynt�ty, his has been proved d�ec_isl_velY in psychological experiment Involving dominant backgrounds and figures,iz a rnents showed conclusively that the thing the reader could recall was the name a or t e 111T • COLOR j:ND "CON&PiCUiTY•• An experiment attempted to determine at what point a white sign became con• spicuous in a rural setting. The subjects were told to walk back in a field until they felt the sign was judged to be adequate. Black lettering was represented by strips of wood attached to the white surface. The results revealed that at 250 yards a white sign had to be 16 square feet in area. A second ex iment attempted to determine the amount by which si ns i virigui 'VTlors woMW hagg to be ra—rFe—r or sma er wail con icuous. The results in terms of the amount of area a colored sign had to exoW a white sign were: Yel� lore Ora White Red Blue Green Black� .g% 0 0 7% 24% 42% 126% A later test, conducted in an urban business street using simbar procedures,gave results very similar,to these. In conclusion. to be conspicuous under open conditions at 250 yards,turns of different colors have to be of different sites. To be Nually conspicuous in shaded arras the colored n arm NNO to De doubled. Black Slue Red Orange Yellow White 36 sq.ft. 22 sq. ft. 18 sq.ft. 16 sq.ft. 14 sq. ft. The results of these experiments have been_Included in this manual tollUrate the fallacy of current signing legislation lion which Ignores the relationships of color and tic --� area and also to serve as a General reference for d WRIninq aqua)•'ooropicuity" for �- signs of--different colors. r i . DESIGN REQUIREMENTS FOR GRAPHIC SYMBOLS AND LOGOS r Effactivi dranhic comet n nation_should lave no room for different interpretations. Its function is to communicate a m effective and alto ax. } Design criteria for outdoor attering have baen noted in the preoading pages. Although criteria for the design of graphic symbol$ cannot be as detailed u that for Uttering styles, there are certain general requirements which should be con- sidered when designing or weighing the merits of a symbol, GRAPHIC SYMBOLS SHOULD: -► 1. Contain only essential elements and be free of minute datail. 2. Be able to be enlarged and reduced without the loss of comprehension of any single element. -#'3. Be as easily understood in black and white as in color. ..* 4. Be simple and tarpt•like, that is, draw the viewer's aye to Itself, as an arrow would find the canter of a hull's-eye. «� S. Be roadily understood and communicate as clearly as possible. Below are a number of graphic symbols. Those on the right conform more closely with the requirements set forth above than those on the left. aor�o ar 11a1.Y • WN1 • r11anCR L All�.� f l , i i S� 1 ! i � I F71 � �reeL w rMt I , H ti'L f WWWREO caw O iiatt pia.. A��• •A 1Vi Vy I ��-Arc=i�4'�=rdr[•�•A � N .r. r iu.t•+••► � S CA vzr r �/�►AP�:1 p.er P.AIV •^ -,LfC.4L .f r ric N c I �S 1� • l I ` Y tf h f; 1' 1 I I i. IJ rr r I I petiti ��n Comm i s-; i on . Member of The Plannrng , Let this petition Serve ,. comm:anity c;pposition to the sign permit 087-18 which enable. granting of the special Nilson Ford to erect an electronic sign 50 feet in height with a 400 square foot message board . Our position doe-, not derive from an anti -comrrarce i viewpoint . The right to advertise is historically linked to I constitutional free speech . However . in an area zoned residential . the right to be free from advertisement is lust as critical to protect . A sign , the magnitude of the visible from many of our homes and proposed one , will be back yards . this is not a political battle but a gUality 1 ife issue . #• Members of the commission , ask yourself if you ' d like to look out the window of your home and see a 400 square font electronic advertisement for automobiles . The undersigned homeowners and re�; identc; urge •/orj to protect , and retain the existing limitation-,our quality of homelife on commercial advertising . i Name Address z . 3 . 6 . 7 . 9A,) 8 • .r.., �c''_7.�C Tea •�*G• , r, J 9 . 10 . IL 12 . 11 ' ►-' � .77 i Name ,..r.� - A d d s s r 417 ilt 13. �,/� - ��. �• �' � �� L 9 . 21 J/%i1`-Ly'C f C. �., t!'�'�►� � f.lr•� .aJ'r!. .; �'"'�.�� �.� ;II YA 2 S.� J •�fj[�l): � �- t•. � �1'f�.t-�:i` 1�' i ��`t, \ .1-••`.\.1aw'• '� `•��..1 f a .� i r, 26 . ki 27. r 2© 2n' ; . . l '< .V I i. •C 32 . �tirL.Lr.., 1 ; , ,� ' .J , ��,(..!�/a_f�.a �.a .. �;1, ;;r�..r,f •�`7rl_'J:�.j - I` 33 . .��. '. � '.� ' . t•t 't• ,.( 1�. . • �� ( c t��l, �1)-.7 `� G �� �'. 34 . al/Alf 1 0 1 1� /r` Ili.'1 ,�►,(• �� 3ti . 36. kA 3-0 . r 10 10 i i Name Address , 39. 40. 41 . r C;_�,j• � .i f� �.. ; tom• '�•+ � t i •I�r' . •. , f 1 t�l l 4 2 . r 43 . i � I J 45 •� 46 . P 47 . 48 . 49. 50 52• 53. 54 . 1. IL t�1•'��t)t:try_ y" 95. �.'.. t I 56 . 97 59. . � . 1 61 . 62 . ' 1 63 . C •�,r,�,.. ( � . � // ��.• /}mot... 'i', .�9 100, January 271 1988 Huntington peach Civic: Center 20CA ,fain Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 RR; Citizens, householder, and taxpayers against the approval of i Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 and Code Amendment No. 87-15. ,1TCN: Mike Adams - Planning Contuission tax ace and owner of properties in The below signod residence and tY located at 18255 Beach Blvd., the isclediate aces of W; 1son Ford Co" y Huntington Beach, do herein wish to voice their opinion in nS nisPermitlNST the issuance of a permit to erect a gin the Code Pmendment No. 67-15. ;b. 87-18 and are definitely against modifying onst on Zhe conczrned below n sebothinoticesens ve met in group and have viewedstheion-site and off since receiving the of 'dilson Ford and find that the tsoconsidecationcalled t the imotor dveficledtraffic rtecesnary• If, You would take in the distraction of this sign an on Beach Blvd., which hic wouldbe hindered by ; would caul s. rom 'just stop and think, the Ford sign thataisinnw50 feet linv the bair le fwith a two bla:k :,ucr:unding area. Now envision 9 40q ;;ciuclCG feet of space, which would liyht up a mile area, this we do not need. ' Irtic:ittng our feelings sand denial not necessary changing anyf Code modification or No. 87-15, we wish to stat(! it is changing at this time- Let us not make Beach Blvd. and Automobile Row much 1 as you have now on Harbor 31vd. in Costa M"sa• .s� you for taking the tine to read this at your hearing and we thank y sincerely hope that our feelings and recommendations are adhered to. Respectfully, Address Name C. 7 if /'yy�7 : v1 �L ��'� 18341 Pammy Lane, H. . W 1, .am WaitLo f► J r. 1 341 panmy �„Gp Lane,.ga Emhof f; �A Ly�r-�r.. � • � N 00 it i Nartv Address it -------------- Page 2 of 2 1 ! CERTIFICATION BY DISPLAY OWNER COVERING MESSAGE CENTER DISPLAYS The undersigned hereby. certifies that they desi.re'to place a message center display• on *their property and understand that such display may only be used to advertise the business con- ducted or services rendered or goods produced or sold on the property on which the display is to be placed. In addition, the undersigned certifies that said display will be operated so that it meets the following criteria: 1• (�s) the proposed display wi11 have, 'I (b) The display 1 t: (d) y a �•ltiro�.nstare.: x�� r¢t i (signature) J*, i g� J STATE OF CALIFORNIA OEPAR`NT uF TRANSPORTATION OUTDOOR ADVE11TI.SING BRANCH t111,111) ".I III•IIItllis SplII.1• . 11%h►K,RTA)ION rai UILO1nQ, 1170 N ST""T.p.0. DO% IAtta. SACRANRMTO.CALI►OR1+IA WS"D 111,1111 I flit•. I APPLICATION FOR STATE OUTDOOR (11tr1, ........ .......... ....... ...... ........ I�t11.f Aili1• ..........I.... .....I.. ADVERTISING STRUCTURE PERMIT A11dif N1,. .......... ................ llAR•>ranlyd ...........• C.It.No. ............ I'nn►plelc•all.Sectiuns.A copy will be returned fur your records.Imsuance of a perlttit will be delayed unless all items are filled in till {III-ttrutler fees remitted.Make Check,.,money urdvrX,We.,payable to tht• I)vpurtlnvnt 1►f Trunsportatiun. •1,•11111111rry ttaview Ftrlluval Kea ............ >f:{II.INI >f .................... Ipphl•atlun Fri.01811- arldahly) tiaU.11U ! •tr111{IFee-(rerundabieIr application not '.""" V-shrtpedatruc•tureuare ltpploted unlelrr previously riled) ........... 1111.0111 Sie}►urute displays and I r r Ildtlt k'eetassesred Irappli-111 placed require r+epurate upliuvatione. .Irurture prior its approval) 1U.IIt1 .................... All pe'rmils expire Devember:31. DISPLAY OWNER iiir.+•r,i 1ii1�;l•liiril�,H�ri�;.il;i�ii e.i a'�.%_........_.,_..._...._... _ IYc1A1 8.1all 11)'lIN ..�lsa '1/NII#I1h11 -�4 ___. LnUlt�Qn -PWch, sa �rl• PROPERTY OWNER Oil 11RUSON IN CONTROLCONTROLOr 111tUlll;lt'1'1' III/UN Willell DISPLAY IS SITUATEN) `. sm— MINI IVI,f1 .+\ If eonxent to placing is written check here C! -'`/i in• `— PROPERTY OWNER MUNT SIIIN IIXIjIs if curt.ent ix VERBAL I)inpiny to be Installed in ORR1ur;t^ _.._/IILNTII 'ICId 13t:Ju^u N _.r.._. on the _UEST __.. side of#3a n./Alf,d �l.f �/) A1,11ufl.Wlihh�kdilNl1 A...I:u• AI-Ill h,t1 r l:u t xlulruti.rrir►aT.�,ull:—"" , z'—..___ F vet/Miles ._,90(j� _ Of TAyTnp Df?rS11;, 1. Proposed installation daft! 5 1 88 a•Icr'a Identification No. If display has been cited,Nutice No.__ I/v pluced by Ef.E7CTRA'IWIA Display Location Sketch: 8110w U.S. or State Route Numbers or Name Of Street; Show Nume of Nearest. Crotiyroud, Over/Underna.4s, or Nrure;,t Landmark; Indicate Sinl;ir 1'lilit.1 <hu,Ihu:;--V. Show diatance� of displuy 11•I,nI intel•liectieln. N !; Indicate V-shuneei Dinl,iuy DESCRIPTION OF1)Isp1.AY Material(IIli.,1,► W+F:C1 S SPACE'FllttLut•,gIYUN:+KP:1('1F 1'uncl: Ilcil;ht Y- ItcngthZ9I 11Wjjud [ Alvtui ® Uthlr l.) 1 llprighta:Numbv ' ' a i r_...2_..iJxe�l p �S7 CJ 1)islionce hetween punt-1 and ground 41 11111 ► i ( 1 Illumination?_ ...._..,.1(rrlrr.Nlr Ai/atrr is+l" no 1•opy lint,side ❑ !loth Icitlt•>. 1 4 !, f lndirate tacing V-rthaped dirpluy ❑ 1 1 rldtertilting('up>•: 1 1 . 11 , ! t11 i ( If � , 1 1 1 ' W11SM FORD � � � } � ► fl ' li � l ` -�- 'i'h1a11p11ranl hereby aKrreatoplaeeKndtnrinluinlhrnd+l•rti�in dr„rib, •11,LN•r)tuninr:nrdin /•er,and tiny nlhrr wpplir.tlAr Ir►;ulatian�.'I'hr upplic.lul 1•rtlil7e�IIt1/1 i111•w1ulrinetll,.mule in Ihi+.rpplictlliun ore lru,,.... K Idtthntrinnl•runinnrrwilhlhrptutiriunru/lheOutdanrAdvrrtfdl[ �t+1 uuder%tuad%that y tiro reel I+trl meat u11-1 no-is be gluon, W, the t11•niut ufu prlmit u1 fill n lucwtlun it in 1116y tilliv llo FF �rc:N t>Y�K� ,�x.s �. •..0 lyN 11 rmn tier , 1!I„,if ,,. 11 j California, _ •�"C,Z ]� �� """auo M uoA= NO'1'K �. KE, HIISk" l Sa E FUI,f$ 1,,1t•kAlENT CRITERIA Muhl ttit?"n'1111.1"ti IVI Ftednr,tl•A1d . vo:ael S.� r / tlrun;tr� and Intulbi'lle Nlynways t L . REOIEST FOR CITY COUI`P%jIL ACTION June 20, 1988 I Date Honorable Mayor and City Council Submitted to: strator�•c Submitted by: Paul Cook, City Admir.i Prepared by: Douglas N. La Belle, Director, Community Development Subject: APPEAL OF PLANB?N15COMMISSION'S ((CONTINUED k'ROMDENIAL MAACH 28, 1988) AMENDMENT NO Consistent with Council Policy? I ] yes New Policy or Exception Statement of Issue, Recommendation,Analysis, Funding Source,Alternative Actions,Attachments: 4 Transmitted for your consideration are the recommendations of the Planning Commission and staff relative to the PP eal Of Commission's denial of Codanning e Amendment No. 87-15. Code Amendment No. Rod 87-15 is a request by Wilson ctronicrreaderboardsresented ywithinithenCity of Electra-Media, to permit ele the Huntington Beach. Then dareferred to the code ued mPlanning March 28, 1988 City Council meeting a Commission for further rtovallowielectronicommendation eaderboardspsubject to alternative ordirt certain criteria. The Planning Commission met and took action on the code amendment on May 3, 1988• ion reviewed the suggested criteria by the The Planni.td Commies ommittee, City Council and staff and took Planning Commission Subc the following votes: A STRAW VOTE MOTION WAS 5 FEET BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: ADE Y SILVA, SECOND BY ON A MAXIMUM SIGN HEIGHT OF 3 AYES: Slates, Silva, Bourguignon NOES: Leipzig ABSTAIN: Ortega I f A STRAW VOTE MOTION WAS MADE BY SILVA, SECOND BY SLATES, ON A MAXIMUM SIGN AREA OF 200 SQUARE FEET, BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: ! AYES: Slates, Silva, Bourguignon NOES: Ortega, Leipzig FTAW VOTE MOTION PASTED Staff was instructed to forward the following recommendations to the City Council should they approve Code Amendment No. 87--15: gecommen a ;on A. Entitlement for CUP & PSP with Design Review Board processing ERB and Public Works approval B. Locational Limited to Beach Blvd. (excluding Criteria landscape corridor portion south of Adams to Pacific Coast Highway) and i parcels with freeway frontage. C. Min. Lot Frontage 200 ft. D. Min. distance to 150 ft. residential E. Min. distance to 100 ft. interior property i line F. Min. distance 150 ft. between ERB signs G. Max. # of ERB signs One per site i H. Max. sign height 35 ft. with 10 ft. min, ground clearance I. Max. sign area 200 sq.ft, max. -- (total sign area limited to twice the ERB portion) J. Intensity/C►laze Cylinders, shade screen and photocell for reducing intensity of lighting at night; maximum measurable light output shall not exceed 5 foot candles at the property line. K. Other signage In addition to the electronic on-site readerboard sign, only one monument sign (maximum 7 fe2t in height, 50 square feet in sign) may be permitted and all other signage shall be brought into conformance RCA - 6/20/88 with the Sign Code. -2w (0740d) I L. Message criteria 1. Message changes No faster than 1 message every 4 i seconds 2. Min. interval 1 second between messages 3. Continuous motion Not permitted 4. Light intensity Not permitted changes (other than between day and night uses M. Hours of Operation 6:30 P14-10:30 FM N. Public Service 10% of message time or as deemed Announcement necessary by the City for j emergency conditions. A MOTION WAS MADE BY SILVA, SECOND BY BOURGUIGNON, TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF CODE AMENDMENT NO. 87--15 TO THE CITY COUNCIL, WITH SUGGESTED CRITERIA, BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: I AYES: Slates, Silva, Bourguignon NOES: Leipzig, Ortega ABSENT: Livengood, Higgins ABSTAIN: None JET QM F ILED - PLANNING COMMISSION HY-LAWA REQUIRE A MINIM M QF FotM VOTES TO APPROVE OR_RENY A C012E 8=NQMEIQT A MOTION WAS MADE BY LEIPZIG, SECOND BY ORTEGA TO RECONSIDER THE PREVIOUS MOTION FOR APPROVAL, BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: Slates, Leipzig, Ortega, Bourguignon NOES: None ABSENT: Livengood, Higgins ABSTAIN: Silva MTIQA MB ED - (It should be noted that the Planning Commission acted to reconsider in order to provide a minimum 4 votes to allow the Code Amendment to precede back to the City Council) . I l i RCA - 6/20/88 -3- (0740d) i I A MOTION WAS MADE BY SLATES, SECOND BY LEIPZIG, TO REAFFIRM PREVIOUS PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION TO DEiJY (FEBRUARY 2, 1988) AND RECOMMEUD TO THE CITY COUNCIL DENIAL OF CODE AMENDMENT NO. 87-15, WITH FINDINGS, BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: Slates, Silva, Leipzig, Ortega NOES: None ABSENT: Livengood, Higgins ABSTAIN: Bourguignon NOTION PASSE T.TNDIN05FQR DENTAL: i � 1. Since the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, Section 961 (Sign Code) allows adequate opportunities for advertising through various types of signage, Code Amendment No. 87-15 to allow electronic reader board signs is not necessary for the preservation and enjoyment of substantial property rights. 2. Electronic reader board signs, if permitted by Code Amendment No. 87-15; will be incompatible with surrounding existing and proposed developments, especially residential land uses. 3. Electronic reader board signs, if permitted by Code Amendment No. 87--15, will have the potential of creating a congestion and circulation hazard to passing motorists. A MOTION WAS HAVE ':Y SLATES, SECOND BY LEIPZIG, TO RECOMMEND THE SUGGESTED CRITERIA (FIRST MOTION) BY PLANNING C%JMISSION, j BASED UPON STAFF AND SUBCOMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS, AND FORWARD i TO THE CITY COUNCIL TO BE INCLUDED IN ORDINANCE SHOULD CODE AMENDMENT NO. 87-15 BE APPROVED, BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: i AYES: Slates, Silva, Leipzig, Ortega, Bourguignon NOES: None ABSENT: Livengood, Higgins ABSTAIN: None TIQN PASSED Ordinance No. 2946-A has been prepared in accordance with the recommendations of the Planning Commission. �Re����t'yn: i ` Staff recommendation is to uphold the original action of the Planning Commission on February 2, 1988, by denying Code Amendment No. 87-15. Should the City Council choose to approve Code Amendment No. 87-15, it is recommended Ordinance No. 2946-B be adopted which includes criteria as suggested by staff. RCA - 6/20/88 -4- (0740d) ANALY6xs: Applicant: Wilson Ford 18255 Beach Boulevard Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Location: City-wide ackstround: Code Amendment No. 87-15, a request to allow electronic readerboard signage by amending the list of prohibited signs in the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, was denied by the Planning Commission with findings on February 2, 1988. The Planning Commission appointed a subcommittee to further study the issue and look into the possibility of allowing electronic readerboards in return for minimizing existing signage. The subcommittee raet and drafted a list of possible restrictions which could be applied to electronic readerboards. The City Council on March 28, 1988 (acting on an appeal of the Planning Commission's denial) continued Code Amendment No. 87-15 and tyro associated entitlements (Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 and 87-19, requests for two freestanding signs that are 50 feet in height in lieu of 15 feet with sign area exceeding 200 sgaare feet in size in lieu of maximum 70 square feet) , for 90 days and referred the code amendment to the Planning Commission for evaluation and recommendation upon an alternative ordinance that would allow electronic readerboards subject to certain location and design standards as recommended by the Planning Commission Subcommittee and ' Department of Public Work's (see May 3, 1988 Planning Commission staff report) . Also, at the City Council meeting, the Council requested further criteria for the code amendment as follows: (1) Require photo cell for reducing intensity of lighting at night. (2) Maximum sign area should be 200 square feet. (3) All readerboard signs should conform with State regulations (CalTrans) . i (4) Define what arterials would be appropriate. With five Planning Commissioners � Commission reviewed the Suggestedpresent on May 3, 1988, the � nin Commission subcommittee, Ccouncil, and staff, and criteria by the nacted to approve a modified code amendment to allow ERB subject to certain location criteria and design standards by a 3 to 2 vote. However, because the Planning Commission By-Laws states that a code amendment needs affirmative vote of four (4) members to approve or, deny, their action was negated. RCA - 6/20/88 -5- (0740d) A reconsideration motion was made to allow another vote (minimum 4 votes) that would facilitate processing the code amendment back to the City Council rather than a two week delay and continuance to the next Planning Commission meeting. The new vote was to reaffirm the Planning Commission's action on February 2, 1988, to deny Code amendment 87-15 with findings. In addition, a motion was made to recommend the Planning Commission's suggested criteria for the code amendment should the City Council approve electronic readerboards. I Issues'. Staff has polled all Orange County cities and found very few which allow electronic readerboard signage. There are a few existing non-conforming signs and others which have been allowed by variance. Some of these signs are located on surface streets. Generally, the larger, taller signs are situated to attract freeway passers-by. Staff has compiled a list of all the electronic signs I in Orange County and many outside of the County along with a locational map. Staff continues to recommend denial of the proposed code amendment to allow electronic readerboard signage within the City for the reasons stated within the original RCA dated March 21, 1988. Should the City Council approve the concept of electronic readerboards, then staff has prepared an alternative ordinance for consideration. The major differences between staff recommended ordinance (Ordinance No. 2946-H) and the Planning Commission recommended ordinance (Ordinance No. 2946-A) , if approved, is as follows: i Staff Planning Commission j Recommendation Recommendation Is (if 1192Yoyed) (if AR2r0yed) Max. Sign Height 15 ft. 35 ft. with 10 ft. ground clearance Max. Sign Area 70 sq.ft. 200 sq.ft. (total sign area limited to twice the electronic reader- board portion) Min. Lot Frontage 400 ft. 200 ft. Staff's recommendation is designed within the Framework of the existing sign code for 15 foot high signs. Signs greater than 7 feet but no higher than 15 feet are permitted up to 70 square feat in size on parcels having more than 400 feet of frontage in order to provide greater separation between signs. A variance would be required for signs exceeding these requirements which could then be reviewed on a case-by-case basis. RCA - 6/20/88 -6- (0740d) Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 and No. 87-19 are scheduled for the July 5, 1988 City Council meeting. The Subcommittee Meeting comments and memorandum from Bruce Gilmer, Traffic Engineer, are attached to the May 3, 1988 Planning Commission staff report. IR9MUM GT.Ads_: ! The proposed project is exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act. INQ~souRCE: i Not applicable. ALTERNATIV ACTION&: 1 (A) The City Council may adopt Ordinance No. 2946-A as suggested by the Planning Commission with the following findings for approval; or (8) The City Council may adopt Ordinance No. 2946-8 as suggested by staff with the following findings of approval.. FINDING. S FOR APPROVAL: g, ' 1. Code Amendment No. 87-15 to allow electronic readerboards ! within the City creates additional signagu opportunities. r, 2. Code Amendment No. 87-15 to allow electronic readerboards on sites abutting a freeway and Beach Boulevard, excluding the portion of Beach Boulevard designated as a landscape corridor south of Adams Avenue to Pacific Coast Highway is consistent with the Huntington Beach General Plan. 3. Code Amendment No. 87-15 to allow electronic readerboards subject to a conditional use permit, certain design criteria and location requirements will assure compatibility with surrounding land uses. 4. Message criteria as part of Code Amendment No. 87-15 to permit electronic readerboards will reduce potential traffic hazards. b7 'A NENT&: I. Reconunended criteria if Code Amendment is approved, including a comparison of subcommittee, staff and Planning Commission recommendations. 2. Draft Ordinance No. 2946-A (Planning Commission recommendation, { if approved) i 3. Draft Ordinance No. 2946-B (Staff recommendation, if approved) 4. Draft Planning Commission minutes dated May 3, 1988 5. Planning Commission staff report dated May 3, 1988. 6. RCA dated March 21, 1988 DLB:SH:kla RCA - 6/20/88 -7- (0740d) r . r . 001 ! COMPARISON MATRIX OF RECOMMENDED( CRITERIA FOR ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGIiAGE 5ubcom++ittee Staff Planning Commission Issue Recogenlation R122MA-g,Btion RecgM:D ation5 (if afl r+r,rovedl A. Entitl"*nt for CUP/PSP CUP i PSP with Design CUP i PSP with Design Review processing ERB Review Board and Public Board and Public Works Works approval aoproval i B. Locational Limited to major Limited to Beach Blvd. Limited to Beach Blvd. (exclud— Criteria arterials except PCH (except landscape ing landscape corridor portion j and landscap* corridors corridor) and freeway south of Adams to Pacific Coast (see Attachments 6 L 7) frontage Highway) and parcels with freeway frontaga C. Min. Lot Frontage 200 ft. Min. 400 ft.* 200 ft. 0. Min. distance to 15o ft. 150 ft. 150 ft. residential E. Min. distance to 100 ft. 100 ft. 100 ft. interior proporty line F. Min. distance Greater than 200 ft. 150 ft. 150 ft. between ERB signs G. Max. N of ERB signs n/a One Ona per site H. Max. sign height 35 ft. with 10 ft. 1S ft.• 35 ft. with 10 ft. min. ground min. ground clearance clearance I. Max. sign area 275 sq.ft. max. — 70 sq.ft.' 200 sq.ft. max. — (total sign sign area limited to area limited to twice the ERB twice the ERB portion; portion) Council recommendation: max. 200 sq.ft. J. Intensity/Glare Cylinders. shade screen same Cylinders, shade screen and and photocell for photocell for reducing intensity reducing intensity of of lighting at night; maximum lighting at night. measurable light output shall not ex:eed 5 foot candles at the property line. • Consistent with Current Muntinpton Beach sign code requirements for all types of freestanding signs. •'Cal Trans Mquirement n/a • not addressed 4 • 1 �a i Subcomsiittec Staff Planning Carn+ission jssue Rt;on n ion Recormendationn RecgMendations ls� rt, v 4 I ' K. Other signage All signage brought into All signage brought In addition to the electronic on—site conformance. max. into conformance" readerboard sign. only one monu— allowable wall signage ment sign (maximum 7 reet in reduced to 100 sq.ft., height. 50 square foot in area) temporary banners per— ma/ be permitted and all other mitted for two 15—day signage shall be brought into periods. conformance with the Sign Code. L. Message criteria i 1. Message changes No faster than 1 message Same Same every 4 seconds" i 1. Mia. interval 1 second" Same Sam# between messages 3. Continuous Not permitted" Sion* :an1e motion 4. Light intensity Not permitted" Same Same t changes (other I than between day and night u:es N. H)urs of Operation n is 8:00 AM-10:00 PM 6:30 AM-10:30 PM N. Public S-trvict n/a 10% of message time 10% of message time or as Announcement or as doomed deemed necessary by the necessary by the City for emergency City for emergency conditions. conditions. • Consistent with current Huntington Beach sign code requirments for all types of freestanding signs. •" CalTrans requirement n/a not addrr-sed I i �a fr �. � , ..� / rw.�+S "'` "I' ^) ♦ �. 1, `,, , i ,tr s _ iw ;\�',T • 'j` r 't� + ,� �* :1 � Y1t .+' � �,� •� +} '\. f� �'r ��+ 7� ..1. * ._r:, ° '� .�5. � .a ,i,, f ;fry rl. i ,1 �„ •!may Y 'l �, a � } "•.✓ :tr 't t� C f,. ,' � ti+ ia; Y 1' �4 �rY' i ,.�i', t Ir yrXl=�( ,� i,"�., ;1 � ;Y 1•r f'' Lp's.� ':•; ,i ft j, v } t'+-tT '',�:;� �`t , '' }.a� , ,� +' ! •'ii- �..?:� r , Ii 1'. i;i,. vi. :'1�. , .,/. ,F �, 1 t ' t ♦ "'� 1 TYy ti d r �1 . et r ,t ,^�,. ,,.r a'- y� •�., i ,r•,. '•* lf.j:' .�-! r ,r -n. � ,� .t.r (�'�' * -`q 'f: i.' ,;.;.5't'i + r• tY ,�, 1°�„� y, , r ✓� .r ,',. y-.t .1' ^�.'.( r�. r,t'�.• t+ ;t e r.�r..:?)� t f� <.t, 4 i �1 ,. n ir'.^t•.C' f 1 7^•r i l�ti ;...��' •tN - t ;{..� t\.V f.•?lt''1',J•;t-M ,1 rw}� ..etrr s .i, .r .,�' , '.t �a.{. .,h. .ir+. +.� i'.,rl.i'}21` ,.� `'� yy r,� .t• � s'? I��rf'�. .tic, -a� 4! � *,f. iy �,:'j7 �,, ,►,ir ';r,r :t f.Li f .'i''Dryy .{j +Ij; �; ,i.,f.:''+.a,'?�>r. r^ ;\��, .t:ia �C••t 1f1p '•�. '�.r+Ai .'� .ra�,�+ r.+ y�i,:l,�r,,. Y y r "r•r irS•• ;r.!;�t k� t,`{...� 'r.t,_ •+' f,• :Y ,rf�p+f-1,r, ->4 ,f � �1,' y�'1. �'i�,.,�. F rf, ! ! 'Y. , r�.�. ,1.+' 3�,A .� -J� '�r�' r.' \. .1� I r.rf t. ♦f .I' '; �-4 1 .'� 'a + !.1, ,'�% .) .�.k lrj r rf'� i,L,. � .r°�;�,r�^,' y�. t'itu. rr"}�, �'^(:n•.t 1l f: ''I P .I� fl ,• .� l•r�ti tr. ::k� .l1 .i��f .v•.1 ".1`� ►• dti lr :yll.• W+;i�.>'",/•3•. �P+, ,.�\1.1�/� �,�+-r �r, '.,` ;ft.{, f.'.. M .,�' 1,� a y. � I,uf .iy};4��4,',t._ i�l � ,q•r.r},ht�� .rt• (. „r �,�r a... . 'r:ro,•� �•rf � .Ers-f o a„ ,S .'} ,+4 y• :.'�` �-l. �1 :f.'hf t;. 1 ('•i. .,i, r, ,tj,:!(. ,�.`n ..r) '-rf .�,�}. r ,'S :.1"t•:' r.(.y' .'f, �!•-�r c; .4 r. ? -,4:r n i'.Ir, 1•:. � 'r�, >+ 7 ,•n 1q)—s' .at �i .i^f 'f. '1 -'r '°� 'i', '.!t{, ..r nr• •S }1'� �,,•Sl•)1. .e�::�,• L.i;.�r ,,{ ,<, '. - ; .'i r�trr rrr F 1, f'} 1 i. ::�,- °,r •'ir. l 1. '.{ �►. '.a,`•.1 , 1•r�t t ..fr i.�y' 'if 'f I .y `,All .'+; ; ,�..ii.. y ,,5. ,�y. .r "(.'r�;t;r,r:a�l,r,l.�,,N4-t,l,. •5 T../rlt.,1r1+. ,y 1 ,f�rri �+', . {(yy+/5 +- M '.:f ii�}:-..r ter �$1 1{'i�r, ;'j,!�:. .-'•. .1'l. `r.I tr•:I' r./.!; f. 'J rt..,t y .�. �°�• (. Y .,�� y.• h� 1 +�t...1 ..f.,(.., 4-♦s'`�� i�' 7. { i 1, l.'' il`Er.r.l.,.f.�1•+� 5 �y�� 'Ir'f A' A' 1�/-'�.1 • � '` 1r hw� y • Y � .�` .1. eT`.r}-l. .+. `t� ,1'_1.• r•q ? ,�.. r ;uq•.Y.w,...� r+tt 7r�h .lt., ..y r..l '1 t(w � t .�G , �•, r � �tt'i rr{ �.r1+4h{',., fi�'' '1 y�r4+, v .'j,�:},i..i i'- ,P '(1 r '� j. ,w, �{�• r, •if, j ,r ,'}.l,xe. .,.,'ls -� tf.r, ,.y�! -,�•r{!, '(r ,� F. ,}�13 r,�. .+ �'S:}• ,.l,�r.r I�,.�r�. �:.i. �... { ,:J ,1 ,} a } Re��' '. � ..v, i ry lf,'L:. .' ,�� 1 {'i t �,t �+. 4 •,�;' 1, {ff. 4 �,`f. ,r P :I ,.YiY 'r'} i•, ., a +.•:;1!1 ,� 1 � �; { ,.31 \� .i.p;r? �7.:'7 ....,S `�:. i t;"'h•i r kr... lr,. f,.,(1•• 1 4•U'r.,..C. .t.,(,• Yw,1 %r �, l: �f..t.' t,S� r ,.��t 5y�fy.i ,L 1, L ` 1. /.+y4• .1'•l'y r' ,1 ',t i' r 1r. 1'.. 1 f y n` nA5�5_�,, i;,, •,d.• r.S�If,.t: �j.� �.,.:�1 . 2!r hlt',!1 s,1.,.,q, '#1s:1 -f � Jt�:.lt.t'.,C."l��',!{:1�! �-v{ :,1�"'i'rt al.•F t'f.{id��_�#,..� �} a:{d11.�3•. 1��,�.i.t il�/S1:•ti�•rr`.•;r�.'27• 4 '• r���.`.r f i � f , 4 r �. ..�.�o.,.--....._ _ __. Publish 6/9/88 rrt OF � = _DFAr ^Q THE Pt,ANNING COIKI$$ i �•ns►�rr?rm�tF 87-15 i (To amend the Huntington Beach Zoning Ordinance to allow electronic reader boards) NOTICE it; HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a pul�lic hearing continued oven in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to rbeeheardnrelativeconsider tothe thestatements applicationf all described persons who wish to b �I below. � �l►'TE/TI Monday, June 20, 1988, 7:00 PM, - public hearing continued open from 3/28/88 f m p g; Code Amendment No. 87-15 -- (Appeal) Wilson Ford Rod Wilson Electra Media To amend Article 961 (Sign Code) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code to allow electronic reader boards. The Planning Commission has reviewed a draft ordinance for the proposed electronic reader boards for City Council consideration. AL STATU Exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act. A copy Of the pro.taised request is on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, for inspection • by the public »4T1 ; The continued public hearings on the two appeals filed by Rod Wilson, Electra Media, relative to Special Sign Permit: 87-18 and Special Sign Permit 87-19 are s,haduled for the July 5, 1988 Council MeW ng. .'ELT. INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions, please call Diana Blaisure, Assistant Planner at 536-5271. HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL By: Alicia M. Wentworth City Clerk Phone (714) 536-5405 Dated 6/7/88 Legal Notice City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.0.Box 190 ' i' Si2 4 Huntington Bench,CA 92648 I' 142-481-12 T.Uernatz 2914 r. Katella nve.#203 Orange,Cn.92667 i n e FIRST CLASS MAID. WATNGTOM ofKTI i1 i i i 7. What colors are rewrrmended for outdoor use? $. Haw much information can an observtr remember in a single reading? i RESEARCH SOURCES Contributions to'the final version of this publication have been made by a number of agencies. We are grateful for the assistance offered by: The University of California at Los Angeles Education-Psychology Library Dr: Alban Burg and the U.C.L.A. Institute of Transportation and Traffic Engineering r-� Foster and Kielur Outdoor Advertising The Automobile Club of Southern California t A bibliography follows the information found herein. I I i THE MOTORIST AND LETTER LEGIBILITY There are two types of situations which involve the motorist and signs: 1 4 1. Signs within the driver's direct cone of vision while driving. 2. Signs outside the driver's direct cone of vision. The first case is primarily a matter of vehicular motion related to letter legibility. However, in the second case the perpendicular distance from the: sign to the road• way becomes an important factor. I i Consider, first of all, a sign within the driver's direct cone of vision: As previously noted in this section, there are five limitations which are imposed on the motorist. The effects of these limitations have been Illustrated in a diagram relating speeds of 40. 50, and 60 mph. The following graphs are extrWons from this diagram, and were also published in Hamilton and Thurston's Human Limitations in Automobile Driving. They relate vehicular motion to letter legibility, I � ' iL 2200 34 !000 34 M 1150 tad j 1500 I D � w, 1260 !� f ' r. 1000 O ! 1 I w la Soo 1 4 i ISO , 10 a a « 10 15 20 Z! X 15 40 a 50 SS so iS To 0 !Ob K?0 6A0 aao g0011OON00 Nco 1600 too6 SPEED 1Y PN 1 LEi1i1L1Tr O;1T�11Gt IrT.I i Thee graphs should be utilized when attempting to determine the letter height requirements for signs oriented to the freeway or highway motorist. They apply only to signs which are on the property the sign pertains to, and must be viowad at a distance sufficient enough to permit the motorist to retake a safe exit from the motor ' .. way. A gac station sign is a prune example. .. ..... ... ...�-....-�. -..,r...w . _r ... ,sir:. CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH INTER-DEPARTMENT COMMUNICATION M WUNGTON 11ACM 1 i To Hal Simmons, Sr. Assoc. Planner From Connie Brockway, Deputy City Clerk Subject Code Amendment 87-15 Date June 30, 1988 Special Sign Permits 87-18 b 87-19 Attached are copies of the mailing labels received from Rod Wilson, Electra fiedia, regarding Code Amendment 87-15, Special Sign Permit 87-18 and Special Sign Permit 87-19. There was no certification as to the validity of the list and would you please check it out for us. We need your verification of the list by July 6. Thanks. CB:bt i i i i 1 i 1 INTER-DEPARTMENT COMMUNICATION 10 M I=101 aLa+ To Hal Simmons, Sr. Assoc. Planner From Connie Brockway, Deputy City Clerk Subject Code Amendment 87-15 Date June 30, 198B Special Sign Permits 87-18 b 87-19 i Attached are copies'of the mailing labels received from Rod Wilson, Electra Media, regarding Code Amendment 87-15, Special Sign Permit 87-18 and Special Sign Permit 87-19. There was no certification as to the validity of the list and would you please check it out for us. We need your verification of the list by July 6. Thanks. CB:bt j OJwc.i. cook R. 77 1208 Poinsettia Ave. / Manhattan Beach, CA 90266 / 213-379-5149 :• ime 28, 1988 Ms. Diana Bla-isure Planning Department 3rd £loon City Hall 2000 Main Street Humtington Bah, Ca. 92648 Dear Diana: Please reschedule the Code Amendment and the two Special Sign Permits as j follows; t! - Co3e Ameznt #87-13 for Public Hearing on i/18/88 I - Spacial Sign Permit #87-19 for Public Hearing m 8/l/80, (Huntington AbE) - Spacial Sign Permit #87-18 for-Public Hearing an 8/15/88, (Wilson Ford) Attached, please find 3 efts of Labels for Huntington AMC and 3 sets of Labels for Wilson Ebrd, as requested by Connie at the City Clerks office. Please call if any atdditional information is needed. If I do not hear from you by 7/1/88 my clients will expect the above calendar schedule. you. I Sincerely, Xod &i"N.— Rod Wilson Ol,ner/Authorived Dealer cc; Daug LaBelle Gail Hutton Cowie Brockway Wilson Pard Huntington AW Awflor e'l Ucap r l W Elertrnnic Visual I Inlomiatwn Systems r. _A t 1 1208 Poinsettia Ave. I Manhattan Beach, CA 90266 / 213-379-5149 f June 28, 1988 Ms. Diana Blaisure Planning Deparbrient 3rd Floor City Hall 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, Ca. 92648 Deer Diana: Please resrhedd.ue the cads Amendwant and the two Special Sign Pexmi.ts as follows; - Cade Ait>vnahmt #87-15 for Public Hearing an 7/18/88 t -- Special. Sign Permit #87-19 for Public Hearing of 8/l/88, (Huntington AM) -- 9_^t,-ial Sign Permit #87-18 for Public Hearing on -1/15/88, (Wilson Ford) :. Attached, please find 3 sets of Labels for Huntington AMC and 3 sets of 1 ` Labels for Wilson Ford, as requested by Connie al- the City Clerks office. f Please call if any additional information is needed. If I do not hear + from you by 7/l/88 my clients will expect the above calendar schedule. Thank you. 1 Sincerely, L Rod Wi.lwn Owner/Authorized Dealer cc: Doug LaBelle Gail Hutton C=iie Brockway Wilson Pord Huntington Mr- I� Qntnow-e t.�CCI ()fltl;VISUa � `" inlot���,7h�n 5�stfms I 0111ce of the City Clerk (" f Huntington '�each 'r°y L__-- - •' ! malty o PRES0PT 1 .�3 � P.O.Box 290 CALIFORNIA926U FIRST rr! 1 ci' rl _:•i` {` _ � ice.y,� •y r ' '� w .•y •~ ��".fir r � � r'a�FO ~j i lua f� r Il �p 9 647 % ' ch, n � �. 'r+� tifitigt'� � � IIIIIIIIillill»Illliiiiiil�liiliililill tts>•f I r � iF+/SaiLl rl: office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Beach t P.O.BOX M CALIFORNIA 92648 C'1R%S r _01.197 . . J3 -10-127 •� Viewpoint % a �uA ton 114ch,Ce 92647 1 i Ililllllllllilillll{111111111111111�11111{Illlllllli { Cityof Huntington Beach , -, r r•.• ;�' `��,_•� I"I' _`is .:.� 1 { �,1 �-_'•.� � , CALIFORNIA 92648 FIRST;�• ��1 1 w ii j P.O.BOX INr i1 ! ;0 ham ��� � ton aerh,CI A2647 I I . I • 4 �I dr 01fics of the City Clerk _.. _ ;;,• e, _ , City of Huntington Beach NRES,0; �"`�.�+ CALIFORNU 92 i r;5 Y �•1., �,, . �� - •i, �' .:;►_=T - • P.O.pox 19 ,,,,.,•,t, r-r �w�"7, .� IaYK dIz2 2YHOW ai�bi mjm, �. NOTIFYj'SCER �It xXWRONG .IjU213 x X;1� fit , . x * * !, * x�CQPt NIRA t: •RN Td C.F.13.''WITH 3575 . L.Byhower S TING M.L.N.A. r OR 18222 Beach :, 6HA E .TO ENTIRE FAMILY Hunting to - --• 1 157-493-02 I� P.Strand W.Turner Ming 1212 Park St. , � 183$1 Pammy Ln. 130'3 Shadow Oak Ln. ' Huntington Beach,Cu�P2648 Huntington Berch,Ca.92648 Malrern,PA 19355 159-043-02 159-043-012 159-271•-66 J.Lebow S.Ekstedi Bank Of America 18271 Pammy Ln. 7836 Connie Dr. Trust- Real Estate Huntington Beach,C.a92646 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 ' P.O. Box 60564 159-043-03 159-271-01 Los Angeles ,Ca.90051 159-271-67 J,.CumJnin s _--_._. -- , ------- i K C Inland Properties . ampbell 18291 Pammy Ln, 7842 Connie Dr. Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 H ,Ca.92646 18377 Beach Blvd. Huntington ach 159--043-04 159-271-02 Huntington Beach,Ca•92648 930-03-401-434 kP 9'3-N-10-a9 g A.Moosa i O.Rosales �,,. Cooke. 18301 Pammy Ln, 7846 Connie Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 15103 6rCy.f'4-*n4L 159-043-05 159-271-03 /�D htt.�r► k'� �` �. J.Armas J.5mith 18311 Pammy Ln. 7852 Connie Dr. Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 159-043-06 159-271-09F- Y.Park O.Folcarelli 18212 Sharon Ln. 18321 Pammy Ln, Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-271-05 159-043-07 H.B. Chamber of Connerce ..Haynes Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Street,2213 Main 2 W.Wamhoff 18202 Sharon Ln. 18341 Pammy Ln, Huntington Beach ,Ca.91648 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-271-06 Attn: Kim Barone 159-043-08 Huntington Beach Co. ?.Contreras J.Bartok 2110 Main Street 15351 Pamray Ln, 18196 Sharon Ln. Huntington Beach, CA Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 012648-2499 159-043-09 159-271-07 H8/FV Board of SeW, Urs D.Ling 8101 Slater Avenue A.Negrete 18205 Sharon Ln. Huntington Beach, CA 92647 18391 Pammy Ln, Huntington Beach C3.92648 Huntington Beach,Ca.92E48 Attn: Judith Severy 159-271-61 159-043-10 Building Industry Assn.-O.C. 2001 E. 4th Street W.Zaleski Huntington Village Santa Ana, CA 7560 Valley Vista 17171 Beach Blvd. HUntington Beach,Ca.92647 Yucca Va11ey,Ca.92284 159-271-63 159-043-11 i YY 7 P.Strand W.Turner T.King 1212 Park St. , ^ 18381 Pammy Ln. 1308 Shadow Oats Ln. Huntington Beacr,,Ca92648 Huntington Peach,Ca.92648 Malvern,PA 19355 159-043-02 159-043-012 159-271-66 J.Lebow S.Ekstedi Bank Of America 18271 Pammy Ln. 7836 Connie Dr. Trust- Real Estate Huntington Beach,C.a92646 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 P.O. Box 60564 1-9-043-03 159-271-01 Los Angeles ,Ca.90051 159-271-67 J, .Cummin s ' 1$291 Pammy Ln, 7842mConnie Dr. Inland Properties Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 18377 Beach 1�lvd. 159-043-04 159-271-02 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 930-03-401-434 A.Moosa O.Rosales H) C1 34-10-V113 18301 Pammy Ln, ' 7846 Connie Ln. 1". Cook`s► Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 1 S'1 G'3 60'efs'�"&*4 159-043--05 159-2 71-03 Np�, ,,,�i k, CA J.Armas J.Smith H. B. Chamber of Comm-arce 1831i Pammy Ln. 7852 Connie Dr. 2213 Main Street #22 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 Attn. Kim Barone 159-043-06 159-271-0�L Y.Park Huntington Beach Company O.Folcarelli 18212 Sharon Ln. 2110 Main Street 18321 Pammy Ln, Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648-249 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-271-05 159-043-07 HB/EV Board of Realtors W.Wamhotf L.Haynes 8101 Slater Ave. 18341 Pammy Ln, 18202 Sharon Ln. Huntington BBeachevCA 92647 f; Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 159-043-08 159-271-06 P.Contreras - i Building Industry Assn/G.C. 18351 reras Ln, f J.Bartok 2001 E. 4th Street Pammy Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 18196 Sharon Ln. Santa Ana, CA. 159-�043-09 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 159-271-07 D.Ling A.h'egrete 18205 Sharon Ln. -�1, , :� •1 18391 Pammy Ln, Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 _._------ ~• ` 4untington Beach,Ca.92648 159-271-61 or 159-043-10 / Huntington Village ?.Zaleski 17171 Beach Blvd. '5613 Valley Vista HUntingtor: Beach,Ca.92647 y - ucca Valley,Ca.92284 /� r r ? � 159-271 59-043-11 --b3 r �> ;� J • U•bimpso•n • Mosenstiel •' 16681 Viewpoint Jamison St. J E. Ln: . Huntington Beach,C.a92646 /•1 2515 2515 a.92806 • 932-1f}• 129 932-LO-130 932-10-141 .1.Foreman J.Heller 1790 Crestmont P1. 16721 Viewpoint Ln. Costa Mesa,C.a92627 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 932-1Q-131 i 932•-10-142 A.Degenhardt D•Lorenzen 13272 Whitney Cir, 16725 Viewpoint Ln. Westminister,C.02683 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 i 932-10-132 932-10-144 L.Frisbia M.Calloway 4531 Sharon Dr. 270 S. Soloamon Dr. La -!ma,Ca.90G23 Anaheim,ca.92807 II 932-IU-•133 932-10-145 I A.Beall J.Evans 16691 Viewpoint Ln. 16731 Viewpoint Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 932-10-134 932-10-146 Y.Perdue H.Wright 218 Main St. 16733 Viewpoint Ln. IfUntington Beach,C.02648 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 932-10•-147 � 932-10-135 J � M.Uhler .Sylva 16695 Viewpoint Ln. 15392 Andaman Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,C.a92649 r� 9 932-10-148 32-10-136 C.Oathout J.Wright 16697 Viewpoint Ln. 16092 Wind2meir l,n. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,C.a92647 e D.Marion , 16711 Viewpoint Ln. IlUntngein Bcach,Ca.92646 932-10-137 i' •i 932-10-138 A.Lopez 6881 Via Carona ' Huntington Beach,C.a92647 932-10M139 Duarte Prop 0071 Slater AVe. 1135 Huntinntnn 8--ch �6 t U-U'/IZ S.Anxis P.Coon R.Bond 17530 Santa Domingo Cir. i"1 7803 Arbor Cir. /1 16654 Arbor Cir. Fountian Valley,Ca.92708 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 932-10-097 932-10-108 932-10-119 M.Shaffer C.Clooten L.Markus 15261 Victoria Ln. 7807 Arbor Cir. 16656 Arbor Cir. Huntington Beach.C.a9764- Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 932-10-098 932-10-109 932-10-120 { T.Brenthall U.Behrendt M.Vesbit 16682Arbor Cir. 16658 Arbor Cir. 7832 Arbor Cir. i iluutington Beach,C.02647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 i I 932-10-099 932-10-01(1) 932-10-121 i W.Coshowe F.Mohnmed S.Martinez 7E325 Arbor Cir. 5082 Loyola Ave. 16651 Viewpoint Ln. Westminister f:a 9268 Huntington Huntington Beach,C.a9.647 3 ton Beach,Ca. 92647 g 932-10-100 932-10-111 932-10-122 K.De Mille C.Smith B.Diesan P.U. Box 3202 16686 Arbor Cir. 16653 Viewpoint Ln. Manhattan Beach,Ca.90266 HUntington Beach,C.a92647 Iluntingtort Beach,Ca. 9 647 932-10-101 932-10-112 932-10-0123 D.Ilickman G.11opkins R.Ceci 7811 Arbor Cir. 1638 Pebble Beach Dr. 1029 Westward 'play Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Hoffman Fstates,IL 60194 Costa Mesa,Cs.92626 1(.Aaran 932-10-113 932-10-124 7813 Arbor Cir. F.Isola AI.Dugan t lluntington i;e ch,Ca.92646 16672 Arbor Cir. 16657 Viewpoint Ln. i 932-10-102 Iluntin6ton Beach,C.a92647 Huntington Bench,Ca. 92647 ' i' 932-10-103 932-10-0114 932-10-125 D.IIubbard F.Parks R.Cochran 8821 Arcel Cir. 2332 Tyler Cir. 16671 Viewpoint Ln. IlUntington r3each,C.02647 IiUntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach.Ca. 92647 932-10-104 932-10-115 932-10-126 Y.Pprdue K.Weiss B.Bradley 7817 Arbor Cir. 18185 Santa Adella Cir. 16673 Viewpoint Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Fountain Valley.C.a:+2708 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 h32-10-105 932-10-11G 932-10-127 M.Ruyf L.Arnold C.Cofoner 7801 Arbor Cir. 8926 Yuba River Ave. 16675 Viewpoint Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Fountain Valley,Ca.92708 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 932-10-106 r 932-10-117 932-10-128 T.Roberts 1'.Skeren T.Kramer 7►'n'; Arbor Cir. 16652 Arbor Cir. 19761 Caprice Dr. I.Nnri nnhnn Daach CA gpgg7 WVfltiVv-h 41OWL"CA 97►Lq"J YeAR A/P f142:-,462-06 1226 S. tlagnolia H.,Cohen �...� Anaheim,Co.92804 r--, 7852 Arbor Cir. 142-481-04 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 44.411t3 =MdC vtX Ct+wAw6W 142-481-05 K.Novak T.Nguyen 7854 Arbor Cir. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 i 8762 Sailport Dr. Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 107-601-41 13M0 CW 1°%J'v- Huntingtor Beach,Ca.92646 932-10-086 CNsc N 0j• 107-601-47 142--481-06,07 932-10-087 N.B. Parekh M. Qureshi A.Benites 8636 Production Ave. STE 9921 Mammoth Dr. 7856 Arbor Cir. San Deigo.Ca.92121 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92646 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 107-691-ZO 142-481-18 932-10-088 1 Nerlo Art Masao I.Newman D.Bradford 9340 Bolsa Ave. 16312 Mandalay Cir. 1854 Boa Vista Cir, . Westminister,Ca.92693 Huntington Beach,Ca.91649 Costa Mesa,Ca.92626 i 107-691-22 142-481--09 932-10-089 Ford Leasing Development R.Pan D.Gunn P.O. Box 43336 P.U. Box 6094 7841 Arbor Cir. I Detriot,I'll 48243 Huntington Beach,Ca. 91615 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 142-181-05 1142-481-10 932-10-090 Ilambly Co. N V D.Hydinger R.'rinkhain Y3 4*3pj% Cir, 16761 Viewpoint Ln. 16372 Thames LN. "R�" Arbor Cir. HUntingtun Bench,Ca.97647 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 I 142-462-06 142-481-12 932-10-091 American Motors Realty T.Bernatz J,Reschke 27777 Franklin Rd. 2914 C. Katella Ave.1203 7845 Arbor Cir. Southfield,MI 48034 Orange,Ca.92667 Huntington Deach,Ca.92647 (� 142-462-09 932-10-81 932-10-U92 (l ABKO Xis*.!TL Inc. D.Bertrand J.Packi P.O. Box 1911 12562 Dale St. i23 24611 Via Raza Detriot,ril 46288 Garden Grove,Ca.92641 E1 Toro.Ca.92630 �I 142-481-01 932-10-082 932-10-093 A.Lane L.Seeley L.Cooke 16912 Green St.04 257.62 Alden Ct. 15103 Grerystoae Lt;ntington Beach,Ca.92649 Mission Veijo,Ca.92691 Norwalk,C a90650 142-481-02 932-10-U83 932--10-0t:4 OCA G. D.,Lee Duarte Prop. 18201 Ivory Coast Ln. 7836 Arbor Cir. 8071 Slater 1140 Iluntington Dench.Ca.92648 Huntington Beach,C.a92647 Huntington 0each,Ca.92647 142--481-03 932-10-084 932-10-095 A.serra M.Jacobsen C enderson 16651 Peale Ln. 7838 Arbor Cir. 1334U Euclid St. Huntington Bearh.f i.0644 Nuht�„�4+�K gca�1, cb ga4y? folrnl-Atn Y1611,61 C(jrg24-t7 i in 300' Owner List E.Wilson �--N 18302nPammy Ln. A/P 1159-031-01 Boll Taylor Ave. Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 j Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-041-05 I 157-351-02 F.DagScott Center $.Horowitz • 18222 Bean h P. Bruckner Jr. 18312•Pammy Ln. 8222 Beach Blvd. 217 S. Violet Ln. Huntington Beach,C.a92648 Huntington }3each,C.a92G46 Orange,Ca.92669 159-041-06 157-493-01,02 15'1--352-05 ` C.Mc Rae 8002 Taylor St. D.Gaiefski I Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 18322 Pammy Ln. 4 157-352-06 HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-041-07 I A.De Grout A.Tomol G.Gaskins I 10072 Overhill Dr. 11063 Tilton Cir. n. Santa Ana,Ca.92705 Fountian Valley,Ca.92708 18342 Pammy Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 157-493-03 157-352-07 159-041-08 K.Kim H.Abel 18202 Beach Blvd, . 640 Via Lido Nord T.Lambright 18352 Pammy Ln. Huintington Beach,Ca.92646 Newport Beach,Ca.92663 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 157-493-04 159-031-01 159-041-09 D•Le•Beau L.Nicholson P. hfartignoni 8052 Kiner Ave. 419 El Modena i 18362 Pammy Ln. Huntir►gton Beach,Ca.92648 "�Newpurt Beach,Ca.92663 T57-493-1�: 159-031-22 , HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-041-010 T.Day G.Herst F.Magdaleno 1188 Hummingbird Ln. 18372 Pammy Ln. 8062 Kiner St. Corona,Ca.91720 liuntington Beach,Ca.92648 I 159-031-24 HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 157-493-15 159-041-11 M.Vanagas T,Parks ti ` 1510 N. y. State College Blvd. 18252 Pamm Ln. 18382gemi Anaheim,Ca.92806 I Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 8382 Pammy 157-341-01 159-041-01 HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 519-041•-12 i E.Vanas F.Aivarez F.Alvarez 207 San Clemente Ln. 18262 Pammy Ln. 18392 Pammy Ln. Placentia,Ca.92670 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 HUntington Beach,Ce.92648 157-341-02 159-041-02.03 159-041-13 C.Ruth ' 8001 Taylor Ave. R.Weber P.Mehan Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 18292 Pammy Ln. 7812 Taylor Ave. :57-351-01 Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 Huntington beach,C.02648 159-041--04 ( 159-043-01 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET OFFICE OF CAI.i FOR NIA 926421 'fH� CITY CLERK E TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN: The public hearing on Code Amendment 87-15 (Appeal to Planning Commission denial of Code Amendment 87-15 filed by Wilson Ford on behalf of Rod Wilson, Electra Media) will be opened on June 20, 1988 and continued open to the Tuesday, July 5, 1988 b Council meeting. This is due to an error in the mailing notification of said hearing. Please call the Office of the City Clerk, if you have any questions - (704) 536-5405. Dated: June 17, 1988 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH Alicia M. Wentworth, City Clerk ; � I (Tdtphofiv 714-535.5227 1 Fes CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK i r I, TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN: I The public hearing on Code Amendment 87-15 (Appeal to Planning Commission denial of Code Amendment 87-151 filed by Wilson Ford i on behalf of Rod Wilson, Electra Media) will be opened on June 20, 1988 and continued open to the Tuesday, July 5, 1988 Council meeting. This is due to an error in the mailing notification of said hearing. Please call the Office of the s City Clerk, if you have any questions - (704) 536.5405. Dated: June 17, 1988 I CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH ' Alicia M. Wentworth, City Clerk IT.hphono:714-SM227l CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 9264$ f OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK i i� TO W101 iT MAY COFICERH: i The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at the regular meeting held June 20, 1988, directea that Vie following open public hearings be continued open to July 18, 1988. I Code Amendment 87-15 - Appeal Special Sign Permit 87-18 - Appeal Special Sign Permit 87-19 - Appeal Dated: June 27, 1988 I f ITWephon.:714.bMZ'71 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH L1:PLV 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK March 31 , 1988 Rod Wilson Electra-Media 1208 Poinsettia Avenue Manhattan Beach, CA 90266 The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at the adjourned regular meeting held Monday, March 28, 1988 continued the public hearing on your appeals Special Sign Permit 87-18 and Special Sign Permit 87-19 for a period of 90 days. The hearings will be tentatively set for July 5, 1988 with readvertisement and re- notification of interested parties. If you have any questions, please call our office. Alicia N. Wentworth City Cler.• AMW:CB:bt i CC: Pam Posten, Development Services I Tel o p►wn.:714-53"2n) i -� r"' I w 1 ', f � f �J ��. , . r_ �': 1 ,�. r ��> ��. f '� 1 �� r.;i �,� � , � ,� �. ; . , I 1 I ! ' .. .. :-. �. _ W __ ,� Publish 7/8/88 I8OTICr, OF PUBLIC HEA,.,M APTEAL-oF THE PT AMN_G,CO MISS1QN'S DENTAL OF _ SFECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO, 87- 9 (To allow a sign in excess of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Peach City Council will hold apublic hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the ? application described below. DATE: Monday, August 1, 1988 TJ 7:00 P.M. CT: Special Sign Permit No. 87-19 APPLI T/APPELLANT: Rod Wilson/Electra Media L(}CATIt: 16751 Beach Boulevard (west side of Beach Boulevard, north of Terry Drive - Huntington AMC) : C-2 (Commercial) PROPOSAL: To allow an electronic reader board sign at a height of 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet with an area of 400 square feet in lieu of 70 square feet. Sign is in excess of total number of signs allowed for the project. ENV';IOMMU M STATUS: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15311, Class 11 of the California Environmental Quality Act. ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the t Department of Community Development, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. � I ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as ol:tlined above. If there are any further questions , please call Scrtt Hess, Associate Planner, at 536-5271 HUNTING!'ON BEACH CITY COUNCIL By: Alicia M. Wentworth City Clerk Phone (714) 536-5405 Dated 7/5/88 f 1 I CITY OF HUNTINGTC3N Br 20M MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK August 3, 1988 Electra Media 1208 Poinsettia Avenue Manhattan Beach, CA 90266 Attn: Rod Wilson The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at the meeting held Monday, August 1 , 1988 accepted your request for withdrawal of appeal filed to Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 and 87-19. Special Sign Permit 87-18 will appear on the August 15, 1988 agenda with the recommendation that Council accept the withdrawal of the appeal. This must appear on the agenda due to the fact that it had been advertised. I Connie Brockway i City Clerk CB:bt (TOrphono,714.636-52271 1 1208 Pclnsettla Ave. / Manhattan Beach, CA 90266 / 213-379-5149 � 1 July 28, 1.988 JIIL 9 1938 bEl".?)!.f , CO'f^gUNITY c, r 0;- ,. 'AN' NC; pl ti/srp,y T Mr. Scott Hess City of Huntington Beach ' 2000 Main Strut Iiuntington Beach, Ca. 92648 �44 Re: 5pec.fa]. Sign P+exmits 1 Dear Scott:: Please withdraw Huntington Ar1C and Wilton Facds Special Sign Pern-&ts fran the i City Councils August Agenda. Sincerely, r Wilson Owner/Authorized Dealer rw/kk � I I t r5111!�M y'�•.f(f'_•xer rl.' �r� I �. �� Uedivnic Visual f Information Systems I' REGt UE FOR CITY COUNCIe�'`4ACTION Date March 21, 1988 Submitted to: Honorable Mayer and City Council Submitted by: Paul Cook, City Admini.stratoi\�C`� Prepared by: Douglas N. La Belle, Director, Community Develop 4ht Subject: APPEAL OF PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 87-19 Consistent with Council Policy? pQ Yes New Policy or Exception Statement of Issue, Recommendation,Analysis, Funding Source,Alternative Actions,Attachments: T-.l. r' STAT iEur QF ISSUE: Special Sign Permit No. 87-19 is a request for an auto dealer sign which exceeds the Sign Code, Section 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, in terms of height, sign area and number of signs allowed. The sign requested is an electronic reader board at a i height of 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet with an area of approximately 300 square feet in lieu of 70 square feet. This sign will exceed the number of freestanding signs allowed for the use. i The electronic reader board portion of this sign is not part of the request; it is the subject of Code Amendment No. 87-15 which is a request to amend the Sign Code to allow such signs. Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, Section 9610.7 regarding Special Sign Permits, staters that "A special sign permit cannot be processed for those signs listed as prohibited in Section 9610.4. " Since the electronic reader board sign is a changeable copy sign, and flashes, pulsates and is intermittently lighted, it is a prohibited sign. The process to exclude them from the prohibited signs section of the code is a code amendment. Therefore, approval of Special Sign Permit No. 87-19 may by granted to exceed height, area and number of signs but not for the electronic reader board portion of the sign without prior approval. of Code Amendment No. 87-15. RECOM ENDATION: Planning Commission Recommendatiign gnd- Action on Febr nary 2. 1988: ON MOTION BY SCHUMACHER, SECOND BY HIGGINS, SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. I 87-18 WAS DENIED WITH FINDINGS, BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: Pierce, Livengood, Silva, Leipzig, Schumacher, Higgins, ► 'i Bourguignon NOES: None ABSENT: ►tone ABSTAIN: :gone ' I PI O 4/84 I I FINDINGS-EOR DENIAL: 1. Shrict compliance with Section 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code (Sign Code) will not result in a substantial hardship to the applicant, because adequate cignage with good visibility is existing. 2. The proposed 50 foot high, 300 square foot electronic reader board will predominate the surrounding area adversely affecting other signs in the araa . 3. The proposed 50 foot high, 300 square foot electronic reader �I board sign will be detrimental to properties located in the vicinity especially adjacent residential uses. 4. The proposed 50 foot high, 300 square foot electronic reader board may be a hazardous distraction to traffic. i 5. Granting of Special Sign Permit No. 87--18 for a 50 foot high, 300 square foot sign would constitute a special privilege inconsistent with limitations upon properties .in the vicinity. P P P Y 6. Exceptional circumstances do not apply that deprive the subject cJ property of privileges enjoyed by other properties in the same zone claznifications. Staff's recommendation is the same as the Planning Commission. �I Applicant: Rod Wilson Electra-Media (Huntington AMC) Location: 16751 Beach Boulevard (west side of Beach, north of Terry Drive) Zone: C2 (Community Business District) General Plan: General Commercial p�scUssio�: � Special Sign Permit No. 87-19 For an electronic reader board at a height of 50 feet with approximately 300 square feet of area is being requested by the applicant to afford advertising fleribi?ity �. needed due to constant change in interest rates, factory rebates and ! creative financing in a constantly changing auto industry. According to Section 961 (Sign Code) the, applicant is allowed one F primary business identification freestanding sign fronting on Beach Boulevard. Although the existing signs on site exceed the maximum allowable heights and areas, the number of signs meets code. Approval of Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 would give the applicant one freestanding sign in addition to those allowed by Code, as outlined in the following matrix. For clarity, sign designations reference attached site plan and elevations. RCA -- 3/21/88 -2- (0180d) 1 � Maximum Allowed Code Exia tins Propmd Total Primary Business Mentification No. of Signs 1 fronting on 1 on Beach 1 on Beach 2 on Beach ' Beach and 1 i fronting on Terry Sign No. 1* Area 70 sq.ft. 160 sq.ft. Height 15 ft. 25 ft. j New Sign* Area 300 sq.ft. Height 50 ft. Secondary Business Identification I No. of Signs 2 1 1 Sign No. 2* Area 30 sq.ft. 15 sq.ft. Height 7 ft. 20 ft. Wall SiarIs No. of ksigns 3 (1 per 3 3 frontage) Sign No. 3 Area 135 sq.ft. Sign No. 4 1 Area 90 sq.ft. i Sign No. 5 Area 16 sq.ft. Total Aree* 200 sq.ft. 241 sq.ft. RCA - 3/21/88 -3- (0180d) r J • f 1 Maximum A)Iowgd 12y Code Existing PronQsQd Total nirgctional Signs No. of Signs 3 (1 per 2 (1 not 2 entrance) located at same entrance) s Sign No. 6* Area 2 sq.ft. 6 sq.ft. Height 4 ft. 2 ft. Sign No. 7* Area 2 sq.ft. 15 sq.ft. Height 4 ft. 20 ft. *Non-conforming One of the major accomplishments of the recent sign code revision was to decrease the heights and areas of signage along the Beach Boulevard corridor to reduce visual clutter. Many auto dealers currently have nonconforming signs but as projects recycle into new uses or upgrade buildings, the signage along Beach Boulevard will become aesthetically more pleasing and lower profile. The proposed sign is 35 feet higher and 230 square feet larger than the maximum sign allowed by code. Circumstances do not exist which justify the need for such an excess. There is no visually-impairing landscaping or large buildings near the li location of the proposed sign. A sign at a height of 15 feet could be adequately seen by motorists passing from both directions on Beaca Boulevard. Apartments are located directly behind the auto dealer and across Terry Drive which may be negatively impacted by the lighting of such a sign at a height of 5o feet. Staff recommends denial of the special sign permit based on the fact i that an electronic reader board at the proposed location may be a hazardous distraction to traffic. Motorists will slow to read the changing copy, taking their eyes off the road. Further discussion of + the electronic reader board concept is contained in Code Amendment No. 87-15. ENVIRO -NITAL_,STATUS The proposed project is exempt Class 11 Section 15311 from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act. i i RCA - 3/21/88 -4- (0180d) gttleD NG SOU'J3CE: Not applicable. �i�'E81Q_.ATYV� ACTYON: The City Council may continue Special Sign Permit No. 87-19 pending approval of Code Amendment No. 87-15. BTUA=NTS: 1. Appeal letter dated February 11, 1988 2. Planning Commission Staff Report dated February 2, 1988 DNL:PP:kla i I� { RCA -- aialiae -5- (0180d) CITY OF HLJN'Y"ti' G TON BEACH CALIFORNIA 92648 4` 2000 MAIN STREET OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK March 31 , 1988 Rod Wilson Electra-Media 1208 Poinsettia Avenue Manhattan Beach, CA 90266 The City Council of the City of Nuntingig88Beach continued the theadjourned meeting held Monday, March 28, regular me 9 it 87�18 and Special .� hearing on your appeals Special Sign Perm Sign Permit 87-19 for a period of 90 days. The hearings will be , 1988 with readvertisement and re- tentatively set for July 5 notification of interested parties. If you have any questions, please call our office. ,T Alicia M. Wentworth City Clerk AMW:CB:bt CC: Pam Posten, Development Services I (7dephons:714-5364227) I i Page 2 - Council/,'--",'ncy Agenda - 3/28/88 (CIrt COUNCIL ITEMS CONTINUED FROM 3/21/88) ' F. Pn1BLIC RTNr,S CONTINIZEn np. N EOM 121[�@ F-3 (a) (C1 tv Counci I)- QO T*nr�p OPEN Pt MLIC AR HE ING - APPEA TO RLA�jN_G COMMISSInN 5 DENI r nF �nnE avDMEIV 87 15 ROD W_ILSON ELECT_ KEbTA Cali HE F QF WILw QN_z= Public hearing continued open from 3/21/88, to consider an appeal filed by Rod Wilson, Electra Media , on behalf of Wilson Ford to the Planning Commission 's denial of Code Amendment No. 87-15 which would amend Article 961 (Sign ( Code) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code to allow electronic reader boards . RA: The PC and st recomme 4mt Coun deny Code Amendm, with f ' i gs for ni as set forth tewT!dN �'o U pub f i} the $�' ated 3/21/88 omp'o 1-0 Rfr�f �C 44 S" Capes '�'d'�l�i , l� 1ro.0/f.4WA/ D To PG FoR E✓�JAT/OA/ 4f S00cl �wwr''r /+�rv� 44s, A�Fi�IE •�VRJ/�P /}RrfRt 4Si MAXIMHM xite vo Fr RCQut ea PHvro raJ.s. To aim s,6N Ar AUfle (Xr/iy F-3(b) ) ONTINi1F12 OIEN PUHfYC EARrnn �►PP A6.0 PLANNING COI�t �E ..�.. ..� „cr A� Td �BsJe11.,ri r ROD WII SQN ELE� MEDIA .��@..- o�roo, Public hearing continued open from 3/21/88, to consider an appeal filed by Rod Wilson, Electra Media , to the Planning Commission ' s denial of Special Sign Permit 87-18 which would allow an electronic reader board sign at a height of 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet with an area of 400 square feet in lieu of 70 square feet. The proposed sign would be in excess of total number of signs allowed for the project . Two petitions which were submitted to the Planning Commission listing approximately 75 signatures approved to SSP 87-1.8 included . The property is located at 18255 Beach Boulevard (w/s of Beach Boulevard, s/o Taylor Drive - Wilson Ford) in the C-2 (Commercial District) RA: The PC and staf ecommend kncil sustain the PC decision eCisian a eny Sneci ��li hh 8? based on finding or enial as set in the FICA dated 3/21/88 . F-3 (c) LC1�xs2Aaas _1)_StQNTINVF�?51� .liFiN�.�_.1iP �__'C4 �l"iNINQ CCIMMISSI4N'.S__Ia.&N�AL OF SP,�CI1�.tr szGN P KI �-�-=-�-- Public hearing continued open from 3/7. 1/88 , to consider an appeal filed by Rod Wilson, Electra Media , to the Planning Commission' s denial of Special Sign Perm4t 87- 19 which would allow an electronic reader board sign at 'a height of 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet with an area of 400 square feet in lieu of 70 square feet . The proposed sign would be in excess of total number of signs allowed for the project. The property is located at 16751 Beach Boulevard (w/s of Beach Boulevard n/o Terry Drive - Huntington AMC) RA: The PC a d s`-efff recommend a ouncil sustain the PC decision deny Spec` ial ,• }� based on finding se forth in the A t ed 3/21/BFs. _ Ott/ I Publish 7/8/88 NOTICE 1OF, PUBLIC HFA , AP_ PE&L ZQ THE PLANNING CQMI 1011'rai 12ENIAL OF SEECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO $7-18 NOTICE I5 HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. Monday, August 15, 1988 7:00 P.M. SUBJECT: Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 APPL1rJ /—A PELLANT: Rod Wilson/Electra Media 18255 Beach Boulevard (west side of Beach Boulevard, south of Taylor Drive - Wilson Ford) C2 (Commercial) PROPOSAL: to allow an electronic reader board sign at a height of 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet with an area of 400 square feet in lieu of 70 square feet. Sign is in excess of total number of signs allowed for the project. ENVIRQMZNTAL STATUS: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15311, Class 11 of the Environmental 'If Quality Act. 4N FIB: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, CA 92648, for inspection by � i the public. i ! ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions, please call Scott Hess, Associate Planner, at 536-5271 HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL By: Alicia M. Wentworth City Cleric Phone (714) 536-5405 Dated 7/5/88 300' E Oyner List , J.Berning �, .Wilson 18302 Panmy Ln. A/I' 1_5 9=031-Q1 8011 Taylor Ave. Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 157-351-02 159-041-05 F.Daghigan Scott Center B.11orowitz 18222 Beach Blvd. 11. Bruckner Jr. 18312•P6my Ln. j Huntington Beach,C.a92646 . 217 S. Violet Ln. Huntington Beach,C.a92648 i 157-493-01,02 Orange.Ca.92669 159-041-06 ' 157-352-05 j C.1•}c Rae 8002 Taylor St. D.Gaiefski Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 18322 Pammy Ln. 157-352-06 IlUntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-041-07 A.De Grout A.Tomol G.Gaskins 10072 Overhill Dr. 11063 Tilton Cir. 18342 Pammy Ln. Santa Ana,Ca.92705 Fountian Wley,Ca.92708 IlUntington Beach,Ca.92648 157-493-03 157-352-07 159-041-08 K.Kim II.Abel T.Lambright 18202 Beach Blvd,. 640 Via Lido Nord 18352 Pammy Ln. Iluintington Beacll,Ca.92646 Newport Beach,Ca.92663 IlUntington Beach,Ca.92648 157-493-04 159-031-01 159-041-09 D.Le•Beau L.Nicholson Martignoni 8052 Kiner Ave. 419 E1 Modena gton Beach,Ca.92648 •N I� Huntington �ewport BeFsch,Ca.92663 362 Parmny Ln. 157-493-14 159-031-22 1}Untington Beach,Ca.92648 159-041-010 F.MaT.Day G.Ilerst 8062gdaleno 1188 Hummingbird Ln. 18372 Pammy Ln. 0G2 }:iaer St. Cororta,Ca.91720 HUntin LonBeach,Ca.926[+8 Iuntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-031-24 157-493-15 159-041-11 ' I M.Vanagas T,Parks M.Gangemi 1510 N. State College. Blvd. 18252 Pammy Ln.Anaheim I8382 Pammy Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 1, 18382y Ln. Beach,Ca.92648 157-341-01 i ,9-041-01 IlUntington 519-041-12 E.Vanas F.Alvarez F.Alvarez 207 Snn Clemente Ln. 18262 Pammy Ln. 18392 Pam,ny Ln. Placentia,Ca.92670 Huntington Beacli,Ca.92648 157-341-02 159-041-02,03 IlUntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-041-13 C.Ruth 8001 Taylor Ave. P.Mehan� Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 18292 PanLmy Ln. 7812 Taylor Ave. 157-351-01 Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 ; Huntington Beach,C.a92648 .159-041-04 i 159-043-01 . ` i P.Strand ' 1212Park- St., W.Turner 'T.King Huntington Beach,Ca92648 ; 18381 Pammy Ln. 1308 Shadow Oak Ln. 159-043-02 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 ' Plalvern,PA 19355 159-043-012 159-271-66 J. 18271Lebow S.Ekstedi Bank Of Amp rica 8271 Pammy Ln. 7836 Connie Dr. Trust- RealEstate Huntington Beach,C.a92646 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 P.O. Box 60564 159-043-03 159-271-01 Los Angeles ,Ca.90051 159-271-67 J, .Cummings 18291 Pammy Ln, ! K.Campbell Huntington Beach,Ca.92648. 7842 Connie Dr. Inland Properties 159-043-04 i Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 18377 Beach Blvd. i 159-271-02 Huntington Beach,Ca.9264E ' 930-03-401-434 A.Moosa 18301 Pammy Ln, O.Rosales ! Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 7846 Connie Ln. 159-043-05 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 t 159-271-03- J.Arras 18311 Pammy Ln. J.Smith Yr Huntington Beacli,Ca.92646 7852 Connie Ur. 159-043-06 1lunL'ington Beach,Ca.92646 ' 159-271-0� ' O.Folcarelli Y.Park 18321 Pammy Ln, 18212 Sharon Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 159-043-07 ! 159-271-05 W.Wamhcff ' L.Haynes 18 341 Panuuy Ln, I8202 Sharon Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 159-043-08 , 159-271-06 P.Contreras 18351 Pammy Ln, 1 J.Bartok Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 ; 18196 Sharon Ln. 159-043•-09 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 ! ' 15.1-271--07 Mlegrete D.Ling 18391 Paruny Ln, 18205 Sharon Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92643 !luntington Beach ,Ca.92648 159-043-10 159-271-61 i td.Zaleski Huntington Village 7560 Valley Vista 17171 Beach Blvd. Yucca Valley,Ca.92284 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 159-043-11 159-271-63 157-493-01 157-493-02 Byhower, L. Daghigh, F. 18222 Beach Blvd. 18232 Beach Blvd. Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington-Beach: CA 92647 2? 7 - � S 157-493-13 Benavides, A. 18221 Gleada Huntington Beach, CA 92646 -151-351-03 Fesmire,'.R. 8021 Taylor- Avenue Huntington Beach, CA 92648 157-351-04 Taylor, M. 8041 Taylor Huntington Beach, CA 92646 159-043-06 akonl Aroons , L 18311 Pamny Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92648 i 159-043-10 Negrete, A. 18361 Pamny Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92648 159-271-02 Albert, P. 7842 Connie Drive Huntington Beach, CA 92646 i 159-271-04 Stellrecht, R. P.O. Box 1786 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 159-271-66 King, T. 4420 Mathews Way Salt Lake, Utah 84124 i ' i I i I5 o� i 1S7- 993 -o� << ' Vol � N Q C, 15`7 - A9 � $Gnav►dG�a� p� . ', N,B. �G4� • 5'7- 35 t- 03 16 f i V tti ICI -�J51 .rjt� II • -T �-1 P Sra(,q g rsq_ R71 Alb-` ) P. ' g 15g_«71 _oe4. 0. N . L gQGci' ts5- n 71 �4 k 7 44�p M4fihecc� I+ Lt, Ur 731. 300' Owner List ~ + E.Wilson J.Berning A/F #159=031-01 �"'011 Taylor Ave. 18302 Pammy Ln. ? .,untingCon Beach,Ca.92648 �" 4iuntington Beach,Ca.92646' 157--351-02 159-041-05 F.Daghigun Scott Center B.Horowitz 18222 Beach Blvd. P. Bruckner Jr. 18312-Pammy Ln. Huntington Beach,C.a92646 217 S. Violet Ln. Huntington Beach,C.a92648 157-493-01,02 Orange,Ca.92669 159-041-06 157-352-05 C.Mc Rae 8002 Taylor St. (, D.Gaiefski Huntington Beach,Ca.92648' 18322 Pammy Ln. `. 157-352-06 1Untington Beach,Ca.92648 159-041-07 A.De Grout A.Tomol 10072 Overhill Dr. 11063 Tilton Cir. G.Gasckins Sa.!ta Ana,Ca.92705 Fountian Va�ley,Ca.92708 18342 Pammy Ln. 157-493-03 157-352-07 HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-041-08 K.Xim H.Abel 18202 Beach Blvd, . 640 Via Lido Nord T.Lambright Huintington Beach,Ca.92646 Newport Beach,Ca.92663 18352 Pammy Ln. 157-493-04 159-031-01 HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-041-09 i D.Le•Beau L.Nicholson 8052 Kiner Ave. 419 El Modena P. Martignoni Huntington Beach,Ca.92648' '"Newport -Beach,Ca.92663 I 18362 Pammy Ln. 157-493-14 HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-031-22 ! 159-041-010 F.Magdaleno T.Day1188 Hummingbird Ln. G.Herst 8062 Kiner St. u C188 Hummingbird 18372 Pammy Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-031-24 HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 ' 157-493-15 159-041--11 1 M.Vanages _ N-- T,Parks 1510 N. State College Blvd. 18252 Pammy Ln. I F1.Gangemi Anaheim,Ca.92806 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 18382 Pammy Ln. 157-341-01 159-041-01 HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 519-041--12 IE.Yanaga F.Alvarez 207 SaV Clemente Ln. 18262 Pammy Ln. F.Alvarez Placentia,Ca.92670 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 18392 Pammy Ln. 157-341-02 159-041-02,03 HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-041-13 c.Ruch s, BIaLe� 8001 TeyLor Ave. •�LbLr CA3rlas I P.Mehan Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 18292 Pammy Ln. y ! 7812 Taylor Ave. 157-351-01 Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 i Huntington Beach,C.a92648 159-041-04 + 159-043-01 . i . P,Strxnd 1.212 ; 18381 Park St. , nerT•King Huntington Beach,Ca92648 Pammy Ln. 1308 Shadow Oak Ln. I 159-043-02 Huntington Beach,Ca.92645 ialvern,PA 19355 . _ 159-043-012 59-271-66 - . J.Lebow 18271 Pammy Ln. S,Ekstedf ' 7836 Connie Dr. Bank Of America Huntington Beach,C.a92646' Trust- Real Estate 159-043-03 Huntington 9each ,Ca.92648 P•O. Box 60564 159-271-01 Los A . _. ngeles ,Cn.90051 J, .cummir s i r 159--271--67 18291 Pammy Ln, I ' 'K:Campbezl Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 7842 Connie Dr. rties 159-043-04 Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 18377d Beach eBlvd. k-159-271-02 Huntington Beach,Ca.926, A.Moosa i r 930-03-401-434 18301 Pammy Ln O.Rosales i Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 7846 Connie Ln. i 159-043-05 Huntington Beach ,Ca,92648 159-271-03- J.Armas + 18311 Pammy Ln. J•Smith Huntington Beach,Ca.926 6-3 7852 Connie Dr. ' l 159-043-06 4 Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 ! -`' 159-271-()qL I O.Folcarelli Y.Park ' 18321 Pammy Ln, 18212 Sharon Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 ^� 159-043�-07 � 159-271-05 t� I 1 W.Wamhaff L.Haynes 18341 Pammy Ln 18202 Sharon Ln. V Huntington Beach,l;a.926on 159-043-08 48 ; Hunting06 Beach ,Ca,92648 I , p.Contreras • •� 18351 Pammy Ln, J.Bartok Huntington Beach,Ca,92648 1"196 Sharon Ln. 159--043-09 Nu, :ngton Beach ,Ca.92648 ! ',159 07 A.Negrete D.Ling 2-8991 Pammy Ln, 18205 Sharon Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach ! I(159-043-10 159-271-61 2648 , W•Zaleski Huntington Village 7560 Valley Vista 17171 Beach Blvd. Yucca Valley,C,a,92284 HUntington Beach,C$,92647 159-•043-11 • _ 159-271-63 . - i (00- w li!t M- 1 r,r• �; � "11 = i'' 0 .`�•'*.��:+ •:'. "yam M a HUNTINGTON BEACH 0 328 POLICE DEPARTMENT MMER N yy 10 F ~ � -1 wE04EX_y ; tJ CiN 1 R•) � 1/0.] FP-aN.r 0 Moe: iW� 1/ols o0oda W 10061 G PAIIKVIEW .+ iXl m m..m sn #r _______ , W •, ; { XV" OR 1W11 „• 1 ' I10'J2 ' 1{091 11101 � ( A121 BEACH % 595 letcI 6t.� r / 2 ' •16111 , 15L,1 • � �, �• P h F h r• h F I , �... iii. �� :" � iiette 1r31S 1 .• its `R1S1 ~ " a m a rl/lSh m ,�, F I f i •� SL7 B17 17 I r1 (I • jB171 tall. 1BLT1 �a r 1!!9L 18l'lo t1211 r a (i2OMW rinl , i 12 0 u • ^• ! ff I 121!1-9 m 187 GROTH (TOMY PA�Mt) _ ..,� CHEVROLET N old 1 � F n n h F r• F 1 ^ 1;!{2S1 PI Y N N N N N N Pa M N /a r4 .Pay •o .'^e F P a 11 18152 ,told 1828 r h r N r F h F� .`�- h rF- n r1`- n IO2S: 1 t/21 {� t/242 11261 .•� 1dI62 .. .w 1829 N .0 F P 4 M M 1129 n 'a ti ''O- 'a n n n r� n 1; fi 18272 nI7 11i72 ^ F F 1WILSON :11301 ONTARIO DR 1929: 929 FORDI 11712 N N N N N ra Pa n Pa �� -N, 11102 19101 1810J :1031L g r• a 'a r ',a' v (`o Po ro� r 8112 lB]ll 1{]2I F� r• r• r F r• F r- I- r` h F M F J 18312 9111 1{)12 11321 18722 11321 11]]1cc ^ ' $ ti b G fi 8142 18141 W 19322 3321 11)22 te)u lust R ^�..pUEl3EC DR e3s2 test �B1s2 9351 8152 IBM* i{)fI N N N N N M N H Pa N 8162 18361 •y P N •' N •D F P .•w `� 18362 '~ w 11371 x !� F r F° ►� 9172 g171 C LB162 9361 BEA1CHPf31HT 8'( ., 11 18372 1N371 t 10372 , r� i l9!hl 18:11 1039I I/39 1110 `� e w o 8392 IB781 I 1 ! N w ��,,� 1/IC2 F r r F n n n P i7)' 8302 8301 1818I 1 -S IIIOI 1110 //G. 11/1 Q 8172 •� � ALBERTA pR m IB1�: tqh: > It312 11111 14412 111U 6412 11i? �� 3412 `'Ot N M N N �• 11/21 111E b m a r. � �► 1tA2 L8401 11/9J 11/21 1/122 1143 F F r- ra122 Q 18121 3113 1/- SII]1 11432 11432 Q Q 9tI: 11412 1R111 Q" 18111 1i425 11471 19131 1844 ^�� n •�� 1041• 1w4T7 114/l �j 111/2 a 11442 F F r- r r- I- IBt1 1141 RANKLIN DR x „ 11151 � 11433 t{IIl Ln 18152 11/5 F YUKON DR 18441 12 P, N N N w M xt t/1S1 d Z Q: 1Bt6 a a a m r-, -2 lll11: p"1lC.Sg O.lt 11141 18462 019162 R PNa n P . n •Nn t~ 0 111S1 11442 F F h F F I- 11471 l{t6i �• Y X n r'.- rO- n 1 11172 C Y � /Ie _ a { � NN•a " W a I. r n "" F n' n � m m c � � A l..i a S? 11�I77 :1/1 A L � F 1/tit � � Fp h i+ F h ry �•` e. r e.O F F F F F •` �- N r. i� F I' �� 202 HUNTINGTON BEACH 0 425 POLICE DEPARTMENT i r w w n .~•� ~ �" 1I002 1100 it = w wK 01 J wm " ZZ � 1102J t Q i Mif0)2 1r02 •� } 110{2 o w m r m a lr0) WII10 .• 1e011 11052 Iru�• 110[1 GLADYS AVE. t�o3: tIo{ a � �4 lial ` Hill uw 1/06J 1106 : + 1i061 CREST VIEW SCHOOL 1t071 w ►~- ~ 2 ~' oi2 W ` • �+ i 1e072 ir07• = = ,. 1i071 if)n 45 1— 109 1/0!1 I 11101 N g q; it092 1/01 J SAMANA CR. » i1oll j l (18052 LISA) 31102 0 Af 1/102 it092 ,r ,� N 1091 IBM tu12 Itlll 1e112 d IBC 1d112 i/10' S 4 1101 ' '" • ,'.� n ti w o A •I N i n "• 1f122 Pr } � � aROYt CII� �' w e • tl i r r r r r r• r r e t�• ' STEALING B AVENUE ul): ul)2 •` '� .�—�� e 2IU2 1/ul �-• 1/152 U1Sl 11152 11151 Z r s ` e u ti• �, •••'•.•tots: ,� ..1, •- �• - r m r 1et62 0o ?:; PtcNLI •t't•••% t117: 11171 lll7t 111c1 tllct lel7t itlGt Z Zr�c ��.62 •.,�:• ) AIrE•�:•=' 1e172 U111 4 ltlft 1t172 11171 O 11172 .•''ti 11112 lflfl 111/i 1— 111t2 �' 1/191 11171 1/175 IIl17S 11172 11112 IY 191e2 16191/20 1r0 w N 1e191 e. 1ri9tq S1MRCP_ Alir r 11202 R 1r211 _1 -'•�r't`j•- :..•� 121 V) 1/212 a � o i m � � e o If211 _ 1120l # o � : : o 11212 swEETMATCA[R 1122: AVENUE lr t2 MINER AVE. .•�'. ! I 11222 ' N . N N N PI •V I• N N !v •y N 1121 0 o '�. "'. ."i .•. ."'. .'�. m i a 17 �11126 r r r • r r armISMww1fJI2 r s 11252 TAIr L !'i• l_0 OR. LE CQN�[ DR.3� tr:c2�l0271 « •+ Z 11212 19211U27111 1227, 12271 1r272 � � "trill < lG:f! 1rIf1 ►{• 1/!tI t/Ira ` ' 1/29 11292 1t291 . 11:e! � � �1]02 i/]Ol !/)0I t30 1t30 1/10t co 1/]at 11)Ot : m ti It]Ot 1r101i1]1 o 41i112 11111 O loll 1]1 ¢ 111J 1r]11 � 1e112 DA`JCY CR. t........,.;cil� tali Ill lt]l `` I r � 1/l2! 1f)22�'.: .•..•�• 1031 1t71 r 11]12 e]21 1/I=2 !t]21 lrl2 11121 .J 1/1J2i �,^', 1- . . If)1 14112 11){1 ow in{2 tt'• 1912 10331 12312 ., .. .. .. .. 11]]I lr)12� 111/1 z �:a• If): 11131 1!)42 e r r r r ~r'r'Ief s 1�152 if)S L rl� X. I/)] 11311 11)52,rin FORELLE Qp 111A2 11)61 lu6- ;•' .»1 !t]cl — J i 11372 ~ .^'. n i li)71 lf]72 ti y LaR7�T0"JE• _ i1271 w / r •+ .. I M4 1/192 total 1/112 • 1— 1 ., 1/)91 2 11391 -+... j ' •• �• 1 111 lt{Ol QAKSTONE i $ UI01 '� r 18/21 Z 11422 .. 16400 1//11 LA PALMA &'E 16{)1 G 1/{)2 ''•ti�,.'��r J� 11421 z 1/{]1 1... ~ .. , 3 coIt{62 0 .... ., '' 1{I .. -+ 11{61 tun .�,.-�I9Q•••, 1 49 -�• • 'o � d n = ` „� .. � � BLUFF �_�... y i�''•� 1 "i�-•ELLIS �, /�=' �, '� � � _ .. � �, .. . ' r i T r � 1 � �. �� I`� . .. '~ � i'i I I �`: . __ ;,:, . i � --- ' . • \ .�. '. ,�� J.Berning 300' OPner List Wilaon A/F 01591031-01 y j;1 Taylor Ave. �"aunti Pammy 1j Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 untington Beach,Ca.92646 I 157-351-02 :59--041--05 F.Daghigan Scott Center B.Horowitz 18222 Beach Blvd. P. Bruckner Jr. 18312•P6my Ln. Huntington Beach,C.a92646 217 S. Violet Ln. Huntington Beach,C.a92648 157-493-01,02 /J�/ � Orange,Ca.92669 159-041-06 157-352-05 C.Mc Rae 8002 Taylor St. D.Gaiefski Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 18322 Pammy Ln. 157-352-06 HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-041-07 A.De Grout A.Tomol G.Gaskins 10072 Overhill Dr. 11063 Tilton Cir. 18342 Pammy Ln. Santa Ana,Ca.92705 Fountian Valley,Ca.92708 157-493-03 157-352-07 IfUntingtan Beach,Ca.92648 I59-041-08 K.Kim H.Abel T.Lambright 18202 Beach Blvd, . 640 Via Lido Nord 18352 Pammy Ln. Huintington Beach,Ca.92646 Newport Beach,Ca.92663 HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 157-493-04 159-031-01 159-041-09 D.Le•Beau L.Nicholson P. Martignoni 8052 Ki.ner Ave. 419 El Modena 18362 Pammy Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 *''Newport $each,Ca*.92663 157-493-14 159--031-22 HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-041-010 T.Day G.Herst F.Magdaleno 1188 Hummingbird Ln. 18372 Pammy Ln. 8062 Kiner St. Corona,Ca.91720 IfUrtington Beach,Ca.92648 ' Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-031-24 157-493-15 159-041-11 M.Vanasas T,Parks M.Gangemi 1510 N. State College Blvd. 18252 Pammy Ln. n. Anaheim,Ca.92806 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 18382 Pammy 157-341--01 159-041-01 HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 519-041-12 E.Vanas F.Alvarez F.Alvarez 207 San Clemente Ln. 18262 Pammy Ln. 18392 Pammy Ln. Placentia,Ca.92670 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 157-341-02 159-041-02.03 159-041-13 C.Ruth �, C A P-O&s S. �l P Mehan 8001 Taylor Ave. 18292 Pammy Ln. 7812 Taylor Ave. Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 157-351-01 Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 ; Huntington Beach,C.a92648 159-041-04 ( 159-043-01 . P.Strand ' - .. •"' W.Turner T.King S 1.212 -Park. St., 18381 Pammy Ln. 1308 Shadow Oak Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca92548 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Malvern,PA 19355 , 159-043-02 y 159-043--012 159-27�-66 J.Lebow S.Ekstedi Bank Of America 18271 Pammy Ln. 7836 Connie Dr. Trust' Real Estate Huntington Beaeh,C.a92646 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 P.D. Box 60564 159-043-03 159-271-01 Los Angeles ,Ca.90051 159-271-67 J,.Cuaimingsw. . �_.... . . ._ . `. K.CaQpbell 18291 Pammy Ln, Inland Properties Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 7842 Connie Dr. 18377 Beach Blvd. 159-043-04 Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 Huntington Beach,Ca•42648 159-271-02 930-03-401-434 i A.Moosa ' ales 18301 Pammy Ln, ' 07846sConnie Ln. ! ` Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 . 159-043-05 1 159-271-03- � i I J.Armas J.Smith + 18311 Pammy Ln. 7852 Connie Dr. Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 ; 159-043-06 159-271-0 Y.Park C.Folcarelli i 18212 Sharon Ln. a 18321 Pammy Ln, Huntington Beach ,Ca.92643 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-271-05 , v 159-043-07 W.Wamhoff 18202 Sharon Ln. 18341 Pommy Ln, Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-271-06 159-043-08 + P.Contreras f J.Bartok f 18351 Pammy Ln, ; 18196 Sharon Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 159-043-09 ! '159-271-G7 D.Ling A.Neg18391rete Pammy Ln, 18205 Sharon Ln. Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-271-61 159-043-10 i W.Zaleski Huntington Village 17171 Beach Blvd. 7560 Valley Vista Huntington I3each,Ca.92647 Yucca Ya11ey,Ca.92284 159-271-63 159-043-11 _ 157-493-01 �157-493-02 Dagghigh, F. , yhower, L. 18232 Brach Blvd. 222 Beach Blvd. Huntington-Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 157-493;-13 Benavides, A. 18221 Gleada Huntington Beach, CA 92646 157-351-03 Fesmire, R. 8021 Taylor Avenue Huntington Beach, CA 92648 157-351-04 Taylor, M. 8041. Taylor Huntington Beach, CA 92646 159=043-06 Arconsakool, L 18311 Pammy, Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92646 159-043-10 Negrete, A. 18361 Pammy Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92648 159-271-02 Albert, P. 7842 Connie Drive Huntington Beach, CA 92646 159-271-04 Stellrecht, R. P.O. Box 1786 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 159-271-66 King, T. j 4420 Mathews Way 4' Salt Lake, Utah 84124 i I I 1209 Poinsettia Ave. / Mahhallan Beach, CA 90266 / 213-379-5149 r-j �., 'e,f`- s E`/�'Z- 4S-1,7 N �� �/71�7 �fyNi, r� X,7C NNc-.4 i c41v �" Ila 11wV711i11refV ef v,b ,�'�S'/N e -.r es- /-V %tea✓ : : sexy` eA � :ol~I a'eNe L f/V C� S Q t71 7-7 AJ y r � /vj-/AJ e"e � ,� .�i i"N -� i '-..c fl//d V. i �� !�fi.c.sa/✓ OCd1Ct tta w• s Electronic Vosual Inlorrnaiion Systems - - I %I Huntington beach department of community development STAff �i.iirrlrl.r-_ REPORT TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: February 2, 1988 SUBJECT: SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 87-19 APPLICANT: Rod Wilson Electra-Media 2&19 ACCEPTED: 1208 Poinsettia Ave. January 22, 1988 Manhattan Beach, Ca 90266 NANBATORY P OCES DER: Huntington AMC March 22, 1988 16751 Beach Boulevard Hunt. Bench, CA 92647 Z=: C2 (Community Business District) REQUIraT: To allow an electronic reader board sign, in GENERAL PLAN: General excess of the Huntington Commercial Beach Ordinance Code. EXISTING USE: Auto dealer LOCATION: 16751 Beach Boulevard (Huntington AM. C) (west side of Beach, north of Terry Drive) any. 2.6 acres 1.0 SUGGESTED A=ION: Deny Special Sign Permit No. 87-19 with findings. 2.0 GENERAL INFORMATION: Special Sign Fermit No. 87-19 is a request for an auto dealer sign which exceeds the Sign Code, Section 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Coda, in terms of height, sign area and number of signs allowed. The sign requested is an electronic reader board at a height o; 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet with an area •:f approximately 400 square feet in lieu of 70 square feet. This sign will ex-ceed ' the number of freestanding signs allowed for the use. The electronic reader board portion of this sign is not part of the request; it is the subject of Code Amendment No. 87--15 which is a request to amend the Sign Code to allow such signs. Huntington I Beach Ordinance Code, Section 9610.7 regarding Special Sign Permits, states that "A special sign permit cannot be processed for those signs listed as prohibited in Section 9610.4." Since the electronic A•f Y,t1,t` Treader board sign is a changeable copy sign, and flashes, pulsates and is intermittently lighted, it is a prohibited sign. The process to exclude them from the prohibited signs section of the code is a code amendment. Therefore, approval of Special Sign Permit No. 87--19 may be granted to exceed height, area and number of signs but not for the electronic reader board portion of the sign without 1 prior approval of Code Amendment No. 87--15. .I SURg T E. ZON AND G H R FL ku])ier Property: I � GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: General commercial C2 (community cusiness District) I ZOnF: i LAND USE: Auto dealer i t•h n S kj0ct-- perty� GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: General Commercial. ZONE: C2 (Community Business District) LAND USE: Auto dealer I Fa t• of Subject Property: ` GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: General Commercial C4 (Highway Commercial) ZONE: LAND USE: Retail center (' 1 ,utL_h of Subject PE92erty: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: General Commercial ZONE: C4 (Highway. Cormnerciai) and R2 (Medium Density Residential Aistrict) LAND USE: Retail center and apartments West of Subiegt Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Medium Density Residential ZONE: R3 (Medium-High Density Residential) LAND USE: Apartments 4.0 ENVIRONMENTAL STATUI: The proposed project is exempt Class 11 Section 15311 from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act. 5.0 CO ST y_ STATUS: Not applicable. r-- Staff Report -- 2/2/88 -2- (9949d) III 6.0 REpEVELOPMENT STATUS: ' The subject property is wAthin the Beach Boulevard Redevelopment Survey Area. 1 7.0 SPECIFIC PLAN: Not applicable. 8 0 SUBDIVISION CQ MIITTEE: Not applicable. 9,0 ISEKgS ANDANALYSIS: Special Sign permit No. 87--19 for an electronic reader board at a height of 50 feet with approximately 400 square feet. of area in being requested by the applicant to afford advertising flexibility needed due to constant change in interest rates, factory rebates and creative financing in a constantly changing auto industry. According to Section 961 (Sign, Code) the applicant is allowed one primary business identification freestanding sign fronting on Beach Boulevard. Although the existing signs on site exceed the maximum allowable heights and areas, the number of signs meats code. Approval of Special Sign Permit No. 87-19 would give the applicant one freestanding sign in addition to those allowed by Code, as outlined in the following matrix. For clarity, sign designations reference attached site plan and elevations. r Maximum Allowed by Code Existing Proposed Total Primary Business ' Identification No. of Signs 1 fronting on 1 on Beach 1 on Beach 2 on Beach Beach and 1 fronting or Terry Sign No. 1* Area 70 sq.ft. 160 sq.ft. Height 15 ft. 25 ft. New Sign* Area 400 sq.ft. Height 50 ft. Secondary Business Identification No. of Signs 2 1 1 �- Sign No. 2* Area 30 sq.ft. 15 sq.ft. Height 7 ft. 20 ft. i Staff Report - 2/2/88 -3- (9949d) i i Maximum Allowed by Code Existina Proposed Total Wall signs ` No. of Signs 3 (1 per 3 3 frontage) 1 Sign No. 3 Area 135 sq.ft. Sign No. 9 I Area 90 sq.ft. t Sign No. 5 1 Area 16 sq.ft. .' Tot.6t Area* 200 sq.ft. 241 sq.ft. ;. r Directional Bigns No. of Signs 3 (1 per 2 (1 not 2 entrance) located at same entrance) Sign No. 6* Area 2 sq.ft. 6 sq.ft. Height A ft. 2 ft. Sign No. 7* Area 2 sq.ft. 15 sq.ft. #, Height 9 ft. 20 ft. *Non-conforming One of the major accomplishments of the recent sign code revision was to decrease the heights and areas of signage along the Beach Boulevard corridor to reduce visual clutter. Many auto dealers currently have nonconforming signs but as projects recycle, the signage along Beach Boulevard will become aesthetically more pleasing and lower profile. The proposed sign is 35 feet higher and 330 square feet larger than the maximum sign allowed by code. Circumstances do not exist which justify the need for such an excess. There is no visually-impairing landscaping or large buildings near the location of the proposed sign. A sign at a height of 15 feet could be adequately seen by motorists as they passed from both directions on Beach Boulevard. Apartments are located behind the auto dealer and across Terry Drive which may be negatively impacted by the lighting of such a sign at a height of 50 feet. Staff Report - 2/2/88 -9- (9999d) /� Staff recommends denial of the special sign permit based on the fact that an electronic reader board at the proposed location may be a hazardous distraction to traffit.:. Motorists will slow to read the changing copy, taking their eyes off the road. Further discussion of the electronic reader board concept is contained in Code Amendment No. 87-15. As an alternative, the Planning Commission may continue Special Sign Permit No. 87-19 to allow staff time to prepare findings and conditions of approval based on the Planning Commission's action on Code Amendment No. 87-15. ;Q•.0 BECQMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission deny Special Sign Permit No. 87-19 with the following findings: FJJJJ IKQ_ _FOR DE AL: 1. Strict compliance with Section 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code (sign Code) will not result in a substantial hardship to the applicant, because adequate signage with good visibility is existing. 2. The proposed 50 foot high, 400 square foot electronic reader board will predominate the surrounding area adversely affecting other signs in the area. 3. The proposed 50 foot high, 400 square foot electronic reader board sign will be detrimental to properties located in the vicinity especially adjacent residential uses. 4. The proposed 50 foot high, 400 square foot electronic reader board may be a hazardous distraction to traffic. 5. Granting of Special sign Permit No. 87-19 for a 50 foot high, 400 square foot sign would constitute a special privilege inconsistent with limitations upon properties in the vicinity. 6. Exceptional circumstances do not apply that deprive the subject property of privileges enjoyed by other properties in the same zone classifications. 11.0 ALTERNATIVE ArTION: Continue Special Sign Permit No. 87-19 pending the approval of Code •Amendment No. 87-15 and direct staff to prepare findings and conditions for approval. „ iI I Staff Report -- 2/2/88 -5- (9949d) t--�- qq ATTAMMTS: �1 1. Area map 2. Site plan dated January 27, 1988 3. Elevations of existing signs 9. Elevation of proposed sign dated December 17, 1987 5. Letter from applicant dated '.-ecember 17, 1987 SH:PP:kla i 5, t Staff Report - 2/2/88 -6-- (9949d) i l ml RI o CF-E R3 R2 :iCcsH RI RI Fit C4o'�`—ti�+ - Rr --1�. R2•!5 c � f � s. s RI r � JqJ R1 �� In R1 RI Rt RI • RI r RI RI fi9R, MiMi Rl C4 , °,RI 00. � a .sasRI . 1. RI e oil oil ..•.w rr Y! RI V4 RI , C Z R! Rt 3M, ti i �' . 1 � • r wti a RI ti i t] R2 �� { p C R3 t �C4 ql Ri �� RI R1 , MI • 1 w � Rt RI .� ..• fit Rt RI , Ri rs m I_. GF—E _ " I R2 r RS ? I t ' M t R3 ( 4 SJ— } . iC ¢ t 1< RI RII RI It R2 K t G4 �^ ro trsT3. :".sxr.+ qy .�. { --— — — _S taraRM[RAVE �--' r-- i Aj nwn+cia+r,eAA3f HUNTP#GTON (MACH ltANNIMG DIVISION i CA '•AN Te S/,Chn�Lk 1 -- � £x�s7-,NJ fo fp a 7_1 1H ` g0r� Z� G }� th 9L Z°.: aOrJf't C e )C- S. t/,P C tv Vic t 2 v[A f �- . I IV r � 1 1 I t mow"'„^^ _- .. .. -'�" - ___..._ �.-- • ._ .. .._.___.._._� r II!„` _ -_�... �"' • ►'� AMCIJee RUNAULT Jars Ca 6 a w r ► ��'a?D L a N S Al 0� Co40 VrRA►L-1 P ►gHuntingto AW, I J00P I RENAULT AME& t N vrc U/IAA -rA Si.� •C /�S e NJ ok 7W i cif .S//dw rPao/t1 '•• _ 41 V tc),q L c. Sid/V / � :service SF,Rv,cr rh-r At lcC) ,Sf JAI I i Sf,u-i y S ,N� •�' ' i u'•n' I i r ^J4+4(.L:Zoc'JR1oi MNI LAl� %T.l J.,41: � COOrROLLCIt VLQ fH alnl&. T1ME 4 T1�NIp Rtih1R@. ti+bf•.Y Ih •S u=:tr�. r. -to M104 04A440tt�R'� �n�� cwAK,�c1Q.R �Oat'7 Ck-Vot 4*81f t-ArN.-Wit V-FKU6 1 rtxwia Mob G*CMAROUOA>WITH • ML'.t 4CIdtr Pw Krwt&LA"-*►5+tia�diRG7�.t►1U *ItH *Him el g►J c�5. .r.Y i Sk n d�' ! � •ns.�lvlr t� 01. IL of 16 it i �, .. 5. -:-- 17 HUNTINGTON Jeep . -� I i r:Ll,y L) ::::;7t'21.7tnr, '. 1`.nc!' !runt'r."."o•: FPrc� , "1 01-(47 Ina rue to t}'t' comlf.t:"_onn 1tt►? c.':'(`.0 ".^,.t.-mC. -: ,,to 7ecl r -nrC'_ni £1":l nmilt sl-n,:1f4 �c ..„n27tf`tT. n'%11r`;' :tit0 �P;i.C:'^ ':: vi:C •:.-,f•p t.•;.t•r +'"UC3: 1;7T,r-f,�, '."1^. 1 t'41101' II p1n.; "IC1Uf?C n f Cfln:lt's.gt,l./' coo. :`�`IP0s:r11oP_`� ,rh�t,11 ! '' c.�F,C!p 1 ot!-f'r corrF,t.'. tor: .1n t!!c ^L':` '011t:!"2'.' cC' '"Ll27tt^es I,krf 11i' n7 S`lrctron:!C to t, mein vi^tle fn r vpr,t c0,j-rt41-1Vr '.nctustr;•. ' na minct rr0�-C,r1,. PdVert�..- , t ,rr, .o t n rt I,rl s '.7r• our� e�l :,r�-_�-. ...,t►• ;:t::t.'.c nor.-c'„M_r^' Ic c:�'7. (T :iu R1:a !-olen true for n0ver"s n,- nur t s ,o,. ,,,, 0_ ruE to t i-e cntlnt:::nt cl, ^n-c '_.:: ci!r !nrlm.-t'r•• rcr .rd1wn wntrNr^t rctCr fncter!r rehe tr'^ n+ :4 +" r!nCnc- n-� :Jt::ct:t t`?nncr� rtc , •^l, cnn7nt cnr,rrFo. (our c1lectre-i'.c -.,vr, ur 1 M-1 ::c do nol- ;'furl tht't r„ ant rig•'le e ':7ce»r._..e!�t •.'.t� nr�.... ,, , J. J 4^{ +nn 1. 4 Inc Thin.; :,enllP�t ►ZF+C.f^, .l. }]F' (,`(1,'►'F•t !a�a.�tp qro% an:? ct•nt7-c .,it's tl-c .'.r.lustr;.•. The.G .r:.nrft�nr o~ t)''• 5 iPnlif:it 11t.11 not i1f+ f"I'l.t:rr.+i.A.}.Z;T ,r eCtrjnr ntn.. tc t. 'r, ruhl'.0 We :'rc%., 21.#17 to thr f ollo:l:.:" - r}ip s al! Cn:7 ho rjNgi •:7E'� ^.t:r.t icall:? to t '• f+ �.n sne. !li enrl 16751 Beach Boulevard, Huntington Beach, CA 92647 (714) 841-3099 (213) 592-5647 ' Tcr.rr.:hrr 17, 1907 i 10.1 cant The electron-'.n- :'t'.^Ctn;"rt+?^f' �^��,"' H��� r?' srlv:, comr.iun" t:. and ?,xthllC norv!cp •�,nr�•.-(�'r -Alon . Wit: t li (` tfne iln .t i r . .. . ., n nn ... , pe r, . .�rn _ r. ,•rn✓cc h, t^� t^t� Tr. � _ !c T`rrt . 1'In m t0 1,C t1'% fffc !, ^i rr� . piny r�►���n Iricr "rcr.:Vf-'it { i ! I ! i i i i i , i t i • f� �"'� Publish 7/8/88 r" NOTICE OF COIdTINUFD PUBLIC H ERRING ' APPM OF THF, PJAMING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF CODE A EM M ST NO, 87-15 (To amend the Huntington Beach Zoning Ordinance to allow electronic reader boards) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing gontinued opgg fromJung 20. 198$ in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE TIME: Monday, July 18, 1988, 7:00 PM, - public hearing continued open from 6/20/88 APPLICATION 1'iVMEES: Code Amendment No. 87-15 - (Appeal) APPLICANT: Wilson Ford APPELLANT: Rod Wilson Electra Media RE011MI: To amend Article 961 (Sign Code) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code to allow electronic reader boards. The Planning Commission has reviewed a draft ordinance for the proposed electronic reader boards for City Council consideration. ENVIRONMENTAL ST TUS: Exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act. ON Fes: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, for inspection by the public RM: The continued public hearings on the two appeals filed by Rod Wilson, Electra Media, relative to Special Sign Permit 87-18 and Special Siyn Permit 87-19 are scheduled as follows: (Special Sign Permit No. 87-18 on August 15, 1988) and (Special Sign Permit 87-19 on August 1, 1988) ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions, please call Scott Hers, Assistant Planner at 536-5271. HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL By: Alicia M. Wentworth City Clerk Phone (714) 536-5405 Dated 7/5/88 r• Aulhorizia to. ubi.flh Adrertrsemrnls of all ktnda including public noticaa by t?ecrea of Iha Supartd Court c11 blif. 1 1. an, Calilornia, Number A•6211, salad 2fi Srplambrr, t96t, and •A•24031,dated 11 June. 1963 f � i STATE OF CALIFORNIA v Gi County of Orange hwa ft~""r""aa.rr / �w��WWA PUIW NOTICE. ~ -` =_ —�•''� I am a Citizen of the United States and a resident of NOTICE a, PIJ M NOTICE'. the'County aforesaid; I am over the age of eighteen ' trllu.Ia HUARWG �`'� pfesta call Fern PcstWL Ar= AMAL OF THE $'Stan'Planner at 57ft•527t. NI years. and not a party to or Interested in the Wow PI ISI O . TY COU CL. i , A Akio cfrarlorrs cmr cauNCIL, rn AlIC1a entitled Inatler. i am a princi al clerk of the Oran •oEIt1ALOF' AL Worihso"h, city ctwtt• !! P +:,k5PEC,IALG M Phonect714)111Mai0a Coast DAILY PILOT. with which is combined the PERM1TM87.0 Puubwrisshheed Orange.Coast Cie allow a '. Oally Pilot March 10,106a NEWS•PRESS, a newspaper of general circulation. �„q,tNe„t�,•.;., ••�••• . printed and published in the City of Costa Miss. TICS% IS HE r N01 IGE. IS HE E9Y County of Orange, State of California, and that a ea hhcuylr t the �lgdt Notice of Jrl 4 r Keax3ag spu kl++wrnQin the coun� Cal Chamber at tht Hunt. i 10n Bach erfic.Center; 2000 Main Sim". Fwt• kViah 9"clo.Catifornla,on' me sale and at the 1*0111- diaated brlow to Meet"Ltd of which copy attached hereto is a true and complete consider tlte.tt.Ianients of ON Parsons Who wun io t* copy, was printed and published In the Costa Mesa, heard iion + to Ih6'&pp- Newport Beach, Huntington Beach, Fountain Valley, MOAT E/TIME:7 21. 0o on day, Irvine, the South Coast communities and Laguna APPLICATION NUMBER: tar" 8qn Permit Nd. Beach Issues of slid newspaper for one a .10 „A P` P CANTIAPPELLANT, Red consecutive weeks to wit the issue(s) of WIIMnswro-mm a': •;' LOCATiON: IAT51 9aath Wkil"ard 04st, aid* of atwv I Beach.9outd• north-ot Ter Dthv' Huntington March 10 198 6 AMZ1 ';.. . - : .•.• t 12OPIE,:621Comme►cisq AGOVESTi•To anaw an stoctro+iC ruder board 11 of a t44111 01 50 teal M IMu 198 of 15 teat with an ana of 400, square feel In ku_of 70 square f"L alwi is In axcaa 198 �ierorM"`titw ppttboro�f t. a al• ENVIRONki .HTAL -STATUS'-CaMigerlcW-ea• snip' puravent .to Section 198 1 5i:cWts 11 01 the CoN• f�'a armfonmentai Ouaaty nri FILE A­COFy of the ' 1 �►_,^ Proposed regain'Is an too t'r the •DMpa nwt:of,.Com+ mt'nity,DeWopment.,2M ( ,- Main Bfrart, Huntington' fl( 04144h.CahfOrNa D264k for 4NpeCtkin the Public.- I declare, under penalty of perjury, that the Au,INT�R>rltTEO PER. foregoing is true and correct. SONS are Ithnfed to attend Sr4 heartn0 and express t>pkriorts of sutYntl w0dence for cr agaLtaI lWIt*app'.cation as outiutod are.,lf.there Executed on Mardi 1 0 egg B— ar$ any 1•srther queSlions at Costa Mesa, California. Signature PROOF OF PUBLICATION NOTI= OF PUBLIC,.MA&M APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISCION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 87-19 (To allow a sign in excess of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code,) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE/TIME: Monday, March 21, 1988, 7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Special Sign Permit No. 87--19 APPLICANT/ AREEJ. ANT: Rod Wilson Electra-Media yO1TI0N: 16751 Beach Boulevard (west side of Beach Boulevard, north of Terry Drive - Huntington AMC) Z C2 (Commercial) , $EQy To allow an electronic reader board sign at a height of 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet with an area of 400 square feet in lieu of 70 square feet. Sinn is in excess of total number of signs allowed for the project. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15311, Class 11 of the California I Environmental Quality Act. ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions please call Pam Posten, Assistant Planner at 536-5271. i Publish 7/8/88 NOTICE Q��I�O�i�11B APE A E = .PLANNI ;L CQHI§SI:0-6 DENIAL Of SOMAL SIG FZIT NO, 87— \11 (To allow a sign in excess of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold apublic hearing in the Council Chamber at the [Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the .� statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. P Monday, August 1, 1988 i �L14E: 7:00 P.M. S ZC: Special Sign Permit No. 87-19 Aa.*, --!ZA f/APPELLANT: Rod Wilson/Electra Media LOCATION: 16751 Beach Boulevard (west side or Beach Boulevard, north of Terry Drive - Huntington AMC) ..m: C-2 (Commercial) PRQ.EQSA To allow an electronic reader board sign at a height of 50 feet in lieu of 15 feet with an area of 400 square feet j.n lieu of 70 square feet. Sign is in excess of total number of signs allowed for the project. ENVIRONMML =TUFz: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15311, Class 11 of the California Environmental duality Act. 0 FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions, please call Scott Hess, Associate Planner, at 536-5271 HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL By: Alicia M. Wentworth City Clerk Phone (714) 536-5405 Dated 7/5/88 ! i i II Authoriled to Publish ACvernsemenls of all kinds including public notices by Decrai of the Superltlr Court of Orange County, t�v Celsfornia. Number A•6:1A. dated 29 Sopremoer. 1961. and N t A=2a02 1.dated It Juno. 1963 �( STATE OF CALIFORNIA ��� .----- County of Orange rvo■C horw.Adoe"t"V 9*•"'0 Nome O 4 -AQ et Irw gym"*." wr ► Pon# \ MIX AMIIAL.To TK COMMIT/1411'!<'• DWAL OF NUCIAL I am a Citizen of the United States and a resident of 1ilOMPe11W1 rlo.rt•1e:. :` the County aforesaid; I ain over the age of eighteen (To alloofat*gbteattii `at 114 fMtntitsrtea,area, years: and not a party to or interested in the belaw ►aoorddmo a coo) "a- litottyl entitled matter. I am a principal clerk of file Orange G uVEN that IItio I`Irilift Coast DAILY PILOT, with which is combined the a ktwoovintnecoun. al Chamber at it* Nunt• NEWS-PRESS. a newspaper of general circulation, twodQ on Grle Center,' . Main Mar+ S1reM, tvunl• printed and published in the City of Costa Mesa, tMilton e a I,e N 1nt rt�, ' County of Orange. State of California, and that a dioaledboleWor WNrvand Cwtieff.t.'re stetenrentl of Aq pMsons who wish to bt Notice of he flahve to the 80911. Public itearin cat"oerenaebelow,,_ 1 iDAM,Monday.Aups!1. TIMC,T:DC 01: of which copy attached hereto is a true and complote bt1$,IECT: Special $IQr) PtKrrul COPY. was printed and published in the Costa Mesa, ' CANrl1PPILLANT: Roth' Newport Beach, Huntington Beach, Fountain Valley, Y'LOC►ElOW. 1 161 .:., 'LOCATION:10151 lseeell Boulevard fired•$tot.of Irvine. the South Coast communities and Laguna , Brach eo+eevaa north or one time r� r ware Huntlneton vvBe�va�vch Issues of ((syyaid newspaper for A i q'i t `Il yXQ� X*X`XX PANE: 5 CV ICt>n�t ',.r Ic1 wit the issue{,) of PgOPC8Al�.".Tq ttlotr sn eleclronic rtedtr board slip- :It a height of SO left in lieu q 15 fail with an Brit of ADD. ,quart lwt 1n sou of 7D' sgYart Mel:ls>or1 is in all • July 198 8 gl�tot l nurrilpproroof dins el- ENVIRON,�lN1jAt, 5TAT113,•Ce)eptvlt.say ex. "Vt I p ouarlt'to•sactim i 198 1153 111.,CMis I of uw 1E ! 1*Cie Klat Auelity Act:..,,, 1' OH FILE: A Copy,of:1M _. 198 Itahe oo cwuirwa C1n4m �M nyslrttlol: 1.2ft Beach. CA 92e+e, ta`•�9'J 198 sr+sctlenby thepu1rtiC.,,'.. ALL,=)tit[A[ TEA:PER. SONS ere InAltd 10 a#W4 ' for or a"a ttte t," lhwo at pvldned EbOrt,�1) 11Nre are any rwrw-e-melons. Was"cell"I Hess,As. I declare, under penalty of perjury, that the soy lift. PlEnner� ;at foregoing is true and ;Orrect. HUNTINGTON,iiAGit lcffv CQ1lNCK,M:Allele Qa1ed 7l5{er:` Executed on July e r 1g8 8 Published ova Coot at Costa Mel , California. :uhP�alJu►ye." seeits" Signature .. PROOF OF PUBLICATION , t 3U0': Owner list t L Leibu Corp. , � 1 932-10-085 A/P flh27;462-06 .�U _..26 S. .Magnolia �'t H. ,Cohen i Anaheim,Ca.92304 7852 Arbor Cir. 142-481-04 Huntington Beach,.Ca.92647 T-jv r3rt CrONSrj�Onfrp 142-481-05 K.'Yovgk I der to Of D BcRsrt 61-t 1 • t67322-Beac1Atvvd:. Ro. . T.Nguyen 7854 Arbor Cir. H11nti-ngtmT-Peach,Ca-�926Ga, j 8762 Sailport Dr. Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 107-601-41 lue-Ckfn vsFerc 13 Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 932-10-086 107-601-47 142-481-06,07 932-10-087 H.B. Parekh M. Qureshi A.Benites 8636 Production Ave. STE 9921 Mammoth Dr. 7856 Arbor Ci- San Deigo,Ca.92121 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92646 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 107-691-20 142-481--08 932-1U-L�88 Norio Art Masao I.Newman D.Bradford 9340 Bolsa Ave. 16312 Mandalay Cir. 1854 Boa Vista Cir, Westminister,Ca.92683 Huntington Beach,Ca.92649 Costa P1esa,Ca.92626 107-691-22 142-481-09 932-10-089 Ford Leasing Development N.Pan D.Gunn P.O. Box 43336 P.O. Box.6094 7841 Arbor Cir. Detriot,MI 48243 Huntington Beach,Ca. 91615 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 142-181-05 142-481-10 932-10-090 Hambly Co. N V D.Hydinger R.Tinkham-?y-y3 16761 Viewpoint Ln. 16372 Thames LN. 763k Arbor Cir. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Buach,Ca. 92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 142-462-06 142-481-12 932-10-091 American motors Realty T.Bernatz J.Reschke 27777 Franklin Rd. 2914 C. Katella Ave J203 7845 Arbor Cir. Southfield,Ml 48034 Orange,Ca.92667 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 I 142-462-09 932-10-81 932-10-092 ABKO XXXIII Inc. D.Bertrand J.Packi P.O. Box 1919 12562 Dale St. #23 24611 Via Raza Detriot,MI 48288 Garden Grove,Ca.92641 E1 Toro,Ca.92630 142-481-01 932-10-082 932••10-093 A.Lane L.Seeley L.Cooke 16912 Green St.14 25262 Alder Ct. 15103 Greystone huntington Beach,Ca.92649 Mission Veijo,Ca.92691 Norwalk,C.a90650 142-481-02 932-10-083 932-10-094 OCA G. D. ,Lee Duarte Prop. 18201 Ivory Coast Ln. 7836 Arbor Cir. 8071 Slater 1140 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach,C.a92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 142-481-03 k 932-10-084 ten/ 932-1 -0 A.serra !lttNt�rljclr M.Jacobsen tlield��'" fr"` 0 r 95 �0144 16651 Peale Ln. o %��u 7 03 Anderson L- d St. qi .0 "1� y � 7839 Arbor Cir. 932-1 r0=096 0 /'1932--10-107 f�' � 932-10--118 S,Anzi P.Coon R.Bond 17530 Santa Domingo Cir. 7803 Arbor Cir. 16654 Arbor Cir. Fountian Valley,Ca.92708 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 I i 932-10--097 ++ 932-10-108 932-10-119 M Shaffer I E.Clooten L.Markus 15261 Victoria Ln. 7807 Arbor Cir. 16656 Arbor Cir. Huntington Beach,C.a92647 + Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 ' k 932-I0-098 932-10--109 932-10-120 M.Nesbit T.Brenthall D.3ehrendt 7832 Arbor Cir. 16682Arbcr Cir. 16658 Arbor Cir. Huntington Beach,C.a92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 932-10-099 932-10-0110 932-10-121 W.Coshowe F.Mohamed S.Martinex 7825 Arbor Cir. 5082 Loyola Ave. 16651 Viewpoint Ln. Huntington Beach,C.02647 Westminister,C3.92683 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 932-10-100 932-10-111 932-10-122 K.De Mille C.Smith B.Dieson P.O. Box 3202 16686 Arbor Cir. 16653 Viewpoint Ln. Manhattan Beach,Ca.90266 NUntington Beach,C.a92647 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 932-10-101 932-10-112 932-10-0123 D.111.ckman G.Hopkins R.Ceci 7811 Arbor Cir. 1638 Pebble Beach Dr. 1029 Westward Way Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Hoffman Estates,IL 60194 Costa Mesa,Cs.92626 H.Aarun 932--10-113 932-10-124 7813 Arbor Cir. F.Isola M.Dugan Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 16672 Arbor Cir. 16657 Viewpoint Ln. 932-10-102 Huntington Beach,C.a92647 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 932-10-103 932-10-0114 932-10-125 D.Hubbard F.Parks R.Cochran 8821 Arcel Cir. 8332 Tyler Cir. 16671 Viewpoint Ln. it NUnti.ngton Beach,C.a92647 IlUntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 932-10-104 932-10-115 932-10-126 Y.Perdue K.Weiss B.Bradley 7817 Arbor Cir. 18185 Santa Adella Cir. 16673 Viewpoint Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Fountain Valley,C.a92708 Huntington Beach;Ca. 92647 t 932-10-105 932-10-116 932-10-127 M.Ruyf L.Arnold C.Cofoner 7801. Arbor Cir. 8926 Yuba River Ave. 16675 Viewpoint Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 1 Fountain Valley,Ca.92708 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 932-10-106 932-10-117 3�(� 932-10-128 T.Roberts Iftl IV N�7 f r Al T.Skeren #-IfNt I Nrj ;nr/ �N Fr�[�t T.Kramer I-fLrNf�^'j 7Rn5 Arbor Cir. �B� U ? 16652 Arbor Cir. ;2. a y� 6V� 19761 Caprice Ur, it a _ 932-10�-140 D.Simpson '16681 J.Rasensti e7: Viewpoint Ln. 2515 E. J��mison St. Huntington Beach,C.a92646 2315 . J;jmi2806 932-1'�- 129 932-10-130 932-10-141 r J.Foreman J.Heller• 1790 Crestmont P1. i 16721 Viewpoint Ln. Costs hlesa,C.a92617 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 i i 932-10-131 I 932-10-142 A.Degenhardt, U.Lorenzen 13272 Whitney Ci 16725 Viewpoint Ln. r. , p Westminister,C.a92683 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 I 932-10-132 932-10-144 H,6 l,'htt/rtG�rc v rdeltntr L.Frisbie M.Calloway a:t► 3 .�►�r91w S rtrcae,� 9 A 1 i 4531 Sharon Dr. 270 S. Soloamon Dr. Teo*ch `lAL4ff% La alma,Ca.90623 Anaheim,ca.92807 eft r✓: K'ni TrIl"W ' 932-10-145 , Brrt al 932-10-133 J.l;vans /14(Al -V A.Beall 16731 Viewpoint Ln. Prt��i 16691 Viewpoint Ln. t!( tv Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 9 y p• Iily 932-10-134 932-10-146 Y.Perdue H.Wright O(" 218 *Win St. 16733 Viewpoint Ln. `�We Huntington Beach,Ce.92647 rtd r lr} t (c. 11Untington Deach,C.a9..648 g L{Nf i N�!-un1 BCj}G�� � g.rt�v: J�rc�t-h s:'�crty 932-10-135 932-10-147 M.Uhler J.Sylva 16695 Viewpoint Ln. 15392 Andaman Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,C.a9?649 7Npees��`f fir''". . FrtrlOrry J � Stye-tr h •., goct E• �t F. 932-10-136 932-10-148 Sr?.n.f C.Oathout J.Wright 16697 Viewpoint Ln. 16092 Windemeir Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 ffpntington Beach,C.a92647 D.Marion 16711 Viewpiont Ln. HUntngton Beach,Ca.92646 932-10-137 . ) 932-10-138 A.Lopez • . 6881 Via Carona Hunt igton Be:ach,C.a92647 932-10-139 0 ra,V 8 tN[ Duarte Prop g x t,y 7 8071 Slater AVe. 0135 _ W. Miller i07-40/ -.V/ E, 93 a-iG - 37 , `,` / 13070 Old 8olsa Chica Rd. 132 Asa Le �Westminster, CA 92683 qewRor ac , 92660 142-462-06 932-10-129 American Motors Realty Ashlee Investment Corp. I 12000 Chrysler 2855 E. Coast Hwy. Highland Park, MI 48288 Corona Del Mar 92625 142-481-06,07 932-10-141 M. Qureshi Kristiansen, N. 4152 Shorebreak Dr. P.O. Box 6442 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Bend, Oregon 97708 142-481-09 932-10-143 Y. Pan C. Laird 9134 Cockatoo Ave. 7926 Seawall Circle Fountain Valley, CA 92708 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 142-481-10 D. Hydinger 16672 Thames Lane Huntington Beach, CA. 92647 932-10-086 P. b H. Development Co. 8071 Slater Ste. 140 1 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 932-10-090 R. ?inlham 7843 Arbor Circle Huntington Bea;,►r, CA 92647 ` 032-10-097 M. Shaffer 15251 Victoria Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92647 932-10-099 Walsh, 0 7825 Arbor Circle Huntington Beach, CA 92647 932-10-121 A. Braun 15561 Santa Isadora Fountain Valley, CA 92703 932-10-0123 R. Cenci 1G29 Westward Way Costa Mesa, CA 92E27 Su u . A�t�Irp (nv�-rmrrSt r�� P �w� Crjrl:�� Del Mtii- 934 ;a �3er-ti-1, Or 9 7'76 Y ` te43 C. �7 H. a . ga�o4$ i i r t I f to -cqa 10 15a�1 1/��trx•�c.. Lr� � .. �a,$ qc-&47. ff; 93.2-%0 •p� f ��a5 AY-tor� Gr "Z- IV - ZI + 1 SSco s r,try (Scs� Z-70� • I 71�cx-nto,� E . I Z 132 V►�,tr� NcwrYx-�- k3cy-7 �;�x,p o� II • I io 7 - poi - r.,, AMc.- /3o7D Oki `cal�a Ch-cr- ra. we-Orm;n3rr_r-, CA 94 Y,83 j wz- qG2--C(, Arrw-,r;C.Cn 1-Jcm.,.� OG,o7 4 IS z srx,,Y py ia• 3, r_A �Q4aq 4 Y. 1n 4134 Ccx X.:%`tM Mlle J 9-27Og 192- 4k1 - IC) Q. N t�tsr V W, B. �t7 93a - 10 . H Slc3,rx - (� 4Z.L q-7 I I I • I' 300' Owner list 44 L Leibu Corp. 932-10-085 i QJP hh2:,462-06 J -26 S. Magnolia �' ""H. ,Cohen Anaheim,Ca.92804 7852 Arbor Cir. 142-481-04 Huntington Beach,.Ca.92647 W.Miller 142-481-05 K:yovak , 16732 Beach Blvd.. T.Nguyen 7854 Arbor Cir. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 8762 Sailport Dr. Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 ;( 107-601-41 Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 932-10-086 107-601--47 142-481-06,07 932-10-087 }I.B. Parekh M. Qureshi A.Benites 8636 Production Ave. STH A 9921 Mammoth Dr. 7856 Arbor Cir. San Deigo,Ca.92121 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92646 Huntington Beactt,Ca.92647 107-691-20 142-481-08 932-10-088 Nerio Art Masao I.Newman D.Bradford 9340 Bolsa Ave. 16312 Mandalay Cir. 18514 Boa Vista Cir, Westminister,Ca.92683 Huntington Beach,Ca.92649 Costa Mesa,Ca.92626 i 107--691-22 x;� 142-481-09 932-10-089 Ford Leasing Development R.Pan D.Gunn P.O. Box 43336 P.O. Box.6094 7841 Arbor Cir. Detriot,MI 48243 Huntington Beach,Ca. 91615 1luntingCon Beach,Ca.92647 142-181-05 ;K 142-481--10 932-10-090 liambly Co. N V D.Hydinger R.Tinkham 16761 Viewpoint Ln. 16372 Thames LN. 7832 Arbor Cir. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 ;e,142-462-06 142-481-12 932-10-091 American Motors Realty T.Bernatz J.Reschke 27777 Franklin Rd. 2914 C. Katella Ave.#203 7845 Arbor Cir. Southfield,MI 48034 Orange,Ca.92667 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 142-462-09 932-10-81 932-10-092 ABKO XXXIII Inc. D.Bertrand J.Packi P.C. Box 1919 12562 Dale St. #23 24611 Via Raza Detriot,MI 48288 Carder, Grove,Ca.92641 E1 Toro,Ca.92630 142-481-01 932-10-082 932-10-093 A.Lane L.Seeley L.Cooke 1691.2 Green St.04 25262 Aldea Ct. 15103 Greystone h untington Beach,Ca.92649 Mission Veijo,Ca.92691 Norwalk,C.a90650 142-481-02 932-10-083 932-10-094 OCA G. D. ,Lee Duarte Prop. 18201 Ivory Coast Ln. 7836 Arbor Cir. 8071 Slater #140 fhintington Beach,Ca.92648 huntingzon Beach,C.a92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 142-481-03 932-10-084 932-10-095 A.serra �, y,�,.n M.Jacobsen C .Anderson 16651 Paula Ln. 7838 Arbor Cir. 1334U Euclid St. t` " Y 932=10-096 ,- ,. 932-10-107 932-10-118 S,.Anzig P.Coon R.Bond 17530 Santa Damin&o Cir. 7803 Arbor Cir. 16654 Arbor Cir. Fountain Valley,Ca.92708 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beaeh,Ca.92647 932-10-097 - 932-10-108 932-10-i19 M.Shaffer E.Clooten L.Markus 15261 Victoria Ln. 7807 Arbor Cir. 16656 Arbor Cir. Huntington Beach,C.02647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 932-10--098 932-10-109 932-10-120 M.Nesbit T.Brenthall D.Behrendt 7832 Arbor Cir. 16682Arbor lair. 16658 Arbor Cir. Huntington Beach,C.a92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 932-10-099 932-10-0110 ,y 932-10-121 .W-.Coshowe F.Mohamed S.Martinez 7825 Arbor Cir. 5082 Loyola Ave. 16651 Viewpoint Ln. Huntington Beach,C.a92647 W^stminister,Ca.92683 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 932-10-100 932-10-111 932-10-122 K.De Mille C.Smith B.Dieson P.O. Box 3202 16686 Arbor Cir. 16653 Viewpoint Ln. Manhattan Beach,Ca.90266 IUntington Beach,C.a92647 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 932-10-101 932--10-112 '932-10-0123 - D.Hickman G.Hopkins .Ceci 7811 Arbor Cir. 1638 Pebble Beach Dr. 1029 Westward Way Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Hoffman Estates,IL 60194 Costa Mesa,Cs.92626 932-10-113 932-10--124 H.Aaran t 7813 Arbor Car. F.Isola M.Dugan Huntington Cir. Ca.9«646 16672 Arbor Cir. 16657 Viewpoint Ln. 932- 0-102 BeacHuntington Beach,C.a9Z647 Iuntington Beach,Ca. 92647 932-10-103 932-10-0114 932-10-125 D.Hubbard F.Parks R.Cochran 8821 Arcel Cir. 8332 Tyler Cir. 16671 Viewpoint Ln. HUntington Beach,C.a92647 HUntington Beach,Ca.92617 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 932-10-104 932-10-115 132-10-126 Y.Perdue K.Uleiss B.Bradley 7817 Arbor Cir. 18185 Santa Adella Cir. 16673 Viewpoint Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Fountain Valley,C.a92708 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 932-10-105 932-10-116 932-1 U-127 M.Ruyf L.Arnold C.Cufonex 7801 Arbor Cir. 8926 Yuba River Ave. 16675 Viewpoint Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Fountain Valley,Ca.9270a Huntington Beuch,Ca. 92647 932-10-106 932-10-117 932-10-128 1'.Roberts T.Skeren T.Kramer 7Kn5 Arbor Cir. 16652 Arbor Cir. 19761 Caprice Ur. f it ► 932-10-140 3 D,.Simpson 16681 Viewpoint Ln. J.Eosenstiel Huntington Beach,C.a92646 2515 E. Jamison St. y 1 932-1(1• 129 Anaheim,Ca.92806 932=10-130 ( 932-10-141 ' J.Heller J.Foreman ; 16721 Viewpoint Ln. 1790 Crestmont P1. Costa Mesa,C.a92627 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 r i 1 932-10-131 932-10-142 A.Degenhardt " D.Lorenzen 13272 Whitney Cir, 16725 Viewpoint Ln. Nestminister,C.a92683 Huntington Beach.Ca.92647 932--10-132 + 932-10-144 M.Calloway 4531 Sharon+++ e 270 S. Solwon Dr. 531 Sharon Dr. , A La alma,Ca.90623 naheim,ca.92807 932-10-133 932-10-145 A.Peall J.Evans 16691 Viewpoint Ln. 16731 Viewpoint Ln. , Huntington Beach,Cc..92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92644, 932-10-134 932-10-146 Y.Perdue H.Wright 218 Main St. 16733 Viewpoint Ln. HUntington Beach,C.a92648 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 i 932--10-135 932-10-147 M.Uhler J.Sylva 16695 Viewpoint Ln . 15392 Andaman Ln. Huntington Beach,Co.92647 Huntington Beach,C.a92649 932•-10-136 932-10-148 out J.Wri ht 16697hViewpoint Ln. 16092 Windemeir Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 llyntington Beach,C.a92647 D.Marion' 16711 Viewpoont Ln. HUntngton Beach,Ca.92646 X 932-10-137 . 932-10-138 A.Lopez 6881 Via' Carona Huntington Beach,C.a92647 932--10-139 Duarte Prop 8071 Slater. AVe. #135 • 1 0 n I � t n a OED 1 ` t 4 tom., YIFWPp1NT � 4ANF � 1 L ANf L AT t sea t's.0 to 11 • .4 H • �• 1. ® • � • � tad• � ♦ ♦ ♦ 1 '•✓ �J ♦ Y r h w ��w•.. �� �1 � Z y b ru R . L. .II • •Ir if (j� Y Y •C ~ ` • , � ► N/ /• i1 • n1 tl y 1 r 1• •N•I' )••I/' •• •, ..\ .�.--.ram .t.N I B£AC/1 er•rp'1 80UL£VARO L B£ACH rwvr nrov Ory:Nl Bax21'ARD t ` ••. I N• +♦ as � 't •T r I ` t. 1. •/9/ram. �� I R . Z •. o • ter• y L£•Cl'NLY�O CiF:cE �n ' Cry Q r > �� =O• _...._�......�.. .1•/ ••• ri i. t i. A 5 4 ..' i ( HUNTINGTON BEACH 0 3291 POLICE DEPARTMENT ' 6+IEIL---" 6501 lb'.,! 10 0 , (O;U: 1n:0 0:0. l•i(11 iso2 lbs� !b'A2 0S0 l•501 650� 16501 i 1iS10 cl: tc Z Lr ►to: i 16521 "'1 165J2 bSl 1.1 16s2J 1fSJl V 16522 16521 —1 16522 1�iS21 1.1 1652 1iS11 V 1652: 14511 S„1 1f52. 16521 —1 16532 ItSJI 14512 t6S11 16512 lbSll 16s12 16S11 ts�lI lhsll 1b51: S•SJl 16512 14911 1651: !fill 11 � ltiSi. 16511 L4411 1b;1: 10541 16512 Iml Ir f6S12 16S/1 16542 16511 t6512 16511 w 16512 16541 111 16S/2 16541 lbS1• l,.ill L6SS6 1 ussl W 16SS2 IOU W 16552 ifSSl f- 16SS2 16SS1 Ms: 16SSL � tb557 1.551 f]. 16552 16551 Z 16SS: 1b55t a. I6Ss: 16511 '� 165f < 1062 l4SfI ~ 1656J 16561fc 1bS62 (6561 HSU 16S61 = 1•S6: 16S6L 16562 lbSol V 16562 106l 16Si2 45n1 •� i 1 M,ll 16572 ton tL 16572 16571 = 16572 It571 16;72 16s71 �` 16512 1iS71 1iS72 16ST1 Z 16S72 1tS11 6572 bS'.1 Z BRUSH A& ~ o �• N+ s a o«A n r n n N N N N N N h N N n ►+do as -� �{� '�' � � .+ N � .7 ti ■ a .. n • v � w r� �: $ IffO 14601 1ff12 N ♦. .. N .v w w w M -1 w n .y •/ w N A-5 H ry n N M NTJ- ww /� r/ q / r • / w / .o • Iif2 16621 BRYANT DR, 166i 1•fl n h N n N N N N N h N n h N N N •v n 1661. Lbb1 ^� .A N N N ry N -. N N w w M w w w � "1 • I6t'1• i672 w 166f. i; / / tl • O ry n N ri .� w .ryi n rrw w�i N ■.l �. M 1667. 16671 16, i� r • • / w • / / • • • w w / LAMBERT lag DR 1668: tc6s• +N+ N N N 0 N ft n n n n pN� � N M .I+y� ny ti n 1669: W a N N IZ N ry 7v .`�i n n i, n wni 1.1 /•1 n n i M O r y r w / n Z / a w a • r / ■ • / / • • / tl • 's , 1670: +�•711 O liTl2 .y .•. .~i • n n .tea �, n n h .�v h :; .ti .Ni .� w• .0i n " �. 1672. 1021 do E 1 V DR 1671: 1�7a •�. 16T1. L67111611 167/l 67141571; w 167Fln IS752 16751 2 v 16712 16751 .+) 6is n 1b751 1d1S7) 1f7S2 1fT71 d^ 16761 S 1,772 16772 Ix 14772 1677171. 111i771 1i771 1f772 f671 �' 167d1 "!� -1 16711 Q Q1 16172 16711 16712 16711 W J 16712 16731 L��LJ1 1 i100 O !q!2 16791 0 37111671 � 671 � Q t,,16 16791 (J1 r7 671�-lbSS 6))? i1771 a 16772 16 ), Q 1679. 16191 tq F— 16792 16791 16712 1i101 3 N- 1679!16791 U F- 10792 161011Z 679h « w 16791 16602 1gCl 1f102 16101 1it011ie01 F% (Q1 Q 6J02 16e01 LLl r^, 411 1 � liu2 at W y y 161n1 16U1 fea ifil. l6el 161] W.1 tell ` 1 LANCASTER DR. �'''`6e ARNETT DR. ,�, M fY n n Y M N ry N n N •V 4� {��, V n r o+ a « n • .n n .w \ ♦ n n N �+ n n r .� h ,q ( 1Le11 •+ .� « ry N N N ry n rZ / i ,,� n .� n ,■. n • •ter i 1t112 w it • r r / r • • / e / / w �� / / r / / w / • ! i O. O. F. C. D. 16162 lff l SARU C . 16161 oc i fi 161t11 161i1 � N Ifeel i 16192 16191 16171 ISM ". M r w f !i 216911 1b712 li 1 f2 RANCHO V1EW SCHOOL 1f9:1 TAMARU OR li l 16►12 , a n li a 16112 A tbI 2lf9Sl (16940 H ST.) if9s1 z 169T1 2 ,CT R t ' . . ...-_.�.. ......._ WARNER 263 a �b..� � � �`'y�i'.r����iN+>f+. I ` s � '� '*�� �,rY..+•r •�,' 1i '1it''' Y! _�p{et{"��1 C ���w.ilttY..:..:.:a:a.S31..i .�,-.r�'rr"�' w•.-� ,, i �"Mit4'�y'j� - ���. t� ��� 1 f1 v Iamb i HUNTINGTON BEACH 0 326 OUCE DEPARTMENT -- 15 01 50 1659 6502 16501 Jf a RHINE � CR J 0 16ll 6512 1631 1651, 165211DANUBE DR 652216521 IX1652! 16S22 6571 1y 1011. Z 16522 gn R N x r w ' 16572 16511 Oa 1b4 - '-1 6512 " .�i n�F• ^ ^ ^ h r h r r ^ �-2 165]2 l65]1 4 165i1 1 toss► 65/2 6 ^ 1011 y16541654l] t Qt by , 54 y��e 1051 2 16Si, DR sl BEACH 65h 165f2 1 I6SG71 63727 16555 CITY DODGE 16511 iisu 16511 J r` '- I. ^ ^ tib� a 1�1 9 C rf� 16EO1 6F0: 1i601 Zn 6602 4 16611�^ $ ^ ru' �w� ► 1by�• y� tray r, �`�'.- 1wi11 �� 16611 14612 DON �b�•q ��� c<< CHRYSLER OR 16622 16621 :6622 1662 n 1by' ti ' ro t 1601 Tli6]2 1IEE66�]11 1b612 16631 N1 ~ e r 166/1 t6R 16W 16442 16642 r 16611 << 100 1665 6zil C6S2 166 cc C �i f�l�•^- 16E61 W 66 tF671 WK,_`$ D' 6472 1E671 -JCHRYSLER 2 669: � 16c6F <' ArHUFlTz,tnt 16E81 16E61 C \�g< O. ^i�'�: DEALER e. G. GARDENS 1b7u RHINE `�j� �' � ISO 16711 N :Z N x ^ ~ �' n .rv. n r•` G. :�..r.. ^ ^ ^�r• h F.^ � is � � � b � O. 16711 16;82 SI 16762 ^ 7472 -.-.� •- TERRY _ i f lo7Sl 16751 1.3761 IU762 Jul. _ Q ry 92 n ti 1R78] 16742 1 11 •P n .+ M NSHADOW 16767 167g1 1672)Nt�1j� F, \^ SANBURY CROSS 16719 = 7l2: n n �� 166]l V� F�ti I�7 4]62 ►�- ram- n 16793 (16761 VIEWPOIN w 4� 16111 DAMASK GR {l 0. C. F C. D BROOKWOOD 1611; ' MANOR 16 81 ' Mail WIND JAMMER 16399 I �y1a " h (;6890 bEACH). "• ^ ^WASHINGTON AVE 1030 159 a�� I 259 d ie (770I WARNER) (SHPP d CNTR. 1041 /e f• r• h ^ ^ i` R ^ I Nett WAR NE ! 282 ' . -"�...�^""':"'�.''•1l Y7191u lIrse lr w:i+i��n.��:•:-• _,., ... _•,,,.��»_.._._..,.-.�..__.._......-��.,:..-.. -