The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutSpecial Sign Permit 93-13 - Superior Electrical Advertising, e Council/Agency Meeting Held: Deferred/Continued to: YApproved ❑ Conditionally Approved ❑ Denied City Clerk's Si tune Council Meeting Date: March 18, 1996 Department ID Number: CD 96-15 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTION SUBMITTED TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS SUBMITTED BY: MICHAEL T. UBERUAGA, City Administrator OAP PREPARED BY: MELANIE S. FALLON, Director of Community Development/ SUBJECT: WITHDRAWAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 V (MERVYN'S CENTER) Statement of Issue,Funding Source,Recommended Action,Alternative Action(s),Analysis,Environmental Status,Attachments) Statement of Issue: Transmitted for your consideration is a letter from the applicant's representative, Award Sign Company, requesting to withdraw Special Sign Permit No. 93-13. Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 represents a request to retain a non-conforming freestanding sign identifying Mervyn's, LA Tronics, Smart & Final, and Cudini and Lucas Jewelers at the Towne House Plaza located at 9891 Adams Avenue. The applicant indicates that a revised sign proposal will be submitted to the City in the near future. Recommended Action: Motion to: "Act pplicant's request to withdraw Special Sign Permit No. 93-13." Attachment(sl: NumberCity Clerk's Page 1. Letter from applicant dated February 29, 1996 requesting withdrawal 2. City Council RCA dated September 18, 1995 1 ATTACHMENT :e TEL No . Feb 29 , 96 16 : 01 No . 006 P . 02 AWARD SIGN COMPANY, INC. ELECTRICAL ADVERTISING 16642 MILLIKAN AVENUE,IRVINE,CA 92714 714.852.1560 • FAX 714.852.0922 February 29, 1996 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH -Planning Division 2000 Main Street P.O. BOX 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Attention: City Council Reference: TOWNE HOUSE PLAZA / 989:1 Adams Ave. Existing pylon sign On behalf of Mark Sork Companies, we are requesting to with draw our s-ign application at this time and will follow up with a revision sign program In the veer iuiur•e. Thank you for_ your attention on this matter. Sincerely yours, AWARD SIGN COMPANY, INC. Ed Go ner Account .Executive EG:-cp LICENSE NO. 642321 . .......... �,'��' HMEl� ..... µ '. .................. Council/Agency Meeting Held: v Deferred/Continued to: ❑ Approved ❑ Conditionally Approved ❑ Denied City Clerk's Signature Council.Meeting Date: September 18, 1995 Department ID Number: CD 95-43 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTION SUBMITTED TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS SUBMITTED BY: MICHAEL T. UBERUAGA, City Administrator PREPARED BY:. MELANIE S. FALLON, Community Development Di ector SUBJECT: APPEAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (CONTINUED FROM THE APRIL 3, 1995 CITY COUNCIL MEETING) [statement of Issue,Funding.Source,Recommended Action,Alternative Action,Analysis,Environmental Status,Attachment(s) Statement of Issue: Transmitted for your consideration is an appeal by former Council Member Earle Robitaille of Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 which was denied by. the Planning Commission on February 1, 1994. The public hearing was originally continued open from the April A, 1994 City Council meeting, to the April 3, 1995 City Council. meeting. The continuance was to allow the Sign Code Committee to conclude their review of the existing sign ordinance. At the April 3, 1995 meeting, the City Council granted another six (6} month continuance to allow finalization of the Sign Code revisions. The Sign Code Committee has completed their review, however, the proposed revisions have not been presented to the Planning Commission or City Council. The Sian Code revisions are expected to be presented to the Planning Commission in October. Staff anticipates the Planning Commission and City Council hearing. process to be completed by the beginning:of next year. Due to the length of time between public hearings, staff will re- advertise the request for the public hearing in March, 1996. Fundinq Source: Not applicable Recommended Action: Motion to: "Continue the public hearing open and re-advertise the public hearing on Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 to the City Council meeting of March 18, 1996." •QUES"T" FOR COUNCIL AC1 MEETING DATE: September 18, 1995 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: CD 95-43 Alternative Action(s): The Council may take the following alternative action: 1. "Uphold the Planning Commission's action by denying Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 with findings (see Attachment No. 2)." Analysis: Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a request by Superior Electrical Advertising, Inc. to permit an existing non-conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding double pole sign to remain at the northwest corner of Brookhurst and Adams (Mervyn's Shopping Center), and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini & Lucas Jewelers in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot sign alloWtied by the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. _The City Council continued the item to allow a Sign Code Subcommittee the opportunity to review and recommend any changes to the existing sign ordinance. As noted, the Sign Code revisions are pending Planning Commission and City Council review. A complete analysis of the request is included in the attached April 3, 1995 staff report. Environmental Status: The proposed project is categorically exempt pursuant to Class 1, Section 15301 of the California-Environmental Quality Act. -- MTU`MSF:HZ:WC Attachment(s): City. Clerk's Page Number 1. Request for Council Action dated April 4, 1995 2. Findings for Denial - Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 CD95-43.DOC -2- 08/30/95 3:45 PM 8 g LSA $ 6 W w ttt • I 3 8 pp' MC T lm _ d I CT7tTlR EDTNM ♦ tea. WAJL*47R ` SLATER H. - - m Ea u"s= g 1 p 9 - - - - •� GARFI= MERVYN'S Yo�VM ADAMS ..... . .................. � ATLAPMA it�:.<,i'c::.;i;�.i... "iS�•:fi�3::JAD 4t:•. AM$ SI N ., f ATTACHMENT NO. 'iUX SSP 93- 13 HUNTMTON BEACH PLANNING DMSION �rr.Lr.�mlmam�-lram-lmlru: -.Ir. . . _ __ ----- _ � • 7' 9wS"No POLE Spew (FACE CNANCQ = '.li .S . .. r-.�• e.. �•,�, .;.. 41 a._l •:wu::.u�n:J...pr_•Iu.� :►au_:Ip:Lg91Ig .�i _._._�. AOArS STRICT SITE PLA M•SI(.•N LOCATION NOT TO SCALE V :t E`I•�ftls'I�i Gyft*1-� �,.ir/�i�w a V DRUG AND DISCOUNT STORES M, L. r� CUDINI ?LUG;s JF\VELERRS �. L.: V� vAN•J.:'cL'srvC JEwal�S•D::v:.:SROILS.R.S•RPra:;SCL3 - D/F FACE CHANGE 1.NE•,'FACES ARE ACRYLIC PL.LS71C w17,1 VINYL OVERLA SCALE: 1R"c1 -0" CoPyt OESICN, iI SCALE: 1 2"= Z COLORS:BACKGROUN�.s7I1t WHITE - N ITl ALL COPY.OARR BLUE S.EOM ALL=SY7-0 CAswET wEASuREAIENYS YO of VERIFIED ON STf PRIOR'O PA.CL{ABRICAflON S O+S1 • �_ ©y�1'r195a ' SUPErior [T FG'.t9L=Jr, v h+rTlti`i deetrksl.RdvvtlSingl �_ _._�_ - �r .,...,..,..,... _- - u; i7-1 rL_�i'^ -s qro•J, (,'Jr�t G+ ATTACHMENT NO.- :Z• RCA ROUTING SHEET INITIATING DEPARTMENT: COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SUBJECT: SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 COUNCIL MEETING DATE: March 18, 1996 RCA ATTACHMENTS _STATUS Ordinance (w/exhibits & legislative draft if applicable) Not Applicable Resolution (w/exhibits & legislative draft if applicable) Not Applicable Tract Map, Location Map and/or other Exhibits Not Applicable Contract/Agreement (w/exhibits if applicable) (Signed in full by the City Attorney) Not Applicable Subleases, Third Party Agreements, etc. (Approved as to form by City Attorney) Not Applicable Certificates of Insurance (Approved by the City Attorney Not Applicable Financial Impact Statement (Unbudget, over $5,000) Not Applicable Bonds (If applicable) Not Applicable Staff Report (If applicable) Not Applicable Commission, Board or Committee Report (If applicable) Not Applicable Findings/Conditions for Approval and/or Denial Not Applicable . ......... . ........... ........ ..... . . ....... .... .. ......... .......... . ... ....... ...................... ....... .. . ...... .... . . ......... _ ..... .... _ . _. ....... EXPLANATION FOR MISSING ATTAC<HMENTS ... _ .... ........... ........ ........ . .. .. . ..... .. ..... ... .. ............... . .. ..... ......... ........ ......... REVCEWED RETURNED FORWARDED Administrative Staff Assistant City Administrator Initial OAY City Administrator Initial City Clerk ... .... .... .. . ....... . ... . ...... .. ......... ........ ... ...... .. ......... ....... ........ `EXPLANATION FOR RETURN OF ITEM • • . • Only) Connie Brockway,City Clerk - --- 070N City of Huntington Beach /� _ ��N 1 U.S.PQSTAGEi`i, Office of the CityClerk PRESORT ( 4 �-- 1, P.O. Box 190 \ ` �1AR31 '95 Z Huntington Beach,CA92648 FIRST -CLASS t . I�14ftJ1/ =;��1a7 ' Ftllf�t, �' i CAa"E T E NA j�c�-� 7—rC_Q<.�L,i�.C� - �Q�Q�� Ems_��-�-• �, . 153 171\01 .15 — �NTINGTp Allan A F inbara ti� 890 Baker Sit -2i70 \Q - \N60RPORq F9y Costa Mesa GA 9'�626 FAIN890'* 926261027 IC94 04/05/95 NOTIFY SENDER OF NEW ADDRESS o r=.r= Q :ALLAN FAINSARG 129 W WILSON ST STE 100 COSTA MESA CA 92627-1586 is C Fg 17. isoe.o- FcpUNTY CPS\ LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING I Connie Brockway,City Clerk ,c .f City of Huntington Beach `�GTO�y 8 vi �:`y:U.S.Pos A Office of the City Clerk P R E S O RT( / �� j5z P.O. Box 190 MAR3Huntington Beach,CA92648FIRST CLASS ACECIz 1 F97005, 1S3 1\71 02 16 Famb�e Allan A Co _ . - pNTINGTp 890 BaGi St =200 �H60PPOBgIf rydF9� ` Cos ta�Mec�a A 92626 v _ FAIN890* 926261026 IC94 04/03/95 --= NOTIFY SENDER OF NEW ADDRESS o #r►=T^�^ Q :ALLAN FAINSARG 129 W WILSON ST STE 100 y F•. a �Q� COSTA MESA CA 92627-1566 FB CF 17. 1909. �pa�ury �P LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 11II1111I1II1I1 sell III • Connie Brockway,City Clerk , City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 /}' �iAR 24 '95 = i Huntington Beach, CA 92648 n CO 151 282 31 45 �.jr. Rff�;? Tp Beach Self Serve Car Wash Hunting 99Q pNTING 0( tio a' 1012 Brioso Dr#202 C 4 Fq :.q;. Q =NOON POBq)p F 17. Costa Mesa CA 92627 pppN T Y cP� LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING II TM b E Connie Brockway, Y City Clerk • . - City of Huntington Beach f the City { ' E Office o Clerk P.O. Box 190 z > r Huntington Beach,CA 92648 pETro _ r Rf ft 153 416 36 163 Alladin Khoja e ET y RA CRS -UNjING . p 0� =NGOR POB4/F —7 Zo C.' KROJ41R 927043001 IN 03/27/95 RETURN TO SENDER 09i►s�.^=r. �t NO FORWARD ORDER ON FILE UNABLE TO FORWARD 44 1 9 = Q RETURN TO SENDER .1909. FppUNTY Cad\ LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING u II all gill 11 11 111 111 , a<E_, {I'a 11 i1�.1tr i 1.e i VI rVI 1 �` J NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH NOTICE IS HEREBY-GIVEN that on Monday,April 3, 1995,at 7:00 PM in the City Council Chambers, 2000 Main Street;Huntington Beach, the City Council will hold a public hearing-on the following items: ❑ 1. APPEAL OF CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 94-25/COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT NO. 9440/CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION(VARIANCE)NO. 94-33/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 94-12 (DEMOLITION OF THE FORMER MAXWELL'S RESTAURANT BUILDING): -Applicant: City of Huntington Beach,Department of Community Services Appellant-Councilmember Dave Sullivan-To permit the demolition of the former Maxwell's Restaurant building and construction of a new 31,000 square foot, three(3) story restaurant and banquet facility. The existing building is 28 feet in height and the request includes maintaining that building height in lieu of a maximum 25 feet as specified in the Downtown Specific Plan. Location-317 Pacific Coast Highway(south of the Municipal Pier at Main Street on the oceanside of Pacific Coast Highway) Planner Assigned: Wayne Carvalho APPEAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO.93-13-SUPERIOR ELECTRICAL ADVERTISING,INC. (CONTINUED FROM THE APRIL 4,1994 CITY COUNCIL MEETING): -Applicant: Superior Electrical Advertising,Inc. Appellant-Former Mayor Pro Tern Earle Robitaille-To permit an existing,non conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot double pole pylon sign to remain in its present location and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini and Lucas Jewelers,in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high,70 square foot freestanding sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code.Location -9891 Adams Avenue(northwest corner at Brookhurst Street) Planner Assigned: Wayne Carvalho 3. .:.CODE AMENDMENT NO. 94-5/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO.94-21-SEABRIDGE SPECIFICYLAN AMENDMENT,CENTERSTONE DEVELOPMENT COMPANY: Applicant: Centerstone Development Company. -To amend the Seabridge Specific Plan to allow medium density residential development on 3.95 acres within Area B designated for Resource Production(01),to create development standards for detached dwellings, to delete the saltwater marsh requirement and delete the requirement that the area be deeded to the Homeowner's Association. A 30 lot subdivision for planned unit development, consisting of 30 single family residential detached units was conditionally approved by the Planning Commission on February 28, 1995. Location-East side of Beach Boulevard, 400 feet south of Adams Avenue. Planner Assigned: Scott Hess NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that initial environmental assessments for the above Item(s)#1 and#3 were processed and completed in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act. It was determined that Item# 1 and#3 would not have any significant environmental effect and,therefore, a negative declaration is warranted. The Planning Commission is recommending approval of Negative Declaration No. 94-12 and Negative Declaration No. 94-21 based on their actions at the January 24, and February 28, 1995, Planning Commission meeting, respectively. NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that Item#2 is categorically exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act. NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVE14 that Item#1 is located in the appealable jurisdiction of the.Coastal Zone ,and includes.Coastal Development-Permit No. 94-10 which.has-been filed imconjunction with.the above request. .. - (CCLG040371) NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING (Continued) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Coastal Development-hearing consists of a staff report,public hearing, City Council discussion and action. Under the provisions of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code,the action taken by the City Council is final unless an appeal is filed to the Coastal Commission by the applicant or an aggrieved party. Said appeal must be in writing and must set forth in detail the actions and grounds by and upon which the applicant or interested party deems himself aggrieved. Said appeal must be submitted to the Coastal Commission office within ten(10)working days of the date of the Council's action. There is no fee for the appeal of a coastal development permit. An aggrieved person may file an appeal within ten(10)working days,pursuant to Section 30603 of the Public Resources Code, in writing to: California Coastal Commission 245 W.Broadway, Suite 380 Long Beach, California 90801-1450 Attn: Theresa Henry (310)590-5071 The Coastal Commission review period will commence after the City appeal period has ended and no appeals have been filed. Applicants will be notified by the Coastal Commission as to the date of the conclusion of the Coastal Commission review. Applicants are advised not to begin construction prior to that date. ON FILE: A copy of the proposed requests are on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach, California 92648,for inspection by the public. A copy of the staff reports will be available to interested parties at the City Clerk's Office after March 30, 1995. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If you challenge the City Council's action in court,you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice,or in written correspondence delivered to the City at,or prior to,the public hearing. If there are any further questions please call the Planning Division at 536-5271 and refer to the above items. Direct your written communications to the City Clerk. Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street,2nd Floor Huntington Beach,CA 92648(714)536-5227 (CCLG0403-2) • The Prude ome Mortgage Company,Inc. 3200 Robb ad Prudential Home Mortgage P.O. Box 19 Springfield, IL 62794-9488 i April 12, 1995 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH/OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK P.O. BOX 190 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA92648 RE: ENCLOSURE To Whom It May Concern: Enclosed please find tax documents recently received from you. Given the information provided on the correspondence, we are unable to identify it with a valid Prudential Home Mortgage loan number. Please provide name, property address and/or parcel number to enable us to properly identify and process the documentation. In the event you cannot provide additional information, please forward it to the property address . If you need further assistance, please call our Borrower Relations Department at 1-800-262-52.94 , Monday through Friday, 8 : 00 a.m. to 4 : 30 p.m. Central Time . Thank you for your assistance . Sincerely; Fran Cookson Process Services M&il TA026 022 RLV L 4� An Affiliate of The Prudential Insurance Company of America, a�1;0-� doing business as P.H.Mortgage Company,Inc.in Ohio. NOTI F CONTINUED PUBLIC HEART 5 q q a o 35 APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (45 Foot High Pylon Sign) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center,2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California,on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE/TIME: Monday,April 4, 1994, 7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Appeal of the Planning Commission's denial of Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 APPLICANT: Superior Electrical Advertising,Inc. APPELLANT: Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue(northwest corner at Brookhurst) ZONE: C2-FP2(Community Business District-Floodplain) REVISED REQUEST: To permit an existing,non conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot double pole pylon sign to remain in its present location and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini and Lucas Jewelers, in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15315, Class 15 of the California Environmental Quality Act. COASTAL STATUS: Not applicable ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Community Development Department, 2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach,California 92648, for inspection by the public. A copy of the staff report will be available to interested parties at City Hall or the Main City Library(7111 Talbert Avenue) after April 1, 1994. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above.- Written communications may also be sent to the City Clerk. If you challenge the City Council's action in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at,or prior to, the public hearing. If there are any further questions please call Wayne Carvalho,Assistant Planner at 536-5271. Connie Brockway Huntington Beach City Clerk r __ wc1p0217 Connie Brockway,City Clerk 01A, City of Huntington Beach .,... _,..__._....,.,..,.... \Office of the City ClerkP.O. Box 190 ,tiHuntington Beach,CA 92648 ---;� , v v a 1 �iS:i ICf%i�i l t�ES, ice JA[vMS TARREN DECKER ! BIRMINGHAM ✓� %W INGTpy �� 1 d ENGLAND � Q =NOON PONAIFO F9 V • cOpNTY LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Council/Agency Meeting Held: Deferred/Continued to:? eniR/9�O ❑Approved ❑ Conditionally Approved ❑ Denied City Clerk's Signature Council Meeting Date: September 18, 1995 Department ID Number: CD 95-43 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTION SUBMITTED TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS SUBMITTED BY: MICHAEL T. UBERUAGA, City Administrator 001 PREPARED BY: MELANIE S. FALLON, Community Development Director SUBJECT: APPEAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (CONTINUED FROM THE APRIL 3, 1995 CITY COUNCIL MEETING) Statement of Issue,Funding Source,Recommended Action,Alternative Action,Analysis,Environmental Stat s,Attachment( Statement of Issue: Transmitted for your consideration is an appeal by former Council Member Earle Robitaille of Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 which was denied by the Planning Commission on February 1, 1994. The public hearing was originally continued open from the April 4, 1994 City Council meeting, to the April 3, 1995 City Council meeting. The continuance was to allow the Sign Code Committee to conclude their review of the existing sign ordinance. At the April 3, 1995 meeting, the City Council granted another six (6) month continuance to allow finalization of the Sign Code revisions. The Sign Code Committee has completed their review, however, the proposed revisions have not been presented to the Planning Commission or City Council. The Sign Code revisions are expected to be presented to the Planning Commission in October. Staff anticipates the Planning Commission and City Council hearing process to be completed by the beginning of next year. Due to the length of time between public hearings, staff will re- advertise the request for the public hearing in March, 1996. Funding Source: Not applicable Recommended Action: Motion to: "Continue the public hearing open and re-advertise the public hearing on Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 to the City Council meeting of March 18, 1996." • REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTI01 MEETING DATE: September 18, 1995 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: CD 95-43 Alternative Action(s): The Council may take the following alternative action: 1. "Continue and direct staff accordingly." Analysis: Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a request by Superior Electrical Advertising, Inc. to permit an existing non-conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding double pole sign to remain at the northwest corner of Brookhurst and Adams (Mervyn's Shopping Center), and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini & Lucas Jewelers in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot sign allowed by the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. The City Council continued the item to allow a Sign Code Subcommittee the opportunity to review and recommend any changes to the existing sign ordinance. As noted, the Sign Code revisions are pending Planning Commission and City Council review. A complete analysis of the request is included in the attached April 3, 1995 staff report. Environmental Status: The proposed project is categorically exempt pursuant to Class 1, Section 15301 of the California Environmental Quality Act. MTU:MSF:HZ:WC Attachment(s): Page City Clerk's - .............. ....... - . ...... ..............._.......... - ............................... .......... . ..................... 1. Request for Council Action dated April 4, 1995 CD95-43.DOC -2- 09/11/95 2:49 PM ATTACHMENT 1 3 Council/Agency Meeting Held: Deferred/Continued to: ❑Approved ❑ Conditionally Approved ❑ Denied City Clerk's Signature = � z Council Meeting Date: April 3, 1995 Department ID Number: CDr.95-15 L acl - REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTION o m r U { N M Z = SUBMITTED TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL MEMB -' � � T SUBMITTED BY: MICHAEL T. UBERUAGA, City Admix- or PREPARED BY: MELANIE S. FALLON, Director of Community Developmen SUBJECT: APPEAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (Continued from the April 4, 1994 City Council meeting) Statement of issue,Funding Source,Recommended Action,Alternative Action,Analysis,Environmental Status,Attachment(s�/, Statement of Issue: Transmitted for your consideration is an appeal by former Councilmember Earle Robitaille of Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 which was denied by the Planning. Commission on February 1, 1994 (see Attachment No. 1). The public hearing was continued open from the April 4, 1994, City Council meeting in order to allow the Sign Code Committee to conclude their review of the existing sign ordinance. The Sign Code Committee has not completed their review therefore, no recommendation on the revisions has been presented to the Planning Commission or City Council. The committee is expected to conclude the review of the ordinance in approximately six (6) months. Funding Source: Not applicable. Recommended Action: Motion to: 'Continue the public hearing open on Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 to the City Council meeting of September 18, 1995." • REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTION MEETING DATE: April 3, 1995 DEPARTMENT ID-NUMBER. CD 95-13 Altemative Action(s): The Council may take one of the following alternative actions: 1. "Uphold the Planning Commission's action by denying Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 with findings as outlined.in.Attachment. No. 5-of:the Request,For Council Action-Staff Report dated April 4, 1994 (see Attachment No. 1);" or 2. "Overturn the Planning Commission's action and aW-o-v_e Special Sign Permit No. 93- 13 as requested by the applicant, with findings and conditions of approval as outlined in Attachment No. 9 of the Request For Council Action Staff Report_ dated April 4, 1994 (see Attachment No. 1)." Analysis• Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a request by Superior Electrical Advertising, Inc. to permit an existing non-conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding double pole sign to remain at the northwest corner of Brookhurst and Adams (Mervyn's Shopping Center), and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini & Lucas Jewelers in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot sign allowed by the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. The City Council continued the item for one (1) year to allow a Sign Code Subcommittee the opportunity to review and recommend any changes to the existing sign ordinance. The subcommittee recommendations are expected to be brought before Council within the next few months. Environmental Status: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15305, Class 5 of the California Environmental Quality Act. Attachment(s)• City Clerk's Page Number 1. Request For Council Action Staff Report dated April 4, 1994 CD95-13.DOC -2- 03/14/95 9:20 AM REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION Date: April 4, 1994 Submitted to: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members Submitted by: Michael T. Uberuaga, City Administrator Prepared by: Melanie S. Fallon, Director of Community Development.`�� Subject: APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF - SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 041 Consistent with Council Policy? ►X1 Yes ( ] New Policy or Exception Statement of Issue,Recommendation,Analysis,Funding Source,Alternative Actions,Attachments: STATEMENT OF ISSUE: Transmitted for your consideration is Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille's appeal (see Attachment No. 4) of Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 which was denied by the Planning Commission on February 1, 1994. The Special Sign Permit request by Superior Electrical Advertising, Inc. is to permit an existing non-conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding double pole sign to remain at the northwest corner of Brookhurst and Adams (Mervyn's Shopping Center), and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini &Lucas Jewelers in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square.foot sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. Mayor Pro Tempore Robitaille appealed the Planning Commission's action due to his belief that the current sign ordinance discourages business rather than promote it and that as a result of our current economic condition, he feels the City should do everything in its power to prevent businesses from leaving the City. RECOMMENDATION: Planning Commission and Staff Recommendation: Motion to: "Sustain the Planning Commission's action.and deny Special Sign Permit No. 93- 13 with findings" (see Attachment No. 5). PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION ON FEBRUARY 1. 1994: THE MOTION MADE BY BIDDLE, SECONDED BY COOK,TO DENY SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO.93-13 WITH FINDINGS(See Attachment No.5)CARRIED BY THE FOLLOWING ROLL CALL VOTE: AYES: BIDDLE,COOK,DETTLOFF,GORMAN,RICHARDSON NOES: INGLEE,NEWMAN ABSTAIN: NONE ABSENT: NONE MOTION PASSED �i ANALYSIS: Background In October 1993, Cudini & Lucas Jewelers requested a special sign permit to approve a sign face change that was installed without building permits to a 140 square foot sign cabinet located on a 45 foot high, 624 square foot non-conforming double pole sign(see Attachment No. 2). The special sign permit application was submitted following the issuance of a Notice of Violation and Request for Prosecution to the Cudini & Lucas business owner by the City's Code Enforcement section for installing the sign panels without appropriate City approval. Upon review of the application and research on the sign, it was discovered that an administrative review approval in 1985, and a planned sign program approval in 1986 required the subject freestanding sign be removed or altered to comply with the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code by January 29, 1988. The property owner an applicant ppliicant were notified a e freestanding sign was non-conforming and would have to be modified to conform with code unless the Planning Commission granted permission for it to remain. The applicant subsequently expanded his special sign permit request to allow the entire sign to remain. If approved, the 45 foot high, 624 square foot sign would be permitted in perpetuity. Prpject Description The 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding sign is located within the asphalt parking lot, approximately 55 feet from the Adams Avenue right of way, and is visible by motorists traveling east and west on Adams Avenue. The entire sign consists of 1. A 224 square foot double face sign copy identifying Mervyn's; 2. A 260 square foot single face sign copy identifying Thrifty, with an L.A.Tronics sign copy on the opposite side (rotating sign); and 3. A 140 square foot square foot double face sign cabinet for Cudini & Lucas Jewelers (see Attachment No. 2) The Huntington Beach Ordinance Code permits one (1)center identification freestanding sign per street frontage, with a maximum height of 15 feet, and 70 square feet in area. The sign is required to be located within a landscape planter and is permitted to identify the center and/or major tenant only. The following is a zoning conformance matrix that compares the applicant's request with Section 9610.5 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code: Section Issue Permitted Proposed 9610.5 Permitted Signs: Adams Ave. (831' frontage) Max.No: Freestanding 1 1 Monument 2 1 RCA-4/4/94 2 ssp93-13 Pamitted- Proposed 9610.5 (Con't) Max. Area: Freestanding 70 sf 624 sf total* (includes 150 sf jewelers sign)* Monument 30 sf 60 sf Max.Height:.. Freestanding 15 ft. 45 ft.* Monument 7 ft. 9 ft. Sign Copy: Limited to center 3 major tenants !- - Freestanding ID and/or major Mervyn's, tenant Thrifty/L.A.Tronics 1 additional tenant: Jewelers* Monument Business ID only Polly's Distance between monument signs 200 ft. N/A Sign location Must be in Located in paved landscaped planter parking lot* *Special Sign Permit Request Administrative Review No. 85-55, approved on January 29, 1986 for a new 1,700 square foot restaurant expansion within the Mervyn's Center,required the property owner to remove or modify the existing 45 foot high sign within a two(2)year period. A condition of approval required that a planned sign program be submitted prior to issuance of building permits for the addition. It also specified that the major identification sign comply with the Huntington Beach Sign Code by January 29, 1988, and that rotating signs were prohibited, referring to the rotating Thrifty sign(see Attachment No. 7). Planned Sign Program No. 86-5, approved in March of 1987, established criteria for all new freestanding and wall signs in the shopping center. It addressed design elements including size, color and sign type to create a coordinated sign theme throughout the center. The sign program also specified the maximum signage allowed for freestanding signs with a 15 foot height limit, a 70 square foot limit on sign area, and a restriction on the sign copy to the center and major tenant only. A condition on the planned sign program requiring the removal or alteration of the non- conforming 45 foot high sign by January 29, 1988 was reiterated in the Notice of Action letter to the property owner(see Attachment No. 8). . 6 RCA-4/4/94 3 ssp93-13 • Planning Commission Meeting At the February 1, 1994 Planning Commission meeting, Mr. Stan Janocha, applicant, Mr. Leo Margarit, store owner of Cudini & Lucas Jewelers, and Richard Harlow spoke in favor of the request. They gave a brief history of the sign, and explained how the Cudini & Lucas business was located in a building not easily visible from the street. Mr. Harlow also suggested that the Commission continue the item until the City Council Sign Committee completed the sign code rewrite. There was no one who spoke in opposition to the request. At the meeting, staff also provided a sign alternative for the purpose of Planning Commission discussion. The alternative consisted of a 15 foot high, 100 square foot double pole sign with �f9 r.(4)tenant panels (see Attachment No. 3) providing street exposure for all four(4)tenants, including Cudini & Lucas. As discussed in the Planning Commission staff report dated February 1, 1994, staff believes that a 15 foot high sign would be compatible with other signs on surrounding commercial properties. The sign would comply with all other sign code provisions including the minimum site angle requirement for signs located in a landscape planter. Reasons for Appeal Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille states in his appeal letter(see Attachment No. 4) that the Planning Commission's action would cause an extreme problem for all businesses in the Mervyn's Center who rely on the sign. He explains that neither the Planning Division nor City, Council have pursued the revision of the sign ordinance, which the Council as a whole has been demanding. Finally, he states that the Chamber of Commerce has been excluded from providing day-to-day input in this matter. u a Staff recommends that the request to retain the 45 foot high pylon sign and permit the Cudini & Lucas sign face change be denied due to its excessive size, and its incompatibility with surrounding signs that have been modified to conform with the current code. The 624 square foot freestanding sign is approximately 900 percent over what is currently permitted under the Huntington Beach Sign Code, and is not proportionate with the shopping center. Furthermore, the property owner has had ample time to comply with the previous conditions imposed over eight (8)years ago. The two (2)year amortization period that the property owner received in 1986, actually resulted in the use of the sign for six(6) additional years. The sign currently provides identification for four(4) different businesses with between 140 and 260 square feet of sign copy for each business. This exceeds the amount of signage permitted on other commercial properties. By denying this special sign permit, the property owner will be required to comply with Code and the previous conditions imposed under Administrative Review No. 85-55 and Planned Sign Program No. 86-5, which will be consistent with other recently installed signs in the vicinity. Staff has provided an alternative action that consists of a 15 foot high, 100 square foot pole sign with up to four (4) tenant panels. This would allow the four tenant who currently have panels on the 45 foot high sign to continue receiving street exposure. A 15 foot high sign would be RCA-4/4/94 4 ssp93-13 _ 1 • compatible with other signs on surrounding commercial properties, including the recently approved Rally's sign (12 foot high).. A new freestanding.sign would be required to be placed in a landscape planter while complying with the minimum site angle visibility requirements. Environmental Status This project is categorically exempt pursuant to Class 15, Section 15315 of the California Environmental Quality Act. FUNDING SOURCE: Not applicable . ALTERNATIVE ACTIO The City Council may make one of the following motions: A. "Approve Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 as requested by the applicant with findings and conditions of approval:" or B. "Approve Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 (staff alternative) as modified by staff with findings and conditions of approval." ATTACHMENTS: 1. Area Map 2 Site plan and sign elevation dated October 6, 1993 3. Sign elevation(staff alternative) 4. Appeal memo from Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille dated February 2, 1994 S. Minutes of the February 1, 1994 Planning Commission meeting(Findings for Denial) 6. Planning Commission Staff Report dated February 1, 1994 7. Administrative Review No. 85-55 8. Planned Sign Program No. 86-5 9. Draft findings and conditions of approval (Applicant's request) 10. Draft findings and conditions of approval (Staff alternative) MTU:MSF:WC:lp RCA - 4/4/94 5 ssp93-13 ♦ 16 BOLSA ® �9 8 MCF sN _ I CLNr — mlNcat HEIL wARINER \ SIATER s \ �o • • • rALBERT \ _ LLUS •\ — — — — GARFIELD MERVYN'S / YORKTOwN U �� • ADAMS R / ••w• y /INDUNAFDLIS Y b� : s>:................................. 8 ATLANTA FFElAMMMT N HAMII.TON lAbAms / S N BANNING Ck / 'ATTACHMENT NO. Alb' SSP 93- 13 HUNTINGTON BEACH PLANNING DMSION EXISTING POLE SIGN..- /FACE CNANGE) —— •:►� ii s ==jJ na �" rye t L_2... tL':UJWYyIi�:�_..17!�lll�:J%�;L'�u;;;lirLgU�lS'-Y ----•�:• . ADANS sTAEET SRE PLAN.SIGN LOCATION NOT TO SCALE � I y :G G ; F�isrltii GYFc*I•� S'F��::+�r•Fi � I Iv I. s�'��% yclfT:n/, 44C;:PsG I=• . v yam` �• RUG AHD DISCOUNT STORES w z a CLIDI''I W) LUCA S JEWELERS � s.' V� vslrt7saC7vt;n+G�EWEtLP;•D::aOs:CROKE°S•APPRLISAtS - . C D/F FACE CHANGE I.NEWFACESAREACRYMPLAS77C WTMWMnOVERLA SCALE: 1/2-= =0- COPY&DESIGN. i COLORS:BACKGROUND-s;S2s WWrTE NSt Of I Vn CABIM ALL COPY-DARK BLUE '' - 2.MOTE:ALL MS77NO CABINET MEASUREMENTS TO BE VERIFIED ON SRE PRIOR TO PA NEC FABRICATION A INSI - supErior ��. dectricel•dvertlslnpl s,e..a..,..t"It - L1+I. !:7'.4 y'I�jJ�j1/� -✓es�gj,JLje'1`h�fti'S ATTACHMENT NO. 2 6TAT: r R�TERNA7NE 7r� ri L . a � I RvN/�S CUo I N I it LUGf} 5 I.JELER%1 0 9891 0 e ATTACHMENT NO., �I CITY COUNCIL COMMUNICATIONITY OV-HUNTINGTOW BEACH' HUNnNGTON!EACH T� t TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members FROM: Earle Robitaille, Mayor Pro Tempore `r DATE; February 2, 1994 SUBJECT: SIGN PERMIT APPEAL: I would like to appeal special sign permit number 93-13.because of the following reasons: 1. The action taken by the Planning Commission will cause an extreme problem for all the businesses in the Mervyn's Center who rely on this sign. 2. Neither the Planning Department nor the City Council, have seen fit to get on with the revision of this ordinance. The Council as a whole has been demanding. 3. The Huntington Beach Chamber of Commerce, whose members have the most to loose or gain,have once again been excluded from providing day-to-day input in this matter. 4. The undue cost to businesses in Huntington Beach is driving out businesses in*local circles, our sign ordinance is known as part of our"business prevention plan." ER:paj xc: City Clerk Melanie Fallon, Director of Community Development DRAFT, B-2 SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (CONTINUED FROM THE DECEMBER 21. 1993 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING): APPLICANT: Superior Electrical Advertising, Inc. LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue (northwest comer at Brookhurst) Special Sign P - -existing 4516uut high, 624 square foot freestanding double pole sign to remain at the northwest comer of Brookhurst and Adams (Mervyn's Shopping Center). In addition,the applicant requests to install a new sign face identifying Cudini &Lucas Jewelers, into an existing five (5) foot by 28 foot sign cabinet which is located directly under the Mervyn's and Thrifty/L.A.Tronics sign copies. The Cudini &Lucas Jewelers sign was installed without permits,which resulted in a violation notice issued by the City's Code Enforcement section in May of 1993. Following a request for prosecution to the City Attorney's Office, the applicant ' submitted this special sign permit application requesting to keep the entire sign. The approval-of Administrative Review No. 85-55 on January 29, 1986, to permit a 1,700 square foot restaurant addition within the Mervyn's Center, required the property owner to remove or alter the existing sign to comply with the City's sign code within two (2) years. The two (2) year sign amortization period ended January 29, 1988, and the sign is still erected. The sign is approximately 900 percent over what is currently allowed by code and is not proportionate in size with the center. Furthermore,the property owner has had ample time to comply with the previous conditions imposed over eight (8)years ago. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Due to the size of the sign and the previous requirement to comply with the City's sign code by January of 1988, staff recommends the Planning Commission deny the request to allow the freestanding sign and the sign face change with findings. THE PUBLIC HEARING WAS OPENED. Stan Janocha, 20781 Hunter Lane, applicant, submitted a letter to the Commission. Mr. Janocha gave a brief history of the sign, and urged the Commission to approve the request. ATTACHMBUONC :1 PC Minutes - 6/15/93 4 (KL001) . i3 i DRAFT Leo L. Margarit, Cudini & Lucas Jewelers, 9891 Adams Avenue, store owner, stated that his business is not easily visible from the street. He asked the Commission to approve their request. Richard Harlow, 211 Main Street, representing applicant, asked the Commission to approve the request, and if they did not to continue the request until the City Council Sign Committee finishes their sign code rewrite. TIEERE NVER PN%0 OTHER PERSONS PRESENT TO SPEAK FOR OR AGAINST THE REQUEST AND THE PUBLIC HEARING WAS CLOSED. A MOTION WAS MADE BY BIDDLE, SECOND BY COOK TO DENY SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 WITH FINDINGS FOR DENIAL,'BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: Cook, Gorman, Dettloff, Richardson, Biddle NOES: Inglee,Newman ABSENT: None ABSTAIN: None MOTION PASSED FINDINGS FOR DENIAL- SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13: 1. Strict compliance with Article 961 will not result in a substantial economic hardship to the applicant because the shopping center is permitted a 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign, two (2) 30 square foot monument signs, and each.business is allowed wall signage that provides adequate signage for the center. 2. There are no unusual site or building characteristics that preclude Cudini &Lucas Jewelers from yielding adequate signage from the'provisions of the sign code. Secondary businesses in the shopping center are permitted wall signs, and can provide exposure by directing customers to the "Mervyn's Center" as intended by the Huntington Beach Sign Code. In addition, a sign panel on a monument sign would be permitted. PC Minutes - 6/15/93 5 (KL001) 1T r DRAFE 3. Due to the fact that there are no unusual site or building characteristics applicant to the site, approval of the 45 foot high, 624 square foot pole sign, and 140 square foot sign face change would be a grant of special privilege not enjoyed by surrounding properties. The existing 45 foot high freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with the City's sign code by January 29, 1988. The sign, in its present state, constitutes excessive signage, and is an aesthetic impact to the commercial center and to surrounding properties. B-3 COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT NO. 93-28/CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 94-2 (CONTINUED FROM THE JANUARY 19. 1994 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING),: APPLICANT: Orange County Environmental Management Agency (Harbors, Beaches and Parks Division) LOCATION: 5801 Seapoint Avenue (west side of Seapoint Avenue between Palm and Garfield). Coastal Development Permit No. 93-28 was continued at the January 19, 1994 meeting to allow for advertising of a Conditional Use Permit in conjunction with the Coastal Development Permit application. Coastal Development Permit No. 93-28 and Conditional Use Permit No. 94-3 are a request by the County of Orange to review and approve the general design plans for Phase I of the Bolsa Chica Regional Park. Phase I consists of development of a forty (40) space parking lot, two park entry points with signage, a vista overlook with interpretive signage,bicycle/pedestrian trails, two picnic areas, security lighting,perimeter fencing and signage, installation of ornamental and native plant materials and irrigation. Phase IA also includes creation of a 2 acre wetland enhancement area located beyond the City' s boundary within the County's jurisdiction. Because this area is outside the City's jurisdiction, the County will be applying directly to the California Coastal Commission to obtain a Coastal Development Permit for this area. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission approve the request because it is consistent with the General Development Plan and Environmental Impact Report that were conceptually approved by the Huntington Beach City Council in October of 1992 and conforms with the plans,policies, requirements and standards of the City's Local Coastal Program PC Minutes - 6/15/93 6 (KL001) - 15 Huntington Beach Department of Community Development 5TAFF REF ORT EXECUTIVE SUMMARY SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (9891 Adams Avenue) Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a revised request to permit an existing 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding double pole sign to remain at the northwest corner of Brookhurst and Adams - '(Me'•J"' SIl ant reque$ts t stall .. new sign f�ee- identifying Cudini & Lucas Jewelers, into an existing five (5) foot by 28 foot sign cabinet which is located directly under the Mervyn's and Thrifty/L.A.Tronics sign copies. The Cudini & Lucas Jewelers sign was installed without permits, which resulted in a violation notice issued by the City's Code Enforcement section in May of 1993. Following a request for prosecution to the City Attorney's Office, the applicant submitted this special sign permit application requesting to keep the entire sign. The approval of Administrative Review No. 85-55 on January 29, 1986, to permit a 1,700 square foot restaurant addition within the Mervyn's Center, required the property owner to remove or alter the existing sign to comply with the City's sign code within two (2) years. The two (2) year sign amortization period ended January 29, 1988, and the sign is still erected. The sign is approximately 900 percent over what is currently allowed by code and is not proportionate in size with the center. Furthermore,the property owner has had ample time to comply with the previous conditions imposed over eight(8) years ago. Due to the size of the sign and the previous requirement to comply with the City's sign code by January of 1988, staff recommends the Planning commission deny the request to allow the freestanding sign and the sign face change with findings. B -2 ATTACHMENT NO.�--L . l6 TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: February 1, 1994 SUBJECT: SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (CONTINUED FROM THE DECEMBER 21, 1993 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING) APPLICANT: Superior Electric Advertising, Inc. 1700 W. Anaheim Street, Long Beach, CA 90813 PROPERTY OWNER: Mark Sork, 1500 Adams Avenue, Suite 315, Costa Mesa, CA 92626 REVISED REQUEST: To permit an existing, non conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot double pole pylon sign to remain in its present location and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini and Lucas Jewelers, in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue (northwest corner at Brookhurst) DATE ACCEPTED: December 9, 1993 ZONE: C2-FP2 (Community Business District-Floodplain) GENERAL PLAN: General Commercial EXISTING USE: Retail Shopping Center . 1.0 SUGGESTED ACTION: Motion to: "Deny Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 with findings for denial." 2.0 GENERAL INFORMATION: Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a request to permit a 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding pylon sign(identifying four tenants: Mervyn's,Thrifty,L.A. Tronics, and Cudini &Lucas Jewelers)to remain at the Mervyn's Shopping Center. The applicant also requests to legalize a sign face change to a 5' by 30' cabinet identifying the Cudini & Lucas Jewelers business which was installed without building permits. Section 9610.5 (b) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code specifies that commercial sites Staff Report-2/1/94 -1- (pcsr005) . i1 l ' with over 400 feet of frontage be restricted to one(1)center identification sign per street frontage, a maximum 15 feet in height and 70 square feet in area. The signs are permitted to identify the center and/or major tenant and must be in a landscaped planter. In addition, the freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with Code by January 29, 1988, as a condition of a previously approved Administrative Review(Administrative Review No. 85-55). 3.0 SURROUNDING LAND USE, ZONING AND GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATIONS: North and West of Su ' ct Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Medium Density Residential ZONE: R3-FP2 (Medium-High Density Residential- LAND USE: Condominium Complex East and South of Subject Propea: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: General Commercial ZONE: C2-FP2 (Community Business-Floodplain) LAND USE: Retail Commercial Uses 4.0 ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: The proposed project is categorically exempt pursuant to Class 15315, Section 15 of the California Environmental Quality Act. 5.0 COASTAL STATUS: Not applicable. 6.0 REDEVELOPMENT STATUS: Not applicable. 7.0 SPECIFIC PLAN: Not applicable. 8.0 SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE: Not applicable. 9.0 ISSUES AND ANALYSIS: Background In October 1993; Cudini & Lucas Jewelers requested a special sign permit to approve a sign face change that was installed without building permits to a 140 square foot sign cabinet located'on a 45 foot high, 624 square foot non conforming double pole sign(see Attachment No. 2). The special sign permit application was submitted as a result of a Notice of Violation and Request for Prosecution that was issued to the Cudini & Lucas business owner by the City's Code Enforcement section for installing the sign panels without appropriate City approval.. / Staff Report-2/1/94 -2- (pcsr005) I¢ Upon review of the application and research on the sign, it was discovered that as a result of an Administrative Review approval in 1985, and a planned sign program approval in 1986, the subject freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code by January 29, 1988 (see Attachment No. 3). The property owner and applicant were notified that the freestanding sign was non-conforming and that it would have to be modified to conform with code unless the Planning Commission granted permission for it to remain. The applicant subsequently expanded his special sign permit request to allow the entire sign to remain. If approved, the 45 foot high, 624 square foot sign would be permitted in perpetuity. Prgject Description The 45 foot high, 24 square foot freestanding sign is located within the asphalt parking lot, _ approximately 55 feet from the Adams Avenue right of way and visible from motorist traveling east and west on Adams Avenue. The entire sign consists of. 1. A 224 square foot double face sign copy identifying Mervyn's; 2. A 260 square foot single face sign copy identifying Thrifty, with an L.A.Tronics sign copy on the opposite side; and 3. A 140 square foot double face sign cabinet for Cudini & Lucas Jewelers (see Attachment No. 2). The Huntington Beach Ordinance Code permits one (1) center identification freestanding sign per street frontage, with a maximum height of 15 feet, and 70 square feet in area. The sign is required to be located within a landscape planter and is restricted to identify the center and/or major tenant. The following is a zoning conformance matrix that compares the applicants request with Section 9610.5 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code: i Section Issue Required Proposed 9610.5 Permitted signs: Adams Ave. (83l' frontage) Max.No: Freestanding 1 1 Monument 2 1 Max. Area: Freestanding 70 sf 624 sf total* (includes 150 sf jewelers sign)* Monument 30 sf 60 sf Max. Height: Freestanding 15 ft. 45 ft.* Monument 7 ft. 9 ft. *Specia-] Sign Permit Request Staff Report-2/1/94 -3- (pcsr005) Q � 1 I Section Issue Required Proposed 9610.5 (Con't) Sign Copy: Limited to center 2 major tenants Freestanding ID and/or major Mervyn's/Thrifty tenant 1 other tenant: Jewelers* Monument Business ID only Polly's Distance between Sign location Must be in Located in paved landscaped planter parking lot* *Special Sign Permit Request The Administrative Review approved on January 29, 1986, for a new 1,700 square foot restaurant expansion within the Mervyn's Center required the property owner to remove or modify the existing 45 foot high sign within a two (2)year period. In addition, a condition of approval required that a Planned Sign Program be submitted prior to issuance of building permits for the addition. It also specified that the major identification sign comply with the Huntington Beach Sign Code by January 29, 1988, and that rotating signs were prohibited (see Attachment No. 5). Planned Sign Program No. 86-5 was approved in March of 1987, establishing criteria for all new freestanding and wall signs in the center. It addressed design elements including size, color and sign type to create a coordinated sign theme throughout the center. The sign program also specified the maximum signage allowed for the freestanding sign with a 15 foot height limit, a 70 square foot limit on sign area, and a restriction on the sign copy to the center and major tenant only. A condition requiring the removal or alteration of the non conforming 45 foot high sign by January 1988, was reiterated in the Notice of Action letter to the property owner(see Attachment No. 6). Staff recommends that the request to retain the 45 foot high pylon sign and permit the Cudini and Lucas sign face change be denied due to its excessive size, and its incompatibility with surrounding signs that have been modified to conform with the current code. The 624 square foot freestanding sign is approximately 900 percent over what is currently permitted under the Huntington Beach Sign Code, and is not proportionate with the shopping center. Furthermore, the property owner has had ample time to comply with the previous conditions imposed over eight(8) years ago. The two (2) year amortization period that the property owner received in 1986, actually resulted in the use of the sign for six(6) additional years. The sign currently Staff Report-2/1/94 -4- (pcsr005) 20 provides identification for four(4) different businesses with between 140 and 260 square feet of sign copy for each business. This exceeds the amount of signage permitted on other commercial properties. By denying this special sign permit,the property owner will be required to comply with Code and the conditions of approval of the Administrative Review and Planned Sign Program which will be consistent with other recently installed signs in the vicinity. Staff has provided an alternative for discussion which includes a 15 foot high, 100 square foot double pole sign with four(4)tenant panels. The alternative will provide exposure for all four (4)tenants while remaining compatible with other signs in the immediate vicinity. 10.0 RECOMMENDATION: Staff reeontmends that the ission den Special Sign Permit No 1-3-with-the following findings for denial: FINDINGS FOR DENIAL - SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 : 1. Strict compliance with Article 961 will not result in a substantial economic hardship to the applicant because the shopping center is permitted a 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign, and each business is allowed adequate wall signage. 2. There are no unusual site or building characteristics that preclude Cudini & Lucas Jewelers from yielding adequate signage from the provisions of the sign code. Secondary businesses in the shopping center are permitted wall signs, and can provide exposure by directing customers to the "Mervyn's Center" as intended by the Huntington Beach Sign Code. 3. Due to the fact that there are no unusual site or building characteristics applicant to the site, approval of the 45 foot high, 624 square foot pole sign, and 140 square foot sign face change would be a grant of special privilege not enjoyed by surrounding properties. The existing 45 foot high freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with the City's sign code by January 29, 1988. The sign, in its present state, constitutes excessive signage, and is an aesthetic impact to the commercial center and to surrounding properties. 11.0 ALTERNATIVE ACTION: The Planning Commission may: A. Approve Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 for a 15 foot high, 100 square foot, multi tenant sign (see Attachment No. 8) with draft findings and conditions of approval; or B. Approve Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 for a maximum two (2) year period with draft findings and suggested conditions of approval (applicant's request). Staff Report-2/1/94 -5- (pcsr005) ATTACHMENTS: 1. Planning Commission Staff Report dated December 21, 1993 2. Applicant's revised narrative 3. Site plans and sign elevations dated October 6, 1993 4. Sign Elevations (Staff Alternative) 5. Administrative Review No. 85-55 6. Planned Sign Program No. 86-5 7. Alternative Findings and Conditions of Approval(Applicant's Request) 8. Alternative Findings and Conditions of Approval (Staff Alternative) SH:W rC:kQjll Staff Report-2/1/94 -6- (pcsr005) z�. huntington beach department of community development STAff REPORT EXECUTIVE SUMARY DECEMBER 21, 1993 SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (9891 Adams Avenue) Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a request to permit a sign face change to a five (5) foot by 30 foot cabinet on an existing 45 foot high pylon sign located at the northwest corner of Brookhurst an Adams (Mervyn' s Shopping Center) . The subject sign, identifying Cudini & Lucas Jewelers, was installed without permits, which resulted in the issuance of violation notice by the City' s Code Enforcement section in May of this year. Following a request for prosecution to the City Attorney' s Office, the applicant submitted this special sign permit application. The 150 square foot sign cabinet is part of a 45 foot high, 634 square foot non conforming freestanding sign, which identifies Mervyn' s, Thrifty, and Cudini & Lucas Jewelers . As a condition of approval for Administrative Review No. 85-55, and a requirement for Planned Sign Program No. 86-5, the freestanding sign was required- to be removed or altered to comply with the City' s sign code by January 29, 1988 . Since the status of the overall sign is that it must be removed, it is inappropriate to consider a sign panel which is part of' the overall sign. The entire sign must be evaluated before a panel can be considered. The City is actively pursuing compliance with the conditions of the aforementioned entitlements, as the applicant has not complied to date. A-PL-FM-23D 1 TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: December 21, 1993 SUBJECT: SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 APPLICANT: Superior Electrical Advertising, Inc. , 1700 W. Anaheim Street, Long Beach, CA 90813 PROPERTY OWNER: Mark Sork, 1500 Adams Avenue, Suite 315, Costa Mesa, CA 92626 REQUEST: To allow an existing sign face change (Cudini & Lucas Jewelers). to . a 150. square foot (5 feet x 30_ feet) cabinet sign, on an existing 45 foot high, three (3) panel, double pole pylon sign, pursuant to Section 9610 . 7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue (northwest corner at Brookhurst) DATE ACCEPTED: December 9, 1993 ZONE: C2-FP2 (Community Business-Floodplain) GENERAL PLAN: General Commercial EXISTING USE: Retail Shopping Center 1 . 0 SUGGESTED ACTION: Motion to: "Deny Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 with findings . " 2 . 0 GENERAL INFORMATION: Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a request to aloow an existing sign. face change to a five (5) foot by 30 foot cabinet on an existing non-conforming 45 foot high 634 square foot pylon sign which identifies three (3) tenants (Mervyn' a, Thrifty & Cudini & Lucas Jewelers) . The Cudini & Lucas Jewelers sign panel was installed without building permits. The entire pylon sign is non-conforming due to its size and that it was required to be brought into conformance with the code in 1988 pursuant to an Administrative Review and Planned Sign Program requirement. Section 9610 . 5(b) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code specifies that commercial sites with over 400 feet of frontage be restricted to one (1) center identification sign per street frontage, a maximum 15 feet in height and 70 square feet in area . The signs are permitted to identify the center and/or major tenant . 3 .0 SURROUNDING LAND USE, ZONING AND GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATIONS: North and West of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Medium Density Residential ZONE: R3-FP2 (Medium-High Density Residential - Floodplain) LAND USE: Condominium Complex East and South of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: General Commercial ZONE: C2-FP2 (Community Business-Floodplain) LAND USE: Retail Commercial Uses 4 . 0 ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: The proposed project is categorically exempt pursuant to Class 15315, Section 15 of the California Environmental Quality Act. 5 . 0 COASTAL STATUS: Not applicable. 5 . 0 REDEVELOPMENT STATUS: Not applicable. 7. 0 SPECIFIC PLAN: Not applicable. $ . 0 SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE: Not applicable. 2 . 0 ISSUES AND ANALYSIS: Cudini & Lucas Jewelers had a 150 square foot (five (5) foot by 30 foot) sign face change without building permits and zoning approval on an existing 45 foot high, 634 square foot non conforming freestanding sign. The business owner was issued a Notice of Violation by the City' s Code Enforcement section for installing the sign panel without appropriate City approval. Following a request for prosecution to the City Attorney' s Office, the business owner submitted a special sign permit application to allow the sign panel to remain. The sign, identifying Cudini & Lucas Jewelers, is in a cabinet located under the existing Mervyn's and Thrifty sign copies (see Attachment No. 2) . The pylon sign, situated off Adams Avenue, identifies Mervyn' s (224 square feet) , Thrifty (260 square feet) , and Cudini & Lucas Jewelers (150 square feet) for a total of 634 square feet . The Huntington Beach Ordinance Code permits one (1) center identification freestanding sign per street frontage, with a maximum height of 15 feet, and 70 square feet in area. The sign is restricted to identify the center and/or major tenant. Staff Report - 12/21/93 -2- (7474d) The following is a zoning conformance matrix: Section Issue Required Proposed 9610 .5(b) Permitted signs: Adams Avenue (831' frontage) Max. Number: Freestanding 1 1 Monument 2 1 Max. Area: Freestanding 70 sq. ft . 634 sq. ft. total** (includes _-. --- -150 sq ft� jewelers sign) * Monument 30 sq. ft . 60 sq. ft. Max. Height: Freestanding 15 ft. 45 ft. * Monument 7 ft. 9 ft. Sign Copy: Freestanding Limited to center 2 major tenants ID and/or major Mervyn' s/Thrifty tenant 1 other tenant: Jewelers* Monument Business ID- Polly' s only Distance between Monument signs 200 ft. n/a Sign location- Must be in land- Located in paved scaped planter parking lot* *Special Sign Permit Request **Non Conforming Sign As a result of an Administrative Review approval in 1985, and a planned sign program approval in 1986, the subject freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code by January 29, 1988 (see Attachment No. 3) . To date, the property owner has not complied with the conditions of approval. Code Enforcement staff is actively pursuing compliance of all previous conditions . Staff recommends that the request for the Cudini and Lucas sign face change be denied because a partial modification to a nonconforming sign is prohibited. Furthermore, since the sign was previously required t( be removed by January of 1988, the property owner is -required to compl)r with the previous conditions and remove the non conforming sign. 26 Staff Report - 12/21/93 -3- (7474d) 10.0 RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission deny Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 with the following findings : FINDINGS FOR DENIAL - SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO, 93-13 : 1. Strict compliance with Article 961 will not result in a substantial economic hardship to the applicant because the business is permitted adequate wall signage by the code. Furthermore, the center is permitted a 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign to identify the center and/or major tenant. 2. T ere are no unusua si a or bu'iIding c ' stics that preclude Cudini & Lucas Jewelers from yielding adequate signage from the provisions of the sign code. Secondary businesses in the center are permitted wall signs, and can provide exposure by directing customers to the "Mervyn' s Center" as intended by the . Huntington Beach Sign Code. 3 . Due to the fact that there are no unusual site or building characteristics applicable to the site, approval of a sign face change to a non-conforming freestanding sign would be a grant of special privilege not enjoyed by surrounding properties . The existing 45 foot high- freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with the City' s sign code on January 29 , 1988 . The sign, in its present state, constitutes , excessive signage, and is an aesthetic impact to the commercial center and to surrounding properties . 11 . 0 ALTERNATIVE ACTION: The Planning Commission may continue Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 until such time the applicant and/or property owner consents to include the entire sign into the special sign permit request . ATTACHMENTS: 1. Narrative 2 .--SitQ-p a s auks-ign- elleva-tiens dated Get9be* 6, '—�_ _ SH:WC:kjl Staff Report - 12/21/93 -4- (7474d) - �1 12/15/1993 11:58 31043519 •SUPERIOR ELECiNYERT PAGE 01 December 5, 1993 MR. WAYNE CARVALHO City of H 'ntington Beach. . 2000 Main Street SIGNAGE Huntington Beach, CA 92648 CORPORATE ea r. _ IDENTITY Superior lectrical Advertising, Inc. and Cudini & PROGRAMMED Lucas Jew lers respectfully request from the City of MAINTENANCE Huntingto Beach, approval on a variance to allow the Identificz tion lettering added to an existing sign to remain as is. The reasoi for our request, is as follows : Approxima ely four months. ago, Mr. Leo Margarit of Cudini & ucas Jewelers contracted to have .vinyl letters a1he ded to the bottom panels of an existing pylon sign. At time this was done. Mr. Margarit did not realize hi needed a permit. Since finding out about the necessity of a permit, he has contracted with Superior to handle the variance. We feel t a variance is justified for the following SERVING THE reason: GLOBEFROM LONG BEACH, C., This is .a existing sign .that is set back approximately HOUSTON, TX 75' from he property line. There_ are three modules on SEATTLE, WA a double o I a structure. Mervyns owns the . rIghts to the top modul T.hrifty and L. A. Tronics have the middle module an Cudini & Lucas Jewelers attached letters to the exist ng blank bottom module. _ . Because a 1 four tenants who are on this sign have extremely poor visibility of their storefrontsfrom both Adam and Brookhurst, they depend on this *pylon - for, their- success. , I spoke w th the property owner today and he is willing - to includ the entire sign in this variance. if the commissio agrees, 'we would like to' continue this item until we . an revise our submittal to include the entire 310.495.380P sign. 800.995.90, 310.435.186t.rA: 1700 West Anaheim Street 8 Long Beach rA OAR1a.1199; 12/15/1993 11:58 3104351� SUPERIOR ELEC #ERT PAGE 02 MR. WAYNE ARVALHO City of Hu tington Beach December ! , 1993 Page 2 of Please cal me and let me know how you would like us to • proceed on this matter. Sin rely, JANOC A SJ/he FAX 714-3 -1540 cc: Leo M rgarit Mark Sork December 16 1993I FT- DEC 1 7 1993 SIGNAGE . MR. WAYNE CARVALHO CORPORATE City of Rlintington Beach IDENTITY 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 PROGRAMMED MAINTENANCE Re: Variance Cudini & Lucas Jewelers Dear Mr. Carvalho: As per your request, Mr. Leo Margarit of Cudini & Lucas Jewelers and Mark Sork, property owner, have agreed to revise our Variance submittal to include the entire pylon sign. Both parties agree to a continuance, if staff needs more time to prepare for this project. Please call me as soon as possible so I can inform all SERVING THE parties the date the Planning Commission will hear this GLOBEFROM case. LONG BEACH, C, HOUSTON, TX Thanks. SEATTLE, WA Sincerely, CQ/ STAN JANOCHA SJ/he FAX 714-374-1540 cc: Leo Margarit Mark Sork 310.495.3808 800.995.9099 310.435.186' 1700 West Anaheim Street Long Beach 30 CA 90813-1195 • BOARD of zcni 1G ADJUSTMEnTS .II CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH-CALIFORNIA P.O. BOX 190.92"1 PHONE 1714) 536-3271 RECONSIDERATION OF CONDITICNAL EXCEPTION NO. 85-96 in conjunction with RECONSIDERATION OF ADMINISTPA'"I" . REVIEW NO. 65-55 Applicant: L & M Investnent Company 1500 Adams Avenue, Suite 315 Costa Mesa, California 92626 Request: To construct a 1,700 Square Foot reste.urant addition with a variance to maintain existing 2'-8 wide planter along Brookhurst Street and Adams avenue Location.: Subject property is located at 19881 Brookhurst Street (Northwest corner of Adams Avenue and Brookhurst Street ) Date of Approval: January 29, 1986 Dear Applicant: Your applications Were acted upon by the Huntington Beach Board of Zoning .,kdjustments on January 29, 1986, and your requests were Conditionally Approved. Under the provisions of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, the action taken by the Board of Zoning Adjustments is final unless an appeal is filed to the Planning Commission by you or by an interested party. Said appeal must be in Writing and must- set forth in. detail the action and grounds by which the applicant or interested party deems himself aggrieved. Said appeal must be accompanied by a filing fee of One Hunlred and Sixty-five Dollars ($165.00) aind submitted to the Secretary of the Planning Commission within ten (10) days of the date of Lhe Board's .decision. The last day for filing an appeal and paying - :ling fee for the above noted application is February. 8, la►.o. ATTACHMENT NO.' Page Two Conditional Exception No. 85-96 Administrative Review No. 85-55 Provisions of the Huntington :�,tach Ordinance Code are such that any application becomes null and void one ( 1 ) year after the final approval, unless actual construction has begun. FINDINI;S FOR APPROVAL CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 85-96 : 1.. Because. of spe.cial. circumstances applicable to the subject property, including size, shape, and location the strict application of the Zoning Ordinance is found to deprive the subject property of privileges enjoyed by cthe: properties in the vicinity and under identical zone classifications. The _ site currently has 6 15% of landscaping and, in addition to the 218" wide planter along Brookhurst and Adams, there is a low garden wall which further screens the parking area. 2. The granting of this conditional exception is necessary in order to preserve the enjoyment of one or more substantial property rights. 3. The granting of Conditional Exception No. 85-96 will not be materially detrimental to the public -welfare, or injurious to property in the same zone classifications. 4. The granting of the conditional exception will not adversely affect the General Plan of. the City of Huntington Beach. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 85-96 1. A revised site plan shall be submitted depicting the modifications described in Condition I of the conditions of ' approval for Administrative Review 85-55. 2. All conditions of Administrative Review No. 85-55 shall be Yj applicable. - CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW 85-55 1. A revised site plan shall be submitted depicting the modifications described herein: a. Indicate compact parking spaces along perimeter of the site b. Provide 643 parking spaces. c. Aisleways shall be minimum 20' adjacent to the new retail space at the northeast corner of the site. d. Delete (five) 5 paralle spaces at the northeast corner of the site along Hrookhurst. e. A minimum of 8 handicapped parking spaces, minimum 14 foot in width. 3z. Page Three Conditional Exception 11o. 85-96 Administrative Review No. 85-55 f . Delete four (4 ) soutierly parking stalls adjacent to ' Pollv's Restaurant. g. North elevation of tte new retail space shall not have any doors unless required by the Fire Department; and shall include a 36' high block wall base. h. Indicate planter area:; i . Modify the slight jog in the main driveway aisle adjacent to the buildings to comply with Fire Department Standard No. 401 . 2. A parking management plan shall be submitted indicating employee parking around the perimeter of the site. 3. The building addition shall comply with Article 969.6 regarding floodplain standarls. 4. A planned sign program shall be submitted prior to the issuance of building permits and approved for all signing within the commercial center pursuant to S. 9760.43 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Cole. All new signs shall comply with the Planned Sign Program. 4 a. The major identification signs shall be removed or altered to comply with Articlf: 976 within two years. Rotating signs are prohibited . 5. The development shall comply with all applicable provisions of the Ordinance Code, Builclnc_ Division, and Fire Department except as noted in Conditional Exception Vo. 85-96. 6. Service roads and fire lanes, as determined by the Fire Department, shall be ,osted and marked. 7. The westerly driveway approach along Adams shall be designated right-hand turn only for exiting. 8. All driveway approaches less than 27' in width shall be a minimum of twenty-seven feet (271 ) in width and shall be of _ radius type construction. 9. The metal posts in the driveway along the north side of the new retail space shall be removed. 10. _ Proposed structures shall be architecturally compatible witt- existing structures. 11. All trash areas shall be fully enclosed with chain link fencing with redwood slats and a matching gate. I Page Four Conditional Exception No . 85-96 Administrative Review No. 85-55 12. Natural gas shall be snubbed in a: the locations of cooking facilities, water heaters, .and central heating units. ; 13. Low-volume heads shall be used on all spigots and water faucets. 14. All building spoils, such. as unusable lumber, wire, pipe, and other surplus or unusable mc-terial , shall be disposed of at an offsite facility equipped to handle them. 15. The subject property shall enter into irrevocable reciprocal driveway and par ng e-&-s€ffent(s) betveen-the-sub jest-sit-e-and --- corner parcel it corner parcel is ever owned separately. The Department of Development Services will perform a comprehensive plan check relating to all Ordinance Code requirements upon submittal of your completed structural drawings . Please be advised that the Board of Zoning Adjustments reviews the i conceptual plan as a basic request for entitlement of the use applied fir in r-lation to the vicinity in which it is proposed. The conceptual l..an should not be construed as a precise plan reflecting conformance to all Ordinance Code requirements. It is recommended that you immediately pursue completion of the Conditions of Approval and address all requirements of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code in crder to expedite the processing of youc total application. I hereby certify that Conditional Exception No. 85-96 and Administrative Review No. 85-55 were Conditionally Approved by* the Board of Zoning Adjustments of the City of Huntington Beach, California, on January 29, 1986, upon the foregoing conditions and citations. Very truly yours, Glen Godfrey, Secretary Board.of Zoning Adjustments GG:jr . (4096d) CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES BUILDING .'AVISION(714)S36-5241 PLANNING DIVISION (714) 536-5271 March 16, 1987 :dark Sork 1500 Adams Avenue Ste. '315 Costa Mesa, CA 92626 --Sum ee t:—P l a=;ed 5--_ _ Dear Mr. Sork: " The Planned Sign Program dated September 2-9 , 1986 submitted for the Mervyn' s Shopping Center has been reviewed and approved with some modifications by the Department of Development Services . Please reference Administrative Review No. 85-55 containing a condition requiring the eventual removal of the major iden-tification signs which you agreed to do. This requirement has been reiterated in the modified Planned Sign Program. The following standards shall govern all freestanding and wall signage within the shopping center . Any changes , alteration, or revision to PSP No . 86-5 shall be reviewed and approved by the Director of Development Services prior to the issuance of applicable permits or the erection or alteration of such signs within the development. FREESTANDING SIGN REQUIREMENTS: A. The following freestanding sign criteria shall be the approved specific requirements : 1. The -major identification signs -shall be removed or altered to comply with Article 961 by January 29 , 1988 -as required by Condition of Approval "No. 42 . .of Administrative Review No. 85-55. The following requirements shall pertain to the " new freestanding signs . a. Two center identification signs shall be allowed, one on each street frontage._ b. Maximum height shall be ' fifteen (15) feet . C. Maximum sign area shall be seventy (70) square feet . d. Copy shall be limited to center and major tenant identification. e. Signs shall comply in all other requirements for freestanding signs given in the Huntington Beach Sign Code. ATTACHMENT NO, gage Two .:lanned Sign Program No. 86-5 2. The existing secondary bus ness identification signs for Polly' s and Coast S&L may remiA n. 3 . The maximum number of freestanding signs on site shall be four (4) , including two (2) center identification - signs and two (2) secondary business identification signs . WALL SIGN GE REQUIREMENTS B. The following wall sign criteria shall be the approved specific requirements for. all new signs 7o= .changes -in any existing wall signs . 1. No sign shall be installed, erected, altered, or reconstructed without prior City approval and issuance of appropriate Building Division permits . a. Prior to submittal for plan check and issuance of permits, the sign plans must be approved by the owner or owner ' s representative. b. UL listed housings shall be required for all wall signage. 2. Each tenant shall be permitted one internally illuminated individual channel letter sign located on the building front . Tenants with a corner unit will be permitted two wall signs, which will not exceed the maximum sign area for business frontage per Section 9160 . 5 of the Huntington . Beach Ordinance Code. a. Copy shall be limited -to- the establishment ' s, name and/or product name. • b. Box-type or can signs small be . architecturally integrated with wall or facia board. C. Exposed neon co_nduit;- tubing* o.r raceway signs are prohibited: 3 . Each sign, including logo, shall be centered on the fascia vertically and horizontally and conform to the following: a. Maximum letter height for all establishments shall be 18 inches for •individual letters . b. Upper and lower case letters from top of the ascender to the bottom of descender shall not exceed 32 inches in overall height . 36 - 'Dage Three: yanned Sign Program No. 86-5 c. Letter he-Ight shall not be 1Qss than 12 inches high. d. Two lines of copy will be permitted on small store-fronts provided the combined letter height including space between words does not exceed 32 inches in height. e. Letter return or cepth shall be 5 inches . f-. Tom--cam ;qnA let'-er return color shall be dark brown. g. Sign length shall not exceed 70 percent of the leasehold width. _ h. Maximum sign area shall not exceed that permitted under Section' 9610 . 5 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. C. No tenant shall affix or maintain upon the exterior•:.walls of the premises or the buildings or in the parking lot and landscape areas any signs other than as permitted herein except with the City and landlord' s approvals . D. All signs fabricated and installed in this shopping center will harmonize with the design standards of the entire shopping center and all co-tenants . If you have any questions regarding this matter, please do not hesitate to contact Pam Posten at 536-5271. Sincerely, Jaynes W. Palin Director by: Glen• Godfrey . Deputy for Planning JWP:GG:PP: jr (7538d) .. ATTACHMENT NO. ALTERNATIVE FINDINGS AND CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL SPECIAL.SIGN PERMIT NO,93-13 (Applicant's Request) FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL-SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO 93-13: 1. Strict compliance with Article 961 will result in substantial economic hardship to the applicant because the existing 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding sign is necessary for identification of the businesses in the shopping center. The location of the building is approximately 200 feet from Adams Avenue,which does not provide adequate street exposure. 2. There are unusual site or building characteristics that preclude the various businesses from yielding adequate signage from the provisions of.the sign code. The location and orientation of the commercial building on the northern side of the property does not provide adequate business exposure on Adams Avenue. 3. Due to the fact that there are special site or building conditions applicable to the site, approval of the 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding sign is necessary to enjoy sign provisions enjoyed by other businesses in the immediate vicinity. 4. The existing 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding sign and 140 square foot sign face change will not adversely affect other signs in the area, nor will the sign obstruct pedestrian or vehicular traffic vision. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL- SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13: 1. The site plan and sign elevations received and dated October 6, 1993, shall be the conceptually approved layout with the following modifications: a. All rotating signs shall be permanently affixed. b. A landscape planter shall be provided at the base of the sign poles. Detailed plans shall be provided depicting compliance.with the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code parking stall requirements. 2. Building and electrical permits shall be obtained within 30 days from the date of this approval. 3. This special sign permit shall not become effective until and "Acceptance of Conditions" form has been signed and notarized by the applicant, and returned to the Planning Division; and until the ten (10)day appeal period has elapsed. 4. The Planning Commission reserves the right to rescind this special sign permit approval in the event of any violation of the applicable zoning laws. Any such decision shall be preceded by notice to the applicant and a public hearing, and shall be based on specific findings. (pcsr005) 3g i ATTACHMENT NO. tO ALTERNATIVE FINDINGS AND CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (Staff Alternative) FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL-SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO, 93-13: 1. Strict compliance with Article 961 will result in substantial economic hardship to the applicant because the proposed 15 foot high, 100 square foot freestanding sign is necessary for identification of the businesses in the shopping center. The location of the building is approximately 200 feet from Adams Avenue,which does not provide adequate street exposure. 2. There are unusual site or building characteristics that preclude the various businesses from yielding adequate signage from the provisions of the sign code. The location and orientation of the commercial building on the northern side of the property does not provide adequate business exposure on Adams Avenue. 3. Due to the fact that there are special site or building conditions applicable to the site, approval of the 15 foot high, 100 square foot freestanding sign is necessary to enjoy sign provisions enjoyed by other businesses in the immediate vicinity. 4. The proposed 15 foot high, 100 square foot freestanding sign will not adversely affect other signs in the area,nor will the sign obstruct pedestrian or vehicular traffic vision. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL-SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO, 93-13: 1. The site plan and sign elevations received and dated October 6, 1993, shall be the conceptually approved layout with the following modifications: a. Maximum height of the sign shall be 15 feet with 100 square feet of sign area including four(4), 25 square foot tenant panels. b. The sign shall be located in a landscape planter. Detailed plans shall be provided depicting compliance with the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code parking stall requirements. 2. Building and electrical permits shall be obtained within 30 days from the date of this approval. 3. This special sign permit shall not become effective until and "Acceptance of Conditions" form has been signed and notarized by the applicant,and returned to the Planning Division; and until the ten (10)day appeal period has elapsed. 4. The Planning Commission reserves the right to rescind this special sign permit approval in the event of any violation of the applicable zoning laws. Any such decision shall be preceded by notice to the applicant and a public hearing, and shall be based on specific findings. (pcsr005) G �� 1 RCA ROUTING SHEET INITIATING DEPARTMENT: COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SUBJECT: APPEAL OF SSP NO. 93-13 COUNCIL MEETING DATE: September 18, 1995 RCA ATTACHMENTS STATUS Ordinance (w/exhibits & legislative draft if applicable) Not Applicable Resolution (w/exhibits & legislative draft if applicable) Not Applicable Tract Map, Location Map and/or other Exhibits Not Applicable Contract/Agreement (w/exhibits if applicable) (Signed in full by the City Attorney) Not Applicable Subleases, Third Party Agreements, etc. (Appoved as to form by City Attorney) Not Applicable Certificates of Insurance (Approved by the City Attorney) Not Applicable Financial Impact Statement (Unbudget, over $5,000) Not Applicable Bonds (If applicable) Not Applicable Staff Report (If applicable) Attached Commission, Board or Committee Report (If applicable) Not Applicable Findings/Conditions for Approval and/or Denial Attached ;EXP;LANATION FO;R MISSING ATTACHMENTS,; REVIEWED RETURNED FOR ED Administrative Staff Assistant City Administrator Initial City Administrator Initial rCity Clerk EXPLANATION,:FOR RETURN OF ITEM. (Below . . . Only) TO CITY CLERK. STAFF: DO NOT MICROFILM OR FILE AWAY IN A BOX. THIS MATTER IS SCHEDULED FOR A PUBLIC HEARING 9/18/95 (CONTINUED OPEN FROM 4/3/95) Document2 04/04/95 9:43 AM TO CITY CLERK STAFF: DO NOT MICROFILM OR FILE AWAY IN A BOX. THIS MATTER IS SCHEDULED FOR A PUBLIC HEARING 9/18/95 (CONTINUED OPEN FROM 4/3/95) Document2 04/04/95 9:43 AM CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK CONNIE BROCKWAY CITY CLERK April 4, 1995 Superior Electrical Advertising, Inc 1700 W. Anaheim Street Long Beach, CA 90813 The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at its meeting held April 3, 1995 continued the public hearing on Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 to September 18, 1995. If you have any questions regarding this matter please call the Office of the City Clerk (714) 536-5227. Connie Brockway City Clerk Evelyn Schubert Deputy City Clerk cc: Wayne Carvalho (Telephone:714-536-5227) I RCA ROUTING S EE INITIATING DEPARTMENT: Community Development SUBJECT: Appeal of SSP 93-13 COUNCIL MEETING DATE: Aril 3, 1995 RGA ATTACHMENTS STATUS Ordinance (w/exhibits & legislative draft if applicable) Not Applicable Resolution (w/exhibits & legislative draft if applicable) Not Applicable Tract Map, Location Map and/or other Exhibits Attached Contract/Agreement (w/exhibits if applicable) (Signed in full by the City Attorney) Not Applicable Subleases, Third Party Agreements, etc. (Appoved as to form by City Attome Not Applicable Certificates of Insurance (Approved by the City Attorney) Not Applicable Financial Impact Statement (Unbudget, over $5,000) Not Applicable Bonds (If applicable) Not Applicable Staff Report (If applicable) Attached Commission, Board or Committee Report (If applicable) Attached Findings/Conditions for Approval and/or Denial Attached . ........ ........_ ......... . . .......... ..... ....... . ...._ ........ - ...... ........ ..... . .. ......... .................. ........ ......... . ........ ......._ ......... . ............ ........... .... ....... ......... . ........... .. ........ ......... ........ ......... EXPLANATION FOR MISSING ATTACHMENTS ...... ......... ................. _ ......... ..._..... ......... ;REVIEWED. RETURNED FOR; DED Administrative Staff Assistant City Administrator Initial City Administrator Initial City Clerk ........ .... .... ........ .. ... _ _ _ ............... ... ......... _ ........ ......_.. ........ . ......_.. ......._ ............... Only)(Below Space For City Clerk's Use Council/Agency Meeting Held: Deferred Continued to g4M12 ❑Approved ❑ Conditionally Approved ❑ Denied City Clerk's Signature _ Council Meeting Date: April 3, 1995 Department ID Number: CDr9.5-15 REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTION o - m J I" Nn.1Mgym-, 7 SUBMITTED TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL MEMB SUBMITTED BY: MICHAEL T. UBERUAGA, City Admini or PREPARED BY: MELANIE S. FALLON, Director of Community Developmen SUBJECT: APPEAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (Continued from the April 4, 1994 City Council meeting) Fstatement of Issue,Funding Source,Recommended Action,Alternative Action,Analysis,Environmental Status,Attachment;K V Statement of Issue: Transmitted for your consideration is an appeal by former Councilmember Earle Robitaille of Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 which was denied by the Planning Commission on February 1, 1994 (see Attachment No. 1). The public hearing was continued open from the April 4, 1994, City Council meeting in order to allow the Sign Code Committee to conclude their review of the existing sign ordinance. The Sign Code Committee has not completed their review therefore, no recommendation on the revisions has been presented to the Planning Commission or City Council. The committee is expected to conclude the review of the ordinance in approximately six (6) months. Funding Source: Not applicable. Recommended Action: Motion to: 'Continue the public hearing open on Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 to the City Council meeting of September 18, 1995." 94 R�QUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTT i MEETING DATE: April 3, 1995 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: CD 95-13 Alternative Action(s):- The Council may take one of the following alternative actions: 1. "Uphold the Planning Commission's action by denying Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 with findings as outlined in Attachment No. 5 of the Request For Council Action Staff Report dated April 4, 1994 (see Attachment No. 1);" or 2. "Overturn the Planning Commission's action and approve Special Sign Permit No. 93- 13 as requested by the applicant, with findings and conditions of approval as outlined in Attachment No. 9 of the Request For Council Action Staff Report dated April 4, 1994 (see Attachment No. 1)." Analysis: Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a request by Superior Electrical Advertising, Inc. to permit an existing non-conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding double pole sign to remain at the northwest corner of Brookhurst and Adams (Mervyn's Shopping Center), and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini & Lucas Jewelers in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot sign allowed by the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. The City Council continued the item for one (1) year to allow a Sign Code Subcommittee the opportunity to review and recommend any changes to the existing sign ordinance. The subcommittee recommendations are expected to be brought before Council within the next few months. Environmental Status: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15305, Class 5 of the California Environmental Quality Act. Attachment(s): City Clerk's Page Number ------------------- For Council Action Staff Report dated April 4 1994 1. Re uest CD95-13.DOC -2- 03/14/95 9:20 AM ATTACHMENT 1 • • REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION Date: April 4, 1994 Submitted to: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members Submitted by: Michael T. Uberuaga, City Administrator Prepared by: Melanie S. Fallon, Director of Community Development*J4t Subject: APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 Consistent with Council Policy? [XI Yes [ ] New Pblicy or Exception Statement of Issue,Recommendation,Analysis,Funding Source,Alternative Actions,Attachments: STATEMENT OF ISSUE: Transmitted for your consideration is Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille's appeal (see Attachment No. 4) of Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 which was denied by the Planning Commission on February 1, 1994. The Special Sign Permit request by Superior Electrical Advertising, Inc. is to permit an existing non-conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding double pole sign to remain at the northwest corner of Brookhurst and Adams (Mervyn's Shopping Center), and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini & Lucas Jewelers in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. Mayor Pro Tempore Robitaille appealed the Planning Commission's action due to his belief that the current sign ordinance discourages business rather than promote it and that as a result of our current economic condition,he feels the City should do everything in its power to prevent businesses from leaving the City. RECOMMENDATION: Planning Commission and Staff Recommendation: Motion to: "Sustain the Planning Commission's action and deny Special Sign Permit No. 93- 13 with findings" (see Attachment No. 5). PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION ON FEBRUARY 1. 1994: THE MOTION MADE BY BIDDLE,SECONDED BY COOK,TO DENY SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO.93-13 WITH FINDINGS(See Attachment No. 5)CARRIED BY THE FOLLOWING ROLL CALL VOTE: AYES: BIDDLE,COOK,DETTLOFF,GORMAN,RICHARDSON NOES: INGLEE,NEWMAN ABSTAIN: NONE ABSENT: NONE MOTION PASSED ANALYSIS: Background In October 1993, Cudini & Lucas Jewelers requested a special sign permit to approve a sign face change that was installed without building permits to a 140 square foot sign cabinet located on a 45 foot high, 624 square foot non-conforming double pole sign(see Attachment No. 2). The special sign permit application was submitted following the issuance of a Notice of Violation and Request-for Prosecution to the Cudini & Lucas business owner by the City's Code Enforcement section for installing the sign panels without appropriate City approval. Upon review of the application and research on the sign, it was discovered that an administrative review approval in 1985, and a planned sign program approval in 1986 required the subject freestanding sign be removed or altered to comply with the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code by January 29, 1988. The property owner and applicant were notified that the freestanding sign was non-conforming and would have to be modified to conform with code unless the Planning Commission granted permission for it to remain. The applicant subsequently expanded his special sign permit request to allow the entire sign to remain. If approved,the 45 foot high, 624 square foot sign would be permitted in perpetuity. Projectect Desription The 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding sign is located within the asphalt parking lot, approximately 55 feet from the Adams Avenue right of way, and is visible by motorists traveling east and west on Adams Avenue. The entire sign consists of. 1. A 224 square foot double face sign copy identifying Mervyn's; 2. A 260 square foot single face sign copy identifying Thrifty,with an L.A.Tronics sign copy on the opposite side(rotating sign); and 3. A 140 square foot square foot double face sign cabinet for Cudini & Lucas Jewelers (see Attachment No. 2) The Huntington Beach Ordinance Code permits one(1) center identification freestanding sign per street frontage, with a maximum height of 15 feet, and 70 square feet in area. The sign is required to be located within a landscape planter and is permitted to identify the center and/or major tenant only. The following is a zoning conformance matrix that compares the applicant's request with Section 9610.5 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code: Section ssue Permitted Proposed 9610.5 Permitted Signs: Adams Ave. (831' frontage) Max.No: Freestanding 1 1 Monument 2 1 RCA- 4/4/94 2 ssp93-13 SectionIssue Permitted Proposed 9610.5 (Con't) Max. Area: Freestanding 70 sf 624 sf total* (includes 150 sf jewelers sign)* Monument 30 sf 60 sf Max. Height: Freestanding 15 ft. 45 ft.* Monument 7 ft. 9 ft. Sign Copy: Limited to center 3 major tenants* Freestanding ID and/or major Mervyn's, tenant Thrifty/L.A.Tronics 1 additional tenant: Jewelers* Monument Business ID only Polly's Distance between monument signs 200 ft. N/A Sign location Must be in Located in paved landscaped planter parking lot* *Special Sign Permit Request Administrative Review No. 85-55, approved on January 29, 1986 for a new 1,700 square foot restaurant expansion within the Mervyn's Center, required the property owner to remove or modify the existing 45 foot high sign within a two (2)year period. A condition of approval required that a planned sign program be submitted prior to issuance of building permits for the addition. It also specified that the major identification sign comply with the Huntington Beach Sign Code by January 29, 1988, and that rotating signs were prohibited, referring to the rotating Thrifty sign(see Attachment No. 7). Planned Sign Program No. 86-5, approved in March of 1987, established criteria for all new freestanding and wall signs in the shopping center. It addressed design elements including size, color and sign type to create a coordinated sign theme throughout the center. The sign program also specified the maximum signage allowed for freestanding signs with a 15 foot height limit, a 70 square foot limit on sign area, and a restriction on the sign copy to the center and major tenant only. A condition on the planned sign program requiring the removal or alteration of the non- conforming 45 foot high sign by January 29, 1988 was reiterated in the Notice of Action letter to the property owner(see Attachment No. 8). RCA - 4/4/94 3 ssp93-13 f • • Planning Commission Meeting At the February 1, 1994 Planning Commission meeting, Mr. Stan Janocha, applicant, Mr. Leo Margarit, store owner of Cudini & Lucas Jewelers, and Richard Harlow spoke in favor of the request. They gave a brief history of the sign, and explained how the Cudini & Lucas business was located in a building not easily visible from the street. Mr. Harlow also suggested that the Commission continue the item until the City Council Sign Committee completed the sign code rewrite. 'There was no one who spoke in opposition to the request. At the meeting, staff also provided a sign alternative for the purpose of Planning Commission discussion. The alternative consisted of a 15 foot high, 100 square foot double pole sign with four(4) tenant panels (see Attachment No.3)providing street exposure for all four(4)tenants, including Cudini & Lucas. As discussed in the Planning Commission staff report dated February 1, 1994, staff believes that a 15 foot high sign would be compatible with other signs on surrounding commercial properties. The sign would comply with all other sign code provisions including the minimum site angle requirement for signs located in a landscape planter. Reasons for Appeal Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille states in his appeal letter(see Attachment No. 4)that the Planning Commission's action would cause.an extreme problem for all businesses in the Mervyn's Center who rely on the sign. He explains that neither the Planning Division nor City Council have pursued the revision of the sign ordinance,which the Council as a whole has been demanding. Finally,he states that the Chamber of Commerce has been excluded from providing day-to-day input in this matter. Summer Staff recommends that the request to retain the 45 foot high pylon sign and permit the Cudini & Lucas sign face change be denied due to its excessive size, and its incompatibility with surrounding signs that have been modified to conform with the current code. The 624 square foot freestanding sign is approximately 900 percent over what is currently permitted under the Huntington Beach Sign Code, and is not proportionate with the shopping center. Furthermore, the property owner has had ample time to comply with the previous conditions imposed over eight(8) years ago. The two (2) year amortization period that the property owner received in 1986, actually resulted in the use of the sign for six(6) additional years. The sign currently provides identification for four-(4) different businesses with between 140 and 260 square feet of sign copy for each business. This exceeds the amount of signage permitted on other commercial properties. By denying this special sign permit,the property owner will be required to comply with Code and the previous conditions imposed under Administrative Review No. 85-55 and Planned Sign Program No. 86-5, which will be consistent with other recently installed signs in the vicinity. Staff has provided an alternative action that consists of a 15 foot high, 100 square foot pole sign with up to four(4)tenant panels. This would allow the four tenant who currently have panels on the 45 foot high sign to continue receiving street exposure. A 15 foot high sign would be RCA-4/4/94 4 ssp93-I3 compatible with other signs on surrounding commercial properties, including the recently approved Rally's sign (12 foot high). A new freestanding sign would be required to be placed in a landscape planter while complying with the minimum site angle visibility requirements. Environmental Status This project is categorically exempt pursuant to Class 15, Section 15315 of the California Environmental Quality Act. FUNDING SOURCE: Not applicable ALTERNATIVE ACTION: The City Council may make one of the following motions: A. "Approve Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 as requested by the applicant with findings and conditions of approval:" or B. "Approve Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 (staff alternative) as modified by staff with findings and conditions of approval." ATTACHMENTS: 1. Area Map 2 Site plan and sign elevation dated October 6, 1993 3. Sign elevation(staff alternative)• 4. :Appeal memo from Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille dated February 2, 1994 5. .Minutes of the February 1, 1994 Planning Commission meeting (Findings for Denial) 6. Planning Commission Staff Report dated February 1, 1994 7. Administrative Review No. 85-55 8. Planned Sign Program No. 86-5 9. Draft findings and conditions of approval (Applicant's request) 10. Draft findings and conditions of approval (Staff alternative) MTU:MSF:WC:lp RCA- 4/4/94 5 ssp93-13 6 16 BOLSA 8 $' MC FAIRN CENTER \1 16 EDINGOL 4-1 \ HELL WARNER ♦ \ SLATER s ��+ • • ' TALBERT ♦ ELLIS ♦ - - - - - - -GARIn= MERVYN'S YORKTOWN UA �� • ADAMS y /]NDIAN"OLIS Y DRUG ' ATLANTA �T N AAMR.TON ::AM I SI N BANNING R I I / ATTACHMENT NO. m SSP 93- 13 1 R� HUNTINGTON BEACH PLANNING DIVISION JIIiI1:;n11::L^inlln:nlll :ilf.;lnl.^,un�fa�: -ir-- - - - -- --- -- 51 - t EXIS TWO POLE SIGN-- C : (FACE CHANGE) F iE ' 'S ��.e e{e d .IL':•Wlll'tdllll J_..�l:,11USw'"dL;1 i ADAMS STREET SITE PLA WSIGN LOCATION NOT TO SCALE � :G �-G��C E1�IS'lfid, GyFG{.I.L, S�JL'jY� I M �- DRUG AND DISCOUNT STORES m l+ M CUDINI&LUCAS JEWELERS %Z tl MANUF:CTURING JEWELERS DIAMOND BROKERS APPR.:ISALS r7L R D/F FACE CHANGE r.NEWFACES ARE ACRYLIC PLASTIC WAN V1Nri OVERLA _ SCALE: COPY&DESIGN. i COLORS: 7328 (USE COMNG CABINETI ALL COPY OA K WHITE BLUE - 3.NOTE:ALL EXISTING CABINET MEASUREMENTS TO BE - VERIFIED ON S(rE PRIOR TO PANEL FABRICATION 6 INS7 superior — ?eject GJiIWi �J� C _�,+'--- _.— ADeress%�GF�S 5r tGCaG-J� y. n�III.I i y electrical advertising) --- _ h-` aw..-a.im FAX _ .. :..c.Myr. Des;gner J k1f,"P*f - w.....'.uw.rsrr.s Sc8'e 1417 r/> --Da:e -'J,. ATTACHMENT NO. Z 6TAror . RLT&RNA71146 ID �D ` l. . a . F N�cs CUC> INI t Luu4 5 ae WE (,&RS 9891 b ATTACHMENT NO., '� J� CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL COMMUNICATION HUNTINGTON BEACH oD = TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members FROM: Earle Robitaille, Mayor Pro Tempore y DATE; February 2, 1994 SUBJECT: SIGN PERMIT APPEAL I would like to appeal special sign permit number 93-13 because of the following reasons: 1. The action taken by the Planning Commission will cause an extreme problem for all the businesses in the Mervyn's Center who rely on this sign. 2. Neither the Planning Department nor the City Council, have seen fit to get on with the revision of this ordinance. The Council as a whole has been demanding. 3. The Huntington Beach Chamber of Commerce, whose members have the most to loose or gain,have once again been excluded from providing day-to-day input in this matter. 4. The undue cost to businesses in Huntington Beach is driving out businesses in local circles, our sign ordinance is known as part of our "business prevention plan." ER:paj xc: City Clerk Melanie Fallon, Director of Community Development H'� DRAFTj B-2 SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO, 93-13 (CONTINUED FROM THE DECEMBER 21, 1993 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING): APPLICANT: Superior Electrical Advertising, Inc. LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue (northwest-comer at Brookhurst) Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a revised request to permit an existing 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding double pole sign to remain at the northwest corner of Brookhurst. and Adams (Mervyn's Shopping Center). In addition,the applicant requests to install a new sign face identifying Cudini & Lucas Jewelers, into an existing five (5) foot by 28 foot sign cabinet which is located directly under the Mervyn's and Thrifty/L.A.Tronics sign copies. The Cudini &Lucas Jewelers sign was installed without permits, which resulted in a violation notice issued by the City's Code Enforcement section in May of 1993. Following a request for prosecution to the City Attorney's Office, the applicant submitted this special sign permit application requesting to keep the entire sign. The approval of Administrative Review No. 85-55 on January 29, 1986, to permit a 1,700 square foot restaurant addition within the Mervyn's Center, required the property owner to remove or alter the existing sign to comply with the City's sign code within two (2) years. The two (2)year sign amortization period ended January 29, 1988, and the sign is still erected. The sign is approximately 900 percent over what is currently allowed by code and is not proportionate in size with the center. Furthermore, the property owner has had ample time to comply with the previous conditions imposed over eight(8)years ago. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Due to the size of the sign and the previous requirement to comply with the City's sign code by January of 1988, staff recommends the Planning Commission deny the request to allow the freestanding sign and the sign face change with findings. THE PUBLIC HEARING WAS OPENED. Stan Janocha, 20781 Hunter Lane, applicant, submitted a letter to the Commission. Mr. Janocha gave a brief history of the sign, and urged the Commission to approve the request. ATTAMMLTMO,,�,. g PC Minutes - 6/15/93 4 (KL001) DRAFT Leo L. Margarit, Cudini & Lucas Jewelers, 9891 Adams Avenue, store owner, stated that his business is not easily visible from the street. He asked the Commission to approve their request. Richard Harlow, 211 Main Street, representing applicant,asked the Commission to approve the request, and if they did not to continue the request until the City Council Sign Committee finishes their sign code rewrite. THERE WERE NO OTHER PERSONS PRESENT TO SPEAK FOR OR AGAINST THE REQUEST AND THE PUBLIC HEARING WAS CLOSED. A MOTION WAS MADE BY BIDDLE, SECOND BY COOK TO DENY SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 WITH FINDINGS FOR DENIAL, BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: Cook,Gorman, Dettloff,Richardson, Biddle NOES: Inglee,Newman ABSENT: None ABSTAIN: None MOTION PASSED FINDINGS FOR DENIAL- SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO, 93-13: 1. Strict compliance with Article 961 will not result in a substantial economic hardship to the applicant because the shopping center is permitted a 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign, two (2) 30 square foot monument signs, and each business is allowed wall signage that provides adequate signage for the center. 2. There are no unusual site or building characteristics that preclude Cudini & Lucas Jewelers from yielding adequate signage from the provisions of the sign code. Secondary businesses in the shopping center are permitted wall signs, and can provide exposure by directing customers to the "Mervyn's Center" as intended by the Huntington Beach Sign Code. In addition, a sign panel on a monument sign would be permitted. PC Minutes - 6/15/93 5 (KL001) DRAFT. 3. Due to the fact that there are no unusual site or building characteristics applicant to the site, approval of the 45 foot high, 624 square foot pole sign, and 140 square foot sign face change would be a grant of special privilege not enjoyed by surrounding properties. The existing 45 foot high freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with the City's sign code by January 29, 1988. The sign, in its present state, constitutes excessive signage, and is an aesthetic impact to the commercial center and to surrounding properties. B-3 COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT NO. 93-28/CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 94-2 (CONTINUED FROM THE JANUARY 19. 1994 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING): APPLICANT: Orange County Environmental Management Agency (Harbors, Beaches and Parks Division) LOCATION: 5801 Seapoint Avenue (west side of Seapoint Avenue between Palm and Garfield). Coastal Development Permit No. 93-28 was continued at the January 19, 1994 meeting to allow for advertising of a Conditional Use Permit in conjunction with the Coastal Development Permit application. Coastal Development Permit No. 93-28 and Conditional Use Permit No. 94-3 are a request by the County of Orange to review and approve the general design plans for Phase 1A of the Bolsa Chica Regional Park. Phase 1 A consists of development of a forty (40) space parking lot,two park entry points with signage, a vista overlook with interpretive signage,bicycle/pedestrian trails, two picnic areas, security lighting,perimeter fencing and signage, installation of ornamental and native plant materials and irrigation. Phase 1 A also includes creation of a 2 acre wetland enhancement area located beyond the City' s boundary within the County's jurisdiction. Because this area is outside the City's jurisdiction,the County will be applying directly to the California Coastal Commission to obtain a Coastal Development Permit for this area. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission approve the request because it is consistent with the General Development Plan and Environmental Impact Report that were conceptually approved by the Huntington Beach City Council in October of 1992 and conforms with the plans,policies,requirements and standards of the City's Local Coastal Program PC Minutes- 6/15/93 6 (KL001) Huntington Beach Department of Community Development STAFF REFORT EXECUTIVE SUMMARY SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (9891 Adams Avenue) Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a revised request to permit an existing 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding double pole sign to remain at the northwest corner of Brookhurst and Adams (Mervyn's Shopping Center). In addition, the applicant requests to install a new sign face identifying Cudini & Lucas Jewelers, into an existing five (5) foot by 28 foot sign cabinet which is located directly under the Mervyn's and Thrifty/L.A.Tronics sign copies. The Cudini & Lucas Jewelers sign was installed without permits, which resulted in a violation notice issued by the City's Code Enforcement section in May of 1993. Following a request for prosecution to the City Attorney's Office, the applicant submitted this special sign permit application requesting to keep the entire sign. The approval of Administrative Review No. 85-55 on January 29, 1986, to permit a 1,700 square foot restaurant addition within the Mervyn's Center, required the property owner to remove or alter the existing sign to comply with the City's sign code within two (2) years. The two (2) year sign amortization period ended January 29, 1988, and the sign is still erected. The sign is approximately 900 percent over what is currently allowed by code and is not proportionate in size with the center. Furthermore,the property owner has had ample time to comply with the previous conditions imposed over eight(8) years ago. Due to the size of the sign and the previous requirement to comply with the City's sign code by January of 1988, staff recommends the Planning commission deny the.request to allow the freestanding sign and the sign face change with findings. B -2 ATTACHMENT Na. - TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: February 1, 1994 SUBJECT: SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (CONTINUED FROM THE DECEMBER 21, 1993 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING) APPLICANT: Superior Electric Advertising, Inc. 1700 W. Anaheim Street, Long Beach, CA 90813 PROPERTY OWNER: Mark Sork, 1500 Adams Avenue, Suite 315, Costa Mesa, CA 92626 REVISED REQUEST: To permit an existing, non conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot double pole pylon sign to remain in its present location and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini and Lucas Jewelers, in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue (northwest corner at Brookhurst) DATE ACCEPTED: December 9, 1993 NE: C2-FP2 (Community Business District-Floodplain) GENERAL PLAN: General Commercial EXISTING USE: Retail Shopping Center . 1.0 SUGGESTED ACTION: Motion to: "Deny Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 with findings for denial." 2.0 GENERAL INFORMATION: Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a request to permit a 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding pylon sign(identifying four tenants: Mervyn's, Thrifty, L.A. Tronics, and Cudini & Lucas Jewelers)to remain at the Mervyn's Shopping Center. The applicant also requests to legalize a sign face change to a 5' by 30' cabinet identifying the Cudini & Lucas Jewelers business which was installed without building permits. Section 9610.5 (b) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code specifies that commercial sites Staff Report-2/1/94 -1- (pcsr005) with over 400 feet of frontage be restricted to one (1) center identification sign per street frontage,a maximum 15 feet in height and 70 square feet in area. The signs are permitted to identify the center and/or major tenant and must be in a landscaped planter. In addition, the freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with Code by January 29, 1988, as a condition of a previously approved Administrative Review(Administrative Review No. 85-55). 3.0 SURROUNDING LAND USE, ZONING AND GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATIONS: North and West of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Medium Density Residential ZONE: R3-FP2 (Medium-High Density Residential- Floodplain) LAND USE: Condominium Complex East and South of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: General Commercial ZONE: C2-FP2 (Community Business-Floodplain) LAND USE: Retail Commercial Uses 4.0 ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: The proposed project is categorically exempt pursuant to Class 15315, Section 15 of the California Environmental Quality Act. 5.0 COASTAL STATUS: Not applicable. 6.0 REDEVELOPMENT STATUS: Not applicable. 7.9 SPECIFIC PLAN: Not applicable. 8.0 SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE: Not applicable. 9.0 ISSUES AND ANALYSIS: Background In October 1993, Cudini & Lucas Jewelers requested a special sign permit to approve a sign face change that was installed without building permits to a 140 square foot sign cabinet located on a 45 foot high, 624 square foot non conforming double pole sign(see Attachment No. 2). The special sign permit application was submitted as a result of a Notice of Violation and Request for Prosecution that was issued to the Cudini &Lucas business owner by the City's Code Enforcement section for installing the sign panels without appropriate City approval. Staff Report-2/1/94 -2- (pcsr005) Upon review of the application and research on the sign, it was discovered that as a result of an 'Administrative Review approval in 1985, and a planned sign program approval in 1986, the subject freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code by January 29, 1988 (see Attachment No. 3). The property owner and applicant were notified that the freestanding sign was non-conforming and that it would have to be modified to conform with code unless the Planning Commission granted permission for it to remain. The applicant subsequently expanded his special sign permit request to allow the entire sign to remain. If approved, the 45 foot high, 624 square foot sign would be permitted in perpetuity. Project Description The 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding sign is located within the asphalt parking lot, approximately 55 feet from the Adams Avenue right of way and visible from motorist traveling east and west on Adams Avenue. The entire sign consists of: 1. A 224 square foot double face sign copy identifying Mervyn's; 2. A 260 square foot single face sign copy identifying Thrifty,with an L.A. Tronics sign copy on the opposite side; and 3. A 140 square foot double face sign cabinet for Cudini & Lucas Jewelers (see Attachment No. 2). The Huntington Beach Ordinance Code permits one (1) center identification freestanding sign per street frontage, with a maximum height of 15 feet, and 70 square feet in area. The sign is required to be located within a landscape planter and is restricted to identify the center and/or major tenant. The following is a zoning conformance matrix that compares the applicants request with Section 9610.5 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code: Section Issue Required Proposed 9610.5 Permitted signs: Adams Ave. (83 F frontage) Max. No: Freestanding 1 1 Monument 2 1 Max. Area: Freestanding 70 sf 624 sf total* (includes 150 sf jewelers sign)* Monument 30 sf 60 sf Max. Height: Freestanding 15 ft. 45 ft.* Monument 7 ft. 9 ft. *Special Sign Permit Request Staff Report-2/1/94 -3- (pcsr005) Section Issue Required Proposed 9610.5 (Con't) Sign Copy: Limited to center 2 major tenants Freestanding ID and/or major Mervyn's/Thrifty tenant 1 other tenant: Jewelers* Monument Business ID only Polly's Distance between monument signs 200 ft. N/A Sign location Must be in Located in paved landscaped planter parking lot* *Special Sign Permit Request The Administrative Review approved on January 29, 1986, for a new 1,700 square foot restaurant expansion within the Mervyn's Center required the property owner to remove or modify the existing 45 foot high sign within a two (2) year period. In addition, a condition of approval required that a Planned Sign Program be submitted prior to issuance of building permits for the addition. It also specified that the major identification sign comply with the Huntington Beach Sign Code by January 29, 1988, and that rotating signs were prohibited (see Attachment No. 5). Planned Sign Program No. 86-5 was approved in March of 1987, establishing criteria for all new freestanding and wall signs in the center. It addressed design elements including size, color and sign type to create a coordinated sign theme throughout the center. The sign program also specified the maximum signage allowed for the freestanding sign with a 15 foot height limit, a 70 square foot limit on sign area, and a restriction on the sign copy to the center and major tenant only. A condition requiring the removal or alteration of the non conforming 45 foot high sign by January 1988, was reiterated in the Notice of Action letter to the property owner(see Attachment No. 6). Staff recommends that the request to retain the 45 foot high pylon sign and permit the Cudini and Lucas sign face change be denied due to its excessive size, and its incompatibility with surrounding signs that have been modified to conform with the current code. The 624 square foot freestanding sign is approximately 900 percent over what is currently permitted under the Huntington Beach Sign Code, and is not proportionate with the shopping center. Furthermore, the property owner has had ample time to comply with the previous conditions imposed over eight(8) years ago. The two (2) year amortization period that the property owner received in 1986, actually resulted in the use of the sign for six(6) additional years. The sign currently Staff Report-2/1/94 -4- (pcsr005) provides identification for four(4)different businesses with between 140 and 260 square feet of sign copy for each business. This exceeds the amount of signage permitted on other commercial properties. By denying this special sign permit, the property owner will be required to comply with Code and the conditions of approval of the Administrative Review and Planned Sign Program which will be consistent with other recently installed signs in the vicinity. Staff has provided an alternative for discussion which includes a 15 foot high, 100 square foot double pole sign with four(4)tenant panels. The alternative will provide exposure for all four (4) tenants while remaining compatible with other signs in the immediate vicinity. 10.0 RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission deny Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 with the following findings for denial: FINDINGS FOR DENIAL - SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 : 1. Strict compliance with Article 961 will not result in a substantial economic hardship to the applicant because the shopping center is permitted a 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign, and each business is allowed adequate wall signage. 2. There are no unusual site or building characteristics that preclude Cudini & Lucas Jewelers from yielding adequate signage from the provisions of the sign code. Secondary businesses in the shopping center are permitted wall signs, and can provide exposure by directing customers to the "Mervyn's Center" as intended by the Huntington Beach Sign Code. 3. Due to the fact that there are no unusual site or building characteristics applicant to the site, approval of the 45 foot high, 624 square foot pole sign, and 140 square foot sign face change would be a grant of special privilege not enjoyed by surrounding properties. The existing 45 foot high freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with the City's sign code by January 29, 1988. The sign, in its present state, constitutes excessive signage, and is an aesthetic impact to the commercial center and to surrounding properties. 11.0 ALTERNATIVE ACTION: The Planning Commission may: A. Approve Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 for a 15 foot high, 100 square foot, multi tenant sign (see Attachment No. 8)with draft findings and conditions of approval; or B. Approve Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 for a maximum two (2)year period with draft findings and suggested conditions of approval (applicant's request). Staff Report-2/1/94 -5- (pcsr005) ATTACHMENTS: 1. Planning Commission Staff Report dated December 21, 1993 2. Applicant's revised narrative 3. Site plans and sign elevations dated October 6, 1993 4. Sign Elevations (Staff Alternative) 5. Administrative Review No. 85-55 6. Planned Sign Program No. 86-5 7. Alternative Findings and Conditions of Approval (Applicant's Request) 8. Alternative Findings and Conditions of Approval (Staff Alternative) SH:WC:kjl ILL,/ Staff Report-2/1/94 -6- (pcsr005) huntington beach department of community development STAff - REPORT EXECUTIVE SUMMARY DECEMBER 21, 1993 SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (9891 Adams Avenue) Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a request to permit a sign face change to a five (5) foot by 30 foot cabinet on an existing 45 foot high pylon Sign located at the northwest corner of Brookhurst and Adams (Mervyn' s Shopping Center) . The subject sign, identifying Cudini & Lucas Jewelers, was installed without permits, which resulted in the issuance of violation notice by the City' s Code Enforcement section in May of this year. Following a request for prosecution to the City Attorney' s Office, the applicant submitted this special sign permit application. The 150 square foot sign cabinet is part of a 45 foot high, 634 square foot non conforming freestanding sign, which identifies Mervyn' s, Thrifty, and Cudini & Lucas Jewelers . As a condition of approval for Administrative Review No. 85-55, and a requirement for Planned Sign Program No. 86-5, the freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with the City' s sign code by January 29, 1988 . Since the status of the overall sign is that it must be removed, it is inappropriate to consider a sign panel which is part of the overall sign. The entire sign must be evaluated before a panel can be considered. The City is actively pursuing compliance with the conditions of the aforementioned entitlements, as the applicant has not complied to date. A-PL-N-23D TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: December 21, 1993 SUBJECT: SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 APPLICANT: Superior Electrical Advertising, Inc. , 1700 W. Anaheim Street, Long Beach, CA 90813 PROPERTY OWNER: Mark Sork, 1500 Adams Avenue, Suite 315, Costa Mesa, CA 92626 REOUEST: To allow an existing sign face change (Cudini & Lucas Jewelers) to a 150 square foot (5 feet x 30 feet) cabinet sign, on an existing 45 foot high, three (3) panel, double pole pylon sign, pursuant to Section 9610 .7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue (northwest corner at Brookhurst) DATE ACCEPTED: December 9, 1993 ZONE: C2-FP2 (Community Business-Floodplain) GENERAL PLAN: General Commercial EXISTING USE: Retail Shopping Center 1 . 0 SUGGESTED ACTION: Motion to: "Deny Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 with findings . " 2 . 0 GENERAL INFORMATION: Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a request to aloow an existing sign face change to a five (5) foot by 30 foot cabinet on an existing non-conforming 45 foot high 634 square foot pylon sign which identifies three (3) tenants (Mervyn' a, Thrifty & Cudini & Lucas Jewelers) . The Cudini &Lucas Jewelers sign panel was installed without building permits. The entire pylon sign is non-conforming due to its size and that it was required to be brought into conformance with the code in 1988 pursuant to an Administrative Review and Planned Sign Program requirement. Section 9610 . 5(b) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code specifies that commercial sites with over 400 .feet of frontage be restricted to one (1) center identification sign per street frontage, a maximum 15 feet in height and 70 square feet in area. The signs are permitted to identify the center and/or major tenant. 3 . 0 SURROUNDING LAND USE, ZONING AND GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATIONS: North and. West of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Medium Density Residential ZONE: R3-FP2 (Medium-High Density Residential - Floodplain) LAND USE: Condominium Complex East and South of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: General Commercial ZONE: C2-FP2 (Community Business-Floodplain) LAND USE: Retail Commercial Uses 4 . 0 ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: The proposed project is categorically exempt pursuant to Class 15315, Section 15 of the California Environmental Quality Act . 5 . 0 COASTAL STATUS: Not applicable. 6 . 0 REDEVELOPMENT STATUS: Not applicable. 7. 0 SPECIFIC PLAN: Not applicable. 8'. 0 SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE: Not applicable. 9 . 0 ISSUES AND ANALYSIS: Cudini & Lucas Jewelers had a 150 square foot (five (5) foot by 30 foot) sign face change ,without building permits and zoning approval on an existing 45 foot high, 634 square foot non conforming freestanding sign. The business owner was issued a Notice of Violation by the City' s Code Enforcement section for installing the sign panel without appropriate City approval. Following a request for prosecution to the City Attorney' s Office, the business owner submitted a special sign permit application to allow the sign panel to remain. The sign, identifying Cudini & Lucas Jewelers, is in a cabinet located under the existing Mervyn' s and Thrifty sign copies (see Attachment No. 2) . The pylon sign, situated off Adams Avenue, identifies Mervyn' s (224 square feet) , Thrifty (260 square feet) , and Cudini & Lucas Jewelers (150 square feet) for a total of 634 square feet. The Huntington Beach Ordinance Code permits one (1) center identification freestanding sign per street frontage, with a maximum height of 15 feet, and 70 square feet in area. The sign is restricted to identify the center and/or major tenant . i .Staff Report - 12/21/93 -2- (7474d) The following is a zoning conformance matrix: Section Issue Required Proposed 9610 ..5(b) Permitted signs : Adams Avenue (831' frontage) Max. Number: Freestanding 1 1 Monument 2 1 Max. Area: Freestanding 70 sq. ft. . 634 sq. ft. total** (includes 150 sq. ft . jewelers sign) * Monument 30 sq. ft. 60 sq. ft. Max. Height: Freestanding 15 ft. 45 ft. * Monument 7 ft. 9 ft. Sign Copy: Freestanding Limited to center 2 major tenants ID and/or major Mervyn' s/Thrifty tenant 1 other tenant: Jewelers* Monument Business ID Polly' s only Distance between Monument signs 200 ft. n/a Sign location Must be in land- Located in paved scaped planter parking lot* *Special Sign Permit Request **Non Conforming Sign As a result of an Administrative Review approval in 1985, and a planned sign program approval in 1986, the subject freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code by January 29, 1988 (see Attachment No. 3) . To date, the property owner has not complied with the conditions of approval . Code Enforcement staff is actively pursuing compliance of all previous conditions . Staff recommends that the request for the Cudini and Lucas sign face change be denied because a partial modification to a nonconforming sign is prohibited. Furthermore, since the sign was previously required to be removed by January of 1988, the property owner is required to comply with the previous conditions and remove the non conforming sign. Staff Report - 12/21/93 -3- (7474d) � . 0 RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission deny Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 with the following findings : FINDINGS FOR DENIAL - SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO, 93-13 : 1. Strict compliance with Article 961 will not result in a substantial economic hardship to the applicant because the business is permitted adequate wall signage by the code. Furthermore, the center is permitted a 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign to identify the center and/or major tenant. 2 . There are no unusual site or building characteristics that preclude Cudini & Lucas Jewelers from yielding adequate signage from the provisions of the sign code. Secondary businesses in the center are permitted wall signs, and can provide exposure by directing customers to the "Mervyn' s Center" as intended by the Huntington Beach Sign Code. 3 . Due to the fact that there are no unusual site or .building characteristics applicable to the site, approval of a sign face change to a non-conforming freestanding sign would be a grant of special privilege not enjoyed by surrounding properties . The existing 45 foot high freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with the City' s sign code on January 29 , 1988 . The sign, in its present state, constitutes excessive signage, and is an aesthetic impact to the commercial center and to surrounding properties . 11. 0 ALTERNATIVE ACTION: The Planning Commission may continue Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 until such time the applicant and/or property owner consents to include the entire sign into the special sign permit request. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Narrative 2 .— i ta-pLans.-and s-igp-elevalieAs da4ed-Geteber 6,1"3 , "t4ve Re; 4 -No. 9 5--5- SH:WC:kjl Staff Report - 12/21/93 -4- (7474d) 12115/1993 11:58 31043518� SUPERIOR ELEC WRT PAGE 01 &II December 5, 1993 MR. WAYNE CARVALHO . . City of H ntington Beach 2000 Main Street SIGNAGE Huntingtom Beach, CA 92648 Dear Mr. arvalho: CORPORATEIDENTITY Superior lectrical Advertising, Inc. and Cudini & PROGRAMMED Lucas Jew 1 ers respectfully request from the City of. MAINTENANCE Huntingto Beach, approval on a variance to allow the identific tion lettering added to an existing sign to remain as is. The reaso for our request, is as follows : Approxima ely four months ago, Mr. Leo Margarit of Cudini & ucas Jewelers contracted to have vinyl letters aided to the bottom panels of an existing pylon sign. At he time this was done. Mr. Margarit did not realize hi needed a permit. Since finding out about the necessity of a permit, he has contracted with Superior to handle the variance. We feel t e variance is justified for the following SERVING THE reason t GLOBE FROM LONG BEACH, CA This is ai existing sign that is set back approximately HOUSTON, TX 75' from he property line. There are three modules on SEATTLE, WA a double ole structure. Mervyns owns the rights to the top modul Thrifty and L. A. Tronics have the middle module an Cudini & Lucas Jewelers attached letters to the exist ng blank bottom mad.ule. _ Because a 1 four tenants. who are .on this sign have extremely poor visibility of their -storefronts from both Adam and Brookhurst, they depend on this pylon for- their- success. I spoke w th the property owner today and .he is willing - to includE the entire sign in this variance. if the commissio7 agrees, we would like to- continue this item until we - an revise our submittal to include the entire 310.495.3808 sign. 800.995.9099 310.435.1867.FAX 1700 West Anaheim Street Long Beach CA 90813-1195 12/15/1993 11:58 31043518io SUPERIOR ELEC ADVERT PAGE 02 . I MR. WAYNE ARVALHO City of Hu tington Beach December 1 , 1993 Page 2 of Please cal me and let me know how you would like us to . . proceed on this matter. SiVJANOCAA 5J/he FAX 714-3 - 1540 cc : Leo M rgarit Mark Sork L L 1�— 3771, x d -.L December 16, 1993 DEC 1 7 1993 SIGNAGE MR. WAYNE CARVALHO CORPORATE City of Huntington Beach '' IDENTITY 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 PROGRAMMED MAINTENANCE Re : Variance Cudini & Lucas Jewelers Dear Mr. Carvalho: As per your request, Mr. Leo Margarit of Cudini & Lucas Jewelers and Mark Sork, property owner, have agreed to revise our Variance submittal to include the entire pylon sign. Both parties agree to a continuance, if staff needs more time to prepare for this project. Please call me as soon as possible so I can inform all SERVING THE parties the date the Planning Commission will hear this GLOBE FROM case. LONG BEACH, CA HOUSTON, TX Thanks. SEATTLE, WA Sincerely, .STAN JANOCHA SJ/he FAX 714-374-1540 cc: Leo Margarit Mark Sork 310.495.3808 800.995.9099 310.435.1867.FAX . 1700 West Anaheim Street Long Beach CA 90813-1195 • BOARD of zoni 1G ADJUSTMEnTS CIT1 OF HUNTINGTON BEACH-CALIFORNIA E.O. BOX 190.92648 PHONE(114)536-3271 RECONSIDERATION OF CCNDITIONAL EXCEPTION ;IO. 85-96 in conjunction with RECONSIDERATION OF ADMINISTRA^'I"t- REVIEW NO. 85-55 Applicant: . L & M Investment Company 1500 Adams Avenue, Suite 315 Costa Mesa, California 92626 P.equest: To conRtruct a 1,700 Square Foot reste.urant addition with a variance to maintain existing 2'-8' wide planter along Brookhurst Street and Adams Avenue Location.: Subject property is located at 19881 Brookhurst Street (Northwest corner of Adams Avenue and Brookhurst Street ) Date of Approval: January 29, 1986 Dear Applicant: Your applications were acted upon byy the Huntington Beach Board of ' Zoning -Adjustments on January 29, 1986, and your requests were ,Conditionally Approved. Under the provisions of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, the action taken by the Board of Zoning Adjustments - is final unless an - Appeal is filed to the Planning Commission by you or by an ` interested part y.y. Said appeal must be in writing and must set forth in. detail the action and grounds by which the applicant or interested party deems himself aggrieved, Said appeal must be accompanied by a filing fee :,f One Hunlred and Sixty-five Dollars ($165.00) a)nd submitted to the Secretary of the planning Commission within . ten (10) days of the date of Lhe Boardl.s :decision. . The last day for filing an appeal and payin a :ling fee for the . f above noted application is February. 8, 19to. ATTACHMENT NO '� Page Two Conditional Exception No. 85-9F, Administrative Review No. 85-55 Provisions of the Huntington 'ileach Ordinance Code are such that any application becomes null and void one ( 1 ) year after the final approval , unless actual construction has begun. FINDINI;S FOR APPROVAL CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION 110. 85-96 : 1 . Because of special circumstances applicable to the subject property, including size, shape, and location the strict application of the Zoning Ordinance is found to deprive the subject property of privileges enjoyed by cthe: properties in the vicinity and under identical zone classifications. The site currently has 6 15% of landscaping and, in addition to the 218" wide planter along Brookhurst and Adams, there is a low garden wall which further screens the parking area. . 2. The granting of this conditional exception is necessary in order to Preserve the enjoyment of one it more substantial property rights. 3. The granting of Conditional Exception No. 85-96 will not be materially detrimental to the public welfare, or injurious to property in the same zone classifications. 4. The granting of the conditional exception will not adversely affect the General Plan of the City of Huntington Beach. CONDITIONS OP APPROVAL CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 85-96 1. A revised site plan shall be submitted depicting the modifications described in Condition 1 of 'the conditions of approval for Administrative Peview 85-55. •- ' ''' " F_l 2. All conditions of Administrative Review No. 85-55 shall be �.` applicable. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW 85-55 1. A revised site plan shall be submitted depicting the modifications described herein: a. Ipdicate compact parking spaces along perimeter of the ��- site b. Provide 643 parking spaces. c. Aisleways shall be minimum 20' adjacent to the new retail space at the northeast corner of the site. d. Delete (five)-5 paralle spaces at the northeast corner of . the site ,along Brookhurst. .; � e. A minimum of -8 handicapped parking spaces, minimum 14 . foot in width.. I Page Three Conditional Exception No . 85-96 Administrative Review No. 85-55 f . Delete four (4 ) sout'ierly parking stalls adjacent to Polly's Restaurant . g. North elevation of tte new retail space shall not have any doors unless required by the Fire Department; and shall include a 360 high block wall base. h. Indicate planter areal; i . Modify the slight jog in the main driveway aisle adjacent to the buildings to comply with Fire Department Standard No. 401 . 2. A parking management plan shall be submitted indicating employee parking around the perimeter of the site. 3. The building addition shall comply with Article 969.6 regarding floodplain standar1s. 4 . A planned sign program shall be submitted prior to the issuance of building permits and approved for all signing within the commercial center pursuant to S. 9760.43 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Cole. All new signs shall comply with the Planned Sign Program. 4 a . The major identification signs shall be removed or altered to comply with Articlf: 976 within two years. Rotating signs are prohibited . 5. The development shall comply with all applicable provisions of the Ordinance Code, BuileLnc Division, and Fire Department except as noted in Conditional Exception Vo. 85-96. 6. Service roads and fire lanes, as determined by the Fire Department, shall be posted and marked. 7. The westerly driveway approach along Adams shall be designated right-hand turn only for exiting. 8. All driveway approaches less than 27' in width shall be a = - minimum of twenty-seven feet (271 ) in width and shall be of radius type construction. 9. The metal posts in the driveway along the north side of the new retail space shall be removed. : Proposed structures shall be architecturally .compatible with existing structures. ' ` . 11. All trash s eas shall be fully enclosed with chain link fencing with redwood slats and a matching gate. Page Four Conditional Exception No . 85-96 Administrative Review No. 85-55 12. Natural gas shall be stubbed in at the locations of cooking facilities, water heaters, and central heating units. 13 . Low-volume heads shall be used on all spigots and water faucets. 14. All building spoils, such as unusable lumber, wire, pipe, and other surplus or unusable mcterial , shall be disposed of at an offsite facility equipp?d to handle them. 15. The subject property shall enter into irrevocable reciprocal driveway and parking easement(s) between the subject site and corner parcel it corner parch'. is ever owned separately. The Department of Development Services will perform a comprehensive plan check relating to all Ordinance Code requirements upon submittal of your completed structural drawings . Please be advised that the Board of Zoning Adjustments reviews the conceptual plan as a basic request for entitlement of the use applied for in r�Iation to the vicinity in which it is proposed. The conceptual l,.an should not be construed as a precise plan reflecting conformance to all Ordinance Code requirements. f It is recommended that you immediately pursue completion of the t Conditions of Approval and address all requirements of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code in crder to expedite the processing of yoitc total application. hereby certify that Conditional Exception No. 85-96 and . Administrative Review No. 85-55 were Conditionally Approved by the Board_ of. Zoning Adjustments of the City of Huntington Beach, . . California, on January 29, 1986, upon the foregoing conditions and ' <. :3{.. _,citations. _ Very truly'yours, Glen Godfrey, Secretary - =:Y`j Board .of Zoning Adjustments { GG.Jr z (4096d) f is A CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MA,'N STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES BUILDING DIVISION(7141 636-6241 PLANNING DIVISION (714) 536-5271 March 16, 1987 Mark Sork 1.500 Adams Avenue Ste. 315 Costa Mesa, CA 9262:6 Subject : Planned Sign Program ro . 86-5 Dear Mr . Sark: The Planned Sign Program dated September 29 , 1986 submitted for the- Mervyn' s Shopping Center has been reviewed and approved with some modifications by the Department of Development Services . Please reference Administrative Review No. 85-55 containing a condition requiring the eventual removal of the major identification signs which you agreed to do. This requirement has been reiterated in the modified Planned Sign Program. The following standards shall govern all freestanding and wall signage within the shopping center . Any changes, alteration, or revision to PSP No . 86-5 shall be reviewed and approved by the Director of Development Services prior to the issuance of applicable permits or the erection or alteration of such signs within the development. FREESTANDING SIGN REQUIREMENTS: A. The following freestanding sign criteria shall be the approved specific requirements : 1. The -major identification signs -shall be removed or altered to comply with Article 961 by January 29, 1988 -as required by Condition of Approval .No. 42 . .of Administrative Review No . 85-55 . The following. requirements shall pertain to the new freestanding signs . a . Two center identification signs shall be allowed, one on each street . frontage. b. Maximum height shall be fifteen (15) feet . C. Maximum sign area shall be seventy (70) square feet. - I d. Copy shall be limited to center and major tenant identification. e. Signs shall comply in all other requirements for freestanding signs given in the Huntington Beach Sign Code. MACHMENT NO. Page Two Manned Sign Program No. 86-5 2 . The existing secondary business identification signs for Polly' s and Coast S&L may remain. 3 . The maximum number of freestanding signs on site shell be four (4) , including two (2*, :enter identification signs and two (2) secondary business identification signs . WALL SIMGE REQUIREMENTS B. The following wall sign criteria shall be the approved specific requirements for. all new signs -ot changes in any existing wall signs . 1. No sign shall be installed, erected, altered, or reconstructed without prior City approval and issuance of appropriate Building Division permits . a . Prior to submittal for plan check and issuance of permits, the sign plans must be approved by the owner or owner ' s representative. b. UL listed housings shall be required for all wall signage. 2 . Each tenant shall be permitted one internally illuminated individual channel letter sign located on the building front . Tenants with a corner unit will be permitted two wall signs, which will not exceed the maximum sign area for business frontage per Section 9160 . 5 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. a . Copy shall be limited to' the establishment ' s name and/or product name. • b. Box-type or can signs shall be . architecturally _integrated with wall or facia board. c. Exposed neon co_nduit,- tubing or raceway signs are prohibited: 3 . Each sign, including logo, shall be centered on the fascia ..vertically and horizontally and conform to the following : a. Maximum letter height for all establishments shall be 18 inches for individual letters . b. Upper and lower case letters from top of the ascender to the bottom of descender shall not exceed 32 inches in overall height. i rage Tnrec- . tanned Sign Program No. 86-5 c. Letter height shall not be less than 12 inches high. d. �vo -lines of copy will be permitted on small store-fronts provided the combined letter height including :pace between words does not exceed 32 inches in height. e. Letter return or depth shall be 5 inches . f . Trim cap and let'.':er return color shall be dark brown. g. Sign length shall not exceed 70 percent of the leasehold width. h. Maximum sign area shall not exceed that permitted under Section 9610 . 5 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. C. No tenant shall affix or maintain upon the exterior" walls of the premises or the buildings or in the parking lot and landscape areas any signs other than as permitted herein except with the City and landlord ' s approvals . 1). All signs fabricated and installed in this shopping center will harmonize with the design standards of the entire shopping center and all co-tenants . If you have any questions aegarding this matter, please do not hesitate to contact Pam Posten at 536-5271. Sincerely, Jaines W. Palin Director by: Glen_ Godfrey - Deputy for Planning JWP:GG:PP: jr (7538d) • ATTACHMENT NO-I ALTERNATIVE FINDINGS AND CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO, 93-13 (Applicant's Request) FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL-SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13: 1. Strict compliance with Article 961 will result in substantial economic hardship to the applicant because the existing 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding sign is necessary for identification of the businesses in the shopping center. The location of the building is approximately 200 feet from Adams Avenue,which does not provide adequate street exposure. 2. There are unusual site or building characteristics that preclude the various businesses from yielding adequate signage from the provisions of the sign code. The location and orientation of the commercial building on the northern side of the property does not provide adequate business exposure on Adams Avenue. 3. Due to the fact that there are special site or building conditions applicable to the site, approval of the 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding sign is necessary to enjoy sign provisions enjoyed by other businesses in the immediate vicinity. 4. The existing 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding sign and 140 square foot sign face change will not adversely affect other signs in the area,nor will the sign obstruct pedestrian or vehicular traffic vision. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL-SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13: 1. The.site plan and sign elevations received and dated October 6, 1993, shall be the conceptually approved layout with the following modifications: a. All rotating signs shall be permanently affixed. b. A landscape planter shall be provided at the base of the sign poles. Detailed plans shall be provided depicting compliance with the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code parking stall requirements. 2. Building and electrical permits shall be obtained within 30 days from the date of this approval. 3. This special sign permit shall not become effective until and "Acceptance of Conditions" form has been signed and notarized by the applicant, and returned to the Planning Division; and until the ten (10)day appeal period has elapsed. 4. The Planning Commission reserves the right to rescind this special sign permit approval in the event of any violation of the applicable zoning laws. Any such decision shall be preceded by notice to the applicant and a public hearing,and shall be based on specific findings. (pcsr005) ATTACHMENT NO.>!O ALTERNATIVE FINDINGS AND CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO 93-13 (Staff Alternative) FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL- SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13: 1. Strict compliance with Article 961 will result in substantial economic hardship to the applicant because the proposed 15 foot high, 100 square foot freestanding sign is necessary for identification of the businesses in the shopping center. The location of the building is approximately 200 feet from Adams Avenue, which does not provide adequate street exposure. 2. There are unusual site or building characteristics that preclude the various businesses from yielding adequate signage from the provisions of the sign code. The location and orientation of the commercial building on the northern side of the property does not provide adequate business exposure on Adams Avenue. 3. Due to the fact that there are special site or building conditions applicable to the site, approval of the 15 foot high, 100 square foot freestanding sign is necessary to enjoy sign provisions enjoyed by other businesses in the immediate vicinity. 4. The proposed 15 foot high, 100 square foot freestanding sign will not adversely affect other signs in the area,nor will the sign obstruct pedestrian or vehicular traffic vision. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL-SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO.93-13: 1. The site plan and sign elevations received and dated October 6, 1993, shall be the conceptually approved layout with the following modifications: a. Maximum height of the sign shall be 15 feet with 100 square feet of sign area including four(4), 25 square foot tenant panels. b. The sign shall be located in a landscape planter. Detailed plans shall be provided depicting compliance with the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code parking stall requirements. 2. Building and electrical permits shall be obtained within 30 days from the date of this approval. 3. This special sign permit shall not become effective until and "Acceptance of Conditions" form has been signed and notarized by the applicant,and returned to the Planning Division; and until the ten (10)day appeal period has elapsed. 4. The Planning Commission reserves the right to rescind this special sign permit approval in the event of any violation of the applicable zoning laws. Any such decision shall be preceded by notice to the applicant and a public hearing,and shall be based on specific findings. (pcsr005) PUBLIC NOTICE - -- • .. NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE CITY! COUNCIL OF THE - CITY OF HUNTiNGTON BEACH NOTICE IS HEREBY. GIVEN that on Monday April 3,1995,at 7:00 PM in the City Council Chambers, 2000 Main Street, Hunting- ton Beach,the City Council will t ohearing PROOF OF PUBLICATION on e following hems APPEALOF CONDI- TIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 94-25 COASTAL DEVELOP- MENT PERMIT NO. 94-10/ EXCEPT STATE OF CALIFORNIA) (VARIANCE)L O. 94I303/ NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 94-12(DEMOLITION SS. OF .THE FORMER MAX- WELL'S RESTAURANT County of Orange ) BUILDING) -Applicant: City of Huntington Beach, De- partment of Community Services Appellant- Coun- NOTICE IS HEREBY cilmember Dave Sullivan - GIVEN that initial environ- Coastal Commission, 245 1 am a Citizen of the United States and a To permit the demolition of mental assessments for the W. Broadway, Suite 380', the former Maxwell's Res• above item(s) #1 and #3 I Long Beach California resident of the County aforesaid- I am taurant building. and con- were processed and com= 90801-1450, An: Theresa struction of a new 31,000 pleted in accordance.with Henry,(310 590.5071 . over the age of eighteen years and not a square foot,three (3) story the California Environ- The Coastal Commission I restaurant and banquet fa• mental Quality Act. It was review period will com- cflity The existing building determined that Item #1 mence after the City appeal party to or interested In the below is 28 feet In height and the and#3 would not have any period has ended and no entitled matter. I am a principal clerk of request includes maintain- significant environmental appeals have been filed. (ng that building height in effect and, therefore, a . Applicants will be notified the HUNTINGTON BEACH INDEPENDENT, a lieu of i maximum 25 feet negative declaration is war- by the Coastal Commission as speckled In the Down- ranted.The Planning Com- as to the date of the con. town Specific Plan. Loca• mission Is recommending clusion of the Coastal er o general circulation, newspaper f l cilation printed tion. - 317 Pacific Coast approval of Negative Dec- Commission review. Ap- p g i .Highwa (south of the Mu. laration No.94-12 and Neg- plicants are advised not to and published in the City of Huntington nicipal Pier at Main Street ative Declaration No.94.21 begin construction prior to on the oceanslde of Pacific based on their actions.at that date. Coast Higghway) Planner, the January 24,and Febru• ON FILE: A copy of the Beach, County of Orange, State of Assigned:Wayne Carvalho ary 28, 1995, Planning proposed requests are on E.-2. APPEAL OF SPECIAL Commission meeting, re- file in the Department of California, and that attached Notice Is a iSIGN PERMIT NO. 93.13 ; spectfvely. Community: Development, 'SUPERIOR ELECTRICAL NOTICE IS HEREBY 2000 Main Street, Hunting- true and complete copy as was printed ADVERTISING, INC. (CON GIVEN that Item #2 Is cat- ton Beach, Californiay TINUED FROM THE APRIL egorically exempt from the 92648, for Inspection b provislons of the California the public. A copy of the and published in the Huntington Beach 4, 1994 CITY COUNCIL Environmental Quality AcL staff reports will be avail- MEETING) •Applicant: Su� NOTICE .IS HEREBY able to Interested parties at and Fountain Valley Issues of said perior Electrical Advertis GIVEN that Item #1 is lo- the City Clerk's Office after mg,Inc.Appellant-Former cated In the appealable ju- March 30;1995. news a er to wit the issues) of. Mayor Pro.Tem Earle Robl= risdiction of the Coastal ALL INTERESTED PER. p P Ing, -To permit an exist- Zone and Includes Coastal SONS are invited to attend foot non conforming 45 Development Permit No. said hearing and express foot high, 624 square toot 94.10 which has been filed opinions or submit evi- double pole pylon sign to in conjunction .with. the dence for or against the remain in its present Iota- above request. application as outlined tion and to allow a 140 NOTICE IS HEREBY above. If you challenge the March 2 3 1995 square foot sign face GIVEN that the Coastal De- City Council's action In rchange identifying Cudini velopment hearing consists court, you may be limited and Lucas Jewelers,in lieu of a staff report, public to raising only those Issues of a maximum 15 foot high, hearing, City Council dis• you or someone else 70 square foot freestanding cussion and Action. Under' raised at the public hearing sign pursuant to Sectior: the provisions of the Hun- described in this notice,or 9610.7 of the Huntington tington Beach Ordinance in written correspondence Beach Ordinance Code: Code, the action taken by delivered to the City at, or Location•9891 Adams Av the City Council Is final un- prior to,the public hearing. i declare, under penalty of perjury, that enue (northwest corner at less an appeal is filed to If there are any further Brookhurst Street) Plannei the Coastal Commission by questions, please call the the fore oin is true and correct. Assigned:Wayne Carvalho the applicant or an ag- Planning Division at 536- g g 3. CODE AMENDMENT grieved party. Said appeal 5271 and refer to the NO 94-5/NEGATIVE DEC. must be In writing and above Items. Direct your LARATION ,NO. 94-2.1 - must set forth in detail the written communications to SEABRIDGE SPECIFIC actions and grounds by the City Clerk. PLAN AMENDMENT, CEN. and upon which the ap- Connie Brockway, Executed on March 24 199 5 TERSTONE DEVELOP- plicant on interested party City Clerk, City of Hun. r MENT COMPANY; Ap• deems himself aggrieved tington Beach, 2000 at Costa Mesa California. opmen Centmpane Devel- To Said appeal must al -sub- Main Street 2nd Floor, r opment Company - To matted to the Coastal Com- r amend the Seabridge Spe: mission office within ten Huntington Beach, CA chic Plan to allow medium (10) working days of the 92648(714)536.5227 density residential develop- date of the Council's ac- Published Huntington ment on.3.95 acres with tion.There Is no fee for the Beach-Fountain Valley In- Area B designated for Re• appeal of a coastal Bevel- dependent March 23,1995. source Production (01), tc opment permit. - create development stand. An aggrieved person my 034•1d0. ards for detached dwell• file an appeal within ten s to delete the saltwater (10) working days, Pursu- mar marsh requirement and de• ant to Section 30603 of the fete the requirement that Public Resources Code, In the area be deeded to the writing to: California Signature Homeowner's Association' A 30 lot subdivision for a planned unit development, consisting of 30 single fam- fly residential detached units"was conditionally T ap- proved by the Planning Tv Commission -on February 28, 1995. Location - East side..of Beach Boulevard, 400 feet south of Adams Avenue. Planner Assigned: Scolt Hess Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 f y f/iR 15341674 :,,�201 r� o� TING NG 6' Jose Keit 1 19851 C1ar Mont'Ln t Z Hunting n Bear.h'(?Ati+�akar,,, o kk ISO LEGAL NOTICE- PUBLIC H A G {} Id d1l, I { { , r ' Brockway,City Clerk • Connie Broc ' - City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O.Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 x IlQ C�� •z f '� "�^�?<l. •,'`r�� State of California Dept of Ge `650 Howe Ave. seramento,CA 95825 INGT°y� O =NGORPORq 1F0 z NOUN TY LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 -35 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 1 ?`1 �? 1 �� `y s.f• I ,� 06 153 415 55 95 MICHAEL RAY GUSTAVESON 3106 S. DEEGON DRIVE SANTA ANA CA 92704 4��NTINGT°y NGORP044 fly �F 9 �F:.__ ao OQ 2V e I), 1909' LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING t Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 24, -5 :j Huntington Beach,CA 92648 A ......... .... 153 415 37 77 �ptJTING Jeanette LaCoijr 1984' Berk-shire Ln LORPOR4 .3 Huntington Beach CA 9-1-A-C LAC0843 926464009 1394 03/27/95 LACOURFORWARDING TIME EXPIRED 651 E 46TH ST APT 7 V, LONG BEACH CA 90807-i571 RETURN TO SENDER NTI % LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk 71, P.O.Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 "v ,A Fernando-. od" ING 9746 Chance C Huntington on a 92)6 4 6 p" ppU NTX % LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING I I I I I h!I I I! 11,1 F t I l 1 1. i .., .. '• ' s fl, r fy r : A Connie Brockway,City City of Huntington Beach lrk Office of the City Clerk P.O.Box 190 � Huntington Beach, CA 92 �e! s�R� ��t�G7aN a� SvC`-?�'� + 648 a 9 G U.S.POSfAGEI+•�7 ' ik FIRST a ffAR3t '�5 y i S �t��s 153 406 55 ��%%TINGT�� > p Mark A Jh1ayes` �Ai'r:,ti tNCOAPgq<I �i Eo �F9 9719 Adams Ave .- , Huntington Beach CA 92646 P, Fri 1909. NTY CPS LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 11�1�,,,I,I�11„,I„1�11.►�l,�ll��l�ll��,i�l��lll�i NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that on Monday, April 3, 1995,at 7:00 PM in the City Council Chambers, 2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach,the City Council will hold a public hearing on the following items: ❑ 1. APPEAL OF CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO.94-25/COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT NO.94-10/CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION(VARIANCE)NO.94-33/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 94-12(DEMOLITION OF THE FORMER MAXWELL'S RESTAURANT BUILDING): -Applicant: City of Huntington Beach,Department of Community Services Appellant-Councilmember Dave Sullivan-To permit the demolition of the former MaxweIl's Restaurant building and construction of a new 31,000 square foot,three(3) story restaurant and banquet facility. The existing building is 28 feet in height and the request includes maintaining that building height in lieu of a maximum 25 feet as specified in the Downtown Specific Plan.Location-317 Pacific Coast Highway(south of the Municipal Pier at Main Street on the oceanside of Pacific Coast Highway) Planner Assigned: Wayne Carvalho 1.0-7-' APPEAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 SUPERIOR ELECTRICAL ADVERTISING,INC. (CONTINUED FROM THE APRIL 4,1994 CITY COUNCIL MEETING): -Applicant: Superior Electrical Advertising,Inc. Appellant-Former Mayor Pro Tern Earle Robitaille-To permit an existing,non conforming 45 foot high,624 square foot double pole pylon sign to remain in its present location and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini and Lucas Jewelers,in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. Location -9891 Adams Avenue(northwest corner at Brookhurst Street) Planner Assigned: Wayne Carvalho ❑ 3. CODE AMENDMENT NO. 94-5/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO.94-21-SEABRIDGE SPECIFIC PLAN AMENDMENT,CENTERSTONE DEVELOPMENT COMPANY: - Applicant: Centerstone Development Company. -To amend the Seabridge Specific Plan to allow medium density residential development on 3.95 acres within Area B designated for Resource Production(01),to create development standards for detached dwellings,to delete the saltwater marsh requirement and delete the requirement that the area be deeded to the Homeowner's Association. A 30 lot subdivision for a planned unit development, consisting of 30 single family residential detached units was conditionally approved by the Planning Commission on February 28, 1995.Location-East side of Beach Boulevard, 400 feet south of Adams Avenue. Planner Assigned: Scott Hess NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that initial environmental assessments for the above Item(s)#1 and#3 were processed and completed in accordance with the California Environmental Quality.Act. It was determined that Item# 1 and#3 would not have any significant environmental effect and,therefore, a negative declaration is warranted. The Planning Commission is recommending approval of Negative Declaration No. 94-12 and Negative Declaration No. 94-21 based on their actions at the January 24, and February 28, 1995,Planning Commission meeting,respectively. NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that Item#2 is categorically exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act. NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that Item# 1 is located in the appealable jurisdiction of the Coastal Zone and includes Coastal Development Permit No. 94-10 which has been filed in conjunction with the above request. (CCLG0403-1) NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING (Continued) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Coastal Development hearing consists of a staff report,public hearing, City Council discussion and action. Under the provisions of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code,the action taken by the City Council is final unless an appeal is filed to the Coastal Commission by the applicant or an aggrieved party. Said appeal must be in writing and must set forth in detail the actions and grounds by and upon which the applicant or interested party deems himself aggrieved. Said appeal must be submitted to the Coastal Commission office within ten(10)workine days of the date of the Council's action. There is no fee for the appeal of a coastal development permit. An aggrieved person may file an appeal within ten(10)working days,pursuant to Section 30603 of the Public Resources Code, in writing to: California Coastal Commission 245 W.Broadway, Suite 380 Long Beach, California 90801-1450 Attn: Theresa Henry (310)590-5071 The Coastal Commission review period will commence after the City appeal period has ended and no appeals have been filed. Applicants will be notified by the Coastal Commission as to the date of the conclusion of the Coastal Commission review. Applicants are advised not to begin construction prior to that date. ON FILE: A copy of the proposed requests are on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach, California 92648,for inspection by the public. A copy of the staff reports will be available to interested parties at the City Clerk's Office after March 30, 1995. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If you challenge the City Council's action in court,you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice,or in written correspondence delivered to the City at,or prior to,the public hearing. If there are any further questions please call the Planning Division at 536-5271 and refer to the above items. Direct your written communications to the City Clerk. Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street,2nd Floor Huntington Beach, CA 92648(714)536-5227 (CCLG0403-2) CFOCOUNCIL PUBLIC HEARING REQ4*T SUBJECT: Off e--f t-r-,I A-(- --*- 10 J f t--P-M, 17- �, 2 S,13 (!!�:OkMNVE0 Ff,--'0k4 T#5 Alt-K/L_ 4�j COLMU(— DEPARTMENT: C-btkm \j MEETING: (q q.5- i ........................ ... ........ ..................... ... . ..... . ....... ................................................................. ............. ....... ftR .... ....... ............ .......... .. ......... N/A YES NO Does Heading and Closing of Notice Reflect City Council Hearing (Not PC) Is a Map attached and/or is a quarter page legal ad required? W If Lappeal, is appellant's name shown on legal notice? If housing is involved, is"legal challenge paragraph" included? If Coastal Development Permit, are the RESIDENT labels attached and is the Coastal Commission Office on the labels? If Coastal Development Permit, has the Master Legal Notice Document been used? >o Is Title Company verification letter attached? Were the.latest Assessor's Parcel Rolls used? (Please ttach verification of Title Co.or indicate that rolls used were derivedrrom Assessor's Rolls in Planning Depl.)whichever applicable) Is the appellant's name and address part of the labels? Is day of public hearing correct -Monday/Tuesday? ,yV Has the City Administrator's Office authorized the public hearing to be set? Is day of public hearing correct -Monday/Tuesday? Is there an Environmental Status to be approved by Council? Are the appellant/applicant's names and addresses on mailing labels? For Public Hearings at the City Council level, please insert the below paragraph of the public hearing notice "ALLJNTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing-and.&Mws.opoqgs or submit to the City Clerk written evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions, please call (insert name of Planner) at 536-5271 CONNIEE BROCKWAY,CITY CLERK CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET-2ND FLOOR HUNTINGTON BEACH,CALIFORNIA'k648 (714)536-5227 GAs/PTUBHER .153 415 21 61 153 4]5 22 62 153 415 23 63 John A DeMarr Grace A Anderson Kirstine L Cerone 16787 Beach Blvd • 21322 Breton Ln • 19836 Berkshire Ln Huntington Beach CA 92647 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 24 64 153 415 25 65 153 415 26 . 66 Gerardo Calderon Guinn E Lumpkin j Charles Stidham 19840 Berkshire Ln Po Box 146 19848 Berkshire Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Midway City CA 92655 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 27 67 1 415 153 415 29 69 Martin A &Ana L Zabala ;19 r o - Hideko Kay Masuda 7152 Fenway Dr#11 856 Ir n 20012 Colgate Cir \\'estminster CA 92683 to ton ac A 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 30 70 1 71 15343532 72 Maureen Hewitt James War 2 Wilson J&Maria A Elder 19864 Berkshire Ln BM 19872 Berkshire Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 33 73 1 153 415 34 74 153 415 35 75 Jos.: Luis B Rodriguez Guinn E Lumpkin Mildred Coker- 2713 Lindy Ave Po Box 146 19882 Berkshire Ln Rosemead CA 91770 Midway City CA 92655 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 36 76 153 415 37 77 153 415 38 78 James Earl Nackey Jeanette LaCour Cheryl A Perry 19841 Berkshire Ln 19843 Berkshire Ln 19847 Berkshire Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 i 153 415 39 79 153 415 40 80 153 415 41 81 Andrew J Acosta Neria Yomtoubian Ricky G Denney 19851 Berkshire Ln Po Box 3595 19859 Berkshire Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Newport Beach CA 92659 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 42 82 153 415 43 83 153 415 44 84 Roger F&Joanne ?�4 Monteen Kenneth W.Newland Lawrence Schultz 802 River Rock Blvd 1836 Iowa St 9945 Cornwall Dr . Huntington Beach CA 37129 Costa Mesa CA 92626 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341545 85 153 415 46 86 153 415 47 87 Ezra Lai Sendler Tseitlin Thomas P & Nancy L Hughes 9941 Cornwall Dr 9937 Cornwall Dr 9933 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 41548 88 153 415 49 S9 153 415 50 90 Gloria Marie Quick Sherri I Foster Joan Poiricr 99-79 Cornwall Dr 9351 Vclardo Dr 9921 Corn\\;ill Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Bcach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Billy H Thomas Herman & Larisa Lebovic j 21972 Yellov%-stone Ln 1985$ Kingswood Ln ;.El Toro CA 92630 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 41554 94 153 415 55 95 : Ellen Zakour Michael Ray Gustaveson 19850 Kingswood Ln 19846 Kingswood Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 od 153 415 57 97 153 415 58 98 Alan Foster Raul Velesquez ]9842 Kingswood Ln 19831 Kingswood Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 : 15341560 100 15341561 101 1 Robin A Gross Hsin-Piao Chen �. 10291 Jon Day Dr 1888 N College Cir H Huntington Beach CA 92646 Long Beach CA 90815 H 153 415 63 103 153 415 64 104 15 Kathy L Harper Helen Garcia-Checlonan R(- - 19851 Kinoswood Ln 19855 Kingswood Ln 11; HuntLnigton Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Fo 153 415 66 106 t3415 67 153 Tony Khorouzan Carl 19863 Kin-s�i°ood Ln 197� Huntington Beach CA 92646 gt a A 92646 Hun 153 415 69 109 15341570 110 153 E.James Wheless James B Bailey Patr 26 Sycamore Crk 10061 Dakota Ave 1988 Irene CA 92715 Garden Grove CA 92643 Hun 1534157 112 15341573 113 1P' S Michael J O'Donnell Nati ,4 Civ' er 19880 Inverness Ln 11987E � a An A.9*) 1 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 76 116 153 Mu-%vaffaq ""' Dung Ky Nouyen Rick 1,08721 us `� Ln 12450 Bay Hill Ct 170i neton each CA-92646 Garden Grove CA 92643 I le%k 1�341578 118 15341579 119 153 Robcrt. M & Rois.in C Eriksen Linda A Stalford Johr T9860 In%-crncss Ln 19856 Inx-crncss Ln 167E HuntinSton Beach CA 926�6 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Hun 153 415 81 121 153 415 82 122 153 415 4 rrancis F d Butts Georg r-ray Peter M ): 5182 DofflWe Ave 18922 NlWint Cimarron St 19840 Inv Irvine CA 92714 Fountain Valley CA 92709 Huntingtc 15341584 124 153 415 85 125 Jonny B Rohrer Kathryn L Orris >198 19836 Inverness Ln 19832Inverness Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 341587 122.,o% 15341601 128 153 416 C Hun ;on Gin •n Ho Kent R Horne John Atta 19801 B 1 9782 Continental Dr 5081 Fick ;Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 San Diegc 15341603 130 15341604 131 153 416 C M Conrad Epley Jerry L Bowen Teri L Alli 9788 Continental Dr 5432 Catowba Ln 9802 Cont Huntington Beach CA 92646 Irvine CA 92715 Huntingtc 15341606 133 153 416 07 134 1534160 - Jacob N4 Lee Ronald P Rouintr= Shriver Ar 9808 Continental Dr 9812 Continental Dr 9816 Cont Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntingto 15341609 136 153 416 10 137 1534161 David W Cooney Ben J Miles Jerome J C 0820 Continental Dr 9824 Continental Dr 5402 Baru Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntingto 153 416 12 139 153 416 13 140 153 416 1 Sharon Rose Getz George Donald Radabaugh John J Ki, 2049 W 236th Place Dr 9842 Continental Dr 24162 Cas Torrance CA 90501 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Mission V 153 416 15 142 153 416 16 143 153 416 1 - William R. Rowland Jerry E Todd Patricia A 9848 Continental Dr 35128 Quartz St 19893 Lur Huntington Beach CA 92646 Yucaipa CA 92309 Huntingtc 153 416 18 145 153 416 19 146 153 416 2 Tan 1\4 Dang Dorothy J Rudd Kimberly 9854 Continental Dr 1946 Pelican Pl 9858 Cont Huntington Bcach CA 92646 Costa Mesa CA 92626 Huntingtc 153 416:2]. 148 153 416 22 149 1534162 Claire A Chris William H Wilsoi Portia Pac �39fi 1 Ins crncss Ln 19843 Inverness Li 19847 Invi Huntington Bcach CA 92646 Huntineton Bcach CA 92646 Huntingtc { 153 416 24 151 153 416 25 152 153 416 26 153 Neila S Ready Craig R Bergquist Bil)y H Thomas 19851 Inverness Ln • 13451 Rosecrans Ave 21972 Yellowstone Ln j Huntington Beach CA 92646 Santa Fe Springs CA 90670 El Toro CA 92630 i 15341627 154 153 416 28 155 153 416 29 156 Margaret A Kuhn ' John P Haberstroh Ronald E Roluffs 19861 Inverness Ln 9879 Cornwall Dr 904 S Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Anaheim CA 92804 153 416 30 157 153 416 31 158 153 416 32 159 Martha E Riggs Susan A Hawkins Judith A Bailey Po Box 86 Po Box 3204 9863 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 92648 Quail Valley CA 92587 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 33 160 153 416 34 161 153 416 35 162 Diane M Reber Ron Schneirson Karla SteckbaLer 9859 Cornwall Dr 353 Mavis Dr 9851 Cornwall Dr Huntinon Beach CA 92646 Los Angeles CA 90065 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 36 163 153 416 3.7 164 15341638 165 Alladin Khoja Glen Richard Swanson Maureen O'Reilly 16412 S Casa Rey Dr 19858 Cambridge Ln 19854 Cambridge Ln Santa Ana CA 92 704 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 39 166 153 416 40 167 153 416 41 _ 168 Turgay Dermenci Shoya& Flory Maeji Wassim F Zaky. 10092 Kamuela Dr 19846 Cambridge Ln 17065 Marina:Bay D'r Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92649 153 416 42 169 153 416 43 170 153 416 44 171 Raymond L&Bonnie B Borough Ethna Saunders Erick Taylor 19842 Cambridge Ln 19831 Cambridge Ln 19835 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 45 172 153 416 46 173 153 416 47 174 Susan Lynn Bisnar Magdi G&Wessam Mina Jose R.& Ines Cabrera 19839 Cambridge Ln 19843 Cambridge Ln 19847 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 48 175 153 416 49 176 153 416 50 177 Frances C Blakesley Richard D Hansen Vincent A Zamora 19851 Cambridge-Ln 354 Lourdes Ln 19859 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Costa Mesa CA 92627 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 51 178 ; 15341652 179 153 416 53 ISO Tcresa Marie Wall Margit Giecl Gmc Ltd 1986, Camhri&c Ln 19867 Cambridge Ln 19871 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646, Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341654 181 153 416 55 182 153 416 56 183 Henry L Adams Jesus O Martinez Susan R Head 19775 Inverness Ln 19879 Cambridge Ln • 19881 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 l 153 416 58 185 15 18 ' Be r Thomas A L'angelle Don Jea ]8 74 ape St 19880 Claremont Ln 19876 nt n F alley CA 92708 Huntington Beach CA 92646 i H to B CA 92646 15341660 187 153 416 61 188 153 416 62 189 Michael G Carroll Donald R Squillace Towhid & Rashida Alam 80 Huntington St#8 Po Box 30385 19864 Claremont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92648 Long Beach CA 90853 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416.63 190 153 416 64 191 153 416 65 192 Ira Maurice Bell Karen Lasagna Jean R Franke 21742 Windsong Cir 4110 Apricot Dr 18212 Muir Woods Ct Huntington Beach CA 92646 Irvine CA 92720 Fountain Valley C 92708 153 416 66 193 153 416 67 194 153 416 68 195 Department Of Veterans Affairs Penelope Wentworth Vincent Dantorii Po Box 942895 10121 Old Ranch Cir 3813 Conquista Ave Sacramento CA 94295 Villa Park CA 92667 Long Beach Cry 90808- 153 416 69 196 153 416 70 197 153 416 71 - 198 Cynthia Cunurnins Richard W Jantzer Gonzalo Caro Aranda 19836 Claremont Ln 19832 Claremont Ln 19841 Claremont-Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341672 199 153 416 73 200 153 416 74 201 Rick &Deanna Vanderpool John L Warde Joseph Keith 19843 Claremont Ln 9682 Melinda Cir 19851 Claremont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 75 202 153 416 76 203 153 416 77 204 Silvia F Benavides Kelly James Donohue Ramon Calderon 19855 Claremont Ln 19859 Claremont Ln 19861 Claremont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 78 205 153 416 79 206 153 416 80 207 Kathy NI C1Rrk Beverly A Rapp Duc Martha C Wagoner-Le 9809 Cormvall Dr 9805 Corn%t all Dr 259 62nd St Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Newport Beach CA 92663 15341681 208 153 416 82 209 153 416 83 210 Jo Ann Walkcr Amin Halim Nancy G Hcnri y 97 Corn��all Dr 9793 Cornwall Dr 17843 Bay St 11cmin�,ton Bcach CA 92646 Huntington Bcaclh CA 92646 Fountain Valley CA 92708 15341684 211 15341685 212 15341686 213 Dale M Spangle • Warren H Miller Michael K Wilkinson 11513 Halaw Ln Po Box 1912 12 Autumnleaf Cypress CA 90630 Newport Beach CA 92659 Irvine CA 92714 153 416 87 214 153 416 88 .215 153 416 89 216 Enrique R Rodriguez Kinh LeKy Sherry S Gilpatrick 19858 Coventry Ln 19854 Coventry Ln 19850 Coventry Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341690 217 15341691 218 15341692 219 James Forbes Randall R Bruno Kent&Rosemary Soughers 19846 Coventry Ln 22152 Wood Island Ln 16166 Mariner Dr auntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92649 15 3 153 4 221 1i 22 ;19801 unti gto Town Ho Huntington no Huntington Co wn Ho B - �� S 19801 Bro _ - 19801 B. rst.St o A 92646 Hun ' n'Beach CA 92646 H gton Beach CA 92646 153 417 01 223 153 417 02 224 153 417 03 225. . Melissa Tracy Doan William R Keller Keith R Snider= 9302 Litchfield Dr 2673 Foothill Dr Po Box 8766 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Vista CA 92084 Fountain Valley CA 92728 153 417 04 226 153 417 05 227 153 417 06 228 Judith Carroll Dunham James E Gutierrez Sr. Joseph C Gianhrone 19851 Coventry Ln 19855 Coventry Ln 19859 Coventry Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 07 229 153 417 08 230 153 417 09 231 Richard Blakeman - Robert G Vouga Michael Richard Ceser 19861 Coventry Ln 9601 Lassen Cir 19844 Keswick Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 10 232 153 417 11 233 153 417 12 234 Clayton E Weimer Timothy A:Szabo Michael R Rai..ncy 19846 Keswick Ln 19850 Keswick Ln 19854 Keswick Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 13 235 153 417 14 236 153 417 15 237 Andrew T& Robyn C Shef Cheryl R Ingraham Jon Douglas Andre\,.,s I1. 19858 Keswick Ln 2138 N Park-way Dr 9741 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 El Monte CA 917:3 Huntington Beach CA 92646 1 117 16 23S 153 417 17 239 153 417 IS 240 Scott R Nicllo Norman S Lawson Emad M & Afaf S Gharghoury 9-45 Corn\%all Dr 15590 Irene Wav 9757 Cornwall Dr HuniinLion Bach CA 92646 Wcstminstcr CA 926fi, Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 19 241 153 417 20 242 153 417 John A J ston James Heidi Swanson Katherine 23 Champwy PI 9767 Call Dr Po Box 21 Laguna Niguel CA 92677 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Seal Beacl 153 417 22 244 153 417 23 245 153 417 2, J. Joanne M Romero Margaret Brayton Scott Mar 19891 Coventry Ln 19895 Coventry Ln 19899 Co% Huntington.Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntingto 153 417 25 247 153 417 26 248 153 417 2', Ysmael R Odron Jerome M Ste\A•art Mary A M 454 S Gendel Dr 19905 Coventry Ln 19909 Covq La Puente CA 91744 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington 153 417 28 250 153 417 29 251 153 417 3G Janette C Bushnell , Brian C Werner Larry Jay 173 Colonial Dr 1 8202 El Pescador Ln 11624 Carr. Newtown PA 18940 La Palma CA 90623 Fountain 153 417 31 253 153 417 32 254 153 417 33 . Ruth Massie Felipe&Christina Gonzalez Jim H&Jo; 19929 Coventry Ln 19931 Coventry Ln 1035 Cove Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntingtor. 153 417 34 256 153 417 35 257 153 417 36 Andrzej Mania Randy M Cold ar Roland Coy 9291 Woodcrest Dr. 19943 Coventry Ln 16872 Bolsa Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington 15341737 259 153 417 38 260 153 417 39 Perry Rezvan Norman Sands Diana L Mc 7021 Nimrod Dr 5096 Tortuga Dr=202 9770 Charin Huntington Beach CA 92647 Huntington Beach CA 92649 Huntington 1534.1740 262 153 417 41 263 153 417 42 James N Cappellia Nettie M Nurse Susie Nielse _0510 Mira Loma Dr 19938 Keswick Ln 19934 Kesw Temecula CA 92592 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington 15341743 265 153 417 44 266 153 417 45 Rita M Kusaka Robert B Mase Madlyn J Si 19930 Keswick Ln 336 Colton St 19924 Kesw Huntington Bcach CA 92646 Newport Beach CA 92663 Huntington 153 417 +6 268 1 4 153 417 48 Gcorcc R Santana Lloyd R Connye G 1\ 19920 Kcs\%'ck Ln _ 9341 Q I v r 12 Via Di N Huniincton Bcach CA 92646 in on �6<36. Laguna Ni€ 153 417 49 271 153 417 50 272 153 417 51 273 Hilary N4 A Collett • William S Berger Brenton L Lilley 19906 Keswick Ln 19902 Keswick Ln • 19898 Keswick Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 i l*82 274 153 417 53 275 15341754 276 ;. .a G Billy H Thomas Christopher I Venelin 121972 Yellowstone Ln 19891 Keswick Ln FA 92708 El Toro CA 92630 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341755 277 153 417 56 278 153 417 57 279 Lois M Meinel Stanley A Dawkins Benjamin Ash 19895 Keswick Ln 71 Acacia Tree Ln Po Box 1403 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Irvine CA 92715 Costa Mesa CA 92628 153 417 58 280 153 417 59 281 153 417 60 282 Norman W Gilbert Rosario Ledesma Feliciano &Jesus-Nava 17568 Mountain Ct 19909 Keswick Ln 19913 Keswick Ln Riverside CA 92503 Huntington Beach ca 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 61 283 153 417 62 284 153 417 63 285 - Brian C& Syl%°ia F Bell Mariano Reynoso Anthony>•4 Lucia 19321 Brooktrail Ln 19921 Keswick Ln 8452 Emerado Pl. Huntington Beach CA 92648 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92683 i 153 417 64 286 15341765 287 153 417 66 288 Ralph &Judy Tall Natalie C NIP-Li Annette S South 3 19929 KesN�ick Ln 19931 Keswick Ln 19391 Mauna Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Bach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 67 289 153 417 68 290 153 417 69 291 Joseph M Cordero Jon M Maxwell Alfonso & Lorena Ramirez 19939 Keswick Ln 11721 Norgrove Ln 9742 Charing Cross Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Los Alamitos CA 90720 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 70 292 153 417 71 293 15341772 294 Fernando Rodriguez Robert R Wine Barbara A& Reginald S Holly 9746 Charing Cross Dr 1933 Republic Ave 20561 Paisley Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Costa Mesa CA 92627 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 73 295_ 153 417 74 296 14,11,417 75 2 Tay Tran Reginald S & Barbara A Holly Hunting - a own H 9758 Charing Cross Dr 20561 Paisley Ln 19801 rsi Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Hu ington .Beach CA 9264 153 417 76 S 153 AJI 77 299 153 417 78 300 Humin�i, i own Ho in n Ho Hunnn on 19 .Ol Br ]9501 Brook f 19E01 B -.. I� on Bc:1ch CA 926 H each CA 92646 Hu ton Beach CA 9�{� i - 155 051 01 301 155 051 05 302 155 051 06 303 Sea Shore Apartment Co Ltd �av-On-Realty Inc • Robert H Cowgill Jr. Po Box 5784 3030 Cullerton St 2760 E Spring St #200 Huntington Beach CA 92615 Franklin Park IL 60131 Long Beach CA 90806 155 051 07 304 155 051 10 305 155 18104 306 Allan Fainbarg Rodgers John H Tr%southland C Downey Savings 890 Baker St #200 2828 N Haskell Ave Po Box 6010 Costa Mesa CA 92626 Dallas TX 75204 Newport Beach CA 92658 1 I TENANT TENANT . ; TENANT 9791 ADAMS AVE A795 ADAMS AVE ' 9803 ADAMS AVE HUN- TINGTON BEACH CA UNTINGTON BEACH CA WUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646 92646 92646 TENANT TENANT TENANT 9807 ADAMS AVE 9811 ADAMS AVE 9861 ADAMS AVE HUN'TINGTON BEACH CA HUNTINGTON BEACH CA HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646 92646 92646 TENANT TENANT TENANT 9891 ADAMS AVE 9901 ADAMS AVE 9941 ADAMS AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA HUNTINGTON BEACH CA HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646 92646 92646 TENANT TENANT TENANT 99'51 ADAMS AVE 9961 ADAMS AVE 9971 ADAMS AVE HL"N'TINGTON BEACH CA HUNTTINGTON BEACH CA HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646 92646 92646 lv��t/1'r�Ud e# 6 '{e c. 2bal 151 401 09 151461 03 153 406 48 BRIAN ABRAMS •GARY BATCHELOR RACHEL KRONER 9741 OLYMPIC DR. 9801 OLYMPIC DR. •19930 VERMONT LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA,92646 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92646 15341508 15341527 15341528 HENRY PHO HUD SAMUEL GRINDSTAFF 9892 CONTINENTAL DR PO BOX 12850 19856 BERKSHIRE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 SANTA ANA, CA 92712 HUNTINTON BEACH, CA 92646 15341541 15341552 15341567 PRUDENTIAL MIKHAIL LEVIN DORENE LEOS PO BOX 740237 10822 EL MAR 19867 KINGSWOOD LN ATLANTA,GA 30374 FOUNTAIN VALLEY, CA 92708 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 i-15341572 153 415 74 153 415 75 DOUGLAS ROSSMAN DELORIS PROULX TEXAS COMMERCE BANK 19882 INVERNESS 21761 OCEANVIEW LN 4680 HALLMARK PKWY HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 SAN BERNARDINO, CA 92407 153 416 09 153 416 13 153 416 16 WALLACE RODECKER SANDRA JEAN RADABAUGH JOHN PULLIAM 17220 NEWHOPE ST#127 9842 CONTINENTAL DR 3047 LOCUSTS FOUNTAIN VALLEY, CA 92708 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92646 RIALTO, CA 92377 153 416 44 153 416 50 153 416 59 GLENDA TAYLOR M-WEST MORTGAGE CORP. HOME SAVINGS OF AMERICA 19835 CAMBRIDGE LN 790 THE CITY DRIVE SOUTH ATTN TERRY CARAWAY#2675 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 ORANGE,CA 92646 PO BOX 5300 IRWINDALE,CA 91706 153 416 88 153 417 13 153 417 34 ELISA LE VICTORIA RETTENMAIER TADEUSZ OBARA 5338 LOS MONTEROS 19858 KESWICK LN 19939 COVENTRY LN YORBA LINDA, CA 92687 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 153 417 52 153 417 76 BA PROPERTIES HUNTINGTON CONTINENTAL ATTN ACQUISITIONS#9021 17821 17TH STREET#270 HQA) 7Nf!7Z' 186)-e-A (2,6- PO BOX 3609 TERMINAL ANX TUSTIN, CA 92680 9aG�F L.A. CA 90051 Let:� MoVFa�!7— Iftl /Spn ,),ems A)L- #345- 170-0 U/, 4&%ht-IM 5 Ce)aHVAIT(V6 70/vt �- �a6 RU t3 9b9Z6 VD `HDV99 NOIDNI.I. M 80LZ6 VD `Ag'PIVA NI JNnO-4 9b9Z6 VD `HDV99 NO.LDNI.LNf1H 2IG HDIMN213HD IP£6. IS HdYI93 NVS PL981 NZ GOOMSONIN P9861 RDI2Id VNVf GNV GAO'PI am2lalID Ai-Lag "df VNaiSIG Ga2Id'IV Lb LIP £SI LS 9IP£SI £S SIP £SI 9P9Z6 VD `HDV29 NOIDNI.LNf1H 9b9Z6 VD `HDV39 NO.LDNIIL MH NZ NDIMM S£661 '21G DIdWA'IO Z8L6 -igi Nsa NOG21OD Ba'I ONVISH-ISH 191 £S 90P £SI LO I9P 191 151 401 09 1 151 401 10 2 1 151 401 11 3 Gloria Rodriguez Anthony George Evelyn M Andamo 9741 Olympic Dr 9751 Olympic Dr • 9761 Olympic Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 151 40401 4 151 461 01 5 151 461 0.2 6 Don & Myra Rubin Toshiki Takata Woodrow Keathley 9762 olympic Dr 9781 Olympic Dr 9791 Olympic Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 151 461 03 7 15146104 8 15146105 9 Lorie Grange Pacita H Malapira Girard M Manke 9801 olympic Dr 9812 Olympic Dr 9802 Olympic Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 151 461 06 10 15146 1 151 461 22 12 Roy ITT Hanaoka Hsi- 2nd 9792 Olympic Dr 9782 c' r 8075 W 3rd St =530 Huntington Beach CA 92646 I ch A 92646 Los Angeles CA 90048 15146124 13 15146128 14 15317101 -- .15_ Shell Oil Co Nevada Investment Holdings Inc Allan A FainbarQ Po Box 2099 220 Congress Park Dr 890 Baker St Y200. Houston TX 7 7252 Delray Beach FL 33445 Costa Mesa CA`9 626 153 17102 16 153 406 06 17 153 406 07 18 Fainbarg Allan A Co Craig M Spier Ricardo & Irma Cas_taneda €90 Baker St =200 19861 Keswick Ln 19865 Keswick Ln. Costa Mesa CA 92626 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 406 08 19 153 406 09 20 153 406 37 21 Jonathan L Dawson Isabelle Trang Ngo Yolanda S Cota. 19869 Keswick Ln 14 Fallbrook 19886 Vermont Ln HuntLngton Beach CA 92646 Irvine CA 92714 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 406 38 22 153 406 39 23 153 406 40 _ _. 24 Leonard C Hilts Fred Feodor Alkhoutoff Jill Ann Putnam"-'. 19890 Vermont Ln 19894 Vermont Ln 19898 Vermont Ln.- Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 35340641 25 153 406 42 26. 153 406 43 27 Dan Dare] Walters Rosalie M Metzger Leonard Ross Russo 19902 Vermont Ln 19081 Mathew Cir 8041 E Bynum St Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Long Beach CA 90808 153 406 —.4 28 153 406 45 29 153 406 46 30 %Vassim F Zaky Arthur A FlicQc Robert H Bcnnett 1 065 Marina Bay Dr 6402 Antrim Cir 19922 Vennont Ln Huntington Bcach CA 92649 Huntington Beach C.A 92647 Huntington Bcach CA 92646 15340647 31 153 406 48 32 153 406 49 33 Jose Luis Franco • William L& Linda A& Rachel Kro • Robert J Parke 19926 Vermont Ln 3872 San Joaquin Ave 6111 Jasonwood Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Los Alamitos CA 90720 Huntington Beach CA 92648 153 406 50 34 153 406 51 35 153 406 52 36 Albert B Hebert Phau Quy Bui Greg& Valerie Viers 19938 Vermont Ln 19942 Vermont Ln 9731 Adams Ave Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 ` 15 40 3 3 153 406 54 38 153 406 55 39 Gor n - n e James A &Catherine A Abshier ! Mark A Mayes 1993 K 9723 Adams Ave 9719 Adams Ave ch CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 406 73 40 153 415 01 41 153 415 02 42 Huntington Continental Townhou Randy L Miller Jean R Franke 9635 Cornwall Dr 9864 Continental Dr 18212 Muir Woods Ct Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Fountain Valley CA 92708 153 415 03 43 153 415 04 44 153 415 05 45 Dolores I Coolidge Jean R Franke Clifton R Reed 9872 Continental Dr 18212 Muir Woods Ct 9880 Continental Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Fountain Valley CA 92708 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 06 46 153 415 07 47 153 415 08 48 Amer Jneid Grant H Wilson Jr. Richard L Gerhold 9884 Continental Dr 9888 Continental Dr 2946 E Pembroke Ct Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Fullerton CA 92631 153 415 09 49 153 415 10 50 153 415 11 51 Cynthia L Swanson Nick Riggs Ghaboos Hamidi 9681 Toucan Ave 9908 Continental Dr 9912 Continental Dr Fountain Valley CA 92708 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 12 52 153 415 13 53 153 415 14 54 Ernest A Pellegrini Patrick L Buxton Richard G Kellehar 9916 Continental Dr 6532 Cerulean Ave 5261 Harvard Ave Huntington Beach-CA 92646 Garden Grove CA 92645 Westminster CA 92683 153 415 15 55 153 415 16 56 153 415 17 57 Nghia Vu Rolando J Granadino Michele Roberge 9928 Continental Dr 9932 Continental Dr 9942 Continental Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 l8 5S 153 415 19 59 153 415 20 60 Blanca Hund Genaro Magana Martha Riggs 9946 Continental Dr 9952 Continental Dr 9958 Continental Dr Huntington Bcach CA 92646 Huntington Bcach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O.Box 190 4Z4 ` Huntington Beach,CA 92648 - ,r 15341538 i8 pNTINGTp Cheryl A P rry - O N 19847 B 'shire Ln �� =NGOHPggq rF �F o q Hun Eton Beach CA 9?646 • v PERR647 926464004 1495 04/04/95 09 Q PERRY MOVED LEFT NO ADDRESS UNABLE TO FORWARD ! (r'�. `Ee 17,190g•F� �� RETURN TO SENDER j cO�NTy cap LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING A I f 111e��119�9��11„I L�11��fill11111311111111111111111111111191 ] i y � \ Il 1 1 I 1 {} b S I f � t A e _ Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 z , ............. _ 53 417 37 1 1 259 INGTpy , � ' Perm Rezva n / O \NOAPON47to Huntington Beach CA9:2647 B 17. 1909• CpUN T Y cps -- LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 - Huntington Beach,CA 92648 ;" ' r� ' 153 416 57 s s -` -�'.,., BETTY GREENE lorp INGTp4,� - 18674 SAN FELIPE ST O `NCORPOB47F ' .. FOUNTAIN VALLEY, CA 92708 v !y GREE674 927081016 1A93 03/25/95 i, `• , .r' : �' ' `, GREEN MOVED LEFT NO ADDRESS UNABLE TO FORWARD > OQ RETURN TO SENDER ppUNTY cps LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 4,� ..:.Csi:..:;w-�,,. '•.i�!3^Sy=�:..4, �+al•.. ��:'.�i::r' :o- ��,,. � .v .s. :.y� y. Y i .'�'.:. ,e.+y}..i,.��may.. „!��!.�.:bT ..al..y.,..• 'Ka rf' :J ':i ._ - -ter Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk z Pm P.O. Box 190 � ' a �� `'� _��_ '„'_ ,. • Huntington Beach,CA 92648 `n Z4 MA 1.`/?�! .5 /995 -- - . 15341555 Michael R 95 -1-9846-K-' GUstaveson pNT I NGTp H €sNaood L-n_. j unt' ton ch ,� �' ca `pC0RP0A4 Bea C 92646: -vo OQ 9'y �_ - cpuNT Y ca LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach _' Uri`�• Office of the City Clerk v•r \c ty s P.O. Box 190 ' _R Huntington Beach,CA 92648 t `, NYINGj _ r 153 415 41 T Yy Ricky G Denney 19859 Berkshire Ln \ n n __ _ jiuniinQioP-,X'h C .4 DENN659* 906461016 1A93 03/25/9S DENNEFORWARDING TIME EXPIRED 1320 W PASEO DORADO �C RFe r�19R9•P� FULLERTON CA 92633-1935 Fc°l/NTY C � RETURN TO SENDER LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEAR NG r {{� III��II��II��II��IiP��1L9�II��II��JIII��JL��11�9J �-'�-��::�• •�:>• ." :'_ - - --- - - r•�-�+w•-.��.-.. �-. ,ram.....-,�,.., •�•�•:�.a,.:.^.•- .:---- _ E � ' s _ ,, ..+ t^ .r r w We .a 's •-n-`� - . i Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach \ r Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 r / 153 415 53 ALFRED DISIENA JR. INGjQ 19854 KINGSWOOD LN p� RPOR4 �F9 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 C.' DISI654 926461016 1395 05/25/95 _ t DISIENA MOVED LEFT NO ADDRESS UNABLE TO FORWARD RETURN TO SENDER cO�NTY LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING uL,9u.,,,,IL.II„Ir,,,rr„,rl„9rr,,,,.,llrl,9,rr,,,lr,991 Connie Brockway,City Clerk :I City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk ;..4 � P.O.Box 190 u;?24 '�,r r L Huntington Beach,CA 92648 AI YO i 1 NtINGT 133 417 06/Gj UJosephC HDtjna_tOT FCUUNTY Ca�� :.: LEGAL NOTICE —PUBLIC HEAR Il�I�„�!�l�Il,:t`t=l�IltEil�sl,;isl�tll�lf�l��iEl�l�I�E=.�I,I! Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach � :` .=.s: =L Li - c�� i�� ,/��. Office of the CityClerk F P.O. Box 190 r RESORT 9� t Huntington.Beach,CA 92648 !1AR31 95 x ;y1 274 ' FIRST Q ASS MAID _ METER- r ,T 4+4 L 1 f' t- o a r 05 2 q + o a i k,•�3 40647. 3 NTINGT Jose;,Luis,Franco OR' 19926•Vetnonl`Ln 1. _"6_9Y0gq're $ CA 92646Hi on' " . �UUNTY LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING 11,1,,,,1,1,il►fill 11111I H111I Connie Brockway,City Clerk . � a ... ....:.. ....... 4.; City of Huntington Beach - ' Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 h' " r , i. 15341536 i. : . 76 pNtINGTp Tames Ear] \'ac- y �O� CORPORq yd 19541 Berkshi" Ln H untinb 01) each;C k.9?646 CppNTY LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach U.S.PGsrAGEjr�. . Office of the City Clerk RESORT P.O. Box 190 " MAR 31 '95 = i Huntington Beach,CA 92648 FIRST CLASS '�,I��}�• �,�a� �a : { I , -�,Eir ,. :. v s 153 415 11 ; S1 Gbaboos Hanidi� ,f INGTpy 9912 Continental Dry - Huntineton Beac:�•� 77 I909 NTY LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING ' ii�l��tltl�ll��el��i�ll�t�tii,( I;II,1,litt;,li;�lltt�i,:{It,ti,:IIIIJtlitt:lf Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach PRESORT ,NGTCN ty j5' U.S.POSTAGEkH`-'+.. Office of the Ci ClerkP.O. Box 190Huntington Beach,CA 92648 r , C9.ASS A �, \ Z` ( lSLTEP � y� y t'.;. 153 406 52 36 Greg&Valerie Viers INGTpy 9731 Adams Ave o�—"IORPOeq,FO J>F9� Huntington Beach CA 92646 VIER731 926464013 IC93 04/03/95 FORWARDING TIME EXPIREDVIERS � y 21542 IMPALA LN 90 OQ HUNTINGTON BEACH C 6-7935 RETURN TOSENDER CpUNTY cps LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING loll 111111111111111111111!!l111111 Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach P...m......e.o..... °,� f.3+�. GTT ii All ,1 u Office of the City Clerk P }r ;/�! SRT 1 P.O.Box 190 x MAR 31 '95 r Huntington Beach,CA 92648 i , S IIAIL ;� ' FIRSa CLAS W.� TERJ i ` 153 415 05 45 ' Clifton R Reed ONT1NGTpy 9880 Continental Dr 1� Q� =NCONPORq rF �F HUn�in� _aton Beach CA 92646 _ - s REED680 926464004 1295 04/03/95 � CD REED 1 MOVED LEFT NO ADDRESS A Q UNABLE TO FORWARD RETURN TO SENDER pUUNTY CP LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING w `� Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 r Huntington Beach,CA 92648 r 15341720/67 ,E "° ` �NTINGTp Ja 97RFRRg7FH4'6'" r'" •` 7 ; ,..�� _Cw �FQ 1Z 1909.E ppUNTY LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING { s { IIE1it.il.IEflt.ifF.ltfltltl..lEilEli.fl:li.i fliili. f Ealll � `"' C Connie Brockway,City Clerk i City of Huntington Beach -•� • ,.�y,;;;;,�,., _ Office of _ s E the City Clerk �'� •' °�„ �' t! ,. �� ,' ;�.. ' P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 1534 17435 :1 ��pHTINGTp?, Rit199Hu646`._ _ y �puNry ca LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING • ' IlEliiiEltlElittElEEirI1tEEIEifEiIEIELf,E,ElliiffillEEEIE;I;i • Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk A P.O.Box 190 '; Huntington Beach,CA 92648 7 1534155 2 92 Herman & L `` ca.Lebovic 19858 Kin vood Ln I NGTpyB Huntin n Beach CA,.9-)646 _ a cpUNTY Ca LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING lilil:l ill l;lilt:il fit Iil11l:1i:Ii11!Ill!ill!HI:it It!I Ill l:ll : Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190. t, �, qd,p.2 t 55 ` l Huntington Beach,CA 92648 't 153 415 46 Q6 i INGTp�, Sendler TseitTin•; p� _N�ORiORq�F d�. 9937 Cornwall 15r HuntinQlnn_Rrarl.rA Q��dF CL� S 77, 1909. \ cpGNTY ca` LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach r _ Office of the City Clerk _ P.O. Box 190 !:,?2* i = Huntington Beach,CA 92648 aE RIy 1 - C Ep i. MOVED LEFT NO ADDRESS 153 417 21 243 INGTp?, Katherine Fay t O� =N�DRPOR4)F �F Po Box 2097 Seal Beach CA 90740 77 ppUNTY cp` LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING, t{ f j j !it IIIIIIftlilfllFFfliillffl,f Ili 3FF3tIIIFIFFIIIfIIIIfflltiffilil! Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach i Office of the City Clerk ! (? P.O.Box 190 i'.: :? - <1 ••'L4 b•) I Huntington Beach,CA 92648 • v p�—�=�N—HO1_1N GfF y {��ntinatnood, �'A 2�1 153 URPOR< Michael Rich rd Cecei R 014 AA :n �riA C Fs 1Z 1909•p LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING t" F 7. .y•• ._�,..—.. __._._.�+.�. -.,i.\�,,.., r_... ..�._..—�— a,.a-,i`.-....+ .'7:.._= N.::.12� s-. ,•Y-'f .t__..•*:� _:t- •rE� — ��- ?:. - .:a._......aY ,l' :i ' Connie Brockway,City Clerk _ �--;;.,;:•.;•. : '.,..,.. City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 �5 s Huntington Beach,CA 92648 153 416 13 y� SANDRA JEAN RADABAUGH 9842 CONTINENTAL DR �pHT NG jpy HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92646 =MtORPOR4/F� RADA842 926461016 1295 03/25/95 RADABAUGH I KENNETH } MOVED LEFT NO ADDRESS 9y @ UNABLE TO FORWARD CF `s Q 1999•'° �c�� RETURN TO SENDER cpUNTY CPS LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING' s,..a+t-a.. Y,,..wsae..Ja 1.. ..ul.n.ra.+..�: ��....,a_......v.y w�... ..m�,a t:.'.a,a•. t ,:�a .., .._ ....� ... .. _.�_ r ._......__., .._....._... ..,... _...,,..._ r, Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 !'':'24 J5 Huntington Beach,CA 92648ro •;j i Qi 4 153 416 13 140 0 \HCONPOgq/F (T/a i George Donald Radabaugh 9842 Continental Dr y Huntington Beach CA RADA642 926461016 1295 03/25/95 Q RADABAUGH I KENNETR j 9 z Z MOVED LEFT NO ADDRESS yC o Q UNABLE TO FORWARD F F�!) l909•" �t�0 RETURN TO SENDER cOpNTY Cps LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING •' IIII oil III III loll IIIIIIII III IIIPIIIIII ! Connie Brockway,City Clerk fie= '` e r; s _ ;' ` City of Huntington Beach / Office of the City Clerk NO 24 ;5 P.O. Box 190 `< j Y Huntington Beach, CA 92648 15340653 ,E t i COR �—;, �NTINGTp J 1993HUN A 92646 7, 190 cF�puNTY cam LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING iil:►I,IIIi;I „ =►1„=ii=:i,l:i�{:iI:mtlli:id:=::IIi _ - '�-v?t,'!.t k b"•y' t ':eJ�-ft�ti�;`4 't,4; �Y' •'c"_�Y.+.'w'S's►.-^F- t � _ c .1 Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk c P.O. Box 190 `= untin - � , ! .t21 c,5 gton Beach, CA 92648 ` ;. . . ]5 3 �]5 7 8 118 GZ�RObcrl.41 & Roicin C Eriksen A�NTINGTp �� T9860 In%-crncss Ln 'Voil OR� Fo �F Hunlinolon Ronch (-•a O-)F,?(. ,~ ERIK860 926461016 1195 03/25/95 9s_w� • ERIKSEN Q MOVED LEFT NO ADDRESS UNABLE TO FORWARD RETURN TO SENDER cpUNTY CP LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEAR NG - �� 111��91L��9�IL�IL911�9�1199911��911�999��1111�9911�991L9�1 !3 f. •rFi FPS%`=!Y/: Connie Brockway,City Clerk ............... City of Huntington Beach sp, �� - Office of the City Clerk - P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 ....._. . -_ 'c .. d �. • ` 15341579 119 INGTp v Linda A Stalford �"ORPOR rF0 �• 19856 Ins STAL856 926461016 1394 03/25/95 FORWARDING TIME EXPIRED Q STALFORD 19621 RODERICK LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-3430• FB,7.1909•� \�O RETURN TO SENDER ppUNT Y cQ� LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING ��IIIII�IIIIIIIII�'III`'IIII'111'lllll'llllll�'I'lll'I111"!111� Y'.•_::��'"•%'•`'�-'.'•-�';�"..--',`A�: F.� Z Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk }' < P.O. Box 190 �+ 24 - luntington Beach,CA 92648 f 153 415 72 pNT I N G Tp DOUGLAS RO SMAN 19882INVE SS O ;"`O"PO HUNTING ON BEACH,CA 92646 il ISO pOUNTY CP LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING t Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O.Box 190 =- Huntington Beach,CA 92648 15341532 7?' Wilson J &M ria A Elder INGTpy � ,� �� 19872 Berks re Ln ~ ' P F Huntington each CA — 46 0 Q A Q `I ppUNTY �P� LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 4} !! ` . li{I!1!IIili�ifi!I!Sli�itiil!liiililiiillll!'.e�iiili!1i��IN , " _ '_ - � � _. . . ....�' •- .. /ate.��r City Clerk 3nrne i Brockway. h i n Beac City of Hunting to Office of the City Clerk _ P.O.Box 190 ton Beach,CA 92 LL .tunting --- \:. 304 155 051 4 Allan F atg 890 Ba�i St `•-A9 6�b COSI2/ c, 2, g2....0NEWipDDRE5S�8l�iS ZI%GT FAINSAO5ENnER GF o *,D �y�Fq NA q-W WI1-SOGA549iba_J556 RPUR4f - �y COSTA MESA , y�F UNtI �P�\ LEGAL NOTICE- PUB �r. Connie Brockway,City Clerk - City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 > J 153 416 50 177 i ��HTINGTpy Vincent A Zamora d Q \MCORPO 19859 CambridQe.Ln_ Hq rFo F�� . 0nnn1. (-A (1'1L AC Li ZAMO859 926464009 IC93 03/27/95 FORWARDING TIME EXPIRED ZAMORA'VINCENT A 19848 CLAREMONT LN :.. HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 9a646-4223 9� QQ RETURN TO SENDER ppUN TY ca` LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING ._.._ ii::►::;t::;l::,�:;isi:�:�:i::�t::t:�:,t:l:l::.:i�ii �::; ;;. , . JNIBd3H onend - 301ION IV931 tilNppp ' .��' �-r- • � /sue=y�c`'•-a=8.. d ', ��:;� � bga•�ld� N-�2.d�INLGr1/»� yp19NI1N�� - , Z� i . 8ti9Z6 d0'yaea8 u016u1lunH Ohl x08 .O.d is i a o aa�I 10�.0 U3 f i.ff0 UaeaB uo36uqunH;o Apo NialO A110'Aumpoig 91uu00 r•. Connie Brockway,City Clerk .:-:,,.> .• City 'of Huntington Beach . ,� : �+ •,• .- -_ _ Office of the City Clerk .P.O. Box 190 TURNED x� Huntington Beach,CA 92648 TosENDER: { F0?w2rciP9 Order Expired :.._, 15341776 77 6 L HUNTINGTON CONTINENTAL, f O�NT I NGTpy 17821 17TH STREET#270 O� `ptORPORfl/FG dF9 TUSTIN, CA 92680 LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 :' '• :4 .;', ?r., ,' f! ; . Huntington Beach,CA 92648 • 1 .J� T51 46107 a' ` ?,HSI-HSIANG LEE NT I N G ' 9782 OLYWIC DR, th. �}VVV �• +( �0 Tpy�Q 1 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 " ..�: •' ` S .! IS F�puNry cap - PUBLIC HEARING LEGAL NOTICE .-._-_ -%:• :_ {ii.!?!li!!!i!. I!:I!?�i!!ii!:�i!l,::!!! .i!!:! .. Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 E Huntington Beach,CA 92648 ; L v 153 416 32 159 Judith A Bailey 1r 9863 Cornwall Dr INGT°y Huntington Beach CA 92646 0�-\hGORPORAfF� �(fA� C7 � y BAIL863 926464009 1594 03/27/95 s*r— ` BAILEYMOVED LEFT NO ADDRESS 9� Ff. �o.. OQ UNABLE TO FORWARD �,►�, e 1�190S. �� RETURN TO SENDER BOUNTY CP` LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 1 IIII111111oil Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 uE T �; �•: " ! �:j "' Huntington Beach,CA 92648 ORS : a. 153 416 64 191 Karen Lasagna �pNTINGT° 4110 Apricot Dr Irvine CA 92720 Q� °OaNTY LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Ilil!!!il!Ili!!1i41!III!i!1'!!I!'!!III i.!!!I!41!flllll!!EI!!!II Connie Brockway,City Clerk d City of Huntington Beach =o'Office of the City Clerk .: P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 `'i 1 " i - _ ..•.sir .. .. ! *� I 1.`. 153 417 37 259 PERRY REZVAN - 9778 CHARIN •C'R�OSS DR w �NTINGTp HUNTINGTOU A 92646 C !B 17.1909.�� OQ ' FCppNTY �P`\. LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING ' il,i,�,�I,I�ii„�(1,1�(i�„I,.I►1i1(„(i,�1((1i��11i1111,i1�,1 - CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH REQUEST FOR LEGAL SERVICES RLS No. S_ 0Fr Gail Hutton, City Attorney Assn To l�L-- Date Date Request :mgde by Telephone D artment adz u�� s'S�4 C/e r. INSTRUCTIONS: File request in the City Attorney's Office. Outline reasons for this request and state facts necessary for City Attorney to respond. Please attach all pertinent information and exhibits. TYPE OF LEGAL SERVICES REQUESTED: [ 1 Ordinance [ 1 Opinion [ ) Stop Notice [ ] Resolution [ ] Lease [ ] Bond ' Meeting [ ] Contract/Agreement ] Deed C e �° r I [ ] Court Appearance [ ] Insurance Other u� iL Awlll Is Request for Preparation of Contract form attache a? [ ] Yes [ ] No Are exhibits attached? f I Yes I No If for Council a tion, If not for Council action, Signature of Department Head Agenda deadline � 3h,:3, desired completion date _ Council Meeting V "4- r- COMMENTS: Routing: i ' I La jiZP/r�o GCH S Pry � PDA / JCB AJF SL ADL TM WBS RCS WSA 95-080 i This Request for Legal Services has been assigned to attorney A R T D E L A L 0 Z A 2/16/9 5 telephone extension 561 0 His/her secretary is ,loan 11 _ . extension r.5 d 0 Keep the goldenrod copy for your files. Please reference the above RLS number for inquiries. Notes Filename Date completed: WP No. RCS 2/28/92 Rev. I MINUTES CITY COUNCIUREDEVELOPMENT AGENCY Room B-8, Civic Center Huntington Beach, California Monday, April 4, 1994 Mayor Moulton-Patterson called the regular meetings of the City Council and the Redevelopment Agency of the City of Huntington Beach to order at 5:00 p.m. CITY COUNCIL/REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY ROLL CALL PRESENT: Silva,-Bauer, Moulton-Patterson,Winchell, Leipzig, Sullivan ABSENT: Robitaille(arrived 7:00 p.m.) STUDY SESSION -OCEAN VIEW SCHOOL DISTRICT VACANT SCHOOL SITES USE OPTIONS (650.20) The City Clerk presented a memorandum from the City Administrator dated March 24, 1994 entitled Council Study Session Regarding Ocean View School District Vacant School Sites Use Options. The Assistant City Administrator presented a staff report using slides regarding recommendations for the following vacant school sites: Crest View, Rancho View, Park View, Pleasant View, Glen View, Robinwood, Haven View, Meadow View and Lark View. Jim Lamb, Business Development Project Manager, reported on retail uses of vacant school sites. Jim Engle, Deputy Director Beach Recreation and Development, reported on park uses of vacant school sites. Discussion was held by Council and staff regarding the Master Facility Use Agreement, vacant school sites as open space, and the need for public input regarding use of the sites. Ron Hagan, Community Services Director, responded to questions from Council. Request for Continuance of Public Hearing -Special Sign Permit No. 93-13-Superior Electrical Advedising. Incorporated -45 Foot High Pylon Sign -9891 Adams Avenue-Northwest Corner Brookhurst Street (420.35) The City Administrator announced that a request for continuance to April 18, 1994 was received from the applicant through their representative Richard Harlow. CLOSED ESSION The Mayor called a Closed Session of the City Council pursuant to Government Code Section 54957.6 to meet with its designated representative Daniel Cassidy regarding Labor Relations Matters-Meet and Confer . -Concerning the following employee organizations: Municipal Employees Organization (MEO), Municipal Employees Association (MEA), Huntington Beach Fireman's Association (HBFA), Police Officers Association (POA), and Marine Safety Officers Association (MSOA). (120.80) 104 Page 2-Council/Agency Minutes -04/04/94 The Mayor called a Closed Session of the City Council pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9(a)to confer with its attorney regarding pending litigation- Kathleen Hancock v. the city -OCSCC 701877. (120.80) The Mayor called a Closed Session of the City Council pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.8 to give instructions to its negotiator, Donald L. Watson, City Treasurer, regarding negotiations with Metro Display/Target Media and Shelter Vision for property located throughout the city on Orange County Transit Authority bus routes. The payment terms and amount of payment on lease will be discussed. (120.80) RECESS -RECONVENE The Mayor called a recess of Council at 5:45 p.m. The meeting was reconvened at 6:25 p.m. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE The Pledge of Allegiance was led by the Mayor. COUN IL/AGENCY ROLL CALL PRESENT: Silva, Bauer, Robitaille, Moulton-Patterson, Winchell, Leipzig, Sullivan ABSENT: None PRESENTATION -CERTIFICATE OF RECOGNITION -71ST WEDDING ANNIVERSARY The Mayor presented a Certificate of Recognition to Mr. and Mrs. (Tom) Koichi Nerio in celebration of their 71 st Wedding Anniversary and their contributions to the community. Their son, Dick Nerio, addressed the City Council and audience and thanked the city for the years his family has enjoyed living here and many years to come. A photograph of Mr. and Mrs. Nerio and other family members present was taken. PRESENTATION -$15,000 CHECK-HUNTINGTON BEACH SMALL BUSINESS ASSISTANCE CENTER Robin L. Tole, Division Public Affairs Manager for General Telephone and Electric, presented a check for $15,000 to Joyce Riddell, President, Huntington Beach Chamber of Commerce, to fund the second year's operation of the Huntington Beach Small Business Assistance Center. PRESE TATION -CERTIFICATE OF APPRECIATION -ORANGE COUNTY TOBACCO USE PREVENTION.COALITION Marilyn Cowan presented a Certificate of Appreciation to Mayor Linda Moulton-Patterson and City Council from the Orange County Tobacco Use Prevention Coalition to acknowledge their work in passing No Smoking Ordinances in the City of Huntington Beach. IL 05. Page 3 -Council/Agency Minutes -04/04/94 INTRODUCTION -STUDENTS -SISTER CITY WAITAKERE. NEW ZEALAND Sharon Simiona, Sister City Association representative, introduced two students, Shannon Cuthrie, 14 years of age, and Fiona Spittles, 15 years of age, from our Sister City Waitakere to the Mayor and City Council. She read a letter from the Mayor of Waitakere and presented a photograph of Kere Kere Beach in New Zealand to the Mayor. . PROCLAMATION -MONTH OF APRIL-HOMEBUYER EDUCATION MONTH -HUNTINGTON BEACH- FOUNTAIN VALLEY BOARD OF REALTORS The Mayor presented a proclamation to Barry Bussiere, Huntington Beach-Fountain Valley Board of Realtors proclaiming April, 1994, as Homebuyer Education Month. (City Council)CONTINUED FROM MARCH 7. 1994-MODIFICATION TO CITY CLASSIFICATION PLAN - ART CENTER CLASSIFICATIONS-RESOLUTION NO.6554-ADOPTED AS AMENDED (700.10) The City Clerk presented Resolution No. 6554 for Council adoption-"A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH TO AMEND THE CITY CLASSIFICATION PLAN." (Adds new classifications: Art Education Coordinator, Exhibition Coordinator, Preparator, Cultural Services Aide.) Discussion was held by Council and staff. Councilmember Bauer requested Gerald Chapman to speak. Gerald Chapman, Art Center Foundation representative, stated that the original partnership between the Art Center Foundation and the city provided for the Foundation to raise funds to renovate the building and the city to supply funding for operate of the Art Center. He requested a Memorandum of Understanding between the Art Center Foundation and the city. A motion was made by Leipzig, seconded by Sullivan, to adopt Resolution No. 6554 as amended to direct staff to inform the employees that the normal six month probationary period will be extended to twelve months in order for the city to determine the funding situation and that the matter be returned in ten months to determine if funding is being generated. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Silva, Bauer, Robitaille, Moulton-Patterson, Winchell, Leipzig, Sullivan NOES: None ABSENT: None (City Council/RedeveloRment Agency) CONTINUED FROM MARCH 7. 1994-AGREEMENT-ROBERT BEIN,WILLIAM FROST AND ASSOCIATES -MCFADDEN BRIDGE WIDENING OVER INTERSTATE 405 -CC-813 -APPROVED (600.10) The City Clerk presented.a communication from the City Administrator requesting authorization to proceed with the hiring of a consultant to prepare environmental documents and provide engineering services for the McFadden Avenue Bridge over Interstate 405. Councilmember Leipzig stated that he had removed the item from the agenda at the last meeting and that staff had provided material in the Council packet to answer his questions. Q 6i • Page 4-Council/Agency Minutes-04/04/94 A motion was made by Leipzig, seconded by Bauer, to approve selection of Robert Bein, William Frost(RBF) and Associates of Irvine, Professional Engineers, Planners and Surveyors, to prepare environmental documents and engineering services for the McFadden Avenue Bridge over Interstate 405, approve an amendment to the current year's redevelopment budget to appropriate$82,000 for consulting, environmental, engineering services and document reproduction expenditures and approve and authorize execution of a Professional Services Contract between the city and Robert Bein, William Frost and Associates for environmental and engineering services regarding the McFadden Avenue Bridge widening over Interstate 405 and authorize the Director of Public Works to expend$82,000 to cover contract costs of$79,000 and $3,000 for anticipated document reproduction expenditures. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Silva, Bauer, Robitaille, Moulton-Patterson,Winchell, Leipzig, Sullivan NOES: None ABSENT: None (City Cecil) CONTINUED FROM MARCH 7, 1994-ACQUISITION OF PARCEL FOR INCLUSION IN HUNTINGTON CENTRAL PARK PER HOLLY SEACLIFF DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT-NORTHEAST CORNER EDWARDS/ELLIS-APPROVED (696-%)(v3o•40 The City Clerk presented a communication from the City Administrator regarding acquisition of a parcel for inclusion in Huntington Central Park. The City Administrator stated that the obligation of Seacliff Partners to clean up any contaminates on the site is included in the Development Agreement and this is just a clarification of that requirement. A motion was made by Winchell, seconded by Leipzig, to direct staff to acquire the 4.5 acre Parcel 7b (AP No. 110-151-15 and 16) located on the northeast corner of Edwards Street and Ellis Avenue, to direct staff to prepare an amendment to the Holly-Seacliff Development Agreement No. 90-1 to provide that upon termination of the existing oil and gas operation on Parcel 7b, Seacliff Partners will abandon all wells on the property and remediate any on-site contaminated soil in accordance with city and state cleanup standards and direct staff to prepare a grant deed for Parcel 7b for Council acceptance. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Silva, Bauer, Robitaille, Moulton-Patterson, Winchell, Leipzig, Sullivan NOES: None ABSENT: None (City Council) CONTINUED FROM MARCH 7, 1994-AMENDMENT NO, 1 TO AGREEMENT- BOYLE ENGINE RING CORPORAT1ON -WATER SYSTEM MASTER PLAN AND FINANCING PLAN - APPROVED (600.10) The City Clerk presented a communication from the City Administrator regarding Amendment No. 1 to the Agreement between the city and Boyle Engineering Corporation for preparation of the Huntington Beach Water System Master Plan and Financing Plan update. Councilmember Bauer spoke regarding the Water Task Force, status report, capital requirements, financing mechanisms, water pressure, and water supply. Page 5-Council/Agency Minutes-04/04/94 A motion was made by Bauer, seconded by Robitaille, to approve and authorize execution of Amendment No. 1 to the Agreement between the city and Boyle Engineering Corporation for preparation of the Huntington Beach Water System Master Plan and Financing Plan update and authorize expenditure of an amount not to exceed $31,900 to fund the Water Master Plan and Financing Plan Update Contract Amendment No. 1. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Silva, Bauer, Robitaille, Moulton-Patterson,Winchell, Leipzig, Sullivan NOES: None ABSENT: None (City Council) CONTINUED FROM MARCH 7. 1994-SEAPOINT AVENUE EXTENSION STUDY- CONTINUED TO MAY 2, 1994-STAFF REPORT REQUESTED (800.60) The City Clerk presented a communication from the Public Works Director, Police Chief and Fire Chief transmitting a preliminary study of the impacts of eliminating the previously approved extension of Seapoint Avenue from Palm Avenue to Pacific Coast Highway. The Public Works Director presented a staff'report in support of completing the extension of Seapoint Avenue for Police and Fire Department requirements. Jim Otterson, Traffic Engineer, presented a staff report on the County Master Plan. Mike Dolder, Fire Chief, presented a staff report relating to Fire response times, the three mile detour around the area, second public exit requirement and modification to Holly-Seacliff agreement. Ron Lowenberg, Police Chief, presented a staff report relating to Police lowered response time, the three mile detour around the area and additional escape route in case of a natural disaster. The City Clerk announced two communications received from Jan Vandersloot and Robert Winchell, Huntington Beach Tomorrow, in opposition to the extension of Seapoint Avenue. . Councilmember Sullivan requested Mr. DeLorm to speak. Al De L r , Seacliff on the Green Homeowners President, spoke in opposition to the extension of Seapoint Avenue to Pacific Coast Highway and in support of an alternative to have a private road for emergency vehicles, bicycle and pedestrian traffic only. The Fire Chief responded to Councilmember Winchell's questions regarding two public safety access and ingress points in the Ocean Crest Development. The City Administrator reported. Discussion was held by Council and staff regarding additional aspects of the proposal. Councilmember Bauer requested a staff report regarding capital improvement requirements, financing mechanisms, and an interim report of the Water Task Force. 108 . Page 6-Council/Agency Minutes -04/04/94 A motion was made by Bauer, seconded by Moulton-Patterson, to direct staff to review aspects of the contractual obligations if Seapoint Avenue is not extended as an arterial street, prepare a report on a limited access road and continue the extension of Seapoint Avenue to May 2, 1994. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Robitaille, Moulton-Patterson, Winchell, Leipzig, Sullivan NOES: Silva, Robitaille ABSENT: None (Redevelopment Agency) DEFERRED FROM JANUARY 18. 1994-IN-LIEU PARKING FEE PROGRAM IMPLEMENTING RESOLUTION -AGENCY RESOLUTION NO, 253-DOWNTOWN SPECIFIC PLAN AREA -MAIN PIER REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA -ADOPTED (340.20) The City Clerk presented Agency Resolution No.253-"A RESOLUTION OF THE REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH ADOPTING AN IMPLEMENTATION PLAN FOR THE ESTABLISHED IN-LIEU FEE FOR PARKING." (Adopts the implementing measures for the In-lieu Parking Fee program within the Downtown Specific Plan Area within the Main-Pier Redevelopment Project Area.) The Economic Development Director presented a staff report using slides regarding the In-Lieu Parking Program. A motion was made by Leipzig, seconded by Winchell, to adopt Agency Resolution No. 253. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Silva, Bauer, Moulton-Patterson, Winchell, Leipzig, Sullivan NOES: None ABSENT: Robitaille (out of room) (Redevelopment Agency/City Council) CONTINUED FROM MARCH 7, 1994-LOAN AGREEMENT- ASSOCIATES NINE -725-733 UTICA AVENUE-AGENCY RESOLUTION NO. 255-COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 6579 -ADOPTED (600.10) The City Clerk presented Agency Resolution No. 255 for Agency adoption-"A RESOLUTION OF THE REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH APPROVING AN AFFORDABLE HOUSING AGREEMENT BY AND BETWEEN THE REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH AND ASSOCIATES NINE." (Approves and authorizes execution of a loan agreement between the Redevelopment Agency of the City of Huntington Beach and Associates Nine, a California general partnership, calling for the expenditure of no more than $546,000 in housing set aside funds in exchange for thirty-six units of affordable housing for households earning below 60% of the Orange County median income, for a period of thirty years.)and Council Resolution No.6579 for Council adoption -"A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH APPROVING AN AFFORDABLE HOUSING AGREEMENT BY AND BETWEEN THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH AND ASSOCIATES NINE." (Approves and authorizes execution of a loan agreement between the City of Huntington Beach and Associates Nine, a California general partnership, calling for the expenditure of no more than $546,000 in housing set aside funds in exchange for thirty-six units of affordable housing for households earning below 60% of the Orange County median income, for a period of thirty years.) Greg Brown, Special Projects Development Specialist, presented a staff report using slides of the property to be rehabilitated and responded to Council questions. 109 . Page 7-Council/Agency Minutes -04/04/94 At the request of Councilmember Silva, Kenneth Reynolds, representative of Associates None, responded to questions by Council. A communication from Mr. Reynolds dated March 11, 1994 has been provided in the Council packets. A motion was made by Sullivan, seconded by Silva, to adopt Agency Resolution No.255 and Council Resolution No. 6579. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Silva, Bauer, Robitaille, Moulton-Patterson, Winchell, Leipzig, Sullivan NOES: None ABSENT: None (City Council) CONTINUED FROM MARCH 7. 1994-STATUS OF HUNTINGTON CENTRAL PARK MASTER PLAN AND THE YOUTH SPORTS COMPLEX PROJECT (920.20) The City Clerk presented a communication from the Community Services Director regarding an update on the status of Huntington Central Park Master Plan and Youth Sports Complex. The Community Services Director presented a staff report. Discussion was held by Council and staff regarding playing fields, site mitigation problems, and other possible sites for a Youth Sports Complex. The Council by consensus directed the report on the status of the Huntington Central Park Master Plan and Youth Sports Complex received and filed. Continued from March 7. 1994-Possible Purchase of Street Lights -Staff Report Requested (800.10) Councilmember Bauer requested a staff report on the possibility of purchasing the street lights. Continued from March 7. 1994-Investigation of Low Flush Toilet Water Program in Orange County - Staff Report Requested (1000.90) Councilmember Bauer spoke regarding a low flush toilet water program he recently read about in the newspaper. Jeff Renna, Water Operations Manager, reported on the program instituted by the Municipal Water District and the Apartment Owners Association of Orange County. Councilmember Bauer requested a staff report regarding the program savings. Continued from March 7. 1994-Trash Bin Requirements for Commercial Sites -Staff Report Requested on Existing Law and Enforcement (810.20) Councilmember Bauer requested a staff report on the existing law and enforcement of trash bin requirements for commercial sites. I10 Page 8 -Council/Agency Minutes -04/04/94 Continued from March 7. 1994-Youth Board -Community Forum -Request for Staff to Arrange Meeting (110.10) The City Clerk presented a communication from Councilmember Silva recommending that Council ask the Youth Board to host a community forum to gain input and brainstorm ways to resolve the conflict between having a place for kids in the downtown area and making the downtown businesses viable at night. A motion was made by Silva, seconded by Sullivan, to request staff to arrange a meeting with the Youth Board, School District representatives and No On Drugs in School (NODS) program representatives, to meet at City Hall for the purpose of conducting a community forum to gain input and brainstorm ways to resolve the conflict between having a place for kids in the downtown area and making the downtown businesses viable at night. The motion carried by the.following roll call vote: AYES: Silva, Bauer, Robitaille, Moulton-Patterson,Winchell, Leipzig, Sullivan NOES: None ABSENT: None Continued from March 7. 1994-Parking Ordinance-Parking Lot Meter Hours -North of Goldenwest on Pacific Coast Highway-Staff Requested to Prepare Amendment to Parking Ordinance (120.90) The City Clerk presented a communication from Councilmember Silva requesting Council to consider directing the City Attorney to prepare an ordinance amendment to change the meter hours from 5 a.m. to dusk to 8 a.m. to dusk to relieve parking congestion in the residential neighborhood adjacent to Goldenwest and Twenty-Second Streets for the early morning surfing crowd, plus it would benefit surfers who don't use the beach all day, but only surf in the morning before work or school A motion was made by Silva, seconded by Sullivan, to direct staff to prepare an amendment to the ordinance code to change the meter hours in the residential neighborhood adjacent to Goldenwest and Twenty-Second Streets from 5 a.m. to dusk to 8 a.m. to dusk. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Silva, Bauer, Robitaille, Moulton-Patterson, Winchell, Leipzig, Sullivan NOES: None ABSENT: None Continued from March 7, 1994-Request to Re-Configure the City Council Sign Ordinance Committee -Approved (110.20) A motion was made by Sullivan, seconded by Leipzig, to request re-configuration of the Council Sign Ordinance committee to add one member from each of the following groups: Huntington Beach Chamber of Commerce, Uptown Business Committee, Huntington Beach Tomorrow and Huntington Beach-Fountain Valley Board of Realtors with each group to select a representative of their organization for Council approval. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Silva, Bauer, Robitaille, Moulton-Patterson, Winchell, Leipzig, Sullivan NOES: None ABSENT: None 111 Page 9-Council/Agency Minutes-04/04/94 Staff Report Requested -Service Station Restroom Policy Councilmember Robitaille requested a staff report on state laws, county ordinances and major service station policy relating to removed restrooms, air and water hoses and the need for English speaking personnel. He requested staff to check with the major providers to determine if they have a corporate policy in local service stations. Staff Report Requested-Parking Requirement for City Parks Councilmember Robitaille requested a staff report regarding parking requirements for city parks and the impact on residential streets. He stated the need for additional parking at Huntington Central Park and others such as Central City Park on Goldenwest Street and Slater Avenue. He stated that a parking plan is needed in these areas. Discussion Held Regarding Options for Continued of Meetings Mayor Moulton-Patterson spoke regarding the number of people signed up for public comments for the meeting and options for continued meetings at a later date. The City Administrator stated that the options for continued meetings will be put on a future agenda for Council action. (City Council)PUBLIC HEARING -APPEAL BY COUNCILMEMBER BAUER OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT NO,93-28 AND CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO 94-3-PHASE IA OF THE BOLSA CHICA REGIONAL PARK-ORANGE COUNTY ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT AGENCY, HARBORS, BEACHES AND PARKS DIVISION - CONTINUED TO MAY 2, 1994-COUNCIL COMMITTEE FORMED (420.80) The Mayor announced that this was the day and hour set for a public hearing to consider the following appeal: APPLICATION NUMBER: Coastal Development Permit No. 93-28 and Conditional Use Permit No. 94-3. PA PLICANT: Orange County Environmental Management Agency, Harbor, Beaches and Parks Division, 300 N. Flower Street, 4th Floor, P. O. Box 4048, Santa Ana, CA 92702-4048 DATE ACCEPTED: December 6, 1993 APPELLANT: Councilman Ralph Bauer, City of Huntington Beach LOQATION: 5801 Seapoint Avenue ZONE: Multiple: CC-CZ(Conservation-Coastal Zone) and ROS-O-CZ(Recreational Open Space-Oil- Coastal Zone) REQUEST: Review and approval of the general design plans for Phase 1A of the Bolsa Chica Regional Park. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: The project is covered by Final Environmental Impact Report No. 521 (FEIR No. 521)for the Bolsa Chica Regional Park, prepared by the County of Orange, recommended for certification by the Huntington Beach City Council on October 19, 1992 and Certified by the Board of Supervisors in November, 1992. Page 10-Council/Agency Minutes-04/04/94 COASTAL STATUS: This project is in the appealable portion of the coastal zone. Under the provisions of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, the action taken by the City Council is final. However, approval of the Coastal Development Permit is appealable to the Coastal Commission pursuant to Public Resources Code, Section 30603. A denial of the Coastal Development Permit may be appealed (Section 13319, Title 14, California Administrative Code)only if the City has approved a development on the basis of local land use regulations but has denied the issuance of a coastal development permit because it cannot make the findings required by Section 13311, Title 14 of the California Administrative Code. Pursuant to Public Resources Code, Section 30603, an appeal by an aggrieved person must be filed in writing within ten ; 0)working days, and addressed to: California Coastal Commission, 245 W. Broadway, Suite 380, P.O. Box 1450, Long Beach, CA 90810-1450 (310)590-5071. There is no appeal fee. The appeal period begins when the Commission receives a notice of the City Council action and continues for ten (10)working days. Applicants will be notified by the Coastal Commission as to the date of the conclusion of the Commission's review period, and as to whether or not an appeal has been filed. Applicants are advised not to begin construction prior to that date. A communication from Amigos de Bolsa Chica was distributed to Council in support of the appeal. The City Clerk announced communcations received and distributed to Council from Barry Ellerbroek, Chairman-Elect Board of Directors, Huntington Beach Chamber of Commerce, dated March 31, 1994 in support, Robert Winchell, Board of Directors, Huntington Beach Tomorrow, dated April 2, 1994 in support, Edmund and Jennie Sakowiz dated April 1, 1994 regarding Linear Park, and Chuck Nelson, Amigos de Bolsa Chica, dated April 4, 1994 in support of the Linear Park. She stated that copies are available for the public pursuant to the Brown Act. A motion was made by Bauer, seconded by Leipzig, to open the public hearing, form a three member Council Committee to address aspects of the Linear Park and continue the public hearing open to May 2, 1994. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Silva, Bauer, Robitaille, Moulton-Patterson, Winche►I, Leipzig, Sullivan NOES: None ABSENT: None Councilmembers Bauer, Leipzig and Moulton-Patterson volunteered to serve on the committee. PUBLIC COMMENTS Jay Murley spoke in opposition to the parking situation in the downtown area. He stated that there are many parking meter violations and recommended an urban parking control to enforce parking laws. William Mello spoke in opposition to pension"spiking"and read from the Orange County Employees Retirement System Book and Resolution No. 6273- 1991 Memorandum of Understanding. He urged Council to stop future pension "spiking". John Merzweiler spoke regarding the need to increase the number of Police Officers in the downtown area. He reported an ongoing crime problem in the downtown area. George Arnold reported complaints that he has registered with no response from the city. He stated that the sign for the Pacific Cafe is in violation of the sign ordinance. He reported that a liquor store leaves trash on the tables and has no trash receptacle. He reported that a restaurant in the second block of Main Street has tables on the sidewalk without permission from the city. He stated that there are no toilets north of the pier 113 and no restaurants on the pier. Page 11 -Council/Agency Minutes-04/04/94 Debbie Cook spoke in opposition to the Agenda Item relative to conveyance of property to the Huntington Beach School District from Seacliff Partners. She spoke in opposition to what she believed to be special treatment given to the Huntington Beach Company and requested that this item be denied. She requested that Council re-read the legal opinion provided to Council on the subject. She stated that letters were distributed to Council prior to the meeting. Barbara Kimbrouah spoke in opposition to Agency Resolution No. 255 and Council Resolution No. 6579 regarding a loan agreement with Associates Nine for the property located at 725-733 Utica Avenue. She stated that the city should not reward non-productive developers. She spoke in support of enforcement of city codes and questioned why the city had not enforced the code in the past. Ms. Kimbrough referred to a recent Los Angeles Times article. Gerald Chapman spoke in opposition to the Agenda Item regarding conveyance of property to the Huntington Beach School District from Seacliff Partners. He spoke in opposition to what he believed was illegal grading and filling of the site. He stated that the homeowners in the area are willing to meet and discuss the problems on the site and requested continuance of this item to allow for further negotiations. Byron Chilleme spoke in opposition to the Agenda Item regarding conveyance of property to the Huntington Beach School District from Seacliff Partners. He stated that he believes the common areas will not be completed if conveyance of the property is allowed prior to their completion. Anna Warner spoke in opposition to the city trash fee. She requested that a new system be instituted that would base trash fees on the number of people in the household or the amount of trash per household. Gerald Catering spoke in opposition to the number of bars in the downtown area, the shooting last weekend, the parking problem, proposed In-Lieu parking fees and requested the Council end subsidies to downtown parking. Carrie Thomas spoke in opposition to the Agenda Item regarding the conveyance of property to the Huntington Beach School District from Seacliff Partners. She read from a letter written by a neighbor to the Planning Commission dated December 21. She urged Council to require all improvements to be constructed prior to the sale of any units. She stated she owns a lot the Ellis/Goldenwest area and the developer was to install equestrian trails and a stable but those improvements were never completed. Jerry Buchanan, Huntington Beach City School District representative, spoke in support of the Agenda Item regarding the conveyance of property to the Huntington Beach School District from Seacliff Partners. He stated that the School District and Seacliff Partners have been in negotiations since February, 1992 and the school district is committed to the planned trails. Don Guillaume spoke in opposition to the extension of Seapoint Avenue to Pacific Coast Highway and the increase in traffic it would cause. He requested Council to study all the problems of extending Seapoint Avenue to Pacific Coast Highway prior to making a decision. I4m Zanic, Seacliff Partners Representative, spoke in support of Agenda Item E-9 regarding the conveyance of property to the Huntington Beach School District from Seacliff Partners. He stated that the equestrian trails will be completed, Seacliff Partners has agreed to maintain the trails and to accept liability. 11:4 • • Page 12-Council/Agency Minutes-04/04/94 (City Council) CONVEYANCE OF 8.863 ACRES OF PROPERTY TO THE HUNTINGTON BEACH SCHOOL DISTRICT FROM SEACLIFF PARTNERS -HOLLY SEACLIFF DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT- CONTINUED TO MAY 2. 1994-COUNCIL COMMITTEE TO MEET WITH SEACLIFF PARTNERS AND HOMEOWNERS (600.10) The City Clerk presented a communication from the City Administrator dated April 4, 1994 regarding conveyance of 8.863 acres of property to the Huntington Beach City School District from Seacliff Partners. The City Clerk announced a communication received from Debbie Cook dated April 3, 1994 in opposition to a legal opinion from the City Attorney and distributed to Council. She stated that copies are available for the public pursuant to the Brown Act. Council Committee Formed to Study the Conveyance of Proper to the Huntington Beach School District from Seacliff Partners Councilmember Sullivan suggested that a meeting be held between Seacliff Partners, the city and interested residents. He volunteered to serve on the Council Committee. Staff Report Requested City Grading Policy-Holly-Seacliff Development Area Councilmember Leipzig requested a staff report on violations of the city grading policy on the site. A motion was made by Sullivan, seconded by Bauer, to continue the request by Seacliff Partners to transfer 8.863 acres of property located within the boundary of the Holly Seacliff Development Agreement to the Huntington Beach City School District to May 2, 1994 and schedule a Council Committee to meet with Seacliff Partners and Homeowners. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Silva, Bauer, Robitaille, Moulton-Patterson, Wnchell, Leipzig, Sullivan NOES: None ABSENT: None (City Council) PUBLIC HEARING -APPEAL BY COUNCILMEMBER ROBITAILLE OF PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO, 93-13 -SUPERIOR ELECTRICAL ADVERTISING. INCORPORATED-45 FOOT HIGH PYLON SIGN -9891 ADAMS AVENUE NORTHWEST CORNER BROOKHURST STREET-CONTINUED OPEN TO APRIL 3. 1995 (420.35) The Mayor announced that this was the day and hour set for a public hearing to consider the following appeal: APPLICATION NUMBER: Appeal of the Planning Commission's denial of Special Sign Permit No. 93-13. APPLICANT: Superior Electrical Advertising, Incorporated APPELLANT: Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue (northwest corner at Brookhurst Street) ZONE: C2-FP2 (Community Business District-Flood plain) 115. Page 13-Council/Agency Minutes-04/04/94 REVISED REQUEST: To permit an existing, non-conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot double pole pylon sign to remain in its present location and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini and Lucas Jewelers, in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15315, Class 15 of the California Environmental Quality Act. COASTAL STATUS: Not applicable The Mayor opened the public hearing. The City Administrator stated that a request was received from the applicant to continue the public hearing to April 18, 1994. Motion to Continue Special Sign Permit No.93-13 to April 18, 1994 A motion was made by Moulton-Patterson, seconded by Leipzig, to continue the public hearing on Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 to April 18, 1994. Amendment to Motion -To Continue for One Year Councilmember Leipzig requested an amendment to the motion to continue Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 for one year until the Sign Committee returns to Council with their recommendations. Motion Withdrawn Mayor Moulton-Patterson withdrew her motion. Special Sign Permit No.93-13 Continued to April 3. 1995 A motion was made by Leipzig, seconded by Sullivan, to continue the appeal relating to Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 to approximately the first meeting in April, 1995 after the Sign Committee returns to Council with their recommendations. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Silva, Bauer, Moulton-Patterson, Winchell, Leipzig, Sullivan NOES: None ABSENT: Robitaille Establish Meeting Date for Special Sign Permit No.93-11 -17422-17438 BEACH BOULEVARD The City Clerk reported that unlike the aforementioned appeal, Council at their March 7, 1994 had continued the hearing on Special Sign Permit No. 93-11 to March 7, 1995 and that there is no Council meeting on March 7, 1995. Councilmember Winchell stated that Special Sign Permit No. 93-11 should be placed on a future agenda to enable Council to continue the hearing to a definite Council meeting. Page 14-Council/Agency Minutes -04/04/94 Public Employees Retirement System (PERS)-Council Committee Report Councilmember Sullivan reported on the status of the PERS Council Committee and stated that questions have been submitted to the law firm of Liebert, Cassidy and Frierson and the Committee will be meeting with Liebert, Cassidy and Frierson next week. (City Council) PUBLIC HEARING-CONTINUED OPEN FROM MARCH 7, 1994-CODE AMENDMENT NO. 92-5-DOWNTOWN SPECIFIC PLAN CODE AMENDMENT-VILLAGE CONCEPT AND DOWNTOWN MASTERPARKING (450.30) The Mayor announced that this was the day and hour set for a public hearing to consider the following: APPLICATION NUMBER: Code Amendment No. 92-5-Downtown Specific Plan Code Amendment-Village Concept and Downtown Parking Master Plan APPLICANT: City of Huntington Beach LOCATION: An area bounded by Golden West Street, Pacific Coast Highway, Beach Boulevard ZONE: Downtown Specific Plan REQUEST: To amend the Downtown Specific Plan for the purpose of scaling down development standards, creating three planning nodes, establishing affordable housing standards and a comprehensive parking management plan. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Covered by the Downtown Specific Plan Environmental Impact Report. COASTAL STATUS: Local Coastal Plan Amendment The Planning Director presented a staff report. The Mayor opened the public hearing. The City Clerk announced communications received and distributed to Council from Joyce Riddell, Chamber of Commerce President dated April 1, 1994 in support of the shared parking concept for the downtown area, Michael Tater dated March 7, 1994 in opposition to district boundary changes, Brian James, Assistant Planner, Village Concept Presentation packet, and David Redford, Apartment Association of Orange County Vice.President, dated April 4, 1994 requesting that the Downtown Specific Plan be continued. She stated that copies are available for the public pursuant to the Brown Act. John Peranteau, Supervisor Sav More Oil Company for twenty-three years, spoke in support of a proposed project by Nazmi Ali for a mini-market and gas station on Pacific Coast Highway. He stated that the project will increase-sales, increase revenue and create new jobs. He stated that drawings of the project were delivered to Council on March 28. Nazmi Ali, property owner, spoke in support of the rezoning of five lots at Seventh Street and Pacific Coast Highway from residential to commercial and stated that he would like to put a gas station and mini-market on the site. George Arnold spoke in opposition to frequent changes of the Downtown Master Plan by different City Councils. He also stated that there is not enough police protection in the downtown area. i.l 7 Page 15-Council/Agency Minutes-04/04/94 Bob Bolen spoke in opposition to changes in the Downtown Specific Plan relating to building heights, space between floors, and parking requirements for the existing buildings. He requested that Council approve five feet between floors and sixty foot building heights. He distributed a communication to Council. Mark Porter spoke regarding density reductions in the proposed Downtown Specific Plan, restriction of restaurant uses and equal treatment for all blocks on Main Street. He stated concerns relative to District Nos. Seven and Eight. The Planning Director reported on the Planning Commission's action on District Nos. Seven, Eight, Nine, Ten and Eleven. Tony Ursino spoke in opposition to the proposed density reductions in the Downtown Specific Plan. He stated that this density reduction would interfere with the development, refinancing and sale of property in the area. He requested that Council incorporate language from the Apartment Association of Orange County letter. Connie Mandic spoke in support of a maximum building height of sixty feet, twenty-four foot alleys, curb cuts, elimination of public open space requirements for interior parcels, cantilevered decks, list of uses for Conditional Use Permits and equal parking requirements for properties located north and south of Orange Avenue. There being no one present to speak further, Code Amendment No. 92-5 was continued to the adjourned regular meeting of April 6, 1994. MEETING ADJOURNED TO WEDNESDAY,APRIL 6. 1994 AT 6:30 P.M. The Mayor announced the hour of eleven o'clock and to comply with Council resolution, asked for a motion to continue the meeting. A motion was made by Sullivan, seconded by Leipzig, to adjourn the meeting to Wednesday, April 6, 1994 at 6:30 p.m (all remaining agenda items to be heard on this date). The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Bauer, Robitaille, Moulton-Patterson,Winchell, Sullivan, Leipzig NOES: Silva ABSENT: None (City Council) PUBLIC HEARING -ELLIS AVENUE UNDERGROUND UTILITY DISTRICT NO. 94-1 - GOLDENWEST STREET TO EDWARDS STREET-RESOLUTION NO.6581 -CONTINUED TO APRIL 6. 1994 (350.20) Public hearing pursuant to Resolution of Intent No. 6578 adopted March 21, 1994 to consider a proposal that an underground utility district be.formed within the public right-of-way along Ellis Avenue between Golden West and Edwards Streets. Resolution No. 6581 -"A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH ESTABLISHING UNDERGROUND UTILITY DISTRICT ON ELLIS AVENUE BETWEEN GOLDEN WEST STREET AND EDWARDS STREET." (Underground Utility District No. 94-1) �. 1:8 Page 16-Council/Agency Minutes -04/04/94 SPECIAL MEETING OF THE HUNTINGTON BEACH PARKING AUTHORITY-CONTINUED TO APRIL 6, 1994 (City Council/Parking Authority) SOUTH BEACH RESTROOM -PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS -CALL FOR BIDS -CC-908 (600.80) Communication from the Director of Community Services and the Director of Public Works regarding construction of South Beach Restroom No. 1. Plans and specifications for the construction of South Beach Restroom No. 1, authorize the Director of Public Works to solicit construction bids, approve sample contract subject to award of contract to Council approved lowest responsible bidder and approve an amendment to the FY 93/94 Parking Authority budget to allocate $239,250 to construct South Beach Restroom No. 1, $130,473 of the projects costs will be reimbursed by a Land and Water Conservation Grant. (City Council/Redevelopment Agency) MINUTES-CONTINUED TO APRIL 6. 1994 (City Council)TRAFFIC SIGNAL MASTER CONTROL AND SURVEILLANCE SYSTEM -TRAFFIC SIGNAL CONTROLLER SOFTWARE PURCHASE-BI TRAN SYSTEMS. INCORPORATED-CONTINUED IO APRIL 6, 1994 (600.95) (City Council) MOBILE HOME REVIEW COMMITTEE APPOINTMENT-NORMA BROWNELL- CONTINUED TO APRIL 6. 1994 (110.20) (City Council) RESTROOMS AT POLICE/PUBLIC GUN RANGE IN HUNTINGTON CENTRAL PARK- CONTINUED TO APRIL 6. 1994 (320.45) (City Council) HUNTINGTON CENTRAL PARK EQUESTRIAN CENTER SUBLEASE TO THERAPEUTIC RIDING CENTER OF HUNTINGTON BEACH -RESOLUTION No.6582-CONTINUED TO APRIL 6. 1994 (600.35) (City Council) RESOLUTION OF SUPPORT-VESSEL PASSENGER SERVICE BETWEEN HUNTINGTON HARBOUR(PETER'S LANDING MARINA)AND CATALINA ISLAND-RESOLUTION NO.6583 - CONTINUED TO APRIL 6. 1994 (120.70) (City Council) PHASE II OF THE BEACH BOULEVARD SMART STREET PROJECT(FORMERLY SUPER STREET)AND PAVEMENT REHABILITATION PROJECT BETWEEN ELLIS AVENUE AND THE NORTHERN CITY LIMITS -PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS-CALL FOR BIDS -CC-784-FED. NO, STPLN 5181(020)-CONTINUED TO APRIL 6. 1994 (600.50) (City Council) REQUEST FOR CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH TO JOIN IN SUPPORT OF AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF -THE CUSTOMER COMPANY V.CITY OF SACRAMENTO-CONTINUED TO APRIL 6, 1994 (630.50) 1:J Page 17-Council/Agency Minutes-04/04/94 (City Council) CENTRAL LIBRARY PARKING LOT PROJECT-AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT WITH KLEINFELDER, INCORPORATED-SOIL INSPECTION AND TESTING -AMENDMENT WITH MONTGOMERY WATSON FOR CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT SERVICES-CONTINUED TO APRIL 6. 1994 (600.10) (Redevelopment Agency)WAHOO'S RESTAURANT-IN-LIEU PARKING FEE- 120 MAIN STREET- MAIN-PIER REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT AREA-CONTINUED TO APRIL 6. 1994 (340.20) (City Council) ORDINANCE NO. 3233-PRECISE PLAN OF STREET ALIGNMENT NO. 92-2(3) EDINGER AVENUE BETWEEN GOTHARD STREET AND 300 FEET WEST OF BEACH BOULEVARD- CONTINUED TO APRIL 6, 1994 (640.10) ADJOURNMENT-COUNCILIREDEVELOPMENT AGENCY Mayor Moulton-Patterson adjourned the regular meetings of the City Council and the Redevelopment Agency of the City of Huntington Beach to Wednesday, April 6, 1994 at 6:30 p.m. in the Council Chamber, Civic Center, Huntington Beach, California. Clerk of the Redevelopment Agency and City Clerk and ex-officio Clerk of the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach, California ATTEST: City Clerk/Clerk Mayor/Chairman 01/31/95 • MINUTES INDEX Page 1 INX CATEGORY SUB VOL PAGE DATE KEYWORDS --- -------- --- ---- ---- --------- ------------------------------------------- 20.80 49 153 02/18/92 DISCUSS:PUB HEAR-APPEAL�P�OONDITIONED APPRVL S 1- /CD�,�.P��91- 9-SUPE�'T9R ELEC C-30�420 .35 420.35 49 153 02/18/92 DISCUSS:PUB HEAR-APPEAL PC CONDITIONED APPRVL SSP 91-8/CDP 91-39-SUPERIOR ELECTRIC-300 PCH-420.35 4 0 49 162 02/18/92 PUB HEAR-AP L COND RVL SSP 91-8/CDP AP D-300 PCH-420.35 420.35 49 162 02/18/92 PUB HEAR-APPEAL COND APPRVL SSP 91-8/CDP . 91-39-SUPERIOR ELECTRIC-20 ' ALT SIGN APPRVD-300 PCH-420 .35 420.35 53 2 08/02/93 DISCUSS: PUB HEAR- APPEAL PC CONDITIONAL APPRVL SSP 93-4- SAN PEDRO SIGN CO- 16732 BEACH BLVD-420.35 420.35 53 11 08/02/93 PUB HEAR-APPEAL PC CONDITIONAL APPRVL SSP 93-4-SAN PEDRO SIGN CO-16732 BEACH BLVD-APPRV/AMEND-420. 35 420.35 53 60 09/07/93 PUB HEAR- GRANT APPEAL/APPRV PLANNED SIGN PROG 93-1/SSP 93-24- OCEAN VIEW PROMENADE- PCH/MAIN-420. 35 420.35 53 156 11/15/93 PUB HEAR- APPEAL PC CONDITIONAL APPRVL SSP 93-9- APPRVD MODIFICATION- RALLY HAMBURGERS POLE- 420. 35 420.35 54 75 03/07/9 PUB HEAR-APPEAL PC DENIAL SSP 93-11-17422-17438 BEACH BLVD-REFER TO COMMI-TTEE-RETURN 3/7/95-420. 35 420.35 54 104 04/04/94 RQST CONT PUB HEAR-SSP 93-13-SUPERIOR ELECTRICAL ADVERTISING-45 ' HIGH PYLON SIGN-9891 ADAMS-420 . 35 420.35 54 115 04/04/ PUB HEAR-APPEAL-SSP 93-13-SUPERIOR ELECTRICAL ADVERTISING-45' PYLON SIGN-9891 ADAMS-CONT 4/3 4 0 . 35 420.30 54 116 04/04/94 ESTAB MEETING DATE FOR SSP 93-11 - 17422-17438 BEACH BLVD HOMEOWNERe A85OCIATION ay.+? ..eroN sent 1,CAI_IFOPINA untington Beach, California 92615 March 16, 1994 Mayor, City Council and City Administrator City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, California 92648 X SUBJECT: Cudini and Lucas Jewelry Sign at Brookhurst and Adams Dear Mayor Patterson, City Council Persons, and City Administrator: The Meredith Gardens Homeowners Association has been made aware of a situation regarding the subject sign that is scheduled for your review in the very near future, and we want you to know how we feel about it. I have had discussions with Mr. Leo Cudini of Cudini and Lucas and with Mr. Mike Fuentes of the city to become familiar with the background on it, including past agreements between the city and the property owner, Mr. Cudini's actions to erect a sign without a sign permit, etc., and it is our understanding that the permit is currently in place, but Mr. Cudini has been cited, along with Mervyn's and L.A. Tronics, for sign ordinance violations, and the intent is to force the removal of the sign. We are not familiar with all of the legal details in this matter, but as a homeowners association in this neighborhood we are very concerned about the business climate there. It strikes us that forcing Mr. Cudini to remove his sign after he invested $6000 to have this sign erected to improve his visibility to prospective customers flies directly in the face of the city's attempts to create a friendly environment for the small businessman. We have personally inspected the sign, and we find it attractive, so we feel that there are no grounds to take the sign down for reasons of appearance. Our MGHA Board of Directors discussed this subject at our monthly meeting on March 9, and we voted unanimously to support Mr. Cudini's efforts to keep the sign in place as it currently exists, and to document our support in this letter to you. We respectfi0y 1= request that you vote to support a friendly business environment for Mr. Cudini inlothis' matter. Feel free to call me at (714) 896-3357 (0) or.(714) 962-5828 (H) if you have questions or comments. <nm Sincerely, co .v r T Bob Riedesel President Meredith Gardens Homeowners Association ID- 3 ' PROOF OF PUBLICATION STATE OF CALIFORNIA) SS. County of Orange ) __ PUBLIC K0T(CE.. ', I am a Citizen of the United States and a rloTlcfaoF i CONTINUED: .� ! resident of the County aforesaid' I am PUBLICHEARINO r APPEAL„OF THE over the age of eighteen years and not a 'rPLANNI r I COMMISSON'S '• ' party to or interested in the below pENIAL::oFJSPt3laAL - p SIGN PERMIT NT ,.� NO 9313"` � ENVIRONMENTAL STA=: entitled matter. I am a principal clerk of , I TUS Categorically exempt p p .(45 Foot Hlgh x ,I pursuant to Section 153.15, Pylon Sign) f Class 15 of ttie Califorrna' the HUNTINGTON BEACH INDEPENDENT, a NOTICE IS HEREBY EnvironmentaFpualityy,Act .I GIVEN that the Huntington I CO'ASTALy"1STATUSiNot.: newspaper of general circulation, printed Beach CifyCounalwill applicable I and published in the City of Huntington Iholdaiputilicheanngln hea f rOtVyFILE A c py,9Atbe I Counal Chamber at the I proposed request is ori-file-' Huntington Beach CIVlc f in the:Coin �ty�oew,elop ; Beach, County of Orange, State of ! center 2000Mam)Street ! ment Department 2000 I Huntington Beacfi Califor Main sStreet �HUnungton California, and that attached Notice is a nia onlhe date and at the' Beadh California, 926A8 i time indicated below tore ! for InspecBon li&W*a p'ub''- true and complete copy as was printed i celve and consider the A,copy'of}thMff re- statements' of all 'persons r port w`�ill�be avaihableo In who wishzto�be+heard(,rela - I teresPed partiestat Cit Hall and published in the Huntington Beach I tive to 6.appiication de for the Main.�Crty utbr and Fountain Valle issues of said i scnbed.below ,. (7111=7albert',ayenue)-after y I DATE/TIME Monday; April 1 1994+ April 4 r1994r7 00 p`_:m # ALL INTERESTED PER newspaper to wit the issue(s) of: APP,LICA'TION NUMBER: SONS are Invited to attend.:' Appeal of the :Planning said'heanng,arid express Commission s denial of opinions or ubmiC`ev`i Special Sign Permit+No 93• Bence for or,-against ahe 113 } applications as outlined 'I APPLICANT Superior above. Writteri dommunica a`I Electrical_Advertising Inc Boris,,-may alsoiibe serif I,p' APPELLANT Mayor,Pro the''City Clerk x if yo�u,thal Tempore Earle Robitaille lengg the,Clty Councils acA LOCATION 9891'°'Adams` Bon in- March youmabe 24, 1994 I Avenue northwest corner°, hmded to raising only t ose at Wookhurst) issuesa your a or someone 'ZONE: • C2 FP2- (Coin else-raised�at-tie Souli6ct',i mumty Business ;Distir w: heanng'described N "thisy Floodplam) i notice or m written cor declare, under penalty of perjury, that REVISED; REQUEST To respondence delivered. for r f permit an existingnoncon the Crty at orpnoi�to the ; tormih 45 foot -high 624` public heanng:-ilf there-are. the foregoing is true and correct. square=footr`'double pole; I any further.=questio,gsr pylon sign to remain m Its please: call Wayne Car. present location and to valho�Assistant Plannelil ! allow a 140 square foot I 536 527� s I sign,.-face,,fchangge tidentit- �Co^nle Brockway, Executed on March 24 1 99 4 ring Cudini and�Lcass�Jew• Hun'tngtonB'each Cltyl elers m lieu of a maximum I Clerk's i 15 foot--high 7j0;.square _I * z at Costa Mesa, California. toot freestanding?sign pur �P-ublished•rHuntington suant to;9-56649610 7�of Beach-Fountain Valley In- II the Huntington Beach Ordi dependent March 24, 4994. L riance Code a x, ;s 1 _ 034084 Signature -3 jor NO OF CONTINUED PUBLIC HEA'Ac APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (45 Foot High Pylon Sign) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE/TIME: Monday, April 4, 1994, 7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Appeal of the Planning Commission's denial of Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 APPLICANT: Superior Electrical Advertising, Inc. APPELLANT: Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue(northwest corner at Brookhurst) ZONE: C2-FP2 (Community Business District-Floodplain) REVISED REQUEST: To permit an existing,non conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot double pole pylon sign to remain in its present location and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini and Lucas Jewelers, in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15315, Class 15 of the California Environmental Quality Act. COASTAL STATUS: Not applicable ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Community Development Department, 2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. A copy of the staff report will be available to interested parties at City Hall or the Main City Library(7111 Talbert Avenue) after April 1, 1994. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. Written communications may also be sent to the City Clerk. If you challenge the City Council's action in court,you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at, or prior to,the public hearing. If there are any further questions please call Wayne Carvalho,Assistant Planner at 536-5271. Connie Brockway j Huntington Beach City Clerk _ wclpo217 • i i f � PUBLIC HEARING REQUEST SUBJECT: (eliX u DEPARTMENT: IqMEETING: NUMBER OF Ph(fW PUBLIC HEARING : (PER- Initial) AUTHORIZATION: Ray fiver Assistant City Administrator Approved by City Adminisetion • COVER SHEET FOR CITY COUNCIL PUBLIC HEARINGS N/A YES NO ( ) Was City Council or Planning Commission public hearing notice typed on Wang? ( ) ( ) If appeal, are appellant and applicant shown on legal notice? { ( ) ( ) If housing is involved, is "legal challenge paragraph" included? ( ) ( ) If Coastal Development Permit, are the RESIDENT labels attached and is the Coastal Commission Office on the labels? Is Title Company verification letter attached? ( ) ( ) Were the latest Assessor's Parcel Rolls used? ( ) ( ) &�s the appellant's name and address part of the labels? ( ) Is day of public hearing correct - Monday/Tuesday? ( ) Has the City Administrator's Office authorized the public hearing to be set? Is there an Environmental Status to be approved by Council. ( ) ( ) Are the appellant/Cpp1ica:n:t::s: ames and addresses on mailing labels? "ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit to the City Clerk written evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions please, call (insert name of Planner) at 536-5227." For Public Hearings at the City Council level. please insert the above pmgmph of the public hearing notice: CONNIE BROCKWAY, CITY CLERK CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET - 2ND FLOOR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA 92649 (714) 536-5227 1350K - 9/93 SUSAN W. CASE OWNERSHIP LISTING SERVICE 917 Glenneyre Street, Suite 7 Laguna Beach, California 92651 714/494-6105 FAX: 714/494-7418 Certification of Property Ownership List THE ATTACHED LIST REPRESENTS THE NAMES AND ADDRESSES OF ALL PROPERTY OWNERS LOCATED WITHIN 300 FEET OF THE EXTERIOR BOUNDARIES OF THE PROPERTY. LOCATED AT 9891 Adams Ave, Huntington'Beach CA 92646 THIS INFORMATION WAS OBTAINED FROM THE LATEST DRANGE COUNTY ARRESSHI NT Rnr_r_g. AC=HHR 4 3993 SUSAN W. CASE NOSE OF CONTINUED PUBLIC HEAA1G APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (45 Foot High Pylon Sign) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE/TIME: Monday, April 4, 1994, 7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Appeal of the Planning Commission's denial of Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 APPLICANT: Superior Electrical Advertising, Inc. APPELLANT: Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue (northwest corner at Brookhurst) ZONE: C2-FP2 (Community Business District-Floodplain) REVISED REQUEST: To permit an existing, non conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot double pole pylon sign to remain in its present location and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini and Lucas Jewelers, in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15315, Class 15 of the California Environmental Quality Act. COASTAL STATUS: Not applicable ON FI A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Community Development Department, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. A copy of the staff report will be available to interested parties at City Hall or the Main City Library (7111 Talbert Avenue) after April 1, 1994. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. Written communications may also be sent to the City Clerk. If you challenge the City Council's action in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at, or prior to, the public hearing. If there are any further questions please call Wayne Carvalho, Assistant Planner at 536-5271. Connie Brockway Huntington Beach City Clerk wc1p0217 1S! 4o► y 1 -61tria Rodriguez j Anthony George Evelyn M Andamo ` 9741 Olympic Dr • 9751 Olympic Dr 9761 Olympic Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 151 40401 4 151 461 01 5 151 461 02 6 Don & Myra Rubin Toshiki Takata Woodrow Keathley 9762 Olympic Dr 9781 Olympic Dr 9791 Olympic Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15146103 7 15146104 8 15146105 9 Lorie Grange Pacita H Malapira Girard M Manke 9801 Olympic Dr 9812 Olympic Dr 9802 Olympic Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15146116 10 151 461F07_- 11 1 151 461 22 12 Roy N Hanaoka Hsi-H an 2nd 9792 Olympic Dr 9782 ly � 8075 W 3rd St#530 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Hun ' B ch A 92646 Los Angeles CA 90048 151 461 24 13 151 461 28 14 153 17101 15 Shell Oil Co Nevada Investment Holdings Inc Allan A Fainbarg Po Box 2099 220 Congress Park Dr 890 Baker St#200 Houston TX 77252. Delray Beach FL.33445 Costa Mesa CA 92626 153 17102 . 16 153 406 06 17 - 153 406 07 18 Fainbarg Allan A Co Craig M Spier Ricardo&Irma Castaneda 890 Baker St#200 19861 Keswick Ln 19865 Keswick Ln Costa Mesa CA 92626 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 406 08 19 153 406 09 20 153 406 37 21 Jonathan L Dawsont Isabelle Trang Ngo - Yolanda S Cota 19869 Keswick Ln 14 Fallbrook 19886 Vermont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Irvine CA 92714 . Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 406 38 22 153 406 39 23 153.406 40 24 Leonard C Hilts Fred Feodor Alkhoutoff Jill Ann Putnam. 19890 Vermont Ln 19894 Vermont Ln 19898 Vermont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 406 41 25 153 406 42 26 153 406 43 27 Dan Daryl Walters Rosalie M Metzger Leonard Ross Russo 19902 Vermont Ln 19081 Mathew Cir 8041 E Bynum St Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Long Beach CA 90808 153 406 44 28 153 406 45 29 153 406 46 30 . Wassim F Zaky Arthur A Fliege Robert H Bennett 1706> Marina Bay Dr 6402 Antrim Cir 19922 Vermont Ln HuntinQton Beach CA 92649 Huntington Beach CA 92647 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Jose Luis Franco William L& Linda A&Rachel Kro Robert J Parke 19926 Vermont Ln • 3872 San Joaquin Ave 6111 Jasonwood Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Los Alamitos CA 90720 • Huntington Beach CA 92648 153 406 50 34 153 406 51 35 15340652 36 Albert B Hebert Phau Quy Bui Greg&Valerie Viers 19938 Vermont Ln 19942 Vermont Ln 9731 Adams Ave Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 1534.0 3 37 153 406 54 38 153 406 55 39 Gordon me James A&Catherine A Abshier Mark A Mayes 1993- K n 9723 Adams Ave 9719 Adams Ave Hu \gt ch CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 406 73 40 153 415 01 41 153 415 02 42 Huntington Continental Townhou Randy L Miller Jean R Franke 9635 Cornwall Dr 9864 Continental Dr 18212 Muir Woods Ct Huntington Beach CA 92646 _ Huntington Beach CA 92646 Fountain Valley CA 92708 153 415 03 43 153 415 04 44 153 415 05 45 Dolores I Coolidge Jean R Franke Clifton R Reed 9872 Continental Dr 18212 Muir Woods Ct 9880 Continental Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Fountain Valley CA 92708 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 06 46 153 415 07 47 153 415 08 48 Amer Jneid Grant H Wilson Jr. Richard L Gerhold 9884 Continental Dr 9888 Continental Dr 2946 E Pembroke Ct Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Fullerton CA 92631 153 415 09 49 153 415 10 50 153 415 11 51 Cynthia L Swanson - Nick Riggs Ghaboos Hamidi 9681 Toucan Ave 9908 Continental Dr . 9912 Continental Dr Fountain Valley CA 92708 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 12 52 153 415 13 53 153 415 14 54 Ernest.A Pellegrini Patrick L Buxton Richard G Kellehar 9916 Continental Dr 6532 Cerulean Ave 5261 Harvard Ave Huntington Beach CA 92646 Garden Grove CA 92645 Westminster CA 92683 153 415 15 55 153 415 16 56 153 415 17 57 Nghia Vu Rolando J Granadino Michele Roberge 9928 Continental Dr 9932 Continental Dr 9942 Continental Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646- Huntington Beach CA 92646 I 153 415 18 58 153 415 19 59 - 15341520 60 Blanca Hund Genaro Magana Martha Riggs 9946 Continental Dr 9952 Continental Dr 9958 Continental Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341521 1D341DL3 w John A DeMarr Grace A Anderson Kirstine L Cerone 16787 Beach Blvd • 21322 Breton Ln 19836 Berkshire Ln Huntington Beach CA 92647 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 24 64 153 415 25 65 f 153 415 26 66 Gerardo Calderon Guinn E Lumpkin Charles Stidham 19840 Berkshire Ln Po Box 146 19848 Berkshire Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Midway City CA 92655 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 27 67 153 Aer- 68 153 415 29 69 Martin A&Ana L Zabala Gorone Hideko Kay Masuda 7152 Fenway Dr#11 1985n 20012 Colgate Cir Westminster CA 92683 Hunac A 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 30 70 153 415 31 7 153 415 32 72 Maureen Hewitt James Warren D `'Nilson J&Maria A Elder 19864 Berkshire Ln Birmin 19872 Berkshire Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 En Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 33 73 153 415 34. 74 153 415 35 75 Jose Luis B Rodriguez Guinn E Lumpkin Mildred Coker 2713 Lindy Ave Po Box 146 19882 Berkshire Ln Rosemead CA 91770 Midway City CA 92655 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 36 76 153 415 37 77 153 415 38 78 James Earl Nackey Jeanette LaCour Cheryl A Perry 19841 Berkshire Ln 19843 Berkshire Ln 19847 Berkshire Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 39 79 153 415 40 80 153 415 41 81 Andrew J Acosta Neria Yomtoubian Ricky G Denney 19851 Berkshire Ln Po Box 3595 19859 Berkshire Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Newport Beach CA 92659 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 42 82 153 415 43 83 153 415 44 84 Roger F&Joanne M Monteen Kenneth W Newland Lawrence Schultz 802 River Rock Blvd 1836 Iowa St 9945 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 37129 Costa Mesa CA 92626 Huntington Beach.CA 92646 153 415 45 85 153 415 46 86 153 415 47 87 Ezra Lai Sendler Tseitlin Thomas P&Nancy L Hughes 9941 Cornwall Dr 9937 Cornwall Dr 9933 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 48 88 153 415 49 89 153 415 50 90 Gloria 'Niarie Quick Sherri I Foster Joan Poirier 9929 Cornwall Dr 9351 Velardo Dr 9921 Cornwall Dr .Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 i 15341551 91 153415-52 92 1Ji415 S ys Billy H Thomas Herman & Larisa Lebovic Alfre C • i �achLCA 21972 Yellowstone Ln • 19858 Kingswood Ln : 1985 Ki d nEl Toro CA 92630 Huntington Beach CA 92646 H agtsln 92646 153 415 54 94 153 415 55 95 153 415 56 96 Ellen Zakour Michael Ray Gustaveson Jan A Van Oosten 19850 Kingswood Ln 19846 Kingswood Ln 19844 Kingswood Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 57 97 153 415 58 98 153 415 59 99 Alan Foster Raul Velesquez Philip D Warner 19842 Kingswood Ln 19831 Kingswood Ln 10041 Beverly Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341560 100 153 415 61 101 153 415 62 102 Robin A Gross Hsin-Piao Chen Albert R McCown 10291 Jon Day Dr 1888 N College Cir 10151 Beverly Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Long Beach.CA 90815 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 63 103 153 415 64 104 153 415 65 105 Kathy L Harper Helen Garcia-Checkman Robert A Woodward 19$51 Kingswood Ln 19855 Kingswood Ln 11943 Verbena Ct Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach'CA 92646 I Fountain Valley CA 92708 153 415 66 106 153 415 67 153 415 68 108 Tony Khorouzan Deloris J a Carlos Caro 19863 Kingswood Ln 19867 L 19781 Kingswood Ln . Huntington Beach CA 92646 Hu gtan a A 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 69 109 153 415.70 110 153 415 71 111 E James Wheless James B Bailey Patrick&Julia M Glascock 26 Sycamore Crk 10061 Dakota Ave 19881 Kingswood Ln Irene CA 92715 Garden Grove CA 92643 Huntington Beach CA 92646 1534157/ 15341573 113 1534157 114 Secretary f Michael J O'Donnell Nations nc 4 rt orporati 34 Civ' er 19880 Inverness Ln 19876 In'er Ln Santa Ana A.9� 1 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Hunt' B ac 92646 15341574, 1153 415 76 116 153 415 77 117 '%1uul�, Dung Ky Nguyen Richard W Mclntee 198Lr/ 12450 Bay Hill Ct 1707 Terrapin Way HuchCA 92646 Garden Grove CA 92643 Newport Beach CA 92660 15341578 118 153 415 79 119 15341580 120 Robert M & Roisin C Eriksen Linda A Stafford John A DeMarr 19860 Im-erness Ln 19856 Inverness Ln 16787 Beach Blvd Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92647 l53- //5-72 /l.3 Vis- 79; BOnlNie //E*lAljW;4)' 471W P ZVo4ft-1-5 61671 NE16tAW4y OR. 0152. U(% pe, 9264 Ira 153 415 S1 121 153 415 82 122 153 415 83 123 Francis Floyd Butts . George Murray Peter M Becker 5182 Doanoke Ave 18922 Mount Cimarron St • 19840 Inverness Ln Irvine CA 92714 Fountain Valley CA 92708 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 84 124 153 415 85 125 jH * 86 126 00000 Jonny B Rohrer Kathryn L Orris gto ontine own Ho 19836 Inverness Ln 19832 Inverness Ln ro •h t Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 o -A 92646 153 415 87 1 153 416 01 128 153 416 02 129 Huntington Con ' own Ho Kent R Horne John Attard 19801 B st St 9782 Continental Dr 5081 Field St H on Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 San Diego CA 92110 153 416 03 130 153 416 04 131 153 416 05 132 Conrad Epley Jerry L Bowen Teri L Allen 9788 Continental Dr 5432 Catowba Ln 9802 Continental Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Irvine CA 92715 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 06 133 153 416 07 134 153 416 08 135 Jacob M Lee Ronald P Rouintree . Shriver Anne D 9808 Continental Dr 9812 Continental Dr 9816 Continental Dr. . Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 09 136 153 41610 137 153 416 11 138 David W Cooney Ben J Miles Jerome J Goldfein 9820 Continental Dr 9824 Continental Dr 5402 Barwood Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92649 153 416 12 139 153 41613 140 153 416 14 141 Sharon Rose Getz George Donald Radabaugh John J Kiang 2049 W 236th Place Dr 9842 Continental Dr 24162 Castilla Ln Torrance CA 90501 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Mission Viejo CA 92691 153 416 15 142 153 416 16 143 153 416 17 144 William R Rowland Jerry E Todd Patricia A Showalter 9848 Continental Dr 35128 Quartz St 19893 Lures Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Yucaipa CA 92399 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 18 145 153 416 19 146 153 416 20 147 . Tan M Dang Dorothy J Rudd Kimberly Ann Konopka 9854 Continental Dr 1946 Pelican Pl 9858 Continental Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Costa Mesa CA 92626 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 21 148 153 416 22 149 153 416 23 150 Claire A Chris William H Wilson Portia Pao Chen &Lois Teo 19841 lnvcrncss Ln 19843 Inverness Ln 19847 Inverness Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 24 151 153 416 25 152 153 416 26 153 Neila S Ready Craig R Bergquist Billy H Thomas 19851 Inverness Ln . 13451 Rosecrans Ave • 21972 Yellowstone Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Santa Fe Springs CA 90670 El Toro CA 92630 153 416 27 154 153 416 28 155 153 416 29 156 Margaret A Kuhn John P Haberstroh Ronald E Roluffs 19861 Inverness Ln 9879 Cornwall Dr 904 S Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Anaheim CA 92804 153 416 30 157 153 416 31 158 153 416 32 159 Martha E Riggs Susan A Hawkins Judith A Bailey Po Box 86 Po Box 3204 9863 Corn,,%•all Dr Huntington Beach CA 92648 Quail Valley CA 92587 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 33 160 153 416 34 161 153 416 35 162 Diane M Reber Ron Schneirson Karla Steckbauer 9859 Cornwall Dr 353 Mavis Dr 9851 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Los Angeles CA 90065 Huntington Beach CA-92646 153 416 36 163 153 416 37 164 153 416 38 165 Alladin Khoja Glen Richard Swanson Maureen O'Reilly 16412 S Casa Rey Dr 19858 Cambridge Ln - 19854 Cambridge Ln Santa Ana CA 92704 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 39 166 153 416 40 167 I 153 416 41 168 Turgay Dermenci Shoya&Flory Maeji ! Wassim F Zaky 10092 Kamuela Dr 19846 Cambridge Ln 17065 Marina Bay Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92649 153 416 42 169 153 416 43 ,170 153 416 44 171 Raymond L&Bonnie B Borough Ethna Saunders Erick Taylor 19842 Cambridge Ln 19831 Cambridge Ln 19835 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 45 172 153 416.46 173 151416 47 174 Susan Lynn Bisnar Magdi G&Wessam Mina Jose R& Ines Cabrera 19839 Cambridge Ln 19843 Cambridge Ln 19847 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 48 175 153 416 49 176 153 416 50 177 Frances C Blakesley Richard D Hansen Vincent A Zamora 19851 Cambridge Ln 354 Lourdes.Ln 19859 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Costa Mesa CA 92627 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 51 178 153 416 52 179 153 416 53 180 Teresa Marie Wall Margit Gieg] Gmc Ltd 19863 Cambridge Ln 19867 Cambridce Ln 19871 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 I 1 53 416 54 181 15341655 182 416 56IS3 Henry L Adams Jesus O Martinez Susan R Head 19775 Inverness Ln • 19879 Cambridge Ln • 19881 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 J 184 153 416 58 185 1534116597 186 Bet yy ree a Thomas A L'angelle Don Jea 18J74 19880 Claremont Ln 19876 1 t n Fo alley CA 92708 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Hunt to B CA 92646 153 416 60 187 153 416 61 188 153 416 62 189 Michael G Carroll Donald R Squillace Towhid &Rashida Alam 80 Huntington St #8 Po Box 30385 19864 Claremont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92648 Long Beach CA 90853 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 63 190 153 416 64 191 153 416 65 192 Ira Maurice Bell Karen Lasagna Jean R Franke 21742 Windsong Cir 4110 Apricot Dr 18212 Muir Woods Ct Huntington Beach CA 92646 Irvine CA 92720 _ Fountain Valley CA 92708 153 416 66_ 193 153 416 67 194 153 416 68 195 Department Of Veterans Affairs Penelope Wentworth Vincent Dantoni Po Box 942895 10121 Old Ranch Cir 3813 Conquista Ave Sacramento CA 94295 Villa Park CA 92667 Long Beach CA 90808 153 416 69 196 153 416 70 197 153 416 71 198 .Cynthia Cumniris Richard W Jantzer Gonzalo Caro Aranda 19836 Claremont Ln 19832 Claremont Ln 19841 Claremont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 72 199 153 416 73 200 153 416 74 . . 201 Rick&Deanna Vanderpool John L Warde Joseph Keith 19843 Claremont Ln 9682 Melinda Cir 19851 Claremont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 75 202 153 416 76 203 153 416 77 204 Silvia F Benavides Kelly James Donohue Ramon Calderon 19855 Claremont Ln 19859 Claremont Ln 19861 Claremont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 78 205 153 416 79 206 153 416 80 207 Kathy M Clark Beverly A Rapp Duc Martha C Wagoner-Le 9809 Cornwall Dr 9805 Cornwall Dr 259 62nd St Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Newport Beach CA 92663 153 416 81 208 153 416 82- 209 153 416 83 210 Jo Ann Walker Amin Halim Nancy G Henri 9797 Cornwall Dr 9793 Cornwall Dr 17843 Bay St Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Fountain Valley CA 92708 ID541b2S4 L11 I-)j +I U 6 ) A.If -- - Dale M Spangle Warren H Miller Michael K Wilkinson 11513 Halawa Ln • Po Box 1912 12 Autumnleaf Cypress CA 90630 Newport Beach CA 92659 � Irvine CA 92714 153 416 87 214 153 416 88 215 1534168.9 216 Enrique R Rodriguez Kinh LeKy Sherry S Gilpatrick 19858 Coventry Ln 19854 Coventry Ln 19850 Coventry Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341690 217 15341691 218 15341692. 219 James Forbes Randall R Bruno Kent&Rosemary Soughers 19846 Coventry Ln 22152 Wood Island Ln 16166 Mariner Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92649 153 41go 22 153 416 94 221 153 416 95 222 Hunti gnti own Ho Huntington Contin «gin Ho Huntington Conti wn Ho 19801 BS 19801 Bro bt St 19801 B st St Hunt A 92646 Hunt' on Beach CA 92646 H on Beach CA 92646 153 417 01 223 153 417 02 224 153 417 03 225 Melissa Tracy Doan William R Keller Keith R Snider 9302 Litchfield Dr 2673 Foothill Dr Po Box 8766. Huntington Beach CA 92646 Vista CA 9.2084 Fountain Valley CA 92728 153 417 04 226 153 417 05 227 153 417 06 228 Judith Carroll Dunham James E Gutierrez Sr. Joseph C Giambrone 19851 Coventry Ln 19855 Coventry Ln 19859 Coventry Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 i Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 T 153 417 07 229 153 417 08 230 153 417 09 231 Richard Blakeman Robert G Vouga Michael Richard Ceser 19861 Coventry Ln 9601 Lassen Cir - 19844 Keswick Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 10 232 153 417 11 233 153 417 12 234 Clayton E Weimer Timothy A Szabo Michael R Rainey 19846 Keswick Ln 19850 Keswick Ln 19854 Keswick Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 13 235 153 417 14 236 153 417 15 237 Andrew T&Robyn C Shef Cheryl R Ingraham- Jon Douglas Andrews II 19858 Keswick Ln 2138 N Parkway Dr 9741 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 El Monte CA 91733 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 16 238 153 417 17 239 153 417 18 240 Scott R Mello Norman S Lawson Emad M &Afaf S Gharghoury 9745 Cornwall Dr 15590 Irene Way 9757 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Westminster CA 9�683 Huntington Beach CA 92646 1)3'417 19 2-41 1Di 41 / ZV -- John A Johnston .:'James D& Heidi Swanson Katherine Fay 23 Chanipney PI • Po Box 2097 Laguna Niguel CA 92677 .H 264 Seal Beach CA 90740 GSay � �� 15341722 244 153 417 23 145 153 417 24 246 Joanne M Romero Margaret Brayton Scott Marshall Brinson 19891 Coventry Ln 19895 Coventry Ln 19899 Coventry Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 25 247 153 417 26 248 153 417 27 249 Ysmael R Odron Jerome M Stewart Mary A Mosier 454 S Gendel Dr 19905 Coventry Ln 19909 Coventry Ln La Puente CA 91744 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 28 250 153 417 29 - . 251 153 417 30 252 Janette C Bushnell Brian C Werner Larry Jay Walraven - 173 Colonial Dr 8202 El Pescador Ln 11624 Carnation Cir Newtown PA 18940 La Palma CA 90623 Fountain Valley CA 92708 153 417 31 253 153 417 32 254 . 153 417 33 255 Ruth Massie Felipe&Christina Gonzalez Jim H&Joanne Bond 19929 Coventry Ln 19931 Coventry Ln 19935 Coventry Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 9M46 153 417 34 256 153 417 35 257 153 417 36 258 Andrzej Mania Randy M Colyar Roland Covey 9291 Woodcrest Dr 19943 Coventry Ln 16872 Bolsa Chica St#105 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92649 153 417 37 259 153 417 38 260 153 417 39 261 Perry Rezvan Norman Sands Diana L McCreary 7021 NTimrod Dr 5096 Tortuga Dr#202 9770 Charing Cross Dr Huntington Beach CA 92647 Huntington Beach CA 92649 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 40 262 153 417 41 263 153 417 42 264 . James N Cappellia Nettie M Nurse Susie Nielsen "0510 Mira Loma Dr 19938 Keswick Ln 19934 Keswick Ln Temecula CA 92592 i Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341743 265 15341744 266 -153 417 45 267 Rita M Kusaka Robert B Mase Madlyn J Singer 19930 Keswick Ln 336 Colton St 19924 Keswick Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Newport Beach CA 92663 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341746 268 153 *4 *169 15341748 270 George R Santana Lloy Connye G Morgan - 19920 Keswick Ln 9341 12 Via Di Nola Huntington Beach CA 92646 Hun6 Laguna Niguel CA 92677 i Hilary M A Collett William S Berger Brenton L Lilley 19906 Keswick Ln . 19902 Keswick Ln 19898 Keswick Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 7 5 274 153 417 53 275 15341754 276 Ge rge eszpre iy Billy H Thomas Christopher I Venelin 16 82 M 21972 Yellowstone Ln 19891 Keswick Ln Fo nta CA 92708 El Toro CA 92630 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 55 277 153 417 56 278 153 417 57 279 Lois M Meinel Stanley A Dawkins Benjamin Ash 19895 Keswick Ln 71 Acacia Tree Ln Po Box 1403 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Irvine CA 92715 Costa Mesa CA 92628 153 417 58 280 153 417 59 281 153 417 60 282 Norman W Gilbert Rosario Ledesma Feliciano &Jesus Nava 17568 Mountain Ct 19909 Keswick Ln 19913 Keswick Ln Riverside CA 92503 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 61 283 153 417 62 284 153 417 63 285 Brian C&Sylvia F Bell - Mariano Reynoso Anthony M Lucia 19321 Brooktrail Ln 19921 Keswick Ln 8452 Emerado PI Huntington Beach CA 92648 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92683 153 417 64 286 15341765. 287 153 417 66 288 Ralph&Judy Tall Natalie C Ngin Annette S South I9929 Keswick Ln 19931 Keswick Ln 19391 Mauna Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 67 289 153 417 68 290 153 417 69- 291 Joseph M Cordero Jon M Maxwell Alfonso &Lorena Ramirez 19939 Keswick Ln 11721 Norgrove Ln 9742 Charing Cross Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Los Alamitos CA 90720 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 70 - 292 153 417 71 293 153 417 72 294 Fernando Rodriguez Robert R Wine Barbara A&Reginald S Holly 9746 Charing Cross Dr 1933 Republic Ave 20561 Paisley Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Costa Mesa CA 92627 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 73 295 153 417 74 296 153 417 75 2 Tay Tran Reginald S&Barbara A Holly Huntington Co a Town Ho 9758 Charing Cross Dr 20561 Paisley Ln 19801 rst St Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Hu ngton Beach CA 92646 15341776 2 8----' 153 417 77 299 15341778 30 Huntington Co ti own Ho Huntington Contin . n Ho n Huntington Co ' r own Ho 19801 eBr - stSt 19801 Broo t 19801 B rst St Hu Beach CA 92646 I Hunting on each CA 92646 Huntii gton Beach CA 92646 1DDUD1 V1 )VI 1�7 .Sea Shore Apartment Co Ltd Sav-On-Realty Inc Robert H Cowgill Jr. Po Box 5784 ,3030 Cullerton St 2760 E Spring St #200 Huntington Beach CA 92615 Franklin Park IL 60131 Long Beach CA 90806 155 051 07 304 155 051 10 305 155 18104 306 Allan Fainbarg Rodgers John H Tr%southland C Downey Savings 890 Baker St #200 2828 N Haskell Ave ! Po Box 6010 Costa A4esa CA 92626 Dallas TX 75204 Newport Beach,CA 92658 j ft AIVA 770' cl C� s'%,4" cTH-NOCer-A-- A4 4-tQ-- saQ� sGll�Rlo72- ��I�/C�'L /�'©D �'A�Lt S /rt�• �'3�S 170� ySl. ANR/ItFltil 5T GmS7-r4 MUSA CA- L 4N6 9e;tC4q CA 908/3 769/ 404Ws 4myw6s7,e�7 ►ckway,City Cle _ _- intin ton Beac 9 U.S.r $T`c f the City Cler . �"as3�.��iu t1tiR Z4 �4 s — I � 7 ! ;�• ). Box 190 Beach,CA 9FIR.» CLASS p I CALIF 1 :",A 050 *' + le �T INGTpy� �j 53 -42 4]�t�20,�/ anson 1aTni P: Heed r y 9767 CoT alle ch CA 92646 iiiiting�on INTY cP� LEGAL NOTICE — PUB L C HEARING 1 E\ANT TENANT i t�NAN 1 9791 ADAMS AVE 9795 ADAMS AVE 9803 ADAMS AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA • HUNTINGTON BEACH CA • HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646 92646 92646 TENANT TENANT TENANT 9807 ADAMS AVE 9811 ADAMS AVE 9861 ADAMS AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA HUNTINGTON BEACH CA HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646 92646 92646 TENANT TENANT TENANT 9891 ADAMS AVE 9901 ADAMS AVE 9941 ADAMS AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA HUNTINGTON BEACH CA HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646 92646 92646 TENANT TENANT TENANT 9951 ADAMS AVE 9961 ADAMS AVE 9971 ADAMS AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA HUNTINGTON BEACH CA HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646 92646 92646 I REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL A TION Date: April 4, 1994 Submitted to: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members Submitted by: Michael T. Uberuaga, City Administrator _ Prepared by: Melanie S. Fallon,Director of Community DevelopmentA 0 Subject: APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 Consistent with Council Policy? [XI Yes [ ] New Policy or Exception Statement of Issue,Recommendation,Analysis,Funding Source,Alternative Actions,Attachments: STATEMENT OF ISSUE: Transmitted for your consideration is Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille's appeal (see Attachment No. 4) of Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 which was denied by the Planning Commission on February 1, 1994. The Special Sign Permit request by Superior Electrical Advertising, Inc. is to permit an existing non-conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding double pole sign to remain at the northwest corner of Brookhurst and Adams (Mervyn's Shopping Center), and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini & Lucas Jewelers in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. Mayor Pro Tempore Robitaille appealed the Planning Commission's action due to his belief that the current sign ordinance discourages business rather than promote it and that as a result of our current economic condition, he feels the City should do everything in its power to prevent businesses from leaving the City. RECOMMENDATION: Planning Commission and Staff Recommendation: Motion to: "Sustain the Planning Commission's action and deny Special Sign Permit No. 93- 13 with findings" (see Attachment No. 5). PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION ON FEBRUARY 1. 1994: THE MOTION MADE BY BIDDLE,SECONDED BY COOK,TO DENY SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO.93-13 WITH FINDINGS(See Attachment No. 5)CARRIED BY THE FOLLOWING ROLL CALL VOTE: AYES: BIDDLE,COOK,DETTLOFF,GORMAN,RICHARDSON NOES: INGLEE,NEWMAN ABSTAIN: NONE ABSENT: NONE MOTION PASSED D . 3 ANALYSIS: Background In October 1993, Cudini & Lucas Jewelers requested a special sign permit to approve a sign face change that was installed without building permits to a 140 square foot sign cabinet located on a 45 foot high, 624 square foot non-conforming double pole sign(see Attachment No. 2). The special sign permit application was submitted following the issuance of a Notice of Violation and Request for Prosecution to the Cudini & Lucas business owner by the City's Code Enforcement section for installing the sign panels without appropriate City approval. Upon review of the application and research on the sign, it was discovered that an administrative review approval in 1985, and a planned sign program approval in 1986 required the subject freestanding sign be removed or altered to comply with the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code by January 29, 1988. The property owner and applicant were notified that the freestanding sign was non-conforming and would have to be modified to conform with code unless the Planning Commission granted permission for it to remain. The applicant subsequently expanded his special sign permit request to allow the entire sign to remain. If approved, the 45 foot high, 624 square foot sign would be permitted in perpetuity. Project Description The 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding sign is located within the asphalt parking lot, approximately 55 feet from the Adams Avenue right of way, and is visible by motorists traveling east and west on Adams Avenue. The entire sign consists of- 1. A 224 square foot double face sign copy identifying Mervyn's; 2. A 260 square foot single face sign copy identifying Thrifty, with an L.A.Tronics sign copy on the opposite side (rotating sign); and 3. A 140 square foot square foot double face sign cabinet for Cudini& Lucas Jewelers (see Attachment No. 2) The Huntington Beach Ordinance Code permits one (1)center identification freestanding sign per street frontage, with a maximum height of 15 feet, and 70 square feet in area. The sign is required to be located within a landscape planter and is permitted to identify the center and/or major tenant only. The following is a zoning conformance matrix that compares the applicant's request with Section 9610.5 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code: Section Issue Permitted Proposed 9610.5 Permitted Signs: Adams Ave. (831' frontage) Max.No: Freestanding 1 1 Monument 2 1 RCA- 4/4/94 2 ssp93-13 • • Section Issue Permitted Proposed 9610.5 (Con't) Max. Area: Freestanding 70 sf 624 sf total* (includes 150 sf jewelers sign)* Monument 30 sf 60 sf Max. Height: Freestanding 15 ft. 45 ft.* Monument 7 ft. 9 ft. Sign Copy: Limited to center 3 major tenants* Freestanding ID and/or major Mervyn's, tenant Thrifty/L.A.Tronics 1 additional tenant: Jewelers* Monument Business ID only Polly's Distance between monument signs 200 ft. N/A Sign location Must be in Located in paved landscaped planter parking lot* *Special Sign Permit Request Administrative Review No. 85-55, approved on January 29, 1986 for a new 1,700 square foot restaurant expansion within the Mervyn's Center,required the property owner to remove or modify the existing 45 foot high sign within a two (2)year period. A condition of approval required that a planned sign program be submitted prior to issuance of building permits for the addition. It also specified that the major identification sign comply with the Huntington Beach Sign Code by January 29, 1988, and that rotating signs were prohibited,referring to the rotating Thrifty sign(see Attachment No. 7). Planned Sign Program No. 86-5, approved in March of 1987, established criteria for all new freestanding and wall signs in the shopping center. It addressed design elements including size, color and sign type to create a coordinated sign theme throughout the center. The sign program also specified the maximum signage allowed for freestanding signs with a 15 foot height limit, a 70 square foot limit on sign area, and a restriction on the sign copy to the center and major tenant only. A condition on the planned sign program requiring the removal or alteration of the non- conforming 45 foot high sign by January 29, 1988 was reiterated in the Notice of Action letter to the property owner(see Attachment No. 8). RCA - 4/4/94 3 ssp93-13 Planning Commission Meeting At the February 1, 1994 Planning Commission meeting, Mr. Stan Janocha, applicant, Mr. Leo Margarit, store owner of Cudini & Lucas Jewelers, and Richard Harlow spoke in favor of the request. They gave a brief history of the sign, and explained how the Cudini &Lucas business was located in a building not easily visible from the street. Mr. Harlow also suggested that the Commission continue the item until the City Council Sign Committee completed the sign code rewrite. There was no one who spoke in opposition to the request. At the meeting, staff also provided a sign alternative for the purpose of Planning Commission discussion. The alternative consisted of a 15 foot high, 100 square foot double pole sign with four(4)tenant panels (see Attachment No.3)providing street exposure for all four(4)tenants, including Cudini &Lucas. As discussed in the Planning Commission staff report dated February 1, 1994, staff believes that a 15 foot high sign would be compatible with other signs on surrounding commercial properties. The sign would comply with all other sign code provisions including the minimum site angle requirement for signs located in a landscape planter. Reasons for Appeal Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille states in his appeal letter(see Attachment No. 4)that the Planning Commission's action would cause an extreme problem for all businesses in the Mervyn's Center who rely on the sign. He explains that neither the Planning Division nor City Council have pursued the revision of the sign ordinance,which the Council as a whole has been demanding. Finally, he states that the Chamber of Commerce has been excluded from providing day-to-day input in this matter. Suminau Staff recommends that the request to retain the 45 foot high pylon sign and permit the Cudini& Lucas sign face change be denied due to its excessive size, and its incompatibility with surrounding signs that have been modified to conform with the current code. The 624 square foot freestanding sign is approximately 900 percent over what is currently permitted under the Huntington Beach Sign Code, and is not proportionate with the shopping center. Furthermore, the property owner has had ample time to comply with the previous conditions imposed over eight(8) years ago. The two (2)year amortization period that the property owner received in 1986, actually resulted in the use of the sign for six(6) additional years. The sign currently provides identification for four(4) different businesses with between 140 and 260 square feet of sign copy for each business. This exceeds the amount of signage permitted on other commercial properties. By denying this special sign permit,the property owner will be required to comply with Code and the previous conditions imposed under Administrative Review No. 85-55 and Planned Sign Program No. 86-5,which will be consistent with other recently installed signs in the vicinity. Staff has provided an alternative action that consists of a 15 foot high, 100 square foot pole sign with up to four(4)tenant panels. This would allow the four tenant who currently have panels on the 45 foot high sign to continue receiving street exposure. A 15 foot high sign would be RCA- 4/4/94 4 ssp93-13 compatible with other signs on surrounding commercial properties, including the recently approved Rally's sign(12 foot high). A new freestanding sign would be required to be placed in a landscape planter while complying with the minimum site angle visibility requirements. Environmental Status This project is categorically exempt pursuant to Class 15, Section 15315 of the California Environmental Quality Act. FUNDING SOURCE: Not applicable ALTERNATIVE ACTION: The City Council may make one of the following motions: A. "Approve Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 as requested by the applicant with findings and conditions of approval:" or B. "Approve Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 (staff alternative) as modified by staff with findings and conditions of approval." ATTACHMENTS: 1. Area Map 2 Site plan and sign elevation dated October 6, 1993 3. Sign elevation(staff alternative) 4. Appeal memo from Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille dated February 2, 1994 5. Minutes of the February 1, 1994 Planning Commission meeting (Findings for Denial) 6. Planning Commission Staff Report dated February 1, 1994 7. Administrative Review No. 85-55 8. Planned Sign Program No. 86-5 9. Draft findings and conditions of approval (Applicant's request) 10. Draft findings and conditions of approval (Staff alternative) MTU:MSF:WC:lp RCA- 4/4/94 5 ssp93-13 16 ROLSA ARGM d4 p7 • � 8 tA' MC F aN v� � I • CENTER IDINGRR ♦ ' HEIL WARNER SLATER s �(+ • • ' iALBERT ♦ _ atlas ♦ — _ — — _ _ .GARFIELD MERVYN'S `• voprm" i U ^� • ADAMS R I �` N ,INDIANAPOLIS nYX ON ....::................................ V ATLANTA m HAM ' D N IAAMQTON DAMS SI N BANNING ATTACHMENT NO. m SSP 93- 13 1 R� HUNTINGTON BEACH PLANNING DIVISION ,mmim;r.;�Tmm:mr. a!r:;Imrunir.nr -ir.- - - --- - _.�._._.�_ EXISTING POLE SIGN-- (FACE CHANGE) _ li R" r.-v w fr- L.._�.. .W'Uf19iUJI1!l�I__.LIU✓W.i:'-`1L';DI_:111�llLUi!'�_..rl�-�..�, ADAHS STREET SITE PLANISIGN LOCATION NOT O SCALE yciK;r'6, "A6i;PfL I aw AmEn VY `051 �. DRUG AND DISCOUNT STORES CUDINI -)CAS JEWELERS M V MANUFACTURING JEWELERS DIAMOND BROKERS'APPRAISALS D/F FACE CHANGE f.NEWFACES AREACRYLIC PLASTIC WITH VINYL OVERLe _ - SCALE: 1/2„=V-0„ COPY&DESIGN. - - ILSd[XIS7ING CABINn1 - L COLORS:BACKGROUND4g328 WHITE ALL COPY-DARK BLUE _ - - S.NOTE:ALL EXISTING CABINET MEASUREMENTS TO BE -- - - VERIFIED ON SrTE PRIOR TO PANEL FABRICATION&INS 1 - - superior - �:= AOy*es Pr'F�b 5r tGC Jf! y. Itl i+I_j; Ts Electrical advertiSinq, C — Phcne �' ILI� cn;ac a�o.aanaaT s.x _ A,= TAgr. -_Geslgner r_ �,/ �Q . I ��YM�M.F.smr}era{ 5c2i2 ^>• Dz;e F—_ 1 AnACHMEN:YNC�. 2 $TkPP RLIERNATNE TFo N�cs "DINI t - LUCAS '^ � Je VJELER $ 989 � ATTACHMENT NO.-,� CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL COMMUNICATION HUNTINGTON BEACH m 00 =i ;n 71 TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members FROM: Earle Robitaille, Mayor Pro Tempore DATE; February 2, 1994 SUBJECT: SIGN PERMIT APPEAL I would like to appeal special sign permit number 93-13. because of the following reasons: 1. The action taken by the Planning Commission will cause an extreme problem for all the businesses in the Mervyn's Center who rely on this sign. 2. Neither the Planning Department nor the City Council, have seen fit to get on with the revision of this ordinance. The Council as a whole has been demanding. 3. - The Huntington Beach Chamber of Commerce,whose members have the most to loose or gain, have once again been excluded from providing day-to-day input in this matter. 4. The undue cost to businesses in Huntington Beach is driving out businesses in local circles, our sign ordinance is known as part of our "business prevention plan." ER:paj xc: City Clerk Melanie Fallon, Director of Community Development i H'� DRAFT, 1 B-2 SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (CONTINUED FROM THE DECEMBER 21, 1993 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING): APPLICANT: Superior Electrical Advertising, Inc. LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue (northwest corner at Brookhurst) Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a revised request to permit an existing 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding double pole sign to remain at the northwest corner of Brookhurst and Adams (Mervyn's Shopping Center). In addition, the applicant requests to install a new sign face identifying Cudini &Lucas Jewelers, into an existing five (5) foot by 28 foot sign cabinet which is located directly under the Mervyn's and Thrifty/L.A.Tronics sign copies. The Cudini & Lucas Jewelers sign was installed without permits, which resulted in a violation notice issued by the City's Code Enforcement section in May of 1993. Following a request for prosecution to the City Attorney's Office, the applicant submitted this special sign permit application requesting to keep the entire sign. The approval of Administrative Review No. 85-55 on January 29, 1986, to permit a 1,700 square foot restaurant addition within the Mervyn's Center, required the property owner to remove or alter the existing sign to comply with the City's sign code within two (2) years. The two (2) year sign amortization period ended January 29, 1988, and the sign is still erected. The sign is approximately 900 percent over what is currently allowed by code and is not proportionate in size with the center. Furthermore,the property owner has had ample time to comply with the previous conditions imposed over eight(8) years ago. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Due to the size of the sign and the previous requirement to comply with the City's sign code by January of 1988, staff recommends the Planning Commission deny the request to allow the freestanding sign and the sign face change with findings. THE PUBLIC HEARING WAS OPENED. Stan Janocha, 20781 Hunter Lane, applicant, submitted a letter to the Commission. Mr. Janocha gave a brief history of the sign, and urged the Commission to approve the request. A`TTA0 , (mil PC Minutes - 6/15/93 4 (KL001) DRAFT Leo L. Margarit, Cudini & Lucas Jewelers, 9891 Adams Avenue, store owner, stated that his business is not easily visible from the street. He asked the Commission to approve their request. Richard Harlow, 211 Main Street, representing applicant, asked the Commission to approve the request, and if they did not to continue the request until the City Council Sign Committee finishes their sign code rewrite. THERE WERE NO OTHER PERSONS PRESENT TO SPEAK FOR OR AGAINST THE REQUEST AND THE PUBLIC HEARING WAS CLOSED. A MOTION WAS MADE BY BIDDLE, SECOND BY COOK TO DENY SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 WITH FINDINGS FOR DENIAL, BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: Cook, Gorman,Dettloff, Richardson,Biddle NOES: Inglee,Newman ABSENT: None ABSTAIN: None MOTION PASSED FINDINGS FOR DENIAL - SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO, 93-13: 1. Strict compliance with Article 961 will not result in a substantial economic hardship to the applicant because the shopping center is permitted a 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign,two (2) 30 square foot monument signs, and each business is allowed wall signage that provides adequate signage for the center. 2. There are no unusual site or building characteristics that preclude Cudini & Lucas Jewelers from yielding adequate signage from the provisions of the sign code. Secondary businesses in the shopping center are permitted wall signs, and can provide exposure by directing customers to the "Mervyn's Center" as intended by the Huntington Beach Sign Code. In addition, a sign panel on a monument sign would be permitted. PC Minutes - 6/15/93 5 (KL001) DRAFT. 3. Due to the fact that there are no unusual site or building characteristics applicant to the site, approval of the 45 foot high, 624 square foot pole sign, and 140 square foot sign face change would be a grant of special privilege not enjoyed by surrounding properties. The existing 45 foot high freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with the City's sign code by January 29, 1988. The sign, in its present state, constitutes excessive signage, and is an aesthetic impact to the commercial center and to surrounding properties. B-3 COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT NO, 93-281CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO, 94-2 (CONTINUED FROM THE JANUARY 19, 1994 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING): APPLICANT: Orange County Environmental Management Agency (Harbors, Beaches and Parks Division) LOCATION: 5801 Seapoint Avenue (west side of Seapoint Avenue between Palm and Garfield). Coastal Development Permit No. 93-28 was continued at the January 19, 1994 meeting to allow for advertising of a Conditional Use Permit in conjunction with the Coastal Development Permit application. Coastal Development Permit No. 93-28 and Conditional Use Permit No. 94-3 are a request by the County of Orange to review and approve the general design plans for Phase I of the Bolsa Chica Regional Park. Phase 1 A consists of development of a forty (40) space parking lot,two park entry points with signage, a vista overlook with interpretive signage, bicycle/pedestrian trails, two picnic areas, security lighting,perimeter fencing and signage, installation of ornamental and native plant materials and irrigation. Phase I also includes creation of a 2 acre wetland enhancement area located beyond the City' s boundary within the County's jurisdiction. Because this area is outside the City's jurisdiction,the County will be applying directly to the California Coastal Commission to obtain a Coastal Development Permit for this area. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission approve the request because it is consistent with the General Development Plan and Environmental Impact Report that were conceptually approved by the Huntington Beach City Council in October of 1992 and conforms with the plans,policies, requirements and standards of the City's Local Coastal Program PC Minutes - 6/15/93 6 (KL001) Huntin ton�each De artment of Communit Devel o ment 9 p y p STAFF REFORT EXECUTIVE SUMMARY SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (9891 Adams Avenue) Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a revised request to permit an existing 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding double pole sign to remain at the northwest corner of Brookhurst and Adams (Mervyn's Shopping Center). In addition,the applicant requests to install a new sign face identifying Cudini & Lucas Jewelers, into an existing five (5) foot by 28 foot sign cabinet which is located directly under the Mervyn's and Thrifty/L.A.Tronics sign copies. The Cudini & Lucas Jewelers sign was installed without permits, which resulted in a violation notice issued by the City's Code Enforcement section in May of 1993. Following a request for prosecution to the City Attorney's Office,the applicant submitted this special sign permit application requesting to keep the entire sign. The approval of Administrative Review No. 85-55 on January 29, 1986, to permit a 1,700 square foot restaurant addition within the Mervyn's Center, required the property owner to remove or alter the existing sign to comply with the City's sign code within two (2) years. The two (2) year sign amortization period ended January 29, 1988, and the sign is still erected. The sign is approximately 900 percent over what is currently allowed by code and is not proportionate in size with the center. Furthermore,the property owner has had ample time to comply with the previous conditions imposed over eight(8) years ago. Due to the size of the sign and the previous requirement to comply with the City's sign code by January of 1988, staff recommends the Planning commission deny the request to allow the freestanding sign and the sign face change with findings. B -2 -ATTACHMENT NO. . • TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: February 1, 1994 SUBJECT: SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (CONTINUED FROM THE DECEMBER 21, 1993 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING) APPLICANT: Superior Electric Advertising,Inc. 1700 W. Anaheim Street, Long Beach, CA 90813 PROPERTY OWNER: Mark Sork, 1500 Adams Avenue, Suite 315, Costa Mesa, CA 92626 REVISED REQUEST: To permit an existing, non conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot double pole pylon sign to remain in its present location and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini and Lucas Jewelers, in lieu 1 of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue (northwest corner at Brookhurst) DATE ACCEPTED: December 9, 1993 ZONE: C2-FP2 (Community Business District-Floodplain) GENERAL PLAN: General Commercial EXISTING USE: Retail Shopping Center 1.0 SUGGESTED ACTION: Motion to: "Deny Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 with findings for denial." 2.0 GENERAL INFORMATION: Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a request to permit a 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding pylon sign(identifying four tenants: Mervyn's, Thrifty, L.A. Tronics, and Cudini & Lucas Jewelers)to remain at the Mervyn's Shopping Center. The applicant also requests to legalize a sign face change to a 5'by 30' cabinet identifying the Cudini &Lucas Jewelers business which was installed without building permits. Section 9610.5 (b) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code specifies that commercial sites Staff Report-2/1/94 -1- (pcsr005) with over 400 feet of frontage be restricted to one (1) center identification sign per street frontage, a maximum 15 feet in height and 70 square feet in area. The signs are permitted to identify the center and/or major tenant and must be in a landscaped planter. In addition, the freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with Code by January 29, 1988, as a condition of a previously approved Administrative Review(Administrative Review No. 85-55). 3.0 SURROUNDING LAND USE, ZONING AND GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATIONS: North and West of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Medium Density Residential ZONE: R3-FP2 (Medium-High Density Residential- Floodplain) LAND USE: Condominium Complex East and South of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: General Commercial ZONE: C2-FP2 (Community Business-Floodplain) LAND USE: Retail Commercial Uses 4.0 ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: The proposed project is categorically exempt pursuant to Class 15315, Section 15 of the California Environmental Quality Act. 5.0 COASTAL STATUS: Not applicable. 6.0 REDEVELOPMENT STATUS: Not applicable. 7.0 SPECIFIC PLAN: Not applicable. 8.0 SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE: Not applicable. 9.0 ISSUES AND ANALYSIS: Background In October 1993, Cudini & Lucas Jewelers requested a special sign permit to approve a sign face change that was installed without building permits to a 140 square foot sign cabinet located on a 45 foot high, 624 square foot non conforming double pole sign(see Attachment No. 2). The special sign permit application was submitted as a result of a Notice of Violation and Request for Prosecution that was issued to the Cudini &Lucas business owner by the City's Code Enforcement section for installing the sign panels without appropriate City approval. Staff Report-2/1/94 -2- (pcsr005) • • Upon review of the application and research on the sign, it was discovered that as a result of an Administrative Review approval in 1985, and a planned sign program approval in 1986,the subject freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code by January 29, 1988 (see Attachment No. 3). The property owner and applicant were notified that the freestanding sign was non-conforming and that it would have to be modified to conform with code unless the Planning Commission granted permission for it to remain. The applicant subsequently expanded his special sign permit request to allow the entire sign to remain. If approved,the 45 foot high, 624 square foot sign would be permitted in perpetuity. eject Description The 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding sign is located within the asphalt parking lot, approximately 55 feet from the Adams Avenue right of way and visible from motorist traveling east and west on Adams Avenue. The entire sign consists of: 1. A 224 square foot double face sign copy identifying Mervyn's; 2. A 260 square foot single face sign copy identifying Thrifty, with an L.A. Tronics sign copy on the opposite side; and 3. A 140 square foot double face sign cabinet for Cudini& Lucas Jewelers (see Attachment No. 2). The Huntington Beach Ordinance Code permits one (1) center identification freestanding sign per street frontage, with a maximum height of 15 feet, and 70 square feet in area. The sign is required to be located within a landscape planter and is restricted to identify the center and/or major tenant. The following is a zoning conformance matrix that compares the applicants request with Section 9610.5 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code: e tion Issue Required Proposed 9610.5 Permitted signs: Adams Ave. (83 V frontage) Max. No: Freestanding 1 1 Monument 2 1 Max. Area: Freestanding 70 sf 624 sf total* (includes 150 sf jewelers sign)* Monument 30 sf 60 sf Max. Height: Freestanding 15 ft. 45 ft.* Monument 7 ft. 9 ft. *Special Sign Permit Request Staff Report-2/1/94 -3- (pcsr005) .0 Section Issue Required Proposed 9610.5 (Con't) Sign Copy: Limited to center 2 major tenants Freestanding ID and/or major Mervyn's/Thrifty tenant 1 other tenant: Jewelers* Monument Business ID only Polly's Distance between monument signs 200 ft. N/A Sign location Must be in Located in paved landscaped planter parking lot* *Special Sign Permit Request The Administrative Review approved on January 29, 1986, for a new 1,700 square foot restaurant expansion within the Mervyn's Center required the property owner to remove or modify the existing 45 foot high sign within a two (2)year period. In addition, a condition of approval required that a Planned Sign Program be submitted prior to issuance of building permits for the addition. It also specified that the major identification sign comply with the Huntington Beach Sign Code by January 29, 1988, and that rotating signs were prohibited (see Attachment No. 5). Planned Sign Program No. 86-5 was approved in March of 1987, establishing criteria for all new freestanding and wall signs in the center. It addressed design elements including size, color and sign type to create a coordinated sign theme throughout the center. The sign program also specified the maximum signage allowed for the freestanding sign with a 15 foot height limit, a 70 square foot limit on sign area, and a restriction on the sign copy to the center and major tenant only. A condition requiring the removal or alteration of the non conforming 45 foot high sign by January 1988, was reiterated in the Notice of Action letter to the property owner(see Attachment No. 6). Staff recommends that the request to retain the 45 foot high pylon sign and permit the Cudini and Lucas sign face change be denied due to its excessive size, and its incompatibility with surrounding signs that have been modified to conform with the current code. The 624 square foot freestanding sign is approximately 900 percent over what is currently permitted under the Huntington Beach Sign Code, and is not proportionate with the shopping center. Furthermore, the property owner has had ample time to comply with the previous conditions imposed over .eight(8) years ago. The two (2)year amortization period that the property owner received in 1986, actually resulted in the use of the sign for six(6) additional years. The sign currently Staff Report-2/l/94 -4- (pcsr005) • provides identification for four (4) different businesses with between 140 and 260 square feet of sign copy for each business. This exceeds the amount of signage permitted on other commercial properties. By denying this special sign permit, the property owner will be required to comply with Code and the conditions of approval of the Administrative Review and Planned Sign Program which will be consistent with other recently installed signs in the vicinity. Staff has provided an alternative for discussion which includes a 15 foot high, 100 square foot double pole sign with four(4)tenant panels. The alternative will provide exposure for all four (4)tenants while remaining compatible with other signs in the immediate vicinity. 10.0 RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission deny Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 with the following findings for denial: FINDINGS FOR DENIAL - SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO, 93-13 : 1. Strict compliance with Article 961 will not result in a substantial economic hardship to the applicant because the shopping center is permitted a 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign, and each business is allowed adequate wall signage. 2. There are no unusual site or building characteristics that preclude Cudini & Lucas Jewelers from yielding adequate signage from the provisions of the sign code. Secondary businesses in the shopping center are permitted wall signs, and can provide exposure by directing customers to the "Mervyn's Center" as intended by the Huntington Beach Sign Code. 3. Due to the fact that there are no unusual site or building characteristics applicant to the site, approval of the 45 foot high, 624 square foot pole sign, and 140 square foot sign face change would be a grant of special privilege not enjoyed by surrounding•properties. The existing 45 foot high freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with the City's sign code by January 29, 1988. The sign, in its present state, constitutes excessive signage, and is an aesthetic impact to the commercial center and to surrounding properties. 11.0 ALTERNATIVE ACTION: The Planning Commission may: A. Approve Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 for a 15 foot high, 100 square foot, multi tenant sign (see Attachment No. 8) with draft findings and conditions of approval; or B. Approve Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 for a maximum two (2) year period with draft findings and suggested conditions of approval (applicant's request). Staff Report-2/1/94 -5- (pcsr005) ATTACHMENTS: 1. Planning Commission Staff Report dated December 21, 1993 2. Applicant's revised narrative 3. Site plans and sign elevations dated October 6, 1993 4. Sign Elevations (Staff Alternative) 5. Administrative Review No. 85-55 6. Planned Sign Program No. 86-5 7. Alternative Findings and Conditions of Approval (Applicant's Request) 8. Alternative Findings and Conditions of Approval (Staff Alternative) SH:W fC:k�j ll Staff Report-2/1/94 -6- (pcsr005) STAff huntington beach department of community development REPORT EXECUTIVE SUD94ARY DECEMBER 21, 1993 SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (9891 Adams Avenue) Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a request to permit a sign face change to a five (5) foot by 30 foot cabinet on an existing 45 foot high pylon sign located at the northwest corner of Brookhurst and Adams (Mervyn' s Shopping Center) . The subject sign, identifying Cudini & Lucas Jewelers, was installed without permits, which resulted in the issuance of violation notice by the City' s Code Enforcement section in May of this year. Following a request for prosecution to the City Attorney' s Office, the applicant submitted this special sign permit application. The 150 .square foot sign cabinet is part of a 45 foot high, 634 square foot non conforming freestanding sign, which identifies Mervyn' s, Thrifty, and Cudini & Lucas Jewelers . As a condition of approval for Administrative Review No. 85-55, and a requirement for Planned Sign Program No. 86-5, the freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with the City' s sign code by January 29, 1988 . Since the status of the overall sign is that it must be removed, it is inappropriate to consider a sign panel which is part of the overall sign. The entire sign must be evaluated before a panel can be considered. The City is actively pursuing compliance with the conditions of the aforementioned entitlements, as the applicant has not complied to date. i ; A-PI-FM-23D TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: December 21, 1993 SUBJECT: SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 APPLICANT: Superior Electrical Advertising, Inc. , 1700 W. Anaheim Street, Long Beach, CA 90813 PROPERTY OWNER: Mark Sork, 1500 Adams Avenue, Suite 315, Costa Mesa, CA 92626 REOUEST: To allow an existing sign face change (Cudini & Lucas Jewelers) to a 150 square foot (5 feet x 30 feet) cabinet sign, on an existing 45 foot high, three (3) panel, double pole pylon sign, pursuant to Section 9610 . 7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue (northwest corner at Brookhurst) DATE ACCEPTED: December 9, 1993 ZONE: C2-FP2 (Community Business-Floodplain) GENERAL PLAN: General Commercial EXISTING USE: Retail Shopping Center 1. 0 SUGGESTED ACTION: Motion to: "Deny Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 with findings . " 2 . 0 GENERAL INFORMATION: Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 is a request to aloow an existing sign face change to a five (5) foot by 30 foot cabinet on an existing non-conforming 45 foot high 634 square foot pylon sign which identifies three (3) tenants (Mervyn' a, Thrifty & Cudini & Lucas Jewelers) . The Cudini & Lucas Jewelers sign panel was installed without building permits . The entire pylon sign is non-conforming due to its size and that it was required to be brought into conformance with the code in 1988 pursuant to an Administrative Review and Planned Sign Program requirement. Section 9610 . 5(b) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code specifies that commercial sites with over 400 .feet of frontage be restricted to one (1) center identification sign per street frontage, a maximum 15 feet in height and 70 square feet in area. The signs are permitted to identify the center and/or -major tenant. 3 . 0 SURROUNDING LAND USE, ZONING AND GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATIONS: North and West of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Medium Density Residential ZONE: R3-FP2 (Medium-High Density Residential - Floodplain) LAND USE: Condominium Complex East and South of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: General Commercial ZONE: C2-FP2 (Community Business-Floodplain) LAND USE: Retail Commercial Uses 4 . 0 ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: The proposed project is categorically exempt pursuant to Class 15315, Section 15 of the California Environmental Quality Act. 5 . 0 COASTAL STATUS: Not applicable. 6 . 0 REDEVELOPMENT STATUS: Not applicable. 7. 0 SPECIFIC PLAN: Not applicable. 8 . 0 SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE: Not applicable. 9 . 0 ISSUES AND ANALYSIS: Cudini & Lucas Jewelers had a 150 square foot (five (5) foot by 30 foot) sign face change without building permits and zoning approval on an existing 45 foot high, 634 square foot non conforming freestanding sign. The business owner was issued a Notice of Vio'lation by the City' s Code Enforcement section for installing the sign panel without appropriate City approval . Following a request for prosecution to the City Attorney' s Office, the business owner submitted a special sign permit application to allow the sign panel to remain. The sign, identifying Cudini & Lucas Jewelers, is in a cabinet located under the existing Mervyn' s and Thrifty sign copies (see Attachment No. 2) . The pylon sign, situated off Adams Avenue, identifies Mervyn' s (224 square feet) , Thrifty (260 square feet) , and Cudini & Lucas Jewelers (150 square feet) for a total of 634 square feet. The Huntington Beach Ordinance Code permits one . (1) center identification freestanding sign per street frontage, with a maximum height of 15 feet, and 70 square feet in area. The sign is restricted to identify the center and/or major tenant . Staff Report - 12/21/93 -2- (7474d) The following is a zoning conformance matrix: Section Issue Required Proposed 9610 .5(b) Permitted signs: Adams Avenue (831 ' frontage) Max. Number: Freestanding 1 1 Monument 2 1 Max. Area: Freestanding 70 sq. ft. 634 sq. ft. total** (includes 150 sq. ft . jewelers sign) * Monument 30 sq. ft. 60 sq. ft . Max. Height: Freestanding 15 ft. 45 ft. * Monument 7 ft. 9 ft . Sign Copy: Freestanding Limited to center 2 major tenants ID and/or major Mervyn' s/Thrifty tenant 1 other tenant: Jewelers* Monument Business ID Polly' s only Distance between Monument signs 200 ft. n/a Sign location Must be in land- Located in paved scaped planter parking lot* *Special Sign Permit Request **Non Conforming Sign As a result of an Administrative Review approval in 1985, and a planned sign program approval in 1986, the subject freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code by January 29 , 1988 (see Attachment No. 3) . To date, the property owner has not complied with the conditions of approval . Code Enforcement staff is actively pursuing compliance of all previous conditions . Staff recommends that the request for the Cudini and Lucas sign face change be denied because a partial modification- to a nonconforming sign is prohibited. Furthermore, since the sign was previously required to be removed by January of 1988, the property owner is required to comply with the previous conditions and remove the non conforming sign. Staff Report - 12/21/93 -3- (7474d) 10 . 0 RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission deny Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 with the following findings : FINDINGS FOR DENIAL - SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO, 93-13 : 1. Strict compliance with Article 961 will not result in a substantial economic hardship to the applicant because the business is permitted adequate wall signage by the code. Furthermore, the center is permitted a 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign to identify the center and/or major tenant . 2. There are no unusual site or building characteristics that preclude Cudini & Lucas Jewelers from yielding adequate signage from the provisions of the sign code. Secondary businesses in the center are permitted wall signs, and can provide exposure by directing customers to the "Mervyn' s Center" as intended by the Huntington Beach Sign Code. 3 . Due to the fact that there are no unusual site or building characteristics applicable to the site, approval of a sign face change to a non-conforming freestanding sign would be a grant of special privilege not enjoyed by surrounding properties . The existing 45 foot high freestanding sign was required to be removed or altered to comply with the City' s sign code on January 29, 1988 . The sign, in its present state, constitutes excessive signage, and is an aesthetic impact to the commercial center and to surrounding properties. 11. 0 ALTERNATIVE ACTION: The Planning Commission may continue Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 until such time the applicant and/or property ,owner consents to include the entire sign into the special sign permit request. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Narrative e . :3.4e- a s d sign-eIevatie• s dated-Getaberr 6, 1"3 SH:WC:kjl Staff Report - 12/21/93 -4- (7474d) 12G15/1993 11: 58 3104351867 SUPERIOR ELEC ADVERT PAGE 01 O December 5, 1993 MR. WAYNE CARVALHO . . City of H ntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntingto Beach, CA 92648 SIGNAGE Dear Mr. arvalho: CORPORATE IDENTITY Superior lectrical Advertising, Inc. and Cudini & PROGRAMMED Lucas Jew lers respectfully request from the City of. MAINTENANCE Huntingto Beach, approval on - a variance to allow the identific tion lettering added- to an existing sign to remain as is. The reaso for our request, is as follows : Approxima ely four months ago, Mr. Leo Ma-rgarit of Cudini & ucas Jewelers contracted to have -vinyl letters a ded- to the bottom panels of an existing pylon sign. At he time this was done. Mr. Margarit did not realize h needed a permit. Since finding out about the necessity of a permit, he has contracted with Superior to handle the variance. We feel t e variance is justified for the fol- lowing SERVING THE reason: GLOBE FROM LONG BEACH, CA This is a existing sign that is set back approximately HOUSTON, TX 75' from he property line. There_ are three modules- an SEATTLE, WA a double ole structure. Mervyns owns the rights to-` the top modu 1, T-hr i f ty and L. A. Tron•i cs have the mi d-d I e module an Cudini & Lucas Jewelers attach•ed. letters' to the exist ng blank bottom module. _ Because a 1 fou-r tenants who are on this sign have extremely poor visibility of their _.storefronts from both Adam and- Brookhurst, they depend, on this pylon for- the-i r- success. - I spoke w th the property owner today and he is willing - to includ the entire sign in this variance. if the - commissio agrees, -we would like to continue this item until we - an revise our submittal- to include the entire 310.445.3806 sign. -- - - - - - - - - --- - 800.995.9099 310.435.1867.FAX i 1700_West Anaheim Street _ -- Long Beach CA 90813-1195 12/15/1993 11:58 3104351867 SUPERIOR ELEC ADVERT PAGE 02 i MR. WAYNE ARVALHO City of Hu tington Beach December 15, 1993 F'age 2 of Please cal I me and let me know how you would like us to . . proceed on this matter. Sin rely, JANOC A SJ/he FAX 714-3 -1540 cc: Leo M rgarit Mark Sork • The Prude Home Mortgage Company,Inc. 3200 Robbin Road Prudential Home Mortgage P.O. Box 19488 Springfield, IL 62794.9488 _ March 29, 1995 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH P O BOX 190 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 RE: NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING To Whom It May Concern: Enclosed please find tax documents recently received from you. Given the information provided on the correspondence, we are unable to identify it with a valid Prudential Home Mortgage . loan number. Please provide name, property address and/or parcel number to enable us to properly identify and process the documentation. In the event you cannot provide additional information, please forward it to the property address . If you need further assistance, please call our. Borrower Relations Department at 1-800-262-5294 , Monday through Friday, 8 : 00 a.m. to 4 : 30 p.m. Central Time. Thank you for your assistance. Sincerely, Chris Gleason Process Services Mail 1 TA0 2 6 1� 022 f 1 An Affiliate of The Prudential Insurance Company of A rica, doing business as P.H.Mortgage Company,Inc.in Ohio. NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that on Monday,April 3, 1995,at 7:00 PM in the City Council Chambers, 2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach,the City Council will hold a public hearing on the following items: ❑ 1. APPEAL OF CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 94-25/COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT NO. 94-10/CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION(VARIANCE)NO. 94-33/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 94-12 (DEMOLITION OF THE FORMER MAXWELL'S RESTAURANT BUILDING): -Applicant: City of Huntington Beach,Department of Community Services Appellant-Councilmember Dave Sullivan-To permit the demolition of the former Maxwell's Restaurant building and construction of a new 31,000 square foot,three(3) story restaurant and banquet facility. The existing building is 28 feet in height and the request includes maintaining that building h lit in lieu of a maximum 25 feet as specified in the Downtown Specific Plan.Location_-3- aF4c Coast Highway(south of the Municipal Pier at Main Street on the oceanside of Pacific Coa laiighway) Planner Assigned: Wayne Carvalho Cos f ( � APPEAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERIk ITcNO, 93-13-SUPERIOR ELECTRICAL ADVERTISING.INC. (CONTINUI�D FROM THE APRIL 4. 1994 CITY COUNCIL MEETING): -Applicant: Superior Electrical Advertising,Inc. Appellant-Former Mayor Pro Tern Earle Robitaille-To permit an existing, non conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot double pole pylon sign to remain in its present-location and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini and Lucas Jewelers, in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. Location -9891 Adams Avenue(northwest corner at Brookhurst Street) Planner Assigned: Wayne Carvalho ❑3. CODE AMENDMENT NO. 94-5/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO.94-21 -SEABRIDGE SPECIFIC PLAN AMENDMENT,CENTERSTONE DEVELOPMENT COMPANY: - Applicant: Centerstone Development Company. -To amend the Seabridge Specific Plan to allow medium density residential development on 3.95 acres within Area B designated for Resource Production(01),to create development standards for detached dwellings,to delete the saltwater marsh requirement and delete the requirement that the area be deeded to the Homeowner's Association. A 30 lot subdivision for a planned unit development, consisting of 30 single family residential detached units was conditionally approved by the Planning Commission on February 28, 1995.Location-East side of Beach Boulevard, 400 feet south of Adams Avenue. Planner Assigned: Scott Hess NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that initial environmental assessments for the above Item(s)#1 and#3 were processed and completed in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act. It was determined that Item# 1 and 43 would not have any significant environmental effect and, therefore, a negative declaration is warranted. The Planning Commission is recommending approval of Negative Declaration No. 94-12 and Negative Declaration No. 94-21 based on their actions at the January 24, and February 28, 1995,Planning Commission meeting, respectively. NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that Item#2 is categorically exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act. NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that Item# 1 is located in the appealable jurisdiction of the Coastal Zone and includes_ Coastal Development Permit No. 94-10 which has been filed in conjunction with the above request.. (CCLG0403-1) tl _ NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING (Continued) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Coastal Development hearing consists of a staff report,public hearing,City Council discussion and action. Under the provisions of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code,the action taken by the City Council is final unless an appeal is filed to the Coastal Commission by the applicant or an aggrieved party. Said appeal must be in writing and must set forth in detail the actions and grounds by and upon which the applicant or interested party deems himself aggrieved. Said appeal must be submitted to the Coastal Commission office within ten(10)working days of the date of the Council's action. There is no fee for the appeal of a coastal development permit. An aggrieved person may file an appeal within ten(10)working days,pursuant to Section 30603 of the Public Resources Code, in writing to: California Coastal'.Commission 245 W.Brgq&4./Suite 380 Long Beach,California 90801-1450 -Attn: Theresa Henry (310)590-5071 The Coastal Commission review period will commence after the City appeal period has ended and no appeals have been filed. Applicants will be notified by the Coastal Commission as to the date of the conclusion of the Coastal Commission review. Applicants are advised not to begin construction prior to that date. ON FILE: A copy of the proposed requests are on file in the Department of Community Development, 2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach, California 92648,for inspection by the public. A copy of the staff reports will be available to interested parties at the City Clerk's Office after March 30, 1995. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If you challenge the City Council's action in court,you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice,or in written correspondence delivered to the City at,or prior to,the public hearing. If there are any further questions please call the Planning Division at 536-5271 and refer to the above items. Direct your written communications to the City Clerk. Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street,2nd Floor Huntington Beach,CA 92648(711) 536-5227 (CCLG0403-2) • � � 4 GEMDecember 16, 1993 DEC 17 1993 SIGNAGE C ;,,,.� = ._`,:,.. CORPORATE MR. WAYNE CARVALHO .,�3Jr�-�dT IDENTITY City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 PROGRAMMED MAINTENANCE Re: Variance Cudini & Lucas Jewelers Dear Mr. Carvalho: As per your request, Mr. Leo Margarit of Cudini & Lucas Jewelers and Mark Sork, property owner, have agreed to revise our Variance submittal to include the entire pylon sign. Both parties agree to a continuance, if staff needs more time to prepare for this project. Please call me as soon as possible so I can inform all SERVING THE parties the date the Planning Commission will hear this GLOBE FROM case. LONG BEACH, CA HOUSTON, TX Thanks. SEATTLE, WA Sincerely, STAN JANOCHA SJ/he FAX 714-374-1540 cc : Leo Margarit Mark Sork 310.495.3808 800.995.9099 310.435.1867.FAX 1700 West Anaheim Street Long Beach CA 90813-1195 ,,. BOARDS Of ZOnlnG ADJusTMEnTs c I/ CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH-CALIFORNIA r� P.O. WX 190.92648 PHONE(714) S36-3271._ . , 9 1 .4 ; RECONSIDERATION OF CONDITIONAL EXCEPT.ON ,10. 85- 6 ' 3 in conjunction with RECONSIDERATION OF- ADMINISTRATI`►L REVIEW NO. .85-55: 'i Applicant: L 6 M .Investment. Company ` 1500 Adams Avenue, Suite 315 - s Costa Mesa, California 92626 1 1 Z P.equest: 1TO construct a 1,700 Square Foot.,restaurant } � t addition =with a variance to maintain existing ' -' 29-8' . wide planter along Brookhurst Street and '4 Adams Avenue r g €4 y Location: Subject property is located at- .19881 Brookhurst y . Street (Northwest corner of Adams Avenue and �+ arookhurat Street ) [Z Irn- Date of Approval:., January ,29, 1986 ` fir{ � 7 Dear .Applicant Your -applications were acted upon byy the Huntington ,Beach Hoard of .' f Zoninq,;,Xdjustments, ,on January, 29, 1966,_ and-.your, requests. were , x; ' rConditionally Approved, L' t # :Ondet the provisions :of. the. Huntington .Beach .Ordinar ce.,_Code, the .ac"t'ion'-taken :by .the: Board of ,Zoning Ad justleents is' final unless an ' eal s filed ao 'the;Plannin Commission 'b ou• .or;b -"an ` 9 Y:Y Y Y interested._.par ty:._ Said 'appeal;.must_ be; in writing •and must set forth r in detail ahe act ion:=and gcounda'. y.-:which the -applicant•. or<,= s ;,Sc `interested patty deeds, himself-aggrieved. Said;appeil`'Must be a• fi-lin9 `fee:,vf .One-- ri'dreWand. Sixty five Dollars, , >> p Y . ( 165.00-)._�{nd submitted` to ttie Secretary of'-the"piannilg Cammiss3on = ; r.w:thinz ten (10) days of the date- of the Board's decision. •_ F* R .t r � aJt. ,, fEiq' '_ • tY r 1 y � t x. -4.t'S{The, laet . .- � -•'• , _ d oday ;ppeal thr i a'sb'ovenoted--appiication is 'February` B 19u0. f� T t •1 } it ti t. . z - �. h y a.yE t Z -t hex v _ -, }h . �� 't ( ,. - ` _L - F a-j I �L- 1.�Yr ' -•, 6. �ATfACHM-ENT N0 ' Page Two Conditional Exception No. 85-96 Administrative Review .No. 85-55 Provisions of the Huntington rioach ordinance -Code..are such that any. application becomes null and void one ( 1 ) year after the final . approval , unless. actual construction has .begun. FINDINGS 'FOR APPROVAL' CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO: 85-96: - =; r, - Because -of special . circumstances appl'icable to the subject " property, ,including .size, shape, and location the strict application of the Zoning Ordinance is found to deprive the subje •-property of privileges enjoyed by other., properties in _ the. 'v,icinity and 'under identical :zone classifications.. The . : . site currently• has 6 15% of landscaping and, in addition, to .` `the 2180 wide':planter along Brookhurst and'-Adams, there - is a. <y Flow garden wall, which further screens the parking area.. 2.- The granting� bf this conditional exception 4s; necessary in order -to .preserve the enjoyment of one or more -substantial -pib0erty .,righ't§ 3. The granting of Conditional 5xception No. -85-96 will not be materially detrimental to tine public " elfare, or injurious . to property '"in. the same zone classifications,,; � { 4. The granting of the conditional exception ;will not .$aversely _ -affect the, General' plan of the City of Huntington,. Beach. CONDITIONS •OP APPROVAL CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO.-•-.�85-96 `revised site plan shall. be,.submitted',depicting.-the Z�4\1 = Y �"". r modifications- described in' Condition _1 of,:`.the conditions of N J,gg``yy r approval for Administrative Review'' v�V''•✓•iT w`r5 N+ � 'S - c •' ¢ - "--r - _ .. _ ..� - .. _ e _ . 1 J, - J 1� Y,. `-2. All ,con`ditions of Administrative. Review No: 85-55 shall .be •-' j �� applicable. G t ;•;. :'CONDITIONS 'OF'.,-APPROVAL ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW .85-55" revised, site plan•-shall -be- submi`ted depicting ;the jioi iJft cat ions described herein: -a. ipdicat6 -compact` parking spaces _alongY,perimeter of the r> x. r b. ".Prov"ide 643 parking spaces. Aisleways shall be. minimum 20' adjacent to the new r t,rt�t a f ....re -spa the northeast'.corner :of .the site t' Fi d. D81ete '(five);:5 .parelle�;spaces at the northeast_.coner yN!i 4 r n of-:the.-'site ;along .Br66ktiurst. « J xf. a ,.� -,� ., ��` e•. A'minimum of :8 handicapped ,paikinq spaces, mum 14 � � • j '�� foot',in :width::; _ ttj :4 y. Page Three Conditional Exception No. 85-96 Administrative Review No. 85-55 f. Delete four (4 ) sout;ierly parking walls adjacent �o " Pollv's Restaurant. _ g. -North elevation of tke new retail space shall not have � . any, doors unless required by the Fire Department; and shall include a_ 360 high block wall. ,base. . h. Indicate planter areas Y ' i . Modify the slight jog. in the main driveway aisle ° adjacent to -the buildings to comply with Fire Department Standard No. `401 . 2. A parking management plan shall be submitted indicating ' . =' employee. parking around the , perimeter of the, site. 3. The building addition shall, comply .with. Articl'e 969:6 :. regarding floodplain standards. 4. A planned. sign program shall be submitted prior to =the .issuance _of building. permits ..and approved "for all signing ` within the commercial center pursuant to S. . 9760.43 of the ' Huntington Beach Ordinance Co4e. . All , new signs -sha'll .comply Y5. with , the. Planned Sign _Program, U _ 4 a.: ..,The major 'identification signs: shall `be removed or ` � altered : to comply with Article::.976 within two years:. F. . Rotating signs are prohibited .-,:.. 5.'. The. development shall. comply with. - all 'appl'icable provisions >> of the -Ordinance Code, Builc inc Division, and' Fire Department , except as ':noted in Conditional Exception j;o. 85-96. t 6. Service roads ,and fire lanes,: as"detereiined.--by the Fire .'Department, shal•1 be` Fosted ,and marked. _ g 4 7. The westerly driveway approach along Adams shall_-be designated right-hand turn only for:.exiting ; . roaches hers than .27 in -width shall'All driveway. .app ,r�- ,4a t - a� ^ r minimum;of twenty-sevenfeet ' (27' ) in width and..shall be of ti r ` radius•'type construction: ` 9. Thte metal posts in the .driveway along:the_•north 'side of the �sr new retail space :shall be removed . .� 7 -,'- _.i_r. :- � _ -z�yi i-` ,.,,' `�. . '. - • t r:�y =--L` r - 0. Proposed structures shall:`beYarchit'ecturally compatible witF existing structures. t . �'n4' jxll. 1111 xitash areas,shall �be .fully.. enclosed with chain :'link =,r t 'fencing with: redwood.:slats and a ..Aatchin a 9 gate. - .� A". Page Four Conditional Exception No. 85-96 Administrat,ive _Review No. 85-55. 12. Natural gas shall be stubbed iri. ar the locations ot-dooking facilities, water heaters, and central heating units 13. Low-volume heads.- shall be: used on all. spigots and :'water --'faucets. a 14. All building -spoils, such as unusable lumber, wire, .pipe, and - e .su lus or unusable material shall be disposed. at ' ,.Y �oth r rp , p • . �, , an offsite- facility equipped to handle them, t: 15: The subject property shall enter into irrevocable- reciprocal driveway and parking easement(s) between the subject- site: and corner parcel it ,corner parce'.: is ever owned separately..... The Department of Development 'Secvices will perform; comprehensive 4 ? plan *theck relating to;all Ordinance Code requirements 'upon .: s., submittal 'of"your compI;eted structural drawings . ,. , , Please be advised that the Board '.of Zoning Adjustments reviews the is 'conceptual, plan as �a basic. request for entitlement. of the,_use. r Y applied fnr -in r�Iation- o ;the ;Vicinity in which it ,i§ prc+posed. :The,conceptual �.an should not:-,be construed as precise plan ;a jeflecting- conformance •toi, all :Ordinance Code requirements' 5. IIt is;' recommended, that you ' immediately. pursue completion. of the ;. Conditions of. .Approval a'nd address all requirements: of the 'RuntirAton.,'Beach,Ordinance:•Code< in cyder to expedite the processing of -.your total•`applfcation.; ,. ,d I hereby :cert•ify that -Conditional. Exception No. 85-96 '.ands .' a ; = Administrative Review No. 85=55 -were Condi-tionally Approved by th"e oard-:of -Zoning .Ad ustments of the Cit B j y bf Huntington• Beach, t Califor.nia,'- on January'-29, 1986., upon .the fore4oinq,-condi;tions•.:and citations.. r a , . .Very truly yours, „ :,� �; i } Ar •Tyr } � Ij�}) � _ � r .ice �_� a'' � � a f '.Glen:Godf cey; .Secretary sr L t, ' ' Board Hof:Zoning Adjustments J. t _._�. ..:.r... . ;•«s�-,.-,,..._,,.. x.:::'_ ,.. .. . ..• �_ ,;.tom .. � ... •a,� , t CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MA:N STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES BUILDING :)IVISION (714)536-5241 PLANNING DIVISION (714) 536-5271 March 16, 1987 :dark Sork 1.500 Adams Avenue Ste. 315 Costa Mesa, CA 9262:6 Subject : Planned Sign Program ro . 86-5 Dear Mr . Sark: The Planned Sign Program dated September 29-, 1986 submitted for the Mervyn' s Shopping Center has been reviewed and approved with some modifications by thc. Department of Development Services . Please reference Administrative Review No. 85-55 containing a condition requiring the eventual removal of the major identification signs which you agreed to do. This requirement has been reiterated in the modified Planned Sign Program. The following standards shall govern all freestanding and wall signage within the shopping center. Any changes , alteration, or revision to PSP No . 86-5 shall be reviewed and approved by the Director of Development Services prior to the issuance of applicable permits or the erection or alteration of such signs within the development. FREESTANDING SIGN REQUIREMENTS: A. The following freestanding sign criteria shall be the approved specific requirements.: 1. The -ma-jor identification- signs -shall be removed or altered to comply with Article 961 by January 29, 1988 -as required by Condition of Approval No. 42. of Administrative Review No . 85-55 . -The following requirements shall -pertain to the - new freestanding signs . a . Two center identification signs shall be allowed, one on each street - f r-ontage. `- b. Maximum might shall be fifteen (15) feet . c:. Maximum sign area shall be seventy (70) square feet . d.. Copy shall be limited to center and major tenant , identification. e. Signs shall comply in all other requirements for freestanding signs given in the Huntington Beach Sign Code. -- --- - - --- 'AT ACHMENT NO. Page Two Tanned Sign Program No. 86-5 2 . The existing secondary business identification signs for Polly' s and Coast S&L may rem;A n. 3 . The maximum number of freestanding signs on site shall be four (4) , including two (2) renter identification signs and two (2) secondary business identification signs . WALL STGNI'-GE REQUIREMENTS B. The following. wall sign criteria shall be "the approved specific requirements for- all new signs -or changes. in any existing wall signs . 1. No sign shall be installed, erected, altered, or reconstructed without prior City approval and -* ssuance of appropriate Building Division permits . a. Prior to submittal for plan check and issuance of permits, the sign plans must be approved by the owner or owner ' s representative. b. UL listed housings shall be required for all wall signage. 2 . Each tenant shall be permitted one internally illuminated individual channel letter sign located on the building front. Tenants with a corner unit will be permitted two wall signs, which will not exceed the maximum sign area for business frontage per Section 9160 . 5 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. a. Copy shall be limited -to the establishment ' s name and/or product name. • b.- Box-type- or can signs shall be -architecturally _integrated with wall or facia board. c. Exposed neon co_nduit,- tubing -or raceway signs _are prohibited: 3 . Each sign, including logo, shall be centered on the fascia vertically and horizontally- and conform to the following : a. Maximum letter. height for all- establishments shall be 18 inches for individual letters . b. Upper and lower case. letters from top of the ascender : to the bottom of descender shall not exceed 32 inches in overall height . f , r 'Dage Three:. . -anned Sign Program No. 86-5 c. Letter he'.1ght shall not be less than 12 inches high. d. Two -lines of copy will be permitted on small store-fronts provided the combined letter height including apace between words- does not exceed 32 inches in height. e. Letter return or eepth shall be 5 inches . f . Trim cap and let".er return color shall be dark brawn. g. Sign length shall not exceed 70 percent of the leasehold width. - h. Maximum sign area shall not exceed that permitted under Section 9610 . 5 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. C. No tenant shall affix or maintain upon the exterior:.walls of the premises or the buildings or in the parking lot and landscape areas any signs other than as permitted herein except with the City and landlord ' s approvals . J. All signs fabricated and installed in this shopping center will harmonize with the design standards of the entire shopping renter and all co-tenants . If you have any questions Zegarding this matter, please do not hesitate to contact Pam Posten at 536-5271. Sincerely, Jacnes W. Palin Director by: -- Glen_ Godfrey - Deputy 'for Planning - JWP:GG:PP: jr (7538d) ATTACHMENT NO, ALTERNATIVE FINDINGS AND CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO.93-13 (Applicant's Request) FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL- SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13: 1. Strict compliance with Article 961 will result in substantial economic hardship to the applicant because the existing 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding sign is necessary for identification of the businesses in the shopping center. The location of the building is approximately 200 feet from Adams Avenue,which does not provide adequate street exposure. 2. There are unusual site or building characteristics that preclude the various businesses from yielding adequate signage from the provisions of the sign code. The location and orientation of the commercial building on the northern side of the property does not provide adequate business exposure on Adams Avenue. 3. Due to the fact that there are special site or building conditions applicable to the site, approval of the 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding sign is necessary to enjoy sign provisions enjoyed by other businesses in the immediate vicinity. 4. The existing 45 foot high, 624 square foot freestanding sign and 140 square foot sign face change will not adversely affect other signs in the area,nor will the sign obstruct pedestrian or vehicular traffic vision. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL-SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13: 1. The site plan and sign elevations received and dated October 6, 1993, shall be the conceptually approved layout with the following modifications: a. All rotating signs shall be permanently affixed. b. A landscape planter shall be provided at the base of the sign poles. Detailed plans shall be provided depicting compliance with the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code parking stall requirements. 2. Building and electrical permits shall be obtained within 30 days from the date of this approval. 3. This special sign permit shall not become effective until and "Acceptance of Conditions" form has been signed and notarized by the applicant, and returned to the Planning Division; and until the ten (10)day appeal period has elapsed. 4. The Planning Commission reserves the right to rescind this special sign permit approval in the event of any violation of the applicable zoning laws. Any such decision shall be preceded by notice to the applicant and a public hearing, and shall be based on specific findings. (pcsr005) • • ATTACHMENT NO.SO ALTERNATIVE FINDINGS AND CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO,93-13 (Staff Alternative) FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL-SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13: 1. Strict compliance with Article 961 will result in substantial economic hardship to the applicant because the proposed 15 foot high, 100 square foot freestanding sign is necessary for identification of the businesses in the shopping center. The location of the building is approximately 200 feet from Adams Avenue,which does not provide adequate street exposure. 2. There are unusual site or building characteristics that preclude the various businesses from yielding adequate signage from the provisions of the sign code. The location and orientation of the commercial building on the northern side of the property does not provide adequate business exposure on Adams Avenue. 3. Due to the fact that there are special site or building conditions applicable to the site, approval of the 15 foot high, 100 square foot freestanding sign is necessary to enjoy sign provisions enjoyed by other businesses in the immediate vicinity. 4. The proposed 15 foot high, 100 square foot freestanding sign will not adversely affect other signs in the area, nor will the sign obstruct pedestrian or vehicular traffic vision. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL- SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO.93-13: 1. The site plan and sign elevations received and dated October 6, 1993, shall be the conceptually approved layout with the following modifications: a. Maximum height of the sign shall be 15 feet with 100 square feet of sign area including four(4), 25 square foot tenant panels. b. The sign shall be located in a landscape planter. Detailed plans shall be provided depicting compliance with the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code parking stall requirements. 2. Building and electrical permits shall be obtained within 30 days from the date of this approval. 3. This special sign permit shall not become effective until and "Acceptance of Conditions" form has been signed and notarized by the applicant,and returned to the Planning Division; and until the ten (10)day appeal period has elapsed. 4. The Planning Commission reserves the right to rescind this special sign permit approval in the event of any violation of the applicable zoning laws. Any such decision shall be preceded by notice to the applicant and a public hearing, and shall be based on specific findings. (pcsr005) NOTICE OF CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARINto APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (45 Foot High Pylon Sign) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center,2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive,and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATEMME: Monday,April 4, 1994,7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Appeal of the Planning Commission's denial of Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 APPLICANT: Superior Electrical Advertising,Inc. APPELLANT: Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue(northwest corner at Brookhurst) ZONE: C2-FP2(Community Business District-Floodplain) REVISED REQUEST: To permit an existing,non conforming 45 foot high,624 square foot double pole pylon sign to remain in its present location and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini and Lucas Jewelers,in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15315, Class 15 of the California Environmental Quality Act. COASTAL STATUS: Not applicable ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Community Development Department,2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. A copy of the staff report will be available to interested parties at City Hall or the Main City Library(7111 Talbert Avenue)after April 1, 1994. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. Written communications may also be sent to the City Clerk. If you challenge the City Council's action in court,you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at,or prior to,the public hearing. If there are any further questions please call Wayne Carvalho,Assistant Planner at 536-5271. Connie Brockway wc1p0217 Huntington Beach City Clerk �• NOTICE OF CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARIIN APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (45 Foot High Pylon Sign) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center,2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California,on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATEIDME: Monday,April 4, 1994, 7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Appeal of the Planning Commission's denial of Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 APPLICANT: Superior Electrical Advertising,Inc. APPELLANT: Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue(northwest corner at Brookhurst) ZONE: C2-FP2(Community Business District-Floodplain) REVISED REQUEST: To permit an existing,non conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot double pole pylon sign to remain in its present location and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini and Lucas Jewelers,in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high,70 square foot freestanding sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15315, Class 15 of the California Environmental Quality Act. COASTAL STATUS: Not applicable ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Community Development Department,2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. A copy of the staff report will be available to interested parties at City Hall or the Main City Library(7111 Talbert Avenue)after April 1, 1994. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. Written communications rhay also be sent to the City Clerk. If you challenge the City Council's action in court,you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at,or prior to,the public hearing. If there are any further questions please call Wayne Carvalho,Assistant Planner at 536-5271. Connie Brockway Huntington Beach City Clerk j wdp0217 NOTICE OF CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARIN APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (45 Foot High Pylon Sign) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center,2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE/TIME: Monday,April 4, 1994, 7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Appeal of the Planning Commission's denial of Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 APPLICANT: Superior Electrical Advertising,Inc. APPELLANT: Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue(northwest corner at Brookhurst) ZONE: C2-FP2(Community Business District-Floodplain) REVISED REQI EST: To permit an existing,non conforming 45 foot high,624 square foot double pole pylon sign to remain in its present location and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini and Lucas Jewelers,in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high,70 square foot freestanding sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15315, Class 15 of the California Environmental Quality Act. COASTAL STATUS: Not applicable ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Community Development Department,2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. A copy of the staff report will be available to interested parties at City Hall or the Main City Library(7111 Talbert Avenue) after April 1, 1994. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. Written communications may also be sent to the City Clerk. If you challenge the City Council's action in court,you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at,or prior to,the public hearing. If there are any further questions please call Wayne Carvalho,Assistant Planner at 536-5271. Connie Brockway Huntington Beach City Clerk r __ wc1p0217 NOTIC F CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARI APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (45 Foot High Pylon Sign) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center,2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California,on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE/TIME: Monday,April 4, 1994,7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Appeal of the Planning Commission's denial of Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 APPLICANT: Superior Electrical Advertising,Inc. APPELLANT: Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue(northwest comer at Brookhurst) (Z )NE: C2-FP2(Community Business District-Floodplain) REVISED REQUEST: To permit an existing,non conforming 45 foot high,624 square foot double pole pylon sign to remain in its present location and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini and Lucas Jewelers,in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15315, Class 15 of the California Environmental Quality Act. COASTAL STATUS: Not applicable ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Community Development Department, 2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. A copy of the staff report will be available to interested parties at City Hall or the Main City Library(7111 Talbert Avenue) after April 1, 1994. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit I evidence for or against the application as outlined above. Written communications may also be sent to the City Clerk. If you challenge the City Council's action in court,you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at,or prior to,the public hearing. If there are any further questions please call Wayne Carvalho,Assistant Planner at 536 5271. ,h Connie Brockway Huntington Beach City Clerk r __ WaPosi7 151 401 0y 1 !�l 401 i u i Si 401 i i j a-I�oigne2 .w� i Anthony George Evelyn M Andamo 9741 Olympic Dr &�• 9751 Olympic Dr • 9761 Olympic Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 151 40401 (A�� 151 46101 5 151 461 02 6 Toshiki Takata Woodrow Keathley 9762 Olympic Dr 9781 Olympic Dr 9791 Olympic Dr (511-1 Huntington Beach CA 92646p g Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 151 461 03 151 461 04 151 461 05 9 Lorie Grange V Pacita H Malapira Girard M Manke 9801 Olympic Dr 9812 Olympic Dr 9802 Olympic Dr eq— Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 151 461 06 10 151 461 U7^----'\ 11 151 461 22 ]2 Roy NHanaoka Hsi-H an a Lt 2nd 9792 Olympic Dr 9782 ly � ��" 8075 W 3rd St #530 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Hiin ' B ch A 92646 Los Angeles CA 90048 151 461 24 1 151 461 28 p� 14 153 17101 C4-4 5 Shell Oil Co Q Nevada Investment Holdings Inc Allan A Fainbarg Po Box 2099 220 Congress Park Dr 890 Baker St#200 Houston TX 77252 -Delray Beach FL 33445 Costa Mesa CA 92626 153 17102 16' ( 1530606 17 153 406 07 18 Fainbarg Allan A Co {� Craig M Spier OJ\ Ricardo&Irma Castaneda 890 Baker St#200 v _ 19861 Keswick Ln 19865 Keswick Ln Costa Mesa CA 92626 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 406 08 19 153 406 09 20 153 406 37 ((��, 21 Jonathan L Dawson' Isabelle Trang Ngo -� Yolanda S Cotes" 19869 Keswick Ln 14 Fallbrook Q 19886 Vermont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Irvine CA 92714 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 406 38 22 153 406 39 23 153 406 40 �1 24 Leonard C Hilts 0 Fred Feodor Alkhoutoff �� Jill Ann Putnam. C?�� 19890 Vermont Ln 19894 Vermont Ln 19898 Vermont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 406 41 25 ( 153 406 42 26 1r 153 406 43 t� 27 Dan Daryl Walters o�1'1 Rosalie M Metzger Leonard Ross Russo 19902 Vermont Ln 19081 Mathew Cir 8041 E Bynum St Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Long Beach CA 90808 i 153 406 44 28 153 406 45 29 15340646 30 Wassim F Zaky Arthur A Fliege 6\ Robert H Bennett 17065 N9arina Bay Dr 6402 Antrim Cir 19922 Vermont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92649 Huntington Beach CA 92647 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 406 47 31 153 406 48 32 153 406 49 33 Jose Luis Franco �� Wil ' Rachel Kro"f- Robert J Parke b� l _ ID GJ2 • 1 A a et O 6111 Jasonwood Dr Huntington Beach CA 9�#H- ISes•�A 1—:4—QR 9 VMVV40 Huntington Beach CA 92648 aZb i . i G 1 I Z&4 to 153 406 50 3 153 406 51 35 153 406 52 36 Albert B Hebert Phau Quy Bui 04 Greg&Valerie Viers K 19938 Vermont Ln 19942 Vermont Ln 9731 Adams Ave Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 40 3 37 153 406 54 38 153 406 55 39 Gordon me a�^ James A&Catherine A Abshier Mark A Mayes 1993� K 9723 Adams Ave O 9719 Adams Ave Hu Mgt ch CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 406 73 40 15341501 41 153 415 02 �� 42 Huntington Continental Townhou Randy L Miller /ryi�--� Jean R Franke 9635 Cornwall Dr 9864 Continental Dr �/" 18212 Muir Woods Ct Huntington Beach CA 92646 Q Huntington Beach CA 92646 Fountain Valley CA 92708 153 415 03 43 153 415 04 �� 44 153 415 05 45 Dolores I Coolidge Jean R Franke Clifton R Reed 9872 Continental Dr 18212 Muir Woods Ct 9880 Continental Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Fountain Valley CA 92708 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 06 46`/ 153 415 07 47 153 415 08 48 Amer Jneid O`er Grant H Wilson Jr. 6 Richard L Gerhold 49884 Continental Dr 9888 Continental Dr 2946 E Pembroke Ct Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Fullerton CA 92631 153 415 09 49 153 415 10 50 153 415 11 51 Cynthia L Swanson Nick Riggs Ghaboos Hamidi O 9681 Toucan Ave 9908 Continental Dr . 9912 Continental Dr Fountain Valley CA 92708 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 12 52 153 415 13 53 153 415 14 54 Ernest.A Pellegrini 6)4N Patrick L Buxton }� Richard G Kellehar 9916 Continental Dr 6532 Cerulean Ave D" \ 5261 Harvard Ave Huntington Beach CA 92646 Garden Grove CA 92645 Westminster CA 92683 153 415 15 55 153 415 16 56 153 415 17 57 Nghia Vu Rolando J Granadino Michele Roberge j 9928 Continental Dr 9932 Continental Dr _ 9942 Continental Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 18 58 K 153415 19 59 15341520 60 Blanca Hund Genaro Magana Martha Riggs 9946 Continental Dr 9952 Continental Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA Q646 153 415 21 61 53 415 22 62- 153 415 23 63 John A DeMarr 49-r-,�Anderson Kirstine L Cerone 1.6787 Beach Blvd O 4 _ __ re on n • 19836 Berkshire Ln , Huntington Beach CA 92647 Huntington Beacb CA 9,)64 Huntington Beach CA 92646 1 c1Z�11(LL.� 15341524 64� .45341525 65 15341526 66 �� GPrarct� Cakron � � Guinn E Lumpkin D� Charles Stidham V� 19 Ln t�` 2 �9 Po Box 146 19848 Berkshire Ln Huntinetnn_Beach CA 92646"'� Midway City CA 92655 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 27 67 153 415 68 153 415 29 69 Martin A&.Ana L Zabala_ Gordo J a n <A v Hideko Kay Masuda 20012 71 C7_ Fpn�i•�� Tyr 1 ttl =H1RE Hun 6 ton ac n A 92646 r0"y� Huntington Beach C264 153 415 30 70 153 415 31 153 415 32 72 Maureen Hewitt oK James Warren De Wilson J&Maria A Elder 19864 Berkshire Ln Birmin ,� � 19872 Berkshire Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 En a'0' Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 33 73 153 415 34. 74 153 415 35 75 Jose Luis B Rodriguez Guinn E Lumpkin �� Mildred Coker Q 2713 Lindy Ave Po Box 146 19882 Berkshire Ln Rosemead CA 91770 Midway City CA 92655 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 36 76 153 415 37 77 153 415 38 8 James Earl Nackey (-4 Jeanette LaCour Cheryl A Perry KI 19841 Berkshire Ln 19843 Berkshire Ln 19847 Berkshire Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 39 79 153 415 40 80 153 415 41 1 Andrew J Acosta 6W-- Neria Yomtoubian Ricky G Denney () 19851 Berkshire Ln Po Box 3595 19859 Berkshire Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Newport Beach CA 92659 Huntington Beach CA 92646 I 153 415 42 82 ' 153 415 43 83 153 415 44 4 Roger F&Joanne M Monteen Kenneth W Newland Lawrence Schultz 04 802 River Rock Blvd ( 1836 Iowa St �� 9945 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 3712z1 ` Costa Mesa CA 92626 Huntington Beach.CA 92646 153 41545 85 153 415 46 153 415 47 C 87 Ezra Lai Sendler Tseitlin Thomas P&Nancy L Hughes 9941 Cornwall Dr 9937 Cornwall Dr 9933 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 48 88 153 415 49 89 153 415 50 90 Gloria 1\larie Quick Sherri I Foster j` Joan Poirier d4 9929 Cornwall Dr � 9351 Velardo Dr D(I 9921 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 151415 51 91 153 415 52 92 153 415 3 93 Billy H Thomas �I�ol :ic Ml)Wq 1 Alfre C i en 21972 Yellowstone Ln 1$8 ingod Ln L ev14 1985 K' to d Ln El Toro CA 92630 ntm ton Beach CA -646 H ach CA 92646 0WN 127 A.-a- AVE • �'•V . CIA 153 415 54 94 153 415 55 95 153 415 56 96 Ellen Zakour O� Michael Ray Gustaveson Jan A Van Oosten 19850 Kingswood Ln 19846 Kingswood Ln 19844 Kingswood Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 i 153 415 57 97 153 415 58 98 153 415 59 99 �laa-F-esi�r ��}fie �Jfe'jItSAwt Raul Velesquez �� Philip D Warner n REV.. 19831 Kingswood Ln 10041 Beverly Dr Hu*+in 4.9 RPac1_CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 �►' c 12-$bb .4 A�� 153 415 60 100 153 415 61 101 153 415 62 102 Robin A Gross Hsin-Piao Chen Albert R. McCown 10291 Jon Day Dr (0 6/, 1888 N College Cir 10151 Beverly Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Long Beach.CA 90815 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 63 103 153 415 64 104 153 415 65 5 U Kathy L Harper I Helen Garcia-Checkman Robert A Woodward 19851 Kingswood Ln "1 19855 Kingswood Ln 11943 Verbena Ct Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach-CA 92646 I Fountain Valley CA 92708 1�--- 153 415 66 106 15341567 i 153 415 68 108 Tony Khorouzan Deloris J a i Carlos Caro 19863 Kingswood Ln 19867 L rory 19781 Kingswood L Huntington Beach CA 92646 Hu gt� a A 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341569 109 153415.70 110 15341571 111 E James Wheless James B Bailey Patrick&Julia M G1asc4 26 Sycamore Crk 10061 Dakota Ave 19881 Kingswood Ln �JJ Irvine CA 92715 Garden Grove CA 92643 Huntington Beach CA 92646 1534157� 15341573 113 1534157 114 Secretary( f a ytami►+g",13,,-►;, Michael J O'Donnell Nations nc rt orporati 34 Civ' er 40 Makerwo ibe S 19880 Inverness Ln 19876 In er 'Ln Santa .Ana A.91 1 I%c,4 gg14 (, Huntington Beach CA 92646 Hunt' n B ac 92646 1534475�� . 15341576 116 �s' 15341577 117 '\�uul� Dung Ky Nguyen �r Richard W McIntee o 198Ld 12450 Bay Hill Ct 1707 Terrapin Way Huch CA 92646 Garden Grove CA 9:2643 Newport Beach CA 92660 -y 153 415 78 118 153 415 79 119 153 415 80 20 Robert,M & Roisin C Eriksen Linda A Stalford John A DeMarr 19860 In%-erness Ln o`� 19856 Inverness Ln 16787 Beach Bled Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92647 453- V/5-72 /1.3 Vi r 71A BOnINiE 11ENI AMIWA)" 47?W Pr9iPA1.4Vftfj-5 U�61671 M6;r"W4y ae. UV% ne, &MI(rWW*RM4 ee�fC,# C+ 6fun/7 IA16MN jO � 926fro 15341581 1 1 15341582 122 15341583 OrI23 Francis Floyd Butts . George Murray �• Peter M Becker 5.182 Doanoke Ave 18922 Mount Cimarron St 19840 Inverness Ln Irvine CA 92714 Fountain Valley CA 92708 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 84 1124 153 415 85 125 1534 86 126 Jonny B Rohrer ' Kathryn L Orris Hun gto ontine. - own Ho 19836 Inverness Ln 19832 Inverness Ln 1980 Bro h t Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 H o -A 92646 153 415 87 1 153 416 01 12$L 153 416 02 129 Huntington Con ' own Ho Kent R Horne ` John Attard 19801 B st St 5* 9782 Continental Dr 5081 Field St H -gton Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 San Diego CA 92110 153 416 03 130 153 416 04 131 153 416 05 04-,, 132 M Conrad Epley Jerry L Bowen \t Teri L Allen 9788 Continental Dr 5432 Catowba Ln °--� 9802 Continental Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Irvine CA 92715 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 06 133 J-1- 153 416 07 134 153 416 08 135 Jacob M Lee Ronald P Rouintree Shriver Anne D 9808 Continental Dr 1A109 9816 Continental Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 �_ 6 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 09 136 :`. 15.3 416 10 137 153 416 11 138 WALL A C E. ,f_ Beri J Miles ' ® Jerome J Goldfein i n r e6Dfc4<L i *': 9824 Continental Dr 5402 Barwood Drco u, , , -R,.;;b C.A U6-46 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92 49 72D OVA3 ST 12-7 - 15341612 F. V. C 139 °rz7o� 153 416 13 140 153 416 14 141 Sharon Rose Getz George Donald.Radabaughr John J Kiang V< 2049 W 236th Place Dr 9842 Cot ental Dr 24162 Castilla Ln Torrance CA 90501 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Mission Viejo CA 92691 153 416 15 142 153 416 16 143 153 416 17 144 William R Rowland 0 Jerry E Todd Patricia A Showalter 9848 Continental Dr 512 QU2= c. 1MD C6ay 19893 Lures Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Yu�xip -�9- ,g Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 18 145 153 416 19 146 153 416 20 147 Tan M Dang Dorothy J Rudd Kimberly Ann Konopka 9854 Continental Dr 1946 Pelican PI 9858 Continental Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Costa Mesa CA 92626 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 21 148 153 416 22 149 153 416 23 150 Claire A Chris William H Wilson �1� Portia Pao Chen &Lois Teo 19841 Invcrncss Ln 19843 Inverness Ln " \ 19847 Inverness Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341624 151 153 416 25 152 153 416 26 153 Neila S Ready : Craig R Bergquist 0� • Billy H Thomas 0� 19851 Inverness Ln 13451 Rosecrans Ave 21972 Yellowstone Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Santa Fe Springs CA 90670 El Toro CA 92630 153 416 27 154 153 416 28 15 `' 153 416 29 156 hR Margaret A Kuhn /. J gib,..st Ci,-- S`1 � H- onald E Roluffs 19861 Inverness Ln v 61 �q�AtQr�904 S Cornwall Dr ®� Huntington Beach CA 92646 H-unting;tw-BsaGh- - 9364b-. Anaheim CA 92804 -0-01 3� o�iq- ,9� 153 416 30 157 153 416 31 153 416 32 159 Martha E Riggs ®� Susan A Hawkins Judith A Bailey Po Box 86 Po Box 3204 9863 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 92648 Quail Valley CA 92587 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 33 160 153 416 34 161 153 416 35 162 Diane M Reber ,,�1 Ron Schneirson Karla Steckbauer 9859 Cornwall Dr U 1 353 Mavis Dr 9851 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Los Angeles CA 90065 Huntington Beach CA 92646 1.5341636 1 153 416 37 164 153 416 38 ®� 165 fITAlladin Khoja � Glen Richard Swanson Maureen O'Reilly 16412 S Casa Rey Dr 19858 Cambridge Ln 19854 Cambridge Ln Santa Ana CA 92704 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 39 166 153 416 40 167 153 416 41 168 Turgay Dermenci Shoya&Flory Maeji Wassim F Zaky 10092 Kamuela Dr 19846 Cambridge Ln 17065 Marina Bay Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92649 15341642 169 15341643 �Z0 153 416 44 04, 171 Raymond L&Bonnie B Borough Ethna Saunders Erick Taylor 19842 Cambridge Ln 19831 Cambridge Ln 19835 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 45 172 153 416 46 173 153 416 47 174 Susan Lynn Bisnar OK, Magdi G&Wessam Mina �� Jose R& Ines Cabrera 19839 Cambridge Ln 19843 Cambridge Ln 19847 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 48 175 153 416 49 176 15341650 177 Frances C Blakesley Richard D Hansen -t�"\ Vincent A Zamora 19851 Cambridge Ln 354 Lourdes.Ln 19859 Cambridge Ln �� Huntington Beach CA 92646 Costa Mesa CA 92627 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 51 178 153 416 52 179 15341653 180 Teresa Marie Nall Margit Giegl Gmc Ltd 19863 Cambridge Ln lJ 19867 Cambridce Ln 19871 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 91_646 Huntington Beach CA 91-646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 I 153 416 54 181 153 416 55y- j182 153 416 56 18.3 Henry L Adams M__ : Jesus O Martinez T , Susan R Head 0< 19775 Inverness Ln 19879 Cambridge Ln V 19881 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 1543�1 184 153 416 58 185 153 416 59 ' 186 Be ree e Thomas A L'angelle � Don Jea 18 19880 Claremont Ln 19876 1 t n Fo alley CA 9�708 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Hunt to B CA 92646 P 3C.101A, S ono 153 416 607 153 416 61 1 153 416 62 189� Michael G Carroll ' Donald R Squillace (3 Towhid & Rashida Alam 80 Huntington St #8 Po Box 30385 19864 Claremont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92648 Long Beach CA 90853 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 63 190 153 416 64 191 153 416 65 4 192 Ira Maurice Bell 0 Karen Lasagna Jean R Franke D 21742 Windsong Cir 4110 Apricot Dr 18212 Muir Woods Ct Huntington Beach CA 92646. Irvine CA 92720 _ Fountain Valley CA 92708 153 416 66. 193 153 416 67 194 153 416 68 5 Department Of Veterans Affairs Penelope Wentworth Vincent Dantoni Po Box 942895 10121 Old Ranch Cir 3813 Conquista Ave Sacramento CA 94295 Villa Park CA 92667 Long Beach CA 90808 153 416 69 196 153 416 70 197 153 416 71 198 -Cynthia Cummins Richard W Jantzer Gonzalo Caro Aranda 0`�__ 19836 Claremont Ln i 19832 Claremont Ln 19841 Claremont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 72 199 . 153 416 73 200�1 15341674 p - . 20� Rick&Deanna Vanderpool John L Warde (J� Joseph Keith -� 19843 Claremont Ln ( 9682 Melinda Cir 19851 Claremont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 75 202 . 15341676 203 153 416 77 2 4 Silvia F Benavides Kelly James Donohue ^ Ramon Calderon 19855 Claremont Ln 19859 Claremont Ln 19861 Claremont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 78 205 �-� 153 416 79 20 153 416 80 O\ 207 Kathy M Clark Beverly A Rapp Duc Martha C Wagoner-Le 9809 Cornwall Dr 9805 Cornwall Dr 259 62nd St Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Newport Beach CA 92663 15341681 208 153 416 82 209 153 416 83 �?10 Jo Ann Walker Amin Halim 7A- Nancy G Henri 9 797 Cornwall Dr 9793 Cornwall Dr V 17843 Bay St Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Fountain Valley CA 92708 153 416 84 211 153 416 85 212 153 41_U8b Dale M Spangle Warren H Miller --, Michael K Wil=koinson 11.513 Hala«•a Ln . Po Box 1912 12 Autumnleaf Cypress CA 90630 Newport Beach CA 92659 Irvine CA 92714 15341697 214 153 416 88 _ 215 153 416 89 216 Enrique R Rodriguez Kinh LeKy �� Sherry S Gilpatnck 19858 Coventry Ln 19854 Coventry Ln 19850 Coventry Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341690 217 15341691 218 15341692 ® 219 J �1 W1 LWek_,tM Randall R Bruno Kent &Rosemary Soughers .19846- n S?C5V;tj44G-t - 22152 Wood Island Ln 16166 Mariner Dr ac 6 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92649 l 53 41 3 2�f`1' 153 416 94 221 153 416 95 222 _ Hui gto onti own Ho Huntington Contin wn Ho Huntington Conti wn Ho 19801 Bro S 19801 Bro t St 5a �`' 19801 B st St Hunt o A 92646 c� Hunt' on Beach CA 92646 H on Beach CA 92646 u4d- 153 417 01 223 153 417 02 224 153 417 03 225 Melissa Tracy Doan William R Keller Keith R Snide> 9302 Litchfield Dr 2673 Foothill Dr Po Box 8766 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Vista CA 92084 Fountain Valley CA 92728 N i 153 417 04 04226 153 417 05 227 153 417 06 d 228 Judith Carroll Dunham James E Gutierrez Sr. Joseph C Giambrone 19851 Coventry Ln 19855 Coventry Ln 19859 Coventry Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 - T 153 417 07 09 153 417 08 230 153 417 09 231 Richard Blakeman Robert G Vouga Michael Richard Ceser 19861 Coventry Ln 9601 Lassen Cir - 19844 Keswick Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Huntingtori Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 10 232 1.5341711 233 153 417 12 234 Clayton E Weimer Timothy A Szabo Michael R Rainey cll/ 19846 Keswick Ln 19850 Keswick Ln 19854 Keswick Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 13 235 153 417 14 236 153 417 15 237 p„ rPw T R R-ak a��hef VCjj A- Cheryl R Ingraham- Jon Douglas Andre's II 19858 Keswick Ln (L 1 D138 N Parkway Dr 9741 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 9264 El Monte CA 917:3 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 16 238 153 417 17 239 153 417 18Q 240 Scott R Mello 01 Norman S Lawson Emad M &Afaf S Gharghoury 9745 Cornwall Dr 15590 Irene Way � 9757 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Westminster CA 92683 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341719 241 15341720 Z4 TS3417zI 14j John A Johnston James D&Heidi Swanson Katherine Fay 6 23 Champney PI �� H-7-Earnwall - S;Xq OLA20648 Po Box 2097 Laguna Niguel CA 92677 Huntington Beach CA 92646 9 C� Seal Beach CA 90740 i 153 417 22 244 153 417 23 29 153 417 2464-246 Joanne M Romero Margaret Brayton Scott Marshall Brinson 19891 Coventry Ln 19895 Coventry Ln 19899 Coventry Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 I 153 417 25 247 153 417 26 248 153 417 27 (-)1 249 Ysmael R Odron - Jerome M Stewart Mary A Mosier 454 S Gendel Dr - 19905 Coventry Ln 6 19909 Coventry Ln La Puente CA 91744 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 28 250 153 417 29 `k51 153 417 30 5� 252 Janette C Bushnell Brian C Werner � Larry Jay Walraven 173 Colonial Dr 8202 El Pescador Ln 11624 Carnation Cir Newtown PA 18940 La Palma CA 90623 Fountain Valley CA 92708 �4� -- U 255 15341731 253 153 417 32 254 153 417 33`�--� Ruth Massie Felipe&Christina Gonzalez Jim H&Joanne Bond 19929 Coventry Ln 19931 Coventry Ln 19935 Coventry Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 34 56 153 417 35 257 153 417 36 258 Andrzej Mania Randy M Colyar Roland Covey 9291 Woodcrest Dr 19943 Coventry Ln 16872 Bolsa Chica St#105 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92649 153 417 37 259 153 417 38 �--260 153 417 39 a '' 261 Perry Rezvan Norman Sands Diana L McCreary 7021 Nimrod Dr 5096 Tortuga Dr#202 9770 Charing Cross Dr Huntington Beach CA 92647 Huntington Beach CA 92649 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 40 26 153 417 41 263 153 417 42 264 - James N Cappellia Nettie M Nurse Susie Nielsen 30510 Mira Loma Dr 19938 Keswick Ln 19934 Keswick Ln Temecula CA 92592 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 43 265 15341744 Robert `[266 .15341745 S Rita ;`4 Kusaka Robert B Mase `-' Madlyn J Singer 19930 Keswick Ln 336 Colton St 19924 Keswick Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Newport Beach CA 92663 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 46 26 153 *4 'M9 15341748 270 00 George R Santana .- Lloy $0 Connye G Morgan19920 Keswick Ln 9341 �'' 12 Via Di Nola HuntingtonBeach CA 92646 Hun6 Laguna Nigucl CA 92677 15341749 271 15341750 212 1Sj41 1 Hilary M A Collett William S Berger b� Brenton L Lilley 19906 Keswick Ln •19902 Keswick Ln • 19898 Keswick Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 1563 �7 5 274 /L.We� 5341753 275 15341754 27f Ge eszpre �y �' 960 Billy H Thomas Christopher I Venelin16 { 1+444 qZ�1 21972 Yellowstone Ln 19891 Keswick Ln Fo CA 92708 El Toro CA 92630 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 55 277 153 417 56 278 `� 153 417 57 „�79 Lois M Meinel Stanley A Dawkins 0 Benjamin\Ash 019L 19895 Keswick Ln 71 Acacia Tree Ln Po Box 14 3 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Irvine CA 92715 Costa Mesa CA 92628 153 417 58 280 153 417 59 281q( 153 417 60 282 J Norman W Gilbert Rosario Ledesma Feliciano &Jesus Nava 17568 Mountain Ct fa� 19909 Keswick Ln 19913 Keswick Ln Riverside CA 92503 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 i 153 417 61 283 153 417 62 2 4 I 153 417 63 285 via ell Mariano Reynoso Anthony M Lucia 19321 Brooktrail Ln i4�'.�-.des;lrk T - 4j8452 Emerado PI Huntington Beach CA 92648 untie WnZ"Gh-GAA46 � � Huntington Beach CA 92683 --- S5 �A-3CAP67EAAD 4 15341764 286 153 417 65 287 q2(075 153 417 66 288 Ralph &Judy Tall />>� Natalie C Ngin 04 Annette S South i o �n V 19931 Keswick Ln 19391 Mauna Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 I If 90(�, % Ste►cv.,t 153 417 67 289 153 417 68 290 153 417 69- 0� 291 Joseph M Cordero ov� Jon M Maxwell 1�d Alfonso &Lorena Ramirez 19939 Keswick Ln 11721 Norgrove Ln 9742 Charing Cross Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Los Alamitos CA 90720 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 70 292 153 417 71 29 153 417 72 04--, 294 Fernando Rodriguez 64, Robert R Wine Barbara A& Reginald S Holly 9 746 Charing Cross Dr 1933 Republic Ave 20561 Paisley Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Costa Mesa CA 92627 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 73 �t295 153 417 74 296 4-- 153 417 75 2 Tay Tran Reginald S &Barbara A Holly Huntington Co a Town Ho 9758 Charing Cross Dr 20561 Paisley Ln 19801 rst St Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Hu ngton Beach CA 92646 Vux-cLo 60A, 153 417 76 2 8,--d 153 417 77 299 153 417 78 30, .-s" Huntington Co t) own Ho Huntington Conti n en Ho Huntington Con town Ho 19801 Br sl St jdW�" 19801 Brook t �'""`'�' 19801 B rst St Hu on Beach CA 92646 1 Huntin; on each CA 92646 Hunti; gton Beach CA 92646 sciin• , bCOL 1�95 05101 301 155 051 05 30 1550.51 Ub. sus Sea Shore Apartment Co Ltd \ Sav-On-Realty Inc o Robert H Cowgill Jr. Po.Box 5784 w ` 63030 Cullerton St •2760 E Spring St #200 vV Huntington Beach CA 92615 Franklin Park IL 60131 Long Beach CA 90806 155 051 07 304 155051 10 305 155 18104 306 Allan Fainbarg Rodgers John H Tr%southland Downey Savings 890 Baker St#200 2828 N Haskell Ave �� ; Po Box 6010 Costa Mesa CA 92626 Dallas TX 75204 Newport Beach-CA 92658 h/,8. G��r�-cam ca�uue�ce. ff'tdA/Tinl�To��fi�f, � s%mil �T�ivoc �- A44-Mr— /L S'Gl�j2lo�, E��i �C/1'L� �S'O� �R-�1 S f�� • �'3i5' AA44,A A f S T Cc,ST�t M AR C q- Ei 2"C6/ CA 909/3 LED • 4447eifvi T le!cemgD lmglz / #un/7_146�7vAI Ate - I,"+ �fun/T��Sl4ToN CA' - i �0 1�1 4tli IV i 4UI 11 s Anthony George Evelyn M Andamo C�t4•l Olympic Dr 9751 Olympic Dr C • 9761 Olympic Dr V tington Beach CA 92 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 404 01 4 151 461 01 5 151 461 02 6 Toshiki Takata �� Woodrow Keathley !9762 Olympic Dr 9781 Olympic Dr 9791 Olympic Drtington•Beach cA 92 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 151 461 03 7 151 461 04 151 461 05 9 Lorie Grange Pacita H A?alapira — Girard M Manke 9801 Olympic Dr 9812 Olympic Dr 9802 Olympic Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15146106 10 15146 I 151 461 22 12 Roy N Hanaoka �"\ H an �; 2nd 9792 Olympic Dr 9i$2 ly r �� 8075 W 3rd St #530 Huntington Beach CA 92646 B ch A 92646 Los Angeles CA 90048 151 461 24 1 151 461 28 p 14 153 17101 5 Shell Oil Co Q Nevada Investment Holdings Inc Allan A Fainbarg Po Box 2099 220 Congress Park Dr 890 Baker St#200 Houston TX 77252 -Delray Beach FL 33445 Costa Mesa CA 92626 153 171 02 16 153 406 06 17 153 406 07 18 Fainbarg Allan A Co �\ Craig M Spier ��\ Ricardo&Irma Castaneda v " 890 Baker St#200 19861 Keswick Ln 19865 Keswick Ln Costa Mesa CA 92626 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 406 08 19 153 406 09 20 153 406 37 21 Jonathan L Dawson' Isabelle Trang Ngo .� Yolanda S Cotp 19869 Keswick Ln 14 Fallbrook (' 19886 Vermont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Irvine CA 92714 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 406 38 22 153 406 39 23 153.40.6 40 24 Leonard C Hilts / \ Fred Feodor Alkhoutoff 6� Jill Ann Putnam 19890 Vermont Ln lJ 19894 Vermont Ln 19898 Vermont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 406 41 25 153 406 42 26 ,r 153 406 43 27 Dan Daryl Walters O� Rosalie M ?N4etzgerV Leonard Ross Russo 19902 Vermont Ln 19081 Mathew Cir 8041 E Bynum St Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Long Beach CA 90808 15340644 28 153 406 45 29 153 406 46 V'� N 30 Wassim F Zaky 6,1 Arthur A Fliege ��\ Robert H Bennett 17065 Marina Bay Dr 6402 Antrim Cir 19922 Vermont Ln Huntin-cton Beach CA 92649 Huntington Beach CA 92647 Huntington Beach CA 92646 I,J WO lit J1 1.JJ TVV TV JL JJJ -WV Z/ Jose Luis F Wil ' KroNA'O- Robert J Parke l ?� GJ2� 1 A q 6111 Jasonwood Drb untin on Beach CA 9?fr 6- • veem Huntington Beach CA 92648 • G�1 q Zi�`t Io 153 406 50 3� 153 406 51 35 153 406 52 36 Albert B Hebert 6 Phau Quy Bui 64 Greg&Valerie Viers 19938 Vermont Ln 19942 Vermont Ln 9731 Adams Ave Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 37 406 54 38 15340655 39 rdon me >53 ames A&Catherine A Abshier Mark A Mayes aK 1 93• Krt� 723 Adams Ave 9719 Adams Ave H gt ch CA 92646 untington Beach CA 92646 O Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 406 73 40 153 415 01 41 r 153 415 02 04 42 Huntington Continental Townhou Randy L Miller Jean R Franke 9635 Cornwall Dr 9864 Continental Dr ttt/// 18212 Muir Woods Ct Huntington Beach CA 92646 Q Huntington Beach CA 92646 Fountain Valley CA 92708. 153 415 03 43 153 415 04 �� 44 153 415 05 d 45 Dolores I Coolidge Jean R Franke Clifton R Reed 9872 Continental Dr 18212 Muir Woods Ct 9880 Continental Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Fountain Valley CA 92708 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 06 46� 153 415 07 47 153 415 08 48 Amer Jneid O Grant H Wilson Jr. 6 Richard L Gerhold 9884 Continental Dr 9888 Continental Dr 2946 E Pembroke Ct Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Fullerton CA 92631 153 415 09 49 153 415 10 50 153 415 11 51 Cynthia L Swanson Nick Riggs Ghaboos Hamidi D{� 9681 Toucan Ave 9908 Continental Dr . 9912 Continental Dr Fountain Valley CA 92708 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 12 52 153 415 13 53 153 415 14 54 Ernest,A Pellegrini Patrick L Buxton Richard G Kellehar /� 9916 Continental Dr 6532 Cerulean Ave D 5261 Harvard Ave C� Huntington Beach CA 92646 Garden Grove CA 92645 Westminster CA 92683 153 415 15 55 153 4.15 16 56 153 415 17 57 Nghia Vu Rolando J Granadino Michele Roberge 9928 Continental Dr 9932 Continental Dr 9942 Continental Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153415 18 58 153415 19 59 jartha 60 Blanca Hund 6�\ Genaro Magana Riggs9946 Continental Dr9952 Continental Dr �� Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 tington CA9H4H Be;8(c) q2 1 53 415 21 bl » Rio « ar w John A DeMarr O 494. A Anderson4 Kirstine L Cerone �/� 16787 Beach Blvd _ __ re on n 19836 Berkshire Ln U� Huntington Beach CA 92647 Huntington Beac CA 991 4 • Huntington Beach CA 92646 I c1C��,e \lLG1.� 153 415 24 64 ,A53 415 25 65 � 153 415 26 66 G��-Calderon Guinn E Lumpkin O� Charles Stidham 19 Ln (.P` ;L 1 Po Box 146 19848 Berkshire Ln Huntindnn_Beach CA 92646"'� Midway City CA 92655 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 27 67 153 415 68 153 415 29 69 martin .�&Ana L Zabala Gordo J ]� a one , Hideko Kay Masuda 7152 Ecnwgyjr#t11 �58Z 19856 er• n 20012 Colgate Cir ��H V25 Hun ton ac :A 92646 r0 Huntington Beach CA 9264 0 -6, 104 cT ZbWo w4 . 15341530 70 15341531 ] 153 415 32 72 Maureen Hewitt oK. James Warren De Wilson J&Maria A lder 19864 Berkshire Ln Birmm 19872 Berkshire Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 En �°,b" Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 33 73 153 415 34. 74 153 415 35 75 Jose Luis B Rodriguez Guinn E Lumpkin D Mildred Coker Q K 2713 Lindy Ave (3� Po Box 146 19882 Berkshire Ln Rosemead CA 91770 Midway City CA 92655 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 36 76 1.5341537 77 153 415 38 8 James Earl Nackey ( Jeanette LaCour Cheryl A Perry a 19841 Berkshire Ln 19843 Berkshire Ln 19847 Berkshire Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 39 79 153 415 40. 80 153 415 41 �1 Andrew J Acosta 6)�� Neria Yomtoubian Ricky G Denney 19851 Berkshire Ln Po Box 3595 19859 Berkshire Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Newport Beach CA 92659 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 42 82 153 415 43 83 153 415 44 4 Roger F&Joanne M Monteen Kenneth W Newland Lawrence Schultz 01 802 River Rock Blvd 1836 Iowa St �� 9945 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 37129 ` Costa Mesa CA 92626 Huntington Beach.CA 92646 153 41545 85 153 415 46 153 415 47 Q4 87 Ezra Lai 01� Sendler Tseitlin Thomas P&Nancy L Hughes 9941 Cornwall Dr 9937 Cornwall Dr 9933 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 48 88 153 415 49 89 153 415 50 90 Gloria N4arie Quick Sherri I Foster Joan Poirier d� 9929 Cornwall Dr 64-1 9351 Velardo Dr 9921 Cornwall Dr Huntington Bcach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341551 y 1 1534T3 52 YZ » b Billy H Thomas u•-H-nftn sc ' '''^`'`c N111��1 L. Alfre C i Jen 21972 Yellowstone Ln • ] " ings%v o Ln �,�/l� 1985 Ki o d Ln El Toro CA 92630 ntm ton Beach CA _646 H agisw� ach CA 92646 1C�QjI?- ELgW A2- AV6 - 153 415 54 94 1 3 4\1555 95 153 415 56 96 Ellen Zakour O� Michael Ray Gustaveson Jan A Van Oosten 19850 Kingswood Ln 19846 Kingswood Ln 19844 Kingswood Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 57 97 153 415 58 98 153 415 59 99 11a terSE&I ��"j(jf ,a,►a Raul Velesquez �� Philip D Warner rwl n -OW.. 19831 Kingswood Ln 10041 Beverly Dr , \ H 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 t 8DK /Z$bb +4�4 A"I 153 415 60 100 153 415 61 101 153 415 62 102 Robin A Gross Hsin-Piao Chen Albert R McCown 10291 Jon Day Dr 0� 1888 N College Cir 10151 Beverly Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Long Beach.CA 90815 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 63 103 153 415 64 104 153 415 65 105 Kathy L Harper G�' Helen Garcia-Checkman { Robert A Woodward U� 19851 Kingswood Ln 19855 Kingswood Ln `-''1 11943 Verbena Ct Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach'CA 92646 II Fountairi Valley CA 92708 153 415 66 106 153 415 67 153 415 68 108 Tony Khorouzan Deloris J a Carlos Caro 19863 Kingswood Ln 19867 L 19781 Kingswood Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Hu gt a A 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 69 109 153 415.70 110 153 415 71 111 E James Wheless James B Bailey Patrick&Julia M Glasc�� 26 Sycamore Crk 10061 Dakota Ave 19881 Kingswood Ln 25 Ir-,zne CA 92715 Garden Grove CA 92643 Huntington Beach CA 92646 1534157� 15341573 113 1534157 114 Secretary f o j(¢rn�ngw:y,Flonn�Michael J O'Donnell Nations ne 7 rt orporati 34.CIN'' er 4671,� ,�, D, S 19880 Inverness Ln 19876 In er Ln Santa Ana A.9) 1 ({�� q,14�� Huntington Beach CA 92646 aunt' on B ac 92646. 153 415 7, 153 415 76 116 153 415 77 117 NluN%-affaq ul�, . Dung Ky Nguyen �c Richard W McIntee O 198 ?e Lr/ 12450 Bay Hill Ct � 1707 Terrapin Way Huntington each'CA 92646 Garden Grove CA 92643 Newport Beach CA 92660 153 415 78 118 153 415 79 119 153 415 80 20 Robert M & Roisin C Eriksen Linda A Stalford John A DeMarr 19860 Im-crness Ln 0� 19856 Inverness Ln 16787 Beach Blvd Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92647 t /.53- y/S 72 I'J3 �i s 7 BOnIN1e 11E*j my W4 G A7?w PfiPw4ft of 5 OYN 6 671 HMfFAM-f ae. 0662- U(% P9 l3uA1r7 +r�14 �C,# - �htnlFiitlra�N 926� 153 415 81 1 1 15341582 122 15341583 123 Francis Floyd Butts George Murray Peter M Becker D - 518_Doano � ke Ave • 18922 Mount Cimarron St 19840 Inverness Ln Irvine CA 92714 Fountain Valley CA 92708 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 415 84 `1124 153 415 85 125 153 4 86 r 126 Jonny B Rohrer © ' Kathryn L Orris Hun mg to ontine own Ho 19836 Inverness Ln 19832 Inverness Ln 1980 Bro t Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 /H o -A 92646 153 415 87 1 153 416 01 128.L 153 416 02 129 Huntington Con ' own Ho Kent R Horne John Attard l }� 19801 B st St �e-�^r' 9782 Continental Dr 5081 Field St H gton Beach CA 92646 � Huntington Beach CA 92646 San Diego CA 92110 153 416 03 130 153 416 04 131 153 416 05 ot"', 132 M Conrad Epley Jerry L Bowen Ten L Allen 9788 Continental Dr 5432 Catowba Ln 9802 Continental Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Irvine CA 92715 Huntington Beach CA 92646 I 153 416 06 133 153 416 07 134 153 416 08 135 Jacob M Lee Ronald P Rouintree . (0:4 Shriver Anne D �� 9808 Continental Dr 1Z. 1 1410AW 9816 Continental Dr. Huntington Beach CA 92646 r 6 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 09 136 .: ``"153 41610 . 137 153 416 11 138 Dax!i3Y-fo2en y. WA"C E. Beri J Miles O p� Jerome J Goldfein i n r eb1)-Fcl<f�_ " 9824 Continental Dr 5402 Barwood Dro 4i=nn Rearh CA Q)AAA Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92 49 ram,+- 772.0 06WR04:t' 153 416 12 139 153 41613 140 153 416 14 141 Sharon Rose Getz ; George Donald Radabaugh John J Kiang 2049 W 236th Place Dr 9842 Continental Dr _ 24162 Castilla Ln Torrance CA 90501 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Mission Viejo CA 92691 153 416 15 142 153 41616 143 153 416 17 144 �. William R Rowland 0 Jerry E Todd Patricia A Shove alter 9848 Continental Dr zct�St n„a�r��gs, hS; tt_ 19893 Lures Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Yucaipa-F - 3�9��,� I�, Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 18 145 153 416 19 146 153 416 20 147 Tan M Dang Dorothy J Rudd Kimberly Ann Konopka 9854 Continental Dr �" 1946 Pelican Pl 9858 Continental Dr V✓, Huntington Beach CA 92646 Costa Mesa CA 92626 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 21 148 153 416 22 149 153 416 23 150 Claire A Chris },� William H Wilson �� Portia Pao Chen &Lois Teo 19S41 Im-erncss Ln \ 19843 Inverness Ln 19847 Inverness Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 )5341,624 151 153 416 25 152 153 416 26 153 Neils S Ready Craig R Bergquist Billy H Thomas 19851 Inverness Ln • 13451 Rosecrans Ave ' \ 21972 Yellowstone Ln d Huntington Beach CA 92646 Santa Fe Springs CA 90670 El Toro CA 92630 153 416 27 154 153 416 28 155 153 416 29 156 Margaret A Kuhn J r.�`t0 � `� � onald E Roluffs 19861 Inverness Ln v (j �q AtA5T,904 S Cornwall Dr Q Huntington Beach CA 92646 H=tingt"-BGar#-6"646— Anaheim CA 92804 153 416 30 157 153 416 31 153 416 32 159 Martha E Riggs Susan A Hawkins Judith A Bailey Po Box 86 ®� Po Box 3204 9863 Cornwall Dr— Huntington Beach CA 92648 Quail Valley CA 92587 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 33 160 153 416 34 161 153 416 35 162 Diane M Reber Ron Schneirson �� Karla Steckbauer 9859 Cornwall Dr 353 Mavis Dr 9851 Cornwall Dr U� Huntington Beach CA 92646 Los Angeles CA 90065 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 36 1P3` 153 416 37 OW, 164 153 416 38 O' 165 Alladin Khoja Glen Richard Swanson Maureen O'Reilly 16412 S Casa Rey Dr 19858 Cambridge Ln 19854 Cambridge Ln Santa Ana CA 92704 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 39 166 153 416 40 167 153 416 41 168 Turgay Dermenci Shoya&Flory Maeji (ry i Wassim F Zaky 61,, 10092 Kamuela Dr 19846 Cambridge Ln 17065 Marina Bay Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92649 15341642 169 153 416 43 153 416 44 C3 b� 171 Raymond L&Bonnie B Borough Ethna Saunders Erick Taylor 19842 Cambridge Ln 19831 Cambridge Ln 19835 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 45 172 153 416 46 173 153 416 47 174 Susan Lynn Bisnar d� Magdi G&Wessam Mina ��,( Jose R&Ines Cabrera 19839 Cambridge Ln 19843 Cambridge Ln ! 19847 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 48 175 153 416 49 176 153 416 50 177 Frances C Blakesley Richard D Hansen �(,� Vincent A Zamora 19851 Cambridge Ln 354 Lourdes Ln " \ 19859 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Costa Mesa CA 92627 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341651 178 l 153 416 52 179 153 416 53 180 Teresa Marie Wall �Margit Giegl Gmc Ltd " 19863 Cambridge Ln V 19867 Cambridge Ln 19871 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 i 153 416 54 181 153 416 55 182 1534165 183 Henry L Adams V Jesus O Martinez J�y� Susan R Head G 19775 Inverness Ln • 19879 Cambridge Ln V • 19881 Cambridge Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 ]S3 d 184 153 416 58 185 1534116597 �'`"� 186 Bet�y ree a Thomas A L'angelle �` Don Jea 18�74 19880 Claremont Ln 19876 1 t n Fo alley CA 92708 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Hunt to B CA 92646 36 z4�, 153 416 60 `187- gtS3o 153 416 61 18 153 416-62 1890 Michael G Carroll 0 Donald R Squillace �� Towhid &Rashida Alam 80 Huntington St #8 Po Box 30385 19864 Claremont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92648 Long Beach CA 90853 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 416 63 190 153 416 64 191 153 416 65 �� 192 Ira Maurice Bell Karen Lasagna Jean R Franke 21742 Windsong Cir 4110 Apricot Dr 18212 Muir Woods Ct Huntington Beach CA 92646 Irvine CA 92720 _ Fountain Valley CA 92708 153 416 66. 193 153 416 67 194 153 416 68 5 Department Of Veterans Affiairs Penelope Wentworth Vincent Dantoni Po Box 942895 10121 Old Ranch Cir 3813 Conquista Ave Sacramento CA 94295 Villa Park CA 92667 Long Beach CA 90808 153 416 69 196 153 416 70 197 153 416 71 198 .Cynthia Cummins Richard W Jantzer Gonzalo Caro Aranda 19836 Claremont Ln 19832 Claremont Ln 19841 Claremont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 115341672 199 153 416 73 200, `� 153 416 74 20 Y Rick&Deanna Vanderpool John L Warde Joseph Keith V- 19843 Claremont Ln (�" 9682 Melinda Cir 19851 Claremont Ln . - Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 i 1 153 416 75 202 . 15341676 203, 153 416 77 204 Silvia F Benavides Kelly James Donohue (�f'a-� Ramon Calderon 19855 Claremont Ln OL 19859 Claremont Ln 19861 Claremont Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341678 205 153 416 79 20 .. 153 416 80 01" 207 Kathy M Clark Beverly A Rapp Due Martha C Wagoner-Le 9809 Cornwall Dr 9805 Cornwall Dr 259 62nd St Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Newport Beach CA 92663 153 416 81 208 153 416 82- 209 153 416 83 _/ 110 Jo Ann Walker Amin Halim l Nancy G Henri C V On- 9797 Cornwall Dr 9793 Cornwall Dr 17843 Bay St Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Fountain Valley CA 92708 1D3 4Jb ZS4p �i i �� i� of Dale M'S angle # Warren H Miller Michael K Wilkinson 11513 Halawa Ln Po Box 1912 12 Autumnleaf Cypress CA 90630 Newport Beach CA 92659 • Irvine CA 92714 15341687 214 15341688 215 1,5341689 216 Enrique R Rodriguez Kinh LeKy © Sherry S Gilpatnck 19858 Coventry Ln 19854 Coventry Ln 19850 Coventry Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341690 217 15341691 218 15341692 219 J �� t,vl t.,}.J Randall R Bruno ll " Kent&Rosemary Soughers n _ pSFWWLm4a-t,. 22152 Wood Island Ln 16166 Mariner Dr tural ae 6 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92649 153 41 3 22 153 416 94 221 153 416 95 222 Hunt' gto onti Town Ho Huntington Contin ,«m Ho Huntington Conti wn Ho 19801 Bro S 19801 Bro �t St 5a 19801 B st St ��" `a.a, Hunt o A 92646 Hun ' on Beach CA 92646 H on Beach CA 92646 � 153 417 01 :.`�,.. 223 153 417 02 r 224 153 417 03 225 Melissa Tracy Doan William R Kellen '''. Keith R Snide{ ,�,r 9302 Litchfield Dr 2673 Foothill Dr Po Box 8766. Huntington Beach CA 92646 Vista CA R2084 Fountain Valley CA 92728 153 417 04 (D4,226 153 417 05 227 153 417 06 �' 228 Judith Carroll Dunham James E Gutierrez Sr. Joseph C Giambrone 19851 Coventry Ln 19855 Coventry Ln 19859 Coventry Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 07 O(29 153 417 08 -� 230 153 417 09 231 Richard Blakeman Robert G Vouga Michael Richard User 19861 Coventry Ln 9601 Lassen Cir . 19844 Keswick Ln Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 10 232 153 417 11 233 15341712 . 234 Cl ayton E Weimer C j Timothy A Szabo Michael R Rainey / 19846 Keswick Ln 19850 Keswick Ln ' 19854 Keswick Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 13 235 ' / 153 417 14 �f!� 236 153 417 15 . J'. 237 .^ =-r,e• R-�t*v ( Shef VE conpr Cheryl R Ingraham" Jon Douglas Andre\•s II 19858 Keswick Ln C�,jry7_138 N Parkway Dr 9741 Cornwall Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 El Monte CA 91733 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 16 238 153 417 17 239 153 417 180/., 240 Scott R Mello ` Norman S Law m M Lawson Ead &Afaf S Gharghoury 97-t5 Corn\%-all Dr �''� .~ 15590 Irene Way 61<_\ 9757 Cornwall Dr Huntington-Beach CA 921646 Westminster CA 92683 Huntington Beach CA 92646 1�341 / 19 L41 1D.51+1 / LU -- i Jbhn A Johnston �(._, James D&Heidi Swanson Katherine Fay 23 Champney PI .o S dy bl-Rob4& Po Box 2097 Laguna Niguel CA 92677 Huntington Beach CA 92646 IJ 9 oSeal Beach CA 90740 153 417 22 244 153 417 23 2$�, 153 417 24 �46 Joanne M Romero 15-- Margaret Brayton Scott Marshall Brinson 19891 Coventry Ln 19895 Coventry Ln 19899 Coventry Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 25 247 153 417 26 24 153 417 27 - f 249 Ysmael R Odron Jerome M Stewart Mary A Mosler 354 S Gendel Dr �� 19905 Coventry Ln 6 19909 Coventry Ln La Puente CA 91744 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 28 250 153 417 29 -�-251 153 417 30 G 252 Janette C Bushnell Brian C Werner 0 Larry Jay Walraven - 173 Colonial Dr J 8202 El Pescador Ln 11624 Carnation Cir Newtown PA 18940. _ La Palma CA 90623 Fountain Valley CA 92708 153 417 31 253 153 417 32 254 . 153 417 33-14, 255 truth Massie Felipe&Christina Gonzalez Jim H&Joanne Bond 19929 Coventry Ln 19931 Coventry Ln 19935 Coventry Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 34 56 153 417 35 257 153 417 36 6 258 Andrzej Mania Randy M Colyar �l Roland Covey 9291 Woodcrest Dr 19943 Coventry Ln 16872 Bolsa Chica St#105 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92649 153 417 37 259 153 417 38 3 260 153 417 39 261 Perry Rezvan Norman Sands Diana L McCreary 7021 Nimrod Dr 5096 Tortuga Dr#202 9770 Charing Cross Dr Huntington Beach CA 92647 Huntington Beach CA 92649 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 40 26 153 417 41 263 ;, 153 417 42 �� 264 . James N Cappellia Nettie M Nurse Susie Nielsen 30510 Mira Loma Dr ;•. 19938 Keswick Ln 19934 Keswick Ln Temecula CA 92592 i Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 43 265 153 417 44 (266 .153 417 45 ?67 Rita M Kusaka Robert B Mase r Madlyn J Singer �X---. 19930 Keswick Ln 336 Colton St 19924 Keswick Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Ne>vport Beach CA 92663 Huntington Beach CA 926.46 15341746 26 153 417 4 ?:') 4 153 417 48 270 George R Santana --- Lloyd & n P c $0 � Connye G Morgan 01 -- 19920 Keswick Ln 9341 G e w' r �v 12 Via Di Nola Huntington Beach CA 9-1646 Hun ' o 6 Laguna Niguel CA 92677 -I 1 - Hilary 1%4 A Collett William S Berger Brenton L Lilley ` 19906 Keswick Ln _ 19902 Keswick Ln 19898 Keswick Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 *Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15A75A 274 R,d� 5341753 275 lS341754 27GOC;A 1y ` ; Kam"' Billy H Thomas ( Christopher I Venelin D 16 44 0021972 Yellowstone Ln (��-- 19891 Keswick Ln. Fo 92708 El Toro CA 92630 Huntington Beach CA 92646 1.53 417 55 277 153 417 56 278 ( 153 417 57 179 Lois M Meinel Stanley A Dawkins t` Benjamin\Ash 19895 Keswick Ln 71 Acacia Tree Ln Po Box 14B3 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Irvine CA 92715 Costa Mesa CA 92628 15341758 280 153 417 59 281, 153 417 60 282 Norman W Gilbert , _ Rosario Ledesma Feliciano &Jesus Nava 17568 Mountain Ct `' 19909 Keswick Ln 19913 Keswick Ln Riverside CA 92503 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 61 283. 153 417 62 42 :74!,�Lv�o; 15341763 � 285 Mariano ReynosoAnthony M Lucia 19321 Brooktrail Ln Xes__ k, La— *8452 Emerado PI Huntington Beach CA 92648 untin pD Huntington Beach CA 92683 153 417 64 286 153 417 65 287 q?to75 153 417 66 288 Ralph&Judy Tall V)k Natalie C Ngin Annette S South fig) 1.99� T 4Ecsw 1.n 19931 Keswick Ln 19391 Mauna Ln �l Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 67 289 153 417 68 290 153 417 69• 0 291 Joseph M Cordero � Jon M Maxwell Alfonso &Lorena Ramirez 19939 Keswick Ln 11721 Norgrove Ln 9742 Charing Cross Dr Huntington Beach CA 92646 Los Alamitos CA 90720 Huntington Beach CA 92646 153 417 70 292 153 417 71 293 153 417 72 L_ 294 Fernando Rodriguez �1� Robert R Wine Barbara A&Reginald S Holly 9746 Charing Cross Dr 1933 Republic Ave 20561 Paisley Ln Huntington Beach CA 92646 Costa Mesa CA 92627 Huntington Beach CA 92646 15341773 295 153 417 74 296 04�-- 153 417 75 2 Tay Tran Reginald S&Barbara A Holly Huntington Co a Town Ho 9758 Charing Cross Dr 20561 Paisley Ln 19801 rst St Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huflffngton Beach CA 92646 • �a,na� hcv4. 153 417 76 2980.1 153 417 77 299 153 417 78 3�� Huntington Co ti own Ho Huntington Contin . o Huntington Con ' town Ho 19801 Br st St . 19801 Brook t 19801 B rst St Hu on Beach CA 92646 �° Hunting on each CA 92646 Hunti� gton Beach CA 92646 I SW nw � 6L'fJ� I 1-)j V.)1 V1 :V1 VJ Sea Shore Apartment Co Ltd \� Sav-'On-Realty Inc Robert H Cowgill Jr. Po Box 5784 01030 Cullerton St 2760 E Spring St #200 Huntington Beach CA 92615 Franklin Park IL 60131 Long Beach CA 90806 15115117 304 155 051 10 305 155 18104 306 Allan Fainbarg q Rodgers John H Tr%southland IC Downey Savings O lJ 890 Baker St#200 2828 N Haskell Ave Po Box 6010 Costa Mesa CA 92626 Dallas TX 75204 Newport Beach,CA 92658 i IJTWA Mi ,70-�l IWCII, C* s%mil �NOQV-A- A lc.X- so�lL OUM{ 2 07;Z EZ65(-�, ci4-L- isoa A--P*t s 170?5 )Y. ?qAM176Yk/ ST CeST�F MOSA cA- "N6 CA go8l3 9a 2� L . AmoAur OC,�WgD IM91&S/ rEf rtA/Tl 7o.4/ - kfu NbToH �- _ f Connie Brockway,City Clerk - ....,:..z�,,,," ,•>.�� City of Huntington Beach aa wj U Office of the City Clerk MAR '�4 s `-t y PO BOX 190 i 'w 4 i s �. HuntingtonBeach CA92648 � c� � I e CyG Q� 41,Ztl Q I N6Tpy 15 341664 19 p� MORRPUBgrF d�. Karen Lasagna / — � 4110 Apricot Dr C.3 � Irvine CA 9_7_0 � z LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 11,I«��I�'11,�,1„1�iii�„il�,rl l:�i►I11:,:E4,=i;I�=II�i;{; :�1�i:I111,:��I;ia .' i r ' I' f ' NOTI F CONTINUED PUBLIC HEA APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF SPECIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 93-13 (45 Foot High Pylon Sign) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE/TIME: Monday,April 4, 1994, 7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Appeal of the Planning Commission's denial of Special Sign Permit No. 93-13 APPLICANT: Superior Electrical Advertising,Inc. APPELLANT: Mayor Pro Tempore Earle Robitaille LOCATION: 9891 Adams Avenue(northwest corner at Brookhurst) ZONE: C2-FP2(Community Business District-Floodplain) REVISED REQUEST: To permit an existing,non conforming 45 foot high, 624 square foot double pole pylon sign to remain in its present location and to allow a 140 square foot sign face change identifying Cudini and Lucas Jewelers, in lieu of a maximum 15 foot high, 70 square foot freestanding sign pursuant to Section 9610.7 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15315, Class 15 of the California Environmental Quality Act. COASTAL STATUS: Not applicable ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Community Development Department,2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. A copy of the staff report will be available to interested parties at City Hall or the Main City Library(7111 Talbert Avenue) after April 1, 1994. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. Written communications may also be sent to the City Clerk. If you challenge the City Council's action in court,you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at, or prior to,the public hearing. If there are any further questions please call Wayne Carvalho,Assistant Planner at 536-5271. Connie Brockway Huntington Beach City Clerk wcIp0217 Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk 4' r ! P.O.Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 ..7k l ~ t RE ?4 67 7 Ana Zabala S�Fen& Dr Ll 1 INGTp �l "CONFOBgIE FA Westminster CA 92693 K Q I LINTY LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING M" °f iH _ml ?16F ?i ??ill- ? iiii . II. �:� ll?i�`lil:?. l! : I! [ }_:[ f. rJ ? �� ! JNIBd31-1 011Bfld - 3 IlON �d q I rl a oo� ti3QN3S O1 Nt1r113t1 Qt1HMtiOd OJL 3-19HNfl 3'1Id NO ti3Qa0, allvmmoA ON ti3QN3S 01 Nuni2t1 S6 T0/170 NT ESOEOESeb N62S33t1J ' y n OESZ6 VD 'aHONIS'I2 3?IV'I yp19NI1N��' 'i l SNK'I wnSSO'I9HV9a 6ZSE LS 9TV EST 9V9Z6 VO'4osa8 u016u1lunH a — q 061.x0 9'O'd Mhal0 Ai<!O a43 fo aolg0 pea8 uot6uijunH;0 40 Milo Apo'AemNoa8 a!uuoo jConnie Brockway,City Clerk :;.City of Huntington Beach : .T,,:.-.. x,.,,..-_. ...�_- .��-_.� �'<�' `� � ,• ` ;= _ Y+` nnV. Office of the City Clerk �, ! P.O. Box 190 ✓� �e>,�; b MAA 0 '�y Huntington Beach,CA 92648 i - t c i F '► GEORG R VESZP 'MY '14894 SWI �k, N T�\ (( L HU GTO 3 :'PlE� 1pp, �9F�,��` I NGTpy •'� ucy� bT NL09 POHg7Fo v�A� _.. U�. NG"1/A, O o Q Suc -9 T 2 F 0i R N TI ca LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach �" «�• �r"°N o u s ,�, { Office of the City Clerk _ �7� P.O. Box190 f,f - __ _. .. . . .. :� = �:... . . :.... .. ... f Huntington Beach,CA 92648CAL I R S T CLASS MAIL i..,� .,. l53- y 7z`• sjoINGTp� BD�NiE`#6*1 AJq -' o '7 7 n1E7h HEhiiti:?1 92b4b-1 i08 7N 0-2'?b.•'•94 RETURN TO SENDER NO 1711; t�'i�tF:C- ORDER' L11 f FILE yAA F� Q U!•?ASL�E 3_'O F_(f� t•:-�Ht=�D `n��Ofe l7 1909.PO��\(O R=Ti RN' I O -E•,[•�DER - UNTy C LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING . . lll,„II.�,IIII:,It,.II.�:(1:::!1,:,!l�:,:,,lttl,.:!!.•,li.,,l I Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach .:_.z. ,..-�. rt._...._..•......_,,,,._.w.._. .....,,.. `�i ;:; �� ;', ;;,::: 't =":Q:..1 � Office of the City Clerk =c4: , `"X P.O. Box 190 1 v K 1 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 ` I -1 c3 G ' ii! �. S � r�ff%f � t?c;;'', �¢ r c i ; t: , f• ., � :� OLD { Forwarding Ord J,a er ErPirad HUNTINGTON IN1MAL TOWN HONEi 'S �NSINGTp 19801 BROO CT ST HUNTING BEACH CA 92646 •� !i 0 `NC,OR POfl4IF ��• O -I-Jr i'�i,_i, i ! is 3':a`irS t:..'• :.5 _ i':i;.l "i i �,..i; 'ta �'•� r'i!.� i.i.•i _: •{•;i•..' :; `•1 t-�:i+ :is!S t _ -.pPT Q e i I:�f•{T!r•.�t:i L?ivl•' 'OR-4 i "ri••I:�e•4 T:iL 1 T"ri F=Lt 73.1—:.!_j...a ei �cpUNTY •°,�1 LEGAL NOTICE -.PUBLIC�HEARING iI,II„II,I�11,I{11I!IiI,,,,IIi,!,I(„11!il,!illlll!1,111!ill . —.-^mod�-r•�±i-- �• ,. ....._. ... � ... ,.. .., _ ...r., ....r�-:..: .. -.... Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach n.�_..>._� ......n... �.,.... Office of the City Clerk e..�. r . .. P.O. BOX 190 �• ? t} �' !�•�� .. Huntington Beach,CA 92648 F n ±�1 +• ;y q^ a a :I I ' t J t• •r I L y I , GORDON J MARONEY 19856 BERKSHIRE IN l HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646 INGTpy .� Q� `hCOfl POfl47F �FA ... O 7 A` �•'�:-li"+:1.j#i7jG• •:r•�t.:rl:'9`11 —_1II�:L �_q•1; i-ILL'!..LF.i• 1'r - •. i r; -TURN PRN T 5-1fi---R IF UNABLE TO FORWARD, `V 71, 1909. �F UN TY `\ RETURN N TO SENDER :•.cP LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING �I�I III'lllllllll�IIIIIIiIIIIiIII!lIfI11I I1tIIIllIti IIFI�II!1� � ' Is` i ,CityC4 , x4a rat. C nnie arockwa t Beach { WF 1 �'•;j*'�'.'„ ° i Hunting°� City° of the City Gler office 9.0. 9GA 92w I Huntington Beach, pUL S 2 I NCK S Cp 92646 L��Sj LLr � ..i�^1L�. �k:•^� 1•.:^i� `� �1�Gt_p {'-iL+='�''r`�1„t f��.Si.!��.�h �-��C.�.i3 �':Y��'•,r+�R. ; ti y tr 1,lrr,,,rr 1,lr • , �:;�_,,:_�' � ,� R��1G nrltlrrlllllr. _ LE L � Connie Brockway,City Clerk . .:;� City of Huntington Beach .„x::�,.�.�.•:�,....�..,�,..0 - -,.....,�. � � •: ,,,^: -'�us.i��:,�Wi'_''a. ate\• �F9 C L =� i ;tv Office of the City Clerk P. O. Box 1 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 g +~�G� T CF YaaD 6'7372t CAL1S ! r t!C1Eii a R Airrft NO 4 US INGTpy ��, uNK/vn —"' ►TIN A ZABALA 19582 BIILNN'.,•t,t',•.I =NC 4!! �F "`lam �� l.. ,��.' 3L1{ Y ING BEA CA 92646 13 � "��.•�}:' VLF 17, 1909. (� LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING ,..III .... . , Connie Brockway,City Clerk ;... .::.,:._.. Cityof Huntington Beach ��_r „• .N,_. �.�.� .r�,.�.�n �� tF Office of the City Clerk 4: •�; �� P.O.Box 190 Irr" J U Fa 6 = MAR 30 04 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 c. a t3 , 73s ��L I F �.. ' ; :% i ae • * a T ro -0ia, ALFRED C IEN 19854 LN HUNTING N CH CA 92646 ► , UNCLAMIASO.AEFUSEq �/ 1 INGTpy r0 LW NOAWK-SS 1, Q`—`Nt;ORPOgq�F �FA� ` �t1 __ 77y •'+ UNK140VM IT UNKN .: ENO SUCH S1;SEET C Ff617 1909•P \�O` � ,�� FppUNTY CP` LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk 1, P.O.Box 190 V V,e:.1 kd S u MAR 50 '�4 s I _ \ Huntington Beach,CA 92648 �01 0j GORDONL I 19935 CK IN HUNT TON.BEAM CA 92646 I NGTpy Q =MCURPORA,,� CpUN TX LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING {{t{tttt{t{tl{t:t{tt{el{:tt{tt{tt{t{t{t{t{{u t n{{a{t{tt{tt{{ i I Connie Brockway,City Clerk _ c Cityof Huntington Beach ` •� ioF4 �_, � ;— ,' i+ l;.y U.S.POSTAGb:mt, Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 VVV "(1 E.s G i MAR 24,'4 Huntington Beach,CA 92W + y 4 i g B'.3 C d�4TA _ •M E T3T ° S y� IL E R—� w w 4 701080 .. - .�._ _._.y /tom � �S. •.• 41552 �2 Mt Herm &La ' a ovic 19858 K oo n •irSs VS �pNtINGTpy Hunting h CA 92646 t' ', 1 � , 1 6. 'tkp Q =NCORPOR4fF '�2I� ' FcpUNTY CPS\ . LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING Iliis�s3iilt �;;{i;1��ltt�+ {;j.. = :►iAli : i ;a�a � l�; ::: :�: :: : :i:: Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 1 Office of the City Clerk ' x MAKO •94 s - 1 Ij P.O. Box 190 g1 ` Huntington Beach,CA 92648 K ��' C' A S S Fiv c.,��F. "a x as `u,o a 153-415-72 BONNIE HEMINGWAY 9671 NETHERWAY DR INGTpy� HUNTINGTON BEACH . CA 92646 /� i'...• P,e`_i 't,7. :.•; — �,�Ia�rE33.=—a.�.0 �.1•i iMll.11.. .i:Li NO FEI�WIARD [In. RETURN TO '-59—NDER 9"V!. DEB=).1909. LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING�� Connie Brockway,City Clerk u..,•�.:.. .......�..,M...�.•�.,,.�nry:.•x...xa \' i3 U a ua City of Huntington Beach �� r i � i Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 E�a:c: d! � Huntington Beach,CA 92648 � R� H Al 9 � "S' `�qQ� ` S � JERRY E TOD 4,}} .rj UA �p Fir 9850 CON ENTI� `�j C�F4�r �;tv, s Lsl� ��<JTINGTp�, HUNTI 'ON BEACH �uj,�92f`r �,✓ � F IN vjL, •yam a,4 �ppUNTY CP LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Ill,f,ll,fill1„l,i:,l,il,,,l,l,l:ll„!„il,l i • 1 1 I 1 f °�"'."".ati^".,',�T.'^" i +/or.�'s+wwt^Fi.'✓�.ivaF;sf„'+`� Y+.s�ec:Pi.tvu.f _,.......�J.. -----� l.r..4:7__._._. ..,..�. �:17sF.7�.-._t•:>ti.•.Isc�+....._ _•--a.....•.._�...r...�._..,- _..,.. ..—..___.._ - '._i..-..,vim^ .....� �� Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach a_�� :mhd.,zy:. .�.....=o. `��GT U U.,. Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 p G€ :.`$ .t MAR 30 '94 :f Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Rs LASS Fvg , .-'; j! C. t " DON J ; 198 CLAR10 � N , HU TINGTON 'litk Cji CA 92646 / "� NTINGT �%. �` � • V 77.1909•� ((O LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING ' II,I,,,,I,I,II,,,I„I,II,,,i„I„I,l„l,l„il fill,l,ll„ill,:I sway, City Clerk itington Beach ..._g �`�;��ory `�*,r�, e�`,5 he City Clerk J� Gam. st.l Box 190 P R E'S 0 R T �' MAR 24 '94 3each,CA 92648 � LASS MAIL ` ?`Tw 0 E T E R-J w a CALIF' } ! 9101080 ' 514 t c r ci a4k 1' y 39 C es iNGT � I�untingt'bn'Beac� _ MA 9' 646 MAYE?l9 426462002- 1N 03r=28/94 - -= C'., ;1 RETURN TO SENDER NO FORWARD ORDER ON FILE UNABLE TO FORWARD RETURN TO SENDER Y LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARI G � : Iti��ltt��l��ti�l16lttl�ltt�,�tt,l�Itl�l�!llttil�lth!llt,!!i I