Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMaster Environmental Impact Report 99-1 - Master Plan of Rec Council/Agency Meeting Held: 9010.A0 Deferred/Continued to: pr ved ❑ nditional Approved ❑ Denied AV A,,*y C y lerk's Signature ✓�- Council Meeting Date: B Au 2, 1999 Department ID Number: PL99-53 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH REQUEST FOR ACTION �eLs SUBMITTED TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS SUBMITTED BY: RAY SILVER, City Administrators PREPARED BY: HOWARD ZELEFSKY, Planning Director�/T�^---� w7 ° SUBJECT: CERTIFY MASTER ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT NO. 9:9-17"� (Master Plan of Recreation Uses For Central Park) M:; Statement of Issue,Funding Source,Recommended Action,Alternative Action(s),Analysis,Environmental Status,Attachment(s) Statement of Issue: Transmitted for City Council consideration is a request by the Community Services Department for certification of Master Environmental Impact Report (MEIR) No. 99-1 for the, Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park. The Master Plan identifies improvements that affect 157.5 acres in Central Park. MEIR No. 99-1 concludes that all potential impacts can be mitigated to a level of insignificance except for temporary air quality impacts and aesthetics impacts. The Planning Commission and staff recommend certification of the MEIR and adoption of the mitigation monitoring program because the benefits of the Master Plan outweigh potential negative impacts, the Master Plan is consistent with the General Plan and the Master Plan is the environmentally superior alternative. funding Source: Not applicable. Recommended Action: PLANNING COMMISSION AND STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Motion to: "Certify Master Environmental Impact Report No. 99-1 as adequate and complete in accordance with CEQA requirements with a Statement of Overriding Considerations by adoption of Resolution No. 99-Z'3 (ATTACHMENT NO. 2) and adopt the Mitigation Monitoring Program (ATTACHMENT NO.d� ,g�weej rPm✓,�S b. c� 12 yyj ��a E vn yr�o n foYi ry °�ru.�t.�A/ eh In enf No• 41 /v -h-e.1 �'), Q J)ast AM- f a,, vaq�. Worn Com.nvn•'c.a.�1 eri ,sv�i m•`t!'e�oC LZ:Zk-1 'l v��^/4as 3 coaae�Ste!!,✓�ti A10) REQUEST FOR ACTION MEETING DATE: August 2, 1999 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: PL99-53 Planning Commission Action on July 13, 1999: THE MOTION MADE BY SPEAKER, SECONDED BY KERINS, TO RECOMMEND CERTIFICATION OF MASTER ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT NO. 99-1 AS ADEQUATE AND COMPLETE IN ACCORDANCE WITH CEQA REQUIREMENTS WITH A STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS BY ADOPTION OF RESOLUTION NO. 1546 AND THE MITIGATION MONITORING PROGRAM AND FORWARD TO THE CITY COUNCIL CARRIED BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: LIVENGOOD, BIDDLE, LAIRD, MANDIC, KERINS, SPEAKER NOES: CHAPMAN ABSENT: NONE ABSTAIN: NONE MOTION PASSED Alternative Action(s): The City Council may make the following alternative motion: "Continue Certification of Master Environmental Impact Report No. 99-1 and direct staff accordingly." Analysis: A. PROJECT PROPOSAL: Applicant: City of Huntington Beach, Community Services Department, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Location: Between Edwards Street on the west and Gothard Street on the east, south of Slater Avenue and north of Ellis Avenue Master Environmental Impact Report No. 99-1 (MEIR) represents an analysis of potential environmental impacts associated with the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park (Master Plan) pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and Section 240.04 of the Huntington Beach Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance. The MEIR analyzes each element of the Master Plan at either a project or program level of detail. Project level elements are well defined and the City anticipates implementation to occur within the next five years. Program level elements are longer-term and the specific site details are not yet determined. Implementation of the program level elements may necessitate additional environmental analysis depending on the ultimate scope of an element, time of implementation and environmental conditions at that time. Pursuant to PL99-53 -2- 07/20/99 3:01 PM REQUEST FOR ACTION MEETING DATE: August 2, 1999 _DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: PL99-53 CEQA, a Master Environmental Impact Report is the proper vehicle for analyzing impacts that may occur as a result of a project being implemented over an extended period of time. The Master Plan includes nine elements which are summarized below and depicted in Attachment No. 1. Master Plan Element General Description Acres Project Level Sports Complex Youth and adult facilities: 8 lighted softball fields 45 overlapping 8 lighted soccer/football fields, up to four roller hockey rinks, 1 batting cage, 2 tot lots, 2 restroom/concession buildings and 800 space ravel parkin lot Consolidated Camping Area Improvements to existing youth tent camping. 13.5 area will include utilities (phone, water, lighting), picnic facilities, fire rings, landscaping and fire hydrant Outdoor Music Area Permanent 2,400 sq. ft. stage platform in area 0.25 where outdoor concerts are currently held Park, Tree and Landscape Expansion of existing yard for storage of plant Maintenance Expansion Yard material, equipment and supplies 0.25 Program Level Midden Area/Urban Multi-use recreation trails for equestrian, 45 Forest/Tra i I head pedestrian and non-motorize cyclist, urban forest, reservation of archaeological area Sully Miller Lake Group Facility Turf area, 1 or 2 docks, restrooms/tackle and bait 20 shop, volle ball area, shade overheads Low Intensity Recreation Area Turf area, picnic facilities, tot lot, restroom, 16 parking Semi-Active Recreation Area Therapeutic riding school facilities, turf 10 area/overflow parking, alternative site for a uatic/swim center, tot lot Police/Civilian Gun Range Existing facility to remain closed until further 7.5 _ environmental analysis _ TOTAL: 157.5 Of the four project level elements, the Sports Complex is the largest and only new park amenity. The three other project level elements represent comparatively minor, but necessary, improvements to existing facilities or operations. Detailed discussion of each project element is found on pages 2-7 through 2-16 of the Draft MEIR. For the program level elements, the MEIR identifies their amenity components with the exception of the Police/Civilian Gun Range which will remain closed. These elements are discussed on pages 2-16 through 2-18. PL99-53 -3- 07/20/99 3:01 PM REQUEST FOR ACTION MEETING DATE: August 2, 1999 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: PL99-53 The City has determined that these facilities are necessary to expand and improve the recreational facilities available to Huntington Beach residents. Using the City's General Plan standard of five acres of park per 1,000 residents, the projected population of the city in 2010 will require an additional 93.3 acres. The net increase of 136 acres that the Master Plan includes is a significant opportunity for meeting this need while also helping to offset the loss of open space at vacant or former school sites. The diverse nature of the recreational facilities is also critical in addressing the varied interests of Huntington Beach residents. B. BACKGROUND The subject Master Plan of Recreation Uses was approved by the City Council on December 15, 1997. A series of actions led to the approval of the Master Plan in its current state beginning in 1991 when the City Council directed staff to develop a master plan for Central Park. The objective was to prepare a plan for the undeveloped acreage in the park; the Park consists of 356.8 acres, of which 220.8 (62%) are developed. In 1992, the City Council approved land use designations for the undeveloped areas of the park and in 1994 approved an amendment to the plan to include a sports complex. In 1996, Measure L was approved by the voters of Huntington Beach authorizing construction of a multi-field sports complex east of Goldenwest and south of Talbert Avenue. In July 1997, the City Council approved a Specific Plan for the Sports Complex (known as Alternative 4A) to be evaluated in an environmental impact report. On December 15, 1997, the City Council approved modifications to the Sports Complex Plan (known as Modified Alternative 4A) and directed staff to analyze the Sports Complex, Outdoor Music Area, Consolidated Camping Area and Park Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion Area at the project level of detail in the environmental impact report. The other elements of the master plan were to be analyzed at the program level of detail. C. PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING: The Planning Commission considered MEIR No. 99-1 on July 13, 1999. Four individuals presented comments during the public hearing. Two of the speakers addressed operation of the sports complex. One speaker expressed concern about water quality at the desiltation basin west of Goldenwest Street due to the existing equestrian uses. The fourth speaker was a member of the City's Environmental Board and indicated that they support the sports complex but that more environmental analysis may be needed for the landfill as the City proceeds with the project. The Planning Commission inquired about the difference in environmental analysis for the project level elements versus the program level elements. Echoing concerns expressed by the Environmental Board, they inquired as to whether sufficient analysis was completed in the environmental document. The Planning Commission also asked for clarification on the desiltation basin and discussed screening of the Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard. Other questions and comments related to traffic generation, police patrol, parking meters and the gun range. PL99-53 -4- 07/20/99 3:01 PM REQUEST FOR ACTION MEETING DATE: August 2, 1999 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: PL99-53 Staff indicated that adequate analysis, including site testing, had been completed for the sports complex area at this stage of the project. There has been early consultation with the various regulatory agencies that would have oversight for the landfill area and these agencies have not indicated that the MEIR was inadequate in its characterization and analysis of the landfill area. Staff also indicated that experience gained from the Central Library project which involved landfill and methane issues provided a sound basis for understanding the challenges associated with the sports complex project. Staff noted that additional analysis may be required for the program level elements of the Master Plan and in association with project implementation. Regarding the desilation basin, staff stated that the existing condition was not the subject of the MEIR. However, the MEIR states that when program elements on the west side of Goldenwest Street go forward at the project level stage, water quality analysis will be required in association for the Master Plan elements. Staff reported that there is an existing proposal for equestrian uses for which they will recommend conditions to address the existing problem. In response to concerns about the Maintenance Yard, :staff suggested the Design Review Board review the landscaping plan. The Planning Commission voted to recommend certification of the MEIR and adoption of the mitigation monitoring program (Commissioner Chapman dissenting) and requested that staff: 1) keep the Environmental Board apprised of activities related to the project, and 2) explore the issue of screening the Maintenance Yard. Attachment No. 7 presents recommended changes in response to the Planning Commission's request. D. STAFF ANALYSIS AND RECOMMENDATION: The MEIR provides a detailed analysis of potential impacts associated with construction and operation of the project level elements. For the program level elements, the MEIR broadly identifies potential environmental effects related to implementation and subsequent technical analysis that may need to be considered when detailed plans are prepared. The issues discussed in the MEIR are those which have been identified in the course of extensive review of all potentially significant environmental impacts associated with the Master Plan. The direct, indirect and cumulative impacts of the Master Plan elements are addressed, as are the impacts of project alternatives. Each of the 15 MEIR issue areas is identified below by impact category. Impacts Mitigated Unavoidable No Impact to Level of Insignificance Significant Impacts ♦ Land Use and Planning ♦ Geological Issues ♦ Aesthetics ♦ Population and Housing ♦ Water ♦ Air Quality ♦ Energy and Mineral Resources ♦ Transportation/Circulation ♦ Biological Resources ♦ Hazards ♦ Noise ♦ Public Services ♦ Utilities and Service Systems ♦ Cultural Resources ♦ Recreation PL99-53 -5- 07/20199 3:01 PM REQUEST FOR ACTION MEETING DATE: August 2, 1999 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: PL99-53 Impacts Mitigated to Level of Insignificance Through the use of appropriate mitigation.measures identified in the Final_MEIR, the majority of the potentially adverse impacts associated with the Master Plan can be mitigated to a level of insignificance. The Findings of Fact, as required by CEQA, review each of the impact areas and list the recommended mitigation measures (Attachment No. 3). A summary of key issues and mitigation measures as a result of the environmental impact report process is provided in the Planning Commission staff report (Attachment No. 4). Significant Unavoidable Impacts There are two adverse environmental impacts anticipated from the proposed Sports Complex element that cannot be completely eliminated through mitigation measures. These effects can be lessened by mitigation measures suggested in the MEIR, and staff recommends these be incorporated into the project. Because these impacts cannot be fully mitigated, a Statement of Overriding Consideration is required. Aesthetics The MEIR concludes that there may be significant unavoidable impacts on aesthetics in association with the operation of night lighting for the Sports Complex. These impacts would affect the Ocean View Estates Mobile Homes. The MEIR recommends a mitigation measure to address the lighting impacts by requiring photo-control-on and off (dusk to dawn), use of low glare lighting and the use of shields so that there is no spillage onto adjacent properties. In addition, a separate Noise mitigation measure prohibits the use of the southwest fields after 10:00 p.m. and requires the lights to be turned off at that time which will further assist in minimizing light impacts. Nevertheless, it is still possible that there will be light impacts to.the-mobile homes. Air Quality There will be short-term significant impacts to air quality during construction of the Sports Complex. These impacts result from emissions of both nitrogen oxides (NO,) and particulate matter (PM,o) associated with construction equipment. The MEIR identifies 12 mitigation measures that will lessen air quality impacts as a result of construction, but they cannot reduce impacts below the South Coast Air Quality Management District's thresholds of significance for the two categories noted. There is also one air-quality mitigation measure designed to mitigate impacts related to excavation of landfill. Long-term cumulative impacts from the proposed project will not be significant. PL99-53 -6- 07/20/99 3:01 PM REQUEST FOR ACTION MEETING DATE: August 2, 1999 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: PL99-53 Public Comments on the Draft MEIR Comments on the Draft MEIR were received from 15 agencies and interested parties. The comments focused on several issues, including: landfill and associated concerns such as methane, traffic and biological concerns. Staff responded to all comments received in the Final MEIR (Attachment No. 5). The Final MEIR includes revised text sections and modified mitigation measures as a result of the comments. Key modifications include: • Biological Resources. In response to comments from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, staff has: - Modified four program level elements to conserve 41.2 acres (57%) of non-native grassland for foraging habitat for birds - Added a mitigation measure requiring implementation of a brown-headed cowbird trapping program • Transportation/Circulation. In response to comments from Caltrans, staff has: - Added three mitigation measures in support of encouraging/enhancing transit services for the Sports Complex • Hazards. In response to comments from the County of Orange and the City of Huntington Beach Environmental Board, staff has: - Added three mitigation measures which address the possible excavation of unknown landfill materials and the requirement for an excavation management plan and a health and safety plan - Clarification in the text that excavation of any landfill areas will comply with the South Coast Air Quality Management District's Rule 1150 Public.Comments on the Final MEIR In response to the Final MEIR, staff received two written comment letters and one verbal comment from parties that had also commented on the Draft MEIR. The written comments were received prior to the July 13th Planning Commission meeting and were forwarded to the Planning Commission for their consideration. The verbal comment was received on July 19th from the Orange County Health Care Agency's Local Enforcement Agency (LEA). As a result of the LEA's comment, one mitigation measure has been revised to clarify that the LEA will have oversight on all work in the landfill area. Attachment No. 8 contains the two comment letters and the consultant's response to the verbal comment from the LEA. Also included in Attachment No. 8 is one additional letter received prior to the Planning Commission meeting regarding the existing desiltation basin. PL99-53 -7- 07/20/99 3:01 PM \4 REQUEST FOR ACTION MEETING DATE: August 2, 1999 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: PL99-53 Alternatives to the Project A range of reasonable alternatives to the proposed project was analyzed in the MEIR pursuant to provisions of CEQA. The discussion of alternatives focuses on alternatives capable of eliminating any significant adverse environmental effects or reducing them to a level of insignificance, even if these alternatives would impede to some degree the attainment of the project objectives or would be more costly. A summary analysis of environmental impacts for each of the alternatives compared to the proposed project is included in Section 4.0 of the Draft MEIR and reviewed in the Findings of Fact (Attachment No.4). The analysis concludes that the proposed Master Plan of Recreational Uses is the environmentally superior alternative. Statement of Overriding Considerations Where impacts cannot-be mitigated to an insignificant level, a Statement of Overriding Considerations must be adopted in conjunction with the certification of an environmental impact report. CEQA requires the decision makers to balance the benefits of the proposed project against its unavoidable environmental risks in determining whether to approve the project. If the benefits of the project outweigh the unavoidable adverse environmental effects, the adverse environmental effects may be considered acceptable to the City. Staff believes that the environmental and social benefits of the Master Plan-of Recreation Uses for Central Park outweigh the adverse impacts to aesthetics and air quality for the reasons set forth in Attachment 2. E. SUMMARY The Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park plans for the development of 136 undeveloped acres and 21.5 developed acres in one of the City's primary park facilities. It is anticipated that the four project level elements will be implemented in the next five years, while the five program elements will be realized over the long term as funding and park planning permits. The improvements to the park acreage will assist the City in meeting the projected park and recreation needs of Huntington Beach residents. Staff recommends that the City Council certify the MEIR with a Statement of Overriding Considerations for Aesthetics and Air Quality because: ♦ The Master Plan is consistent with the goals, objectives and policies of the General Plan ♦ The proposed mitigation measures reduce most potential impacts to a level of insignificance ♦ The Master Plan is the environmentally superior alternative ♦ The environmental and social benefits of the project outweigh and override the unavoidable adverse effects of the project: temporary air quality impacts during construction and aesthetic impacts due to night lighting. PL99-53 -8- 07/20/99 3:01 PM REQUEST FOR ACTION MEETING DATE: August 2, 1999 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: PL99-53 Environmental Status: In accordance with the California Environmental.Quality Act, Master. Environmental-impact Report No. ,99=1 was prepared.-by Sapphos Environmental to analyze the potential impacts of the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park. The MEIR serves as an informational document for decisions to be made by the City and was prepared under the requisite procedure that is outlined below: September 2, 1997 A Notice of Preparation was filed with the State Clearinghouse and the County Clerk to notify public of intent to prepare a MEIR. September 18, 1997 Public Scoping Meeting held at Huntington Central Library for public to submit verbal and written comments on issues to be addressed in the MEIR. Meeting notice was sent to approximately 1,800 households within 1,000 feet of the Park and to interested agencies. February 26, 1999 Notice of Completion filed with the State Clearinghouse and the County Clerk. Draft MEIR available for public review and comment for 45 days (Comment period: February 26, 1999 to April 12, 1999). Draft MEIR available for review at City Hall, Central Library, Murdy Community Center and Edison Community Center. Notice of Availability of Draft MEIR sent to approximately 1,800 households and interested agencies. July 13, 1999 Public hearing before Planning Commission to review and recommend to City Council certification of Final MEIR No. 99- 1. Prior to certifying and adopting the MEIR by resolution, the City Council may amend the document. It should be noted, however, that removal of any of the recommended mitigation measures will require findings and justification. The analysis section of this report contains further discussion regarding the MEIR. PL99-53 -9- 07/20/99 3:01 PM REQUEST FOR ACTION MEETING DATE: August 2, 1999 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: PL99-53 Attachment(s): City Clerk's Page Number No. Description 1. Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park 2. Resolution No. 99-s3(Final MEIR No. 99-1) with Statement of Overriding Considerations 3. CEQA Environmental Findings of Fact 4. Planning Commission Staff Report dated July 13, 1999 5. Final MEIR No. 99-1 under separate cover- not attached 6. Mitigation Monitoring Program (under separate cover - not attached 7. Le islative Draft Changes to MEIR 8. Correspondence on the MEIR RCA Author: mbb PL99-53 -10- 07/20/99 3:01 PM LIMIT OF EXISTING MAINTENANCE SYMBOL FACILITY L LEGEND EXPANSION INCLUDES THE ADDITION OF 9600 SQUARE FEET DENOTES EIR PROJECT LEVEL •+DENOTES EIR PROGRAM LEVEL MAI �AA77L'�' CITY PARK,TR E . I LANDSCAPE 4 MAINT AN YARD ENHANCED IMPROVEMENTS INCLUDE: �O,. ,SRO IMPROVEMENTS AND CONSOLIDATION PARCOURSE _=� TALBERT LAKE/ `I I EXISTING MEADOW EXISTING - . - SHIPLEY NATURE AMPHITHEATER t-- �• -_ - CENTER I Y. I OUTDOOR MUSIC AREA EXISTING ADVENTURE PLAYGROUND _ i FACILITY INCLUDES:ACCESS ROAD FROM S; IN EXISTINGGOLDEN WEST WEST STREET,FAMILY PICNIC SHELTERS WITH BBQ'S,RESTROOM I o YOUTH ' S BUILDING,TOT LOT AND PARKING LOT ,� z EXISTING SHELTER LIBRARY tLow INrE sITY RE RRE�ATION AR I � I — ��•• '��r�`tf' � �`+� _ _K '' SPORTSCOMPLE +...�. n,arewE.�..✓• 9�:�'t � -1�>t --`.?',..e lea' -" - � - f HUNTINGTON LAKE DISC�p`F I �..�'i. 0':.+ ORANGE COUNTY COURSE I' - * RANGE 'TRANSFER STATION ' EXISTI G - �G PARKMEN \ 3I BASIN'' -f—- - SULLY EXISTING I - i } -EQUESTRIAN Il1ER LAKE 1 - I - ` CENTER 't - j •. - ' ISTA �r�����ra��l�• v. ^' 'n POINT: 0 t00% •4461. •T• •sus • �. ". GROU _ �LD �, FACI • IF O EXISTING ' 1 �. URBAN FOREST:,: ' OCEAN VIEW I' J ACCESS TO I _� d; EMI-ACTI� ESTATES MOBILE 1 WELD T M. t dy -- TKAI�' O O ' HOMES _ • ' J WELDER ECREATION ' J �I REGIONAL � `° �+ TRAILHEAD. PARK -� e ACCESS TO TRAIL FROM EXISTING MULTIPURPOSE TRAIL EQUESTRIAN ESTATES � + I _ AREA TO INCLUDE MASSES OF LT TREES OF VARIOUS SELECTED SPECIES TABLES.HITCHIIUTY NG POST,BIKE HE AND FROM ELLIS AVENUE ER ICNI I FACILITY INCLUDES:ATHERAPEUTIC ,ROAD— � ~A EFACN E R STROOM BUILDITY INCLUDES: NG PICNIOAD C SHELTER TRAILS RIDING CENTER,OPEN TURF AND FISHING DOCKS,TRAILS OPEN YURF AREAS,PARKING OVERFLOW PARKING REf RUOAO LOT,VOLLEYBALL COURT,AND TOT LOT -.• FACIUTY INCLUDES:ACCESS ROAD FROM ELLIS CEINTERG.TOLT LOT SITU T CS --FACIUTY INCLUDES:ACCESS FROM AVENUE,RESTROOM BUILDING,PARKING LOT WITH STANDARD SPACES,AND EQUESTRIAN TALBERT AVENUE d GOLDENWEST TRAILER PARKING SPACES STREET GRAVEL PARKING LOT, EIGHT( LIGHTED SOCCER ^_ .r FBIA`DSELDIS LIGHTED ROLLER HOCKEY COURTS, BATTING CAGE,TW O 21 CONCESSION/RESTROOM LE ? TOT OTSdPICNIC SHELTERS 0 200' 400' 800, N LJLV I S .°.....ten,. FIGURE 1.0-4 SNP W U NONE 111 Proposed Project Ow ]`""`'°n"pi—in"°"""° ewurcc Ol�nn�ng Huntington Central Park Master EIR Huntington Beach, California - � ,� � �-� �. �=- e Qe � - � �� � - �n RESOLUTION NO. 99-53 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CERTIFYING MASTER ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT NO. 99-1 FOR THE MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES FOR CENTRAL PARK WHEREAS, Master Environmental Impact Report No. 99-1 has been prepared to address the environmental effects, mitigation measures, and project alternatives associated with the proposed Master Plan of Recreation Uses Central Park; and The Draft Master Environmental Impact.Report was prepared in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), the State CEQA Guidelines, and the City's environmental procedures; and Written and oral comments on Master Environmental Impact Report No. 99-1 were received from the public and responsible public agencies during and after the review period; and Such comments and testimony were responded to through a Response to Comments document and said document was made available in a manner prescribed by CEQA and the CEQA Guidelines; and Public Records Code 21092.5(a) requires that the City of Huntington Beach provide a written proposed response to any pubic agency that commented on the Master Environmental Impact Report, and the Response to Comments included in the Final Master Environmental Impact Report satisfy this provision; and Section 15092 of CEQA Guidelines provides that the City shall not decide to approve or carry out a project for which an Environmental Impact Report was prepared unless it has: (a) eliminated or substantially lessened all significant effects on the environment where feasible as shown in the findings under Section 15091 of the CEQA Guidelines; and (b) determined that any remaining significant effects on the environment found to be unavoidable under Section 15091 are acceptable due to overriding concerns as described in Section 15093 of the CEQA Guidelines; and Section 15093(a) of the CEQA Guidelines requires the City to balance the benefits of a proposed project against its unavoidable environmental risks in determining whether to approve the project, NOW, THEREFORE, the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach does hereby find and resolve as follows: SECTION 1: The City Council hereby finds and certifies the Final Master Environmental Impact Report as complete and adequate in that it addresses all environmental effects of the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park and fully complies with the requirements of CEQA and the Guidelines. The Final Master Environmental Impact Report will ultimately be composed of the following: 7/1-J99reso/EIR99-1/07/14/99 1 (a) Draft Master Environmental Impact Report and Appendices; (b) Planning Commission and City Council Staff Reports; (c) Planning Commission and City Council Minutes; and (d) Comments received on Draft Master Environmental Impact Report and responses to those comments. All of the above information has been and will be on file with the City of Huntington Beach Planning Department, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, CA 92648, and with the Secretary of the Commission. SECTION 2: The Final Master Environmental Impact Report has identified all significant environmental effects of the project and that there are no known potential environmental impacts not addressed in the Final Master Environmental Impact Report. SECTION 3: The City Council finds that the Final Master Environmental Impact Report has described all reasonable alternatives to the project that could feasibly obtain the basis objectives of the project (including the "no project' alternative), even when these alternatives might impede the attainment of project objectives and might be more costly. Further, the City Council finds that a good faith effort was made to incorporate alternatives in the preparation of the Draft Master Environmental Impact Report and all reasonable alternatives were considered in the review process of the Final Master Environmental Impact Report and ultimate decisions on the project. SECTION 4: The City further finds that the benefits gained by the City and its current and future residents by virtue of implementing the goals and policies of the proposed General Plan, override the unmitigatible effects of Aesthetics and Air Quality as detailed in Master Environmental Impact Report No. 99-1 (Exhibit A). SECTION 5: The City Council hereby adopts Master Environmental Impact Report No. 99-1. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at a regular meeting thereof held on the end day of august , 1999. ATTEST: Mayor ; L�essir�l� City Clerk APPROV D AS TO FORM: REVIEWED AND APPROVED: i t�rne1r, INITIAT D AND APPROVED: City Administrator Dir&tdr of Planni 7/k/99reso/E1R99-1/07/14/99 2 Res. No. 99-53 STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) ss: CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH ) I, CONNIE BROCKWAY, the duly elected, qualified City Clerk of the City of Huntington Beach, and ex-officio Clerk of the City Council of said City, do hereby certify that the whole number of members of the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach is seven; that the foregoing resolution was passed and adopted by the affirmative vote of at least a majority of all the members of said City Council at a regular meeting thereof held on the 2nd day of August, 1999 by the following vote: AYES: Julien, Garofalo, Dettloff,Harman NOES: Bauer, Green, Sullivan ABSENT: None ABSTAIN: None City Clerk and ex-officio Cl rk of the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach, California 177 EXHIBIT A STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS The Final Master Environmental Impact Report(MEIR) identified and discussed significant impacts on geologic issues, water,.air quality, transportation/circulation, biological resources, hazards, noise, public services, utilities and service system, aesthetics, cultural resources and recreation which could occur as a result of construction and operation of the project and program level elements of the Master Plan. With the implementation of the mitigation measures discussed.in the Final MEIR, these impacts can be mitigated to levels of insignificance except for unavoidable significant impacts on air quality (during construction) and aesthetics as identified in Section IV of these Findings. The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach determined that the environmental and social (recreational) benefits of implementing the project outweigh and override the unavoidable adverse effects of the project. The City of Huntington Beach has determined that the benefits of the project, when balanced against all adverse effects, cause those effects remaining after mitigation to be acceptable due to the following considerations: • The Master Plan would allow the City of Huntington Beach (City) to fulfill their goals in providing passive and active recreational opportunities to residents within the service area for Central Park. Specifically, the Master Plan provides an opportunity for development of the following active and passive recreation facilities: Sports Complex, Outdoor Music Area, Consolidated Camping Area, Low Intensity Recreation Area, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head, Semi-Active Recreation Area and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility. The Master Plan provides for development of facilities and programs on 136 undeveloped acres and 14 improved acres within an existing 356.8 acre regional park facility.The project and program level elements of the Master Plan would help the City meet the current and future (2010) demand for such facilities. The Master Plan would also help to relieve the over-use of nearby recreational facilities experienced mainly at Murdy and Edison Parks. In addition, the Master Plan would help the City comply with its park standard of five (5) acres per 1,000 people (City of Huntington Beach 1994a). Given the projection of estimated population growth of 9.8 percent to the year 2010, the City will need to expand its park land by 93.3 acres for a total of 1,053.6 acres to meet this requirement. • Development of the Sports Complex converts a 45-acre capped landfill with bare/ruderal vegetation. (fenced to preclude public access)to a usable, and aesthetically pleasing public venue for recreation. • Implementation of the Master Plan will provide diverse recreational opportunities for all citizens consistent with the City of Huntington Beach General Plan goals adopted by the City Council, 1996. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 W:I PROI ECTSI 1096-0041 FINDINGSI 1096004.S09 —1— • Implementation of the Master Plan is consistent with a number of goals and objectives identified in the Recreation and Community Services Element of the City of Huntington Beach Genreal Plan, including : ♦ ..Enriching the quality of life for residents through. the provision of. additional passive and active recreation opptunities; ♦ Providing additional passive and active recreation facilities to meet the needs of existing and anticipated population levels; ♦ Provide upgraded and renovated facilities to meet current recreation demands of youth and adults as described in the Draft Youth Sports Needs Assessment Study, ♦ Maximize the effectivnessof Central Park through the provision of additional facilities in existing undeveloped areas of the Park; ♦ Provide for operation of the Park in a safe, effective, and efficient manner through the appropiate design of new facilities; ♦ Provide for phased implementation of project and program level elements of the Master Plan to coincide with the demand for services as well as with the City's fiscal resources. • Implementation of the Sports Complex element of the Master Plan includes a parking lot that provides for revenue generating opputunities. • Implementation of the Sports Complex element of the Master Plan accomplishes Recommendation No.1 of the Draft Youth Sports Needs Assessment Study to develop a multi-purpose Sports Complex. • Implementation of the Master Plan is consistent with Measure L land use authorization to allow for construction of lighted soccer and softball fields, a roller hockey rink and snack bar concessions, parking, restrooms and related improvements. • Implementation of the Master Plan will provide recreation facilities that have been desgined consistent with the Crime Prevention through Environmental Design Guidelines. • Implementation of the Master Plan will provide recreation facilities desgined in compliance with the requirments of the Americans with Disabilities Act. • The short-term unavoidable impacts generated from construction related activities are outweighed by air quality improvements in the long-term. The Master Plan, through its landscaping design,will reduce current levels of nuisance dust and PM,o emissions from wind-driven dust clouds from the vacant lot(45 acres of capped landfill) adjacent to the mobile home park. • The impacts of the night lighting on the adjacent Ocean Park Mobile Home Estate are outweighed by the benefits of replacing the adjacent vacant lot(an attractant for illicit Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 f I NDINGS11096004.509 —2— activities) with a recreation facility designed consistent with the Crime Prevention through Environmental Design Guidelines. • The Master Plan would improve the storm drainage system by replacing the 36-inch metal pipe between Talbert Lake and Sully Miller.Lake that is currently inadequate and unable to properly serve its intended function.of directing storm water flows between the two lakes and preventing storm water from overflowing onto city streets. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 WAPROJECTSI 1096-0041 FI NDINGSI 1096004.509 —3— aw ................ ................................................................................. ........................ ENVIRONMENTAL FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES FOR CENTRAL PARK CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA STATE CLEARINGHOUSE NUMBER 9709 1 007 PREPARED FOR: _ CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA. 92648 PREPARED BY: SAPPHOS ENVIRONMENTAL, INC. 1 33 MARTIN ALLEY PASADENA, CALIFORNIA 9 1 105 JUNE 22, 1999 ENVIRONMENTAL FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES FOR CENTRAL PARK CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA STATE CLEARINGHOUSE NUMBER 9709 1 007 TABLE OF CONTENTS Section Page Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1-1 A. Certification . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I-1 B. Background . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1-1 C. Project Improvements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1-4 D. EIR Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1-7 E. General Findings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 1-9 II Potential Environmental Effects Which Are Not Significant . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . II-1 II.A Land Use and Planning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . II-1 11.13 Population and Housing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . II-1 ILC Energy and Mineral Resources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . II-2 III Potential Environmental Effects Which Can Be Mitigated to a Level of Insignificance . . III-1 A. Geological Issues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III-1 B. Water . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III-4 C. Transportation and Circulation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III-5 D. Biological Resources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III-7 E. Hazards . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III-10 F. Noise . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III-13 G. Public Services . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III-14 H. Utilities and Service Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111-16 I. Cultural Resources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III-20 J. Recreation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III-23 IV Significant Unavoidable Impacts Which Cannot Be Mitigated to a Level of Insignificance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV-1 A. Air Quality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV-1 B. Aesthetics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV-3 V Findings Regarding Alternatives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V-1 A. Alternatives 1: Ball Field (Save Our Kids) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V-2 B. Alternatives 2: Commercial Alternative . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V-3 C. Alternatives 3: Mixed Use Alternative . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V-4 D. Alternative 4: No Project . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V-6 VI Findings and Requirements Regarding Mitigation Monitoring Program . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI-1 A. Requirements of Mitigation Monitoring Program . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI-1 VII Findings Regarding Location and Custodian of Documents . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII-1 A. Location and Custodian of Documents . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII-1 VIII Findings Regarding Independent judgement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII-1 IX Statement of Overriding Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IX-1 X Section 15091 Findings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . X-1 Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page i W.1PROJECTS1 1096-0041FINDINGSI 1096004.TOC TABLES V-1. Summary of Master Plan of Recreation Uses and Alternatives Capable of Attaining Most of the Basic Objectives of the Project . . . . . . . . ... . . . . . . . . V-8 V-2. Elements of the Master Plan of Recreation Uses and Alternatives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V-9 V-3. Comparative Analysis of Impacts for Master Plan of Recreation Uses and Alternatives . V-14 Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page ii W:I PROJECTS11096-0041 F1 NDI NGSI 1096004.TOC SECTION INTRODUCTION I.A CERTIFICATION FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS REGARDING THE FINAL MASTER ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT FOR MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES FOR CENTRAL PARK CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA (State Clearinghouse Number 97091007) The City of Huntington Beach (City) hereby certifies the Final Master Environmental Impact Report (Final Master EIR) for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, Huntington Beach, California, State Clearinghouse Number 97091007 (which consists of Volume I: Draft Master Environmental Impact Report [MEIR] for Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park dated February 26, 1999;Volume 11: Technical Appendices to the Draft MEIR for Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park dated February 26, 1999; and Volume III: Final MEIR for Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, dated June 22,1999;and is collectively referred to as the Final Master EIR) has been completed in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and all applicable federal, state and local statutes and regulations that govern the management of specific environmental resources; and that the City has received, reviewed, and considered the information contained in the Final MEIR, all hearings, and submissions of testimony from officials representing federal, state and local agencies, organizations and private individuals with a particular vested interest in the project. Having received, reviewed, and considered the foregoing information, as well as any and all other information in the record, the City hereby makes findings pursuant and in accordance with Section 21081.6 of the Public Resources Code as presented in Sections II through X of these Environmental Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations. I.B BACKGROUND Existing Conditions Huntington Central Park is centrally located in the City of Huntington Beach, northeast of the future Harriett M. Wieder Regional Park, Orange County, California (Figure 1.0-1, Regional Map). Golden West Street and Talbert Avenue cut through the center of the Park. The Park site street boundaries are Slater Avenue on the north, Gothard Street on the east, Ellis Avenue on the south, and Edwards Street on the west. The site is depicted on U.S.G.S. 7.5 minute series Seal Beach and Newport Beach topographic quadrangle maps, Range 11 West, Township 5 South, Southeast corner of Section 27, West'/2 of section 26, Northeast quarter of Section 34 and Northwest quarter of Section 35 (Figure 1.0- 2, Vicinity Map). Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page W W.I PROI ECTSI 1096-0041 FI NDI NGSI 1096004.S01 Huntington Central Park is a public regional park facility, consisting of 356.8 acres of which 220.8 acres are developed (City of Huntington Beach 1996a). The remaining 136 acres are undeveloped. The City acquired the Park with park bonds, subdivision fees, Housing and Urban Development(HUD) grants and county revenue sharing funds through a series of transactions beginning in 1969 and continuing up to the present time. The City's decision to buy the Park resulted from its objective to provide adequately sized active and passive parklands to meet the recreation needs of existing and future residents, and to preserve natural resources within the City of Huntington Beach and its sphere of influence. The official park dedication occurred in 1974. In 1991, the City embarked on the development of a Master Plan for Huntington Central Park to provide diverse recreation opportunities for all citizens consistent with the Huntington Beach City Goals of the General Plan adopted by City Council (1996a). In 1992, the City approved a land use Master Plan for the undeveloped areas of the Park. Subsequently, the City approved an amendment to the plan to accommodate youth sports in 1994 and in 1996 Measure L was passed authorizing construction of a multi-field sport facility over the former landfill and mushroom farm site located south of Talbert Avenue and east of Golden West Street. The purpose of the proposed Master Plan is to plan for facilities and programs within a 157.5-acre study area. The Master Plan proposes four elements on 21.5 acres of existing developed areas of the Park: Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion (0.25 acre), Outdoor Music Area (0.25 acre), Consolidated Camping Area (13.5 acres), and Police/Civilian Gun Range (7.5 acres). Three of these elements have been recommended to improve 14 acres in existing developed areas of the Park consistent with the existing or immediately adjacent land use. The existing 7.5 acre non-operational Police/Civilian gun range is identified in the MEIR as a park element that will be subject to subsequent environmental documentation if modified or relocated. Five elements are proposed for 136 acres in the existing undeveloped areas of the Park: Sports Complex (45 acres), Low Intensity Recreation Area (16 acres), Midden/Urban Forest/Trai I head (45 acres),Semi-Active Recreation Area(10 acres),and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility (20 acres). The City Council identified several project alternatives for developing the Sports Complex element of the Master Plan and identified the Modified Project 4A alternative as the proposed project to be evaluated in the MEIR. Consistent with the Draft Youth Sports Needs Assessment Study (City of Huntington Beach 1997), the year 2010 was set as the horizon for analysis of elements of the proposed Master Plan. The primary element that distinguishes Modified Project 4A from the other alternatives under consideration is the configuration and type of lighted ball fields, roller hockey, and appurtenant facilities. The Park's existing facilities are maintained in the proposed project and alternatives to the proposed project evaluated in this MEIR. The planning effort involves improving 136 vacant acres,and 14 developed acres in a manner that is compatible with existing uses. Several proposed improvements outlined in the Master Plan are not anticipated to go forward in the near future but are expected to be implemented once funding sources are secured. Therefore, it was decided that these improvements would be evaluated at a program level of analysis in accordance with the CEQA Statutes and Guidelines. The MEIR analyzes environmental impacts associated with the Sports Complex component of the Master Plan, as well as three other project level elements. Areas Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 1-2 W.-WROJECTSI 1096-0041FINDINGS11096004.S01 addressed at the project level were analyzed at all phases of the project including planning, construction and operation. Project Objectives The project objectives for the Master Plan were designed to fulfill a number of goals outlined in the City of Huntington Beach General Plan and recommendations put forth by the Draft Youth Sports Needs Assessment Study, as well as to fulfill voter approved Measure L allowing for the construction of a multifield sport facility. Overall, the goals guiding the following objectives emphasize meeting the needs and demands of area residents and visiting patrons for ample recreational facilities, diverse recreational opportunities and innovative programs. In providing for such recreational opportunities, proposed facilities would need to ensure continual renovation and upgrading to allow for efficient and quality use. Development of the 136 undeveloped acres, as well as the proposed improvements to 14 developed acres within the Huntington Central Park represents an important opportunity to provide adequate recreational opportunities for anticipated population levels defined in the City of Huntington Beach General Plan. Several objectives were crafted as strategies for fulfilling such goals. The following lists those objectives the City of Huntington Beach must meet as they are described in the Master Plan. Objective 1: Support the City of Huntington Beach General Plan Goals Adopted by City Council, 1996 Objective 2: Address Relevant Issues and Ensure Consistency with Applicable Goals, Objectives and Policies Identified in the Recreation and Community Services (RCS) Element of the Huntington Beach General Plan Objective 3: Provide opportunities to offset maintenance costs through incorporation of revenue generating facilities and programs Objective 4: Implement Recommendation No. 1 of the Draft Youth Sports Needs Assessment Study [to be finalized as Recreation Facilities and Open Space Study] Objective 5: Consistency with Voter Approved Measure L Objective 6: Address Relevant Issues and Ensure Consistency with Applicable Goals, Objectives and Policies Identified in the Environmental Resources/ Conservation Element(ERC) of the Huntington Beach General Plan Objective 7: Consistency with Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) Guidelines Objective 8: Ensure compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act(ADA) Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 1-3 W.I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 Fl NDI NGSI 1096004.S01 I.0 PROJECT IMPROVEMENTS The draft MEIR for the Master Plan examined a total of five(5) alternatives which included a No-Project Alternative as required by the California Environmental Quality Act (Public Resources Code 15126 (d) (4)). Of the alternatives, the City Council identified Modified Project 4A as the proposed Master Plan for the purposes of the MEIR. The proposed Master Plan maintains the current existing recreation uses of the Park, while adding additional recreation uses and enhancing existing facilities on fourteen (14) acres of the developed park. Two program elements of the Master Plan, Police/Civilian Gun Range and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility, may require substantial improvements to ensure the safety of recreation uses. Such improvements would be considered in subsequent environmental documentation. Site preparation and construction of the project and program level elements of the Master Plan will be undertaken in accordance with all federal, state, and City building codes. City ordinance allows daily construction activities to be undertaken Monday through Saturday (excluding Federal holidays), between the hours of 7:00 am to 8:00 pm. As a result of mitigation measures recommended in conjunction with this Master Plan, the City has determined to limit grading and construction activities to between 7:00 a.m. and 7:00 p.m. on Mondays through Fridays and to between 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. on Saturdays. Construction equipment will be turned off when not in use. All grading and earthwork will be performed under the observation of a geotechnical engineer to ensure proper subgrade preparation, selection of satisfactory materials, and placement and compaction of structural fills. Any unanticipated adverse conditions encountered will be evaluated by the project engineering geologist and the soil engineer, and the appropriate recommendation made and followed. If possible, grading activities will be undertaken during the non-rainy season (April 15 to October 15) to reduce the potential for soil erosion and increased surface runoff to result in adverse impacts on water quality. The plans and specifications for the proposed project will include a requirement for the construction contractor to comply with all provisions of the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Program administered by the California Regional Water Quality Control Board as they relate to avoiding impacts on storm water quality during construction. The construction contractor will be required to incorporate Best Management Practices consistent with the guidelines provided in the California Storm Water Best Management Practice Handbooks: Construction Activities. Should the construction period continue into the rainy season, supplemental erosion measures would need to be implemented, including but not limited to the following: • Mulching •. Geotextiles and mats • Earth Dikes • Temporary Drains and Gulleys • Silt Fence • Straw Bale Barriers • Sand Bag Barrier • Brush or Rock Filter • Sediment Trap Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 1-4 W:1 PROJECTS11096-0041 FINDINGSI 1096004.SO 1 All program and project level elements of the Master Plan will comply with Fire Department specifications for access and fire flows, including but not limited to: • Structures not within 150 feet of fire access as defined by the Huntington Beach Fire Code shall be provided with automatic fire sprinklers and appropriate alarming devices. • All pathways used as fire access shall maintain a minimum width as specified by the Fire Department. 0 Maximum travel distance (on approved fire access routes) to a fire hydrant should be no more than 500 feet. This means they are about 1,000 feet apart in the park, if needed. This can be modified depending on structure placement. The Master Plan of Recreation Uses in the Park was evaluated at two (2) distinct levels of detail: (1) Project Level and (2) Program Level. I.C.1 Project Level Improvements The MEIR provided the requisite level of analysis for the City Council of Huntington Beach to understand the environmental consequences of proceeding with construction of the elements analyzed at the Project Level of detail. The four (4) elements considered at the Project Level are: a Sports Complex, a Park,Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard expansion area, an outdoor music area, and a consolidated camping area. Sports Complex: Forty-five (45) acres of the 136 remaining undeveloped acres are.designated for a Sports Complex. The proposed location for the Sports Complex consists of a "L-shaped" parcel south of Talbert Avenue and east of Golden West Street. This element of the proposed Master Plan involves development of a 800 space gravel parking lot, a batting cage, up to four (4) roller hockey rinks, eight (8) lighted softball fields,eight(8) lighted soccer/football fields, two (2) tot lots with accompanying shade structures, and two (2) restroom/concession buildings. Soccer fields are overlaid on softball fields. Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Expansion Yard: Approximately one-quarter of an acre (9,600 square feet/0.25 acre) of the developed Park is designated for expansion of the existing Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard. Construction activity will include expanding the existing Yard, adding a new chainlink fence, removing all existing shrubs, grading, and adding new plantings. Outdoor Music Area: Approximately one-quarter of an acre (0.25) of the developed Park is designated to formalize and. improve the existing Outdoor Music Area. That project was conditionally approved by the Planning Commission of the City of Huntington Beach on January 27, 1998. The construction involves a bandstand structure which will be less than 3000 square feet. General elements/activity might include mobilization, grading and drainage, electrical, asphaltic concrete and concrete placement, minor Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations lone 22, 1999 Page 1-5 W:IPROJECTSI 1096-0041 FINDINGSI 1096004.501 structure assembly,complete automatic irrigation system,site furniture,and installation of plant material. Consolidated Camping Area: Thirteen and one-half (13.5) acres of the developed Park are designated for improvements to the existing consolidated youth tent camping. The location for this element consists of an oval shaped parcel located north and east of the Talbert Lake Meadow and south of the existing Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard. General elements/activities might include mobilization, grading and drainage, electrical, asphaltic concrete and concrete placement, minor structure assembly, a telephone line, security lighting, water facilities, a picnic/ group meeting area, complete automatic irrigation system, site furniture, and installation of plant material. I.C.2 Program Level Elements Five Elements were chosen to be addressed at the Program Level of detail because construction funding was not available or timing is uncertain. Consequently, detailed proposals for these elements are not currently available. This Master EIR identifies planning assumptions and subsequent technical reports and analysis that may need to be considered by the City prior to approval of construction of individual program elements. The five (5) elements to be considered at the Program Level are: the Low-Intensity Recreation Area, the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head, the Semi-Active Recreation Area, the Police/Civilian Gun Range, and the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility. Low Intensity Recreation Area: Sixteen (16) acres of the remaining undeveloped 136 acres are designated as additional picnic and passive activity areas. Project elements and construction activity would be determined when this feature moves forward as a capital improvement project. General elements/activities might include mobilization, grading and drainage, electrical, asphaltic concrete (parking area) and concrete placement, minor structure assembly to provide shade overheads, restroom, tot lot, open turf area, complete automatic irrigation system, site furniture, and installation of plant material. At least four (4) acres of the existing non-native grassland would be maintained and enhanced to conserve suitable foraging habitat for birds. Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head: Forty-five (45) acres of the remaining undeveloped 136 acres are designated for preservation of the Native American midden archaeological area; a citizen-participation urban forest planting program; in addition to a trail head, viewpoint, and multi-use recreation trails for equestrian, pedestrian, and non- motorized cyclist. General elements/activities might include mobilization, grading and drainage, electrical, asphaltic concrete and concrete.placement, structure assembly to provide shade overheads, a restroom at trail head, complete automatic irrigation system, site furniture, and installation of plant material. At least twenty-four (24) acres of the existing non-native grassland would be maintained and enhanced to conserve suitable foraging habitat for birds. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 1-6 W:IPROJECTSI 1096-0041 FI NDI NGSI 1096004.501 Semi-Active Recreation: Ten (10) acres of the remaining undeveloped 136 acres are designated for the City's therapeutic riding school facilities, an open turf field for recreation that will also provide overflow parking during special events at the existing equestrian center, parking lot, tot lot, restroom and as the proposed alternative site for an aquatic/swim center. (The primary site for the aquatic/swim center is at Ocean View High School.) General elements/activities might include mobilization, grading and drainage, electrical, asphaltic concrete and concrete placement, minor and major structure assembly, complete automatic irrigation system, site furniture, and installation of plant material. Sully Miller Lake Group Facility: Twenty (20) acres of the remaining undeveloped 136 acres have been designated for a group picnic and fishing facility. The analysis in this Master EIR is based on plans that currently include one or two docks, restroom/tackle and bait shop, a volleyball area, an open turf area, and shade overheads. General elements/activities might include mobilization, major grading and earthwork operations, drainage structures, electrical, asphaltic concrete and concrete placement, minor structure assembly, complete automatic irrigation system, site furniture, and installation of plant material. Police/Civilian Gun Range: - The seven and one-half (7.5) acre Police/Civilian Gun Range was operated by the Police Officer's Association from the late 1960's to January 4, 1997 when the City Council terminated the year-to-year tenancy lease. Part of this closure decision was based on the range safety study completed February 12, 1996, by Kramer One Inc. and a range safety study completed April 13, 1994 by Larry Aguilar. Any modification or relocation of the existing facility would be subject to subsequent environmental documentation. The existing "service" road leading to the Gun Range is within the County property identified as "the existing Orange County Transfer Station No. 2." Any proposed use of the road requires permission from the County. I.D EIR PROCESS The City of Huntington Beach is the Lead Agency under CEQA and is responsible for the preparation of a Master EIR in compliance with the CEQA Statutes and Guidelines. The City has taken steps to encourage regulatory agencies and the public to participate in preparation of the environmental analysis for the proposed project. During the early planning phases of the proposed project, the City distributed query letters to representatives of seventeen (17) regulatory agencies requesting that all relevant background information and technical reports be provided to the MEIR team. A substantial amount of information related to the project area was received and incorporated into the Master Plan and the MEIR. The City posted a Notice of Preparation (NOP) for the MEIR with the County Clerk and the Governor's Office of Planning and Research on September 2, 7997. The Notice of Preparation was mailed directly to forty-three (43) public agency representatives and three (3) copies placed in the three (3) City libraries nearest to the project location: Central Library, Main Street Branch Library, and Oak View Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 1-7 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-004I F1 NDINGSI 1096004.S01 Library. A total of ten 00) letters of.comment were received in response to the NOP. A Notice of Availability (NOA) of the NOP was mailed directly to all residents within 1,000 feet of the boundary of Huntington Central Park. The NOA announced a scoping meeting. The City conducted the scoping meeting to facilitate early consultation with interested parties in compliance with Section 15082 of the CEQA guidelines. The meeting was held on Thursday, September 18, 1997 at the Central Library, 7111 Talbert Avenue, Huntington Beach, California and attended by ten (10) individuals. The Notice of Completion for the draft MEIR was posted with the County Clerk and the Governor's Office of Planning and Research on February 26, 1999. The draft MEIR was available for public review between February 26, 1999 and April 12, 1999. A Public Notice of the NOA of the draft MEIR for public review appeared in The Independent and was mailed directly to 1,806 local interested parties. It was also posted at the Shipley Nature Center and the Library at Huntington Central Park. Copies of the draft MEIR were available for public review at the following locations: Huntington Beach Central Library, 7111 Talbert Ave., Huntington Beach, California, 92647 Edison Community Center, 21377 Magnolia Ave., Huntington Beach, California, 92646 Murdy Community Center, 7000 Norma Dr., Huntington Beach, California, 92647 City of Huntington Beach Community Services Department, 5th Floor, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California,.92648 City of Huntington Beach Planning Department, 3rd Floor, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, 92648 The draft MEIR addressed the following areas of controversy raised by agencies and the public during the scoping process: • Potential impacts of the elements of the proposed Master Plan. on surface and/or groundwater, • Potential impacts from additional wastewater on the existing sewer system, • Potential hazards to people and property from development in vicinity of abandoned and active oil wells, • Potential hazards to active wells from development, • Potential hazards related to development in proximity to methane rich soils, • Potential for erosion, drainage, and infiltration of irrigation water into underlying landfill material, • Traffic and Circulation issues, including ingress/egress to the Police/Civilian Gun Range, • Potential issues related to compatibility of construction and operation of proposed elements of the Master Plan with adjacent land uses, • Proposed placement of the Aquatic Center (as an alternate site) at the northwest corner of Ellis and Golden West Street, • Provision of adequate parking to support elements of the proposed Master Plan, • Conversion of 0.25 acre of Huntington Central Park to support expansion of the Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Yard, • Loss of overflow parking area from proposed improvements northwest at the intersection of Golden West Street and Ellis Avenue, and Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 1-8 W.IPROIECTSI 1096-0041 FI NDI NGSI 1096004.S01 • Concern related to impacts on archaeological resources from planting of the Urban Forest. The draft MEIR was circulated for a period of 45 days from February 26, 1999 to April 12 , 1999. In the draft MEIR, the City of Huntington Beach considered a total of seven (7) action alternatives to the proposed Master Plan during the planning phases of the proposed project. The proposed project, each of the seven action alternatives, and the No-Project alternative were considered in the MEIR. Ultimately, two action alternatives were determined to be incapable of meeting most of the basic objectives of the project; and were not carried forward for detailed evaluation in the MEIR. Two additional action alternatives were determined to be infeasible and were not carried for detailed evaluation in the MEIR. Three action alternatives were carried forward for detailed evaluation in the MEIR. As required by CEQA, the No-Project Alternatives was carried through for detailed consideration. The City received ten (10) timely letters of comment and five (5) late letters of comment. All timely and late letters of comment reviewed prior to April 30, 1999 were reviewed and considered in the Final MEIR. LE GENERAL FINDINGS The City of Huntington Beach has addressed all environmental issues recommended by the California Environmental Quality Act Guidelines (1996 Version in place of the time of publication of the NOP) as part of the evaluation of the project and program level elements of the Master Plan. The Final MEIR concludes that the proposed project, Alternative 4A (modified) for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses will have no significant impacts on three (3) environmental issue areas (Land Use, Population.and Housing and Energy and Mineral Resources). The Final MEIR determined that the project and program level elements are expected to result in significant impacts that can be reduced to a level of insignificance with incorporation of the recommended mitigation measures for the following environmental resources: Geologic Issues,Water, Transportation/Circulation, Biological Resources, Hazards, Noise, Public Services, Utilities and Service Systems, Cultural Resources, and Recreation. The Final MEIR determined that construction of the Sports Complex element of the Master Plan would result in significant impacts on air quality during construction and significant impacts on aesthetics during operation that cannot be mitigated to a level of insignificance. The MEIR determined that construction of the Sports Complex element of the Master Plan would result in significant short-term impacts on air quality. Incorporation of the recommended mitigation measures substantially lessens impacts on air quality resulting from construction of the Sports Complex. The identified mitigation measures will substantially lessen PM,,and No,,emissions during construction to the maximum extent possible. However, construction impacts on air quality related to No, and PM,o emissions cannot be reduced to the level of insignificance during construction. There are no anticipated long-term significant impacts on air quality related to the operations of the park once the proposed project is completed. The number of vehicle trips made to the site during regular park operating hours is not expected to increase. Rather, trips are expected to be transferred from existing venues within the City of Huntington Beach. Impacts on aesthetics for the temporary location of the Ocean View Estates Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 1-9 W.I PRO/ECTS11096-0041 FINDINGSI 1096004.S01 Mobile Home Complex, resulting from night lighting of soccer/football fields would remain significant during night use of the soccer/football fields. The City of Huntington Beach evaluated seven action alternatives during preparation of the Master Plan and MEIR. Two (2) of the action alternatives were determined to be incapable of meeting most of the basic objectives of the project and were not carried forward for detailed evaluation. In addition, two action alternatives were determined to be infeasible due to engineering and construction constraints related to contaminated soils. Therefore, those alternatives were not carried forward for detailed evaluation. Four alternatives (three action alternatives and the No-Project alternative required by CEQA) were carried forward for detailed evaluation. Alternative 4A (modified), the proposed Master Plan, was determined to be the environmentally superior alternative. In accordance with Section 21081.6 (4) (1) of the CEQA Statutes, the City of Huntington Beach has prepared a mitigation monitoring program for those measures required to mitigate or avoid significant elements on the environment. In accordance with Section 21081.6(a)(2) of the CEQA Statutes, the City of Huntington Beach has specified the location and custodian of the documents and other materials which constitute the record of decision used in the decision making process for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses. In accordance with Section 21081.1 (c)(1), the City of Huntington Beach has found that it has independently reviewed and analyzed the information contained in the environmental documentation and exercised its independent judgement in reaching its conclusions. The City of Huntington Beach has prepared a Statement of Overriding Considerations with respect to unmitigated construction impacts on air quality from PM,o and NOX emissions that are expected to exceed the threshold established by the SCAQMD. The City of Huntington Beach has prepared a Statement of Overriding Considerations with respect to unmitigated impacts on aesthetics at the temporary location of the Ocean View Mobile Home Estates related to night lighting. The City of Huntington Beach has made the required findings pursuant to Section 15091 of the CEQA Guidelines. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations lone 22, 1999 Page 1-10 W.I PROI ECT511096-0041 FINDI NGSI 1096004.501 SECTION II POTENTIAL ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS WHICH ARE NOT SIGNIFICANT II.A LAND USE AND PLANNING Significant Impact: None Finding: The Master Plan is not expected to result in significant impacts on land use or planning. Therefore, no mitigation is required. Facts: The above finding is made based on the analysis included in Section 3.1, Land Use and Planning of the MEIR. The Master Plan will not alter the existing land use nor impact surrounding land use as defined in the City of Huntington Beach General Plan. The project and program level elements of the Master Plan are consistent with The Zoning Ordinance and Subdivision Designation OS-PR, Open Space-Parks and Recreation. Huntington Central Park will continue to operate as a recreational facility as zoned by the City of Huntington Beach. Therefore, no applicable plans or policies adopted by local, State and Federal agencies with jurisdiction over the project will be challenged by the proposed project. 1111.13 POPULATION AND HOUSING Significant Impact: None Finding: The Master Plan is not expected to result in significant impacts on population and housing. Therefore, no mitigation is required. Facts: The above finding is made based on the analysis included in Section 3.2, Population and Housing of the MEIR. The Master Plan has been designed to accommodate the recreational demands and needs of the anticipated population growth in the service area for this regional park facility, through the year 2010. Huntington Central Park is located in a largely built-out area of the City of Huntington Beach and is not expected to induce substantial growth or concentration of population, nor displace any existing residents. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page II-1 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 FI NDI NG511096004.502 II.0 ENERGY AND MINERAL RESOURCES Significant Impact: None Finding: The Master Plan is not expected to result in significant impacts on energy and mineral resources. Therefore, no mitigation is required. Facts: The above finding is made based on the analysis included in Section 3.8, Energy and Mineral Resources of the MEIR. The Master Plan is not expected to conflict with adopted energy conservation plans; use non-renewable resources in a wasteful or inefficient manner; or result in the loss of availability of a known mineral resource that would be of future value to the region and residents of the state. - Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 11-2 W.IPROJECTS11096-0041FINDI NGSI 1096004.S02 SECTION III POTENTIAL ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS WHICH CAN BE MITIGATED TO A LEVEL OF INSIGNIFICANCE III.A GEOLOGIC ISSUES Significant Impact: Several potential geologic and geotechnical constraints exist within the project level areas. Special considerations must be given to these constraints in the design and construction of the Sports Complex element of the Master Plan to avoid impacts to people from: • compressible materials (i.e., settlement) • ground subsidence • soils/formations susceptible to volume change (i.e., expansion and shrinkage) • corrosive soils Gross and surficial slope stability in the location of the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility could have a potential impact on geologic issues. Finding: Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into,.the Master Plan which mitigate or avoid the significant effects on the environment related to geologic issues. Facts: The following mitigation measures, Measure Geology 1-7, as identified in Section 3.3.4 of the Draft Master EIR, will eliminate or substantially lessen the significant impact on geologic issues related to construction of the Sports Complex to a level of insignificance. It is anticipated that the following project and program level elements —Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Expansion Yard, Consolidated Camping Area, Low Intensity Recreation Area, and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility— potentially requiring development over landfill materials, over potentially expansive soils, over areas with peat organic soils, and over areas underlain by liquefaction-prone soils will require mitigation similar to those outlined in Measure Geology-1 through Measure Geology-7. Measure Geology-1: The City of Huntington Beach shall incorporate the following recommendations into Plans and Specifications for the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan for the proposed project as a means of reducing the effects of expected ground surface settlements on the proposed improvements: Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 111-1 W:IPROJECT511096-0041FINDI NG511096004.503 • For environmental compliance, maintaining at least a 6400t thick layer of cover soils over the refuse; this would require special permitting from the Regional Water Quality Control Board (RWQCB) as a monolithic cover system • Pre-loading areas where structures are planned to reduce the elastic component of the refuse settlement • In-situ improvement of the upper portions of the refuse through the use of dynamic compaction • Including a synthetic reinforcement material in the 6-foot thick cover soil layer to create a stiff layer of soil capable of supporting structures and tending to distribute the effects of differential settlement Measure Geology-2: Prior to circulation of plans and specifications for construction of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach shall undertake sufficient engineering analysis to specify earthwork techniques to mitigate for the presence of peat, alluvial, and colluvial soils. The potential to design structures to accommodate the potential settlement resulting from compression of those materials may be considered. Alternatively, compressible soils may be removed and replaced with engineered fill that is less compressible or is reworked during grading to reduce compressibility. Other construction techniques such as dynamic compaction, compaction grouting, or vibro flotation/replacement can be used to improve the materials in situ (i.e., in place) so that they are not as susceptible to compression. Measure Geology-3: During construction of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the Construction Contractor shall ensure that all soils on the site impacted by proposed foundation loads and pavements will be improved as required. Typically, improvement consists of removing the materials to a predetermined depth below the proposed foundations and pavement sections, adjusting the moisture content of the materials so that they can be optimally compacted, and replacing and compacting the materials back into the zone below the foundations and pavement sections. Measure Geology-4: Prior to issuance of building permits and development of the Sports Complex element improvements located in the construction debris portion of the landfill, a minimum 4-foot thick soil cover layer must be maintained to serve as a monolithic cover system. Because the inert debris disposal pit was permitted by the RWQCB, it is anticipated that a properly designed monolithic cover system will be accepted and would allow for irrigated land uses. Measure Geology-5: The City of Huntington Beach will include in the plans and specifications for the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan the need to remove collapsible materials prior to construction of any structures or pavement. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations Juoe 22, 1999 Page I11-2 W.I PROJECTS11096-0041FINDINGS11096004.S03 The City of Huntington Beach will also include in the plans and specifications for the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan the need to reduce the potential for damage from expansive soils through incorporation. of appropriate engineering, design, and construction methods. These methods typically include either reworking the materials so that they are placed at a moisture content and density that is less susceptible to expansion or treatment of the expansive soils with lime to stabilize them. Measure Geology-6: The City of Huntington Beach shall include in the plans and specifications for the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan the need to incorporate appropriate design and construction measures related to correction of corrosive soils' potential to corrode ferrous materials through: • Proper selection of construction materials • Cathodic protection, including sacrificial rods or materials • Removal of the corrosive materials adjacent to the ferrous materials and replacement with non-corrosive soils • Concrete elements that will be in contact with potentially corrosive materials can be designed using special cement that is more resistant to corrosion Measure Geology-7: The City of Huntington Beach will include in the plans and specifications for all project level elements requiring imported fill material, the need for soils brought on-site to comply with City Specification 429 and as such,these activities would be subject to review and approval by the City Fire Department. Measure Geology-8: Mitigation measures have also been provided for potential impacts resulting from implementation of the program level elements of the Master Plan. The following measure is provided specifically for improvements associated with the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility element: The City of Huntington Beach shall include in the Final Design for the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility element of the proposed Master Plan the need to stabilize the surrounding slopes. Potential measures that could be incorporated into the final design include: • Regrading of the slopes to flatter inclinations .• Reducing the slope heights to reduce the forces tending to cause instability • Constructing soil buttress fills at or near the toes of slopes • Using proper vegetation to reduce soil erosion and corresponding surficial instability Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 111-3 W.I PROJECT511096-0041 FINDINGS11096004.503 I 11111.13 WATER Significant Impact: Runoff generated from the Sports Complex improvements will result in impacts on the existing 36-inch- diameter CMP between Sully Miller Lake and Talbert Lake. Construction and operation of the Sports Complex, and the Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Expansion Area and program level elements may result.in degradation of water quality. Construction activities related to implementation of the project and program level elements may result in increased erosion and/or siltation from exposure of bare surfaces to runoff and construction related water sources. The Semi-Active Recreation Area element may result in degradation of surface water associated with equestrian related uses and discharge of chlorinated water. . Irrigation water from the Sports Complex has the potential to degrade groundwater resources through increased infiltration into the underlying landfill material. Finding: Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project which mitigate or avoid the significant effects on the environment related to water. Facts: Implementation of Measures Water-1 through 4 are anticipated to reduce potential impacts related to erosion and siltation, and increases in the rate and amount of surface runoff resulting from construction of the project and program level elements below the level of significance. Implementation of Measure Hazards-5 is expected to reduce potential impacts on groundwater from irrigation of the Sports Complex below the level of significance. Measure Water-1: The City of Huntington Beach will require that project design of the Sports Complex will be undertaken to ensure that there is no substantial increases in the rate and amount of surface runoff. Incidental drainage will be routed off of the site to existing storm drains to the north and west. It is assumed that improvements to the existing storm drain system will be completed before project completion, as described in Measure Utilities-3. Measure Water-2: The construction contractor will be required to incorporate Best Management Practices (BMPs) consistent with the guidelines provided in the California Storm Water Best Management Practice Handbooks for Construction and Industrial/Commercial Activities, and Appendices F and G of the DAMP. Revegetation of cut and fill slopes resulting from project development will be undertaken Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 111-4 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 FINDI NGSI 1096004.503 with native vegetation or compatible non-invasive drought tolerant species wherever feasible. Compliance with this mitigation measure shall be demonstrated prior to issuance of grading permits or building permits, whichever comes first. Measure Water-3: The construction manager will be required to incorporate City Ordinance No. 3364 entitled "Storm Water and Urban Runoff Management' and Best Management Practices (BMPs) consistent with the guidelines provided in the California Storm Water Best Management Practice Handbooks: Municipal to ensure control of flood hazards and water quality prior to issuance of grading permits or building permits, whichever comes first. Measure Water-4: The City of Huntington Beach will reevaluate potential impacts to surface water quality from implementation of the Semi-Active Recreation Area and the Gun Range program level elements and determine appropriate mitigation measures as are appropriate. Measure Hazards-5: This measure is described in the Hazards Section of the Master EIR. III.0 TRANSPORTATION AND CIRCULATION Significant Impact: The Sports Complex element has a significant impact on the level of service (LOS) at the intersection of Golden West Street and Slater Avenue. In addition, traffic congestion at the access/egress routes for the proposed Sports Complex are anticipated, thus causing an impact. Finding: Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project which mitigate or avoid the significant effects on the environment related to transportation and circulation. Facts: Implementation of Measures Transportation/Circulation-1 through -10 are expected to reduce impacts on traffic safety on residential streets; parking; work area traffic; and roadway capacity and level of service below the level of significance. Measure Transportation/Circulation-1: Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the timing of the signal at the intersection of Golden West Street and Slater Avenue shall be optimized by the City Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 111-5 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 FI NDI NG511096004.503 of Huntington Beach to accommodate increased volume of traffic associated with this project element as indicated in the Traffic Impact Study (Appendix F of the MEIR). Measure Transportation/Circulation-2: Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach shall reconstruct the existing median on Golden West Street (at the location of proposed Driveway B) to accommodate a southbound left turn pocket. The storage length for the turn pocket shall be 200 feet with a 90-foot transition. Measure Transportation/Circulation-3: Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach shall improve Driveway A to a full width of 304eet to facilitate adequate site access. Driveway A shall be improved to incorporate 50 feet of throated driveway which would accommodate storage for two vehicles. Adequate sight distance shall be provided for exiting vehicles to safely merge into Golden West Street. This measure is intended to avoid conflicts between offsite and onsite circulation. Measure Transportation/Circulation-4: Prior to operation of the Sports Field Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach shall improve Driveway B to a full width of 42 feet to facilitate adequate site access. Driveway B shall be improved to incorporate one lane inbound and two lanes outbound. Driveway B shall be improved to incorporate 100-feet of throated driveway which will accommodate storage for four vehicles in each lane. This measure is intended to avoid difficulties between offsite and onsite circulation. Measure Transportation/Circulation-5: Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach shall construct the entrance component of Driveway C to accommodate a 100- feet throated entry to prevent queuing of vehicles into the cul-de-sac area. The entrance component of Driveway C shall be constructed to a width of 14-feet. This measure is required to prevent interference with signalized operations at the intersection of Talbert Avenue and Golden West Street. Measure Transportation/Circulation-6: Prior to completion of the Sports Complex element of the proposed.Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach shall construct the exit component of Driveway C to be aligned with an existing drive aisle in the library parking lot. The exit component of Driveway shall be constructed to a width of 14-feet. Construction of the exit component of Driveway C shall include signage and striping to the specifications of the Traffic Division of the Public Works Department of the City of Huntington Beach to ensure appropriate direction of traffic flow. Adequate sight distance shall Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations lune 22, 1999 Page 111-6 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 FINDINGSI 1096004.S03 i be provided for exiting vehicles. This measure is required to ensure adequate circulation within the new and existing parking areas. Measure Transportation/Circulation-7 Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach shall construct Driveway D to a full width of 30-feet to facilitate adequate site access. Driveway D shall be improved to incorporate 50-feet of throated driveway which would accommodate storage for two vehicles. Adequate sight distance shall be provided for exiting vehicles. This measure is intended to avoid on-site and off-site circulation difficulties. Measure Transportation/Circulation-8: During the initial five years of operation, the City of Huntington Beach shall provide incentives to encourage transit use to and from the Sports Complex, as necessary to remain below Congestion Management Agency and South Coast Air Quality Management District thresholds for congestion. Measure Transportation/Circulation-9: During the initial five years of operation, the City of Huntington Beach shall coordinate with the local transit agency to improve or increase service as necessary to remain below Congestion Management Agency and South Coast Air Quality Management District thresholds for congestion. Measure Transportation/Circulation-10: Prior to construction, the City of Huntington Beach Public Works Department shall review the Plans and Specifications for the Sports Complex to ensure that the requirement to offer security level bicycle racks at convenient and safe locations has been incorporated into the Sports Complex, as necessary to remain below Congestion Management Agency and South Coast Air Quality Management District thresholds for congestion. 11111.113 BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES Significant Impacts: Construction of the Sports Complex element of the Master Plan adjacent to Sully Miller Lake, and the Park Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion and Consolidated Campground adjacent to Talbert Lake-Meadow could potentially result in significant impacts to sensitive bird species potentially occurring in riparian disturbed vegetation. Implementation of the Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion and Consolidated Camping Ground elements could potentially impact disturbed riparian habitat adjacent to these planned improvements. Program level improvements planned for the non-native grasslands within the park could result in a significant loss of foraging habitat for raptors at the park. Lastly, the development of areas surrounding. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page III-7 W:I PR OJECTSI 1096-0041 FI ND1 NGSI 1096004.S03 I Sully Miller Lake could potentially result in significant impacts to disturbed riparian habitat, which is potential habitat for the least Bell's vireo and southwest willow flycatcher. Findings: Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project which mitigate or avoid the significant effects on the environment related to Biological Resources. Facts: All significant impacts are reduced to a level of insignificance with implementation of the following mitigation measures, Measure Biological Resources-1 through -6. Conducting directed surveys for sensitive species potentially occurring in disturbed riparian habitat in the park prior to construction in these areas will allow for appropriate scheduling of construction activities to avoid impacts to these species if they are found to be present. Presence of an environmental monitor at all sites where grading is scheduled to occur adjacent to riparian habitat will ensure no impacts occur to potential wetlands or habitat for sensitive species. Measure Biological Resources-1: Directed surveys for least Bell's vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher will be conducted prior to commencing any construction activities near disturbed riparian habitats. Directed surveys for least Bell's vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher will be conducted in accordance with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and California Department of Fish and Game published protocols for such surveys at the time that such surveys are undertaken. If the presence of either species is confirmed, construction and design plans will be modified to avoid impacts to these species. Measure Biological Resources-2: An environmental monitor will be present during grading and construction of the Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion, the Consolidated Camping Area, and the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility to ensure no unauthorized impacts occur to areas potentially subject to U.S. Army Corps of Engineers jurisdiction or to existing disturbed riparian habitat in areas adjacent to element of the proposed Master Plan. The Construction Monitor shall hold a permit for directed surveys for least Bell's vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher. The Construction Monitor shall be authorized to issue a stop work order in the unlikely event that southwestern willow flycatcher or least Bell's vireo are determined to be present in adjacent disturbed riparian habitat during construction. Measure Biological Resources-3: Directed surveys for six sensitive plant species that have the potential to be present in non-native grassland, southern tarplant (Hemizonia parryi ssp. australis), Coulter's goldfields (Lasthenia glabrata ssp. coulteri), Coulter's saltbush (Atriplex coulters), south coast saltscale (Atriplex pacifica), many-stemmed dudleya (Dudleya multicaulis), and intermediate Mariposa lily (Calochortus weedii var. intermedius) will be conducted prior to moving forward with program level elements which Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 111-8 W.I PROJECTS11096-0041 FI NDI NGSI 1096004.503 I will impact non-native grasslands within the Park. Directed surveys for the six sensitive plants will be conducted in accordance with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and California Department of Fish and Game published protocols for such surveys at the time that such surveys are undertaken. In the absence of a published protocol, such surveys will be undertaken in accordance with Guidelines for Assessing the Effects of Proposed Developments on Rare and Endangered Plants and Plant Communities prepared by the California Department of Fish and Game. Measure Biological Resources-4: Potential impacts to foraging habitat for raptors resulting from development of non-native grasslands in the Park could be mitigated by enhancing conserved areas of non-native grassland at a ratio of 1:1 for acres of impact on non-native grassland to provide suitable habitat values and functions for raptors. Mitigation for impacts on non-native grassland will be accomplished within conserved non-native grasslands in association with the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility, Low Intensity Recreation Area, Semi-Active Recreation Area and Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head. Enhancement of non-native grassland would include, but not be limited to, the planting of native trees within and adjacent to conserved areas of non-native grassland. Measure Biological Resources-5: Potential impacts resulting from implementation of the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility element would be mitigated through creation and enhancement of disturbed riparian habitats in the Shipley Nature Center and Talbert Lake-Meadow at a ratio of 3:1 for acres of impact. Measure Biological Resources-6: Concurrent with operation of the Sports Complex, the City shall implement or cause to be implemented a brown-headed cowbird trapping program. The brown-headed cowbird trapping program will be submitted to the Service for review and comment at least three months prior to the beginning of grading. Traps used to remove cowbirds will be modified Australian crow traps. These traps allow live capture of birds so that non-target birds can be released unharmed. The traps will be "baited" with live juvenile or female brown-headed cowbirds which will be captured prior to the trapping period with baited traps or mist nets. The juvenile or female cowbirds attract the attention of adult birds and lure them into traps. Once inside the trap, it is difficult for the birds to escape and they can be easily removed. Approximately four bait birds are kept in a separate cage within the trap and are not removed until the trapping season is over. The traps will be placed and maintained so as to provide trapped and bait birds ample shade, food, and water while they are in traps. All cowbirds (male, female, and juvenile) that are caught in the traps will be disposed of humanely. Trapping will take place during the nesting period of riparian bird species found in Central Park that are known to be parasitized by brown-headed cowbirds. Traps will be checked daily during the trapping period to remove both trapped cowbirds and non-target species, which will be released. Bait birds lost to predation or escape will be replaced during the daily checks. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page I11-9 W.1 PROJECTS11096-0041 FINDI NGSI 1096004.S03 An annual letter report documenting the results of the trapping program will be submitted to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Results of the trapping program will be recorded including the date and time of trap checking, observer(s), weather, age of trapped birds (both target and non-target species), the treatment of the birds (whether released, disposed of, or retained as bait birds), and other data pertaining to any unusual event, such as predation or loss of bait birds. 11111 HAZARDS Significant Impact: Construction in the vicinity of existing plugged and abandoned oil wells has the potential to expose people and property to hazards. Construction in the vicinity of methane rich soils has the potential to expose people and property to hazards. Operation of recreation facilities in proximity to Golden West Street and the oil field area west of Golden West Street has the potential to expose people and property to hazards. Construction of the Sports Complex, Sully Miller Lake Group Facility, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head and the Semi=Active Recreation Use Area has the potential to expose construction crew to oil saturated soils during excavation. Construction in the vicinity of methane rich soils has the potential to exacerbate lateral migration of methane. Construction in the vicinity of active oil wells has the potential to expose people to hazards Finding: Changes or alteration have been required in, or incorporated into, the project which mitigate or avoid significant effects on the environment related to hazards. Facts: Implementation of the following mitigation measures, Measures Hazards-1 through -15, will reduce impacts related to hazards below the level of significance. Measure Hazards-1: The plans and specifications for construction of the Sports Complex will reflect the need to reabandon the existing plugged and abandoned oil well within the proposed development area consistent with City of Huntington Beach Specification Number 422. Reabandonment will be undertaken during construction of the Sports Complex element of the Master Plan. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 111-10 W.IPROJECTSI 1096-0041 f I NDI NGSI 1096004.S03 Measure Hazards-2: The plans and specifications for construction of the Sully Miller Group Area will reflect the need to reabandon two existing plugged and abandoned oil wells within the proposed development area consistent with City of Huntington Beach Specification Number 422. Reabandonment will be undertaken during construction of the Sully Miller Group Facility element. Measure Hazards-3: The plans and specifications for the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head and the Semi-Active Recreation Area will reflect the need to reabandon twenty-nine (29) existing plugged and abandoned wells within the proposed development area consistent with City of Huntington Beach Specification Number 422. Reabandonment will be undertaken during construction of the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head and the Semi-Active Recreation Area elements of the Master Plan of Recreation Uses. Measure Hazards-4: Studies to evaluate the potential for landfill gas (LFG) generation and migration will be completed prior to development of the Sports Complex. Appropriate mitigation measures will be coordinated with the South Coast Air Quality Management District, Solid Waste Local Enforcement Agency (LEA), RWQCB, and the City of Huntington Beach Fire Department. Mitigation measures could entail active or passive extraction of LFG to control surface and offsite migration and passive barriers with vent layers and alarm systems below all enclosed structures on and within 1,000 feet of the landfill boundary. A comprehensive monitoring network will be established around the perimeter of the landfill. Periodic monitoring of the monitoring network and at locations above the surface of the landfill will be performed. Measure Hazards-5: Where the City of Huntington Beach determines the need to include irrigated land uses over areas underlain by refuse as part of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the plans and specifications will reflect the need to incorporate a more elaborate cover system to control moisture infiltration into the refuse. A suitable cover system could consist of a synthetic geomembrane,geotextile fabric for protection of geomembrane and filtering for the drainage layer, a drainage layer, and a vegetation layer or an approved alternative. Measure Hazards-6: The City of Huntington Beach shall prepare an Emergency Evacuation Plan for potential impacts related to (1) potential hazardous materials release on Golden West Street, or (2) a rupture or explosion in the vicinity of the oil field area west of Golden West Street. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page III-11 W:I PROJECTS11096-0041 FI NDI NGS11096004.S03 Measure Hazards-7: Plans and specifications for the Sports Complex, the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head and the Semi-Active Recreation Area will identify the potential to encounter oil saturated soils during excavation. If oil-saturated soil is encountered during excavation, plans and specifications shall require the construction foreman to contact the City of Huntington Beach, who shall contact the DOGGR and follow appropriate guidance. Measure Hazards-8: Appropriate methane mitigation features such as gas detectors, gas migration barriers, venting systems, and classified electrical installation shall be incorporated into plans and specifications for all proposed structures overlaying the former landfill and within 1,000 feet of the perimeter of the landfill. Design consideration for potential LFG migration through pipes, trenches, or other conduits shall be incorporated into Plans and Specifications. Methane migration features will be consistent with the requirements of the City of Huntington Beach Specification Number 429 and other applicable State and Federal regulations. The methane migration features shall be submitted for review and approval to the Orange County Health Care Agency, Environmental Health Division, which is the LEA for all cities and unincorporated areas of Orange County. Measure Hazards-9: Any unrecorded or unknown wells uncovered during the excavation or grading process shall be immediately reported to and coordinated with the City and DOGGR. In addition, should any unknown and unexpected landfills be excavated and discovered during the construction phase of the proposed project, construction work will be immediately halted and LEA will be notified. Further construction operations will resume at the discretion of LEA and upon work approval by LEA. Measure Hazards-10: Any redevelopment within the known oil field will shall be conducted in conformance with City requirements. City requirements include those outlined in Article 79 of the Uniform Fire Code (UFQ. Measure Hazards-11: The City Fire Department will prepare a Fire Risk Evaluation prior to issuance of grading permits. Measure Hazards-12: Plans and specifications for the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head shall include construction of an 8-foot high block wall enclosure around extant active oil wells and associated equipment. The block wall enclosures will include suitable gates which are capable of accommodating large workover equipment into the well sites. Landscaping that is climbable along the wall shall be Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations line 22, 1999 Page I11-12 W.I PROI ECTS11096-0041 FI NDI NGSI 1096004.S03 prohibited, since it defeats the purpose of the wall. Suitable vehicular access for well workover equipment shall be provided for active wells. Measure Hazards-13: Prior to construction of a gun range, a preliminary endangerment assessment (PEA) should be completed to screen the site for potential human and ecological health risks associated with possible contaminants including drilling muds, petroleum products, solid wastes, heavy metals, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and polychlorinated biphenyls. Measure Hazards-14: The City of Huntington Beach will prepare an Excavation Management Plan prior to beginning excavation within the limits of the landfill which will be submitted to and approved by the executive officer of the SCAQMD. This plan shall identify mitigation measures to be activated as necessary during excavation to ensure that a public nuisance condition does not occur. Mitigation measures shall be selected after consideration of the physical characteristics of the landfill. Measure Hazards-15: Prior to construction of the Sports Complex, Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion, Consolidated Camping Area,and Low-Intensity Recreation elements of the Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach Fire Department and Public Works Department shall review all construction plans and specifications to ensure that the specifications require that each contractor involved in grading activities develop a site-and action-specific comprehensive Health and Safety Plan. The plans and specifications will require that the Health and Safety Plan be developed using the information available about past uses of those sites and the possibility that solid waste, PCH- contaminated soils, and/or potentially hazardous waste materials could be encountered. III.F NOISE Significant Impact: Construction and operation of the Sports Complex could result in impacts on ambient noise levels in the adjacent land uses (especially on the Ocean View Estates mobile homes). Finding: Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project which mitigate or avoid. the significant effects on the environment related to noise. Facts: Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 111-13 W:IPROJECTSI 1096-0041 FINDI NCSI 1096004.S03 It is anticipated that implementation of Measures Noise-1 and -2 will reduce long-term operational impacts associated with the Southwest Softball field on the adjacent Ocean View Estates Mobile Homes below the level of significance. Implementation of Measures Noise-3 through -5 will reduce short-term impact on ambient noise levels within Ocean View Estates Mobile Homes from construction of the Sports Complex. No additional noise impacts are anticipated from the project level elements. Measure Noise-1: The City of Huntington Beach shall restrict amplified voice announcement systems for the Southwest Softball Fields. This restriction will alleviate noise impacts at residences at the Ocean View Estates such that noise ordinance limits are not exceeded. Measure Noise-2: The City of Huntington Beach shall restrict use of the Southwest Softball Fields after 10:00 P.M. The lights shall be turned off at this time and the fields closed. This restriction will alleviate noise impacts at residences at the Ocean View Estates. Measure Noise-3: The City of Huntington Beach shall limit grading and construction activities to daily operation hours between 7:00 A.M. and 7:00 P.M. (Monday through Friday) and 8:00 A.M. to 5:00 P.m. on Saturdays. Construction shall not take place on Sundays or Federal holidays. Measure Noise-4: The construction manager shall ensure that all construction and grading equipment is properly maintained and turned off when not in use. Measure Noise-5: The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has estimated that noise levels from construction equipment can be lowered by as much as 13 dBA by implementing noise control features that require no major redesign or extreme cost. The City of Huntington Beach shall require that all construction equipment incorporate noise reduction control features. All vehicles and compressors should utilize exhaust mufflers, and engine enclosure covers as designed by the manufacturer should be in place at all times. III.G PUBLIC SERVICES Significant Impacts: The existing fire hydrant at the proposed location of the Consolidated Camping Area is inadequate. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page I11-14 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 FI NDI NG511096004.503 It is anticipated that implementation of the project and program level elements are likely to result in the need for additional police protective services. It is anticipated that construction of the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head and Semi-Active Recreation Area may preclude use of the southwestern portion of the Park as a cross country training course for up to one season. Findings: Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project which mitigate or avoid the significant effects on the environment related to public services. Facts: Implementation of Measure Public Services-1 will reduce impacts associated with inadequate fire hydrant facilities at the proposed Consolidated Camping area to below the level of significance. Implementation of Measures Public Services-2, -3, and -4 are capable of reducing impacts associated with the need to provide additional police protection to below the level of significance. Implementation of Measures Public Services-5 and-6 are capable of preserving existing education (e.g. training course for high school cross-country teams) to below the level of significance. These mitigation measures are listed below. Measure Public Services- 1: The City of Huntington Beach will provide a permanent fire hydrant in the proposed Consolidated Camping Area in order to provide adequate fire protection infrastructure in that area. a Measure Public Services- 2: In order to reduce the need for additional police protection services, the City of Huntington Beach will maintain landscaping around the western and southern boundaries of the Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Expansion Yard Area at less than two feet in height.The chain link fencing will have approximately one-inch openings in order to discourage individuals from climbing over the fence and from cutting holes in the fence. Measure Public Services- 3: The City of Huntington Beach will design the proposed tot lot areas in the Park to allow visibility in those areas. This will discourage loitering and crime, as well as, provide a greater sense of safety to the users of these areas. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 111-15 W.I PROJECTSI 1096-004WINDINGSI 1096004.503 Measure Public Services-4: The City of Huntington Beach will modify the design of new restroom facilities from the design of existing restroom facilities in order to promote better safety, thus reducing the need for additional police protection services. New restrooms shall include an exterior door that is locked open during park hours. New restroom design shall allow anyone from outside the restroom to see if there is anyone in the restroom before entering. This shall be attained by allowing no interior restroom wall (except the main structural wall) to meet the floor. The feet of anyone in any area of the restroom shall be visible from the outside. Measure Public Services-5: . Prior to completion of Final Design for the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head and/or the Semi- Active Recreation Area, the proposed training course for the cross-country teams will be submitted to the Huntington Beach Unified High School District for review and comment to ensure that the course is suitable for training junior varsity and varsity cross-country squads. Measure Public Services-6: Prior to construction of the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead and/or the Semi-Active Recreation Area, coordination will be undertaken with the Huntington Beach Unified School District to identify an alternative training course within Huntington Beach Central Park to train junior varsity and varsity cross-country teams during periods when the southwestern portion of the Park will be closed for construction. III.H UTILITIES AND SERVICE SYSTEMS Significant Impacts: PROJECT LEVEL ELEMENTS The proposed project level elements will result in a peak hour demand for water that will impact existing water supply. The project level elements will result in a peak hour demand for potable and irrigation water that generates a need for substantial alteration of the water distribution system. The proposed project may increase sewer generation that exceeds the capacity of existing sewer facilities. The Sports Complex elements will impact the existing deficient 36-inch diameter corrugated metal pipe that conveys storm water between Sully Miller and Talbert Lakes. Implementation of the proposed Sports Complex Element is anticipated to exacerbate existing storm drainage deficiencies that service the west side of the Sports Complex Area. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations . June 22, 1999 Page Ill-16 W:I PROJECTS11096-0041 FI NDI NGSI 1096004.S03 Electrical loads may exceed the capacity of the existing infrastructure, and a new electrical service will be required to serve the project. PROGRAM LEVEL ELEMENTS Program level elements may result in impacts to existing water supply. Increased runoff from program level elements may result in impact to existing storm drain facilities. Electrical loads from the implementation of program level elements may result in impacts to existing electrical infrastructure. The potential exists for impacts on surface water runoff as the result of project construction and implementation. Findings: Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project which mitigate or avoid the significant effects on the environment related to Utilities and Service Systems. Facts: Implementation of Measure Utilities-1 will reduce the impacts associated with irrigation water supply to below the level of significance. Once the Green Acres Project is operational and is able to provide reclaimed water for irrigation, impacts to the area's water supply will be further mitigated to below the level of significance. Implementation of Measure Utilities-2 will reduce the impact to the existing irrigation distribution system to below the level of significance. Implementation of Measure Utilities-3 is anticipated to reduce any impacts associated with additional sewage generation as a result of implementation of the Master Plan elements. Implementation of Measure Utilities-4 and -5 should reduce the impact from the Sports Complex to existing storm drain facilities along Golden West Street to below the level of significance. Implementation of Measure Utilities-6 will mitigate impacts to existing electrical systems to below the level of significance. Implementation of Measure Utilities-7 will reduce impacts to existing water supply and distribution systems as the result of program level elements, to below the level of significance. Implementation of Measure Utilities-8 will reduce impacts to storm drain facilities to below the level of significance for program level elements. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page Ill-17 W.I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 FI NDINGSI 1096004.S03 Implementation of Measure Utilities-9 will ensure that program level elements will not result in significant impacts. Implementation of Measure Water-3, which appears in Section 3-4 in the MEIR, will reduce impacts associated with additional surface runoff from pre-and post-construction activities to below the level of significance. These mitigation measures are listed below. Measure Utilities-1: The City of Huntington Beach shall utilize the existing City domestic potable water supply for the irrigation water supply until the Green Acres Project is operational and able to distribute water to Huntington Central Park. Measure Utilities-2: The City of Huntington Beach shall develop an irrigation system for the Sports Complex Element to the standards and specifications required for a reclaimed water irrigation system in order that this new system can accommodate reclaimed water supply from the Green Acres Project. Measure Utilities-3: Prior to final design of the Sports Complex, the City of Huntington Beach will conduct a sewer flow monitoring test to determine the capacity of the existing 15-inch diameter pipeline in Golden West Street. If the existing capacity is determined to be inadequate to accommodate the proposed project's sewage flow, replacement of a determined portion of the sewer line shall be undertaken at that time. An 8—inch diameter collector sewer line will be required for carrying waste discharges from the project. Measure Utilities-4: The City of Huntington Beach shall replace the currently damaged 36-inch diameter corrugated metal pipe which runs between Sully Miller Lake and Talbert Lake to accommodate current and future surface runoff from the proposed Sports Complex site. The new line, a 36-inch reinforced concrete pipe, shall be designed and constructed in conjunction with the overall Sports Complex Drainage Improvements. Measure Utilities-5: Plans and specifications for the Sports Complex will reflect the need to direct storm runoff from the west side of the site to the new 36-inch reinforced concrete pipe specified in Measure Utilities- 4, Measure Utilities-6: Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page III-18 W.I PROJECT511096-0041 FI NDI NGSI 1096004.503 The City of Huntington Beach shall install a new pad-mounted 1000 KVA transformer to provide adequate electrical service to the project. It will be determined during the design whether or not the transformer will be surface mounted or located in vault during the construction phase of the project. PROGRAM LEVEL Mitigation measures have been identified for potential impacts resulting from increased irrigation requirements for the proposed program level elements of the Master Plan. These measures may include one or a combination of the following strategies. Measure Utilities-7 If the Green Acres Project is not yet operational and able to supply water to the program level elements of the Master Plan prior to the development of final plans and specifications, additional studies will be undertaken to determine the extent to which one or a combination of the following measures will be necessary to reduce impacts to water supply systems for program level elements during the interim until water from the Green Acres Project is available: • reduce the required irrigable areas by 10 percent; _.. • enhance the utilization of existing groundwater systems (i.e., subpotable wells); or • supplement the irrigation supply with water from the domestic water system. Measure Utilities-8: City of Huntington Beach will require that design of program level elements will be undertaken such that there are no substantial increases in the rate and amount of surface runoff. Incidental drainage will be routed off of the site to existing storm drains. It is assumed that any necessary improvements to existing storm drain systems will be completed before the completion of program level elements. Measure Utilities-9: Prior to the construction of program level elements, additiona[electrical load analyses shall be undertaken to determine the need for additional electrical transformers. Measure Water-3 As described in Section lll. B of this Statement of Findings and Overriding Considerations. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 111-19 W:I PROJECTS11096-0041 FI NDI NGS11096004.S03 111.1 CULTURAL RESOURCES Significant Impacts: The potential to disturb paleonotological resources that represent valuable scientific information is most likely to occur in association with the excavation, grading, road construction, and utility placement for program level elements. Disturbing these resources would create an impact on Cultural Resources. Construction of the Low Intensity Recreation Area element has the potential to result in significant impacts on CA-ORA-142. Construction of the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head element has the potential to result in significant impacts on CA-ORA-82, CA-ORA-1318, and CA-ORA-1275. CA-ORA- 82 is considered potentially eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places. Construction of the Semi-Active Recreation Area element has the potential to result in significant impacts on CA- ORA-1317. Ground-disturbing activities in association with the Low Intensity Recreation Area, the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head, and the Semi-Active Recreation Area elements have the potential to result in discovery of currently unknown burial or cemetery sites that would constitute a significant impact. Findings: Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project which mitigate or avoid the significant effects on the environment related to Paleontological Resources. Impacts to Archaeological resources could remain significant if burial sites are discovered during implementation of the Proposed Action. If no burial sites are discovered, impacts can be reduced below the level of significance through the implementation of the following mitigation measures. Facts: Implementation of Measures Paleontology-1 through -4 would reduce the potential for impacts on paleontological resources below the level of significance. The discovery of a burial(s) or cemetery in association with the Low Intensity Recreation Area, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead, or Semi-Active Recreation Area elements would preclude the ability to reduce impacts below the level of significance. Subsequent environmental analysis will be required in association with the Low Intensity Recreation Area, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead,and Semi- Active Recreation Area elements to assess the level of impact on cultural resources. In the absence of. discovery of burial(s) or cemetery sites it is anticipated that implementation of Measures Archaeology-1 through -8 would reduce impacts on prehistoric Archaeological resources below the level of significance. Implementation of Measures Historic-1 through-3 would reduce the potential for impacts on unknown but potentially present historic resources below level of significance. Measure Paleontology-1: Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 111-20 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 FI NDI NGSI 1096004.S03 The plan and specifications for construction of the Low Intensity Recreation Area, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head, Semi-Active Recreation Area, and the Sully Miller Lake Group Picnic Facility shall identify the need to engage a qualified vertebrate paleontologic monitor to monitor excavation in native substrates. During excavation, the monitor should be equipped to salvage fossils as they are unearthed to avoid construction delays and to remove samples of sediments which are likely to contain the remains of small fossil vertebrates. The monitor must be empowered to temporarily halt or divert equipment to allow removal of abundant or large specimens. Measure Paleontology-2: If located during excavation, recovered specimens shall be prepared by a qualified paleontologist to a point of identification, including washing of sediments to recover small fossil vertebrates. Measure Paleontology-3: If located during excavation, specimens will be identified by a qualified paleontologist and curated into a museum repository with retrievable storage. Measure Paleontology-4: - A report of findings will be prepared with an appended, itemized inventory of specimens. The report and inventory, when submitted to the Public Facilities and Resources Department of the Orange County Harbors, Beaches and Parks Division, will signify the completion of the program to mitigate impacts to paleontologic resources. Measure Archaeology-1: Prior to final design of the Low Intensity Recreation Area, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head and . Semi-Active Recreation Area elements of the proposed Master Plan sufficient cultural resources investigations shall be undertaken to identify the location and extent of CA-ORA-82, CA-ORA- 1317, CA-ORA-142, CA-ORA-1275, and CA-ORA-1318. Measures to avoid impacts on cultural resources shall be incorporated to the maximum extent practicable with the guidelines provided in Parts A and B of Section II of the CEQA Statutes and Guidelines. Measure Archaeology-2: If avoidance of CA-ORA-142 is determined to be infeasible, then a test level program shall be developed. Infotech's (1989) Prehistoric Sites Management Planning section states: "If appropriate data were collected from the extensive, unreported excavations east of Edwards Street, analysis of that information might suffice for the delineation of productive research there." If data are insufficient, additional testing is recommended. The testing should characterize the site structure, contents, integrity, age and nature of the occupation(s).Testing activities should include, Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 111-21 W.I PROJECTS11096-0041 FI NDI NGSI 1096004.S03 but are not limited to, auguring, surface collection units, surface transect units, and the examination of cut banks to determine the sites horizontal and vertical boundaries. Controlled manual excavation, with control columns, would follow preliminary testing, to provide a detailed delineation of the site's characteristics and importance under the criteria outlined in Appendix K, Section III. Measure Archaeology-3: The City of Huntington Beach shall engage a qualified archaeologist to attend the pre-grade meeting for Low Intensity Recreation Area, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head, and Semi-Active Recreation Area elements. Measure Archaeology-4 The City of Huntington Beach shall engage a qualified archaeologist tp monitor during grading activities within soil layers above bedrock material for Low Intensity Recreation, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head, and Semi-Active Recreation Area elements. During initial removal of vegetation, the archaeologist shall monitor daily to observe and retrieve any buried artifacts that may be uncovered. If important prehistoric or historic resources or deposits are encountered, then evaluative testing and/or other appropriate archaeological investigations shall be conducted. Measure Archaeology-5: The City of Huntington Beach shall coordinate with the Native American Heritage Commission.to identify an appropriate Native American monitor to be included in any testing, data recovery, and . monitoring activities related to the Low Intensity Recreation, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead, and Semi-Active Recreation Area elements. A Memorandum of Agreement shall be prepared to deal with possible buried human remains. If a burial, burials, or a cemetery are encountered, reburial of the remains on other City properties may be requested by the Native Americans. A cemetery is defined as, in excess of six burials. Measure Archaeology-6: The archaeological monitor shall have the authority to temporarily divert or redirect grading to allow time to evaluate any exposed prehistoric or historic material. Measure Archaeology-7: Any scientifically significant artifacts shall be properly recovered after evaluation by, and under the supervision of, a qualified archaeologist. A data recovery plan that includes an excavation plan, laboratory analysis and report preparation, shall be developed prior to the recovery of the remains. Measure Archaeology-8 Any recovered prehistoric and historic artifacts shall be offered, on a first right-of-refusal basis, to a repository with a retrievable collection system and an educational and/or research interest in the Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page III-22 W.1 PROI ECTSI 1096-0041FINDINGSI 1096004.S03 materials. Copies of the report shall be submitted to the South Central Coast Information Center, Fowler Museum, University of California, Los Angeles. An additional copy shall accompany any recovered artifacts to the repository. Measure Historical-1: Prior to the initiation of grading activities in support of the Low Intensity Recreation Area, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head, and Semi-Active Recreation Area, the City of Huntington Beach shall engage a qualified archaeologist to periodically monitor grading activities for historic archaeological resources. Measure Historical-2: The archaeological monitor shall- have the authority to halt.grading until exposed historic archaeological resources can be evaluated for their importance. Measure Historical-3: If the historic archaeological resources are deemed to be important, then a testing or data recovery program shall be developed and implemented. - III.J RECREATION Significant Impact: Three of the program level elements of the proposed Master Plan (Low Intensity Recreation Area Improvements, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head Improvements, and Semi-Active Recreation Area Improvements) have the potential to result in impacts on recreation through the temporary or permanent disruption of existing recreation uses. Two of the program level elements, the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility and the Police/Civilian Gun Range, have the potential to result in impacts on the safety of recreation users. Finding: Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project which mitigate or avoid the significant effects on the environment related to recreation. Facts: Implementation of Measures Recreation-1 through -3 would reduce significant impacts on recreation users below the level of significance. Implementation of Measures Recreation-4 and -5 will reduce potential impacts on recreation users related to safety below the level of significance. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page 111-23 W.1 PROJECTSI 1096-0041 FINDINGSI 1096004.S03 Measure Recreation-1: At least thirty days prior to construction, the City of Huntington Beach shall post signs in the vicinity of the Low Intensity Recreation Area indicating the proposed construction schedule and alternate recreation facilities (including location and hours of operation) located in the service area for passive recreation use that can be used during the construction period. Measure Recreation-2: At least thirty days prior to construction, the City of Huntington Beach shall post signs in the vicinity of the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head Improvements indicating the proposed construction schedule and alternate recreation facilities (including location and hours of operation) located in the service area for passive recreation use that can be used during the construction period. Measure Recreation-3: At least thirty days prior to construction, the City of Huntington Beach shall post signs in the vicinity of the Semi-Active Recreation Area Improvements indicating the proposed construction schedule and alternate recreation facilities (including location and hours of operation) located in the service area for active recreation use that can be used during the construction period. Measure Recreation-4: Prior to completing final design for the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility element, the City of Huntington Beach will undertake sufficient analysis to define site-specific slope remediation and water quality treatment to comply with state-of-the-practice for safety of recreation users. Such measures will be incorporated into plans and specifications. Measure Recreation-5: Prior to completing final design for the Police/Civilian Gun Range element, the City of Huntington Beach will undertake sufficient analysis to define safety elements into the facility design to comply with state-of-the-practice for recreation users. Such measures will be incorporated into plans and specifications. Alternative locations for the Police/Civilian Gun Range should be considered as part of that analysis. Such analysis will be considered in the subsequent environmental analysis for this element. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page III-24 W:IPROJECTSI 1096-0041 FI NDI NGS 11096004.503 SECTION IV SIGNIFICANT UNAVOIDABLE ADVERSE IMPACTS WHICH CANNOT BE MITIGATED TO A LEVEL OF INSIGNIFICANCE The City of Huntington Beach has determined that, although the Final Master Environmental Impact Report (MEIR) mitigation measures recommended as part of the proposed project will substantially reduce the level of impact on air quality and aesthetics resulting from temporary construction activities and operational night lighting of the multiple sports fields, impacts to air quality regarding PM,o emissions and glare intrusion on nearby residents at the Ocean View Mobile Home Complex cannot be mitigated to below the level of significance. Consequently in accordance with Section 15093 of the State CEQA Guidelines, a Statement of Overriding Considerations has been prepared (See Section IX) to substantiate the City's decision to accept these unavoidable adverse environmental effects because of the benefits afforded by the proposed project. IV.A AIR QUALITY Significant Impact: During construction, there will be significant unavoidable emissions of both nitrogen oxides NO.and PM,o from construction on the peak-day and in the peak quarter. During construction, NO.emissions from heavy equipment and construction crew trips will exceed the threshold for significance. Finding: The mitigation measures identified in the Section 3.5.4 Air Quality of the MEIR cannot reduce PMt0 during construction below the significance threshold defined by SCAQMD. The City of Huntington Beach has recommended thirteen (13) mitigation measures identified by the SCAQMD as being capable of reducing construction emissions of NO), and PM,o. Implementation of Measures Air- 1 through Air-12 will substantially reduce emissions of NO.and PM,o during the construction phase. The recommended mitigation measures will reduce, to the maximum extent feasible, the adverse environmental effect of PM,o emissions. These measures, however, will not reduce emissions to a less than significant level. Long term cumulative impacts from the proposed project will not be significant at either the regional or local levels. The adoption of the following mitigation measures for air and in light of the Statement of Overrriding Considerations prepared in Section IX, impacts on air quality from the proposed project are considered not significant. Facts: The above finding is made based on a Statement of Overriding Considerations that has been prepared for the proposed project and that the implementation of the following Measures Air-1 through Air-12 will minimize construction impacts on air quality, resulting from NO,,and PM,o emissions. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page IV-1 W.IPROJECTSI 1096-0041 FI NDI NGSI 1096004.SO4 CONSTRUCTION EMISSIONS Measure Air-1: Moisten soil each day prior to commencing grading to depth of soil cut. Measure Air-2: Water exposed surfaces at least twice a day under calm conditions and as often as needed on windy days when winds are more than 25 miles per hour or during very dry weather in order to maintain a surface crust and prevent the release of visible emissions from the construction site. Measure Air-3: Treat any area that will be exposed for extended periods with a soil conditioner to stabilize soil or temporarily plant with vegetation. Measure Air-4: Wash mud-covered tires and under-carriages of trucks leaving construction sites. Measure Air-5: Provide for street sweeping, as needed, on adjacent roadways to remove dirt dropped by construction vehicles or mud which would otherwise be carried off.by trucks departing project sites. Measure Air-6: Securely cover all loads of fill coming to the site with a tight fitting tarp. Measure Air-7: Cease grading during periods when winds exceed 25 miles per hour. Measure Air-8: Provide for permanent sealing of all graded areas, as applicable, at the earliest practicable time after soil disturbance. In addition, the following measures to reduce equipment and employee travel emissions will be implemented wherever feasible: Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page IV-2 W.I PROJECTS11096-0041 FI NDI NGSI 1096004.SO4 Measure Air-9: Maintain construction equipment in peak operating condition so as to reduce operation emissions. Measure Air-10: Use low-sulfur diesel fuel in all equipment. Measure Air-11: Use electric equipment whenever practicable. Measure Air-12: Shut off engines when not in use. The following mitigation measure addresses potential impacts resulting from the release of noxious odors during excavation of landfills in association with the Proposed Project. Measure Air-13: Prior to beginning excavation in the area of the Huntington Landfill, an Excavation Management Plan must be prepared. This Plan shall be submitted by the City to the SCAQMD under the requirements of Rule 1150. The Plan shall contain measures for mitigating odors. No excavation will begin until this plan has been reviewed by the SCAQMD Executive Officer and approved for its adequacy in mitigating all potential air quality impacts that could result from excavation of the landfill site. The Plan shall also address the possibility of other construction activities distributing and exposing odor-producing waste in areas of the park not undergoing direct excavation. IVB. AESTHETICS Significant Impacts: Implementation of the proposed project will have a significant impact on aesthetics for the temporary location of the Ocean View Mobile Home Estates that will result primarily from the new installation of lights. These lights are considered a new light source seen by surrounding residents particularly during night use of the soccer/football fields and softball fields and on residents adjacent to the sports field. The proposed project will also have a negative aesthetic impact on the temporary location of adjacent residents from placement of the new boundary fences and walls. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page IV-3 W:I PROJECTS11096-0041 FI NDINGSI 1096004.504 Findings: Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project which substantially reduce the significant effects on the environment related to Aesthetics. Impacts resulting from night lighting of the soccer/football fields and softball fields will remain significant, affecting the temporary location of the Ocean View Estates Mobile Home Complex. Facts: Implementation of Measures Aesthetic-1 through -3 would reduce most impacts on aesthetics below the level of significance. Impacts on aesthetics resulting from night lighting of soccer/football fields and softball fields would remain significant during night use of the soccer/football fields, impacting the temporary location of the Ocean View Estates Mobile Home Complex. Measure Aesthetics- 1: Prior to completion of Plans and Specifications for the Sports Complex, the City of Huntington Beach shall include specifications related to security and night lighting to minimize impacts to the adjacent mobile homes. At a minimum, such specifications shall require the use of photo- control-on and time-clock-off(dusk to dawn) system to control security and night lighting. The type of illumination system for security lighting will be low glare and will not interfere with views yet will provide security. Security lighting will use high-efficiency, non-glare, high- pressure sodium lamps. Night lighting shall be oriented away from residential areas. The use of shields shall be considered as a means of minimizing the effects of night lighting on the temporary location of the Ocean View Estates Mobile Home Complex. Measure Aesthetics-2: Prior to completion of Plans and Specifications for the Sports Complex, the City of Huntington Beach shall include specifications for landscape treatment to screen the south side of the 6-8- foot-high wall to be constructed between the southern boundary of the Sports Complex and the Ocean View Estates Mobile Homes. Measure Aesthetics-3: Prior to completion of Plans and Specifications for the Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion, the City of.Huntington Beach shall include specifications for landscape treatment of the chain link fence to be constructed along the western and southern boundaries of the expansion area. The landscape treatment will comply to'the maximum extent practicable with the Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design Guidelines. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations lune 22, 1999 Page IV-4 W.I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 FI NDI NGSI 1096004.SO4 SECTION V FINDINGS REGARDING ALTERNATIVES Alternatives to the project described in the the Final Master Environmental Impact Report(MEIR) were considered. The Final MEIR addressed a-range of reasonable alternatives that would feasibly attain most of the basic objectives as a means of evaluating the ability of the alternatives to avoid or substantially lessen the significant effects of the project. The City of Huntington Beach evaluated seven alternatives during the preparation of the Master Plan and MEIR. Two (2) of the alternatives were determined to be incapable of meeting most of the basic objectives of the project and were not carried forward for detailed evaluation. In addition, two alternatives were determined to be infeasible due to engineering and construction constraints related to contaminated soils. Four alternatives (three action alternatives and the No-Project alternative required by CEQA) were carried forward for detailed evaluation. A summary of the ability of the project and four alternatives under consideration to meet the objectives of the project is summarized in these Findings as Table V-1, Summary of Master Plan of Recreation Uses and Alternatives Capable of Attaining Most of the Objectives; Table V-2, Elements of the Master Plan of Recreation Uses and Alternatives; and Table V-3, Comparative Analysis of Impacts for Master Plan of Recreation Uses and Alternatives. The three action alternatives analyzed were determined to be consistent with all of the project objectives.Although not capable of meeting most of the basic objectives of the project, the No- Project Alternative was carried forward for detailed consideration as required by the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). Alternative 4A (modified), the proposed Master Plan, was determined to be the environmentally superior alternative. The City of Huntington Beach determined, based on the alternatives analysis provided in Section 4.0 of the Draft Master EIR that impacts on air quality arising from construction generated emissions would not be avoided or substantially lessened by either of the alternatives including the preferred alternative. Although the No-Project Alternative would avoid impacts on air quality arising from construction, it is not.capable of meeting most of the basic objectives of the project. Therefore, the Master Plan (Alternative 4A, modified) was determined to be the Environmentally Superior Alternative. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page V-1 V :IPROJECTSI1096-0041FINDINGSI1096004.S58 The alternatives to the project evaluated in this section are as follow: Ball Field(Save Our Kids)Alternative Commercial Alternative Mixed Use Alternative No Project Alternative V.A Alternative 1: Ball Field (Save Our Kids) Alternative Description of Alternative: In this alternative, program and project level improvements are the same as the proposed project with the exception of the proposed Sports Complex. Sports Complex Element In this alternative the recommended facilities include: lighted practice fields, minimum of 746 parking spaces, a minimum of two (2) concession-run roller hockey courts, two (2) overlay soccer/football fields, one (1) lighted 300' outfield and four (4) lighted 200' outfield ball diamonds complete with dugout areas and bleacher plazas, various site furnishings (i.e.: litter receptacles, drinking fountains, benches), centralized restroom/concession building, multi- purpose gymnasium with offices/lockers/meeting rooms, and an outdoor aquatic facility with fifty (50) meter pool, diving tower, and therapeutic pool. Effectiveness in Meeting Project Objectives:As with the project,this alternative meets all of the project objectives described in Section 2.2 of the MEIR. The summary of this alternative's ability to meet the City's project objectives is provided in Table V-1. Comparison of Effects of the Alternative to Effects of the Project: The regulatory framework and existing conditions would be the same as that described for the project. A summary comparison of this alternative to effects of the Master Plan is presented in Table V-3. This table relates that this alternative differs from the Master Plan in the assessment of geologic issues, water, air quality, hazards, noise and utilities and service systems. ► Geologic Issues- Additional structures(multi-purpose Gymnasium and Aquatic Center) to be constructed at the proposed Sports Complex will increase the potential for exposure of people to geologic issues. ► Water- Development of this alternative could result in increased quantities and rates of surface water runoff and increased water quality impacts from development of 8.3 additional acres of impervious surface. Development of an aquatic center could result in water quality impacts from discharge of chlorinated water from the site. ► Air Quality- Slightly lower overall construction impacts are expected from implementation of this alternative, due to a decrease in the number of parking spaces to be constructed; however, impacts on air quality remain significant and require implementation of the same mitigation measures described for the project. ► Hazards- Increase in impervious surface from 2.7 acres in proposed project to 10.0 acres increases the potential for methane migration. An additional mitigation measure, Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page V-2 M I PROI EC7511096-0041 FI NDING511096004.558 Measure Hazards-13, is required to reduce risks to people and property to a less than significant level. ► Noise- Location of the adult softball field farther from the mobile home site will reduce operation impacts of the field on the mobile home site. Development of the Aquatic Center has potential to expose sensitive receptors to noise impacts. This alternative requires incorporation of all mitigation measures required for the project. ► Utilities and Service Systems- Impacts to sewer and water supply would increase with this alternative. Impacts from irrigation would be lower but still present under.this alternative. As with the project, this alternative requires incorporation of the mitigation measures required for the project. Feasibility: Alternative 1 is not feasible. Facts: The above finding is based on the following: • Impacts related to geologic issues, water, hazards, and noise are exacerbated and require the consideration of additional mitigation measures. • This alternative was determined to be not feasible as.a means of avoiding or mitigating for significant impacts on air quality associated with the project in that it would require implementation of the same mitigation measures required for the project and would not reduce anticipated PM,o and,Nox emissions. • This alternative was determined to be not feasible as a means of avoiding significant impacts on aesthetics from night lighting associated with the project in that it would require implementation of the same mitigation measures required for the project and would not reduce anticipated impacts from night lighting. V.B Alternative 2: Commercial Alternative Description of Alternative: Program and project level improvements in this alternative are the same as the proposed project with the exception of the Sports Complex. Sports Complex Element In this alternative the recommended facilities include: lighted practice fields, approximately 670 parking spaces, a minimum of two (2) concession-run roller hockey courts, four (4)overlay soccer/football fields, four (4) lighted 300' outfield ball diamonds complete with dugout areas and bleacher plazas,various site furnishings(i.e. litter receptacles, drinking fountains, benches), and a restroom/concession building. Effectiveness in Meeting.Project Objectives: As. with the project, this alternative meets all of the project's objectives described in Section 2.2 of the MEIR. The summary of this alternative's ability to meet the City's project objectives is provided in Table V-1. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page V-3 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 FI NDINGSI 1096004.S58 Comparison of Effects of the Alternative to Effects of the Project: The regulatory framework and existing conditions would be the same as that described for the project. A summary comparison of this alternative to effects of the Master Plan is presented in Table V-3. This table relates that this alternative differs from the Master Plan in the assessment of water, air quality, hazards, noise and utilities and service systems. Water- Development of this alternative could result in increased quantities or rates of surface water runoff and increased water quality impacts from development of 1.0 additional acres of impervious surface. ► Air Quality-Same as with Alternative 1. ► Hazards- Increase in impervious surface from 2.7 acres in proposed project to 3.7 acres increases the potential for methane migration. An additional mitigation measure, Measure Hazards-14, is required to reduce risks to people and property to a less than significant level. ► Noise- Placement of the roller hockey rinks closer to the Ocean View Estates has the potential to result in slightly increased noise impacts. ► Utilities and Service Systems- Impacts to sewer and water supply would increase with this alternative. Impacts from irrigation would be lower but still present. Feasibility: Alternative 2 is not feasible. - Facts: The above finding is based on the following: • Impacts related to water, hazards, noise, and utilities and service systems will be exacerbated with this alternative. • This alternative was determined to be not feasible as a means of avoiding or mitigating for significant impacts on air quality associated with the project in that it would require implementation of the same mitigation measures required for the project and would not reduce anticipated PM,o and No,emissions. • This alternative was determined to be not feasible as a means of avoiding significant impacts on aesthetics from night lighting associated with the project in that it would require implementation of the same mitigation measures required for the project and would not reduce anticipated impacts from night lighting. V.0 Alternative 3: Mixed Use Alternative Description of Alternative: Program and project level improvements considered in this alternative are the same as the proposed project with the exception of the Sports Complex element. Sports Complex Element In this alternative the recommended facilities include: lighted practice fields, approximately 503 parking spaces, a minimum of two (2) concession-run roller hockey courts, six (6) overlay soccer/football fields, four (4) lighted 300' outfield ball diamonds complete with dugout areas and bleacher plazas, various site furnishings (i.e.: litter receptacles, drinking fountains, Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page V-4 W.IPROJECTS11096-0041FINDINGSI 1096004.S58 benches), centralized restroom/concession building, and two (2) concession-run stadium baseball with pitcher's cage. Effectiveness in Meeting Project Objectives: As with the project, this alternative meets all of the project's objectives described in Section 2.2 of the MEIR. The summary of this alternative's ability to meet the City's project objectives is provided in Table V-1. Comparison of Effects of the Alternative to Effects of the Project: The regulatory framework and existing conditions would be the same as that described for the project. A summary comparison of this alternative to effects of the Master Plan is presented in Table V-3. This table relates that this alternative differs from the Master Plan in the assessment of geologic, water, air quality, hazards, noise, utilities and service systems and aesthetics. ► Geologic Issues- An increased area of irrigated turf overlying landfill material at the proposed Sports Complex will increase the potential for exposure of people to geologic impacts. An additional mitigation measure, Measure Geology-9, is required to reduce geologic impacts associated with this alternative below the level of significance. ► Water- Development of this alternative could result in increased quantities or rates of surface water runoff and increased water quality impacts from development of 2.8 additional acres of impervious surface. ► Air Quality-Same as with Alternative 1. ► Transportation/Circulation- Development of this alternative would result in increased impacts on parking. An additional mitigation measure, Measure Air-8, would 'be required to reduce impacts on transportation/circulation below the level of significance. ► Hazards- Increase in impervious surface from 2.7 acres in proposed project to 5.5 acres increases the potential for methane migration. An additional mitigation measure, Measure Hazards-15, is required to reduce risks to people and property to a less than significant level. ► Noise- Placement of the roller hockey rinks closer to the Ocean View Estates has the potential to result in slightly increased noise impacts. ► Utilities and Service Systems- Impacts from irrigation would increase. ► Aesthetics-An additional mitigation measure, Measure Aesthetics-4, would be required to reduce impacts on aesthetics on Golden West Street traffic and on the library below the level of significance. Feasibility: Alternative 3 is not feasible. Facts: The above finding is based on the following: • Impacts related to geologic issues, water, transportation/circulation, hazards, noise, utilities and service systems, and aesthetics would be exacerbated with this alternative. • The addition of mitigation measures not required for the proposed project would be required to reduce impacts on aesthetics. • This alternative was determined to be not feasible as a means of avoiding or mitigating for significant impacts on air quality associated with the project in that it would require implementation of the same Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page V-5 W:I PROIECTSI 1096-0041FINDINGSI 1096004.S58 mitigation measures required for the project and would not reduce anticipated PM,o and No.emissions. V.D Alternative 4: No Project Alternative Description of Alternative: This project differs from the proposed project in that no improvements to the park would be made, and it would continue to be operated in its currently existing state. Effectiveness in Meeting Project Objectives: The No-Project Alternative does not meet any of the project objectives. It was carried forward for analysis as required by CEQA. Comparison of Effects of the Alternative to Effects of the Project: The regulatory framework and existing conditions would be the same as that described for the project. A summary comparison of this alternative to effects of the Master Plan is presented in Table V-3. This table relates that this alternative differs from the Master Plan in the assessment of geologic, water, air quality, transportation/circulation, biological resources,energy and mineral resources, hazards, noise, public services, utilities and service systems, aesthetics,.cultural resources and recreation. ► Geologic Issues- The No-Project Alternative would likely result in a maintenance of the existing level of risk at the Park with respect to seismic ground shaking in the Newport- Inglewood fault zone, seismic ground shaking subsidence of the land (particularly in the vicinity of the former landfill), and expansive and collapsive soils. ► Water- The No-Project Alternative would likely result in a maintenance of the existing level of risk to people and property from existing drainage deficiencies at the location of the proposed Sports Complex. ► Air Quality-There would be no short-term air quality impacts since there would be no construction. The No-Project Alternative would likely result in maintenance of current levels of nuisance dust and PM,o emissions from wind-driven dust clouds impacting mobile home residents south of the Sports Complex. ► Transportation/Circulation- The No-Project Alternative would result in a continuation of the existing transportation/circulation conditions at the Park. No new impacts would be anticipated and no new measures would be required. ► Biological Resources-There would be no impacts related to Biological Resources with the No-Project Alternative. ► Energy and Mineral Resources- Six active oil wells are located in southwestern area of the Park. These would not be impacted with the No-Project Alternative. ► Hazards The No-Project Alternative would likely result in a maintenance of the existing level of risk to people and property from abandoned and plugged oil wells, transport of hazardous material on Golden West Street, and methane migration from underlying landfills. ► Noise- No impacts related to Noise would occur with the No-Project Alternative. Ambient noise levels are expected to remain the same. ► Public Services- There would be no impacts to Public Services with the No-Project alternative. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page V-6 W:I PROI ECT511096-0041 FI NDI NG511096004.S5 B ► Utilities and Service Systems-This alternative could potentially result in impacts on utilities and service systems. There would be no impacts to irrigation and potable water supply or water distribution, and no impacts to electrical systems. The existing 36-inch corrugated metal pipe between Talbert Lake and Sully Miller Lake is currently inadequate. The existing storm drain on Golden West Street is inadequate. ► Aesthetics-There would be no impact to Aesthetics with the No-Project alternative. ► Cultural Resources- Existing levels of operations and maintenance and passive recreation have the potential to adversely effect paleontological resources where excavations are made into underlying parent material. Existing recreation use levels have the potential to adversely effect five known pre-historic cultural resource sites:CA- ORA-142, CA-ORA-82, CA-ORA-1318, CA-ORA-1275, and CA-ORA-1317. These impacts could occur with the No-Project alternative. ► Recreation- There would be a significant impact on-recreation with the No-Project alternative. The demand for recreation will not be met and there would be an inconsistency with the voter-approved Measure L which endorsed the improvement of Central Park. Feasibility: This alternative is not feasible. Facts: The above finding is based on the following: - Although significant impacts could be avoided with the No-Project alternative, this alternative is incapable of meeting any of the project objectives specified in the Draft MEIR. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page V-7 W.I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 FI NDI NGSI 1096004.S58 TABLE V-1 SUMMARY OF MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES AND ALTERNATIVES CAPABLE OF ATTAINING MOST OF THE BASIC OBJECTIVES Object ve 1 Obleetrve 2 Objective 3 Objective 4 ;Obtectjye 5$ Objective 6 -Objective 7, Objective 8 1996 City General Revenue� Draft Youths Measure L General CPTED imlADA _ -: iGoals Plan RCS Generafion a.Sports .: _ Plan ERC Gwdelmes :Con bance p .Element - Needs Element M_ - m Assessment - `* `" """� s :.,fir r -b: •s,.. :. x. x ,`. n s•-= ' Proposed Project (Alternative 4A Modified) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes ALTERNATIVES Alternative 1 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Alternative 2 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Alternative 3 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No-Project No No No No No No No No Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page V-8 W.1 PROJECTSI 1096-0041 FINDI NGSI 1096004.S5A TABLE V-2 ELEMENTS OF THE MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES AND ALTERNATIVES 'A�TER _RN-AL' 7: � � 7,,", � T NA I !,k,7 S; ­t;­ ALT JE 4 -1 A 5- T. P SW VkO Y-,-ER,-' IV ----NAT 47-1 4 7,71-7, _Z' SPORTS COMPLEX 45-Acre Vacant Lot Net Import= 110,000 cy Net Import= 110,000 cy Net Import= 110,000.cy Net import— 110,000 cy Chain-link Fence Grading=45 acres Grading=45 acres Grading=45 acres - Grading=45 acres One Plugged and Abandoned Oil Well Impervious Surface=2.7 acres Impervious Surface=11 acres Impervious Surface=3.7 acres Impervious Surface=5.5 acres Construction Access is Northbound Construction Access is Northbound Construction Access is Northbound Construction Access is Northbound U.S. Interstate 405 to Golden West St. U.S. Interstate 405 to Golden West St. U.S. Interstate 405 to Golden West St. U.S. Interstate 405 to Golden West St. south to Edinger Street east to Gothard south to Edinger Street east to Gothard south to Edinger Street east to Gothard south to Edinger Street east to Gothard Street South to the project site Street South to the project site Street South to the project site Street South to the project site Staging w/1 Construction Area Staging w/I Construction Area Staging w/I Construction Arla Staging w/I Construction Area PHASE 1 PHASE 1 PHASE 1 PHASE 1 Construction=38 weeks Construction—38 weeks Construction=38 weeks Construction—38 weeks Gravel Parking Lot(800 spaces) Gravel Parking Lot(366 spaces) Gravel Parking Lot(366 spices) Parking Lot(285 spaces) Sidewalk Adjacent to Golden West St. 2 90'x140' Roller Hockey Courts Parking Lot(216 spaces) Parking Lot(257 spaces) Buffer Zone/Block Wall 2 Minor Baseball Fields Parking Lot(88 spaces) Parking Lot(40 spaces) Tot Lot w/Shade Structure 2 220'x340' Soccer/Football Field 2 90'x140' Roller Hockey Courts 2 85'x 185' Roller Hockey Courts 4 Lighted 300' Softball Fields Overlays 4 Soccer/Football Field Overlays 3 195'x300' Soccer/Football fields 4 Lighted 210'x330' Soccer/Football 1 Senior Baseball Field 4 300' Softball Fields w/Permanent 2 180'x300' Soccer/Football fields fields 1 T-Ball Field Backstops and Lighting 2 Stadium Baseball Concessions 4 85'x185' Roller Hockey Courts 1 Restroom/Concession Stand 2 Restrooms/Concession S6nds Restroom w/Concession Building PHASE 2 Batting Cage PHASE 2 PHASE 2 i Construction= 22 weeks Construction—22 weeks Construction— 22 weeks i Sports Practice Field PHASE 2 Sports Practice Field Sports Practice Field Construction=22 weeks Tot Lot w/Shade Structure PHASE 3 Restroom w/Concession Building Construction=38 weeks 4 Lighted 300' Softball Fields Parking Lot = 380 Spaces w/Bleachers Multipurpose Gymnasium w/offices, 4 Lighted 210'x330' Soccer/Football lockers, and meeting rooms fields Outdoor Aquatic Facility PARK, TREE,AN DLANDSCAPE 0.25 Acre Landscaped Area of Park Construction=3 weeks Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed-Project Same as Proposed Project MAINTENANCE YARD EXPANSION No Facilities Grading=0.25 acres Cut/fill=400 cy, balanced onsite Construction Access is Northbound U.S. Interstate 405 to Golden West St. south to Edinger Street east to Gothard Street South to the project site Staging w/I Gothard Parking Lot( Proposed Expansion Area Fence Gravel Hubbing Yard Equipment Storage Storage Bins Tree Planter w/Bank Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page V-9 W.IPROJECTSI 1096-0041FINDINGSI 1096004.S5A TABLE V-2 ELEMENTS OF THE MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES AND ALTERNATIVES O A ER4 AT IR OUTDOOR MUSIC AREA Construction=4 weeks Element Approved by Board for Element Approved by.Board for Element Approved by Board for Element Approved by Board for Grading=0.1 acres Construction: Same as No Project Construction: Same as No Project Construction:Same as No Project Construction:Same as No Project Cut/fill=230 cy, balanced onsite Construction Access is U.S. Interstate 405 to Golden West St. south to Edinger Street east to Gothard Street South Staging.w1l Designated Project Area CONSOLIDATED CAMPING AREA 13.5 Acres currently used for youth Construction=3 months Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project tent camping. Grad i ng=13.5 acres Cuttfill=2,000 cy, balanced onsite No ADA accessible restroom facility. Telephone Line No security lighting. Security Lighting Water Facilities PicniclGroup Meeting Area Automatic Irrigation System Site Furniture Installation of Plant Material LOW INTENSITY RECREATION 16.0 Acres-undeveloped vacant lot Construction=16 acres Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project Grading=Undetermined Used annually as temporary location Cuttfill=Undetermined for Disc Golf Picnic Facilities w/shade structure Restroom Tot Lot Open Turf Area Play Area Automatic Irrigation System Site Furniture Installation of Plant Material MIDDEN AREA/URBAN FOREST/ 45 acres with 24 plugged and Construction=45 acres Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed-Project Same as Proposed Project TRAILHEAD abandoned oil wells Grading=undetermined Cut/fill=undetermined 6 active oil wells Social Trails Shade Overheads Accessible Restroom at Trailhead Automatic Irrigation System Site Furniture Installation of Plant Material Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page V-10 W.IPROJECTS11096-0041FINDINGS11096004.S5A TABLE V-2 ELEMENTS OF THE MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES AND ALTERNATIVES p.. p F< .r _ .. . a. . _ E L RNATIVE.1.. E.2-.,y - _..... ... ELEMENT .. NO PRO ECT PROPOS D PRO ECT ,,- ATE ALTERNATIV ALTERNATIVE,3 . _ x m _ SEMI-ACTIVE RECREATION AREA 10 acres with 6 plugged and Construction=10 acres Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project- Same as Proposed Project abandoned oil wells Grading=undetermined Cut/fiII=undetermined Used as overflow parking for major equestrian and fund-raising events at Therapeutic Riding Center Huntington Central Park Open Turf Passive Field (Overflow Parking) Tot Lot Aquatic/Swim Center Parking Area Automatic Irrigation System Site Furniture Installation of Plant Material SULLY MILLER LAKE GROUP 20 acres with 2 plugged and Construction=7.5 acres Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project FACILITY abandoned oil wells Grading=undetermined Cut/fill=undetermined " Abandoned quarry w/perennial water Abandoned landfill Group Picnic Facilities Fenced Fishing Facilities Automatic Irrigation System Site Furniture Installation of Plant Material POLICUCIVILIAN GUN RANGE Police/Civilian Gun Range facilities are Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project closed City Council subcommittee assigned to evaluate relocation of Police/Civilian - Gun Range (including existing location)- Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page V:1 1 W.I PROJECT511096-0041 Fl NDI NG511096004.55A TABLE V-3 COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF IMPACTS FOR MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES AND ALTERNATIVES r _ _ _ _ _ , r_ ,_s - �_ . e RESOURCE. . �... DME ., ._ NO PRO ECT_ .._. . ... ..PROPOSED.PRO ECT _. _� �_ALT RNATI E �.. -_ ._ _ _ . . - LAND USE AND PLANNING • No impact on land use and planning • No impact on land use and planning Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. anticipated under the No-Project anticipated under the proposed project. Alternative. Does not conflict with adopted Does not conflict with adopted environmental plans and goals of the environmental plans and goals of the community where it is.located. community where it is located. Is compatible with existing land use in Is compatible with existing land use in the vicinity. the vicinity. Does not disrupt or divide the physical ► Does not disrupt or divide the physical arrangement of an established arrangement of an established community. community. w Does not convert prime agricultural ► Does not convert prime agricultural land to non-agricultural use or impair = land to non-agricultural use or impair the agricultural productivity of prime the agricultural productivity of prime agricultural land. agricultural land. • No mitigation measures are required. i • No mitigation measures are required. POPULATION AND HOUSING • No impact on population and housing • No impact on population and housing Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. anticipated under the No-Project anticipated under the proposed project. Alternative. Does not exceed official regional or ► Does not exceed official regional or local population projections. local population projections. Does not induce substantial growth in ► Does not induce substantial growth in the project area,either directly or the project area,either directly or indirectly. indirectly. Does not displace any existing ► Does not displace any existing housing. housing. • No mitigation measures required. • No mitigation measures required. GEOLOGIC ISSUES • The No-Project Alternative would likely • Development of recreational facilities in. Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. result in a maintenance of the existing the vicinity of the proposed Sports • Additional structures(multi-purpose • An increased area of irrigated turf level of risk at the Park with respect to Complex has the potential to expose Gymnasium and Aquatic Center)to be overlying landfill material at the seismic ground shaking in the Newport- people to geologic problems. constructed at the proposed Sports proposed Sports Complex will increase Inglewood fault zone,seismic ground Development over compressible Complex will increase the potential for the potential for exposure of people to shaking subsidence of the land materials(peat soils,alluvial and exposure of people to geologic issues. geologic issues. (particularly in the vicinity of the former colluvial deposits,artificial fill,refuse, • As with the proposed project,site-specific • As with the proposed project,this landfill),and expansive and collapsive and landfill material) may result in design requirements and incorporation of alternative requires incorporation of soils. natural or earthquake-induced Measures Geology-1 through-8 are Measures Geology-1 through 8.An settlement and structural damage. expected to reduce geologic impacts additional Measure Geology-9 is required ► Development in a seismically-active . associated with this alternative below the to reduce geologic impacts associated area has the potential to impact all level of significance. with this alternative below the level of proposed structural developments. significance. • Implementation of Measures Geology-1 through-8 is capable of reducing risks to people from geologic problems below the level of significance. • Measure Hazards-2 addresses impacts related to potential ground subsidence related to underlying refuse at the Sports Complex site. I i Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page V-12 W.IPROJECTSI 1096-0041 FINDINGSI 1096004.S5A TABLE V-3 COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF IMPACTS FOR MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES AND ALTERNATIVES < C. r.. ...., ... ..._.a'-,. .S`. yr .. � a..- ^^._.:... •--_ ._{_ -�.+S �-av'-�+,rir.-- � SA"i > _ -:,._ _' ,.. '�-.. _ �Z` .._ _a .. >..�...s. _..w. _. _-. >-:. "cam'. ,�- _.......a. r.:::. ,.�-.. __ w _.-..-. .�_- _ >:. -. >...., � .R. .. .... 4...z ... .. .-rr.T.-3 .. > ._. .,� _.:...-.-..,,. -'ax' ,.s z�. ,a r. �. � .-__. .� _ .,.� �.- - �- _ � -> -. -_.., ._�._ <„�-. .' � < .. �..�: F. ,.- _� �.- -_,a. - =.s��•� -,_.- `�-..� ��'.-_ "`_- . _ _ 4s : _ ., .-... €. .-. '�.,_...- _ .. _ ems_ _ - .. _ ...=<a.. _.-- - - , a ��.. _. _p_ .- �;.- r..,=c,:�.-.r,�. ..�.Y-- . _ �_ OPOSED_PRO E -- _,,ALTERNATIVE_.1 r __ ,_ IYE. -x _ __. _ TERNATtYE 3, x _ _ . -RESOURCE_ . ���<,, M.._ __ �_NQ-PRO ECT _ �.__. . _�PR CT .,.__x E_ _.__ �_ >_ �.._ ACTER AT �AL -..�. 3a._..-�.�_.e..._:P-....>.._,._..:..__.,_ .ram-a:_�...ea' � _-w�. e<..f..,=. .5.:�-__�_..._-_.W.�...w-..«._, _�':.e..a�`.:s...�"-_..<. .....e �.fix.a.F_.. ._�_.. _'��� '�. -t. __� 3as>. <-..dice:_,.-.-..> ...�_._.,.,... WATER • The No-Project Alternative would likely • Development of the proposed project has Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. result in a maintenance of the existing the potential to result in impacts on water • Development of this alternative could • Development of this alternative could • Development of this alternative could level of risk to people and property from resources. result in increased quantities and rates of result in increased quantities or rates of result in increased quantities or rates of existing drainage deficiencies at the Construction of the project-level surface water runoff and increased water surface water runoff and increased water surface water runoff and increased water location of the proposed Sports Complex. elements could result in impacts to quality impacts from development of 8.3 quality impacts from development of 1.0 quality impacts from development of 2.8 stormwater and runoff water quality additional acres of impervious surface. additional acres of impervious surface. additional acres of impervious surface. during the construction phase. • Development of an aquatic center could • As with the proposed project, • As with the proposed project, ► Operation of the proposed Sports result in water quality impacts from implementation of Measures Water-1 implementation of Measures Water-1 Complex may result in impacts to discharge of chlorinated water from the through-4 and Measure Hazards-5 is through-4 and Measure Hazards-5 is surface and/or groundwater quality site. expected to reduce impacts of this expected to reduce impacts of this from the use of pesticides and fertilizer • As with the proposed project, alternative on water below the level of alternative on water below the level of on the turf areas and from leaching of implementation of Measures Water-1 significance. significance. the closed landfill. through-4 and Measure Hazards-5 is Implementation of Measures Water-1 expected to reduce impacts of this through-4 is expected to reduce impacts alternative on water below the level of on water from the project level elements significance.. of the Master Plan to below the level of significance. • Implementation of Measure Hazards-5 is expected to reduce potential impacts on groundwater from irrigation of the Sports Complex below the level of si nificance. AIR QUALITY • No construction would take place. • Proposed project would have significant Same as proposed project. Same as Alternative 1. Same as Alternative 1. Therefore,there are no anticipated short- short-term construction impacts on air • Slightly fewer overall construction _ term impacts on air quality due to quality and would exceed SCAQMD impacts are expected from construction would result from thresholds for NO,and PM,o. implementation of this alternative,due to implementation of the No-Project • Long-term cumulative impacts ai'e not a decrease in the number of parking Alternative. expected. The number of vehicle trips to spaces to be constructed. • The No-Project Alternative would likely the site during operation is expected to result in maintenance of current levels of transfer from one park to another. . nuisance dust and PM,o emissions from Therefore,regional air emissions are wind-driven dust clouds impacting expected to remain at current levels. mobile home residents south of complex. • Implementation of Measures Air-1 through-8 are expected to reduce short- term fugitive dust emissions below the level of significance. Implementation of Measures Air-9 through-12 would reduce short-term construction impacts from nitrogen oxides and PM,o,however not below the level of significance. TRANSPORTATION/CIRCULATION • The No-Project Alternative would result • Development of the proposed project has Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. in a continuation of the existing the potential to result in impacts on • Development of this alternative would transportation/circulation conditions at transportation and circulation. result in increased impacts on parking. the Park. No new impacts would be Operation of the proposed Sports • As with the proposed project,this anticipated and no new measures would Complex would significantly impact alternative would require implementation be required, one key intersection requiring of Measures-1 through-7.An additional mitigation (Golden West Street and Measure-8 would be required to reduce Slater Avenue). impacts on transportation/circulation ► Operation of the proposed Sports below the level of significance. Complex would result in increased vehicle congestion requiring mitigation. ► Operation of the proposed Sports Complex will not result in insufficient parking on or offsite. • Implementation of Measures Transportation/Circulation-] through-7 are expected to reduce impacts on transportation/circulation below the level of significance. Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page V-13 W.IPROJECTS 11096-0041F1NDINGS 11096004.S5A TABLE V-3 COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF IMPACTS FOR MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES AND ALTERNATIVES __ .... .. _- 2..:.. _ �e._ _'p: __ - _-xT ,._.:._ _: >. -.Aar' ..-r* -x'.., .-. ..-e..,_3=G .'2 , - ,`.F - _ - - ;; __ .-. _ ._ _ �_• .W. -� . _. _ . �-- .;_ r., .: , . . � A.. .,.x. , _ �.- _ ERNAT{VE 1 .-- - _ _ E �r.�. _ z_,_�- ._ , , � NO.PRO ECT._._.__� ..�..__ .�._ __,PROPOSED PRO ECT ,_�; � . _ _ �►LT: _ __ �_< . � IY_2 r_ _ _ �..r �ALTERNATLVE 3g BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES • No impacts on biological resources are • Implementation of this project could Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. anticipated under the No-Project result in potential impacts to biological Alternative. resources at the Park. ► Does not impact endangered, Implementation of the proposed threatened,or rare species or their project could result in potentially habitats(including but not limited to significant impacts to riparian habitats plants,fish, insects,animals,and adjacent to project element locations. birds). Improvements planned for non-native Does not impact locally designated grasslands could result in loss of species(e.g., heritage trees). foraging habitat for raptors. Does not impact locally designated • Implementation of Measure Biological natural communities(e.g.,oak forest, Resources-1 through-5 would reduce coastal habitat,etc.). project and program level impacts on Does not impact wetlands habitat biological resources below the level of (e.g.,marsh,riparian,and vernal significance. . . . pool). ► Does not impact wildlife dispersal or migration corridors. • No mitt gt is r wired. ENERGY AND MINERAL RESOURCES • Six active oil wells are located in • Six active oil wells are located in Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. southwestern area of the Park. southwestern area of the Park. The ► Does not interfere with full economic project is not expected to impact these or recovery of the known natural any other known energy or mineral . resources. resources in the Park ► Consistent with adopted energy Does not interfere with full economic - conservation plans. recovery of the known natural ► Does not use non-renewable resources resources. in a wasteful or inefficient manner. Consistent with adopted energy • No mitigation measures required. conservation plans. ► Does not use non-renewable resources in a wasteful or inefficient manner. 4 • No mitigation measures required. HAZARDS • The No-Project Alternative would likely • Development of recreation facilities in Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. result in.a maintenance of the existing the vicinity of abandoned wells poses a • Increase in impervious surface from 2.7 • Increase in impervious surface from 2.7 • Increase in impervious surface from 2.7 level of risk to people and property from potential for hazards to people and acres in proposed project to 10.0 acres. acres in proposed project to 3.7 acres. acres in proposed project to 5.5 acres. abandoned and plugged oil wells, property. Impervious surface increases the potential Impervious surface increases the potential Impervious surface increases the potential transport of hazardous material on W Development over methane-rich soils for methane migration. for methane migration.- for methane migration. Golden West Street,and methane has the potential to pose a hazard to , • As with the proposed project,this • As with the proposed-project,this • As with the proposed project,this migration from underlying landfills. people and property. Alternative requires implementation of Alternative requires implementation of Alternative requires implementation of ► Development adjacent to Golden Measures Hazards-1 through-12.An Measures Hazards-1 through-12.An Measures Hazards-1 through-12.An West Street which is used to transport additional Measure Hazards-13 is additional Measure Hazards-14 is additional Measure Hazards-15 is hazardous materials and development required to reduce risks to people and required to reduce risks to people and required to reduce risks to people and near active oil wells poses a hazard to property to a less than significant level. property to a less than significant level. property to a less than significant level. people. ► Soil excavation within historic oil fields has the potential to expose construction workers to hazards. ► Development of vacant lots increases the risk of fires. ► Development adjacent to active oil wells exposes people to potential hazards. • Implementation of Measures Hazards-1 Through-12 is capable of reducing risks ; to people and property from hazards to a less than significant level. Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page V-14' W.I PROJECTS11096-0041FINDINGSI 1096004.SSA TABLE V-3 COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF IMPACTS FOR MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES AND ALTERNATIVES .._:. y_ : — _. _ .. a _ _ r _ _ e x n._, _.4 _ -__ __.� _ n_._,.. -. . a _._ __ M W_.-,._. _ . NO ROE PR POSEQ PRO E . A F ___ rLTERNATIVE 1 V _ - e ...� - _... _ _ . F CT r_�. O __ CT._ _.. _ _._ � N Th �� ..,__ __-____ _. N V � _l� ._ .� ...- �.-_ 1 � _ .... �._aETER A ._._-.. _ A ER A.TI 3 NOISE • No impacts on noise anticipated from the • Potential noise impacts may result from : Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. No-Project Alternative. Ambient noise development of the proposed project. • Location of the adult softball field farther • Placement of the roller hockey rinks • Placement of the roller hockey rinks levels expected to remain the same. Short-term noise impacts are expected from the mobile home site will reduce closer to the Ocean View Estates has the closer to the Ocean View Estates has the in.association with construction of the operation impacts of the field on the potential to result in slightly increased potential to result in slightly increased proposed project. - mobile home site. noise impacts. noise impacts. Long-term noise impacts are expected • Development of the Aquatic Center has •.As with the proposed project, • As with the proposed project, in association with operation of the potential to expose sensitive receptors to implementation of Measures Noise-1 implementation of Measures Noise-1 _= adult softball field. noise impacts. -through-5 will reduce noise impacts through-5 will reduce noise impacts • Implementation of Measures Noise-1 • As with the proposed project, from construction and operation below from construction and operation below through-5 will reduce noise impacts implementation of Measures Noise-1 the level of significance. the level of significance. from construction and operation below through-5 will reduce noise impacts the level of significance. from construction and operation below the level of significance. PUBLIC SERVICES- • No impacts on public services are • Potential impacts on public services may Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. __ Same as proposed project. anticipated from the No Project result from development of the proposed Alternative project. ► .No impact on emergency response Emergency medical response, police plans of emergency evacuation plans. protection,and fire protection services ► Adequate emergency response will be impacted by the proposed services. project ► Southwestern portion of the Park Construction of the Semi-Active serves as training course for Recreation Area and Midden . Huntington Beach Unified High Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead elements School District cross-country squads. have the potential to displace the • No mitigation measures required. cross-country training course during -" construction. • Implementation of Measures Public Services-1 through-6 would reduce impacts to below the level of significance. UTILITIES AND SERVICE SYSTEMS • This alternative could potential ly.resuIt in • This alternative could potentially result.in Same as proposed project Same as proposed project Same as proposed project impacts on utilities and service systems. impacts on utilities and service systems. Impacts to sewer and water sully w Impacts to sewer and water.sully Impacts from irrigation would . No impacts to irrigation and potable Impacts to irrigation and potable water would increase. would increase. increase. water supply or water distribution. supply from increased peak hour Impacts from irrigation would be Impacts from irrigation would be • As with the proposed project, No impacts to electrical system. demand. i lower but still present. lower but still present. implementation of Measures Utilities-1 ► 36-inch corrugated metal pipe Impacts to Park water distribution ( • As with the proposed project, • As with the proposed project;_ through-9 and Measure Water-3 would between Talbert Lake and Sully Miller systems due to peak demand. implementation of Measures Utilities-1 implementation of Measures Utilities-1 reduce impacts below the level of Lake°currently inadequate. Sports Complex impacts to existing through-9 and Measure Water-3 would through-9 and Measure Water-3 would significance. ► Existing storm drain on Golden West storm drain system,particularly 36- reduce impacts below the level of reduce impacts below the level of Street is inadequate. inch corrugated metal pipe and - significance. significance. • Implementation of Measure Utilities 4 Golden West Street. would reduce impacts from the 36-inch Impacts on.electrical supply to the corrugated metal pipe below the level of proposed Sports Complex. :. significance. • Implementation of Measures Utilities-1 through-9 and Measure Water 3 would; reduce impacts below the level-of significance. Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page V-15 W.I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 FINDINGSI 1096004.S5A TABLE V-3 COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF IMPACTS FOR MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES AND ALTERNATIVES JMa _ z ... _a EC -�� OIS ALTERt1€ATiYE03_ r_ AESTHETICS • No impact on aesthetics is anticipated • Implementation of the proposed project Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. under the No-Project Alternative. has the potential to generate significant • In addition to Measures Aesthetics-1 ► No scenic highways or vistas will be impacts on aesthetics. through-3,Measure Aesthetics-4 would_ impacted. New sources of light could potentially be required to reduce impacts on ► No demonstrable negative aesthetic impact surrounding land uses in the aesthetics from this alternative on Golden effect will result from this alternative. vicinity of the Sports Complex . West Street traffic and the Iibrary below ► Light or glare is not expected to Placement of new boundary the level of significance. change from existing conditions. fencestwalls has the potential to result • No mitigation measures are required. in a negative aesthetic impact. • Implementation of Measures Aesthetic-1 through-3 would reduce most impacts on aesthetics below the level of significance. Impacts on aesthetics resulting from night lighting of soccer/football fields and softball fields would remain significant during night use of the soccer/football fields, impacting . the temporary location of the Ocean View Estates Mobile Home Complex. CULTURAL RESOURCES • Existing levels of operations and • Excavations undertaken in underlying Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. maintenance and passive recreation has parent material during construction of the the potential to adversely effect Low Intensity Recreation,Midden Area/ paleontological resources where Urban Forest/Trailhead,and Semi-Active excavations are made into underlying Recreation Area has the potential to result parent material. - in significant impacts on paleontological` j • Existing recreation use levels have the resources, pre-historic cultural resource potential to adversely effect five known (CA-ORA-142,CA-ORA-82,CA-ORA- pre-historic cultural resource sites:CA- 1318,CA-ORA-1275,and CA-ORA- ORA-142,CA-ORA-82,CA-ORA-1318, 1317),and potentially important and CA-ORA-1275,and CA-ORA-1317. unique cultural resources. • Implementation of Measures Paleontology-1 through-4,Measures Archaeology-1 through-7,and Measures Historical-1 through-3 is expected to reduce impacts on cultural resources below the level of significance. RECREATION • The impact on recreation is expected to • The project level elements are not Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. be significant under the No-Project expected to result in impacts on Alternative. recreation or require mitigation. ► Demand for neighborhood or regional • Three(3)program-level elements of the parks or other recreational facilities proposed Master Plan(Low-Intensity will not increase as a result of Recreation Area,Midden Area/Urban implementation of this alternative. Forest/Trailhead,and Semi-Active ► Anticipated future demand for Recreation Area)may result in temporary recreational opportunities will not be or permanent disruption of existing met under this alternative. recreation uses. ► This alternative would not be • Implementation of Measures Recreation-1 consistent with the voter approved through-5 is expected to reduce program Measure L for improvements at level impacts on recreation below the Central Park. level of significance. ► Existing recreational facilities will not be affected. • No mitigation measures are required. Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page V-16 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 FINDI NGSI 1096004.55A SECTION VI FINDINGS REGARDING MITIGATION MONITORING PROGRAM VI.A REQUIREMENTS OF MITIGATION MONITORING PROGRAM Section 21081.6 of the Public Resources Code(California Environmental Quality Act [CEQA] Statutes) requires that when a public agency is making the findings required by Section 21081 of the (CEQA Statutes) and Section 15091(a)(1) of the CEQA Guidelines, the public agency shall adopt a reporting or monitoring program for the changes made to the project as a condition of project approval, adopted in order to mitigate or avoid significant effects on.the environment. The City of Huntington Beach has adopted a Mitigation Monitoring Program that meets the requirements of Section 21081.6 of the Public Resources Code (CEQA Statutes) which provides a monitoring program designed to ensure compliance of the project with mitigation measures adopted by the City of Huntington Beach Planning Department. Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page VI-1 W.I PROJECTSI 1096-0041FINDINGSI 1096004.S06 SECTION VII FINDINGS REGARDING LOCATION AND CUSTODIAN OF DOCUMENTS VILA LOCATION AND CUSTODIAN OF DOCUMENTS Section 10.0 of the Master Environmental Impact Report(MEIR) contains a list of all references used in the preparation of the environmental analysis. Unless otherwise noted, reference materials are located at the City of Huntington Beach, Planning Department which shall also serve as the custodian of the documents constituting the record of proceedings upon which the City of Huntington Beach City Council has based its decision related to the project. The designated location and custodian of documents is as follows: Ms. Mary Beth Broeren Senior Planner City of Huntington Beach Planning Department 2000 Main Street, 3rd floor P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, California 92648 Tel: (714) 536-5550 Fax: (714) 374-1540 References not available from the City of Huntington Beach, are located at Sapphos Environmental, Inc. by contacting: Information Manager Sapphos Environmental, Inc. 133 Martin Alley Pasadena, CA 91105 (626) 683-3547 Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page Vl1-1 W.I PROJECT511096-0041FIN DIN G511096004.507 SECTION. Vlll FINDINGS REGARDING INDEPENDENT JUDGEMENT Pursuant to Section 21082.1(c)(1) of the Public Resources Code, the City of Huntington Beach finds that the Final Master Environmental Impact Report reflects the independent judgement of the City of Huntington Beach as the lead agency for the proposed project. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page Vlll-1 W:IPROJECTSI 1096-0041 FI NDI NGSI 1096004.S08 SECTION IX STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS The Final Master Environmental Impact Report(MEIR) identified and discussed significant impacts on geologic issues, water, air quality, transportation/circulation, biological resources, hazards, noise, public services, utilities and service system, aesthetics, cultural resources and recreation which could occur as a result of construction and operation of the project and program level elements of the Master Plan. With the implementation of the mitigation measures discussed in the Final MEIR,.these impacts can be mitigated to levels of insignificance except for unavoidable significant impacts on air quality (during construction) and aesthetics as identified in Section IV of these Findings. The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach determined that the environmental and social (recreational) benefits of implementing the project outweigh and override the unavoidable adverse effects of the project. The City of Huntington Beach has determined that the benefits of the project, when balanced against all adverse effects, cause those effects remaining after mitigation to be acceptable due to the following considerations: • The Master Plan would allow the City of Huntington Beach (City) to fulfill their goals in providing passive and active recreational opportunities to residents within the service area for Central Park. Specifically, the Master Plan provides an opportunity for development of the following active and passive recreation facilities: Sports Complex, Outdoor Music Area, Consolidated Camping Area, Low Intensity Recreation Area, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head, Semi-Active Recreation Area and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility. The Master Plan provides for development. of facilities and programs on 136 undeveloped acres and 14 improved acres within an existing 356.8 acre regional park facility. The project and program level elements of the Master Plan would help the City meet the current and future (2010) demand for such facilities. The Master Plan would also help to relieve the over-use of nearby recreational facilities experienced mainly at Murdy and Edison Parks. In addition, the Master Plan would help the City comply with its park standard of five (5) acres per 1,000 people (City of Huntington Beach 1994a). Given the projection of estimated population growth of 9.8 percent to the year 2010, the City will need to expand its park land by 93.3 acres for a total of 1,053.6 acres to meet this requirement. • Development of the Sports Complex converts a 45-acre capped landfill with bare/ruderal vegetation (fenced to preclude public access)to a usable, and aesthetically pleasing public venue for recreation. • Implementation of the Master Plan will provide diverse recreational opportunities for all citizens consistent with the City of Huntington Beach General Plan goals adopted by the City Council, 1996. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page IX-1 W:IPROJECTSI 1096-0041 FI NDI NGSI 1096004.S09 • Implementation of the Master Plan is consistent with a number of goals and objectives identified in the Recreation and Community Services Element of the City of Huntington Beach Genreal Plan, including : ♦ Enriching the quality of life for residents through the provision of additional passive and active recreation opptunities; ♦ Providing additional passive and active recreation facilities to meet the needs of existing and anticipated population levels; ♦ Provide upgraded and renovated facilities to meet current recreation demands of youth and adults as described in the Draft Youth Sports Needs Assessment Study; ♦ Maximize the effectivnessof Central Park through the provision of additional facilities in existing undeveloped areas of the Park; ♦ Provide for operation of the Park in a safe, effective, and efficient manner through the appropiate design of new facilities; ♦ Provide for phased implementation of project and program level elements of the Master Plan to coincide with the demand for services as well as with the City's fiscal resources. • Implementation of the Sports Complex element of the Master Plan includes a_parking lot that provides for revenue generating opputunities. • Implementation of the Sports Complex element of the Master Plan accomplishes Recommendation No.1 of the Draft Youth Sports Needs Assessment Study to develop a multi-purpose Sports Complex. • Implementation of the Master Plan is consistent with Measure L land use authorization to allow for construction of lighted soccer and softball fields, a roller hockey rink and snack bar concessions, parking, restrooms and related improvements. • Implementation of the Master Plan will provide recreation facilities that have been desgined consistent with the Crime Prevention through Environmental Design Guidelines. • Implementation of the Master Plan will provide recreation facilities desgined in compliance with the requirments of the Americans with Disabilities Act. • The short-term unavoidable impacts generated from construction related activities are outweighed by air quality improvements in the long-term. The Master Plan, through its landscaping design, will reduce current levels of nuisance dust and PM,o emissions from wind-driven dust clouds from the vacant lot(45 acres of capped landfill) adjacent to the mobile home park. • The impacts of the night lighting on'the adjacent Ocean Park Mobile Home Estate are outweighed by the benefits of replacing the adjacent vacant lot (an attractant for illicit Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page IX-2 W.1PROJECTSI 1096-0041 FINDINGSI 1096004.S09 i activities) with a recreation facility designed consistent with the Crime Prevention through Environmental Design Guidelines. • The Master Plan would improve the storm drainage system by replacing the 36-inch metal pipe between Talbert Lake and Sully Miller Lake that is currently inadequate and unable to properly serve its intended function of directing storm water flows between the two lakes and preventing storm water from overflowing onto city streets. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page IX-3 W:I PR OJ E C TS 1109 6-0041 FIN D I N GS 11096004.S09 SECTION X SECTION 15091 FINDINGS Based on the foregoing findings and the information contained in the record, the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach has made the following findings with respect to the significant impacts on the environment resulting from the proposed project: • Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project which avoid-or substantially lessen the significant environmental effects as identified in the Final Master Environmental Impact Report (MEIR). • The changes and alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of the City of Huntington Beach. • The mitigation measures identified in the Final MEIR are feasible and will be required as conditions of approval. Based on the foregoing findings and the substantial evidence contained in the record, and as conditioned by the foregoing findings: • All significant effects on the environment due to the Master Plan have been eliminated or substantially,lessened where feasible. • Any remaining significant effects on the environment found to be unavoidable are acceptable due to the overriding concerns set forth in the foregoing Statement of Overriding Considerations. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22, 1999 Page X-1 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041FINDINGSI 1096004.S 10 4�.e9. � '� �� � ,, � v _. u a �� s,< � � �, i r_ �. •JJ � ��� Crty�of HunhngtonBeach�Planning�Deuartment � �� n..- to �STAFfFREP RAT x TO: Planning Commission FROM: Howard Zelefsky, Director of Plannin BY: Mary Beth Broeren, Senior Planne DATE: July.13, 1999 SUBJECT: MASTER ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT NO. 99-1 (Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses) LOCATION: Between Edwards Street on the west and Gothard Street on the east, south of Slater Avenue and north of Ellis Avenue STATEMENT OF ISSUE: Master Environmental Impact Report No. 99-1 (MEIR) represents an analysis of potential environmental impacts associated with a Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park(Master Plan) as proposed by the City of Huntington Beach Community Services Department. The Master Plan consists of nine elements on 157.5 acres: Sports Complex, Consolidated Camping Area, Park Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion Area, Outdoor Music Area, Low Intensity Recreation Area, Semi-Active Recreation Area, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead, Police/Civilian Gun Range and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility. The MEIR concludes that the proposed Master Plan is the environmentally superior alternative. It identifies mitigation measures to address potential environmental impacts and concludes that all but two issue areas (Aesthetics and Air Quality) can be adequately mitigated. Staff recommends that the Planning Commission recommend certification of the MEIR with a Statement of Overriding Considerations for Aesthetics and Air Quality because: ♦ The Master Plan is consistent with the goals, objectives and policies of the General Plan ♦ The proposed mitigation measures reduce most potential impacts to a level of insignificance ♦ The Master Plan is the environmentally superior alternative ♦ The environmental and social benefits of the project outweigh and override the unavoidable adverse effects of the project: temporary air quality impacts during construction and aesthetic impacts due to night lighting. RECOMMENDATION: Motion to: "Recommend Certification of Master Environmental Impact Report No. 99-1 as adequate and complete in accordance with CEQA requirements with a Statement of Overriding Considerations by adoption of Resolution No. 1546 and forward to the City Council (Attachment No. 3)." SEEN EINEENEW ■0 Pon��i ���-uuu.uuu ��uuuun►�� .O.IIIIIOIIU �•.rI I are Uttn.: Z4-�•�•nlf��_ 111I1 iu.N1u11 .7..Ir.►- ��It.O►� ■ ►�� ..�, , _•ui � .In1uuuuv I1"III ias 00 MANiuu.nw ullinlgillt1.11aIIIIIIIof to n= 'Fui.0 sit so _���— — ��iiiinuuu uu ► R_ i IIIIIIIIIIII..tt1 -�---__ - ■,`-:i�,,� � Intul.;.1 / ;q,.q`■.��.q:qO: - Imeceuua�� �t11n1111tt Ittl � Q �Y����' _l911�91CINE%••�•' I�...I...11...... 2 51-51_Y -W- 2=iLK"i ■ IIIIIIIIIIIi� ���_���'_'---... Illlllllf l; .IIIIIIIL' ���■ Iltlllllllll IIIIIIII 'Hi'T4*�' ��•� �� num o ■riiri'.�IRo.. m � uuu■ w�auuluml, I � ��iri1i� ���u�,���iiiiiiiiuii■�ll��a � ' ■rrr■ r"milwnudr11r11�� -®' Generalof Master 1� nlnulnu;■�111! � .InlN�ul. N Ills Plan Improvements VICINITY MAP MASTER ENVIRONMENTALIMPACT REPORT • 1 THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON ALTERNATIVE ACTION(S): The Planning Commission may take alternative actions such as: A. "Deny Master Environmental Impact Report No. 99-1 with findings for denial." . B. "Continue Master Environmental Impact Report No. 99-1 and direct staff accordingly." GENERAL INFORMATION: APPLICANT: City of Huntington Beach, Community Services Department, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, CA 92648 PROPERTY City of Huntington Beach, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, CA 92648 and OWNER: Various owners of encyclopedia lots between Edwards and Goldenwest Sts. REQUEST: Certification of an environmental impact report for the master plan of 157.5 acres of Huntington Central Park. DATE OF COMPLETE APPLICATION: MANDATORY PROCESSING DATE(S): December 15, 1997 Not applicable SUBJECT PROPERTY AND SURROUNDING LAND USE,ZONING AND GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATIONS: LOCATION b ` GENERAL PLAN #� ZONINGS �_ LAND IISE Subject Property: Open Space-Park OS-PR(Open Space— Park and Recreation Uses Parks and Recreation),IG in Huntington Central (General Industrial) Park(HCP),Undeveloped Areas in HCP, Oceanview Estates Mobilehome Park, Gun Range closed North of Subject Residential Low Density, RL(Low Density Single Family Residential, Property Commercial Visitor, Residential), CG(General Nursery, GTE (portion across Industrial Commercial),IG(General Slater): Industrial East of Subject Industrial PS (Public-Semipublic),IG Industrial,Police Heliport, Property(portion (General Industrial) Fire Station, Orange across Gothard): County Transfer Station closed South of Subject Residential Low Density Ellis-Goldenwest Specific Single Family Residential Property(across Plan and Holly Seacliff Ellis): Specific Plan West of Subject Residential Low Density RL(Low Density Single Family Residential, Property(portion and County of Orange Residential) and County of Future Harriett M. Wieder across Edwards): I Orange I Regional Park and Vacant Staff Report-7/13/99 2 (99sr28) PROJECT PROPOSAL: Master Environmental Impact Report No. 99-1 (MEIR) represents an analysis of potential environmental impacts associated with the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park(Master Plan) pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and Section 240.04 of the Huntington Beach Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance. The MEIR analyzes each element of the Master Plan at either a project or program level of detail. Project level elements are well defined and the City anticipates implementation to occur within the next five years. Program level elements are longer-term and the specific site details are not yet determined. Implementation of the program level elements may necessitate additional environmental analysis depending on the ultimate scope of an element, time of implementation and environmental conditions at that time. Pursuant to CEQA, a Master Environmental Impact Report is the proper vehicle for analyzing impacts that may occur as a result of a project being implemented over an extended period of time. The Master Plan includes nine elements which are summarized below and depicted in Attachment No. 1. :'Master Plan Eleinejit ' Geiicral Description Acres Project Level Sports Complex Youth and adult facilities: 8 lighted softball fields 45 overlapping 8 lighted soccer/football fields,up to four roller hockey rinks, 1 batting cage, 2 tot lots, 2 restroom/concession buildings and 800 space gravel parking lot Consolidated Camping Area Improvements to existing youth tent camping area will 13.5 include utilities (phone,water,lighting),picnic facilities,fire rings,landscaping and fire hydrant Outdoor Music Area Permanent 2,400 sq. ft. stage platform in area where 0.25 outdoor concerts are currently held Park, Tree and Landscape Expansion of existing yard for storage of plant material, Maintenance Expansion Yard I equipment and supplies 0.25 Program Level Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead Multi-use recreation trails for equestrian, pedestrian 45 and non-motorize cyclist, urban forest,preservation of archaeological area Sully Miller Lake Group Facility Turf area, 1 or 2 docks, restrooms/tackle and bait shop, 20 volleyball area, shade overheads Low Intensity Recreation Area Turf area,picnic facilities,tot lot, restroom, parking 16 Semi-Active Recreation Area Therapeutic riding school facilities,turf area/overflow 10 parking, alternative site for aquatic/swim center,tot lot Police/Civilian Gun Range Existing facility to remain closed until further 7.5 environmental analysis TOTAL: 157.5 Staff Report-7/13/99 3 (99sr28) Of the four project level elements, the Sports Complex is the largest and only new park amenity. The three other project level elements represent comparatively minor, but necessary, improvements to existing facilities or operations. Attachment No. 2 presents the site plans of the project level elements. Detailed discussion of each project element is found on pages 2-7 through 2-16 of the Draft MEIR. For the program level elements, the MEIR identifies their amenity components with the exception of the Police/Civilian Gun Range which will remain closed. These elements are discussed on pages 2-16 through 2-18; however, site plans have not been prepared for them due to their programmatic nature. The City has determined that these facilities are necessary to expand and improve the recreational facilities available to Huntington Beach residents. Using the City's General Plan standard of five acres of park per 1,000 residents, the projected population of the city in 2010 will require an additional 93.3 acres. The net increase of 136 acres that the Master Plan includes is a significant opportunity for meeting this need while also helping to offset the loss of open space at vacant or former school sites. The diverse nature of the recreational facilities is also critical in addressing the varied interests of Huntington Beach residents. The MEIR is subject to City Council approval. Pursuant to the Huntington Beach Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance, specific project components of the Master Plan for park and recreational facilities are subject to Design Review Board and Conditional Use Permit approval by the Planning Commission. In the case of the Outdoor Music Area, Conditional Use Permit No. 97-39 and Negative Declaration No. 97-20 were approved by the Planning Commission on January 27, 1998. This element was on an earlier processing track because it is a project sponsored by the Friends and Neighbors of Seacliff organization. Although already approved, this project level element was included in the MEIR so that the cumulative impacts of all Master Plan elements could be evaluated. Proiect History: The subject Master Plan of Recreation Uses was approved by the City Council on December 15, 1997. A series of actions led to the approval of the Master Plan in its current state beginning in 1991 when the City Council directed staff to develop a master plan for Central Park. The objective was to prepare a plan for the undeveloped acreage in the park; the Park consists of 356.8 acres, of which 220.8 (62%) are developed. In 1992, the City Council approved land use designations for the undeveloped areas of the park and in 1994 approved an amendment to the plan to include a sports complex. In 1996, Measure L was approved by the voters of Huntington Beach authorizing construction of a multi-field sports complex east of Goldenwest and south of Talbert Avenue. In July 1997, the City Council approved a Specific Plan for the Sports Complex(known as Alternative 4A)to be evaluated in an environmental impact report. On December 15, 1997, the City Council approved modifications to the Sports Complex Plan (known as Modified Alternative 4A) and directed staff to analyze the Sports Complex, Outdoor Music Area, Consolidated Camping Area and Park Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion Area at the project level of detail in the environmental impact report. The other elements of the master plan were to be analyzed at the program level of detail. Staff Report-7/13/99 4 (99sr28) ISSUES: General Plan Conformance: The proposed project is consistent with the goals and objectives of the City's General Plan and the Land Use Element designation of Open Space-Park on the subject property and the following goals, objectives and policies. Goal LU2: Ensure that development is adequately served by transportation infrastructure, utility infrastructure, and public services. The proposed park improvements will assist the City to provide adequate public services (recreational amenities and programs)to serve the growing resident population. Certification of the MEIR will allow the project level elements to more forward to the specifications and plans phase and will facilitate and streamline future environmental review of the program level elements that are developed as funding permits and demand for services require. The MEIR also analyzes the infrastructure that will be required for the proposed park development and demonstrates that adequate capacity is available to support-the project with the recommended mitigation measures. - Objective HCR 1.1: Ensure that all the City's historically and archaeologically significant resources are identified and protected. The Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead program level element consists of 45 acres that have been designated, in part, for the preservation of the Native American midden archaeological area. Additionally, mitigation measures are recommended for addressing other potential archaeological sites for two other program level elements: Low Intensity Recreation Area and Semi-Active Recreation Area. Policy RCS 1.1.1: Provide leisure opportunities through programs and activities that serve the general population as well as the specialized needs of the disabled, children and elderly. The Master Plan of Recreation Uses fulfills this policy by incorporating a variety of recreational amenities and facilities, including a therapeutic riding center proposed for the Semi-Active Recreation Area. Policy RCS 2.1.1: Maintain the current park per capita ratio of 5.0 acres per 1,000 persons, which includes the beach in the calculation. The Master Plan of Recreation Uses plans for the development of 136 acres that are currently undeveloped in Central Park. Provision of these facilities will greatly assist the City in meeting the park standard; an additional 93.3 acres is needed to meet projected demand in 2010. Goal RCS 3: Develop park sites to provide diverse recreational and sports facilities that meet the residents' and visitors' active and passive recreational needs. Staff Report-7/13/99 5 (99sr28) The Master Plan of Recreation Uses includes a broad spectrum of active and passive recreational facilities. The Sports Complex is the most active component of the Master Plan, and at the opposite end of the spectrum, the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead and Low Intensity Recreation Area are the most passive components anticipated to provide multi-use trails, nature watching opportunities, turf and picnic area. Goal RCS 4: Ensure recreation facilities are renovated and upgraded to meet the current recreational interests of adults and youth. Improvements to the existing Consolidated Camping Area and Outdoor Music Area fulfill this goal.. Goal RCS 7: Operate and maintain City parks and recreation facilities in the most safe, effective, and efficient manner. The expansion of the Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard will allow the City to more effectively and efficiently provide maintenance services to the 136 acres proposed for development in Huntington Central Park. The improvements will provide the Public Works Department with more storage area for materials and equipment that are needed for the expanding park system. Objective U 1.2: Ensure that existing and new development does not degrade the City's surface waters and groundwater basins. The MEIR contains adequate mitigation measures to ensure that water quality is not compromised as a result of the project. The City has consulted with the Regional Water Quality Control Board and has adequately addressed potential impacts that might occur as a result of constructing the Sports Complex over a former landfill site. The City will also consult with the appropriate regulatory agencies upon implementation of the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility program level element. Policy U 1.3.4: Require the use of reclaimed water for landscaped irrigation, grading and other non- contact uses in the new developments, where available or expected to be available. The MEIR identifies that reclaimed water, when available from the Green Acres project, will be used to irrigate proposed improvements, as appropriate. The irrigation system will be designed to connect to this system when it is on-line. Objective ERC 1.2: Enhance the environmental quality of the City's open spaces (including parkland...), thereby improving the quality of life. The proposed park improvements will greatly improve the environmental quality of open space within the city. Development of the Sports Complex will result in proper capping of a former landfill and address methane migration concerns and the reabandonment of an oil well. Development of the program elements: Semi-Active Recreation Area, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility will provide for the proper abandonment of 31 oil wells and associated soil remediation. Staff Report-7/13/99 6 (99sr28) Objective ERC 2.1: Evaluate, enhance and preserve the City's important habitat areas. In conjunction with the development of the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead, Semi-Active Recreation Area, Low Intensity Recreation Area and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility program elements, the City proposes the conservation/enhancement of 41.2 acres of non-native grassland to provide foraging habitat for birds. This effort would include the planting of native trees within and adjacent to conserved areas which would expand nesting opportunities as well. Policy ERC 2.1.10: Conduct construction activities to minimize adverse impacts on existing wildlife resources. The MEIR identifies mitigation measures which address this policy, including surveying the program element areas in conjunction with supplemental environmental analysis and prior to proceeding with project implementation, and designing specific components of these projects to minimize adverse impacts. Policy EH 3.2.3: Provide mitigation measures and other assistance intended to reduce the potential for the buildup of methane to hazardous levels within existing buildings. Although there are no existing buildings that are of concern in the Master Plan area, development of the Sports Complex over a former landfill site requires careful design and mitigation to address potential impacts related to methane. The MEIR includes specific considerations and mitigation measures related to this issue, and the plans and specifications for the facility will be reviewed by several regulatory agencies with oversight in this matter. In response to early consultation with these agencies, the parking lot for the Sports Complex is proposed to be gravel to avoid buildup of methane and to allow passive venting to continue. ZoninP Compliance: The Master Plan of Recreation Uses is located in the OS-PR(Open Space—Parks and Recreation) zone and complies with the requirements of that zone. Structures in conjunction with the Master Plan(e.g., concession/restroom buildings)will comply with the development standards summarized below. SECTION. TISSUE` CODE'PR6,W ox > PI OEOSE �3 213.08 Setbacks -Front, Interior Side, Rear Min 25 ft. Will comply -Exterior Side Min. 0 ft. Will comply Structure Height Max. 45 ft. Will comply Environmental Status: In accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act, Master Environmental Impact Report No. 99-1 was prepared by Sapphos Environmental to analyze the potential impacts of the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park. The MEIR serves as an informational document for decisions to be made by the City and was prepared under the requisite procedure that is outlined below: Staff Report-7/13/99 7 (99sr28) Member 2. 1997 A Notice of Preparation was filed with the State Clearinghouse and the County Clerk to notify public of intent to prepare a MEIR. September 18, 1997 Public Scoping Meeting held at Huntington Central Library for public to submit verbal and written comments on issues to be addressed in the MEIR. Meeting notice was sent to approximately 1,800 households within 1,000 feet of the Park and to interested agencies. Februaa 26, 1999 Notice of Completion filed with the State Clearinghouse and the County Clerk. Draft MEIR available for public review and comment for 45 days.(Comment period: February 26, 1999 to April 12, 1999). Draft MEIR available for review at City Hall, Central Library,Murdy Community Center and Edison Community Center. Notice of Availability of Draft MEIR sent to approximately 1,800 households and interested agencies. July 13, 1999 Public hearing before Planning Commission to review and recommend to City Council certification of Final MEIR No. 99-1. Prior to recommending certification and adoption of the MEIR by resolution, the Planning Commission may amend the document. It should be noted, however, that removal of any of the recommended mitigation measures will require findings and justification. The analysis section of this report contains further discussion regarding the MEIR. Coastal Status: Not applicable. Redevelopment Status: Not applicable. Design Review Board: Not applicable, however, specific improvements of the Master Plan will be subject to review and approval by the Design Review Board. Other Departments Concerns: The MEIR, including technical appendices, was circulated to other Departments for review and comment. All Department comments and recommendations have been incorporated into the MEIR and its mitigation measures. No conditions of approval apply to the MEIR. As development of individual elements of the Master Plan occurs, specific design requirements will be applied by various departments, as necessary. Public Notiricadon: Legal notice was published in the Huntington Beach. /Fountain Valley Independent on July 1, 1999, and notices were sent to property owners of record within a 1,000 ft. radius of the subject property, tenants at the Ocean View Estates Mobile Homes, persons and agencies who commented on the draft MEIR, and interested parties. In total, 1,859 notices were sent in preparation for the public hearing. Staff Report-7/13/99 8 (99sr28) ANALYSIS: The MEIR provides a detailed analysis of potential impacts associated with construction and operation of the project level elements. For the program level elements, the MEIR broadly identifies potential environmental effects related to implementation and subsequent technical analysis that may-need to be considered when detailed plans are prepared. The issues discussed in the MEIR are those which have been identified in the course of extensive review of all potentially significant environmental impacts associated with the Master Plan. The MEIR discusses potential adverse impacts in 15 issue areas. The direct, indirect and cumulative impacts of the Master Plan elements are addressed, as are the impacts of project alternatives. Each of the 15 issue areas is identified below by impact category based on the MEIR analysis. Mitigated and Unavoidable Significant Impacts are discussed in further detail on the following pages. Impacts Mitigated Unavoidable No Impact to Level of Insignificance Significant Impacts ♦ Land Use and Planning ♦ Geological Issues ♦ Aesthetics ♦ Population and Housing ♦ Water ♦ Air Quality ♦ Energy and Mineral Resources ♦ Transportation/Circulation ♦ Biological Resources - ♦ Hazards ♦ Noise ♦ Public Services ♦ Utilities and Service Systems ♦ Cultural Resources ♦ Recreation Impacts Mitigated to Level o In!LJOificance Through the use of appropriate mitigation measures identified in the Final MEIR, the majority of the potentially adverse impacts associated with the Master Plan can be mitigated to a level of insignificance. The Findings of Fact, as required by CEQA, review each of the impact areas and list the recommended mitigation measures (Attachment No. 4). A summary of key issues and mitigation measures as a result of the environmental impact report process is provided below. ♦ Geological Issues The Sports Complex element is an area underlain by the former Huntington Beach Landfill, a former inert debris disposal pit and petroleum-contaminated waste soils. The MEIR identifies six mitigation measures specific to construction of the Sports Complex element because of these factors. The mitigation measures are designed to minimize or avoid impacts related to compressible materials, ground subsidence, expansive soils and corrosive soils. They include maintaining at least a six foot thick layer of cover soils over the refuse area of the former landfill and maintaining a minimum four foot thick soil cover over the inert debris portion of the landfill. Any cover system will be reviewed and coordinated with the appropriate agencies including the Regional Water Quality Control Board. Staff Report-7/13/99 9 (99sr28) ♦ Transportation/Circulation Potential impacts to transportation/circulation stem from trips to and from the Sports Complex, the only new project level element. There are 10 mitigation measures which address these impacts. Specific improvements required include: 1) optimizing the timing of the signal at Golden West St. and Slater Ave, 2) reconstructing the median on Golden West St. to accommodate a southbound left turn pocket, and 3) constructing four driveways to serve the Sports Complex. ♦ Biological Resources Potential impacts to biological resources could occur due to proximity of the project and program level elements to habitat areas in Central Park and, for the program elements, loss of foraging habitat in non- native grassland areas. Six mitigation measures are recommended. The measures are designed to avoid or lessen impacts and include directed surveys of certain bird and plants species prior to commencing construction and having an environmental monitor present during grading and construction of certain project and program elements. Additionally, a brown-headed cowbird trapping program is proposed in conjunction with the operation of the Sports Complex. ♦ Hazards Hazards impacts stem from the presence of oil wells, the former landfill and potential methane exposure/buildup. There are 15 recommended mitigation measures, which include: 1) re-abandonment of plugged and abandoned oil wells, 2) an emergency evacuation plan, 3) development of appropriate construction techniques in association with appropriate regulatory agencies to address methane, including ongoing monitoring of methane levels, 4)proper cover over former landfill areas, 5) an Excavation Management Plan, and 6) a Health and Safety Plan. The MEIR concludes that all potential hazards impacts can be lessened to a level of insignificance. ♦ Noise Potential noise impacts relate to construction activities and operation of the Sports Complex. Three mitigation measures address construction related noise requiring noise reduction for construction equipment and limiting the hours of construction from what is normally allowed by the City's Municipal Code. Two are specific to the Sports Complex operations: 1) restrict amplified voice announcement systems for the Southwest Softball Fields such that noise ordinance limits are not exceeded, and 2) restrict use of the Southwest Softball Fields after 10:00 p.m. (i.e., turn off lights and close fields). ♦ Utilities and Service Systems There are nine recommended mitigation measures that ensure that there are adequate utilities to serve the Master Plan elements. Key improvements include replacement of a 36-inch diameter metal pipe which runs between Sully Miller and Talbert Lakes to accommodate runoff from the Sports Complex site, and designing the irrigation system for reclaimed water(domestic water will be used in the interim until reclaimed becomes available). Staff Report-7/13/99 10 (99sr28) ♦ Cultural Resources Potential impacts to cultural resources are only expected in association with program level elements. There are a total of 15 mitigation measures that address paleontological, archaeological and historical impacts. When the affected program level elements are brought forward to the design and implementation stages, these mitigation measures will ensure that the cultural resources are properly protected and analyzed. Significant Unavoidable Impacts There are two adverse environmental impacts anticipated from the proposed Sports Complex element that cannot be completely eliminated through mitigation measures. These effects can be lessened by mitigation measures suggested in the MEIR, and staff recommends these be incorporated into the project. Because these impacts cannot be fully mitigated, a Statement of Overriding Consideration is required. ♦ Aesthetics The MEIR concludes that there may be significant unavoidable impacts on aesthetics in association with the operation of night lighting for the Sports Complex.. These impacts would affect the Ocean View Estates Mobile Homes. The MEIR recommends a mitigation measure to address the lighting impacts by requiring photo-control-on and off(dusk to dawn), use of low glare lighting and the use of shields so that there is no spillage onto adjacent properties. In addition, a separate Noise mitigation measure prohibits the use of the southwest fields after 10:00 p.m. and requires the lights to be turned off at that time which will further assist in minimizing light impacts. Nevertheless, it is still possible that there will be light impacts to the mobile homes. ♦ Air Quality There will be short-term significant impacts to air quality during construction of the Sports Complex. These impacts result from emissions of both nitrogen oxides (NO.) and particulate matter(PM,o) associated with construction equipment. The MEIR identifies 12 mitigation measures that will lessen air quality impacts as a result of construction, but they cannot reduce impacts below the South Coast Air Quality Management District's thresholds of significance for the two categories noted. There is also one air-quality mitigation measure designed to mitigate impacts related to excavation of landfill. Long-term cumulative impacts from the proposed project will not be significant. Public Comments on the Draft MEIR Comments on the Draft MEIR were received from 15 agencies and interested parties. The comments focused on several issues, including: landfill and associated concerns such as methane, traffic and biological concerns. Staff has responded to all comments received in the Final MEIR(Attachment No. 5). The Final MEIR includes revised text sections and modified mitigation measures as a result of the comments. Key modifications include: Staff Report-7/13/99 11 (99sr28) C �- ♦ Biological Resources. In response to comments from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, staff has: - Modified four program level elements to conserve 41.2 acres (57%) of non-native grassland for foraging habitat for birds - Added a mitigation measure requiring implementation of a brown-headed cowbird trapping program ♦ Transportation/Circulation. In response to comments from Caltrans, staff has: - Added three mitigation measures in support of encouraging/enhancing.transit services for the Sports Complex ♦ Hazards. In response to comments from the County of Orange and the City of Huntington Beach Environmental Board, staff has: - Added three mitigation measures which address the possible excavation of unknown landfill materials and the requirement for an excavation management plan and a health and safety plan - Clarification in the text that excavation of any landfill areas will comply with the South Coast Air Quality Management District's Rule 1150 Alternatives to the Project -.- A range of reasonable alternatives to the proposed project was analyzed in the MEIR pursuant to provisions of CEQA. The discussion of alternatives focuses on alternatives capable of eliminating any significant adverse environmental effects or reducing them to a level of insignificance, even if these alternatives would impede to some degree the attainment of the project objectives or would be more costly. A summary analysis of environmental impacts for each of the alternatives compared to the proposed project is included in Section 4.0 of the Draft MEIR and reviewed in the Findings of Fact (Attachment No. 4). The analysis concludes that the proposed Master Plan of Recreational Uses is the environmentally superior alternative. Statement of Overriding Considerations Where impacts cannot be mitigated to an insignificant level, a Statement of Overriding Considerations must be adopted in conjunction with the certification of an environmental impact report. CEQA requires the decision makers to balance the benefits of the proposed project against its unavoidable environmental risks in determining whether to approve the project. If the benefits of the project outweigh the unavoidable adverse environmental effects, the adverse environmental effects may be considered acceptable to the City. Staff believes that the environmental and social benefits of the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park outweigh the adverse impacts to aesthetics and air quality for the reasons set forth in Attachment 3. SUMMARY: The Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park plans for the development of 136 undeveloped acres and 21.5 developed acres in one of the City's primary park facilities. It is anticipated that the four project level elements will be implemented in the next five years, while the five program elements will be realized over the long term as funding and park planning permits. The improvements to the park acreage will assist the City in meeting the projected park and recreation needs of Huntington Beach residents. Staff Staff Report-7/13/99 12 (99sr28) recommends that the Planning Commission recommend certification of the MEIR to the City Council with a Statement of Overriding Considerations for Aesthetics and Air Quality because: ♦ The Master Plan is consistent with the goals, objectives and policies of the General Plan ♦ The proposed mitigation measures reduce most potential impacts to a level of insignificance ♦ The Master Plan is the environmentally superior alternative ♦ The environmental and social benefits of the project outweigh and override the unavoidable adverse effects of the project: temporary air quality impacts during construction and aesthetic impacts due to night lighting. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park 2. Site Plans of Project Level Elements 3. Resolution No. 1546 (Final MEIR No. 99-1)with Statement of Overriding Considerations 4. CEQA Environmental Findings of Fact 5. Final MEIR No. 99-1 includes Response to Comments (under separate cover—not attached) 6. Mitigation Monitoring Program(under separate cover—not attached) SH:MBB:kjl I - Staff Report-7113/99 13 (99sr28) EXISTING LIBRARY STRUCOTTURREESITH SHADE T p`WO WAY ENTRY DRIVE-D, REMONS /CONCESSION BUILDING SIDEWALK \\ y ADJACENT TO ' = IALBERT 'gY FROM eRr TALBERT�,m+ �� r DRIVE'C' OUR(d))LIGHTED. 300'SOFTBALL it, ! FIELDS WITH PHASE 1 GRAVEL _ BLEACHERS PBAORXI CLOT WRp1I '•' _ ' ENOTES TYPICAL SPES CA �II SPORTS LIGHTING ENTRY DRIVE WITH I I l;`` •t FOUR W LIGHTED NORTH 8 SOUTH ° ''' I -11 SOCCER FIELDS BOUND EXR• r.--:•:, j DRIVE,B, EXISTING I ESA NG CAGEDISC COURSE 5)^ .� EXISTING '►, Ilj EXISTING �n ENTRY DRI GUN RANGE -- I ORANGE COU TY I WITH NORTH RESTROOM/CONCE5S10N TRANSFER STATION BOUND ONLY I -• I BUILDING WRFG.FIE EQUIPMENT E7QT-DR1VE'A' - OkSIDEWALK . �CENT TO I DEVELOPABLE U)LDEN — 11.2'I , / - .•;;, FOURLIGHTED 300'SOFTBALL FIELD 6 TOT LOT WRH i WITH 4HER5 s'�•�•i2 SHADE STRUCTURES. — r— - 1 PROBABLE LOCATION OF 6 '.7 'jT0'WIDE CONCRETE 1\1'lll� EARTHBERM DENOTES TIWALK SPORTS ADJACEMTO 'I _ i "'' C,OIDENWEST. FOUR 4�UGHTED 20'WIDE I r— -� " .I SOCCEERR R S 210'X 330' BUFFER ZON 1 r .., WITH TREES I. ',Ti .. �� BETWEEN /;��`(,, BLOCKWALL AND -'?• tiwSULLY MILLER. / SPORTS FIELDT, — '.: - N ' gg I ddd LAKE r �.. fft ILOCLKBE ALL `... , :d.' ERO ERT LINE EXISTING �� I '' I �II� WHO / J,�' OCEAN VIEW°. �,l�.�� —:�, I:.�:� •�•T ESTATES tit) ate ���� � t� •� MOBILE HOMES 0.,Rmp is lam of tm aft p 09 L-* . .nRf or relo°.m"Of°r m+ra e.eoa.wa a«nw°f t°ae.w°.n m mw,w,tmn NOTES: SOCCER FEW SHOWN HEREON CAN BE USED AS FOOTBALL FIELDS. CKtM�„ Legend �•� r 0 125 2W sm N U v I S No.4A Modified FIGURE 2.3.1.4A S 0 YIAO�WEVIfl6 Sports Complex ATTACHMENT NO. _ ., K K L m. EL I& EL N C I 011 ice:. lim: I ; wa': 1131 +. ( A A A x EXPANSION ,.6 GTE x 16 I p BARK SHALL BE PIA ED ENEATH PLAry I�1 i FACILITY AREA-GUASTING-RUES I I I A o '- o W ':�';'•i'; S E INS SHOP b ; jORAG HOLQING STORA HED I, zk Z:�� ' BINS YARYARx m +1 1 /o ASP LTIC* �• i"�"•`� . 01AY LD G YARD EXISTING PAR INGItOT•1 X 4_IN OFFICES I 'I `0.1 IN YARr~' .�: ! EXISTI G PRK, E & L�1lD6C E �' Z5 Z �. .. P.;.'. :••: X \ I , JVIAINTENANCE Y RD & DI Y6I N 20� 6 2 x E B S EADQUAR RS I �� ' 5.2 Od`\i`�� pNED. TI PQRUM• ) REFUSE BI S PARKIN x O � \ O 7.0 01.. 4.3 6.2 x 30� O .9 D NOTES: EXISTING ELECTRICAL&WATER FROM THE CURRENT MAINTENANCE FACILITY SHALL-BE BROUGHT TO THE EXPANSION AREA N z FIGURE 2.3.1-2 —{ Park,Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Z WIPOOS Expansion Area 0 Huntington Central Park Master EIR • Huntington Beach, California 1 a LA. wit in", SLATER AVENUE EXISTING PARKING LOT EXISTING TOT LOT GTE FACILITY DENOTES SECURITY WALKWAY LIGHTING I.— __ AND SOURCE FOR ELECTRICAL,WATER LU AND EMERGENCY PHONE. Uj a N w — PARK, TREE ANDLU c� LANDSCAPE N R• •j'' ' MAINTENANCE AREA _ iLU Z � �— w 4 9 TYPICAL TREES -4v EXISTING PARKING LOT w T ER EXISTING RESTROOM, TYPICAL BBQ& PICNIC- ` TABLES TURF AMPHITHEATER & .• - FIRE RING --{ TYPICAL TURF —{ EXISTING RESTAURANT '•� �� � EXISTING PARKING LOT � Z ACCESS ROAD WITH SECURITY LIGHTING& ONE(I) DENOTES BOUNDARY OF PARKING SPACE WITH EMERGENCY PHONE, m Legend CONSOLIDATED CAMPING AREA ELECTRICAL& ATER � z ® Proposed Park,Tree and NEW RESTROOM �N Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion Area o so, too, Sao' t��s FIGURE 2.3.1-3 QjNSININ M11101h Consolidated Camping Area W •• "'� ' Huntington Central Park Master EIR Huntington Beach, California -TALBERT LAKE CCM711ACNI SMALL BEACH C MA APP!MIL M CIT1 dMm5002ImT c W �10 AD AM nsTro To AccaMomT�u+osuw WJQA 1CM SMALL My CVUWNAP ON TO SANWOU c �jig-� �• +..� IN, ti S PROVW AS AN AUMWM BID � y \ WBENCHES n � 1 �..1 s••a..a i+ee \ r16 /MOICt A WO W OOCO.C.'. MM 3.20 W Cw0lTf \ J�C .0 20' 40' 801, w,OSAs m z Legend / v q;. Existing Trees r J� 6XI,T„a..mmLW m Proposed Park Benches ,.�� .. �.v. W/o�sAa�.AaM.a STALLS Trash Recpetacles . V � v FIGURE 2.3.1-4 MINH E9VIROQ D% Outdoor Music Area Huntington Central Park Master EIR Huntington Beach, California ATTACHMENT NO ITEM B-3 REVISED STAFF RECOMMENDATION MASTER ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT NO. 99-1 (Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses) Motion to: "Recommend Certification ofMaster Environmental Impact Report No. 99-1 as adequate and complete in accordance with CEQA requirements with a Statement of Overriding Considerations by adoption of Resolution No. 1546(Attachment No. 3) and the Mitigation Monitoring Program (Attachment No. 6) and forward to the City Council." (99SR28a) VRM s - n FINAL MASTER ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT FOR MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES FOR CENTRAL PARK, CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA VOLUME III STATE CLEARINGHOUSE NUMBER 9709 1 007 PREPARED FOR: CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA 92648 PREPARED BY: SAPPHOS ENVIRONMENTAL, INC. 1 33 MARTIN ALLEY PASADENA, CALIFORNIA 9 1 105 JUNE 22, 1999 FINAL MASTER ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT FOR MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES FOR CENTRAL PARK, CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA VOLUME III STATE CLEARINGHOUSE NUMBER 9709 1 007 TABLE OF CONTENTS Section Page 12.0 Response to Comments on Draft Master Environmental Impact Report . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12-1 12.1 Summary Distribution List/Respondents . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12-1 12.2 Response Matrix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12-4 12.3 Letters of Comment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12-33 13.0 Clarifications and Revisions to Draft Master Environmental Impact Report . . . . . . . . . . 13-1 Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page i W.I PROJECT511096-0041 EI R IR TCI 1096004.TOC SECTION 12.0 RESPONSE TO COMMENTS ON DRAFT MASTER ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT The Draft Master EIR was completed and forwarded to the Office of Planning and Research (OPR) on February 26, 1999. A Notice of Completion was posted at OPR and the County Clerk of the County of Orange on the same day. The Notice of Availability(NOA) of the Draft Master EIR for public review was advertised in the local newspaper Huntington Beach Independent. The NOA was forwarded via regular mail to 1,806 interested parties. All interested parties were notified of the availability of the Draft Master EIR for public review and the location of local libraries where the two volumes of the Draft Master EIR were available for review for a period of 45 days. The Draft Master EIR and/or public NOA was also mailed to several federal, state, regional and local agencies. A total of 10 timely letters of comment and 5 late letters of comment were received on the Draft Master EIR. The public comment period closed on April 12, 1999 at 5:00 pm. This section contains a summary of the distribution list for the Draft Master EIR and the parties providing comments. A summary of comments received, cross referenced to the letters providing the comment, and response to comments is provided in the matrix in Section 12.4. All letters of comment received on the Draft Master EIR including those received after the published deadline have been addressed. The comment letters have been divided into the following five categories: (1) Federal Agencies; (2) State Agencies; (3) Regional and County Agencies and Organizations; (4) Cities; and (5) Private Organizations and Individuals. This section of the Final Master EIR also contains a response matrix, which identifies the individual comments of each letter and provides a corresponding response. 12.1 SUMMARY DISTRIBUTION LIST/RESPONDENTS Federal Agencies Of the three federal agencies identified below, no timely letters of comment were received. A late letter of comment was received from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. The comment letters and corresponding response are provided later in this section. The distribution list for the EIR included a total of three Federal Agencies. All three agencies received a copy of the Notice of Availability as well as a copy of the Draft Master EIR: • United States Department of Agriculture, Natural Resource Conservation Service • U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service • United States Environmental Protection Agency, Watershed Protection Branch State Agencies Of the nine state agencies identified below, two timely letters of comment were received from the California Environmental Protection Agency, Department of Toxic Substances Control and the State of California, Department of Transportation. One late letter of comment was received from the California Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-1 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041 EI R IR TCI 1096-004.IN T Regional Water Quality Control Board. The comment letters and corresponding responses are provided later in this section. The distribution list for the Draft Master EIR included a total of ten State Agencies. All ten agencies received a copy of the Notice of Availability as well as a copy of the Draft Master EIR: • State of California Department of Conservation, Division of Oil, Gas, and Geothermal Resources • California Department of Fish and Game • California Department of Transportation • California Integrated Waste Management Board • State Historic Preservation Office • California Coastal Commission, South Coast District • California Environmental Protection Agency, Department of Toxic Substances Control • Office of Planning and Research • Native American Heritage Commission • California Regional Water Quality Control Board Regional and County Agencies Of the eighteen Regional and County agencies identified below, two timely letters of comment were received from the County of Orange, Planning and Development Services Department and the Orange County Transportation Authority. Two late letters of comment were received from the Southern California Association of Governments and the County of Orange Health Care Agency. A copy of these letters and corresponding responses are provided later in this section. The distribution list for the EIR included eighteen Regional and County Agencies. All eighteen agencies received a copy of the NOA as well as a copy of the Draft Master EIR: • County Sanitation District of Orange County, California • South Coast Air Quality Management District • Ocean View Elementary School District • Westminster Elementary School District • Huntington Beach Elementary School District • Huntington Beach Union High School District • Orange County Vector Control District • Metropolitan Water District of Southern California • Orange County Municipal Water District • Orange County Water District • County of Orange Health Care Agency • County of Orange Integrated Waste Management Department • County of Orange Public Facilities and Resources Department • Orange County EMA • Orange County Transportation Authority • Orange County Department of Education • Orange County Flood Control District • Southern California Association of Governments Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-2 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 EI R IR TCI 1096-004.I NT Cities Two timely letters of comment on the Draft Master EIR were received from the City of Fountain Valley and the City of Huntington Beach Environmental Board. A copy of these letters and corresponding responses are provided later in this section. The NOA and Volume I of the Draft Master EIR were provided to three neighboring cities: • City Fountain Valley • City of Costa Mesa • City of Westminster In addition,the NOA and the Draft Master EIR were provided to twenty-three City of Huntington Beach representatives and departments, as well as the City of Huntington Beach Environmental Board. Private Organizations and Individuals Four timely letters of comment were received from private organizations and individuals: the Gas Company, Marijane Swanson, Larry McNeely, and Kathy Kurjan. One late letter of comment was received from the Central Park Trail Committee. The distribution list for the Draft Master EIR included a total of eight private organizations and individuals. All of these private organizations and individuals received a copy of the NOA and a copy of Volume I of the Draft Master EIR: • The Gas Company • Save Our Kids • Time Warner Communications • Telephone Operations GTE • Yolanda Bateson • Bill Garrity • Larry Geisse, M.D. • Kathy Kurjan The NOA was also forwarded via regular mail to 1,806 interested parties and individuals, noting the locations where the Draft Master EIR was available for public review. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-3 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EI R IR TCI 1096-004.1 NT 12.2 RESPONSE MATRIX RESPONSE TO COMMENTS MATRIX tt ._ HUNTINGTONBEACH CENTRAL PARK MA .. S�TERPIAN �. PROCEDURAL ommen : I he document has been reviewed and does not warrant any clearinghouse comments at this time. Should there be a change to the scope of the project, please send that information to SCAG to the attention of the Crearinghouse Coordinator. Commentor(s): SCAG (1) Response: Thank you for providing your letter of comment on the Draft MEIR. The information provided has been noted. Comment: The identified agencies indicated that the Draft Master MEIR had been received and reviewed. Each of these agencies responded by submitting letters of comment. Commentor(s): DTSC (1), LEA1) Caltrans(1), RWQCB (1�, Countyy (1), OCTA (1), Env.Board (1), LEA (1), Fountain Valleylf), CPTC (1), Kur'an (1), ervice (1) Response: Thank you for your comments. They will be forward to the City Council for consideration during the decision-making process. Comment: Based upon the review of the Draft MEIR, the Environmental Board finds significant deficiencies in one key issue, and has general concerns over other aspects of the project. Commentor(s): Env. Board (2) Response: The Environmental Board identified 17 issue areas of concern. Their primary concern related to the inadequate characterization of the former landfill underlying the proposed Sports Complex. CH2M Hill the City of Huntington Beach Public Works Department and the Fire Department, IWA and JHA were all contacted and provided with copies of the Environmental Board's comment letter to assist in clarifying the.existing conditions relating to landfill gas emissions, methane production, water quality, noxious odors and night lighting of the project site. Responses have been provided for each issue in this section. Comment: Commentators appreciate the opportunity to provide input on this project. Commentor(s): Caltrans(4), OCTA(7), Env. Board (20), LEA(12), Fountain Valley(2), Kurjan (21), Service (17) Response: Thank you for taking the time to review the Draft Master EIR and for providin your input. Your comments have been evaluated and considered for incorporation into the�inal Master EIR as responses to comments in this section and clarifications and revisions in the following section. Comment: We look forward to reviewing the Final Master EIR and the Plans and Specifications for the construction of the Sports Complex element of the Master Plan when they become available. Commentor(s): RWQCB (7), Response: Thank You for being an active articipant in the development and implementation of the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park. A copy of the Responses to Comments will be forwarded to you 10 days prior to the Planning Commission considering the Final Master EIR for certification. Comment: Under Section 11 - Distribution List for EIR, page 11-6, Lisa Mills should be listed as OCTA's CEO (not Stan Oftelie) Commentor(s): OCTA (5) Response: Thank you for callingour attention to this information. The change you requested has been made in the Clarificaions and Revisions Section (Pa a 11-6) of the Final Master EIR. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-4 W.I PROJECTS 11096-0041 EIR IR TO 1096-004.IN T PROJECT DESCRIPTION Comment: The list regarding related projects should also include the construction of the City Day Labor Center on the Orange County Transfer Station #2, and the Industrial Development proposed for the property to the south of Transfer Station #2. The property is currently owned by Parkview Partnership and with City approval will be transferred to Burke Holdings. Commentor(s): County (19) Response: The Day Labor Center is not the current use of Transfer Station #2. It is an approved project that will be implemented during August of 1999. In their letter to Burke Holdings dated March 15, 1999, the City of Huntington Beach states that the Fire Department will not approve the Conditional Use Permit for the Industrial Development until a methane extraction system is operating and safe levels of methane are observed. Testing will not be complete until early 2000. Therefore this development cannot be listed with the related projects at this time. Comment: The statement: "The design slopes for the proposed Sports Complex will decrease to 1% over large areas due to the grading requirements for the playing fields," is inconsistent with the Figures 2.6-1, 2.6-2, 2.6-3, 2.6-4 which show a 2-3% gradient across the field. Commentor(s): County (21) Response: The proposed project has a gradient of 1% on the playing fields while the alternatives have a 2-3% gradient across the playing fields. The above referenced figures depict the alternatives, not the proposed project. Comment: The City of Fountain Valley is requesting that the EIR fully address the impacts of the import of the fill material to the site. The EIR should address the path of travel for the trucks delivering the fill material, the exit route,the estimated number of truck trips, the hours of operation, and the length of the operation. Commentor(s): Fountain Valley (1) Response: The information requested by the City of Fountain Valley regarding the path of travel for hauling of imported material, the exit route, the estimated number of truck trips, the hours of operation, and the length of operation, is provided in Section 2.3.1 of the MEIR. To minimize community impact from truck traffic, the less residential Gothard Street will be used as the major haul route from the 405 freeway to the site. Gothard Street can be reached by exiting 1-405 south onto Golden West Street, east on Edinger and then south onto Gothard Street. Once at the site, the existing "service" road leading to the Gun Range would provide a route to the construction site that avoids other existing recreation and library uses at the Park. As indicated in Table 2.3.1-3 of the MEIR, there are a total of 9,116 estimated truck trips of the 9,116 truck trips, 7,857 will be dedicated to the anticipated impact of 110,000 cubic yards of fill material area over a period of 55 weeks. At an estimated load of 14 cubic yards per truck trip, a total 142 truck trips per week would be expected. The Santa Ana River was identified as the most likely source of fill material for the purposes of the analysis. As indicated in section 2.3 of the MEIR, daily construction activities will be undertaken Monday through Saturday (excluding Federal holidays) between 7:00 am and 8:00 pm. As a result of Measure Noise 3 the City of Huntington Beach has determined to limit grading and construction activities to between 7:00 am to 7:00 pm on Mondays through Fridays, and to between 8:00 am through 5:00 pm on Saturdays. The analysis undertaken in the MEIR is based on the more limited hours of construction and grading activities. As indicated in Section 3.6.2 of the MEIR, the Traffic Impact Study concluded that haul trips would not exceed the capacity of the local street network. Comment: A resident made a request to keep Central Park a tranquil, passive park. Commentor(s): Swanson (1) Response: Thank you for your comment. It will be forwarded to the City Council for consideration during the decision-making process. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-5 W:I PROI ECTS 11096-0041EIR IR TCI 1096-004.1 NT I Comment: A resident expressed the concern that the program level plans were not adequately addressed within the referenced EIR. Commentor(s): Kurjan (2) Response: Please refer to the MEIR, Page 2-6 which explains that there currently are not adequate details available on Program Level elements because construction funding is not available at this time or the timing of those elements is uncertain. As indicated on Page 2-6 of the MEIR, five elements of the proposed project were addressed at the program level of detail. These elements addressed at the program level are the most likely land uses under consideration for ultimate development of Central Park consistent with City of Huntington Beach General Plan goals and objectives. However, these elements are not currently funded for construction. Consistent with the requirements of Section 15168 of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines, the anticipated elements were analyzed at a Program Level of detail to "ensure consideration of cumulative impacts that might be slighted in a case-by-case analysis; avoid duplicative consideration of basic policy considerations; and allowing the Lead Agency to consider program wide mitigation measures. The level of analysis undertaken on the program level elements was consistent with the requirements of CEQA and allowed the City to achieve its objectives related to analysis of significant impact requiring mitigation, cumulative impacts requiring mitigation and programmatic mitigation measures. Comments: A resident is concerned with tree removal in the proposed expansion area. Commentor(s): Kurjan (4) Response: No trees are anticipated to be removed within the proposed expansion area in association with the Proposed Project. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-6 W:(PROJECTS!1096-0041 EIRI RTCI 1096-004.INT i LAND USE AND PLANNING Comment: The Land Uses Adjacent to Study Area section does not discuss the Bruce Brothers Pit Landfill and the City's use of Orange County Transfer Station Section #2 as a Day Labor Center. Commentor(s): County (20) Response: The Day Labor Center is a temporary facility. This is an approved project that will be in place in August of 1999. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-7 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EI R N TO 1096-004.1 NT GEOLOGICAL-ISSUES '> Comment: A final cover system for land use change area over an inactive municipal solid waste landfill, especially the land use area shall be designed and maintained in accordance with Section 2190 of title 27. In accordance with Section 21090(a), the Regional Board may allow an alternative final cover design if the performance equivalency of the alternative to the prescriptive cover design in minimizing water infiltration is demonstrated. Commentor(s): RWQCB (2), (3) Response: Any final cover system proposed for the portions of the development underlain by the former landfills will comply with Title 27 requirements and include designing the final grades to promote surface water runoff and minimize ponding of water, designing final cover material components to be compatible with the proposed post-closure activities, and designing the draina e system to control and convey stormwater flows. Additional considerations wilralso be adressed to accommodate post-closure land uses and activities. For example, the City recognizes that irrigated portions of the proposed development located over the former landfills require special consideration to mitigate potential groundwater impacts. The locations of the irrigated portions of the proposed development have been selected to reduce the areas that overlie the former landfills. Where irrigated portions of the development overlie the former landfills, an appropriate final cover system will be designed, permitted, constructed, and maintained in compliance with Title 27 requirements. The City intends to fully support any request for approval of an alternative final cover system, including an equivalent pertormance demonstration consistent with the requirements of Title 27 Section 21090(a). Comment: Figure 3 shows lines for a geo hysical survey, but results such as section profiles are not included in the appendix. The descriptions here for the former Huntington Beach Landfill are inconsistent with descriptions presented in Pie 3.9-7. Is the Inert Debris Disposal Pit described here referring to Bruce Brothers Pit?Clarifications required. Commentor(s): County (25) Response: Appendix C, Geophysical Evaluation, was inadvertently omitted from the technical appendices of the DMEIR. This appendix is provided in the Clarifications and Revisions Section of this document. There was some confusion regarding the ppropper names of the two significant landfills at the site. This confusion carried over from the SWIS list, previous reports for the site and anecdotal. information. The references to the Huntington Beach Landfill in Appendix C of the DMEIR also generally apply to the Gothard Street Landfill. The references in the Geologic Report to a former inert debris disposal pit describe the Bruce Brother's Pit. A revised Figure 8 is provided in the above mentioned Geophysical evaluation which better defines the former landfills. Comment: Figure 8 should show existing closed landfills (Bruce Brothers Pit, Huntington Beach Landfill, and Orange County Transfer Station #2 Commentor(s): County(26) Response: The referenced Figure 8 has been revised as suggested and is provided in the Clarifications and Revisions Section of this document in the Geophysical Evaluation mentioned above. The Orange Count Transfer Station #2 is underlain P the former Gothard Street Landfill. Comment: Please note that compliance with SCAQMD Rule 1150.1 is also part of landfill closure and post closure requirements. Commentor(s): County(9) Response: The City will comply with provisions of SCAQMD Rule 1150 regarding submittal of an Excavation Management Plan prior to any excavation on the site of the closed landfill and Rule 1150.1 provisions regarding closed landfill reporting. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-8 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EI R IR TCI 1096-004.I NT WATER Comment: It is suggested that Page 3.4-8, mitigation measure Water-2 and Water-3, state that compliance with mitigation should be prior to issuance of grading permits or building permits,whichever comes first. Commentor(s): County (4) Response: Please refer to page 3.4-8 of the Clarifications and Revisions. Measures Water-2 and -3 have been revised to slate that compliance with mitigation should be prior to issuance of grading permits or buildin per its, whichever comes first. Comment: With regard to Sully-Miller Lake Group Facility Program Element, the Environmental Board finds that the draft EIR did not adequately address the existing water quality of the lake. Commentor(s): Env. Board (9), Env. Board (17) Response: There is currently no known data which documents the water quality for the Sully-Miller Lake. As Sully-Miller Lake was analyzed as a program level element, studies will be conducted on the water quality of the lake and potential areas of contamination as part of the environmental analysis prior to finalizing plans andspecifications for construction. Comment: Resident suggests that the City should implement the Green Acres Project prior to moyin forward with the park plan. Resident requests that key milestones for the Green Acres Project such as the NOP, scoping meeting, EIR, construction timing, etc. be included in the MEIR. Resident expressed concern about using a project that has no scope as a mitigation measure. Commentor(s): Kurjan (17) Response: The City of Huntington Beach water demand is met through two sources of water,groundwater and imported domestic water which is purchased from the Metropolitan Water District. Groundwater, which is regulated by the Orange County Water District (OCWD), supplies water to meet 75 percent of the City's annual demand. This agency monitors groundwater basins to prevent over-depletion of this resource and to impose fines on purveyors who violate their groundwater allocation. Should drought conditions occur, having separate irrigation services allows the City to disenga a the "less critical" irrigation services so that the limited sup�pply can meet the more importWdomestic water demand. To postpone the development of tfie Park based on the pending Green Acres project implementation would delay a project with substantial public beneficial use. Strategically, it is better to desi n an irrigation system for its ultimate supply (in this case, the Green Acres project then to wai for the supply system to be implemented. Currently,the best estimation for the Green Acres protect to provide water to the City is 2008. However, this is not a firm date. The Orange County Water District is the lead agency for the Green Acres project and as such is responsible for information regarding the project timing. Comment: Regarding Mitigation Measure-4, how can re-evaluation of impacts with no proposed action cause an issue to be eliminated? Commentor(s): Kurjan (18, 19) Response: Please see pa a 2-6 of the MEIR for a discussion of the differences between project and program level elements. As the Semi-Active Recreation Area and Gun Rangge are program level elements,detailed proposals for these elements have not yet been created.-The MEIIZ identifies planning assumptions and subsequent technical reports and analysis that may need to be considered by the City prior to approval of construction of individual program elements. In this case, Measure Water4 on page 3.4-8 of the MEIR specifies that the potential impacts to surface water quality from implementation of these two program level elements will be reevaluated at which time an necessarymitigation measures willll be identified. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-9 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EI R IR TCI 1096-004.1 NT AIR UALITY, Comment: SCAQMD Rule 1150.1 for landfills should be included in the list on page 3.5-4 Commentor(s): County (22), Env. Board (8), Env. Board (16) Response: The project may involve excavating into a portion of the closed landfill. A paragraph will be added under Rules and Regulations in the Environmental Setting section as follows: "The proposed Sports Complex is partially underlain by the Huntington Landfill as are structures at and near the un range. Any excavation on the site of the landfill will be subject to SCAQMD Rule 115&which requires that an Excavation Management Plan must be submitted to and approved by the executive officer of the SCAQMD prior to beginning excavation. This plan shall identify mitigation measures to be activated as necessary during excavation to ensure that a public nuisance condition does not occur. Mitigation measures shall be selected after consideration of the physical characteristics of the IancTfill. Excavation of the site will also be subject to rule 1150.1 provisions regarding closed landfill reporting.11 Excavation of the site will also be subject to rule 1150.1 provisions regarding closed landfill reporting. The range of mitigation measures may include control of grading activities under certain wind conditions and staging of grading activities. Comment: The Environmental Board believes that the MEIR should address the potential for odor release during construction activities over the former landfills in the event refuse is uncovered. Commentor(s): Env. Board (10), Env. Board (18) Response: As indicated in the Clarifications and Revisions to pa a 3.5-16, the discussion of odors has been revised to read: "Excavation in the area of the Huntington Landfill could result in the release of noxious odors from exposing decomposin waste buried in the landfill. The Excavation Management Plan submitted by the City to tRe SCAQMD under the requirements of Rule 1150 wilt contain measures for mitigating odors. No excavation will begin until this plan has been reviewed by the SCAQMD Executive Officer and approved for its adequacy in mitigating all potential air quality impacts that could result from excavation of the landfill site. The Plan will also address the possibility of other construction activities disturbing and exposing odor-producing waste in areas of the park not undergoing direct excavation. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-10 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041 EI R IR TCI 1096-004.1 NT TRANSPORTATION/CIRCULATION Comment: Additional traffic generated by the project could impact 1405, SR-39 (Beach Boulevard) and SR-1. Commentor(s): Caltrans (2) Response: The anticipated traffic distribution and assignment pattern for the Huntington Central Park Sports Complex has been developed in coordination with the City of Huntington Beach Community 5ervices Department. Because the proposed Sports Complex is intended to serve the residents of Huntington Beach and is based on the project distribution and assignment pattern, the origin and destination of project- related traffic along the San Diego Freeway (I- 405)and Pacific Coast Highway(SR-1) is expected to be minimal. While Beach Boulevard is a major north-south arterial in t e City of Huntington Beach, project-related traffic will use Goldenwest Street as the north-south access roadway to and from the park. In addition, Beach Boulevard is considered a Super Street in the Orange County Master Plan of Arterial Highways (MPAH)with a daily roadway ca achy of 72,000 vehicles per day(vpd)and can accommodate the minimal project-related traffic. Therefore, the project-related tra fic impacts along these arterials are considered insignificant. Comment: Additional measures should be considered due to the additional trips generated by the rropposed Sports Complex. In order to remain below the Congestion Management Agency OM1A) and Air Quality Management District(A MD) thresholds for congestion the following measures were suggested for consideration: 1) Provide incentives to encourage transit use to and from the complex; 2) Coordinate with local transit agency to improve or increase service if needed- 3) Consider shuttle services from designated area(s) to the complex during peak hours;4) bfter security level bicycle racks at convenient and safe locations. Commentor(s): Caltrans (3) Response: Please see Clarifications and Revisions to Page 3.6-22 of the MEIR for the incorporation of three (Measures No. 1, 2, and 4)of the four measures recommended,by Caltrans to assist the City of Huntington Beach in remaining below threshold for congestion management established by the Congestion Management Agency and the South Coast Air Quality-Management District. Measure No. 1, 2, and 4 recommended by Caltrans would provide incentives to encourage transit, provide for improved and increased transit service, and incorporate security level racks into the design of the Sports Complex. The City of Huntington Beach in consultation with its traffic consultant Linscott, Law and Greenspan, has determined that Measure No.3 recommended by Caltrans would not be an effective means of congestion management for the Sports Complex. The Sports Complex is a regional park facility directed primarily for the residents of the City of Huntington Beach who are currently served by an effective public transit system, the provision of a shuttle service as recommended by Caltrans would be redundant to the existing service. Comment: The existing "service" road leading to the Gun Range is within County property identified as "the existing Orange County Transfer Station "2". Any proposed use of the road requires permission from the County. Commentor(s): County (18) Response: Thank you for your comment. Please refer to page 2-9 in the Clarifications and Revisions Section where the information you have rovided has been incorporated. Comment: It is anticipated that the demand for bus service on Sundays may increase as a result of the proposed project. In addition, it has been proposed that future bus service to the project area should also operate on Gothard Street. Commentor(s): OCTA (2) Response: The City of Huntington Beach concurs with the conclusion of the Orange.County Transportation Authority that the operation of the Sports Complex may generate an increase in demand for service on Sunday. Please see Clarifications and Revisions to Page 3.6-22 that provides for coordination between the City of Huntington Beach and the local transit with which to increase and improve service through implementation of Measure Transportation/Circulation -9. Comments: In order to facilitate the operation within the project vicinity, OCTA recommends that bus transit amenities such as bus pads, turnouts and shelters be incorporated into project plans. Project developers should consult with bCTA to determine specific locations for these amenities when more detailed site plans become available. Commentor(s): OCTA (3) Response: Thank you for your comment. Your concerns will be forwarded to the City Council during the decision making process. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-11 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 EI R N TO 1096-004.1 NT Comment: Under ec ion b- rghniza ions an ersons onsu e , page - o re erences o at the top of the pages ould be corrected to read "Orange ounty'Transportation Authority". Commentor(s): OCTA (4) Response: Thank you for your comment. Please refer to pagge 8-2 in the Clarifications and Revisions Section where fhe information you have rovided has been incorporated. Comment: In order to minimize negative impacts to the City of Fountain Valley street system, staff recommends routing the truck traffic away from Fountain Valley arterial streets to the greatest extent feasible. Commentor(s): Fountain Valley(1) Response: No construction traffic will be traveling through the City of Fountain Valley. Comment: Resident is concerned that the EIR traffic assessment does not accurately document current traffic conditions. Commentor(s): Kurjan (9) Response: The existing traffic counts were conducted during the peak commute hours (7-9 AM and 4-6 PM) on a typical" weekday in Fall 1997 and/or Winter 1998. These traffic counts were conducted to capture the"typical"traffic conditions on any given weekday,which has become the accepted practice of professional traffic engineers when preparing any traffic analysis. Comment: Resident requested a contact number to report potential traffic violations committed on Slater between Gothard and Goldenwest. Commentor(s): Kurjan (10) Response: The contact number to report traffic violations is the City of Huntington Beach Police general hone number: (714) 960-8811. Comment: Resident is concerned with the change in number of parking spaces from 630 to 800 spaces. Resident requests an enlarged drawing of the gravel parking lot with spaces drawn-in, including the parking meters be made. Resident also requests that the EIR include the City's expected gains in revenue and provide the proposed pricing for the spaces, the expected usage, projected annual income. Commentor(s): Kurjan (11) Response: Since the NOP and scoping meeting, Traffic studies, by the EIR's consulting Traffic Engineer, showed that it would be necessary to design for 800 spaces. This amount would accommodate the ei ht (8) ball fields and eight (8) soccer fields that are proposed on the conceptual plan. At the OP and scoping meeting, the 630 spaces noted were designed to be 10 x 20' each. Upon the notice of needing to have 800 spaces the spaces were down sized to 9'-6" x 20' each. Both of these stated dimensions exceed pity of Huntington Beach standards of design requirements. Parking spaces at the Library have not been utilized to boost the amount of spaces to 800. The Sports Complex has been designed as a stand alone facility with spaces designed to accommodate a worst case scenario utilizing acceptable industry standards for parking demands. A striping plan has been submitted to the City and is on the file with Public Works Engineering Department. The City Council will make a decision on Parking meters as art of the ro'ect implementation. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-12 W:I PROJECTS 1 1096-0041 EI R IR TO 1096-004.I NT BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES Comment: NEPA requires all federal agencies to"...make available to State, counties, and municipalities advice and information useful in restoring, maintaining, and enhancing the quality of the environment." Commentor(s): Service (2) Response: The City has throughly reviewed the information provided by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the California Department of Fish and Game related to the proposed Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park. The comments provided by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the California Department of Fish and Game will be considered by the City of Huntington Beach during the decision making process. The analysis contained in the MEIR has determined that with the incorporation of the recommended mitigation measures, the elements of the proposed Master Plan will not affect anv state or federal listed endangered species;and therefore, it is not anticipated that the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service will have any statutory authority over the proposed pro ect level elements of the Master Plan. Should the City propose to move forward with the Sully Miller Lake Group facility` coordination will be undertaken with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Wi the U.S. Fish and ldlife Service to determine their respective areas of jurisdiction. Comment: Service mandates require the Service to provide comment on any public notice issued for a federal permit or license affecting the nations waters. Commentor(s): Service (3) and (4) Response: The regulatory framework related to Section 404 of the Clean Water Act is described on Page 3.4-1 of the MEIR. The project level elements of the proposed Master Plan have been designed to avoid impacts on "waters of the United States and wetlands afforded protection pursuant to Section 404 of the Federal Clean Water Act. With the exception of the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility, the program level elements of the proposed Master Plan have been designed to avoid impacts on waters of the United States' and wetlands afforded protection pursuant to Section 404 of the Federal Clean Water Act. The potential development of one or two docks is the only component under consideration within a potential wetland. It is likely that such work would effect less than 0.3 acres and be completed pursuant to NWP No. 2W The MEIR was circulated to the U.S.Army Corps of Engineers for review. The U.S.Army Corps of Engineers provided no comments contradicting the conclusions provided in the MEIR. The potential for impacts on "waters of the United States" and other wetlands afforded protection pursuant to Section 404 of the Clean Water Act would need to be evaluated prior to the completion of plans and specifications (and the associated environmental documentation pursuant to CE A for the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility program level elements. Comment: The Service stated that Section 9 of the Federal Endangered Species Act prohibits the "taking" of federally endangered wildlife. Other commentors recommended that Measure Biological Resources 1-3 be undertaken during optimal periods to assess presence or absence of federally endangered plant and wildlife species. Commentor(s): Service (5), Kurjan (5) Response: The City of Huntington Beach does not anticipate any"taking"of federally endangered wildlife in association with the project or program level elements of the proposed Master Plan. As noted in Table 3.7-1 of the MEIR, there have been occasional observations of southwestern willow flycatcher and least Bell's vireo is a rare fall and winter visitor in the vicinity of the Shipley Nature Center at Central Park. There are no known occurrences for these species in the vicinity of Sully Miller Lake. However directed surveys were recommended to be undertaken prior fo the completion of pans and specifications (and the associated environmental documentation pursuant to CEQA) for the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility program level element. Measure Biological Resources-1 was provided to document absence prior to the completion of the environmental documentation for this program level element. As noted in Table 3.7-1, the six sensitive plant species that have the potential to occur in association with non-native grassland were not observed at Central Park and are not expected to occur within the Park. However, directed surveys were recommended to be undertaken prior to the completion of pplans and specifications (and the associated environmental documentation pursuant to CEQA) for the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head and Semi- Active Recreation Area pro ram level elements. Measure Biological Resources-3 was provided to document absence priorlo the completion of environmental documentation for this program level element. See Clarifications and Revisions to Pages S-11, 3.7-46 and 3.7-47 for clarification that directed surveys for sensitive species undertaken as part of Measure Biological Resources 1 and Measure Biological Resources 2 will be.conducted according to protocols described by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the California Department of Fish and Game. Measure Biological Resources 2 requires monitoring to protect riparian habitat that is present throughout the year. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-13 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EI R IR TCI 1096-004.1 NT Comment: The Department is responsible for administering section 1600 et seq. of the Code, for activities affecting lakes rivers and streams. Commentor(s): Service (6) Response: The Department's authority pursuant to Section 1600 is acknowledged in Section 3.4.1 of the MEIR. The Department's responsibilities pursuant to the State Endangered Species Act are described in Section 3.7.1 of the MEIR. The project level elements of the proposed Master Plan have been designed to avoid imppacts on lakes or streams afforded protection pursuant to Section 1600 of the State Fish and Came Code. With the exception of the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility, the program level elements of the proposed Master Plan have been designed to avoid impacts on lakes or streams afforded protection pursuant to Section 1600 of the State Fish and Game Code. The potential development of one or two docks is the only component under consideration potentially located withinthe jurisdiction of the California Department of Fish and Game. The potential for impacts on areas within the jurisdiction of the California Department of Fish and Game would need to be evaluated prior to the completion of plans and specifications (and the associated environmental documentation pursuant to CEQA) for the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility program level elements. Comment: I he ervice concludes that the proJec willa within ajurisdictions o e Service Department because the pprotLect will "1 a built on portions of 357 acres of largely open space lands adjacent to the Bolsn Chica Wetlands, will si nificantly alter the ecology and function of the Huntington Central Park/Weider Regional P& Bolsa Chica Wetlands Regional Wildlife Area. Commentor(s): Service (7) Response: As indicated on page S-1 of the MEIR, Huntington Central Park is one of two regional park facilities located within the City of Huntington Beach. Figure 3.1-1 of the MEIR, correctly indicates the entire regional park facility being designated as Open Space-Park in the City of Huntington Beach General Plan. Figure 3.1-2 correctly describes the zoning for Central Park as Community Facilities (Recreational District). As described on page 1-1 ofthe MEIR, 220.8 acres of the existing 356.8 acre re ional park facility are developed. Existing facilities are depicted on Figure 1.0-3 of the MEI�, designated as a regional park in the City of Huntington Beach General Plan. Elements of the proposed Master Plan address improvements on 136 acres of undeveloped area within the Park and an additional 14 acres of existing improved area within the Park. The existing unimproved area includes 45 acres on top of a closed landfill 55 acres in a largely abandoned oil extraction area, 15 acres in a closed sand and gravel quarry and 16 acres in a past borrow site. The proposed improvements are consistent with the Upen space-Park designation of the General Plan. As depicted in the General Plan the Park is located on the Huntington Mesa and does not include any portion of the Bolsa Chica Wetlands, nor is any portion of Central Park designated as a Regional Wildlife Area. The Bolsa Chica Wetlands are part of a State Wildlife Refuge owned by the State Lands Commission and administered by the California Department of Figh and Game. Weider Regional Park is owned and administered by the County of Orange. The City has provided for conservation of areas that have the potential to provide habitat for migratory birds througgh the designation of Shi ley Nature Center and Jack Green Nature Area which are existing facilities that are not part ofphis project. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-14 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041 EI R IR TCI 1096-004.I NT Comment: In their letter of comment, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the California Department of Fish and Game indicated that"the proposed project may result in direct or indirect, adverse effects to four state and federally endangered species: The California least tern, peregrine falcon; least Bell's vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher. In addition the California Department of Fish and Came identified four State Species of Special Concern that would be potential) effected b the proposed project: white-tailed kite, tricolored blackbird, Cooper's hawk and loggerheadshrike. It is the conclusion of the Service that general wildlife surveys were conducted during winter and adequate surveys for these or other listed and sensitive species have not been done and apparently will not be done until prior to the commencement of construction activities or prior to "moving forward with program level elements." Therefore potential impacts to these species cannot be disclosed nor appropriately mitigated per CEQA requirements. Commentor(s): Service (8) Response: See response to comments No. 4,5,6,7. Potential impacts on federally listed species are addressed in Section 3.7.3 of the MEIR. As indicated in Table 3.7-1 of the MEIR the California least tern is not known currently or historically from Huntington Central Park and the program and project level elements of the proposed project are not expected to have any impact on this federally and state listed species. As indicated in Table 3.7-1 of the MEIR, the peregrine falcon is noted on the Huntington Central Park Bird List as a rare species year round, primarily in association with the Shipley Nature Center. The proposed Master Plan does not include any modifications to urban forest or disturbed riparian habitats found in association with the Shipley Nature Center or Jack Green Nature Area. The conversion of ruderal/bare and developed areas of the Park would not be expected to effect the infrequent visits by the peregrine falcon. As indicated in Section 3.7.3 of the MEIR, areas under consideration for development of the protect level elements of the proposed Master Plan do not support suitable habitat for southwestern willow flycatcher and leastBell's vireo. With the exception of the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility areas under consideration for development of program level elements of the proposed Master Plan do not support suitable habitat for southwestern willow flycatcher or least Bell's vireo. Suitable habitat for these species is primarily limited to the Shipley Nature Center and Jack Green Nature Area which are not the subject of the proposed Master Plan. See Response to Service (5) for information related to additional documentation that will be undertaken for southwestern willow flycatcher and least Bell's vireo prior to completing the environmental documentation for the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility. In response to comments provided by the Service and the Department,the City has revised the project description for the Low Intensity Recreation Area and the Midden Area/Urban orest/TraiIhead program level elements of the proposed Master Plan to minimize the loss of potential foraging habitat for birds considered to be sensitive by the Service and by the Department. See Clarifications and Revisions to pages 2-16 and 2-17 of the MEIR undertaken to minimize impacts on potentially suitable foraging habitat for State and Federally designated sensitive birds, including raptors. See Clarifications and Revisions to pages 3.7-44 and 3.7-45 and Table 3.7-3 of the MEIR for clarification that the program level elements can be undertaken in a manner that minimizes impacts on potentially suitable foraging habitat for State and Federally designated sensitive birds, including raptors. In response to comments received from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the California Department of Fish and Game, the City of Huntington Beach revised four elements of the Master Plan to increase conservation of non-native grasslands: Low- Intensity Recreation Use Area, Sully Miller Lake Group Facility, Semi-Active Recreation, and Midden Area/Urban Forest/TraiIhead. Central Park currently supports 72 acres of non-native Master that are subject to annual mowing or discing for fire control. The modification to the M1C�taster Plan delineated in the Clarifications and Revisions would result in conservation of 41.2 acres (57%) of non-native grassland within Central Park. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-15 W.I PROJECTS 11096-0041 EI R IR TO 1096-004.INT r � Comment: The Service concludes that the consideration or proposed implementation of the individual project elements will require further CEQA review and the appropriate disclosure and mitigation of impacts to sensitive and listed species. Commentor(s): Service (9) Response: The potential for indirect impacts on least Bell's vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher are specifically identified disclosed and identified on Page S-11 and in Section 3.7.3 of the MEIR. As described in the dEilR, the indirect impact is limited to the potential for construction to disturb least Bell's vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher in disturbed riparian habitat located northwest of the Consolidated Campground protect level element and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility program level element of the proposed Master Plan. Least Bell's vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher are rare and infrequent visitors to Central Park and are not expected to occur within disturbed riparian habitat. However, in the unlikely event that such species were present, Measure Biological Resources-2 was recommended to ensure that disturbed riparian habitat areas were monitored to ensure avoidance of impacts during construction. See Clarification and Revision to Page 5-11 and 3.7-47 for additional mitigation measure that will ensure avoidance of impacts on southwestern willow flycatcher and least Bell's vireo during construction. Comment: Service biologists have repeatedly detected California least tern in the project area although the DEIR states that California least tern has not been recorded in Central Park. The service also notes that the southwestern willow flycatcher is a federally endangered species as well as State endangered. In addition, contrary to the assertion in the DEIR, Cooper's hawks evident) bred in the park during 1998, as evidenced by the presence of a fledgling and protective adult. The Service suggests);hat the area apparently mapped as non-native grassland in the eastern portion of the park actually is a part of Talbert Lake. The area mapped as �rassland is now largely under water, which is often the case during non-summer months. The Service recommends that a refinement of these mapped areas be completed. Commentor(s): Service (10) Response: Please see Clarification and Revision to page 3.7-13 which indicates that the California least tern is an uncommon spring and summer visitor to Huntington Central Park. In their July 8, 1997 letter, the Service states their belief that the California Feast tern is a frequent visitor to the Park; however, they provide no documentation that the bird has been seen in areas under consideration for development of elements of the proposed Master Plan. According to Life on the Edge(BioSystems Analysis Inc. 1994), least terns form breeding colonies of 30 fo 50 pairs. As stared in Table 3.7-1 of the MEIR, the nearest known nesting colonies are located at Huntington State Beach and the Bolsa Chica Ecological Reserve. This species feeds on anchovies, top smelt,Jacksmelt, and other small, nearshore prey. Huntington Central Park does not provide suitable nesting or foraging habitat for this species. Please see the Clarification and Revision to pa a 3.7-15 which correctly identifies the southwestern willow flycatcher as a Federally and tate listed endangered species. As indicated on page 3.7-40 of the MEIR Cooper's hawk is identified in "Birds of Huntington Central Park" as an uncommon spring, fall and winter visitor which has been known to nest within the Park. No occupied nesting habitat for Cooper's hawk was identified in locations under consideration for project and program level elements of the proposed Master Plan. Vegetation found in association with Talbert Lake-Meadow is accurate) described on Pages 3.T-5 and 3.7-6 of the MEIR as being comprised of 8 acres of mowed turfgrass subject to seasonal flooding and 8 acres of disturbed riparian vegetation. The elements of the proposed Master Plan have been designed to avoid impacts on the Talbert Lake-Meadow. Landscaped areas mapped on Fi ure 3.7-1 of the MEIR are described on pages 3.7-3 through 3.7-5 of the MEIR, including the frees associated with such areas. These areas do not meet the definition of native woodland habitats described in Holland's Preliminary Descriptions of the Terrestrial Natural Communities of California. In addition the urban forest mapped on Figure 3.7-1 of the MEIR is described on page 3.7-5, including the trees associated with such areas. Disturbed riparian habitats located throughout the park, includin associated native trees are described onpages 3.7-6 and 3.7-7 of the MEIR. As indicated in%ble 3.7-3, the Sully Miller Lake Group t acility program level element was identified as having the potential to result in conversion of disturbed riparian habitat. Such impacts would be the subject of environmental documentation. The location of all mature trees is clearly distinguishable on large scale color aerial photographs of the Huntington Central Park. The project design will not affect any known feeding or nesting site.Thank you for pointing out the omission of federal status for the southwestern willow flycatcher. Southwestern willow flycatcher is a federally and state listed endangered species. Thank you for the information on confirmed breeding of Cooper's hawk at Huntington Central Park. Project level elements of the MEIR will not result in the removal of any trees which might provide suitable nesting habitat for Cooper's hawk. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-16 W:I PROJECT511096-0041EI RIRTCI 1096-004.INT T � Comment: The current vegetation that remains at Central Park continues to provide habitat for, in particular, an extraordinary array of avian wildlife resources. Commentor(s): Service (11) Response: Diverse avian use of the park is primarily associated with the Shipley Nature Center and Jack Green Nature Area which are not affected by the elements of the proposed Master Plan. The elements of the proposed Master Plan will not convert any portion of the urban forest or landscape areas that provide suitable resting habitat for migratory birds. Urban forest under consideration with the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head program level element of the proposed Master Plan and landscape materials associated with the Low Intensity Recreation and Semi-Active Recreation program level elements of the proposed Master Plan are likely to provide suitable restinghabitator migratory birds. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-17 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041 EI R IR TCI 1096-004.1 NT Comment: The Service requests that the project be redesigned to prevent or minimize to the extent possible the proposed loss of approximately 150 acres of potential wildlife habitat including 12 acres of regionally scarce riparian woodland habitat, and avoid impacting the diverse and sensitive avi auna found therein. In theirJ'oint letter of comment the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the California Department of Fish and Game made the following statement: "The City of Huntington Beach has, to the best of our knowledge, not complied with an order issued by the Environmental Protection Agency to restore riparian habitats in designated Talbert Lake Wetland south and east of the Jack Green Nature Are. This issue must be successfully resolved prior to the issuance of State or Federal permits that would impact vegetated wetlands and waters at this site. To assist the City in restoring these habitats and to provide additional habitat for migratory birds, the Service, City Staff, and then Mayor Dr.Victor Leippzig sougght and received a cost-share rant to fund riparian and woodland restoration eftorts. Althou h the on inal sum of10 000 for purposes of revegetation and the control of exotic pants is still-available to the pity, the grant expires at the end of this calendar year. " Commentor(s): Service (12) Response: See Response to Service (7) which describes how project level elements are proposed for existin landscaped and ruderal/bare areas of Huntington Central Park, including a capped landfillgwhich provides minimal habitat value. Conservation of 150 acres of"potential'wildlife habitat recommended by the Service and the Department is not a feasible alternative. The City acknowledges the need to minimize impacts on disturbed riparian vegetation found in association with the proposed location for Sully Miller Lake Group Facility. The potential conversion of 11.7 acres was presented as a worst case scenario for development of this element. Upon identification of a more detailed proposal for this part of the Park, additional environmental documentation would need to be undertaken to support the decision-making process related to this element of the proposed Master Plan. See Response to Service (11) which describes the conservation of existing riparian habitat within Huntington Central Park and the associated diverse and sensitive avifauna that occur in association with these areas, particularly the ShipleyY Nature Center and the Jack Green Nature Area. The project and program level elements of tY�e proposed Master Plan are not expected to result in impacts on the Shipley Nature Center or the Jack Green Nature Center. The City is not aware of any outstanding order from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). In July 1986, Park, Tree and-Landscape Division of the City of Huntington Beach recommended vegetation management measures to comply with an order by tYie Orange County Vector C:ontrol District to achieve mosquito abatement. These actions were successfully undertaken. In their letter dated January 6, 1987, the Service notified the City of "Apparent Unauthorized Activity at Central Park, Uran e County, and Its Potential Effect on the Least Bell's Vireo, A Federally Listed Endangered pecies. In January 1987, the EPA requested more information from the City regarding the claims made by the Service. In response to that letter the City requested a meeting with EPA. The City forwarded a second letter in January 198� providing information requested by the EPA. The information in the March 1 887 the Cit was supplemented com bled withrapceaseeandydesist order Issued by the EPA In April 1985, the City attornewrepared "Responses to Findings of Violation and Orderfor Compliance." On April 22, 1987, the U.S. Army Corps of En sneers sent a letter to the City of Huntington Beach stating their belief that work undertaken gy the city did not constitute a violation pursuant to Section 404 of the Clean Water Act. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers furnished copies of the letter to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the U.S. EPA. In November 1989, the City retained The Keith Companies to prepare Wetland Delineation, Impact Assessment, and Preliminary Mitigation Recommendations, Talbert Lake and Huntington Lake, In June 1990,the City retained The Keith Companies to prepare Talbert Lake Desiltation Basin Mitigation and Maintenance Plan. These reports supported use of Nationwide Permits to complete two projects: Huntington Lake Desiltation Basin and Talbert Lake Desiltation Basin. In August 1995, the Service sent a letter to the City (Honorable Victor Leipzig) indicating approval of funds for a migratory bird habitat restoration project in Huntington Central Park. The Challenge Cost-Share Agreement was executed in August 1995. Those tunds were directed toward implementation of "Shipley Nature Center Habitat Enhancement and Creation Program." In September 1996 the City confirmed its intent to expend funds provided by Fish and Wildlife Grant#14-48-dOl at the Shipley Nature Center. The elements of the proposed Master Plan do not involve any work in the area of the Talbert Lake-Meadow which have been determined to be subject of the jurisdiction of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers or the California Department of Fish and Game. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-18 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EI R I R TCI 1096-004.I NT t � Comment: The Service stated that"project-related destruction of approximately 68 (of the 72 available) acres of grasslands (DEIR page 3.7-43) contributes to the ongoing massive depletion of the habitat type in southern California." The Service requested tfiat mitigation measures related to impacts on grassland and disturbed riparian habitat provide assurances to guarantee the successful restoration of habitat values and functions." Commentor(s): Service 03) and 04) Response: Please see Response to Service (8) for a discussion of revisions to the project description for program level elements of the proposed Master Plan that have been undertaken to reduce impacts on grasslands below the threshold for significance. Comment: The Service recommends that the function and integrity of existing sensitive habitats and wildlife on public lands, to the extent possible, be buffered from the proposed project site. Commentor(s): Service 0 5) Response: The primary areas of existing suitable habitat for sensitive s ecies within Huntington Central Park are located in the Shipley Nature Center and Jack Green Nature Center. The Sports Complex is bounded on the north by the library parking lot, on the east by Gothard Street and a closed gun range,on the south by an abandoned sand and ravel quarry and a mobile home park, aon the west b Golden West Street. The consolidatged campground is located within and surrounded by landscaped areas of the Park. The Park, Tree anO Landscape Maintenance Yard is bounded on the north by the GTE yard, on the east by the existing Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Yard, and to the south and west by landscaped areas of the Park. The Outdoor Music Area is entirely located within and surrounded by landscaped areas of the Park. The Low Intensity Recreation Area is surrounded by existing landscaped areas of the Park. The Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head and Semi-Active Recreation Area are bounded by a dog ppark, landscaped areas of the Park, and an equestrian center to the north Golden West Street to the east, Ellis Street to the south and Edwards Street to the west. The Sully Miller Lake Group Facility is bounded by rudera(/bare area to the north the closed Orange County Transfer Station to the east, Ellis Street to the south, and the mobile kome park to the west. The project level and pro ram level elements of the Park do not abut state designated sensitive habitats; therefore, thNervice's recommendation to incorporate buffers is not warranted. Measure Aesthetics-2 requires the use of shielded, directed lighting recommended by the Service and the Department. Elimination of lighting as recommended by the Service and the Department, would be inconsistent with the establisked project objective of achieving"Crime Prevention through Environmental Design." The City will consider the use of native plants in defining plant palettes for landscaped areas. Comment: The Service recommends that a cowbird abatement program be developed and implemented to preclude possible project-related effects to the vireo, flycatcher, or any sensitive songbird species that breed within five miles of the project site. Commentor(s): Service 0 6) Response: In order to enhance and restore habitat function to remaining and restored habitats such as Shipley Nature Center, and Jack Green Nature Area, the City has added Measure Biological Resources - 6 to add a brown-headed cowbird trapping proggram to remove brown-headed cowbirds from areas with the highest concentrations of nesting migratory birds species at Huntington Central Park. It should be noted that brown-headed cowbird is abundant in all habitats in the Park(MEIR,Appendix G),and is therefore considered to be an existing condition within the Park. Comment: July 8, 1997 Commentor(s): Service (18) Response: Referenced letter was not received by City of Huntington Beach or its consultant. The issues identified in the letter have been addressed in the METR and will be considered by the City of Huntington Beach Planning Commission and City Council during their decision-making process related to the ro osed Master Plan. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-19 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EIRIRTCI 1096-004.INT HAZARDS Comment: A geophysical survey was suggested to be performed to detect possible buried drums, tanks, or piping. The park was historically used as'a dumping ground before present hazardous waste control Taws Commentor(s): DTSC (2) Response: The areas of the site where the former Huntington Beach Landfill (SWIS No. 30-AB-0026), the Gothard Street Landfill (SWIS No. 30-AB-0014), a municipal waste site operated by Orange County and the Bruce Brother's Pit site are located have been extensively explored. Kleinfe(der (1989, 1990) and CH2M Hill (1996, 1998) have performed various field explorations at these sites. Much of these explorations were invasive in nature using small- diameter hollow-stem-auger borings and back hoe-excavated test pits. To the City's knowledge, no buried drums, tanks or piping have been encountered in any of the field explorations. Also significant earthwork at these locations has occurred since landfill operations ceased. this earthwork has resulted in.soil cover over the landfills ranging from an estimated 4 to 25 feet thick (CH2M Hill, 1998). In addition to the field explorations already completed at the sites, site-specific geotechnical studies will be required prior to facility development to establish facility-and building-specific geotechnical design parameters. The results of these efforts will provide additional information regarding the presence or absence of buried drums,tanks, or piping. Field explorations to date have not encountered any of these objects. The proposed development in the areas of known former dumping will tend to improve upon existing conditions. These improvements come in the form of additional soil fill over significant portions of the site, improvement to existing surface water control systems, and the addition of final cover systems over portions of the ormer landfills where irrigation uses are proposed. A minimum 4 foot thick soil cover will be maintained over the former landfill sites. Comment: The target area within the former shooting range may contain a large quantity of lead bullets and fragments. This area should be screened for lead contamination. If significant lead contamination is found, a PEA should be performed. The agency expresses an ecological and human health concern in that runoff from the former gun range could contaminate surface water at Sully Miller Lake. Commentor(s): DTSC (4), County (13) Response: Both DTSC and the County raise legitimate concern over the existence of lead contaminants from bullets and fragments at the former shootin ran e. The City is fully aware that lead concentrations in surface water sources such as Sul y Mier Lake can affect human health and normal ecosystem production. A Preliminary Assessment of the Former Police Department Firing Range was conducted by Americlean Environmental Services, Inc.to determine the parts per million of lead in the soil at the base of the target area. Despite the fact that the soils at the gun range were reported to have high lead content above EPA thresholds, the gun range is considered a program level improvement and not an element of the proposed project. Therefore,any special consideration and/or designing of mitigation measures to reduce impacts to Sully-Miller Lake from soil contaminated with lead will-be re-visited prior to developing tans andspecifications for Sully-Miller Lake and gun range improvements. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-20 W:IPROJECT511096-0041EIRIRTO 1096-004.INT I Comment: Several commentators noted that the MEIR did not correctly delineate several landfills which would affect the proposed project. Certain agencies commented that the MEIR is unclear in describimthe locations and names of CIA landfills such as Joseph S. Fern(30-Cr-0090) and R.W. McClellan and sons (30-CR-0054) and the Bruce Brothers Pit (a city owned facility). Boundaries of the former waste dump sites should be clearly defined and evaluated through subsurface investigation. Consequently, Figure 3.9.2-1 needs to be revised. A preliminary endangerment assessment(PEA)should be completed to screen the site for heavy metals, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, polychlorinated biphenYls, and the associated potential human and ecological health risks. These agencies urge the City to review the list of additional CIA landfill sites which may impact the proposed project. Commentor(s): County 05, 14), LEA (2, 3, 4), DTSC(3), Env. Board 02) Response: There has been some confusion regarding the proper identification of the various landfills and disposal pits located in the area of the proposed project site bounded by Talbert Avenue to the North, Golden West Street to the West, Gothard Street to the East and the southern limit of the existing inactive Gun Range facility. Based on our review of available records and discussions with various regulators, there are two distinct facilities in this area of the proposed development. One is the former municipal solid waste landfill known as the Gothard Street Landfill (SWIS No. 30-AB-0014) and Huntington Beach Landfill (SWIS No. 30-AB-0026). Apparently this is one contiguous landfill owned by different parties. The City of Huntington Beach owns the Huntington Beach Landfill, while the County of Orange owns the Gothard Street Landfill. In addition the City of Huntington Beach owns the Bruce Brother's Pit site that was permitted for disposal of inert debris in fhe early 1980s. The locations of each of these sites are shown on Revised Figure 8 from our April 24, 1998 Geology Report. Apparently, the SWIS list is in error where it indicates that the Huntington Beach Landfill is also known as the Bruce Brother's Pit. The Revised Figure 8 is provided in the Clarifications and Revisions Section of this document in the Geophysical Evaluation. The City and their consultants have considered the list of CIA landfills submitted with the LEA's letter of October 9, 1997. None of the field explorations or literature reviews performed in support of DEIR preparation have disclosed either the McClellan or Fern facilities on the proposed project's site. Therefore, we can not confirm or deny the existence of these sites. Design-level studies should provide more detailed information about existing conditions that could impact the proposed development. If the design-level studies disclose conditions that could significantly impact the proposed project, then specific mitigation measures will be developed and implemented. These mitigation measures will fall within the range of mitigation measures already described in the DIER. In addition, all construction plans and specifications will require that each contractor develop a site-and action-specific comprehensive health and safe%y plan ((H&SP) for all construction activities. The plans and specifications will require that the H&SP be developed using the information available about past uses of these sites and the possibility that solid waste, PCH- contaminated soils, and/or potentially hazardous waste materials could be encountered. Figure 3.9.2-1 has been revised to include the McClennan and Fern CIA sites. This figure is provided in the Clarifications and Revisions Section of this document. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-21 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EIRI RTC11096-004.INT I Comment: A detailed characterization of the waste contained in the former Huntington Beach Landfill and Inert Debris Disposal Pit needs to be provided (e.g., the potential for the former landfill sites to contain hazardous waste). Commentor(s): Env. Board (4) Response: The former landfill is located in an old gravel pit. The landfill began accepting typical nonhazardous municipal waste, including organic materials in the early 1950s; the closure date is uncertain. The landfill accepted household trash, landscapingg cutti.n s, and other nonhazardous organic debris. Some activity was still evident in a 1959 aeriafphotoggraph (Kleinfelder, 1989). The date when the landfill stopped accepting municipal waste is believed to be prior to 1960. Disposal of construction waste on the adjacent construction debris landfill was halted in the late 1960's or possibly, early 1970's (Kleinfelder, 1990). The depth to the bottom of the landfill was found to be as great as 60 feet (approximate elevation -15) (Kleinfelder, 1989). We have not reviewed any information that suggests or confirms that hazardous waste was disposed in this landfill. However, the presence of hazardous materials can not be ruled out. We believe that any hazardous materials in this landfill that could pose a risk to public health and safety would manifest themselves in groundwater and/or air quality impacts. Both the groundwater conditions and air quality conditions will be monitored after landfill closure in compliance with existing regulations. Direct human contact is highly unlikely. Hazardous materials were known to be disposed of in the Bruce Brother's Pit area prior to its use as a permitted inert disposal area in late 1979. As stated in Section 3.3.2 of the DEIR, "From 1927 to 1949, the pit was used as a disposal site for rotary drilling muds and waste muds from sumps. In 1957 a permit was issued for the disposal of inert materials. Violations occurred from 7 957 to 19�2 as a result of the acceptance of liquid refinery wastes, oil, and brines and sump bottoms at the pit..." The potential for these materials to have an adverse impact on public health and safety is believed to be low, primarily because of their depth below current and proposed ground surface elevations. Again, risks posed to human health and safety would likely manifest themselves in groundwater and/or air quality impacts. Groundwater and air quality monitoring programs consistent with current landfill closure and post-closure requirements will provi e a method for early detection of potential adverse impacts. The California Regional Water Quality Control Board, Santa Ana Reggion's Waste Discharge Requirements (WDR) Order No. 81-012, for the Bruce Brother's Pifstates that the site was formerly used as a chi(dren's pplayground known as Adventure Play round. The WDRs were adopted on February 13, 1981 and allowed for disposal of GrouA wastes, which are inert materials such as construction and demolition debris. Also, the proposed development in the areas of known former landfills will tend to improve upon existing conditions. These improvements come in the form of additional soil fill over significant portions of the site, improvement to existing grades and surface water control systems, and the addition of final cover systems over portions of the former landfills where irrigation uses arLE2120secl. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-22 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041 EI RIR TO 1096-004.I NT Comment: The text states on Page 3.9-7 that the "Huntington Beach AKA the Bruce Brothers Pit" is part of what is known as tie Gothard Street Landfill-located at 18131 Gothard Street, however this statement is incorrect. It is important to note that the Bruce Brothers Pit and the Gothard street Landfill are distinct landfills. These two sites are also described on page 3.9-8 of the DMEIR. As indicated, the Bruce Brothers Pit was used by the city as a disposal site for rotary drilling mud and waste mud from sumps from 1927 to 1949. It is unclear whether the drilling mud has been excavated prior to the deposition of inert materials. If not, the impact on groundwater should be addressed. Commentor(s): County (23) Response: The reference on Page 3.9-7 is incorrect. The former Huntington Beach Landfill (SWIS No. 30- AB-0026), is located southeast of the intersection of Golden West Street and Talbert Avenue and extends below the existing Gun Range facility. This landfill is contiguous with and for engineering purposes is the same as the Gothard Street Landfill (SWIS No. 30-AB-0014),which extends to Gothard street and underlies the former Orange County Transfer Station. The estimated limits of these landfills, and Bruce Brother's Pit are shown in the revised Figure 8 from Appendix C provided as Attachment to Appendix C, following Section 13 Clarifications and Revisions, of this Final Master EIR. This distinction will be made in the Final EIR. The City does not know if the drilling muds reported to have been disposed in the area of the Bruce Brother's Pit from 1927 to 1949 were removed prior to the placement of inert materials. Current groundwater quality information from this vicinity of the site indicates that the groundwater is not potable and is already impacted. The proposed project will not make this situation worse. The actions that are proposed for this development will enhance the situation at the portion of the site over the former Bruce Brother's Pit relative to the current conditions. As stated in Section 3.3.4 of the DEIR a minimum 4-foot thick soil cover will be maintained over the former Bruce Brother's Pit. The City intends to demonstrate that the 4-foot thick soil cover can be as protective of the environment as a prescriptive final cover per the requirements for an engineered alternative final cover system contained in CCR Title 27 Section 21090. Design-level studies should provide more detailed information about existing conditions that could impact the proposed development. If the design-level studies disclose conditions that could significantly impact the proposed project, then specific mitigation measures will be developed and implemented. These mitigation measures will fall within the range of mitigation measures already described in the DIER. In addition,all construction plans and specifications will require that each contractor develop a site-and action-specific comprehensive health and safety plan (H&SP) for all construction activities. The plans and specifications will require that the H&SP be developed using the information available about past uses of these sites and the possibility that solid waste, PCH- contaminated soils and/or potentially hazardous waste materials could be encountered. Comment: The exact boundary between the Huntington Beach Landfill and the inert debris disposal pit was not determined as a result of the report of Geology Conditions. Are the Huntington Beach Landfill and the inert debris disposal pit the same site? As indicated on page 3.9-7 of the DMEIR, a permit was issued in 1957 for the disposal of inert materials. Was this permit issued for inert material disposal on the Bruce Brothers Pit site or another site? Commentor(s): County (24) Response: No, the Huntington Beach Landfill and the inert debris disposal pit are not the same site. Apparently,the California Solid Waste Information System is in error in its identification of the Huntington Beach Landfill as also being known as the Bruce Brother's Pit. The City believes that the 1957 EtL21jLLAas for activities at the Bruce Brother's Pit location. Comment: Areas in the vicinity of former oil wells should be evaluated for petroleum product spills and drilling mud disposal pits. Also, frequently used maintenance areas should be identified where chemical spills and dumping may have occurred. Fugitive surface gas emissions should be measured including core toxic gas emissions and methane. Any subsurface investigation should also include sampling for methane gas, a potential hazard associated with both landfills and oil fields. Commentor(s): DTSC (5), Env.Board (5) Response: Please refer to the response to LEA(5)for a discussion on landfill gas generation, migration, and monitoring. A design-level study to explore the nature, location, and concentration of landfill as throughout the proposed development area will be performed prior to development. The results of this study will be used to design a landfill gas control system that will comply with all applicable regulations. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-23 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EIRI RTC11096-004.INT Comment: A final cover system for land use change area over an inactive municipal solid waste landfill, especially the land use area, shall be designed and maintained in accordance with Section 2190 of Title 27. The LEA and RWQCB must approve any actions that alter the cover of any of the affected landfills. Commentor(s): RWQCB (2), County (16), LEA (9) Response: This comment is noted. All landfill-related closure and post-closure activities will be completed in compliance with CCR Title 27. Comment: The study of landfill gas production should be conducted,and results_presented in the draft EIR, not as a art of Mitigation Measure Hazards-4, as suggested on Page 3.9-12 of the document. I he study needs to evaluate not only the existing setting, but also changes to gas production that could result when the site is subjected to "dynamic compaction , and then capped with a synthetic membrane and 6-feet of soil. Commentor(s): Env. Board (6) Response: Please refer to the Supplement to Technical Appendix C in the Clarifications and Revisions Section of this document which states that a study to estimate LFG generation has been performed. CH2M HILL performed a landfill as generation model analysis for the former Huntington Beach/Gothard Street Landfill. Resuffs from the analysis indicate that the maximum landfill gas roduction rate was approximately 1,000 cubic feet per minute(cfm) around 1960. Currently, andfill gas production at the site, based on the model, is about 50 cfm with gas production in the year 2010 estimated to continue to decline to about 25 cfm. Therefore, because of the age and characteristics of this landfill we believe LFG generation is in the declining stages. This belief is shared by the South boast Air Quality Management District (SCAQMv D, 1-995). The planned development for the areas underlain by the former landfill should not result in an increased LFG generation rate. Site improvement techniques such as dynamic compaction are not expected to result in increased LFU generation. The construction of a final cover system should reduce the amount of surface water percolation into the underlying waste materials thereby decreasing the LFG generation rate relative to current conditions. The cover system will also change the current migration patterns. Comment: Prior to public use of the bioremidiated soil disposal area the area must be sufficiently covered with compacted clean fill as recommended in the draft MEIR. It is recommended by this agency that bioremidiated soil disposal area be covered with at least one foot of compacted clean fill. Commentor(s): RWQCB (5) Response: The City agrees with the concerns raised in this comment. The remediated soil has been treated to comply with the specifications of the City of Huntington Beach Fire Department. - These soils will be covered with at least 1 foot of clean soils during project grading operations. Comment:0 The projects described in the MEIR will most likely require the installation of additional dedicated landfill gas monitoring probes to quantitatively assess the concentration and possible migration of landfill as.The Mi igation Measures Section needs to include a statement that if any unexpected landfills are discovered during the projects implementation the LEA will be immediately notified and appropriate measures will be taken. The LEA and other appropriate regulatory agencies must approve all work to be performed that relates to any of the inactive landfills unless notified otherwise. Commentor(s): County (17), LEA (7,10, 11) Response: The following text will be added to Section 3.9 of the draft MEIR as an addition to mitigation Measure Hazards-9 to address the discovery of any unknown landfills during the implementation phase of the project. "Should any unknown and unexpected landfills be excavated and discovered during the construction phase of the proposed project, construction work will be immediately halted and LEA will be notified. Further construction operations will resume at the discretion of LEA and upon work approval by LEA." Comment: The draft MEIR does not provide detail on the testing procedures and disposal cleanup criteria of remaining PHC-contaminated soil. A PHC-contaminated soil disposal plan, detailingthe testing procedures, storage, and disposal and cleanup criteria of the PHC-contaminatedsoil, for approval. Commentor(s): RWQCB (6) Response: The proposed project has been designed to avoid intrusive activities in the area of the PCH- contaminated soils. The project's current conceptual grading plan indicates fill ranging from about 2 to 4 feet thick will be placed in this area. Also,the design consists of non-irrigated uses for this portion of the site. Therefore, the actions that are proposed for this development will enhance the situation at the portion of the site where the PH-contaminated soils exist relative to the current conditions. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 7 999 Page 12-24 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EI R IR TCI 1096-004.1 NT Comment: Electrical conduits utility pipes, and trenches with permeable bedding materials are potential conduits for landfill gas migrat d ion. Design consideration for potential LFG migration control through pipes,trenches,or other conduits should be incorporated into plans an specitications. Commentor(s): County 02) Response: Please refer to Clarifications and Revisions Page 3.9-13 which incorporates the language you provided. Comment: The DMEIR should include a discussion of whether SCAQMD Rule 1150, Excavation of Landfill Sites or Rule 1150.1, Control of Gaseous Emissions from Municipal Solid Waste Landfills, wilt apply to this project. SCAQMD rule 1150.1 for landfill should be included in the list on page"TV-2 Commentor(s): County (22), Env. Board (8), Env. Board (13) Response: The project may involve excavatin into a pportion of the closed landfill. A paragraph will be added in Section 3.0, Hazards uAer the Kules and Regulations subsection which states: "SCAQMD Rule 1150 will require the preparation of an Excavation Management Plan prior to be inning excavation and will be submitted to and approved by the executive officer of the SCA�MD. This plan shall identify mitigation measures to be activated as necessary during excavation to ensure that a public nuisance condition does not occur. Mitigation measures shall be selected after consideration of the physical characteristics of the landfill. This requirement is separate from CEQA requirements. While analysis of impacts and agency coordination of comments on impacts would assist in the preparation of the Plan, they would not substitute for this requirement. Section 13.0 of this final Master EIR will also reflect the addition of a new mitigation measure to address the potential excavation of any unknown landfill materials. SCAQMD Rule 1150.1 applies to the former landfills located at the proposed project site. The City intends to comply with all applicable portions of Rule 1150.1 during design, construction, and monitoring phases of the project. In addition, the City will comply with California Code of Regulations, Title 27 Section 20919 for gas control. All construction plans and specifications will require that each contractor develop a site-and action-specific comprehensive health and safety plan H&SP)for all construction activities. The plans and specifications will require that the H& P be developed using-the information available about past uses of these sites and the possibility that solid waste, PCH-contaminated soils and/or otential) hazardous waste materials could be encountered. Comment: In the development of the Sports Complex element of the Master Plan, the former landfill area will be capped with a geomembrane to prevent percolation of water and a 6-foot layer of soil compacted on top to establish stability for development activities. `The Environmental Board is concerned that these actions may have the potential to change the character of the former landfill. For example, capping the landfill may limit air intrusion to the site creating ideal conditions for anaerobic andfgll as generation. Furthermore, capping the site may cause landfill gas, if present, to migrate lallerany into other areas of Central Park. The EIR should fully evaluate this potential and explore the appropriate mitigation measures. Commentor(s): Env. Board (14) Response: It is believed that the landfill is currently in an anaerobic state, which is typical of most municipal solid waste landfills after initial waste disposal. If this landfill was in an aerobic state, then areas of subterranean spontaneous combustion would likely be evident. Construction of a final landfill cover system will significantly change the exiting LFG migration/emissions patterns. As is described in the response to Env. Board (7) below, an LFG control system will be designed,constructed, maintained, and monitored if desi n-level studies indicate that LFG migration is a risk to human health and the environmenf. Regulations included in CCR Title 27 for LFG control at closed sites and SCAQMD Rule 1150.1 will be considered. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-25 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EI R I RTCI 1096-004.I NT Comment: A conceptual design of an active or passive gas collection system, as well as monitoring programs needed to support the systems operation should be presented as this will impact other aspects of the draft EIR (e.g., construction emissions, utilities, etc.). Commentor(s): Env. Board (7), Env. Board (15), LEA(5) Response: Landfill as has been addressed in the Supplement to Technical Appendix C of the DMEIR in the ClariTications and Revisions Section of thisdocument. As part of the current EIR CH2M HILL performed a landfill gas generation model analysis for the former landfill. Resurts from the analysis indicate that the maximum landfill as production rate was about 1,000 cubic feet per minute (cfm) around 1960. Currently, landfill gas production at the site, based on the model is about 50 cfm with gas production in the year Z010 estimated to continue to decline to about 25 cfm. Therefore, because of the age and characteristics of this landfill, we believe LFG generation is in the declinin sta es. This belief is shared by the South Coast Air Quality Management District (SCAQMN, 1915). Landfill gas is currently being created by the refuse contained within the landfill mass. As the refuse decays, methane is produced and accumulates until released. The rate of methane production is variable dependant upon the pace of decomposing.material. As the rate of methane production is unstable, the risk of upset due to release of accumulated methane is significant. Because of the age and characteristics of this landfill we believe LFG generation is in the declining stages. However, development over the closed landfill that causes an increase of water migration through the cover soils into the refuse could result in higher LFG generation rates than are currently being observed at the site. Also, construction of a low- permeability final cover system will change the existing LFG migration patterns. As part of the project's implementation, additional studies will be performed to assess the actual characteristics and location of LFG migrating from the site as well as the human health risks using potential receptors and current LFG data. If the studies indicate that LFG is still a significant risk appropriate control measures consistent with Title 27 and SCApMD regulations will be designed and constructed. The control measures could include the following: > A passive LFG control system that provides a low-resistance path for escaping LFG to reduce offsite migration > An LFG treatment system that either scrubs the LFG to remove hazardous materials (e.g., granular activated carbon), or burns the LFG to destroy virtually all of the hazardous materials (e.g., a flare) > LFG barrier systems below all enclosed structures on or within 1,000 feet of the landfill; the barrier systems could include a granular monitoring layer below the barrier and a granular vent layer above the barrier with passive exhaust vents releasing to the atmosphere > An engineered cover over the landfill to limit the amount of moisture that enters the landfill thereby not increasing the rate of LFG generation > An active LFG control system that creates a low pressure zone within the refuse thereby reducing.LFG offsite migration > A subsurface cut-off walFto control LFG migration into selected areas of the development > Periodic monitoring to verify that LFG migration is under control Comments:. Per a database presented in the attached ERIIS Report, the 18-acre Bruce Brothers Pit was listed as a potential contaminated hazardous waste site. Are any mitigation measures required for this site? Please clarify the status of the site Commentor(s): County (27) Response: The proposed project does not involve grading or excavation of existing landfill materials. See Clarifications and Revisions to Measure I Fazards-9 and the addition of Measure Hazards-14 and Measure Hazards-15 to ensure adequate protection during construction and operation of the proposed project. Comment: Resident is concerned with potential environmental impacts with respect to the ground water from automobile fluids that will result from the 800 parking spaces. Commentor(s): Kurjan (12) Response: Storm water runoff and conveyance systems will be designed in accordance with current regulatory requirements as indicated in the draft Master EIR, including the implementation of storm water best management practices (BMP's) to reduce runoff contaminants into natural or storm channel facilities. Comment: The passive control system currently in operation in front of the Central Library may need to be expanded and enhanced due to possible effects of the proposed projects. Commentor(s): LEA (6) Response: The potential need to expand and enhance the passive control system in operation in front of the Central Library is addressed in Mitigation Measure Hazards-4, which calls for the completion of studies to evaluate the potential for landfill gas generation and migration prior to development of the Sports Complex. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-26 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041EIR IR TCI 1096-004.1 NT NOISE Comment: Resident is concerned with noise impacts regarding the possible gun range at the proposed project site. Commentor(s): McNeely (1) Response: The gun range is currently closed and is considered a pnram level element to be analyzed at a later date when appropriate funding is made available. hould the gun range be re-opened as part of the pro ram level improvements, a noise impact analysis will be prepared and incorporated into ge environmental discussion of im acts from gun range operations. Comment: Resident is concerned with noise as it relates to the amplified voice announcement system. The following information is requested: (1) Purpose and scope (2) Frequency of use (3) Hours of operation (4) Number and orientation of speakers (5) Will music or audio transmission be allowed Commentor(s): Kurjan (13) Response: Currently, there are no plans and specifications prepared for the proposed project. Upon completion of the plans and specifications, the resident will be notified in writing of the purpose and scope of the public address system to be installed as part of the proposed project. The notification will include information regarding the above inquiries. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-27 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EI R IR TCI 1096-004.I NT PUBLIC SERVICES Comment: Resident concludes that Mitigation Measures Public Services-2 through 4 are inadequate and additional police protection will be needed. Commentor(s): Kurjan (20) Response: The park itself will not be increasing in size, rather positive recreation uses will be displacing negative uses that could occur on the undeveloped lands within the park. Those undeveloped areas of the park are currently patrolled by city police, and this will continue after these areas have been developed. The implementation of Crime Prevention through Environmental Design will be sufficient to maintain adequate safety at the park. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-28 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EIRI RTCI 1096-004.INT UTILITIES AND SERVICE,SYSTEMS Comment: All underground drain pipes,sewer lines, and other water lines, such as the irrigation lines to be installed within the landfill must be double-walled to provide secondary containment in the event of pipe leakage. This should be addressed in the Plans and Specifications for the construction of the Sports Complex. Commentor(s): RWQCB (4) Response: Double walled pipe is sometimes mandated to transport leachate from within a landfill to a remote location, tank, or treatment facility, to provide secondary containment. In the event double walled pipes are not available as needed to convey domestic wastewater, domestic water, storm water and irrigations water, the final design and Plans and Specifications will evaluate available pipe materials and joint systems and select the pipe system best suited to the intended use that most closely approximates the secondary containment characteristics of double walled pipes. Comment: The Southern California Gas Company has facilities in the area where the project is proposed. The project could be served by an existing main without any significant impact on the environment. The service would be in accordance with the company s policies and extension rules on file with the California Public Utilities at the time contractual arrangements are made. The availability of natural gas is based upon present conditions of gas supply and regulatory policies. Commentor(s): Gas Co. (1) Response: Thank you for Your information. The Southern California Gas Company can provide gas service to the Project from an existing main line without any significant impacts to the environment. The availability of natural gas service is based on the present gas supply and regulatory olicies. Comment: Estimates of gas for non-residential projects are developed on an individual basis and are obtained from the Commercial-Industrial Market Services Staff by calling 1(800)427-2000. Several programs have been developed several programs which are available upon request to provide assistance in selecting the most energy efficient appliances or systems for a particular project Commentor(s): Gas Co. (2) Response: The Commercial-Industrial Market Service can estimate gas usage for non-residential uses. The Lead Planning Associate for the area can provide information regarding construction and cost of initiating service. Comment: Information regarding construction particulars and any costs associated with initiatingservice may be obtained by contacting the Lead Planner Associate for your area at(714) 3 -3498. Commentor(s): Gas Co. (3) Response: Thank you for providing this information. It will be forwarded to the appropriate persons for their use during implementation of the Proposed Project. Comment: The subject area lies within the watershed of East Garden Grove-Wintersburg Channel. The Federal Emergency Mana ement Agency(FEMA)and the County of Orange are studying flood hazards associated withTast Garen Grove Wintersburg Channel as part of floodprain re- zoning efforts of the Santa Ana River (SAR). The zone is currently zoned as A-99 by FEMA because of the SAR. When the SAR floodplain zone (A-99) is removed, anticipated in late 1999,as a consequence of the SAR federal project, FEMA is likely to show portions underlyingg the SAR floodplain as a residual floodplain resultingfrom East Garden -Wintersburg Channel This will require floodplain regulations to be fol1owed for insurable structures within the residual floodplain area. Commentor(s): County (2) Response: The City understands this and will comply with all required regulations should any part of the Project be zoned as a floodplain. Comment: Section 34 "Water"of the MEIR should be revised to state that parts of the project might be subject to floodplain regulations, which might require mitigation. Commentor(s): County(3) Response: Please refer to the Clarifications and Revisions Section page 3.4-4 which incorporates the above information. Comment: The MEIR does not address the requirement for protection or replacement of existing groundwater monitoring wells located within the proposed Sports Complex area. Commentor(s): County (10) Response: The City will take all appropriate measures to ensure that all groundwater monitoring wells current l in service remain operational. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-29 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041 EI R I RTCI 1096-004.I NT Comment: Updated language was provided regarding solid waste management plans. The Integrated Waste Management Act of 1989 supplanted the Z'berg-Kapiloff requirement for counties to prepare Solid Waste Management Plans every three years. Commentor(s): County (11) Response: Please refer to the Clarifications and Revisions Section page 3.12-1 and 3.12-2 which integrates the suggested language. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-30 W:I PR OJEC T511096-0041EIR IR TCI 1096-004.I NT AESTHETICS Comment: The draft MEIR reports that night I�i hting of the soccer/football and softball fields would create significant impact to the Ocean iew state Mobile Home Park, even after mitigation. The Environmental Board recommends that further mitigation measures, such as the planting of trees immediate to the north of the mobile home parR, consideration of other site alternatives that place the lighting further from the mobile home park, or using only the most northern fields for night activities. Commentor(s): Env. Board (11), Env. Board (19) Response: Thank you for your comments. Please see page 3.13-6 Measure Aesthetics-1. Though the proposed project will result in a significant impact to the Ocean View Mobile Homes Estates through tF�e creation of new light when night lighting is used adjacent to these residences, these effects will be reduced as a result of the proposed mitigation measures. Comment: Resident is concerned with the hours of operation relating to night lighting and the height and number of light poles in the Sports Complex area. Resident requests that measures be taken to miti ate the impact of night lighting from the Northeast fields on the residences on the north side of Slater Avenue. Commentor(s): Kurjan (15, 16) Response: As described on page 3.13-3 of the MEIR,the ni ht lighting component of the Sports Complex element has been esigned so that light emit te� from the structures will be directed towards the center of the Sports Complex,away from the residences. The night lightin component wil I utilize directional fixtures that will minimize glare on the surrounding residents. The reflectors are designed to redirect all upward light downward to the playin�surface, eliminating the "sky glow"effect and dramatically decreasing the offsite spill light. a height of the pores relates o the ability of the reflector system to re-direct the light. The higher the pole, the more downward the beam of light is projected. The proper downward angle allows the reflector system to work properlv and hide from direct vision the light sources. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-31 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EI R IR TCI 1096-004.I NT RECREATION Comment: To avoid confusion, it is su gested that the term "bike trails" cited within the MEIR on page 3.15-7 be replaced within tie MEIR with the term "bikeway", so as to not confuse trail (dirt) and bikeways (paved). Commentor(s): County (5) Response: The term "bike trail" was used to describe both Class I and Class II bike facilities, which is consistent with the description of these types of facilities in the Circulation Element of the City of Huntington Beach General Plan (1996). Comment: The term "equestrian trail" utilized on page 3.15-8 of the MEIR should be replaced with the term "multiple-use trail". It is likely that hikers and mountain cyclists may also use these routes. Commentor(s): County (6) Response: The Recreation and Community Services Element of the City of Huntington Beach General Plan 0996) provides a section titled "Equestrian Trail System" under which it is stated that"the City maintains approximately two miles of horse trials located in Huntington Central Park." The description of these facilities on page 3.15-8 of the MEIR was worded to provide consistency with the General Plan. Please refer to Clarifications and Revisions section page 3.15-8 for revisions to the descri tion of equestrians facilities for Harriett M. Wieder Re ional Park Huntington Beach, Calivornia. As described in the Harriett M. Wieder Regional ark General Development Plan and Resource Management Plan 1997 Update prepared by the County of Orange,trails designed to accommodate equestrian uses are referred to as"riding/hiking trails.' Comment: It should be noted the Santa Ana River Regional Riding and Hiking Trail is a multiple-use trail and not exclusively equestrian. Further the trail planned through Harriet M. Weider Regional Park and linking to Huntington Cental` Park is a multiple-use trail. This trail's full name is "Huntington Beach Regional Riding and Hiking Trail". The MEIR should reflect this information. Commentor(s): County (7) rTesponse: Please see Clarifications and Revisions section page 3-15.7 which has integrated the titles of these facilities. Comment: The MEIR should discuss how Huntington Central Park and Harriet Weider Regional Park will link to their respective trail and bikeway systems. It has become commonplace to provide basic amenities, such as "horse-height" buttons, at locations where a trail is needed to cross a public roadway. Commentor(s): County (8) Response: Please refer to Clarifications and Revisions section page 3.15-10 which describes a "horse- height" button which has been installed at the intersection of Edwards Street and Ellis Avenue. Comment: The Commentors feel that multi-purpose trails can accommodate recreational needs and the aesthetic appearance of the community. In addition they feel that there is diminishing space available in the City and that demands for Central Park are increasing. The Commentors suggest expansion of existing trail system to a multi-purpose trail system to eliminate impact to other uses. It is suggested that the provision of horseback riding facilities in the Park as well as existing special events including running events can expand tourists' interest in the area. Several benefits of multi-purpose trail systems are provided. Examples of how multi-purpose trails are integrated with other recreational amenities in the area. Further, the Commentors provide sspecitic suggestions for how multi-purpose trails can be developed in the Park. The Central Park Trail Committee would like to meet with and be an active participant in the Central Park Master Plan of Recreational Uses (the names of committee members were included in the response letter). Commentor(s): CPTC (2) Response: At the time that the"urban forest"element of the Master Plan is developed into a more detailed project level element, the comments provided by the Central Park I Trails Committee will be taken under consideration. Comment: Resident notes that the Sports Complex plans are misleading in their description of the 8 lighted softball fields and 8 soccer/football fields. This description does not mention that the fields overlay and can only be utilized eight at a time rather than sixteen, which the plans could unintentionally indicate. Commentor(s): Kurjan (3) Response: Please refer to pages 2-7 and 2-8 of the MEIR for a description of the potential configurations for uses of the sports fields. Table 3.15.3-1 on page 3.15-12 of the MEIR was developed for use in the traffic analysis. A portion of the table was omitted in error and has been updated in Clarifications and Revisions section page 3.15-12. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-32 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041 EI R IR TCI 1096-004.I NT Comment: Resident concludes that the reduction of open space outlined on page 3.6-18 for the Boy Scout Camping Event is not beneficial to the City. Commentor(s): Kurjan (7) Response: This area is used for youth camping events more than once a year. The Boy Scout Camping Event itself occurs approximate ly once a year. Comment: Resident requests specifications regarding the improvements that require paved services in the Consolidated Camping Area. Commentor(s) Kurjan (8) Response: Additional paved surfaces created for the Camping Area included parking bays adjacent to the access road and walks to the new restroom facility in order to accommodate accessibility requirements. The existing paved access road shall remain and will be maintained for re-use under this area's consolidation. 12.3 LETTERS OF COMMENT Following this page, copies of letters commenting on the Draft MEIR and responded to in the matrix above have been provided. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 12-33 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EI R IR TCI 1096-004.I NT OF �-5. Comm n-&, DE=T VII cJJ 01 1u.Uu 0u 441 y 0 1 a I'Wb 13A-0 :"WU 1J.S Fish one wiial::c Service CA Dc'.. OfFsh& G—e Carlsbad Fish xsd Wildlife Office 4949 tiiEVT1QEC Ave= 2730 Lai-Avmue,W= S=Di=Caiii=i-921%'-1662 Caiacad,Caiiforua 920o6 - (619)467-4201 (7b0)431 FAX(6:9)467-42 5 FAX 7,6C)431--,m_961 a Mary Seth Broe.--..a APR 2 3 l�cn Suer P!san,e; City of Hut tfi�Beach Planning Dcpa= :t 2000 Main Stye t-,3fe t'iflol P.O. Box 190 H,+�g-ton Beach, C i'�l'�92648 R--: Doi Maw R=viro=cm=al Impact R=ort fire :Plan of R=cr__tioa liter,or Central Park,City of lq=L;r�Bea-- California DeuMm nroa-= Wf-- the Fish and Wildli.:5:Sc7vicr(Sem: )and California Dcparcm3t of-:sn and Crj= (De-,ar=mt). a=:"'.Qax-C'P oprto IIIl'I�+ to=rn,,t O=the re!=?MC_:1 &3f:C�1rOII.=G.^�L31 i=aa report(DELR) and assor.:=ed proiecm We fltrthher aamec amm tha:you agreed to c=---d the deadline for comments unn't Amu 23. 1999,per a telephone conversaaion with Loren Fiat's of the Service. The Sc:+i=did not==ive the dcrrm=umil April _`. 1999. Per the DEIR,the prvpczed projeu eor•---t of nine e'':tl�'�includes a sure complcy a rna;n%==Ce ysrd expansion, outdoor ausic camsolidated C=Dine =es, low irsL eery sre- rstcd.':^area, omen force,semi-ardvc r 3on area, lake gouty;ac:iity, and polic���viiisn Fun rar�Qe G� Coalmeuts Buse the National Ervironment;l Polity. Act CT it'--1,S=don 102G)re-wires that"ail e3ez:rra of tl,,.n:deer C-overnme�t sas1l..�alG ev :1 le:o ��s, cound�,mr icipaii�es._ Z advice and=fm=cm>Lseful iu resterin&^3inta4. and=han=g tee qua-117 of the c=svir==—t"and be=use the Fish and Wildliir Servire mz}+have stattaory 1r`-�TTI jtna� :-thorny Qv a.-tb`subje--projeey we one•for your corgi pion t:er fm haulm¢general=d sper fic cotazrC= The primary ocnrxm aeri-,,nryiA-r of*.he Service is the yrot=don of;ubhc =sa and-iic!ife t�ourcrs aid tL--z habit=. 0=mandstas tumt er rrt uim-d=-.''c p r-ride coral;c'^...J cm =Y pt•=nc:ice issuer for a Fere:al pcmit err l; —, tnc aaaon's wa1L.S (c g, s-^��n 40� =0�1 T', 0; H2 C3,rim pG.1 LC=T ra:, rJO. _ - .cw HPr. __ _C_O Q_.__P�� r_ ui' e..; UU 10:vu ;ou iJl MOTS tyfary Beth Broeren of the Cl=z Water.act and won I0 of Riv==ii Harbar< 3 Apprvpration A La of i 899). T'nc Servic: is:Iso rs onsble far_dmiaisz--mg the i mr dad Tr:=y Ac:(M^T A).B ell �-7e Protection Act, and Eadaagsad Species Ac.of 19,3 as amended(Ac:). Spc,incal.ly, Section i o:the Am requiz-Federal ag=cies to consult with the S---v,ice shcte dd a be d- tinrd that th--s dise==my may affect a lid tiv-.,arcned or e-daa;e:..3 spe;ies. During the;e curu assessment or rwiew Frocas9,the agency may engage in pianrzig e=ort; but rosy not make any kr--ve:sible c-,=niitmeat of,-wourc=. Such a ccm,,,i== =uld c:nsarurc a violation of Section 7(a7 of tLe Ac-- If a listed spe=ies may be affe_,td icy any �..ru,by a:�--al ?-rd agcn-cy,the auency shaald coata.&-ota office,in vm L-!-.and res?uetsr formi cor:suitation pu=umt to Samna?of the Act ln&Tmal consultation may be u5ad m cxchtnige informanon and resolve ct:auic=pnor to a NkTittea reRust for foc=zl consultation. I Section 9 cf the Act prohib-its the "mkine" of f=L—_.i'iy er�'hmeercd wildlife. Ti aidag ire.]"ei "hares", Which may`.^luck dcsauction of nec`sary babitat os disruption of bre dins or fee L= � be iariors. Tak:incidental to otherwise lavvfvl ac:ivitiea can be authoriy by the provi_zions or I C ;adaa 7 of the A<(if Feral jarria-di on,funding or perr r ,applies) or section 10 of the Ac:(when thou is no demonsz-axed:e.-_-al nexi1 The lacer section requires the deve_-'opm=t of a babiraz con_se.-mdoa plan. T�Depard=I,=a trusts r eacy cad;the Ca-1;o.-=Faviratmmentsl Q'ur L ity Ac-, (CEQA), and pt:rsuaat to won 1802 of the Fish and Crane Cad:,is rponsiblc to ass.:e tux a-proem consmar on and m22nagmnarrt of fish and x ildlife resoLzcas. Pursuam to secricr,2050 e:sea. of the Code,we are responsinle for the California Endanee.-ed SpeL:ics Act(CP&A). l� ,A-lso,purest to ration 1600 es seq. of the Cod=,the Depmnent is responsible for ad-mistering zgr==c=ft for acdvitics that affect l 6v=, s tti.s:d associates npauan haoi=s. Based upon the iniormarioa in the DETSR and our casre=t 3=owlede2 of pt:blic fiNh anc wiiall-fe :-sources with the--azdy axs and env= s,we conc!uce ti=the project will fJ1 whi in our: rive jurs ctions as deed by Federal add Stain law becsyse o=proposed iznv c=to a va ity of r,noLic f--h auri wua'tife habitats dad s---=in.and around juasr=ctioT, �- warv-s of the United StaTrs.We Rather canclade taut src::s of the proiec:eL-nerts,:s FroDoscd.may result in inc-c **Tlerrly mirigated or unnaitignm unpacts w vegCs d j%aisdicdonal weJm:ds or wat—of the United States and seve-1 sensitive wildlife species, including. I pote tially,prole-__c i migrrsory birds and lissed, eacang=d spec. We maintain :hat the proposed project,Whigs will be built on pardons of 357 acr=oflarg y open spa=l=ds adia=t to the Bol.sa Chica We-dands,v.0 significantly alter tb`ecology and fi-n=or.of The Hunting n Central Par✓W ede<Reesonal PsrluSolsa Chica Wetia-,k regional wildlifc amz- ce proposed proj=may result m dire.or roots+ -, ad effects to four Stn:e and fed..-.ally endaneered Sz c ca;thr-Caiiiornia lea_ Lem(&rrna anrillcrm brown:; "t='), per-eg=,e falcon D (Fairs peregrinzu,, 1.vt Bell's.vireo(Vireo bell i pusillus, `Yirro'�, and soa:h%v=cs glow 10 fIycrc e:(LMpidor_-rra.f lri e=imus; "flyc'a=r' "). In addition, the white=mile..••' ldx(.lams leu.:r-us), tricolors blackbird(Agalaitu rricolar;, Cooper's haws(Acc z7ira ccno;�rri;), =e r. rl - T• pr H DC:i C --- �c .n -_ cCc ^ C_ =C r B. C r^rt GE=T A;, rip. ,�� -� ^pr• - -- per:__� i ua,cJ/'JU le.:%) P1t i0u i•,l Vole '^�-�1tiL�DtL rrU �JUu4 Mary Betio Broe:ea f loggclrvti slmxe(Znnizcr ludovicimrus), all California Species of Spz_ial Conc::n may ix au cted. If the project is regulated by the Army Cons of Engint--c-s, we.k i ask thaT agency to consult vidm the Scnzce forpotearial advr---c effect to listed specs —1 .0f to Le to we initiaaen of reaia-a1*r+mimtq processes Although the DEIR discloses the potcatial for somc imp;ri to sensitive haam ats and wildlife in the proposed project area and environs and movides for gc=-a_�, as yet largt?y unsspe^ncd mitiggdonmessures to address p:oje:t r_letsd incpacz to these res=ces,nn r-ous armarett excismcros or e:.-crs=pe r in the document Dulr T-n-c._Tlc mire:• ea ,which add;--as these 63R'C0arxiCS and oriuSsions and=atom swage coons W reduce =pacts to Us-zed and sensiIIve soecies, fallow. Spec Cogent S The smte i purpose of the document is to assew the"_. virotsLz=p"a1 cC wequ=c es of the pmposed Master Plan of IL---nation Uses for Hur=gto„ Cer—a1 Park...."(DEIR,page S 1). According to the DEM(page 1-2,p=zgmph 4), of in^==res'lting from the proposed irnprovcmeai9 within the Masrc Plea ws con&u--zd at—.o (_)levels of detail witch the Master EIR, 1)Project Level and 2)P:ogr=Lzvd." The DEIR conui-as descripd=of at lest 6 individual projcot e!e==ts that colle-_'vt?y+tans ==Modincr:Projcc: 4a;the pre=cd pwj=t(DEIR,page 1-2). Howeve!,the general wildlife survey::.--e conducted dtuing winter(DEER,page:.7-a)(dlaing which time the t=,f yrztch_:, and vireo and many otbe_sensitive apcaies are on tie wintering grounds in Latin A=cxic_) an::aaL-c usta sus for these or other listed and spe::es have not been do`s uad atper n-dy will not Ce done until prior to the cnmtn�*r_�-n!-�t 02 CA^. 4tI11G�0I]dC1vtQC5 QT'�"ltr tD ' Ov1II� :OIwL'S.' withprogam lave?elerncm (I)EM,page 5-11).Tact=ter_,; ram iarDa m che_-e evees cannot,of raurse,be disclosed nor x==1 riatzy maid awed pc C�Q s r�ili.��.dl Although it is acimowleiged ttzat project-re.ated;m^-cts cau d result in incest iapac-s to s.�vz bird spa=,cs,=pttorz,the virea and Ilycatz�w(DFTR,page S-11),th:x Lmraes have=t berms specifically ids:rifir-d awess�',or disclosed in coni=czion wi,-;.,a r-�rajc:-;Ic�c! -view. Tbetufare,we canclnde that the conside.-asion or promosed i:=le: eta Lion of-,�o individual project,e?e=aents will requite further CEQA review dad the sapropr_to is:losu.-aca miti_acan of impacts to sensitive and listed m=.; s. Pre-cm=mcson surveys(DYE page S-11)do not coir;firl taitigation measures nor tin. as yr'tmsdc-ard moeincations:h mdi•idiom:.oj : el=aat cL-scimions should listed or sensitive recces be cocas. (e_g., DED,,Page S-i t, WltiMlion Measure I). Althoagn we wM c mngmt tenon forthco=ng CEQA doeum=;oat aadrss=:,viduai Project claaeaa awoeiatz--4 with the Mast=Plan,wt would lase to pcitn scYaai acpartnt eraor3 is ti;e prestut DER. For b==a, althovan it is stwed ihst tr--n hzs not be=re-_nr et from Htinn-ton Coral Paris, Service biologists have repeatedly derma 4 the species in the proie-ar-_(F:eesc we srsc'ad letter dated July 8, 1997 to the City of Fi�-ton Beams ze=: t:ie de:cloy rrt �p of a Specific Plan far Huntingten CtTal Pik, which we include as past of oc.:commeats). P!ense note also tbat the fyc=her ir,a federally &--dam Bred species as-eU as S=e (Dl page 3.7-15). In addition, contrary to the wsction in the DI-yrZ hawks r-nd=tly bred in the paz during 1998, as iccc.-d by the presc=cc c 7 s fic igiiag a' j F�Ori _-17. OF ~B, CCriri DE) DE=T ra;, rtp. _7_ __•_TP'•1 P� • •. -:L:.'e '�.u t'1.i vv y,._ :tl: rn�-�.'.!(L.`.tlrlll `!+U t41UUS Mary BeIL Broc.= b proL-ctive aauit The ores anpartntly mapped as non-native ga:slaud in rht a2sttarn portion al the paid(I)FIR,Figure:.7-1)asmrally is z pit ofTalbc.,Lake. The=lea rn-.ped as ggasslard is 1 CD now lady under war=,which is of=tb`case dunng non-sz:mmr:months. We:ecoma*_--d the refln=ent of th:map to re-flect this fact and to d_-pic t�_-=-Lent cf woodland in ail:seas of the peak including,in pamcal3,-le Lann s-=ed areas. Although wo note had a=--that"...native g12nt coc=unities have be-n largeiv been el;** Tj_-d is the Paris by past land use-___"(DFM 3.7-3),the vegetation that rem:zrs continues to providee ha7==for,in psrticaIar, an e^-aordinarp gray of avian wudlife (see arrz:he�lettrr)_ Although,the riparian vege ariea in th c park has been ciasssifled As m the DEM this habitat type,in w3oeiation with the 'uu for=st"wmpon=:_i in the c=eptiona.ily wcIl- ccnc.-ivad "laacscapee':r-..s,c=:dnu=to scrosmodate z diverse breedig sviiauna and Jearl grvvid�cover and Enraging asicrohabitats for one of tt::=2s docameuted eonc_—Jaaaou_ of migratory birds in CaLiz-amia or t}se'U itrd Stars a a whole. To preserve this cctmordi==7 reso��,we ask that the pmject be : csie=ed to 1)preve`t o: minitmze to the extent aoszfale tbz proposed loos of ap p*ox+-r+A1p,'y 350 cic.^es of M- 1 or potantial�•s7dlife habitat, ir-cludi:ng 12 acts of zz dCually riparian woodland habitat and 2)avoid itapac-.ing the diverse and sensitive avifsma found than i ne Cky of Huntington Beach has,to the best of our lmowiedge,not cmpiied with as order issued by the E�viroamatai Pro=don Agency 20 res,,ore ripad=hab=- =in desig;at4 Tatbe-.Lake wed and sot:h and east of the Jack C:'e=Namm A.-e& nis issue must be stc=sfully resolved prier to tn-- isszmnce of Z State or F�--a1 peziits that would impart vegzatc"wudmds and-vale=at,his site. To assist the City in re= ingg thcsc=buz s anz to provide additional habitat for migratory bir i,the Service, City staff, anal th=Mavor Dr.Vicaor L piiz sought and t VC ?-�A_t-share grant to fund ri_uariaa attd woodland resaor.alion efccrts. k aougi the sum of`i 10,000 for purpoxs of revegetaticn and the cmaal of exotic plants is sill available to the City,the in—nt mmi*es at the gad of this calendar year. The prnjec.-tti=ed desaacdou of 68 (of the 72 available)a zr:=of V=sisads (DE R,pap 1.7-45)eant:ib=es tc the ongoing,--give depie:ion of zis hebirat:ype in souther a CaUfarnia.As is rcilzeted is the DER(e.g pore S-11),this habitat type providcz imporant foraging habitat for:ammm(birds of pray)in particular and is part of the relativeiy intact ecowstem of the rezian. Given the paucity and ever_ie,.. " abundance of nxtor forszia; habitat wid is tar =south..=California,the aBtsremly termiugared loss of 658 acr—_ of this habitat type(and the loss of 49 of 5! aces of"bamrrade-ai"habitat)should be consid_=d a .-a=t hnvact. We the=.ft=r.,..atamend thrs the project be drsiu ed to myni*ni im- - to this habitat type and the spces dcpcideat th=on.=Iuding the w•hitr-tailed hate. If area-,res are nut or cannot be tau=to raidgare y=jet-_rciatra impa&_—to gassiands on-site, then we stlggger.th.=efforts are unoertak=to CzinscTve or restore habitats off-site and to mitlgaze w•tat we believe to be sigo.>tesat, adverse impacts to the zffircied_pccics. Ibis could done,in past, by contff=ting to non-profit agencies and enzhics commined to the cone-'vaaor- Jt 3G51tive hale d—a=im3 zagtor spec Although the DER rural.-tarsi mitigacea will be doac to offi et pronect-indi.;ed F�QFI 1. -(T, OF H2, COriri DE I JE=T F,:;x NQ. Apr. -- looC 04:4GPM P5 �s UU 441 bOlO ejU08 NLiry Beth E oer cn S loss=to ripar m and gesai=d habitats,no assuraac=ar_made to parc -dic s-azc ssful rcatortdca of habitat values and functons. In addition,ahhaueh it suggested that"(p]otential =pacts to f—Qing babirai for ravtors resulting from d_YEoum=t of nna-native pm9i=ds in the Panic could be mitigated by mhaaczing mder-L�areas at a ratio of 1.1..."OEM,pag=S-11), it is 1Me disclesed Th21 appro y 49 of the=d.e'tutg SS aces of rude:ziibare ar=u w-11 be impatca by the proposed project eleaicnts(DEIR,pag:3.7-43). In this-regard, the-=-QA 1---d a.gent:y rimot dew=zalysis of the feasibility of sacs a (miti gationj pronosai until a lame:tug, such as during yut-to-be cau menc d fe ms].and scam pc.-=i proccsses"Cle te.with leg�L Deputy Attorney General.Psn=soa w the County of Riv=sidc, l)G-C:nbc:20, 1990). We recommend that the:unction and integrity of=sdng sensitive habitas and wildlife on public Iands be;mote---tci from g;a;c-z;t-z=iattd impacts by bufe:iag dies: Isnds,to the e=ent poss.Cole,from the proposed pmjc,-t sitts. Tao construction of aPwVP--LTM phYILMI bzrrics.tic establishment of prudent btxF5, s, and implemeatadon of ecologically sound land=d prone:-.y msaag ae3t pmcdces likely wed reducs the iin=. s to sensitive habit=that inevitably oerar as a result of the adj aceat canSM%'^tion, opcMbon,and mainreaancc of land de reiopmerm These unpa=include,bat arc not limited to,Umm=&noise,an incensed and the grolife-=atiaa and spr-A:mg of exotic piaass'and tmimaLs. 7=lattr:,which.inclad--�;foal c=and non-native routs,have been eoaelusively implicated in ti;decliinc of ntaa-ous:.ativc wfdlife species. To redvrs these poted=i itapa.^s,we rrammend 1)t ze cltut-:ing of all F;oi ec: clemcat9 on lends with the least wildlife habitat value(e._., es-tensiyeiy:n=c.Lred areas i'amc.'amiy adja,c�i to existing f u liti.c5,2)the tLse of=iiieid--,- directed agii i_:.g (o.no lighting at all)and 3)landscaping t mrK,---:Ergc!y, not=r-r: Y,of= nts Ztive pla Gay Tyoldz,e=znsive lawns,and othg are=wirb =aniwared,non-native gasSms provide p iLe forazi g I-;- Zor the brood-par-stsitic brown-Iuade:i cowbird(a,folodLrus,=rT-'a species z3= has==-°d tr==Ammly in numbers in--=6c n•Cahfbr is eoa--jmtant'%itb the antbropoflezic altcati=o:the land--=zo- Cowi-srds are widesexsd oblieacc mc=parasites =.d have drus dossed the Ieprodm :ive productivity of the end=+-e►ed vireo,flr;zw- and �P a miesous o*xr song'oird se:c:s "^out sots CZ&mia Because Ibis s;c es has bcW coded w caved tan to 3 mil=b`:wc=their fvrzging(feeding)areas and breeding locales, individual wwoirds could be expel in easily commute between all portc=of the prole:t erea mall hrciimg habits m the park and the adiaceat Boba C3ica wctlands. Bcc=e ao known, e ve Quay=,-u m co bits from tailizing fcraging habitats c:=xed by the wnstr=tioti,operation,and ma:,,+, mn.—c of c=ansive sassy lawns or fields we suggcs that a cowttird abat==program b: developec,and imaiemcnted to preclude possible projem-reiared .=. to the vira, fly catchc, or:ny se-hive songbird ape:=that b, with►n five hilts of the projec-t site. We tick you in adva=e for your cooperation in assuring the apz=—Jar cater atioe of �cad d wildlife Lbit=Sad full}prot�-'med spe e_. Our conun—t5 are irmtended to • exsist you in thr dcY--lr:,. =t of m tigntion m=smres to;.revert trap:.==to Iced soeca=, protect migatory birds and other ash and wfl&fe re-ou mcs. We reccmzn-end ttac the project i incorporate additional auiigzdoa m=m-m-a as specified or su„ages:d above to*rrvct ad"cz-5c =pry OF N? COmrl D�! DE=T F ,H>, r4p. . -� _ 1�-�3 Apr. _Z 19F _ ._'-r1 P , 1 i• i / :V VJ I',A • VV •w.6 CV:•J 1 "J-`�:.2\L�:JAL 1'�'V E+JVVI May Beth Brocza 6 =pem to sensitive habitats and a 1wiac array of protected or sensrve sp.ies IM tte pmjc=area and environs. W:wouid,a=m-_c ate the cppor,mucy to assist you in the zvgard. indic-ated above,we wdl Comm x oa MIM"vidual pmje::,,eiemc=once thcsc have been Q-:ir d, ispacts hz-ve bl-- =azaiy�,and so=,,fc mitgat:an=V-b,--..n pmposd Plc`-c awl free to Cs1 Lori Heys or the Fist and WEdY Sen ice at 760-43 i-9440 or Lam Davit of me CaiLbrnis J Dcpar=czt of:ish and Gfmr e:619-467-4-2.07 should you desire additicnsi i foir..arion or c?-�ian of o=comments. Sinc=eiy, ,T=A Bartel i++AL=Tipper U Assistant Field Suae:visar Faoix Con=a-vadoa Sure-.visor U.S- F'Lh and Wildlife Spice Dc=r=c=of-1sh and Came Mayor and City Caunai, City ofHuntinum Bey US.A=v Corps of F-m2ine=(Ar= Re2uLvo-Branca) Bnvirar. .l ?rote-on Ag=cy, Re-ion 9(.k= Roo Le:dy) C-j=- rnia Dc=zrtrrcat of Fish and Gamc (At= L==Davis) F=Cri C i T' of HS, COMM DE°.j DE=T �' . _ C -- �s - _S �4 -,�!y It:UJ r.S4 .ou 4J- bo10 •, rt0 �J °r :ace :=�Pr1 po United States Depar=ient of the Interior isri AND wIIDL.==s-av1C7r, -y Eco+a�1 Scvicz Csrst Field Ofix: Lokes AVMM was Catsa�.C,:lixa^�4:^A3 July S, 1997 Mr. Tun B. Engle Deputy Dlr�r Comrzmnity SeMc Deraraneat Gty ofHuntin ten Beads 2000 Mam Sys Hu--tinatoa Boncb, Gr fumip,92648 Re: Specific Plan for Hundagma C=rrai Park Dear Mt.Enec IN-ark you for ycur Ie=dazed ,-sf, 16, L99 i, regarairg the pr oposcd c„-ve�ocmens of a Spe_if-c Plan for Ce:sttal Parr H a^4cn.Sctc^.� OtanSe Cti^uury, CaUcraiz pc: yo.r 1e:te:, tre Ciry of F-uW:ngton Beata has ey:ge_4 d ;Onsailarg(5 Xa,hos to hei, =-iea the Spec Plan and to prepa= =vironmeat l com-Eance documecu=orL Gwen the exte:r,, location, and or-�*+-a os we*:L-j:d area aoodiL3.*1c hai zs in F*** ==n Ce rjzl Paris and cur spec k=owledge of the biota cal saanm.-s tha^.in, the Service anprejares the op pomary to r,5Lq the C* of Fum6ngton Bears is aci:, eaviroaasernal ccin?nznca curing the d 3-p.mar and imnie_ne:ztation cf the?!=We fusthe :o ddemify need xa:a-le the large and i=;cro=n_Carr-1 r=cnrce base that L- conisind wi- ,w the P;rt Berm of the d==sr=ed, wry&h aad wildlife resour-ts.than are P,ttsent in F•won a Ceot-al Pyk aad t$e adjac= Bola Chits, Finn and Wildlife Se ice bloiom= eve=d=--aken various and pe:snoal smd=of th-biorm=those local= Given a rcmposite of the results of s=-cu cz,we conclude that trap relative ab=dance of wcdamd and wc:)diA^a veacion close to I the coat nppmrady m ttpons�31e,m parac ul-sr, for regionally unpre---�dc=md densities of migratory bird✓ m F=n=gtan Cc=al P31z The wMow-domm ted wetl3ads on: a tan side of the park a:e, in particaiar, a phenotnmal draw for migratory birds. There were, for i-st-nce, over 400 sat:sha-d rrigraras dere--cd the:a on May 13, 1994. Ovc-A marc than 275 spe::er of birds.azve been dete.c--d m fnrscsgtan Ce=%1 Park irciidmg the federal and states -lifted, c dangcd prrrinc=icon, brown pelican, and Calimrnia least t-"n. In ads:-rive, smz= :.ad nOrttinglnng birds showing the cha ac:r..st cs of the en-dangeed 1— Bell's vireo have sisa been re.e=erTy dztc=:d in the park F illy,the cast re-= of the am=y wuu-1cw flycatchers=or&--4 is ti:e park w-a.s date_aed s:n2ing is vegetative ac ac t to Fumdagton Lake on -fay 10, I497. W-low fly==c ers breeding m sauthwestern Cal orn a are federally-listed sad s=e-ldsted u end=gc d OF yB. COrvi DE" DE?T Fes;: No. ,1 :5-srj Ar,T. _Z 19T— 0-1:SPr.l Pa ld:u4 Yk3 7UU 4.11 9616 F;U Qooe Mr. Jura Engle '— Igor". =and regianally scarce habitats rr_rescared within the park izciude riven=woodland and freshwater marsh H+mfim.) r' Lake and emvirors (lndudinst the aria scuth---z of the Jack Green Nam-am sea) eantrin s-ec; areas that have been id=rd ed as a ju=isric:ional Wetlard by the E-vironme_ntal Proteacuon Agency. Gncr ac*q th-� you for the aoporrmk,-v to parddpate in the pL.mmng yroc:ss a_soc ated with the deve;optrt= of s Soec.-ic Plan fcr CCe=sl Park P!eue S---'E=to chi.:ar or Loren Eays of my sty at 760-431-9440 &Euth=iniormaEon or&-mL-== Six`ely, ' an �.cia C.Kuoctich F e?d 5 aperrisor c Saoohos En„a,,o„e=al ' 5. 15 Department of Toxic Substances Control Edwin F. Lowry,Director 5796 Corporate Avenue _ winstoa li Hicrox Cyp--.ss. Caiiforcta 90630 •(rav Davis St_^ttsr,, for Govc nor E_.v�orsnental Froc-r_uon April 7, 1999 Ms. Mary Beth Broeren Senior Planner City of Huntinston Bcach Pldnnin; Department P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beacl-4 California 92648 REVIEW OF "DRAFT NLASTER EN—VIRON?N2EI T3L IMPACT REPORT FOR MASTER PLAIN OF RECREATION USES FOR CENTRAL PARE;., CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA, DATED FEBRUARY 26, 1999 Dear Ms. Broeren: The Department of Toxic Substanccs Control (DTSC) has rcviewed the abovc-m--itioned report received on March 29. 1999. DTSC pc.;ormcd a focused review of Section :.9 of the ? rcoort. Enclosed are DTSC's comments. If you have any ouestions regarding this matter please call Michaci Edwards, P.E. at (714) ;8=-5474 or me at (714) 484-5461. Sincurely, Greg Holmes unit Chief Southern California Cleanup Oprations Branch A cc: Mr. Tumid Saebfar Branch Cnief Southern California Clcanup Operations Lta.nch A Department of Toxic Subs-,.ances Conrol 1011 Grandview Avenue Gic--idale, California 91201 Califorma!::nvuc===rs!Protection Ag-tcy e�Primtcd on Rccycicd Pair ' r COMMENTS ON "DILA.FT MASTER ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT FOR '.MASTER PLAIN OF RECREATION USES FOR CENTRAL PARK, CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, Ca, DATED FEBRUARY 26, 1999 C,n�menrc 1. A geophysical survey should be performed to detect possible buried drums, tanks, or piping. Z The park was historically used as a dumping ground before present hazardous waste control 1au s. 2. The Phase I Assessment performed by National Assessment Corporation identified some forme:sites alone the eastern portion of the site in which wastes were dumped and buried, including drilling muds, petroleum products, and solid wastes. Other sites similar to this have been found to be contaminated with heat•y metals, polycycUc aromatic bydrocarbors, and 3 polychlorinated biphenyls. Neither the boundaries of the former disposal sites nor the boundaries of dumping are defined in the report. These boundaries should be clearly defined and evaluated through subsurface investigation A preliminary endangerment assessment (P.E4) should be completed to screen the site for these possible contaminants and the associated potential human and ecological health risks. You may contact DTSC for more information about the PF A4 process. F 3. A forme: shooting range is located just north and up gradient of Sully. Mille:Lake. This I shooting range was operational from the late 1960s to 1997. The target area may contain a lame quantity of lead bullets and bullet f;a,_nents. This area shou.id be screened for lead contamination. If Si--Mificant lead contamination is found, a PEA should be wormed. An ecological and human health concern is that runoti from the former gun range could contaminate surface water at Sully Miller Lake. Birds, fish, and other acuatic orsanisms could be affected. Also, any people who fish in the lake and consume these fish may be at risk. Leachate from former dumping and buried wastes and runoff from the cxisfing transfer station are also of concern, in that water at Sully Miller Lake,Huntington Lake and Talbert Lake,may be impacted_ 4. Oil drilling and pumping has also taken place within the parx. Areas in the vicinity of these former oil wells should be evaluated for petroleum product spills and drilling rnud disposal pits. Also, frequeally used maintenanc-c areas should be identified where chemical spills and dumpins may have occurred. Any subsurface investigation at the park should also include s�npline for methane gas, a potential hazard associated with both landfills and oil fields. C LA ,i STATE OF CALIFORNIA—BUSINESS AND TRANSPORTATIONqPp, AGENCY / /9 to,, GRAY DAVIS. Govcmoi DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION -o DISTRICT 12 2501 PULLMAN STREET y' SANTA ANA.CA 92705 eFaz April 6, 1999 Mary Beth Broceren File: IGR/CEQA City of Huntington Beach SCH m: 97091007 2000 Main Stroct DEIR Huntington Beach, California 92648 � Dear Ms. Broceren: Thahk'you for the opportunity to review and comment on the Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) for the Huntington Central Park expansion project. The proposed project consists of expansion of Huntington Central Park which is located in the City of Huntington Beach: bounded by Slater, Gothard, Ellis, and Edwards Streets. The 1 proposed project is to improve 136 acres of undeveloped and 7.5 acres of existing developed area. The project includes construction of a Sports Complex: improvement/expansion of the consolidated group campground, outdoor music area, trailhead, police/civilian oun range, semi-active and low activity recreation areas, Sully Miller Lake Group Facility and the maintenance yard. Caltrans District 12 is a reviewing agency and has the following comments at this time: Transportation/Circulation: The additional traffic generated by the proposed Sports Complex is expected to have a significant impact at the intersection of Goldenwest and 2- Slater. The city has included traffic improvements and mitigation measures in the DEIR to address this issue as well as air quality. It should be noted however, that the additional traffic generated by the project could impact 1-405, SR-39 (Beach Boulevard) and SR-1. The Short-term Mitigation Measures (Air-1 through Air-12) to be implemented during the construction phase are noted. Long-term Mitigation Measures in Table 3.5.1-2: Air 3 Quality Element Applicabie Objectives and Poiicies are also noted, however additional measures should be considered due to the additional trips that will be -1- generated by the proposed Sports Complex. Also, in order to remain below Congestion M (CI VA)Agency (CA) and Air Quality Management District (AQMD) thresholds for congestion the following measures should be considered: 1) Provide incentives to 3 encourage transit use to and from the complex (information, discounts); 2) Coordinate with local transit agency to improve or increase service if needed; 3) Consider shuttle service from designated area(s) (eg. park and ride, major retail, residential) to the complex during peak times; 4) Offer security level bicycle racks at convenient and safe locations. Please continue to keep us informed of future developments, which could potentially impact our State Transportation facilities. If you have any questions or need to contact us, please call Lynne Gear at (949) 724-2241. Sincerely, ROBER T ,>!OSEPH hief Advance Planning Branch Cc: Tom Loftus, OPR Ron Helgeson, HDQTRS Planning -2 of 2- NO. —o:�cx -pr Z)_ � California Rebion2l Water Quality Control Board Santa Ann Region wt°sto� - 1s+:Seo: :ntt�set Address: Geay pivu i e.erayJo. 3731 M:in!OWL SWIM SOU.Riw Mr-.C-IIlSrela 92'01-333V favvnniaewn( Pine M91 M-4130- FAX"I I4;.42n C—A-mmw ➢�oreet"` April 16, 1999 40et•4r`brand tax trans m7tai.Terno 767,+ 9 Ms. May Beth Bror-n T'S t`to-r+, Rom{ Br�s4van I— Cfia.�.e LsQ G Ciry of.Htmtii g n Best },� P1 i . t�l I�PL Pm+ww �J11 Sane 20% Mffia st ect, 31, floor 4 -, l ` P. o.sax 190 11=tington Beach, CA 92648 COl1 NMINTS ON"DRAFT MASTER F-NV ROIVWNTAL IMPACT REPORT (EIFt) FOR THE HLTN"MGTON , , A1.PARK.YLOSTbB PL4-1V OF RECILLATION USES" Dear Ms. Bmerem We have nevi--ed the "Draft Master DER for the Ht=6ng=n Ceara! Pars blaster P13-of R_.---e&bon Us=." As peat of the C--aa-.l f k r^....'ve•'a?acat.the CXV of Humington Beach is � proposing to construct a Sparte Cotaplex over�e City-awned ins..;vc Got -hard Strom:L:,ndfill. iae pzopos--d Sporn Ca=lex consists of= goo-span gravel p-arking lot. a bararg tee. up to four roll=ho:.1-ey rinks.eight lig u:softball field-,tight lighted soccer/fao:ball :ieids, two tat lots with accomplyiag shade-jucturas, and two l�savor>r'cc.��ioc ytliid'n:g9. Based umn our r view,we have the following coraments re•gr.:ding &.1•e Sports Corrmtex element of thr:masmr pl$a: 1. Fi„a1 rove-Svssem for Land I:Sg Change Area oytm Am lm=ti-m '•(�U-�t:8si Solid u;mme A final cove systt:m for the land use wage arcs over tan inEcave laedfi11, estxcI . tlL Z irrigated land use mma, shall be designed, cons",cte3,and maintas:-cid in accord..nee with scijon 21090 of Title 27 (copy enclosed) 7=d.-aft EIR des;.^~�, various alt_.--aove cover syst-,=to rninien=r wat±.r iavltraEon to wastes,and thus,redu::e potential ir=acts or. groundwater fnmm irrigation of th_ Sports Comply ltese tar nest-izd arid- yleacure Geology-] (a 6-foatmonollthic soil coves),Measure Geology-4 (a 4-foot monclithic soil covc), and Measte� Ha rd-5 (a coves corsi� of a synttle-sc geo membrane. gmtextile, a &-mi:-_re!.aye-., and a veaetsrave layer). Ca[ijornia Baviro►menial Protection Agency .I3 R`Ocied Paper . i Ms May Beth Broer'ea April 16. 1999 Ciry of Huntington Beach Planning Department In accordance with Simon 21090(a). t^.c R gion_1 Board may allow-.altc^..ztive fi z c:v^design if the performance. ectuvaleney of t}r-zIM--.=vc to th_prescnDa ve cove- 3 d_=ign m mu= i=& w31.0 inftitsaon i5 drmonst==L .ptzor Lo the development of the plans and specincsdoas for the commnxtioa of the Sports Compiex,the City musz propose and obtain anFmva3 by the Rgdoriai Board of the s.,-le='--d cover system. 2. S ' - Wa>:-rJScwc i_.incs i Ail tmdecground drain pipes. sewer linen,an-d oth,:. WM=iincs,Stich Zs the irrigation lines,to d be insstnned within the lam-dilll must be double-walled to provide secondary CL ' LR*T+"-1 in th--event of pipe leakage. T'nis chould be ac',drszed in the Plans and Speciscations fcr Lie i cons ru;..ion of the Sports Complex. 3. Testimg- Stara�,,gig Di3=sa': ofP=--ale Hvdtocaboa IPHC.-Contaminate-A Soil According to Sect=3.9.3, Pragc 3-9-9,_z=Xrnately 13,000 cubic;yards of FHC- contaminated soil,asroimted with the library pmidag lot expansion pmja,, were bioremediated,and up to 195,000 cubic yards of P:iC-contami=ied soil sill re---n4i at the site. T"he 13,000 cubic yard FITIC-crximmimt--soil was bior_me3iated in 1995. =d was&mosal l � of at the mushcmom;a.-m locat_d sourbwest of the landfii! site and StL3y lvfuie. Lake Ic February of 1999,Re Tonal Board staffmaducued a confirmation saranlie; of the soil. Tno an8lytical r--=Its indicate that the PHC ssiI has 6e3 remedmmd to level that would not pose a s�nih=t threat to neat:-quality. However, prior to public use oftbe biorcmediated sail disposal mva,t=near must be sufficie•atly covered with com?aved c.Icam fill as rct:otamcsded=the draft PD, We rec=mmrad that the biozr-mc-Aiwcd soli di=sal arc's be cuviced wWh at 1=-st one fDot of compac%rd c1C= MI. The draft E R proposers to test and d'isncse of the re-maining PRC-contaminmed soil howevc, it does not provide details on the testing procedures and disposaUcleanup=cia. 7I10 disposal or re-se of auy PHC-contaminated so=1 must be r-=mvCd by the R4oral Board and possibly other reguJatory ageacies, Sur.I as the Otaage County Health Care Agcey. L•ocrl E-mfor =:ie„t Agency. The City shall submit a PHC-costa im±ed soil disposal plan, dem0img the`=stm8 pro=&== storage. and disposal and cl=up crit=::ia or the PHC-co=%a—i--f— soil, for our apmovaL We look forward to reviewing the final Fitt and the Plans and Speci&--ons for the cors`^iction of the Soom Complex dement of the Mash Plan runs they become wvmmihlble. Caly'arnia EnvirDnmenral PrWrcIion, Cal Rep esa hpry ---I0N E a6CN_ Nc. 9e9 -6 -mac 23•3o?". r'3 Ms. ,glary Beth Brcc-ea April 16, 1999 City of H=.tim-,,wa Beach Pla=ing De^p.ar=eat I If you have any qu.�tions,please ;o=wc:Joa.-mc :.; of my saff st(909; 79=-'291, or you may cants:i=at(909) 782-3295. Singe!y, Dixie B. Lass, Chief Land Disposal Simon Eaclostae: Copy of Section 21090 of Tidz 27,California Code of!.egWaUor-a cc: O=e-. County In-7....ted Wass.N i:aagem.:n rr.mm ea[-Vicr w'ilson,"Kevin Kondru Orsa�c Cotmty H--L 4 C:.. Agcocy,L 4-?ani:is Hensnaw JPLZIc'�nic-:r.dtx Cafrjornia Faviran�+ie.�il?fosr�-s;oa f3e�cy �a ROO--1w Pop- to —oo-t , .NW."'r 6 119 9�� � SourHERN CALIFORNIA tit r, •r.1:n •'J LY � \ April 13, 1999 :rfu ASSOCIATION Of Ms. Mary Seth Broeren GOVERNMENTS Senior Planner Cry of Huntington Beach Planning Department main office P. 0. BOX 190 a:ca Wes-5evenln S:rce: Huntington Beach, CA 92648 .2-'n Floar LaS Ange+es.Cailfornla RE: SCAG Clearinghouse 19900118 Draft Master EIR for Master 90017.3435 Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Dear Ms. Broeren: We have reviewed the above referenced document and determined that it is not regionally significant per Areawide Clearinghouse criteria. Therefore, the project does not warrant 0 . L-k. ,^- clearinghouse comments at this time. Should there be a change in the scope of the project, we would appreciate the opportunity to 1 6..d.—...G:[. ..........C,...... :nets 1. ...... ;,�'�� review and comment at that time. �. �a o -• A description of the protect was published in the April 1, 1999 -r--�-- Intergovernmental Review Report for public review and comment. ._... 3u.oer•,.••MJ.wu.v ..mvena •�---�� The project title and SCAG Clearinghouse number should be used �_= �•---• _-tom in all correspondence with SCAG concerning this project. bR/O•ti,+••10w..,r.es..f.Lt•lO1N lG�L. Correspondence should be sent to the attention of the �.:�a.- .,... ..�>.s. Clearinghouse Coordinator. If you have any questions, please _ .: tie- �•�.. :- contact me at (213) 236-1917. :as;•c.•C •:ae M1.ee.. Rms:ds'k�� Sincerely, IeuT:Q FR.:.m Clta•Hatt WLR7..•� L•...:3 A tt'.IOa ass•.C._....� . L`r S,a°me" :m wnrr:n !a_ :llhea /. r:.:.awo[:•'•M Meu,.I..-,Ne.e.'.W..aYaP. J DA V I D S i i N I anager, Performance Assessment .nd Implementation a,,.,,•tr ter+.ore. .. _ .Iv u _ :Y QL, JOS:(' ia+..ns p�'`�"'*��' ^1,�i������— �•�J l r'`.�� ice/�;`i- FFL Ilv�N�j TF305�& THS t, "kt,� IY County of Oranba ,00 K "�aER sr. = Planning & Development Servacz Department �„�, ,,,�"��; uuLac aaaa:as Y0 a= Iui SAX-,A ANA CA .ZM-O&S APR 12 MS m•' s� FAX� 9.7+•tTT1 NCL 99-15 Ms. Mary Beth Broe:en, Senor Plane City of Huntington Beach Planning Deper=ent 2000 Main Stz Vo Floor P.O. Box 190 Hun-ineton B=ch, C.q 92648 SUBJECT: DM.EIR for the Htmringwn Ce=r.l P=.k Mauer Plaa of Rau: =cnal use, Dear Ms. Broerea: The above referenced r=a a Draft Master Eavi.ronme_—a inn:gin Report(DMEiR) for the City of Huntington Beach. The purpose of the proposed Maas--.Plan is m markedly improve the auaL'ry of the B--tingeton Beach Central Pak,improve the expo ict ccs of thosc using the Parma and es=iish typ:s of rwrcation uses for the v=w.t areas of the Parr. i to 370- ace site is bounder by Sias:r Avenue on the north,Goti•<rd Sur on the c:Wit, 1=11.is Avenue on the south, and Edwards Street on the west. Golden Wes eStrze. and;alben Avenue cur throueh the c=t=of the Panic. T:•te Comuy of Or.-nge has rcvicwed the DM-'-]R =d off=s the following coasrrreas: FLOOD 1. The subioat area lies within the watch d of Fast Gard=Grovc-W incersbur°Chmnel (raclity C05). Thr Fedcrmi E-zcg=cy Mann;==t Agecy (FERIA) and the County ofOt=¢e are studying flood hazards associwtd with East Cr=drnn Grove-winte:sburg Chrnnel as part of floodplain raoning e!:orts of the Samoa Ana Rive: (SAR). FE? A is antieipatw to=3n-^..te:esidual flood zones for Est Garden Grove-Vtntc,--burg Channe! in the late 1999. Z. Th: subje=are&ie c•=.xly z^nc:6 as A-99 'ov FEN LA because of the SAR. When the Z SAR floodplain zone (A-99) is re novcd as a consegt--xe. of compirion of:he SAR federal project, FEMA is irk y to show portions undelying the SAR floodpiam as a residual flaodpiain rsuhing from :.ant G_rd=Grove-Vfint--sbure Caannci. This will ,zquire floodplam regulations to be followed for irsurabic structures within, t:ie residual fioodplaln area Post-Ir=ax Nola F.Q.�p-<Na rc^u tuQ Gz lei hli San- �. Scchoa 3-4, "Wat=-' of the DIMEiR should be revised to stmcz taet pzns'or&..e pro e might be subjec:to fiaodpiais rsa=lations, whicb might require rr gation. WAT=R QUALITY 4 We suggest that ?a°c 3.-8, mitigation measwre Water-? a_zd Wa•.:• smote that �A comphance with ttsit,gauon shouid be ptio-to issuance. of vradine pernnu or building p--Mits. WhIC11--re: comes fast. OFEN SPACE RECREATION Page 3.15.7, T.-ails; To avoid coofu-sion, :t is reconiz--ead--4 the ter "bike trails" cited within the DMEIR be reaL9c„:d with the term"brkeway", so as to not confuse nail (dirt) and 'bikeways (paved). o. Paee 3.154, Trans. The t.-.m "eques--ian trail" utilized wirh the DMEiR should w replaced with the =="multiple—trail". It is likely that hikers and rrowitain cyclists CO may also use thr: routes. If so, these user groups should be recognized as full participam. It shcruld be no---d tb--t tl=Santa Ana River Re^giazial Riding and Hiking Trail Ls a multipl-use trail.and is not c ^ � ively a==��a" =usrh-1 the trail p12aae,d through Harriet M. Weider R..;ional Perk, and linidng to Huntington Central Paris, is a rnu?tL plc- use trail. This treil's f all ua=ne is `�!uadngton Bezc-h Regional Riding and l in ing Trail". The D\MR should retl--=this information. $. Th-— s no discussion within the DME R as to how i-ununeton Bc=h Cenral Para a,= Harriet Weider Reg:oral Paris will Iink to dty:.r r-mspc7ve umdl aad bikeway s}•ste-ns O This should be-dis;:ssed within the tee It has beea^e sac_-nonpiace to providc bnzic arne hies, sr1. as "'Horse-heignt"buao^s, at locations wh.ra a =ii nceds to cross a public madway WASTE MAWAGEIvaNT S. Camel Comments Th.- DME1R text L aee 3.3-2)states that the city of Huntme:.on Bcach has ur,dertakea 9 caordiriation with the California Integrarad West_ Board,the Lecai Enfort: met Agency t_.=A), and the SARWQCS to ensu= consistency with CCR,Title 21J. Howev=, also please note that cornplisace with SCAQMD Ruie 1150.1 is alsc a pa.^. of 1a-tdfW closure and pest blasts:.reouire.-n ts. The D:MEM does not ecdress the mquil---e=for protection or mplac,=.,tent of cxisttng 10 ,oundwaie*menitoring wells locate3 within the ptoposcd Sports Cornpiex ama. q DNEIR Text-gpe=ific Comments A Page :.12-1 R.e=ui=ry Framework, liz,-ioaal I I 2 j 3r•, L _V The following rstc-nent upd8res the lart�Uge rc=ding solid wasw marzgea:ent ��) plans: `/ OV > T-ne Intcarated Waste M:naee n=: Act of I989 (AB 939, She.) supplanted the Z'bC.-g-Kapiloi.reuuim neat for countim to prep-. Solid Waste Management Plans cv,: three years. AB 939 it-posed write re ucion rnannd .cs on co uuies to reduce the amount of waste disposed of in iandfills by 252/o by 19,95 and by 50416 by the ye---2000. Additiio��n��alf�ly, it requir__+ counties and citi_s to prepare various solid waste plarimmg docurn---m that dernonstrate-d what programs would be i=lemezted to comply with AB 939 mandates. Counties az- required to prepare Countywide Irtt_grated Wale ate, ge:neat Plans every 5 years that document 15 y=rs of dispo=l capacity, si,---nari.ze city piannine docimc-Xts, ar,d set forth criteria for sitina new land5ls. S. ?ape S-13, /vLiti=tioa M--=ures/Mcasute t-a2putds-8; Pug: 3.9-13, y1es=e Ha_zzmds-3 The text s=es: "Appropriate methane rot ation features such as ras detectors, pas miararion barrier,venting syste-.s, and classified ele--aicsl insra%tation shAB be incorporated into plans and specifications for all proposed s uc--aes overlaying the former landfill and' within 1,000 feet of the perimet..:of the landfd l." In addition, ciccaicsi coad_its, utiliy pipes, and L-e`cizes with pe:mcabic bc:�3itg mat►en.als =potezitiai condtuts for L n-,Jf l gas rnipm on_ Design consid`.ration for potmtisl LrG migration control throz;,h Yids,tr-.nches. or ozh aonduits should be incorporated taro pions and spec f"c tiom C. Pzge S-19, Mitigation tilcssure��M-str R�:cation-S The t_-Yt states: "Prior to corpleting anal d_-si� for•dr_Polic:JCiviliwl Range el--mcat, the City of l4untirgton Beach will urd---mkc sufricict analysis to define t'3� safe'-y elements for incorporation into tls fazdity design to cotrmly with state-of- 1 th---p—ia=C2 for r=.-cation riser's." Owe to potential lead contamination In the soils fern its previous use as a PolieelCivilian Range,the analysis_could also include tb-, %mnac, of I=d on w3t=r aualirv. D. c=ieure 1.0-3 The figl.ue does not id=tify the exis'ung two landfill.with the boundancs dclir-aced: Goutzrd Szmt L.aaditll(The Ciry cv.--s=proxinuttly two thirds and the County appznxiaate:y one third, hewn is Ore-c-c C'ounry Tr s2o: S:3aon ?)and the Bruce Brothers Pi:la City-ow-nzd fr ilitti). E. Pag: 2.1, Section 2.1 Prot=Location,second o`rserapn attar bullet �5 Tn_ Bruce Broth_•s Pit is located% thin the proje:and was not mentioncc. F. Page 2-18, Seaton 2.4 Inteadcd Us= of the Dlv= third Wad-aril Th: text starts: "Earth-•, all proposnd deveio^ment on closed landfiil(s, sitr(s) mast be amroved by the LEA prior to census:,--don in ord--. to ens,Qt t_^.c appropriate level of envircaaental :view and mitgaticn hrs cP-.n pe:fortxtt'.- ?1ease note that approval fiam the Rzgponal Ware Quality Controi Board is ::so rewired for ai: proposed drvciopmz rt on closed landfills per CCR Tale i G. Page 2-8, arc and par -sah The text states "Prior to final Plans and Spe:iacat,.on, survey will no-_^:to l be und:3taken at the Sport Complex to deL--mine is existing methane moritorng stations are P-dequ-te or if there is a need to supplement with addiuonal anonitoring snd passive colltadon system during constr-uction and operation, in co= m«with the City of Huntington B=h Specification 429." All landfill gas monitoring snd control systatns at closed la-�Ils aiao reqLurc compiianj= with the LEA and SCAQMD mquii -us. H. Page 2-9.third paragraph Tee text states: "Once at the site,t»:eds-ing "scrvicc" road iesd:ng :c thz gun rw4e would provide a roue to the const:-tion sttc w• .,cl: avo.ds ot:.cr cXi, ::tg t"-reatian and Library rues at the Parx." `Q The existing"se_-vice"road leading to the Gum Range is wutr:n CoLnm) propeM, l!J id=tifued as "the existing Orange Cotcm+Tra=f r Statio ==" Any -.ropos`d use of the mad requires permission iron the County I. Page 2-12, Section Z 5,Rciated P,of e,:s The List shouid e1� include the cot —lion o the City Day _abor Canter or, L-.e Orange County Tra.,naa Station#Z and the Indusuiai Development proposed for the pto_tr_ry to she south of Transfer Station T2. T.x prooc.T is c%;r-._=t[y owMrd by Parrcview Partne.si ip and with City approval will be rrunste-Ted Z Burke Holdings_ (See C-,ry Concitioaal Use Pe=it No. 98-21.) 1. Page 3.1-6. Land Uses Adjacent to Study Area, se_onc pa:ayroph 2-D This section does not disc-ass tap Bruce Broth= Pit Land-M =d tnc Crt's use of Orange County Transier Station*'2 as a Day Labor Cc^te:. K Pane 3 4-6, ars paragraph Zl .1 i he tc.xt '1 he design slopes for', --proposed Spurs C crnpi x will decre?sc 2J rz 1%over Large ar e.:s due to ;he Lading regmmmenu :or:.,.e pisying fie 1- G cVll• This st:e-ment is =otListnt with the Figures 2.6-1, 2.6-2, 2.6 and 2.6-4 which show 2-3% gradient across the field- L. Page 3:-4, Ruie-s) acid Reguladons Pace 3.9-2, Stan(PUJe: and P eguiaaons'r SCAQMD Rule 1150.1 for landfill should be mciuded rr. the lasts on both p2 t: M. F•°ge 3.9-7, Solid Waste Infor:a.tion Sys Tbc text stags. "Huntington Besc.' AKA the Bruce BTOtilC=5 Pit" is par, o:-:1t.az is known as the Gothard i g,eifiil located at 1813' Got: --d Sat— .,-Ibis statement is lac;n t. It is imparaxnt th&: the 18-ac a Brut: Brothers Pu tt �3 correctly described and depic=i as diftr-e=1-41111 from :he God=d Suet Landfill,^crc dcscribcd ire the sane accz+on in the Final D\SIR and fume doc=enta6oti,p1m identify throe two properties as saerste and diatine.sites in both narrative descriptions as well as all exhibits. These two sites ere also described in Page 3.94. As indi==d, tk-,- Bruce Broth---s Fit was used by the city as a disposal site for rotary drilling Wud and waste mud from sumps fiat. 1927 W 1949. It is unelc--r%V ether the drilling thud had be`n cz:.avated prior to decumdon of in--.mamriBls. If not. the impact on groundwat= should be sdtL . h. Page 3.9-9: "The exact boundary be:we=The Huntingto❑ B -acb :a_:d_rJl and tLe imri debris Lsposal pit was not as a result of the upon of Geology Candltlons(CH-2-M Hin 1998)." �G Bated on the info:=Tina presented in Page 3.9-7 and our ck,=ai at acevc,arc the Hurltingum Beach Landfill and the inert debris disposal pit the swnc site? As Indicated in Page 3.9-7"in 1957, a p it was issued for t-= disposal of inen, materials" Was th;—pc=ziit issued for inert materials dispow-1 on the Bruce Brothers Pit site, or ants=. site? 10. Comments on Volume ll (Teranica.i Appendices) A.pp=dix C, Central Park Master cIR Geology Conditions A. 1 fie text states: "The iocznions for:his field trs:inm art snuv.r, on :iaure ' :ne can results ate provided it Appendix C." he Figure 3 shows lilies -or geophysical ;urvey. but resultz such :Ls section profiles are no: included in the appendix 2S S _ . -�C.� _ ,.C-�...:� -_'� - A.}cG'.�<, .. a __ - , Jp•�:�'- ;=sae _ T-hc d==,ptions 7erc for the forme: Humun_wn Beach L.M-511 are inconsistent Zrj with descriptions presented in Page 3 9-7. is the In-r Debc:s Disxsal Pit described here ref.--.ma to Br=-- Broth= Pir7 Clanflcatior is requiTed. C Fiyu= 8 --he fit= sbouid show----stL^.o c:cscd lanrinlie (.Bruce Brotn=9 Pit, Hun, neton z Landfill, and the Orange Cocmry Transf= Station Appene—x H. Phase I Ezvironme-m-al Site Assssm—:: D Pnge I, Scction l 0 Ezsutivc Summary sixth paraeraF'i Pe: data ase presented in the a:.acsad SMS Rccon,tat 18-acrc Bru.s Brotacrs Z� Pit was listed �s a potential=ntaminzze h-7--rdous waste site. Are any mitigation m=sures ,-=quird for this sis? Pie°-sc cla:-:fy the status of:.he site. As indicated in the sath paragraph,the Bruce Brotne_-s Pit site LS located at the southwestern=rner of Talbert Avarua and Gothard Str_-e.,. However, Pictures 2.6-5 and 2.3.1-1B of Vohrne I and ftgtae 8 of Volume 11 Ap_oendio C show a dim-rent locanoa for the;tiraated limits of th:s landfill. Are these the same sites? Please cI_ri y. llw-r-k you for the oppo,:.t:iry to rtsaonc to t.�c DNE.2. !f you :aavc any questions. pl—c conk:the or f:=i > c to ca.il C-ario'ne Fw—ymEn dir..zdy. Ca-lone r..,a5 be reachrd at(774) 834-2�22. Vc/y / e-2ettor, J =vin=c=tal and Project 1 Pla.^-urs Serviccs Division CH 3,5 �OIL, -06+ mtzl'cClm� ocTa � 1�J�9 Anal 12, 1999 a�aa of ors Ch&"f. Mary Beth Broeren Lase,-,w City of Huntington Beach Planning Department Vim-ch"W'" 2000 Main Street ¢am L C" P.O. Box 190 awwo, Huntington Beach, California S2548 Cr+we I.C.yO dfww 7bmc* Subject Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Paris am:w Draft Mastm Environmental Impact Report(EIR) r.,,rt„w City of Huntington Beach rafftlw "goalr„rdo Dear Ms. Broeren: zwom Jw"°"of The Orange County Transportation Authority (OCTA) has reviewed the above 1, _� � referenced document. OCTA has the following comments to provide regarding oir� various issues discussed in the EIR: f.4Cf-am Wmt! a..Qa Bus Turnouts and Bus Pads Ctmiently, the project silt is served by OCTA bus route 25 via Golden West Street. Route 25 operates Monday through Saturday and provides service oo.Mar, Z you"O'"Wt every 30 minutes throughout the day. It is anticipated that the demand for bus A",wC.ens service on Sundays may inereasa as a result of proposed project In addition, rt Aft-V° hes been proposed that futura bus serves to the project area should also CA4AW V.SMM operate on Gothard Street. AN@& e "�D°' t In order to facilitate the operation and uae of buses within the project rica-uty, OCTA recommends that bus transit amenities such as bus pads, turnouts, and 3 shelters be Incorporated into project plans. Project developers should consult with OCTA to determine specific lo.bons for these amenities when more detailed site plans become available. On an administrative note, the following references tc OCTA In the document should be corrected as described: q • Under Section 8 — Organizations and Persons Consulted, page 8-2, both I references to OCTA at the top of the page should be corrected to read "Orange County Transportation Authority". • Under Section t 1 — Distribution List for EIR. page 1.1-6, L!sa Mills should be J listed as OCTA's CEO (not Stan Ofteiie). :Taro Co.nfr-anaxrtE trap.� nonry SMSoua+Mon Szr"IP.Q.BOY 7476J/Orange/'�u"ioin,� 9286:-158z. (714)b8GOC (620-1) Mary Beth Broeren April 12, 1999 Page 2 All future environmental and planning documents for this and other proiects in l � the City of Huntington Beam should =me to my attention. OCTA appreciates the opportunity to provide input on this project Please see that OCTA's comments are considered for the final EIR documentation. if you have any questions in the Future or need additional information. I can be reached at (714) 550-5751. Sincerely, Amy Vlfaivoord Assistant T ransportadon Analyst Planning and Development C �` —711G. o CCUVrrf of oRAN©E CryRCM-Y Cmx=-:A HEALTH CARE AGENCY ML=71e Fim". PUSUC HEALTH cs:�srrrc�� �tFOR arvtstaac o� ENVIRONMEOU �H �•�.G�-r �=P+a4& maIe7-3= ► x-p,v Crr4fa9 A,7ril 16, 1999 Ms..'ry BGn Broeren Scrior Planes city ofFhUUk gtmt Flaming PC Sa 190(taauing address) L Jl Kunungtoc Beau CA 926d5 Subject: Draft Susie: Enviroamrntal L-apatt Report (DMEIR) for the Hunting a Beech CAIIttsl Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses,loud February 26,L999 D&r.Ms. Browen- The Otzrry Coumy Health Ct: ro ^y,F--V== ual-Hz-a14h Division is tw-Solid Wasrt Local Adp--my (L=A)for all Cutts and vrmcorparac:i m=of O;aav Cc---ty. Liter pro---=Ia of tb=P' ,.D:: Resovr,:�C= the L- can=--tcn with ncc CzWIIv-...ia h2tel Wa= NSmae--nm•x Board (GWI,Sj Peanits and mspe~-= Solid Was~Fr::ides(active and closed)andfills, weir sedor;and ear=QS ng ima hjm)in O:-ange CZC=V. 'I=?Urocv- of tiffs leas:is to Sub= fl^.e =4'3 c==ts = the Dyer iI—W=Eavi.-U l I arm-i Rmv= (DIV=— a for die F.r=in= a Bea;.12 C--c=1 P---Ma-=Plan of R=7esdm Lis-c. C---III rise DNn:M is —oU gsepw Wd cam_—ehencvely add=Ms =atsy of d* LEA'S a xcss t=gmurg the ptO.Josed=vjc a. Aff r iew of LRa doamx=the L_4 ha:tb_following CaTlTi>mmm Tepx znS the MIML 1. Se=don 3.13 Lzad Uses Actjaaaat to tbo Study Area and Section 3.92 E;zaeng Site Conditions Solid Wass': Infen== Sys Thane Secdow do not list aD of th--possaly iapaated k=:i%e landfill Sit= in the area Z The L A su't a Ur.cf Closed.Illeflal ar.kbe:wed(QA)I andFIl Sites to the City o2 E ' g=Bewb on 0 .obk 9, 1997. Tbe Cty is Bra 3 to review de list for 3ddmmai C7A lz�dfill sizes such as lompii 9.Fem (30,-R-0090)and R.W.-Mci�-1.r=mtri Sorts f 30-r—R-OX4)which=y uapact the gtooasrd p`v•eL 2. The DMEM is ,—L---a in de=:bmg 1-4- lo=oas sad t►a;ms of CA I—crUIs wh=!%wM ears- t5e�voomC � 3 Prof=. 3. F.:s 3.9.1 1 n=6 to be revised dt-the Cky o(Fiat=gran Belch addtesses co mmra=rnx I Azad 2. The propc=d irTi-cm&m of i:h=Sports Comrlp=?cz=addilif—I lenda"Il deczimceitirn gag to be goatmind ir-n si= -�a �«>L'Slls. 71e Cry srsst e.a3uasz nod pleat the naprom= consul meamzw inc!udiag the possa ky o±a s„ve active laodfm e.s c:atrol sysrenL In aminon a potential iac-..sae is L�dfit1 decorap=non ;=s g om=on and rnig cn may t-_quite s ci imge in the mo4&adng fr=tse=y of_e -k--o=cstica ps uus :vr=g pt-,:ib= sty i., dL-%i in firm of ti~ City of Hssnangtca B.s_h Contra! Library nord)of the finr^ngton Bach Landfill. At nits a=the palms which have hi=nmriv btsa m:Pacad fora rurgtaung 1=c± i gal art: monitored ta==bIy. I zrxlfiIl deoompositi= prot,—.q brat �---va not d---vcd sib=canc==-tv-d d lar4f U_vw am bdaa cmetreriy. M3. Mary e--m_roeren A ail I& 1999 Page No. 2 5. The tie g-as cotrsoi syar=curt.--dy in oge26en it&cnt of ter-C--=aal Laxmry may=*d m be epamdcd I L and ear;du-.m- e pm--Ne clle=of the prcpcsed proj— 6. ragt Z-6 slat~ sail gas swncys wiwiu be tmd.--aim.. at thz q)-= ec-...pbz in c---d-- to if � cristiag laczdfill gas t:err armg sys==is e6equ=. T=LZA r=sz approve t-c propcBed Boil gss m=VC7;rdor ro im;3lc=o=6on. The LEA views soil_ s swvays as a valuable method to q=Btsiveiy aasms eubstafaca gate c-mcetrr,o-1 But. he pmects deslaed in the D;v=wM most 15c ly zagtatfl&c in-alhoiaa a's,&E nal d,-died ::err f it m s ink--mg woes to cuattadve}y=== c3e rnncmm=:den sad possible mig;ad m err lan aEll decampositiott ems. Installation of mca gevbs rmrst ix Bane utsde n wpr4l=aaptwed by the 12 y 7. Scion 2 5 ter. Pmje=:This Section nexls to be ccp=dd to dune th9 poem=al for migt=g L .dfM d:-mpocuco ttas to advpme:iy=pact adre= or - a hazard The Secmm sabttld � a!-so indua=the proposed devt:;optm=t of'm&js J baEdings at 19241 and 16251 Gathard S— and should be =w--=d aitmr all of the inactive landUs in the era of tar;xeposcd=pie=am ccm ;a== a. Any gotta of landiti?s tisaa be dog is a—to pcoa=m zsm-off nod wear wow trMU2=s faro he oast~. L^Sl=on of w'.;-mto I=dff'1s manse c the g=etmm mad trigaaoa cf L•tt Aml dec=wosid=gas. In ad&ii t eovsr modffieari.= that dr.== permmaYfiry can irsv-.era`the dizm=--laadfill dtrongoaitica gas 01 wUl tz;mm In--. ly. Thew emnd=aacus Arad to be mkaa auto acco mt wbem dc-ag mg d= T=ts field caaml=. 71tc LA and Sazra Ana Rcp mal Water Qaa&ty Como]Board must apoeove any acams that altar $to co —of any of the BfB=d lmmafvlls. 9. Sec-zicm 3.9 a Mmgmion Me=n-.z This Sc=cn needs co arid.+-a s"-P=�tlim if Bay t ImL-Ms arc diseow eel duang thr mrt:ic �1.r� n�acLts irnrL-t�:a:iex t will be i* noCfiec?and a rntigation l0 ==sur=wM�--taken. 10. Tba LEA and oth-'a47ro=8-b.nsularory am+c^es tars;appmvz aA work to be performed that ro;firr+c to any of I (� d=inucti-m-landBs unless nctiE=d od miser Truk you for the oppormniry to subt it t =c.--tsr=ts=p dmg tf-DIvIEPL F,eaee cmcx--mes at(714)66:-2014 or I t Swv=Sham a(714)66%-36Z if zh arc-ray gu=dcm r--zu- mg the wramm=provides::-in mrmrse to the Snaect Now--of Piewamtica. Sin _;y Pia F3enahaw,RE-JS Swe vzsing Fa2_-dom Waste Srr-cialic Said Wasps LxKal F2fott:-tt=t A--=y F�vatmrr=Bel�::.:lth Di.-irioa PH- cc Fes-J an:c30.Cali:ornm Wass-NlmwgT=--c Beard DL.ic Lass.&;a ua Am Rzcaaal was=QtaLty Concnl Boar.:' David Jars,Somh Co=Ai:Qpaly'N� Dinrim St: noe Mc C?ar--ti=,C=an, C==-v Tat-;Bed Wm= ** .�=Devact==t CITY Or FOUNTAIN VALL-EY iJ:"Ji:,A`cR AVENUE F0L',:7A,,N '.*AL__-_. A 9a7J6-4'30 ;u;.:400, iAX: f714; i9l.4GY^ April 12, 1999 Ms. Mary Beth Broeren Ctty of Huntington Beach Planning Department P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92W RE: Comments to the Draft Master Environmental Impact Report for the Huntington Central Paris Master Plan. Dear Ms Broeren: The City of Fountain Valley has reviewed the Draft Master Environmental Impact Report for the Huntington Central Park Master Plan and appreciates the opportunity to comment on the proposed project. As described in the Drag =nvironmental impact, Report, the construction of the proposed Sports Complex will result in the net import of approxima ety 110,000 cubic yards of fill material i ne impart of the esiimated amount of fill is a significant amount of material and the City of Fountain Valley is requesting that the 1. Environmental Imped Report fully address the impacts of the import of the fill material to the site. The Environmental Impact Report should address the path of travel for the trucks delivering the fill material, the exit route, the estimated number of truck trips,the hours of operation, and the length of the operation. In order to minimize nenative impacts to the City of Fountain Valley street system,staff recommends rotating the truck traffic away from Fountain Valley arterial streets to the greatest extent feasbie. Thank you again for the opportunity to comment on the proposed project and if you have 2- any questions, contact me at(714) 9-93-4427. Sincerely, roc-rr fr.,rum Robert Frankfin t7/ lcar Planne iP1 •/-. 7V �. 1S �. c: City Engineer file a w.� r = 4�it ornmentat, ward \n �}�•fi�t -ice } I.11�'y'%. :.I f Y 'Jr% Hl, N i!NG7()N ..=.NCH \O )� � �`i 5l T(44- EnAeV w�ynTwC;,,w 04rw POZI off'= Sox 190 . F;unt;r.c:On A^ 't 12, 1999 4L.%Lzry Beth Broc-c \ City of HLmti:.gton Bcch Plar_ning 7co�'C1��t ��u• �Qrd 2000 y1s-i- Seeet,Y4 moor P.O.Box 190 i:�.Cagton n,rc' C&92648 Subject: Draft Mastc-Environmental Imp=Report for Master Plan of Re-creation Use For Central Park City Of Huntington Beach, CA De-s Ms.Breeze✓` Tx V, rozm mal Bay d of:he City of Hu=mgton3ead is pieased to sucr-it its co=eat;snd m-commendslions on Drat r=vironrm -tal L-apartReport(W,St Ciear-ing Hocse Prom No. 9 i091007,fo:the-Mari.-Play of Rem-ti=escs for Cntal?:sit The r'avao �c.l Board d sc�ss� the ,--y of%h-- E t at it;regularly sca6duied meeting on Av^19, 1999. Tom,cc=--nts included beltsG we:.-a rovvd by Board action st*-y s=e meeting. Overall Findin:s; '2zsed tm=:�_=+irw of the Drz:=PIP,,the Snviron.—mr?l Boz:d imcs sigainczn_dc5c-.=ces is one Z ley issue, 2—d hzv:b c,-w cuzc--rs over other rspec-s oftne -ojeci Each of the weir_, below r--.zd m be sum,r and/or befort t]--Ea is ce:rned_ 1. Tm lacy area c:con•-=rc:,atms to the physical c:zra ==Gn of is fame:landfills tim, smderlie the proposed Sports Corapl°x_ As require::in CEQ.k cent itions nerd to be 3 ft:lly defined soar.to M110-n proper evaluation of the project's Gvi o, c==i ia,=c sad subst~u=--ait+ga:on me:staes I e additional lardEll cliQ t;izason covJd mquire c'tu_^:es to majcr ei ernerrts of the project to insure public heslt�er.3 s:.ic:y grate^otz. in this, the Board fora tha follovring during its defiocaticros: • A detailed charset--imEon o:tuc.vast.-contained in the form=E•_L.,i�3=ac�L c� Lan&-fi'll and Inc.,.Debris D; osal Pit n.-::ds b be provided(e.g.,the pot=till for the fC. J-- 12"dfM SitrS to Contaia M32r =US W2SM.:. The fug=e sr-^-,ace gas eaissicns, to mclude:=--t_ne as well as con toxic as I 7 eortaarir �,s:^.onld be measrd s pat of Le overall cba-a��radon eE the� 'Ihc Nis.M:ry.pet! o A4^r1 12, 1999 Page 2 pot=tai for 1andEH gas dg:--tor.as Fart of t-e ettrt=g s'-otld be evaluara-4 • A str,,Ay of Ldtiil -s pmiucaou should'x :onducted, and resu;ts presented in ut d:- ER.not es part of'-A'1Ytion Me_surc_Haares as suggu.cd on Pap 3.9 of t r documcm The Mdy n---:s tc evaluate not only the existing searing,but eking,to gas production tat could r-_su:t whzn ti;.ate is subje=te to"dy.a-sic corns ac zon",=d � then cs,---oed with a svnthe•ic mew*-7=.e tad 6-fee:of sou. • Based upon the landfM gas produzli=swdv,'Lae &-Z.*l EIR should Y.ovid_a recommendation on the nee--;fc airaer an acre or past-.landfill ps collw.don .rystcm, as-. ?] ss Se monitog prvga heed-:to xjppor.the sys +vc .^: r..r, ten's npcaboa A cancanil design of such a sy;---=shoed be prcacntea is this w-M anp=t otL_, ame_s of C.efr c..3.R(e.g, cazscnc on emis.ions,u:,iites,c�.). • The d. ,=- R needs to provide a disatsr_aa of x+=fhc=South Coast Air Qu--hTy S viamg--ncat Dis=--z(SCr:QMD)PwIc 1150,F.tcavaaon otL -.dI6II Sates,or Rule 1150.1, Cor-srol of G=cous&r_trionr from 1vrrrl:'pc!Soi.d W sre Landfills,Wm agpiy to this projrt. I With r heard to the Sully Nnller bake Group:acfiiry?r oaram d--Ea�L-oamta'si Boz=c find;;hat the arat._iR did not zdaquatz;,add.—ss the c-'-=i g wa--. ?t slity of th.W=. Pits+ough tars;s a program t c dra-EIR should a:lest re-Iv.-any c:dstmg ornrtan o- t-'s topic and pleas a)at-- en.-iron=ts1 doc•.=.cz--.on to s`u watc=-z.--lity and ar=s of po:-.t°I oontznor_ 3 The d,fi E-IR ropers that noxioLs odors will not ecc^:d.-�ag c=s-.:velon- The E:,v&onr--- l I IL Board'acUe-e==t�-c F.iR s;_ozid adcrc--s the pot=-ri_1 for odor rc:case d:airg con smrmcaon actYitics over thm fr.rm=I=Uffis in the-.mot rc-lace is t--covcmd. 4. The BiR r=crts thct nigh:!J:gb=-%s of ti:soc:,=v'footrsL a,id so DUD a 1 fic ds would czar_a sismiflc=it W-c:to the Oc�.View:lazes Mobil:Herne Pazi; -:vea af;:=mingatom TIC Err;ronrn==l Boant reco =ds I"—,i=-yter r.'t4mti==can=-,s.:eh as the p:antsng oftIl � l\ tans i"-ediaz:to cite tor-.h of the mobil.-home pa<'s cons:d--mtic n of-od=>tc altc ua&es thzt place the hoicking fit-thcr. Lrom M*Zz Eome Pee, or use only th-:nost n=-Ja=m:^s for night ac:i-ities. Disz..sslon: Q?�l Chtl2ctcr-i'mti -Tne cbm-ft Ea n_ds to tacre EItiV c amc- St'. 1 0 �L C.t°.".0 fP3s171�, i_475,2 CCS^' 3L• G :Or'le!i ^�'orDr g`+^.S T'�"..�"]l BI1G lI7LIt `cb:s Dis:o�—'?it shell c oe it_1y ch-�ce-iz r' ?,,:t:ouah the&af=- ;Lpso:-id_s a d'_sct�or. of.:a:-T:v--^.ed coat=:of thz i.:^d>rPs, there x-- no:.lazes vm this stc. anc ispos:,' use a=d d=ng a I Nts Mary occ April 12, ?-=e 3 i pc:-:od of time Wner's-zarrou;w=c laws were roc w-.11 dr.eloped. Lc:cc�5 �1>~ aresc-cc of t,:?g dots:rastc would a2ow the a=ropra:-healtl:and, ?':y to be :rive:pno,;o the of Cona'"=C-tan actmuds. Als ,wive conloontim deza is %ita1 ir. sLLL.-YLng gas imi;-•ajor. =d artlr0-'ria:e=idmd8on rams=s. F=Th=-1ore, n aC tfEar`to Ell:t•Cht:a':;c-1e'me Slt�- 'LUE:cs s_^ouid be conduz;ed that measure the quantities of tan; it may mi_d'or.,It: l�ic�3u-mr=ts should sgeciz=f=methane coc:nE. hpdnicarbocs and:he core :ox;c e_ contaminants idrtified�m SCAQMD Rule 1150.1. i S-`o;r 3.9,i-�_ZAADS, provides mit gamoo rs:rst=_s._ated.to tht for.-� landfill a;*-f prair_t;i:e. N s gation Mezram-F�=;c:s-:,reoucm thd,the poten�l for isndi;M gas g=e-atich be stuair_ rac ot;,--- appra-".ate= igazen ma=ras be cooramd a:fo tao SCAQZD. �o]d Wes;e Local 3 crivrc.-r:enc Ages.^�,Re-,ion:!Water Quality Ceatrol EoarcL and h City of Hurrda;t:,n S=cu fu- Depe~�r.:t. Tne Eaviroatnenm1 Board believes that h-�e act orq ar iced•U:uro,�.d.-ng, uU c'hmetezi;ation the groje..,and therz-fo.e, snotidbe undcrt:!km as par..of tt._czfr ErR d.cre'.00a:ent In the dr ml op meat of the Spats Cola d^eat of the M2s:r.?!zz,, the Amer landMi =-ea w-.:i be =p*with a gea==b.n=to pret,-mr,-pa-colation of cv= , =d a 6-foor,ia;r. cf soil on top to establish stactlity for dsvelopm=at vities The$;v_-ctmtratal Board is coacmed tl:at th a_---imm rray have the po=tial ro change the cl-^-seer of?b-for.-ter IS<dE:1 . For r-mole,c r-ptag tc le.^cfill rrsay licit 2ir ixrt an to the si=cr==-g ideal editions for a=er ubic lr--dlili S.0 F`s..hcnom capping&.e site m:y cause LandiM gas.if Frey to wag raze lat--all,:=no cthz .=-czs o C:- -ai Park the r-M should flay evaicate trrs pot`-ntisl gad explore tine hap;o-laic=Xrio L on a�nr+as. In a s nilar fa lion, a L-rrdcll Z s prodne`1C s^.* shoaid cTe=:o d LL Z e rcco.=.=csaa s on t_Se of pave er active L-ndEl: gas ego: r;vJ.--- Sz-ce -..e gctsaos-: SLJ-S Com..:i_, is co*sid-e; a F+'C71L^:.-Ca t of t1C NLse.C?L-:,t3:-=.tu'==Uk s oaic zc::ess:.-...- ds=il--. sue:, c�conal design of tat gbs crsol systems :tarn tr 9 des;r, er --ss ca;be mace a; ,o I c=structiaa ix=ncs and i=ac-- on+.=titles If m 2c4tv-aas car't:o1 ays�- is at :zc:, locswoo_of the blower-mtio--&ot:d be idert^e;:md the need fun an}•ga ,.���Qe-�e:_isclit+cs(c;_ fla.�—'+s=id z acdres.;ed. ' AS prcvi0"I ly di=a!*e; eoozd::&t:oa With the a±-rrae>y :Cg ictcr;as :c,s't mud be coa du-;,,--I rs pat $t oe caR.iR process. SCAQ:D g„t- 1150.T=ratrpit.sppues to t--L.- cavazicm 0C1zmdell s-t s. If during the co--s r ,.^top of ie Sports Cerapiez-----v waste be a Rini I ISO avaticr_Pl— may seed to be gror.w-.d- Also,SCAQMD mule 1150.1 r_o..=s the gaseous m exvnme as well as hew l=d 1!s Tac find�g of st_^:ar_icYc'.s�i lz.^.a n' ass. c: az plan to�5'ail cWt--ol eye*--.a my triggc tail talc Tac F-R should adazcss t:,c avrucaa:Sr. of'aott tiese mlees to the proposed;=*t. S_ltv Mi7ac-L.aice Grour'sciity Pratr-a . F=_.,t-F=h--ea%u onmeAtai on Rul Se cand::. d on the Su115 ZvEner Lake Croup F=ahy since ti=s.is a pm��plc a_ saaul resieu:the wm-t--gtnl^y a.Les re1_�ed to use lske The lakc=-y h.-ti-cc^st::::;=-to nmc L or c:= seepage =d Iradfm-mi r sCoa 5r=the adjac.-t`ormc 1a-.d511s.tmt=my A%S.Lvz--y:7ct)broeren AM-1 12. 1999 Pap L hatted t:_Jake's aua.isty. T'1`_ d=r.EM shouic addr--s t:s Issue,provid`ng n�_T,- kg dzn . ��- avaiiaole, or diS—IC p13=to evalu=e this iss.:: dov-i:--c.-,mtion is pr:7parca Potential Odor 1=acts- Ta9 d.af-,EM disuses the pc--iOiiity 3f odors d=ia;cor_rsuc ion:howevc.• comsc actor.=2y=co-er waste contained in the forte:aacfiil -=6:22 -n odor=azt. dr=ft Ea. repor•S that chc cove_over':hie forsc I=d:,11 4 Md 15 f=;cr A_tre c allow Z..:s of t:-t .AvC,the possfbiny of�1----y castruzM=cqu. M=,inad�er C--dv ezposinp k-as--,sm,.uld be conside-.zd, tS well as t1L any SZ7sa uClc oars az?, andtT.:g--vors. S,'=L5cz t irtnact of Field Lir---no -Tae dr!:M.rz,ors fait-se impacts on a�,.iatic;from m rat lien-ting of socc=fooioall fields and softbal18e!ds wo-.Id r-=-"n significa t dsi�ri&.use o=the soeec+=oot_aIl fields,i-rpa.das the Oc=View Es: ez Mobile Ho:n-.Pats. •Jto^ mingxnon me-anres sho:ud'oo explored as part of the E:FL T:pon oMy o:planting L11 tte=nary of,h,=mobu_aomc paw aray prcvcit direct vi„-w of the ligbrtiro by ra-side:c_ Aso, L--feasauity of li=-:ting t}e fright use I� of the fields just north of tht:park should be e-plorcd. '-By 0oPMgg aiqlrt acnm ties en oriv the nctrhe:n n-ost fioids, this=y=Snif cmt reduce tbL-.spa,=to--==lane�:G=-p2xx. Finally,m:m iar to A:=adve No. 1,the poses ity of tnovyg the aarknc lent to tL-south of the ca=le;in tie;xcle .ed alt==wdve, should be This would d7c=--_•tea L:sbr-;-g fr=the=oboe home pa:�red.,:citt_ =Postzo. :-Ti r nviro=eatal Board tpprecia*es the oppora.rity to com=eat- I Z v SiL=_.e1y, EN V1ROM&M-N 1 tt r BOARD r. �� rz*s R.Canon �rL-abet. The Gas Cnr' panya gran a Coast Region E cE l v a r� C�9CG�1/1.�,gN� MAR - g DEPARTMENT OF March 3, 1999 /t City of Huntington beach Plannine Department P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach. CA 92648 Southern California Attention: Ms. Mary Beth Brocrem Gas Company ilJii,ng idd.e:; Subject: EIR - Huntington Beach Central Park Master Plan C.i 3 Thus lever is not to be interpreted as a contractual commitment to serve the proposed project but only as an information service. Its intent is to noaty you that the Southern California Gas Companv has faciuties in the area where the above named project is proposed. Gas service to the project could be served by an existing train without any significant impact on the environment. The service would be in accordance with the company s policies and extension rules on file with the California Public Urihries Commission at the l time contractual arrangements are made. 1 The availability of natural gas service, as se: forth in this letter, is based upon present conditions of gas supply and regulatory policies. Asa public utiliry, the Southern California Gas Company is under the lumsdicmon of the California Public Uniicies Commission. We can also be affected by acnons of gas suooly or the condition under which service is available, gas service will be provided in accordance with revised conditions. Estimates of gas usage for non-residennal pro iects are developed on an individual basis and are obtained from the Commercial-Industrial Market Services Stab by calling 1(800)42i-2000. We have developed several programs which are available upon request to provide assistance in selecting the most energy efncient appuances or systems for a particular project. If you desire further informanon on any of our 2— energy conservation programs, please contact this office for assistance. Information regarding coasnvcnon particulars and any costs associated with initiating service may be obtained by contacting the Lead Planning.Associate for your area at(714) 379-3438. Sincerely, Robert S. W arth Technical Supervisor 1Pc c-Ic! ci•rc o rn.,m.JOc ON Pm -2( a - - VCA 08 SPN r© — !07G CaEE�S CAE E�rNCt 32 o ''a l " �D y 9g , ° _ pl !!��A tut 11• V G r 1�; I1,,,1 Ili, I­i,11 ,1;llrrir„Ill,i,rll ,r�:►„Il , „I,II C E 1 V E D APR 12 log' Q�.�;;.�1� �. • CAS-Q-- c._t:� ;�.� � 9 r VI �= i �.�l G�1�• - C;G1; �� MS �1r't�v 7J �'Y�r— RECE1v �D ��� �tiig� �; -- 1 ..5,�� ;--��� .` ��_.�of�,;�•;�`r� CD - LcLJ �= O,J Ls& i FrM � Al 5 T�11� v5E P�2 Pr. -F�t 5,{�L Rr�nCcz a r4lT� L U c� 1J�A� 1� k. "70 L i c'S O c� 2 f c. t t-,,o 2�-�00. 1�L S ,J T1�ZvS L o n� A�ai II MU� L ( f= o �. (---)2rz 1 M �- IjE— (� -7� 7 z -Tr? -� �-G/C s soL/ ��e S =i��2�.-i o•.�S April 12, 1999 Ms. Mary Beth Broeren, Senior Planner City of Huntington Beach Planning Department 2000 Main Street, 3rd Floor P.O. Box 190 C4, uy-j Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Dear Ms. Broeren: Thank you for the opportunity to review the Draft Master Environmental Impact Report for Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach, California. As a lay person, I have reviewed the information and have hopefully interpreted the data correctly. I have to admit that I was somewhat confused about which plan went forward, since I have a copy of the 4A modified plan from the NOP which is different from the one printed in this EIR. Once I figured this out, all cotnmencs are trade based on the map as outlined in Figure 1.0-4. I am resident of the city within 1,000 feet of the proposed projects and I have a few items of concern, which are outlined below. Please seriously consider my comments as the City moves forward with the outlined plans. As much as possible, I have also suggested mitigation measures for each issue. As stated in my response to the NOP, 1 continue to express my strong concern that the program level plans are not adequately assessed within the referenced EIR. I understood that this EIR was supposed to cover both the project and program level plans in sufficient detail to obviate the need for any future EIR(s). This EIR states clearly that program level 2- assessment is not adequate. For example: "The local subsurface conditions of the program level improvement areas are not addressed in detail in this EIR" (page 3.3-6, paragraph 4); "The environmental impacts associated with the program level improvements are not analyzed in detail in this EIR" (page 3.3-13, paragraph 6); and "Build out of these program level elements will be subject to subsequent environmental documentation, however they are analyzed conceptually in the Master EIR" (page 3.6-19, paragraph 6). The Sports Complex as described on page S-2 paragraph 3 states that the plan includes 8 lighted softball fields and 8 soccer/football fields, but the summary fails to mention that these fields are overlayed and only eight fields can utilized at one time, not sixteen. Having overlayed fields allows for better utilization of space and thus greater flexibility to 3 the City for planning, but it is misleading. Usage as outlined in Table 3.15.3-1, Sports Complex Conceptual Use Schedule on page 3.15-12, shows primarily only four fields being used any day of the week. Does this preclude the possibility that all eight fields could be utilized simultaneously? If all eight fields will be used simultaneously, this EIR needs to be adjusted to reflect the true maximum usage. + Page I of 5 The areas of concern that I have include the following: Maintenance Expansion Area Tree removal Timine of endangered species survevs Concealing shrubbery Group Camping Area Cost versus benefit Sports Complex Traffic Parking Noise with respect to hours of operation and use of amplified sneaker syst.ems Night lighting and hours of ot)eration Proposed irrigation and run-off Police r)rotection Maintenance Expansion Area Tree removal ,{ Page S-2 paragraph 4 fails to mention the number of trees that would need to be removed to build the expansion area. From my inspection of this area, there are about two dozen trees that will be lost. A proposed mitigation measure is to replace these lost trees near the expansion area. Timing of endangered species survevs Please be sensitive to conduct Biological Resources Mitigation Measures T1-3 at the appropriate intervals in order to capture meaningful data_ If surveys are done S inappropriately (off-season), these species most likely will not be noted, and incorrectly assessed. Please add a comment regarding timing to Section 3.7-46. Concealine shrubbery For reducing the need for police protection, Mitigation Measure Public Services T2 proposes that less than 2-foot high landscape be used_ The existing maintenance area stores garbage, excess park equipment, and vehicles that are easily visible through the fencing. This area currently has higher-profile landscaping than what is proposed for the expansion area; therefore, the expansion area needs to be concealed better. Please consider vine/thorn-like landscaping that deters climbing or loitering. Bougainvillea may be a nice and visually appealing option. Group Camping Area Cost versus benefit The EIR states on page 3.6-18 paragraph 3 that the large Boy Scout Camping Event occcurs approximately once a year. Is it worth the money and the reduction of open space to T improve the area for this rate of usage? My husband and I walk frequently in this area and are concerned about losing this appealing open area to "improvements," like a new Page 2 of 5 restroom, a fire hydrant, and fire pits. The usage by these scouts is no more than twice a year from.what my husband and I have seen in the past eight years since we began walking regularly in the park. On page 3.4-5 it mentions "Consolidated Camping Area (various improvements requiring op paved surfaces)." Please specify the improvements that require paved surfaces. Sports Complex Traffic The traffic assessment in the EIR was performed prior to the opening of the Home Depot store, and peak summer traffic was also not considered in the assessment. Since the Home Depot began operations about one year ago, we are currently experiencing increased traffic on Slater between Gothard and GoIdenwest. Unfortunately, thorough traffic analysis on Slater between Gothard and Goldenwest was not included as part of this EIR. However, the EIR does state in the last paragraph on page 3.6-13 that the only intersection that will degrade to an LOS E condition (the worst) is the Goldenwest and Slater intersection. The proposed Transportation/Circulation Mitigarion Measure 41 is to "optimize" (increase)the cycle time alone Goldenwest. Currently, at high traffic times, the westbound traffic already backs up on Slater at Goldenwest and blocks entrance or egress at Duello Street. Backed up traffic occasionally hinders traffic at Lucero Strut as well. When the mitigation measure is implemented, the increased cycle time at Goldenwest will jeopardize the safety of the residences in this housing area by potentially blocking the only two entrances and egresses to this tract. Please consider as part of Transportabon/Circulation mitigation measures that the westbound side of Slater be painted to require motorists to not block these openings when waiting at the traffic signal. I would also like to ask that the speed limit be reduced to 35 miles an hour. For those of us who want to turn right into our housing tract or cross the street to visit the park- it is extremely dangerous because the cars are traveling much too fast coning down the hill at Gothard. No trucks are currently allowed on Slater between Gothard and Goldenwest. With the I fO anticipated 9,116 truck trips during construction, who can we call to report any traffic abuses if this begins to happen? Parkin The proposed park plan has changed since the NOP and scoping muting. I do not see how 900 spaces fit into the same area that was outlined at the NOP where it originally stated 630 spaces would fit. It also states on page 3.15-12, paragraph 2 that only 630 spaces will generate revenue. Please explain this discrepancy in the final EIR and show an enlarged drawing of the gravel parking lot with the spaces drawn-in, including the parking meters. The Sports Complex's parking plan has an outlined border in Figure 1.0-4 which appears to capture existing library parking to get the number of spaces up to 800. Please explain. The EIR recommends that the parking spaces at the Sports Complex not be metered, knowing that athletes will use existing free library spaces before paying to park. Page 3 of 5 I agree with this assessment. Please include in the EIR the City's expected gains in revenue and provide the proposed pricing for the spaces, the expected usage, and projected annual income. HB will be the only league in the county that charges athletes to park in order to play. I suggest that the needed revenue be collected through league fees rather than parking meters. Rain run-off from in the parking areas was considered, but not with respect to potential LZ environmental impacts to the ground water from automobile fluids that will be inevitable with 800 parking spaces. Noise with resDect to hours of operation and use of amplified sneaker systems Amplified voice announcement systems are noted in ivfitigation Measure Noise #1 on page S-13, but no detailed information on these systems are included within the EIR. Please address in the final EIR the following concerns about noise as they relate to amplified voice announcement systems. 13 1. Purpose and scope 2. Frequency of use 3. Hours of operation 4. Number and orientation of speakers 5. Will music or other audio transmission be allowed? Also, there is no mention of the anticipated use of helicopters to protect the area- What is the current use of helicopters for the park versus what might be needed when the park expands in space by 60%9 Ni--ht lishtine and hours of ooeration What will be the actual hours of operation since the Conceptual Use Schedule on page 3.15-12 indicates field usage on Sundays will be as late as 10:30 p.m.? How late will the S parking lot lights be left on? It seems to me that the height of the poles on the sports fields, number of poles, and number of lights per pole are excessive. Please comment on the necessity for such lighting. Why were no detailed studies performed to study light/glare impact, similar to the Acoustical Analysis performed by Davy and Associates? Specific measures need to be proposed to mitigate the impact of night Lighting from the Northeast fields on the residences on the north side of Slater Ave, because these fields are located on a high point of the park on light poles that will be 90 feet tall. Proposed irrisation and run-off This EIR clearly states on page 3.12 that "the existing water supply system is incapable of supporting any of the new project or program elements." This inadequacy cannot be mitigated by a project/resource that does not exist; but this is exactly what is proposed. I consider this backward planning. Huntington Beach is a drought-prone geographical t region. The EIR states that the only available water to irrigate the Sports Complex project is existing potable ground water and to access it, the pumping systems would need Page 4of5 to be upgraded. This puts the entire city at risk for substantially depleting our ground water resources. According to this EIR, HB residents use 75% of the water from this same source. The rest is purchased from the Metropolitan Water District. If the wells are seriously depleted because of this new usage, all of the city residents including the City I �. will pay unacceptably high prices for water. That is, if we are allowed to even buy all the water we would need. Therefore, it is imperative for the city to implement the Green Acres Project prior to moving forward with the park plan. What is the anticipated timing for this project? Please include the key milestones like the NOP, scoping meeting, EIR. construction timing, etc. Is this project budgeted: if not, how will it be paid for? Having a project that has no scope used as a mitigation measure is unacceptable. Mitigation Measure #4 on page 3.4-8 is used to reduce the water impacts related to erosion and siltation below the level of significance, but how can only re-evaluation of potential impacts with no proposed action cause an issue to be eliminated? Mitigation Measure 4 on page S-8 is used to bring the issue of water down below the level of significance. Paraphrasing this statement it basically says, 'we will worry about it later but whatever is determined will nullify the problem'. Police orotection The park will be increasing in size by 60%, and much of the increase will be high intensity use. It unrealistic to think that the outlined mitigation measures 2-4 on page S-14 will completely eliminate the need for additional police protection. These three measures are ZO 1. limiting the height of landscaping around the maintenance vard expansion to less than 2 feet, 2. design the tot lots with visibility, and 3. design the new restroom to see if someone is in the restroom when entering. Thank you for the opportunity to comment and for providing a copy of the Draft EIR for z review. I ask that when the revised EIR is available, I might receive a copy also. Thank you in advance. Sincerely, ``" Kathy Kurjan cc. Ciry of Huntington Beach City Council Members Planning Commission Members Jim Engle Mr. Scott Graff, Sapphos Environmental Page 5 of 5 i Huntington Central Park Master Plan Input (EiR#99-1) Apq )npp Multi-Purpose Trail Alternative With the review of the Central Park draft E1R presently in progress, and development of remaining park land imminent, it is important to address certain issues that will have a negative impact on residents currently utilizing both developed and undeveloped portions of the park. Most newly developed "communities" have incorporated multi-purpose trail systems not only to accommodate recreational needs of the community, but because it also enhances the appearance of the area. We have an opportunity to put a "face-lift" on our not-so-young community with little cost involved - just some ingenuity. The outcome would also enhance the functionality of the park. Due to increasing population and diminishing open space and park areas, an increasing demand has been placed on the City for diverse recreational uses. The acceptance of "In-lieu-of" fees from developers has left some neighborhoods with little or no park areas. Areas once utilized for 2, recreational activities are presently being developed into residential neighborhoods, shrinking available space and further increasing the demand on Central Park. Mitigation to demand on park space can be achieved by allowing sharacr- use by compatible users of the same park space. As areas for trail systems are in increasing demand from running clubs, school track teams, walkers and equestrians, a well-designed trail system would satisfy many user groups with minimal impact on park area- Presently, the existing trail system within Central Park is congested and utilized by runners and walkers all hours of the day - the opportunity and time to expand the trail system and eliminate impact to other uses is now. The Hilton has also embraced Central park as a marketable recreational area. It is being promoted as a destination for public horseback riding as a family activity, allowing tourists to experience more than the obvious beach activities. This, in conjunction with the annual running events sponsored within the City is a unique opportunity to integrate those events with Central Park and expand the tourists' interest and involvement within Huntington Beach. The multi-purpose trail system will benefit the City and its residents in various ways. • COSt to install is minimal • Cost to maintain is minimal and can be achieved by users such as (cam) -E I l (Equestrian Trails Incorporated) -Running Clubs -Track Teams • increased revenue from tourist horse rentals -Expanded trail system - longer and more interesting riding area -Revenue from running club and special events Many regional parks within Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside, San Bernardino and San Diego counties incorporate multi-purpose trails into recreational uses. Multi- purpose trails abutt golf courses, picnic areas, camping areas, automobile access areas and more. Enclosed are pictures exhibiting placement of such trail / systems. Many of the trails are wide enough to accommodate runners, walkers �e and horses simultaneously -these trails have proved to be popular and functional- The trails tend to be placed at the perimeter of the park areas where there is little or no impact on other park uses. Central Park Specmc Plan presently has identi�oed areas for equestrian trails in the "urban forest" area. It is recommended the trail continue along the perimeter of the park on undeveloped parkland, with a connection to the existing park perimeter (see attached map). Phase I could include all areas between Edwards and Goldenwest, north of Ellis. Phase 11 could include the area between Goldenwest and Gothard, north of Ellis and could bisect an area near Sully Miller Lake. The Central Park Trail Committee would like to meet with, and be an active participant in the Central Park Master Plan of Recreational Uses. Members include: Norma Ankerstar Mary Bell Jack Bowiand Vicky Campbell Jenny Jo Jackson Jean Kimbrell Carrie Thomas f Proposed Multi Purpose Trails It is respecffU4 requested tthattie-a dition of mufti-puTose #-7.s be adder#to tlTe I m#mgtorr Beacr€ P stem, T'rte cached map, ut ti--ree,park ama west of Golderrwest zndTrorth-of EMs, zhows said proposed traits: #`ag 8,dipk-4s sketch of the prod trail in the park area east or Goldenwest and north o1 ETRs {Phase Hj. 9 1. Beginning.at the driveway to the.equestiwi center and the- existtrg horse trait, heading #rough-the tree-area in front of th Fr Golf parking lot,-to-theikilIt of the-eyisting stairs where the trails would be on a.slight incline. Toes. area ¢aes not inters-ere with ndsti% use as Uze tr2ils would be under the tree area- * ich. is not use'_ A.Waoden. whtraii fence coal' be pierced herxee3a the trail and Golcroirwest Street- ?fttr th;L-ee area. snght grad�mg woLgi be necessary at the in.cl_ine. 2. T kre tram would cQrAinwe a;ongthe cuff(Deiow on the Goldrenwest side), then up t m- incline and back to ttre-a path vW runs ateng Hof GQdenwe-st and continue through trees to the;mod ►p channel_ This area is coznpleteiy=developed. No gradingv=16 be necemry. A*air. L',,e ad&tiorr of a spiibza:l Ie=ae could be pLa—ced betff-eee3 L.Be f--4 an-' Goldenwest Street. 3-. The traff ttwrt-left and follow behind the Nature Center t to the existing chain fink fence. I� This area is a aatura4 sway and would ar:y reqwe-that !>aa gales he .00eaed to the channel area. Additional ehaiaLmk fench:z could be added to {prevent children from entering into the channel area 4_ T le trail woWd b.-tm le#and follow the chainlink fence on the sou side of the Nature center. Z i I 'ice is a miatme of 6r a� free areas. Again. the trail would not interfere with emsting uses. Paae: 1 cf 2 5. The trail would then turn south along side of the existing path way and then east through the unimproved park back to the north end of the Frisbee golf parking lot. It may also be possible to have the trail continue south to the existing horse trail through the Frisbee Golf area �3 'rf and when the Frisbee Golf Course is relocated. This area is mostly undeveloped and again would require no major changes and does not inte.-iere with existing uses Again. only a so irrail fence could be added to delineate the trail. 6. In addition, another map is attached showing additional park land. It is proposed that the trail system be extended along Goldenwest Street at the AC Maron Property across Ellis and along Goldenwest passed the prior Horse World Stables to connect to the trail system between the existing homes. THANK YOU FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION. Page: 2 of 2 t o ji m/s,4) r N is,tr 1 `. 1.`/�- �Ir d`7 lV�r1. /O C\ C/•1/ .b f) O O O r�'^ram C) fjl [if all C' m m I 1 r" �'' 'r Il �• . t7 [ 10?11 !1 •(.1. N ••'� agll ./Y•rm\�L'1_Yiltt/i/lV1C�:If.tl711)u?�/M1��c0�Ll/>.Ti.:J• wY. +F I , bu 10 GI t/ �I�`�•r I _ '� Q •l• � ���►Z�'d i. q. r. n. a h .�, n. t4 c+ 0 O � 0 0 • A w �A+4 M�df 4►-L9i�� �fYi—t�-4+ '�QT—�"�19r�f�.i !��— � !io +� Golden West St. if 1 ` tr np• .,,,1A T- OV 1 -��; �• U Dn � Y n or,-� � � n 11 D Z '^Du' 97 0C �j QL' m (.0 1 m 10 I� II II h-" �r •.1;r `�n�Zin� 7`-1"•() s<z�v ,+Z;rl� �� � Cj ' A _NZ _!•IIM/I�t '-+-==rc�� ..' '_ys. ._7 1�:ia'�1n�Q )!r]s � 1'� _ J r rl : "9% I — --I� ` l�jC ;'L _1l j^..y" ..L��= �� TO J}�,'�!'3a �_-�a�"_ �'j°►���� �¢_:- .r.��' �-" 1 :d ) (,• 4§ ' Il:li 1 l[o`I`^,rt�0;,, i'- f� .1 =' .!_ , I, L --! /� -Z..�` �•'� \ l� 1 ' _ lu � 1 �, � �jr�� N it —I • :, -- I I�I - ' 1 (`�O•.�}Mll'll1 ti�Cl� ��:1.�--+ - .T-- �. J i_ Ir._ l� , � �� �I`I :Irtl . ITT In, rrd in C ('1 f I c � IL.:� �4 i � I i� � I�1�, 1 +� � �- - `�-Y���.� �•( ,t• 3 fl 1 1 ' 1 � r: ✓4 1 In (I� '(i�• ,, , , �' ..� �•t � 1. ffm �+ ( (it, 1 {a I•.n�:11; Tmn :r1 :.,n '.I'llf-- .r 'rl .'� ' III V - ''Lr r t .i �l ! r• f�In (, tt ' r -- I• � .. .��� - - �I.1�. •. ) I !'1:' I�,' f f 1 ---1- -'� �G��- �I ••_ _t,•- �� r. _, ;i -' ,. rll � �' iI I — I S�— �� _ rf�� LII /.r O •l 1��1 t.fl��.^r-�-fJ) II � —� I�•n it Oz r�l11►-9V.-" _Z1 =•� I.l 1 1 i I ; + '� t I �' �L�T `1 ..� `�1 r1 1 :F.' J i �� Y•$—� I 1' I .1 �'tl'\'•ice +',;�y/: J full: IF ( 11. ODTIIAIM 0 ITIIF6T (,• V b or CI Un-1 /Uj [[))7 ()7 moil �nl Qn L7_=1 v O z y �o }A �P 'flGZII,( }) o n o Z 0 1 '•A""•'I' ' I. �'� � 11,5� •fir• r h. + �. 'I• {ir'Y ti• ,r• �b , ). low •,Illi 11�•.1 �' r .I• �:ij. .r ,;.I', ,yk I � ma'__ .I:.�.-• I".111� '1 � i,��ti.lijj t11C Imo.; `t,+ yF I IH1 :�..'_T�t?�•`r - =.1 p.• r•:. .. 1.:I' •��rl��,''' ,I ',•r � �i I ' /�• 51 I, J) •{f ��•� � 'I• .. 1%� U ', II'1 � r'1�• :,^,�. t�•, ,.+ ••�ti'i'?sjil� � f'� ti� �' l;• t t 1 "�.4� : 'II, �r }',�,,` fr,''�• ��,;. et� ►+' ,I'I: %r1•'� i}�' .f,� �,ii r� �•' � I ',1,1i,��1� 1,, .± ��i�11 .{, �.1y1 �� � � ,�' , f.f 1 . Nil �, r, Ir 1.'• y 1 ,' �,.h r 1j... .o' 1 f +`('�. '• r�b•ice-�'� ''� � f f� 1�1• 11 I' •1. '✓ r l f �. �.1 1' I �Ir .',i+�l• 'A r� I �•�. Y.. r �. fir, .�•� I °r 1. '• ••L, "r j•�� - .�a�► u', j.l''1',' a:.1:, :. �•, ;,.i�lj ',v e'' r �i1 � is•;t:�C�'.,,' {r; L �..I 4•. I•14 4 t•� / dl/ ('1 fil 1 Id' �.•+ � J•1l,I,,l?,� '' '�'!ii,l' ,1ty�` } '����rY J�1 ► � '1:"�'� r •,,t1Cv. �r/1�,.: !'•:�j.l,� � � li'�,•, •°.}I�i'• '.'. +•.�.•• •If�� p �� .+,!'l.j: �1''v1:i,- _1'",J,?•' :,,, 'i• ' '•`:� ,1'.,� •t:' i'li.l •.t•r•r. ' 'h• t- +r.u,l ,n �!� ., i i'�: 1. �r'.y •1'�: ••.�� ,�'1,1�' 'fit. ir,. ( o .r'r , �i, Q I 1� •,i.: ;i�1 � >,��..�,� 1 .. ��1,:I.�.' „;,i�l'�;��1r' ' � �1 ' 'I ` rrr . �• r'' 11 ,. �. .�, 1i:• 1 r•. 1 tt�' bo�o o - ly,f 3' tip i ;;' !' ,/ r r _,, ,,+��tH �YIlp- a•1 � �� � 1:::t,r ;I 11 II . „ ••;.. 1� •� 1��'a�:�{' �'�',. i •. ; . sal :L•��1 )'t!. �t•a '� �� 7 VI I ,. v^• 1•�.vr, i 1111'��U 11 li• 1t1,• �•� 'i •' 1 1 ��•��� i,, .l P,t i �1'�:.' �'t 'I r 1:i �• '�VC •� .`'+' .+ ' ,1 t j J,•� ;1,,1;1,/�� t. 1,��1� I,t. I' •:1 W~ •►:- '.t -r. ••;r;r � �•'. n a: to. i,, .. '• � , t _ •y1''l1)'!�H,��1�;;�'1' ''�� I,. !�,II ,I ,'I •�t ..,' ;�1� (.,' le '� 'r•:s�l,^!.t� �..y::�':.,�;� 's:�l!a,.: t .I•i.l 1"'1'J�.:o„� • �'il•,` '.:L...l•'r°f:' '.• �;' ,1' It•l1+,1�, ..IT ItE�s1: u:,•l�:S(1`:1'. ! t .. � . __....._,....;FtiMMs� �ii► tryr ' �--.:+.13•-`t `s.''.'—=�-i.J�'ii,��'ij��:i �„,,,.::i.,ll•I�: ...• :1::':... r j SECTION 13.0 CLARIFICATIONS AND REVISIONS TO THE DRAFT MASTER ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT Note to Reader: Section 13 consists of clarifications and revisions to the draft Master Environmental Impact Report (MEIR) for the Master Plan for Recreation Uses for Central Park (Master Plan) which has resulted from responses to comments received from responsible agencies and the public. The draft MEIR was released for a 45-day public review period between February 26 and April 12, 1999. The City of Huntington Beach received ten (10) timely letters and five (5) late letters commenting on the draft MEIR. The letters of comment received on the draft MEIR provided comments on land use and planning, geologic issues, water, air quality, transportation/circulation, biological resources, hazards, noise, public services, utilities and service systems, aesthetics, and recreation. As a result of responding to public and agency comments on the draft MEIR, clarifications and revisions were made to the Executive Summary (incorporation of changes to mitigation measures and additions of mitigation measures), Project Description, Water,Air Quality, Biological Resources, Hazards, Utilities, and Service Systems, Recreation, Organizations and Persons Consulted, and Distribution List for Environmental Impact Report. The City has determined that development of existing undeveloped areas of Huntington Central Park is required to provide adequate recreational opportunities for the anticipated 2010 population levels. Through their November 5, 1996 approval of Measure L, the Voters of the City of Huntington Beach authorized construction of a multi-field sport facility south of Talbert Avenue and east of Golden West Street on property that was formerly a landfill and mushroom farm site. Measure L seeks to enhance field availability for youth sports through relocation of existing adult softball leagues from Murdy and Edison Community Centers, making those areas available for youth sports (County of Orange General Services Agency 1996). The purpose of the proposed Master Plan is to plan for facilities and programs at Huntington Central Park that will continue to provide diverse recreation opportunities for all citizens consistent with the goals of the City of Huntington Beach General Plan adopted by City Council (1996a). The City of Huntington Beach designates Central Park as a regional park. The planning effort involves maintaining existing facilities as well as improving 136 acres of undeveloped and 14 acres of developed park land in a manner that is compatible with existing uses. An additional 7.5 acres of existing developed area at the Police/Civilian Gun Range is part of the program level environmental analysis. Any modification or relocation of the existing facility would be subject to subsequent environmental documentation. This section includes a copy of each page of the draft MEIR for which clarifications and revisions have been undertaken (the draft MEIR page number is indicated in the lower right corner of the page). Information being deleted from the draft MEIR text is indicated as Wit. Information being added in the response to agency and public comments on the draft MEIR is indicated in bolded and underlined text. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 13-1 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041 EI R I CNR 11096-004.S 13 I an equestrian center, an earthen dam, a midden area, a disc golf course, an open passive area, the Shipley Nature Center, two snack bar/restaurants, a dog park, walkways and parking facilities. S.2 PROPOSED ACTION The purpose of the proposed Master Plan is to plan for facilities and programs within the 157.5-acre study area that will continue to provide diverse recreation opportunities for all citizens consistent with the goals of the City of Huntington Beach General Plan. The Master Plan of Recreation Uses proposes four elements on 21.5 acres of existing developed areas of the Park: Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion (0.25 acre), Outdoor Music Area (0.25 acre), Consolidated Camping Area (13.5 acres), and Police/Civilian Gun Range (7.5 acres). T-Hese-farm Three of the four elements, Park, Tree,and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion, Outdoor Music Area, and Consolidated Camping Area, are located in an existing turfed area of the Park north of Talbert Avenue and the library, east of Golden West Street, south of Slater Avenue, and west of Gothard Street. The Police/Civilian Gun Range is located south of Talbert Avenue. Existing uses would remain unchanged within the remaining 199.3 acres of the total 220.8 acres of improved area within Central Park. Five additional elements are proposed for 136 acres in existing undeveloped areas of the Park: Sports Complex (45 acres), Low Intensity Recreation Area (16 acres), Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head (45 acres), Semi- Active Recreation Area (10 acres), Sully Miller Lake Group Facility (20 acres). These elements are proposed on undeveloped acres of the Park located north of Ellis Avenue, and east of Edwards Street, south of Talbert Avenue, and west of Gothard Street, and on an additional undeveloped parcel located north-:of the existing disc golf course, south of the Shipley Nature Center, and west of the Library and Golden West Street. There are seven and one-half(7.5) additional acres designated for the Police Gun Range that is part of the EIR's Program Level analysis. Any modification or relocation of the existing gun range facility would be subject to subsequent environmental documentation. For the proposes of this.Master EIR, the police/civilian gun range was analyzed as a non-operating facility which was its condition at the time of field reconnaissance in October 1997 and its current condition. A brief description of the elements of the proposed Master Plan follows: Project Level Elements • Construction of a Sports Field Complex: Forty-five (45) acres of the 136 remaining undeveloped acres has been designated for a Sports Complex. The proposed location for the Sports Complex consists of a 'L-shaped" parcel south of Talbert Avenue and east of Golden West Street. This element of the proposed Master Plan involves development of a 800 space gravel parking lot, a batting cage, up to four (4) roller hockey rinks, eight (8) lighted softball fields overlapping eight (8) lighted soccer/football fields, two(2)tot lots with accompanying shade structures, and two(2)restroom/concession buildings. • Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Expansion Area: Approximately one-quarter of an acre (9,600 square feet/0.25 acre) of the developed Park has been designated for expansion of the existing Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard. Construction activity will include expanding the existing Yard, adding a new chainlink fence, removing all existing shrubs, grading, and adding new plantings. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page S-2 W:IPROJECTSI 1096-0041EIRICNRI 1096-004.S 13 • Potential for erosion, drainage, and infiltration of irrigation water into underlying landfill material (Section 3.9, Hazards). • Traffic and Circulation Issues, including ingress/egress to the Police/Civilian Gun Range (Section 3.6, Transportation/Circulation). • Potential issues related to compatibility of construction and operation of proposed elements of the Master Plan with adjacent land uses (Section 3.1, Land Use and Planning). • Proposed placement of the Aquatic Center (as an alternate site) at the northwest corner of Ellis and Golden West Street (Section 3.1, Land Use and Planning). • Provision of adequate parking to support elements of the proposed Master Plan (Section 3.6, Transportation/Circulation). • Conversion of 0.25 acre of Huntington Central Park to support expansion of the Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Yard (Section 1.3, Purpose and Need). • Loss of overflow parking area from proposed improvements northwest at the intersection of Golden West Street and Ellis Avenue (Section 3.6, Transportation/Circulation). • Concern for impacts on archaeological resources from Urban Forest (Section 3.14, Cultural Resources). S.4 ISSUES TO BE RESOLVED The issues to be resolved by the City include the selection of alternatives, including the proposed project, and whether or how to mitigate the significant environmental effects of the proposed project. S.5 POTENTIAL IMPACTS FOUND TO BE NOT SIGNIFICANT In preparation of the Draft Master EIR, the City determined that there was no evidence that the proposed project would cause significant environmental effects in the following environmental impact areas: Land use, population and housing issues. In addition, after mitigation the following impact categories will have no significant environmental effects: water, air quality (long-term), transportation and circulation, biological resources, hazards, noise, public services, utilities, cultural resources, and recreation. Aesthetic impacts at the temporary site for the Ocean View Estates Mobile Homes from introduction of light and glare from night lighting of soccer/football field and softball fields remains significant after implementation of the specified mitigation measures. During construction, there will be significant unavoidable impacts to air quality: long-term cumulative air quality impacts from the proposed project will not be significant. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page S-5 W:IPRO)ECTSI 1096-0041EIRICNRI 1096-004.513 Water Issues:. .; 4 - Runoff generated from the Measure Water-1: Implementation of Measures Sports Complex The City of Huntington Beach will require that project design of the Sports Complex will be undertaken to Water-1 through-4 are improvements will result in ensure that there is no substantial increases in the rate and amount of surface runoff. Incidental drainage anticipated to reduce impacts on the existing 36- will be routed off of the site to existing storm drains to the north and west. It is assumed that potential impacts related to inch-diameter CMP between improvements to the existing storm drain system will be completed before project completion, as erosion and siltation,and Sully Miller Lake and Talbert described in Measure Utilities-3. increases in the rate and Lake. amount of surface runoff resulting from construction of the project-level elements Construction and operation Measure Water-2: below the level of of the Sports Complex,and The construction contractor will be required to incorporate Best Management Practices(BMPs)consistent significance. the Park,Tree and Landscape with the guidelines provided in the California Storm Water Best Management Practice Handbooks for Maintenance Expansion Area Construction and Industrial/Commercial Activities,and Appendices F and G of the DAMP. Revegetation of and program level elements cut and fill slopes resulting from project development will be undertaken with native vegetation or may result in degradation of compatible non-invasive drought tolerant species wherever feasible. Compliance with this mitigation water quality. Construction measure shall be demonstrated prior to issuance of grading permits or building permits,whichever activities related to comes first. implementation of the project and program level Measure Water-3: elements may result in The construction manager will be required to incorporate City Ordinance No. 3364 entitled "Storm Water increased erosion and/or and Urban Runoff Management"and Best Management Practices(BMPs)consistent with the guidelines siltation from exposure of provided in the California Storm Water Best Management Practice Handbooks:Municipal to ensure bare surfaces to runoff and control of flood hazards and water quality both during a id after eenstruetion aetivities prior to issuance of construction related water grading permits or building permits,whichever comes first. sources. Measure Water-4: The Semi-Active Recreation The City of Huntington Beach will reevaluate potential impacts to surface water quality from Area element may result in implementation of the Semi-Active Recreation Area and the Gun Range program level elements and degradation of surface water determine appropriate mitigation measures as are appropriate when these become project level elements. associated with equestrian related uses and discharge of chlorinated water. Irrigation water from the Implementation of Measure Sports Complex has the Hazards-5 is expected to potential to degrade Measure Hazards-5: reduce potential impacts on groundwater resources This measure is described in the Hazards Section of this Master EIR. groundwater from irrigation through increased infiltration of the Sports Complex below into the underlying landfill the level of significance_. material. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999(Screencheck Version) Page S-8 W.IPROJECTSI 1096-0041 EIRICNR11096-004.513 Air Quality Peak daily and quarterly Measure Air-1: Implementation of Mitigation emissions during Moisten soil each day prior to commencing grading to depth of soil cut. Measures Air-1 through-13 construction of project and will reduce air quality program level elements of Measure Air-2: impacts during the the Master Plan are expected Water exposed surfaces at least twice a day under calm conditions and as often as needed on windy days construction phase.These to exceed the SCAQMD when winds are Tess more than 25 miles per ma's'hour or during very dry weather in order to maintain a measures, however,will not standard for nitrogen oxides surface crust and prevent the release of visible emissions from the construction. reduce emissions of nitrogen and PM,o. oxides and PM,o to a less Measure Air-3: than significant level,and Treat any area that will be exposed to air for extended periods of time with a soil conditioner to stabilize therefore are considered soil or temporarily plant with vegetation. significant short-term construction impacts. Measure Air-4: Wash mud-covered tires and under-carriages of trucks leaving construction sites. Long term cumulative impacts from the proposed Measure Air-5: project will not be Provide for street sweeping,as needed,on adjacent roadways to remove dirt dropped by construction significant. The significant vehicles or mud which would otherwise be carried off by trucks departing project sites. impacts are short-term during construction and will not Measure Air-6: have a long-term impact on Securely cover all loads of fill coming to the site with a tight fitting tarp. either regional or local air quality. Measure Air-7: Cease grading during periods when winds exceed 25 miles per hour. Measure Air-8: Provide for permanent sealing of all graded areas,as applicable,at the earliest practicable time after soil disturbance. Measure Air-9: Maintain construction equipment in peak operating condition so as to reduce operation emissions. Measure Air-10: Use low-sulfur diesel fuel in all equipment. Measure Air-11: Use electric equipment whenever practicable. Measure Air-12: Shut off engines when not in use. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page S-9 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041 EI R I CNR 11096-004.S 13 Aii Quality.,continued Excavation of the landfill Measure Air-13: areas of the nark could Prior to beginning excavation in the area of the Huntington Landfill,an Excavation Management Plan result in the release of must be prepared. This Plan shall be submitted by the City to the SCAOMD under the requirements of noxious odors. Rule 1150. The Plan shall contain measures for mitigating odors. No excavation will begin until this plan has been reviewed by the SCAOMD Executive Officer and approved for its adequacy in mitigating all potential air quality impacts that could result from excavation of the landfill site. The Plan shall also address the possibility of other construction activities distributing and exposing odor-producing waste in areas of the park not undergoing direct excavation. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 5-9 W:1 PROJECT511096-0041 EIRICNRI 1096-004.513 Transportation and Circulation w The Sports Complex element Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-1: has a significant impact on Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan,the timing of the signal at LOS at the intersection of the intersection of Golden West Street and Slater Avenue shall be optimized by the City of Huntington Golden West Street and Beach to accommodate increased volume of traffic associated with this project element as indicated in the Slater Avenue. In addition, Traffic Impact Study(Appendix F) traffic congestion at the access/egress routes for the Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-2: proposed Sports Complex Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan,the City of Huntington are anticipated. Beach shall reconstruct the existing median on Golden West Street(at the location of proposed Driveway B)to accommodate a southbound left turn pocket. The storage length for the turn pocket shall be 200 feet with a 90-foot transition. Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-3: Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan,the City of Huntington Beach shall improve Driveway A to a full width of 30-feet to facilitate adequate site access. Driveway A shall be improved to incorporate 50 feet of throated driveway which would accommodate storage for the two vehicles. Adequate sight distance shall be provided for exiting vehicles to safely merge into Golden West Street. This measure is intended to avoid conflicts between offsite and onsite circulation. Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-4: Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan,the City of Huntington Beach shall improve Driveway B to a full width of 42 feet to facilitate adequate site access. Driveway B shall be improved to incorporate one lane inbound and two lanes outbound. Driveway B shall be improved to incorporate 100-feet of throated driveway which will accommodate storage for four vehicles in each lane. This measure is intended to avoid difficulties between offsite and onsite circulation. Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-5: Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan,the City of Huntington Beach shall construct the entrance component of Driveway C to accommodate a 100-feet throated entry to prevent queuing of vehicles into the cul-de-sac area. The entrance component of Driveway C shall be constructed to a width of 14-feet. This measure is required to prevent interference with signalized operations at the intersection of Talbert Avenue and Golden West Street. Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-6: Prior to completion of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan,the City of Huntington Beach shall construct the exit component of Driveway C to be aligned with an existing drive aisle in the library parking lot. The exit component of Driveway C shall be constructed to a width of 14-feet. Construction of the exit component of Driveway C shall include signage and striping to the specifications of the Traffic Division of the Public Works Department of the City of Huntington Beach to ensure appropriate direction of traffic flow. Adequate sight distance shall be provided for exiting vehicles.This measure is required to ensure adequate circulation within the new and existing parking areas. Measure Transportation/Circulation-7: Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the City of Huntington ]MIDlementation of Measures Beach shall construct Driveway D to a full width of 30-feet to facilitate adequate site access. Driveway D Trans ortation Circu ation-8 shall be improved to incorporate 50 feet of throated driveway which would accommodate storage for two through-10 are ex ecte to vehicles. Adequate sight distance shall be provided for exiting vehicles.This measure is intended to avoid reduce con estion related to on-site and off-site circulation difficulties. development of the Sports Com lex below thresholds Measure Trans ortation/Circulation-8: esta is e the Dunn t e imtia rve ears o o eration the Cityof Huntington Beach shall provide incentives to Con estion ana ement encourage transit use to and trorn the S orts Complex,as necessa to remain below Congestion A enc an the SouthCoast Management Agency an SouthCoast Air Clua itv Manazement Distnct thresholds tor congestion. Air Qua itv Management District. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 5-10 W:I PR OJEC T511096-0041 EIR I CNR 11096-004.513 Transbortation and:Circulation; continued, ` Measure Trans ortation/Circulation-9: During the in tial five years of operation,the City of Huntington Beach shall coordinate with the local transit agency to improve or increase service as necessa to remain below Con estion Management Agency an out oast Air Quality Management Agency t res o s or congestion. Measure Trans ortation/Circulation-10: Prior to construction t e city ot Huntin on Beach Public Works Department shall review the Plans and S eci ications to ensure that t ere wrement too offer security evebicycle racks at convenient an sa e locations has been inco[gorated into the Sports ComDlex.as necessa to remain below Congestion Management Agency an Southoast Air Quality Management Agency t res o s tor congestion. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 5-10 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041 EI R I CNR 11096-004.513 .Biological.Resources r._ Construction of the Sports Measure Biological Resources-1: All significant impacts are Complex adjacent to Sully Directed surveys for least Bell's vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher will be conducted prior to reduced to a level less than Miller Lake,and the Park commencing any construction activities near disturbed riparian habitats. Directed surveys for least Bell's significant with Tree and Landscape vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher will be conducted in accordance with the U.S.Fish and implementation of Measure Maintenance Yard Expansion Wildlife Service and California Department of Fish and Game published protocols for such surveys at Biological Resources-1 and Consolidated the time that such surveys are undertaken. If the presence of either species is confirmed,construction through 6. Conducting Campground adjacent to and design plans will be modified to avoid impacts to these species. directed surveys for sensitive Talbert Lake-Meadow could species potentially occurring potentially result in Measure Biological Resources-2: in riparian habitat in the park significant impacts to An environmental monitor will be present during grading and construction of the Park,Tree and prior to construction in these sensitive bird species Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion,. arrd the Consolidated Camping Area,and the Sully Miller Lake areas will allow for potentially occurring in Group Facility to ensure no unauthorized impacts occur to areas potentially subject to U.S.Army Corps of appropriate scheduling of riparian vegetation. Engineers jurisdiction or to existing disturbed riparian habitat in areas adjacent to elements of the construction activities to Implementation of the Park proposed Master Plan. The Construction Monitor shall hold a permit for directed surveys for least Bell's avoid impacts to these Tree and Landscape vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher.The Construction Monitor shall be authorized to issue a stop species if they are found to Maintenance Yard Expansion work order in the unlikely event that southwestern willow flycatcher or least Bell's vireo are determined be present. Presence of an and Consolidated Camp to be present in adiacent disturbed riparian habitat during construction. environmental monitor at all Ground elements could sites where grading is potentially impact riparian Measure Biological Resources-3: scheduled to occur adjacent habitat adjacent to these Directed surveys for six sensitive plant species that have the potential to be present in non-native to riparian habitat will ensure planned improvements. grassland, southern tarplant(Hemizonia parryi ssp.australis),Coulter's goldfields(Lasthenia glabrata ssp. no impacts occur to potential coulteri),Coulter's saltbush (Atriplex coulteri),south coast saltscale(Atriplex pacifica), many-stemmed wetlands or habitat for In their ioint letter of dudleya(Dudleya multicaulis), and intermediate Mariposa lily(Calochortus weedii var. intermedius) will sensitive species. comment,the U.S. Fish and be conducted prior to moving forward with program level elements which will impact non-native Wildlife Service and the grasslands within the Park. Directed surveys for the six sensitive plants will be conducted in accordance Implementation of Measure California Department of with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and California Department of Fish and Game published protocols Biological Resources-6 will Fish and Game suggested for such surveys at the time that such surveys are undertaken. In the absence of a published protocol, reduce possible proiect- that a cowbird abatement such surveys will be undertaken in accordance with Guidelines for Assessinz the Effects of Proposed related effects to the vireo, grogram be developed and Developments on Rare and Endangered Plants and Plant Communities prepared by the California flycatcher,or any sensitive implemented to preclude Department of Fish and Game. songbird species that breed possible project-related within five miles of the effects to the vireo, Measure Biological Resources-4: project site below the level flycatcher,or any sensitive Potential impacts to foraging habitat for raptors resulting from development of non-native grasslands in the of significance. songbird species that breed Park could be mitigated by enhancing ruderal7bme conserved areas of non-native grassland at a ratio of within five miles of the 1:1 for acres of impact on non-native grassland to provide suitable habitat values and functions for prey project site. speeies raptors. Mitigation for impacts on non-native grassland will be accomplished within conserved non-native grasslands in association with the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility, Low Intensity Recreation Area,Semi-Active Recreation Area,and Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead. Additionally, strategie planthig of tmes in the developed areas to allovy broad,epeii areas for foraging would mitigate for less o Enhancement of non-native grassland would include,but not be limited to,the Wanting of native trees within and adiacent to conserved areas of non-native grassland. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page S-1 1 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 EIR I CNR 11096-004.S 13 Measure Biological Resources-5: Program level improvements Potential impacts resulting from implementation of the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility element would be planned for the non-native mitigated through creation and enhancement of disturbed riparian habitats in the Shipley Nature Center grasslands within the park and Talbert Lake-Meadow at a ratio of 3:1 for acres of impact. could result in a significant loss of foraging habitat for Measure Biological Resources-6: raptors at the park. Lastly, Concurrent with operation of the Sports Complex,the City shall implement or cause to be implemented the development of areas a brown-headed cowbird trapping program.The brown-headed cowbird trapping program will be surrounding Sully Miller submitted to the Service for review and comment at least three months prior to the beginning of Lake could potentially result grading. in significant impacts to riparian habitat,which is Traps used to remove cowbirds will be modified Australian crow traps. These traps allow live capture of potential habitat for the least birds so that non-target birds can be released unharmed. The traps will be"baited"with live iuvenile or Bell's vireo and southwest female brown-headed cowbirds which will be captured prior to the trapping period with baited traps or willow flycatcher. mist nets. The juvenile or female cowbirds attract the attention of adult birds and lure them into traps. Once inside the trap,it is difficult for the birds to escape and they can be easily removed. Approximately four bait birds are kept in a separate cage within the trap and are not removed until the trapping season is over. The traps will be placed and maintained so as to provide trapped and bait birds ample shade,food,and water while they are in traps.All cowbirds(male,female,and iuvenile)that are caught in the traps will be disposed of humanely. Trapping will take place during the nesting period of riparian bird species found in Central Park that are known to be parasitized by brown-headed cowbirds.Traps will be checked daily during the trapping period to remove both trapped cowbirds and non-target species,which will be released. Bait birds lost to predation or escape will be replaced during the daily checks. An annual letter report documenting the results of the trapping program will be submitted to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Results of the trapping program will be recorded including the date and time of trap checking,observer(s),weather,age of trapped birds(both target and non-target species),the treatment of the birds(whether released,disposed of,or retained as bait birds),and other data nertaining to any unusual event,such as predation or loss of bait birds. Energy and Mineral Resqurce§ . No significant impact. No mitigation required. Not applicable. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 5-I I W.IPROJECTS11096-0041EIR ICNRI 1096-004.513 Hazards . ��£. � � V' Construction in thq vicinity Measure Hazards-1• Implementation of Measures of existingplug�ged and The plans and specifications for construction of the Sports Complex will reflect the need to reabandon the Hazards-1 through-+215 abandone we s has the existin plunge and abandoned oil well within the ro osed development area consistent with Cit of will reduce impacts relaTed potential to expose people Huntington 73each Specification Number 422. Reabandonment will be undertaken during construction of to hazards below the level of and property to hazards. the Sports Complex element of the Master Plan. signiticance Measure Hazards-2: The plans andspecifications for construction of the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility element will reflect the need to reabandon two existing plug ged and abandoned oil wells within the proposed development area consistent with City of Huntin ton t3each Specification Number 422. Reabandonment will be undertaken during construction of the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility element. Measure Hazards-3: The plans and specifications for the Midd n Area/�rban ForestlTrailhead Improvements and the Semi- Active Recreation Area improvements will reflect t e need to reabandon twenty-nine(29)existing plugged and abandoned wells within the proposed development area consistent with City of Huntington Beach Specification Number 422. Re abandonment will be undertaken during construction of theMidden Area/Urban ForestlTraiIhead Improvements and the Semi-Active Recreation rea elements of the Master Plan of Recreation Uses. Construction in the vicinity Measure Hazards-4- of methane rich soils has the Studies to evaluate the potential for landfill gas(LFG)generation and migration will be completed prior to potential to expose people development of the Sports Complex. Appropriate mitigation measures will be coordinated with the South and property to hazards. Coast Air Quality Management District,Solid Waste Local Enforcement Agency(LEA), RWQCB,and the City of Huntington Beach Fire Department., Mitigation measures could entail active or passive extraction of LFG to control surface and offsite miQration and passive barriers with vent layers and alarm systems below all enclosed structures on and wRhin 1,000 feet of the landfill boundary. A comprehensive monitoring network will be established around the perimeter of the landfill. Periodic monitoring of the monitoring network and at locations above the surface of the landfill will be performed. Measure Hazards-5: Wherl the City of Huntington Beach determines th need to include irrigated land uses over areas under ain by refuse as part of the Spports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan,the plans and specifications will reflect the need to incorporate a more elaborate cover system to control moisture infiltration into the refuse. A suitable cover system could consist of a synthetic,geomembrane,geotextile fabric for protection of ggeomembrane and filtering for the drainage layer,a drainage layer, and a vegetation layer or an approved alfernative. Operation of recreation Measure Hazards-6: facilities in proximity to The City of Huntington Beach shall prepare an Emergency Evacuation Plan for potential impacts related to Golden West Street and the (1.)potential hazardous materials release on Golden West Street, or(2)a rupture or explosion in the oil field area west of Golden vicinity of the oil field area west of Golden West Street. West Street has the potential to expose people and property to hazards. Construction of the Sports Measure Hazards-7: Complex, Sully Mill r Lake Plans and specifications for the Sports Complex,the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility,Midden Area/Urban Group Facility,MiZen Forest/Tra i I head Improvements and the Semi-Active Recreation Area will identify the potential to Are Forest/Trai I head encounter oil saturated soils during excavation. If oil-saturated soil is encountered during excavation, and the Semi-Active plans and specifications shall requir the construction foreman to contact the City of Huntington Beach, Recreation Use Area has the who shall contact the Department olConservation, Division of Oil, Gas,and Geothermal Resources potential to expose (DOGGR)and follow appropriate guidance. construction crew to oil saturated soils during excavation. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 5-1 1 W:IPROJECTSI1096-004IEIRICW 1096-004.513 "Hazards,continued AL Construction in the vicinity Measure Hazards-8: of methane rich soils has the Appropriate methane mitigation features such as gas detectors,gas migration barriers,venting systems,and potential to exacerbate classified electrical installation shall be incorporated into plans and specifications for all proposed lateral migration of methane. structures overlaying the former landfill and within 1,000 feet of the perimeter of the landfill. Design consideration for potential LFG migration through pipes,trenches,or other conduits shall be incorporated into Plans and Specifications. Methane migration features will be consistent with the requirements of the City of Huntington Beach Specification Number 429 and other applicable State and Federal regulations. The methane migration features shall be submitted for review and approval to the Orange County Health Care Agency, Environmental Health Division,which is the LEA for all cities and unincorporated areas of Orange County. Measure Hazards-9: Any unrecorded or unknown wells uncovered during the excavation or grading process shall be immediately reported to and coordinated with the City and DOGGR. In addition,should any unknown and unexpected landfills be excavated and discovered during the construction phase of the proposed proiect,construction work will be immediately halted and LEA will be notified. Further construction operations will resume at the discretion of LEA and upon work approval by LEA. Measure Hazards-10: Any redevelopment within the known oil field will shall be conducted in conformance with City requirements. City requirements include those outlined in Article 79 of the Uniform Fire Code(UFC). Construction in the vicinity of active oil wells has the Measure Hazards-11: potential to expose people to The City Fire Department will prepare a Fire Risk Evaluation prior to issuance of grading permits. hazards. Measure Hazards-12: Plans and specifications for the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head Improvements shall include construction of an 8-foot high block wall enclosure around extant active oil wells and associated equipment. The block wall enclosures will include suitable gates which are capable of accommodating large workover equipment into the well sites. Landscaping that is climbable along the wall shall be prohibited,since it defeats the purpose of the wall. Suitable vehicular access for well workover equipment shall be provided for active wells. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 5-13 W:I PROJECTS11096-0041 EI RI CNR 11096-004.513 Hazards,continued Measure Hazards-13: Prior to construction of a Run range,a preliminary endangerment assessment(PEA)should be completed to screen the site for potential human and ecological health risks associated with possible contaminants including drilling muds,petroleum products,solid wastes,heavy metals,nolycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and polychlorinated biphenyls. Measure Hazards-14: The City of Huntington Beach will prepare an Excavation Management Plan prior to beginning excavation within the limits of the landfill which will be submitted to and approved by the executive officer of the SCAOMD. This Plan shall identify mitigation measures to be activated as necessary during excavation to ensure that a public nuisance condition does not occur.Mitigation measures shall be selected after consideration of the physical characteristics of the landfill. Measure Hazards-15: Prior to construction of the Sports Complex,Park,Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion, Consolidated Camping Area,and Low-Intensity Recreation elements of the Master Plan,the City of Huntington Beach Fire Department and Public Works Department shall review all construction plans and specifications to ensure that the specifications reauire that each contractor involved in grading activities develop a site-and action-specific comprehensive Health and Safety Plan. The plans and specifications will require that the Health and Safety Plan be developed using the information available about past uses of those sites and the possibility that solid waste,PCH-contaminated soils,and/or potentially hazardous waste materials could be encountered. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 5-13 W IPROJECTS11096-0041EIR1CNR11096-004.513 Norse a tee: Construction and operation Measure Noise-1: It is anticipated that of the proposed facilities The City of Huntington Beach shall restrict amplified voice announcement systems for the Southwest implementation of Measures could result in impacts on Softball Fields. This restriction will alleviate noise impacts at residences at the Ocean View Estates such Noise-1 and-2 will reduce ambient noise levels in the that noise ordinance limits are not exceeded. long-term operational adjacent land uses impacts associated with the (especially on the Ocean Measure Noise-2: Southwest Softball field View Estates mobile homes) The City of Huntington Beach shall restrict use of the Southwest Softball Fields after 10:00 p.m. The lights below the level of shall be turned off at this time and the fields closed. This restriction will alleviate noise impacts at significance. residences at the Ocean View Estates. Measure Noise-3: Implementation of Measures The City of Huntington Beach shall limit grading and construction activities to daily operation hours Noise-3 through-5 will between 7:00 a.m. and 7:00 p.m.(Monday through Friday)and 8:00 a.m.to 5:00 p.m.on Saturdays. reduce short-term Construction shall not take place on Sundays or Federal holidays. construction noise impacts at adjacent residential Measure Noise-4: properties below the level of The construction manager shall ensure that all construction and grading equipment is properly maintained significance, as well. No and turned off when not in use. additional noise impacts are anticipated from the project Measure Noise-5: level elements. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has estimated that noise levels from construction equipment can be lowered by as much as 13 dBA by implementing noise control features that require no major redesign or extreme cost. The City of Huntington Beach shall require that all construction equipment incorporate noise reduction control features. All vehicles and compressors should utilize exhaust mufflers, and engine enclosure covers as designed by the manufacturer should be in place at all times. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 5-13 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 EI RI CNRI 1096-004.S 13 SECTION 1.0 INTRODUCTION This master environmental impact report (Master EIR) has been prepared by the City of Huntington Beach to assess the environmental consequences of the proposed Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Huntington Central Park (Appendix A). The City of Huntington Beach is the lead agency for this proposed project pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). Huntington Central Park is centrally located in the City of Huntington Beach, northeast of the future Harriett M. Wieder Regional Park, Orange County, California (Figure 1.0-1, Regional Map). Golden West Street and Talbert Avenue cut through the center of the Park. The Park site street boundaries are Slater Avenue on the north, Gothard Street on the east, Ellis Avenue on the south, and Edwards Street on the west. The site is depicted on U.S.G.S. 7.5 minute series Seal Beach and Newport Beach topographic quadrangle maps, Range 11 West, Township 5 South, Southeast corner of Section 27, West '/2 of section 26, Northeast quarter of Section 34 and Northwest quarter of Section 35 (Figure 1.0-2, Vicinity Map). The City acquired the Park with park bonds, subdivision fees, Housing and Urban Development (HUD) grants and county revenue sharing funds through a series of transactions beginning in 1969 and continuing up to the present time. The City's decision to buy the Park resulted from its objective to provide adequately sized and located active and passive parklands to meet the recreation needs of existing and future residents, and to preserve natural resources within the City of Huntington Beach and its sphere of influence. The official park dedication occurred in 1974. Huntington Central Park is 356.8 acres of which 220.8 acres are developed (Figure 1.0-3, Existing Conditions). The remaining 136 acres are undeveloped. The planning effort involves maintaining existing facilities as well as improving 136 acres of undeveloped and 14 acres of developed park land in a manner that is compatible with existing uses. An additional 7.5 acres of existing developed area at the Police/Civilian Gun Range is part of the program level environmental analysis. Any modification or relocation of the existing facility would be subject to subsequent environmental documentation. The purpose of the proposed Master Plan is to plan for facilities and programs within the 157.5.-acre study area which is comprised of 136 acres of existing undeveloped area and 21.5 acres of existing developed area of the Park. The purpose of the proposed Master Plan elements are to provide diverse recreation opportunities for all citizens consistent with the Huntington Beach City Goals of the General Plan adopted by City Council (1996a). The Master Plan of Recreation Uses proposes four elements on 21.5 acres of existing developed areas of the Park: Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion (0.25 acre), Outdoor Music Area (0.25 acre), Consolidated Camping Area (13.5 acres), and Police/Civilian Gun Range (7.5 acres). The first three elements are located in an existing turfed area of the Park north of Talbert Avenue and the library, east of Golden West Street, south of Slater Avenue, and west of Gothard Street. The Police/Civilian Gun Range is located south of Talbert Avenue, east of Golden west street, north of Ellis Avenue, and west of Gothard Street. Existing uses would remain unchanged within the remaining 199.3 acres of the total 220.8 acres of improved area within Central Park. Five additional elements are proposed for 136 acres in existing undeveloped areas of the Park: Sports Complex (45 acres), Low Intensity Recreation Area (16 acres), Midden/Urban Forest/Trai I head (45 acres), Semi-Active Recreation Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 1-1 W.1 PROJECT511096-0041 EIRICNRI 1096-004.513 i SLATED!AVENS --�--� ' SYMBOL LEGEND P DENOTES DOSTING .I ' t PARIONG LOT P PA DENOTES E)QS7ING I )S JJ PLAY AREA 16� PA r R4! a i R DENOTES DdSTING RESTROOI PAMJTY j = "'-Pic ,, `.,}4..; 17 i CITY PARK,TREE AND LANDSCAPE • DENOTES DOSTING MAINTENANCE YARD — PARCOURSE STATION ` ['a.. 13 " A ` 'JACK GREEN NATURE .A�* ' CONSERVATION AREA r- 12 All 1 P I' 1 11 Pr CAMPING AREA` I RESTAURANT R ' PARCOURSE WITH'. P All R STATIONS NOTEDT`y 1 QI ALBERT LAKE- . '. OVERFLOW j rSHIPLE NNATURE MEADOW , A: 9 A'CAMPING AREA 1 AMP HITHEATER PHITHEATER— J1' LOW y.. OUTDOOR r� X - MAINTENANCE MU R SIC 17 L� QA GARDEN AREA ADVENTURE. i }t J• I s 6 �l PLAYGROUND . 3 UBRARY P YOUTH SHELTER i 1 4 P TM PAR1C 5 '' \��'✓ t f q L.`T 1 ALO T:. Ave+lJE— P I � r P R . PA PICNIC v} J RESTAURANT PA I, ISC iP. AREA . �. HUNTINGTON PICNIC °c, ORANGE COUNTY R;• � GUN i PA LAKE FISHING DOCK COURSE - RANGE TRANSFER STATION _ L I`� r, DOG PARK �, `".� `�z �-�i `:`~`' `'� �U ,� r_na-r-• g ,. . DETENTION np p _ -:c..-CE /f r BASIN " G`IIIY}l�> P � PI EENTEIRMI r II`�y'?\ R SULLY 'I' MILLER ), LAKE EARTHEN F TEMPORARY ! t`�,'iu irMPF' `r MULTWSE TRAILS pt,M OVERFLOW OCEAN VIEW ,.•.•. t;i r 1 ' AREA E5IATES MOBILE / OIL. �. .:=C, .�^ _. v HOMES '. g ,✓ % _. _- DESILTATION - - �wz BASIN r� NOTE: N LJ v I S Legend �:+. =WA ORANGE COUNTY TRANSFER STATION SHALL BE USE_ AS A DAY LABOR CENTER. THE CENTER IS SCHEDULED TO BE IN PLACE IN 1999. A.c P L A..,.0 0 200' 400' 800, .ALL AREAS SHOWN HEREON ARE EXISTING. FIGURE 1.0-3 mSfl mP Efll'IflOflfflEflifl6 Existing Conditions Huntington Central Park Master EIR rnource planning Huntington Beach, California 2.3 PROJECT IMPROVEMENTS The proposed development improvements at the Park are consistent with the objectives established by the City of Huntington Beach for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses, Huntington Central Park. The May 13, 1996 Huntington Beach General Plan describes existing Parks and Recreation facilities in the "Recreation and Community Service Element." Huntington Central Park is described as one of two existing regional parks (City of Huntington Beach, 1996a). The Draft Youth Sports Needs Assessment Study(19970 defines regional facilities in the City of Huntington Beach to include parks of greater than 100 acres in size and are intended to serve the population within a 60-minute driving distance. There are several alternatives that were developed for the Master Plan. These are examined in Section 4: Alternatives to the Proposed Project, of this document. Of these alternatives, the City Council identified Modified Project 4A as the proposed Master Plan for the purposes of this Master EIR (Figure 2.3-1, Proposed Project). The proposed Master Plan maintains the current existing recreation uses of the Park, while adding additional recreation uses and enhancing existing facilities on fourteen (14) acres of the developed park. In addition, this planning effort involves improving 136 vacant acres in a manner that is compatible with existing uses, that meets the City General Plan objectives, and that meets the Park's Master Plan goals. Two program elements of the Master Plan, Police/Civilian Gun Range and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility, may require substantial improvements to ensure the safety of recreation uses. Such improvements would be considered in subsequent environmental documentation. Site preparation and construction of the project and program level elements of the Master Plan will be undertaken in accordance with all federal, state, and City building codes. City ordinance allows $daily construction activities wa+ to be undertaken Monday through Saturday (excluding Federal holidays), between the hours of 7:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. As a result of mitigation measures recommended in conjunction with the Master Plan, the City has determined to limit grading and construction activities to between 7:00 a.m. and 7:00 p.m. on Mondays through Fridays and between 8:00 am and 5:00 pm on Saturdays. Construction equipment will be turned off when not in use. All grading and earthwork will be performed under the observation of a geotechnical engineer to ensure proper subgrade preparation, selection of satisfactory materials, and placement and compaction of structural fills. Any unanticipated adverse conditions encountered will be evaluated by the project engineering geologist and the soil engineer, and the appropriate recommendation made and followed. If possible, grading activities will be undertaken during the non-rainy season (April 15 to October 15) to reduce the potential for soil erosion and increased surface runoff to result in adverse impacts on water quality. The plans and specifications for the proposed project will include a requirement for the construction contractor to comply with all provisions of the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Program administered by the California Regional Water Quality Control Board as they relate to avoiding impacts on stormwater quality during construction. The construction contractor will be required to incorporate Best Management Practices consistent with the guidelines provided in the California Storm Water Best Management Practice Handbooks: Construction Activities. Should the construction period continue into the rainy season, supplemental erosion measures would need to be implemented, including but not limited to the following: • Mulching • Geotextiles and mats • Earth Dikes Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 2-5 W.I PROJECT511096-0041 EIRICNRI 1096-004.513 I mobilization,demolition,clearing and grubbing,earthwork and grading, drainage structures, methane gas mitigation, electrical for security and athletic lighting, asphaltic concrete and concrete placement, gravel placement, minor structure assembly, complete automatic irrigation system, site furniture, and installation of plant material. All new electrical service lines are required to be underground. Phase I construction activity is estimated at 38 weeks. Phase I will include the improvements along the west side of the complex which can be generally described as the gravel parking lot, batting cage, roller hockey rinks, four (4) of the eight (8) lighted softball fields, four (4) of the eight (8) lighted soccer/football fields, one (1) of the two (2) tot lots, and one (1) of the two (2) restroom/concession buildings. Phase II construction activity is estimated at 22 weeks. Phase II will include the remainder of the improvements on the northeast corner of the site which can be generally described as four (4) of the eight (8) lighted softball fields, four (4) of the eight (8) lighted soccer/football fields, one (1) of the two (2) tot lots, and one (1) of the two (2) restroom/concession buildings. It is anticipated that the Contractor will utilize the most westerly portion of the proposed Phase II soccer fields for construction staging. Based upon the preliminary grading plan, a net import of 110,000 cubic yards will be required. Rough and precise grading will be required on the entire forty-five (45) acre site. Estimated construction crew for Phase I and Phase II are provided in Table 2.3.1-1 Estimated Phase 1 Construction Crew Sports Complex and Table 2.3.1-2 Estimated Phase II Construction Crew Sports Complex. Estimates of construction crews are provided in man days which are a measure of the amount of work to be completed by a single person in a single day. The anticipated truck trips in support of construction of improvements which are being analyzed at the project level of detail are summarized in Table 2.3.1-3, Required Dump Truck Trips. A total of 9,116 truck trips will be required during construction. Most of the trips will be required to deliver the 110,000 cubic yards of fill required at the site. Assuming fifty-five (55) weeks of the sixty (60) week construction schedule is available for hauling fill to the site, the interval between trucks would be approximately seventeen (17) minutes. Fill in this quantity is currently available from the Santa Ana River via the U.S. Interstate 405 Freeway. "Downstream" soils most likely will need some degree of environmental testing prior to City of Huntington Beach park placement. To minimize community impacts resulting from truck traffic, the less residential Gothard Street will be used as the major haul route from the 405 Freeway to the site. Gothard Street can be reached by exiting 1-405 south onto Golden West, east on Edinger and then south onto Gothard Street. Once at the site, the existing "service" road leading to the gun range would provide a route to the construction site which avoids other existing recreation and library uses at the Park. The existing "service" road leading to the Gun Range is within County property identified as "the existing Orange County Transfer Station No. 2." Any proposed use of the road requires permission from the County. There are no anticipated road closures. A variety of construction equipment would be utilized during grading activities including bulldozers with sheepsfoot, scrapers, motor graders, water cat/water truck/vibratory compactor and bottom dump trucks. During utility construction, equipment would include backhoes, track excavator/water truck, and air compressor/jackhammer, and concrete saw. Facility construction would involve the use of trenchers/forklift,small crane/concrete pump, concrete finishing machines,and Skilsaws. The amount of each type of construction equipment anticipated to be required during each phase of construction is provided in Table 2.3.1-4, Construction Equipment. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 2-9 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041 EI R ICNR 11096-004.S 13 Construction Scenario As envisioned, this element of the proposed Master Plan requires limited construction activity. Construction staging will be accomplished within the limits of the proposed project. All construction material will be transported north or south on Gothard Street with no lane closures required. Precise grading is estimated at approximately 230 cubic yards. Cut and fill are anticipated to be balanced onsite. Construction is estimated at three to four weeks. Construction activities will consist of mobilization, clearing and grubbing, demolition, precise grading and drainage, sub-base preparation, AC paving and concrete placement, structure assembly, site furniture installation, electrical, installation of new irrigation, installation of new plant material, clean-up, and inspection. Vehicles will generally originate from 405 Freeway and Golden West Street. Post-installation maintenance will continue for a period of ninety days following construction. Construction activities can be completed by a 15 member crew. There are a total seventy-one (71) truck trips anticipated in support of the proposed construction activity. An additional four truck trips per week are anticipated during the post-installation maintenance period. Truck trips are shown in Table 2.3.1-7, Outdoor Music Area Truck Trips. TABLE 2.3.1-7 OUTDOOR MUSIC AREA TRUCK TRIPS TRUCK TYPE CONSTRUCTION POST 1INSTALLATION OTAL MAINTENANCE (per.wee Full Size Pick-up Truck 23 4 Full Size Pick-up Truck with Cab 28 - 16 Wheeler 1 - Dump Trucks 17 - Delivery Truck with Flatbed 2 - TOTAL 71 4 2.3.2 Program Level Improvements Low-Intensity Recreation Area Sixteen 06) acres of the remaining undeveloped 136 acres of Huntington Central Park have been designated for additional picnic and low-intensity recreation activities. The proposed location for this element of the proposed Master Plan is a rectangular parcel west of Golden West Street and south of the Shipley Nature Center, north of the existing disc golf course, and east of the existing passive picnic area on Cliff View Lane. Project elements and construction activity would be determined when this feature moved forward as a capital improvement project. General elements/activities might include mobilization, grading and drainage, electrical, asphaltic concrete (parking area) and concrete placement, minor structure assembly to provide shade overheads with barbecue and picnic amenities, restroom, tot lot, open turf area, complete automatic irrigation system, site furniture, and installation of plant material. At least four(4) acres of the existing non-native grassland would be maintained and enhanced to conserve suitable foraging habitat for birds. The City may choose to consider the incorporation of an Urban Forest Element at this location in addition to or as an alternative to implementation of the Urban Forest element in association with the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head element identified in the Master Plan. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 2-16 W.I PROJECTS 11096-0041 EIR I CNR 11096-004.S 13 1 Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead Forty-five (45) acres of the remaining undeveloped 136 acres have been designated for preservation of the Native American midden archaeological area; a citizen-participation urban forest planting program; in addition to a trailhead, viewpoint and multi-use recreation trails for equestrian, pedestrian, and non-motorized cyclist. The site identified for this element of the proposed Master Plan consists of a "L-shaped" parcel located south of the existing Dog Park and Equestrian Center, west of Golden West Street, north of Ellis Avenue, and east of Edwards Street. Project elements and construction activity would be determined when this feature moved forward as a capital improvement project. General elements/activities might include mobilization, grading and drainage, electrical, asphaltic concrete and concrete placement, structure assembly to provide shade overheads, a restroom at trailhead, complete automatic irrigation system, site furniture, and installation of plant material. At least twenty-four(24)acres of the existing non-native grassland would be maintained and enhanced to conserve suitable foraging habitat for birds. Semi Active Recreation Area Ten (10) acres of the remaining undeveloped 136 acres have been designated for the City's therapeutic riding school facilities, an open turf field for recreation that will also provide for overflow parking during special events at the existing equestrian center, and as the proposed alternative site for an aquatic/swim center. This element of the proposed Master Plan is located on a roughly square parcel (a.k.a. as the Marion property) immediately northwest of the intersection of Ellis Avenue and Golden West Street. Project elements and construction activity would be determined when this feature moved forward as a capital improvement project. General elements/activities might include mobilization, grading and drainage, electrical, asphaltic concrete and concrete placement, minor and - major structure assembly, complete automatic irrigation system, site furniture, and installation of plant material. Sully Miller Lake Group Facility Twenty (20)'acres of the remaining undeveloped 136 acres have been designated for a group picnic and fishing facility. This element of the proposed Master Plan consists of a roughly rectangular parcel that surrounds and includes the existing Sully Miller Lake, located north of Ellis Avenue and east of the existing Ocean View Mobile Homes. The analysis in this Master EIR is based on plans that currently include one or two docks, restrooms/tackle and bait shop, a volleyball area, an open turf area, and shade overheads. Project elements and construction activity would be determined when this feature moved forward as a capital improvement project. General elements/activities might include mobilization, major grading and earthwork operations, drainage structures, electrical, asphaltic concrete and concrete placement, minor structure assembly, complete automatic irrigation system, site furniture, and installation of plant material. Police/Civilian Gun Range The seven and one-half(7.5) acres gun range was operated by the Police Officer's Association from the late 1960s to January 4, 1997 when the City Council terminated the year-to-year tenancy lease. Part Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 2-16 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EI R ICNR 11096-004.513 which is currently used as detention storage for surrounding drainage systems. Water flows northerly from Sully Miller Lake into Talbert Lake via a 36-inch corrugated metal pipe (CMP). In the January 1993 City of Huntington Beach Master Plan of Drainage, the City concluded that the 36-inch diameter pipe connecting Sully Miller Lake and Talbert Lake is inadequate and should be enlarged to a 108-inch diameter pipe. A contrary conclusion was later made by an additional study prepared in July of 1993 (City of Huntington Beach 1993a). In this report, the storage capacity of Sully Miller Lake was evaluated based on a 100-year storm event and the possibility that the 36-inch diameter CMP did not connect the two lakes. It was concluded that Sully Miller Lake is adequate to provide adequate flood protection even with the 36-inch diameter pipeline being inoperable. The current position of the City is that the existing 36-inch diameter CMP is damaged to the extent that it no longer provides flood control protection, particularly as the pipe is intended to convey stormwater overflow from Sully Miller Lake to the Slater Channel area. The Flood Insurance Rate Map, prepared under the National Flood Insurance Program, does not indicate any 100-year flood hazard areas within the project-level areas. The Flood Insurance Rate Map does, however, indicate that program level elements north of Lake Talbert and in the vicinity of Lake Huntington and an area west of it, are located in a flood zone A99, or a zone subject to flooding during a 100-year storm event. No 100-year flood hazard has been delineated for the remaining portion of the program level areas. The hydrology of the Holly Seacliff development project draining to Sully Miller Lake from the south of Ellis Avenue was studied for the development of the Urban West Communities, Tract 14659 (City of Huntington Beach 1995d). The improvements designed for this development to mitigate for construction silt and debris included a new detention basin upstream of one of the existing double 72-inch diameter reinforced concrete pipe (RCP) crossing at Ellis Avenue. The subject area lies within the watershed of East Garden Grove-Wintersburg Channel. The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) and the County of Orange are studying flood hazards associated with East Garden Grove Wintersburg Channel as part of floodplain re-zoning efforts of the Santa Ana River (SAR). The zone is currently zoned as A-99 by FEMA because of the SAR. When the SAR floodplain zone(A-99) is removed,anticipated in late 1999,as a consequence of the SAR federal project. FEMA is likely to show portions underlying the SAR floodplain as a residual floodplain resulting from East Garden -Wintersburg Channel. This will require floodplain regulations to be followed for insurable structures within the residual floodplain area. Portions of the Proposed Project area could fall within this floodplain. If that is the case, those areas would be subject to floodplain regulations which might require mitigation. Groundwater The City of Huntington Beach provides drinking water to the Park that is collected from a series of groundwater wells within the City. The wells tap into the Talbert Aquifer, a confined aquifer of sand and gravel extending approximately 130 feet below ground surface (bgs) to over 1,300 feet bgs. According to the City of Huntington Beach Water Division, local groundwater accounts for approximately 90 percent of the water provided for domestic service; the remaining 10 percent is made up of water purchased from the Metropolitan Water District, which obtains its supply from the Colorado River and State Water Projects. All water supplies at the Park meet the regulatory requirements for the State of California, Department of Health Services for maximum contamination levels. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.4-4 W IPROJECT511096-0041EIRICNRI1096-004.513 In past field investigations conducted for the landfill (Kleinfelder 1990a and 1990b), no groundwater has been encountered. Previously available data in the vicinity of the project location indicates that groundwater is located approximately 54 feet below existing ground surface. Actual groundwater conditions may vary depending on landscaping irrigation and seasonal conditions. 3.4.3 Impacts This section analyzes the potential for significant impacts on water that would occur from implementation of the proposed project. The threshold for determining if significant impacts on water would occur is based on Appendix G of the California Environmental Quality Act Statutes and Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999(Screencheck Version) Page 3.4-4 W:IPROJECTSI1096-0041EIRICNR11096-004.513 I Measure Water-2. The construction contractor will be required to incorporate Best Management Practices (BMPs) consistent with the guidelines provided in the California Storm Water Best Management Practice Handbooks for Construction and Industrial/Commercial Activities, and Appendices F and G of the DAMP. Revegetation of cut and fill slopes resulting from project development will be undertaken with native vegetation or compatible non-invasive drought tolerant species wherever feasible. Compliance with this mitigation measure shall be demonstrated prior to issuance of grading permits or building permits, whichever comes first. Measure Water-3. The construction manager will be required to incorporate City Ordinance No. 3364 entitled "Storm Water and Urban Runoff Management' and Best Management Practices (BMPs) consistent with the guidelines provided in the California Storm Water Best Management Practice Handbooks: Municipal to ensure control of flood hazards and water quality both eltiring and after eomstruetwom aetivities prior to issuance of grading_permits or building permits, whichever comes first. Measure Water-4. The City of Huntington Beach will reevaluate potential impacts to surface water quality from implementation of the Semi-Active Recreation Area and the Gun Range program level elements and determine appropriate mitigation measures as are appropriate. 3.4.5 Level of Significance After Mitigation Implementation of Measures Water-1 through -4 are anticipated to reduce potential impacts related to erosion and siltation, and increases in the rate amount of runoff resulting from construction of the project level elements below the level of significance. Implementation of Measure Hazards-5, which appears in Section 3.9 of this Master EIR, is expected to reduce impacts on groundwater from irrigation of the Sport Complex element to below the level of significance. Huntington Central Park blaster Plan of Recreation Uses final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.4-8 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EI R I CNR 11096-004.513 restricts emissions of fugitive dust, applies primarily to controlling emissions during construction and specifies mitigation measures to reduce sources of fugitive dust. The proposed Sports Complex is partially underlain by the Huntington Landfill, as are structures at and near the gun range. Any excavation on the site of the landfill will be subject to SCAQMD Rule 1150 which requires that an Excavation Management Plan must be submitted to and approved by the executive officer of the SCAQMD prior to beginning excavation. This plan shall identify mitigation measures to be activated as necessary during excavation to ensure that a public nuisance condition does not occur. Mitigation measures shall be selected after consideration of the physical characteristics of the landfill. Based on Rule 1150, feasible mitigation measures include, but are not limited to: gas collection and disposal, baling, encapsulation, covering of the material, and chemical neutralizing If a public nuisance is found to occur, measures identified in the Excavation Management Plan will be implemented immediately, together with additional measures which the executive officer of the SCAQMD deems appropriate. Excavation on the site will also be subject to Rule 1150.1 provisions regarding closed landfill reporting. Local The City of Huntington Beach Air Quality Element is included as a mandatory element of the City's General Plan under California Government Code Section 65303. The goal of the Air Quality Element is to improve regional air quality by a) decreasing reliance on single occupancy vehicular trips, b) increasing efficiency of transit, c) shortening vehicle trips through a more efficient job-housing balance and a more efficient land use pattern, and d) increasing energy efficiency. The following Table-3.5:1-2 identifies the applicable objectives and policies from the City's General Plan Air Quality Element. TABLE 3.5.1-2 AIR QUALITY ELEMENT APPLICABLE OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES P-olicy` Definition AQ 4.1 Reduce the number of truck trips during the daily peak travel periods (8:00am to 5:00 pm) AQ 6.1.2 Investigate the feasibilty of providing new Class II bicycle lanes to encourage commuter bicycle trips. AQ 6.1.2 Continue to improve existing Class 11 bike lanes for safer bicycle travel AQ 7.1 Reduce vehicle emissions through traffic flow improvements and use of alternate fuel consuming vehicles. AQ 8.1.1 Continue to enforce construction site guidelines that require truck operators to minimize particulate emissions. AQ 8.1.2 Require installation of temporary construction facilities (such as wheel washers) and implementation of construction practices that minimize dirt and soil transfer onto public roadways. AQ 8.1.3 Encourage developers to maintain the natural topography, to the maximum extent possible, and limit the amount of land clearing, blasting, grading, and ground excavation operations needed for development. AQ 10.1.1 Continue to require the utilization and installation of energy conservation features in all new construction. Source: City of Huntington Beach General Plan (1996a) Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.5-5 W:IPROJECTSI 1096-0040RICNR11096-004.S 13 Exhaust Emissions From Construction Equipment: The project will require use of heavy equipment, although not all equipment will be in use on a daily basis because different equipment is in use for different phases of construction. For the Sports Complex, maximum equipment emissions occur during the grading and excavation and utility construction phases. The other three components, which have much shorter overall construction schedules, are assumed for this worst case analysis to be under simultaneous construction. All equipment was assumed to be in use for a full eight hours on the peak day and for eight hours a day during each construction day. Equipment estimates and construction schedules provided in Section 2 of this Master EIR were used as the basis of the analysis. Emission calculations, based on heavy equipment emission factors contained in Tables A9-8-A and A9-8-B in the CEQA Air Quality Handbook (SCAQMD 1993b), are shown for each project component in the Appendix to this report. Maximum Daily construction emissions for peak day construction, without mitigation, are shown in Table 3.5.3-2, Maximum Daily Construction Emissions Without Mitigation (in pounds per day). Paints and Coatings: Emissions from paints and coatings will be low. Painting and coating will be required for the concession stand. Finishing will occur after the peak construction day. The project applicant will use SCAQMD-compliant coatings. Because of the low emissions per application and the phasing of the coating applications, emissions will be less than significant. Odors: There are no the area of the four projeet eompOlIeMtS al!211�-T_ed here that e Ilestilt on the rel Excavation in the area of the Huntington Landfill could result in the release of noxious odors from exposing decomposing waste buried in the landfill. The Excavation Management Plan submitted by the City to the SCAQMD under the requirements of Rule 1150 will contain measures for mitigating odors. No excavation will begin until this plan has been reviewed by the SCAQMD Executive Officer and approved for its adequacy in mitigating all potential air quality impacts that could result from excavation of the landfill site. The Plan will also address the possibility of other construction activities disturbing and exposing odor- producing waste in areas of the park not undergoing direct excavation. Toxins: There are no known sources of toxic emissions resulting from previous uses in the area of the four project components analyzed here that could be released during grading and excavation. Summary of Construction Impacts(Project Level) Without mitigation, there will be significant emissions of both nitrogen oxides and PM,o from construction on the peak day and in the peak quarter. Long term cumulative impacts, however, will not be significant because impacts are short-term during construction and will not have a long-term impact on either regional or local air quality. The proposed project is to incorporate twelve mitigation measures which will reduce the maximum daily construction emissions of carbon monoxide, reactive organic compounds and sulfur oxides for the expected construction period. However, emissions of both nitrogen oxides and PM,o on peak day and peak quarter construction periods will exceed the SCAQMD Construction Thresholds only in the short term and will not have a significant long term impact on either regional or local air quality. Operation The project level elements of the proposed Master Plan are not expected to result in operational regional impacts. The project level elements do not include facilities that would generate gaseous emissions from natural gas or electricity usage and thus no release of toxic or odor is expected. Similarly, the soccer and softball fields would replace other existing school field facilities described in the Draft Youth Sports Needs Assessment Study 0 9970. The project level elements would result in a transfer of vehicles trips from existing school field facilities to Huntington Central Park and therefore Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.5-16 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 EI R I CNR 11096-004.S 13 increased recreation user days would have a corresponding increase in emissions from regional trips and vehicle miles traveled which may exceed air quality threshold levels established by the SCAQMD. 3.5.4 Mitigation Measures The City shall require that all construction comply with SCAQMD regulations, including Rule 402 which specifies that no there be no dust impacts offsite sufficient to cause a nuisance, and SCAQMD Rule 403, which restricts visible emissions from construction. Specific measures to reduce fugitive dust shall include the following: Measure Air-1: Moisten soil each day prior to commencing grading to depth of soil cut. Measure Air-2: Water exposed surfaces at least twice a day under calm conditions and as often as needed on windy days when winds are less more than 25 miles per elay hour or during very dry weather in order to maintain a surface crust and prevent the release of visible emissions from the construction. Measure Air-3: Treat any area that will be exposed for extended periods with a soil conditioner to stabilize soil or temporarily plant with vegetation. Measure Air-4: Wash mud-covered tires and under-carriages of trucks leaving construction sites. Measure Air-5: Provide for street sweeping, as needed, on adjacent roadways to remove dirt dropped by construction vehicles or mud which would otherwise be carried off by trucks departing project sites. =°Measure Air-6: Securely cover all loads of fill coming to the site with a tight fitting tarp. Measure Air-7: Cease grading during periods when winds exceed 25 miles per hour. Measure Air-8: Provide for permanent sealing of all graded areas, as applicable, at the earliest practicable time after soil disturbance. In addition, the following measures to reduce equipment and employee travel emissions will be implemented wherever feasible: Measure Air-9: Maintain construction equipment in peak operating condition so as to reduce operation emissions. Measure Air-10: Use low-sulfur diesel fuel in all equipment. Measure Air-11: Use electric equipment whenever practicable. Measure Air-12: Shut off engines when not in use. Measure Air-13: Prior to beginning excavation in the area of the Huntington Landfill, an Excavation Management Plan must be prepared. This Plan shall be submitted by the City to the SCAQMD under the requirements of Rule_1150. The Plan shall contain measures for mitigating odors. No excavation will begin until this plan has been reviewed by the SCAQMD Executive Officer and approved for its adequacy in mitigating all potential air quality impacts that could result from excavation of the landfill site. The Plan shall also address the possibility of other construction activities distributing and exposing odor-producing waste in areas of the park not undergoing direct excavation. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.5-18 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EI R I CNR 11096-004.513 Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-5: Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach shall construct the entrance component of Driveway C to accommodate a 100-feet throated entry to prevent queuing of vehicles into the cul-de-sac area. The entrance component of Driveway C shall be constructed to a width of 14-feet. This measure is required to prevent interference with signalized operations at the intersection of Talbert Avenue and Golden West Street. Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-6: Prior to completion of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach shall construct the exit component of Driveway C to be aligned with an existing drive aisle in the library parking lot. The exit component of Driveway shall be constructed to a width of 14-feet. Construction of the exit component of Driveway C shall include signage and striping to the specifications of the Traffic Division of the Public Works Department of the City of Huntington Beach to ensure appropriate direction of traffic flow. Adequate sight distance shall be provided for exiting vehicles. This measure is required to ensure adequate circulation within the new and existing parking areas. Measure Transportation/Circulation-7: Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach shall construct Driveway D to a full width of 30-feet to facilitate adequate site access. Driveway D shall be improved to incorporate 50-feet of throated driveway which would accommodate storage for two vehicles. Adequate sight distance shall be provided for exiting vehicles. This measure is intended to avoid on-site and off-site circulation difficulties. Measure Transportation/Circulation-8: During the initial five years of operation, the City of Huntington Beach shall provide incentives to encourage transit use to and from the Sports Complex, as necessary to remain below Congestion Management Agency and South Coast Air Quality Management District thresholds for congestion. Measure Transportation/Circulation-9: During the initial five years of operation, the City_of Huntington Beach shall coordinate with the local transit agency to improve or increase service as necessary to remain below Congestion Management Agency and South Coast Air Quality Management District thresholds for congestion. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.6-22 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 EI R ICNR 11096-004.513 Measure Transportation/Circulation-10: Prior to construction, the City of Huntington Beach Public Works Department shall review the Plans and Specifications for the Sports Complex to ensure that the requirement to offer security level bicycle racks at convenient and safe locations has been incorporated into the Sports Complex, as necessary to remain below Congestion Management Agency and South Coast Air Quality Management District thresholds for congestion. Please refer to Exhibit 14 of Appendix F of this Master EIR for a graphic depiction of the Future Roadway Conditions and Intersection Controls which includes implementation of the proposed intersection improvements described above. 3.6.5 Level of Significance After Mitigation Implementation of Measures Transportation/Circulation-1 through --710 are expected to reduce impacts on traffic safety on residential streets; parking; work area traffic; and roadway capacity and level of service below the level of significance. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.6-22 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0040RICNR1 1096-004.SI3 I . l BIRDS Name: California least tern (nesting colony) (Sterna antillarum) Status: FE, SE Description: A small species of tern, with a sharp bill, and a white forehead patch contrasting with the black crown. Habitat: Coast, estuaries, lagoons, diked ponds, and harbors. Nests in colonies on beaches and sandbars. Requires unpolluted feeding areas in lagoons and estuaries all year. Occurrence: Not reeord_d from -a' nark. CNDDB lists sightings at Huntington State Beach, Bolsa Chica Ecological Reserve, Anaheim Bay (CDFG 1997). All these sites supported nesting colonies in the past. Only Huntington State Beach site with active nesting colony. 'Birds of Huntington Central Park" identifies least tern as an uncommon spring and summer visitor to the Park. This species is believed to winter along the coast of Central and South America. According Life on the Edge (BioSystems Analysis Inc. 1994), least terns form breeding colonies of 30 to 50 pairs. As stated in Table 3.7-1 of the DMEIR, the nearest nesting known nesting colonies are located at Huntington State Beach and the Bolsa Chica Ecological Reserve. This species feeds on anchovies, top smelt, iacksmelt,and other small, nearshore prey. Huntington Central Park does not provide suitable nesting or foraging habitat for this species. Name: California brown pelican (Pelecanus occidentalis) Status: FE, SE Description: A large dark water bird with a long pale bill and a white band around the neck which contrasts sharply with the yellow back of the head and dark face. A pelagic bird that is often seen flying single file over the ocean in small flocks. Habitat: A species commonly associated with salt bays, beaches, and ocean. Often over shallow waters along the immediate coast. Occurrence: A rare visitor to Central Park in winter. This species was listed in the CNDDB for this region (CDFG 1997). Occurrence noted from Huntington Central Park Bird List (City of Huntington Beach 1997a). Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.7-13 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041 EI R I CNR 11096-004.S 13 I Name: Swainson's hawk (Buteo swainsoni) Status: ST Description: A large Hawk, with pointed wings, a dark chest band, and light tail bands. Habitat: A migratory species which prefers open grasslands. Occurrence: In Central Park this species is considered an accidental visitor in spring. This species was not listed in the CNDDB for this region (CDFG 1997). Occurrence noted from Huntington Central Park Bird List (City of Huntington Beach 1997a). Name: Peregrine falcon (Falco peregrinus) Status: FE, SE Description: A large species of falcon, with distinctive "black sideburns" on its cheeks. Habitat: Prefers open country. Occurrence: In Central Park it is a rare species year round. The CNDDB did not list this species for this region (CDFG 1997). Occurrence noted from Huntington Central Park Bird List (City of Huntington Beach 1997a). Name: Southwestern willow flycatcher (Empidonax traillii extimus) Status: FIE, SE Description: A moderately sized species of drab-colored flycatcher with light wing bars and an indistinct eye ring. Habitat: Riparian areas, willow thickets, and brushy areas Occurrence: Occasionally seen in the spring and fall in Central Park. This species was not listed in the CNDDB for this region (CDFG 1997). Occurrence noted from Huntington Central Park Bird List (City of Huntington Beach 1997a). Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.7-15 W:IPROJECT511096-0041EIRICNR 11096-004.513 TABLE 3.7-3 IMPACTS TO EXISTING BIOTIC COMMUNITIES FROM MASTER PLAN IMPROVEMENTS HUNTINGTON CENTRAL PARK, CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH BIOTIC " Existing Impacts COMMUNITY Pre-const[uction Preserved f Project impacts 1 Post-;6n."struction .(Acres) (Acres) .` (Acres) (Acres) Landscaped 80 64.5 -0.24 (2) 64.5 -13 (3) +9.6 (3) -0.24 (4) ++57411.4 (5)2 -1.7 (8)2 i 4.8-(6) +1.9 (7)2 ++-4-48_6 (8)2 Urban Forest 20 20.2 - 20.2 +49--217.2 (6)2 Non-native 72 3787.8 -+5 411,4 (5)2 3-&Z.8 5,12 Grassland 26.0 -43-217.2 (6)2 +44426.0 (6)2 1_6 -9-.61.0 (7)2 1.6 7 2 5.8 8 2 Disturbed Riparian 34 21.9 -11.7 (8)2 21.9 Ruderal/Bare 55 5.8 -43.2 0) 3-8 -5.8 (8)2 Water Features 21 21.1 - 21.1 Developed' 74 69.1 -4.8 (9)2 69.1 +43.2 (1) +0.24 (2) +3.4 (3) +0.24 (4) A�T6)o ( 4 +��5_1 (77)2 +4.8 (8)2 +4.8 (9)2 Total 356 206.4236.0 -1.48 9107.3 355.3 Project Level Elements: Program Level Elements: (1)Sports Field Complex (5)Low-Intensity Recreation Area (2)Park,Tree and Landscape (6)Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead Maintenance Yard expansion (n Semi-Active Recreation Area (3)Consolidated Camping Area Use Area (4)Outdoor Music Area (8)Sully Miller Lake Group Facility (9)Police/Civilian Gun Range' ' Developed acreage includes 6.3 acres of paved trails throughout the park 2 Impacts from Program Level elements are estimated based on existing design plans. A more detailed analysis of impacts is required when the projects move forward as capital improvements. 3 The Police/Civilian Gun Range will result in 4.8 acres of impact to existing developed property. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.7-43 VV:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 EI R I CNR 11096-004.S 13 Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion The expansion of the current Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard is expected to total 0.24 acres. All impacts will occur to landscaped portions of the Park. All shrub plantings removed by grading and construction will be replaced along the new perimeter of the facility. No trees will be removed by the Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard expansion. The expansion of the maintenance yard is not expected to result in significant impacts to plant communities in Huntington Central Park.A small disturbed riparian area exists adjacent to the area planned for the expansion of the Park,Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard. No significant impacts to wildlife are expected unless impacts to the nearby disturbed riparian habitat occur during grading and associated collateral construction disturbance. Possible sensitive species which could be impacted by disturbance of disturbed riparian habitat are: yellow warbler, Virginia's warbler, yellow-breasted chat, Cooper's hawk, and sharp-shinned hawk. Consolidated Camping Area The Consolidated Camping Area is planned to impact a total of 13 acres. All impacts will occur to landscaped property and existing developed land. As currently designed, the consolidated campground borders on disturbed riparian habitat, an environmentally important habitat in Huntington Central Park. A small finger of disturbed riparian habitat runs into the proposed campground area. Two sensitive species which may occur in this habitat are least Bell's vireo (federally-and state-listed as endangered) and southwest willow flycatcher (state listed as endangered). Both species have been recorded from Huntington Central Park.The southwestern willow flycatcher may have bred in the past at Huntington Central Park (Gallagher 1997). Cooper's hawk and yellow warbler may also utilize this habitat when present at Huntington Central Park. Impacts to disturbed riparian habitat would be _.. considered significant if any of these sensitive species are determined to be present. Outdoor Music Area The proposed enhancement of the current outdoor music facility will impact 0.24 acres of landscaped grounds.The project will result in the removal of one non-native, ornamental tree. However, two new trees will be planted in the vicinity of the stage area. Impacts resulting from implementation of the Outdoor Music Area project are not considered significant. Program Level Improvements Low-Intensity Recreation Area Development of the Low-Intensity Recreation Area will result in impaets to 1 conversion of 11.4 acres of non-native grassland. A minimum of 4.0 acres of non-native grassland within this element of the proposed Master Plan will be maintained and enhanced to provide foraging habitat for state and federally designated sensitive birds, including raptors. The conversion of 11.4 acres of non- native grassland that are currently used on an interim basis for disc golf, parking, and as a source of fill material for sand bags to low intensity recreation facilities does not conflict with adopted goals of the City of Huntington Beach General Plan. The conversion of 11.4 acres of non-native grassland would not result in the"take"of any state or federally listed endangered species,or their habitat that has been determined to be critical under the Federal or State Endangered Species Act. Implementation of this program level element of the proposed Master Plan results in partial development of an existing disturbed area of the Park and would not be expected to interfere with the movement of any resident or migratory fish or wildlife species or substantially diminish habitat Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.7-44 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041 EI R I CNR 11096-004.S 13 for fish, wildlife or plants. Conversion of 11.4 acres of non-native grassland to turf for low-intensity recreation would not constitute a significant impact on plant or wildlife resources. impaets to tile plant eommitimity are mot eonsidered signifieamt. I lowever, beeatise this area us inhabited by signifieant 11tiffibers of rodents, development of this areawill potentially restilt in sign if ieant impaets to fiDod Supply and foraging territery for raptors present at the Pai k. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.7-44 W:IPROJECTS11096-0041EIRICNR11096-004.513 Midden Areal Urban Forestl Trailhead This element is projected to irmpaet a total of 43.2 convert up to 17.2 acres of non-native grassland. Beeatise there tire evve wetted areas whieh support wetlamd 'vegetatuen in this MOM llative grasslamd area, V t may be meeessary to eenduet a delimeation of jurisdietiomal "waters of tile bmited States" if tile projeet design sHows potemtial t- impaet these wetted areals. Furthermore, sevem sensutive plamt speeies have potential te) oeetir in this area of the park, and niay potemfially be impaeted by of this projeet element. Loss of tHis grasslamd wetild eamstittite a sigmifieant imipaet to habitat for these speeies if they vvere determimed to be presemt within the Park. Non-native grassland habitat provides important foraging habitat for three sensitive species of wildlife: tri-color blackbirds, American peregrine falcon, and Swainson's hawk.Tri-color black birds nest in the cattails of Huntington Lake and forage in the non-native grassland areas of the project site. The American peregrine falcon forages over open areas for small ground dwelling mammals, such as the California ground squirrel. The non-native grassland area has the largest population of California ground squirrels in Huntington Central Park. Swainson's hawk forages either on small mammals or large insects depending on the season. Both Swainson's hawk and American peregrine falcon require open grassy areas for foraging. Both of these species are known to occur at Huntington Central Park. Less of this habitat vvotild eonstittite a sigmifieamt impaet to foraging habitat for these sensiti A minimum of 26.0 acres of non-native grassland within this element of the proposed Master Plan will be maintained and enhanced to provide foraging habitat for state and federally designated sensitive birds, including raptors. The conversion of 17.2 acres of non-native grassland are located within a partially abandoned oil field that is subject to annual mowing/discing for fire control to provide conservation of a known prehistoric midden area/urban forest/ and trailhead does not conflict with adopted goals of the City of Huntington Beach General Plan. The conversion of 17.2 acres of non-native grassland would not result in the "take" of any state or federally listed endangered species, or their habitat that has been determined to be critical under the Federal or State Endangered Species Act. The designation of the 26.0 acres to be used for conservation and enhancement of non-native grassland will attempt to include all wetted areas that have the potential to be subject to the jurisdiction of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers or the California Department of Fish and Game. Implementation of this program level element of the proposed Master Plan results in partial development of an existing disturbed area of the Park and would not be expected to interfere with the movement of any resident or migratory fish or wildlife species or substantially diminish habitat for fish, wildlife or plants. Conversion of 17.2 acres of non-native grassland to urban forest and trailhead facilities would not constitute a significant impact on plant or wildlife resources. Semi-Active Recreation Area This element is projected to impact a total of 9-.-68_0 acres of non-native grassland. There are six sensitive plant species which have potential to occur in this non-native grassland, and may potentially be impacted by implementation of this project element. Loss of this grassland would constitute a significant impact to habitat for these species if they were determined to be present within the Park. Non-native grassland habitat provides important foraging habitat for three sensitive species of wildlife: tri-color blackbirds, American peregrine falcon, and Swainson's hawk.Tri-color black birds nest in the cattails of Huntington Lake and forage in the non-native grassland areas of the project site. The American peregrine falcon forages over open areas for small ground dwelling mammals, such as the California ground squirrel. The non-native grassland area has the largest population of California Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.7-45 W:IPROJECTSI 1096-0041EIRICNR11096-004.513 ground squirrels in Huntington Central Park. Swainson's hawk forages either on small mammals or large insects depending on the season. Both Swainson's hawk and American peregrine falcon require open grassy areas for foraging. Both of these species are known to occur at Huntington Central Park. Loss of this habitat would constitute a significant impact to foraging habitat for these sensitive species. Sully Miller Lake Group Facility The Sully Miller Lake Group Facility will be designed to avoid impacts to disturbed riparian habitat surrounding the Lake. Impacts resulting from implementation of this element of the Master Plan would not be considered significant in the absence of impacts to disturbed riparian habitat. If Sully Miller Lake Group Facility designs which avoid impacts to disturbed riparian habitat are not considered feasible, significant impacts would most likely result from implementation of this element of the Master Plan. Implementation of the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility element could potentially i Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.7-45 W:IPROJECT511096-0041 E1 R ICNR 11096-004.513 I result in impacts to 11.7 acres of disturbed riparian habitat. The existing 5.8 acres of ruderal/bare habitat would be enhanced to support non-native grassland habitat similar to that which is present within the Park west of Golden West Street. Two sensitive species which may occur in this habitat are least Bell's vireo (federally-and state-listed as endangered) and southwestern willow flycatcher (state listed as endangered). Both species have been recorded from Huntington Central Park. The southwestern willow flycatcher may have bred in the past at Huntington Central Park (Gallagher 1997). Because Sully Miller Lake is currently closed to the public, it represents the least disturbed habitat within the Park, and therefore has the greatest potential for supporting these listed species. Potential sensitive species which may occur at Sully-Miller Lake may include: common loon, double-crested cormorant, western least bittern, white faced ibis, northern harrier, osprey, long-billed curlew, and yellow-billed cuckoo. Cooper's hawk and yellow warbler may also utilize this habitat when present at Huntington Central Park. Furthermore, Sully Miller Lake is listed on the National Wetland Inventory Map (1974), and may be subject to U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Corps) federal jurisdiction as a wetland. Any potential impacts to jurisdictional wetlands would be considered significant and require mitigation. Police/Civilian Gun Range Implementation of this program level element of the plan would potentially result in impacts to 4.8 acres of existing developed property. No significant impacts are expected to result from implementation of this element of the plan. 3.7.4 Mitigation Measures Construction of the Sports Complex adjacent to Sully Miller Lake, and the Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion and Consolidated Camping Area adjacent to Talbert Lake-Meadow could potentially result in significant impacts to sensitive bird species potentially occurring in riparian vegetation. Implementation of the Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion and Consolidated Camping Area elements could potentially result in significant impacts to riparian habitat adjacent to these planned improvements. Program level improvements planned for the non-native grasslands within the Park could result in a significant loss of foraging habitat for raptors at the Park. Lastly, the development of areas surrounding Sully Miller Lake could potentially result in significant impacts to riparian habitat, which is potential habitat for the least Bell's vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher. Measure Biological Resources 1 - Directed surveys for least Bell's vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher will be conducted prior to commencing any construction activities near disturbed riparian habitats. Directed surveys for least Bell's vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher will be conducted in accordance with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and California Department of Fish and Game published protocols for such surveys at the time that such surveys are undertaken. If the presence of either species is confirmed, construction and design plans will be modified to avoid impacts to these species. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.7-46 W:IPROJECT511096-0041EIRICNRI 1096-004.513 Measure Biological Resources 2 - An environmental monitor will be present during grading and construction of the Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion, and the Consolidated Camping Area, and the Sully Miller lake Group Facility to ensure no unauthorized impacts occur to areas potentially subject to U.S. Army Corps of Engineers jurisdiction or to existing disturbed riparian habitat in areas adjacent to element of the proposed Master Plan. The Construction Monitor shall hold a permit for directed surveys for least Bell's vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher. The Construction monitoring shall be authorized to issue a stop work order in the unlikely event that southwestern willow flycatcher or least Bell's vireo are determined to be present in adjacent disturbed riparian habitat during construction. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.7-46 W:I PROJECTS11096-0041 EI R ICNR 11096-004.513 Measure Biological Resources 3 - Directed surveys for six sensitive plant species that have the potential to be present in non-native grassland, southern tarplant (Hemizonia parryi ssp. australis), Coulter's goldfields (Lasthenia glabrata ssp. coulteri), Coulter's saltbush (Atriplex coulteri), south coast saltscale (Atriplex pacifica), many- stemmed dudleya (Dudleya multicaulis), and intermediate Mariposa lily (Calochortus weedii var. intermedius) will be conducted prior to moving forward with program level elements which will impact non-native grasslands within the Park. Directed surveys for the six sensitive plants will be conducted in accordance with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and California Department of Fish and Game published protocols for such surveys at the time that such surveys are undertaken. In the absence of a published protocol, such surveys will be undertaken in accordance with Guidelines for Assessing the Effects of Proposed Developments on Rare and Endangered Plants and Plant Communities prepared by the California Department of Fish and Game. Measure Biological Resources 4 - Potential impacts to foraging habitat for raptors resulting from development of non-native grasslands in the Park could be mitigated by enhancing ,tideraWbare conserved areas of non- native grassland at a ratio of 1:1 for acres of impact on non- native grassland to provide suitable habitat values and functions for}prep-speeies raptors. Mitigation for impacts on non-native grassland will be accomplished within conserved non-native grasslands in association with the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility, Low Intensity Recreation Area, Semi-Active Recreation Area, and Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai[head. Additwonally, strategie Planting of trees on the developed a-eas to allovv broad, open areas for i0raging would mitigate for loss of existimg foraging ha Enhancement of non-native grassland would include, but not be limited to,the planting of native trees within and adjacent to conserved areas of non- native grassland. Measure Biological Resources 5 - Potential impacts resulting from implementation of the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility element would be mitigated through creation and enhancement of disturbed riparian habitats in the Shipley Nature Center and Talbert Lake-Meadow at a ratio of 3:1 for acres of impact. Measure Biological Resources 6- Concurrent with operation of the Sports Complex, the City shall implement or cause to be implemented a brown-headed cowbird trapping program. The brown-headed cowbird trapping program will be submitted to the Service for review and comment at least three months prior to the beginning of grading. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.7-47 W:IPROJECTSI 1096-0041EIRICNR11096-004.S 13 Traps used to remove cowbirds will be modified Australian crow traps. These traps allow live capture of birds so that non-target birds can be released unharmed. The traps will be "baited" with live Ouvenile or female brown-headed cowbirds which will be captured prior to the trapping period with baited traps or mist nets. The juvenile or female cowbirds attract the attention of adult birds and lure them into traps. Once inside the trap, it is difficult for the birds to escape and they can be easily removed. Approximately four bait birds are kept in a separate cage within the trap and are not removed until the trapping season is over. The traps will be placed and maintained so as to provide trapped and bait birds ample shade, food, and water while they are in traps. All cowbirds (male, female, and juvenile) that are caught in the traps will be disposed of humanely_ Trapping will take place during the nesting period of riparian bird species found in Central Park that are known to be parasitized by brown-headed cowbirds.Traps will be checked daily during the trapping period to remove both trapped cowbirds and non-target species, which will be released. Bait birds lost to predation or escape will be replaced during the daily checks. An annual letter report documenting the results of the trapping program will be submitted to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Results of the trapping program will be recorded including the date and time of trap checking,, observer(s), weather, age of trapped birds (both target and non-target species), the treatment of the birds (whether released,disposed of,or retained as bait birds),and other data pertaining to any unusual event, such as predation or loss of bait birds. 3.7.5 Level of Significance After Mitigation Planned improvements for Huntington Central Park are consistent with the goal outlined in the City of Huntington Beach General Plan (1996a), as they relate to biological resources. All significant impacts are reduced to a level less than significant after mitigation ark prior to construction in these areas will allow for appropriate scheduling of construction activities to avoid impacts to these species if they are found to be present. Presence of an environmental monitor at all sites where grading is scheduled to occur adjacent to riparian habitat will ensure no impacts occur to potential wetlands or habitat for sensitive species. Potential impacts resulting from program level elements will be mitigated through strategic planting design to avoid loss of significant foraging habitats and through creation and enhancement of potentially impacted habitats in other areas of the Park. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.7-47 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 EI R ICNR 11096-004.S 13 Community Right-to-Know requirements under the Superfund Amendment and Reauthorization Act into the California program. AB 3777 (California Health and Safety Code, Section 25531 et. seq.) amends and augments Mandatory Hazardous Waste Source Reduction Act. AB 3777 also instituted the Risk Management and Prevention Program, which is an operation and facility-related risk prevention plan which must be prepared and submitted by acutely hazardous material handlers to local administering agencies upon request. Once approved, the Risk Management and Prevention Plan must be fully implemented within one year. In their letter of comment on the Notice of Preparation, the Santa Ana Region of the California Regional Water Quality Control Board provided the following guidance: "Redevelopment of the former municipal solid waste and inert landfill sites, located south of Talbert [Avenue], west of Gothard Street, and east of Golden West Street, which is part of the Central Park Master Redevelopment Plan, must comply with Title 27 requirements to minimize water infiltration through wastes, to prevent water ponding over wastes as a result of landfill settlement or improper grading, and to resist erosion of the landfill surface as a result of precipitation." The Divi"sion of Oil, Gas, and Geothermal Resources of the Department of Conservation ([DOGGR] Appendix B) provided the following precautions with respect to development in the vicinity of active wells: "We [DOGGR] recommend that an eight foot wall enclose [active] wells and associated equipment within the project site. Suitable gates should be provided which are capable of - - allowing large workover equipment into the well site. Landscaping that is climbable along the wall should be prohibited, since it defeats the purpose of the wall." Additional guidance was provided by DOGGR (Appendix B) with respect to construction of concrete or asphalt surfaces in the vicinity of methane-rich soils: "Methane gas can accumulate beneath developed areas where concrete and/or asphalt surfaces prevent the natural migration of the methane gas to the atmosphere. If this occurs and a crack develops in the concrete or asphalt, at some later time, the gas could migrate into the interior of an overlying structure and create the potential for explosion or fire. Therefore, gas detectors, gas migration barriers, or venting systems should be considered. Please consult with the local building and safety department for specific recommendations for this area." Regional SCAQMD Rule 1150 will require the preparation of an Excavation Management Plan prior to beginning excavation and will be submitted to and approved by the executive officer of the SCAQMD. This plan shall identify mitigation measures to be activated as necessary during excavation to ensure that a public nuisance condition does not occur. Mitigation measures shall be selected after consideration of the physical characteristics of the landfill. This requirement is separate from CEQA requirements. While analysis of impacts and agency coordination of comments on impacts would assist in preparation of the Plan, they would not substitute for this requirement. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.9-3 W:IPROJECTS11096-0041EIRICNR11096-004.S 13 SCAQMD Rule 1150.1 applies to former landfills located at the proposed project site. The City intends to comply with all applicable portions of Rule 1150.1 during design, construction, and monitoring phases of the project. In addition, the City will comply with California Code of R gulations, Title 27, Section 20919, for gas control. County The Public Safety Element of the Orange County General Plan (County of Orange 1987) define goals related to public safety. Specifically, the Safety Element establishes as a goal of the County to: "Provide for a safe living and working environment consistent with available resources." Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.9-3 W.I PROJECTS 11096-0041 EI R ICNR 11096-004.513 • Solid Waste Information System As legislated under the Solid Waste Management and Resource Recovery Act of 1972, the California Waste Management Board maintains a list of certain facilities, i.e. "active" solid waste disposal sites, "inactive" or "closed" solid waste disposal facilities, and transfer facilities. Three (3) separate listings for the subject property occur on this database. One (1) additional SWF facility within a half-mile radius of the subject property is also listed (Appendix H). The listing identified within a half-mile radius of the subject property are depicted in Figure 3.9.2-1, Oran= County CLA Landfill Sites. OO Huntington Beach Landfill a.k.a. as the Br -- Brothers Pet is part of what is also known as the Gothard Landfill located at 18131 Gothard Street. This 18 acre portion of the landfill is located at the southwestern corner of Talbert Avenue and Gothard Street. This area was a sand-mining operation prior to 1927. From 1927 to 1949, the pit was used as a disposal site for rotary drilling mud and waste mud from sumps. In 1957, a permit was issued for the disposal of inert materials. Violations occurred from 1957 to 1972 as a result of the acceptance of liquid refinery wastes, oil and brines and sumpbottoms at the pit. In 1972 the city purchased the property and closed the pit in 1973. In October 1979, the City received a permit to grade the pit as a construction debris site and by the end of 1982, approximately 212,000 cubic yards of material had been deposited in the subject site. OO Sully Miller Construction Company No. 1 a.k.a. Sully Miller Lake, 7221 Ellis Avenue, is located on the southern perimeter of the subject property at Ellis Avenue. The facility address is reported as a closed solid waste disposal site. The former use of the subject property as a landfill poses a high potential to adversely affect the environmental integrity of the subject site at this time (Appendix H). OO Taylor Street Station No. 4, Taylor Drive at Golden West Street, is located on the subject property at the intersection of Taylor Drive and Golden West Street. The facility address is reported as a closed solid waste disposal site. The former use of the subject property as a landfill poses a high potential to adversely affect the environmental integrity of the subject site at this time (Appendix H). ® Metzler, W.E., is located southeast of the intersection of Gothard Street and Slater Avenue. This facility address is reported as a closed hazardous waste site and appears to pose a low potential to adversely effect the environmental integrity of the subject site at this time. (5) Gothard Street Landfill, 18131 Gothard Street, is located along the eastern perimeter of the subject property on Gothard Street. The facility address is reported as an archived small volume transfer station. The former use of the subject property as a landfill poses a high potential to adversely affect the environmental integrity of the subject site at this time (Appendix H). Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.9-7 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EIRICNRI 1096-004.513 -l>erte en ns...f2 }A"t .r "i SIIm r I AMER S AV Ih i O w AY �rTR DK d , ;'�' W ti I ru 3e I .��v C_IN M I o OCEAN ► RELSt�OR 33 I ��°s'� Caxr VIEW HS 0 .. `~ - s x7ErmA I i 8 .1. DR 53 _ x . —,�,�,I� � � OR -, v00K DR wti P� i Y AY N °`�gz ao �3 CEOAR N o LIEGE O u � FREEtYI1�I�' oRl =r7KILD, NCIR Zg-� r'p'"ra `5 Sua..ra py C 1 ENT RO i OR - HORIxO"J � �. gETttl DR' z RELL PALOALIO �ATH 00. CIR pRlsa ,'{ n+x- o C J DRCaa'�Dwro.= ONE DR ~'KlRKUPomra.,La AENA gg S Ill :� wlm oRec _''LL��IIia- 813f��P. o a�x7,p R 6aL'�6 j oa Yx� $ Ax oR 1_27OR 9SONBRE 1 WACdI'00.ia?� Yl 6! ~w+ ... OR I 00.z1 I 0R R 1� KAAD OR IV J J 50 Of STA PAL VI OR t� -:..r4, gg W W _ c TEf�MDRIDtl I A ru �r.Axl��S5 Fr,.x. 4 � x�3 � tr z 7 lot a Arr CIR ur SEODYlA z YAi.• OR YJ z NIITWMfIOJCIR "I 9a CIR_ RK ;.��•,�+< 7 VISTA SOL 0R o tEtam � 1 KELL :p SI 4 can ,. $ u �uR : , Ar a� SAR! VIA OR .4& {C,-"` DES OR 0I OR ARMA 00. IN > `•"�'r-/ Fes. r .,LI AV Jo GALte I I IAImtxEs-_<•UROI ES RIO 4. jRjrvi yrr RELYA IxYU" AEL D0.= �q Wls u5i �P `+ r t L. CENTRAALt.. WOODWIND OR Ar- R� IER ON OR �a► ixrEn.�I� l . ONO DR = x 'PALLI IGIUTER 00. KISER x ! AODA ELD 7 xAll4llRE 3�55dt L ! RAl1URAL dl - .,+'(- = N� Yuortnn a �[,^7'vC4rors�iYf - ?:+'Q *'' �, ..AV 'fir Qi - 6 R3 L RKrRr b'PT �Er:EM1_ �a'�kaid_�-'"^S: T` C zi tELO JASaYt. � i -•OA _ y'�:'i �+,. �. 001 y c HARRIlIAN V - �Lx 8y GLDIfDi �� �' 8 a - x P...-•�.�.,iy m O-$ , � ��� g� - in t �3' .� - E sc 7 L s•• V a m q c z PR0CA.11 PARKYIEW =.... Ht C ° tic r :5 ,xt N�RT7fG uN < OR offARto UOP 1\ P�a*. Q t`vr5d. �e TAY I1R I W yK�� g1EHEC Vp i�f� zw.FIEFS C a pR l O� fit` ,y�1' T .yewy• N [fLrtS ` u`+I - ALM'. Q I a T a Y� AV 3 m r \ AUTOPARK Obi AV OR f R••% ELLIS E-�LIS _NLTCNINGPOST iCIR © w,tl�'7� ` yE m5 ` cuRa CO—RRArLI.= i 1 w` �f S CIRIbcVI r ,XI Rat u u LNIG >r.(� rm c• sHta as el- ER` ul t l ycn �a REGILWAL' � SRD H5L*O_ OROJ ERNEST AV Mi °A rAdtr�ta sr.-•t«..$t. C a►plt� 027E v O j �$ITFI tZ:l. 6 a• r UN 'OR -•r �1RFIELO AV GARRIELDIX I1 AV uR 1 y ti201 8 I I $. /� r •"'+* 't-^.. S? u=al rl srAsiAY� =MIIIA6Yd p BEACH V - ~ CLAY I �s aC=7SO1�1 AV ' YELiDIr ttEVE - i I �f1GfH ►i •.. 'Iy,�}IVt�KEYi a n. OR�Fm,� ' �z D n Xtl • P C�KB(✓ODI;' L ?a, Ax ,y,+ - jl rr s1g 3 6ARDEx I _-i $` I 1 1 ri�tf�` 1, a 7 O 4 D `' -_-�^; � lNVfI7R;7'CCP.�a •� HILLR N a VI L/F'IR�a a .L : ; suai�c ��q =� _ c � " Map not to scale. Legend 10 30-AB-0026, Huntington Beach Landfill O5 30-AB-0014, Gothard Street Landfill Status: Closed (aka Golden West Disposal Station) Status: Closed O 30-CR-0033, Sully Miller Construction Company#1 © Standard Oil of California No. 1 (aka Ellis and Golden West or Huntington Beach (aka Cherran No. 1) Status: Closed Rock Plant) Status: Closed 30 30-CR-0035, Taylor Street Station #14) O7 30-CR-0090, Fern CIA Status: Closed Status: Closed ® 30-CR-0023, Wilbur E. Metzler ® 30-CR-0054, McClellan Status: Closed (aka Metzles W.E.) Status: Excavated REVISE ffi MINOR OrangeIY County LandfillLA nndf3t Sites environmental compliance resource planning Huntington Central Park Master EIR Huntington Beach, California extraction of LFG to control surface and offsite migration and passive barriers with vent layers and alarm systems below all enclosed structures on and within 1,000 feet of the landfill boundary. A comprehensive monitoring network will be established around the perimeter of the landfill. Periodic monitoring of the monitoring network and at locations above the surface of the landfill will be performed. Measure Hazards-5: Where the City of Huntington Beach determines the need to include irrigated land uses over areas underlain by refuse as part of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the plans and specifications will reflect the need to incorporate a more elaborate cover system to control moisture infiltration into the refuse. A suitable cover system could consist of a synthetic geomembrane, geotextile fabric for protection of geomembrane and filtering for the drainage layer, a drainage layer, and a vegetation layer or an approved alternative. Measure Hazards-6: The City of Huntington Beach shall prepare an Emergency Evacuation Plan for potential impacts related to (1) potential hazardous materials release on Golden West Street, or (2) a rupture or explosion in the vicinity of the oil field area west of Golden West Street. Measure Hazards-7: Plans and specifications for the Sports Complex, the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head and the Semi- Active Recreation Area will identify the potential to encounter oil ._ saturated soils during excavation. If oil-saturated soil is encountered during excavation, plans and specifications shall require the construction foreman to contact the City of Huntington Beach, who shall contact the DOGGR and follow appropriate guidance. Measure Hazards-8: Appropriate methane mitigation features such as gas detectors, gas migration barriers, venting systems, and classified electrical installation shall be incorporated into plans and specifications for all proposed structures overlaying the former landfill and within 1,000 feet of the perimeter of the landfill. Design consideration for potential LFG migration through pipes, trenches, or other conduits shall be incorporated into Plans and Specifications. Methane migration features will be consistent with the requirements of the City of Huntington Beach Specification Number 429 and other applicable State and Federal regulations. The methane migration features shall be submitted for review and approval to the Orange County Health Care Agency, Environmental Health Division, which is the LEA for all cities and unincorporated areas of Orange County. Measure Hazards-9: Any unrecorded or unknown wells uncovered during the excavation or grading process shall be immediately reported to and coordinated with the City and DOGGR. In addition, should any unknown and unexpected landfills be excavated and discovered during the construction phase of the proposed project,construction work will be immediately halted and LEA will be notified. Further construction operations will resume at the discretion of LEA and upon work approval by LEA. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.9-13 W I PROJECT511096-0041 EIR ICNRI 1096-004.513 Measure Hazards-10: Any redevelopment within the known oil field will shall be conducted in conformance with City requirements. City requirements include those outlined in Article 79 of the Uniform Fire Code (UFC). Measure Hazards-11: The City Fire Department will prepare a Fire Risk Evaluation prior to issuance of grading permits. Measure Hazards-12: Plans and specifications for the Midden Area/Urban Forest/TraiIhead shall include construction of an 8-foot high block wall enclosure around extant active oil wells and associated equipment. The block wall enclosures will include suitable gates which are capable of accommodating large workover equipment into the well sites. Landscaping that is climbable along the wall shall be prohibited, since it defeats the purpose of the wall. Suitable vehicular access for well workover equipment shall be provided for active wells. Measure Hazards-13: Prior to construction of a gun range, a preliminary endangerment assessment(PEA)should be completed to screen the site for potential human and ecological health risks associated with possible contaminants including drilling muds, petroleum products, solid wastes, heavy metals, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and polychlorinated biphenyls. Measure Hazards-14: The City of Huntington Beach will prepare an Excavation Management Plan prior to beginning excavation within the limits of the landfill which will be submitted to and approved by the executive officer of the SCAQMD. This Plan shall identify mitigation measures to be activated as necessary during excavation to ensure that a public nuisance condition does not occur. Mitigation measures shall be selected after consideration of the physical characteristics of the landfill. Measure Hazards-15: Prior to construction of the Sports Complex, Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion,Consolidated Camping Area, and Low-Intensity Recreation elements of the Master Plan.the City of Huntington Beach Fire Department and Public Works Department shall review all construction plans and specifications to ensure that the specifications require that each contractor involved in grading activities develop a site- and action-specific comprehensive Health and Safety Plan. The plans and specifications will require that the Health and Safety Plan be developed using the information available about past uses of those sites and the possibility that solid waste, PCH- contaminated soils, and/or potentially hazardous waste materials could be encountered. 3.9.5 Level of Significance After Mitigation Implementation of Measures Hazards-1 through -+215 will reduce impacts related to hazards below the level of significance. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.9-14 W.I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 EI R ICNR 11096-004.S 13 3.12 UTILITIES AND SERVICE SYSTEMS This section of the Master Environmental Impact Report (EIR) summarizes the results of the environmental analysis related to utilities and service systems. This section describes the process used to assess the potential for the proposed project to result in significant impacts related to utilities and service systems. The following questions were analyzed in consideration of ability of the proposed project to result in significant impacts on utilities and services systems: • Does the proposed project cause the existing water and sewer system to exceed its design capacity? • Does the proposed project cause the existing storm drain system to exceed its design capacity during a capital storm event? • Will the proposed project require upgrading the existing electrical transmission facilities to the site? • Will the proposed project require relocation of a significant portion of an existing utility? This section of the environmental analysis is based on written correspondence,telephone coordination, and information provided by the City of Huntington Beach and local utility companies responsible for providing utilities and service systems to the proposed project site. The regulatory framework, existing conditions, thresholds for determining significance, impacts, mitigation, and the level of significance after mitigation are described. A complete copy of the Utility Report (IWA Engineers 1999) appears as Appendix J to this document. Additionally, information regarding storm drain facilities appears in the Drainage Report as Appendix D to this document (IWA Engineers 1999). 3.12.1 Regulatory Framework Sta to The California Solid Waste Reuse and Recycling Access Act of 1991 requires each jurisdiction to adopt an ordinance by September 1, 1994 requiring each "Development Project" to provide an adequate storage area for collection and removal of recyclable materials. Regional The operational responsibilities of all landfills and transfer stations lie with the County of Orange's Integrated Water Management Department. Trash services are provided to jurisdictions by cities and sanitary districts. The State Waste Management Board, created by the State of California in 1972, provides direction and funding to the counties pursuant to the implementation of the Z'berg-Kapiloff Solid Waste Control Act of 1976, whieh requires eounties to provide managernent plans that nieet deserabed minimurn requirements and to update the management plan every three years. The Integrated Waste Management Act of 1989 (AB 939, Sher) supplanted the Z'berg-Kapiloff requirement for counties to prepare Solid Waste Management Plans every three years. AB 939 imposed waste reduction mandates on counties to reduce the amount of waste disposed of in landfills by 25 percent by 1995 and by 50 percent by the year 2000. Additionally, it required counties and cities to prepare various solid waste planning documents that demonstrated what programs would be implemented to comply with AB 939 mandates. Counties are required to prepare Countywide Integrated Waste Management Plans every five years that document 15 years of disposal capacity, summarize city planning documents, and set forth criteria for siting new landfills. The County has prepared the Solid Waste Management Plan for the County of Orange in response to this requirement. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.12-1 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041EIR ICNR 11096-004.S 13 the real property personnel in Administrative Services. The use of this area is temporary pending improvements to this area as part of park development. The Central Library/Huntington Central Park parking lot south of the library is also used for extra parking during the GTE event with a shuttle to the event provided. Midden Area This undeveloped area, which is characterized by hilly terrain, dirt paths and non-native grass vegetation, provides up to 360' views which include the Pacific Ocean, Mt. Baldy in the San Gabriel Mountains, and Saddleback Peak in the Santa Ana Mountains. The character and unrivaled views of this area make it a popular area for many trail uses. During the fall season, the trails are used for cross country running, including training and competition by high schools, colleges, and universities. The undeveloped character of this area also provides for a different experience through the presence of trails for hikers, equestrian uses and mountain biking. Trails from this area are currently planned to be linked to the Harriett M. Wieder Regional Park (County of Orange 1997). Dog Park The approximately 2-acre dog park is a fenced facility that allows dogs off-leash within the Park. These types of facilities have become extremely popular in the vicinity of Huntington Central Park. The Dog Park provides dog owners with opportunities to incorporate visits to the dog park with walks through the rest of the Park. This use of the Park was originally intended to be temporary, but it has evolved over time to become a permanent use. Turf Picnic Area This area borders the west side of Huntington Lake and lies north of the Dog Park. It is used for day picnicking. Other Activities and Support Facilities In addition to the site specific recreational activities and facilities located in Huntington Central Park, several other activities and support facilities related to recreation are located within the park. Trails Huntington Beach Central Park provides for biking, walking/hiking as well as equestrian use through the provision of a circulation system. Currently, the park contains approximately 5.8 miles of designated trails. These provide Class I (off road) bike trails which connect to Class II (on road with striped lanes) bike trails that run along Slater Avenue, Golden West Street, Talbert Avenue, and Edwards Street(City of Huntington Beach 1996c). Proposed bike trails that link to Central Park include a Class I trail through Harriett M. Wieder Regional Park, and a Class II trail along Golden West Street (City of Huntington Beach 1996b). Currently, the only Class I bike trails in the City of Huntington Beach are located in the Park, along the Santa Ana River, and along the coast. The Santa Ana River Regional Riding and Hiding Trail is a multiple use trail. An additional Class I trail (a multiple use trail) is proposed which would connect Huntington Central Park to the Harriett M. Wieder Regional Park (City of Huntington Beach 1996b). The Class I Trail, known as the Huntington Beach Regional Riding and Hiking Trail, will link Huntington Central Park to the Harriett M. Wieder Regional Park. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.15-7 W:I PROI ECTSI 1096-0041 EI R ICNR 11096-004.S 13 The City maintains approximately two miles of equestrian trails within the Park. Other equestrian trails within the City include those located in the residential area south of Ellis Avenue between Edwards and Golden West Streets, and along the Santa Ana River (City of Huntington Beach 1996b). An additional equestrian riding/hiking trail is proposed for the Harriett M. Wieder Regional Park, which will connect to Central Park's existing equestrian trail system. However, the Regional Park trail will not provide for beach access for equestrian use. Birdwatching The Jack Green Nature Area/Talbert Lake Area contains a naturally occurring, seasonal wetland/meadow which is adjacent to a drainage that supports dense vegetation. This provides for outstanding bird watching opportunities. The Park has a reputation among bird-watchers as being one of the best bird watching locations in the area due to the high number of bird species identified there. This recreational activity draws many people to Huntington Central Park. Restaurants Two food concessions are located within the Park. The Park Bench Cafe is located on the west side of Talbert Lake-Meadow, with indoor and outdoor dining tables. This facility serves breakfast, lunch and dinner during the summer months, and breakfast and lunch throughout the remainder of the year. This facility also allows dogs in the outdoor dining area, making it a popular facility for dog walkers. Alice's Breakfast in the Park, the second food concession, is located by the northeast corner of Huntington Lake. Special Events/ Park Uses Due to the size of Central Park and its facilities, the Park has been used for several special events, many of which are annual. In addition to the library, playhouse, equestrian and camping special events mentioned above, other events have included a Civil War re-enactment and auto shows, among others. Two different permits are issued for special events in the Park. If other City departments besides Community Services need to be involved with the event, then a "Specific Event Application" must be filed with the City's Community Services Department to gain a permit. All other park special events, with the exception of youth camping, require a "Special Permit-Central Park", which is issued through the Park ranger. One other special use in the park requiring permitting is filming. Either a fee and/or a permit may be required for motion picture filming and still photography by the following entities: professional commercial film and video organizations/individuals; students conducting coursework with instructor verification; news agencies; and government agencies and educational film production organizations/individuals. All fees and permit matters related to filming are facilitated by the City of Huntington Beach Film Office. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.15-8 W:IPROJECTSI 1096-0041EIRICNR11096-004.S 13 Trails Currently, plans exist for bicycle, and equestrian/hiking trails to link Huntington Central Park to Bolsa Chica State Beach through the development of the Harriett M. Wieder Regional Park (Regional Park), a County of Orange facility (County of Orange, Public Facilities & Resources Department 1997). This connection is proposed to be made from the northernmost end of the Regional Park, across Edwards St., and into the eastern end of Central Park near the current Dog Park area (County of Orange, Public Facilities & Resources Department 1997). Currently, the bicycle/pedestrian trail is designed to be ten feet wide and constructed with a hard surface. A separate riding/hiking trail will link with the Huntington Beach Equestrian Center at the Park. The trail is designed to be ten feet wide with a soft surface. An extension of this trail will cross Edwards Street at Ellis Avenue to access the equestrian center. A "horse height" button has been installed at this intersection to facilitate the safe crossing of horseback riders through this intersection. Camping In addition to those found within the Park, City camping facilities include: the 150-space recreational vehicle (RV) camping at the Sunset Vista Camper Facility on Pacific Coast Highway at Lake Street, which is operated by the City from September 15 through May 31; the 100-space camping facility at Bolsa Chica State Beach, which is operated by the State Department of Parks and Recreation and provides year-round camping with a maximum two week stay; and an en route RV camping program at the City beach, which is available between June 1 and September 14 (City of Huntington Beach 1996a). 3.15.3 Impacts The threshold for determining if significant impacts on recreation would occur is based on Appendix G of the California Environmental Quality Act Statutes and Guidelines. The likelihood for significant impacts on recreation to occur was evaluated based on the potential for the proposed project to: • Conflict with established recreational uses of the area, or • Substantially increase the need to provide maintenance and services that cannot be supported by existing or proposed funding mechanisms. Sports Complex Implementation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan is not anticipated to have a significant impact to established recreational uses. Construction, operation, and maintenance of the Sports Complex is expected to provide increased opportunities for youth and adult sports. Operation of the Sports Complex is not anticipated to create a substantial need to provide maintenance and services that cannot be supported by existing or proposed funding mechanisms. The Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan will serve the City's adult sports program while providing expanded opportunities for youth soccer, football, and girl's softball. It will also include up to four roller hockey arenas and a batting cage. The improvements associated with the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan will relieve existing conflicts between adult and Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.15-10 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EI R I CNR 17 096-004.513 TABLE 3.15.3-1 SPORTS COMPLEX CONCEPTUAL USE SCHEDULE tt, CONCEPTUALUSE* - -TOTAL_ (Players/ `k 3 S ectatof s ADULT SOFTBALL Monday through Friday(6:00 p.m.) 36 Weeks • 3 games per night on 4 fields = 12 games per night • 30 players and 20 spectators = 50 people per game • 12 games per night* 50 people per game = 600 people per night • 600 people per night * 5 nights per week = 3000 people per week(Mon.through Fri.) • 3000 people per week * 36 weeks per year = 108,000 players/spectators per year 108,000 Saturday Softball Tournaments(8:00a.m.-9:00 p.m.) 44 Weeks 0 11 games per day on 4 fields = 44 games per day 0 30 players and 20 spectators = 50 people per game • 44 games per day * 50 people per game = 2200 people per day • 2200 people per day * 44 weeks per year = 96,800 players/spectators per year 96,800 Sunday(9:30 a.m.-10:30 p.m.) 36 Weeks - • 10 games per day on 4 fields — 40 games per day 4 30 players and 20 spectators = 50 people per game • 40 games per day * 50 people per game = 2000 people per day • 2000 people per day * 36 weeks per year = 72,000 players/spectators per year 72,000 YOUTH SOCCER Monday through Friday(4:00 a.m.-9:00 a.m.) 6 Weeks 0_3 games per day on 4 fields = 12 games per day • 30 youth players and 40 spectators = 70 people per game • 12 games per day * 70 people per game = 840 people per weekend • 840_neor le per week * 6 weeks per year = 5,040 slavers/spectators per year 5040 Saturday and Sunday(8:00 a.m.-10:00 p.m.) 6 Weeks 0 9 games per day on 5 fields = 45 games per day • 45 games per day on two days = 90 games per weekend • 28 youth players and 56 spectators = 84 people per game • 90 games per weekend * 84 people per game = 7,560 people per weekend * 7,560 people per weekend * 6 weeks per year = 45,360 players/spectators per year 45,360 * Conceptual use schedule, developed by City of Huntington Beach,Community Services Department, is based on proposed sports facilities within the Sports Complex element and historic patterns of sports park operation in the City. This schedule estimates an annual maximum use scenario. The recommended location for the Sports Complex is an existing fenced vacant lot, therefore construction, operation, and maintenance of the Sports Complex would not conflict with established recreational uses of the area. Construction, operation, and maintenance of the Sports Complex is expected to provide increased opportunities for youth and adult sports. The City intends to offset maintenance costs for the Sports Complex through revenue generated by the 630-space metered parking lot being constructed in association with the Sports Complex and by permits for use by organized sports. There may also be opportunities for organized sports to participate in maintenance and operation of fields. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 3.15-72 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 EIR ICNRI 1096-004.513 Orange County TramsitTransportation Authority . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Lisa Mills Orange County Transportation Association . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jorge Duran Orange County Vector Control District . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Gilbert Challey Orange County Water District . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . William Mills Jr. Public Facilities and Resources Department, Program Development Division . . . . Herb Nakasone CITIES City of Fountain Valley School District . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Marc Ecker City of Westminster . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Brian Fisk City of Westminster Elementary School District . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Barbara Dehart City of Huntington Beach Huntington Central Park Library Research Desk City Attorney . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Paul D'Alessandro Community Services . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ron Hagan Jim Engle Economic Development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carol Runzel Environmental Board . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Allen Macenski Fire Department . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Tim Greaves Matt Vadala Bob Brown Huntington Beach Elementary School District . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jerry Buchanan Huntington Beach High School District . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Tish Koch Huntington Central Park . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . Dave Winkler Ocean View Elementary School District . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dr. James Tarwater Park, Tree and Landscape . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Daryl Smith Jim Jones Chuck Davis Planning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mary Beth Broeren Julie Sakaguchi Linda Niles Police Department . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jim Moore Luis Ochoa Jan Thomas Public Works Water . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Debbie DeBow Ward Reynolds Howard Johnson Engineering . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Doug Stack Bruce Crosby John VonHolle Steve Krieger Streets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Don Noble Traffic . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Bruce Gilmer Terri Elliot Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 8-2 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 EI R I CNR 11096-004.S 13 I I COUNTY OF ORANGE INTEGRATED WASTE MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT** ATTN: Kevin Kondru 320 N. Flower Street, Ste. 400 Santa Ana, California 92703 COUNTY OF ORANGE INTEGRATED WASTE MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT** ATTN: Ms. Sue Gordon 320 N. Flower Street, Ste. 400 Santa Ana, California 92703 COUNTY OF ORANGE PUBLIC FACILITIES AND RESOURCES DEPARTMENT** ATTN: H.I. Hakasone, Manager Program Development Division PO Box 4048 Santa Ana, California 92702-4048 COUNTY OF ORANGE PUBLIC FACILITIES AND RESOURCES DEPARTMENT** ATTN:Jeff Dickman PO Box 4048 Santa Ana, California 92702-4048 ORANGE COUNTY EMA** ATTN: Mr. George Britton, Manager Environmental Project Planning Division PO Box 4048 Santa Ana, California 92702-4048 ORANGE COUNTY TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY** ATTN: ``an.eftel►z, Lisa Mills, CEO 550 South Main Street PO Box 14184 Orange, California 92863-1584 ORANGE COUNTY TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY** ATTN:Jorge L. Duran, Transportation Analyst 550 South Main Street PO Box 14184 Orange, California 92863-1584 ORANGE COUNTY TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY** ATTN: Ms. Pamela Galera 550 South Main Street PO Box 14184 Orange, California 92863-1584 Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Final Master Environmental Impact Report June 22, 1999 Page 1 1-6 W:IPROJECTSI 1096-0041EIRICNR11096-004.S 13 ATTACHMENT A ��� =TRANSLTION'lONE `5. '(LA Ea CONTAMINATED SOIL— . n tm� n>ovr I _r I ctp ^J C' 1 �' t (!, }- n. 1 i /F"XCA JA i cD AND:. ! ' y ., I.. it( /r-r•-• ;:', ���, ---=��- �::• � _- I REMEDIATED� ..ti:i.�y ~—\_-"1' r _'l�` I ° �{` :CONTAMINATED SOIL'. -:� �?vii; ;; Ir' C ' vi^ ' I !/' \'``� \ ' 1 III,'I !iI{ `� �N PLACE !� �+ _ .:,iL '- — _BRUC.E �� d .� Ej �IL. �?BRGTHER 5 � I- (.I' `/ i1' :�,• - _ - - !• l I V.- c .r HUNTINGTON BEACH�✓� 7. I :I li ''El�u ' �_. .LANDFILL •�,�.: _ L',' i� _ _ "•1 i r/`•`F!�/ �C _ rti"r�'y �r l i i=. sy'•r-\. to t,�! !il'� ,'� I r-'�j v J. !i - •�Y,//i// I ,!i-. - !� J l ., i i -- x l'' •! r •>i { I r-_. _,,,; �'1' : I i; ;; ! •� ��-,-""� `� '1• y/,/ �// �,��,/ f�•r- �' r J /rY � ` { �! /7 '�r ;•`^T ° t � i P;�IS ice` _ ✓ J >w` 'j ,r GOTHARD STRE UJI L-ANDFI 1 0:.:�� I l �`1 ,rc(` / �xe� \� -,j \�-I- ��(� j '� "�.' •�� •� t - 1 i 1i? -� LL �' `I '!' i1;I r ~ �!-� �` ` (fir ;''N' / / `!`I I II a \ \ ` ! II'11 t I I 9 I .4 } I I,M iI t/i r. \\ \, >p.I .f= ;I� ,� ! �'' j• �✓l( - �'.\� / ( //ur--� /� _ 0"A La •� lit i�P�, i •�I� M• �' ��"•r f----�.`" r�/ 11� ,l 5 La �l cr Q •rf _ \�\�� 3 I a�V -�� !��> �I ;r •4 i �I:'f '' i �l' cl ' J l !• ,p• ��iSj ,l�i' ���_�. �,m --, w/^ ':� III. W: I 41 rV...4;: ' : 1 I ,f \, jj ;'` \—' \r „o I 1 .;'� I v J 'uir �I�'y('' � .\� % \\\ \�,\`\ ��1 f —��� i.r �� n-rG-•-i I �;'\ (�I ^�"1 I �i I liy I' IiI..J• r �r 1 .,��`iW�...ol `.2 j -i•.- I= �I}.i ill 1 � �'^-��\\`• � �^��`1\�\'\;\�, // r� � ( i �� V� � xl\ Ll�.r>��/"-^_�—�'— �l(IfA 137�1 �(�` ; r, b ;, ' I,I�jI il'II ,�!;� 1'rI ii -�`:�=n`-iiT ITTr-r>—�-.�a��lc,�+ Q CI I�!Ss='� ^1 1� I I I i I �y `,I 1- y •.wJl I I1 - - r; :1[,�i 9 �— i• n:: n ut .1, . 11 I \���J � ,, \� � '� � � I1 i � I t I I � ;q .�s., j , i II >,. �ti I ;,u� 1�, l , ` �r .silo i `1 -' �ii'�': I I I �I• .�' jl ( IIi ' '� L• •` Lei it I ' I�-11 '°' I I ! �-��• `> �-•., ;I 'I `` I �i Ij I- _ I •'II -y � � I I ' � I I AEI I J !I I WI d �l� a) I o � r�oJ ¢:J� i� - I l0! i- - I M •�.+rl I I'I i!:'•r ,n� .0 \ I ( I I I a• .' r d I I 'j / - /fir it 1/.i 1-•-,rf I a1.';� ocr I3•. } —fl_� - - ,1 I I I %�� ��l�Ip' p I\\`� �' n u• ! I_ �rl v l // / ur�i�l: ! �" fit'.' 'E�1g"-'! `f I �.,, •:�`�s �.�'✓ II " 'I ° �'( _ ,o•k1 -b � �� ! �. i '.., � ,>, -� `_'�/ ;III_ 1 Q�±tl_� � •f' �I,' /,%�"%% �c��`'��Y� _ I� `"� I � ,�1 I ,' /l/1\( :.i� �I O ' - :>` 1 l �y � `lam"`\ '' I I i---� �-•��' L' � � � ' I•'� �--�� -� sa, O / -�I � � �I i I � � �-_ !�. ' •F�;vo{'+'•4l I •,1/Iq' �l \-r';\1`�I � _! i I � i I• I 11 ' y"aa',c I t{t, . 1-/ `„ �• `•�1 ai ill I 1 i, -'r: >���� l i 7 �.s•.: `tt` a `\.i`1 iI •\ ` ) i/Y ��r 1 s.•. ,, ' I w' '0 �� J ' �` ; I''` ;� I p1 -yy' 11(III' \y1� ;7r;!;%�\t� ',.Y �r �• 1 ) ` � na rV � C ,., �� :( II 'L_. it I ,'�—•� " ' ( il.�_-,� /i�/�\• /..%::- ar , i I ; 1, i !. ,I�t• , f,f' rr� �� '`-_;i'�'i •t'. I .`c`! 1 r , ! ;I I _ 'N I 4:r-r4Z—AAli�7liE=' � �— - - - - -�• � _� —— - - Reference: C44-of Huntington Beach, Depar*,ent of P c works, i Reference: Kleinfelde_ 1990. 1997. Phase 2 Groundwater Investigation, Main Library Parking Lot Expansion. City of Huntington Beach, Huntington : 1 i Beach. Ca by GeoScience Analytical, Inc. November 15, 1994 FIGURE 8 JI -LEGEND: ' ��� 60Q ESTIMATED LIMITS OF LANDFILL ----------- 'ESTIMATED LIMITS OF ESTIMATED LIMITS OF I CENTRAL PARK MASTER ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT -SCALE.1-=300' WASTE TYPE 1HYDROCARBON-CONTAMINATED SOIL HUN TINGTON BEACH, CA - ---'--� ESTIMATED LIMITS OF. GOTHARD tXCAVAiED NATCHED RTION NOVEMBER 1993 OF THE AANO REMEDIATED) BASE MAP FROM IWA E^1GINEERS ! STREET.LANDFILL - CH2M(�{ BILL. 1:- PROJECTS\135730.CPhp\rev35730c21.OWC 21-Moy-1997 T ' r . ATTACHMENT B I: CH2M HILL Geology and Soils Technical Report Appendix C Geophysical Evaluation OQ3198 CAMr DoCUMEmMWORD\PROJECTS\HBLF\EIR SuPPOR1WBGE0 aewSEO.DoC 23 I K-prime Ceosdence, Inc 10001 NE. 12th St, Ste. 101, Bellevue, WA 98004 / Tel-Fax 206-454-4372 May 12, 1997 Mr.Tim Laumalds CH2M HILL #3 Hutton Centre Dr., Ste. 200 Santa Ana, CA 92707 Dear Mr. Laumakis, This letter report presents the preliminary results of geophysical services performed as part of the Huntington Beach Central Park EIR. The purpose of the work was to assist in defining the depth and lateral limits of landfill refuse and soil cover along two transects through the old landfill site. The general objectives, methods and approach of this investigation are the same as those of our earlier seismic reflection work at the former Gun Range site(see report dated July 22, 1996). Three seismic reflection profiles (Lines 100, 200 and 300) were acquired, utilizing the SeisPulse seismic source (Pat), consisting in total of 80 shotpoints with horizontal spacings of 25 feet. The layout of the seismic lines is shown on the plan in the Appendix. Lines 200 and 300 are oriented north-south, and share a common tie point at shotpoints 201 and 301. These lines were merged during processing,and are represented as a single seismic profile. Line 100 is an east-west profile that ties Line 200 at shotpoints 118 and 205. Interpreted seismic profiles are included in the Appendix. The most prominent event on these profiles(observed between 5 and 40 msec) is the seismic pulse that travels directly from source to receiver. The direct event demonstrates that the seismic pulse originating from the source consists of a peak followed by a trough and then by a larger peak. The time difference between the arrival and second peak of the direct event source wavelet is approximately 30 msec. A distinct reflector(Event A) arriving at approximately 105 msec is observed on the north end of combined Line 200/300, and can be mapped southward to shotpoint 201/301. This reflector is interpreted as originating from the contact of the landfill material and the underlying native soil. The mapped reflector shallows in a southward direction, implying that the landfill material is thinning in this direction. Also on the northern end of Line 200/300 another event arriving approximately 30 msec earlier and paralleling the mapped reflector is observed, and is interpreted as the first peak of the source wavelet. Thus, Event A mapped on this profile is interpreted as the second peak of the source wavelet, and is delayed from the actual arrival of the base of the landfill reflector by about 30 msec. Depth control of the landfilUnative soil contact is provided by boring B-6, located approximately at shotpoint 233. In B-6 this contact is at a depth of 50 ft, and the mapped reflector has a corresponding two-way travel-time of 90 msec. The actual arrival time of the landfill base reflection at this shotpoint would then be 60 msec after a 30 msec correction, and implies an average seismic velocity of 1670 ft/sec for the landfill and soil cover. At shotpoint 201/301 the Event A arrival time is 60 msec, and has a corrected initial arrival time of 30 msec. This corresponds to a depth of approximately 25 ft using the average velocity derived from B-6. A weak but distinct reflection event can be observed at a two-way traveltime of about 105 msec on the eastern end of Line 100, and ties to Event A interpreted on Line 200/300. This mapped reflector shallows in a westward direction, implying that the landfill material is thinning in this direction. Depth control of the landfilUnadve soil contact on Line 100 is provided by boring B-8, located approximately at shotpoint 106. In this B-8 this contact is at a depth of 55 ft, and the mapped reflector has a corresponding two-way traveltime of 100 msec. The actual arrival time of the landfill base reflection at this shotpoint would then be 70 msec after a 30 msec correction, and implies an average seismic velocity of 1570 ft/sec for the landfill and soil cover. This is in reasonable agreement with the average velocity calculated from B-6 along Line 200/300. The interpretation of Lines 100 and 200/300 indicates that the landfill thins to the south and west in the survey area A local trough-like feature is apparent on Line 100 at shotpoint 124 and Line 200/300 at shotpoint 208. The contact between soil cover and landfill material was not resolved on these seismic lines, probably because the relevant reflector could not be distinguished from the direct wave. This implies, however, that this contact probably lies at a depth of 25 ft or less along our seismic profiles. The lateral limit of landfill material inferred from the seismic sections(taken at the termination of Event A) agree with surface mapping; these marginal contacts apparently slope at angles of about 45°. The interpreted records are summarized in the time and depth sections included in Appendix A. A single average seismic velocity of 1620 ft/sec was used throughout to convert time to depth, after accounting for the 30 msec delay. We cannot be certain,however, that the site can be characterized n by a single velocity, thus, the depth interpretation should be viewed as a first approximation only. As described below, the depth model can be considerably refined in the course of future work. Conclusions and Recommendation for Further Work The relatively little geologic control at present constrains us to a single velocity model for the site and therefore to depth estimates which are entirely a function of the assumed velocity. Future work involving the seismic method for engineering purposes requires establishment of greater geologic control in the subsurface so that spatial variations in seismic velocities, if present, may be better estimated Such control would be a natural outcome of any future drilling program allowing reinterpretation of the existing time domain data at any time as new velocity control is established. Refinement of the depth model as a function of this control will result_ In conjunction with drilling, downhole measurements of velocities should be conducted- Measured velocity profiles will provide independent confirmation of the derived average velocities from borehole control and will allow the direct determination of individual velocities in the soil cover, refuse and bedrock units. The site velocity structure determined from these measurements provides the independent basis for verifying the identity of reflectors, thickness variations in specific units and depths to reflecting horizons. Limitations This report is based on the field geophysics as described,and information from boring logs, reports and figures provided to us. The results are intended to support an EIR; they should be considered preliminary and should not be used for engineering design. Interpretations reflect assumed seismic velocities. This report makes no warranties either expressed or implied as to depth accuracy, nor to the identity of reflections, without independent velocity control. Further, findings in this report are based on limited data The apparent nature and continuity of subsurface reflections is in part a function of data density. Additional shot points or seismic profiles could reveal other or additional conditions than those presented in this report. We reserve the right to review engineering conclusions based on these results, and future applications of the results by other consultants, including any additional geotechnical or geophysical data acquired in future investigations. We appreciate the opportunity to be of service on this project_ Please contact us if there are any questions. K-prime Geoscience, Inc. Stephen Palmer, PhD. Kent McMillan, PhD. Geophysicist Engineering Geologist CEG 1152 Attachments: Appendix Distribution: (1) Addressee APPENDIX repare, Far C112M Ilill.Inc. May 997 R4 PC L[NFS 200 and 300 Ifunalngton Reach,CA Data Aquishlon a, I Client C112M Ifill.Inc. Shot By K-prime Gcosclenct Associates.Inc. Date Shot April 24.1997 4qlk Coc klddow R order EGG-S12 IMF- A .4e hannels 2 Atli JU, IA14;4&AI'ANW Filter 20-500111 Geophones 8 Ile. Source scispulle SP In,. 250 ft. Direction South to North K.p,i.e Gcuscie�Assecialm Inc. 10()Ul NE 12th Street.1101 Bellevue.WA 98004 2W454-4 72 110 West TIE TO LINE 200 Prepared For 101 110 1 120 130 012M Hill.Inc. 0 0 May 8.1997 10 10 FINAL SECTION 20 m LINE 100 30 30 Huntington Beach.CA e0 w Data Aquishlon 60 _ sn Client C1121.1 III11•Inc. Shot By X-prime Geoscience Associates.Inc. Date Shot April 24.1997 60— - - 60 Recorder EGO-S12 Channels 2 70 70 Filter 20-500 11s Geophones 811a. m m Source SelsPulse 'dt .f •tY SP Int. 250 it. 90 90 Direction East to West a s. E Im "� tm u Processing Sequence 110 110 _ Rctonnat sm Sort Trace Balance 130 _ - tm Kill Channel 2 Filter 20.30-90-120 Its bandpass 110 _ 140 Manual Statics Scale ISO ms AGC 150 t50 160 160 X-prime Gc sclence Associates.Inc. 970 - 170 10001 NE 12th Strut.1101 Bellevue.WA 98001 too _ _ _ too 2064344372 f90 - 190 mo m0 I Shot Point Surface East West MI ❑ Reflector A Depth A 130 0 0 -10 - 0.01 -20 0.02 HU -30 N -40 • 0.03 E E: -50 ...... ....................., ., ❑ 0.04fq a� -60 ❑ ID - E 0.05 -70 ❑ ❑ ❑ _ ❑ ❑ ❑ -0.063 -80 -90 ❑ 0.07 -100- -0.08 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 Station - Feet Seismic Line 100 Surface 1 Shot Point South ......• Depth A ❑ Reflector A North 310 301/201 240 0- 0 -10 0.01 -20 0.02 -30 N 40 ❑ ................... ........... 0.03 ti ❑ i- 50 ^..• ..... 0.04 d ❑ 13 ❑ ❑ ❑ 11 ❑ 11 ❑ ❑ A -60 ❑ ❑ u ❑ 0.05 T -70 n td ❑ ❑ -0.06 3 -80 -90 ❑ 0.07 -100 0.08 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100 Station-Feet Seismic Line 200/300 240 M�HCA B-6 \ N LLJ J O O O at O O O O 5000 101 N f� 130 �� 205 O 6000 By-16 1 1 8 LINE 1 B-8 \`1 201 \__ _ + + 1000 T 0 0 o - d O O O O 0 5000 101 0 N 0 205 118 LINE 1 O 6000 a-16 B-8 30t 01 \ + + 1000 B-33h ` GUN RANGE SEISMIC LINE NET Z r MUNICIPAL WASTE 310 NATIVE CENTRAL PARK AREA CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH PLAN OF SEISMIC LINE LAYOUT T � _ MITIGATION MONITORING PROGRAM MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES FOR CENTRAL PARK CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA STATE CLEARINGHOUSE NUMBER 97091007 PREPARED FOR: CITY OF HUNTNGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA 92648 PREPARED BY: SAPPHOS ENVIRONMENTAL, INC. 133 MARTIN ALLEY PASADENA, CALIFORNIA 9 1 105 JUNE 22, 1999 r [ SECTION I INTRODUCTION The California Environmental Quality Act(CEQA, Public Resources Code Section 21000 et seq.) requires a lead or responsible agency that approves or carries out a project where an.environmental impact report has identified significant environmental effects to adopt a "reporting or monitoring. program for the changes to the project which it has adopted or made a condition of project approval in order to mitigate or avoid significant effects on the environment". The City of Huntington Beach is the Lead Agency for the subject project. A public agency shall provide that measures to mitigate or avoid significant effects on the environment are fully enforceable through permit conditions, agreements, or other legally-binding instruments. Conditions of project approval may be set forth in referenced documents which address. required mitigation measures, or in the case of the adoption of a plan, policy, regulation, or other public project, by incorporating the mitigation measures into the plan, policy,regulation, or project design. The Project is entitled Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach, California. The Project proposed action has both project level and program level elements: Project Level Elements • Construction of a Sports Complex • Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Expansion Area • Outdoor Music Area • Consolidated Camping Area Program Level Elements • Low Intensity Recreation Area • Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head • Semi-Active Recreation • Sully Miller Lake Group Facility • Police/Civilian Gun Range The mitigation monitoring program (MMP) contained herein satisfies the requirements of CEQA as they relate to the Master Environmental Impact Report for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach, Orange County, California. A Draft Master Environmental Impact Report (DMEIR) dated February 26, 1999 was circulated for a 45-day public review and comment period. A total of 14 letters of comment were received on the DMEIR. As a result of comments received, eight (8) new mitigation measures were identified, and nine (9) mitigation measures were modified. The DMEIR identifies mitigation measures that have been incorporated into the project to avoid, reduce, and mitigate for significant impacts on Geologic Issues, Water, Air Quality, Transportation, Biological Resources,Hazards, Noise, Public Services, Utilities,Aesthetics, Cultural Resources, and Recreation. This MMP will be adopted by the City of Huntington Beach. This MMP has been designed to ensure compliance with mitigation measures for the DMEIR approved project during implementation of the Proposed Action. Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 1-1 W:IPROJECT511096-0041MMPI MMP.INT SECTION 11 MONITORING PROGRAM The following Table II-1 lists those mitigation measures required by the City of Huntington Beach to mitigate or avoid significant impacts anticipated in association with construction, operation, and maintenance of the project and program level elements of the proposed Master Plan of Recreation Uses described in the Master Environmental Impact Report. (MEIR). It shall be the responsibility of the City of Huntington Beach to carry out the Mitigation Monitoring Program (MMP) by imposing the requirements of the mitigation measures throughout the project. The MMP describes each required mitigation measure, organized by impact area, with an accompanying delineation of: • The element or elements of the Master Plan for which the specific mitigation measure is required (a total of nine elements were evaluated, four project level elements and five program level elements): (1) Sports Complex (2) Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Expansion Yard (3) Outdoor Music Area (4) Consolidated Camping Area (5) Low Intensity Recreation Area (6) Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head (7) Semi-Action Recreation Area (8) Sully Miller Lake Group Facility (9) Police/Civilian Gun Range • The agency or agencies (and private parties) responsible for implementation; • The period of the project during which implementation of the mitigation measure is to be monitored. • The Enforcement Agency (the agency with the power to enforce the mitigation measure); and • The Monitoring Agency(the agency to whom the reports are made). As indicated mitigation measures are completed,the Monitoring Agency will sign and date the MMP indicating that the required mitigation measure has been completed for the subject period. The Monitoring Agency will also note the documentation (title of the monitoring report) that was used to document successful implementation of the mitigation measure. - i Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page ll-1 W.I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 MMPI MMP.SC2 TABLE iI-1 MITIGATION MONITORING PROGRAM MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES FOR CENTRAL PARK, CITY OF HUNTiNGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA —,: -- ._.� 3.__ MAP yam_ aw�a s-e--s•:>ri a - APP-LEES } v E MITIGATIO. FMEASURE_- - .-... .� - ,_i.:i---r • t_. �_.- _- _- ...a._ -i. _.i3.._. -..l+v.r •rt,r _sbi__a », :t.. ri>.3 � --- ?,Ss2 F •+a,x �< iAG- _- P� .a- A s f . ... -. � aR- `fir- � � �._ �fRC` `Sl"GI�TA�t�RE/c3ATE ... r.S�e'--c.- .L c.. '•�v'--.. h- ::i .S •-' _ .... .. .- _ ... _x z _ s t__ d x ter.: ..,._� GEOLOGICAL ISSUES - - - Measure Geology-1: X X X X X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of OThe City of Huntington Beach shall incorporate the following recommendations into Beach completion of Beach, Huntington Plans and Specifications for the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan final Plans and Department of Beach, Planning for the proposed project as a means of reducing the effects of expected ground surface Specifications for Public Works Department settlements on the proposed improvements: Sports Complex (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Regional Water • For environmental compliance, maintaining at least a 6-foot thick layer of cover Quality Control rJ soils over the refuse;this would require special permitting from the Regional Water Board (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Quality Control Board(RWQCB) as a monolithic cover system 1 • Pre-loading areas where structures are planned to reduce the elastic component of the refuse settlement Witte of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) • In-situ improvement of the upper portions of the refuse through the use of dynamic i compaction • including a synthetic reinforcement material in the 6-foot thick cover soil layer to (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) create a stiff layer of soil capable of supporting structures and tending to distribute the effects of differential settlement ((Title of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) It is anticipated that all project and program level elements(Park, Tree,and Landscape a►ntenance Area, Consolidated Camping Area;Low Intensity Recreation Area;and Sully iller Lake Group Facility)requiring development over landfill materials,potentially ' expansive soils, areas with peat organic soils, and areas underlain by liquefaction prone ? I soils will require mitigation similar to that outlined in Measure Geology-1. t Measure Geology-2: X X X X X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to circulation of plans and specifications for construction of the Sports Complex Beach completion of Beach, Huntington element of the proposed Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach shall undertake final Plans and Department of Beach, Planning I sufficient engineering analysis to specify earthwork techniques to mitigate for the Specifications for Public Works Department le of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) presence of peat,alluvial, and colluvial soils. The potential to design structures to Sports Complex . accommodate the potential settlement resulting from compression of those materials may be considered. Alternatively, compressible soils may be removed and replaced (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) with engineered fill that is less compressible or is reworked during grading to reduce compressibility. Other construction techniques such as dynamic compaction, compaction grouting, or vibro flotationfreplacement can be used to improve the (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) materials in situ(i.e., in place) so that they are not as susceptible to compression. it is anticipated that all project and program level elements(Park, Tree, and Landscape ritle of Monitoring Report (SignaturefDate of Monitoring Agency) Maintenance Area; Consolidated Camping Area;Low Intensity Recreation Area;and Sully i Miller Lake Group Facility)requiring development over landfill materials,potentially expansive soils, areas with peat organic soils, and areas underlain by liquefaction prone �-tle of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring agency) soils will require mitigation similar to that outlined in Measure Geology-2. 1 I I - J Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-2 W.I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB - ..a Zi%s Sr' ..'A•o!Y'. _ _ a ,a.r....v 4•+ :.-�'..:. _.�_<'r_+_3�._rx'�.'w.,_ - �� b. __ r.... .._ r '_Yv�.. ,. S.t, . .-- - - .-. ,,..... _n-4+ __ Y ._.z- ,i.-_e-xc.�^-•l_. z..[_-!_srer ...v. g. �.y_.^".Z. - ..-�_ .9u., s� _ �. _, ', a__ -- -� ._ a+. - ::z 1 ,F `? _ - A,aS .� `r-:.1:;? ..� -_ �. -t'-!r_+•ase.-xr+-G>C '?..J'.-.- .- � .�.` c_ .. .r=_?.i. a.G _.t.=.. _ .:v. - -.._ r � x; _ �;; ;. ��. �. .oH, tom- � . <. ES�O. � �... g_ _ . y, �.[. ti �-. � =" - ,-i30CUME�VTATiON$OF COMPLIANC _ Y�� (` - e. `�. A ��va.._- _-�-.��•_:.�. � _ .- _ > �.<�.._.. _.... zf his...._,,, .,.,Ike _' xy-A _ 4 .. :<e+•-_ _ ar+S+e. - . � -� � ._. :��`�„-' ..�. ._ ��,.,� - -- :-� •`..-. . . ING, ITiGAT101��4IEASURE��� ..g.-= �. ._,._ �;- _ �: . _-'� - _� Via. ---�-�;�� ., ,# , . RESPOhf _ _ _ _ OK_,..., . . .- � �`�� :PRO ECT. ,.PROGRAM - .�--x- -� � - � -- t=��� - � : E -TAT;IMP[_EM_.- �0 ;t'ERIO_D �lG (�GY` •A`CE- � - ..� - - - S,O.I)R SIGWATURUtr.��.�- n:�ta. Measure Geology-3: X X X X X City of Huntington During City of Huntington City of During construction of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan,the Beach Construction of Beach, Huntington Construction Contractor shall ensure that all soils on the site impacted by proposed Sports Complex Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) foundation loads and pavements will be improved as required. Typically, improvement Public Works Department consists of removing the materials to a predetermined depth below the proposed foundations and pavement sections, adjusting the moisture content of the materials so (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) that they can be optimally compacted, and replacing and compacting the materials back into the zone below the foundations and pavement sections. (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturetDate of Monitoring Agency) It is anticipated that all project and program level elements(Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Area;Consolidated Camping Area; Low Intensity Recreation Area;and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility)requiring development over landfill materials,potentially (ritle of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) expansive soils, areas with peat organic soils, and areas underlain by liquefaction prone soils will require mitigation similar to that outlined in Measure Geology-3. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Geology-4: X X X X X City of Huntington Prior to issuance City of Huntington City of Prior to issuance of building permits and development of the Sports Complex element Beach of building Beach Huntington improvements located in the construction debris portion of the landfill,a minimum 4 permits for Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) foot thick soil cover layer must be maintained to serve as a monolithic cover system. Sports Complex Regional Water Department Because the inert debris disposal pit was permitted by the RWQCB, it is anticipated that Quality Control a properly designed monolithic cover system will be accepted and would allow for Board (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) irrigated land uses. it is anticipated that all project and program level elements(Park, Tree, and Landscape i (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturefDate of Monitoring Agency) Maintenance Area;Consolidated Camping Area;Low Intensity Recreation Area;and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility)requiring development over landfill materials,potentially. expansive soils, areas with peat organic soils, and areas underlain by liquefaction prone (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) soils will require mitigation similar to that outlined in Measure Geology-4. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Geology-5: X X X X X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach will include in the plans and specifications for the Sports Beach completion of Beach, Huntington Complex element of the proposed Master Plan the need to remove collapsible materials final Plans and Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) prior to construction of any structures or pavement. Specifications Public Works Department The City of Huntington Beach will also include in the plans and specifications for the (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan the need to reduce the potential for damage from expansive soils through incorporation of appropriate engineering, design, and construction methods. These methods typically include either reworking (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) the materials so that they are placed at a moisture content and density that is less susceptible to expansion or treatment of the expansive soils with lime to stabilize them. (Tile of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) It is anticipated that all project and program level elements(Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Area; Consolidated Camping Area; Low Intensity Recreation Area;and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility)requiring development over landfill materials,potentially (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) expansive soils, areas with peat organic soils, and areas underlain by liquefaction prone soils will require mitigation similar to that outlined in Measure Geology-5. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page I/-3 W:I PROI ECTSI 1096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 M, a=­W �M4 0, 1 OT 1 0- 0011111 TNEK M 0000iF, MIT" :RESP-0-NSIBLI AAO NON Measure Geology-6: X X X X X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach shall include in the plans and specifications for the Sports Beach completion of Beach, Huntington Complex element of the proposed Master Plan the need to incorporate appropriate final Plans and Department of Beach, Planning design and construction measures related to correction of corrosive soils'potential to a Specifications Public Works Department corrode ferrous materials through: (Title of monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) • Proper selection of construction materials (Title of monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) • Cathodic protection, including sacrificial rods or materials • Removal of the corrosive materials adjacent to the ferrous materials and (Title of monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) replacement with non-corrosive soils • Concrete elements that will be in contact with potentially corrosive materials can (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) be designed using special cement that is more resistant to corrosion it is anticipated that all project and program level elements(Park, Tree, and Landscape (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Maintenance Area;Consolidated Camping Area;Low Intensity Recreation Area;and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility)requiring development over landfill materials,potentially expansive soils, areas with peat organic soils,and areas underlain by liquefaction prone soils will require mitigation similar to that outlined in Measure Geology-6. Measure Geology-7: X X X X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach will include in the plans and specifications for all project Beach completion of Beach, Huntington level elements requiring imported fill material, the need for soils brought on-site to final Plans and Department of Beach, Planning (Title of monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) comply with City Specification 429 and as such,these activities would be subject to Specifications Public Works Department review and approval by the City Fire Department. City of Huntington (titleI of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Beach, Fire Department (Title 1 of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of monitoring Agency) Measure Geology-8: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach shall include in the Final Design for the Sully Miller Lake Beach completion of Beach, Huntington Group Facility element of the proposed Master Plan the need to stabilize the final Plans and Department of Beach, Planning surrounding slopes. Potential measures that could be incorporated into the final design Specifications Public Works Department include: (title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) • Regrading of the slopes to flatter inclinations Reducing the slope heights to reduce the forces tending to cause instability 0 Constructing soil buttress fills at or near the toes of slopes & Using proper vegetation to reduce soil erosion and corresponding surficial instability Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 114 VV.IPROJECTS11096-004IMMPIMTMNPLAN.TBI ��_.=e - --- �."'-_- ='� t->. "� c+_--."-3 =•� . .. . �, . . .: _. �� - _ . .: - Wiz. - g 3 - �-, -�;z:: _ � DO_CUMEN A�IO1I�OF COMPLIANCEr. RE � - = RESP=_O rStBLE MONITO ll�G ;f1\1FORCEIvlENT lei Q�i1TORtNG fi. < M[TIGATIONIVtEASU,, ,�. -. --� ._. ;PRO ECG �PROGRAM.� - - - • .r _, -•--� ,_. - •-�.. 4 _ w z MPATto _ . Too E Cyr G _, �a -- �"AV. .�.�. --,.. - °-�.. - '° ._ s X a. 3 a _ -. 2.� -�:Jr - RTC. SO.URCE�._, S1.GNATURf/DA.; _ - Measure Water-1: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of i The City of Huntington Beach will require that project design of the Sports Complex Beach completion of Beach, Huntington will be undertaken to ensure that there is no substantial increases in the rate and final Plans and Department of Beach, Planning amount of surface runoff. Incidental drainage will be routed off of the site to Specifications Public Works Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) existing storm drains to the north and west. It is assumed that improvements to the existing storm drain system will be completed before project completion, as described in Measure Utilities-3. Measure Water-2: X X X X X X X Construction. During City of Huntington City of The construction contractor will be required to incorporate Best Management Contractor Construction Beach, Huntington Practices(BMPs) consistent with the guidelines provided in the California Storm Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Water Best Management Practice Handbooks-for Construction and Industrial/ Public Works Department Commercial Activities, and Appendices F and G of the DAMP. Revegetation of cut and fill slopes resulting from project development will be undertaken with native Regional Water (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) vegetation or compatible non-invasive drought tolerant species wherever feasible. Quality Control Compliance with this mitigation measure shall be demonstrated prior to issuance of Board grading permits or building permits,whichever comes first. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) i (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) l (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency. ,! (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturelDate of Monitoring Agency) Measure Water-3: X X X X X X X City of Huntington During City of Huntington City of The construction manager will be required to incorporate City Ordinance No. 3364 Beach Construction, Beach, Huntington entitled "Storm Water and Urban Runoff Management"and Best Management Practices Post Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Moritoring Agency) (BMPs)consistent with the guidelines provided in the California Storm Water Best Construction Public Works Department Management Practice Handbooks:Municipal to ensure control of flood hazards and . i water quality prior to issuance of grading permits or building permits,whichever comes Regional Water (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) first. Quality Control Board (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) } ` (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 1I-5 W.I PROJECT511096-0041 MMPI MTMNPCAN.TB 1 � . - __ - MIl IG �OL�t EASURE RO •a = �R��Irt� _ 4 , . _ - ._. y . O 0 RCxf StG :.�.REtD Measure Water-4: X X City of Huntington During City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach will reevaluate potential impacts to surface water quality Beach Environmental Beach, Planning Huntington from implementation of the Semi-Active Recreation Area and the Police/Civilian Gun Review Pursuant Department, Beach, Planning Range program level elements and determine appropriate mitigation measures as are to CEQA Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) appropriate. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) i - Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-6 W:IPROJECTSI1096-0041MMPIMTMNPL4N.7-B 1 a - - �O - ,- O OFeCOMP.ElANCf • �,<= O - - l�RE - - � -• =� _ ; - _ RESPOfiIS[BLE MO.NtTORt..:_G=.E EO_ CEMENT �4t0a iT0 �N_C�;. _ "-��T�— 'z =- - � - - �-��1- :•..¢ -�- .�(MPLEMEN �r�� ONE P RIUD- -AGE�i� - AGE COX r A --. ,�� ��: -- 1 ,. -.,_. ri..-+�.. -t.... _ T- -�- ._ F-� _. - V.. _ � _- +_ •__. , - �. a-.,a.,-,. �..' :. .- --. � - _.'fir=.. .-r-,... .� -_ s.-.v--_ �. :�..-__ � $sue. -. ,y-<.. -.�`_.. ,_�'a_-» i,. .. .... _-.. .- � �. -..<.:G. _... -x._ .::t`- .2•u=-' IAIR The City of Huntington Beach.shall require that all construction comply with SCAQMD regulations, including Rule 402 which specifies that no there be no dust impacts offsite sufficient to cause a nuisance,and SCAQMD Rule 403, which restricts visible emissions from construction. Specific measures to reduce fugitive dust shall include the following: Measure Air-1: X X X X X X X X Construction! During City of Huntington City of Moisten soil each day prior to commencing grading to depth of soil cut. Contractor Construction Beach, Huntington Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Public Works Department South Coast Air (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Quality Management District (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) i (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) 'i (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) i (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) , I (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Air-2: X X X X X X X X Construction During City of Huntington City of Water exposed surfaces at least twice a day under calm conditions and as often as Contractor ! Construction Beach, Huntington needed on windy days when winds are more than 25 miles per hour or during very dry ! Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) weather in order to maintain a surface crust and prevent the release of visible emissions ! Public Works Department from the construction site. j South Coast Air (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Quality Management District (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) I - I (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-7 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 MMPIMTMNPLAN.T81 _.�..«..: -.i = - y - �m >� .e+.. - its _.,-:. "r�- - - •�.' = _`£�'S= -• _ _ 0-1 — .�.� �. � CUMENTATtONAOty=C�OMPEiANCE ` .+;.,. _ -_x5�. •7. .acre. -..- asc, =.,t: .T- ....�...,.=xiF..F.R.-,.,K> - ,. ;: _ - . r• t';,- ,v'`.'—"fir'.-r--. -- ,'.Sa E= .. 4 - _ �: _ : - � ;.;,. - - :: _. �_ �, ,�RE ,O lBLE� MITIGAT.iO EAS RE � _-. _ �` ��- - : �< �-_•-m � ,. :; - - -- : , .�- SP�S .<-:.-: - _v.., � �. .,-.. t 3PRU ECT.:APR©GRAM.y-� � - ... ,IMPLEMENS�►TiON� - . . Measure Air-3: X X X X X X X X Construction! During City of Huntington City of Treat any area that will be exposed for extended periods with a soil conditioner to Contractor Construction Beach, Huntington stabilize soil or temporarily plant with vegetation. Department of Beach,Planning (ride of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Public Works Department South Coast Air (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) Quality Management District (Tide of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) (ride of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) 'Aeasure Air4: X X X X X X X X Construction During City of Huntington City of _ Wash mud-covered tires and under-carriages of trucks leaving construction sites. Contractor ! Construction Beach, Huntington - Department of Beach, Planning ('s ide of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency} Public Works Department South Coast Air (Tide of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Quality Management District (fide of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Tide of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturelDate of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) { (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) I (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturetDate of Monitoring Agency) i I - Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program ' June 2Z 1999 Page 11-8 W.-I PROJECT511096-0041MMPIMTMNPLAN.T81 axe v - x _, : . �_ -m, UOCi1MENTATtO ` OIS MPLtAIC Y - T��v, � - _ RESPON9tBLE� - MONITORI G..EN ORCEMENT' MO;IORf = G = : MITI. ON EASt�R - W- t - - - >. PRO fCTsPROG Y �- JMPLEI,4IETATCO fERCUC3 ,QiGE= CY AGft�tGY - - YMIF ATTEIffift NAThR Measure Air-5: X X X X X X X X Construction, During City of Huntington City of Provide for street sweeping, as needed, on adjacent roadways to remove dirt dropped Contractor i Construction Beach, Huntington by construction vehicles or mud which would otherwise be carried off by trucks Department of. Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) departing project sites. Public Works Department j South Coast Air (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Quality Management j District (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) i (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) ! (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) I (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) TI \ Measure Air-6: X X X X X X X X Construction During City of Huntington City of. ) Securely cover all loads of fill coming to the site with a tight fitting tarp. Contractor 1 Construction Beach, Huntington f Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) I Public Works Department i . South Coast Air (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Quality Management District (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) I r (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) i i (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) r I Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-9 W.I PROJECT511096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB I :sr�."� 3-z -`a,=n,.=� �� -.�:i,t.�.�-.y'a "`;--+=ems<,....<; ,.-"ass - ::� t3Q UtiIENTAT QN.OF=CO PLtA _ : - : . _, CE ENFORCEMENT MITIGA JO. ..EAS - —� ,. .• _ � ..:,4 � .z>fr ���..,�-_ - :---� �= ,k-�:. _ ; .�-�< s�.,� �.--.�:: �- -- -::, - _ -- -- . ` ~ _ _ ,=�- . x . - . _ :��_...�.�• .�. - fMPLEME��AT�O;.�J'.ERtQi3 _ �AG'��E�NCY _ �GEt�G]� _ -� �-- - f 4 5 b= '8 PARTY � r - - TUA F SOURCE ,�"`�StGl1T. 51 Measure Air-7: X X X X X X X X Construction During City of Huntington City of Cease grading during periods when winds exceed 25 miles per hour. Contractor Construction Beach, Huntington Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Public Works Department South Coast Air (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturelDate of Monitoring Agency) Quality Management District (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturelDate of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) ,Measure Air-8: X X X X_ X X X X Construction During City of Huntington City of Provide for permanent sealing of all graded areas,as applicable,at the earliest Contractor; Construction Beach, Huntington ! practicable time after soil disturbance. Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturelDate of Monitoring Agency) Public Works Department South Coast Air (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Quality Management District (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) r I (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturelDate of Monitoring Agency) f (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturetDate of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program 's June 22, 1999 Page 11-10 W:IPROJECT511096-0041MMPIMTMNPLAN.TB1 i - I - z - _ _ <DOCUIGIEI�T.A710N--O �= - - - - - ,:,_- tee- � _�-=4 -�-.:. -_ -�- .� - - -_- ,�,. .,.�� �•r , - v .x _ ;- , .: _ - a - �- E�tFORCEMEi�I�"� - 1T=ORING�:-` 4 - p' R r _ s •-- - - - - a __ _.�. - __ - �OURC :SIGN"A�TURE�DA In addition,the following measures to reduce equipment and employee travel emissions will be implemented wherever feasible: Measure Air-9: X X X X X X X X Construction During City of Huntington City of Maintain construction equipment in peak operating condition so as to reduce operation Contractor Construction Beach, Huntington emissions. Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Public Works Department South Coast Air (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Quality Management i District (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) ! (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) I (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) i i l (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency' l Measure Air-10: X X X X X X X X Construction During City of Huntington City of Use low-sulfur diesel fuel in all equipment. Contractor; Construction Beach, Huntington i Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Public Works Department I -. South Coast Air (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Quality Management District (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) i I (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) j (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturelDate of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) i i (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) i 7 Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-1 1 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 = x-x - - - .._ _. . -. �- _ -:- - _ _ � -_ - ..-. .ate-�<�-�r_.<4.:: - ,.. sa -_. _ -_ - _., •= --�%�- .:s,=s- _ ..,, ,,�:..�......-.:,. �r-`x"'- °. ,.a� _:---�.� -e... _ F-��cs - - - t ;.,-•,,,.:_. �.��_ _ �_ - .� _,APPUE$'TO��: _ �" - -�_-•� . - _ - _ __. s. CUMEI�TATIONOF�COMPLIA r������,��._, a�,:� ���..�e�r .. '>-• � � '�-- ,-� _ �. - � 1�-�t- . -�,,,� .�RESPONSIBLE- _ Mtn :ITflR[NGi f- FORCEMEN< •MO. iTOR[N_ � r, = ,_-�::��.._ � �- NIITIGA�t.O, RAM •. _.: _ - _. ) CT.. PROG •., � � � _ �� _ _ -+Gr. r, -- ._ �� _ s a - . - 99-1 SO, T[ RE1DATf Measure Air-11: X X X X X X X X Construction During City of Huntington City of Use electric equipment whenever practicable. Contractor Construction Beach, Huntington Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Public Works Department South Coast Air (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Quality Management District CTi{le of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) 1` (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturefDate of Monitoring Agency) L (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring ReporO (SignatureMate of Monitoring Agency) (fitie of Monitoring ReporO (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Air-i2: X X X X X X X X Construction During City of Huntington City of J Shut off engines when not in use. Contractor Construction Beach, Huntington Department of Beach, Planning (Ttle of Monitoring Report) (SignaturefDate of Monitoring Agency) Public Works Department South Coast Air (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Quality Management District itle of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) i (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) I f (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturefDate of Monitoring Agency) (i t)e of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (title of Monitoring Reporo (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) !The following mitigation measure addresses potential impacts resulting from the release of noxious odors during excavation of landfills in association with the Proposed Project. 1 Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-12 W:IPROJECTSI 1096-0041MMPIMTMNPLAN.TB 1 .�,.: :_ AL _ 6 - At'FLIEa_. v. - rR a - <. #3OCtJ'=E_:_ITIOA=OF`COMPLtANC z � . . -e s _ L. EASC�.R r .- _ y; RESPONS[ CE MO !_TORI G E EO CEMEN;T :MO, ITORIN:ry ATIO OD - A GE �__ =. `_ t SRC SW:C��A�t-IDA- Measure Air-13: X X Construction Pre-Construction South Coast Air City of Prior to beginning excavation in the area of the Huntington Landfill,an Excavation Contractoi Quality Huntington Management Plan must be prepared. This Plan shall be submitted by the City to the Management Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturefDate of Monitoring Agency) SCAQMD under the requirements of Rule 1150. The Plan shall contain measures for District Department mitigating odors. No excavation will begin until this plan has been reviewed by the SCAQMD Executive Officer and approved for its adequacy in mitigating al I potential air (rile of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) quality impacts that could result from excavation of the landfill site. The Plan shall also address the possibility of other construction activities distributing and exposing odor- producing waste in areas of the park not undergoing direct excavation. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-13 W.I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 a .r. .. ,� -�_. s -� _ .-�- 4�..-- ,�.�:•:,_.. ,• W - _,�- .-=-� - =.-.� .�� ,.. ,--� - ....-.: - -.:=_;-�.-e :. _ter•,_-.. s-, �.- -�, >r _ ..... .,. -.» .,.-sty _. c _. -.r. Ss ._.-. -,�-!�-„ ._ 'Y=: a- - '..^ -` -_ - fx- 1;i ._•�#" - - - - .#.:� %z.:r a..:✓... a:J T .cR:tT - xs-.. .J- "- .: .� _`- -r .�` "' .__-_. --f3"- 's ,�;-' .b.'^--^-""_'ae �. _ d %�4am-. S"- _ ..� _ ,fie Y - ." 3 "1-,e _ - ..i x.-« _ _ .:p�_.; ,,,�,_ _-��+•�y . � ,����� g �,- x _. �.y _ :APPLIES TO.�-.� � ,�_ "� � OCUMEL�tTk�IO �OFCO �LIANCE_ •� i- .v )) ..F<.,• .e .-`--,. t(.�''`�.SC¢i.a_v-._ _. v:. ,..E'!tg:.$'_ x...-.r T _^, ..- 2t .G'._+C-:�"'f^.6:va>v C_2-'§''-'� S�Is�S' .,c:4.el+�n �-� YiF�'. -i"�tka� - r.p..!. ':-"3"-a"- -e.s.£^'"? ..�r .. ' x... t+✓-rr z,�r fie, 'i-_ -,e3ixdaaawE`.�Y".�.s�:...e s�f.-.x —i_ -±- 2 _ - -✓f -- '].. - .. -Sep - .... is t�va.: .i - six- -c _. - �:. �. T_ �._ �' .N. t __ L ! 1-T RI NITORING` - .�. _ . .; 4 RESPOtVSI�= r OIL Ct, NG FNFORCEMEN `M0 r = x MITI-ATIO-N MEASURE a Y _ _ �. ..--__ - _.: � s .� .< PRO ECT.. ROGRAWt. _-- IMPLEMENTAL - PARTY - .._. ._ I -•_•., _ -:.- - •�","E'2..' ._� .` :r-- s.�Y- .. _ ,r_ = - '£��+j-s'^. c �c � =.'.,.R::ems §. -k3� .... TRANSPORTATION ._._,. Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-1: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan,the Beach operation of Beach, Huntington timing of the signal at the intersection of Golden West Street and Slater Avenue shall be Sports Complex Department of Beach, Planning optimized by the City of Huntington Beach to accommodate increased volume of traffic Public Works Department associated with this project element as indicated in the Traffic Impact Study(Appendix (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-2: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan,the City Beach operation of Beach, Huntington of Huntington Beach shall reconstruct the existing median on Golden West Street(at Sports Complex Department of Beach, Planning the location of proposed Driveway B)to accommodate a southbound left turn pocket. Public Works Department The storage length for the turn pocket shall be 200 feet with a.90-foot transition. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-3: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan,the City Beach operation of Beach, Huntington of Huntington Beach shall improve Driveway A to a full width of 30-feet to facilitate Sports Complex Department of Beach, Planning adequate site access. Driveway A shall be improved to incorporate 50 feet of throated Public Works Department driveway which would accommodate storage for two vehicles. Adequate sight distance j shall be provided for exiting vehicles to safely merge into.Golden West Street.This i measure B is intended to avoid conflicts between offsite and onsite circulation. I (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-4: X City of,Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to operation of the Sports Field Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, Beach operation of Beach, Huntington the City of Huntington Beach shall improve Driveway B to a full width of 42 feet to Sports Field Department of Beach, Planning facilitate adequate site access. Driveway B shall be improved to incorporate one lane Complex Public Works Department J inbound and two lanes outbound. Driveway B shall be improved to incorporate 100= feet of throated driveway which will accommodate storage for four vehicles in each lane. This measure is intended to avoid difficulties between offsite and onsite circulation. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-5: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan,the City Beach operation of Beach, Huntington ? of Huntington Beach shall construct the entrance component of Driveway C to Sports Complex Department of Beach, Planning accommodate a 100-feet throated entry to prevent queuing of vehicles into the cul-cle- Public Works Department sac area. The entrance component of Driveway C shall be constructed to a width of 14 I feet. This measure is required to prevent interference with signalized operations at the intersection of Talbert Avenue and Golden West Street. CTitle of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-6: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to completion of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan,the Beach operation of Beach, Huntington City of Huntington Beach shall construct the exit component of Driveway C to be Sports Complex Department of Beach, Planning aligned with an existing drive aisle in the library parking lot. The exit component of Public Works Department i Driveway shall be constructed to a width of 14-feet. Construction of the exit component of Driveway C shall include signage and striping to the specifications of the Traffic Division of the Public Works Department of the City of Huntington Beach to ensure appropriate direction of traffic flow. Adequate sight distance shall be provided j for exiting vehicles. This measure is required-to ensure adequate circulation within the j new and existing parking areas. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) I i i f Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-14 W.IPROJECT511096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB l _ --- - PP1tESTO. NMI; •� � - W.:_e.� _ - ,� - _ �� �x � P _ StBCE�`- MO ITC?RI G,.EN �ORCEMENT.� ONITORIbIG - - - _ ".� ,.� � - - - -- � - - -- -- PROC IAM - t _ - - - � -K•--=-� ,t 1' EL�;T'_TION" -PER(QD- - CENGY - �AGEN - - - - SO.URCEN tGNATEREDAf E Measure Transportation/Circulation-7: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan,the City Beach {' operation of Beach, Huntington of Huntington Beach shall construct Driveway D to a full width of 30-feet to facilitate Sports Complex Department of Beach, Planning adequate site access. Driveway D shall be improved to incorporate 50-feet of throated Public Works Department driveway which would accommodate storage for two vehicles.Adequate sight distance shall be provided for exiting vehicles. This measure is intended to avoid on-site and off- (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) site circulation difficulties. Measure Transportation/Circulation-8: X City of Huntington Post City of Huntington City of During the initial five years of operation,the City of Huntington Beach shall provide Beach Construction Beach, Huntington incentives to encourage transit use to and from the Sports Complex, as necessary to Department.of Beach, Planning remain below Congestion Management Agency and South Coast Air Quality Public Works Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Management District thresholds for congestion. Measure Transportation/Circulation-9: X City of Huntington Post City of Huntington City of During the initial five years of operation,the City of Huntington Beach shall coordinate Beach Construction Beach, Huntington with the local transit agency to improve or increase service as necessary to remain. Department of Beach, Planning below Congestion Management Agency and South Coast Air Quality Management Public Works Department (Tide of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Agency thresholds for congestion. Measure Transportation/Circulation-10: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to construction,the City of Huntington Beach Public Works Department shall. Beach Construction Beach, Huntington review the Plans and Specifications to ensure that the requirement to offer security level Department of Beach, Planning bicycle racks at convenient and safe locations has been incorporated into the Sports Public Works Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Complex,as necessary to remain below Congestion Management Agency and South Coast Air Quality Management Agency thresholds for congestion. - J I • Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-15 W I PROJECT511096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 �. _ .. .,. ..,-.- _.. ..._ .-_• .-•_•� __ -..,,< -,<>- ...-Y-- ...,.:_.... .,-. _ _ .<-.�.r -�. ...�-_...._y .ems__.: -._ -.. „- .- --..-.,... - a+xr.r»._--.� --..>--•...__ --.mw--- _'�... - .._ _...•t""--'WR -..c=t_ .z -�_,a..�i..'�"'. .-o _; ..,..x- -. .- _. -... �'-r :x:.e+:r «.. -++z t'�.-•E i...- ..r"'.`»:. ... _e•.;a,...._.'-=5 c ,,r_.._ .. - -?^ - 5?-. .:- saf .>---_aa"...-� •• �M.cd-_ ,..Y`c_ -..taw s.--`" •"<, k. �APFLtES TOa �. = •• -._�„� - _ _. CUMENTA7IOOF=CCUMPLIANCE : --z...,. :<x&�a�' '..:'z�'r�3z".��t:rsx.� --..a^- .�?-W_.-, __ __... -_: >-... --.- s�9�-'�''�,c ..._ _ ,�_.:�•_ .e.,,.-, �• -.:a:--a' - ... "•c.o.�t. � =-s- .. - "vr-'- "s .yi'""- ..,.- •.- _ s�3''.,a r< - _ .d*« - `' _ - a -s - _-�c'r-;h'�` :vs.::�± _.- i ; F RESP G�! tBt_E _. MO . L�OR1t�G: E-NFORCEMENT_ MO{�IiTORtNG� - MITtGATION.,MEASURE .- � � - ,- , . - .,� -PRO ECT..: PROGRAMS «-N :.w .: - . ,-_. -_ - -`- -_ �". -�.,z�a�l�_.--�g�..� •._ "-� - -_.. .:e.;. --:a.._�r.:�x :.-� :_;::..coo - - - t- -�-•r -� -..az� �. .-- '� _ z,�� — .:. . . .. _ �.�__ _-.�- _ _ ., .•.� _�. � - �x - -- •.• - -,a. =_sz_ �. _. 3 �".s-""' ,ram, - `ay � ,�.�:� � - __ _ r., - •' - #_��s+im- ..�„_. si BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES. ..r Measure Biological Resources-1: X X City of Huntington_ Prior to City of Huntington City of Directed surveys for least Bell's vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher will be Beach Construction Beach, Huntington . conducted prior to commencing any construction activities near disturbed riparian Department of. Beach, Planning habitats. Directed surveys for least Bell's vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher will Public Works Department be conducted in accordance with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and California Department of Fish and Game published protocols for such surveys at the time that U.S. Fish and such surveys are undertaken. If the presence of either species is confirmed, Wildlife Service construction and design plans will be modified to avoid impacts to these species. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) California Department of Fish and Game (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Biological Resources-2: X X X City of Huntington During City of Huntington City of An environmental monitor will be present during grading and construction of the Park, Beach Construction Beach, Huntington Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion, and the Consolidated Camping Department of Beach, Planning Area,and the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility to ensure no unauthorized impacts occur Public Works Department to areas potentially subject to U.S.Army Corps of Engineers jurisdiction or to existing (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturelDate of monitoring Agency) disturbed riparian habitat in areas adjacent to elements of the proposed Master Plan. U.S.Army Corps The Construction Monitor shall hold a permit for directed surveys for least Bell's vireo of Engineers and southwestern willow flycatcher.The Construction Monitor shall be authorized to (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) issue a stop work order in the unlikely event that southwestern willow flycatcher or least Bell's vireo are determined to be present in adjacent disturbed riparian habitat during construction. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) 4easure Biological Resources-3: X X X City of Huntington During City of Huntington City of Directed surveys for six sensitive plant species that have the potential to be present in Beach Environmental Beach, Planning Huntington. i non-native grassland,southern tarplant(Hemizonia parryi ssp.australis),.Coulter's Review Pursuant Department Beach, Planning i goldfields(Lasthenia glabrata ssp.coulteri), Coulter's saltbush (Atriplex coulters),south to CEQA Department coast saltscale(Atriplex paciffca), many-stemmed dudleya(Dudleya multicaulis),and intermediate Mariposa lily(Calochortus weedii var. intermedius) will be conducted prior to moving forward with program level elements which will impact non-native grasslands within the Park. Directed surveys for the six sensitive plants will be (rifle of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) conducted in accordance with the U.S.Fish and Wildlife Service and California Department of Fish and Game published protocols for such surveys at the time that I such surveys are undertaken. In the absence of a published protocol, such surveys will (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) be undertaken in accordance with Guidelines for Assessing the Effects of Proposed Developments on Rare and Endangered Plants and Plant Communities prepared by the California Department of Fish and Game. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) 4 Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-16 W:I PROJECTS11096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 - -,_. _+•b_",S+-:- n. t.t' _ -a - _ '�+.-- ._.. .... ..... .. �...�. -. � � e...�.. - _- mom.:.-."..._ - ix"t+�"_4A3e =�G=:=as--X}(f-,a`,.- >- :->�v-_' :-._� .+• :"�^...._ - � � . �xx .ti_ � ,, .� -.� - ._ _: �fi .: : _ .- • RESPO.:SiBL MO tT�R[I�G,ENFORCEMEN-T.�1�+lQNITORING� _ - �..� - � �- " - .�- .. - � -. - -� _ _ s__, � ��. 1 �::�,�.� ..:-_ -_-;- E�T�i - 1 = A�F � `GE• CY - - m�- _ .SQURC•' S�tG~ 1.'A •RE�DAT Measure Biological Resources-4: X X X City of Huntington During City of Huntington City of Potential impacts to foraging habitat for raptors resulting from development of non- Beach Environmental Beach, Planning Huntington native grasslands in the Park could be mitigated by enhancing conserved areas of non- Review Pursuant Department Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) native grassland at a ratio of 1:1 for acres of impact on non-native grassland to provide to CEQA Department suitable habitat values and functions for raptors. Mitigation for impacts on non-native grassland will be accomplished within conserved non-native grasslands in association (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) with the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility, Low Intensity Recreation Area, Semi-Active Recreation Area, and Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head. Enhancement of non-native grassland would include, but not be limited to,the planting of native trees within and (Title of.Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) adjacent to conserved areas of non-native grassland. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) i (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Biological Resources-5: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Potential impacts resulting from implementation of the--Sully Miller Lake Group Facility Beach implementation Beach, Huntington element would be mitigated through creation and enhancement of disturbed riparian of Sully Miller Community Beach, Planning habitats in the Shipley Nature Center and Talbert Lake-Meadow at a ratio of 3:1 for Lake Group Services Department acres of impact. Facility Element Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Biological Resources-6: X City of Huntington Post- City of Huntington City of Concurrent with operation of the Sports Complex,the City shall implement or cause to Beach Construction Beach, Huntington be implemented a brown-headed cowbird trapping program.The brown-headed Community Beach, Planning cowbird trapping program will be submitted to the Service for review and comment at Services Department least three months prior to the beginning of grading. Department Traps used to remove cowbirds will be modified Australian crow traps. These traps U.S. Fish and allow live capture of birds so that non-target birds can be released unharmed. The traps Wildlife service will be"baited"with live juvenile or female brown-headed cowbirds which will be captured prior to the trapping period with baited traps or mist nets. The juvenile or female cowbirds attract the attention of adult birds and lure them into traps. Once inside the trap, it is difficult for the birds to escape and they can be easily removed. Approximately four bait birds are kept in a separate cage within the trap and are not removed until the trapping season is over. The traps will be placed and maintained so as to provide trapped and bait birds ample shade, food,-and water while they are in traps.All cowbirds (male,female, and juvenile)that are caught in the traps will be disposed of humanely. Trapping will take place during the nesting period of riparian bird species found in Central Park that are known to be parasitized by brown-headed cowbirds.Traps will be checked daily during the trapping period to remove both trapped cowbirds and non- target species,which will be released. Bait birds lost to predation or escape will be replaced during the daily checks. An annual letter report documenting the results of the trapping program will be submitted to the U.S.Fish and Wildlife Service. Results of the trapping program will be recorded including the date and time of trap checking, observer(s),weather, age of (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) trapped birds(both target and non-target species), the treatment of the birds(whether released,disposed of, or retained as bait birds), and other data pertaining to any unusual event,such as predation or loss of bait birds. J Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page//--17 W.1 PROJECT511096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB +3. �_.�.,,_r_ _a _ ..,�� �-,..ri�':-� . � - - _ D"OCUMENT�►TtO-N�OF�'CxOMPL1A`NCE -�. ::>. �VCO tTOR[�G:FNFORCEN�[ENT-MONi��RiNG� _RESPO SfBCE _ _ � _ -. - - �-=�•= _--�• - E-14tEN� t o A : SLGNAT°.R 'DA -�--vy' jy S_,. �. .- -__ .. .:... . ..__.... _..-. _ , __ _. _ . . ..,-<__ ..__. .. . .c''.-x.T_._..__ x,. ...�. �._ '-ta. _'�•-. ..3... s-x Measure Hazards-1: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of The plans and specifications for construction of the Sports Complex will reflect the need Beach completion of Beach, Huntington to reabandon the existing plugged and abandoned oil well within the proposed final Plans and Department of Beach, Planning development area consistent with City of Huntington Beach Specification Number 422. Specifications Public Works Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) _Reabandonment will be undertaken during construction of the Sports Complex element of the Master Plan. City of Huntington Beach, Fire Department Department of Oil, Gas, and Geothermal Resources Measure Hazards-2: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of The plans and specifications for construction of the Sully Miller Group Facility will Beach completion of Beach, Huntington reflect the need to reabandon two existing plugged and abandoned oil wells within the final Plans and . Department of Beach, Planning proposed development area consistent with City of Huntington Beach Specification Specifications Public Works Department (title of Monitoring Report) (Signaturemate of Monitoring Agency) Number 422. Reabandonment will be undertaken during construction of the Sully Miller Group Facility element. City of Huntington Beach, Fire Department ' Department of Oil,.Gas,and Geothermal Resources Measure Hazards-3: X X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of The plans and specifications for the Midden Area/Urban Forest/1"railhead and the Semi- Beach completion of Beach, Huntington Active Recreation Area will reflect the need to reabandon twenty-nine(29) existing final Plans and Department of Beach, Planning plugged and abandoned wells within the proposed development area consistent with Specifications Public Works Department City of Huntington Beach Specification Number 422. Reabandonment will be undertaken during construction of the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head and the City of Huntington Semi-Active Recreation Area elements of the Master Plan of Recreation Uses. Beach, Fire Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Department of Oil, Gas,and Geothermal i Resources (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (DOGGR) I i I I - i i Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-15 W.I PROJECTSI 1096-004IMMPI MTMNPLAN.TB - �•. -- -^--�- _ -='.x�r-:�-.,.r e%.ir-- .-�- ._ .mom, __ .-�. -._ ..�_� _- - � ... y ae.'�s�:,.�,�Cs� - - -�; �_... _ - -- zr.^:�- _."s.,�--.. �� 1 - �- " 3. � _,_ . -.�._- �_ �. -,..-_ _ = -,APPLI ES T .- � �;: - �-� •�. � _ - D= C(��.E_ A�tQ a�E3F�COMPL-iA � ....= ..� - (� _. = - .�..�--�__- _ , • -= °' --4 : - R _ . . . _ RESPONStB E � MO ITC?RING= L P 01 4G RAM. ' PERIOD wt S-O RCE= � . -M, Sfi ATIRElD_7t:. Measure Hazards-4: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Studies to evaluate the potential for landfill gas(LFG)generation and migration will be Beach development of Beach, Fire Huntington completed prior to development of the Sports Complex. Appropriate mitigation Sports Complex Department Beach, Planning measures will be coordinated with the South Coast Air Quality Management District, Department Solid Waste Local Enforcement Agency(LEA), RWQCB,and the City of Huntington South Coast Air Beach Fire Department. Mitigation measures could entail active or passive extraction of j Quality LFG to control surface and offsite migration and passive barriers with vent layers and Management alarm systems below all enclosed structures on and within 1,000 feet of the landfill District boundary. A comprehensive monitoring network will be established around the perimeter of the landfill. Periodic monitoring of the monitoring network and at Regional Water locations above the surface of the landfill will be performed. Quality Control Board (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Hazards-S: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Where the City of Huntington Beach determines the need to include irrigated land uses Beach completion of Beach, Huntington over areas underlain by refuse as part of the Sports Complex element of the proposed final Plans and Department of Beach, Planning Master Plan, the plans and specifications will reflect the need to incorporate a more Specifications Public Works Department elaborate cover system to control moisture infiltration into the refuse. A suitable cover system could consist of a synthetic geomembrane,geotextile fabric for protection of Solid Waste Local geomembrane and filtering for the drainage layer, a drainage layer,and a vegetation Enforcement layer or an approved alternative. Agency Regional Water Quality Control Board (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Hazards-6- X City of Huntington Prior to . City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach shall prepare an Emergen6y Evacuation Plan for potential Beach completion of Beach, Huntington impacts related to(1) potential hazardous materials release on Golden West Street,or final Plans and Department of Beach, Planning (2)a rupture or explosion in the vicinity of the oil field area west of Golden West Street. ; Specifications Public Works Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Hazards-7: X X X X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Plans and specifications for the Sports Complex,the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility, Beach completion of Beach, Huntington Midden Area/Urban.Forest/Trailhead and the Semi-Active Recreation Area will identify final Plans and Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report (SignaturetDate of Monitoring Agency) the potential to encounter oil saturated soils during excavation. If oil-saturated soil is Specifications Public Works Department encountered during excavation, plans and specifications shall require the construction foreman to contact the City of Huntington Beach,who shall contact the DOGGR and DOGGR (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) follow appropriate guidance. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) I Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 i Page f1-19 W.I PROJECT511096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 �. - _ ,.,- __a,__..<.:.-_. .- _�_.-r•�...,¢`. "�-z......�1...�_"-.' �-. - L::J`•.:n.-, ,r-":_,"�S`:: --:Y:> pyw•_ tn. .- ,. - _ .--cfi_ :-- _ ., ,� ,�-. �t .... ""'+''�Y .«. -s..� .<..r - —rf`_ ++:-3�, _u4-� .� _. _. ..s' "e t •'�� �'�.iii5."_ S�;; � __ _,a..:a. .:, - .. ,m• =. �_ _,-�.. - _-. -' 4 z -�. G r - -; tT- - _ - -F - `a„'`, .x' 't'•-..��i_A .0 _ _ '�._.-.,<< AM BLE_ -MONITORING.ENFORCEMENT - G TIO. =�VtEASURE - �• - - - RESPONSi - - - - -- - .- .�. �.. .�. •;: -�.%� -- t `" " - s- ^ _- .-� .-_. -� .Y`_ .. s. � .m' i � _ .?.�+vsx -TnW;•"'.sc 6w'^J't' ..�-3s.ao)• 4 '�� 1 • PRO ECT.. PROGRAM. ,. ,: _ ., Y , �. 1MPLEMENTA710 PERIOD• -__ _.-- --� ._ �� -•.a. ..—�.s• ;, _._.- s -- .. s. :-. ua .3 = �s-.+�" -�:, _ A,�b'_t"- �.�.'.-„n ">' �^'.i�<.'' _ _ .i.+w ....fit '.e - _. . � URC - _ ,� SIGNAyf:.UREIDAT - IR Measure Hazards-8: X X X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Appropriate methane mitigation features such as gas detectors,gas migration barriers, Beach completion of Beach, Huntington venting systems,and classified electrical installation shall be incorporated into plans final Plans and Department of Beach, Planning and specifications for all proposed structures overlaying the former landfill and within Specifications Public Works Department 1,000 feet of the perimeter of the landfill. Design consideration for potential LFG migration through pipes,trenches, or other conduits shall be incorporated into Plans City of Huntington and Specifications. Methane migration features will be consistent with the Beach, Fire requirements of the City of Huntington Beach Specification Number 429 and other Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency applicable State and Federal regulations. The methane migration features shall be submitted for review and approval to the Orange County Health Care Agency, Orange County Environmental Health Division,which is the LEA for all cities and unincorporated areas Health Care of Orange County. Agency, (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency Environmental Health Division (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Hazards-9: X X X X X X X X City of Huntington During City of Huntington City of Any unrecorded or unknown wells uncovered during the excavation or grading process Beach Construction Beach, Huntington shall be immediately reported to and coordinated with the City and DOGGR. In Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) addition,should any unknown and unexpected landfills be excavated and discovered . Public Works Department during the construction phase of the proposed project,construction work will be immediately halted and LEA will be notified. Further construction operations will DOGGR (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturelDateof Monitoring Agency) resume at the discretion of LEA and upon work approval by LEA. (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturefDate of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report). (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency (title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (title of Monitoring Report) (Signatureloate of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturelDate of Monitoring Agency Measure Hazards-10: X X X City of Huntington During City of Huntington City of Any redevelopment within the known oil field will shall be conducted in conformance Beach redevelopment Beach, Fire Huntington with City requirements. City requirements include those outlined in Article 79 of the of known oil Department Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Uniform Fire Code(UFC). field Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturelDate of Monitoring Agency) IWO Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-20 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 : _�..�,: �. _�= �°'--�-_. ,.,...:._ _...,� - ._�.��:� ems•----�- :._. .s. -.J:C._}'Sa'.. iL ,,. ..�.>. �. .:- ._ "._ _s s - -rn _. f ..... --z. _ s _ $ c^.-.rz°� _ _sffi"._ YY. - _ tea. c.- - -..__ , co-.,. -.c; _ - ,w,•r . v � -- �>.- � :� .�__ -.. wu s4.�.:.e ': t ra. -t -._;�+".-*srn. -sr sue. ..,-- -'m._ - - ,- "` _. .-:. -',s-.: -sW�x- s=,•- - :- c •4 - r= r ......;._.>sr-w... • -... _..€.`---=t-z... � � ras.t�.--v�wr. r -.5�.,+�+e�s�-�_ .. -_ _. : - ?-' :.- :. �- � -- .�- -, � _ �.� � �-, RESP.O StB,CE s - ONtT.ORtT�`G..E�1=0RCEMENT_ MONITORtt�. MfT1GAT10N.---MEASURE. . . x�_..•� .., .:_-... ..,.. - - :. �--: _ ._> - - . ,ter•-t �- _- - � - -� - , - �- - �,� Measure Hazards-11: X City of Huntington Prior to issuance City of Huntington City of The City Fire Department will prepare a Fire Risk Evaluation prior to issuance of grading Beach, Fire ' of grading Beach, Fire Huntington permits. Department permits Department Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Department Measure Hazards-12: X City of Huntington During City of Plans and specifications for the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head shall include Beach preparation of Huntington construction of an 8-foot high block wall enclosure around extant active oil wells and Plans and Beach, Planning associated equipment. The block wall enclosures will include suitable gates which are Specifications Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) capable of accommodating large workover equipment into the well sites. Landscaping that is climbable along the wall shall be prohibited, since.it defeats the purpose of the wall. Suitable vehicular access for well workover equipment shall be provided for active wells. Measure Hazards-13: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to construction of a gun range,a preliminary endangerment assessment(PEA) Beach development of Beach, Huntington should be completed to screen the site for potential human and ecological health risks Gun Range Department of Beach, Planning associated with possible contaminants including drilling muds, petroleum products, Public Works Department solid wastes, heavy metals, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and polychlorinated biphenyls. California EPA. (Title of Monitoring Reporo (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Hazards-14: X City of Huntington Pre-Construction City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach will prepare an Excavation Management Plan prior to Beach Beach, Huntington beginning excavation within the limits of the landfill which will be submitted to and Department of Beach, Planning approved by the executive officer of the SCAQMD. This plan shall identify mitigation Public Works Department measures to be activated as necessary during excavation to ensure that a public nuisance condition does not occur. Mitigation measures shall be selected after South Coast Air consideration of the physical characteristics of the landfill. Quality Management District (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Hazards-15: X X X X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to construction of the Sports Complex, Park,Tree and Landscape Maintenance Beach Construction Beach, Fire Huntington Yard Expansion, Consolidated Camping Area,and Low-Intensity Recreation elements of Department and Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) the Master Plan,the City of Huntington Beach Fire Department and Public Works Department of Department Department shall review all construction plans and specifications to ensure that the Public Works specifications require that each contractor involved in grading activities develop a site- (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) and action-specific comprehensive Health and Safety Plan. The plans and specifications will require that the Health and Safety Plan be developed using the information available about past uses of those sites and the possibility that solid waste, PCH- (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) contaminated soils, and/or potentially hazardous waste materials could be encountered. (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) - _ •- - k- _ _ y — ._ , a.-. _... __ ....,........ rxt. �_._ .,�-,.<.._ _._..='._-, .._- .��._ ��..._�__-.._ _.. .,. �'-. _, ..�-�3 .�..„__.. � .�,- �Wit. .-,-�..'�_ �.�,-�.. �- - �• ,�-��.�. . _<,>=,.� ..___�_�. _- k - -_�_�..�,�p�.��" s:� >. _��`�_�:���,:::;: Measure Noise-1: X City of Huntington Post- City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach shall restrict amplified voice announcement systems for Beach Construction Beach, Police Huntington the Southwest Softball Fields. This restriction will alleviate noise impacts at residences Department Beach, Planning at the Ocean View Estates such that noise ordinance limits are not exceeded. Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Noise-2: X City of Huntington At time of City of Huntington City of _ The City of Huntington Beach shall restrict use of the Southwest Softball Fields after Beach occupancy of Beach, Police Huntington 10:00 P.M. The lights shall be turned off at this time and the fields closed. This Southwest Department Beach, Planning restriction will alleviate noise impacts at residences at the Ocean View Estates. Softball Fields Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) i Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-21 W.I PROJECT511096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.T81 i ��. __ � - - - -• - --. .., _ . ��- - ,. , __ _yr_ .x. �.�,_... _=. .-_�'' �• � � �. �_�*. -_ � ��. - .: DOCUMENTAT ON=4f "COMPLIANCE.- =_-� - : : ._, E - TORE tTt _. RESPO�,NSlBC _. MO _ NG ENORC EN.. MHO 1 _ ri M f RAM.• � T :PROJECT. PROG r MPS, EMENT _ N, b StGiVATURI=tDA? ,w Measure Noise-3: X X X X Construction.; During City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach shall limit grading and construction activities to daily Contractor Construction Beach, Police Huntington operation hours between 7:00 A.M.and 7:00 P.M. (Monday through Friday)and 8:00 Department Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) A.M.to 5:00 P.M.on Saturdays. Construction shall not take place on Sundays or Department Federal holidays. (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturelDate of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturelDate of Monitoring Agency Measure Noise-4: X X X X Construction During City of Huntington City of The construction manager shall ensure that all construction and grading equipment is Contractor Construction Beach, Huntington properly maintained and turned off when not in use. Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Public Works Department City of Huntington (ritle of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) Beach, Police Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report (SignaturelDate of Monitoring Agency )easure Noise-5: X X X X X X X X City of Huntington During City of Huntington City of The U.S.Environmental Protection Agency has estimated that noise levels from Beach Construction Beach, Police Huntington construction equipment can be lowered by as much as 13 dBA by implementing noise Department Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) control features that require no major redesign or extreme cost. The City of Huntington Department Beach shall require that all construction equipment incorporate noise reduction control features. All vehicles and compressors should utilize exhaust mufflers,and engine (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) enclosure covers as designed by the manufacturer should be in place at all times.- (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) (ritle of Monitoring Report) 1(Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) J Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 7999 Page 11-22 W:IPROJECTS11096-0041MMPIMTMNPLAN.TB 1 i _ - < r-, __ �J+i." __ -.-- r_ .. - �...'3'w raT;.,. '. .__"- - �_..v -a — ..w .. _ .��. .. - S cl+_. _ ... .. .t"` ..A. .. >.. . �� _. - c. -. r. -._ . - -:.-�• .. .+. .v.—x-.l -a'� "' _ ..._ - �;�.._-. .-.vaS�-.+—�::. - i_ L.? ..-..� - .mJ-F.. _.a- ,..':+a -«. _ --- -c:. - _t+2:. 's, . ^s —I- G �S 'r J -•' e - i 3� � ._ ___. ��...__ � _ -..-�� _ _, � _ ___ -� PPCIE . . __ x�- � _ = AOCUMEI�TATION`OF COMPLIAN - -.�:�� �..�,. .. >x-. - ;.. .- .. .- cal: .-er -,' --..• - - ," - - -x _ - .. . - - - - a < - r. ..�: - r _ _ .. ,� .: , �� __. �. = �._ � . ... � ,:,,.�� r�.--� ��. _:_. _ . �:. . _ .. SI E - NtT(3 i . • E EMENT� MO ITORINC .. � MITIGATIO :MEASURE _,,:- � .��_ �.,_ - -��-�_ - �- - ��� .. � : --Y ��,RESPOI�E BL , MO � x G , ORC- - n �" - _ , _��;�.,�,_ �•_ _ - ��• _. .- �... . PROjECT.r - .. - .e :»S'.,.TL'a - � -•; . -.r+v.. -a.. .zrM1;;r.._.a .✓.� V 4— - _ : � ��� JOURC � - . .: «., ._ - :-�� _ ATUREIt?ATE����i -, - .._.. ..:- .,_ _. -... -., -- :.-.. .>: ,«. -.. .. _ _. ._ . -: ._.- .r .,_ �...do �....,: -;•.�.. �� -,�-.:.:? +=r � PUBLIC SERVICES ,., _. �. Measure Public Services-1 X City of Huntington Construction City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach will provide a permanent fire hydrant in the proposed Beach Beach, Fire Huntington Consolidated Camping Area in order to provide adequate fire protection infrastructure Department Beach, Planning in that area. Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Public Services-2 X City of Huntington Construction City of Huntington City of In order to reduce the need for additional police protection services, the City of Beach Beach, Huntington Huntington Beach will maintain landscaping around the western and southern Community Beach, Planning boundaries and the Park,Tree and Landscape Maintenance Expansion Yard Area at Services Department less than two feet in height.The chain link fencing will have approximately one-inch Department openings in order to discourage individuals from climbing over the fence and from cutting holes in the fence. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Public Services-3 X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach will design the proposed tot lot areas in the Park to allow Beach Completion of Beach, Huntington visibility in those areas. This will discourage loitering and crime,as well as, provide a Final Plans and Community Beach, Planning greater sense of safety to the users of these areas. Specifications Services Department Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Public Services-4 X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach will modify the design of new restroom facilities from the Beach Completion of Beach, Huntington design of existing restroom facilities in order to promote better safety,thus reducing the Final Plans and Community Beach, Planning need for additional police protection services. New restrooms shall include an exterior Specifications Services Department door that is locked open during park hours. New restroom design shall allow anyone Department from outside the restroom to see if there is anyone in the restroom before entering. This i shall be attained by allowing no interior restroom wall (except the main structural wall) / to meet the floor. The feet of anyone in any area of the restroom shall be visible_ from the outside. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Public Services-5 X X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to completion of Final Design for the Midden Area/Urban Forest/1"raiIhead and/or Beach Completion of Beach, Huntington the Semi-Active Recreation Area, the proposed training course for the cross-country Final Plans and Community Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) teams will be submitted to the Huntington Beach Unified High School District for Specifications Services Department review and comment to ensure that the course is suitable for training junior varsity and Department varsity cross-country squads. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Public Services-6 X X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to construction of the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head and/or the Semi- Beach Construction Beach, Huntington Active Recreation Area,coordination will be undertaken.with the Huntington Beach Community Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Unified School District to identify an alternative training course within Huntington Services Department Beach Central Park to train junior varsity and varsity cross-country teams during periods Department when the southwestern portion of the Park will be closed for construction. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) . <.. . -- - .a. .�.-e-...0.--._ .. .... _ -.. <, ..A m. ._-. _. _... _ -�. _. _ .. _.-. .. '✓�. ._. .-�az._�- ., s...--, x .-_ _ -. se+4.,<=a. h s=:s,,:�- _`_'4_ - -.iX�•:.w,.� ,.._� 2--„y.. .. e ,- _ _ -. .._- --- .. -,.S -�x«. _-< ... -_. .. .- #. ..-,- ^3+ +T. _....� ... 'SV._. ... F..4 —-•.Y.. �_. ,E'.='+^•f _*'�•�.':+. Y -. _ 'R.e -, _..ss+._- "n.. ... '>«'Y�--. � f...,_ Y=t > .g= - -.- x.e.s.¢9_....v:'..,.e... `»,_•.:vh.r .:_- .r-:UTtUT1E5. �:4 Measure Utilities-1: X X X City of Huntington Post- City of.Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach shall utilize the existing City domestic potable water Beach Construction Beach, Huntington supply for the irrigation water supply until the Green Acres Project is operational and Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) able to distribute water to Huntington Central Park. Public Works Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) j (Title of Monitoring Report) I(Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) j Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-23 W.I PROJECT511096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.T 81 Rim 06� ;UNtr4UANq e. E - X4- 3-0- RQ;�7 St E 4b. M rjh&N.lt Milt T OR' ROME- �QN XaI lna NI.a --8- TUM_ _-�-�- _ SIGNATUREIDA Measure Utilities-2: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach shall develop an irrigation system for the Sports Complex Beach Completion of Beach, Planning Huntington Element to the standards and specifications required for a reclaimed water irrigation Final Plans and Department Beach, Planning system in order that this new system can accommodate reclaimed water supply from Specifications Department the Green Acres Project. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Utilities-3: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to final design of the Sports Complex,the City of Huntington Beach will conduct a Beach Completion of Beach, Huntington sewer flow monitoring test to determine the capacity of the existing 15-inch diameter Final Plans and Department of Beach, Planning pipeline in Golden West Street. If the existing capacity is determined to be inadequate Specifications Public Works Department to accommodate the proposed project's.sewage flow,replacement of a determined portion of the sewer line shall be undertaken at that time. An 8-inch diameter collector sewer line will be required for carrying waste discharges from the project. (Title of monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of monitoring Agency) Measure Utilities-4: X City of Huntington Construction City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach shall replace the currently damaged 36-inch diameter Beach Beach, Huntington corrugated metal pipe which runs between Sully Miller Lake and Talbert Lake to Department of Beach, Planning accommodate current and future surface runoff from the pro-posed Sports Complex site. Public Works Department The new line,a 36-inch reinforced concrete pipe,shall be designed and constructed in conjunction with the overall Sports Complex Drainage Improvements. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Utilities-5: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Plans and specifications for the Sports Complex will reflect the need to direct storm Beach Completion of Beach, Huntington runoff from the west side of the site to the new 36-inch reinforced concrete pipe Final Plans and Department of Beach, Planning specified in Measure Utilities-4% Specifications Public Works Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) �asure Utilities-6: X City of Huntington During design City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach shall install anew pad-mounted 1000 KVA transformer to Beach phase Beach, Huntington provide adequate electrical service to the project. It will be determined during the Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of monitoring Agency) design whether or not the transformer will be surface mounted or located in vault Public Works Department during the construction phase of the project. Measure Utilities-7.- X X X X X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of If the Green Acres Project is not yet operational and able to supply water to the Beach Completion of Beach, Huntington program level elements of the Master Plan prior to the development of final plans and Final Plans and Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) specifications,additional studies will be undertaken to determine the extent to which Specifications Public Works Department one or a combination of the following measures will be necessary to reduce.impacts to water supply systems for program level elements during the interim until water from the (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Green Acres Project is available: • reduce the required irrigable areas by 10 percent; (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) • enhance the utilization of existing groundwater systems(i.e.,subpotable wells);or • supplement the irrigation supply with water from the domestic water system. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) I(Tide of Monitoring Report) I(Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-24 W.I PROJECT511096-0041MMPIMTMNPLAN.TB I MEN. y^^.ate_._ t r... - :.v- ._'9:;.• ..._,,.ct.e.r^ '. ,-.. 'r__ ..._.-. ..-... � --�_� IV[Ef��ATi�N=OF'COtiiPL[ANCE _ �_ -_ •-x�.. � Y:-x x'y._ � f=�.a,•;-'^ .,-•..:.5-��- - r-. �� - __ �,,y�,-..r; 1 �]f�s.�_ � .9_• _ 9+__ -G:x���'i-tY'- h/i^��'rYri�a �. �?�a. ,�?' --'T'�a'-^�.'.C�,.f'MFx.L''S'��'t= �,sv�-.-:--+•�'�.'�` -_ .-_�"-^a_'"=r - -_;_ '. -�-. ": -�P�. _,'iJ'-'. -. ...Em. _.-r - s,�,�.t��_ Y.. R S O . . BCE �.� MONITORING` �IFORCEMEN. .�MO ITQRt__. .�: _., �._ x � z PROGRAM. _ i - ,.� a .. - �- ,:.._.'� :::r '�_ -•.j » U t . sue, xi s� .ss _ ,tMi'L-EME'#�i�AT10 �_P<fRtOU� � AGE CY�_.�-, I WX 7 9 - SOGIRCE' 3�._ �tGN�Tt1RE�DA Measure Utilities-8: X X X X X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of City of Huntington Beach will require that design of program level elements will be Beach Completion of Beach, Huntington undertaken such that there are no substantial increases in the rate and amount of Final Plans and Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) surface runoff. Incidental drainage will be routed off of the site to existing storm drains. : Specifications Public Works Department It is assumed that any necessary improvements to existing storm drain systems will be completed before the completion of program level elements. (title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency Measure Utilities-9: X X X X X City of Huntington During City of Huntington City of Prior to the construction of program level elements,additional electrical load analyses Beach Environmental Beach, Huntington shall be undertaken to determine the need for additional electrical transformers. Review Pursuant Department of Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) to CEQA Public Works Department �. (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) _i (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency _ v.= - ..-' It AESTHET -_. _�.�_�-_ _ .��._.._,w._.�N._�.�, ,�-._ ..�_.._.r �:�,�_,��-�"�., u:; E.�� �„ ,., -�,_� � . .. ,..-�._> ..,��`�:� � -�����. ,,,., .ROM Measure Aesthetics-1 X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to completion of Plans and Specifications for the Sports Complex,the City of Beach Completion of Beach, Huntington Huntington Beach shall include specifications related to security and night lighting to Final Plans and Community Beach, Planning minimize impacts to the adjacent mobile homes. At a minimum, such specifications Specifications _Services Department shall require the use of photo-control-on and time-clock-off(dusk to dawn) system to Department control security and night lighting. The type of illumination system for security lighting will be low glare and will not interfere with views yet will provide security. Security lighting will use high-efficiency, non-glare, high-pressure sodium lamps. Night lighting shall be oriented away from residential areas. The use of shields shall be considered as a means of minimizing the effects of night lighting on the temporary location of the Ocean View Estates Mobile Home Complex. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Aesthetics-2 X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to completion of Plans and Specifications for the Sports Complex,the City of Beach Completion of Beach, Huntington Huntington Beach shall include specifications for landscape treatment to screen the Final Plans and Community Beach, Planning south side of the 6-8-foot-high wall to be constructed between the southern boundary of Specifications Services Department the Sports Complex and the Ocean View Estates Mobile Homes. Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-25 W:I PROJECTS11096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN_T81 �Rs�--.�s--.c-t:-�v �OCUNTATIQNOFOMPLtANCE. MtTtG: : -- r < _ •- ,ESP..ONSIBt� MO_ ITORtI�[G. ENFO CENT MOI�t= -ORIK1G - �l O - _FASt�.RE g .- :-� �" v=: - - -Y ,� _-,, _ = . � � x_ :, � ; �.��.. � — :- i, 'RO, EGT,, PRC}GR�kt IMPCEMCt�ITT10 >PER Ot?. AGENGY y:AG€tCY N 1 Measure Aesthetics-3 X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to completion of Plans and Specifications for the Park,Tree and Landscape Beach Completion of Beach, Huntington Maintenance Yard Expansion,the City of Huntington Beach shall include specifications Final Plans and Community Beach, Planning for landscape treatment of the chain link fence to be constructed along the western and Specifications Services Department southern boundaries of the expansion area. The landscape treatment will comply to the Department maximum extent practicable with the Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design Guidelines. ffitle of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) f I - I Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-26 W.1 PROJECT511096-0041 MMPIMTMNPL4N.TB i y = - ; - _ P11ES0: y - DOCUMENTIQFCO PLIAiC �v _ - - MlTIGATLO EASIIRI RESPON 1 lOb11.T�RtNG_:ENFORCEME• T l4tONtTORt _ _ - - 1r PROCftAM.- , _ - - - .tA+►PLEMEN TKO b0a,00AGFICY AG CY PAtt� - v. = ' E SOURCE _ S!G A.T. R11t)>�►T -.:..._ .. - ...-- _ -.._z. :. ? .._.-. _-. ....- --. - _. _ _•= _ .. i .-. ,.:_._._ -s-- _T. _ _#...--.t� __ `. _-- .'i'.. .mac... - ,,. � ��r s..z r_ t• -.,.- ._� -,--.... .'�`. ,- _. r.r'a-. ... ..r .`�'... _ ...�.,..-. - .- _� ...--�-. .T,- '�Y'-. x`_--, -.ax:.m..-i - - .' . MMIN Paleontological Resources Measure Paleontology4: . X X X X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of The Plans and Specifications for construction of the Low Intensity Recreation Area, Beach Completion of Beach, Huntington Midden Area/Urban ForestlTrai I head, Semi-Active Recreation Area, and the Sully Final Plans and Community Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Miller Lake Group Picnic Facility shall identify the need to engage a qualified vertebrate Specifications Services Department paleontologic monitor to monitor excavation in native substrates. During excavation, Department the monitor should be equipped to salvage fossils as they are unearthed to avoid Construction (Title of Monitoring Reps (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency construction delays and to remove samples of sediments which are likely to contain the remains of small fossil vertebrates. The monitor must be empowered to temporarily halt or divert equipment to allow removal of abundant or large specimens. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Paleontology-2: X X X X City of Huntington Construction City of Huntington City of 1 If located during excavation,recovered specimens shall be prepared by a qualified Beach Beach, Huntington paleontologist to a point of identification, including washing of sediments to recover Community Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) small fossil vertebrates. Services Department Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency 1 (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturefDate of Monitoring Agency (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Paleontology-3: X X X X City of Huntington Construction City of Huntington City of If located during excavation,specimens will be identified by a qualified paleontologist Beach Beach, Huntington and curated into a museum repository with retrievable storage. Community Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) Services Department Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturetDate of Monitoring Agency (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Paleontology-4: X X X X City of Huntington Construction City of Huntington City of . A report of findings will be prepared with an appended, itemized inventory of Beach Beach, Huntington specimens. The report and inventory,when submitted to the Public Facilities and Community Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Resources Department of the Orange County Harbors, Beaches and Parks Division,will Services Department signify the completion of the program to mitigate impacts to paleontologic resources. Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignatumtDate of Monitoring Agency I (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-27 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 _- _.- -.w. -:__X_- ..- a cs `: x x a _ ".:X� _ ._s`-;-•...,ry7 .._���.^" :_�.�-..__�"ate- =r..�2'"��,'°sc;� -,•.'-°:>L.- ."�".-, as-,.�dv..� Y. .� _ �-zs--.a,;.-x -_ .�.. 2s��.c .�.: s '�_ .zv.=..�. - Via. � 'PRO >-:r.�.. ,RESPO S18 I�IO.. 1_T_ORING. FNfORC ENT MO . ITOR! °G -. =. _ :�:•.:" - - ; MP :TAT Q R,ERtOD„ AGEIV = k i- a5 - _ SQ: Archaeological Resources Measure Archaeology-1: X X X City of Huntington During . City of Huntington State Historic Prior to final design of the Low Intensity Recreation Area,Midden Area/Urban Beach Environmental Beach, Preservation Forest/Trai I head and Semi-Active Recreation Area elements of the proposed Master Plan Review Pursuant Community Office (Title.of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency sufficient cultural resources investigations shall be undertaken to identify the location to CEQA Services and extent of CA-ORA-82, CA-ORA-1317, CA-ORA-142,CA-ORA-1275,and CA-ORA- Department 1318. Measures to avoid impacts on cultural resources shall be incorporated to the (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency maximum extent practicable with the guidelines provided in Parts A and B of Section 11 of the CEQA Statutes and Guidelines. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Archaeology-2: X X X City of Huntington Pre-Construction City of Huntington City of If avoidance of CA-ORA-142 is determined to be infeasible,then a test level program Beach Beach, Huntington shall be developed. Infotech's 0989) Prehistoric Sites Management Planning section Community Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) states: Services Department Department "If appropriate data were collected from the extensive, unreported excavations east State Historic (Title.of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) of Edwards Street,analysis of that information might suffice for the delineation of Preservation productive research there." Office (Title of Monitoring Report (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) If data are insufficient,additional testing is recommended.The testing should characterize the site structure,contents, integrity,age and nature of the occupation(s). Testing activities should include, but are not limited to,auguring,surface collection units, surface-transect units,and the examination of cut banks to determine the sites horizontal and vertical boundaries.Controlled manual excavation,with control columns, would follow preliminary testing, to provide a detailed delineation of the site's.characteristics and importance under the criteria outlined in Appendix K, Section- Measure Archaeology63: X X X City of Huntington Construction City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach shall engage a qualified archaeologist to attend the Beach Beach, Huntington pre-grade meeting for Low Intensity Recreation Area,Midden Area/Urban Community Beach, Planning critle of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Forest/Trai I head,and Semi-Active Recreation Area elements. Services Department Department State Historic (Title of Monitoring Report) (SignaturelDate of Monitoring Agency) Preservation Office (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Archaeology-4: X X X City of Huntington Construction City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach shall engage a qualified archaeologist to monitor during Beach Beach, Huntington . grading activities within soil layers above bedrock material for Low Intensity Community Beach, Planning Mile of Monitoring Reporu (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Recreation,Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead,and Semi-Active Recreation Area Services Department elements. During initial removal of vegetation,the archaeologist shall monitor daily to Department observe and retrieve any buried artifacts that may be uncovered.If important prehistoric State Historic (Title,of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) or historic resources or deposits are encountered,then evaluative testing and/or other Preservation appropriate archaeological investigations shall be conducted. Office (Title.of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) } Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-28 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 MMPIMTMNPLAN.TB 1 .- _ t fir:- -= - = 4. .. -„� --,. - -.� - �-X= -` �. - _ ..�.. _ . .'---- .y 5 .- x'� -''Lt -`'''• _��-.`-. ;'s.�-. .�.-�.;..���`—�•� �,� -� - •,_s ^..?.- ..,.. - � a.: �'- _._. _ -a.--- - °, ;� ..r ..3d_ -. •-: ..lei. - .- -- "- f - - . �, .,^, _ . ,-;�RESPONStB E_. MO_ tTORthTG E FORCEME[�[Ta MOAfLTORtNG�, _ - -sue M[T1.GAT10 _'MEASt�R � - _ -_- _- - _ - - -�:_.� �._�. , _ , � _ � .A u�, ,_ .�, _ ,�. -� _ -.� _�s�-. -.�_-�-- - :�:• _ -- _ - ._ 11WLEl1�tEtTAT 0 ER(OD AGENCY - AC€. CY: y RE - Measure Archaeology-5: X X X City of Huntington Pre-Construction City of Huntington City of The City of Huntington Beach shall coordinate with the Native American Heritage Beach Beach, Huntington Commission to identify an appropriate Native American monitor to be included in any Community Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) testing,data recovery,and monitoring activities related to the Low Intensity Recreation, Services Department Midden Area/Urban Forestl Trailhead,and Semi-Active Recreation Area elements. A j Department Memorandum of Agreement shal I be prepared to deal with possible buried human i State Historic (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) remains. If a burial, burials, or a cemetery are encountered,reburial of the remains on Preservation other City properties may be requested by the Native Americans. A cemetery is defined Office as, in excess-of six burials. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Native American Heritage Commission Measure Archaeology-6: X X X Archaeological During grading City of Huntington City of The archaeological monitor shall have the authority to temporarily divert or redirect Monitor activities Beach, Huntington grading to allow time to evaluate any exposed prehistoric or historic material. Community Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Services Department Department State Historic (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) i Preservation Office (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Archaeology-7: X X X City of Huntington During grading City of Huntington City of Any scientifically significant artifacts shall be properly recovered after evaluation by, Beach activities Beach, Huntington and under the supervision of,a qualified archaeologist.A data recovery plan that Community Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) includes an excavation plan, laboratory analysis and report preparation,shall be Services Department developed prior to the recovery of the remains. Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Measure Archaeology-8: X X X City of Huntington Post excavation City of Huntington City of Any recovered prehistoric and historic artifacts shall be offered,on a first right-of-refusal Beach I Beach, Huntington basis,to a repository with a retrievable collection system and an educational and/or ! Community Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) research interest in the materials. Copies of the report shall be submitted to the South Services Department Central Coast Information Center, Fowler Museum, University of California, Los Department Angeles. An additional copy shall accompany any recovered artifacts to the repository. (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Historic Resources Measure Historical-1: X X X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to the initiation of grading activities in support of the Low Intensity Recreation Beach commencement Beach, Huntington _ Area,Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head, and Semi-Active Recreation Area,the City of grading Community Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) of Huntington Beach shall engage a qualified archaeologist to periodically monitor i activities Services Department grading activities for historic archaeological resources. Department_ (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) i (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-29 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.T81 _ q. •.��....� i. ..Ka .... -.•�-ra ,. __ "`+� ""�. -.._'-fit' _,._a,%>. ._ _...-� ... _c-....,. _ '-'g- .;:..,s_ - - ._. ._�, _ __ .r>a.. - -,. � _...,..__..+•r.. _��^`.`: .. ... :r(' -'- _ � - .__.. e.-. � t __ �•`�_.�� �_. _ 1,r, .�_� �••- ,. ..> .._. � _. _ -. _ _ ��> - ..max.- - -'-.,.r. ,..: - ..�+_. ,. .�„ "L:"'?+�-s. -s- ,-a..o. -'�:.. _ �-sue^ .t_a..xw;..-...-s r�+S� ;.lt.� +- � -"�-r--- =:s4' •�-r::.. MONITORING ENFORCEMENT7VI0, ORINGt _ _ . > _' :��.��m._,.�:�. - �.--_.. PtEMEN��� ON, PERIOD ��� 4--� a_ _r_- .. 5- :;- -. -. s.- _ ,:•.:,mac v> -. - _ _: -. a _ -- - --- •>iy'�'sti .._ _. ,"�.."3 _ -r q - _� _ .. Ems-.. �-t,..._. - -.- - - v-;. ar- _s:.y.:.x �,.s.;?k� -.:a^-_ a-2tt- --�-� �-ax 4... �Sf Grp I�RErt?A7F�. Measure Historical-2: X X X Archaeological During grading City of Huntington City of The archaeological monitor shall have the authority to halt grading until exposed Monitor Beach, Huntington historic archaeological resources can be evaluated for their importance. Community Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Services Department Department Measure Historical-3: X X X City of Huntington During grading City of Huntington City of If the historic archaeological resources are deemed to be important,then a testing or Beach Beach, Huntington data recovery program shall be developed and implemented.- Community Beach, Planning (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) Services. Department Department _. ..Y..._-:.d _ .. - .: -s._ -,wl' x->-'�. �-=:.�... .. -..... _ zr-.- -`_ - •._-. '�'. _'x- .._e�. .s. _. .we ,s.:.- > s.. _.. .....Lw-. - :'.3.5.- ,:§ ,'� � - .sSX ` .:-;'i. .'4�''z-" . -....,..«- ._,,.:. •.,�^:�.,. �'"",.,.�.-. _ .<<Y>. _ _ .,-.,.-.x... ,,.. '"- -u.�..._.r..,>._-.�,.a_r.,EoG- ...- �-�...y+sak..x� ._�r-, .�._____ _.-:�:-.-._...r._.tw,.-.-..-. w,.....-.-. ..--".,.�...- _ ._x -.�-,-".s-'..,'s'� � _-c Nr3a:aa. s-.,�. .=.:�.�::�.-4..- u...�; .'ll�''�' �....-.a.�.+r Measure Recreation-1: X City of Huntington Pre-Construction City of Huntington City of At least thirty days prior to construction,the City of Huntington Beach shall post signs in Beach Beach; Huntington the vicinity of the Low Intensity Recreation Area indicating the proposed construction Community Beach, Planning schedule and alternate recreation facilities(including location and hours of operation) Services . Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) located in the service area for passive recreation use that can be used during the Department construction period. Measure Recreation-2: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of At least thirty days prior to construction,the City of Huntington Beach shall post signs in Beach Construction of Beach, Huntington the vicinity of the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head Improvements indicating the Midden Community Beach, Planning proposed construction schedule and alternate recreation facilities(including location Area/Urban Services Department Critle of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) and hours of operation) located in the service area for passive recreation use that can be Forest/Trai I head Department used during the construction period. Improvements Measure Recreation-3: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of At least thirty days prior to construction,the City of Huntington Beach shall post signs in Beach Construction of Beach; Huntington the vicinity of the Semi-Active Recreation Area Improvements indicating the proposed Semi-Active Community Beach, Planning construction schedule and alternate recreation facilities(including location and hours of Recreation Area Services Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) operation) located in the service area for active recreation use that can be used during Department the construction period. Measure Recreation4: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to completing final design for the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility element,the Beach completion of Beach, Huntington City of Huntington Beach will undertake sufficient analysis to define site-specific slope Final Plans and Community Beach, Planning 1 remediation and water quality treatment to comply with state-mof--the-practice for safety Specifications Services Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature(Date of Monitoring Agency) of recreation users. Such measures will be incorporated into plans and specifications. Department Measure Recreation-5: X City of Huntington Prior to City of Huntington City of Prior to completing final design for the Police/Civilian Gun Range element,the City of Beach completion of Beach, Huntington Huntington Beach will undertake sufficient analysis to define safety elements into the Final Plans and Community Beach, Planning facility design to comply with state-of-the-practice for recreation users. Such measures Specifications Services Department (Title of Monitoring Report) (Signature/Date of Monitoring Agency) will be incorporated into plans and specifications. Alternative locations for the Department Police/Civilian Gun Range should be considered as part of that analysis. Such analysis will be considered in the subsequent environmental analysis for this element. ' J Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Mitigation Monitoring Program June 22, 1999 Page 11-30 W.I PROJECT511096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 " = a ° Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park (MEIR No. 99-1) MEIR Legislative Draft Changes The following changes shall be made to the MEIR: In Response to Planning Commission Request, Add Sentence to end of Measure Aesthetics—3: (Page 3.13-6 of the Draft MEIR) Prior to completion of Plans and Specifications for the Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion, the City of Huntington Beach shall include specifications for landscape treatment of the chain link fence to be constructed along the western and southern boundaries of the expansion area. The landscape treatment will comply to the maximum extent practicable with the Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design Guidelines. The landscape treatment shall be submitted to the Design Review Board for review and approval prior to installation. In Response to Verbal Comments from the Orange County Health Care Agency's Local Enforcement Agency, Add Sentence to end of Measure Hazards—9: (Page 3.9-13 of the Final MEIR) Any unrecorded or unknown wells uncovered during the excavation or grading process shall be immediately reported to and coordinated with the City and DOGGR. In addition, should any unknown and unexpected landfills be excavated and discovered during the construction phase of the proposed project, construction work will be immediately halted and LEA will be notified. Further construction operations will resume at the discretion of the LEA and upon work approval by LEA. Additionally, workplans will be submitted to the LEA and other appropriate regulatory agencies for all assessments and investigations that relate to any of the inactive landfills identified in the proiects described. In Response to the Planning Commission's Request that the Environmental Board be kept apprised of progress on the Sports Complex, staff does not recommend any changes to the MEIR. However, staff will keep the Environmental Board updated on the status of the project, including preparation of plans and review by regulatory agencies. The updates will be presented to the Board at their regularly scheduled meetings; at a minimum the updates will be quarterly. �^\/\& » � y` � �&�?° »} �>��: � -��»y y���} _x . : . ?. : t �:���«� :�.» �q a , � - . � .>saw:� , � . . . :�:������,�� �: . � . . ,�� y . � »_ y/ � ��a r \�� �� �\ .» �:. - �p�% ����® _. �} . . . . .> � - . . . :. - , . �. �: . .ate�< : a -s: __� v� v c . / > k� : �� y �� \ � �\�� - . » _ � �� �� � ��\±���^� . - �©� .���\ . . . . � . . . , . � y . � .: ��. �. �a �:� . �». . w� .« � :: �. �. . ,. . . m , �� ._� � <&�«,« �� �����7�a. �. . . »�:�� ��«���<��m��vz���?�_ . . � 7-08-1999 d:28PM FROM FOUNT. VLY CITY. HALL 714 965 A498 P. 1 CITY OF FOUNTAIN VALLEY 10200 SLATER AVENUE • FOUNTAIN VALI.F.Y, CA 92708.47.36 - (714) 59 -4400, FAXr (714)593.4498 July 8, 1999 Ms. Mary Beth Broeren City of Huntington Beach Planning Department P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 RE: Comments to the Draft Master Environmental Impact Report for the Huntington Central Park Master Plan. Dear Ms Broeren: Thank you for responding to the City of Fountain Valley's concern regarding the potential impact of the proposed improvements associated with the implementation of the Huntington Central Park Master Plan. Specifically,as described in the Draft Environmental Impact Report,the construction of the proposed Sports Complex will result in the net import of approximately 110,000 cubic yards of fill materials which could have a significant impact to the City of Fountain Valley's street system. Staff recommends that the response to the concern be memorialized as a mitigation measure and eventually a condition of approval for the project. Restricting truck traffic to the streets described in the response will eliminate truck traffic impacts to the City of Fountain Valley street system. Thank you again for the opportunity to comment on the proposed project and if you have any questions, contact me at(714) 593-4427. Sincerely, Post-Jr.Fax Note 7671 Cage.' rca°pes► r To At From Robert Franklin `°./Dept' u� co. Principal Planner Phone Pnoner Fax r /Y J �G Fax r L7 c: City Engineer file 07-10-1.9 12:15an Fron-ALLEUAN - R40 I7142454355 T-025 P.02/03 F-04 July 10, 1999 M. s.Mary Beth Broeren,Senior Planner City of Huntington Beach Planning Department 2000 Main Street,P Floor P.O.Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Dear Ms.Broeren: Thank you for the opportunity to review the Final Master Environmental Impact Report for"Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park,City of Huntington Beach, California, Volume W. Most of the points I raised in my original letter were addressed in the above referenced document;however,some were not,and that is why I am writing. I cannot attend the July 13, 1999 Planning Commission Meeting in person,so would you please ensure that this letter is given to the Planning Commission for them to consider my requests as part of their approval of this ER? - The response document states that no trees will be removed to expand the maintenance area,but I continue to disagree. I urge the Planning Commission to walk the area themselves and see. There was no comment made to my suggestion for hiding the unsightly maintenance area; in fact,the mitigation measures propose that less than 2-foot high landscape be used. The existing maintenance area stores garbage,excess park equipment,and large vehicles that are easily visible through the fencing. The current area has higher-profile landscaping than what is proposed for the expansion area and these items ate readily visible. The proposed expansion area needs to be better concealed than the current area,not less. Please consider vine!thorn-like landscaping that deters climbing or loitering. The EIR response admits that the Boy Scout Camping Event occurs approximately once a year. I continue to emphasize that it is neither worth the money.nor the reduction of open space to improve the area for this rate of usage. Please provide camping usage data for the last couple of years that justifies ruining this beautiful area with fitepits,a bathroom and a public phone. The response to my comments about the traffic assessment being performed prior to the opening of the Home Depot store,and not at peak summer traffic times was dismissed. The survey clearly states in Appendix P that the assessment was completed in November 1997. Since the Home Depot began operations about one year ago,we are currently experiencing increased traffic on Slater between Gothard and Goldenwest. The EIR clearly states that the only intersection that will degrade to a LOS E condition(the worst) Page 1 of 2 Ot-10-DD 12:1500 Frw-ALLERuAN - R&D IT142434355 r-�l5 r.ueiva :-u(4 r � 1 is the Goldenwest and Slater intersection. The proposed mitigation is to"optimize" (increase)the cycle time along Goldenwest..Currently,at high traffic times,the westbound traffic already backs up on Slater at Goldenwest and blocky entrance or egress at Duello Street. Backed up traffic hinders access at Lucero Street at peak times as well. When the mitigation measure is implemented,the increased cycle time at Goldenwest will further jeopardize the safety of the residences in this housing area by allowing traffic to block the only two entrances and egresses to this tract. Please,I employe you w mitigate the westbound side of Slater and paint DO NOT BLOCK on the streets at both entrances/egresses to regaire motorists not to block these openings when waiting at the impending lengthened cycle.at the traffic signal. I also ask that the speed limit be reduced to 35 miles an hour so that crossing the street to the park,and turning into our tract is no: as dangerous. I asked for the an enlarged drawing of the gravel parldng lot with the spaces drawn-in to see how 800 par`icing spaces could fit into the original planned area that had 630 spaces. Unfortunately.this was not done. It was explained in the response that an additional 170 spaces could be generated by reducing the size of each parlang space. When I do the math with the numbers provided for space size,only 33 additional spaces will fit within the proposed parking area Where will the other 137 spaces be located? The City's expected gains in revenue by installing parking meters needs further assessment,especially since the EM recommends against it. Huntington Beach will be the only league in the county thit requires athletes to pay for parking in a city park. I continue to believe that the needed maintenance revenue should be collected through league fees rather than parking meters. Lastly,I disagree with the response that says that the paik will not require any additional police protection once the park increases in high-intensity use by 60%. Please ask any HB . Police Officer and see if they agree with the EIR assessment. Thank you for the opportunity to comment. I am sorry that I could not speak in front of the Plamiing Commission about these items. Sincerely, Kathy Kutan cc. Planning Commission Members Mr.Scott Graff, Sapphos Environmental Page 2 of 2 12Julyl999 Howard Zelefsky Huntington Beach Planning Commission 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 6661 Z ' ��lh Dear Sir I am writing with regard to the "Master Environmental Impact Report No. 99-1 (Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses". I disagree with the plan's conclusion regarding the adequacy of the "existing desiltation basin" for the size of the"existing equestrian center" and its relation to"Huntington Lake". Please disapprove the report in its current form because it is incomplete. I wish to testify at the Hearing on Tuesday, July 13, 1999. I consider the plan inadequate and flawed due to its current and its future assessment of the damage to "Huntington Lake"caused by the effluents, which originate at the existing equestrian center,and flow through the existing desiltation basin into the lake. I believe the current condition of the basin is causing excessive organic nutrients to enter the lake,resulting in high bacteria growth,weeds extending 6 to 8 feet from the shore and brackish, foul water. An examination of the shore of the lake near the basin shows water flowing directly into the-lake, possibly through a standpipe in the basin, or through a channel beneath the sand and cement berm at the north side of the basin. The effluents may cause serious harm or suffocation to the game fish in the lake, and may be harmful to the fishermen and others if the any chemicals from the equestrian center are present in the lake water. This is a relatively recent situation. In past years the basin was dry except during the rainy season. The equestrian center doubled in size in the last few years. As a result it may be using more water to flush the horse stalls, etc., such that now daily a continuous stream of water runs from the equestrian center to the basin. The problem was recognized about a year ago when a fence was put around the basin to prevent children from playing in the basin's water. I recommend you do not approve the subject environmental impact report until a complete study of the basin and lake has been conducted by California Game and Fish and by other appropriate environmental agencies. I believe the basin may violate federal clean water acts. To approve the report could subject the City of Huntington Beach to lawsuits and unplanned later expenditures to clean the lake and land surrounding basin area. Others and I enjoy the Central Park and Huntington Lake and look forward to the improvements detailed in the various planning documents. Personally, I would like the equestrian center to remain if the problems of effluents within the basin are resolved; I enjoy riding there also. P'.h-w CA Robert C. Schwan 6761 Vista Del Sol Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Tel: (714) 848-2939 elk 3 ��3 �,i LIY`^tn., '�. ? t•irlr��+ tip- _4 3 ' �f 1 7 , -. - _ - r: Tf 4¢F � � T r j `��,� f•S2 �`T l r,{ t k v• is'-. E r j�iif}kt l 1 �J(1�:ry{Ifj1•�'�1 s.1*..- jpOlt Air R Thy ,t low Jv�,`�:`�'1. �+• ���'.'s�c� ,vary�� i"J(' � r Li��,, r}''�`rXY� y� y4a• -��`� '9� . Ma Ll �,:{er -•� �'�'f f�s3 L � rt »'a.,,y� kr; Sl {{�-xfl - "tei�'�;-ttat} t'` y�L `R� bar a: ...;1r ���„�� [ _•{� '�A��..Y,fr y � •,.. �.� - 5 � :�:,;l�. rFx-�,r„r.� ._tF.{.��"�r.'�4�i��,.:t° �e y` v;.- a��,..���Tt t`1:�1'i�: 'ems.: 1 y Etyi F, v :"-.y�f/5I�fi�•:,r'�•.n ' «.'��SF'.• �}y}�1 a.t• F''- .r.r��E -•.T ,,�k kr-t�1 ,•M-t� .�„ ,�� ,;� q t�i.• t, t - 1,�R,r i ,��y ♦,r y +�k, � �-+ �`'f .�,$^fit' `'.. ,� �:. ��a� �, 'i N : � r 44r• `r i � 4... C .}1 "3 j 1 �°�'�ch��� 1.: j •i � '�""' ir''�.u,•1 e �r�l4v>t} '�!I4� �j� +. _ al 1 � �� 'r '+i til! .t.�l r �yhrs•: � '�€..q 1 ,' �J t A '� �'i{,r� f `S 'rl • 4 "'�I. ����ji V t r 'y #f�i�i r •y 117 ,i ..� �'``j,. ;;tiyt {Y � � •,F e ��{�} O > ;{ a•Ilr�'4 r ,r• t i �y J. M i —'i ,1 �,�{1f �~ '�I awl�t,. '?>� i �� r r ,..• �•�tfr ' •,l t y !i�'�� ;,1 } err... �. Sty u.�•..) ,y IHJ• ^t� r ,7 IT. 1 f�,{.y� f''i 't•t e `y v � f ��`(� �•n f r"� t '��'�3,11,a �6 � 1 L j1.7T 'i �.f L .r JJ�.•�J •1,v }D,''C, c f � /'. H�• �y'�r�1 '•!'. f l.,t ij�:11�:"1 � f.` r r � :r,�ey� ' {{,tv ltv L �±�rr,�'� / 1 rt�'!' ,�lle .at~�t 1'' � i ��,� r 11 *�)�1' '!s7 ',•.v �I) •t ! r p7r/, �Dy' 114 tr{N r34 w° �!t 0 1 CI { V1 1 fktt�, Fu.2j'S rA' j 1 !y�S`i,� '�}�' � �� i S "S, lr I��•��?�'�' �o �§F�i��+: Ik '�'1��3 • Pi'`����'".d' 44XTRi �!`�,� Vl A r•t '"i�y5 alp s,�ji.> {,y�, y / SI 1 f 1�, ��1�1 1r �� .I.v '•..! � 1,� 4 �5 �J� ��'' dd'yy'�4' fat�,117z itt n,ak&;'��f 4r +_} 1 pF�d y'f}�'#���tK�l� "�!!� �a i•�/'�.��r ;'f'� 1 Tr ,, n.,-s�r.,T 3.. f*�ht•o5�i .... � r } t ; . �'�`•h 5 +l.�rli�•J,yr j'V[/r'A''�Y��'1 C =� .� U Jul-21-99 09:64A P'02 DRA FI July 21, 1999 Ms.Mary Beth 8rrx:ren City of Huntington Breach RianninR Dep.trtment 2UDO Main Street, .3rd 'door P.O. Box 190 Huntingmn Beach, California 92648 50jec.t: Revised Mitigation MQaSUre I Wards-9 for the Final Master EIR for Huntinglon Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses Dew Ms. Umeren; S;ipphos Environmc'ntal, Inc.reccived a call from .Mr. Steve Sharp of the Orange Co,cnty Health Care:agency on July 19, 1999 regarding one of his Agency's comments on the Gran .Master LIR for Huntiij lWri 11-mril Part; Master flan of Rocreation {.Uses. Mr. Sharp wanted further clarification of the scope of the Agen:y'.s review jurisdiction, the mrilment in question related to the I Ieulth Care Agency's jurisdiction over all work related to the inactive landfills on the site. the c,omrn2rct was delineated as LEA('1) in the I imil Master LIR. It has beer: decidad that the br_:t courses of action to rectity this situation would he to revise one of the mitigatloo iT)PUSUrrs in the.. Final Master EIR, in order to fully incorporate the Ilealth Cart Agency'; comment. Consequently,Mil gation Measurft Hazares-9 from the rinal Master EIR has been revised to siata that work glans will be submitted to the LEA anti other appropriate'regulatory agencies for all asse"mr.nts and investigations that relate to any of the inactive landfills identified in the project,descrioed. This revised mitigation mceasure will be.-prepared as an errata insert page to the.Final Master EIR,die Mitigation MoriiLoring Proerim,and the. Findings and Overriding Considerations tilat nave been adopted for thin project. A copy of this letter wall be forwarded to Mr.Sharp ai the Orange County HedIth Czre Agency. Shaine you havn any questions regarding the content of this letir.r, please contact Sapphos Environmental, Inc. (Ms. Kathleen Phillips)at(626)683-3547. Sincerely, SAPPHOS ENVIRONMENTAL, INC. Kathleen Phillips Environmental Analyst C.c:: Mr. Steve.. Sharp Orange.C:nunty Health Care Agency 2009 Last Fdirger Avenue Santa Ana, California 92705 Wt\l ROILC I51106 004L R AOMEN[ALL I i H.KAf Jul-21-99 O9:54A P.O3 Measure Hazard6.9: Any unrecorded or unknown wells unc oycred during the excavatioi)or grading process shall bL: immediately reported to and coordinated with the City and DOCGR. Any unknown and unexpected landfills that are discovered ,and excavcttcd during the construction phase of the proposed project, will be reported to LEA and construction woik wili by immediately halted, Further construction operations will resume a the discretion of LEA and upon work approval by LEA. Additionally,-majtUlans Will be submitted to-the LEA and other appropti to regulatory agencies for all assessments and investigations that relate to any of the inactive landfills identified _,In the pgjecls described. W:\PR,OjEC:T5.1096 004\rlR\A[)L)END\ADI)ENDmm-KAr- PROOF OF PUBLICATION STATE OF CALIFORNIA) NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING . SS. BEFORE THE CITY_ 'COUNCIL OF THE. County of Orange ) CITY"OV" " HUNTINGTON BEACH, NOTICE 1S HEREBY GIVEN that on Monday, am a Citizen Of the United States and a 4ugust2,1999,at7:00PM in the City Council resident of the County aforesaid; I am Street,bHuntingo0'Beach, the City-Council will hold a over the age of eighteen years, and not a public hearing on the.fol- lowing Item:. party to or interested in the below MASTER ENVIRONMEN- jTAL -IMPACT. REPORT entitled matter. I am a principal clerk of :NO:99=1 (MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION ,USES the HUNTINGTON BEACH INDEPENDENT, a _App cant: CityLofPHunt- 'ington Beach; Community newspaper of general circulation, printed Services Department Re- quest: Certification of an and published in the City of Huntington !environmental impact re- Iport for the master plan of Beach, County of Orange, State of ;157.5 acres in Huntington 'Central Park Location: Be- California, and that attached Notice is a tween Edwards the iwest,•.,Gothard. Street., on i true and complete copy as was printed the east,Slate r Ave nueon the North and Ellis Avenue and published- in -the -Huntington' Beach 6.6the Soutti.Planner As- signed:,'Mary':Beth Broeren and Fountain Valley i$$Ue$ of said NOTICE:IS`HEREBY: GIVEN-that the above item newspaper to wit the issue(s) of: is covered by.Environmeh- tal-Impact Report No.99-1. ON'FILE: A copy of the- p�oposed request is on file in the Planning Depart- ment, 2000 Main_Street, Huntington Beach, Califor- nia.92648, for inspection by the public.A copy of the July 22 , 1999 staff report will be available to.interested parties at City Hall or the Main City.Li- 1 brary (7111 Talbert Ave- nue)after July 29,1999. ALL INTERESTED PER- SONS are invited to attend I declare, under penalty of perjury, that said hearing'andexpress the foregoing is true and correct. opinions or denceforora 9submir eP_ ainstthe a Ifrlicati'on-as outlmed.above.. -..you challenge the City Council's action-in court, you may be limited to rais- EXE'CUted On I ing•only",those issues;you J u 1 v 2 2 , 19 9 9 or someone else raised at the" public hearing_-de- at Costa Mesa, California. scribed in this notice,or in written correspondence. delivered to the City at, or Frior to,the public hearing. I there are any further. PI .please call the Planning Department at 536-5271 and refer to the above item. Direct your written communications to. the City Clerk. - Connle Brockway, :.- City Clerk ... Signature ::` Hunti Ci_ty'of ngton Beach. —20.00_Maln-Street--- 2nd.Floor Huntington Beach , California 92648 r (714)536-5227 Published -.Huntington Beach-Fountain Valley Independent July 22,1999 074-194 PROOF OF PUBLICATION STATE OF CALIFORNIA) } NOTICE OF = PUBLIC HEARING S S BEFORE THE CITY 'COUNCIL OF,..HE CITY_OFF"5 County of Orange ) HNOTN TONUB IS EEfi& REBY GIVEN• that on Monday, August 2,1999;at-7:00 I am a Citizen of the United States and a In -the City. Council in 2000 -Main Street, Huntington Beach; resident of the County aforesaid; I am the City Council will hold a- public hearing on the fol- over the age of eighteen years, and not a lowing Item: i MASTER ENVIRONMEN- party to or interested in the below .TAL IMPACT. ,-REPORT NO.99-1 (MASTER PLAN entitled matter. I am a rinci al clerk of OF; RECREATION USES P P aFOR" CENTRAL-PARK) `Applicant: City -of.-"Hunt- the HUNTINGTON BEACH INDEPENDENT, a 'ington'Beach; Community- newspaper of general circulation printed ;Services Department--Re- bquest: Certification-of an `environmental -impact re= and pu lished in the City of Huntington port for the master plan of 157.5 acres in Huntington Beach, County of Orange, State of Central Park Location:Be- tween Edwards on the California, and that attached Notice is a twest, Gothard Street,on true and complete copy as was printed the east,Slater Ellis Avenue the North and Ellis Avenue As- and published in the Huntington Beach on the South Planner As signed:Mary'Beth 8[oeren P •NOTICE Is HEREBY and Fountain Valley issues of said GIVENthat the-above item is covered by Environmen- talnewspaper to wit the issue(s) of: ON FILE: A c py of he ON FILE: AA copy of the proposed request is on file in the Planning. Depart- ment, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach,Califor nia.-92648, for,•.inspection by_the.public.A copy;of the staff report will be available July 22 , 1999 "to interested parties at City Hall or;the Main City Li- brary (7111 Talbert`Ave- nue)after July 29,1999. ALL INTERESTED PER- SONS are invited to attend I declare, under penalty of perjury, that said hearing submit express opinions or submdst _.evi-' ap- the foregoing is true and correct. dpecationnce southor ed.ab've lication as outhned.above:. If you challenge the-City council's action in court, :you maybe limited to rais- ing only;"those issues you or someone else,iaised at Executed on July 22 , 1999 the `public hearing de at Costa Mesa, California. scribed in this notice,:or in C written- correspondence delivered to the City at, or 1Inor to,-the public hearing. there are .any further questions please cal the Planning Department at 536-5271 and refer to the above item Direct your written communications to the City.Clerk.' Connie Brockway, City Clerk C ty of Huntington Beach - Signature I___2000 main-streat-_ grid Floor Huntington Beach California 92648, (714)"536-5227 Published Huntington` Beach-Fountain Valley Independent July 22,1999 074-194 TABLE V-2 ELEMENTS OF THE MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES AND ALTERNATIVES ELEMENT'„"_: ,- NO PROJECT `== PROPOSED PRjOJECT_ ALTERNATIVE ALTERNATIVE,2 ALTERNATIVE 3 - _T . . _ _ PROJECT SPORTS COMPLEX 45-Acre Vacant Lot Net Import—110,000 cy Net Import— 110,000 cy Net Import—110,000 cy Net Import— 110,000 cy Chain-link Fence Grading-45 acres Grading-45 acres Grading-45 acres Grading-45 acres One Plugged and Abandoned Oil Well Impervious Surface-2.7 acres Impervious Surface—11 acres Impervious Surface—3.7 acres Impervious Surface—5.5 acres Construction Access is Northbound Construction Access is Northbound Construction Access is Northbound Construction Access is Northbound U.S.Interstate 405 to Golden West St. U.S.Interstate 405 to Golden West SL U.S.Interstate 405 to Golden West St. U.S.Interstate 405 to Golden West St. south to Edinger Street east to Gothard south to Edinger Street east to Gothard south to Edinger Street east to Gothard south to Edinger Street east to Gothard Street South to the project site Street South to the project site Street South to the project site Street South to the project site Staging wA Construction Area Staging wA Construction Area Staging wA Construction Area Staging wA Construction Area PHASE 1 PHASE 1 PHASE 1 PHASE 1 Construction—38 weeks Construction—38 weeks Construction—38 weeks Construction—38 weeks Gravel Parking Lot(800 spaces) Gravel Parking Lot(366 spaces) Gravel Parking Lot(366 spaces) Parking Lot(285 spaces) Sidewalk Adjacent to Golden West St 2 90'x140'Roller Hockey Courts Parking Lot(216 spaces) Parking Lot(257 spaces) Buffer ZoneBlock Wall 2 Minor Baseball Fields Parking Lot(88 spaces) Parking Lot(40 spaces) Tot Lot w/Shade Structure 2 220'x340'Soccer/Football Field 2 90'x140'Roller Hockey Courts 2 85'x185'Roller Hockey Courts 4 Lighted 300'Softball Fields Overlays 4 Soccer/Football Field Overlays 3 195'x300'Soccer/Football fields 4 Lighted 210'x330'Soccer/Football 1 Senior Baseball Field 4 300'Softball Fields w/Permanent 2 180'x300'Soccer/Football fields fields 1 T-Ball Field Backstops and Lighting 2 Stadium Baseball Concessions 4 85'x185'Roller Hockey Courts 1 Restroom/Concession Stand 2 Restrooms(Concession Stands Restroom w/Concession Building. PHASE 2 Batting Cage PHASE 2 PHASE 2 Construction—22 weeks Construction-22 weeks Construction—22 weeks Sports Practice Field PHASE 2 Sports Practice Field Sports Practice Field Construction-22 weeks Tot Lot w/Shade Structure PHASE 3 Restroom w/Concession Building Construction—38 weeks 4 Lighted 300'Softball Fields Parking Lot—380 Spaces " wBleachers Multipurpose Gymnasium w/offices, 4 Lighted 210'x330'Soccer/Football lockers,and meeting rooms . fields Outdoor Aquatic Facility PARK,TREE,AND LANDSCAPE 0.25 Acre Landscaped Area of Park Construction-3 weeks Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project :- Same as Proposed Project MAINTENANCE YARD EXPANSION No Facilities Grading—0.25 acres Cut(fill—400 cy,balanced onsite Construction Access is Northbound U.S.Interstate 405 to Golden West St. south to Edinger Street east to Gothard Street South to the project site Staging wA Gothard Parking Lot( Proposed Expansion Area Fence Gravel Hubbing Yard Equipment Storage Storage Bins Tree Planter w/Bank Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park _ - Findings and Overriding Considerations June 2Z 1999 Page V-9 WAPROJECT511096.0041 FINDlNGS11096004.S5A TABLE V-2 ELEMENTS OF THE MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES AND ALTERNATIVES ;_ELEMENT -NO PROJECT PROPOSED PROJECT -`;: ALTERNATIVE.1', NATIVE2': ALTERNATIVE3,.a _; -- AITER OUTDOOR MUSIC AREA Construction-4 weeks Element Approved by Board for Element Approved by.Board for Element Approved by Board for Element Approved by Board for Grading-0.1 acres Construction:Same as No Project Construction:Same as No Project Construction:Same as No Project Construction:Same as No Project - Cut/fill-230 cy,balanced onsite Construction Access is U.S.Interstate 405 to Golden West St.south to Edinger Street east to Gothard Street South Staging w/I Designated Project Area CONSOLIDATED CAMPING AREA 13.5 Acres currently used for youth Construction-3 months Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project tent camping. Grading-13.5 acres Cut/fill-2,000 cy,balanced onsite No ADA accessible restroom facility. Telephone Line No security lighting. Security Lighting Water Facilities PicniclGroup Meeting Area Automatic Irrigation System Site Furniture Installation of Plant Material -- -- - - ®RUGRAAf•ELEMEMS' �r* ,= Y'�r.;�'��'�x;>.�-.�:s��.� t_.a.�.': _ -;- ` Sr,-^,�5, `�z�`-'*�+�.: �.T-c_"�'?""-.e:.�:� n.�'t��=:= `��-"a=`r� :"`�''�--•�-.- - _-_`'T �p.'k" � '�-�i��T�•' LOW INTENSITY RECREATION 16.0 Acres undeveloped vacant lot Construction-16 acres Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project Grading-Undetermined Used annually as temporary location Cut/fill-Undetermined for Disc Golf Picnic Facilities w/shade structure Restroom Tot Lot Open Turf Area Play Area Automatic Irrigation System Site Furniture Installation of Plant Material MIDDEN AREAIURBAN FOREST/ 45 acres with 24 plugged and Construction-45 acres Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project TRAILHEAD abandoned oil wells Grading-undetermined Cutffi l l-undetermined 6 active oil wells Social Trails Shade Overheads Accessible Restroom at Trailhead Automatic Irrigation System Site Furniture Installation of Plant Material Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park _ _ findings and Overriding Considerations June 22.1999 Page V-10 w.t PROI ECT517096-0041 FINDING517096004.55A TABLE V-2 ELEMENTS OF THE MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES AND ALTERNATIVES "N 2�PR_,OP0 PROJECT'. r'. _�! :-�_ _-AfTERNATIVE*�- LTERNATIV WA 0 SED 3 SEMI ACTIVE RECREATION AREA 10 acres with 6 plugged and Construction—10 acres Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project abandoned oil wells Grading—undetermined Cut/fill—undetermined Used as overflow parking for major equestrian and fund-raising events at Therapeutic Riding Center Huntington Central Park Open Turf Passive Field(Overflow Parking) Tat Lot Aquatic/Swim Center Parking Area Automatic Irrigation System Site Furniture Installation of Plant Material SULLY MILLER LAKE GROUP 20 acres with 2 plugged and Construction—7.5 acres Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project FACILITY abandoned oil wells Grading—undetermined Cut(fill—undetermined Abandoned quarry w1perennial water Abandonedlandfill Group Picnic Facilities Fenced Fishing Facilities Automatic Irrigation System Site Furniture Installation of Plant Material POLICEICIVILIAN GUN RANGE Police/Civilian Gun Range facilities are Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project Same as Proposed Project dosed City Council subcommittee assigned to evaluate relocation of Police/Civilian Gun Range(including existing location) Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22,1999 Page V_I I w.1,I)ROJECT511096.0041FINDINCS1 1096004.55A TABLE V-3 COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF IMPACTS FOR MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES AND ALTERNATIVES RESOURCE' ,_ r NO PROJi _ z yPROPOSED PROJECT .` VMS TERMA71VE1_�« 9, SAC ERHfA71V ? ALTER.ATl1/E_3r LAND USE AND PLANNING • No impact on land use and planning • No impact on land use and planning Same as proposed project Same as proposed project , Same as proposed project. anticipated under the No-Project anticipated under the proposed project Alternative. - Does not conflict with adopted - • Does not conflict with adopted environmental plans and goals of the environmental plans and goals of the community where it is located. _ community where it is located. - Is compatible with existing land use in - • Is compatible with existing land use in the vicinity. thevicinity.- - Does not disrupt or divide the physical • Does not disrupt or divide the physical arrangement of an established arrangement of an established community. community. - - Does not convert prime agricultural Does not convert prime agricultural land to nonagricultural use or impair land to nonagricultural use or impair the agricultural productivity of prime the agricultural productivity of prime agricultural land. agricultural land. • No mitigation measures are required. i • No mitiaation measures are reouired. POPULATION AND HOUSING 9 No impact on population and housing • No impact on population and housing Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project anticipated under the No-Project anticipated under the proposed project Alternative. - Does not exceed officiai regional or - Does not exceed official regional or local population projections. ' local population projections. - Does not induce substantial growth in - Does not induce substantial growth in the project area,either directly or the project area,either directly or indirectly. _- indirectly. - Does not displace any existing Does not displace any existing housing. ' housing. • No mitigation measures required.,, • No mithtation measures reauired. - GEOLOGIC ISSUES • The No4lroject Alternative would likely • Development of recreational facilities in Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project- Same as proposed project, result in a maintenance of the existing the vicinity of the proposed Sports • Additional structures(multi-purpose • An increased area of irrigated turf level of risk at the Park with respect to Complex has the potential to expose Gymnasium and Aquatic Center)to be overlying landfill material at the seismic ground shaking in the Newport- people to geologic problems, constructed at the proposed Sports proposed Sports Complex will increase Inglewood fault zone,seismic ground - Development over compressible Complex will increase the potential for - the potential for exposure of people to shaking subsidence of the land materials(peat soils,alluvial and - exposwe of people to geologic issues. geologic issues. (particularly in the vicinity of the former colluvial deposits,artificial fill,refuse, • As with the proposed project,site specific - • As with the proposed project,this ' landfil8,and expansive and collapsive and landfill materia4 may result in design requirements and incorporation of - alternative requires incorporation of soils. natural or earthquake4nduced Measures Geology-1 through-8 are Measures Geology-1 through-a.An settlement and structural damage. expected to reduce geologic impacts - additional Measure Geology-9 is required Development in a seismically-active associated with this alternative below the to reduce geologic impacts associated area has the potential m impact all level of significanm with this alternative below the level of proposed structural developments. _ significance. • Implementation of Measures Geology-1 through-8 is capable of reducing risks to - people from geologic problems below the level of significance. • Measure Hazards-2 addresses impacts related to potential ground subsidence - related to underlying refuse at the Sports - Complex site. Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Findings and Overriding Considerations lure22,1999 Page V-12 W.-I PROI ECTSI 1096.0041 FINDlNG511096004.SSA TABLE V-3 COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF IMPACTS FOR MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES AND ALTERNATIVES .� '-r... st agar--:s&.y -. __ rw.L -3- RESOt7RC " k— NO.PROJECT---jlm- . --? PROPOSED PROJECT xr_ -;' ALTERNATLVEI f _� _L:At7ERNATIVE '- '` ^� s ALTERNATIVE WATER - • The No-Project Alternative would likely • Development of the proposed project has Same as proposed project Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project result in a maintenance of the existing the potential to result in impacts on water • Development of this alternative could • Development of this alternative could • Development of this alternative could level of risk to people and property from resources." result in increased quantities and rates of -result in increased quantities or rates of result in increased quantities or rates of existing drainage deficiencies at the - Construction of the project-level surface water runoff and increased water surface water runoff and increased water surface water runoff and increased water- location of the proposed Sports Complex, elements could result in impacts to quality impacts from development of 8.3 quality impacts from development of 1.0 quality impacts from development of 2.8 stormwater and runoff water quality additional acres of impervious surface. additional acres of impervious surface. additional acres of impervious surface. during the construction phase. • Development of an aquatic center could • As with the proposed project, • ,.s with the proposed project, - Operation of the proposed Sports result in water quality impacts from implementation of Measures Water-1 implementation of Measures Water-I Complex may result in impacts to discharge of chlorinated water from the through-4 and Measure Hazards-S is through 4 and Measure Hazards-5 is surface and/or groundwater quality site. expected to reduce impacts of this expected to reduce impacts of this - from the use of pesticides and fertilizer •As with the proposed project, alternative on water below the level of alternative on water below the level of on the turf areas and from leaching of implementation of Measures Water-1 significance. significance. the closed landfill. through 1 and Measure Hazards-5 is - • Implementation of Measures Water-1 expected to reduce impacts of this through 4 is expected to reduce impacts alternative on water below the level of - on water from the project level elements significance.of the Master Plan to below the level of significance. • Implementation of Measure Hazards-5 is expected to reduce potential impacts on ' groundwater from irrigation of the Sports - below the level of si nificance. AIR QUALITY • No construction would take place. • Proposed project would have significant Same as proposed project Same as Alternative 1. Same as Alternative 1. Therefore,there are no anticipated short short-term construction impacts on air • Slightly fewer overall construction term impacts on air quality due to quality and would exceed SCAQMD impacts are expected from construction would result from thresholds for NOx and PM,, implementation of this alternative,due to implementation of the No-Project • Longterm cumulative impacts ale not a decrease in the number of parking Alternative. expected. The number of vehicle trips to spaces to be constructed. - • The No-Project Alternative would likely the site.during operation is expected to result in maintenance of current levels of transfer from one park to another. _ nuisance dust and PM, emissions Fran Therefore,regional air emissions are wind-driven dust doug impacting expected to remain at current levels. - - mobile home residents south of complex. • Implementation of Measures Air-1 . throw A are expected to reduce short - - term fugitive dust emissions below the level of significance. Implementation of - Measures Air-9 through-12 would reduce short-term construction impacts from nitrogen oxides and PM_however not below the level of si nificance. TRANSPORTATION/CIRCULATION • The No-Project Alternative would result • Development of the proposed project has Same as proposed project: Same as proposed project. Same as proposed projecL in a continuation of the existingthe potential to result in impacts pacts on • Development of this alternative would transportation/circulation conditions at transportation and circulation. - result in increased impacts on parking. the Park No new impacts would be - Operation of the proposed Spats • As with the proposed project,this anticipated and no new measures would Complex would significantly impact alternative would require implementation be required. one key intersection requiring of Measures-1 through-7.An additional mitigation(Golden West Street and Measure-8 would be impacts on tran wired to reduce Slater Avenue), sportgnordarcvlation Operation of the proposed Sports below the level of significance. Complex would result in increased - vehicle congestion requiring mitigation. Operation of the proposed Sports Complex will not result in insufficient parking on or offsite. • Implementation of Measures Transportation/Circulation-1 through-7 are expected to reduce impacts on transportation/circulation below the level of significance. Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Findings and Overriding Considerations June22,1999 - Page t'-I3 W:IPROJECTS11096-0040NDINGSI f 09600a.SSA . TABLE V-3 COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF IMPACTS FOR MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES AND ALTERNATIVES TE RCE. �PROPOSED aziw_ W4-0,0MINATI El E, Y�'-NO PR6jEcr11WM5-.7 t: I AL RNAnVE BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES • No impacts on biological resources are 0 Implerneiitation of this project could Same as proposed project Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project anticipated under the No-Project result in potential impacts to biological ternative, resources at the Park. • Does not impact endangered, Implementation of the proposed threatened,or rare species or their project could result in potentially habitats(including but not limited to significant impacts to riparian habitats plants,fish,insects,animals,and adjacent to project element locations. birds). Improvements planned for non-native • Does not impact locally designated grasslands could result in loss of species(e.g.,heritage trees). foraging habitat for raptors. • Does not impact locally designated 0 Implementation of Measure Biological natural communities(e.g.,oak forest Resources-1 through-5 would reduce coastal habitat,etc.). project and program level impacts on • Does not impact wetlands habitat biological resources below the level of (e.g.,marsh,riparian,and vernal significance. pool). • Does not impact wildlife dispersal or migration corridors. * No mitigation is required. ENERGY AND MINERAL RESOURCES 0 Six active oil wells are located in 0 Six active oil wells are located in Same as proposed project Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project southwestern area of the Park southwestern area of the Park. The • Does not interfere with full economic project is not expected to impact these or recovery of the known natural any other known energy or mineral resources. resourcesin the Park • Consistent with adopted energy Does not interfere with full economic conservation plans. recovery of the known natural • Does not use non-renewable resources resources. in a wasteful or inefficient manner. Consistent with adopted energy. 0 No mitigation measures required. conservation plans. • Does not use non-renewable,resources in a wasteful or inefficient manner. 0 No mitigation measures Etguired- HAZARDS a The No-Project Alternative would likely 0 Development of recreation facilities in Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project Same as proposed project' result in a maintenance of the existing the vicinity of abandoned wells poses a a Increase in impervious surface from 2.7 0 Increase in impervious surface from 2.7 0 Increase in impervious surface from 2.7 level of risk to people and property from potential for hazards to people and acres in proposed project to 10.0 acres. acres in proposed project to 3.7 acres, acres in proposed project to 5.5 acres. abandoned and plugged oil wells, property- Impervious surface increases the potential Impervious surface increases the potential Impervious surface increases the potential transport of hazardous material on Development over methan&rich soils for methane migration. for methane migration. . for methane migration. Golden West Street,and methane has the potential to pose a hazard to As with the proposed project,this 0 As with the proposed project this * As with the proposed project,this migration from underlying landfills. people and property. Alternative requires implementation of Alternative requires implementation of Alternative requires implementation of • Development adjacent to Golden Measures Hazards-1 through-12.An Measures Hazards-I through-12.An measures Hazards-1 through-12.An West Street which is used to transport additional Measure Hazards4 3 is additional Measure Hazards-14 is additional Measure Hazw&l 5 is hazardous materials and development required to reduce risks to people and required to reduce risks to people and required to reduce risks to people and near active oil wells poses a hazard to property to a less than significant level. property to a less than significant level. Property to a less than significant level. people. • Soil excavation within historic oil fields has the potential to expose construction workers to hazards. Development of vacant lots increases. the risk of fires. • Development adjacent to active oil wells exposes people to potential hazards. 0 Implementation of Measures Hazards-1 through-12 is capable of reducing risks to people and property from hazards to a less than significant level. Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Findings and Overriding Conadetattions June 2Z 1999 Page V-14 W.WROJECTS1 1096-W4WINDINGSI 1`096004.S5A TABLE V-3 COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF IMPACTS FOR MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES AND ALTERNATIVES -PROP.051—.W— --Z.N0 P LTERN;kTiVE�i-W A ERNAT NOISE • No impacts on noise anticipated from the 0 Potential noise impacts may result from Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. Same as proposed Project. No-Project Alternative.Ambient noise development of the proposed projecL 6 Location of the adult softball field farther 0 Placement of the roller hockey rinks 0 Placement of the roller hockey rinks levels expected to remain the same. - Short-term noise impacts are expected from the mobile home site will reduce closer to the Ocean view Estates has the closer to the Ocean view Estates has the in association with construction of the operation impacts of the field on the Potential to result in slightly increased potential to result in slightly increased proposed project mobile home site- noise impacts, noise impacts. - Long-term noise impacts are expected s Development of the Aquatic Center has * As with the proposed project, 0 As with the proposed project in association with operation of the potential to expose sensitive receptors to implementation of measures Noise-1 implementation of Measures Noise-1 adult softball field. noise impacts. through-5 will reduce noise impacts through-5 will reduce noise impacts 0 Implementation of Measures Noise-1 9 As with the proposed project, from construction and operWon below from construction and operation below through-5 will reduce noise impacts implementation Of Measures Noise-1 the level of significance. the level of significance. from construction and operation below through-5 will reduce noise impacts the level of significance. from construction and operation below the level of significance. PUBLIC SERVICES • No impacts on public services are • Potential impacts on public services may Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project Same as proposed project- anticipated from the No Project result from development of the proposed Alternative project • No impact on emergency response Emergency medical response,police plans at emergency evacuation plans. protection,and fire protection services • Adequate emergency response will be impacted by the proposed services. project • Southwestern portion of the Park Construction of the Semi-Active serves as training course for Recreation Area and Midden Huntington Beach Unified High ArealUrban Forest/Trailhead elements School District aosscountry squads. have the potential to displace the i • No mitigation measures required. cross-country training course during construction. • Implementation of measures Public Services-1 through-6 would reduce impacts to below the level of sienificange -UTILITIES AND SERVICE SYSTEMS 0 This alternative could potentially result in • This alternative could potentially result in Same as proposed project Same as proposed project Same as proposed project impacts on utilities and service systems. impacts on utilities and service system Impacts to sewer and water sully impacts to sewer and wafer sully Impacts from irrigation would • No impacts to irrigation and potable Impacts to irrigation and potable water would increase. would increase. increase. water supply or water distribution. supply from increased peak hour impacts from irrigation would be impacts from irrigation would be I As with the Proposed project • No impacts to electrical system. demand. lower but still present lower but still present. implementation of measures Utilities-1 • 36-inch corrugated metal pipe Impacts to Park water distribution j 0 As with the proposed project, 0 As with the proposed project, through-9 and measure Water-3 would between Talbert Lake and Sully Miller systems due to peak demand. implementation of Measures Utilities-] implementation of Measures Utilities-1 reduce impacts below the level of Lake currently inadequate. Sports Complex impacts to existing through-9 and measure Water-3 would through-9 and measure Water-3 would significance. • Existing storm drain an Golden West storm drain system,particularly 36- reduce impacts below the level of reduce impacts below the level of Street is inadequate. inch corrugated metal pipe and significance. significance. e Implementation of Measure Utilities 4 Golden West StreeL would reduce impacts from the 364nch Impacts on electrical supply to the corrugated metal pipe below the level of proposed Sports Complex. significance. • Implementation of Measures Utilities-1 through-9 and Measure Water 3 would reduce impacts below the level of significance. Matter Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22,1999 Page V-15 W.IPR0lECTSII096,W41FlNDJNGSI 1096004.SSA TABLE V-3 COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF IMPACTS FOR MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES AND ALTERNATIVES �... - -- .-_- sue. _ - -.-, fa3 . _.c ---- RESUURC`;^ NO.PRO)fCT PROPOSED PRO)ECL LTERNATIV�f f s ALTfRIYATIYE .. -_°�a._ ALTfRNATiY_ A - AESTHETICS • No impact on aesthetics is anticipated • Implementation of the proposed project Same as proposed project Same as proposed project. Same as proposed project. under the No-Project Alternative. has the potential to generate significant • In addition to Measures Aesthetics-1 • No scenic highways or vistas will be impacts on aesthetics. - through-3,Measure Aesthetics4 would impacted. New sources of light could potentially : be required to reduce impacts on - • No demonstrable negative aesthetic impact surrounding land uses in the aesthetics from this alternative on Golden effect will result from this altemative. vicinity of the Sports Complex West Street traffic and the library below • Light or glare is not expected to Placement of new boundary the level of significance. change from existing conditions. fencestwalls has the potential to result - • No mitigation measures are required. in a negative aesthetic impact. • Implementation of Measures Aesthetic-1 through-3 would reduce most impacts on aesthetics below the level of " significance. Impacts on aesthetics - resulting from night lighting of soccer/football fields and softball fields would remain significant during night use - of the soccer/football fields,impacting. the temporary location of the Ocean View Estates Mobile Home Corr lex. - CULTURAL RESOURCES • Existing levels of operations and • Excavations undertaken in underlying Same as proposed projecL Same as proposed project - Same as proposed project maintenance and passive recreation has parent material during construction of the - the potential to adversely effect Low Intensity Recreation,Midden Areal: paleontological resources where Urban ForesUirailhead,and Semi-Active - excavations are made into underlying Recreation Area has the potential to result - - parent material. in significant impacts on paleontological -I - -- - • Existing recreation use levels have the resources,prehistoric cultural resource -- potential to adversely effect five known (CA-0RA-142,CA-0RA-62,CA-ORA- prehistoric cultural resource sites:CA- 1318,CA-0RA-1275,and CA-0RA- ORA-142,CA-0RA-62,CA-ORA-1318, 1317),and potentially important and - CA-0RM1175,and CA-0RA-1317. unique cultural resources. _ • Implementation of Measures Paleontology-1 through-4,Measures - - Archaealogy-I through-7,and Measures " Historical-1 through-3 is expected to " reduce impacts on cultural resources - below the level of significance. RECREATION • The impact on recreation is expected to • The project level elements are not Same as proposed project Same as proposed project. - Same as proposed project be significant under the No-Project expected to result in impacts on - Alternative. recreation or require mitigation. • Demand for neighborhood or regional • Three(3)program-level elements of the . parks or other recreational facilities proposed Master flan(Low-Intensity -will not increase as a result of Recreation Area,Midden Area/Urban - - - implementation of this alternative. ForestrTrailhead,and Semi-Active - • Anticipated future demand for "Recreation Area)may result in temporary - recreational opportunities will not be or permanent disruption of existing met under this alternative. recreation uses. • This alternative would not be • implementation of Measures Recreation-1 consistent with the voter approved through-5 is expected to reduce program - - Measure L for improvements at level impacts on recreation below the Central Park. level of significance. - • Existing recreational facilities will not be affected. • No mitigation measures are required, Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Findings and Overriding Considerations June 22,1999 Page V-16 W:I PROIECT511096-004 tFINDINC511096004.55A 08-02-99 03:39pm From-ALLERGAN - R&D 17142464855 T-084 P.01/02 F-177 Personal Facsimile TO: Ms.Mary Beth Broeren and the HB City Council Care of Connie Brockway FAX (714) 374-1557 FROM: Kathy Kurjan Phone (714) 246-4303 FAX (714) 246-4988 SUBJECT: Comments for Tonight's City Council Meeting Regarding the EIR for the Central Park Master Plan DATE: August 2, 1999 Page 1 of 2 Please call me if there is trouble with the transmission_ Dear Connie: Will you please ensure that the Council receives these comments in consideration of agenda item D-1? Sorry for the short notice. Thank you, f Kathy Kurjan` t ('7 08-02-99 03:39pm From-ALLERGAN - R&D 17142464855 T-084 P.02/02 F-177 August 2, 1999 Ms. Mary Beth Broeren,Senior Planner 2000 Main Street,3`a Floor P.O.Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Dear Ms. Broeren: Thank you for the opportunity to review the Final Master Environmental Impact Report for"Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park,City of Huntington Beach, California, 'Volume 111". And thank you for presenting my comments to the Planning Commission prior to their vote last month. I understand that they did discuss many of the points I raised,but one point still concerns me so I will continue to raise it. I am concerned about the safety of the residents located on the Northeast corner of Goldenwest and Slater. Transportation and Circulation Mitigation Measure#1 (page 5-10) will increase traffic cycle times which will cause automobiles heading westbound to block ingress and egress to this tract. It is a safety issue because emergency vehicles will not have timely access into or out of the tract during moderate traffic times. - The traffic assessment for this street was performed prior to the opening of the Home Depot store,and was not completed during peak summer traffic times. The traffic survey clearly states, in Appendix F,that the assessment was completed in November 1997. Nome Depot began operations in second quarter 1998, and we have been experiencing increased traffic on Slater between Gothard and Goldenwest ever since. The E11Z states that the only intersection that will degrade to a LOS E condition(the worst)is the Goldenwest and Slater intersection due to the park plan. The proposed mitigation is to"optimize" (increase)the traffic light cycle time along Goldenwest. Currently,even at moderate traffic times,the westbound traffic backs up on Slater at Goldenwest and blocks Duello Street. At peak traffic times, automobiles block Lucero Street as well. When the mitigation measure is implemented,the increased cycle time at Goldenwest will surely cause both streets to be blocked with moderate traffic. I feel the safety of the neighborhood is jeopardized if emergency vehicles cannot access Slater from either Duello or Lucero,the only two openings for this tract. Please.add wording to Mitigation Measure#1 so that the westbound side of Slater receives the street markings"KEEP CLEAR"at both entrances and exits to require motorists not to block these openings when waiting at the lengthened cycle at the traffic signal. Thank you for the opportunity to comment. Sincerely, c C-1 - - R 7j 'f Kathy Kurjan c; w cc. City Council Members , MASTER ENVIRONMENTAL IMPA CT REPOR T NO. 99-1 for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Ell Proposal • MEfR.N-o-9—l-represents^an anal s� potential environmental impacts associated with the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park. • The Master Plan includes nine elements on 157.5 acres (136 of which are currently undeveloped). • Master Plan of Recreation Uses was approved by the City Council on December 15, 1997. i r Proposal (cont 'd.) • The MEIR analyzes each element of the Master Plan at either a project or program level of detail. • Project level elements are well defined and the City anticipates implementation to occur within the next five years. • Program level elements are longer-term. Proposal (cont 'd) • The Master Plan Elements are: • Project Level • Sports Complex----._ • Consolidated Camping Area ="m • Outdoor Music Area • Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard • Program Level • Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead • Sully Miller Lake Group Facility • Low Intensity Recreation Area • Semi-Active Recreation Area • Police/Civilian Gun Range 2 Analysis • The MEIR concludes there will be NO IMPACT to: • Land Use and Planning • Population and Housing • Energy and Mineral Resources Analysis (cont 'd.) • The following impacts can be mitigated to a level of insignificance with mitigation measures: - • Geological Issues • Water • Transportation/Circulation • Biological Resources • Hazards • Noise • Public Services • Utilities and Service Systems • Cultural Resources • Recreation 3 I \ Analysis (cont 'd-) • There are two unavoidable significantl� .= impacts in association with the Sports Complex: • Aesthetics (Night Lighting) • Air Quality (Temporary) • Various mitigation measures are recommended to reduce these potential impacts. Analysis (cont 'd.) • Because all impacts cannot be mitigated to a level of insignificance, a Statement of Overriding Considerations must be adopted. • The City Council may take this action if environmental and social benefits of the Master Plan outweigh the adverse impacts to aesthetics and air quality. 4 Analysis (contd.) • Comments on the Draft MEIR were received from 15 parties. • Pursuant to CEQA, Staff responded to all comments received on the Draft. • Final MEIR includes revised text sections and modified mitigation measures as a result of the comments. s cn 771 Analysis (cont 'd.) a • The Planning Commission voted to'- ' recommend certification of the MEIR and adoption of the mitigation monitoring program on July 13th, and requested staff to: • Apprise the Environmental Board of activities related to the project. • Explore the issue of screening the Maintenance Yard. 5 .r. Recommendation • Staff recommends the City Council certify Master Environmental Impact Report No. 99-1 as adequate and complete in accordance with CEQA requirements with a Statement of Overriding Considerations by adoption of Resolution No. 99-53 and the Mitigation Monitoring Program because: Recommendation (cont 'd.) • The Master Plan is consistent with the goals, objectives and policies of the General Plan. • The proposed mitigation measures reduce most potential impacts to a level of insignificance. • The Master Plan is the environmentally superior alternative. • The environmental and social benefits of the project outweigh and override the unavoidable adverse effects of the project. 6 End of Presentation NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEAC$ NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that on Monday, August 2, 1999, at 7:00 PM in the City Council Chambers, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, the City Council will hold a public hearing on the following item: ❑ MASTER ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT NO. 99-1 (MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES FOR CENTRAL PARK) Applicant: City of Huntington Beach, Community Services Department Request: Certification of an environmental impact report for the master plan of 157.5 acres in Huntington Central Park Location: Between Edwards on the west, Gothard Street on the east, Slater Avenue on the North and Ellis Avenue on the South Planner Assigned: Mary Beth Broeren NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the above item is covered by Environmental Impact Report No. 99-1. ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Planning Department, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. A copy of the staff report will be available to interested parties at City Hall or the Main City Library (7111 Talbert Avenue) after July 29, 1998. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If you challenge the City Council's action in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at, or prior to, the public hearing. If there are any further questions please call the Planning Department at 536-5271 and refer to the above item. Direct your written communications to the City Clerk. Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street, 2nd Floor Huntington Beach, California 92648 (714) 536-5227 (G:\LEGALS\COLNCIL\99\99cc802.doc) Connie Brockway, City Clerk 9 c o ti• ``s �,y w G� ,t City of Huntington Beach #elf, Office of the City Clerk ETU J P.O. Box 190 To . y . 1 ?J Huntington Beach, CA 92648 3 H MET`a"6IM3 .k (\ :Occupant 7051�ELlis-Ave:;°-#15 UV Huntington Beach, CA 92647 IN6rp�, i CURR7-77-.- --926461002 :'1N` ' • .. - RETURN='TO"=' N Rz'._=>_­;°-::� . •. -,- - - j FO W RD LE R`uc�sK'T� LEGA NOTICE: PUBLI( FARffi NIDT KN0'';'k1 S2L6as-sz4a. . I2 111,1111111111119111111111:1111oilo1111r11,1,�111„111�1,11I,IJ - __ t Connie Brockway, City Clerk =` o City of Huntington Beach Office of- the City Clerk >. c.?_ 1;..:.���c�� s'rs r �F.r�F+...�9i; a_�:A .. . P.O. Box 190 .1'�L2� Huntington Beach, CA 92648 C/ _VL HMETER 51,& 53 A ETU -ccupant To 7051 Ellis Ave.,-#39 V iENaFR° Huntington Beach, CA 92647 IN6rpy 4 3 V �07 _ *s -•CURR7.77 -426481'002 AN 23' /27/A9 Z ?; RETURNFORWARD ORDER OW FILL- .. t _ �Q: TUNABLE- TO FORWARD - �' 0 -SENUF:R GFTIIGN TA FAFNnFG �7 d� ` pu1rTY .P LEGAL:NOTICE PUBLIC:HEA I T;E1 FT L fp \ .muss - ��i 7►=i M1a� ! :jj qq J , _.,_ 1 s }` T -_; -1-d-`-•:_ .-'-111.111i11�1l111111„11111,-,tt11111�� � 1111l111111 11111111111 � 4 f CITY of HUNTINGTON BEACH • P.O. Box 190 California 92648 /60y 7/ ALICES BREAKFAST IN THE PARK � P 0 BOX 111 HUNTINGTON BEACH CALIFORNLA 92648 fill III IIIIIIII ULM- MUM 3118nd 301I0N IV931 8t,9Z6 VZ) q:)L;)g U012UPUnH DA!J(j Ai;)IADV'j ZZ99 uospisno aoy[V 31jud;)ql ul Isepiewa s,3311V 8V9Z6 VO 'peeg uoj6uijunH 06 L X08 'Od MJ810 40 814110 931,90 99 uolBui unH 10 40 )P810 fi410 'ALAq30J8 e1UU00 Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 ------ Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Ocean Vie ny/Colt Mike 16787 ch Blvd. ING gton Beach,CA 92647 Paz d cliverabie, Commercial Mail Receivin Agency, R zation to T O S ail f r his Addresspp-- ATI LE AL NOTICE- PUBLIC HEARING ,11 0r 1*111 111 011MMIIIIIIII 1111111 IJI 1111111111M III 11111,1111111111 Illldd:.: Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk ? q1 P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 California Youth Hockey Assoc Mike Muckenthaler, 1608 fEllcrest Circle- T, �NTINGTp Huntington Beach, CA 92648 10 CO RETURN RETURN To TO SE SENDER N 0 F R 1,�TMJI�T LEG -E UBLIC HEA NG -,,�,,UBLIC HEA Connie Brockway, City Clerk q } City of Huntington Beach Office o the f City Clerk P.O. Box 190 ' Huntington Beach, CA 92648 ercial „Undeliverable, Comm Agency' .�•� -• :-: : ,.::: :;.-- : ,�=: Receiving t;on to N Aothoriza ' AddreSs�i'ntington Beach Surf City Em Mail for This Mike Gonya Receive 16787 Beach 638 Huntin each,CA 92647 INGTpp, C.2 - y EIURN ER U cp I fi:,j0t� GAL NOTI - PUBLIC H 1 Q ,V,1SICI 1;l;,iIIIUI,l,I III Hill 1111111111111It 1Af;1 Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 � 1IVE DAD[E Huntington Beach, CA 92648 "` 10 S gpDDE UNABLE x� ,A_ 159-393-29 IN6TO,y� F UGO J.ENENBACH �O ��w►on4r �. O BOX 152 POCATE 0 ID 83201 Ca 00 9 — �O NTI ca LEGAL NOTICE- PUBLIC HEARING - - 8��'�cs4 fi4�ZD 0 Office of the City Clerk fee CITY of HUNTINGTON BEACH P.O. Box 190 California 92648 165-031-39 KENNETH E.CRUMLEY 17702 EL NOPAL LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6681 TURN IRETURI'7- TO SENDER _-:,f FWDG PRDEP ;-Y0'FFv-7! C,- .H' 40. 111111111111 Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk - P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 _ Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave.,#19 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 INGTpy�``9 - CURR777 926481002 IN 23 07/27/99 RETURN:-TO SENDER ms�sa+r�a.rrxl RETURN NO FORWARD Si`•iDER ON FIL RETURF� �•_; OQT- C UNA6LE T� FORWARD r r��rr 7.1 ff+ �.►9 \{� i '-�1^r RFTIIRN TO SENDER i n =1(L J' �i l:�_i;•ems: .__�_,'f f: .. � LEGAL NOTld�, �lJ�L1C HEARING Connie Brockway,City Clerk ;;.: ;;• ---v, --City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk JL P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92640T` z � 111-381-35 t tINGtpr i� ��+M+q� B�f►' PLC 3991 MACARTHUR BL#22 v NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-3009 s P,E TURN _. — IRE T URN. �- LEGAL NOM-5.-`PUBLIC HEAR NG 3t��i•, rv�a �-��� iltlt��Illltlltttlttllt�ltll,����tIII�IItIItIIIII��IIt�t�Il�ll Connie Brockway, City Clerk ` City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave.,#25 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 I NGTpy� CURR777 926401002 IN 23 07/27/99 --` - RFTIIRN 5ENDER �' a c s.- RETURNo S{'m ER ONE FILE ► 9 -w o _ _ _ ,U ABLE T FORWARD i _ _ ���,_f��Z_/f0f.* �(,• rt - l - >. - , �!.:w�T, rn .rrY CCn1I'1F� - 19 TY w LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Connie Brockway, City Clerk -.- ., x City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 159-063-14 ING WILLIAM RAYMOND&VICKIE L..DOUGLASS O�c `y�ofr044�f BF 18441 CARNABY LN HUNTING ON BEACH CA 92648-1409 C-a - y _ RETURN C oe TO SEtJDER A i c LE AL NOTICE- PUBLIC HEAR G Connie Brockway, City Clerk _ City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 r 9 Occupant 77 7051 Ellis Ave.,#23 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 I N6Tpy�F CURR777 926481002 IN �23t 07/27/99 +c. RETURN TO 5ENnEIR QETL'RN �� "" NO FORWARD OR JjKTUhNFIwr7v-_1 9y Q C/'� - UNABLE TO € RWAA CF ���L uo�•►4 `��O k_ C f'_i' _t RETURN TO 5 ` ` pNDER $ o F UNTY Q► - - - LEGALNOT-ICE- PUBLIC� IR�I �4 8 ' " -� 111111 flog 1111111111 I'lll"1-I1111�ff�11.11�111'f 11/'.-..s Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beachz ' Office of the City Clerk � J t- P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 _' :�; ✓-� _ / 9 ` 159-063-07 I � WIINGTp�, SHAR, N OTTO-BATES 8527 EDGEBROOK DR GARDEN GROVE CA 928 1910 V y GNIC�c'/ Y�O'fY1V1.7 1IM ee V//c'O/`YY __,>.. - - r--z.�•.•.:_ -�>.., RETURN TO SENDER 911 'RETURN NO FORWARD ORDER ON FILE REUNABLE TO FORWAR TO SENDER ! _—,. RETURN TO SENDERD ITO SE D l-it` IfH•CP`�� ATTEMPTED 1_0 NTv LEGAL NOTICE- PUBLICS _�.._ i 1,l„i;►,IIIi„I,,,111,1,1i11„l,il,ii,lllll'ri WN Connie Brockway,City Clerk n '-�• City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O.Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 \ \1 .,._. � ��' tit 4... ._�? . . . . . •+ INs 111-391-02 ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P r y 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 .:r•.rn�c:Zvi'-'-=�.--- ----t..i-:-;.mr�r�•..-:, s RETURN RETUR ;_.__ N TO SENDER — TO SENDS — tr PUBLIC ERRING }j )) 11 i}} Ili {Ij ) I'i {{ }} ,{{ )) FF f ! �:-�,::..-. _ sg t'.+'.+�•�1 �. .� {{F1i1411i11I{i115fF1t`.ii?{{.iii!{�t�li4.l�SiSli� ��FifiFiit� Connie Brockway, City Clerk I City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 •'`•:�• y_,•:sr �-.;�,__ •ter 165-203-37 INGtpyd JOHN M.CHISOLM 17281 LEE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6208 li'�• it loos ,L GAL;NOTlm-Pi�B� I R��` - k +7 III IIIIItill! .,onnie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach t Office of the City Clerk L P.O. Box 190 _ Huntington Beach, CA 92648 -r-� 159-072-04 _ �NTINGjO ROBERT V.REIDER 6332 NEWBURY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6567 NTY" LEGAL NOTICE- FO l H RIUG ` . 3tIQ1 '-1 Ike 1� a -; IIIlS ii 11{1111111i1S1111111�1i111U1�'il il'�if lllllllllllil li l� J -� Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 _ Huntington Beach, CA 92648 de Michael 1 mbrose Ln. Hton Beach,CY.•A.92648 NTINGT 1 aQ`�����e•roe,�fOy4A LEGAL NOTICE—RQBAcWFARWQ46 • Office of the City Clerk ';a�V' '�''r'�` a . •• . JJ CITY of HUNTINGTON BEACH P.O. Box 190 California 92648 __' -_.-ter► 3 a ._ ;-. �^/- 165-075-06' �Bi_F_ WILLIAM V.KOTLENSKY 5931 BUCHANAN AV SAN BERNARDINO CA 92404-3410 Pu s Li C HEA•U N& p ro'r ': 4w"_-: I•tl�tt�1t111�t i I I fit(,1 I Ii I I I I l Iiii I I f I III II IIIIIfi� Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 = -;•� .--- n_ ;,�=,ram_r ��.•. 165-392-38 KENNETH J.&DOROTHY J.BOURGUIGNON TIN6 17712 GOTHARD ST O� P044 � HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6253 LEGAL NOTICE- PUBLICS r�, IItltlttltltllt till till till Itill {I{Ill{lllf{{1fIS1111{I{Ill{lit{�{11{{111{Ilfl{ �- 1 Office of the City Clerk CITY of HUNTINGTON BEACH V� ---------- ----- HO P.O. Box 190 California.92648 165-033-08 GENCAGA &LILIANA ALIYAZICIOGLU 6921 VIA CARONA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6649 ;i IP Heik/W- • Office of the City Clerk CITY of HUNTINGTON BEACH P.O. Box 190 California 92648 'i PAF 165-391-40 ROBERT A.CONTORELLI 17712 METZLER LN - HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6245 VIF3L I.CL �'HGAPEl NQ ,a2.60,-, • Office of the City Clerk CITY of HUNTINGTON BEACH - P.O. Box 190 California 92648 165-354-06 GEORGE A.CASTELLI 6681 SORIA CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6644 CAST681 926474029 1698 20 07/2b/99 FORWARD TIME EXP RTN TO SEND CASTELLI 'GEORGE A PO BOX 3505 MESQUITE NV 89024-3505 f W3t-ic. HC- nklNGr • Office of the City Clerk -� CITY of HUNTINGTON BEACH " P.O. Box 190 California 92648 t 165-071-28 RALPH LABELSON 16312 SPARTAN CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-2526 LABE312 926494028 1795 18 07J24199 FORWARD TIME EXP RTN TO SEND LABELSON 17372 ROB ROY CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5639 v � ( j jj !tf i f tPuslz I�, Ml! yap qe. '3rGf�4� �i\��0 ii!�!!111! Ilillil'.! i!1! lM!11111 lidli!!�!tidli!!!!1!il Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Af& 14 • vp 'A 92648 �4 Huntington Beach, C C 4r)" P'0/1 V & r4ft �1'6 1 59-352-24 ING EDWARDS-LINDBORG-DAH 30110 CROWN VALLEY PY#PY LAGUNA NIGUEL CA 92677-2043 cft3 �puN ca ca TY LEGAL NOTICE - PUBI-Iq FARffi t-b% 77 Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648�n������4� + _.. . f ,�— RQU �L./ / 159-201-21 QgAA��O. LEONARD 0.LINDBORG ING 30110 CROWN VALLEY PY#PY MAP A -.,. i LAGUNA NIGUEL CA 92677-2043 QZ F�ppNTY LEGAL NOTICE- PUBLIC HEARING ''11617 c4tdVa 4ltlttttl[�s��sslttt�lett�tslt��lttttlttltt�ltltttt�ststttltti Connie Brockway,City Clerk r City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk ; P.O. Box 190 - Huntington Beach.CA 92648 � 'f w`•., of '10 1tic Tp 11a152-2 a �.�"~'�•� !�',' FRANCES LORE ENSIGN - y 416 W LAS PALMAS DR ,t! _ FULLERTON CA 92835-1536 �aiNTr �r' LEGAL NOTICE- PUBLIC HEARING AUTO 92986 Now Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk - P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92646 159-352-25 .r:� �. Fl, MEOWNERS AS SN COUNTRY _ Nt .: �jy 1,,R 1720 COAST XIN6 HwY �Q�_��ca►u�+rfo BF9� '! � �,_ SUNSET B 0742 V y , F�NNNTY �P`` LEG (,,(�f,OTICE- PUBLIC HEAL-E 11T{��l z•Y i -PU s C H 41 Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk .. f P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach CA 92648 INGTpy Art Orta 66 o BF 17351 Lee Cir. y -=_ 9y Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Z 9,yC �; o �Q �cppNTY cP`�� LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING • Office of the City�Clerk J CITY_ of HUNTINGTON BEACH P.O. Box 190 California 92648 zd 7�a Foersf Cleo /7 fan Cot C'�� : c�a.C.-Itl J .Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach c*G T c ti Offioe of the City Clerk �`/ W f" Q ti --� P.O.Box 190 lU121 9 -'� Hunti ° . ngton Beach,CA 92648 z a� � H METER 555:L71 ely TROY M.MCCLEERY " FLEGAL-.NOTI Ez TV 4,PAICd WNW--, { xty.-k�r 43Y'¢+.t`+F". x {, rx .•df3 ri R '� �, 't h'3 * , 47, N E v 0JU162L-9- JU1122'�9-P.O. Box 190 -I- I �' 1 :.Huntington Beach, CA 92645H METER 555: Ocean View Little League Bob-Becnazd;President PO-Box 351 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 J 1 IN6Tpp, 9 d for All cppNTY LEGAL NOTICE PUBLIC HEARING fi 9 41Mn lx x - `- .•� 1 r �r�= ice' <- v,; -r -a 3,.ai -�- wry 't„-. .�,�� -_. ��5 - � Pam; ��- �` �� ����� . � �� u� r,�� � � .� -u , �. ,� wt � ��� • � Office of the City Clerk �� �f-_ •._._ - � CITY of HUNTINGTON BEACH P.O. Box 190 California 92648 n G �D D licGl�CC9i �o�.�Sr�u� vCity of Huntington Beach f �' Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Katerina's �pp1INGTp�, 300 &&/Fie afiSr llay to - co: ` -.�.�. -.d".:'- S - --..'-""+•eT:t°1lVl'Jiv)x^.la::f.'-PCF��v:'..4 >_ LEGAL N01ICE- Ply L C HE RII G G -� cv-ca IItl,tttltltlltttlttllttltlltttt,tlllt1tll►ltltlttlltttttilll �/�0 Office of the City Clerk T.N CITY of HUNTINGTON BEACH •COO California 92648 P.O. Box 190 I'E R 165-411-06 ERNANI &MARIA VIRGINIA DORR 17442 APEX CIRCLE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5728 RETURN To RETURN RETURN": TO SENDER TO SENOERF,----T AT ATTEMPTED -fill ,,F� Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach r Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 r r 165-203-05 George,Butlerworth 7072 Betty Dr. Huntington Beach,CA.92647 o��pNIN6Tpy�F9 ,.� RETURN rn cc►}nc�' 11 LIMA NOTICE- PUBLIC HEARING Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 '� = 165-093-11:'= __:• }_}- __ 's Hartstein,Steven 4240 Harbor Blv .B-307 Oxnard,CA. 9 35 i ING `ChC� �� �i y; �►9 �� t�E i i-i�'1, i /�~--`�.�.� --'s I :� CJ N D f..`i . ... ��auNrr �a` B LGA LI Q �+ t' �ai��� tt+t►++►t{I►Il+++l►+tt►}till}►+}+{t11+11►11+►►1+l+ill►+►►+I{tl Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 1165-344-05 65-344-05 CHARLES C UMMETT 9 C 17792 RANZALN ING U T C C HU NGTON rBEACH CA 92647-6616 Ca RETURN RE:I'UR yC q I; N . TO SENDER-t�lj TO HN0ERc<,,-- : uHTr jA-T M T LEGAL NOTICE- k? Connie Brockway, City Clerk Q P 9 9 City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 165-345-1 3 C TH D ONATO 17 I QUINTANA N UNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6634 ING C.3 RPTURN RE TO SENfi- T 01 ENDER R 1 Eli I _ T IPTED D N LEGAL NOTICE - PUBL�r TI , I 'ml ' 67 -4, rs Connie Brockway, City Clerk �9 _ City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 165-211-02 �VNTING 6L lfoSZyLVIAN VITAL F 7161 BETTY DR -5450 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 926547 RIN RETURN IRETU' TQ S! TO SE- C' D LEGAL NOTICE -,P.UKI�tRW '47 Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 1-17 165-203-43 ...j Wixom,Julie 17342 Lee Cir. ING Huntington Beach,CA.92647 TO SENDER �Tn c c: j n oli RETURN RETURN LEGf L Connie Brockway, City Clerk �- /._, ;+ City of Huntington Beach . . __ • • ` Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 `+ L N' (/ and ay 1 L iento Dr. Hunting n Beach,CA.92647 ��pNtIN660 Tpy C-, . RETURN FRETURN � 9it is, �oQ Ti) SE=N0ER�� �T0 SENDIE` �OpNTY ca` I IT � - p,U_ Connie Brockway, City Clerk ` City of Huntington Beach ` Q _ ' Office of the City Clerk � -� ~•"• -'- _ ,.., _ P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 165-202-05 �pgTINGP DONALD BROGGER 4A 7031 BETTY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA92647-5448 v co �pUNTY �a` LEGAL NOT - t�R �ta-r •=s�J`IIt i Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 L 165-215-07 Mezher, Samir 7211 Slater Ave. Huntington Beach,CA.92647 ING ci T U RN RETURN YX is%% . 0 SENDER CpUNT1Ga 'r rl I-f-,I n r-n�� U*W47 Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 V'A 159-412-01 DWAYNE &CRYSTAL FUHRMAN /77.9(p SAmPSorJ Ln, PING JBe,,o,.C4.9z&14S RET-UR;l RETURt ITO SENDER' ,TO SENDER I - I D NTI V' L Z ! LEGAL NOTICE- P� W.0 1,6ti III I till till 11111 ill • Office of the City Clerk F- CITY of HUNTINGTON BEACH 7if P.O. Box 190------------- California 9264880TD&,P i -A5-411-15 CARLOS A.&ZULMA C.CELLA 5 A�r F 1541 9 � RUTO 92686 Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 165-071-17 ZSIGMOND FRIGYES 17392 ROB ROY CIR I,NGTQ,yd HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5639 CP iRETURIN 'ETURN 1-14DE T1 P,D LEGAL NOTICE - PZI3 H 111 111 1 11 11111 till 11"11111 A il I 1 11*1 1%1 d I ®r R ^;P.T F r -r r7"!i. R! . Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 qpdel'Oerable, commercial Mail AgencY, 9-eceIvIng. 40.01110 EWntington Beach Surf City No PLaklorl_ pdd18ss I y m ur il for Mike Gonya 8 Beach 38 Receive 16787 Beach Huntin each,CA 92647 ING NO 0'4 r C2 RETURN ER TO , ::yj S N D rE R E n - PUBLIC Connie Brockway, City Clerk '9 City of Huntington Beach F:i Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 165-392-62 JELE &STJEPAN HEFRCEG ING 846-1 GRACE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-3125 HrZRC461** 926464017 1498 14 07/27/99 ca FORWARD TIME EXP RTN TO SEND HERCEG 'KATARINA JELE 19562 MAYFIELD CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-6618 LEGAL NOTICE- PUBLICS WRW4 6 RETURN TO .SENDER Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 1 Office of the City Clerk P.O.Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 r` - 111-401-09 'iINS TQ ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P yy �� 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 RE . . F TUR�SENDCR�_- a�• z ctJDERt Nt� :T AiTNOTICE- UBLIC HEARING a.ut Sl:� {{eissssls{s{{sssiss{fssis{{ssssst{i{s�st{{sss{:{ss{{sssss{s{{ Connie Brockway,City Clerk .` City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk q` x P.O.Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 l l t r 111-401-09 ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P jINsrO+, LIP 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR �pstwr���� B�► NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 RETURN --- E'. TO SENDER I ENZEGAL NO ICE- PUBLIC HEARING R DDRESS 3cF. �, _ �,�,Ta '����4 ���13U If,{:MLI:f1:::J::II::f:f1::,:::IIIIIIJIM IA11s:s:J:I1 CITY COUNCIL/REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY PUBLIC HEARING REQUEST SUBJECT: — Ve 1� Use s a-lr DEPARTMENT: MEETING DATE: CONTACT: " -}o..r, �Ic h PHONE: SSS� N/A YES NO Is the notice attached? ( ) ( ) Do the Heading and Closing of Notice reflect City Council(and/or Redevelopment Agency)hearing? ( ) 44 ( ) Are the date,day and time of the public hearing correct? ( ) ( ) If an appeal, is the appellant's name included in the notice? If Coastal Development Permit,does the notice include appeal language? ( ) ¢Q ( ) Is there an Environmental Status to be approved by Council? ( ) ( ) Is a map attached for publication? ( ) ( ) Is a larger ad required? Size ( ) ( ) Is the verification statement attached indicating the source and accuracy of the, mailing list? (s �r ► p ka. n l Xr cam„� c.,�ec�s aba Lws� Are the applicant's name and address part of the mailing labels? QQ ( ) ( ) Are the appellant's name and address part of the mailing labels? If Coastal Development Permit, is the Coastal Commission part of the mailing labels? If Coastal Development Permit,are the Resident labels attached? ( ) ( ) Is the33343 report attached? (Economic Development Dept. items only) Please complete the following: 1. Minimum days from publication to hearing date 1 2. Number of times to be published 1 3. Number of days between publications_ r 110-151-01 110-151-02 110-151-03 CITY OF HUNT GTON BEACH CITY HUNT TON BEACH CITY OF HUN TON BEACH PO BOX 19 PO BDX 1 PO BO HUNT TON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNT] TON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HU NGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 1 110-151-0 110-151-05 110/.HERZOG CI F HUNTINGTON BEACH RUSSEL F.HERZOG RUS 2 0 MAIN ST 431 SWISHING WELL LN 431 WELL LN UNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 ANAHEIM CA 92807-3541 ANA07-3541 110-151-07 110-151-08 110-151-09 CIT/HTINGTON BEACH CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF NTINGTON BEACH 200 PO B, 190 POB190HUNEACH CA 92648-2702 HU INGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-1 -10 110-151-11 110-151-12 GARY B.T AN GARY B. RMAN CITY O HUNTINGTON BEACH 5112 BRIARHIL OR 5112 BRI RHILL DR PO B X 190 YORBA LINDA C 2886-3700 YORBA INDA CA 92886-3700 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-151-13 110-151-14 110-151-1 CITY OF NTINGTON BEACH CITY OF NTINGTON BEACH CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH PO BOX 90 PO BOX 90 2000 M IN ST HUNTIN TON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTIN TON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-1 -16 110-151-17 110-152-01 CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH PACIFIC AMER OIL CO CORP J. MAAG 2000 MAI ST 30110 CROWN VALLEY PY#PY 25955 VIA DEL REY HUNTINGT N BEACH CA 92648-2702 LAGUNA NIGUEL CA 92677-2043 SAN JUAN CAPISTRANO CA 92675-4460 110-1 2-02 110- 52-03 110-1 -04 CITY 0 HUNTINGTON BEACH YEVONN LUO YEVO E LUO PO BO 190 18102 BRO HURST ST#M181 18102 OOKHURST ST#M181 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 FOUNTAIN V LEY CA 92708-6737 FOUNTAI VALLEY CA 92708-6737 110-152 5 110-1 -06 110-152-07 YEVONNE L 0 CITY 0 UNTINGTON BEACH LEONA HARLIN 18102 BROOK URST ST#M181 2000 MAI ST PO BOX 5255 FOUNTAIN VAL EY CA 92708-6737 HUNTING N BEACH CA 92648-2702 CHULA VISTA CA 91912-5255 110-152-08 110-152-09 110- 52-10 RICHARD W.MEYER HSI HSIANG&CHEN HSIU LEE CITY 0 UNTINGTON BEACH PO BOX 880 9782 OLYMPIC DR PO BOX 1 MONTICELLO UT 84535-0880 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-4867 HUNTINGT BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-152-1 110-1 -12 11 152-13 CITY OF H NTINGTON BEACH CITY F HUNTINGTON BEACH Cl OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN T PO B 190 PO OX 190 HUNTINGT BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTI GTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HU TINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 r"> 110-152-14 110-15 -15 110- 52-16 MARGARET BAILEY CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH CITY F HUNTINGTON BEACH 4060 CHAPMAN PL PO BOX 1 PO 8 190 RIVERSIDE CA 92506-1139 HUNTINGT BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTI TON BEACH CA 92648-0190 11 152-17 110-1 2-18 110-1 V-19 CITY F HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF NTINGTON BEACH 2000 IN ST FL 2 PO BOX 1 0 2000 MAIN T HUNTIN TON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGT BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTO BEACH CA 92648-2702 110- 2-20 11 152-21 110-152-23 MARGAR T BAILEY CITY F HUNTINGTON BEACH FRANCES LORENE ENSIGN 4060 CHA AN PL PO BO 190 416 W LAS PALMAS DR RIVERSIDE A 92506-1139 HUNTIN ON BEACH CA 92648-0190 FULLERTON CA 92835-1536 110-15 01 110-1 -02 110- 3-03 CITY OF NTINGTON BEACH CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH CITY O HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN T PO BOX 1 0 2000 MA ST HUNTINGTO BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGT BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-153-04 110-153-05 110- 3-06 LEWIE P.DERIGO MC KENZIE MARVEL B EST OF CITY O HUNTINGTON BEACH 807 MAIN ST 1709 DRY CREEK RD 2000 MA ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-3416 COOKEVILLE TN 38501-9324 HUNTING ON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110- 53-07 110-15 08 110- 3-09 CITY O HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF NTINGTON BEACH CITY O HUNTINGTON BEACH PO BOX 0 PO BOX 19 PO BOX 0 HUNTING N BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTO BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTING N BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-1 3-10 110-1 -11 110-153 12 CITY O HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY I HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH 2000 M IN ST PO BO190 2000 MAI ST HUNTIN TON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTI GTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTING ON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-153- 3 110-15 -14 110-153-1 CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH CITY O HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF H NTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAR ST 2000 M IN ST 2000 MAIN T HUNTING ON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTI GTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTING N BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-153-1 110-15 -17 110-153-1 CITY OF H NTINGTON BEACH CITY O HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN ST PO BO 190 PO BOX 0 HUNTING ON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTI GTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTIN TON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-153-19 110-1 3-20 110-15 21 CITY OF HU TINGTON BEACH CITY F HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY O HUNTINGTON BEACH PO BOX 190 PO BOX 190 2000 M IN ST HUNTINGTO BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNI INGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTI I GTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 r 110-160- 1 110-16 -02 110-16 -03 PACIFIC AMER L CO CORP CITY O HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY O HUNTINGTON BEACH 30110 CROWN VA PY#PY PO BOX 90 PO BOX 90 LAGUNA NIGUEL CA 77-2043 HUNTIN TON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTIN TON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-16'1-01 110-161- 110-161- CITY O HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF H NTINGTON BEACH CITY OF H NTINGTON BEACH 2000 MA N ST 2000 MAIN T PO BOX 1 HUNTIN TON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGT N BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGT N BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-161- 4 110-161-05 110-161-06 CITY OF NTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HU TINGTON BEACH CITY OF H NTINGTON BEACH PO BOX 190 2000 MAIN PO BOX 19 HUNTINGT TI N BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNNGT BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGT N BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-161-07 110-161-08 110-161-09 CITY OF H NTINGTON BEACH CITY OF H TINGTON BEACH CITY OF H TINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN I T PO BOX 19 2000 MAIN T HUNTINGTC N BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGT N BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGT N BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-161-10 110-161-1 110-161-1 CITY OF H NTINGTON BEACH CITY OF H NTINGTON BEACH CITY OF H NTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN T 2000 MAI ST 2000 MAI ST HUNTINGT N BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTING ON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTING ON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-161-1 110-161-1 110-161- 5 CITY OF H NTINGTON BEACH CITY OF H NTINGTON BEACH CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAI ST 2000 MAIN ST PO BOX 90 HUNTING ION BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTING ON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTIN TON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-161-1 110-161- 7 110-161 18 CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY 0 HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAI ST PO BOX 90 PO BO 190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTIN TON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNT! GTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-161- 9 110-161- 0 110-1 1-21 CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF LINITINGTON BEACH CITY F HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAI ST 2000 MAIN ST 2000 AIN ST HUNTIN ON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNT NGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 1 110-161- 2 110-161-13 110-1 1-24 CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY F HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAI ST PO BOX(�90 PO B X 190 HUNTING ON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTIN TON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-1624 110-162i 2 110-162-03 CITY OF INTINGTON BEACH CITY OFtIHUNTINGTON BEACH JOHN SCOTT MILLER 2000 MAIN�ST PO BOX goPO BOX 14 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 BONDURANT WY 82922-0014 110-162 4 110-162-05 110-1 2-06 JOHN ;CO MILLER DAVE R.PACK DAVE .PACK PO BOX 14 9882 VERDE LOMAS Cl 9882 RDE LOMAS CI BONDURANT 82922-0014 VILLA PARK CA 92861-3126 VILLA ARK CA 92861-3126 n 11 -162-07 1 -162-08 110 162-09 CI F HUNTINGTON BEACH CI F HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY F HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 IN ST 2000 IN ST PO BO 90 HUNTIN • ON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTIN ON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTIN ON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-162- 0 110-162-11 110-162-12 CITY OF H NTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUN NGTON BEACH CITY OF HUN NGTON BEACH 2000 MAINS PO BOX 190 2000 MAIN ST HUNTINGTO EACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON B CH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON B CH CA 92648-2702 110-162-13 110-16 14 110-162 15 CITY F HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH 2000 IN ST 2000 MAI ST 2000 MAI ST HUNTI GTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTIN ON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTIN TON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-162- 6 110-162-1 110-162-1 CITY OF NTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HU TINGTON BEACH CITY OF H TINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN T 2000 MAINS 2000 MAIN S HUNTINGTO BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON EACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGT BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-162-1 110-1 2-20 110-1 2-21 HSI HSIANG& HEN H.LEE CITY HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY O HUNTINGTON BEACH 9782 OLYMPIC 2000 M IN ST PO BOX 90 HUNTINGTON B H CA 92646-4867 HUNTI TON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTIN ON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-1 2-22 110 162-23 110- 62-24 CITY F HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY F HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 IV AIN ST PO B X 190 PO B 190 HUNTI GTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNT GTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTI GTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-16 -01 110-16 2 110-1 3-03 CITY 0 HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH CITY 0 HUNTINGTON BEACH PO BO 190 2000 MAI ST 2000 M IN ST HUNTIN TON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTIN ON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTIN TON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-163- 4 110-163 55 110-163- 6 CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAI ST 2000 M N ST 2000 M IN ST HUNTING ON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTIN TON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNT GTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-163-07 110-163/HTINGTON 110-16 -09 CITY OF HU INGTON BEACH CITY OF BEACH CITYF HUNTINGTON BEACH PO BOX 190 PO BOX P OX 190 HUNTINGT N BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINEACH CA 92648-0190 NTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-163- 110-163 11 110-163`2 CITY OF\HUTINGTON BEACH CITY OF NTINGTON BEACH CITY OF H NTINGTON BEACH PO BOX 2000 MAIN T PO BOX 19 HUNTINEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGT N BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGT N BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-163-13 110-1 -14 110-163 15 WALTER D.SERVICE CITY 0 HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH 7050 RUNNING IRON LN PO BOX 190 2000 MAI ST FL 2 POCATELLO ID 83204-3817 HUNTIN ON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTING ON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-163-16 110-163-17 110-16 18 JOHN COLLIER ROBISON PATRICIA A.MITCHELL CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH 2110 MURRAY HOLLADAY RD 4147 GARDENIA AVE PO BOX 1 SALT LAKE CITY UT 84117-5236 LONG BEACH CA 90807-3006 HUNTINGT BEACH CA 92648-0190 110- 63-19 110-163- 110-163 1 CITY F HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF NTINGTON BEACH CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH 2000 IN ST PO BOX 1 PO BOX 1 0 HUNTI TON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGT N BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTING N BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-163-22 110-16 -23 110-16 -01 RICHARD ALLEN RAILL CITY 0 HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF NTINGTON BEACH 200WMIDWAYDR#130-B PO BOX 90 PO BOX 19 ANAHEIM CA 92805-6552 HUNTIN ON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTO BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-164-0 110-164-03 -164-04 CITY OF H NTING�BEACHCITY OF HUN INGTON BEACH CITY OF H NTINGTON BEACH PO BOX 1902000 MAIN ST 2000 MAIN STDHUNTINGTON B HUNTINGTON B 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-16 -05 110-164-06 110-1 -07 CITY F HUNTINGTON BEACH CHARLES B.KIMBALL HAROLD \CA ON 2000 IN ST 2460 SAN FRANCISCO ST PO BOX 1 HUNTI TON BEACH CA 92648-2702 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94123 CARLSBA018-1097 110-164-08 110-164-09 110-164-1 51635189 SECOND FAMILY LIM ITED PARTN CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH CITY O HUNTINGTON BEACH 16242 WALRUS LN PO BO 190 2000 IN ST FL 2 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-2546 HUNT GTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNT GTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-164-11 110-164-12 110-1 4-13 MONIDA B.ROCKWELL HAROLD C.MORTON CITY OF NTINGTON BEACH 939 36TH ST PO BOX 1097 PO BOX 19 OGDEN UT 84403-1113 CARLSBAD CA 92018-1097 HUNTINGTO iaEACH CA 92648-0190 110-164-1 110-164-15 110-164-16 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GLENDENE BLANKENSHIP KATHRYN C.TILTON PO BO 190 PO BOX 156 401 PROSPECT CIR HUNTI GTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 WESTMINSTER CA 92684-0156 SOUTH PASADENA CA 91030-1745 110-164 17 110-164-18 110-164- 9 CITY OF H NTINGTON BEACH WILLIAM C.SCOULLER CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH PO BOX 19 8302 INDIANAPOLIS AVE 2000 M ST HUNTINGT BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-5011 HUNTI GTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-1 -20 110-164-21 110-1 -22 CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH LEWI DERIGO CITY 0 HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN T 807 MAIN PO BOX 90 HUNTINGT BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTO EACH CA 92648-3416 HUNTING ON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-165-01 110-1 5-02 110-165-03 YETURU RAMA REDDI CITY 0 HUNTINGTON BEACH STAN WOJNILOWICZ 17610 BEACH BL#O 35-Fi PO BOX 90 25545 CALLE BECERRA HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6846 HUNTING N BEACH CA 92648-0190 LAGUNA NIGUEL CA 92677-4436 110-16 -04 110-165-05 110-16 -06 CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH KENNETH H.MILLER CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAI T 2901 TAM OSHANTER DR PO BOX 90 HUNTINGT BEACH CA 92648-2702 EL DORADO HILLS CA 95762-4238 HUNTIN TON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-165-07 110-165-08 110-165-09 CITY OF UNTINGTO EAC CITY OF H IN ON BEACH INGTON BEACH PO BOX 19 N ST SUNTIE HUNTINGTON CH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-165-1 U 110-165-11 110-165-12 CITY OF UNTINGTON B CH �TY HUN ING BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAI T90 000 MAIN ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-165- 3 110-165-14 110-165-15 CITY OF UNTINGTON BEA H UNTINGTON CH CI OF HUNTINGT CH PO BOX 1 r 2000 MAIN 2000 HUNTINGTO GA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-165-16 110-165-17 110-165-18 CITY OF NTINGTO ITY OF HU TON B CH CI OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN T 200 STREET PO BO 0- HUNTINGTO EACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648- 190 110-165-19 110-165-20 11 65-21 CITY OF HUN INGTON BEACH CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH PO BOX 190 2000 M IN ST PO BOX 19 HUNTINGTO BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTI TON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGT N BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-165-22 110-16 23 110-165-24 CITY OF HUNTINGT BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HU TINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN ST 2000 IN STREET 2000 MAIN S; HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 9 -2702 H INGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-180- 110-180-0 i10-18U-06; PACIFIC AME IL CO CORP CITY O HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH 30110 CROWN V LEY PY#PY 2000 AIN ST 2000 M N ST LAGUNA NIGUEL 92677-2043 HU tNGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNT GTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-180-90 11 80-12 110-180-13 CITY OF H NTINGTON BEACH CITY OF UNTINGTON B CI F HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN ST 2000 MAINS 2000 M 1 V�ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-180-14 1 80-17 CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUN GTON BEACH CITY OF H NGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN T 2000 MAIN ST 2000 MAIN ST HUNTINGTO CA 9 702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-180-18 110-180-19 110-181-01 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CI F HU TINGTON BEACH CI HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN ST 2000 MAIN ST 2000 MAIN`ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON B 6H 6A 6? -2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-181-02 110-181-03 110-181-04 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CI UNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF H ON B -CH 2000 M IN ST PO BOX 19 P BOX 477 HUNTI TON BEAC A 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 SUN CITY CA 92586-0477 110-181-05 110-181-06 110-181-07 MELVtN F.KELLER CI OF HUNTINGTON BEA CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 4534 SW HEWETT BLVD PO B 20 PORTLAND OR 97221-3109 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON B 8-2702 110-181-08 110-181-09 110-181-10 CITY F HUNTINGTON BEA CITY TON BEACH ITY OF HUNTINGTON B 2000 M N ST 000 MAIN ST 2000 HUNTING EACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-181-11 110-181-12 110-182-01 CITY L HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTI INGTONBEACH 2000N ST 20 T PO BOX 190 HUNTINGTO CH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-182-02 110-182-03 110-182-04 CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH HSI HSIANG HEN H.LEE CITY HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 AIN ST 9782 OLYMPIC P BOX 190 H TINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEA CA 92646 4867 BOX BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-182-05 110-182-06 110-182-07 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH ON 8EA H CITY OF HUNTING BEACH 2000 M PO BOX 190 2000 MAIN ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 CITY OF H qTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN ST 2000 MAIN ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110A 82-11 110-182-12 110-183-01 PRANCE ORENE ENSIGN CITY OF NTINGTON BEACH CITY F HUNTINGTON BEACH 416 W LAS P S DR 2000 M ST P OX 190 FULLERTON CA 835-1536 HUN GTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 Y 110-183-02 110-183-03 110-183-04 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH iTINGT TINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN ST 2000 MAIN ST PO BOX 190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-183-05 110-183-07 110-183-08 CITY OF HUNTIN ITY OF HUNGINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNGINGTON BEACH PO 0 2000 MAIN ST 2000 iN'ST- HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-183-09 110-183-10 110-183-11 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITBOX1 NTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN ST 2000 MAIN ST PO HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-183-12 110-183-13 110-183-14 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH PO BOX 190 190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEA 648-0190 110-183-15 110-183-16 110-183-17 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNGINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN ST 2000 MAIN ST PO BOX 190 HUNTIN CA 92648-0190 110-183-18 110-183-19 110-183-20 CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH JAMES R.MAAG CITY OF TINGTON BEACH PO X 190 25955 VIA DEL REY PO X 190 H TINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 SAN JUAN CAPISTRANO CA 92675-4460 NTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-183-21 110-183-22 110-183-23 CITY OF HUN CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH PO BOX 190 PO BOX 190 2000 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-183-24 110-183-25 110-184-01 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN ST AIN ST 2000 MAIN ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648- 2648-2702 11/TIINGTON 110-184-03 110- 84-04 . CITNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF H TINGTON BEACH HSI HSIA &CHEN H.LEE PO 2000 M ST 9782 OLYMPI R HU BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON B H CA 92646-4867 110-184-05 110-184-06 110-184-07 CITY OF HUNT CITY OF HUNTI INGTO BEACH 2000 MAIN ST 2000 MAIN ST 2000 MAIN ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 /NT 110-184-09 110-184-11 INGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTI ON BEACH CITY OF H INGTON BEACH 2000 MAI PO 190 BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTL GTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 NTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-184-12 110-184-13 110-184-14 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN ST 2000 MAIN ST PO BOX 190 HUNTMGlQN a ACH CA 02648 2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CH CA 92648-0190 110-184- 110-184-16 110-184-17 Cl F HUNTINGTON BEACH WILLIAM B.BLANCHARD BETTY MC QUILLEN P BOX 190 150 YUCCA DR 38211 VISTA DR UNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 SEDONA AZ 86336-3222 CATHEDRAL CITY CA 92234-2142 /MAIN 110-184-19 110-184-20 GTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN ST EACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-184-21 110-184-22 110-184-23 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN ST OX 190 2000 MA H CH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-185-01 110-185-02 110-185-03 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HU F HUNTINGTON BEACH 2 IN ST 2000 MAIN ST 2000 MAIN ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-185-05 110-185-06 110-185-07 CITY 0 HUNTINGTON BEACH GEORGINA L.CARTWRIGHT CITY OF HU ON BEACH PO X 190 33816 ALCAZAR DR PO B 0 HU TINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 DANA POINT CA 92629-2404 TINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 11/GTON 110-185- 99 110-185-10 CITGTON BEACH CITY OF NTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUN INGTON BEACH 200 2000 M ST 2000 MAIN HUACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTI GTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGT N BEACH CA 92648-2702 110/INGTON /UNTINGTON 110-185-13 CITINGTON BEACH NTINGTON BEACH CITY 0 UNTINGTON BEACH 200 PO X 190 HUBEACH CA 92648-2702 BEACH CA 92648-0190 H TINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-185- 4 110- 85-15 11/GTON CITY HUNTINGTON BEACH GEORGIN CARTWRIGHT CITNGTON BEACH 2000 AIN ST 33816 ALCAZA R 200 HU INGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 DANA POINT CA 629-2404 HUEACH CA 92648-2702 110-185-17 110-185-18 110-185-19 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON RFArH H 2000 MAIN ST 2000 MAIN ST PO BOX 190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-185-20 110-185-21 110-185-22 CITY CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN ST 2000 MAIN ST 2000 MAIN ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-185 3 110-186-0 110-186-0 CITY F HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY HUNTINGTON BEACH 200 MAIN ST PO X 190 200 AIN ST HU TINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HU TINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-186-03 110-186 4 110-186-05 YETURU SUSEELAMMA HSI HSIANG& EN H.LEE CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH 17610 BEACH BLVD#35-B 9782 OLYMPIC DR PO X 190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6855 HUNTINGTON BEAC A 92646-4867 H TINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 110-186- 110-186-07 110-186-08 CITY F HUNTINGTON BEACH PATRICIA G.POYYAK CARL J.&ALICE M.OBERT 20 MAIN ST 3916 CEDAR BAYOU DR 15271 SHASTA LN H NTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 DALLAS TX 75244-7217 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-3024 110-186-09 /MAIN 110-186-1 J.A.JOHNSON TINGTON BEACH CITY HUNTINGTON BEACH 3079 MAIDEN LN 200 MAIN STALTADENA CA 91001-1726 BEACH CA 92648-2702 H TINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-186-1 1/NTINGTON 110-186-14 CITY 0 HUNTINGTON BEACH CINGTON BEACH HERMAN HARMS 2000 AIN ST 2 5655 116TH PL SE HU TINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HBEACH CA 92648-2702 BELLEVUE WA 98006-3711 110-186-15 110-186-16 110-186- HUNTINGTON BEACH CO ALICE E.HUGHES CITY HUNTINGTON BEACH PO BOX 285 PO BOX 3404 200 MAIN ST HOUSTON TX 77001-0285 SANTA FE SPRINGS CA 90670-1404 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 IIU-160-16 110-186-19 110-186-2Q CITY OF HUNTIN CITY O HUN CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN ST PO BOX 190 2000 MAIN ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HUNTINGTON CH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 110-186-21 110-186- 110-210-01 CITY OF NTINGTON BEACH CITY F HUNTINGTON BEACH WILLIAM LANDIS 2000 M N ST PO OX 190 !q 01 A UfijuE or THe S AR5 HUNT GTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 HONTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 S�iT� G70 LJS ^AIGO, GS1 C.4 . 9C6(r -1 110-210-02 110-210- 3 110-2�0-04 GOLDENWEST PARTNERS LLC GOLDE EST PARTNERS LLC GOLENW ST PARTNERS 5620 E SANTIAGO CANYON RD 5620 E SA TIAGO CANYON RD ORANGE CA 92869-1436 ORANGE CA 92869-1436 110-210-06 110-21 -07 110-21 -10 DOROTHY THOMAS LOUIS C SPELTZ GOLDEN ST PARTNERS LLC 163 FOND VIEW DR 5620 E SANTI CANYON RD CENTERVILLE MA 26320 ORANGE CA 92869-1436 11 210-11 110-210-12 110-210-13 RUT L.GORDON IBRAHIM H.ELBARD KEVIN D.&LORA L.CRUZE NO AD RESS 6992 DERBY CIR 6982 DERBY CIR NO AD ESS HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1563 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1563 110-210-14 110-210-15 110-210-16 GARY W.&RITA R.STENLUND JHANGIANI HARESH S DEAN 0.&KATHLEEN G.GREGG 6972 DERBY CIR 6962 DERBY CIR 6942 DERBY CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1563 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1563 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1563 110-210-17 110-210-18 110-210-19 AHMAD H.&MARLI ABDELMUTI MACKEY &D.1999 TRUS DAVIS VICTORIA COLONNA 6932 DERBY CIR 6912 DERBY CIR 6902 DERBY Cl HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1563 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1563 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1563 110-2 0 110-210-21 110-210-22 GOLENWEST RTNERS TERRY D.&PENNY L.NELSON KHANH G.&MY T.D.PHAM 6921 DERBY CIR 6935 DERBY CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1564 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1564 110-210-23 110-210-24 110-210-25 FRANK E.&SHARON K.KOMIN BRADLEY SCOTT&SANDRA LEE HARRISON BEACH HAMPTONS HOMEOWNERS 6961 DERBY CIR 6981 DERBY CIR WWRT 38TH FLOOR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1564 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1564 LOS ANGELES CA 90071-1406 110-210-26 110-210-27 110-210-28 GMEOWNERS MEOWNERS WWRT 38TH FLOOR WWRT 38TH FLOOR WWRT 38TH FLOOR LOS ANGELES CA 90071-1406 LOS ANGELES CA 90071-1406 LOS ANGELES CA 90071-1406 .74 110-21 -29 111-032-3 111-042 41 BEACH H MPTONS HOMEOWNERS CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH CITY 0 HUNTINGTON BEACH 38TH FLOOR PO BOX 90 PO BO 190 LOS ANGEL CA 90071-1406 HUNTI TON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNT GTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 111-05 -38 111-381-01 111-381-02 CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH SHORES#116 L.P.LYON 6 L.P.LYON PO BOX 1 4490 VON KARMAN 4490 VON KARMAN AV HUNTiNGT BEACH CA 92648-0190 ORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 111-381-03 111-381-04 111-381-05 SHORES#116 L.P.LYON SHORES#116 L.P.LYON SHORES#116 L.P.LYON 4490 VON KARMAN AV 4490 VON KARMAN AV MAN AV NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT B 60-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 111-381-06 111-381-07 111-381-08 SHORES#116 L.P.LYON 6 L.P.LYON 449Q 4490 VON KARMAN AV 4490 VON KARMAN AV NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 111-381-09 111-381-10 111-381-11 SHORES#116 L.P.LYON SHORES#116 L.P.LYON 4 4490 VON KARMAN AV 4490 VON KARMAN AV NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 111-381-12 111-381-13 111-381-14 SHORE #116 L.P.LYON SHORES#116 HORES#116 L.P.LYON 4490 V N KARMAN AV 4490 VON KARMAN AV 4490 VON KARMAN AV NEWP RT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 111-3 1-15 111-381-16 111-381-17 SHOR S#116 L.P.LYON DONALD E.&SANDRA K.CRABB SHORES#116 L . ON 4490 ON KARMAN AV 7375 SHERWOOD DR 4490 VO MAN AV N ORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7023 NEW RT BEACH CA 92660-2008 111-381-18 111-381-19 111-381-20 SHORES#116 L.P.LYON SHORES#116 L.P.LYON SHORES#116 L.P.LYON 4490 VON KARMAN AV A RNIAINI AVO 449U VUN KARMATTMUr NEWP -2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 111-381-21 111-381-22 111-381-23 SHORES#1 SHORES#116 L.P.LYON SHORES#116 L.P.LYON 490 VON KARMAN AV 4490 VON KARMAN AV 4490 VON KARMAN AV NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 111-381-24 111-381-25 1/ORTKBEACH SHORES#116 L.P.LYON SHORES#116 L.P.LYON SP.LYON 44 0 VON KARMAN AV 4N AV NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 N CA 92660-2008 111-3 -27 111-381-2 111-381-29 S RES#116 L.P.LYON SHORE #116 L.P.LYON SHOR #116 L.P.LYON 4 0 VON KARMAN AV 4490 V N KARMAN AV 449 ON KARMAN AV EWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 N RT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 111-381- 111-381-31 111-381-32 SHOR S#116 L.P.LYON SEAG SHORES#116 L.P.LYON 449 ON KARMAN AV 2 CORPORATE PLAZA DR#250 4490 VON KARMAN AV N ORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7944 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 111-381-33 111-381-34 111-381-35 SHOR 116 L.P.LYON SEA E COMMUNITY ASSN PLC 449 ON KARMAN AV 61 EWPORT CENTER DR#700 3991 MACARTHUR BL#22 PORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 ORT BEACH CA 92660-6498 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-3009 111-381-36 111-381-37 111-381-38 PLC PLC PLC 3991 M 3991 MACARTHUR BL#22 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-3009 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-3009 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-3009 111-381-39 111-381-40 111-381-41 PLC PLC 3991 MACARTHUR L.# 3991 MACARTHUR BL#22 3991 MACARTHUR BL#22 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-3009 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-3009 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-3009 111-381-42 111-381-43 111-381-44 PLC HORES#116 L.P.LYON SHORES#116 L.P.LYON 399 RTHUR-SL#22 4490 VON KARMAN AV 4490 VON KARMAN V NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-3009 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 N/ORTBEACHLCA CA 92660-2008 111-3 -01 111-391-02 1 TR M.MCCLEERY ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P ACIATES L P 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 2AZA DR NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 N 92660-7911 111-391-04 111-391-05 111-391-06 ANNANDALE ALE A SO IATES L P 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 111-391-07 111-391-08 111-391-09 ANNANDA SSO ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 23 CORPORAT NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 NEWPORT BEACH CA 9266 -7911 111-391-10 111-391-11 111-391-12 A CIATES L P CIATES L P ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 23 CORPORATE PLAZA D 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 PORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 111-391-13 111-391-14 111-391-15 ANNANDALE ASS ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L E ASSOCIATES L P 23 CO E PLAZA DR 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 111-391-1 111-391-17 111-391-18 ANNAN ALE ASSOCIATES L P TUAN ANH VO JOHN E.CAREY 23 CO PORATE PLAZA DR 7092 EVENINGSONG DR 7082 EVENINGSONG DR NEW RT BEACH CA 92660-7911 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7005 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7005 111-391-19 111-391-20 111-391-21 SHORES#116 L.P.LYON NAM HOANG PHAM HANAWI 1992 TRUST 4490 VON KARMAN AV 7062 EVENINGSONG DR 7052 EVENINGSONG DR NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7005 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7005 111-391-22 111-391-23 111-391-24 YOSHINAMI CHIN MATTHEW M.DENNING THOMAS A.ELLIOTT 7042 EVENINGSONG DR 7038 EVENINGSONG DR 7034 EVENINGSONG DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7005 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7005 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7005 111-391-25 111-391-26 111-391-27 JAMI L.SCHRADER STEVEN R.ROUSSEAU PAUL H.&ANH M.N.THAI 18641 GARNET LN 18631 GARNET LN 18621 GARNET LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7004 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7004 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7004 111-391-28 111-391-29 111-391-30 TODD HAROLD HOEKSTRA MATTHEW J.SINGLETON ROBIN FRANCIS SHORETTE 18611 GARNET LN 18601 GARNET LN 18591 GARNET LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7004 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7004 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7003 111-391-31 111-391-32 111-391-33 LARRY L.LUHRSEN MELVIN F.&J.P.IT CORNWELL AMY E.SIREK 18587 GARNET LN 18581 GARNET LN 18575 GARNET LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7003 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7003 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7003 111-391-34 111-391-35 111-391-36 EDMUND H.LOUIE LOC VAN NGUYEN JOHN B.&LEE ANN C.CORRAL 18565 GARNET LN 18555 GARNET LN 7056 ASHLEY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7003 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7003 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7002 111-391-37 111-391-38 111-391-39 IVOR P.&BARBARA J.ISAACS RICHARD A.&MARY E.HUGHES DAN &CHARLENE GOODMAN 7046 ASHLEY DR 7036 ASHLEY DR 7035 ASHLEY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7002 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7002 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7001 111-391-40 111-391-41 111-391-42 GARRETT G.&LYNDA G.RUTHERFORD LI QUANG&DUYEN NGUYEN GERALD A.&VICTORIA L.BARBISAN 7045 ASHLEY DR 7055 ASHLEY DR 7065 ASHLEY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7001 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7001 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7001 .N 111-391-43 111-391-44 111-391-45 RYNE D.&IRENE J.PEARSON ANTHONY &ELIZABETH GIAMBONE D.G.STONEHUCKER 7075 ASHLEY DR 7085 ASHLEY DR 7095 ASHLEY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7001 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7001 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7001 111-391-46 111-391-47 111-391-48 TIMOTHY K.&MICHELLE MC KEE STEVEN J.LOSCHIAVO LINDA L.COMPTE 7105 ASHLEY DR 7115 ASHLEY DR 7125 ASHLEY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7000 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7000 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7000 111-391-49 111-391-50 111-391-51 DAVID C.FAULKNER KENT A.&JANET E.RICHARDS STEVEN W.&KIMBERLY J.SCHULTZ 7135 ASHLEY DR 7145 ASHLEY DR 7126 ASHLEY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7000 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7000 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7014 111-391-52 111-391-53 111-391-54 HIEU TRONG LAM ROSS L.&SUSAN J.RAYBURN GUY E.&JUSTINE ZIERTEN 18552 GARNET LN 18562 GARNET LN 18568 GARNET LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7013 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7013 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7013 111-391-55 111-391-56 111-391-57 FRANK O.ROOD HIEN HO TONG LEE CHARLES&MIKI UEDA LEROW 18572 GARNET LN 18574 GARNET LN 18578 GARNET LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7013 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7013 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7013 ----!(-" 111-391-58 111-391-59 111-391-60 SOONDUK PARK BRIAN KING ROBERT F.BAYER 18582 GARNET LN 18586 GARNET LN 18622 GARNET LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7013 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7013 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7012 111-391-61 111-391-62 111-391-63 SHORES#116 L.P.LYON RON P.FEINER SHORES#116 L.P.LYON 4490 VON KARMAN AV 18657 AMBROSE LN 4490 VON KARMAN AV NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7010 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 111-391-64 111-391-65 111-391-66 SHORES#116 L.P.LYON SHORES#116 L.P.LYON ANTHONY P.JENKINS 4490 VON KARMAN AV 4490 VON KARMAN AV 18691 AMBROSE LN NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7010 111-391-67 111-391-68 111-391-69 EDWARD E.SCHANIEL GUY M.ANTHONY SHORES#116 L.P.LYON 18697 AMBROSE LN 10931 SADDLERY RD 4490 VON KARMAN AV HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7010 SANTA ANA CA 92705-2540 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 111-391-70 111-391-71 111-391-72 SHORES#116 1 -----ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P ANNANDALE ASSO TES L P 4490 V KARMAN AV 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 .- IIi-oai-/ 111-391-75 SEAGATE COMMUNITY SEAG TE COMMUNITY GAT OMMUNITY 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR#250 23 RPORATE PLAZA DR#250 23 CO PORATE PLAZA DR#250 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7944 N PORT BEACH CA 92660-7944 N ORT BEACH CA 92660-7944 111-391-76 111-391-77 111-391-78 SHORES#116 L.P.LYO SHORES#116 L.P.LYON SHORES#116 L.P.LYON 610 N CENTER DR#700 4490 VON KARMAN AV NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-6498 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 EACH CA 92660-2008 111-391-79 111-391-80 111-391-81 S PLC ��~ 4490 VON KARMAN AV 23 3991 MACARTHUR BL#22 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7944 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-3009 111-391-82 111-391-83 111-391-84 •-.2LC _ PLC ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P 3991 MACARTHURUR BLIP 9 3991 MACARTHUR BL#22 23 CORPORATE PDR OTNEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-300 RACHA26 9 A 266 0-7911 111-391-85 111-391-86 111-40 SHORES#.._. & l&L P L-YON SHORES P.LYON TROY M.MCCLEERY 4490 VON KARMAN AV 4490 VON KARMAN AV NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 111-401-02 111-401-03 111-401-04 TROY M. EERY TROY M.M ERY TRO MCCLEERY 111-401-05 111-401-06 111-401-07 DENISE RUST TROY CLEERY CHARLES LAW ALBANO 18797 AMBROSE LN 7114 FOREST GLEN DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7016 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7026 111-401-08 111-401-09 111-401-10 CHARLES A.&S.M.TR DELARUE ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P JAMES M.WHITELAW 7154 FOREST GLEN DR 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 7144 FOREST GLEN DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7026 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7026 111-401-11 111-401-12 111-401-13 CHRISTOPHER L.MEYER ROBERT P.BOYER BRIAN M.MEEHAN 7154 FOREST GLEN DR 18788 STRATTON LN 18778 STRATTON LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7026 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 111-401-14 111-401-15 111-401-16 HARRY MAKOROW GERALD N.&DIANE R.FULLERTON KEVIN HIROSHI LEE 18772 STRATTON LN 18768 STRATTON LN 18758 STRATTON LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 111-401-06 111-401-07 111-401-08 TROY M.MCCLEERY CHARLES LAW ALBANO CHARLES A.&S.M.TR DELARUE 7114 FOREST GLEN DR 7154 FOREST GLEN DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7026 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7026 111-401-09 111-401-10 111-401-11 ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P JAMES M.WHITELAW CHRISTOPHER L.MEYER 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 7144 FOREST GLEN DR 7154 FOREST GLEN DR NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7026 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7026 111-401-12 111401-13 111-401-14 ROBERT P.BOYER BRIAN M.MEEHAN HARRY MAKOROW 18788 STRATTON LN 18778 STRATTON LN 18772 STRATTON LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 111-401-15 111-401-16 111-401-17 GERALD N.&DIANE R.FULLERTON KEVIN HIROSHI LEE MICHAEL P.DECARLO 18768 STRATTON LN 18758 STRATTON LN 18754 STRATTON LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 111-401-18 111-401-19 111-401-20 CHRISTOPHER J.&KATHLEEN A.SAENZ ROBERT A.FISHBURN ROY 0.&ASHLEE T.GUILLERMO 18750 STRATTON LN 18746 STRATTON LN 18736 STRATTON LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 111-401-21 111401-22 111-401-23 PHUONG N.&DAVID C.LE JOEY TSEUNG MING CHEUNG JOHN W.&CAROLYN L.LEWIS 18728 STRATTON LN 18722 STRATTON LN 18716 STRATTON LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 111-401-24 111-401-25 111401-26 ANNANDALE ASSO TES L P ROBERT W.&CARYN R.ARMSTRONG TUNG V.&DIEUCHOA T.VO 23 CORPORAT LAZA DR 18702 STRATTON LN 18698 STRATTON LN NEWPORT CH CA 92660-7911 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7006 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7017 111-401-27 111-401-28 111-401-29 ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P TROY M.MCC 23 CORPORATE P Rr---- �PlEb7 BEACH CA 92660-7911 111-401-30 111-401-31 111401-32 TROY M.MCCLEERY SHl1RFG#116 L P LYON SHORES#116 L P LYON 4490 VON KARMAN AV 4490 VON KARMAN AV NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 111-401-33 111-401-34 111-401-35 SHORES#116 L.P.LYON SHORES#116 L.P.LYON SHORES#116 L.P.LYON 449 VON KARMAN AV 4490 VON KARMAN AV NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT BEAC 660-2008 111-4U1-�;o 111-401-37 111-401-3d SHORES#11 L.P.LYON SHORES#116 .P.LYON STEFANO COLAIACOMO 4490 VON KA MAN AV 4490 VON KA AN AV 18642 AMBROSE LN NEWPORT B CH CA 92660-2008 NEWPORT B CH CA 92660-2008 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7028 111-401-39 111-401-40 111-401-41 ANNANDALE SSOCIATES L P ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P 23 CORPO E PLAZA DR 23 COMQnMA C 01 AzA r%c QQRPORATF Pi AZA DR NEWPORT B CH CA 92660-7911 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 111-401-42 111-401-43 111401-44 ANNANDALE A SOCIATES L P RICK R.&NANCY S.KRATZER ANNANDAL SOCIATES L P 23 CORPORAT PLAZA DR 18682 AMBROSE LN 23 COR TE PLAZA DR NEWPORT B CH CA 92660-7911 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7028 N ORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 111-401-45 111-401-46 1 1-401-47 ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P ANNAN LE ASSOCIATES L P 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 23 CORPO 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR NEWPORT B - NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 111-401-48 111-401-49 111-401-50 ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 2 23 e0RPefbkTE44AZAZB NEWPORT BEA NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 111-401-51 111-401-52 111401-53 ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P ANNANDALE ASSOCIATES L P TROY M.MCCLEERY 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR NEWPORT B - 911 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 111-401-54 111-401-55 111401-56 TROY M.MCCLEERY TROY M.MCCLEE Y M.MCCLEERY 111-401-57 111-401-58 111401-59 TROY M.MCCLEERY ANNANDA SOCIATES L P LANCE M.&SANDRA K.TOWERS 23 C PORATE PLAZA DR 18765 STRATTON LN N PORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7008 111-401-60 111-401-61 111401-62 PAUL R.&DOROTHY J.ANDERSON STANTON W.MASUMURA JOHN WAI LEUNG&SHUI DON LOH 18761 STRATTON LN 18759 STRATTON LN 18751 STRATTON LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7008 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7008 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7008 111-401-63 111-401-64 111401-65 WAI CHENG SEETOO CARL J.TEMPLE FRED G.&PATRICIA A.REDMON 18747 STRATTON LN 18743 STRATTON LN 18737 STRATTON LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7008 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7008 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7008 111-401-66 111-401-67 111-401-68 RICHARD &VERONICA P.MARTINEZ KEVIN &IRENE M.HENNESSY HOANG VAN PHAM 18731 STRATTON LN 18725 STRATTON LN 18719 STRATTON LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7008 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7008 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7008 1/TRATTON 111-401-70 111-401-71 PACIVER ANNAN E ASSOCIATES L P TROY MCCLEERY 1 LN 23 C PORATE PLAZA DR HEACH CA 92648-7008 N ORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 + 111-401-712 111-401-73 111-401-7 ANNANDALE SSOCIATES L P JACK A.&JENNIFER M.PAHOLSKI TROY MCCLEERY 23 CORPO TE PLAZA DR 18691 STRATTON LN NEWPOR BEACH CA 92660-7911 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7007 111-401-75 111-401-7 111-401-77 ANNANDALE A OCIATES L P AN NDALE ASSOCIATES L P SHERWOOD NEIG ORHOOD ASSN 23 CORPO E PLAZA DR 23 ORPORATE PLAZA DR 23 CORPORAT LAZA DR NEWPORT EACH CA 92660-7911 N 0RT BEACH CA 92660-7911 NEWPORT BE CH CA 92660-7911 111-401-78 111-401-79 111-401-80 SHERWOOD NEIGHBORHOO N SHERW99B NEIGHBGRHOOD ASSNTY 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 23 CORPORATE PLAZA DR#250 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7944 111-401-81 111-401-82 111-401-83 TROY TROY M.MCCLEERY TROY M.MCCLEERY 111-4 -01 111-411-02 111-411-03 DI M LE CARLOS A.AGUILAR CRAIG P.HARVEY 18711 ASHFORD LN 18717 ASHFORD LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7033 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7033 111-411-04 111-411-05 111-411-06 SCH G HOU NO 3 LLC O 3 LLC 3 CO RATE PLAZA DR 3 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 3 CORPORATE P R NEVOORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 111-411-07 111-411-08 111-411-09 SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC 0 3 LLC SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC 3 CO DR 3 CORPORATE PLAZA DR LAZA DR NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 111-411-10 111-411-11 111-411-12 SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC Qrlw Nni Ic Nn 3 LLC 3 CORPORfEF'D 3 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 3 CORPORATE PLAZA DR NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 111-411-13 111-411-14 111-411-i5 SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC 3 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 3 CORPORATE PLAZA DR P DR NEW P T REACH CA 92660 7 1 1�32660 905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 111-411-16 111-411-17 111-411-18 SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC 3 CORPOR 3 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 3 CORPORATE PLAZA DR NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 111-411-19 111-411-20 SCH HOUSIN SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC 3 CORPO TE PLAZA B PLAZA DR 3 CORPORATE NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 111-411-22 111-411-23 111-411-24 THOMAS M.KELLEHER ANGELA B.SYKES TIMOHTY J.ARGUELLO 7256 ROCKRIDGE DR 7266 ROCKRIDGE DR 18780 FAIRFAX LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7020 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7020 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7019 111-411-25 111-411-26 111-411-27 J.THOMAS HAND RACHEL C.MONTECILLO FRANCIS T.PETERS 18776 FAIRFAX LN 18772 FAIRFAX LN 18766 FAIRFAX LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7019 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7019 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7019 111-411-28 111-4 -2 111-411-30 JAMES SUTTON TUNG AARON C.&LISA R.CARGILE 18762 FAIRFAX LN 18742 FAIRFAX LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7019 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7019 111-411-31 111-411-32 111-411-33 JAMES 0.GROSS LAWRENCE J.&DEBRALEE G.LARKIN JEREMY S.&DENISE I.LEVINE 18736 FAIRFAX LN 18726 FAIRFAX LN 18722 FAIRFAX LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7019 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7019 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7019 111-411-34 111-411-35 111-411-36 JAMES A.&BRENDA J.STANGELAND JENNIF DILUZIO JASON HUTCHEON 18716 FAIRFAX LN 18696 FAIRFAX LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7019 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7019 111-411-37 111 411- 111-411-39 SCOTT K.KIEN TH0 S C.DUBAR LYNNE M.CRISAFI 18692 FAIRFAX LN 7314 SHERWOOD DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7019 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7021 111-411-40 111-411-41 111-411-42 JOHN P.&TERI L.E.DELANEY LIM H.&LINDA F.CHOI WADE ELLIOTT 7318 SHERWOOD DR 18697 FAIRFAX LN 18707 FAIRFAX LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7021 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7018 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7018 111-411-43 111-411-44 111-411-45 BYRON C.&LYNN E.CHILLEME GREGORY B.DALY MATTHEW CASSARINO 18717 FAIRFAX LN 18725 FAIRFAX LN 18735 FAIRFAX LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7018 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7018 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7018 111-411-46 111-411-47 111-41148 JOHN C.SIENS MARIO A.MONTOYA RONALD W.&SHERISE M.BIEBER 18739 FAIRFAX LN 18745 FAIRFAX LN 18755 FAIRFAX LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7018 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7018 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7018 111-411 111-411-50 111-411-51 SCH USING NO 3 LLC MARVIN J.GRIMM J.K.&CATHERINE S.DEAN 3 C PORATE PLAZA DR 18769 FAIRFAX LN 18775 FAIRFAX LN N PORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7018 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7018 111-411-52 111-411-53 111-411-54 SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC USING NO 3 LLC 3 CORPORATE P ORPORATE PLAZA DR 3 CORPORATE PLAZA DR N PORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 111-411-55 111-411-56 111-411-57 SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC 3 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 3 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 3 CORPORATE PLAZA DR NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 111-411-58 111-411-59 111-411-60 SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC JEFFREY MOORS 3CORPORATE R NEWP RT BEACH CA 92660-7905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 111-411-61 111-411-62 111-411-63 HA CO Q ELAINE N.KLUBNIKIN ERIC J.&ANN M.PETTY 18716 ASHFORD LN 18708 ASHFORD LN 18702 ASHFORD LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7032 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7032 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-7032 111-411-64 111-411-65 111-411-66 SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC 3 CORPORATE PLAZA DR 3 CORPORATE P 3 CORPORATE P DR NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 111411-67 111-411-68 111-411-69 SEAGATE COMMUNITY SEAGATE COMMUNITY SCH HOUSING NO 3 LLC 23 RATE PLAZA DR#250 3 CORPORATE PLAZA DR NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7944 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7911 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-7905 111-4/EACH 111-411-71 159-011-01 SCH LC SCH HOUSI NO 3 LLC GREG J.&JENNIFER WIESE 3 CO DR 3 CORPO TE PLAZA DR 18011 WESTLAKE CIR NEW92660-7905 NEWP T BEACH CA 92660-7905 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1130 159-011-02 159-011-03 159-011-04 DONALD WILLIAM NOREEN ALLEN F.LEOF KENT &JOY MADOLE 18021 WESTLAKE CIR 18031 WESTLAKE CIR 18041 WESTLAKE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1130 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1130 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1130 159-011-05 159-011-06 159-011-07 TODD K.&JEANINE M.BASHORE EDWARD H.HARRISON LEIF &CARY THOMPSON 18051 WESTLAKE CIR 18061 WESTLAKE CIR 18071 WESTLAKE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1130 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1130 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1130 159-011-08 159-011-09 159-011-10 DAVID JOEL&SANDRA MARIE SANDLER MUHS 1992 PARTNERSHIP EUGENE E.CONLEY 18081 WESTLAKE CIR 6921 LOYOLA DR 18101 WESTLAKE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1130 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-4055 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1114 159-011-11 159-011-12 159-011-13 JACK J.QUINTON HAYES TRUST JOHN G.ROBBINS 18111 WESTLAKE CIR 18112 FRESHWATER CIR 18102 FRESHWATER CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1114 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1118 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1118 159-011-14 159-011-15 159-011-16 JIMMIE P.&HEIDI A.REAVES WILLIAM R.SAKSA VASILE VALENTIN&LILIANA TIFREA 18092 FRESHWATER CIR 18082 FRESHWATER CIR 18072 FRESHWATER CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1122 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1122 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1122 159-011-17 159-011-18 159-011-19 CRAIG &GAIL SUSSKIND TIMOTHY P.TURNER ALLAN R.WHITE 18062 FRESHWATER CIR 18052 FRESHWATER CIR PO BOX 3053 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1122 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1122 BIG BEAR LAKE CA 92315-3053 159-011-20 159-011-21 159-011-22 JOHN MICHAEL BARRETT JEFFREY J.&ANN-MARIE MILLAR ANDREW J.VERDONE 18151 RIVERSIDE CIR 18022 FRESHWATER CIR 18012 FRESHWATER CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1077 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1122 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1122 159-011-23 159-011-24 159-011-25 MARGO LYNN GAYLER SZEKERESH ROBERT WENDY C.COCKLEY 18011 FRESHWATER CIR 18021 FRESHWATER CIR 18031 FRESHWATER CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1122 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1122 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1122 159-011-26 159-011-28 159-011-29 CHARLES N.BAKER ANTHONY C.MINNITI ALLEN J.STROH 18041 FRESHWATER CIR PO BOX 1862 18071 FRESHWATER CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1122 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-1862 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1122 159-011-30 159-011-31 159-011-32 ROGER L.&DAWN M.GARLAND DALE ROBERT BAKER ALANA HSUEH CHING CHE NG TSAI 18081 FRESHWATER CIR 18091 FRESHWATER CIR 981 PASEO LA CRESTA HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1122 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1122 PALOS VERDES ESTATES CA 90274-203E 159-011-33 159-011-34 159-011-35 JOHN L.REYNOLDS DONALD W.&SHARYN Q.CLAYPOOL RICHARD R.STEVENS 18111 FRESHWATER CIR 18112 CLEARWATER CIR 18102 CLEARWATER CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1125 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1126 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1126 159-011-36 159-011-37 159-011-38 HAROLD RONALD COOK MICHAEL T.PETROZZI PATRICIA ANN HAAS 18092 CLEARWATER CIR 17422 GASPERS CIR 18072 CLEARWATER CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1119 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5607 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1119 159-011-39 159-011-40 159-011-41 HERBERT B.&NANCY E.COLEMAN ABRAHAM ASHER DANIEL &CAROL NEEDHAM 18062 CLEARWATER CIR 18052 CLEARWATER CIR 18042 CLEARWATER CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1119 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1119 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1119 159-011-42 159-011-43 159-011-44 MARIAN VIOLET MEYERS JOHN MICHAEL BARRETT WILLIAM P.WILLS 800 12TH AV 18151 RIVERSIDE CIR 18012 CLEARWATER CIR SWEET HOME OR 97386-2223 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1077 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1119 159-011-45 159-011-46 159-011-47 ROBERT D.&RHONDA M.JENSEN ASELE ROUCHLEAU JAMES E.&JESSICA M.ELLIS 18011 CLEARWATER CIR 18021 CLEARWATER CIR 18031 CLEARWATER CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1119 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1119 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1119 159-011-48 159-011-49 159-011-50 ROY M.SARVER ALECTOR C.RAMOS. MARGARET T.BRADLEY 18041 CLEARWATER CIR 18051 CLEARWATER CIR 18061 CLEARWATER CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1119 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1119 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1119 159-011-51 159-011-52 159-011-53 DONNA F.LEBLANC PHILIP A.GERRITY AMIR &AKIKO H.AGHAJANI 18071 CLEARWATER CIR 18081 CLEARWATER CIR 18091 CLEARWATER CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1119 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1119 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1119 159-011-54 159-011-55 159-012-05 MICHAEL &ROBIN LOPERFIDO CH/RH TRUST CITY OF H GTON BEACH 18101 CLEARWATER CIR 4600 E SUNSET RD 202 PO 190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1127 HENDERSON NV 89014-2202 H NTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 159-021-01 159-022-01 159-022-02 CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH GARY D.GARNER IWAMOTO EARL IWAO&JOYCE LYNN PO B 190 18011 CLIFFVIEW LN 18021 CLIFFVIEW LN HUN INGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1120 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1120 159-022-03 159-022-04 159-022-05 PATRICIA M.HAANING BURTON L.&DONNA O'DONNELL JANSEN CDF 11 LLC 18031 CLIFFVIEW LN 18051 CLIFFVIEW LN 2130 SANTIAGO DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1120 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1120 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-3838 159-022-06 159-022-07 159-022-08 RICHARD L.&SUSAN E.LUCIAN ROBERT J.WILLIAMS HIROHISA &KUNIE ISOGAWA 18052 SHOREVIEW CIR 18042 SHOREVIEW CIR 18022 SHOREVIEW CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1124 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1124 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1124 159-022-09 159-022-10 159-022-11 EDWIN E.COOK ROBERT G.KOODRICH KARL A.VAN HOLT HOLT 18012 SHOREVIEW CIR 18011 SHOREVIEW CIR 18021 SHOREVIEW CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1124 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1124 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1124 159-022-12 159-022-13 159-022-14 JOHN KRAMER HALE FRED G.&SHARON G.HALL ROBERT K.NIMMONS 18041 SHOREVIEW CIR 18051 SHOREVIEW CIR 18061 SHOREVIEW CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1124 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1124 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1124 159-022-15 159-022-16 159-022-17 DARYL D.SMITH LONG CONCHITA M 1998 TRUST MICHAEL C.BURKENFIELD 6611 LAKEVIEW DR 6601 LAKEVIEW DR 6591 LAKEVIEW DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1123 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1123 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1121 159-022-18 159-022-19 159-022-20 M.ROBERT BOOZAN CHRISTOPHER T.GANZ DENNIS D.MILLER 438 MAIN ST#C 18072 UPPERLAKE CIR 8614 BLUE BIRD AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-5132 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1129 FOUNTAIN VALLEY CA 92708-6201 159-022-21 159-022-22 159-022-23 ROBERT &SUE ANN RAYBURN VANCE CARRUTH JILA ORDIBEHESHTI 18052 UPPERLAKE CIR 18843 SAN FELIPE ST 18022 UPPERLAKE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1129 FOUNTAIN VALLEY CA 92708-7400 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1129 159-022-24 159-022-25 159-022-26 GLORIA D.SUNGHERA ROBERT L.SNELL MICHAEL JOSEPH&CAREY L.MC CORD 18012 UPPERLAKE CIR 18011 UPPERLAKE CIR 18021 UPPERLAKE Cl HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1129 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1129 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1129 159-022-27 159-022-28 159-022-29 BONNIE L.WILBER HJELMSTROM GORDON F JAMES E.MASON 619 MT OLIVE DR 18041 UPPERLAKE CIR 2108 E CORWIN RD BRADBURY CA 91010-1232 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1129 BULLHEAD CITY AZ 86442-8745 159-022-30 159-022-31 159-022-32 SHEILA A.BLYTH DEBRA B.BUDNA BETTY LAINE 18061 UPPERLAKE CIR 830 CASITAS CT 9705 DEEP FORK DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1129 SAN LUIS OBISPO CA 93405-4727 NORMAN OK 73026-8274 159-022-33 159-022-34 159-022-35 JUDITH D.GAGLIONE JOYCE L.COLLIFLOWER VICTOR M.&SHARON L.OSWALD 6571 LAKEVIEW DR 6561 LAKEVIEW DR 6551 LAKEVIEW DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1131 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1131 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1131 159-022-36 159-022-37 159-022-38 MICHAEL R.BOOZAN DIANE DE MOULIN JOHN KENNETH SUSMAN 438 MAIN ST#C 18102 WESTLAKE CIR 1797 PENINSULA PL HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-5132 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1113 COSTA MESA CA 92627-4591 159-022-39 159-022-40 159-022-41 JOHN A.CHIARENZA JUDI A.CARLSON JOHN L.BOLAND 18082 WESTLAKE CIR 18072 WESTLAKE Cl 16729 SILKTREE ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1130 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1130 FOUNTAIN VALLEY CA 92708-2340 159-022-42 159-022-43 159-022-44 ANTHONY C.&PAULA M.MINNITI MANUEL LEYVA KENNETH D.SIMMONS PO BOX 1862 18042 WESTLAKE CIR 16882GOTHARDST#E HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-1862 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1130 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5456 159-022-45 159-022-46 159-023-01 JAMES B.&DONNA L.GRAY PETER F.&LORETTA M.RAIA CITY TINGTON BEACH 18022 WESTLAKE CIR 18012 WESTLAKE CIR P HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1130 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1130 HUNTI`NGTON BEACH CA 92648-0190 159- -02 159-061-32 159-061-33 CITY OF UNTINGTON BEACH WILLIAM R.BRUNER BERNARD &LISA VALENTIN PO BOX 19 18391 GASPE CIR 18401 GASPE CIR HUNTINGTO BEACH CA 92648-0190 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1421 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1421 159-061-34 159-061-35 159-061-36 MICHAEL R.FROST LARRY K.LARSON FREDERICK &KATIE BARBAROSSA 18411 GASPE CIR 18421 GASPE CIR 18431 GASPE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1421 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1421 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1421 159-061-37 159-061-38 159-061-39 LINDA LUCILLE GOLDSMITH WILLIAM H.OSNESS WILLIAM R.SMITH 18441 GASPE CIR 18451 GASPE CIR 18461 GASPE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1421 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1421 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1421 159-061-40 159-061-41 159-061-42 BRUCE E.BARTELS GERALD D.BAKER JEROME C.&JUDY E.GREENBERG 18472 CARNABY LN 18462 CARNABY LN 5100 WATCHWOOD PATH HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1410 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1410 COLUMBIA MD 21044-5708 159-061-43 159-061-44 159-061-45 STEVEN K.&SUSAN R.DANIELSON FERDINAND B.CAPTAIN MURNEZ BLADES 18442 CARNABY LN 18432 CARNABY LN 18422 CARNABY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1410 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1410 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1410 159-061-46 159-061-47 159-061-48 DAVID A.CONLEY HOWARD T.&JO ANN M.UMEHIRA GARY A.&LAURI S.BOSILJEVAC 18412 CARNABY LN 18402 CARNABY LN 18392 CARNABY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1410 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1410 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1451 159-061-68 159-061-69 159-061-70 JAMES A.&CHRISTINE C.MOSS JERRY A.&JUDY G.VINLAND DANY &ILANA RAY 7542 DANTON CIR 7562 DANTON CIR 8 SUNRIVER HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1411 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1411 IRVINE CA 92614-5402 159-061-71 159-061-72 159-061-73 FREDERICK CHARLES&DONNA M.CLEMENS DENNIS L.GRAFF JEFFREY A.WELLS 7582 DANTON CIR 7571 DANTON CIR 7561 DANTON CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1411 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1411 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1411 159-061-74 159-061-75 159-061-76 ALBERT L.CASTELLANO THOMAS J.&D.A.(.GEALY SCOTT A.SMITH 7541 DANTON CIR 18322 CARNABY LN 18312 CARNABY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1411 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1408 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1408 159-061-77 159-061-7 1 62-07 YOSHIHARU &BEATRICE N.NAKASHIMA YOSHIH RU NAKASHIMA GIL T LAI 7572 ONTARIO DR 7572 0 TARIO DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1426 HUNT GTON BEACH CA 92648-1426 159-062-08 159-062-09 159-062-10 MARKUS &AYA GROPL ANGELO J.&TRACEY A.CORSO CHRISTOPHER V.GRUBER 7561 ONTARIO DR 18292 CARNABY LN 18282 CARNABY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1425 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1453 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1453 159-062-11 159-062-12 159-062-13 JAMES W.MARTIN STEVE S.&ANTONINETTE L.SULLIVAN LARRY A.&VICKY M.MC NEELY 7542 TAYLOR DR 7562 TAYLOR DR 7572 TAYLOR DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1444 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1444 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1444 159-063-04 159-063-05 . 159-063-06 ROBERT P.WINSTEIN STEPHEN E.MIKULA BARRY L.MORGAN 7572 APPLEBY DR 7562 APPLEBY DR 7552 APPLEBY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1405 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1405 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1405 159-063-07 159-063-08 159-063-09 SHARON R.OTTO-BATES RICHARD C.MORLEY SUSAN E.MC CLELLAN CLELLAN 8527 EDGEBROOK DR 7522 APPLEBY DR 7512 APPLEBY DR GARDEN GROVE CA 92844-1910 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1405 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1405 159-063-10 159-063-11 159-063-12 MIKE A.KLUBNIKEN NANCY T.KELLY GLENN T.&STEPHANIE A.HORIUCHI 18481 CARNABY LN 18471 CARNABY LN 18461 CARNABY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1409 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1409 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1409 159-063-13 159-063-14 159-063-15 EUGENE C.&ETTA S.VENN WILLIAM RAYMOND&VICKIE L.DOUGLASS JAMES RICHARD GORDON 18451 CARNABY LN 18441 CARNABY LN 18431 CARNABY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1409 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1409 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1409 159-063-16 159-063-17 159-063-18 REX NEBEKER H.RALPH BOSTIC GLORIA A.APODACA 18421 CARNABY LN 18411 CARNABY LN 18401 CARNABY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1409 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1409 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1409 159-063-19 159-063-20 159-063-21 BRAD T.LARSEN SEGIO R.SAENZ TED D.BOWMAN 18391 CAMABY LN 18371 CARNABY LN 18361 CARNABY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1407 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1407 159-063-22 15 3-23 159-063-24 JOHN D.&SHARON E.BORGES BR. E. ARILU FIKE GARRY K.&LYNN M.NEWMAN 18351 CARNABY LN 1250MOCKINGB 500 18321 CARNABY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1407 DALLAS TX 75247-4 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1407 159-063-25 159-063-26 159-063-27 RONALD J.WOLF JOHN W.GILMORE CAROL A.LAZAR 18311 CARNABY LN 18301 CARNABY LN 18291 CARNABY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1407 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1407 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1452 159-063-28 159-063-29 159-063-30 MOHAMMAD A.&MONOARA HAQUE MAURICE NGUYEN LEONARD R.ESPINOSA 18281 CARNABY LN 18261 CARNABY LN 6882 EVENING HILL DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1452 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1452 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2137 159-071-07 159-071-08 159-071-09 STEVEN I.PACZKO RICHARD M.EHRET JOHN G.HATALA PO BOX 2329 6291 NEWBURY DR 6301 NEWBURY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-0329 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6533 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6535 159-071-10 159-071-11 159-071-13 KENNETH W.CARPENTER DAVID W.&DANA J.MOLLICA EDWARD DANIEL PELANT 6311 NEWBURY DR 6331 NEWBURY DR 3020 EARLMAR DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6535 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6535 LOS ANGELES CA 90064-4632 159-071-14 159-072-02 159-072-03 DAVID A.&PATRICIA J.DE RUSH JEFFREY A.&PATRICIA R.MOULTON MATT A.&DONNA M.CRAMER 6361 NEWBURY DR 6302 NEWBURY DR 6312 NEWBURY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6535 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6567 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6567 159-072-04 159-072-06 159-072-08 ROBERT V.REIDER RONALD H.BERNHARD TAKANAO &ESTHER T.MATSUBARA 6332 NEWBURY DR 6352 NEWBURY DR 6372 NEWBURY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6567 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6536 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6536 159-072-09 159-072-10 159-072-11 YING T.&CHINYING WANG STANLEY D.&WILMA A.CLARK DALE B.HAGEY 14544 PEBBLEWOOD DR 6361 GLENFOX DR 6351 GLENFOX DR NORTH POTOMAC MD 20878-4311 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6523 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6523 -Al 159-072-12 159-072-13 159-072-14 BRIAN C.COWIE MICHAEL F.COOK FRANK A.URSICH 6341 GLENFOX DR 6331 GLENFOX DR 6311 GLENFOX OR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6523 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6523 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6523 159-072-15 159-072-16 159-073-08 MARK E.&SUN H.DAGGETT KEVIN C.&PAULA S.YARYAN CHESTER P.&CONSTANCE C.R.TOMSICK 6301 GLENFOX OR 6291 GLENFOX DR 6282 GLENFOX DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6523 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6521 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6522 159-073-09 159-073-10 159-073-11 GARY F.MC CONNELL CONNELL MARK L.&PRISCILLA J.BURNETT WILLIAM M.&MONICA E.PRATS 6292 GLENFOX DR 6302 GLENFOX DR 18081 WELLBROOK CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6522 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6522 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6553 159-073-12 159-073-13 159-073-14 SALLIE J.WALKER RUSSELL G.JONES JAMES A.STRINGER 18091 WELLBROOK CIR 18101 WELLBROOK CIR 18121 WELLBROOK CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6553 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6553 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6553 159-074-01 159-074-02 159-074-03 CHARLES H.BUNTEN STEPHAN P.&KERRIE A.RUBINO STEVEN D.&KAREN M.PITTS 18132 WELLBROOK CIR 18112 WELLBROOK CIR 18102 WELLBROOK CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6553 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6553 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6553 159-074-05 159-074-06 159-074-07 RONALD J.ZAWISTOWSKI ANDREAS J.&SHEILA A.SAAR JAMES M.&DIANA L.SCHELLENBERG 1009 DAISY AVE 18081 FIELDBURY LN 18091 FIELDBURY LN CARLSBAD CA 92009-4818 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6550 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6550 159-074-08 159-074-09 159-074-10 RICHARD &VIVIAN ODELL SACHA MARCROFT PATRICK CHI-KONG&LING-KIT MAY CHAN 18101 FIELDBURY LN 18111 FIELDBURY LN 18121 FIELDBURY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6550 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6550 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6550 159-074-11 159-081-01 159-081-02 JEROME K.&ANNAMARIE MANDICH MICHAEL C.&TRACEY 0.SPRINGMAN KENNETH H.BENNETT 18141 FIELDBURY LN 6971 LAWN HAVEN DR 6401 NEWBURY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6550 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2121 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6565 159-081-03 159-081-04 159-081-05 VICTORIANO &ZENAIDA AMBATA JOHN T.&SHARYL A.PAGE JOHN T.HORTON 6411 NEWBURY DR 6421 NEWBURY DR 6431 NEWBURY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6565 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6565 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6565 159-081-06 159-081-07 159-081-08 JOHN &DENISE PULLEY CRAIG &CATHERINE L.CULACIATI BRUCE H.WEST 6451 NEWBURY DR 6461 NEWBURY DR 6471 NEWBURY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6565 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6565 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6565 159-081-09 159-081-10 159-081-11 ROBERT W.&PAULA E.LILLIS WILLIAM W.HOWATT MARK A.&CHRISTIE M.CUMMINS 6481 NEWBURY DR 18012 LAKEPOINT LN 18022 LAKEPOINT LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6565 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6529 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6529 159-081-12 159-081-13 159-081-14 NOEL P.&DEANNE REMO ALBERT M.CORBETT MICHAEL F.&MADELINE C.SHERMAN 18042 LAKEPOINT LN 18052 LAKEPOINT LN 18062 LAKEPOINT LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6529 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6529 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6529 159-081-15 159-081-16 159-081-17 PETER J.JAKUBOWSKI ERIC E.SPENCER WILLIAM F.&ALICE G.PAYNE 18072 LAKEPOINT LN 18082 LAKEPOINT LN 18092 LAKEPOINT LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6529 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6529 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6529 15 �081-1,48 159-082-01 159-082-02 ERICROL LARSEN DWIGHT L.&MARJE C.ANDERSEN STEVEN DANA&SHELLEY NICHOLSON 18122 LAKEPOINT LN 18132 LAKEPOINT LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6561 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6561 159-082-03 159-082-04 159-082-05 JAMES F.&LESLEY-ANNE D.HERBOLD BART &SHERREY HOLLANDER MAXWELL J.&DENISE J.SMITH 18142 LAKEPOINT LN 18152 LAKEPOINT LN 18162 LAKEPOINT LN HUNTINGTON BEACH.CA 92647-6561 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6561 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6561 159-083-01 159-083-02 159-083-03 JAMES D.&PAULA S.JONES TIM J.&JOLIE A.WEGNER ERNEST &SANDRA KOCSIS 6382 NEWBURY DR 6402 NEWBURY DR 6412 NEWBURY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6536 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6538 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6538 159-083-04 159-083-05 159-083-06 JAMES L.&ELIZABETH C.PUTNAM KATHERINE A.NICHOLS MITCHELL &CYNTHIA DORNSIFE 6422 NEWBURY DR 6432 NEWBURY DR 6452 NEWBURY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6538 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6538 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6538 159-083-07 159-083-08 159-083-09 DAVID M.POLANCIC JOHN G.&MARY ANN HUBER MICHAEL A.&KRISTINA J.ADELMAN 6462 NEWBURY DR 2772 RICKENBACKER CT 6471 GLENFOX DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6538 OREFIELD PA 18069-2254 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6525 159-083-10 159-083-11 159-083-12 MANUEL &ELEANOR E.REYES ROBERT M.&ELAINE S.BLUM WILLIAM J.TROUNCE 6461 GLENFOX DR 6451 GLENFOX DR 6431 GLENFOX DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6525 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6525 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6525 159-083-13 159-083-14 159-083-15 PAUL D.TWEDT DANIEL P.&S.M.TRUS BECKER JUNE COAST PROPERTIES 6421 GLENFOX DR 6411 GLENFOX DR 18652 FLORIDA ST#300 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6525 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6525 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-6069 159-083-16 159-084-01 159-084-02 SUSAN L.HARRIS BRUCE ALAN&JOANNE M.FISCHER MARY C.FLEURY 6381 GLENFOX DR 18081 LAKEPOINT LN PO BOX 1312 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6523 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6528 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-1312 159-084-03 159-084-04 159-084-05 ANTHONY YTURRALDE VELDA L.KING BENSON TRUST 5196 CALIFORNIA AVE 18111 LAKEPOINT LN 18121 LAKEPOINT LN NORCO CA 91760-1616 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6528 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6528 159-084-06 159-084-07 159-084-08 BERNARD &MARY J.BENDOW RICHARD M.GARAY DIXIE L.LONG 18131 LAKEPOINT LN 18141 LAKEPOINT LN 18151 LAKEPOINT LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6528 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6528 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6528 159-084-09 159-084-10 159-084-11 ALAN J.&JOHANNA H.REID CHARLES M.&JANA LANNING RUSSELL KALANDER 18161 LAKEPOINT LN 18152 BRENTWELL CIR 18142 BRENTWELL CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6528 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6518 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6518 159-084-12 159-084-13 159-084-14 MOON FAI&CHRISTINE SIU MARK &CAROLE HOFFMAN WILLIAM B.&SANDRA G.SMALLSHAW 18132 BRENTWELL CIR 18122 BRENTWELL CIR 18112 BRENTWELL CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6518 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6518 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6518 159-084-15 159-084-16 159-084-17 ROBERT HARRISON BEAM BONNIE G.AINSWORTH DON W.&LINDA J.GRIFFITHS 18102 BRENTWELL CIR 18092 BRENTWELL CIR 18082 BRENTWELL CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6518 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6518 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6518 159-085-01 159-085-02 159-085-03 DUANE R.&DEBORAH K.HURTADO BERTIL V.BYSTROM DAVID R.&BOBBIE D.MEARS 18081 BRENTWELL CIR 18091 BRENTWELL CIR 18101 BRENTWELL CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6518 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6518 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6518 159-085-04 159-085-05 159-085-06 JUNE COAST PROPERTIES BRIAN A.WHITE VAL J.&MELISSA K.BENINCOSA 18652 FLORIDA ST#300 18121 BRENTWELL CIR 18131 BRENTWELL CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-6069 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6518 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6518 159-085-07 159-085-08 159-085-09 PHILLIP J.&KRISTEN S.SHEARER STEVE A.O'KEEFE HONG CHEOL&KYU R.KIM 18141 BRENTWELL CIR 18151 BRENTWELL CIR 18191 FIELDBURY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6518 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6518 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1051 159-085-10 159-085-11 159-085-12 JACK D.MALEY BRIAN THOMAS&SHELLY KNOWLES FRONK JERRY ROBERT JASO 18132 FIELDBURY LN 18122 FIELDBURY LN 18112 FIELDBURY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6520 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6520 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6520 159-085-13 159-085-14 159-085-15 RAYMOND J.&KAREN S.SHAW RON R.&LOUISE K.BONE WILLIAM M.&MONICA E.PRATS 18102 FIELDBURY LN 18092 FIELDBURY LN 18081 WELLBROOK Cl HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6520 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6520 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6553 159-089-01 159-201-01 159-201-04 SIGNAL COMPANIES INC GORDON BRUCE&JEANNINE M.POWERS JOSEPH J.&JANET WEISER 4343 VON KARMAN AVE 7452 TALBERT AVE 7400 TALBERT AVE NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2005 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1239 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1239 159-201-05 159-201-06 159/F. 20109 JOSEF J.&JANET WEISER ANTOINE F.KAHALE NALE 7400 ALBERT AVE 17722 SANTA MARIA ST 7T AVE HU TINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1239 FOUNTAIN VALLEY CA 92708-4326 H BEACH CA 92648-1239 159-201-10 159-201-11 15/EpH NABIL F. HALE NABIL F. HALE JONET WEISER 7412 T BERT AVE 7412 T BERT AVE 740AVE HUN NGTON BEACH CA 92648-1239 HUNT NGTON BEACH CA 92648-1239 HUBEACH CA 92648-1239 159-201-13 159-201-21 159-201-22 CON BLISS LEONARD O.LINDBORG THOMAS J.BIALEK 7403 HARRIMAN AVE 30110 CROWN VALLEY PY#PY 18202 ENTERPRISE LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1203 LAGUNA NIGUEL CA 92677-2043 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1217 159-201-24 159-201-25 159-201-26 GARY L.&JANICE L.CHANCY GARY L.&J ICE L.CHANCY BUNN BEAR LIMITED PARTNERS HIP 18242 ENTERPRISE LN 18242 EN RPRISE LN 18072 GOTHARD ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1217 HUNTI TON BEACH CA 92648-1217 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1213 159-201-27 159-201-28 159-201-29 PAUL M.&PATRICIA TAYLOR GORDON L.BAIR MFV 7391 VINCENT CIR 7421 VINCENT CIR 27451 LOS ALTOS#210 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1246 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1246 MISSION VIEJO CA 92691-6331 159-201-30 159-201-31 159-201-32 ROCKY BEACH PROPERTIES LTD THOMAS J.BIALEK VINCENT ENTERPRISES 70400 KINIKIN RD 18202 ENTERPRISE LN 7392 VINCENT CIR MONTROSE CO 81401-7701 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1217 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1246 159-201-33 159-201-34 159-201-36 BUNN BEAR LTD PARTNERSHIP S R W ENTERPRISES EUGENE J.DUCHENE 16452 BARDSTABLE CIR PO BOX 18388 3682 AQUARIUS DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-2114 ANAHEIM CA 92817-8388 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-2505 159-201-37 159-/AQARIUS 159-201-39 EUGENE J.DUCHENE EUGCHENE WALID &NABIL FARID KAHALE 3682 AQUARIUS DR 3682 DR 8975 SWORDFISH AV HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-2505 HUNBEACH CA 92649-2505 FOUNTAIN VALLEY CA 92708-5037 159-202-03 159-202-04 159-202-05 BIALEK SUSAN TRUST ROBERT D.HOXSIE FIDENCIO &VIVIAN O.ALVAREZ PO BOX 3368 6762 JARDINES DR 18262 PAMMY LN TUSTIN CA 92781-3368 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6628 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1432 159-211-01 159-211-03 159-211-08 ELLO ENTERPRISE J.A.HAZE R&M ASSOCIATES PARTNERSH IP 28855 VIA VENEZIA 18302 GOTHARD ST MALIBU CA 90265-4061 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1227 159-211-10 159-211-11 15 11-12 RAYMOND N.GALVIN WILLIAM F.BEESEMEYER WILLIAM F. ESEMEYER 19565 WOODLANDS LN 3835 BIRCH ST 3835 BIRCH ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-5526 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2616 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2616 159-211-13 159-211-14 159-211-15 TOPEFA OF NEW JERSEY INC GOTHARD PROPERTIES SAMUEL F.HEYMAN 1750 BRIELLE AVENUE#B-2 18292 GOTHARD ST 100 LAUREL ST OCEAN NJ 77123-948 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1225 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94118-2025 159-211-16 159-212-02 159-212-04 SAMUEL F.HEYMAN CEDRIC A.WHITE FREDERICK G.MUESEGAES 100 LAUREL ST 526 PEBBLE BEACH PL 7332 SIENA AV SAN FRANCISCO CA 94118-2025 FULLERTON CA 92835-2728 WESTMINSTER CA 92683-6131 159-212-05 159-212-07 159-212-08 JOHN R.LEPAK ENVIRONMENTAL DEVELOPERS LARRY H.STRASBAUGH 29061 RIDGEVIEW DR 5160 CAMPUS DR 825 BUCKLEY RD LAGUNA NIGUEL CA 92677-1625 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-2101 SAN LUIS OBISPO CA 93401-8130 159-212-09 159-212-10 159-212-11 ENVIRO EN DEVELOPERS ENVI/RTBEACCHCA92660-2101 L DEVELOPERS WALTER R.COYLE 5160 C PUS DR 5160 R 9091 KAHULUI DR NEW RT BEACH CA 92660-2101 N HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-7818 159-212-12 159-252-12 159-252-13 OLGA TR-OF EXEMPT[ON JENKINS SERGIO E.&ROSA E.QUINTANAR STEVEN L.&KAREN D.HAMSTROM 9116 MCBRIDE RIVER AVE 18191 LEAF CIR 18185 LEAF CIR FOUNTAIN VALLEY CA 92708-6439 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1060 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1060 159-252-14 159-252-15 159-252-16 DAVE L.&KAREN L.WOOTEN CARL R.&KAREN L.ZAPTIFF AVISHAI &LISA J.F.HERSKOVITZ 18181 LEAF CIR 18182 LEAF CIR 18192 LEAF CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1060 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1060 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1060 159-252-17 159-252-18 159-252-19 WALTER R.&SHERRY D.SMITH GARY &CARLA HEGENBART PATEL TRUST 18202 LEAF CIR 18206 LEAF CIR 18212 LEAF CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1060 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1060 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1060 159-252-20 159-252-21 159-252-22 JAMES &CAROLYN KOCH GARY R.&PAGE GERMAIN DINA BRAENDLE 6301 PACEMONT DR 6311 PACEMONT DR 18261 FIELDBURY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1092 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1092 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1053 159-252-23 159-252-24 159-252-25 JAMES J.&EVA S.ELSER JAMES A.&JUDITH L.WHITE CHARLES M.&JANINE A.BELL 18251 FIELDBURY LN 18241 FIELDBURY LN 18231 FIELDBURY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1053 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1053 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1053 159-252-26 159-252-27 159-252-28 STEPHEN CHAING PA LIU GERALD L.&ELIZABETH A.JONES HONG CHEOL&KYU R.KIM 18211 FIELDBURY LN 18201 FIELDBURY LN 18191 FIELDBURY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1053 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1053 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1051 159-253-01 159-253-02 159-253-03 JASON SUNG KIM WILLIAM ALAN&JAN G.DRUMMOND RICHARD S.&VIRGINIA MARCHANT 6381 TALEGATE DR 6391 TALEGATE DR 6401 TALEGATE DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1079 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1079 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1081 159-253-04 159-254-01 159-254-02 THOMAS B.BURKET PATRICK O.PIERCE ALAN &KELLY HURST 6411 TALEGATE DR 18312 FIELDBURY LN 18302 FIELDBURY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1081 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1054 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1054 159-254-03 159-254-04 159-254-05 STEVE &BETTY KELEPECZ IRENE E.GUARDERAS THOMAS GREER 18292 FIELDBURY LN 18282 FIELDBURY LN 18272 FIELDBURY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1052 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1052 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1052 159-254-06 159-254-07 159-254-08 MICHAEL D.&CAROLYN M.HAWKINS DAVID R.&C.LYN SCOTT ROBERT MICHOWSKI 18262 FIELDBURY LN 18252 FIELDBURY LN 18242 FIELDBURY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1052 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1052 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1052 159-254-09 159-254-10 159-254-11 JOSEPH L.&GINA P.NOTRICA JAY B.&ROSEMARY ZAIDENBERG DANIEL J.&LISA K.MC DONALD 6372 TALEGATE DR 6382 TALEGATE DR 6392 TALEGATE DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1078 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1078 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1078 159-255-09 159-255-10 159-255-11 HEIDI DE BRITTON CHUL YUNG&HAJA JUNG AMADOR DINO L&C TRUST 6302 PACEMONT DR 18291 FIELDBURY LN 918 CAMINO DE LA REINA#5 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1091 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1040 SAN DIEGO CA 92108-3257 159-255-12 159-255-13 159-301-01 THEO &VIRGINIA T.ROLA THOMAS A.&MELODY A.BUKSA ARLENE A.TR#A GALLAGHER 18311 FIELDBURY LN 6271 MOONFIELD DR 5131 LOYOLAAV HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1040 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1039 WESTMINSTER CA 92683-2722 159-301-02 159-301-03 159-301-04 RICHARD G.MARCZ KELLY A.DUNAGAN PRESSURE RESEARCH UNDER 8 CHESTERFIELD RD 18092 REDONDO CIR 30872 S COAST HY#175 ROLLING HILLS CA 90274-5222 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1326 LAGUNA BEACH CA 92651-8134 159-302-01 159-302-02 159-302-03 JOHANN ASSIGAL JOHAN ASSIGAL LAWRENCE J.O'BRIEN 16530 DAISY AVE 1653 DAISY AVE 31161 DORAL PL FOUNTAIN VALLEY CA 92708-2207 F NTAIN VALLEY CA 92708-2207 LAGUNA NIGUEL CA 92677-2435 159-302-04 159-302-05 159-302-06 PACIFIC PARK LLC P/ECA K LLC ANNA H.HIGMAN 2082 BUSINESS CENTER DR#2 2SS CENTER DR#2 PO BOX 545 IRVINE CA 92612-1129 I612-1129 ROSEMEAD CA 91770-0545 159-302-07 159-351-21 159-351-22 TRIPLE H PROPERTIES THOMAS R.&BARBARA J.ADAMS RICHARD SENA&REBECCA GALE FLORE; PO BOX Olb I 1 6531 POLO CIR 6551 POLO CIR ROSEMEAD CA 91770-0545 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1543 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1543 159-351-23 159-351-24 159-351-25 GREGORY LIND&REBECCA ANN STRAYER WILLIAM D.&SHARON L.BRIGHAM CRAIG V.&KELLY J.TOWERS 6571 POLO CIR 6581 POLO CIR 6601 POLO CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1543 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1543 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1544 159-351-26 159-351-27 159-351-28 PUNDARI K.&SUNDARI CHEMITIGANTI KENDALL BERN ANDERSEN GOVINDBHAI M.&GAJRABEN G.PATEL 6621 POLO CIR 6622 POLO CIR 8791 GARDEN GROVE BLVD HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1544 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1542 GARDEN GROVE CA 92844-1211 159-351-29 159-351 30 159-351-31 CURTIS J.&JOANNE M.CHIVERS LC DI ON LAURENCE KUTINSKY 6582 POLO CIR 6552 POLO CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1542 HUN INGTON BEACH CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1542 159-351-32 159-351-33 159-351- 4 SAMUEL F.&WANDA L.SHON PARK#15 CENTRAL PA #15 CENTRAL 10602 HUMBOLT ST 505 PARK AVE 50 PARK AVE LOS ALAMITOS CA 90720-2448 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 N PORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 159-3 1-35 159- 51-36 159-351-37 PARK#1 CENTRAL PARK 15 CENTRAL EDWARDS-CENTRAL PARK HOMEO WNER 505 PARK VE 505 PA K AVE 99PARK AVE NEWPORT EACH CA 92662-1000 NEWP T BEACH CA 92662-1000 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 159-352-01 159-352-02 159-352-03 ALEX MERUELO BRADLEY D.&ROBIN SMITH SALVATOR W.&BARBARA F.CRACCHIOLC 6651 SHIRE CIR 19162 QUIETSANDS CIR 6691 SHIRE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1500 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2111 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1500 159-352-04 159-352-05 159-352-06 MICHAEL A.&SANDRA F.DAVIS COURTNEY DUBAR GERALD L.&PATRICIA M.CHAPMAN 6711 SHIRE CIR 6741 SHIRE CIR 6742 SHIRE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1500 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1500 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1500 159-352-07 159-352-08 159-352-09 GORDON M.WATSON JOHN D.&JAN MACKEY VINCENT CHEE KEI&JOYCE L.F.ENG 6732 SHIRE CIR 6712 SHIRE CIR 6692 SHIRE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1500 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1500 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1500 159-352-10 159-352-11 159-352-24 JAMES R.&ELISE LEANNE MOWREY NOLL N.&KARIN EASTER GURWELL EDWARDS-LINDBORG-DAH 6672 SHIRE CIR 6652 SHIRE CIR 30110 CROWN VALLEY PY#PY HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1500 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1500 LAGUNA NIGUEL CA 92677-2043 159-352-25 159-352-26 159-361-01 . VIEW HOMEOWNERS AS SN COUNTRY DAVID D.DAHL MICHAEL N.MAXWELL 17205 PACIFIC COAST HWY 505 PARK AVE 7351 AUTOPARK DR SUNSET BEACH CA 90742 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1247 159-361-02 159-361-03 159-361-04 FARD HOSSEI AMAVANDI HAYRIGH SAHAKIAN DOWNEY TRUST 42 ARBOL 7321 AUTOPARK DR 31831 GREENS PT IRVINE 92612-2626. HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1248 LAGUNA NIGUEL CA 92677-2901 159-361-05 159-361-06 159-361-07 JAMES R.&MONICA L.BROUSSARD MAX F.&KATHLEEN K.LIPPKA PETERSON TRUST 7282 AUTOPARK DR 9161 KAHULUI DR 6621 SILVERSPUR LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1200 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-7820 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1521 159-361-08 159-361-09 159-361-10 WILLIAM J.GARRITY CONSTANCE A.TR H.ENDRIC HENDRICKS GOTHARD PACIFIC LLC 6921 LAURELTON AVE 2720 LA PANZA RD 610 NEWPORT CENTER DR#700 GARDEN GROVE CA 92845-1420 CRESTON CA 93432-9761 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-6498 159/INGTON 361 159-362-01 159-362-02 CITGTON BEACH SHAMROCK PROPERTIES III STEVE E.&DARLENE PATTON PO 7330 LINCOLN WAY 7711 EVEREST CIR HUEACH CA 92648-0190 GARDEN GROVE CA 92841-1427 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-3016 159-362-03 159-362-04 159-362-05 WILLIAM D.&DELORES A.JACOBS ANNLYNN CORP CHARLES R.&LYNN E.RICHEY 7322 AUTOPARK OR PO BOX 2242 2313 WEATHERFORD CT HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1200 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-0242 CLAREMONT CA 91711-2227 159-362-06 159-371-01 159-371-02 JAMES R.&MONICA L.BROUSSARD MICHAEL S.SUMMERS SANG &KYOUNG CHUNG 7282 AUTOPARK DR 6861 HITCHINGPOST CIR 6851 HITCHINGPOST CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1200 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1531 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1531 159-371-03 159-371-04 159-371-05 VALERIE K.SCHURMAN PHILIP D.&MARILYN B.LAYTON GILDERMAN TRUST 6841 HITCHINGPOST CIR 6821 HITCHINGPOST CIR 6822 HITCHINGPOST CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1531 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1531 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1530 159-371-06 159-371-07 159-371-08 GARY M.&FRANCES T.OKURA JEROME IRWIN STILLMAN WARREN E.HOLTHAUS 6842 HITCHINGPOST CIR 6852 HITCHINGPOST CIR 6862 HITCHINGPOST CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1530 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1530 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1530 159-371-09 159-371-10 159-371-11 CHAO-MING &WEI-LUEN LU GREGORY G.&DONNA R.HIRN HARVEY B.DORREN 6861 CORRAL CIR 6851 CORRAL CIR 6841 CORRAL CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1534 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1534 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1534 159-371-12 159-371-13 159-371-14 RICHARD &KATHLEEN FIFIELD MICHAEL R.CULLY RANDALL C.GALL 6821 CORRAL CIR 6826 CORRAL CIR 6846 CORRAL CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1534 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1533 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1533 159-371-15 159-371-16 159-3>AVE RONALD 1.&EMILY A.BRINDLE ELLIS CENTRAL PARK HOMEOWN ERS ASSN ELLIS ARK HOMEOWN ERS ASS 18851 GOLDENWEST ST 505 PARK AVE 505 PAHUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1511 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 NEWP CA 662-1000 159-371-18 159-371-19 159-371-20 ELLIS CENTRACPAR RSA LLIS CENTRAL rRK HOMEOW AS # K-HOMEOWN-ERS ASS 505 PAR 505 PARK AVE 505 PARK AVE NEWP�T BEACH CA 92662-1000 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 159-371-21 / 159-381-01 159-381-02 ELLIS CE RAL PARK HOMEOWN ERS ASSN CHRIS &LINDA LEICHT AARON &SHER PAI 505 P K AVE 6811 HITCHINGPOST CIR 6781 HITCHINGPOST CIR N PORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1531 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1529 159-381-03 159-381-04 159-381-05 JEFFREY V.&BELINDA DAVIS WALLY A.&DEBORAH L.AL-ASEER JEFFREY C.JOY 6761 HITCHINGPOST CIR 6762 HITCHINGPOST CIR 6772 HITCHINGPOST CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1529 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1529 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1529 159-381-06 159-381-07 159-381-08 LORRAINE A.FORAN MACHADO R R SR&R M TRUST LAWRENCE JOHN GEISSE 6792 HITCHINGPOST CIR 6812 HITCHINGPOST CIR 6811 CORRAL CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1529 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1530 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1534 159-381-09 159-381-10 159-381-11 SUNG MO&MYUNG S.HONG THOMAS MARK BACON ALEX KUTAS 6791 CORRAL CIR 6771 CORRAL CIR 6761 CORRAL CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1532 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1532 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1532 159-381-12 159-381-13 159-381-14 TIMOTHY J.&GENA RYAN ALBERTO A.&CYNTIA C.MONES MONES ALAN A.&NORMA D.ANKERSTAR 6762 CORRAL CIR 6772 CORRAL CIR 6792 CORRAL CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1532 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1532 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1532 159-381-15 159-381-16 159-381-17 PAUL L.KOLLAR ELLIS ENTRAL PARK HOMEOWNERS AWN ELLIS CE, L7�.RAL PARK HOMEOWN ERS ASS 6812 CORRAL CIR 505 ARK AVE 505 PA�KNAVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1533 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 N71116RT BEACH CA 92662-1000 159-381-18 159-381-19 159-381-20 ELLIS CEN 9FLNIIM€91PM1-Ef2S-f4SSii---- ELLIS CENT WN ERS ASSN L PARK HOMEOWN ERS ASS 505 PARK AVE 505 PARK AVE 505 PARK AVE NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 159-391-05 159-391-06 159-391-07 PARK#8 CENTRAL PARK CENTRAL THOMAS C.PETERSON 505 PARK AVE 505 ARK AVE 6621 SILVERSPUR LN NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 N ORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1521 159-391-08 159-391-09 159-391-10 SHIRMARD &SHIRIN FARAHMAND EDWARD D.LAURANCE THEODORE G.&CHERYL L.LASKER 6601 SILVERSPUR LN 6581 SILVERSPUR LN 6571 SILVERSPUR LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1521 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1516 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1516 159-391-11 159-391-12 159-391-13 ERIC RESCIGNO DENNIS F.&KATHLEEN D.D'AMBRA KEVIN P.&PAULETTE W.CONLISK 6551 SILVERSPUR LN 6541 SILVERSPUR LN 6531 SILVERSPUR LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1516 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1516 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1516 159-391-14 159-391-15 159-391-21 AMARAL TRUST EDWAR -CENTRAL PARK HOMEOWNERS PARK#8 NTRAL 6525 SILVERSPUR LN K AVE 505 P AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1516 NEW ORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 N ORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 159-391-22 159-391-2 159-391-29 EDW DS-CENTRAL PARK HOMEO WNERS PARK CENTRAL PARK ONE TWO CENTRAL ARK AVE 505 P RK AVE 505 PARK AVE N T BEACH CA 92662-1000 N ORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 159-391-30 159-391-31 159-391-32 TIMOTHY THIEN&KHANH VAN BUI MORDEHAI ZADIK MARTIN MENICHIELLO 6621 HORSESHOE LN 6601 HORSESHOE LN 6591 HORSESHOE LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1525 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1525 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1525 159-391-33 159-391-34 159-391-3 ROCCANOVA TRUST STEPHEN P.&COLLEEN COATES ISRAEL EDW DS-CENTRAL PARK HOMED WNER 65711 HORSESHOE LN 6561 HORSESHOE LN ARK AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1525 PORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 159-391-36 159-391 37 159-391-38 RONALD IRVING&EMILY ANN BRINDLE PARK O E TWO CENTRAL RONALD &STEPHANIE JOAN SCHUM BOS 6521 SILVERSPUR LN 505 PAR AVE 6515 SILVERSPUR LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1516 NEWPO T BEACH CA 92662-1000 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1516 159-391- 159-391-40 159-391-41 EDWARDS-CE RAL PARK HOMEO WNERS CLINTON G.GERLACH JACK &BARBARA FALFAS 99NARK AVE 701 OCEAN AVENUE#203 6542 HORSESHOE LN NEWPORT BEAC CA 92662-1000 SANTA MONICA CA 90402-2651 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1523 159-391-42 159-391-43 159-391-44 CORY &KATHERINE MEREDITH DANIEL A.AGAJANIAN PARK ONE 0 CENTRAL 6552 HORSESHOE LN 6572 HORSESHOE LN 505 PARK A E HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1523 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1523 NEWPORT EACH CA 92662-1000 159-391-45 159-391-46 159-391-47 JAMES D.&KATHRYN M.LEO HOWARD &SUZANNE ROSEN PARK E TWO CENTRAL 6592 HORSESHOE LN 6622 HORSESHOE LN 505 P RK AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1523 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1523 N ORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 159-391-48 159-391-49 159-391-50 PARK#12 CENTRAL PARK#8 ENTRAL PARK ONE O CENTRAL 505 PARK AVE 505 PAR AVE 505 PARKA E NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 NEWPO BEACH CA 92662-1000 NEWPORT EACH CA 92662-1000 159-391-51 159-39 -52 159-391-53 PARK ONE TWO CENTRAL PARK# CENTRAL RICHARD C.DAVIS 505 PARK AVE 505 PA AVE 6562 SILVERSPUR LN NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 NEWPO T BEACH CA 92662-1000 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1503 159-391-54 159-391-55 159-391-56 LISA A.MAHDAD WALTER J.&CYNTHIA R.HEKIMIAN FISLER BARBARA M TRUST 6572 SILVERSPUR LN 6592 SILVERSOPUR DR 6612 SILVERSPUR LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1503 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1503 159-391-57 159-392-01 159-392-02 JOHN M.LOWN DANIEL &INGRID LIAO DECATUR DILDAY 6622 SILVERSPUR LN 18622 QUARTERHORSE LN 18612 QUARTERHORSE LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1503 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1502 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1502 159-392-03 159-392-04 159-392-05 DAVID &STEPHANIE BUCKALEW KATRINA H.NGUYEN RONALD M.&JANICE M.MITTERMEIER 18602 QUARTERHORSE LN 6652 CARRIAGE CIR 6662 CARRIAGE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1502 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1501 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1501 159-392-06 159-392-07 159-392-08 MICHAEL T.&ELIZABETH ANNE MC CALL GOPAL REDDY YETURU TALMADGE RAY RACHELS 6672 CARRIAGE CIR 6682 CARRIAGE CIR 6692 CARRIAGE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1501 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1501 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1501 4 159-392-09 159-392-10 159-392-11 ALLEN &SANDRA REDMAN GUNTER WETZEL NGUYEN-HUU &THIEN TRANG T.NGUYE 6681 CARRIAGE CIR 6671 CARRIAGE CIR 6661 CARRIAGE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1501 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1501 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1501 159-392-12 159-392-13 159-392-14 DEAN A.BARLOW HUNTINGTON BEACH ESTATES H HUNTING N BEACH ESTATES H 6651 CARRIAGE CIR !�MRWB �RANS AVE R RANS AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1501 HAWTHORNE CA 90250-1502 HA HORNE CA 90250-1502 159-392-15 159-392-16 159-393-02 HU G�TO�N BEACH ESTATES H HUNTINGTO CH ESTATES H CITY E1R TbON BEACH Q �RANS AVE QlmFt RANS AVE 000 MAIN ST H WTHORNE CA 90250-1502 HAWT RNE CA 90250-1502 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 159-393-03 / 159-393-05 159-393-06 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH MILTON H.MAROW MILTON H. ROW 2000 S7 864 N BUNDY DR 864 N�', NDY DR WXtINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 LOS ANGELES CA 90049-1507 L09ANGELES CA 90049-1507 159-393-07 �_ 159-393-08 159-393-09 CITY OF INGTON BEACH MILTON H.MAROW �864 TON H. OW AIN ST 864 N BNB 1' DY DR UNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 LOS ANGELES CA 90049-1507 ANGELES CA 90049-1507 159-393-10 159-393-11 159/�DY CITY O HUNTINGTON BEACH MILTON AROW MILTAROW 2000�dIAIN ST 864 N NDY DR 864 DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2702 LOS A GELES CA 90049-1507 LOS ANGELES CA 90049-1507 159-393-14 159-393-15 159 393 6 H.A.EST LANG HAROLD C.MORTON MILT H.MAROW PO BOX 5255 6741 SHIRE CIR 864 BUNDY DR CHULA VISTA CA 91912-5255 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1500 LOS ANGELES CA 90049-1507 159-393-17 159-393-18 159-393-19 HEBER T.HANKS DANIEL &INGRID LIAO MARGARET LINDSEY 80 S LAKE AVE#823 18622 QUARTERHORSE LN 10081 BEVERLY DR PASADENA CA 91101-2636 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1502 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-5424 159-393- 159-393-22 159-393-2 MILTON .MAROW T.COURT EY DUBAR T.COU NEY DUBAR 864 N B NDY DR 6741 SHI E CIR 6741 S IRE CIR LOS A GELES CA 90049-1507 HUNTI TON BEACH CA 92648-1500 HUNTI GTON BEACH CA 92648-1500 159-393- 159-393-2 159-393-27 MILTON .MAROW MILTON .MAROW MILTON H.M OW 864 N B NDY DR 864 N NDY DR 864 N BUND DR LOS A ELES CA 90049-1507 LOS GELES CA 90049-1507 LOS ANGE S CA 90049-1507 159-393-29 159-393-30 159-393-31 HUGO J.ENENBACH COURTNE DUBAR T.COURTLY DUBAR PO BOX 152 6741 SHIR CIR 6741 SHIR CIR POCATELLO ID 83201 HUNTING ON BEACH CA 92648-1500 HUNTINGT N BEACH CA 92648-1500 159-393- 159-393-3 159-393-36 MILTON .MAROW MILTON H MAROW MILTON HJDD( OW 864 N B NDY DR 864 N BU DY DR 864 N BUR LOS A ELES CA 90049-1507 LOS ANG LES CA 90049-1507 LOS ANGA 90049-1507 159-39 -37 159-393-3 159-393 2 MILTO H.MAROW MILTON H. AROW MILTON .MAROW 864 N B NDY DR 864 N BLIND DR 864 N B NDY DR LOS AN ELES CA 90049-1507 LOS ANGEL S CA 90049-1507 LOS AN LES CA 90049-1507 159-39 -43 159-393-44 159- 3-45 MILTON .MAROW MICHAEL A.&SANDRA F.DAVIS MICHA L &SANDRA DAVIS 864 N BU Y DR 6711 SHIRE CIR 6711 SH E CI LOS ANGEL S CA 90049-1507 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1500 HUNTIN ON BEACH CA 92648-1500 159-393 159-393-4 159-393-51 MICHA L &SANDRA DAVIS MILTO H.MAROW MILTON H. ROW 6711 HIRE CI 864 N UNDY DR 864 N BU Y DR HU INGTON BEACH CA 92648-1500. LOS ANGELES CA 90049-1507 LOS GELES CA 90049-1507 159-393/H. ROW 159-393-53 159-393-54 MILTON TIMOTHY J.&GENA RYAN TIMOT J.&GENA RYAN 864 N BU 6762 CORRAL CIR 6762 RRAL CIR LOS AA 90049-1507 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1532 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1532 159-VSHE 159 1-01 159-411-02 T.CO DUBAR DAVE &JIL WIGNEY JUNG W.KIM 6741 R 15051 SUSS IR 6841 DERBY CIR HUN BEACH CA 92648-1500 HUNTINGTON B CH CA 92647-2724 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1505 159-411-03 159-411-04 159-411-05 VIRON KONSTANTINIDIS GARY A.&ROBIN A.HYBL JOSEPH B.&FELICIA YEN-CHENG YOUNG 6831 DERBY CIR 6811 DERBY CIR PO BOX 1067 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1505 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1505 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-1067 159-411-06 159-411-07 159-4 -08 DOROTHY T.COURT BARTON A KUBELKA DDS INC ANTHONY PASCOE 6781 DERBY CIR 10951 CHESTNUT ST 17221 JULIP L HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1505 LOS ALAMITOS CA 90720-2327 HUNTINGTON B CH CA 92647-5623 159-411-09 159-411-10 159-411-11 RONALD K.MARKS ARNOLD &THERESE BRENDER JAY B.&LYNNE B.DAVIS 6752 DERBY CIR 6772 DERBY CIR 6782 DERBY CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1506 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1506 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1506 159411-12 159-411-13 159-411-14 WAYNE M.&VICKI L.SMITH WAYNE &RACHEL LEADER GELSO &MARIA T.DISPALATRO 6772 HITCHINGPOST CIR 101 RAINBOW DR#4410 18691 JOCKEY CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1529 LIVINGSTON TX 77351-9340 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1507 159-411-15 159-411-16 159-411-17 JAMES D. R.RYE JUNG-CHOU CHANG HOWARD T.&JANE S.YATA 9488 HONEYSU E AVE 18721 JOCKEY CIR 18731 JOCKEY CIR FOUNTAIN VALLEY C 2708-1407 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1507 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1507 159411-18 159-411-19 159411-20 MAHVASH KEYVANAZAR CHRISTIANO TRUST DAVID R.&CANDACE J.MELIN 9594 NIGHTINGALE AVE 18752 JOCKEY CIR 18742 JOCKEY CIR FOUNTAIN VALLEY CA 92708-7233 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1508 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1508 159-411-21 159-411-22 159-411-23 PATRICK B.&JOYCE CAROLYN ROCHE HARTMAN TRUST RAYMOND C.&ROWENA C.WANG 11254 JAMAICA ST 18722 JOCKEY CIR 18712 JOCKEY CIR CYPRESS CA 90630-5316 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1508 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1508 159-411-24 159-411-25 159411-26 JERRY H.PABBRUWEE CHRISTOPHER LEE&VANESSA DEE MC THOMAS J.&J.(TE WATK►NSON 18702 JOCKEY CIR YJOCKEY CIR 18682 JOCKEY CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1508 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1508 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1508 159-411-27 159 11-28 159 11-29 THANH VAN&MAI PHUONG TRAN ELLIS- ENTRAL PARK#9 HOME OWNERS ELLIS CE TRAL PARK#9 HOME OWNERS 18662 JOCKEY CIR#CR lZ3AGA E AVE#B 49AGATE V y E#B HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1508 NEWPOR EACH CA 92662-1001 NEWPORT B H CA 92662-1001 159-411-30 159-411-31 159-411-32 ELLIS C L PARK#9 HOME OWNERS ELLIS CENTRAL PARK#9 HOME OWNERS ELLIS CENTRAL PARK#9 HOME OWNERS f2EPAGATE AVE#B AVE#B NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1001 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1001 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1001 159412-01 159-4 2-02 159412-03 DWAYNE &CRYSTAL FUHRMAN PARK#9 ENTRAL PARK#9 CENTRAL /7 75(0 SAM PSo J Ln, 505 PARK A 505 PARK AVE HJN�Ingfvn f�Pgc� C4 .9Z(CL)S NEWPORT B CH CA 92662-1000 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92662-1000 165-021-01 165-021-02 165-021-03 CHARLES F.&ISABEL C.RAINWATER RONALD B.&MARGARET A.LEAR JAMES G.LAROS 17511 VIA ESPANA LN 17521 VIA ESPANA LN 17531 VIA ESPANA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6684 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6684 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6600 165-021-04 165-021-05 165-021-06 PAUL R.MARANIAN BENJAMIN M.MORIMOTO CECIL JOHN&BARBARA FOLMAR 17541 VIA ESPANA LN 6851 VIA ANGELINA DR 6841 VIA ANGELINA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6600 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6683 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6683 165-021-07 165-021-08 165-021-11 LENHARD P.PRESZLER WILLIAM F.HALL MARY ALICE IRWIN EVANS 6831 VIA ANGELINA DR 6811 VIA ANGELINA DR 6791 VIA ANGELINA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6683 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6683 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6661 165-021-12 165-021-13 165-021-14 ROBERT A.KUEHNL DONALD K.GENET RUSSELL R.&ROCHELLE C.TURNER 6761 VIA ANGELINA OR 6751 VIA ANGELINA DR 6731 VIA ANGELINA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6661 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6661 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6661 165-021-15 165-021-16 165-021-17 GERALD S.FRIED JAMES A.&KAREN L.KISIAH ELAINE A.ROTH 6732 CRISTA PALMA OR 6752 CRISTA PALMA DR 6772 CRISTA PALMA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6621 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6621 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6621 165-021-18 165-021-19 165-021-21 STEVEN D.&JANICE H.BOCHMAN EDDIE &S.JO FALZON RONALD D.KING 6782 CRISTA PALMA DR 6792 CRISTA PALMA OR 6822 CRISTA PALMA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6621 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6621 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6623 165-021-22 165-021-23 165-021-24 RICHARD N.CRANDALL LAWRENCE C.EISELE SALVATORE J.&MARY CUMELLA 6832 CRISTA PALMA DR 6831 CRISTA PALMA DR 6821 CRISTA PALMA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6623 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6622 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6622 165-021-25 165-021-26 165-021-27 ROSERT A.KUEHN ARTHUR S.TAKIDO STEVEN MICHAEL COLACCHIO 6801 CRISTA PALMA DR 6791 CRISTA PALMA DR 6781 CRISTA PALMA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6622 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6620 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6620 165-021-28 165-021-29 165-021-30 STEVEN A.&MARY E.MELINE ANDERSON TRUST BOWEN TRUST 6761 CRISTA PALMA DR 6751 CRISTA PALMA DR 6731 CRISTA PALMA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6620 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6620 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6620 165-021-31 165-021-33 165-021-35 RAYFORD W.WILLIAMS HENRI E.FRONT MARY ALICE IRWIN EVANS 6711 CRISTA PALMA DR 6801 VIA ANGELINA DR 6791 VIA ANGELINA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6620 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6683 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6661 165-021-36 165-021-37 165-022-01 JANICE K.CUMPTON EDDIE &S.JO FALZON BRIAN F.&MELANIE L.REILLY 6802 CRISTA PALMA DR 6792 CRISTA PALMA DR 6872 VIA ANGELINA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6623 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6621 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6682 165-022-02 165-022-03 165-022-04 JAMES W.CAMPBELL DONALD J.KEELEY SALVATORE J.DIFRANCIA 6862 VIA ANGELINA OR 6852 VIA ANGELINA DR 6842 VIA ANGELINA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6682 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6682 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6682 165-022-05 165-022-06 165-022-08 GEORGE MASSAS OKERMAN TRUST ROBERT S.KIRKSEY 6832 VIA ANGELINA DR 6812 VIA ANGELINA DR 6792 VIA ANGELINA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6682 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6682 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6662 165-022-09 165-022-10 165-022-11 SCOTT E.&MARY ELISSIA ROBINSON GREGORY S.BROWN MICHAEL J.&KATHRYN L.WEBER 6782 VIA ANGELINA DR 6762 VIA ANGELINA DR 6752 VIA ANGELINA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6662 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6662 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6662 165-022-12 165-022-13 165-022-14 GLENN WILLARD KIMMEL KAREN A.CASS STEPHEN G.&MARY P.KLUNK 6732 VIA ANGELINA DR 6731 VISTA DEL SOL DR PO BOX 1102 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6662 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6651 LOS ALAMITOS CA 90720-1102 165-022-15 165-022-16 165-022-17 ROBERT C.&LINDA L.SCHWANZ BRADLEY &RONNY FISHER JAN U.STOLZENBURG 6761 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6781 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6791 VISTA DEL SOL DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6651 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6651 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6651 165-022-18 165-022-19 165-022-20 SCOTT A.&ANNE L.MORTON CURTIS J.DAVIS WINONA S.ABBOTT 6801 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6811 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6831 VISTA DEL SOL DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA.92647-6685 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6685 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6685 165-022-21 165-022-22 165-022-23 MAURICE A.JESSNER FRANCIS E.RAINS EDWARD B.LANGER 6841 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6851 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6861 VISTA DEL SOL DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6685 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6653 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6653 165-022-24 165-023-01 165-023-02 MICHAEL &WENDY C.SCHNEIDER LAURENCE J.STUPPY JAMES KEVIN&SHEILA K.HOLLIDAY 6871 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6872 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6862 VISTA DEL SOL DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6653 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6654 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6654 165-023-03 165-023-04 165-023-05 YOLANDA A.BATESON JAMES E.&CYNTHIA C.MANGHAM ILENE MARIE WOOD 6852 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6842 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6832 VISTA DEL SOL DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6654 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6654 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6654 165-023-06 165-023-07 165-023-08 ROBERT ALEXAN STRANGE RAYMOND T.&DARLENE A.BAXTER GEORGE &CAROLEE FOCHT 6812 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6802 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6792 VISTA DEL SOL DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6654 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6654 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6652 165-023-09 165-023-10 165-023-11 PAULINE ELIZAB JUDSON JAY HOON CHUNG ROBERT P.MARSOUN 6782 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6762 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6752 VISTA DEL SOL DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6652 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6652 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6652 165-023-12 165-023-13 165-023-14 RONALD L.&LAUREL A.GRAICHEN JOANNA M.THUVE STUART A.&URSULA K.SOUDERS 10452 BRIGHTWOOD DR 6731 VIA CARONA DR 6751 VIA CARONA DR SANTA ANA CA 92705-1591 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6645 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6645 165-023-15 165-023-16 165-023-17 ARMOND D.TAYLOR KRSTO &SVETLANA VUKOJE GERALD J.SOUZA 6761 VIA CARONA DR 6781 VIA CARONA DR 22361 WALLINGFORD LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6645 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6645 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-8453 165-023-18 165-023-19 165-023-20 OLDAR TRUST CLAUDETTE Y.BELYEA BEVERLY ANNE MC KENZIE 6801 VIA CARONA DR 6811 VIA CARONA DR PO BOX 2435 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6647 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6647 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-0435 165-023-22 165-023-23 165-023-24 GRACE MELLO DOUGLAS A.WILSON STEVEN &JUDITH B.ROEMER 6851 VIA CARONA DR 6861 VIA CARONA DR 6871 VIA CARONA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6647 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6686 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6686 165-024-01 165-024-02 165-024-03 JO PEDROJETTI WARREN &TERRY L.DUFFY KENNETH D.TRESTER 6872 VIA CARONA DR 6862 VIA CARONA DR 6852 VIA CARONA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 9264776648 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6648 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6648 165-024-04 165-024-05 165-024-06 NICHOLAS B.&CARLA ESPINOSA V.J.&STACY A.TYRA PHILIP R.&JULIE E.GUITE 6842 VIA CARONA DR 6832 VIA CARONA DR 6812 VIA CARONA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6648 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6648 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6648 165-024-07 165-024-08 155-024-09 PATRICK J.&KIM I.GIBBS CHERYL Y.KENDRON WILLIAM H.PEDIGO 6802 VIA CARONA DR 6792 VIA CARONA DR 6782 VIA CARONA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6648 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6646 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6646 165-02 -10 165-024-11 165-024-12 THOMA A.MARDESICH GARY L.&M.CYNTHIA DROEGER THOMAS MARDESICH 6752 VIA CARONA DR 6732 VIA CARONA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6646 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6646 165-024-13 165-024-14 165-024-15 DONALD R.&PAULA C.BAIRD FRANK E.&TERESA E.GONZALEZ RAYMOND O.KOCH 17702 AVILLA LN 6751 JARDINES DR 6761 JARDINES DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6657 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6627 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6627 165-024-16 165-024-17 165-024-18 MARLENE R.MC LAUGHLIN LAUGHLIN MARK E.PETERSEN HOWARD J.MC GILTON GILTON 6781 JARDINES DR 6791 JARDINES DR 6801 JARDINES DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6627 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6627 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6629 165-024-19 165-024-20 165-024-21 JAMES R.STEPHENSON VICTOR JOHN SCHISLER BIRGER &SUZANNE STAHLBUHK 6811 JARDINES DR 6841 JARDINES DR 6851 JARDINES DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6629 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6629 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6629 165-024-22 165-024-23 165-024-24 DALE E.SWANSON KEVIN O.&BRENDA B.SCHROEDER KARL M.T.SCHUTTENHELM 6862 JARDINES DR 6852 JARDINES DR 6842 JARDINES DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6629 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6629 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6629 165-024-25 165-024-26 165-024-27 NEVILLE &JENNIFER BRAHAM JAMES DONN&ALICE TERESE MOORE PATRICK G.MC CAFFERY CAFFERY 6812 JARDINES OR 6802 JARDINES DR 6792 JARDINES DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6629 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6629 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6628 165-024-28 165-024-29 165-024-30 DAMASO H.SUTIS ROBERT D.HOXSIE THOMAS C.DALLAS 6782 JARDINES DR 6762 JARDINES DR 6752 JARDINES DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6628 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6628 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6628 165-024-31 165-024-32 165-024-33 KENNETH J.JACKSON VIRGINIA ROSS CITY OF HUN NGTON BEACH 6742 JARDINES DR 6712 JARDINES DR CITY HAL HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6628 - HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6628 HUNTI TN BCH CA 92646 165-031-01 165-031-02 165-031-03 YIN &MEI KO TERRY J.WONG RONALD G.SAMPSON 6871 LOS AMIGOS CIR 6881 LOS AMIGOS CIR 6891 LOS AMIGOS CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6659 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6659 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6659 165-031-04 165-031-05 165-031-06 ELAINE METAXAS M.A.&ZOE C.FALLEY SEO-OAN &HEA-SOOK KIM 2300 MAIN ST 6911 LOS AMIGOS CIR 6921 LOS AMIGOS CIR IRVINE CA 92614-6223 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6659 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6659 165-031-07 165-031-08 165-031-09 RALPH P.CRAFT JAMES &ILONA CALLOS JEFFREY WENNERMAR&PAMELA ANN 6941 LOS AMIGOS CIR 6951 LOS AMIGOS CIR ff(fftR7RMIGOS CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6659 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6659 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6659 165-031-10 165-031-11 165-031-12 PHILIP E.&KAREN 1.RIDOUT HANS LIETZ DONALD K.GARRICK 6962 LOS AMIGOS CIR 6952 LOS AMIGOS CIR 6942 LOS AMIGOS CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6659 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6659 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6659 165-031-13 165-031-14 165-031-15 MARVIN C.GREENWOOD PIERRE J.&MONIQUE MENARD WHITE J.HARRIS 6922 LOS AMIGOS CIR 6912 LOS AMIGOS CIR 6902 LOS AMIGOS CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6659 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6659 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6659 .4k 165-031-16 165-031-17 165-031-18 KENNETH E.DOBSON TED NIEDWICK TODD WILLIAM&CHRISTINE MARIE BERT 6892 LOS AMIGOS CIR 6882 LOS AMIGOS CIR 6872 LOS AMIGOS CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6659 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6659 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6659 165-031-19 165-031-20 165-031-21 THOMAS J.DUCHENE STANLEY A.WRIGHT FARREL S.&CONNIE L.MITCHELL 6871 VIA ANGELINA DR 6881 VIA ANGELINA DR 6891 VIA ANGELINA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6671 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6671 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6671 165-031-23 165-031-24 165-031-25 SON NGUYEN TERRANCE A.FLETCHER DONALD A.WALLACE 6911 VIA ANGELINA DR 6921 VIA ANGELINA DR 6931 VIA ANGELINA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6671 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6671 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6671 165-031-26 165-031-27 165-031-28 JAMES A.&LUCIA C.ROSENBERG ELIZABETH J.JONES GREGORIO LINSANGAN 6941 VIA ANGELINA DR 6961 VIA ANGELINA DR 17582 EL NOPAL LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6671 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6671 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6658 165-031-29 165-031-30 165-031-31 GEORGE T.MATSUURA FRANCISCO A.FLORIAN[ LULUBEL 0.CHURCHILL 17592 EL NOPAL LN 17602 EL NOPAL LN 17612 EL NOPAL LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6658 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6680 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6680 165-031-32 165-031-33 165-031-34 G.MARION SWEENEY JAMES E.&SUZANNE M.CARLSON DARLENE J.MANN 17622 EL NOPAL LN 17632 EL NOPAL LN 17642 EL NOPAL LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6680 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6680 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6680 165-031-35 165-031-36 165-031-37 GARY C.&KIMBERLY A.SANDERS JACK PAIGE C.WAYNE&IRENE S.FULLEN 17652 EL NOPAL LN 17662 EL NOPAL LN 17672 EL NOPAL LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6680 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6680 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6680 165-031-38 165-031-39 165-032-01 CURTIS &JENNIFER GIESE KENNETH E.CRUMLEY STONE TRUST 17692 EL NOPAL LN 17702 EL NOPAL LN 6882 VIA ANGELINA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6680 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6681 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6682 165-032-02 165-032-03 165-032-04 TADASHI &HIROKO MIZUTANI AARON J.MINTZ SHIRLEY A.CHAPMAN 6892 VIA ANGELINA DR 6902 VIA ANGELINA DR 6912 VIA ANGELINA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6682 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6603 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6603 165-032-05 165-032-06 165-032-07 DAVID J.&JANICE L.SORG CAROLYN NEWCOMB ZSIGMOND JILL P 6922 VIA ANGELINA DR 6932 VIA ANGELINA DR 6931 VISTA DEL SOL DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6603 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6603 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6655 165-032-08 165-032-09 165-032-10 HERBERT J.BOLTON INGRID HADDAD THOMAS M. DAWES 6921 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6911 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6901 VISTA DEL SOL DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6655 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6655 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6655 165-032-11 165-032-12 165-033-01 WENDEL R.&KATHRYN E.WERSCHING BARBARA GAIL SNIDER ASSOCIATE RELOC MNGMNT 6891 VISTA DEL SOL DR 842 S MONROE ST 105 DECKER ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6653 ARLINGTON VA 22204-1538 IRVING CA 75062-6654 165-033-02 165-033-03 165-033-04 RICHARD D.SHINN WARREN ALLAN&SUSAN BRADLEY KENNETH C.MAILMAN 6892 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6902 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6912.VISTA DEL SOL DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6654 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6656 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6656 165-033-05 165-033-06 165-033-07 REZA &FARIBA ESFANDIARI JOAN CATHERINE SIMON SEAN W.&LISA M.BEACH 6922 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6932 VISTA DEL SOL DR 6931 VIA CARONA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6656 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6656 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6649 165-033-08 165-033-09 165-033-10 GENCAGA &LILIANA ALIYAZICIOGLU FRANCIS 0.MC CARTHY CARTHY JUDY L.PESTOLIS 6921 VIA CARONA DR 6911 VIA CARONA DR 6901 VIA CARONA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH.CA 92647-6649 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6649 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6649 165-033-11 165-033-12 165-034-01 DIANE K.KAMPSCHUUR JERRY LEE&SANDRA W.ALONZO MARIA CRUZ JOHANSSON 6891 VIA CARONA DR 6881 VIA CARONA OR 6882 VIA CARONA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6686 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6686 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6648 165-034-02 165-034-03 165-034-04 EDWARD W.&NANCY L.DEUEL WALTON JAY MC GARRIGLE THOMAS M.&LESLIE M.LOWMAN 6892 VIA CARONA DR 6902 VIA CARONA DR 6912 VIA CARONA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6648 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6650 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6650 165-034-05 165-034-06 165-034-07 PEN &ME[-YU LIAO ROBERT D.&VAL M.KREIDEL PAUL E.SCHERER 6922 VIA CARONA DR 6932 VIA CARONA DR 6931 RIO VISTA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6650 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6650 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6660 165-034-08 165-034-09 165-034-10 JOHN &STACEY CROFT CALISE JO ANN MAXINE SIMS GLASS ROBERT H.S.MAC DONALD 6921 RIO VISTA DR 6911 RIO VISTA DR 6901 RIO VISTA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6660 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6660 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6660 165-034-11 165-034-12 165-034-13 MARK A.&LYNNE M.BUTSKI ALEXANDER MANESH JACK E.ALLEN 6891 RIO VISTA DR 6881 RIO VISTA DR 6871 RIO VISTA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6660 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6660 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6660 _N 165-034-14 165-034-15 165-034-16 MICHAEL 0.&KIM M.FOGARTY ROBERT M.GORDON DAVID J.&KAREN L.LENSING 6872 RIO VISTA DR 6882 RIO VISTA DR 6892 RIO VISTA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6660 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6660 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6660 165-034-17 165-034-18 165-034-19 DIANE TRU ST DAVISSON DAVID R.&SHIRLEY A.REYNOLDS ROBERT &MICHELLE WOLKOYS 6902 RIO VISTA DR 6912 RIO VISTA DR 6922 RIO VISTA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6660 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6660 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6660 165-034-20 165-034-21 165-034-22 THOMAS &KIMBERLY COLEMAN CHIKAKO OKAMURA BILLY RAY&BARBARA SUE BOYTE 6932 RIO VISTA DR 6942 RIO VISTA DR 9015 DAUM CT HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6660 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6660 SPRINGFIELD VA 22153-2453 165-034-23 165-0 -24 165-071-01 GIACOMO BENEVENTO CITY OF NTINGTON BEACH SCOTT J.&SUSAN H.SANNER 6962 RIO VISTA DR DQ�X ZC1�0 CITY HALL 17302 MARGARITA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6660 HUNTINGTN CH CA 92646 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5633 165-071-02 165-071-03 165-071-04 GERALD S.WAWACK GARY P.&CARLA D.RAGO DIANE RODECKER 1705 HOLLY TRL 17342 MARGARITA LN 17352 MARGARITA LN CEDAR PARK TX 78613-6476 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5633 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5633 165-071-07 165-071-08 165-071-09 RICHARD G.PENJOYAN GARY M.&DONNA M.LEWIS HOWARD LEE&KATHIE HERDMAN 17321 ROB ROY CIR 3441 VENTURE DR 17302 ROB ROY CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5672 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-2533 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5639 165-071-10 165-071-11 165-071-12 NAN E.TEMPLETON STEVEN LESLIE&JUNE J.COHEN RONALD D.MURPHY 17312 ROB ROY CIR 17322 ROB ROY CIR 17342 ROB ROY CIRCLE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5639 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5639 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5639 165-071-17 165-071-18 165-071-19 ZSIGMOND FRIGYES DENNIS W.&BRENDA C.LUPTON PETER &RHONDA WAINWRIGHT 17392 ROB ROY CIR 17391 DREY LN 17381 DREY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5639 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5615 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5615 165-071-20 165-071-21 165-071-22 JOHN A.MASTRIGHT ROBERT H.&LISA R.SUMMERS ALFRED P.STEINBERG 17371 DREY LN 17361 DREY LN 17351 DREY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5615 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5615 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5615 165-071-23 165-071-24 165-071-25 SARAH C.CALDWELL ADRIAN F.&LINDA K.C.GOMEZ DOUGLAS C.&KATHLEEN M.HARRINGTO 17341 DREY LN 17321 DREY LN 17311 DREY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5615 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5615 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5615 165-071-26 165-071-27 165-071-28 EINAR A.STEFFERUD JAMES &DIANE M.VANDERGRIFF RALPH LABELSON 17301 DREY LN 17382 ROB ROY CIR 16312 SPARTAN CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5615 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5639 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-2526 165-071-31 165-071-32 165-071-33 ROBERT QUINN MORRIS JOHN JAMES MC CLUSKEY JERRY D.&CAROLYN K.ERNST 17351 ROB ROY CIR 17341 ROB ROY CIR 17352 ROB ROY CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5672 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5672 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5639 165-071-34 165-072-01 165-072-04 LAWRENCE R.&SUSAN M.BRANKOV STEPHEN S.KALLAOS RICHARD J.LLOYD 17362 ROB ROY CIR 17341 MARGARITA LN 17351 MARGARITA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5639 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5632 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5632 165-072-05 165-072-06 165-072-07 QAQUNDAH PAUL Y THOMAS G.&SARAH H.MELTON DONALD C.&BARBARA A.BANDOLI 3901 LEGEND CIR 6772 BAKER DR 6782 BAKER DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-3076 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5619 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5619 165-072-08 165-072-09 165-072-10 RUFUS W.WHITE MICHAEL S.&LORI A.CREVDA KENNETH G.MUSSELMANN 6792 BAKER DR 17371 ROB ROY CIR 17381 ROB ROY CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5619 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5671 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5671 165-072-11 165-072-14 165-072-15 TIEN HAN&YUNG HUI H.WU FRANCES H.ROSEN WILLIAM J.PATTERSON 17391 ROB ROY CIR 6771 MANHATTAN DR 6791 MANHATTAN DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5671 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5630 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5630 165-072-16 165-072-17 165-072-18 HOMAYOUN RE2Ai REYNALDO R.AVILA SAM J.&JERALDINE S.KALLAOS 6781 MANHATTAN DR 17321 MARGARITA LN 17341 MAGARITA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5630 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5632 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647 165-073-01 165-073-02 165-073-03 CHARLES E.G.LEECH ISAAC L.ROYER SCOTT &LINDEE S.SCHUENEMAN 17442 KURT LN 17422 KURT LN 17412 KURT LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5629 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5629 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5629 165-073-06 165-073-07 165-073-08 JOSEPH A.MILCHAK ROBERT W.ROWE JONG G.&CHIN HYO KAHNG 6832 MANHATTAN DR 6842 MANHATTAN DR 6852 MANHATTAN DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5667 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5667 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5667 165-073-09 165-073-10 165-073-11 ANN T.RYAN MONROE &KATHLEEN E.BUNGE JAMES &CAROL FINERTY 6862 MANHATTAN DR 6872 MANHATTAN DR 6871 SPICKARD DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5667 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5667 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5655 165-073-12 165-073-13 165-073-14 JIMMIE L.GLORE NOELLE M.GERDE JOHN STITES 6861 SPICKARD DR 6851 SPICKARD DR 6841 SPICKARD DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5655 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5655 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-565.' 165-073-15 165-073-16 165-073-17 EDITH MARIE HAGENAH HSIN-CHIA KAN JAMES M.&CHRISTY J.KULAKOWS 6831 SPICKARD DR 6821 SPICKARD DR 6811 SPICKARD DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5677 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5677 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-567- 165-073-18 165-073-19 165-074-01 ROBERT D.LLOYD BIENVENIDO C.RABANO JAMES E.&LAURIE A.WARSZAWSK 6822 MANHATTAN DR 6812 MANHATTAN DR 17411 KURT LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5678 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5678 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-567: 165-074-04 165-074-05 165-074-06 WAYNE &MARILYN SEEBOLD GERALD P.&NORMA J.MANNION JOHN B.LIPPOLD 17451 KURT LN 6782 SPICKARD DR 6792 SPICKARD DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5673 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5680 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-568C 165-074-07 165-074-08 165-074-09 JAMES 0.HILLMAN GARY L.FARLEY THOMAS F.&ELVA P.KOPACZ 6802 SPICKARD DR PO BOX 1680 6822 SPICKARD DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5656 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-1680 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-565E 165-074-10 165-074-11 165-074-12 JAMES DAVID&SHERRY A.MARLAR RICHARD H.BALDWIN LEANN THEISS 6832 SPICKARD DR 6842 SPICKARD DR 6852 SPICKARD DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5656 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5656 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-565E 165-074-13 165-074-14 165-075-01 WILLIAM E.&DIANE M.LAIDLAW WAYNE D.WESTFALL CLARENCE E.BRYAN 17441 KURT LN 555 DESEO AV 17302 DREY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5673 CAMARILLO CA 93010-8464 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-561 E 165-075-02 165-075-03 165-075-04 BLAIR M.&FRANCES T.LENOIR VIRGINIA ELENA REYES KENNETH J.&JACQUELINE A.MAC 17312 DREY LN 17322 DREY LN 17342 DREY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5616 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5616 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-561E 165-075-05 165-075-06 165-075-07 ALAN G.&VICKI A.PORTER WILLIAM V.KOTLENSKY JEFFREY S.&JUDITH E.SCHIEBERL 17352 DREY LN 5931 BUCHANAN AV 17372 DREY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5616 SAN BERNARDINO CA 92404-3410 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-561E 165-075-08 165-075-09 165-091-01 YUKIKO YAMAUCHI LARRY J.MAGERKURTH E.WALLACE DUNN 6372 NEWBURY DR 6871 MANHATTAN DR 17302 WHETMORE LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6536 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5675 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-560t 165-091-02 165-091-03 165-091-04 MARIAN M.KAYSER JAMES F.&CYNTHIA L.DOUGLAS PRENTISS M.&JUANITA M.CUSTE. 17312 WHETMORE LN 17322 WHETMORE LN 17342 WHETMORE LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5600 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5600 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-56C 165-091-05 165-091-06 165-091-07 C.WAYNE&IRENE C.FULLEN ALAN &LESLIE JO GOULD TANNER S.&BARBARA A.PETERS( 17352 WHETMORE LN 17362 WHETMORE LN 17372 WHETMORE LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5600 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5600 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-56C 165-092-01 165-092-02 165-092-03 RICHARD D.&SUSAN J.TURCHI EDWARD K.&CYNTHIA B.ENSIGN REUBEN R.GARCIA 17392 WHETMORE LN 17402 WHETMORE LN 17412 WHETMORE LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5681 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5669 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-56E 165-092-04 165-092-05 165-092-06 JOSEPHINE SPADA RICHARD ALBERT WAGNER JUNG WAN KIM 537 N 19TH ST 17442 WHETMORE LN 17452 WHETMORE LN MONTEBELLO CA 90640-3130 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5676 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-567 165-092-07 165-092-08 165-092-09 ARTHUR M.SILVERSTEIN GEORGE M.&MELODY A.MARTON MARTIN C.&HELGA H.HOFFMANN 6962 SPICKARD DR 6942 SPICKARD DR 6932 SPICKARD DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5658 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5658 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-565 165-092-10 165-092-11 165-092-12 BILLY LIN WANG EDWARD J.DUFF ELLEN L.HALE 15221 POLLY AVE 6912 SPICKARD DR 6902 SPICKARD DR LAWNDALE CA 90260-2448 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5658 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-565 165-092-13 165-092-14 165-093-01 JACK &MARILYN J.LAZARRE JOSEPH SULLIVAN PATRICK T.MURMAN 6892 SPICKARD DR 6872 SPICKARD DR 17301 WHETMORE LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5668 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5668 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-564 165-093-02 165-093-03 165-093-04 FLORENCE PAVLISH DALLEY TRUST GAITANE H.GAUGLER 17311 WHETMORE LN 17321 WHETMORE LN 15052 TEMPLE ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5647 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5647 WESTMINSTER CA 92683-6229 165-093-05 165-093-06 165-093-07 FREDERICK C.TRUEMAN JOE E.DE LACHICA LACHICA JOHN E.DICKERSON 17351 WHETMORE LN 17361 WHETMORE LN 17371 WHETMORE LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5647 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5647 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-564 165-093-08 165-093-09 165-093-10 DON SHIGERU MORITA WILLIAM G.&DELRITA B.SCHULZ MICHAEL D.ALLEN 17381 WHETMORE LN 17391 WHETMORE LN 17392 GIBSON CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5647 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5647 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-56 165-093-11 165-093-12 165-093-13 AMOS DANIEL BARTZ STEVEN RTSTEIN EVERETT B.ROE 17382 GIBSON CIR 3350 CABALLO E 17362 GIBSON CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5617 SANTA YNEZ CA 93 - 782 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5617 165-093-14 165-093-15 165-093-16 JOHN M.ROHRIG EDWANA A.MARTIN FRANCES OPPENHEIM 17352 GIBSON CIR 17342 GIBSON CIR 17322 GILBSON CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5617 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5617 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5617 165-093-17 165-093-18 165-093-19 ANNEMARIE ARKLESS FRED CORDOVA ROBERT J.&JULIE L.FRANZ 17312 GIBSON CIR 17302 GIBSON CIR 17311 GIBSON CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5617 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5617 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5617 165-093-20 165-093-21 165-093-22 JOHN F.MASSEY BARBARA A.STANGE WALTER G.TOR 17321 GIBSON CIR 17341 GIBSON CIR 17351 GIBSON CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5617 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5617 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5617 165-093-23 165-093-24 165-093-25 STEVEN R.&VIRGINIA MAH AUDETTE ABBAS LILAZY NEWMAN-GREEN INC 17361 GIBSON CIR 17371 GIBSON CIR 57 W INTERSTATE RD HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5617 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5617 ADDISON IL 60101-4509 165-093-26 165-094-01 165-094-02 TOM &LETTY FORTH WILLIS C.WHITED JESUS R.&DIANA D.ARTIAGA 17391 GIBSON CIR 6942 MANHATTAN DR 6932 MANHATTAN DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5617 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5631 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5631 165-094-03 165-094-04 165-094-05 JAMES M.&MARY E.TOMASEK JOHN H.MC KINLEY KINLEY MARLENE S.KLINE 6922 MANHATTAN DR 6912 MANHATTAN DR 6902 MANHATTAN DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5631 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5631 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5631 165-094-06 165-094-07 165-094-08 ALLEN R.&BARBARA B.ADAMS MARY KATHERINE HARRIS LOYAL B.&MARGARET F.MASSEY 6892 MANHATTAN OR 6891 SPICKARD DR 6901 SPICKARD DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5667 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5655 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5657 165-094-09 165-094-10 165-094-11 RODNEY J.HUNTINGTON LORI DI LEVA JERRY G.SCHOENENBERGER 6911 SPICKARD DR 6921 SPICKARD DR 6931 SPICKARD DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5657 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5657 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5657 165-094-12 165-151-25 165-151-26 JOHN KING CHARLOTTE CLARK DAVID W.&MARILYN M.WESTMORELAND 6941 SPICKARD DR 6572 MONTOYA CIR 6562 MONTOYA CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5657 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6633 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6633 165-151-27 165-151-28 165-151-29 HELMER &HOPE J.NORDWALL DAVID P.&RICK]R.VANHOOREBEKE RICHARD B.GORE 6552 MONTOYA CIR 6542 MONTOYA CIR 6532 MONTOYA CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6633 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6633 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6633 165-151-30 165-151-31 165-151-32 SEVERN L.KELSEY ROBERT E.CARBONELL HSU SHING-MING 6522 MONTOYA CIR 6521 SABBICAS CIR PO BOX 4127 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6633 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6636 IRVINE CA 92616-4127 165-151-33 165-151-34 165-151-35 JOHN S.QUINN ESTIAMBA TRUST NATHAN MARK&JULIE A.REESE 6541 SABBICAS CIR 6551 SABBICAS CIR 6561 SABBICAS CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6636 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6636 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6636 165-151-36 165-151-37 165-151-38 GEORGIA SANDQUIST IVY M.HOWARD LEON R.NADOLSKI 6571 SABBICAS CIR 6572 SABBICAS CIR 6562 SABBICAS CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6636 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6636 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6636 165-151-39 165-151-40 165-151-41 EARLE W.ROBITAILLE ROBERT L.WALKER BRUCE T.HEMPHILL 6552 SABBICAS CIR 6542 SABBICAS CIR 6532 SABBICAS CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6636 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6636 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6636 165-151-42 165-151-43 165-151-44 DAVID R.WELLS ROMAN CATHOLIC ARCHBISHOP/ ELENA A.BOULTER 6522 SABBICAS CIR 3424 WILSHIRE BLVD 6531 JARDINES DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6636 LOS ANGELES CA 90010-2241 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6624 165-151-45 165-151-46 165-151-47 JOHN PICKLE ALI ASGHAR&PARVIN OSTOVARPOUR FERNANDO ELLSWORTH 6541 JARDINES DR 6551 JARDINES DR 6561 JARDINES DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6624 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6624 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6624 165-151-48 165-152-19 165-152-20 JOE DI PIETRO DENNIS A.TOWGOOD LANGE TRUST 6571 JARDINES DR 17611 SAN ROQUE LN 17621 SAN ROQUE LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6624 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6642 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6642 165-152-21 165-152-22 165-152-23 PHILIP B.&KIM V.KLIPPEL RICHARD L.&SAMANTHA BODKINS N.NEIL&ANGELA HARDIN 17631 SAN ROQUE LN 17641 SAN ROQUE LN 17651 SAN ROQUE LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6642 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6642 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6642 165-152-25 165-152-26 165-152-27 CARLOS R.&LYNNE C.MARTIN ZELMA HEUSTIS ROBERT E.DARLING 17671 SAN ROQUE LN 6502 JARDINES DR 6512 JARDINES DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6642 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6625 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6625 165-152-28 165-152-29 165-152-30 JACK P.&CARMEL BOUSARD ANTONIO CARUNGAY FREDRICK J.RICARDO 6522 JARDINES DR 6532 JARDINES DR 6542 JARDINES DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6625 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6625 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6625 165-152-31 165-152-32 165-152-33 DONALD R.CARLSON ROBERT G.&ANNA M.DREIFUS TERRY SPENCER 6552 JARDINES DR 6562 JARDINES DR 6572 JARDINES DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6625 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6625 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6625 165-152-34 165-161-01 165-161-02 ALLAN R.THOMPSON ROY J.&VIRGINIA S.L.CHAPMAN DARRYL FRIED 6582 JARDINES DR 6691 CRISTA PALMA DR 6681 CRISTA PALMA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6625 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6665 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6665 165-161-03 165-161-04 165-161-05 MARK S.&JUDY NUSSBAUM EDMUND B.BOSSART PATRICK J.&GERRY FLOWERS 6671 CRISTA PALMA DR 6661 CRISTA PALMA DR 6651 CRISTA PALMA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6665 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6665 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6665 165-161-06 165-162-01 165-162-02 BARBARA CHARLES&D TRUST PAUL L.ORRIS EDWIN C.&ROSEMARY JOHNSON 6641 CRISTA PALMA DR 6621 CRISTA PALMA DR 6611 CRISTA PALMA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6665 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6619 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6619 165-162-03 165-162-04 165-163-01 EUI K.LEE JAMES &JULIANNE S.BANCROFT SCHOOL OCEAN VIEW DIST 6601 CRISTA PALMA DR 6591 CRISTA PALMA DR 7972 WARNER AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6619 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6617 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647 165-164- 1 165-164-02 165-164-03 JUNE U ROLAND V.CLAFLIN HENRY JOSEPH&CATHERINE K.LA" 6682 JARDINES DR 6672 JARDINES DR. HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6666 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6666 165-164-04 165-1 -05 165-165-01 RORY M.DEANGELIS CITY OF HU\BCH GTON BEACH OSCAR A.BERNHOFF 6662 JARDINES DR CITY HALL 6642 JARDINES DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6666 HUNTINGTN CA 92646 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6626 165-165-02 165-165-03 165-165-04 MARY C.MAHER PATRICK J.&TRACY SAVAGE PAUL W.BOWMAN 6632 JARDINES OR 6622 JARDINES OR 4931 LOS PATOS AV HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6626 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6626 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-4458 165-165-05 165-165-06 165- 65-07 MATTHEW A.&CATHERINE B.THOMSON THOMAS L.BEBOUT CITY HUNTINGTON BEACH 6602 JARDINES OR 6592 JARDINES OR CITY HA HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6626 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6625 HUNTINGT BCH CA 92646 165-201-01 165-2 -02 165-202-01 SAMUEL S.HOENIG RONA D J.ATKINS RICHARD F.BOLF 7111 BETTY DR 12461 BEATRICE ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5450 LOS ANGELES CA 90066-6903 165-202-02 165-202-03 165-202-04 PAUL &DIANE L.GILES RONALD A.HAVIS THOMAS E.RABURN 7071 BETTY DR 3 CLEAR SPRING 7041 BETTY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5448 IRVINE CA 92612-3612 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5448 165-202-05 165-202-06 165-202-07 DONALD BROGGER JOHN &NICOLE KELSER JAMES RIVERA 7031 BETTY DR 7031 BETTY DR 7001 BETTY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5448 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5448 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5448 165-203-01 165-203-02 165-203-03 CHARLES ROBERT KNOTH JANET E.STEWART ELLEN HOPE 7112 BETTY DR 7102 BETTY DR 7092 BETTY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5451 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5451 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5449 165-203-04 165-203-05 165-203-06 DONALD W.&SARAH E.PATTERSON GEORGE W.BUTTERWORTH MARY D.EVANS PO BOX 2242 PO BOX 531 7062 BETTY DR HUNTINGTON.BEACH.CA 92647-0242 SAN LUIS OBISPO CA 93406-0531 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5449 165-203-07 165-203-08 165-203-09 RONALD A.EGLIT STEPHEN VAN HUGHES CLAUDIA MARLE JACKSON 7042 BETTY OR 19852 LOTUS LN 7022 BETTY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5449 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-3415 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5449 16S-203-10 165-203-11 165-203-12 ROGER GONZALES GUY &RONYE ZINN PEDRO A.&AMPARO S.BUITRAGO 7002 BETTY DR 17292 GOLDENWEST ST 17302 GOLDENWEST ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5449 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5447 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6236 16S-203-13 165-203-14 165-203-15 JOHN A.&THERESA S.MORELLO MICHAEL A.&GERALDINE Y.AMES SCOTT E. 1998 TRUS PETERSON 17322 GOLDENWEST ST 17332 GOLDENWEST ST 17342 GOLDENWEST ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6236 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6236 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6236 165-203-16 165-203-17 165-203-18 JOHN F.&MARTHA H.BERGMAN CHARLES R.MC GRUDER GRUDER LEONARD A.&CAROLINE LEVY 17352 GOLDENWEST ST 17351 MILL CIR 17341 MILL CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6236 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6210 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6210 165-203-19 165-203-20 165-203-21 THOMAS ALLEN EMERSON MILL CIRCLE TRUST#17321 BRENDA ANN KEINER 17331 MILL CIR 24801 VIA PRINCESA 4 AUTUMN OAK HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6210 LAKE FOREST CA 92630-2021 IRVINE CA 92604-3749 165-203-22 165-203-23 165-203-24 DAVID W.ATHERTON SEIJU E.TERADA MARK &YUKO MCCONNELL 17291 MILL CIR 17281 MILL CIR 17282 MILL CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6210 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6210 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6210 165-203-25 165-203-26 165-203-27 DAPHNE JEAN CHRISTIE DOUGLAS B.DANIELSON STEVE A.&COLETTE SAND 24521 CHAMALEA 10191 DEWEY DRIVE 17322 MILL CIR MISSION VIEJO CA 92691-4822 GARDEN GROVE CA 92840-1022 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6210 165-203-28 165-203-29 165-203-30 HENRY S.&ANGELA RAMIREZ KENNETH W.GUNN STAN M.&KATHLEEN M.KADOWAKI 17332 MILL CIR 17342 MILL CIR 17352 MILL CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6210 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6210 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6210 165-203-31 165-203-32 165-203-33 ARTHUR M.ORTA NANCY L.WHITE JERRE C.&JULIA M.REID 17351 LEE CIR 17341 LEE CIR 17322 LEE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6208 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6208 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6208 165-203-34 165-203-35 165-203-36 FARID AL-ALI ROBERT E.&CARRIE L.JOHNSON JOHN D.&ANNE M.BRASIE 17321 LEE CIR 17311 LEE CIR 17291 LEE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6208 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6208 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6208 165-203-37 165-203-38 165-203-39 JOHN M.CHISOLM ERWIN B.FLUEGGE VICTOR B.&ALICE M.KORNAHRENS 17281 LEE CIR 17282 LEE CIR 17292 LEE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6208 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6208 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6208 165-203-40 165-203-41 165-203-42 THOMAS W.PEGLER JERRE G.REID CARTER B.&SUSAN K.WURTS 17312 LEE CIR 17322 LEE CIR 17332 LEE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6208 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6208 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6208 165-203-43 165-204-01 165-204-02 JAMIE J.&JENNIFER J.BENNETT LAURAL WINSTON MICHAEL PALAFOUTAS 17342 LEE CIR 37473 SKYLIGHT RD 7022 FORD DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6208 INDIO CA 92203-8932 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6207 165-204-03 165-204-04 165-204-05 JAY A.&TEMORRA D.BOGERT AMELIA KIMBARK M.JEAN PUCKETT 7032 FORD DR 7042 FORD DR 7062 FORD DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6207 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6207 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6207 165-204-06 165-204-07 165-204-08 MICHAEL A.&MICHEEE R.ROGERS MICHAEL J.GEHRES DORIS G.HARMON 7072 FORD DR 7082 FORD DR 7092 FORD DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6207 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6207 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6207 165-204-09 165-204-10 165-204-11 MARK &ANNA MERS MARK EDWARD&ANNA C.MERS JERRE G.REID 7102 FORD DR 7112 FORD DR 17322 LEE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6235 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6235 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6208 165-204-12 165-204-13 165-204-14 WILLIAM L.&SUSAN L.P.GIFFORD NOSHIR &GOOL JESUNG ROBERT M.&AUDREY T.HIRAO 7131 NIMROD DR 7121 NIMROD DR 7101 NIMROD DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6221 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6221 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6221 165-204-15 165-204-16 165-204-17 CARLO RUNO GERALD CARLSON MICHAEL J.&YASMINE R.MARTIN 7091 NIMRO R 7071 NIMROD DR 7061 NIMROD DR HUNTINGTON B H CA 92647-6220 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6220 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6220 165-204-18 165-204-19 165-204-20 IRA R.KAUFMAN FLOYD J.WHITTON ROGER A.&ELIZABETH M.GLICKMAN PO BOX 3696 7041 NIMROD DR 7031 NIMROD DR QUINCY CA 95971-3696 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6220 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6220 165-204-21 165-204-22 165-204-23 JAMES E.&ANGELA KESLER ALDO A.DECARVALHO TUAN VO 7021 NIMROD DR 17441 MASHIE CIR 16235 MT GUSTIN ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6220 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6209 FOUNTAIN VALLEY CA 92708-1324 165-204-24 165-204-25 165-204-26 JIM MOCK JAY JETT LEO A.RUDNICK 17461 MASHIE CIR 17471 MASHIE CIR 4712 EL RANCHO VERDE DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6209 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6209 LA PALMA CA 90623-2410 165-204-27 165-204-28 165-204-29 HERBERT J.LAKIN LOUISE M.MILLER ANTHONY J.&SUZANNE D.LIBERTO 17492 MASHIE CIR 17472 MASHIE CIR 17462 MASHIE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6209 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6209 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6209 165-204-30 165-204-31 165-204-32 LORIN T.MAXWELL PHILLIP S.BURTIS ROBERT MAEDA 17452 MASHIE CIR 17451 DUELLO LN 17461 DUELLO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6209 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6211 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6211 165-204-33 165-204-34 165-205-01 DELMORE HAO-CHI WU STEPHEN R.&CATHERINE GOLDMAN ROBERT C.&KIMBERLEE N.DAVIS 17471 DUELLO LN 17491 DUELLO LN 7122 NIMROD DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6211 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6211 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6222 165-20 02 165-205-03 165-205-04 JOSEPH .GAGLIONE ADAM H.&TAMMI L.SAMANIEGO TIMMY N.OSUMI 17452 DUELLO LN 17462 DUELLO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6212 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6212 165-205-05 165-205-06 165-205-07 MARC A.TAKACS GERALD R.WAMPLER SABRY A.SALEH 17472 DUELLO LN 14452 SOUTHFIELD DR 7101 SLATER AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6212 WESTMINSTER CA 92683-4841 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6224 165-205-08 165-211-01 165-211-02 THOMAS C.&SHARRON L.STAAB THOMAS W.MC ADA ADA SZYLVIAN VITAL F 7121 SLATER AVE 7171 BETTY DR 7161 BETTY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6224 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5450 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5450 165-211-03 165- -04 165-211-05 PETER C.&BIRGITTA K.BACKLIN PER ERIKSSO ROBERTA J.DUKE 7141 BETTY DR 7131 BETTY DR 7121 BETTY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5450 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 47-5450 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5450 165-212-01 165-212-02 165-212-03 BRETT E.LATROBE TJERNAGEL DAVID ANDREAS KIL OAN&JUNG SOOK KIM 7172 BETTY DR 11362 ROBERT LN 7142 BETTY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5451 GARDEN GROVE CA 92840-1731 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5451 165-212-04 165-212-05 165-212-06 ROGER L.HIGBEE THOMAS J.REES DONA F.BURRELL 7132 BETTY DR 7122 BETTY DR 17352 CANNA CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5451 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5451 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6206 165-212-07 165-212-08 165-212-10 CARL A.WALKER TRUDY J.LE CLAIR RANDALL D.&SHEILA M.OLMSTEAD. 17342 CANNA CIR 17332 CANNA CIR 17312 CANNA CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6206 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6206 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6206 165-212-11 165-212-12 165-212-13 MARTIN P.LINK STEPHEN HOWARD STEPHEN B.&JACQULINE M.MARSH 17292 CANNA CIR 17282 CANNA CIR 17281 CANNA CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6206 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6206 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6206 165-212-14 165-212-15 165-212-16 TERRY SCOTT LEACH MARK W.&CATHLEEN M.HALL JAY THOMAS PETERSON 17291 CANNA CIR 17311 CANNA CIR 17321 CANNA CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6206 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6206 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6206 165-212-17 165-212-18 165-212-19 CAROL M.BUCHEA SCOTT W.&HEATHER L.SHAW LARRY W.RICHARDS 17331 CANNA CIR 17341 CANNA CIR 13381 EL DORADO DR#202F HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6206 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6206 SEAL BEACH CA 90740-3524 165-213-01 165-213-02 165-213-03 MICHAEL J.&JANA L.KASLER KEVIN OWEN&LINDA ELLEN BROOKS ALBERT A.ARVIZU 21912 SUMMERWIND LN 7132 FORD DR 7141 NIMROD DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-8268 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6235 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6221 165-213-04 165-213-05 165-213-06 RICHARD &KATHERINE C.KURJAN RICHARD &HARRIET DUFF LUFT MALCOLM T.MULLENS 7151 NIMROD DR 7161 NIMROD DR 17442 LUCERO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6221 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6221 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6219 165-213-07 165-213-08 165-213-09 DELTON R.EMERY RYOJU HANAZAWA MARTIN D.LIPMAN 17452 LUCERO LN 26861 TRABUCO RD#E-211 17472 LUCERO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6219 MISSION VIEJO CA 92691-3535 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6219 165-213-10 165-213-11 165-213-12 R.SCOTT MCWILLIAMS JAMES C.&LINDA W.LUTH THOMAS J.&PATRICIA E.MELODY . 17492 LUCERO LN 17491 FLOWER LN 17471 FLOWER LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6219 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6230 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6230 165-213-13 165-213-14 165-213-15 GEORGE V.MC CLELLAND CLELLAND KENNETH R.HOLZ MICHAEL M.&MARY K.ANAYA 17461 FLOWER LN 17451 FLOWER LN 17441 FLOWER LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6230 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6230 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6230 165-213-16 165-213-17 165-213-18 CLARENCE A.PRUDEN PETER &PAMELA ANDRES ROGER BERUSCHE 7171 SUNBREEZE DR 7181 SUNBREEZE DR 7191 SUNBREEZE DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6231 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6231 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6231 165-213-19 165-213-20 165-213-21 KENNETH W.HERFT PAUL D.DALTON DANIEL S.KELLER 5502 W 142ND PL 7211 SUNBREEZE DR 7221 SUNBREEZE DR HAWTHORNE CA 90250-6634 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6270 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6270 165-214-01 165-214-02 165-214-03 FRANKLIN E.&GAYLE R.MOORE SUN TRUST GEORGE L.&LYNN PIETERSE 7142 NIMROD DR 7132 NIMROD OR 7131 SLATER AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6222 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6222 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6224 165-214-04 165-215-01 165-215-02 MICHAEL JOHN KNOX DANIEL &DARLENE MONDELLO MARC &FRIDA COHEN 7141 SLATER AVE 7222 SUNBREEZE DR 7212 SUNBREEZE DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6224 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6232 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6232 165-215-03 165-215-04 165-215-05 ROBERT &JANICE E.HOLLINGSWORTH LUIS &GERALDINE M.ANDRADE GERALD L.&SANDRA S.BLAIN 7202 SUNBREEZE DR 7192 SUNBREEZE DR 7191 SLATER AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6232 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6232 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6254 165-215-06 165-215-07 165-215-08 REX B.&BARBARA LUNDQUIST DOUGLAS &JUDY GRAVEN DEAN R.WILKE 7201 SLATER AVE 7211 SLATER AVE 7221 SLATER AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6225 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6225 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6225 165-261-05 165-26 -08 165-261-09 WM F.BARRY WOOD IND COMMERCE WOODWIND COMMERCE PARK LLC PO BOX K 11845 W OLYMPIC BLVD#1200 COTULLA TX 78014-1490 LOS ANGELES CA 90064-5026 165-261- 165-261-39 165-261-42 HARRI .HALE GRAYBEALTRUST FRANCES BLASER NO DRESS 17816 SAMPSON LN 344 S MCCARTY DR NO ADDRESS HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-7147 BEVERLY HILLS CA 90212-3719 165-261-43 165-261-44 165-261-45 NORBERT L.&LEE C.GRIESMAN DON WALTON DON ALTON 8531 BAYONNE DR 3163 BARBADOS PL 316 ARBADOS PL HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-2602 COSTA MESA CA 92626-2301 C TA MESA CA 92626-2301 165-261-46 165-261-47 165-261-50 THYCON REALTY CORP PTNSHP BDKH MOORE GUY TRUST 155 CANAL ST 5435 ROANOKE AVE 53 NIGHTINGALE DR NEW YORK NY 10013-4511 YORBA LINDA CA 92887-3757 ALISO VIEJO CA 92656-1708 165-261-51 165-261-52 165-261-55 LARRY LESTER&BARBARA ELLEN KOCH MARLYN W.KINNEY FRED P.&SUSAN E.DELGLEIZE 1628 MINORCA DR 1153 CHAPARRAL CT 17771 SAMPSON LN COSTA MESA CA 92626-4852 MINDEN NV 89423-8861 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6790 165-261-56 165-261-57 165-261-58 ROBERT VAN DOREN D S I REALTY INCOME FUND E IGHT WILLIAM J.SULLIVAN 17842 SAMPSON LN 18552 MACARTHUR BL#495 7612 WOODWIND DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-7147 IRVINE CA 92612-1220 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-7164 165- 61-59 165-261-60 165-2 1-61 WOO IND COMMERCE MARK BENABOU 6316 FORESTER DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-6612 165-261-62 165-261-63 165-261-65 HUNG TIEN&HWA-YIN C.OU DONALD E.WESTERDALE FIVE H INVESTMENTS 8952 BAYWOOD DR 3352 BOUNTY CIR 17921 LYONS CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-2616 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-2806 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-7167 165-261-66 165-261-69 165-261-70 THREE LYONS LTD CHETTA JOSEPH TRUST PAUL MORA 17922 LYONS CIR 3122 SHORE OR 7521 TALBERT AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-7167 GROVE OK 74344-5814 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1382 165-262-01 1 -262-02 165 62-03 f LIDO WOODWIND PARTNERS LID WOODWIND PARTNERS LIDO OODWIND PARTNERS 16055 VENTURA BL#1002 1605 VENTURA BL#1002 16055 ENTURA BL#1002 ENCINO CA 91436-2611 ENCI O CA 91436-2611 ENCIN CA 91436-2611 165-262-04 165-271-01 165-271-02 ROCKY V.&JULIE FLEEMAN JOSEPH C.HAERTSCH OLIVER &SVETLANA R.STIVI 9947 DAHLIA CIR 7231 SUNBREEZE DR 7241 SUNBREEZE DR FOUNTAIN VALLEY CA 92708-2028 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6270 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6270 165-271-03 165-271-04 165-271-05 JAMES M.NISHIOKA ANTON IBRAHIM&SAMIA ANTON SALAK BERNARD L.&SHARON L.RUE 7251 SUNBREEZE DR 7261 SUNBREEZE DR 7271 SUNBREEZE DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6270 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6270 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6270 165-271-06 165-271-07 165-271-08 MIN SOCK JU DANA WILSON LAWRENCE R.&PATRICIA MERTENS 7281 SUNBREEZE DR 7291 SUNBREEZE DR 17442 GRASS CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6270 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6270 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6234 165-271-09 1 -271-10 165-271-11 NGOC KIEN NGUYEN ANWAR &SI IN SOEHENDRO RICHARD J.&MARILYN A.SNYDER 17452 GRASS CIR 4310 LOMBARDY L 17472 GRASS CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6234 HOFFMAN ESTATES IL'6 5-1240 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6234 165-271-12 165-272-02 165-272-03 WILLIAM E.&DIANE S.RUSTIN DAVID &BOBBI DORVEE ELIOT &EDY MARTINEZ 17492 GRASS CIR 17461 GRASS CIR 17471 GRASS CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6234 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6238 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6238 165-272-04 165-272-05 165-272-06 MARTIN &VICTORIA BURKHARDT LEO C.&THERESA GOMEZ JOHN F.&KRISTI K.BRADOSKY 17491 GRASS CIR 17492 SKYLINE LN 17472 SKYLINE LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6238 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6233 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6233 165-272-07 165-272-08 165-273-01 SAMUEL &VERONICA LA ROSA STEVEN G.&REBECCA G.LOVSTEEN GOLDBERG MORDECHAI TRUST 8271 W ARGYLE ST 17452 SKYLINE LN 17451 SKYLINE LN NORRIDGE IL 60656-3065 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6233 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6237 165-273-02 165-273-03 165-273-04 G.VICTOR LEIPZIG ODIE W.COFFEY JOHN T.&JEAN L.HARDUVEL 17461 SKYLINE LN 17471 SKYLINE LN 17491 SKYLINE LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6237 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6237 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6237 165-341-01 165-341-02 165-341-03 ANN DOUILLARD JACK P.BOUSARD PAUL KRIZ 17741 ALTAMIRANO LN 6522 JARDINES DR 17761 ALTAMIRANO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6605 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6625 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6605 165-342-01 165-342-02 165-342-03 DOUGLAS C.&RENEE L.HARMON JOSEPH MC MYLER JOSEPH V.ALBANO 5901 WARNER AVE 2204 WINDING HOLLOW LN 17811 ALTAMIRANO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-4659 PLANO TX 75093-4147 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6607 165-342-04 165-342-05 165-342-06 RICHARD E.&CECILE DE NUCCIO GARY E.FISHER PAUL &HELENA KRIZ 17821 ALTAMIRANO LN 17831 ALTAMIRANO LN 17761 ALTAMIRANO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6607 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6607 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6605 165-343-01 165-343-02 165-343-03 DARBY TRUST ROBERT C.ABERCROMBIE - CHRISTY JANE VIVION 735 YNEZ CIR 17762 ALTAMIRANO LN 17772 ALTAMIRANO LN DANVILLE CA 94526-3550 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6606 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6606 165-343-04 165-343-05 165-343-06 GREGORY T.&CHRISTIE A.WEBER MARSHALL S.SHIPLEY H.R.&JYOTI KESHAVAN 17782 ALTAMIRANO LN 17792 ALTAMIRANO LN 6902 VERDE RIDGE RD HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6606 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6606 RANCHO PALOS VERDES CA 90275-4640 165-343-07 165-343-08 165-343-09 ANDERSON TRUST SCOTT H.&MARY A.PILLEN JAMES A.TULLIO 19912 CORBY AVE 17822 ALTAMIRANO LN 5331 GLENSTONE DR LAKEWOOD CA 90715-1030 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6608 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-4703 165-343-10 165-343-11 165-343-12 KENNETH &DEBORAH FISHER JEFFREY J.&AMBER KELLY LAUSCH STANLEY JEROME NELSON 17842 ALTAMIRANO LN 17841 CARRANZA LN 4904 ONYX ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6608 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6615 TORRANCE CA 90503-2834 165-343-13 165-343-15 165-343-16 TONI L.MAYNOCK DANE &SALLY A.SPEAKMAN KENNETH D.WOLDER 23993 CATAMARAN WAY 17791 CARRANZA LN 16212 PIEDMONT CIR LAGUNA NIGUEL CA 92677-4209 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6615 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-1807 165-343-17 165-343-18 165-343-19 STEPHEN D.&LESLEY C.LIND LORETTA K.FLEMING CLINE WALTER&MARY TRUST 17771 CARRANZA LN 17761 CARRANZA LN 17751 CARRANZA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6615 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6615 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6615 165-344-01 165-344-02 165-344-03 JAMES M.KONOWAL HERBERT KOPF CRAIG T.YONEYAMA 17752 CARRANZA LN 4982 ROCHELLE PL 17772 CARRANZA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6616 ESCONDIDIO CA 92025-6483 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6616 165-344-04 165-344-05 165-344-06 DAVID S.&KATHY NELSON CHARLES C.BRUMMETT LEONE BERMAN 17782 CARRANZA LN 17792 CARRANZA LN 9561 ACKLAY CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6616 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6616 FOUNTAIN VALLEY CA 92708-5101 165-344-07 165-344-08 165-344-09 DANA &EMILY K.JOHNSON DZIURAWIEC EDWARD J ERIC DAVID&DEBBIE ELLEN ZARAGOZA 17822 CARRANZA LN 17962 SCOTIA CIR 17842 CARRANZA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6616 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6540 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6616 165-344-10 165-344-11 165-344-12 BARBARA P.KEMPSTER GEORGE D.SLINKER PAUL DOUGLAS&BARBARA JO 17891 SAN DOVAL LN 17831 SAN DOVAL LN Y'9AHMVAL LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6637 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6637 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6637 165-344-13 165-344-14 165-344-15 JOSEPH E.&KYUNG HI MUNDINE ANDREW J.&GENUTE VIACIUNAS UHDEN TRUST 17811 SAN DOVAL LN 17791 SAN DOVAL LN 1235 N HARBOR BLVD#115 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6637 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6637 FULLERTON CA 92832-1323 165-344-16 165-344-17 165-344-18 WALID W.TAWDI JANICE A.REEVES IWAMOTO RICHARD T&ROSE Y 17771 SAN DOVAL LN 17761 SAN DOVAL LN 17751 SAN DOVAL LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6637 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6637 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6637 165-345-01 165-345-02 165-345-03 MARTIN WAYNE HENDERSON UPWICH MARIE A.VAN DER ANTO►NETTE 17752 SAN DOVAL LN 17762 SAN DOVAL LN 17772 SAN DOVAL LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6638 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6638 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6638 165-345-04 165-345-05 165-345-06 MICHAEL A.BERARDINI LESTER W.&CYNTHIA S.MASSENGALE WIKTOR &EWA TONN 17782 SAN DOVAL LN 17792 SAN DOVAL LN 17812 SAN DOVAL LN HUNTINGTON.BEACH CA 92647-6638 . HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6638 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6679 165-345-07 165-345-08 165-345-09 RICHARD A.JONES REX L.COMBS JOSEPH E.&KYUNG H.MUNDINE 17822 SAN DOVAL LN 17832 SAN DOVAL LN 17842 SAN DOVAL LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6679 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6679 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6679 165-345-10 165-345-11 165-345-12 BRANDON GROVE RODGER W.&CAROLYN RHINEHART J.EARL&DIANE TILLMAN 17841 OUINTANA LN 17831 QUINTANA LN 17821 QUINTANA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6673 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6634 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6634 165-345-13 165-345-14 165-345-15 CATHY T.DONATO BRUCE WARREN&DEBORAH L.WILSON MICHAEL &PATRICIA NAGATOSHI 17811 QUINTANA LN 17801 QUINTANA LN 17791 QUINTANA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6634 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6.634 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6634 165-345-16 165-345-17 165-345-18 ALFRED J.CHOMPFF LAWRENCE V.NASH LLOYD &STELLA HAYNES 17172 NORTHFIELD LN PO BOX 206 17761 QUINTANA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5533 WEDDERBURN OR 97491-0206 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6634 165-345-19 165-346-01 165-346-02 CORNELIUS RAPCHUN ALFREDO S.VILLANO BARRY H.&ELAINE H.KUHNKE 17751 QUINTANA LN 17752 QUINTANA LN 6512 OXFORD DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6634 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6635 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-2642 155-346-03 165-346-04 165-346-06 JOSEPH N.MILLER DONALD H.KILLMEYER CLIFFORD W.&DOROTHY E.GILLESPIE 17772 QUINTANA LN 17782 QUINTANA LN 17812 QUINTANA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6635 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6635 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6635 165-346-07 165-346-08 165-346-09 ROBERT &SHARON ALLENDE SANDUSKY TRUST CHARLES &JANIE WILLIAMS 17822 QUINTANA LN 17832 QUINTANA LN 17842 QUINTANA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6635 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6635 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6635 165-346-10 165-346-11 165-346-12 DONALD W.BARNEY WILLIAM M.ANDERSON CHARLES B.ROARK 17841 SAN LEANDRO LN 17831 SAN LEANDRO LN 17821 SAN LEANDRO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6676 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6676 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6676 165-346-14 165-346-15 165-346-17 STEPHEN G.HEADLEY JULIUS L.&SHANNON L.JONES STEVEN N.&MARY J.ALBERT 17791 SAN LEANDRO LN 17781 SAN LEANDRO LN 17761 SAN LEANDRO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6675 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6675 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6675 165-346-18 165-347-01 165-347-02 BENJAMIN B.KIM IWAMOTO ROSS YUKIO JERRY W.ROSS 17751 SAN LEANDRO LN 17752 SAN LEANDRO LN 17762 SAN LEANDRO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6675 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6640 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6640 165-347-03 165-347-04 165-347-05 LEONARD J.DAVIS HABIB &MARINA C.SHARIFZADEH JOHN M.&EILEEN R.BURDETTE 17772 SAN LEANDRO LN 17782 SAN LEANDRO LN 17792 SAN LEANDRO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6640 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6640 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6640 165-347-06 165-347-07 165-347-08 PLYLLIS G.FENDER WRAY A.&MARY B.MILLER JEFFREY A.&RENEE C.CARNIVAL 17812 SAN LEANDRO LN 17822 SAN LEANDRO LN 17832 SAN LEANDRO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6640 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6640 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6640 165-347-09 165-351-01 165-351-02 RUSSELL E.THOMAS FARROUKH N.&VEERA F.SIDHWA JIMMY EUGENE COLE 17842 SAN LEANDRO LN 17851 ALTAMIRANO LN 17861 ALTAMIRANO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6640 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6607 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6607 165-351-03 165-351-04 165-351-05 RONALD W.FREEMAN FAY M.HARDY DAVID J.PLANTE 17871 ALTAMIRANO LN 17881 ALTAMIRANO LN 17891 ALTAMIRANO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6607 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6607 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6607 165-351-07 165-351-08 165-351-09 STEPHEN P.DURANT LEO R.CHIECHI TONY S.&MICHELE M.HUNT 3702 SEASCAPE DR 6521 CADIZ CIR 6511 CADIZ CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-2520 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6613 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6613 165-351-10 165-351-11 165-351-12 LINDA TRAN ARTHUR J.LAMBERT KENNETH D.SIMMONS 6501 CADIZ CIR 6502 CADIZ CIR 100 FLUOR DANIEL DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6613 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6613 GREENVILLE SC 29607-2761 165-351-13 165-351-14 165-351-15 KENNETH A.&MICHAELA CARPENTER CHARLES W.JOHNS CHING-SONG &RUFUNG K.CHANG 6522 CADIZ CIR 6562 LUCIENTO DR 9069 MCBRIDE RIVER AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6613 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6631 FOUNTAIN VALLEY CA 92708-6405 165-351-16 165-352-01 165-352-02 OVA JAMES M.BURROUGHS JOHN P.HILGER 6582 LUCIENTO DR 18102 NEWMOON LN 17862 ALTAMIRANO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6631 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-1027 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6604 165-352-03 165-352-04 165-352-05 HORACE R.ROBERTS JOHN R.&LINDA CALKINS MARTINEZ DENISE K TRUST 17401 ALMELO LN 17882 ALTAMIRANO LN 17892 ALTAMIRANO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-4622 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6604 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6604 165-352-06 165-352-07 165-352-08 THOMAS J.DOWNS ROBERT P.&SHARON L.PIERSON MARK SPANGRUD 17912 ALTAMIRANO LN 17922 ALTAMIRANO LN 5611 RIDGEBURY DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6610 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6610 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-4827 165-352-09 165-352-10 165-352-11 DAVID J.&DEBORAH A.LUJAN RAYMOND E.WARD LAURENCE A.BROWN 6571 LUCIENTO DR 19431 RANCH LN#108 8472 DEEPVIEW DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6630 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2442 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-3810 165-352-12 165-352-13 165-352-14 CURTIS D.CAMPBELL RICHARD RAY WEBER DOYLE E.LOCKWOOD 2060 N TUSTIN AVE 6611 LUCIENTO DR 6421 MYRTLE DR SANTA ANA CA 92705-7827 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6630 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-3319 165-352-15 165-352-16 165-352-17 JOAN P.NELSON JAMES D.VAN GORDER GORDER DAVID &LAURA GOMEZ 17911 CARRANZA LN 17891 CARRANZA LN 6572 COLON CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6670 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6670 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6667 165-352-18 165-352-19 165-352-20 MEL H.&GAY H.CONNLEY ROUKOZ &ROBIN R.ELKHOURI NEWLIN TRUST 6561 COLON CIR 6571 COLON CIR 17881 CARRANZA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6667 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6667 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6674 165-352-21 165-352-22 165-352-23 LAWRENCE D.&VIRGINIA A.CAFIERO GERALD LEE NIXON RALPH H.HAGGARD 17871 CARRANZA LN 17861 CARRANZA LN 17851 CARRANZA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6674 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6674 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6674 165-353-01 165-353-02 165-353-03 JOSEPH JACK&LUCINDA L.BONVILLAIN LINDA D.&DAVID L.FARROW MAJESTA M.HUDSON 6602 ARACENA DR 6612 ARACENA DR 6622 ARACENA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6611 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6611 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6611 165-353-04 165-353-05 165-353-06 NORMAN G.&SANDY D.JORGENSEN PETER L.RASIC NANCY D.ALLEN 17852 SAN DOVAL LN 17851 QUINTANA LN 17861 QUINTANA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6679 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6673 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6673 165-353-07 165-353-08 165-353-09 TIMOTHY J.WALKER CLAIRE POTTS SHAWN D.JONES 17871 QUINTANA LN 17881 QUINTANA LN 17891 QUINTANA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6673 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6673 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6673 165-353-10 165-353-11 165-353-12 GARY J.TUCKER JOHN R.&SHARON R.SNAPPER ANTONY E.&ELIZABETH S.BRINE 17896 CARRANZA LN 17892 CARRANZA LN 17882 CARRANZA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6664 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6664 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6664 165-353-13 165-353-14 165-354-01 JEANNE C.CRAIG KEVIN A.&YVONNE N.WALSH KAMAL K.NARANG 17872 CARRANZA LN 17862 CARRANZA LN 4321 MOUNTAIN SHADOWS DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6664 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6664 WHITTIER CA 90601-1723 165-354-02 165-354-03 165-354-04 DENNIS MASUDA RONALD D.DI LAURA LAURA DEAN MAHER 17862 QUINTANA LN 17872 QUINTANA LN 17882 QUINTANA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6678 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6678 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6678 165-354-05 165-354-06 165-354-08 DENNIS D.LAMBERT GEORGE A.CASTELLI KENNETH G.ERICKSON PO BOX 2157 6681 SORIA CIR 17892 QUINTANA LN MONTROSE CO 81402-2157 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6644 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6669 165-354-09 165-354-10 165-354-11 NANCY C.RUSH JOHN E.MERRILL JACK C.&LEAH J.HEINRICH 17912 QUINTANA LN 17922 QUINTANA LN 704 SANDPIPER DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6669 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6669 SEAL BEACH CA 90740-5744 165-354-12 165-354-13 165-354-14 LILLIAN E.METTEER JAMES WALTER PETERSON RONALD J.GILBERT 6641 LUCIENTO DR 6651 LUCIENTO DR 6661 LUCIENTO DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6672 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6672 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6672 165-354-15 165-354-16 165-354-17 WILLIAM H.SMAW VELARDE TRUST BRIAN D.LA SALLE SALLE 6671 LUCIENTO DR 6681 LUCIENTO DR 17921 SAN LEANDRO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6672 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6672 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6639 165-354-18 165-354-19 165-354-20 MICHAEL D.SLOAN GENEVIEVE GROVER HOWARD L.DAVIS 17911 SAN LEANDRO LN 17901 SAN LEANDRO LN 17891 SAN LEANDRO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6639 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6639 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6639 165-354-21 165-354-22 165-354-23 STEPHEN BARKER JOYCE ANN WEBBER HIROSHI &YOSHIKO YANO 17881 SAN LEANDRO LN 17871 SAN LEANDRO LN 17861 SAN LEANDRO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6639 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6639 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6639 165-354-24 165-355-01 165-355-02 CHARLES J.WALLACE DIANA RIZZO JIMMIE S.&MARIA P.HINES 17851 SAN LEANDRO LN 6602 LUCIENTO DR 6612 LUCIENTO DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6676 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6632 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6632 165-355-03 165-355-04 165-355-05 HARUO OHSHIMA JAMES E.BAILEY JERRY L.PEDIGO 6622 LUCIENTO DR 6642 LUCIENTO DR 6652 LUCIENTO DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6632 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6632 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6632 165-355-06 165-355-07 165-355-09 MAXIMILLIANO &ANDREA CONTRERAS STAN L.ARROLLADO MARK S.&MAUREEN C.JENNINGS 1101 TIJERAS AVE NW 6672 LUCIENTO DR 6711 CALPE CIR ALBUQUERQUE NM 87102-2911 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6632 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6614 165-355-10 165-355-11 165-355-12 LARRY L.HENDERSON RIP ALLAN&SHARLENE E.SANDERS JOSEPH T.WHALING 6721 CALPE CIR 6962 LAWN HAVEN DR 6732 CALPE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6614 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2121 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6614 165-355-13 165-355-14 165-355-15 FRANK BOROSTYANKOI BILLIE J.COPEN ROBERT A.OWENS 6722 CALPE CIR 6712 CALPE CIR 17912 SAN LEANDRO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6614 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6614 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6677 165-355-16 165-355-17 165-355-18 PHILLIP A.&TRACY R.LUTH M.KATHRYN ANGELONI SUSAN JANE WEXLER 17902 SAN LEANDRO LN 17892 SAN LEANDRO LN 17882 SAN LEANDRO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6677 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6677 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6677 165-355-19 165-355-20 165-355-21 CHRISTOPHER ANDREW&IRMA MARGARITA GEORGE A.&SANDRA L.SEDIA BONNIE ELLEN MILLER MN LEANDRO LN 17862 SAN LEANDRO LN PO BOX 1594 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6677 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6677 SUNSET BEACH CA 90742-1594 165-391-05 165-391-0 165-391-23 GERALD A.JONES GERALD A.JONES STANKO FAMILY LTD PARTNERS HIP 16771 BAYVIEW DR 16771 YVIEW DR 16771 BOLERO LN SUNSET BEACH CA 90742 SUNS BEACH CA 90742 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-3025 165-3 1-27 165-391-37 165-391-38 AUGUST ROHLFS CLIFFORD Z.BATTELLE 10832 ALTA ST 1833 E 17TH ST#320 GRASS VALLEY CA 95945-4923 SANTA ANA CA 92705-8629 165-391- 165-391-40 165-391-41 STANKO FAMI LTD PARTNERS HIP ROBERT A.CONTORELLI GERD G.&TERE K.OTTERBACH 16771 BOLERO L 17712 METZLER LN 2612 SALMON DR HUNTINGTON BEA CA 92649-3025 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6245 ROSSMOOR CA 90720-4928 165-391-43 165-39 165-391-45 METZLER INDUSTRIAL SLATER METZLE INDUSTRIAL SLATER METZLER I USTRIAL SLATER 17532 METZLER LN 17532 M TZLER LN 17532 M ZLER LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647 6239 HUNTIN TON BEACH CA 92647-6239 HUNTI TON BEACH CA 92647-6239 165-391-46 165-391-47 165-392-01 JERRY L.VANIMAN DEWAYNE L.BROWN RAFAELA SOLORZANO 17762 METZLER LN 3651 AQUARIUS DR 7890 SPEER AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6245 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-2504 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6726 165-392-02 165-392-03 165-392-04 RAFAELA SOLORZANO RUBEN C.SOLORZANO RUBE O 7899.SP�EER AVE 7890 7890 SPEER AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6726 . HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6726 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6726 165-392-05 165-392-06 165-392-07 JACK SINDER TAKASHI YAMADA JACK S ER 16055 VENTURA BLVD#1002 8312 KINER AVE 16055 ENTURA BLVD#1002 ENCINO CA 91436-2611 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-1520 ENCINO CA 91436-2611 165-392-08 165-392-09 165-392-10 JACK aMER JACK SINDE 16055 VENTURA BLVD#1002 --- 055 VENTURA BLVD#1002 16055 VENTURA BLVD#100 ENCINO CA 91436-2611 ENCINO CA 91436-2611 ENCINO CA 91436-2611 165-392-11 165-392-12 165-392-13 JACK SINDER JACK SINDER JACK SINDER .1 LVD#1002 ENCINO CA 91436-2611 ENCINO CA 91436-2611 ENCINO CA 91436-2611 165-392-14 165-392-15 165-392-25 JACK SIND�� HAROLD KENNETH MOORE ELLWIN E.ASHWILL 16055 VE�TURA BLVD#1002 600 MAGNOLIA WAY 725 W TOWN AND COUNTRY RD#140 ENCI CA 91436-2611 LA HABRA CA 90631-5964 ORANGE CA 92868-4704 165-392-26 165-392-38 165-392-39 SAM PAZZULLA KENNETH J.&DOROTHY J.BOURGUIGNON JOHN T.HEWITT 10297 CARDINAL AVE 17712 GOTHARD ST 5492 BOLSA AVE FOUNTAIN VALLEY CA 92708-7403 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6253 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-1021 '4. 165-392-40 165-392-4 165-392-42 ORGAN-O-SIL FIBER CO INC ORGAN -SIL FIBER CO INC RALPH C.RIGGS PO BOX 86 PO BO 86 1824 PARK ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-0086 HUNTI GTON BEACH CA 92648-0086 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2735 165-392-43 165-392-44 165-392-46 ROBERT M.BLINN ROBERT M.BLINN DONALD E.GOODE 1615 GLORIETTA BLVD 1615 GLORIETTA BLVD 219 ALABAMA ST CORONADO CA 92118-2912 CORONADO CA 92118-2912 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-5205 165-392-47 165-392-48 165-392-49 DONALD .GOODE LLOYD W.DYE LLOY �DYE219 A AMA ST 17532 GOTHARD ST 17 2 GST HUNT GTON BEACH CA 92648-5205 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6214 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6214 165-392-50 165-392-51 165-392-52 DONALD GOODE ALBERT J.GEIS LLOY�DE 219 ALA AMA ST 17532 GOTHARD ST 17 ST HUNTI GTON BEACH CA 92648-5205 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6214 NTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6214 165-392-54 165-392-60 165-392-62 TAKASHI YAMADA AKIO TSUCHIDA JELE &STJEPAN HERCEG 8312 KINER AVE 6093 RONALD CIR 8461 GRACE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH.CA 92646-1520 CYPRESS CA 90630-3946 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-3125 165-392-63 165-392-64 165-392-66 DEWAYNE L.BROWN BRUCE B.COOK DONALD E.GOODE 3651 AQUARIUS DR 5910 LAKESHORE DR 219 ALABAMA ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-2504 CYPRESS CA 90630-3371 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-5205 165 92-67 165-392-69 165-392-70 DON D E.GOODE STEVEN C.STUMP DEWAYNE L.BROWN 219 A AMA ST 17631 METZLER LN 3651 AQUARIUS DR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-5205 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6244 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-2504 165-392-71 165-392-72 165-401-01 MAHENDRA D.SANGHVI JAMES R.HETZLER M&M MACHINE&TOOL CO INC 17780 GOTHARD ST 208 CRYSTAL BAY COURT 17800 GOTHARD ST HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6216 RANCHO MIRAGE CA 92270-3125 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6217 165-401-03 165-401-04 165-401-06 R.L.CALL STORAGE EURO PARTNE RSHIP 7.LT PUBLI YIH SHUNG&MEI KUEI LEE 3802 SEASCAPE DR PO BOX 25025 17925 METZLER LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-2524 GLENDALE CA 91221-5025 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6258 165-401-07 165-401-08 165-401-09 CLENDENEN PROPERTIES BIG DOG INVESTMENTS LLC RALPH B.MOSBACH 4639 TREMONT LN 17875 METZLER LN 17932 METZLER LN CORONA DEL MAR CA 92625-3130 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6257 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6256 165-401-10 165-40 -11 165-401-12 SHIGETO SHIWOTA SHIGE 0 SHIWOTA DANIEL J.&BRENDA FINK 6761 MORNING TIDE DR 6761 M RNING TIDE DR 415 CREST AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2627 HUNTI GTON BEACH CA 92648-2627 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-3438 165-401-13 165 1-14 165-401-15 CARL E.TENBRINK COOKING STEMS IN C.DYNAMIC OMAR DEEN 6851 PRESIDIO DR 10850 PORTAL R 17802 METZLER LN HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-3065 LOS ALAMITOS 90720-2509 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6255 165401-16 165-401-17 165-401-18 JAMES R.WENTZ MANILAL &REKHA PADHIAR MANTHEI 5181 STALLION CIR 17782 METZLER LN 3541 COURTSIDE CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-3607 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6245 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-2924 165-401-19 165401-20 165-401-21 ROBERT &MARY TADDEO ERIC CHEN HBI PARTNERS 3 18204 S 3RD ST 3392 VENTURE DR 71 64TH PL FOUNTAIN VALLEY CA 92708-4427 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-2551 LONG BEACH CA 90803-5677 165-401-22 165401-23 165-401-24 TOM R.&LINDA L.STEPHEN JOHN H.ECKHARDT JEFFREY M.&MARY H.LEONARD 7451 TALBERT AVE BLDG 3 PO BOX 3747 25732 HIGHPLAINS TERRACE HUNTINGTON BEACH-CA 92648-1209 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92605-3747 LAGUNA HILLS CA 92653-6316 165-401-25 165-401-26 165-401-27 AMIGOS LLC LEE G A SYSTEMS INC LEONARD TRUST 3991 MACARTHUR BLVD#100 17872 GOTHARD ST 17892 GOTHARD ST NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-3030 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6217 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6217 165-401-28 165-411-01 165-411-02 JEFFREY M.&MARY H.LEONARD BRYANT R.&MARILYN K.SELLER MILLEN RODNEY K TRUST 25732 HIGHPLAINS TERRACE 17491 APEX CIR 7572 REYNOLDS CIR LAGUNA HILLS CA 92653-6316 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5728 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-6787 165-411-03 165-411-04 165-411-05 WILLARD C.&PATRICIA C.JOHNSON MAHESH M.PATEL KATSUJI &YASUYO KAWAKUBO 5412 BOLSA AVE#B 17441 APEX CIRCLE 17411 APEX CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-1056 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5728 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5728 165-411-06 165-411-07 165-411-08 ERNANI &MARIA VIRGINIA DORR JOHN M.&SANDRA L.MESSICK YOUNG TRAN 17442 APEX CIRCLE 17452 APEX CIR 17462 APEX CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5728 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5728 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5728 165-411-09 165411-10 165-411-11 ELI T.LEE JOSEPH T.LEE STEVEN &DEBRA LEITNER 9371 POWER DR 9371 POWER DR 6241 FLORENCE AV HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-7236 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-7236 BELL GARDENS CA 90201-3227 165-411-12 165-411-13 165-41 -14 STEPHEN &JERILYN TR RIMEL RAYMOND G.DURDA RAYMO G.DURDA 190 MONARCH BAY DR 6661 MORNING TIDE DR 6661 MR ING TIDE DR MONARCH BEACH CA 92629-3434 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92648-2606 HUNTINGT N BEACH CA 92648-2606 165-411-15 165-411-16 165-411-17 CARLOS A.&ZULMA C.CELLA WILLIAM C.GOODMAN TAKASHI YAMADA 506 LAKESIDE DR 17032PALMDALEST#C 8312 KINER AVE FULLERTON CA 92835-1541 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-5424 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-1520 165-411-18 165-411-19 165-411-20 JESUS AGUILERA STEPHEN J.RIMEL JOSEPH PLANCARTE AGUILERA PO BOX 147 190 MONARCH BAY DR PO BOX 1291 SUNSET BEACH CA 90742-0147 MONARCH BEACH CA 92629-3434 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92647-1291 165-411-21 JESUS AGUILERA PO BOX 147 SUNSET BEACH CA 90742-0147 110-151-10 110-152-03 110-152-22 Gary Turman Luo,Yevonne Shenk,Robert PO Box 307 19632 Clancy Ln 1735 Stanford Ave. Crestline,CA.92325 Huntington Beach,CA. 92646 Menlo Park,CA.94025 110-210-20 110-210-22 111-381-01 Bartoli,Joseph Shen,Jay Olson,Todd 6901 Derby Cir. 6935 Derby Cir. 7272 Bazil Cir. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111-381-02 111-381-03 111-381-04 Bliss,Con Hu,Liang Kuang Frank Mardin Conrad 7282 Bazil Cir. 7292 Bazil Cir. 18521 Bentley Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 111-381-05 111-381-06 111-381-07 Goodman,Phillip Conboy,Leo Santana,Jose 18531 Bentley PO Box 19678 18545 Bentley Ln. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Irvine,CA. 92623 Huntington Beach, CA. 92648 111-381-08 111-381-09 111-381-10 Heapy,Roderick O'Connell,John Chiu,Jung 18549 Bentley Ln 18555 Bentley Ln 18565 Bentley Ln. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111-381-11 111-381-12 111-381-13 Williams,James II Heine,Philip Le,Hoai 18558 Bentley Ln. 18548 Bentley Ln. 18538 Bentley Ln. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 111-381-14 111-381-15 111-381-17 Horn,Jerry KIingensmith,Jack Brown,Ricky 18528 Bentley Ln. 18518 Bentley Ln. 7385 Sherwood Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111-381-18 111-381-19 111-381-20 Berg,Kevin Hunter,Stirling Peters,Mark 7384 Sherwood 7380 Sherwood 7374 Sherwood Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111-381-21 111-381-22 111-381-23 Tran,Thuy Thi Armitage,David Martanegara,James 7370 Sherwood 7366 Sherwood 7362 Sherwood Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 111-381-24 111-381-25 111-381-26 Read,Steven Abando,Angelito Wolfe,Gary 7358 Sherwood 7354 Sherwood 7350 Sherwood Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 g:\fbnns\address\Iabe is 111-381-27 111-381-30 111-381-33 Suzuki,Richard Sherwood Assn.C/o Don Boortz Sherwood Assn. C/o Janet 7346 Sherwood 610 Newport Center#700 4100 Newport P1. #350 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Newport,CA.92660 Newport Beach, CA. 92660 111-391-01 111-391-02 --111-391-03 Sinn,Pearl Shutts,Robert Chandryko,Janusz 7096 Foxboro Cir. 7092 Foxboro Cir. 12476 Picrus St. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 San Diego, CA. 92129 111-391-04 111-391-05 i 11-391-06 Covert,Howard Philips,Gerald Cao,Jason 7072 Foxboro Cir. 7062 Foxboro Cir. 7052 Foxboro Cir. Huntington Beach, CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111-391-07 111-391-08 111-391-09 Haas,Gordon Soriano,Valerian Woicik,Chris 7042 Foxboro Cir. 7032 Foxboro Cir. 7031 Foxboro Cir. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111-391-10 111-391-11 111-391-12 Sherlock,James Lim,Ernest Martinez, Scott 7037 Foxboro Cir. 7045 Foxboro Cir. 7055 Foxboro Cir. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111-391-13 111-391-14 111-391-15 Blake,Kenneth Stnenseng,Arne Hubbard,Jeff 7065 Foxboro Cir. 7075 Foxboro Cir. 7085 Foxboro Cir. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111-391-16 111-391-19 111-39140 Yoon,David Richard,Robert Siart,Jack 7095 Foxboro Cir. 7072 Foxboro Cir. 7045 Ashley Dr. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111-391-62 111-391-63 111-391-64 Feiner,Ron Nguyen,Stefanb Shelley,Terry 18657 Ambrose Ln. 18665 Ambrose Ln. 18675 Ambrose Ln. Huntington Beach CA 92648 Huntington Beach CA 92648 Huntington Beach CA 92648 111-391-65 111-391-68 111-391-70 Pretrowski,Wojtek O'neil,Richard Sherwood Neighbad Assn. C/o heffern 18685 Ambrose Ln. 18705 Ambrose Ln. 610 Newport Beach#700 Huntington Beach CA 92648 Huntington Beach CA 92648 Newport Beach,CA.92660 111401-01 111401-02 111401-04 Apple,Robert Matsunari,James Spates,Frederick 18769 Ambrose Ln. 18775 Ambrose Ln. 18789 Ambrose Ln. Huntington Beach, CA.92648 Huntington Beach CA 92648 Huntington Beach CA 92648 g:\forms\address\labels 111-401-06 111-401-09 111-401-05 Fowler, William Moller,Brian Axtell,Jonathan 7104 Forest Glen Dr. 7134 Forest Glen Dr. 18797 Ambrose Ln. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach, CA.92648 Huntington Beach CA 92648 111-401-24 111-401-27 111401-28 Trilevsky,Michael Ta,Thanh Linvorapun, Suhat 18708 Stratton Ln. 18694 Stratton Ln. 18690 Stratton Ln: Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 111-401-29 111-401-30 111-401-31 Field,Scott Payne,Richard Womack,Michael 7225 Sherwood Dr. 7215 Sherwood Dr. 7205 Sherwood Dr. Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach, CA. 92648 Huntington Beach, CA. 92648 111-401-32 111-401-33 111-401-34 Rowe,Dustin Johnson,James Farney,Joseph 7195 Sherwood Dr. 7185 Sherwood Dr. 7175 Sherwood Dr. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 111401-36 111-401-35 111-401-37 Nehls,William Kalamian,Mitchell Kim,Jamie 18637 Ambrose Ln. 18631 Ambrose Ln. 18645 Ambrose Ln. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111401-39 111-401-40 111-401-41 Tawa Yasahiko Nuno,Martin Lahage, Chris 18652 Ambrose Ln. 18662 Ambrose Ln. 18668 Ambrose Ln. Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 111-401-42 111-401-43 111-401-44 Hoang,Victor Kratzer,Rick Panchak,Edward 18676 Ambrose Ln. 18682 Ambrose Ln. 18688 Ambrose Ln. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111-401-45 111-401-46 11140147 Mandel Michael Rubio,Rhonda Pathak,Kishorchandra 18700 Ambrose Ln. 18702 Ambrose Ln. 18708 Ambrose Ln. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111-401-48 111-401-49 111401-50 O'Dwyer,Francis Hernandez,Arthur Lo,Henry 18714 Ambrose Ln. 18722 Ambrose Ln. 18728 Ambrose Ln. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 111-401-51 111-401-52 111-401-53 Lee,John Bonas,Maury Passaguindici,Allen 18734 Ambrose Ln. 18742 Ambrose Ln. 18748 Ambrose Ln. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 g:\forms\address\labels 111-401-54 111-401-55 111-401-56 Nguyen,Phuong Dicambio,Michael Einman, Glenn 18754 Ambrose Ln. 18762 Ambrose Ln. 18766 Ambrose Ln. Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach, CA. 92648 111-401-57 111-401-58 111-401-69 Kieu,Nam Ranalli,Anthony Hudson,Bradley 18774 Ambrose Ln. 18769 Stratton Ln. 18715 Stratton Ln. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111401-70 111-401-71 111-401-72 Nguyen,Tien McCleery,Troy Sullivan,Dennis 18707 Stratton Ln 18701 Stratton Ln 18695 Stratton Ln Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 111-401-74 111-411-01 111-411-04 Dinh,Thong Le,Diem Medina,Louis 18687 Stratton Ln 18705 Ashford Ln 18723 Ashford Ln Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111-411-05 111-411-06 111-411-07 Knorr,Brian Lliteras,Janet Hart,Peter 18729 Ashford Ln 18737 Ashford Ln 18741 Ashford Ln Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111-411-08 111-411-09 111-411-10 Reichert,Beverly Bunker,Gregory Zappala,Joseph 18745 Ashford Ln 18751 Ashford Ln 18757 Ashford Ln Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111-411-11 111-411-12 111-411-13 Donovan,Chris Vraneza,Joseph Jones, Gregory 18763 Ashford Ln 18767 Ashford Ln 18771 Ashford Ln Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 111-411-14 111-411-15 111-411-16 Tran,Tuan Lace,Jeff Kelly,James 18775 Ashford Ln 18779 Ashford Ln 18783 Ashford Ln Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111-411-17 111-411-18 111-411-19 Hansen,Kyle Scmidt,Pat Carr, Stephen 7206 Rockridge 7216 Rockridge 7226 Rockridge Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach, CA. 92648 111-411-20 111-411-21 111411-29 Yotsuya,Hideo Carder,David Yang,Tung 7236 Rockridge 7246 Rockridge 18752 Fairfax Ln. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 g:\fomis\address\labels 111-411-38 111-411-33 111-411-35 Dubar,Thomas Irving,George DiLuzio,Jennifer 7310 Sherwood 18722 Fairfax Ln. 18706 Fairfax Ln. Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach, CA.92648 1 I 1-411-49 I 11-411-52 111-411-53 Tucker,Kent Oye,Jon Schrader,Gene 18763 Fairfax Ln. 18774 Ashford 18768 Ashford Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 111-411-54 111-411-55 111411-56 Smith, Scott Nowak,Michael Galvin,Dennis 18762 Ashford 18756 Ashford 18748 Ashford Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 111-411-57 111-411-58 111-411-59 Sitton,Robert Powell,Joe Elisha,Sasson 18742 Ashford 18736 Ashford 18728 Ashford Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 111-411-60 159-022-05 159-022-31 Wahlgren-Lindstrom,Anita Fee,Fredrick Duncan,Bernard 18722 Ashford 18062 Shoreview Cir. 6561 Lakeview Dr. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 159-022-37 159-063-07 159-063-23 De Moulin,Diane Otto,Bates Sharen Fike,Bradley 22676 Water Way 7532 Appleby Dr. 18331 Carnaby Ln Lake Forest,CA.92630 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 159-063-24 159-081-18 159-083-06 Shih,Ko-liang Larsen,Eric Bilotti,Alfred 2449 W 228`s St. 18102 Lakepoint Ln. 16357 Wimbledon Lane Torrance,CA.90501 Huntington Beach,CA.92647 Huntington Beach,CA.92649 159-085-01 159-085-14 159-211-01 Ruzuecki,James Poe,Charles Ellonis Enterprises 18081 Brentwell Cir. 18092 Fieldbury Ln 507 N Rodeo Dr. Huntington Beach,CA.92647 Huntington Beach,CA. 92649 Beverly Hills, CA. 90210 159-255-09 159-255-11 159-351-30 Hetzler,Robert Amador,Dino c/0 Saudi Aramco Nguyen,Ha Son 16751 Sea Witch PO Box 1664 Abqaiq 6572 Polo Cir. Huntington Beach,CA.92649 Saudi Arabia 31311 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 159-352-02 159-361-02 159-411-01 Smith,Bradley Dramavandi,Fard Wigney,Dave 6671 Shire Cir. 30402 Via Estoril 6861 Derby Cir. Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Laguna Niguel,CA.92677 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 g:\fbnns\address\1abe1s 159-411-08 159-411-15 165-024-10 Pascoe,Anthony James Rye Schnorr,Ron 6751 Derby Cir. 18711 Jockey Cir. 6762 Via Carona Dr. Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach, CA.92647 165-031-04 165-031-31 165-033-01 Metaxas,Elaine Beuttell,Lynn Gocke, Sewell 6901 Los Amigos Cir. 788 E.Linden 6882 Vista Del Sol Huntington Beach,CA. 92647 Lake Forest,IL. 60045 Huntington Beach, CA. 92647 165-033-07 165-072-06 165-074-12 Shea,Rich Nielsen,Jorgen Baggetta,Mark 6931 Via Carona 6772 Baker Dr. 6852 Spickard Dr. Huntington Beach,CA.92647 Huntington Beach,CA. 92647 Huntington Beach,CA.92647 165-075-06 165-093-09 165-093-12 Kotlensky,William Sanbau,LLC Hartstein, Steven 22111 Newport Ave.#136 17391 Whetmore Ln. 4240 Harbor Blvd.B-307 Grand Terrace,CA.92313 Huntington Beach,CA.92647 Oxnard,CA. 93035 165-151-43 165-152-33 165-164-01 Boyer,Esther Spencer,Terry Takahama,James 5901 Lancefield Dr. PO Box 3058 6692 Jardines Dr. Huntington Beach,CA.92649 Huntington Beach,CA.92645 Huntington Beach, CA.92647 165-201-02 165-202-06 165-202-07 Atkins,Ann Camp,Roger Merlino,Jeff 11255 Big Dipper Dr. 7021 Betty Dr. 7001 Betty Dr. Mira Loma,CA. 91752 Huntington Beach,CA.92647 Huntington Beach,CA.92647 165-203-05 165-203-20 165-203-33 George,Butlerworth Brackman,Steve Tyler,Kathleen 7072 Betty Dr. 17321 Mill Cir. 17331 Lee Cir. Huntington Beach,CA. 92647 Huntington Beach,CA. 92647 Huntington Beach,CA.92647 165-203-43 165-204-15 165-205-02 Wixom,Julie Bruno,Carlo Gaglione,Joseph 17342 Lee Cir. 5120 Lincoln Ave.#326 7102 Nimrod Dr. Huntington Beach,CA.92647 Cypress,CA.90630 Huntington Beach,CA.92647 165-211-04 165-212-19 165-215-07 Eriksson,per Richords,Larry Mezher,Samir 35 Cliffwood 6657 Deer Park 7211 Slater Ave. Aliso Viejo,CA.92656 Miopines,CA.95345 Huntington Beach,CA.92647 165-261-08 165-261-09 165-261-69 Sullivan,Will Gale,Doris Chetta,Joseph 7212 Woodwind Dr. 4422 Tomlinson PO Box 1386 Huntington Beach,CA.92647 Arlington,CA.92503 Cambria,CA.93428 gAforms\address\labels 165-271-10 165-343-15 165-344-15 Soehendro,Anwar Shorb,Ray Uhden,Roger 17462 Grass Cir. 17791 Carranza Ln. 17781 San Doval Huntington Beach,CA.92647 Huntington Beach,CA.92647 Huntington Beach,CA. 92647 165-345-13 165-352-10 165-352-12 Crawford,Jeff Ward,Ray Campell, Curtis 17811 Quintana 6581 Luciento Dr. 5862 Liege Dr. Huntington Beach,CA.92647 Huntington Beach,CA.92647 Huntington Beach,CA. 92649 165-352-13 165-391-05 165-392-38 Richard,Weber Gaj Properties Bourguignon,Ken 7702 Joel Ave. PO Box 337 7071 Warner Ave.#F-410 Stanton,CA.90680 Sunset Beach,CA. 90742 Huntington Beach,CA. 92647 165-392-43 165-39244 165-392-62 Blinn,Robert Blinn,Robert Herreg,Jele 4013 Corte Tierra Alta 1400 Glorietta Blvd. 19562 Mayfield La mesa,CA.91941 Coronado,CA.92118 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 165-401-14 165-411-02 165-411-03 Dynamic Cooking Systems Athey,Graig Johnson,Willard 5800 Skylab Rd. 7441 Vincent Cir. 17461 Apex Cir. Huntington Beach,CA.92647 Huntington Beach,CA.92648 Huntington Beach,CA. 92647 165-411-15 159-011-13 159-083-16 Cella,Carlos Hague,Pauline Hams Susan 18266 Santa Carlotta 18102 Freshwater Cir. 16851 Bluewater Cir. Foutain Valley,CA.92708 Huntington Beach,CA. 92648 Huntington Beach,CA.92649 Leonard R. Espinosa 11016316 11140103 6882 Evening Hill John Robinson TR Timothy Ashcroft Huntington Beach, CA 92648 2110 E. 4800 South 18781 Ambrose Ln. Salt Lake City, UT 84117 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 16534605 16534613 16534616 David Rubio Robert Sigler Richard Nowak 17792 Quintana 17811 San Leandro 17771 San Leandro Huntington Beach, Ca 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, Ca 92647 I'5qCr1Zoy ?-Obe'Y 4 0-11 Z P2.10(-tV' gAforms\address\labels President 1 County of Orange Public Facilities & Pacific Coast Archaeological 18 H.B. Chamber of Commerce Resources Dept./H.I.Nakasone Society,Inc. 2210 Main Street,Suite 200 P.O. Box 4048 P.O. Box 10926 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Santa Ana,CA 7 02-4048 Costa Mesa,CA 92627 Attn:Jane Gothold Judy Legan 2 Mr.Tom Zanic 12 County of Orange/EMA 19 Orange County Assoc.of Realtors New Urban West Iviichael M.Ruane,Dir. 25552 La Paz Road, 520 Broadway Ste. 100 P.O. Box 4048 Laguna Hills,CA 92653 Santa Monica,CA 90401 Santa Ana,CA 92702-4048 President 3 Council on Aging 15 County of Orange/EMA 19 Amigos De Bolsa Chica 1706 Orange Ave. Thomas Mathews P. O.Box 3748 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 P. O. Box 4048 Huntington Beach,CA 92605 Santa Ana,CA 92702-4048 President 5 Jeff Metzel 16 Planning Department 19 Huntington Beach Tomorrow Seacliff HOA Orange County EMA PO Box 865 19391 Shady Harbor Circle P. O.Box 4048 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Santa Ana,CA 92702-4048 Julie Vandermost 6 John Roe 16 County of Orange/EMA 19 BIA-OC Seacliff HOA Tim Miller 9 Executive Circle#100 19382 Surfdale Lane P.O. Box 4048 Irvine Ca 92714-6734 Huntington Be ,-h,CA 92648 Santa Ana,CA 92702-4048 Richard Spicer 7 Lou Mannone 16 Planning Dir. 20 SCAG Seacliff HOA City of Costa Mesa 818 West 7th,12th Floor 19821 Ocean Bluff Circle P. O.Box 1200 Los Angeles,CA 90017 Huntington Beach CA 92648 Costa Mesa,CA 92628-1200 E.T.I. Corral 100 8 FANS 16 OC County Harbors,Beach 35 Mary Bell John Miles and Parks Dept. 20292 Eastwood Cir. 19415 Castlewood Cir. P. O.Box 4048 Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Santa Ana,CA 92702-4048 John Scandura 9 Sue Johnson 16 Bolsa Chica Land Trust 40 Environmental Board Chairman 19671 Quiet Bay Lane Nancy Donovan,President 17492 Valeworth Circle Huntington Beach,CA 92648' 4831 Los Patos Huntington Beach,CA 92649 Huntington Beach,CA 92649 William D.Holman 11 Edna Littlebury 17 Koll Company 39 PLC Gldn St. Mob.Hm.Owners Leag. 4343 Von Karman 23 Corporate Plaza,Suite 250 11021 Magnol?..Blvd. Newport Beach,CA 92666 Newport Beach CA 92660-7912 Garden Grove,CA 92642 g:broeren\advance\hcpeir\noa1b1 Planning Dir. 21 Dr. Duane Dishno 29 City of Fountain Valley HB City Elementary School Dist. 10200 Slater Ave. PO Box 71 Fountain Valley,CA 92708 Huntington Beach,CA 92626 Planning Director 22 Jerry Buchanan 29 City of Westminster HB City Elementary School Dist. 8200 Westminster Blvd. 20451 Craimer Lane Westminster,CA 92683 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Planning Director 23 Mr. Herb Nakasone,General Mgr City of Seal Beach OC Flood Control District 211 Eight St 300 N. Flower Street Seal Beach,CA 90740 Santa Ana,CA 92702-4048 Sally Graham 38 Country View Estates HOA 37 Mr. Stanley Sprague,General Mgr Meadowlark Area Carrie Thomas OC Municipal Water District 5161 Gelding Circle 6642 Trotter Drive PO Box 20895 Huntington Beach,CA 92649 Huntington Beach CA 92648 Fountain Valley,CA 92728 Patricia Koch 32 Country View Estates HOA 37 Mr. Robert S.Warth HB Union High School Disrict Gerald Chapman Technical Supervisor,The Gas Co 10251 Yorktown Avenue 6742 Shire Circle PO Box 3334 Huntington Beach;CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92648 Anaheim,CA 92803-3334 Robert Joseph 25 HB Hamptons HOA 37 Mr.Wayne Pitzer,Supervising Engr Caltrans District 12 Keystone Pacific Prop.Mangmt Inc. So California Edison Company 3347 Michelson Dr, Ste. 100 4100 Newport Place,Suite 350 1325 South Grand Ave Irvine,CA 92612-0661 Newport Beach,Ca 92660 Santa Ana,CA 92705 Director 26 Orange County Sanitation District Mr. Gilbert Challey,District Mgr Local Solid Waste Enf.Agy. P.O.Box 8127 OC Vector Control District O.C.Health Care Agency Fountain Valley,CA 92728-8127 PO Box 87 P.O.Box 355 Santa Ana,CA 92702 Santa Ana,CA 92702 Ron Frazier 31 Mr.John Nelson,Asst Superintendent Mr.John Wodraska,Gen Mgr Westminster School District OC Department of Education Metropolitan Water District of SC 14121 Cedarwood Avenue 200 Kalmus Drive PO Box 54153 Westminster CA 92683 Costa Mesa,CiL 92628 Los Angeles,CA 90054 r Marc Ecker 28 Lisa Mills,CEO Mr.William R. Mills,Jr. Fountain Valley OC Transportation Authority(OCTA) General Mgr,OC Water District Elementary School District P.O.Box 14184 PO Box 8300 17210 Oak Street Orange,CA 92613-1582 Fountain Valley,CA 92708 Fountain Valley CA 92708 George Britton,Manager Mr.Robert Mazzola,Engineer Robert Moel,Vice President and Environmental Proj.Planning Div. Telephone Operations GTE General Manager Orange County EMA 7292 Slater Avenue Time Warner Communications PO Box 4048 Huntington Beach, CA 92647-6240 7441 Chapman Avenue Santa Ana, CA 92702-4048 Garden Grove, CA 92641 Ms. Patricia Wolf Aileen Taber g:broeren\advancelhcpeir\noatbl Regional Manager,Region 5 South Air Quality Management Dist Department of Fish and Game (SCAQMD) 330 Golden Shore,Suite 50 21865 E. Copley Drive Diamond Bar_CA 91765--4182 Terry Dolton Bob Winchell Gordon LaBedz 17892 Shoreham Lane 6411 Weber Circle 339 Regatta Way Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Seal Beach, CA 90740 Jan Vandersloot Victor Leipzig Bolsa Chica Conservancy 8101 Newman,#C Dr.Louann Murray 3842 Warner Avenue Huntington Beach, CA 92647 17461 Skyline Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach,CA 92649 Ocean View Little League Huntington Valley Little League Huntington Beach Surf City Baseball Bob Bernard,President Renee Aumiller Mike Gonya PO Box 351 209 Hartford 16787 Beach Blvd, #638 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Seaview Little League Huntington Beach Girls Softball Robinwood Little League Mike Cassidy Gale Coffman Donald Gray 21021 Kauch Cr. 16171 Littler Drive 15882 Duncalk Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Fountain Valley Youth Baseball Save Our Kids So Huntington Bch Jr.Miss Softball Bret Hardin Chuck Beauregard Marie Ensey 10222 Niagara Drive 5942 Edinger Ave, Ste 113-3 07 21252 Hillsdale Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92646 H.B. Field Hockey AYSO Region 55 AYSO Region 56 Manilal Padhiar Deborah Wilson Commissioner Cliff Anderson 17782 Metzler Drive 17801 Quintana Lane 9832 Kings Canyon Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92646 AYSO Region 117 AYSO Region 143 North Huntington Beach Soccer Club Leanne&Bob DeCrescentis Commissioner Don Ludolph President George Mitton 9632 Telhan Dr 5121 Tasman Dr 18601 Newland St,Unit 94 Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92646 South Coast Soccer Club Wolfpack Soccer Club Edison Aquatic Boosters President Bruce Bricks President Cory Hardin Marily Monahan, Co-President 9961 Kings Canyon Dr 9863 James River Circle 20051 Mayport Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Fountain Valley,CA 92708 Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Huntington Beach Jr. All American Huntington Beach Pop Warner Football County of Orange Integrated Waste Football Barry Ehrreich Management Department President Joe Lamkin 19931 Carmaria Ln Kevin Kondru 16691 Tunstall Ln#3 Huntington Beach, CA 92646 320 N.Flower St., Ste. 400 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Santa Ana,CA 92703 Camela Dillard,President Ocean View Pony/Colt HB Aquatics Booster Club HB High Tennis Booster Club Mike Gonya Tom Shaw,President 1905 Main Street 16787 Beach Blvd. 504 7ei Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 James Jones 30 g:broeren\advance\hcpe r\noalbl Ocean View Elementary School district 17200 Pinehurst Lane Huntington Beach CA 92647 Westminster School District HB Union High School District HB High Sch Baseball Boosters Dr. Gale Wickstrom, Supt. Susan Roper, Supt. Nick Tomaino 14121 Cedarwood Avenue 10251 Yorktown Avenue 6812 Scenic Bay Lane Westminster, CA 92683 Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 AYSO Region 143 Ocean View School District HB Volleyball Club. Commissioner Jorggi Delaney James R.Tarwater, Supt. Elizabeth Ward,President 5052 Sisson Dr. 17200 Pinehurst Lane 5382 El Dorado Drive Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Marina Aquatics Booster Club California Youth Hockey Assoc Huntington Valley Little League M.Beauregard,President Mike Muckenthaler Yvonne O'Reilly 15691 Sunburst Lane 1608 Hillcrest Circle 8711 Mossford Drive Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92646 HBHS Tennis Boosters Club Roller Hockey Ms. Tara Abdou Ms. JoAn poirel Bob Boland 6622 Cory Drive 18881 Santa Isadora Street 322 Main St%-et Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Fountain Valley, CA 92708 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Seaview Little League Ocean View Aquatics Boosters Nat'l Jr Basketball HB South Rick Fraser Doug Wood,President Ms.Linda Johnston,Vice President 22162 Laguna Cir. 6531 Kilda 21661 Brookhurst St.,Unit 328 Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Huntington Beach, CA 92646 AYSO Region 55 Boy Scouts of America Janet Beck David Smith Todd Meyer,Field Director 6782 Crista Palma Drive 16452 Woodstock Ln. 3590 Harbor Gateway N. Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Costa Mesa, CA 92626 Bill Garrity Girl Scouts of America HelenSpencer 18451 Repair Ln. Val Miller,Field Director Allied Arts Board Huntington Beach,CA 92648 1620 Adams Avenue 8766 Tulare#405C Costa Mesa, CA 92626 Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Chris Craig Roy Richardsc..-_, Paul Schmitt 529 Lake Street Citizens Participation Advis Bd New Deal Skate Co Huntington Beach, CA 92648 16982 Bedford Lane PO Box 3757 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92628 Kent Hawkins Alec Schroedor Loretta Wolfe 9 Sea Terrace Rampland Historic Resources Board Newport Beach, CA 92657 225 W.Duarte Rd. 411 6`h Street Monrovia, CA 91016 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Bob Filipek Tanya Grimes,Exec Director Meadowlark Golf Course 301 20'Street Hunt. Valley Boys&Girls Clubs Men's Club Huntington Beach, CA 92648 9191 Pioneer Drive 16782 Graham Street Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 g:broeren\advance\hcpeir\noaIbl Yevonne Luo Margaret T.Lindsey Elmer E.Brown 9886 Raritan Avenue 10081 Beverly Drive 524 S. 900 E Fountain Valley, CA 92708 Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Salt Lake City, UT 84102 Yuk T./So Lau Ronald T. McDevitt Cal Rietzel 8922 Ernest Fulsom Dr 27 Rue Cannes 15402 Capri Circle Garden Grove,CA 92841 Newport Beach, CA 92660 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Bob Mills Carl Clink,President Debbie Cook 19771 Elmcrest Lane Historical Society 6692 Shetland Circle Huntington Beach, CA 92646 824 Lake Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Thomas Boczar John Miller Duane Woolpert Double EagleEnterprises 9415 Mount Israell Rd Woolpert Imports, Inc. 301 Bear Ridge Escondido, CA 92029 1896 Redondo Ave Pleasantville,NY 10570 Signal Hill, CA 90804-1224 Yeturu R.Reddi Clarence A. Juhl George Cross 17610 Beach Blvd#55 9002 Regatta Drive 19842 Isthmus Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92626 Jim Ruziccki Carol Alter-Nelson Bill Blair 18081 Brentwell Circle 5702 Venture Drive 15732 Dawson Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Mark Bentley R.J.McNeil Michael Jacobs Indoor Soccer Park 16642 Irby Lane Pro Tour Classics 14530 Espola Road Huntington Beach, CA 92647 1001 S.El Cielo Dr. Poway, CA 92064 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Betty Kennedy Tom Duchene Mrs. Bryant 7672 Anita Lane 6871 Via Angelena Drive 17302 Drey Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Regina Frias Ann Bryan Higher Flyers Disc Golf Club 5101 Tortuga Drive 17302 Drey Lane Wayne Shurtz Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 PO Box 1134 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Park Bench Cafe Dave Graf Mary Harris, General Manager Michael&Christie Bartusick Gentry Golf Hunt. Central Park Equestrian Cntr 20431 Graystone Lane 14501 Acacia Drive 18381 Golden West Street Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Tustin, CA 32680 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 g:broeren\advanceXhcpeir\noalbl Ocean View Ests Mobile Home Jim Hicks John Ahart George Fader 7652 Garfield Avenue#18 190 Pomona Avenue 7051 Ellis Avenue, Space#43 Huntington Beach CA 92648 Long Beach, CA 90803 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 National Rifle Association Mary Blake Tom Freker,President Dennis Davenport 19431 Ranch Lane#103 Huntington Beach Soccer Club 16542 Kettler Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92648 6402 Shayne Drive Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Therapeutic Riding Center Alice's Breakfast in the Park Gerald A. Jones 5642 Windcroft Drive Alice Gustafson 16771 Bayview Drive Huntington Beach, CA 92649 6622 Lakeview Drive Sunset Beach,CA 90742 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Mark Reid Police Officers Association Peter Preston 27315 Jefferson Avenue Officer Chris Tatter 6862 Jardines Dr Temecula, CA 926590 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Lana Ickes Huntington Beach Youth Shelter Slater Metzler Industries 16441 Whittier Lane 7291 Talbert -.venue 17532 Metzler Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Clifford Z.Battelle YMCA Harold K. Moore 1301 Dove St.,#101 7262 Garfield Avenue 600 Magnolia Way Newport Beach, CA 92660 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 La Habra,CA 90631 Bill Hartge Carlone Herman Ming-Min&Sue Kan 17121 Edgewater HB Youth Soccer Club 17692 Stanfield Cir Huntington Beach, CA 92649 18931 Crimson Circle Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Rafaela/Ruben Solorzano I L Nino Ming/Sun Kan 7890 Speer Avenue 1805 E. Garry Avenue,#100 17801 Sampson Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Santa Ana, CA 92705 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Marielle T.Morel Sharon KOWb:L Sam T.Pazzulla 17511 Rainglen Ln 17707 Sampson Lane,#B5 10297 Cardinal Avenue Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Fountain Valley, CA 92708 110-010-55 Dewayne L.Brown Don Martinson Atlantic Richfield Co 3651 Aquarius Drive 73860 Shadow Lake Dr PO Box 2485 Huntington Beach,CA 92649 Palm Desert,CA 92260 Los Angeles, CA 90053 g:broeren\advance\hcpeir\noalbl Occupant Occupant Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave., #1 7051 Ellis Ave.,#2 7051 Ellis Ave.,#3 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Occupant Occupant Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave.,#4 7051 Ellis Ave.,#5 7051 Ellis Ave., #6 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Occupant Occupant Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave.,#7 7051 Ellis Ave.,#8 7051 Ellis Ave.,#9 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Occupant Occupant Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave.,410 7051 Ellis Ave.,#11 7051 Ellis Ave.,#12 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Occupant Occupant Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave.,#13 7051 Ellis Ave.,#14 7051 Ellis Ave.,#15 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Occupant Occupant Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave.,#16 7051 Ellis A•.'+;., #17 7051 Ellis Ave.,#18 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Occupant Occupant Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave.,#19 7051 Ellis Ave.,#20 7051 Ellis Ave.,#21 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Occupant Occupant Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave.,#22 7051 Ellis Ave.,#23 7051 Ellis Ave.,#24 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Occupant Occupant Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave.,#25 7051 Ellis Ave.,#26 7051 Ellis Ave.,#27 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Occupant Occupant Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave., #28 7051 Ellis Ave.,#29 7051 Ellis Ave.,#30 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 g:broeren\advance\hcpeir\noalbt Occupant Occupant Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave.,#31 7051 Ellis Ave.,#32 7051 Ellis Ave.,#33 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Occupant Occupant Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave.,#34 7051 Ellis Ave.,#35 7051 Ellis Ave.,#36 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Occupant Occupant Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave.,#37 7051 Ellis Ave.,-439 7051 Ellis Ave., #39 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Occupant Occupant Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave.,#40 7051 Ellis Ave.,#41 7051 Ellis Ave.,#42 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Occupant Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave.,#43 7051 Ellis Ave.,#44 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 g:broeren�advance�hcpeirinoalbl Wldongll:swuoa:IINU:O Y�RI03'IHT SY�i?I03�Y�II?l�'J U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Department of Conservation California Environmental Protection Attn: Mr. Ken Corey Div. of Oil, Gas&Geothermal Resources Department of Toxic Substances 2730 Loker Avenue West Attn:Ken Carlson Attn: Gregg Holmes Carlsbad, CA 92008 5816 Corporate Ave. Ste. 200 5796 Corporate Ave. Cypress CA, 90630-4731 Cypress, CA 90630 California Regional Water Quality California Regional Water Quality 111-010-54 Control Board Santa Ana Region Control Board Santa Ana Region Yajma Kenetsu USA Land Disposal Section Attn: Mr. Mike Adackapara 3703 Long Beach Bl., #E14 3737 Main Street, Ste. 500 3737 Main Street, Ste. 500 Long Beach, CA 90807 Riverside, CA 92501-3339 Riverside, CA 92501-3339 otlag uo 6£££-i0SZ6 VD `ap►slan 6£££-109Z6 dD `apisianrg €r a a lei @b uo all-8 b 10- i I niuio3c O sai 06, 9 OOZ £ �A As O saouips n saamosag leuuagloa0u@ o . I U�wk saomosa-d%gftV6bN%BUY& dwA4ed aolnzaS R uottaaloid uauiuoiinug EdUo3?Te'J uot�Eniosuo�3o luounnd�aQ aalnlaS anPltM ptre 14sT3 S. G:KIM:FORMS:LBLFOWM Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach T i of? E N Office of the City Clerk AUMITIONAL POSME.RAE P.O. Box 190 OFP'i'ST E FOR COUNIRY SHOViN is CENTS PER HALF 07 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 I _T­ II E. 159-255-11 Amador,Dino c/0 Saudi Aramco PO Box 1664 Abqaiq VNG Saudi Arabia 31311 4f 17q LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING.- " It it it Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 V'A Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave.,#21 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 pNTINGTp .14 CURR777 926481002 IN 23 07/27./99 SENDER TURN 0-TURN IRETURN, RD ON FILE REI BY iR: A LE FORWARD TT LE L NOTICE— PUBLIC�HEARING Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648,E C Occupant 7051 Ellis Ave.,#37 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 ING .aQE��N"T" C-0 CURR777 9a6481r*1 -SENn002 INER 23 07/27./99 Pd.-T 7 ILE FOR �R REfIJ0,N eT GAL NOTICE P Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 9 �h /�{2 '�j 159-392-13 HUNTINGTON BEACH ESTATES H 011 WIf(W4� RANS AVE HAWTHORNE CA 90250-1502 C2. VIAV SEE- PUB Connie Brockw, City of Huntington Office of the City Cleir, P.O. Box 190 S S 5 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 M R 111-401-6 Hudson, radle y 18715 S aton L n. Huntin on Beach,CA.92648 ING; HUDS715 . 926481008 IN 27 08/07/9W 4:0 RETURN TSENEYETF, Z.T i fi U,TR-I NO FORWARDN' 0 jl�-O fl:z-0 UNABLE,! trj'F8MW'A'R_,g,ti .f' P, RETURMt 9E 564 CE- .,AL'NnQE- PUBLIC HEARING ---------- Connie Brockway, City Clerk m City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Nat'l Jr BasketbaLl BB South h/I / Ms.LindkJohiWon Vice President roo St.,Unit 328 AhAington Beach, CA 92646 ING Mal % C-4 9264640RO IN 16 07/27/99 CO JOHN661 RETURN TO SENDER NO FORWARD ORDER ON FILE it 40% UNABLE TO FORWARD RETURN TO SENDER LEGAL NOTICE- PUBLIC HEARING ...... SIM, (M) 11141111111141111111111411111 fill Ft f4ftiloMo ys • way, City Clerk 31 Cam. us. ngton Beach e City Clerk Fr :ach, CA 92648 ETU To � 159-081-06 SEf+DER 0 Smmanual Hu 6451 Newbury cxEs Bell- 92647 y Onelafrra. Hunting TO -- e i�Jhi� rdia.���IS . No sucq strcer �,rur. am NDER4OFONEW1ADDRE5507 14 No such officc,a;�at.ys OorotHU rama;l;otp;saQl�aps p0 MOUNT' A g07a3-1001 LEGAL NOTICE- PUBLIC HEARING - L NcoLE, Cd ,�rJ.Jvc Council/Agency Meeting Held: Deferred/Continued to: Approved ❑ Conditionally Approved ❑ Denied City CI 's gnatur Council Meeting Date: March 1, 2004 Department umber: PL04-02 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH REQUEST FOR ACTION SUBMITTED TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL EMBERS _ rrn a SUBMITTED BY: RAY SILVER, City Administrator.-. _ o= 0 -«_ PREPARED BY: HOWARD ZELEFSKY, Director of Planning �--- o JIM ENGLE, Director of Community Servic s w SUBJECT: APPROVE ADDENDUM NO. 1 TO THE FINA MASTER n ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT FOR THE MASTER PLAN OF RECREATION USES FOR CENTRAL PARK. [Statement of Issue,Funding Source,Recommended Action,Alternative Action(s),Analysis,Environmental Status,Attachment(s) Statement of Issue: Transmitted for your consideration is Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for Central Park. The Addendum analyzes the potential environmental impacts associated with the closure of Driveway "D" to the Sports Complex. Driveway "D" connects the eastern portion of the Sports Complex parking lot to the Huntington Beach Central Library parking lot. The analysis concludes that no significant impacts will result; therefore, staff recommends the City Council approve and file the Addendum to the Final Master EIR. Funding Source: Not applicable. Recommended Action: Motion to: "Approve Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master Environmental Impact Report for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park. (ATTACHMENT NO. 1)." Alternative Action(s1: The City Council may make the following alternative motion: "Continue Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master Environmental Impact Report and direct staff accordingly." V7- � REQUEST FOR ACTION MEETING DATE: March 1, 2004 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: PL04-02 Analysis: A. PROJECT PROPOSAL: Applicant: City of Huntington Beach, Community Services Department Location: Huntington Beach Sports Complex (South of Talbert Avenue and East of Goldenwest Street). Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master EIR for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park represents an analysis of the potential environmental impacts associated with changes to the Sports Complex as a result of the closure of Driveway "D". The analysis of the project, prepared by Sapphos Envinonmental, Inc. has determined that none of the conditions described in Section 15162 of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines calling for the preparation of a Subsequent EIR has occurred, and that there would not be new or more significant impacts than those contained in the Final Master EIR. Therefore, an Addendum to the Final Master EIR is appropriate. Addendum EIR's are approved as administrative items. B. BACKGROUND A Master EIR (SCH # 97091007) for a Master Plan for a portion of Central Park, including the Sports Complex, was certified by the City Council in 1999. The Mitigation Monitoring Program includes four specific mitigation measures that address the four ingress/egress points (Driveways "A" —"D") for the Sports Complex. In July 2003, the City Council decided it was necessary to charge a parking fee at the Sports Complex and to minimize the likelihood of Sports Complex patrons using Library parking. This will result in the closure of Driveway "D" which connects the Sports Complex parking lot with the library parking lot. Since this is a modification to the previously approved mitigation measures (ATTACHMENT NO. 3), a review of the previously certified EIR was required pursuant to CEQA. In order to prepare this environmental analysis, on October 20, 2003, the City Council approved a contract with Sapphos Environmental, Inc. C. STAFF ANALYSIS AND RECOMMENDATION: Closure of Driveway "D" The Huntington Beach Sports Complex includes an 800-space parking lot with access provided by four ingress and egress driveways: Driveways "A" through "D" (ATTACHMENT NO. 2). Driveway "D" is located roughly in the center of the northern boundary of the Sports Complex. As constructed, Driveway "D" connects the eastern portion of the Sports Complex parking lot with the Huntington Beach Central Library parking lot. PL04-02 -2- 2/12/200411:06 AM REQUEST FOR ACTION MEETING DATE: March 1, 2004 DEPARTMENT ID NUMBER: PL04-02 The closure of Driveway "Y would be accomplished through the construction of a gate. This gate would be lockable and would be of identical scale and construction materials as the existing fencing. It would allow the driveway to be available for emergency use in the event that evacuation or immediate emergency access to the northeast portion of the Sports Complex was required. In addition, a 6-foot chain-link fence would be constructed along the north boundary of the Sports Complex from Goldenwest Street to Gothard Street. Environmental Impacts The only potential area of concern is related to potential traffic impacts; all other CEQA issue areas are either not affected by the proposed change or are adequately addressed within the certified Final EIR, e.g. temporary construction impacts associated with the fence. The traffic impact analysis for the closure of Driveway "Y concludes that the remaining three driveways are anticipated to operate at acceptable levels of service (LOS) C or better. However, while on average Driveway "B" is at LOS C, the approach delay for the westbound left-turn movement is LOS F. The traffic analysis concludes that with modifications to Driveway "B" an acceptable LOS of C or better would remain. The median in Driveway "B" would be altered by the construction of a curved extension to the west end of the existing median, which would reduce two egress aisles to one and prevent left-turn movements onto Goldenwest Street. The traffic analysis considers other potential solutions, including a traffic signal, however, staff believes that the modifications to the Driveway "B" median are the most cost effective and timely. The proposed changes do not result in significant impacts nor require the implementation of any additional mitigation measures. Staff believes the Addendum adequately analyzes the proposed change to the Sports Complex consistent with CEQA. Staff recommends that the City Council approve Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master Environmental Impact Report for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park as submitted. (ATTACHMENT NO. 1)." Attachment(s): City Clerk's Page Number No. Description 1. Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master EIR for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park. 2. Sports Complex Driveway Locations 3. Final Master EIR for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park Mitigation Measures. 4. Power Point Presentation RCA Author: Jason Kelley/Mary Beth Broeren PL04-02 -3- 2/18/2004 4:50 PM NT . ATTA r ,max -� �.•g ;.,,n � � �# rt +� r � ' '� ,tx. �. y' ` � ' e;4 �� } ADDENDUM NO.. I TO THE FINAL MASTER ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT " REPORT FOR THE MASTER P -AN OF RECREAIION•,USES FORAv . . : CENTRAL. PARK; CITY OF HUNIINGTONBEACH, -CALIFORNIA r '. STATE CLEARIN5HOUSE -NUMBER 97091007 ` ' g 4 PREPARED. FOR 70 ' CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH ` PLANNING DEPARTMENT p' 200 MAIN STREET, 3RD FLOOR HUNTINGTON BEACH', CA 92648 ,i PREPARED BY: -S zSAPO.A,ds 1EWWRONMEN'TAL, INC ` xI 330'MARTIN ALLEY r PASADENA, CA 9 1 105 u JANUARY. I ,Z► '20041,: '° TABLE OF CONTENTS SECTIONS PAGE 1.0 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................... 1-1 1.1 Background......................................................................................................... 1-1 1.2 Purpose and Need............................................................................................... 1-1 2.0 REFINED PROJECT DESCRIPTION..................................................................................2-1 2.1 Project Refinements.............................................................................................2-1 2.2 Other Minor Project Changes..............................................................................2-2 3.0 ANALYSIS OF ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS CAUSED BY THE REFINED PROJECT........3-1 3.1 Environmental Impacts........................................................................................3-1 3.2 Mitigation Measures............................................................................................3-3 3.3 Level of Significance after Project Refinements ....................................................3-3 4.0 'FINDINGS ......................................................................................................................4-1 TABLES PAGE 3.1-1 Comparison of 2003 Existing Traffic Conditions with 2005 Traffic Conditions Capacity Analysis of Driveway D Closed and No Left-Turn Exit at Driveway B.....................................3-2 3.1-2 Comparison of 2003 Existing Traffic Conditions with 2005 Traffic Conditions Capacity Analysis of Driveway D Closed and Two-Way Traffic on Driveway C....................................3-3 FIGURE FOLLOWS PAGE 2-1 Illustration of Proposed Project Modifications......................................................2-1 APPENDIX Appendix A Letter Report from Linscott, Law & Greenspan, Engineers Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master EIR for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach, California January 12, 2004 Sapphos Environmental, Inc. S:11125-0061Huntington Beach Sports Complex Addendum lTOC.doc Page i SECTION 1.0 INTRODUCTION This Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach, California, is prepared pursuant to, and in compliance with, Section 15164 of the State California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines to document technical refinements to the proposed project. The project refinements are being undertaken by the City of Huntington Beach (City) and are. subject to approval by the City.of Huntington Beach City Council. 1.1 BACKGROUND The City adopted the Final Master EIR for Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach, California on June 22, 1999.' The purpose of the Master Plan for Central Park was to provide diverse recreation opportunities for all citizens consistent with the Huntington Beach City Goals of the General Plan adopted by the Huntington Beach City Council. This project included the development of a 45-acre Sports Complex, which has been largely constructed and includes an 800-space parking lot, eight lighted softball fields, overlapping with eight lighted soccer/football fields, two tot lots, two restroom/concession buildings, a batting cage, two arena soccer fields, and two roller hockey rinks. The Sports Complex is scheduled to open in spring 2004. The Final Master EIR contained a project-level analysis of the proposed project. It examined the environmental effects of construction and operation of the Sports Complex.*The Final Master EIR determined that all project-related impacts could be reduced to less than significant levels through the implementation of the specified mitigation measures. Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master EIR is being prepared for the Lead Agency designated by the State of California, as defined in Section 15367 of the State CEQA Guidelines. The City is the Lead Agency for the project. 1.2 PURPOSE AND NEED The purpose of Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master EIR is to describe and analyze changes to the adopted project description. ' City of Huntington Beach, 22 June 1999. Final Master Environmental Impact Report for Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach, California.Contact: City of Huntington Beach Planning Department 2000 Main Street, 3`1 floor, Huntington Beach,CA 92648. Prepared by:Sapphos Environmental, Inc., 133 Martin Alley, Pasadena, CA 91105. Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master EIR for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach, California January 12, 2004 Sapphos Environmental, Inc. S:11125-0061Huntington Beach Sports Complex Addendum lAddendum Sec 1.doc Page 1-1 For budgetary reasons, the City of Huntington Beach City Council has decided to charge patrons a fee for using the Sports Complex parking lot. In order to effect this change, the City has determined that the following minor technical changes must be made to the project: • The closure of Driveway D • The modification of the median in Goldenwest Street at Driveway B to prevent left turns from Driveway B The City of Huntington Beach will also have the option to modify Driveway C. to create an inbound and outbound driveway. An analysis of the project refinements has determined that none of the conditions described in Section 15162 of the State CEQA Guidelines calling for the preparation of a Subsequent EIR has occurred, and that there would not be new or more significant impacts than those contained in the Final Master EIR. Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master EIR for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach, California January 12, 2004 Sapphos Environmental, Inc. S:1 1 1 25-0061Huntington Beach Sports Complex Addendum Oddendum Sec 1.doc Page 1-2 SECTION 2.0 REFINED PROJECT DESCRIPTION This section provides a detailed description of the refinements to the project that are necessitated by the decision of the City of Huntington Beach City Council to charge patrons a fee for using the Sports Complex parking lot and the changes to the project precipitated by that decision. Please see Figure 2-1, Illustration of Proposed Project Modifications, for a graphic summary of the project refinements. 2.1 PROJECT REFINEMENTS Closure of Driveway D The Huntington Beach Sports Complex includes an 800-space parking lot with access provided by four ingress and egress driveways: Driveways A through D. Figure 2-1 depicts the locations of these four driveways. Driveway D is located roughly in the center of the,northern boundary of the Sports Complex. As constructed, Driveway D connects the eastern portion of the Sports Complex parking lot with the Huntington Beach Central Library parking lot. The closure of Driveway D would eliminate direct vehicle and pedestrian access to and from the adjacent library parking lot. The closure of Driveway D would also inhibit Sports Complex patrons from parking in the Huntington Beach Central Library parking lot for free and walking into the Sports Complex. The closure of Driveway D necessitates Sports Complex patrons to enter through Driveway A, B, or C, and therefore they will pay the required fee in order to gain entrance to the Sports Complex parking lot. The closure of Driveway D would be accomplished through the construction of a gate. This gate would be lockable and would be of identical scale and construction materials as the existing fencing. It would allow the driveway to be available for emergency use in the event that rapid evacuation or immediate emergency access to the northeast portion of the Sports Complex was required. In addition, a 6-foot chain-link fence would be constructed along the north boundary of the Sports Complex from Goldenwest Street and Gothard Street. Modification of the Median in Goldenwest Street at Driveway B Driveway B is located roughly in the center of the western boundary of the Sports Complex. As constructed, it is a full-access driveway that allows inbound and outbound traffic to and from Goldenwest Street. Left turns onto Goldenwest Street from Driveway B are presently possible. As one of the technical refinements related to the implementation of parking fees, the median in Driveway B would be modified to prevent left turns from Driveway B. This would be accomplished through the construction of a curved extension to the west end of the existing median, which would reduce two egress aisles to one and prevent left-turn movements onto Goldenwest Street. Extension of the median would require an additional 20 linear feet of concrete. The modification of the median at Driveway B would prevent traffic impacts that could occur as a result of the closure of Driveway D. Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master EIR for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach, California January 12, 2004 Sapphos Environmental, Inc. S:1I 12S-0061Huntington Beach Sports Complex AddendumlAddendum Sec 2.doc Page 2-1 7 7',, V" tj� J - ----- -Wert Ava Driveway C Driveway D tE r he Cii),has the oplion to I Driveway Dwill be closed to 1! 1i modify Driveway C byaddi jig both vehicle and peclesil-i'111 outbound lane to createiraffic wilh a lockable,gale. 11 111b0L111CJ/0L1lb0L111(l driveway. Driveway B The median in Driveway B P"E: will be modified to prevent V 4 left IL11 1)5 from Driveway Driveway A N Rl- ni(x1ificalions to Drivee A- vay A W-z -e will be no There ?""etll" 41- g Y Z_ Ck'k' SOURCE:City of Huntington Beach Planning Department N I 000ft 500ft Oft I 000ft 2000ft L-------- SCALE LEGEND Huntington Beach Sports Complex footprint FIGURE 2-1 Illustration of Proposed Project Modifications Optional Modification of Driveway C to Create an Outbound Traffic Lane Driveway C is located in the northwest corner of the Sports Complex, off of Talbert Avenue. In the Final Master Environmental Impact Report for Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach, California, this driveway was analyzed as a one-lane-in and one-lane-out driveway. However, during construction, the outbound lane was eliminated, and only the inbound lane was built. This modification to the originally analyzed project did not result in significant environmental impacts. The City of Huntington Beach would retain the option to convert the exiting inbound driveway into an inbound and outbound driveway. Driveway C is currently 20 feet wide and 160 feet in length from Talbert.Avenue to the library parking lot. A landscaped area is located to the west of the driveway and an 8-foot-wide sidewalk to the east. Converting Driveway C to accommodate two-way traffic would require widening the driveway to 26 feet by removing the existing 8-foot- wide sidewalk and constructing a new curb and gutter along the east side of the driveway. A standard curb and gutter would require 9 yards of concrete. Widening the driveway would require 90 tons of additional asphalt. Both inbound and outbound portions of the modified driveway would conform to all City of Huntington Beach requirements and regulations. The conversion of Driveway C would further alleviate any potential traffic impacts that would occur as a result of the closure of Driveway D. 2.2 OTHER MINOR PROJECT CHANGES Other minor changes to the project occurred during Phase 2 of construction of the Sports Complex. Phase 2 was to consist of a batting cage, four roller hockey rinks, and a small building. However, only two hockey rinks were constructed, with the other two being replaced by two soccer arenas. These minor changes to the project required no additional environmental documentation. Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master EIR for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach, California January 12, 2004 Sapphos Environmental, Inc. 5:1I 125-0061Huntington Beach Sports Complex Addendum lAddendum Sec 2.doc Page 2-2 SECTION 3.0 ANALYSIS OF ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS CAUSED BY THE REFINED PROJECT This Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach, California, is prepared pursuant to, and in compliance with, Section 15164 of the State California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines to document technical refinements to the proposed project. The project refinements are being undertaken by the City of Huntington Beach (City) and are subject to approval by the City of Huntington Beach City Council. 3.1 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS The results of the analysis of environmental impacts undertaken in the Final Master EIR would remain the same for all issue areas analyzed. The scope of potential environmental impacts for this Addendum No. 1 was determined by applying the environmental checklist contained in Appendix G of the State CEQA Guidelines to the refined project description. Transportation and circulation is the only CEQA issue area to which environmental impacts would have the potential to occur. The minor modifications to the median at Driveway B, Driveway D, and, if implemented, Driveway C, would not result in significant impacts nor require mitigation measures not described in the Final Master EIR. Transportation and Circulation Linscott, Law & Greenspan, Engineers (LLG) evaluated the potential traffic impacts from the proposed project modifications at four study intersections on a near-term (2005) basis. The report from LLG is enclosed as Appendix A, Letter Report from Linscott, Law & Greenspan, Engineers. Updated existing p.m. peak-hour data were collected at the four study intersections. Background conditions were also updated based on the status of current development within the area, as documented by the City. The Level of Service (LOS) of the traffic conditions was graded from A to F, A being the best and F being the worst.' Closure of Driveway D and Modification of Median at Driveway H A traffic-impact analysis of the closure of Driveway D and the modification of the median in Goldenwest Street at Driveway B to prevent left turns from Driveway B was completed by LLG. The northbound and southbound left-turn movements on Goldenwest Street would be maintained. Based on the traffic analysis conducted by LLG, implementation of the project refinements would not result in significant impacts nor require the implementation of any additional mitigation measures. Table 3.1-1, Comparison of 2003 Existing Traffic Conditions with 2005 Traffic Conditions Capacity Analysis of Driveway D Closed and No Left-Turn Exit at Driveway B, shows KeiI Maberry, 12 December 2003. Traffic Impact Analysis for Proposed Changes to the Huntington Beach Sports Complex, Huntington Beach, California.Contact: Linscott, Law&Greenspan, Engineers, 1580 Corporate Drive,Suite 122,Costa Mesa,CA 92626. Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master EIR for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach, California January 12, 2004 Sapphos Environmental, Inc. S.11125-0061Huntington Beach Sports Complex AddendumlAddendum Sec 3.doc Page 3-1 that all study intersections would operate at an acceptable LOS with the implementation of the project refinements. TABLE 3.1-1" COMPARISON OF 2003 EXISTING TRAFFIC CONDITIONS WITH 2005 TRAFFIC CONDITIONS CAPACITY ANALYSIS OF DRIVEWAY D CLOSED AND NO LEFT-TURN EXIT AT DRIVEWAY B �� � 3003 Ex�stmg�Traffic � n2005 PWs Protect Traffic ; E udy Intersections4 ,�� z- , _� {. StTime ON oConditions� Conditions H A t'!I or HGM' ICU or HCM LOS.. < Goldenwest Street at Slater p.m. ICU = 0.718 C ICU = 0.773 C Avenue Goldenwest Street at p.m. ICU = 0.349 A ICU = 0.511. A Library/Talbert Avenue Goldenwest Street at p.m. HCM = 0.00 A HCM = 0.5 A Driveway A seconds per seconds per vehicle vehicle Goldenwest Street at P.M. HCM = 0.00 A HCM = 1.7 A Driveway B seconds per seconds per vehicle vehicle KEY: HCM = Highway Capacity Manual; ICU = Intersection Capacity Utilization; LOS = Level of Service NOTE: It would be significant if the intersection LOS is E or worse. z The 2005 Background Traffic Conditions include updated information regarding planned and funded improvements that are expected to be constructed by 2005. SOURCE; Linscott, Law & Greenspan, Engineers, 2003. Preliminary Traffic Impact Analysis Addendum for.Proposed Changes to the Huntington Beach Sports Complex, Huntington Beach, California. Contact: 1580 Corporate Drive, Suite 122, Costa Mesa, CA 92626. Optional Modification of Driveway C to Create an Outbound Traffic Lane A traffic-impact analysis of the additional modification of Driveway C to create an outbound traffic lane was completed by LLG. This additional refinement would allow two-way traffic at Driveway C. Based on the traffic analysis conducted by LLG, implementation of this refinement would not result in significant impacts nor require the implementation of any additional mitigation measures. Table 3.1-2, Comparison of 2003 Existing Traffic Conditions with 2005 Traffic Conditions Capacity Analysis of Driveway D Closed and Two-Way Traffic on Driveway C shows that all study intersections would operate at an acceptable LOS with the implementation of this additional, optional project refinement. Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master EIR for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach, California January 12, 2004 Sapphos Environmental, Inc. S:1 1 1 25-0061Huntington Beach Sports Complex AddendumlAddendum Sec 3.doc Page 3-2 TABLE 3.1-2 COMPARISON OF 2003 EXISTING TRAFFIC CONDITIONS WITH 2005 TRAFFIC CONDITIONS CAPACITY ANALYSIS OF DRIVEWAY D CLOSED AND TWO-WAY TRAFFIC ON DRIVEWAY C -t` ;2003 Existmg�l rafficz� 2005 Plus Prolect�Traffic Study Intersections - Time= �-��``� �Condttions'; ,� � Conditions' " 3 � ` '� ICU or HCM __ LOSS ICU or HCM :xLOS k_ Goldenwest Street at Slater p.m. ICU = 0.718 C ICU = 0.773 C Avenue Goldenwest Street at p.m. ICU = 0.349 A ICU = 0.507 A Library/Talbert Avenue Goldenwest Street at p.m. HCM = 0.00 A HCM = 0.1 A Driveway A seconds seconds per vehicle per vehicle Goldenwest Street at p.m. HCM = 0.00 A HCM = 6.9 A Driveway B seconds seconds per vehicle per vehicle KEY: HCM = Highway Capacity Manual; ICU = Intersection Capacity Utilization; LOS = Level of Service NOTE: ' It would be significant if the intersection LOS is E or worse. z The 2005 Background Traffic Conditions include updated information regarding planned and funded improvements that are expected to be constructed by 2005. 3 The Highway Capacity Manual recognizes the average intersection delay as the measure for determining whether the intersection has an LOS grade of A. However,the westbound left-turn delay on the westbound approach, which is part of the average intersection delay value, has an LOS grade of F (454.4 seconds per vehicle). Reference: National Research Council, Transportation Research Board, 2000. Highway Capacity Manual. Washington, DC: Transportation Research Board. SOURCE, Linscott, Law & Greenspan, Engineers, 2003. Preliminary Traffic Impact Analysis Addendum for Proposed Changes to the Huntington Beach Sports Complex, Huntington Beach, California. Contact: 1580 Corporate Drive, Suite 122, Costa Mesa, CA 92626. 3.2 MITIGATION MEASURES Mitigation measures as described in the Final Master EIR would remain the same for all issue areas. Under both of the analyzed transportation scenarios, the refinements to traffic would not create any new significant impacts in addition to those identified in the Final Master EIR; therefore, additional mitigation measures would not be required. 3.3 LEVEL OF SIGNIFICANCE AFTER PROJECT REFINEMENTS Implementation of the refinements to the Huntington Beach Sports Complex described in Section 2.0 would not affect the level of significance after mitigation, as described in the Final Master EIR. Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master EIR for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach, California January 12, 2004 Sapphos Environmental, Inc. S:I 1125-0061Huntington Beach Sports Complex AddendumlAddendum Sec 3.doc Page 3-3 SECTION 4.0 FINDINGS This Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach (City), California, has evaluated the potential environmental impacts associated with the project refinements described in Section 2.0. Based on the analysis contained in Section 3.0, it has been determined that the refinements to the Huntington Beach Sports Complex, as discussed in Section 2.0, neither create new or more significant environmental impacts, nor require any major revisions to the Final Master EIR. Under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), Section 15164, an Addendum to an EIR is the appropriate form of document for a project change if none of the conditions described in Section 15162, calling for preparation of a Subsequent EIR, has occurred. The conditions requiring the preparation of a Subsequent EIR, which do not exist for the proposed refinements to the Huntington Beach Sports Complex, are defined in Section 15162 of the State CEQA Guidelines: The project will have one or more significant effects not discussed previously in the EIR. • Significant effects previously examined will be substantially more severe than those shown in the EIR. • Mitigation measures or alternatives previously found to be unfeasible would, in fact, be feasible and would substantially reduce one or more significant effects of the project, but the project proponent declines to adopt the mitigation measure or alternative. • Mitigation measures or alternatives that were not previously considered in the EIR would substantially lessen one or more significant effects on the environment, but the project proponent declines to adopt the mitigation measure or alternative. As a result of the analysis conducted in Section 3.0, the City has concluded that the refinements to the Huntington Beach Sports Complex do not materially differ from the project adopted in the Final Master EIR; therefore, none of the conditions defined in Section 15162 of the State CEQA Guidelines would occur as a result of the implementation of the proposed refinements. Refinements to the project description are consistent with the requirements of CEQA and do not raise new or more significant effects to the environment. The Final Master EIR analysis comprehensively, discloses those environmental impacts that would be anticipated in association with the construction and operation of the Huntington Beach Sports Complex. Therefore, the City has concluded that a Subsequent EIR, or any follow-up EIR, is not required and that an Addendum to the Final Master EIR is the appropriate CEQA compliance document for approval of the refinements to the project description. This finding is made pursuant to, and in compliance with, the State CEQA Guidelines, Section 15164 (e). Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master EIR for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park, City of Huntington Beach, California January 12, 2004 Sapphos Environmental, Inc. 5:1I 125-0061Huntington Beach Sports Complex Addendum lAddendum Sec 4.doc Page 4-1 APPENDIX A LETTER REPORT FROM LINSCOTT, LAW& GREENSPAN, ENGINEERS `{ Philip M.Linscott,P.E.(1924-2000) Jack M.Greenspan,P.E. William A.Law,P.E(Ret.) Paul W.Wilkinson,P.E. John P.Keating,P.E. David S.5hender,P.E. E N G I N E E R S darne M.Look-Jaeger,P.E. Richard E Barretto,P.E. ENGINEERS&PLANNERS III, TRAFFIC,TRANSPORTATION,PARKING 1580 Corporate Drive,Suite 122 ■ Costa Mesa,California 92626 Phone:714 641-1587 ■ Fax:714 641-0139 December 12, 2003 Mr.Kyle McClure SAPPHOS ENVIRONMENTAL,INC. 133 Martin Alley Pasadena, CA 91105 Subject: PRELIMINARY TRAFFIC IMTACT ANALYSIS ADDENDUM FOR PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE HUNTINGTON BEACH SPORTS COMPLEX,HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA Dear Mr. McClure: As requested, Linscott, Law & Greenspan, Engineers is pleased to submit this Preliminary Traffic .Impact Analysis of the proposed changes to the Huntington Beach Sports Complex project. This analysis assesses the traffic impacts resulting from the closure of one ingress/egress driveway from -:the Central.Library parking lot to the Sports Complex parking lot (Driveway D). This letter will outline the traffic impact analysis in relation to the prior traffic impact analysis conducted for the Huntington Beach Sports Complex Environmental Impact Report(Ea),dated February 22, 1999.It utilizes methodologies that are consistent with those used in the Huntington Beach Sports Complex EIR as well as those of the Huntington Beach Traffic Study Guidelines. INTRODUCTION This Traffic Impact Analysis evaluates the potential traffic impacts from the closure of one ingress/egress driveway from the Central Library parking lot to the Sports Complex parking lot (Driveway D) at four study intersections on a near-term (2005) basis. Updated existing PM peak hour data were collected at the four study intersections.Background conditions were also updated based on the status of current .development within the area as documented by the City of Huntington Beach (City). In addition,'this analysis evaluates two potential operational changes to the remaining Sports Complex driveways as alternatives to only closing Driveway D. These are: • ,Alternative No. 1 — Install median modifications in Goldenwest Street at Driveway B in order to restrict outbound left-turn movements from Driveway B and the Frisbee Golf Driveway,while maintaining the northbound and southbound I left-turn movements on Goldenwest Street. Northbound U-tums would be 4 Pasadena-626 796-2322 ■ San Diego-619 299-3090 0 Las Vegas-702 451.1920 ■founded 1966 0 An LG2W13 Company irt Mr.Kyle McClure SAPPHOS ENVIRONMENTAL,INC. fSports Complex EIR Addendum December 12,2003 ` E N G I N E E R S Page 2 1 I permitted to allow vehicles exiting the Sports Complex to travel southbound on Goldenwest Street via a right tum from Driveway A and a northbound U-turn at the Goldenwest/Driveway B—Frisbee Golf intersection. I • Alternative No. 2 — Convert Driveway C from a one-way inbound driveway to a two-way driveway'in order to reduce the outbound left-turn traffic volume at IDriveway B. UPDATED YEAR 2005 TRAMC CHARACTERISTICS IUpdated Project Traffic Distribution.and Assignment Exhibit 1, attached, presents the project traffic distribution pattern for the Sports Complex with Driveway D open, consistent with Exhibit 8 in the approved EIR traffic impact analysis, dated February 22,�2003.Exhibit 1 serves as a reference for those exhibits that present redistributed traffic as a result ofthe closure of Driveway D. -- Exhibit 2, attached, presents the project traffic distribution.pattern for the Sports Complex with Driveway D closed and no additional operational modifications at any of the other three project driveways. As presented in Exhibit 2 and compared to Exhibit 1, an additional 15 percent of project traffic has been redistributed through the Goldenwest—Slater intersection; 23 percent of project traffic has been redistributed away from the Gothard—Talbert intersection;.an additional 8 percent of project traffic has been redistributed through. the Goldenwest Ellis intersection; and -the Goldenwest Library/Talbert Avenue intersection gained 15 percent more inbound project traffic and 20 percent more outbound project traffic. However, all outbound traffic on Talbert was eliminated with the closure of Driveway D. In addition, as presented in Exhibit 2, Driveway B gained 13 percent more outbound left-turn project traffic and 45 percent more outbound right-turn project traffic and an additional 5 percent more inbound project traffic, while Driveway A gained 5 percent more outbound right-turn project traffic and an additional 3 percent more inbound project traffic. Exhibit 3, attached, presents the project traffic distribution pattern for the Sports Complex with Driveway D closed and a no-left-tum exit at Driveway B (Alternative No. 1). As presented in Exhibit 3 and compared to Exhibit 1,the redistribution pattern is identical to Exhibit 2, except.at the Goldenwest Driveway B intersection,which gains an additional 30 percent outbound project traffic via a northbound U-turn and loses the 30 percent outbound left-turn project traffic, and the Goldenwest Driveway A intersection, which gains 30 percent more outbound right-turn project traffic headed toward the U-turn at the Goldenwest Driveway B intersection. i q�. Mr.Kyle McClure LINSCOTI SAPPHOS ENVIRONMENTAL,INC. Sports Complex EIR Addendum December 12, 2003 ENGINEERS Page Exhibit 4, attached, presents the project traffic distribution pattern for the Sports Complex with Driveway D closed and two-way traffic on Driveway C(Alternative No. 2).As presented in Exhibit 4 and compared to Exhibit 1, the redistribution pattern is identical to Exhibit 2, except at the Goldenwest Library/Talbert Avenue intersection, which gains only a net additional 5 percent outbound project traffic but gains 35 percent project traffic on Library/Talbert Avenue as an outbound right-turn and left-tum movement (20 percent right and 15 percent left). The outbound left-turn and right-turn movements at Driveway B reduce from 30 percent to 15 percent and'60 percent to 30 percent,respectively, and Driveway A remains identical to Exhibit 2. Year 2003 Existing Traffic Updated Existing PM peak hour traffic volumes at the four study intersections, which were determined to be evaluated in this report were collected on October 30, 2003 by Transportation Studies Inc.Appendix A contains the detailed traffic count data. Year 2005 Project Traffic Traffic Volumes with Driveway D Closed and No Additional Operational Modiftcations I_ The anticipated PM peak hour project volumes, associated with Driveway D closed and no additional operational modifications at any of the other three project driveways, are presented in Exhibit 5. The traffic volume assignments presented in Exhibit 5 reflect the traffic distribution characteristics shown in Exhibit 2 and the traffic generation forecast presented in Table 5 of the approved EIR traffic impact analysis. Traffic Volumes with Driveway D Closed and No-Left-Turn Exit at Driveway B The anticipated PM peak hour project volumes, associated.with Driveway D closed and no-left-turn exit at Driveway B,are presented in.Exhibit 6. The traffic volume assignments presented"in Exhibit 6 reflect the traffic distribution characteristics shown in Exhibit 3 and the traffic generation forecast presented in Table 5 of the approved EIR traffic impact analysis. Traffic Volumes with Driveway Closed and Two-Way Traffic on Driveway C The anticipated PM peak hour project volumes, associated with Driveway D closed and two-way traffic on Driveway C, are presented in Exhibit 7. The traffic volume assignments presented in Exhibit 7 reflect the traffic distribution characteristics shown in Exhibit 4 and the traffic generation forecast presented in Table 5 of the approved EIR traffic impact analysis. 1 � 1 • i I I Mr.Kyle McClure ILINSCOTT SAPPHOS ENVIRONMENTAL,INC. Sports Complex E1R Addendum December 12, 2003 ` E N G I N E E R S Page I Year 2005 Background Traffic Ambient Traffic Consistent with the approved EIR traffic impact analysis,future.growth in the traffic volumes at the study intersections has been calculated by incorporating a two percent (2 percent) annual ambient growth rate. The application of this growth rate to existing 2003 traffic volumes results in a four I percent(4 percent)growth in existing volumes at the four study intersections to horizon year 2005. I Related Projects Traffic Characteristics iAccording to the City Planning Department,the status of the two related projects contained in the approved EIR traffic impact analysis is as follows: the Home Depot project is completed and 4 opened, and a majority of the development under the Holly Seacliff Specific Plan is completed, except for approximately six projects that are either under construction or approved for development. Appendix B, attached, contains a list of all the projects within the Holly Seacliff "Specific Plan and their current status as well as the trip generation forecast of the projects.that are under construction or approved for development. As presented in Appendix B, the remaining Holly Seacliff Specific Plan projects have a trip generation potential of 342 PM peak hour trips (166 inbound, 176 outbound).. Year 2005 Background Plus Project Traffic I The estimates of project-generated traffic volumes for the. three driveway access/operational scenarios were added to the year 2005 background conditions to develop traffic projections for- the year 2005.background plus project traffic conditions. Exhibit 8 presents the year 2005 PM peak hour background plus project volumes, associated with Driveway D closed and no additional operational modifications at any of the other three project driveways. Exhibit 9 presents the year 2005 PM peak hour background plus project volumes, associated with Driveway D closed and a no-left-turn exit at Driveway B. Exhibit 10 presents the year.2005 PM peak hour background plus project volumes, associated with Driveway D closed and two-way traffic on Driveway C. 1 I i Mr.Kyle McClure SAPPHOS ENVIRONMENTAL,INC. Sports Complex EIR Addendum December 12,2003 E N G I N E E R S Page I i I UPDATED YEAR 2005 TRAYFIC IMPACT ANALYSIS 1 The relative impact of the added project traffic volumes generated by each of the three driveway access/operational scenarios during the PM peak hour was evaluated based on analysis of future operating conditions at the four study intersections, with 'and without, the proposed project. The Highway Capacity Manual (HCM) methodology(for unsignalized intersections) and Intersection Capacity Utilization (ICU) methodology(for signalized intersections) were utilized to investigate the future intersection delay and volume-to-capacity relationships, respectively, and service level characteristics at each study intersection. The.significance of the potential impacts of the project at each key intersection was then evaluated using the traffic impact criteria of the City, described as follows: i "Significant Traffic Impact"for unsignalized intersections: A "Significant" traffic impact for unsignalized intersections is defined as a project-related average overall intersection delay value greater than or equal to LOS E(36.0 seconds/vehicle to 50.0 seconds/vehicle), which requires mitigation by reducing the V/C ratio to LOS D (35.0 seconds/vehicle or less) or baseline,if the baseline is LOS E or F(greater than or equal to 36.0 seconds/vehicle). Baseline is defined as the pre-project condition(Year 2005 Background). "Significant Traffic Impact" for signalized intersections: A ".Significant" traffic impact for signalized intersections is defined as a project-related V/C ratio value greater than or equal to LOS E (0.905), which requires mitigation by reducing the V/C ratio to LOS D (0.904) or baseline,if the baseline is LOS E or F (greater than or equal to 0.905). Baseline is defined as the pre-project condition(Year 2005 Background). I Updated Year 2005 PM Peak Hour Intersection Capacity Analysis For reference purposes, Table 1. presents the PM Peak Hour Intersection Capacity Analysis Summary for the study intersections of Goldenwest Street at Slater Avenue-and Library/Talbert Avenue,presented in the approved EIR traffic impact analysis. These are the conditions that would occur if Driveway D was not closed and all other Driveways operated as originally designed. As presented in Table 1, the study intersection of Goldenwest Street at Slater Avenue would be anticipated to operate at LOS E with project traffic and would require traffic signal timing mitigation. The PM Peak Hour Intersection Capacity Analysis Summary for the proposed changes to the project under each driveway access/operational scenario, at the four study intersections, is presented as follows: L , I 4 Mr.Kyle McClure • SAPPHOS ENVIRONMENTAL,INC. Sports Complex E1R Addendum December 12, 2003 E N G I N E E R S Page Tra is Impact Analysis with Driveway D Closed and No Additional Operational Modifications Table 2 presents the PM peak hour intersection capacity analysis summary for the scenario with Driveway D closed and no additional operational modifications at any of the other three project 1 driveways. As presented in Table 2, all four study intersections are anticipated to operate at acceptable LOS C or better with Driveway D closed and no additional operational modifications at any of the other three project driveways.However, it is important to note that while,on average, the Goldenwest Driveway B intersection is at LOS C, the approach delay for the westbound left-tum movement is LOS F (926.1 seconds per vehicle). Appendix C, attached, contains the ICU and HCM intersection LOS calculation worksheets for the year 2005 updated traffic conditions for the scenario with Driveway D closed and no additional operational modifications at any-of the other three project driveways. Traffic Impact Analysis with Driveway D Closed and No-Left-Turn Exit at Driveway B Table 3 presents the PM peak hour intersection capacity analysis summary for the scenario with Driveway D closed and a no-left-tum exit at Driveway B. As presented in Table 3, all four study :intersections are anticipated to operate at acceptable LOS C or better with Driveway D closed and a -no-left-tam exit at Driveway B. Driveway A and Driveway B are anticipated to operate at LOS A -during the PM peak hour with virtually no intersection delay. Appendix D, attached, contains the ICU -and HCM intersection LOS calculation worksheets for the year 2005 updated traffic .conditions for the scenario with Driveway D.closed and a no-left-turn.exit at Driveway B. Traffic Impact Analysis with Driveway D Closed and Two-Way Traffic on Driveway C Table 4 presents the PM peak hour intersection capacity analysis summary for the scenario with Driveway D closed and two-way traffic on Driveway C. As presented in Table 4, all four study intersections are anticipated to operate at LOS C or better with Driveway D closed and two-way traffic on Driveway C. However, it is important to note that while, on average, the Goldenwest Driveway B intersection is at LOS A,the approach delay for the westbound left-tum movement is LOS F (454.4 seconds per vehicle). Appendix E, attached, contains the ICU and HCM intersection LOS calculation worksheets for the year 2005 updated traffic conditions for the scenario with Driveway D closed and two-way traffic on Driveway C. In addition, closure of Driveway D from the Central Library parking lot to the Sports Complex parking lot would not result in a significant adverse impact at the intersection of Talbert Avenue and Gothard Street under any of the three analysis scenarios. The intersection of Talbert Avenue.and Gothard Street will experience 75 PM peak hour project trips under all three analysis scenarios with Driveway D closed,compared to 248 PM peak hour project trips with Driveway D open. i . Mr. Kyle McClure LIN fTIT SAPPROS ENVIRONMENTAL,INC.- ' Sports Complex EIR Addendum December 12, 2003 E N G I N E E R 5 Page 7 1 TRAFFIC SIGNAL WARRANT ANALYSIS Based on the volume of traffic expected to use the study intersection of Goldenwest Street at Driveway B in year 2005,we conducted traffic signal warrant analyses to determine if year 2005 background plus project traffic triggers a signal at the three driveway access/operational scenarios. IManual of Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MLJTCD) and State of California Policy and Criteria IThe justification for the installation of a traffic signal at an intersection is based.on several guidelines, which include the warrants set forth in the Manual of Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD) and State of California's Traffic Manual. The MUTCD lists eleven I parameters that help to determine the necessity of a traffic signal at an intersection. Of the eleven warrants, Warrant 3 (Peak Dour Volume Warrant)is applicable for purposes of this analysis. This warrant is used for future peak hour conditions with project traffic. A detailed application of Warrant Sheet 3 (Figure 4C-4: 70% Factor; Critical Speed on Major, Street->_ 40 mph) for the study intersection of Goldenwest Street at Driveway B may be found in Appendix F. Other factors taken into consideration for the installation of a traffic signal at these intersections include vehicle delay, sight distance, and safety conditions. The traffic volumes used in the signal warrant analyses were based on year 2005 background plus project traffic. The following section summarizes the traffic signal warrant analyses at the study intersection of Goldenwest Street at Driveway B for each of the three operational scenarios. Traffic Signal Warrant Analysis with Driveway D Closed and No Additional Operational Modifications Based on- the traffic signal warrant for the scenario .with Driveway D closed and no additional operational modifications at any of the other three project driveways, the traffic signal warrant is satisfied. In addition to satisfaction of the peak hour traffic signal warrant, the approach delay for the westbound left-turn movement is LOS F (926.1 seconds per vehicle) at the Goldenwest— Driveway B intersection,which provides further justification for installation of a traffic signal under this scenario. Analysis with Driveway D Closed and No-Left-Turn Exit at Drivew B f Traffic Signal Warrantv v ay Based on the traffic signal warrant for the scenario with Driveway D closed and no-left-turn exit at I Driveway B, the traffic signal warrant is not satisfied. All of the study intersections would be i operating at an acceptable LOS. i i -u __ 77 Mr. Kyle McClure LINSCOTT SAPPHOS ENVIRONMENTAL,INC. liLAW & Sports Complex EIR Addendum f 'W December 12, 2003 E N G I N E E R S Page 8 Traffic Signal Warrant Analvsis with Driveway D Closed and Two-Way Traffic on Driveway C Based on the traffic signal warrant for the scenario with Driveway D closed and two-way traffic on Driveway C, the traffic signal warrant is not satisfied. However, installation of a traffic signal at Driveway B is recommended because the westbound approach delay is LOS F (161.5 seconds per vehicle) and westbound left turn movement delay is also LOS F (454.4 seconds per vehicle) at the Goldenwest—Driveway B intersection. This equates to 4.66 vehicle-hours of delay and 4.41 vehicle- hours of delay,respectively, for the westbound approach and westbound left turn movement, which is very close to the vehicle delay warrant requirement of 5.00 vehicle-hours of delay for two approach lanes and exceeds the requirement for one approach lane (4.00 vehicle-hours of delay). CONCLUSION Based on our analysis of the -traffic impacts resulting from the closure of one ingress/egress driveway from the Central Library parking lot to the Sports Complex parking lot (Driveway D), closing Driveway D with no additional operational modifications at any of the other three project driveways or closing,Driveway D.and converting Driveway C to two-way traffic (Alternative No. 2), would result in significant impacts and/or require substantial mitigation measures that were not analyzed in the Huntington Beach Sports Complex E1R. This would lead to the installation of a traffic signal at the intersection of Goldenwest Street and Driveway B. However, the-closure of Driveway D and the installation of median modifications to restrict outbound left-turn movements at Driveway B (Alternative No. 1) or a combination of installation of median modifications to restrict outbound left-turn movements at Driveway B (Alternative No. 1) and converting Driveway C to two-way traffic (Alternative No. 2) would not result in unanalyzed significant impacts, nor would it require any additional mitigation measures (including installation of a traffic signal at the intersection of Goldenwest Street and Driveway'B). Therefore, it is recommended that Alternative No. l (installation of median modifications in Goldenwest Street at Driveway B in order to restrict outbound left-turn movements from Driveway B and the Disc Golf Driveway, while maintaining the northbound and southbound left- turn movements on Goldenwest Street) or a combination of Alternative No. 1 and Alternative No. 2 be implemented in conjunction with the closure of Driveway D, which connects the Central Library parking lot to the Sports Complex parking lot. Mr.Kyle McClure • SAPPHOS ENVIRONMENTAL, INC. Sports Complex EIR Addendum December 12, 2003 E N C I N E E R 5 Page We appreciate the opportunity to submit this Preliminary Traffic Impact Analysis. Should you have any questions or comments regarding this analysis,please contact our office at(714) 641-1587. Very truly yours, LINSCOTT,LAW& ENSPAN,ENGINEERS !i OVESS/p y� *Keil�D. benyfl low Seni Tran tion Engineer * �~ Attachments qT£O ---"-"�f12500C20 2 63�reportk2505 Updated BBCP TU Letter 12-10-03.doe i I i i I 1 'I lI 1 0 0 5% o-10% SLATER l �5% j L57. AV 10%—► — Lo CENTRAL 1 I r IL PARK I s �59� r — s ,I 1 Unci 4--15% 0 N N Sq% ( I In se 'n"l o �► p� TALBERT AV r a 15%—� p n 109 - N O rV �y �n 8%—� -------------- � / N B" ' I I ` b 5% I I NE ( ' .A. ' SPORTS COMPLEX it be 14—z% N -3% in n 0 -- - - - - - - -- — — � ELLIS t-2% AV N o 2%--� .l 5%� 1% i .n I V a W uD 3 O Z o sJ Q = O N W C.5 N N a? -41N ,� a _4% GARFIELD 8 t-2% AV N 3%! 4%j t 4%--► o c I N C I. KEY N f— = INBOUND PERCENTAGE EXHIBIT 1 NO SCALE a'— =OUTBOUND PERCENTAGE I �q C&TT PROJECT TRAFFIC DISTRIBUTION GREENSPAN WITH DRIVEWAY D OPEN I ENGINEERS HUNTINGTON BEACH CENTRAL PARK � i . I i M 0 0-10% SLATER j j--20% .� .--10% AV 10%—+ 10% I 10% I. fib\" 1 10% 000 L' — in - - - - -� CENTRAL PARK I \ F30% " �► I I ALBERT AV — '< 10�—0 Ln _ J to o,� D vE r-------------- A 1 I \\ i B \ N o ,�- ; ; SPORTS COMPLEX rrcp I� � IQ-2% N �� I r9 3% b b c 11% o - -- - - - - — ----� ELLIS .-5% AV `i 5%—o N t N a . N Z ww a J g N 0 � p � w N GARFIELD b t-2% AV N n 4%--► / 6� a N � c KEY INBOUND PERCENTAGE EXHIBIT 2 N NO SCALE a OUTBOUND PERCENTAGE PROJECT TRAFFIC DISTRIBUTION UNSCOTT LAW & WITH- DRIVEWAY "D" CLOSED & I GREENSPAN NO ADDITIONAL MODIFICATIONS N o I r+ E E a s HUNTINGTON BEACH CENTRAL PARK tt _. ..f - _ _..... .. ._ M _O o-109e SLATER j 1-20% -10% AV ,o%—• ,o%� p 1 10%j 1 10% N M N I CENTRAL PARK l I I I N I ( 0ou') TALBERT AV \ a0Lr) . I \ Looms o tQ RIVE B" I b L40% I 1 1 I I \ o o ; SPORTS i _N� -----� I COMPLEX Y >�j, IQ-2% ELLIS .—g% AV `i + o I Ln se 5%� 6�� M ' O F- n W m } O Z w a ' 0 o N O 3 W t l CIE N a � P to M �I tea% GARFIELD 0 r) L2% AV In o N n N 4%—• / v v o n i • c KEY i (t,40 EXHIBIT 3 INBOUND PERCENTAGE SCALE a-- OUTBOUND PERCENTAGE i LlNsco rr ,PROJECT TRAFFIC DISTRIBUTION LAW & WITH DRIVEWAY 'D CLOSED & GREENSPAN NO LEFT'-TURN:. EXIT ® DRIVEWAY B. ENGINEERS Q 1 N E E R s HUNTINGTON BEACH CENTRAL PARK D M O_ a--10% SLATER j i-20% .� *_Io% AV 10%_ 10%-i 10%j 10fi to oMo• L_ r� - - - - -, I CENTRAL 1 1 PARKr . i l gSy r`)o' r N 4—3 0% 4-15% 1 / I N � 1 00 15% I 1 .-10% \ �'�'v' / i �• !� TALBERT AV 10%— J \\ ;ate o v r------ --------- o B I I d Ito% ' E 1 I A I \ clit ; ; I SPORTS `-----� I COMPLEX x a Ln 0 0 ELLIS. . -5% AV 7 6%-� kt a W m 3 0 wa O o tn v 0 0 e L2 o--4% GARFIELD b 8 t-2% AV N # n --► o 4% I o v o N C KEY �T IN PERCENTAGE EXHIBIT 4 1t NO SCALE a--- = OUTBOUND PERCENTAGE LINSCOTT PROJECT TRAFFIC „DISTRIBUTION : LAW & WITH DRIVEWAY D CLOSED & GREENSPAN TWO-WAY TRAFFIC ON BEACH DRIVEWAY P„C" ; ENGINEERS ' I I I I ot2o G SLATER J 1 ,r— 104 AV S0— N�� 2� I I CENTRAL PARK f r•- - - - - - � �Jy3� 1-52139 I � — / 69 I �_ I i�l/ —52 1 � 23— TALBERT AV � . n� o . r — \ C� R� i-------------- I \ I co 1 L — 23 E I I I ( 1 a 1 I \\ o� ,� `-----� SPORTS I COMPLEX ( a L. n L- - -- - - - - - - - - o — — J ELLIS AV N N N i fn F _o W N 3 Z o c J � N W C9 cp cp v O GARFIELD AV in n 0 N 0 I o I N / - � I EXHIBIT 5 N Nd SCALE � I I, PM PEAK HOUR PROJECT TRAFFIC VOLUMES LINSCOTT & LAW WITH DRIVEWAY "D" CLOSED & GREENSPAN NO -ADDITIONAL MODIFICATIONS I E N 0 iN N E E R SE E R S HUNTINGTON .BEACH CENTRAL PARK 1 �c 0 ono —0 ' SLATER J { l 104 AV o--, Ir 1 r 52 Nr,--r I v, FL - -- - - I CENTRAL 1 — I PARK f _ '-52 1 /000 _ J le, 1 J I L 139\1 \ �1 1 r 1 1 �: 0 rn rn oo N - 0 I I ---52 \\ 0--.� ; L 0 TALBERT AV r B Ito 92 l E 1 I i A I I 1 ( / 1 I ----- SPORTS�. � i COMPLEX m I 0 L --- - - -- - -- - -- - J ELLIS AV `i N 3 i O �. N E O w v 3 z w a J _j• O a 9 - _ �d W CD a i O GARFIELD AV N I o 0 N i C i EXHIBIT 6 �tNO SCALE PM---PEAK HOUR PROJECT TRAFFIC VOLUMES LINSCOTTWITH DRIVEWAY "D" CLOSED & LAW & GREENSPAN NO LEFT TURN • EXIT ® DRIVEWAY "B" ERS HUNTING ON BEACH CENTRAL PAR EN01NE K • i o�0 0 SLATER J I l 104 AV 52J Nto-;r - - - - - - CENTRAL PARK \ _ p I - - - - - - ���1 1`52 I . 69\ \\ )/ I F- 1 Ir / co _ o I I \\ o I I , 35 1 TALBERT AV — f r 'l 23-- J a'N o c� r — ---- ZE f to o \ 8 I \ � � I I / 123 VE � I I I I r / i � A � I I \\ � SPORTS I _ -----' COMPLEX Y I I . I r u 0 -- - - - - -- -- -- -� ELLIS AV `i I i N � W m 3 O z w a p o J cn 0 Q _ p O N i N GARFIELD AV N a i I: o t C EXHIBIT 7 N No SCALE PM Pam{ HOUR PROJECT TRAFFIC VOLUMES LINSCOTT & LAW WITH DRIVEWAY "D" CLOSED & GREENSPAN TWO-WAY TRAFFIC ON DRIVEWAY C ENGINEERS HUNTINGTON BEACH' CENTRAL PARK 313 758 SLATER 189 AV 83J� 1 511-- rno^ I 196N L - -. - - - -- # I CENTRAL I PARK I r'S269 I — 139 M ` .. co � � I 11� N 1` ( ` N 119 I I \ l 36 1 TALBERT AV - ! r J \\ :2 o�� r _` r----I--------- " / =o B" I I IL ` 23 E I I it i I Acli ' I I �\ t2n S.----J SPORT I _ I COMPLEX . Icp c 1 I ff 0 L_-- - - -- - - - - - - --I ELLIS AV N N_ 1 N N Z w a 1 0 o O w O N a 3 N GARFIELD AV N n o j o l 0 N N C EXHIBIT 8 (tNO SCALE LINSCOTT YEAR 2005 PM PEAK HOUR TRAFFIC VOLUMES LAW & PROJECT TRAFFIC WITH DRIVEWAY "D" CLOSED & GREENSPAN NO ADDITIONAL MODIFICATIONS ENGINEERS HUNTINGTON BEACH CENTRAL PARK i j ooN[i) 313 758 SLATER J I l 89 AV 11—Sl-- ac" ) • 196-1 L i CENTRAL I i PARK ) / I � �r � �N �,I9 ) r36 TALBERT AV \ 'f j J \ M o t� r - r-------------- I Z-4- RNE ) � •�-o � � B i I 92- I E i ) I A ^� ----� SPORTS _ t _ I COMPLEX Y 7 t I I u ff 0 L-- - - - - --- - - - -- - J ELLIS AV cic 0 i • n ►- v N N w to 3 Z w a o 0 J N O a ce Q Q v ll - rn 3 N GARFIELD AV N 0 i o I N j • c I EXHIBIT 9 (tw SCALE LLNSCOTT YEAR 2005 PM PEAK HOUR TRAFFIC VOLUMES LAW & WITH PROJECT TRAFFIC WITH DRIVEWAY "D CLOSED •& GREENSPAN NO LEFT TURN EXIT ® DRIVEWAY "B" ENGINEERS HUNTINGTON BEACH CENTRAL PARK I �oN `- 313 758 SLATER 189 AV 83J 1 { r -1 51t— rnoN { 196N F� L- - - - -- -1 I CENTRAL I _ I PARK I /C'o 35 cb )ter /I I \ \� ti/ I N o n m 1I-1 f i Go r / N 165 I I / ( L 71 TALBERT AV a,Lo I / RvE r-------------- 23 .E I i { ( / i A I I M cli SPORTS I _ ------ I COMPLEX o 7 t o 0 N -- -- - - - - - - -- -� ELLIS AV c • •i N a� E m W O W 0 � J in 0 J 1- W N P O N GARFIELD AV N M O / O .I O U1 N 1 i tNO EXHIBIT 10 SCALE & YEAR 2005 PM PEAK HOUR TRAFFIC VOLUMES LAW LINS WITH PRGJECT TRAFFIC WITH DRIVEWAY "D" CLOSED & j GREENSPAN TWO .WAY TRAFFIC BEACH DRIVEWAY LYPARK ENGINEERS HUNTINGTON E'N G I N E E R S TABLE I YEAR 2005 PEAK HOUR INTERSECTION CAPACITY ANALYSIS SUND ARY WITH DRIVEWAY D OPEN' Preliminary Traffic Impact Analysis for 'Proposed Changes to the Huntington Beach Sports Complex Huntington Beach, California ' .. • ':�.. is Ai d �"I 5�1''t.�:l 1 �{.• ''^:�' ..� �'�'�� �, ��" '(YJ "Moll*W 4 i#1Phs W/ MUkAtion Air ~_ a.. , Mat.K 3) Goldenwest Street Q AM 0.620 B 0.753 C .0.753 C 0.000 N Slater Avenue PM 0.714 C 0.9095 E 0.928 E 0.020 Y 22.8 C . 4) Goldenwest Street @ AM 0.277 A 0339 A 0339 A 0.000 N — - Lib (falbert Avenue PM 0356 A 0."2 A 0.490 'Source:This table was taken directly from the prior traffic impact analysis conducted-.for the Huntington Beach Sports Complex Environmental Impact Report(FIR),dated February 22,1999. `l Of the 4 study intersections analyzed in this report,only the Goldenwest Street at Slater Avenue and Goldenwest Street at -Library/Talbert Avenue were required to be analyzed in the Huntington Beach Sports Complex. 3Year 2005 Background Traffic Conditions include planned and funded improvements that are expected to be constructed by year 2005. .14 Significant if intersection LOS is B or worse. s LOS also shown as intersection delay in(seconds)using Highway Capacity Software(HCS)unsignalized intersection. Bold ICU and LOS values indicate adverse service levels based on City and/or CMP LOS standards. i . I st O K, LAW E N G I N E E R 5 TABLE 2 YEAR 2005 PEAK HOUR INTERSECTION CAPACITY ANALYSIS SUMMARY WITH DRIVEWAY D CLOSED &NO ADDMONAL MODIFICATIONS Preliminary Traffic Impact Analysis for Proposed Changes to the Huntington Beach Sports Complex Huntington Beach, California mo4wolt tlTa >tyz �t rttFa o-tl 8 w4ft p,. _ Etta - 3) Goldenwest Street @ Slater Avenue PM 0.718 C 0.752 C 0.773 C 0.021 N 4) Goldenwest Street Q Library/Talbert Avenue PM 0349 A 0.366 A 0.511 A 0.145 N 11) Goldenwest Street Q Driveway A PM 0.00 A 0.00 A 0.1 sec/veh A — N 12) Goldenwest Street Driveway B PM 0.00 A 0.00 A 24.5 seclveh C3 — N 'Year 2005 Background Traffic Conditions include updated information regarding planned and funded improvements that are expected to be constructed by year 2005. Significant if intersection LOS is E or worse. 'The Highway Capacity Manual recognizes the average intersection delay as the measure for determining the intersection LOS, which is LOS C,but the westbound left-turn delay on the westbound approach,which is part of the average intersection delay value,is LOS P(926.1 seconds/vehicle). Bold ICU and LOS values indicate adverse service levels based on City and/or CMP LOS standards i I LAW E N G I N E E R 5 TABLE 3 YEAR 2005 PEAK HOUR INTERSECTION CAPACITY ANALYSIS SUMMARY WITH DRIVEWAY D CLOSED &NO-LEFT-TURN EXIT @ DRIVEWAY B Preliminary Traffic Impact Analysis for Proposed Changes to the Huntington Beach Sports Complex Huntington Beach,California }! TtCtni� !.: Pia0it1�lirlt°3e °'' ils !� ct#jt +pliet/ . . will - -,> 3) Goldenwest Street @ Slater Avenue PM 0.718 C 0.752 C 0.773 C 0.021 N 4) Goldenwest Street @ Lib galbertAvenue PM 0.349 A 0.366 A 0.511 A 0.145 N k 11) Goldenwest Street @ Driveway"A" PM 0.00 A 0.00 A (I.5 see/veh . A — N 12) Goldenwest Street @ Drivewa `B" PM 0.00 A 0.00 A 1.7 sec/veh A — N Year 2005 Background Traffic Conditions.include updated information regarding planned and funded improvements that are expected to be constructed by year 2005. z Significant if intersection LOS is E or worse. Bold ICU and LOS values indicate adverse service levels based on City and/or CUP LOS standards sk I i I 1 Z 'LINSCOTT �{ 4%r E N G I N E E R S TABLE 4 YEAR 2005 PEAK HOUR INTERSECTION CAPACITY ANALYSIS SUMMARY WITH DRIVEWAY D CLOSED &TWO-WAY TRAFFIC ON DRIVEWAY C PreliminaryTraffic Impact Analysis for P Y Proposed Changes to the Huntington Beach Sports Complex Huntington Beach, California 3 7- I ;< 3) Goldenwest Street Q Slater Avenue PM 0.718 C 0.752 C 0.773 C 0.021 N 4) Goldenivest Street >' Library/Talbert Avenue PM 0.349 A 0.366 A 0.507 A 0.141 N 11) Goldenwest Street Q Drivewa A PM 0.00 A 0.00 A 0.1 sec/veh A — N 12) Goldenwest Street a@ Drivewa B PM 0.00 A 0.00 A 6.9 sec/veh A' — N Year 2005 Background Traffic Conditions include updated information regarding planned and funded improvements that are <_> expected to be constructed by year 2005. a Significant if intersection LOS is.E or worse. The Highway Capacity Manual recognizes the average intersection delay as the measure for determining the intersection LOS, �. which is LOS A,bdt the westbound left-tam delay on the westbound approach,which is part of the average intersection delay value,is LOS F(454.4 seconds/vehicle). Bold ICU and LOS values indicate adverse service levels based on City and/or CMP LOS standards l C I E N G 1 N E E R 5 i 4 f � I I I j W I P a I L E N G t N E E R 5 r:. is='s f APPENDIX A EXISTING 2003 TR AFFIC COUNT DATA 1 1' I Inc.Transportation Studies, <' 1350 Reynolds Avenue - C{y: HUNTINGTON BEACH Suite 115 File Name :H0310080 Direction: GOLDENWEST STREET Irvine,CA 92614 Site Code :00000§19 V Direction: SLATER AVENUE Start Date : 10/30/2003 _ Page No : 1 Groups Printed-Turn nq Movements GOLDENWEST STREET SLATER AVENUE GOLDENWEST STREET SLATER AVENUE Southbound Westbound Northbound Eastbound Start Time Ri ht Thru Left Right I Thru Left Right I Thru I Left Right I Thni I Left Int Total Factor 1.0 1.01 1.0 1.01 1.01. 1.0 1.01 1.01 1.0 1.01 1.0 1 1:0 04:00 PM 21 233 42 43 133 16 38 210 29 23 125 I 14, 927 04.15 PM 23 215 47 60 155 15 21 205 28 34 144 12! 959 !,. 04:30 PM 22 230 41 72 158 11 23 213 27 20 113 11 ".941 04:45 PM 23 232 -`39 78 186 17 15 188 36 36 113 17 '980 Total 69 910 169 253 632 59 97 816 1201 113 495 54 .3807 05:00 PM 26 240 53 84 175 19 23 256 46 34 121 231 1100 05:15 PM 17 191 58 90 200 19 15 226 39 37 131 17! 1040 05.30 PM 32 216 52 64 180 22 19 244 42 27 103 16; 1017 _ 05:45 PM 31 202 -44 63 174 22 17 243 34 40 136 24 i 1030 Total 106 849 -207 301 729 82 74 969 161 138 491 801 4187 Grand total 195 1759 376 554 .1361 141. 171 1785 281 8.3 251 '986 134i 7994 A Total% 2.4 22.0 14.7 I 26.9 0.0 6.9 1.8 I 2.1 2.6 22.3 13.5 I 13.1 1Z.3 1.7 I I l I , I. I Transportation Studies,Inc. 1350 Reynolds.-Avenue. - ,'ity: HUNTINGTON BEACH Suite 11s File Name ; H0310081 .- $Direction: GOLDENWEST STREET Irvine,CA.92614 Site Code :00000979 dV Direction: TALBERT-LIBRARY ENTRAN Start Date : 10/30/2003 Page No : 1 Groups Printed-Tumin_q Movements GOLDENWEST STREET TALBERT-LIBRARY - GOLDENWEST STREET TALBERT-LIBRARY i Southbound Westbound Northbound Eastbound Start Time RiqLtj Thru Left Right I Thru Left Right I -Thru Left Right F 'Thru Left Int.Total Fadtor 1.0 1 1.01 1.0 1.01 1.01 1.0 1.0 .1.01 1.0 1.0 1.0 1-.0 04:00 PM 0 211 17 17 0 9 .10 223. 0 0 0 0 487 . 04:15 PM 0 245 25 22 0 9 7 226 01 0 0 0 534 04:30 PM 0 211 17 25 0 6 9 246 0 0 0 .0 514 04:45 PM 0 261 19 33 0 14 7 201 0 0 0 0 535 Total 0 928 781 97 0 381 33 896 01 0 0 01 2070 05.00 PM 0 245 24 34 0 11 •8 316 0 0 0 01 63.8 05:15 PM 0 222 16 33 0 7 5 215 0 0 0 . 0 558 05:30 PM 0 233 14 23 0 12 5 298 0 0 0 0 �85 05:45 PM 0 265 19 24 0 5 9 267 0 6 '0 0 589 Total 0 965 73 •114 .0 35 27 1156 0 0 0 01 2370 Grand Total 0 1893 151 l 211 0 73 d 60 2052 0 0 0 0 I 4440 Apprch% . 0.0 92.6 7.4 I 74.3 0.0 25.7 If 2.8 97.2 0.0 0.0 0.6 0.0 Total% .0.0 42.6 3.4 4.8 0.0 1.6 1.4 462 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 I Transportation,Studles%Inc. 1350 Reynolds.-Avenue Kity: . HUNTINGTON BEACH Suite 115 File Name : H0310082 S Direction: GOLDENWEST STREET Irvine,CA.92614 Site Code : 00000916 -W Direction: CENTRAL PARK DRIVEWAY Start Date : 10/30/2003 Page No : 1 Groups Printed-Tum nq Movements CENTRAL PARK CENTRAL PARK GOLDENWEST STREET DRIVEWAY GOLDENWEST STREET DRIVEWAY Southbound Westbound Northbound Eastbound Start Time Right Thru Left Ri ht 1 hcu I Left Ri ht Thru Left Ri ht Thru Leftl Int.Total Factor 1.01 1.01 1.0. 1.01 1.0 1 A 1.01 1.01 1.0 1,0 1.0" 04:00 PM 0 234 0 0 0 0 -0 231 0 0 0 01 465 04:15 PM 2 232 0 0 0 0 0 221 1 0 0 01 .456 04:30 PM 3 219 6 0 0 0 0 230 0 0 0 0 452 04:45 PM 2 253 01 0 0 0 0 250 1 1 3 0 1 ' 510 Total 7 938 0j 0 0 01 0 932 21 3 0 1 1 1883 05:00 PM 1 287 0 0 0 0 0 304 0 1 0 0 593 05:15 PM 0 264 0 0 0 0 0 316 1 4 0 0 585 05:30 PM 1 217 0 0 0 0 0 286 0 3 0 0 507 05,45 PM 0 222 '0 0 0 0 0 242 0 2 0 2 466 Total 2 990 0 0 0. 0 0 1148 1 10 0 2 2153 Grand Total 9 1928 0 0 0 0 0 2080 3 13 0 3' 40311 Apprch% 0.5 99.5 0.0 ( 0.0 0.0 O.D 0.0 99.9 0.1 I 81.3 0.0 18.8 I Total% 0.2 47.8 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 .0.0 51.5 0.1 0.3 0.0 0.1 1 D k t' I �n e E N G J N E E R 5 APPENDIX S HOLLY SEACLIFF SPECIFIC PLAN PROJECT STATUS &TRAFFIC GENERATION FORECAST i r: f „�.... •?�a�r -.::rl� =:��_'�"`�� _a"� -`a�� _-_ ���_ as :��, ,r� .-.- --___. _ - :�-� --- ___.. N HOLLY SEACLIFF CONSTRUCTIONSCHEDULE OVERVIEW PM PEAK NoV� AS-OF OCTOBER 2003 IN OUT ?O?AL MAP APPROVED PERMITS % REF.# PROJECT TYPE UNITS ISSUE_ D BUILT Bluffs �SFD 85 85 100 1 ' 143$5 - Pacific.Landing SFD 29 29 100 2 14590 Greystoue Keys DUP 150 150 100 3 ' 14662 Lyon Shores SFD 90 90' 100 (�1 4 14659 Port Ivy SFD 83 83 100 5 14700 6 Promenade -ATT, 80 80 100 CONDOS Riviera SFD 101 101 100 7 14700- Sandpipier SFD 81 81 100 8 14659 - SeaCvuntry SFD -63 63 .100 "9 , 14659 St.Augustine ..SFD 71 71 100 10 14355 Ttdibtrryl SFD :79-' 7J 100 11 14700 Westport SFD 126 126 100 12 14700 P HOLLY SEACLIFF TMIP CONSTRUCTION SCHEDULE OVERVIEW PM Pr-Al u wiz_ AS OF OCTOBER 2003 ICJ OUT TOTAL z MAP APPROVED PERAMS % REF. # PROJECT TYPE UNITS ISSUED BUILT g 27 Siena A is APTS 29 •29 Built 28 Main St Condos CONDOS 21 21 Under P.A. $ Const.- 8 30 Industrial m 57,391sq. ft. 57,391sq. ft. Under Bld s. PO4. 1-9 Const. 7 -49 S 6 31 Geil Kiln 1ND . 21,500sq,ft. Built Manufacturin PROPOSED A Hearing in 29 Bonanni SFD 20 Proposed falUwinter `03 115 '7 2 p TOTAL APPROVED UNITS: 29006 11958 TOTAL SQ. M APPROVED: 174,231 174,231 FV E N G I N E E R S C 1 . I APPENDIX C ! FUTURE YEAR 2005 DRIVEWAY"D" CLOSED AND NO ADDITIONAL EVIPROVEMENTS I INTERSECTION CAPACITY UTILIZATION(ICU) &HIGHWAY CAPACITY MANUAL(HCAI) LEVEL OF SERVICE CALCULATION SHEETS 6 •9 i 4 - LINSCOTT,LAW&GREENSPAN,ENGINEERS 1580 Corporate DOW,Sude 122 Casts Mesa CA 92626 (714)641-1597 INTERSECTION CAPACITY UTILIZATION Goldenwest Street 0 Slater Avenue N•S St: Goldenwest Street Peak hr. PM pate: '......... E-W St: Sister Avenue Annual Growth: 2.00`Y pale of Count: 2003 Project: Huntington Basch Central Park Projection Year. 2005 File: 1873EIR Addendum lCU3 +rwn ,};• Brr3• :C I:iQPk%:`•: ? %:•':�Z005^:•:>:z:':> FNbThru .... am � r..,.. r.r.r....... �....... Par,.. :.-. :...O ft 161 1700 0.095 6 167 0.098 0 167 1700 0.098 23 190 1700 0.112. 0 190 1700 OAl2 0 19D 1700 0.112 ru 969 3400 02B5• 39 1008 0296' 25 1033 3400 0.3M• 69 1102 34DO 0.324 ' 0 1102 3400 0.324 0 1102 3400 0.324 ight .74 17DO 0.044 3 77. 0.045 0 77 1700 0.045 48 123 1700 0.072 -0 123 1700 0.072 0 123 17DO 0.072 Sb Left 207 1700 0.122• 8 215 0.127 0 .215 1700 0.127• 0 215 170D 0.127• 0 215 1700 0.127 ' 0 216 1700 0.127' Sb-Thru 849 5100 0.166 34 am 0.173 22 905 510D 0.177• 156 1061 5100 0208 0 1061 5100 0208 0 1061 5100 0203 . Sb Right" 106 1700 0.062 -4 110 n.065 0 " 110 1700 '0.065'' "`" 0 110 1700 '0.065 ' 0 110 1700 0,065 0 110 1700 0.065 Eb Left BO 1700 0.047.1 3 63 0.049• 0 83 1700 0.049• 0 83 1700 0.049• 0 83 1700 . 0.049• 0 83 1700 0.049 ' j EbTtuu 491 3400 0.144 20 511 0.160 0 611 3400 0.150 0 511 3400 -.0.150 0 511 3400 0,150 0 511 3400 0,150 Eb RIghC•. 138 1700 0.081 6 144 0.084 0 144 1700 0.084 52 196 1700 0.115 0 196 1700 0.115 0 196 1700 0.115 Wb Left - 82' 1700 0.048 3 65 0A50 - 0 85 1700 0.050. 104 189 1700 6.111 0 189 1700 0.111 0 109 1700 0.111 Wb Thru 729 3400 0214 * 29 758 O.W• 0 758 340D 0223 0 768 3400 0223' 0 758 340D 0.223• 0 758 3400 0223 Wb Right" 301 17DO 0.177 12 313 0.154 0 313 1700 0.184 0 313 1700 0.184 0 313 1700 0.184 ' 0 313 1700 0.184 4 }..}:. .a : ..,x our}:.r:.:;:...v::.:::4:t•::.r.:�.a;;..;•i}}:•:.;.:..:.:.:r.•.....:...:::..::.::...}.:.:.:•..,:•.,•:....�::::::.r.:-d ,n.:. ...}:F+4 +: :rx r ... a .........:... r.r,...:. � ..:...:. r...:A ...,....:..:...,..,..f. ...........r. ..r .r... .x v I M.. :. r.. , , .....,,. r ..^.:..,•+:r.n...:. n:...r .?:}.ti.. v.•.1 .. �4r::::.v::;.- :.....r..,.nri:C:•::. :. ,v:'.}.}?'.:.:. .., ..�1�`t3:...}.: ..:...r...r...:.......:...r�:4,ttS9:.:..:........................:... .::r:...•.:::..,.. .. r:::•:�.::i.>r:;>:is}}r::;.:•}:::::•:<i.;;.::;<:<s:r:;:::;;.:;:.:«•.•�<h.,�...�........�4i�,>.....:.::.::......::::.::::::.:.:.... ..}..............::i...:..,,.,..,.>;,.:.,.:::,..n•::.::,«..,........................:::•::<<•:::.......................................................:.. ..r...:,.....:.::.....:?h��',...,:...................... .t��.�^:.;.`7t:1!aft#Vt::..............:..........:.r..3t:..... ... .. ... 1CU" -'0.71B 0.745 '0.752- O.T73 0.773 0.773 LOS C C C C C C •'Functions is a right turn lane;however,not striped as such Area Traffic Mitigation: 10:54 AM •Key conflicting movement as a part of ICU Pmjert ICU Impact; 0.020' 1 Counts conducted by:City of HB November 1997 2 CspacIWdxpressed In'vetbhWrof green - �R�a .....v„ .c., �.. �aa.... .:�.� -�r.cr r.,i�1`•.�..�.._.T,�..�'�� "s x `n: �' f T .tn,� �,.,. r �- e:_.,.. � :�>; ':�+�s,����c-tea{r i-,� Y,r)3't l-n�r� >v."g-' r,','r .c.. .T+.s>�-''' k w-. E s" - - s- r• .rr-. ,fig. .�i_,a, 3x!:.�•L .e3..:w.v:".. .;;'' '1:7r, s .J. ,. f 1.) _..-, _. :. .F-.,°YF' '�z.,._.7,..i.?. _:� �.�.. .,.. _ .fxY.�,.f j i L-. R•sra} yY A tit �-3rT _c`: .Jy "s' fr� .yam ru'�s 'iK[Y h Xrti,r '�t,}- Q. •ss ssnw.T h ,c, lS�> �60 .,t�?7�.w ,b5r j.cr .,- .', ,3'".._Y� '� a 'srs;1'£ d'.�r rT�'��s :'u w ° t 2.cT•'( * 8s�* .f� �.,..,.y�'�YTm:.: r �`.-?4.Gt�'"T`r; ',. j,u`,.t'.-, G'„„gypp'i`fiixa 9 Ak i p�s«•Y `'..�• JU.;FwiTtr� �,y. ; "� "'ty`r gg i S rc:9)w:,r i >- j .� w..3--E,TYk Fr Y�T ty^3'E)a•4 t r f- � , ,�..,1•.��Cx?-�^M4�e�,r*e�. ='�ta '�i��` r t'�.,r„t,�� 'Y�?•.` t:l�..,.,,�'i� 'S's(`y{.�,,C x �,,-u!'.: ,.fi•-!�..tll,.�A.� ��,,.� ._. ?� 4`t .f�,�,�f{7,�"'✓ -,s.�... .o:. .:r v 3...e,. -.. .. .._... l�.tr,. .:r. -s .,1.'• s':. S' ,lam )t ,S.,F }' -• ($1 V•- p�r�J/ 9 } } � {y x5t{ k 5 3f i .fit L� YiZr r2 t .d� iN�r� v a;L9 7 n i r3 G 3s. , c,>a. c *,.� v:"\ €l :.7s�: r_,,'��•.i' it { Y,.}'�'•y.,?Y. 'I LYyI ,��'r t n `S\., ..}..�... � :._..� � _t.,ci. � ..u.:-. _� 'i vYC...d `t...S::r- .::Cs. Z.}._.fi��'F ...��r?..: ''..i• t r 1' t F t vs I 1 Y•-` Kr,[ -'4 n 1'rP 1 r -i,« 7a-ra .a � ?y och. .r' iy: �} �^ Saw G [y�'��� .. ?1' er-O �-.�..ili;L :� �r s �,t �....'.,:c.s ,'-,s..'-^n�..t,.�' ,� i��vP`t�'.�-'Ni 5,, ,:n i rr�c.�. �,i} .v.:�; v�.s y._ ✓-� r •1 i - - 11 " 11 - - has.°,i��Ci����yc��f'�(`���`di��P�?s..�.��� * .�0�'. ',, c��.�r� f 5 :rr fir:'. r�i, j N,�';r�£'(t4t��' -Yr svrs"4�. r is,�� `s 'y€�3� c Fy � ;i •: 71Iy 1 11 11 11 11 11 11 ~ �'' f.i � .7(�Q}.r. nn��..l. fir .' ,.;�: c� -: .F,-s c.'�:S'tl �+!o';:r. V.. 5.' . ,.A.I�io try,r��.i t�G44 rr ;, �„��t_ k:.=iC—ram}v _�• •f...:.4t t �..rj'. F t} .t. 'j •• • }0 .� d �/ LAW E N G I N E E R S APPENDIX D FUTURE-YEAR 2005 DRIVEWAY"D" CLOSED AND NO LEFT TURN EXIT AT DRIVEWAY`B" INTERSECTION CAPACITY UTILIZATION(ICU) &HIGHWAY CAPACITY MANUAL(HCYI) LEVEL OF SERVICE CALCULATION SHEETS F I r I I I ATOM"-_ :...__.._-- -.._......_ UNSCOTT,LAW S GREENSPAN.ENGINEERS 1580 Corporate Ddm,Su@e 12Z Costa Mess CA 92626 ui,i)641-1687 INTERSECTION CAPACITY UTILIZATION Goldenwesl Street 0 Stater Avenue NS St: Goldenwesl Street Peak hr. PM . Date: `•'•^•"• E-W St: Slater Avenue Annual Growth: 200% Date of Count: 2003 Project• Huntington Beach Central Park Projec0on Year. 2005 File: 1873EIR Addendum-ICU3 .•{ 4:c% •'n`.'}ii:' .�+�:. }�;• ..�+.; {.}y;yr i. i C :}Z6 � ..{:•'r.:l;R }}i,4'•:tit^i::;:;}}: )F 'Y F 6 .n o'`•`Y. 89•i� -..•ram... .lam ..:�•�.�ri :.i- Q3. .r:r/ . �i.� .�. .}}}}:.y:. } •::..<rr ,... ..a. . '.. �. :•:': . . .. . . . r...r. r.r::.r::.,.�•.rr. . . : r.. r::i :'r r..:Fil�,.f::. .�..r`''I-rr9�„�,'.,r s}Y4:;>:}.:.<:.}:;,:, : .]�....,,,�t... : �.. :. �7..(�.,r�r.,.. .,.. .. { h. :.+. (L. .., ...-,.•:.: " � .. g�, ...?.•��7� .::':;-':,T•-}}•}..-,}i�S�i..:.l+:.r�v`: '� ...L!{i`v .:5... JC .. ..r :n•{N.. .. .:r r. "r`P .k,.rr. .,:. ,4Yr.. n: :L..r:.:• +M .. 3..r 4 .,..,... r:. {x•.tti`..:.}:!... .. ,,: ...... :.. .. .... v..v S. .. v. :...:::•::.,:•:.:::.:}:}. :.}:{!r:-:..�}' :}•:o�:?::�':%.;:.:;•+•: r...'.}r+ .r3:r.." -r F{"-:$.:.�4i ..r•�`fA'Ad. ,<+°.�Q1a1..,... .:4lllt�d' ..Qta.... ...:'Ir:.!��f•+.r...:. t7t-dl•.,.:L..•.:r: .}::Xflfb..r:r::•:.Atic�dr,r.;o. ..."1'.... ..s..:. :.:}.r.:s K• :'t::'- r}...r.. .,4:. ,.r ..r .. ........:..�:.:4:•-::...... :•:...,.....:.:::.::::.... ....... .� .�' .taF-r ..?Xl.C,r. ..1(dtlb#Sz:>x�aitacl,.::�.. .9r 1fCE>�%'i . ....,.r.s'3.`.. ....::*'..... .:. .. f.:.+s .,:r. ..::.::.::,,. .::.,:,r.: {. .,.;.:. :.•:..: .::,.rr.-:,..:.:rr::.-•r .::r.::::..:., •.:......r....::..r:-4.t4:• .::.}°'..1r .:,,..,; ,...,,r., ,.:....:r ...:},::,•. 4: :.: .f 4:x•S•..,}.:;.:•:•:.,.,. firs...:........ :�: :3•r :::• .::.,-r:. r ':. 'y?;�, rf,:•,^,5. •` ..: ..... }.;, L•y.: ):;.`.;r:.y.,i}}` ,}:}>...:.;•+^4:: :::•• :.n 7tn•}•� 4 e.i„1/. .:.4. 1f r.F p( .}{{- .. •;. Nb Left 161 1700 0.095 . 6_ 197 0.098 0 167 1700 0.098 23 too 1700 0.112 0 190 1700 0.112 0 190 1700 0.112 Nb Thru B68 3400 0285'• 39 �008 0296' 25 1033 3400 0.304' 68 1102 3400 0.324' 0 1102 3400 0.324 ' 0 1102 3400 0,324 Nb Right- 74 1700 0.044 3 71 0.045 0 77 1700 0.045- --46 -123 .1700 -0.072 0 123 1700 0.072 0 123 1700 0.072 b Left 207 1700 0.122• e 215 0.127' .0. 215 .. 1700 0.127 ' ..0 215 _ 1700. 0.127 ' 0 215 1700 0.127 ' 0 215 1700 0.127 Sb Thru 849 5100 0.166 34 B83 0.173 22 905 5100 0,177 156 1061 Slot) 0208 0 1061 5100 0,208 0 1061 5100 '0208 SbRight- 106 1700 0.062 4 110 0.065 0 1f0 1700 0.065" 0 1101700 0.065 0 110 1700 0.065 0 110 1700 0.065 Eb Left 80 1700. 0.047' 3 83 0.049• 0. 83- 1700 0.049' 01 83 1780 0.049• 0 83 1700 0.049 ' 0 83 1700 0.049 Eb Thru 491 3400 0,144 20 611 0.150 0 511 3400 0.150 0 611 3400 0.150 0 511 3400 0.J50 0 511 3400 0.150 Eb Right•' US 1700 0.081 6 144 0,084 0 144 1700 0.084 52 -196 1700 0,115 0 lea 1700 0.116 0 196 1700 0.115 Wb Left 82 1700 0.048 3 85 0.050 0 05 1700 0.050- 104 189 1700 0,111 0 189 1700 0.111 0 189 1Tt)0 0.111 Wb Thru 729 3400 0214 29 758 0=1 0 758- 3400.-0223•• 0 758 3400 0223• 0 758 3400 0223 0 758 3400 0,223 Wb R1ght•• 301 1700 0.177 12 313 0,184 0. 313 1700 0.184 0 313 1700 0.184 0 313 1700 0.184 0 313 1700 0.164 w v.w....4.;,••i. ":. ••fi H•. rr v:•:::•:v••:::•;•}•:•. •. v:�:. }• .}{+.Fny.v}..,;,...y.,}:ii%`•{�•{'r yr}.;.4�•;..,.4}h}':%?.ar,:i.}.f.;,.,}.. ...r U {dne::%ir.A J,� r Y4n Y}{.r ../.. .+./ r..i r. +.{:. ....C.... ... v.}':h::4xr-....{r.}v!rr.:x.:{rrr.•i}i'r:i}}:4:::{4w:h... . .: .:. .....x Y: .✓t n F. .. .r.4.{...v.. .p.:.r.rr.,{r..FrY.r..,•...`/n,..:......:.r. .fN ..... wt :.•..::..:.........: }}}i}} i.:Fi::.},:•:{•}:•}}} f.F- }. .:....0 f. ..:n r. ,b{.. ..v n .,r.:...:..r..r.?r.r.:...4...fi. �....�.0 .. r.r.r •..fi... ..n...n.}, ':�1Fr r?;i ...vk�': h......:..... .r rt.,.+..�...r..I�Y.`!Y.•.....r.. /.,if{,':..:..f•.r..1...n� ...... ....:../....{... ... .n. :.Y 1y`��.r n ..,••• .rfi..• }T `fW1^l:n...r%;:,+.;:h:{.:C.}}}}':v:: :F:..:�: vr:. r.:.,.rrw.�::•r.::::....:.::n:.y:%i:; :i?iY ICU 0.718 0.745 0.7ti2 0.773 ::•:;...::>.::........ :::r:::::..:•::}S:•:. :::>.:;:.r.•.s: Vr :<::s :::........ C 0.773 0.773 LOS C C C C C ••Functions as a right turn lane,however,not striped as such Area Tratlic Mitigatton: 11 b9 AM •Key conglcting movement as a part of ICU Project ICU Impact: 0.020. 1 Counts conducted bY•City of HB November 1997 a' "2 Capactty expressed In vetuhbur of green ' { �..y!a� �� .-....� .a.r�r�., �.'��t-.,. �,}�.,....Ss-t.:-�.. � ;�,.� .,r�-'sj_{:� ',A.,?,r,.��a�e Jt;'�t�.•.G.•�.3.s'_..4 ...hr ...�-, "t'; '!''; :.,t�J.a;,: �':.{�.���,,.�e.._ � � t �Sa i _- �,x ``'f aK�s`r;�..r-_��=,�ea�i�G-`fi. �I .��t�,41,`�°.•flr? ',,t...4i Y�}.:�"' J -r r'',�7,,h°`tom. � "t.'n =cE/Y. ,�'4'?''P�`.j r'.{sL^='�i v 5.,w b�>.,/r.�.�c �t � '-'i��''S �f 3.r 5� f�3t,�y }T`�l7 t,�} ibt'�S r-i.,1��zgef.,�t�✓,�°'�i` T1�`�a'" P�'"�r hs�f -`t o urn`ry �r�;�2'.^t S,•S��a�x,'� �Yi '"`,i�*I' v�-����.��4� ���JN..�� .��.'4 A.s,'' >qt..ri��r,� �,::�u'' '/'�•�r��.'V3�c�T..=�?„.t,��.r.�g.s:.�fi�' 'i�l..!'..�.�:r,�y-cz,';"'r��1;'zirt,?,cs.rf}`:`y�;,�"`.�'.� �<M, �s�_?;:.r-1 r.'?;..,,-,+i-.,., t[.. � u ' _�fl�@i�'�E'�TT 3Sin Y} r `•.'^ y !`'� �'ti Z r Ir v�+n-:fit a i"r `"fit£ �. '.^'.. J Fr.F.x fc 1 -f '.>.r t Y`� f�.t�b,s' #}t! ? a.rC r 'N� -5. Nn, . ,'a:�� .. . .:.._ �.A-_ ���#r.. ¢Sb-�:el.�';�...-••,. ,�'{r:t..z:..3��rh':=.,. �,k,Yt'{'�....-..-:��,ti.F_n._.t�Y.-��'.�.<,��:,`*.a.J�'w`�x,'tj. `�x.t,�..a?�"?.'�-x-��3`t�'_-"�'r�f.t �- tu : �� t~IK �) '^* S .4, '{.� P 7 ! 3- TR M t _.S �..c3 v.YY �^1_ s::? J" `� ra "r� �i..-.F�`i`�,�c f'rr a _,r.. ,•_.r 5, !.. _:r°y,S ,-t,}� 6 �` "' - ,?:TF. A., C't-., rt.E.;}.. .rat �<-•:J.� ri: f...L Z. � '.J�1 fo n;��lr ���.7�P, f fi�"3+3. ��,, r�.E T,:f":,';...'��s..'K'�i>z.,�>�,:xirZt�.�T!r,G++':�. 4;In: �'z..�,4-z.1,1n�"��,I.�}+.��Et.�r".,�_•d..J !2 7 1..r� F : t '' �+,�f C�:�tr�, N��Cli Iidi {!�' .�: I� r�T3 V1 ,V{ ` > ., ti 'a v' )Tlyi'"'.'K, _ �,1 f'r�y,�s� 3 t.I- 4 ` St,... �y.' _ y� fyyf��i.-!r_} ,, S J� +�3 [� K. C� l+rF-i. M� } � r'sl�Li•s4 �'1" • • • • Mslomqtgm itl}t 4y etiat��1' t. ,C� t'^' {'.> 2, r r• d�,ir gi} 1' +.,;- .a ,� S +•. 5+1 .i +}. + .:15. �'r! s} i+ 5� W '*C! :+ t C4:, J5 ......•� ;� ,..... t-�:.-.r 5 re'.'l„= ,7 t.. ..s vl..rc.t t... Y tfi'...a +iiYY:rf n-r ... _. .,.�_ d.. .3.�. S� 7.a.�,_,t, n •_'.>:,. it • - - -- / 11 11 �- 1 4 1 K -C K1oii .r J 1 { • - - 1 1 1 1 7rl 1 'a l y. k1 , • - - - • l yt { 1 1 1 1 1 1 - - - ?-.-. )�� iE,t. _,,,L.i.x-. +�. 'i-.l 4 it " ;�, ,w ,ia.,, wA� i�f' � ^, >.,�.; ,,p.}.ty..•'aar� 2;. lr�f �F'rt �^��� �{a��[7!y,�u,�url�sr.�.�fL-ti�S°l�'� '!;r., �'�eb�t� tk_: xah�t,�,c�����t•�°�f-U`��1„1�,��r `� �r � z K t;,#•'_�_ -,,_:• IwoNEI- E N G I N E E R S APPENDIX E FUTURE YEAR 2005 DRIVEWAY `D CLOSED AND TWO-WAY TRAFFIC ON DRIVEWAY `C' INTERSECTION CAPACITY UTILIZATION (ICU) &HIGHWAY CAPACITY MANUAL (HCM) LEVEL OF SERVICE CALCULATION.SHEETS ,t 3_T+. . a i I 4 f' y I UNSCOTT,LAW&GREENSPAN,ENGINEERS 1580 Corporate Drive,SuRe 12Z Costa Mesa CA 92626 (714)641-1587 INTERSECTION CAPACrI'Y UTILIZATION Goldenwest Street Q Sister Avenue N-S St: Goldenwest Street Peak hr, PM Date: 11/06M3 E-W Sr Slater Avenue Annual Growth: 2.00% Datwo(Count: 2003 "ect: Huntington Beads Central Perk Projection Year. 2005 File: 1873EIR Addendum-ICU3 . .:Yfi'<:R}}x ::d,, ;}.+.Sj jI115:•• v.v+:}.;?`:;xh:>} I F 2 g:Y.G;}...•.:•+• .....`}:;.:+.,:?r::>'F•.'•'RFfi:r •a::^:r•F':},r•v: q .. .,St�� `. .�. .��.��CF+r..�F.rS• '.r � ..T. Q� :i�f.x .+'� .l r� ..�P.�}�Q�:; ... rv`::��.... i.;}'�:- .{.. /"} N. . -:. :T.TQ.T.....n�...:.. ... .v:.:E�n��T•:{•.r.:.:x. n.; rr�r �� Q�• r7f.n:�:}•'•i!; {\:...::nv.{.x:::• .r. .}n.l..,>..f,. ..: r fi .r•.. ..-. -. .. f. , `.�',p .n. r, ., {'1A •',•rr. '.-fyW.:•f{4'• +.'. +r},. hF4}..;.. ... •.... ... ... f . n ..: .. } ,. r :•• ..: � +. .+::$ `n}}Y.•:''+'` •'.Y o.. ,y <j}`r. +�. ••l5i:r•?'.';.'.::., ..:•..d.d frvr.. ..;w. f.,., .>� .,. ..,.. .�� ...� ...{. ... .a.,t r.-.�•. ... ...... .... rT'.:....:••::/:r.• :i+•^:w5:i.+..�..?;.• 'i';�:;... ..: ..v C' •, :n• ..... :: .+.Y!...} .. . .w .,r.+•:... ::.y:... Fx;� •:4' :•:tS':"i{<i"���:;?:}$>'? ,, ✓.n � '•� .' •1A11 .hR•. !f} i. .?.{ ^L•n:+G•,'1dG. .'-}:1Ad .:3":'Eak.xr..r -�.4+:�::{•:. pkd:•F :Q ,.::•}.:r::•.ry J'i..W f +vF;r -.T •::, }.- n� d•.��•.,. .::t.{:n:.v..... T +?:r:^ }.�,.. ..fi .ry . 1�• Vut' .�..• .. .. . .. r- a r. -r �,7�y•,,•�� >:- .. �... •, -. .:.�{,r., :...,x......:. c•:i .:.... .:•:t:^•.:>:�F•:��. ::?A!1..... ..:;�.txl:��'E`�>s:::::;:.};•:::2..}•t. .i:>. :r.r...•.•..<.;-:...+, fi .. + :,»;t r�:-.}•::..,.'}T.•`}''!•� - ....,%•ti�i• x< �.x:n.r .Y.,...f. : �-}�.•}:: •:: ... f,: ? .:•...:.,..::. n t%i....,.( .,:... }.,F>. r. ..•fr. oI rS� ..•.,S^ :.: . ;,. �S + S }:f:• �r:.•::.•.;.+.;:.r{.�vfn::r. :r+f. Nb Left 161 -1700 0.096• .6 167 0.098 0 157 1700 0.098 23 190' 1700 0.112 0 190 17D0 0,112 0 19D 1700 Y0.112 Nb Thru 969 3400 0.285• 39 1008 0296 25 1033 3400 0.304• 69 1102 3400 0.324• 6 11D2 3400 0.324 0 1102 3400 0.324 Nb Right 74 1700 0.044 ..3 77 0.045 0 77 17DO 0.045 48 123 170D 0.072 0 ..123. 1700 0.072 0 123 WOO 0.072 Sb Left 207• 1700 0.122• 8 216 0.127 ' 0 215 170D 0.121'• 0 215 1700 0.127• 0 215 1700 0.127 0 215 1700 0.127' b Thru 849 5100 0.166 34 SB3 0173 22 965 51d0 0.177 . 156 1061 8100 0208 0 1061 5100 0208 0 1061 6100 0203 b Right•• 108 1-700 0.062 4 110 0.065 0 110 ­1700 -0:065'• -0- '' '110- 17DO 0.065 0 110 -1700 0.065 0 110 1700 0.665 . Eb Left Do 1700 0,647' 3 83 0.049• 0 t13 1700 DO • 0 63 1700 0.049' 0 63 1700 0.049 0 83 1700 0.049 [� Eb Thru 491 3400 0.144 20 511 0.160 0 511 340D 0.160 0 611 '3400 0.160 0 511 3400 0.150 0 511 3400 0.150 Eb Right- 138 1700 0.081 6 144 0.084 0 144 1700 0.684 52 196 1700 0.115 0 196 17DO 0.115 0 196 1700 0.115 1 6 Left 02 1700 0.048 3 85 0.050 0 85 1700-0.050 104 189 1700 0.111 0 189 1700_ 0,111 0 189 1700 0.111 Wb Thru 720 3400 0.214 ' 29 758 0.223' 0 758 3400 0223• 0 758 3400 0223• 0 . 768 3400 0.223 ' 0 758 3400 0.223•• b Right•• 301 .1700 0.177 12 313 0.184 0 313 17DO 0.184 0 313 1700 0.184 0 313 1700 0.184 0 313 1700 0.184 ::::.:...,.. ..,.:•:•....:,.-:•r r r::•::..::�::.�:.::rr.....::...yr.:•. -.:-n•:,..r.. .•.....;,..ft.,ter.,..{v •rv....:..•...:..::.r:.,•.:.:.:v:..r::.r.:..:•::•:..•.r - ...n. }..n..:.. n: ..,r\:::. ,� ,.. S:..Mtr.Y.r .n. W. 1 ..}}:n:•:'ln/.r n,.......Y.. ...+r. ... :x.:•:it:x::•,•:x. •�.:.:::•�.:• .r.C. : .r ..... :tF.r. :....:..r... Y , .{, :. ,.:....w-,..a ..:}}:.::v..:::-.i:{;..:{.;�.y,..•:.,.:..:v::.: q ,.v.v... x}.x...r..n ..v .. ....:::::•:v:::::rr..y:.}}r?•;x.•:..••::•w:::.::.•v : }:sx-::.�: .ri ..nrrv.}:-:rvrr ..... ..:xY.. .R.. v..;•;.•:f.:x.:v:r v::•:v::?v.: :r.... .. f � ,-. .. : r.r .fir.. ........::..�•:•:,... r:. .........,.r...:..n:,....:.•::::f•:•::::::...::....:.: :... .. ....:v//,y�{ :. ..v., , .{.C.-.T}Tr}+Y.•:: :....+. .Y....... .w rv.......�:::n�ya�yy rn. '�,�:rv{li. vn.. iCU 0.718 0.745 0.762 0.773 0.773 0.773 LOS C C C C C C ••Functions as a right tum lane;however,not striped as such Area Trattic Mitigation: 10•.38 AM Key conflicting movement as a part of ICU Project ICU Impact: 0.020 1 Counts conducted by.TSI OetoW2003 2 Capacity expressed In veh/hour of green f�����U�y��f .4 t li'',-�.r.��1t{Is}�1 "t y�/rg !rr'.-•:�M.-.�jfj >•±��h�v��`S,yea�l �:��. F� C�rR�.ML.�i,y rd.t. "V E i`i � ;-,. s. .:,+`- i 7 �� 'tv_.'t*2,�• --r`�.�_..-.�?M-:��,-.__,..��s�_ i>� '.cam.,._, �u?�.�:�,-��..c.1r '_��� t- a...:_.:.• ' ��.u..r�-.�.-4.�r, S ����� -w tQ7�.`.-�F ��F��{�-rF r�S �+y. �fv�i er�'�j�-(f �,�i1m� ,.yt.�`�F`gy��s4`�d?rr� � y-� }i�S�_�f.r�riff v .�'f S�jfi.xE �•YJ 1 -Y- .J rU .. . e�?id�3.�-.-?,��:r!E_.�: .}t.�. r. ��?Pc'S�� _.,,I�y,:. f.S;1,y..>>�,`:w'i� :"7��'�?_siq��,�`C.tt'�'r fi'7^•C.!i.vf•: ..�+::�I,`,t`-.�,t'. `S''.,,!`!��a, E'E2.,:r., 2 )"t v��r�'Si'.,I��¢� (/r f }.v 4� � Ij' � �;'�xyxc�"r^ t�ynt.�j'ys-`.. . . t,sz L'�e'z 4 7i y;�'�P e :��t"eit {'�ta AF k'.'t• �<.� L ,� .Y •y � .. �t--n�^. 'C�`1�U�f yr~3l T �.7�t1}err, 1 'L....e.. � �'��T•.:, 7i"t �, ,a.,,j� �y-r��' .y� tE ! .7" t. I ",.-�1 t 1 - • • 1 • I • 1 1 • 1 1 3 z�tV�'C�o %dix� -'{tr n.�c`'": r'o-"'r;9 _v' r5�s,'�e��Y•,r, l�'��'`v � >r'�y (rlf.�w��h�i �x"� Y� "�uz.y�t'* � ,.F"5 r t u $ � T,r �a " K , .'�tir'`r } ,f 3 e v>•..._.k.,^s,r-.rr�,hu�t�E k'.S.'..��.e.?`..9...-i�r;,r"i�rZ<.a�.F= ,t`r.��a ...-,x..;.l4r.'� -a��.�,..y..� `��.-,F�I U�n�-��c:�'o`�' M1� r „� :�'i+}4„'�ir„=d�5+u3 .},�4 1 r-_�;r � I`c>�>,.i 5:#� 77 t�- �' � zi�Vati�` u�.r`t' ;Tcl � � t1 r' �•I rt.- �I ,,,� I � .JC,'r`+ . _?A.lu.•t:tx, tr:?C� re>rt' a .,.� �C..,x;r-, G ..e�....4 .3,t.�.i., .>c V.. ;,;^.:., ,.1:�`:N', .�__ .I;�>'af 1/ !% Y f ✓.5 T - �'y:Cl y`rS +sF r' US I� P �. `.� J 4"• tr-.,1 xltr S t t T' ,c. Ott' U} I-c:- J. n. r� .,4 1 r Ra .. at -•Mn WLel ti Wiol L N�� � �t �'-Jf��IltFe�fF G�!�"tgzr ,.:�tr L�..jjrt1''��.. r:�i �' _Y .tt?i';;. r+ I�;P 5 •f. `: .� ��1:.�r.i I �- > L e r i t 14' [r a c: x�� y�?1..�� .�,.��..._ ..,.,.::� 4...,1:::. .. :'F..._.._:an.-. S.F� w'.•, ,? .'t:h�ry� r,1'r- utL.l,,`.iFi I .�, r Y .�� y - �, rtE Gf YIT"��n�i 4r-!" A:ri 2� o: �k•�, '..;�1�, j�xC; ,r y Ltd .�, Z� �4�f?z -.�tr'c Zrt ;fit E ', t ,-a.,p.y�. t z� ,.t q .t ,s 1:: • �� l'Z��4:.• J s.�" IJ si. :S : _v� it <T A eft IS -^! C 1 V >•4l„ -:r Su.. ; Y 4 '...,rr> < .q 9 -_.., }_r Mrl.., •1 • - {{ 11 • 11 - _ -{yigl r;f Fii4r f�i�il }rxi "'Lit >r �t{V t ,r.. ,M1h}!_1..�.V. .!, rr i,= ,..,...0 7, -1 .; c��, _, i ..., F :,,.:2::•r^ �.,,i... � �'" ,• [a 1 Ya 1 sN p �ilii '�of11'r u��� �'� rv` s ato}I : �o�o5r�5}r'+"U"us S e >r s5❑ I i 7 �F t t''' 1 11 11 11 11 11 11 'L �..i�n��1✓.1 l �i �M1)...:,,".- .'E..,.,.�t - - r MMlii1 1 1 1 1 1 t`� S,t -y h* �. Y t ! r o1 6- •� al J, IL1l�.1V) AJ l�i�]t 11��.,..f•7�l�r97�t-�j�4x,.� OJ��1R,a,�°''�.Y��,'�yY?}t��A` n-� '7F 33yy�5'' tjC��1�N"�F{i�`1rY i`t rrttJil�.,S S a:E i;.5, � �r� `. r.. t..' E N G I N E. E R S q APPENDIX F TRAFFIC SIGNAL WARRANT ANALYSIS I December 2000 Page 4C-9 Figure 4C 3_ Warrant 3, Peak-Hour 600 a- 500 2 OR MORE LANES.&2 OR MORE LANES E U O¢ 400 2 OR MORE LANES&1 LANE 0 j 3� i LANE& 1 LANE Cc < z 200 - '150 O ' > 100. -100 2 C7 2 ' 400 500 600 700 800 900 1060 1100 1260 1300 1400 1500 1600 1700 1800 MAJOR STREET:TOTAL OF BOTH APPROACHES— VEHICLES PER HOUR (VPH) 'Note:150 vph applies as the lower threshold volume-for a•minor-street approach with two or m6i-e1anes'and 100 vph applies at1he lower . . threshold volume for a'minor-street approach with onelane_ Yaa. zoos T,e�F></G"VOLvM,E WdTLl �lL1✓EGJA-r t>a GtoS�� _ ,4.•,C Ni o 4061 ri ar-* 4- oREn sLA r1 I M Pry VerY1. rS ``•. A Figure'4C=4. Warrant 3�'Peak Hour-(70% Factor.) (COMMUNITY LESS THAN 10000 0PULA'frO.OR:ABOVE•70.km/h•(40 diph):ON•:MAJOR,STREET) -crLa r-l� c s t b�.►a i vvA.0 AA',a'T . ►2 .::5 4T i s Fr C—jC . > 2 OR MORE LANES 400 &2 OR MORE LANES U };, w Oa 2 OR MORE LANES&1 LANE < 0: 300 LL 1 rn LL ¢ LANE&1 LANE O g. 200 F• Z Cara��i j O 100 '100 • `< 75 30.0 400 500 600` 700 806 900 1000 1100 1200 1300 Qs00 MAJOR STREET—TOTAL OF.BOTH APPROACHES— VEHICLES PER HOUR (VPH) *Note:100 vph applies as the lower threshold volume,for a minor-street approach with two or more Lanes and 75 vph applies as the lower threshold wllime fora minor-street approach with one.lane. Ilune 2001 Sect 4G05 December 2000 Page 4C-9 1j Figure 4C-3. Warrant•3, Peak Hour 1J 600 _ . 50f 2 OR MORE LANES&2 OR MORE LANES O ! r 400 2 OR MORE LANES&i LANE a ED Q 300 1 LANE&1 LANE 0 w J C 'q Z= 200 '150 > 100 *100 2 C7 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100 1200 1300. 1400 1500 1600 1700 1800 MAJOR STREET—TOTAL OF BOTH APPROACHES— VEHICLES PER HOUR (VPH) 'Note-150 vph applies as the lower threshold volume for a minor-street -• approach with two or more lanes and 100 vph applies as the lower threshold volume for a minor-street approach with one lane_ Zy9O ram• 7-AL4jc 1 G w 1—rt.{ �'— prL\vEEWA•--r "y-->" AND o*-, OR1vEW.4-r Uc/' • Go c.r��.•i wE37 s-r. @ �Fz/t/L�W q.Y q 8 a Figure 4C-4. Warrant 3, Peak Hour(70% Factor)- (COMMUNITY LESS THAN 10,000 POPULATION OR ABOVE 70•km/h (40 mph)ON MAJOR STREET) • "T��t c_ s 1(��JL1�., v./,4•e�,.►T is �� 5A-tCs i�t E-� 2 OR MORE LANES&2 OR MORE LANES Q 400 I I • 1 I ti 2 OR MORE LANES& 1 LANE FUJ 1L '300 N Q 1 LANE&1 LANE ' Z M 200 D �O > 00 100 *75 ` 3 0 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100 1200 1300 Z500 MAJOR STREET—TOTAL OF BOTH APPROACHES— �:_ VEHICLES PER HOUR VPH *Note:100 vph applies as the lower threshold volume for a minor-street approach with two or more lanes and 75 vph applies as the lower threshold volume for a minor-street approach with one lane_ June 2001 Sect.4C.05 I H - ATTAC 9j .�f �r� T '_ - _u���� J �, R+e„e`k `� � 7 ✓� H'. t� AQ"' t A sue` `�� i..�� ..,,,y TM � ?Nw '�f• �M". E _ tE 4h TR ir. f+c! � Yt'1y d7 t �] �ty . €` W # e y z 1 ' � d u v .� rEst fES3x - , � - � ��""'°s• .s� --=fix ��"'�'i � 4 � �'�� y � W � § a i�u ' L 47 Drive "A" is located on the east side of Goldenwest Street, approximately 1,000 feet south of Talbert Avenue. Drive"A" is a right-in, right-out unsignalized access driveway. Drive `B" is a full access driveway located approximately 700 feet south of Talbert Avenue on the east side of Goldenwest Street. Drive "C" is a one lane in and one lane out driveway located east of Goldenwest Street off Talbert Avenue. Drive "C" exits onto the :existing library parking lot south of Talbert Avenue. Drive "D" is located west of the terminus of Talbert Avenue, about halfway between Golde.nwest Street and Gothard Street. Drive "D" connects the eastern portion of the parking lot directly to the existing library parking lot. The driveway is a full access driveway with one inbound lane and one outbound lane. 4 i k x AA .- Ar �....p�3 �@ 'Y�3w 9NJ. .�. Hy t \ \ d DRAFT MASTER ENVIRONMENTAL`IMF'ACT. REPORT FOR .MASTER -PLAN OF RECREATIQN_USES FOR C'ENTRAL"PARK ; C , F, A ITY•'OF HUNTINGTON BEAC �H CALIORNI ` VOLUME l STATE CLEARINGHOUSE NUMBER 9709 1007 ` t \ l vi zz \ PREPARED FOR \ \\ ClTY OF'Htj 4t r,TON BEACH � ` ` � 2000,MAIN .STREET HUNTINGTON BEAC LIFORNIA 9' 48 lz it PREPARED BY Siv APPHOS`ENVIRONMENTAL \ ` � I33 MARTIN'ALLEY F'ASADENA CALIFORNIA J I 105 ` FEBRUARY 26 1999 c `fDRAFT MASTER ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT) \; 4 \ lz i \ iz F � K it t AL f MASTER PLAN OF s "."� �, -2r TEaM fIr an G s-.:ed.r *q -R1'r 1 1`F�ki'm 3 �}� ..a,� S s',°.r,:,.' Y f. ` `i'�+`:, 7+,a-„{, � �< ,r �',,eia.+� - nw. r4 3 -vim ..s 5.'�.�t a 9t tea. Stir. "' M TIGA ION�MEASURE ��;F ' jra •'�e1a '.^ni'N 2 ` 6 `S Fz � S ''3.'ai 3_.t`yT �' '+ 41. i p+ 'i 2 z- �A 4 Sa.},tA•a''€''p�' c ,,,y- 7 ._-rs GEOLOGICALdISS`UES° _ :_ ° Measure Geology-1: OThe City of Huntington Beach shall incorporate the following recommendations into Plans and Specifications for the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan for the proposed project as a means of reducing the effects of expected ground surface settlements on the proposed improvements: • For environmental compliance, maintaining at least a 6-foot thick layer of cover soils over the refuse; this would require special permitting from the Regional Water Quality Control Board (RWQCB) as a monolithic cover system • Pre-loading areas where structures are planned to reduce the elastic component of the refuse settlement • In-situ improvement of the upper portions of the refuse through the use of dynamic compaction Y Including a synthetic reinforcement material in the 6-foot thick cover soil layer to create a stiff layer of soil capable of supporting structures and tending to distribute the effects of differential settlement It is anticipated that all project and program level elements (Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Area; Consolidated Camping Area; Low Intensity Recreation Area;and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility) requiring development over landfill materials, potentially expansive soils, areas with peat organic soils, and areas underlain by liquefaction prone soils will require mitigation similar to that outlined in Measure Geology-1. Measure Geology-2: Prior to circulation of plans and specifications for construction of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach shall undertake sufficient engineering analysis to specify earthwork techniques to mitigate for the presence of peat, alluvial, and colluvial soils. The potential to design structures to accommodate the potential settlement resulting from compression of those materials may be considered. Alternatively, compressible soils may be removed and replaced with engineered fill that is less compressible or is reworked during grading to reduce compressibility. Other construction techniques such as dynamic compaction, compaction grouting, or vibro flotation/replacement can be used to improve the materials in situ (i.e., in place) so that they are not as susceptible to compression. It is anticipated that all project and program level elements (Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Area; Consolidated Camping Area; Low Intensity Recreation Area; and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility) requiring development over landfill materials, potentially expansive soils, areas with peat organic soils, and areas underlain by liquefaction prone soils will require mitigation similar to that outlined in Measure Geology-2. Huntington,,Central Park Master.Plan of Recreation Uses June 2.2 1999'; W:IPROJECTSf°7096 0041MMPIMTMNPLAN.TB1 _.y nkxk4✓a <` rtY y X•"g,-rrtr> z '"$r Stu aa�_ r ro �• t �-.—z'gys �a. a ''Y�' �•� "fP a T '°fr.# Ys,-°',� Y.teA r xn 9 '' r. 'ri'�x �i-' i 4hu,t>.v� bs MlT1GAT1,0N MEASURE , 3. Measure Geology-3: During construction of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the Construction Contractor shall ensure that all soils on the site impacted by proposed foundation loads and pavements will be improved as required. Typically, improvement consists of removing the materials to a predetermined depth below the proposed foundations and pavement sections, adjusting the moisture content of the materials so that they can be optimally compacted, and replacing and compacting the materials back into the zone below the foundations and pavement sections. It is anticipated that all project and program level elements (Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Area; Consolidated Camping Area; Low Intensity Recreation Area; and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility) requiring development over landfill materials, potentially expansive soils, areas with peat organic soils, and areas underlain by liquefaction prone soils will require mitigation similar to that outlined in Measure Geology-3. Measure Geology-4: Prior to issuance of building permits and development of the Sports Complex element improvements located in the construction debris portion of the landfill, a minimum 4- foot thick soil cover layer must be maintained to serve as a monolithic cover system. Because the inert debris disposal pit was permitted by the RWQCB, it is anticipated that a properly designed monolithic cover system will be accepted and would allow for irrigated land uses. It is anticipated that all project and program level elements (Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance.Area; Consolidated Camping Area; Low Intensity Recreation Area; and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility) requiring development over landfill materials, potentially expansive soils, areas with peat organic soils, and areas underlain by liquefaction prone soils will require mitigation similar to that outlined in Measure Geology-4. Measure Geology-5: The City of Huntington Beach will include in the plans and specifications for the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan the need to remove collapsible materials prior to construction of any structures or pavement. The City of Huntington Beach will also include in the plans and specifications for the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan the need to reduce the potential for damage from expansive soils through incorporation of appropriate engineering, design, and construction methods. These methods typically include either reworking the materials so that they are placed at a moisture content and density that is less susceptible to expansion or treatment of the expansive soils with lime to stabilize them. It is anticipated that all project and program level elements (Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Area; Consolidated Camping Area; Low Intensity Recreation Area; and Sully Miller Lake Group Facility) requiring development over landfill materials, potentially expansive soils, areas with peat organic soils, and areas underlain by liquefaction prone soils will require mitigation similar to that outlined in Measure Geology-5. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June.22, 1999 W:IPROJECTS11096-0041MMPIMTMNPLAN.TB1 M;4 ' y i •`3`s b- s -j. i zy. b v - ,*w h -_ r e;»`.:e z 4, T >"* - SA s. '�-at? z.y zr'� xmt w firs.*a£ t' _3y tdr` �l'qk 'a'#x iraf yz �N.`#',v-�'� a -%, s � ram'."'} 't 'tea - _ M[T[GATION MEASURE c., �� � � t� , .. e � �, y+.•< Y -.,,� - -+�c +3'ti + }�. v: � z�# �1a6 <s��aait � s � -may rah v€�'ri.ca'gg a a- ���ix Measure Geology-6: The City of Huntington Beach shall include in the plans and specifications for the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan the need to incorporate appropriate design and construction measures related to correction of corrosive soils' potential to { corrode ferrous materials through: • Proper selection of construction materials • Cathodic protection, including sacrificial rods or materials • Removal of the corrosive materials adjacent to the ferrous materials and replacement with non-corrosive soils • Concrete elements that will be in contact with potentially corrosive materials can be designed using special cement that is more resistant to corrosion It is anticipated that all project and program level elements (Park, Tree, and Landscape Maintenance Area; Consolidated Camping Area; Low Intensity Recreation Area; and Sully Miller Lake Group facility) requiring development over landfill materials, potentially expansive soils, areas with peat organic soils, and areas underlain by liquefaction prone soils will require mitigation similar to that outlined in Measure Geology-6. Measure Geology-7: The City of Huntington Beach will include in the plans and specifications for all project level elements requiring imported fill material, the need for soils brought on-site to comply with City Specification 429 and as such, these activities would be subject to review and approval by the City Fire Department. Measure Geology-8: The City of Huntington Beach shall include in the Final Design for the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility element of the proposed Master Plan the need to stabilize the surrounding slopes. Potential measures that could be incorporated into the final design include: • Regrading of the slopes to flatter inclinations • Reducing the slope heights to reduce the forces tending to cause instability • Constructing soil buttress fills at or near the toes of slopes • Using proper vegetation to reduce soil erosion and corresponding surficial instability Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses., June 22, 7 999 W:IPROJECTS11096-0041MMMMTMNPLAN.TB 1 2 tSIX Ms *3y` MITIGAT10i,1"MEA5URE�Y sF�t Y.AM, raw tira s 7 } aL� a . ��-kv Measure Water-1: The City of Huntington Beach will require that project design of the Sports Complex will be undertaken to ensure that there is no substantial increases in the rate and amount of surface runoff. Incidental drainage will be routed off of the site to existing storm drains to the north and west. It is assumed that improvements to.the existing storm drain system will be completed before project completion, as described in Measure Utilities-3. Measure Water-2: The construction contractor will be required to incorporate Best Management Practices (BMPs) consistent with the guidelines provided in the California Storm Water Best Management Practice Handbooks for Construction and Industrial/ Commercial Activities, and Appendices F and G of the DAMP. Revegetation of cut and fill slopes resulting from project development will be undertaken with native vegetation or compatible non-invasive drought tolerant species wherever feasible. Compliance with this mitigation measure shall be demonstrated prior to issuance of grading permits or building permits, whichever comes first. Measure Water-3: The construction manager will be required to incorporate City Ordinance No. 3364 entitled "Storm Water and Urban Runoff Management"and Best Management Practices (BMPs) consistent with the guidelines provided in the California Storm Water Best Management Practice Handbooks: Municipal to ensure control of flood hazards and water quality prior to issuance of grading permits or building permits, whichever comes first. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 7999 ' W:IPROJECTSI1096-0041MMNMTMNPLAN.TB 1 n MEASURE,�4ati'��B`-� �-cxiri�3�Y' 2 1��� t• .#vsn� „��s7r �r�n„'$ MiliGATIONs - x`��5 z"t" y� ;• y�"�' .ay Sa�c,� sr,�,�, 3t y`..r a�s�����, > >��e•�aa�`a3 t'�.'".a�x��3. � t � �° 't.�ti Measure Water-4: The City of Huntington Beach will reevaluate potential impacts to surface water quality from implementation of the Semi-Active Recreation Area and the Police/Civilian Gun Range program level elements and determine appropriate mitigation measures as are appropriate. .Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation.Uses '. June 22; 1999 W.I PROJECT511096-0041 MM.PI MTMNPLAN.T81 x' a 5k— 3 2`u „u.a-e �.. S x. s. z_' i ✓e e x..:,�; . MITIlATION MEAASURE t qe ad -s t� N ks tID sa`'�, Ys y �`p ai & �.y�c c. �x�l�..: i'�{.�a' af*�. '��a � ���-t"} �v..�;� m`` `a` ��' `." •,'«�.- .�e�, r�"�'����i3i�t AIR Q.LIALITY = Y The City of Huntington Beach shall require that all construction comply with SCAQMD regul construction. Specific measures to reduce fugitive dust shall include the following: Measure Air-1: Moisten soil each day prior to commencing grading to depth of soil cut. Measure Air-2: Water exposed surfaces at least twice a day under calm conditions and as often as needed on windy days when winds are more than 25 miles per hour or during very dry weather in order to maintain a surface crust and prevent the release of visible emissions from the construction site. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 1 " a � 3,fi":3'. t4:� 4�:� .�' �`'aS *�.s..` 4YA F �.'a,a '`; u+r '�a h sxz�, -' .` cg 'cry , ^ .b R-5 aF s5 `Y #,3 t ct &i'^} ��'T a Y?_-,u�- i -�a` -} M c k �y_ Mtl'IGATIONMEASURExF �`'�,♦1' �`� "AN x ft '' Yv "k �� � Measure Air-3: Treat any area that will be exposed for extended periods with a soil conditioner to stabilize soil or temporarily plant with vegetation. Measure Air-4: Wash mud-covered tires and under-carriages of trucks leaving construction sites. Huntington.Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses _ June 22, 1999 W:IPROJECTSI1096-0041MMPIMTMNPLAN.TB 1 es . r ¢. +" Arr_ x �* si` '4-t>u''b"s .a�+ 4 `S.a.. a 4 W� �t-a t 4 4 w # *�`L9"ex'<[.Y ``v .P- `� 1 1 r x -w.a f'� h z. �' ?x,.u# Sa S ♦.4x `.s.�.2°-"'� �`�-. �,^4 �S��d 3c 4'`�ia � '� ,� �-�+&Y �'�. �z "r,,§,+c f"� nh4 �S'���^ $I d' l z�: A' Measure Air-5: Provide for street sweeping, as needed, on adjacent roadways to remove dirt dropped by construction vehicles or mud which would otherwise be carried off by trucks departing project sites. Measure Air-6: Securely cover all loads of fill coming to the site with a tight fitting tarp. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 60�" + ,. ��= 5-.N3 k� "Y�^'x�``tk *"�`'Y`�rr rY x�„m'h ,sxti srti�, �.a '"*.-.'ti. M#TtGATia .MEASURE� 4 �� � t � 4.�, �`�f ti$".. �•ds qYp.+`h� 4 "t'C� s'e,�,kt'+�,��,�•tib � �t x� �.i, n ' r'�r�'�`rc z3 fH v �'��` z-f`i� �ti„ � a.r��� �t� � a•.�w.,�,�:>r Ff'�k�-��5., SS1'"3�t�T n�Y'`t���'"#'� �f f�T s `3+.�'���,'? ����M'`�'� X� � a✓d x #a 3� Measure Air-7: Cease grading during periods when winds exceed 25 miles per hour. Measure Air-8: Provide for permanent sealing of all graded areas, as applicable, at the earliest practicable time after soil disturbance. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 MMPI MTMNPL9N.T81 s x 40 ME $- 8 S � 5�n�yaf, tartnk�ss MITIGATION MIfASURE ya t A § €, - .. zqp In addition, the following measures to reduce equipment and employee travel emissions will Measure Air-9: Maintain construction equipment in peak operating condition so as to reduce operation emissions. Measure Air-10: Use low-sulfur diesel fuel in all equipment. 3 Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W:I PROJECTS11096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 . Al 'y fi, a F'i. -3hm* �'',ti g i a r zc, 3Yc. ik�k `y ti xy� 4Y. "t 4', Y t , M�Ec Ai'y" 'N ��4 ezS..-uf .^zcrc G v �a f"� .P y�� '��'to-d,'Y `'�`tts�d`''�r "Y '�`rk5i�'�� �`q `` s � Y�''-x�er�`'•"'a'�,M'� S��i,. s e az S Measure Air-11: Use electric equipment whenever practicable. Measure Air-12: Shut off engines when not in use. The following mitigation measure addresses potential impacts resulting from the release of nc Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041 MMPI MTMNPL4 N.TB m " "ors€ f a s m r n u ;' r--, t aY. ,}a. r e -�z§` c" i A a s...,# r -� ` r k ➢ +ems y 3'& i- s-u S s� +� ,-,fii'xiv,,}} .'.i A a, y[�..'�� 5�2F;u.E'r �' S4 4��tir' � `u x'aa�s •R 1 vas `1 Y.V t' Measure Air-13: Prior to beginning excavation in the area of the Huntington Landfill, an Excavation Management Plan must be prepared. This Plan shall be submitted by the City to the SCAQMD under the requirements of Rule 1150. The Plan shall contain measures for mitigating odors. No excavation will begin until this plan has been reviewed by the SCAQMD Executive Officer and approved for its adequacy in mitigating all potential air quality impacts that could result from excavation of the landfill site. The Plan-shall also address the possibility of other construction activities distributing and exposing odor- producing waste in areas of the park not undergoing direct excavation. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 � � ,R„y"•�-.- i s> .f .,���rx...t- },, "'- [�.�az .,^ -''�'1- s y ' " "�r�1-�t' 'i. . * q M#TIG'ATIU�N MEASURE� � ..tS � 5.. i"y sri k'a t "^ �iAx °'slx tag ' #s ai�y �x a. 3` Cu - Sx _ "? ,xr.�j-` z x - i �s.58-e"r P.ad _ 4^'' "�S ur r .32..' �%. `'x"` �"a.- a"Q. TRANSPORTATION Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-1: Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the timing of the signal at the intersection of Golden West Street and Slater Avenue shall be optimized by the City of Huntington Beach to accommodate increased volume of traffic associated with this project element as indicated in the Traffic Impact Study(Appendix F) Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-2: Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach shall reconstruct the existing median on Golden West Street (at the location of proposed Driveway B) to accommodate a southbound left turn pocket: The storage length for the turn pocket shall be 200 feet with a 90-foot transition. Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-3: Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach shall improve Driveway A to a full width of 30-feet to facilitate adequate site access. Driveway A shall be improved to incorporate 50 feet of throated driveway which would accommodate storage for two vehicles. Adequate sight distance shall be provided for exiting vehicles to safely merge into Golden West Street.This measure B is intended to avoid conflicts between offsite and onsite circulation. Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-4: Prior to operation of the Sports Field Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach shall improve Driveway B to a full width of 42 feet to facilitate adequate site access. Driveway B shall be improved to incorporate one lane inbound and two lanes outbound. Driveway B shall be improved to incorporate 100- feet of throated driveway which will accommodate storage for four vehicles in each lane. This measure is intended to avoid difficulties between offsite and onsite circulation. Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-5: Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach shall construct the entrance component of Driveway C to accommodate a 100-feet throated entry to prevent queuing of vehicles into the cul-de- sac area. The entrance component of Driveway C shall be constructed to a width of 14- feet. This measure is required to prevent interference with signalized operations at the intersection of Talbert Avenue and Golden West Street. Mitigation Transportation/Circulation-6: Prior to completion of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach shall construct the exit component of Driveway C to be aligned with an existing drive aisle in the library parking lot. The exit component of Driveway shall be constructed to a width of 14-feet. Construction of the exit component of Driveway C shall include signage and striping to the specifications of the Traffic Division of the Public Works Department of the City of Huntington Beach to ensure appropriate direction of traffic flow. Adequate sight distance shall be provided for exiting vehicles. This measure is required to ensure adequate circulation within the new and existing parking areas. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 7999 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.T81 i *ty L�4 x ,x`� nfird'"iF 'f'3a�',, 1a�k 't�-f �v r-m # � •cM,`x s v Est. \t � ` �"�u�.YS'1�` -.G t 3w' , �3 S a K sue, a � -r,,N. k r< MITIGATIaDNx MfASURf x fiA � 4 'h (� X �� .y'p, t,y ��f -- Y Y t °U -'N`.,� � L "G �"�i. f E l •Y.. S "i�'z - - 1gt,iL`yjiAl IRSag`".Y � fi� �. �� "'+'_�Fe�£� � ,� r� x t � ss n a �z�-"' `' ���� `3 k`+> n x z� ` a� '"" 5✓•`" t 0 W '��» e -� ��ti �'�'wixt��� TS,a�"'�a'� x"`n,,,a,°..5��"'c-v`c;"�'"�•k�ic-o � -.4^,�ir$�•�.��'3N �����` "� ',"` j_ .>?v ,n'..n •�:r.�✓3� .v..u3-i h �:Y :� ,,r.v§`-. ..'l:.- st.Tv�-n Measure Transportation/Circulation-7: Prior to operation of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan,the City of Huntington Beach shall construct Driveway D to a full width of 30-feet to facilitate adequate site access. Driveway D shall be improved to incorporate 50-feet of throated driveway which.would accommodate storage for two vehicles.Adequate sight distance s shall be provided for exiting vehicles. This measure is intended to avoid on-site and off- site circulation difficulties. i Measure Transportation/Circulation-8:. During the initial five years of operation, the City of Huntington Beach shall provide incentives to encourage transit use to and from the Sports Complex, as necessary to remain below Congestion Management Agency and South Coast Air Quality Management District thresholds for congestion. Measure Transportation/Circulation-9: During the initial five years of operation, the City of Huntington Beach shall coordinate with the local transit agency to improve or increase service as necessary to remain below Congestion Management Agency and South Coast Air Quality Management Agency thresholds for congestion. Measure Transportation/Circulation-10: Prior to construction, the City of Huntington Beach Public Works Department shall review the Plans and Specifications to ensure that the requirement to offer security level bicycle racks at convenient and safe locations has been incorporated into the Sports Complex, as necessary to remain below Congestion Management Agency and South Coast Air Quality Management Agency thresholds for congestion. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.T81 r�5 w y 4 s S • A51, 65 xaY >�.'�f-,. .�;: _ s.`�a >� ifiN.K,..,a � f �x_T X k �Sc � n.-fad. . MI`fI,GATION�MEASUREY � - �,.c�.i� BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES ; ... Measure Biological Resources-1: Directed surveys for least Bell's.vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher will be conducted prior to commencing any construction activities near disturbed riparian habitats. Directed surveys for least Bell's vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher will be conducted in accordance with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and California Department of Fish and Game published protocols for such surveys at the time that such surveys are undertaken. If the presence of either species is confirmed, construction and design plans will be modified to avoid impacts to these species. Measure Biological Resources-2: An environmental monitor will be present during grading and construction of the Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion, and the Consolidated Camping Area, and the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility to ensure no unauthorized impacts occur to areas potentially subject to U.S. Army Corps of Engineers jurisdiction or to existing disturbed riparian habitat in areas adjacent to elements of the proposed Master Plan. The Construction Monitor shall hold a permit for directed surveys for least Bell's vireo and southwestern willow flycatcher. The Construction Monitor shall be authorized to issue a stop work order in the unlikely event that southwestern willow flycatcher or least Bell's vireo are determined to be present-in adjacent disturbed riparian habitat during.construction. Measure Biological Resources-3: Directed surveys for six sensitive plant species that have the potential to be present in non-native grassland, southern tarplant (Hemizonia parryi ssp. australis), Coulter's. goldfields (Lasthenia glabrata ssp. coulteri), Coulter's saltbush (Atriplex coulteri), south coast saltscale (Atriplex pacifica), many-stemmed dudleya (Dudleya multicaulis), and intermediate Mariposa lily (Calochortus weedii var. intermedius) will be conducted prior to moving forward with program level elements which will impact non-native grasslands within the Park. Directed surveys for the six sensitive plants will be conducted in accordance with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and California Department of Fish and Game published protocols for such surveys at the time that such surveys are undertaken. In the absence of a published protocol, such surveys will be undertaken in accordance with Guidelines for Assessing the Effects of Proposed Developments on Rare and Endangered Plants and Plant Communities prepared by the California Department of Fish and Game. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 MMMMTMNPLAN.TB 1 "` 5t �t aM IT�I:G'�tAvd'TIOsN' aCMU R-E5t{'t}�iw -3 r �1',rw� y MiAni�y -r 2a' 1 ,,. !u-�,x2,;�, 3v x\b+fwr 3w 0 EAS A� � . �z�,3 •?Eis'�`n,.;�t��..�. ;�:'�� �:L.+... ,ik:;.f".t t�4 Y.� >.<s:.,:..;..�i+�Xs.�:<.� a �71��".�z�f:&r :.s9�', ..��Y'�..k''�;��.�.n�xr�a�Y �v��'��a's Measure Biological Resources-4: Potential impacts to foraging habitat for raptors resulting from development of non- native grasslands in the Park could be mitigated by enhancing conserved areas of non- native grassland at a ratio of 1:1 for acres of impact on non-native grassland to provide suitable habitat values and functions for raptors. Mitigation for impacts on non-native grassland will be accomplished within conserved non-native grasslands in association with the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility, Low Intensity Recreation Area, Semi-Active Recreation Area, and Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head. Enhancement of non-native grassland would include, but not be limited to, the planting of native trees within and adjacent to conserved areas of non-native grassland. Measure Biological Resources-5: Potential impacts resulting from implementation of the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility element would be mitigated through creation and enhancement of disturbed riparian habitats in the Shipley Nature Center and Talbert Lake-Meadow at a ratio of 3:1 for acres of impact. Measure Biological Resources-6: Concurrent with operation of the Sports Complex, the City shall implement or cause to be implemented a brown-headed cowbird trapping program. The brown-headed cowbird trapping program will be submitted to the Service for review and comment at least three months prior to the beginning of grading. Traps used to remove cowbirds will be modified Australian crow traps. These traps allow live capture of birds so that non-target birds can be released unharmed. The traps will be "baited"with live juvenile or female brown-headed cowbirds which will be captured prior to the trapping period with baited traps or mist nets. The juvenile or female cowbirds attract the attention of adult birds and lure them into traps. Once inside the trap, it is difficult for the birds to escape and they can be easily removed. Approximately four bait birds are kept in a separate cage within the trap and are not removed until the trapping season is over. The traps will be placed and maintained so as to provide trapped and bait birds ample shade, food, and water while they are in traps. All cowbirds (male, female, and juvenile) that are caught in the traps will be disposed of humanely. Trapping will take place during the nesting period of riparian bird species found in Central Park that are known to be parasitized by brown-headed cowbirds. Traps will be checked daily during the trapping period to remove both trapped cowbirds and non- target species, which will be released. Bait birds lost to predation or escape will be replaced during the daily checks. An annual letter report documenting the results of the trapping program will be submitted to the U.S:Fish and Wildlife Service. Results of the trapping program will be recorded including the date and time of trap checking, observer(s), weather, age of trapped birds (both target and non-target species), the treatment of the birds (whether released, disposed of, or retained as bait birds), and other data pertaining to any unusual event, such as predation or loss of bait birds. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W:I PROJECTS11096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 i ldRxQ3't� {r'4' t`F_ v""'�q '#` i,�i ..Sl,Tn`""$�. HAZARDS t l Measure Hazards-1: The plans and specifications for construction of the Sports.Complex will reflect the need to reabandon the existing plugged and abandoned oil well within the.proposed development area consistent with City of Huntington Beach Specification Number 422. Reabandonment will be undertaken during construction of the Sports Complex element of the Master Plan. Measure Hazards-2: The plans and specifications for construction of the Sully Miller Group Facility will reflect the need to reabandon two existing plugged and abandoned oil wells within the proposed development area consistent with City of Huntington Beach.Specification Number 422. Reabandonment will be undertaken during construction of the Sully Miller Group Facility element. Measure Hazards-3: The plans and specifications for the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead and the Semi- Active Recreation Area will reflect the need to reabandon twenty-nine (29) existing plugged and abandoned wells within the proposed development area consistent with City of Huntington Beach Specification Number 422. Reabandonment will be undertaken during construction of the Midde_n Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head and the Semi-Active Recreation Area elements of the Master Plan of Recreation Uses. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 MM PI MTMNPLAN.T81 i ' - {4 n ,,,zv``,? bra r, a' - t. - N h. u 3xy.. 'i ay'� ..�+ ,x`"(� 3y x "\`v 'k.-.6"` ..,x„z. _'. a E X 5 °&x ' ��"��� +s.-..S,�«,,,��k^�. .h,�,; x �,"�.�>�s ��`7'�•v�§ems t,.�Y�` t � �.�Y�,,p�x�,y'`�, T.� �'„y. �.,.; Nt'- �„��.. �.h"�'��+ �,x. ri�ta5;r,'Vt< '°s `?< ♦tea` '+z 'rY" .�}a 0_0+r�fx 1 's ,ax� � a�� r_'� �i .:�..x s�'l; Measure Hazards-4: Studies to evaluate the potential for landfill gas (LFG) generation and migration will be completed prior to development of the Sports Complex. Appropriate mitigation measures will be coordinated with the South Coast Air Quality Management District, Solid Waste Local Enforcement Agency (LEA), RWQCB, and the City of Huntington Beach Fire Department. Mitigation measures could entail active or passive extraction of LFG to control surface and offsite migration and passive barriers with vent layers and alarm systems below all enclosed structures on and within 1,000 feet of the landfill boundary. A comprehensive monitoring network will be established around the perimeter of the landfill. Periodic monitoring of the monitoring network and at locations above the surface of the landfill will be performed. Measure Hazards-5: Where the City of Huntington Beach determines the need to include irrigated land uses over areas underlain by refuse as part of the Sports Complex element of the proposed Master Plan, the plans and specifications will reflect the need to incorporate a more elaborate cover system to control moisture infiltration into the refuse. A suitable cover system could consist of a synthetic geomembrane, geotextile fabric for protection of geomembrane and filtering for the drainage layer, a drainage layer, and a vegetation layer or an approved alternative. Measure Hazards-6: The City of Huntington Beach shall prepare an Emergency Evacuation Plan for potential impacts related to (1) potential hazardous materials release on Golden West Street, or (2) a rupture or explosion in the vicinity of the oil field area west of Golden West Street. Measure Hazards-7: Plans and specifications for the Sports Complex, the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head and the Semi-Active Recreation Area will identify the potential to encounter oil saturated soils during excavation. If oil-saturated soil is encountered during excavation, plans and specifications shall require the construction -foreman to contact the City of Huntington Beach, who shall contact the DOGGR and follow appropriate guidance. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, .1999 W.I PROJECTS 11096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 . "' fF Measure Hazards-8: Appropriate methane mitigation features such as gas detectors, gas migration barriers, venting systems, and classified electrical installation shall be incorporated into plans and specifications for all proposed structures overlaying the former landfill and within 1,000 feet of the perimeter of the landfill. Design consideration for potential LFG migration through pipes, trenches, or other conduits shall be incorporated into Plans and Specifications. Methane migration features will be consistent with the requirements of the City of Huntington Beach Specification Number 429 and other applicable State and Federal regulations. The methane migration features shall be submitted for review and approval to the Orange County Health Care Agency, Environmental Health Division, which is the LEA for all cities and unincorporated areas of Orange County. Measure Hazards-9: Any unrecorded or unknown wells uncovered during the excavation or grading process shall be immediately reported to and coordinated with the City and DOGGR. In addition, should any unknown and unexpected landfills be excavated and discovered during the construction phase of the proposed project, construction work will be immediately halted and LEA will be notified. Further construction operations will resume at the discretion of LEA and upon work approval by LEA. Measure Hazards-10: Any redevelopment within the known oil field will shall be conducted in conformance with City requirements. City requirements include those outlined in Article 79 of the Uniform Fire Code (UFC). Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 MMNMTMNPIAN.TB 1 '`��' " Agl � gs ! 3•fytt Y-! -anai``� SrrCr g ? '' a;. r .'"ki§ x ". 3r�u.' �,T k - ,"'.z is s M11 iGA�TiONMEASURE � �� t . ER si< ` �, � ,ems ` .2- "W >.xC �iwt - 'a'��' t . �,a3�. '$� x;` cwa.., k,�.'ice"s`�'� 'Nf4 Measure Hazards-11: The City Fire Department will prepare a Fire Risk Evaluation prior to issuance of grading permits. Measure Hazards-12: Plans and specifications for the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head shall include construction of an 8-foot high block wall enclosure around extant active oil wells and associated equipment. The block wall enclosures will include suitable gates which are capable of accommodating large workover equipment into the well sites. Landscaping that is.climbable along the wall shall be prohibited, since it defeats the purpose of the wall. Suitable vehicular access for well workover equipment shall be provided for active wells. Measure Hazards-13: Prior to construction of a gun range, a preliminary endangerment assessment (PEA) should be completed to screen the site for potential human and ecological health risks associated with possible contaminants including drilling muds, petroleum products, solid wastes, heavy metals, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and polychlorinated biphenyls. Measure Hazards-14: The City of Huntington Beach will prepare an Excavation Management Plan prior to beginning excavation within the limits of the landfill which will be submitted to and approved by the executive officer of the SCAQMD. This plan shall identify mitigation measures to be activated as necessary during excavation to ensure that a public nuisance condition does not occur. Mitigation measures shall be selected after consideration of the physical characteristics of the landfill. Measure Hazards-15: Prior to construction of the Sports Complex, Park, Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion, Consolidated Camping Area, and Low-Intensity Recreation elements of the Master Plan, the City of Huntington Beach Fire Department and Public Works Department shall review all construction plans and specifications to ensure that the specifications require that each contractor involved in grading activities develop a site- and action-specific comprehensive Health and Safety Plan. The plans and specifications will require that the Health and Safety Plan be developed using the information available about past uses of those sites and the possibility that solid waste, PCH- contaminated soils, and/or potentially hazardous waste materials could be encountered. )n a Measure Noise-1: The City of Huntington Beach shall restrict amplified voice announcement systems for the Southwest Softball Fields. This restriction will alleviate noise impacts at residences at the Ocean View Estates such that noise ordinance limits are not exceeded. Measure Noise-2: The City of Huntington Beach shall restrict use of the Southwest Softball Fields after 10:00 P.M. The lights shall be turned off at this time and the fields closed. This restriction will alleviate noise impacts at residences at the Ocean View Estates. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB a. sMA , � �t t;' i '� � ' c 't''€}s 3c' MITIGATIdNAMEMORE�t z �.- '°y,�'"c'�;`�-�f�'t"'c, � „��'0""—;k.}��C''Y�w�t'�-r``�•s� '3��+.2k i swig'��*�'�_:'�`"T�4zr-a��`�n,���"���:, ...,���>-0�'t da.�_.�`i"'�+zz.c�,�-' - Measure Noise-3: The City of Huntington Beach shall limit grading and construction activities to daily operation hours between 7:00 A.M. and 7:00 P.M. (Monday through Friday) and 8:00 A.M. to 5:00 P.M. on Saturdays. Construction shall not take place on Sundays or Federal holidays. Measure Noise-4: The construction manager shall ensure that all construction and grading equipment is properly maintained and turned off when not in use. Measure Noise-5: The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has estimated that noise levels from construction equipment can be lowered by as much as 13 dBA by implementing noise control features that require no major redesign or extreme cost. The City of Huntington Beach shall require that all construction equipment incorporate noise reduction control features. All vehicles and compressors should utilize exhaust mufflers, and engine enclosure covers as designed by the manufacturer should be in place at all times. I i Huntington.Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22 199.9 W:IPR.OJECTSI1096 g041MMPIMTMNPLAN.T81 Mu'v4'Y 'rya Ti�"#'h,=C-;:y y r s .� WV ,rw2 t *- .a-wc ,.ii�''Y < 3- ;C fi # S",se `Yv 3 A,,, 'G. x f " .� !� �.s ri,:a.� 2{ "#F+'- '4 fi i F ! ,f'iR`v � W �- r` "�- PUBLIC:SER-%ICES` _.. ._,: i. .. -.a _., ;..,.. . ., .... Measure Public Services-1 The City of Huntington Beach will provide a permanent fire hydrant in the proposed Consolidated Camping Area in order to provide adequate fire protection infrastructure in that area. Measure Public Services-2 In order to reduce the need for additional police protection services, the City of Huntington Beach will maintain landscaping around the western and southern boundaries and the Park, Tree and.Landscape Maintenance Expansion Yard Area at less than two feet in height. The chain link fencing will have approximately one-inch openings in order to discourage individuals from climbing over the fence and from cutting holes in the fence. Measure Public Services-3 The City of Huntington Beach will design the proposed tot lot areas in the Park to allow. visibility in those areas. This will discourage loitering and crime, as well as, provide a greater sense of safety to the users of these areas. Measure Public Services-4 The City of Huntington Beach will modify the design of new restroom facilities from the design of existing restroom facilities in order to promote better safety, thus reducing the need for additional police protection services. New restrooms shall include an exterior door that is locked open during park hours. New restroom design shall allow anyone from outside the restroom to see if there is anyone in the restroom before entering. This shall be attained by allowing no interior restroom wall (except the main structural wall) to meet the.floor. The feet of anyone in any area of the restroom shall be visible from the outside. Measure Public Services-5 Prior to completion of Final Design for the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head and/or the Semi-Active Recreation Area, the proposed training course for the cross-country teams will be submitted to the Huntington Beach Unified High School District for review and comment to ensure that the course is suitable for training junior varsity and varsity cross-country squads. Measure Public Services-6 Prior to construction of the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head and/or the Semi- Active Recreation Area, coordination will be undertaken with the Huntington Beach Unified School District to identify an alternative training course within Huntington Beach Central Park to train junior varsity and varsity cross-country teams during periods when the southwestern portion of the Park will be closed for construction. UTILITIES Measure Utilities-1: The City of Huntington Beach shall utilize the existing City domestic potable water supply for the irrigation water supply until the Green Acres Project is operational and able to distribute water to Huntington Central Park. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W:IPROJECTSI 1096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 4p. - S e�r rz '^5;e`� ♦; .L - a ' "„ , j ''Z`- "hT . e -''.n�`'� v >l� ,y �;s y n am rs �k's'" r 3� "'�` ''�$� $` a'+� `a2``.+}Set3'- eo- .. MITIGATIOI�IMEASURE K € 04 k" ��-d>` ��. �'f3 {i-t.. ,,.r�,' s�.�� 4 L s' rd'z1v -`°`-�T�y�.$�,^,-+x.Y �kr�"ea't' -``•"�l - ..r. ,ifi. sck.�,7,�n -K,�.i* ,..,�Y �Z• '� ,cs°'2 � fi. 'arcs '� ri" "E' 'h,�. -� � ��,� t S x �,',f.�.Y" �1.auS:*,-.+3 X.�•�^�S.�iw��,.�''R,ii �,�,_tT l"` s-T;4'e,:,..�.. €�s�.'.�.,�X4t...�i *.'{M�At-�- �-�":.:.�+,.'��'�'=a.e;'3.�i" �`k'.:c'.. z',i..;�� Measure Utilities-2: The City of Huntington Beach shall develop an irrigation system for the Sports Complex Element to the standards and specifications required for a reclaimed water irrigation system in order that this new system can accommodate reclaimed water supply from the Green Acres Project. Measure Utilities-3: Prior to final design of the Sports Complex, the City of Huntington Beach will conduct a sewer flow monitoring test to determine the capacity of the existing 15-inch diameter pipeline in Golden West Street. If the existing capacity is determined to be inadequate to accommodate the proposed project's sewage flow, replacement of a determined portion of the sewer line shall be undertaken at that time. An 8—inch diameter collector. sewer line will be required for carrying waste discharges from the project. Measure Utilities-4: The City of Huntington Beach shall replace the currently damaged 36-inch diameter corrugated metal pipe which runs between Sully Miller Lake and Talbert Lake to accommodate current and future surface runoff from the proposed Sports Complex site. The new line, a 36-inch reinforced concrete pipe, shall-be designed and constructed in conjunction with the overall Sports Complex Drainage Improvements. Measure Utilities-5: Plans and specifications for the Sports Complex will reflect the need to direct storm runoff from the west side of the site to the new 36-inch reinforced concrete pipe specified in Measure Utilities-4:. i Measure Utilities-6: The City of Huntington Beach shall install a new pad-mounted 1000 KVA transformer to provide adequate electrical service to the project. It will be determined during the design whether or not the transformer will be surface mounted or located in vault during the construction phase of the project. Measure Utilities-7: If the Green Acres Project is not yet operational and able to supply water to the program level elements of the Master Plan prior to the development.of final plans and specifications, additional studies will be undertaken to determine the extent to which one or a combination of the following measures will be necessary to reduce impacts to water supply systems for program level elements during the interim until water from the Green Acres Project is available: • reduce the required irrigable areas by 10 percent; • enhance the utilization of existing groundwater systems (i.e., subpotable wells); or • supplement the irrigation supply with water from the domestic'water system. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June..22;.J.999... W:I PRO/ECT517096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 i �y5`t<�,D .a'M +{� ":i+. r.- `,.-'.�.a,'e. x'M1�w. 3.z. aa`Y`�, � �.� s � k r�.� " t �� � MITIGATION MEASURE�� � A _ � .cC �R^��9'��, s'+k�t-�'�-.c`�����,-nr�.t 3 � $ � � �Ja�*��R�"" Y�''� .�.A aS `a�ez'aa. i Sc�"�X x�-,•..�,�-x:' Measure Utilities-8: City of Huntington Beach will require that design of program level elements will be undertaken such that there are no substantial increases in the rate and amount of surface runoff, Incidental drainage will be routed off of the site to existing storm drains. It is assumed that any necessary improvements to existing storm drain systems will be completed before the completion of program level elements. Measure Utilities-9: Prior to the construction of program level elements, additional electrical load analyses shall be undertaken to determine the need for additional electrical transformers. AESTHETICS Measure Aesthetics- 1 Prior to completion of Plans and Specifications for the Sports Complex, the City of Huntington Beach shall include specifications related to security and night lighting to minimize impacts to the adjacent mobile homes. At a minimum, such specifications shall require the use of photo-control-on and time-clock-off(dusk to dawn) system to control security and night lighting. The type of illumination system for security lighting will be low glare and will not interfere with views yet will provide security. Security lighting will use high-efficiency, non-glare, high-pressure sodium lamps. Night lighting shall be oriented away from residential areas. The use of shields shall be considered as a means of minimizing the effects of night lighting on the temporary location of the Ocean View Estates Mobile Home Complex. Measure Aesthetics-2 Prior to completion of Plans and Specifications for the Sports Complex, the City of Huntington Beach shall include specifications for landscape treatment to screen the south side of the 6-8-foot-high wall to be constructed between the southern boundary of the Sports Complex and the Ocean View Estates Mobile Homes. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W:IPROJECTSI 1096-0041MMPIMTMNPLAN.TB 1 .-�•xxFd K �r ..#+ ,f ,€,c�. 9`'1'r q _rtr s v >' ssA � ti Ewa a�> s ar z 2A MR` M1TI+�ATION MEASURE S W MINE Zr-x*- -i ?'cYka c: a y. �� � `�z";�"4 e$S'.l d 3 �' 'u ids. _3 .i^..' 3 K'{. ✓�L byn - '�'�. zr r..z�.ra' s t �. "� sa,�a- `� '� -�`���•,r��,�,��� ,r k�a 4 �x� �'�x f �� Measure Aesthetics-3 Prior to completion of Plans and Specifications for the Park,Tree and Landscape Maintenance Yard Expansion, the City of Huntington Beach shall include specifications for landscape treatment of the chain link fence to be constructed along the western and southern boundaries of the expansion area. The landscape treatment will comply to the maximum extent practicable with the Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design Guidelines. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W:I PROJECTSI 1096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.T81 i,vate- -� t r . r sx ? x ``aA ','vY. 'N � s a k. N s ls._.y i \. "?ei .a. ..- v - y a 3�r ,x�s`c^ ' i,X \,?.,-t# �;�a* a„ +.4`.f- '�u�' � � < ,� "�� 3 MITIGATION MEASURELy � � nt � 4y Or -� Me Paleontological Resources Measure Paleontology-1: The Plans and Specifications for construction of the Low Intensity Recreation Area, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head, Semi-Active Recreation Area, and the Sully Miller Lake Group Picnic Facility shall identify the need to engage a qualified vertebrate paleontologic monitor to monitor excavation in native substrates. During excavation, the monitor should be equipped to salvage fossils as they are unearthed to avoid construction delays and to remove samples of sediments which are likely to contain the remains of small fossil vertebrates. The monitor must be empowered to temporarily halt . or divert equipment to allow removal of abundant or large specimens. Measure Paleontology-2: If located during excavation, recovered specimens shall be prepared by a qualified paleontologist to a point of identification, including washing of sediments to recover small fossil vertebrates. Measure Paleontology-3: If located during excavation, specimens will be identified by a qualified paleontologist and curated into a museum repository with retrievable storage. Measure Paleontology-4: A report of findings will be prepared with an appended, itemized inventory of specimens. The report and inventory, when submitted to the Public Facilities and Resources Department of the Orange County Harbors, Beaches and Parks Division, will signify the completion of the program to mitigate impacts to paleontologic resources. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W.I PROJECTS 1 1096-004IMMPIMTMNPLAN.T81 i { \ c�£y$�-"ss e c, ih' i '?- a i r tti-_x xx 1 -Na �, �A h "F"r' -v.a zn �, a'3a a f 3r'c y.r �c,aa .r.,„ K -3.<-.T' s. �y�S .kkn t"C��s" {,^^k, r fi z;,n`4'a. u\2 a�"'a a x .,�'§'','�,-} � 1ny� 8 F MITIG�TIONMEASURE � Y k � � gp x;' "` -,vpM ,hq^n `7 ��,����� r�ixFc�saA=x��`n�ca�����x�v� �'"� *re"+5'~��+'�„xy •'�-�'�a� �c��,n�'a•�*'d�. �s�1��h ��"'r,:�'"\� ,.r�''- x ' ._.'3,,:.t ,�r'�,a: ��'.. _„._� h.^a� .,a...a«,.-. tT.wa,a.�a--..-,.�x�..s-:.-.G�,.c.rn�.....t`�.na...-�`• :?,r,-S�_..a.,.u"rn.s-.w....5.,.,��,_t�_..n.x Archaeological Resources Measure Archaeology-1: Prior to final design of the Low Intensity Recreation Area, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head and Semi-Active Recreation Area elements of the proposed Master Plan sufficient cultural resources investigations shall be undertaken to identify the location and extent of CA-ORA-82, CA-ORA-1317, CA-ORA-142, CA-ORA-1275, and CA-ORA- 1318. Measures to avoid impacts on cultural resources shall be incorporated to the maximum extent practicable with the guidelines provided in Parts A and B of Section II of the CEQA Statutes and Guidelines. Measure Archaeology-2: If avoidance of CA-ORA-142 is determined to be infeasible, then a test level program shall be developed. Infotech's (1989) Prehistoric Sites Management Planning section states:. "If appropriate data were collected from the extensive, unreported excavations east of Edwards Street, analysis of that information might suffice for the delineation of productive research there." If data are insufficient, additional testing is recommended.The testing should characterize the site structure, contents, integrity, age and nature of the occupation(s). Testing activities should include, but are not limited to, auguring, surface collection units, surface transect units, and the examination of cut banks to determine the sites horizontal and vertical boundaries. Controlled manual excavation, with control columns, would follow preliminary testing, to provide a detailed delineation of the site's characteristics and importance under the criteria outlined in Appendix K, Section III. Measure Archaeology-3: The City of Huntington Beach shall engage a qualified archaeologist to attend the pre-grade meeting for Low Intensity Recreation Area, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head, and Semi-Active Recreation Area elements. Measure Archaeology-4: The City of Huntington Beach shall engage a qualified archaeologist to monitor during grading activities within soil layers above bedrock material for Low Intensity Recreation, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead, and Semi-Active Recreation Area elements. During initial removal of vegetation, the archaeologist shall monitor daily to observe and retrieve any buried artifacts that may be uncovered. If important prehistoric . or historic resources or deposits are encountered, then evaluative testing and/or other appropriate archaeological investigations shall be conducted. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 MM PI MTMNPLAN.TB "'x�` x ;ds� ' �- a3e kqt- s ASUI F " � vl;vi z& y5^ r-,'A Measure Archaeology-5: The City of Huntington Beach shall coordinate with the Native American Heritage Commission to identify an appropriate Native American monitor to be included in any testing, data recovery, and monitoring activities related to the Low Intensity Recreation, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trailhead, and Semi-Active Recreation Area elements. A Memorandum of Agreement shall be prepared to deal with possible buried human remains. If a burial, burials, or a cemetery are encountered, reburial of the remains on other City properties may be requested by the Native Americans. A cemetery is defined as, in excess of six burials. Measure Archaeology-6: The archaeological monitor shall have the authority to temporarily divert or redirect grading to allow time to evaluate any exposed prehistoric or historic material. Measure Archaeology-7: Any scientifically significant artifacts shall be properly recovered after evaluation by, and under the supervision of, a qualified archaeologist. A data recovery plan that includes an excavation plan, laboratory analysis and report preparation, shall be developed prior to the recovery of the remains. Measure Archaeology-8: Any recovered prehistoric and historic artifacts shall be offered, on a first right-of-refusal basis, to a repository with a retrievable collection system and an educational and/or research interest in the materials. Copies of the report shall be submitted to the South Central Coast Information Center, Fowler Museum, University of California, Los Angeles. An additional copy shall accompany any recovered artifacts to the repository. Historic Resources Measure Historical-1: Prior to the initiation of grading activities in support of the Low Intensity Recreation Area, Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head, and Semi-Active Recreation Area,the City of Huntington Beach shall engage a qualified archaeologist to periodically monitor grading activities for historic archaeological resources. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses. June 22, 1999 W:I PROJECT511096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 3. 3 K +� '`•� Y c `S � c . '1 r 3'�`�`'G*,�i x�� rod X y�.�-c+g-`3�`z� � ro'S��'�i-F z,�. �'# �"`�'�r p:.t��y"v>�•,�a '«� � �"`- c t "Z t 20 Measure Historical-2: The archaeological monitor shall have the authority to halt grading until exposed historic archaeological resources can be evaluated for their importance. Measure Historical-3: If the historic archaeological resources are deemed to be important,then a testing or data recovery program shall be developed and implemented. Measure Recreation-1: At least thirty days prior to construction, the City of Huntington Beach shall post signs in i the vicinity of the Low Intensity Recreation Area indicating the proposed construction schedule and alternate recreation facilities (including location and hours of operation) located in the service area for passive recreation use that can be used during the construction period. Measure Recreation-2: At least thirty days prior to construction, the City of Huntington Beach shall post signs in the vicinity of the Midden Area/Urban Forest/Trai I head Improvements indicating the proposed construction schedule and alternate recreation facilities (including location and hours of operation) located in the service area for passive recreation use that can be used during the construction period. Measure Recreation-3: At least thirty days prior to construction, the City of Huntington Beach shall post signs in the vicinity of the Semi-Active Recreation Area Improvements indicating the proposed construction schedule and alternate recreation facilities (including location and hours of operation) located in the service area for active recreation use that can be used during the construction period. Measure Recreation-4: Prior to completing final design for the Sully Miller Lake Group Facility element, the City of Huntington Beach will undertake sufficient analysis to define site-specific slope remediation and water quality treatment to comply with state-of-the-practice for safety of recreation users. Such measures will be incorporated into plans and specifications. Measure Recreation-5: Prior to completing final design for the Police/Civilian Gun Range element, the City of Huntington Beach will undertake sufficient analysis to define safety elements into the facility design to comply with state-of-the-practice for recreation users. Such measures will be incorporated into plans and specifications. Alternative locations for the Police/Civilian Gun Range should be considered as part of that analysis. Such analysis will be considered in the subsequent environmental analysis for this element. Huntington Central Park Master Plan of Recreation Uses June 22, 1999 W:I PROJECTS 11096-0041 MMPI MTMNPLAN.TB 1 ATTAC-H4M'-E'N'T, #4� ADDENDUM TO THE EIR FOR THE SPORTS COMPLEX PROJECT PROP SAL Addendum No. I represents an analysis of potential; environmental impacts associated with changes to the Sports Complex as a result of the closure of Driveway ``D I 1 BACKGROUND ➢Final:Master EIR for Central Park and the Sports Complex was certified 19:99. ➢1Vhtigation Monitoring Program includes four mitigation measures that address Driveways BACKGROUND (eont'd) ➢In July 2003, the City Council decided to charge a parking fee`at the Sports Complex to minimize the use of the Library parking, re ultng m ➢The closure of Dnveway "D" via a gate ➢Construction of a 6 ft chain lin Tence along the north boundary of the Complex from Goldenwest St to Gothard St;: 2 ANALY S I S Potential area of concern related to CEQA is traffic impacts. ➢ All other CEQA issues are not affected or are adequately addressed in certified Final.EIR. . Addendum is appropriate level of CEQA review ANALYSIS (cont'd) The raffic analysis concluded: ➢ The remaining hree driveways will operate at acceptab e Level of Service of C or better, however, ➢ Modif cations necessary to Driveway "B" `to prevent left turn movement:onto Goldenwest St to eliminate approach delay 3 RECOMMENDATION Staff Recommends that the City Council .Mi approve Addendum`No ` 1 to the Final Master Environmental Impact Report for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park as submitted END OF SLIDE SHOW 4 RCA ROUTING SHEET INITIATING DEPARTMENT: Planning and Community Services SUBJECT: Approve Addendum No. 1 to the Final Master Environmental Impact Report for the Master Plan of Recreation Uses for Central Park COUNCIL MEETING DATE: March 1 , 2004 RCA ATTACHMENTS STATUS Ordinance (w/exhibits & legislative draft if applicable) Not Applicable Resolution (w/exhibits & legislative draft if applicable) Not Applicable Tract Map, Location Map and/or other Exhibits Not Applicable Contract/Agreement (w/exhibits if applicable) (Signed in full by the City Attome Not Applicable Subleases, Third Party Agreements, etc. (Approved as to form by City AttomeA Not Applicable Certificates of Insurance (Approved by the City Attome ) Not Applicable Financial Impact Statement (Unbudget, over$5,000) Not Applicable Bonds (If applicable) Not Applicable Staff Report (If applicable) Not Applicable Commission, Board or Committee Report (If applicable) Not Applicable Findings/Conditions for Approval and/or Denial I Not Applicable EXPLANATION FOR MISSING ATTACHMENTS REVIEWED RETURNED FOR DED Administrative Staff Assistant City Administrator Initial City Administrator Initial rCity Clerk EXPLANATION FOR RETURN OF ITEM: