Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
Davenport Marina - Establishment of Pierhead Line for the p
RECORDED IN OFFICIAL RECORDS — s EX . 89-603306 I OF ORANGE COUNTY.CALIFOR DS IA Ci7 I "4 00 PM NOV g .89 Recording requested by &` Retur►i to: Office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Beach This'idocument is solely for the 2000 Main Street official business of the City Huntington Beach, CA 92648 of Huntington Beach, as oontem- plated u±1dei Government Code Sec."6103 and should be recorded RESOLUTION NO. 5801 free of charge. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY i OF HUNTINGTON BEACH ESTABLISHING A PIERHEAD LINE IN THE DAVENPORT MARINA WHEREAS , the City of Huntington Beach desires to establish a pierhead line for the Davenport Marina; and Huntington Beach Municipal Code section 13 . 32 . 020 ( f ) provides that the distance from the bulkhead to the pierhead line shall be determined by the City Council ; and The City Council adopt the findings set forth on Exhibit "B" attached hereto and incorporated by reference herein . NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach that there is hereby established a pierhead line in the Davenport Marina , also designated as Lot C of Tract 4880 ; that the establishment of said pierhead line conforms ±—�to - city policy; and the pierhead line and the property on which such pierhead line is established is described in Exhibit "B" , attached hereto and incorporated by reference herein . PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at a regular meeting thereof held on the 19th day of October , 1987 . M ATTEST : APPROVED AS TO FORM : City Clerk t.1-t-y tt `�ney REVIEWED AND APPROVED : INITIATED AVD APPROV D: City Administrator Iw Director of Public Works E)WIBIT "B„ 89-603306 A PIEPH AD LINE FOR THE DAVENPORT MARINA, IN T T"HE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH Beginning at the southwesterly corner of Lot 7, Tract 4880, as shown on a map recorded in Book 172, Pages 12 to 19 inclusive of Miscellan- eous Maps, Records of Orange County, State of California . Thence north 890 44' 00" west 125.67 feet to a point, thence north 00 16 ' 45" west 40.25 feet to a point, thence south 890 44 ' 00" west 8.40 feet to a point, thence north 00 16 ' 45" west 66.00 feet to a point, thence south 890 43' 45" west 18.45 feet to a point, thence north 00 16 ' 45" west 104.77 feet to a point, thence south 890 43' 30" west 13.00 feet to a point, thence north 00 16 ' 45" west 90.00 feet to a point, thence south 890 43' 15" west 13.00 feet to a point, thence north 00 16 ' 45" west 64.00 feet to a point, thence north 890 43' 15" east 13.00 feet to a point, said point being the terminus of said pierhead line . 2/8/8S i J *89-603306 -- �, SM . w V LOT 'C� Irl Z� F7 N OL 1 J , Ir UL • N rn P P05E Pit-RHEAD LINE / EX H «f 89-603306 Exhibit "B" to Resolution No. 5801 of the Huntington i Beach City Council j dated October 19 , 1987 FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW INTRODUCTION If any finding of fact is a conclusion of law then it shall be deemed to be so denoted . The Superior Court of Orange County in Case No . 46-75-77 , having concluded that the establishment of a pierhead line is a quasi-judicial function of the Council , the following findings or conclusions are found and concluded: 1 . The city is empowered to adopt pierhead lines to protect navigable channels from encroachment . 2 . Pursuant to Huntington Beach Municipal Code Section 13 .32 .020 , the City council of the City of Huntington beach has the power to establish pierhead lines by resolution . 3 . The Orange County superior Court in John J . Stanko v . City of Huntington Beach, case no . 46 75 77 , has mandated the city to set aside the pierhead line established by the City Council in ' Resolution No . 5523 , adopted June 3 , 1985 . 4 . Davenport Marina is located along the subject channel depicted on attached exhibits , and is improved -with various docks, slips , and gangways . 5 . The subject channel is a navigable waterway . A low bridge which crosses the channel to davenport Island prevents further navigation by vessels , except for small boats . A ninety foot width at the bridge is desirable for safe turning of vessels and navigation . 6 . A minimum channel width of seventy feet is necessary for navigation of vessels in the channel . 7 . Expansion of the existing marina further into the channel would impair navigation, create traffic and parking impacts, and be incompatible with the residential character of the neighborhood . 89 603306 "Exhibit "B" to Resolution 5801 October 30 , 1987 Page ( 2 ) 8 In the interest of the health , safety and welfare of the citizens of Huntington Beach , no additional boat docking facilities or end ties can be allowed outside the limits of the pierhead line as shown in Exhibit "B" . N .B. The attached "Proposed Pierhead Line "Exhibit B" and a Pierhead Line for the Davenport Marina are incorporated by reference herein as thoughtfully set forth at this part . i r' Res. No. 5801 --60316 STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) sa: CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH ) I, ALICIA M. WENTWORTH, the duly elected, qualified City Clerk of the City of Huntington Beach, and ex-officio Clerk of the City Council of said City, do hereby certify that the whole number of members of the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach is seven; that the foregoing resolution was passed and adopted by the affirmative vote of more than a majority of all the members of said City Council at a regular meeting thereof held on the 19th day of October 19 87 by the following vote: AYES: Councilmen: Winchell, Mays, Finley, Erskine, Green NOES: Councilmen: Kelly ABSENT: Councilmen: Bannister(out of room) v' City Clerk and ex-officio Clerk of the City Council of. the City of Huntington Beach, California The foregoing instrument is a correct COPY of the-original on fife in this office. Attest_ //_ 19- City Clerk and- f the City Council of-thel",Ky of Huntington Ceaoh, J Cal. By Deputy b tTo G/L.,..1 �GCI��r�, �/�- Date 1 C DUPLICATE Signed ' P4 dY 4# 2g<- xE �i Date Signed R*difytart %= 45 465 SEND PARTS 1 AND 3 WITH CARBONS INTACT. Poly Pak(50wts)4P465 PART 3 WILL BE RETURNED WITH REPLY. LATHAM & WATKINS ATTORNEYS AT LAW CHICAGO OFFICE 650 TOWN CENTER DRIVE PAUL R. WATKINS (1899-1973) - SEARS TOWER, SUITE 6900 TWENTIETH FLOOR DANA LATHAM (1898-1974) CHICAGO, ILLINOIS 60606 TELEPHONE(312) 876-7700 COSTA MESA, CALIFORNIA 92626-1918 TELECOPIER (312) 993-9767 TELEPHONE (714) 540-1235 SAN DIEGO OFFICE LOS ANGELES OFFICE TELECOPIER (714) 755-8290 701 "B" STREET, SUITE 2100 555 SOUTH FLOWER STREET TLX 590777 SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA 92101-6197 LOS ANGELES, CALIPORNIA 90071-2466 TELEPHONE (519) 236-1234 TELEPHONE(Z13) 485-1234 ELN 62793272 TELECOPIER (519) 696-8281 TELECOPIER(213) 614-8763 WASHINGTON, D.C. OFFICE NEW YORK OFFICE 1333 NEW HAMPSHIRE AVE., N.W., SUITE 1200 53RD AT THIRD, SUITE 1000 November 3, 1987 WASHINGTON, D.C. 20036-1594 885 THIRD AVENUE TELEPHONE (2C2) 828-4400 NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10022-4802 TELECOPIER (202) 828-4415 TELEPHONE(212) 906-1200 TELECOPIER (Z12) 751-4864 Ms. Connie Brockway Acting City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92640 Re: Davenport Marina Pierhead Line Dear Ms. Brockway: Pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section 1094 . 6, please accept this letter as a request that you prepare and certify the administrative record for the action taken by the Huntington Beach City Council on October 19, 1987, rescinding Resolution No. 5523 and adopting Resolution No. 5801, establishing a revised pierhead line for the Davenport Marina. When the estimate of the costs of preparing and certifying that record is available, including the costs of preparing a transcription of the Council hearing, please let me know. If there is anything my office can do to expedite the process of assembling and certifying the administrative record, I will happily cooperate. Thank you for your quick attention to this request. Very truly yours, Robert K. Break cc: Bob Sangster, Esq. John Stanko �\ S22\rkb\sanko.city ;,"iff CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK November 3, 1987 Latham and Watkins 660 Newport Center Drive Suite 1400 Newport Beach, CA 92660-6415 The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach, at its regular meeting held October 19, 1987, held a public hearing concerning establishment of a pierhead line at the Davenport Marina. It thereafter adopted Resolution No. 5801 which established the pierhead line. A copy of Resolution No. 5801 and findings are enclosed. This is a final administrative decision to which you are entitled judicial review. You are hereby notified that pursuant to provisions of Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure of the State of California you have ninety days from November 3, 1987 to apply to the courts for such review. If you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact our office - 536-5227. Alicia M. Wentworth City Clerk AMW:bt Enc. CC: Gail Hutton, City Attorney Doug LaBelle, Community Development Director Paul Cook, Interim City Administrator 1 Tele phone:714-536-5227) 0 P 543 '158�% 397 RECEIPT FOR CERTIFIED MAIL NO INSURANCE COVERAGE PROVIDED NOT FOR INTERNATIONAL MAIL (See Reverse) Sent to The Stanko Trust John J. Stanko Trustee 1ftnjnd�olero Lane P.O.,State and ZIP Code Huntington Beach CA 92649 6 Postage E N) * Certified Fee Special Delivery Fee G Restricted Delivery Fee t.*.J � c-) Return Receipt Showing x�C " to whom and Date Deliverer ,o t >l a Return receipt showing to wljmn, s -;K m Date,and Address of Delivvb T o TOTAL Postage and Fees a S; LL .i g Postmark or Date E 0 LL N a r: .A .1 LJ CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH LLi a 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK November 3, 1987 The Stanko Trust John J. Stanko, Trustee 16771 Bolero Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92649 The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach, at its regular meeting held October 19, 1987, held a public hearing concerning establishment of a pierhead line at the Davenport Marina. It thereafter adopted Resolution No. 5801 which established the pierhead line. A copy of Resolution No. 5801 and.findings are enclosed. This is. a final administrative decision to which you are entitled judicial review. You are hereby notified that pursuant to provisions of Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure of the State of California you have ninety days from November 3, 1987 to apply to the courts for such review. If you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact our office - 536-5227. Alicia M. Wentworth City Clerk AMW:bt Enc, CC: Gail Hutton, City Attorney Doug LaBelle, Community Development Director Paul Cook, Interim City Administrator (Telephone:714-536-5227) t �uth.�.iied to Publish Advertisements of all kinds Iincluding public s!otices.by Decree of the Superior Court of Orange County, C.nlifornwa, Number A-6214, dated 29 September. 1961. and A•24831. dated 11 June. 1963. STATE OF CALIFORNIA County of Orange PublK House Aa.en:aino Cov«ed by this of idsv,t is set in7 point with 10 PKe Coiumn width I am a Citizen of the United States and a resident of Io-o f the County aforesaid; I am over the age of-eighteen �` ' years, and not a party to or interested in the below entitled matter. I am a principal clerk of the Orange Coast DAILY PILOT, with which is combined the rutiut, NOTICEt NEWS-PRESS, a newspaper of general circulation, ;NOTICE+OF n � printed and published in the Cityof Costa Mesa, PUBLIC NEARING Q. ESTABLISHMENT OF County of Orange, State of California, and that a PIERHE S_7A E NOTICE IS HEREBY• if Notice of __ Dji h l i c lie a r i n^ GIVEN that the Huntington Beach.City.Council will hold• (� a public hearing in the Coun-1 v ;cil Chamber at the Hunt- ington Beach CWk Center,t 2000 Meth $tr'eet Hunt-i:. ` �ington Beach,California,.on of which copy attached hereto is a true and complete the date and'at•the time in- � dicated below to receive.and 1 copy, was printed and published in the Costa Mesa, conslder'the.statemerits otl i all persons who'wish to be;� _ Newport Beach, Huntington Beach, Fountain Valley, heard relative to:the appli 1 -' Irvine, the South Coast communities and catidn'descrlbed t)elow. Laguna ; •DATEI`MonddS[July 20,:, 1987 Beach issues of said newspaper for one time TIME:7:00•P.M: j SUBJECTr'Establishment . consecutive weeks to wit the issue(s) of i of Pierhead Line AP.RLICANT6>Cityof Hunt-! i inLOCATION:,.Tract .4880,! Lot C:-southwest Daven port,-Drive and; tbgewate I July 9 ] Lane (4052 ::Davenport 19$ Drive—Davenport Marina). I PROPOSAL:'To establish a pierheadjaline, for the purpose of docking 6;oats. 198 ENVIRoN"MENTAL STATUS: Exempt, Section 15305,Class_5;according-to the California Environmental 198 Quality Act. ISALL INTERESTED PER- DNS are invRid'to attend ;'said,,hearing'-and_;express 198 i opinions or:sul mit Ievidence Ito r or against the application as outlined above.All appli- cations, exhibits,.;and de- 198 inriptions of-this proposal are on file withthe;Office'of the"City Clerk;, 2000 Main, Street, Huntington, Beach, !California for inspection by I declare, under penaltyofperjury, that the ! IjU TIQN0 HUNTINGTON BEACH foregoing is true and correct. j iTv•`COUNCIL; By: Alicia M: Wentworth;;,City Clerk, �P"n4.-_-'(i14)r52i615405 :. Dated 7i6/8- Published Orange Coast, Executed on Ju 1 y 9 1 gg ] Daily Pilot July9 1967 Th862� at Costa Mesa, California. Sinnature PROF OF PUDLICATI0a3 M �bI.s 7/9/87 ::NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING P ESTABLISHMENT OF PIERHEAD LINE NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington. Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center , 2000 Main Street , Huntington Beach, California , on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE: Monday, July 20 , 1987 TIME: 7 : 00 P.M. SUBJECT: Establishment of Pierhead Line APPLICANT: City of Huntington Beach LOCATION: Tract 4880 , Lot C - southwest of Davenport Drive and Edgewater Lane (4052 Davenport Drive=Davenport Marina) PROPOSAL : To establish a .pierhead line for the purpose of docking boats . ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS_: Exempt , Section 15305 , Class 5 , according to the California Environmental Quality Act . ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. . All applications , exhibits, and descriptions of this proposal are on file with the Office of the City Clerk, 2000 Main Street , Huntington Beach, California, for inspection by the public . HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL By: Alicia M. Wentworth City Clerk Phone (714) 536-5405 Dated 7/6/87 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH ' 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK July 24, 1987 Latham & Watkins, Attorneys at Law 660 Newport Center Drive #1400 Newport Beach, CA 92660-6415 Attn: Virginia Croudace On July 20, 1987 the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach continued open .the public hearing on the establishment of pierhead -line-Davenport Marina-to September 8, 1987. Please call Paul Cook, Director of Public Works for further infor- mation - 536-5431. Alicia M. Wentworth City Clerk AMW:CB:js (Telephone:714536-5227) LATHAM & WATKINS ATTORNEYS AT LAW CHICAGO OFFICE 660 NEWPORT CENTER DRIVE, SUITE 1400 PAUL R. WATKINS (1899-19731 SEARS TOWER, SUITE 6900 NEWPORT BEACH, CALIFORNIA 92660-6415 DANA LATHAM (1898-1974) CHICAGO, ILLINOIS 60606 TELEPHONE (312) 876-7700 TELEPHONE (714) 752-9100 TELECOPIER (3121 993-9767 TELECOPIER (714) 759-8891 SAN DIEGO OFFICE LOS ANGELES OFFICE TLX 590777 701 "B" STREET, SUITE 2100 555 SOUTH FLOWER STREET ELN 62793272 SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA 92101-8197 LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90071-2466 TELEPHONE (619) 236-1234 TELEPHONE (213) 465-1234 TELECOPIER (619) 696-8281 TELECOPIER (213) 614-8763 - WASHINGTON, D.C. OFFICE NEW YORK OFFICE 1333 NEW HAMPSHIRE AVE., N.W. SUITE 1200 53RO AT THIRD, SUITE 1000 July 17, 1 7, '1 1 987 WASHINGTON. D.C. 20 036-15 9 4 885 THIRD AVENUE U 70 TELEPHONE 4202)828-4400 NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10 02 2-4802 TELECOPIER (202) 828-4415 TELEPHONE (212) 906-1200 TELECOPIER (212)75I-4864 BY MESSENGER r v c City Council City of Huntington Beach ^- 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Attention: Alicia Wentworth, City Clerk Re: Davenport Marina Dear Ms. Wentworth: Pursuant to a telephone conversation I had this afternoon with Paul Cook, the City's Director of Public Works, I am hereby requesting, on behalf of Dr. John Stanko, that the City Council continue the public hearing on Agenda Item F-2c set for Monday, July 20, 1987 at 7: 00 p.m. before the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach. This agenda item concerns establishment of a pierhead line in Davenport Marina. We hereby request a continuance of this matter to August 17, 1987, and have been assured by Mr. Cook that, upon receipt of this letter, a continuance will be granted and the matter will not be heard Monday, July 20, 1987. Very truly yours, Virgin P. Croudace of LAT AM & WATKINS cc: Robert Sangster, Esq. Gail Hutton, Esq. Paul Cook S01\vpc\dr. 001. ltr 07/17/87 2 : 55pm + Publish G� NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING f NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE: SUBJECT: APPLICANT: C4-V--( e;�= OL�gr(�A 47n)}.( bguPry fo'-f br LOCATION: �?-- 1 PROPOSAL: ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: N��I ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. All applications, exhibits, and descriptions of- this proposal are on file with the Office of the City Clerk, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, for inspection by the public. HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL s By: Alicia M. Wentworth City Clerk Phone (714) 536-5405 Dated ZONING INDEX MAP 9-5-II 10-5-II DM D II LEGEND 19-6-10-SECTION-TOWNSHIP-RANGE 16- -11 15- -II N14- 11124- 30-5-11 DM 18 17 DM 15DM 22-DISTRICT MAP 22 L - f 24-5-I I 19-5-11 5-11 21- -II 22-5-II 2 -5- 1 DM 2 DM 21 DM T D 4 D 25 S DM 27 ..i 29-5-11 �� 27- -II 2 -5-11 .25- -11 AM 35 DM34 %DM33 DM31 D 0 \; / �n32-5\ 11 33-5-II y`��'34= -II 3 -5-11 36-5-11 DM 36 DM 37 38 39' ` DM40 5-6-11 3-6-11 2- -11 ,1-6-11 6-6-10 5+6-10 I/ D M 4 DM -2 DM I D 6 DM�/ II 1% I � !l 9-6-11 0-6-II II- -II 12- -II 7-6-IO 8-6-10 DM10 DM 12 DM13 6M7 VM8 14 II 13-6-11© 18-6-10 17-6-10 O ----- CITY OF �Fy � l tiD1I4 DM20 DM19 HUNTINGTON BEACH ORANGE COUNTY CALIFORNIA r 24-6-1 19- -10 / DM 29 w22/ �DVT[D YMCM ID.IK RYMWD GDY,6LCM RfOIUICM . CR.CDUMiL-O,IgwMfl Mp W I ON in= 1111111l11 1111111111 1111111111 1111111111 -=r1111i11�� - r1l�urrr>, :-1 �; 111l111!!1.11111111� ii�11w1ii '� � � �r: 11111!!!!!11 11111111�1 iiiiiii iiiiiiiii'.•=C �• :• � � • 1111111111 :1! 1 �.'� ••'•• :: _� 1111l11111 1�i11111111 �111. �rllllr am1111111111 1 11111111-■ _ /♦11111 .. .. .. . .. •• •• •a •• Mal NIIIIIIII MINI �/11111 •• •• •. _. • 111111\►� /r1111ram am .0 .:. ' 1111111111 ■�i� `�■■■■■ Emma. ..:... �. a ■�IIIIr ..m am .r .. ..:.. . 1111111111. / �IIIIIIIIIIIr-If11111111i i �. ' 1111111111�� 11 �61111lily - �s� .• �tr11�1 ♦tart �� �11� •� �� -�♦ •♦ •• lfill � ,,,, _°'��� �♦�111�� Ills `�" ���ii i��i iiG::=�� 1!��� ' �����1�►��,��,`,, �1 ��� - �_�IIIII �III • 2LANNING . e ZONING DM 23 SECTIONAL DISTRICT MAP 20 -5 - II ..[fi°° NOTE" CITY OF ADOPTED DECENER 5.1960 �^ [o'a'aro'"'.c•N...cNr or rc o wT[No[o To c,rcNo ro TNc ccNr[. CITY COUNCIL ORDINANCE 00.-004 L G N.w,Ir Or.., M I'M - LEGEND AMENDED CARE ORD.NO. AMENDED C._5E ORD.Mo. Q I,.f m—nam n ppmcr HUNTINGTON BEACH a -62 292 976 S-I6-66616,26: 0 6-4-62 247 907 - 7-16-66 66.281226 CW m[oW'�Dvon Rf,�[NIML asTr, 10-7-8! !67 1007 Q-S-86 66-53 1269 ., ��PA�Na,r mT.c7 - l-2.64796A0900 5-6-6666-721D0{ ® 'c TM ram" 2 �. 4.6-64 4101045 9.18-ST 6767.22 I349 ® , ems REM.—asr*=T ORANGE COUNTY, CALIF0RNIA ;o- 9Pr;7z'; 5-4:6 1048 a_,8=6861��4'! � �«zo lam K 1.7-6079-7 2w2pES NpS-19-64 4341056 2-17-69 66481471 ® C=l CCe.t.oAL 91ST.KT 5-4-81PIM8o-I 4996 6-I-64 4061059 4-7-69 69-4 M66 ® WNrUNrtT FACILITIES CEDUC•TgM OKTRICT 9.20-02 92.7 2575 8-19-844mA601079 7-19-71 7Oi9 1620 � CorNMTr FAMIT[S 1.[CREATMAt1 ds7RCT R-1-6262-8 270 11.2-64 470 1096 12-20-717f20®16922 3 .�] roslLENorE DISTRICT 7-221--6661 9664•7 2T6S046 M+EC19E PL...L8"MENT ��7-BSF_IDOD02vE 2606 IJ 18-65498 IIBJ 718-77 va77-22207 ® omcNaro I—an 6TREET. 11 1 67 8Do I164 7-3-70 784 2291 ® Duu.n CLASSi"IM m.,TLL 20416DIR0R. Lft EOINGER —'_ •-_•---- - nv E L R I-CZ URI RI-CZ U ► � �• RI i RI RI RIIIR! C2 MH R2 V201 1; RI PRELUDE DR CF—E 9� S wnct t'E>:•RI I xso: 1ins R3.oNA DR //fy_Cie Cj SWTE 1 t jRI1N R K LO CR.a RJ-Cr RI R! A 9 8 G~� Z L RI RKAMDY DR MAUI CR 1P °' I-CZ i1-oli7eia£'r RI RI RI •PA Ir+i EP2 j RI-CZ '-•-- - .'q OPERETTA 0R OAKU DR. G~ 4 RI 3 RI U RI RI l DR Z 3 0 1JE.._.._._... • -S fiNARY) DR. MH RI RI _ c� N - c4-I o c E c D y. I._Pl-CZ . --- - D 4 .. .7 -.0 R2 R2 C4 j i N U WR-CZ-FP2 %n7 In 1 '�L— — AVE -— rsD•.s'sYr R3 pp9b'q CIIRISTMN4 BM K1000 6 91bl�CJw ;cF;07 R2 RI-CZ CF-R R2 C4 CF-E w R2 aus�l - :•:s1E.�R .z.. ..cro1.- R2 �' R3 #�6=a� w a _ .TAR R2 q oR RI-CZ aVGti cA- vq. Dq J CKWI K �wRQ J \ l iM4lYM.M:LI:: CF-R ML rST•DR z = �,Q R2 = � RI-CZ R- `� Z Gti R3 R2 R2 R2 R2 R2' (OJl%QJl A9ay _ RI-CZ Ir •• R2 R2 7 PEARCE s'. RI-CZ Ya ':voiiQ•�a's � DALE Ak DR. I s r j�3 1 . RI-CZ aGi R2 R2I R2 R2 R2 R2 R3 U RI-CZ gi RI CZ 1 TR '! RI CZ RI CZ I. C4-CZ I MILD !T R3 ! U RI-CZ i = u NPORT I a �RI j $U Y NR3 R3 R3 _ R3 = R3 0 J_N N U a 0 I I N C2 I _ U N DR. m D: S 1CZ�RI < J ---- i J—� ao 71 F WARNER AVE I J CCCSSS R! THMMAP WAS PREPARED FOR ORANGE 60 33 COLWTV ASSESSOR DEPT.PURPOSES ONLY. TWA M XE GUARANTEE AS TO 178- 3 2 ITS ACCURACY(NORM A IVIES ANY LIABILRY • so /u ��?o� S p' o a v o FOR OTNER tAEB. TO BE REPRODUCED. 4 C V COPYRNiNT ORANGE COUNTY ASSESSOR K'ESTPOg71 `JF. d' 10 0' 14 ;�• �s ^ ,W TRACT. "'/Jo .. /49 Q O O h y /48 O9 13 r O LAAE c 0 O C 6�0✓ � , 9 O a 12 v 67 b �U50H/4 . 44 �s• `tea o - �s as ��91. o �� -... . ' - ; O ; O - tee. .. st'� 10 � � b 19 ►� .. 0 90 f 21 p 3 s s�so• _ e• 20 76j 2 21 i 19 /e J 75 E�G�'4TER - `�so ♦so• _' -' A4• 16 r'� . o �A. s .5�' AA� Q 1./52 30 ; M �• Oc O sa •is Q /3 f, OT Ae ; 3 O O s 3 3•II o Iit 00tE a;r ns M L 36 AC 3. (SE ~ io' 4 ` `J .fiE AR A j 0 O , wHA1+F 2T � "e sa• � • 2 MD. 498�. - Q j LOT C a MOTE` LOTS B 737 ?/ //IAw HAVE WHARFAdE RIGHTS W A 1 OOEF/NEO AREA OF LOT D.• AS SNOW. 44 ___J^P/ERM£AO L iNE sq5 31 NOTE - ASSESSOR'S BLOCK 9 ASSESSOR'S MAP ?; PARCEL NUMBERS BOOK 178 PAGE 32 I _ O. SHOWN IN CIRCLES• COUNTY OF ORN(GE MARCH /97/- __rR—NO.-4880---_M.M. 172 - /2 TO /9 /NCL. � 1Dublish 7/9/87 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING ESTABLISHMENT OF PIERHEAD LINE NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center , 2000 Main Street , Huntington Beach, California , on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE: Monday, July 20 , 1987 TIME: 7:00 P.M. SUBJECT: Establishment of Pierhead Line APPLICANT : City of. Huntington Beach LOCATION: Tract 4880, Lot C - southwest of Davenpo�rt Drive and Edgewater Lane (4052 Davenport Drive,N'( e � rn&F-41bo PROPOSAL: To establish a pierhead line for the purpose of docking boats . ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS : Exempt , Section 15305 , Class 5 , according to the California Environmental Quality Act . ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above . ' All applications , exhibits, and descriptions of this proposal are on file with .the Office of the City Clerk, 2000 Main Street , Huntington Beach, California, for inspection by the public . HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL By: Alicia M. Wentworth City Clerk Phone (714) 536-5405 Dated 7/6/87 LCT3 Af* 1-76- I S- It "Z 151 t 157, -7 -�12 -- 1 , 69 1 -78 - S7!Z7- IS/ 14, 1Sj Q -ram Lo . �1 i NOrE - M1ARFA6E R/6NTS fR JPe1 - - LOrS r ro rD/NC NAVE 1TNARFAGE RIGnrS Ise-3 2� IN A DEFINED AREA OF LOr C AJ JNOWN. 36 LOr I HAS IWARFAGE R/eNrS rO ALL OF LOr O. rL`,- LOTS B TO JI INC NAVE WMARF46C RICN/S LOT A c IN A ArFINE0 AREA CF THE 400'CIMNNEL ~FASE AREA I As DhtllrN. S. 32 rsE[ WE)Wr Ocr • .� r .4►N' Lor L. Mir• - `\ ued.. Pr. AD LINE for c .ns a" A AsEE 4 : O O, 06, :O O• O. O O B• ,SJ. 9 O . TRACT is• ; oil . '�.'.� swrEAala➢a Mrbt= --o-- Y LANE --q fi rowm I W „Q ,�• �. �j �j O C .® _ �1 _ ®;.fit„ .V-, 41 V-` �• sRS.et172i ` 4 -ALLK A YS O- _w ` EAr• Y Q a- - fi �'._ O �• - - t j . S£A WInN LANE h1 u • , % X Imo. • D "e rr — O 1 Vtooits 15 1. LJ • er OO O Ne i (� 83 Q •: A, " it • 7 e O Y J \J O O 10 11 42 12 O O g 0. O �.a..o—BOL£RO LANE 8 J• • ® ® ® © ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® l7 I Y I I I i I I I I WNA446E F{IEA r E At rf) FAST LIME OF 400'CIIANAFL 6rJ N07E-ASSESSORS BLOCK B• ASSESSORS AUP MARCH /97/ INDEJOEDfOO ro STATE of"LIP TRACT NO. 3/32 M.K /B2-14 TO 20 /NCL. PARCEL NurB£RS BOOK 178 PAGE 31 w a00A'sJse PAGE�/ of TRACT NO 3264 M.M. /B5-27 TO 54 INCL. OFFICIAL RECAIOS. SNOWN IN CIRCLES COWVrr OF ORANGE 71RACT NO. 5050 M M 191-59-45 INCL. .d 33 178-32 `" Ke .o,. moo• PAW Se' p VIIAW 09 O • p r-.. �_si•y `, f le C + Z Ica - � EOGEwgTEq AA. Ig `„s ..�. � 30 cn LOT A f•Aor f ' if LQ/IfJ cr a O { ^Y - AM AC AU 48W el MC NAY[ /IM0fA6L MINA AV A MPNEO AREA AP "r O AS SAVWW. Ac _r k _�ialr,AtsP Law,y 31 ' ASSESSOR'S AIAP •_" t' NOTE•ASSESSOR'S BLOCK 9 PARCEL NUMBERS BOOKI7B PAGE 32 'CD IN CIRCLES COUNTY 0E ORANGE MARCH 1971 rR. NO. 4880 M.M. /72-12 TO /9 /NCL. we• .••t rVLLOW.NG LOTS NAVE ADJACENT 1AVARrAG( - R/GNTS L/NOFfJNED AREA Ol LO) _ LOTS 1,l,S,6,4N0 1 t Z - W t TO rt MIG � �� ne-36 - n>a f0 4YC AND PNELPS s L4,yE t - Jrfi ocr O' O O O O O O O U ` �J1 O O O� W.wr Lfr rid EMI EW rro rS9 tfi.7r' � �.' rllt Ely A� tr/ t/Z 11! Dr t !f rm vp No IQ 20 i `/ 'z ; n le , n le 0 Lraw asr,.Lno fvi M GR' S • so, 1 Y' IR.M• AV:y O p O 1 r�EDBFIYATER `+• �` .•' . r - fo • s. a• PON LOT of VO•S1ofr • � �. 4M : , .. pgALN T E r7 S RR' ,�� - •74 O45 144• 43 /1 j� •t• ayr• ea +) _ ~. a ,�.. .ST O fn • 47 p Z� • 'a tt '31 `s z `� 4M O ; O L A2 ,L ft S N 40 49 01 Z p •J7 Oy Q p it O � .A p! M /QRLOIA; O fZ p; So is At • IW.Las♦ ; //6LI ,f ANLA 4 (scar AOTt/ io' rc k 38 37 NOTE•ASSESSOR'S!LOCK e ASSESSOR'S MARCH 197I TR.A42 53bYJ M.M. 200-6 M 14 ML PARCEL NUMBERS WOK178PAGE 36 ` 1 SHOWN IN CIRCLES COUNTY Of ORANGE 31 NJT£' '- -- LOTS / rO IS NMC. AND N TO SS INC OF to.. S0S0 NAVE WHARFAGE R/GNrs /N A 178— DEF/NEO'AREA Or LOr 4 AS SHOWN. - Lors " r0 54 ra. SOSO ANO LOrs St r0 60 IYc. OF TR 5I64 NAVE WHARFAGE R/GNrS AY A DCF/NEO AREA of THE 400'CHANNEL AS SHORN. 38 Iff _ O 0 do O H �- Is ' aDgo ® (� 0-p� °T pp wry 2 O S O aE •may. O O ee �+wt L 0 i so �® 4 >�O is S V I OfifJI n s \ MsoO .� 12 a r 18 ✓ 3 a 6 , `FJ Id t0 do s T a AM Q s \ O a N \- /'• /Oo' y a• to O •� V\` - O N•IN O cD \ . r u Q so 3 O 4 ..A• e Amw ® e p x ® /IJ IF a_ i EAST L/NE of 400' CHANNEL MEMO rD - SrArE of•cALN! N O IN to N , Z -.R BwK 6360 OUSE �� re yL IS W - of OffIIAL ierCOwOt O ' O ^M ,. H 14 1 IGM LOrlot rC� 60r, .5050 \�' ►Ip '� 31 �- b AMRCN /97/ TR.NO.. 5152 M.M. 1a2-14 TO20/ACL. NOIE•ASSESSOR'S MOCK B ASSESSOR'S M" CDTR. AV 5264 A/M/85-27 TO 34 ma. PARCEL NUMBERS 8009176 PAGE 3T TR AV 5050 M.M.191-39 TO 43/NCL- SHOWN IN CIRCLES COUNTY Of ORANGE PARCEL MAP P- M 27-23 � `._ - .,ay►i.a: - ..- .. K:.. _ .a,c.s;.1+,.-- ...i-!.•:i=:cs, .,.�t� a- ,.,..._ ....ri...•�rN�+'s•. r _�.ryc. 'N�Q�••vY�!"'I�I: ri7lii=ii"'�2i.'�i'{s•i::i:'i`c•r•. -:awe�t""L=s• •f.Aa'a:'�wd DISTRICT NUMBER: 054A HUNTINGTON 'SEACH CITY PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP-. TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS COOS 178=312-06 TENG, MOSES 278-313-07 SMITH, MARION HANNAN TR 178-314-OS WHITE, TRAVIS E 04-007 16882 SEA WITCH LN 04-007 16882 BOLERO LN 04-007 3892 FINISTERRE OR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 178-313-01 ROWSELL, ARTHUR P 178-313-08 TOPPO, FRANK R 178-314-06 DAVIS, FREDERICK R 04-007 16861 SEA WITCH LN 04-007 16872 BOLERO LN 04-007 3882 ►INISTERRE OR HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 178-313-02 BUTLER, HERBERT E 278-313-09 MEYER, ALEX 178-314-07 BAKER, JOSEPH C 04-007 16871 SEA WITCH LN 04-007 16862 BOLERO LN 04-007 16942 BOLERO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 178-313-03. RTBA, JAMES R 178-314-01 MOURITZ, PETER F 178-114-08 PASTER, PAUL G 04-007 16881 SEAWITCH LN 04-007 3942 FINISTERRE OR 04-007 16952 BOLERO LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 178-313-04 ELLISON, MERLIN FRANKLIN 178-314-02 WARDEN, CHARLES H 178-314-09 FISHER, MEYER 04-007 2N0 TR 04-007 3932 FINISTERRE OR 04-007 16972 BOLERO LN 3911 FINISTERRE OR HUNTINGTN BCH; CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL .92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 178-313-05 STEWARO, RONALD 176-314-03 WILSON* GRANT H 178-314-10 LONMEYER, WALTER W TR 04-007 3891 FINISTERRE OR 04-007 3922 FINISTERRE OR 04-407 16 981 BOLERO LN HUNTINGTON REACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 9t64 9 178-313-06 MOORE, CARL A 178-314-04 HURWITZ, FRANCIS H 178-314-11 MARSHALL9 WILLIAM H 04-007 3881 FINISTERRE OR 04-007 3912 FINISTERRE OR 04-007 16992 BOLERO LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 .. :,u•.--.eta�tiiailiWK :Nt�11fF'. . .yPR♦tF c9Af- .i�I,Ria ►!i'.•.. .� ." Ai `_i�•�i��T'NP'�'• '�['1"t�:q`�"t.��a%t 6? .m:.fl�� _ •F DISTRICT NUMBER 054A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP- TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS :CODE 178-292-10 WILLSIE, RICHARD E 178-292-17 CRIMMINS* DENNIS F 178-311-02 HUNTINGTON HARBOUR CORP 04-007 17187 ROUNDHILL OR 04-007 17131 ROUNDHILL DR 04-007 4241 WARNER AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 178-292-11 SHORR, STUART C 178-292-18 PATTEN, THEODORE C TR 178-311-03 ROQUET, C 04-007 17179 ROUNDHILL 04-007 17127 ROUNDHILL DR 04-007 1203 N 13STH ST HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 - HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 GARDENA,- CA 90249 178-292-12 SHORES, PETER B 178-292-19 WOOD, LEONARD CASS 178-312-01 CITT OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 04-007 17171 ROUNOHILL OR 04-007 17123 ROUNDHILL OR 04-007 P 0 BOX 190 - HUNTINGTN BCH► CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92648 178-292-13 GARRETT, GEORGE N 3RO 178-301-01 HUNTINGTON HARBOUR CORP 178-312-02 REIMER, RALPH H 04-007 17163 ROUNDHILL OR 04-007 SUITE 430: 04-007 16862 SEAWITCH LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 9171 TOWNE CENTRE OR HUNTINGTON BEACHr CA 92649 SAN DIEGO, CA 92122 178-292-14 FALCON, JOSEPH A TR 178-301-03 HUNTINGTON HARBOUR BEACH .178-312-03 MILLS, JOAN 6 04-007 1715S ROUNDHILL OR 04-007 CLUB AND MARINA 04-007 16872 SEA- WITCH LN - HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 4121 WARNER -AVE HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACHr CA 92649 178-292-1S GOLDBERG, SAIL 178-301-04 HUNTINGTON HARBOUR BEACH 278-322-04 HUNTINGTON HARBOUR CORP 04-007 17147 ROUND HILL OR 04-007 CLUB AND MARINA 04-007 29S BROADWAY 7TH FLOOR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 4121 WARNER AVE SAN DIEGO, CA 92101 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 178-292-16 SMILEY, JACK C 178-311-01 HUNTINGTON HARBOUR CORP 178-312-OS KNOTT, JOHN L 04-007 17139 ROUNDHILL DR 04-007 4241 WARNER AVE 04-007 16878 SEA WITCH LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647. HUNTINGTON BEACH. CA 92649 DISTRICT NUMBERI 056A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS zI► TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE 178-374-07 CHICK, ROBERT L e 178-37S-OS PARKIN. GREGCRT L 178-375-12 LANGSTON, OREN EUGENE TR 04-007 26821 BARUNA LN 04-007 2SOO W ORANGETHORPE AVE 04-007 16822 BARUNA LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 SUITE V i HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 FULLERTON, CA 92633 178-374-08 CAMPBELL, MILA J 178-375-06 THOMPSOH, .,RALPH T . 278-375-13 KAVASCH, WILLIAM E. 04-007 26621 BARUNA LN 04-007 16762 BARUNA LN 04-007 16832 BARUNA LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 178-374-09 GOLDENSON, LEWIS W 178-37S-07 CONKLIN, ROBERT R '178-375-14 SOLUM. DAMES R TR 04-007 16831 BARUNA LN 04-007 16172 BARUNA LN 04-007 16842 BARUNA LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 178-37S-01 MASON, J L TR 178-37S-08 BELK, EARL H 178-37S-1S SWARTZ. DONALD P 04-007 16712 BARUNA LN 04-007 16622 CHANNEL LN 04-007 168S2 BARUNA LN = HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 178-37S-02 MILANO, P R 178-37S-09 LAZEAR, THOMAS J 178-37S-16 WOODRUFF, SANDRA S 04-007 P 0 BOX 626 04-007 16792 BARUNA LN 04-007 P 0 BOX 881171 SUNSET BEACH, CA 90742 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 STEAMBOAT SPRINGS, CO .80488 178-37S-03 SELVIN, GERALD J 178-37S-10 KING, PRESTON MC CAULET 178-37S-17 HUNTINGTON HARBOUR CORP 04-007 16732 BARUNA LN 04-007 26802 BARUNA LN 04-007 4241 WARNER AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH. CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 178-37S-04 AGLIOZZO, CARL MICHAEL TR 178-375-11 RANDOLPH, CARL L 178-375-18 HUNTINGTON HARBOUR CORP 04-007 16742 BARUNA LN 04-007 16812 BARUNA LN 04-007 4241 WARNER AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 OISTQIC M ( s 054A HUNTINGTON PEACH CITI PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZII PARCEL NO/ OWNERS :I► PARCEL NO/ OMNtas EIP TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS COOL 178-363-4S DAVE GRATTAN A SONS INC 178-363-SZ REEDER, WILLIAM H H 178-363-S9 VISCARDI-MOALLEM, 04-007 16247 MONTOYA 04-007 1444 OAKLAWN RD 04-007 FILOMENA P 0 BOX 2264 ARCADIA, CA 91006 4081 DAVENPORT OR IRWINDALE, CA 91706 HUNTINGTON BEACH* CA 92649 178-363-46 MCWHINNEY, DEREK C 178-363-S3 BILLER, MICHAEL ANTHONY 178-363-60 BESLEY, THOMAS F TR 04-007 4021 DIABLO CIR 04-007 4072 DIABLO CIR 04-007 . 4061 DAVENPORT OR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH; CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 178-363-47 WOOLSEY, WILLIAM F 178-363-S4 GORDON, BENJAMIN 178-363-61 NICHOLSON, EDWARD LALONDE 04-007 4001 DIABLO CIR 04-007 4082 DIABLO CIR 04-007 TR HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 40S1 DAVENPORT OR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 178-363-48 PAUGH, JOHN THOMAS TR 178-363-SS JANESKI, GERARD J 178-363-62 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 04-007 4002 DIABLO CIR 04-007 4092 DIABLO CIR 04-007 P 0 BOX 190 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92648 178-363-49 STANSFIELD, JEFFREY J 178-363-S6 ZWICK, EUGENE B 178-363-63 HUNTINGTON HARBOUR CORP 04-007 SOS2 WARNER AVE 04-007 P 0 BOX 2460 . 04-007 4241 WARNER AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 278-363-50 JOKES, JESSE L 178-363-S7 BANZETT, HONARD 178-363-64 HUNTINGTON HARBOUR CORP 04-007 4032 DIABLO CIR 04-007 16851 EDGEWATER AVE 04-007 4241 WARNER AVE HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 178-363-32 HIESHIMA, GRANT B 178-363-S8 GILL, LEE B JR 278-371-01 SAHAGEN, ARMEN N 04-007 40S2 DIABLO CIR 04-007 16861 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 167S7 BOLERO LN HUNTINGTN BCH► CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 DISTRICT NUMBER= 054A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE 278-323-10 BAER, RICHARD 6 TR. 178-323-17 MAIORANA, RUSSELL J 178-323-24 HUNTINGTON HARBOUR CORP 04-007 169SS EDGEWATER LN 04-007 16985 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 4241 WARNER AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 178-323-21 MENGER, ELLEN M 178-323-18 THOMPSON, WILLIAM H TR 178-323-27 STANKO, JOHN J TR 04-007 16959 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 17017 EDGEWATER 00 .04-007 16771 BOLERO LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92�a9 178-323-12 FIPP, THOMAS J 178-323-19 THOMPSON, WILLIAM H TR 178-323-28 STANK09 JOHN J TR 04-007 16963 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 17017- EDGEWATER LN 04-007 16771 BOLERO LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH* CA 92649 178-323-13 ROBISON, -EDWARD M ET AL 178-323-20 FERRULLI, MICHELE THOMAS 178-331-01 COLAO. GIOVANNI B 04-007 16967 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 TR 04-007 16931 SAYBROOK LH HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 17003 EDGEWATER LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH. CA 92649 178-323-14 MOULTON, A MICHAEL TR 178-323-11 THOMPSON, JAMES R 178-331-02 JONES, CLAUDE M 04-007 16971 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 17007 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 16455 LAOONA CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH. CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 178-323-15 600600IAN9 ALEXANDER 178-323-22 60ULDING, STANFORD 6 178-331-03 JONES, STEVEN A 04-007 16975 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 P 0 BOX 240 04-007 169SI SAYBROOK LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 SUNSET BEACH, CA 90742 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 178-323-16 BUCCGLA, VICTOR J TR 178-323-23 HUNTINGTON HARBOUR CORP 178-331-04 ROSENBAUM, DANIEL I 04-007 26979 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 4241 WARNER AVE 04-007 16971 SAYBROOK LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 .{ `.R r�1�A •`If r.j: .;�i�p .s' - _W a a._�• _ `. +t-- .BA; :T!-..1-- - r et; - 1►X 1 .ir•�--� Ott:: y :i.r:'p.;.:, ��F :I,i�t',k 5-'a� . :'rl;'� ^i. "_ '►jj {- .�` � ;. tisrt� - t •fit `i 939Y, !+ _7-�4f:tAV•Rs�3 'b'.�C'�r . •.� - DZSTRZCT NUMBER: 054A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS - ZIP TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE 178-3tt-19 JACOBI, KURT E 178-322-26 PETERSEN► ALAN M 178-323-03 CLIFFORO, PHYLLIS E . 04-007 16996 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 1414 KYNETON RD 04-007 16915 EDGEWATER LN HUNTINGTON BEACH. CA 92649 VILLANOVA, PA 19085 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 178-322-20 PIERCE, ALBERT R TR 178-322-27 ATKINSON. STEVEN 0 178-323-04 JAMES 0 STEVEN A ELEANOR 04-007 16988 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 16932 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 STEVEN REVOCABLE TRUST HUNTINGTON BEACH. CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH. CAL 92649 16923 EDGEWATER LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 4 '9 178-32t-21 RABURN, LOUIS C 178-322-28 HANSEN, BETTY J 178-323-05 M E S T 04-007 16980 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 P 0 BOX 1091 04-007 208 N YNEZ AVE SUITE 228 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 MONTEREY PARK, CA 917S4 178-322-22 MOOREHEAD, R B JR 178-322-29 WELCH, MICHAEL DAVID 178-323-06 AYOTTE, ALLYN A JR 04-007 16972 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 26919 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 1693S EDGEWATER LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 178-3tt-23 RITCHIE, RICHARD 0 178-322-30 RIBAL, LOUISE B 178-323-07 FORD, SCOTT ALAN TR 04-007 16964 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 16908 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 1,6941 EDGEWATER LN. HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH: CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 178-322-24 OVERENO, THOMAS 178-322-31 OSTEEN, JACK L 178-323-08 AHMADI, BEHROOZ 04-007 16956 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 26902 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 26947 EDGEWATER LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 178-3t2-2S COX, RANDALL G 178-323-02 CRAIG, WILLIAM A 178-323-09 VAS NUNES, EDWARD H 04-007 16948 EDGEWATER LN 0.4-007 16911 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 16951 EDGEWATER LH HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH► CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 awrr . Y)n%ii•. �►at • f DISTRICT NUMBER: 054A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE 178-3t1-08 CIMMARRUSTI, MIKE R 178-322-05 RANCE, JOHN 3 178-322-22 SIMONE, EUGENE S 04-007 26981 WESTPORT OR 04-007 16932 ROUNDHILL DR 04-007 17003 ROUNDHILL OR HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HONTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 178-321-09 LONGMAN, ROBERT W 178-322-06 WRIGHT, GEORGE W 178-322-13 DELAPLAIN, CHARLES A 04-007 26991 WESTPORT OR 04-007 16939 ROUNDHILL OR 04-007 17011 ROUNDNILL OR HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH. CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH. CAL 92649 278-322-10 GEIGER, ALOIS 278-322-07 TROILO, J ANTHONY 178-322-24 IMHOFF, HARRY R 04-007 17001 WESTPORT DR 04-007 16947 ROUNDHILL DR 04-007 17027 ROUNDHILL OR HUNTINGTN BCH. CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 178-322-01 MCCRANIE, THOMAS K 178-322-08 STIEMERLING, GISELA 178-322-15 HANDSCHER, HEIR 04-007 26901 ROUNOHILL OR 04-007 16963 ROUNDHILL DR 04-007 17028 EDGEWATER LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH. CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH. CA 92649 178-322-02 JOHNSON, BOYD A 178-322-09 WOLTER9 DONALD G 178-322-16 CIRILLO., SHIRLEY E 04-007 16907 ROUND HILL OR 04-007 16971 ROUNDHILL OR 04-007 17020 EDGEWATER LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 178-322-03 HAENTZSCHEL, LESTER E . 178-322-10 SLINEY, CHARLES M 178-322-17 FORD. CHARLES W TR 04-007 26915 ROUNDHILL OR 04-007 26979 ROUND HILL OR 04-007 17022 EDGEWATER LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 178-322-04 CHU, NORMAN S C 178-322-11 MITCHELL, NORMAN M 178-322-18 DE LA HATE, ROSS A 04-007 16923 ROUNDHILL OR 04-007 16987 ROUNDHILL OR 04-007 17004 EDGEWATER LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 I l ,i.,- , K�:'1�i�09 F t31� 4. '(t•:� i `a: +�.+�.- �` �;, f u3"", t. - •60C 1.1Si. DISTRICT NUMBER: 054A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE 178-314-33 QAQUNOAH, PAUL Y 178-315-04 COONEY, GEORGE T 178-315-11 YOUNIS, ERNEST 04-007 3901 LEGEND CIR 04-007 16922 BARUNA LN 04-007 16992 BARUNA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 178-314-34 BAKER, ROBERT C 178-315-OS GIBSON, JAMES K 178-315-12 BERESFORD, JAMES P 04-007 3911 LEGEND CIR 04-007 16932 BARUNA LN . 04=007 448 S PASADENA HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 PASADENA, CA S B 178-314-35 BULLOCK, BOB 178-315-06 R i A HOLDINGS 178-315-13 FINK, ALDOR 6 04-007 3921 LEGEND CIR 04-007 N BUILDING. SUITE 105 04-007 17022 BARUNA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 17772 E 11TH ST HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 TUSTIN, CA 92680 178-314-36 CUMMINGS* EDWARD H 178-315-07 HOUSEAL, ROBERT W JR 178-315-24 FITZPATRICK, NITA 04-007 3941 LEGEND CIR 04-007 16952 BARUNA LN 04-007 5478 WILSHIRE BLVD 0203 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 LOS ANGELES, CA 90036 178-315-01 ST PIERRE, RONALD. 178-315-08 HERRICK, LYLE D 178-315-IS GLUM, FRANK P 04-007 VAUGHN TR 04-007 12027 S EAST END AVE 04-007 17052 BARUNA LN 16892 BARUNA LN CHINO, CA 91710 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 9" 9 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 i 178-315-02 FERGUSON, CRAIG C 178-325-09 PERRY, JOHN W 178-315-16 FIELD, ARTHUR H TR 04-007 16902 BARUNA LN 04-007 16972 BARUNA LN 04-007 27062 BARUNA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH. CA 92649 178-315-03 FERGUSON, OLIVER J 1f8-315-10 BUSS, WILLIAM C 178-315-17 ANDERSON* STEPHEN HUME TR 04-007 16912 BARUNA LN 04-007 16982 BARUNA LN 04-007 17072 BARUNA LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649' HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 . '. ►wee i.�01 • DISTRICT NUMBERS 054A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY •• ' PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE 178-314-12 CONNER. KENNETH J 178-314-19 CLAPP, DAN 6 178-314-26 CAMPAGNA# FRANCIS E, 04-007 27002 BOLERO LN 04-007 3921 SIRIUS OR 04-007 3911 KITTEN CIR HUNTINGTN BCH# CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 178-314-13 RAILEY, CHARLES JR 178-314-20 GILLEN, DANIEL E- 178-314-27 KAHELIN, EDWARD W 04-007 17022 BOLERO LN 04-007 3941 SIRIUS DR 04-007 3921 KITTEN CIR HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA "0649 178-314-24 GILBRECH, PATRICIA H 1787314-21 KIRKEGAARD-JENSEN, ULF 278-324-28 WHITEP JAMES K 04-007 17032 BOLERO LN 04-007 3942 KITTEN CIR 04-007 3941 KITTEN CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH# CAL 92649 178-314-15 OU BOURDIEU# GRAYCE E 178-314-22 ALLARD, THELMA 178-314-29 PERUMEAN, DAVID 04-007 17042 BOLERO LN 04-007 3922 KITTEN CIR 04-007 3942 LEGEND CIR HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACHP CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 178-314-16 RYAN, CURTIS A 178-314-23 RIDENOUR, JAMES M 178-314-30 WEINER, N JEFFRIES 04-007 3881 SIRIUS DR 04-007 3912 KITTEN CIR 04-007 3922 LEGEND CIR HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH# CAL 92649 178-314-17 LUPICA, JOSEPH A JR 178-314-24 BURNS, ROBERT E 178-314-31 CAUBLE, DAVID HYTEN 04-007 3891 SIRIUS OR 04-007 3902 KITTEN CIR 04-007 3912 LEGEND CIR HUNTINGTON BEACHP CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH# CA 92649 178-314-18 SIMMONS# CHESTER L 178-314-25 VESSEY, DAVID 0 178-314-32 ULTSCHP PETER .R 04-007 3911 SIRIUS OR 04-007 3901 KITTEN CIR 04-007 3902 LEGEND CIR HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 DISTRICT NUMBER: 054A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE 178-361-20 MILLER, JANE H 178-362-07 TAYLOR, JAMES. J 178-362-14 MARSHALL* JAMES C TR 04-007 16652 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 16851 PHELPS LN 04-007 16832 EDGEWATER LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 178-362-01 •CAINE# WALTER A JR 178-362-08 LANDSMAN, GERALD L 178-362-15 CROOK. LUCILE E 04-007 16781 PHELPS LN 04-007 16861 PHELPS LN 04-007 26822 EDGEWATER LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL �9 178-362-02 HOLMES, JOHN S 178-362-09 NEWBERG, ALBERT 178-362-16 SAVOLD, TERRY L 04-007 16791 PHELPS LN 04-007 26871 PHELPS LN 04-007 16802 EDGEWATER LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 178-362-03 GRUNDFOR, WARREN P 178-362-10 HEISLER, ROBERT L 178-362-17 HERSH, GEORGE T 2NO 04-007 16801 PHELPS LN . 04-007 - 16872 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 16792 EDGEWATER LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 178-362-04 KLAYMAN, ARNOLD I 178-362-11 CASTRO,::MARGARET 178-362-18 MESHKINPOUR, H009HANG TR 04-007 16821 PHELPS LN 04-007 16862 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 18981 GLENMONT TER HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 IRVINE, CA t� 178-362-05 TOLLE, THEODORE C 178-362-12 GRAVATTE, GRANT 0 178-363-01 DEMOS, GEORGE O 04-007 16831 PHELPS LN 04-007 16852 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 16641 EDGEWATER LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 178-362-06 BRUTTIG, LELAND J 178-362-13 BROWN, PETER M 178-363-02 POLIK, RAYMOND E 04-007 16841 PHELPS LN 04-007 16842 EDGEWATER LN 04-007 16651 EDGEWATER LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 99649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL. 92649 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH INTER-DEPARTMENT COMMUNICATION HUNTINGTON BEACH �To Alicia Wentworth From Robert Sangste City Clerk Deputy City At oriney Subject Davenport Marina = Date August 13, 1987 At the request of the property owners and because some of the residents are going to be out of town on August 17 , 1987 , the public hearing on Davenport Marina Pierhead Line should be continued to the second regular meeting in September. V_ =- - - see; D IL 8S-o5$c C I TY AT �tTY OF HUNTING T ON BEACH C I I Y OFFICE OF Tk1E CITY CLERK rl�JNTlhuI l . ®RAND;1M OF SERVICE 1 ! SERV€ N: - k L YNN PROCESS SERVER 4 i DATE: -- 8� f ......--•-•----- -------------. . 5 TIME:.�. � 3S AM 6 7 8 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 9 FOR THE COUNTY OF ORANGE 10 11 JOHN J. STANKO, as Trustee of ) Case No. 46-75-77 The Stanko Trust, UDT 9/24/80, ) 12 ) Petitioner, ) PEREMPTORY WRIT OF 13 ) MANDAMUS VS. ) 14 ) CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, ) 15 et al. , ) 16 Respondents. ) 17 18 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA TO CITY OF HUNTINGTON 19 BEACH AND CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, 20 RESPONDENTS: 21 -Judgment having been entered in this action, ordering 22 that a peremptory writ of mandamus be issued from this Court, 23 YOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED immediately on receipt of 24 this writ to set aside your Resolution No. 5523, adopted June 3, 25 1985, establishing a pierhead line in the Davenport Marina, 26 which proceedings are hereby remanded to you, and to reconsider 27 your action in the light of this court's findings of fact and 28 conclusions of law., and to take any further action specially REQUES4 FOR CITY COUNCIPACTION Date September 10, 1987 Submitted to: Honorable Mayor and City Council /� 1 Aeo,11,V1 C ah T ()f 29 L, Submitted by: Paul E. Cook, Interim City Administratb �2 CM 7 44` (�IV Prepared by: Paul E. Cook, Interim City Administrator q� ) 0 f O N 9,147 1. Subject: Establish a Pierhead Line for Davenport Marina, Huntington Harbour tg J-1,0t Consistent with Council Policy? [A Yes [ ] New Policy or Exception Statement of Issue, Recommendation,Analysis, Funding Source,Alternative Actions,Attachments:. STATEMENT OF ISSUE: The Orange County Superior Court has ordered that Resolution No. 5523, adopted June 3, 19859 establishing a pierhead line in the Davenport Marina be set aside and a public hearing be held to reconsider the previous action. RECOMMENDATION: 1. Rescind Resolution No. 5523 which establishes a pierhead line for the Davenport Marina. 2. After holding a public hearing, adopt the attached resolution establishing a pierhead line per Exhibit "D". ANALYSIS: Pursuant to Section 13.32.020 of the Municipal Code, the pierhead line is established by City Council Resolution. "Pierhead Line" means the line between the bulkhead and the waterway, which line separates the.area open for navigation from the area extending outward from the bulkhead in which the mooring and docking of vessels is permitted. The exact distance from the bulkhead to the pierhead line shall be determined by the City Council. On June 3, 1985, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 5523 establishing a pierhead line for the Davenport Marina in accordance with the attached Exhibit "B". Exhibit "B" proposes a pierhead line along the outer edges of the existing docks at the narrow section of the navigable channel and 13 feet from the outer edges of the docks, in the wide part of the channel. This action would allow the marina to maintain two (2) end-tie moorings and eliminate two. The minimum navigable channel width would be 70 feet. On May 4, 1987, as the result of a lawsuit filed in 1985 by Dr. John Stanko, the owner of the Davenport Marina, the Orange County Superior Court found that the City should have held a noticed public hearing prior to adopting Resolution No. 5523 and that Dr. Stanko has a vested right to continue the use of all existing marina facilities that are lawfully permitted. The court ordered that Resolution No. 5523 be immediately set aside and that the City Council reconsider your previous action in light of the Court's findings of fact and conclusions of law and to take any further action specially enjoined upon you by law. The Court's Writ of Mandamus states that nothing in this writ shall limit or control in any way the discretion legally vested to the�_s City. PIO 5/85 Establish a Pierhead Line for Davenport Marina, Huntington Harbour September 10, 1987 Page 2 The judge who made the decision in this case seemed to feel that the owner should have the right to use all end ties which would be allowed per Exhibit "D". Therefore, staff is recommending that, after holding a formal public hearing, the City Council adopt the attached resolution establishing a pierhead line in accordance with Exhibit "D" which would allow a pierhead line legalizing all end ties to existing docks but no further expansion of the marina into the navigable channel. Other alternatives which were presented to the City Council on June 3, 1985 are also attached for consideration. Exhibit "A" indicates a pierhead line along the outer edges of the existing dock and would result in the elimination of four (4) end-tie moorings on the extremities of the docks. The action would establish a navigable channel width of 70 feet between pierhead lines. The marina proprietor would be penalized by this action. Exhibit licit indicates pierhead line that is approximately parallel to the lot line of Lot "C". The minimum channel width is 60 feet, and the maximum would maintain a width of 85 feet. The marina owner would be able to utilize the major portion of the Lot "C". This is the alternative that the marina owner is requesting. Staff is also presenting two other alternatives for consideration. Exhibit "E" is the pierhead line approved by the Corps of Engineers when the marina was originally proposed in 1964. Staff feels that this pierhead line encroaches into the channel so far that it inhibits navigation and turning at the Davenport bridge. Exhibit "F" is similar to Exhibit "D" except that it allows a 30 foot pierhead line parallel to the end of the marina parking lot. This would allow a ninety foot turning basin at the Davenport bridge. Staff does not recommend this alternative, however, because it allows further expansion of this commercial marina in a residential neighborhood. The marina owner has recently submitted plans requesting a permit to add docks to the marina which would extend outside the limits of Exhibit "D". The owner has not submitted a recent proposal for a pierhead line for the entire marina. Staff strongly feels that no modifications to the existing marina should be permitted until the City Council has established a pierhead line for the marina. FUNDING SOURCE: No expenditure of funds is involved in the recommended action. ALTERNATIVE ACTION: 1. Adopt Exhibits "A", licit, "E" or "F" pierhead line. 2. Readopt Exhibit "B" pierhead line. 3. Deny the recommendation for pierhead line at this time. CWT:PEC:dw 1308g i 9-5-11 10-5-11 DM 9 1 if is- .11 DM 18 17 IS -5-11 21- -11 22-5-11 2 -5-11 24 ,. oM DM 21 DW24 25 t M 26 DM:27 SO-XIS 5-11 - I V-D1-11 =S-u -11 AMDM 34 ` DA4 ON32 CM31 DM30F.RW ECr Mr I ' DM DM 37 38 39 DM 40 5-6-11 1 �6�iY � ' 3-6-11 2 -a 1-6-11 64-10 -10 DM 4 �( I oM 3 2 om � 1 DM 6 DIM 9-6-II -6-11 1 -II Q 6-n T-6-10 6-6-10 DM 10 I DM 01112 mogL' DM.f3 OM 7 DmB AII& 014"6-1 13-6-11 18-6-10 �fl�i 10 CITY OF ` -_�'yiA1 OM14 DM20 DM19 HUNTINGTON BEACH •r:- s. ORANGE COUNTY CALIFORt" i 24-6-1 9- -10 �__ • .. DM 29 wrr a�w�snr•r w.r.c.•�...•a o f II1are 111� . � ���� i1����11��1 11111 �� - ��, • 11. ••�••:C•�•. OR• . �llll. • j j .,. •� • •• • c� - • ' ��ii� 111� �:•'� �iii �RK •• � ail � .•. •• Mimi i1r I ■ 111111111 �M �1���111111� �Hil11111111 Z _; E' !_ ► =•kid =iiiiil • _ : E: :: Eg 1 111111 1 -- �_- .. -- 1 �� ill 111111 1�111111�1 �•►�1�11= __ _ :WO :_ :w: ==1==r� • C ... - -- -- .. . -- ._..E �C11=mill - . . � 11111111111 111�111111 �� E - .. .- - � 11 /1 1 11� 11 "11 11 11� 1010 �IE.�„II'll. � E • ZZ am ••.i1111111. �illll� 1111111111.111111111111 a 1111111111�� II11111111 1111111111 � = 1 - 1111iIIIIII � 1 � I111111111 1111111111 ��'�_° � - E ililllllll\� II11111111-1111111111 3��:��� �E _ C 11i1111111111 t. ,, :E E-.E;E;E 1111111 �..� EC �E _ r �I�'��� E 1 "= :� EE a: :, I BE �ii EoiZi■ � � I A9 I i RESOLUTION NO. P9 0 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH ESTABLISHING A PIERHEAD LINE IN THE DAVENPORT MARINA WHEREAS, the City of Huntington Beach desires to establish a pierhead line for the Davenport Marina; and Huntington Beach Municipal Code section 13 . 32 .020 ( f ) provides that the distance from the bulkhead to the pierhead line shall be determined by the City Council; and The City Council adopt the findings set forth on Exhibit attached hereto and incorporated by reference herein . NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach that there is hereby established a pierhead line in the Davenport Marina, also designated as Lot C of Tract 4880 ; that the establishment of said pierhead line conforms to city policy; and the pierhead line and the property on which such pierhead line is established is described in Exhibit attached hereto and incorporated by reference herein. PASSED AND ADOPTED by_ the. City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at a regular meeting thereof held on the day of , 1987 . Mayor ATTEST : APPROVED AS TO FORM: { City Clerk CityAM-rney REVIEWED AND .APPROVED: NITIATED AND O_V D: City Administrator Directo of Public Works 3 FINDINGS Davenport Marina Pie�rhead L:i-ne 1 . The city is empowered to adopt pierhead lines to protect navigable channels from encroachment. 2 . Pursuant to Huntington Beach Municipal Code 5 13 .32 .020, the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach has the power to establish` pierhead lines by resolution . 3 . The Orange County Superior Courtin John J . Stanko v. City of Huntington Beach, case no . 46 75 77 , has mandated the city to set aside the pierhead line established by the City Council in Resolution No. 5523 , adopted June :1, 1985 . 4 . Davenport Marina is located along the subject channel depicted on attached exhibits , and is improved with various docks-, slips , and gangways . r- 5 . The subject channel is a navigable waterway. A low bridge which crosses the channel to Davenport Island- p-cee vnts further navigation by vessels, except for small boats. A ninety foot width at the bridge is desirable for safe t"ur.ning of vessels and 'navigation . 6 . A minimum channel width of sixty feet . i.s necessary for ' " navigation of vessels . in the channel . 7 . Expansion of the existing marina further into the channel would impair navigation, create traffic and parking impacts , and be incompatible with the residential character ,of the neighborhood. << `BAN �E' � � lA^ 4H .V a� 1 enjoined upon you *by law; but nothing in this writ shall limit 2 or control in any way the discretion legally vested in you; and 3 YOU -ARE FURTHER COMMANDED to make and file a return to' - - 4 _this writ on or before , 1987, 5 setting fo hat you have done to comply. T.0,R4ti J U L 1 0 1987 6 "' G RY L RANVILLE 7 (Se :{ :;;?c° Clerk � rl� Deputy Clerk 8 �ii..... � j' J. BA Ply 9 LET THE FOREGOING WRIT ISSUE. 10 e dge of the uperi Cour 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 AC, PARKIHGj L47T 23.61 , A PROPOSED PIERHEAO LINE - Ch W -- LOT ..p. L ' - g fD 2 Q ROPOSEDPIERHEA LINE EXHIBI A EXHIBIT 'W' A PIERHF.AD LINE FOR THE DAVENPORT MARINA IN THE CITY OF KWINGPON BEAD Beginning at the southwesterly corner of Lot 7, Tract 4880, as shown on a map recorded in Book 172, Pages 12 to 19 inclusive, of Miscellaneous Maps., Records of Orange County, State of Cali- fornia, Thence north 890 44' 00" west 125.67 feet to a point, thence north 00 16' 45" west 40.25 feet to a point, thence south 890 44' 00" west 8.40 feet to a point, thence north 00 16' 45" west 66.00 feet to a point, thence south 890 43' 4S" west 16.45 feet to a point, thence north 00 16' 45" west 104.77' feet to a point, thence south 890 43' 30" west 2.00 feet to a point, thence north 00 16' 45" west 90.00 feet to a point, thence south 890 43' 1S" west 13.00 feet to a point, thence north 00 16' 45" west 64.00 feet to a point, said point being the terminus of said pierhead line: 2/8/85 f EXHIBIT 'C ' A PIERHEAD LINE FOR THE DAVENPORT MARINA IN THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH Beginning at the southwesterly corner of Lot 7, Tract 4880 , as shown on a map recorded in Book 172 , pages 12 and 19 inclusive of Miscellaneous Maps , Records of Orange County, State of California. Thence North 89' 44 ' 00" West 138 . 67 feet to a point. Thence North 190 00 ' 00" West 275 . 50 feet to a point. Thence North 00 16 ' 45" West 220 . 50 feet to a point. Said point being the terminus of said pierhead line. DAVENFIORT �QI 96P 3o I 82� 30 AC,PAFWJNGI Lo'r _ PROPOSED c � PIERN D �I I\jN E \ J , kn \ � - \ LOT � 2 �. MAIST.. _ N/\ (JL P OP 5ED Pl . LINE _F�R _ WA R I ILIA OWNER � \ 11�11 EXN.1 IT 9�18�87 p.41 210.0 -- a PRO SED / LINE LOT �C, .� Ul f sa\ �...+�► 2 P �� M .� RIBEAD LJ� EXPIBIF D EXHIBIT "D" A PIERHEAD LINE FOR -THE DAVENPORT MARINA IN THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH Beginning at the southwesterly corner of Lot 7, Tract 4880 , as shown on a map recorded in Book '172, pages 12 and 19 inclusive of Miscellaneous Maps , Records of Orange County, State of California. Thence North 890 44 ' 00" West 138.67 feet to a point. Thence North 00 16 ' 45" West 43.00 feet to a point. Thence South 890 44 ' 00" West 12 .00 feet to a point. Thence North 00 16 '45" West 66 .00 feet to a point. Thence South 890 43145" West 33.00 feet to a point. Thence North 00 16 ' 45" West 195 .00 feet _ to a point. Thence South 890 43' 30" West 13.00 feet to a point. Thence North 00 16 ' 45" West 64 .00 feet to a point. Thence North 890 43 ' 15" East 13.00 feet to a point. Said point being the terminus of said pierhead line. 7/15/87 f • 0/0.00 —brow Sfr.��ov A-,a t•fc• -/0.00 scA[EiwF�ET TQ,4CT .V�SZG4 1 � �u[N'A -- h \ P� slse+ rIDf iLOOD F/DE I • _—�(� 4GO ' . Ip, 000 Juu ju en Aj 71.0 SS O D! — '-� --,- A I � a o I T2,4CT - .4880 00 3 CAL iN fEFr - Fw X H 15 IT eel EXHIBIT "E" A PIERHEAD LINE FOR THE DAVENPORT MARINA IN THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH Beginning at the southwesterly corner of Lot 7 , Tract 4880 , as shown on a map recorded in Book 172, Pages 12 to 19 inclusive of Miscellaneous Maps, records of Orange County, State of California, thence south 88*51124" west 30 .00 feet to a point, thence north 89*44100" west 70.02 feet to a point, thence south 89051153" west 29 .98 feet to a point, thence north 18637157" west 333. 71 feet to a point, thence north 0016145" west 150 .00 feet to a point, thence north 89051153" east 50 .00 feet to a point, said point being the terminus of said pierhead line. 7/14/87 y EXHIBIT 'B". A PIEWE AD LINE FOR THE DAVENPORT MARINA, IN 71M CITY OF HMING 0W BEACH Beginning at the southwesterly corner of Lot 7, Tract 4880, as shown on a map recorded in Book 172, Pages 12 to 19 inclusive of Miscellan- eous Maps, Records of Orange County, State of California . Thence north 890 44' 00" west 125.67 feet to a point, .thence north 00 16 ' 45" west 40.25 feet to a point, thence south 890 44 ' 00".west 8.40. feet:,to. a point _ thence north 09 -16' 45" west 66.00" feet to a point, thence south 890. 43 45" west 18.45 feet to a point, thence north 00 161-45" west 104.77 feet to a point, thence south 890 43' 30" west 13.00 feet to a point, thence north 60 16' 45" west 90.00 feet to a point, thence south 890 43' 1$" west 13.00 feet to a point, thence north 00 16.' 45" west 64.00 feet to a point, thence north 890 43' 15" east 13.00 feet to a point, said point being the terminus of said pierhead-UT fe. .2/8/85 • I s a ' 13 �� PRot�9Efl �- N o Vi W Ale RwibuDl _ U ms LOT 1 � 4 CD �1 \ � rn = Z �' P05E P PI!.R- H LIN n " .AE X H F . Q , L8/51/L mr-1 avamwid a9sod M . e 1 � lnfi* t4•s t t • Y r ,0, lo, 3NM , CBS Owd A � 1 LOT 1*7 � � 1 iZ EXHIBIT "F" A PIERHEAD LINE FOR THE DAVENPORT MARINA IN THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH Beginning at the southwesterly corner of Lot 7, Tract 4880 , as shown on a map recorded in Book 172 , pages 12 to 19 inclusive of Miscellaneous Maps , Records of Orange County, State of California. Thence North 890 44 ' 00" West 138 . 67 feet to a point. Thence North 00 16 ' 45" West 43.00 feet to a point. Thence' South 890 44 ' 00" West 12.00 feet to a point. Thence North 00 16 ' 45" West 66 .00 feet to a point. Thence South 890 43' 45" West 33.00 feet to a point. Thence North 00 16 ' 45" West 195 .00 feet to a point. Thence South 890 43' 30" West 13.00 feet to a point. Thence North 00 16 ' 45" West 64 .00 feet to a point. Thence South 890 43' 15" West 22.00 feet to a point. Thence North 00 16 ' 45" West 100 .00 feet to a point. Said point being the terminus of said pierhead line . 7/15/87 Huntington Harbour Property Owners Assocktilon, Inc. P. O. BOX "i SUNSET BEACH, CALIFORNIA September 16, 1987 Honorable Mayor and City Council i 200 Main Street Huntington Beach, California Re: Davenport Marina Pierhead Line. Dear Mayor and City Council Members: Members of the Huntington Harbour Property Owners Association (HHPOA) have indicated a preference for a pierhead line as set forth in Exhibit "B" j of the Request for City Action dated July 13, 1987. Readoption of this pierhead line allows for safe passage of boats through the narrowest point of the channel as well as providing an aesthetically clean appearance to the marina. Exhibits "C", "D",-"E" and "F" of the July 13 Request for City Action are not acceptable to our members because they each restrict passage of boats in the channel and may result in a hazardous situation being created. With respect to your authority and responsibility, the HHPOA recommends that you readopt the pierhead line established by Resolution Number 5523 1 on June 3, 1985 and Identified as Exhibit OF in the Request for City Action. Sincerely, Norman Y. Smith, President HHPOA i w �O - d 7 CO J V%C %\ YK ��. �'l�- lT`� ��1}'ley 7✓� en 'HPt -� H �useai sAay 13 , 197 Ken Thompson 16863 Algonquin, Huntington Leach, California Subject ; Davenport ;-farina Near r:en Since the completion of the r4arina, this office h-as received numerous complaints pertaining to the vessels that have been moored at thr-- erIctreme on(i of each finger by ,geans of a side tic only. "his situation his resulted in ancroac'.unent into the adjac-nt navitjahle w-aterway. ^he pity Larhor Per-iit 4'o. 513 ,Iate ) June 21, 1972 , did not include the use of tiiase extrcrito f inuers for permanent si,. a tie -noorings. rhese finijor.s ar,- to be used only for the pirpose of temporary :noo-rin,r/(.)F" loal--on load equipment and personnel and/or for emerf.tenry -ioor.inn. You are hereby instructf:�.l to find perrianent floorings for those vessels now occupyinct -theses extrer'ie _`in,aers at some other location, and to post these sli>>s .for temporary nooring only. Very truly yours, Z' s's6�.ed h'' y.fi. C. i�artge<< 0. 'tart"e Director. of Public Works r +; '� rr-' x - ~` Pam• "� �t.a 3-r�. ♦ C 1. i /�L� ;_�6 1' Pr--.S 'X--.,f�:��'�' y��9 i--�..��'z•� .p �_ � �,a Yt-.; xy4.,y - Art.X, § � hb" Art. XI, 4 I CONSTITUTION OF CALIFORNIA 121 public interest. [New section adopted June 8, 1976.1 = t [Access to Navigable Waters] SEC. 4. No individual, partnership, or corporation, claiming or tred to exist possessing the frontage or tidal lands of a harbor,bay,inlet,estuary,or i State. [New other navigable water in this State, shall be permitted to exclude the right of way to such water whenever it is required for any public t purpose, nor to destroy or obstruct the free'navigation of such water; [- and the Legislature shall enact such laws as will give the most liberal conditions construction to this provision,so that access to the navigable waters of tion this State shall be always attainable for the people thereof. [Newsec ' the water : ;t extent of adopted June 8, 1976.] ; ible use or .=; [State Control of Water Use] d that the =: SEC. 5. The use of all. water now appropriated, or that may iew to the = people and hereafter be appropriated, for sale, rental, or distribution, is hereby w of water = declared to be a public use, and subject to the regulation and control :s and shall of the State, in the manner to be prescribed by law. [New section !d for the adopted June 8, 1976.] not extend [Compensation for Water Use] I of use or n a stream z:- SEC. 6. The right to collect rates or compensation for the use of ; f the flow ` : water supplied to any county, city and county, or town, or the inhabitants thereof, is a franchise, and cannot be exercised except by i for the lee,, in view y Prescribed authority of and in the manner b law. New section ' y [ � I at nothing _ adopted June 8, 1976.] 1 owner of `;r~"=. [Acquisition of Real Properly—Conformance to California Water Laws] �r's land is SEC. 7. Whenever any agency of government, local, state, or depriving "21r< federal,hereafter acquires any interest in real property in this State,the y entitled. j ta also enact accepnce of the interest shall constitute an agreement by the agency to conform to the laws of California as to the acquisition, control, use, led. [New = and distribution of water with respect to the land so acquiied. [New section adopted June 8, 1976.] tKi .I i city,city Q, ARTICLE XI. [Repealed June 2, 1970. See Article XI, below.] er of any ` ' l tion, shall 1 rships, or ARTICLE. XI served t0 LOCAL GOVERNMENT _ s`• finds and SECTION 1. [Repealed June 2, 1970. See Section 1, below.] �. essary for d county, [Counties—formation, Boundaries, Governing Body, Elected Sheriff] porations ' l: SEC. 1. (a) The' State is divided into counties which are legal lecessary subdivisions of the State. The Legislature shall prescribe uniform fil otect the procedure for.county formation, consolidation, and boundary change. •New Article XI adopted June 2,1970. r �t�• SIM has � 'S ., 4vy�°•_ `3�,'R. } rr n 'elk, lew, 7 t kA 41 ot At Wyt .1" lei 4"9-),A Ik Ir S AJ, iv . 1 1. 4 ,16. % .,4A yjtz dw 4 FO .re Yk Jv AV 4P. rn� 'I"Ap ja tv ro 21 IS2 rpy4 Ft 10- 'Ai OOL 14 Ilk IV dpo � 44 A 4 K�! )IF* 7 Al 'Ivnk) 4 kv% .6 q 4 X,7: 'I % "Ito site WA* f4 vw _tJ Y*N7N:,` A PETITIC. , TO THE CITY COUNC. _ OF AmAjW HUNT{ ONI BEACH 2 d� 4qy THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNC I L TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF. THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS.1 . �. C _w_r 0n )MOD eaV---,un0, 1� 2nruna OJ - 4. / Q� 5. 01ky- gUSbn I L9 I j& 6-\'Z5!::LL 411 ��7. ure A PETITIC- . TO THE CITY COUNT. _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA 15 PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. Cc -) 2. 3. L� l5 t diarL I o 5 o co C o+Lu'-� Cvl\ ►� 4. .5�c tf yr l bso� Cu Fc�c_+ Cun H . . &;7. a u of)40 ci -1-1 a fa 2�0�k)8. al i t3o &/� A PETITIC TO THE CITY COUNC OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT 1 NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL I S.EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. a � 2. 3. 5. ANou � LA-dch � C �cTc. � �� 37 • A PETITIG. _ TO THE CITY COUNC OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNTINGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCT I NS. / 3. CaddIriga-k- 4. ioot�l 5. d&-Ij j 1 � 6. 8. A PETITI( . TO THE CITY COUN( _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BYLAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA 15 PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. A PETITk,.4 TO THE CITY COUNT .,- OF HUNTINGTON BEACH -- - - THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MAR1 NA 15 PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOP T PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. I A PETITI( . TO THE CITY COUN( _ OF HUNTINCTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING 1S TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE P I ERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REOUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT P I ERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. 2. o ` e 5. 6. 7. 8. A PET1Tk TO THE CITY COUNC - OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 198S. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BYLAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA 15 PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO - ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. : 1 . 2. I-7 �j -7 / Q-cit.- A 3. 5. 6. 7. 8. A PETITIL. . TO THE CITY GOUNC,.- OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. 2. 1 " .;ct,(,�c,� lJ ►` ( �� �i(> i�t r. �'1.. 13. j Z `I 1 y 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. A PETITk , TO THE CITY COUN( _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE P I ERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL 15 EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT P I ERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. %1. g, pryjslqz M b 92JAy 2. SaNIrIR r / D � 3_ r'! 4. .6, gz-(. 5. 6. 7. 8. 15, A PETITk . TO THE CITY COUNT _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE P I ERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT P I ERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. E?Z- y� 2 /I f l i ca,►r cic 14 r if rhev� o0 i 5. 7 61 7. 8. 6 A PETIM , TO THE CITY COUNC _ OF HUNTINCTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEAR I NG i S TO BE HELD I N THE COUNC I L CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT .AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. - 1. 17/J-Z 3 6. 7. 8. A PETITIG.r TO THE CITY COUN(,.L- OF HUNTINGTON BEACH-------- - ---_--- THE CITIZENS OF HUNT 1 NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 Or THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES T PROTECT IGAB E CHANNELS FRO►" OBSTRUCTIONS. 7 v zv/ 4_ 5_ c/ -3 2 f YVIOe-AT7 G l 7 G '�� 70�. -,?z G 9 9 8. A PETITIC. . TO THE CITY COUNC OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW ,MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. .S'7 7 2 1. 2.6� 2. 7.2 1711Y. 6/41 9lzlwly 3_ S? 7a? Le c,r- j� 4. t,3o�l� n 3`L► ee� `l ZG-l 6- ILC'�. 75 a f.�ir,ge� 7. z) 8. 1 A PETITIOi-4 TO THE CITY COUNC _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. ? CA . 1 26 46q 4. � 5 q �J Ll-m 9� `�7 - A PETITI(m TO THE CITY COUNC.,- OF ---HUNTINCTON7BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 Or THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND T HAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA 1S PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL. IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. 1. 36. IOZ7 $. �-7 A PETITIC.. . TO THE CITY COUNC OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7 3 a. A PETITIL.. TO THE CITY COUNC _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. 2. 4. 5. 6. 6 ma 7. A PETITIG.4 TO THE CITY COUNC _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE P I ERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT P I ERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. JL 2 � +f7/07 ,- 1 ell" 4. 5. 6 4 , 7. 8. �6 �- . � A PETITI(A TO THE CITY COM, .L- OF HUNTINGT U EACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987.TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE "MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION `MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. &0 6�0 ^J /y/. s /3. 14,o - Lj.��w ► 7. wl3 z6h4 e r a 4 e, 8. A PETITIu.4 TO THE CITY COUN( _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS-ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE C I TY COUNC I L I S EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. 1. 2. 4. &1 1. 3_ 8. -� A PETITIA TO THE CITY COUNT _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE P I ERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT P I ERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. 1. 3. 3 5. Cli S/ 7. j 8. .e .�. A PETITI _ TO THE CITY COUN _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERTON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SEtT I ON 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANN I NG TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. 2. \UA6 3_ 4. 6. 7� &t: y� 8. ,g A PETITit . 4 TO THE CITY COUN _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. 1 1 . 3. 4. 5. �?'i�?�2/yam ;7 �- - z, 6. 7. 8. 4011WIleR A PETITI J TO THE CITY COUN OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA 15 PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. i. r7l#) 00 - q41 (71 qO 2. 3_ i 3) rot 4. 5. 6. s � G 7. d'20 8. A PETITIC . TO THE CITY COUNC _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE P I ERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT P I ERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. zE�� � 5. &�4 4 7. r � u/t/lJ�l. /602z (fv /d 9z EY A PETITIG, TO THE CITY COUNC _ _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE. WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS.. 2. 5. 7. $. 3 A PETITIU. 4 TO THE CITY COUNC _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. 2. 4 ` UG+� /70 /5. 5. " dZ� &11�: 6. 17 Z � Lqn,14 A PETITIA TO THE CITY COUNC _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE P I ERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA 15 PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT P I ERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. Gr 2. Od 2-Z� :t—IX &:�,Z Z�Ze�5Z glee��,e � Z 3. 4. 1� . 5._C'S�.�c � 1�4��� �,,—Y � ai�-tS'� L-k�. �A -QS. IV v . 7.) J A PETITk 4 TO THE CITY COUN( _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED 1N RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. i 2. /7 3_ 9.2 6. A PETITk- , TO THE CITY COUN( _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. 2_ 3_ 3 3 4. 5_ I �9� 7. 8_ 9, A PETITlk _ . TO THE CITY COUNC _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT 1 NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. 1. 2. .25 13. r r -; xx-2- 4. 5. 2 'ad�� U-4 pil- 6_ 96 `S (ram tv X i✓r A PETITk _ 4, TO THE CITY COUN( _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE _PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. .THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM .OBSTRUCTIONS. I. ... gloo 4. W46- 5. 3311 Veiil m V. 234 ..3 6. 02 .� e A/ y��yy 7. A PETITIuA TO THE CITY COUNu ,L OF HUNTI NGTON-Bf ACH - ---- -- - -- THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA �S PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. NAME ADDRESS 1 . 2. 3. 4. f 6. 7. 6 g C (14-D E3, t< <c ]r 1l A PETITIC,.. TO THE CITY COUN(, _ _ OF HUNTI NGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA 15 PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. l I . aL � 1 dta 4. Z / - z 6. 7. 8. A PETITI. . TO THE CITY COUN( _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE P I ERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE P I ERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. . -!z2- /Z�71 1- &IV / /6� ���✓��r GEC 3 � 1111A'qA"? r��v 4. 2 5 6. 6 7. i A PETITIL . 4 TO THE CITY COUNC. _ OF HUNTINGTON BEACH THE CITIZENS OF HUNT I NGTON BEACH URGE THE COUNCIL TO APPROVE THE PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA AS ADOPTED IN RESOLUTION NO. 5523 ON JUNE 3, 1985. A PUBLIC HEARING IS TO BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS ON SEPTEMBER 8, 1987 TO ADOPT THE PIERHEAD LINE. NECESSARY FINDINGS AS REQUIRED BY LAW MUST BE MADE. ARTCLE X SECTION 4 OF THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION PROVIDES FOR ACCESS TO NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THIS STATE AND THAT NO ONE SHALL OBSTRUCT FREE NAVIGATION. THE OWNER OF THE MARINA IS PLANNING TO EXTEND HIS DOCKS WHICH WILL MAKE FREE NAVIGATION MOST DIFFICULT AND DANGEROUS. THE CITY COUNCIL IS EMPOWERED BY LAW TO ADOPT PIERHEAD LINES TO PROTECT NAVIGABLE CHANNELS FROM OBSTRUCTIONS. ' �2. A� t-' , , � 6. '� G/ a / 7. 8. 7 0 / 3 re Daoecyrpp�vt A PETITION TO THE CITY COUNCIL OF HUNTINGTON BEACH We residents of Huntington Beach ask the City Council to permit the expansion of Davenport Marina within the existing property line of the Marina . We feel that we should have access to a marina boat slip, At the present time boat slips are very limited . We request that you permit Davenport Marina to-Guild the additional slips as sfP�on�the at a�emaO, 1 , ZZ9 �_sys 2 ,�i66 r v G $.C'A'L Z� `l9 34 9 - ,W1, 6 . ,.. L 04,ity 74 JW 1 h'G 12 .A PETITION TO THE CITY COUNCIL OF HUNTINGTON BEACH We residents of Huntington Beach ask the City Council to permit the expansion of Davenport r1arina within the existing property line of the Marina . We feel that we should have access to a marina boat slip , At the present time boat slips are very limited . ie request that you permit Davenport ,Marina to build the additional slips as shown on the attached map, ZL 3s _ S �� � q 3 , Ic�43S �I ►a A — � �?��� 4 , 5 . 6 ,'oo Z�q 7, fV2 9�4'f 7 CA� 10 , 64 Flo 12 . A PETITION TO THE CITY COUNCIL OF HUNTINGTON BEACH We residents of Huntington Beach ask the City Council to permit the expansion of Davenport Marina within the existing property line of the Marina. We feel that we should have access to a marina boat slip . At the present time boat slips are very limited. L;e request that you Permit Davenport "farina to build the additional slips as shown on the attached map. 3 ,a�1 �� v y/� -��, Gam" �/ 7 ;�7 7 70E _ $, 9 . 10. 0 11 , A PETITION TO THE CITY COUNCIL OF HUNTINGTON BEACH We residents of Huntington Beach ask the City Council to permit the expansion of Davenport Marina within the existing property line of the Marina . We feel that we should have access to a marina boat slip . At the present time boat slips are very limited , ie request that you permit Davenport "farina to build the additional slips as shown on the attached map , C 8 . 101 11 , A PETITION TO THE CITY COUNCIL OF HUNTINGTON BEACH We residents of Huntington Beach ask the City Council to permit the expansion of Davenport Marina within the existing property line of the Marina , We feel that we should have access to a marina boat slip . At the present time boat slips are very limited , Ue request that you Permit Davenport Marina to build the additional slips as shown on the attached map , Lz 2 Y3. 34L 4 . 7 . 8. i 9 , d --7 6-IC44)v l i v Sj --6 2 2,ei 10 L-44. 129 A PETITION TO THE CITY COUNCIL OF HUNTINGTON BEACH We residents of Huntington Beach ask the City Council to permit the expansion of Davenport Marina within the existing property line of the Marina. We feel that we should have access to a marina boat slip, At the present time boat slips are very limited, 'rle request that you Permit Davenport Marina to build the additional slips as hown on the attached map, 3 4. 67. �. 8, 9, 10, 11, . 12 , A PETITION TO THE CITY COUNCIL OF HUNTINGTON BEACH We residents of Huntington •Beach ask the City Council to permit the expansion of Davenport Marina within the existing property line of the Marina. We feel that we should have access to a marina boat slip . At the present time boat slips are very limited. We request that . you permit Davenport Marina to build the additional slips as shown on the attached map, 2 . - gay 01 law 5 s� 6 . � 7, 9 . 10, 11, 12 , HUNTINGTON BEACH A PETITION TO THE CITY COUNCIL OF We residents of Huntington Beach ask the City Council to permit the expansion of Davenport Mlorina within the existing property line of the Marina. - . We feel that we should have access to a mar.ina boat slip . At the present time boat slips are very limited. We request that you permit Davenport "farina to build the additional slips as shown on the attached map , 2. n it 3 , 6. t 81 98 ��3 % c�-,��-� C�� inn. 5' c t c L (A tjc A PETITION TO THE CITY COUNCIL. -OF HUNTINGTON BEACH We residents of Huntington 'Beach ask the City Council to permit the expansion of Davenport Farina within the existing property line of the Marina . We feel that we should have access to a marina boat slip . At the present time boat slips are very limilted . We request that you Permit Davenport Marina to build the additional slips as s wn on the attached map 0^_P�_ 2 ru s ed Lh . oov 06 6, lg(2 jrj Slr&f2 A VL_e'� ko 9 vpj�h - - �1� op— OF s 106 10 j� t 44��r A PETITION. TO THE -CITY:'.COUNC I L ._OF -HUNT I NGTON BEACH We residents of Huntington Beach ask the City Council to permit the expansion of Davenport Marina within the existing propery line of the Marina. We feel that we should have acess to a marina boat slip . At the present time boat slips are very limited . We request that you permit Davenport Marina to build the additional slips as shown on the attached map. 2. 3. 4. 5, 6. 7. 8. 10. 11. 12, 13. 14. 15, . �i /�l/ ��� ✓ire 97 ��-,-� ��,�-e . �►- SSA-►�-�o _ �-,� ,���/-�-,� • May 31 , 1985 • • • POSITION PAPER ON PROPOSAL TO ESTABLISH A PIERHEAD LINE FOR DAVENPORT MARINA, HUNTINGTON HARBOUR • • • Prepared for Dr. J.J. Stanko, Marina Operator, by Latham & Watkins • • • • I INTRODUCTION The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach • has before it a proposal to establish a pierhead line for Davenport Marina in Huntington Harbour. The current proposal is the most recent in a series of attempts by the • City Council to deal with what apparently is perceived to be a problem regarding Davenport Marina. In October 1962, Huntington Harbour Corporation • (the "Corporation") dedicated the fee interest in the land underlying Davenport Marina to the City. This dedication and easement , a copy of which is attached as Appendix A, • reserved to the Corporation an assignable right to construct and operate a broad range of uses , including a marina. In May 1964, the City granted Conditional • Exception (Use Variance) No. 707 (the "Conditional Exception") to the Corporation for the construction of Davenport Marina and a parking lot . The Conditional • Exception authorized the construction of 91 slips on the Davenport Marina site; it contained no provision, condition or limitation requiring any work or construction with • respect to the marina or the marina parking lot to be performed within any specific time limit . A copy of the Conditional Exception is attached as Appendix B. • • • • In July 1964 the Corporation obtained from the United States Army Corps of Engineers and the City those permits necessary to authorize the construction of the • parking lot and Davenport Marina. Relying upon those permits, the Corporation constructed the marina parking lot, installed the necessary utilities , constructed the marina • bulkhead, installed an initial 17 boat slips, and began operating and using the marina and parking lot. In 1967 , the Corporation obtained a harbor permit from the City • authorizing the construction and installation of gangways and an additional 9 boat slips ; acting pursuant to those permits , the Corporation completed the additional construc- tion. In 1971 , an additional 48 boat slips were authorized for Davenport Marina by the Corps of Engineers • and the City of Huntington Beach, pursuant to Harbor Permit No. 518 . The Corporation then began construction of the additional 48 slips. In November 1972 , the City issued a • cease and desist order ordering the Corporation to stop work on Davenport Marina until an environmental impact report could be prepared and certified. The Corporation voluntar- ily deferred further action until the City had time to develop policies and procedures for environmental impact reports . • • 2 In January 1974, the Corporation formally requested the City to rescind the cease and desist order and allow completion of Davenport Marina. Prior to that time, the City Attorney had correctly ruled that neither state law nor City guidelines required preparation of an environmental impact report on the completion of the marina. Notwith- standing the City Attorney' s Opinion, on February 19 , 1974 , the City Council held a public hearing on the question of whether to revoke the Conditional Exception, and at the close of the hearing voted 4-2 in favor of revocation. The Corporation brought a mandate proceeding against the City in Orange County Superior Court, Huntington Harbour Corporation v. the City of Huntington Beach, Orange County Superior Court Case No. 211820 (1974) . The Court , Judge Mark A. Soden, presiding, found that the City had committed a prejudicial abuse of discretion in revoking the Conditional Exception. The Court issued a Judgment ordering a peremptory writ of mandamus , remanding the proceedings to the City Council and commanding the City Council to set aside its revocation. The City Complied. The Judgment appeared to have settled all questions between the parties . In 1975, Dr. Stanko purchased Davenport Marina from the Corporation. Dr. Stanko has operated Davenport Marina since that time. 3 • • The City Council has before it a renewed proposal to establish a pierhead line for Davenport Marina. The February 21, 1985 staff report with respect to this matter, • entitled "Request for City Council Action, " sets forth three possible pierhead line proposals , respectively identified as Exhibit "A, " Exhibit "B, " and Exhibit "C. " The staff report • recommends the adoption of a pierhead line pursuant to Exhibit "B. " Should the City Council follow the Staff report, Davenport Marina would lose several of its existing • side-tie moorings , despite the judicial determination that it has a vested right to complete build-out of the marina. To assist the City in its efforts to reach a • reasonable and responsible determination regarding establishment of a pierhead line for Davenport Marina, this position paper discusses some of the legal implications associated with the adoption of any of the staff' s proposals . Dr. Stanko ' s attorneys will be present at the hearing on the proposed pierhead line , should the City Council have any questions . II DAVENPORT MARINA HAS A VESTED RIGHT TO BUILD • OUT AND OPERATE ALL APPROVED FACILITIES. A. The City is contractually bound to permit the continued unimpeded operation and build-out of Davenport Marina. 4 • • The original dedication and reservation of easement by which the Corporation deeded the fee to the land underlying Davenport Marina to the City makes dedication of • the fee subject to reservation of an easement "upon and through the entirety of. . . [the marina site] " for the purpose of locating, constructing, maintaining, using, operating or • renting thereon, free of any rental charge by the City of Huntington Beach, docks , piers , wharves , slips , ramps , floats , landings and other mooring structures , and footings , • pilings and ancillary structures for bulkheads located on adjacent properties of the undersigned corporation, and dockhouses , club houses , marine fuel stations , restaurants , hotels and other structures or buildings of any nature or type for aquatic, recreational, fishing, boating, marina or harbor, and ancillary purposes of all kinds , whatsoever. . . . " This easement was expressly made severable and assignable. The inescapable conclusion to be drawn from the dedication and reservation of easement is that the Corporation or its successor in interest has never been required to procure a conditional exception from the City. The easement rights to construct Davenport Marina appear to be subject only to any applicable City building permit and similar requirements , with which the Corporation and Dr. Stanko have complied. 5 B. The Orange County Superior Court has determined that the Davenport Marina operator has a vested right to complete build-out of the Marina. Judge Soden' s Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law in the Huntington Harbour case, together with the Judgment he entered in favor of the Corporation, establish that, in addition to its reserved easement rights to build a marina, the Corporation has a vested right to complete and operate Davenport Marina. A copy of the Court ' s Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law is attached as Appendix C. A copy of the Court ' s Judgment is attached as Appendix D. The Huntington Harbour case is a conclusive determination of the marina operator' s entitlement to all slips originally authorized by the Conditional Exception, including those slips previously authorized but not yet constructed. See Appendix C, Conclusion of Law 3 (b) : "Huntington Harbour Corporation . . . has a vested right to complete the Davenport Marina. " (Emphasis added. ) C. Both the Corporation' s reserved easement rights and the vested rights under the Conditional Exception have transferred to Dr. Stanko . The marina easement contained in the City' s grant deed is expressly assignable and was transferred to Dr. Stanko when he purchased Davenport Marina. The Conditional Exception is a conditional use permit ("CUP") . It was 6 • • granted to the Corporation, Dr. Stanko ' s predecessor in interest, by the City in a quasi-adjudicative action, following a public hearing. Under California law, a CUP is • not a personal right of the owner of the property at the date the CUP is issued; instead, the CUP runs with the land and is available to any subsequent owner. Cohn v. Board of • Supervisors , 135 Cal. App. 2d 180 (1955) . Once an owner has acquired vested rights in a permit, those rights are protected to the same extent as if the use were a preexisting non-conforming use. Trans-Oceanic Oil Corp. v. Santa Barbara, 85 Cal. App. 2d 776 ( 1948) . The Huntington Harbour case conclusively determined ,that the marina' s CUP had become a vested right by reason of the developer ' s reliance upon issued permits and upon investments in construction. D. Current zoning may permit the present scale of marina operations . The original zoning for the Davenport Marina site • was single family residential. The present zoning, however, is CF-R. To the extent that the operation of the marina is a permitted use under the present community facilities zoning, the Conditional Exception would be voided and a present use permitted to continue as is . Because the Davenport Marina is a going concern which would then be protected under present zoning, this too would constitute a 7 • • vested right protectable by a court. Once again, this conclusion is supported by an Opinion of the City Attorney, a copy of which is attached as Appendix E (See Discussion of Question 2) . III IF THE CITY ATTEMPTS TO TAKE ACTION AGAINST THE • MARINA OPERATOR'S PROPERTY RIGHTS , HE WILL BE ENTITLED TO A WRIT OF MANDATE RESTRAINING THE CITY FROM ACTING, TOGETHER WITH MONEY DAMAGES. • A. The City can be restrained from acting. Should the City now attempt to establish a pierhead line that would eliminate any of Davenport Marina's • side ties , even assuming that it could lawfully establish such a pierhead line, Dr. Stanko would be entitled to a judicial writ of mandate prohibiting the City from • instituting any action to prevent him from using the side ties as part of his marina operations . Magruder v. Redwood, 203 Cal. 665 (1928) . Moreover, since the present use is • based upon the Marina' s earlier permits, as well as upon contract rights under the reserved easement, Dr. Stanko could enforce the Orange County Superior Court ' s prior • Judgment against the City. Trans-Oceanic , supra, 85 Cal. App . 2d at 795 . Indeed, should the City attempt to circumvent that Judgment , the City might be exposed to the • Court ' s contempt power. • 8 • B. If any slips were eliminated by City action, the City would be required to pay just compensation. The Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution requires the City to pay "just compensation" when the City "takes" a person' s private property rights for public use. A "taking" can occur in two ways : either through formal condemnation (eminent domain) proceedings , or informally through a process known as "inverse condemnation, " which occurs when a government act or • regulation exceeds the government ' s power to regulate through the police power and frustrates the private property owner' s "reasonable investment-backed expectations" with respect to the property. Hamilton Bank of Johnson City v. Williamson County Regional Planning Commission, 729 F. 2d 402 (6th Cir. ) , cert. granted, 105 S .Ct. 80 (1984) (No. 84-4) . • In December 1975, following the entry of Judgment in the Huntington Harbour case, John J. O 'Connor, Deputy City Attorney, sent a memo to H. E. Hartge, the City' s Director of Public Works , answering the following question: "If the City Council was to establish a pierhead line for the Davenport Marina which resulted in the removal of • existing docking facilities , would the City be required to compensate the marina owner for this loss?" The Deputy City Attorney replied: "We respond in the affirmative. Establishment of a pierhead line by the City which would 9 • • require the removal of existing docking facilities as originally approved by the City, would clearly involve inverse condemnation in which the City would be required to • compensate the marina owner. Citation of authority is unnecessary, as this is basic law in California. " A copy of the Deputy City Attorney' s response is attached as Appendix • F. The present staff proposals are a repetition of proposals before the City Council in 1975 . Notwithstanding • any changes that may have occurred with respect to the California law of inverse condemnation since that date, federal courts are becoming increasingly active in • protecting a property owner 's rights under the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution. With the exception of the First Circuit, every federal court of • appeal that has decided the matter has determined that compensation in terms of money damages must be paid to a property owner for "takings" made through inverse condemnation by way of excessive government regulation. This monetary compensation may be either the full value of the property taken if the City ultimately punccases all of • the owner' s interest, or it may be damages for the period the invalid law or act was in effect before being overturned by the court . • • 10 • The Hamilton Bank case referred to above provides a particularly striking illustration. In 1973 , the Planning Commission of Williamson County, Tennessee approved a preliminary plat for a proposed cluster housing development covering 676 acres . The approved plat indicated that 736 dwelling units were to be permitted on the tract. • Lot lines , however, were only drawn for the first 469 units . Project development began, and between 1973 and 1979 the Planning Commission approved final plats for several • sections . The developer spent $3 , 000, 000 to $5 , 000,000 in improvements to the property during that time. In 1977 the zoning regulations were changed, but • the Planning Commission continued to apply the 1973 regulations to the project, since it had originally been approved under those earlier standards . That policy changed in 1979, when the Planning Commission decided to apply then- current regulations to future plats submitted by the developer. The developer, and Hamilton Bank, its successor in interest, submitted preliminary plats which included plans for developing the remaining undeveloped portion of the project by building 476 additional dwelling units , to bring .the development ' s total number of units at build-out to 688, substantially less than the 736 units authorized under the initial plat . Notwithstanding its prior approvals • and the fact that the completed project was going to have 11 significantly fewer homes than originally authorized, the Planning Commission denied the Plat. Hamilton Bank then brought an action in federal f court against the Williamson County Planning Commission under several theories of law, including inverse condemnation. The jury in the district court found that by disapproving Hamilton Bank's application to develop the balance of the property, the Planning Commission had frustrated the bank's reasonable, investment-backed expectations regarding the use of its property and that the Fifth Amendment required compensation to be paid to Hamilton Bank. The jury assessed damages against the Planning Commission in the amount of $350, 000 for the temporary taking of Hamilton Bank's property interest in the right to complete its development during the period between the time of the Planning Commission action and the date of trial . Hamilton Bank, supra, 729 F. 2d at 403-04 . The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals , interpreting the • opinions in San Diego Gas & Electric Co. v. City of San Diego, 450 U.S. 621 ( 1981) , concluded that the United States Supreme Court will hold in the proper case that compensation 0 must be paid for temporary regulatory takings . 729 F. 2d at 409 . _.The Sixth Circuit ' s decision is presently being reviewed by the United States Supreme Court and a decision 41 is expected momentarily. 41 12 The Court of Appeals also noted that the federal taking claim could be maintained even in the absence of a vested right under state law to finish the development. i Id. , at 407. Of course , the Huntington Harbour decision states that the marina operator has just such a vested right to complete development of Davenport Marina. Thus , it appears that Dr. Stanko ' s right to compensation is significantly stronger than the developer' s right to compensation in Hamilton Bank. Nevertheless , the staff report states that "No expenditure of funds is involved in the recommended action." IV « ESTABLISHMENT OF ANY ONE OF THE PIERHEAD LINES DISCUSSED IN THE STAFF REPORT HAS OTHER TROUBLING LEGAL IMPLICATIONS. Although other legal implications will not be treated at length in this position paper, establishment of any of the pierhead lines discussed in the staff report suggests several additional legal problems that would be created for the City. Legislative acts are subject to judicial review to determine whether they are arbitrary and capricious . Arnel Development Co. v. City of Costa Mesa, 126 Cal. App. 3d 330, 337 (1981) . Similarly, any quasi-adjudicative action by the City Council, such as establishment of a pierhead line for Davenport Marina, must 13 meet an even stricter test . As set forth in Arnel, the essence of an arbitrary and capricious act is a legislative change of mind, in the absence of a "significant change in • circumstances . " Id. The City has previously appro ed 91 slips or Davenport Marina, including the side tie uld be lost 0Jr J1V4v — if one of the staff' s proposed pierhead lines were to be l)JC9--b adopted. Yet, the staff report makes no mention of any change in circumstances that would justify establishing a pierhead line contrary to earlier approvals . One would think that the City would consider whether the proposed pierhead lines further or retard the goals and policies set forth in the City' s General Plan and in the Coastal Element of the General Plan, which implements the California Coastal Act. The Coastal Element states that the "Coastal Act encourages increased recreational boating as a use of coastal waters . " Coastal Element , Section 2. 2. 8. The Coastal Element then notes that there is a • shortage of boating facilities in Huntington Beach. Id. The proposed Council action would remove existing berthing facilities in the face of a proclaimed shortage. Such an action would raise serious consistency problems, which -must be considered by the City Council . • 14 • V CONCLUSION The owner of Davenport Marina has a vested right to maintain all present facilities . The proposed pierhead lines discussed in the staff report present troubling legal implications that the City Council should carefully consider before making a decision on a pierhead line for Davenport Marina. • • • • 15 �- r IN THE CITY OF HU COUNTY OF ORANE SCALE 1" = 50' BEING A SUBDIVISION OF PORTIONS OF 0174 LOTS SECTION 29, TOWNSHIP 5 SOUTH , RAN( 62.338 ACRES RECORDS OF COUNTY OF JOHN T. GUTH RIE OCTOBER I Tne und�.�sig ea_copQ T,heiha:6e onlyparly.having any record fit'e ,nIeresl in foie ands covered by this;w 1 mop rTrOCt 4860 in�4e City of Huntington Beach, the Boundaries of which are shown oo said map hy,7 h/ue- 44 co ored Jorder line,does henehy conse,t !o theprepare jinn and.eco:„�bj n ofsa%o,77a d �'edics{'o,� tO the ouhlic use.Ors;,P,<{rc:,?ose: Larne-ke.%,e,&*ewa-e-Lo�� Dry;f`e.;!oo�`D,,.,ve,rY c_or Or/ve, Ocvenpo� Drive, Concur�anP :�eaford 4anc raver/y!ooe, B/air/aae and Courjney��sne, ono hereby af'"ers for dedication ,,o the City of Auntingtoo Beach (/'T�e�'s;"o:,n d e�-.s:77e�^js _'a4s.'.;,�? 7,7d/,'4 and'ie d o- e7c,?:e 4Fe.^.',7 0nS jor sox ,i J�;'(Z. x..N.? „',^eJ S,7Ga�n J.? .i a.�'.770.7,' o ..V.al'Unde-groat/wote-s!nand to al/o,{:a/d trJC'Jut w/ SOUf 0.74l':;' ht Of e7,4g JUr,jCe J,^!a t`e subsur,a:e ohove odep. 5 ofSCO,• access o :�ou.�c!,i/; 1;�•'ve '�� �o.s ve?.:nd.o Xe:1mr.-Or.•'ve .rc.1n ;'ti,tAr), , / 1„s v�, ova'(S.)AI'of'ots A,J, "and D for uue only ospu6//c andnavigah/e waterways,ondno otherpurpases whatsoever, ercepti,�g end,�ese,�ving,.howeve:; ° ♦nla the u/lde.,signed corpora,,? ,'he{/lowing severable and assignah/e easements,and rights-of way in moots 1 5 B,Cand D. W As.'o.'0!D easewel its and:,ghts-of woo-/n., over, acres.s, uoon.cnd f novai a,!l of sa.'d Lot D fiexx/r:ose of 0c.75y, -one`ruc-'" ,,n,i;71m?4a, UsinY 0/70 Jpe.-atiny 15e^eo17,{^ee aj�cy.�e�ta.',:ha.-ge:Sy j42 s C,-ty of. ✓.�finglo;�3eac.i,docys, whorve;s/,p; •a:71,os,�ie�s, t;'oe.`s, :aWiny_� and Ofse.-meoricy ue=�res aoc 'Or,7504',,70,DI;'/ngs ana-Jn�i �r�S,f-G'"jG!�eJ o,-,5u/kheoas on ad-�ce.�j:7rGp��, es, and(A)As to Lots B and If . lasements andrights-of way.:; ove.; ocross, upon and through the entirety of each of said Lots B and C C for the purpose of construct/ng,.ro/ntaining, using,operating orrenting Menem,free orar,y re,1710/c/,7rge by I". e City of h'untington Beach,loci r.,plea:, wharves, sl/ps,ramps,floats,/and/ngs and other mooring structures, and footings,p//ingJ and onc/llary slhtc.jares for hu/kheads Ibcated an adjacent properties of the enders/geed eorp- o-o,'/on,and dockhouses, c/uh houses, mangy e fuel sfal&7j,restaurants,hotels, and other structures or hu//dings ofo/!y nature or type for oquot/c,recreational, t thing,600finy, /m-ino or harhor, and onc;%/ary purposes of al/kinds, whatsoever, the oregoing structures and thing:fo he located, canstruc fed,maintained,uses ape,rafed I or rented for prof t or not for prof/} for c omme,-cia/purposes or noncommercial purposes,and fxp.-/vJ je per- C. par, oses and uses orpuhlic purposes and uses in the d/scret/on of the undersigned corporaAan,ar is successors All *idoss/gns;(4) Lot E for ie»,poro.y p•, bl*,c Street Pwrposes ur%Jil _1uck 7r►+t aS ;c orker ►ubjic �t•tet ocross ►5 pr•vlded t. ::UT'iVvTOti' r,A.R3OGR C,7R,aDr?4T'ON D d y Attesj- L.W. Doug/as Jr, 0 P.rs„dit George Potter Jr., Ass is 10,E#lSec.-etory 5�a!e of Ca,'/forw/ ' I 4Jpanty of Orange f- ,i. -,`: ''_N•.•fir��o ay C� IN "I-I-I E CITY OF 1-I U N. N;GTO N'�`B`E a JUHN T. GUTHRIE OCTUBER, �u %1 e9.7r 731c y,f.0o' ' .. e•�nn•u•f7• > I v :. T 2..1y o t.0 r ITS f.�.:... �•'i' ��.f ttO.f fr c �a109r— (; a•goo•ss ir' to•••' '- R•�.oo• Z b i•�o�T: i 1 0 � Q M '^ Z n ! LUT c. k° av 1t 3 Ulf'13•,O.Y d n •Oa oe•WOOL. .. u e0•!r 14-4 RDc.1000• w V r• e i 7 +� d ues•s.oo-w.�'� ' (Y. W 'IS—or '� u06-21.74-L RDA. _ Q' 7• 8 v • �` a. Si s l6.ts• %U 6. 7 e•� r . - 1. J O,•cN O� � 1mm rwx r" cos IM BILL. EXCUl ICE toss •MLs�.silt) ' f (1 t a+fst ra GPW is w8od lam adr i tar. WS 10 trod ssbtr "ralsaphs WAc ordl.na to itsa letters amd sabers.) MIZM7D0 BA12 a IMMURM • CM& C%Wf 41WWW P. 0. fw U7. &MIROet_�eeel. Caliloww" r ADi04:S:• __ Ifilm tfatl.n Jim. banicotta sawk, mu ftaosa 4. TItIS EkMJ 10M IS RB:4UCSM2 TO MQaT: Cosatr etioa of a swim and eacrias rttfaC Wt. C. LEGAL DESCKIPTION Or PROPERTY VHICH cmirIONAL cKes TIOM is Ta mmas '• partloe of Lot 173and all of Lot C is Tract j NO. C1,- of ibaatingtoa least. County of Orange, state of Califorsiao as per nap racord-sd la loot Ill. pqm U a It inclusive. of Kiscallaoeors Maps. Records of said County. h lots US sad 266 sa Tract 5I60. City of lbatingtoa leach. County of Oran". • •rate Of Califoraia.. 1 D. PRESENT '.ON110C OF SAID PROPLKrY: 1-1 L. PRESENT USi: :* PAOPEKTY !'.hG/OR BUILDINGS, IF ANY t Vacant property. i P. BKItY Dc.SC: 1P:IUN OF TYP:. ',ND &M-BEc C•F BUILDINGS AND/OR STRU%.TURES ' 6'H1.:H nR_ '. .. Ili: LOCAIEL ll .' . SUCH PROD-3ri. STAIT FAM PAMT NEW CC%NU.'T1' :; T: BE UNJ;;k7.1s .N Ai TER :;:KjITIUNAL E'CEPTION IS GRANT.L•. (It this t:wz cannot be uro tiered at tt•:d tlo�, so state aid RLae f ' reAsons r The proposed merino constructio- and related parking facilities are pottaraad after the facility on Lot 174 o Tract 4880. One (raw building is Plane" and will houet restroow facilities end telephone svitchssar. � 1 r t t _ .� _ ....A'_';-.w.rye..:;,•s°f►Qs�.��tJr7�y1�.1...,- M.w wwr�ta��""�"`w.,i-_"� C. Tlie:..2: 001�'ITtCTK*� JJSTit'11M� S1l.D �!'J'rIT?ClM. G��'':Qt: - 1. The fact that eke�"o",L w suss6Oe�i..ary Z.itiww of � cireswtancea are app luabla to the prepert7�fsvolved, w La Its tandod use, 161ch do slat awly sail to aft rp"Paty to the save sous am SMI&lasd as tot Ths eaattvetLos of the Wrina is dictated by the seed get *It" by VW*trass 1stt+ear reai,daata wu bore now"eritoet Lou. !ba saestewtus se Yeae ssrLsst ' Is r tatsorai part of the smalastw ferbo wt eK-11cort. i 7. That the pr+eaervscion and anjo7tseett of as» or sure subetautial frty riRhts,ar•e dependent v variance pon a is oxplai.ned q otiloows: Marine cosstruetioa is not presently included is aqy city aaniaq alassiftuttas. The wring con apt as proposed was part of the original aster flan. . The parting lot has boas divided as scorn for several reasons. It allon stage coaatructioa. The auxiliary lct need only be oonstructod Chas the full =*Iensst of *lips is built as ahown; as planned the design allow for thaw additional waterfront lots. 1 '�. Mar t1w Rrantine of said proposed variance will riot be materially detrimental to the. public welfare et Iajurtous to the property of improve:xmts in the distriet In wbich i sald property In locsttd for the following reasons: The mrina facility is later-dad to serve tao cou—nience and requiremosts if the interior lot owner. The parking areas will baLandscaped W fuse" as is _other areas of !luntingtom Harbour. • ' I�- ..',�'-�t� � .: v �. n, ,, '¢'?�ili�.ek;.� ;5�7�,.�?�.►�wr�4�' fy3, •s �M� ��� '�• �!�h�'1 7T� •�r�Tt7�ilit'V; -;� '"�1� 1�.t.N�1L; -nr•j't :�; .,ti l 'r .{,e.. DEB 1�1� • VY .t AV IL t L UM MO ;9"i fi]Ci t Cf ltl:: CITY OI O Xn* r.%M W:n I. C"J.6 OV= . KTI?ICMl roti aWkil-L A" ACE nQN .;USL tiAtiiAWX) do s+s:teo Oeaeh. Glitatrsis Oath �►s.arr !fL 19 M • �iJ Cit t % 18=t1n.. Commission Ciei atl • !lur.ti i or r+- .oh. WL(c rtt)s. Orr!L�.ye i lent •A-%& sigma, &,. ti . of yLoporty hereinatier descri0ed. hereby • rwbpectfully pettttot•+ ytxtr Hurwrable Soft to recommend to the City C3, acii o: t•va City of t tt:.tittFtar asset , CalifornLe, the grantieO of earlittomt oxceptlow t , the X-atrictt.,ae Uvosed Upon tba Oroparty by Ow Oierrict eta Orcina-oce for 06.e rsak.as sad. under the coaditiobs t set forth is f.11 ., the foilnwiny paW.•e attached hereto and wads a part tt.erecf. I. cwrty-fi%v a,-:.lar (25.00) fan -a temSored herewith. vaTy truly yours. • Wma aml= rLai= hddres+ *iAl� • �mciastm Mach. Calttoeala • )hotfa ti ,, SS1-SSSS • • � .n y�{�.r: . 4w r+ 1ayl � k� -.p��S.' 't•�,T, ,4•h 's°"' �2 \ � 1 r y ' r.t . �,,ar wA•~ `� y .�`�TY• �� �� bV �� `�'�'� •�'', .�ya�"�,. e at`s 3��`' F r a� �"� • K),'yp ,� "y!' ,=ri�� � Qt r rrk bti R•..t''» � t' ^y ,,t a .. '� ♦ •. Yb1.ii, a 1iJPJ .qg, i r"• t'r r �1 Rr..B i� +v•4 •'j+. Al yC 'tr•, rat . 14P=V'M r.'',a, v��,t (•`. . yr, 2 i r Y .. s.. � ycb �� - � •+iv.� .• ntl�A-,�'st;� .. .�;' f -,r�n"t0`'�} 3''�; ['4 � "`� a *' ..._ , :,.-,.'�' i�: 'tine• q r �! .�. t •;'►:y �Tf L• - r ', . ft� ,.+`S.y7 `'��. ~ _��C� •. .,r y �'- .)T.i,� t t ��y+�� L�`• - e�•U-�„!b � � +j S-+��l -r e ✓ � �•. -or t-�.��:1. .2 '✓rvrla' �' =' Tt.' •_ya y►'�'ta iv�C- 4�i: - - r'.'i� -\, '4 i ~ f *•:'. a }►A yF"'• �i�. '�.. '., 'cs� -- t' �r�v!•�:. �� - �'+ t�K`�.' "` � , q +S7 -.jr-- {� � .,. - r.- � • . � � - - r ��� r :S'~ � A'-e - r Sb.• i aBL� � �, r� kC,�� 3-�- � '\' ✓`' �' •} .: 7 .,.1 o i�r;�, "•'•y... •'• �I • w� - � - gq1 «;.�� �-s ��'..Y,• �- '�`�` ?�t' �.. � tt, - ;,i. -1P •.� ar�,.,"r •-' .{N, J :r' � � � � � � - 400 -�- s, y. � �y."�'r/i,~{� Yt..'F �;t-j {fie.�`C•'Y .,x.:� �,ys,�• ...�f'-. j; f f, ,bN � - ♦ ter r y ';.,-rr. „ : � . x ` s,' •.'• :. �. tl Y r wow IL y .-� si.� > `-►' ls ie opt '�4�:`ht ' .• '`. � •� '. .� - ar i! -•Sta i •:r _'� , � � _�� +1qi -tom ml .. ;..4 T %fir ...� ,.. � 4 y�ji��. '.iti•.- "� ya'�g�� �` f. �.^' ,r-?i.. /d..L�;t,���"`' �' � �\r.-.9.i jr.. Y fix r1. l r �,✓ r �,Sy`7L, 7" •�y{ 7�:{.•r Il*.e's I • -b r' d• h9r' a t{t i r .. •S 3•I' Y fr .V t-. - '� J'. {: 'r: •- -,,' y ) ,t� •j�y+dC•ia . `��'� -a- � s r � � v '. � A A-�•�rd{ t,.r � --it: ij�•- . a'. ♦ 5�j. 1,• � _ � 'Ir vi/��.;i'.a: :-• qq Vy � � . �t�,rr "�. � �j e, 'r- '•fit •.rl �' .!-t -.,r y � t y`, tief _*.. 'i _ ._ � �\,. .tea - �:. � � r�' iii *!,� s' do�.. d •�,ja�.�;�. f�. � j _ *y;�-.�t ea 1.r r. r - I. �a. a"'��r' 'c.� -; � i-'t+`�r"�'' ,� '-�y�''�' 3* '� 1.�LrA ;: ""r` r'{r•.'�• '�r,�" �..r... a . ►. �"liI r �-i � r ry, r v A r - �► Ya7r s:� -� � , i _ - - � - r- -a- -? .}... �v.,. �+YY•- _ L -' ,.fir .•]. 4i`;-.. _,'� • _ ,.+t4 m,.' rc:g. a fl .: r :_�`. ,� �.. tt� � may. _ ._�.....�.�� « � � iUD. •f .♦;.:,h. !.A tyt-.r' •}�` t. - - 6:ri•J `T�t ' :. -f � .'. 4 ..'�: .�, r.- _r,-:�t '.i•. t Jai a.y �•. - t .,' �,"� D •-t 4V- ♦ t Al., � c `s (T. f(' f:';. t /, _� 1'IJ n.:• V x ! a - �r 4�. - �`.+ .` -,KM •� '•rLs, �. ;•�,�.f v � 'aAr ,X� �'�•� - •. �y ;it 51i�- �t �s1�r�,�b �w :... l k .t�r • y •; q 1: -fJ y_ t •, r�+ J� - t.r p l►,j �'!.. ' ,� ••► � cY: _.1 r�_ Y.,�1S�, i 5:' q cS`fn t/'. IA � .q.1t :, "4 -i`:y •fr: i vrw _ , 7 .1�Y,•}• 'C'Y t R. .Y r 'f «Y• �T�Ma' 44 • y�7 �d .T 3t•°53,,�/' :�1W c4 f�' _•fir 1'• I_ r•t — ` l ti '� I, � ��t� �` �^"�•'�' T .jam +a41' ,7,*kno �Y1�T. �3♦t Mr•,i `1 +. •tg: 2.fF��. t. _ ,ice ,!. t � .. ' (�. I, t F r- �r�tht �•7 R.,yyC1 1 _ , '' ,ti. :� J` `.�`1e`�t'L�jh� qr� � � '•o:S.• it��C"��.'Ar�O;� is�.,4 +-�_:��.YVI�r r d>� �.•. j M�;^�•;f� ,fit `F� • ;�•-. °' $ / �- ;: _�r r�n•'.ii.d.'•• .,p1t, .. i' 4 h�.r o •1+- ,. r --ltC, ;.y `y it 3- Y - r,,";••b i:. f�,;._�• rr +•-1jlr" r' s.'��',' -1 `� 't9t� rA.•'�t/ ,r.. .f. •;l{o; f`• •h s .Y r• thpi,. • -•4•-T� }� A f.'t'id�.Ir r�"l::•.! �Y f ' .�.•rot�•.T,�i-i. �R• �lyd'�If`r: , t :.q; � • ._'�•:;: i Y 8' -,_ •''y•y_ t S �'"' .r �•'lt.;.•:�^ - .°w,' . } 1 r f '7'�i'.-f�N •S� yr , nab may] - L `. ' ._ r�, A'-:r .✓' I,;./.� �y '.c.�,�'•�'tY��'. 1� '��'d•p•.t V irq' -[t`ii,ill lhT <- 3R .�.1 �f R- 'l•Y� ' F .� y r 'rT � Yp :�it� r' R•'Y•.`.•�1... +T_�'�.'ti�..'�4•.'7�a+ �'� J�r" ��C - r���� Y ++�•�. � I �'.� ,. a � .:• FIP .' .�„•,,!• 'r ^fy ��yd L L'�L �'f'1Q - ��.!) y '"{PM 4 �_.� .:�•' r ♦ /'`' � rtl�r!A„7j'C• � •. �'�o Y_-r , ,IM,. g• w{ a "1•��� s ,,r%' �`7c v ��w�+v`�c_- � `.'�4 t�,� i^ 3� � ,. •-t; I�. -7+r �, f., r_V ",I� ,3., ; 4+. i ,a; ° Yr ',t 1;1'-r' T._ •` + � ~� 4 � L, .. �. .�., t •'�;. :�a�� y.�) f ��.��' -r is 1 ��.w? cC 1 A, �. '� �* - !Sr � >M1•t r r -t 'ht,�•' 7- 4- '�'�- •+1�t 4F�' .h?. rt• i '�L.i/ !Z. 4•tom'' + -}• S�,/.•t':r"' •j"r9YF•: L _�:l ;� p }R�•r•4� 1� i w 11F {trr��i�1.Sit�►:a�� -�-'v) `1'fF,( ' - ' • t-t1F ,�r3. 1Sr�. �z•�, A ems. #� i� f�n * -���A' �4� FyY •Sr � l •� �li�f ry,•� ri _ �. 'R -. � � ,4• r s Sj. �1. -� � r v. `v�f� - ... _� ��. Z{� �1,.���=!(+b,�j'� r>j}r '�v j_s�� ��t�4>..,I'7s.{'�'�-�1 yt� F'# ?�� `g,. � �p�,k� '"M. ti,a � ��.A��i{g �<AF•it�'1�r �~{'tV 1 Mt ;yt .��Lri'p:r' ��t �r�i'�RF a .� �e::�.Y�6ta�I�„r E 1;��l i�«�'f �S+. '.,j� 1�y-.(,�'+��aYPi.: �.l+j�"�."`� .•/t'�� f TT J a ' ;r '>t -� M `i .� E�r S k1 a{ F 't �R �Y• o �..^ ..Nk .. ._ - t`,yS t'�}- p.. ri .. ti e r,•J -1.a ?rY Q'"sy +t -.� ,.ti" '�er: ,.: �t y' -.YY 4•.. �2 ,, : • � � � - $ -.. �'i �,+J•r�y ,f 7T a'!wr,�x• • .2 _�t-. ,�, _��•.��� - �t+��-:•+.;��y�.� 1� •,�. � 'W, �; ��- .�'S i•.i. .y��:�/ .ate.r•r� t:t. i•+# J,y} re _ psyS"'lC7 9;t f @, c S' :}'"�c•C'¢. _�-J'. . t7 .i �•. - fy a '}- .i t. �•. �.J` t . .'• , .. •- G t �`:•'1 �yT•I.Y..,J -ads'k :y'!t!�; r,E -��.- n ."71, k.a•��"t '18�8'i M*�� '�t �: i �`.�x�-•�;,, �,:o- ter viz � x,"++l .- f 'o ` • " t•+ry �4 r, �� �" � � �it ' 1'Yw ) Y a t.rl.� ti S r/ ' p iOr • t frR, .:yi.'!;v'?"�r`."�' ' rZ,'•`1"'y .i�i�J. •"' y". o'f1S��•+pL'17 �-t.' -�ia w,t;,y�ih '4c ;'7••• {c rq 'p+j;��:;t' ,j;� ' r ,t .. � ,� �'',.f, �r•._,,, -c`�':' ;F _ "r .y C 'd'I .. � a 1k �yl. �' ,�,(f J,J'`j, ,�p,�,' "9".r �•�;� '�".�-��svr P� r � f ,:'4� 1. �• ; ' � t a." '•�, A.�. 1\.IL: ,,.;' 4 '�.�.' " .yy, .. s � rtr J � t '..,M'I �• � w,' r ,3e t ri.j7} f.•ri' � r�Nl �r ,�; ,t '�•• � �♦' t :.'f • � r ■� r l :'i'fJ f{� y, ```��t�� ''� ri,ry .'r,� .�y '�.Lht L f� •4l �. '^�� � y�' ..,�•��?f'-rr��! j's' �'r� rt: �P,^(l�4�, � i•,n � !!.r\,i.�''•N r} ilk I I ? , � - f: j '�tF.:srt.� .[¢„Ir' �•�R'��' + r. `'•..+� E.�' � � r�"A•, . ! �.yI ,'•y tiro i;, +. a k ' e_ . I�/ A ..,w �'c?Il. + t; ,t, ,r yl + T '.5�. •4,;�qt ',s y: �j,n. � •t �'. + �,: � � ',NJ.. ) t'i`,; !'.`� '�, ,, is, y •r i �fn P �, r f"l y: .`+' � s e»� I cP 'aT, � I�� r � ... ,; .. f ,✓v is ti'. 'Y',d �,x4`� rft,�' r i�. v... H `t''. r 7 fa'�}�w �"'� , '.J.. , '•�d w G �ii"„fn YIrrf t f,, rrt'. {'�.��i,+ �1+• � #+ � � 'rM 'A 9C•!I'� t � � '1'1�.>,\ t •.,r,l ' �'� t' i ,r t' � rl�. h•r+{`�,Y.' '•�;�`.• t/; •,' 't'' X =n';q ::'} �t4 •R. ??,� . . . � ,, I. �Y 'y:�r�.�,t �'" J, ���~ !F '� '• 1� •'•� � 1 Ly,,�f• w,y. <' , aye. .},r. t. k' ,�r� P• .• , ♦rJ', �,�:a '.�y� H .{fir I. . •� „ : . � J s�"•!i'd•, :.7 .� � xs;,r� +F 41'_�p�r*�•,rs!'.��"il�*;q$.��G �S S'i't� �!' J i�.F;- �'!��`�"Y J'��^ . ,,': �C � f 1•� „� 5V�' t R G;�M i'T� y�.f 1 7i +� 4 t :� 1,IF��7.�'K'kY7 F 1 yai,y ,Yby t I lop. l ,t . d' ' '�ty4t .VZ, �:'•. A '•ffi•a; , '., ,f.$ 'fi g,:a! iSw,< aL� + ' '` •!'•' ` .p ti ' l `•r �i • 'I n c'..•t �} 'ti A•^fi�+tF ,�� ,' sp �� �, ,tisy''�� t,�j„ '.��:{., 1V" :`1�' • I , 1, a,��~ t?J^a I �.,p"�:i 1J'�e� '>� 1�R,! 'I.:�7 � �:''+.I r 4 , `[ h Y r �j t f �H.. 'F ;, T'; r•' t 1�I.,,Y, + �� r' r � J '� •'�arty � '4 +� ;;= a. k ';� � e4'" 'r *f -*:•rot' ,� �! �7 '.�' t� r- ,iP �« s., `7 •J'��'a. t�'�":ti �kN t a' �:�7r „1 � ,��1�y' ''�yF.. S `A.+.� '` �4�G M t � 7+ "� '4•:c� b.`v i°.r i .•'•��i•�,' t1-� fit' 71 ► ,.. �M. � � a �.. '�tp 4wi s�1; �; � ��, ; ",' T .:f�l' '� ✓�" Mr 1 f "� ' .�;::i A T � r,.,y .I�'• .�•:.. f4r�. rtt `K '�`. �� , o ^.4X�E iyJ� { �.',. '� �5�+�,`' iuPwO f .� l'.�'r�M��f'�`r G {J� '• , dA, •! ba. ,I�. 'r .�1 .• .i. ;. T'� �r •.r r( PAW yrr' '1i,,, r.l'k � a r,y..•.,' tir „Y7►�,� �'t .fir � .:.. �• ' + r :.4.., .�'rT""- K►� >�` S. �. k' i�ry'.r, l��� �M V� � ' • t ��1p ..;•. ' )) ,'v.. ,.�,r( '� rr1+', f��ya�: :T!i'yrT• J� �11,..u4 � 'ryy'?K y�i•�t -Tryet�r .�°'�Cr. �' �'�'� .i'.�� : . •I. 1 I t�� �'!]� � �tl'�;,d� � '�.'N .� 'Ysr r� s "}ahlf r..l. �'4�,` ' ., 'r:, �j,'�?�' a, ,� ''t+"•'�l'I a �,,"�►'y � �: �. i,� t>t,�� w R't �. '+' .I �`I ��' �'yt4rt�t;'NI 3�,^ ' l 'l•. •.r J^J�� F :.y � � ��'�t ['•^,j , ��i.r`�/`'�y '{ � t S 1-4 ;� ,,'. 'M FQ yy,, (5ri{,'S��7 7�Lam' y �Y� +•R� i � , 1 .:t?Sa ,r' 1 ., 'Y ;t). i. t,'"� Y lid A� ✓►: 'i F r' ,.t<r.{. f� �. ,I.� 1'' ,� �� 3+'YE��A, 93r,{t :�'� �'�`.;,R$' y.^ll" 777 #ti�t.•'r.• yr"�'!L �'5", � 'l�V a 4 � r„ rJs �t ` •� '0; ,:y.,. ? �.• 71 �•J yt �� 1{� 1 y '� f Merl G: .�\ r:`' •t ;' r 7•'y{� •,ta''.J +,1� �a� •t �� !`,�''t,+'r •�' 4 A� .ice`. ` t!1'V ��:4 .� t�,��ll�"!I, �'ok i• � r .... i,l'�'"*"f�y:Q.',L�'^� .. .;'d :�.4�' N L.fl* `Y. r 1F .'f'��.r. ',lfi t. , c ; i ti¢a f * ' li tYq `t.� !r i^i ir'�`,}y' t�n.j 1� i 1r ►..t, F fi a «.,' `� Irr•r wb r'Ri }yy�'Pi�.Ae4; 'i }tf' Y� t rt a «fir r G, `Z'r 5.F +9 f�� �1 i ��' fc �• bFht t•.`��• r .. ,+a': '�y, a h "45 1"..r.. < ` �r r • � 7'y r r r Rt. � n�j^,n � u, v +. � ,r t, ��'S r a , S .S �r� 'r. ! I '+jti'�v ;{ sy 0 5ix�r. a la4•' '' ., '^ :+a�.S,:: I r, 4`4 "j'N".? !i� lye r.t' •r r �, • n r M ,r.: Sys.;, , 10 wr /7� + ,r� :, :t s , ' > , •ter• '�r... a ''+' C yr T'�'•.r r.! 1;Y'� I. y 'r }r!q• !. F.: Y' YF... .19 <.a..it • » r•• 'FYI' 7'' fi� :'Vtr@`, ],M"' ,"'I � ,�. l�. �' '. .j, .. .. r n;.�. .� � . �r� r'pj�ar e.�o'g P At.13�'�.sl� 'rr�,`.+ �,F,.F'►i,��r� �. +:'� �'ty' �4. ��1 •r ':t� � a �,,�: v,�,� h '�, ,yy►����f ;g76rti"^e.. �; F1�a' �� a k;' 1?,• � r E�Y�s • :i r•r � rh}1 �{Y;c� +b.tkro �t��, '•`yynfi,�f;.1 ��� :+�' i , � �' ' � '�' ," �•FM1� ���$ ly �Jti♦• iyr�y�i��' "�, 'yea � •k�7 i• '''R r� ' .)i�i'� sf" ! ,� ,�� '» ({'JQ• •#,j:,.. •�: 0'�,r�:�,'�."�I+� � '�: ��r '�`'rt�t .t .��`.• 1f ;+' tC'�lr'J'f'�,'�! a ( iT' 1 4 . . -� �►� a •Y•n:. vr�r rpy� �� a��) �r ,�j�`rR' „ ;'+��yh r ; � } "� i h O t.•'w r 0 .4� Jry Z" t �� 11:: .. '1 't y>7� � � � .f' p� ;b,{•°' tt,, y �:' �rd 14�( ;`a '�'C4f�.�}, � dv.1V��r�dr' •• a'a}' ' <�' �� A" ,� P.v � ►'t a M .� � '�.�'+ r � .!� � ' f~ 1 t. n ?/� 2}, a r r' 'k'''L/ x?. r ;, '' �'� ,• .r ,fI 'A �.; � '�•� .91 r Au L } '� „ r, `ey.^'M.' � ,fie YfSe�' a A' b•e"r'".'it �� ;:. ati f. {� .11 � :�. 7.j � VfN•.� !', K,y+ ,>''��.J4,{'�u,'Yy`*,, `4 '�jl r tJ, r � �t tr �y, , h'. -r t-' 1 � ` vff" +;,r� t �,�,.. 'a`(r", 4'i: 'f�',�f�• ,�' r�.�►.0 Y+ ,'.� '' 'r b P = Iob .g .: �rA �t..tf�,t4'i`, ,"il� .�1 nwl 'r {y ( 4 c' �),y,,, r� F j ►•r; ' •~ F O w. •.9 µk�r K ar `+ +Kim ' y t '7E1 st �'r" .�� • � �S '...A N } ..S It +,C�jI}�4;'*�( ,���'° ?:ier •,7T i �„J,� a �' tiP ai h �, C: � � ►"►� � � `,1 ��t.�rj. �'11�•,'! y`tv^�• �w'�dc$. rk� '�' ^• ri��y��AR f'Y1•' r'� ►a � t, .� r rriL Z1 5l.}r J:y�f �• �`,�' / +. 'rb ' '� 'j t� c. �'� rt � j�. ";a ,��y�i`��,e•'��`",,�rr�: y,ii LY 1 '}>l; rst� p 'rr� "�W , •:.) '��,,,�,,trlj�.. , V!^ ..ate ••�ta~''• �+cf"3 ra •.a. A 7 7 , r ` + * �# ti .ati ail' a! r Y.?I V 1.44 ., a ^�,^ Nw�. �,' �k�yr-��y`r�R ,,�,j#�e�'�"t',.,;ti'"•�y��}.ja 49p�' [��,�i � ','.;�+^u�fw,�'�el• 4i 7 r+�,��may, `} 7 r>f� w ti1!�' ':A''. r �,'�i� `r '�'S+�y r� ;a m .•S'1••g.�w J�k� •'di5' w'C I�.. '�.� s; . • _ •'�.•.q ar• ? ca ��,c,�'r�' �F :3i%` � ; t`'�1•' � 'S.i+'Sr ', ,'� I •!'' r y a•p � a p t i 7 7� ,� 1'' 1 y f.�. ,'�r n $4::. ,, �{�.�'�� Y �, 1 .M,,6 n t a .r' .r a.i.• i +yF{'• ;;►•Sar•�il ,. r '�Y y r: , • y {�;(� n .3r � ar.;•,.$y'�N; MJ�Jl�yL i. r,yLM+Mt, �' KS' a{ r �,�� ..r.. ' r k, .S' t. +•y�� uy` + k.�V'�r'�!�'1��' <f« �i¢'' 7:r ) .,7r,ti!~d s�3'+t{', ��i ��r P M `� yr . '•e,R.4'.y r� ,� -!' as 'ri. ' . N r��.ti� r Fr��a �$i ft.a.R��t It.' �7S�r .r `6f>ir tL 'i is i � .J',fJ•;�t �4a�1,'�'a§�•` ,s�i `�Y•:..rs y :;d. ��1111 ' .'�,: '� �,. -. :,� .' '�.U�j�r t i .. r 'ice • y � 'r 'y •�.'�� As' ?•h{r5'l�.. r.1��Pj4!t"'yr '`f•,�r,,�•.,s4'Y�,.�f1 �}l-�t�w�Z, h'"�"t Y`'p�r � � �1 .p!i ': • �� rt Y > i t*, .S' rayl• t '4 (, r��,t 1�f.e oi4 re,+� i'.r .1� a°•t S�« * •.1t i 4t J f P Y't Mir r 1fcr ?�•rt h� 4�Y �{ °H>{iK�'�'�,;. e"•�'.�yJV; ��' .•. .1 �a h t ' ; :, y"' . 4 ;f;r +>+` �' °y ,l, r� ,F's � . try e. � a.•'t�, �' e,. . .., :. �._.+..,....,k .Jr'r1�'a�.''`-.�y3t..'���i�`; �:.+St.rr..fi5'J�.`.�.��..�.i.�'.�.7�. }jY.:.tJ?, �}.�rlr.•.S1rS#�i. :.�..j .a . �� �� :i x._. 1 rUD134 AND DP Wa :ate Attorneya .at Law � r 615 South ?lower dtsei! suite 1201 1 Los Angel-ps, C4liiornia 9001E 4 624-1001 y .. Lora_ sya for P*titioatr. i SUPERIOR COURT 00 THE STATE OF CALIVORNIA h7O)t .THE COWNTY OF ORANGE 11 HUYTINGTON HARBOUR. CIORPORATION, j. a corporation, ) • ::'.: 13 ." .. ) . 211l20 petitionir; � : . 13 ! THE; CITY OF HU'7TINGTON..B$ACN. :` r 16 LTC. , et al ) •' .FINVIVQd OVIPACT AND ! CONCLt1111M_ :QT LAM 17 1Wepnsl4alitS ji 1 It WILLIAM S. .PURCELL AND WILLIAM } A. ,CItAIG, . r Intervenaze: . 1 22 This matter crape regularly before, this Court on May 100 23 1974, for hearing._ Thomas F. Midfield III Of EN A�iD.:a1 a 24 appeared as attorney for petitieh;1 Mill Mavis, Ospa'ty City 23 n Attorney appeared as attorney for respondents 'a"_Upse -beats" 26 1 appeared as attorney for the intervs+aors. !ha'Yeawd of.'tbo 27 administrative proceeding having been received '.at* oridelte :4ad 28 examined by the court, additional evidence haviaq bees~ reoeidied ..,a.:y^'� .. - _ 7 �•-y�!; F�, _.�. r_ s R^ -� ..t.R x 'e�' -` t - i7 ne- � - �.. ..:�•- '„Q"ca t`.= - `.,. ti• 'r .r �yy";. .� ..;s t. 1 ! by tiro i7eurt. arguments•havin,7 been presented, and the macLer 2 �' having been submitted for d4cisiotle..she Coast.:Mkp. the .following ' FUDIMIS OF FACT a I. . Petitioner,.Nuntingtdn- Urbour Corporation, was at S a all cimQa mentioned 1n the petition, and is, a corporation duly 6 organised -and exlstinq• tinder and by viMe 41.Us :frills_ of the . 7 State of DsLwar and 'authorised .bo do busitAOs ..iA lAe,,State of • California. • . 2. At all .tiOes mentioned herein,•. the City of Huntingt F to jrach was,.. and now is, a charter city and municipal eor!x,ration I1 organised and existing under and. by virtue o the laws of. the 12 State of California. . 13 3. Petitioner.; at'ail tION imeatlwisd. in.4Ni petition, la has .been,. ind is, -the owtor of Lot AU i i '1!rsart tmo. 4180, .City of 15 nuntington Beach, -C Mt 0 ,0 f.:_ita1 "o! Califosnia as per. y 16 map recorded in look 172, 'paoso 14:to -19 inexnsive.'; ef utiecell- 17 aneous sups, records �of said County., and pf.a severable and. Is assignable easement .and 'right.of.way in ..o7ror itcross; upon end 19 �, through the entirety of Lot C. in said-Tract'-'No.. 4880, for the 20 purpose of constructing, maintaining, ;using*. operating or renting 21 thereon, free of "y rental 4.4tges by the '.City of Huntington 22 Beach, docks, piers, whartrer; alipe; _sasPs,: floato landings and 23 other mooring structures and footiags, piIin" and ancillary 24 structures for bulkheads_located on adjacent properti*s.of 2! i; Petitioner, and 4ockhouses, clubhouses, marine fuel. stations,- 26 ` restaurants, hotels and other structures or.Duildugs .of say 27 nature or typo for aquatic, recreational, fishing,- 'boat iaq.,. oaring or harboyr, and ancillary purposes bt all Rinds. Feb - .tpt <.re cesc; ar .b,k !"r «•swr rzr -> .. - • the forequinf) structures and' things .to be ldc6tods- constructed,. 2 maintained.. . used, ooratod. crreatmd. forI e pCofit-or. aut for prof. it, for commorcial purposes or noncommercial p4rposei, and for 4 private purposes and uses or public purposes &'ad 'uses in the discretion of the corporation, or its successors and assigns. 6 The underlying fee interest in Lot -C was. dedicated to Respondent 7 City by the Huntington 14rbour. .CoMpration in .1962. Aot iisa I sonetinws hereinafter referred. to'as the. Davenpori Marina. 9 4 4. Aci%pondent,- City Council of the City of Huntington 10 1jea0i consists of Mayor Jerry 14athey, Councilmen litenry Duke, T.W: i. .11 isartlett, Donald D. S.hipley, N.. jack. Green, Alvin M. Coen and 12 !1 councilwom.on Norma B Gibbs ' and at all times mentioned in the- potitipn, has been and now .is that governmental b6dy ultimately Ia responsible for the 'administration. of. this zoning ordinances and 13 regulations of the City .of Huntington beicb and authorized under .16 Division 9.of the .Nwitington -b"ch Ccdinaace Code to hear and 17 decide the questibn'of who th'ar.'.or..'ndt a g.iva6 cQndtional 'excep- ... ... ..... Is tion should be revoked. 19 1! S. On or about May 19# bS*41k* remPO ndent City' -granted 20 Conditional Exception (Use.Variance) Wo..�107 to the Huntington 21 Harbour Corporation. This Condltional .Excoptton permits the 22 construction of a Marina .and marina parking. lot on Lots C and 173 21 of Tract 11c. 4890 in that water qriented residental dorm uni ty 24 known as Huntington Harbour. '. This Conditional Excepiion (Use Variance) No. 707 contains' no provision,ion, condition or limitation'. 26 requiring any or all of the work authorized thereby to be per- 27 formed within any specific time Wait. tote 211S .and 266 of'TrAwft.'. L 28 5360, although originally a part of the applicai4en -for 'Conati O� -"�*XW, U Exception (Use' Varlaswef .m6s 707i'Ance-.40t 3 by the Exception as actually granted 3 6. in or about July 1964, Petitioner obtained lromthe 4 United States Army Corps of. Lhgin*ers and the City of Huntington Beach those permits rwcessary to. OutbWISS tho.'66"UNOtIAOS of 6 the marina and parking lot includiaq.:tbe geotgoom facilities 7 authorized by Conditional Exception No. .707. In and 'af tor July T.. • 1964, the Cerporation, in good 1 alth and In rellande. upoh the 9 granting of Conditional exception. No.- 707 and the -other pemits 110 Issued by the City and by. the Corps of Engineers., constructed -the 11 marina parking lot, to 'provide paiking for the marina as Authorized 12 by Conditional Exception No 707, co"tructed the rwMiced 13 restroom facility, installed, niscessAiry-4tiliti6s, cofwtructed the t 0. -14 marina bulkhead and installed sevoute"lift. ' 11of. and Is operating and using the marina ik#d 'the Parking -.0t. ItAiR crac Of 16 this work was in exoass of our hundred and twenty thousand .17 ($120,000.00) dollars. - 8 7. in. or about Septea"r 1967,..the Cit. Huntington 19 Beach issued Petitioner & .harbour.'Permit authorizing the construc- -jan addition* 20 tion and.installa.tich of gways. and slips foe. I boat slips. In or about.t1w. last thres-sanths, of. 4967, Petitioner 22 in good faith and ln:roltince an Conditional Xubertion' (USA . 1 23 Variance) tie. 707 and upon the harbor permit Issued by the City, 5 24 did construct and install the gangways and nine (9)..boat. slip* • 25 at a cost of In excess of nineteen thousand, eight hundred 26 ($19,900.00) dollars. 27 1. on or about March 10, 1971, the Department of the- 28 Army, Los A"elon District Corps of ftVinsers Los 1 which authorised potitoner to. construct and install. forty.-eight _ (48) additional .boat slits in DaveMOrt Mas006 "On,or 1100 ti 3 June 21, 197Z,. S espondent City. of:14untingtoa..8aach Lamed.° a Harbour Permit. No. 518 which authorised the.construction4" 3 installation bf docks and the forty-tight (49). additional boat u` 6 slips previously p p y authorised by the:Corps at AM11's.._ Stan 7 June 21, 19T2 and )November. 14, 1972, :petitioners in.good. taint 8 and in reliance upon,Conditional Exception No* :707, ;the_ Corps of 9 engineers Permit, and Harbor Permit-No. S18 eutesed into a to contract for the construction and installation of forty-eight (48) }1 It ' additional boat slips, and the pilings .and headwalks .to which the 12 slips would be attached, installed the pilings aA'! 0acke or F 13 ' headwalks necessary to. the installation of the additional slips, 14 had manufact,u'ed-each of the .fe .ret#ht (41) additional slips IS at an off site location prep aratory. ao their being floated into 16 place and thus completing the IYtitta. 17 The contractual obligation. incurred.by V titiottar in f.:. 18 reliance on the Condition.,) Exceptign and tiff 1971%72. permits 19 };obligated the Corporationto pay in excess of one hundred and five 20 thousand, six hundred ($105,600.00) dollars.: The work .actually it rperformed as of November 14, 1972 in reliance on Conditional 22 .Exception No. 707, the 1971 Corps of Engineers..parnsit and the 23 '.City•n Permit No. 518 had a cost of in excess of. seventy-six_ 24 thousand, tiiirV; tw-) ($76,012.00) dollars. 25 9. On or about November. 14, .19.72, Respoi7deAt City of • �� . {Huntington Beach issued a cease and desist order Casgot 27 rdering. it to cease further :.irk on Dsvepport i rile' lentil �{ nvirontnentai impact report had beef prepas's0 as requ.. ; a ah r - - 4 F 'iY ., K .. F 1 California Environmental .Quali#y Ant of :174nblio :Nesmiurce►s 2 Code 21000 et. seq.) and the quldeliats for tM irpl*i4ntatton .of that act adopted by the C1ty. .. 4 to., orior to lw0110 s I ,..117' "titio"r-had expeiie e 3 1 n excess.of two hundred:8nd ninet.:A thoua44Wd,:-folio hundred -and i thirty-two ($4l9'2;2.00).•dollarf' 0 good .taftb am. is. reIL&WW 7 upon Conditional txc"tion Ho. .?07j, .and had•.000a.trtiated:_the parka - its► �. . .. . i ' lot to serve the ene6ww w+rin ; .had: constructed the restroom 9 facility for the marine,, had mnstrutted anCinstalled. all of the ' 10 bulkheads, •A1in9s, headw;ilks.. ..9angnays ,pAd,_brows for the entire. 11 marina, had constructed. and lirsta11ed donnly-nin• 129) .boot. slips It and had wanutactured and cast ea 'O!. the +tdditioosi. f4stY-sight., -�` ' t 13 (48) boat. slips and was ready, dillinq and: ible. to install said ; 14 slips and. •• late the W' 1A a . ... -gyp venpurl.�asiw., ... perioq of .102. 1s months, petitioner constructed .tvinty-all le-`.(�9) boat *Iipi in li DavesmpOrt Marina. 17 ll.. On or prior. to Janus 21 1#74.,. pft$tionler. formoll k It requested that the respondent .Bwftinyton Deaah. City Council �r 19 rescind the cease and.dosist.order ani.-ahldl/ 6omplietion•of .the aenprt Maria (Lot Tract R .' ai AtriothatZfl . 21 a date the City Attorneys office of the City of Sunur ton .Beach }� 22 had correctly ruled that neither.the state, law mr the City...: 23 guidelines required the preparation of an .Environmental .tmp&cmt 24 Report on the completion of the marina. 25 12. On rebruary 19, 1974, Responosnt City Council at its regular meeting held a public hearing'on the.questloor,of Whltlyt s W 6. .27• to rwvoke Conditional Exception (use.Variance). No.. 707 .and 'N .2 close of. the hearing voted 4-= to revoke the Conditional y- r • - -t!:aaa •tar- -J -. -�S -. 1 shay l 1, upon order of the City Qsuboil, liia�sdislily-ao�snvs _' actions, proceeding Of ptpoeedi"s .tor tho �tssMeik, tpiogal sad 3 enjoinvent thereof Is. the. pannir. provided by 16i. and shall tak such other steps an4. ahall apply to such avert or courts ,as may havo 'jurisdiction to grant.iud relief as ,i►i11 absR�.: Ma emove i such building, sts�ature. _or use gad. sustain e2d eaioin aujtt J 1 person, firm or corporation- from atti ;` iA bgildi Pe � � � Uri oft 0• . M• t moving or maintaining any such building or stsuctuts or uai,ny any property contrary ..to the provisions of this Article. 10 failure to abide .by ,and YeithintlY coapl,p rith. any and all . 4 It conditions that may be attached to �the granting of any Condition& Vy - ,,.: 13 Exception pursuant to. the provisions of this trticle.snall con 13 stitute grounds for .the.,,revbeetioh:.oi,.said.Cq�dillonal Exception _ 5 14 by the City Council All Retssdies providi4 Jot basgia slwli.be 15 cumulative And not oxclusiva*` ti .. Each b the foregoing' dectiosmls�.of tbo..thmtington''U461% 17 ordinance Code were valid_and is oftent.at alh timer. relevant to, K. 2 z'T lS this action. , �;; z 19 14. The findings pt the ;City Council Of trine: delay.. under. 20 the provisions of Section. 9837.1 is .not supported-by the. weight 21 of the evidence nor by substantial ovialnos in tbs light of. the 22 whole record. 23 it. tntervenors williasa F. Purcell and William A. Craig .` U are each taxpayers,. residents and property owners La." pondaAt 25 City of Huntingtun beach and each reside. in A :waterfront ham :LA 26 Huntington Barbour In _iaanediate proximity to site uVenport Marina r Lack intervenor is a person who has an Interest in thi latter r litigation is this action, t Y R �gs� s .� - -. - � � y t-. - } ,. r ,_ ♦ -t Y��`ey.r'aye .}} - ;�;a �r ' ,-Y""``�- ' _s.1 A _ K f. 3 •hts'°�y ',�. t y4 4e . ...n...�._.......aat=a.e.or'�w.J,..,.....y...:.s,.. . ..a�.,ac.�ea»a.►::J ies ,.r...:� '�ii'-r.. 1: 16� In Its:Application for Conditio"! "PtLO-- (Use 2 - Variance) Vqq :707-If pdt4tIWwX VOpM4AtOd; dt1%at.:.4hi'-.ApplA cant 3 willinq and able to. Carty out tM..putposas for which the 4 condition&! Vxceptlon .ia soughtj that he� will' ProomA to do 60 4 with6ut Unnfidessory delay." 17. TI-.0 VI ty Council of the City ai .11miltington. Beach co,n-.. . 7 ducted a public h9arLng an the revoc.stion of Coridi.t Loni 1 9xceptio 4 707 on rebruary 19, ISM 'Pettitioner appeared indpartiCLPAtOd 9 and offered evidence -during said:public 'he at inq.' Riespondent rity to Council at its meetihq .follow*bo'th*,.F*bru&Fy.Xt, 1974 action. It revoking Conditiorial..Lxcep.tioii. 70.7.-4 ..... ... ... iWrov*4 nutars. at that . - , .. ...... .. .. - facts from the 13 meeting setting fortti.thim ioll6wil;g 'timiagis 13 evidence presented' at gaid pibll-�:�' 14 ."1. Th-at U66 ..Variance ?01 was, granted.. to.-SuAt'lligton Harbour Is Co.rooration in t1ay� 1.964 .far se"ntrAl I" �t slips in the. 16 Area known As 64016 17. 20 That from May'lig 4.- 11ovaimbe'r 1972''"Iy Ovonty-�nifte. boat *lips were t. FdOu"t 3 That a ceai* .444- desist...oider.�Fas44"d..by the' -City Council a f t116 City.of Nuatt"t" Beach, in MoVember 1972 to remain in effoctluniil an'. envoommen. at teport he, s 22 b#4m prepared. That eig. Attw*t vas aMe .by ths.8untington 21 Harbour Corporation.t a re4move the coase ind.,doiliat order. 24 4. That during the Interim ptriod .the Mv6tin gton Rarbiour 29 corporation constructed fifty-tiva boat .a lips,! .0 hoteaft 26 Months -in Christian& 15ay and 4Jxtj-A#;"-b"t in fifteen w�ntha in Towle Retates In 111"Unlo-q 26 ftat 'maj iovirommotal Changes in. -9- Y -C .......... ------ have occurred siroi' the graitting bi O@* .Varjanqv 707* That 2 the Davenport Marina .portion of Me harbor has becomesat- iously affect*d *0*16qLaally by 4"he. dabrise.4ad water 4 pollutica. That during the interim period the 'Runtington Harbour Caroporation has caus&d. additional slips .th be 9onm struct*d in Chzl4tlans Be APA T*Ws 116totes WMah. haVO Y. 7 . Obarige's contributed to these andthat to permit continued construatAost of. the rem i n i ng.' slips in Davenportmarinia would further contribute to the to enviornmental and ecologicai changeto It 6. That the continuance of We Use-Variance would have. . 12 gerious effects on the area 4w that salribids roblem parking p 13 have arivi6n which w.cAlld be- further omplicated .by theAn- Psi 14 stallation of mbr* -boat ali Is 7. That the Huntinqton-.Wbour-' M.! &U" h"-Vidt *aosw 16 factorily explal"d' the.delay 18.801449�--�A ng....to. install the remaining boat 811,pa .under, Use, 17 VerLancv. -not .6btai to S. That the Huniingt104k.'jiArbour Corpotation .hos 19 Vested rights to install the remining- - .004t:21,10 r 20 Use Variance'767 I'm 21 9. That the f act that-only vrsnty-ni�o 611pe Wis-inital 22 in 102 montho. 00natitutes un son h . 9637.1. 23 provisions of Huntinqf�oh Beach Ordinance Code Bection. 99,37.1. 10, -,tiat Us* Varianc" 707 be revokod.sedo 24 18. The Superior Court finds that theis was no substlinii 'l . 29 evidence presented at the P*Lruary 14, 1974 0 ublic boaringto support the 10 findi.:igs of fact (a 26 at forth -at 1"Wth -in jP1,OMq- .,. .31 of Fact go. 17), and in addition the SuperLOT, CDO". in t"* -:7 .21 proceeding in the exercise of LtsAndependent. juOFMat Laft-141111. ITT, the weight and preponderanicie of 'tAq .1evi4ence OmieAted at -jp& ring does not support said 10 tact' 2 public hea tjndi#qs*'6f (or any 3 of theip). made by the City Council of February 19,p 1974.- 4 19. Petitioner has exhausted all a4ailablo administrative 5 repwdies. 20. . Petitioner has no plain, speedy, and adequate reftedy 7 in the ordinary course of law. 21. Thoso Conclusions of Law hereafter recited are by 9 t1h L a reference. incorporated heroin as findings of Fact to the 10 extent such a designation may be Appropriate, 11 rrum, these f acts the:Court m4kqs the. followLago 12 LAM 13 1 Respondent ccmW t ted a pt.*JuftcLa' l abuse of discretion, 14 1within the meaning of CCP Section 109.4*$(b) , to that respondents'. Is findings are not supported byjhe evidemos. as 9,OW4 in this Court 8-: 16 Findings of tract No*. 14 and 18. This is true wbathor. this,Co%irt 17 Applies the, substantial 'evidence at th4':.jn;depeMK%n't Jod,"'nt'.Uwt* 19 tied s:pz*j"1cAsl abuse ot 'dis 2. Respondent comi criUen 19 within the meaning of CCP Section 109CS(b). in that the. fLndLnqs .:: docLsio ' ri 20 I;made by the City Council does not support. the n t o *vok 21 Conditional Exception (use Variance) no. 707. 22 3. Respondent CO=Ltte4 a prejudicial. abuse of. ftecreti I ! and acted without and in excess of its urLsdiciton-wfthin the U i meanLrc ^O rCP Section 1094.5(b) in that the C1 ty.Coummi IL toilet 25 atu proceed in the maaner required by lawLn that$ 26 (a) neither Section 9637,1 not toy other proyLsion .of .27 Huntington Beach Ordinance Code nor the terms of Condition" ZxoeptLon (U" Variance). No. ?J7 provide 'l"al 4vthWdtv 4*'-'4ff- -7 ^MN'Al V Y•y• v 1 . revoke said exception. r . _ (b) Muntin'vtoo Varboor ft"ration bavint s+sds 3 suestantial 4"aditwras,. performed iuostantial oonstraolion, a and incurred substantia2 .lLokilitios io.400d tsi>zb solianee upon t Conditional Cxc"tion (Use ftilanioO Nos,767 A" San or vomit 6 No. Slt has a. .V"ted sight to 6wipioti`the Oa rt 7 4. Those findings of fact hasstofore recited are by this • reference incorporated herein as Conclusions of Law to .the far. 9 extent such a designation. may be appropriate.. : 10 S. Judgment should be enttsedi I1 (a) ordering_ a pormnWtory • ►tit of .mandamus. oo issue : 12 from this Court, reAandinq the proceedings .to retbond#nt.City b 13 Council of the City of HUntingtw►'9w% 4nd common"" respondent . 14 tc, set @aide its decision and`.order entitled ORevoCation..of Us" 1S ' variance No. 7L76, and to take As* 'lasther todde, .specially 16 enjoined upon it by law= ;and 17 (b) Avrarding petitioner eta 'costs ti)-this action. 1• L8R' JUDGlE;JT 88 RMAED ACOORD2116LY. 19 �. 20 DATED s 21 +' 11 X MARK A! JUDW ►= • 22 , 23 21 23 ,t 26 t x r yN -12- ,, t � t,.,�.j,l: tL'iC'..� t�d3i ."��rni�. ��Od17 `4 .• �-� � - ,.:,+ �.:l16 f,u � 8001LURA Irk 1'•F t z , VT OF•�t� B�AS� � GI►L1'� �" � �fr s 13, a C"'_t j ii 4l l'.IugV f i, L i t l-t'� S• _Oulw 7a•V �1� Wt►yAL ,4. l-f'.7 4 rK _+ (�, tii�.a 4 � i I �'�'1 7Y d - 2 J•- - t - f•. .". h. 4 �t q -•��}}ia.��'` �a'•.X �f�r-s ' � � � is • "7p t'r":�`� 3 � t� d + •. ire a.. Z •h l s tart tit Cd�� �r ^ - ff l _. "4,.r,."•f � ty. �Mil Vb -- I jo - - ?MY:eA WS -- 4 rt r ` Attorney . pperz�� as itt wy,fat t s p , l =s ,,. .rr,* as attorpey for tbo . fntatvgpot Shy r t �f 04ri ni-N.trsttve. rwooardirgs h*v b 11 s x r lncas►ills_M by tha Ct�t� ��ElOaaj, �►� �,* �..•t �°:�;,��=�.�rr- i �� �,��� � -- •, 4}a �y-. 7,rc�•T.r+t l�: r � � +� � r-• � } �� �. i13-'i ���r•6.{_e'>I. x -_'�'rr n•-� i r l P�� ' v,�, y+��;1�: �•.-yz �� r - r rj•� 'q' - - 4 Y t�y,�. t ✓ r T �„L c .c4 � ,. � �: �,. "- .eft a �y�'`w�-�`9h'.°` +� -c�- •d7•tg3tytlN,5.,�,'Sy,'' �•�r }`r a � 3,�d4� r ."'' ,;. 0 3 144 _ t a ' r • ', +gave b eri a 101:A lZ z oiR� att c �e�cting t r i t t16+r �1#�ic ►4"� t Co I = # ► O'► ' • :a �F��c tr=,nQrx..besrh srKi c�a+s�� s� •idaC to. �t�t e � ;.� �� J�•¢a'.Flet.r':ax 15,. .E ?4 srk.fCl !'r 'R vaarstick of � - �:� r, �sr�•9 . t�+ • �t;;a �e�i� tct•�h+�r artier• s1,e►r..�i�Ily '�-C; tR is feat or. in Chet ifs i�: y.,>>• tr ran.r.�l �:.h ut the di c stipa.a�gal� 4' t i 7c3 i.tc !'1s2. r�:fl*?@►Tf{�Alt�L z+t;,` - -' At C' 2�'JQBL ��74�',�f. l'�t`$�k�` ��j,1j` �• � �}�c.�•4�4� ;�°r1►tO�Tf� � .. .�,� � �•t='' 4 c t)t)f.. i i ���� rsP ."�:.¢ '�S c ��{ -7� w. �f r ,[ i the A Volume 140 ~s > 9x 2f $t. JEob1t• 4'w =Y C1etiE ' 24 .. - w 3�g.F t`•y�-e�S'� arc, C '� fif k Aa . _ r�1 •, a�� a.��x� r •-� r�jt5 t AW CV.. 1 �3 w lam. •+ \.I �.('S`.j('} r<-'t� • : •-.�.F;�'�� . y_ s � y• w_ rr.t..; ,w'�''-+.�` •,7',...'r,.u'�� R�'�'��s1,���'';� �'. +� ter._,, _ h $k .. .r._i4�..r�� ...•.n ._ -_. .�... ..e.._.r....._u....l.., .. _ ... __ ��_ .., r .� .•r �. •.:..c S-. .. ..,. }.J.v,a,._.. _ .a�.... .. _.:fir_.n _ , ����i�%s .. 01 OFFICE OF' THE CITY ATTORNEY e • �' ,� `' OPINION NO. 714-11 • January 31 , 1974 moo'' 6� JF�`aG. SUBJECT : Davenport Marina • REQUESTED BY : Don P . Bonfa, City Attorney r PREPARED BY : John J . O 'Connor, Deputy City Attorney • QUESTION 1 : In Subdivision 4830 , Huntington Harbour dedicated a fee interest to the city in the property underlyinf, the channels , with a reservation of easement rights to construct a marina on the surface . Is this reservation of easement rights to construct a marina legally valid? ANSVJ'EN 1 : Yes . Reservation of marina rights on the surface of the water is legally valid and , Huntington Harbour has the right to construct the marina subject to the limitations dis- • cus Lied hereinbclow . QUESTION 2 : The property underlying the channels was zoned R1 at the time of dedication to the City. Was a use variance necessary to construction of a marina? • ANS.-;ER 2 : Some cases hold that even though the property is owricd by a public entity and therefore exempt from zoning regulations , development of the property by private interests must • conforr: to appropriate zoning limitations , ther0f'ore , a use variance would appear proper. QUESTION' 3 : Zonin of the property underlying. the channe1 ti,as nov: been changed to a commu- nity facilities district desi[-nation . Is a rr: ri n,_ perr;_ ttod in a community facilities d _strictY %P:S lrF; 3 . A fLicilitics district. permits "recrcational area.," . While recreational • area., are further defined, in the code , it, would Seery: that this category is broad er.014', -i to encc:r:.pa: s mar_Lnas . • Fil I - C;`� ICE' 01, iaE� CI:'Y A" TOR';? FY January jl , 1974 �p1nion No. 74-11 Page 2 QUESTION 4 : Fee to the property underlying the marina Is a::rted by the City subject to the Huntington HarL,our Corporation ' s reservation of an ease- rri�nt. ;'ur private property uses, including a marina. Is use of the surface for private m::r na purposes legally valid? • ANSWER 4 : As a condition to accepting; the dedication of the fee underlying; the marina and in approving Tract 4880, Huntington Harbour Corp) ration expressly reserved use of the surf'_,ce of the channel for marina purposes . This is a private , assignable easement and the o,::r:er has the same proprietary rights as any other ovrner of private property . There is no requirement that it be used exclusively for public purposes . QUESTION' 5 : Would it violate constitutional provision of • equal protection to restrict use of the marina to allot,: the Huntington Harbour to restrict use of the marina to residents of Huntington Harbour? ANSWER 5 : Since the easement rights are private • property , and the marina is held in a propri-etary capacity, as such , it can be restricted to the use of Huntington Harbour residents . DISCUSSION OF QUESTION 1 : In 1962 , Final Tract Uup 4880 was filed with the Orange County • Recorder . Under provisions of this subdivision, the City of Huntington Beach accepted dedication of the areas designated as watcr.;.a,ys -- "for use only as a public navigable waterway and no nt-,c r purpo:,e ;,;hatsoever, excepting and reserv-*;_ng however unto k ;:,:ntir, ;i: n Nr,*'hour ) f* , the fc>llov:ing>, severable and assign- able ea Cer?r�nts and ri ht.s• of way in , over, across , upon and • throu,rh }T (t}:c �;e �:utc. r;:�I,ys )�` for the purpose of construct- 4 igT, ruinta:inin -, u:i t,�;, operation or renting freethereon , ree of .and- r:.-r:t;al ci,:: t;y tine Cat; of iiuntinE,t on Beach , docks , piC'I' , li.':7t3'VP:• , t '; rP_mp, • , i'loats , lug"i '.1, ,F and otti:er mooring; -uctur•L•.. t_ria foct.iTiL,6 , pIlLn.,s and an-0-1 Ilary structures • fc,r bulkhI -UJ;> loc tC:,! on Lldj<<cent properties to the undersigned coi-poration , zind dvc:;:!;:-.u:_es , cluhhouses , miarine field stations , taI-,! :,r,tc , ha?:c7 . , and other structure; or buildings of any naturt Or t.yp : fc;' a_luat c , reerc.-ation , fishing';, boating;, marina • OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY January 31 , 1974 Opinion No. 74-11 Page 3 or harbor, and other ancillary purposes of all kinds , whatsoever, • the foreE;oing structures and things to be located , constructed , maintained , used , operated, or rented for profit or not for pro- fit , for commercial purposes or noncommercial purposes , and for private purposes and uses or public purposes and uses in the discretion of ** (Huntington Harbour Corporation)** or its suc- cessors and assigns . "' • A reading of the forejoing (copy attached hereto as Exhibit I) t makes it abundantly clear that. the City of Huntington Beach In accepting, the dedication agreed to a broad and pervasive reservation of rights in the Huntington Harbour Corporation , and this reservation expressly permits the construction of a • marina as proposed by the Huntington Harbour Corporation . This is a reservation of a private proprietary easement , is legally valid, and was agreed to and accepted by the City under those terms and conditions . DISCUSSION OF QUESTION 2 : The property underlyng the waterway was zoned R1 at the time of dedication to the City , and has remained zoned R1 until several months ago when it was zoned to a community facilities • district . The law is well settled that a public entity is not hound by its zoning. Bail�Iv V. City of Los Angeles , ( 1956) 116 C . 2d 132 , Kubach Cu . v. McQuire 1926 ) 199 C . 21.5 ; 32 Ops . Calif. A.G . 143 ( 195 .) , California Zoning Practice , Section 859 , Page 355 . However, there is some authority which seems to indicate that even though a public entity is not bound by • zoning regulations , that a private developer desiring to con- struct a project on property owned by a public entity must comply r;ith existing zoning regulations . Wilsey & Co . V. San Bernardino , ( 1957 ) 155 C.A . 2d 145 . However, in the Wilsey case , the lease expressly provided that the structures would hive to comply, with local zoning regulations . In • the press evjt s1tuat.ion involving Davenport Marina, there was no express requiromer:t by the City in accepting the dedication that cons ruction of the marina or the other designated faci- lities cc.:,-.-ply .:i.th zor:ing regulations . Huntington Harbour CorporatiC'11 did .n fact request. and secure approval of a use variance from the 1?1 zoning for construction of the marina. • While tt,:is use varia7,e may not have been required in view of the cone iti.on:• of acceptance of the dedication , since it has bee:n prc;vurcd i-:ith *Elie approval of the City , and in any event m-ay no lont'er he required in vier: of the rezoning of the prol-c_rt.y to community facilities, district , this question • is now 1;.;Jot . • OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY January 31 , 1974 Opinion No . 74-11 Page 4 DISCUSSION ON QUESTION 3 : Community facilities districts designated CFRs permit "recrea- tional areas" . Recreational areas are not further defined , how-ever, they would seer.; to encompass a boating recreational facility such as a •marina . Webster' s definition of "recrea- tional" is "equipped to provide diversion or amusements" . Boating is generally accepted as a recreational activity . r DISCUSSION ON QUESTION 4 : The fee to the property underlying the waterway is owned by the City , however, there has been an express reservation of private proprietary surface easements of the waterway for the purposes enumerated and set forth under the discussion of Question 1 , supra. These reservations expressly include the use of the surface for a marina. Therefore , use of the surface of the water for marina purposes is not use of public property but in fact use of private property under reservations of the private easement which has been expressly reserved by Huntington Harbour Corporation. DISCUSSION ON QUESTION 5 : It necessarily follows from our discussion of Question 4 that since the reservation of an easement for construction of a marina is private property rather than public property , that Huntington Harbour Corporation can restrict and limit use of the marina to residents of Huntington Harbour, if they are so disposed . Since the easement for construction of the marina remains private property, there would be no constitutional prohibition against restricting use of the marina to residents of Huntington Harbour. Of course , Huntington Harbour Corpora- Lion could not discrim-Inate against residents of Huntington Harbour on the basis of age , color, sex , etc . as provided under the Federal Civil. Right. Act of 1964 . JOHN J . O ' CONNOR Deputy City Attorney JJO :er • �A CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH INTER-DEPARTMENT COMMUNICATION W NINGTON BEACH • To H . E. Hartge , Director From John O'Connor Public Works Deputy City Attorney Subject Davenport Marina Pierhead Line Date December 2, 1975 • In your memorandum dated November 26, 1975 you have posed the following question: "If the City Council was to establish a pierhead line for the Davenport Marina which resulted in the removal of existing docking facilities , would the City be • required to compensate the marina owner for this loss?" We respond in the affirmative . Establishment of a pierhead line by the City which would require removal of existing docking facilities as originally approved by the City , would clearly involve inverse condemnation in which 'the City would • be required to compensate the marina owner. Citation of authority is unnecessary , as this is basic law in California. v.-V ,U . 0' CONNOR Deputy City Attorney JJO' C :cs APPROVED : DON P. BONF City Attorn • • RECEIVED DEPT. OF PUBLIC WOR''KS :j 1975 HUNTINCTON EEACH. CAS is