Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutApprove Negative Declaration No 14-005 and Adopt Resolution City of Huntington Beach 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 f a �v DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND BUILDING www huntingtonbeachca gov Planning Division NOTICE OF CITY COUNCIL ACTION Building Division CUober� ,YO�5 714,536,5241 City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 SUBJECT: GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT NO. 08-0091 NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 14-005(HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT UPDATE) APPLICANT: City of Huntington Beach REQUEST: ND: To analyze the potential environmental impacts associated with the adoption and implementation of the Historic and Cultural Resources Element update GPA: To update the Historic and Cultural Resources Element LOCATION: Citywide DATE OF ACTION: October 19, 2015 On Monday, October 19, 2015, the Huntington Beach City Council took action on your application, and approved General Plan Amendment No 08-009 by approving City Council Resolution No 2015-64, and approved Negative Declaration No 14-005 with findings for approval Under the provisions of the Huntington Beach Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance, the action taken by the City Council is final If you have any questions, please contact Ricky Ramos, the project planner, at rramos(c-surfcitV-hb orq or (714) 536-5624 or the Community Development Department Zoning Counter at(714) 536-5271 Sinc ely, CA KHei3---" Director of Community Development SH JJ RR kdc Notice of Action GPA 08-009/ND 14-005 October 19,2015 Page 2 Attachments 1 ND No 14-005 Findings for Approval 2 GPA No 08-009 Resolution No 2015-64 c Scott Hess, Director of Community Development Joan Flynn, City Clerk Ricky Ramos, Senior Planner Property Owner Project File i ---- -T��� --------------- ATTACHMENT NO. 1 FINDINGS OF APPROVAL I NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 14-006 i FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL - NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 14-006: 1 Negative Declaration No 14-005 has been prepared in compliance with Article 6 of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines It was advertised and available for a public comment period of thirty (30) days Comments received during the comment period were considered by the City Council prior to action on the Negative Declaration and General Plan Amendment No 08-009 2 There is no substantial evidence in light of the whole record before the City Council that the project will have a significant effect on the environment i i I i I i Attachment 1 1 ------------- ------- - - --- RESOLUTION NO. 2015-64 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH APPROVING GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT NO.08-009 (HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCE ELEMENT UPDATE) WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach has adopted a General Plan, and The planning and zoning laws of the State of California provide for the adoption and amendment of general plan elements to address local concerns,and The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach desires to updatr it-, General Plan in keeping with changing community needs and objectives, and The Planning Commission of the City of Htuntington Beach, after giving proper legal notice, held a public healing to consider General Plan Amendment No. 08-009 and recommended approval to the City Council, and Aftei giving proper legal notice,the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach held a public hearing where public comment was received and the proposed Historic and Cultural Resources Element update was thoroughly reviewed and considered,and The environmental impacts have been analyzed as part of Negative Declaration No. 14-005. NOW, THEREFORE, the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach does hereby resolve as follows SECTION 1 That Genial Plan Amendment No. 08-009, which is an update to the Historic and Cultural Resources Element, is hereby approved The Director of Planning and Building is hereby directed to prepare and file an updated General Plan Historic and Cultural Resources Element 15-4905/126091 1 Resolution No 2015-64 PASSEL) AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at a regular meeting thereof held on the day of ,2015 Mayor REVIEWED AND APPROVED APPROVED AS-Jk FORM City Manages _ City Attorney 1InTIATEO AND PP OVED, - Dir ctoi df Planning and Building ATTACHMENTS Exhibit A- Historic and Cultural Resouices Element Update 15-4905/126091 2 Dept ID PL 15-018 Page 1 of 3 Meeting Date 10/19/2015 ,, yoga 6 -0-/\ CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH g REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION MEETING DATE: 10/19/2015 SUBMITTED TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members SUBMITTED BY: Fred A Wilson, City Manager PREPARED BY: Scott Hess, AICP, Director of Planning and Building SUBJECT: Approve Negative Declaration No 14-005 and Adopt Resolution No 2015-64 approving General Plan Amendment No 08-009 (Historic and Cultural Resources Element Update) — Continued from the April 6, 2015, City Council Meeting Statement of Issue Transmitted for City Council consideration are Negative Declaration (ND) No 14-005 and General Plan Amendment (GPA) No 08-009 for the General Plan Historic and Cultural Resources Element (HCRE) update ND 14-005 is a request to analyze the potential environmental impacts associated with the adoption and implementation of the HCRE update GPA No 08-009 is a request to update the HCRE The Planning Commission and staff recommend approval This item was continued from the April 6, 2015, City Council meeting Financial Impact Not applicable Recommended Action A) Approve Negative Declaration No 14-005 with findings (Attachment No 2), and, B) Approve General Plan Amendment No 08-009 by adopting City Council Resolution No 2015- 64, "A Resolution of the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach Approving General Plan Amendment No 08-009 (Historic and Cultural Resource Element Update) " (Attachment No 3) Alternative Action(s) The City Council may take alternative actions such as Continue Negative Declaration No 14-005 and General Plan Amendment No 08-009 and direct staff accordingly Analysis A PROJECT PROPOSAL Applicant City of Huntington Beach Location Citywide FIB -499- Item 15. - 1 Dept ID PL 15-018 Page 2 of 3 Meeting Date 10/19/2015 Negative Declaration (ND) No 14-005 represents a request to analyze the potential environmental Impacts associated with the adoption and Implementation of the Historic and Cultural Resources Element update pursuant to Chapter 240 of the Huntington Beach Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance (HBZSO) and the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) General Plan Amendment (GPA) No 08-009 represents a request to update the Historic and Cultural Resources Element (HCRE) of the General Plan pursuant to the California Planning and Zoning Laws B BACKGROUND The City Council held a public hearing on the project on April 6, 2015, and continued the item The City Council directed staff to contact the owners of the 257 eligible historic structures to ask if they want their property to be included on a voluntary historic properties inventory, conduct a public informational meeting, and return with the item as amended Staff held a public meeting on September 24, 2015, and explained the voluntary historic properties inventory and the survey Staff also elaborated on and responded to several questions regarding the Mills Act program Several requests to be included on the voluntary historic properties inventory were received at the meeting and the weeks after it C STAFF ANALYSIS AND RECOMMENDATION All the prior analysis on the ND, GPA, and survey are provided in the April 6, 2015, Request for City Council Action which is included as Attachment No 1 to this report The following is an update on the project Voluntary Historic Properties Inventory Staff has compiled an initial voluntary historic properties inventory which is included as Attachment No 10 to this staff report for information only It consists of eligible properties from the survey that the property owners have requested to be included as well as those properties that are City-owned The inventory will be maintained by planning staff and property owners can opt in or opt out of the inventory at anytime Staff and the Historic Resources Board (HRB) have been able to identify the following benefits to property owners who voluntarily include their property on the inventory 1 The inventory and photos of the properties will be posted on the City's website 2 Property owners will receive a Certificate of Recognition 3 Property owners will be notified of future incentive programs 4 The HRB may offer research assistance on property history It should be noted that whether a property is on the Voluntary Historic Properties Inventory or not, all 257 properties identified in the survey are eligible for the Mills Act program Downtown Specific Plan (DTSP) The DTSP Environmental Impact Report (EIR) includes a mitigation measure which requires a report from an architectural historian if changes are proposed to a historic structure within the DTSP Staff has been able to clarify since the April hearing that this mitigation measure would only apply to the historic structures that are specifically listed in the DTSP EIR Item 15. - 2 I-IB -500- Dept ID PL 15-018 Page 3 of 3 Meeting Date 10/19/2015 SUMMARY Staff's Recommendation Approve Negative Declaration No 14-005 and General Plan Amendment No 08-009 based upon the following - The project will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment - The updated HCRE is consistent with the General Plan and reflects the City's current goals, objectives, and policies that will guide future decisions regarding historic structures - The project includes a Historic Context and Survey Report which identifies an updated inventory of potentially historic structures (local landmarks inventory) which can be used to assist the City in managing its historic preservation goals Strategic Plan Goal Improve quality of life Attachment(s) 1 April 6, 2015, Request for Council Action for ND No 14-005 and GPA No 08-009 2 Suggested Findings for Approval ND No 14-005 3 Draft City Council Resolution No 2015-64 Approving GPA No 08-009 4 Negative Declaration No 14-005 (Includes Environmental Checklist, Response to Comments, Errata to the Negative Declaration, and Comment Letters) 5 Draft Historic and Cultural Resources Element Update (tracked changes) 6 1991 Existing Local Landmarks Status 7 Historic Context and Survey Report Appendix B (Updated Landmarks Inventory) 8 Planning Commission Staff Report dated February 24, 2015 9 Draft City Policy for Minor Updates to the Historic Context and Survey Report 10 Voluntary Historic Properties Inventory dated Oct 8, 2015 11 PowerPoint Presentation 12 Historic Context and Survey Report(not attached but available at http//www huntingtonbeachca gov/governmenVdepartments/planning/environmental- reports/environmental-report-view cfm?ID=22 SH JV RR kdc 11B -501- Item 15. - 3 Dept ID PL 15-005 Page 1 of 6 Meeting Date 4/6/2015 CITY OF HUNTINGTON REACH REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION MEETING DATE: 4/6/2015 SUBMITTED TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members SUBMITTED BY: Fred A Wilson, City Manager PREPARED BY: Scott Hess, AICP, Director of Planning and Building SUBJECT: Approve Negative Declaration No 14-005 and Adopt Resolution No 2015-16 approving General Plan Amendment No 08-009 (Historic and Cultural Resources Element Update) Statement of Issue Transmitted for City Council consideration are Negative Declaration (ND) No 14-005 and General Plan Amendment (GPA) No 08-009 for the General Plan Historic and Cultural Resources Element (HCRE) update ND 14-005 is a request to analyze the potential environmental impacts associated with the adoption and implementation of the HCRE update GPA No 08-009 is a request to update the HCRE The Planning Commission and staff recommend approval Financial Impact Not applicable Planning Commission and Staff Recommended Action A) Approve Negative Declaration No 14-005 with findings (Attachment No 1), and, B) Approve General Plan Amendment No 08-009 by adopting City Council Resolution No 2015- 16, "A Resolution of the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach Approving General Plan Amendment No 08-009 (Historic and Cultural Resource Element Update) " (Attachment No 2) Alternative Action(s) The City Council may take alternative actions such as Continue Negative Declaration No 14-005 and General Plan Amendment No 08-009 and direct staff accordingly Analysis A PROJECT PROPOSAL Applicant City of Huntington Beach Location Citywide Item 15. - 4 IJB -502- Dept ID PL 15-005 Page 2 of 6 Meeting Date 4/6/2015 Negative Declaration (ND) No 14-005 represents a request to analyze the potential environmental Impacts associated with the adoption and Implementation of the Historic and Cultural Resources Element update pursuant to Chapter 240 of the Huntington Beach Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance (HBZSO) and the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) General Plan Amendment (GPA) No 08-009 represents a request to update the Historic and Cultural Resources Element (HCRE) of the General Plan pursuant to the California Planning and Zoning Laws The current General Plan was adopted in 1996 and serves as policy framework for future development of the city The HCRE is one of the General Plan Elements and guides the City's decisions regarding historic and cultural resources by identifying goals, objectives, policies, and implementation programs as well as providing technical information and outlining issues regarding the protection of the city's historic resources and provision of arts/cultural services Only the historic resources component of the HCRE is proposed to be updated at this time The cultural resources component is not being revised The City initiated the update because the existing local landmarks list in Table HCR-2 of the HCRE requires updating Many of the properties listed in the local landmarks list have since been demolished or significantly altered while others are archaeological or not historic In addition, the update also allows the City to give a fresh look at the goals, objectives, policies, and implementation programs to make sure they continue to address the city's long-term needs B PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING AND RECOMMENDATION The Planning Commission held a hearing on the project on February 24, 2015 There were four speakers Two members of the Historic Resources Board (HRB) recommended that the HRB be allowed to do additional survey work to address what they believe are remaining issues with the completed survey One person expressed concerns about impacts to property owners of historic buildings The chair of the Historic Wintersburg Preservation Task Force spoke about historic Wintersburg The Planning Commission asked what restrictions there are on historic buildings They also discussed the need to develop a process for updating the survey in between the comprehensive updates recommended every five years in the HCRE The Planning Commission recommended approval of the requests with the addition of a policy in the HCRE to consider crowdsourcing to support preservation efforts (see Policy HCR 1 4 6 in Attachment 4) Planning Commission Action on February 24, 2015 A motion was made by Kalmick, seconded by Semeta, to approve ND No 14-005 carried by the following vote AYES Hoskinson, Semeta, Pinchiff, Kalmick, Crowe, Mandic, Brenden NOES None ABSTAIN None ABSENT None MOTION PASSED A substitute motion was made by Brenden, seconded by Pinchiff, to continue ND No 14-005 and GPA No 08-009, but was withdrawn HB -;o;- Item 15. - 5 Dept ID PL 15-005 Page 3 of 6 Meeting Date 4/6/2015 MOTION WITHDRAWN A motion was made by Kalmick, seconded by Hoskinson, to approve GPA No 08-009 with the addition of a policy to consider crowdsourcing to support preservation efforts carried by the following vote AYES Hoskinson, Semeta, Pinchiff, Kalmick, Crowe, Mandic, Brenden NOES None ABSTAIN None ABSENT None MOTION PASSED A motion was made by Kalmick, seconded by Mandic, for a minute action to request City Council to direct staff to evaluate an intra five year process for updating the Historic Context and Survey Report of the HCRE carried by the following vote AYES Hoskinson, Semeta, Pinchiff, Kalmick, Crowe, Mandic, Brenden NOES None ABSTAIN None ABSENT None MOTION PASSED C STAFF ANALYSIS AND RECOMMENDATION ANALYSIS: The following provides an overview of the Historic and Cultural Resources Element and the key updates Overview and Key Changes The updated HCRE is organized into four main sections Technical Synopsis, Issues, Goals, Objectives, and Policies, and Implementation Programs The Technical Synopsis section contains background information including the city's historic context and predominant architectural styles The Issues section outlines a list of major concerns that have been identified regarding historic structures The Goals, Objectives, and Policies section describes what the city would like to achieve and provides policy guidance relating to managing the city's historic structures The Implementation Programs section includes the actual steps that can be taken to ensure the goals, objectives, and policies of the HCRE are met The HCRE update includes the following notable changes which are shown in Attachment 4 1 Technical Synopsis and Issues — These sections include an update to the historic context of the city and its predominant architectural styles by incorporating information from the associated Historic Context and Survey Report explained later on in this staff report The issues- relating to historic structures were also reviewed and updated All the existing outdated tables and exhibits, including the local landmarks list in Table HCR-2, are being deleted Instead of continuing to include a local landmarks list in the HCRE, the City will maintain a separate local landmarks list which includes all the properties in the city that have been identified as having historic significance as a result of a recent survey as well as Item 15. - 6 HB -504- Dept ID PL 15-005 Page 4 of 6 Meeting Date 4/6/2015 future survey updates This will allow future updates to the list as needed without requiring an amendment to the HCRE Table HCR-2 (1991) lists 79 local landmarks comprised of 212 properties One of the 79 landmarks is the Wesley Park neighborhood which consists of 134 properties alone The current status of these landmarks is noted in Attachment 5 and summarized as follows 79 properties have been carried over into the updated landmarks list, ■ 133 properties have been demolished, heavily altered, or are not historic and have been removed from the updated landmarks list 2 Goals, Policies, Objectives, and Implementation Programs—These sections only required a few revisions to update and clarify existing goals, objectives, policies and implementation programs Staff and Galvin Preservation Associates, the City's consultant, prepared and reviewed the changes to the HCRE to make sure they are consistent with the General Plan, appropriate, and reflect the city's long-term interests The HCRE update was also reviewed by the HRB and their comments were incorporated Historical Context and Survey Report As part of the HCRE update, Galvin Preservation Associates (GPA) conducted a citywide survey to identify and evaluate potential historic structures in the city The purpose of the survey is to update and expand the City's existing 1986 Historic Resources Survey Report and to update the HCRE The survey included a reconnaissance level survey of all ±2,400 buildings in the city that were at least 50 years old when the survey was commenced in 2009, focusing on the historic core areas as well as select buildings located outside the historic core and other outlying areas identified by the HRB City staff and GPA worked closely with the HRB over several years on the survey and the results are outlined in the 2014 Historic Context and Survey Report The updated local landmarks (historic structures) list is identified in Appendix B of the Historic Context and Survey Report which is provided as Attachment 6 to this staff report In addition, GPA reviewed the three previously identified potential historic districts in the 1986 survey and determined that they no longer maintain enough integrity to be considered historic districts according to national, state, and local register criteria GPA identified two smaller concentrations of buildings in the 2014 Historic Context and Survey Report that would constitute a local historic district as follows a Main Street-Crest Avenue—This district is located on Main Street and Crest Avenue between 11th Street and Palm Avenue b 9th Street—This district includes most of the west side of 9th Street between Walnut Avenue and Olive Avenue HB -505- Item 15. - 7 Dept. ID PL 15-005 Page 5 of 6 Meeting Date:4/6/2015 MAIN'STREET—CREST AVENUE 9TH STREET HISTORIC" DISTRICT HISTORIC DISTRICT �J ra T° C , l UGUND LEGEND eu e�A a e4 lac, t5irtric Lve[u�amrn ' �A§sat�iw.�¢ttlriWl3mrK LHA9£ffi49Nau.MsBai'k A'4 1 1 4*0 y MREr Con istent with industry standards, the HCRE includes an implementation program that recommends the Historic Context and Survey Report be comprehensively updated every five years to keep the data it contains current. Minor updates in the interim can also be made based on a draft policy memo included in this report (see Attachment 8) that was developed by staff and reviewed by the HRB to address the Planning Commission's minute action recommendation to City Council. CEQA and Historic Structures'. The updated local landmarks list in Appendix B of the Historic Context and Survey Report identifies 257 local landmarks and would serve as a list of historic structures for purposes of evaluating future projects under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). This list requires periodic update and can be used to assist the City in managing its historic preservation goals. It should be noted that, except for the 20 additional historic buildings identified within the Downtown Specific Plan area, no new regulatory requirements will be imposed on these landmark buildings that did not exist before the survey was conducted. Only some buildings will no longer need an evaluation as a result of the survey (the other±2,140 properties surveyed that were determined to not be historic). In 1999, the City established a policy clarifying the level of environmental review for historic structures listed in the General Plan. Basically, any demolition of a listed historic structure was subject to environmental review under CEQA. Additionally, any construction work on a historic resource was required to comply with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties in order to be exempt from environmental review. However, based on recent CEQA research, it has been determined that a ministerial demolition permit or alterations to a historic resource are not subject to CEQA even if the alteration does not comply with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards. If the City wishes to adopt a Preservation Ordinance that requires discretionary approval of proposed demolition or alterations of historic structures, then CEQA would apply to the discretionary action. Absent a Preservation Ordinance, inclusion on the list would not result in triggering CEQA requirements when demolishing or altering a historic structure unless it is proposed within the context of a project requiring discretionary approval by the City or the structure Item 15. - 8 _ Dept ID PL 15-005 Page 6 of 6 Meeting Date 4/6/2015 is located within the Downtown Specific Plan where changes to a historic structure are subject to a mitigation measure requiring a report from an architectural historian D SUMMARY Staff's Recommendation Approve Negative Declaration No 14-005 and General Plan Amendment No 08-009 based upon the following - The project will not have a significant adverse Impact on the environment - The updated HCRE is consistent with the General Plan and reflects the City's current goals, objectives, and policies that will guide future decisions regarding historic structures - The project Includes a Historic Context and Survey Report which Identifies an updated list of potential historic structures (local landmarks list)which can be used to assist the City in managing its historic preservation goals Environmental Status Staff has prepared ND No 14-005 pursuant to Section 240 04 of the HBZSO and the provisions of CEQA and determined that no significant impacts are anticipated as a result of the proposed project The Planning Division advertised draft ND No 14-005 for a 30-day public review period commencing on November 6 and ending on December 5, 2014 Two comment letters were submitted and a response and errata have been included with the attached ND Histonc Resources Board(HRB)Comments HRB identified what it believes are some shortcomings of the new historic survey and provided several recommended corrective actions that essentially involve adding more properties to the local landmarks list The HRB's comments are provided and addressed in Attachment No 3 Environmental Board Comments The Environmental Board was notified of the Negative Declaration and did not submit any comments Prior to any action on GPA No 08-009, it is necessary for the City Council to review and act on ND No 14-005 Planning Commission and staff are recommending that the negative declaration be approved with findings Strategic Plan Goal Improve quality of life Frrata to the Negative Dedaratlen and Gemment I ette%) 4 Draft Histerin and G ltural Resewrnes Clement Update (traGked nhaRgesl 991 F=X!Stlnn I anal -'and-marks Status 6 HiSterin Gente)t anrd Survey RepoictAppendix 6 (Updated I rd anmaFk I rt) 7 Planning Gemm1661en Staff Ronan dater! Cebi: rani 'ail 7(1'd�. 9—Pewei:Pein+,r P,FP-E-;e itat19R M SH JV RR kdc IJB -507- Item 15. - 9 FATTACHMENT #2 ATTACHMENT NO. 1 SUGGESTED FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 14-005 SUGGESTED FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL - NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 14-005: 1 Negative Declaration No 14-005 has been prepared in compliance with Article 6 of the California Environmental Quality Act(CEQA) Guidelines. It was advertised and available for a public comment period of thirty(30) days. Comments received during the comment period were considered by the City Council prior to action on the Negative Declaration and General Plan Amendment No 08-009 2 There is no substantial evidence in light of the whole record before the City Council that the project will have a significant effect on the environment. Item 15. - 10 HB -508- �►TTACHNT #3 RESOLUTION NO. 2015-64 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH APPROVING GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT NO. 08-009 (HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCE ELEMENT UPDATE) WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach has adopted a General Plan, and The planning and zoning laws of the State of California provide for the adoption and amendment of general plan elements to address local concerns, and The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach desires to update its General Plan in keeping with changing community needs and objectives; and The Planning Commission of the City of Huntington Beach, after giving proper legal notice, held a public hearing to consider General Plan Amendment No. 08-009 and recommended approval to the City Council; and After giving proper legal notice,the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach held a public hearing where public comment was received and the proposed Historic and Cultural Resources Element update was thoroughly reviewed and considered; and The environmental impacts have been analyzed as part of Negative Declaration No. 14-005. NOW, THEREFORE, the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach does hereby resolve as follows: SECTION 1: That General Plan Amendment No. 08-009, which is an update to the Historic and Cultural Resources Element, is hereby approved. The Director of Planning and Building is hereby directed to prepare and file an updated General Plan Historic and Cultural Resources Element. 15-4905/126091 1 Resolution No . 2015-64 PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at a regular meeting thereof held on the 19 t biay of October , 2015 AV M r REVIEW APPROVED: APPROVED AS FORM. YQ�t Manager City Attorney TIATE ND PP ROVED: it ctor lanning and Building ATTACHMENTS Exhibit A• Historic and Cultural Resources Element Update 15-4905/126091 2 Exhibit "A" — Resolution No . 2015-64 CommuNrrY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESo URGES ELEMENT STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS In addition to the seven mandatory elements, other optional elements may be included in a City's General Plan The California Government Code Section 65303 states The General Plan may include any other elements or address any other subjects which, in the judgment of the legislative body, relate to the physical development of the county or city Huntington Beach's Historical and Cultural Element is just such an optional element Once adopted, this element will have the same legal status as any of the mandatory elements Additionally, other state requirements pertaimng to the mandatory elements, such as internal consistency, also apply to the optional element This element outlines the overall City goals as they relate to historical and cultural resources within the city and identifies the policies and objectives that the City will follow to meet those goals TECHNICAL SYNOPSIS A. HISTORIC RESOURCES To best understand the importance of Huntington Beach's historic resources, it is necessary to examine the history and events that helped shape the community's built environment Along with a basic historical understanding, the styles and variations of Huntington Beach's architectural resources must also be examined. The overall intent of this section is to identify the historical resources of the community,their current designations and community status,and the issues affecting their future 1. City History The City of Huntington Beach exemplifies the trials and tribulations of developing a modern city within a region lacking many of the characteristics required for commercial and residential development, with the exception of raw land The city was developed atop a series of treeless bluffs overlooking swampland on all three sides,with the Pacific Ocean to the west Native Americans occupied the Huntington Beach area as far back as eight thousand years ago Subsequently, the Mexicans, or Califormos, also recognized the natural resources of the area, and ranchos were partitioned off of the original holdings During the late nineteenth century settlers began to recognize that the peaty soils surrounding what was to become Huntington Beach were cultivatable and could produce a variety of crops It was not until 1903 that the framework of the fledgling community that later became Huntington Beach was formed, largely through the connection of the Pacific Electric Railway to Long Beach Incorporated in 1909,by the 1970s Huntington Beach had become one of the fastest growing cities in the nation The settlement and history of Huntington Beach was influenced as much by its geomorphology as it was by its culture and people The geological history of Huntington Beach reflects dramatic changes in ocean levels and terrestrial life THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-1 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT It was during the inter-glacial periods that the ocean extended as far inland as Santa Fe Springs and Buena Park Major flood events occurred in the early 1860s and again in 1938 The flood of 1938 destroyed thousands of acres of farmland in the Santa Ana River plain, depositing thousands of feet of sand For tens of thousands of years the Santa Ana River plain was a large swamp, as thick peat deposits underlie the entire region The Newport-Inglewood fault zone runs underneath Huntington Beach This fault contributed to the Long Beach Earthquake of 1933 (epicenter was actually in Huntington Beach), which damaged or destroyed countless buildings in the city of Long Beach and neighboring communities The fault zone did have some benefits for Huntington Beach, creating oil traps that resulted in the development of large oil reserves beneath the community Huntington Beach was inhabited by indigenous people dating back to 8,000 BP Between 7,000 and 1,200 BP, prelustoric sites were characterized by large numbers of cogstones and discoidals, and relatively few projectile points Ethnographically, the Gabrielino Indians (Tongva), Chumash, and other tribes occupied the area that would later become Huntington Beach At the time of Spanish contact in the 18th century they occupied a large swath of land along the California Coast, which include most of present-day Los Angeles and Orange counties, plus several offshore islands The early history of Huntington Beach prior to its development as a city is tied largely to the development of ranches along the bluffs overlooking swamp lands associated with the area's river channels By the late 1890s a loose-knit community had developed, although no formal townsite had yet been established Instead, small farming communities were created, generally near transportation hubs and away from the flood plains along the river channels and swamps Farming families include the Coles, Newtons and the Furutas During this period, most of the valuable agricultural lands in Huntington Beach were held by a few families or companies The land was then leased to tenant farmers, many of whom were Mexican and Japanese Based upon historic records, Japanese immigrant farmers played an important part in the agricultural history of California and Huntington Beach In June of 1906 there were more than 1,000 Japanese at work in the celery fields The amicable events that occurred in the mid-1930s, including visits by Japanese dignitaries, unraveled following the Japanese bombing of Pearl Harbor in December 1941 Ultimately, most of the Japanese living or working in Huntington Beach were forcibly removed and incarcerated Prior to 1901, the area now known as Huntington Beach was known principally for its agriculture On July 30, 1901, it was announced that the name of the new town near Bolsa Cluca Bay had been changed from Bolsa Beach to Pacific City Other accounts suggest that the fledgling community was also referred to as "Shell Beach" until sometime in 1901, when it was renamed Pacific City In 1902, surveyors were reportedly at work surveying the rail line between Santa Ana and Newport Beach, which would eventually reach Huntington Beach As the Los Angeles Time reported on May 30, 1903, "in the future the town would be called Huntington Beach" The spring of 1904 was a busy time for the newly formed city of Huntington Beach The pier,beach, and the Arbamar Methodist Convention Grounds were drawing tourists to the community and town lots were being sold as quickly as they became available In May 1904,the Los Angeles Tames noted that materials were being shipped to Huntington Beach for construction of the electric railway from Los Angeles to Huntington Beach via Long Beach In 1909, Huntington Beach was formally incorporated and THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-2 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT encompassed an area of 3 57 square miles While agriculture helped sustain the local economy,the beach and Huntington Beach pier were the most important tourist attractions in the city The Huntington Beach Oil Field was the first of the Los Angeles basin oil fields discovered in Southern California in the 1920s, transforming the area into an urban oil boom town overnight and resulting in an acute housing shortage Within a year and a half, the city's population had grown from just over 1,600 to 7,000 people, with another 4,000 job seekers without a place to stay The maximum production of the Huntington Beach Field was reached on July 13, 1923 at 127,163 barrels per day from 199 wells By early 1929, the major oil companies were suffering an oversupply of oil Standard Oil shut down 30 producing wells in Huntington Beach,which marked the end of the era of the early oil booms Like other Southern California beach communities, Huntington Beach offered a variety of outdoor recreation pursuits associated with the Pacific Ocean Early-day residents and visitors to the city pursued activities such as bathing and surf-fishing Today, it is difficult to separate the sport of surfing from Huntington Beach,which for many has become a commercial business and way of life Thanks to the efforts of pioneering surfing greats like Duke and Freeth followed by Higgins and Belsth, surf contests became popular during the late 1920s and early 1930s, and surfing gained mainstream popularity in the 1950s which led to the establishment of surf clubs, surf shops, and the city's moniker "Surf City USA" By the early 1960s surfing had become a mainstream part of life in Huntington Beach The first surf shop in Huntington Beach opened in 1956, and the West Coast Surfing Championships brought tourists to the city to support its growing infrastructure In January of 1944, the United States Navy unveiled plans to build an ammunition depot on 5,000 acres of land within an area that is now within the City of Seal Beach In November of 1944, the new facility was commissioned as the United States Naval Ammunition and Net Depot at Seal Beach Hundreds of civilian jobs were created in addition to the large number of naval personnel Nearly the same time, Douglas Aircraft completed a new plant in Long Beach,and the combination of the two facilities resulted in increased demand for housing in Huntington Beach and nearby communities The number of automobiles had increased since the 1920s and was, by the early 1940s, the principle mode of transportation in Huntington Beach World War II brought a brief resurgence in the popularity of rail travel In fact,rail ridership hit an all-time high in 1944 During the 1950s with the development of an interstate highway system, increased sales of automobiles, the usefulness and efficiency of rail lines, particularly along the coast,began to wane Following World War II, factories and businesses previously outfitted for wartime production began to retool in order to address the quickly evolving post-war economy Servicemen and women returning home from the war, a rapid rise in the birth rate in the country, and the creation of maritime ports such as Long Beach,together created a marked need for new housing throughout Southern California Unlike other communities in Southern California, much of the land base within the city of Huntington Beach was in active oil production Oil derricks remained a part of the city's landscape and were interspersed among cottages and businesses Agricultural production continued to serve an important role in the local economy Much of the land originally used for agricultural purposes remained until the 1960s and 1970s By 1960 Huntington Beach had grown from 3 57 square miles to over 25 square miles as a result of a series of farmland annexations The city had become the fastest growing in the continental United States THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN 11-HCR-3 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT in the 1970s. Today, Huntington Beach reflects many phases of the city's development from early twentieth century cottages intermixed with mid-century modern residences, and large tracts of post-war housing development. It has remained a tourist destination, with numerous visitors coming to experience the city's vast waterfront. After over 100 years of incorporation, Huntington Beach is home to nearly 190,000 residents as of 2010. 2. Architectural Resources The buildings within Huntington Beach are comprised of a variety of architectural styles. These styles serve as a physical background to understanding the history and culture of the Huntington Beach area. The following describes predominant architectural styles that remain in Huntington Beach today. Many of these styles, both business and residential, were in use coincident with each other and not only in the particular era designated here. a. Brick or Wood Front Commercial(1850-1940) Brick or Wood Front Commercial buildings were constructed " ­Afthroughout Southern California beginning in the 1850s. 47 Wit ' Variations include brick-front facades; Italianate facades; classically-inspired brick, stone, or stucco-faced facades; arcaded blocks; and false-front designs. All these variations ,. 1 applied to commercial architecture in Huntington Beach have their antecedents in the Northeast and the Midwest. Each design could be adapted individually or in groupings, often- times sharing a common wall. Character defining features ' — include 1-3 stories in height; 3-5 bays; classical detailing;brick and iron cladding and decoration, a flat roof with a parapet; columns; decorative pilasters; dentils; cornices; double-entrance doors; deeply-set windows; store-front windows; continuous sills; corbelling; oriels; belt courses; round or arched windows; and, in the case of false-front designs, a flat roof or gable roof behind the front parapet. Parapets often varied from a stepped gable, semi-circular gable,pedimented stepped gable,to a triangular pediment. b. Queen Anne(1880-1910) Queen Anne,Queen Anne Cottage, Shingle and Eastlake are all style variations on the Victorian theme that occur in Huntington Beach's residential structures. 4 "hig Victorian, in American architecture,refers to styles that were popularized during the last decades of Britain's Queen ...E s elisp Victoria's reign(1837-1901). Victorian styles clearly reflect industrialization changes in their elaborate detailing and '? ? decorative components such as irregular elevations, frequently broken up by towers or bay windows and the exteriors decorated with spindles, fretwork, sawnwork and - elaborate scrollwork. Queen Anne architecture" is a misnomer because the style drew no inspiration from the formal Renaissance architecture that dominated Queen Anne of England's reign(1792-1714). It was named and THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-4 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT popularized by a group of English architects who borrowed the visual vocabulary of late medieval styles, including half timbering and patterned surfaces. The William Watts Sherman house in Newport, Rhode Island, built by Boston architect Henry Hobson Richardson and featuring a half-timbered second story, is recognized as the first Queen Anne style house built in America. The British government introduced the Queen Anne style to America with several buildings it constructed for the 1876 Centennial Exposition in Philadelphia, and helped to launch a style that soon replaced Second Empire as the country's most popular and fashionable domestic architecture style. e. Late Victorian Era Vernacular(1900-1915) At the turn of the century America's love of Victorian ideals Chi— began to wane, and builders transitioned from ornamented Queen Anne designs to more simple, and less ornamented )c- a styles. Late Victorian architecture in Huntington Beach is characterized by buildings that retain certain elements of Victorian architecture, including fenestration, porches, but way r I I1 �, reveal indications of the development of Craftsman and k .• a Bungalow Architecture. One sub-type of the Late Victorian = Vernacular was the Cross-Gable Cottage house style, T s ° developed from late nineteenth century designs found in � many Southern California communities. The cross gable provided an additional projection that was relatively simple to design and build, and offered additional space for bedrooms and a kitchen. Another important subtype of the Late Victorian Vernacular homes is the Hipped Roof Cottage house. The residence is characterized by its square massing, single-story height, and hipped roof. Homes were designed with a half or full front porch as is seen in the house on the left. The ornamentation of these homes generally includes brackets under the roof eaves, gingerbread and fretwork above the porch columns, and a symmetrical or asymmetrical facade. In other cases the homes lacked any significant ornamentation and followed the transitional styles associated later with Arts and Crafts and Craftsman Bungalow houses. d.. Neoclassical Box Beach Residences(1900-1912) Neoclassical homes became popular during the early decades of � the twentieth century in Huntington Beach. These homes emphasize a rectangular volume with classical ornamental detailing. The residences are covered by a moderately-pitched - hipped or pyramid roof and often have small dormers. The entry is recessed under the principal roof and is either a partial width porch on the corner or a full width front porch supported R. by columns. The windows are tall and narrow double or single hung wood windows and sometimes have decorative multi-light windows on the upper pane. These residences were typically small and boxy in form with slightly boxed eaves and wide cornice bands under the eaves. The siding is typically horizontal dropped siding. This revival of interest in the classical models dates from the World's Colombian Exposition held in Chicago in 1893. The expositions' planners mandated a classical theme, and many of the best-known THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Il-HCR-5 Commu IITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT architects of the day designed dramatic colonnaded buildings arranged around a central court. The exposition was widely photographed, reported, and attended; soon these Neo-classical and Colonial Revival models became the latest fashion throughout the country. e. Cottage Bungalows(1912-1940) The quintessential single-family residential unit developed on much of California's coast, was the "beach cottage" or "cottage bungalow." The beach cottage was adopted by many builders as an economical solution to more expensive custom homes. While beach cottages were designed in a variety of styles, including Craftsman, Bungalow, Mediterranean, the fundamental architectural characteristics were its relatively simple design and modest size. Three distinguishable wood- " V frame varieties can be found throughout portions of IOU Huntington Beach, including the front-gable, the side-gable, and the hipped roof design. Variations of these examples are ii also found with stucco exterior cladding. Cottages in the Huntington Beach area were commonplace from the beginning of the 201h century through the 1950s. They were constructed by individuals as second homes or as worker's housing for those working in the nearby oil fields. Indicative to Huntington Beach was the relocation of these modest homes as the oil companies moved their operations from area to area. This category includes small, modest homes, beach cottages and California Bungalows. The word Bungalow can be traced to India, where in the 19th century,the British used it to describe a one story house with a high encircling porch. In California,the term is applied to houses that have similar characteristics but their design concepts derive from completely different antecedents. The California Bungalows drew much of their influence from the small-scale, one-story, Queen Anne-style cottages that were profusely built throughout California between 1880 and 1890. It was this basic form in which architects brought elements of the craftsman movement,the Stick Style and others into a very distinct American synthesis. This style of homes primarily served as beach resort cottages and modest housing for those in Huntington Beach. Exterior wall surfaces are covered with board and baton clapboard or stucco. These houses are built of a single story with a porch or porches. Their windows are wood hung in either double-hung or casement. f. Craftsman/Bungalow(1905-1930) The Craftsman style was born in California and drew inspiration from the Arts and Crafts movement and its focus on natural materials. Widely disseminated through pattern books and magazines, it became the most prevalent style for small houses in the nation until the Great Depression. One and 1% story Craftsman style houses are popularly known as bungalows. The craftsman house is one of the few indigenous American styles inspired by the work of two Southern Californian t brothers, Charles and Henry Greene. The theme of the craftsman construction emphasized function and beauty while utilizing local materials to blend with local landscapes. The craftsman style became increasingly popularized through various publications, and as result, a flood of pattern books offered plans for craftsman THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-6 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HisTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT bungalows. It was through these mechanisms that the craftsman house quickly became the most popular and fashionable house style in the country. In common with the Prairie style, the hallmark of a Craftsman house is its roof. In this case, it is generally a shallow gable (versus hipped) roof with overhanging eaves and visible roof beams and rafters. Pull or partial-width porches with tapered square supports, often of stone or concrete block, are typical. Characteristic bungalow windows are double-hung with rectangular divided lights in the top sash and a single light in the bottom sash. The Craftsman style experienced a peak in popularity in Southern California during the early 1920s. and Huntington Beach was no different. The city has a wealth of architectural resources in this style. Most are single-family residences, although there are also Craftsman apartment buildings. There were modest bungalows, as well as more substantial Craftsman examples, including those that are two-stories in height. Craftsman homes began to be constructed from about 1905, although the boom period for this style within Huntington Beach did not appear to occur until the 1910s. The character defining features include horizontal wood board cladding and multi-front gabled (often low-pitched) roofs. There is often a primary gabled roof at the facade, and a secondary roof at the porch below. The wide overhanging eaves had exposed rafters, and extended and/or elaborated rafter ends. There are frequently decorative vented openings, false beams and/or stickwork within the gable. Tapered (often heavy) squared pilasters are used as porch supports. There are wood windows with multiple panes above a single pane(sometimes flanked by double hung sash windows) at the facade. The other windows are also often double hung sash, sometimes with lamb's tongues; the main window at the first floor facade often consisted of a fixed window with multiple panes at the top, flanked by double hung sash windows. The Craftsman windows are typically surrounded by wide casings. g. Eclectic and Revivalist(1920-1940) ' The Eclectic movement began near the end of the 19th century and embraced a variety of Old World architectural i` traditions. Emphasizing careful copies of historic patterns, it spawned a number of period revival styles that coexisted i'll,hil' in friendly competition, including Colonial Revival, Tudor/English Cottage Revival, Neoclassical, and Italian Renaissance Revival. The Tudor Revival style in America was based loosely on MR medieval English architecture. Enormously popular in the 1920s and 1930s, it benefited from advances in masonry veneering technique that allowed for the re- creation of English brick and stucco facades. Steeply pitched roofs, prominent cross gables, half- timbering, large chimneys with chimney pots, and tall narrow windows with multi-pane glazing are the hallmarks of the Tudor Revival style. Entrance doorways, typically arched, are often elaborated with brick surrounds mimicking quoins. Multi-pane casement windows in groups of three or more are common. THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-7 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT h. Mediterranean,Spanish,and Mission Revival(1920-1940) For the first three decades of its existence,the architecture : .. of Huntington Beach was largely defined by Late- ` Victorian or Arts and Crafts (Craftsman) styles. Not until the late 1920s and 1930s did the developers op s and builders "N begin to expand the architectural horizons of the iatU community to include Mediterranean styles of civic buildings, businesses, and residences. The use of architectural elements and designs indigenous to the countries surrounding the Mediterranean Sea began to take hold in the late-19th century and reached its apogee at the San Diego exhibition in 1915. There were several styles that quickly gained popularity - most notably Spanish-Colonial derived from Spain, Mexico, and South America, and Mission, derived from Spanish Missions in California and the American Southwest. h1 later years other sub-forms developed, referred today as Spanish Revival, Italian-Villa, and Tuscan. Spanish eclectic architecture is another term applied to the various forms of Mediterranean design, characterized by asymmetrical shapes with cross-gables and side wings; low pitched roofs; red roof tiles; little or no overhanging eaves; stucco siding; courtyards; carved doors; spiral columns and pilasters; carved stonework or cast ornaments; patterned tile floors and wall surfaces; and arches, especially over doors, porch entries and main windows. Domestic buildings of Spanish precedent built before 1920 are, for the most part, free adaptations of the mission style. Not until the Panama-California Exposition of 1915, held in San Diego, did the precise imitation of more elaborate Spanish prototypes received greater attention. The interpretations focused on the richness of Spanish precedents and architectural traditions that were observed throughout Latin America. The style features low pitched roofs, usually with little or no overhang, and red tile roof coverings. The floor plans are typically informal with simple box-like shapes. Prominent arches are usually placed above the door, principle windows or just beneath the porch's roof. Wall surfaces are almost always stucco on an asymmetrical facade. i. Bungalow Courts(1920-1940) The development of Bungalow Courts provided affordable -� housing during a period of growth in the oil boom industry l in Huntington Beach. The numerous courts in Huntington Beach developed from three typological and stylistic ' � sources: the bungalow courts of the early 20th century s _ whose antecedents began in Southern California; auto courts or motor courts; and popular architecture styled zs_ i after Traditional and Mediterranean designs. The typical 4wi . " - character defining features of bungalow courts include multiple small single-family residences that open into a central courtyard area. The units may be attached or detached, but all have separate entrances and porches facing the inner court. Architectural styles may include Craftsman bungalow or Spanish Colonial Revival detailing. THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN 11-HCR-8 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOLiRCES ELEMENT j. Art Deco(1925-1940) The term Art Deco was coined from the Exposition des Arts Decoratifs held in Paris in 1925. Robert Mallet- Stevens (1886-1945) helped promote Art Deco .. - ed Europe.in E e. In the United architecture as it developed p p States Art Deco was embraced Y Y b Raymond Hood who - �* v—s-A"_ 1 "qjQd designed three of the most distinctive buildings in New aY ' York City: the Radio City Music Hall auditorium and foyer, the RCA building at Rockefeller Center, and the New York Daily News building. Rectilinear designs, vivid color, strong lines and undulating, repeating patterns are a trademark of Art Deco design, especially in the Deco buildings of the 1930s. Some buildings are embellished with flowing waterfall effects, while others present colors in bold, geometric blocks. But, Art Deco design is about more than color and ornamental patterns. The very shape of these buildings expresses a fascination for orderly forms and primitive architecture. The typical character defining features of Art Deco buildings include an emphasis on blocked massing, horizontal ornamentation, symmetry, rounded corners or cornices, stepped parapets, flat rooflines, stylized vertical motifs such as pilasters or integrated stripped Classical ornamentation. k. Zigzag Moderne(1925-1940) The zigzag moderne style of architecture is an off shoot of Art Deco design, which originated in France in the 1910s _ and became popular in the United States in the 1920s and 30s. Zigzag Modeme is highly decorative with the fapade of L r buildings utilizing geometric ornamentation. It was popular on commercial storefronts in urban areas and large public buildings, especially high rise buildings such as hotels and _ movie theaters, skyscrapers, and restaurants. It utilized expensive and exotic materials and veneers as well as steel and glass. In contrast to the Streamline Modeme and Art Deco styles, the ornamentation emphasized verticality and geometric motifs such as zigzags, swags, and corbels. It often exhibits a smooth exterior surface material and often included tilework, wood veneers, marble, painted terra-cotta and metals on the lower facades. L Minimalist/Minimal Traditional(1940-1960) Minimalist Architectural designs were a product of the modern era of architecture beginning during World War II - and continuing into the 1950s. Designed for working class families, minimalist buildings are generally modest in size and ornamentation, often-times built as tracts, but almost always exhibiting design elements that veered away from T Emi' the earlier Craftsman and Bungalow styles. In Huntington each minimalist homes appear during the early 1940s perhaps in response to the very modest cottage homes of the oil boom years. The typical character defining features of minimal traditional buildings include compact massing, low pitched multi-gable or hipped roofs with shallow eaves, modest ornamentation, inset porches under the THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-9 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT principal roofline, simple wood post porch supports, single car garages (attached or detached), oriel windows'. simple surrounds, smooth stucco exteriors or simple wood board exterior siding (or a combination thereof). m. California Ranch (1930-1970) Sometimes called the California ranch style, this home in the Modern architectural family, originated in the 1930s by 01 architects such as Cliff May. It emerged as one of the most popular American styles in the 1950s and 60s, when the automobile had replaced early 20th-century forms of transportation, such as streetcars. Now mobile homebuyers h< .a ilia 3. ti could move to the suburbs into bigger homes on bigger lots. The style originated as a reflection of the Rancho type IM of architecture with an emphasis toward an inner courtyard - and privacy toward the street. It implemented interior — —— "corridors" and often had a splayed plan or sprawling plan. Smaller versions or "ranchettes" implemented the same design concepts in a compact manner. The decorative details to the exterior take their cues from the spare and hardy practicality of western styles like Monterrey Spanish Colonial, Prairie and Craftsman homes as well as the Western False Front shops and board & batten mining shacks popularized by Wild West epics of the era like High Noon and How the West Was Won. It is characterized by its one-story, pitched-roof construction, attached garage, wood or brick exterior walls, and picture windows. n. Modern and Neo-Eclectic(1935-1970) The International and Modernistic styles, emphasizing horizontals, flat roofs, smooth wall surfaces, and large window expanses, renounced historic precedent in a radical 1 departure from the revival styles. Most suburban d y "g ar - , k k }� houses built since 1935 fall into the Modern style category. These include the familiar forms we call Cape (officially termed minimal traditional), ranch, split-level and contemporary. The one-story ranch house form, designed by a pair of California architects, was the prevailing style during the 1950s and 1960s. Contemporary was the favored style for architect-built houses between 1950 and 1970. Neo-Eclecticism, which emerged in the mid-1960s and supplanted the Modern style, represented a return to traditional architectural styles and forms. It includes Mansard, Neo-Colonial, Neo-French, Neo-Tudor, Neo- Mediterranean, Neo-Classical, and Neo-Victorian. These styles borrow prominent details from historic models in bold, free interpretations. o. Courtvard Apartments(1950-1975) Evolving from the Bungalow Courts of the 1920s and 1930s, a revival of sorts began in the 1960s that resulted in " - the development of multi-unit apartments with interior courtyards. The designs in Huntington Beach were more whimsical, often including Polynesian motifs. THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-10 COMMUNTTY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT 3. Historic Resources The City of Huntington Beach has played an important role in the development of California and that history is visible today through the City's built environment. As such the City has an interest in preserving, promoting and improving the historic resources and districts within Huntington Beach for the educational, cultural, economic and general welfare of the public. In 1986, the City conducted a survey documenting the historic core of the City of Huntington Beach. From 2008-2012, the City and Historic Resources Board (HRB) updated and expanded the previous survey to include a study of all potentially significant buildings within the entire city. The historic survey identified several buildings that were either individually eligible for the National Register, California Register of Historical Resources, or that may have significance at the local level. The survey also updated and identified concentrations of buildings that qualify as historic districts. of potentially historic properties, which The City of Huntington Beach maintains a master inventory po y p p , comprises all the properties within the city that have been identified as potentially having historic significance. This inventoryis periodically updated and is used to assist the City with managing its short p y p and long term historic preservation goals. The determination of historical significance was based on methodology that is consistent with the State of California Office of Historic Preservation's (OHP) guidance as outlined in Instructions for Recording Historic Resources and the Department of the Interior's National Park Service Bulletin 24 Guidelines for Local Surveys: A Basis for Preservation Planning. The California Office of Historic Preservation has established a series of status codes, which identify the historical status of the property. The California Historical Resource Status Codes are codes that were created by OHP as a database tool to classify historical resources in the state's inventory which had been identified through a regulatory process or local government survey. The code system was initially created as National Register Status Codes in 1975 but has since been updated and changed in 2004 due to the ambiguity of the early coding system and changes in the needs of local governments' registration programs statewide to convey the significance of resources for purposes of the CEQA. Implicit within the status codes is a hierarchy reflecting the level of identification, evaluation and designation to which a property had been subjected. The following table identifies the list of historic status codes. THE CITY OF HliNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-I I COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT California Historical Resource Status Codes 1 Properties listed in the National Register(NR)or the California Register(CR) _D Conti tutor t a tst,'r ni m.i-tiple-i s z;ic_e ope t;'l tecl in NR by diekeep:r.Listed n the CR. Individual piupeity lictec'n NR by -re Keppeir,Listed in flip CR. 1CD L te.7 in the rR,,,s a cwti itrtor t j a dktric i n-witil l .sour•:_e n l._rt� by Vile Sl CS 111sted in the CR .s ndin du:l pcopei W by t'-€e SHRC. 1CL =t t i at-,IIy llStac n tile r_alifcrn a ^a sza-Includes. afF i L=it�1ln-ai> :7r ,nd above and Poia)t;:f HMsru ir:a? I it. at nominated afar Dec =•rL- r 1997 and r+n rnrrend -d fc.-listing by tPic Si 2 Properties determined eligible for fisting in the National Register(NR),or the California Register(CR) s L� minpd elialblp fu! NR as ar,.LndhAdual ur,p_tty and is a=onh iLut,�r tr an-ligible d sttj=in a f_:!_al=eqljlaTory pit cess_ Listed in tyre CR, ZD Contributor frja rEstrict d t rninrd eligible t_i R by the K epei.Ls e�J in the CR. ZDZ -,,ntJbLi-or t a d st`,r deteirik I&igible t_r lR by:onse€Tsus th i.rh spite°1 196 p, es,.List in the r-R. cut r t-,, di_ is dete=rtai-r d elialible t r i R b;Rarr -Ix, atioia Liste-in the C.R. D I C)iihi'r.9for t a di__+_ rJ to mine-I halble t_r h; Purs.i it r�ti stir+n a6t;,,iri, ut,ev e.uy SHP0.Listed in-yip CR. ZS I uir•idual_i€ i erty.- rm n_rr,e_€irrle for NF by,'Pre Keotpe,.List,d In tyre(=R. `2 1 Ai id al n l rt ^dp rn,n c a€p,€ '�ir NR--�y a oni er a Moi ih e ion W,,,i i cr s.Listed in he C---R. S3 I uJ.ub,nl,€ _sty de_rn n_c r i P. of Par,by Pat 1 Tax r-rtn_ari_i. n th'_CR. Z54 I�di-ridual;€ her y Je naa d e,igilbit"or NP 1111-ianr P Se--ion lJc without ie ie:u by SHPi.L eer_in the CR. ZCEI De--i mined Okllble for CR as-,an isid'ovIdual^i i-eit;=ark i�,i ortnbuter tc n :i;ibis distract by tl SrIRC. KID r. n i rbutcT t7 a lisf is deter raio;e l eliri^hle far istnq in hp CR by the SHRC ZCS Individual:;r c i.eitr detena;ned e i I,ble for li-'snl in the CR bay the.SHRC. 3 Appears eligible for National Register(NR)or California Register(CR)through Survey Evaluation 3P 5i eligibie fcor NP Itinftl indib dually and as a t=ontr€ uto_to a NR el€gi=,iµ disbict through sruv , _valuation. 3D Appears eligiL e fe, NP,a_a na i in uticr to a NP-ligibie r:istrie t throi-gh sury y-valuation. 3S Ali- a,3 ellgi--ie for NR as an in;liVir ual Prof _y thnC.ir h_e.rVey Nva unzio,n. 3C8 Appear. elb il. _to CR be h indlvi i.a,lu and as a^:nFh ib tal to a i R _,igllrle ur_tiict('-sough a sJI-Vey evaluation€. StCD po a s el oarL_to r=R_s i"ontr€ �,�-s-to a r k irilble Jr tiict the Di gii a sUrveg�evalu,tdfjn. 'tCS �l a-_el:3i --far CR y_a1 tridi r.-,i i.rap i tl r:or;r l _t r;ey ev rat+r+n. 4 Appears eligible for National Register(NR)or California Register(CR)through other evaluation 4i 1' -r List i r Cr;i d P-opeiti,- -PRC s5024. S Properties Recognized as Historically Significant by Local Government 5DQ (u.tu._itDr t d st i that is listed or-lpsin ated locally. 5D2 _iitrihu=ar to a distic ha,is ell i,e for (,cai listing-)r designaticn. 5D3 Appeir�to bea nr_lbutur to a listrif t that au'p.ar7 eligible for r ai i tii ig,r desirmadon thnoutgh u.!ey e✓aiLv;tion. 551 I. lrtulr al_€ d arty that is lisued or icnat c'vocally. stiZ I d tuli_al ,ii ipeity that is elicrible t_r al ii tnq rij ce r,(inn. 5S ^I R a,s to be it ividUl q p igib'ie-fro I,r.al lAng -o Se`i n(ion h-nowh u. aaa rion. 5B L by siclnir c rat both individually(listed,eligi ue,ar al_ e-licli s-1 and as a,ointiiburca to.;cdut,_-th,yt i :co dy lusted, d-_innated, etamine iiibla cr a1)[_i=.rs illibe tlu-'i11f-1 SUPi-'Y -v oche-n. 6 Not Eligible for Listing or Designation as specified 6-- D t-imin-aJ inrdraihlefor -r_.taevk frnrn California Regi,t:-bey SHRC. i Land;,a ai ks or Paints Of IntFrest f,t.nd inpliai_,_for designation L'^y SHRC. i;L D_t_irninpd insigiblefoi local listu g _r designation th _i gh i fai i vIeby+ , _ _,map wa-rant speda>^.on_ldenation in lc(-Al I:ianwnr. bT D t trnined injighle foci NR throe r h Part I Tax Certification pmrc ss, 6U Este mimed inek-li ie for NRpuisuant 0 Section 101j,ritiiout rev t Cy 5HF'C?. 61."v Rercv-er fiain NR by the KeaPyer. 6b; Dete-mined iraeli jble for the NR by SHRC or Keeppr. by D-t_mined ineilgihle for NR by conseirsus th rvLtgn SeCti-_n 106 pi or es, N s'va rated i..r CR:or Loral Lists;n. aZ Fcu rd iiaellable for NR.CR of Lr:or ai deSigilitil thrvtrq r •i= =y e ValiJaation. 7 Not Evaluated for National Register(NR)or California Register(CR)or Needs Revaluation 7i R e ed-; :,BHP foe e^.aluaiion•r artion I;ut not yet eea;uater. 7., FF o Lrnitted to OHP f action'i a not ie-valtiated. 7L ,tafe Hl,tn it al Land^.,ks 1 .ia-a,d Point Of Hktoric7 Irt_test jec.jojljteci prior to lanivary1`-€nh Needs ro b --e'-air_ated' _is€ng itIent ctasv_laIds. 7I-1 ZSul mitten'.to€THP beat_, t .vaivated-referred r:o NIPS. N r is to to r,�- airiated(F:niw z NR St-a-M5 Code 4) 7N1 t-_d,to be eevaluaft cl(Fcn,rn'�>°NF SC4) may become dickle fc r NR ,r t:oratirn oi Caen meets otlr_i _l. Marie cmelticins. 7P- Identified In Re annals ar e Leve'`;uivey:Not eva'it.ate. 71.11J i•bmitteci to r3Hl)-rr tics- A'Lh--L,, . 13 3r THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-12 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT a. National Register of Historic Places The National Register of Historic Places is the Nation's official last of cultural resources worthy of preservation Authorized under the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966, the National Register is part of a national program to coordinate and support public and private efforts to identify, evaluate, and protect our historic and archeological resources Properties listed in the Register include distracts, sites, buildings, structures, and objects that are significant in American history, architecture, archeology, engineering, and culture The National Register is administered by the National Park Service, which is part of the US Department of the Interior The criteria for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places include those properties that are A Associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of our history, or B That are associated with the lives of persons significant in our past, or C That embody the distinctive characteristics of a type, period, or method of construction or that represent the work of a master, or that possess high artistic values, or that represent a significant and distinguishable entity whose components may lack individual distinction,or D That has yielded,or may be likely to yield, information important in prehistory or history b. California Register of Historical Resources The California State Historical Resources Commission has designed this program for use by state and local agencies, private groups and citizens to identify, evaluate, register and protect California's historical resources The California Register is the authoritative guide to the state's significant historical and archeological resources The California Register program encourages public recognition and protection of resources of architectural, historical, archeological and cultural significance, identifies historical resources for state and local planning purposes, determines eligibility for state historic preservation grant funding and affords certain protections under the California Environmental Quality Act The criteria for inclusion in the California Register of Historical Resources include any object, building, structure, site, area, place, record, or manuscript which a lead agency determines to be historically significant or significant in the architectural, engineering, scientific, economic, agricultural, educational, social, political, military, or cultural annals of California may be considered to be an historical resource,provided the lead agency's determination is supported by substantial evidence in light of the whole record Generally, a resource shall be considered by the lead agency to be "historically significant" if the resource meets the criteria for listing on the California Register of Historical Resources (Pub Res Code SS5024 1,Title 14 CCR, Section 4852)including the following 1 Is associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of California's history and cultural heritage, 2 Is associated with the lives of persons important in our past, 3 Embodies the distinctive characteristics of a type,period,region, or method of construction,or represents the work of an important creative individual, or possesses high artistic values, or 4 Has yielded, or may be likely to yield, information important in prehistory or history THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-13 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT The California Register of Historical Resources was not created until 1998 by an act of the State Legislature Under the provisions of that legislation, the following resources are automatically included in the California Register • Resources formally determined eligible for, or listed in,the National Register of Historic Places through federal preservation programs administered by the Office of Historic Preservation, including the National Register program,the Tax Certification program,National Historic Preservation Act Section 106 reviews of federal undertakings, • State Historical Landmarks(SHL)numbered 770 or higher, and • Points of Historical Interest(PHI)recommended for listing in the California Register by the State Historical Resources Commission c. City of Huntington Beach Historic Landmarks The City does not currently have official criteria for local listing Therefore, for the survey update the project team used the California Register of Historical Resources criteria as a basis for local significance During this process each of the criteria were adjusted to relate to the local history of Huntington Beach As a result of the historic survey update,the following status codes were assigned to properties located in the City of Huntington Beach For a complete inventory of properties identified in the city, refer to the City of Huntington Beach's Historic Context& Survey Report and subsequent updates,maintained in the City's Planning and Building Department Following is a description of the status codes identified in Huntington Beach • 1S Individual property listed in the NR by the Keeper Listed in the CR This status code was given to any property that is currently listed on the National Register These properties were not re-evaluated as part of this survey (Included in updated Landmark List,Historical Resource for the purposes of CEQA, Eligible for federal tax credits) • 3S. Appears eligible for NR as an individual property through survey evaluation. This status code was given to properties evaluated on DPR 523 B forms and found to be eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places (Included in updated Landmark List,Historical Resource for the purpose of CEQA) • 3CB. Appears eligible for CR both individually and as a contributor to a CR eligible district through survey evaluation This status code was given to properties evaluated using the DPR 523 B form and found to be eligible for listing on the CR both individually and as the contributor to a CR eligible district (Included in updated Landmark List,Historical Resource for the purpose of CEQA) • 3CD. Appears eligible for CR as a contributor to a CR eligible district through survey evaluation This status code was given to properties that were evaluated using the District Record Form and found to be contributors to a historic district eligible for listing on the CR (Included in updated Landmark List, Historical Resource for the purpose of CEQA) • 3CS Appears eligible for CR as an individual property through survey evaluation This status code was given to properties that were evaluated using the DPR 523B form THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN 11-HCR-14 COMMUNn'Y DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESO URGES ELEMENT and found to be individually eligible for listing on the CR (Included in updated Landmark List,Historical Resource for the purpose of CEQA) • 5S1 Individual property that is listed or designated locally This status code was given to all the extant (non-altered) properties from the previous Landmark List on the City's General Plan This includes only the historic architectural properties (Included in updated Landmark List,Historical Resource for the purpose of CEQA) • 5S1/7N1- This status code was given to properties that are currently listed on the Landmark List that have been altered, but the alterations are reversible These properties would require rehabilitation/restoration to qualify as a historic property today (Not included on updated Landmark List-Not a historical resource per CEQA) • 5S2. Individual property that is eligible for local listing This status code was given to properties that were previously evaluated in 1986 and given the status code of 5S2 and had not been significantly altered since the previous evaluation (Included in updated Landmark List,Historical Resource for the purpose of CEQA) • 6L. Determined ineligible for local listing or designation through local government review process, may warrant special consideration in local planning This status code was given to 1) non-contributing buildings located within historic district boundaries 2) properties previously identified in the 1986 survey that were still intact but do not appear to meet NR or CR criteria today, and 3) newly identified properties constructed prior to 1959 that received a DPR 523A form but upon further evaluation did not appear to meet NR or CR criteria today These properties did not receive a DPR 523B form (Not included on updated Landmark List-Not a historical resource per CEQA) • 6Z. Found ineligible for NR, CR or Local designation through survey evaluation This status code was given to properties that were evaluated under the established contexts but did not meet any criteria,had poor integrity or have been demolished since a prior evaluation (Not included on updated Landmark List-Not a historical resource per CEQA) • 7N. Needs to be re-evaluated This status code was given to properties that 1) were not visible from the public right of way (due to fences, landscaping, or distance from public right of way), or 2) were located within post World War II suburban tract developments that may constitute a historic district at a later date Although the latter do not appear eligible at the time of this survey, additional research and evaluation in the future may find an entire tract development eligible if it meets NR or CR criteria in the future (Not included on updated Landmark List-Not a historical resource per CEQA) • 7N1 Needs to be reevaluated- may become eligible for NR w/restoration or when meets other specific conditions This status code was given to 1) properties that have been relocated or are currently under restoration, and 2) properties that were previously identified on the Landmark List in the City's General Plan that have since been altered (Not included on updated Landmark List-Not a lustorical resource per CEQA) • 7R. Identified in Reconnaissance Level Survey Not Evaluated This status code was given to properties that were recorded in the property inventory spreadsheet but was not THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-15 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL REsouRCES ELEMENT recorded using a DPR 523 A or B form These properties do not appear at the reconnaissance survey level, within the established contexts for Huntington Beach to be historically significant, however the local Planning and Building Department may determine that additional evaluation may be necessary on a case by case basis through the permitting process if the City, owner, or interested party provides substantial evidence that the property may be historically significant for the purposes of CEQA d. Vulnerability to Change Since the historic survey was originally completed for downtown Huntington Beach in 1985,more than half of Huntington Beach's historical resources have been destroyed and/or demolished Of the three potential historic districts identified by the 1986 survey, two are no longer eligible as historic districts and the boundaries of one has been diminished due to subsequent demolitions and renovations The 2008-2012 historic resources inventory updated the information from 1986 and found that approximately 50% of the buildings identified within the downtown core area have since been significantly altered or demolished The downtown historic resources are extremely vulnerable to change The commercial areas, specifically Main Street,have experienced extreme development pressures to maximize their land uses due to escalating land values Older residential areas have also experienced an increased intensification of development Much of the one-story beach cottage character of downtown has changed to larger three-story beach houses With the development activity occurring in areas of the City with significant historical resources, the City must decide the importance of these resources and what direction should be taken to preserve those elements critical to the character of the City,either onsite or through a historic relocation program The Downtown Specific Plan calls for the creation of a mixed use/commercial intensity use along Main Street and Pacific Coast Highway The zoning allows commercial uses to be multiple stories high, thus applying significant development pressure on smaller, older structures in the vicinity Secondly, the plan identified at one point over 50 percent of the structures in the study area as seismically unstable,stating they must ultimately be improved to meet seismic standards or be demolished e. Availability of Funds Currently,there are no funds available to owners of historic properties within the City of Huntington Beach, particularly for the rehabilitation or relocation of historic buildings The City does not maintain funds specifically for the preservation or relocation of historic properties in danger of demolition or alteration However, as outlined in this Historic and Cultural Resources Element, it is the City's intent to continue to develop and promote financial incentive programs for owners of historic property owners to assist with the ongoing costs of preservation of these limited resources These financial incentives would be in the form of tax abatement programs through the County Assessor (Mills Act program) The City would also provide information to the public within the Planning and Building Department on other available fundmg programs, as they become available The financial incentive programs are only available to properties that are maintained on the City's Landmark list and are outlined in the policies and objectives below THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-16 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT B. CULTURAL,RESOURCES 1. Introduction Over the past twenty years, the City has made great strides in addressing the provision of arts and cultural services to residents and visitors A Cultural Master Plan was adopted in 1994 guiding the development of cultural services and facilities In addition,the City has begun to develop the cultural infrastructure that can provide the range of services residents require While the cultural life of Huntington Beach is quite active, the addition of the new wing of the Huntington Beach Public Library and Cultural Center and the imminent opening of the Huntington Beach Arts Center lend a new, high visibility focus for culture that will have an impact on residents and the entire region This strengthened activity relating to arts and culture is a result of the local residents' desire for a higher profile for arts and cultural activity The city is a composite of identities - "surf', "oil", environmentalism, multiple histories of indigenous inhabitants, agriculture,revival meetings,rail and other transportation links All these serve as the building blocks of an exciting and vibrant cultural context offering much to residents and visitors The revitalization of Main Street and its cultural amenities has brought a new image and vitality to downtown Huntington Beach This area has a vibrant but rapidly diminishing assortment of historic structures that enhance a sense of history for both resident and visitor and provide the foundation for a strong community image 2. Existing Conditions a. Cultural Facilities,Artists,and Arts Groups There are a number of cultural facilities in Huntington Beach,including multi-faceted visual and performing arts spaces, historic sites, and outdoor facilities With the recently opened annex to the Huntington Beach Public Library and Cultural Center and the anticipated opening of the Huntington Beach Arts Center in 1994, cultural activities in Huntington Beach will have a strong and visible presence The vitality of the artists and arts groups comprise an active and focused cultural scene in the city Although there are few large or highly structured arts and cultural organizations in Huntington Beach,there is a core of local artists, both professional and amateur, as well as many arts groups that are conducting a wide array of high-quality programs • The soon-to-be opened Huntington Beach Arts Center is a community arts facility that will provide local citizens and a regional audience with opportunities for exposure to and involvement in the visual arts It will have three gallery spaces, a studio, classrooms, meeting rooms, and a bookstore and gift shop, • The City's Parks and Recreation program includes arts and crafts classes held in parks and community centers throughout the city, • The Huntington Beach Public Library and Cultural Center, with its new wing devoted to children, also includes a 300-seat theater,several meeting and classrooms • The Huntington Beach Playhouse is a thirty-year old community theater now performing in the new theater at the library The group presents 16 performances of six shows during the year as well as an outdoor Shakespeare series in Huntington Central Park and a children's Christmas program, THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN 11-HCR-17 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT • The Newland House Museum is a showcase of local lustory operated by the Historical Society and the city In addition to exhibition space in its restored building and barn,there is outdoor space for additional exhibits and special events in the area between the house and barn, • The International Surfing Museum opened in its first location in 1988 and is presently in a 2,000 square foot renovated space in the downtown Plans to build a new, state-of-the-art museum facility are currently developed, and funding is being sought A "Surfing Walk of Fame" is being established and has received much attention in the international surfing community, • Golden West College has a wide range of cultural facilities and active instructional programs in the arts with an emphasis on both traditional and electronic forms of most artistic media Its program of theater production currently includes about 40 percent non-student actors, • The Huntington Harbour Plulharmonic Committee has an active program of fund-raising for the Orange County Performing Arts Center In addition, the Committee provides a range of programs for public school children, including in-school programs and bus trips to the Performing Arts Center, • The Huntington Beach Concert Band performs in venues around Orange County With about seventy-five members, half of whom are from Huntington Beach, the band has played at City Council meetings,ground-breakings,concerts in Huntington Central Park,and other locations It is the only band of its type in Orange County not supported by a school district, • The School for the Performing Arts at Huntington Beach High School currently has an enrollment of approximately three hundred students and offers classes in dance, theater, music, and television production,and • A wide range of other groups, including the Arts Associates and the Huntington Beach Art League, are also active in the community Many arts and historic groups in the city function on a volunteer basis, without paid staff or permanent facilities Artists have generally not been able to work in the city, primarily because of the cost of renting space and the lack of professional venues in which to exhibit and perform their work b. Resources for Arts Education The quality of arts education in Huntington Beach depends in large measure on the particular school and school district that a clmld attends In part,because there are four school districts in the city,the range and quality of offerings vary Elementary and middle schools rely on classroom teachers to integrate the arts (as a teaclung tool) into the cumculum Middle schools' visual arts, music, band and choir specialists are shared within districts All four high schools have basic instruction in some of the performing arts (generally, some combination of choir,band, drama, and dance)with faculty shared among them Each school has visual arts programs that are run by two visual arts specialists The School for the Performing Arts at the Huntington Beach High School was established to provide advanced performing arts classes and ensembles at the lugh school level It offers a wide array of arts experiences to students citywide While the primary opportunity for providing arts education experiences for cluldren lies with the public schools, there are additional opportunities directed toward children and older residents The City has several programs that have an impact on arts and cultural education The City's HBTV Channel 3 offers a talk show about the arts The new Huntington Beach Arts Center will offer interpretive programs, school tours, and workshops in various media, disciplines and issues The THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-18 COMMUNTTY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT Recreation, Beaches, and Development Division of the Community Services Department offers extensive classes in centers throughout the city,although there are relatively few classes in visual and performing arts Few,if any,classes are offered for teens and adults Classes for children include some crafts and dance The Huntington Beach Public Library and Cultural Center offers a range of cultural programs There is a new children's wing, but because of budgetary constraints, the amount of cultural programming is limited Rental fees for using the facilities are out of range for smaller cultural groups Nonprofit arts and cultural groups in Huntington Beach have played an important role in providing educational opportunities for schoolchildren Among the activities that have been provided are • The Huntington Harbour Philharmonic Committee, in addition to raising money for the Orange County Performing Arts Center, coordinates field trips to the center for a variety of tours and performances They also bring ensembles into the schools for assemblies that can include performance and demonstrations of instruments They sponsor the "Music Mobile"which travels to elementary schools to introduce third graders to musical instruments, • The Newland House Museum offers tours of its facility to schools, primarily third and fourth graders who are studying local and California history In addition, the Historical Society offers special 2 hour tours of the facility, and • The Japan America Society has developed a cultural program for schools, building on the Sister City Program c. The Role of the Cultural Services Division&Advisory Board of the City of Huntington Beach The Cultural Services Division is responsible for an array of activities, including oversight of construction and program development for the new Huntington Beach Arts Center and overseeing historic and cultural programs in the community At the present time,its primary roles are that of manager of many of the city's existing arts programs and presenter of visual arts activities There are other roles of the division,including serving as a "catalyst" to assist local arts groups in promotion, location space, fund-raising for cultural projects, and capital project oversight The Allied Arts Board is designated to advise City Council on all matters pertaining to the arts in Huntington Beach It was responsible for developing the initial ten-year plan for cultural activities that led to the establishment of the Cultural Services Division as well as other important milestones in the development of the cultural life of the city Along with the Historic Resources Board (which oversees historic programs and activities), the Allied Arts Board, in its role as advisor to the City Council, can, among other things, study and interpret the needs of the community for cultural programs and facilities, recommend cultural policy on such matters as programming, facilities, and funding, assist local arts groups to better fulfill their missions, and encourage individuals, civic groups, and businesses to support arts and culture with time,money,and in-kind services The master plan provides an overview of key issues and a "vision statement" for culture in the city It presents a series of recommendations on the priorities for culture,addresses the role of the Cultural Services Division, identifies the necessary resources to realize the goals articulated through the recommendations, and describes steps toward implementation by the city and arts advocates and organizations THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-19 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT d. Funding for the Arts and Culture Huntington Beach has been generous in its support of arts and cultural activities The recent history of private sector financial support for the Huntington Beach Arts Center, as well as the city's funding of the Cultural Services Division over the past eight years,indicate a trend of increased support Huntington Beach has some very effective,pnvate-sector fund-ralsmg initiatives The Huntington Harbour Philharmonic Committee raises money, some of which goes to support local educational experiences for children around certain types of music The Huntington Beach Arts Center Foundation has raised significant sums of money in support of the construction and programming at the Huntington Beach Arts Center, some of which will involve educational programs for children Fund-raising in Huntington Beach has historically been focused on"bricks and mortar"capital funding The downtown and the Pacific coast areas have been designated as "visitor serving" in the General Plan The City is committed to developing destination attractions and activities in those areas, most of which are seen to be related to arts and culture These attractions and activities include the Huntington Beach Arts Center, the planned Celebration Plaza, arts and craft fairs and festivals, and concerts in Pier Plaza and Huntington Beach Central Park Amphitheater These attractions are bringing visitor dollars to the targeted areas,increasing foot traffic and bringing consumers that increase retail sales e. Urban Design,Aesthetics,and Public Art While the City and the various community groups have taken action to develop a pleasing urban environment, the visual appeal and feel of the city remain key concerns for many residents Residents would like to see a concerted effort undertaken to improve this important aspect of the community Issues regarding landscape and plant selection, hardscape design, building materials, public space allocation and the inclusion of public arts are but a few of the issues raised ISSUES I A citywide inventory of historic resources has been conducted, however the inventory was conducted at a reconnaissance level and therefore is in continual need of revision The State of Califorma recommends that historic resource surveys be updated every five years Continual updating of the City's historic inventory would help identify all structures and sites critical to the overall historic character of the community (HCR I 1 1) 2 The City does not have a Historic Preservation Ordinance or other requirements or guidelines that would help to preserve or protect the Clty's historic landmarks (HCR 114, HCR 12 2, HCR 12 3, HCR 12 4, and HCR 13 7) 3 The City does not currently have a process or procedure to fully mitigate impacts (demolition) of historical resources that are vulnerable to redevelopment within the City Therefore,the City should consider maintaining land for the relocation and protection of historic resources under eminent threat (HCR 121, and HCR 12 3) 4 Downtown commercial and residential areas are experiencing extreme development pressures to maximize their land uses No guidelines exist to protect and/or restore the historic character of these older areas As a result, older structures are being demolished for the construction of new buildings The City is losing the historic character of the area (HCR 113, HCR 1 14, HCR 121, HCR 123, HCR 124, HCR 133, HCR 134, HCR 136, and HCR 137) THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-20 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT S Adaptive reuse has been rarely utilized and should be actively promoted (HCR 13 6) 6 The City does not currently have informational brochures for property owners regarding options for historic property preservation 7 The City's per capita income and education levels are among the highest in the nation These demographics suggest a population likely to have high expectations for services, particularly in the area of arts and cultural activities (HCR 2 2 1, and HCR 3 2 2) 8 Most of the support for arts and culture has come from a relatively narrow spectrum of Huntington Beach residents The percentages of younger families, children and youth, and the populations of Latino and Asian residents are increasing As a result, the mix of arts and cultural programming will have to be designed to meet the needs of a demographically diverse audience Much of the thrust of the Cultural Master Plan involves recognizing the necessity to reach new constituencies,to broaden the programming offered and to identify new sources of financial and political support for the full range of cultural activities (HCR 2 2 1 and HCR 3 2 2) 9 One of the major problems facing cultural and historic groups is the difficulty in obtaining information about access to facilities and financial resources While the Cultural Services Division has an extensive collection of publications on arts issues,historic services,and fund-raising, access to that information is limited (HCR 2 11 and HCR 2 2 2) 10 There is a lack of a ready means of communication within the arts community It will be important to develop mechanisms to address this need for better communication, to allow for more effective sharing of information among artists and groups, and to inform a wider public of cultural activities in the arts community (HCR 2 1 1 and HCR 2 2 2) 11 The ability of small, volunteer cultural/historic groups to handle the managerial aspects of their operations is often limited This is partly due to a lack of sufficient time or grounding in business, space development,and tenant/landlord skills (HCR 212) 12 Recently constructed arts facilities will require time to become fully operational and their impact on the cultural community is necessarily difficult to assess Additional cultural facilities will ultimately be required to address the full range of community needs (HCR S 2 2) 13 Examples of currently underutilized performing arts facilities are • Golden West College has a large amphitheater with seating for about 1,000,it is only minimally used It would require stage and technical support improvements to make it more useful, • The Huntington Beach High School Auditorium, seating about 700, is heavily utilized during the school year, however, it is available during the summer months and might be more fully utilized then Rehabilitation work is needed for the facility to function more effectively for school and community use, • The Huntington Beach Public Library and Cultural Center's utility for arts and cultural groups is presently limited by the lack of staff available for programming and the relatively high rental fees charged to arts and cultural groups for their use, • The grounds of the Newland House Museum and Newland Barn could be used for additional cultural and/or historic programming However, the lack of space for collections and archives warrants the development of a local museum centrally located,and • Existing theatrical spaces are heavily used, so it is clear that there is interest in theater However, there is little performing space available for programming smaller bilingual, multi-cultural performances and experimental productions Renovation of outdoor amphitheaters in city parks is needed to allow for a broader range of programming increased THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-21 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT use by local organizations and increased safety and comfort of audiences (HCR 51 1, HCR 512, and HCR522) 14 Providing opportunities for artists to live and work in Huntington Beach is important to the long-term growth of the city's cultural life There are no affordable artists' spaces for living and working in Huntington Beach in lower cost space in industrial and/or business parks outside of the downtown core or vacant downtown buildings (HCR 5 2.4) 15 There is a need for outdoor interpretive centers to address several aspects of the city's history, notably the Bolsa Chica wetlands and the Native American populations (HCR 5 1 1) 16 While the City is not responsible as the lead public entity to provide arts programs for school age children and youth, it has been a strong advocate for increased attention in this area The public schools in Huntington Beach have cut back programming in arts education in order to address severe budget problems The issue of lack of access to arts training and appreciation course has affected other curriculum efforts to enhance learning in the classroom, to improve school attendance,and to enhance the self-esteem of students,particularly youth at risk (HCR 4 1 2) 17 Currently, there is no one coordinating or fostering long-term relationships between professional artists and the public schools In the elementary schools, for example, programs are either enrichment assemblies or field trips or are provided by classroom teachers rather than professional artists (HCR 4 1 2) 18 Because of the music education programming of the Huntington Harbour Philharmonic Committee and its fund-raising to support those programs,the City's students have access to a range of musical experiences But, while activities in tlus discipline are provided on a consistent basis, others (in particular, drama and the visual arts) are not, unless they are offered on an ad hoc basis by particular teachers or parents (HCR 4 1 2) 19 Without comprehensive funding for arts and culture in all parts of the city, it is very difficult to equitably address the needs of the community A current priority is the need of the Huntington Beach Arts Center to get its programming in place and develop a secure base of endowed support (HCR 5 12 and HCR 5 2 3) 20 The City has been very supportive of cultural activities, responding to impressive community support and fund-raising, yet these very programs are expected to fulfill a no-net-cost requirement The Cultural Services Division is designated as the City's local arts agency and, as a result, is eligible for significant funding available through state and federal sources to such agencies (HCR 5 2 3 and HCR 5 1 4) 21 The visitor industry is seeking ways to promote Huntington Beach as a destination While it is unlikely at the current time that the City's arts groups will be a primary reason for a visit, they certainly can contribute to a lengthened stay The potential for heritage and cultural tourism may provide opportunity for additional funding partnerships (HCR 5 2 1) THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-22 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT GOALS, OBJECTIVES,AND POLICIES Objective HCR12 The following section presents the goals, objectives, Ensure that the City ordinances, programs, and policies policies, and programs for Historic and Cultural create an environment that fosters preservation, Resources in the City of Huntington Beach At the end rehabilitation, and sound maintenance of historic and of each policy is a reference to the appropriate archaeological resources implementation program Each implementation program's schedule and possible funding sources are Policies indicated in the Historic and Cultural Resources HCR 1.21 Implementation Matrix Utilize the State of California Historic Building Code, Secretary of Interior Standards for Historic Historical Resources Rehabilitation, and standards and guidelines as prescribed by the State Office of Historic Preservation Goal as the architectural and landscape design standards for HCR I rehabilitation, alteration,or additions to sites containing To promote the preservation and restoration of the historic resources in order to presen7e these structures in sites, structures and districts which have a manner consistent with the site's architectural and architectural, historical, and/or archaeological historic integrity (I--HCR 1, 1-HCR 3, and 1-HCR 5) significance to the City of Huntington Beach. HCR 12.2 Objective Encourage new development to be compatible with HCR I I adjacent existing historic structures in terms of scale, Ensure that all the City's historically and massing, building materials and general architectural archaeologically significant resources are identified and treatment (I--HCR 6) protected HCR 12.3 Policies Investigate the appropriateness of establishing a HCR 1.1.1 "receiver site" program and explore the opportunity to Continually update the existing citywide survey of integrate historic buildings with cultural and arts potentially historic resources subject to City Council education (I--HCR 1) approval (I-HCR 1) HCR 124 HCR 1.1.2 Investigate the feasibility of initiating an "adopt a Consider the designation of any historically significant building" program to preserve historic structures that public trees, archaeological sites, parks, structures,sites would be removed from their sites (I--HCR 1) or areas deemed to be of historical, archaeological, or Objective cultural significance as a Huntington Beach City HCR 1 Historical Point, Site or District (I-HCR 1, and 1-HCR HCR 2,1-HCR 3,) Consider the provision of incentives (strategies, assistance, and regulations) for the maintenance and/or HCR 113 enhancement of privately owned historic properties in a Consider establishing a historic overlay for historic manner that will conserve the integrity of such resources structures throughout the City The overlay should be in the best possible condition structured to allow the underlying land use to continue as well as support the reuse of the historic structure (I- Policies HCR 1,1-HCR 3,1-HCR 5, and LU 15 3 1) HCR 13.1 Encourage owners of eligible historic income-producing HCR 11.4 properties to use the tax benefits provided by the 1981 Consider recording the importance of oil history in the Tax Revenue Act as well as all subsequent and future City's development (I--HCR 1) financial incentives (I--HCR 1) THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-23 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT HCR 13.2 Policies Consider the waiver of building permit fees for owners HCR 1.4.1 of small properties with historic resources who are Encourage the promotion of the City's historic resources unable to benefit from other government programs for in visitor and tourist oriented brochures (1-HCR 8) the rehabilitation,alteration or reuse of their structure(s) only if rehabilitated in accordance with established HCR 14.2 historic preservation guidelines (1-HCR 1) Promote community awareness of historic preservation through Huntington Beach's appointed and elected HCR 13.3 officials, Its various departments, and local boards and Consider allowing flexibility in building code organizations (1-HCR 8) requirements for the rehabilitation of historic structures as specified in State Historical Building Code Part 8, HCR 1.4 3 Title 24 if rehabilitated in accordance with established Encourage the involvement of the local schools and historic preservation guidelines (1-HCR 1) Goldenwest College in preservation programs and activities (1-HCR 8) HCR 1.3.4 Provide appropriate technical advice to private property HCR 1.4.4 owners seeking to restore historically significant Consider combining sites containing historic features structures (1-HCR 1) (interpretive centers) with recreational learning opportunities and arts and culture (1-HCR 9) HCR 1.3.5 Advocate that local lending institutions provide HCR 14.5 appropriate financing for the rehabilitation and Encourage the provision of uses that are conducive to restoration of historically significant structures (1-HCR public use and education in historic structures (1-HCR 7) 1,and 1-HCR 4) HCR 13 6 HCR 14.6 Encourage appropriate adaptive reuse of historic Consider crowdsourcmg to support preservation efforts resources in order to prevent misuse, disrepair and demolition, taking care to protect surrounding Cultural Resources neighborhoods from incompatible uses (1-HCR 1) Goal HCR137 HCR2 Explore alternatives that enable a property owner to Develop avenues for communication and sensitively add to the existing structure, or develop an participation in arts and cultural activities and accompanying building on the site that allows property programming to bring together diverse segments of development rights to be realized Deviation to the community setbacks,height,parking,and other requirements should be considered to make the preservation of an existing Objective historic building feasible when no other reasonable HCR 2.1 alternative exists (1-HCR I and 1-HCR 6) Improve access to arts and cultural activity for all residents and assist in networking information of HCR 1.3 8 cultural activities Preserve and reuse historically significant structures, where feasible (1-HCR 3 and I-HCR 7) Policies HCR 2.1.1 Objective Assist cultural groups in networking and bringing artists HCR 1.4 and arts organizations together (1-HCR 10 and 1-HCR Promote public education and awareness of the unique 12) history of the Huntington Beach area and community involvement in its retention and preservation THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-24 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT HCR 2 1.2 Policies Provide technical assistance to historic, cultural groups and artists (I-HCR 11) HCR 3 2.1 Consider providing educational opportunities that focus Objective on the City's cultural history (I-HCR 1, I-HCR 3, and HCR 2.2 I-HCR 8) Raise the community's awareness of the full range of arts,history,and culture available in Huntington Beach Goal HCR 4 Policies Expand opportunities for the City's children to HCR 2 2.1 receive quality experiences of arts and culture. Provide opportunities for increased exposure for arts and cultural activities throughout the city (1-HCR 12 Objective and I-HCR 13) HCR 4.1 Strive for a full range of performing and visual arts, HCR 2.2.2 educational programming and experiences to children Facilitate networking between arts and cultural groups throughout the city and the general public (I--HCR 12 and I-HCR 13) Policies Goal HCR 4 1.1 HCR 3 Seek support for arts education (I-HCR 8) Highlight the City's unique cultural heritage and enhance its visual appeal. HCR 4 12 Strive to broaden cultural opportunities for children Objective (I-HCR 8) HCR31 Promote a high standard of visual quality of art, Goal architecture and landscape architecture in the public HCR 5 realm Establish a wide range of arts and cultural programs and facilities that address the needs and interest of Policies residents,workers,and visitors. HCR 3 1.1 Increase community representation and input into the Objective decision making about arts and culture (I-HCR 1, U D HCR 5.1 14 1, and I-UD S) Ensure adequate facilities, staff, and funding for all city provided arts programs HCR312 Consider that individuals advising the City on cultural, Policies urban and visual design issues have a background in HCR 5.11 architecture, urban design, or fine arts (I--HCR I and Assure that existing cultural facilities in Huntington UD 14 1) Beach are used effectively (I--HCR 8 and I-HCR 12) HCR 3.1.3 HCR 5.1.2 Encourage urban design and public art projects to Advocate partnership agreements for capital projects enhance the image of the City and foster a sense of (I--HCR 1,1--HCR 8,1--HCR 10, and I--HCR 12) place (I--HCR 1,1--HCR 14, and UD 14 1) Objective HCR32 Clarify and highlight the cultural heritage and identities of Huntington Beach for residents and visitors THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-25 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT HCR 5.13 d Study the feasibility of enacting a program to Identify and consider the interests of the community provide incentives for preservation, while planning new cultural facilities (I--HCR 8, 1-HCR restoration, rehabilitation or relocation of 10, and I-HCR 12) historic resources through purchase of facade easements, waiver of fees, flexible building HCR 5.1.4 requirements, adaptive re-use, rehabilitation Consider a permanent funding mechanism to support the loans and grants, and technical advice by local art agency (I-HCR 13) person(s) qualified in historic preservation, restoration techniques, and loans and grant Objective programs,receiver site and building and siting HCR 5.2 regulations Facilitate the growth of the arts and cultural community a Examine the feasibility of establishing a Policies historical resource center which acts as an HCR 5.2.1 archive and clearinghouse of artifacts and Encourage the participation of new audiences for arts resource documentation and provides learning opportunities for the public and cultural activities (I--HCR 8, 1-HCR 13, and I-HCR 16) f Explore the feasibility of relocating the Historical Society's city archives to an HCR 5.2.2 accessible location such as the downtown Coordinate and cooperate with other city departments g Consider developing an oil history museum or and interest groups with the planning for existing and interpretive center new public cultural amenities (I--HCR 17) h Explore the development of a plan for a HCR 5.2.3 phased- in "cultural corridor" including the Assist in the development of partnerships among arts areas surrounding Golden West College, groups and the business community (I--HCR 8 and Huntington Central Park, Main Street Library, 1-HCR 12) Main Street and the Art Center to the Pier The plan shall consider such things as HCR 5.2.4 developing a uniform visual identity Encourage opportunities for artists to live and work in through street banners and signage and Huntington Beach (I--HCR 1) public improvements,and IMPLEMENTATION PROGRAMS • identifying potential sites for City-sponsored public artwork I-HCR 1 Studies/Mauaina/Survevs I Designate historic districts and individually significant buildings, structures and sites as a Perform ongoing survey updates every five local historic landmarks years to maintain an updated inventory of J Explore the feasibility of incorporating the buildings, structures or sites identified as history of the local Native American peoples potentially having historical or archaeological into existing interpretive centers significance b Adopt the California Register Criteria as the city's official designation criteria for local landmarks c Conduct a study investigating the feasibility of creating new or expanding"receiver sites"and creating an "adopt a building" program (An "adopt a building'program includes corporate or civic group's sponsoring the refurbishing, rehabilitation, and continued upkeep of a historic structure) THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-26 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT k Explore if there is sufficient programming and I-HCR 6 audience for a small, flexible (or'black box') Design Review/Permiffing Process/Environmental theatrical space in the downtown, geared Review toward multi-purpose usage and small, experimental productions a Review existing design standards and I Determine the nature of public and private guidelines to ensure they are conducive to support for the proposed International Surfing compatible development, if warranted, revise Museum the design standards in Explore shared and affordable, '-work/live" b Review the impacts of zoning changes and space for artists and arts groups General Plan amendments on historic preservation objectives and, if warranted, I-HCR 2 revise the proposed zone change or Plan Municipal Code/Design Guidelines amendment to reflect the historic preservation ob)ectives Utilize the State of California Historic Building Code to c Evaluate the current procedures for reviewing accommodate the rehabilitation of historic and older all demolition permit applications for historic structures structures I-HCR 3 I-HCR 7 Preservation Ordinance Historic Resources Funding Consider the creation of a Preservation Ordinance The Work with local lending institutions in developing a Preservation Ordinance shall financing program or other programs to provide financial assistance benefiting owners of historic a enable the City to designate any site deemed resources who can prove a need for financial assistance historically, archaeologically, or culturally in connection with historic preservation significant as a historic point, structure,site,or district, I-HCR 8 b establish design guidelines and standards for Interagency Participation and Coordination preservation,adaptive re-use,etc, a Work with the managing board (or c establish criteria and procedures for creating organization) of the Huntington Beach Hotel new historic overlay areas,and /Motel Business Improvement District and d conform to State and Federal criteria for others on developing brochures, self-guided establishing a preservation ordinance walking tours,traveling exhibits promotmg the historical resources of the City I-HCR 4 b Work with the local school districts, local Land Use Element preservation programs, libraries, and community centers to Implement land use programs as cited in I-LU 1,I-LU develop and promote preservation classes, 7,AND I-LU 14 activities and programs, • enhance the range and scope of arts I-HCR 5 educational programming offered by the Rehabilitation and Preservation Standards City,including Maintain on file the Secretary of Interior Standards for - a cultural programs for cable Historic Rehabilitation and the standards and guidelines television, of the State Office of Historic Preservation as guidelines - a youth oriented calendar of arts and on restoring, altering or adding to designated historic cultural events,and structures - an artist residencies program located in community centers and other youth oriented facilities throughout the City, and THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-27 COMMUNrry DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT • provide art and historic classes accessible I-HCR 11 to a diverse range of residents Technical Assistance Programs c Work with local preservation organizations to Develop technical assistance programs to tram develop a historic building handbook that community arts, cultural, and historic groups in,but not describes historic structures, sites,and districts, limited to,the following and provides information on building research and appreciation, and sets forth guidelines for a running a small organization - financial rehabilitation as funds are available management, fund-raising, marketing and d Coordinate with local historic preservation long-range planning, organizations such as the Historic Resources b developing partnerships and joint ventures Board and Historical Society with private businesses, City agencies and e Work with other City departments to develop a others,and plan to assure that existing arts and cultural c planning to assess community interest and facilities are rehabilitated and maintained as identify and encourage new audiences feasible f Coordinate proposals for new facility needs I-HCR-12 with the Central Park Master Plan's proposed Business Leader, Art Administrators, and Resident additional outdoor performing arts spaces, and Outreach the Beach Master Plan's proposed arts and cultural programming in the Pier Plaza area a Develop a private sector group of business and civic leaders, arts organizations and artists to g Establish a high-level, inter-agency working rovide leadership support for arts and cultural group of senior staff from appropriate City p provid departments to coordinate cultural initiatives activities b Work with community groups to develop h Link cultural tourism objectives through residents'program interests promotional he-ins and special events with a cultural focus or component I-HCR 13 I-HCR 9 Arts Programmmg Recreation and Commumtv Services Element Incorporate arts and cultural events as part of existing community events and attractions, major sporting Implement Parks and Recreation policies and programs as cited in RCS 1.1.2 and I-RCS 2 events,and community celebrations where feasible I-HCR 14 I-HCR 10 Public Art Ordinance Arts/Cultural Resources Network Develop systems and networks to provide access to Consider the creation of a public art ordinance that information resources,such as encourages public and private sector involvement The ordinance shall a a community arts, culture, and history a identify funding sources for a formal public newsletter, arts program,and b a clearinghouse cataloguing and registering b utilize the existing ad hoc art program as a temporary and permanent spaces available for model arts and cultural use, c a centralized event clearinghouse, d an artists' register available for an art in public places program, gallery owners, presenters, and others with resumes,slides or tapes,and e a media production resource list THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-28 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT I-HCR 15 I-HCR 16 Celebration Plaza Allied Arts Board and Historic Resources Board Continue to oversee the development and programming Diversify the membership of the Allied Arts Board and for the Celebration Plaza located at the intersection of the Historic Resources Board to include a broader Main Street and Acacia Avenue As currently planned, perspective from all segments of the city the Celebration Plaza is an outside public assembly area which includes hardscape and landscape amenities I-HCR 17 connecting the Arts Center and the Main Street Branch Cultural Master Plan Library Implement the City Council approved Cultural Master Plan,as feasible THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-29 ADMINISTRATION m c m m � m E m ac m r a c E a m m o m O ❑ E U ❑ C � � C N y N — L.L m N N C y E E C LL C N N > N U E O 3 m n o a ao `o m 0 o ti E E o Q c ii O O h N ❑ C O T U u9 p y Q LL tQ O C E C ❑ � U U � U O C d N N N N �_ � O1 N O N O U O L N N Q1 U1 L N to C) O CD Q ❑ of C7 O U) LL No. Name CITY OF HUI TINGTON BEACH CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH PROGRAM RESPONSIBLE AGENCY FUNDING SOURCE SCHEDULE HCR-1 Studies/Mapping/Surveys • • • • • • • • • Ongoing and Every 5 Years" 1 year upon HCR-2 Municipal Code/Design Guidelines • • • • • • • Plan adoption* HCR-3 Preservation Ordinance • • • • • • 1 year upon Plan adoption* HCR-4 Land Use Element • • • Ongoing` HCR-5 Rehabilitation and Preservation Standards • • Ongoing* HCR-6 Design Review/Permitting Process/ • • ® • ongoing* Environmental Review HCR-7 Historic Resources Funding • • • • • • Ongoing* HCR-8 Interagency Participation and Coordination • • • • • • • • • ongoing* HCR-9 Recreation and Community Services Element • • • Ongoing* HCR-10 Arts/Cultural Resources Network • • • • 2 year upon Plan adoption* 2 year upon HCR-11 Technical Assistance Programs • • • Plan adoption* HCR-12 Business Leader,Arts Administrators,and Resident • • • • Ongoing* Outreach HCR-13 Arts Programming • • • • • Ongoing* HCR-14 Public Arts Ordinance • • • • • • • • 2 year upon Plan adoption* HCR-15 Celebration Plaza • • • • • Ongoing* HCR-16 Allied Arts Board and Historic Resources Board • • • 2 year upon Plan adoption* HCR-17 Cultural Master Plan • • • • Lei Ongoing* *As funding permits HISTORICAL and CULTURAL RESOURCES IMPLEMENTATION PROGRAM MATRIX ¢IL-T R CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN II-HCR-30 Res. No. 2015-64 STATE OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF ORANGE ) ss: CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH ) I, JOAN L FLYNN the duly elected, qualified City Clerk of the City of Huntington Beach, and ex-officio Clerk of the City Council of said City, do hereby certify that the whole number of members of the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach is seven, that the foregoing resolution was passed and adopted by the affirmative vote of at least a majority of all the members of said City Council at a Regular meeting thereof held on October 19, 2015 by the following vote AYES: Posey, O'Connell, Hardy, Sullivan, Delgleize, Peterson NOES: None ABSENT: Katapodis ABSTAIN: None a City rk and ex-officio erk of the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach, California ATTACHMENT #4 '� P _)-� _ --.. _ �_.-- 1v'A fS• r i';:'i+,�4 [-. _51"']7 '3 its.^ __�--.��K`�,. b�_ -�4^.q#max .ir _ �=;�' A'+a^r .,. •A .-«t'±.� w _� i� � �g -�a{ 3S +E-:4u� ___ 'o _� a` xis=L ,s't - ,y,,a,�� ��� `�_`a�' _ _ _`�* •-a_t" .. �. —�._ �^`yE �'r. - i(''�� lujl VA ��- _�a�y,, �;��• � _�1 :- r.`_..z-' _ �.X 5 i7j� , ��€� jr `'� •` ,��€h '�=x.V q - - _ "us�f _-' ,�+ �t „ �" � 3�r ��i aera�t {.ate �X `� i @�Li *� _� M14s�` 3,Fs_4 �, �, is. _�k .'�-• z,. a+ "" FAi 1. PROJECT TITLE: General Plan Historic and Cultural Resources Element Update Concurrent Entitlements: General Plan Amendment No 08-009 2. LEAD AGENCY: City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Contact: Ricky Ramos, Senior Planner Phone: (714) 536-5271 3. PROJECT LOCATION: Citywide 4. PROJECT PROPONENT: City of Huntington Beach 5. GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Various 6. ZONING: Various 7. PROJECT DESCRIPTION Introduction: The Historic and Cultural Resources Element(HCRE) is one of the Elements in the Huntington Beach General Plan adopted in 1996 The HCRE is a policy document that guides the City's decisions regarding historic and cultural resources by identifying goals, objectives,policies, and implementation programs as well as providing technical information and outlining issues regarding the protection of the cty's historic resources and provision of arts/cultural services The existing HCRE is available on the city website (www.huntingtonbeachea gov). Existing Element: The existing HCRE is organized into four main sections Technical Synopsis, Issues, Goals, Objectives, and Policies, and Implementation Programs The Technical Synopsis of the HCRE includes separate sections on historic resources and cultural resources. The historic resources section includes a brief summary of the history of Huntington Beach and the predominant architectural styles that remain in the city today Figure HCR-I depicts historic resources that are described in further detail in subsequent pages in the HCRE. Table HCR-2 lists 79 G\ENVIRONM\CHECKLST P- I HB -511- Item 15. - 13 local landmarks comprised of 212 properties that were generated by the Huntington Beach Historic Resources Board (HRB) and considered to be of significant importance to the local community The significance of a structure or a place is based upon its overall contribution to the community by its historical, cultural, social, or visual function(s) It is the intention of the HRB to place these structures and places on a City listing for protection and/or preservation of the landmark's size, scale, design and/or function The HCRE references the Historic Survey of 1986 which was completed to provide documentation of potential historic and cultural resources so that City policies and regulations can be established to protect and preserve these resources while allowing for new development The Historic Survey of 1986 identified three potential historic districts within the downtown area a Main Street/Downtown—This district includes the 2na and a portion of the 3ra blocks of Main Street as well as the 2na and 3ra blocks of 5th Street. b. 9th Street—This district spans from approximately the north half of the 3ra block to the south half of the 5th block of 9t" Street c. Wesley Park—This district incorporates an irregular boundary focused along Main Street from Acacia to about IOth and I Ith Streets The cultural resources section discusses existing cultural facilities and programs as well as resources for arts education. It describes the roles of the Cultural Services Division and Allied Arts Board together with funding for the arts and culture in the community The Issues section identifies 20 major concerns regarding local historic and cultural resources followed by a Goals, Objectives, and Policies section which guides the City's decisions regarding historic and cultural resources The goals,objectives, and policies promote the preservation and restoration of historic resources as well as the provision of arts and cultural activities in the community. The Implementation Programs section outlines specific steps to be taken to implement the goals, objectives, and policies. Reason for Project: The City initiated an update to the HCRE because the existing local landmarks list in Table HCR-2 needs updating. Many of the properties listed in the local landmarks list have since been demolished or significantly altered while others are archaeological or not historic. Proposed Changes: Only the historic resources component of the HCRE is proposed to be updated at this time. The cultural resources component is not being revised. A copy of the HCRE update is provided in Attachment 1 and includes the following notable changes 1) The history of Huntington Beach and the predominant architectural styles remaining found on pages II-HCR-1 through-5 of the existing HCRE were substantially re-written. 2) The historic resources section on pages 11-HCR-6 through-16 was substantially re-written 3) Figure HCR-1 (Historical Resources) on page H-HCR-7, Tables HCR-1 (Category Ratings for Historical Landmarks) and -2 (1991 Local Landmarks) on pages 11-HCR-8 through-11, and the Pnoo 7 Item 15. - 14 xB -5 1 photos of historic resources on pages II-HCR-12 and-13 were deleted. Instead of continuing to include a local landmarks list in the HCRE, the City will maintain a separate local landmarks list which includes all the properties in the city that have been identified as having historic significance This will allow future updates to the list as needed without requiring an amendment to the HCRE The updated local landmarks list is shown in Appendix B of the City of Huntington Beach Historic Context and Survey Report (updated June 2014) Table HCR-2 lists 79 local landmarks comprised of 212 properties in 1991 The current status of these landmarks is noted in Attachment 2 and summarized as follows. - 79 properties have been carried over into the updated landmarks list; ■ 133 properties have been demolished, heavily altered, or are not historic and have been removed from the updated landmarks list The updated list in Appendix B includes 260 local landmarks and is included as Attachment 3 4) The issues relating to historic resources on pages II-HCR-20 through-23 have been updated and added to. 5) Several goals, objectives, policies and implementation programs relatmg to historic resources found on pages II-HCR-23 through-30 have been updated Historical Context and Survey Report: As part of the HCRE update, Galvin Preservation Associates (GPA) conducted a citywide survey to identify and evaluate potential historic resources in the city. The purpose of the survey is to update and expand the City's existing 1986 Historic Resources Survey Report and to update the HCRE The survey included a reconnaissance level survey of all buildings in the city constructed prior to 1959 (i.e structures that are at least 50 years old when the survey was commenced in 2009), focusing on the historic core areas as well as select buildings located outside the historic core and other outlying areas identified by the Huntington Beach Historic Resources Board. The results of the survey are outlined in the Historic Context and Survey Report(updated June 2014)by GPA which is referred to in the HCRE The updated local landmarks list, included in Appendix B of the Historic Context and Survey Report, would serve as a list of historic resources for purposes of evaluating future projects under the California Environmental Quality Act(CEQA) Historic resources on the updated list that are proposed to be demolished would require environmental review under CEQA. Furthermore, any construction work on a historic resource must comply with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties in order to be exempt from CEQA environmental review. In addition, GPA reviewed the three previously proposed potential historic districts in the 1986 survey and determined that they no longer maintain enough integrity to be considered historic districts according to national, state, and local register criteria. GPA identified two smaller concentrations of buildings in the 2014 Historic Context and Survey Report that would constitute a local historic district as follows: a Main Street-Crest Avenue—This district is located on Main Street and Crest Avenue between 11t' Street and Palm Avenue. P.,.* 7 xB 1;_ Item 15. - 15 IIli 'N,T 1. S-1 J, ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS POTENTIALLY AFFECTED: The environmental factors checked below would be potentially affected by this project, involving at least one impact that is a"Potentially Significant Impact"or is"Potentially Significant Unless Mitigated,"as indicated by the checklist on the following pages ❑ Land Use/Planning ❑ Transportation/Traffic ❑ Public Services ❑ Population/Housing ❑ Biological Resources ❑ Utilities/Service Systems ❑ Geology/Soils ❑ Mineral Resources ❑ Aesthetics ❑ Hydrology/Water Quality ❑ Hazards and Hazardous Materials ❑ Cultural Resources ❑ Air Quality ❑ Noise ❑ Recreation ❑ Agriculture Resources ❑ Greenhouse Gas Emissions ❑ Mandatory Findings of Significance DETERMINATION (To be completed by the Lead Agency) On the basis of this initial evaluation I find that the proposed project COULD NOT have a significant effect on the environment, and a NEGATIVE DECLARATION will be prepared I find that although the proposed project could have a significant effect on the environment, there will not be a significant effect in this case because the mitigation measures described on ❑ an attached sheet have been added to the project A MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION will be prepared I find that the proposed project MAY have a significant effect on the environment, and an ❑ ENVIRONMENTAL IMTACT REPORT is required I find that the proposed project MAY have a"potentially significant impact"or a"potentially significant unless mitigated impact"on the environment, but at least one impact(1)has been adequately analyzed in an earlier document pursuant to applicable legal standards, and(2)has ❑ been addressed by mitigation measures based on the earlier analysis as described on attached sheets An ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT is required, but it must analyze only the effects that remain to be addressed I find that although the proposed project could have a significant effect on the environment, because all potentially significant effects(a)have been analyzed adequately in an earlier EIR or NEGATIVE DECLARATION pursuant to applicable standards, and(b)have been avoided ❑ or mitigated pursuant to that earlier EIR or NEGATIVE DECLARATION, including revisions or mitigation measures that are unposed upon the proposed project, nothing further is required tZ.., tZ_,��,.,.us Signature 1 1 Date Ricky Ramos Senior Planner Printed Name Title D--- G HB -515- Item 15. - 17 EVALUATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS: 1 A brief explanation is required for all answers except"No Impact"answers that are adequately supported by the information sources a lead agency cites in the parentheses following each question A"No Impact" answer is adequately supported if the referenced information sources show that the impact simply does not apply to the project. A"No Impact"answer should be explained where it is based on project-specific factors as well as general standards 2 All answers must take account of the whole action involved Answers should address off-site as well as on- site, cumulative as well as project-level, indirect as well as direct, and construction as well as operational impacts 3 "Potentially Significant Impact" is appropriate,if an effect is significant or potentially significant, or if the lead agency lacks infonnation to make a finding of insignificance If there are one or more"Potentially Significant Impact" entries when the determination is made,preparation of an Environmental Impact Report is warranted 4 Potentially Significant Impact Unless Mitigated"applies where the incorporation of mitigation measures has reduced an effect from"Potentially Significant Impact"to a"Less than Significant Impact." The lead agency must describe the mitigation measures, and briefly explain how they reduce the effect to a less than significant level(mitigation measures may be cross-referenced) 5 Earlier analyses may be used where,pursuant to the tiering,program EK or other CEQA process,an effect has been adequately analyzed in an earlier EIR or negative declaration Section 15063(c)(3)(D) Earlier analyses are discussed in Section XIX at the end of the checklist 6_ References to information sources for potential impacts(e g, general plans, zoning ordinances)have been incorporated into the checklist A source list has been provided in Section XIX Other sources used or individuals contacted have been cited in the respective discussions 7 The following checklist has been formatted after Appendix G of Chapter 3,Title 14, California Code of Regulations,but has been augmented to reflect the City of Huntington Beach's requirements SAMPLE QUESTION: Potentially Significant Potentially Unless Less Than Significant Mitigation Significant ISSUES(and Supporting Information Sources) Impact Incorporated Impact No Impact Would the proposal result in or expose people to potential impacts involving Landslides? (Sources 1, 6) 0 Discussion The attached source list explains that 1 is the Huntington Beach General Plan and 6 is a topographical map of the area which show that the area is located in a flat area. (Note This response probably would not require further explanation) Pnno li Item 15. - 18 HB -516- I. LAND USE AND PLANNING. Would the project a) Conflict with any applicable land use plan,policy, or 0 regulation of an agency with jurisdiction over the project(including,but not limited to the general plan, specific plan, local coastal program, or zoning ordinance) adopted for the purpose of avoiding or mitigating an environmental effect? (Sources 1,3,4) b) Conflict with any applicable habitat conservation plan ❑ El El 0 or natural community conservation plan(Sources 1 and 3) c) Physically divide an established community? (Sources ❑ El ❑ x❑ 1 and 3) Discussion a-c: The HCRE update is not in conflict with any applicable land use plan, policy, or regulation of the City It does not change the General Plan land use or zoning designation on any property. The update is consistent with the other General Plan elements including the policies and objective listed below and any applicable regulations Policy LU 4 2 2—Permit historically significant buildings to vary from standard City codes, providing that the variations do not endanger human life and buildings comply with the State Historical Code Objective LU 15 3 —Facilitate the preservation of historically and architecturally significant points, structures, sites and districts Policy LU 15 3 1—Encourage that structures designated with a"Historic Preservation Overlay"be retained, unless infeasible due to structural conditions or costs that prohibit a reasonable economic use of the property Several properties that are in the 1991 Local Landmarks list in the existing HCRE are proposed to be eliminated from the list(see Attachment No 2 for current disposition/status)primarily because they have either been demolished, significantly altered, are archaeological in nature, or are not historic due to age An updated landmarks list has been prepared with the Historic Context and Survey Report to include only qualified historic resources The HCRE update focuses on policies and technical information regarding historic resources and will not conflict with any habitat conservation plan or natural community conservation plan It does not involve any physical changes that would divide an established community No impacts are anticipated II. POPULATION AND HOUSING. Would the project. a) Induce substantial population growth in an area, either El ❑ ❑ 191 directly(e g, by proposing new homes and businesses) or indirectly(e g.,through extensions of roads or other infrastructure) (Sources 3 and 10) b) Displace substantial numbers of existing housing, El El El 0 necessitating the construction of replacement housing G\ENVIRONM\CHECKLST °^"" 7 1-113 -517- Item 15. - 19 elsewhere (Sources 3 and 10) c) Displace substantial numbers of people,necessitating El El El 0 the construction of replacement housing elsewhere? (Sources 3 and 10) Discussion a-c: The HCRE update does not propose any new homes,businesses, or extensions of roads or infrastructure It does not involve the displacement of existing housing or residents It does not change the General Plan land use or zoning designation on any property No impacts are anticipated M.GEOLOGY AND SOILS. Would the project a) Expose people or structures to potential substantial adverse effects, including the risk of loss, injury, or death involving(Sources 1, 3, 10, 13) 1) Rupture of a known earthquake fault, as delineated El El El 0 on the most recent Alquist-Pnolo Earthquake Fault Zoning Map issued by the State Geologist for the area or based on other substantial evidence of a known fault9 n) Strong seismic ground shakmg9 El El El Z iii) Seismic-related ground failure,including El ❑ liquefaction? iv) Landslides? ❑ El El 9 b) Result in substantial soil erosion, loss of topsoil, or El El El0 changes in topography or unstable soil conditions from excavation, gradmg, or filh (Sources 1, 3, 10) c) Be located on a geologic unit or soil that is unstable, or El El El Z that would become unstable as a result of the project, and potentially result in on or off-site landslide, lateral spreading, subsidence, liquefaction or collapse9 (Sources. 1, 3, 10, 13) d) Be located on expansive soil, as defined in Table 18-1-B El El El Z of the Uniform Building Code(1994), creating substantial risks to life or property9 (Sources 1, 3, 10) e) Have soils incapable of adequately supporting the use of Item 15. - 20 HB -518- septic tanks or alternative waste water disposal systems ❑ ❑ ❑ where sewers are not available for the disposal of wastewater(Sources 1, 3, 10) Discussion a-e: The HCRE update involves updates to the goals,policies, objectives, implementation programs, and technical information,among others,relating to the preservation of historic resources in the city The HCRE update does not propose any new construction or physical changes It does not change the General Plan land use or zoning designation on any property Therefore, it would not expose people or structures to earthquake faults, seismic ground shaking/ground failure, or landslides It will not result in soil erosion or any other geologic impacts No impacts are anticipated. IV.HYDROLOGY AND WATER QUALITY. Would the project a) Violate any water quality standards or waste discharge ❑ ❑ ❑ requirements'? (Sources 1, 3, 10) b) Substantially deplete groundwater supplies or interfere ❑ ❑ ❑ 9 substantially with groundwater recharge such that there would be a net deficit in aquifer volume or a lowering of the local groundwater table level (e g, the production rate of pre-existing nearby wells would drop to a level which would not support existing land uses or planned uses for which permits have been granted? (Sources 1, 3, 10) c) Substantially alter the existing drainage pattern of the ❑ ❑ ❑ site or area, including through the alteration of the course of a stream or river, in a manner which would result in substantial erosion or siltation on or off-site'? (Sources 1, 3, 10) d) Substantially alter the existing drainage pattern of the ❑ ❑ ❑ site or area, including through the alteration of the course of a stream or river, or substantially increase the rate or amount or surface runoff in a manner which would result in flooding on or off-site? (Sources 1,3, 10) e) Create or contribute runoff water which would exceed ❑ ❑ ❑ the capacity of existing or planned stonnwater drainage systems or provide substantial additional sources of polluted runoff? (Sources. 1, 3, 10) f) Otherwise substantially degrade water quality ❑ ❑ ❑ (Sources 1, 3, 10) D___n HB -519- Item 15. - 21 g) Place housing within a 100-year flood hazard area as mapped on a federal Flood Hazard Boundary or Flood Insurance Rate Map or other flood hazard delineation maps (Sources 1, 3, 8, 10) h) Place within a 100-year flood hazard area structures El 9 which would impede or redirect flood flows? (Sources- 1, 3, 8, 10) i) Expose people or structures to a significant risk of loss, El ❑ El injury or death involving flooding, including flooding as a result of the failure of a levee or dam? (Sources 1, 3, 8, 10) j) Inundation by seiche,tsunami, or mudflow? (Sources: El 9 1,3, 10) k) Potentially impact stormwater runoff from construction activities (Sources 1, 3, 10) 1) Potentially impact stormwater runoff from post El El - construction activities? (Sources 1, 3, 10) m) Result in a potential for discharge of stormwater El pollutants from areas of material storage,vehicle or equipment fueling, vehicle or equipment maintenance (including washing),waste handling, hazardous materials handling or storage, delivery areas, loading docks or other outdoor work areas? (Sources 1, 3, 10) n) Result in the potential for discharge of stormwater to affect the beneficial uses of the receiving waters? (Sources 1, 3, 10) o) Create or contribute significant increases in the flow El velocity or volume of stormwater runoff to cause environmental harm? (Sources 1, 3, 10) p) Create or contribute significant increases in erosion of the project site or surrounding areas? (Sources 1, 3, 10) D--- rn Item 15. - 22 xB -520- Discussion a-p: The HCRE update involves updates to the goals,policies,objectives, implementation programs,and technical information,among others,relating to the preservation of historic resources in the city The HCRE update does not propose any new construction or physical changes Therefore, it would not affect water quality standards or groundwater supplies, create or contribute to runoff or erosion, or alter existing drainage patterns It would not expose people or structures to the flood hazard areas or inundation by seiche,tsunami,or mudflows No impacts are anticipated V. AIR QUALITY. The city has identified the significance criteria established by the applicable air quality management district as appropriate to make the following determinations Would the project a) Violate any air quality standard or contribute ❑ El 11 substantially to an existing or projected air quality violations (Sources 1, 3, 10) b) Expose sensitive receptors to substantial pollutant El 11 El191 concentrations (Sources 1, 3, 10) c) Create objectionable odors affecting a substantial ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑9 number of peoples (Sources 1, 3, 10) d) Conflict with or obstruct implementation of the El ❑ El 9 applicable air quality plan? (Sources 1, 3, 10) e) Result in a cumulatively considerable net increase of ❑ El ❑ ❑9 any criteria pollutant for which the project region is non-attainment under an applicable federal or state ambient air quality standard(including releasing emissions which exceed quantitative thresholds for ozone precursors)? (Sources 1, 3, 10) Discussion a-e: The HCRE update involves updates to the goals, policies, objectives, implementation programs, and technical information,among others,relating to the preservation of historic resources in the city The HCRE update does not propose any land use,new construction, or physical changes and will not result in any emissions It does not change the General Plan land use or zoning designation on any property Therefore, it would not affect any air quality standards or plans,cause substantial pollutant concentrations, or create objectionable odors No impacts are anticipated VI. TRANSPORTATION/TRAFFIC. Would the project a) Conflict with an applicable plan, ordinance or policy ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑9 establishing measures of effectiveness for the performance of the circulation system,taking into account all modes of transportation including mass transit and non-motorized travel and relevant components of the circulation system, including but not lnnited to intersections, streets, highways and freeways, Z)--. 11 HB -521_ Item 15. - 23 pedestrian and bicycle paths, and mass transit? (Sources 1,3, 10) b) Conflict with an applicable congestion management El ❑ 13 ❑x program, including, but not limited to level of service standards and travel demand measures, or other standards established by the county congestion management agency for designated roads or highways? (Sources 1, 3, 10) c) Result in a change in air traffic patterns, including either ❑ El 0 an increase in traffic levels or a change in location that results in substantial safety risks? (Sources 1, 3, 10) d) Substantially increase hazards due to a design feature El ❑ ❑ (e g, sharp curves or dangerous intersections) or incompatible uses? (Sources 1, 3, 10) e) Result in inadequate emergency access? (Sources 1, 3, ❑ ❑ 0 10) f) Result in inadequate parking capacity? (Sources 1, 3, El ❑ 10) g) Conflict with adopted policies, plans,or programs ❑ ❑ ❑ 0 regarding public transit,bicycle, or pedestrian facilities, or otherwise decrease the performance or safety of such facilities? (Sources 1, 3, 10) Discussion a-g: The HCRE update involves updates to the goals, policies, objectives, implementation programs, and technical information, among others,relating to the preservation of historic resources in the city The HCRE update is consistent with the General Plan including the Circulation Element. It does not propose any land use, new construction, or physical changes It does not change the General Plan land use or zoning designation on any property Therefore, it will not result in any additional traffic or congestion, change in air traffic patterns, increase hazards due to a design feature,or affect emergency access, parking,or any component of the circulation system No impacts are anticipated VII. BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES. Would the project a) Have a substantial adverse effect, either directly or through habitat modifications, on any species identified as a candidate, sensitive, or special status species in local or regional plans,policies, or regulations, or by the California Department of Fish and Game or U S,Fish and Wildlife Service9 (Sources 1,3, 10) Item 15. - 24 HB -522- b) Have a substantial adverse effect on any riparian habitat ❑ or other sensitive natural community identified in local or regional plans, policies, regulations, or by the California Department of Fish and Game or US Fish and Wildlife Service9 (Sources 1, 3, 10) c) Have a substantial adverse effect on federally protected El El El 19 wetlands as defined by Section 404 of the Clean Water Act(including,but not limited to,marsh, vernal pool, coastal, etc)through direct removal, filling, hydrological interruption, or other means9 (Sources 1, 3, 10) d) Interfere substantially with the movement of any native El El El 19 resident or migratory fish or wildlife species or with established native resident or migratory wildlife corridors or impede the use of native wildlife nursery sites9 (Sources 1, 3, 10) e) Conflict with any local policies or ordmances protecting El El El 9 biological resources, such as a tree preservation policy or ordinance9 (Sources 1, 3, 10) f) Conflict with the provisions of an adopted Habitat El El El Z Conservation Plan(HCP),Natural Community Conservation Plan(NCCP), or other approved local, regional, or state habitat conservation plant (Sources 1,3, 10) Discussion a-f: The HCRE update involves updates to the goals,policies, objectives, implementation programs, and technical information, among others,relating to the preservation of historic resources in the city The HCRE update does not propose any new construction or physical changes It does not change the General Plan land use or zoning designation on any property In addition, existing policies for historic tree preservation are not proposed to be deleted or revised as part of the HCRE update Therefore,it will not result in any habitat or wetland modifications, interference with the movement of any fish or wildlife,tree removal, or conflict with any HCP or NCCP No impacts are anticipated VIII. MINERAL RESOURCES. Would the project a) Result in the loss of availability of a known mineral El El El resource that would be of value to the region and the residents of the state9 (Sources 1, 3, 10) b) Result in the loss of availability of a locally-important ❑ ❑ ❑ mineral resource recovery site delineated on a local general plan, specific plan, or other land use plan? (Sources- 1,3, 10) p- 2 HB -52 3- Item 15. - 25 Discussion a-b: The HCRE update involves updates to the goals,policies, objectives, implementation programs,and technical information, among others, relating to the preservation of historic resources in the city. The HCRE update does not propose any new construction,physical changes, or policies that would affect any mineral resource recovery in the city No impacts are anticipated IX.HAZARDS AND HAZARDOUS MATERIALS. Would the project. a) Create a significant hazard to the public or the El El El Z environment through the routine transport,use, or disposal of hazardous materials9 (Sources. 1, 3, 10) b) Create a significant hazard to the public or the El El 1:1 environment through reasonably foreseeable upset and accident conditions involving the release of hazardous materials into the environment? (Sources 1, 3, 10) c) Emit hazardous emissions or handle hazardous or �x acutely hazardous material, substances, or waste within one-quarter mile of an existing or proposed school (Sources 1, 3, 10) d) Be located on a site which is included on a list of hazardous materials sites compiled pursuant to Government Code Section 65962 5 and,as a result, would it create a significant hazard to the public or the environments (Sources 1, 3, 10) e) For a project located within an airport land use plan or, El El 11 1E where such a plan has not been adopted,within two miles of a public airport or pubic use airport,would the project result in a safety hazard for people residing or working in the project area? (Sources 1,3, 10) f) For a project within the vicinity of a private airstrip, El El El IRI would the project result in a safety hazard for people residing or working in the project area? (Sources 1, 3, 10) g) Impair implementation of or physically interfere with an El El19 adopted emergency response plan or emergency evacuation plan? (Sources 1, 3, 10) h) Expose people or structures to a significant risk of loss, El El El 1E injury, or death involving wildland fires, including D___ 1 A Item 15. - 26 HB -524- where wildlands are adjacent to urbanized areas or where residences are intermixed with wildlands9 (Sources 1,3, 10) Discussion a-h: The HCRE update involves updates to the goals, policies, objectives, implementation programs, and technical information,among others,relating to the preservation of historic resources in the city The HCRE update does not propose any land use, new construction,or physical changes and does not involve the transport,handling, use or emission of hazardous materials It does not change the General Plan land use or zoning designation on any property It does not include any policies that relate to emergency response or exposure to wildland fires No impacts are anticipated X. NOISE. Would the project result in a) Exposure of persons to or generation of noise levels in 0 excess of standards established in the local general plan or noise ordinance, or applicable standards of other agencies9 (Sources 1,3, 10) b) Exposure of persons to or generation of excessive groundborne vibration or groundborne noise levels9 (Sources 1, 3, 10) c) A substantial permanent increase in ambient noise 0 levels in the project vicinity above levels existing without the project9(Sources 1,3, 10) d) A substantial temporary or periodic increase in ambient 0 noise levels in the project vicinity above levels existing without the project9 (Sources 1,3, 10) e) For a project located within an airport land use plan or, where such a plan has not been adopted, within two miles of a public airport or public use airport, would the project expose people residing or working in the project area to excessive noise levels9 (Sources 1, 3, 10) f) For a project within the vicinity of a private airstrip, �x would the project expose people residing or working in the project area to excessive noise levels9 (Sources 1, 3, 10) Discussion a-f: The HCRE update involves updates to the goals,policies, objectives, implementation programs, and technical information,among others,relating to the preservation of historic resources in the city The HCRE update does not propose any policies, new construction, or physical changes, or the establishment of a land use that would generate or expose people to any noise in the short-or long-term It does not change the General Plan land use or zoning designation on any property No impacts are anticipated XI.PUBLIC SERVICES. Would the project result in " HB5?s- Item 15. - 27 - substantial adverse physical impacts associated with the provision of new or physically altered governmental facilities,the construction of which could cause significant environmental impacts, in order to maintain acceptable service ratios, response times or other performance objectives for any of the public services a) Fire protection9 (Sources. 1,3, 10) El El El0 b) Police Protection9 (Sources. 1,3, 10) El D ElZ c) Schools9 (Sources 1, 3, 10) El El El 0 d) Parks? (Sources 1, 3, 10) El El El e) Other public facilities or governmental services9 El0 0 (Sources 1,3, 10) Discussion a-e: The HCRE update involves updates to the goals, policies,objectives, implementation programs, and technical information, among others, relating to the preservation of historic resources in the city The HCRE update does not propose any policies,new construction, or physical changes that would result in an mcrease in the demand for public services or the need for new or physically altered govermmental facilities It does not change the General Plan land use or zoning designation on any property No impacts are anticipated XII. UTILITIES AND SERVICE SYSTEMS. Would the project a) Exceed wastewater treatment requirements of the El El El0 applicable Regional Water Quality Control Board? (Sources 1, 3, 10) b) Require or result in the construction of new water or El El0 0 wastewater treatment facilities or expansion of existing facilities,the construction of which could cause significant environmental effects9 (Sources- 1, 3, 10) c) Require or result in the construction of new stonm water drainage facilities or expansion of existing facilities, the El El El0 construction of which could cause significant environmental effects9 (Sources 1, 3, 10) d) Have sufficient water supplies available to serve the A--- 1 F Item 15. - 28 HB -526- project from existing entitlements and resources, or are ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑x new or expanded entitlements needed? (Sources 1, 3, 10) e) Result in a determination by the wastewater treatment ❑ ❑ ❑ N provider which serves or may serve the project that it has adequate capacity to serve the project's projected demand in addition to the provider's existing commitments? (Sources 1, 3, 10) f) Be served by a landfill with sufficient permitted ❑ ❑ ❑ capacity to accommodate the project's solid waste disposal needs? (Sources 1, 3, 10) g) Comply with federal, state, and local statutes and ❑ ❑ ❑ 9 regulations related to solid waste? (Sources 1, 3, 10) h) Include a new or retrofitted storm water treatment ❑ ❑ ❑ control Best Management Practice(BMP), (e g water quality treatment basm, constructed treatment wetlands?) (Sources 1, 3, 10) Discussion a-g: The HCRE update involves updates to the goals,policies,objectives, implementation programs, and technical information, among others,relatmg to preservation of historic resources in the city The HCRE update does not propose any policies, land use, new construction, or physical changes that would result in an increase in demand for utilities and service systems or the construction of new facilities It does not change the General Plan land use or zonmg designation on any property No impacts are anticipated XIH. AESTHETICS. Would the project a) Have a substantial adverse effect on a scenic vista? ❑ ❑ ❑ (Sources 1,3, 10) b) Substantially damage scenic resources, including,but ❑ ❑ ❑ not limited to,trees,rock outcroppings, and historic buildings within a state scenic lughway? (Sources- 1, 3, 10) c) Substantially degrade the existing visual character or ❑ ❑ ❑ quality of the site and its surroundings? (Sources 1, 3, 10) d) Create a new source of substantial light or glare which ❑ ❑ ❑ 19 would adversely affect day or nighttime views in the area? (Sources 1, 3, 10) HB -527- Item 15. - 29 Discussion a-d: The HCRE update involves updates to the goals,policies, objectives, implementation programs, and technical information,among others,relating to the preservation of historic resources in the city The HCRE update does not propose any policies, new construction, or physical changes that would have a substantial adverse impact on a scenic vista or create a new source of light or glare It does not propose removal or alteration of scenic resources including trees,rock outcroppings,and historic buildings within a state scenic highway The HCRE update includes policies that encourage rehabilitation of historic structures in accordance with state and federal design standards as well as policies that provide incentives for private property owners to maintain and enhance their structures No negative impacts are anticipated XIV. CULTURAL RESOURCES. Would the project a) Cause a substantial adverse change in the significance 0 of a historical resource as defined in 515064 5? (Sources 1, 3, 4, 5, 10) b) Cause a substantial adverse change in the significance ❑ El ❑ 0 of an archaeological resource pursuant to 515064 59 (Sources 1, 3, 10) c) Directly or indirectly destroy a unique paleontological El El El0 resource or site unique geologic feature? (Sources- 1, 3, 10) d) Disturb any human remains, including those interred El El El0 outside of formal cemeteries? (Sources 1, 3, 10) Discussion a-d: The HCRE update involves updates to the goals, policies, objectives, implementation programs, and technical information,among others, relating to the preservation of historic resources in the city The following policies were strengthened to provide more protection of historic resources HCR 1.1.1-Continually update the existing citywide survey of historic resources HCR 1.1.2 - Consider the designation of any historically significant public trees, archaeological sites, parks, structures, sites or areas deemed to be of historical,archaeological,or cultural significance as a Huntington Beach City Historical Point, Site or District HCR 1.1.3 - Consider establishing a historic overlay for historic structures throughout the City The overlay should be structured to allow the underlying land use to continue as well as support the reuse of the historic structure HCR 1.2.1 - Utilize the State of California Historic Building Code, Secretary of Interior Standards for Historic Rehabilitation, and standards and guidelines as prescribed by the State Office of Historic Preservation as the architectural and landscape design standards for rehabilitation, alteration, or additions to sites containing historic resources in order to preserve these structures in a manner consistent with the site's architectural and historic integrity Item 15. - 30 HB -528- HCR 1.3.1 -Encourage owners of eligible historic income-producing properties to use the tax benefits provided by the 1981 Tax Revenue Act as well as all subsequent and future financial incentives The HCRE update does not propose any policies, new construction, or physical changes that would have a substantial adverse impact on a historical, archaeological, paleontological, or geological resource or disturb any human remains The HCRE update actually promotes the preservation of historic resources in the city that have been identified based on accepted criteria during a recent historic resources survey As a result of the recent historic resources survey,260 local landmarks have been identified which is an increase from the original 212 in the existing HCRE No negative impacts are anticipated XV. RECREATION. Would the project a) Would the project increase the use of existing El neighborhood, community and regional parks or other recreational facilities such that substantial physical deterioration of the facility would occur or be accelerated9 (Sources 1,3, 10) b) Does the project include recreational facilities or require the construction or expansion of recreational facilities which might have an adverse physical effect on the environment9 (Sources 1, 3, 10) c) Affect existing recreational opportumties9(Sources 1, 3, 10) Discussion a-c: The HCRE update involves updates to the goals, policies, objectives, miplementation programs, and technical information,among others, relating to the preservation of historic resources in the city The HCRE update does not propose any policies, land use,new construction, or physical changes that would increase the use of,or affect park and recreational facilities, or propose the construction or expansion of recreational facilities. It does not change the General Plan land use or zoning designation on any property Triangle Park and Lake Park have been added to the local landmarks list but it would not affect existing recreational opportunities No impacts are anticipated XVI. AGRICULTURE RESOURCES. In determining whether impacts to agricultural resources are significant environmental effects, lead agencies may refer to the California Agricultural Land Evaluation and Site Assessment Model(1997) prepared by the California Dept of Conservation as an optional model to use in assessing impacts on agriculture and farmland Would the proj ect a) Convert Prime Farmland,Unique Farmland,or Farmland of El Statewide Importance(Farmland), as shown on the maps prepared pursuant to the Farmland Mapping and Monitoring Program of the California Resources Agency,to non- agricultural use9 (Sources- 1, 3, 10) n,,,,' 10 HB -,2)9- Item 15. - 31 b) Conflict with existing zoning for agricultural use, or a ❑ ❑ ❑ 0 Williamson Act contract? (Sources 1, 3, 10) c) Involve other changes in the existing environment which, ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑x due to their location or nature, could result in conversion of Farmland, to non-agricultural use? (Sources 1, 3, 10) Discussion a-c: The HCRE update involves updates to the goals,policies, objectives, implementation programs, and technical information, among others,relating to the preservation of historic resources in the city The HCRE update does not propose any policies,new construction, or physical changes that would convert any farmland to non-agricultural use or conflict with existing zoning for agricultural use It does not change the General Plan land use or zoning designation on any property No impacts are anticipated XVII. GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS. Would the project a) Generate greenhouse gas emissions, either directly or ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑x indirectly, that may have a significant impact on the environments (Sources 1, 3, 10) b) Conflict with an applicable plan,policy or regulation adopted for the purpose of reducing the emissions of greenhouse ❑ ❑ ❑ 0 gases (Sources 1, 3, 10) Discussion a-b: The HCRE update involves updates to the goals,policies,objectives, implementation programs, and technical information, among others, relating to the preservation of historic resources in the city The HCRE update does not propose any policies, land use,new construction, or physical changes that will result in any emissions It does not change the General Plan land use or zoning designation on any property Therefore, it would not generate greenhouse gas emissions or conflict with any plan,policy, or regulation adopted to reduce greenhouse gas emissions No impacts are anticipated XVHI. MANDATORY FINDINGS OF SIGNIFICANCE. a) Does the project have the potential to degrade the quality of ❑ ❑ ❑ 0 the environment, substantially reduce the habitat of a fish or wildlife species, cause a fish or wildlife population to drop below self-sustaining levels,threaten to eliminate a plant or animal community, reduce the number or restrict the range of a rare or endangered plant or animal or eliminate important examples of the major periods of California history or prehistory (Sources 1, 3, 10) b) Does the project have impacts that are individually limited, ❑ ❑ ❑ 0 but cumulatively considerable ("Cumulatively considerable"means that the incremental effects of a project are considerable when viewed in connection with the effects of past projects,the effects of other current projects, and the effects of probable future projects ) (Sources 1, 3,4, 5, 10) Papw 20 Item 15. - 32 HB -5310- c) Does the project have environmental effects which will El El El 9 cause substantial adverse effects on human beings, either directly or indirectly (Sources 1, 3, 10) Discussion a-c: Based on the analysis in Section I-XVII the HCRE is an update to an existing policy document pertaining to historic resources It does not propose any land use, new construction, or any physical changes It does not change the General Plan land use or zoning designation on any property It does not have the potential to degrade the quality of the environment, substantially reduce the habitat of a fish or wildlife species, cause a fish or wildlife population to drop below self-sustaining levels, threaten to eliminate a plant or animal community, reduce the number or restrict the range of a rare or endangered plant or animal or eliminate important examples of the major periods of California history or prehistory It would not result many cumulatively considerable adverse impacts or cause substantial adverse effects on human beings No impacts are anticipated HB- ;1- Item 15. - 33 XIX. EARLIER ANALYSIS/SOURCE LIST. Earlier analyses may be used where,pursuant to tiering,program EIR, or other CEQA process, one or more effects have been adequately analyzed in an earlier EIR or negative declaration Section 15063 (c)(3)(D) Earlier documents prepared and utilized in this analysis, as well as sources of information are as follows Earlier Documents Prepared and Utilized in this Analysis Reference# Document Title Available for Review at: I City of Huntington Beach General Plan City of Huntington Beach Planning and Building Dept,2000 Main St Huntington Beach and at bq//www huntmo-tonbeachca gov/Government /Departments/PlanninWgp/index cfin 2 City of Huntington Beach Zoning and Subdivision City of Huntington Beach City Clerk's Office, Ordinance 2000 Main St,Huntington Beach and at http//www huntmgtonbeachca$ov/government/ elected officials/city clerk/zoninga code/index cfm 3 Draft Historic and Cultural Resources Element Update See ..t__L_ u�_ (June 2014) 4 1991 Local Landmarks List with Current Status See2kftftehment 42 5 Appendix B(Updated Landmarks List)of Historic See'MteehmerA QT Context and Survey Report(Updated June 2014) 6 Historic Context and Survey Report(Updated June City of Huntington Beach Planning and 2014) Building Dept,2000 Main St Huntington Beach 7 City of Huntington Beach Geotechnical Inputs Report City of Huntington Beach Planning and Building Dept,2000 Main St Huntington Beach g FEMA Flood Insurance Rate Map (Dec 2009) `L 44 9 CEQA Air Quality Handbook South Coast Air Quality Management District(1993) 10 City of Huntington Beach CEQA Procedure Handbook `L 11 Trip Generation Handbook, 7b Edition,Institute of Traffic Engineers 12 Airport Environs Land Use Plan for Joint Forces Training Base Los Alamitos(Oct 17, 2002) 13 State Seismic Hazard Zones Map Pn(V ?7 Item 15. - 34 HB 32- 14 Hazardous Waste and Substances Sites List www calepa sov/sitecleanup/cortese 15 City of Huntington Beach Municipal Code City of Huntington Beach City Clerk's Office, 2000 Main St,Huntmgton Beach and at hqp Hwww huntmstonbeachca soy/government/ charter codes/municipal code cfm 7 3 HB -53j Item 15. - 35 - RESPONSE TO COMMENTS FOR DRAFT NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO 14-005 I This document serves as the Response to Comments on the Draft Negative Declaration(ND)No 14-005. This document contains all information available in the public record related to the ND as of February 9, 2015 and responds to comments in accordance with Section 15088 of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines. This document contains six sections. In addition to this Introduction,these sections are Public Participation and Review, Comments, Responses to Comments,Errata to the Draft ND, and Appendix The Public Participation section outlines the methods the City of Huntington Beach has used to provide public review and solicit input on the Draft ND The Comments section contains those written comments received from agencies, groups, organizations,and individuals as of Dec. 5,2014 The Response to Comments section contains individual responses to each comment The Errata to the Draft ND is provided to show corrections of errors and inconsistencies in the Draft Mitigated Negative Declaration It is the intent of the City of Huntington Beach to include this document in the official public record related to the Draft ND Based on the information contained in the public record, the decisionmakers will be provided with an accurate and complete record of all information related to the environmental consequences of the project II PUBLIC PARTICIPATION AND REVIEW The City of Huntington Beach notified all responsible and interested agencies and interested groups, organizations, and individuals that a Draft ND had been prepared for the proposed project The City also used several methods to solicit input during the review period for the preparation of the Draft ND The following is a list of actions taken during the preparation, distribution, and review of the Draft ND. 1 A 30-day public review period starting November 6, 2014 and ending December 5, 2014 for the Draft ND was established 2. Notice of the Draft ND was published in the Huntington Beach Independent on November 6, 2014. Upon request, copies of the document were distributed to agencies, groups, organizations, and individuals III COMMENTS Copies of all written comments received as of December 5, 2014 are contained in Appendix A of this document All comments have been numbered and are listed on the following pages All comments from letters received have been retyped verbatim in a Item 15. - 36 HB -534- comment-response format for clarity Responses to Comments for each comment which raised an environmental issue are contained in this document III RESPONSE TO COMMENTS Draft ND No 14-005 was distributed to interested groups, organizations, and individuals The report was made available for public review and comment for a period of 30 days. Copies of all documents received as of December 5, 2014 are contained in Appendix A of this report Comments have been numbered with responses correspondingly numbered. Responses are presented for each comment which raised a significant environmental issue Several comments do not address the completeness or adequacy of the Draft ND, do not raise significant environmental issues, or request additional information A substantive response to such comments is not appropriate within the context of the California Environmental Quality Act(CEQA) Such comments are responded to with a"comment acknowledged"reference This indicates that the comment will be forwarded to all appropriate decision makers for their review and consideration HRB-1 Comment Honorable Mayor and City Council Members, Chair and Planning Commission In regard to Draft Negative Declaration (ND) No 14-005, the Historic Resources Board of Huntington Beach (HRB) would first like to express grateful appreciation to the City and Galvin Preservation Associates (GPA) for the effort to update the Historic Resources Survey for Huntington Beach That said, there are still several issues that MUST be addressed The HRB's concerns regarding the shortcomings of the GPA Draft Survey are and have been the subject of numerous reports and commentaries provided by the HRB over several years Response These comments do not address the completeness or adequacy of the draft ND, do not raise significant environmental issues, or request additional information A substantive response to such comments is not appropriate within the context of CEQA Comments acknowledged and will be forwarded to all appropriate decisionmakers for their review and consideration. HRB-2 Comment The major remaining issues are summarized • The methodology of classification for historic structures was developed under the HB -535- Item 15. - 37 original inaccurate Historic Context and has not been sufficiently changed to reflect the copious corrections and additions brought to light by the HRB - This misunderstanding of the way the city developed has led to a group of categories with arbitrary dates as borders that do not reflect the city's history accurately enough, therefore miscategorising a significant amount of historic buildings, thus diminishing their significance on, or eliminating them from, the currently proffered historic lists. Response The City has provided sufficient analysis to support the conclusions of the ND The historic context and historic resource survey were developed in accordance with the Secretary of Interior's Standards and Guidelines for Historic Preservation and National Register Bulletin 24, Guidelines for Local Survey- A Basis for Preservation Planning. The City hired qualified historical professionals who meet the Secretary of Interior's Professional Qualifications for History and Architectural History to complete the Historic Context using industry standards and methodology for how to complete the work The entire methodology for developing the historic context is provided in the Historic Context and Survey Report starting on page 20 The report provides substantial details on the organization of the historic context based on themes, geography and chronology In addition, the City and its consultant completed several rounds of additional work to address the HRB's comments and corrections resulting in the final draft of Historic Context and Survey Report HRB-3 Comment • The situation above leads to a set of diminished historic districts and a diminished number of those districts overall Several state and national guidelines for preservation documentation provide for methods that allow much greater flexibility in the creation of districts— in size, shape and content (mixing eras, categories, and/or ratios of contributing structures). Those options have been dismissed to a significant degree For example, the two proposed historic districts that are being proffered by GPA use two different(thus arbitrary) standards for inclusion of historic structures The proposed Main Street District is a combination of Early Resort and Oil Boom (but only the early boom, up to 1935) residential structures (not commercial) and the proposed 9th Street District uses only the Early Resort era but includes contributor structures that are neither resort nor oil boom structures Neither district, nor any smaller groupings of structures (of which there are many) that would qualify, uses discontiguous districting or other recognized districting methodologies that would legitimately qualify more historic resources - The districting issue is exacerbated by the initial directive from former Planning Staff to GPA to deliberately keep the Survey's historic districts small to make the idea of restrictive districts more palatable for the public This directive was kept from the HRB until it's resulting conflicts made the initial draft survey untenable Item 15. - 38 HB -5-36- Response The City has provided sufficient analysis to support the conclusions of the ND The historic context and historic resource survey were developed in accordance with the Secretary of Interior's Standards and Guidelines for Historic Preservation and National Register Bulletin 24, Guidelines for Local Survey A Basis for Preservation Planning. The City hired qualified historical professionals who meet the Secretary of Interior's Professional Qualifications for History and Architectural History to complete the Historic Context and Survey Report using industry standards and methodology for how to conduct a survey and identify historic districts The criteria utilized are based on established National and California Register criteria. In addition, the City and its consultant completed several rounds of additional work to address the HRB's comments and corrections regarding historic districts resulting in the final draft of Historic Context and Survey Report The additional anecdotal information regarding the direction given to the City's consultant is used to further the commenter's point but does not specifically address the adequacy of the ND HRB-4 Comment • While significant improvement has been made with additional funding from the City and massive volunteer effort from the HRB, the Survey and its General Plan List of Significant Structures is still not an accurate reflection of the city's historic resources Particularly troubling, due to funding limitations, the critical criteria of association with persons or events reflective of local, state or national history has been omitted from this study with the exception of a mere handful of structures either already prominent or identified by the HRB in the course of this study Response The City has provided sufficient analysis to support the conclusions of the ND. The historic context and historic resource survey were developed in accordance with the Secretary of Interior's Standards and Guidelines for Historic Preservation and National Register Bulletin 24, Guidelines for Local Survey A Basis for Preservation Planning. The City lured qualified historical professionals who meet the Secretary of Interior Professional Qualifications for History and Architectural History to complete the Historic Context and Survey Report using industry standards and methodology for how to complete the work The entire methodology for developing the historic context and conducting the survey is provided in the Historic Context and Survey Report The report provides substantial details on research methods and survey approach. Since the project involves updating a current adopted element of the City's General Plan for which a historic survey was completed and adopted, the survey, in addition to the impact conclusions of the ND, accurately reflect an update to the current General Plan element While the commenter implies that the scope of the project should have been expanded, it does not undermine the accuracy of the work that was completed for the scope of the proposed project In addition, the City and its consultant completed several rounds of additional work to address the HRB's comments and corrections resulting in the final draft of Historic Context and Survey Report The reconnaissance level survey that was HB�537_ Item 15. - 39 completed by the City's consultant is typical of what many local jurisdictions have done and used for their historic preservation efforts HRB-5 Comment. Further, the HRB considers that incorporating a methodology for additions and or corrections to this Draft Survey is absolutely critical. Regardless of the efforts of all concerned, the likelihood that the fullness of subsequent research will document the nature of structures not identified by this report is significant Response The City understands that the Historic Context and Survey Report is a living document that will require ongoing update to keep the information current. The Historic and Cultural Resources Element update includes Implementation Program I-HCR 1 which speaks to performing ongoing surveys every five years to maintain updated information HRB-6 Comment • An auxiliary corrective action meeting between HRB and Planning Staff to allow the HRB to address and correct the issues in the Survey and the resulting diminished lists has discussed the following corrective actions but not implemented/included them 1 Use full range of districting techniques and tools to include all eligible historic resources in Draft Survey and in General Plan Lists derived from it (eg• contiguous and discontiguous boundaries, 65% contributor thresholds and status codes reflecting a more accurate application of the National Register of Historic Places criteria for mclusion, especially NR Criterion A and C and CR Criterion 1 and 3.) Response- See responses to HRB-3, HRB-4 and HRB-9. HRB-7 Comment 2. Apply districting parameters evenhandedly to all potential historic districts, regardless of size, as allowed by NR& CR standards (eg Main Street District should include full 1920-1960 Oil Boom Era, not just to 1935. 9th Street District should use same parameters. All other groupings of structures with similar dates/associations should be listed as potential districts) Response. See responses to HRB-2, HRB-3 and HRB-4 S Item 15. - 40 HB -5 3s- HRB-8 Comment 3 Include a proper protocol for supplementing the qualifying information about the historically significant structures overlooked or miscategorized by the draft survey Response The comment suggests that historic structures were overlooked or miscategorized by the survey See responses to HRB-3 and HRB-4 City staff has had numerous meetings with the HRB to discuss their concerns about the survey report and agrees that developing a protocol for supplementing the survey report in between the ongoing periodic survey that is called for in the Historic and Cultural Resources Element update would be useful The comment does not address a specific impact the suggested mitigation measure would be necessary to ensure mitigation of an impact to a less than significant level HRB-9 Comment Without the above recommended mitigation measures, adoption of Draft ND No.14-005 will absolutely result in the demolition of many historic resources— a very significant impact on the environment according to CEQA Due to the potentially irreversible impacts on our community's historic assets, the HRB regrettably recommends Draft ND No 14-005 not be adopted until these issues can be fully and appropriately corrected The Board also recommends the City utilize the very well and specifically qualified volunteer HRB members to correct the issues addressed here without further expense to the city Response: The Draft ND concludes that the HCRE and associated Historic Context and Survey Report will not cause a substantial adverse change in the significance of a historic structure Substantial adverse change in the significance of a historic structure is caused by proposed demolition or alterations that do not comply with federal standards. The HCRE update involves updates to the goals, objectives, and policies among others, that support the preservation of historic structures in the city The HCRE update does not propose or require any new construction or physical changes such as demolition or alterations of a historic structure that would have a direct substantial adverse impact on a historic structure. In addition,the HCRE update does not propose any policies that would indirectly result in or cause reasonably foreseeable physical changes such as demolition or alterations of a historic structure that would have a substantial adverse impact on a historic structure Instead, the HCRE update promotes the preservation of historic structures in the city that have been identified in the current survey as well as any future surveys The City has provided sufficient analysis to support the conclusions of the ND. The historic context and historic resource survey were developed in accordance with the Secretary of Interior's Standards and Guidelines for Historic Preservation and National xB -j 39_ Item 15. - 41 Register Bulletin 24, Guidelines for Local Survey- A Basis for Preservation Planning The City hired qualified historical professionals who meet the Secretary of Interior Professional Qualifications for History and Architectural History to complete the Historic Context and Survey Report using industry standards and methodology for how to complete the work It identifies an updated list of historic structures and other data that can be used to assist the City in managing its historic preservation goals The survey report is a living document that requires periodic update to keep the information current Therefore, the mitigation measures recommended by the HRB are not needed to avoid any substantial adverse impacts to historic structures as none have been identified. HRB-10 Comment We would very much appreciate the opportunity to expand on these issues if you have any further questions about the background and/or technical issues involved Respectfully submitted Duane Wentworth, Chair,Historic Resources Board of Huntington Beach Response: These comments do not address the completeness or adequacy of the draft ND, do not raise significant environmental issues, or request additional information A substantive response to such comments is not appropriate within the context of CEQA Comments acknowledged and will be forwarded to all appropriate decisionmakers for their review and consideration 7 Item 15. - 42 HB -540- Morrissey-1 Comment Dear Mr Ramon I request the property located at 406 and 406'f Ninth St Huntington Beach,CA 92648,be removed and not considered as historic landmark My w tfe and I are retirement age and I want to be able to build a new home to serve as the Morrissey Family Horne It is a great location and four blocks from the beach Tne designation as historic landmark prevents this On February 14, 1984,my wife and I became owners of 406 and 406 r5 Ninth St Huntington Beach,CA 92648 We have owned the property for over 30 years, This property consists of two house and garage and uniquely on a lot and a half,approximately 40 feet wide The normal lot on the number streets is 25 feet wide Huntington Beach 30 years ago was march different. The downtown area was not built up. There was still a lot of oil wells It definitely was not as appealing as it is today However, I had the vision to purchase and keep this property realizing it was an excellent financial investment The value of this property is the ability to build a large beautiful home with the possibility of a three car garage with room for additional three cars on the garage's apron I would deeply appreciate your assistance in realizing my personal and financial goals Bert Regards, t k lames E Morrissey 5361 Richmond Ave., Garden Grove,CA 92845 Response These comments do not address the completeness or adequacy of the draft ND, do not raise significant environmental issues, or request additional information. A substantive response to such comments is not appropriate within the context of CEQA. However, it should be noted that inclusion of the commenter's property on the local landmarks list would not preclude the commenter from developing his property or place regulatory requirements beyond those currently in effect Additionally, inclusion on the list does not change the uses permitted on the property Comments acknowledged and will be forwarded to all appropriate decrsronmakers for their review and consideration IV ERRATA TO DRAFT ND The following changes to the Draft ND are noted below The changes to the Draft ND as contained within this errata sheet do not affect the overall conclusions of the environmental document Page 3 —Proposed Changes HB -541- Item 15. - 43 The updated list in Appendix B includes 2-60 257 local landmarks and is included as Attachment 3 Page 3 —Historic Context and Survey Report The updated local landmarks list, included in Appendix B of the Historic Context and Survey Report, would serve as a list of historic resources for purposes of evaluating future projects under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Historic resources on the updated list that are proposed to be demolished would require environmental review under CEQA if it involves a discretionary action. Furthermore, any construction work on a historic resource must comply with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties in order to be exempt from CEQA environmental review if it involves a discretionary action. Page 19—Cultural Resources The HCRE update does not propose any policies, new construction, or physical changes that would have a substantial adverse impact on a historical, archaeological, paleontological, or geological resource or disturb any human remains. The HCRE update actually promotes the preservation of historic resources in the city that have been identified based on accepted criteria during a recent historic resources survey. As a result of the recent historic resources survey, 2,W 257 local landmarks have been identified which is an increase from the original 212 in the existing HCRE No negative impacts are anticipated. 9 Item 15. - 44 HB -542- Appendix A „s -543- rem 15. - 45 fli6torie R�6oare�6 board An advisoiv board to the Huntington Beach Cit3 Council December 5, 2014 Honorable Mayor and City Council Members, Chair and Planning Commission In regard to Draft Negative Declaration (ND) No 14-005, the Historic Resources Board of Huntington Beach (HRB) would first like to express grateful appreciation to the City and Galvin Preservation Associates (GPA)for the effort to update the Historic Resources Survey for Huntington Beach That said, there are still several issues that MUST be addressed The HRB's concerns regarding the shortcomings of the GPA Draft Survey are and have been the subject of numerous reports and commentaries provided by the HRB over several years The major remaining issues are summarized • The methodology of classification for historic structures was developed under the original inaccurate Historic Context and has not been sufficiently changed to reflect the copious corrections and additions brought to light by the HRB - This misunderstanding of the way the city developed has led to a group of categories with arbitrary dates as borders that do not reflect the city's history accurately enough, therefore miscategonsing a significant amount of historic buildings, thus diminishing their significance on, or eliminating them from, the currently proffered historic lists • The situation above leads to a set of diminished historic districts and a diminished number of those districts overall Several state and national guidelines for preservation documentation provide for methods that allow much greater flexibility in the creation of districts—in size, shape and content(mixing eras, categories, and/or ratios of contributing structures) Those options have been dismissed to a significant degree For example, the two proposed historic districts that are being proffered by GPA use two different(thus arbitrary) standards for inclusion of historic structures The proposed Main Street District is a combination of Early Resort and Oil Boom (but only the early boom, up to 1935) residential structures (not commercial) and the proposed 9th Street District uses only the Early Resort era but includes contributor structures that are neither resort nor oil boom structures Neither district, nor any smaller groupings of structures (of which there are many) that would qualify, uses discontiguous districting or other recognized districting methodologies that would legitimately qualify more historic resources •The districting issue is exacerbated by the initial directive from former Planning Staff to GPA to deliberately keep the Survey's historic districts small to make the idea of restrictive districts more palatable for the public This directive was kept from the HRB until it's resulting conflicts made the initial draft survey untenable •While significant improvement has been made with additional funding from the City and massive volunteer effort from the HRB, the Survey and its General Plan List of Significant Structures is still not an accurate reflection of the city's historic resources Particularly troubling, due to funding limitations, the critical criteria of association with persons or events reflective of local, state or national history has been omitted from this study with the 2000 Main Stieet ♦ Huntington Beach Califoinia ♦ 92648 Phone ( 714 ) 536 - 5271 ( Planning and Building Dept ) Item 15. - 46 HB -544- fli6torie R�6owre�es board An adxisoiv board to the Huntington Beach City Council exception of a mere handful of structures either already prominent or identified by the HRB in the course of this study Further, the HRB considers that incorporating a methodology for additions and or corrections to this Draft Survey is absolutely critical Regardless of the efforts of all concerned, the likelihood that the fullness of subsequent research will document the nature of structures not identified by this report is significant •An auxiliary corrective action meeting between HRB and Planning Staff to allow the HRB to address and correct the issues in the Survey and the resulting diminished lists has discussed the following corrective actions but not implemented/included them 1 Use full range of districting techniques and tools to include all eligible historic resources in Draft Survey and in General Plan Lists derived from it (eg contiguous and discontiguous boundaries, 65% contributor thresholds and status codes reflecting a more accurate application of the National Register of Historic Places criteria for inclusion, especially NR Criterion A and C and CR Criterion 1 and 3) 2 Apply districting parameters evenhandedly to all potential historic districts, regardless of size, as allowed by NR& CR standards (eg Main Street District should include full 1920- 1960 Oil Boom Era, not just to 1935 9th Street District should use same parameters All other groupings of structures with similar dates/associations should be listed as potential districts) 3 Include a proper protocol for supplementing the qualifying information about the historically significant structures overlooked or miscategonzed by the draft survey Without the above recommended mitigation measures, adoption of Draft ND No 14-005 will absolutely result in the demolition of many historic resources—a very significant impact on the environment according to CEQA Due to the potentially irreversible impacts on our community's historic assets, the HRB regrettably recommends Draft ND No 14-005 not be adopted until these issues can be fully and appropriately corrected The Board also recommends the City utilize the very well and specifically qualified volunteer HRB members to correct the issues addressed here without further expense to the city We would very much appreciate the opportunity to expand on these issues if you have any further questions about the background and/or technical issues involved Respectfully submitted Duane Wentworth, Chair, Historic Resources Board of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Stieet ♦ Huntington Beach , California e 92648 Phone ( 714 ) 536 - 5271 ( Planning and Building Dept ) xB -545- Item 15. - 47 December 1, 2014 Mr Ricky Ramos Senior Planner City of Huntington Planning and Building Department P 0 Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Re Negative Declaration No 114-005 for General Plan Historic and Cultural Resource 406 and 406%Ninth St Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Dear Mr Ramos I request the property located at 406 and 406% Ninth St Huntington Beach,CA 92648, be removed and not considered as historic landmark My wife and I are retirement age and I want to be able to build a new home to serve as the Morrissey Family Home It is a great location and four blocks from the beach The designation as historic landmark prevents this On February 14, 1984, my wife and I became owners of 406 and 406% Ninth St Huntington Beach,CA 92648 We have owned the property for over 30 years This property consists of two house and garage and uniquely on a lot and a half,approximately 40 feet wide The normal lot on the number streets is 25 feet wide Huntington Beach 30 years ago was much different The downtown area was not built up There was still a lot of oil wells It definitely was not as appealing as it is today However, I had the vision to purchase and keep this property realizing it was an excellent financial investment The value of this property is the ability to build a large beautiful home with the possibility of a three car garage with room for additional three cars on the garage's apron I would deeply appreciate your assistance in realizing my personal and financial goals Best Regards, ames E Morrissey 5361 Richmond Ave, , Garden Grove, CA 92845 Email lemornsseyl@email coom 714 812-6929 Item 15. - 48 x8 -546- ATTACHMENT #5 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH HISTORIC RESOURCES ELEMENT Prepared for: City of Huntin ton Beach e �,mN Prepared by Galvin Preservation Associates Inc. 231 California Street El Segundo, CA 90245 HB _54 7_ Item CoNsR NN=DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT_ STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS In addition to the seven mandatory elements, other optional elements may be included in a City's General Plan The California Government Code Section 65303 states: The General Plan may include any other elements or address any other suhjects which, in the judgment of the legislative body, relate to the physical development of the county or city Huntington Beach's Historical and Cultural Element is just such an optional element Once adopted, this element will have the same legal status as any of the mandatory elements Additionally, other state requirements pertaining to the mandatory elements, such as internal consistency, also apply to the optional element This element outlines the overall City goals as they relate to historical and cultural resources within the city and identifies the policies and objectives that the City will follow to meet those goals TECHNICAL SYNOPSIS A. HISTORIC RESOURCES To best understand the importance of Huntington Beach's historic resources, it is necessary to examine the history and events that helped shape the community's built environment. Along with a basic historical understanding, the styles and variations of Huntington Beach's architectural resources must also be examined The overall intent of this section is to identify the historical resources of the community, their current designations and community status, and the issues affecting their future 1. City History (Note- Section re-lvritten) The City of Huntington Beach exemplifies the trials and tribulations of developing a modern city within a region lacking many of the characteristics required for commercial and residential development, with the exception of raw land The city was developed atop a series of treeless bluffs overlooking swampland on all three sides,with the Pacific Ocean to the west Native Americans occupied the Huntington Beach area as far back as eight thousand years ago Subsequently, the Mexicans or Californios also recomnized the natural resources of the area, and ranchos were partitioned off of the original holdings During the late nineteenth century settlers began to recognize that the peaty soils surrounding what was to become Huntington Beach were cultivatable and could produce a vanM of crops It was not until 1903 that the framework of the fledgling community that later became Huntington Beach was formed largely through the connection of the Pacific Electric Railway to Long Beach Incorporated in 1909 by the 1970s Huntington Beach had become one of the fastest growing cities in the nation The settlement and lustory of Huntington Beach was influenced as much by its geomorphology as it was by its culture and people The geological history of Huntington Beach reflects dramatic changes in ocean levels and terrestrial life THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 50 HB -548- COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURALRESOURCESELEMENT It was during the inter-glacial penods that the ocean extended as far mland as Santa Fe Spnngs and Buena Park Major flood events occurred in the early 1860s and agam m 1938 The flood of 1938 destroyed thousands of acres of farmland in the Santa Ana River plain depositingthousands of feet of sand For tens of thousands of years the Santa Ana River plam was a large swamp as thick peat deposits underlie the entire region The Newport-Inglewood fault zone runs underneath Huntington Beach This fault contributed to the Long Beach Earthquake of 1933 (Micenter was actually in Huntington Beach) which damaged or destroyed countless buildmgs m the city of Long Beach and neighbormg communities The fault zone did have some benefits for Huntington Beach creating oil trans that resulted in the development of large oil reserves beneath the community Huntington Beach was inhabited by indigenous people dating back to 8,000 BP Between 7,000 and 1,200 BP prehistoric sites were characterized by large numbers of cogstones and discoidals, and relatively few projectile points Ethno rg_aphically the Gabrielino Indians (Tongva), Chumash. and other tribes occupied the area that would later become Huntington Beach At the time of Spanish contact in the 18th century they occupied a large swath of land along, the California Coast which include most of present-day Los Angeles and Orange counties plus several offshore islands The early history of Huntington Beach prior to its development as a city is tied largely to the development of ranches along the bluffs overlooking swamp lands associated with the area's ever channels By the late 1890s a loose-knit community had developed, although no formal townsite had vet been established Instead small farming communities were created generally near transportation hubs and away from the flood plains along the nver channels and swamps Farming families include the Coles, Newtons and the Furutas Durmg this penod most of the valuable ag icultural lands in Huntington Beach were held by a few families or companies The land was then leased to tenant farmers many of whom were Mexican and Japanese Based upon historic records imm igrant migrant farmers played an miportant part in the agricultural history of California and Huntington Beach In June of 1906 there were more than 1,000 Japanese at work in the celery fields The amicable events that occurred in the mid-1930s, includmg visits by Japanese dignmtaries unraveled following the Japanese bombing of Pearl Harbor in December 1941 Ultimately, most of the Japanese living or working in Huntington Beach were forcibly removed and incarcerated Prior to 1901 the area now known as Huntington Beach was known prmcipally for its agriculture On July 30 1901 it was announced that the name of the new town near Bolsa Chica Bay had been changed from Bolsa Beach to Pacific City Other accounts suggest that the fledt ling community was also referred to as "Shell Beach" until sometmie in 1901 when it was renamed Pacific City In 1902, surveyors were YMortedly at work surveymg the rail lme between Santa Ana and Newport Beach which would eventually reach Huntington Beach As the Los Angeles Time reported on May 30 1903 "m the future the town would be called Huntington Beach" The spring of 1904 was a busy time for the newly formed city of Huntington Beach The pier,beach and the Arbamar Methodist Convention Grounds were drawing tourists to the community and town lots were being sold as quickly as they became available In MU 1904 the Los Angeles Times noted that materials were being shipped to Huntmgton Beach for construction of the electric railway from Los Angeles to Huntmgton Beach via Long Beach In 1909 Huntington Beach was formally incorporated and THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB -5,49- Item 15. - 51 CommuNiTy DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT encompassed an area of 3 57 square miles While agriculture helped sustain the local economy,the beach and Huntington Beach pier were the most important tourist attractions in the city Thy. > jose Nlafpdel Met&,--m ly 1 784 b Gardeft , ccGespel » e aeh the THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 52 xB -550- COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER _HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCESELEMENT rends !Hived the ffiesa to any ;s,-..g eewnaRmity. « „ It was , wells wefe dftlied aftd streets wefe paved, Stafftaft r-eahzed the Reed fef fnass#ffispef"off aftd ts fepefted 2, H+iffttng500 squafe feet lets cc b 2,000 baffels ef eil pamped pef day, the Balsa Chie peeple hiq , ` fits , , Huff:. 4 r Beaeh Gepa af* �.eaeb. �.,,.,,the. ,.to n�t� Street f r$�s nnn_ , , b , b demand, eutb,ffig THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB -5511- Item 15. - 53 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT Huntington Beach Oil Field was the first of the Los Angeles basin oil fields discovered m Southern California in the 1920s, transforming the area into an urban oil boom town overnight and resulting m an acute housm shortage hortage Within a year and a half, the egy's population had grown from just over 1,600 to 7,000 people with another 4,000 ,ob seekers without a place to stay The maximum production of the Huntington Beach Field was reached on July 13 1923 at 127,163 barrels per day from 199 wells By early 1929 the major oil companies were suffering an oversupply of oil Standard Oil shut down 30 producing wells in Huntington Beach which marked the end of the era of the early oil booms Like other Southern Califorma beach communities Huntington Beach offered a variety of outdoor recreation pursuits associated with the Pacific Ocean Early-day resjdgnts and visitors to the city pursued activities such as bathing; and surf-fishing Today, it is difficult to separate the sport of surfimg from Huntington Beach which for many has become a commercial business and way of life Thanks to the efforts of pioneerings urfng greats like Duke and Freeth followed by Higgins and Belsth, surf contests became popular during the late 1920s and early 1930s, and surfimg gamed mainstream popularity in the 1950s which led to the establishment of surf clubs, surf shops, and the city's moniker "Surf City USA " By the early 1960s surfing had become a mainstream part of life in Huntington Beach The first surf shop m Huntmgton Beach opened in 1956 and the West Coast Surfing Championships brought tourists to the cily to support its growing mfrastructure In January of 1944 the United States Nagy unveiled plans to build an ammunition depot on 5,000 acres of land within an area that is now within the City of Seal Beach In November of 1944, the new facility was commissioned as the United States Naval Ammunition and Net Depot at Seal Beach Hundreds of civilian jobs were created m addition to the large number of naval personnel Nearly the same time, Douglas Aircraft completed a new plant in Long Beach and the combination of the two facilities resulted in increased demand for housmg m Huntington Beach and nearby communities The number of automobiles had increased since the 1920s and was by the early 1940s, the principle mode of transportation in Huntington Beach World War II brought a bnef resurgence in the popularity of rail travel In fact, rail ndership hit an all-time high m 1944 During the 1950s with the development of an interstate highway system increased sales of automobiles the usefulness and efficiency of rail lines, particularly along the coast, began to wane Following World War If, factones and businesses previously outfitted for wartime production began to retool in order to address the quickly evolving post-war economy Servicemen and women returning home from the war, a rapid nse m the birth rate in the coup= and the creation of maritime ports such as Long Beach together created a marked need for new housmg throughout Southem California Unlike other communities in Southem Califomia, much of the land base within the city of Huntington Beach was in active oil production Oil derricks remained a part of the crty's landscape and were interspersed among cottages and businesses Agricultural production continued to serve an important role in the local economy Much of the land originally used for agricultural purposes remained until the 1960s and 1970s By 1960 Huntington Beach had grown from 3 57 square miles to over 25 square miles as a result of a senes of farmland annexations The city had become the fastest gowing m the continental United States in the 1970s Today Huntington Beach reflects mM phases of the egg's development from early twentieth century cottages mtermmed with mid-century modem residences and large tracts of post-war housing development It has remained a tourist destination with numerous visitors coming to enenence THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 54 HB -552- COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORICAND CULTURAL RESOURCESELEMENT _ the city's vast waterfront After over 100 years of incorporation, Huntington Beach is home to nearly 190,000 residents as of 2010 2. Architectural Resources (Portions that were substantially re-written or added are underlined) tomes-iinThe buildings with Huntington Beach are comprised of a variety of architectural styles These styles serve as a physical background to understanding the history and culture of the Huntington Beach area The following describes predominant architectural styles that remain in Huntington Beach today Many of these styles both business and residential were in use coincident with each other and not only iu the particular era destgnated here a. Brick or Wood Front Commercial(I850-I940) swt^' b Brick or Wood Front Commercial buildings were constructed throughout Southern California beginning in the 1850s Variations include bnck-front facades, Italianate facades. c y classically-inspired brick stone or stucco-faced facades. arcaded blocks and-false-front designs All these variations applied to commercial architecture in Huntington Beach have their antecedents in the Northeast and the Midwest Each r design could be adapted individually or in groupmgs, often- times sharing_a common wall Character defining features include 1-3 stones in height 3-5 bays classical detailing brick and iron cladding and decoration a flat roof with a parapet: columns decorative pilasters- dentils cornices double-entrance doors deeply-set windows, store-front windows continuous sills corbelling oriels- belt courses; round or arched windows and, in the case of false front designs a flat roof or gable roof behind the front parapet Parapets often varied from a stepped gable semi-circular gable pedimented stepped gable to a triangular pediment b. Oueen Anne(I880--19I0) Queen Anne, Queen Anne Cottage, Shingle and Eastlake are all style variations on the Victonan theme that occur in Huntington Beach's residential structures Victonan, in American architecture,refers to styles that were popularized during the last decades of Britain's Queen - Victoria's reign (1837-1901) The sit ,le ifftfedueed theeenstraetiefieA ' b be�i lily Victonan styles clearly reflect industrialization changes in their elaborate detailing and decorative components such as irregular elevations, frequently broken up by towers or bay windows and the exteriors decorated with spindles, fretwork, sawnwork and elaborate scrollwork THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB -553- Item 15. - 55 COMMUNrry DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT N@m4aftd ifeiise, 223 SPA Str jot(ce��e) b. Colonial Revi ,aVNeo Glass:^^'nueen Anne architecture" is a misnomer because the style drew no mspiration from the formal Renaissance architecture that dommated Queen Anne of England's reign (1792-1714) It was named and popularized by a group of English architects who borrowed the visual vocabulga of late medieval stiles mcludmg half tunbermg and patterned surfaces The William Watts Sherman house in Newport Rhode Island, built by Boston architect Henry Hobson Richardson and featuring a half-timbered second story, is recognzed as the first Queen Anne style house built in America The British government introduced the Queen Amie style to America with several buildings it constructed for the 1876 Centennial Exposition in Philadelphia, and helped to launch a style that soon replaced Second Empire as the country's most popular and fashionable domestic architecture style. a Late Victorian Era Vernacular(1900-I9I5) s n At the tum of the century America's love of Victorian ideals 1 5,% began to wane, and builders transitioned from ornamented ** ..r Queen Anne desi ans to more simple, and less ornamented Fx* rf' styles Late Victorian architecture in Huntmgton Beach is characterized by buildings that retain certain elements of Victorian architecture, mcludmg fenestration, porches, but reveal indications of the development of Craftsman and Bungalow Architecture One sub-type of the Late Victonan Vernacular was the Cross-Gable Cottage house style, developed from late nineteenth century designs found in many Southern California communities The cross gable provided an additional projection that was relatively simple to design and build,and offered additional space for bedrooms and a kitchen Another important subtype of the Late Victorian Vernacular homes is the Hipped Roof Cottage house The residence is charactenzed b its is square massing, single-story height, and hipped roof Homes were designed with a half or full front porch as is seen m the house on the left The omanientation of these homes generally includes brackets under the roof eaves, gingerbread and fretwork above the porch columns and a symmetrical or asymmetncal facade In other cases the homes lacked any significant ornamentation and followed the transitional styles associated later with Arts and Crafts and Craftsman Bungalow houses d Neoclassical Box(eff;ea-Beach Residences(-1900-I9-12)_ Neoclassical homes became popular during the early decades of ��. the twentieth century m Huntington Beach These homes v emphasize a rectangular volume with classical ornaniental detailing The residences are covered by a moderately-pitched TINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 56 - HB --14- COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCESELEMENT hipped or pyramid roof and often have small dormers The entry is recessed under the principal roof and is either a partial width porch on the corner or a full width front porch supported by columns. The windows are tall and narrow double or sin lg_e hung wood windows and sometimes have decorative multi- Wilt windows on the upper pane These residences were Mica]ly small and boxy in form with slightly boxed eaves and wide cornice bands under the eaves The siding is typically horizontal dropped siding_ This revival of interest in the classical models dates from the World's Colombian Exposition held m Chicago m 1893 The expositions' planners mandated a classical theme, and many of the best-known architects of the day designed dramatic colonnaded buildings arranged around a central court The exposition was widely photographed, reported, and attended, soon these Neo-classical and Colonial Revival models became the latest fashion throughout the country a THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB -.5;s- Item 15. - 57 CommuNny DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT J� !41Z1 CaeL 428 /ua-Ri vv 321 702 i i LzrSu vv L.. CVLL(1SLs/Lallaga11V7 THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 58 JIB -556- COMMUNrry DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER _--HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT e, Cottage Bungalows(1912-1940) The quintessential single-family residential unit developed on much of Califorrua's coast, was the "beach cottage" or "cottage bungalow" The beach cottage was adopted by many builders as an economical solution to more expensive custom homes While beach cottages were designed in a variety � rr styles, including Craftsman, Bungalow, Mediterranean, the sari fundamental architectural characteristics were its relatively simple design and modest size Three distinguishable wood- '` frame varieties can be found throughout portions of Huntington Beach, including the front-gable, the side- ag ble, and the hipped roof design Variations of these examples are also found with stucco exterior cladding Cottages in the Huntington Beach area were commonplace from the beginning of the 20"' cenUgy, through the 1950s They were constructed by individuals as second homes or as worker's housing for those working in the nearby oil fields Indicative to Huntington Beach was the relocation of these modest homes as the oil companies moved their operations from area to area This category includes small, modest homes, beach cottages and Cahforma Bungalows The word Bungalow can be traced to India,where in the 19th century,the British used it to describe a one story house with a high encircling porch. In California,the term is applied to houses that have similar characteristics but their design concepts derive from completely different antecedents The California Bungalows drew much of their influence from the -small-scale, one-story, Queen Anne-style cottages that were profusely built throughout California between 1880 and 1890 It was this basic form in which architects brought elements of the craftsman movement,the Stick Style and others into a very distinct American synthesis This style of homes primarily served as beach resort cottages and modest housing for those in Huntington Beach Exterior wall surfaces are covered with board and battenbaton clapboard or stucco These houses are built of a single story with a porch or porches. Their windows are wood hung in either double-hung or casement L-,d- Craftsman{eifea/Bungalow(1905_1930) r7F, i The Craftsman style was born in California and drew 'f,.� " ;.�,',' ;�,,. � u inspiration from the Arts and Crafts movement and its focus on natural materials Widely disseminated through pattern books and magazines it became the most prevalent style for small houses in the nation until the Great Depression One and 1'/2 story Craftsman style houses are popularly known as bun alg ows NGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN . Y 11B Item 15. - 59 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT The craftsman house is one of the few indigenous American styles inspired by the work of two Southern Californian brothers, Charles and Henry Greene. The theme of the craftsman construction emphasized function and beauty while utilizing local materials to blend with local landscapes The craftsman style became increasingly popularized through various publications, and as result, a flood of pattern books offered plans for craftsman bungalows It was through these mechanisms that the craftsman house quickly became the most popular and fasluonable house style in the country In common with the Prairie style the hallmark of a Craftsman house is its roof. In this case, it is generally a shallow gable (versus hipped) roof with overhanging, eaves and visible roof beams and rafters Full or partial-width porches with tapered square supports often of stone or concrete block, are typical Characteristic bungalow windows are double-hung with rectangular divided lights in the top sash and a single light in the bottom sash The Craftsman style expenenced a peak in populanty in Southern California during the early 1920s, and Huntington Beach was no different The city has a wealth of architectural resources in this style Most are single-family residences although there are also Craftsman apartment buildings There were modest bungalows as well as more substantial Craftsman examples, including those that are two-stories in height Craftsman homes began to be constructed from about 1905, although the boom period for this ale within Huntington Beach did not appear to occur until the 1910s. The character defining features include horizontal wood board cladding and multi-front gabled (often low-pitched) roofs There is often a priniga gabled roof at the facade and a secondary roof at the porch below The wide overhanging, eaves had exposed rafters and extended and/or elaborated rafter ends There are frequently decorative vented openings false beams and/or stickwork within the gable Tapered (often heavy) squared pilasters are used as porch supports There are wood windows with multiple panes above a single pane(sometimes flanked by double hung sash windows) at the facade The other windows are also often double hung sash sometimes with lamb's tongues, the main window at the first floor facade often consisted of a fixed window with multiple panes at the top flanked by double hung sash windows The Craftsman windows are typically surrounded by wide casings z Eclectic and Revivalist(1920-1940) The Eclectic movement began near the end of the 19th century and embraced a variety of Old World architectural traditions Emphasizing careful copies of historic patterns it spawned a number of period revival styles that coexisted _= in friendly competition including Colonial Revival, Tudor/English Cottage Revival, Neoclassical, and Italian Renaissance Revival. The Tudor Revival style in America was based loosely on medieval English architecture Enormously popular in the 1920s and 1930s, it benefited from advances in masonry veneering technique that allowed for the re- creation of English brick and stucco fagades Steeply pitched roofs prominent cross gables half- timbering large chimneys with chimngy12ots and tall narrow windows with multi-pane glazing are the hallmarks of the Tudor Revival style Entrance doorways typically arched, are often elaborated with brick surrounds mumcking quoins Multi-pane casement windows in groups of three or more are common THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 60 HB -558- CommuNTrY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT h. Mediterranean,Spanish, and Mission Revival(1920-1940) For the first three decades of its existence,the architecture of HuntinZon Beach was largely defined by Late- � � Victonan or Arts and Crafts (Craftsman) gabes Not until the late 1920s and 1930s did the developers and builders begm to expand the architectural horizons of the community to include Mediterranean styles of civic buildings, businesses, and residences The use of architectural elements and designs indigenous to the countries surrounding the Mediterranean Sea began to take hold in the late-19th century and reached its apogee at the San Diego exhibition in 1915 There were several styles that quickly gained popularity - most notably panish-Colonial derived from Spain, Mexico, and South America, and Mission, derived from Spanish Missions in California and the American Southwest In later years other sub-forms developed referred today as Spanish Revival Italian-Villa, and Tuscan Spanish eclectic architecture is another term applied to the various forms of Mediterranean design, charactenzed by asymmetrical shapes with cross-gables and side wings low pitched roofs red roof tiles little or no overhanging eaves stucco siding,• courtyards carved doors spiral columns and pilasters, carved stonework or cast ornaments patterned the floors and wall surfaces and arches, especially over doors, porch entries and main windows e-,,,e�oaigs Reef faftefs af-e usua4ly e)Epesed with deeer-ative beams ef bfaees eoffliiieal� added tmdef the gables Per-ehes are eAer-full of peAtial width wA the feef suppefted by tapered sqiiff� eelufrffis, whie THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB -5-59- Item 15. - 61 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT Domestic buildings of Spanish precedent built before 1920 are, for the most part, free adaptations of the mission style Not until the Panama-Cahforma Exposition of 1915, held in San Diego, did the precise umitation of more elaborate Spanish prototypes received greater attention The interpretations focused on the richness of Spanish precedents and architectural traditions that were observed throughout Latin America. The style features low pitched roofs, usually with little or no overhang, and red tile roof coverings The floor plans are typically informal with simple box-like shapes Prominent arches are usually placed above the door,principle windows or just beneath the porch's roof Wall surfaces are almost always stucco on an asymmetrical facade 1 1 1 115 7th St feet 509 loth We 828 1 1th St fee+ English , Geer-gtafie Ffeneh e walls, pampets, tile feefs an b twef ? b eftefaRy easement ef datible hung and the &� deer-fs eften heavy weed tft design Most homes ef this peffed de and ai-7e weed&aEae THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 62 HB -560- COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT L Bungalow Courts(1920-I940) The development of Bungalow Courts provided affordable „s1 housing dunng_a penod of growth in the oil boom industry m Huntington Beach The numerous courts m Huntmgton Beach developed from three typological and stylistic sources the bungalow courts of the early 20th century whose antecedents began in Southern Califomia; auto courts or motor courts, and popular architecture styled after Traditional and Mediterranean designs The typical character defining features of bungalow courts include multiple small single-family residences that open into a central courtyard area The units may be attached or detached, but all have separate entrances and porches facing the inner court Architectural styles may include Craftsman bungalow or Spanish Colonial Revival detailing_ �. Art Deco (1925-I940) The teen Art Deco was corned from the Exposztzon des Arts Decoratzfs held in Pans m 1925 Robert Mallet- Stevens (1886-1945) helped promote Art Deco architecture as it developed in Europe In the United States Art Deco was embraced by Raymond Hood, who � t designed three of the most distmctive buildmgs m New ��•ice York City the Radio City Music Hall auditorium and foyer, the RCA building at Rockefeller Center, and the New York Daily News building Rectilinear designs, vivid color, strong lines and undulating, repeating patterns are a trademark of Art Deco design, especially in the Deco buildmgs of the 1930s Some buildmgs are embellished with flowmtr waterfall effects, while others present colors m bold, geometnc blocks But, Art Deco design is about more than color and ornamental patterns The very shape of these buildings expresses a fascination for orderly forms and prmutive architecture The typical character definmg features of Art Deco buildings include an emphasis on blocked massmg, horizontal omamentation, s�etU, rounded corners or cornices, stepped parapets, flat rooflmes, stylized vertical motifs such as pilasters or integrated stepped Classical ornamentation k. ZiLzaz Moderne(1925-I940) a_ The zigzag moderne style of architecture is an off shoot of Art Deco design, which originated m France m the 1910s and became popular m the United States ill the 1920s and 30s Zigzag Moderne is highly decorative with the facade of buildmgs utilizing geometnc ornamentation It was popular on commercial storefronts in urban areas and large public buildings, especially high nse buildings such as hotels and -`= movie theaters, skyscrapers, and restaurants It utilized expensive and exotic materials and veneers as well as steel and glass In contrast to the Streamline Moderne and Art Deco styles, the omamentation emphasized verticality and geometric motifs such as zigzags, swags. and corbels It THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB -561- Item 15. - 63 COIN U Y DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT often exhibits a smooth extenor surface material and often mcluded tilework wood veneers marble painted terra-cotta and metals on the lower facades L Minimalist/Minimal Traditional(1940-I960) F , Minimalist Architectural designs were a product of the � u a modem era of architecture begmnm during World War U � g g and contmuing into the 1950s Designed for workingclass lass families minimalist buildin sp are eg nerally modest in size - and ornamentation often-tunes built as tracts, but ahnost always exhibiting design elements that veered away froin Illlf �Il�) di the earlier Craftsman and Bungalow styles In Huntm on Beach minimalist hoines appear during the early 1940s perligps in response to the very modest cottage homes of the oil boom years The typical character defining features of minimal traditional buildings include compact massing low pitched multi-gable or hipped roofs with shallow eaves modest omamentation, inset porches under the principal roofline simple wood post porch supports single car garages (attached or detached), oriel wmdows sunple surrounds smooth stucco exteriors or simple wood board exterior siding (or a combination thereof) m. California Ranch (1930--I970) Sometimes called the California ranch style, this home in vrrY the Modem architectural family, onginated in the 1930s by architects such as Cliff May It emerged as one of the most popular American styles in the 1950s and 60s when the -§ automobile had replaced early 20th-century forms of -' - - transportation such as streetcars Now mobile homebuyers - could move to the suburbs into bigger homes on bigger lots The style originated as a reflection of the Rancho type of architecture with an emphasis toward an inner courtyard - and privacy toward the street. It implemented intenor "coindors"and often had a splayed plan or sprawling plan Smaller versions or "ranchettes" nnplemented the same design concepts in a compact manner The decorative details to the extenor take their cues from the spare and hardy practicality of westem styles like Monterra Spanish Colonial Prame and Craftsman homes as well as the Westem False Front shops and board & batten mining shacks popularized by Wild West epics of the era like High Noon and How the West Was Won It is characterized by its one-story pitched-roof construction attached garage, wood or bnck exterior walls, and picture windows n, Modern and Neo-Eclectic(1935—I970) The International and Modernistic styles, emphasizmg honzontals flat roofs smooth wall surfaces, and large window expanses renounced histonc precedent in a radical departure from the revival styles Most suburban houses built since 1935 fall mto the Modem st le category These include the familiar fonns we call Cape (officially termed minimal traditional), ranch, split-level - and contemporary The one-story ranch house form GTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 64 HB -562- COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT designed by a pair of California architects, was the prevailing style dunng the 1950s and 1960s Contemporary was the favored style for architect-built houses between 1950 and 1970 Neo-Eclecticism, which emerged in the mid-1960s and supplanted the Modem style, represented a return to traditional architectural styles and forms It mcludes Mansard, Neo-Colonial Neo-French Neo-Tudor, Neo- Mediterranean Neo-Classical and Neo-Victonan These styles borrow prominent details from histonc models in bold,free interpretations o. Courtyard Apartments(1950-1975) Evolving from the Bungalow Courts of the 1920s and • _. 1930s, a revival of sorts began in the 1960s that resulted in the devellMment of multi-unit apartments with mtenor courtMards The designs in Huntmaton Beach were more whimsical often mcludmg Polynesian motifs k^ THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB -563- Item 15. - 65 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT 3. Historic Resources FigureDepfeted oft iT-.o ztr�nzroin-v�s�m�or-�i�Ftxrt.-r�amarTr %-ciiP-ci +''fl�-l�t'at'ms-Ynl''��) .,,1 Pie 1,,.,+e fte..1 t,., t have been .1 tf d are d b d below Y a pfesefvtag the 0 lnalc✓sys a ies gfeatef fleidbility ift detefftmiEfig the types of-feha buildings, Afnefteaft e e The City of Huntmg;ton Beach has played an important role in the development of California and that history is visible today through the City's built environment As such the Crtyhas an mterest m preserving promotmg and improving the historic resources and districts withm Huntmgtton Beach for the educational cultural economic and general welfare of the public In 1986,the City conducted a survey documentmg the lustoric core of the City of Huntmaon Beach From 2008- 2012 the City and Historic Resources Board (IM) updated and expanded the previous survey to include a stud of f all potentially significant buildmgs wrthm the entire city The lustonc survey identified several buildings that were either individually eligible for the National Register. Califoma Register of Histoncal Resources or that may have significance at the local level The survey also updated and identified concentrations of buildings that qualify as lustoric distncts lt. 1 ( ) It the Ae.,t,., of the HRB t„ l., a the rt�-i racOi�C-a}l�-age,-caxcarar-36Ei�-6�'i�l�i�$C�k9ii� —rx.vrt„ t, e e >seale, de and/of ftmetteft Table 14CR4 repfeseffts the fattng system devised by the Depaftfnefft of the Intenef ai THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 66 HB -564- COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT hThe City of Huntington Beach maintams a master inventory of potentially histonc properties, which compnses all the properties withm the city that have been identified as potentially havmg historic significance This inventory is periodically updated and is used to assist the City with managing its short and long term historic preservation goals The determination of historical sigauficance was based on methodology that is consistent with the State of Califomia Office of Historic Preservation's (OM guidance as outlined in Instructions for Recording Historic Resources and the Department of the Interior's National Park Service Bulletm 24 Guidelines for Local Surveys A Basis for Preservation Planning The Califomia Office of Histonc Preservation has established a series of status codes, which identify the historical status of the property The Califomia Historical Resource Status Codes are codes that were created by OHP as a database tool to classify historical resources m the state's inventory which had been identified through a regulatory process or local goverment survey The code system was mitially created as National Register Status Codes in 1975 but has since been updated and changed in 2004 due to the ambiguity of the earl cog system and changes in the needs of local govenunents' registration programs statewide to convey the significance of resources for purposes of the CEQA Implicit within the status codes is a hierarchy reflecting the level of identification, evaluation and designation to which a property had been subjected The followmg table identifies the list of histonc status codes THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON' BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB _5,65_ Item 15. - 67 CommuNrry DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER — ---HISTORX-AND—CULTUR L.RESODUBCES California Historical Resource Status Codes aaop es _ t ale a�egi_r _Ry1,gk6i!�lifo _fah {CRC] 1D Contributor to a district or multiple resource property listed in NR by the Keeper Listed in the CR- is Individual property listed in NR by the Keeper Listed in the CR iCD Listed In the CR as a contributor to a district or multiple resource property by the SHRC ICS Listed in the CR as individual property by the SHRC. iCL Automatically listed in the California Register—Includes State Hrstoncal Landmarks 770 and above and Points of Historical Interest nominated after December 1997 and recommended for listing by the SHRC Wis,R�=r+ r8 talior'� 2B Determined eligible for NR as an individual propp.Jty and as a contributor to an eligible district in a federal regulatory process Lasted in the CR- 2D Contributor to a district determined eligible for NR by the Keeper Listed in the CR 2D2 Contributor to a distinct determined eligible for NR by consensus through Section 106 process Listed in the CR 2D3 Contributor to a district determined eligible for NR by Part I Tax Certification Listed In the CR. 2D4 Contributor to a district determined eligible for NR pursuant to Section 106 without i evew by SHPO Listed in the CR 2s Individual property determined eligible for NR by the Keeper Listed in the CR- 252 Individual property determined eligible for NR by a consensus tnrough Section 106 p€aces.Lamed in the CR 2S3 Individual property detemined eligible for NR by Part I Tax Certification Listed In the CR. 2S4 Individual property determined eligible for NR pursuant to Section 106 without review by SHPO Listed in the CR 20 Determined eligible for CR as an individual property and as a contributor to an eligible district b}the SHRC- 2CD Contributor to a district determined eligible for I shng in the CR by the SHRC. 2CS Individual property determined eligible for listing in the CR by the SHRC. 3B Appears eligible for NR both rndmdually and as a contributor to a NR eligible district through survey evaluation 3D Appears eligible for NR as a contributor to a NR eligible district through survey evaluation. 3s Appears eligible for NR as an individual property through survey evaluation 3CB Appears eligible for CR both lnd'iwnduaily and as a contributor to a CR eligible district though a survey evaluation 3CD Appears eligible for CR as a contributor to a CR eligible oistrict through a survey evaluation 3CS Appears eligible for CR as an individual property through survey evaluation ACM Master list-State Owned Properties—PRC f 5024 PRO- '11LIK191,160f, 4 La 5D1 Contributor to a district that is listed or designated locally 5D2 Contributor to a district that is eligible for local listing or designation 5D3 Appears to be a contributor to a district that appears eligible far local listing or designation through survey evaluation. 5S1 Individual property that Is lusted or designated locally 552 Individual property that is eligible for local listing or designation 5S3 Appears to be inervndually eligible for[oral listing or designation thi ough survey evaluation 513 Locally significant both individually tiisted,eligible,or appears eligible)and as a contributor to a district that is locally listed, designated,determined eligible or appears eligible through survey evaluation 6C Determined ineligible for or removed from California Register by SHRC. 63 landmarks or Points of Interest found ineligible for designation by SHRC 6L Determined ineligible for local listing or designation through local government review process,may warrant special consideration in local planning 6T Determined ineligible for NR through Part I Tax Certification process 6J Determined Ineligible for NR pursuant to Section 106 without ieview by SHPO 6W Removed from NR by the Keeper 6X Determined ineligible for the NR by SHRC or Keeper 6Y Determined ineligible for NR by consensus through Section 106 process—Not evaluated for CR or L.acal Listing 67f Found ineligible for NR,CR or Local designation through survey evaluation_ +r, ill dal 73 Received by OHP for evaluation or action but not yet evaluated 7K Resubmitted to OHP for action but not reevaluated. 7L State Historical Landmarks 1-769 and Points of Historical Interest designated prior to January 1998—Needs to be reevaluated using current standards 7M SubnNtted to OHP but not evaluated-referred to NPS 7N Needs to be reevaluated(Formerly NR Status Code 4) 7N 1 Needs to be reevaluated(Foi merly NR SC4)—may become eligible for f.R wirestoration or when nmee s other specific conddrorms 7R Identified in Reconnaissance Lerel Surve} Not evaluated TN Submitted to 0HP for action—wrthdram'L 12191200_ THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 68 HB -5,66- COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER F�ISTORICAND CULTURAL RESOURCESELEMENT a. National Register of Historic Places The G#y Gym aad Pkmige was added to the register- tn 1993 The s#-detwe was built fft 1931 alad is still used for-its efiginal purpose as a g5T&�tmtum afid peel f6eility THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB _567_ Item 15. - 69 r r Q 4 LU SEAL }, WESTMINSTER BEACH BOLSA� I .I MG 0 z _ f FADDEN r •^�•.«•. HEIL r WARNER FOUNTAIN VALLEY �A zr � }sLATER cos COUNTY OF �+ 'TALBERT ORANGE (BOLSACHICA) in f ' 1 ELLIS ,J m m r l•�• _ GARFIELD r Z % Y()PMV N AIM PACIFIC OCEAN _ / tNDraNAPous I ATLANTA R � % Legend PIERcgq� HANILTON C4 Boundary Potential Districts % BANNING Areas with known concentra of histonc resources / COSTA Local Historic Res CBS % MESA 1 Huntington Bea ter / 2 Huntington High School 3 Bartlett Pa ewland House) 4 Central brary / Nafko Register 1 ewtand House(1898) / Helm House/Furnishing Co (1904) 3 Gamer House(1M 4 Worthy House(1880) 5 Cdy Gym 1 1 / HISTORICA}.RESOURCES '° ��c�Q1 Item 15. — 70NTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB -568- COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER Th5TOB aANDEuruRAL-REsoURCESELEMENT Ratings The National Register of Historic Places is the Nation's official list of cultural resources worthy opreservation Authorized under the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 the National Register is part of a national program to coordinate and support public and -rivate efforts to identify, evaluate and protect our historic and archeological resources Properties listed in the Register include districts, sites, buildings, structures, and obiects that are significant in American history architecture, archeology, engineerz= and culture The National Register is administered by the National Park Service, which is part of the US Department of the Interior The cnteria for inclusion in the National Register of Histonc Places include those properties that are A Associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad pattems of our history, or B That are associated with the lives of persons significant in our past, or C That embody the distinctive charactenstics of a We, period, or method of construction or that represent the work of a master, or that possess high artistic values or that represent a si mificant and distinguishable entity whose components may lack individual distinction, or D That has yielded, or may be likely to yield, information unportant m prehistory or history b. California Register of Historical Resources The California State Historical Resources Commission has designed this program for use by state and local agencies priVate groups and citizens to identify, evaluate, register and protect California's historical resources The California Register is the authoritative guide to the state's sip-ziifcant historical and archeological resources The Cal forma Register program encourages public recognition and protection of resources of architectural, historical, archeological and cultural szgnzfzcance identifles historical resources for state and local planning purposes determines eligibility for state historic preservation grant unding and affords certain protections under the California Environmental QualztvAct The cnteria for inclusion m the California Register of Historical Resources include any object, building structure site area, place record_ or manuscript which a lead agency deter nines to be historically significant or significant in the architectural en mg eenng scientific economic agricultural, educational social political mihtary or cultural annals of Califomia may be considered to be an historical resource provided the lead agency's determination is supported by substantial evidence in light of the whole record Generally, a resource shall be considered by the lead agency to be "histoncally significant" if the resource meets the cnteria for listing on the Califomia Register of Historical Resources (Pub Res Code SS5024 1 Title 14 CCR, Section 4852)including the following 1 Is associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad pattems of Califomia's history and cultural heritage, 2 Is associated with the lives of persons important in our past, 3 Embodies the distinctive characteristics of a type,period region or method of construction, or represents the work of an important creative individual or possesses high artistic values or THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB _569_ Item 15. - 71 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESO URGES ELEMENT 4 Has yielded or may be likely to yield information important in prehistory or history The California Register of Historical Resources was not created until 1998 by an act of the State Legislature Under the provisions of that legislation the followmQ resources are automatically included in the California Register • Resources formally detennmed eligible for or listed in, the National Register of Histonc Places through federal preservation programs adinuustered by the Office of Historic Preservation,mcludmg the National Register program,the Tax Certification program.National Historic Preservation Act Section 106 reviews of federal undertakmgs, • State Histoncal Landmarks(SHL)numbered 770 or higher, and a Appears 1 5 1.1 for-7...+,,,.b e—J as a +.+nbule.-to a 1 AT+ t 1 4 - Reg.,+o. dtsl et 4 May beeeme el}gible for- M41ffi y cm/SD Appears indiNgdeally ehole foF leeal landmark desipatieii. g Nefte ef the above NR Not fated bit- b nifieanee AA ATehaeeleR;ea +o l fS Histofie 1 e.+o THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 72 HB -570- COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT • Leeu-Points of Histoncal Interest(PHIS recommended for listing in the California Register by the State Historical Resources Commission c. City of Huntington Beach Historic Landmarks City of Huntmgton Beiteh ss ir � w - 9151 t�.a D..r. +vac z —. ` 17011-each !'1.. tef fftff — 1 77 1z�zTr Beaeh Eff I — S 1^QT�ne 4VA 47 84�P - Is c3^ MeDeflgall4Douglas — Is 2^�Bushafd Heed — Is 3e i cakfe 4e — Is ,, 49-79 — Is 2' 8 c* I LR 4^1�o r De.�lme wale — I4 — AAS 7 162-Go4hwd Slate — 13P 4� Heuse 494* - Is ^ ffigggms Hoosee 494-5 3 FR Lake Rail 4923 - Is Los petes/off V iter-Towee-F - Is ` - Is „44� Olson Buildifig 49476 3D 4993 3D 44M 3D Is 1'�aifl 04mT-Dfugs 448 &D � See T--able 14C R 1 THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB - 71- Item 15. - 73 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT _ Frc Fir ,ss _ � $ Landwar `.. Sigairleaaee Rating fir& R4r -rT��cv.s 4984 3D s 247-Maffi194-0 3D Is 2,�m H B Sheet MeW 49+9 3D Is 7l^7z q-Mafi D,....eer-Feed P.Fiwl 47" 3-D S 325-Maia 49-5-1 — s I{ 493-3 3D s NlaiDA4th C. ark i905 — w Mam Street. 3-D s 1905 49M -3 s 2000-Maffl 4474 — s — s 2173 n Newland E4+s&� — s Ej*ah&,%Hease — FdR lie US Post e 49-3C 38D Is n 4-4DhW Dr- l4awes Me,a.,a ai.,a 4936 3D RLF �lam. nrr=-H uH-B--R'W nln 4 16P u�em 3-B s Telephone&Eehang l6nnG14 Petws Laadffig — 21100 PCH 49W — -I-93-3 -3 Ii 1600 V)34 3 s — �s s THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 74 IJB -572- CommuNTry DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER LISTOR[C AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT___ TABLE 14 (eeFA) ddiesg" Pese pt�4� -D4- -W 7-Z7 7111 Talbeft Cea#-Val 7-2—M-c Tib� 9 412 414 WalBut Dr-�Gom.m..er.-eia.i 4920% 9 -54-3.5%IQ IATZ-t Helms House Fumishin 4904 3D $ 5203 Afamef Meadow4ar-k S 4/3D 941/p- 7360 73-86 Wa� WaFaer-Bapt4st Chufeb- 4906 A4S 762-2 Wunef 9 7642 WameT Ft�� s AlamerLB Seer Edison Substation H/p g,-g york4om% Neftham l4euser3 s 34g--,�2 Yotmg Build-Hig, 492-3 5±-A3D 344-3fd 1880's Hou&e -5 ti 204--54h &hank4 I e las ep, 494-2 � 218 4918 4/3D 9 314--5th Zigzag Me4efja 4938!S -5 9 317-5th C-faftsman Bungalow 4W 5-t s Golonial4e� 490-5 -51 9 42-6-6th Kekntwo#hy HoUsee 4S90!s 47 8-P./P 41"th Baptist 0Rweh 4906 4 9 4940% -5 s 42-7-7th Bwagalew Gel—ut 1925 -5 s 401 403 Ah C-Faftsffwn Aparo-effEss 4930 --lil $ 4229-74h Nee Classteal House 1940 s 341-84h Pkc�ewval Q+ufe-b- 4224-M Hotel Evaggelme 1906 -3 s 24+#th V4etffi-ta 4-9" -5 3a-1-1-04h St Mary's Ghunelh, 494,0 -5-*- 144340th , J-uEl-,e amer-House 4907 -5 844/P 4-2040th Womods GW3house 194-6 4 9 THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB -573- Item 15. - 75 u � , f',. ��� i3 "a 3�P`"-fin� '� ,..-_, A a.,.r�...,}l� ...1 t .✓,o � i Vey l E � `` ".��.-r.�',����'-,�`~'�3s� _ ., ems' ,• ::�" kr.����..�^ -�.' �,t 1 a s I ` Gamer house 190Y A-7 Wat k S 0 moo _ S WN OF Ym I I f n m rP: P r I c lN LWQ s w .I �} jq- y< ' .57 f i " 5 r ,r i h . ., y r �•.� c� .�,'� yd 4� t$�r w4.d'c`�J¢p�ar�� . . 1A 00 E "' COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT On a hiot bluff evefleakifig the leMands ef Hafitiagteft Beaeh stands the heffie built by Wdhaffi aftd Mary e > established a > sen,tee b b is the e* b , e The Rehii]Alefdiy Heuse ts estbr&ted te ha-ve been built abet# 1880 Tlifs modified Queen Aiine is efte ef e the hease fetaffis tffHeh ef its btstefie tfAegtty The houses b -ftifieanee is pr-efnzulgated by b e s htstory The Helm Worth), house, whieh sits adjaeefft le the Helm Hease b b b gi The Gafnef > eenstFaeted in > b e. Potential National Landmarks The g was listed efi studied afe also petentiaNy eligible Staee the date ef the e Please see acn9etks'.r208-3n SeeRon"evcivdr THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 78 HB -576-31 COMMUNTTy DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT afe fe vefsed- > 400, > > s ea*development. Wesley k Maffi Stpeet,up te Tenth Metme This e&ea inehides inany ef the Gtty's early heffies whiek wefe moved to Wesley Park after-the 1926zewn let eil beem Mafiyef the e The City does not currently have official critena for local listing Therefore, for the survey update the project team used the California Rester of Histoncal Resources criteria as a baseis for local significance Dunng this process each of the criteria were adjusted to relate to the local history of Huntington Beach As a result of the historic survey update the following status codes were assigned to properties located m the City of Huntmaton Beach For a complete mventory of properties identified in the city, refer to the CLty of Huntmpton Beach's Histonc Context& Survey Report and subsequent updates, maintained m the Cgy's Planning and Building Depart vent Following is a description of the status codes identified m Huntington Beach • 1S Individual roperty listed in the NR by the Keeper Listed m the CR This status code was given to any property that is currently listed on the National Register These properties were not re-evaluated as part of this survey.(Included m updated Landmark List Historical Resource for the purposes of CEQA• Eligible for federal tax credits) THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB -577- 32- Item 15. - 79 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT • 3S Appears eligible for NR as an individual propert through survey evaluation This status code was given to12roerties evaluated on DPR 523 B forms and found to be eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places (Included in updated Lanchnark List,Historical Resource for the purpose of CEQA) • 3CB. Appears eligible for CR both mdividually and as a contributor to a CR eligible distnet through survey evaluation This status code was given to properties evaluated usmg the DPR 523 B form and found to be eligible for listing on the CR both individually and as the contnbutor to a CR eligible district (Included in updated Landmark List Histoncal Resource for the purpose of CEQA) • 3CD Appears eligible for CR as a contributor to a CR eligible district through survey evaluation This status code was given to properties that were evaluated using the District Record Fonn and found to be contnbutors to a historic district eligible for listing on the CR (Included in updated Landmark List Historical Resource for the purpose of CEQA) • 3CS Appears eligible for CR as an individual property through survey evaluation This status code was given to properties that were evaluated usmg the DPR 523B fonn and found to be individually eligible for listing on the CR- (Included in updated Landmark List-,Historical Resource for the purpose of CEQA) • 5S1 Individual propeM that is listed or decimated locally This status code was given to all the extant (non-altered)properties from the previous Landmark List on the City's General Plan This includes Only the histonc architectural properties (Included m updated Landmark List Histoncal Resource for the purpose of CEQA) • 5S1/7N1- This status code was given to ,properties that are currently listed on the Landmark List that have been altered but the alterations are reversible. These properties would require rehabilitation/restoration to qualify as a histonc property today (Not mcluded on updated Landmark List-Not a histoncal resource per CEQA) • 5S2 Individual property that is eligible for local listing This status code was given to properties that were previously evaluated in 1986 and given the status code of 5S2 and had not been significantly altered since the previous evaluation (Included in updated Landmark List,Historical Resource for the purpose of CEQA) • 6L Detemimed ineligible for local listing or designation through local government review process may warrant special consideration in local planning This status code was given to 1) non-contnbutm bg uildmgs located within historic district boundanes 2) properties previously identified in the 1986 survey that were still mtact but do not appear to meet NR or CR criteria toda} and 3 newly identified properties constructed pnor to 1959 that received a DPR 523A form but upon further evaluation did not appear to meet NR or CR criteria today These properties did not receive a DPR 523B form (Not mcluded on updated Landmark List-Not a histoncal resource per CEQA) THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 80 HB -578-33 CommuNny DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT • 6Z Found inelijnble for NR, CR or Local designation through survey evaluation This status code was given to properties that were evaluated under the established contexts but did not meet any criteria, had poor integrity or have been demolished since a prior evaluation (Not included on updated Landmark List-Not a historical resource per CEQA) • 7N Needs to be re-evaluated This status code was given to properties that 1) were not visible from the public right of wa�(due to fences landscaping, or distance from public right of way) or 2) were located within post World War H suburban tract developments that may constitute a historic district at a later date Although the latter do not appear eligible at the time of this survey, additional research and evaluation in the future mgy find an entire tract develgpment eligible if it meets NR or CR criteria in the future (Not included on updated Landmark List-Not a historical resource per CEQA) • 7N1 Needs to be reevaluated- may become eligible for NR w/restoration or when meets other specific conditions This status code was even to 1) properties that have been relocated or are currently under restoration and 2)properties that were previously identified on the Landmark List in the City's General Plan that have since been altered (Not included on updated Landmark List-Not a historical resource per CEQA) • 7R Identified in Reconnaissance Level Survey Not Evaluated This status code was given to properties that were recorded in the property inventory spreadsheet but was not recorded using a DPR 523 A or B form These properties do not appear at the reconnaissance survey level within the established contexts for Huntington Beach to be historically significant however the local Planning and Building Department may determine that additional evaluation may be necessary on a case by case basis through the permitting process if the Crty, owner, or interested party provides substantial evidence that the propM may be historically significant for the purposes of CEQA d. Vulnerability to Change Since the lustoric survey was originally completed for downtown Huntington Beach in 1985, a stgmfie more than half of Huntington Beach's historical resources have been destroyed and/or demolished Of the three potential historic districts identified by the 1986 survey, two are no longer eligible €er alas historic districts us-��-id the boundaries of one has been diminished due to subsequent demolitions and renovations The 2008-2012 historic resources inventory updated the information from 1986 and found that approximately 50% of the buildings identified within the downtown core area have since been significantly altered or demolished The downtown historic resources are extremely vulnerable to change The commercial areas, specifically Main Street, aye ex erienced extreme development pressures to t�naxmuze their land uses due to escalating land values THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB -579- 34 Item 15. - 81 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT Older residential areas arehave also expeft ffwiffggx enenced an increased intensification of development Much of the one-story beach cottage character of downtown has changed to larger three-story beach houses With the development activity occurring in areas of the City with significant historical resources, the City must decide the importance of these resources and what direction should be taken to preserve those elements critical to the character of the City,either onsite or through a historic relocation program The Downtown Specific Plan calls for the creation of a mixed use/commercial intensity use along Main Street and Pacific Coast Highway The zoning allows commercial uses to be * iu iultiple stones high, thus applying significant development pressure on smaller, older structures in the vicinity Secondly, the plan identified at one point over 50 percent of the structures in the study area as seismically unstable, stating they must ultimately be improved to meet seismic standards or be demolished fe. Availability of Funds b 7 Currently,there are no funds available to owners of historic,properties within the City of Huntington Beach, particularly for the rehabilitation or relocation of historic buildings The City does not maintain funds 5pecifically for the preservation or relocation of historic properties in danger of demolition or alteration However, as outlined in this Histonc and Cultural Resources Element it is the City's intent to continue to develop and promote financial incentive programs for owners of historic property owners to assist with the ongoing costs of preservation of these limited resources These financial incentives would be in the form of tax abatement programs through the County Assessor (Mills Act prod The City would also provide information to the public within the Planning_and Building Departments on other available funding programs as they become available The financial incentive programs are only available to properties that are maintained on the City's Landmark list and are outlined in the policies and objectives below B. CULTURAL RESOURCES 1. Introduction Over the past twenty years, the City has made great stndes in addressing the provision of arts and cultural services to residents and visitors A Cultural Master Plan was adopted in 1994 guiding the development of cultural services and facilities In addition,the City has begun to develop the cultural infrastructure that can provide the range of services residents require While the cultural life of Huntington Beach is quite active, the addition of the new wing of the Huntington Beach Public Library and Cultural Center and the imminent opening of the Huntington Beach Arts Center lend a new, high visibility focus for culture that will have an impact on residents and the entire region This strengthened activity relating to arts and culture is a result of the local residents' desire for a higher profile for arts and cultural activity The city is a composite of identities - "surf', "oil", environmentalism, multiple histories of indigenous inhabitants, agriculture, revival meetings,rail and other transportation links All these serve as the building blocks of an exciting and vibrant cultural context offering much to residents and visitors THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 82 HB -580-35 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT The revitalization of Man Street and its cultural amenities has brought a new image and vitality to downtown Huntington Beach This area has an vibrant but rapidly dummtshm assortment of historic structures that enhance a sense of history for both resident and visitor and provide the foundation for a strong community image THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Na _;8 1. 3to Item 15. - 83 CommuNrry DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL REsouRCESELEMEA7T 2. Existing Conditions a. Cultural Facilities,Artists,and Arts Groups There are a number of cultural facilities in Huntington Beach, including multi-faceted visual and performing arts spaces, historic sites, and outdoor facilities With the recently opened annex to the Huntington Beach Public Library and Cultural Center and the anticipated opening of the Huntington Beach Arts Center in 1994,cultural activities in Huntington Beach will have a strong and visible presence The vitality of the artists and arts groups comprise an active and focused cultural scene in the city Although there are few large or highly structured arts and cultural organizations in Huntmgton Beach,there is a core of local artists, both professional and amateur, as well as many arts groups that are conducting a wide array of high-quality programs • The soon-to-be opened Huntington Beach Arts Center is a community arts facility that will provide local citizens and a regional audience with opportunities for exposure to and involvement in the visual arts It will have three gallery spaces, a studio, classrooms, meeting rooms, and a bookstore and gift shop, • The City's Parks and Recreation program includes arts and crafts classes held in parks and community centers throughout the city; • The Huntington Beach Public Library and Cultural Center, with its new wing devoted to children, also includes a 300-seat theater, several meeting and classrooms • The Huntington Beach Playhouse is a thirty-year old community theater now performing in the new theater at the library The group presents 16 performances of six shows during the year as well as an outdoor Shakespeare series in Huntington Central Park and a children's Christmas program, • The Newland House Museum is a showcase of local lustory operated by the Historical Society and the city. In addition to exhibition space in its restored building and bam,there is outdoor space for additional exhibits and special events in the area between the house and bam, • The International Surfing Museum opened in its first location in 1988 and is presently in a 2,000 square foot renovated space in the downtown Plans to build a new, state-of-the-art museum facility are currently developed, and funding is being sought. A "Surfing Walk of Fame" is being established and has received much attention in the international surfing community; • Golden West College has a wide range of cultural facilities and active instructional programs in the arts with an emphasis on both traditional and electronic forms of most artistic media Its program of theater production currently includes about 40 percent non-student actors, • The Huntington Harbour Philharmonic Committee has an active program of fund-raising for the Orange County Performing Arts Center. In addition, the Committee provides a range of programs for public school children, including in-school programs and bus trips to the Performing Arts Center; • The Huntington Beach Concert Band performs in venues around Orange County With about seventy-five members, half of whom are from Huntington Beach, the band has played at City Council meetings, ground-breakings, concerts in Huntington Central Park, and other locations. It is the only band of its type in Orange County not supported by a school district, THE CITY OF HliNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 84 HB -58--31 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURALRESOURCESELEMENT • The School for the Performing Arts at Huntington Beach High School currently has an enrollment of approximately three hundred students and offers classes in dance, theater, music, and television production, and • A wide range of other groups, including the Arts Associates and the Huntington Beach Art League, are also active in the community Many arts and historic groups in the city function on a volunteer basis,without paid staff or permanent facilities Artists have generally not been able to work in the city, primarily because of the cost of renting space and the lack of professional venues in which to exhibit and perform their work b. Resources for Arts Education The quality of arts education in Huntington Beach depends in large measure on the particular school and school district that a child attends In part, because there are four school districts in the city,the range and quality of offerings vary Elementary and middle schools rely on classroom teachers to integrate the arts (as a teaching tool) into the curriculum Middle schools' visual arts, music, band and choir specialists are shared within districts. All four high schools have basic instruction in some of the performing arts (generally, some combination of choir,band, drama, and dance)with faculty shared among them Each school has visual arts programs that are run by two visual arts specialists. The School for the Performing Arts at the Huntington Beach High School was established to provide advanced performing arts classes and ensembles at the high school level It offers a wide array of arts experiences to students citywide While the primary opportunity for providing arts education experiences for children lies with the public schools, there are additional opportunities directed toward children and older residents The City has several programs that have an impact on arts and cultural education The City's HBTV Channel 3 offers a talk show about the arts The new Huntington Beach Arts Center will offer interpretive programs, school tours, and workshops in various media, disciplines and issues. The Recreation, Beaches, and Development Division of the Community Services Department offers extensive classes in centers throughout the city,although there are relatively few classes in visual and performing arts. Few,if any,classes are offered for teens and adults Classes for children include some crafts and dance The Huntington Beach Public Library and Cultural Center offers a range of cultural programs There is a new children's wing,but because of budgetary constraints, the amount of cultural programming is limited Rental fees for using the facilities are out of range for smaller cultural groups Nonprofit arts and cultural groups in Huntington Beach have played an important role in providing educational opportunities for school children Among the activities that have been provided are • The Huntington Harbour Philharmonic Committee, in addition to raising money for the Orange County Performing Arts Center, coordinates field trips to the center for a variety of tours and performances They also bring ensembles into the schools for assemblies that can include performance and demonstrations of instruments. They sponsor the "Music Mobile" which travels to elementary schools to introduce third graders to musical instruments, THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB _583_ 38 Item 15. - 85 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT • The Newland House Museum offers tours of its facility to schools, primarily third and fourth graders who are studying local and California history In addition, the Historical Society offers special 2 hour tours of the facility, and • The Japan America Society has developed a cultural program for schools, building on the Sister City Program c. The Role of the Cultural Services Division&Advisory Board of the City of Huntington Beach The Cultural Services Division is responsible for an array of activities, including oversight of construction and program development for the new Huntington Beach Arts Center and overseeing historic and cultural programs in the community At the present tune, Its primary roles are that of manager of many of the cmty's existing arts programs and presenter of visual arts activities. There are other roles of the division, including serving as a "catalyst" to assist local arts groups in promotion, location space, fund-raismg for cultural projects, and capital project oversight The Allied Arts Board is designated to advise City Council on all matters pertaining to the arts in Huntington Beach It was responsible for developing the initial ten-year plan for cultural activities that led to the establishment of the Cultural Services Division as well as other important milestones in the development of the cultural life of the city Along with the Historic Resources Board (which oversees historic programs and activities), the Allied Arts Board, in its role as advisor to the City Council, can, among other things, study and interpret the needs of the community for cultural programs and facilities, recommend cultural policy on such matters as programming, facilities, and fundmg, assist local arts groups to better fulfill their missions; and encourage individuals, civic groups, and businesses to support arts and culture with time,money,and m-kmd services The master plan provides an overview of key issues and a "vision statement" for culture in the city It presents a series of recommendations on the priorities for culture, addresses the role of the Cultural Services Division, identifies the necessary resources to realize the goals articulated through the recommendations, and describes steps toward implementation by the city and arts advocates and organizations d. Funding for the Arts and Culture Huntington Beach has been generous in its support of arts and cultural activities The recent history of private sector financial support for the Huntington Beach Arts Center, as well as the cmty's funding of the Cultural Services Division over the past eight years, indicate a trend of increased support Huntington Beach has some very effective, private-sector fund-raising initiatives The Huntington Harbour Philharmonic Committee raises money, some of which goes to support local educational experiences for children around certain types of music The Huntington Beach Arts Center Foundation has raised significant sums of money in support of the construction and programming at the Huntington Beach Arts Center, some of which will involve educational programs for children Fund-raising in Huntington Beach has historically been focused on"bricks and mortar"capital funding THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 86 HB -584-3q COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT The downtown and the Pacific coast areas have been designated as "visitor serving" in the General Plan The City is committed to developing destination attractions and activities in those areas, most of which are seen to be related to arts and culture These attractions and activities include the Huntington Beach Arts Center, the planned Celebration Plaza, arts and craft fans and festivals, and concerts in Pier Plaza and Huntington Beach Central Park Amphitheater These attractions are bringing visitor dollars to the targeted areas, increasing foot traffic and bringing consumers that increase retail sales e. Urban Design,Aesthetics,and Public Art While the City and the various community groups have taken action to develop a pleasing urban environment, the visual appeal and feel of the city remain key concerns for many residents Residents would like to see a concerted effort undertaken to miprove this important aspect of the community Issues regarding landscape and plant selection, hardscape design, building materials, public space allocation and the inclusion of public arts are but a few of the issues raised ISSUES 1 4- -A citywide inventory of historic resources has never-been conducted—A however the uiventory was conducted at a reconnaissance level and therefore is in continual need of revision_ The State of California recormnends that lustoric resource surveys be updated every five years Continual updating of the Cgy's historic inventory would help identify all structures and sites critical to the overall historic character of the community (HCR 1 1 1) 2 2 The City has gwen level- k aeseme , ll signifieant .,...,,et ,does not have a Historic Preservation Ordinance or other requirements or guidelines have wee efeateathat would help to preserve or protect diem-the City's historic landmarks. (HCR 114,HCR 12 2, HCR 12 3, HCR 12 4, and HCR 13 7) 3. N Owe ,.yeftt that The City does not currently have a process or procedure to fully mitinate impacts (demolitionLhistorical e4 eturesresources that are uff"vulnerable to remain at theff ewr-ent sitesredevelopment within the City. Therefore, the City should establish a consider maintaining land for the relocation "hilt,,.-eal park "and protection of historic resources under eminent threat (HCR 12.1, and HCR 12 3) I 4 4--Downtown commercial and residential areas are expenencmg extreme development pressures to tntensifyrnaxunize their land uses No guidelines exist to protect and/or restore the historic character of these older areas As a result, older structures are being demolished for the construction of new buildings The City is losing the historic character of the area (HCR 113, HCR 114, HCR 121, HCR 12 3, HCR 12 4, HCR 13 3, HCR 13 4, HCR 13 6, and HCR 13 7) S -5Adaptive reuse has been uteri artily utilized and should be actively promoted (HCR 13 6) 6 6---The City does not currently have informational brochures for propga owners regardin options for historic properly preservation 7 The City's per capita income and education levels are among the highest in the nation These demographics suggest a population likely to have high expectations for services, particularly in the area of arts and cultural activities (HCR 2 21, and HCR 3 2.2) 8 -7---Most of the support for arts and culture has come from a relatively narrow spectrum of Huntington Beach residents The percentages of younger families, children and youth, and the populations of Latino and Asian residents are increasing. As a result,the mix of arts and cultural THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 87 HB -585- qcc) COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT programming will have to be designed to ineet the needs of a demographically diverse audience Much of the thrust of the Cultural Master Plan involves recognizing the necessity to reach new constituencies, to broaden the programming offered and to identify new sources of financial and political support for the full range of cultural activities (HCR 2 21 and HCR 3 2 2) 9 —One of the major problems facing cultural and historic groups is the difficulty in obtaining —information about access to facilities and financial resources While the Cultural Services Division has an extensive collection of publications on arts issues, historic services,and fund-raising, access to that information is hmrted (HCR 21 1 and HCR 2 2 2) THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 88 HB -586-41 CommuNrry DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT 10 9--There is a lack of a ready means of communication within the arts community It will be important to develop mechanisms to address this need for better communication, to allow for more effective sharing of information among artists and groups, and to inform a wider public of cultural activities in the arts community (HCR 2 1 1 and HCR 2 2.2) 11 10 The ability of small, volunteer cultural/histonc groups to handle the managerial aspects of —their operations is often limited This is partly due to a lack of sufficient time or grounding in business,space development, and tenant/landlord skills (HCR 212) 12 44----Recently constructed arts facilities will require time to become fully operational and their impact on the cultural community is necessarily difficult to assess Additional cultural facilities will ultimately be required to address the full range of community needs (HCR 5 2 2) 13 12.—Examples of currently underutilized perfonmmg arts facilities are• • Golden West College has a large amphitheater with seating for about 1,000, it is only minimally used It would require stage and technical support improvements to make it more useful; • The Huntington Beach High School Auditorium, seating about 700, is heavily utilized during the school year, however, it is available during the summer months and might be more fully utilized then Rehabilitation work is needed for the facility to function more effectively for school and community use, • The Huntington Beach Public Library and Cultural Center's utility for arts and cultural groups is presently limited by the lack of staff available for programming and the relatively high rental fees charged to arts and cultural groups for their use, • The grounds of the Newland House Museum and Newland Barn could be used for additional cultural and/or historic programming However,the lack of space for collections and archives warrants the development of a local museum centrally located,and • Existing theatrical spaces are heavily used, so it is clear that there is interest in theater However, there is little performing space available for programming smaller bilingual, multi-cultural performances and experimental productions Renovation of outdoor amphitheaters in city parks is needed to allow for a broader range of programming, increased use by local organizations and increased safety and comfort of audiences (HCR 51 1, HCR 512, andHCR522) 14 +3- -Providing opportunities for artists to live and work in Huntington Beach is unportant to the long-term growth of the city's cultural life There are no affordable artists' spaces for living and working in Huntington Beach in lower cost space in industrial and/or business parks outside of the downtown core or vacant downtown buildings (HCR 5.2 4) 15 14—There is a need for outdoor interpretive centers to address several aspects of the city's history,notably the Bolsa Chica wetlands and the Native American populations (HCR 5 1 1) 16. 4-5---While the City is not responsible as the lead public entity to provide arts programs for school age children and youth, it has been a strong advocate for increased attention in this area The public schools in Huntington Beach have cut back programming in arts education in order to address severe budget problems The issue of lack of access to arts training and appreciation course has affected other curriculum efforts to enhance learning in the classroom, to improve school attendance,and to enhance the self-esteem of students,particularly youth at risk (HCR 4.12) THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB -587- 47 Item 15. - 89 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORICAND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT 17 4 —Currently, there is no one coordinating or fostering long-term relationships between professional artists and the public schools In the elementary schools, for example, programs are either enrichment assemblies or field trips or are provided by classroom teachers rather than professional artists (HCR 4 1 2) 18 17 Because of the music education programming of the Huntington Harbour Philharmonic Committee and its fund-raising to support those programs, the City's students have access to a range of musical experiences But, while activities in this discipline are provided on a consistent basis, others(in particular, drama and the visual arts) are not, unless they are offered on an ad hoc basis by particular teachers or parents (HCR 4 1 2) 19 4$---Without comprehensive funding for arts and culture in all parts of the city, it is very difficult to equitably address the needs of the community A current priority is the need of the Huntington Beach Arts Center to get its programming in place and develop a secure base of endowed support (HCR 5 12 and HCR 5 2 3) 20 19. The City has been very supportive of cultural activities, responding to impressive community support and fund-raismg, yet these very programs are expected to fulfill a no-net-cost requirement The Cultural Services Division is designated as the City's local arts agency and, as a result, is eligible for significant fundmg available through state and federal sources to such agencies (HCR 5 2.3 and HCR 5 14) 21 20 The visitor industry is seeking ways to promote Huntington Beach as a destination While it is unlikely at the current time that the City's arts groups will be a prunary reason for a visit,they certainly can contribute to a lengthened stay The potential for hentage and cultural tourism may provide opportunity for additional funding partnerships (HCR 5 2.1) THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 90 HB -588- 43 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT GOALS, OBJECTIVES,AND POLICIES Objecdve HCR 1.2 The following section presents the goals, objectives, Ensure that the City ordinances, programs, and policies policies, and programs for Historic and Cultural create an environment whxehthat fosters preservation, Resources in the City of Huntington Beach At the end rehabilitation, and sound maintenance of historic and of each policy is a reference to the appropriate archaeological resources unplementation program Each implementation program's schedule and possible funding sources are Policies indicated in the Historic and Cultural Resources HCR 1.2.1 Implementation Matrix Utilize the State of California Historic Building Code, Secretary of Interior Standards for Historic Historical Resources Rehabilitation, and standards and guidelines as prescribed by the State Office of Historic Preservation Goal as the architectural and landscape design standards for HCR 1 rehabilitation, alteration,or additions to sites contammg To promote the preservation and restoration of the historic resources in order to preserve these structures in sites, structures and districts which have a manner consistent with the site's architectural and architectural, historical, and/or archaeological historic integrity (1-HCR 1,I-HCR 3, and I-HCR S) significance to the City of Huntington Beach. HCR 1.2.2 Objective Encourage new development to be compatible with HCR 1.1 adjacent existing historic structures in terms of scale, Ensure that all the City's lustoncally and massing, building materials and general architectural archaeologically significant resources are identified and treatment (I-HCR 6) protected HCR 1.2.3 Policies Investigate the appropriateness of e-iq3aadmg the HCR 11.1 establishing a "receiver site" program and explore the Idei�Continually uRdate the h d op ma to integrate historic buildings with cultural existing citywide survey of and arts education (I-HCR 1) potentially historic resources subject to City Council royal (I--HCR 1) HCR 1.2.4 b Investigate the feasibility of initiating an "adopt a HCR 1 12 building" program to preserve historic structures that Consider the designation of any historically significant would be removed from their sites (I-HCR 1) public trees, archaeological sites, parks. er strictures, sites or areas deemed to be of Objective historical, archaeological, or cultural significance as a HCR 1.3 Huntington Beach City Historical Point,Site or District Consider the provision of incentives (strategies, (1-HCR 1, and I-HCR 2,I-HCR 3,) assistance, and regulations) for the maintenance and/or enhancement of privately owned historic properties in a HCR 1.1.3 manner that will conserve the integrity of such resources Consider establishing a historic overlay for historic in the best possible condition structures throughout the City The overlay should be structured to allow the underlying land use to continue Policies teas well as support the reuse of the historic HCR 1.3.1 structure (1-HCR 1,I-HCR 3,I-HCR S, andLU 1 S 31) Encourage owners of eligible historic income-producing properties to use the tax benefits provided by the 1981 HCR 1.1.4 Tax Revenue Act as well as all subsequent and future Consider recording the importance of oil history in the financial incentives (I-HCR 1) City's development. (I-HCR 1) THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN 1 HB -5sq_ 1+4 Item 15. - 91 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AATD CULTURAL RESO URGES ELEMENT HCR 1.3.2 Policies Consider the waiver of building permit fees for owners HCR 14.1 of small properties with historic resources who are Encourage the promotion of the Crty's historic resources unable to benefit from other government programs for in visitor and tourist oriented brochures (I-HCR 8) the rehabilitation, alteration or reuse of their structure(s) only if rehabilitated in accordance with established HCR 1.4.2 historic preservation guidelines (I-HCR 1) Promote community awareness of historic preservation through Huntington Beach's appointed and elected HCR 13.3 officials, , the Consider allowing flexibility in building code is various departments, requirements for the rehabilitation of historic structures and local boards and organizations (I-HCR 8) as specified in State Historical Building Code Part 8, Title 24 if rehabilitated in accordance with established HCR 1.4.3 historic preservation guidelines (I-HCR 1) Encourage the involvement of the local schools and Goldenwest College in preservation programs and HCR 1.3.4 activities (I--HCR 8) Provide appropriate technical advice to private property owners seeking to restore historically significant HCR 14.4 structures (I-HCR 1) Consider Comb combuun sites containing historic ' features (interpretive centers) with recreational learning HCR 1.3.5 opportunities-and arts and culture (THCR 9) 1 Advocate that local lending institutions provide appropriate financing for the rehabilitation and HCR 1.4.5 restoration of historically significant structures (I-HCR Encourage the provision of uses that are conducive to 7) public use and education in historic structures (I-HCR 1, and I-HCR 4) HCR 1.3.6 Encourage appropriate adaptive reuse of historic HCR 1.4 6 resources in order to prevent misuse, disrepair and Consider crowdsourcmg to support preservation efforts demolition, taking care to protect surrounding neighborhoods from incompatible uses (I-HCR 1) Cultural Resources HCR 1.3.7 Goal Explore alternatives that enable a property owner to HCR 2 sensitively add to the existing structure, or develop an Develop avenues for communication and accompanying budding on the site that allows property participation in arts and cultural activities and development rights to be realized Deviation to programming to bring together diverse segments of setbacks, heights,-and-parking, and other requirements the community. should be considered to make the preservation of an existing historic building feasible when no other Objective reasonable alternative exists (I-HCR 1 and THCR 6) HCR 2.1 Improve access to arts and cultural activity for all HCR 1.3.8 residents and assist in networking information of Preserve and reuse histonca ly siQ ificant structures. cultural activities where feasible (1-HCR 3 and I-HCR Policies Objective HCR 2.1.1 HCR 1.4 Assist cultural groups in networking and bringing artists Promote public education and awareness of the unique and arts organizations together (I-HCR 10 and THCR history of the Huntington Beach area and community 12) involvement in its retention and preservation THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 92 HB -590- 'ts COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL,RESOURCES ELEMENT HCR 2.1.2 Policies Provide technical assistance to historic, cultural groups and artists (I-HCR 11) HCR 3.2.1 Pfeserve-aod-xeese-hest iFaRy sigiufieent ��T Objective where F b «HC D , ,._a HCR 2.2 Raise the community's awareness of the full range of II��.2 arts,history,and culture available in Huntington Beach Consider providing educational opportunities that focus on the City's cultural history (I-HCR 1, I-HCR 3, and Pokcies I-HCR 8) HCR 2.2.1 Provide opportunities for increased exposure for arts Goal and cultural activities throughout the city (I-HCR 12 HCR 4 and?-HCR 13) Expand opportunities for the City's children to receive quality experiences of arts and culture. HCR 2.2.2 Facilitate networking between arts and cultural groups Objective and the general public (I-HCR 12 and I-HCR 13) HCR 4.1 Strive for a full range of performing and visual arts, Goal educational programming and experiences to children HCR 3 throughout the city Highlight the City's unique cultural heritage and enhance its visual appeal. Policies HCR 4.1.1 Objective Seek support for arts education (I-HCR 8) HCR 31 Promote a high standard of visual quality of art, HCR 4.1.2 architecture and landscape architecture in the public Strive to broaden cultural opportunities for children realm (I-HCR 8) Policies Goal HCR 3.1.1 HCR 5 Increase community representation and input into the Establish a wide range of arts and cultural programs decision making about arts and culture (I-HCR 1, U D and facilities that address the needs and interest of 1 41, and I-UD S) residents,workers,and visitors. HCR 3.1.2 Objective Consider that individuals advising the City on cultural, HCR 5.1 urban and visual design issues have a background in Ensure adequate facilities, staff, and f indmg for all city architecture, urban design, or fine arts (I-HCR 1 and provided arts programs UD 141) Policies HCR 3 1.3 HCR 5.1.1 Encourage urban design and public art projects to Assure that existing cultural facilities in Huntington enhance the image of the City and foster a sense of Beach are used effectively (I-HCR 8 and I-HCR 12) place (I-HCR 1,I-HCR 14, and UD 1 41) HCR 5.1.2 Objective Advocate partnership agreements for capital projects HCR 3.2 (I-HCR 1,I-HCR 8,I-HCR 10, and I-HCR 12) Clarify and highlight the cultural heritage and identities of Huntington Beach for residents and visitors THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN FHB -591- y(P Item 15. - 93 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CUL7TIRAL REsouRCESELEMBNT HCR 5.1.3 rehabilitation, and continued upkeep of a Identify and consider the interests of the community historic structure) while planning new cultural facilmes (1-HCR 8, I-HCR 10, and I-HCR 12) HCR 5.1.4 Consider a permanent funding mechanism to support the local art agency (I-HCR 13) Objective HCR 5.2 Facilitate the growth of the arts and cultural community Policies HCR 5.2.1 Encourage the participation of new audiences for arts and cultural activities (I-HCR 8, I-HCR 13, and I-HCR 16) HCR 5.2.2 Coordinate and cooperate with other city departments and interest groups with the planning for existing and new public cultural amenities (1-HCR 17) HCR 5.2.3 Assist in the development of partnerships among arts groups and the business community (I-HCR 8 and 1--HCR 12) HCR 5.2.4 Encourage opportunities for artists to live and work in Huntington Beach. (I-HCR 1) IMPLEMENTATION PROGRAMS I-HCR 1 Studies/Manning/Surveys a. Perform ongome survey whwlrupdates the-every five years to maintain an updated 44inventorti of buildings, structures or sites identified as potentially having historical or archaeological significance b Review e x•�ngAdopt the California Register Criteria as the city"s official desisnation criteria for ei4efia;as local landmarks c Conduct a study investigating the feasibility of creating new or expanding"receiver sites"and creating an "adopt a building" program (An "adopt a building"program includes corporate or civic group's sponsoring the refurbishing, THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 94 xB -59-2- `4-1 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT d Study the feasibility of enacting a program to provide incentives for preservation, restoration, rehabilitation or relocation of historic resources through purchase of facade easements, waiver of fees, flexible building requirements, adaptive re-use, rehabilitation loans and grants, and technical advice by person(s) qualified in historic preservation, restoration techniques, and loans and grant programs, receiver site and building and siting regulations e Examine the feasibility of establishing a historical resource center which acts as an archive and clearinghouse of artifacts and resource documentation and provides learning opportunities for the public f Explore the feasibility of relocating the Hsstoncal Society's city archives to an accessible location such as the downtown g Consider developing an oil history museum or interpretive center h uFban design-End aesthetie eeneerns—te appr-epfiate boards and eemmtssiens i---Explore the development of a plan for a phased- in "cultural corridor" including the areas surrounding Golden West College, Huntington Central Park, Main Street Library, Main Street and the Art Center to the Pier The plan shall consider such things as • developing a uniform visual identity through street banners and signage and public improvements,and • identifying potential sites for City-sponsored public artwork 3 DEplefe deli abng ssi pate historic districts and/ep-are-l#eey individually significant peiatsbuildines, structures, sites a-ad distw-ts and sites as local eable program Series highhghittmg -the eeB historic landmarks 1 I Explore the feasibility of develepRig—a incorporating the history of the local Native American peoples into existing interpretive eeatercenters THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN 1 HB -593-416 Item 15. - 95 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT raj Explore if there is sufficient programming and I-HCR 6 audience for a small, flexible(or"black box") Design Review/Permittine Process/Environmental theatrical space in the downtown, geared Review toward multi-purpose usage and small, experimental productions a. Review existing design standards and n—Determine the nature of public and private guidelines to ensure they are conducive to support for the proposed International Surfing compatible development, if warranted, revise Museum the design standards el Explore shared-, and affordable, "work/live" b Review the impacts of zoning changes and space for artists and arts groups General Plan amendments on historic preservation objectives and, if warranted, I-HCR 2 revise the proposed zone change or Plan Municipal Code/Desien Guddelmes amendment to reflect the historic preservation objectives Utilize the State of California Historic Building Code to c C-e4i- Evaluate the current procedures for accommodate the rehabilitation of historic and older reviewing all demolition permit applications structures for historic structures I-HCR 3 I-HCR 7 Preservation Ordinance Historic Resources Funding Consider the creation of a Preservation Ordinance The Work with local lending institutions in developing a Preservation Ordinance shall financing program or other programs to provide financial assistance benefiting owners of historic a. enable the City to designate any site deemed resources who can prove a need for financial assistance historically, archaeologically, or culturally in connection with historic preservation significant as a historic point, structure,site, or district, I-HCR 8 b establish design guidelines and standards for Interagency Participation and Coordination preservation,adaptive re-use,etc, a. Work with the managing board (or c establish criteria and procedures for creating organization) of the Huntington Beach Hotel new historic overlay areas,and /Motel Business improvement District d conform to State and Federal cnteria for `efif fenee and" `""'s n"'t""and others on establishing a preservation ordinance developing brochures, self-guided walking tours, traveling exhibits promoting the I-HCR 4 historical resources of the City Land Use Element b Work with the local school districts, local preservation programs, libraries, and Implement land use programs as cited in I-LU 1,I-LU community centers to 7,AND I-LU 14 develop and promote preservation classes, activities and programs, I-HCR 5 enhance the range and scope of arts Rehabilitation and Preservation Standards educational programming offered by the City,including Maintain on file the Secretary of Interior Standards for Historic Rehabilitation and the standards and guidelines - a cultural programs for cable of the State Office of Historic Preservation as guidelines television, - a youth oriented calendar of arts and on restoring, altering or adding to designated historic structures cultural events, and an artist residencies program located in community centers and other youth oriented facilities throughout the City, and THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN TT TT/" ,t C4 Item 15. - 96 HB -594- (j\ Commu IIry DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESO URCES ELEMENT provide art and historic classes accessible I-HCR 11 to a diverse range of residents Technical Assistance Programs c Work with local preservation organizations to Develop technical assistance programs to tram develop a historic building handbook that community arts, cultural, and historic groups m,but not describes historic structures,sites,and districts, limited to,the following and provides information on building research and appreciation, and sets forth gmdehnes for a running a small organization - financial rehabilitation as funds are available management, fund-raising, marketing and d Coordinate with local historic preservation long-range planning, organizations such as the Historic Resources b developing partnerships and joint ventures Board and Historical Society with private businesses, City agencies and e Work with other City departments to develop a others,and plan to assure that existing arts and cultural c planning to assess community interest and facilities are rehabilitated and maintained as identify and encourage new audiences feasible f Coordinate proposals for new facility needs I-HCR 12 with the Central Park Master Plan's proposed Business Leader Art Administrators and Resident additional outdoor performing arts spaces, and Outreach the Beach Master Plan's proposed arts and cultural programming m the Pier Plaza area. a. Develop a private sector group of business and civic leaders, arts organizations and artists to g Establish a high-level, inter-agency working provide leadership support for arts and cultural group of senior staff from appropriate City activities departments to coordinate cultural initiatives b Work with community groups to develop h Link cultural tourism objectives through promotional tie-ins and special events with a residents program interests cultural focus or component I-HCR 13 Arts Proarammmg I-HCR 9 Recreation and Community Services Element Incorporate arts and cultural events as part of existing Implement Parks and Recreation policies and programs community events and attractions, major sporting events,and community celebrations where feasible as cited in RCS 1.1.2 and I-RCS 2 I-HCR 14 I-HCR 10 Public Art Ordinance Arts/Cultural Resources Network Develop systems and networks to provide access to Consider the creation of a public art ordinance that p y p encourages public and private sector involvement The information resources,such as ordinance shall a a community arts, culture, and history a, identify funding sources for a formal public newsletter, arts program,and b a clearinghouse cataloguing and registering b utilize the existing ad hoc art program as a temporary and permanent spaces available for model arts and cultural use, c a centralized event clearinghouse, d an artists' register available for an art in public places program, gallery owners, presenters, and others with resumes,slides or tapes,and e a media production resource list THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN uB -595-so Item 15. - 97 CommuNrry DEVELOPMENT CHAPTER HISTORicAND CULTURAL RESOURCESELEMENT I-HCR 15 I-HCR 16 Celebration Plaza Awed Arts Board and Historic Resources Board Continue to oversee the development and programming Diversify the membership of the Allied Arts Board and for the Celebration Plaza located at the intersection of the Historic Resources Board to include a broader Main Street and Acacia Avenue As currently planned, perspective from all segments of the city the Celebration Plaza is an outside public assembly area which includes hadscape and landscape amenities I-HCR 17 connecting the Arts Center and the Main Street Branch Cultural Master Plan Library Implement the City Council approved Cultural Master Plan,as feasible THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN Item 15. - 98 HB -596- 5 i Z _ — ADLINSTRATION i I 1 Z a �" .�-i gi �; a,lm d ca' itil�ja;s!�!Z3,val8 �cs(¢�a a;c3llvaf� , No. Name A- cnrarM nNMB I i cmoFraArtweTa+e�cx i ` i PROGRAM RESPONSIBLEAGENCY RMINGSOURCE SCHEDULE FHQ Studies Mappingl Surveys • • 0 I IG j � �• �•I • �•; � io i * -Mumapal Cie!Design Guidelines • •' II I ;I I• �s E I•-- -I I i k o i ( na 1 4 � n � 1 Yearupon HOWPreservation Ordinance • • I• i• --�!o,•f i i j 1 PlanAdop�* / ------ �- - I i Ong ng* Land Use Element •I ! � I O� � j � �•I � � i of --- —i ' ! 1-- ! — Rehabilitation and Preservation Standards--- • ; i ( i ! i•I ! ( j Ongoing Design Review 1 Perm>tbng Process 1 ®� ! j p Io I (•f I i ongoing Environmental Review 07 Historic Resources Funding •i •; I •' ,•j -i I •�• - 0Wftq* HM$ Interagency Participation and Coordination •!• j f• O' • •4 •;• 4 •I ( ongoing I I Recreation and Community Services Element •I • j 1 ®� i ! ! Ongoing* ' HN I --� - 2 Years upon Ar tsd Cultural Resources Network , •! •I •_•; ( Plan Adoption* 2 Years u pon (pj1 Technical Assistance Programs • i I 1.1 • Plan Adoption - 12 Business Leader,Arts Administrators,and 00 I® I ,o iOngoing* Resident Outreach HV3 —Arts Programming ;• • • ® • 9} Marsupon Public Arts Ordinance •' • ® 101 • !•' ® • Plan Adoption 15 Celebration Plaza • • •;•, • ( Ongoing ----r--- 0�6 Allied Arts Board and Historic Resources Board — ®----- -- ® ® 1 p�Ad u - -- � opb°p t' 17 Cultural Master Plan • � • -•�' • • i— ongoing I ' *As funding permits HISTORICAL and CULTURAL RESOURCES IMPLEMENTATION PROGRAM MATRIX -IHCR 1 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH GENERAL PLAN HB -597- Item 15. - 99 1I-11CJF 52 A ATTACHMENT #6 J. 0 cxnwouN� ► 1 ► 1 Current. siti Updated AddressDescription D Historical � 1 Landmark Sionificancon/Statu Status n► 11 ating Rating e Less than 9151 Atlanta Post Office -- -- H/P 45yrs of 6Z Age Less than 17011 Beach Charter Center -- -- S 45yrs of 6Z Age 17211 Beach Earl Fire Station 1953 __ S Heavily 6Z y Altered 19820 Beach Newland House 1898 1 S-H/P Intact 1 S/5 S 1 Beach Bartlett Park -- -_ A/S Archaeolog N/A Boulevard y McDonnell- Less than 5301 Bolsa S 45yrs y f 7N e 20491 Bushard House and Barn -- __ S Demodlishe 6Z 305 California Craftsman House 1910 -- S Intact 3S/5S1 801 California Brown House/Tower 1927 -- S Intact 3S/5S 1 Less than 7561 Center Old World Village 1978 -- H/S 45yrs of 6Z Age Clay/Goldenw Huntington A-1 1920 __ H/S Demolishe 6Z est Well d Clay/Yorktown Reservoir Hill -- -- A/S Archeology N/A 216 Crest Mayor McCallen 1928 5*/3D H/P Intact 3CB/5S2 House Mayor Manning Relocated 3CS/5 S 1/ 701 Delaware House -- -" H/P to IOth& 7NI Orange Edwards Hill Archaeological -- -- A/S Archeology N/A Area Heavily 17292 Stricklm House 1937 -- H/P Altered or 6Z Goldenwest Demolishe d 17162 Gothard Slater House c. 1920 -- H/P Intact 3S/5S 1 713 Hill House 1906 -- S Intact 3 S/5 S 1 505 Lake Higgins House 1915 5 H/P Intact 5S1/5S2 1035 1 lth Lake Park Cabin 1923 -- H/P Intact 5S1/3S Los Water Tower -- __ S Demodlishe N/A Patos/Orian 135 Item 15. - 100 1x13 .598- MUYf11iGNN TWDI Prior 1 Address DescriptionHistorical LandmarkDispositi 1 11 Rating _Rating / 1 e s 20444 Sts. Simon&Jude Less than Magnolia Church S 4 Age f 115 Main Olson Building 1916 3D S Demdolishe 6Z 122 Main Pacific City Hall 1903 3D S Altered 5S1/3S/7 N1 124 Main Obarr Drugs 1910 3D S Intact 3 S/5 S 1/5 S2 123 Main Huntington C66 1906 3D S Demalishe 6Z 126 Main Standard Market 1928 3D S Demolishe 6Z 1905 Main HuntingtonBeach 1926 3 S Intact 3S/5S1 Less than 2000 Main H.B City Hall 1974 -- S 45yrs of 6Z Age 205 Main H.B.News 1904 3D S Intact 5S1/5S2 207 Main Princess Theater 1910 3D S Altered 5S1/6Z Less than 2111 Main Seacliff Village -- -- S 45 Yrs of 6Z Age 213 Main H.B. Sheet Metal 1919 3D S Intact/Alter 3S/7N1/5 ed S 1 217 Main Pioneer Feed&Fuel 1904 3D S Intact 3S/5S1 525 Main Main Street 1951 -- S intact is Library 525 Main Triangle Park 1912 -- S Intact is 610 Main Terry's Garage 1933 3D S Demodlishe 6Z Wesley Park Partially New Section Intact/New New Main Street (Includes 134 3D S District es-See parcels) Boundary Districts Below Main/11th Farquhar Park 1905 -- H/S Intact 5S1/3CS 21730 Newland Edison Plant 1956 -- S Historic Not 6Z 5452 Old Graham House -- -- H/P Intact 3S/5S1 Pirate Drive 136 HB -599- Item 15. - 101 pUMIM4TlN1 i61CN Prior Prior 1 HistUpdated 1 1 1 Address lDescription Landmarksiti Status -' 11 de Rating e � , 1 316 Olive U.S.Post Office 1936 3/3D S Intact 3S/5S1 411 Olive Dr.Hawes 1936 3D H/P Intact 5S1 Medical Building 114 PCH Garner House 1905 3 S Intact 2S/2S2/3 S/5S 1 Peter's Landing Less than 16400 PCH (Shopping Center) '- S 45Ayrgeof 6Z Less than 21100 PCH Waterfront Hilton 1990 -- S 45yrs of 6Z Age Demolishe PCH H.B Pier -- -- S d and 7N1 Rebuilt H.B. 414-416 PCH Com an /Tele ho -- __ S d Demohshe p y p 6Z ne Exchange Pacific Coast Bolsa Chica Non- Hwy Wetlands -- '- S Architectur N/A 1502 Palm Dwyer School 1933 3 S Intact 3S/5S1 1600 Palm H B Gym& 1931 3 S Intact 1S/5S1 Plunge 16400 St Bonaventure Less than rs Springdale Church -- -- S 45Ay Age 7N Central Park Less than 7111 Talbert Library -- -- S 45Ay eof 6Z 412-414 Dr Shank 1920s -- S Altered 5S1/7N1 Walnut Commercial 513-519 Helms House 1904 3D S Intact 1S/5S1 Walnut Furnishing Co 5203 Warner Meadowlark Site -- 1/3D S-H/P Demodlishe 6Z 7360-7386 Warner Baptist 1906 -- A/S Intact 3S/5S1 Warner Church Japanese 7622 Warner Presbyterian. 1910 -- S Intact 3 S/5S 1 Church 7642 Warner Furuta House 1912 -- S Intact 3 S 8081 Warner Edison Substation c. 1900 -- H/P Intact 3CS/5S1 137 Item 15. - 102 HB -600- M - w.m�wa Prior Prior siti Updated Address1 'ate Historical Landmark1Status Landmark1 1 -Rating 11 .Rating Burned/ 333 Yorktown Northam House -- 5 S Demolishe 6Z d 303 3rd St. Young Building 1923 5*/3D S Demodlishe 6Z 310 3rd 1880s House -- 5 S Demdolishe 6Z 204 5th Shank House 1912 3/31) S Intact 3S/5S1 218-220 5th City Hall/Jail 1918 4/31) S Intact 3S/5S1 311 5th Zigzag Modern 1930s 5 S Intact 3CS/5S1 317 5' Craftsman 1910 5* S intact 3CS/5S2/ Bungalow 5 S 1 321 5th Colonial Revival 1905 5* S Altered 5S2/5S1/ 6L 126 6th Helm/Worthy 18 80s 1 S-H/P intact 1 S/5 S 1 House 410 6' Baptist Church 1906 4 S intact 3S/5S1 111-115 7th Spanish Colonial 1910s 5 S Demodhshe 6Z 127 7' Bungalow Court 1925 5 S Demodhshe 6Z 401-403 7th Craftsman 1920 5* S Intact 3 S/5 S 1/5 Apartments S2 428 7th Neo-Classical 1910 5* S Intact 3S/5S1 House 3018' Period Revival 1928 5* S Intact 3CS/5S1 Church 421 8th Hotel Evangeline 1906 3 S Intact 3 S/5 S 1 211 9th Victoria Eastlake 1906 5 S Intact 3 CB/5 S 1 321 loth St Mary's Church 1910 5* S intact 3CS/5S1 Now incl Manning House at 403 10th Judge Warner 1907 5 S-H/P 1010 3S/5S2/5 House Orange S 1 Street, undergoing restoration 42010th Clubhouse 1916 4 S Burned 6Z 138 HB -60 1- Item 15. - 103 ATTACHMENT #7 P .E Mf.^rTYN TPA N bCN Appendix B Updated Landmark List Sorted by Address Item 15. - 104 xB -602- 1 � �TIN^I'.BIxCN APN Address Land Use Year Built Status Code 1 167-321-21 17022 A St Commercial 1924 3CS 2 024-014-15 1106 Acacia Ave Multi Family ca 1915 5S2 Dwelling 3 024-014-07 1116 Acacia Ave Single Family 1922 5S2 Dwelling 4 024-202-11 310 Alabama St Multi Family 1950 3CS Dwelling 5 024-184-15 510 Alabama St Single Family 1910 3CS Dwelling 6 024-187-02 605 Alabama St Single Family 1912 3CS Dwelling 7 024-182-12 722 Alabama St Single Family 1924 3CS Dwelling 8 024-181-11 808 Alabama St Single Family 1908 3CS Dwelling 9 142-103-27 7742 Alhambra Dr Single Family 1906 3S Dwelling 10 142-103-35 7832 Alhambra Dr Single Family 1956 3CS Dwelling 11 142-102-42 7891 Alhambra Dr Single Family 1931 3CS Dwelling 12 142-102-26 7931 Alhambra Dr Single Family 1933 3CS Dwelling 13 165-363-05 17132 Ash St Single Family 1938 3CS Dwelling 14 153-091-29 19820 Beach Blvd Newland House 1898 1S/5S1 19822 Beach Blvd 15 163-123-01 17082 Bolsa Single Family 1927 3CS Chica St Dwelling 16 024-225-03 305 California St Multi Family 1916 3S Dwelling 17 024-214-14 801 Califorma St Multi Family 1925 3S Dwelling 18 167-472-08 17631 Cameron St Commercial 1947 3CS 19 024-082-05 201 Crest Ave Single Family 1920 3CD Dwelling B-1 1413 -603- Item 15. - 105 4 B.� N�'+vTIN^THY.8[RCN APN Address Land Use Year Built Status Code 20 024-082-02 211 Crest Ave Single Family 1931 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 21 024-081-29 216 Crest Ave Single Family ca. 1930 3CB/5S2 Dwelling 22 024-081-11 224 Crest Ave Single Family 1925 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 23 024-081-33 226 Crest Ave Single Family 1916 3CD 228 Crest Ave Dwelling 24 024-071-08 302 Crest Ave Single Family 1922 3CD 803 Main St Dwelling 25 024-071-09 306-310 Crest Single Family 1922 3CD/5S2 Ave Dwelling 26 024-072-02 307 Crest Ave Single Family 1916 3CD Dwelling 27 024-072-03 311 Crest Ave Single Family ca. 1905 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 28 024-071-12 330 Crest Ave Single Family 1921 3CB/5S2 Dwelling 29 024-071-11 334 Crest Ave Single Family 1931 3CD Dwelling 30 024-042-05 405 Crest Ave Single Family 1950 3CS Dwelling 31 025-104-05 903 Delaware St Single Family 1916 3CS Dwelling 32 025-111-41 2506 Delaware St Multi Family 1911 3CS Dwelling 33 024-184-10 225 Elmira Ave Single Family ca 1905 3CS Dwelling 34 025-162-07 1110 England St Single Family ca. 1912 3CS Dwelling 35 024-184-07 200 Frankfort Ave Commercial 1913 3S 36 024-232-21 837 Frankfort Ave Multi Family 1912 3S Dwelling B-2 Item 15. - 106 xB -604- as NtxTlM'T04 BERCN ' Address Land Use Built Status 0 37 111-021-06 17052 Gothard St Industrial 1912 3CS 38 111-024-22 17162 Gothard St Commercial Building ca. 1920 3S 39 024-241-13 628 Hartford Ave Single Family 1946 3CS/7N1 Dwelling 40 024-232-37 713 Hill St Single Family 1905 3S Dwelling 41 024-216-12 602 Huntington St Single Family ca. 1905 3CS Dwelling 42 024-216-08 616 Huntington St Single Family 1911 3CS Dwelling 43 024-215-10 704 Huntington St Single Family 3S Dwelling 44 024-214-05 816 Huntington St Single Family 1916 3CS Dwelling 45 025-053-28 1007 Huntington Single Family ca 1917 3CS st Dwelling 219 Indianapolis Single Family 46 025-054-12 1918 3CS Ave Dwelling 47 024-134-18 407 Lake St Single Family ca. 1930s 5S2 Dwelling 48 024-173-02 505 Lake St Single Family 1920 5S2 Dwelling 49 024-082-08 729 Lake St Multi Family 1905 3CD/3S Dwelling 50 023-074-08 1819 Lake St Single Family 1958 3CS Dwelling 51 165-312-08 7822 Liberty Ave Single Family 1922 3CS Dwelling 52 024-153-07 117 Main St Commercial 1914 3S 53 024-153-18 119 Main St Commercial 1920 3S 54 024-154-03 120 Main St Commercial 1908 3CS/7N B-3 HB -605- Item 15. - 107 Nt^TM^T04 BECN FIB APN Address Land Use Year Built Status Code 55 024-153-17 121 Main St Commercial 1920 3S/5S2 56 024-154-02 122 Main St Commercial 1902 3 S/7N 1 57 024-154-02 124 Main St Commercial 1912 3S/5S2 58 024-147-28 205 Main St Commercial 1920 5S2 59 024-147-23 213 Main St Commercial 1914 3S/7N1/5S1 60 024-147-14 217 Main St Commercial 1910 3 S/5S 1 61 024-144-01 328 Main St Commercial 1949 3CS 62 024-172-10 522 Main St Commercial 1922 3CS 63 024-135-01 525 Main St Educational Building 1950 1S/5S1 64 024-135-01 525 Main St Triangle Park 1912 1S 65 024-095-10 603 Main St Single Family ca. 1928 5S2 603 6th St Dwelling 66 024-095-09 605 Main St Commercial 1936 5S2 67 024-095-07 609 Main St Single Family 1901 3S/5S2 Dwelling 68 024-095-06 617 Main St Single Family ca 1915 5S2 Dwelling 69 024-095-05 619 Main St Single Family ca. 1925 5S2 Dwelling 70 024-072-17 711 Main St Single Family 1937 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 71 024-072-16 713 Main St Multi Family 1923 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 72 024-072-15 717 Main St Multi Family 1913 3CB/5S2 Dwelling B-4 Item 15. - 108 1-113 -606- +canN^ray e[ecw AddressAPN 1 Use Year Built Status Code 73 024-072-14 719 Main St Multi Family 1922 3CD Dwelling 722 Main St Single Family 74 024-082-22 ca 1905 3CD/5S2 724 Main St Dwelling 75 024-082-21 726 Main St Single Family 1917 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 76 024-072-13 727 Main St Single Family 1917 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 77 024-082-20 730 Main St Single Family 1922 3CB/5S2 732 Main St Dwelling 78 024-072-12 731 Main St Single Family 1915 3CD/3S Dwelling 79 024-082-19 734 Main St Single Family 1939 3CD Dwelling 80 024-072-11 735 Main St Single Family 1920 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 81 024-082-18 738 Main St Multi Family 1914 3CD/3S Dwelling 82 024-072-09 741 Main St Single Family 1922 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 83 024-082-17 742 Main St Single Family 1935 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 84 024-082-15 752 Main St Single Family 1922 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 85 024-082-14 754 Main St Single Family ca 1940 3CD Dwellin 86 024-072-01 755 Main St Single Family 1919 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 87 024-081-18 804 Main St Single Family 1925 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 88 024-081-16 806 Main St Single Family 1905 3CD Dwelling 89 024-081-15 810 Main St Single Family 1930 3CD/5S2 Dwelling B-5 1-113 -607- Item 15. - 109 P 1.W Hl ifN^;�BE4CN APN Address Land Use Year Built Status Code 90 024-081-25 814 Main St Multi Family 1922 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 91 024-071-06 815 Main St Single Family 1905 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 92 024-081-26 816 Main St Multi Family 1928 3CD Dwelling 93 024-071-03 825 Main St Single Family 1935 3CD Dwelling 94 024-061-04 912 Main St Multi Family 1923 5S2 Dwelling 95 023-062-17 1802 Main St Single Family 1927 5S2 Dwelling 96 023-062-16 1812 Main St Single Family ca 1905 3CS Dwelling 97 023-062-14 1816 Main St Single Family 1917 5S2 Dwelling 98 023-062-24 1828 Main St Single Family 1956 3CS Dwelling 99 023-020-22 1905 Main St Educational Building 1926 3S 100 025-044-17 211 Memphis Ave Single Family 1909 3CS Dwelling 101 111-372-07 17102 Nichols Single Family 1947 3S Ave Dwelling 102 146-201-59 5452 Old Pirate Single Family ca 1910 3S/5S1 Ln Dwelling 103 024-144-04 316 Olive Ave Post Office 1936 3S/5S1 104 024-147-01 411 Olive Ave Surf Museum 1935 5 S 1 105 024-118-02 717 Olive Ave Single Family ca 1920 5S2 Dwelling 106 024-033-08 1211 Olive Ave Single Family ca 1906 3S Dwelling B-6 Item 15. - 110 HB -608- f NL TIN^i0h BERCN APN Address Land Use Year Built Status Code 1406 Olive Ave Multi Family 107 024-024-14 1919 3CS 1408 Olive Ave Dwelling 108 024-132-08 614 Orange Ave Single Family 1917 3CS Dwelling 109 024-105-18 1010 Orange Ave Single Family 1907 3CS/5S1/7N1 Dwelling 110 024-027-01 1115 Orange Ave Single Family 1913 3CS Dwelling 111 024-163-08 110 Pacific Coast Commercial 1920 5S2 Hwy 112 024-163-09 114 Pacific Coast Commercial 1906 2S/2S2/3S/5S1 113 024-038-10 1102 Pacific Coast Motel ca 1960 3CS HWY 114 024-082-12 601 Palm Ave Commercial 5S2 606 Palm Ave 115 024-072-28 814 Palm Ave Single Family 1948 5S2 Dwelling 116 024-072-23 900 Palm Ave Single Family 1915 5S2 Dwelling 117 024-092-18 907 Palm Ave Single Family ca 1925 5S2 Dwelling 118 023-100-09 1502 Palm Ave Educational Building 1933 3S/5S1 119 023-100-07 1600 Palm Ave Institutional Building 1931 1 S/5 S 1 120 111-023-18 17066 Palmdale St Industrial 1929 3CS 121 024-051-28 1021 Park St Single Family 1961 3CS Dwelling 122 023-085-16 1102 Park St Single Family 1956 3CS Dwelling B-7 xB -609- Item 15. - Ill FIE HtnTIN^!'!N B[RGN APN Address Land Use Year Built Status Code 123 023-084-06 1121 Park St Single Family 1957 3CS Dwelling 124 023-062-07 1817 Park St Single Family 1925 5S2 Dwelling 125 024-131-15 509 Pecan Ave Single Family 1915 3CS Dwelling 126 024-131-12 519 Pecan Ave Single Family 1905 3CS Dwelling 127 024-104-07 712 Pecan Ave Multi Family ca 1930 5S2 Dwelling 128 178-242-07 16812 Sims St Multi Family 1923 3CS Dwelling 129 165-311-35 7792 Speer Ave Single Family ca 1915 3CS Dwelling 130 165-311-16 7942 Speer Ave Commercial 1922 3CS 131 167-531-24 8371 Talbert Ave Multi Family 1935 3CS Dwelling 132 167-531-23 8375 Talbert Ave Multi Family 1948 3CS 8421 Talbert Ave Dwelling 8375 Talbert Ave Multi Family 133 167-531-23 1916 3CS 8461 Talbert Ave Dwelling 134 024-147-09 414 Walnut Ave Commercial 1926 5S1/7N1 412 Walnut Ave 135 024-153-25 513 Walnut Ave Commercial 1904 1S/5S1 136 111-021-18 7360 Warner Ave Religious Building 1906-1907 3S/5S1 137 111-021-18 7386 Warner Ave Single Family 1910 3S/5S1 Dwelling 138 111-372-06 7622 Warner Ave Religious Building 1910 3S 139 111-372-06 7622 Warner Ave Manse 1910 3S 140 111-372-06 7622 Warner Ave Religious Building 1934 3S/5S1 141 111-372-07 7642 Warner Ave Single Family ca. 1912 3S Dwelling B-8 Item 15. - 112 HB -610- �d N`TW^ina tS CH 4 APN Address Land Use Year,RUM Statu&Code 142 111-372-07 7642 Warner Ave Barn ca 1912 3S 143 8081 Warner Edison Substation ca 1900 3CS 144 142-211-52 7581 Washington Single Family 1935 3CS Ave Dwelling 145 024-164-01 325 2nd St Commercial 1941 3CS 146 024-147-08 204 5th St Police Substation 1912 3S/5S1 147 024-147-03 218 5th St Commercial 1908 3S/5S1 148 024-142-14 311 5th St Commercial 1931 3CS/5S1 149 024-142-12 317 5th St Commercial 1913 3CS/5S2/5S1 150 024-151-06 121 6th St Residential 1907 3CS 151 024-152-01 126 6th St Single Family ca 1880 1S/5S1 Dwelling 152 024-142-19 308 6th St Multi Family ca 1920 5S2 Dwelling 153 024-142-06 310 6th St Multi Family 1949 3S/5S2 Dwelling 154 024-141-11 313 6th St Multi Family 1920 5S2 Dwelling 155 024-141-10 317 6th St Multi Family 1906 5S2 Dwelling 156 024-141-08 323 6th St Multi Family 1921 5S2 Dwelling B-9 HB -611_ Item 15. - 113 e 1 � Hi alit+^IOv Bi KN # APN Address Land Use Year Built Status Code 157 024-132-19 401 6th St Commercial 1906 3 S/5 S 1 158 024-132-15 409 6th St Single Family 1927 5S2 Dwelling 159 024-132-13 411 6th St Single Family 1920 5S2 Dwelling 160 024-172-06 613 6th St Commercial 1943 3CS 161 024-124-07 121 7th St Multi Family 1920 5S2 Dwelling 162 024-151-02 124 7th St Multi Family 1923 5S2 Dwelling 163 024-151-01 126 7th St Single Family 1920 5S2 Dwelling 164 024-118-14 215 7th St Single Family 1924 5S2 Dwelling 165 024-141-04 316 7th St Multi Family 1905 5S2 Dwelling 166 024-108-17 401 7th St Multi Family 1912 3S/5S1/5S2 Dwelling 167 024-132-07 402 7th St Single Family 1917 5S2 Dwelling 168 024-132-06 406 7th St Single Family 1907 5S2 Dwelling 169 024-108-15 427 7th St Single Family 1923 5S2 Dwelling 170 024-132-01 428 7th St Single Family 1905 3S/5S1 613 Pecan Ave Dwelling 171 024-131-09 504 7th St Single Family 1905 3CS Dwelling B-10 Item 15. - 114 xB -61 2- H,,, Nt�iw^T4'.BiaCN APN Addresse Use Year Built Status Code 172 024-131-06 510 7th St Single Family 1905 5S2 Dwelling 173 024-131-05 514 7th St Single Family ca 1905 5S2 Dwelling 174 024-104-08 527 7th St Single Family 1916 5S2 Dwelling 175 024-094-16 601 7th St Multi Family 1915 5S2 Dwelling 176 024-094-12 617 7th St Single Family 1917 5S2 Dwelling 177 024-123-03 125 8th St Single Family 1926 5S2 Dwelling 178 024-117-14 215 8th St Single Family ca. 1912 5S2 Dwelling 179 024-117-11 227 8th St Single Family 1922 5S2 Dwelling 180 024-113-19 301 8th St Religious Building ca. 1928 3CS/5S1 181 024-114-23 324 8th St Single Family 1904 3CS Dwelling 182 024-107-10 421 8th St Multi Family 1906 3S/5S1 Dwelling 183 024-104-05 510 8th St Single Family 1922 5S2 Dwelling 184 024-104-04 514 8th St Single Family 1922 5S2 Dwelling 185 024-103-11 515 8th St Single Family 1920 5S2 Dwelling 186 024-104-03 518 8th St Multi Family 1922 5S2 Dwelling B-11 HB -613- Item 15. - 115 EP Ht+TiN'"TO'BS.CN APN Address Land Use Year Built Status Code 187 024-103-08 527 8th St Single Family 1922 5S2 809 Acacia Ave Dwelling 188 024-093-39 601 8th St Single Family 1916 5S2 Dwelling 189 024-094-03 618 8th St Multi Family 1925 5S2 Dwelling 190 024-122-06 115 9th St Multi Family 1920 5S2 Dwelling 191 024-116-18 201 9th St Single Family 1912 3CD Dwelling 192 024-116-17 207 9th St Single Family 1905 3CD Dwelling 193 024-116-15 211 9th St Single Family 1905 3CB/5S1 Dwelling 194 024-116-14 215 9th St Single Family 1905 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 195 024-116-13 217 9th St Single Family ca. 1905 3CB/5S2 Dwelling 196 024-116-12 219 9th St Single Family 1917 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 197 024-116-10 227 9th St Single Family 1938 5S2 Dwelling 198 024-113-07 310 9th St Single Family 1925 5S2 Dwelling 199 024-112-12 311 9th St Single Family 1925 5S2 Dwelling 200 024-113-06 314 9th St Single Family ca. 1905 5S2 Dwelling 201 024-112-09 323 9th St Single Family 1920 5S2 Dwelling B-12 Item 15. - 116 11B -614- Ht nStN^Th B[CN APN Address Land Use Year Built Status Code 202 024-112-08 327 9th St Single Family 1915 5S2 Dwelling 203 024-107-07 406 9th St Single Family 1905 5S2 Dwelling 204 024-106-15 407 9th St Single Family ca 1925 5S2 Dwelling 205 024-107-06 410 9th St Single Family 1915 5S2 Dwelling 206 024-106-17 411 9th St Single Family 1916 5S2 Dwelling 207 024-107-05 412 9th St Single Family 1915 5S2 Dwelling 208 024-107-03 418 9th St Multi Family 1922 5S2 Dwelling 209 024-103-17 508 9th St Single Family 1923 5S2 Dwelling 210 024-093-05 616 9th St Single Family 1918 5S2 Dwelling 211 024-093-04 618 9th St Single Family 1920 5S2 Dwelling 212 024-093-03 620 9th St Single Family 1924 5S2 Dwelling 213 024-122-02 122 1Oth St Multi Family 1924 3CS Dwelling 214 024-111-25 321 loth St Religious Building 1923 3CS/5S1 215 024-105-18 403 1Oth St Single Family 1907 3S/5S1/5S2 Dwelling 216 024-105-17 405 1Oth St Single Family 1917 5S2 Dwelling B-13 HB -6 1 5- Item 15. - 117 tl .IJ E 3 Nt�Tiv^!9Y BS CX 4 AP N Address Land Use Year Built Status Code 217 024-101-18 501 1Oth St Multi Family 1924 5S2 Dwelling 218 024-091-10 617 loth St Single Family 1915 3CS Dwelling 219 024-091-08 623 loth St Single Family 1916 5S2 Dwelling 220 024-043-09 701 1Oth St Single Family 1913 5S2 Dwelling 221 024-043-08 705 loth St Single Family 1921 5S2 Dwelling 222 024-081-08 912 loth St Single Family 1903 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 223 024-081-05 922 1Oth St Single Family ca 1900 3S/5S2 Dwelling 224 024-061-36 931 1Oth St Single Family 1925 5S2 Dwelling 225 024-111-04 318 llth St Single Family 1905 5S2 Dwelling 226 024-111-03 320 1lth St Single Family 1924 5S2 Dwelling 227 024-027-09 327 llth St Commercial 1918 3CS 228 024-105-09 406 11th St Single Family 1915 5S2 Dwelling 229 024-105-06 412 11th St Single Family 1907 5S2 Dwelling 230 024-101-10 502 11th St Single Family 1917 5S2 Dwelling 231 024-014-15 601 11th St Commercial 1926 3S B-14 Item 15. - 118 HB -616- NlPTE4^;04 B{CN APN Address Land Use Year Built Status Code P 232 024-091-03 614 1 lth St Single Family 1920 5S2 Dwelling 233 024-043-04 702 11th St Single Family 1907 3S/5S2 Dwelling 234 024-017-19 802 1 lth St Single Family 1926 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 235 024-017-19 808 1lth St Single Family 1926 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 236 024-017-19 812 1 lth St Single Family 1926 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 237 024-071-18 816 1lth St Single Family 1926 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 238 939-506-54 820 11th St Condominium 1947 3CD/5S2 239 024-071-18 828 1 lth St Single Family 1926 3CD/5S2 Dwelling 240 024-061-08 934 11 th St Single Family 1925 5S2 Dwelling 241 024-061-09 936 1 lth St Single Family 1940 3CS Dwelling 242 024-061-16 952 1 lth St Single Family 1924 5S2 Dwelling 243 024-054-01 1035 1 lth St Lake Park 3CS 244 024-054-01 1035 llth St Lake Park Clubhouse 3CS 245 024-054-01 1035 1 lth Street Boy Scout Cabin 1935 3S 246 024-033-14 201 12th St Single Family ca 1905 5S2 Dwelling B-15 HB -61 7- Item 15. - 119 PIE Address 247 024-034-02 220 12th St Multi Family ca 1965 3CS Dwelling 248 024-027-32 312 12th St Single Family 1905 5S2 Dwelling 249 023-092-04 709 12th St Single Family 1961 3CS Dwelling 250 023-091-01 825 12th St Single Family 1954 3CS Dwelling 024-041-01 251 024-041-03 898 12th St Farquhar Park 3CS 024-041-04 252 024-051-27 905 12th St Single Family 1960 3CS Dwelling 253 024-026-25 312 13th St Single Family ca 1915 5S2 Dwelling 254 023-093-30 817 13th St Single Family 1948 3CS Dwelling 255 024-024-13 305 14th St Multi Family 1943 3CS Dwelling 256 024-024-16 315 14th St Multi Family 1917 5S2 Dwelling 257 024-012-03 618 14th St Single Family 1916 5S2 Dwelling B-16 Item 15. - 120 xB -6 1 8- ATTACHMENT #8 Citygof Huntington Beach`Planning and Building Department STAFF REPORT HONTINGTON BEACH ' 7 TO: Planning Commission FROM: Scott Hess, AICP, Director of Planning and Building BY: Ricky Ramos, Senior Planner DATE. February 24, 2015 SUBJECT: NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 14-005/GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT NO. 08-009 (HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT UPDATE) APPLICANT: City of Huntington Beach LOCATION: Citywide STATEMENT OF ISSUE: • Negative Declaration No. 14-005 request - Analyze the potential environmental impacts associated with the adoption and implementation of the Historic and Cultural Resources Element update. • General Plan Amendment No 08-009 request: - Update the Historic and Cultural Resources Element(HCRE) of the General Plan • Staffs Recommendation: Approve Negative Declaration No. 14-005 and General Plan Amendment No 08-009 based upon the following - The project will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment - The updated HCRE is consistent with the General Plan and reflects the City's current goals, objectives, and policies that will guide future decisions regarding historic structures - The project includes a Historic Context and Survey Report which identifies an updated list of potential historic structures (local landmarks list) which can be used to assist the City in managing its historic preservation goals. RECOMMENDATION: Motion to A. "Approve Negative Declaration No. 14-005 with findings (Attachment No 1)," B "Approve General Plan Amendment No 08-009 and forward draft City Council Resolution (Attachment No. 2) to the City Council for adoption" HB -619- Item 15. - 121 ALTERNATIVE ACTION(S): The Planning Commission may take an alternative action such as "Continue Negative Declaration No. 14-005 and General Plan Amendment No 08-009 and direct staff accordingly." PROJECT PROPOSAL: Negative Declaration(ND)No 14-005 represents a request to analyze the potential environmental impacts associated with the adoption and implementation of the Historic and Cultural Resources Element update pursuant to Chapter 240 of the Huntington Beach Zoning and Subdivision Ordinance (HBZSO) and the California Environmental Quality Act(CEQA). General Plan Amendment(GPA)No. 08-009 represents a request to update the Historic and Cultural Resources Element (HCRE) of the General Plan pursuant to the California Planning and Zoning Laws. The current General Plan was adopted in 1996 and serves as policy framework for future development of the city. The HCRE is one of the General Plan Elements and guides the City's decisions regarding historic and cultural resources by identifying goals, objectives,policies, and implementation programs as well as providing technical information and outlining issues regarding the protection of the city's historic resources and provision of arts/cultural services Only the historic resources component of the HCRE is proposed to be updated at this time The cultural resources component is not being revised. The City initiated the update because the existing local landmarks list in Table HCR-2 of the HCRE requires updating. Many of the properties listed in the local landmarks list have since been demolished or significantly altered while others are archaeological or not historic In addition, the update also allows the City to give a fresh look at the goals, objectives, policies, and implementation to make sure they continue to address the city's long-term needs Study Session: The request was presented to the Planning Commission for study session on February 10, 2015. The following questions were raised that required further follow up by staff- 1 Is there a public review process for updating the local landmarks list? Policy HCR 1.1 1 of the HCRE has been modified to reflect that comprehensive updates to the citywide survey of historic resources are subject to City Council approval. 2. Is there a generic name that can be used in Implementation Program I-HCR 8 to refer to the Huntington Beach Conference and Visitor's Bureau9 Implementation Program I-HCR 8 has been modified to address this issue. Item 15. - 122 1-02/24/15 HB -620- (15SR05 ND 14-005 GPA 08-009) ISSUES: General Plan Conformance: Staff reviewed the draft HCRE update for consistency with the other General Plan Elements. Only a minor follow up modification to the Coastal Element is needed to be consistent with the HCRE update The draft HCRE is consistent with the existing goals, objectives, and policies of the General Plan as follows. A Land Use Element Policy LU 4 2 2 - Permit historically significant buildings to vary from standard City codes, providing that the variations do not endanger human life and buildings comply with the State Historical Code. Policy LU 4 3.3 - Provide economic assistance, as funds are available, for the improvement of physically deteriorated structures in the City. Objective LU 15.3 - Facilitate the preservation of historically and architecturally significant points, structures, sites and districts Policy LU 15 3 1 - Encourage that structures designated with a"Historic Preservation Overlay"be retained, unless infeasible due to structural conditions or costs that prohibit a reasonable economic use of the property B Coastal Element Objective C 5 1 - Identify and protect,to the maximum extent feasible, sigmficant archaeological, paleontological and historic resources in the Coastal Zone Policy C 5 16 -Reinforce downtown as the City's historic center and as a pedestrian-oriented commercial and entertainment/recreation district, as follows 1 Preserve older and historic structures, 2 Require that new development be designed to reflect the Downtown's historical structures and Downtown design guidelines, 3 Amend the Downtown Specific Plan (as an LCP amendment subject to Commission certification)to: a Coordinate with the Citywide Design Guidelines; b Incorporate historic preservation standards and guidelines, c. Coordinate Downtown development and revitalization with policies and programs of the Historic and Cultural Resources Element. C Recreation and Community Services Element Policy RCS 1 12 - Combine sites that contain historic or natural features with recreational learning opportunities,where possible The goals, objectives and policies in the updated HCRE support those listed above by, among others, encouraging the identification and maintenance of historic structures as well as participation in financial incentives like the Mills Act which the City has recently adopted. PC Staff Report—02/24/15 HB -621- (15SR05 ND 14-001tem 15. - 123 Zoning Compliance: Not applicable. Urban Design Guidelines Conformance: Not applicable Environmental Status: Staff has prepared ND No. 14-005 pursuant to Section 240 04 of the HBZSO and the provisions of CEQA and determined that no significant impacts are anticipated as a result of the proposed project The Planning Division advertised draft ND No 14-005 for a 30-day public review period commencing on November 6 and ending on December 5, 2014 Two comment letters were submitted and a response and errata have been included with the attached ND. Historic Resources Board(HRB)Comments HRB identified what it believes are some shortcomings of the new historic survey and provided several recommended corrective actions that essentially involve adding more properties to the local landmarks list. The HRB's comments are provided and addressed in Attachment No 3 Environmental Board Comments The Environmental Board was notified of the Negative Declaration and did not submit any comments. Prior to any action on GPA No 08-009, it is necessary for the Planning Commission to review and act on ND No. 14-005 Staff, in its initial study of the project, is recommending that the negative declaration be approved with findings. Coastal Status Not applicable. Redevelopment Status: Not applicable. Design Review Board: Not applicable Subdivision Committee: Not applicable Other Departments Concerns and Requirements: Not applicable Public Notification: Legal notice was published in the Huntington Beach Wave on February 12, 2015 and notices were sent to property owners of record and tenants of the 258 local landmarks identified in the recent survey, individuals/organizations requesting notification(Planning Division's Notification Matrix), and interested parties As of February 17, 2015, no additional communication supporting or opposing the request has been received Application Processing Dates: DATE OF COMPLETE APPLICATION MANDATORY PROCESSING DATE(S) June 16, 2014 Not applicable Item 15. - 124 t-02/24/15 HB -622- (15SR05 ND 14-005 GPA 08-009) ANALYSIS: The following provides an overview of the Historic and Cultural Resources Element and the key updates Overview and Kedges The updated HCRE is organized into four main sections. Technical Synopsis, Issues, Goals, Objectives, and Policies, and Implementation Programs The Technical Synopsis section contains background information including the city's historic context and predominant architectural styles. The Issues section outlines a list of major concerns that have been identified regarding historic structures The Goals, Objectives, and Policies section describes what the city would like to achieve and provides policy guidance relating to managing the city's historic structures. The Implementation Programs section includes the actual steps that can be taken to ensure the goals, objectives, and policies of the HCRE are met. The HCRE update includes the following notable changes which are shown in Attachment 4 1 Technical Synopsis and Issues — These sections include an update to the historic context of the city and its predominant architectural styles by incorporating information from the associated Historic Context and Survey Report explained later on in this staff report. The issues relating to historic structures were also reviewed and updated All the existing outdated tables and exhibits, including the local landmarks list in Table HCR-2, are being deleted. Instead of continuing to include a local landmarks list in the HCRE, the City will maintain a separate local landmarks list which includes all the properties in the city that have been identified as having historic significance as a result of a recent survey as well as future survey updates. This will allow future updates to the list as needed without requiring an amendment to the HCRE. Table HCR-2 (1991) lists 79 local landmarks comprised of 212 properties One of the 79 landmarks is the Wesley Park neighborhood which consists of 134 properties alone. The current status of these landmarks is noted in Attachment 5 and summarized as follows: ■ 79 properties have been carried over into the updated landmarks list, ■ 133 properties have been demolished, heavily altered, or are not historic and have been removed from the updated landmarks list 2 Goals, Policies, Objectives, and Implementation Programs — These sections only required a few revisions to update and clarify existing goals, objectives, policies and implementation programs Staff and Galvin Preservation Associates, the Ctty's consultant, prepared and reviewed the changes to the HCRE to make sure they are consistent with the General Plan, appropriate, and reflect the city's long-term interests The HCRE update was also reviewed by the HRB and their comments were incorporated PC Staff Report—02/24/15 HB -62 3- (15SR05 ND 14-00Item 15. - 125 Historical Context and Survey Report As part of the HCRE update, Galvin Preservation Associates (GPA) conducted a citywide survey to identify and evaluate potential historic structures in the city. The purpose of the survey is to update and expand the City's existing 1986 Historic Resources Survey Report and to update the HCRE. The survey included a reconnaissance level survey of all±2,400 buildings in the city that were at least 50 years old when the survey was commenced in 2009, focusing on the historic core areas as well as select buildings located outside the historic core and other outlying areas identified by the HRB City staff and GPA worked closely with the HRB over several years on the survey and the results are outlined in the 2014 Historic Context and Survey Report The updated local landmarks (historic structures) list is identified in Appendix B of the Historic Context and Survey Report which is provided as Attachment 6 to this staff report In addition, GPA reviewed the three previously identified potential historic districts in the 1986 survey and determined that they no longer maintain enough integrity to be considered historic districts according to national, state, and local register criteria. GPA identified two smaller concentrations of buildings in the 2014 Historic Context and Survey Report that would constitute a local historic district as follows a Main Street-Crest Avenue—This district is located on Main Street and Crest Avenue between 1 Ith Street and Palm Avenue b. 9th Street—This district includes most of the west side of 9th Street between Walnut Avenue and Olive Avenue 1IAIN STREET-CRESTAVENUE 9TH STREET HISTORIC" DISTRICT HISTORIC DISTRICT ar 6 LEGEND LEGEND ua.,ea�rtabutw. LNtrkt'��c,en4tlbnWrs ..ems IH trMt Nmadner u 'ry` lvdgeNef fw..Un M tLB 8 r Item 15. - 126 t-02/24/15 HB -624- (15SR05 ND 14-005 GPA 08-009) CEOA and Historic Structures The updated local landmarks list in Appendix B of the Historic Context and Survey Report identifies 258 local landmarks and would serve as a list of historic structures for purposes of evaluating future projects under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) This list requires periodic update and can be used to assist the City in managing its historic preservation goals It should be noted that no new regulatory requirements will be imposed on these landmark buildings that did not exist before the survey was conducted Only some buildings will no longer need an evaluation as a result of the survey (the other +2,140 properties surveyed that were determined to not be historic) In 1999, the City established a policy clarifying the level of environmental review for historic structures listed in the General Plan Basically, any demolition of a listed historic structure was subject to environmental review under CEQA Additionally, any construction work on a historic resource was required to comply with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties in order to be exempt from environmental review. However, based on recent CEQA research, it has been determined that a ministerial demolition permit or alterations to a historic resource are not subject to CEQA even if the alteration does not comply with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards If the City wishes to adopt a Preservation Ordinance that requires discretionary approval of proposed demolition or alterations of historic structures,then CEQA would apply to the discretionary action. Absent a Preservation Ordinance, inclusion on the list would not result in triggering CEQA requirements when demolishing or altering a historic structure unless it is proposed within the context of a project requiring discretionary approval by the City or the structure is located within the Downtown Specific Plan where changes to a historic structure are subject to a mitigation measure requiring a report from an architectural historian SUMMARY: Staff s Recommendation Approve Negative Declaration No 14-005 and General Plan Amendment No. 08-009 based upon the following - The project will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment. - The updated HCRE is consistent with the General Plan and reflects the City's current goals, objectives, and policies that will guide future decisions regarding historic structures - The project includes a Historic Context and Survey Report which identifies an updated list of potential historic structures (local landmarks list) which can be used to assist the City in managing its historic preservation goals. ATTACHMENTS: 2 Dr-aft City re,,.,ed Desel„t,en Appr-evifig�Gv n i re 08 009 > Respense te Gemments, Tl #l4 + .l G itti fal Deseur-ees Element 71.deAe(t...,eLd 1. s) 4�1TlTC'rZT,C�TfG'C[LIITGITTCCQ�GJ�'n7SGTL—Il71TIGT1 r��C[[��CTC[Glc j urs*vnc c vrrtc.areind Scii dcy-n cpirwrn=p"..a,* B ( .dad cd b und iarcs z. .) 7 14ist, Ge..te.,� ..,1 S 4nebed btit .l.al.le ,.♦ � e De ef4(.iet a SH JV RR kdc PC Staff Report-02/24/15 HB -625- (15SR05 ND 14-001tem 15. - 127 ATTACHMENT #9 CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH INTER-DEPARTMENT COMMUNICATION HUNTINGTON BEACH P P - xx DRAFT TO: Planning Staff FROM: Scott Hess, AICP, Director of Planning and Building SUBJECT: MINOR UPDATES TO THE HISTORIC CONTEXT AND SURVEY REPORT AND LOCAL LANDMARKS INVENTORY DATE: September 23, 2015 The Historic and Cultural Resources Element recommends that historic surveys should be updated comprehensively every five years subject to City Council approval pursuant to Policy HCR 1 1 1 and Implementation I-HCR 1 However, minor updates to the historic survey and local landmarks Inventory can be completed by staff in between the comprehensive updates subject to the following procedures 1 Deleting from Inventory proposed by property owner— In order to propose the deletion of a property from the Local Landmarks Inventory, the property owner shall submit a report from a qualified architectural historian demonstrating why the property should be removed from the Inventory for review and approval or denial by planning staff Planning staff shall give notice to the Historic Resources Board (HRB) when a request for deletion is received to allow the HRB to provide comments within 45 days prior to a decision by planning staff 2 Adding to Inventory proposed by property owner— In order to propose the addition of a property to the Local Landmarks inventory, the property owner shall submit a report from a qualified architectural historian or from the HRB demonstrating why the property should be added to the inventory for review and approval or denial by planning staff Planning staff shall give notice to the HRB when a request for addition is received to allow the HRB to provide comments within 45 days prior to a decision by planning staff 3 Adding to inventory proposed by HRB — In order for HRB to propose the addition of a property to the Local Landmarks inventory, HRB shall submit a report demonstrating why the property should be added to the inventory for review and approval or denial by planning staff The request must be accompanied by written authorization from the property owner G\Ramos\HCR Element Update\Draft Policy for Minor Updates to Historic Survey-with HRB comments(clean)docx Item 15. - 128 HB -626- The architectural historian or HRB members preparing the report must meet the Secretary of the Interior's Professional Qualifications Standard, Code of Federal Regulations, 36 CFR Part 61 Planning staff will modify the Local Landmarks Inventory upon approving the report G\Ramos\HCR Element Update\Draft Policy for Minor Updates to Historic Survey-with HRB comments(clean)docx HB -627- Item 15. - 129 ATTACHMENT # 10 City of Huntington Beach Voluntary Historic Properties Inventory (October 8, 2015) ddresr. ;Type , A►d� 1 5 th 204 Police Substation* Sept 2015 2 7 th 510 Single Family Residential Sept 2015 3 8 th 603 (formerly 601) Single Family Residential Sept 2015 4 9th 217 Single Family Residential Sept 2015 5 9th 227 Single Family Residential Oct 2015 6 1 1th 320 Single Family Residential Oct 2015 7 1 1th 406 Single Family Residential Sept 2015 8 11th 1035 Lake Park, Clubhouse, and Sept 2015 Boy Scout Cabin* 9 12 th 898 Faquhar Park* Sept 2015 10 A 17022 Single Family Residential Sept 2015 11 Beach 19820 Newland House* Sept 2015 12 Crest 211 Single Family Residential Sept 2015 13 Elmira 225 Single Family Residential Sept 2015 14 Gothard 17052 Industrial Sept 2015 15 Huntington 1007 Single Family Residential Sept 2015 16 Main 217 Commercial Oct 2015 17 Main 525 Main St Library and Sept 2015 Triangle Park* 18 Main 727 Single Family Residential Sept 2015 19 Main 735 Single Family Residential Sept 2015 20 Main 738 Multi-Family Residential Sept 2015 21 Olive 411 Surf Museum* Sept 2015 22 Palm 1600 City Gym and Pool* Sept 2015 23 Pecan 519 Single Family Residential Sept 2015 *City-owned properties Item 15. - 130 HB -628- ATTACHMENT # 11 IN IF ts \ gg Ar ' \ � tin y L \� w V-4 sr E opill v \• Q�\ \ s ilk M `\\ \\ :10\ a \ ,jql > a i..L x r� f �r �A� 'f \ HB 29- Item 15. - 13 -6 1 6�TV 4 \to 0ow 'Ark I/AP 0 0/1 vol ,ww", W All, *-4w diduk, go, aa a svK IS \Rl I *q 1 7 al 4 W"' 1-1 cl m\ Alk w 40, co /* All 1 41,AAR All Pq Item 15. - 132 HB -630- ow 1"11 WA, owlNOR a son 51il 3r\ its 10 u�` "g �_"`\ �\ " ,,�M�� � ,. ��,� " �� ,�� � � Item 15 A(-o *14F A -014 oo, *a%swookw1w n" -W, T7 WWI jfRW ron "A AD 3 0 A- 'I,\\ \g �ZZ go gng,!t— cn I V11- ,_o q *44 �hl Ak I tw oe Item 15. - 134 , HB -6- w s # =, vPIP \ -� `¢`'yam 01 t/ ' Al' LO u i 414 - It' ra %/4 i \ r- t- t"" l!'3 LOt"" e- e- t- e- e- It Je- �:? N CAI N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N �.. �6k> �� �� f\ m � �\ �+� w= +w M.+ w r.. r+ w� r.. w r+ w+ +»a O. L1 C1 CL .w Gl Gl C1 C9. CS L'7s. CL C6 t� w-� C3. C3. C1 C1 CL P:9. C;� 0 0 0 0) cU w w (U w 0 w fU a) 0 cU 0 0 VAR Wkik,44 \\ c3 i i Ra i m R9 t i t43 R7 taS f �a y y` C C C C C qj C C C C G G �, G �, Y l i btk Pfi Sf9 if! tf1 UI VY CP7 tt9 tA3 �l7 CR9 T 0 V) v= ^� a tU 411 iU GLt tL9 tU C + G3 tU 49 iU 0y V7 4 ` \ 0 LY cr m E" Ix m � ram' *y� C�" � IY x cr kN rW, << v E E E E E E E _ E E _J E m E ' c4 R7 m tQ m m mmL' ml S �y tSf y� \ ` a, (n LL LL U- LL U- U. m o U- C u- LL U- qy w 0 U- U- U! LL Pm 21 ��3 tL f1J 0 ( C w ..I m U- U) Z co a) 0 F— � � C� C3 (t) \ ? \ it QI,- ti Q w cm') 00 Q M r U7 O (`� ti us') CO r Q m r- \ 04 LO (0 N (N M 11 r cc N N CV LO 1*- h- M1- of e- V) Fi 2 ' C OL 1p ifl G C C C C E Val LO hWOF-:« r N-0 Cry # It') lw It— CO I'm IF e- e^ r r ILO r- , clbb a�. , 711 CIO ICT WX 41 e,F \ \ ` a� Item 15. ny :� ^\ \1 yr N-5-10 4\01P' IL On 43/1 At lf oz Oka A& % Jr," Wk I FIFIV, Zal qf, vj MW WME I Q)", ,>4pp cn \ X� >i�jxw r2t Pk Item 15. - 136 'HB -634- !"AL 44L Lim" av or omplyripwil IN 'Jo \ " B » \ \ 1 -71 �*0 C\ 00 r�% r of amm \AV\ a � Olt E .\ y \ic, it Zia! low c r' W a✓ � ��°� s �� £r ins s� '" ✓` Item 15. - 13 -63 7 j HB �- ss \ 1.1 wo LB At oll 1 ui '•� �^� \ 3 gPPA f AN VNE R £ mItem 15. - 138 '\ x �. 'F I R - NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that on Monday, October 19, 2015 at 6 00 p m in the City Council Chambers, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, the City Council will hold a public hearing on the following planning and zoning item ❑ 1 NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 14-005/GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT NO. 08-009 (HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT UPDATE) Applicant: City of Huntington Beach Request: ND: To analyze the potential environmental impacts associated with the adoption and implementation of the Historic and Cultural Resources Element update GPA: To update the Historic and Cultural Resources Element Also, information will be provided on which property owners have requested to be on the voluntary historic properties inventory On February 24, 2015, the Planning Commission held a public hearing on this item and recommended approval to the City Council Location: Citywide City Contact: Ricky Ramos NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the initial environmental assessment for Item #1 was processed and completed in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act It was determined that Item #1 would not have any significant environmental effect and, therefore, a negative declaration is warranted Negative Declaration No 14-005 is on file at the City of Huntington Beach Planning Division, 2000 Main Street, and is available for public inspection and comment by contacting the Planning Division, or by telephoning (714) 536- 5271 ON FILE A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Planning and Building Department, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public A copy of the staff report will be available to interested parties at the City Clerk's Office or online at http //www huntingtonbeachca qov on Thursday, October 15, 2015 ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above If you challenge the City Council's action in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at, or prior to, the public hearing If there are any further questions please call the Planning and Building Department at (714) 536-5271 and refer to the above items Direct your written communications to the City Clerk Joan L Flynn, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street, 2"d Floor Huntington Beach, California 92648 714-536-5227 http Hhuntingtonbeachca gov/HBPublicComments/ C \Users\esparzap\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\BGU3Z50B\10-19-15 ND 14-005 GPA 08-009 (HCRE) docx CITY COUNCIL/REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY PUBLIC HEARING REQUEST FORM MEETING DATE- 1:f>C�r' IC11, �015 SUBJECT N --L�' DEPARTMENT- CONTACT NAME: P1ce'`f "i-�3 PHONE 53 co-- S(-I-L{ N/A YES NO ( ) (VI ( ) Is the notice attached? S*Litr• iw-e Do the heading and closing of the notice reflect a hearing before the City Council and/or Redevelopment Agency? Are the date, day and time of the public hearing correct? (v) ( ) ( ) If an appeal, is the appellant's name included in the notice? (v-) ( ) ( ) If Coastal Development Permit, does the notice include appeal language? Is there an Environmental Status to be approved by Council? Is a map attached for publication? ( ) ( ) (vj Is a larger ad required? Size ( ) (vo ( ) Is the verification statement attached indicating the source and accuracy of the mailing list? W-f crr-e S-tppp (✓� ( ) ( ) Are the applicant's name and address part of the mailing labels? (✓) ( ) ( ) Are the appellant's name and address part of the mailing labels? If Coastal Development Permit, is the Coastal Commission part of the mailing labels? (✓) ( ) ( ) If Coastal Development Permit, are the resident labels attached? Is Summary Report 33433 attached? (Redevelopment Agency items only) What is the minimum number of days from publication to hearing date? What is the minimum number of times to be published? What is the specified number of days between publications? KIA FOR ADMINISTRATION AND CITY CLERK USE ONLY Approved for public hearing Date noticed to newspaper Date published Date notices mailed Aa3AV-09-008-L )wdn-dod pjogaj a!ja!aAaj 4uaulB6je43 ®09LS®Aa3AV 1.!,jege6 a!zasinn ap SUBS ujortiane•mmm ap u0.e ajngPey el g zB!ldBa 7 aa!ad a sa!a:ile;saaaanb!43 167-321-21 1 024-014-15 2 024-014-07 3 Ryan Timothy J Jamen George Joseph Agee James Everett& Knsty Rene 17022 A Ln 5801 Bellfield Lane 1424 Serpentine Dr Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Redlands, CA 92373-6557 024-202-11 4 024-184-15 5 024-187-02 6 1 B P Inc Tomatsu Inc Mc Cormick Steven Craig Po Box 8582 921 N Harbor Blvd 605 Alabama St Alta Loma, CA 91701-0582 La Habra, CA 90631-3103 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-182-12 7 024-18 8 142-103-27 9 Yerush Vigil Craig Charles lmi Sina Ewers Sandra K Po 580 18697 Santa Carmela St#182 1437 W Malvern Ave Be Fountain Valley, CA 92708-6335 Box 808 Fullerton, CA 92833-2431 Beverly Hills, CA 90209-5808 142-103-35 10 142-102-42 11 142-102-26 12 Fey Michael West Helen Ohara Tsuyoshi 19451 Olana Ln 7891 Alhambra Dr 3208 Philo St Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Los Angeles,CA 90064-4719 165-363-OS 13 163-123-01 15 024-225-03 16 Duong Phuong or Current Owner Ziebarth Warren S Delmer Robert J 17132 Ash Ln 17082 Bolsa Chica St 30S California St Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-214-14 17 167-472-08 18 024-082-OS 19 Owner Yamada Shigeru Le Long Chinh 801 California St 7942 Speer Dr 8918 La Dona Ct Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Fountain Valley,CA 92708-3319 024-082-02 20 024-081-29 21 024-081-11 22 Ohiggins Colleen M Farrell Patrick L Macallister Denise 30061 Canyon Crk 216 Crest Ave 224 Crest Ave Trabuco Canyon,CA 92679-3017 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-081-33 23 024-071-08 24 024-071-09 25 Kemmerer Marcus Erik Family Tr Szuba Ted L Yturralde Kathy L 226 Crest Ave 302 Crest Ave 306 Crest Ave Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-072-02 26 024-072-03 27 024-071-12 28 Senese Family Trust Eberly Tina C Saylor David D 307 Crest Ave 311 Crest Ave 330 Crest Ave Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024 043 91 29 024-071-11 30 024-042-OS 31 Eberle 'amen Q.Van Hove C Est Fulvio Lawrence B Case Casey C 3"�Ave 334 Crest Ave 605 Barroilhet Ave Huntington Beach GA 9'G"4 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 San Mateo,CA 94402-1042 ! � ® 154-06� 1 b?p o g-0&, ®09LS ate!dujal @AjaAv ash 009LS /��/�; ! o1 Bull 6uo!e PUBSINEIM ® low s!agel®!Bad Ase3 A213Ab-09-008-6 ,wdn-dod pjogaj al jalanaj juawa6jeq� a sue � 00965®A213A11}!jege6 a1 zasll!ifl wortiane nnnnnn ap ul}e ajnqpey of a zagdaa p- s I jeled a sell3e}sauanb113 025-104-05 32 024-184-10 34 025-162-07 35 Hernandez Alan Churchwell Jeffrey&Christal Wagner Lucille&Robert M 11544 Excelsior Dr 225 Elmira Ave 3079 Nestall Rd Norwalk,CA 90650-5753 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Laguna Beach, CA 92651-2026 024-184-07 36 024-232-21 37 024-232-21 37 Naah Steve K Owner/Occupant Owner/Occupant 8302 Cade Cir 837 Frankfort Ave 839 Frankfort Ave#A Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 024-232-21 37 111-021-06 38 111-024-22 39 Owner/Occupant Surf Dog Llc Hankins Myron E 839 Frankfort Ave#A 20401 Sun Valley Dr 10112 Fox Springs Rd Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Laguna Beach, CA 92651-1166 Cowan Heights, CA 92705-1508 024-241-13 40 024-232-37 41 024-216-12 42 Bruce William M Daniel and Alyssa Murphy Nicastro Michael N 19350 Ward St 713 Hill St 602 Huntington St Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 024-216-08 43 024-215-10 44 024-214-05 45 Davda Jayendra&Anila Ott Melvyn Fox David Carl 616 Huntington St 704 Huntington St 816 Huntington St Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 025-053-28 46 025-054-12 47 024-134-18 48 Gamache Suzanne Seiler Rebecca L Orens Richard A&Patricia 1007 Huntington St 219 Indianapolis Ave 407 Lake St Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 024-173-02 49 024-082-08 50 023-074-08 51 Le Uyen Westward Partner Llc Unterman Alan B 5029 Heleo Ave 806 Main St 1819 Lake St Temple City, CA 91780-3825 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 165-312-08 52 024-153-07 53 024-153-18 54 Cao Henry 117 Main Hb Llc Alfonso Frank 8731 Brooke Ave 117 Main St 6630 Vickiview Dr Westminster,CA 92683-7702 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 West Hills,CA 91307-2749 024-154-03 55 024-153-17 56 024-154-02 57/58 Morning Jade Corp Draper George E Lim Sang H 2855 Pullman St 1210 Pecan Ave 3810 Wilshire Blvd#911 Santa Ana,CA 92705-5713 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Los Angeles, CA 90010-3218 024-147-28 59 024-147-23 60 024-147-14 61 Robert Koury Llc 1997 Turner Family Trust Langevin Douglas M S 200 Main St#206 18052 Freshwater Cir 13711 Yellowstone Dr Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Santa Ana, CA 92705-2683 T ND/4--pOs r ,%AP3 do-dod asodxa jaded paaj r @09LS aleldwal®IGany ash 009 LS® � g rt]�iG/1J� 01 awl 6uole puaaww� ® -2-c is Z slage-1®lead Ase3 T ( luawa6aey� i A213Ab-O�-008-L ,Wdn-dod pjogaj a!jalan�a , ®09LS®J1213A�d�!aege6 a!zas!i!�n � � ap sues � worAjane-nnnnnn ap uge ajny3ey el @ zalldaa o , Jeled a sa!l3e;saq�.anb!13 024-144-02 62 024-144-01 63 024 134 07 64 Bolen Robert D Goodall Walsh&Parnakian Gavle Leulse 1818 Pine St 3505 Cadillac Ave#g1 O940 El PFesi ente Ave Huntington Beach, CA92648 Costa Mesa, CA 92626-1431 F,.untain Valley,GA 9"08 4307 024-172-10 65 024-095-10 68 024-095-09 69 Derigo Lewie Paris Lane Victoria Jean Allen Robert R 807 Main St 637 Frankfort Ave 327 Crest Ave Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-095-07 70 024-095-06 71/72 024-072-17 73 Dubar Robert Rogers George L Robertson Helen Xuereb 609 Main St 16882 Gothard St#e 416 De Sola Ter Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Corona Del Mar, CA 92625-2650 024-072-16 74 024-072-15 75 024-072-14 76 Owner/Occupant Goddard James William Owner/Occupant 713 Main St 3164 Willow Bend Dr 719 Main St Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Chico,CA 95973-8716 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-082-22 77 024-082-21 78 024-072-13 79 Zwilling Bernice Maxine Gorman Ruthe Huniu Norman S 31942 Mount Rainier Dr 726 Main St 16422 Sundancer Ln Laguna Niguel,CA 92677-2807 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92649 024-082-20 80 024-072-12 81 024-082-19 82 Kiralla Agnes Folger Matthew J &Linda J Kaae Richard S 1010 Pacific Coast Hwy 731 Main St 734 Main St Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-072-11 83 024-082-18 84 024-072-09 85 Sorrell Paul A Da Silva Joseph Albert Owner/Occupant 735 Main St 738 Main St 741 Main St Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-082-17 86 024-082-15 87 024-082-14 88 Kiralla Kathleen A Kang Wang Liang Tom Y Jtl Tr 742 Main St 752 Main St 18362 Oxboro Ln Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-072-01 89 024-081-18 90 024-081-16 91 Long Charles J&Joanne H Costello Joanna Gleason Patrick G&Gina T 755 Main St 804 Main St 806 Main St Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-081-15 92 024-081-25 93 024-071-06 94 Fennell Michael D AnduJo Virginia Oddo David P Po Box 511 PO Box 2668 815 Main St Huntington Beach, CA 92648 La Habra,CA 90632-2668 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 T N 1)1�--D(Is— ( .,a6p3 do-dod asodxa jaded peag 1 @09L5 a}eldwal®AGany asn @09L5® 1� r�ltr��� of aull 6uole puas 3,ur-2.3 slage-1®lead Ase3 T AH3Ad-09-008-6 ,Wdn-dod pjogaa al aaipnqu ;uawa6jey- 009LS®AH3AV:t!jege6 a!zesmin ap sues wortiane nnMnn , ap w;e amy�ey e! zaydaa - , aa!ad q se!ix;sauenbi 3 024-081-26 95 024-071-03 96 024-061-04 97 C&B Real Estate Invs Inc Sullivan Brian J Family Tr Kooken Rita C 20129 Jersey Ave 825 Main St 12215 Santiago Rd Lakewood,CA 90715-1047 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Banning, CA 92220-6821 023-062-17 98 023-062-16 99 023-062-14 100 Cullum Darlene A Melott Tammy Hoskinson Michael 27800 Blue Sky Ln 1812 Main St 402 11th St Canyon Country,CA 91351-5700 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 023-062-24 101 023-020-22 102 025-044-17 103 Danielson Esther M HBUHSD Fiorillo Dominick A 2781 W Macarthur Blvd Ste B 5832 Bolsa Ave 11721 Vultee Ave Santa Ana,CA 92704-7095 Huntington Beach,CA 92649 Downey,CA 90241-5420 146-201-59 105 024-144-04 106 024-118-02 108 Smith Carl & Elizabeth United States Of America Zero Lawrence A 5452 Old Pirate Dr 6771 Warner Ave Po Box 183 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Surfside,CA 90743-0183 024-033-08 109 024-024-14 110 024-132-08 111 Cate Margaret Fox Gwendolyn G Zektser Elan 25 Picard Cir 11783 Eton Dr 614 Orange Ave Easthampton, MA 01027-2665 Grand Terrace,CA 92313-5124 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-105-18 112 024-027-01 113 024-163-08 114 Santiago Joseph D Attalla Mirette I Tks Fast Grill Inc 403 loth St 3449 E Pacific Coast Hwy 110 Pacific Coast Hwy Huntington Beach, CA 92648 _ Signal Hill, CA 90755-1903 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-163-09 115 024-038-10 116 024-082-12 117 Peck Ralph Barot Family Trust Huntington Beach Masonic Bldgassn 8404 Lexington Rd 1102 Pacific Coast Hwy 601 Palm Ave Downey, CA 90241-2622 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-072-28 118 024-072-23 119 024-092-18 120 Fowler Michael James Gene Yellow Van Dev Llc Glade Alex W 814 Palm Ave 900 Palm Ave 2180 Harvard St#380 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Sacramento,CA 95815-3327 023-100-09 121 111-023-18 123 024-051-28 124 School Huntington Beach Union High District Rogers Mark H& Diana D Welinder Family Trust 20451 Craimer Ln 6591 Morning Tide Dr 1021 Park St Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 023-085-16 125 023-084-06 126 023-062-07 127 Payne Barbara Gerhart MacAllister Donald A Dusterhoft Paul R 1102 Park St 1121 Park St 1817 Park St Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 a/JQ('� P W1a6p3 do dod asodxa ® waded peal r @09LS a;e!dwas @Ajand asn 00965 0�� � ® r.(�n 01 auii 6uole puce ® 4 or- 2.�!' slags 1,�,laad Rse3 T AH3AV-09-008-L f 3Wdn-dod paogaa al aapAat ;uawa6jeyp IF @09LS®A83AV�ljege6 al zesgl�.n a sues wo�IGane•MMM i ap ulp aanypey el g zalldaa p ; jaled a selpe;seuer&44 024-131-15 128 024-131-12 129 024-104-07 130 Derigo Lewie Paris Rosales Oscar Javier Clary Michael M 807 Main St 519 Pecan Ave 1120 Pacific Coast Hwy Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 131 132 133 178-242-07 165-311-35 165-311-16 BRAGG MAYELA FAMILY TRUST AKIN SHARON L FAMILY TRUST YAMADA SHIGERU 5540 E 6T"ST 7791 LIBERTY DR 7942 SPEER AVE LONG BEACH,CA 90814-2034 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92647 134 135 136 165-531-24 167-531-23 167-531-23 MARY LANGSTON OWNER OWNER 8371 TALBERT AVE 8421 TALBERT 8461 TALBERT HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92646 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 137 138, 154 139, 140 024-147-09 024-153-25, 024-152-01 111-021-18 WISE S E SEQUOIA TR SHIRLEY D WORTHY CHURCH WARNER AVE BAPTIST 414 WALNUT AVE 801 13T"ST 7360 WARNER AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92647 104, 141, 142, 143, 144, 145 146 147 111-372-06,-07 lenelle Godges, Region Manager 142-211-52 NICHOLS STREET PROPERTIES LLC Local Public Affairs LASITER STEVEN C PO BOX 1026 Southern California Edison 5581 STANFORD AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 estm nsterBolsa Avenue GARDEN GROVE,CA 92845 Westminster,CA 92683 148 150 151, 152 024-164-01 024-147-03 024-142-14 JOHNSON LOLA GALITZEN DONALD ANDREW STUPIN 73014T"STREET PO BOX 151 215 5T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 153 155 156 024-151-06 024-142-19 024-142-06 ROBERT& DONNA ASPEREN JAMES BEARD&PEGGY ONEAL JUDITH WOOD FAMILY INVESTMENTS LLC 1216T"STREET 19481 POMPANO LN#112 19681 QUIET BAY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 157 158 159 024-141-11 024-141-10 024-141-08 PETER D YOUNGSMA PEDERSEN ROBERT A HANYA GALITZEN PO BOX 327 1313 E AVENUE Q12 PO BOX 151 SURFSIDE, CA90743-0327 PALMDALE, CA93550 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 160 161 162 024-132-19 024-132-15 024-132-13 CHURCH COMMUNITY BIBLE OF HB MICHAELI FLOWERS PHILIP&KIM PETERSEN 4016T"STREET 5150 CANDLEWOOD ST#3 1137 W ROYAL PALM ROAD HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 LAKEWOOD,CA 90712-1900 PHOENIX,AZ 85021-5660 163 164 165 024-172-06 024-124-07 024-151-02 ELLEN COSTELLO& B BREWSTER TR JOHN ROST KING LAURA A 613 6T"STREET 123 7T"STREET 425 ULTIMO AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 LONG BEACH,CA 90814 T o�Dl� � Wia6P3 dn-dod asodxa jaded paBj @09L5 a;eldwal @(aaAV ash i ®09LS p�� ® ,T I�I 1 n�1� ! o;Bull 6uole puceUMMM ® 5 °�23 slagel®laad Ase3 T AH3AV-09-008-L .1 ,Wdn-dod pjogaj al jalanaj 3uawa6ae43 009LS®AU3AV I!jege6 of zesium wor tiaw mmm a ul a ain 3e e e zal daa ap suas , p } y y ! , i - , jalad a salme}sauanbl;3 166 167 168 024-151-01 024-118-14 024-141-04 SMITH JANET MARITAL TRUST JAMES PAGNENELLI MICHAEL L FEEMSTER 1021 KINGS ROAD 215 7T"STREET 19731 BUSHARD ST NEWPORT BEACH,CA 92663 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92646 169 170 171 024-108-17 024-132-07 024-132-06 HUCH TAI CHENG UJIMORI WESLEY N N REVOC TR WAYNE& PAULA BURTON 1033 VIA ZUMAYA 3220 LOWER RD#A 406 7T"STREET PALOS VERDES ESTATES,CA 90274 HONOLULU, HI 96822-6400 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 172 173 174 024-108-15 024-132-01 024-131-09 0 CALLAGHAN IRENE R ROSEMARY ROBINSON HAW THOMAS ALAN 52 S PORTOLA 19486 SANDCASTLE LN 504 7T"STREET LAGUNA BEACH,CA 92651-6719 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 175 176 177 024-131-06 024-131-05 024-104-08 KENNETH E PHILLIPS ALFRED W KERR VERNA110HNSON 510 7T"STREET 10851 PATRICIA DR 527 7T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 GARDEN GROVE,CA 92840 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 178 179 180 024-094-16 024-094-12 024-123-03 SWEARINGEN IDA E MICHAEL MCMAHON A& N HAN LLC 6017T"STREET 27477 PASEO AMADOR 125 8T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 SAN JUAN CAPISTRANO,CA 92675 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 180 181 182 024-123-03 024-117-14 024-117-11 OWNER/OCCUPANT BARBARAI PRIDDY MARSHAANN HOULE 125 8T"STREET 383 E 7T"AVE 49554 PAIUTE CT HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 SALT LAKE CITY, UT 84103-2737 AGUANGA,CA 92536-9131 183 184 185 024-113-19 024-114-23 024-107-10 CHURCH FIRST OF CHRIST PETER G DODGE ERICH REISEN 810 OLIVE AVE 9 SUMMERHILL GARDENS 5874 EAGLE ISLAND HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 TORONTO,CANADA WEST VANCOUVER, CANADA BCV7W1V5 186, 187 188 189 024-104-05 024-103-11 024-104-03 BREKT INC ARUNUS SODONIS&SHERRY QUENGA KELLY ROBERT 930 10T"STREET 466 FOOTHILL BLVD#A PO BOX 744 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 LA CANADA FLINTRIDGE,CA 91011-3527 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 190 191 192 024-103-08 024-093-39 024-094-03 DAVID A MCLEOD BAROT SURENDRA P&TARULATA S 8T"STREET INVESTMENTS LLC 19671 BEACH BLVD,#101 603 8T"STREET 5042 CORNELL AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 WESTMINSTER,CA 92683 193 194 195 024-122-06 024-116-18 024-116-17 WILLIAM RUSSELL PAXSON ALLEN BENTON EUGENE SIMON CHEUNG&CHEUW OEY 115 9T"STREET PO BOX 230 109 TREEHOUSE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 IRVINE,CA 92603-0692 �Nb/y--C- r N,laBP3 do-dod asodxa jaded paaj P @09LS 4eldwag oAjany asD oonse)AN3AW ��,I�G Ii'� 04 aull 6uole puce ® Co 01- 2-3 Slage-I®laad Rse3 Easy Peel®Labels i A ® Bend along line to i w AVERY@ 51600 Use Avery®Template 51600 j Feed Paper ® expose Pop-up EdgeTM j 196 197 198 024-116-15 024-116-14 024-116-13 HUGH A MORAN JUDITH A EDELEN LIVING TRUST MAHMOOD EMAMI 2119T"STREET 215 9T"STREET 1021 ARANCIA DR HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 FORT COLLINS, CO 80521-4920 199 200, 211 201 024-116-12 024-116-10 024-113-07 THOMAS GAGLIO THOMAS D CONLON DAVID E ARTHUR 2725 TERRAZA PL PO BOX 944 310 9T"STREET FULLERTON,CA 92835 ARCATA, CA 95518-0944 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 202 203 204 024-112-12 024-113-06 024-112-09 CHRISTOPHER D HOGAN TERRACE HOLDINGS LLC ZIMMERMAN J WICKHAM 900 PACIFIC COAST HWY#107 1812 WESTERLY TER 323 9T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 LOS ANGELES,CA 90026 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 205 206 207 024-112-08 024-107-07 024-106-15 HUGGINS P M COOPER MORRISSEY JAMES EDWARD BRANT L BLASINGAME 6702 HARBOR KEY CIR 5361 RICHMOND AVE 405 9T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 GARDEN GROVE,CA 92845 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 208 209 210 024-107-06 024-106-17 024-107-05 JOHN F MANNING ROESCHLAUB WILLIAM MARTIN BEVERLY A KHALIL 1705 PARK ST 1120 PACIFIC COAST HWY 7 TICONDEROGA HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 IRVINE,CA 92620-2558 212 213 214 024-103-17 024-093-05 024-093-04 CLETE M ZIMMERMAN NORMAN&COLLEEN CHAPMAN DIANE V BRIGGS 508 9T"STREET 616 9T"STREET 618 9T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 215 216 217 024-093-03 024-122-02 024-111-25 PATRICK L FARRELL HARLOW RICHARD A SAINT MARYS BY THE SEA CHURCH 216 CREST AVE 1742 MAIN ST 2811 E VILLA REAL HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 ORANGE,CA 92867 218 219 220 024-105-18 024-105-17 024-101-18 JOSEPH D SANTIAGO JANIS JOHN WILLIAMS MARK E&TR 403 10T"ST 405 10T"STREET 501 10T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 221 222 223 024-091-10 024-091-08 024-043-09 SCHLAGER JAMES F KOSLOSKY OSCAR 1 &JANETTE NEVINS MICHAEL D& EUGENIA E 9391 BREAKWATER CIR 16734 VON SOSTEN RD 701 10T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92646 TRACY,CA 95304-9721 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 224 225 226 024-043-08 024-081-08 024-081-05 LILLEY LYNETTE LEVESQUE RUSSELL J COOLEY PETER K 705 10T"STREET 912 1CP STREET 92210T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 Etiquettes faciles a peter /�A t\f —C'0�; ® Repliez a la hachure afin de ; www.avery.com i Mfico7 to nmhari+aVPRY®RunO I�Ic��� LSens de reveler le rebord Pop-upM� 1-800-GO-AVERY 'I ; Easy Peel®Labels i A Bend along line to 1 IN AVERW 5160® i Use Avery®Template 51600 j Feed Paper ® expose Pop-up EdgeTM j 1 227 228 229 024-061-36 024-111-04 024-111-03 WEISS ADAM & EUGENIA LIBERMAN CONTRERAS BARBARA B HORNER NANCY M 93110T"STREET 6901 LOYOLA DR 320 11T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 230 231 232 024-027-09 024-105-09 024-105-06 ZEIDAN FAMILY TRUST HABERMANN NANCY JEAN DELMAR RICHARD & DIANNA R 1207 CITRUS PLACE 40611T"STREET 8579 TRINITY RIVER CIR COSTA MESA, CA 92626 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648-4508 FOUNTAIN VALLEY, CA 92708-5535 233 234 235 024-101-10 024-014-15 024-091-03 MUSSER PAUL B JAMEN GEORGE JOSEPH COLUMBUS PAUL SAVAS 502 11T"STREET 5801 BELLFIELD LN 2505 DA VINCI HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 IRVINE,CA 92614 236 237, 238, 242 239 024-043-04 939-506-58,59,57 939-506-60 ZANONI VICTOR & PATRICIAA MERRILLSTEVEN F CHERNEY MICHAELJ 601 PATTEN AVE 17650 LOS ALAMOS ST 1118 PARK ST OCEANSIDE, NY 11572-1034 FOUNTAIN VALLEY, CA 92708 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 240 241 243 939-506-55 939-506-54 024-061-08 RENE A BROOKBANK CHERNEY MICHAEL 1 ROSOW LAVERGNE D 81611T"STREET 1118 PARK ST PO BOX 85 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 244 245 249 024-061-09 024-061-16 024-033-14 AMES NICHOLAS COGHILL SCHLEY FAMILY TRUST HALL RONALD C 93611T"STREET 6692 HARBOR KEY CIR 201 12T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 250 251 252 024-034-02 024-027-32 023-092-04 BAUER INVESTMENTS SLIFF-SWORD EVELYN LTRUST CLOUSE DARREL L 16511 COTUIT CIR 2686 COLDWATER CT 709 12T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92649 CORONA,CA 92881-4172 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 253 255 256 023-091-01 024-051-27 024-026-25 MASON JEFFREY A RINGER JOHN D &ANNE E WHITE MARK 825 12T"STREET 905 12T"STREET 16312 BRADBURY LN HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92647 257 258 259 023-093-30 024-024-13 024-024-16 HANSON NADINE OBRIEN SHARON K DUNAI ELEANOR C 817 13T"STREET 3 OAK TREE LN 315 14T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 IRVINE,CA 92612-2232 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 260 173 33 024-012-03 ^'132 01: 025-111-41 HANAN KUPFERMAN ALEX NGO PO BOX 4314 803 HUNTINGTON ST 2506 DELAWARE DIAMOND BAR,CA 91765-0314 HUNTINGTON BEACH GA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 Etiquettes faciles a peler4b/1---ws— ® Repliez a la hachure afro de ; www.avery com I Utilisez le aabarit AVERY®5160�cl/9/1' '�Sens de.. reveler le rebord Pop-upM� ; 'd o '� 7-800-GO-AVERY ; Easy PeelO Labels i A Bend along line to a �� ®5160® Use Avery®Template 51600 j Feed Paper ® expose Pop-up EdgeTM j 33 11 025-111-41 142-102-42 PLN INVESTMENT LLC Gayla Totaro 3382 CORTE CASSIS 16251 Wayfarer COSTA MESA,CA 92626 Huntington Beach,CA 92649 UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE NF HUNTINGTON PLAZA SIGMA ENTS INC 6771 WARNER AVE 6222 WILSHIRE BLVD#400 111 S KRAEMER BLVD#C HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 LOS ANGELES, CA 90048-5100 BREA, CA 92821-4676 OLD WORLD OWNERS ASSOCIATION SAINTS SIMON &JUDE CHURCH TAKI SUN INC/PETERS LANDING MARINA 23046 AVENIDA DELA 2811 E VILLA REAL DR 6400 E PACIFIC COAST HWY LAGUNA HILLS, CA 92653 ORANGE,CA 92867 LONG BEACH, CA 90803-4206 WATERFRONT PONSTR GTION GENERAL MANAGER STATE OF CALIFORNIA (DARR! GORBETT) WATERFRONT HILTON HOTEL STATE LANDS COMMISSION 660 AIEWPE)RT CENTER DR ui 050 21100 PACIFIC COAST HIGHWAY 100 HOWE AVE#100 -NEWPORT BEACH GA 92660 6 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 SACRAMENTO,CA 95825-8202 SAINT BONAVENTURE CHURCH AES HUNTINGTON BEACH, LLC DOUGLAS REALTY CO INC 2811 E VILLA REAL DR 21730 NEWLAND STREET PO BOX 3707 ORANGE,CA 92867-1932 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92646 SEATTLE,WA 98124-2207 RICHARDSON CANDY COE SEACLIFF VILLAGE SHOPPING CENTER INC JEFFREY A FISHER 17292 GOLDENWEST ST 18818 TELLER AVE#277 23901 CALABASAS RD#1065 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92647-5447 IRVINE,CA 92612-1612 CALABASAS,CA 91302-1560 5T"STREET PROPERTY MGMT LLC 7816 CONNIE DR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648-1332 66, 67, 107, 149 14,122,246,247,248,254 S®TT 024-147-01,08 024-054-01 KELLEE FRITZAL,REAL ESTATE SERVICES,CITY OF HB JANEEN LAUDENBACK DIRECTOR OF COMMUNITY SERVICES,CITY OF H INTER-O I•I•I C E D B P O BOX 190 P 0 BOX 190 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 N,�) /,/ -t� /,-jh Etiquettes faciles b peter ; ® Repliez b la hachure afro de ; www.averycom Utilisez le aabarit AVERY®51600 '�Sen�s dew+ r6v6ler le rebord Pop-upmc 13 1-800-GO-AVERY Aa3AV-09-008-L ,Wdn-dod pjogau al jalanau ;u8w86je42 009LS®AH3AV Ilaege5 al zasnan ap sues ,ua as ad a se a sa anbl13 o3ti iu►nn anenn ap use amy�ey e�a rai�dab ® } 3l 024-014-15 2 024-014-15 2 024-014-15 2 Occupant Occupant Occupant 1106 Acacia Ave 1108 Acacia Ave 601 11th Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-014-07 3 024-202-11 4 024-202-11 4 Occupant Occupant Occupant 1116 Acacia Ave 302 Alabama St 304 Alabama St Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-202-11 4 024-202-11 4 024-184-15 5 Occupant Occupant Occupant 308 Alabama St 310 Alabama St 510 Alabama St Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-182-12 7 024-181-11 8 142-103-27 9 Occupant Occupant Occupant 722 Alabama St 808 Alabama St 7742 Alhambra Dr Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 142-103-35 10 142-102-26 12 142-102-26 12 Occupant Occupant Occupant 7832 Alhambra Dr 7931 Alhambra Dr Unit A 7931 Alhambra Dr Unit B Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 142-102-26 12 153-091-29 14 153-091-29 14 Occupant Occupant Occupant 7931 Alhambra Dr Unit C 19820 Beach Blvd 19822 Beach Blvd Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-225-03 16 024-225-03 16 024-214-14 17 Occupant Occupant Occupant 305 California St#A 305 California St#B 809 California St Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-214-14 17 024-214-14 17 167-472-08 18 Occupant Occupant Occupant 811 California St 813 California St 17631 Cameron Ln Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 024-082-05 19 024-082-05 19 024-082-02 20 Occupant Occupant Occupant 201 Crest Ave 201 Crest Ave Unit% 211 Crest Ave Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-071-08 24 024-071-09 25 024-072-02 26 Occupant Occupant Occupant 803 Main St 310 Crest Ave 307 Crest Ave#A Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 7 o l -� V w,a5P3 do-dod asodxa jaded paed r ®09LS a}eldwal®IGaAV Bsn ', @09LS pAH V 04 Bull 6uole pugs V 10 o4= 73 slagel oblaad Rse3 �i AH3AV-09-008-L 1 ,wdn-dod pjogaj a!jalgAaj Iu8w85Je43 @09L5®AH3AV I.ljege5 a!zesllan ap sues , woxAjane-mmm 11 ap w}e ajn43e4 el g zapdsy - , jaled a sepe;sauar& 024-072-02 26 024-042-05 31 025-104-05 32 Occupant Occupant Occupant 307 Crest Ave#B 405 Crest Ave 903 Delaware St Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 025-111-41 33 025-111-41 33 025-111-41 33 Occupant Occupant Occupant 2506 Delaware St 2508 Delaware St#A 2508 Delaware St#B Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 025-111-41 33 025-111-41 33 025-111-41 33 Occupant Occupant Occupant 2510 Delaware St#1 2510 Delaware St#2 2510 Delaware St#3 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 025-162-07 35 024-184-07 36 024-184-07 36 Occupant Occupant Occupant 1110 England St 200 Frankfort Ave 512 Alabama St Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 111-021-06 38 111-024-22 39 024-241-13 40 Occupant Occupant Occupant 17052 Gothard St 17162 Gothard St 628 Hartford Ave Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-216-12 42 024-215-10 44 024-173-02 49 Occupant Occupant Occupant 311 Frankfort Ave 708 Huntington St 505 Lake St Unit%: Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-173-02 49 024-082-08 50 024-082-08 50 Occupant Occupant Occupant 505 Lake St 729 Lake St 729 Lake St#1/2 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-082-08 50 024-082-08 50 024-082-08 50 Occupant Occupant Occupant 729 Lake St#A 729 Lake St#B 729 Lake St#C Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-082-08 50 024-082-08 50 024-082-08 50 Occupant Occupant Occupant 729 Lake St#D 729 Lake St#E 729 Lake St#F Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 165-312-08 52 024-153-07 53 024-153-07 53 Occupant Occupant Occupant 7822 Liberty Dr 117 Main St#101 117 Main St#201 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 P Wl96P3 do-dod asodxs jaded paaj f ®09L5 aleldwal @Ajew asn ®09L5 ® ���/� r/ i olsuil6uolepuss ® ! !t opZ2 slagel t�laadAse3 T A113Ab-09-008-1, f ,wdn-dod pjogaj al jalanaj ivawa6JeP f @09LS®J1213"I!jegeiS el zesimn ' 11 woxAme Amm ' a ul ajn 3e a zai dBa ap sues P 4 N 1@ I v , salad a sal!�e�sa anb!I- 024-153-07 53 024-153-07 53 024-153-07 53 Occupant Occupant Occupant 117 Main St#202 117 Main St#203 117 Main St#204 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-153-07 53 024-153-07 53 024-153-07 53 Occupant Occupant Occupant 117 Main St#205 117 Main St#206 117 Main St#207 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-153-07 53 024-153-07 53 024-153-18 54 Occupant Occupant Occupant 117 Main St#208 117 Main St#209 119 Main St Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-154-03 55 024-154-03 55 024-153-17 56 Occupant Occupant Occupant 120 Main St 120 Main St#201 121 Main St Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-154-02 57 024-154-02 58 024-147-28 59 Occupant Occupant Occupant 122 Main St 124 Main St 205 Main St Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-147-28 59 024-147-23 60 024-147-14 61 Occupant Occupant Occupant 205 Main St#1/2 213 Main St 217 Main St Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-144-02 62 024-144-02 62 024-144-02 62 Occupant Occupant Occupant 320 Main St 320 Main St#1/2 322 Main St Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-144-01 63 024-144-01 63 024-144-01 63 Occupant Occupant Occupant 324 Main St 326 Main St 326 Main St#101 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-144-01 63 024-134-07 64 024-172-10 65 Occupant Occupant Occupant 328 Main St 410 Main St 522 Main St Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-135-01 66/67 024-135-01 66/67 024-095-10 68 Occupant Occupant Occupant 525 Main St 525 Main St#A 603 Main St Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 T Ab la5p3 do-dod asodxa mm=m jaded peal P @09LS aleldwal okaw asn i ®0965 OAUSAV s 01 Bull 6uole puce ® �--oF '21 slagey®lead Ase3 lol r9hr T A213A11-09-008-L ,Wdn-dod paogaj al jalanau tuawa6ae4� @09LS®AH3Ad I!aegeb a!zeslan ap SUBS 11 worAjOAe-Amm i ap uge amy-3e4 el q zagdab - , salad a sall3e}sauai&13 024-095-09 69 024-095-07 70 024-095-06 71 Occupant Occupant Occupant 605 Main St 609 Main St#1/2 617 Main St Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-095-0 71 024-072-17 73 024-072-16 74 Occupant Occupant Occupant 619 Main St 711 Main St 720 Palm Ave Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-072-16 74 024-072-15 75 024-072-14 76 Occupant Occupant Occupant 718 Palm Ave 717 Main St 721 Main St#B Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-072-14 76 024-082-22 77 024-082-22 77 Occupant Occupant Occupant 721 Main St#A 724 Main St 722 Main St Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-072-13 79 024-072-13 79 024-072-13 79 Occupant Occupant Occupant 727 Main St#A 727 Main St#B 727 Main St#C Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-082-20 80 024-082-18 84 024-082-18 84 Occupant Occupant Occupant 730 Main St 738 Main St#101 738 Main St#102 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-082-18 84 024-082-18 84 024-082-15 87 Occupant Occupant Occupant 738 Main St#201 738 Main St#202 752 Main St Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-082-15 87 024-082-14 88 024-081-16 91 Occupant Occupant Occupant 750 Main St 754 Main St 806 Main St Unit Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-081-15 92 024-081-15 93 024-081-25 94 Occupant Occupant Occupant 810 Main St Unit% 810 Main St 810 Main St Unit 1 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-081-25 94 024-081-25 93 024-081-25 93 Occupant Occupant Occupant 810 Main St Unit 3 810 Main St Unit 5 810 Main St Unit 6 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 T 1\1,6 I1- Wia6p3 do-dod asodxa ® jaded pa8J f 009LS ejeldwal GfUBAV ash i o09 Ls GAN3AV 1 J in b4 �/1 i of auq 6uole puceIIANNIIIIIIIIIIII ® -IA s!agel®load/(se3 i AH3AV-09-008-t ; ,wdn-dod pjogaj al jalanaj 3uawa=4e 0091S®Aa3AV I!aege6 a1 zas!I!ln i wortiane•Annnnn I ap use ejnipey el @ zalldab ap�a5 ; jaled a sal saaaanb!13 024-071-06 94 024-071-06 94 024-081-26 95 Occupant Occupant Occupant 815 Main St Unit A 815 Main St Unit B 816 Main St Unit 2 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-081-26 95 024-071-03 96 024-061-04 97 Occupant Occupant Occupant 816 Main St Unit 4 827 Main St 912 Main St Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-061-04 97 023-062-17 98 023-062-14 100 Occupant Occupant Occupant 914 Main St 1802 Main St 1816 Main St Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 025-044-17 103 024-144-04 106 024-118-02 108 Occupant Occupant Occupant 211 Memphis Ave 316 Olive Ave 717 Olive Ave Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-033-08 109 024-024-14 110 024-024-14 110 Occupant Occupant Occupant 1211 Olive Ave 1406 Olive Ave 1408 Olive Ave Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-105-18 112 024-027-01 113 024-163-09 115 Occupant Occupant Occupant 1010 Orange Ave 1115 Orange Ave 114 Pacific Coast Hwy Unit 1 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-163-09 115 024-163-09 115 024-163-09 115 Occupant Occupant Occupant 114 Pacific Coast Hwy Unit 2 114 Pacific Coast Hwy Unit 3 114 Pacific Coast Hwy Unit 4 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 024-163-09 115 024-072-28 118 024-092-18 120 Occupant Occupant Occupant 114 Pacific Coast Hwy Unit 5 814 Palm Ave#1/2 907 Palm Ave Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 023-100-09 121 023-100-07 122 111-023-18 123 Occupant Occupant Occupant 1502 Palm Ave 1600 Palm Ave 17066 Palmdale Ln Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92647 024-131-15 128 024-104-07 130 024-104-07 130 Occupant Occupant Occupant 509 Pecan Ave 712 Pecan Ave 714 Pecan Ave Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 � ® ib'(C('�I S� T wla6p3 do-dod asodxa jaded peal 0096S a;eldwaj ohaAd asn ®0965 pAH o�aul!6uolepuceJamm ® 1� o� y s!age-I®laad�(se3 �i AH3At1-09-008-L Mdn-dod pjogaj al jalanaj }uawaBjey3 ( 009LS®AV3AV:Lliege5 al zasuan a sua woxAme-Awm ap ul}e aing3eq el a zagdaa p 5 ; salad a sall3e}sauenb113 131 024-104-07 130 024-104-07 130 178-242-07 Occupant Occupant OCCUPANT 718 Pecan Ave 720 Pecan Ave 16812 SIMS ST Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 132 137 138 165-311-35 024-147-09 024-153-25 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 7792 SPEER AVE 412 WALNUT AVE 513 WALNUT AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 138 138 138 024-153-25 024-153-25 024-153-25 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 513%WALNUT AVE 517 WALNUT AVE 515 WALNUT AVE UNIT 1 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 138 138 138 024-153-25 024-153-25 024-153-25 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 515 WALNUT AVE UNIT 2 515 WALNUT AVE UNIT 3 515 WALNUT AVE UNIT 4 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 138 138 138 024-153-25 024-153-25 024-153-25 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 515 WALNUT AVE UNIT 5 122 6T"STREET 122 6T"STREET UNIT HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 138 138 138 024-153-25 024-153-25 024-153-25 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 124 6T"STREET 124 6T"STREET UNIT Y2 128 6T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 139 140 147 111-021-18 111-021-18 142-211-52 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 17022 GOTHARD ST 7386 WARNER AVE 7561 WASHINGTON AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92647 147 148 150 142-211-52 024-164-01 024-147-03 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 7581 WASHINGTON AVE 325 2ND ST 218 5T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 150 150 151 024-147-03 024-147-03 024-142-14 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 218 5T"STREET UNIT 1/2 220 5T"STREET 3115T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 152 154 155 024-142-12 024-152-01 024-142-19 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 317 5T"STREET 126 6T"STREET 308 6T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 w e6P3 do-dod asodxa jaded paaj r 009LS%eldwal®IGany ash 009LS ® my ® �,114 /A/ 01 aull 6uole puas ® ! is nd-- -)a slagel®land Ase3 T A113nb-09-008-11, 3wdn-dod paogaj al aalgnaa ;uawa6jetp @09L5®AH3AV I!jege6 al zeslan ap sua5 , as a so ire sa wm tianennn+►nn ap upamy3ey el a zagdaa - !ed ! anbl;3 156 156 156 024-142-06 024-142-06 024-142-06 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 310 6T"STREET 310 6T"STREET UNIT 1/2 310 6T"STREET REAR UNIT HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 156 156 157 024-142-06 024-142-06 024-141-11 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 312 6T"STREET 312 6T"STREET UNIT 1/2 313 6T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 158 158 158 024-14 1-10 024-141-10 024-14 1-10 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 317 6T"STREET 317 6T"STREET UNIT A 317 6T"STREET UNIT B HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 159 159 159 024-141-08 024-141-08 024-141-08 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 323 6T"STREET UNIT A 323 6T"STREET UNIT B 323 6T"STREET UNIT C HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 159 159 159 024-141-08 024-141-08 024-141-08 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 323 6T"STREET UNIT D 323 6T"STREET UNIT E 323 6T"STREET UNIT E1 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 159 160 160 024-141-08 -132-19 024- -19 OCCUPANT OCCU T OCCUPA 323 6T"STREET UNIT E2 402 ORANGE AVE U 1 402 ORANGE AVE U HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92 8 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 160 160 160 4-132-19 02 .132-19 024- -19 OCCU T OCCUP OCCUPA 402 ORANGE AVE 3 402 ORANGE AVE UNiT,4 402 ORANGE AVE U%92 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 9 48 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92 8 HUNTINGTON BEACH,C 160 160 160 -132-19 0 32-19 0 -132-19 OCCUP OCCUP OCCU T 402 ORANGE AVE U 6 402 ORANGE AVE U 7 402 ORANGE AVE 8 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 161 162 164 024-132-15 024-132-13 024-124-07 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 409 6T"STREET 4116T"STREET 1217T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 165 165 165 024-151-02 024-151-02 024-15 1-02 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 124 7T"STREET UNIT A 124 7T"STREET UNIT B 124 7T"STREET UNIT C HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 Wla6R3 do-dod asodxa jaded paai r 009L5 ajeldwal®IGany asD 009 L5 ®ACE w nN�! /,�/ i 01 gull 6uole pua8 ® ! !c,of=-La sage,jnlaad Ase3 T AMAV-O9-008-6 ,wdn-dod pjogaj al jalanaj ;uawa6jetp 00965®AH3AV 1!aege6 ai zesinin ap suas woxAmAe Amm , ap ule ain9eg q a zaildaa , aalad a salpe}sa;lanbl;a 165 165 165 024-151-02 024-151-02 024-151-02 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 124 7T"STREET UNIT D 122 7T"STREET UNIT A 122 7T"STREET UNIT B HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 165 165 166 024-151-02 024-151-02 024-151-01 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 122 7T"STREET UNIT C 122 7T"STREET UNIT D 126 7T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 166 166 166 024-151-01 024-151-01 024-151-01 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 128 7T"STREET 615 WALNUT AVE 617 WALNUT AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 168 169 169 024-141-04 024-108-17 024-108-17 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 316 7T"STREET 4017T"STREET UNIT A 4017T"STREET UNIT B HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 169 169 170 024-108-17 024-108-17 024-132-07 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 403 7T"STREET UNIT C 403 7T"STREET UNIT D 402 7T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 172 172 173 024-108-15 024-108-15 024-132-01 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 427 7T"STREET 707 PECAN AVE 613 PECAN AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 173 176 178 024-132-01 024-131-05 024-094-16 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 428 7T"STREET 514 7T"STREET 6017T"STREET UNIT 1 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 178 178 179 024-094-16 024-094-16 024-094-12 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 6017T"STREET UNIT 2 6017T"STREET UNIT 3 617 7T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 180 180 181 024-123-03 024-123-03 024-117-14 OWN ER/OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 803 WALNUT AVE 803 WALNUT AVE 215 8T"STREET UNIT Y2 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 182 182 183 024-117-11 024-117-11 024-113-19 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 227 8T"STREET 229 8T"STREET 3018T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 b f Y---OC f wia6P3 do-dod asodxe jaded paaJ ®0915 a;e�dwal®IGanV ash ®0965®�� V f0�+���� o;jug 6uo�e puce ® t-1 or slage3 0188d Rse3 T AH3Ad-09-008-L f 3 do-dod pjogaj al jaIgAgj ;u8w86jeg3 @09LS®AV3AV I!aege6 al zas!p;n ap sua5 , worNaAe-mNm ap up ajng3eq el a za!ldab - , aa!ad @ sa!pe}sauanb!13 184 185 185 024-114-23 024-107-10 024-107-10 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 324 8T"STREET 4218T"STREET UNIT 101 4218T"STREET UNIT 201 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 185 186 186 024-107-10 024-104-05 024-104-05 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 4218T"STREET UNIT 103-1 510 8T"STREET 510 8T"STREET UNIT 1/2 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 187 188 188 024-104-04 024-103-11 024-103-11 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 514 8T"STREET 515 8T"STREET 515 8T"STREET UNIT 1/2 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA92648 189 189 189 024-104-03 024-104-03 024-104-03 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 520 8T"STREET UNIT 1 520 8T"STREET UNIT 2 520 8T"STREET UNIT 3 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA92648 189 190 190 024-104-03 024-103-08 024-103-08 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 518 8T"STREET 809 ACACIA AVE 527 8T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 191 192 192 024-093-39 024-094-03 024-094-03 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 6018T"STREET 618 8T"STREET 618 8T"STREET UNIT 1/2 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA92648 192 194 198 024-094-03 024-116-18 024-116-13 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 620 8T"STREET 2019T"STREET 217 9T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 199 200 200 024-116-12 024-116-10 024-116-10 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 219 9T"STREET 227 9T"STREET 907 OLIVE AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA92648 202 203 205 024-112-12 024-113-06 024-112-08 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 3119T"STREET 314 9T"STREET 327 9'STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA92648 205 206 208 024-112-08 024-107-07 024-107-06 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 907 ORANGE AVE 406 9T"STREET 410 9T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA92648 T /}c - W,a6p3 do-dod asodxa jaded paad ®0915 aje!dwal @AJOAV esn ' 09L5 i 01auil 6uole puce ® 16 w s!age-!®lead Ase3 i ® 0�� � inll�'�ismosim Aa3AV-O"08-1, wdn-dod pjogaj al jalanaj WOLuct laW i @09LS®AH3AV}ljegeb al zosimn ap sues wortiane-mmm , ap ui;e ojn43e4 el g zalldaa - , salad a saloe;sa�anbl;� 209 209 209 024-106-17 024-106-17 024-106-17 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 4119T"STREET 407 9T"STREET 407 9T"STREET UNIT 101 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 210 210 211 024-107-05 024-107-05 024-107-03 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 412 9T"STREET 414 9T"STREET 418 9T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 211 215 216 024-107-03 024-093-03 024-122-02 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 420 9T"STREET 620 9T"STREET 122 10T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 217 218 220 024-111-25 024-105-18 024-101-18 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 321 10T"STREET 1010 ORANG AVE 503 10T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 221 221 222 024-091-10 024-091-10 024-091-08 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 619 10T"STREET 61710T"STREET 623 10T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 223 223 226 024-043-09 024-043-09 024-081-05 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 1006 PALM AVE 1004 PALM AVE 920 10T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 228 230 230 024-111-04 024-027-09 024-027-09 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 318 11T"STREET 327 11T"STREET 32711T"STREET UNIT 101 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 230 231 232 024-027-09 024-105-09 024-105-06 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 1105 ORANGE AVE 406 11T"STREET 41211T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 234 234 234 024-014-15 024-014-15 024-014-15 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 60111 T"STREET 1106 ACACIA AVE 1108 ACACIA AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 235 236 236 024-091-03 024-043-04 024-043-04 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 614 11T"STREET 702 11T"STREET 1030 PALM AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 1' Nb IY-' 11111aBp3 dn-dod asodxa jaded paaA 009L5 a}eidwaj Q)AjaAV esn 1 009L5 oAtMAW ® i o;awl 6uole pua8 p lam►a�� slagel®lead Rse3 1�1s/is i Aa3AV-09-008-L 3wdn-dod pjogai al jaianar +uap seas � 009LS®AH3AV I!aegeb a1 zas!mn wor/Vane mmm a w e aan 3e e e zai da ap sua5 P ; 4 4 a , �a!ad a sap�e}sa�anb113 237 238 239 939-506-58 939-506-59 939-506-60 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 802 11T"STREET 808 11T"STREET 812 11T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 241 242 243 939-506-54 939-506-57 024-061-08 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 820 11T"STREET 828 11T"STREET 934 11T"STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 245 245 250 024-061-16 024-061-16 024-034-02 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 952 11T"STREET 954 11T"STREET 220 12T"STREET UNIT 1 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 250 250 250 024-034-02 024-034-02 024-034-02 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 220 12T"STREET UNIT 2 22012T"STREET UNIT 3 220 12T"STREET UNIT 4 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 250 250 250 024-034-02 024-034-02 024-034-02 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 220 12T"STREET UNIT 5 220 12T"STREET UNIT 6 220 12T"STREET UNIT 7 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 250 250 250 024-034-02 024-034-02 024-034-02 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 220 12T"STREET UNIT 8 22012T"STREET UNIT 9 220 12T"STREET UNIT 10 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 250 250 250 024-034-02 024-034-02 024-034-02 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 220 12T"STREET UNIT 11 220 12T"STREET UNIT 12 22012T"STREET UNIT 14 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 250 250 250 024-034-02 024-034-02 024-034-02 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 220 12T"STREET UNIT 15 220 12T"STREET UNIT 16 220 12T"STREET UNIT 17 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 250 250 250 024-034-02 024-034-02 024-034-02 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 220 12T"STREET UNIT 18 220 12T"STREET UNIT 19 220 12T"STREET UNIT 20 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 250 251 256 024-034-02 024-027-32 024-026-25 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 220 12T"STREET UNIT 21 312 12T"STREET 312 13T"STREET UNIT A HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 -OOS� f W1a6p3 do-dod asodxa jaded paaj 009LS ale!dwal®IGaAV esn 009L5 ® 1.�to f lc//� 01auil 6uole PuaB ® 'ty o��1 slagel®laad�(se3 i AM3AV-09-008-6 1 ,wdn-dod pjogau a(jalgAaj w8w8oje4� i 0965 2l3AV;!aege6 al zaslll;� woriGaAe Amm ap uge amgpe4 el a zolldoH op sues ® lad a sep�el sa:4e,bl;3 v 256 257 258 024-026-25 023-093-30 024-024-13 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 31213T"STREET UNIT B 817 13T"STREET UNIT 1/2 305 14T"STREET UNIT 1 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 258 258 258 024-024-13 024-024-13 024-024-13 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 305 14T"STREET UNIT 2 305 14T"STREET UNIT 3 305 14T"STREET UNIT 4 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 260 260 024-012-03 024-012-03 OCCUPANT OCCUPANT 618 14T"STREET 618 14T"STREET UNIT 1/2 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA 92648 N,J) r wla5P3 do-dod asodxa jaded pool ®096S a;eldwal®AaaAV ash 009L5 Q)At ASAW a 1 o;Bull 5uole PUBS ® 2l o� '� slagel®lead Ase3 A113AV-09-008-11, ,Wdn-dod pjogaa al jalgAaa Juawanieya r 009LS®AH3AV 1.!aege6 al zesll!}f1 wo3-Aiane'mmm a ul a aan 3e e e za!daa ap sues P 1 4 4 I . I V , salad a sali3e;sans. j� SAM DUNLAP DAVID BELARDES TERESA ROMERO GABRIELINO TONGVA CHAIR JUANENO CHAIR JUANENO P 0 BOX 86908 32161 AVENIDA LOS AMIGOS 31411-A LA MATANZA ST LOS ANGELES, CA 90086 SAN JUAN CAPISTRANO, CA 92675 SAN JUAN CAPIRSTRANO, CA 92675-2674 SONIA JOHNSTON JOYCE PERRY ANTHONY MORALES CHAIR JUANENO CHAIR 1UANENO CHAIR GABRIELINO TONGVA P 0 BOX 25628 4955 PASEO SEGOVIA P 0 BOX 693 SANTA ANA, CA 92799 IRVINE, CA 92612 SAN GABRIEL, CA 91778 LINDA CANDELARIA ANDREW SALAS CHAIR GABRIELINO TONGVA CHAIR GABRIELINO P 0. BOX 180 P 0. BOX 393 BONSALL, CA 92003 COVINA, CA 91723 1 2 3 HB Chamber of Commerce Orange County Assoc of Realtors Amigos De Bolsa Chica President Dave Stefanides President 2134 Main St Ste 100 25552 La Paz Road P 0 Box 1563 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Laguna Hills, CA 92653 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 5 7 8 Huntington Beach Tomorrow SCAG ETI Corral 100 President Richard Spicer Jean Kimbrell,Treasurer PO Box 865 818 West 7th, 12th Floor P 0 Box 2298 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Los Angeles, CA 90017 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 9 11 13 Environmental Board Chair Matrix Environmental Newland House Museum Kim Nicolson Attn Shawn Gauer,Senior Planner Pres, H B Historical Society 918 Palm Ave,Apt A 6701 Center Drive West#900 19820 Beach Blvd Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Los Angeles, CA 90045 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 14 17 19 Historic Resources Board Chair Kirsten Berg 0 C Ping & Dev Services Dept Duane Wentworth 18870 Kithira Circle Director 16291 Countess Drive,#108 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 P 0 Box 4048 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Santa Ana, CA 92702-4048 19 20 21 0 C. Planning & Develop Dept City of Costa Mesa City of Fountain Valley Michael Balsamo Planning Director Planning Director P 0 Box 4048 P 0 Box 1200 10200 Slater Ave Santa Ana, CA 92702-4048 Costa Mesa, CA 92628-1200 Fountain Valley, CA 92708 22 23 24 City of Newport Beach City of Westminster City of Seal Beach Planning Director Planning Director Planning Director P 0 Box 1768 8200 Westminster Blvd 211 Eighth St Newport Beach, CA 92663-8915 Westminster, CA 92683 Seal Beach, CA 90740 26 29 29 Department of Transportation, Dist 12 Fountain Valley Elem School Dist Fountain Valley Elem School Dist Maureen El Harake, Branch Chief Marc Ecker Rina Lucchese, Executive Assistant 3347 Michelson Dr Suite 100 10055 Slater Avenue 10055 Slater Avenue Irvine, CA 92612-8894 Fountain Valley, CA 92708 Fountain Valley, CA 92708 /V,6/` - W,a6P3 do-dod asodxa jaded paal @09LS a;eldwal @AmAV ash 1 ®09L5 p W /Cq(�j�� i %auy 6uole puns T 11 'L22 a?23 slagel®lead Ase3 i AH21AV-0"08-11. ,Wdn-dod piogai al aalanga ;uawaoJey:) r ®09LS H3"I!aege6 al zesluin uloY AJOAVAU M ap use aunypey el @ zalldaa Op �a5 i ®clad a Sallie}sauanb!z3 30 30 31 HB City Elementary School Dist. HB City Elementary School Dist. Ocean View School Dist Gregg Haulk, Superintendent John Archiald Attn• Cindy Pulfer, Admin Services 17011 Beach Blvd, Ste 560 17011 Beach Blvd,Ste 560 17200 Pinehurst Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 31 32 32 Ocean View School Dist Westminster School District Westminster School District Gustavo Balderas, Superintendent Christine Fullerton Richard Tauer,Superintendent 17200 Pinehurst Lane 14121 Cedarwood Avenue 14121 Cedarwood Avenue Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Westminster, CA 92683 Westminster, CA 92683 33 33 36 HB Union High School District HB Union High School District OC County Harbors, Beach& Parks Stephen Ritter Greg Plutko,Superintendent Dept. 5832 Bolsa Avenue 5832 Bolsa Avenue P 0. Box 4048 Huntington Beach,CA 92649 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Santa Ana, CA 92702-4048 40 41 41 Hearthside Homes Bolsa Chica Land Trust Bolsa Chica Land Trust 27285 Las Ramblas,Suite 210 5200 Warner Avenue, Ste 108 Joe Shaw, President Mission Viejo, CA 92691 Huntington Beach,CA 92649 5200 Warner Ave#108 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 44 45 46 Downtown Business Association HB Downtown Residents Association Gabrieleno/Tongva Tribal Council Mr Steve Daniels 412 Olive Ave#493 Chairperson 200 Main Street#106 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 PO Box 693 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 San Gabriel, CA 91778 46 49 54 Juaneno Band of Mission Indians Coastkeepers Karen Cadavona Acjachemen Nation Gary Brown Southern California Edison 3151 Airway Ave Suite F-110 Third Party Environmental Review 31411 La Matanza Street y 2244 Walnut Grove Ave,Quad 4C472A San Juan Capistrano, CA 92675-2625 Costa Mesa, CA 92663 Rosemead, CA 91770 54 Jenelle Godges,Region Manager Mary Adams Urashima Richardson Gray Local Public Affairs 19432 Pompano Lane,#110 415 Townsquare Lane,#208 Southern California Edison Huntington Beach,CA 92648 7333 Bolsa Avenue Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Westminster,CA 92683 57 Kathleen Belohovek 18849 Lister Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92646 /J /cal/9�/.� ®09LS® wia6P3 do-dod asodua jaded paaj 009LS a4eldwal®AGany as0 o4 cull 6uole puce ® 11 23 0 i=23 slage-1®laad AS83 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that on Monday, October 19, 2015 at 6 00 p m in the City Council Chambers, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, the City Council will hold a public hearing on the following planning and zoning item ❑ 1 NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 14-005/GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT NO. 08-009 (HISTORIC AND CULTURAL RESOURCES ELEMENT UPDATE) Applicant: City of Huntington Beach Request: ND: To analyze the potential environmental impacts associated with the adoption and implementation of the Historic and Cultural Resources Element update GPA: To update the Historic and Cultural Resources Element Also, information will be provided on which property owners have requested to be on the voluntary historic properties inventory On February 24, 2015, the Planning Commission held a public hearing on this item and recommended approval to the City Council Location: Citywide City Contact: Ricky Ramos NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the initial environmental assessment for Item #1 was processed and completed in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act It was determined that Item #1 would not have any significant environmental effect and, therefore, a negative declaration is warranted Negative Declaration No 14-005 is on file at the City of Huntington Beach Planning Division, 2000 Main Street, and is available for public inspection and comment by contacting the Planning Division, or by telephoning (714) 536- 5271 ON FILE A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Planning and Building Department, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public A copy of the staff report will be available to interested parties at the City Clerk's Office or online at http //www huntingtonbeachca qov on Thursday, October 15, 2015 ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above If you challenge the City Council's action in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at, or prior to, the public hearing If there are any further questions please call the Planning and Building Department at (714) 536-5271 and refer to the above items Direct your written communications to the City Clerk Joan L Flynn, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street, 2"d Floor Huntington Beach, California 92648 714-536-5227 http //huntmgtonbeachca qov/HBPublicComments/ C \Users\esparzap\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\BGU3Z50B\10-19-15 ND 14-005 GPA 08-009 (HCRE) docx