HomeMy WebLinkAboutCode Amendment 71-32 - Ordinance 1769 - Establish Equine Sta ff®damit ®f Pt6fication
State of 'California
County of Orange � ss (��
City of Huntington Beach !
George Farquhar, being duly sworn on oath, says: That he is a
citizen of the United States, over the age of twenty-one years.
That he' is the printer and publisher of the Huntington Beach
News, a weekly newspaper of general circulation printed and pub-
lished in Huntington Beach, California and circulated in the said
County of Orange and elsewhere and published for the dissemination
of local and other news of a general character, and has a bona fide 1 C:ate
subscription list of paying subscribers, and said paper has been
established, printed and published in the State of California, and 60
County of Orange, for at least one year next before the publication 9 �
of the first insertion of this notice; and the said newspaper is not
devoted to the interest of, or published for the entertainment of any
particular class, profession, trade, calling, race or denomination, or 0�14' A /�
any number thereof. Q4� '" /C,
The Huntington Beach New was adjudicated a legal newspaper ;r=G4S'i
of general circulation by Judge G. K. Scovel in the Superior Court
of Orange County, California August 27th, 1937 by order No. A-5931. :
That the CODE AMENDMENT 71-32 ,
Published HUptington Beach New;-7 nu e
of which the annexed is a printed copy, was published in said news- 22, 1972. =. ;- f
NOTICE OF 1`61346`t EARINO
CODE AMENDNIEf t-71-32
paper at least one issue NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN tilat a pub-
lic hearing will be held, by the City
Council of the City of Huntington Beach,
commencing from the 22nd day of June in the Council Chamber of the Civic
Center, Huntington Beach, at the hour
r�� of 7:00 P.M., or as soon thereafter as
19�_, June possible,. on Monday the 3rd day. of
and ending on the Z nd day Of July, f572; for the purpose of consider-
ing ,., 'ptoposed code amendment, ini-
tiateid by the City Planning Commission,
19 7!2 both days inclusive, and as often during said period and to ,establish° equine standards for com- I
times of publication as said paper was regularly issued, and in the mercial horse stables and require sub-
re be-
regular and entire issue of said ews a er proper, and not in a fore fora::Use Permit Application be-
g p P P fore the Planning Commission for such
supplement, and said notice was published therein on the following use.
dates, to-wit: All interested persons are invited to.
[��7enattend said hearing and express their
June 22, 19 I m opinions for or against said Code Amend-
ment. information may be obtained
from the Office of the City.Clerk.
DATED: 6/19/72
CITY OF.HUNTINGTON BEACH,
By: Paul C. Jones
City Clerk
�— Publisher
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 2 rci day of
June i9 72 .
Notary Public
Orange County, California
F,P OFT AS D
THOM D. WYLLiE
�
Notary� * Y Public-C.ii ;o,nia
"o Orange County
' My Commission
Exoiras
"� pN" September 12, 1974
Y ty of Huntington Beach 1 '
County of ®range ,
State of California
Affidavit of Publication
of GEORGE FARQUHAR
Publisher Huntington Beach News
Filed
Clerk
By
Deputy Clerk
J
FIE
�tY CLER
1T1.
OF 9112 Pioneer Drive
Huntington Beach, CA 92647
June 16, 1972
Mr. Alvin Cohen
Honorable Mayor of Huntington Beach
5th Street and Orange Avenue
Huntington Beach, California: 92648
Dear Mr. Cohen:
This letter is written in behalf of the hundreds of protestors
against the nwly proposed "Morse Ordinance" which is being sent to you
from the Planning Comiseion.
I am not against a workable ordinance, as I feel one is necessary.
However, the proposed ordinance is designed for one purpose, and that
is to "use the Horses out of Huntington Beach".
The most popular word these days is "PROGRESS", and this means more
Correctional Institutions to house the growing delinquency population,
more funds for a larger Police Force, Juvenile Officers and welfare
rolls.
Huntington Beach is attractive to future homebuyers because it offers
the largest variety of interests, of which, Horses are a great part.
#3. 949, page 1. 5.9490. "Horses not to be permitted to be led, or
ridden off the site of an established riding trail." Many of our
young people support their own horses by odd jobs and babysitting.
If they do not have special streets to ride from Ranch to Ranch for
their "Horse Shows" they will have to rent trailers for their horses
and this will cause a hardship for these young people and will lessen
the entrants in these shows.
Every campaigner whether for City, State or Federal Office he is
campaigning for, stresses the need for "Activities" for the teenagers
to curb the traffic in drugs, theft and immorality. Yet here our
Planning Commissioners are finding every way to make our city a
"Cement Jungle: with very limited space for healthful activities.
There are 2,000 Horses in Huntington Beach with most of the owners
young people. These young people show responsibility and maturity
in the cage and expense of their horses.
Isn?t it a shame that they, our Planning Commissioners are so blind
as to put their personal feelings before the welfare of our young people.
Sincerely,
Mrs. Joan M. Bush
THIRD DRAFT e STAFF REVIEW
]Proposed Code Amendment No. 72-1
�B.ean e 8, 1972
May _- Se neral.ly referred to as
vo 'STANDARDS-NON-COMMERCIAL"
EQUINE. -
That the f 1l:otAng: ti nges:. are proposed to the Huntington Beach
Ordinance 64d ntett . l�eing to add Article 963 Equine
Sg'aandard -Won--Cot el�, i�aI :to. the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code
Said "Artie le pt,6vi t�s.'fog: Oie keeping of equines in nondcoMmercial
ec}u1-n6. ficIl-it fes-Iii a:"mangier" ,Aich will not endanger the health,
peac.e4, =d--szfdty 'of .:he o nunity and which .will assure that
eq�nine Are : � f " in ;a. c1 n.and sanitary condition and not subm
j ect:ced � : s�'f f;� D rue: ty, or abuse. Said changes shall read
as, follows,,.
0 0 . 0 0 o!`'o 0 . 0,0 0
REPEALED. ($none)
'a 0 0 0 G 0 0 0 O'a 0 o-0 0-C.9'O.e 0 a o A 0 e e a a_ 0,0 a e a 0 a e 0 0 0 e 0. 0 0 0 a o o e 0 e 0 e 0 e 0 0 e 0 e 0 0 p a e 0 0 0
REN ET(ED o,' (none)
0 0 0 o'c.0 0.10 o ;a 0 0 0'0 0 0:0 0'0 0 0,0 0. o o.o.o a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 o a 0,0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o e e o 0 p p 0 • p o 0 o e o 0 o 0 e
AMENDED.- .'(none)
a 'o o a'o o o'o•o o o`o a o'o p 00 o o o o o.o o-o 0 o a o a o o o o 0 0 o o e e e o e o o e e e o e o 0 o e e o e o o e e e o o e
ADDED
ARTICLE 963
EQUINE STANDARDS=NON-COMKERCIAL
- (Special Rion=Commercial Developments)
S09630 Intent and Purpose: The intent of this Article is
to, establish standards for the keeping of equines on a.;
non-commercial basis and .in a manner which will not endanger the
tnealth9 peace., and safety. of the community and which will assure
that equines are kept in a clean and sanitary condition and not
subjected to, sufferingn cruiltyy .or abuses It is further the
intention of this Article to provide for the regular inspection
o-f non-corcial equine facilities to assure that good stable
:management" is a continuing practice. Such inspection is for the
"purpose. of minimizing fly production, reducing natural fly
attractants,, and to prevent the breeding of flies. 1
.3rd,
S,9631 Uses Permitted: Equines may be permitted in any
zoning district subject to an Administrative Review
Application before the Board of Zoning Adjustments and subject to
the provisions. delineated in this Article. Equines maintained
under this Article, are intended for private, non-commercial use.
:Equines are not,. permittred on vacant land as it is the intention
that the care of equines be on a continuing basis.
So9632 , Uses Prohibited: Commercial operations of any
nature are prohibited under this Article.
So9633 Yard Requirements : The yard requirements shall
pertain to all structures that relate to equines
including but not limited to stalls , corrals, arenas,' and fly-
tight manure bins. Exception: Pastures or grazing areas . All
such structures shall maintain a minimum distance of one hundred
( 100) feet from any dwelling unit other than a unit on. subject
property that is used for human habitations
All yard requirements shall be measured frogi the
existing property line, the ultimate right-of-way line as adopted
on the Master flan of Arterial Streets and Highways and any
amendments thereto, or any precise plan of a street or alley
alignment; whichever may be greater.
S. 9633. 1 Front: The front yard setback shall be a minimum of
fifty (50) feet.
So963302 Interior Side: The interior side yard setback shall
be a minimum of twenty-five (25) feet. Except: The
interior side yard setback shall be a minimum of fifty (50) feet
for one equine and one hundred (100) feet for two or more equines,,
3rd; 72-1 ; 6-8-72
from any property line that is coterminous with property that is
residentially zoned, residentially used, or master planned for
residential use.
So963303 Exterior Side: The exterior side yard setback shall
be a minimum of fifty (50) feet
'So963304 Rear: The rear yard setback shall be a minimum of
twenty-five (25) feet. Except: The rear yard
setback shall be a minimum of fifty (50) feet for one equine , one
hundred (100) feet for two or more equines from any property line
that is coterminous with property that is residentially zoned ,
residentially used or master planned for residential use.
Sa9634 Development Standards : The development standards
establish minimum and maximum requirements for general and specif_ i�
standards for maintaining equines as follows :
So963401 General Standards : Minimum building site:
n 10,000 square feet for two ( 2) or fewer equines . Fob
each additional equine over two ( 2) there shall be an additional
10,000 square feet provided.
So963402 Specific Standards :
to Corrals : There shall be a minimum size corral
of 288 square feet provided for each equine
except that a mare and foal may be corralled
together for a period not to exceed twelve (12)
months. Each equine corral shall meet the
following requirements :
3rd ; 72-1 ; 6-8-72
a. The minimum size corral shall be two hundred
eighty-eight square feet with a minimum
dimension of twelve (12) feet and shall have
a five (S) foot high fence.
bo Each corral shall be provided with a combin-
ation manger and feeder and a permanently
installed water system with automatic drink-
ing controls . The watering cup or drinking
device shall , at all times , .be under a
shaded area.
ca Each equine shall be provided with a minimum
of ninety-six (96) square feet of shelter
covering with a minimum dimension of eight
(8) feet . Shelters shall be sloped away
from corrals or rain-gutters , which lead to
the outside of the corral , shall be installedi.
d. Corral floors shall be graded to slope away
from the center of the corral .
2 . In all enclosures where equines are maintained ,
the land surface of such enclosures shall be
graded above the remaining land surface so as
to provide adequate drainage .
3 . Stallions shall be maintained in a manner that
will protect people and other animals .
3rd; 72- 1 ; 6-8-72
4 . Density of Equines : The maximum number of
equines permitted on any one site shall be four
(4) equines ; except that more than four (4)
equines may be kept on a site where such equine4
are owned by the person residing on such site.
.5 . Access : All public rights-of-way shall be
fenced and limited ingress and egress for vehicAes
and horses shall be provided.
6. Back-siphoning device shall be installed to
protect the public water supply. An approved
pressure vacuum breaker is recommended on the
water line serving the corrals . The vacuum
breaker should be at least twelve ( 12) inches
above the highest point of water usage or an
approved double-check valve may be acceptable .
S. 9635 Standards of Performance: It is the intent of these
standards to attain free circulation of air and
maximum exposure to sunlight for the purpose of improving sanitatiob.
Pipe fences are favored for maximum air circulation.
So963501 Fly and Insect Control : Fly and insect control shal.il
be diligently prracticed and , : ect to �r. :cle 312 .
A. Disposal of stable wastes shall follow one or more of these
suggestions :
1 . All thin layer spreading shall be subject to
the approval of the Orange County Health Officer.
2 . Immediate off-ranch delivery to farmers for
direct fertilizer use , or to a county landfill.
3rd9 72-196-8=72
for destruction.
30 Temporary placement shall not exceed forty-
_ r
eight 08)% hour.s in an .all-concrete three-walled
opera_ storage bin with removal to on-or off
ranch use or destruction on a suitable schedule.
Size of .sforage bin depends on projected daily"
volume ofwasteso Note- The size and .number
could be predicated on the number of allowed
.. horses,
B. Feed.managers or boxes shall not be placed near water sources
s:inc d spilled feed attracts flies and makes a good
breeding site , for f lies.
So963502 rodent Control: Rodent control shall be diligently
• practiced and the entire premises shall be kept in
an ot erly and sanitary manner to prevent possible rodent
infestation. - The following guidelines and criteria shall be
cofnside d in reviewing plans and in operation.
AD AI1 ' ry .graihs shall be stored in rodent proof metal containers
'a -`and: fiay shall be stored in a covered structure on a cement
slab or on a -rt$sed wood platform that maintains a minimum
cleatince of eighteen . (18) inches above the ground.
B ny_x;*k equipment, device, substance, or material shall be
s ore on ri�kffi or shelves at least twelve (12) inches above
the floor surfaced 'Tack room floors shall maintain a minimum
Clearance- of 9-ix - (6) inches above the ground.
y
A
G
So9635a3 Water Management: Special attention shall be given
:. � �,.
to. . ater `.sources because accumulation of manure,
.bedding, and/or feed with 'water are ideal for fly production. For
�" . effective reduction of .these-,fly=production sources , the following
9t
=' :guidelines are :provided:
Ao Anon=leaf v�l've` for all troughs, bowls, cups and other water
sources shall .be provided.
B.- Axitomatit .,valves, or sanitary drains if water-flow is con-
tiouous, acre needed equipment for large troughs or. cups<
Co U ,. ddock., and corrals, the owner should properly grade the
earth surface to- suit the master drainage plan so rain water
t� water-txoug4 overflow- does not form ponds.
Do Trequeoly...,remove stall bedding from underneath water cups.
: S.9635 Stable Sanitation: Good sanitary methods around
barns, stalls, paddocks, arenas, tack sheds, and
the `wntr`.'s.` u� tors are as important as manure man: ement o A
I=: q p g
general*. cleanup. program should accompany the manure management
system. teed .control near corrals, grater troughs , and surrounding
areas .around paddocks helps the sun to penetrate and allows the
movement of air Thisi helps to they the manure and reduce resting
places , for. certain .,flieso Controlling weed growth from open
waste water drains .reduces potential habitats for filth flies ,
gnatq P and 064quitoes o
So9635.,5 . . Dust Control: Continued dust control of the entire
premises shall be maintained and subject to
applicable provisions of Article 949 and Article 313.
Sa963506 Stable Management: The management of equine
.facilities shall meet the requirements of the Orange
County Health b,epartment to. keep environmental problems at a
mina
So9 .: Enforcement: The Orange County Health Officer in'
concert with Articles 312, 313, and 902 are herein
vested Frith_ the duty and authority to regularly inspect all
non-commercial -equine facilities within the City,, Prior to
Vecupane yp
a report and recommendation of the Orange County
Health Wicer shall be forwarded to the nirector of Building and
safety. Certificate of Occupancy. shall be subject to the approval
of the Ore County Health Officer.
r:
It
/ MJ14TINGTON IAXE RIDERS
MMINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA
July 2, 1972
The Honorable City Council
City of Huntington Beach
City Tull
Huntington Beach, California
RM; Proposed Code Amendments Yos. 71-32, 72.1 and 72-8
Gentlemen:
First, I want to express the appreci.atift of almost 100 families who
are represented by the Huntington Lake Riders for your action on
June 19 in adopting the Preliminary Plan for Reeraational Trails.
The City of Huntington Beach elan be proud of the fact that a aombina.tion
trail plan for eyeling, hiking and riding has been worked out so that
those setivities can be p=su.ed by residents of the City.
The points I would like to bring to your attention regarding the
proposed ordinznees on equestrian standards are more significant
because of your action two weeks ago than they would have 'been had a
trail plan not been adopted.
Those of us who are involved in equestrian activities understand,
appreciate and stronr :y approve of the establishment of appropriate
standards for keeping; horses in our City.
The proposed code amendments on equestrian standards before you now
eoneern the members of the Huntington bake Riders for basically three
reasons:
1. For all practical purposes, they seem likely to eliminate the
possibility that a resident of the City would be able to keep
horses for his own family's use on his own property;
2. The combination of stringent commercial stable standards
(most of which seen like desirable requirements) with an
indefinite time period for wrieh such use would be permitted
raises a question as to the probability of any commercial
stables existing under the proposed standards; and
3. The establishment of the proposed req�ula.tions in the absence
of trail linkages between major stables or stable concentrations
would effeetively eliminate much of the meaningful equestrian
activity now being carried on, particularly for the children
and youthful riders.
I would like to emphasize again: we are not opposed to stronger
requirements. We are only opposed to requla.tions whitish wov_ld have the
effeet of eliminating the opportunity to carry on equestrian activities
In Huntington Bea,eh.
Funtington Beach City ;o-anell, July 2, 1872
Page 2
If it is your desire that theb-oportunity for equestrian activity
remain as part of the diverse recreational choices available to the
residents of Huntington Beach, we urge that more time be devoted
to certain sections of -oronosel amendments to ensure the aetual
preservation of equestAan' facilities.
I know you are pleted in the -position of trying to Satisfy a very
diverse public interest in the best way you can. We think It would
be inappropriate to attempt to negotiate specific changes in the
proposed amendments here in this public hearing. Instead, I would
like to suggestthat this matter be referred back to the Planning
Co=ission for further work sessions to reconvile the regulations
governing equine standards and the equestrian trail system so that
they effes' tively reinforee ereh other.
Nffort4 by 'both the elected officials and citizenry of Y-antington
Bepah to eaT)Italize on the significant assets of this P.rsa have
been both significant and effective. 'do ask nov for an opportanity
to participate in carrying that record further.
In viow of the qvertio ne that still remain about the practical
Dossibility of continued equestrian activity In our city, T
resneetfully request that this proposal and the matter of additional
local equestrian trail linkages be referred bake to the Planning
Commission for further study and report. I and my follow elv-b
members offer our ,,!.,nergies In working with the, Planning Commission
and Its staff towakd the end of creating- improved - and eontinv.ed
equestrian opportunitie.e? In the City of Huntington Beach.
Sincerely yours,
Huntington Lake Riders, Inc.
Publish 6/22/72
PUBLIC HEARING SET
Postcards_..----.
• FOR:...........---------((-��--''•---------•--•-•---•-
_ -3�-
..............0 ........ """" "' NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
CODE A1+ WNtEIiPr 71-32
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that a public hearing will be held by the
City Council of the City of Huntington Beach, in the Council
Chamber of the Civic Center, -Huntington Beach, at the hour of
7t00 P.M or
soon thereafter as possible, on Monday
the day of July , 19 72 , for the purpose of
considering a proposed code amendment, initiated by the City Planning
commission, to establish equine standards for commercial horse stables
and require submittal for a Use Permit Application before the
Planning Commission for such use.
All interested persons are invited to attend said hearing and
express their opinions for or against said Code Amendment
Further information may be obtained from the Office of the City
Clerk.
6/19/72
DATED: CITY OF- HUNTINGTON BEACH
By: Paul C . Jones
City Clerk
City Clerk
City of Huntington Beach
The Huntington Aeach Planning Commission, at their regular/adj-auvned
meeting held Z- , recommended
l o of
If approval has been recommended, the City Council will be required to
hold a public hearing on this matter. Although there is a 10 day appeal
period, we suggest that the matter be set for the earliest possible City
Council meeting, because the purpose of any appeal is to have a hearing
before the City Council and this is already being accomplished. We
further suggest that you not accept any appeal, as it will serve no purpose.
If approval has been recommended other than as requested, the City Council
will be required to hold a public hearing on this matter. However, there
is a possibility that the Planning Commission's decision will be appealed;
therefore, we suggest that publication be held off until the 10 day
appeal period has expired.
If denial has been recommended, the City Council may summarily deny the
request. However, we suggest that the matter not be scheduled on the
City Council agenda until the 10 day appeal period has expired.
A copy of the Planning Department legal notice, enc—a=+ts-t�of=ownerr�s-=o-f-
pe -with#n90e =a€ he—sue, a��--will be submitted upon your
request.
The applicant in this matter is
(Address)
(Telephone) •
Kenneth R. Reynolds,
Planning Director
By 6 O AO
--7
i�
Number of E-cerpts Blond
Publish Once
f
LEGAL NOTICE
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
CODE AMENM4MT No 71-32
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that a public hearing will be held
by the City Planning Commission of the City of Huntington
Beach for the purpose of considering �g®�o��d cods a�ndm�n� go
establish equine attandards for commercial horroe stablem and require
i
submittal for a Uge permit Application before the Planning Commission
for such use.
r
a
'Daid hearing will be held at the hour of 7*00 PeMo
9
-,n ,Dunce 6p 1972 , in the Council Chamber of the Civic Center,
—in tington T:F ach, California, en 5th Street between Main Street
1
=,nd Orange hvenue.
All int , rested persons- ai,t• inv.Lted to attend saki hearing
and expresc their opinions for or against the proposed
Code Amendment
Further information may be. obtained from the City
P13nning Department.
To1 ,�.,hone No 536-5271
DATED thi:- 25th t1,1V i' may, 1972
CITY PLANNING COMMISSION
By
K.A. Reynolds
Secretary
. f
O
Hunfinston Beach p�aWns COMMSSB®n
P.O. SOX 990 CALIFORNIA 92546 t;
June 19, 1972
TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL
FROM: Planning Commission
RE: Code Amendment No. 71-32
ATTN: David D. Rowlands , City Administrator
Paul Jones, City Clerk
Gentlemen:
Transmitted herewith is a copy of Code Amendment
No. 71-32. Said amendment proposes to establish
equine standards for commercial horse stables
and require submittal of a Use Permit application
before the Planning Commission.
By a majority vote, the Planning Commission, at
its June 6, 1972 meeting, approved Code Amendment
No. 71-32 and recommends approval by your Honorable
Body.
The State Planning Act requires that a public
hearing be held after which the Code Amendment may
be adopted by ordinance.
Respectfully submitted,
A-,Z41,
K.A. Reynolds
Secretary
Encl: Code Amendment No. 71-32
KAR:vm
eAJ
FIFTH DRAFT - STAFF REVIEW
Proposed C::de Amendment No. 71-32
June 8 , 1972
May be generally referred to as :
"EQUINE STANDARDS-COMMERCIAL"
That the following changes are proposed to the Huntington Beach
Ordinance Code:. The intent being to add Article 949 Equine
Standards to the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. Said Article
provides for the keeping of equines in commercial equine stables
in a manner which will not endanger the health, peace , and safety
of the community and which will assure that equines are kept in a
,clean and sanitary condition and not subjected to suffering,
cruelty, or abuse. Said changes shall read as follows :
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
REPEALED: (none
, )
RENUMBERED: (none)
AMENDED: (none)
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
ADDED:
ARTICLE 949
EQUINE STANDARDS-COMMERCIAL
(Special Commercial Developments)
-S . 9490 Intent and Pur ose: The board and care of equines
is hereby declared to be a commercial enterprise of
a recreational nature and a luxury in an urban environment. The
,intent of this Article is to establish standards for the keeping
of equines in a manner which will not endanger the health, peace ,
land safety of the community and which will assure that equines
are kept in a clean and sanitary condition and not subjected to
suffering, cruelty, or abuse nor permitted to-be led or ridden
off the site other than onto an established riding trail . It is
further the intention of this Article to provide for the regular
,inspection of equine stables to assure that good stable management '
is a continuing practice. Such inspection is for the purpose of
minimizing fly production, reducing natural fly attractants , and
to prevent the breeding of flies.
5th; i ,_ 32 ; 6-8-72
I
S. 9491 Uses Permitted: The following uses may be permitted
i
for a period to be determined by the Planning
Commission subject to the approval of a Use Permit Application by
the Planning Commission:
A. The following uses where such use is adjacent
to an established equestrian trail or where a
minimum riding area of one (1) acre for every
I ten (10) equines is provided:
1. Animal and Convalescent Stables
i
2. Commercial Equine Stables
3. Livery and Boarding Stables
4. Private Club Riding Stables
5. Public Equine Stable
6. Rental Stables
7. Riding Academy
B. The following uses where a time limit and
frequency is determined as a part of the
approval:
1. Equitation Show
2. Rodeo
S . 9492 Yard Requirements : The yard requirements shall
pertain to all structures including but not limited ,
to stalls , corrals , arenas and fly-tight manure bins , except:
pastures , grazing areas , access roads , and watchman' s quarters ..
i
All such structures shall maintain a minimum of three. hundred (300)
feet from any property that is used, zoned or master planned for
residential use.
s
i
5th; 71-32 ; 6-8-72
All yard requirements shall be measured from the
existing property line , the ultimate right-of-way line as adopted
I
i
on the Master Plan of Arterial Streets and Highways and any
t
amendments thereto , or any precise plan of a street or alley
i
alignment; whichever may be greater.
'S. i9492. 1 Front: The front yard setback shall be a minimum
of fifty (50) feet.
S.,9492. 2 Interior Side : The interior side yard setback shalli
be a minimum of twenty-five (25) feet.
S. 9492.3 Exterior Side: The exterior side yard setback
shall be a minimum of fifty (50) feet.
! S . 9492.4 Rear: The rear yard setback shall be a minimum of
twenty-five (25) feet.
Se9493 Development Standards : The development standards
establish minimum and maximum requirements for
general and specific standards for maintaining equines as follows : r
S. 9493. 1 General Standards :
1 . Minimum building site: two (2) acres
2 . Minimum riding area: shall be one (1) acre
for every ten (10) horses where stable does not
abut an established riding trail.
I
3 . Minimum frontage: One hundred (100) feet
4 > Maximum building height: twenty-five (25) feet
: �( _ / 62
5t.,; 71-32; 6-8-72
5 . Landscaping and Irrigation: Landscaping and
� I
irrigation system shall be subject to approval
f
of the Planning Department and provided in the
following manner:
j
a. A five (5) foot planter shall be provided
along the front property line.
b. A five (5) foot planter with perimeter treei
and shrubs shall be provided along the side
and rear property lines.
c. A permanent irrigation system shall be
provided.
6 . Sign: The minimum development standards for
all signs shall conform to Article 976.
7 . Parking: The minimum development standards for
all vehicle parking shall conform to Article 97%,
S. 9493. 2 Specific Standards :
1 . Corrals , racks and stalls : A1.1 corrals , racks
and stalls shall conform to the following
requirements :
a. Equine corral: - There shall be one',.corral '
provided for each equine. Except: A mare
I and foal may be corralled together for a
= period not to. exceed twelve (12) months
I
and corrals may be designed for more than
one equine provided that all standards shall
be multiplied by the number of equines .
Each equine corral shall meet the following ,
requirements :
5tn; 71-32; 6-8-72
f1) The minimum size corral shall be two
hundred eighty-eight (288) square feet
with a minimum dimension of twelve (12)
I
i
feet and shall have a minimum five (5)
foot high fence.
2) Each corral shall be provided with a
combination manger and feeder and a
permanently installed water system with
automatic drinking controls . The
watering cup or drinking device shall ,
at all times , be under a shaded area.
3) Each equine shall be provided with a
minimum of ninety-six (96) square feet
of shelter covering with a minimum
dimension of eight (8) feet. Shelters
shall be sloped away from corral center '
or rain-gutters , which lead to the
outside of the corral , shall be installed;'
4) Corral floors shall be graded to slope
away from the center of the corral .
b. Box Stall : A box stall is optional. and may
be provided in lieu of equine corrals . Box
stalls shall be a minimum size of one
hundred forty-four (144) square feet and
shall maintain a minimum dimension of
twelve (12) feet. �.
T
71-32; 6-8-72 � ,•
c. Wash Rack: There shall be one wash rack
provided for every thirty-five (35) equines ,"
but in no case shall there be less than
one ( 1) wash rack. Each wash rack shall
meet the following requirements :
1) 'The minimum size wash rack area shall
be six (6) feet wide and eight (8) feet ,
long
2 ) Each wash rack shall be provided with a
permanent watering system.
3) Each wash rack shall be constructed wit
I
a concrete slab flooring.
i
I 4) Each wash rack shall be connected to an
approved sewerage system.
2. In all enclosures where equines are maintained,
the land surface of such enclosures shall be
graded above the remaining land surface.
3. Exercise rings shall maintain a minimum dimensionn
of thirty (30) feet.
4. Arenas shall maintain a minimum of 10,000 square
feet with a minimum dimension of eighty (80) feet.;
5. Stallions shall be maintained in a manner that
will protect people and other animals .
6. Density of Equines : The maximum number of
equines shall be twenty-five (25) equines per acre:
i
7. Public Toilets : Public toilets for each sex i
shall be provided. NOTE: Portable outdoor
sanitation facilities shall not be permitted
I _
of
i
i
5**1-32 ; 6-8-72
I �
l
except they may be permitted for equitation eve*js
8 . Storage and Tack Areas : Storage and tack areas
. shall be provided and designated. on 'the plot pl4.ri
i
9 . Trash, solid waste disposal areas , and dumpster�'
to be designated and conveniently located with
an all-weather road access provided.
10. Access : All public rights-of-way shall be
fenced and limited ingress and egress for
vehicles and horses shall be provided.
I
11. Watchman Quarters : One mobilehome unit or
equivalent for the watchman quarters shall be
provided and subject to Planning Department
approval.
12. Lighting for rodeos , stables , and horse shows
shall be such that it is directed onto the site .
13. Back-siphoning device shall be installed to
i
protect the public water supply. An approved
pressure vacuum breaker is recommended on the
i
water line serving the corrals . The vacuum
breaker should be at least twelve (12) inches
above the highest point of water usage or an
approved double-check valve may be acceptable.
14. Security lighting shall be provided and all
utilities shall be underground. - — —
® O
5th; 2 ; 6-8-72
I
5. 9494 Standards of Performance: It is the intent of these ,
standards to attain free circulation of air and max
jimum exposure to sunlight for the purpose of improving sanitation.
Pipe fences are favored for maximum air circulation.
S. 9494. 1 Fly and Insect Control : Fly and insect control shall,
be diligently practiced and subject to Article 312.
A. Disposal' of stable wastes shall follow one or more of these
i
suggestions :
1. All thin layer spreading shall be subject to the approval
of the Orange County Health Officer.
2. Immediate off-ranch delivery to farmers for direct fertil-
izer use, or to a county landfill for destruction.
3. Temporary placement shall not exceed forty-eight (48) hours;
I
I
in an all-concrete three-walled open storage bin with
removal to on- or off-ranch use or destruction on a suit-
able schedule. Size of storage bin depends on projected
daily volume of wastes . NOTE: The size and number could
be predicated on the number of allowed horses.
B. Feed mangers or boxes shall not be placed near water sources
since damp spilled feed attracts flies and makes a good breed- '
ing site for flies .
IS. 9494. 2 Rodent Control : Rodent control shall be diligently
practiced and the entire premises shall be kept in
an orderly and sanitary manner to prevent possible rodent infesta- '
tion. The following guidelines and criteria shall be considered
' i
in reviewing plans and in operation:
A. All dry grains shall be stored in rodent proof metal containers',
and hay shall be stored in a covered structure on a cement slab
or on a raised wood platform that maintains a minimum clearance. .
of eighteen ( 18) inches above the ground. .
B. Any tack equipment, device, substance, or material shall be
i
stored on racks or shelves at least twelve (12) inches above
the floor surface. Tack room floors shall maintain a minimum
clearance of six (6) inches above the ground.
iS. 9494. 3 Water Management: Special attention shall be given i,
to water systems because accumulation of manure,
;bedding, and/or feed with water are ideal for fly production. For
effective reduction of these fly-production sources , the following
guidelines are provided:
A. A non-leak valve for all troughs , bowls , cups , and other water.
�J sources shall be provided. '
B. Automatic valves , or sanitary drains if water-flow is continu-
ous , are needed equipment for large troughs or cups .
C. In paddock and corrals , the developer should properly grade
the earth surface to suit the master drainage plan so rain
water or water-trough overflow does not form ponds .
D. Frequently remove stall bedding from underneath water cups .
S. 9494.4 Stable Sanitation: Good sanitary methods around
� J
barns , stalls , paddocks , arenas , tack sheds, and
the owner' s or watchkeeper' s quarters are as important as manure
management. A general cleanup program should accompany the manure
management system. Weed control near stables , corrals , water
,troughs , and surrounding areas around paddocks helps the sun to � '
penetrate and allows the movement of air. This helps to dry the
,manure and reduce resting places for certain flies . Controlling
weed growth from open waste-water drains reduces potential habitats
g P
for filth flies , gnats , and mosquitoes .
IS. 9494. 5 Dust Control: Continued dust control of the entire
j premises shall be maintained and subject to Article
I313. The following methods for dust control shall be followed:
I
A. A method for light water sprinkling of arenas and exercise pens'
shall be provided.
B. Chemical control of dust may be permitted. i
C. Perimeter trees and shrubs shall be required for dust control.
iS. 9494. 6 Stable Management: The management of commercial
j
horse stables shall meet the requirements of the
Orange County Health Department to keep environmental proE)lems at
a minimum.
S. 9495 Enforcement : The Orange County Health Officer in
concert with Articles 312, 313 , and 902 are herein
,rested with the duty and authority to regularly inspect all
I�ommercial horse stables within the City. Report and recommendation,
by the Orange County Health Officer shall be forwarded to the
' Director of Building and Safety. I
0 ,f) F rra
I,
RECEIVED
C{ ;'1T%Or CALF.
tiUNTtf�{,
7681 Danube Drive
{ 16 : 3 2 Huntington Beach, CA 92647
June 15, 1972
The Honorable Mayor of Huntington Beach
City Council Clerk
5th Street and Orange Avenue
Huntington Beach, California 92648
Dear Honorable 1-layor:
RE: Code Amendment No. 71-32, 72-8, 72-1
This letter is in behalf of the hundreds of protesters against
the new proposed "horse ordinance" which is being sent to you from
the Planning Comission. Several horsemen were on the committee to
draft the new proposed "Horse Ordinance", but none of their suggestions
were accepted.
There are '§everal" requirements that MUST be changed. I am attaching
A.C. Marion' s letter sent to the Planning Commission stating the three
unworkable standards that must be changed. I attended the Public Hearing
with other interested horse, lovers and objected to these three (3) un-
workable and unrealistic requirements, but as Roger Slate said, "I didn't
like the motor bikes and I got ridof them". Then mark Porter commented,
"I'm sorry we gave Williams! Stable a permit" . Mr. Bazil asked "Why"?
and Porter said because of the "hundreds" of complaints. Mr. Bazil said
those hundreds of complaints were from only one family across the street.
It was quite obviou.d with the "uncalled for" remarks among the commissioners
they had any interest in developing workable, realistic standards.
What are the unworkable ones? #1. S. 91�92 Yard, Requirements. "All
interior and rear setbacks shall maintain 300 feet from any proporTty, etc. "
With this setback a 2 acre commercial stable must require at least 10 -
12 acreas idiich 8 to 10 would be unusable. Within 5 years none of the
commercial or nor.-commercial stables within Huntington Beach would be able
to meet these standards unless some real estate. contractors with money
would be able to drop $7 ,0 00 or more.to improve the stables.
#2. 5.94011. "The follovang uses for a period not to exceed 5 years
subject to the approval of a use Permit Application by the Planning Com-
mission. " With, all the landscaping requirements, yard requirements
operating standards, setbacks, this 5 year maximum length of variance
is unrealistic to assume that an investment like this can be written off
within 5 years, thus all stables will be closed.
Honorable Mayor of Huntington Beach
Page -2-
June 15, 1972
#3 . 949, page 1. 5.9 90. "Horses not to be permitted to be led,
or ridden off the site of an established riding trail." There are no
riding trails between the stables from HuntinE.,ton Beach Ranch to li illiams'
Ranch to A.C. Marion's Ranch to Rex Reynold' s Rance vrhere they hold horse
and pony shows for children and adults. So none of the children can go.
Why am I writing this letter? I do not own a stable, or two acres
of land in Huntington Beach so I can board YY ponies, but I have two
girls who train their ponies, ride them, and shove them in horse shoves.
It will be me, and other horse omners, -rho will be paving high unreasonable
costs for the stables. Among all the boys and girls rho own horses, or
ponies, the daily grooming, and hours and hours of training for a horse,,
shot,, you will find none of them finding time to use drugs that are peddled
within the bounderies of Huntington Beach.
At the Public Hearing, no considerations were given to these objections.
Iffe realize there must be a horse ordnance, but not one so unrealistic
and unworkable that all stables must go. We are not asking for you to
oppose a horse ordinance, but only request that a REASONABLE horse ord�nce
be passed so we can continue to have good recreation for our children.
Sinc e1 fir,
Mrs. Robert (Lucille) Horner
lh
Rr
W` _ b MAY 31 1�72
PLAwtiING DEPT.
A. C. MARION
INVESTMENTS
P.0.BOX 108 18892 MAIN STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH
(714)847-1246 CALI FORMA 92648
May 31, 1972
The Planning Commission
City of Huntington Beach
Civic Center, 5th St. and Orange Ave.
Huntington Beach, California 92648
Gentlemen-:
Having served on the committee that helped draft the new proposed "Horse
Ordinance", and attending 2 study sessions, I feel compelled to write
this letter.
At the risk of sounding like a "broken record" I think this is an excellent
basic ordinance, maybe the best in the state. However with these 3 minor
changes, made in the study session, I think the whole ordinance has been
destroyed:
#1. The 5 year maximum length of variance. With the building and
landscaping requirements in this ordinance it would require an invest-
ment of $20,000r3.�,000, excluding the cost of the land. It is unreal-.
istic to s� that-" investment like this can be written off in
such a short time.
#2. The 30q!ssetback, wh_ ere adjacent to R1 or master planned R1. I
would think with the proposed landscaping and operating standards
would preclude such a setback. With this setback a 2 acre commercial
stable would require 10 to 12 acres, of which 8 to 10 would be unusable.
#3. On the non-commercial section. We were under the impression that
we were to develop standards to allow .the keeping of private horses
in R1 areas. Here again, with the addition of the 100' setback it
would require about 40,000 sq.ft., or almost one acre of land to keep
2 horses.
In closing, I would say if the above 3 conditions are included in the
proposed ordinance, you are saying that there will be no horses in this
city.
Very truly,4o0A�-,'r
Marion
ACM/lr
' ����'�t�•lFD
• rfi'�`Ji= e ��
HUNT1k�C.� , r �,:,;�, ���• 9112 Pioneer Drive
Huntington Beach, CA 92647
June 16, 1972
Mr. Alvin Cohen
Honorable Mayor of Huntington Beach
5th Street and Orange Avenue
Huntington Beach, California 92648
Dear Mr. Cohen:
This letter is written in behalf of the hundreds of protestors
against the newly proposed "Horse Ordinance" which is being sent to you
from the Planning Commission.
I am not against a workable ordinance, as I feel one is necessary.
However, the proposed ordinance is designed for one purpose, and that
is to "phase the Horses out of Huntington Beach`".
The most popular word these days is "PROGRESS", and this means ,more
Correctional Institutions to house the growing delinquency population,
more funds for a larger Police Force, Juvenile Officers arid. welfare
rolls.
Huntington Beach is attractive to future homebuyers because it offers
the largest variety of interests, of which, Horses are a great part.
#3. 949, page 1. 5.9490. "Horses not to be permitted to be ledt or
ridden off the site of an established riding trail." Many of our
young people support their own horses by odd jobs and babysitting.
If they do not have special streets to ride from Ranch to Ranch for
their "Horse Shows" they will have to rent trailers for their horses
and this will cause a hardship for these young people and will lessen
the entrants in these shows.
Every dampaigner whether for City, State or Federal Office he is
campaigning for, stresses the need for "Activities" for the teenagers
to curb the traffic in drugs, theft and immorality. Yet here our
Planning Commissioners are finding every way to make our city a
"Cement Jungle: with very limited space for healthful activities.
There are 2,000 Horses in Huntington Beach with most of the owners
young people. These young people show responsibility and maturity
in the care and expense of their horses.
Isnit it a shame that they, our Planning Commissioners are so blind
as to put their personal feelings before the welfare of our young people.
Sincerely,
2,, z
Mrs. Joan M. Bush
-_ _ _. _ _
,I. t�
,�l :`t 9 3.t•„Q7.' ,"'`,':;i •.T.c;^ *5 `�':C y, .�y�.. i�te';•.t:.eLir.E•a i^ r,t_.'S:r ..>, .xr _
-� ";ia yYe 7. k ,,.,y..-rr..2 t"z' ,,,¢ac .rd'> -
p -?,.,,., ..SNfw i�`A., .re$p, }g'. ,3;p -4`�t. "*`•.t .1., tk,'.. 6..:.'.`. „�`
:>t:+' ,.gk r ,�•Fo, `ter„ >.y�"::'i{-., `iJ':.;-.'?:<' � � J� ;-�,.- _p:.::<,.
4.. S. 1 1";.-
"'V
F F" fit
K Mara',
e` �.,r"r. ";t? .. }�':�` -•s.::'..'...: r ,.s, - _ _ psi=o`.
_ � - '�;�-go-
Cam. .y:t'"�":� k�:
,'fir" %x�'=`' 'y:.. s .,
J
- -5Y'.stf .>.- J rk x,...nle _awn,r',;y,` i.�,.':',t"." •: �:t._ =•e°:.
Pv.f., k.n .tf%=Y.. ^YS
h �"
r-, 2 t
-. �'
{ �„� �3
} �y ew. ��•4'r3+
T
'3
irk'} p� -
4.•
5 ��
-,.+, r. .7 "lT **}yyyw; ,.c+, .Y'de L�3 �.',:� "ai', v.l h, �.
`Yi 4
• ..PY'
-t h,fi=f.' rs9'i 1i `f•#•'. f5 •;',�<^`!>�6,.^'�'-;C ,�����+}3e. y4'��r i �.,yy i�`.k`J Y' y'M - 3>i'4:'"-• ,�,
�Iv
3 ',u'P^;',��`Yt �7? 3's_,r •.':,�u1 (,r '?ry »• = m �d'za•"-11 t;! ,t+._ 3My a-- t� ,a c .r
* U � _
:;",'`";;# ls1l i wx .Tl'° Y� rizeF,\.�?f_"g,":— ,. z -:..��„�-:�'.&?c`-5€'.s L�,,�! 'tnx-. -fi: -f.- 1,, t
.�- ,•- •�' 4R -3'F, .Ta'" .'x9 •3a;., M::`a�_i."' •c"•.r'�§au,`, tt ,r Y:. �' ;! _ .i ,� fie'S -e 'ti ,i
.�'-i t I u _ tdl � ,,,. ,.--' .t" �,�'O-;+r,g. ���`_ ', r'g'«'i?;, •�,P:,%,•,,- �. t. Ai4. t a j -x:- �;Y .:� �: -
rr _x -a. -r' t :+ Gt�. ;1,�',.,�,r.Tt,.t '"<S•3 .�Sw d.�"y,"�'4" awt 'V4b�s .i r t t, ,.T e.
3 ".: `. °-. '£ w;,c r A,"s >o- y.':: 4'K's, ,yz�,.,.4 `g •d:.k'4, 'o _,,y. �'`'}t..8r 4, c t'. E •k° at�'{h!-S .rt.. � •.:' .�-"`'s #��E,'9•mi'�'.o. 5:�:"`{,, r, •'Si•.. .:;.�i,'•`"y 5 ,"w. Mon - eJ. ,3*:ti,. :w:,..
Lky d�.i"t`zt„ix1. . L �,..;.T.;rrr 'i..x;, '.r "5�', -`'F'• X.'�.'r. .:r-','.x�, x.s .r,,.. --i.,
..>;�<._ t,. -n.,., S -'r' wyryl .,' =,'P: x�.L.a 'i ,.n,.,k-:r sb''` i1.sry "-x� afi.>.+ _ _ <� 4"t:J .,iz":,,,;
: e•:,'+'.; ., u:r FZ w::t' `e.C�„�Sr57 ys,.•a-r os'r; .0�...,ta •P i�+e c.. s,Y�`"t"" ."..24` _ _ :�..
�i . t,.,a F,-' .,'?t ,,. w ..uy }x.,: :',.J•03, .,ta ," ,;.<i ,ice': - _ r. `y'.v x`:''' § _
.,,t, H13� ";;,'i,k. r^ •'r>;d'w'^:;��&ikf?` .-<• r.'�,_ g g ::}„ ;..n;+:' !`4:�';��.,4. s >e, _ y '.s
-,a't "''y ;:a a y.:r, .a'...A,;�, -s. �"'-t,:r:;2't-"w,�k tt'" "y"xj', -�ta",�n w` r -a..Fr c"' r s *> .--�, >,' ',; � r:
.,? sc .,�., .. ;.a'r "°.n'r { fr h..a ,> -TF."• .fl6',;'c:` - .>;�_ -.ti .:i y ,¢
t a.r. .-Y y r, `,N___ t:. ,Yn�,'s•zl r" ^' y.Yfi{-'.a: ., rZr.,d, Pre.7^ y x ..�✓ry^ ^..N'.t. L-
"sr .,d„. °`•" .!Jf: xt .x � ,:':27: ..,f" ':lfi ik'S -r'„-,v'rvia J -'r`''ti`� ,r .Vtav . Q11 1 G I s
,r i y. k-1•c ,a z,,,. i ,.e^%,yi ,k '?' .4 E _.I " r: al
,,' C:. x. .4,. _. . } r,�<S` t' '.`✓:!a._' ,, -wk ,`yam£,- a _ .� .:t'- } q 1 �''+ S, 4
-Fr„ 2 a. ... N"'n" Sw 'P .K„<u'v a4..w*'�;��a=;r+'",,. ".i ;:;3, _ ;a `Qi�F 'U3. 1,tr. .r�� LL�+.1-13. o
_ r , k" o ',, r t E, r 'rg . 1-1 F , k" < rya r !
*.I:t,� �a�as., �,y;r; -sf"` + a �',•ey C '_ .;?`t- -ce'a.,?rt.u •'�' i"4`''a,,.i;,'�,'`•�`.,r < RS-;�3. �„€.`-,r�y,+.;°,�:�.:;a'r% '� - d ,,fie > _
s'<� t fig.h: `' L,<;5�_. ,k`-. -9 9 '"�', _ k>, .` S`S3>.t A f 4 Sp C, b Ir ,r',`". '"t
Ott rs,; _ i'n" "'- •d"' t
�' { '�:'Fxt, s."ro. ``s�: ,.�,�',,,'a-.'"< Al.$'4t t' .Yi+-*y,. ,. '"�'„ ? ��` a""'t- ,,- `'" esf 't -� .. � �1.1 5a
=< i.�;%''r `,+!: ,' }�y, . ¢¢ ry �y�a i'.rr. .jµ -r`:t z c_: x� ;L:, '.f:i/ d s ` 'q - S "¢ .; '":"`,
y ;z`'- �, `-,, .V`3,L �.'V c`�n'�,` �,. "• •xrY -.r -" t`Ps "� ,s '^ .5;�' Y :Y ., •Atrx, 'j;
z'�.�'�" "'.u? >?".�:': .a,<t r. ya ,c,. .t :.•„— r :'.^:r..e;: :. ,`�- .t_y u-,u- -#- «%�'` ""' _ •'•'e
, P. _ rr Q �^ ?,5 rid,:' .
-rY- d. -�i s� :r>w•,.,r,_--'4," >,N u .,at;n '...p S.11,,� ?i�:�-�'^. ,�.- y- 'Y ;=^�,.4L,,,,>,..
'at '"",';, b. .y ,. 'L€"^`:tS.Y><-%,- "'*`: `;�.sy•L #„•:a'.. .:-Yc.+ ::t» a- ,..}.4
- - y a i t , � ��.y=# ,,.t�iS ,.,i,.x. "`4,r.',-x ?l •v,;, -9 _ $•?.,,,i, , - ��-
:a#91:�,-.. 1 4Y'-', .S:,n¢•F,� a','�:�7y'rs:.c '.•.., ,ip„y ^,.-s �<•.y^ C fi;.,. „ ,as -•°••.."�,•G,. _ o '�e f,
-r r t•; r,s1 'F •.=�'',&, ,` ,. P P'r`t,"-f�i"r°z J _4 % _ _ L _ y,- j<. •1 ..
. ;Y,_ .n ,§y * ''"' r ��r' ''JIB x4�„�.r°.��.,9•�,��' -�,�>�;.�, �'%14�' �, a- - F y } � Yr tt
t`.*' w e��*r"x '� "at?x .# ,�y#. 2 ``^pJ rt',.' >.r yr Jr ;.t "SYR.; `' r t _ k, ° ra
f «`v 2'l`- �` - y,F 4.'_�• •s�=t :r¢' t+.t.s; ''s•< y.2' '',L: `'`c`' 3 - t t l °'
is 'S 3 t '. +',,`� .,;r<: �`� ? .t r;..,.��;F;pt',,�r t -,.a'°'' b "? a- -r s,
�� - k -aye k, t ' a{ yy } y j ,N
,;� i .;3 $'a Y > Aa+ Y ,r �+Y'",� t k TTt :;?n I.B -[,a .J l+'f�-F.��E : �: ,"n� lr- f� i
�3',,�_ 4h _" ' �"£,ICTAWN, -
4 Yt. F.a>7C�i'd t�€l,i r h �V'e4__ Y- , "'i�.L� 5�, �..� it `'I hCf. ,'�i''.�i'�n 04"�� ._�t�,Lt -
.f wnim�.r- , have I e� A . W UMI
�� ,, ] ' r � Q ° wt 1y �t�e�1�^i�3 ' i t
: `°�'rfr r t -u k .y,J r -
Kgy
F`S�.ra ��, - + y. ty, - .4' t . . Li, a.k ' it
zC' . 0eW re ���;°���� �:�t�r �a�ry ire" rs ,of
°r *�' �.
� `t x zx tt ��if rvr s� , c2 n 'n :vi, 3`' f'.hOir- h e `�nYT
,t�.,a �rer1flrt c�u :nd .nle. . y y c. q x
s a, o t� 9 ..- fl-i� t,,� J��,"'lQ i
` � , t ae a,s on'` I ?.i, "ve seen i�,rs b tirSvra o 1
wa� "" - , N 'er�e v IN �0eiY.5� �ve�yt��in�. �;n.'per home. coverer"
t r � ; � ' o tier' hu,?�; ire the:ors . ,�
,,t $ ;,�,,;- �iAm" ga� c all.r.l illiba ,ea. , IN s�' condi%��•� & is I" rtainl�� °, : ,
cue try 75s `67' ,�, ' � 5
j ,`.y,:.- - -tl'' �d5' "irk �c �f r. }r r'sa, � 11rk"7.rR.P' f T.An€� }t'1 tElEE ,`.HOC.Ii t7 X`- .c C':���"'f? trj�.t�th .L��Tjd+�. 4w,` F.
f ' ��S ne ra is ` -ttrpb�.� t;;a b4. � �:n��, r l ;" to f"ri d o
4 � be _ tta 1r yo z mem?�er� c��' the e��i n ;�al
f,ixl s t � � ' fo th9 ," l� au h fa• i L
',11 _- b� . ett :� � o
3.,">.r*S, .f`.r: -S- � a?.'sY✓tt, ,� t ,x f✓ y, w "'. ,W,*'' ''� s ri ` +•t...Va k':-r x
V ,i iet.. } ..° >Y`y 4-.L {4 "'+..-a:Y'.� �•Sy`s, ;,i ;,3."q�tlar,y'' .s5; -
_ 't.;k,,J" 1.
�1",?•:3�"�•a�.`i,, r'titµ ✓,*,;,;i�.,, lls}s^> -w-<•� :�i c-4 �»,•'s�»,-- ' • .:1..:
', :J;A;?s'•�-'f`,i,,:';.;t'�,�, it4-7- .:z.,_ Fr,;" ;4pm.. r.. :a. .4 i :sx
# � �vY`"}�t.;L,)r4�' ,roj2,-.x'.Kei":F.•d.. +f* 'iif .Sf�'G6 Y - <-
14 r'� ,'sy- M� :Y� + 3 fng,si�' xz +vy'c�.� aa4•°'�" r x
t a t ems? .� ?r, �s A.r i.'cdf�*$ ,�.ia3 '•e s, '43' y"y+' 4 �'. !'f .-.'..y y.... o-:z _
- - -.,vt - 1 k _ •R b,ar es 3 ',d,{ t- t�aC'�-. ,a"fi1.11.1 tgy ,. -? .7•as lr llkge[li a�.� -Won, WIT '
-x ;a}t'S-xr 5 s 'F *..'� •..,�'- +-I'` r d ag'',,,�F Win,- _4 t t - ad,b' C 1 C, �Q- i- D 5•
t_a t i - rxt s `` Y t iN ..: ;�xr;,rr y-a 9: r ', !•, ti r r tY1 y��j{. .�!
> i ';wy.'.4i +u kw i`;:;F'ef. xS;J,i'Yfir- - € ,•�;; ,��,tH tx i i. .a,- -r1e .�t ti'W lira .',C'. 11-6 xOny!^ - x
st` ;e' :"'"':'�rc•.: a « ,:.-s.N�.Y11 ` hr'P,e y -??,t4'e 1'r :: •"5 a 4_. -yts _ .4 _ ° =}
i -a31= `F;3.tic' ,t�•:c w�.,�s r^T.!•a.:. `.ram `J;w`.x.-.w 33i3`'il .,_,i' x.5 y� r x;'� ;•. . ,;;rt 3 'a.:. 1 'Lt �.f
s SY••.':u3Vlz"•`.- .4�;."•:a;nu#;Yfi t�". rr,' '^it `. '.^"•. .`' Est}r; 'Y
4i
c
I ti r
' `i' 3 ., .., ,'-
:'. -'1 - - -F. f 6'� tt
x {{
_ Fr
ny,
Ina
- p � A ' - Y K t - L C ,Ly
Y "" ,pi .t.,-- �- :3 't+ �^` f•sY •F�e Y s. '. - _ j k 'c"-�
d
#� surt ,L, J f !' � aJ k - 1- 1 � a
a
��� .r 3 s V. z t ti _ v, s* '
t C
4 k r "t ,�r s 1544
H ,'� 1
Y 4. r y,
�� f
k - r- ' 'ast a r �i+" °5r *fit ., ���` ry _ St r t - -yam