Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCode Amendment 88-14 - Electronic Readerboard Signs - Public ri A, �h 4 R CITE( OF i--Il, NTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK March 22, 1989 Gary Gray Huntington Jeep/Eagle 16751 Beach Blvd. Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Dear Mr. Gray: The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at its regular meeting held February 6, 1.989, denied the appeal filed on your behalf by Councilman Silva relative to Code Amendment No. 88-14, Electronic Readerboard. This is a final decision. You are hereby notified that pursuant to provisions of Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure of the State of California you have ninety days from March 22, 1989 to apply to the courts for judicial review. If you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact our office at 536-5227. Sincerely, Connie Brockway, CMC City Clerk CB:me Enclosure CC: Councilman Jim Silva City Attorney City Administrator. Director Community Development (Telephone: 714-536-5227) Y � § 1094.5 SPECIAI. PROCEEDINGS Part 3 Note 378 — n.anded for necv trial de n(nvo. Prescod % minea wain i.•:.;ioner hnd tto, jurisdicli(in California I'll enlIdoy�me nI Ills. .lpponls ltd. and did not do -rrtnhie moritN. Western Air (1971i) 127 ('al.Rptr. 5.10, 57 C.A.Rd 29. l,lneN ]m°, v. sobieski,(11181) 12 Cnl.itptr. Trial eourt's judgunew dvii%ing writ of 71t1, tall ('.A.3d 300. mandate to compel director of agrieultnro Tract tlint letter discharging senior typ- to Net aside his decision revoking petition- ist clerk in office of county clerk stated er's license as aircraft pilot iu businesN of that she.\vas guilty of misconduct in re- pest control was re.vorscd and case re oioOng i:ublie records from 1ho files and mnnded to trial vourt with direction» to nntlilating old Neereting them on various remand case to director for purpose of dates, wlierenN .in licarittg before comity t reconsidering the penalty in•eviously im- civil servive voininission evidence was in- posed, where it was found taunt some of traduced .only as to what took place on the charges ngninst petitioner were not one of the tinter, did not require the dis- supported by evidence. Wingfield v. t riot court of appeal on ni,l,enl from judg- Directnr of Agriculture 0972) 105.Col. ment awurdiug senior tyld,t clerk writ of Rpm 618,29 C.A.3d 200. mandate, after reversing tho judgment of Proceeding for review of rleniai by con- the superior court, to remand the mutter missioner of corporations of permit .to to the c•ynuuission for rc,•onsideration, change voting; rights of shareholder» wht re.. there was a similarit c of facts stir- would be remanded to superior court. for rounding removal of the documents on all determination whether there was sllllst:m= of the dates. Pratt v. Los Angeles C!oun- ty Civil tieiviee l'ominissiou (1952) 238 anal evidence to support .commissioner's I.2d iv3.1(15 C.A.2d 111. fiadingr, where court 'improperly deter- 1094.6. Judicial review; decisions of local agencies; petition; filing; time; record; decision and Marty defined; or- dinance or resolution (a) Judicial review of any decision of a local agrnc}-, other than school district, as the term local agency is defined in Section 54951 of the Government Code, or of any commission, board, officer or agent thi. reof, may be had pursuant to Section 1094:5 of this rode only if the petition for writ,of mandate pursuant to such section is filed -YA thin the time limits:specified in this section. (b) Any such petition shall be filed not later than the 90th day following the date on which the decision becomes final. If there is no provision for reconsideration of the decision in any applicable provi- sion of any statute, charter, or rule, for the purposes of this section, the decisi�°, is final on the date it is made. If there is such provision for reconsideration, the decision is final for the purposes of this sec- tion upon the expiration of the period during which such reconsidera- tion can be sought; provided, that if reconsideration is sought pursu- arit to.any such provision the decision is final for the purposes of this section on the date that reconsideration is rejected. (c) The complete record of i he proceedings shall U, prepared by Ille local agency or il5 vollimis!:I(Nl, hoard, officer, or agent whlt'h made the decision and shall be delivered to the petitioner within 90 days after he has filed a written request (ticrefor. The local agency may recover from the petitioner its actual costs for transcribing or otherwise preparing the record. Such record shall include the tran- Script of the proceedings, all pleadings, all notices and orders, any proposed decision by a hearing officer, the final decision, all admitted 674 1 y°1 Title 1 ..RIT OF MANDATE § .1�!•-4.6 exhibits, all rejected exhibits in the possession of the local agency or its commission, board;officer, or agent, all,written evidence;'and any other papers in the case. (d) If the petitioner files a request for the• record as specified in - stihllivision (c1 within 10 bays Itflcr the d:tlr the decision becomes (I- nal as provided in subdivision (b), the time within which a petition pursuant to Section 10:)4.5 tnay be filed shall he,extended to not later than the 30th day following the date on which the record is either personally.delivered or mailed to the petitioner or his attorney of rec ord, if he has one. (e) As used in this section; decision'means adjudicatory admin- istrative.decision made,'after hearing, suspending, demoting, or dis- missing an officer or employee, revoking or denying an.application for a permit or a license, or denying an application for any retire- ment benefit or allowance. (f) In making a final decision as defined in subdivision (e), the local agency shall provide notice to the party that the time within which judicial review must be sought is governed by this section. As used in this subdivision, "party" means an officer or em- ployee who has been suspended, demoted or dismissed; a person whose permit or license has been revoked or whose application for a permit or license has been denied; or a person whose application for a retirement benefit or allowance has been denied. (g) This section shall be applicable in a local agency only if the governing board thereof adopts an ordinance or resolution making this ,section applicable. If such. ordinance or :resolution is adopted, the provisions of this section shall prevail over any conflicting provision in any otherwise applicable law relating to.the subject matter. (Added by Stats.1976, c.276,p.581, § 1.) Forms See West's Califoruifl Code Forms,Civil Procedure. Library References Administrative Law and Procedure C.J.S. Public Administrative Bodies and C-712. Procedure 193. Notes of Decisions In general I Lint public emplo mien relations .honed Exhaustion of administrative remedies 2 had' jurisdiction to determine whet.lier the unfair pruceice charges were •iustifiell; nud, is view of teachers' failure 1. In general to e<luurst their administrative remedies under the Rnddrt Aet, trial court erred in tichnol hourd's 'unilnti+ral freezing of granting writ of mandate to compel super- fv:ivhers' snhu•ies after. beginning of nem, inteodrnt of district and others to ruise school yeor; while vomract negotiations italar•i-•s of eertuin teachers. Amadot• Vul- werc wending, ar•gtnrhly evil an unfair loySw'ondnry P:duentors Ass'u �. Newlin pruelice iu violutiou of tilt! ltodda Act so (1979) 151 Cul.Itptr. 724, 8.9 C.A.3d 25-1. 675 • �� !' CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH INTER-DEPARTMENT COMMUNICATION HUNTINGTON BEACH To Gail Hutton From Connie Brockway City Attorney City Clerk Subject Code Amendment 88-14 Date March 15, 1989 Electronic Readerboard Signs In the past I called Mr. Amsbary when I needed to know if the attached 90-day letter (pursuant to Res. 4723) needed to be sent to parties such as Huntington Jeep Eagle. Pursuant to Mr. Amsbary's advice these letters have been sent to all applicants and or appellants who have been denied any kind of permit, CUP'S, Zone Cases, Conditional Exceptions, etc. . The legal advertisement on this Code Amendment stated that Huntington Jeep was the applicant, so even though a Code Amendment is not the same as the above zone cases etc. , should a letter be sent to him as the Council 's motion was to let the matter die with no further action? o; -e Page 5 - Counci 1/Ag,..,,y Minutes - 2/6/89 The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: MacAllister, Green, Winchell , Bannister, Mays, Silva, Erskine NOES: None ABSENT: None Mayor Bannister left the room. (City Council) PUBLIC HEARING - APPEAL FILED BY COUNCILMAN SILVA OF PLANNING COMMISSION DENIAL OF CODE AMENDMENT 88-14 - MOTION TO APPROVE FAILED - ELEC- TRONIC READERBOARD SIGNS - HUNTINGTON JEEP-EAGLE The Mayor Pro Tempore announced that this was the day and hour set for a public hearing to consider the following: SUBJECT: Code Amendment No. 88-14/Negative Declaration No. 88-39 APPELLANT: Councilman Silva APPLICANT: Gary Gray on behalf of Huntington Jeep/Eagle LOCATION: City wide PROPOSAL: Appeal filed by Councilman Silva of the Planning Commission's denial of a request to amend Article 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, to permit electronic readerboard signs. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Negative Declaration No. 88-39 will be considered by Council in conjunction with the request. The City Clerk announced that all legal requirements for notification, publi- cation and posting had been met, and that a communication dated January 9, 1989, was received from Dean Allison in opposition of the appeal . The Mayor Pro Tempore declared the hearing open. Jeff LeBow and Eric Weber spoke in opposition of the use of electronic reader- board signs. Rick Evans and Rod Wilson spoke in support of the appeal to approve Code Amendment 88-14 in favor of readerboard signs. There being no one present to speak further on the matter and there being no further protests filed, either oral or written, the hearing was closed by the Mayor Pro Tempore. The City Clerk presented Ordinance No. 2989A for Council consideration - "AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH AMENDING THE HUNTINGTON BEACH ORDINANCE CODE SECTIONS 9610.4, 9610.5, 9610.9 AND 9610.10 TO ALLOW ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNS." Following discussion, a motion was made by Silva, seconded by MacAllister, to overrule the Planning Commission decision, grant the appeal and approve Negative Declaration 88-39, approve Code Amendment 88-14, based on findings r� Page 6 - Council/Ag—cy Minutes - 2/6/89 for approval set forth in the February 6, 1989 RCA and after reading by title, approve the introduction of Ordinance No. 2989A. The motion failed by the following roll call vote: AYES: MacAllister, Mays, Silva NOES: Green, Winchell , Erskine ABSENT: None (Bannister out of the room) A motion was made by MacAllister, seconded by Silva, to overrule the Planning Commission decision, grant appeal and approve Negative Declaration 88-39, approve Code Amendment 88-14, based on findings for approval set forth in the 2/6/89 RCA and after reading by title, approve introduction of Ordinance No. 2989B. Following discussion, Councilman MacAllister withdrew the motion. A motion was made by Winchell , seconded by Green, to let the matter die with no further action. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: AYES: Green, Winchell , Silva, Erskine NOES: MacAllister, Mays ABSENT: None (Bannister out of the room) Mayor Bannister returned to the room. RECESS - RECONVENE The Mayor called a recess of Council at 8:50 p.m. The meeting was reconvened at 9 p.m. CONSENT CALENDAR - (ITEMS REMOVED) The City Administrator requested that the purchase agreements pertaining to the acquisition of three mobilehomes in Pacific Trailer Park be continued and that the item regarding the purchase of Main Pier Phase I Oil Interests be removed from the consent calendar and considered separately. Councilman MacAllister requested the item regarding the Municipal Art Center Renovation Agreement be removed from the Consent Calendar and considered separately. Councilman Erskine requested the item regarding the bid award for legal adver- tising and the item regarding modification of requirements for relocated businesses to receive in lieu payment be removed from the Consent Calendar and considered separately. CONSENT CALENDAR - (ITEMS APPROVED) On motion by Erskine, second Silva, Council approved the following items, as recommended, by the following roll call vote: AYES: MacAllister, Green, Winchell , Bannister, Mays, Silva, Erskine NOES: None ABSENT: None Authorized to Publish Advertisements of all k ':us including public notices by Decree of the Superior Court of Orange County, California. Number A-6214, dated 29 September. 1961. and 4-24831. dated 11 June, 1963. STATE OF CALIFORNIA County of Orange P.Doc hlol.G Aa+snwnQ COvWdd py !Mf atho*Y,t » so! � J ppin! wlltt 10 pKs CO{uTn width CC,\, 1 VV I am a Citizen of the United States and a resident of the County aforesaid-,'I am over the age of eighteen years, and not a party to or interested in the below —_-___ entitled matter. I am a principal clerk of the Orange PUBLIC NOTICE Arton Coast 'DAILY PILOT, with which is combined the Beace961of ncHCode,tto Beach Ordinance Code, to NEWS-PRESS, a newspaper of general circulation, permit electronic read- erboard signs. printed and published to the 'Cityof Costa Mesa, ENVIRONMENTAL e l !'STATUS: Negative Declar- ation No.88-39 will be con- County of Orange, 'State of California, and that a sidered by Council in Con- 'Junction Not �cr- with the request. Notice of ONNF FILE: A copy of the (proposed Code Amendment is'on file with the Depart- ment of Community De- velopment. ALL INTERESTED PER- Of which copy attached hereto is a true and complete iSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express copy, was printed and published in the Costa Mesa, opinions or submit evidence for or against the application Newport Beach, Huntington Beach, Fountain Valley, as outlined above.All appli- PUBLIC NOTICE cations, exhibits, and de- scriptionsIrVine, the South Coast communities and Laguna I onilwith the office of the 1 tilTte ( CORRECTED on file with the Office of the Beach issues of said newspaper for NOTICE OF City Clerk,2000 Main Street, PUBLIC Huntington Beach, Cali- consecutive weeks to wit the issue APPEAL OF publi s) of HEARING publi ,for inspection by the c. PLANNING HUNTINGTON BEACH COMMISSION CITY COUNCIL DENIAL.OF By: Connie Brockway, CODE City Clerk, Phone (714) February 1 198 AMENDMENT ! 536-5404 88-14 Published Orange Coast ELECTRONIC Daily Pilot January 20, 1989 READERBOARD Amended publication SIGNS February 1, 1989 198 NOTICE IS HEREBY __� _F=75 GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold 198 a public hearing in the Coun- Gcil Chamber at the Hunt- ington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Hunt- ington Beach,California,on 198 the date and at the time in- dicated below to receive and (Iconsider the statements of all persons who wish to be 198 ;heard relative to the appli- cation described below. DATE: Monday, February j6, 1989 TIME:7:00 P.M. I declare, under penalty of perjury, that the SUBJECT: Code Amend. P Y P 1 rY+ m e n t N o foregoing is true and correct. No.i88 39gativeDeclaration APPLICANT: Gary Gray- Huntington Jeep/Eagle APPELLANT:Councilman Executed on February 1 gg 9 Silva LOCATION:City-wide at Costa Mesa, CallfOr PROPOSAL: Appeal ofl the Planning Commission's ,T* _ denial of a request to amend USi ature 'N ,, �. PROOF OF PUBLICATION Authonzeo to PunitS^ Adve:-t;SAMents of ail kt,. lcwo:ng ;7ublic notices by Decree oI the SuD'ertor Court of Jrarnye County. California, !dumber A-6214. dated 29 Septemoee, 1961, and 4724831. Cared i t ,tune. 1963. STATE OF CALIFORNIA: County of Orange auaK note a novartonp co.moe D♦ tm9 eflfosvtl q bt m 7 ,osnl i r Ih 10 P.-D Cowin etotn I am a C+tizen of the Jnited States and a resident of the County aforesaid; !,am over the age of eighteen PUBLIC NOTICE Years, and NOVICE OF not a party t0 OC interested in the below PUBLIC HEARING entitled matter. i am a principal cleric of the Orange APPEAL OF (oast DAILY PILOT, with which is combined the COMMISS16 �;?�': .�� DENIAL OF NEWS-PRESS, a newspaper of general circulation, CODE' AMENDMENT;; ,printed and published in the City of,Costa Mesa, 88-14 ELECTRONIC—', , County of Orange. State of California, and that a READERBOARD?;;;,'.' Public Hearin SIGNS?":',.'' Notice of g NOTICE IS ;HEREBY GIVEN that the H66tingt6n Beach City Council,will'.hold" a public hearing in the,Coun cil Chamber at the',Hunt- -~ _ ington Beach•Civic'-Center; of which Copy attached hereto is a true and complete 2000 Main street, Hunt- . ington Beach,California,on copy, was printed and published in the Costa Mesa, the red and at the time nd diceted below to receive and Newport Beach, Huntington Beach, Fountain Valle consider the statements of y all persons who wish)to-•be'I Irvine, the South Coast communities and La una heard relative to:i4tieappii- g cation described be ow.-_;';. Beach issues of said newspaper for 1 time 6 D�ABT� ry, E: Monday, Februa TIME:7:00 P.M. consecutive weeks to wit the issue(s) of SUBJECT: CodePAmend- m e n It <'NI o 88-14/NegativeDeclaration No.88-39 APPLICANT:Gary ray- January . 20 9 Huntington Jeep%Eagle _ 198 APPELLANT:";�Ccuncil 'Silva I 'LOCATION:City-,wide' . PROPOSAL: Appeal--.,of 198 the Planning Commission's (denial of a request.to amend Article 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code,.to 198 permit electronic read- erboard signs. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Negative Declar- ation No.88-39 will be con- sidered by Council in Con- junction with the request.. ; ON FILE: A'copy of the proposed Code Amendment 196 is on file with the Depart- ment of Community De- velopment. ALL INTERESTED_':PER= SONS are Invited to attend I declare, under penalty of perjury, that the said hearing and^;.express opinions or submit evidence; foregoing is true and correct. for or against the a" lication as outlined above:,All appli- cations,"exhibits, and'de scriptions of thiBPoposal:are Executed on s anuary 20 g on file with the Office of the 198 _ City Clerk,2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, Cali- at Costa Mesa, Caafiforhia. fornla,for inspection by the public. HUNTINGTON,-' BEACH CITY COUNCIL By: Connle Brockway, gnat re City Clerk, Phone (7.14) 536-5404: Published Orange Coast Daily Pilot January 20, 1989 F_-75 PROOF OF PUBLICATION t PROOF OF PUBLICATION This space is for the County Clerk's Filing Stamp (20155 C.C.P) r- STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF ORANGE, I am a citizen of the United States and a resident of the County aforesaid;I am over the age of eighteen years, and not a party to or interested in the above-entitled matter. I am Proof of Publication of the principal clerk of the printer of the Huntington Beach News 314 Fifth St., #C Huntington Beach,CA 92648 (714)WO.2906r:141;3 ar9-4335 a newspaper of general circulation,printed and published weekly ------NOTICE ofPUBLIC HEARING . in the City of NG Huntington Beach COMMISSONF DENIAL IOF County of Orange, and which newspaper has CODE AMENDMENT.88-114 RE - been adjudged a newspaper of general ESE so RD SGNSDER Circulation by the Superior Court of the County NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will i of Orange,State of California,under the hold a public hearing in the Council Charrber at the Huntington Beach August 27 Zr� 1 Civic Center,2000 Main Street,Hunt-' date of ( , 19 J( ington Beach,California on the date and at the time indicated below to A 5930 receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard rela- Case Number ; that the tiveto the application described below. notice, of which the annexed is a printed copy HATE Monday,February 6,1989 (set in type not smaller than nonpareil), has TIME: 7:00 p.m been published in each regpular and entire issue SUBJECT: code amendment No. i t O 88-14/Negative Declaration No.88- of said newspaper and not in any supplement 39 thereof on the following dates, to-wit: APPLICANT: Gary Gray; Huntington Jeep/Eagle APPELLANT: Councilman Silva 213 LOCATION:City-wide PROPOSAL:Appeal of the"Planning all in the year 19 89 Commission's denial of a request to i y amend Article 961 of the Huntington I certify (or declare) under penalty of perjury Beach Ordinance Code, to permit electronic readerboard signs. that the foregoing is true and correct. il ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Negative Declaration No.88-39will be Huntington Beach considered by Council in Conjunction Dated at with the request. ON FILE A copy of the proposed his 3rd day of� 19,�,� Code Amendment is on file with the California,i Department of Community Develop- ment. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and Signature express opinions or submit evidence, g for or against the application as out-, lined above.All applications,exhibits, Free copies of this blank form may be secured from: and descriptions of this proposal are California Newspaper Service Bureau, Inc. on file with the Office of City Clerk2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach, Advertising Clearing House California,for inspection by the public. P.O.Box 31 HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY UNCIL Laos Angeles,CA 90053 (213)625-2541 By:Connie Brockway Please request GENERAL Proof of Publication City Clerk when ordering this form. Phone(714)536-5404 Dated:January 17,1989 _ Publish in_the Huntington Beach News Feb 3,1989 REQUES f FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION Date February 6, 1989 Submitted to: Honorable Mayor and City Council Submitted by: Paul E. Cook, City Administrator Prepared by: Mike Adams, Acting Director of Community Development 4 Subject: APPEAL OF PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF CODE AMENDMENT NO. 88-14 TO ALLOW ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNS Consistent with Council Policy? , Yes [ ] New Policy or Exception �.� a��q 03 Statement of Issue, Recommendation,Analysis, Funding Source,Alternative Actions,Attachments: i STATEMENT OF ISSUE: Transmitted for your consideration is an appeal by Councilman Silva of the Planning Commission' s denial of Code Amendment No . 88-14 . The Code Amendment, requested by Gary Gray-Huntington Jeep/Eagle, seeks to amend Article 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code to permit electronic readerboard signs within the City. RECOMMENDATIONS• PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION AND RECOMMENDATION: ON MOTION BY SLATES AND SECOND BY ORTEGA, THE PLANNING COMMISSION ON JANUARY 4, 1989, DENIED CODE AMENDMENT NO. 88-14 BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: Slates, Ortega, Kirkland, Higgins, Leipzig NOES: Bourguignon, Williams ABSENT: None ABSTAIN: None FINDINGS FOR DENIAL: 1 . Since the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, Article 961 allows adequate opportunities for advertising through various types of signage, Code Amendment No. 88-14 to allow electronic readerboard signs is not necessary for the preservation and enjoyment of substantial property rights . 2 . Electronic readerboard signs, if permitted by Code Amendment No . 88-14, will be incompatible with surrounding existing and proposed development, especially residential land uses . PIO 5/85 3 . Electronic readerboard signs visible from City streets would have the potential of slowing traffic and distracting to passing motorists . 4 . Code Amendment No . 88-14 to permit 35 foot high, 175 square foot electronic readerboards would be incompatible with the majority of existing signs constructed throughout the City since 1974 . 5 . Code Amendment No . 88-14 for electronic readerboard signs are more appropriate adjacent to freeways where there is not a mixture of vehicle/pedestrian flow, there is a greater maximum speed limit, and less competition amongst signs . STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff concurs with the Planning Commission and recommends that the City Council deny Code Amendment No. 88-14 . ANALYSIS• Applicant : Gary Gary-Huntington Jeep/Eagle Appellant: Councilman Jim Silva Code Amendment No. 88-14 and Negative Declaration No . 88-39 constitute a request to amend Article 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code (Sign Code) to permit the use of electronic readerboard signs within the City of Huntington Beach. Currently, Section 9610 .4 (a) of the Code prohibits "flashing, moving, pulsating or intermittently lighted signs including searchlights; except public service signs such as those for time and temperature. " Section 9610 .4(h) prohibits "changeable copy signs, including electronic readerboards; except theatre marquees . " The requested code amendment would amend these prohibitions to exempt electronic readerboards, add specifications and locational criteria for such signs, and amend certain definitions to accommodate the aforementioned changes . It is important to note that the applicant would not be the only property owner eligible to apply for a readerboard. Rather, a number of businesses/property owners along Beach Boulevard and the 405 Freeway would be eligible, depending on the criteria proposed. A similar Code Amendment (No. 87-15) to permit electronic readerboard signs was proposed by Wilson Ford earlier this year . The Planning Commission denied the request on March 28, 1988 . The City Council, on appeal by the applicant, directed the Planning Commission to evaluate and make recommendation upon an alternative ordinance to allow electronic readerboards, subject to certain criteria, as recommended by the Planning Commission Subcomittee and the Department of Public Works . RCA - 2/6/89 -2- (1909d) On May 3 , 1988, the Planning Commission reaffirmed their previous action and recommended denial of the code amendment to the City Council . However, they also forwarded a list of recommended sign criteria for the Council ' s consideration, should the Council have chosen to approve the amendment . At the July 18, 1988 City Council meeting, a motion to disapprove Code Amendment No. 87-15 failed by a vote of 3 to 3 . Therefore, the Planning Commission' s denial prevailed. Code Amendment No . 88-14 as requested by the applicant consists of the suggested ordinance forwarded to City Council by the Planning Commission on May 3, 1988, with two modifications . The maximum sign area requested is 175 square feet rather than 200 square feet, and an additional locational requirement is proposed which would limit the use of electronic readerboards to businesses that are located on minimum 2 acre parcels and rely upon the outdoor display of merchandise as the primary means of business . There are four primary issues involved in the code amendment : height, size, the concept of moving/changing message type signs and compatibility with nearby uses . a. Height From 1974 to 1986, the sign code permitted signs up to 20 feet in height within 20 feet of the front property line. Those signs set back 21 feet or greater could be up to 25 feet in height . Currently, the code limits sign height to 7 feet for parcels with less than 400 feet of frontage and to 15 feet for parcels with more than 400 feet of street frontage. This code amendment request is to allow signs up to 35 feet in height, which would be incompatible with other signs in the City established since 1974 and contrary to the current code. b. Size Prior to 1986, the size limit was based upon one square foot of sign area per one lineal foot of lot frontage with maximum 100 square feet for signs within 12 feet of the front property line. A maximum of 150 square feet was permitted for signs within 13 to 20 feet of the front property line, and a maximum of 200 square feet for signs greater than 20 feet from the front property line. The varying setback requirement in relation to size was to reduce the impact of a large sign close to public streets . Freestanding signs are currently limited to 70 square feet in size (80 square feet within an opaque background) on parcels with over 400 feet of frontage and to 30 square feet in size (40 square feet within an opaque background) on parcels with less than 400 feet of frontage. Proposed Code Amendment No. 88-14 is for a maximum 175 square foot sign area anywhere on the site (it may be within the front 25 foot building setback area) provided the site has a minimum 200 foot lot frontage. This size limit and location is incompatible with other signs constructed along Beach Boulevard since 1974 . RCA - 2/6/89 -3- (1909d) C. Moving/Changing Type Signs : Electronic readerboards may increase the risk of hazardous distraction to motorists . Use of flashing signs for advertising is visually demanding and may be confusing to drivers, thereby causing slowing of traffic on arterial highways and increasing potential vehicle/pedestrian conflicts . Electronic readerboard signs are more appropriate along freeways where the speed limit is 55 mph and there is not a mixture of vehicle/pedestrian flow. Beach Boulevard is posted maximum 45 mph and has sidewalks on both sides for pedestrian use. A high sign coupled with moving/changing messages can be distracting to motorists and increase the potential of vehicle/pedestrian conflict. Staff recommends that the use of flashing, blinking, pulsating, or intermittently lighted signs be reserved for public safety, signalized intersections and driving safety/control messages to motorists . d. Compatibility: The Huntington Beach sign code recently underwent extensive review and amendment by the City Council, with input from the Planning Commission, Chamber of Commerce, and other business and citizen groups . The intent of the revised ordinance was to limit sign heights, reduce visual clutter, create a more aesthetically pleasing appearance to passing motorists and create more consistency between signage. These code changes were in response to the increasing urban character of the street scenes in Huntington Beach. In the past, freestanding signs of 30 to 60 feet were erected to attract motorists from miles away. However, today' s urban development is too cluttered to allow for effective communication at this distance. Lower signs within the motorists direct cone of vision are more easily seen and read. In addition, electronic readerboards are incompatible with residential uses . The majority of parcels along Beach Boulevard are approximately 300 feet deep and adjacent to residential uses . The signs can be obnoxious due to their glare and blinking. However, new technology can reduce glare and reduce their impact . At the time that previous Code Amendment No. 87-15 was processed, staff conducted a poll of all Orange County cities, and found very few that permit electronic readerboard signs . There are a few existing non-conforming signs, and some others allowed by variance. Some of these signs are located on surface streets, however most larger, taller electronic readerboard signs are adjacent to freeways . A table attached to the Planning Commission Staff Report of December 13, 1988 lists the cities polled, their policies on readerboards, and the location of existing readerboards within those cities (Attachment No . 4) . Also attached to that Staff Report is a table and map citing samples of readerboards in Orange and Los Angeles Counties (Attachment Nos. 5 and 6) . RCA - 2/6/89 -4- (1909d) ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Pursuant to the environmental regulations in effect at this time, the Department of Community Development posted draft Negative Declaration No . 88-39 for ten days, and no comments, either verbal or written were received. The staff, in its initial study of the project, has recommended that a negative declaration be issued. Prior to any action on Code Amendment No . 88-14 it is necessary for the City Council to review and act on Negative Declaration No . 88-39 . Staff feels that, should the requested code amendment be approved, the suggested restrictions and criteria outlined in the attached draft ordinances will mitigate potentially adverse impacts to a level that is not significant pursuant to CEQA Guidelines . This does not mean, however, that all land use-related impacts will be completely eliminated, as discussed in the Analysis section of this report . ALTERNATIVE ACTION: Should the City Council wish to approve the requested code amendment, staff has prepared an alternative ordinance for consideration. The major differences between staff ' s recommended ordinance and the applicant ' s request are as follows : Staff Recommendation Applicant Recommendation Issue (if approved) (if approved) Max. Sign Height 15 ft. 35 ft. with 10 ft. ground clearance Max. Sign Area 70 sq. ft. 175 sq. ft . Min. Lot Frontage 400 ft. 200 ft. Min. Lot Area None 2 acres Type of Business No restrictions 80% of merchandise in outdoor display; display/work areas must be min. 20% of site area Staff ' s alternative would assure size and height compatibility with other signs constructed since 1986 . The size limit of 70 square feet would allow for two or three lines of lighted messages and full character graphics on a more proportionate scale. In addition, without the type of business requirement, the code amendment would be applicable to all properties with over 400 feet of frontage regardless of the business type. Staff has received inquiries for electronic readerboards from non-outdoor display type businesses . RCA - 2/6/89 -5- (1909d) Staff ' s alternative is basically designed within the framework of the existing sign code. Based on staff ' s proposed locational criteria, approximately 18 sites along Beach Boulevard and the freeway would be eligible to apply for electronic readerboard signs . This does not take into account possible lot consolidations to achieve the suggested 400 feet of lot frontage. Any request to exceed these standards would be based on a case by case analysis of the property and use pursuant to a special sign permit (variance) . As mentioned previously, the applicant has added two locational requirements to the previously proposed ordinance for Code Amendment No. 87-15 . These include a 2 acre minimum lot size and a requirement that a business utilize outdoor display for 80 percent of their merchandise. Such extensive use of outdoor display areas visible to passing motorists, however, would seem to reduce the need for additional signage, rather than increase it . Using the applicant ' s proposed locational criteria of minimum 2 acre lot size and 200 foot lot frontage, approximately 32 sites along Beach Boulevard and the freeway would be eligible for electronic readerboard signs . Again, this does not take into account possible lot consolidations to achieve the applicant ' s suggested lot frontage and lot size. At the January 4, 1989, Planning Commission meeting, it was suggested by several Planning Commissioners that, as a compromise, the applicant and staff investigate the possibility of placing one electronic readerboard near the 405 Freeway. One sign, directed at freeway traffic, could then serve all dealerships/businesses along Beach Boulevard, eliminating the need for readerboards on properties south of the freeway. Staff is investigating this possibility with Caltrans, and will report at the February 6 Council meeting. The City Council may take one of the following Alternative Actions : A. Approve Negative Declaration No. 88-39 and Code Amendment No. 88-14 as proposed by the applicant, with findings by adopting Ordinance No. -A (Attachment 3) ; or B. Approve Negative Declaration No. 88-39 and Code Amendment No. 88-14 as modified by staff, with findings by adopting Ordinance No. DAM -B (Attachment 4) . ATTACHMENTS: 1 . Letter of Appeal dated January 6, 1989 . 2 . Negative Declaration No. 88-39 3 . Ordinance No . �.�R-A as proposed by applicant 4 . Ordinance No. aTL-B as proposed by staff 5 . Planning Commission Staff Report dated January 4 , 1989 . 6 . Planning Commission Staff Report dated December 13 , 1988 . 7 . Draft Planning Commission Minutes dated January 4, 1989 . 8 . Letter dated January 9, 1989 . MA:LP:gbm RCA - 2/6/89 -6- (1909d) CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL COMMUNICATION ° • • • NUNTINGTON BEACH 'O. ' TO HONORABLE CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS and p R OW4 SILVA CITY CLERK COUNCIL SUBJECT DATE Appeal of Planning Commission Decision January 6, 1989 Code Amendment #88-14 and Negative_ Declaration#88-39 I hereby appeal the Planning Commission decision relative to applicant Gary Gray - Huntington Jeep-Eagle and Code Amendment #88-14. 1 feel the readerboard sign would be good for the auto dealership and the city. JS:bb x 0130c-4 , C0 _K+ , LZI-) ®J CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH INTER-DEPARTMENT COMMUNICATION HUNTINGTON BEACH - - - - To Laura Phillips From ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES Assistant Planner SECTION Subject ENVIRONMENTAL INFORMATION Date December 2, 1988 FORM NO. 88-39 -. Applicant: Huntington Jeep Eagle 167S1 Beach Boulevard Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Request: Code amendment to allow electronic readerboards within the City of Huntington Beach Location: City of Huntington Beach along freeways and along Beach Boulevard, excluding the portion designated as a landscape corridor from Adams Avenue to Pacific Coast Highway. Background Staff has reviewed the environmental information form noted above and has determined that a negative declaration may be filed for the project. In view of this, a draft negative declaration was prepared and was published in the Daily Pilot and posted in the Office of the City Clerk for a ten (10) day public review period commencing December 2, 1988 and ending December 12, 1988. If any comments regarding the draft negative declaration are received, you will be notified immediately. Recommendation The Environmental Resources Section recommends that the Planning Commission approve Negative Declaration No. 88-39 finding that the proposed project will not have a significant adverse effect on the environment. Mitigation Measures X The attached mitigating measures will reduce potential environmental effects resulting from the project and are recommended as conditions of approval r Respectfully submitted .. ..-,,� Kelly ai Assistant lanne KM:gbm (1684d-1) APPEND 1 ENV1ROmAEN7AL 0-EC}C-IS7 FORM (To Be Comp:eted By Lead Agency) 1. Bock,r ound i• "iQrre of Procarent Hun t i ng t on J eep Eag I e 2. .adcress and Phone Nurrb�rr of ProP<x)ent 16751 Beach Boulevard , Huntington each , CA 92647 3. Ccte of 0 cklist Stbmitted November 29 , 1988 4. Agency Requiring Checklist City of Huntington Beach 5. Nome of ProQosal, if cWl;ccbie Code Amendment No, 88-14 Environmental Assessment No. . 88-39 li. Environmental Imports (�KpiCr at Ions O( Gil "jes" and "MaYiD,>"f an jNCrs ore re^uireC cn '� �r�t5 xlk-rbe f i0 Ezr.h. Will the ✓ropcsal result in: c. '✓nstcble -ar'h ccrditions or in c:` nges ;n geologic sLbstrtctures? X b. D;srwfiorrs, dispiccemer.tz, corrpoction or overcovering of tt,c ,;cii? X c. Chmge in t000grephy or ground surfoce relief features.' X d. The destruction, covering or modificotion of any un;que geologic or physical features? X e. Any increcse in wind or water erosion of so;is, either on or off the site? X f• Charges in deposition or erosion of beach sands, or changes in siltation, deposit;on or erosi on which may modify the channei of a river or stream or the bed of tt,e ocean or any bay, inlet or lake? X 115 Yes No ~ g. Exposure of Peopie or property to geolo- gic N--z:rds svch as earthgvci<es, I r1rislides, mvaslides, ground failure, or similar h=ord3? X Z. Air. Will the proposal result in: �. S"ostantial air emissions or deterioration of ambient air quality? X b. The cro-ition of objectionable odors? X C. Alteration of air movement, moisture, or temperature, or any change in climate, either locally or regionally? * X 3. Water. . 'Hill the pr000sal result in: a. Chenges in currents, or the course of di- rection of water moY_.rnE. , in either mcrwe or fresh waters? X b. Changes in absorption mates, droinoge _ terr,s, or the rate and amount of surface runoff? X C. Alt"rat:cns to t�� course or flow of flood WCters X d• Chcrxe in ")e amount of svrfoc^ water in any water body? X e. D schcrge into surface waters, or in any alteration of surface water quality, in- cluding but not limited to temperotvre, dissolved oxygen or turbidity? X f. Alteration of the direction or rote of flow of grovnd waters? X g. Change in the quantity of ground waters, either through direct odditioru or with- drawals, or throvgh interception of an aquifer by cuts or excavations? X h• Svbstontial reduction in the amount of water other,-vise available for public water supplies? X i. Exposure of people or property re- lated hazards 'svch as to water flooding or t i da 1 waves? X 116 Yes maybe 4. Plant Life. Will the proposal result in: a. Chcr.ge in the diversity of species, cc nurroex of any species of plants (including trees, shcvhs, gross, crops, and oquatie plants)? X b. R.edtction of the nun^bers of any unique, rare or endcr,gered species of plants.? X C. lntrodtction of new Z.-Cles of plants into an area, or in a barrier to the normal replenishment of existing species' X d. Reduction in ocreace of any agricultural crop? X 5. Animal life. Will the proposal result in: a. Ch nr ge- in the diversity of species, or numbers of arty species of animals (birds, lend animals including reptiles, fish and s^eilfish, benthic organisms or insects)) X b. P.educticn of the nurrcers of cry unique, rare or endcngtred species of animals? _X_ C. lrtrc6—cticn o; new saecies of animals into ar creo, or result in a bcrrier to the migration or movement of animals? X d. Deter:oration to existing fish or wildlife hcbitat? X 6. tfoise. Will the proposal result in: a. Increases in existing noise levels? X b. Exposure of people to severe noise levels? X 7. Light and Glare. Will the proposal produce X new light or glare? 8. Land Use. Will the proposal result in a sub- stontial alteration of the present or planned s land use of an area? X 9. 1Va ral Resources. Will the proposal result in: a. Increase in the„,,ate of use of any natural resources? X 117 • Yeas P- b. Substrntial dea letion of any nonrenewable natural resource? X IQ. Rissc of t> set. Will the prapasal inveoly4= a. A risk of an explosion or the release Of hc.z ar d0xn nks t once s (including, but not limited to, oil, pe366de3, chemicals or rodiation) in the event of an accident or inset conditions? X b. Possible interference with an ernergrncy r e von%se plan or an erne rger-acy evocvat ion plan? X 11. Population. 'Hill the proposal alter the location, distribution, density, or growth rate of the Fuman population of an area? X 12. F"Ing. 'Hill the proQosol affect existing hous- ing, or create a demand for additional housing? X 13. TrarLs*aticn/Circulation. Will the proposal result in: a. Generatio., of ;vbstcntial ad,,�itioncl vehicular movem.rt? X b. E`fecls on exis!ind per'ikirc, facilities, or cemend for new per',cing? X C. Substantial in-pact upon existing transper_ taticn systems? X d. Alterations to present patterrLs of circula- tion or movement of people and/or goo,.{s? X e. Alterations to waterborne, roil or air traffic? X f. Increase in traffic hazards to motor vehicles, bicyclists or pedestrians? X 14. Public Services. Will the proposal hove an effect upon, or result in a need for new or altered govemmental services in any of the following areas: y a. Fire protection? �•� X b. Police protection? X c. Schools? X I, l s Yes No d. Parks or other recreational focilities? x \ �. Maintenance of public facilities, inc!udinq roc ds, x f. Other governmental services? x I S. Encrgy. '+Mill the proposal result in; a. Use of substantial amounts of feel or energy? x b. Substantial increase in derry-nd upon exist- ing sources of energy, or require the development of new sources of energy? x 16. Utilities. Will the proposal result in a need for new systems, or substantial alterations to the following utilities: a. Power or noturai gas.? x b. Communications systems? x C. Water' x d. Sewer or sep t;c t crrk s? x e. Storm water dre inoge? x f. Sclid wcste and disposal? x 17. N,vrnrn l-teaIth. Will the proposal result in: a. Crefltion of any health hazard or potential health hazard (excluding mental health)? x b. Exposure of people to potential health haz ar ds? x 18. Aesthetics, Will the proposal result in the obstnicticn of any scenic vista or view open to the public, or will the proposal result in the creation of an aesthetically offensive site open to public view? x 19. Recreation. Will the proposal result in an impact upon the quality or quantity of existing recreational opportunities? _ x 20. Cultvral Resaurces. x' a. WYill the proposal result in the alteration of or the destructicin of a prehistoric or historic orchaeological site? x 119 • - Yes Maybe No b. Will the proposal result in adverse physical or oesthetic effects to a prehistoric or X historic building, structure, or ob;.ect? C. Does the proposal have the potential to cause a physical clung+- which would affect unil?Ve ethnic cultural values? X d. Will the proposal restrict existing religious or socr ed uses w i tfi in the potential i mac t area? X 21. lNanciatory Findings of Significance, r . a. Does the project have the potential to degrade the quality of the environment, substantially reduce the habitat of a Fish or wildlife species, cause a fish or wild- life population to drop below self sus- taining levels, threaten to eliminate a plant or animal community, reduce the nun-ber or restrict the rouge of a rare or endcn,ered plant or animal or eliminate important examples of the major periods of California history or prehistory? X b. Dces the project hove the potential to achieve short-term, to the disadvcntege of long-term, environmental goals? (A s`:ort- term impact on the environment is one which occurs in a relatively brief, definitive period of time while long-term impacts will endure well into the future) X c. Does the project have impacts which ore individually limited, but cumulatively con- siderable? (A project may impact on two or more separate resources where the impact on each resource is relatively small, but where the effect of the total of those immacts on the environment is significant.) X d. Does the project have environmental effects which will core substantial adverse effects X on human beings, either directly or indirectly? 111. Discussion of Environmental Evaluation IV. Determination (To be completed by the Lead Agency) 120 DISCUSSION OF YES AND MAY ANSWERS ON ENVIRONMENTAL CHECKLIST NO. 88-39 LIGHT AND GLARE 7. The proposed project has the potential to have significant impacts upon the environment with respect to light and glare, particularly in the immediate vicinity of any site which would be allowed to have a readerboard. Light projection from a readerboard or several readerboards together onto adjacent residences could prove to be quite severe without appropriate constraints upon height, size, sign frequency, location and hours of operation. The following mitigation measures are included within the proposed Code Amendment and should reduce light and glare impacts from readerboards to a level of non—significance: Height A. The maximum height of an electronic readerboard shall be thirty—five (35) feet and shall have a minimum ground clearance of ten (10) feet. Size B. The maximum sign area which includes an electronic readerboard shall be one hundred seventy five (175) square feet. Sign Frequency C. The maximum number of electronic readerboards shall be one per site. D. The minimum lot frontage of the parcel shall be two hundred (200) feet. Location E. The minimum distance between electronic readerboards shall be one hundred fifty (150) feet. F. The minimum distance from an electronic readerboard to the interior property line shall be one hundred (100) feet. G. The minimum distance from an electronic readerboard sign to any residence shall be one hundred fifty (150) feet. H. Readerboards shall be allowed only on parcels abutting,a freeway and on parcels abutting Beach Boulevard, excluding the portion along Bach Boulevard designated as a landscape corridor south of Adams Avenue to Pacific Coast Highway. Hours of Operation I. Hours of operation shall be limited to 6:30 a.m. to 10:30 p.m. (1684d-2) i To control the intensity of light projection from a readerboard: Irilensity J. Readerboards shall have cylinders, a shade screen and a photocell for reducing the intensity of lighting at night. K. Maximum measurable light output of the electronic readerboard shall not exceed 5-foot candles at the property line. With mitigation measures, no significant impacts are anticipated. TRAFFIC AND CIRCULATION 13f. Flashing, pulsating signs with messages have the potential to be a hazardous distraction to motorists. It is important to monitor sign frequency, the distance between signs, and the rate at which messages are flashed. By monitoring these factors, one is able to minimize the distracting elements of the proposed type of sign. The following mitigation measures are included in the proposed Code Amendment and should reduce the impacts of readerboards upon traffic safety to a level of nonsignificance: Sign Frequency Please refer to Measures C and D under Light and Glare. Distance Between Signs Please refer to Measure G under Light and Glare. Message Frequency L. Readerboard messages shall be no faster than one message every four seconds and the minimum interval between messages shall be at least one second. The above measure is suggested by the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans). The requirement of a Conditional Use Permit for installation of an electronic readerboard will allow the City to monitor the cumulative impacts readerboards may have upon traffic safety. In addition, the following measure is included in the proposed Code Amendment to enhance traffic safety: M. A minimum of ten (10%) percent of message time; or any percentage deemed necessary by the City for emergency conditions, shall be used for public service announcements. With mitigation measures, no significant impacts are anticipated. (1684d-3) 1. AESTHETICS 18. Several factors including height, size, number, frequency, message type-and location will contribute to the aesthetic impacts electronic readerboards singularly and cumulatively have on their neighborhoods. If allowed, electronic readerboards must be limited to a size which is somewhat harmonious with other signs in an area. Obviously, the shorter a sign and the smaller its square footage, the less of a visual impact upon the street and adjacent neighborhood. Measures A and B under Light and Glare address these concerns. The distance between readerboards and the number of them visible on a street effect the degree to which visual impacts will be experienced by traffic on the subject street and by adjacent residences. The fewer the number of readerboards and the greater the distance between them, the lesser the aesthetic impact. Mitigation Measures C and D address these concerns. Y Limiting the location of readerboards, a commercial property and their distance from residential property will reduce aesthetic impacts upon those properties. Measures E, F and G under Light and Glare address these concerns. Locating the signs on streets or along freeways where their presence will not appear to be out—of—place or incompatible with the surrounding environment will also decrease aesthetic impacts resulting from electronic readerboards. Their limitation to a portion of Beach Boulevard or along freeways and only on lots with relatively greater street frontage address this concern. Mandatory review through a Conditional Use Permit for installation of electronic readerboards will contribute to lessening the negative aesthetic impacts associated with allowing the proposed type of sign. Wtih mitigation measures, no significant impacts are anticipated. (1684d-4) vi S ORDINANCE NO. -A AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH AMENDING THE HUNTINGTON BEACH ORDINANCE CODE SECTIONS 9610 .4 , 9610 .5 , 9610 . 9 AND 9610 . 10 TO ALLOW ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNS The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach does ordain as follows: SECTION 1 . Section 9610 .4 (a)and (h) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to read as follows : 9610 .4 Prohibited signs . The following signs are prohibited within the City of Huntington Beach: (a) Flashing, moving, pulsating, or intermittently lighted signs , including searchlights; except electronic readerboards and public service signs such as those for time and temperature. // (h) Changeable copy signs, except electronic readerboards or theatre marquees . SECTION 2 . Section 9610 . 5 (Permitted Signs-Schedule) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to incorporate into the schedule the following specifications pertaining to electronic readerboards . (b) COMMERCIAL Use of Sign Type Maximum Maximum Maximum Number Area Per Height Sign Electronic Readerboards (See Section 9610 . 9 (d)for specifications) SECTION 3 . Section 9610 . 9 (Miscellaneous Provisions) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to incorporate the following: (d) Electronic Readerboards . Electronic readerboards may be permitted subject to the approval of a conditional use - 1 - permit by the Planning Commission, approval of a planned sign program according to the provisions of section 9610 .6 and approval of the Design Review Board according to the provisions of Article 985. Approval of electronic readerboards shall be subject to the following standards : ( 1 ) Permitted signs . Electronic readerboards may be free standing or wall type signs . The maximum number of electronic readerboards shall be one per site. The maximum sign area which includes an electronic readerboard shall be one hundred seventy-five (175 ) square feet . The total sign area shall be limited to twice the size of the electronic readerboard portion of the sign . The maximum height of an electronic readerboard sign shall be thirty-five (35 ) feet and shall have a minimum ground clearance of ten (10 ) feet . The electronic readerboard shall have cylinders, a shade screen and a photocell for reducing the intensity of lighting at night . The maximum measurable light output of the electronic readerboard shall not exceed 5-foot candles at the property line. (2 ) Location requirements . The minimum lot frontage of the parcel shall be two hundred ( 200 ) feet. Electronic readerboards shall be allowed only on parcels abutting a freeway and on parcels abutting Beach Boulevard, excluding the portion along Beach Boulevard designated as a landscape corridor south of Adams to Pacific Coast Highway The minimum distance between electronic readerboards shall be one hundred fifty ( 150 ) feet. The minimum distance from an electronic readerboard sign to any residence shall be one hundred fifty ( 150 ) feet . The minimum distance from an electronic readerboard to the interior property line shall be one hundred ( 100 ) feet . Outdoor Business - Any commercial outdoor business which relies principally on the outside display of eighty (800 ) percent or more of merchandise as the primary means of business, and for which the combined outdoor display areas, showrooms , inventory and work areas comprise no less than twenty (20% ) percent of total site . area . This shall apply only to properties fronting Beach Boulevard and parcels with freeway frontage, with each property having a minimum of two (2 ) acres . ( 3 ) Other standards . In addition to the electronic readerboard sign, one monument sign, maximum of seven ( 7 ) feet in height and a 2 - s maximum of fifty (50 ) square feet in sign area, may be permitted and all other 'signage shall be brought into conformance with the provisions of this article. The hours of operation of any electronic readerboard shall be limited to 6 :30 am to 10 :30 pm. At least 10% of the message time, or any percentage deemed necessary by the city for emergency conditions, shall be used for public service announcements. Messages on an electronic readerboard shall be no faster than one message every four seconds and the minimum interval between messages shall be at least one second. Continuous motion of messages is not permitted. Light intensity changes (other than between day and night uses) are not permitted . SECTION 4 . Section 9610 . 10 (Definitions) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended as follows: ( 15 ) Electronic Readerboard: A changeable message sign consisting of a matrix of lamps which are computer controlled. ( 16 ) Flashing or animated • sign: A sign intermittently reflecting light, or which has any illumination which is not maintained constant in intensity, color or pattern, except electronic readerboards and those for time and temperature . ( 17 ) Freestanding sign: (Text unchanged) ( 18 ) Grade: (Text unchanged) ( 19 ) Grand opening: (Text unchanged ) (20 ) Ground level : (Text unchanged) (21 ) Height of sign: (Text unchanged ) (22 ) Indirect illumination: (Text unchanged) (23 ) Industrial center : (Text unchanged) (24 ) Interior illumination: (Text unchanged) (25 ) Item of information: (Text unchanged) (26 ) Land development project : Text unchanged) ( 27 ) Monument sign: Text unchanged) (28 ) Logo: (Text unchanged) (29 ) Nameplate sign: (Text unchanged) 3 - I (30 ) Nonconforming sign: (Text unchanged) (31 ) Open house sign: (Text unchanged) ( 32 ) Political sign: (Text unchanged ) (33 ) Projecting sign: (Text unchanged) (34 ) Real estate sign : (Text unchanged) ( 35 ) Roof sign: (Text unchanged) (36 ) Sign : (Text unchanged ) ( 37 ) Sign copy: (Text unchanged) (38 ) Sign structure : (Text unchanged) ( 39 ) Site: (Text unchanged) (40 ) Site (street ) frontage: (Text unchanged) (41 ) Subdivision directional sign: ( Text unchanged) ( 42 ) Supergraphic: (Text unchanged) (43 ) Temporary sign: (Text unchanged) ( 44 ) Trespassing sign: (Text unchanged) (45 ) Wall sign : (Text unchanged) ( 46 ) Window sign: (Text unchanged) PAGE END 4 - I w SECTION 5 . This ordinance shall take effect thirty days after its passage. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at a regular meeting thereof held on the day of , 1988 . Mayor ATTEST: APPROVED AS TO FORM: City Clerk City Attorney REVIEWED AND APPROVED: INITIATED AND APPROVED: City Administrator Director o ommu ity Development 5 - w, ORDINANCE NO. - ` -B AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH AMENDING THE HUNTINGTON BEACH ORDINANCE CODE SECTIONS 9610 .4 , 9610 .5 , 9610 .9 AND 9610 . 10 TO ALLOW ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNS The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach does ordain as follows: SECTION 1. Section 9610 .4 (a)and (h) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to read as follows : 9610 .4 Prohibited signs . The following signs are prohibited within the City of Huntington Beach : (a) Flashing, moving, pulsating, or intermittently lighted signs, including searchlights; except electronic readerboards and public service signs such as those for time and temperature. (h) Changeable copy signs, except electronic readerboards or theatre marquees . SECTION 2 . Section 9610 .5 (Permitted Signs-Schedule) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to incorporate into the schedule the following specifications pertaining to electronic readerboards . (b) COMMERCIAL Use of Sign Type Maximum Maximum Maximum Number Area Per Height Sign Electronic Readerboards ( See Section 9610 .9 (d) for specifications) - 1 - SECTION 3 . Section 9610 . 9 (Miscellaneous Provisions) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to incorporate the following: (d) Electronic Readerboards . Electronic readerboards may be permitted subject to the approval of a conditional use permit by the Planning Commission, approval of a planned "sign program according to the provisions of section 9610 .6 and approval of the Design Review Board according to the provisions of Article 985 . Approval of electronic readerboards shall be subject to the following standards: ( 1) Permitted signs. Electronic readerboards may be free standing or wall type signs . The maximum number of electronic readerboards shall be one per site. The maximum sign area which includes an electronic readerboard shall be seventy (70 ) square feet . The total sign area shall be limited to twice the size of the electronic readerboard portion of the sign. The maximum height of an electronic readerboard sign shall be fifteen ( 15 ) feet . The electronic readerboard shall have cylinders, a shade screen and a photocell for reducing the intensity of lighting at night . The maximum measurable light output of the electronic readerboard shall not exceed 50-foot candles at the property line . ( 2 ) Location requirements . The minimum lot frontage of the parcel shall be four hundred ( 400 ) feet. Electronic readerboards shall be allowed only on parcels abutting a freeway and on parcels abutting Beach Boulevard, excluding the portion along Beach Boulevard designated as a landscape corridor south of Adams to Pacific Coast Highway The minimum distance between electronic readerboards shall be one hundred fifty ( 150 ) feet . The minimum distance from an electronic readerboard sign to any residence shall be one hundred fifty ( 150 ) feet . The minimum distance from an electronic readerboard to the interior property line shall be one hundred ( 100 ) feet. ( 3 ) Other standards . In addition to the electronic readerboard sign, one monument sign, maximum of seven ( 7 ) feet in height and a maximum of fifty (50 ) square feet in sign area, may be permitted and all other signage shall be brought into 2 - conformance with the provisions of this article . The hours of operation of any electronic readerboard shall be limited to 6 :30 am to 10 :30 pm. At least 10% of the message time, or any percentage deemed necessary by the city for emergency conditions, shall be used for public service announcements. Messages on an electronic readerboard shall be no faster than one message every four seconds and the minimum interval between messages shall be at least one second . Continuous motion of messages is not permitted. Light intensity changes (other than between day and night uses) are not permitted. SECTION 4 . Section 9610 . 10 (Definitions ) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended as follows: ( 15 ) Electronic Readerboard: A changeable message sign consisting of a matrix of lamps which are computer controlled. ( 16 ) Flashing or animated sign: A sign intermittently reflecting light, or which has any illumination which is not maintained constant in intensity, color or pattern, except electronic readerboards and those for time and temperature. ( 17 ) Freestanding sign: (Text unchanged) ( 18 ) Grade: (Text unchanged) ( 19 ) Grand opening: (Text unchanged) (20 ) Ground level : (Text unchanged) ( 21) Height of sign: (Text unchanged) (22 ) Indirect illumination: (Text unchanged) ( 23 ) Industrial center : (Text unchanged) (24 ) Interior illumination: (Text unchanged) ( 25 ) Item of information: (Text unchanged) (26 ) Land development project : Text unchanged) (27 ) Monument sign: Text unchanged) (28 ) Logo: (Text unchanged) (29 ) Nameplate sign: (Text unchanged) (30 ) Nonconforming sign: (Text unchanged) - 3 - (31 ) Open house sign: (Text unchanged) ( 32 ) Political sign: (Text unchanged) (33 ) Projecting sign: (Text unchanged) ( 34 ) Real estate sign: (Text unchanged) (35 ) Roof sign: (Text unchanged) (36 ) Sign: (Text unchanged) (37) Sign copy: (Text unchanged) (38 ) Sign structure: (Text unchanged) ( 39 ) Site: (Text unchanged) (40 ) Site ( street ) frontage: (Text unchanged) ( 41) Subdivision directional sign: (Text unchanged) ( 42 ) Supergraphic: (Text unchanged) ( 43 ) Temporary sign: (Text unchanged) ( 44 ) Trespassing sign: (Text unchanged) ( 45 ) Wall sign: (Text unchanged) ( 46 ) Window sign: (Text unchanged) PAGE END 4 - SECTION 5 . This ordinance shall take effect thirty days after its passage. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at a regular meeting thereof held on the day of , 1988 . Mayor ATTEST: APPROVED AS TO FORM: City ClerkF,-City Attorn REVIEWED AND APPROVED: INITIATED AND APPROVED: fL-z" -j6A#112 �M City Administrator Di ector bf Commun y Development be 5 - huntington beach department of community development STAFf TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: January 4, 1989 SUBJECT: CODE AMENDMENT NO. 88-14/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 88-39 (CONTINUED FROM DECEMBER 13, 1988 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING) APPLICANT: Gary Gray DATE ACCEPTED: Huntington Jeep/Eagle October 14, 1988 16751 Beach Blvd. Hunt. Beach, CA 92647 MANDATORY PROCESSING DATE: Not applicable REQUEST: To amend Article 961 of the Ordinance Code to LOCATION: City-wide permit electronic reader- board signs . 1. 0 SUGGESTED ACTION: Deny Code Amendment No . 88-14 with findings . 2 . 0 GENERAL INFORMATION: Code Amendment No. 88-14 and Negative Declaration No. 88-39 were continued from the Planning Commission meeting of December 13, 1988, at the applicant' s request . Staff is still recommending denial of the requested code amendment . However, should the Planning Commission decide to recommend adoption of the code amendment to the City Council, staff would suggest an additional criteria be added to the alternative ordinance as drafted by staff (Attachment No. 2 of the staff report dated December 13, 1988) . It is recommended that no temporary flags, banners, balloons, or other temporary signs be permitted for sites with an electronic readerboard sign. Included with this report is a brief summary of the features of the code amendment proposed by the applicant, as compared to those features of the alternative ordinance suggested by staff . ATTACHMENTS: 1. Summary Chart 2. Letter .received. December ,7, 1988 3 . Staff ,Report dated December 13 , 1988 SH:LP:kla . , (1802d) A-FM-23C . SUMMARY CHART OF PROPOSED ORDINANCES Feature Proposed by Applicant Proposed by Staff Entitlements CUP, PSP, DRB CUP, PSP, DRB Required Type of Sign Freestanding or Wall Freestanding or Wall Max. Number 1 per site 1 per site Max. Size 175 sq. ft. ; total sign 70 sq. ft. ; total sign area not to exceed 2X area not to exceed 2X size of readerboard size of readerboard portion portion Max. Height 35 ft . with min. 15 ft . 10 ft . clearance Max. Intensity Cylinders, shade screen Cylinders, shade screen and photo cell required. and photo cell required. Max. light output 5-ft. Max. light output 5-ft . candles at property candles at property line line Min. Lot Frontage 200 ft . 400 ft. Location Abutting freeway or Abutting freeway or Beach Blvd. (except Beach Blvd. (except between Adams and PCH) between Adams & PCH) Min. Distance 150 ft . 150 ft. between Electronic Readerboards Min. Distance 150 ft . 150 ft. to Residence Min. Distance to 100 ft. 100 ft. Interior Property Line Type of Business 80% of merchandise in No restrictions outdoor display; display/work areas must be min. 20% of site area Min. Parcel Size 2 acres`' None specified SUMMARY CHART OF PROPOSED ORDINANCES (Continued) Feature Proposed by Applicant Proposed by Staff Hours of 6 : 30 AM - 10 : 30 PM 6 : 30 AM to 10 : 30 PM Operation Public Service 10% of message time or 10% of message time or for emergencies for emergencies Frequency of Min. 4 seconds with Min. 4 seconds with Message min. 1 second interval. min. 1 second interval . No continuous motion No continuous motion or intensity changes or intensity changes Other Signs One monument 7 ft. One monument 7 ft . On Site high, 50 sq. ft . high, 50 sq. ft . All other signs in All other signs in conformance with conformance with Article 961 Article 961 Temporary Banners Permitted 6 months Prohibited per calendar year in accordance with Article 961 Tom Bematz & Associates .2914 East Katella Avenue Suite 203 Orange, California 92667 (714) 997-1785 December 5, 1988 RECEIVED DEC 0 71988 Mr. Mike Adams Planning Commission DF'?a_!�'._ME ;T OF P. 0. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 REFERENCE: CODE AMENDMENT NO. 88-14 NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 88-39 Dear Mr. Adams, Regarding the above mentioned reference, please, please do not approve that ugly reader board for Huntington Jeep/Eagle. Their business lot is already one God-awful mess. I own the shopping center at the South West corner of Beach Boulevard and Terry Drive, just south of the aforementioned company. We were forced to remove our modest front signage because of the ordinance in force. Why should a car dealer be allowed to use a Las Vegas type of sign? Already they cause an eyesore in the neighborhood because their sales people and customers park in my shopping center and adjoining properties. They do not provide adequate parking for their personnel or customers . Their property always looks like a garbage heap. A reader sign of this type would only show that Huntington Beach approves of their sleazy and ugly operation and places a vote for an inconsiderate business operator. Please say "NO" to this motion to amend Article 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code to permit electronic readerboard signs. Sincerely, Thomas H. Bernatz ' THB:dw cc : HB Planning Commission -Developers- Investors 4 huntington beach department of community development STA f F TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: December 13 , 1988 SUBJECT: CODE AMENDMENT NO. 88-14/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 88-39 APPLICANT: Gary Gray DATE ACCEPTED: Huntington Jeep/Eagle October 14 , 1988 16751 Beach Blvd. Hunt. Beach, CA 92647 MANDATORY PROCESSING DATE: Not. applicable REQUEST: To amend Article 961 of the Ordinance Code to LOCATION: City-wide permit electronic reader- board signs. 1 . 0 SUGGESTED ACTION: Deny Code Amendment No . 88-14 with findings . 2 . 0 GENERAL INFORMATION: Code Amendment No. 88-14 and Negative Declaration No . 88-39 constitute a request to amend Article 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code (Sign Code) to permit the use of electronic readerboard signs within the City of Huntington Beach. Currently, Section 9610 .4 (a) of the Code prohibits "flashing, moving, pulsating or intermittently lighted signs including searchlights; except public service signs such as those for time and temperature. " Section 9610 .4(h) prohibits "changeable copy signs, including electronic readerboards; except theatre marquees . " The requested code amendment would amend these prohibitions to exempt electronic readerboards, add specifications and locational criteria for such signs, and amend certain definitions to accommodate the aforementioned changes . 3 . 0 ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Pursuant to the environmental regulations in effect at this time, the Department of Community Development posted cZraft Negative Declaration No. 88-39 for ten days, and ,no commeritk, either verbal or written were received:� The staff, in its initial study of the project, has recommended that. a negative declaration be .issued. Prior to Iany action on Code Amendment No. 88-14 it is necessary fo,r the Planning Commission to review and act on Negative Declaration A-F M-23C J No. 88-39 . Staff feels that, should the requested code amendment be approved, the suggested restrictions and criteria outlined in the attached draft ordinances will mitigate potentially adverse+ impacts to a level that is not significant pursuant to CEQA Guidelines . This does not mean, however, that all land use-related impacts will be completely eliminated, as further discussed below. 4 . 0 ISSUES AND ANALYSIS: Background: A similar Code Amendment (No . 87-15) to permit electronic readerboard signs was proposed by Wilson Ford earlier this year. The Planning Commission denied the request on March 28, 1988. The City Council, on appeal by the applicant, directed the Planning Commission to evaluate and make recommendation upon an alternative ordinance to allow electronic readerboards, subject to certain criteria, as recommended by the Planning Commission Subcomittee and the Department of Public Works . On May 3, 1988, the Planning Commission reaffirmed their previous action and recommended denial of the code amendment to the City Council. However, they also forwarded a list of recommended sign criteria for the Council ' s consideration, should the Council have chosen to approve the amendment. At the July 18, 1988 City Council meeting, a motion to disapprove Code Amendment No. 87-15 failed by a vote of 3 to 3 . Therefore, the Planning Commission' s denial prevailed. Analysis.: Code Amendment No. 88-14 as requested by the applicant consists of the suggested ordinance forwarded to City Council by the Planning Commission on May 3 , 1988, with two modifications . The maximum sign area requested is 175 square feet rather than 200 square feet, and an additional locational requirement is proposed which would limit the use of electronic readerboards to businesses that are located on minimum 2 acre parcels and rely upon the outdoor display of merchandise as the primary means of business . There are four primary issues involved in the code amendment: height, size, the concept of moving/changing message type signs and compatibility with other signs . a. Height : Since about 19741 no signs over 25 feet have been approved except through a variance (special sign permit) procedure based on the signs ' location ( i .e. adjacent to a freeway) . Tha. sign code from 1974 to 1986 permitted signs up to 20 feet in heighi within 20 feet of the front property line`: Those signs setback 21 feet or greater " could be up to 25 feet in height . Our current code limits sign height to 7 feet for parcels with less than 400 feet of frontage and to 15 feet for parcels with more than 400 feet of street frontage. Staff Report - 12/6/88 -2- ( 1609d) This is to reduce clutter of signs and to allow adequate exposure for larger parcels . This code amendment request is to allow signs up to 35 feet in height, which would be incompatible with other signs in the City established since 1974 and contrary to the current code . b. Size: Freestanding signs are currently limited to 70 square feet in size (80 square feet within an opaque background) on parcels with over 400 feet of frontage; parcels with less than 400 feet of frontage are limited to maximum 30 square feet of sign area (40 square feet with an opaque background) . Prior to 1986, the size limit was based upon one square foot of sign area per one lineal foot of lot frontage with maximum 100 square feet for signs within 12 feet of the front property line. A maximum of 150 square feet was permitted for signs within 13 to 20 feet of the front property line, and a maximum of 200 square feet for signs greater than 20 feet from the front property line. The varying setback requirement in relation to height was to reduce the impact of a large sign close to public streets . Proposed Code Amendment No . 88-14 is for a maximum 175 square foot sign area anywhere on the site (it may be within the front 25 foot building setback area) provided the site has a minimum 200 foot lot frontage. This size limit and location is incompatible with other signs constructed along Beach Boulevard since 1974 . Electronic readerboard signs greater than 15 feet in height and 70 square feet in size (current sign code limits) are more appropriate along freeways where the speed limit is 55 mph and there is not a mixture of vehicle/pedestrian flow. Beach Boulevard is posted maximum 45 mph and has sidewalks on both sides for pedestrian use. A high sign coupled with moving/changing messages can be distracting to motorists and increase the potential of vehicle/pedestrian conflict. In addition, higher signs are not necessary along Beach Boulevard. In the past, freestanding signs of 30 to 60 feet were erected to attract motorists from miles away. However, today' s urban development is too cluttered to allow for effective communication at this distance. Lower signs within the motorists direct cone of vision are more easily seen and read. C. Moving/Changing Type Signs : As mentioned before, electronic readerboards may also increase the risk of hazardous distraction to motorists . Use of flashing signs for advertising is visually demanding and may be confusing to drivers, thereby causing slowing of traffic on arterial highways and increasing potential vehicle/pedestrian conflict.$ . Staff recommends that the use of flashing, blinking, pulsating, or`i�otermittantly lighted signs be reserved'-for public safety, signalized intersections and driving safety/control messages to motorists . Or, if a changing message is necessary, require the message to remain on the board for no less than 10 seconds . Staff Report - 12/6/88 -3- (160.9d) i t d. Compatibility: The Huntington Beach sign code recently underwent extensive' review and amendment by the City Council, with input from the Planning Commission, Chamber of Commerce, and other business and citizen groups . The intent of the revised ordinance was to limit sign heights, reduce visual clutter, create a more aesthetically pleasing appearance to passing motorists and create more consistency between signage. These code changes were in response to the increasing urban character of the street scenes in Huntington Beach. At the time that previous Code Amendment No. 87-15 was processed, staff conducted a poll of all Orange County cities, and found very few that permit electronic readerboard signs . There are a few existing non-conforming signs, and some others allowed by variance. Some of these signs are located on surface streets, however most larger, taller electronic readerboard signs are adjacent to freeways . A table attached to this report lists the cities polled, their policies on readerboards, and the location of existing readerboards within those cities (Attachment No. 4) . Also attached is a table and map citing samples of readerboards in Orange and Los Angeles Counties (Attachment Nos . 5 and 6) . In addition, electronic readerboards are incompatible with residential uses . The majority of parcels along Beach Boulevard are approximately 300 feet deep and adjacent to residential uses . The signs can be obnoxious due to their glare and blinking . However, new technology can reduce glare and reduce their impact . Recommendation: Staff is recommending denial of the requested Code Amendment based on findings outlined by the Planning Commission in their denial of Code Amendment No . 87-15 in May, 1988, and the discussions herein. The Planning Commission found that electronic readerboard signs would serve to increase visual clutter along Beach Boulevard and possibly throughout the City, impact adjacent residents with light and glare, and allow possible distractions to motorists . Alternative Action: Should the Planning Commission wish to approve the requested code amendment, staff has prepared an alternative ordinance for consideration. The major differences between staff ' s recommended ordinance and the applicant ' s request are as follows : Staff Recommendation Applicant Recommendation Issue (if approved) (if 0proved) Max. Sign Height 15 ft.` 35 ft . with 10 ft . ground clearance Max. Sign Area 70 sq. ft. 175 sq. ft . Min. Lot Frontage 400 ft. 200 ft. Staff Report - 12/6/88 -4- (1609d) Staff Recommendation Applicant Recommendation Issue ( if approved) (if approved) Min. Lot Area None 2 acres Type of Business No restrictions 80% of merchandise in outdoor display; display/work areas must be min. 20% of site area Staff ' s alternative would assure size and height compatibility with other signs constucted since 1986 . The size limit of 70 square feet would allow for two or three lines of lighted messages and full character graphics on a more proportionate scale. In addition, without the type of business requirement, the code amendment would be applicable to all properties with over 400 feet of frontage regardless of the business type. Staff has received inquiries for electronic readerboards from non-outdoor display type businesses. Staff ' s alternative is basically designed within the framework of the existing sign code. Based on staff ' s proposed locational criteria, approximately 18 sites along Beach Boulevard and the freeway would be eligible to apply for electronic readerboard signs . This does not take into account possible lot consolidations to acheive the suggested 400 feet of lot frontage. Any request to exceed these standards would be based on a case by case analysis of the property and use pursuant to a special sign permit (variance) . As mentioned previously, the applicant has added two locational requirements to the previously proposed ordinance for Code Amendment No . 87-15 . These include a 2 acre minimum lot size and a requirement that a business utilize outdoor display for 80 percent of their merchandise. Such extensive use of outdoor display areas visible to passing motorists, however, would seem to reduce the need for additional signage, rather than increase it . Using the applicant ' s proposed locational criteria of minimum 2 acre lot size and 200 foot lot frontage, approximately 32 sites along Beach Boulevard and the freeway would be eligible for electronic readerboard signs . Again, this does not take into account possible lot consolidations to acheive the applicant ' s suggested lot frontage and lot size. 5 . 0 RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission deny Code Amendment No . 88-14 with the following findings : FINDINGS FOR DENIAL: 1. Since the Huntingtonµ Beach Ordinance Code, Article 961 allows adequate opportunities for advertising through various types of signage, Code Amendment No. 88-14 to allow electronic readerboard signs is not necessary for the preservation and enjoyment of substantial property rights . Staff Report - 12/6/88 -5- (1609d) S 2 . Electronic readerboard signs, if permitted by Code Amendment No. 88-14 , will be incompatible with surrounding exi'sting and proposed development, especially residential land uses . 3 . 'Electronic readerboard signs visible from City streets would have the potential of slowing traffic and distracting to passing motorists . 4 . Code Amendment No. 88-14 to permit 35 foot high, 175 square foot electronic readerboards would be incompatible with the majority of existing signs constructed throughout the City since 1974 . 5 . Code Amendment No. 88-14 for electronic readerboard signs are more appropriate adjacent to freeways where there is not a mixture of vehicle/pedestrian flow, there is a greater maximum speed limit, and less competition amongst signs . 6 . 0 ALTERNATIVE ACTION: (A) The Planning Commission may approve Negative Declaration No. 88-39 and Code Amendment No. 88-14 as proposed by the applicant (Attachment No . 1) , with findings; or (B) The Planning Commission may approve Negative Declaration No. 88-39 and Code Amendment No . 88-14 as modified by staff (Attachment No. 2) with findings . ATTACHMENTS: 1 . Ordinance proposed by applicant (No . - A) 2 . Ordinance as modified by staff (No. - B) 3 . Negative Declaration No. 88-39 4 . Table - Orange County Cities - Sign Policies 5 . Table - Sample Electronic Readerboards 6 . Map of Sample Electronic Readerboards 7 . Sample Readerboard per applicant ' s criteria SH:LP:kla Staff Report - 12/6/88 -6- (1609d) ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNAGE REQUIREMENTS BY CITY ORANGE COUNTY ERB Signs Prohibited How ERB City by Code Existing Signs Sign Permitted Anaheim No Anaheim Toyota Building Travel Lodge permits Pac-Tel Anaheim Hilton Anaheim Convention Center Embassy Suites Brea Yes None Buena Park Yes House of Imports Variance Costa Mesa Yes Harbor Plaza Planned Sign Program Fairgrounds Not under City jurisdiction Cypress Yes None City Council Fountain Yes None --- Valley Fullerton No None CUP Garden Grove Yes Orange County Volvo Approved with condition: 1 message change/ 24 hour period Irvine Yes None --- Laguna Beach Yes None Design Review Board La Habra Yes None Variance/CUP La Palma Yes None City Council Los Alamitos Yes None_ Planned Sign Program Newport Beach No None --- Orange No Rehabilitation Institute Design Review Board Placentia Yes None Variance ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNAGE REQUIREMENTS BY CITY (Continued) ERB Signs Prohibited How ERB City by Code Existing Signs Sign Permitted San Clemente Yes None Variance San Juan Yes None --- Capistrano Santa Ana Yes Santa Ana Auto Center Variance (Redevelopment Area) Seal Beach Yes None --- Stanton Yes None Variance Tustin Yes None --- Villa Park --- None --- Westminster Yes Centennial Thrift & Loan Variance Sunset Ford Variance Yorba Linda Yes None Variance OUTSIDE ORANGE COUNTY ERB Signs Prohibited How ERB City by Code Existing Signs Sian Permitted Arcadia Yes None --- Carson No Cormier Chevrolet Variance ITT Building Permit Carson Civic Center Exempt Compton Yes Auto Mall Redevelopment Area Downey Yes Embassy Suites Public Service Sign Duarte No Duarte Toyota Architectural Duarte Suzuki Board approval La Mirada Yes Gateway Plaza Redevelopment Agency ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNAGE REQUIREMENTS BY CITY (Continued) OUTSIDE ORAN CQUNTY ERB Signs Prohibited How ERB City by Code Existing Signs Sign Permitted Long Beach Long Beach Convention Center Monrovia Yes Auto Mall Variance Norwalk Yes Norwalk Toyota Sign Use Permit Ramada Inn (Variance) Pasadena No Pasadena Civic Center Building permit Hastings Ranch Shopping Nonconforming Center Santa Fe No, but Santa Fe Springs Plaza City-funded limited to project 10 acre sites South Gate No Pete Ellis Dodge Non-conforming Jeep/Eagle SAMPLES OF EXISTING ELECTRONIC READERBOARDS IN ORANGE AND LOS ANGELES COUNTIES + Size of Lines of Electronic Approximate Electronic Business Location Box Height Cogy Centennial Thrift NEC Beach and 3 ' x 20 ' 30 '-35 ' 1 & Loan Westminster 60 sq. ft. (Westminster) Sunset Ford* S. of Garden 7' x 35 ' 60 ' 3 Grove Blvd. 245 sq. ft. (west of Edwards) (Westminster) Orange County 10120 Garden 6' x 25 ' a 35 ' 3 Volvo Grove Blvd. 125 sq.ft . SWC (Garden Grove Blvd. and Brookhurst) (Garden Grove) Gateway Plaza* Valley View off 8 ' x 15 ' 50 ' 3 5 Freeway 120 sq.ft. (La Mirada) House of Imports* 6862 Manchester 8 ' x 25 ' 30 ' 3 Beach Boulevard 200 sq.ft. and 5 Freeway (Buena Park) Santa Fe Springs Off 605 Fwy. 8 ' x 25 ' 45 ' 3 Shopping Center on Telegraph 200 sq.ft . (Santa Fe Springs) Norwalk Toyota 11530 Firestone 6 ' x 25' 40 ' 2 Blvd. (Norwalk) 150 sq.ft. Ramada Inn* 14299 Firestone 8 ' x 30 ' 93 ' 3 Boulevard off 240 sq.ft. � . 5 Freeway (Norwalk) - *Freeway visibility Size of - Lines of " 3 Electronic Approximate Electronic Rosiness Location Box Height Copy Embassy Suites 8425 Firestone 6 ' x 18 ' 35 '-40 ' 3 Blvd. (Downey) 108 sq. ft. Pete Ellis Dodge 5800 Firestone 5 ' x 25 ' 55 ' 3 Jeep/Eagle Blvd. (Firestone 125 sq. ft. exit off Long Beach Freeway) (South Gate) Cormier Chevrolet* Wilmington @ 8 ' a 25 ' 110 ' 3 405 Freeway 200 sq. ft. (Carson) ITT* Wilmington @ 4 ' x 18 ' 45 ' 3 405 Freeway 72 sq. ft. (Carson) Carson Civic 701 E. Carson 6 ' x 18' 15 ' 3 Center (Carson) 108 sq. ft. Monument Anaheim Toyota* 1601 S. Anaheim 8 ' x 25 ' 50 ' 3 Blvd. (Harbor 200 sq. ft. exit off 5 Freeway) (Anaheim) Travel Lodge* 1221 S. Harbor 6 ' x 18' 30 ' 3 Blvd. (Harbor 108 sq. ft. exit off 5 Freeway) (Anaheim) Pac-Tel* (Harbor exit 5 'x 21' 30 ' 2 off 5 Freeway) 105 sq. ft. (Anaheim) Anaheim Hilton 777 West 6 ' x 18 ' 25 ' -30 ' 3 Convention Way 108 sq. ft. (Katella/Harbor) (Anaheim) w Anaheim Convention 800 W. Katella 6 ' it 25 ' 35-40 ' 3 Center (Kate1T'a/Harbor) 150 sq. ft. (Anaheim) Embassy Suite* Glassel off 6 ' x 18 ' 50 '-60 ' 3 91 Freeway 108 sq. ft . *Freeway visibility 1 V Size of Lines of Electronic Approximate Electron Business Location Box Height Copy Santa Ana Auto (Edinger Exit 5 ' x 17 ' 60 ' 3 Center* off 55 Freeway) 85 sq. ft . (Santa Ana) Orange County Fairgrounds* Fair/55 Freeway 5 ' x 20 ' 20 ' 2 .(Costa Mesa) 100 sq. ft. Harbor Plaza 2300 Harbor 5 ' x 20 ' 30 ' 1 Boulevard . 100 sq.ft. (Harbor/Wilson) (Costa Mesa) Compton Auto* Harbor Freeway 10 ' x 36 ' 85 ' 3 Plaza @ Artesia 360 sq. ft. (Compton) Pasadena Civic 300 E. Green 6 ' x 16 ' 15 ' 2 Center (Public (Green and Los 96 sq. ft. Monument Service Robles) Announcements (Pasadena) Hastings Ranch Rosemead/ 3 ' x 25 ' 40 ' 1 Shopping Center Foothill 75 sq. ft. (Pasadena) Duarte Toyota* (Buena Vista 7 ' x 36 ' 55 ' 3 Exit off 210 252 sq. ft. Freeway) (Duarte) Duarte Suzuki* (Buena Vista 7 ' x 30 ' 55 ' 3 Exit off 210 210 sq. ft. Freeway) (Duarte) Rehabilitation 1800 E. LaVeta 9 ' x`L',� 30 ' 1 Institute .-,(Tustin Blvd. 9 sq. ft. north of 22 Freeway) (Orange) *Freeway visibility Size of Lines.. of Electronic Approximate Electronic Business Location Boa Height Copy Long Beach 300 E. Ocean n/a n/a n/a Convention Center Blvd. (Long Beach) *Freeway visibility Y Eck V pigg IVA WRA Niw*4 it WINE M)O LL ,��nTE ll/ Ra ��<A��t1lee�iil'NF�'t�11a4MF8D� r F fp tGif+O. I� L;�+tL1pf�.tWJ►�11�ATIOt.I,' O e Node v to P �,tea• 0 EL E•ir� = tx�u � Lc�r.1 �t6 1.� �:�! ORAFT C-2 CODE AMENDMENT NO. 88-14/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 88-39 APPLICANT: GARY GRAY - HUNTINGTON JEEP/EAGLE Code Amendment No. 88-14 and Negative Declaration No. 88-39 were continued from the Planning Commission meeting of December 13, 1988, at the applicant ' s request. Code Amendment No. 88-14 and Negative Declaration No. 88-39 constitute a request to amend Article 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code (Sign Code) to permit the use of electronic readerboard signs within the City of Huntington Beach. Currently, Section 9610 .4(a) of the Code prohibits "flashing, moving, pulsating or intermittently lighted signs including searchlights; except public service signs such as those for time and temperature. " Section 9610 . 4(h) prohibits "changeable copy signs, including electronic readerboards; except theatre marquees . " The requested code amendment would amend these prohibitions to exempt electronic readerboards, add specifications and locational criteria for such signs, and amend certain definitions to accommodate the aforementioned changes . ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Pursuant to the environmental regulations in effect at this time, the Department of Community Development posted draft Negative Declaration No . 88-39 for ten days, and no comments, either verbal or written were received. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Deny Code Amendment No. 88-14 with findings . THE PUBLIC HEARING WAS OPENED Rick Evans, Vice-President of Huntington Jeep/Eagle, spoke in support of the code amendment. He said electronic readerboards were a necessity for automobile dealers along Beach Boulevard due to the increased competition from auto malls . Rod Wilson, Electra-Media, spoke in support of the code amendment. He said with approval of an electronic readerboard sign all existing signs would be removed from the dealership property thus cleaning up and improving the area. He also said the dealership was in agreement with all requirements and conditions addressing the concerns of adjacent property owners . He gave additional statistics on the safety of electronic readerboards . Eric Weber, 18292 Pammy Lane, spoke in opposition to the code amendment . He feels Beach Boulevard has its own recognition and does not have to compete with auto malls . He would like to see a regulation imposed on the visual clutter on Beach -Boulevard. PC Minutes - 1/4/89 -5- (1931d) DRAFT Jeff Lebow, 18271 Pammy Lane, representing 60 adjacent neighbors, spoke in opposition to the code amendment . He said the quality of life needs to be protected in this matter and requested the property owners/residents be given consideration. There were no other persons present to speak for or against the code amendment and the public hearing was closed. Majority of the Commission were opposed to electronic readerboards on Beach Boulevard because of aesthetics, safety and visual pollution. They felt they should be located along the freeway. A large readerboard at the corner of Beach Boulvard and the 405 freeway was suggested. A MOTION WAS MADE BY SLATES, SECOND BY ORTEGA, TO DENY CODE AMENDMENT NO. 88-14 AND NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 88-39 WITH FINDINGS, BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: Slates, Livengood, Leipzig, Ortega, Higgins NOES: Williams, Bourguignon ABSENT: None ABSTAIN: None MOTION PASSED FINDINGS FOR DENIAL: 1. Since the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, Article 961 allows adequate opportunities for advertising through various types of signage, Code Amendment No. 88-14 to allow electronic readerboard signs is not necessary for the preservation and enjoyment of substantial property rights . 2 . Electronic readerboard signs, if permitted by Code Amendment No . 88-14, will be incompatible with surrounding existing and proposed development, especially residential land uses . 3 . Electronic readerboard signs visible from City streets would have the potential of slowing traffic and distracting to passing motorists . 4 . Code Amendment No . 88-14 to permit 35 foot high, 175 square foot electronic readerboards would be incompatible with the majority of existing signs constructed throughout the City since 1974 . 5 . Code Amendment No. 88-14 for electronic readerboard signs are more appropriate adjacent to freeways where there is not a mixture of vehicle/pedestrian flow, there is a greater maximum speed limit, and less competition amongst signs . PC Minutes - 1/4/89 -6- (1931d) i .h January 9, 1989 Members of the City Council Huntington Beach Civic Center Huntington Beach, CA 92646 SUBJECT: CODE AMENDMENT 86-14 Ladies and Gentlemen ; I am writing to urge you to uphold the Planning Commission ' s denial of Ordinance 8B-14 which seeks to allow electronic readerboards along Beach Boulevard . I am opposed to the amendment for the reasons outlined below. 1 . Electronic readerboards are by design an obnoxious form of advertising . The automobile dealers along Beach Boulevard presently have so many banners, balloons, signs, and others attention getting devices on their properties that the Council should consider an ordinance requiring the clean up the lots rather than permitting this additional form of visual .pollution . 2. The Electronic readerboards boards will not increase sales revenues to the dealers in Huntington Beach I fail to understand how the addition of electronic readerboards will help dealers in Huntington Beach better compete with the auto malls as discussed by the dealers at earlier public hearings. Advertisements along Beach Boulevard will create business for one HB dealer at the expense of another HB dealer. The only way to better compete with dealers in other cities is to construct the electronic reader boards along the freeway where they rightfully belong . In closing I remind you that this is not an isolated request but would pave the way for at least sixteen electronic boards all along Beach Boulevard . I urge you act responsibly and, uphold the Planning Commission ' s denial . cerely Dean Allison 20362 Bridgeside Lane #203 Huntington Beach, CA 92646 U Publish 1/20/89 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING APPEAL OF PLANNING COMMISSION DENIAL OF CODE AMENDMENT 8 8-14 ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNS NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements "of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE: Monday, February 6, 1989 TIME• 7 : 00 PM SUBJECT: Code Amendment No . 88-14/Negative Declaration No . 88-39 APPLICANT: Gary Gray - Huntington Jeep/Eagle APPELLANT: Councilman Silva LOCATION: City-wide PROPOSAL: Appeal of the Planning Commission' s denial of a request to amend Article 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, to permit electronic readerboard signs . ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Negative Declaration No . 88-39 will be considered by -Council in Conjunction with the request . ON FILE: A copy of the proposed Code Amendment is on file with the Department of Community Development ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. All applications, exhibits , and descriptions of this proposal are on file with the Office of the City Clerk, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, for inspection by the public . HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL By: Connie Brockway City Clerk Phone (714) 536-5404 Dated 1/17/89 Office tof the City Clerk ' T City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 ResL 791ident Huntington each, CA 92648 �i,�.,,��:i:a33:�� .r�x,�,,,��►a Office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Beach �a 30 J AN P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 Aroonsakool,_ ! : �tntinKCon (ie�tclt ,Cr�. �)2(�4Ii 15 9--Dyr4 t - � 1et7 `� Office of the City Clerk City of Huntingtori Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 1 .rr�llin_ijE1r lon r> i'r>1.i C i . 92647 y,�;,ter: ,n�u-ritin;rt gron°,.Beach r BOX 190 ctz CALIFORNIA 92648 v7 � } Circle A) n each, CA 92647 U , 1 i P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 1)32-1.0 011 13<:[�c11 ( <i . 92047 t/ Office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 ; VAN MAL,EN, DAVID K 16663 ARBOR CIR 92647 hWlTINGTON ©EACIij CA 0 .,r•u''-.. „ r;a i:::::.r'i.) :. (,'F.::"I'l.li��:i'? ..t't:i :;l:::i'•11:ii::a�: , __ -=ua1�1L1�1V11 1DCacn P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 CARI.5tlt1, JAMES 16731 APIW[; C R IIUNTIt1G1Uli 6EACH, CA 92647 ..'`7 i:]...l,.J.t. 11.i.:" A:.`•Ti is}':%' r^ bi is F•1i:1 r���i::Jl:?i�;l:i:faf Vince of Uitl%,Ity City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 LAIIAA, N A 1661 U 49, 1 11 T I H, 4 JC t;I4' 'lydjk?r);1P CH CA 926,0 r v Office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 TOt y� LOPEZr L �@ 'F%� ' IS635 A 92647 - CH NUNTIN1 N� �F 141:31 ''rt'ii;.5NJ. -4; I 1::',f,(.)It:i•! 1,C) Dr-4 (".1.1J:,:. �.)1'�E�iIr;L..I:L I t.l i•'t.11•ta,`!!••ii•il.; f f Office of the City Clerk fl City of Huntington Beach P.O.sox 190 r CALIFORNIA 92648 J - Resident t 7881 Beachpoint Cir, 144 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 ! a _ I i t Office of the City Clerk ) city of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 4 Hilly STEPHEN DOUGLAS 16633 ARBOR CIR 42647 / HUNTINGTON BEACHP CA ' f I !i f ii ii i ii j i is j I I l Publish 1/20/89 .NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING APPEAL OF PLANNING Cf"'LISSION DENIAL OF CODE AXEN17t4ENT 8 8-14 ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNS NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Bach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE: Monday, February 6 , 1989 TIME: 7 : 00 PM SUBJECT: Code Amendment No . 88-14/Negative Declaration No . 88-39 APPLICANT: Gary Gray - Huntington Jeep/Eagle APPELLANT: Councilman Silva LOCATION: City-wide PROPOSAL: Appeal of the Planning Commission ' s denial of a request to amend Article 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, to permit electronic readerboard signs . ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Negative. Declaration No . 88-39 will be considered by Council in Conjunction with the request . ON FILE: A copy of the proposed Code Amendment is on file with the Department of Community Development ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said nearinq and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the applicatic . as outlined above. All applications, exhibits , and descriptions 3�f this proposal are on file with the Office of the City Clerk, 20Ci Main Street, Huntington Beach, California, for inspection by th• public. HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL By: Connie Brockway City Clerk Phone (714) 536-5404 Dated 1/17/80 L%\# w R� � � � - 300' Owner list M & I, Leihu Corp. qn-1U-UF35 /( r �F S.7 Magnolia v 1 Cohen A/P R14?.-4G2-OG „Whe:im,Ca.92804 7852 Arbor (;J.z. 106"l _-. I 142--4f31-04 ,rz �� S, IluriLi.rt Yton Beach,Ca.92647 W. 142-481--05 932-10-086 1673 ..l Be T.Nguyen P & U Uev. 6732 Beach B.1vd • 8762 Sa.i:.lport Dr, 8071 Slater. Ave. l ./, IlUnti.ngton Beach ,Ca. 92647 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92646 Ilunt�.ngton Beach,Ca.92G47 ]07-601-41 I 1.42-681-06,07 932_10-087 107-601-47 I H.H.8. Pareklt M. ( ureshi A.13enites I 8636 99`ll Mammoth Dr. i 7856 Pr-OducLion Ave. STE, Arbor Ci.r. ]litn tang t.on ,Ca 92646. IlO"ng tun Leach,Ca,c San Ueigo,Ca .'JZ121 Beach I J2647 1�r2-481-U8 932-10-088 107-691-20 I.Newman N I).13radCord Nero Arl: Mnsao 16312 Mandalay Cir. 1 1854 Boa Vista Cir ' . WestBulsa Ave. Huntington 13each,Ca. 92649 Costa Mesa ,Ca . r estminisLer,Ca • 926E33 J2626 I 142_-481-09 932-10-089 10?-691-22 K.Part D.Gun n Ford Leasing Development P.O. Box 6094 7841 43336 P.O. Bur, Arbor Cir, Huntington 13each,Ca • 91615 Huntington 13each,Ca.c DC L r10 C ,^11 4824 3 J264 7 932-10-090 14"1-181-U5 'I` Ilambl.y Co. N V 142--481.--10 N. .i-nkham 16761 1 i.cr:IpuinC Ln . D.11ydinger 7832 Arbor Cir.IlUnti.ngLon Boach ,(.a . 92667 16372 Thames LN , Ilunl.:i.n bton Beach,Cr1.92647 Huntington Burch ,Ca . 92647 I i 142-462-00 American MoLors Realty 142-481-JZ 932-10-091 27777 l�rankl i.n Rd . 'l'.13ernat' � ,l. 11eschlce SoutbCield ,Pl1 48034 gran e, Kt:rl2667 Ave. 11'2_03 7865 Arbor Ci:r. Orange,Ca.92667 Huntington Beach ,Ca .92647 142-462-09 A13KO XXXI1.1 inc. 932-10-81. 932-1.0-092- P.O. Box 191() j D. Bert-.ra` d J. Packi., De.LrioL,,�11 4s;�'88 12562 Dale St . #23 � 2461.1 Via Ra?a Carden Grove,Ca .92641 ; El "Toro,Ca .92630 i 932-10-082 932-10-093 142-487-U1 L.See1.cY A. Lane L.Cooke 16912 Green SL . 114 252.62 A1dea Ct. 15103 Creystone I;rrnLingLon 8each ,Ca . 92649 Mission Vei.jo,Gr .92691 I Norrva.l.k,C.a90650 1 932-10-083 481-U 932-10 094 CA 1_ D. ,Lee Duarte Prop. UCA G. 7836 Arbor Cir. 8071 Slater #140 18201 .Ivory Coast Ln. I Huntington 1.3each ,C.a92647 Ilunt:i:nt,t.ort 13cach,C..t.92647 IlinrCingCort Beach,Ca• 92648 I � 142-481-03 932-10-084 n.Serra -M.,Jacobseir - - 932-.10-095 1.6651 Peale l.,n . 7838 Arbor C:(r . C, • Anderson IfUnti.np,l-on 1.3e�ach ,s��.9264) ' 11340 L:uc.l. id. SL. c Huntington Be�ach,C.a92647 j Fountain Va:l.le C Y, a.92708 W.Wamhoff L.Haynes 121P. 2 Park St. , 1.8341 Pammy Ln, 18202 Sharon Ln. 212 Par ; , Huntington Beach Ca92648 Hunti.ng.ton Bench,Ca .92648 Huntington Reach Ca.92648 159-iA3-02 159-043-08 15.9-271-06 J.Arimond P.Contreras 18351 Pammy Ln, J.Bartok 1.8271 Pammy Ln, j Huntington Beach ,Co.92648 Huntington Beach,(4.92648 181.96 Sharon Ln. �c 1 1.59-043-00 Huntbigton Belch J 92648 1�)-043-03 1.59-271-07 J, .Cummings ll.L:i.n 18291 Pammy Ln, I A.Negret.e 18391 Pammy L.n, 18205 Sharon Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-043-04 I Huntington BeHch ,Ca .92648. Iluntiii �ton Beach Ca.92Ei4f.3 . 1' 159-043-10 159-271-61 I I A.Pii H nif.i.ngt.on Village 18301.I Pammy L � W.7.a.leski_ y n 7560 Valley ' V:i.sta 17171 Beach Blvd. Huntington lieach ,Cn .92648 IlUnt :ngton Beach,Ca.92647 159-043-05 Yucca All.ey,Ci .92284 1.59-271-63 159-043-11 L.Aroonsakool 18311 Pammy Ln , Huntington Rench ,Q. 92648 159-043-06 0.Fol care II i Y.I'ark 18321 Pammy L,n , 18212 Sharon Ln . Huntington Reach ,Cn.92648 i Huntington Beach Ca .92648 1.59-043-07 1>9-271-05 I W.Turner. tom•..King 18381 Pammy Ln. 1308 Shadow Oak Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Malvern,PA 1.935.5 1597043-01 2 1 59-271-66 S.Ekstedi. Bank Of America 78.36 Connie Dr, 'Trust Real Estate Huntington Beach Ca.92648 P.O. Box 60564 159-271-01 Los Angeles ,Ca.90051 159=271-67 P.Albert A & E .Investments LTD 7842 Connie Ln . 15300 Ventura Blvd.N320 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 Sherman Oaks,Ca.91403 159-271-02 930-401-434 O.Rosa.les 7846 Connie Ln. Huntington Reach ,Ca .92648 1.59-271-03 t cy R..Stellrech C)C, P.O. Box 1786 (� Huntington Beach Q. 92648 � �1 1.59-271-04 Cj f. 932=10-096 932-10-107 v4 932-10-118 S. Anzis `Goan (�< (� F `�.. 17510 Santa Domingo Cir. r�O3 Arbor C :ir. 1665i4 Arbor C.ir. PounLi 11) Val.1.ey ,Ca.92708 Huntington 13each ,Ca. 92647 Hull Li.ngLon I3each,Ca.92.647 932-10-097 932-10-108 932=10.119 M.ShafCer I .Clooten L.Markus 1. 5261. Victoria I.n. 7807 Arbor Cir. 166.56 Arbor Cir. IluntingLon 13each,C.02647 Huntington I3each,Co.92647 IluntingLon Beach,Ca.92647 932-10-098 932-10-109 932-1-0-1.20 M.Nesbit 'T.I3renthall- D._I3ehrendL 7832 Arbor Mr, 16682Arbor Mr. 16658 Arbor Mr. IluntingLon 13enuh ,C.a92647 IlrrnUngton 13each,Ca.92647 (luntingLon,(3eacll ,Ca.92647 932-10-099 93 2-10-0110 932-10-12.1 W.Coshowe F.Mohamed S.MarLinez. 7825 Arbor Cir. 5082 Loyola Ave. 1_6651 Viewpoint Ln. IluntingLon Reach,C.a92647 Westmin:i_sLer,Ca.92683 IlunLi_ngLon Beach,, 92647- 932-10-100 932-10-111 932-10-122 K . Ue Mille C.Sm:i.Lh i3.Ui_eson Y.O. Box 3202 1 16686 Arbor Cir. 16653 Viewpoint Ln. Manhattan 13each,Ca. 9_0266 IIUntinyon 13each,C.02647 lluntington I3each,Ca. 92647 932-10-101 932-10-112 932-10-0123 D. Ilickman G.Ilopk_i.ns R.Cec:i 781 1 Arbor Ci r . 1638 Pebblc+_ Beaclr Ur, 1029 Westward bray Huntington Uncli ,Q.-92.647 IIoF man Estai.es, k OOJ94 Costa Mcsn,Cs.92626 932-10-102 932-10-1.1.3 932-1:0-124 R. I,a v igne F. NO la N.DUgn n 21 112 Tirif C Mi . 16672 Arbor C.i_r, 16657 Viewpoint Ln. 11UnLi.ngton 13ench ,C;.a92647 Hunt:i:ngton 13each ,C.-a92647 Huntington 13each,Ca. 112647 9 , - , 32 1()-tU_3 932-10-0114 932-1U-1.1_5 11. Hubbard F.Parks R.Cochran 1 8£321 Arcel Cir. 8332 Tyler Cir. 16671 Viewpoint Ln. HUnCington Beac_hKa92647 11Uni.i.nbion 13each ,Ca.92647 Huntington Beachja. 92647 r i i 9'32- .10-104 932-10-115 932-1O-126 Y . Purdue K.Wei5s- 13. 13rad ley 7817 Arbor Cir. 18185 Santa Adel_.l_a Cir. 1.6673 Viewpoint, Ln. Huntington 13cach ,Ca .92647 Fountain Val._1_ey,C.892708 IluntingLon 13each,Ca. 92647 i PII.R u y f-105 932-10-1 1 6 932-10-1 27 -Ruy( 7801 Arbor Ci.r. L. Arno Ld C.Cofoner 8926 Yuba River Ave , 16675 Viewpoint Ln. 1 hunting-Lon Reach,Ca .92647 Fountain Val_Ley,Ca .92708 Iluntington U'each,Ca.. 92647 )32-10-10(i 93'L-10-117 c 932-10-128 i T. Roberts T.Skeren T.Kramer Arbor Cir. 16652 Arbor Mr. NMI Capulce Dr. }iunG .ngto+n_ 13c�ach,Ca . 92647 IIUnt:i.ngLon Beach Ca . 926[r7 Yorba 1,.inda,(:6.92686 1 932-10-129 9.32--10-1.40 Ashlee Investments J.1{o senstie..i 2855 T. Coast Hwy 2515 E. Jamison St. Cr;.rona Del. Mar,Ca .92-626 Anahe i.m,Ca.92806 P S � 932-10-130 932-10-i41. J.Foreman J.He l.ler 1790 Crestmont Pl . 16721 Viewpoint Ln. Costa Mesa,C.a92627 lf(fnting-t:on L'each,C.a.92647 932-10-131 932-10-142 A.Degenhardt D.Lor-enzerr 13272 Whitney Ci.r , 16725 Viewpoint Ln. Westminist:er-,C.a92683 Huntington 13each,Ca,92647 932-1(t-13"l. 932-10-144 M.Cal loway 450 Sharon Dr .- 270 S. SOJoamon Dr. In alma,Ca.?)623 Anaheim,ca.92807 932-10-1 33 932710-14 5 A.Beall J.Rvans 16691 Viewpoint l,n , 167.31 Viewpoint Ln . Huntington Reach ,Ca.92647 Huntington 13each ,Ca.92647 932-1O-1 36 932-10--1.46 Y.Perdu(, H.Wri_ght. 218 min St . 1673.3 V:i-ewpoint Ln. IiUnti-ng(.on heach ,C.a92648 Huntington 1-1ench,Ca.92647 c)32-1(1-135 932-10-14 7 M.R% Wylva 1 66Q') V i ewl)()i u t. Ln. 15392 Andaman Ln . HuntingLnn Heach ,Ca-.92647 Huntington 93r;ach,CW2649 932-10-136 932-10-148 C.Oathout J.Wr.ight 16697 Vicrwpoi.nt_ Ln, 16092 Wi-ndemelr Q. Huntington Reach,0 32647 Huntington Reac:h ,C W2647 ]3.'1'V�orntc,n 1 671 1 'viewpoint [Ln . Huntington Beac_-h ,Ca .9-2647 932-10-1-38 A. Lopez 6881 Via Caroua Huntington Reach,C.0264'7 932-10-1:39 Duarte Prop 8071. Slater AVe. #1135 ilunting't.on Beach ,Ca.92647 $!Wilson K.Nc Cormick `..Belden 15611 Taylor- Ave. - 9440 Siskin Ave. I 18302 Pammy Ln.. Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Fountain Valley ,Ca .92708 ! Huntington Beach,C.a92648 157-351-02 157493-01 159-041-05 Scott Center '&Horowitz P. Bruckner Jr. i L.Byhower 18312 Pammy Ln. 217 S. Violet Ln. 18222 Beach Blvd . lHuntington Beach,C.a92648. Orange,Ca.92669 Huntington Beach ,Ca .92648 I 1159-041-06 1.57-352-05 � 157-493-02 C.Nc Rae 8002 Taylor St. A. De Grout D.Gaiefski Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 10072 Overhi.11 Dr. 118322 Pammy Ln. 157-352-06 Santa Ana,Ca.92705 Huntington Beach,Ca .92648 157=493-03 ;159-041-07 A.`l'omo.t i I G:Gaskins 1.1063 Tilton Cir , R.Narctui.s 18342 Pammy Ln. Founti.an Vall.ey,Ca.92708 18202 Beach Blvd. c I lltlnt:ington Beach,Ca.92648 1.57-352-07 Huntington Beach ,Ga. 92648 157-493-04 i '159-041-08 I ' H.Abel br:ight Lam 640 Via Lido Nord D.Le Beau ).1'..Lam Pammy Ln. Newt�ort .13each,Ca.92GG3 8052 Kiner Ave. I HUntin.g ton Beach,Ca.92648 159-031-01. Huntington Beach,Ca .92648 157-493-14 159-04.1-09 L,.Nichol.sori I; P. Nart:ignoni. 419 El Modena F.Magdal.eno 18362 Pammy Ln. St . Newport l3eaclr,Ca.92663 8062 Kiner i � HUntngton Beach,Ca.92648 159-031-22 Huntington Beach ,Ca .92648 ! 1.59-041-010 157-493-15 I ' T. Day N.Vanagas G.Herst 1.188 Hummingbird Ln , j 1510 N. State College Blvd , 18372 Pammy Ln. Corona,Ca.9.1720 j Anahei.m,Ca.92806 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-031-24 157-341-01 1597041-1.1. I T,Parks I N.Nunkeby M.Gangemi 18252 Pammy Ln. 20901 Pioneer Blvd. ! 18382 Pammy Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca .92648 Lakewoocl ,Cn.9071.5 I, HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 1 157-341-02 c 159-04].-01 I � 51. )-041—.1.'2 f F.Alvarez C. Rut.h F.AJ_varez 18262 Pammy Ln. 8001 Taylor Ave. ;j 1.8392 Pammy Ln . Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach,Ca•92648 HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-041-02 03 157-351-01 159-04.1.-13 P.Nehall ].F.3292 C;.292 Pammy 7812 Taylor Ave. auuuy l.,n• - ---_; Huntington Beach,G.a92648 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-041.-0/i � 159-0�+3-U1 I M & L Leibu Corp. / 911-10-08.5 3UU' Owner list 6 S. Magnolia v 1 . ✓./ — A/Y R142--462-OG '7� $ Cohen Whe:im,Ca.92804 7852 Arbor 142-48.1-U4 (-/ z S' 11 Li"g,tan 13each,Ca.92047 �7 7- 142-481--05 932-10-086 tJ.PIi.Lier T.Nguyen P & H Dev. 10732 Beach 131vd . i 8762 Sa.i..l_port Dr. 92646 8071 S1aLer Ave.IlUnti.ngton Beach,Ca.92647 Jluntington Beach ,Ca. 111.4 1(j7-6U.1-41 - Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 I 142-481-06,07 ! 932-10-087 107-60.1-47 I M. Qureshi1 A.13eni.tes H.B. Parekh 9921 Mammoth Dr. 7856 Arbor 8636 Produc_ti.on Ave. STE Ilunt:ingLon 92 BeAch ,Ca , 92646 Huntington Beach,Ca:91647 San Dei.go,Ca. 121 142-481-0,3 932-10-088 107-691-20 I .Newman D,BradLord i;erio Art Plnsao 16312 Mandalay Cir. i 1854 Boa Vista 9340 Bo_lsa Ave. Huntington unti.ngLorr 13each,Ca .92649 I Costa Mesa ,Ca.92626 tJestminister,Ca . 91683 i I 142-481-09 937-1U-089 107-691-22 R.Pan D.Gunn Ford Leasing Development P.U. Box 6094 7841. Arbor Cir,1'.0. Box. 43330 Huntington Beach, , 91615 Huntin Lon 13each,Ca,c DeLriot ;Ml 48243 g )2647 932--1 U-09() lamb y Co. --142481.-10 R.Ti-nkham HarnbJ.}- Co. N V -1),II din �r 78:32 Arbor (�' 10761 Vi.ti•,p0inL Ln . } g ` Qr. IlUnti.ngtun Lenc.li ,Ca . ) t26f - 16372 Thames LN. I HuntingtonBeach,Cn.92647 i 7 HunUngton Beach ,Cyr . 92647 I 1 r,2-462-(.)tr American NoL(115. Realty 142-481-12 932-10-091 T.13ernaLz J. Reschke 27777 Franklin Rd . 2914 E. KaLelln Ave. N203 Southfield J11 48034 786 i Arbor Cir. Orange,Ca.92667 Huntington Beach,Gri.92647 142-462-09 932-10-£31 c) r A13KO XXXll..i Inc. _32 LU-U)2 P.O. Box 1919 D. Hertrand I J. Packi.: Uetriot,Ml 4f; ;38 12562 We St . #23 2.4611 Via Raw Carden Grove,Ca. 92641 Bi `Ioro,Ga :926:30 932-10-082 932-.10-093 142-481-U1 A. Lane L.Seeley L.Coo& I.5262 Atde�� C:t. � 16912 Green SL . #4 15103 Creystone ach,Ca . 4'l6(�9 Mission Vei.jo,Ca.92691 I Norwa.l.k,C.a90650 {:untirigton Bc .' I 932-10-083 932.-10-094 142-481-02 D. ,l..ee Duarte Prof. OCA G. ! 7-836 Arbor: Cir. £307.1 Slater N-140 18201 .ivory Co,ist Ln . Huntington Beach,CW2647 HunLi:ngLon 0each,Ca.92617 Hun ingCon Beach ,Ca. 92648 I 142-481-03 932-10-084 n.serre M.Jacobsen 932-10-095 10651 Peale Ln . C„ Anderson -. . 7838 Arbor C:ir. 17340 Euclid St. 11UnLingLon HeOch Ca.92649 Huntington Beach,C.02647 i Fountain Val.ley,Ca.92708 1I.B. Chamber of Commerce j 2 ; 3 Main Street, #22 / Huntington Beach, CA 92648 ATTN: Kim Barone Huntington Beach Co. , 2110 Main Street H. Beach, CA 92648-2499 ATTN: R. J. Work ( [1 1 HB/FV Board of Realtors J 8101 Slater Avenue Huntington Beach, CA 92647 ATTN: Judith Severy Building Indust-ry Assn.-O.C. 2001 F. 4th Street Santa Ana, CA U Legal Notice City of Huntington Beach T 1 Office of the City Clerk PNA' P. O. Sox 190 9 Huntington Bach, CA 92648; w�`� �' ►� N �n '`• F 1 `�� (ri MAR ,w ; a.�•�`'"" r. jk yk 04 E' uf'►?—� N 'WP MEMORIAL PARK r HININGTO� CH ,CA. 92EE3 ,�WW U� F RSTGLASS MAIL 9 uHiC8 Ot the City Clerk City of Huntington Beach P.O. BOX 190 r yti tfORNiA 648 J.Arimond 18271 Pammy Ln, Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 F5 !+3-03 / Legal Notice City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk " P. O. Box 190 � Y; 1 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 J 1� 932-10-090 REl�j� R.Tinkham FQ STo `�o Arbor Cir. 4743 92b47 F"o�R ® untinQrnn Rna�h r, o-)r-/.-711UklTli�GTON BCH, CA ® �i: T P;C t R FIRST CLASS MAIL _ MUNTINGTON BEACH t ` M Legal Notice City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P. O. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 ; * a r ry � `cec W.Miller Errs asrURti HUntington Beac , 7 107-601-41 FIRST' CLASS MAIL HUNTINGTON BEACH �'C( h4 f'. - i .. Office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Bcach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 j M. Nesbit 7823 Arbor Circle Huntington Beach, CA 92647 932-10-098 ✓t: F Office of the City Clerkov r % City. of Huntington Bcach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 932-10-90 R. Tinkam 7843 Arbor Circle .Huntington Beach, CA 92647 300' Owner list M & L Leibu Corp. / 9'?_10_085 / &0:��' �'�"�� a A/P #142-462-06 r/ n6 S. Magnolia `open v heirn,Ca.92804 i, _ Arbor Cir. 142-481-04 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 W.Miller 142-481.--05 932-10-086 16732 Beach Blvd. T.Nguyen P & H Dev. HUntington Beach,Ca.92647 j 8762 Sailport Dr. 8071 Slater Ave.#14 107-601-41 Huntington Beach,Ca.92646 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 107-601-47 142-481-06,07 932-10-687 11.13. Parekh M. Qureshi A.Benites 8636 Production Ave. STE 9921 Mammoth Dr. 7856 Arbor Cir. San Deign Ca.92121 Huntington Beach,.Ca. 92646 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 107-691-20 142-481-08 932-10-088 Nerio Art Masao I.Newman D.Bradford 9340 I3olsa Ave. 16312 Mandalay Cir. 1854 Boa. Vista C.i-r, Westminister,Ca.92683 Huntington Beach,Ca.92649 Costa Mesa,Ca.92626 107-691-22 1.42-481-09 932-10-089 Ford Leasing Development R.Pan D.Gunn P.O. Box 43330 P.O. Box 6094 7841 Arbor Cir. Detriot,11,1.1 48243 Huntington Beach,Ca, 91615 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 142-181-05 142--481-10 932-10-090 Hambly Co. N V D.Hydinger R.Tinkharn 16761 Viewpoint Ln. 16372 I'liames LN• 7832 Arbor Cir. Huntington Benclr,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 Hunt:i-ngton Beach,&.92647 142-462-06 142-48.1-12 932-10-091 American Motors Realty. '1'.Bernatz J.Reschke 27777 Franklin Rd. 2914 E. Katella Ave.#203 7845 Arbor Cir. Southf.ield ,M1 48034 Orange,Ca.92667 Huntington Beacfi,Ca,.92647 142-462-09 932--10-81 932-1.0-092 ABKO XXXIII Inc. D.Bertrand J.Packi• P.O. Box 1919. 12562 Dale St. #23 24611 Via Raza Detriot,MI 48288 Garden Gr-ove,Ca.92641 El Toro,Ca.92630 142-481-01 932-10-082 932.-1.0-093 A.Lane L.Seeley L.Cooke 16912 Green St.#4 25262 Aldea Ct. 15103 Greystone huntington Beach,Ca.92649 Mission Vei.jo,Ca.92691 Norwal.k,C.a90650 . 142-481-02 932-10-083 932-10-094 OCA G. D. ,Lee Duarte Prop. 1820.1 Ivory Coast 1,n. 7836 Arbor Cir. 807.1 Slater #140 Huntington Beach,Ca..926.48 Huntington Beach,C.a92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 142-481-03 932-10-084 A.serra 932-10-095 P1.Jacobse'r Q .Anderson 16651 Peale I,n. 7838 Arbor C:ir. 17340 Euclid. St. Huntington 13each,Ca.92649 Huntington Beach,C.a92647 Fountain Val.l.ey,Ca.92708 932-10-129 9.32-10-1.40 Ashlee Investments J.Rosenst.i.e1 � 2855 E. Coast flwy 2515 E. Janri_son St. I C,-mona Del Mar,Ca.92626 Analie_i.m,Ca.92806 932-10-130 9.32-10-1.41. J.Foreman J.Heller 1790 Crestmorit Pl. 167.21 Viewpoint Ln. Costa Mesa,C.a9.2627 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 932-10-131 932-10-1.42 A.Degenhardt D.Lorenzen 13272 Whitney. Cir, 16725 Viewpoint Ln. Westministe.r,C.a92683. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 932-10-132 932-10-144 L.Frisbi.e M.Gal,l.oway 4531 Sharon Dr. 270 S. Sol.oalnon Dr. La alma,Ca.90623 Anaheim,ca.9280.7 932-10-133 932-10-1.45 A.Beall J.Evans 16691 Viewpoint I,n. 16731 Viewpoint Ln. HuntJngt:on Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 932-10-134 932-10-I46 Y.Perdtie 11.Wri.ghv. 218 Main St. 16733 Viewpoint Ln.. 11Untington Beach ,C.a92648 Huntington Be.ach,Ca.92647 932-10-135 932-10-147 M.Uh1er J.Sy.lva 16695 V:iewpoi.nt. Ln. 15392 Andaman Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 1luntingt:on Beach,C.a92049 932-10-1.30 932-10-1.48 C.Oathout J.Wright 16697 Viewpoint Ln. 16092 W .nderneir Ln. funtington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,C.a92647 932-10-017 B.Thornton 16711 Viewpoint I,n. Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 932-10-1.38 A.Lopez 6881 Via Carona Huntington Beach,C.a92647 932-10-139 Duarte Prop 8071 Slater AVe. #135 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 932=10-096 932-10.-107 932-10-118 S.Anzis Coon liond `17530 Santa Domingo Cir. 1803 Arbor. Cir. 654 Arbor Cir. Founti*jn Vall.ey,Ca.92708 Iiunt_i.ngton I3each,Ca.92647 Hinti_ngton 13each,Ca.92647 932-10-097 932-10-108 932-.10-119 M.Shaffer G.Clooten L.Markus 15261 Victoria Ln. 7807 Arbor Ci.r. 16656 Arbor Cir. Huntington Beach,C.a92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 932-10-098 932-10-109 932-10-120 M.Nesbit T.Brenthall D.Behrendt 7832 Arbor Cir. 16682Arbor Cir. 16658 Arbor Cir. fluntington Beach,C.a92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 liiinli.ngton,lieach.,Ca.92647 932=10-099 932-10-0110 932-10-121 W.Coshowe F.Mohamed S.Martinez 7825 Arbor C .r. . 5082 Loyola Ave. 16651 Viewpoint Ln. Huntington Beach,C.a92647 Westmin:i.ster,Ca.92683 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 932-10-100 932-10-111 932-10-122 K.De Mil:Le C.Smith B.Dieson P.O. Box 3202 16686 Arbor Cir. 16653 Viewpoint Ln. Manhattan Beach,Ca.90266 IiUnt.ington Beach,C.a92647 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 932-10-1.01 932-10-112 932-10-0123 D.Hickman G.Hopkiris R.Ceci 781 1 Arbor Ci r-. 1638 Pebble Beach Ur. 1029 WesLward Way Ifuntington Beach,Ca.92647. Hoffman Bstates,lf., (:)0194 Costa Mesa,Cs.92626 932=10-102 932-10--113 932-10-124 R.Lavigne F.I:sola H.Dugan 21172 Banff Im. 16672 Arbor Cir. 10657 Viewpoint,- Ln. HUnLington Beach,C.a92647 Huntington Beach,C.a92647 lluntingt.on Beach,Ca. 92647 932-10-103 932-10-0114 932-10-125 D.Hubbard. F.Parks R.Cochran 8821 Arcel Cir. 8332 Ty:Ler Cir. 16671 Viewpoint Ln. Ht)ntingLon Beach,C;.a92647 IiUnti.ngLon Beach,Ca.92647 lluntington Beach,Ca. 92647 932-1.0-104 932-10-115 932-10-1.26 Y.Pe.t,dLie K.Weiss 13.13rad1.ey 7817 Arbor Ci_r. 1.8185 Santa Adel.l.a Cir. 16673 Viewpoint Ln. IftintingLon Beach,Ca.92647 Fountain Val.l.ey,C.a92.708 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 . uyf-1U5 M R 932-1.0-11G 932-10-127 uyf L.Arnold U.Cofoner 7801 Arbor Cir.Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 8926 Ytiba River Ave. 1.6675 Viewpoint Ln. Fountain Valley,,Ca.92708 Huntington Beach,Ca. 92647 932-10-128 932-10-106 932-10-117 T.Roberts T.Skeren T.Kramer 7u05 Arbor Cir. 16652 Arbor Cir. 19761 Caprice Dr. fluntington Beach,Ca.92647 Huntington Beach,Ca.92647 Yorha Linda,Ca.92686 P.Strand W.Turner r.King 1212 Park St. , , 308 Shadow Oak Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca92648 t8381 Pammy Ln. Huntington 3-02 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Malvern,PA 1935.5 '' 159,043-01.2 1.59-271-66 r J.Arimond S.Eksted.i" Bank Of America 18271 Pammy Ln, 7836 Connie Dr. Trust Real Estate Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 P.O. Box 60564 159-043-03 159-271.-01 Los Angeles ,Ca.90051 159-271-67 J, .Cummi.ngs P.Albert A & E Investments. LTD 18291 Pammy Ln, 7842. Connie Ln. 15300 Ventura Blvd.#320 Huntington 13eacli,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 Sherman Oaks,Ca.91403 159-043-04 159-271-02 930-401-434 A.Moosa O.Rosal.es 18301 Pammy ILn' 7846 Connie Ln.. j Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 Hunt043-05 159-271-03 R.Stel:lrech C L.Aroonsakool P,O, Box 1786 l� J 18311 Pammy Ln' Huntington Beach ,Ca.91648 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 H C 159-043-06 unt271-04 Y.Park O.Fol cared li. 18212 Sharon Ln. 18321 Pammy Ln, n Beach ngto Hunt i ,Ca.n2648 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntngto u 159-043-07 L.Haynes off 18202 Sharon Ln. 1.8341W.Wa 8341 Pammy Ln' Hunti:ngCon Beach ,Ca,92fi48 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 1.59-271-06 1.59-043-08 P.Contreras J.BarLol, 18351 Pammy Ln, 18196 Sharon Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach ,Ca.92648 1.59-043-09 1.59-271-07 A.Neg1).Li_ng, 18391 ete Pammy Ln' 1.8205 Sharon Ln. 8391 Huntington Beach ,Ca.n2648 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Hunt271-fit 159-043-10 W,7aleski_ Huntington Village 17171 Beach Blvd. 7560 Valley Vista HUiitingCon 13each,Ca.92647 Yucca VaL1ey,Ca.92'l84 1.59-27.I-63 159-043-11 •300' '*Owner List Belden I S I ,�'�*yG� Wilson A/P #159-031-01 11 Taylor Ave. 3302 Pammy Ln. Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 i Ilunt.ington Beach,C.a92648 170� 1.57-351-02 159-041-05 Scott Center B`.Horowitz K.Mc Cormick P. Bruckner Jr. 18312 Pammy Ln. 9440 Siskin Ave. 217 S. Violet Ln. Huntington Beach,C.a92648 Fountain Valley,Ca.92708 Orange,Ca.92669 159-041-06 157-493-01 157-352-05 L.Byhower C.Mc Rae 18222 Beach Blvd. 8002 Taylor St. D.Gaiefski Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 18322 Pammy Ln. 157-493-02 157-352-06 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 159-041-07 A.De Grout A.Tomol 1 kirrs asG 10072 Overhill Dr. 11063 Tilton Cir. G. as . Santa Ana,Ca.92705 Fountian Valley,Ca.92708 I 8342 Pammy Ln. l3each,Ca.92648 157-493-03 1.57-352-07 159-041-08 I � i R.Marquis fl.Abel 18202 Beach Blvd. T.Lambright 640 Via Lido Nord Huntington 13each,Ca.92648 1.8352 PammyLn. Newport Beach,Ca.92663 IlUntingtonBeacli,Ca.92648 157-493-04 ! 159-031-01 159-04.1-09 i I).Le Beau L.Nichol.son 8052 Kiner Ave. 419 E1 Modena ! F. Martignoni }luntington 18362,Pammy L,n. Beach, Newport .Beach,Ca.92663 }IUntington Beacli,Ca.92648 157-493-14 159-031-22 ! 159-041-010 i T.Day G.Herst F.Magda leno 1.188 Hummingbird Ln. 18372 Pammy Ln. 8062 Ki.ner St. Corona,Ca.91720 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 HUntington Beach,Ca.92648 g j 159-031-24 159-041-1.1 157-493-15 I M.Vanagas 1 T Parks 1510 N. State College Blvd. I 18252 Pammy Ln. M.Gangem.i18382 Parnmy Ln. Anaheim,Ca.92806 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 IlUntington Beach,Ca.92648 157-341-0.1 ! 159-041.-01 ' 519-041-1.2. ! T}.hlunk'eby F.Alvarez F.Alyarez 1832 rez 20901 Pioneer Blvd. � 18262 Pammy Ln. i Lakewood,Ca.9071.5 Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 ..839ingtonPammy Ln. Beach,Ca.92648 157-341-02 159-041-02,03 j 159-041-13 i C.Rut}l C.Blazej P.hiehan 8001 Taylor Ave. 18292 Parnmy Ln. 7812 'Taylor Ave. Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 ! Huntington Beach,Ca.92648 157-351-01 Huntington 13each,C.a92648 159-041-04 ! 159-043-01 i i Legal Notice _ City of Hur ington Beach Office of the City Clerk P. O. Sox 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92649,�li ,��_ �;:-�$,, > i� � _ .r---�•�__��,.,..,��� I., MAR a- J 0 04 N WP MEMORIAL PART: ` r ;,- NIJNINGf6 CN,CA. 92663 .� ✓VJ ` F'jRS� ASS MAIL linrrcraa BEACH 9 r� _ uHiCe of the City Cleric C lti of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 ? J ! iLtFORMIA 648 .'.� , w � v J.Arimond 18271 Pammy Ln, n Hunti ton B,.g each,Ca.92648 TS -043-03 s f9{ F3 Hljp41 SEA S.SH C .t. [:.T�I'N T'� 7I* Mt U � •��lCJE'� �. -7, Lega ot ce City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 T Huntington Beach,CA 92648 k 932-10-090 R E ril R.Tinkham"0' Arbor Cir. - 4743 g , 92647 untingt-on :,R,:4r-jj 0 r- -7 1111 J�rn k CA iGTON BCH numil. El MOVE.;% mc I- FIRST. CLASS MAIL HUNTINGTON BEACH 'nL;U.I ---------- Legal Notice City of Huntington Beach office of the City Clerk /'v R.0.Box.190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 W.Miller Huntington Beac 7 1110 40 107-601-41 7 FIRST CLASS MAIL HUNTINGTON BEACH 7 . RFr B. Chamber of Commerce !;3 Main Street, #22 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 ATTN. Kim Barone Huntington Beach Co. !' 2110 Main Street H. Beach, CA 92648-2499 C� ATTN: R. J. Work HB/FV Board of Realtors 8101 Slater Avenue Huntington Beach, CA 92647 ATZN: Judith Severy Building Industry Assn.-O.C. 2001 F. 4th Street Santa Ana, CA t; ' Y' r . AC62J301/FM CTL 0006896 06-01-88 9:22 PM 1988-89 CITY/DISTRICT PARCEL LIST PAGE 2,239 DISTRICT NUMBER: 054A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE IRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE 932-101-41 HELLER, JOHN PATRICK 932-101-48 WRIGHT, JULIA V 932-170-07 FISKNES , JACK EDWARD 04-010 16721 VIEWPOINT LN 04-010 16092 WINDEMEIR LN 04-001 76 -075i AIRWAY OR 4HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 INDIAN LLS, CA 92210 I' I 932-101-42 LORENZEN, DAVID TIMOTHY 932-170-01 OCHOA, G 'GERT GLEN 932-170-08 HOLLANDI RICHARD H 04-010 16725 VIEWPOINT LN 04-001 UNIT 101/ 04-001 17192 P ' IFIC COAST HWY HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 17192 P IFIC COAST HWY APT 202 HUNTING ON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNT�NGT BCH, CAL 921 1 � 932-101-43 PERDUE, YVETTE M 932-170-02 EVANS, CHARD W 932-170-04 SWART, RONALD L 04-010 218 -A MAIN ST 04-001 17192 P IFIC COAST HWY 04-001 17192 PACIFIC COAST HWY HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 UNIT 10 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTING 0 BEACH, CA 92649 'I ii 932-101-44 GALLOWAY, MICHAEL G 932-170-03 MALCHOW, LMER J ET AL 932-170-10 BEST, THOMAS D 04-010 270 S SOLOMON OR 04-001 3496 BR ATA DR 04-001 1346 GL �JFINNAN AVE ANAHEIM, CA 92807 HUNTING N BEACH, CA 92649 COVINA Ij�AL 91722 ri 932-101-45 EVANS, JEANNE G 932-170-04 SHEPARD, DANIEL A 932-170-11 SOOAROi' R BE.RT M TR 04-010 16731 VIEWPOINT LN 04-001 UNIT 1 4 04-001 801 W lt)S IN AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 17192 ACIFIC COAST HWY SANTAI �N , CA 92705 HUNTIN TON BEACH, CA 92649 i 4 �1 932-101-46 WRIGHT, HAR LD L 932-170-05 STABLO4,, NEIL J 932-170-1_` LARKINr PATRICIA G 04-010 16733 VIEWPOINT LN 04-001 17192 (`ACIFTC COAST HWY 04-001 16711 EENVIE.W LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 HUNTING`TON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTIN ON BEACH, CA 92649 932-101-47 SYLVA, JULIA E 932-170-06 GAUKLER, DOROTHY 932-170-1i MC DANI LS, KAREN C 04-010 15392 ANDAMAN LN 04-001 UNIT 106A, 04-001 12639 B RGESS HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 17192 PACIFIC COAST HWY LA MIR DA, CA 90638 HUNTING;TON BEACH, CA 926,,9 i � \ AC62J301/FM CTL 0006895 06-01-88 9:22 PM 1988-89 CITY/01!11RICT PARCEL LIST \1 PAGE 2,238 DISTRICT NUMBER 054A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZI13 PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE IRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE IRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE 932-101-20 SEHRENOT, DONNA J 932-101-27 COFONE , CELIA 1;32i�01-34 PERDUE, YVETTE 04-010 16658 ARBOR CIR 04-010 16675 VIEWPOINT LN 0 010 218 MAIN ST -HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 932-101-21 MARTINEZ, SERGIO P 932-101-28 KRAMER, TED 932-101-35 UHLER, hfARCINE ANIZ 04-010 16651 VIEWPOINT LN 04-010 19761 CAPRICE OR 04-010 16695 \*2EWPOINT LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 YORBA LINOA, CA 92686 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 932-101-22 OIESON,. BBRIAN 932-101-29 SIMPSON, DAVID J 932-101-36 OATHOUT, CAROLYN L 04-010 16653 VIEWPOINT LN 04-010 16681 VIEWPOINT LN 04-010 16697 VIEWPOINT LN HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 932-101-23 CENCI, RUTH M 932-101-30 FOREMAN, JOHN A 932-101-31 MARION, DONALD PAUL 04-010 1029 WESTWARD WAY 04-010 1790 CRESTMONT PL 04-010 16711 VIEWPOINT LN COSTA MESA, CA 92627 COSTA MESA, CA 92627 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 r` , 932-101-24 DUGAN, MARK A 932-101-31 DEGENHARDT, ADRTAN J 932-101-3.3 LOPEZ, ANTONIO J 04-010 16657 VIEWPOINT LN 04-010 13272 WHITNEY CIR 04-010 6881 VIA CARONA HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 WESTMINSTER, CA 926,33 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 932-101-25 COCHRAN, ROBIN L 932-101-32 FRISBIE , LEONARD 0 932-101-3 ) DUARTE PROPERTIES 04-010 16671 VIEWPOINT LN 04-010 4531 SHARON OR 04-010 %LBK ASSOCIATES HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 LA PALMA, CA 90623 SUITE 135 8071 SLATER AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH, .CA 92647 932-101-26 BRADLEY, BRIAN C 932-101-33 BEALL, ALFRED E 932-101-41 ROSENSTIEL, JON C 04-010 16673 VIEWPOINT LN 04-010 16691 VIEWPOINT LN 04-010 2515 E JAMISON ST HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 ANAHEIM, CA 92806 AC62J301/FM CTL 0006894 06-01-88 9:22 PM 1988-89 CITY/DISTRICT PARCEL LIST PAGE 2,237 DISTRICT NUMBER: 054A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE IRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE 932-100-99 COSHOW, WALTER E 932-101-06 ROBERTS, TONY M 932-101-13 ISOLA, FREDA 04-010 7825 ARBDR CIR 04-010 7805 ARBOR CIR V106 04-010 16672 ARBOR CIR -HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 932-101-00 OE MILLE, KATHRYN LYN 932-101-07 DEPT OF VETS AFFAIRS OF 532-101-14 PARKS, FIREDOIE E 04-010 OE MILLE, BRUCE ALAN 04-010 STATE OF CAL 04-010 8332 TT ER CIR P 0 BOX 3202 7803 ARBOR CIR HUNTItGTON BEACH, CA 92646 MANHATTAN BEACH, CA 90266 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 932-101-01 HICKMAN, ,DARYL 932-101-08 CLOOTEN, EUGENE J 932-101-15 WEISS, KENNETH 04-010 7811 ARBOR CIR 04-010 7807 ARBOR CIR 04-010 18185 SANTA AOELLA CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 FOUNTAIN VALLEY, CA 92708 932-101-02 AARON, HAROLD 932-101-09 BRENTNALL, THOMAS ELMER 932-101-14 ARNOLD, LAWRENCE 0 04-010 7813 ARBOR CIR 04-010 3RD 04-010 8926 YUBA RIVER AVE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 16682 ARBOR CIR FOUNTAIN VALLEY. CA 92708 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 932-101-03 HUBBARD# DARRYL C 932-101-10 MOHAMED, FAROUK 532-101-17 SKEREN, THO11AS M JR 04-010 8821 ARCEL CIR 04-010 5082 LOYOLA AVE 04-010 16652 ARBOR CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 WESTMINSTER, CA 92683 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 s �4 932-101-04 PERDUE, YVETTE M 932-101-11 SMITH, CHRISTOPHER 932-101-13 BOND, RICHARD L 04-010 218 -A MAIN ST 04-010 16686 ARBOR CIR 04-010 16654 ARBOR CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 932-101-05 RUYF, MARJORY L 932-101-12 HOPKINS, GEORGE S32-101-1') rARKUS, LINDA S 04-010 RUYF-LEVESCY, MARJORY L 04-010 1638 PEBBLE BEACH OR 04-010 1.6656 ARBOR CIR 7801 ARBOR CIR HOFFMAN ESTATES, IL 60114 HUNTINGTON REACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 AC62J301/FM CTL 0006893 06-0I-88 9 22 PM 1988-89 CITY/DISTRICT PARCEL LIST \�� PAGE 2,236 DISTRICT NUMBER: 054A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP FARCEL NO! OWNERS ZIP TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE IRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE 932-100-78 $HAW, ROBERT E 932-100-85 COHEN, HARRY 932-100-9:: PACKI, JOSEPH TR 04-010 25891 APPIAN WAY 04-010 7852 ARBOR CIR 04-010 24611 VIA RAZA .MISSION VIEJO, CA 92691 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 EL TORO, CA 92630 932-100-79 VENTER, RAYMOND S 932-100-86 NOVAK, KENNETH J 932-200-95 COOKE, �,ESLIE R 04-010 7826 ARBOR CIR #79C 04-010 %THE KLEVENS GROUP 04-010 15103 ,PEYSTONE HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 8071 SLATER AVE #140 NORWA V, CA 90OL-n HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 932-100-80 DI GREGORIO, LOUIS 932-100-87 BENITES, ABRAHAM 932-100-9'► DUARTE PROPERTIES 04-010 8801 ANTHONY DR 04-010 7856 ARBOR CIR 04-010 %L B K ASSOCIATES LTD HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 8071 SLATER SUITE 140 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 932-100-81 BERTRAND, DONALD T 93'1-300-88 BRADFORD, DOUGLAS G 932-100-95 ANDERSEN, CHARLES EDWARD 04-010 12562 DALE ST #23 04-010 1.854 BOA VISTA CIR 04-010 17340 EUCLID ST GARDEN GROVE, CA 92641 COSTA MESA, CA 92626 FOUNTAIN VALLEY, CA 92708 932-100-82 SEELEY, LAURA L 932-100-89 GUNN, DALE F 932-100-96 ANZIS, STANLEY 04-010 25262 ALDEA CT 04-010 7841 ARBOR CIR 04-010 17530 SANTA DOMINGO CIR MISSION VIEJO, CA 92691 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 FOUNTAIN VALLEY, CA 92708 f 932-100-83 LEE, DAE HEE 932-100-90 TINKHAM, RONALD B S32-100-97 SHAFFER, MADALYN 04-010 7836 ARBOR CIR 04-010 7843 ARBOR CIR 04-010 15251 VICTORIA LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 932-100-84 JACOBSEN, MARIE W 932-100-91 RESCHKE , JERRY 932-100-9.5 NESBIT, MIKE. 04-010 7838 ARBOR CIR 04-010 7845 ARBOR CIR 04-010 7823 ARBOR CIR HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 -AC62J301/FM CTL 0006892 06-01-88 9:22 PM 1988-89 CITY/DISTRICT PARCEL LIST \� PAGE 2,235 DISTRICT NUMBER: 054A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIIl FARCEL NO.,' OWNERS ZIP TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS COVE IRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE 932-100-57 M,EZZANATTO, JENNIE 932-100-64 KNOLL, MARIE 932-100-71 DAVEY, JAMES H 04-010 7742 ARBOR CIR 04-010 9202 CAPROLTOWN DR 04-010 7806 ARBOR CIR ,HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 932-100-58 ONETO, CLAUDIA M 932-100-65 MAC LEOO, MARCIA J 932-100-71 FAJARDO ' ESTEBAN ET AL 04-010 7744 ARBOR CIR #2 04-010 7762 ARBOR CIR 04-010 7608 ARL R CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 HUNTIt,GTN BCH, CAL 92667 932-100-59 ELFENBEINV EDWARD L 932-100-66 KERR, GEORGE W TR S32-100-73 DUPONT, BARRY G 04-010 21172 BANFF LN 04-010 1434 DEAUVILLE PL 04-010 710 RIDGESIDE ST HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92646 COSTA MESA, CA 92626 MONROVIA, CA 91016 932-100-60 YAMASHITA, SHIGERU 932-100-67 LA CASSE , ROBIN S 932-100-7,r DA CUNHA, WALTER 04-010 7748 ARBOR CIR 04-010 7766 ARBOR CIR 04-010 5581 INDIAN WELLS CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON [SEACH, CA 92646 / 932-100-61 GREGG, PHILLIP W 932-100-68 MC COWN, ALBERT R 932-100-7': LEVESQUE, . AHES RICHARD 04-010 P 0 BOX 1104 04-010 10151 BEVERLY OR 04-010 7814 ARBOR CIR A2 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 i 932-100-62 BINDER, MICHAEL L 932-100-69 FOLCH, LORENZO 932-100-76 SCOTT, DOUGLAS A 04-010 7.754 ARBOR CIR 04-010 346.3 SAN RAFAEL CIR 04-010 7818 ARBOR CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 COSTA MESA, CA 926.^.6 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 932-100-63 PETERS, MARY T 932-100-70 LOPEZ, ANTONIO J 532-100-71 ADCOCK, LUCY M 04-010 7756 ARBOR CIR 04-010 6881 VIA CARONA OR 04-010 7822 ARBOR CIP HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTN B(.H, CAL 92647 AC62J301/FM CTL 0006891 06-01-88 9:22 PM 1988-89 CITY/DISTRICT PARCEL LIST PAGE 2,234 DISTRICT NUMBER: 054A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL N0.' OWNERS ZIP TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE 1RA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE 932-100-36 PERDUE, YVETTE M 932-100-43 SMITH, DIANE D S32-100-51 SANCHEZ, CARLOS A 04-010 16677 ARBOR CIR 04-010 16725 ARBOR CIR 04-010 16745 ARBOR CIR HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 932-100-37 GOSLIGA, RICHARD B 932-100-44 MARTINEZ, SERGIO P ET AL 932-100-51 DUARTE FA OPERTIES 04-010 16681 ARBOR CIR 04-010 16331 DUCHESS LN 04-010 . %L8K &ASSOCIATES HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 8071 SLATER AVE SUITE 140 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92 932-100-38 O'NEILL, SIRENE 932-100-45 CARLSON, JAMES 932-100-52 GREENWALD, GEORGE F 04-010 1 SEAMIST CIR 04-010 16731 ARBOR CIR 04-010 9802 EFFINGHAM NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92663 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 932-100-39 LOPEZ, ANTONIO J 932-100-46 BUELL, GEORGE W TR 932-100-5.$ KRAMER, TED 04-010 6881 VIA CARONA DR 04-010 4871 MAUI CTR 04-010 19761 CAPRICE DR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92649 Y045A LINDA, CA 92686 932-100-40 NAILLING, BONNIE LYNNE 932-100-47 RICE, DAWNA S 932-100-54 GRANT, CYNTHIA DOMINGO 04-010 16687 ARBOR CIR 04-010 16735 ARBOR CIR 04-010 ALLEN, CYNTHIA DOMINGO HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 16241 EAGLE LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92' 932-100-41 THOMPSON, STERLING 932-100-48 SUTTY, GEORGE J 932-100-5: DRAPER, CHRIS R 04-010 16721 ARBOR CIR 04-010 7906 MOONMIST CIR 04-010 6451 SILVERHEF.L CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 932-100-42 CLARK, PATRICIA E 932-100-49 HOLDRIDGE , DOUGLAS J 932-100-5 , RIFFENBURGH, ROBERT R JR 04-010 8894 WARNER AVE 04-010 16741 ARBOR CIR 04-010 16757 ARBOR CIR #56 FOUNTAIN VALLEY, CA 92708 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 AC62J301/FM CTL 0006890 06-01-88 9s22 PM 1988-89 CITY/DISTRICT PARCEL LIST PAGE 2,233 DISTRICT NUMBER: 054A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWffERS ZIP FARCEL NO ' OWNERS ZIP TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE 932-100-15 PENEWELL, EARL J 932-100-22 HAYES, VIRGINIA M 932-100-24 HOLLISTER* ALMA M 04-010 16625 ARBOR CIR 04-010 16643 ARBOR CIR 04-010 0204 SE 64TH ST HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGIN BCH, CAL 92647 MERCER ISLAND, WA 98040 932-100-16 MATSUI, EIKO 932-100-23 KOBAYASHI, ATSUKO 932-100-30 VAN MALVENr DAVID K 04-010 55 MANN ST 04-010 16645 ARBOR CIR 04-010 16663 4RBOR CIR IRVINE, CA 92715 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 9201 932-100-17 BURNHAM, LYNNE 932-100-24 FALLON, JOHN H 932-100-3,. TOLKIN, ALGERNON J 04-010 16631 ARBOR CIR 04-010 16647 ARBOR CIR 04-010 16665 ARBOR CIR HUNTINGIN BCH, CAL 92647 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 HUNTINGTN BCH► CAL 92647 932-100-18 LOPEZ, ANTONIO J 932-100-25 HUNTER, JAMES A 932-100-31 PAPPAS, GEORGE P TR 04-010 16635 ARBOR CIR 04-010 16651 ARBOR CIR 04-010 121 VILLAGE LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 COLMA, CA 94015 1" 932-100-19 HILL, STEPHEN DOUGLAS 932-100-26 WOLINS, SETH E 932-100-3i DEPT OF VETS AFFAIRS OF 04-010 16633 ARBOR CIR 04-010 16655 ARBOR CIR 04-010 STATE OF CAL HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTO14 BEACH, CA 92647 16671 ARBOR CIR HUNTINGTON BEACHr CA 99 ` } 932-100-20 FOLCH, LORE�NZO 932-100-27 HERMES, WAYNE 932-100-3", TIRELLA, LINDA S 04-010 3463 SAN RAFAEL 04-010 51 VIA ZAPADOR 04-010 16675 ARBOR- CIR COSTA MESA• CA 92626 RANCHO SANTA MARGARITA,CA 92608 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 ti 932-100-21 TELLIS, ADELE 932-100-28 BUTTS, FRANCIS F 932-100-3.'; rORASH, DEAN CHARLES 04-010 16641 ARBOR CIR 04-010 5182 DOANOKE 04-010 16673 ARBOR CIR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 IRVINE , CA 92714 HUNTINGTON DEACHr CA 92647 AC62J301/FM CTL 0006889 06-01-88 9:22 PM 1988-89 CITY/DISTRICT PARCEL LIST PAGE 2,232 DISTRICT NUMBER: 54A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO.' OWNERS ZIP TRA NA(AMPESINA AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE IRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE 931-990-46 L.EGG, MES J (932-100-01 SCOTT, JOHN P 532-100-01 CLEARY, JANET E 04-007 1,6526 DR 04-010 BRUCE, LLOYD W 04-010 26627 VIEWPOINT LN ,HUNTIN TN BCH, CAL 92649 BRUCE, LLOYD W FUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 14681 KENSINGTON LN WESTMINSTER, CA 92683 931-990-47 KAMPEN KATHLEEN A 932-100-02 JORDAN, EDWARD T 932-100-09 RUELAS9 AECILE P 04-007 16528 , AMPESINA DR 04-010 16613 VIEWPOINT LN 04-010 36631 VIEWPOINT LN HUNTIN TON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 92647 HUNTINGTN BCH, CAL 9261' 931-990-48 JESSEE, SUSAN P 932-100-03 LANA, CLAUDIO A 532-100-11 LA BOUNTA, JACQUELINE S 04-007 16530 C MPESINA DR 04-010 16615 VIEW POINT LN #3C 04-010 26633 VIEWPOINT LN HUNTING N BCH, CAL 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 931-990-49 MAY, MA SETTA V 932-100-04 RYDER, DIANE 932-100-1 '. MILLER, ROBERT M 04-007 16564 M SHERROD CIR 04-010 9391 BANNING AVE 04-010 39891 WEENS LN FOUNTAI VALLEY, CA 92708 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 HUNTINGTON BEACH# CA 92646 y. 931-990-50 JOSEPH, DOUG 932-100-05 ANDERSON, JOHN L JR 932-100-1 '. GOLAN, ANGELO 04-007 16534 CA PESINA DR 04-010 16621 VIEWPOINT LN 04-010 16637 VIEWPOINT LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTINGTN B(;H, CAL 92647 t 931-990-51 MILLER, ROBERT M 932-100-06 OLDFIELD, JANET 5'32-100-1S STEVENS, NETTIE TR 04-007 19891 WE ENS LN 04-010 16623 VIEWPOINT LN 04-010 410 E 20TH ST HUNTINGT N BEACH, CA 92646 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 COSTA MESA, CA 92627 931-990-52 HUNTINGT N TOWN HOME 932-100-07 WILSON, B GENE TR 932-100-1 ► FERDUE, YVETTE M , 04-007 HOMEOWNE S ASSN 04-010 3110 ALTA VERDE OG-010 218 MAIN ST 1825 LOM TA BLVD FALLBROOK, CA 920::8 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 LOMITA, AL 90717 AC62J301/FM CTL 0005171 06-01-88 9:22 PM 1988-89 CITY/DISTRICT PARCEL LIST PAGE 514 DISTRICT NUMBE 054A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY I PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIF' PARCEL NO, OWNERS ZIP TRA AME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NA E AND ADDRESS COCE TRA NAMEIANO ADDRESS CODE 142-474-34 PET RMANN, URSEL 142-474-41 BABIC, IVAN 142-474-41 SCIIEL ENdAUM, HARRY W 04-010 '1563 CENTER AVE #36 04-010 756liC LATER AVE 141 04-010 75u1 ENTER AVE 316 HULA INGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTIN TON BEACH, CA 926f,7 HUIITI GT N EEACH, CA 92647 I i 142-474-35 SKI TIMAS, ALFRED 142-474-42 GUYS ,3 GALS SUN TANNING 142-474-4- WEIT 7�ST SOCCER LEAGUE 04-010 7561 CENTER AVE UNIT 35 04-010 MANAGE ENT 04-010 INC HUNT NGTON BEACH, CA 92647 7561 C LATER AVE #16 7561 E TER OR HUNTIN TON BEACH, CA 92647 HUATI G N BCH, CAL 9 i i 142-474-36 PETE MANN, URSEL 142-474-43 MASRI AMER 142-474-50 MAIRI AMER 04-010 7561 CENTER DR 436 04-010 21 CP.O 'KETT 04-010 21 CR KETT HULA INGTON BEACH, CA 92647 IRVINE i CA 92734 IRVIN CA 92714 i I 142-474-37j RBA HER. EMILE J 142-474-44 DE LOS RIOS, MERCEDES 142-474-5' WETSS IRWIN D TR 04-010 756A CENTER AVE 038 04-010 7561 C NTER OR 844 04-010 7561 CENTER AVE 024 HUN NGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTIN TON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTIN TON BEACH, CA 92647 j.: r 142-474-38 ERBA HER, EMILE ET AL 142-474-45 HERMAN S, ERWIN 142-474--5; STFNZE WERNER 04-010 75611 ENTER OR 038 04-010 7561 C NTER AVE #Z 04-010 75fi1 C TER AVE 853 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTIN TN BCH, CAL 92647 HUNTING ON BEACH, CA 92447 142-474-39 L0, S U HUI 142-474-46 WANG, IN LANG [142-481-0; 1-0: LADE , ANTHONY J 04-010 7561 CENTER AVE 439 04-010 7561 C NTER AVE #46 10 16912 GREEN ST #4 HUNTI GTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTIN TON BEACH, CA 92617HUJ4 114bTUN BEACH, CA 92649 142-474-40 GALBA , ALOIS 142-474-47 WEST C AST SOCCER LEAGUE OCA, G NEVIN 11 JR 04-010 16549 IT NEOTA ST 04-010 INC 10 18.!01 IVORY CCAST LN FOUNT N VALLEY, CA 92708 7561 CENTER OR HUNTINGTON EEACH, CA 92648 HUNTIN TN BCH, CAL 92647 AC62J301/FM CTL 0005172 06-01-88 9:22 PM 1938-39 CITY/DISTRICT PARCEL LIST PAGE 5115 DISTRICT NUMBER: 054A HUNTINGTON BEACH CITY F14i-481-03 CEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO/ OWNERS ZIP PARCEL NO, OWNERS ZIP TRA NAME AND ADDRESS CODE TRA NAME AND ADDRESS COCE TRA NA E AND ADDRESS CODE S RRA, ARTURO 142-481-10 HYDINGER, DONALD D 142-491-C! HUANG, N TA-BEEN 4-010 16651 PEALE LN 04-010 16572 THAMES LN 04-007 16a52 INI LN HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92647 HUNTIN N EEACH, CA 92646 142-481-04 M S L LEIBU CORP 142-481-11 RED LOBSTER INNS OF 142-(*91-0t GOTHARDJ USINESS CENTER 04-010 %M A L FABRICS O4-010 AMFRICA INC 04-007 LTn 1226 S MAGNOLIA ATTN PPTY TAX DEPT 16o91,-H GOTHARO ST ANAHEIM, CA 92804 P 0 BOX 593330 HUNTINGT N BEACH, CA 92 ORLANDO, FL 32859 142-481-05 )NGUYEN, THIET TAN 142-481-12 bFRNATZ, THOMAS H 142-492-0: HUNTINGT N-GOTHARD 04-010 ­ 8762 SAILPORT DR 04-010 2914 E KATELLA AVE #203 04-007 PROPERTI S LTD HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 ORANGE , CA 26f7 SUITE 60 10900 WI SHIRE BLVD LOS ANGE ES, CA 90024 142-481-06 QURESHI, MOHAMMED S A 142-491-01 GOTHAR BUSINESS CENTER 142-492-0. MEIERVE , JOHN ROBERT 04-010 4152 SHOREBREAK DR 04-007 LTD 04-007 5190 CAM US DR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 16691 FI GOTHARD ST NE14PORT EACH. CA 92658 I)UNTIN TON BEACH, CA 92647 142-481-07 QURESHI, MOHAMMED S A 142-491-02 RCOTEN BERNARD TR 142-492-0:i GOTHARD BUSINESS CENTER 04-010 4152 SHORE BREAK OR 04-007 310 SA JOSE DR 04-007 LTD HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 PALM SI INGS, CA 92264 16691 -H GOTHARD ST HUNTINGTON EEACH, CA 97 142-481-08 NEWMAN, IRVING 142-491-03 COONS, EX B 142-492-0! PACIFIC YSTEMS 04-010 16312 MANDALAY CIR 04-007 16622 MINI LN 04-007 P () BOX 99 HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92649 HUNTING ON BEACH, CA 92647 SANTA M ICA., CA 90406 I 142-481-09 PAN, YUNG H 142-491-04 GOTIIARDi USINESS CENTER 142-492-0( PACIFIC YSIEYS 04-010 9134 COCKATOO AVE 04-007 LTD 04-007 P 1) BOX 99 FOUNTAIN VALLEY, CA 92708 16691 -HI GOTHARD ST SANTA MO ICA, CA 90406 HUNTINGT N BEACH, CA 92647 107-691-20 12-462-09 107-691-22 Art. Nerio sKO XXXIII Inc. a ord Leasing Development 9340 Bolsa Ave . Chrysler Realty Attn Dealership re - West. Westminster , Ca. 92683 Tax Dept. -Clms 416-16-05 P .O. Box 43336 co P.O. Box-.1919 Detroit, Mi Detzpit, Mi . 48243 Tom Bernatz & Assoc. 107-601-47 142-181-05 2914 E. Katella Parekh, H .B Hambly Co N V Ste 203 8636 Production Ave . Ste A Banbury Cross Apts .- orange , Ca . 92667 San Diego , Ca. 92121 16761 Viewpoint Ln. Huntington Beach , Ca. 92627 142-462-06 ............ `- " Resident Resident American Motors Realty 18292 Pammy Ln . 18271 Pammy Ln. Tax Affairs 416-16-05 Huntington Beach , Ca. 92647 Huntington Beach , . Ca . 9264: 12000 Chrysler Dr. Highland Park, Mi 48288 Resident Resident Resident 18392 Pammy Ln . 18302 Pammy Ln . 18312 Pammy Ln . Huntington Beach , Ca. 92647Huntington Beach , Ca 92647 Huntington Beach , Ca 92647 Resident Resident Resident 18322 Pammy Ln . 18342 Pammy Ln . 18362 Pammy Ln . Huntinaton Beach , Ca 92647 Huntington Beach , Ca. 92647Huntington Beach , Ca 92647 Resident Resident Resident 18372 Pammy Ln . 18391 Pammy Ln . 18381 Pammy_ Ln . Huntington Beach , Ca 92647 Huntington Beach , Ca . 92647 Huntington Beach , Ca . 92647 Resident Resident Resident 18371 Pammy Ln . 18341 Pammy Ln . 18321 Pammy Ln . Huntington Beach , Ca 92647 Huntington Beach , Ca . 92647 Huntington Beach , Ca . 92647 V Resident Resident Resident 18311 Pammy Ln. 18309 Pammy Ln . 18291 Pammy Ln . Huntington Beach , Ca . 92647Huntington Beach , Ca . .92647 Huntington Beach , Ca . 92647 Resident Resident Resident 18292 Pammy Ln . 18352 Pammy Ln . 18271 Pammy Ln . Huntington Beach , Ca. 92647Huntington Beach , Ca . 92647 Huntington Beach , Ca . 92647 Resident Resident Resident 18352 Pammy Ln. 7881 Beachpoint D6 7881 Beachpoint D15 Huntington Beach , .Ca. 92647Huntington Beach , Ca . 92647 Huntington Beach , Ca . 92647 Resident Resident Resident 7881 Beachpoint D21 7881 Beachpoint D22 7881 Beachpoint #5 Huntington Beach , Ca. 92647Huntington Beach , Ca. 92647 Huntington Beach, Ca . 92647 Resident "esident Resident 7881 Beachpoint #4 381 Beachpoint #14 7881 Beachpoint #19 Huntington Beach, Ca . 92647 Huntington Beach , Ca. 92647 Huntington Beach , Ca . 9264 Resident Resident Resident 7881 Beachpoint #9 7812 Beachpoint #15 7812 Beachpoint 116 Huntington Beach , Ca. 92647 Huntington Beach , Ca. 92647 Huntington Beach , Ca . 92647 Resident ' �. Resident Resident 7912 Beachpoint A-17 7912 Beachpoint A-21 7912 Beachpoint A-12 Huntington Beach , Ca . 92647 Huntington Beach , Ca . 92647 Huntington Beach , Ca . 926% Resident Resident Resident 7882 Beachpoint #17 7882 Beachpoint #2 7882 Beachpoint #3 Huntington Beach , Ca 92647 Huntington Beach , Ca . 92647 Huntington Beach , Ca . 9264 Resident 7882 Beachpoint #1 Huntington Beach, Ca . 92647 1 4 a • • • i • • • rur �s iFMx , i - • • '. i • • � • • , yt4:�'i�'`u'x�,tµ-0 xt+,�fv}`� t}�\ 1 �� .r 4zY�. �i f •' ♦ �L • ( � L - 1 • • • S•-2'-r x'�c,�i,;r I��r ,*. i e<i�.a�` C • � • • � i • • • ' • �..: Y;Luz :2 �Yr �� *._� ,FD -rt - • • 1 1 • • �a r '•.d.4 r • 4"rtiT.1 r>f e • • • i • • � • `�"a 4a7y afia �i:� .r t � y. _ • • , � • • • � I i • ��t ,a M .'•Z"'�•sS'r f ,a„y 1:ix - s Ufa c'�g�',�.. .�..,f�wt+u•.f� a�. n�.� ,,,;t, 4,zxt'' F .:nth sL1 ll � T♦' , � ':{ t� � �, ,. �. t I � 1 f Dl"Zt t'-,. 2%♦ _'-h..th .... � :�?. .. ,N.. �h Y •t, � ;k. .. ._ .,;.. .1.,.... .....,-F,x' S V 4 , ,ff.!'. Y ,x• 4f K, .Y• T'7.f r� n:' at- .'. -... u+ n Y. .,, •�.,...>..w ,S .-Js S.. 51. �j .,afr' j. F..... .+." .,,. 1 8 .., r r. ;,,r a :.,•.-t,,_.. ::�. �.,r.,.,.•u..hr, .t).,.,i, to 3 > t^.,. r.,ha" .�. ._ ... d..a.Eo__ _..... r' -, .:.,..•.., r.,... •.. ;.-a,.,,.r,..;...-_. -c C•r:. S 1' ,'I F. _, l..z. ._. :.'Da.- -._..,.%. . ..rt'"fh... ,...,...t .. 'e ,.. .�- ........� .•,. ..:-r� r,. ,... a. ...'u.. ... v...n r„ ,.C-N. ..._. ...- .. .. ,...,.,,. .,. .:. .. :.. :.Y•'' , .,.t,.... pp vv�..: .. S �. Y ..... G:.p':{ '1" �� *3. )_ •2. ��\ .,....., _.r ... .. ,e q.s... ,,2 .. '..,r u. �. _...,� �-� .,t•. ..w>..- _.x„,.':n ... t s..,.....Y, .A":.� .G:G:. .. rY.„i.. ..a J .. .0 _.v. ._ ..�•'s r.,.r ''t_. � '�u. ... •t. k� h'.-.. ..�: S S .,:, a d...,. ,� ,Fr.: < .+. •' v x.�;, H nl,k1....,-:�j ...:, ,_ ,ty, a s>,,.ih .:' •..• �._ -.,Irr.. a ,.d' .. ,: -t;�.:. +.. .. arc:, as �c^ 7 Qµ• {;, •.,5. �l.{'.' ...-.�.. 1•..+..•.�:.,- �...�'�.....,.h.r.>.,,.,:...., r.........,f n:.':.4...Mh'yP.,.....,IrVr...>-i...v.....[..1.....t.�... '.a7.'-;i.•.....f::.:.. t _;.-Ka.�+.,,..�%.fi_t t:.�.w.r3a. yl -, �•5�.':. ..f. '.,i. t,uMa X...:.!'}(''.:`4 �3->nY`.•.y T!��,��� ed,.�;�•.�`.,- • .>, ... ., y-l;,, ,..,,•. .x:.ar,•�.t ..o ..� '.a,�..._�,•.»..... ."}•,... a. ... 'r '�' � ...r-, r•, v-` rif J t ,, u.. s .�3i± ^. +:. ...., ..••ia- � •.Yu...ti ..:: ' ',.:�•,.. ..'..�vS :��..Y .T4• ...cV .L, 'A � � t - t -..,s .,. ._ -rslu`I.a+•-. ., .. -,„. 3. ,., .�e.: : ._ >:..'..., -...,. S' .. � ::.. '-x..- .r,.,....„.>. .� � .1;F Ci >'?• ,� Y iu.. .. -.,.. ..-. .. ....�Yr`'•r _ a-. ,.., 7_ .Ate 5�- .....4"'.._ .� -•. ,,. r,:- -a-..... F- .. _ .f s.. _y.-. ,.--+-.... -rrs°S.>,xTia':'-:�:_. �+... ,.•a`�,-.. - .... �:.. .r.�{'rrs, -. .. -.. � ,_..>-m..._F .;..".: ....-... e.. is >-s, L w:-. •,9 .x ..,.: ,_, ,:. 7,Ts,--•..r .,� ,. �... ,� ..a-..r._,k -, if w., ..�`..,.., �,-. .a. _,. act:t:. :,x ,-t S,. .3"_. s.+: x. ,�i�.,, i,. -ti !ham..+ :-_.{�s,-v ....,. .i-. .. � ... fr _:✓... k w>..,..., idr.r.• tt,y 'r '� .,........• :,' k .� f 3 .,I, i - ,. _. ,. -t):,r_ , ... ,rx r. ,,: ,. 7. ....�•. , r. ro�.a„ ...,..,, ,� .,,.. t.,.t Y'. .,"' .._� ii-"l"3 u a .r , �z r k-,... ,Y„ •t...r .x.wt.. w r, rC .,t >.' "z ..a.,: �, .s .,r' •Si xti�: +. ?.... -rC-,..e .M:, r ..:.�',._-`.a.,.',•.n :.y- r,.}".v. iL,. v ^., c. v?....'.. ,+rl. 5:',. 'F X ..�,'.N.:w a�{ ::fib'" '>f_. d t•,.a- .. {S�.�w`., . ..�. ,t,•->:.-L -.�. .uE. .,5 3... ,• -,.: �S. .: 'v {, ry F..t�' ,..,.. n...-._ .. .a Y.: Ye..rx t _t•: ';..\ -�-• ...li'ti'Yl. -�i�f ..- 5:. ,-r.... "tr' .}-' ,.rr. ..�, ., r.� .....- -+... .;.,.t, ..,.....,.uK .kr :,.:,.ss:. ,r Y✓i� r 1 y �i�,r., .x: w'a:•cY.nw. ^,.n,.. �?�.,' - r`+.,•r^ •. ..�. r wxs. ..h'f „•i{<T. ia,_„ _:�,.._. n.�-n. <..._,''h• C... �. - ..:, .-,_.. _u-.:,� ...,_. <.r '"y 'r.Y �.,'�!- ,'9. $.. ::3 ��. .-n ,r-a�S.>v....s ,x f. .:.,», v x. '2'..a _.'r�•.. r. :•,r- `w-,-➢, .e!.., y ',.._.._ , ,.. 'e_., i.'r.•` -e ,S: -4'• ''<. .,'.r z ,•,q r^� .. tom, �! Fy .,'���.,.,fr ...,'�.. "{�•°„ .-.>.,:..a,r � _.r_., .x„ 7r; '. -r"r: .x _. 1 r. :.'.-+r.:.fT-.S�"< i'v:..' i.:.t, v. x... :rc._ l I,L;..$:•':Fs .1.t 4 •f`.!' 1{+K,• r•,,,..} •t'=.'" t. t, ,s.,.rr t •u> r- �,c < y.+. y�.,,- .,� .:t.�,• �;•...• :.�?, ..�, y+, Jy" :,a F:',."., -��. t;,•y.{Y'-. '�sc". ro-K(i3. xTG w..., i G i. `��t.F ~. 14�... .R;.„i: aL �•t� ,y D .n�yl.. �F�,. r�. ,yam+! ♦'Y;r►. ,��.�a,�''t'�,y,.�z Y... _\�'vri�••v� rt, ti�'u>' �•c'�� 'Lre, a'• .,� .r a�'!+4 ..,, �iHKI i� :t �r' �x� '��i� yy�� :"Y;.;ar•�" ..y^.� ..�' ! t+,' _ ', .,.,mr t-r„,,f� �_'„'+�,�.�...•t .., r�.-fZ. � ,. � �•,• . , �v\ ,�'.. ,u ��V� .R y .,.,*• h.}�,•'r... y..: �Y• T - 4 f•..> �v.. '�->_.. ;,. .s ��.. :,yµ.:-�r�"{iD'. * 'L"w"R.�1"x.r'•��,.W..�'��.."v�!.>i+Y !�t"•':.� ♦ -h''Y � �.y•..�-,1 R� 7. ��,_.. - �.,. •.of ,.� �:.-: ski'.., >: <r:.•'."p". .. •:i.-�:... ..za�. ,_f ,�.sy} - .,.,;. -.'•.�,t.« ?'.,,' w ^r -:", .`.�.' •`L. �.A'Z:(,.:::--.^ -,rKL�'"YY h.k�-:.a,�rM. ..,lYl4 1 ,, ��i.if'.•y,�..v CZ '�h' 'rr:- '7DP .i4: .5 y..� i Office of the City Clerl City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 Resident t 7881 BeachDoi t 6 4 7 Huntington Be(ch Office of the City t;iem City Of Huntington Beach CALIFORNIA 92648— P.O.BOX 190 ALGERNON J RBOR CIR lo N BcH, CAL 92647 CFO A it It wid0h! It DUG A N It A 16657 V HT LN HU%TIN N \H, CA 92647 FAG. o AV Office of the City Clerk - <; ton Beach City of Huntin g ; CALIFORNIA 92648 i P.O.BOX 190 D L�I i'A 166 J� 004 A 92647 I 1{Ui{3 Z_ c�O r.u.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 ,,4IAYE 'Iti''I ri Lb 2f C fR 1 CAL 92647 O 4,_0 N, 7 Office of the City Clerk Clty of Huntington Beach 0. P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 f I 'I�5NK,1 t.-D P, 7 3 , tiU, f& E3�L CAL 92647 i �FQ • HUNTINGTON BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 325 T BERT N N ry N n n ID m ^ n 102 18015 18032 n -3 ^E88EX_ �� 18021 (SHP n 1 , O 18023 1 rrr3��� OZ 18062 1 -A ; � 18033 CNTR.) _ 10061 p r I�j 18035 c Q � PARKVIEW J jYI coo m m m coo W 18081 3'--- -- I<1 in1 18092 8091 W, I;I >� 1 1s1osILI w�PPv ( 8121 BEACH) ill101 ; Yi f� s12 RJ. 595 N N ID � r mmmmmmmmmmoommm �18141 - r- r n r r r r r r 1 186114 6 18 151 lW0N 118156 86 nrwmr 1 6 � 8162f 72 875 j � 1817 1818 08 91�9181 1816820 01 082 18211182282 0"N' H H 182iJr< mmN :1821215 f GROTHm (TERRY PARK) CHEVROLET m a o co.� n r m co co m m ono w oho m ^ nnnrn ,.1 ro rr` n 18251 N N N N N ry -N N N N N N N N N N 1826 * r m m o ry M n r o N M NA,'o 18252 1828 n v v o 18252 18251 Z nnr n n n 18281 1829• m m m o N r� u o N M 18262 18261 .J 1826218291 r r ° 18272 18271 18272 18301 ONTARIO DR 1829218291 18292 WILSON 18312 N N18311 ^ D N N 18302 18302 FORD n �n m o N aD 18255 O mmo TB312B31 11832 u) o 111321 18312 18311 18312 r ^ ^ ^ r r r r r r n r r ro n8322 18321 m o 18331 ,n m W 18322 18321 18322 ^ r 8342 18341 �. 18351 D4NTON R. QUEBEC DR 8352 18351 3 18342 18341 18342 18361 N N 18352 18351 18352 th Nm N N N N N N N N 8362 18361 Q8351_- r r `r' � m m r, m or N -4 18362 - 18371 r r r• r r r r r r r n 8372 18371 Lu 18362 18361 I _ BEACHPOINT 8T 18391 18391 N r�i v� m m m 18372 18371 L -y 1839 0 w w o a o 18381 18372 I -�--� 1890 � 8382 r 18401 18402 /�Q 422 Q ' � 18361 6 1 1840 8402 1841 382 18381 18382 L839 18411 18412 ALBERTA 8392 .R 18411 1842 N N N N 841218401 18391 18392 L " 183 18421 18422 18422 t 18421 1843 Z 84 18401 18402 18431 18432 184320 18421 18423 1 218431 1844 " 842 18423 1844218441 m 18442 W 1843 18412 18425 r r r 18 27 18451 Q 18441 M 1845 Z-- 1843 18452 r YUKON 844 RANKLIN DR F x 18451 Q 18452 r DR 1844 432 N N N N N 18432 L8461 Q 18462 C'�18462 1846 N N N N N 'N N N m m w m m m m n J 16442 MARK C. BLOW V 18472 18461 QR = m m m m .� .m - 18451 18492 r r .r r n r n 18l�55 L8471 1846 �8� . N N ., i . 1 1 1 .1 / r1 a N .O rl �-Ir .-1 ':'-1 m O N r-1 �p n m m O rl N M zD' n W "'� '-1 :848 PPP N 18482 ^ n �.. t- �. ^ n r r r m m m m m m W ° 0 18477 292 Yi huntington beach department' of community development STAf f EPORT.- TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: January 4, 1989 SUBJECT: CODE AMENDMENT NO. 88-14/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 88-39 (CONTINUED FROM DECEMBER 13, 1988 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING) APPLICANT: Gary Gray DATE ACCEPTED: Huntington Jeep/Eagle October 14, 1988 16751 ,Beach Blvd. Hunt. Beach, CA 92647 MANDATORY PROCESSING DATE: Not applicable REOUEST: To amend Article 961 of the Ordinance Code to LOCATION: City-wide permit electronic reader- board signs. 1. 0 SUGGESTED ,ACTION: Deny Code Amendment No. 88-14 with findings . 2 . 0 GENERAL INFORMATION: Code Amendment No. 88-14 and Negative Declaration No. 88-39 were continued from the Planning Commission meeting of December 13, 1988, at the applicant ' s request. Staff is still recommending denial of the requested code amendment. However, should the Planning Commission decide to recommend adoption of the code amendment to the City Council, staff would suggest an additional criteria be added to the alternative ordinance as drafted by staff (Attachment No. 2 of the staff report dated December 13, 1988) . It is recommended that no temporary flags, banners, balloons, or other temporary signs be permitted for sites with an electronic readerboard sign. Included with this report is a brief summary of the features of the code amendment proposed by the applicant, as compared to those features of the alternative ordinance suggested by staff . ATTACHMENTS' 1. Summary Chart 2 . Letter received December 7, 1988 3 . Staff Report dated December 13, 1988 SH:LP:kla (1802d) C'_ A-F M-23C 78 SUMMARY CHART OF PROPOSED ORDINANCES Feature Proposed by Applicant Proposed by Staff Entitlements CUP, PSP, DRB CUP, PSP, DRB Required Type of Sign Freestanding or Wall Freestanding or wall Max. Number 1 per site 1 per site Max. Size 175 sq. ft . ; total sign 70 sq.ft. ; total sign area not to exceed 2X area not to exceed 2X size of readerboard size of readerboard portion portion Max. Height 35 ft. with min. 15 ft. 10 ft . clearance Max. Intensity Cylinders, shade screen Cylinders, shade screen and photo cell required. and photo cell required. Max. light output 5-ft. Max. light output 5-ft. candles at property candles at property line line Min. Lot Frontage 200 ft . 400 ft. Location Abutting freeway or Abutting freeway or Beach Blvd. (except Beach Blvd. (except between Adams and PCH) between Adams & PCH) Min. Distance 150 ft . 150 ft. between Electronic Readerboards Min. Distance 150 ft. 150 ft. to Residence Min. Distance to 100 ft . 100 ft. Interior Property Line Type of Business 80% of merchandise in No restrictions outdoor display; display/work areas must be min. 20% of site area Min. Parcel Size 2 acres None specified 4 T SUMMARY CHART OF PROPOSED ORDINANCES (Continued) Feature Proposed by Applicant Proposed by Staff Hours of 6:30 AM - 10:30 PM 6:30 AM to 10:30 PM Operation - Public Service 10% of message time or 10% of message time or for emergencies for emergencies Frequency of Min. 4 seconds with Min. 4 seconds with Message min. 1 second interval. min. 1 second interval . No continuous motion No continuous motion or intensity changes or intensity changes Other Signs One monument 7 ft. One monument 7 ft. On Site high, 50 sq. ft. high, 50 sq. ft. All other signs in All other signs in conformance with conformance with Article 961 Article 961 Temporary Banners Permitted 6 months Prohibited per calendar year in accordance with Article 961 } Torn Bematz & Associates 2914 East Katella Avenue Suite 203 Orange, California 92667 (714) 997-1785 December 5, 1988 RECEIVED DEC 0 71988 Mr. Mike Adams r)F"AR f Mrn1 r OF Planning Commission P. 0. Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 REFERENCE: CODE AMENDMENT NO. 88-14 NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 88-39 Dear Mr. Adams, Regarding the above mentioned reference, please, please do not approve that ugly reader board for Huntington Jeep/Eagle. Their business lot is already one God-awful mess. I own the shopping center at the South West corner of Beach Boulevard and Terry Drive, just south of the aforementioned company. We were forced to remove our modest front signage because of the ordinance in force. Why should a car dealer be allowed to use a Las Vegas type of sign? Already they cause an eyesore in the neighborhood because their sales people and customers park in my shopping center and adjoining properties. They do not provide adequate parking for their personnel or customers . Their property always looks like a garbage heap. A reader sign of this type would only show that Huntington Beach approves of their sleazy and ugly operation and places a vote for an inconsiderate business operator. Please say "NO" to this motion to amend Article 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code to permit electronic readerboard signs. Sincerely, Thomas H. Bernatz THB:dw cc : HB Planning Commission —Developers- Investors— nuntington beach departmen. of community development R E['10 STAf f TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: December 13, 1988 SUBJECT: CODE AMENDMENT NO. 88-14/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 88-39 APPLICANT: Gary Gray DATE ACCEPTED: Huntington Jeep/Nagle October 14, 1988 16751 Beach Blvd. Hunt. Beach, CA 92647 MANDATORY PROCESSING DATE: Not applicable REQUEST: To amend Article 961 of the Ordinance Code to LOCATION: City-wide permit electronic reader board signs. 1 .0 SUGGESTED ACTION: Deny Code Amendment No. 88-14 with findings. 2 .0 GENERAL INFORMATION: Code Amendment No. 88-14 and Negative Declaration No. 88-39 Constitute a request to amend Article 961 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code (Sign Code) to permit the use of electronic . readerboard signs within the City of Huntington Bleach. Currently, Section 9610.4(a) of the Code prohibits "flashing, moving, pulsating or intermittently lighted signs including seatchlights; except public service signs such as those for time and temperature. " Section 9610.4(h) prohibits "changeable copy signs, including electronic readerboards; except theatre marquees. " The requested code amendment would amend these prohibitions to exempt electronic readerboards, add specifications and locational criteria for such signs, and amend certain definitions to accommodate the aforementioned changes. 3 .0 ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Pursuant to the environmental regulations in effect at this time, the Department of Community Development posted draft Negative Declaration No. 88-39 for ten days, and no comments, either verbal or written were received. The staff, in its initial study of the project, has recommended that a negative declaration be issued. Prior to any action on Code Amendment NO. 86-14 it is necessary for the Planning Commission to review and act on Negative Declaration Aga& am A-F M-23C No. 88-39 . Staff feels that, should the requested code amendment be approved, the suggested restrictions and criteria outlined in the attached draft ordinances will mitigate potentially adverse impacts to a level that is not significant pursuant to CEQA Guidelines . .� This does not mean, however, that all land use-related impacts will be completely eliminated, as further discussed below. 4 . 0 ISSUES AND ANALYSIS: Background: A similar Code Amendment (No. 87-15) to permit electronic readerboard signs was proposed by Wilson Ford earlier this year. The Planning Commission denied the request on March 28, 1988. The City Council, on appeal by the applicant, directed the Planning . Commission to evaluate and make recommendation upon an alternative ordinance to allow electronic readerboards, subject to certain criteria, as recommended by the Planning Commission Subcomittee and the Department of Public Works. On May 3, 1988, the Planning Commission reaffirmed their previous action and recommended denial of the code amendment to the City Council . However, they also forwarded a list of recommended sign criteria for the Council ' s consideration, should the Council have chosen to approve the amendment. At the July 18, 1988 City Council meeting, a motion to disapprove Code Amendment No. 87-15 failed by a vote of 3 to 3 . Therefore, the Planning Commission' s denial prevailed. Analysis • Code Amendment No. 88-14 as requested by the applicant consists of the suggested ordinance forwarded to City Council by the Planning Commission on May 3, 1988, with two modifications . The maximum sign area requested is 175 square feet rather than 200 square feet, and an additional locational requirement is proposed which would limit the use of electronic readerboards to businesses that are located on minimum 2 acre parcels and rely upon the outdoor display of merchandise as the primary means of business . There are four primary issues involved in the code amendment: height, size, the concept of moving/changing message type signs and compatibility with other signs . a. Height Since about 1974, no signs over 25 feet have been approved except through a variance (special sign permit) procedure based on the signs ' location (i .e. adjacent to a freeway) . The sign code from 1974 to 1986 permitted signs up to 20 feet in height within 20 feet of the front property line. Those signs setback 21 feet or greater could be up to 25 feet in height. Our current code. limits sign height to 7 feet for parcels with less than 400 feet of frontage and to 15 feet for parcels with more than 400 feet of street frontage. Staff Report - 12/6/88 -2- (1609d) This is to reduce clutter of signs and to allow adequate exposure for larger parcels. This code amendment request is to allow signs up to 35 feet in height, which would be incompatible with other �- signs in the City established since 1974 and contrary to the current code. b. hir&a Freestanding signs are currently limited to 70 square feet in size (80 square feet within an opaque background) on parcels with over 400 feet of frontage; parcels with less than 400 feet of frontage are limited to maximum 30 square feet of sign area (40 square feet. with an opaque background) . Prior to 1986, the size limit was based upon one square foot of sign area per one lineal foot of lot frontage with maximum 100 square feet for signs within 12 feet of the front property line. A maximum of 150 square feet was permitted for signs within 13 to 20 feet of the front property line, and a maximum of 200 square feet for signs greater than 20 feet from the front property line. The varying setback requirement in relation to height was to reduce the impact of a large sign close to public streets . Proposed Code Amendment No. 55-14 is for a maximum 175 square foot sign area anywhere on the site (it may be within the front 25 foot building setback area) provided the site has a minimum 200 foot lot frontage. This size limit and location is incompatible with other signs constructed along Beach Boulevard since 1974 . Electronic readerboard signs greater than 15 feet in height and 70 square feet in size (current sign code limits) are more appropriate along. freeways where the speed limit is 55 mph and there is not a mixture of vehicle/pedestrian flow. Beach Boulevard is posted maximum 45 mph and has sidewalks on both sides for pedestrian use. A high sign coupled with moving/changing messages can be distracting to motorists and increase the potential of vehicle/pedestrian conflict . In addition, higher signs are not necessary along Beach Boulevard. In the past, freestanding signs of 30 to 60 feet were erected to attract motorists from miles away. However, today°s urban development is too cluttered to allow for effective communication at this distance. Lower signs within the motorists direct cone of vision are more easily seen and read. C . Moving/Changing Tyne Signs : As mentioned before, electronic readerboards may also increase the risk of hazardous distraction to motorists. Use of flashing signs for advertising is visually demanding and may be confusing to drivers, thereby causing slowing of traffic on arterial highways and increasing potential vehicle/pedestrian conflicts . Staff recommends that the use of flashing, blinking, pulsating, or intermittantly lighted signs be reserved for public safety, signalized intersections and driving safety/control messages to motorists. Or, if a changing message is necessary, require the message to remain on the board for no less than 10 seconds. Staff Report - 12/6/88 -3- (1609d) f d. Compatibility: The Huntington Beach sign code recently underwent extensive review and amendment by the City Council, with input from the Planning Commission, Chamber of Commerce, and other business and citizen groups . The intent of the revised ordinance was to limit sign heights, reduce visual clutter, create a more aesthetically pleasing appearance to passing motorists and create more consistency between signage. These code changes were in response to the increasing urban character of the street scenes in Huntington Beach. At the time that previous Code Amendment No. 87-15 was processed, staff conducted a poll of all Orange County cities, and found very few that permit electronic readerboard signs. There are a few existing non-conforming signs, and some others allowed by variance. Some of these signs are located on surface streets, however most larger, taller electronic readerboard signs are adjacent to freeways . A table attached to this report lists the cities polled, their policies on readerboards, and the location of existing readerboards within those cities (Attachment No. 4) . Also attached is a table and map citing samples of readerboards in Orange and Los Angeles Counties (Attachment Nos. 5 and 6) . In addition, electronic readerboards are incompatible with residential uses . The majority of parcels along Beach Boulevard are approximately 300 feet deep and adjacent to residential uses . The signs can be obnoxious due to their glare and blinking. However, new technology can reduce glare and reduce their impact. Recommendation: " Staff is recommending denial of the requested Code Amendment based on findings outlined by the Planning Commission in their denial of Code Amendment No. 87-15 in May, 1988, and the discussions herein. The Planning Commission found that electronic readerboard signs would serve to increase visual clutter along Beach Boulevard and possibly throughout the City, impact adjacent residents with light and glare, and allow possible distractions to motorists . Alternative Action: Should the Planning Commission wish to approve the requested code amendment, staff has prepared an alternative ordinance for consideration. The major differences between staff ° s recommended ordinance and the applicant ' s request are as follows: Staff Recommendation Applicant Recommendation Issue (if approved) (if approved) Max. Sign Height 15 ft. 35 ft . with 10 ft. ground clearance Max. Sign Area 70 sq. ft. 175 sq. ft. Min. Lot Frontage 400 ft . 200 ft. Staff Report - 12/6/88 -4- (1609d) Staff Recommendation Applicant Recommendation Issue (if approved) (if approved) Min. Lot Area None 2 acres Type of Business No restrictions 80% of merchandise in outdoor display; display/work areas must be min. 20% of site era Staff ' s alternative would assure size and height compatibility with other signs constucted since 1986 . The size limit of 70 square feet would allow for two or three lines of lighted messages and full character graphics on a more proportionate scale. In addition, without the type of business requirement, the code amendment would be applicable to all properties with over 400 feet of frontage regardless of the business type. Staff has received inquiries for electronic readerboards from non-outdoor display type businesses . Staff ' s alternative is basically designed within the framework of the existing sign code. Based on staff ' s proposed locational criteria, approximately 18 sites along Beach Boulevard and the freeway would be eligible to apply for electronic readerboard signs . This does not take into account possible lot consolidations to acheive the suggested 400 feet of lot frontage. Any request to exceed these standards would be based on a case by case analysis of the property and use pursuant to a special sign permit (variance) . As mentioned previously, the applicant has added two locational ` requirements to the previously proposed ordinance for Code Amendment No. 87-15 . These include a 2 acre minimum lot size and a requirement that a business utilize outdoor display for 80 percent of their merchandise. Such extensive use of outdoor display areas visible to passing motorists, however, would seem to reduce the need for additional signage, rather than increase it . Using the applicant ' s proposed locational criteria of minimum 2 acre lot . size and 200 foot lot frontage, approximately 32 sites along Beach Boulevard and the freeway would be eligible for electronic . readerboard signs . Again, this does not take into account possible lot consolidations to acheive the applicant' s suggested lot frontage and lot size. 5 . 0 RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission deny Code Amendment No. 88-14 with the following findings: FINDINGS FOR DENIAL: 1 . Since the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, Article 961 allows adequate opportunities for advertising through various types of signage, Code Amendment No. 88-14 to allow electronic readerboard signs is not necessary for the preservation and enjoyment of substantial property rights. Staff Report - 12/6/88 -5- (1609d) 2 . Electronic readerboard signs, if permitted by Code Amendment No. 88-14, will be incompatible with surrounding existing and proposed development, especially residential land uses . 3 . Electronic readerboard signs visible from City streets would have the potential of slowing traffic and distracting to passing motorists. 4 . Code Amendment No. 88-14 to permit 35 foot high, 175 square foot electronic readerboards would be incompatible with the majority of existing signs constructed throughout the City since 1974 . 5 . Code Amendment No. 88-14 for electronic readerboard signs are more appropriate adjacent to freeways where there is not a mixture of vehicle/pedestrian flow, there is a greater maximum speed limit, and less competition amongst signs. 6 . 0 ALTERNATIVE ACTION: (A) The Planning Commission may approve Negative Declaration No. 88-39 and Code Amendment No. 88-14 as proposed by the applicant (Attachment No . 1) , with findings; or (B) The Planning Commission may approve Negative Declaration No. 88-39 and Code Amendment No. 88-14 as modified by staff (Attachment No. 2) with findings. ATTACHMENTS: 1 . Ordinance proposed by applicant (No. - A) 2 : Ordinance as modified by staff (No. - B) 3 . Negative Declaration No. 88-39 4 . Table - Orange County Cities - Sign Policies 5. Table - Sample Electronic Readerboards 6 . Map of Sample Electronic Readerboards 7 . Sample Readerboard per applicant ' s criteria SH:LP:kla Staff Report - 12/6/88 -6- (1609d) ��cow,vncn�cl-�nr1 ORDINANCE NO. , -A �..� AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH AMENDING THE HUNTINGTON BEACH ORDINANCE CODE SECTIONS 9610 .4, 9610 .51 9610 .9 AND 9610.10 TO ALLOW ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNS The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach does ordain as follows: SECTION 1 . Section 9610.4 (a)and (h) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to read as follows: 9610 . 4 Prohibited signs. The following signs are prohibited within the City of Huntington Beach: (a) Flashing, moving, pulsating, or intermittently lighted signs, including searchlights; except electronic readerboards and public service signs such as those for time and temperature. (h) changeable copy signs, readerboards, except 2129tunig readerboards or theatre marquees. SECTION 2. Section 9610 .5 (Permitted Signs-Schedule) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to incorporate into the schedule the following specifications pertaining to electronic readerboards. (b) COMMERCIAL Use of Sign Type Maximum Maximum Maximum Number Area Per Height - - Sign Electronic Readerboards (See Section 9610 .9(d)for specifications) SECTION 3 . Section 9610.9 (Miscellaneous Provisions) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to incorporate the following: - 1 - (d) Electronic Readerboards. Electronic readerboards may be perm ted subject to the approval of a conditional use - permit by the Planning Commission approval of a planned sign program according to the Provisions of section 9610.6 an approval of the Design Review Board according to the provisions of Article 985. Approval of electronic readerboards shall be subiect to the following standards: ( 1 ) Permitted signs. Electronic readerboards may be free standing or wall type signs. The maximum number of electronic readerboards shall be one per site. The maximum sign area which includes an electronic readerboard shall be one hundred seventy-five 175 square feet. The total sign area shall be limited to twice the size of the electronic readerboard portion of the sign. The maximum height of an electronic readerboard sign shall be thirty-five 35feet and shall have a minimum ground clearance of ten (10 ) feet. The electronic readerboard shall have cylinders, a _shade screen and a Photocell for reducing the intensity of lighting at night. The maximum measurable light output of the electronic readerboard shall not exceed 5-toot candies at the property line. (2 ) Location requirements. The minimum lot frontage of the parcel shall be two hundred (700) feet . Electronic readerboards shall be allowed only on parcels abutting a freeway and on parcels abutting Beach Boulevard, excluding the portion along Beach Boulevard designated as a landscape corridor south of Adams to Pacific Coast Highway The minimum distance between electronic readerboards shall be one hundred fifty (150 ) feet. The minimum distance from an electronic readerboard sign to any residence shall be one hundred fifty ( 150 ) feet. The minimum distance from an electronic readerboard to the interior property line shall be one hundred (100) feet. Outdoor Business - Any commercial outdoor business which relies _principally on the outside display of eighty (80%) percent or more of merchandise as the primary means of business, and for which the_ combined outdoor display areas, showrooms, inventory and work areas comprise no less than twenty ( 20%) percent of total site area. This shall apply only to properties fronting Beach Boulevard and parcels with freeway frontage, with each Property having a minimum of two (2) acres. 2 - ( 3 ) other standards. In addition to the electronic readerboard sign, one monument sign, maximum of seven 7 feet in height and a maximum of fifty (50 ) square feet in sign area, may be permitted and all other signage shall be brought into conformance with the provisions of this article. The hours of operation of any electronic readerboard _shall be limited to 6 :30 am to 10:30 pm. At least 10% of the message time, or any percentage deemed necessary by the city for emergency conditions, shall be used for public service announcements. Messages on an electronic readerboard shall be no faster than one message every four seconds and the minimum interval between messages shall be at least one second. Continuous motion of messages is not permitted. Light intensity changes (other than between day and night uses) are not permitted. SECTION 4 . Section 9610 . 10 (Definitions ) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended as follows: ( 15 ) Electronic Readerboard: A changeable . message sign consisting of a matrix of lamps which are computer controlled. ( 16 ) Flashing or animated sign: A sign intermittently reflecting light, or which has any illumination which is not maintained constant in intensity, color or pattern, If except electronic readerboards and those for time and temperature. ( 17 ) Freestanding sign: (Text unchanged) ,CX7X ( 18) Grade: (Text unchanged) ,CX�X ( 19 ) Grand opening: (Text unchanged ) (20 ) Ground level: (Text unchanged) XZ01 (21 ) Height of sign: (Text unchanged) ,CZXX (22) Indirect illumination : (Text unchanged) ,CzzX ( 23 ) Industrial center : (Text unchanged) Xz�X (24 ) Interior illumination: (Text unchanged) Xz�X (25) Item of information: (Text unchanged ) Xz�X ( 26) Land developmentproject: Text unchanged) fXjUy (27 ) Monument sign: Text unchanged ) 3 - ,Cz7X (28) Logo: (Text unchanged) ,Cz1�X (29 ) Nameplate sign: (Text unchanged) ^� Xz�X ( 30 ) Nonconforming sign: (Text unchanged) 1001 ( 31 ) Open house sign: (Text unchanged) 10.1; ( 32 ) Political sign: (Text unchanged) IOU (33 ) Projecting sign: (Text unchanged) ( 34 ) Real estate sign : (Text unchanged) ,COX ( 35 ) Roof sign: (Text unchanged) ,COX (36 ) Sign: (Text unchanged) 101 (37 ) Sign copy: (Text unchanged) MI (38 ) Sign structure: (Text unchanged) MI (39 ) Site: (Text unchanged) ,CAI (40) Site ( street ) frontage: (Text unchanged) , 4ol ( 41 ) Subdivision directional sign: (Text unchanged) Mrl (42 ) Supergraphic: (Text unchanged) XXZX (43 ) Temporary sign: (Text unchanged) (44 ) Trespassing sign: (Text unchanged) ,CX ( 45 ) Wall sign: (Text unchanged) i fA.91 (46 ) Window sign: (Text unchanged) PAGE END i 4 - SECTION 5. This or0inance shall take effect thirty days after its passage. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at a regular meeting thereof held on the day of , 1988 . Mayor ATTEST: APPROVED AS 10 PORM: City Clerk City Attaxner REVIEWED AND APPROVED: INITIATED AND APPROVED: City Administrator Director of Community Development 5 - Planning Staff Recommendation (Legislative Draft ) ' ORDINANCE NO. _ -B AN ORDINANCE OF 'THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH AMENDING THE HUNTINGTON BEACH ORDINANCE CODE SECTIONS 9610 .4 , 9610 .5 , 9610 .9 AND 9610. 10 TO ALLOW ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNS The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach does ordain as follows: SECTION 1 . Section 9610 .4 (a)and (h) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to read as follows: 9610.4 Prohibited signs. The following signs are prohibited within the City of Huntington Beach: (a) Flashing, moving, pulsating, or intermittently lighted signs, including searchlights; except electronic public service signs such as those for ttiime and temperature. (h) Changeable copy signs, except ej gg rnni g read rboards or theatre marquees. SECTION 2 . Section 9610 .5 (Permitted Signs-Schedule) of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended to incorporate into the schedule the following specifications pertaining to electronic readerboards . (b) COMMERCIAL Use of Sign Type Maximum Maximum Maximum Number Area Per Height Sign Electronic Readerboards (See Section 9610 .9(d)for specifications) _ l _ ll • e- If • • rMan W.M.4MW I Mj ic• M- I / • • 1 - • ! 1 • ! • f • • -to - • - ll ' f. • • 1 - - } • • • • • t • f • • {{ } - �._ _.fit. .�:._ 11--11"._�.-_ - t - - -- •li •. t.,. �..-. � ._ � !.._ • � • _ � !. 11 1 It • } - •11 - .1 • t • - • • • Other stands d . . in d9dW to the, -sign. one The hours of o®station of anv electrons �- repAe,-►, �...a shall be limited to 6:30 am to 10 :30 om. !Salt s e. or any 2ggggp 0 be used for Qublic §Rrv"k arinoucements �'lessaaes on an electronic readerboard shall be no faster _than one message eyery fgug seconds and the minimum interyll between messages shall be at least one second continuous motion of messaaes is not Dermit ed Fight intensity changes (other than between day and night uses are not permitted. SECTION 4 . Section 9610 . 10 (Definitions) of. the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is amended as follows: Gomuter controlled . Flashing or animated sign: A sign intermittently reflecting light, or which has any illumination which is not maintained constant in intensity, color or pattern, except except 91=990ig ggAderboAgd§ 'tea those for time and temperature. U01 L U Freestanding sign: (Text unchanged) ,1471 $ Grade: (Text unchanged ) 1W.1 4121 Grand opening: (Text unchanged) 126L Ground level : (Text unchanged) 100AY , ? Height of sign: (Text unchanged) ,IXXX Indirect illumination: (Text unchanged) XXZX ( Industrial center : (Text unchanged) XX�X Interior illumination: (Text unchanged) XXXX f Item of information: (Text unchanged) XX�X Land development roiect: Text unchanged) A49X Monument sign: Text unchanged ) 3 - xXXX Logo: (Text unchanged) Nameplate sign: (Text unchanged) Xz�X Nonconforming sign: (Text unchanged ) Open house sign: (Text unchanged) X�XX Political sign: (Text unchanged) X�XX 33 ) Projecting sign: (Text unchanged) Aill Real estate sign : (Text unchanged) X� X Roof sign: (Text unchanged) (Text unchanged) Sign copy: (Text unchanged) Sign structure: (Text unchanged) Site: (Text unchanged) X�pX Site (street ) frontage: (Text unchanged) Subdivision directional si_qn: (Text unchanged) ,I�XX Supergraphic: (Text unchanged) � zX Temporary sign: (Text unchanged) X �XSA_4j Trespassing sign: (Text unchanged) XXX 45 Wall sign : (Text unchanged) X�$XIA61 Window sign: (Text unchanged) PAGE END 4 - SECTION 5 . This ordinance shall take effect Thirty days after its passage. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at a regular meeting thereof held on the day of , 1988 . Mayor ATTEST: APPROVED AS TO FORM: City Clerk r�Cy �t�t�rney REVIEWED AND APPROVED: I ITIATED AND APPROVED: Ve,00000 City Administrator Dirlyter of Community evelopment be 5 - 1 H 1 INTER-DEPARTMENT COMMUNICATION Hes�c4a►�� To Laura Phillips From ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES Assistant Planner SECTION Subject ENVIRONMENTAL INFORMATION Date December 2, 1988 FORM NO. 88-39 Applicant: Huntington Jeep Eagle 16751 Beach Boulevard Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Request: Code amendment to allow electronic readerboards within the City of Huntington Beach Location: City of Huntington Beach along freeways and along Beach Boulevard, excluding the portion designated as a landscape corridor from Adams Avenue to Pacific Coast Highway. Background Staff has reviewed the environmental information form noted above and has determined ►-- that a negative declaration may be filed for the project. In view of this, a draft negative declaration was prepared and was published in the Daily Pilot and posted in the Office of the City Clerk for a ten (10) day public review period commencing December 2, 1988 and ending December 12, 1988. If any comments regarding the draft negative declaration are received, you will be notified immediately. Recommendation The Environmental Resources Section recommends that the Planning Commission approve Negative Declaration No. 88-39 finding that the proposed project will not have a significant adverse effect on the environment. Mitigation Measures X The attached mitigating measures will reduce potential environmental effects Y:{ resulting from the project and are recommended as conditions of approval.{ Respectfully ubmitted, Kelly ai Assistant lann KM:gbm t1684d-1) APPENN X 1 ENVIRONMENTAL CNECXLIST FORM (To Se Completed By Lead Agency) I. Bacicgrotxvi 1. Nerne of Prooment Hunt i ng t on Jeep Eagle 2. .address and Phcne Number of Proponent 16751 Beach Boulevard , Huntington Beach , CA 92647 3. C•.te of C.' cklist SLbmitted November 29 , 1988 4. Agency Requiring Checklist City of Huntington Beach S. Name of Proposal, if applicable Code Amendment No. 88-14 Environmental Assessment No. 88-39 li. Environmental Impacts (Exolonations of cll "yes" and "maybe" answers are required' on attcched shee-s.) Yes Maybe No I. Ecr'h. Will the proposal result in: c. llnstcble earth conditions or in changes in geologic substructures? x b. Disruptions, displacements, compaction or overcovering of ttfie sail? x C. Change in topography or ground surface relief features'. x d. The destruction, covering or modification Of any unique geologic or physical features? x e. Any increase in wind or water erosion of soils, either on or off the site? x f. Changes in deposition or erosion of beach sands, or charges in siltation, deposition or erosion which may modify the channel of o river or stream or the bed of the ocean or any boy, inlet or lake.? x 115 Yes 9. Evasum of p^opie or property to geolo- Sic hc'--crds such as earthquakes, lance+slides, mu4slides, ground failure, or similar hazards? X 2. Air. Will the proposal result in; So-bstantial air emissions or deterioration of ambient air quality? X b. The cr#-ition of objectionable odors? X C. Alteration of air movement, moisture, or temperature, or any change in climate, either locally or regionally? X 3. water• Will the proposal result in; a. Changes in currents, or the course of di- rection of water movements, in either marine or fresh waters? X b. Changes in absorption rates, drainage pat. terns, or the rate and amount of surface ruroff? _X c. Alteratiors to the course or flow of flood waters? .�.. X d. Change in the amount of surface water in ony water body? X e. D�schcrge into surface waters, or in any alteration of surface water quality, in- cluding but not limited to temperature, dissolved oxygen or turbidity? X f. Alteration of the direction or rate of flow of ground waters? X g. Change in the quantity of ground waters, either through direct odditions or with- drawals, or through interception of an aquifer by cuts or excavations? X h. Substantial reduction in the amount of water otherwise available for public water supp ties? X i. E)posure of people or property to water re- lated hazards such as flooding or tidal waves? X 116 Yes Maybe tJo D. Plant Life. Will the proposal result in: a. Change in the diversity of species, or nurr)er of any species of plants (including !tees, shrubs, grass, crops, and aquatic X Plants)? b. Reduction of the numbers of any unique, rare or endangered species of plants? X— C. Introduction of new Species of plants into an area, or in a barrier tc the normal replenishment of existing species'. X d. Reduction in acreage of any agricultural crop? X 5. Animal Life. Will the proposal result in: a. Change in the diversity of species, or numbers of ary species of animals (birds, land animals including reptiles, fish and she i I f ish, benth is organisms or insects)? X b. Reduction of the numbers of any unique, rare or endangered species of animals? X C. Introduction of new species of animals into an area, or result in a barrier to the � migration or movement of animals? _ X d. Deterioration to existing fish or wildlife habitat? X 6. Noise. Will the proposal result in: a. Increoses in existing noise levels? X b. Exposure of people to severe noise levels? X 7. Light and Glare. Will the proposal.produce X new light or glare? 8. Land Use. Will the proposal result in a sub- stontial alteration of the present or plonned land use of an area? X 9. Natural Resources. Will the proposal result in: a. Increase in the rate of use of any natural resources? X 117 Yes ,►ate � b. Substcntial depletion of any nonrenewcble natural resource? X I�. Rj..k of up-.et. will the proposal involves a. A risk of an explosion or the release of N zardous substances (including, but not limited to, oil, pesticides, chemicals or radiation) in the event of an accident or upset conditions? X b. Possible interference with an emergency response plan or an emergercy etiocLIGtion plan? X 11- Population. Will the proposal alter the location, distribution, density, or growth rate of the human population of an area? X 12. Housing. W111 the proposal affect existing hous- inn, or create a demand for additional housing? X 13. Transportation/Circulation, Will the proposal result in. a. Generation of substantial additional vehicular movement? X b. Effects on existi-N parking focilities, or _ demand for new parking? X C. Substantial impact upon existing transper_ tation systems? X d. Alterations to present patterns of circulo- t ion or movement of people and/or goods? X e. Alterations to waterborne, rail of air troffic? X f. Increase in troffic hazards to motor vehicles, bicyclists or pedestrians? X 14. Public Services. Will the proposal have an effect upon, or result in a need for new or altered govemmental services in any of the following areas: a. Fire protection. X b. Police protection? X C. Schools? X !18 Ves No d. Parks or other recreational focilities? X �. Mointenonce of public facilities, including r and s' X f. Other go,,emmental services? X IS. Energy. 'Hill the proposal result in: a. Use of substantial amounts of fvel or energy? X b. Substantial increase in demand upon exist- ing sources of energy, or require the development of new sources of energy? X 16. Utilities, Will the proposal result in a need for new systems, or substantial alterations to the following utilities: a. Power or natural gas? X b. Communications systems? _._ZS__ C. Water'. X d. '-;ew-r or septic tonics? X e. Storm wa!er drainage? X f. Solid wcste and disposal? X 17. i-iurnrn 1 eoIth. Will the proposal result in: o. Creation of any health hazard or potential health hazard (excluding mental health)? X b, Exposure of people to potential health hazards? X 18. Aesthetics. Will the proposal result in the obstruction of any scenic vista or view open to the public, or will the proposal result in the . creation of an aesthetically offensive site opus to public view? X 19. Recreation, Will the proposal result in an impact upon the quality or quantity of existing recreational opportunities? X 20. Cul tural Resources, a- 11Vill the propowl result in the alteration Of ar the destruction of a prehistoric or historic archoeologiCal site? X 119 Yes b. Will the proposal result in adverse phyy;Cal or aesthetic effects to a prehistoric or historic building, structure, or object? X C. Does the proposal have the potential to cause a physical change which would affect unique ethnic cultural values? X d. Will the proposal restrict existing religious or sacred uses within the potential ierpotI area? X 21. Mandatory Findings of Significance. r a. Does the project have the potential to degrade the quality of the environment, substantially reduce the habitat of a fish Of wildlife species, cause a fish or wild- life population to drop below self sus- raining levels, threaten to eliminate d Plant or animal community, reduce the number or restrict the range of a rare or endangered plant or animal or eliminate important examples of the major periods of California history or prehistory? X b. Does the project have the potential to "y... achieve short-term, to the disadvantage of long-term, environmentol goals? (A short- term impact on the environment is one which occurs in a relatively brief, definitive period of time while long-term impacts will endure well into the fututeJ X c. Does the project have impacts which are individually limited, but cumulatively con- sideroble? (A project may irrpact on two or more separate resources where the impact on each resource is relatively small, but where the effect of the total of those impacts on the environment is significant.) X d. Does the project have environmental effects which will cause substantial adverse effects on human beings, either directly or indirectly? X III. Discussion of Environmental Evaluction IV, Determination (To be Completed by the lead Agency) 120 DISCUSSION OF YES AND MAY ANSWERS ON ENVIRONMENTAL CHECKLIST NO. 88-39 LIGHT AND GLARE 7. The proposed project has the potential to have significant impacts upon the environment with respect to light and glare, particularly in the immediate vicinity of any site which would be allowed to have a readerboard. Light projection from a readerboard or several readerboards together onto adjacent residences could prove to be quite severe without appropriate constraints upon height, size, sign frequency, location and hours of operation. The following mitigation measures are included within the proposed Code Amendment and should reduce light and glare impacts from readerboards to a level of non—significance: Height A. The maximurn height of an electronic readerboard,shall be thirty—five (35) feet and shall have a minimum ground clearance of ten (10) feet. B. The maximum sign area which includes an electronic readerboard shall be one hundred seventy five (175) square feet. Sign Frequency C. The maximum number of electronic readerboards shall be one per site.. D. The minimum lot frontage of the parcel shall be two hundred (200) feet. Location E. The minimum distance between electronic readerboards shall be one hundred fifty (150) feet. F. The minimum distance from an electronic readerboard to the interior property line shall be one hundred (100) feet. G. The minimum distance from an electronic readerboard sign to any residence shall be one hundred fifty (150) feet. H. Readerboards shall be allowed only on parcels abutting a freeway and on parcels abutting Beach Boulevard, excluding the portion along Beach Boulevard designated as a landscape corridor south of Adams Avenue to Pacific Coast Highway. Hours of Operation I. Hours of operation shall be limited to 6:30 a.m. to.10:30 p.m. (1684d-2) To control the intensity of light projection from a readerboard: �... Intensity J. Readerboards shall have cylinders, a shade screen and a photocell for reducing the intensity of lighting at night. K. Maximum measurable light output of the electronic readerboard shall not exceed 5-foot candles at the property line. With mitigation measures, no significant impacts are anticipated. TRAFFIC AND CIRCULATION 13f. Flashing, pulsating signs with messages have the potential to be a hazardous distraction to motorists. It is important to monitor sign frequency, the distance between signs, and the rate at which messages are flashed. By monitoring these factors, one is able to minimize the distracting elements of the proposed type of sign. The following mitigation measures are included in the proposed Code Amendment and should reduce the impacts of readerboards upon traffic safety to a level of nonsignificance: Sign Frequency Please refer to Measures C and D under Light and Glare. Distance Between Signs Please refer to Measure G under Light and Glare. Message Frequency L. Readerboard messages shall be no faster than one message every four seconds and the minimum interval between messages shall be at least one second. The above measure is suggested by the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans). The requirement of a Conditional Use Permit for installation of an electronic readerboard will allow the City to monitor the cumulative impacts readerboards may have upon traffic safety. In addition, the following measure is included in the proposed Code Amendment to enhance traffic safety: M. A minimum of ten (10%) percent of message time, or any percentage deemed necessary by the City for emergency conditions, shall be used for public service announcements. With mitigation measures, no significant impacts are anticipated. (16S4d-3) AESTHETICS 18. Several,factors including height, size, number, frequency, message type and location will contribute to the aesthetic impacts electronic readerboards singularly and cumulatively have on their neighborhoods. If allowed, electronic readerboards must be limited to a size which is somewhat harmonious with other signs in an area. Obviously, the shorter a sign and the smaller its square footage, the less of a visual impact upon the street and adjacent neighborhood. Measures A and B under Light and Glare address these concerns. The distance between readerboards and the number of them visible on a street effect the degree to which visual impacts will be experienced by traffic on the subject street and by adjacent residences. The fewer the number of readerboards and the greater the distance between them, the lesser the aesthetic impact. Mitigation Measures C and D address these concerns. Limiting the location of readerboards, a commercial property and their distance from residential property will reduce aesthetic impacts upon those properties. Measures E, F and G under Light and Glare address these concerns. Locating.the signs on streets or along freeways where their presence will not appear to be out-of-place or incompatible with the surrounding environment will also decrease aesthetic impacts resulting from electronic readerboards. Their limitation to a portion of Beach Boulevard or along freeways and only on lots with relatively greater street frontage address this concern. Mandatory review through a Conditional Use Permit for installation of electronic readerboards will contribute to lessening the negative aesthetic impacts associated with allowing the proposed type of sign. Wtih mitigation measures, no significant impacts are anticipated. r..r (l 684d-4) ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNAGE REQUIREMENTS BY CITY ORANGE COtJ�ITY ERB Signs Prohibited How ERB City by Code Existing Signs Sign Permitted Anaheim No Anaheim Toyota Building Travel Lodge permits Pac-Tel Anaheim Hilton Anaheim Convention Center Embassy Suites Brea Yes None Buena Park Yes House of Imports Variance Costa Mesa Yes Harbor plaza Planned Sign Program Fairgrounds Not under City jurisdiction. Cypress Yes None City Council Fountain Yes None --- Valley Fullerton No None CUP Garden Grove Yes Orange County Volvo Approved with condition: 1 message change/ 24 hour period Irvine Yes None --- Laguna Beach Yes None Design Review Board La Habra Yes None Variance/Cup La Palma Yes None City Council Los Alamitos Yes None Planned Sign Program Newport Beach No None --- Orange No Rehabilitation Institute Design Review Board `' Placentia Yes None Variance ELECTRONIC READERBOARD SIGNAGE REQUIRENENTS BY CITY (Continued) ERB Signs Prohibited How ERB City by Code Existing Signs Sign Permitted .San Clemente Yes None Variance San Juan Yes None --- Capistrano Santa Ana Yes Santa Ana Auto Center Variance (Redevelopment Area) Seal Beach Yes None --- Stanton Yes None Variance Tustin Yes None Villa Park --- None --- Westminster Yes Centennial Thrift & Loan Variance Sunset Ford Variance Yorba Linda Yes None Variance OUTSIDE ORANGE COUNTY ERB Signs Prohibited How ERB City by Code Existing Sign, Sian Permitted Arcadia Yes None Carson No Cormier Chevrolet Variance ITT Building Permit Carson Civic Center Exempt Compton Yes Auto Mall Redevelopment Area Downey Yes Embassy Suites Public Service. Sign Duarte No Duarte Toyota Architectural Duarte Suzuki Board approval La Mirada Yes Gateway Plaaa Redevelopment Agency `-' ELECTRONIC READEEROARD SIGIRAGR RXQUIROMWS BY CITY (Continued) OUTSIDE DBANQB CDt�io4TY ERB Signs Prohibited How ERB City by Cock EXIgting Algag Sign Permitted Long Beach Long Beach Convention Center Monrovia Yes Auto Mall Variance Norwalk Yes Norwalk Toyota Sign Use Permit Ramada Ion (Variance) Pasadena No Pasadena Civic Canter Building permit Hastings Ranch Shopping Nonconforming Center Santa Fe No, but Santa Fe Springs Plaza City-funded limited to project 10 acre sites South Gate No Pete Ellis Dodge Non-conforming Jeep/Eagle SAMPLES OF EXISTING ELECTRONIC READERBOARDS IN ORANGE AND LOS ANGLLES COUNTIES - Size of Lines of Electronic Approximate $lectronic gusiness Location Ho: Haight Coov Centennial Thrift NEC Beach and 3' x 20' = 30'-35' 1 8 Loan Westminster 60 sq.ft. (Westminster) Sunset Ford* S. of Garden 7' x 35' 60 ' 3 Grove Blvd. 245 sq.ft. (west of Edwards) (Westminster) Orange County 10120 Garden 6' x 25 ' 35' 3 Volvo Grove Blvd. 125 sq.ft. SWC (Garden Grove Blvd. and Brookhurst) (Garden Grove) Gateway Plaza* Valley View off 8' x 15' 50' 3 5 Freeway 120 sq.ft. (La Mirada) House of Imports* 6862 Manchester 8' a 25' 30' 3 Beach Boulevard 200 sq.ft. and 5 Freeway (Buena Park) Santa Fe Springs Off 605 Fwy. 8' x 254 45' 3 Shopping Center on Telegraph 200 sq.ft. (Santa Fe Springs) Norwalk Toyota 11530 Firestone 6' x 25' 40' 2 Blvd. (Norwalk) 150 sq.ft. Ramada Inn* 14299 Firestone 8' x 30' 93 ' 3 Boulevard off 240 sq.ft. 5 Freeway - (Norwalk) - *Freeway visibility . Six® of Lines of �. Electronics Approximate Electronic business Location Sex. Height _ C92Y Embassy Suites 8425 Firestone 6' x 18' 35'-40' 3 Blvd. (Downey) 108 sq.ft. Pete Ellis Dodge 5800 Firestone 5' x 25' 55 ' 3 Jeep/Eagle Blvd. (Firestone 125 sq.ft. exit off Long Beach Freeway) (South Gate) Cormier Chevrolet* Wilmington 8 8' x 25' 110 ' 3 405 Freeway 200 sq.ft. (Carson) ITT* Wilmington t 4 ' x 18' 45' 3 405 Freeway 72 sq.ft. (Carson) ` Carson Civic 701 E. Carson 6' x 18' 15' 3 Center (Carson) 108 sq.ft. Monument Anaheim Toyota* 1601 S. Anaheim 8' x 25' 50' 3 Blvd. (Harbor 200 sq.ft. exit off 5 Freeway) (Anaheim) Travel Lodge* 1221 S. Harbor 6' x 18' 30' 3 Blvd. (Harbor. 108 sq.ft. exit off 5 Freeway) (Anaheim) Pac-Tel* (Harbor exit 5$x 21' 30' 2 off 5 Freeway) 105 sq.ft. (Anaheim) Anaheim Hilton 777 West 6' x 18' 25'-30' 3 Convention Way 108 sq.ft. (Katella/Harbor) (Anaheim) Anaheim Convention 800 W. Katella 6' x 25' 35'-40' 3 Center (Katella/Harbor) 150 sq.ft. (Anaheim) Embassy Suite* Glassel off 6' x 18' 50 '-60' 3 91 Freeway 108 sq.ft. *Freeway visibility Size of Liner f Electronic Approximate Elegy Business Location Box Height Co Santa Ana Auto (Edinger Exit 5' x 17' 60' 3 Center* off 55 Freeway) 85 sq. ft. (Santa Ana) Orange County Fairgrounds* Fair/55 Freeway 5' x 20' 20' 2 (Costa Mesa) 100 sq.ft. Harbor Plaza 2300 Harbor 5' x 20' 30' 1 Boulevard 100 sq.ft. (Harbor/Wilson) (Costa Mesa) Compton Auto* Harbor Freeway 10' x 36' 85' 3 Plaza 8 Artesia 360 sq. ft. (Compton) Pasadena Civic 300 E. Green 6' x 16' 154 2 Center (Public (Green and Los 96 sq.ft. Monument Service Robles) Announcements (Pasadena) Hastings Ranch Rosemead/ 3 ' x 25' 40' 1 Shopping Center Foothill 75 sq. ft. (Pasadena) Duarte Toyota* (Buena Vista 7' x 36' 55' 3 Exit off 210 252 sq. ft. Freeway) (Duarte) Duarte Suzuki* (Buena Vista 7' x 30' 55' 3. Exit off 210 210 sq.ft. Freeway) (Duarte) Rehabilitation 1800 E. LaVeta 9 ' x 1' 30' 1 Institute (Tustin Blvd. 9 sq.ft. north of 22 Freeway) (Orange) *Freeway visibility Size of + Linen of Electronic Approzimate Electronic Business Location Box Height Cepv Long Beach 300 E. Ocean n/a n/a n/a Convention Center Blvd. (Long Beach) *Freeway visibility 1 F or ✓� p"ll�ltw�► � �� riot-**" IT- , mwn _ "M�~sue ... wwl vp • ♦� .�TCC\ a aj TAwl s 111111i111+ 0,4L 11I lit I wool I PIR fA •.� '��-^ ��I !q!!!q� �ONE Iggrl►AT ao 0 r tQ K wex 6. 0 ►pro:- N Wn� fww�, 4 rro. N At."rtr ivaes.iti1�►.t�►Inr�J.- a. ILM o = OBO 4 u� ,pro • e P ►� �r Q P Q EL E1//� _ t%pU m LOr1 oir= 1.c� Office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Beach - P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 9 ' <. R *,t y 1 Inmy Ln . O 0�_r,� on Beach ; Ca . 92.647 v� o �p o Office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 KOBAYASHI , AT!;IJK.O 16645 APBOR CTR HUN f Itir.1 t1N BEACH , CA 92647 /�f',.', /4,:iR.'.,3' 7NJ. 01 R.'..:i!>;9 RETURN TO NO Fl]R!~!ARDJ NLr CiRDI TZ ON F Jf L.F-1 UNAG3I_.I" TO 1:01_1�WEtRD i; CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK January 11, 1989 Dean Allison 20362 Bridgeside Lane #203 Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Dear Mr. Allison: Today this office received your letter dated January 9, 1989, regarding the appeal filed by Councilman Silva to the Planning Commission's denial of Code Amendment 88-14. The appeal is tentatively scheduled for the February 6, 1989, Council meeting. Your letter will be transmitted to the City Council , staff and all others receiving Agenda Packets. The City Council Agenda and back-up material on this . appeal will be available approximately one week prior to the Council meeting. If you would like copies of same, please feel free to come by the office or phone and copies will be mailed to you. Sincerely, 1 f Connie Brockway, CMC City Clerk CB:pm (Telephone:714-536-5227) Office of the City Clerk C Ity of Huntingtot. 3each P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 ,. IU,2-481-06,07 e' 9921 � un0rh Ur. Ilurr :� i I3e0ch ,Cyr , 92646 0 • J P.O.BOX 190 vCALIFORNIA 92648 Ilun C' r o V i 1 Lage 71 J. 111vd . V' P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 t . t.King 1 3O8 Shadow Oak Ln . ial.vevn ,PA 19355 159-271-66 Office of the City Clerk City ` of Huntington Bc4,ii P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 V. tt :. Cop, I'll tin`yLoll ,.ic 13eli,Cs . 92647 ?Islsss:lsi:fls:tissli::sis!Iilt P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 o�Resident $ 7881 Beachpoint #4 Huntington Beach, Ca . 92647 Q� ?isissssliisiMsss?st?issslssi:?? l 1 1 K 11 111.L L.L L l..Lt•1,1 1 P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 qq 77 ,�t•,U�C �p � "Resident , 7912 Beachpoint A-17 �Juntington Beach , Ca . 92647 —84 - � f s Office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 '< ; ow /(\�/�/j yesident 7882 Beacr:p i r,t =17 V Huntington each , Ca 92647 lip (IililE?I?11�1??!IF'.I�?i?I!!li�l Office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 Resident 7912 Beachpoint A-21 Huntington Beach , Ca . 92647 I Y Resid nt 7912 B achpoin A20 Huntin ton B h, CA 92648 Office of the City Clerk City ' of Huntington Beach P.O. BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 . r �tv t 1 Resident =` 912 Beachpoint # 1 H ntington Beac CA 92648 Office of the City Clerks City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 Pv GVF 'UCH NUMBER 6, 'yS1 Ate¢ Ave, . 1'11.4 1 � lfilXi; ig oi � h,Ca.92647 P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648' 2j e7.' 'Q31v(I . � f�^n/t.- fP Beacl�;*�. 92G4t3 ,�ti r•v.tiUX 190 CALIFORNIA 9264$ -.� cr,jv� 3001..i3U0" ? - r>:8 Blvd .#320 Shc (.'m' J )al(S,Ca.91403 �Atternpted No fi!f?i??:f(?(i:(Ifiii?ij �t} i i i ii li n Office of the City Clerk t x City of Hu nti n to n B � p�� g each s i98`� P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA92648 '.'; � '' rT-,C Ileacl�..l3l:v(I . 1}each,Ca .92647 �v it?I!??ilil!li!iil!ill,!,#:{iilliiiiiliiliiil!(llf!I I Office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 ": 107-601-47 , Parekh , H:B 8636 Production Ave . Ste A San Diego, Ca. 92121 P.O.BOX 190 �CALIFORNIA" t8 a _ J. KERB, GAORGE TR -� 13 D[ t1VI1.L U PL 4 %: COSTA MESA, CA 92626 i'dC:{ h(:1F+:+..tr•^:f�;l:}::(a��i:; 1:ll��aal::a��, t: .,l l:1i`•tr'�rE:.l...f:: '('('i I::•{::1l�"t!.!r'':IC}::(:L..i=: y'C1@rK > ' City of Huntington Beach - P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 k �t F yp 41 My Ln , �Cy �� � on Beac, , � Ca . 92647 d Office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 KOSAYASHI , ATSUKO 1661+5 ARr1OR CIR c � {{L:N7Irru1 r7N f,EACH r [:A 1..64 /4::32317W. f�:H�:•CURN 'T'O 13[:.N1'X- L,.•, r-w .:.rntC1�'Y'�Jr rl�:l')I"72 (7t`t 1'71_h a Uttice of the City Clerk City of Hunting to Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 ( - d 07-60.1-1,7 Parek.h 8636 Pr0OUCLi.ml Ave. Office of the City Clerk > City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 q � iS F: �T h0GRESS Lj ATTEMPTED. UI�I;IVO'dUN �- '0 SUCH F�UR�iBER Resident 7882 Beachpoi # 17 Huntingto ach, CA 92648 lill!II hill I!If „ll,lf:1,11=t1,„I� ll,i Resident E 7881 Beachpoint �' Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Bc. .,:h P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 Resident 7881 Beachpoi nt Ci r D-22 Huntington Beach, C 92648 ,6 11!��ls=�tlsill:rt1t21I!:I!+�i��!�t*.Iif!�tf131?t!I1=.t City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 �tIAYE ItiiA tt KCAL 92b��7 t I s City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 D L4. I t�tS A 166 * tS�lf'lI`a t_N HUIITKd(; '1I Alf .A 92647 F19 y� Office of the City Clerk -City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648. -? " Resident h 7881 Beacnpoioch '647 Huntinaton Be ° ,3 f Office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 ALGERNON J �w RBOR CIR �y I�T N BCH, CAL 92647 O 11111,11#,#„,#„#,## Office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Beach - P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648., . DUGAN, A 1e6 57 Y P N'C LN HUFITiN H, CA 92647 F© Office of the City Clerk City of Huntington Beach P.O.BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 a tNKI I I-D t; ' �I1 L C AL y2 'i7 N U. d 4