HomeMy WebLinkAboutZone case 77-3 Area B - Planning Commission - Magnolia St anm
Gj
V1
r
PIEMO TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
May 211, 1977
Planning Commission Members
John O'Connor, Deputy City Attorney
Zone Case 77-3 "B"
This memorandum respond, to the Planning Commission's 1-equr�st for
an analysis of a letter in opposition to the rezoning of the sub-
ject property.
The law is clear that; a city has the inhe vent. authot,.tt;y uttclt,r 1 Ls
police power to re:.ot.e property, and a rezoning is valid even though
it may cau,e substantial diminution in the value of the property.
Pennsylvania Coal Cotef. n.v v . Mahon, 260 11%S 393. :Sce also 711 Yale
Law Journal 3Et. In Uc'lcl i31aLt: v. fietrt ted, 369 11" 590, the United
States Supreme Court. Ili ld ghat a regulat.tcitz :'r i1ch prec lud►-d use or
a quarry, and required t h'at, it; be filled to 17-1r'ound water level, was
held valid even though the value of the: 1.rclpe?rt;y a-) a quarry was
almost: total.1j dest,roye:c1, 1'rr_.-pe-1,ty values ctlr! be :;ut s,tat3tIal.l.y
reduced by r'ec;ul ate fart , i'c r• e,xtrtnl) I,e , tr; llrlcl,te l3r'c:k 239
US 3y11, the Urtltc(l St at of +�l r►�tn�' { Gut t+�c-ci:•t �t 113+. r.lrr!
that I-ed1jeed the v:t.itar� i,y nv(�r f'Of A- Iet t,lrr. lr•.'teltr)(� ' 3t;r' ref' t:tlC.1 I(1
J. 1"irtiblet'�_�_,.1�•
__ y
r't)itlfi t•rlli ,,h rc (iTj'-" ,f! veil u,- ,;-lj.j3t'c;x 1rn,.!.� .l;r 7. ~ , ttid o 1:,r ! n Cotv;n.l .l
r "!tod Nock Pr'oduot.: ,.'. C"It 369
e. r tJJ '.ticts +.ub:,tar)l:,all,, t'c.d1 .-d by th(.: tr'.:( ni►lt;,
a .'
i3' l t.t 1
.; ,. t ''• t t•i• �, c I'f';:(:+t3 I7 "
uphold
lr►t* t.•• ••r
i ,r; Lh.
t ., 3. is ,r (••xe t'r'
rat' t:1le r.it,y' :t 1��;
i 1 V'�� (�(�t•;ret�
t,1;'�r'r� ',h�� t'
. ,�:t itti� 3:'
,1r1',', 1 t`; :�1 rat! ,;r�t1t3.1
j'�.1rrn13inF� 1 1'i.nc .tl�l(
:;. 1lr'.
1) ): r ;,j
�,t)rir l ! ,
+. }t=' !' �(•t.�t i 1 r �tl--
te ntj(,nu of, tho
:vvj
t hf. .t )t� („� trt
.. ;, j :r
) ,, t,,. r;' }.►t ��.tt
►,c�,
t v. t..d'Al
}r�+3rlti fil�ittt11.r3f�
j>t'lr3c:lj}.lc.,
!:; lr.'1-�J1Iy ,S►J:;'
! i't.rtF r,
'It;11 :''1.11(.1,.
I;r•;;E,(�'ct.:l'+3.1 �+,,;,� t:(,t11t(il t.t r.`''.S �
Edward Selich, Planning'Director
Planning Department
City of Huntington Beach
P. 0. Box 190
Huntington Beach, California 92648
Re: ZONE CASE NO. 77--3"B"
Uiar Sir:
June 8, 1977
1l. NTINGTON BEACI I
PLANNING DEPT.
JUN I U i,J: ,
P. 0. Box 190
i iuntington Benh, OA 92648
This office requests a copy of the proposed. ordinance
for this zone change,. na----Well-as--a--copy., of the land use
descriptiong,.for an LU and an RA distriot-. It is also
re uest�pd-�that further notices concerning z4nin
than cr`nos. 77-311A" through "r� D" be sent t •theollowin
add es -
�. ..--- �,
====,Sta --California
Department of Transportatiot.
Excess Lands Section
Attn: Z. Harrison
120 South :spring Street
Los Angeles, California 90012
Your courtesy anj ccoperat;ion in thJ g matter its appreciated,
Very truly yours,
.10130ph A. Montoya
DY
1111 chnel. J. Hanna
Attorney
I,,1i? • d c
•
ZC # 77-3"B"
August 30, 1977
r.r 00 400 00rr••rr/•r•rr•rrr••.r•••rrrp/••••.
r Y1•• r rf• r r•rr••rr•r•r •••1/1•,
•t•...
••.1lfr..•r ,..,...•, ..
:
114-495-05
114-495-14
11+�493-�158
Burns L Peterson
Ralph H Hatfield
,':Hurley, Pauline
l Gold Bluff
9142 Christine Drive
;.9161 Christine Dr
Irvine, Calif
Huntington Beach, Calif
H tIncgton Beach, CA 92646
92714
92646
111--495-06
114l
.J14-493•-16s
� t J Sin Jr
D Nunes
Charleess D
:,Levin, Ralph
9222 Christine Drive
9132 Christine Drive
9141 Christine or
'MAntington
Huntington Beach, Calif
�
Huntington Bwch, Calif
Beach, CA 92646
92646
92646
rirrrrr•r•1•r....r•.rr..r.1...•r•r.rrr
••....r1♦rrrr•r•.r....•r.r...,,•
r•a,./.r..rr.♦rr..,.•.•..a,..•-•
,,114-494-09s
114-495-07
114-495-16
Tuttle, Julian M
Lucille A Bagnoli
Michael S Chaplin
9121 Christine Dr
9562 Hightide Drive
9122 Christine Drive
4h1ntingtcn 3each, CA 92646
ifunti.ngton Beach, Calif
Ilurtington Beach, Calif
92646
92646
114-494-10s
114-495-08
114-481-09
Nall, Clifford
Amysue C Harris
Raymon3 F Jones
9111 Christine Dr
:
9202 Christine Drive
22052 Hula Circle
Huntirxiton Beach,. CA 92646
s
Huntington "ch, Calif
Huntington Beach, Calif
92646
92646
114-494-11s
114-495-09
14--481-06
A)=ahwLs'ort, Pearl R
RicIvird A Pobjoy
Christopher Valsaunakis
9101 Chr. stinse Dr
9192 Christine Drive
22081 Susan Lane
ftuntington Lktach, CA 92646
t;untiIvit:on Mach, Calif
Huntirxlton Wach, Calif
92646
926.16
114-495-01
114-495-10
114-491-07
Jufanita C Wair
R Wdjll
i rrknl'd B WI. inn
9272 Christine Drive
9182 Mritati.rw. Griv(.
13074 'frail lk)ll(-m
Iiuntirfit.cn rs--<ach, calif
lIWILi.rrf#:on
1kniston, gbxas
92696
92046
77024
114 .495-02
ll 1- 19�i-1 l
Ill-•1II1-qE3
Jams C ILbotscatt
ti.
9262 Christine Drive
9172 Cizri,f;Lirx) Privu
22072 Eiula Circle.
"untirgicx, leac}l, C.ali.f
I *ar.•f1, Ca,lit
:
H.urt:ircJtorl L3-ach, Calif
92646
192646
92646
114•-495-03
: 'Jwtex B'tenx-r
t•',xrtj?t,al l f;
14252 Mristitw Dr.iw.-
:
9JG2 Chri:tine brive
1,i'U4.1 NO,) C4.1 lc;
iiltlrtgtar) Ik'_ cho Calif
lh-Ultir?it"41 1}.V 'hf Calif
11;Ultilx1to-1 1.Y:1'h' Calif
12646
926116
111.4-495-04
-y0 1-1 ,
kicluird 1d-x -!.s
•
.,lGe,s•.�t �� 'I r.•d i..+
tt11I1S4
y
J P. } '.�4't C.! �.%� 1, 6 rr�
R24. 2 Olr•ist..ine In
,/,��y,, ► �' t•ra,
SWi:7 IrY4Lon F�.�.ae,., ,..
.
itol tiir•;R: �:R t4..':::••((y,
_f t .. _. { , t.,:S...l
!tt,f i rt 1� 1
3. l l t: r,. �..'1 �`_'';1',: t � i i f.
02646
,+»+«. ..... ,,,�...,. __.._.._. ...-. ...... :!.
a
'
r
.....*•'+u...,:.au-!,F.sws. ..+.,....... ac_•..... ... ... .,...>Y . •.•.x:.
.. �'"X., .... ..a .w:�•,r.;m ... r. ; �•a*i..... ,�..,,,..
e
Y
.� .. • ... 1 . . 1 . • • • • • • 1 • ♦ . • • 1 • • • • • • • • f •
•
:�••1.1.4-160-42 ..
CbLmtX Sanitation District #1
"of Orange.•0mmty et al :
P.O.bmc ' 8127
Vomtain V&Uev, Calif 92708 :
. • • • • • • • • 1 . • • ♦ • • ♦ • f • • • • 1 • • • ♦ • • • • .
ZC.#77-3 'B'
August 30, 1977 (JH)
•
,114-150-43 114-•513-08
-,:C0mty Sanitation Dsitricts Jack W Fletcher
:4112, 3, % 6, , 7 & 11 22211 M&Llibu Lane
'P.O. P.O. Box 5175 Huntington Beach, Calif
.1.0844 Ellis Avenue 92648
Fountain Valley, California
92708
•
114-160-55
Brookhurst Associates
8383 Wilshire Blvd Suite 1050 :
Baverly hills, Calif
90211 :
114-7.60-69 :
Daisey E 11 11borpe :
Philip Piceirelly
P.O. box 4187
Msa, Arizona a 85201
114-513-09
RaWn-d J Courtney
22221 Malibu Lane
Iiuntirxlton Bach, Cal -if
92646
1 . . I • • • • • ► • . . . . . . . , • • . ... . . . . . . . . .
114-513-10
Berman Kohler
8312 Leilani Drive
liuntimjton Bach, Calif
92646
114-513-11
km; r:ck:roc
I14-160-45 1iAxitAxiti
x ;
114-511-17
Arthur C Jones
9321 L-,ilani Circle
Huntington Beach, Calif
: 92646
114-511-18
RidaW P Quenneville
9331 Leilard Drive
11antingtoi, Beach, Calif
92646
114-491-02
Jack L I e mister
9231 Christine Drive
: Huntington &each, Calif
92646
114-4 91--03
Henry M zgwa
9241 Christine Drive
Iuntington Beach, Calif
92646
:14-491-04s
: Fox, Paysiond J
9261 Christine Dr
: lftmt:irxjon Bach, CA 92646
:
t
114-492-15s
M, ;,Zola, Dave: J
9191 Christirxi Dr
ItwitimjUm Beach, C1►92646
i14�4Ga�-Aa
114-�1.3-11.
114-49.-16s
lkvokhura Astxx:icatfis
1*-tier I' At4r,-'•,a
:
I'�az'1kur�, tiruk►lcl It
`' fibber rt It IQ4jz
9322 lk-ilanl IwIvr..
9201 Cru• tr;t:i nc Ur
: Fimic:ial Conatrr npit:
Il mtj tr,It.r.X) lv-ZZldh, Ual i f"
Ilt.rtt»1ixlt; m FY2ach,
CA 92646
8383 Wilshire 1,14Ai
1
92646
:
Suits` 1061j
J 14-•`il i -J :?
1.14-492-1Jtt
:falovhrly Hil1F�, C'fjli`
.�,c�I,�tx�rs L'J ::�n;c�.�t�
Itly�Yi,f'Ft.rr}k
` 3 ?"1a Lvi limi Drive
9211. C r'it;k. ne [fir
11(mLi.tr3t on i� �i�+:?,, U111 t'
:
HU11 i rrllran E; NACIt,
(Y02046
92640
I
�� 1.�.�•'4 ii0w54
`'
•
1.3.•1-413--1 �.�
{
: i.1a ltirCi Ik 11 t't, al
l.t,!! srXl�.'}t'S
"` ;�- ,r•
..4301 N FltAri"mu
:
4 32Z Ti!hit
9).71 t }r.1:?t'2ttk.' 1st
o% W6,16
` t 5
92646
r ;i ,• .. wi . a - _ �,,^:...,,. ....._. _.... ... I
..., .Ia'.Nlr+9w'art"..:....,:.:".�;.,�„•'q��...•.•i+...•.r.... `� �.•
wt•q/�'•t" ..r:-.......-•. ....�—
•
. r
•
t
i
.. . . .. .6f
,,,,, Y,;•...-,.4r^. _ -. i:..a+n ,. ......,.....-lYPi+-_'-.::'T.a..-...,•yv.•,cs.:svw
'.y'.. "'A s+s»+.:•.•'w�...
♦ t ♦ ♦ . . . . » I • . . . . . . a . ^ . . �• . r
^sxr+rwr.�Ye+*n-.. .. .. ,,.�,X........wi>"�r".:+t.F:.*...-..ro.
` .., ..., ._ ..--+.a.ri1.::,;yw...^—�-'b""r
}
j.
♦ � I i i 1 1 i i 1 i /1 • 1 1 f 1 1 1 f • • • .. 1 ... f • ! • .. • S
. • ...... • . • • ♦ • 1 1 1 .. • ! • / .. • 1 1 • .. 1 ♦ .
'.114481.-18
•
Ellyn: B Wikxc
7C77
22071 M"t Circle
August 30, 1977 (Mi)
'}ltwir�gfi�on Beach, Calif
92646
f
�:114-48h`•19
114-481-27
Fran lI l B Goodeno igh
Gordon E Bunting
.r W02 O ristine Drive
9082 Christine Drive
Hatitia gtart Beach, Calif
Huntington Beach, Calif
'0264f,
92646
,..
.•114-481-20
114-481-28
Don ffiwzk
Edward E Loranger
9012 Christine Drive
lip 9092 Christine Drive
'" iiuntington Beach, Calif
Mtntirxgton Beach, Calif
92646
92646
.114-481-21
114--481-29
Rayn=4 0 Viminti
:
1.14-401-29
U9 Via Lido Soud
Floyd Patrick Jr
N Wort Beach, Calif
9102 Christine Drive
. 52663
liuntingtan wach, Calif 92646
I
'
114--481-22
:
114-401-30
` Richard B Weir
Lr st,--r P Golfoa
9032 Christine Drive
22161 Word Ialwtd Lane
ltuntington Beach, Calif
llwnt.irxitai Beach, Calif
9:2646
92646
.1 ♦ 1 • • ♦ • • . . . . . . . . l . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . •,
. . . . . , . . . . . . . . . • • . . . . . . .. . . ♦ .
114-401-23
1.14-481-09
William R Darke
lby.wn 3 F RM Jonc!s
9042 Christine Drive
22052 It as Circic
flunt:i.m3toll Deach, Calif
lhxrit fi'$jt.rx, 52ac:li, Calif
92646
92646
114-481- .4
114-481-•10
William 4 lloagti
Frail, 14 CalabreF.:�
`: 9052 Christine Drive
22042 llul.:, Circle
• )intirkl ton Dead i, Ca 1 i f
thin Lb rl ton C -f l i f
92646
92646
'1f,.l,l...•........ .....•....
•r
»
.•. •.•. ......... ........ . .
114--401-25
a.i4�9 3.1.-11
' Ibxvey iie:rxlarsr+r,
Vi,ry.x-rit: G C,u ea,
9062 Chriotiw brive
.'.
22022 Hula Circft.
}�1ttt�.rM3tcxa l�►...ach,C,.31ii
t,�u,tir,cJtc'n� l�y.l%:'tt, C:z,lif
9x6�l6
52646
'.l ei--�41#3.--2h
Crztur j� C'c,iir,ty FZ:-cd Coritic.l.
C!u IsLi.ne Drive
U.(;. !x)x 1078
" ij�nting ;l '.[i;: h, ca 1 i f
�
::i 1:'�:.� .tt~f'I, ;':e � •i � ''':'I1S �
::`:;.... •' •. .....• o`r'„'fir w..!.wr.. �... ,.,..,. w.+..»['i +... .}w. .. rseyy. -._..
' t
` r
1
»
.....................
.�...................,
»