Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPub Hear - Appeal of PC Denial CUP 92-44/CE 92-47/ND 92-40 REQ URT FOR- CITY. COUNRL ACTION Date February 7, 1994 Submitted to: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members DE/ii��D Submitted by: Michael T. Uberuaga, City Administrattoo� • Prepared by: Howard Zelefsky, Planning Director aye APPEAL TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL Subject: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-44, CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 92-47,AND NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 92-40 Consistent with Council Policy? [ ] Yes [ ] New Policy or Exception Statement of Issue, Recommendation,Analysis, Funding Source,Alternative Actions,Atta ts: Qat� STATEMENT OF ISSUE: Transmitted for your consideration is an appeal of the Planning Commission's denial of Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44, Conditional Exception No. 92-47, and Negative Declaration No. 92-40 (Attachment No. 1), filed by Dan Brimlow, (applicant), and Ken Brimlow. They requested to "approve in concept" a 310 foot tall communications tower which exceeds the maximum height requirement of 40 feet in an M2 district. The subject property is located at 8541 Edison Avenue, a private street behind the Edison plant, east of Newland Street and north of Pacific Coast Highway. Since the project is located in a non-certified area of the Coastal Zone, it is subject to final approval by the California Coastal Commission. RECOMMENDATIONS: Planning Commission Recommendation: Motion to: "Uphold the Planning Commission's denial of Negative Declaration No. 92-40, Conditional Use Permit No.92-44, and Conditional Exception No. 92-47 with findings (Attachment No. 2)." Planning_Commission Action on December 7, 1993: ON MOTION BY INGLEE AND SECOND BY NEWMAN, THE PLANNING COMMISSION DENIED NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 92-40 BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: INGLEE,NEWMAN, BIDDLE, GORMAN, NOES: COOK, DETLOFF, ABSENT: RICHARDSON ABSTAIN: NONE Plo 5/85 MOTION PASSED ON MOTION BY INGLEE AND SECOND BY NEWMAN, THE PLANNING COMMISSION DENIED CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-44 AND CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 92-47 WITH FINDINGS BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: INGLEE,NEWMAN, BIDDLE, GORMAN, DETLOFF, COOK NOES: NONE ABSENT: RICHARDSON ABSTAIN: NONE MOTION PASSED Staff Recommendation: Motion to: "Approve Negative Declaration No. 92-40, Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44 and Conditional Exception No. 92-47 for a reduced height of 212 feet high tower with findings and conditions of approval (Attachment No. 3)." ANALYSIS: Project Description The applicant has disassembled and relocated to Huntington Beach a 310 foot high communications tower that was located in Santa Ana adjacent to the Santa Ana(I-5) Freeway for 35 years. When the freeway expansion required the removal of the tower, the applicant acquired it. The tower has been dismantled and is stored on the site of an existing storage yard. The applicant proposes to reconstruct the tower and make it available for public and private communication purposes. Presently,the site contains a caretaker's mobilehome, office building,miscellaneous storage items and debris, and both operable and inoperable vehicles. The site lacks any landscaping, and resident or customer parking is unavailable. Large concrete slabs remain on the site as remnants from a previous animal shelter use. The storage items will be removed to allow sufficient space for the tower,two equipment trailers, five on-site parking spaces, landscaping, and operable vehicles. The communications tower will be painted a galvanized gray, and will be compatible with the tower color used for the 220KV electrical towers in close proximity to the site. The applicant has received Federal Aviation Administration(FAA) conditional approval RCA 2/7/94 2 rcatowr • • for construction of the tower which is required due to its height. In accordance with FAA requirements, strobe lights will be installed for day use and running lights for night use. Construction of the tower must comply with the Uniform Building Code; there are no guy wires proposed. Because the site is located in a floodplain, additional engineering studies are necessary to ensure that the tower will not incur or cause damage to other properties in the event of a flood. Construction of the tower will accommodate multiple frequency users such as police, Coast Guard, Harbor Patrol, fin radio, and cellular phone. Multiple use of the tower will reduce the number of individual facilities. There are a variety of types of antennas that may be placed on the tower at different height locations. Each user would have its own operating system and could use several systems, multiple frequencies, and would need two antennas - receiver and transmitter. Typical antennas include whip, yagi, directional panel, corner reflector, parabolic, UHF and VHF. As technology improves or changes, the variety, size and shape of antennas may change to a smaller type and ability to combine users into one antenna. A condition is included that requires Planning Division review and approval of the size, location, and color of all antennas and issuance of a building permit prior to installation of each antenna. Public Hearing At the Planning Commission public hearing five persons spoke regarding the project. Two of the speakers read from letters addressed to the Planning Commission; these letters are included (Attachment No. 7). The concerns raised at the public hearing included visual intrusion, structural stability of the tower, possible resonance patterns, radiation potential, sufficient public notice, and liability. The applicant's consultant informed the Planning Commission that a new tower could be built if the existing tower proved to be structurally unsound. He also indicated that conditions of approval could be imposed on the project to limit the size of dish antennas, encourage lattice type antennas whenever possible, and require radiation review for potential users that might emit radiation. Staff Recommendation: Based upon the comments by citizens and the Planning Commission, staff is recommending approval of the communication tower but limiting its height to 212 feet which is compatible with the Edison Plant smoke stack. In addition, it will reduce the usable area for the existing storage business, provide a landscaped street scene, and on- site parking will be included on the site. Construction of the tower on this site will be compatible with the 212 foot high smoke stacks of the Edison Generating Station and 150 foot high 220 kv towers in the vicinity. A condition is included that requires Community Development Department to review and approve the size, location, and color of all antennas prior to issuance of a building permit for each antenna. RCA 2/7/94 3 rcatowr FUNDING SOURCE: Not applicable ALTERNATIVE ACTION: Motion to: "Overturn the Planning Commission's denial and grant the applicant's request with findings and conditions as contained in Section 10.0 of the Planning Commission's Staff Report(Attachment No. 6)." ATTACHMENTS: 1. Letter of Appeal 2. Findings for Denial (Planning Commission Action) 3. Findings and Conditions of Approval (Staff Recommendation) 4. Negative Declaration No. 92-40 5. Site Plan and Elevations received December 7, 1993 6. Planning Commission Staff Report dated December 7, 1993 7. Letters received at the Planning Commission meeting RCA 2/7/94 4 rcatowr CORRECTED Lr..ETTER CITY OF HUNTINGT`7N BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK CONNIE BROCKWAY CITY CLERK March 14, 1994 Ken Brimlow 652 E. Culver Avenue Orange, CA 92666 Gentlemen: The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at its regular meeting held Monday, February 7, 1994, denied your appeal to the Planning Commission's denial of Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44, Conditional Exception No. 92-47, and Negative Declaration No. 92-40. This is a final decision. You are hereby notified that pursuant to,provisions of Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedures of the State of California you have ninety days from February 16, 1994, to apply to the courts for judicial review. The minutes will be mailed to you at a later date. If you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact this office at 536-5227. Sincerely yours, ,� WJ. Connie Brockway, CMC City Clerk CB:cc i Enclosure CC: City Administrator City Attorney Melanie Fallon, Community Development Director 1051K (Telephone:714-536-5227) § 1094.5 SPF.CIAI, PROCEEDINGS Part 3 Note 376 n.nttled fnr iw•w• Irial de Onto. 1'rrxen•l �. tniur,l 4-om ;—inn,•r hnd iw juri,.,lirlinu valiforuln los. Ai.in•nls lhl. nn,l ,161 uui d,Irrmiur owritm. \\'eRtrn+Air tua,ti) 1_'7 vol.npir. 5it►, '97 C.A.31l 29. I.loex Inv. v. Soble.%k( (11181) 721 Cnl.ltplr. 'lrlel t•ourt'K jnd:;n+et,t d­n%int; writ of 7IA. I II I ('.:\:*,1 3119. n,nndnte to compel dirrrtor of agrivulturo Iriivt that letter dixchargiiig mcnior tyli- in Met nxi+le l+lx derision rrvnkiog prtlsinu• 61 eh•rk in offire of vomit+ clerk minted rr'r lit-rime as nircraft ilih,t ill hrixinrxx ,.1 tint xlr,• w:+x pull)• of nti-ondurt in re. prat ronlrol wnx n•verxed nod mite re moviolt puhlie rr,•nnix from thn files and ninndnl to Irial .,nirt with dirrrtinum to unitilating and xern•ims: them on vnrloux reomod ruse to dirvrtur fur purpoxr of dutem, wheren+t ill livarinF before county 11 rowonx(drrlug the peitully lireviotisly im. eh-it servive cmutnixshm rvidrnee wnR ill. Iwsed, where it was found tint some of traduced only nit to w•hnt took place on the charges ugninxt petitioner wern not nine of the Inter, did imt require the diR- solgtorled by evidence. Wingfield V. trim rune, of al+pr.,t) on n1.1,rn1 from judg. Director of Agriculture (11172) 103 Col. inent ow•ardiul; senior tyl,i.t clerk writ of Itptr.019,20 C.A.3d 2011. manditte. after reveritintt il:o jtidgincut of l'roccedit,g for review of denial b} ,out- the muperior .•nurt, to remand the matter mtssloner of or review or n( permit to to the r,nnn+ixxiun for r.—nosideration, r. rhnnxe voting rights of xhnrrholderx romid g rr n•ns n xiOilnrity u( fact� :ill would he rrntnndrd to superior court for of ill(- l; rrinovnl of . I Torments on oil on- deterinhoilion whether there w•nit auhmt:lu= Iv ill(- dntem. 1'rnit v. l.nx .\u�elrx ) 238 tial evidence to support u.,minividuiter'a tg Civil �ervicr; l?omtnidsluu (19;,1) 2:U3 fiudingst, where court improperly deter- I':d'3. 1(15C.ASr1111. 1094.6. Judicial review; decisions of local Agencies; petition; filing; time; record;,decision and j arty defined; or- dinance or resolution (a) Judicial review of any decision of a local agency, other than school district, as the term local agency is defined in Section 54951 of the Government Code, or of any commission, board, officer or agent _the-roof, may be had pursuant to Section 1094.,5 of this code only if ;. =the petition for writ:of mandate pursuant to such section is filed IeAthin the time limits specified in this section. (b) Any such petition shall be filed not later than the 90th day following the date on which the decision becomes final. If there is no provision for reconsideration of the decision in any applicable provi- sion of any statute, charter, or rule, for the purposes of this section, the decisI�n is final on the date it is made. If there is such provision for reconsideration, the decision is final for the purposes of this sec- tion upon the expiration of the period during which such reconsidera- tion can be sought; provided, that if reconsideration is sought pursu- alit to any such provision the decision is final for the purposes of this ection on the date that reconsideration is rejected. (c) The complete rorord or the pro(•cedings shall lx• prepnred by Ille 1(x.:tl ; "vilc•y or it, vnnunis,:inn, h(r.trd, officer, (u• siginit which made the decision and shrill bo dolivcred to the petitioncr within 90 (lays ;iftcr he has filed a written rcOucst therefor. The Kies) agency may recover from the petitioner its actual costs for transcribing or otherwise preparing the record. Such record shall include the tran- Script of the proceedings, all pleadings, all notices and t::'ders, any proposed decision by a hearing officer, the filial decision, all admitted 674 A NOTICE OF PUBLIC I APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S CONDITIONAL DENIAL-OF CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-44,CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 92-47, NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 92-40 (Proposed Communications Tower) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chambers at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach,California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE/TIME: Monday,February 7, 1994, 7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Appeal of Planning Commission's Denial of Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44/ Conditional Exception No. 92-47/Negative Declaration No. 92-40 APPLICANT: Dan Brimlow tia APPELLANT: Dan Brimlow and Ken Brimlow LOCATION: 8541 Edison Avenue ZONE: M2-0-FP2(Heavy Industrial Combined with Oil with Floodplain Overlay) REQUEST: To "approve in concept" a 310 foot tall communications tower which exceeds the maximum height requirement of 40 feet in an M2 district. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Environmental Assessment No. 92-40 will also be considere_d by Council. COASTAL STATUS: This project is in a non-certified area of the Coastal Zone and must be ultimately reviewed and approved by the California Coastal Commission. ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Community Development Department, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach,California 92648, for inspection by the public. A copy of the staff report will be available to interested parties in the City Clerk's office after February 4, 1994. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit to the City Clerk,written evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If you challenge the City Council's action in court,you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice,or in written correspondence delivered to the City at,or prior to,the public hearing. If there are any further questions please call Susan Pierce,Associate Planner,at 536-5271. Connie Brockway City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach,CA 92648 (714)536-5227 (splp165) Southern California Edison Company 7333 BOLSA AVENUE WESTMINSTER,CALIFORNIA 92683 S JERRY J.OOMINGUEZ [Tn '�jELERHONE MANAGER,HUNT]NGTON BEACH (744)895-0271 X January . 31, 1994 N, m Connie Brockway r City Clerk ` City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main St. Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Dear Ms. Brockway: Re: Appeal .of Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44/Conditional Exception No. 92-47 - Dan Brimlow, 8541 Edison Ave. In regards to the above referenced matter;`- the followinginformation is submitted: 1 . It is requested" that 'as a condition of any approval, the prop- erty owner be required to provide insurance in the amount of $6 million naming Southern California Edison as additional in- sured; also, to advise us on any renewal or cancellation of said policy. This is requested given a .scenario were the tower to fall down in a southerly direction. A fuel oil tank is located ap- proximately 100 feet south of Mr. Brimlow's property. The tank at full capacity holds 200,000 Bls. of low sulphur petro- leum with a value of about $3.4 million. The tank itself plus any resultant cleanup is estimated at about $2.5 million. In addition, there could also be a risk of fire since the FAA would require electrical power for safety lighting. 2. Mr. Brimlow has indicated the transmission signals would be in the less than 1000 watt range. However, it has been my expe- rience that even this "low" frequency operation would require .that each individual frequency be checked and "lined out" if currently in existing''use by 'Edisori or other' local" users of com- munication frequencies. 0 r. 3. Although the structure should be clear_ of our 220,000 volt ;. �.. transmission facilities to the east, it could impact any number of 12,000 volt distribution lines should the tower come down. z ; Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, erry Dominguez cc: Michael Dolder l�:ui,:fi ��': i�:.tulltrtrlj' - iii i:d3'�. Tlnu•scray. )erect )er ti. S�3 t 1:1,1 : :,�, OF --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- PLA111 CAM �- ��y �v� Telecommunications Planing & Site Acquisition Services FSoD December 16, 1993 93-04 City Clerk G7a J. rn CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 Main Street P.O. Box190 Huntington Beach, Ca. 92648 = ^' -A-4 3m Re: Appeal of Planning Commission Action C.U.P. #92-44, Variance #92-47, Neg. ' Dec. #92-40 ; 71 On behalf of our client.. Daniel Brinllow: we hereby appeal the decision e)f the P411111ing Commission on December 7. 1993. denying Conditional Use Permit. No. 92-44. Conditional Exceptlon 92-47. and Negative Declaration 92-40. In response to the Findings for Denial we are submitting the following responses: • The Southern California Edison power generating facility and related transmission lines are considered major utilities. providing a public benellt.. 'I'll(- telecommunications industry is rapidly transforming the ways in which all facets of lilies operate. The need for paging. two-way radio. point to point. microwave links. Personal C•;o11 municallons' Systems and Public. Safety Emergency Radio- will continue to Increase ;:througllout the rest of this decade. In several ,jurisdictions in Southern'X.Calilornia. communications . sites and 1flcilitles are considered Minor utilities which promote public health. saloty and welfare. For this reason It .is felt that the proposed use would be consistent with that of other utilities in the Immedialc�vir.inity. • Tl1e Planning Commission seemed to Ignore the;recommendations offered by the County of Orange Director of Information`Systems' which concluded that there was a need for several new communications sites in Orange County and one specifically in Huntington- Beach. . The fact that the Planning Commission could make a landing that suflaclent co11u11unlc•alions opportunities exist: in Iluntington Beach and in other Areas of Orange County without any documentation is unfalr- and irresponsible. It is expected that this facility will become an ."Important addition to the Countys telecommunications bacicbone system for both private and public • The proposed tower structure will create a visual impact. �I-Iowever. both Staff and the Erivironnlental Board recognized .that the site was directly adjacent to a major visual Impact source and could not significantly degrade the visual aesthetics of'.the surrounding area. An updated visual analysis will be prepared for Stal - review prior to the Council Appeal to illustrate the filet this tower is compatible in size. bulls and scale with other utility sil-tu:-tures In the general vicinity. The visual Impact created by the SCE, Dower generation facility and associated high voltage electrical transmission lines will allow the proposed project to blend with these structures. , 1991 Village Park Way - Encinitas. California 92024 - -(619) 634-2170 . i . 4 Oily Clerk - C ItV O( I11.Intington Beach ll�igo 2 of 2 • The proposed c•onlnulnica1loI1S equipment and antennas are regula(ed by the F.C.C. lend IIIt1St. strictly comply wall its regulil(ions for interference. While interlOrence is,•possible. it is highly unlikely any would occur �It this loc allon. However. if interference does occur. then steps would be 1�11ken ro rcinedy the problem inlnledb-mely at the project sponsors expense. • it woes suf;f?ested Mil( rindlo frequency (RF) rad I1.1011 IS c1 po(VIIHill site impm.l. to neighboring properties. Prior to the Planning; Co1mllission hearing the applicant surrll litte-d all F.C.C. nuI'morandunl spec•flying ci;r(,Iin F.C.C. rc,g;ulatc•d services which are excluded ,from RF evaluation. !This Ill('lnorandtlm 5tate'5 that "... there is no evidence*.of excessive RF ra( jinon exposure, (.luring routine and normal operation of land-mobile and fixed c0I1I11I1.InicatiOII8 services. including cellular radio and nitcrowave point to point radio...... The types of radio seryie"' (o 'be ;;Lconinio laced i1( this hic�ility will all be exenlpl from RF evaluation s _ • Issues were raised as to the structural integrity`anti fitness of the proposed lower structure due to age and possible lac•lt of Ilia inIenanc.•e. 11 was enwhatically explained to the Planning Co1111i1iSSIo11 that this tower would mcem, thorough review and inspection .by !e Ilc•ensecl lower siruClur�-il eng IlICCr prior to building I>c•rmit submittal. Also: the building department will require wiled loading analysis and tower loot:lng designs to be tort ilie-d as well. 11' the existing tower is not structurally sound. then a new tower Will be Substituted in its place. It is felt_ -hat enough safeguards exist so as to CIISure that the general public is adequately protected. Prior to the City Council Appeal hearing. the. project sponsor has Indicated that he would like the opportunity to discuss 'tile proposed project in greater . detail with those parties who expressed their _concerns at. the Planning Commission hearing and also to other surrounding property owners. It is sincerely hoped that their concerns and suggestions can be somehow Incorporated into all ultimately thoughtful project design. PlanCom 67 CC: Community Development via Fax 714.374. 1540 County of Orange. General Services Agency. Info. Systems Client. 14A1 VillanP Park Wav - Fni-initac ( alifnrnia g7f17d - 1A14) R:t4-717(I OPHRFFEmLllm�iss iATES- conlmumcst consultants " RECEIVED MADE A PART OAHE RECORD AT MEETING ITEM NO. 7 February 4, 1994 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK CONNIE BROCKWAY Via Fax (909) 928-0232 Mr. Daniel Brimlow 31188 Water Avenue Nuevo, CA 92567 RE: Huntington Beach, CA, Tower Prospect Dear Daniel: Shaffer & Associates has conducted a preliminary market survey and site evaluation. Our findings are as follows: The mountain sites to the north and west are far enough away to be considered complementary to your proposed tower location. Existing communications facilities to the south and east (Newport Beach, San Clemente) are either at capacity or not available for rental. This leaves the north and east as your only area of competition. Although Signal Hill is an established communication facility with fine area coverage, it has a reputation within the industry for having RF intermodulation problems (interference) which, in some cases, diminishes signal coverage. Your Huntington Beach tower would fill-in as well as enhance area coverage. In discussion with national and regional clients based in southern California, we have found two companies that would utilize your tower upon completion of its construction. Four other companies that are interested in your site and will be expanding their coverage within 12 to 18 months. Several other companies confirm the desirable concept of your proposed tower location, but have no expansion requirements in the immediate future. 3060 P081 Oak Boul0vard Sulle 1700 Houston, Texas 77056.6836 (713) 621-4490 Fax: (7U) 021-5751 0. C. F. C. R. E A S E M E N T H U N T I N G. T O N B E A C H CHANNEL IOO'-O" ------- t I LD t t i ISBX6' t � I t t SLAB 40' X 58' t , VEHICLE CARETAKER I _. _ STORAGE TRAILER, t i Ii SLAB 38' X 85' , t VEHICLE STORAGE t FUTURE ANIMAL KENNELS i I I ENTIRE AREA I IS PAVED WITH ASPHALT FOR VEHICLE STORAGE PROPOSED RADIO PAR A EQUIPMENT TRAILER IAPPROX. 340 S.F.) Z I ------------------------------- GAS MAIN FUTURE RADIO EOUIPMENT TRAILER 20' ENTRANCE GATE 31 TOW STRUCTURE n+y 12" STEP OFF AREA GENERATOR l0'-0" 1� 36" BOX TREES WATER Mn' POWER POLE 30'-0" EXISTING 30' EASEMENT FOR INGRESS AND EGRESS FEB 04 194 16:19 SHAFFER ASSOCIATES 128 P02 Mr. Daniel Brimlow February 4, 1994 } Page 2 Finally, while a 210' tower is favorable and sellable, a 300' structure would reduce shadowing caused by the higher elevations around Newport Beach and allow maximization of the proposed location. The preliminary research that we have conducted indicates that this proposed site would be a profitable business venture. Please call with comments or questions. Regards, Royce C. Robbins Site Management RCR/ks +�?=::el,r. , c'S. r"�'"i�{.k�a �`N f� "LY.� 't'r„LtS�t£N'5�. %f�'fi"K--?:f,:t_.•a� ..5 rz.*- ;e'i. _•�.,... ?Y,.,•-- t rinZ. �. �5 =� .•' , f1B—OT—S19nLi anduvMea AI-aaa � y �,[ 'Fd 5, :} +'1. .y �'i��r .'l�'' �. :.`•K;i': .,:fa :1'� F _ tr < Q y ` . �_,_ .,.. \., .,. ... +y�,a.�`x. .l. , '. •Z,_;; .>3 9.' ) t5� .�•�ai' ? � .y 3':: `.i-�'3'" r�. -Ti�•,&�45._ .✓::^ "iL P..., l'� j. L'.L�.1„ 4.', ... +5... �rf •r y ,t' 1"i ��E.J=' fF�' ..sPx''}� ,y7 ,(±/�y�+ - ::*;,.r•*6 ,<..�.,,^a. ., t. ,., 1. % 4:• r , s �'�r���7 I .M ,,��:+f Ti, �'7� __��yy�55__ a�'r'.:�� �b��z t �.• .aG'•i�^d�Ca!'_.;.v4:J,"_,:.��.2�:^ _c4�" "<f�•+Se.�s Lf �• r.Y �fr'w"u•a :"Y'� iti -;' .. n{S'. •' ` a. `V �.'*aJan:__ "x •).. ...•. .. .. �. '. ..1'.4 .. ., C c• .lt .� ,. .s,. .C..l l j ..1•, 3=�ii: r,�..Y« �)'f".'S..�a — � ,�v<•. . -_.. . � � �7♦. .�_ , . ;t :.k .., r� . �•,-/ / •:,.. �r, .�`�•� Line,of Sight Areas /. a� X^:.,p.�y, ..i --�.•c ..t.. i`t,' ..� ib�r.�v. �'K''". y�:'s„�.:f.'. $M \' �- 's' sf •4 i ...;: ,�. ..t. e-t w'b' .K.`f.�."•ire• •9 >" :t i Shadowed Areas 1.! r.11. .Lake.Arrowho,d , * + + ;�'1 . , . `1 I //! craatUna Ant Elv Ant. krts a -MonFr ANSL ERPd Ant. Orient Latitude Canso. t=14Mtridgr'1. 1 1 1 1 1 ' / / /! // / // / Ing ins Site (feet) (010 Type (degs) LDngitudc d Doke \ 1 / t Altseens: i 205.0 .00 OfNOI N 33 38 ' \s { Hidden . , #1 � M 117 5E Agoura Hills \ don / )hmcoy Ystlake Village \ ♦ \ \ \ �� t earn din, ♦♦ \\ ♦ Angola* \�- 80 HI land dlanlintone \\ Linda \ ! Yucaipa % ce lyr \ \ Cs11 co River, , + a (test Whittle / 11Whitt ' Cher L, Habr fl ` ♦ \ d SsnttloHeh f s /// / / // / Valley au, \ Norw,lk Le reds flower F pert P1 Lakewood L, ParkCar / \Orranc t firs an / e ///""/�li Lakeview we Cvnrf , Vil r / / ` Sign Hill AlY �t a �\ n / //i avo tstss s ord F�QE► tf�ttT�#9il des 9642 asseh Tus + j� tan Ea + + tau er .. / Bents 4untln i Fountain Val y_ �� ��� a Winchester ingtan Beach Ala Him _ ' El Toro � _ — = T a^Sin t, a Hot sprin zz Rainbow i. • th 11. + ' . .� Hidden Wando7sllsyl OF F Vlate Son Narcaa Escondido Carlsbad.Lake San Warm ... ice'•' .' ., l - . on .. \\ ;\ \ i `.` + \ \ �er►t•-Monfr 1I I 1 1 I l l l / / / // /� Qestrin• May Q�d Mt OP t. �+ \ \ \• '. \ \ \ \ Canada Fltan4tii I 1 7 1 , / // Orient ut�tL \.\ \, \ \ , / ! ! / inp tnae Site (feet) (dN Type We* l °�" \ ank 1` ` ` \ Alteden. 1 1 / / f/ . ! 1 305.0 .00 amm M 3 atoms' t ! �' i. /� M 117 Apoure \ \\\\.�.,., \. \ \.• ,a \ �( � j(f I( � f 1 , 1 Meetlek• pa \ \ . \ \ \ tr / // Bern ino '' '\ \ \ .•\ '. 1 tom• I \'.,\'\\, ♦\ \ \� Sen I� mean ! �/ q OOrype. /; /. // Hi hlond doe Mpolea\, \ 1`1' ,' South Pa•sds ggg•��n,, nnnt 1 / / i / ; / !alto' \ si ly oQ \ ., \` \'. San Tor4i1fK ] 0 tlry /. /r r r �, ;'; /FdnlinA Isar • � � \ ♦ \ \. \.� \\••�\`\ �\``� loottipt'�eltoni dl"wton• 41Iu ! :�/�j'/ �/ ���'/ -Loan Lintla a\ / / / ' Yucaipa /Tarr►ve konics leer Cit]1 \�\1 \ POW 1,4 1 t1i Or VP C� berC' eo lvera A� /. ,F,�' ��p jam/ Ce 1 • at Whittier- !/ // _,CA/�i y / e Char de J,)Mitt \ \ \ •�. OX i1•a �aR� •\\ Sou \ \ \ I \ c.` •y Santsoeeh r ! i i ' / r" //! ' �`' out J net Vrygtie` �arood ( E t� ea /// ! ! !� � ,' .}le,�[��. 11aF� rill•y La IArads \ \�., � t ox•r �� \ • \ \`\ F Slart Plad r //. ��/ �! .f�Dsi tl•n✓ a;� J�/� Torrence) rson� an Ba no /i�/ /� � i� Lakeview Mead I Cypress Vili/ \� �\ Ha11 eiaiaiaorla� ton sn ;/ii��i" / �i � /�/ ��^!' r Y�Kyavo n don soul Beach tat TUB n F�'l!'- , - . +M notcr + i .% _ �_ mlan Bents tin /'' ' Hemet ES =� Fo taro Val y == "� }3_ y Winchester -- —+ — '�--- El Tare�� -----•-„.....---- -.•_—__.__�_---= Co a Mesa = - _ ___ e-elstno TOi►2� mho esnte-IMrprlt — _ ri e•iBh _ Duc r — t to Hot Sprin mecule f j i` r '1 �/ !// \\ \\ \.� \ '�\.�\ �Bahl�a • to Ball ; `,\\; `\ uth Hidden IleadO -� �• i I(�r ll� a�I ��� 11 i��.i�� t� ` \\\ '\\• \. •\ \, \''\ ! 'Valley i 'r'l l J ,' � .,his l! l ' �f 11 � f� 11 � � �i! ,` '\' ,`1 \\\ `\•,� \ \ \ \�\\` \ �/ J' r •/r/,. ;; (�!, 1 ,'��� 1>, ,,'`\11\,,\ \'\\ \ \ \ \` .\ \\\••\ \\\\\\ \ �� \ Vista fr / ' r r r 1•I 1 j! i + � I I1, '1 tt ,�� ' 1'�'� \•`\�\�.\\\\ \`,\\\ \\\•\\\\\`\\ \\\\\ ,` \'\ r" , ",i r r 'r• , ( it I , 'a , .41 t 11,�,•`•,` `,'' 1 ,\\ ��\`,\\ \,.\\�\\\� \� `\ \\\`�\ ``.\\ San Marcos E•COndidO 1 \ \ Lake Ban Marcos cinites RECEIVED OTY CLERK ''`T Y i F 1710 Pine Street - - Huntington Beach , -CA 92648 EEC February 7 , 1994 Mayor and City Council City of Huntington Beach 7. - 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach , CA 92648 Re: Public Hearing Item D-4 - Dear Mayor Moulton-Patterson and Members of the Council : As a private citizen and resident of this community , I strongly urge you to uphold the Planning Commission 's denial of this item . I believe that this type of structure would be a step backwards for this City . I also think that the public has not been made fully aware of what visual impact the structure will have--it will be seen from practically everywhere within the City limits! Even though the staff is recommending--a shorter tower , -our community is the wrong place for such an object . Thank you . Sincerely , Bob Biddle BB: jj ILv. , ^ :r 7 9a4 • 02/07/94 16:02 2t 3104044603 INCO COMM. BROK. 01 ECt tIttw Romano CtCITY LER to 814 i 4 astilitln Avenue 14UWTtHerDs jk Atitj,. 1-1 untinglon Leach, Califomia 92646-6I� B fi (714) 969-7260 February 7, 1994 M, Connie Brat: ,,N�aE City Clerk City of Huntington Bead: Huntington Beach, Calif-ornia 92648 Sent by Facsimile Re.: Conditiomil Use Permit 92-44 (Ptoposed communication iGm,-) Dear Ms. Fir(,,1 I reel Qom..clled to express my dissatisfaction with the plan to install a 310 foot tall communication tower near Newland and the Pacific Coast Highway. Our beautiful coastline is already aesthetically diminished by the Edison Generating Plant. The proposed communication tower would not only stand nearly 100 feet taller than the Edison Plant, it would make the plant look uglier than it already is. As a resident who would have to look at the proposed tower on a daily basis I urge the Planning Comnli"sion and City CoujitJl to reject this application. Sincerely, �A Bruce Romano 1 • y. ` ' o;'n� cat FEBRUARY 7, 1994 OPINION APPEAL TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DENIAL OF CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 92-44, CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION 92-47, AND NEGATIVE DECLARATION 92-40 ORANGE COUNTY HUMANE SOCIETY 21632 NEWLAND STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92646 (714) 536-8480 0 Dear Members of the Orange County Planning Commission: 1. The Orange County Humane Society continue in our opposition to the use,of property adjacent to ours for the construction of a 212' tower for the following reasons: a. safety. -tower structural integrity. -radiation. b. visual intrusion. c. lack of need. Each topic will be discussed in turn. A. Safety The concerns about the age, maintenance, and fitness for intended use of the proposed tower remain unanswered. The current appeal promises a thorough engineering evaluation. Approval of the project must include the following engineering caveats: -evidence that the tower is'suiftbl®_fbr�&.Ourpas® other than that for which it was designed. -evaluation not only the design, but liks 0 A ® :the eatos ung s4r :�4 rat - TIZ6 ®re to assess the effects of fatigue, corrosion, dismantling and lack of maintenance. -evaluation of the integrity of the only P�o �`a00Y These questions are all the more pressing in light of the uncertainty of the potential for liquefaction and the utter certainty of continued seismic activity. The present proposal offers no evidence of the lack of a radiation hazard. PLANCOM vaguely quotes an FCC report which may or may not apply. Additional) the S 9 Y q P Y YY. `b a_-V ©I,-c*m.bIh-6d- �d®0al o 44��are not addressed. As we at the Orange County Humane Society would be forced by proximity to the transmitters, we feel the commission should demand a detailed electromagnetic radiation evaluation that considers the well known effects of- ffi�10�4�oo_�a A _I - ' • B. Visual Intrusion The Orange County Humane Society maintains that a 212' tower in the proposed location will create significant visual impact on the surrounding community, thereby denying substantial property enjoyment. About antennas: -Height improves coverage by increasing "line of sight." -multiple frequencies. -consolidation. -Antennas will be placed as high as possible. -High antenna placement will-- --increase visual impact. --decrease useful load of tower. --minimize functionality --existing structures. The project as currently proposed takes lff �j�n the existence of the,Edison power plant smoke stacks as mitigating the visual impact of the tower. The revised project suggests The tower will be galvanized fir—cul jd�lioQ�� off®vti�®i�_��m� 4t�s olr �® and �hftl �t���®� �0_3 r. sc-®m �=� �� otiii4i®� Oi�entind. As such the tower will be plainly visible during the day for at beacons and white strobe lights mandated by F ditral;=i a t -ftddOffitoons will make this structure a dominant feature of the landscape for many miles, particularly at night. The project as presently proposed does not provide for adequate notification of area residents. Before allowing the project to go forward, the planning commission should require notification of residents within a wo mile radius. C. Public Benefit. Police, Fire- benefits are obvious. Harbor Patrol - better on a mountain? Commercial venture- -GTE, Page Net, Mobil Comm, Pactel -LA Cellular, Pactel --complete coverage Property Rights -to the extent that they interfere or threaten to interfere with the rights of others. -As the tower shrinks, so does the potential for public benefit. --threat outweighs benefit. Huntington Beach Planning Commission r��F3 P.O. BOX 190 CALIFORNIA 92648 December 10 , 1993 Dan Brimlow 31188 Water Avenue Nuevo, CA 92567 SUBJECT: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-44/CONDITIO AL EXCEPTION (V .RI-.NCE) NO. 92-47/NEG-.TIV E DECL-_RLTION NO. 92-40 REQUEST: To " approve in concept" a 310 foot tall communications tower which exceeds the maximum height requirement of 40 feet . . LOCATION: 8541 Edison Avenue DATE OF ACTION: December 7, 1993 FINDINGS FOR DENIAL - CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION (VARIANCE) NO. 92-47 : 1 . Since the subject property can be fully developed with other industrial uses, such a conditional exception for a communication tower is not necessary for the preservation and enjoyment of substantial property rights . 2 . Granting of Conditional Exception (Variance) No. 92-47 for a 310 foot high communication tower would constitute a special privilege inconsistent with limitations upon properties- in the vicinity. The subject property was legally subdivided and developed in a manner consistent with applicable zoning laws . 3 . Exceptional circumstances do not apply that deprive the subject property of privileges enjoyed by other properties in the same zone classifications . FINDINGS FOR DENIAL - CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. . 92-44 : 1 . The proposed 310 foot high commercial tower will not be . compatible with adjacent properties/uses because the tower may create adverse visual impacts due to the substantial height increase. Other structures in the vicinity do not .exceed 212 . feet in height . �.a�ew z A (7469d-12) Conditional Use Permit No . 92-44/ Conditional Exception (Variance) No . 92-47/ Negative Declaration No . 92-40 Page Two 2 . The establishment , maintenance and operation of the communications tower will be detrimental to the general welfare of persons working or residing in the vicinity and detrimental to the value of the property and improvements in the neighborhood because : a . The antennas have the potential of emitting radiation onto surrounding proerties and onto persons and animals living or working in the vicinity of the proposed tower . b. Operation of the tower may create electrical disturbances to businesses and residents in the vicinity of the proposed tower . c. Testimony at the public hearing revealed that the structural stability of the 65 year old 'tower has been weakened by the two (2) previous dismantlincs and reconnections, corrosion, and lack of maintenance or safety inspections . Therefore, the tower at the proposed location may be unsafe for installation . 3 . There are sufficient communication opportunitites within the City of Huntington Beach and other locations in the county are avaialble for the proposed tower. In addition, construction of the proposed tower and future placement of a variety of antennas will be detrimental to the visual and aesthetic quality to persons utilizing Pacific Coast Highway, a scenic highway, which is within 2, 000 feet of the subject property. 4 . The granting of Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44 for a 310 foot high communications tower will adversely affect the General Plan of the City of Huntington Beach, in particular, the Scenic Highways Element . I hereby certify that Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44 , Conditional Exception (Variance) No. 92-47 and Negative Declaration No . 92-40 was denied by the Planning Commission of the City of Huntington Beach on December 7 , 1993 , upon the foregoing findings . Sincerely, Mike Adams , Secretary Planning Commission by: i Scott Hess Senior Planner (7469d-13) FINDINGS FOR "APPROVAL IN CONCEPT" - CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-44 • 1. The location, site layout, and design of the proposed 212 foot high communications tower properly adapts the proposed structures to streets, driveways, and other adjacent structures and uses in a harmonious manner. 2 . The 212 foot high communication tower will allow consolidation of individual antennas onto one (1) structure on one (1) site. 3 . The access to and parking for the proposed communication tower does not create an undue traffic problem. 4 . The property is zoned M2 (Heavy Industrial) which is appropriate for communication towers . 5. At the time of operation, the proposed 212 foot high communication tower can be provided with infrastructure in a manner that is consistent with the Huntington Beach Coastal Element and Coastal Land Use Plan of the General Plan. 6 . The proposed construction of a 310 foot high communication tower conforms with the public access and public recreation policies of Chapter 3 of the California Coastal Act. SUGGESTED CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL - CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION (VARIANCE) NO. 92-47/CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-44 : 1. The site plan and elevation received and dated December 7, 1993, shall be the "approval in concept" layout with the following modifications : a. The landscaped area along Edison Avenue shall be increased to ten (10) feet in width. b. The tower shall be painted a galvanized gray color. c. A six (6) foot high masonry wall or slated chin link fence shall be constructed along the front of the storage facility and behind the landscaping and parking area. d. The radio equipment trailers shall be placed on permanent foundations . e. Maximum height of the communications tower shall be 212 feet. 2. Prior to submittal for building permits, the applicant/owner shall complete the following: a. A detailed soils analysis shall be prepared by a registered Soils Engineer. This analysis shall include on-site soil sampling and laboratory testing of materials to provide detailed recommendations regarding grading, chemical and fill properties, foundations, retaining walls, streets and utilities. 7530d 2 3 . Prior to issuance of building permits, the applicant/owner shall complete the following: a. Submit a copy of the revised site plan pursuant to Condition No. 1 for review and approval and inclusion in the entitlement file. b. A landscape construction set must be submitted to the Department of Public Works and approved. The Landscape Construction Set shall include a landscape plan prepared and signed by a State Licensed Landscape Architect and shall include all proposed/existing plant materials (location, type, size, quantity) , an irrigation plan, an approved site plan, and a copy of the entitlement conditions of approval. The landscape plans shall be in conformance with Section 9608 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code and the Water Conservation Ordinance. The set must be approved by both the Departments of Public Works and Community Development prior to issuance of building permits. c. Submit a copy of a completed Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) elevation or floodproofing certificate. d. Submit evidence of California Coastal Commission approval. e. All inoperable vehicles and miscellaneous storage shall be removed from the site. 4 . Fire Department requirements are as follows : a. Fire extinguisher shall be installed in the building pursuant to Fire Department requirements per Fire Department Standard 424 . b. A gate locking system shall be approved by the Fire Department per Fire Department Standard 403 . c. Address numbers must be installed against contrasting background per Fire Department Standard 428 . d. Flammable liquids stored on-site must comply with Fire Code Article 79 . 5 . All building spoils, such as unusable lumber, wire, pipe, and other surplus or unusable material, shall be disposed of at and off-site facility equipped to handle them. 6 . Prior to final building permit approval, the following shall be completed: a. All improvements (including landscaping) to the property shall be completed in accordance with the approved plans and conditions of approval specified herein. 7530d 3 b. Compliance with all conditions of approval specified herein and any California Coastal Commission conditions of approval . 7. Prior to installation of any antenna on the tower, the Community Development Department shall review and approve the size, location and color of the antenna and a building permit shall be issued. 8 . Any structures proposed for construction in the future and not shown on the conceptually approved site plan shall require Planning Commission approval. 9 . Vehicle storage shall be limited to those areas shown on the conceptually approved site plan. 10 . This conditional use permit shall not become effective for any purpose until an "Acceptance of Conditions" form has been properly executed by the applicant and an authorized representative of the owner of the property and returned to the Planning Division. CODE REQUIREMENTS: 1. The development shall comply with all applicable provisions of the Ordinance Code, Building Division, and Fire Department . 2 . Construction shall be limited to Monday-Saturday 7: 00 AM to 8 : 00 PM. Construction shall be prohibited Sundays and Federal holidays . 3 . Future animal kennels shall be subject to approval of a. conditional use permit. 4 . Customer parking shall not be used for storage. 5 . Conditional Exception (Variance) No. 92-47 and Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44 shall become null and void unless exercised within one (1) year of the date of final approval by the City, or such extension of time as may be granted by the Planning Commission pursuant to a written request submitted to the Planning Division a minimum 30 days prior to the expiration date. 7530d 4 ENVIRONMENTAL CHECKLIST FORM CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH PLANNING DIVISION ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT NO. 92-40 1. Name of Proponent: Dan Brimlow Address: 1119 E. Washington Santa Ana, CA 92701 Phone Number: 714-774-7066 2. Date Checklist Submitted for Review: July 26, 1993 3. Concurrent Entitlement(s): Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44 Conditional Exception No. 92-47 4. Proiect Location: 8541 Edison Avenue 5. Proiect Description: To permit construction of a 310 foot high communications tower on a site used for storage. The property is zoned M2-0—FP2, Heavy Industrial combined with Oil , Floodplain. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS (Explanations of answers are included after each subsection.) Yes Maybe No 1. Earth. Will the proposal result in: a. Unstable earth conditions or changes in geologic substructures? _ _ X Discussion: The proposed project does not involve any activities which will create unstable earth. _ conditions or alter geologic substructures. It is, however, located within an area containing potentially unstable conditions. Although the project is not located within the Alquist-Priolo Special Study Zone; it is, however, within an. area containing the South Branch Fault which. has not been precisely located and determined not to be seismically active. The site ^s also located in an area with a very high threat of liquefaction. In .addition, the site contains a moderate to high percentage of expansive soils. The project will be subject to standard conditions of approval requiring submittal of a soils analysis and implementation of grading, foundation, etc. recommendations contained therein. No significant impacts are anticipated. f Yes Maybe N.4 b. Disruptions, displacements, compaction or overcovering of the soil? X Discussion: Grading and construction activities associated with the project will result in disruption, displacement, compaction and overcovering of the soil . With implementation of standard conditions of approval requiring submittal of soil studies and a drainage plan, no significant impacts are anticipated. C. Change in topography or ground surface relief features? X _ Discussion: The site is relatively flat. Although some grading will occur, the finished grade is expected to be substantially the same as that which currently exists. No significant impact is anticipated. d. The destruction, covering or modification of any unique geologic or physical features? _ _ X Discussion: The project site is currently occupied by miscellaneous storage items. It is primarily flat and does not contain any unique physical features. e. Any increase in wind or water erosion of soils, either on or off the site? X _ Discussion: Minor short term wind and water erosion may occur during grading and construction. The project will be subject to standard conditions of approval requiring submittal of a desilting plan to control erosion and implementation of dust control measures; therefore, no significant impacts are anticipated. f. Changes in deposition or erosion of beach sands, or changes in siltation, deposition or erosion which may modify the channel of a river or stream or the bed of the ocean or any bay, inlet or lake? _ X Discussion: The project is adjacent to an Orange County Flood Control Channel (Huntington Beach Channel) on the north. The ocean is approximately 1/2 mile to the south. The project site does not drain directly into either body of water. g. Exposure of people or property to geologic hazards such as earthquakes, landslides, mudslides, ground failure, or similar hazards? X Discussion: The site is bounded on the north by the Orange County Flood Control Channel (Huntington Beach Channel). In the event of water overflow, the site could incur flood damage. Compliance with floodplain Regulations (Article 940 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code) .should minimize- any potential damage 'to the facility. See la also. The facility is unmanned and is not anticipated to expose people to any geologic hazard. 2. Air. Will the proposal result in: a. Substantial air emissions or deterioration of ambient air quality? _ _ X Discussion: -Short-Tenn: Minor short-term deterioration of local ambient air-quality may occur during site preparation and construction as a result of construction equipment emissions and dust. The impacts that may result are not considered significant and will be further reduced by standard conditions of approval which require dust control measures, restrictions on construction activities during smog alerts, and maintenance of equipment in proper time. ' No significant impact is anticipated. Long-Term: Operation of the communication tower is not anticipated to increase any emissions from the site; only one person is expected to service the facility at a maximum frequency of once per week. Continued operations of the storage facility may reduce the emissions generated by customers because the usable area for storage will be reduced and result in .fewer storage related customers. 3 Environmental Checklist -2- (17960) i • Yes Maybe b. The creation of objectionable odors? _ _ X Discussion: The proposed communication facility will not generate or create any odors. C. Alteration of air movement, moisture, or temperature, or any change in climate, either locally or regionally? _ _ X Discussion:: The proposed project does not propose any land uses which may affect local or regional climate. 3. Water. Will the proposal result in: a. Changes in currents, or the course of direction of water movements, in either marine or fresh waters? X Discussion: The site does not drain directly into any natural body of water. b. Changes in absorption rates, drainage patterns, or the rate and amount of surface runoff? _ _ X Discussion: The site is currently occupied by a storage operation which utilizes 3 concrete slabs. Slight increases in surface runoff may occur due to the overcovering of the site with additional impervious surfaces. Drainage pattern may be altered by the construction of the communication tower. C. Alterations to the course or flow of flood waters? _ _ X Discussion: The site is located in the floodplain. New construction has the potential to alter flood flow both on-site and onto adjacent properties. Development in the floodplain is subject to Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) requirements which have been incorporated into Article 940, Floodplain. See 3b. d. Change in the amount of surface water in any water body? X Discussion: See 3a and 3c. e. Discharge into surface waters, or in any alteration of surface water quality, including but not limited to temperature, dissolved oxygen or turbidity? _ _ X Discussion: See 3b and 3c. f. Alterati-bn of the direction or rate of flow of ground waters? _ X. Discussion: The proposed project does not involve any activities which will impact the direction or flow of groundwaters. g. Change in the quantity of ground waters, either through direct additions or withdrawals, or through interception of an aquifer by cuts or excavations? _ _ X Discussion: See 3f. h. Substantial reduction in the amount of water otherwise available for public water- supplies? _ X Discussion: The project site is used as a storage facility, and has an on-site caretaker. Continued use of the operation has negligible impact on water usage. Adding the unmanned communication tower is not expected to reduce the amount of water supply; however, site improvements as proposed will provide approximately 1 ,000 square feet of landscaping. No significant impact is anticipated. Environmental Checklist -3- (1796D) Y�3 Maybe i. Exposure of people or property to water related hazards such as flooding or. tidal waves? — X Discussion: See 3c. 4. Plant Life. Will the proposal result in: a. Change in the diversity of species, or number of any species of plants (including trees, shrubs, grass, crops, and aquatic plants)? _ X Discussion: The site does not contain any vegetation. No significant impact is anticipated. b. Reduction of the numbers of any mature, unique, rare or endangered species of plants? _ X Discussion: See 4a. C. Introduction of new species of plants into an area, or in a barrier to the normal replenishment of existing species? _ _ X Discussion: .Landscaping associated with the proposed project will introduce new plant species to the site. However, plant materials are expected to be common landscaping species and will be contained within the project boundaries. No significant adverse impact is anticipated. d. Reduction in acreage of an agricultural crop? _ _ X Discussion: The site is not used for agricultural purposes. 5. Animal Life. Will the proposal result in: a. Change in the diversity of species, or numbers of any species of animals (birds, land animal's including reptiles, fish and shellfish, benthic organisms or insects)? X b. Reduction of the numbers of any unique, rare or endangered species of animals? _ + . X c: Introduction of new species of animals into an area, or result in a barrier to the migration or movement of animals? _ _ X d. Deterioration to existing fish or wildlife habitat? _ _ X Discussion (a,b,c,d): The site is presently occupied by a storage business and does not support any rare or unique animal species. No animals are anticipated to be sionificantly impacted by development of the site. 6. Noise. Will the proposal result in: a. Increases in existing noise levels? Discussion: Short-.Term: During the grading and construction phases, noise levels on the site will increase. However, the project is. relatively small in scale and will be subject to standard conditions of approval, restricting hours of construction activities. There are no noise sensitive uses, e.g. schools, churches, hospitals or residential, in the.immediate area. Existing uses .include- those typically found in industrial areas. No significant impacts are anticipated. Checklist -4- (1796D) Yes Mavbe NQ Long—Term: Continued operation of the storage facility and operation of an unmanned communication tower are not expected to increase the existing noise level . A diesel powered back up generator will be provided with an above ground fuel tank on a portion of the paved lot operation of the generator is subject to compliance with the noise ordinance. No significant impacts are anticipated. b. Exposure of people to severe noise levels? _ X Discussion: The project does not contain any provisions that will expose people to severe noise levels. The unmanned facility generates no noise. See 6a also. No significant impacts are anticipated. 7. Light and Glare. Will the proposal produce new light or glare? _ _ X Discussion: The proposed communication building may provide security lighting and the tower will contain the FAA required lighting at the top. Security lighting will be controlled by imposition of standard conditions of approval requiring that lighting be directed away from adjacent properties. There are no light sensitive uses in the vicinity. No significant impacts are anticipated. 8. Land Use. Will the proposal result in a substantial alteration of the present or planned land use of an area? X Discussion: The site is located in an industrial zone which allows storage use. The communication tower is subject to approval of a conditional use permit for the unclassified use. The project is in substantial compliance with the City's General Plan Land Use Designation. Site improvements required by the Ordinance Code will alter the present use of the site; landscaping and on—site parking will be provided. No significant adverse impact is anticipated. 9. Natural Resources. Will the proposal result in: a. Increase in the rate of use of any natural resources? _ _ X b. Substantial depletion of any nonrenewable natural resource? _ _ X Discussion (a,b): Construction of the communication tower in conjunction with the storage use is not anticipated to result in any substantial increase in the rate of use or depletion of any natural resource. 10. Risk of Upset. Will the proposal involve: a. -A risk of an explosion or the release of hazardous substances (including, but not limited to oil, pesticides, chemicals or radiation) in the event of an accident or upset conditions? _ X _ Discussion: The site is currently utilized as a storage facility. Items stored may have contaminated the site and soils in the area. However, the project will be subject to standard conditions of approval which require the clean-up/removal of contaminated.soils to comply with state and local requirements as directed and approved by the City Fire and Public Works Departments. In addition, the site, is also located within a methane zone. Accumulation of methane may result in explosion- related hazards. The project, however, -will be subject to standard conditions of approval which require methane ventilation and monitoring pursuant to Fire Department approval . With implementation of standard conditions of approval, no significant adverse impacts are anticipated. I Environmental Checklist (1796D) ..J Yes Maybe Njc b. Possible interference with an emergency response plan or an emergency evacuation plan? _ X _ Discussion: The project for a communication tower may be used for emergency evacuation broadcasting. The tower may interfere with emergency evacuation in the event the tower should fall and prevent access to and from Edison or Newland Avenues. However, the City's building and zoning codes require the tower to be designed and be constructed to meet earthquake, flood and structural standards, no significant adverse impact is anticipated. 11. Population. Will the proposal alter the location, distribution, density, or growth rate of the human population of an area? _ _ X Discussion: Operation of the proposed facility and continued use as a storage facility are not anticipated to alter the growth rate in the area. No additional jobs will be created; therefore, no change to distribution and growth rate of population. 12. Housing. Will the proposal affect existing housing, or create a demand for additional housing? _ X Discussion: See 11. The project does not create a demand for additional housing. No significant impacts are anticipated. 13. Transportation/Circulation. Will the proposal result in: a. Generation of substantial additional vehicular movement? _ _ X Discussion: The existing storage facility will remain in operation. A once-a-week visit to the communication facility will result in negligible impact on traffic both on Newland Street and Edison Avenue. No significant impacts are anticipated. b. Effects on existing parking facilities, or demand for new off-site parking? _ X Discussion: Access to the site is taken from a private street, Edison Avenue. Presently there are no on-site parking spaces; implementation of this project will provide driving construction a minimum of 5 on-site parking spaces. No demand for off-site parking is anticipated. C. Substantial impact upon existing transportation systems? _ _ X Discussion: A temporary impact to the existing transportation.system may occur during construction. The private street, Edison Avenue, is only 30 feet wide. The Fire Department requires a minimum clear width of 24 feet for fire access along Edison Avenue; therefore, during construction no significant impact is anticipated. d. Alterations to present patterns of circulation or movement of people and/or goods? _ _ X Discussion: Access to the site will continue to be taken from Edison Avenue. No permanent alteration to the area's circulation pattern is -proposed. e. Alterations to waterborne, rail or'air traffic? _ _ X Discussion: The communication tower will be equipped with lights as required by Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). No significant impacts are anticipated. Environmental Checklist -6- (1796D) Yes Maybe H2 f. Increase in traffic hazards to motor vehicles, bicyclists or pedestrians? _ _ X Discussion: Building construction in compliance with front setback requirement will afford visibility to the private accessway. No significant impacts are anticipated. 14. Public Services. Will the proposal have an effect upon, or result in a need for new or altered governmental services in any of the following areas: a. Fire protection? _ _ X b. Police protection? _ X C. Schools? X Discussion (a,b,c): Compliance with Fire code requirements will minimize any adverse effects on fire protection services. The project is in compliance with the General Plan and will not generate any students. d. Parks or other recreational facilities? X Discussion: The project will not require dedication of any additional park land. e. Maintenance of public facilities, including roads? _ _ X Discussion: The project will be connected to the City's water and sanitary sewer systems for the area. The continued use of the storage business and unmanned communication facility will have minimal, if any, additional impact on the sewer and water systems. A once—a—week vehicle trip along the arterials and the private street to allow routine maintenance of the communication building are not anticipated to create any additional impact on any public roads. f. Other governmental services? _ _ X Discussion: All public services are available to the site. No additional facilities or equipment are required to serve the site. 15. Energy. Will the proposal result in: a. Use of substantial amounts of fuel or energy? _ _ X Discussion: The proposed communications tower includes an above ground .generator. This generator may be powered by fuel or electricity. Because the remaining portions of the site will be used for storage and on—site parking, it is anticipated that no significant increase in amount of fuel or energy would occur above that usually associated with a manufacturing use on a site of similar size. b. Substantial increase in demand upon existing source of energy, or require the development of sources of energy? _ _ X Discussion: See 15a. 16. Utilities. Will the proposal result in a need for hew systems, or substantial alterations to the following utilities: a. Power or natural gas? _ _ X f Environmental Checklist —7— (1796D) ! ! Yet Maybe Np b. Communication systems? _ _ X C. Water? — _ X d. Sewer or septic tanks? — _ X e. Storm water drainage? _ _ X f. Solid waste and disposal? _ _ X Discussion (a,b,c,d,e,f): All utilities are available on-site and adequately service the storage use. Due to the infrequent visits and low volume of activity at the facility (1 maintenance trip per week) and lack of a permanent building, the tower will have a negligible impact, if any, on any utility. No significant impacts are anticipated. 17. Human Health. Will the proposal result in: a. Creation of any health hazard or potential health hazard (excluding mental health)? _ _ X b. Exposure of people to potential health hazards? _ X Discussion (a,b): See 10a. 18. Aesthetics. Will the proposal result in the obstruction of any scenic vista or view open to the public, or will the proposal result in the creation of an aesthetically offensive site open to public view? X Discussion: The site is located approximately 2,000 feet from the ocean. The 300+ foot tower will be visible from the beach and ocean as well as surrounding properties. Although the subject site is located adjacent to the electrical generation site, the massive Edison facility will not block all views of the tower. To reduce visual impact and reduce maintenance, the tower will be galvanized gray. Any features added to the tower in the future such as satellite dishes, cellular antennas or other types of antennas will be subject to compliance with Huntington Beach zoning provisions applicable to antennas at that time. 19. Recreation. Will .the proposal result in an impact upon the quality or quantity of existing recreational opportunities? X Discussion: The site is not located on property zoned or used for recreational purposes. No significant impact is anticipated. 20. Cultural Resources. a. Will the proposal result in the alteration of or the destruction of a prehistoric or historic archaeological site? _ X b. Will the proposal result in adverse pf+ysical or aesthetic effects to a prehistoric or historic building, structure, or object? _ X C. Does the proposal have the potential to cause a physical change which would affect unique ethnic cultural values? _ X rvironmental Checklist -8- (1796D) Yes Maybe NP d. Will the proposal restrict existing religious or sacred uses within the potential impact area? _ _ X Discussion (a,b,c,d): The site is not located in the vicinity of any known archaeological sites or other cultural resources. 21. Mandatory Findings of Significance. a. Does the project have the potential to degrade the quality of the environment, sub- stantially reduce the habitat of a fish or wildlife species, cause a fish or wildlife population to drop below self sustaining levels, threaten to eliminate a plant or animal connunity, reduce the number or restrict the range of a rare or endangered plant or animal or eliminate important examples of the major periods of California history or prehistory? X b. Does the project have the potential to achieve short-term, to the disadvantage of long-term, environmental goals? (A short-term impact on the environment is one which occurs in a relatively brief, definitive period of time while long-term impacts will endure well into the future.) X C. Does the project have impacts which are individually limited, but cumulatively consid- erable? (A project may impact on two or more separate resources where the impact on each resource is relatively small, but where the effect of the total of those impacts on the environment is significant.) r X d. Does the project have environmental effects which will cause substantial adverse effects on human beings, either directly or indirectly? _ X E-vi ronmental Checklist -9- (1796D) DETERMINATION On the basis of this initial evaluation: I find that the proposed project COULD NOT have a significant effect on the environment, and a X NEGATIVE DECLARATION will be prepared. I find that although the proposed project could have a significant effect on the environment, there _ will not be a significant effect in this case because the mitigation measures described on an attached sheet have been added to the project. A NEGATIVE DECLARATION WILL BE PREPARED. I find the proposed project MAY have a significant effect on the environment, and an ENVIRONMENTAL _ IMPACT REPORT is required. Date Si gnAure Revised: March, 1990 For: City of Huntington Beach Community Development Deoartment Environmental Checklist -10- (1796D) ;-ANNING ZONING DM 14 SLCTIONAL DISTRICT MAP 13-6- 11 CITY OF ol•ED ...c. 1. 960 r N, 9 �1- 6! , 2, HUNTI'NGTON BEACH 5.7.,2 :1, too fit fit 4 1 M-w R AN G E C 0 U _N T Y. C A L I F 0 R_N I A 1-2C.6 -C 31 3 1117 ;7.. 1­61 fii ;2!- 12 N,7 Irt3 I I I I 1 I R G RI i I I P.I _i3 ;k3 C4 ;I R3 A3 R 3 _W__) I r1l !RI ;ql ......... RI ems C4 CF-E RI RI ;72 ::0 - c- �::.. _�J�IL��,RBI ',:��._1 + J L R 3 LRI j A 3 6==,: R 3 1 1 R 3 CF 01-R 41 X 77 • MI-A-0 ................ Rl RA U L= iM 11, MI-A-0 m.I--A 0-cz 0 LUD-0-CZ ' N12- 0 ............... Cl MH-CZ a 4�: 0-LUD-01"C­Z;.cP2 M2-0 M2_0 c:r Responses to Comments Negative Declaration No. 93-40 Communications To-v+•er I. INTRODUCTION This document serves as the Response to Comments on the Negative Declaration No. 93-40. This document contains all information available in the public record related to the Negative Declaration as of Friday. November 19. 1993 and responds to comments in accordance with Section 15088 of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines. This document contains six sections. In addition to this Introduction, these sections are Public Participation and Review, Comments, Responses to Comments, Errata to the Draft Negative Declaration, and Appendix. The Public Participation section outlines the methods the City of Huntington Beach has used to provide public review and solicit input on the Negative Declaration. The Comments section contains those ATitten comments received from agencies, groups, organizations, and individuals as of Friday,November 19, 1993. The Response to Comments section contains individual responses to each comment. The Errata to the Draft Negative Declaration is provided to show corrections of errors and inconsistencies in the Draft Negative Declaration. It is the intent of the City of Huntington Beach to include this document in the official public record related to the Negative Declaration. Based on the information contained in the public record the decision makers will be provided with an accurate and complete record of all information related to the environmental consequences of the project. II. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION AND REVIEW The City of Huntington Beach notified all responsible and interested agencies and interested groups, organizations, and individuals that a Negative Declaration had been prepared for the proposed project. The City also used several methods to solicit input during the review period for the preparation of the Negative Declaration. The following is a list of actions taken during the preparation, distribution, and review of the Negative Declaration. 1. A cover letter and copies of the Draft Negative Declaration wefe filed with the State Clearinghouse on October 14. 1993. The State Clearinghouse assigned Clearinghouse Number 93101065 to the proposed project. A copy of the cover letter and the distribution list is available for review and inspection at the City of Huntington Beach, Planning Department, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648. Responses to Comments Negative Declaration No. 93-40 Communication Tower DOT-1 Comment: The California Department of Transportation, Division of Aeronautics, has reviewed the above-referenced document with respect to CEQA. The following comments are offered for your consideration. Response: The continent consists of a description of the proposed project for identification purposes. No further written response is necessary. T-2 Comment: According to the Negative Declaration,the 310 foot tower to be located at Edison Avenue and Newland Street, will be equipped with lights as required by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). The report did not state whether a Notice of Proposed Construction or Alteration(Form 7460-1) has been filed with the FAA. If this form has not been filed, we advise you to contact the FAA at the following address: FAA, Western-Pacific Regional Office, P. O. Box 92007, Worldway Postal Center, Los Angeles, CA 9009. Response: The applicant has filed a Notice of Proposed Construction with Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). D T-3: Comment: Thank you for the opportunity to review and comment on this proposal. If you have any questions regarding our comments, please call me at 916-324-1833. Response: The comment is acknowledged and will be forwarded to_the appropriate decision makers for consideration prior to action on the proposed code amendment. Response to Comments ND 93-40 3- DIST 12-1: Comment: Thank you for the opportunity to review and comment on the Negative Declaration No. 92-40. The proposed project is to permit construction of a 310 foot high communications tower on a site presently used for storage. Response: The comment consists of a description of the proposed project for identification purposes. No further xvritten response is necessary. DIST 12-2: Comment: Caltrans District 12 has no comment at this time. Please continue to keep us informed of any further developments that could potentially impact our State Transportation Facilities. If you have any questions, or need to contact us, please feel free to call Aileen Kennedy on (714) 724-2239. Response: The comment is acknowledged and will be forwarded to the appropriate decision makers for consideration prior to action on the proposed communication tower project. HBEB-1 Comment: The City of Huntington Beach Environmental Board has received and reviewed the above mentioned project. The Environmental Board concurs that a Negative Declaration is the appropriate level of environmental review for the project. In addition to the areas of concern addressed on the Negative Declaration, the board feels that the following issues need to be clarified. Response: The comment is acknowledged and will be forwarded to the appropriate decision makers for consideration prior to action on the proposed project. Please refer to HBEB-2 through HBEB-4 Responses below. Response to Comments ND 93-40 -4- • � J BH EB_2: Comment: Section La "The site is also located within an area with high threat of liquefaction." Although the standard conditions of approval require analysis of the soils, grading, etc., it cannot be said that "no significant impacts are anticipated", therefore "No" should be "Maybe", until adequate information is complied with relation to potential threats. Response: The errata will be included to indicate a "maybe" environmental impact. However, mitigation cannot the recommended until a thorough analysis of soils on site has been completed. Therefore, additional discussion is not necessary. HBEB_3: Comment: Section 10: In addition to the hazards mentioned there are oil tanks in the area and electric power lines, these hazards are not mitigated. Response: Any structural damage to the tower may allow the tower to break or fall over resulting in damage to structures, i.e., power lines, oil tanks, buildings. The errata has been changed to reflect this concern. HBEB_4: Comment: Section 13: Aesthetically this is a very high tower that will surpass the height of the Edison Power Plant smoke stakes significantly. The Yisual.impact of this tower on its' oven may be offensive and the future features of satellite dishes would need further clarification. Response: The applicant has submitted fact sheets that describe the various types of antennas that may be added to the tower. Zoning provisions applicable at the time of individual antenna installation may require separate zoning entitlement. The comment is acknowledged and will be forwarded to the appropriate decision makers for consideration prior to action on the proposed project. Response to Comments ND 93-40 5- HBEB-5. Comment: The Environmental Board recommends approval of NTD No. 92-40 subject to adequate analysis and resolution of the above issues. Response- The comment states support of approval of the Negative Declaration. Comment acknowledged; it xvill be forwarded to decision makers prior to action on the project. B B-6: Comment: If you have any questions or concerns regarding our comments, please contact Theresa Rey, Chairperson of the Review Subcommittee. Response: Comment acknowledged and will be forwarded to decision makers prior to action on the proposed project. GOPR-1: Comment: The State Clearinghouse has submitted the above named proposed Negative Declaration to selected state agencies for review. The review period is now closed and the comments from the responding agency(ies) is(are) enclosed. On the enclosed Notice of Completion form you will note that the Clearinghouse has checked the agencies that have commented. Please review the Notice of Completion to ensure that your comment package is complete. If the comment package is not in order,please notify the State Clearinghouse immediately. Remember to refer to the project's eight-digit State Clearinghouse number so that we may respond promptly. Response: Comment acknowledged and will be forwarded to decision makers prior-to action on the . proposed project. Response to Comments ND 93-40 -6. GOPR-2: Comment: Please note that Section 21104 of the Californi Public Resources Code required that: "a responsible agency or other public agency shall only make substantive comments regarding those activities involved in a project which are within an area of expertise of the agency or which are required to be carried out or approved by the agency." Commenting agencies are also required by this section to support their comments with specific documentation. Response: Comment acknowledged and will be forwarded to decision makers prior to action on the proposed project. GOPR-3: Comment: These comments are forwrded for your use in preparing your final EIR. Should you need more information or clarification, we recommend that you contact the commenting agency at your earliest convenience. Response: Comment acknowledged and will be forwarded to decision makers prior to action on the proposed project. GOPR-4: Comment: This letter acknowledges that you have complied with the State Clearinghouse review requirements for draft environmental documents, pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act. Please contact Mark Goss at (916) 445-0613 if you have any questions regarding the environmental review process. Response: Comment acknowledged and will be forwarded to decision makers prior to action on the proposed project. Response to Comments ND 93-40 -7- V. ERRATA TO DRAFT NEGATIVE DECLARATION The following changes to the Draft]Negative Declaration and Initial Study are as noted below. The chances to the Draft Necative Declaration as they relate to issues contained within this errata sheet do not affect the overall conclusions of the environmental document. The changes are identified by the comment reference. Earth, pg. 1 (item l a) 1k7 ill the project result in unsable earth conditions or changes in geologic substructures? The answer has been chanced to "maybe." Risk of Upset pg. 5 (item I Oa) Discussion has been modified to read as follows: "The site is currently utilized as a storage facility. Items stored may have contaminated the site and soils in the area. However, the project will be subject to standard conditions of approval which require the clean-up removal of contaminated soils to comply with state and local requirements as directed and approved by the City Fire and Public Works Departents. "Within 310 feet of the site, there are a variety of structures that may be affected in th event any structural damage should occur to the tower. Structural damage may cause the tower to break or fall resulting in damage to the surrounding structures, i.e., power lines, oil tanks, other buildings. Design and construction of the tower in compliance with the City's building and zoning codes should result in a structure capable of withstanding heavy winds, earthquakes and floods; therefore, no significant impact is anticipated. "In addition, the site is also located within a methane zone. Accumulation of methane may result in explosion related hazards. The project, however, will be subject to standard conditions of approval wich require methane ventilation and monitoring pursuant to Fire Department approval. "With implementation of standard conditions of approval, no significant adverse impacts are anticipated." I Response to Comments 4 ND 93-40 R- i • APPENDIX A STATE OF CALIFORNIA—BUSINESS AND TRANSPORTATION AGENCY PETE WILSON, Governor DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION DISTRICT 12 2501 PULLMAN STREET v� SANTA ANA, CA 92705 1�w p � 1g93 November 1, 1993 Ms . Susan Pierce File: IGR/CEQA Associate Planner SCH 93101065 City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Community Development Huntington Beach, Ca. 92648 Dear Ms . Pierce: Thank you for the opportunity to review and comment on the Negative Declaration No. 92-40 . The proposed project is to permit construction of a 310 foot high communications tower on a site presently used for storage. Caltrans District 12 has no comment at this time. Please continue to keep us informed of any further developments that could potentially impact our State Transportation Facilities . If you have any questions, or need to contact us, please feel free to call Aileen Kennedy on (714) 724-2239 . 'ncerely, EVERRETT EVANS, Chief Office of Planning and Public Transportation cc: Tom Loftus, OPR- Ron Helgeson, HDQTRS Planning T.H. Wang. Traffic Operations STATE OF CALIFORNIA•BUSINESS.TRANSPORTA.-ON AND HOUSING AGENCY PETE WILSON. Govemor DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION _ DIVISION OF AERONAUTICS 1130 K STREET—4th FLOOR r MAIL: P.O. BOX 942873 SACRAMENTO,CA 94273-0001 (916)322-3090 TDD (916)654-4014 October 29, 1993 _, t Ms. Susan Pierce ,I`I v 0 .1 ;3j3 City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Dear Ms. Pierce: City of Huntington Beach, Negative Declaration No. 92-40 for a 310-Foot Communication Tower: SCH## 93101065 c T 1 The California Department of Transportation, Division of Aeronautics, has reviewed the above-referenced document with respect to CEQA. The following comments are offered for your consideration. According.to the Negative Declaration, the 310-foot tower to be located at Edison Avenue and Newland Street, will be equipped with lights as required by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). The report did not state whether a Notice of Proposed Construction or Alteration (Form 7460-1) has been filed. with the FAA. If this form has not been filed, we advise you to contact the FAA at the following address: FAA Westem-Pacific Regional Office P.O. Box 92007 Worldway Postal Center Los Angeles, CA 90009 Thank you for the opportunity to review and comment on this proposal. If you have -3 any questions regarding our comments, please call me at 916/324-1833. Sincerely, SANDY HESNARD Environmental Planner cc: State Clearinghouse FAA, Western-Pacific Regional Office 161 j vt 11 11) Q I I. ul cl (1) ::1 10) .,: 11. 0 f: L 1. r1 1 fit 1-1 1 11) Ij lit 01) 111 f tit I I h Cf, 4) f 1, 11) ri, fit In fb VI III ft 111 1: fit tit I t". ill .`.I' %-- 1:1, (1, ".3' 11 (P Cr .J, 1­:1, rl' 1­ 0. (D<: (I fit III I- Up W 0 M 41) (1 N C) to'( fit sit t v r? (1) (1 1: 1.) co- cl. c: N :71 0 rk III %U ID if top I... (h 0 1 111 ft. W t,( 1'. Cf" ;.t (11 $�: I' I.- I I III O. Vol I", cf I a I h UP III :j, <: trp� - ,I :.I fly (1) 0 fort P- I I. I... I., r-. In II. .r 1., ::11 , W. :.1 (71 0 11 Cf' I:: lot (it I W I I.: I r r n tot s..: of 4t, r.r 4 1 1-h (I Cf- ::I' ::J 0 r r n -n 00 of (1) O I.. I I'll rt, U 0) off '.I , T I h 111 of v­, p I-" N, 4.) A) gi) 4-> N - c a ::j cf Do I F: Z ft, U-) c • (1) (1) -- -- 0 1 1 $0 kfg r) (1) r v Do ::1 0 (1) tpj C) :W cf- ul ::1 ::1, 11 Lr Ica f.,: x Ill "I In 1-1 :11 to to I I At I-- 1-1 fl.,'t 1­ 0 rl too 0 0, P 131 At Cf,119 (11 S-: *-I of 1­ (1) S-j ill 41) of e 0 0 t- of It, ::I t-, ct, I--- pop fit fit Do I- tw-oil ri. ut is, :-.I- In 1-( (1) .'0 t t .11 ill ­ 11, tit W Cf, (0) o U I-t :j of (D (1) Do P. 1 41) $7: (1) :11 :_I C) G-) In :.1, (D P. I- : 0 :J Cr (1) U-) I 11(l (,) (!1it l ? :I --I (1, $.1. ft) ff,Q '.1 0 W fit of m Al (1) (1) (1) 1-h 11; C) 11, 41, 0 Cf- 1,1" 1... 1-1 C I- (ff , Of ill P- 0. f- 0 of of ('I Z F, Cf' 0 1r1 ::1, 0 (it 4-1 Cf, 0. c f- III (to 1-1 :I 4 1 t t (11 0 fit 1: 41) ri rt )­ of (1) o —aw N Ill( v- Cu 0 C) :1 ::1 10 . tip p) 0 ff* 1-1 11' It, W- 10 1: (1) 0 of ::j ::J, ..., I.: no Co. sip r.: (11 n, (1) 1-t, t:J (P :J it) 1-1- of rl- fit (1) rr 01 0 (1) CL < In (it rl T T 1Y W-%(1 0 to ::l #0 t 1. of CI 1:1. t-I 4) it, :.1 C. (1) 0 1:$' u V 10 of ILI 11:11. co 0-( ill 1­ 0., (it 11, ll (T) fit I.V 11) (1- ".1' of ".) rt, 0 (1) 1­ ff 0 (1 111 I:r 0 Cf, 1), 11 ,I (it of (1) ::I I... . 0. ::3, Cf-11:1 ri f 1 4.) 1. In Vt (:I r I ll,j 1 0 VI (P ID (1) 1.: 1, 0 sip U fit of L-1. T I 0 1, 0 I-h :J Do Id of —0 0 Ct rt' (if N 1-1 f-: f:: 1-h L-4 cf- vf* Ill :1 C.) #-- :.I-vTj 1--- 0 IU Cf' I - 1-11 - I C f (to (P got I— (P f-I. :'l 1.; 1-1 no (1) 4,1 O rf- CI- 11) k(p I-) U13 t p.— 17.1. (D :_.T1 - I') (l it) (1) ic► (1) fit r t C) ff) Cf, "f, t l (1) f h Do C) Ill, ,I- H (1) Ill Cf, Do t (,1 4,P rr 0. (1) 1­ no I III ct, t-ol t.r P- 1.1 %'1. P-- () (1) y UO Ill C) C) 1.1. () () (11 < 01 (D 0 In I-J. 0 (D V( v P a) f)* :.I- c) I o =I - ::I I'll t,t. CL (1) <, I- f-I 1-1 I'l C t (1) CL f V cf, (D tip (1, tit-! '•,Ki, (1 • ko (I) r in c: rf* I-h 1), in Do of t;e! c) 41) (D IT) 0 C) tj C ::j r— :,.1 1: '1 cf* Cf, I I %(I V :1 (_D I V tit 1­ (11 IA.tit I V I III, < 1.41 f. 1­ it-# I'I', 1-, 10 1­ fit fit if) i or 0 1' Cf- Ill ;Y L-: 4-1 lu lu IlJ t-t (ff rr 11 I't :f b I :x lot 1 0 CIO QO Ci 0 1-1 fit f I. P. 41) 1-1 (11 $11 P- It) ::I I:L ft, cf Vt 0 1--- Ili -.0 IT) (D Cr (n 10 (1) ff, (_0 G) I of 0) rt k: of I'll ft, t-1 fit 0 (.0 CO F.: 11 41) to r f- f7? 1-1 1.11 :.-.1 (1) rr rt ft' ft, 11 -T- 0 ::1 1-11 (1) of cf- 1-1- ft cf no <. STATE OF CALIFORNIA PETE WILSON, Governor �I GOVERNOR'S OFFICE OR.F LANNING AND RESEARCH 1400 TENTH STREET '•' '~ SACRAMENTO, CA 95814 '•:sr% November 17, 1993 SUSAN PIERCE �� _ 9 ='•' CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 92648 Subject: NEG DEC NO. 92-40 COYYSUNICATIONS TO'h%R SCH f: 93101065 Dear SUSAN PIERCE: I The State Clearinghouse has submitted the above named proposed Negative Declaration to selected state agencies for review. The review period is now closed and the comments from the responding agency(ies) is(are) enclosed. On the enclosed Notice of Completion form you will note that the Clearinghouse has checked the agencies that have commented. Please review the Notice of Completion to ensure that your comment package is complete. If the comment package is not in order, please notify the State Clearinghouse immediately. Remember to refer to the project's eight-digit State Clearinghouse number so that we may respond promptly. Please note that Section 21104 of the California Public Resources Code required that: P� "a responsible agency or other public agency shall only make substantive comments regarding those activities involved in a project which are within an area of expertise of the agency or which are required to be carried out or approved by the agency." Commenting agencies are also required by this section to support their comments with specific documentation. These comments are forwarded for your use in preparing your final EIR. Should { you need more information or clarification, we recommend that you contact the 3 I commenting agency at your earliest convenience. iK This letter acknowledges that you have complied with the State Clearinghouse review requirements for draft environmental documents, pursuant to the f I California Environmental Quality Act. Please contact Mark Goss at (916) 445- j 0613 if you have any questions regarding the environmental review process. Sincerely, VI�4 �,4'71_0. Christine Kinne Deputy Director, Permit Assistance Enclosures cc: Resources Agency STATE OF�;ALIFORNIA-BUSINESS.TRANSPORT. N AND HOUSING AGENCY PETE WILSON,Govemor DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION DIVISION OF AERONAUTICS :s 1130 K STREET-4th FLOOR MAIL: P.O.BOX 942873 SACRAMENTO,CA 94273-0001 , (916)322.3090 TDD (916)654-4014 October 29, 1993 L CC` Ms. Susan Pierce City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Dear Ms. Pierce: City of Huntington Beach, Negative Declaration No. 92-40 for a 310-Foot Communication Tower: SCH# 93101065 The California Department of Transportation, Division of Aeronautics, has reviewed the above-referenced document with respect to CEQA. The following comments are offered for your consideration. According to the Negative Declaration, the 310-foot tower to be located at Edison Avenue and Newland Street, will be equipped with lights as required by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). The report did not state whether a Notice of Proposed Construction or Alteration (Form 7460-1) has been filed with the FAA. If this form has not been filed, we advise you to contact the FAA at the following address: FAA Western-Pacific Regional Office P.O. Box 92007 Worldway Postal Center Los Angeles, CA 90009 Thank you for the opportunity to review and comment on this proposal. If you have any questions regarding our comments, please call me at 916/324-1833. Sincerely, 0I iginal signed by SANDY HESNARD Environmental Planner cc: State Clearinghouse FAA, Western-Pacific Regional Office ORNI F Nice of Completion • s..Nor, Maillo:State Clearinghouse.1400 Tenth Stral,S3cr3mcmo,CA 95814 9161-5-0613 SCH tl 9810 1 0 6 5 Project Title: t -4 r Lead Agency: C.,i., rf tJ h,,,k: P• Contact Penon: `�„t' .. P Sweet Address: Mew'n -ni re e r Phone: 7l y--s Ae 51 7 city: .a.i .h'1oir„ P-t"C/- Zip: `/Lf.Vk County: C;, —— —————————————————————————————————————— Project Location County. _+-'!'j+< - - - Ciry/Necest Cornmuniry: iL:,h 1114 Ic., Rr , /, Cross Streets: rel"", a—i Nr.t l[,."l Zip Code: 9i s N v TOW Acres: Assessor's Parcel No. 1,4 C-t Yr--2+ Scction: r-+ Twp. C- Range: /_ Base: ^irt• Within 2 Miles: SureY.wy0: / Warcrvays: PC.,Ar 4ccr. r N�..ti.,,k., r3i. ,L C hn,+ e I Airpo:s: - Rail-ays:ivy Schools: Kc=4i,c, a.4.-r ————————...-———————————————————————————————— Document Type CEOA: ❑NO ❑Supp;c7ncn5ubsequent NEPA: ❑NOI Other: ❑JoL'it Doeurnenl C'Er1y Coro ❑EIR(Prior SCH No.) ❑EA G*,e Docc rent ;KNeg Dec ❑Other ❑Daft EIS REP ❑Draft EM ❑FONSI De, -�6 ------------------------------- '-1� ------ Local Action Type r1EA i elf RitJGH01JSF. ❑General Plar.Update ❑Specific PIL-1 ❑Rcwne ❑Ar)c=auo r ❑General Plan Amene--nnt ❑Masw P1rt ❑Pre-.one ❑Redevelopmnt ❑Gene-al Plan Ele-rent ❑PIL%ned Unit De,•eioprnent ❑Use Pcrnit j"''Ccastal PC-Ut ❑Community Plan ❑Site Plan ❑Lax'Division(Subdivision, ®'othe-,C-.N 1i Fir: 1 Parcel Map,Tray Map,etc.) Ut c t':r.r,,t Development Type M Residential: Units Acru ❑W'aw FaeUtics: Tvpe MGD LJ office: Sq,h. Acres Emp"O;eu ❑T.ansponation: Type Com=%excial: Sqr!• Acru E+rp o eu []Mining: Mineral ❑Indus`ial: Sq/1. Acres Z-oPlcyeu ❑PC-= Type wAni 0 Educatioatal ❑Waste Trtarnent Type ❑Recrational ❑Hazardous Waste Type '�Ilter�� 4rn .ti: kr:,.rr ——————————————————————————————"-—————————..- Project Issues Discussed In Document g.Acsthedc/Visual flood Plain/Floodint @'SchookNnivcaitiu awater Quality ❑Agrlculttral Land ❑Forest Landrre Hurd ❑Septic Systems ®'Waw Supply/Ground-•stet E Ai;Qj&Bry a ctologic/Seismic 9Stwe:Capacity gwtilandfRipwian jS�ArcheologicaLrlIubricil ❑Mincals Sol E-osiorJC6mpae;io-J0rading ®'Wildlife xcoastil Zaire $,Noise Igsolid Waste 50rowth Inducing i3'ainagarAbsorprion ®PopulatiorOiousing Balance KToaieAla ardous Kl"use ❑Eeonorn c/Iobs ®Public Services/Fatuities C Traffic/C'trculs6on Cumulative Effects ❑F•iscal ZReceatio&`Prks R'Qegeta:ion OOther ————————————————————————————————————————— Present Land Use/Zoning/Ceneral Plan Use /,rC/u.jr,al_ She/eyt f cpe;, / _ FP Z� Nec�i I„a _h•,LLI v I Flcodplu_,t�� bida5ly�u1_C s„t.', ---------- Project Description T"c re-'m C_o,•--frochn,: C-F a 3,0 fit h9h ce:+�rnu.�.4tfirn5 haver, CLEARINGHOUSE CONTACT: XARR GOSS (926) 445-0613 CKT SIT CUT SIrT /� • Aeswasrcea State/Consumer Svcs S?ATE REVIEW BEGAN: IV - I p - `1 2 _ — —_ ---Coastal Cosa DEPT REV TO AGENCY: II - ID - snow AGENCY RIV TO SCH s II - Ij _ • 11wGame SCH COMPLIANCE * P stag. — — B !�_ �pKR Yth/Adlt Corrections PLLAS[ MOTE SCE IUMMIA�1 1AL(`OO�B lbu■ Tranep Baum Aeronautics n Casa PLEASE FORWARD LA3Z OOIBtntTB DIR<CSSyY 2V LIJ►D AGIfC! 012Y �• Caltrans 0 1 —PUC AQY.D;APCD: 33 (Resourcesr !p /� ) • • State Len a Comm i"S' Bent- by ;sad / sent by c Ht E VALLEY F'KY P.02: DEc 07 '93 1 46 " 0. C. F . C. R. E A S E I.M E N T H U N T t N G T O N B E A C H C H A N N E L. � y r 1 1 1 1 40, X4$a. i 1 1 , Y'a-t)C.s CAF2kTAKE� 1 � 'o- 'IRA)LFJti 1 3a. X as, i 1 RAV i PAR .A 1 Zj }-+1Pogr-- GAS 7N -----------•----•----•--• • .--� bl b 1-As Rl V:ME T AREA ENTIRE 1'i'1 PAVED . WITH ASPHALT i r l .,��] �j�+. L1�f'0( `r X• ✓ + O 5i F, 20• CN7 GATE 12• 5'fT O'r 91•0' C+C�<RA•JR t�l •.._..�., OSG /V A_ y f 30- box 7RM ATTACH .;ENT NO. 30•f-0, EY1ST;'4 3p' CAScwo,'T roA 11Kr+ OU A•O CCAC.0 f 1 TOWER SIGHTING PER F.A.A. 310 FT. CONDITIONS » 300 FT. LEVEL TYPICAL F.M. N-1, ARKAY i e� I i i I i v 212 FT. POWER PLANT OBSTRUCTION I - 200 FT. LEVEL Em I I I I I TYPICAL ANTENNA STAR MOUNT I I I TYPICAL -ANTENNA STAR MOUNTING ARM PLAN VIEW — NO SCALE 100 FT. LEVEL TYPICAL 6' DISH • - Iv - 25 WIDE TOWER BASE GROUND LEVEL U CONCEPTUAL ANTENNA MOUNTING i• section 1A 2A section 8 length upper • read lower • read tower logo lower horizontal* tower diagonals boll* 3A 1A l0' IA' 1V' 1-15116'0 solid - h8'0 sold 3/4' 2A 29 1'4' 7-0r 2'0sdid - 1-1/4'0 sold 3/4' 3A 20' 7-W 7.8' 2-7/16'0 sold 1-1/4'0 solid 1-1/4'0 sobd 3/4' 1 I fib' for 60'<8-1/2X3/8 pi - <2.1/2X2X1/4 314' 2 19 W-W E-0 60'<9.1/2X3B <i-3I4X1-/4X1/4 f.s.2X2X3/16 3/4' 2 3 19' 60 TS 60'<9.12 X 3/8 pl 42X2X3t8:ts2X2X3/16 11/16'0 solid 4' 4 19 TV 6-10r 60'<11 X 318 pf I.s.2X2X3/16 11/16'0 sobd 3/4' 3 5 19 8'-101 lorw 60'<11-12 X 3/8 t.s.2X2X3/16 11/16'0 solid 3/4' 6 IV lu-(r 11 S 60'<11-3/4 X 7/16 pi ls2X2X3/16:fs2-1/2X2-12X3f8 11/16'0 solid 3/4' 7 18' 111S 17$ 60'<12 X 7/16 pi fs3X3X1/4x2X2-1/2X1/4 11/16'0 sobd '• 3/4' 4 _8 16-12' 1 Z-91 W-1' 60'<14-12 X 7/16 pl dlsac2Xi/4:<3X2X1/4 11/16'0 solid 3/4' 9 17-12' 14'1' 16-4' 60'<15X12pi dfs2X2-12X1/4:<3X2X1/4 11/16'0sohd 314"' 5 10 18-12' 164' 160 W<15XI12pi dfs2X3X1/4:<3X2-1/2X5116 I1/16'0 solid E 314' 11 18-12' Mir 190 60'<15-1/4 X 9/16 dfs2X3X1/4x3-t/2X2-1/2X5/16 3/4'0sobd T4" 6 302'-6" 12 18-12' 160 ltlW 60'<16 X 9/16 p1 dfa2X3X1/4:<3-12X3X5/16 3/4'0 solid i 3/4- 13 13-12' JVA' 27-1' 60'<1&1/4 X W16 pi dIs 2-Y4X3x1/4 11/16'0 solid E 3/4' 14 17-1/2' 27-1' 29-X 60'<16 X 9/16 pf 42)(2-12X5116 bb <3X2-12X5/16 bb ; N4' 7 8 9 • 10 11 12 13 APO 148- 121 -21 8541 EDISON AVE. HUNTINGTON BEACH, CA 14 _ TITLE I EDISON AVE . 'COMMUN I CATIONS TOWER huntington beach department of community development STAff E pOR EXECUTIVE SUNIlKARY DECEMBER 7, 1993 CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION (VARIANCE) NO. 92-47/ CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO, 92-44/ NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 92-40 (8541 Edison Avenue) Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44 is a request for "Approval in Concept" for a 310 foot tall communication tower pursuant to Article 963 , Unclassified Uses, of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. The tower will be located in an existing non conforming storage yard. Conditional Exception (Variance) -No. 92-47 has been initiated because the proposal does not comply with the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, Article 953, which has a maximum building height of 40 feet . The applicant is requesting: a height of 310 feet. The subject property is located at 8541 Edison way, a private street, east of Newland Avenue and north of Pacific Coast Highway. If approved, in concept, the project will be forwarded to the California Coastal Commission for final approval . - Staff recommends approval of the project because the tower will be located in an area with other utility structures that exceed the maximum height limit, will be compatible in color, and allow consolidation of future antennas onto a single structure. i A-PL-FM-23D • 0 a BOISA ARCAM t{gpp t0.' MC FADblN D• � I Z CENTER - EDINGER ` I- ♦ Mal WARNER ♦. - - - ,` ♦ SLATER s �f+ • . • ' TALBERT cb�♦ ♦ ♦ ELLIS 0S • �- .E ♦ - - - - - - GARPIELD - YORKTOWN SITE ADAMS .r.w /INDIANAPOLIS _ r I I I I I i I �, '• ATLANTA DI-2 0. TON HAMILTON • BANNING Q n 14 ISON P . m CUP 92-44/CE 92-47/ND 92-40 HUNTINGTON BEACH PLANNING DIVISION OR TO: Planning Commission FROM: Community Development DATE: December 7, 1993 SUBJECT: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-44/CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION (VARIANCE) NO. 92-47/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 92-40 APPLICANT: Dan Brimlow, 31188 Water Avenue, Nuevo, CA 92567 PROPERTY OWNER: Ken Brimlow, 652 E. Culver Avenue, Orange, CA 92666 REOUEST: To "approve in concept" a 310 foot tall communications tower which exceeds the maximum height requirement of 40 feet . . LOCATION: 8541 Edison Avenue DATE ACCEPTED: August 5, 1993 ZONE: M2-0-FP2 (Heavy Industrial Combined with Oil with Floodplain Overlay) GENERAL PLAN: Industrial General EXISTING USE: Storage Yard (Land Of Pliny) ACREAGE: 0 .39 acres 1. 0 SUGGESTED ACTION: Motion to: A. "Approve Negative Declaration No. 92-40; " and B. "Approve in concept Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44 and Conditional Exception (Variance) No. 92-47 with findings and suggested conditions of approval . " 2 . 0 GENERAL INFORMATION: Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44 is a request for "Approval in Concept" for a 310 foot tall communication tower pursuant to Article 963 , Unclassified Uses, of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. The tower will be located in an existing non conforming storage yard. I i • Conditional Exception (Variance) No. 92-47 has been initiated because the proposal does not comply with the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, Article 953 , which has a maximum building height of 40 feet . The applicant is requesting a height of 310 feet . The subject property is located at 8541 Edison Way, a private street, east of Newland Avenue and north of Pacific Coast Highway. If approved, in concept, the project will be forwarded to the California Coastal Commission for final approval . 3 . 0 SURROUNDING LAND USE, ZONING AND GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATIONS: North of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Industrial General ZONE: M1-A-0-CZ (Restricted Manufacturing District combined with Oil and Coastal Zone Overlay) LAND USE: . Orange County Flood Control Channel and Light Industrial . East of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Industrial General ZONE: M2-0 (Heavy Industrial Combined with Oil Storage) LAND USE: Automobile Storage South of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Industrial Energy Production ZONE: M2-0 (Heavy Industrial combined with Oil) LAND USE: Edison Generating Plant West of Subject Property: GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATION: Industrial General ZONE: M2-0 (Heavy Industrial combined with Oil) LAND USE: Animal Clinic and Kennel 4 . 0 ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Pursuant to the environmental regulations in effect at this time, the Department of Community Development advertised draft Negative Declaration No . 92-40 for thirty (30) days, and four (4) written comments were received. The staff, in its initial study of the project, has recommended that a negative declaration be issued. Prior to any action on Conditional Use Permit. No. 92-44 and Conditional Exception (Variance) No. 92-47, it is necessary for the Planning Commission to review and act on Negative Declaration No. 92-40 . Staff Report - 12/7/93 -2- (7455d) 5 . 0 COASTAL STATUS: The proposed project is located in a non-certified area of the Coastal Zone and subject to final approval by the California Coastal Commission. Prior to California Coastal Commission consideration,, the project must be "approved in concept" by the City. 6 . 0 REDEVELOPMENT STATUS: Not applicable. 7 . 0 SPECIFIC PLAN: Not applicable. 8 . 0 SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE: Not applicable. 9 . 0 ISSUES AND ANALYSIS: The applicant has relocated to Huntington Beach a 310 foot high communications tower that was located in Santa Ana adjacent to -the Santa Ana (I-5) Freeway for 35 years . When the freeway expansion required the removal of the tower, the applicant acquired it (see Attachment No. 9) . The tower has been dismantled and it is stored on site pending approval for reconstruction. The applicant proposes to reconstruct the tower and make it available to various governmental agencies and private companies for communication purposes by renting (leasing) space for individual receivers and transmitters antennas . The tower will be reconstructed on the site of an existing storage yard, Land of Pliny. Presently, the site contains an on-site caretaker ' s mobilehome, office building, miscellaneous storage items and debris, and both operable and inoperable vehicles . The site lacks any landscaping or parking for the resident or customers . Large concrete slabs remain on the site as remnants from a previous animal shelter use. An assortment of storage items and inoperable vehicles will be removed to allow sufficient space for the tower, a 25 foot triangular area, and to provide a minimum of five (5) on-site parking spaces, landscaping, and space for storage of operable vehicles . The communications tower will be painted a galvanized gray, and will be compatible with the tower color used for the 220 KV electrical towers in close proximity to the site. The applicant has received Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) conditional approval for construction of the tower which is required due to its height . In accordance with FAA requirements, strobe lights will be installed for day use and running lights for night use. Construction of the tower must comply with the Uniform Building Code; there are no guy wires proposed. Because the site is located in a floodplain, additional .engineering studies are necessary to ensure that the . tower will not incur or cause damage to other properties in the event of a flood. As previously mentioned, construction of the tower will reduce the- storage area for the existing storage business and provide a landscaped street scene and on-site parking which the . site currently is lacking . Staff Report - 12/7/93 -3- (7455d) • • Communications needs are expanding. Recent applications have been approved by the Planning Commission to allow cellular facilities/antennas . These antennas have been approved for location on rooftops of tall buildings as well as on freestanding poles up to 85 feet in height . An example of a communication facility on a building rooftop is City Hall with the emergency communication antennas . In many instances, however, a tall building can accommodate the antennas due to a safety code conflict . Construction of a tall tower will accommodate multiple frequency uses such as police, Coast Guard, Harbor Patrol, FM radio, and cellular phone. Multiple use of the tower will reduce the number of individual facilities . There area a variety of types of antennas that may be placed on the tower at different height locations . Each use would have its own operating system and could use several systems, multiple frequencies, and would need two (2) antennas - receiver and transmitter. Typical antennas include whip, yagi, directional panel, corner reflector, parabolic, UHF and VHF (see Attachment No. 7) . As technology improves or changes, the variety, size and shape of antennas may change to a small type and ability to combine users into one (1) antenna . Although the area is in non certified area of the coastal zone, staff has reviewed the tower and its effect on the coastal zone. Maximum height in the coastal zone is 35 feet, which is substantially lower than the proposed tower height . Existing structures in vicinity currently exceed this height. These include the Edison Generating Plan that has 212 foot high smoke stacks and 150 foot high 220rvtowers (see Attachment No. 4) . Construction of the tower at its proposed location will blend with those structures . The site is also visible from Pacific Coast Highway, a scenic highway. Future antenna placement, however, should be reviewed and approved by the City prior to installation to ensure that any adverse visual impacts may be reduced. One of the alternative actions recommended is to reduce the tower height to 150 feet . This height will be more compatible with the 220kv electrical towers in the immediate vicinity, and, thereby reduce the visual impact that may be created by construction of a 310 foot high communications tower. 10 . 0 RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission approve in concept Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44 , Conditional Exception (Variance) No. 92-47 and Negative Declaration No. 92-40 with the following findings and suggested conditions of approval : FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL - CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION (VARIANCE) NO. 92-47 : 1. There are exceptional or extraordinary circumstances or conditions applicable to the land, buildings or premises involved that do not apply generally to other property or uses in the district . Staff Report - 12/7/93 -4- (7455d) r • 2 . The granting of a conditional exception for a 310 foot high communications tower is necessary in order to preserve the enjoyment of one or more substantial property rights . 3 . The granting of Conditional Exception (Variance) No. 92-47 for a 310 foot high communications tower will not be materially detrimental to the public health, safety and welfare, or injurious to the conforming land, property, or improvements in the neighborhood. 4 . The granting of this conditional exception from Section 9550 . 04 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code will not defeat the general purposes or intent of the code which is to limit the height of manufacturing uses and structures . 5 . The granting of the conditional exception for a 310 foot high communications tower will not adversely affect the General Plan of the City of Huntington Beach because: a. It conserves land resources by providing opportunities for joint participation among all levels of government, private citizens and involved agencies and organizations (2 . 1.2 . 1) . b.. It provides a community facility for the public ' s health, safety and welfare that will be used as a communication system for use by persons living or working in the City (3 .4 .2 . 6) . 6 . The increased height is necessary to obtain multiple frequencies for consolidation of various receiving and transmitting antennas on a single tower. FINDINGS FOR "APPROVAL IN CONCEPT" - CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-44 : 1. The location, site layout, and design of the proposed 310 foot high communications tower properly adapts the proposed structures to streets, driveways, and other adjacent structures and uses in a harmonious manner. 2 . The 310 foot high communication tower will allow consolidation of individual antennas onto one (1) structure on one (1) site. 3 . The access to and parking for the proposed communication tower does not create an undue traffic problem. 4 . The property is zoned M2 (Heavy Industrial) - which is appropriate for communication towers . 5 . At the time of operation, the proposed 310 foot high communication tower can be provided with infrastructure in a manner that is consistent with the Huntington Beach Coastal Element and Coastal Land Use Plan of the General Plan. Staff Report - 12/7/93 -5- (7455d) i �z 42 - - r 3 B-5 wee �J \ 6 . The proposed construction of a 310 foot high communication tower conforms with the public access and public recreation policies of Chapter 3 of the California Coastal Act . SUGGESTED CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL - CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION (VARIANCE) NO. 92-47/CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-44 : �.. 1. The site plan and elevation received and dated i December 7, 1993, shall be the "approval in concept" layout with the following modifications : a . The landscaped area along Edison Avenue shall be increased to ten (10) feet in width. b. The tower shall be painted a galvanized gray color . c. A six (6) foot high masonry wall or slated chin link fence shall be constructed along the front of the storage facility - and behind the landscaping and parking area . d. The radio equipment trailers shall be placed on permanent foundations. 2 . Prior to submittal for building permits, the applicant/owner shall complete the following a. A detailed soils analysis shall be prepared by a registered Soils Engineer . This analysis shall include on-site soil sampling and laboratory testing of materials to provide detailed recommendations regarding grading, chemical and fill . properties , foundations , retaining walls, streets and utilities . 3 . Prior to issuance of building permits, the applicant/owner shall complete the following : a. Submit a copy of the revised site plan pursuant to Condition No. 1 for review and approval and inclusion in the entitlement file. b. A landscape construction set must be submitted to the Department of Public Works and approved. The Landscape Construction Set shall include a landscape plan prepared and signed by a State Licensed Landscape Architect and shall include all proposed/existing plant materials ( location, type, size, quantity) , an irrigation plan, an approved site plan, and a copy of the entitlement conditions of. approval . The landscape plans shall be in conformance with Section .9608 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code and the Water Conservation Ordinance. The setmust be approved by both the Departments of Public Works and Community Development prior to issuance of building permits . c . Submit a copy of a completed Federal Emergency Management_ Agency (FEMA) elevation or floodproofing certificate. d. Submit evidence of California Coastal Commission approval . St-a-f-f—Report 12/7/9-3 6=-- ( 1960D) e. All inoperable vehicles and miscellaneous storage shall be removed from the site. 4 . Fire Department requirements are as follows : a . Fire extinguisher shall be installed in the buildings pursuant to Fire Department requirements per Fire Department 'STandard 424 . b. A gate locking system shall be approved by the Fire Department per Fire Department Standard 403 . c. Address numbers must be installed against contrasting background per Fire Department Standard 428 . d. Flammable liquids stored on-site must comply with Fire Code Article 79 . 5 . All building spoils, such as unusable lumber, wire, pipe, and other surplus or unusable material, shall be disposed of at and off-site facility equipped to handle them. 6 . Prior to final building permit approval, the following shall be completed: a . All improvements (including landscaping) to the property shall be completed in accordance with the approved plans and conditions of approval specified herein. b. Compliance with all conditions of approval specified herein and any California Coastal Commission conditions of approval. 7. Prior to installation of any antenna on the tower, the P1-ann-ing Division shall review and approve the size, location and color of the antenna and a building permit shall be issued. 8 . Any structures proposed for construction in the future and not shown on the conceptually approved site plan shall require Planning Commission approval . 9 . -Vehicle storage shall be limited to those areas shown on the . conceptually approved site plan. .10 . This conditional use permit shall not become effective for any purpose until an "Acceptance of Conditions" form has been properly executed by the applicant and .an authorized representative of the owner of the property and returned to the Planning Division.. CODE REQUIREMENTS: 1 . The development shall comply with all applicable provisions of the Ordinance Code, Building Division, and Fire Department . 2 . Construction shall be limited to Monday-Saturday 7 : 00 AM to 8 : 00 PM. Construction shall be prohibited Sundays and' Federal holidays . Staff Report - 12/7/93 -7- (1960D) 3 . Future animal kennels shall be subject to approval of a conditional use permit . 4 . Customer parking shall not be used for storage. 5 . Conditional Exception (Variance) No. 92-47 and Conditional Use Permit No . 92-44 shall become null and void unless exercised within one (1) year of the date of final approval by the City, or such extension of time as may be granted by the Planning Commission pursuant to a written request submitted to the Planning Division a minimum 30 days prior to the expiration date. 11 . 0 ALTERNATIVE ACTION: The Planning Commission may: A. Deny Negative Declaration No. 92-40 and Conditional Exception (Variance)- No. 92-47 and Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44 with findings for denial; or B. Approve Negative Declaration No. 92-40, Conditional Exception (Variance) No. 92-47 and Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44 with the additional condition that the tower height not exceed 150 feet . ATTACHMENTS: 1. Narrative 2 . Negative Declaration No. 92-40 3 . Site plans and elevations dated July 23, 1993 4 . Site plan and height comparison 5 . Letter from Bethel Towers dated December 11, 1992 6 . Letter from County of Orange dated April 8, 1993 7. Antenna Fact Sheets 8 . FAA Notice of Proposed Construction 9 . News article 10 . Alternative Findings for Denial SH: :kjl Staff Report - 12/7/93 -8- (7455d) J US T I F T,"�TT'- 1 j I T I r7- I.j 7 T` H S AUG 0 3 1993 This I i,_-'ai t n fc-�r d e ve-I t t t L to e C'-!r; C d n r t1- EVEo)';4_ L ' EJir_!:,n P.' �_,nt Est 87"21 Edson Ave . Huntin-7itc-) _ ea � I., r t t this 1 t-,,:!a t 1-1 W o! 4 c,f- ig h prC,, l-in- v1sitil-ity Cran.-:,e C-:,untv with Mir.ImBl victual !TTIL�'act . The J tower would the needed gri--wing needs and requirements to s--upport Pultlic and Safety a c t i v i 1L.1 ---P_ i n lu d 1 n q _lice , :C1 r e r.2.L c.L:e a 1-1-d -7-if:a r q Y V a e :B t+..=,:: C1 I e 'S erry I r e-a—,n s advant .3--r-z-. 'i_vfng a -S.' O' t;'v­_r --t the- .L o c at-Lill a 'u L 1 b F '__E' NT P I A" D 0±�' the F1 "T Cou-,ty iif Cir :Sn:::e- -Com m u n C a-t ic-n i n a t rig police, f i r e, a n d e jT;valry e ncy m,=7-d_ .a I z v 1. c­_7-P, S 3:on q I y a _rts and L_-_ncour_-­e?_ the tower i. n mouth u n't i ng t_-Orj Beach due to t h e exiating insuffic;.ent radio ci_-Iverage. I2COM-PATTRT1 TTY.OF C!-111-111-'N!CATION,-- WITH TALL BUILDINGS: There are Problems concerned with antennas on buildings. For example, Bethel Tcnwers, the hirihest buildings around, has in the past lease-d antenna space, and is considering rem,Dving its antennas due to tenants opinions and fears that radio equipm-ant on top of their building may be affecti—q their TV and rad o re_--eption, as well as their telephone`.. -e-rox Towers in -.anti Ans has also had to reject co,-­munlcations +-_,n t=c C;f their building due to a aaftey code conflict . T.1,a e will need to be relocated on a Sufficiently high, site. Please se-2 attached I-etter . RAD t'IATION -EXOSURE: Higher antennas And tranaiitte ra further reduce the possibility of radiation duer- to the increased vertical separation of the ground and transmitters. AESTHETICS: We feel this would be a prime location that would minimize- the visual ir:pact for a- tall lattice tower ., even though the tower be se-an througlh and bl-ands into the skyline.. h,ecauae : 1 . Looking from the N!_­rth the. power plant is in the back '2---c-1p. Lo.zklnq from PCH , the power. p'L_nt would block the site Vi'_7-W COmpletely . 3. Looking from East and Weat the radio tower wc-uld sit among the ta-111 power line towerE- . r,T-T L 7 1 F.:�E!D 1- T MC Y AC 0 M.r 0 D A T D-D!,11 T h e 211 A h e i q�1 t a I I C'w a ...........___.......... rr 1 Li I t a e t e v Y a e -a r a t i- n f r _ -_iv•=rs t r a)-:S'ri i t t t E! sit e, -t g r 4- 1; 4- 1 i a + r,17 oV j r'r- FUTURE_ZXPA1d_I'_N _ T}:_ ='' he-ight allows the number of antennas to be increased without having to build additional al:tenna to, -,ers . Cr_";1-1UNIC_STIGN__COiv_��_�LID I__^NS__ rc_=mrr•.unications -rs should try to use common towers, buildings, and sites wrlen at all possible to reduce the visual impact associated with multi-tower sites. It has become common practice for communication sites to consolidate all operations onto one tower . This increases efficiency and allows for improved maIiagement of towel- site . New 31itenna combining techniques could also reduce the number o= antennas significantly . The key issue to Keep in mind is that modern _-ommunicatlon's faciliti-S vital to public health, safety s:-:d welfare . _ s tJ�"•RAT:V^ 11= :�' ^.q- _ri,^Cri �irG' A . Because -f ti:_ r:=='d fal 3=-_uatC c-mmun1c= _i=n cov_ra7B " J In th— area ;.r -;-,:Dzinq `-=' a _'10' =:rrir.unl=2tiol towar. Ple:.a_ z-tt__ us` cati or.a . B . The tower ,^-uld -r vid_ the reeded com.municati_.na lin;-s to Alamitos, C_�sta ?S__ - , 4'_stmi:":st_r, and __nta Ana allowing all .to colla'_rr=rrate their burin•=ss• needs, es well aa. people using the tower w rL]ld rr_ the City r-f Huntington each, Police, Fire, Emer•geenc`y` R-_dlio ar and D ai`_e1 rl: t _rl=, as well as- ,__. thq_='t._ Would serve- the Coact Gu__ = , Hartr•_r r=__ _1 and oce- n going v C�Be-Is as well a t.1C +_j Cilera1 pu_a 2.on :;f Huntington Prach . Ea=h ya »c•u1d h a v e th•__r ow separ"Ct= syst_Tii . Each user _=U1J uEe G^v-a sY of .I an-d mu 1 t i I _ fr_quencies, and .`oi_,Id _ _eq i 1 J _ _ _ G' anten n a S; o n a r=-'=iv- and one to transmit . As a _ es'__ , the- type of antennas would vary from simple whips to small dishes . Typical Antennas being used could be : whip. yagi , d_recti -nal panel ; corker reflector, parabolic, UHF and VHF. Technology is changing so fast, and so are the sizes end _--hap es of antennas, As well as the capabilities for combining several similar users on to one antenna . C. PROJECT: Radio i_QrimLl"11LLti=+:J� T_rv'c�' _ 1k'�' SERVICES: Radio Co;::mun—ation,a Vehicle =tor._ge I�. The surrounding uses _i the property are as follows: North - Self Storage _oath - Edison Se nerating Plant East - Auto Wreckin-g West - Dog .Kennels TeA.,.i sr1� ss��.1 —r,✓Erzs a �D l so�� Wp►Y h� a ED�so�.l G��+�4'T'r►a '��+T m 2 \ p Noi rk 1_61 Co 4Y .Syr XtA N p N i ft?-oPoSEo 2P.Dlo solSon1 4S94ZeA"TTI-WG 'T2AkwnISSIo-A -row�rt PLAN-r' Towrc� �R,'T hill L N i NO(l� _� Z6 BETHEL TAMERS "for Retirement Living In California" COSTA MESS-, CALIPORN{A 92627 :ice `■� .8 0 666 West 1 Sth Phone: (714) 642-9941 JUDITH WEATHERSPOON Administrator December 11, 1992 Mr. Daniel Brimlo+w 1235 N. Gilbert Suite "D" Anaheim, Ca. 92801 Dear Mr. Brimlow, It was a pleasure to meet you earlier this week when you inquired• about renting space on our roof for an antenna. I am sorry to inform you that at this time there are five (5) antennas besides our own, plus our elevator equipment roan and boiler room. The roof is as full as we wish for it to be. In addition we frequently experience interference with our television reception. Naturally our 300 Senior Citizens just know it cm-es from "those other antennas on the roof." As a result we are now considering the removal of the antennas that are there now. I am sorry we cannot accomodate your request. S' ely your Judith Weatherspoon Administrator Owned and Operated by the Southern California District Council of the Assemblies of God R.A.SCOTT,Director General Services Agency A UN.-rly (Z> F ROBERT G.LOVE,Deputy Director General Services Agency 2 t JACOUELINE K. NILIUS,Director GSA/Information Systems 5 (Z 3 R A N G E �-� GENERAL SERWCtc, AG-NC'{ Information Systems 14 Civic Center P:aza,ri:s:Flox Santa Ana,California 92701-4047 (714)834.5500 April Q. 1g_3 To Whom It N3v r.:oncern: This letter will confirm that there is a need for a communications tower in .he southwest area cf Huntington Beach. The County of Oranee has operated a Coordinated Public Safety Communications System for the County and =or its :rp:)~E`ed c`ties s'nce the incert;cn ?Jbl 'c Safety radio in 1534. The System is now in need :,f several r:ew •-ommunications sites with towers, one in Huntington Beach, to keep pace witI.l the growing requirements to support Public Safety activities, including pciice, fire, and emergency medical services. The news was enthusiastically received by this -."Iivis'on that a communications tower of approximately 310 feet in height, which is to be constructed, owned, operated, and . ,airtained by a Private party at his sole expense, h_s been proposed for construction next to the Southern California Edison Company's power plant in Huntington Beach. T-his location is believed to be an ex:ellent place f:;r a sub=t-tntial communications tower, in that it would have a minimal visual impact due to the existing transmission likes and supports which converge there and the height of the power plant. Further, the proposed site is located in an industrial zone, away from residential areas, thus providing greater security. It is believed that sucl-, a =�ci':ity would be in the public interest, providing needed antenna space for Public Safety as well as for commercial use. Communications are vital to the Public Safety, health, and weifa:-e of the citizenry , especially in this densely populated - ccur,ty . The GSA/Communications Division strongly -supports and encourages the concept of tiie commun i:.at i ons tower near t proposed the Edison plant in Huntington Beach. You ray contact Gary Gray, Ciiisf Telecommunications Engineer, at ( I .. . 4311 'f there are any questions. r - Sincerely, 1 / Jacq eline K. Nili�s ��Ji�ECtJr of Infcrrr:t ;Gn 3:-LE^'S BROAD BAND—ANTENNA `A- �� - . F .; - 6 or 9 dB GAIN, 120-174 MHz e .._.. The DB224 is a lightweight, high-gain Radiation Patterns �� antenna for 120-174 MHz. It has a broad When the four elements are positionedi' 10 dB bandwidth, and it provides op- evenly, every 900 around the mast, a timum performance in single or multi- 6 dB gain circular pattern results. r, frequencysystems. -� b... When the four elements are positioned It can be mounted on the top or side of in line, collinearly, a 9 dB gain offset a tower and arrayed to give a circular or pattern is created. �`- offset horizontal pattern. Its broad response — 10 MHz or more in the For ease of handling and shipping, the mast is made in two sections. A unique r : 150-174 MHz range — permits it to per- center splice assures proper alignment. - form efficiently on both transmit and receive frequencies. >� :.•_ T A split version of the DB224, two anten- he construction of the antenna assures nas on the same mast, is available in superior lightning protection. The )' both 3 d6 omni and 6 d6 directional radiators operate at DC ground, and the aluminum mast with its pointed top cap patterns. Separate feed lines terminate at the bottom of the mast, and each _ provides a positive low resistance . ; I discharge path to the tower or ground antenna operates independently of the other in omni or directional pattern. system. Isolation is 35 dB or more. Side Mounting Ordering Inform2tionT. s: The patterns indicate the typical pattern shape of Please specify exact frequency or range _ 1y the antenna side mounted on a tower with an 18• (and termination if non-standard). Order to 24• (457.2 to 609.6 mm) face. the DB224 or DB224S Split Antenna for circular patterns, the DB224E or DB224 DS224E 01 DB224ES Split Antenna for offset pat- Cimuiar I _ offset 33 1o__ ` 30° terns. Clamps for top mounting are sup Antenna aAnteen a plied, but for side mounting, order the 30 600 DB5001 Side Mount Kit. The DB224X f has a shortened mast for air shipment. i r For Sway Brace Kit, order 12088 (four 9� required). ,. .� Top Mounting - �1 i s30° 1 S 3DO IL 300' t11 ps \. 60° _ 210° 150° DB224 (omni),mounted on side of tower 270°-- 00 330° �_p � 300 h1 e c`' Data ! Materials: H 1: 300° ':� -'�ooB_ 60� 240° �1zo` Mast— upper (aluminum) — in. (mm) ,r `--� 1.75(44.45) OD with .062 to 210° 1eo 50° .125(1.57 to 3.18) wall Mast- lower (aluminum) - in. (mm) ,.-; ) 27oc �a 900 Horizontal patterns of the DB224 (6 dB) and 2(50.8) OD with .125 to � :�.` DB224E (9 dB). i .187(3.18 to 4.75) wall Electrical 02'3 Radiating elements (aluminum) - in. (mm) ' 240r - 120° Frequency Ranges- MHz 118138', 138 t50, ' 5(12.7) OD with .058(1.47) wall _ Mounting clamps(Galvanized steel) OB365.OS _ _ _ 150-160, 155.165. 164.174 2i0, 15°O ; f Maximum exposed area 180°� Bandwidth (150-174 MHz) - MHz -- 10 (flat plate equivalent) - ft2 (m2) 3.15(.292) DB224E, elements pointed toward the tower �R _ 1.5 to 1 or less — -- Lateral thrust at 100 mph Nominal impedance - ohms _ 50 1 0° _ (161 km/hr) - lbs. (Kg) 126(5i.15) 33D° :5 30' Gain (over half-wave dipole) Wind rating:' 10 Omni pattern - dB 6.0 Survival w/o ice — mph (km/hr) 100(161) 30D' 60, Offset pattern_-_dB __9.0 Survival with .5' (12.7 mm) radial ice $ Maximum power input - watts 500 mph (km/hr) 74(119) Vertical beamwidth (half power points) 160 Overall length (150-174 MHz) 270--. . - _.. --- - in. (mm) 255(fy,77) g� Decoupling between antennas 1. Shipping length - in. trnm) 148(3759) (split models) - dB 35 minimum -- Lightning protection Direct ground Net weight (wiclamps) - lbs. (kg) 32(14.51) Shipping weight (wiclamps) _ ___ Standard Termination: Capnve Type N-Male - lbs. (kg) 48(21.77) --• attached to end of a flexible lead. Other fittings can be supplied on special order. •kp rnoumet antenna wine•aa,;-s,eatq increase[when 2'"�;BCoi .. . - -- - antenna is sroe Toumec . . 06224E- elements pointed away 'rom the tower Gain and bandwidth are reduced m;ne 120!5:.M•1;bane NOTE The rnechan,ca saecan,a:.,ns are aep•aaK to,the amenna spmal cut for 12D138 Mn:band cmnng the 124150 Mm.man[ I c�Ei. 5T. .� 0 DAL �!S TX , ; ;610 • ­Jt�E 1214) 631•i:_ '71 0 DIRECTIONAL ANTENNA 101 10 dB GAIN, 33.174 MHz A 6-element array, the DB286 consists 7"��'-­­ of two 3-element Yagis spaced one-half wavelength apart and fed in phase through a cable transformer. It mounts to the top or side of a tower and provides 10 dB gain over a narrow horizontal pattern. The 150 MHz model, if side mounted, must clear the tower by 2' (606.9-mm) or more. No field 4 tuning is required: the DB286 is W_0A assembled and adjusted for minimum VSWR at the factory. Higher Gain Two antennas can be stacked for 13 dB gain, and four antennas can be stacked "A for 16 dB gain. A vertical spacing of .75 Is to 1.0 wavelengths between antennas 000.�_ ff U .4 a recommended. Larger antennas are supplied with heavy duty orientation brackets, and the size and wall thickness is increased on the Electrical D21a larger models. 118-174 MHz Frequency Ranges- MHz 33-50, 66-88, Ordering Information Angle mount 118-15Q 150-174 Please specify frequency (and i Bandwidth- MHz 2 to I VSWR termination it non-standard). Order Al 35 MHz 1.2 -40-88 DB286 for 10 dB gain, DB286-2 fora MHz T-mount Al 50 MHz 1.7 2-antenna array with 13 dB gain, the 30-40 MHz Y-mount Al 74 MHz 2.5 DB286-4 for a 4-antenna array with 16 Al 160 MHz 6.5 op DB286 Bandwidth- MHz 1.5 to 1 VSWR 1 dB gain -bolts and clamps 33 300 Al 35 MHz 05 Included Brackets, V DB28&2 are in ded to fit round members up to 5 DB2864 Al 50 MHz 1.0 3" (76.2 mm) 00 and angle members 3 X 74 MHz .00 600 up to 2ff (50.8 mm). Other size clamps Al 160 MHz 4.0 are available on special order. .10 Nominal impedance- ohms 50 270P Maximum midband gain 9op (over haft-wave dipole) - dB 10 Maximum power input- watts 5W Horizontal bearnwidth (half power) 24 1 1200 Front to back ratio- dB I Lightning protection Direct ground I Standard Termination: Captive Type N-Male 21 150P attached to end of flexible lead. other fittings DB286 horizontal radiation pattern. are available on special order. 7 35 Mhz Range 50 Mhz Range 74 Mhz Range 160 Mhz Range Materials: Cross boom (aluminum) - in. (mm) 2(50S)x3(76.2) 2(50.8)x3(76.2) 2(50.8)x2(50.8) 1.5(38.1)x2(502) with .125(3.18)wall with .125(3.18) *211 with .125(3.18) wall with .078(1.98) wall Support booms (2) (aluminum) - in. (mm) 2(50.8)x3(76.2) 2(50.8)x3(76.2) 1.5(38.1)x2(50.8) 1.5(38.1)x2(502) with .125(3.18)wall with .125(3.18) wall with .078(1.98) v%211 with .078(1.98) wall Elements (aluminum) - in. (mm) .75(19.05) dia. to- .75(19.05) dia. to .75(19.05) dia. with .75(19.05) dia. with l(25.4)dia. 1(25.4) dia .875(22.23) dia. sockets .975(22.23) dia. sockets Bracket- in. (mm) Y-mount type, T-mount type, T-mounl type, Aluminum angle welded Gal. steel, 2(50.8) Do Gal. steel, 2(50.8)OD Gal. steel, 2(50.8) OD to cross boom Mounting clamps Galvanized steel Galvanized steel Galvanized steel Stainless steel Maximum exposed area (flat plate equivalent) - 112 (m� 8.76(.814) 4.99(.464) 3.41 (.317) 1.5(.139) Wind rating: Survival without ice - mph (krrVhr) 110(177) over 125(201) over 125(201) over 125(201) Survival with Y (12-7 mm) radial ice - mph (krrVhr) 75(120.75) 100(161) over 125(201) over 125(201) Lateral thrust at 1D0 mph (161 krtVhr) - lbs. (kg) 340(154.22) 2D0(90.72) 1 k(61.69) 60(27.22) Height (vertical) - ft. (m) 14(4.Z7) 10(3.05) 7(2-13) 3(.91) Width (horizontal) - ft. (m) 14(4:27) 10(105) 7(2.13) 4(1.22) Depth (horizontal) - ft. (m) 12(3.66) 8(244) 6(1.93) 3(.91) Net weight (w/ClamDS. brackets) - lbs. (kg) 125(56.7) 82(3719) 41 (18.6) 17(7.71) Shipping weight (wlClamDS, brackets) - lbs. (kg) 175(79.38) 115(52-16) 52(23.59) 32(14.51) -31 0 L L 21 r w "M DIRECTIONAL14ur ANTENNA F. - ? - -- 8 dB GAIN, 450-470 MHz A light duty Yagi, the DB432 antenna is made for 450-470 MHz and is excellent j for control or point-to-point communica � � ai lions. It is also well suited for tem- porary _ r r� C ¢� v. or portable use. rq,,F6, r•,-{_ All components used in the support boom and elements are made of high • • : strength aluminum alloys, mounting _ -- -- - -•- -- bracket and'hardware components of galvanized or stainless steel. ;+ F'}} t' �" '`S '� - •• c A unique mounting arrangement permits s rapid azimuth orientation. Each antenna Is assembled and checked .:;-<,;:;_q.-. _ _ s:;. - . •..�n _ for minimum VSWR at the factory. No 41 field pruning or adjustment is required. .a Lightning protection is provided by _'f direct ground. cermg in!�rmcllon t� _ r p 4 Please specify exact frequency or range. -_ .� T"` �_`s?.lt$ "y ,vim MIN Order the DB432 8 dB gain Yagi for ! ::�' 450-470 MHz. Mounting clamp Is in- DB432 8 dB Gain Antenna_ � i eluded. Azimuth Pattern _ 00 - ------- ---- -- CieCGiLaI Join 330° 15 300 uen Fre Ranges 10 Frequency ges — MHz i D9432 450-4701. 300° _Oae� Boo Bandwidth— MHz 20 5; VSWR 1.5 to 1 or less .\\ 10 i �l- Nominal impedance_— ohms _ __50_ I 1 Forward gain (over halt-wave dipole) — dB 8 ! 2700 I 900 Polarization _ z Vertical i Maximum power input — watts 100 Lightning protection _ _ Direct ground !� t i Standard Termination Captive Type N-Female I 2100 1 1500 a 180° Materials: Support boom Aluminum Elements Aluminum Mounting brackets Galvanized steel Maximum exposed area (flat plate_equivalent) — hz(m2) 52(.048) Dimensions (HxL) — in. (mm) 36(914.4)x14(355.6) Net weight — lbs. (kg) 5(2.27) Shipping weight— lbs. (kg) 8(3.63) 31 ; DIRECTION YAGI ANTENNAS ` , s:v-1 806-960 MHz . DA The DB492 and DB493 are light-duty, - 806-866 MHz antennas that are excellent for control or point-to-point communica- tions. They are also well suited for tem- DB492ti, porary or portable use. upht-duty li The DB498 for 806-866, 824-896 and 1aoi I I 896-960 MHz is a heavy-duty antenna (1 f for permanent installation. All aluminum :. parts are gold anodized and a radome covers the radiator to prevent corrosion ' and ice build-up. It will withstand winds to 150 mph (241 km/hr). All components used in the support boom and elements are made of high : , strength aluminum alloys, with mounting DB44a bold bracket and hardware components of Aeodhad Antenna y _ �`� galvanized or stainless steel. ,s � � A unique mounting arrangement permits, rapid azimuth orientation. Each antenna is assembled and checked for minimum VSWR at the factory. No DB493 11 field pruning or adjustment is required. uoh4uw_ i• f: �� Ordering Information Please specify exact frequency r range. p fy q cY o age. CAN BE SHIPPED UPS. i Order DB492 8 d6 gain or DB493 6 dB I gain for light-duty. Order DB498 9 dB gain heavy-duty for permanent installa- antennas and one 14498/9-2 phasing Superflexible cable, N-Male and TNC- tions. Dual model DB498 is also harness. Mounting clamps are included. Male connectors, are optional. Order available by ordering two DB498 A 15' (4.57 m) HELIAXQ 1/4" (6.35 mm) D611881-15. DB492 B dB Gain, Horizontal DB493 6 dB Gain, Horizontal 08498 9 dB Gain, Horizonal 0° 0° 0° 330° 15 30° 330° 15 ! 30° 330° 1 15 / 300 � 10� \ � 10�, �15 I 300° , '.Oee_ ., •� 600 30 600 300° \ ',Ode II 600 1 t�'0 , 270° i 900 270° - I 90° 270° 11 190° 11 240° i t i 1200 240° 7 : ' `� 120° 2400 ; 1200 2100 180°' 1500 2100 1 1800 1500 2100 180° ; \ 150° Frequency Ranges — MHz Materials: DB492, DB493 A = B06-866,.K = 920-960 Support boom Aluminum DB498 A = 806-866, C = 824-895, K = 896.960 Elements Aluminum -- - -—-- - - Mounting brackets Galvanized steel Bandwidth- MHz Same as above VSWR 1.5 to 1 or less Dimensions (HxQ — in. (mm) Nominal impedance — Ohms 50 DB492 7.5(190.5)x25.5(647.7) -------p---- - - - ----- DB493 7.5(190.5)x13(330.2) Forward gain (over half-wave dipole) — dB DB498 .7.5(190.5)x25.5(647.7) D8492 8 Net weight — lbs. (kg) DB493 6 DB492 3.5(1.59) DB498 9 DB493 .7(.32) Polarization Vertical DB498 5(2.27) Maximum power input — watts 1D0 - Shipping weight — lbs. (kg) i Lightning protection Direct ground DB492 6(2.72) DB493 3(1.36) r Standard Termination Captive Type N-Female DB498 8(363) 3103 C'. EC ji. - - - j :: 33 CORN P-ECTOR ANTENNA • i 9 dBd GAIN, 806-960 MHz With a solid metal reflector, the D6495 — is an exceptionally strong antenna that provides 9 dBd forward gain. a front to back ratio of 25 dB. and a 64. 65 or 40 MHz bandwidth in the 806-960 MHz range. It mounts to the top or side of a lower, and no field adjustment is required. For additional gain, two antennas can be :`�;. stacked for 12 dBd gain. Coverage can a be broadened by fanning the antennas apart; however, forward gain will be _ - ' reduced somewhat. 3 J If desired, two DB495 antennas can be mounted on opposite sides of a tower for a bidirectional pattern with a 9 dBd gain in each direction. Contact the factory for details. r. The DB495 is made of high-strength aluminum alloys, the mounting hardware ��. of stainless steel. The radiating element f. is a uniquely designed center fed dipole DB495 Corner that gives maximum protection from R'RefleelOr AntennaWith its broad bandwidth, the antenna gives optimum performance in single or multi-frequency systems. 00 00 330° 15 ' 300 330° 15 1 300 Please specify exact frequency or range. 10 10 —----- --- - -- 5 5 �• 300° oae! Boo 300° :Oae 1 600 9 d8d 1 ea DB495 Antenna -5 -5 2 ea DD495 Antena i10 110 12 dBd 1 ea 14495-2 Dual Harness 270' I I 90° 270° ( ; I 900 The 11653 mounting hardware is includ- ed to fit round .members up to 3" (76.2 mm) OD angle members up to 2" (50.8 °t� mrn). Other size clamps can be ordered f 1 , 240° i 1 � 120° �jl`�,�� 1200 separately, see page 87 and 88. � 2400 2100 \ 1500 2100 ! 00 1500 1800 18 D8495 Vertical (elevation) radiation pattern DB495 Horizontal (azimuth) radiation pattern Mecha^ical Dz«, I Materials: Reflector support booms (aluminum) - in. (mm) 1(25.4)OD with .083(2.108)wall i Reflector Aluminum 1 Radiating element boom (aluminum) - in. (mm) 1 (25.4) diameter with .083(2.108)wall Radiating element Aluminum Frequency Ranges - MHz A=806.870, B=670-935, C=920.960 Mounting bracket Aluminum I Bandwidth - MHz same as above Mounting clamps Stainless steel V-bolts -area -----_. ..-_ - - - -- - Nominal impedance - ohms 50 _ Maximum exposed area (flat plate equivalent) -ttz (rrtz) 2.35(.218) �,R p 1.5 to 1 or less Lateral thrust at 100 mph (161 km/hr) - lbs. (kg) 95(43.09) ------..- --------------- -Wind rating --- --- ---- Forward gain (over half-wave dipole) - dB 9 Survival without ice- mph (km/hr) 10O(161) Polarization Vertical Survival with 1.5• (38.1 mm) radial ice - mph (km/hr) 85(t3n Maximum power input - watts 150 _- Dimensions: -- - Azimuth beamwidth of single DB495 (half power) 400 Height - in. (mm) 12(304 8) Elevation beamwidth of single DB495 (halt power) 600 ----- - - Maximum width - in. (mm) 18(457.2) Front to back ratio - dB 25 Maximum depth (front to back) - in. (mm) 14(355.6) Lightning protection _ Direct ground Net weight- lbs. (kg) 10(4 54) Standard Termination: Captive Type N-Mate attached to end of flexible lead. _Ship !n weight_- lbs. (kg)—__ 14 6( 35) Other fittings are available on special order. 34 s . ._. _.__;u DALLAS CYLINDRICAL ARABOLIC ANTENNA 11.4 dBd GAIN, 942-960 MHz A vertically polarized antenna, the DB496 �M' P 7 u pJf rovides 11.4 dBd gain and an 18 MHz 'Kt µ.= bandwidth to cover the 942-960 MHz ��� range. It meets or exceeds FCC requirements for beamwidth and minor _ = � ��.. lobe degradation (Part 94, Category B). w ��-+_- The DB496 mounts to the top or side -r de of a tower. Especially ruggged, it resists - ft i.;t, `4 Q.Zfta winds to 125 mph 201 km/hr and it is weatherproof. _ .iv -, � _ Two of these antennas can be stacked for a gain of 14 dBd. -� A double dipole directional radiator is enclosed by an ABS radome, which minimizes changes in VSWR, even �� ;r•,.. under severe icing. The unique design ..A of the feed gives maximum protection } .Y from moisture. '-� DB496 L�rilndrlrat r=3 � s Pamboflc Afatanrra The frame of the cylindrical parabolic reflector is made of high strength - aluminum alloys, the screen of expanded flat metal, and contact points �\��� 330° 05 30° between frame and screen are riveted for maximum strength. Mounting „P I hardware is made of stainless steel. 5 Gain and VSWR are essentially flat �V'C` �`-7 300° -1o�B-1 ;,, \ 600 across the bandwidth, which assures optimum performance for the antenna ; �� z;5 , i10 in single or multi-frequency systems. 270° I 1190, i Ordering Information \ I� Please specify frequency or range. Gain 0-der 11.4 dBd 1 ea DB496-A An ten na 2a0� ;� ' �� �. 1200 I 2 ea DB496-A Antenna f t 14 dBd 1 ea 14496-2-A Dual Harness 2100 180, 1. 1500 Included are V-bolts and straps to fit Horizontal radiation pattern of DB496 (vertical round members up to 3" (76.2 mm) polarization) showing power gain with respect OD, angle members to 2" (50.8 mm). to an isotropic radiator (0 dB level). Other size clamps can be ordered separately, see page 87 and 88. CAN BE SHIPPED UPS. 'R-�`_- Data Materials: Radome Molded ABS resin 1 i Reflector frame (aluminum) - in. (mm) .625(15.88) 8 .75(19.05) dia. --- with .058(1.47) wall Reflector screen stamped, flat sheet aluminum Frequency—Range - MHz 942.960 Radiating element (aluminum) - in. (mm) .375(9.53) solid rod Bandwidth - MHz 18 Radiating element boom (aluminum) - in. (mm) 1 (25.4) dia. with .083(2.11) wall VSWR 1.5 to 1 or less Mounting bracket (aluminum) Welded Nominal impedance - ohms 50 Mounting clamps Stainless steel V-bolts with Forward gain galvanized cross straps Over isotropic - dBi 13.5 Maximum exposed area (flat plate equivalent) - ttz (mz) 1.30(.121) Over halt-wave dipole.- dBd 11.4 Lateral thrust at 100 mph (161 km;hr) - lbs. (kg) 52(23.59) Polarization Vertical - - h'arimum power input - watts 100 Wind rating: Survival without ice - mph (km.'hr) 125(201) Vertical beamwidth (half power) 440 Survival with Y (12 7 mm) radial ice - mph (km.!hr) 85(137) Horizontal.beamwidth (pall power) t90 Dimensions: Minor lobe levels (minimum) - aB -15 Height - in. (mm) 13.5(342.9) From to back ratio - dB 20 Maximum width - in. (mm) 42(1,066.8) Lightning protection Direct ground Maximum depth (front to back) - in. (mm) 17(431.8) standard Terrmnation Captive Type h-r.Aale attached to end of flexible lead. Net weight - lbs (kg) 9(4.08) Other fittings are avaean;e on specia. order Shipping weight - lbs. (kg) 15(6.80) . 5"), 105°IECTIONAL ANTENNA .- . � 3 . x sr ii 10 dBd GAIN, 820-900 MHz - - - -- IMPROVED for AMPS cellular stations, - Wltlioptlonal ttR bracket M " -= ` - —- this antenna r g '1[eterina T DB5086P and DB5D60 Pipe Mount o provides gain of 10 dBd in a 105 horizontal radiation pattern. =:; - s , ,,•:r It mounts to AMPS-style monopole platforms. Model DB834R-F is also available for - "a ... pipe-to-pipe mounting, if the optional mounting kit, DB5080, is ordered. This ; ,� �;,�- _, ,. ..:.;•- -_{ permits the antenna to be mounted to specific towers, poles and other structures. ' The DB834R-F antenna uses a special 1 phasing of four radiating e;ements to provide the required 820-900 MHz frequency bandwidth and the specified . horizontal and vertical radiation patterns. . :.., The eight-rod backscreen is made of high strength 6061 T6 welded aluminum- to-aluminum to minimize corrosion and unwanted signals. Radiators are made of silver plated 12 Gain-dBd vs. Frequency-MHz VM va. Frequency-MHz brass and are fed via a high quality, 2.0 low-loss semi-rigid cable harness. s :1 The one-piece radome is molded of high 1.5 I impact plastic and offered in DB Horizon 6 BlueT" color. The radome and a 3 moisture resistant gasket are secured to 800 840 880 920 960 Boo B40 B80 920 960 an integral aluminum alloy plate with non-magnetic stainless steel hardware. i Each antenna is tested for power rating DB834R-F Vertical Pattern DB634R-F Horizontal Pattern compliance and the absence of 00 intermodulation generators. +60° 330° 115 300 �-- Order DB834R-F for AMPS-style o 0 5G , platforms. For pipe mounting order 300 _od _ + d 600 DB5080 Pipe Mount Kit. VAPOR- , i/`�30 �. 5 WRAPE and jumper are included. Order DB834RF-F for EIA flange, non- pressurized. Order DB834RP-F for --10 5 Oda 5 ' 15 0° 2700 ; .900 pressurized. _ CAN BE SHIPPED UPS. ~ —300 i- i -� 1200 HELIAX is a registered trademark or Andrew Corporation. � VAPOR-WRAP is a registered trademark o'Decider Products �`—_- —600 2100 1800 \ 1500 Materials: Radome High Impact molded plastic Reflector screen Alodined 6061 T6 Radiators Silver plated brass Frequency Range — fAHz 820.900 Support pipe 6061•T6 Gain — dBd 10±1 Mounting clamps Galvanized steel vswR 1.5 to 1 or better Maximum exposed area (flat plate equivalent) — tt= (m') 2.35(219) Beamwidth "E' Plane inall Dover) 185640 Lateral inrust at 100 mph (161 km/hr) — lbs. (kg) 80(3629) Beamwiotri H• Plane rnan Do-ve:i 1050±50 Front to Inc.. ratio — c? 25+2 Dimensions iHW.'x(D) — in (min) 42(1.066.8)x205(.520 7)x7 0778) Maximum Dower input — ...... 525 rJet , 4R — iDs. (:gl D8634R•F 19(8.62) Nominal ;^Defiance — on^s - 50 DB5080 5(2.27) Lightning D'0tec,ion Direct ground Shlpping wei;nt — Ibs (kg) Terminat;cn N.FVnI-A (fixed) DB834R-F 21 19.53) HELIAX :.er r, r'.,,e;N Male DB5080 10(a 53) f - 75 SERIEW DIRECTIONAL PANEL ANTENNAS, 890-960 MHz I-) ­--ol These 1-foot, 3-foot and 6-fool tall panel Ordering Information DB886H45/60-YY 6401 antennas for 890-960 MHz have passed See the table for model numbers and (1829 mm) antenna certification tests for the European specifications to suit your requirements. GSM System. Specify 7-16 DIN connectors or N-type They offer superior VSWR ratings with connectors. A clamp set is included for Rx better than 1.5 to 1 and Tx better mounting to 1.5"(38.1 mm)to 3"(76.2 mm) than 1.2 to 1. Front-to-back ratios are pipes. Platform mounting kits_and greater than 23. 26 or 28 dB. Maximum brackets for mechanical downtilt are DB883H45160-YY Pool power input is 500 watts. optional. See page 88 and contact (915 mm) antenna Horizontal beamwidths are available in Decibel's marketing staff. 450 and 600 models with gains from 7 to 16 dBd. See table for vertical 8B—H60-X Standard N Type beamwidths, detailed gains and other 88—H60E-X Flange specifications. 88—H60E-X 7-16 DIN Electrical downtilt of up to 90 is 88—H60D-X Dual = 2x884 in available on request for the 883 and an 8 ft. radome 886 models. Change 60 to 45 Design and Construction for 450 horizontal beamwidth. Electrically and mechanically these antennas offer the best trade-off between small size vs. windloading and high front-to-back ratios. Each antenna is tested for power rating compliance and the absence of intermodulation generators. D88811144"60-7 The panels measure 5 inches (127 mm) 14001 (305 mritj deep and 12 inches (305 mm) wide. antennas Radomes are made of light gray fiberglass that is weather and UV resistant. Radiation elements are of silver-plated brass and the back panel of alloclined aluminum alloy. Vertical Patterns The antenna feed is copper hardline, mounting clamps are galvanized steel, and fasteners are stainless steel. All metal parts are•gounded for lightning protection. *NOTE: Based on winds of 100 mph (161 km/hr). 3C' 30' Horizontal Patterns Specifications DB881H45E-YY DB883H45E-YY 0a86)5.9 5 E_Y Y Gain — dBd/dBi 8.5/10.6 13/15.1 16/18.1 .3 Horizontal beamwidth 450 450 450 vertical beamwidth +30 600 210 90 JOCK -20 ert Front-to-back ratio— dB >26 >28 >28 a .X Maximum exposed area — ft2 (MI) 1.04(095) 3.08(.285) 6.17(.572) Z 7t-- Lateral thrust — lbs. (kg)* Side 10(4.55) 42(19.09) 90(40.91) Front 47(21.36) 138(62 73) 275(125) Dimensions (WxHxD) — in. (mm) 12(305)x12(305ix5("Z) 12(305)x36(915)x5(127) 12(305lx72 0829)x5(127) Net weight — lbs. (kg) 4(1.8) 11 (5.0) 20(9-0)' Snipping Weight — lbs. (kg) 9(4.1) 17(7.7) 29(13.1) V E Y Gain — dBd/dBi 7.2/9.3 12/14.1 Horizontal beamwidth 600 600 600 Vertical beamwidth +30 600 210 9° Froni-io-back ratio — dB >23 >28 >28 Maximum exoosed area — ft2 (M2) 1 04(.09;zi 3.08(285) 617(.572) inrusi — lbs. (kg)' Side 10(4.55t 42(19.09) 90(40911 Front 47(21.35i. 138(62-73) 275(125) Dimensions (WxHxD) — in. (mm) 12(305?x,.2(305))<5 n27) 12(305)x36 t915)x5(127) 12(305)x712(t629)x5(12-1) Net weight — lbs. (kg) 4(18) 11 (50) 20(90) Shipping weight — IbS (kg) 9(40) 17(7 29 113 11 7 -;1�4 CLESE�­ 5T P0. BOX CALLAS TX 753'5E-C1610 PHONE ('141) Register .z O Colluiltmity News - r-_ _. __ ... .._.. .•.. ...,.... — .. .. . - _., ....... ...... .-.._. .. 1 !'lease see W.n STE,'2 New owner has high hopes for-former KYMS radio tower , By Gus Santoyo The new owner,Daniel Brimlow of Ana- shape." Dan McNames tried to buy the tower from Mary scrapped?" McNames asked. "It's I The Orange County Register helm,said he wants to rebuild it as a com- LDL but couldn't come up with the money historic.It's a piece of Orange County his- munications tower for government use or Department of Transportation officials in such a short time. McNames,a geolo- tort'. 1 du not want to see the io+cer 1 SANTA ANA — For 35 years, the old cellular hones somewhere on a piece of bought the tower frotn KYMS because it p p gist and classical music enthusiast from scrapped." i KYMS radio tower—a 320-foot-high steel land he owns near Pacific Coast Highway was in the right of wa;�of the 1-5 expansion_ Anaheim, has an agreement with a San ine r behemoth — weathered lightning bolts, in Huntington Brach. Caltrans gave the toner to LDL Enty a Diego radio station to broadcast into Brimlow said he has no intention of ' smog and rain as it overlooked the often ing, the demolition contractor, Brimlow Orange County. scrapping the toter. clogged Santa Ana (1.5) Freeway. Brimlow,who helps run a family-owned offered crane service-in exchange for the Now,the historic relic sits disassembled salvage business in Orange, said radio tower,but wound up paying cash;he won't McNames fears that Brimlow might "A lot of people are looking for commu in a pile of large hanks and loose bolts at a buffs and ham operators have besieged say how much. junk the tower altogether."Why would nications towers.- he said. "This one is Huntington Beach storage yard•the victim him with offers for the tower. somebody want to cut up a 1928 Roadster? real valuable since all the major moun- of the 1-5 expansion. "It's a nice totter. It's in real good Before the deal with Brimlow was made, Why would somebody want the Queen taimops are filled up.I'm going to keep it. mountain Valley school board- Seniors pack gets incumbent, newcomer �. _ r w ,R. By Hector Castro free clinic for Y Th.fl.onne Rnunfv goniclar �-.� ._._. ..-. _�.. ..�, .. 8��.. ��.....�.�.. we.+: .. - Ow• ...,-:Sic�tn ATTACHMENT NO. 10 ALTERNATIVE FINDINGS FOR DENIAL CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION (VARIANCE) NO. 92-47/ CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-44 FINDINGS FOR DENIAL - CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION (VARIANCE) NO. 92-47: 1. Since the subject property can be fully developed with other industrial uses, such a conditional exception for a communication tower is not necessary for the preservation and enjoyment of substantial property rights . 2 . Granting of Conditional Exception (Variance) No. 92-47 for a 310 foot high communication tower would constitute a special privilege inconsistent with limitations upon properties in the vicinity. The subject property was legally subdivided and developed in a manner consistent with applicable zoning laws . 3 . Exceptional circumstances do not apply that deprive the subject property of privileges enjoyed by other properties in the same zone classifications . FINDINGS FOR DENIAL - CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-44 : 1. The proposed 310 foot high commercial tower will not be compatible with adjacent properties/uses because the tower may create adverse visual impacts due to the substantial height increase. 2 . The establishment, maintenance and operation of the communications tower will be detrimental to the general welfare of persons working or residing in the vicinity and detrimental to the value of the property and improvements in the neighborhood. -3 . The granting of Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44 for a 310 foot high communications tower will adversely affect the General Plan of the City of Huntington Beach, in particular, the Scenic Highways Element . (7455d-8) Southern California Edison Company 7333 BOLSA AVENUE WESTMINSTER.CALIFORNIA 92683 JERRY J. DOMINGUEZ - TeLEPHoNE MANAGER.HUNTINGTON BEACH (714)895-=71 December 7. 1993 Plannina Commission City ofyHuntinaton Beach 2000 Main St. Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Dear Planning Commissioner: Re: Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44 Dan Brimlow, 8541 Edison Ave. In regards to the above referenced matter, the following information is submitted: 1 . It is requested that as a condition of any approval, the property owner be required to provide insurance in the amount of $6 million naming Southern California Edison as additional insured; also, to, advise us on any renewal or cancellation of said policy. This is requested given a scenario were the tower to fall down in a southerly direction. A fuel oil tank is located approximately 100 feet south of Mr. Brimlow's property. The tank at full capacity holds 200,000 Bls. of low sulphur petroleum with a value of about $3.4 million. The tank itself plus any resultant cleanup is estimated at about $2.5 million. In addition, there could also be a risk of fire since the FAA would require electrical power for safety lighting. 2. Mr. -Brimlow has indicated the transmission signals would be in the less than 1000 watt range. However, it has been my experience that even this "low" frequency operation would require that each individual frequency be checked and "lined out" if currently in existing use by Edison or other local users of communication frequencies. 3. Althouch the structure should be clear of our 220,000 volt transmission facilities to the east, it could impact any number of 12,000 volt distribution lines should the tower come down. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Jerry Dominguez DEC 0 7 'G� 12':4 � E 'JP LLE`Y ih Y • P t=�_ �oe V News i%edls Ale Ue i M 193�-5c% Nocerdod ustlnp of wsas+s u►d I4"f16 N � NEWxz szz.000a F$DF-RAL COMMUNICATIONS CO MMISSICN .t919 M STASET, N.W. WASHINGTON, D.C. 20SS4 ^.�•� .'"v^0•,.�y, 1^wpy^c1•^f^ O+zo.n IS,p^aCI.Qn DlY.„01,n, ,It lost p+ a[Orw.w.U,p^01ast ,.^•�• v es o+a se •o^ Ses wC eC: 5,$ F 20 QED•O C _••t sr;+ peport No, DC- - AC::CN ;ti JGCR=. CASS XebruB. > 12 , i987 C ?=A::3 FCC-RZZ;Ul A 7 rD SLZV:CLS Z-Cl_v�cD 7 01M RF % Ai:CN =7ALZ 7-6CN; Ry ltAD?A;:vN CvA.rVAilON OF Sul? ri+,Z:'r' AND .r.AR STA::ONS PROP S'aD (GPN, DOa7T ,5-144) h Commission has ca:egoricai:y excluded certain F:C-regula ed =ac "- ivies and services from rad :o;requency (RF) radiation. evaluation. also proposed amending ?arr 80 of the :u-es to provide rote:tion for humans from pocenrially hazardous R7 radiation generated by s ip earth and radar stations . :he Corx�ission noted that the vast majority of 'rCC-regulare services would be excluded from routine RF radiation evaluation because ill iv ideally or cumulatively they do not have a significant effect on :he "q tlicy` of the human environment." The American National Standards IA ritute RF safety guidelines are used to measure excessive XF radiation ex sure to humans. Proposed , facilities and services a2L excluded from "nF adiation evaluation include: experimental broadcast stations (Part 5) , sate litre cot.- munications facilities (Part 25) , radio and television broadcast - stations (Part 7:) , experimental and developmental broadcast stations Parr 74, Subpart A) , and low power :elevision stations (Part 74, Subpart C) . -The FCC pointed out there •was no evidence of excessive RF adiation exposure during routine and normal, operation of land-mobile ind fired communications services , including cellular radio, microwave point6to-point radio, and most auxiliary broadcast services. Therefore, applications for facilities licensed under Parts 21 22, '23 , 90, 94 , and other appropriate Parts of the rules are not require to rou- rinely submit environmental information Concerning exposure to U r d ation. In - ittplementing the National Environmental Policy Act regardin potent- ially hazardous RP radiation from FCC-regulated services , :he FCC proposed two amendments to Part 80 for ship earth and marine radar stations. The first would require that ship earth and marine radar stations be properly installed and safely operated by complying with the RF safety gu ;delines. The second would require that manufacturers of transmitters for sh p earth and marine radar stations provide each unit with RF exposure guide ines for installation and operation. It noted the proposed amendments ould be admiaist:atively more feasible than requiring separate environmental anal- ysia of every application fer a ship earth or radar station. (over) �f .rd►t 7 � s December 7, 1993 Eileen Pinder Orange County Humane Society 21632 Newland Street Huntington Beach, CA 92646 .(714) 536-8480 Chairman City of Huntington Beach Planning Division Dear Sir: We at the Orange County Humane Society oppose the approval of Conditional Exception 92-47, Conditional Use Permit 92-44, and Negative Declaration 92-40 as they are presently proposed. Several concerns must be addressed before the proposed project is allowed to proceed. Structural Integrity: -The tower structure was built in 1928. -Said structure will have been dismantled and moved three times if approved. -Previous locations were adjacent to a freeway and near the ocean in Santa Barbara. -The previous owner, KYMS Radio, did on several occasions make emergency repairs caused by corrosion to secure the upper dipole portion of the tower. -No records of maintenance or inspection exist. The previous owners performed no inspections for the five years preceding its sale. The above conditions have subjected the proposed structure to the deleterious effects of corrosion and fatigue. The Orange County Humane Society suggests the Department require a substantial engineering inspection of the entire structure to assess the effects of corrosion and fatigue over its 65 year life span. Additionally, the design application of the proposed structure is to support a single dipole broadcast antenna. The significantly larger frontal area of cellular and microwave antennas will result in much greater aerodynamic pressures resulting form wind. At the very least, a detailed wind loads structural study is an absolute necessity to assure the public safety. A failure of such a large structure in proximity to 220kv powerlines could spell disaster. C. cington Beach ie City Qlerk t:-,.'r• .. / c • it r J [ 3ox190 ii each, CA-R2648 James R. Bohlke 21851 Newland St . Trlr 274 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 APN: 890-892-74 NGTpy 8-OHLi<E MOVED T NO O FORWARD Y ca LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING RETURN TO SENDER III„,II„,►,Il,1ii,,lt„1lI.,,!l,,,II,,,,,►IlII„,il,,,il,,,l tington Beach -- _ - ie City Clerk '-r J yrs 3ox 190 :n ?s r �= Z7 each,CA 92648 j,�_:fy; r:• q :1. C`` L i11 Thomas L. Gorzynski NGTpti 21851 Newland St . Trlr 220 " rFo 6 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7635 APN: 890-892-20 y GORZZ851 9264b41 u_16 1H92 i 1 21-8/9'-$ FORWARDING 'TIME :r.--.t—D C GOR YNSKIe T HOMA 24734 ZANTA i-L 1909.►"�P`��o RAMO A CA 92065-4 SENDERTY LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING RETURN TO1111„LG„�,li„11„11„,Il„�l1,►,IL,►►„Ifii,,,li,,,ll,►►I ;kway,City Clerk „ ntington Beach the City Clerk `- . Box 190 Beach,CA 92648 -a Michael Twomey 21851 Newland St . Trlr 130 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 fINGTp�, APN: 890-891-30 o9vo90 BF TWOM 51# 92646400f3 1193 �=51: FORWARDING TIME E•P IREb g TWO BEY = 8162 22ND ST 17, 1999►'� coQ WEST-MINSTER CA 92683-324.6 NTY CPS\ RETURN T❑ SENDER LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 111 11 1! 11 11 It 11 It 1111 11 11 1 1 1 Away,City Clerk ,-itington Beach the City Clerk . V -.... .._ ..,i -.._.._.... ?;�� C `•. ='• Box 190 .•., -r __ i ;�7 _. Beach,CA 92648 Aldine M. Hankle r 21851 Newland St. Trlr 32 HNGTpy Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 3RPOR4r �F APN: 890-890-32 FORW"-RDTNG TIME ir,'PISRED •�- -�- Q HANkLE Q 4572 HAZELNUT AVE 1909.a SEAL BEACH C#•t' 9+0 40-29i8 vTv ca LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING RETURN TO SENDER III,+,III,,,,II,III oil I,,,11„It1,,,II,,,IA8 III Its III IIIII,II Ickway,City Clerk mtington Beach ,.-..._ .._....::.._ - o� �;. �,•_,_.- _ - the City Clerk N_._.. .�..,.. �< \` �= _- �L . �. Box 190 : y. j C __ '+ ., ' !r Beach,CA 92648 Curtis Carl Davidson 21851 Newland St . Trlr 94 OP' f , Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 �RPORA"OR��FO FF9 _ .APN: 890-890-94- .r D�i'•:+.T'ii'iA 92iCl�a 1=�y2 +�7..''28:'9'! FORWARDING TIME EXPIRED DAVIS = � Q 9282 COM TOC K DR 1909.'���\�(O HUNTING T ON BEACH CA 92b'+b-5924 vTv LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING RETURN TO SENDER lIII,ItIIIIIII{„1I,ItIIIIIIII{i„IIl,I„I,IIIi,,,III„Il,,,t f' may,City Clerk _ tington Beach -ie City Clerk _ .I 3ox 190 each,CA 92648 1:qn X. - gaiga i ► E - nd St . Trlr 73 VGT Bh CA 92646-7621 4 0-73 R,fFO _ y LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 1I+I++++I+I+III++i++I+III fit I+I+II++++I+I+,+It+I+I++++II+.,III e uiry uierK--— -- --- —-- ---- --- - _- - -- -- :ach CA 92648 ' - 3 _rZ August E. Cor 21851 Newland St . Trlr 49 JGj Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 )R4rF - APN: 890-890-49 _ y +"t�rc-$51 92�t'tEs'!>.i�iL 1293 01:"2L::?'s CDR a Q MOVED LEFT NO t DDRE== 1JN`AeLE TO FORWARD Y �a` LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING RETURN TO SENDER 111„.il,+++ 119111„11,19il+till$I1111tiM1lll+„IlI„II$$it Scott Davis 21851 Newland St . Trlr 122 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 _ VGTpy� APN: 890-891-22 y C ;+:i cS11 g2b4b40 0b 1992 +a1:'28%S'-;• �5!�1At�:C+ItN+= TIME EXPIRED _Ap Q DAV 1,. ^_ g 9282 CCIMST00e OR _o Q Ht�NTIN•NOPTON EEACH CA 92646-592'•� I909.•.��``o RETURN TO SENDER ntington Beach the City Clerk •Box-190it � ` Beach, CA 92648 James R. Bohlke 21851 Newland St . Trlr 274 Huntington $h CA 92646-7638 APN: 890-892-74 NGTpy ,AMAATF BF _ y MOVED LEFT NO ADDRESS S �7,1909• �\�( UNABLE TO F ORNI ,RD NTY CP LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING RETURN TO SENDER III„,It,,,t,}!„II„It„t!} „}}t„it,,,,,,llti,,,ll.,tll,,,l intington Beach _ .. . _ -_. __y ..-,...:•-r_..� �.: ';;' ^�... _ _ - f the City Clerk ', ). Box 190 'd :,1L7 w Beach,CA 92648 Thomas L. Gorzynski TINGTpy 21851 Newland St . Trlr 220 CORPORA., d�. - Huntington Bh CA 92646-7635 APN: 890-892-20 - y Ga Pi851 92b%40 0 e- .1.:=z _ 24734 ZANT i PL �„ 1909�° ���Q Rs MONA CA 920 6 �NTY CP LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING RETURN TO SENDER Itl,,,lt„t„!i„!t„!I„,its,,!!t„II,,,,,,IIlI9„Ii,,,llt&J ockway,City C7terk _ untington Beach f the City Clerk j`_ - 0. Box 190 §'' 1,4N 27 „ -" n Beach,CA 92648 ,j 1 Michael Twomey 21851 Newland St . Trlr 130 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 ING APN: 890-891-30 �NTTpy d� `NCORPORATFQ A Ti 11M8S1W 92L%400i' 1193 FORWARDIP•>O TIME EXPIRED TWOMEY 81E32 c 2NO ST _s.6 1909.f� WESTMINSTER CA 92r 383--324b SUNTY CPS\ RETURN TO .ENDER LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING tit 11 if 11 ,t it t, 11 ckway,City Clerk untington Beach f the City Clerk Box 190 Beach,CA 92648 := �� 5 5 Aldine M. Hankle 21851 Newland St . Trlr 32 TINGTp�, Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 C9RPOg4IF �Fq APN: 890-890-32 HAi•fi•�A S 92646�}t_E�j3 � �a� l3_:'c�::91+ F OR g H A N K LE Q 4572 HAZELNUT AVE SEAL BEACH CA 90740-29 ^8 NTY �a� LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING RETURN TO SENDER {(G,1ti111,11111g111i9911,>< ll,9,IIIP9„IIU91{,1911, 11 ockway,City Clerk untington Beach f the C Clerk - _•�_.. ... . ,_.._,..._, , ,c i �•. � r;'=_�;:�'l'.` �.>�. O. Box 19017 n Beach,CA 92648 Curtis Carl Davidson 21851 Newland St . Trlr 94 TINGTpy Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 (,9RPOR41 dFq - APN: 890-890-94 DAVIS FORWARDING TIME EXPIRED 9282 COM TOCK Can - ��` HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92b46-5924. �NTY CP LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING RETURN TO SENDER {its,JI11,111{1111,1I1111111I11111 fill toll 1111111811#16111111 w ckway,City Clerk ntingtonBeach /'�:c;°;� _ _ f the City Clerk Box 190 Beach,CA 92648 Sherry F agaiga •f7i�; ;,,,� `�.- Y - 21 51 wland St . Trlr 73 -�: 1;:a• `~ 4 TINGT Hu t ' gton Bh CA 92646-7621 py AP -890-73 RRPORq fF �/ °` y Z NTY Ca LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING 1111,l„I,I,II.„I„11II„1,,PIlII,,,,I,I„,II,I,i,,,,ll,,,lll the city cierK-------- --- ---------—-- - -- --- -------� -- -- --� - -_ -- - Box 190 Beach, CA 92648 ! ' August E. Cor 21851 Newland St . Trlr 49 TINGT Huntington Bh CA .92646-7628 ORPORq rF��dF APN: 8 9 0-8 9 0-4 9 - - -. s �:t7R-851 g?646u►3�tb 1293 01.?8.1"9! . C-0R Q MOVED LEFT NO ADDRESS UNAeLE TO FORWARD RETURN TO SENDER NTY Ca LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING III„► IMItI!„ii,,11,,,U,,,11,,,1I,,,,,III II,,,II,,,Ii,,,1 Scott Davis 21851 Newland St . Trlr 122 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 _ iINGTpy�F APN: 890-891-22 &ORPORgIfO 19 is 01/28%9'f FOr"t'jARCtlNG TIME EXPIRED IZC CIA 9282 CClMSTOCK DR H►NTIt•NrTON EEACH CA 92646- 92'. >:;7'ISO%.P RETURN TO SENDER .4 Approved by City Admi*ration • COVER SHEET FOR CITY COUNCIL PUBLIC HEARINGS N/A YES NO ( ) Was City Council or Planning Commission public hearing notice typed on Wang? ( ) ( ) If appeal, are appellant and applicant shown on legal notice? ( ) ( ) If housing is involved, is "legal challenge paragraph" included? ( ) ( ) If Coastal Development Permit, are the RESIDENT labels attached and is the Coastal Commission Office on the labels? Is !*!! 6 verification letter attached? ( ) ( ) Were the latest Assessor's Parcel Rolls used? ( ) ( ) ( ) Is the appellant's name and address part of the labels? ( ) Is day of public hearing correct - Monday/Tuesday? ( ) Has the City Administrator's Office authorized the public hearing to be set? ( ) ( ) Is there an Environmental Status to be approved by Council. ( ) ( ) Are the appellant/applicant's names and addresses on mailing labels? "ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit to the City Clerk written evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions please, call (insert name of Planner) at 536-5227." For Public Hearings at the City Council level Please insert the above paragraph of the public hearing notice: CONNIE BROCKWAY, CITY CLERK CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET - 2ND FLOOR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA 92648 (714) 536-5227 1350K - 9/93 • i , : i 1 • i 4 1 f CERTIFICATION OF PROPERTY OWNERSHIP LIST THE ATTACHED LIST REPRESENTS THE NAMES AND ADDRESSES OF ALL PROPERTY OWNERS LOCATED WITHIN 1,000 FEET OF THE EXTERIOR BOUNDARIES OF THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 8541 Edison Avenue, Huntington Beach, CA 92646. THIS INFORMATION WAS OBTAINED FROM THE LATEST Orange County Assessment Rolls December 1, 1993. SUSAN PIERCE ASSOCIATE PLANNER C:\splpl68 (C) 1993 TRW REDI Property Data No. Grid Owner Name Address Price (K) Date APN Number Use 1 30-D1 MILLS LAND & 148-011-06 430 2 30-Dl MILLS LAND & 148-011-07 430 3 30-Dl LINDSAY CHARL 8622 HATTERAS $7U 07/76 148-071-28 163 4 30-Dl LEE TERESA JE 8572 SANDY H00 07/89 148-081-01 163 5 30-D1 HOLCOMB KELLY 8562 SANDY H00 $240F 04/9 148-081-02 163 6 30-Dl JEPSEN LESLIE 8552 SANDY HOO $36F 08/73 148-081-03 163 7 30-Dl FUGET MARION 8542 SANDY H00 $249F 03/93 148-081-04 163 8 30-Dl COWGER THOMAS 8532 SANDY HOO $6U 09/68 148-081-05 163 9 30-Dl NIEMANN JAMES 8522 SANDY H00 $142F 06/85 148-081-06 163 10 30-Dl LEWIS WAYNE A 8512 SANDY H00 $80F 03/77 148-081-07 163 11 30-Dl AYERS LAWRENC 8502 SANDY HOO 07/92 148-081-08 163 12 30-Dl BOYER GAY A 21441 ANTIGUA 05/87 148-081-09 163 13 30-Dl HILL JOHN F 21431 ANTIGUA $46F 04/75 148-081-10 163 14 30-Dl GASTEIGER ROG 21421 ANTIGUA 12/91 148-081-11 163 15 30-D1 KELLEY KATHY 21431 SEAFORTH $255V 08/91 148-086-15 163 16 30-Dl ELLISON DOLOR 21441 SEAFORTH 10/87 148-086-16 163 17 30-D1 DICKENS JOANN 8561 SANDY H00 06/92 148-086-17 163 18 30-D1 BUMATAY ANDRE 8551 SANDY H00 $33F 10/72 148-086-18 163 19 30-Dl STACK DONALD 8541 SANDY H00 $5U 02/69 148-086-19 163 20 30-Dl WELLS STEVEN 8531 SANDY H00 03/90 148-086-20 163 21 30-Dl BUTLER VIRGIL 8521 SANDY H00 $100P 08/90 148-086-21 163 22 30-Dl SELNA MICHAEL 8522 MILNE DRI $245F 01/91 148-086-22 163 23 30-Dl DANGOTT MICHA 8532 MILNE DRI 08/89 148-086-23 163 24 30-Dl HOUSEMAN PHIL 8542 MILNE DRI $284F 01/91 148-086-24 163 25 30-Dl LOPEZ REYNALD 8552 MILNE DRI $39P 01/79 148-086-25 163 26 30-Dl APODACA REFUG 8562 MILNE DRI $80F 05/77 148-086-26 163 27 30-Dl KAPLAN BERNAR 21502 NEWLAND $165C 04/88 148-121-01 364 28 30-D1 TARNUTZER BYR 8570 HAMILTON 02/74 148-121-03 336 29 30-Dl CITY OF HUNTI 148-121-04 420 30 30-Dl ORANGE COUNTY 11/80 148-121-15 415 31 30-Dl ORANGE COUNTY 148-121-16 415 32 30-Dl CITY OF HUNTI 8641 EDISON AV 148-121-17 300 33 30-Dl LENIHAN THOMA $250F 12/80 148-121-18 364 34 30-Dl SANDGREN PAUL 8551 EDISON AV 04/91 148-121-19 420 35 30-Dl SANDGREN PAUL 8551 EDISON AV 04/91 148-121-20 208 36 30-D1 BRIMLOW KEN 8541 EDISON AV 11/76 148-121-21 420 37 30-Dl NASRE NABIL 8521 EDISON AV 07/87 148-121-22 244 38 30-Dl NASRE NABIL 21632 NEWLAND $58F 07/84 148-121-23 163 39 30-D1 ORANGE COUNTY 148-121-24 415 40 30-Dl C-040 projeC,+ IISiW as 9-:59-V {! — l9) 148-121-25 321 41 30-Dl PETERSEN DONA 21541 SURVEYOR $279F 11/83 939-48-001 112 42 30-Dl BARON ROBERT 21531 SURVEYOR $367F 11/90 939-48-002 112 43 30-Dl STUART GARY 21521 SURVEYOR $260F 12/81 939-48-003 112 44 30-Dl THE SCHUHRKE 21571 SURVEYOR 05/82 939-48-004 112 45 30-Dl FEHER DONALD 21561 SURVEYOR $390F 06/87 939-48-005 321 46 30-Dl BRAR HARNEK S 21591 SURVEYOR 12/91 939-48-006 321 47 30-Dl BRAR HARNEK S 21581 SURVEYOR 12/91 939-48-007 321 48 30-D1 BOUCHER RAYMO 21611 SURVEYOR $362F 07/82 939-48-008 112 49 30-Dl MIORELLI EMIL 21601 SURVEYOR 01/87 939-48-009 112 50 30-Dl YEH NING 21522 SURVEYOR $357F 05/89 939-48-010 112 --- ---------- -- ---------------------------------- - ---- ------ >> Reported data believed to be reliable but accuracy is not guaranteed << City of Huntington Beach (C) 1993 TRW REDI Property Data No. Grid Owner Name Address Price (K) Date APN Number Use 51 30-Dl SCHNUERER GER 21532 SURVEYOR $300F 12/90 939-48-011 112 52 30-Dl KRAUS GENE 21542 SURVEYOR 03/89 939-48-012 112 53 30-Dl HILL DOUGLAS 21562 SURVEYOR $230P 07/87 939-48-013 321 54 30-Dl A-MED HEALTH 21572 SURVEYOR $460F 06/89 939-48-014 321 55 30-Dl MINKOFF DONAL 21582 SURVEYOR $78P 10/86 939-48-015 112 56 30-Dl PAYLEFF INTER 21592 SURVEYOR $69P 12/86 939-48-016 321 57 30-Dl PEARCH HOWARD 21602 SURVEYOR 11/87 939-48-017 321 58 30-Dl WALTERS WILLI 21612 SURVEYOR $115P 07/86 939-48-018 112 59 30-Dl GRODACH CARL 21622 SURVEYOR $82P 05/85 939-48-019 321 ------------------------------------------------------------ >> Reported data believed to be reliable but accuracy is not guaranteed << City .of Huntington Beach 60 Dan Brimlow 31188 Water Avenue Nuevo, CA 92567 61 Paul Risse Southern Calif. Edison 21730 Newland St. Huntington Beach 92646 62 Southern Calif. Edison 2244 Walnut Grove Rosemead, CA 63 Land of Pliny 8541 Edison Avenue Huntington Beach, CA 92648 (C) 1993 TRW REDI Property Pata P Y No. Grid Owner Name Address Price (K) Date APN Number Use 1 30-D2 MILLS LAND & 21851 NEWLAND 114-150-72 136 . 2 GIBBARD ROSS 21851 NEWLAND O1/90 890-890-04 400 3 GAMBERT DAVID 21851 NEWLAND 02/87 890-890-05 400 4 KOTYLUK ROBER 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-11 400 5 OLMSTEAD DAWN 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-12 400 6 IMADA KENJI 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-14 400 7 LOPEZ SEBASTI 21851 NEWLAND 12/92 890-890-16 135 8 MC CUTCHEON B 21851 NEWLAND 05/90 890-890-17 400 9 PECK TIMOTHY 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-18 400 10 CARLSON JEFFR 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-21 400 11 ADKINS JO ELL 21851 NEWLAND 02/85 890-890-24 400 12 HIRANO JOHN S 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-26 400 13 DIMENT NICK 21851 NEWLAND 02/88 890-890-27 400 14 REYES TIMOTHY 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-29 400 15 GARCIA SYLVIA 21851 NEWLAND 05/92 890-890-30 400 16 MINNS PATRICK 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-31 400 17 HANKLE ALDINE 21851 NEWLAND 02/85 890-890-32 400 18 CLIFFORD RUSS 21851 NEWLAND 02/91 890-890-33 400 19 MARQUEZ RODOL 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-34 400 20 LUNT BRIAN 21851 NEWLAND 02/88 890-890-44 400 21 KROTZ CARYL M 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-45 400 22 ELLIOTT JUDIT 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-46 400 23 TRUDEAU ROBER 21851 NEWLAND 09/91 890-890-48 400 24 COR AUGUST E 21851 NEWLAND 05/89 890-890-49 400 25 EBER MICHAEL 21851 NEWLAND 02/88 890-890-50 400 26 RUSSELL DAVID 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-51 400 27 MC CLOUD R BE 21851 NEWLAND 02/90 890-890-58 400 28 BRAVENER LEE 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-63 400 29 SCHUMACHER WI 21851 NEWLAND 04/89 890-890-64 400 30 SEPHTON ROBER 21851 NEWLAND 02/93 890-890-65 400 31 OPPE JANET 21851 NEWLAND 02/90 890-890-67 400 32 TENAY LORI 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-69 400 33 UMBAUGH LINDA 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-70 400 34 FESAGAIGA SHE 21851 NEWLAND 07/92 890-890=73 400 35 PITTMAN JACK 21851 NEWLAND 02/86 890-890-76 400 36 BAILEY JOEL A 21851 NEWLAND 09/91 890-890-77 400 37 THORNTON THOM 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-79 400 38 TYE PAMELA 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-81 400 39 SCHROEDER JOH 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-84 400 40 DIEMER ROBERT 21851 NEWLAND 10/88 890=890-89 400 41 STUEVE ROBERT 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-91 400 42 MORROW PAUL 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-92 400 43 BORNTREGER RI 21851 NEWLAND 02/85 890-890-93 400 44 DAVIDSON CURT 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-94 400 45 JOHNSON MARLY 21851 NEWLAND 02/85 890-890-97 400 46 MC CLELLAND R 21851 NEWLAND 11/89 890-890-99 400 47 DIONNE KENNET 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-02 137 48 HULSE MICHAEL 21851 NEWLAND 02/86 890-891-03 137 49 MARKS JANE 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-07 137 50 HALLINAN TIMO 21851 NEWLAND 10/91 890-891-09 137 ------------------------------------------------------------ >> Reported data believed to be reliable but accuracy is not guaranteed << City of Huntington Beach (C) 1993 TRW REDI Property Data No. Grid Owner Name Address Price (K) Date APN Number Use 51 SIMPSON ALBER 21851 NEWLAND 09/91 890-891-10 137 52 JURA RALPH G 21851 NEWLAND 02/84 890-891-12 137 53 PETERSEN CHER 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-14 137 54 MOSS KENNETH 21851 NEWLAND 11/92 890-891-15 137 55 BOSTON MARVIN 21851 NEWLAND 12/92 890-891-16 137 56 CAVER JAMES L 21851 NEWLAND 02/88 890-891-18 137 57 CHIACULAS CLA 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-21 137 58 DAVIS SCOTT 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-22 137 59 MALLARD ELEAN 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-26 137 60 KOSCIELSKI RO 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-28 137 61 TWOMEY MICHAE 21851 NEWLAND 11/89 890-891-30 137 62 TOWNSEND LISL 21851 NEWLAND 02/84 890-891-31 137 63 GIBBS NIGEL 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-35 137 64 HALL DENNIS W 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-37 137 65 TUEY SHAWN 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-38 137 66 WELLS PATRICI 21851 NEWLAND 10/90 890-891-40 137 67 SEAL JOHN J 21851 NEWLAND 02/83 890-891-42 137 68 WINE LYNETTE 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-43 137 69 SCHNEELOCH RI 21851 NEWLAND 02/88 890-891-44 137 70 KLEMANTOVICH 21851 NEWLAND 07/91 890-891-47 137 71 HALLMAN CLARE 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-48 137 72 COOK DEREK 21851 NEWLAND 06/92 890-891-59 137 73 FAISON DAVID 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-63 137 74 WEINSTEIN SPE 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-65 137 75 DOCHTERMAN WE 21851 NEWLAND O1/93 890-891-67 137 76 BERES KENNETH 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-68 137 77 JENSEN LOIS A 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-69 137 78 SULLIVAN STEP 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-70 137 79 HARRY LEE J 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-71 137 80 HUNTER MARGIE 21851 NEWLAND 02/87 890-891-76 137 81 DORSI MICHAEL 21851 NEWLAND 07/92 890-891-81 137 82 KELLY THOMAS 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-83 137 83 PORCH RICHARD 21851 NEWLAND 02/84 890-891-90 131 84 WEBSTER THEOD 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-91 137 85 MORTON WILLIA 21851 NEWLAND 05/91 890-891-92 137 86 ZAMORA RUDY T 21851 NEWLAND 02/87 890-891-96 137 87 SMITH LONNIE 21851 NEWLAND 02/86 890-891-97 137 88 FOGEL ED 21851 NEWLAND 10/90 890-892-02 137 89 RICHARD GILBE 21851 NEWLAND 07/92 890-892-03 137 90 MYNAR THOMAS 21851 NEWLAND 02/92 890-892-05 137 91 UNDERWOOD WAR 21851 NEWLAND 02/87 890-892-06 137 92 SCHULTZ JAMES 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-09 137 93 HAMM ROBERT L 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-12 137 94 SPEZIALE CIND 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-18 137 95 GORZYNSKI THO 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-20 137 96 ALEXANDER KEN 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-21 137 97 BRADLEY FRANK 21851 NEWLAND 02/85 890-892-24 137 98 MCGOWAN KEVIN 21851 NEWLAND 02/86 890-892-27 137 99 FUERST MARNIE 21851 NEWLAND 11/90 890-892-29 137 100 HALE MONTE L 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-33 137 ------------------------------------------------------------ >> Reported data believed to be reliable but accuracy is not guaranteed << City of Huntington Beach (C) 1993 TRW REDI Property Data No. Grid Owner Name Address Price (K) Date APN Number Use 101 RATTRAY WILLI 21851 NEWLAND 08/89 890-892-37 137 102 NELSON WALLAC 21851 NEWLAND 04/90 890-892-42 137 103 FOLKINS DAVID 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-45 137 104 PEIKERT TOM A 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-48 137 105 BAIRD MARTIN 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-49 137 106 CRUM ROBERT A 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-50 137 107 MARTT MERIDEE 21851 NEWLAND 02/86 890-892-51 137 108 BARRERA MARIA 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-54 137 109 WERICK ELAINE 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-55 137 110 HANSON GEORGI 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-56 137 111 VANATTA PATRI 21851 NEWLAND 08/89 890-892-57 137 112 SMALLHASSON D 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-59 137 113 NYE LAWRENCE 21851 NEWLAND 08/90 890-892-61 137 114 YBARRA MARK A 21851 NEWLAND 02/87 890-892-62 137 115 SULLIVAN MART 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-63 137 116 HUNTINGTON BY 21851 NEWLAND 02/88 890-892-68 137 117 NAAKTGEBOREN 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-69 137 118 VANVIANEN RUD 21851 NEWLAND 05/92 890-892-70 137 119 BOHLKE JAMES 21851 NEWLAND 02/88 890-892-74 137 120 PIERCE PATRIC 21851 NEWLAND 11/88 890-892-75 137 121 MC CLELLAND C 21851 NEWLAND 10/90 890-892-77 137 122 CLARK REBECCA 21851 NEWLAND 10/90 890-892-82 137 123 MCGILLION FRE 21851 NEWLAND 02/86 890-892-83 137 124 RETANA MARTHA 21851 NEWLAND 11/89 890-892-87 137 125 CHAPIN JACQUE 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-96 137 126 WOODRIDGE MIC 21851 NEWLAND 890-893-01 137 127 CARSON EILEEN 21851 NEWLAND 11/92 890-893-06 137 128 LAWRENCE BETT 21851 NEWLAND 02/87 890-893-10 137 129 MALONE THOMAS 21851 NEWLAND 02/88 890-893-14 137 130 HUPP WARREN 21851 NEWLAND 02/86 890-899-01 137 131 RADMACHER CUR 21851 NEWLAND 890-899-02 137 132 SCOTT FLOYD 21851 NEWLAND 890-899-03 137 133 AKIN MARY D 21851 NEWLAND 890-899-04 137 134 MILLARD ELEAN 21851 NEWLAND 890-899-05 137 135 CRANK HAROLD 21851 NEWLAND 12/89 890-899-06 137 136 SAYEGH THEODO 21851 NEWLAND 06/91 890-899-07 137 137 SIMPSON MARK 21851 NEWLAND 03/90 890-899-08 137 138 MARTIN MARY 21851 NEWLAND 10/89 890-899-09 137 139 DICK JAMES W 21851 NEWLAND 12/90 890-899-10 137 140 ANTIS ROBERT 21851 NEWLAND 10/90 890-899-11 137 141 ROUSSEAU SCOT 21851 NEWLAND 01/91 890-899-12 137 142 GERDING KENNE 21851 NEWLAND 10/91 890-899-13 137 143 BEAVER JENNIA 21851 NEWLAND 10/91 890-899-14 137 144 PURO JAMES P 21851 NEWLAND 11/91 890-899-15 137 145 CAPUTO ANTHON 21851 NEWLAND 08/91 890-899-16 137 146 MARCH PHILLIP 21851 NEWLAND 09/91 890-899-17 137 147 HOPPER STEVEN 21851 NEWLAND 11/92 890-899-18 137 148 WALLS WILLIAM 21851 NEWLAND 12/92 890-899-19 137 ------------------------------------------------------------ >> Reported data believed to be reliable but accuracy is not guaranteed << City of Huntington Beach Reynaldo L. Lopez Refugio G. Apodaca 8552 Milne Dr. 8562 Milne Dr. Huntington Bh CA 92646-7006 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7006 APN: 148-086-25 APN: 148-086-26 Bernard B. Kaplan Byron M. Tarnutzer P.O. Box 5278 4 Upper Newport Plz Z Huntington Bh CA 92615 Newport Beach CA 92660 APN: 148-121-01 APN: 148-121-03 City f Huntington Beach Count F1 d Control Dist Orange N Add s 92648 �-% No Add ss 3 d APN: 14�8 121-04 APN: 1 -121-15 County Flood Control Dist Orange City of /Huington Beach P.O. Box 7108 3 city H` 31Huntington Beach, CA 92615 Huntingh CA 92646 APN: 148-121-16 , 15 APN: 1 =\21-17 Thomas J. Lenihan Paul B. Sandgren 22021 Hula Cir 3 3 8551 Edison Ave. 31V Huntington Bh CA 92646 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7603 APN: 148-121-18 APN: 148-121-19 Paul B. Sandgren 3 j Ken Brimlow 3 8551 Edison Ave. 652 E. Culver Ave. Huntington Bh CA 92646-7603 Orange CA 92666 APN: 148-121-20 APN: 148-121-21 Nabil Nasre Nabil Nasre 3 21632 Newland St . 377 21632 Newland St . Huntington Bh CA 92646, Huntington Bh CA 92646-7610 APN: 148-121-22 APN: 148-121-23 County F1ood' Control Dist Orange P. 0. Box 7108 39 Huntington Beach, CA 92615 APN: 148-121-24 "P: 1"" 1»--T5- Dan Briraow 31188 Water Avenue too Nuevo, CA 92567 Paul Risse Southern Calif. Edison til 21730 Newland St. Huntington Beach, CA 92646 148-121-05 Southern Calif. Edison 62, 2244 Walnut Grove Rosemead, CA Land of Pliny (03 8541 Edison Avenue Huntington Beach , CA 92648 Donald M. Petersen y/ Robert F. Baron �z 21541 Surveyor Cir 16611 Carousel Lane Huntington Bh CA 92646-7066 Huntington Bh CA 92649 APN: 939-48-001 APN: 939-48-002 Gary Stuart The Schuhrke Family Trust 1<S� 10172 Theseus Dr. �3 21571 Surveyor Cir Huntington Bh CA 92646 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7066 APN: 939-48-003 APN: 939-48-004 Donald J. Feher Harnek S. Brar 6 2051 Orizaba Ave . No. 10 19502 Woodlands Lane Signal Hill CA 90804 Huntington Bh CA 92648 APN: ' 939-48-005 APN: 939-48-006 Harnek S . Brar Raymond P. Boucher 19502 Woodlands Lane u 7 21611 Surveyor Cir Huntington Bh CA 92648 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7015 APN: 939-48-007 APN: 939-48-008 Emil P. Miorelli9 Ning Yeh �p 9871 Hot Springs Dr. 21522 Surveyor Cir Huntington Bh CA 92646 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7067 APN: 939-48-009 APN: 939-48-010 Gerhard M. Schnuerer 1 Gene Kraus 5 z 6406 W. Ocean Front 6502 W. Ocean Front Newport Beach CA 92663 Newport Beach CA 92663 APN: 939-48-011 APN: 939-48-012 Douglas Andrew Hill ,53 A-Med Health Care Center $ 21181 Hillsdale Lane 21572 Surveyor Cir Huntington Bh CA 92646 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7067 APN: 939-48-013 APN: 939-48-014 Donald E. Minkoff 55-1- Payleff International Corp .SL 1903 Yacht Enchantress 6161 Arrowroot Lane Newport Beach CA 92660 Rncho Pls Vrd CA 90274 APN: 939-48-015 APN: 939-48-016 Howard C. Pearch '7 William C. Walters S f P.O. Box 1437 21612 Surveyor Cir No. 8B Costa Mesa CA 92628 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7068 APN: 939-48-017 APN: 939-48-018, Carl W. Grodach .51 Villa At Huntington Beach Associ 117 Via Dijon 19752 cA ur Blvd. No. 240 Newport Beach CA 92663 Irvine 92715 APN: 939-48-019 APN: 9- 8-025 Villas t untington Beach Associ Villas t untington Beach Associ 19752 Ma rthur Blvd. No. 240 19752 Ma rthur Blvd. No. 240 Irvine C �92715 Irvine CA 92715 APN: 939-48-026 APN: 939-48-027 Gary leacher Villa`' 'A Huntington Beach Associ 8304 A -anta Ave . No. 104 19752 McArthur Blvd. No. 240 Huntingt n Beach CA 92646-6101 Irvine CA 92715 APN: 939-48-028 APN: 939-48-029 Anthony Caputo Phillip March 21851Newlandst No. 113 21851Newlandst No. 215 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7629 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7635 APN: 890-899-16 APN: 890-899-17 Steven R. Hopper William H. Walls 21851Newlandst No. 204 21851Newlandst No. 95 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 9264'6 APN: 890-899-18 APN: 890-899-19 • Craig Mc Clelland Rebecca F. Clark 21851 Newland St . Trlr 277 21851 Newland St . Trlr 282 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 APN: 890-892-77 APN: 890-892-82 Fredrick P. McGillion Martha Retana 21851 Newland St . Trlr 283 21851 Newland St . Trlr 287 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 APN: 890-892-83 APN: 890-892-87 Jacqueline Chapin Michael W. Woodridge 21851 Newland St . Trlr 296 Sam Lord' S Castle St . Philip Barbadc Huntington Bh CA 92646-7639 West Indies APN: 890-892-96 APN: 890-893-01 Eileen T. Carson Betty Lawrence 21851 Newland St . Trlr 306 21851 Newland St . Trlr 310 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7640 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7641 APN: 890-893-06 APN: 890-893-10 Thomas Malone Warren Hupp 21851 Newland St . Trlr 314 21851 Newland St . Trlr 146 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7641 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7630 APN: 890-893-14 APN: 890-899-01 Curt .Radmacher Floyd Scott 21851 Newland St . Trlr 133 21851 Newland St . Trlr 284 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 APN: 890-899-02 APN: 890-899-03 Mary D. Akin Eleanor . Millard 21851 Newland St . Trlr 280 21851 Newland St . Trlr 264 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 APN: 890-899-04 APN: 890-899-05 Harold Crank The B. Sayegh 21851 Newland St . Trlr 28 21851 Newland St . Trlr 265 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7627 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 APN: 890-899-06 APN: 890-899-07 Mark N. Simpson Mary Martin 21851 Newland St . Trlr 303 21851 Newland St . Trlr 15 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7640 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7624 APN: 890-899-08 APN: 890-899-09 James W. Dick Robert Antis 21851 Newland St . Trlr 305 21851 Newland St . Trlr 6 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7640 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7622 APN: 890-899-10 APN: 890-899-11 Scott A. Rousseau Kenneth J. Gerding 21851 Newland St . Trlr 149 21851Newlandst No. 22 . Huntington Bh CA 92646-7630 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7625 APN: 8907899-i2 APN: 890-899-13 Jennian Beaver James P. Puro 21851Newlandst No. 52 21851Newlandst No. 156 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7628 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7631 APN: 890-899-14 APN: 890-899-15 David Faison Spencer Weinstein 21851 Newland St . Trlr 163 21851 Newland St . Trlr 165 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7631 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7631 APN: 890-891-63 APN: 890-891-65 Wesley Dochterman Kenneth Beres 21851Newlandst No. 167 21851 Newland St . Trlr 168 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7632 APN: 890-891-67 APN: 890-891-68 Lois A. Jensen Stephen Sullivan 21851 Newland St . Trlr 169 21851 Newland St . Trlr 170 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7632 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7632 APN: 890-891-69 APN: 890-891-70 Lee J. Harry Margie A. Hunter 1605 E. 15th St . 21851 Newland St . Trlr 176 Santa Ana CA 92701 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7632 APN: 890-891-71 APN: 890-891-76 Michael Joseph Dorsi Thomas Kelly 21851 Newland St . Trlr 181 21851 Newland St . Trlr 183 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7632 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 APN: 890-891-81 APN: 890-891-83 Richard Lee Porch Theodore Webster 21851 Newland St . Trlr 190 21851 Newland St . Trlr 191 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 APN: 890-891-90 APN: 890-891-91 William G. Morton Rudy T. Zamora 21851Newlandst No: 192 21851 Newland St . Trlr 196 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7633 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 APN: 890-891-92 APN: 890-891-96 Lonnie Smith Ed Fogel 21851 Newland St . Trlr 197 21851 Newland St . Trlr 202 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 APN: 890-891-97 APN: 890-892-02 Gilbert H. Richard Thomas J. Mynar 21851Newlandst No. 203 21851Newlandst No. 205 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7633 APN: 890-892-03 APN: 890-892-05 Warren C. Underwood James P. Schultz 21851 Newland St . Trlr 206 21851 Newland St . Trlr 209 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 APN: 890-892-06 APN: 890-892-09 Robert L. Hamm Cindy Speziale 21851 Newland St . Trlr 2i2 21851 Newland St . Trlr 218 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7635 APN: 890-892-12 APN: 890-.892-18 Thomas L. Gorzynski Kenneth Alexander 21851 Newland St . Trlr 220 21851 Newland St . Trlr 221 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7635 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7635 APN: 890-892-20 APN: 890-892-21 0 Frank H. Bradley Kevin McGowan 21851 Newland St . Trlr 224 21851 Newland St . Trlr 227 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7635 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7635 APN: 890-892-24 APN: 890-892-27 Marnie Fuerst Monte L. Hale 21851 Newland St . Trlr 229 21851 Newland St . Trlr 233 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7635 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7636 APN: 890-892-29 APN: 890-892-33 William A. Rattray Wallace Nelson 21851 Newland St . Trlr 237 21851 Newland St . Trlr 242 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7636 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7636 APN: 890-892-37 APN: 890-892-42 David Folkins - Tom A. Peikert 21851 Newland St . Trlr 245 21851 Newland St . Trlr 248 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7636 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 APN: 890-892-45 APN: 890-892-48 Martin Baird Robert A. Crum 21851 Newland St . Trlr 249 21851 Newland St . Trlr 250 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 APN: 890-892-49 APN: 890-892-50 Meridee Martt Maria Elena Barrera 21851 Newland St . Trlr 251 21851 Newland St . Trlr 254 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 APN: 890-892-51 - APN: 890-892-54 Elaine M. Werick Georgia W. Hanson 21851 Newland St . Trlr 255 21851 Newland St . Trlr 256 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 APN: 890-892-55 APN: 890-892-56 Patricia Kay Vanatta Debi Smallhasson 1464 Withers Ave . 21851 Newland St . Trlr 259 Monterey CA 93940 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 APN: 890-892-57 APN: 890-892-59 Lawrence R. Nye YBARRA Mark A 21851 Newland St . Trlr 261 21851 Newland St . Trlr 262 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 APN: 890-892-61 APN: 890-892-62 Marta Sullivan Huntington By The Sea 21851 Newland St . Trlr 263 21851 Newland St . Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 APN: 890-892-63 APN: 890-892-68 Mark A. Naaktgeboren Rudolf Vanvianen 21851 Newland St . Trlr 269 21851 Newland St . Trlr 270 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 APN: 890-892-69 APN: 890-892-70 James R. Bohlke Patricia J. Pierce 21851 Newland St . Trlr 274 21851 Newland St . .Trlr 275 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 APN: 890-892-74 APN: 890-892-75 Jane Marks Timothy J. Hallinan 16400 Pacific Coast HWY No. 222 21851Newlandst No. 109 Huntington Bh CA 92649 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7629 APN: 890-891-07 APN: 890-891-09 Albert R. Simpson Ralph G. (Or) Jura 21851Newlandst No. 110 21851 Newland No. 112 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7629 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7629 APN: 890-891-10 APN: 890-891-12 Cheryl L. Petersen Kenneth E. Moss 21851 Newland St . Trlr 114 21851Newlandst No. 115 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 Huntington Beach CA 92646 APN: 890-891-14 APN: 890-891-15 Marvin Boston James L. Caver 21851 Newland St . Trlr 116 21851 Newland St . Trlr 118 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 APN: 890-891-16 APN: 890-891-18 Claude A. Chiaculas Scott Davis 21851 Newland St . Trlr 121 21851 Newland St . Trlr 122 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 APN: 890-891-21 APN: 890-891-22 Eleanor Mallard Robert Koscielski 31544 Mayhew Lane 21851 Newland St . Trlr 128 Menifee CA 92584 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 APN: 890-891-26 - APN: 890-891-28 Michael Twomey Lisle Stephen (Or) Townsend 21851 Newland St . Trlr 130 21851 Newland St . Trlr 131 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 APN: 890-891-30 APN: 890-891-31 Michael T. Eber David A. Russell 21851 Newland St . Trlr 50 21851 Newland St . Trlr 51 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 APN: 890-890-50 APN: 890-890-51 R. Benson Mc Cloud Lee C. Bravener 21851 Newland St . Trlr 58 21851 Newland St . Trlr 63 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA. 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-58 APN: 890-890-63 William J. Schumacher Robert L. Sephton 21851 Newland St . Trlr 64 21851 Newland St . Trlr 65 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-64 APN: 890-890-65 Janet Oppe Lori Tenay 21851 Newland St . Trlr 67 21851 Newland St . Trlr 69 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-67 APN: 890-890-69 Linda Umbaugh Sherry Fesagaiga 21851 Newland St . Trlr 70 21851 Newland St . Trlr 73 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-70 APN: 890-890-73 Jack L. Pittman Joel A. Bailey 21851 Newland St . Trlr 76 21851 Newland St . Trlr 77 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-76 APN: 890-890-77 Thomas R.' Thornton Pamela Tye 21851 Newland St . Trlr 79 21851 Newland St . Trlr 81 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-79 APN: 890-890-81 John H. Schroeder Robert Diemer 21851 Newland St . Trlr 84 • 21851 Newland St . Trlr 89 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-84 APN: 890-890-89 Robert Stueve Paul Morrow 21851 Newland St . Trlr 91 21851 Newland St . Trlr 92 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-91 APN: 890-890-92 Richard W. Borntreger Curtis Carl Davidson 21851 Newland St . Trlr 93 21851 Newland St . Trlr 94 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-93 APN: 890-890-94 Marlys T. Johnson Rodney Mc Clelland 21851 Newland St . Trlr 97 21851 Newland St . Trlr 99 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-97 APN: 890-890-99 Kenneth Dionne Michael W. Hulse 21851 Newland St . Trlr 102 21851 Newland St . Trlr 103 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 APN: 890-891-02 APN: 890-891-03 Mills Land & Water Co Ross J. Gibbard P.O. Box 7108 21851 Newland St . Trlr 4 Huntington Bh CA 92615 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7622 APN: 114-150-72 APN: 890-890-04 David Gambert Robert Kotyluk 21851 Newland St . Trlr 5 21851 Newland St . Trlr 11 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7622 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7623 APN: 890-890-05 APN: 890-890-11 Dawn Olmstead Kenji Imada 21851 Newland St . Trlr 12 21851 Newland St . Trlr 14 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7623 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7623 APN: 890-890-12 APN: 890-890-14 Sebastian Lopez Bill C. Mc Cutcheon 21851Newlandst No. 16 21851 Newland St . Trlr 17 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7624 APN: 890-890-16 APN: 890-890-17 Timothy A. Peck Jeffrey M. Carlson 21851 Newland St . Trlr 18 21851 Newland St . Trlr 21 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7624 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7625 APN: 890-890-18 APN: 890-890-21 Jo Ella Adkins John S. Hirano 21851 Newland St . Trlr 24 15629 Mindru A Huntington Bh CA 92646-7626 Huntington Beach CA 92647 APN: 890-890-24 APN: 890-890-26 Nick Diment Timothy C. Reyes 21851 Newland St. Trlr 27 21851 Newland St . Trlr 29 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7627 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7627 APN: 890-890-27 APN: 890-890-29 Sylvia M. Garcia Patrick J. Minns 21851 Newland St . Trlr 30 21851 Newland St . Trlr 31 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 APN: 890-890-30 APN: 890-890-31 Aldine M. Hankle Russell Clifford 21851 Newland St . Trlr 32 21851 Newland St . Trlr 33 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 APN: 890-890-32 APN: 890-890-33 Rodolfo F. Marquez Brian Lunt 21851 Newland St . Trlr 34 21851 Newland St . Trlr 44 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 APN: 890-890-34 APN: 890-890-44 Caryl M. Krotz Judith Ann Elliott 21851 Newland St . Trlr 45 21851 Newland St . Trlr 46 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 APN: 890-890-45 APN: 890-890-46 Robert Trudeau August E. Cor 21851Newlandst No. 48 21851 Newland St . Trlr 49 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7628 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 APN: 890-890-48 APN: 890-890-49 Mills Land & Water Co Mills Land & Water Co P.O. Box 7108 P.O. Box 7108 Huntington Bh CA 92615 Huntington Bh CA 92615 APN: 148-011-06 APN: 148-011-07 Charles L. Lindsay Teresa Jean Lee 8622 Hatteras Dr. ?j 21901 Kiowa Lane Huntington Bh CA 92646-7024 Huntington Bh CA 92646 APN: 148-071-28 APN: 148-081-01 Kelly Holcomb Leslie L. Jepsen (o 8562 Sandy Hook Dr. 8552 Sandy Hook Dr. Huntington Bh CA 92646-7017 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7017 APN: 148-081-02 APN: 148-081-03 Marion M. Fuget Thomas M. Cowger $ 8542 Sandy Hook Dr. 7 8532 Sandy Hook Dr. Huntington Bh CA 92646-7017 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7017 APN: 148-081-04 APN: 148-081-05 James C. Niemann Wayne A. Lewis /D 8522 Sandy Hook Dr. 8512 Sandy Hook Dr. Huntington Bh CA 92646-7017 9 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7017 APN: 148-081-06 APN: 148-081-07 Lawrence H. Ayers Gay A. Boyer 1 y 8502 Sandy Hook Dr. 21441 Antigua Lane Huntington Bh CA 92646-7017 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7014 APN: 148-081-08 APN: 148-081-09 John F. Hill Roger L. Gasteiger /Y 21431 Antigua Lane 21421 Antigua Lane Huntington Bh CA 92646-7014 /7, Huntington Bh CA 92646-7014 APN: 148-081-10 APN: 148-081-11 Kathy Kelley Dolores J. Ellison 21431 Seaforth Lane 21441 Seaforth Lane Huntington Bh CA 92646-7042 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7042 APN: 148-086-15 APN: 148-086-16 Joann M. Dickens Andrew J. Bumatay �$ 8561 Sandy Hook Dr. 8551 Sandy Hook Dr. Huntington Bh CA 92646-7016 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7016 APN: 148-086-17 APN: 148-086-18 Donald E. Stack Steven B. Wells zC� 8541 Sandy Hook Dr. 8531 Sandy .Hook Dr. Huntington Bh CA 92646-7016 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7016 APN: 148-086-19 APN: 148-086-20 Virgil J. Butler 94 Michael W. Selna -L y 8521 Sandy Hook Dr. 9762 Kite Dr. Huntington Beach CA 92646-7016 Huntington Bh CA 92646 APN: 148-086-21 APN: 148-086-22 Michael O. Dangott Z 3 Phillip Houseman 2-)4 8532 Milne Dr. 8542 Milne Dr. - Huntington Bh CA 92646-7006 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7006 APN: 148-086-23 APN: 148-086-24 Nigel Gibbs Dennis W. Hall 2185;L. Newland St . Trlr 21851 Iceland St . Trlr 137 Huntington Bh CA 92646- 9 Huntinw Bh CA 92646-7629 APN: 890-891-35 APN: 890-891-37 Shawn Tuey Patricia Wells 21851 Newland St . Trlr 138 21851 Newland St . Trlr 140 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7630 APN: 890-891-38 APN: 890-891-40 John J. Seal Lynette Wine 21851 Newland St . Trlr 142 21851 Newland St . Trlr 143 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7630 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7630 APN: 890-891-42 APN: 890-891-43 Richard P. Schneeloch Michael Klemantovich 21851 Newland St . Trlr 144 21851Newlandst No. 147 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7630 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7630 APN: 890-891-44 APN: 890-891-47 Clarence E. Hallman Derek Cook - 21851 Newland St . Trlr 148 21851 Newland St . Trlr 159 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7630 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7631 APN: 890-891-48 APN: 890-891-59 Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 {' Huntington Beach,CA 92648 Aldine M. Hankle 21851 Newland St . Trlr 32 INGTpy Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 =NLORPOR4)F dF APN: 890-890-32 FL I,l:fr;RL�3h4 t r•iE E -P 4:' G HAN LE 4572 HAZELNUT AVE SEAL E.EACH CA 9f 74f i-291 l3 F cpUN TY CP`\ RETURN TO =Et••IOEF LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Lonnie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach �. Office of the City Clerk _ _,._ �,�aL:Q,., �h P.O. Box 190 3 �'F". s. �` "^r\\ '!-!, Huntington Beach,CA 92648 s� Curtis Carl Davidson TING Tpj, 21851 Newland St . Trlr 94 , Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 O =NLORPON4lF� dF9 APN: 8 9 0-8 9 0-9 4 ZZ _=> _ +'•'+•--ram-.ter. Q •'f l: - �►� -- P=r.!+:aF:Cti[;,�- iTf1E EXPT;iED �9y eZ 0.4VY�S >c `FB 1909.pN o 9282 = Cif i••!�NT?i•31:t'L-N= 'E :;CH CA gab%-592y FcpDNTY Ca LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING RETt i9N TO SENDER U I,I,III„ll11111,IIIIIIIIli„1 nununylvll L,va.,rr, ... „__._ Sherry F agaigaT�c$�� ;f 21 51 wland St . Trlr 73 I,,- �tJTINGTp Hu t gton Bh CA 9264.E-7621 I.d pF�`NLORPOR4)E y�F9 AP -8 9 0-7 3 9.yo oQ ppUNTY CP` LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING f i `t i f ( +r I'III If IIIIIIII fill ll,,'if III i IIIII,I I,iil„IIIJIIII1III„II Office of the City Clerk yG z a 27 `4 9y P.O.Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 • �`,w 43 ;� August E. Cor 21851 Newland St . Trlr 49 INGrpy Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 APN: 890-890-49 O� =NSORPOR�TFO �F� - -- _ y COR-$mil v o CC1R Ni0'•.!EC{ LEFT NO ADDRESS L INAESLE TO F13PWARD 'yC E$77,t909•P \�O RETURN TO SENDER FpUUNTY cam LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING ,„1111,„Il,„ll,. vny vt wi mi i9turi r3eacn Office of the City Clerk :u _;� P.O. Box 190 :yam.: 4�, ;u �4 r. :�7I Huntington Beach,CA 92648ei Scott Davis 21851 Newland St . Trlr 122 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 �pNSINGrp�, O� NSORPORq/fO B�. APN: 890-891-22 ICIR!:IijI-RDIi'•1►_ TIME EXPIRED DAVIS 9282 �• a 1g09 �4 Ht NT";'NGTt"t.N BEACH CA i 92cr4b-'Sqc CpUNTY Ca` RETURN TO SENDER LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING P.O.Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 fp.4 James R. Bohlke 21851 Newland St . Trlr 274 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 APN: 890-892-74 INGrpy y0 =%ORPON4t PF V •.,-:i'i' I i?1=1 CS'�r t r t!-fl�l'` lf� lei BOHLK oQ HOVED LEFT NO ADDRESS 1 s i9p9 UNABLE TO FORWARD cpUN T Y Ca�\� RETURN TO SENDER NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING • Connie Brockway, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach •.-, Office of the City Clerk �+ `F P.O. BOX 190 b s"6 - 7w i Huntington Beach,CA 92648 i Thomas L. Gorzynski INGTp?, 21851 Newland St . Trlr 220 O Nt09VORgrFo BF Huntington Bh CA 92646-7635 =_ qy APN: 890-892-20 w t_ 9'y %EsL 17.1 - pQ 24734 kr•NT i r L. GFcpl1 CP`\�SO RAt1t7�aA '-R T � %�E NTY fi•JC�ER LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING RETURN TO Connie Brockway, City Clerk -- q J;v City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk P.O. Box 190 _ < • " t -' �* Huntington Beach,CA 92648 F„'Y :7 1�" at; 4" `ii "t` Michael Twomey 21851 Newland St . Trlr 130 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 APN: 890-891-30 ���NTINGTpyB Q _NOp9POR47FO F9� FORWARDING ARDING TIME TWOME•Y 9 z 8162 22ND ST Wk=3TM?'N'=T ER CA 92682-324b G' a Q 1909' �\ RETURN TO SENDER F�puNJI �a� LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach �`�'/"t/,/` Office of the City Clerk t `J a., P.O.Box 190 t E c �' Huntington Beach,CA 92648SIL t Stephen Su4ivan - 21851 New and St . TrIxf-170 INGT� Huntington Bh CA 92646-7632 APN: 890 891-70 O SULL851W 92b4b1 231 3,%q2 0810 FORWARDING TIME f=XPIRED o """ SULLIVAN 2420 Ht NTINGTON ST #n HUNT..l NGTON 13EACH +_4'-`s 9Rb48- Wil' CF cUUN TV cP��� _ LEGAL NOTICE PUBLIC HEARING RETURN TO SENDER 111#811„S1111111,Sol 1,1411,,. City Clerk ; Connie Brockway, . ,�;° �• _ s-_ ,..,...� . t� C ton Beach ity of Hunting .•;. ,.;, :, v _ 4 Office of the City Clerk `V• `--�, ¢` '� t' c7 111 \ E 1 P.O.Box 190 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 r` ,< 9 _t. . _ ,.- x �•=?` � (.fic�Ent ,..,,,.: — 93M506 45 '� - �`, r{ 0 ' ti GJV4 Sr M,arc�• G` j Alan H Boyer grT�M �� x y mil` l L: ,�a •:, pr ° cant a �314 Pacific Coasi`Hwy J%, e n untington Beach.,CA 926419 kNol, L NTINGTp J/O—`N�O0.POF4TF0 F9 '� - C:S4:�;.�; i. �, •__.'11�.{ 1 •_ 11-4t.?�.f'+.0 v Al 01P.0,EF. ' Y FI3-WARD 0 'YO cF�DUNTY Cap\ LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING , I�.kd�.�y„ti„t , I�,,,, li„�u„►! v � Jerk ch k tom\ ?648 _ _ I !• :r c 201 Georgia W. Han on 21851 Newland St. Trlr 256 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 APN: 890-892- 6 'Ir{N. {{-I��`..•1 ��•yy!�L7�t101 ►i!Ls �.J.�I�i ►��: INS ,:l !_�. i RGIA MC►:jED LEFT NO i=;DDRE'S UNABLE TO FORWARD RETURN TO SENDER LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING Clerk iach irk - r, t ' • w John S. Hirano: ='�= 15629 Mindru A Huntington Beach CA 92647 a APN: 890-890-26 ` ` .En' . 1 LEGAL NOTICE PUBLIC HEARING 1 Ilrl►►►►I►)►li►r►l►rll►►►lrr7►Il utTice OT me uny uiem !-1 P.O. Box 190 es Huntington Beach,CA 92648 i�� • , 5 IL James L. Caver awl NN . ,a n�1 21851 14A1w St . Trlr 118 Hunting qn-\_�B i CA 92646-7629 , ING APN: NO = 8 "t Rpo q2'r3464006 IN 01/2 RETURN TO SENDER NO 'FORWARD ORDER ON FILE UNABLE TO FORWARD RETURN TO SENDER LEGAL NOTICE PUBLIC HEARING Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Off ice of the City Clerk 'J'A' 'C:' P.O. Box 190 Li')7 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 r ;' - �� T� Robert ielski 21851 Ne and St . Trlr 128 n o Hunt i Bh CA 92646-76Z-9 AAl I N G to., APN: 0-8 1-28 K=r— E3 1 N qmE34'IT RETURN TO NO FORWARD ORDER ON FILE QNASL= TO FORWARD RETURN TO SENDER p�UN T Y % LEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING off 111111SI11,11,111 Office of trie uity L;ierK C i'T ;�1 27 'c:4 P.O. Box 190 Z� Huntington Beach,CA 92648 If- I: l IT Mary D. Akin* 21851 Newland r 2 Huntington ]Bh �2 6-7 INGTpy APN: 890-899-04 ­L-T E3 01/261 5 1 C31 M M.:1&110 Q iN RETURN TO _ENDER NO FORWARD ORDRR ON FILE UNABLE TO FORWARD RETURN TO SENDER cFppUNTYLEGAL NOTICE — PUBLIC HEARING Connie Brockway,City Clerk U.S.ity of Huntington Beach .�........<_�,..,��. ,�•..a�...°rz.w...,.�....,..�-. ,��• t� =:�.�::_. �� F Office of the City Clerk r_ !7 F•S ry "s F, P.O. Box 190 z-3g J. J -94 Huntington Beach,CA 92648Al Cindy Spe iale 21851 e and St . Trlr 218 Hunting n Bh CA 92646-7635 INGTp APN: 89 - 92-18 9 `Fe i ,P O ycF COUNT Y LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING f f ( ` I�J111111�1��,1111111�11111 fill III 11111111t1111111111 11+1111( 111 Connie Brockway,City Clerk - City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk C� P.O. Box 190 4/p` /M� u �To - FQ Huntington Beach,CA 92648 NSA""41 pTF JV Elai 14"Nerickk 21851 Newlaria.St Tr] r, 255 Hunt ingtonk-Bh CA;f92646-763 APN: 890-892-5`hfJ I NGTpy %r O \N(,ORPORq - �, gL'64640 -5 lid :'c! RE T URN T13 SENDER NO FORWARD ORDER ON FILE - t tN`BLE TO Fi75WARD 9 `Fe- OQ RETURN TO :SENDER ycF C�UN T Y LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING r.r r r r-.- S ZL?%�L-%�..�• _O II ISO JIIIsu 1I11IIIII1 111II11III111IIIIJ II 111111111141411111 Connie Brockway,City Clerk City of Huntington Beach Office of the City Clerk `v P.O. Box 190 Huntington Beach,CA 92648 r V 939 504 72 399r ; Keith S & Lois Raffel . INGTpy 711 Ocean Ave#331 f I ` RPD Huntington Beach CA 92648 uNty LEGAL NOTICE - PURLGGffA 1'tltllllt�tl�t U�ttlttt�ttttt�l �!�l11�3}�2.�.�lli!!1ltl�ltl.l�l3911.t.'lil..11 kway,City Clerk itington Beach the City City Clerk Box 190 � v �, 3each,CA 92648 Dennis • Hall 21851 Ne land St . Trlr 137tosrD� HuntingtN- 1 h CA 92646-7629 APN: 890 -37 '� �R I NGTpyA � .9 POR4 rF �F i('3YIL'..:iSi¢.1�7 1G193 {..{1'28,1 91 - EW :,Cc HALL R-ii+:1 I{� 'tii•1'i•ON CA 92678-{554 LEGAL NOTICE - PUBLIC HEARING PUBLIC HEARING CITY COUNCIL AGENDA DATE APPROVAL SUBJECT: COUNCIL MEETING DATE: NUMBER OF HEARINGS ALREADY SCHEDULED: APPROVED: Ray Si er, Assistant City Administrator NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S CONDITIONAL DENIAL OF CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-44,CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 92-47, NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 92-40 (Proposed Communications Tower) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chambers at the Huntington Beach Civic Center,2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach, California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE/TIME: Monday,February 7, 1994, 7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Appeal of Planning Commission's Denial of Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44/ Conditional Exception No. 92-47/Negative Declaration No. 92-40 APPLICANT: Dan Brimlow APPELLANT: Dan Brimlow and Ken Brimlow LOCATION: 8541 Edison Avenue ZONE: M2-0-FP2(Heavy Industrial Combined with Oil with Floodplain Overlay) REQUEST: To "approve in concept" a 310 foot tall communications tower which exceeds the maximum height requirement of 40 feet in an M2 district. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Environmental Assessment No. 92-40 will also be considered by Council. COASTAL STATUS: This project is in a non-certified area of the Coastal Zone and must be ultimately reviewed and approved by the California Coastal Commission. ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Community Development Department, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California 92648, for inspection by the public. A copy of the staff report will be available to interested parties in the City Clerk's office after February 4, 1994. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit to the City Clerk;written evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If you challenge the City Council's action in court,you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at,or prior to,the public hearing. If there are any further questions please call Susan Pierce,Associate Planner, at 536-5271. Connie Brockway City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach,CA 92648 (714) 536-5227 (splp165) i D NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEA APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S CONDITIONAL DENIAL OF CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-44,CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 92-47, NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 92-40 (Proposed Communications Tower) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chambers at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach,California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE/TIME: Monday,February 7, 1994, 7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Appeal of Planning Commission's Denial of Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44/ Conditional Exception No.92-47/Negative Declaration No. 92-40 APPLICANT: Dan Brimlow APPELLANT: Dan Brimlow and Ken Brimlow LOCATION: 8541 Edison Avenue ZONE: M2-0-FP2(Heavy Industrial Combined with Oil with Floodplain Overlay) REQUEST: To "approve in concept" a 310 foot tall communications tower which exceeds the maximum height requirement of 40 feet in an M2 district. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Environmental Assessment No. 92-40 will also be considered by Council. COASTAL STATUS: This project is in a non-certified area of the Coastal Zone and must be ultimately reviewed and approved by the California Coastal Commission. ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Community Development Department, 2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach,California 92648,for inspection by the public. A copy of the staff report will be available to interested parties in the City Clerk's office after February 4, 1994. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit to the City Clerk,written evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If you challenge the City Council's action in court,you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at, or prior to,the public hearing. If there are any further questions please call Susan Pierce,Associate Planner,at 536-5271. Connie Brockway City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach,CA 92648 (714)536-5227 (splp165) Z. Approved by City Administration COVER SHEET FOR CITY COUNCIL PUBLIC HEARINGS N/A YES NO ( ) Was City Council or Planning Commission public hearing notice typed on Wang? ( ) ( ) If appeal, are appellant and applicant shown on legal notice? ( ) ( ) If housing is involved, is "legal challenge paragraph" included? ( ) ( ) If Coastal Development Permit, are the RESIDENT labels attached and is the Coastal Commission Office on the labels? Is y verification letter attached? ( ) ( ) Were the latest Assessor's Parcel Rolls used? ( ) ( ) ( ) Is the appellant's name and address part of the labels? i. ( ) Is day of public hearing correct - Monday/Tuesday? ( ) / Has the City Administrator's Office authorized the public hearing to be set? ( ) ( ) Is there an Environmental Status to be approved by Council. ( ) ( ) Are the appellant/applicant's names and addresses on mailing labels? "ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit to the City Clerk written evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If there are any further questions please, call (insert name of Planner) at 536-5227." For Public Hearings at the City Council level please insert the above paragraph of the public hearing notice: CONNIE BROCKWAY, CITY CLERK CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET - 2ND FLOOR HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA 92648 (714) 536-5227 1350K - 9/93 • • Reynaldo L. Lopez Refugio G. Apodaca 8552 Milne Dr. 8562 Milne Dr. Huntington Bh CA 92646-7006 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7006 APN: 148-086-25 APN: 148-086-26 Bernard B. Kaplan Byron M. Tarnutzer P.O. Box 5278 4 Upper Newport Plz Huntington Bh CA 92615 Newport Beach CA 92660 APN: 148-121-01 APN: 148-121-03 City f Huntington Beach Count F1 d Control Dist Orange N Add s 92648 �-� No Add ss 3 0 APN: 14�8 121-04 APN: 1 -121-15 County Flood Control Dist Orange City Qf Hu tington Beach P.O. Box 7108 3 1 City H` 1 2- Huntington Beach, CA 92615 Hunting --, Bch CA 92646 APN: 148-121-16 , 15 APN: 1 -121-17 Thomas J. Lenihan Paul B. Sandgren 22021 Hula Cir 3 3 8551 Edison Ave . 3 1V Huntington Bh CA 92646 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7603 APN: 148-121-18 APN: 148-121-19 Paul B. Sandgren 3 j Ken Brimlow 3 8551 Edison Ave . 652 E. Culver Ave. Huntington Bh CA 92646-7603 Orange CA 92666 APN: 148-121-20 APN: 148-121-21 Nabil Nasre Nabil Nasre 3 21632 Newland St . 37 21632 Newland St . Huntington Bh CA 92646 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7610 APN: 148-121-22 APN: 148-121-23 County F1ood' Control Dist Orange P. 0. Box 7108 39 Huntington Beach, CA 92615 APN: 148-121-24 APN. 2,r-2-5= Dan Brirrjow 31188 Water Avenue 400 Nuevo, CA 92567 Paul Risse Southern Calif. Edison L � 21730 Newland St. Huntington Beach, CA 92646 148-121-05 Southern Calif. Edison 62, 2244 Walnut Grove Rosemead, CA Land of Pliny 8541 Edison Avenue Huntington Beach , CA '92648 Donald M. Petersen y/ Robert F. Baron ),2- 21541 Surveyor Cir 16611 Carousel Lane Huntington Bh CA 92646-7066 Huntington Bh CA 92649 APN: 939-48-001 APN: 939-48-002 Gary Stuart The Schuhrke Family Trust �y 10172 Theseus Dr. Yj 21571 Surveyor Cir Huntington Bh CA 92646 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7066 APN: 939-48-003 APN: 939-48-004 Donald J. Feher Harnek S. Brar 4t6 2051 Orizaba Ave .. No. 10 �/S 19502 Woodlands Lane Signal Hill CA 90804 Huntington Bh CA 92648 APN: ' 939-48-005 APN: 939-48-006 Harnek S . Brar Raymond P. Boucher 8' 19502 Woodlands Lane u 7 21611 Surveyor Cir Huntington Bh CA 92648 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7015 APN: 939-48-007 APN: 939-48-008 Emil P. Miorelli 4'9 Ning Yeh Sp 9871 Hot Springs Dr. 21522 Surveyor Cir Huntington Bh CA 92646 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7067 APN: 939-48-009 APN: 939-48-010 Gerhard M. Schnuerer / Gene Kraus 5 z 6406 W. Ocean Front 6502 W. Ocean Front Newport Beach CA 92663 Newport Beach CA 92663 APN: 939-48-011 APN: 939-48-012 Douglas Andrew Hill ,53 A-Med Health Care Center S y 21181 Hillsdale Lane 21572 Surveyor Cir Huntington Bh CA 92646 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7067 APN: 939-48-013 APN: 939-48-014 Donald E. Minkoff 5-5, Payleff International Corp S'L 1903 Yacht Enchantress 6161 Arrowroot Lane Newport Beach CA 92660 Rncho Pls Vrd CA 90274 APN: 939-48-015 APN: 939-48-016 Howard C. Pearch '77 William C. Walters St P.O. Box 1437 21612 Surveyor Cir No. 8B Costa Mesa CA 92628 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7068 APN: 939-48-017 APN: 939-48-018 Carl W. Grodach 51 Villa At Huntington Beach Associ 117 Via Dijon 19752 cA ur Blvd. No. 240 Newport Beach CA 92663 Irvine 92715 , APN: 939-48-019 APN: 9- 8-025 Villas t untington Beach Associ Villas t untington Beach Associ . 19752 Ma rthur Blvd. No. 240 19752 Ma rthur Blvd. No. 240 Irvine C 2715 Irvine CAA 92715 APN: 939-48-026 APN: 939-48-027 Gary leacher Villa' A ' Huntington Beach Associ 8304 A anta Ave . No. 104 19752 \cArthur Blvd. No. 240 Huntingt n Beach CA 92646-6101 Irvine A 92715 APN: 939-48-028 APN: 939-48-029 Anthony Caputo Phillip March 21851Newlandst No. 113 21851Newlandst No. 215 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7629 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7635 APN: 890-899-16 APN: 890-899-17 Steven R. Hopper William H. Walls 21851Newlandst No. 204 21851Newlandst No. 95 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646 APN: 890-899-18 APN: 890-899-19 Craig Mc Clelland Rebecca F. Clark 21851 Newland St . Trlr 277 21851 Newland St . Trlr 282 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 APN: 890-892-77 APN: 890-892-82 Fredrick P. McGillion Martha Retana 21851 Newland St . Trlr 283 21851 Newland St . Trlr 287 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 APN: 890-892-83 APN: 890-892-87 Jacqueline Chapin Michael W. Woodridge 21851 Newland St . Trlr 296 Sam Lord' S Castle St . Philip Barbado Huntington Bh CA 92646-7639 West Indies APN: 890-892-96 APN: 890-893-01 Eileen T. Carson Betty Lawrence 21851 Newland St . Trlr 306 21851 Newland St . Trlr 310 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7640 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7641 APN: 890-893-06 APN: 890-893-10 Thomas Malone Warren Hupp 21851 Newland St . Trlr 314 21851 Newland St . Trlr 146 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7641 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7630 APN: 890-893-14 APN: 890-899-01 Curt Radmacher Floyd Scott 21851 Newland St . Trlr 133 21851 Newland St . Trlr 284 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 APN: 890-899-02 APN: 890-899-03 Mary. D. Akin - Eleanor . Millard 21851 Newland St . Trlr 280 21851 Newland St . Trlr 264 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 APN: 890-899-04 APN: 890-899-05 Harold Crank Theodore B. Sayegh 21851 Newland St . Trlr 28 21851 Newland St . Trlr 265 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7627 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 APN: 890-899-06 APN: 890-899-07 Mark N. Simpson Mary Martin 21851 Newland St . Trlr 303 21851 Newland St . Trlr 15 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7640 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7624 APN: 890-899-08 APN: 890-899-09 James W. Dick Robert Antis 21851 Newland St . Trlr 305 21851 Newland St . Trlr 6 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7640 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7622 APN: 890-899-10 APN: 890-899-11 Scott A. Rousseau Kenneth J. Gerding 21851 Newland St . Trlr 149 21851Newlandst No. 22 _ Huntington Bh CA 92646-7630 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7625 APN: 890-899-12 APN: 890-899-13 Jennian Beaver James P. Puro 21851Newlandst No. 52 21851Newlandst No. 156 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7628 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7631 APN: 890-899-14 APN: 890-899-15 David Faison Spencer Weinstein 21851 Newland St . Trlr 163 21851 Newland St . Trlr 165 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7631 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7631 APN: 890-891-63 APN: 890-891-65 Wesley Dochterman Kenneth Beres 21851Newlandst No. 167 21851 Newland St . Trlr 168 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7632 APN: 890-891-67 APN: 890-891-68 Lois A. Jensen Stephen Sullivan_ 21851 Newland St . Trlr 169 21851 Newland St . Trlr 170 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7632 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7632 APN: 890-891-69 APN: 890-891-70 Lee J. Harry Margie A. Hunter - 1605 E. 15th St . 21851 Newland St . Trlr 176 Santa Ana CA 92701 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7632 APN: 890-891-71 APN: 890-891-76 Michael Joseph Dorsi Thomas Kelly 21851 Newland St . Trlr 181 21851 Newland St . Trlr 183 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7632 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 APN: 890-891-81 APN: 890-891-83 Richard Lee Porch Theodore Webster 21851 Newland St . Trlr 190 21851 Newland St . Trlr 191 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 APN: 890-891-90 APN: 890-891-91 William G. Morton Rudy T. Zamora 21851Newlandst No. 192 21851 Newland St . Trlr 196 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7633 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 APN: 890-891-92 APN: 890-891-96 Lonnie Smith Ed Fogel 21851 Newland St . Trlr 197 21851 Newland St . Trlr 202 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 APN: 890-891-97 APN: 890-892-02 Gilbert H. Richard Thomas J. Mynar 21851Newlandst No. 203 21851Newlandst No. 205 Huntington Beach CA 92646 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7633 APN: 890-892-03 APN: 890-892-05 Warren C. Underwood James P. Schultz 21851 Newland St . Trlr 206 21851 Newland St . Trlr. 209 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 APN: 890-892-06 APN: 890-892-09 Robert L. Hamm Cindy Speziale 21851 Newland St . Trlr 212 21851 Newland St . Trlr 218 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7633 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7635 APN: 890-892-12 APN: 890-_892-18 Thomas L. Gorzynski Kenneth Alexander 21851 Newland St . Trlr 220 21851 Newland St . Trlr 221 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7635 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7635 APN: 890-892-20 APN: 890-892-21 Frank H. Bradley Kevin McGowan 21851 Newland St . Trlr 224 21851 Newland St . Trlr 227 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7635 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7635 APN: 890-892-24 APN: 890-892-27 Marnie Fuerst Monte L. Hale 21851 Newland St . Trlr 229 21851 Newland St . Trlr 233 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7635 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7636 APN: 890-892-29 APN: 890-892-33 William A.. Rattray Wallace Nelson 21851 Newland St . Trlr 237 21851 Newland St . Trlr 242 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7636 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7636 APN: 890-892-37 APN: 890-892-42 David Folkins - Tom A. Peikert 21851 Newland St . Trlr 245 21851 Newland St . Trlr 248 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7636 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 APN: 890-892-45 APN: 890-892-48 Martin Baird Robert A. Crum 21851 Newland St . Trlr 249 21851 Newland St . Trlr 250 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 APN: 890-892-49 APN: 890-892-50 Meridee Martt Maria Elena Barrera 21851 Newland St . Trlr 251 21851 Newland St . Trlr 254 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 APN: 890-892-51 - APN: 890-892-54 Elaine M. Werick Georgia W. Hanson 21851 Newland St . Trlr 255 21851 Newland St . Trlr 256 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 APN: 890-892-55 APN: 890-892-56 Patricia Kay Vanatta Debi Smallhasson 1464 Withers Ave . 21851 Newland St . Trlr 259 Monterey CA 93940 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 APN: 890-892-57 APN: 890-892-59 Lawrence R. Nye YBARRA Mark A 21851 Newland St . Trlr 261 21851 Newland St . Trlr 262 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 APN: 890-892-61 APN: 890-892-62 Marta Sullivan Huntington By The Sea 21851 Newland St . Trlr 263 21851 Newland St . Huntington Bh CA 92646-7637 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 APN: 890-892-63 APN: 890-892-68 Mark A. Naaktgeboren Rudolf Vanvianen 21851 Newland St . Trlr 269 21851 Newland St . Trlr 270 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 APN: 890-892-69 APN: 890-892-70 James R. Bohlke Patricia J. Pierce 21851 Newland St . Trlr 274 21851 Newland St . .Trlr 275 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7638 APN: 890-892-74 APN: 890-892-15 Jane Marks Timothy J. Hallinan 16400 Pacific Coast HWY No. 222 21851Newlandst No. 109 Huntington Bh CA 92649 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7629 APN: 890-891-07 APN: 890-891-09 Albert R. Simpson Ralph G. (Or) Jura 21851Newlandst No. 110 21851 Newland No. 112 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7629 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7629 APN: 890-891-10 APN: 890-891-12 Cheryl L. Petersen Kenneth E. Moss 21851 Newland St . Trlr 114 21851Newlandst N0. 115 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 Huntington . Beach CA 92646 APN: 890-891-14 APN: 890-891-15 Marvin Boston James L. Caver 21851 Newland St . Trlr 116 21851 Newland St . Trlr 118 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 APN: 890-891-16 APN: 890-891-18 Claude A. Chiaculas Scott Davis 21851 Newland St . Trlr 121 21851 Newland St . Trlr 122 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 APN: 890-891-21 APN: 890-891-22 Eleanor Mallard Robert Koscielski 31544 Mayhew Lane 21851 Newland St . Trlr 128 Menifee CA 92584 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 APN: 890-891-26 APN: 890-891-28 Michael Twomey Lisle Stephen (Or) Townsend 21851 Newland St . Trlr 130 21851 Newland St . Trlr 131 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 APN: 890-891-30 APN: 890-891-31 Michael T. Eber David A. Russell 21851 Newland St . Trlr .50 21851 Newland St . Trlr 51 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 APN: 890-890-50 APN: 890-890-51 R. Benson Mc Cloud Lee C. Bravener 21851 Newland St . Trlr 58 21851 Newland St . Trlr 63 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-58 APN: 890-890-63 William J. Schumacher Robert L. Sephton 21851 Newland St . Trlr 64 21851 Newland St . Trlr 65 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-64 APN: 890-890-65 Janet Oppe Lori Tenay 21851 Newland St . Trlr 67 21851 Newland St . Trlr 69 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-67 APN: 890-890-69 Linda Umbaugh Sherry Fesagaiga 21851 Newland St . Trlr 70 21851 Newland St . Trlr 73 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-70 APN: 890-890-73 Jack L. Pittman Joel A. Bailey 21851 Newland St . Trlr 76 21851 Newland St . Trlr 77 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-76 APN: 890-890-77 Thomas R.' Thornton Pamela Tye 21851 Newland St . Trlr 79 21851 Newland St . Trlr 81 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-79 APN: 890-890-81 John H. Schroeder Robert Diemer 21851 Newland St . Trlr 84 21851 Newland St . Trlr 89 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-84 APN: 890-890-89 Robert Stueve Paul Morrow 21851 Newland St . Trlr 91 21851 Newland St . Trlr 92 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-91 APN: 890-890-92 Richard W. Borntreger Curtis Carl Davidson 21851 Newland St . Trlr 93 21851 Newland St . Trlr 94 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-93 APN: 890-890-94 Marlys T. Johnson Rodney Mc Clelland 21851 Newland St . Trlr 97 21851 Newland St . Trlr 99 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7621 APN: 890-890-97 APN: 890-890-99 Kenneth Dionne Michael W. Hulse 21851 Newland St . Trlr 102 21851 Newland St . Trlr 103 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 APN: 890-891-02 APN: 890-891-03 Mills Land & Water Co Ross J. Gibbard P.O. Box 7108 21851 Newland St . Trlr 4 Huntington Bh CA 92615 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7622 APN: 1147150-72 APN: 890-890-04 David Gambert Robert Kotyluk 21851 Newland St . Trlr 5 21851 Newland St . Trlr 11 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7622 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7623 APN: 890-890-05 APN: 890-890-11 Dawn Olmstead Kenji Imada 21851 Newland St . Trlr 12 21851 Newland St . Trlr 14 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7623 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7623 APN: 890-890-12 APN: 890-890-14 Sebastian Lopez Bill C. Mc Cutcheon 21851Newlandst No. 16 21851 Newland St . Trlr 17 Huntington Beach CA 92646 - Huntington Bh CA 92646-7624 APN: 890-890-16 APN: 890-890-17 Timothy A. Peck Jeffrey M. Carlson 21851 Newland St . Trlr 18 21851 Newland St . Trlr 21 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7624 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7625 APN: 890-890-18 APN: 890-890-21 Jo Ella Adkins John S . Hirano 21851 Newland St . . Trlr 24 15629 Mindru A Huntington Bh CA 92646-7626 Huntington Beach CA 92647 APN: 890-890-24 APN: 890-890-26 Nick Diment Timothy C. Reyes 21851 Newland St . Trlr 27 21851 Newland St . Trlr 29 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7627 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7627 APN: 890-890-27 APN: 890-890-29 Sylvia M. Garcia Patrick J. Minns 21851 Newland St . Trlr 30 21851 Newland St . Trlr 31 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 APN: 890-890-30 APN: 890-890-31 Aldine M. Hankle Russell Clifford 21851 Newland St . Trlr 32 21851 Newland St . Trlr 33 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 APN: 890-890-32 APN: 890-890-33 Rodolfo F. Marquez Brian Lunt 21851 Newland St . Trlr 34 21851 Newland St . Trlr 44 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 APN: 890-890-34 APN: 890-890-44 Caryl M. Krotz Judith Ann Elliott 21851 Newland St . Trlr 45 21851 Newland St . Trlr 46 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 APN: 890-890-45 APN: 890-890-46 Robert Trudeau August E. Cor 21851Newlandst No. 48 21851 Newland St . Trlr 49 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7628 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7628 APN: 890-890-48 APN: 890-890-49 Mills Land & Water Co ' Mills Land & Water Co P.O. Box 7108 P.O. Box 7108 Huntington Bh CA 92615 Huntington Bh CA 92615 APN: 148-011-06 APN: 148-011-07 Charles L. Lindsay Teresa Jean Lee 8622 Hatteras Dr. 3 21901 Kiowa Lane Huntington Bh CA 92646-7024 Huntington Bh CA 92646 APN: 148-071-28 APN: 148-081-01 Kelly Holcomb Leslie L. Jepsen �o 8562 Sandy Hook Dr. ✓ 8552 Sandy Hook Dr. Huntington Bh CA 92646-7017 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7017 APN: 148-081-02 APN: 148-081-03 Marion M. Fuget Thomas M. Cowger 8542 Sandy Hook Dr. 7 8532 Sandy Hook Dr. Huntington Bh CA 92646-7017 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7017 APN: 148-081-04 APN: 148-081-05 James C. Niemann Wayne A. Lewis /0 8522 Sandy Hook Dr. 8512 Sandy Hook Dr. Huntington Bh CA 92646-7017 9 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7017 APN: 148-081-06 APN: 148-081-07 Lawrence H. Ayers Gay A. Boyer y 8502 Sandy Hook Dr. 21441 Antigua Lane Huntington Bh CA 92646-7017 /( Huntington Bh CA 92646-7014 APN: 148-081-08 APN: 148-081-09 .. John F. Hill Roger L. Gasteiger 21431 Antigua Lane 21421 Antigua Lane Huntington Bh CA 92646-7014 /7, Huntington Bh CA 92646-7014 APN: 148-081-10 APN: 148-081-11 Kathy Kelley Dolores J. Ellison /(o 21431 Seaforth Lane 21441 Seaforth Lane Huntington Bh CA 92646-7042 /S Huntington Bh CA 92646-7042 APN: 148-086-15 APN: 148-086-16 Joann M. Dickens Andrew. J. Bumatay �$ 8561 Sandy Hook Dr. 8551 Sandy Hook Dr. Huntington Bh CA 92646-7016 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7016 APN: 148-086-17 APN: 148-086-18 Donald E. Stack Steven B. Wells -2t) 8541 Sandy Hook Dr. 8531 Sandy Hook Dr. Huntington Bh CA 92646-7016 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7016 APN: 148-086-19 APN: 148-086-20 Virgil J. Butler 94 Michael W. Selna -Z Z 8521 Sandy Hook Dr. 9762 Kite Dr. Huntington Beach CA 92646-7016 Huntington Bh CA 92646 APN: 148-086-21 APN: 148-086-22 Michael O. Dangott Z Phillip; Houseman 2— )4 8532 ,Milne Dr. 8542 Milne Dr. - Huntington Bh CA 92646-7006 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7006 APN: 148-086-23 APN: 148-086-24 Nigel Gibbs Dennis W. Hall 21851 Newland St . Trlr 15 21851 NaWland St . Trlr 137 Huntington Bh CA 92646- 9 Huntin Bh CA 92646-7629 APN: 890-891-35 APN: 89 891-37 Shawn Tuey Patricia Wells 21851 Newland St . Trlr 138 21851 Newland St . Trlr 140 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7629 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7630 APN: 890-891-38 APN: 890-891-40 John J. .Seal Lynette Wine 21851 Newland St . Trlr 142 21851 Newland St . Trlr 143 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7630 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7630 APN: 890-891-42 APN: 890-891-43 Richard P. Schneeloch Michael Klemantovich 21851 Newland St . Trlr 144 21851Newlandst No. 147 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7630 Huntington Beach CA 92646-7630 APN: 890-891-44 APN: 890-891-47 Clarence E. Hallman Derek Cook 21851 Newland St . Trlr 148 21851 Newland St . Trlr 159 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7630 Huntington Bh CA 92646-7631 APN: 890-891-48 APN: 890-891-59 CERTIFICATION OF PROPERTY OWNERSHIP LIST THE ATTACHED LIST REPRESENTS THE NAMES AND ADDRESSES OF ALL PROPERTY OWNERS LOCATED WITHIN 1,000 FEET OF THE EXTERIOR BOUNDARIES OF THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 8541 Edison Avenue, Huntington Beach, CA 92646. THIS INFORMATION WAS OBTAINED FROM THE LATEST Orange County Assessment Rolls December 1, 1993. C.E SUSAN PIERCE ASSOCIATE PLANNER C:\splpl68 •(C) 1993 TRW REDI PropertyRata No. Grid Owner Name Address Price (K) Date APN Number Use 1 30-D1 MILLS LAND & 148-011-06 430 2 30-Dl MILLS LAND & 148-011-07 430 3 30-D1 LINDSAY CHARL 8622 HATTERAS $7U 07/76 148-071-28 163 4 30-Dl LEE TERESA JE 8572 SANDY H00 07/89 148-081-01 163 5 30-Dl HOLCOMB KELLY 8562 SANDY H00 $240F 04/91 148-081702 163 6 30-Dl JEPSEN LESLIE 8552 SANDY H00 $36F 08/73 148-081-03 163 7 30-Dl FUGET MARION 8542 SANDY HOO $249F 03/93 148-081-04 163 8 30-Dl COWGER THOMAS 8532 SANDY HOO $6U 09/68 148-081-05 163 9 30-Dl NIEMANN JAMES 8522 SANDY HOO $142F 06/85 148-081-06 163 10 30-Dl LEWIS WAYNE A 8512 SANDY HOO $80F 03/77 148-081-07 163 11 30-Dl AYERS LAWRENC 8502 SANDY HOO 07/92 148-081-08 163 12 30-Dl BOYER GAY A 21441 ANTIGUA 05/87 148-081-09 163 13 30-D1 HILL JOHN F 21431 ANTIGUA $46F 04/75 148-081-10 163 14 30-Dl GASTEIGER ROG 21421 ANTIGUA 12/91 148-081-11 163 15 30-Dl KELLEY KATHY 21431 SEAFORTH $255V 08/91 148-086-15 163 16 30-Dl ELLISON DOLOR 21441 SEAFORTH 10/87 148-086-16 163 17 30-Dl DICKENS JOANN 8561 SANDY H00 06/92 148-086-17 163 18 30-Dl BUMATAY ANDRE 8551 SANDY H00 $33F 10/72 148-086-18 163 19 30-D1 STACK DONALD 8541 SANDY H0O $5U 02/69 148-086-19 163 20 30-Dl WELLS STEVEN 8531 SANDY HOO 03/90 148-086-20 163 21 30-D1 BUTLER VIRGIL 8521 SANDY H00 $100P 08/90 148-086-21 163 22 30-Dl SELNA MICHAEL 8522 MILNE DRI $245F 01/91 148-086-22 163 23 30-Dl DANGOTT MICHA 8532 MILNE DRI 08/89 148-086-23 163 24 30-Dl HOUSEMAN PHIL 8542 MILNE DRI $284F 01/91 148-086-24 163 25. 30-Dl LOPEZ REYNALD 8552 MILNE DRI $39P 01/79 148-086-25 163 26 30-Dl APODACA REFUG 8562 MILNE DRI $80F 05/77 148-086-26 163 27 30-Dl KAPLAN BERNAR 21502 NEWLAND $165C 04/88 148-121-01 364 28 30-Dl TARNUTZER BYR 8570 HAMILTON 02/74 148-121-03 336 29 30-Dl CITY OF HUNTI 148-121-04 420 30 30-D1 ORANGE COUNTY 11/80 148-121-15 415 31 30-Dl ORANGE COUNTY 148-121-16 415 32 30-Dl CITY OF HUNTI 8641 EDISON AV 148-121-17 300 33 30-Dl LENIHAN THOMA $250F 12/80 148-121-18• 364 34 30-Dl SANDGREN PAUL 8551 EDISON' AV 04/91 148-121-19 420 35 30-Dl SANDGREN PAUL 8551 EDISON AV 04/91 148-121-20 208 36 30-Dl BRIMLOW KEN 8541 EDISON AV 11/76 148-121-21 420 37 30-Dl NASRE NABIL 8521 EDISON AV 07/87 148-121-22 244 38 30-Dl NASRE NABIL 21632 NEWLAND $58F 07/84 148-121-23 163 39 30-Dl ORANGE COUNTY 148-121-24 415 40 30-Dl "MAO frojer-+ 11SXed as 1-b9-YR {I -- �9� 148-121-25 321 41 30-Dl PETERSEN DONA 21541 SURVEYOR $279F 11/83 939-48-001 112 42 30-Dl BARON ROBERT 21531 .SURVEYOR $367F 11/90 939-48-002 112 43 30-Dl STUART GARY 21521 SURVEYOR $260F 12/81 939-48-003 112 44 30-Dl THE SCHUHRKE 21571 SURVEYOR 05/82 939-48-004 112 45 30-Dl FEHER DONALD 21561 SURVEYOR $390F 06/87 939-48-005 321 46 30-Dl BRAR HARNEK S 21591 SURVEYOR 12/91 939-48-006 321 47 30-Dl BRAR HARNEK S 21581 SURVEYOR 12/91 939-48-007 321 48 30-Dl BOUCHER RAYMO 21611 SURVEYOR $362F 07/82 939-48-008 112 49 30-Dl MIORELLI EMIL 21601 SURVEYOR 01/87 939-48-009 112 50 30-Dl YEH NING 21522 SURVEYOR $357F 05/89 939-48-010 112 ------------------------------ ------------------------------ >> Reported data believed to be reliable but accuracy is not guaranteed << City of Huntington Beach Y OC) 1993 TRW REDI Property4ta No. Grid Owner Name Address Price (K) Date APN Number Use 51 30-Dl SCHNUERER GER 21532 SURVEYOR $300F 12/90 939-48-011 112 52 30-D1 KRAUS GENE 21542 SURVEYOR 03/89 939-48-012 112 53 30-Dl HILL DOUGLAS 21562 SURVEYOR $230P 07/87 939-48-013 321 54 30-Dl A-MED HEALTH 21572 SURVEYOR $460F 06/89 939-48-014 321 55 30-Dl MINKOFF DONAL 21582 SURVEYOR $78P 10/86 939-48-015 112 56 30-Dl PAYLEFF INTER 21592 SURVEYOR $69P 12/86 939-48-016 32� 57 30-Dl PEARCH HOWARD 21602 SURVEYOR 11/87 939-48-017 321 58 30-Dl WALTERS WILLI 21612 SURVEYOR $115P 07/86 939-48-018 112 59 30-Dl GRODACH CARL 21622 SURVEYOR $82P 05/85 939-48-019 321 ------------------------------------------------------------ >> Reported data believed to be reliable but accuracy is not guaranteed << City of Huntington Beach 60 Dan Brimlow 31188 Water Avenue Nuevo, CA 92567 61 Paul Risse Southern Calif. Edison 21730 Newland St. Huntington Beach 92646 62 Southern Calif. Edison 2244 Walnut Grove Rosemead, CA 63 Land of Pliny 8541 Edison Avenue Huntington Beach, CA 92648 16 OC) 1993 TRW REDI Property ata No. Grid Owner Name Address Price (K) Date APN Number Use 1 30-D2 MILLS LAND & 21851 NEWLAND 114-150-72 136 2 GIBBARD ROSS 21851 NEWLAND 01/90 890-890-04 400 3 GAMBERT DAVID 21851 NEWLAND 02/87 890-890-05 400 4 KOTYLUK ROBER 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-11 400 5 OLMSTEAD DAWN 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-12 400 6 IMADA KENJI 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-14 400 7 LOPEZ SEBASTI 21851 NEWLAND 12/92 890-890-16 135 8 MC CUTCHEON B 21851 NEWLAND 05/90 890-890-17 400 9 PECK TIMOTHY 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-18 400 10 CARLSON JEFFR 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-21 400 11 ADKINS JO ELL 21851 NEWLAND 02/85 890-890-24 400 12 HIRANO JOHN S 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-26 400 13 DIMENT NICK 21851 NEWLAND 02/88 890-890-27 400 14 REYES TIMOTHY 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-29 400 15 GARCIA SYLVIA 21851 NEWLAND 05/92 890-890-30 400 16 MINNS PATRICK 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-31 400 17 HANKLE ALDINE 21851 NEWLAND 02/85 890-890-32 400 18 CLIFFORD RUSS 21851 NEWLAND 02/91 890-890-33 400 19 MARQUEZ RODOL 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-34 400 20 LUNT BRIAN 21851 NEWLAND 02/88 890-890-44 400 21 KROTZ CARYL M 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-45 400 22 ELLIOTT JUDIT 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-46 400 23 TRUDEAU ROBER 21851 NEWLAND 09/91 890-890-48 400 24 COR AUGUST E 21851 NEWLAND 05/89 890-890-49 400 25 EBER MICHAEL 21851 NEWLAND 02/88 890-890-50 400 26 RUSSELL DAVID 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-51 400 27 MC CLOUD R BE 21851 NEWLAND 02/90 890-890-58 400 28 BRAVENER LEE 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-63 400 29 SCHUMACHER WI 21851 NEWLAND 04/89 890-890-64 400 30 SEPHTON ROBER 21851 NEWLAND 02/93 890-890-65 400 31 OPPE JANET 21851 NEWLAND 02/90 890-890-67 400 32 TENAY LORI 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-69 400 33 UMBAUGH LINDA 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-70 400 34 FESAGAIGA SHE 21851 NEWLAND 07/92 890-890-73 400 35 PITTMAN JACK 21851 NEWLAND 02/86 890-890-76 400 36 BAILEY JOEL A 21851 NEWLAND 09/91 890-890-77 400 37 THORNTON THOM 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-79 400 38 TYE PAMELA 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-81 400 39 SCHROEDER JOH 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-84 400 40 DIEMER ROBERT 21851 NEWLAND 10/88 890-890-89 400 41 STUEVE ROBERT 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-91 400 42 MORROW PAUL 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-92 400 43 BORNTREGER RI 21851 NEWLAND 02/85 890-890-93 400 44 DAVIDSON CURT 21851 NEWLAND 890-890-94 400 45 JOHNSON MARLY 21851 NEWLAND 02/85 890-890-97 400 46 MC CLELLAND R 21851 NEWLAND 11/89 890-890-99 400 47 DIONNE KENNET 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-02 137 48 HULSE MICHAEL 21851 NEWLAND 02/86 890-891-03 137 49 MARKS JANE 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-07 137 50 HALLINAN TIMO 21851 NEWLAND 10/91 890-891-09 137 ------------------------------------------------------------ >> Reported data believed to be reliable but accuracy is not guaranteed << City of Huntington Beach i� OC) 1993 TRW REDI Property0ata No. Grid Owner Name Address Price (K) Date APN Number Use 51 SIMPSON ALBER 21851 NEWLAND 09/91 890-891-10 137 52 JURA RALPH G 21851 NEWLAND 02/84 890-891-12 137 53 PETERSEN CHER 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-14 137 54 MOSS KENNETH 21851 NEWLAND 11/92 890-891-15 137 55 BOSTON MARVIN 21851 NEWLAND 12/92 890-891-16 137 56 CAVER JAMES L 21851 NEWLAND 02/88 890-891-18 137 57 CHIACULAS CLA 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-21 137 58 DAVIS SCOTT 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-22 137 59 MALLARD ELEAN 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-26 137 60 KOSCIELSKI RO 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-28 137 61 TWOMEY MICHAE 21851 NEWLAND 11/89 890-891-30 137 62 TOWNSEND LISL 21851 NEWLAND 02/84 890-891-31 137 63 GIBBS NIGEL 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-35 137 64 HALL DENNIS W 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-37 137 65 TUEY SHAWN 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-38 137 66 WELLS PATRICI 21851 NEWLAND 10/90 890-891-40 137 67 SEAL JOHN J 21851 NEWLAND 02/83 890-891-42 137 68 WINE LYNETTE 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-43 137 69 SCHNEELOCH RI 21851 NEWLAND 02/88 890-891-44 137 70 KLEMANTOVICH 21851 NEWLAND 07/91 890-891-47 137 71 HALLMAN CLARE 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-48 137 72 COOK DEREK 21851 NEWLAND 06/92 890-891-59 137 73 FAISON DAVID 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-63 137 74 WEINSTEIN SPE 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-65 137 75 DOCHTERMAN WE 21851 NEWLAND O1/93 890-891-67 137 76 BERES KENNETH 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-68 137 77 JENSEN LOIS A 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-69 137 78 SULLIVAN STEP 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-70 137 79 HARRY LEE J 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-71 137 80 HUNTER MARNIE 21851 NEWLAND 02/87 890-891-76 137 81 DORSI MICHAEL 21851 NEWLAND 07/92 890-891-81 137 82 KELLY THOMAS 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-83 137 83 PORCH RICHARD 21851 NEWLAND 02/84 890-891-90 137 84 WEBSTER THEOD 21851 NEWLAND 890-891-91 137 85 MORTON WILLIA 21851 NEWLAND 05/91 890-891-92 137 86 ZAMORA RUDY T 21851 NEWLAND 02/87 890-891-96 137 87 SMITH LONNIE 21851 NEWLAND 02/86 890-891-97 137 88 FOGEL ED 21851 NEWLAND 10/90 890-892-02 137 89 RICHARD GILBE 21851 NEWLAND 07/92 890-892-03 137 90 MYNAR THOMAS 21851 NEWLAND 02/92 890-892-05 137 91 UNDERWOOD WAR 21851 NEWLAND 02/87 890-892-06 137 92 SCHULTZ JAMES 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-09 137 93 HAMM ROBERT L 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-12 137 94 SPEZIALE CIND 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-18 137 95 GORZYNSKI THO 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-20 137 96 ALEXANDER KEN 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-21 137 97 BRADLEY FRANK 21851 NEWLAND 02/85 890-892-24 137 98 MCGOWAN KEVIN 21851 NEWLAND 02/86 890-892-27 137 99 FUERST MARNIE 21851 NEWLAND 11/90 890-892-29 137 100 HALE MONTE L 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-33 137 >> Reported data believed to be reliable but accuracy is not guaranteed << City of Huntington Beach C) 1993 TRW REDI Propertylata No. Grid Owner Name Address Price (K) Date APN Number Use 101 RATTRAY WILLI 21851 NEWLAND 08/89 890-892-37 137 102 NELSON WALLAC 21851 NEWLAND 04/90 890-892-42 137 103 FOLKINS DAVID 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-45 137 104 PEIKERT TOM A 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-48 137 105 BAIRD MARTIN 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-49 137 106 CRUM ROBERT A 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-50 137 107 MARTT MERIDEE 21851 NEWLAND 02/86 890-892-51 137 108 BARRERA MARIA 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-54 137 109 WERICK ELAINE 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-55 137 110 HANSON GEORGI 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-56 137 111 VANATTA PATRI 21851 NEWLAND 08/89 890-892-57 137 112 SMALLHASSON D 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-59 137 113 NYE LAWRENCE 21851 NEWLAND 08/90 890-892-61 137 114 YBARRA MARK A 21851 NEWLAND 02/87 890-892-62 137 115 SULLIVAN MART 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-63 137 116 HUNTINGTON BY 21851 NEWLAND 02/88 890-892-68 137 117 NAAKTGEBOREN 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-69 137 118 VANVIANEN RUD 21851 NEWLAND 05/92 890-892-70 137 119 BOHLKE JAMES 21851 NEWLAND 02/88 890-892-74 137 120 PIERCE PATRIC 21851 NEWLAND 11/88 890-892-75 137 121 MC CLELLAND C 21851 NEWLAND 10/90. 890-892-77 137 122 CLARK REBECCA 21851 NEWLAND 10/90 890-892-82 137 123 MCGILLION FRE 21851 NEWLAND 02/86 890-892-83 137 124 RETANA MARTHA 21851 NEWLAND 11/89 890-892-87 137 125 CHAPIN JACQUE 21851 NEWLAND 890-892-96 137 126 WOODRIDGE MIC 21851 NEWLAND 890-893-01 137 127 CARSON EILEEN 21851 NEWLAND 11/92 890-893-06 137 128 LAWRENCE BETT 21851 NEWLAND 02/87 890-893-10 137 129 MALONE THOMAS 21851 NEWLAND 02/88 890-893-14 137 130 HUPP WARREN 21851 NEWLAND 02/86 890-899-01 137 131 RADMACHER CUR 21851 NEWLAND 890-899-02 137 132 SCOTT FLOYD 21851 NEWLAND 890-899-03 137 133 AKIN MARY D 21851 NEWLAND 890-899-04 137 134 MILLARD ELEAN 21851 NEWLAND 890-899-05 137 135 CRANK HAROLD 21851 NEWLAND 12/89 890-899-06 137 136 SAYEGH THEODO 21851 NEWLAND 06/91 890-899-07 137 137 SIMPSON MARK 21851 NEWLAND 03/90 890-899-08 137 138 MARTIN MARY 21851 NEWLAND 10/89 890-899-09 137 139 DICK JAMES W 21851 NEWLAND 12/90 890-899-10 137 140 ANTIS ROBERT 21851 NEWLAND 10/90 890-899-11 137 141 ROUSSEAU SCOT 21851 NEWLAND O1/91 890-899-12 137 142 GERDING KENNE 21851 NEWLAND 10/91 890-899-13 137 143 BEAVER JENNIA 21851 NEWLAND 10/91 890-899-14 137 144 PURO JAMES P 21851 NEWLAND 11/91 890-899-15 137 145 CAPUTO ANTHON 21851 NEWLAND 08/91 890-899-16 137 146 MARCH PHILLIP 21851 NEWLAND 09/91 890-899-17 137 147 HOPPER STEVEN 21851 NEWLAND 11/92 890-899-18 137 148 WALLS WILLIAM 21851 NEWLAND 12/92 890-899-19 137 ------------------------------------------------------------ >> Reported data believed to be reliable but accuracy is not guaranteed City of Huntington Beach CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK CONNIE BROCKWAY CITY CLERK February 16, 1994 Ken Brimlow 652 E. Culver Avenue Orange, CA 92666 Gentlemen: The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at its regular meeting held Monday, February 7, 1994, denied your appeal to the Planning Commission's denial of Conditional Use Permit No. 92-44, Conditional Exception No. 92-47, and Negative Declaration No. 92-40. This is a final decision. You are hereby notified that pursuant to provisions of Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedures of the State of California you have ninety days from February 16, 1994, to apply to the courts for judicial review. The minutes with the conditions of approval will be mailed to you at a later date. If you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact this office at 536-5227. Sincerely yours, Connie Brockway, CMC City Clerk CB:cc Enclosure CC: City Administrator City Attorney Melanie Fallon, Community Development Director 1051K Telephone:714-536-5227) ' I PROOF%OF PUBLICATION STATE OF CALIFORNIA) SS. County of Orange ) PUBLIC NOTICE I am a Citizen of the United States and a NOTICEOF PUBLIC HEARING resident of the County aforesaid; I am APPEAL OF THE over the age of eighteen years r and not a PLANNING COMMISSION'S party to or interested •(n the below ' CONDITIONAL DENIAL OF entitled matter. I am a principal. clerk USE CONDITIONA clerk of PERMIT NO. 92-a4, p oOAcSTs in aTnon-certS. fied the HUNTINGTON BEACH INDEPENDENT a CONDITIONAL area of the Coastal Zone / EXCEPTION NO. and must be ultimately re- newspaper of general circulation/ printed 92-47,NEGATIVE viewed and approved by DECLARATION NO. the California Coastal Co and published in the City of Huntington 92.ao mission, (Proposed ON FILE: A copy of the Beach, County of Orange, State of ComTower lions proposed reque is on fip in the Communit Develo ) ment Department, 20Q0 and that attached Notice is a NOTICE IS HEREBY Main Street, Huntington California, GIVEN that the-Huntington Beach, Galitornia 92648, true and complete copy as was printed Beach C-ity Council will for inspection by the pub hold apublic hearing in the lit. A copy of the staff and published in the Huntington Beach Council Chambers at the port will be available to in- Huntington Beach Civic terested parties in the C-ity and Fountain Valley issues of said ;Center, 2000 Main Street, C-Jerk's office after Feb Huntington Beach, C-alifor- ruary 4,1994. nia,on the date and at the ALL INTERESTED newspaper to to wit the issue(s) of: (time indicated below tore SONS are invited to attend �ceive and consider the said hearing and express statements of all persons o inions or submit to the who wish to be heard rela- Cty Clerk,written evidenxee five to the application de I{or or against the applica .scribed below. lion as outlined above. If DA�TE/TIME:Monday,Feb you challenge the City 'ruary 7,1994,7:00 PM Council's action in court, January 27, 1994 APPLICATION NUMBER: I you may be limited to rais- Appeal of Planning Com- mg only those issues you mission's Denial of C-ondi- or someone else raised at :tional Use Permit No. 92- �the public hearing de- 44/ Conditional Exception scribed in this notice, or in INo. 92-47/Negative Decla- written correspondence de- ration No.92-40 i livered to the City at,, or APPLICANT:Dan Brimlow prior to,the public hearing. I declare, under penalty of perjury, that APPELLANT: Dan Brimlow If there are any further and Ken Brimlow .. questions please call the foregoing is true and correct. LOCATION: 85'4.1 Edison Susan Pierce, Associate Avenue Planner,at 536-5271. ZONE: M2-0-FP2 (Heavy Connie Brockway, Industrial Combined wi)h City Clerk, City o1 Hun• Oil with Floodplain Overlay) Executed on January27 REQUEST:To"approve in t,ln�gton Beach, 2000 / 199.�, concept" a 310 foot tall Matn Street, Hun• communications tow r �Gington Beach, G which exceeds the matci• at Costa Mesa, California. 926aa(714)536-522 mum height requirement of published Huntington 40 feet in an M2 district. Beach-Fountain Valley In- ENVIRONMENTAL STA- TUB: Environmental A,S- dependent January 2, sessment No. 92 40 will 1994. also be considered y 014-623 LtCouncil. Signature 0� ATTACHMENT NO. 3 ALTERNATIVE FINDINGS AND CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-44 CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 92-47 NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 92-40 FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL - CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION (VARIANCE) NO. 92-47: 1. There are exceptional or extraordinary circumstances or conditions applicable to the land, buildings or premises involved that do not apply generally to other property or uses in the district. 2. The granting of a conditional exception for a 212 foot high communications tower is necessary in order to preserve the enjoyment of one or more substantial property rights . 3 . The granting of Conditional Exception (Variance) No. 92-47 for a 212 foot high communications tower will not be materially detrimental to the public health, safety and welfare, or injurious to the conforming land, property, or improvements in the neighborhood. 4 . The granting of this conditional exception from Section 9550.04 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code will not defeat the general purposes or intent of the code which is to limit the height of manufacturing uses and structures. 5 . The granting of the conditional exception for a Z12 foot high communications tower will not adversely affect the General `Plan of the City of Huntington Beach because: a. It conserves land resources by providing opportunities for joint participation among all levels of government, private citizens and involved agencies and organizations (2 . 1.2. 1) . b. It provides a community facility for the public ' s health, safety and welfare that will be used as a communication system for use by persons living or working in the City (3 .4 .2 . 6) . 6. The increased height is necessary to obtain multiple frequencies for consolidation of various receiving and transmitting antennas on a single tower. 2. An official thirty_ (30) day public review period for the Negative Declaration was established by the State Clearinghouse. It began on Monday, October 18, 1993 and ended on Wednesday.;November 17, 1993. However, notice of the Draft Negative Declaration was no published until October 21, 1993. Therefore, public comment letters were accepted by the City of Huntington Beach through November 19, 1993. 3. Notice of the .Negative Declaration was published in the Huntington Beach Independent on Thursday. October 21, 1993. Upon request, copies of the document were distributed to agencies, groups, organizations, and individuals. III. COMMENTS Copies of all written comments received as of Friday,November 19, 1993, are contained in Appendix A of this document. All comments have been numbered i and are listed on the following pages. All comments from letters received have been retyped verbatim in a comment-response format for clarity. Responses to Comments for each comment which raised an environmental issue are contained in this document. IV. RESPONSE TO COMMENTS The Negative Declaration No. 93-40 was distributed to responsible agencies, interested groups, organizations, and individuals. The report was made available for public review and comment for a period of thirty (30) days. The public review period for the Negative Declaration established by the State Clearinghouse commenced on October 18, 1993, and expired November 17, 1993. The City of Huntington Beach accepted comment letters through November 19, 1993. Copies of all documents received as of November 19, 1993, are contained in appendix A of this report. Comments have been numbered with responses correspondingly numbered. Responses are presented for each comment which raised a significant environmental issue. Several comments do not address the completeness or adequacy of the Negative Declaration, do not raise significant environmental issues, or request additional information. A substantive response to such comments is not appropriate within the context of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). Such comments are responded to with a "comment ackno-,vledged" reference. This indicates that the comment will be forwarded to all appropriate decision makers for their review and consideration. Response to Comments ND 93-40 �- r 51"1g3 00 NOT REMOVE CARBONS 7 , p.11 t' • Form Approved OMB No. 2720.OXI r Aeronautical Study Number usbePOrrrhMrd l,On100rbrOn NOTICE OF PROPOSED CONSTRUCTION OR ALTERATION G3'AwP F.b.nl }vl.aon AOminNtntlon .. •• ' 1. Nature of Proposal 2. Complete Description of Structure A. Type B. Class C work Scheouie Dates A includeeltective,ad,atedpOwe,andass,gneCtieduencyof {New Construction b] Permanent.- Beginning F G C APPROVAL all existing proposed or modified AM FM or TV broadcast ❑ Alteration stations utilizing this structure ❑ Temporary (DurahOn months Eno �`t NT t't B Include sue and contrqu,aaon of power uansm,ssion i,nes 3 A Name and address of individual, company, corporation, etc. proposing the and Ine.,5:,pno,hh9 10.0r5,n the v,C,n,1y C,1 FAA tac,l-t-es construction Of alteration.(Number-Strew.C4y S:a!e and Zip Collet and puw,.-aar)cn;, 714 836-a4O0 C lncfude Intymal,on showing site orientation d,rneri5,On5 ( 1 and COysvucliOn n:al C,-a-s of the pro Vo5ed structure ana code Telephone Number F KEN 310' STEEL TRI-LEG LATICE 1119 E. WASHINGTON' COMM- UNICATION TOWER WITH A TO SANTA ANA, CA 92701 25' TRIANGULAR BASE. ANY FUTURE CHANGE IN �— FREQUENCY,RADIATED POWER B. Name.addresi and telephone number of proponent's representative if different than 3 above. OR ANTENNA CHARACTERISTICS DAN SHALL BE FILED AS NOTICE TO 1119 E. WASHINGTON THE FAA ON FORM 7460-1. SANTA ANA, CA 92701 (it more space is required,Con►inue on a separate sheet.) 4. Location of Structure S. Height and Elevation (Complete to the nearest foot) A. Coordinates B.Nearest City,Town and Slate C Name of nearest airport.hetipori.flightpark. A. Elevation of site above mean sea level TO nearest second) HUNTINGTON BEACH or seaplane base 10, o r rr (1)Distance to Q of Distance from structure to nearest point of S. Height of Structure including all 33 38 53 nearest runway appurtenances and lighting(if any) above Latitude city center Miles ground,or water if so situated 310' (2)Direction to 4B (2)Direction from structure to airport C. Overall height above mean sea level(A• 8) 117 0158 43 Longitude 12 N OF E 320' D. Description of location o1 site with respect to highways.streets.airports.prominent terrain features,existing structures.etc.Attach a U.S.Geological Survey quadrangle map or equivalent showing the rewions t:;of construction s:;e to nearest a,rport(s).fit more space is re^uired.continue or,a separate sheet of paper and attach to this notice.) 160' EAST OF THE INTEP.SECTIUN OF NEWLAND ST. AND EDISON WAY. Notice ilreC.aeCDy?art77ot7neFeaaa•A.,ai,onAegt,;ar,onsr;: ,f.R.Pan:.':,:u:sudnrroSacfic: ;i0:ofrneiederarAvra:,onAcro1195885amen0e(7(49U.S.C.7707). Persons who knowingly and willingly violate the Notice requ»ementS of Part 77 are Suplect to a line(arnl,ndi prnauy)of not more than S50C lot the first ollense and not mote than$2.000 for subsequent offenses.pursuant to Section 9C2(a)of the Federal Aviation Act of 7958.as amended(49 U.S.C. 1472(a)). I HEREBY CERTIFY that all of the above statements made by me are true, complete, and correct to the best of my knowledge.in addition,i agree to obstruction mark and/or light the structure in accordance with established marking 8r lighting standards If necessary. Date Typed Name/rifle of Person Filing Notice Signature 7/17/93 tim boettcher ettherretum this_dorm or Issue-e.sepatat acknowtedga-9Rt" Z S 0tiriental Notice of Contsntctforf FAA Form 7AW21tt required any time the ptoJet:t7s iD_ant)oneQ'on _.. ....._ _ j1�7t leiiat 48 hoots before the start o!construction�.� •-moss not ieautre a notice t - _ iYlth7n five day hp Constrtrejiogreachesit8 g(eatest.heiphG i ;•� •tlPiiot'identiTled-a�"an r�I Ci_ ••�,.c.•�=-*��-- ; .^: -- „�„�-,�':--= _ - an attei-niiaid of FA r ..(,' un ess�j� �t eterttYnat o g���trrotAd be a hfstard eo'al. ---- not _ .,, y. ...-.c.� .� ;•► 1 -9E=:-s: = ewe r: a�s:�a�:.r.d,:arwa `-..:;::,r.. .e - eiin�Tn`afed by the Issuin off) 'y .13�361 nedats=anotisrtuation'under.thb' '(6� s 1 a pr i tftpt►oA oil - -- - 4� ....- - _ �i io pedere "� on a eet 1 hi 'a e F I CiommttnlcatitXta Coirdf>tsstana4 standards`ofFARPad7TSbtip'nr'cr-Dut�R/y +pct oillorat�netrocttoltpermtj;(a.mbS3e�othefCCono'rbeloreUteaDcreaxpliattor►dateFM- -" l�rtoi httrard tei navipatton: 6a .Ord�defirm'lrletlon ez fires oie the date,�reacr)bed ttm;FCC1of' m t�lLta�tL"S . � iprl /A p1.0r;" '"'srT>=��wstr toh,oronlFitdatethe'F.CGdenlestfi6applfcatlo'n�.' r : 1i0?tted per FAA Advt "ry Cfrcula� "+ �' '-'Np I�'g for e>iFerbM..oftthe ehacilv�e pe iod of this deterrnin_atio'n rrnrat ja�rr7aAced OFOellvere r=�f!``41341,Chaptei{sj � '� ✓ - V _ -the tssulnp oH)ee at least 15 days prior to the expiration date -- tf the etructure le sub :•:�-Obatructton marking and lighting are not: � � le:i to the licensing authority of the tO. -.'' //neceeaary.�;,r� that A b_Le...•�._,�-�1 c�.a-a�-...�r.(' re+-+_. /irk.. �.r�!;!'•er..`. . Remarks: - r : . �. .., All Its16 ar LEE AM aturW e7* t h .,��' ,=AA Form 7460.1 ra-as) ` DO NOT REMOVE CARBONS �WP a - I ` Radiation Hazard: -The proposal as it exists is far too vague as to the number, operating frequencies, and power levels of the transceivers that will occupy the tower. -No information is presented detailing the level of radiation in the vicinity of the base of the tower. -Electromagnetic emitters are known to cause complex interference and resonance patterns. No information is presented on the radiation hazard caused by the combined interference of the many different components. It is the position of the Orange County Humane Society that the Planning Department ought to require a detailed study of the level and type of electromagnetic energy the array of antennas will actually produce and the potential ill effects on animals and humans living and within it. The Orange County Humane Society concurs with the position of residents that the visual intrusion of the tower substantially detracts from use, enjoyment and value of the surrounding property. If there are any questions or further consultation is desired, please feel to contact me at the Orange County Humane Society. Thank you for your consideration. Eileen Pinder Manager, OCHS I i i e I -- 0 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEAR11 APPEAL OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S CONDITIONAL DENIAL OF CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 92-44,CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO.92-47, NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 92-40 (Proposed Communications Tower) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chambers at the Huntington Beach Civic Center,2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach,California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. DATE/TIME: Monday,February 7, 1994, 7:00 PM APPLICATION NUMBER: Appeal of Planning Commission's Denial of Conditional Use Permit No.92-44/ Conditional Exception No.92-47/Negative Declaration No. 92-40 APPLICANT: Dan Brimlow APPELLANT: Dan Brimlow and Ken Brimlow LOCATION: 8541 Edison Avenue ZONE: M2-0-FP2(Heavy Industrial Combined with Oil with Floodplain Overlay) REQUEST: To "approve in concept" a 310 foot tall communications tower which exceeds the maximum height requirement of 40 feet in an M2 district. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: Environmental Assessment No. 92-40 will also be considered by Council. COASTAL STATUS: This project is in a non-certified area of the Coastal Zone and must be ultimately reviewed and approved by the California Coastal Commission. ON FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file in the Community Development Department,2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach,California 92648, for inspection by the public. A copy of the staff report will be available to interested parties in the City Clerk's office after February 4, 1994. ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend.said hearing and express opinions or submit to the City Clerk,written evidence for or against the application as outlined above. If you challenge the City Council's action in court,you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City at,or prior to,the public hearing. If there are any further questions please call Susan Pierce,Associate Planner, at 536-5271. Connie Brockway City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach,CA 92648 (714) 536-5227 (splp165)