Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutConditional Use Permit 76-36 - GEORGE SHIBATA - Construction Affidavit of P fication State of California t� County of Orange 53 � 1' City of Huntington Bench E George Farquhar, being duly sworn on oath, says: That he Is n citizen of the United States, over the age of twenty-one years. (, That he is the printer and publisher of the Iuntington I3each V f News, a weekly newspaper of general circulation printed and pub- lished in Huntington Beach. California and circulatt-d in the said County of Orange and elsewhere and published for the dissemination of local and other news of a general character. and has a bona fide j a` subscription list of paying subscribers, and said paper has becrr ---------•--•--- -.---..=----- . established, printed and published in the State of California, and l P•sbitssea tfifntih 1460S hills• County of Orange, for at least one year next before the publication f1f�T1t+G ait f. 11IllliMe :`•' of the first insertion of this notice; and the -,aid nen•sp;,{x•r is not •;: ,. devoted to the Interest of, or published for the ^ntertainment of any � � lam= p particular class, profession, trade. calling, rncc or denomirurtinn. or C4tip)fflOtiAt.•El►.� any number thereof. ' ' Notlt�- � IiLIRF,�ir,I}Y�f'�#�jfa The Huntington Beach New %%-a% adjudicated a legal newspaper lit"Peat .wiH;t�►'tr2tli Y is lMii'Ci of general circulatJon by Judge G. IC. Scovel In the Superior Court C9' t �' ►i bf H' ; '1 ore •o A•5 31. .Irr Itta, Caul+Clt C.i}i lief of Orange County, California August '.37th, 1.37 by order h J C ar, �`'�� - the A .�,'__S'i-4���TZONAL_ r.. k'�`PPE�L TQ D �pta ,,e►M, k+�: dori,i In avit to.� �e�6mf r tsernair eta 7b.34 and-Can 1 EXCEPT, #16--3 cic USE FERMI #24��b�_-- ----- tpai�ttio. �-32, try tht a • i'VA I of which the annexed is a printed copy, was published in t:.aio: vs- adjust. s. t9ty f'•►.irtif d,' 36 Is a request to pamlt the eonatrard%n.of a carport to.sat4sfy fhe pYWIr ragalta: paper at least one 18du8 - .. _ ._. _ __. . menu pursuant to Sklkm 0106 and C*% ---- 'dltional Exseptioin tVa, 7w�2 fs.a to permit, • 12'tt, antroocfafr!ant• Int the required 22 M b0bd a. for a:f eornmi,neing from the _ 2 EL._ dny of . -Se-p-temba r_. _.� ... sorry carport in lia,t of 34ctton 41 ;61 thd: ffufitli+Rten •-ankh* •ortftda+lb� Code. The subject.troperty is W.AtM I L_____ and ending on the __Znd day o' *A.tembex on the north side of Oerorr Cirr'o pfotttsr.4teiy bo ft. rill, of CM ,Lan* In the hi (t.ow DeAstty h"111" i lyZ�, both days inclusive, and as often during said perimi and 'District)' A teSs1 deWiptttxa,(a ,°pf . times of publication as said paper was ret;ularly issued, anti in the i nAll the Manning.oeriatr 11K t*d'A' regular and entire issue of said pewspaper proper, and not In a :attend said nearing and,.w0tesi: t>~aIr supplement, ann said notice was published therein on the following 100i"j*ns for W si""st ._seld:Cvrtrfi~ieltit Exgept4nt and, dates, to-wit: ; llse.PQ rr�I IL rd,trif Initr�ttllstiCyl : ts�' iY'tiilil i from the Office-of t.'w %Qif�•tI;' = Se CITY.,0VHVf4yINaTQf4.ft" -- _. _---._---- -- City Cffffk :l ubUsher Subscribed and sworn to before me thL% __-_3_r _ _ day of Notary Public Ornng,e County, California ' THOMAS D. WYLLIE , J Nofapy YubCr Cali+�rPi♦ . . ........ ... . . . . .. . .. .... .I � �II� �� . per! �.,�Vi ,t� t r •! G�it.lt.i r7. ��dQl► ~ ��i'i I r i. 5 71 ��ct•n: �ite C ,, 2 2b47 n� tu::_.c i unI( , J .Clo CAI IF. August 25, 1976 City Council of Hantinrton Beach, City Hall, Huntington Beach, .Cali£ . Hon. Council Members : We wish to appeal the negative zes onses of the Hoard of Zoning Adjustments and the ,sue P t Planning Commission who denied our Conditional Exception �u'�'L�' requests #7f,-32 and 76-36. These would have allowed the construction of a carport with a. 10' setback from the front property line and the retention of a converted garage area as livini, space in our single family dwelling at 3271 Devon Circle . Granting these exceptions wodld have satisfied our living needs and met the provisions of Sec. 9106 of the N. B. Ordinance code . Detailed reasons for this request, and justification of"hardship" are a part of the record in this matter,. The unusual aspect of this appeal lies in the fact that the garage conversion is at least 13, and possibly 15 years old, that it existed 10 years ago when the property was purchased by us . No action was taken by the city during; that period, nor were any complaints filed against it. We feel that purchasers of homes in Huntington Beach should have protection against retroactive action of this type While the r ra tin� of this appeal might not set precedent under these circumstances, we also suggest that an instruction by the City Council not to pursue the enforcement of S--!c . 9106 in this instance because of prior neglect to do so by the City Attorney, need not be .)recedeiit setting either. , and would provide an equitable solution for all parties. Thank you for your attention to, and consideration of , this natter„ � Sincerely, 13dvmrrd S. Brady btarF pet II. Brady Minutes: H. H. Planning Commission Tuesday, August 17 , 1976 Page 6 , APPEAL 'r0 DENIAL � USE PERMIT NO. 76-36/CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 76--32 . Applicant: George Shibata Appellant: Edwarl and Margaret Brady The request is to parmit a 12-foot encroachment into the required - 22-foot setback for a front entry carport in lieu of Section 9106 . 2 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. The subject property is located on the notth side of Devon Circle approximately 60 feet east of Channew Lane in an R1, Low Density Residential D-i.stricv:.. _ , Use Permit No.-- 76-36 is a request to allow the construction of a carport to satisfy the covered off--street parking requirements of � the R1 district . This existing garage was illegally converted to a family room several years ago. The present property owner has filed this request as the result of a recent building violation notice issued by the Department of Building and Community Development . I Conditional Exception No. 76•-32 was filed in conjunction with the Use Permit and is a request to reduce the required setback from 22 feet to-'12 feet for carports that are entered directly from a street. The proposed setbac'r, for the carport is 10 feet from the right-of-way of Devon Circle. I John Cope stated that he had no information to add to that contained in the staff report. The public heating was opened. I Mrs. Brady, Appellant , addressed the Commission and stated that she and her husband had purchased this home ten years ago and at the time they bought it the garage had been converted into a family room. She further stated that she did not realize she was in violation of the code until she received a notice to reconvert the garage back to its original use within a fourteen day period . The Commission inquired as to whet brought about the- notice of violation. Walt Lipps , Building Department representative, stated that the notice of violation was brought to the attention of the Building Department by a -roue of Huntington Harbour residents. r The public hearing was closed. Commission discussion ensued . ON MOTION BY DOYLE AND SECOND BY PARKINSON APPEAL TO DENIAL OF CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 76--32 AND USE PERMIT NO. 76-36 WERE DENIED FOR THE FOLLOWING REASONS BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE : ► -6- 8/17/76 - PC Minutes : H. Planning. Commission , Tuesday , August 17, 1976 Pace 7 1. Subject prgperty is a conforming lot, with no building constraints or unusual circumstances to justify granting of the Conditional Exception. 2 . The applicant has failed to demonstrate sufficient legal hardship to justify granting of the exception . 3 . Granting of this request would constitute granting of special privilege not enjoyed by surrounding residential properties. 4 . The plan submitted is not in conformance with the setback re- quirements of the district in which it is located. 5. Granting of this request with the encroachment- into the required setbacks would serve to establish an undesirable precedent within the City. AYES : Parkinson, Gibson, Finley, Slates, Boyle NOES : Shea ABSTAIN: Newman j. ABSENT: None i APPEAL TO DENIAL SIGN PERMIT NO. 5177 A22licant and A aellant: QRS Corporation This Appeal is to the denial cf a 90 square foot monument sign on the southeast corner of Saybrook Lane ' and Boardwalk Drive. John Cope presented a slide of the area and gave a brief background report on the history of the request. The public bearing was opened. Bob Van Gerpen addressed the Conunission and stated that the pro- posed sign was to be a srift-sell image on the corner of wood construction with no lighting, and that it would be in keeping with the character of the neighborhood. Hans Smith, resident of the area, spoke in opposition to the construction of the sign, stating that it would be totally un- necessary. I ' . The public hearing was closed Commission discussion ensued. ON MOTION BY GIBSON AND SECOND BY SHEA APPEAL TO DENIAL OF SIGN PERMIT NO. 5117 WAS DENIED FOR THE FOLLOWING, REASONS BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: 7- 6/17/76 -• PC Minutes, H. A. Board of Zoning Adjustments July 14, 1976 Page 2 of Main Street approximately 50 feet south of Olive Avenue in a C3 , General Business District. The Chairman informed the Board that this request is a Categorical Exemption, Class V, California Environmental Quality Act, 1970 . The Chairman reopened the public hearl,:g. There being no one present: to speak on the proposed project, the public hearing was closed. Secretary Cope reported that the Department of Building and Community Development has determined that this request will be handled through the Certificate of Occupancy procedures . ON MOTION BY COPE AND SECOND BY LIPPS CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 76-29 WAS WITHDRAWN, WITH THE CONCURRENCE OF THE APPLICANT, BY THE FOLLOW- , ING VOTE: AYES: COPE, ELLSTROM, LIPPS NOES: NONE .. ABSENT: "NONE I � ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW NO. 76--90 (Continued from 7-•7-76) � Applicant: Ralph N. Highsmith To permit the establishment of small shops and a beauty shop in an existing building pursuant to Section 9453 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code , located on the east side cf Main Street. apprcximately 50 feet south of Olive Avenue in a C3 , General Business District. Secretary Copra reported that the Gepnr_tment of Building and Commu:ity Development has determined that this request will be handled through the Certificate of Occupancy procedures . ON MOTION BY COPE AND SECOND BY LIPPS ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW NO. 76--96 WAS WITHDRAWN WITH THE CONCURRENCE OF THE APPLICANT, BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: COPE, ELLSTROM, LIPPS NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 7 6-•3 2 (In Conj ./UP 7 6--36) Applicant: George Shibata M To permit a 10-foot encroachment into the required 22 foot setback for 'a front entry carport in liou of Section 9106 . 2 of the Hunti ngtori Beach Ordinance Code, located on the north side of Devon Circle approximately 60 feet east of Channel Lane in an Rl, Low Density Residential District. The Chairman informed the 'Doard that this request is a Categorical Exemption, Class V, California Environmental Qu;ility Act, 1970. • BZA 7-14-76 Page 2 Pub l ire h 9Z2176 ftetoards fB NOTICE of Ptra.IC NXAKIPC APPB.LL TO.0 Z=PTIOW NO. 76-32 AND USE PERMIT NO. 6-36 WITICE IS HE1tEDY GIVEN that a public hearing Mi 11 be held by th3 City Council of the City of Huntington Reach, in the Council I Charmer of the Civic Center, Huntington Peach, at the hour of Zak, I P. M. , or tls soon thereafter as possible p an the 22tb sixty of Se tember , 19 76 , for the pux se of considering an appeal to denial of Uic Permit No. 76-36 and Conditional Exception No. 76-32 by the Board of Zoning Adjustments. Use Permit No. 76-36 is a request to permit the construction of a carport to satisfy the parking requirements pursuant to Section 9106 and Conditional Exception No. 76-32 1s i a request to permit a 12 ft. encroachment into the required 22 ft. cutback for I a front entry carport in lieu of Section 9106.2 of the Huntington Beach ordinance . Cod*. The subject property is located on the north side of Devon Circle appiorinately 60 ft. east of Channel Lame in the R1 (Low Density Residantial j District) . A legal description is on file in the Planning Department Office. i I I All interested persons are inrikad to att4nd said hearing and express their optniow for or against said ems«.{nwnJim and Use Permit. ru rt eer inforsirtion My be obtained frM the Office of the Clay C urk. MUM ►t tiota K. Vwatnarth �Ity. Clerk USE BALL POINT PEN ONLY—PRE= FIRMLY CASE+ RECEIPT [_,flACITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH p.n. aox»,HUNTIWGTON BEACH.CALIFIIAN1A 22648 1it41 s asl� CITY TREASURER -WARREN 0. HALL 1 ~r l / 0EPT.ISSUING ' `'': AT _ /�- _. RECEIVED FROM .-- Pon J AMOUNT tECEIVED CASH Cl CHECK Ali__- 5- I� 7 s7 )c A.D.A.* ACCOUNT AMOUNT TOTAL No. 4 CUSTOMER ii ''00. Off. UP #76-36 AP's by Jana CB #76-32 178-431-�32 176 -431-40 George Shibata: Pete'r Daletaout Oa r K minnich .610. Nssrport Center Drive 11905 Wiritersburg Avenue 16612 Channel Lane Suite 1500 fountain Valloy, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Newport Beach, Calif 92708 92649 Edgard 178--431-33 178-431••A l. Edward BradyBra circle Albert R Rasai. Fred F Bauchwits t I3u11iD ton Beach, Calif 3341 Admiralty Drive 1662 Channel mane 92649 Huntington Beach, Calif Huntin*ton Brach, Calif 92649 92649 170-431-02 178-431-34 178-431-92 Huntington Partnership Louie R Conk 3261 Devon Circle 1800 'Century Park East 3332 Admiralty Drive Huntington Beach# Calif Suite 1100 Huntington" Beach, Calif 92649 Los Angeles, Calif 90067 92649 1 ' 1.78-431-04 178-431-35 178-431-44 Jahn H Anton Erling K Haase Andre Varese 16581 Channel. sane 3322 Admikalty Drive 3281 Devon Circle Hun,`.irigton Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif 92649 92649 92649 178-431-27 178-431-36 178-431-45 Alice Edgar Mark M Sekulich A Bayard uod Jr ii 100 Hermosa Avenue 3312 Admiralty Drive 3291 Devon Circle i Lang Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calf Huntington Beach, Calif i 90802 92649 92649 178-431-28 176-431-37 179 -431-46 Nelson H McCrady Jr Edwa�td R Davenport George R fbllmer John R Dunfoe 3291 Admiralty Drive Stilwell Inc 3301 Devon Circle 9u�xiaingi:An Beach, Calif 5900 wilabire Blvd Huntington Search, Calif 1 . 2K 9 Suite 110+D 92649 178--431--29 Los Angeles, California 178-431--47 Gilbert M Reel 9003G B C Cooper 3301 -Aft ralty Drive 3311 Devon Circle Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif 92649 92649 176-431-30 178-431.-30 178-431-48 Richard H Korff Jud+ti, A Lougher Oswald M Kir►g 1 3311 Admiralty Drive 3292 Admiralty Drive 3321 Devon Circle Huntington Beach. Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif 92649, 92649 92649 178-431-31 178-431-39 170-431-49 j Clayton. L Solum Harvey E Camborg Charles R Mayer 3321 A mirlaty Drive 16602 CtAnnel Lane 3322 Devon Circle Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beech, Calif 92649 92649 92649 i Ow 10 1 791431-50 178-565-32 178-565-53 wiranae H Weitzel Charles H Caplinger Jr Peter C Muth 312 Dev6n Circle 16672 Intrepid Lane 3171 Remora Lane anti ngon He�ch, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif , 2649 92649 92649 ?8--431w51 178-565-33 178-565-54 ohn D Kenagy Gregory A Grani Edmunde B Garo 54 N Bundy Drive 16U"52 Intrepid Lane 3161 Remora Drive s Angeles, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif O049 92649 92649 78-431--52 178--565-34 178-565 -55 avid Koran Sheldon Solomon 9rentowood Savings & Loar 282 Devon Circle 16656 Intrepid Lane 12601 San V ncente Blvd . uatington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Los Angeles , Calif 2649 92649 900e5 78-431-53 178-565-35 178--565-01 abort F Boone Martin L Blackstone Huntington Harbour Corp 272 Devon Circle 16652 Intrepid Lane 4241 Warner Avenue V ntingcton Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Teach, Calif 11649 92649 92649 ,118-431-54 178-565--36 178-565-02 Robert C ,'`.astin Roger A Mohrhoff B A Berkus Associates I3252 Devon Circle 16642 Intrepid Lane 8430 Santa Monica Blvd Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Los Angeles, Calif 92649 92649 90069 178-432-01 178-565-37 178- 565-03 John D Tokaruk William G turner James P Tolano 16591 Channel Lane 16632 Intrepid Lane 16592 Tiburon Place Ountington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif 92649 92649 92649 178-432-02 178-565-38 178-565-04 viicent B Muth Louis A Troutman Jr Charles A Brodie 16001 Channel Lane 3201 Remora Drive 16596 Tiburon Place Na tington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif 92449 92647 92649 170-432-04 178-565-51 178-565-05 Jack 0 McKenna Rou O S Ching Stanley B Wood 16421 Channel Lane 3191 Remora Drive 16602 Tiburon Place Usitington WwCh, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif ; 92649 92649 92649 178-565.-31 178-565-52 178-565-06 Nm n inik Irving Beckman Walter P Uschyk 166d2 Intrepid Lane 3181 Raaaora Drive 16612 Tiburon Place Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif 92649 92649 92649 ,Atit;••._s...+�..�.........►v-a.+.......,�,,.,.,�,r ..._ .._ .. ........ . .» ,s, sJ,, .. - + r . 1�' -5a507 A,odney,' M P de `16616 'Tiburon Place tuntington Beach, Calif 9. 2A 92649 178-565-08 , Ronald W dodges 16618 Tiburon Place Huntington Beach, Calif 92649 178 5-09 Jo ,8 'McNeill "0622 Tiburon Place Huntington Beach, Calif 92649 { . 178-56&-10 Vera J Butler 16626 Tiburon Place Hunt,,' tots Beach, Calif 92549 - } 17 P 165--11 Pa V Lindstrom 166:02 Tiburon Place Huntington Beach, Calif 92649 178-565-12 Stanley W Sorensen 16642 Tiburon Place Huntington Beach, Calif 92649 17dw565--13 i' Bank of: A'nprica Nt & Sa Tax Dept,. #3245 P.O. Box 37000 San Francisuo, Ca 94137 178-•565-15 Francis B DuMll 16925 S r4cific Ave Q�t. .�ret Imach, Calif 90743 Dept. of transportation 120 So. Spring Street Loa Angeles, Calif 90052 Attn: Staff bgeistant Design B _.' 0. Hunti tBtor� Beech pienninB cnmm3siian P.O. Box 16C CALIFORNIA U646 Honorable Mayor and City Council FROM: Planning Commission DATE: September 13, 1976 ATTN: Fl^yd G. Belsito, City Administrator RE: USE PERMIT NO. 76-36/CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 76-32 : APPEAL TO DENIAL APPELLANT: Edward S. and Margaret H. Brady 3271 Devon Circle Bua Huntington ^..h, California 3 ifornia APPLICANT: George Shibata 610 Newport Center Drive Suite 1500 P ► newport Beach, Calif. 92660 REQUEST: USE PERMIT NO. 16-36 Use Permit No. 76--36 is a request to allow the construction of a carport facility to satisfy the covered off-street parking requirements of the Rr-1 District. CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION 76-32 Conditional Exception 76-32 is a request to permit a 12- foot setback for a front entry carport in lieu of Section 9106. 2 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. LOCATION: The subject property is located on the north side of Devon Circle approximately 60 feet east of Channel. Lane in as R1, Low Density Residential District. PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION: ON MOTION BY BOYLE AND SECOND BY PARKINSON APPEAL TO DENIAL OF CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 76-32 AND USE PERMIT No. 76--36 WAS DENIED FnR THE FOLLOWING REASONS BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: 1. Subject property is a conforming lot, with no building constraints or unusual circumstances to justify granting of the Conditional Exception. 2. The applicant has failed to demonstrate sufficient legal hardship to justify granting of the exception. 3. Granting of this request would constitute granting of special privilege not enjoyed by surrounding residential properties. Page Two plan submitted is not in conformance n r � . The P mance with the setback re- q�uirements of the district in which it is located. 5.' `Granting of this request with the encroachment into the required setbacks would serve to establish an undesirable precedent within the City. AYES: Parkinson, Gibscn, Finley, Slates, Boyle . NOES: Shea ABSTAIN: Newman ASSENT: None PLANNING COMMISSION PXCO1MENDATION: Planning Commission recommends denial of Use Permit No. 76-36 and Conditional Exception No. 76-32 . SUMMARY ANALYSIS : Use Permit No. 76-36 is a request to allow the construction of a carport to :satisfy the covered off-street parking requirements of the R1 district. The existing garage was illegally converted to a family room several years ago. The present property owner has filed this request as the result of a recent building violation notice issued by the Department of Building and Community Develop- ment. Conditional Exception No. 76-32 was filed in conjunction with the Use Permit and is a request to reduce the required setback from 22 feet to 12 feet for carports that are entered directly from a street. The proposed setback for the carport is 10 feet from the right-of-way of Devon Circle. Both applications were considered by the Board of Zoning Adjustment^ at its meeting of July 14 , 1976 and were denied. The applicant thus appealed to the Planning Commission. The Commission in its discussion on the requests considered the intent of the carport setback requirement, which is to enhance pedestrian and traffic safety and vision and to provide for a more desirable street scene. The Commission members felt that there were no unusual circumstances attributable to the subject property, that the applicant failed to demonstrate any legal hardships, and that ouch a setback precedent would adversely affect surrounding properties . The Commission therefore denied Conditional Exception No. 76-32 and Use Permit No. 76-36. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: The proposal is a Class 11 exemption "Existing Facilities, " and is therefore exempt from further environmental -review. Thirei j SUPPORTING INFORMATION: 2. P�,atii�irig Coiistiss3 on," M3.riutes `. f3 Baird of `Zo, il. Adjustinents Minutes Respectfully submitted, r Edwas% D. • Selich secretary' EGS:JMC:gc . . I If ti . Minutes, H .B. Board of Zoning Adjustments July 14 , 1976 Page 3 The Chairman opened the public hearing. Mr, and Mrs . Brady were present to represent their application. The proponents explained the need for the carport and the difficulties imposed upon them by the illegal addition which -had been made to the home they purchased some years ago. There being no other persons present to speak in regard to the proposed project, the public hearing was closed. The Board addressed the criteria of hardship on the property, determining that the property is a conforming lot with no unusual aspects to justify the exception. The precedent-setting . nature of an approval on this request was also considered. ON MOTION BY COPE AND SECOND BY ELLSTROM CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 76--32 WAS DENIED FOR THE FOLLOWING REASONS , BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: REASONS FOR DENIAL: 1. " Subject property is a conforming lot, with no building constraints or unusual circumstances to justify granting of the Conditional Exception. 2 . The applicant has failed to demonstrate sufficient legal hardship to justify granting of the exception. 3. Granting of this request would constitute granting of special privilege not enjoyed by surrounding residential properties. AYBS: COPE, F.LLSTROM, LIPPS NOES : NONE ABSENT: NONE USE PERMIT NO. 76-•36 (Cont. from 6-30-76) (In Conj . /CE 76-32) Applicant: George Shibata To permit the construction of a carport to satisfy the parking requirements pur. uant to Sectior 9106- of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code . located on the north side of Devon Circle approxi- mately 60 feet east of Channel Lane in an Rl, Low Density Residential District. The Chairman informed the Board that this request is a Categorical. Exemption, Class V, California Environmental Quality Act, 1970 . The Chairman opened the public hearing. Mr. and Mrs. Brady were present at the meeting. There being no one to speak on the pro- posed project, the public hearing was closed . In light of the denial of the setback requested in Conditional Exception No. 76-32 , it was the consensus of the Board that the BEA 7-14-76 Page 3 t Minutes, H.B. Board of Zoning Adjustments my 14 , 1976 rage 4 carport would be nonconforming to code and could not be approved. N •MOTION BY COPE AND SECOND BY ELLSTROM USE PERMIT NO. WAS DENIED FOR THE FOLLOWING RE:-.SONS, BY THE FOLLOWINGVOTE: REASONS FOR DENIAL: 1. The plan submitted is not in conformance with the sethack, re-- quirements of the district in which it is located. 2 . Granting of this request with the encroachment into the requnt ithin setbacks would serve to establish an undesirable pre the City. AYES: CopE, ELLSTROM, LIMPS NOES,- NOIJE ABSENT: NONE uSE PERMIT NO. 76-38 Applicant: Barregar, Guest & Strasmann i To permit the construction of a six t pur- apartment building chOrdinanceCode, suant to Section 9162. 3. 1 of the Huntington { h located an the weft side of F,lm Street approximately 100 feet sout . ..Of Sycamore Avenue in an R2, Medium Density Residential District. The Chairman informed the Board that this request was granted Nega Live Declaration No.o. 76-61 b the Environmental Review Board on . July 13 , 1976. c . Blake Barre gar and Joe Guest opened the ubl�.r, hearing. 9 The Chairman op P were present at the meeting . There being no one present to speak on the project, the public hearing was closed. Board review included location of the trash enclosure. The plan was found to be in co nformance �e to code, but the appli cants were cautioned � run of about the possibility of; hiwater install in order to provide adequate ON 'MOTION BY LIPPS AND SECOND BY COPE THE BOARD ADOPTED NEGATIVE DECLARATION No. 76-61 BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYrES : COPE, ELLSTROM, LIPPS NOES.: NONE ABSENT: . NONE _ ON ,M!]TION BY'. ELLSTROM A?J D SCCOND�, BY LIPPS US E PERMIT NO. 76-38 WAS APPROVED WITH THE FOLLOWING FINDINGS AI�U COh�DIT20N , Y THE FOLLOWING VOTE I BZA 7»•14M76 Page 4 City Council City of Hungtington Beach Dear Councilmembers : I am the owner• of the property located at which is in the vicin ty of 3271 Devon Circle, Huntington Beach. This latter parcel is the subject of an "appeal to denial of conditiorial exception #76-32 and use permit #.E76-36" , now pending before you. For the guidance of the Council , I wish to state that I have no objection to the present garage conversion which now exists on the above property nor to its continuance in its present form. 1 Signed r�J Date Comment. Ci ty counit:il City of Hungtington Beach Dear Counci'tmembers: I am the owner of the property located at c2 e62 which is in the vicinity of 3271 Devon Circle, Huntington Beach. This latter parcel is the subject of an "appeal to denial of conditional exception #76-32 and use permit #76-36" , now pending before you. For the guidance of the Council , I wish to state that I no obJection to the present garage conversion which now exists on the above nor to its continuance in its resent form. property P Si gned , 2L:��i Dates �Z: z Z 2(o Comment: THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS WELL MAINTAINED, TIAS NAIL THE EXISTING GARAGE CONVERSION FOR MANY YEARS ANO IS A CREDIT To THIS NEIGIMORIIOOD. IT SHOULD BE LEFT IN ITS PRESENT FORM . City Council City of Hungtington Beach Dear Councilmembers: + I am the owner of the property located at which is in the vicinity of 3271 Devon Circle, Huntington Beach. This latter parcel is the subject of an "appeal to denial ,f conditional exception #76-31 and use permit #76-36" , now pending before you. For the guidance of the Council , I wish to state that I have no objection to the present garage conversion �-.,hich now exists on the above property nor to its continuance in its present form. Signed /��1�'� .r � � � , t Lcc- Date Comment: I "►r,' ��,' AIL f G= :•y, r �.�•C.k..�'--�...L..:.�i�.�� 1._••f..•�.L.,t--•-{..t�...Z�<�'.Lf i����.� .''Sri...l..��...•t�-(.1.�c..;�3 > �[/� �,;7 Cr �"' '✓`:�'."•�""'� 1/` 4•�lr .+'"vl..� �}'�� �r • vow City-council City of Hungtington Beach Dear Councilmembers : I am the owner of the property located a- which is in the vicinity of 3271 Devon Circle, Huntington Beacn. This latter parcel is the subject of an "appeal to denial of conditional exception #76-32 and use permit #76-36" , now pending before you. For the guidance of the Council , I wish to state that I have no objection to the present garage conversion which now exists on the above property nor to its continuance in its present form. Signed � W Date cc� Comment: Ci ty council City of Hungtington Beach Dear Counciln*mbers : I am the owner of the property located at which is in the viCinity. of 3271 Devon Circle, Huntington Beach. This latte'r' parcel is the subject of an "appeal to denial of conditional exception #76-32 and use permit #76-36" , now pending before you. For the guidance of the Courcil , I wish to state that I have no obJection to the present garage conversion which now exists on the above property nor to its continuance in its present form. Sign 1W. Date Comment: City Council City of Hungtington Beach Dcar Councilmembers: I am the owner of the property located at which is in the vicinity of 3271 Devon Circle, Huntington Beach. This latter parcel is the subject of an "appeal to denial of conditional exception #76-32 and use permit #76-36" , now pending before you. For the guidance of the Council , I wish to state that I have no objection to the present garage conversion which now exists on the above property nor to its continuance in its present form. Signed Cormient: City Council City of Hungtington Beach Deer- Counci lmembers: I any the owner of the property located at which is in the vicinity of 3271 Devon Circle, Huntington Beach. This latter parcel is the subject of are "appeal to denial of conditional exception #76-32 and use permit #76-36" , now pending before you. For the guidance of the Council , I wish to state that I have no objection to the present garage conversion which now exists on the above property nor to its continuance in its present form. 4 Signed— Date Comment: 'I City Council City of Hungtington Beach Dear Councilmembers : I am the a neerof the propert located at which is in the vicinity of 3271 Devon Circle , Kuntington Beach. This latter parcel is the subject of an "appeal to denial of conditional exception #76-32 and use permit #76-36" , now pending before you. For the guidance of the Council , I wish to state that I have no objection to the present garage conversion which yr exists on the above property nor to its continuance in its present fo Signed Date i Comment: i I City Council City of Hungtington Beach Dear Councilmembers : I am the owner of the property located at C which is in the vicinity of 3271 Devon Circle, Huntington Beach. This latter parcel is the subject of an "appeal to denial of conditional exception 11?76-32 and use pernnr #76-36" , now pending before you. For the guidance of -the Council , I wish to state that I have no objection to the present garage conversion which now oYists on the above property nor to Its continuance in its present form. Cik' Si fined Date J Comment: i I IN ty Counci l. City of Hungtington Beach Dear Councilmembers: I am the owner of the property located at which is in the vicinity of 3271 Devon Circle, Huntington Beach. This latter parcoi is the subject of an "appeal to denial of conditional exception #76-32 ane use permit 076-36" , now pending before you. For the guidance of the Council , I wish to state that. I hove no objection to the present garage conversion which now exists on the above property nor to its continuance in its present form. f Signed [gate Comment: I ' i 173 Publish 9/23/76 p�inc Postcards 68 NOTICE QP PMIC NWINc CONDITIONAL EXCEPTION NO. 76-32 NOTICE IS KERE Y GIVgN that a public hearing will be hold by the . City Council of the City of Huntington' Beach, in the Council Chamber of the Civic Center, Rmtingtim Reach, at the hour of. 7:00 P. M. , or 1 ai soon thorsafter an possible , on Wednesday, IIIWAIY.WI�1�.�� the 6t1z day of tobe is 1.976, for the purpose of c(maidering Conditional Exception No. 76-32 which is a request to permit they elimination of the required covered parking for an existing single family resi- dence. This exception raquect is in lieu of Section 9106 of the Huntington Brach Ordinance Code. f The subject property is located on the north side of Devon Circle, approx.bwtely 60 feet cast of Channel Lane in the RI (Low Density Residential Distrie:l . A / legal description is on file in the Planning Department Office. All interested persons are invited to attend said hearing and exprtes their opl,nioar for or agatxa t 4aid C.ar►dittt.)nal I:xFnpt Lon 76-32. Further information moy be obcolood #ram the Offices of tb* City r OATXD , CITY 0V NMI"" ISLCH IL Seiyte:�4aer1 zl , 137ti • ��LOLS�6 h.eAtWort r .i w lanet �.�{,,'tip�c.�c rZ�'�-r.��c- -� . �� . ��rs-r�J r �-�- �►•t,.f do toe I J � 01 UP i76-36 AP's by Jana CE #76-32 178-431-32 176-431-40 George Shibat$ peter Dalebout Omer M Minnich 610 Newport Center Drive 11905 Wintersburg Avenue 16612 Channel Lane Suite 1500 Fountain Valley, Calif Huntington Beach# Calif Newport Beach, Calif 92708 92649 178-431-33 178-•431•-41 Edward snarly Edwa Devon Circle Albert R Rossi Fred F Sauchwits 3271 Huntington Beach, Calif 3341 Admiralty Drive 1662 Channel Lane 92649 Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Be+�cht Calif 92649 92649 178-431•-02 178-431-34 178-•431--32 Hur,tington Partnership t Louis R Cpok 3261 Devon Circle 1800 Century Park East 3332 Admiralty Drivp. Huntington Beach, Calif. Suite 1100 Huntington Beach, Calif 92649 Los Angeles , Calif 90067 92649 ► 178-431-35 178-�431-44 ' 78--431-04 John H Aicton Erling W Naess Andrei Vereas ' 16581 Channel Lane 3322 Admiralty Drive 3281 Devon Circle L W c Calif Huntington Beach, Calif i Huntington eeac�!, Calif Iivntingto�. Beach, n9' 92649 92649 ; 92649 178-43:L-47 178-431--36 178-41k-45 Alice Edgar M Sekulich . A Bayard Dod Jr 100 Hermosa Avenue 3312 Admiralty Drive 3291 Devon Circle Long Beach, Calif Hunti.ngtco Beech, Calif 92G49ngtc�n Beach, Calif 90602 92649 178-431--28 178_431-3' 178-431-46 Nelsen H McCrady Jr George R Foll.mer John R Dunfee: Edward R Davenport Stilwoll inc 3301 Devon Circle 3291 Admiralty Drive 5900 Wiltshire Blvd Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Suite 110b 92649 t 92649 178--431-29 Los Angeles, California 1.78-431--4-9 Gilbert M Reel 90036 B G Cooper 3301 Admiralty Drive 3311 Devon Circle c Huntington Beach, Calif 2649 gl:oti Beech, Calif 9 92649 26g4 i 178"431.-30 178-431-39 178-431--48 Richard M Kox'ff Judith A Lougher Oswald M King 3311 Admiralty Drive 3292 Admiralty Drive 3321 Devoe Circle Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif �2649 92649 92649 t .,. � •� --4 3 a.-31 17'8-•431-•39 179-431--49 � i Clayton ?, So?.sun Ilrarvey 39 Umberg Charles R Mayer 3321 Admiraaty Drive 16602 Charinol Lane 3322 Devon Circle Huntington peach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif 9264992649 92649 i : •• . ..... w.+w...r..rrr+ry I�IN114+.wrp r 1 178-431-50 178-565-•32 178-565-53 Lawrence H Weitzel Charles H Caplinger Jr Peter C Ruth 3312 Devon Circle 16672 Intrepid Lane 3171 Remora Lane Huntingon Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, CaUf Huntington Calif 92649 92649 92649 178--431-51 178--565--33 , 178-565-54 John D Kenagy Gregory A Grani F.,dmunde B Garo 354 N Bundy Drive 16662 Intrepid Lang � 3161 Remora Drive Los Angeles, Calif Huntington Beach; Calilf , Huntington Beach, Calif 90049 9264� 92649 176--431-52 178--j565--34 178-565--55 David Doran Shelooin Solomon Brentowood Savings i , 32b2 Devon Circle 16650 Intrepid ?,�ne 1.2001 San Vincente Blvd. , Huntington Beach, Calif ! Los Angeles, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif 92649 92649 = 90049 i 178-431-53 178--565-35 178-565-01 Robert F Boone MartJn L. Oiaekstone Huntington Harbour Corp 3272 Devon Circle 16652 Intrepid Lane 4241 Warner Avenue ` Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif , Huntington Beach, Calif 92649 92649 92649 178-431-54 7.78-565•-36 178-565-02 Robert C Austin Roger A Ho"hoff B A Berkus Associates 3252 Devon Circle 16642 Intrepid Lade 8430 Santa Monica Blvd Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Los Angeles, Calif 92649 92649 90069 176--432-01 . 178-565-03 John d Tokaruk William G Warner James P Tolano 16591 Channel Lane 16632 , I:itrepid Lane 16592 Tiburon Place Huntington Beach, Calif tiuntingt`on Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif 92649 92649 92649 176-432-02 178-•565-38 178-565-04 Vincent B Ruth Louis A Troutman Jr Charles A Brodie 16601 Channel Lane 3201 Remora Drive 1659G Tiburon Place Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif 92649 92647 92649 178•-432-04 178--565-5.1 i 178-565-05 Jack G McKenna Rou O'�S Ching ' Stanley n Wood 1662.1 Channel Lane 3191 IRemo.ra Drive �� 1.6602 Tiburon Place Huntington Beach, Calif Huntington Beach, ,Cali.. . Huntington Beach, Ca; if 92;A9 92649, i 92649 118-565-31. 178--505 '52 178-565-06 IJorman Fai.k Irving 8mkivan Walter P Uschyk 16682 .Intrepid Lane 3181 Remora', Drive 16612 Tiburon Place Huntington Beach, Calif Hurti qt.( i !beach, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif 92649 92649 92649 t ' fr i • ,1'f8-565- U7 Rodney M Ftyd© 1b616 Tiburon Place. _11u' nti ngton Beach, Calif. 22" 92649 179-565-08 Ronald VI Hodges 16618 Tiburon Place funtington Beachr Calif 92649 179-565--09 .Jo B McNeill 16622 Tiburon Place Huntington Beach, Calif . 9.2649 .118-565--10 Vera -i Butler 16626 Tiburon Place Huntington Butch, Calif 1 92649 j 178-565-11 Paul V Lindstrom 16632 Tiburon Place Huntington Beach, Calif '92649 . 11U-565--12 Stanley. W Sorensen 16642. Tiburon Place Huntington Beach, Calif 92649 : Bank of America Nt & Sty T&x Dept. 43245 P.O. Box 37000 San Francisco, Ca 94137 178=-565w15. . :Francis B Duball : 16925 S Pacific Ave sunset Beach, Calif .9a742 .,Dept. -ref trwimportati.on 110 So. .Spring Strout . Los Angeles,' Calif 90052 Attn z Staff Aosiatastt Design. Is . . OF 0 7 5-3 6 XP b by J*D,-k � t CE 0 76--32 � 4. y , Yi 178--431-�:32 � 178-431-40 Gebrge Shibata t Peter Dalebout c Omer M Minn.i.c:h 6.10 Nwwwrt Center Drive I ' i 11905 Wintersburg Avenue '1.6(;1 2 Channel La rW suite Fountain Calif' Iitintington Peachr C.-I l i f Newport beach, calif t � g�y0r� 926,19 - - _ ______________ __ _ - - --_ ------- ___---_--_ _ - -� ' _- __- ____-_- ---_- __-�- -'� I � C:�1►ti'tLt�► BradyI 1?8-'4�1•• .33 I �.79--A.31-�SZ Albert it Roff;ci ' Frod F Bauchwitz 4 3271 . Devon Circler + 3341 Admiralty 1)r. ive 1.662 C'hanw-1 Lane r h` Calif � iiUrktiogton Beac.. , Hu-nti.ngror, Beacil,, Ca ' if fltznti.;zti+ton its-ach, Ca3 if ---.�__- _-_'___ _ __-_-_ -_ r-- - -- ---- g------ -- _ - _ _- � I.7�3-aJL-A ____.._______ _� ).l:1- 451-13,. 17 ' _, • : ` t i Loui!• R Cook I 3l(, l I)c:von ,�ircle► t.iuut.inc to:'� lyaa:�s.c r�.zi. l UOO Century Par� . ;ticlmiralty Tirivi, 1{untirlto,n F,.. ach, Calif +i�l,��� ,�.�1:L7 I ��lirllr:.,:'';t.r}a'k }"%1"i2l.:�ir rY`yl � i ► �+.i�l)i '! 1 ---- ----- --- - ---- --__ - - !. - --- --- - - -- -- - --- -- - - - - - - - - -_- _--_- __ -- -__ -- __- 17�w#3;�•.p,i - � Joha . 13 Nxt.on I Erl i nq w tiauun "Tart vnrrer;s :!.b5dl. Channel Lana- I 3322 Akicr..ixi.ilty Dr ivy: :3261 Devon C;[.-clo i(un:in+ tor► B.c,c.-:;: , CaI'l, t I clulltl ilcltcry: i3c�nc~.I , t�:x� j .i: :itzfir ;n�jtorx Ise. rh, Ca 1,A.r �cli�^ t,.r3gar I Yiai.?; M Se a) l ic'h A !ii ,<<'t-ci Dcw1 Jr: ILiu He: r�•a , •. �'sz:ta}r :tic: iral.ty Drive 3291 Devon ^irc..lc I 17t�r)w i ?'! )7'7 llc.?��'? , +.'.� !. f ' Hut'+t .f n,-4 'on Reach, �,.•6Ii f. i�c"1��..i I `.'�-t• . __ _ _ ___ _ _ _ __ _r_ _ ___ _ ___'_.__ _ _ .. _ __ _ _ _ _ � - -17t�- 1 "i1•-4t� _ .._.._-_ -__ _. I 1.7El-A .3S �•3 . ool.soti H McCriOy Jr,. I i-z►org(, It J<_hr It Dunfc,-e Edward H Uavenffurt Stilwell 111C 33r;: (),avon C_frc l4y 1.3211 -Admiralty UriVe 5900 wi: E bi—f: S1..,k � Ilkint:rttxton reach , C;41 i.',. Ifunt1f gt.on 1jenc'h, C-ili.i I :�tait c� I :�1t) 9.1E:,,t� - �1 --- - - -. _ --- _ _ _ _ — _ _ — _r - - - - _ — .- _ _ _ _ _ — _ — _ - - - - - _ ' - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - 17 .,431- 9 Le.)- �trkle�les , �:zlizc:� :�it� - i 176- 4.31 -47 ' Criibart~ M Reel � l��� '3t+ ' b t► Co,;pe'r j; 01 -Aclmi.raIty Drive; I ; 3311 Devon Cire10 I I Etutzt irviton 1.)eltc��t, hunt$x _ -`_ - -- _ _ - - _ -_ - -.,- - - _. -r-- -.`/{- --_ - -- - - --. - - ._"1tt.-�3x-3G I Zr � 4_.�1-3i1 f 3 4 31 -43 I ftic:hard K Kor f L Carr WA 1 f.? JAI FwtpirAlty Drive I 3292 A6AJ.rmlty Urivo. Uuntlagtott Dosch, i.'n lif I Ruryt.im wrat3. floac b, Ca Ily I Non t:.wIt on f, -' 1'.:.431- I1 �- 17It-- 4.31-3U I 17ts-41 ! - i9 .`. ty; text Y� �tai.0 l I 11arve y E Gc anoxc Ch:tri.cz , FL M y�+r r ive il�urik .t �;#trorx ae. a 'n, Calif I Hunt'trgtox �+c9e�!�.. i'ly l.f.f tl:ant±inc;t-c,t1 k1a=,ttc�jz. z�ai.if. •• • L - - - w - - _. - - - - - - - - _ tin'�,- _ -u M... M - M .-y _ _I_ -. - V -r 4 h M T 'r 'ti I - _ • 17b 43JL"50 1.78-.565•-32 178-565-53 Lawrence. li Weitzel Charles if Caplingcr Jr Peter C Ruth 331.2 uevdn Circle16672 Intrepid Laren 3171 Remora I..anu Huntingon Beach, Calif Huntington Beach. Calif Huntington Beach, Calif. 92649 92649 92649 178--431.-51 178-565-33 178-565--54 John D Kenagy Gregory A Grani F.dmunde B Garo 454 N Bundy Drive16G52 Intrepid Sane 1 3161 Remora Drive L08 Angeles, Calif Huntington Beach, Calif tiunt~ing4ton Beach,. Calif 90049 92649 92649 - - - - - - - - - - - 1i8 178-565--55- 432-52 • fihel.dun :�olcrnr�n Are�ntowoo Favi nci ; David l3oz'a ri . 32tl2 Devon Circ1tL 1.6656 Intrepid Lane 12001 San Vircente FAlvd Huntington tie,z..;�, <.'.aii.f Huntir.�,t.0n 6e�ac�1, Calif � Los Am,e�les, Calif ,$ 1b99 y264 5 9Qr14�! ' Hobert F bocnv Martin l., binch tor,i- tluntino on Harbour Cc%rp 3272 Devon Circle Intrepid 4241. warner Avenue .• Hunt.ington beach, CaI i ; Hunting -onbeach, Calif Huntington Beach, � al if 92649 92649 92649 �+ wI.79w431»•54_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ - - _ ; 17E •-SGS--O, _ _ _ _ _. _ _ __ _ _ _ _ - Robert C Aurtin Roger A Mohr'hni`f H A Berkus Acsociaten 32:�2 Devon Circle 16642 Intrepid Lane 8410 Seknt:a Monica n1vi.l iuntington Beech, Calif Huntington Beach, Cal if Lis Anneles , Calif 926X9 91649 90069 D-s-•432•-til. I'll b-56 '•'_0_1_ - _ t John D Tokaruk William G Wac•rier Jamen P 'Ilan 16591 Charuiel Lance 16632 Intrepid x.aroe 1659: Tiburon Place Huntington beacth, .�a 11 `• Huntimit:on k vikc h , . � a " 936� 9 f f intinytt►n : each, "r 11 fi 9264µ 92649 Vincent D RuUt Louis A Troutman it- A HrMie .16601. Channel lane 3201 Remora Drive 16594; Tiburon Place c: Huntington Beach, Call " ff inc: ington He Ach, CCm 1. i f }ienf irtcltc1n Ucyach, Calif 926419 92647 _ 1.7t1•��t31-t?.� _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _._ _._ .. .�•�� .;65-51 '7d`56 5-,0 5 Jack G lstcKe3nm Rou 0 S C h i nq Stanley D hood ;. .16621 Channel Lane: 3191 Hernora Orive. 16602 Tiburon l'lactr r . Huntinytan Beach, Calif liu»tington Besaeh, Calif ifuntinkitor. Beach, Calif `. 92641) f,• 92649 92649 " .i'i 565- 52- _ _ _ _ _ - - - _ _ _ _ • _ 278-•aEi --Ot+ + --- �."*.Mwrman I1aik Irving Heckman ii.3lter iy tfnchvk Intrepid Lanes t 3181 Remora Drive 16fi12 I'iburc.�r. f►lace i 'i?-111untington Beach, Calif itunt i ngt on D aach, Calif iiur,t.ington lioac,~h, ra 1j.f,' 9::649 t 92649 926.49 J i.r.'.r:.r.:w.•+•r...—.,..—., —— —...—— _ r__.._ . .....v .._ ..... _ .. + ..._ .._. w .. ._ .. _ .n w... ... .. .. _ ... ... ... ._..-.. _.w_.......w._ w...... r:" ' '•r I. t - ---- � - - - - - - - - -- _ _ _ _ .-__ - _ �-_ ._ .. _ _ _ _- - ___ _ %odney M Hyde :`I:• 616 Tiburon Place ' I Huntington .Beasch# Cg i ltX to 97649 04-565-08 � Ftraz��lc� �' 3.tcx.Ige� � I 16618 Tiburon Place Huntington Beach, .Calif 9.26*45 i t 16622 Tiburon Place I t - - - - - - -- - - - - - -- - - a, t _ _ _- _ --_- _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ -i- - _ - _ - - .- _ _ _ _ - ; - - - - -- V era ,J Hiltbur 3.s 626 '3`I.burun flat:e � t J Hunt.ington menc:ti, calif ; J 92649 _____ _ _ ___ I ___ _ ___________ - . -- - ,i -- --______- ___!___ _ _ __ ___ __ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ I.` + Paul V LitylNt.rom ' l 16632 Tiburon Place ; iiuntington beach, Calif 92649 ; 170--565-12 ~�+ i ;y'L1q!'i�iiV i� SoX'en,6w, t I I 16642 Tiburon Plac:r. I I Huntington beach, Calif I „ZEc�t9 � Bank of twerica lit 1, IS a i I ` Ta.% Dept. 03245 � t . P .O , Box 37 000 � i s a n F ray ru:.i ra c:o, C;i 9 4 13 G _ --------------- - - - - --- -- -- --- - - - --- - -- --- ---- ----__ _-_ __ ___-_-_-_ - f. �lai,c a H t u'Un I l I .�G925 g Pacific Ave S1 I.But. 110ach, Calif i ~_-_ _ _- _ _ ___ _ __ •_ .. _ -__-_- -___ _______ ____________. Of t"W'Opor.to tioli � .-----r -w__ _ -r V M__ _ y r rt+•• �'r'