Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutConditional use permit 89-9 - International Red Onion - To p i JO'Millie r� A. 'inow6d 10 ,0•ibr+lll Adrer1rst,mLgn1,. of joII 1 end{ nccludin ;'lubt+c / ~•Y �.,+Iy nr,,t(g1 by CJ*Cro# of Iho 5t,p,,r,rr Cburl 01 Orange County. Cr-avenla, Hunobar A-62141• ditlfrc 29 Soplambat. 1961. •n0 �• _ 1 ` (r A-?4s31, dated 11 Juno. 1 163 STATE OF CALIFORNIA County of Orange r.crt »01w. Aa.601" cp.vwr a by wl Ir 0%de-A: N .« in OWd W41h 10 pcs cPfttfff% I am a Citizen of thn United States stnd a resident of the County aforesaid; I am over Ihi age W eighteen ,r✓ r years, and not a party to or inlero.eled in the below entitled mWier. I am a principal Clerk of the Orange iloaast DAILY PILOT, with whir„) is combiner/ that Nk-WS-PiRESS, a n6wspaper of g6neral circulation, f printed and published in the City of Costa Most. , .1 County of Orange. State of California, and that a V� Notice of of which copy attached hereto is a ?rub end t:omplete copy, was printed and published In the C:,sta Mesa, Newpo,7 Leael+, Huntington Ceach, Fountain Vallsy, trs in the South Gast communities and t,ajuna I5dai;r. Issues of said newspaper for c'"f3lticutlVe weeks to wit the issue(s'p of .-May 25., ilia.____ I darlaire, under penalty of perjury, that the foregoft is true and corn c:. Executed on _....W►L.25.w....._.r...,._, r 19d 9 If Costa Mesa, California. r Sigttrl�tre �9 -2 , C' up , I s PROOF OF PUBLICATION � Y ' 'a ` .000 r r ' 14 0 '0 'iY'''L'+1''+' '.tR• ,, It is the position of the Red anion that the Planniag Comynission ruled in error baaed on ,the fc1lowing reasons: 1 . Several people who spoke in opposition matte falue and misleading etateuert6 lending the Coaxission meabrer•n to boli-eve otir plan was inaccurate and the Red Onion was virilattng soning regulations. 2 . Upon the ani)ouncement of this item for Public Hearing Commissioner Slates publicly commented that no matter what was said his intentions were to deny our request and further stated that he had ties with the Costal Commission and they would never approve this application. We feel that those tents mts will as other derogatory remarks made by commissioner Slates before any testiLaony was given denied us a fair and iupartiai hearing. As to finding no. 1 there will be no additional noise generated i as this is a public walkway facing a busy harbor area. Th s space was designed and approved for public use end the sound of a small group of people having a quiet brunch could not be overheard above the noise of the many boats in the harbor. In addition, the 1inited hours of operation should not disturb any persons residing in the aria. Am to finding no. 2 the ;persons utilizing the dining area are the persons working and residing in this area. The decision to dine at the Fled Onion is one made of choice. we simply request tha same nights en juyed by every other busintit:r and resident in the area . Virtually every Broadeeoor resident has patio furniture outside as well as every restaurant in Peters Landing. The Red Onion is the only one not allowed this i privilege. ..s to finding no. 3 by creating a place for the public to sit in sight of the shops in Peters landing we feel this would give the other ±aerdhants +exposure without the detrimental effect of .:outdoor advortlaing. Thia mast likely will increase business thus raising property v-luea and generating additional sales tax for the City. The proposed use would be for the overall benefit of Paters Landing. 1Pinding no. 4 states that our proposal would narrow the walkway co e1 and Mould conflict with thk spirit of the Coastal iswicn intent for a 10' public accessway. At no time would our proposaI create anything less than loll of rccessway. In fact, with the aftitioh of landsoape planters we feel this would add to the beauty and create a warmer and more people friendly atmarphn%- It is the spirit of the Costal Commission that r ireM this area to be dedicated for the public use and e mart. Our customer are the public and it will be them who enjoys this a"a the most. o'A woo j r 1 . The past prcbleas betwfcn the Red Onion and area residents hava beer. a result of our night club operation. This requiter if gran•_cse would be an important stop An cultivatiaq tine rest&u rant wrket thus reduc.inq our economic dermndence on the night club portion of our bucine46 '"he pod Onion has made important strides in rolvirg so" of V!6 past problems and will continue to do so vi.*h gylut help and support. It is truly our desire to be good neighbors and a valuable asset to the coaeeunitV, Wo respectfully request your consideration on this matter. i Respeotfully sutaittod, TAIT i ASSOCIM281, INC. �441&M;v 44 . ;9*04 William D. Fancher 1 g1.4 i i 0 h / { 1 r k�•• �• r, p+r• �;� _ .11.•�, �• .�li II (�\� .�.� i._ '•i�lY '� •�ram•r1 I ���+� :�.',,,���,'�� 1�•�.� t�� i'1,�. _�r�.'�i� !! �'1• .1 •.7 •r• rir •1. -• .. �•t , •i�y••r Y • '♦.11•.�4•r y/}�•r'� �Y" 1" r ..,t t. .I. • 1 •.lv •,. .•.• .. • 'I •• . .. 1 / t e' (IV 1 :`.'..57�•,�Z'']� PI ti',� • , . r . • .► .' -1� •)).ma�y `F 41 � ri.I •r . I 1 ' .. �. •�r •. �, t r .� .• ,ram , •Dr._ �.v..r'�'• '�i� �' ' 7'Y', •' + No N.lAhcm am* 7ArT w =�% 0• Fs?+ChK �• Ca rFAS 1'foJ�ef Mbyq* (714)dl'if 4M FAX 1 1• , + 1 J 11 I' ' r �W '• v . - vcrr tloww , • ��,` � � u µwti��h I , r j 91 T y��' -in Tit fA f,t� �' ,� •!' . r y .. ttldMt+'N�7iri� 'elwy�+qrl � � �► . i + i i AD 1-i- i?? n o is be � I1� } T'!� ::J>':"f�:: . ••4;��?.4; i .L'li(': . l r.".1 C! � �C� 15 �.1 ' , am! :1 b e c i l.i s&y the docks ti r e 1': ','tn 1 "-I1;.1111, . 1.� load by r10 feet , creating inadequate J.-or the ar:r. king lot for ,tic'. L.*, �,ti c9 p. rSi:. .!lti i.(9 , Ct l.11J uvHrburdened , T� �r�� , , l.1 .1 > . �? �� 1. i i }ant;,-.nt"ia� �, c> E.A ir:c� cYfL .. . i1n»ac-L- i-o taatorways in the H(I . i)rop,.)!;ed ):oat: --dyers-ely impact: an existing C-- AP1' iCAN'i.' ; Red Onion The: )r oposed request; to permit outdoor dining on a nw:rtion of a publics walkway adjacent to tithe Iled onion Restaurant located in Pei:er ' a Landing . The proposed project is categorically Exempt pursuant tc Class l., Section 15301 of the California Environmental Quality Act . MAML- M'-U.d: Porter ' s Landing was originally approved by the California woastal Commission in 1976 . Approval of ;:hea project included a condition that a 10 foot wide public walkway be completed ►.nd open to the public. . The wal kpp ay was to be. locaterl adj accent to the marina bulkhead alo:.q the entire waterside boundary of the complex . Because the regi,-Ir.ement for a public walkway Gas imposed by the California Ccastvl Commission, the proposed outuoor dining within L"*-at %irea must by reviewed and approved by the Coastal Commission. Should the Plnnninq Commission approve the project , it will be an "Approval in concept" only. HTAFZ RECQMWM TION Approve Conditional, Use Permit No . 89-9 with findings and conditions of approval . Commiasione+r Elates said he would be voting against the proposr.l becabse he did not feel that tho coastal Commission would appr(Ave the request . PC Xinut*s 4/4/$9 -ll.-- (2487d) r W ' 101 ri• .}X, r . •/ram , , 441 r CLINK HUN 71NC r jiTr OF i 11Wr a n=.a,NdC 1 1�H, C A j r. ca OWMAka ehormn 1141 JU4 g gas II May 26 , 1969 TArr The City of Huntington Beach Cf f ice of the City Clerk 200 Alain street Huntington: Beach, Ca 92648 .Att-n: Connie Brockway Dear No. brockway: Re: Appeal of Planning Corr,- t scion l s Denial of C.U. P. 89-9 Tait & Associates, Inc. has been ceear? oyed by then Red Onion to assis`~ then in aolving the many protlenr, that exist between themselves and the adjoining property owner-A. I we feel tr at the denial f_ror the planning Commission is a direct result from these problems . Over the last month, we have built sound walls, realigned the sound systes, closed off windows , and implemented new procedure policies. However, additional time Is needed to zee: If these lmpro7mments %ao infact nitignte current situat{ona, it is our desire at the ti'- n of the h.carin►g to preeevit -the Council with a proven plan that is permanent solution 'to an ongoi:.,g r=Giul�1. so its light of theme facts, respee+-*idly request that this "Etter bv) continued for 20 days . The Rend anion wiiahes Iwo be a goad n*ighbor and a valuable asset to the ronmunity and would appreciate Itha opportunity to prove so. 1 Respectfully, TAIT & ASSWIATZS, INC. SILL FAMCARR /gd r' Jr, 5'' N. 6okhol 81, 1 I.O. Box 4429 1 Oran. CA W131('i14)IS44 0b 1 (?14)&9A4= PIAX comb CITY OF HUNTINGTMI BEACH 2OOi� hiQ�N STREET CALIVORNIA 92648 OFFICE OF Tr'4 VT CLERIC i I July 6 , 7. 969 Tait & Associates , Inc . tiLO N. Eckhof.f Street P.O. Box 4429 Orange, Ca . 92613 Attn: Bill FArcher Phe City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at Its ,July 5 , 1989 meeting accepted your withdrawal of your appeal relative to the Planning Commission ' s denial of CUP 89-9 . Sincerely , Connie Brockway City Clerk CRtbas cc 1 Mike Wamsa Community Development director M ' it 1 ITS, 7171 v . RBI v I REQUE T FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION Deft June . 5�9 _ gebftW to: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members Submi by: Paul E. Cook, City Administrator s � rexliry; Mike M&ms, Director of Community Developme ,b A1aPRAL (IF PLAIMAnG COMIS►SION"S D►MICAL OF ODMDITIOEAL UEZ PEMIT VO. 89-9 Corn swa with Council Policy? Yee ( l Now Policy or Exa"lon $tatwrwrt of I.*N, Ricomn'Iandetiall,/elrfslyni:, Funding Source, AhernNtiwr Aotton:, Atfaolomsnts: f { KK,fig IWM» ' Transmitted for your consideration is an appeal by Tait Associates representing lntearnatl anal Red Onion to the Planning Commission° s denial of Conditional Use Permit No . 89-9 . Conditional Use permit Igo. 89-9 is a request to permit; outdoor dining adjacent to the bulkhead on a portion of a public walkway (west side of restaurant) . Planning C12i ninsion &jQ=,;1ndAtJgg., The Planning Commission rer omaiendi that the City Council uphold the Action taken by the planning Commission on April 4 , 1969, by denying the a p"a 1 and Conditional Use Permit No. 89-9 . On Xpri 1 4 * 1989 , the Planning Commi,ision took the following action : A D1D' ION "AS N"R.' 9i SLATES AND 1'.'TCOND 8Y WILLIAMS TO DENY C;O1NDIT1011AL USE PSAIT SO. 89-91 BY THE FOLLOWING MOTE: AYES., Slates, Leipzig, Williams , Mountford NOES: nourguignoa, Firkland {=" ABSENT: done A90fr 1tli: None Cr - - C7 rJ rt ct � cr n 16 T p roposmd outdoor dining expansion will not be compatibi�--,�, V1i.A� 4djaaent properties due to noise and additional activity . aeaeeiated With Loutdoor dining . it Us establish ent, maintenance and operation of the outdoor dining expiL"sion will be detrimental to the general welfare of persons wolking aT residing in the vicinity. Noise and activity generated will be Incompatible with adjacent �,. coadmialm deg,%elopamnt , r\ 4 ' paa 3 . The establishment , maintenance and oper+atiin of the outdoor dining expansion may to detrimental to the raltic of the property and improvements in the. neighborhood . 4 . The proposed outdoor dining expansion conflicts with the spirit of the Coastal Commission' s condition for unobstructed access along the walkway. The dining area proposed narrows to a ariniaw:a 4 foot which is inadequate space for dining and still maintain a 10 foot walkway. Additionally, the presence of diners on the public walkway may intimidate they public and discourage their use of the area . Staff itecommandation ; The Planning Staff recommends thrit the City Council reverse the action taken by the Planning Commission can Apri'_ 40 1989 , by approving the appeal and Conditional Use Permit No. 89-9 with findings slid conditions of approval (seer Attachment No . 1) . Appliegnt/ Appellant: Tait and Associates/xnteirnational Red Onion Location: 16450 Pacific Coast Hip wa, (Peter' s; Landing) The applicant is proposing 3 two-person tables and 5 four-person► tables for aN total of 30 seats along the west farads of the roistaurant facing the marina , Tt s outsic!e dining area is proposed to ba used between the hourr of 10: 00 MA and. 3 :00 PM on Saturdays and Sundays only. A minimum 10 foot wide walkway as reguirond by the Coastal Commission will be maintained. Parking required for Peter ' s Landing by t .e City's parking ordinanue totals 714 spaces . There are currently 743 syacen available (a surplus of 19 Spaces) . The proposed azpansion of the Red Onion by 282 square feet will generate the need for only 3 morrit parki_tg spaces . Therefore, the ' proposed outdoor Laing area is not anticipated to create additional parking problem. Concerra: . ,1�sva been revised regarding the potential noise that would be go-terated,i by outdoor dining. T:Ae Broadmore Condominium complex is ,`jst6d directly to the north of the proposed outdoor dining a-oea ,. Should ihe City Couniuil apprLiVo Conditional use permit No . 89-�J# %:he proJoct would be conditioned to most the Citf' s Noise Ordinance ($action 8.40 of the Huntington Beach Municipal Code) . In additiono the project would be conditioned to prohibit music or any Other noise froo b*109 aired on outside speakers, '"he hours that the applicant is . proposing as well as the outdoor ..-;ning area' s 01084 ,proximity to the busy herbour Mould seem to eradicate that any noise generated by that outdoor dining area Mould have Little or no irVact on the adjacent residents. r '. Wh i13/cq -1- (3775d) womb 'When Peter' s Landing was approved by the Coastal Commission its 1976 , they project was conditioned to provide r minimum 1-!.-foot wide walkway adjacent to the marina Sulkhoad along the entire waterside boundary of the complez. The project has been conditioned theL no curtains or other devices he uued to isolate the outdoor dining area and adjoining walkway from the continuous walkway system. In addition, a condition is included to provide some form of separation between tha table area and the 10 foot walkway by providing additional trees , landmcaping and/or rope, . ",fatal Status; Peter ' s Landing was originally approved by the CaliforrlA Caattal Commission in 1976 . Approval of the project included & eondi�ion that a minimum 10 foot wide public walkway be completed and npen to the public: The walkway was to be located adjacent to the m-%rina bulkhead along the entire waterside boundary o, the complez. Because the requirement for a public walkway wake imposed by the California Coastal Commission, the proposed outdoor dining within that area must be reviewed ax!,d approved by the Coastal Commissiono . Should the City Council approve the project, it will be an Oapproval in c uncept" only and forwarded to ' he Coastal Ca!wsission, XmIrOmAnntal Ststm: the proposed project is categorically exempt r,ursuant to Class 1, Section 13301 of the California Enviromental - Quality Act . OMING Not applicable . M ACTION: As an alternative, the City Council may a:�prave the appeal and Conditional Use Permit No . 89-9 for a 90 -day trial period with findings and conditions of approval . 1 . Staff ' a re commended V.ndings for approval and cr.t;1. 1itions of approval 2 . Applicant 's letter of appeal 3 . Deduced plans of the appl,icant ''a proposal 4 . planning Comiasion minutes dated April 'S , 1* 19 S. PlannAng Comisarion staff report dated Ape?. !. 1909 WA - 6/5/49 -3- (2775d) STAFF RECOMMMED FINDINGS AND COND'.TIONS OF APPROVAL FIJIj?JIGS ,WVAL 1 . The estrablashrnent, maintenance and operation of the outdoor dining on the walkway will not be detrimental to the general nealEare of persons residing or working in tti vicinity: a. The hours of operation (10 : 00 AM tj 3 : 00 PH on Saturday; and Sundays only) and size of the proposed outdoor dining area will not create an adverse noise impact on the adjacent condiminium development . 2 . The propos'e1 outdoor dining will be compatible with adjacent residential properties with the restriction placed on the use permit rega7ding number of tables , hours of operation and compliance with the City•s poise ordinance. 3 . The establishment# maintenance and operation of the outdoor dining will not be detrimental to the vAlue of the property and improvements in the neighborhood . 4 . The proposed outdoor dining will not conflict with the Coastal Comission's condition for unobstruc*,,ed access along the walkway, The use will also be subject to review and approval of the California Coastal Commission. 5 . The proposed outdoor dining will not have a detrioental e�fect an parking for Peter ' s Landing due to the size of the operation. ,:asoisY a all -;d: 1 . The alto plan receivid and dated March ,28, 1989 ; shall be xevise►d depicting the modificationo described herein: e. A ld-foot wide publ#A. walkway shall remain free and clear of all obstacles, including landecaping. The 4pplicant shall, devise ar :weans acceptable to the Di nectar of Coy pity Development to ^learly delineate the 10-Eoot wide public walkway from the table/dining era& . 3 . Pxior to commencing the outdoo.. dining use, than fallowing shall be completed: a. The applicant shall su:,+it a letter from Peter 's Lending authorising outdoor stet. + ce in conjunction wi*.h brunch service, b. The appliea nt' c plans shall be reviewed and Approved by the California Ccsstal Commission. A Copy of the approved blab y, shall be submitted to tho Department of Community `�' peveloi�t. E: . '' Attachment 1 J. i' t91F r i.`1 � i d p „• 3 . The use shall comply with the City' s noise Ordinance (Section 8. 40 of the Municipal Cnde) . 4 . The hours of operation for the outdoor dining aria shall be i limited to 10 : CO AAA to 3 : 00 PH on Saturdays and Sundaye . 5 . No more than 30 seats shall be allowed as shown on the approved floor plan. G S . Ho onsic or any other n.A se shall be aired over the loudspeaker system on the outdnoyr patio. 7. Physical barriers which Could impinge on this public use of the lb ' wide walkway Zuch as curtains or ropes , ' shall be prohibited. G . The development shall comply with all applicable provisions of the Ordinance Code* Building Divisicn and Fire Department . Exiting requirements shall be reviewed and approved by the Building Division. 9 . This conditional use permit shall not become effective for any purpose until an "Acceptance of Conditions* form has been properly executed by the applicant and an authorised representative of the owner of the property and returned to the Planning Divisionj and until the ten day appeal period has elapsed . 10. S:auld the California Coastal Connission. approve the applicant 's request, the Planning Commission shall review the use withla one year to determine if the conditions are being complied with and if those conditions are adequate. 11. The Planning Commission reserves the right to %evoke this Conditional use permit if any violation of these conditions or the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code occurs . Additional tables � or choice placed an the welkway beyond Chose expressly allowed by this use permit shall constituter a violation of the conditions of approval. 13. This Conditional Use 12ormit shall bucoaua null and void unless ease .-used within one (1) year of the date of final approval by the California Coastal Commission or suu'ala extension of time as � r"3r be granted by the Planning Commission pursuant to a written request oubs4tted to the Planning Department a minimum 30 days prior to expiration date. "i Attachment ent 1 � i r. R 10 . mrra �rrc. NUMT14tYNtI &EACH,CAL f.. j April 14, 198D The City : of. Auntington Beach 3000 Main St. Huntington Brach, CA 92648 Attn: City Council Rea International Red Onion C.U.F. / 80-8 Honorable mayor and Members of the City Counoi.l , This letter shall serve as on Appeal of the Planning Commission ' decivion regarding the abcrved referenced matter: On Burch 7, 1988 the International lied Onion filed a request for outdoor seating at its Huntington Harbor loco•.Lion. This application was nct based on economics but aimply to accommodate the many customers who request outdoor tables. On April a, 1989 the Planning Commission denied our application based on the, fallowing findings. 1. The prap wwA outdoor dining expansion will not be compatible with adjacent properties due to noise and additional activity associatsd With outdoor dining. Z. The astablIshment, maintenance and operation of the outdoor dining expansion will be detriw'.tal to the general welfare of persona. working or residing in the vicinity. Noise and activity generated will be incompatible with adjacent Goindowiniun &�velopment. 3. . establ ic at, saintenanoo and operation of the outdoor . dining w.;, jisian may be detrimental to the value of the PC peaty mW improvements ir. the neighborhood. 4. The outdoor dining eYpa�ian conflicts with the spir t of the Coastal ComaLssion's condition for unoMtruot*d acca ►rs along the walkway. The dining area JP11 0 »WsVws to a mininin 4 foot which is inadequate awn tar dining mg stilt sainUin a 10 foot walkway. itlwally, tha prereson► of *in*" ..on the public walkway my intimidate ths. publio and discos~+aq�r tajwir aunt of the area. 1 NO 80"f 8t.I P.O. %x 44N 1 Oran., CA =$181 (714)83448W 1 (I 1419344= FIAX �,k 1 • w Y weir i THE PUBLIC HEART ING WAS OPENED . Ralph Sal.tsenan , in attorney representing lutern3tional Red Onion , aroke in ►upport: c:f, the requo-st. . He fled Onion rind worke(3 with the community aitd H) uadm,ire Hoinconw©rt� hssoci atio:i to ini.►:igate any proularns that may oc%cur . Eli).). Fancher , reprauenting Jtit:ei:nat:iunal Red Onion, spokes in s•Jpport of tKa request . Ji.my Loizides , bar manager of Inter.nat.ion3 ;l Red Onion: spoke :.n support of the request , Vernon, Dockendorf , 19402 MacQregor , patron u:: International Reid Onion spoke in support- of the request . Richard Dorsey, 3221 Francois , spoke in opposition to the request . He was opposed to the reduction in the public walkway. Carol Swanson, 16"65 Martin Lane, spoke in opposition to the request . She complained that the noise from the set up and clean up crews was a concern 'Co the residents . Richard Marcoulliear, 3201 Moritz Drive, spoke in opposition to the request . He questioned the possibility of maintaining the 10 foot minimum public walkway with 4 foot tables in the proposed area . Merolla Dorsey, 3221 Francois , w concerned due to International , Red Onion lack of concern for thi residents in the area and also stated that the measurement for the public walkway was inaccurate. I In response to public testimony-, Hill Fancher reported that he took the measurements and that the measurements were accurate. There were no other persons present to speak for or against the re quest and the public hearing was closed . A MOTION WAS MADE BY SLATES AND SECOND BY WILLIAMS TO DENY CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO . 83-9,, HY THE FOLLOWING VO'A. OE; AYES : Slates , Leipzig, Williams , Mountfola NOSS : Eourguignon, Zirkland ASSEM'Z: None A0611AIN: None NOTION M55M 1 . The Proposed outdoor dining expansion will not be compatibie3 with adjacent proper`,ins dues to noise and ndditional activity associated with outdoor dining. PC Minutes 4/4/89 -12- e F, ,y k, a 1 2 . The establishment , maintenance I end operation of the outdoor dining expansion ;rill be detr. iui.:. I:a l to the general welfare of persons working or residing in the vicinity . Noises and activity generated will. be incompatible with 3d j acent condominium development . 3 . The establishment , maintenance and operation of the outdoor dining ezp:�insion may be detrimental to the value of the property and improvements in the neighborhood . 4 . The proposed outdoor dining expansion conflicts with the spirit of the Coastal Commission ' s condition for unobstructed access along the walkway. The dining area proposed narrows to a minimum 4 foot which is inadequate spare for dining and still. maintain a 10 foot walkway. Additionally, the presence of diners on the public walkway may intimidate. the public and liscuuxage their use of the area . U ADP-1 LIMITED srGN PERMIT NO. 89-1 APPLICANT: Steve Therkiault united Sign permit: No . 89-1 is a request to modify two existing ' ti-tenant freestanding signs at an office complex .,outhw a 3terl of rner a,%4 Solsa Chi,r.a . They applicant is requesting to add ur 30 sq re foot identification par.els for Coldwell Banker to side og he two signs . Section on 9610 . 8 (c) of the taunt ington ach � Ordinance ode specifies that the planning Commission may low a change of e for nonconforming signs and extend their a for up to two years . A cash bond ici required to guarantee lt�hplr removal at that time. : Approve Limited Sign P mit No . 89--1 with fi ings and conditions of approval . . THE PUBLIC HEADING WAS OPEN Curt Bauer, representing Coldwe B iker, spoke in rupport of the request . He said they should not a responsible :or the Harbor Diagnostics portion of the sig David Giipin, property mans r represen ng tho owner, spoke in support if ;he request. There were no other p sons present to speak r or against the request and the ,pub c hearing was closed . Commissioner Wi ams recommended- that the, entire s n be brought into conformaa Commission Kirkland said the sign serves a need and f'e two years not be a unreasonable request . ;;4 ' Histtaten 4r4169 �13- (Z487fl r I 1 11 .i f huntington beach depertmr.>nt of community devolopment ffAf f .AEPORT TO: planning Conunission FROX: Community De•. :opment DATE: April 4 , 1989 I SUBJECT: CONOTTIONAL TISE PERMIT' "40 . 89--9 I • Internatioual Red Onion P, ' A M D : 1139 E. Domingues, Suite H March 7, 190 Carson, CA 90746 MA QATORY RROCE MUM: T permit outdoor dining May 71 1989 on a portion of a public walkway, ZONE : VSC-Cz (Visitor Serving Commercial-Coastal r.n.��►TtON; 16450 Pacific Coast Hwy. Zone) (Peter ' s Landing) QNERAL PLAN: Visitor 15, 000 square feet Serving Commercial (Rest:a•arc ant.) 1 EXI TING =,* Restaurant I Q 9JIGGESTED A TI!D i: hpprove Conditional Use Permit No, 89-9 with fin6ings and conditions � of approval . 2-0_i .�NERAL -TIM &TION: Conditional Use Permit No . 89-9 is a request to permit outdoor dining on a portion of a public walkway adjacent '.a the Red Onion Restaurant located in Peter ' s handing 3 a 0.. . AIMRWIIIIJQ. LKNQ USE . ZONING AN1 OEIIEML PLAN. D UNATT=ONS: alibi act P- XtX: f. OPAL PLAN CESIGHATION: Visitor Serving Commercial ZONN: VSC-CZ (Visitor Serving commercial- Coastal zone) LAND USE: Res' . urant in Peter ' s handing Y�1' (NNE L PLAN DESNINATION: Visitor lerving Commercial ZONN: it2--PD--C2 (Medium Density Residential- Planned Development-Coastal Zone) rWD USE: Condominiums C--G Ir 1 r , ' are M011 4 4 j14 yra M1 I! 1 1 sub i t3 A'�t L PLAID DESIGRATION : Vl ai to r, Serving Carnage rci a l ZONE: R4-CZ (H,!gh Density Renidential-Coastal Zone) LAND USR : Condominiums Juati of ${b 1!zQPQXU: County of. Orange, Sunset Beach Residential , Commercial 4_a_..._411 IRONCKTAL TUS: Whs proposed prriect is categorically exempt pursuant to Clans 1 , Section 15301 of the California Environmental Quality Act . Peter ' s Landing was originally approved by the California Coastal Comair:eion in 1976 . Approval of the project included a condition that; a 10 foot wide public walkway be ccmpleted and open to the public . The walkway was to be located adjacent to the marina bulkhead along the entire waterside boundary of the complex. Because the requirement for a public walkway was imposed by the California Coastal Comrttiss�on, ,.he proposed outdoor dining within that area must be reviewed and approved by the Coastal Commission . Should the Planning Commission approve the project , it will be an "approval in concept" only. §. . 0 RgMML Not applicable. ,7_LJ „ SPECIFIC PLAN: Not applicable . 8 `0 Not applicable . q .0_ _ M A1+1&UsTs: tLL- ad : In 1987, International Red Onion made a► simi'.ar request to perms t Outdoor dieting can the public walkway. An June 3 , 1987, Use Permit No. 87-32 was denied by the Board of Zoning Adjustments . The Board Of l6oning Adjustment 's action was upheld upon appeal to the Planning Commission on August: 4, 1987 . The minutes for those actions have br4n ottacbed to this report . The mandatory one--year time f rama for resubmitting a request which has been denied has expired; therefore, the applicant has resubmitted their request . The applicant 's request shows 5 too-parson tables and 5 four-person tables for a total of 30 seats along the west facade of the building facing the marina . The applicant is proposing to leave one set of fresh doors open along the Nutt side of the building to provide sec*e$ to the outdoor tables . 'The outdoor dining area is proposed to be used between the hours of 10 :00 AM and 3 :00 PM on Saturdays and Sundays only; the original request was for expanded hours~ which inc»W W"WSYs. A Minimum 10 foot wide public walkway *gill be ss�3�ltsin#d . :4 "15t4ft mast - 4/4/39 6-3- (331i6) , ._, Parking required for Peter ' s Landing by the City' s parking code totals 724 spaces . There are presently 743 spaces available. . (This parking requirement takes into ac.-ount; s 100 space c:ew:.t for shared use of parking permitted by the Board of Zoning Adjustments through Administrative Raview No . 62-•44 . ) The expansion of the Red Onion Restaurant by approximat::1y 282 square foet will generate the need for three additional parking SPLXes based an the City ' s requirement of 1 spare per 100 square feet of restaurant area . The expansion of the Rad Oniou kest,aurant to include uutdour dining , therefore, is not anticipated to cause additional parking problems at Peter ' s Landing . C, Noise : Adjacent residents of the Broadmore Condominium complex have historically raised concerns regarding the potential noise that would be generated by outdoor dining . The Br.oadmore Condominium compi3rx is located diroctly to the north of the proposed dining area . Should they Planning Commission approve the applicant ' s request , the project would be required to meet the City'.& Noise Ordinance (!Section 8 . 40 of the Huntington Beach Municipal Cade) . in. addition, the project could be conditioned to prohibit music or any other noise from being aired on outside speakers . Hours of outdoor dining and the number of diners permitted could also be limited to minimize the noise created by outdoor dining . , 2" Cg•Gsta Access ; In a telephone -conversation regarding t:ie subject propaail Don Schmitz, Ca).ifornia Coastal Commission staft analyst for Huntington, Beach, expressed Concern over any activity within the public walkway that would hinder or discourage the public ' s use of the subject ten ( 10) foot aide walkway. In the past, the Red Onion has utilized the walkway for outdoor. dining . Heavy plastic curtains were dropped at either end of the outdoor dining area, clearly impinging on the public' s right for unolistructod access along the walkway. The project has be6n conditioned that no curtains or other devicbs be used to isc:ate the outdoor dining area a-id adjoining walkway from the continuous walkway system. In addition, a condition is included to provide some form of separation between the table area and the 10 ' walkway by providing additional trees , ? andscaping and/or rope . 10 .0 H$COMMIj93: Staff recomaends that the Planning Commission approve Conditional Use Permit No . 89-9 with the following findings and conditions of approval: staff Report -- 4/4/89 -3-- (2311d) . ,Poo r v - ,t/I N ,'c INDTH E tart APPROVAL: 1 . The establishmenij maintenance and operation of the outdoor dining on the walkway will nor be detrimental to the general welfare of persons residing oz., workinS in the vicinity: a . The hours of operation (10 : 00 Art to 3 : dd PM on Saturdays and Sundays drily) and size of the proposed outdoor dining area will riot create an adverse noise impact on the W scent condominium development . 2. The proposed outdoor dining will be compatible with adjacent residential properties with the restriction placed on the use permit regarding number of tables , hours of operation and, corriplianne with the City ' s Norse Ordinance . 3 . The establishment , maintenance and operation of the outdoor dining will not be detrimental to the value of the property and improvements in the neighborhood . 4 . The proposed outdoor dining will not Conflict with the Coastal Commission' s condition for unobstructed access along the walkway. The use will also he subjac:t Vn review and approval of the C`.al ifoxnia Coastal Cemmi€lion. 5 . The proposed outdoor dining will not have a detrimental effect or. parking for Peter ' s I•snding due to the size of the operation. C;SIDI T IOT IO S_ OF APPROYAL s 1 . The site plan received and dated March 28 , 1989 , shall be revised depicting the modifications describer) herein: a . A lb-foot wide public walkway shall remain Free and clear of all obstacles , including landscaping . The applicant shall devise a means acceptable to the Director of Community nevelopment to clearly delineate the 10-foot wide public walkway from the table/dining area . 3 . Prior to commencing the outdoor dining use, the following shall be completed: a . The applicant shall submit a letter from Peter ' s Landing authorizing outdoor service in conjunction with brunch service, b. The applicant ' s plans shall be reviewed and approved by the California Coastal Commission . A copy of the approved plan shall be submitted to the Department of Community Development . d. Staff Roport - 4/4/89 -4- (2311d) q ;h .y Y „I Y. ` f,v 1 Y1 I 3 . The use shall comply with the City' s Noise Ordinance (Secciar 8 .40 of the Municipal Code) . 4 . The hours of operation for the outdoor dining area shall be limited to 10 : 00 AM to 3 : 00 PM on Saturdays and Sundays . 5 . No more than 30 Beats shall Le allowed as shown on the approved floor plan . 6 . No music Shall be aired over the loudspeaker system can the outdoor patio . 7 . Physical barriers which could impinge on the public use of the 10 ' wide walkway such as curtains or ropes, shall be prohibited . S . The development shall comply writ`: all applicable pioviaions of that Ordinance Code, Building Division and Fire Dx3pai:tment . Exiting requirements shall be reiviewecl and approved by the Building Division. 9 . This conditional use permit shall not became effective for any przzpose until an "Acceptance of Conditions" fare, has been properly executed by the applicant and an authorized representative of the owner of the property and returned to the Planning Division; and until the tors day appeal period t-as elapsed. 10. Should the California Coastal Commission approve the applicant ' s requr, it , the planning Commission shall review the use within one Year to determine if the conditions are being complied with and if those conditions are adequate . 11 . The Planning 0:ormtission reserves the right to revoke this conditional use permit if any violation of these conditions or the Hunt3,ngton Beach Ordinance Code occurs . Additional tables or chairs placed on the walkway beyond those expressly allowed by this use permit shall constitute a violation of the conditions of approval. 12 . This Conditione'! Use Permit shall benome null and void unless exercised within one (1) year of the date of final approval by the California Coastal Commission or such extension of time as may be granted by the planning Commission pursuant tc a written request submitted to the planning Department a minimum 30 days prior to expiration date. 11. 0 ALTERNAT13M A=IQX: Deny Conditioned Use Permit No . 89-9 with findings . Area msp 34 Applicant 'S Narrative dated March 29, 1989 3 * Board of SOn109 Adjustments minutes dated June 3 , 1987 4 . Planning Coaftiasion minutes dated August 4 , 1987 ill t fi!t t k1a Staff Report 4/4/89 (3311d) s Orr. Or 4 law c no SIP ei IZ ��\ •.T �; � ;, r• \ �/ ♦`fir` � rV �/ (`�� �'< \���- � � � ` •1�; �' , � �.I /d. � < �`\``�\}\�\�- r \Wye y +y,� ram\ � � ti , � ! r � ��!�'�-�•,•`; ; C. Y, 8 • 10 cr Oe '•�'• Y � -1 r d ' � �Qq � .r. a r�•rr � Ll �J . V� r I P I� 139 FED ONION 499 03/29,-t 9 161 SIN P !'^ 01 $UONE M. SAL AS . J Vk* J'rrRoWmi match 29 , 1989 Mr Tom Rogers 20 4 Main Street Hu tington Beach , CA 9264B Raj Huntington Harbour Red onion Patio seating D4fr Mr . Rogers : W@ ' have sunmi'ttpd for your appr,Nval our proposed plans for %PWW /VY� V }Y}�.� �A 11MM •.W.. V�..ly♦ •.• ♦.y� .yw w.r � MM Y.14 M.. �MWvI .r�I V. at: 1g450 iacific Coast Highway. Tht area that we are requesting the use of is very low traffic. We intend to seat in this area on '.y on Saturdays and Sundays CC m 10 s 00 A.M. to 3 % 00 p.m. during this proposed use , we wi l insure that aK 10 foot walk way is maintained at all tifts o . Thank You Zor your time and consideration and ; hope that you osri approve our request . ?lease contact m• if you have any oogcerna or questions regarding Lades matter. S�,�oexaly, a 14. galas Bpi Ivi aci Ronald Newman, President - Red Onion Restaurants Ralph 861�tsman - Salomon , Saltsman AJamieson Law Firm Bill FanMhor - Tait and Associates ��a•s1�a'�� aY „y TIN ,TQN REACH L'SA ...ZQKINQ ADJUSTMENTS Room Bw-f - Civic Center 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, California i�EOI�Lb�1►►"SC'. .,�1I�...��.Z.�.,�..:.,�.U._�.�� MUD MEMBERS-S ;S•EN Evans , Godfrey, Krejci , Poe, Smith STAFF MMERE. PRES Phillips I UPON MOTION BY EVANS AND SECOND BY POE, MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING or MAX 2o , 19871 WERE .APPROVED AS TRANSCRIBED, BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES : Evans , Godfreyt Krejci , Poe • DOES : Norte ABSRNT: Norte ABSTAIN: Smith UPON MOTION BY SMITH AND SECOND BY POE, MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF MAY 27, 19871 WERE APPROVED AS TRANSCRIBED, 8Y THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: Evans* Godfrey, Krejci , Poe, Smith ROSS: None ASSENT: None Ab$TAIN: None USE PERMIT NO. 87-3 2 (Cont . from 5/2 7/8 7) A821irant * I8karnatiort� DiQD A .request to permit outdoor dining on the patio area . Subject property is located at 16450 Pacific Coast Highway (North side of Pacific Coast Highway approximately five hundred feet ( 5001 ) West of Admiralty Drive) . This request is covered by Categorical Exemption, Class 1, • Califdrnia Environwatal Quality Act , 1985. The Staff mea:ber , Laura Phillips, reminded the Board this item had been continued from the previous meeting to readvertise the request. 'Staff Is understanding of the Original request had been for amA w 1, �Nt Minutes , If . 15 , Board of ioni.ng Adjustments June 3 , 1987 Fags 2 outdoor dining on the patio fc,r Sunday brunch only; however , the applicant ' s represontat.ive stated they were requesting dining on the patio for the entire time they were open for service . The applicar ;: proposes eleven (11,1 tables on the patio facing the walkway. Staff has several concerns -- one of which is maintaining the minimum lien font ( 1.01 ) clearance on the walkway as required by the Coastal Commission . The site plan shows tables along the building well which would extend outwardly approximately four feet (4 ' ) . L'i ase tables would be situated between the several doors on that side of the building . Maintaining the proper clearance would necessitate waiter service through t:hosb doors without encroachment into the walkway clearance . They Fire Department is requiring that Table 10 be relocated because it is blocking a fire exit . Some type of railing or division would be required between the tables and the walkway or smaller table$ could be installed, allowing service around tbeim. Staff has received several letters and calls from adjacent residents in objection to this request; because of added noise, . increased) parking demands , traffic, late night disturbances , and difficulty of reaching their buats whrough the walkway access . Staff recommended approval of the request with conditions, including those presented to the Board . Daryl Smith asked Staff if the applicant had previously been made aware of, the recommended conditions and Staff replied in the affirmative . The public Hearing was opined by Chairman Dennis Kreici . The applicant ' s representative, Ralph Salteman, was present , along with Bradley Anderson . Mr.'. Saltsman stetted he concurred with the conditions and recommendations made by Staff and would have no problems adhering , to them. He -added the Red O:Mori wanted to be a flood neighbor to the adjacent residents and held meetings with them periodically to discuss and resolve any problems which might occur. Dennis Krejci reminde' d the applicant that Staff .was recommending the operation be conducted in such' a, manner that no customer or employee would enter the area within the ten feet (10 ' ) walkway space . Mr . Saltzman stated he understood this restriction. - Leonard Itkoff, 3205 Moritz Drive, stated he docked his boat in the marina and had, on many occasions over the last three years, been stopped' by pet:eer ' s Landing security or restaurant employees from going along the walkway to reach his boat. He mentioned that the Red onion held ps ctAox in thin areea* and had plastic canopy dividers with pipe on the *bottom with which they blocked off the area. ilea also added he had measured , t:he available space, and the area between the planters and the water Line would be only six and one--half feet (6-1/21 ) wide. Mr, itkoff also objected to the noise from the digco .area upstairs over the main restaurant . -Z- 6/3/87 BZA i t Minutes , H . B. Board of Zoning Adjustments June 3 , 198 Page 1 Stefan Steinberg , 16591 Tropez Lane , zt-ated he lived in the nearby hroodmoor complev and had mailed a letter of objection to the Board . Mr . Steinberg added he was a member of the Sroanmoor F.o0aowners ,Association but was: unaware of any "good neighbor" policy meetings such as ientioned by Mr , Saltsman . Mr, Steinberg also saiA he and other people cc casionally walked their dogs along the wall.way area and wondered if the Health Department might not hags objections to food being Served in an area li.ko this . He further expressed complaints about the late night noise, parking problems, etc . He xtated the Homeowners Association presently had an injunction against "the Red Onion because of past problems and he and others had been keeping a log showing dates and times of various intractionn or infringements upon their personal rights . Dennis• Krejci said it seemed many of the problems mentioned might stern from alcoholic beverages being served on the premises . Glen Godfrey &sked Mr . Eteinberq if he would be able to furniba "the Board a copy of the complaints covered in the "daily log" they were keeping. Mr . Steinberg said he could make it available to' the Board, along with a copy of the temporary injunction. Daryl Smith asked Staff if she had analyzed the parking situation in relation td the additional restaurant seating . Staff said it would be minimal - something liken two and one-half (2-1)'2) spaces . There wias no one also present wishing to speak for or against the, request so the Public Hearing was closed . Glen Godfrey added he did not think the applicant was providing ample parking as requirid by Code. He said vAlet parking • joint une parking, and a Parking Management Plan had hee�n worked out in the past ..tb allow joint use parking and the plan had been approved by the city Council , Tom Poe stated he had many concerns over approval of the request because of blocking of fins exits and circulation around . th&� tables and through the building . He added the fire Department had problems in than past with access and circulation and ' he would snot be comfortable with approving the site plan as presented : Dennis Krejci ''asked if . Torn Poe was 6peaking from a practical point of view or -as a Aria fighter . Mr . Pbe replied from the. s.tandpolAt: of a fire fighter, Code writer, plain checker and functional point of view, Loa -Rvans agreed -with Toga Poe ' s concerns and added the restaurant had. caused many problems in the past . He ' also said the walkway was • not provided for use by a restaurant but: rather for use of th® -general public for access to the water. Mr. Evans said he win ready to make a motion - for denial, . whereupon Daryl Smith asked that ai condition be added to the Findings for Denial relaWre to . the fire safety. iesus. Mr. Evans and Mr . Poe concurred , and Glen Godf ray added he. also had concerns over closure of and encroachment into the Coastal Cowniaaion•s required accessway, as well as parking problems. • � - 611/67 - BSA r Minutes , H . S. Board of Zonina AdjuAtments June 3 , 1987 Page 4 Mr. Saltsman asked if he might speak again ; ► Fie said ins concerns had been expressed which could not be resolved .. UPON NOTION BY EVANS AND SECOND BY SMITH, USE PERMIT NO. A 7-32 WAS DENIED WITH THE FOLLOititNG FINDINGS, BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE; 1. - The proposed titre will not be, compatible with adjacent properties clue to noise and additional activity associated with outdoor- dining. 2 . Tire esrabli shmant ; maintenance .and•,operation, of , the•.use will , be detrimental to the, general welfare of persons working; or• residing in•• the,,vica,pity. • �►h1oise,.&nd.-activity generated will be incompatible with adjacent condominium development . 3 . The establishment , maintenance and operation of the use will be • detrimental ,to the value of the property and improvements in they neighborhood . 4 . The proposed use --conflictA witri.�th •.Gpi i tip:�,t��e, ;C} qs�8 l .. a Commission,! a' ►ognd3 t f an , far unobstrkicteti . scges along walkway. ► I 3 . The proposed ,use:-xil•l. aggx-avate. an.;pxisting parking problem in the evenings,. . ' 6. Granting of; the use will compound past pr6blems with blocking df the fire exits and difficulty circulating through the building due to t6bles blocking the aisles . AYEq: Evans, Godfrey, Xrejc;i , Poe, Smith NOES: Nt�r�e f ► . . ;; � , . •, • . ►� '� , ABOUT; ,None i,,jA t i ; ►:< < ff +! ► i , ;� NDT'ION WAS MADP 8Yi SMITH 4AND 88C0N1?XD;,B)�:1XR9 'CI;.THAT4THE•,LMD -USE DIVISION.•BE REQUESTED ,TO ..I HIMSTIGATS.-THE XOMPLr AINTS RELATIVE ;TO • ENCROACH T• IETO ?THE y WALKWAY a BYi-REOTAURANT&-,SUCH ASS-;RED• ORION,,�ANP BRISTOL CAFE# THE PlkIKING SITUATION, AND ENFORCEMENT OF STIPULATIONS A sG91CXV UPON MWEEIR THE CXTY AND PETEk 'S LANDING. MOTION CMRIED BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYIS: ' Evans# Godfrey, Xrelci , Poe,-Smith 110E8 f lions ABBEpT: Nana ,. -4- 6/3/67 Bay/y a , 1 , .w *�I�rLV�III IY�W�IM 1iil� a �`^ —w�..a�_�.. ...w.-.r_.�____ . u�_._.,.._�..__.._..._�_.__....—.._._.---- .._.-...__._. ---. �._.�.. ....__.w_«.__•.__ If lighting is included in the parking lot , high-�n�Vic n . vapor lamps shall be used for energ 4w igs . ,Al outside t-Jng shall be directed to V-bnt "spillage" onto ad d aCe�rl 1, P?ero tj . 6. The Planning Commi:7. .J eserves the t to revoke this Condi,tirona;^ imit: if any violation o ese conditions , or ! `ington Bedch Ordinance (.",ode, occurs , C-2 AARRRAL TO _�'A�'��.5� 40HINQ AD6fUSTMEN1.'_�� QEN jbU_&___ 5Z t dim) APPLICANT: 1NTERNATIONA!, RED ONION Use Permit No . 87-32 _s a r.(trluest to 0ermi.t cutftoz; dining on a portion of a public walkway adjacent. I.o t:ho 1tel Onion Restaurant Ij located in Pete; ' s Landing . T)ic rekjtiost wa.; denied by the Hoard of: I ' Zoning Adjustments on ,JvnF.,„ 3 : }.987 , and has been -3ppealed Ul, the applicant . This apl.-lication wag continued froni i:hi: July 2 , 1987 J'Iann ].ng Commission meeting to allow ti Ttilc_ for he applicant t-o c OVE ,P u plarl I that addresses the cancerns of j,he hoiiieowne•rs . I I The proposed project i:� exenipt: pu: suP, i".c to Class, It 8eclf iuri !_1301 of the C.al,ifornia Fnviro.nmerb ;:a;. =AM Continue the Appeal to the Boa: .-a of Zoning Ad.jl:fi tine.X1C ' y Denial at Use Permit No . 87-32 to the August 1.8 , 1987 ]:Tanning Ccm,iiisslon I► Meeting at the applicant ' s request . Ralp2, Saltsman, applicants repxesentati7e, addressed the Commission to exylain why he was requesting a continuance . He explained Lhat due to medical reasons he was not fully recovered to zepreserit his client in the appeal and therefore was requesting a few more weeks . The Commission agreed that the: appeal had been on-going for long e nou h and that they public hearing and action on the entitlement a�ea�d I i i PC Kinutos - 8/4/87 • 7- (8909d) T / VAOF Z AJ., y yl L A NDTION WAS MADE BY LIVENGOOD, Sl::C;OND BY 1,ErPZZG, TO I)EIW THE RMUZST FOR CONTINUANCE: ON USu PER.NUT F17-32 , BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE AYRS : Silva, Sch-imachor , i�,�.erc,y.t�;; , ir'ienr.;n , Leipziq , Sunnmerel ]. , Livengood NOBS : Hone ABSENT: Mcne ABSTAXN : None TNX PUBLIC HEADING WAS OPENED Ralph SaltaMfin, representing the Applicant , spoke in support of the request for outdoor dining . Steve Rosen, Wanager of the Red Onicia, spoke in support of the request and read the agreement that, the Red Onion had with Pete IL , ► Isanding ro-garding hours of ope ra1Z.-iu n , serving hour: , dancing .egulations, regulations on the outdoor patio , disc jockeyF ; etc. . He discussed his meeting with the adjacent homeownars and st•ited that all efforts -ere being made to satisfy their complaints regasdi.ng noise, security gua.ds , disturbances, etc . Itobort J . Morgan, 16319 Grenoble Lane , President of the Homeuwns ers Association, stated that the homeowners dial ent:F.r into an agreement: with the Reel Jnion but: to da!:e had not received any satrisfac:ti.oxl� i lie further stated that the Red. Onion is still blocking off their patio, - making no attempts ro rurtai ). the noise problems , or adhering to any of the compl ai_*xts . Co►ttmissione;r Silva asked Mr . Morgan it lie personally had witnessed any alcohol being servers on the outside patio . t+ir . Morgan, staged that he had . Richard Dorsey, '�221 Francors, $roadmoor resident, spoke can the integrity of the Red Union ' s : ntentiuns . Carol Swansono 1.6365 Martin Lane, quastioned the intentions of the Fed Onion. St stated that the noise created by the Red onion -is her main ouncern. She said that between the drunks , the automobiles leaving the restaurant, and the dumping of, the glass bottles by the employees that the noise was beco-sing unbearable, Chairman Pi.er%�e guestioned Ms . Swanson as to whether she had noticed any dumping of glass bottles since the July 34th. violation notification . She stand. that yaps she had . 4' r rAoftard itkoff, 3305 Moritz Drive, spore in opposition to the request for outdoor dining . He asked why the Red union was being allowed to use the outdoor dining area even though they were denied the use by the ?.turd of Zoning Adjustments in June of 1967 . . PC Minutea -- 8/4/E7 -S- ( ego9d) E - 1 n r•� 1 Pool 1 Eric Rosenberg , 16511 Bordeaux Lane, spoke in opposition to the request and voiced his complaints regarding the noise from the Ited onion, especially emanating from the perking lot . ' Them were no other persons pre,v ;nt to speak for or against the request and the public hearing w&s closo4. � A M011;(gyp WAS NAPE BY LIVENG000, SECOND BY PIERCE, TO DENY THE APPEAL TO THE BOARD OF ZONING ADJUSTMENT ' S DENIAL OF USE PFRMIT NO. 87--3 2 , WITH FINDING80 BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: At the advice of the Deputy City- Attorney, Commissioner Sumnarel] , stated that he would be abstaining from the voti . "us: Siilva , Schumacher, Higgins, Pierce, Lo pz�g , hivengood NOES: None ASSENT: None ABSTAIN: Su:rMmerell 1 . The proposed outcloor dining expansion will not be compatible with adj Gent properties due to noise and additional activity associated with oi: �:door dininq . 2 . The establishment, maintenance and. operation of the out%lnor dining expansion wi'�.1 be detrimental to the general welfare of persons working or residing in the vicinity. raise and activity generated will be incompatible with adjacent condominium development based on the Police report (dated August 1986 to present.) and to pt+blic testimony heard at the Planning commibsion public hearing dated August 9 , 1987 , 3 . The establishment:, maintenance and operation of the outdoor dining expansion will. be di'.�rimental to the value of the property and improvements in the neighborhood. .1 . The proposed outdoor dining expansion conflicts with the spirit of the Coastal Cr,maission ' s condition for unobstructed access slono- the walkwey. The dining area proposed narrows to a minimum 4 foot: which is inadequate space for dining and still maintain a 10 foot walkway. 5. Qrantinq of the proposed outdoor dininq expansion will compound � past problems associated with Mocking of the fire exits and difficulty circulating through, the building due to tables blocking the aislots. i PC Minutes - 8/4/87 -9- (8909d) a Poll f x'1 •� , Publfsh 5 25 89 APPE" OF PLANNING COMMX SS ION IS DENIAL OF CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO . 89-9 (To permit outdoor dining on a portion of a public; walkway adjacent to the bulkhead) -ac MM103 IB MR35Y GtVICY that the Huntington Beach City Council will t; hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at the Huntington beach Civic: Center, 2000 main Street, Huntington Beach, California , on the dote and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the atotWbenta of all persona who avian to be heard relative to the ' Application described below. " MATE/TIME: Monday, June 5, 1989 , 7 : 00 PM "Rh1!QA11QN Nang$ : Appeal of Planning Commission ' s Denial of Conditional Use Permit No , 89-9 A ELICANT/ Red Onion/Tait & Associates L=,10u: 16450 Pacific Coast Highway ZDM: VSC-CZ ('Visitor Serving Commnercial--Coastal Zone) To permit outdoor dining adjacent to the bulkhead on a portion of a public walkway (west side of restaurant) . ENVIISQNMENTAL AZU: Categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15301 , Class 1 , of the California . • Environmental Quality Act . ,� T8►T3 � The project was originally approved by the California Coastal Commission . This expansion of ;N.'. use is tlSu sV,h j-,�ct to roview and approval of the C811for is Coastal Commission . 47A ;J 1: A dopy of the proposed request is on file in the City :,ri` r•::;;• Clerkis Office, 200 Main Street4 Huntington Beach , ;� ,• Califoruis 92648 , for inspection by the public . 1 AU INTR IrSTED PEbSONS are Invited to attend said hearing and A pnea opiri�oans or stibmi.t evidence For or against- the application . outlined above. All applications, exhibit$ , and descriptions of � i$ prcposol are on file with the office of the City Clerk 2000 1e dtrast, Huntington beach, California, for inspectio-, by the s a' irk ° MTING'I'ON BEACH C 1TX COUNCIL By: Connie Brockway* City Clerk Phone: ( 714 ) 536--5404 5/221IN /1�I�Is71rM4 ' FM �......__.I . — - 34d3113 F. i2 �� J � � '•;�w � it N• Y , ,00�: 1 t�, ,.,,.,�',. Cfiwri` ♦ED rRvPEFaa VMA ♦iW ' �♦i/U w Fw w���. hll vi:"i yE 1 The r;ttsched lisp was taken from th® latest available Orange CoUnty Assessawnt roll, of all the persons to vhom all property to *&#eased for a distance of 300 ft . from the extericM !'fie 44rles of the subject prupe y, legally dtcoribed ag follows e may I ste 8 gnaVue I j. li l 1 '�I fir';I .•�. LL k, 4 OP }gyp s QjfNERSHIP L15T WITHIN 1300 OF J -No 5-84540 Paoifi.c Coast Hwy. a' irigtdn Soh. ASSESSOR 'PARCEL NUMBER OWNER NAM Y State of Calif not on 1 , r tax roll . N 3 . 178-44.6 l0 Huntington Partnership 2a c/o Thomas McGllira 1299 Oc4a►n Ave 9 th Flr .. Santa Mon'Ca►, CA. 90401 iA'•I y 178-441-12 Huntington Partnership 3 YP c/o American restaurant 75C Terrado Plaza #231 I Covina, CA, 91723 4 . 178- 442-15 , 6 r 7 r 8 , 9 , 12 , 13 , 17 ;droadmoor Hui,,cington 4 2i, 74 r 25 r 27 . Harbotir Comm. Aran . r,/Io Management Service Y 76-443--3 , 6 , 16 17601 17{:h -�t . #21.8 Tustin. CA . 92680 5 . 936-29-1 Douglas Moss S .3301 Moritz Dr. ftu.ntington Bi:h, CA. 92649 6 . 936-29-2 Jimmie McGee 6 . 3299 Moritz Dr. Huntington Bch , CA . 92649 7. 936-29-3 Jeff Specht 7 . 3591 Court,aide Ciro 4' Huntington Bch, CA. !02649 936-29-4 Jim Btntson P 0 Cox 668 ` Seal Beach, CA. 90740 936-29-5 David Herzig 9 3293 Moritz Ar• Huntington Bch, CA. 92649 r i, s � 'i� I A w.! oflb' snob R r , 1 ` 654V 1l611 title FROM tU l 7 ; 64693 F 04 a.., page 2 �itJD FiR ASSESSOR. PARCEL NUMBER OWNER NAME; 936-29 Barry Spiegel li 17182 Greenleaf Ln. Huntington Bch , CA. 92641 �w ,l• 936-29�-7 Ben S'avk.in 11 , a.�f,•.; ,• 3289 Moritz Dr . ,ysa , H%!ntington Bch, CA.. 92649 12 . 936-29-6 Briar, Prentice i2 . 5149 Alta-, Canyada La Canada CA. 91011 .a 13 . 93 .; -29w9 Raul Anguiano 13. c/o Anderson , 'William 17831 San Leandro Ln . Huntington Boh, CA. 92647 1 936-29-10 William Vawter 14 . 3281 Movit4 Dr . Huntington Soh, CA . 92649 ] 5 . 936-29-11 Sonja Hagal 15 . 1441 Veteran Ave 4301 Los Angeles , CA. 90024 � L# . 936-25 -12 Patricia Garner 1$ . ;> 3283 Moritz pr . Huntington Deb CA. 92649 17 936-29-13 Robert Garrity 17 . 3277 Moritz Dr. Huntington Bch, CA. 92649 : 936-29-14 Katherine Alain 16. 9209 Colima ;Ate #2600 1lhittier CA. 90603 4 y AO 1.le P' ! 1 y ,4 Y i ?� ,,,, VIV196! $ i I l• FAGh r TO 17; 464695 R ,63 Page 3 MUM"It A802880R PARCEL NUM ER OWNER NAME Robert Dressler 903 N . Snow Goose ' A ti rl Orange , CA. 92669 a 936-29 -16 John Cushman 7o. 333 S . Grand Ave #4000 Los AnVelest CA. 90071 936 -29-17 Men Lehman 21. 31.31 Francois Dr .. "'` Huntington Bch , CA. 92649 22 . 936"-29-19 Allan Boyack 22 . 3235 Fran^.ois Dr. Huntinaton Bch, CA. 92649 23 . 936r-29-19 Lorene Addis 234 3237 Fr4ncois Dr . Huntington Bch, CA. 92649 24 . 936-29-20 David Broderick 24 . 17190 Ave ire Santa Yn$z Pacific Palisades, CA. 90272 't 25. 9.36-29-21 All Anarican .Pzoperti il; ;: . 731 E. 4th St. Long Bch, CA. 90902 21 936-29-22 Richard 51£0s 26 1740 Rocky Rd. 1 FUllarton CA. 926$1 27 . 936-29-23 Eldon Johns 27 . p 0 Box 2879 6ee1 BeAch , CA. 90740 ..w'•k fit,. , 1f�- r i, 1'r 11119 FROM Ta s7t b�fy3 P. 07 �... 1 '`�. Page 4 VVX WVMZR ASSESSOR PARCEL NUMBER 0KNER WAKE .. .r '' ' • �; 936-20 -24 ?�;`•1' � ROri Pie a 1.1t11a 20 . r., 3255 Francois Dr. ,Huntington Bch CA 92649 936-29 -25 Gary Carlin 29 . 3261 Francois Dr, Huntington Bch, CA. 92649 30. 93E-29-26 Nancy Swenson 30 . 3265 Francois Dr . Huntington Bch , CA. 92649 31. 936-29-27 Ronald Wheatland 31 , 3271 Vrancois Dr. Huntington Bch, CA. 92649 32 . 936-29 -28 Daniel Jones 32 . 3275 Francois Dr. Huntington Bch, CA, 92649 33. 936-29--29 David Akiderson 33. P O Box - 41911 Los Angeles, CA. 90041 4ia{I 34. 936-29-30 Edwin Kiefer 34 . 3281 Francain -Dr . Huntington Bch, CA. 92649 936-29-31 Michael Tromb17 35 . 3285 rranocia Dr. Huntington Bch , CA. 92649 936-29-32 Edgar Woodall 36 . P 0 Box 3682 Fullerton, CA. 91634 , ,+rP jMlir r;•( �y' 4 . 10 one M�,rrr r •, IV22elss i 11119 FROM t'��l TO 171 64693 F • �b Page 5 E 3 "UMISSSR ASSESSOR PARCEL NUMBER OWNER NAMR0 rLj �:+':., .,. ��• 936-29- 31 Harvey Levin 37. -.' 16411 LakZakre Ln• Huntington Bch, CA. 92649 38. 936-29-34 Johnnie Baxter 39 . fir,,#7 16415 w_ Lazare Ln . Huntingtor, Bch, CA. 92640 936 -29�-35 �tut Ih 39 . Guillou 39 . r' ; 16 417 Lazare to . Huntington Bch, CA. 92649 , 40 . 936-29-36 Richard Norholm 40 . 16421 Lazdm Ln. Huntington Bch, CA. 92649 41 . 936. 29-37 Bradford Bls3weis 41 . 16423 Lazare Ln. Hunti'l9ton Bch, CA. 92649 i 42. 936-29-39 La*,::enCe Clark 42 . 631 S. Atlantic Bile Monterey Pk . CA. 91754 y. 43. I: 36-29-39 Donald Ostl.und 43 16429 Lazar® Ln ., Huntington Bch, CA 92649 936-29-40 Phillip He Cullough 44 . ►'iy:r , 16431 Lazare Ln. #� Runtington Bch, CA. 92649 r I .;: 936-29-•4l►' Mitch®11 Latter 45 . 45. 3245 Anne Cir. Huntington Bch, CA. 9264Si { i r 1�1 i • i f 1 '•' TO f ?1 �S37�d93 OixX+ 1,009 111 FROM Page 4 AE'rm 19ty-021 ASSICSSOR 1PARC.4-L NUMBER OWNER N 460 936-29-42 Chrixtimn Paul 46 Bela Dacosta St. Vney, CA, 90240 47. 936-29-43 Robsrt Whes1sr 47 16416 Grimaud Ln. Hutting ton Bob, CA. 9"149 48. 936 -29-�44 Annotte Bolatin 48 . . A. 16337 Grenoble Ln. Huntington Bch, CA. 92649 49 . 936 .29-45 Joseph Vicic 49 . 11 4 th Chin be* Rd . .7urog Town 'Singapore 2261 3d. 936-29-46 ftrilY n Carson 50 . 16347 Grenoble Ln. Htntington Beach, CA. 92649 S►�, . 936 -29-47 Robert Fames 51 . 3202 Anne 'Cir Huntington Bch, CA. 22647 e�} .2, gab-29w-48 �'4s��e�r ,,pechtk 52. 3206 Anne Gr. z; Huntington 30h, CA. 92649 r $. 9►36�-29-49 Harold Lydnen 53. 25722 4ceammod ter. Dana Point.# CA. 92629 4. 936-29- 40 0uvt Rees 54 . ' 3214 Anne Cir Huntington Bch, CA. 92649 1 y 1 I 7 ' $0t72r190f 11120, FROM TO 171 646�T P. �r APage 7 , ASSESSOR PARCEL NUMBRR OWNER NAME 2 1 ,"��"' ' 436- -� ], John Fuini 55 . 3222 Anne Cir . ;. Huntington Bch , Cal. 9264 936-29-52 Scott; Kimball. $6 . 3226 AZi 4 Cir. Huntington Bch, CA. 9204 57, 936-29--53 Larry Cunningham 57 . 3228 Anne Cir. . Huntington Bch, CA . 926C 56. 936-29-54 ;:achary Parker 58. 3232 Anna Cir , Huntington Bch, CA. 92649 59 . 936 -29-55 Larry Witt 59 . 3234 Anne Cir. Huntington BCIy, CA. 92649 60. 936-29-56 Peter Xremer 60 . 1 Civic Plaza 6290 Newport Dal,, CA, 92660 61. 936. 29-57 Jahn Gaffey 61. 54 Oak Tree Ln . Irvine CA. 91715 936-29 -58 xenneth Johannsen 62. ` 129 h Pearl St, Balboa TQ1ard CA. 92662 P` 936-29-59 Paul Bednars 63 . 16428 Max*.in Ln. Hurt tingto,l Bch, CA. 92649 L '� 1, v^I Pi AOC r A:h_ P. e� '-"'OsvI989 11121 FROM To 171 *t4603 r, ,M1 xvx "Oman ASSRSOOR PARCEL DUMBER UWNHR NAB 936-20 -60 James Masters 64 . r� 16426 Martin Ln. Huntington Bch, CA. 9264 M1�•11'�ui ± . �. . 5, 936-29-61 na.rbara Colin 65 16422 Martin Ln. Huntington Bch, CA. 9264 46 . 936-29-42 t"I,S Robert Carson 66 . 16561 Channel Ln . Huntington Bch, CA . 926 67. 936-29-6.3 William Tuclrer 67 . 1.5 412 Martin Ln Huntington Bch , CA. 9264! 68. 936-29-64 Nancy Cohn 68 . 1641.4 Martin Ln . Huntington Bch, CA. 9264 69 . 936-29-65 Michael badatubner 69 . 3267 Morita Dr. Huntington Bch, CA. 9264 78 . 936-29-66 Jog Amicc 70 . 3265 Morityt Dr. Huntington Bch, CA. 92641, 4 71 . 936 -29-67 Edward Chambers 716 v 3261 ":aritz Dr. 619 Huntington Bch, Ch. 9264 12. 936--29-6 a Chau- po Wei 72 2755 Wallingford Rd. r Saa Marina, CA. 91108 N... � 1 11 21 FROM Page 9 wLgwBR 1 &$ �$OR PARCEL IRIKIRR OWNER NA" +p a: 9 36-29-69 Jacqueline StUrge* 13. 3259 Moritz Dr. HuntLngton Doha CA. 9364 936-,29-70 David Grattan 74 . 3253 Morita Dr . h Hunt{.ngton Bch , CA. 926f �s�•F 75 . 936-29-71 Re"dlor Gratoh 75. 325L Moritz Dr . Huntington Bch, CA, 92641 76 . 936-29-72 Robert Crah 76 . 5959 Avenida La Vida AnaheiMj CA. 92807 77 936-29-73 aohn Stanko 77. 1677�. Bolero La. HuAt.ington 90he CA. 92649 78. 936-29-74 Ruth Moss 78. 15 416 Olive B ran:h La Mirada, CA. 90638 936-29-76 Patricia Hairline 79. . .{ 3239 Moritz Dr. ` Rgntingtor. Bch , CA. 9164':"'I`; 9 3 6-2 9 7 ;`. Renato Longo rd 6.0 33.37 Morita Dr, �t Xu ntinjtou Bch, CA,, 9264 N, 01. 9 36- 29-70 David Whitt alL 3235 Moritz ur . ''' Huntington Bch . , CA 9264 Ir 1,,f,Y" v � � i..+'.Y'• .. 's!R' ' '�) •'yld;r'Y`f�,. '�•s ?i Nil', .,+;•y; , ..r`l,�j`, . u yl�� ':}111 .. ��".� " 936-29-79 rsksh4or Sehabi 93�,:I 3191 Francois or. s Huntington hvh, , CA 99 'fir•,'', he' ' J.4m** Baard 934 319695 rraacroit Dr . j Huntington Bch . , CAA 9264 µ "'�, 04 -81 Marc Spitz 94 . 3201 Francois Dr . Huntington Bari . , CA 9264 M --82 William Kra,gos 8t A). 85. 241 Z. Country Hills Dr . La Habra, CA90631 .;. { -$3 Richard Schwatts 96 . Y" 3207 Prw noii is Dr. Kuitingta'n fich. . CA 92649 -8+4 Zilen Huhia 87 . 3211 Francois Dr . Huntington Bch, , CA 92649 Ann Faporhexn 3215 Francoig Dr. 8209 Huntington Both.BCh . 1 CA 92649 •: , 89 . -86 Richard Dorsey 89 . 3221 Fra:ioois Dr. Hungting ton Bch . , CA 9264 90 . --87 Terri Mc Cone Et Al 90 . 16446 Woodruff Ave. Beliflowe r, CA 90706 M ?, ,' �. � r +, i .� ,� Ly1 rs� / M r , � spa ''«� ,.',v � �r^� �r� 4 .� •,� S r 14 Iv ,^I�ij ."J'"'�, fit / � I�V�.1•r• rJ6}, �.wYi.41,' y r 3' ' "l ,f. �' f y� .. r r ,.r. r u , . Ntl' is r/ '•r � ��.p, . r �' �'��. is���� r r, �►i l �4e'��� r, � 1r � �.}�'y�,���', w, John Draw ch r � '�;� • g ,� �89 L►er Mareolek 92 3207 Anne Mr . r . �k. Huntington Hch. , CA 92644 93.' --90 Faye wine 9 3 . 3205 A -ne Ciro Huntington Bch . , CA 92644 -91 Bother Ferber ' 11219 8 . Parmount Blvd . Downey, CA 90241 �y -92 X143t 319 5' Anne M r. Huntington Bch . , CA 92f n -9 3 Martha W-iso 9.6,9, S1.91 AADO c4r" Huntington bob. , CA 926 97►. -94 Milian Rosen. 3193 Anne fir. ' Huntington Bch. , CA 9 2'i#r 96. -95 Betty Urson g6 . P.O. Box 2072 Orinda, CA 94563 99 .-96 Philip 9immorrgren 99 . 1636) Merti_n Ln. Huntington Bch . , CA 926 t �. `. '��1 111� � � .) •1'' ' T� 1 " r l i I` M +I'L • ' 1�+ •', �( F JI°'�.�M 1 ,. r 1�1,� •�' �� , .r , ,.1+�y� �•,� , ( T HIV} .�, yy •a .� J'��� S f Lh•�lY y;t' •,.r I � ,'Ih �.µ r � , `� 1 � � � aY t�t�• +•!� ' z'��y'� • .T' � Iwk�� 4 � , � ■pi� � .� t� I, I� .' N'FI meµ,�� fi ,ai,►rlt.. �i,,.W�T'':;:' dt .c�<''1. f:Ii+�;ll�.v• ar,il'�y +l�lfi�•r- .'a 4,:1 ,w��� tM•• .. - q. K � I ��yut•a n,.� 4 I . ° k r Mwtinvton Bob w r . *44:41 C AlIva, Lai 8Nf tech 1Q ' 5901 Warner Ave. 0431 ., Huntington Bch# , CA 926,41 , Y f" • C Pedro 1Ae 102 y.Y,�r•, a 349'1 Ven' ire 0r ffuhtirlgt.�c+n Bch.', CA 92d4� T sl• -100 Lewis A cold Tr Box 2423 ' . .... Anaheim, CA ,02804 1,K -101 carry Graham �. 16379 Martin Ln. Huntington bob. , CA 92440 -102 Ken Fre jxach 10 16835 Algonquin at . Huntington Bch. , CA 926 4 ; 104. -10 3 John Henry. 1-171 16471 Tropes, La. Buritagtan ".ch.'r CA '92641 107. -104 Edward Te►rr Tr 101 9160 Dinsdala - Downey, CA 90240 Y09 -105 Edith Schwartz 10g 12653 11ing fit. Studio City, CA 91604 {r'l��x� aWy<,`� .+4" 1*5F N+Y '' 0,'4 •'7'*`1n '+.1+!hy 01M .lr,*' or�_ v � I �r', +�G •' r �f�f,�h, rf �,x 1 �a. �e ! i.,�., i•; 'l•Y i�r �.�1Lly�tfl, ` l.i6 1 - !'7 i„ a a5 � �' � �P+ >� f' •A a,a �, + t,r' � �� f � � '+r � �1•l � '1. �' , r.o. i �.: � '��� Imo` + �• �� L�i n �.• r-�rx , y,, x s � � � 1 rr �1 �rQ M�rt�/A�x.'�'�.�.. .�iW�i' •�� i r !A+�r , +yy 7 r: �p1,, t1 ir,� i «� �! � �l it `�'�„ , � �r }\�'' '+T��',• ��!r;`I M '+'7 tnr! f`iY'M.91h �J••, �"•r4'r• •r: ., � W^' �, �,�/ ,wl�yr ... r!..Y, «a- j,� r rc \ � J�,�.r'� � .d r,r.�I�rJ� �• .i -r r,x,i !, > 14 11#6,4463 Pao ten Dr :l Los Angeles, CA 000 i ��. -107 'VSnQes�t '�reril�i�ltrilt� 111 • `���: .,�,� .. 164As' T��o�ez Lea. HUnt ing ton BCh. , CA r AM 16e1 Powell 16 4 9 i Trop*X Lao l; .•r;; Huntington Bch . , CA 9260 yy --109 Rabo rt Moore ." !.">Y 16495 Tropes Ln. Huntington 80h. , CA 924A -210 ,r, 7 16497 Trope% Ln. Run tington f' A« , CA 9 rudeko Yakoy' W"' 15483 Pinyon Ci r. }r' Fount*lA viiy r , CA 9 i 7p! -112 George Budenz 11� 5250 ?*Cate .fir, Riverside, CA 92506 116 . --113 Carl Heider Et Al 11I 16512 Bordeaux Ln. Huntington 8.4h. , CA 9201 117 . -114 Linda Wood 11 165O6 Bordeaux La . Huntington Bch. , CA 926 N� � t'�S � �hh +r,S. •e'r•i�,' � �� r' � �1°� T ,��y7�Q 0. r 11 �� •`h' 1 '��'b „h�., i, ip 41 9 1. i _,�r•.ti y��� OV 1h, S•;,� 'i r j. 4�, "T' 4J`'•';��i •l , r�•r w � a•. i�1��1 h r y. p 1, ell k + t w w po. / t•. �'rr y y J�' ,xr ., '.x r� .. �'r'," }ir!�11.�'. 1•rt�..x� �rd�1�L• 'v... a.G. ...w '''ti ir�i�'•'�� •. ,. 0'7,�'�kl page 1' Malcolm Gillies MAP Bass tol"Ont0i Longardo :: . 2237 90ritl Dr. Hung ngtvn Soh, CA.036 7; "P117 Richard Names 120 , 1042 Bmer&1d Ter. Glthdaloj CA, 91201 �118 Edward Tritoak 121 . 16492 Bordeaux Ln. ,; ,, ,.•' Ht ntingtg4 Bch, CA. 9261 122, 119 Scott WillinV440 122 . All 16511 Bordeaux Huntington Bch, Cho 9264 r ` x.Y' I• 123. -120 Police Mac Caul,ey 123 . Unit 210 16505 30rdeaux Ln + Huntington Hch, CA. 92001 124. -121 Cary ma curdy. 1124 . . 16:�O1• �It�rda��r 1,tb. Huntington Bch, COL. 926 125 -122 Thomas Lovelace 125. 16495 BordeaUX Ln. Huntington Sch, CA. 9264 126 . -123 Richard Smith 126 3829 95th Ave NE Bellevue, WA, 90084 p ! — ^• \ �,� "Y Y� e• �^'�.�� �"��#�f - y/1'hI�',��J '� i.1 N i r •. yr, +' .t' * f yr y �' a� 4N + 1 } �'c, �? 1J, N , rl ��. ,�.��,,. y' Alit •r '�fikl r� ��' q L'V' �r�W y of 'n rl ki'„�� ��' .'�M'�1ffit!• � �/��M��r�y,Iry, �1k1+ . '� ''�' ' .�!41�iw'r , ' � r rY'��1K r-r h '�� .}�"�1'��!{ ! s� r � Tiy"�'�'1 , 1 ;Mh f+ Y F F� � � ! 1'i 'Y 1i 1!• \ I li- ! �y 1 � IY � \ i rA l!~ f' 'M �r14 t. '.'N"" .J h a�r ,,l ^j. r,r.1•,�' ;��y �, �1I ,y +j'p� 'kC •�,I� ��^T�I��"TI'�AY' '�I. ('. 1;C-;� I, �� '... I. I, \'' �I „ ,,y . �� '1'� Y Y� •*;�} i� �' � i� L �•1}` I-• t/y"'�'. y L yr7•�i l r,�.�.�r��,•'rtp� r�L!�'�• 'P y�} {�}Y ���i . 'H, � J';, � F M , L / 1 Ili f y y w'�''r gg M ,1 5�: pie ��T,L{' 1\��� � 1 •',F. ,•i� ti t k. �' •`. � ,! ? ;iiiJiMff�yii, i ,h k wn 1 qlow ..r�, Mr,, l 11 f� ^ .y��r ;}�� i'a r y"I,�,,,Y�r '• L 1 1 �1 Y•'• � �' ' � yL'�` I '�,Y. R Y 1 ,� •r'� �.: �.Y.✓ ,w ��..r ..y . MM ANF' I��' 4�'� ,uLl,q''�,� �al�� '•A ' 'R; 4�+tiY�l�.,i �'� � �'�•� ,wry Jack Markovits i a P 0 aax 1604 Suauet 'eah, CA. 126 Robert Crawford 129 . ' VI 16466 BordeaL tax Ln e 1' 127 ton Gearhart 130 . r' 16462 *Sardoaux L». Suntington' bats, CA, 335, 1' 14i 1be 1 131. " ; . 128 Judith borLdoaux Ln. Huntington Snh, . CA. 0261 • r 433. li9 Paul Buchanan 1.12, 4172 Windsor Dr o Huntington 80b, A. 9304 1,33 130 Ki0hael Gilles 133 . 16 6 5 2. Bordeaux Tao Ruatington Sc h CA, '0364 104 • 131 Robert Giovanoni 1134 . 16625 Martin Ln. Xuntington 80ht CA. 9264 i 135 . 132 Father Ferber 1350, 1454 Gel.aky ter. Newport Seaoh CA. 63660 M \ �+ Li s T "xr '', Nti A ,� '�" S y.„ i n i!'` k• i 7d �� yy11R` 1 "F :N'- j i '��yT 'i. + J • 4 ,�� a• •' 1.6 + P•W. .,• r , '�� a w- a •,+'. P�• � !Y nor r' 91,',� � i k �, .• n 1e�7�;,, �' J r 1 I,rr��'yU 1 SU r 1 � �' � !.Jf,A T , I.�S•, i" �1 F � .I ' ��{Y!Ilt„� �. +n #r G��r'�� "I, ., I n 7•� �,4 4'r•�, r � 44. �{,= I � �nSil} r r i j,� ! :u nl'nijw �i• ., I s rl rr:.;r i•. pw. r0 MRM64601 I. Ir Page 13 ',��•14�,�, 7dt�,tr' .11 .'�, ou,nrtian Quo 136 l0 415 Martin Ln• W, VuAtLngtoa Uh* 9204 1;#4 NommA Abrahams 113 7 r 16411 Martin ran. Huntington uh, CA.01640 Susan Misseark 139. 3229 Moritz Dr H=tittgt0n b6h, CA. 9 264 .I1 C., - iJ -13$ Terence Mann 139 . P D box '262 Anahoift, CA. 92905 �7�. -137 tarry Inholder 140 . 3325 XorLts Dr,- Huntington $ah, CA. 71 T.: 92649 1410 -13 8 Raymond Mathews 141. 3223 Moritz Dr. ._ •• Huntington Bob, CA. �a 4, k 92649 %vN 1 -139, 140 r ?24 Peter Krmer 142 . ^J, C/o Xrrenwr Co. 1 Civic Plaza Suite 290 i Nerwpdrt Bch, CA. 92660 -141 George Off 143 . 3� 15 Moritz Dr . Huntington Bch, CA. 92649 144 . --141 Frank Ferraro 144 . 3213 Moritz Dr. Huntington Bch, CA. 92649 4 A•, t Aff uwl P. r N T 010-29 143 iaan flog 14 . r rw tin at&, �. 92649 r > c Von Fa11 140. i . 3209 Moritz Dr. Huntington Bch, Ch. 02641, q ffffff r ! Sv IT �, 1477 Wat.lton Barton 147. 3207 Moritz or. i JP 9204 „Y Laonar4 Ttko!1 148. r ` 3205 Morita or. ` 04atingtton Bch,, CA. - 92649 -14 7 gug ne i4altsar 149'. 9492 S . Peatharhill Dr . ' Villa Park CA. 02662 1 •, -148 Richard Marcoullier ISO . 3201 Moritz Dr. 11=t.in9t0n 80h, CA, 92641 -149 Roberti Friedland 150 , 3199 mor'itt' Der. Huntington SO, CA. 92649 • -150 Darryl Dorsett 151. 319S MovLtz Dr. Huntington Bch, CA. 92049 153 . -151 Fitter Va lov 152. 3193 Moritz Dr. Huntington Soh, CA. 52649 Y " n�r.,�y} 1• +• 3 1i S �"� 1P� � it��, / �,. � �Z 8 �hyr�";.�1 ��''�� � l�, � r i�1' k{� y r ','Y � ��y y',`i rl�/' t1�• ,b t ? n. I `k,M�•,.I„�'. :r, d MIY I. Ih�i. �" � •�.nlw,••Mw.1K1�y,, Vr • 1��, • +► r'. • S•i,,ratt . .N, ..P: \1„ . � Jj�IP � � 93 9+,�tN►ren 4 164. CyP=a•$ CA* �lo Itudy Gates s 3187 Moritz or. muntingtOn 30h , ' 92649 err„�, ,,• , 3185 Harihx Dr. M49 .0 04. John Franklin 1370 ' P 0 Bost 2292 Alton w0fiv 138 994o� Orr and Da: . r elk 90670 lam« �157 h Robert Morgan 1S9. 16329 Grenoble Ln4 92649 1,Rt� -.158 91-w:Aeteri Alford 160 r 16331 drenobla Ion. ' Hubtington Bch. Cho 92649 r;• 14I. -189 Richard Stasberry 161. 16333 Grenoble Ln. Rvatingt.on BCZ1 r C.A 92649 162 . -160 Kenneth 8trottman 162 . 16335 Greenoblei Zn. Huntington Bch# (W 92649 � 4+r�+.krl..';,h�,v1,1•P f , +�• ��' „d�rr�r�'ii � Ir'..� f. �.y'+1=4+i I •'A,ry�i ' -�tw 11~li''�' �� 1, ,,i 'C .r.V rr` w� ' f r". , _ . r�117� F '�• .+. +�. '�, '".,1 �� . �� 4 4. 1N'o + M 'r' �Qr 7 y Vt•y`� �I a��� I�r r+� , r + �[ ���, i f 4'�1� i L,h ply 0i Page Amette wren 143 . A"O CAR 92449 -162 Christine Touts ja an 164 16339 Grenoble Lno ch, CA. Huntington B 92649 r•r. � ' 1„- r```,;;, • i i« -16 3 Sant Construction C0, 105 Si* Kraemr 81. 9122 Placentia CA. 92670 �i6 4burton Mill ►rn 166 17171 San4 rt Lee Cto gal y`, Muntington Bch, CA `•92649 Amin FarWaZ 16702567 Camino Del Sol Pullett+oa CA, 92633 NarA lyn Me Gavin, 169 .E 16347 Gr*nojble Ili H ntington Bch, CA. 92649 1690 -267 Mart Combs 169. 16341 Greaohle LA, . ; . Huntington Bch, CA, 92649 170. -166 Brn,tat 170 P Q sox 496 Sunset Bch, CA. 90742 171 . -169 ftna .d PGlito 171 1100 W. glanoakes B1 . G."landale 'CA. 91202 17j W S 71 I- too L4 Mr. c tow la ME, , Cho 4 -471 SQ04A Pierce 3 1064 5 , AlfrOd St g Los An sloc, CA. 90035 -.172 George buys 174 . k li 5 17 , TrQpe z LA mVmtjnqt6n Bohr -173 WOrtmann oil co. 175 . 3044 rocthL11 Slo 91214 Robert Lariardo 1766 -174 17VA 16525 Tropez M=tington Scht Parnell -175 David 1 177 . . 16527 TropOx Ln r4 Suntington Schf CA 9 176 David con" p 0 box 2767 rong Soachr CA. 90601 IM -177 Stefan steinberg 179. 16541 Tropet VA. Huntington Bch, Chi. 92649 180 . -1.78 mark Weiss 180 . 16545 Tropez Ln. Huntington Bch , CA. 9261 �t r. n �!5�,�. 1 '` �•1 � � � . ram'' i�'�� �'� � � + ! •,,y,ko W. IA 14 x t `I 1 room TO .�M I.. ��+�"�'* r'�k� .�r w�t��•+.i�,��tir• �'���:�'���I�`�'�„f'��'�rt +',.'M+�Tr•���5�,�#'�'fM'::a11�' �i��� �����'�� 1 �����,�����A1i �, ,1 poga 21 jack Greenberg 181 16541 Tropes Ln. X=tinqtft Soho CA* 064fIC 182 . Ronald Jones .; 11454 X* 186th 8t 0114 >!; Artesia, CA. 00701 � �► �3 81 Mickey Shubin 103 . 16555 Tropes Lh. uUntingtan sob, CA. 92649 IPA -182 gl,..•I Edvard Twinin 1840 16 55 7 TrOVOz Ly .� ch, CA.Huntington t 92640 -123 D:L=a Males 185 . 16561 Tropes Ln. Huntington 30h, CA. 92449 Ise . -184 Clamant 6irol.i 186 • 3230 Pallowfic;ld Dr . pind Bar. CA. 91765 197. -185 Karla Bnnail 7.87 . -16575 Tropes Ln. Huntington Bch, CA. 9'2649 f 168 , •-166 Donald Leach Ise . 16561 Tropes Ln. Huntington Bch, CA. 92649 189 - 187 Edward Loker 16585 Tropez Ln. Huntington nch, CA. 92649 1A aYSI `�' AFf'�►t f' 1 r t i 1�r '�+r �� f ' �i �19 r+ J• 1 ' ��Y, Y { Alt . �, J �°�,'iti�1 �� �� '�� ' 'I .• ,,� `�Y%+l�t�,,�r il�� .`,, j'.1�YNj 1 ;:,�1� .�.r ..' ��r � - Y• A 10 VL t f INN f °`.t 1 � �t�• ' � ' 1 -` �,' {'i.,. �I'r' �'•,i J } n '` �P"{w.+s►M' 5'"�'• ',ilMi�y} a++. " '� fly,`�!�'al a:a {4}' p w t' ;'yli�tlx, 1 +r.���r�► �r ripe" 22 n S o ter 20her 9 09 F� t f "Sol TCOPOR LA sch rOA y' Mary V44per 16 s , h ��,' �'. Hutritirigtats Behr MCA. 92649 log en Jack Carden 192 . 16395 Tropez Ln. guntingt0a loch 92649 "? -191 ,+,': cz*mne 6charwath 193 y:.:..:�'.'` 16597HUnti ` ngton Bch CA 92649 '. -192 Walter Wood 194 4031 Mox'hing 3t.ar Lr. Runitiogton BQh, CA. 92649 lose Richard Zahn 295. 358 B. Main 3t. 921 Orange, CA. 92668 -r194 David Combs 196 . P 0 BOX 2767 197. -195 • Robert Bailey 197 . 16591 Peale Ln . Hunt.ingtor. Bps , CA. 92649 199. -1.96 Lee Taylor 190 . 16606 Bordeawx xn. Htilntingtorl Bch, V. A. 92449 r; j'F ' i9''!`r%• Rt Y'•' ` ' �?;"" !�1 ,,�i" r, Y,d� '�M. ".., �a� 4o 17 JJ, • Iti d A + , " w Al Y. o ,4�o Paolo M14 +' pert 99ttliabIds a' I•R' t WI Longa •'r 1 Tanat Posh y HuntIngton Bch, �Av 92649 -199 i c/o letter, Beverages it 10624 14idwa�r Cerritos# U. 90701 202. -200 Gary HSO� 202 166�0 �Orda�ux Huntington Bob* CA. k; -201 Scott Walker Tiong Soo,CL, CA• 906=.5 . 2040 -202 Ruesal Singer 2Q4 . 16580 Bordeaux Ln. �.:ia,'• Bch, CA.Huntington , 92649 a ?. 2050 w203 04 r ►xd NCO t 0 . Huntington -SobC.A. 92644 206. -204 Torrence Patton 2060 ' 16576 Sordoa x Huntington Bari, CA. 92649 207. -205 Richard Berry 207 . 16572 Bordeaux Ln. Huntington Sch, CAA. 92649 11 r14•) nY,ti; i• - yY ,r, yfL .'Y,q(F JYy.� ^1 1; .�'.l :1.•a' l '�Y ` .5i, '' •{ ., I_�e 'i r '°ad'• r 1, y ry• 1;x 'M� }(•� ,,y5i���� ,. y 'i' r �A I i * �' i ,�~� :'}�nib..,5i, Ilk Falls to 0141360692 Y .. Al P: ' `pM l ., " ., 'a.. t r.•. :,iMr Page 24 936-29-206 9�ta'uo Takash�.tr 209. ti> 16566 Borde-aux Ln. •�, t��ntirt�tan Hch,'.' CA. �264� �R 1 207 Lynne Gorli.na 20P• 14562 PbrdO*Ux Ltd. }:: •. 'M+`:," hunt ton Bob p CA. 02641 -208 Francis Harker 210. 178 i Yy" 0 Ratho d� R . " San Marino, MCA. 91109 ns; ' 211 -30 9 Banc Wi*,moth 2110 YI` 16599 Aordeaux Ln. Huntington Ddhe CA. 92649 t 2126 2.k0 Bohn Davit 212 . 16501 Bordeaux LB. huntingtoA Bch, CA. 92649 Jeff Wityak 212 . a 16575 Sordoaux dun. ,N Huntington Boh, CA. 92649 R $�.; • -212 Btaaley• Rosen 214. 1565 Via Corsica LpaqUna Bah, dA.. 02651 21�. -213 John Saako 215 . 'd 2197 Cal.avera F1. Fullarton CA. 9n622. i 216 . -21.4 Bruce Coo 1 d 216 10 Stillwater Irwin* CA. 92713 k f0�s�1►�IG.M1rUtIlM1Ya-5�'n:11w•Mlf Y+•`h,w +KrfM4�" .u+1/hIRI�lIAP1 - •,a{wiW'YM�}M'" '.• •..•.,, ' '- '� r f ern � t:�� � �: I•• f r.�, �l�w 'r"�"�� } L !}'� Ls "•Jl ' �r ' r �! , � ��h / 1 ti � �.1 ti !{+,�'L^+'r' ��•+'r' •''etl � r 1•� 1• 1 S'�'6,Y f� n',+ � ,n rWi r y,;L, �r�,'1. •r�.� ! v, 1 1 �':'i, � !'A+.�' �,.r� ���+.yli S�a��'' � .�a+-.W,' h�745 rs �• 1° .+we •'� �� � ♦� � .. ;•a: , fC! rl + � 'i .� d,�[ rdA R.N'• � ♦ J:I��fir .*,Mp "ol 41 '„ T``�!•'i "' `�, t„ K ..';. ,w�` '�r:♦ti �T'hti��`f ��yy.y�, p + r 1 a'• ' ' + � M G•� r'rt 1 }ail�i r � �,,,�"" ,y 1.�,���:`-�+ fi y <<,, Q '1 i"' ^( ',f,,1: r ly �' � .I♦Jk.'..'� �. i 5.,: x ,�3 r, ( l,�t'S�;', ,S ` � a , � 1 'L, °� •� ar M'.}wtir1r� A3 off f o '�'rryl �{ �sM,•wt:' r�ri, ;p,y '?. " ! ''* mom -AIM. 2 5 ' ' F x,'' � ;'► 934-22-215 TArr Norenvon 217. �> 16541 borda&ux Ln. Hmtingt*n Roh, Ch• f• ' 92449 J I11 y. 4 ;42 T, 92649 �•.,4 ,j �6 9 8 =oux fruntington ., 92649 *vole Ia. w • ,1� Ikuntington Bch, CA. rrf' 92649 1; ji�h stern Cypraif's, CA 90630 rFr F� � �110 #41apertt' P000rk 2220 Ad4r tl. 1 90649 �221 SuAan AA,zrkor 221. 1F.951. t�i�tntinrde��ot� tom gooS a4 99649 '222 • wi].�laua N6,rxe11 224 1450 2ordeaux La �t�tritin►gtc�n ach, CA. 92649 225« -r223 i4 Ar 9*0* 2:5 . M0 Greenfield .Ave 4204 Ike Angeles, CA. 90025 r • I . � •� , '�•� '!� �.,� i1"'Y-���^ r� '.`' b,• �{.ir�lr��,'.",.,,I,:,V✓t A11;I�:•�r^���',1�1L�,1,!�.� y�y��q�*'�✓'r��„•!'�• ' 94 , .� , ,% '•,, 11,..;♦.p i,.. a •f, + y I ,, r„ L9w , , h.�,� I 4 4 , a""'j�{ ,��(}/a SI ��• W� i 4 /,' `r.= � ^ �, '• +. 1 I •,�7giRi'�f.l 'I . r ���4G 2.7 xt- r I - r • by �e • , Piave 26 a 1 936-29-P224 Datti*�. StadMuellar 22*6 ,DJ.,µ ;•, jai Rotlto i /NI r' ♦Ni r' � y Mantim l:10 IA 5,2310 %Ven qu^c CA} �1r' .�M i• 44 h 1 � k. -227 lana1G Potriah 226. in Ci 1 �' A�ntinl�trVli ��� � �rf1 i 9U49 -228 Robert 3uoh 2. . 16432 Girmijin Ci r. untingtm Bali, C► 92649 .�:�. IU229 Sally Meandosa 230 . 16�69 Ga�'maine Cix. ; RtMtinvton Bash, CA. 92649 �Ix -230 Ahti .hony Graf for 2' tr4--ical. Yin Mai . ' Huntington Bob CA ��• - � , 92649 • - s` -231 Mark Ti*rh*. 232. Imunting,to' Is Bob CA. ,G,•;(=r�� - x�4 i.9 .,Glx� n Cix,. 9NO ' -232 wixliamt Tiffany23,3. a 16461 Qermain Cir. Huntington Uab* CR. � 92649 ' 2346 -233 Ronald O*nkins 234 , 16455 G*rmain Cir. ; Huntington Bch, CA. i 92449 I .p T, � �j l" ^^ y'��r'�� ,� �. y�', f 5 ..'. y-M M �' ``, 1 ""171 T5.•;➢' •I!` i '( f��' ►+ '"t�i"'�' ( � 1 �, v{.w �, �t�, iL' R' , 'err l��(1� , �{ �'y � �. �t' 'y � •, 1� 'vr P ( r,, � 'y '�'r r •'S'l. ,1 '"!J' y�. �"�,�f•, Z•h,`. •� , �W�,�b 41i, J � „rK ,• ' v. I tip' t J:'""•,y. I � ,;pare°>'4.1.''+• ., � •� Y;^,; li {� 344i� s Lei Ch��,, ��y:;'�'���F • �1�ilaw, � " V�t i , 9 627 CQsk#& use& CA ia -237 �y1 p 'N sob 49 0.0 Y'�f I 11 aid owits rw 2 L�6�kr� Lh '��II �•(��u� �J 1 �Ivtt��i a�'n Da CA240 • 02641 pAnald Lea _ r 6 229 16427 JAzare La. , g, t�nq�.ancjh, CA. ,? -240 y` 1t� ��iold Ave -241 Doh CA. 92649 MichtaY Graham 243. 43 . -242 16443 Laza►xa Ln• 92649 _ ! �ah . ,1 � / Ll•" Y � 1 a � \` 1 FIr " J� i. �r'#'• •� 1^•:N r �1' 1 r O'����N4�i�, �'", 1 ..kir ,' � 1 � /� r�3�>- '4i •1�. 'r rr,�I«��'r .,M � ,Ey)•iLJ{r2iJ, �,7r•' Y ',�,r, TO I nir��X_ya ��1: � ,w�_r� ��r �'' r 1� .b l � 1 .. �'��y{ v..�� .� F � h, •y J �J r ,° r ,S�r !r:'',11��(I �'� I RiV ;� �{/*„ � 'L,�1 � J �_ ., 1 " ".• + � ` �w"�f'' ' ,-� + .\a ' bi'� ' Nh f � A+�:,� /k�'��r11i'r� � �,f ^� �"� .r •f'•v •�'f�, •a r eg 1 , ,.,Lau�lrhff: Mb 1dr Ira7 i'. •o'a —�' iwi...'. �: To l?ldd%9L469$ P.2? �1 PAO* 2 v '/( w�r11' r J Jack 9cf;hwabl 244. P O Box 797 Sunset Bch, CA. 90742 lift on CA# rr 9.it4o •,art," g'F'i^',� +f r�� ly �l� _ypr S�tiR '�'`'� e L� .1,' '' ;. ri� ;r ^ ;'�; I � fu`'IK�cal. �4• };. , � ',^.... Tait • . �:,.�,,;: 1 Igo o N. Rbkhoff s t. tj �- Oran ga# CA. 02613 yf �a 1 Y 1FL g I lye� 1' ��ti S� / fy J-r'., .r i-• � 4.. 1 1 ��1 •IV , ' F'' �' '1 .1'r. 'i r,l a f , '� 1r�'+ 111R i�d. Jr'!r 1�P�i r ,a• " � d1 � Ir y i r r )• �i , f.i,j�`4�ir, I✓h 0W- ,4i �, i �. ,f9•�1'e, /, t•, rr a I 1 1 , RIJ I,i,ry ;�,•1t•"/�Y; I{y,�1J�y, 4,' �Y���r� i /�1 �' f' i ,�I } 1 '+•Iry1 5 V 1 1' / i r „fir �., e..r�l�►Sd;"'�;tCir4]L'r.\trllfler.� . .a'e; .:n !.,.,, ,. r , _ �—y — --'-'- ---.,_,.._. .. --- _ - • . 11 1 r r(f• „law,`."•r ''� * i1W' (D� • ' iac �M • CITY MYw � M MY106104 PEACH,CALIF. June 27, 1$ft �crrr ngtan +C r Council ,fit 29 1130 AN 19 Beach city Hsu r ZMtrvet t�cirrlb pn Beach, Odkwris'k"= �� ' Ir Cacr+nalirr�nrbets: r n is FW%W Pm o*. My family and I live at 1&U9 Grenoble Lang; Huntington Ille , In the orcamoor Huntington Harbour condominium complex. Our oewftlij irdum Is 94 601 from the noethernrost wd of the Red Onion, on the sarne W r' Imift Ap 1W 1.11, ber. Wen pur+chaaed our home In January of We yeas. N the time of our woo " dd,hot rebelve a tonnd deckwire from the Noting broiler, Tom Won; we om verbally,toil by him tiled all pr oblerns with the Red Onion W been solved years r bebre (with the mid tidn of 9000sslonar parking lot noise at 2:00 ISM); and, ;n an ww, with tho Red Onion man&por In December and a Broadmoor neighbor, we were led to believe that we would not have problems with the Rod anions presence. 1 WV ovoid be furOw from the truth. (We later dieooverod that the n0ghbor s condo ' Is Sowly ohfeklod from the noise problems by our c+ando). t ' TIC tad•Onion changed martagement In mid-January. The volume on the, disc muW wont to unbeliovable heights. The bass vibrations strongly shook the Red Otic+n's► ,wail (next to our home), their wall violently shook their windows In their ohs, which in turn sent low fracluency shoat waves right through our wal, into our bedroom and Into the other rooms of our home. During this period which united 3 months), we ht the best dual glazed windows we could fin , slept with 35-dedbel ear lugs, slept in our living room, slept in our daughter's bodroom, 1@4 Umn many In addition, I started making calls to the Red Onion' management. Although my Writs were maelved with,::polite sympathy, the results were temporary, at best. Z71'Usftd Wing the Hunts n Beach Police Department. Numerous tunes an 1 vuId Come out, observe the problem, and go over to the Fled Onion to speak to t trowr tnanspr. The results, again, were tom�rary, at best. Next the police got the 1lleMr' tntatNgon1e unit involved and sr►�psmed lhrd I crorrfacx the Police Dhlet dirscxiy. Pr+hm this nt on, when 1 would call the police they wmjld come to rid home & take b Grime fort, an April 18th I retarived a call from Detective Ford of the Vice bMt orm unit to came to the simian to sign the necessary forms to prowed wrath a "dIstuding the peace" prosecution. Curiously, also on April 1 gth, I rived a phone call rrorn the (then) new General � IWNSW of the Red Union. He said he was sorter for oil the problems that they had been causing. He told me of their pearls for •doubling the thickness of their rmrttwmmost wall, for plexiglessing the western-Bing wrlitdows, and for maldr g other changes. I igreed to defer pressing the misdemeanor charges until I could evaluate the results of their proposed changes. a r' • y r r M 1 7 4% A r !' Their now wall Is In phw (a khough cosm"mily speaking it is still not finished). TIM rkrrai Hamper and the Regional Manager came over to my horno In early May andwe ,wr* agreed upon a wound level that was reasonable. 'Thin level was set while, -0140� , w, their est' song was laying. , This level was adhered to by the Iced , "baresi t died ju*eye for arbour a week. since then I have had to oall nurne►rous times to a*them to rum the music down. They have riot abided by the agreernerrt. They have not hulled the "siuwd limber* that they had promlaed. They have no! installed the "sound monft W that they told the Planning Department about. They do not odrrtrol the qwd disc rya who oontrol the sound boards. As you ht not be aware, the Fled Onion Is not prima dly a restaurant, It Is a bar. The of the bar Is Sop rwons. Cyr their busiest nights of the %sek, another,100- plus mars wait outsld to et inside even at midnights). The bar business Is Wed by the Fred Onion's g of choling only $1 for drinks and as We " 50 Wide for a beer. here special� rises ar buffet dinner and 3 drinks for 5 dollars. This, coupled with the R*d Onion's apparent marketing exporience of selling more drink* when the .r►ouslc is the loudest, Is tho source of almost all of the neighbor's oxauperatione. The Red union is turning hundrsds of drunks loose on our neighborhood, the Pacific Coast Highway, and the community at large each nigh. I arm ssak of the '9ed Orrinn's booming bates speakers; I am sick of the diunks-to-be yelling and screaming while they are waiting to got inside; 1 am slck of the drunks yviliV and screarnirig by the fence 13 feet from my home; I am sick of the drunks oNrrrbiing rarer the fence; I am slut of not being able to open a window In my home at night,.! am sW of?he drunks yelling, racing their care, tmehing, and psrforrninp various sexual preludes in the parking lot which is 24 feet from my 5 year-old daughters bedroorn. 1 am pleading with you to not allow the Fred Onion to Increase their activity, but to srpport mar neighbors and me In our effort to win a quiet, respectable neighborhood In Mrhlatt to Ilya and rarlse our chlktrerr. In this short utter I have not had time to develop MY other wow of concern. However, we plan to use the Impending misdamear?or either as leverage to forc9 the F';ad Onion tu make some enforceable c s Cn t it own, or as the charges turn into a conviction, to petition the piatni Department (s►nd ultimartely, the City Council) to curtail its hous and methods ro operation. The only thing the Red Onion understands Is MONEY. Please do not reward O*m with more at this point. Thank you for your%me and, prayerfully, your consideration. Sincerely, A. Randall P Sroardrnoor homeowner �i ti y .I .7M 1 N. i , - _Pw ./*✓ POP ♦ � � _ 1;fin �h k 1 � O 1 .1 �> Y 1' � ail• ��� � 1 ' k', ! won h I I • LOW911 ,t + ti I�• L' u, ,w 1v ai. Tge Ra ,' •1 iM , SAW WAAWP 60, ZNl; •� f,� v! r �,� � N�N�O�O� NI-N�NNC� �°� d •� NON-O?OP DANCING 6 NONsITIP NbOCICC Of MUSIC NeNINITOP MONDAY$ •/ Arwjw AIL a r, • om 'L' 4 �J AS Draft or 4 TO in p Mn on ele►�tr�c guitar moots" vea ways � �KNAC su!npor 8tldarst • s Hutoy tildsun Aemsoftl Court 1 T", Pao*,Fosbrs,sltd k)b molt Ateby KNAC FREE P 1MW On a H VWI HU~MiH+ WR OWN awcbftgbymwmwww ♦ i PliiAi � �� i 4 ��t�C M 11 M,�` Iun bo M.NI ISM bw Of L . Dim Intl on <r�C, L i w •,� �L`�f yMi��•w fi ti. r b •�".,Jt /'t�J y.�( L �/4� �- f`- J 7-_`l�7� 1.. M � M /''iJ]t�[rr_fib���I�j7 �,�K��»� ., •` �`1 , �1,7�� J�•'w-. �C�i.P; i �l J '..- J \ �r-. -, �'Lp�n. i. 5, ,-��j1 , v�'y f I f, ' � a Y3 Ztitl•� tay -•, x .{ ,�«• ,li, �;.�_ •11`�fl♦ ."•��I fir 4 *, ill r a \ 1' • r � � y' \ \i I 1 10 low ,•Ay Ile , ' ILW o ANY� y ` a Impon Beery 0 Cofbe Drfnks • r And mVlwl c a w s In Vie bat anly Must by 21 tmos ttems vxty y,et 10cetnatt 198b lilt'] 0111nn. Inc. 1 4 CITY OF HUNTIN TON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET CfiLIFOHNIA 9-964V OF-VICE Of THE CITY CLERK. June 29, 1989 r Mr. Randall Prescott 16349 Grenoble Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Bear Mr. Prescott I received your letter toda�r regarding the public hearing on the Red Onion appeal and I have forwarded copies of it to the City Council memb2rs and staff along with copies (as be,t could be reproduced) of the attachments. If I may be of further assistance please call me. Sincerely, Connie Brockway City Clerk y9•.h 71 I1 TVA I, i + t 1 . .1 •1 JUN 2 W9 CITY OF HUNT,,NGTON BEACH ,t, L-Dui-��-c�.�' ,•;�.��.,.�C yam.,, CITY COUNCI arFl.,F ale it. -t r�4� fry at me, A:v �� •'1 �1+l��''�'«• r�.wad�( /u W'ie,� ex Zoe ,ram 1 1 �. fir • *�..-• A. iE I L00 ' s P. 0. Box 190 HunUr*on Basch, CA 92W - Kerri f ar:Ler 1657ts-Bourdeaux Huntington Reach, CA 92649 FIRST CLASS _MAL Legal N6061 R fx'Y of "UntL-*m Beech Offi.of do CRY Cmit P. 10.fax 190 tfunthvjt *Back CA OnA � ti � e Patricia Reilly 3237 Moritz Huntingtan Beach, CA ° G9 SST SS MAL r lbloVs- r, r- - Kerrf Garber 16578 6a;rrda rAx Huntingtu' n Beach, CA 92649 e` CLASS ,MAL k r. LOW NO"CO city of huotk-Oon Bich P. 0. Hoot IW �iwrtMO A Bomb.CA 4 Patricia Reilly .. J 3237 hori tz F liuntington BeaChs CA 92649POE - w ft,4 Lk FIRST `SS MAL rose; Legal Notice_ M 2 9Z=0- OWN 0 U Renato Longcrda S0 . a� 3237 Ma:itz Dr . U � Huntington Bah g , CA. 92649 L-UN :37' 052710y.1. I�Wl) i'Z:t1E:: EXPO Rig L UNGORDO FIRST CLASS - IV AIL LLA SAND NIGUEL c:;A 92677 LeSel Notice Cky of NuIR1440 h DONA WAmtW4w a"".CA WM C. A `#P David Grattan 74 . 0�4000 3253 Moritz Dr.e V Huntington f3ch, r 49 v ,e �fi� .ir r, sw. `•' 414 i FIRST CLASS MAIL N�tla• Ow"K CA am 01, `? lop Barbara Go1in 15422 Hartiri An. �F 0 Huntington Bc . 00CoLA" MAIL 11rinor.hlrllr���ulhlrr�nilh�I��illrrtl���l��rl t ',r, r 'gal;. . . .�. LOW like of ValwaiRt MY Patricia Garnertip, 3283 Moritz Dr. o Huntington Bch� � �41'4����,, ., \4, �! F ST U SS AL 1111t11thI III ttlIIIII III!II III II Bit],I III!I III II121 lama= l t _ Leal If atid. .. Jffhv of the Cky CIKk ,_ P.o. Bova l;'JPRESORT r�qi Jimmie McGee 3299 Moritz Dr. _ Huntington BchfCN. 92649 ,l MCG 99 G5274U2-1 05l2-7/89 F. MCGEE RET!&N 1'D SENDER FIRS' CLASS MAL �llllis.:,= ��. r�r, �� ,LUT NO aQakEss - � R C�;�;R w.� 0; Legal Notloe , Dffkpo of the City Clerk OR. limosthoW it Noah, CA SUN �' � � (� .S ►ti'�Y 2 Richard Ladderbush 245 . 16449 Lazare Ln, U Huntington Bch, CA . � ti 92649 L.,f3U 9q U5:?p1(1wJ. FWD T'l'h1E: whP'I:) L.A- DOE E'U:31.1 ����� ��� y,'7�rq TL7NY 'T RA� �f�:17' I_N All '1I:1 :8I::NUEh Legal Notice City of IUr wqw Bosch KwKip"Waft CA Me y ..•r r .• !. N .S ' Stever, Quackenbush 2271 . i 16482 Germain. Cit . Huntington Bch , CA. Y` 92649 11 BRIARGLEN FIRST CLASS MAIL Ii��lRV:A"f4-. CA y2fxAI F2I.:TURN, W: SENDER Leval Notice City of HWnshom beach tlUndo lae ibuk CA AIM «� Dick Malo#ley aX Q� 16 5 3 6r -`I' `'� Hunti,�gt�ri BC , 92649 .��p r"PlIT S MAIL. ,errr`r •■ /�■p.MwF ..._,r ,yi. . .. ... ' 4 14, ,, q , -�/ f� � Cyr. •�1 ., try �"� _ ._.~•.�-- .. �'I .. .• . 1 Alt Ft­1 PUL . a cr•�' r �r �I �1 r f . 00ye 13 r . f - Q � r 60 47 G � / peo h t 6M0al NOON . •��1l)ry- ti;Yr'• - - aty bf Hwgk%w Booth .••••..r ...w . . .. .•,.. �l .� .,tl•. - offift of to"Me* P.O Hoyt 1!C i !,•r 2 ) i . Jow6,CA OW i { V t' Q EH i n . f�FWQ ''. Ci ayton Corwin 172 . 16511 TropQ z Ln . CA. Huntington Bch , 92649 GUh 11 U527AWN1 q',;j 21 t r ' E FORWARDINI" UF:DER ON F:I:I..,I:: ••fit FIRST CLASS ���L QER . UNF��.�l_k: TOhUF�WF�h�) Up! N60441 City of HuntkV a',Bfwch 0"We of tm Cky Mwk Hunti�V1on . ' , �kfa �•-- N DE- M:F"r ty Lambs 169 . �., '19 Grenoble Ian . ;_. H� ton Bch , CA. 'r g rotK11c7 92649 �r1Ry�,A SE 71E-19 a � NO I7*I7hWAR1)1.NI✓ UF'iDER ON FILE LE= FIRST CLASS MAIL Ii���� UNABLE r•ca ��I�;;wr�h� ' L,KoI Moat. • 06 "WON*"spook FIRST r-i 1011not;h Strottmen 162 . ro % 16335 Greenoble Ln . $ENafff . Huntington Bch, CA. rum Q2649 u527 s Y,' DER �•� 3`i ` .,..�... A 8E WETUNN TO SEt4OL8 E �'Cl�l�iAa ` ' �� FORWARDING OPUER UN F'�L�. �. UNAgI_•E T't� t WF1F�l7 was W ,& 9„14,11,,,r,,,i;l„iltIII , 1 1' .y n ,mow 0"b"of ow city C" City of Hnntin ton Bcach Ix ���� �10. iS MIFty1kNIA 92C I6 f� 0 / 34 A►VTHU- N Y CSITLIS PE k Qq to f� HUNT I N�{TO9264 r. oflue of tt City Clod ,.+ City, of Huntington Beach I:,y 1 P., s� � CAU . . di 159-352 -11 LARRY R W TEAS 6652 SHI CIR HUNTINGT R BUI CA 92648 re GENDE . �, + Y jo 1. . 1' 4 t Pil..rrl't Y OF HUN"1"ItalG` ON BEACH fail 1rY�ii �AM� �� w ZW MAIN STREET CALIF:)RNIA 32648 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK June 5, 1989 Ak. Stephen S,tanbeta 16541 r4opez Lxne Hantc:ngyton Such, CA 92649 I �e�c M�i. S.t�.cnbe�tg r FoUm ng ouA eonvvthat.ion I ataA.ted .to white a note .to AdmiAZb.tutUon uga,td nq yyour cuncexnb od patine en6oneement and the btockage a6 .the w zk=ya, however Y be Leve .it muCd be mane e66eeti.ve., i6 you woutd w►kite a. t•etten .to .the Uty Counat oute/ininy you& concenna. . T witt then per int it bon ,the Uty Council packeta, as wpm az att otheh paeketA which au 6eM to the Ubnakiea, nempapeu and att key &U66 membvu. You& to tteh. wit,l. atao be made a matteA L16 public ecotid. , Ptea e, tet me know .i6 you weutd .t.{.ke a Zettteh inctudcd in .the packerta. I wantd need youh t et ten by Flay oh. Monday at the •ea to t. S.i;nee�te�y, Con.v a Skv kway City UeAA P.S. Ak. Steinbe&g, pteaae note that the laty 5.th meeting 6att6 on a Wedne,aday becm4 e, o l the hot ida y. lydW A:7144004=1 t 1 1Mi ,11 • CITY OF HUNTIN TON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92048 I OFFICE of THE CITY CLERK 1 , v � l �7 •y, 1 u 1 June 7. 1969 Bi11 Pancher Tait b Associates , Inc . P.O. Box 4429 Orange, CA 92612 Thank .you for your letter dated May 26, 1989 requesting a contt.lua►nce of your appeal to the Planning Commission' s aerial of Conditional Use Permit No. 89-9, Pursuant �o a resellutia:; of the City Council , there is a $30 charge to continue the matter to July S . 1989. The check should be made payable to City of Huntington Beach and mailed to the Office to the City C1Prk. If you have any questions regarding this matter, please do not hesitate to call x me at (714) 536-5209. Evelyn Schubert, CMC Deputy City Clerk CB:ES: ln - Lanai Ma1ir "an of the C"C$Wk =; a; y �'' + • �': _ - . Ra.a" 1!!0 xy�,! David Broderick 24 . 'a �! 180 Ave De Santa Ynez - Y P ' fic Palisades . CA_ < RETURN fM SENDER MT DELWERWAX AS AWRE:SSED t� LWARLE TO FURWARD i R i,f?hf TO 'Et` DER I FIRST CLASS MAIL i Ugal Notice City of Huntington Beach Ofiia of the City Gait P. 0.hove 120 Hunth-On , BmA,CA 82018 �. Susan Barker `9 16551 Besdeaux Let. Huntington Bch, -CA- 92649 L, f FRET CLASS MAIL