The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutConditional Use Permit 88-23 - Negative Declaration 88-24 - 1 MEN& Y CI �I�•�htG w�r.,p�• �•6 '� c•tiied :� br^,t�1 ;gE � r �„ i i 4bJ 1 �b1f0 � � Juht !�i3 $"ATE OF CALIF7RNIA ...r"1 r ;,� �,� , IyE ( t .ate Mb•,,. a;,.an•r-:, '�''r• ' ._ , I)tr. .3 .-'e ;j.' 1r►1� 4.untt 8f� tCb8�10 ,�� r:r 1►1� b9E df �li�hif+8r1 ,' i _ -5. aria r+~, a party to or rtierested in th,t brlowRE . ....� ...� rat.1tr ; am a UIIn"'1:A, r',Prr, of the C)targe CZE C*AW DAILv PIL0 i with whrCh i? corntindd Me NEWS-PRESS. a newsDaPar of general circulation, Pte printed 2nd publishe(l in the C;Ity Of {^.os,9 KIM2. County of Orange. State of Cal,forma, ::no that a Nonce oft�'f:�? C f� -.�'_•. '..�::... is SL E'd ierei is a f.uf, .aria c0mI-,ieIe t A3t : ..r 1=.r Or1N jrUt.Jli✓rlN.: 11. tr:t 41.::'aid Mes 1yN,�� Ma�.'1, H:1'11+'�L710"1 Vf't3�rl. }=JUrltRlh 'J? �CY rl��e "r• :a�:�, �._�s� �ommumties ano fc�y�rlo r,eb:n tom' Sai.; newtrspet t:tir I wr-•ks tc: wit the issue(s) of I oaclare, under penalty of perjury, that the foregoing it true and correct. - � t st Costa Mesas CB,A,mils. co 3 PkOOF Of PUSLt AllOrl ; ..' r • f ` + r tib' ' '•"u•' . •, yy , r . +ar t ► SIT. ��4� •�e�a88p " MOOCH, CAEIRORNIA 9E447 17141 3Si-lS50 JANUARY 5 1989 c rY • , pit 'MMIS $ROMAY, CITY CLEM AND 4A M "LE MAYOR AND CIT`C ( Y1 M HERS 2000 MAIN STUET � MMTINGTOR BEACH, CALIF. 92648 SUBJECT: CHANGE IN OUR I,ETTER OF APPEAL, WRITTEN 12/16/88. RE, CUP 88-[3 AND NEGATIVE DECLARATION 88--24. WE NISH TO RMWVE OUR CON4lEtIT MENTIONED IN THE Al0VE LETTER 0". APPEAL CONCIRNING ACCESS TO AND n0K CEDAR AVE AND PALMDALE STREET, ITEM 7 PAGE 4 OF ST"r REPORT DATED I.1;'1/88. " THIS IS TN. ONLY PORTION THAT WE WISK TO WITHDRAW THE UlANCE OF OUR LETTER WILL REMAIN AS WRITTEN. •"I S I19CBAELS T . HILL . a 8*We RAWALL LUOER CC INC. n�{� T fin.Ir, •,1� �{h 41�7" � ,Y�_J. .1iai�iw'�Yti�lilwAY1`f,M.�L=iw�_ ' 1inv.i.•tiYL'.�.'I r"r+h.r.p /xi ,:, „ A '1• • . .,'ti.a --- a.� P. r' I MA�'.A2 ST. t77E1i�11-NlNEE 62647 t.r Olt, t Joe F49 COW" RAOCKWAT. CITY CLEAR ANTI' HONORABLE ::AYOR AND C IT C COUNCIL MEMBERS f 2000 NA7N ST'EERT HUNTINGTON RUCH:, CA 926 SUWECT s APPEAL OF W Sk -23 AND NIRGATIVE DECLARATION: 88-24. W19 HEMT A."L'.L TU PLAYXING CrWISIONIS RULING REGARDING OUR APPLICATION YOR CONDITIONAL GSY PERMIT NO 85-23, NEGATIVE DELLARATIONI NU 88-24, APPROVIM AT THE DECEM13BR 6p 1988 MBELING. WE AU OPPOSINC •TAE FCLLOWING, ITEM3-,, ITEM7 AND ITEM90 AS WRITTEN: IN RUIXEINCE TO CONDITION NO3 ITEM G, PA;�E 4, RANDALL L��BBR IS NOT IN AGREEMENT TO DEDICATE ACCESS FOR FUTURE INDUSTRIAL USES ABUTTING TO THE LEASE AREA. BY HAVING OTHER BUSINKSS RSTABLISHMMS ATUNPiINiG TO USE PART OF THIS AREA � AND RAIL FOOTAGE WOE PROVE TO BE A DISADVANTAGE, TO OUR OPI ATIONs BRINGING ABOUT DISRUPTION AND AN ADVERSE EFFFCT. IT IS NOa IN KEEPING WITU OUR PURPOSE UvrgMD.?D„ UNLOADING AND MOVING MR NATRITAL. Its ADDITION, 'FOR SECURITY REASONS; THIS Wt`ULD PROVE TO NE A DISADVANTAGE FOR US, IN REFERENCE TO CONDITION NO 7 YI G AMISS TO MMOINCT USE Oi LY, RANDALI. LM43U REQU93TS TA?,8, TO 33 CRAY= TO IMLUiDIC VHNICLES OF RL4DALL LUNNDn COKPANT "MIURG 02 CBDAL Aft. NOT ALL OF Oft VIRM.E8 WOULD USE THIS ' Aams AM VOW NR U$ED 01 A LIMITED EKT=TTANT BASIS. ITEM 200M nICLOAR MAKING 0f MUM. C44 A-JL� e.F;• CC 0044 won co rC. owl" 0_ 70 ., 11 - 023 111 - 360 - 12 ''AAN0ALL 0 . WILL1AM � IL :. I/CMS , G. C . � HOHNSTriN PHILIP i RUE DU PARC 7412 CEDAR ST . P . O . BOX 1020 MEWPORT BEACH , CA . 92660 HUNTINGTON BCH . , GA . 92649 HUNTINGTON BCH . 926iS .' 11 -010- 71 111 •-023- 16 Roy Dickson TENACO INC . C/O TAX DEPT . MEL MERMELSTEIN 417 iolt ►l Ell! 13treer. - PO . BOX 54419 1cn"; ANNEX P . O . BOX 2300 Slli t (, 6 0 LOS ANGELAS, CA , 9r. 054 HUN I INGTON BCH . CA ,. 92647 Los Angeles , CA 9U01 � 111 -023--03 113 -023- 17 Mike Kolodl iej Sou-hern Pacific Transpi.. . Co. HOUND , CHONG LOUNG CUCAMUNGA I N DU S f R I AL 610 Main, Street. 8662 pgODKSIDE DR . *FROME INVESTMENTS Los Angeles , CL g1?414 hUNTINGTON BLH CA . 3[ 54S 2900-A BRISTOL ST . #201 COSTA MESA , CA . 92626 { 111 -023- 04 111 -024- 07 Larry Ennernan M, Nationwide Plastering Co. HOLING , CHONG LOUNG GYLDSTRAh3 , LEIF E . 17172 Palmdale Street , #21 f,` 8662 BROOKSIDE DR , 1 / 12. 1 PALMDALE ST . Huntington :leach, CA 92647 � ', I-;UNTINGTON 801 . , CA • 92546 HUN'fINGTON BCH . , 0A . 92647 ' 1 111 -023 - 05 111 - 024 - 08 HANSEN , JOR6EN D. SLA'.ER , RUTH B . TR . 554 Si'EWART CANYON RD . 17162 GOTHARD 5T , FALL BROOK , CA . 92028 HUNTINGTON BCH . , CA . 92647 111 -023-06 111 - 024-09 HANSEN , JORGEN D . SLATEP9 RUTH B . TR . "%64 STEWART C^NYON RP. 17162 GOTHARD ST . FALLBROOK , CA . 92026 HUNTINGTON BC:i , . CA . 92647 111-023•-07 111 -024-10 OE LEONARDI , JOHN $LATER RUTH B . TR . 17021 SANDRA LEA IT . 17162 GOTHARD ST HUNTINGTON BCH . , CA . 92649 HUNTINGTON BCH , . CA . 92647 ' 11-023-08 111-024• 11 OE LEONARDI , JOHN SLATER, RUTH 0 . TR . �,.; 57021 SANDRA LEE ST. 171 - 2 GOTHARD ST . UNTINGTON BCH . ,CA. 92649 HUNTINGTON SCH . , CA . 92647 DE LEGRARD19 JOHN JAMES LUMBER CO i 17021 SANDRA LEE ;T. 17311 NICHOLAS ST . HUNTINGTON gCH . ,EA. 92649 HUNTINGTON BCH . , CA . 92647 li 111 -023- 13 1 ] l�36D�b6 0E LEOMAR01 JOHN JAMES LUMBER CO +! .1.7021 SAwC)RA LEE- ST . P.O. Box 1188 10TINSTON BCH. CA. 92649 HUN'FiNGTON BOH . , LA. 92647 Ii, • of lh* City clefix Huntington unt n rn B h....t,..l.a,..��.1,t...'.,.w_., .. . .. M.YM�tiK4` i.�� M`` )` �•-�: •: ; _ r- C4 rAf �j y rA"1 120 OALIFORMIA 921+46I FIRST 1`{ A 11 �1L3 -0� RDI , JOH{l S NORA LEE Sr , ., NG*i ON BCH . , CA . 92649 OfRao of the City C%rk City of Huntington Beach ..w_.., •.,. 1._., .. . . _ . . .. ._. ��'�'•°"��^��1 ��'�=` �' � • 0,6.BOX lip CALIFORNIA 9264� F;P t� ('I � I 1% • 11 1*23•-08 �W 0 R;DRA I , JOHN LEE 576 Wl . , CA . 92649 AN Ctff oo of the city clor'r City of Huntington Beach MIF"ORNIA 92SU r it 1', ! �1 �� •fir 1 1 •+ 4 i Y; 111 -•023 . GE EQ JOHN �` HUN . , CA . 92649 r olflc& of ihe City Cisrk P.O. !3nX 140 CALIFOFcNIA 92648�� ,: � . •� .., s 3 - 3, 3 RD I , JOHN O j NDRA REF ST El ij . , t;A . 92649 {111111{I{s{{1ss{!sl{s{1!s{;s{11{�!{{!s dill !{sf{{ I' Q +x 1 to+ vqw�fl-&A. i r 011100 Of P"city Clot City of Huntington Huh.. .� ,�.,�.,,, �:, .�•:. 10 CALIFORNIA 9264R �� ,• � �� '� 1� PANT ynl ach, CA 92649ILI ` ; r COY V� f� � Office of the City Gferk - - City of Huntington BeachUr .4.■ox in CALWORN IA 9 t6W! ;1 ; �� ;,�. r� ~"• ' i i pE SEE0 JOHN 170 LEE ST . HUN < . , CA . 92649 � • I II.f,,,�I�i,lip,�i,►II,I,„I,:I„Il�ll,,,l,l�,�i,�ll A.Fuuajjjj8L1)Il JaCRLr1 t{{t .. �.�„ �.•��;c;tc�ti��` ;.,�.:';�.:;. ,� L.: P.O. i tli0 CALIMRMIA 926" FIRS T , , o. 11 3- 13 DE R019 JOHN MORA LEE- ST . L: N SCH. , CA . 92649 Y 1 Y I � I 7. + •• !'r' 1 At 4i d '?4 >" Y of the PUC. More importently, the storage of lumber on the A fnbject Area has absolutely no impact on traffic. As ,shown Oft Pxhibit A attached hereto, the only industrial users of they r� 4 SObject Area would be Randall Luwrber, James Lumber Company , and Ideal ballet Company. Presently, ,Tames f-umber has access d I►d scant to the right of way to service its various lumber yards ►' 7 wnd therefore has no need for access across the SuUject ,Area. ftn4a.* l Luber 'as trucks will take the very same route they are S presently taking to and from its lumber ,yard , and therefore, 10 there will be absolutely no change with respect to the number 11 and route of the trucks on which the lumber will be Loaded. 1,2 And, presently Idjal Pallet has no right to cross Southern pacifies 13 property as per the PLIC ' s decision, a copy of which is attached 14 hereto as Exhibit C. Therefore , there is absolutely no impact 15 or, traffic caused by the storage of lumber in the Subject Area . 16 As a result, there is no logical connection between Condition 17 3.g and reducing the impact of traffic on the surrounding public l� streets. l� 9G 5. The dition :[aeoried by the Commiesion Constitutes an 21 Unconsti utional Talon of private Property Without Just 22 C,�aannjensation in Violates of the 5th Amendment and the K� ':;• 23 Due Pyrocwi Clause of the 14th Amendment of t:,e United F' t,ata GRuStit lion ;�nrsuant to Nolan v, . California 35 CO.g,tal Q9mis*iott (1987) 97 L.Ed Zd 677. $d Since, fhrre, is no logical connection between Condition 27 24, a,-d alleviating traffic impacts on� Q p public streets , said S$ Condition constitutes an unconstitutional takiag of private y l Ilk IL F property without hue Process of Law in violation of the Sth A aid 14th Amndment• to, the Constitution via Nolan v. California 3 Costal Comission (1907) 97 L.Rd . 24 677. In that case, the 4 Su►pror Court of the United States invalidated a Condition imposed 5 by the California Costal Commission on at home owner requiring b that hoe owner to grant a public casement across its beach 7 front property an a condition for gxanting ek Vormit to build r l'( d a house can the property. The Court held that said condition g in effect constituted a taking of property without just compensation 10 in violation of the Sth Amendment of this Constitution . 11 The Court reasoned that the Costal Commission ' s require- 12 ment that the Nolai&q allow the public an easement to pass across 13 a portion of their property as a condition for granting a Permit � 14 to build, a house on the property constituted Legislative extortion 13 since there was no evidence that their proposed development 16 would have a direct adverse impact on public access to the beach . 17 (Id. at 689 . in Similarly, in our case, there exists ro evidence that { 19 the simple storage of lumber on the Subject Area will impact 30 traffic on the public streets. As a result, the Commission r 31 in constitutionally prohibited from requiring Randall Lumber 33 to dedicate access across Southern Pan;ific ' s right of way in order to relieve traffic on the public streets. With rem � ., F pact , 24 to the "logs cal nexus test", this came is identical to them„& 25 drier and the reforer the Condition imposed by the Commission � 10d 00n titutes an unconstitutional taking of primate property in O alation of the Sth Amendment. ' 28 120 s : 4 00 yti'i Randall Lumber hate Abso.littely No Ri h� Under the Lease $ N roament With Southern Pacific to Irrevoc4bly Conyes�; $ "d Offer to Dedicatee Access Across Southern Pacific ' s d ProPerty for Abutting Inds rial Users. 1 . !� Finally, and perhaps most basically, the Commission' s 6 Condition 3 .9 requires Randall Lumber to dive up property rights 7 that it does not possess. For example, the Commission is requiring d Randall Lumber to convey an "irrevocable offer of access" across 9 Southern Pacific' s right of way. This is clearly a property 10 right and one that would exist in perpetuity . however , Randall 11 Lumber ' s Lease Agreement does not exist in perpetuity and does 12 not give Randall Lumber the right to convey any access across 13 the Subject Area. , let alone access rights that extend beyond 14 the life of the Lease. It is an axiomatic priiicipal. of property 15 law that one can only convey an interest in property if he 16 possesses such an interest . It would he an anomaly indeed 17 if a Lease;e of property could convey interest to third partie3 � 18 that survive the life of the Lease without the permission of 19 the Landlord. As a result, the Commission 's Condition is simply 20 not "orkable and should be voided by the City Council . $1 $9 rxz . 113 CONCLUSION $d Based on the foregoing points and Authorities as discussed $$ he:ein, the City Council of the City of Huntington beach is ' 8d ra ctfull y requested to void Condition 3.g imposed by the 27 PlhAding comi,a sign. $$ Vateds Decor 160 1989 Respectfully submitted# y By y ` FW 016130 ', . +1 Vic,.•',+,.' •,• , +': •a,�.�'��,F��+� j Alf � +. s WARN A + t AVE* , 'Sl CEDAR AVE* IDEAL PALLET coo JAMES LEER CO. 41-14 JAMES LWER COO. RANDALL LIFER 00t i4y ; AL • a r 7 1� F lslr�=' C OEM .1 AL hontiottle deice P1310119 CIMMISS1810 : r P.G. bob[ 1" CAL.IMON41A SUM I:e asoeed _„�,19�1 i I I i f PLC M DEC 110TICS OF ACTION Awliconts Randall Lumber Co. 17332 GUthard Street - Huntington Beach, CA S abj&Ct i CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 88-23/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 88-24 Your application was acted upon by tho Huntington Beach Planning Commission on December 6 , 1988 and your request wags Withdrawn Approved Approved with Condi tuna XX (See Att4chea) Disapproved r• . Tabled ' Continued until Under the provisions of the Huntington beach Ordinance Code, the action � taken by the Planning Commission is final.1. unless an appeal is filed to the City Council, by you or as interested party. Said appeal oust be in waiting and Must ,cart forth in detail the a►ct.ions- and grounds by and upon Wtiab the aepplicQ t or Interested part l deems hims-alf aggrieved. d&id appeal curt be L-40ompanied by a filing fee of one hundred and Sixty-five (4165) dolla►sae and be suba►i trod to the City Clerk '• off ice wi thi s ton (10) days Qf the date of the Caaatssion'ar &*tics. In your *arse, the last day for filing an appeal and paying the filing ' fee far Decreer •16, 1018 provisional of the suntinotce soaeh oediaax►ce cowo are sudh beat fty A 1 iC&tice b"O"s ae11 00 void one (1) year after 11 arl apprOWL20 on ers ae#aal 00ft0trUOtice Ua started e .r'.J , f 4 ` �� .I... .'.IMF,�'SS- TiiF LMWM... yi.,. ,,.• n _ ......i...... ._._'_._.. iiM/)pp 7r#t' n 11 til .u' yj l •i,:y 81tingfan lack P181 161 C400181191 1 , . �►aoere r �, gee RECEIVED DEC 12 1 Mantis l l Lumber Cos 173$2 Gothard street fluntinqton Reach* California 91647 SUB MT: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 88-23/EECATI'VIR DECLARATION NO. 88-24 RXMST: To allow unloading , loading and star~rge of lumber � producto for a maximum of 5 years on leased property. � LOCATION: Southern Pacific right-of-way on the went We of railroad tracks located at the eastern terminus of Cedar Avenue (approximately fob feet etnt of the intersection of Gotha rd Street and Cedar Avenue) . oan or "PWVAL: December 6. 1988 1 . The establishment, maintenances aril operation of the proposed temporary loading, unloading and storage of lumbar products for live (5) yoars will not be detrimental to: a. The general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity; � h. Property and imperoveinnts in the vicinity of st;,.:h use p�, building. #6 Utilining the site for loading, unloading and ivtora a of lumbar I r$h l LuWwr and providing future access for the adjacent 1ft4 t i l0l Uses$ through the proposed storage area will ", ' •,` '61ifti t* potential increased vehicular 1XVacts on local itrofte Gad arterial** N` s. Providing rovingalong the designated roadway portion of the site will provi adequate support for file apparstur and adeptate, dust control . r ;�re 1 �•: .., .. ...... .-. u+6+.ram w 'VMXTXCMZ USX MMIT MQ« 88-2$/pEGAT1V'1P MCLARATION NO. 88 -24 41. Tho pro"sead loading, unloading and storages of lumWr on the site i8 convietatt with the City's General Flan which permits industrial cures of t%ta type. I x DEC 12 go " " Ve "f'�r site plan dated received September 28, 198�, shall be `' rovised and resubmitted to depict the following modificstiones a« Lumber rtack area$ shall be limited to 50 by 15G feet with 15 feet rpacing on all sides of each lumbor stock. b. Turning radius for fire lanes sha'16. 1 be designed to Fire Department specificationc . c. All gates shall open to full width with no canter posts . 6. Paved su�:faee on all fire lances and vehicular :ravel lanes. 2. Prior to use of the lease area for lumber storage, the applicant shall obtain a Certificate to Operate. 2« Prior to lexuanca of a Certificate to Operate, the applicant � shall comply with the following 1,tems : j a* hlVo (2) fire hydrants are required and shall be installed J subject to Tire Department approval of location with a minim= water flow of five thousand (5.000) gallon$ per minute. bt A Paved surface shall be provided for the fires lanes and Vehicular travel lanes which Sri l l be capable of supporting ire apparatus subject to tIAe approval of th a Fire pa rtMnt, unity Development and Publics Works A sit fact high fence shall be providod around. the storage Cad6f Avenue improveaernts per Public Works standaard,$ shall �. +0* OwkingO signs sbsll be posted inside the storage area, r it* Departsent rat shall be issued for this storage sobilitr upon C1,00pretion and compliance of all Fire Report ant r"uirments« 4 f, ., s?; . I a �'. whuT.eiCSltli�liiA.ii1M�lfi iuFY}IN}.LY,r,..4;+'M M' •,i,.+:rr I.• '.,,. . .t r > ,,. .,y,',• 4y"'�43':•1:y}6'n7V�llti':k.h w n R r , Yi /1 YY++ 41 A r I'41 x3 o + USM P MIT NO. 88-23/92GATIVR DECL"ATION 00. A8-24 ApIpliceat anal/or property owner shall submit a signed and botarised irrevocable of;er to dediC+ate truck access for lyd"8trial uses abutting tho lease area. A copy of the 1 legal instrument shall be approved by the City Attorney as to form and content . A copy shall be filed with the °• Department of Comunity Development. 4 . Nazi height for lumbec stacks shall be sixteen ( 19) feet. S. Fire apparstus accece shall be provided from the south through the existing Randall Lumber Co. facility. 8 . The operation shall comply with all applicable pr•oviBions of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, Building Division, Department of Public Works and Fire Department . 7 . Access to and from Cedar Avenue and Palmdale Street to the subject site shall be limited to emergency access only. 6 . The lease area shall not be opE"u to the general public for retail sales. 9 . The proposed use shall be restricted to unloading and loading of railroad cards and storage of lumber. 1 10. Time period of Conditional Use permit No. 88-23 shall be for a period of fivca (5) years from approval date. " 11. The planning Coarrrifssion reserves the right to revok6 Conditional Use permit No. 38 -23 if any violatio. of these conditions or the Huntington Beach Ordinance Cide occurs. I hereby certify that Conditional Use permit No. 88-23 and Negative Declaration go•. 98-24 were approved by the Planning Commission of the city of funtington Beach on December 6, 1988, upon the foregoing 9in4iege .Dnd, eorditions. This approval irepropents conceptual a proval.^ Only; detailed plans must be submitted for review and the T' a oremationed coviditions completed prior to final approval, Kik* Adam, Secretary 1. Flowing Comiasion bry ,T as Senior Planner ,I f n r^It•der / ..,. '.� 'r „ii•+r 1 q' M F711"�+Ldf�Ny • LE I I / OCT 9 0 1997 1 M1r plrlart $T&.%9-&6j4 OCt*MW Io, 1987 t SINInv , it Coe"nktloa or Maio tin iriAWAUS �.`• ass �a�lx��rl• r (111104 p Q40b*r to,V load) -IPACx'*_C TRWKSTATION FACMIC detoodants. Ote * Attairmy at &av o for # tC,�Y'RaY tC L31er r �� .. 4:06t am Pam f f o Twaipportati any t MA a Ati:drnry Loll or $ou w� ��IQ Tomad C n 4r4 891 404tharn Qadi ia Iredustri. Da"Iqpmmt Ccegway1 dotmodants. Compird tr ld"% oallsis sygrt", Uc, (Ida&&) and Vol r�Yol�oie� t�r��atr�na hll d�r�t�inati+� �� dotants ;` A�► Paa i tic TrandrexutLom Gd (SP) , f outharn ftai t is jAnd �oJpu•34 R and dostbitn ftdtrio toduatrIsl Covslopment ft (aotn-*0 in WmAx Nell to build a SWC track tar hest ar to 1pnWise a a is Wo ImMa track so 14@41 apuld tk*a wpm j SWOWW ts b stk sldor ad a r.ilvey Mr while 1 atllAl+V z l 's mite" arud R014 m" Mith such iaailltls*. ry I / r / r 4 r l.i .. .00 a • Ideal turOor alleges that Wendantb nave refuted to all►@V .94oal to stone lumen on the night-at-vey property It laaaed 91mm di nt while ollowing Ideal•n eosyet iota and neighbors to Ott JUMOV on lerA aieiloriy leased Efdl1 deftndantd• rincirt ii fMlo t►Ut ditaedli aU have termWted Idoal's rears of deft0ftnUt rk4twofeway prqwrty and MY* imrarxed Ideal that they wll# out odd Sdeal•s socoad to the team track for unloading of lwWWw while otill Vriential moese to the team track to taeal' s a N.Aterw and melyMmme ideal contendor that It bat u f to red to puraMot tho pywisu ly leased property from 46tendants for the Vm&Vmm oil puttlat in a *par t,xacXo but treat dalandant• have Venom tw "U the Pr"Wrty to x4e1Al. _ ideal gaintains that dol Bate• Actlonr or* In v,iolotion or "lie utilities (PU) C040% 8eO 3*m 46I a" that Neal will oo aompetitivsly harked by i�► eni�s• eot�t+ Ideal reams an order txosMA Ilea 60mmisrf ran x"svirsnd, d#Sessd to dust ;dee& tall •r.oessa to unloadirq and loading 1"SIStfes at tiro •team Ug" Immediately behirA and 6414 t to Idool •e property and prahi>bi.ting 4efer4ants or any other -aatity !ter I . ��i Ideal '* access Beta to tsr1� track area 144# 4 ana used by xasol. i . =fit a e or eterin an?! d a Whieli �l ry ter* with Neal a ooe"S' to the I. fir!ng or sellinuoU rlghtwat-way MOC-Or YJ n i•i ttp aesd h 304twe! • truck to any enter other. 'awn 11 +Atf 00d4# 600t-10n• r+ater 'Gd is in this dealslen are in tas M %w. '" KI go 4'. �' ydr.w,' Y r 1—N+1 ■ 1 . .+ r• , d.td+il-Qpd hlJ/Mh't/ekiltq 'YM , * t ►ily, M lthmnh ideal's atonthmto•aonth tenancy with hp bag 6tn terM"tad in av=rdance With the saran of the original ]LOBOS. l 1. gray avail itself og dpo s ho4reat Ppubl is teas tracku ftr gnJ"drop of IuWwr WhIeA is appro•Aisateltr tWO Alas AMY. � ie Lt will iw lancer have trio convenience of "b&Ck dooe vallerding Chet It enjoyed unearth* lase, Idea). Will be no worse :. egg Uan other members of -As nil 9rgJVht receiving publ!o who are ra § m t Mituated Oong a Fail Line arg who gave to go to the noaroat public teas ths4k to recrive their freight shipmwtoo We conclude, Cron &Ll the avideAct, that rip did not violate Beet ten 453 and that tha emplaint should !m denied. a -��s►� &to 1v;i2dfatlen Although a quebtion repar+dinyi stata versus tedoxal, JOrisdlctlan was raised by 4.hN AW during the heartaq, se was MM V016 ra NM at. Issue by either party in their pleadiagr. The Bair Imue pgapea•1If bolero the eoanisei an is tho Isovs at dinarlatnatt.an di v dautit'a 453 al lagod by cvepLainstst aV* r Whi6h va do have Jurisd letior wt wa nand not, therefore, oonaldar any federal vwmftm Mate u�"'I�� t�Q�fp�! i�l �•r it no voe of a qs-x-too -Coat parcel cc spoe right of w*y by td I ur+as subject to tho to elms of a one-year written lease, nelo f nd ontered into by rip wA ideal.. t . A tar the one-Year l vase eXpi real, Ideal continued to us* d►S6XWJ8§=tQ0t rightdDot.V,%Y ,pas'oal an a aronth-tenth basis --now t" team at tho original lease. 1. The tr"r of the l+"" franted Saab party the irilht to " UxIdAWto the l oeve on tt d eys i wtitUm notions i0 the ter" of the xer " pr*OLted Id".1 Isar etaylng IMMor on the ti-x-1 Jtbq lewaed pa rml . g+ Mai a+tva* VISP SUM tMt ' 11A b0 psrwitted to atera ,1. Imber an Its leased paw. rr M y r$4,e I i go 61 i •. �� a tscarrt inu l its Warnar Avenue ,rpm: l lac team t raok when id ieasod a major part len of that right Of w&y tQ Jaaas Lumber ►erlY. . f . ljat Y any continue to race f wa toil $hlpents Of IUWMW# AS It so devi:#a, at the public team tracke alerq with other terra of the railcar lydight rec4iving ptbilo, JaMtod two jriles *way a . sp has no 14gti ebl igat-fort t�% pernit Industrial recolvere Pt ra i lasr Rrs ioh% whose properti a• 11v along a rail line to come rat« dPr•a right of way ter loading or wiloadinq purpo tos without � dP's psrsisaiion. • 9 . Public team tracks or lsaigbt stations dssignatsd by tP ore, available to r*oeivers of railcar freight for unloading or Pei�llvtnq traiybx. 10. SP drew uo V' I#in• and cast, figuer+rr for iastallatlon of A wLtch and spec to ideal . 110 dP did not re,tuss to fnwtalY. a rail spoor for* Idtal , �.,.. 22 . Wool ra tuna d to 'hays of Ott ll a switob and :apu bmaura of cos t+ 13. as t s-r atnsted Tdool l■ manth-to-a*nth occupancy of SP#s r1ght eff way in aroor khae with toe to **9 Oe ariginol loasa+ U . aP did no: unlawtully discriPinate againat Ideal . 1t. MC*. #rid APIWe, are, not public -0121tira. ` , IRAs o! jWW .• . 1, Since thle cowl"mart do** nat have Jurisdiction Over j *VM*,, and SPIDCa. , the tWMP 4Lnt r as to tbese dgtanftatk s •e avis e It 14ktl h0i ft4t Mrt ft4g WV46M Of p=oot 60 to UhIaW'tUl diewilaination or or 4FA ito ooW343nt ohmaid ks deal•a_ 1 �'�•� '�••'�� •:�� TI�011 .! M 6„•iy,I��!; ' �� u�1�� ''�'''.%,4�ry�••'��nt'� �i.� ,�/ .�;Y ^. ��r�rL�� '��';�r�i�+' N^•��5{..V p�,'��.rra �'.:,.r A�A.��;�' � ;�� '� r� �� A'r� r. �I �. '��i��1"�I {�Yp��,��, �.�M..� '"��',o, Y.�,,; +�'`1,ir1 ;,;�� :�,.�� 'r' "'y,;.��.��•.�� .`��•'�•• .,' .! ..� ��'1�,, •��} �rr y�� 'n',�I!r��r ".,.,A A. �M`r 4d,• ';•+', ° e+' 'art' ,' Wit lot n „r Y.' : •1 . .� l a' g �. (do Adomm 0as wit* Re t .to 0 s r ' TIO "*gob* at I ft&U* $,V*t4We ZW• NM % '• ' 0' Pr�� ►�i� �� o der s�o�r titer. ' Went Dona VUL � 'Q M Almillm i S* 7 L • . II Fi. s ' r, i ; d • 2r +. rfs.•. . . , 4 '� •' f "fir ^ y '' � �, , � r +'Tj • 96 ' }fir / ' ,•.r'��•i„, '' ` � ' ', r "AL ALLET SYSTEM, INC. . t r 74n CEDAR STREET HUNTING TON MACH,CALIFORNIA MM7 PNOW 4213)804M or 1710 W MI Pl artnitr` ttpp� ck Pla"Ins Camission Web rt f radk � i n- Ana late Planner •• apt• 1 , 1 S88 iV-"7%Mt of COMMitY 00velopMunt This 1s o rtipectfulIy ,request the Huntington Beach Planning Commission that the CorAltiomal Use Permit number 8h-231Nggative Declaration numer 88-2t. requested � the applicknt, Randall Lwober' Company, not be granted on the grotxrrds th8�,: • • . It wi 11 01 splaCe the ideal pallet CoTpany •coamappletely and totally and i, cause it to coast' existing as a viable lumber and pallet operation. Since 107s.9 Ideal Pallet Company has been dependent on havinq,,agcess to t►re Southern f ac i f i c Puhl i c Team Track it Ili nteesberg, for the W a purpose of ragpivirrg and uni-Ailing its. direly needed raw materlal ( lu r y , far its exister . , See photo-copy of letter where it apeclficalIy .stipulates "' The only Bak will be. throogh Ideal Pm11it's adjoining property." ) � . Ltaber is Idoa1 Pal 1 et's ,ea i n stay anJ without it becomes non operable OW ultimately A(ln-existent. ' �-�- Idvil Pallet has -been in continual operation since 1965 and has always paid its taxes ar.d bills in a timely manner. ( See photo-copy of Lusrmans latest credit relort .enclosed. ) Approximately fifty percent of its lumber e.ost goes towards freight and the major receipient from that, freight i§ and always has been the Southern Pacific -kilraad Company, whose representatives are in concert with Randall Lumber Company to di;,�1 ocate Ideal pallet Company, its owner and its 12 employees, whose sel e 1 i vel i hooe has been der i veal for all those year* on a sterdy and secure basis* By b1twl:-irg Ideal 's access to the Southern Pacific MintersbeCg Public Tooia Track and b%, Rangy►all storing lumber along side the narrow path adjacent to the Ideal Pallet's boundry, it will pl a Ideal Pullet into an additional fire hazard. our trucks and numerous Southern -Pacific Piggy-back Vans that enter our Main gate at Palmdale will not be able to egress unless access to and through the . outhern Pacific right-away is left open as It always has been. A BRIEF HISTORY OF WHO WAS HERE FIRST: As you may be aware, Ideal Pallet was the first lumber and pallet manufacturinp Coapany to locate its facility in Huntington Beach, along the �, Southern Pacific Public Team Track as early as 1971-72. After going through NNW inn 6� r1s? +1 'Y .• . `+11+1 .. �._ 01 ` :• VY 771 ' '; lei`; ,.• s •. s • the difficult legal process of eminent lain and relocation procliria.' with the Co,ant of Lot Angeles and the Southern pacific Rai 1 road Canny O ideal Pallet f pally located ;ts Manufacturing facilities to a cowiprable l�a ion a � tPacificern Rai1 Line in Huntington Beach. Haviny access to the Southern Pacific Wintersberg Public Tess Track was the w►ai i reason Ideal Pallet located its facility from Las Dales County to Orannggee County, In the City of Huntington Beach. 11 eaeeplied �'• with every ordinance code. ( Set copies of letters 3/14/72 and 4/b/72, ) and Ideal Pallet is hereby •respectfully requesting: that all parties along thu saw strip and i 4 ,the saes•typo 9f ration be equally bawd by the Cityof Hunting Beach ordinance code ser ion and comply fully with the Huntington leach planning Department and the City Ordinance Sections. 3aaes L x6er .Co wny located its facilities across from Ideal Pallet r during 1975 76, while Randall Lumber located its facilities next to Ideal Pallet not unt i 1. 197E. Both aaoes Lumber and Randall Luber, with tho cooperative of -6;he Southern Pao fi c Railroad, constructed a spur track, which l eAds into their iwewd i ate facilities. Ooth James and Randall do not have to depend on the exisring team track, while Ideal Pallet System, continuously, to this day, riffles es solely and almost 'exclusively on the Southern Pacific's des-;gnated team track num*r 4992, for its raw material ( lumber j to be shipped in, as well as their piggy-beck systm. �1 As indi+:ated before fifty percent of Ideal 's cost for the raw -material � (. Coes towarJi freight and to be excluded from access to that freight would be tantamount %o I dea l l s demise. The City of Huntington Beach and many of its werchants and citizens would be denied accessibility to --noden pallets locally if ideal were to cease to ex st. Outside truck traffic would increase Considerably as a result and by additional heavy truck traffic to Huntington Beach, from the Southern Pacific's piggy-beck traffi.:. What is also crucial for the Commission to consider is that if Ideal Is " put our of business " by the action of the granting of this Conditional Ilse Permit 1.0 Randal 1 , i t wi 11 be the death of a 23 year old reputable company and a toss of ,fobs to its employees whose employment at Ideal has been the source of Income and their l i vel i hood. RespectlAJIj sftjted .._.. Mel Nermel st ei n - Ares i dont IDEAL PALLET S1 MN O I NC. . i ,a '""' ''f1 r • �, ,,' Wr;" by C - tt +a�• " . , }n ,, .. : ,. f tMY�. A 3 \ f r� ia,, 1� � R '1• ar.r i ,� f 1 1 ♦5r• . d 1•k} 1 af/ r f r i•i. 'fir Cr4 Y' a' r ",; , , .. P� p•µ� , '�� ,P�f ��i„`"' h'Y+t 'rt r,! •.• .. .' r .'i R i'�,� �+';Or r . . � � +. ,.r�,`. yy :��+ ir.:}+,r r�Z�i,f • : r'P, :1, •' I, aS� ,1,� err . )r, 1 �,,, i 1•.nr• w•Wrl ' r'. 77' r ( 'k xy' +M( +r,r i Si r �•K. ., i , , � J'� + r,. �tiNr+fk',ha�i� /, �1s1'•v«'r', �•h :r ( ,`T' w •: •'aC,' r .. .. i M 1� it ~MPo� w�r1t k�p�rr t Ott :. { M im r�� w� sit �'' CdAbtr�r To to 90• IS44 Marjull fiber Co. 17332 ►thard stt"t July Is* loss Hunt. Sasebo CA 93447 r EY $Oat.tbo rn Pacific Isi l road deptember lg, 1980 i1C South Hain street Aerge i", CA !ad la s MI (General •�' I>sdustriel) To *lief daloadis ` lead- Ing awaa►�d storage of lumber hr. Jam: GeneraNl jccAkIcto for a e 21=m of InduStrial t years on i**$** jproperty @ , low: ►n a bh racif is rlgbt--of- 'load aq and au81044ing area. M *s the crest side of r' ;14 I as** V tacks mated at t 1.25 &e tas 31 tba. east*rs terminus of ceder Avenue (approximately � SOC feet .east of the inter- woction of dothard street ` 'W CAIda r Avenue) . ' Ova Aeration No. dd-Za and Waditioual Use Permit . iSS►' find iaa a sad cesnditioes of approval. � MltOrstl Ueo serlalt No. 88 -33 is a request by Randall Lumber Co. to utt ors a1.20 act* site which is owned by the southern Pa►cif is manse " tor "lead* load sad store luaatt products for a period oaf � five (s) years pursuent to Section 2432, 2ofterstZ Sp AIA Zama# of the ftatlagdton peach Ordinance Cod*, i 1 • R T•{- ��9rr5 R,.y1 �yl.r��r'�Et(�P � f� ' .rr��R�, N m4�'� It. . �., .,,�� *,,Ja r,7lw;y� (Fr'; ',•I�i'{I +,• •, � i .'t�, 1W �,,J• f 6J 1. \ J+. Y T 1 F, w r ( �.r lf,�, •"i�rlVl�,,.l :1. 4�I rYf , iJ SI "rA '.r +'T t f" .,I•'I IM•T 1, ` 7' 4F I, ) Ilk rn'I :''; ;• !r.i :�+.1, :j f .rhl�l�� „~,U,4R*1�• �,'� � •�. rl . . k .,aio,lal —�R•:'x'W' .'..,.�,�y�`,F:. I.�• t. rI 1�1�1�""N113y g 00.104diso, 34841me 49d store" of lumbot products by J ar `WA 101MIGN I Senegal Industrial Ir Xx (General laftetrial) t •, Nbol4aale lumber VzowMssirag (JUMS r'ti'; Lufter Co e lmhjuw ia"ItV CAM me 16"T3011 t General Industrial _ us (General Industrial) Molerale laseber piruwasing (Kafadali UPWWr Co m' RtM, hTIM General Ims"ttial ,� • �. � {deea+rrat la�Euatrial� � t il�aroaesal�e allet ;:;:*Gassing (Ideal . . Pei alot Co ' Wkt to the tsnviroamatel. Togulations in effect at this Heuer, . art Of C AYSit* Developarant parts* draft p'egativd r Ma►e ati-t4 four toes day$& and no Cooments, either verbal or � `t "to f ived. The staff, is its initial stuay of the 6"Alk ed , M. 1 l�,XMM ended that a native declaration be Issued. jPaioar to any actkbn an Conditional Use l*ersiit do. $8 .23, it to ' Oat"Weiry for tb il rlanninp 00MISsion to review and act on Onative l set 6n do. 48-24 . CC -STATM: Not . _... PPlicablo• sacIFIC, , M: Not appl' cable. • ..�. MIY-1-8i.� CM1 t Not applicable, too lest MM._.AM119tat Sarndsll 16UWAWZ CAI- iN prapasing to utilise an existing *team Brack" aree bated between dame t:usbar Co . and ideal pallet Co. tat Stolle Report - !r 7/tt •g- �� M r {~ !J r,a i .i Y f f gob "1W. y' mate mVp loading and storage of iueabar products for s rlod of ltaa W ream$ The tequest is wiry similar to t., ea tin, Jaarss Lbor Co. operation 10e4tled to the riosth of the pro NO site. The Jamep lamb e>: . gray storage us• was ap roved the City Council on Moverrber 17 IT868 with a nusbr o� eendit one of appsava'l . Randall Lumber Co. is booking to operate their Proposed taWrory use with the requirements a$ the Jams LuSibet Co. operation. Staff has analyzed the Jamey Lumber Coo use and recommends one signigiaont departure From their conditions of approval. Staff • recommends that fire lanes and vehicular travel lanes be paved Prather than just provide an "all-weather~ surface. The fire Department has recommended the paving in order to support fire apparatus in case of a fire. The •all -weather" surface that was required of James Lumber Co. has proven to be unacceptable to their. give S'ightinS capabilities . lities . Another issue that needs to bm addressed is providing access to the P team track for on existing business that abuts the "tsars track" area. Randall Lumber Co . has obtained an exclusive lease for the 'steam track" area from the Southern Pacific Railroad QuWany which does not of low 14001 Pallet Coe (currentlythe only other user of the to m track) access to the "tam track" in order to ogre-load #nd load their products . Staff has a concern with cloning access to .the tease tracks If ideal Pellet Coe does ' riot have ass to the team track« two large truck traffic will increase on Palmdale Street, Cedar Avenues dothard' Street and other ma or arterials. Staff it reg+ mmand j g that Randall Lunar Co. provide ideal Pallet Co. access across they lease area in order to minimise vehicular impacts on existing streets. Staff supports the applicant 's request to operate the proposed use for fine (i) years with conditions to provide ideal coal?.et Co. access only to the "team track" and to comply with all staff recommended conditions of approval. Staff rccommends that the Planning Commission approve Negative larratian U06 96-26 and ConditiOnal Use permit No. 88-23 with the following fin6inas end conditions of approval: irLIDINOA MR AlUMALs 1 . The establishment, maintenance and operation of the proposed temporary leiadin , unloading and storage of lumber products for five (S) Terre wIl l not be detrimental too. a . The general "alter* of persons tesiding or working in the vicinity; b. Property and improvenespts In the vicinity of such use or bu i ld iner . StMEE Repast 9.17I'66 41 } J,N 1 I " n Yx7!A 7 ' , i, fy f 7 Y •: 'M1T+•r .j' � ;i"',,'�'7s l' ',1+.1 7 F;11'1 {I..r s, •1 i Jig . • .f • • • . IN: 444444 • / 9' ` �►Jlt I. # for ielMdis/ µalo0ing and Stan"", of 29116019 sod l ids tyre for the adjacent tevh" Itroulb the. 1COV0604 stoareve,. s*es ,.M 11TUtiate potential increased vehica ar impacts an local doll eted sosdMay .� � raise of the site V I hr wlso sdeduate support for lire apparatus end! .r; edegg0 S. ,Cont too proposed aoddi"t ualoading and storage of lumber on the site Is ooneistdnt With the City's "Recoil 1Aan which persists 4440941111 tutees 02 this h sit* plan datwd ;taWciived sae "t, 348C shall I* revised and ir"01mittod to "Ipict the, fd1lowing ssditiaations t s g. I441e41t a minima 30 .feet wide OCaesc 6tea f soft gate aponiUg for Ideal Ballot Co:; to teas , track. b, 16usJxor stack arias shiWbe llzite4 ta' SO -by SO foot with 15 foot spacing on all rides of each lumber stack*. ¢ ' 'i'lrs gas ► t his for fire lanes shell bi fidk i jsred`1d 'piss Dopatta�ans •psclficatians. } d, All votep shall both id -full" width with no center pasta. et, , pav surface on all tirii lanes and vehlealar travel lenses 1 . Prior to issuance of a Certificate to Operate, the applicant shall fir with the following items: a. poug (4) fire hpdrants are required and shall be installed sub Got to Pi tie Deportment approval of location with a D0 wet flew of five thouset4 15,060) gallons per ►fie. , b. A paved Surface shall be provided for the .fire lanes and vehiculat travel latws wbicb sill be capable at supporting fire apparatus subject to the approval of the piss Department, COM MunitY Derrelopmftnt. and public Mork$ Dena rtia ant . . co A six foot high fence shall be provided around the storage site. d# Cedar Alfeilub improvesents per public M rks standards shall be competed. s. *no omol-Ang's signs shall be posted inside the storage area . � d of r "port y117 e •Jh �� ^r, . ; !3 ,..i��i iyL� } Nor : a ; 1 ie .'� '•y* {, �is , 1 dq w� ■i . It 446, � n��r � 12Y •r }.Ot r M �s �,l d �, •i i � f yF i i SR" �" �,.y�, , 17r •iA{ y,pe• )r r VIR i °L 1l 4 b R r', .., r 146 4 ,{ A rise attmat rrMit $ball be issued for -this sterrollo facility Opole o p tion and Compliance of all Ti to p',• to Aftlicant armor property mast shall submit s 01944 and . •....is sed access a ro ant to permit use by ideal 214t *1 9eot wide acaessway on the subjedt Site n awsal "llot Co, access late to tease track« copy of 1 1 al f nst rument shall be approved by the cMoe R Wormy crartment to form and. content . A copse shall be cwltb the of Community Development e s . gas" beight for lurrrber stacks shell be sixteen (id) feet , 49 Fit* apparatus accbas shall be providod from the south through ` t -69101ng RaMall Lumber co* facilitye a .' son shall con► r with all applicable Provisions of hh 1too Mooch Ordinonce Code, Building Divisiorti, b+rp►aNrt of public Works and lire Deporrtnrent. fie ACC048 trom Cedar Avenue shall be limited to emergency ecoess only I • r� it, • The 1 1 storage► yard shall not be open to the goneral public for roth 1 solos* • S. %U 01 Bee hall be veltrictsrd to ualoadi , loadin and � stb1r ago lumber* � d to Vi00 of Conditional Use Permit bo. tt�•23 shall be for • tiAmri of t ive (b) years; from approval !latee io. The Pleasing Commisvion reserves the right to revoke Conditional 'Use Remit M. •t-xl it an violation of then* eapd1tions or the t ptington Beach Drdleardoa Ccde *course e :' Planns mission may modify Conditional Use Permit pro. GO-2$ ad deactibdid or Sony with flndings. t 1. Area snap i k* site plan dated June 9« 1989 3. Letter from Southern Pacific Railroad dated received Ausuet S, 1SBS 41 Loose Agreeivent between Randall Lumber co . and Southern pacific Railroad b. #egat9TS De•slaratiort No. 68-24 sN:s�ytkla d Staff Report !.'7/B• r$ 1 ■ L S, 1 vjo h4L - y. r � r � one Nar*1 sot All : did. I r` r�r 4r Y'�,� ,1fr}1'wt�`y�gY� t�,l(77( yvTt!1 t i1'k •�I � 1 .14 ir I L; IP OW Wli rr' ` ' Ai '.v.�: F" •�fXL '•W � •�i 4i7��YY'_W ��,- .•.r.,:��. hJ .;n.� d... - .r•�MyrNl� . ' ItfY A ti a qp � a .,,)f, +•:0 •• •. j ' y i• 4 0. k �• + ,� 41Pa e. as ISO `( ` w•.PON ft a t 4 .4L t e 1 t I �IMy Aprome ' • .. .. .,� � �.. ( � ;.1 ' i •lam'- ��' ry: , Y�• a, a'°� ��'.� / •, �f �,r,, ;� '�.1y,� �1 ;vr"l' 4"k�+� ' 4,. V. r KIR V�'" .',.2�,� � N+ {' f'�f� '.I,��rrr„` ,. �.li,, r 1'S4R,. �,A,r r N ''Iv ,'' .. `r '�' * I v' � • + era<� WS° '✓ � r i `I+ 1'i+' r. . ` 'F — F �I�•S'. ' ,1,* ';'� , �rr,� F a, r r r ti �• v v .+. >, big I Max ijk- 0 : T I x t I �4 .,V °':. 'A+yr .I• r . I,I`. .7:'rm '6:1i . ` d.. +i'rr'v"•: 'i � �. I 'I w i IM •rr 'ba• . ',,,9��}`f;a�ti', 'rip• , � 1 hh tir. '.; ; M ^Ix Is x -I Poll" � 1 v ors U *or fA6m oonve0sation this date pertaining to ideal . sal ia�i+i still Ads leap onP property at !lunt,nptQn ` ,htto~ is copy'at letter sent to Mr. Mv�Ystd'in at Ideal G yalt�t.' , It ds"i Leapt Dopsrtnent at Ssn..Pramisco was out -` Al to OWWO Utionr 061. ther&loro v continued to s p&OWnt Also ?M s*nding vapy of letter which 1 sent to our Were DeOMWtment w f it ► '40 s they did cease in flailing .mottcos btt. Mir. MMkm%s"$A hts. Our Leers Depart t !$greed they► 11� Ili"' ' in wt 'nat1i� notices, then �9ar *ailing notices again. r wo .pp*en to wr Uase Mpartmont mW Owy will again comas to i 1 of tilii turd fttuni to Mr. Mfr"Istein all *ani,a$ taransitted since r , As $eft rw backgro . 11x. t xtaalatain fileo suits with t4o CM �ark6" titer. A two day hearing was WA in Un AMples Wit"LOAPA loot. ' Mr. Meawlstain then filed suit with Caiitornis 't x tt and lost towro ai**. Yir dbcW* Ration is n"ftd of those actions. 1 will gladly provide. Your$ truly, R. J6 rlson Itjr. sir�ese dsvelalstrt . N.C. Lae ! atlor, Corn. Attorneyo tM". r�. Irf►��ns ' •y . r x N,R,- ,; • � iti �. It ' '" ,,"kqK W w tn." 71 t+1r ' • tl'y l p�.ii� ��j,r �,-14 ;,.i VV ;r 7M'.1 9 r .w)�ti 1 Wr','Rr,l•f.' a &SO -1601 "last. Coo Pli rT 1 r,lr snot lw � �lty p�r'wrlo�rrwht Fete t v- CW phases conversation this dater pertaining to Ideal ►; � co. at lrgatiions M 'still has leash on dp prvcr*rty *t pwhtiogt*n Utoahed is copy of !ether sent to Mr. MrTS0160i►n Of Ideal ,� ' ' ,'* ; ` ►e4164ft 'waft' 06"rtwmt at *an rwnw2iow wale not to 0r.+0x3^tAone •o, therefor*# contMood to ound psymant t Altpa dr► a-WASng Hwy of letter which I sent to aw Leased stto t It Mw 0evelves they did caas+e in nailing notice but Mir. Mrnrlstsis r unwed to wnd LA Faywwnt.t. due Trbhwt Depart nt #igu"d tb%7 cads rep ox ` in tsA sailing not.iraee, then began nailing 00tlt*4 again. I ha" sp**% to out Loose papart ant and they will o9ain cease to pailSottess -WA t'C46oud to Mr. Mervolstein -all hiss transmitted since Ap ftr : bsok9round# lie. Hermletein Mind suite with the CV= because of on.• anneal lotion. A two day hearing was bold in We Angeles and Oft. !house .stain !cart. lie. Mer"elstain then li2ed suit with Call#amia rater Court and last there also. it dmow-ttatiars is nsedod of these actions, I rill gladly provide. Yours truly, X. J. rlson "Vt. l irre� rlaprscnt ca: Mt. we votier, Gen. Xttorn!eyt s.r. ,p,�j+y � �. ,;V , -re's•t. a ,;r , �,'`' �'�.�''i�; � WIT- Saw, �,.�r, "'• 9' y • �71'rP• e'� :r r 1', �T'q, i ,• a �t �• f,l tr � �;��,•„ ��,� �!.�� elae� Y `fib, l�s�" � ,�a�.,:+a, i„ �.;. ,^. Att.60hed por your request is lekt* r sent reiiatered C .i, S�r n ,•ti . , ' to Me+ 142reolstaino I'lease 41scontinuc to m a Ll regusst for pant ;�4AIt X-11364 to tdosl Pal4t , Huntington 40amrch,. fife 404'�� 1*imi -Oihcollsclon ka not batett the California P y�Tn'i 'np r �' *,� ,•' � .!' fo& "th* ,dLiWsn M f ; "i rr I.• •�:/j ,. '�••q ,4M;,P�: !i� it 'ir ►r,;' • ' ., ., Carlson lk nt a±c Mr. S. C. L' autsch; LA • y , butler, Gen . Attorney, SrT. $F T11 i r r wr r r f�. ;R,' xr� '➢ �V1 Fx Jn i t rS � ♦ ! rrT.i ,�+ a �%. ' a Y';� u M 'v 1r�7 Lys 1 � ��i !✓��X� ��d' � n �� °�' �a, tr �Jy� r � •, � 1. s •� ,1Y �•�,� b� x' \� ��,'M i �t�'r r� },h,�' 1 it ! � j 1 `A'�� r ^E r�� + � .e�`. � � � r••�y��, e I 4 �r r wig o ti r, r Ma , t(V•- . �FF 'i.�•', 4. f•`. ,� is r• L M. ow a bill 'for Yew ��r'� mot to , ft'�'�. r+�ta� �+ �• '`� 1�o�r� addMo�* Oragyp► T CrodI pit Ir"SWU006 Co sex *u4m Spa �r 94Y s w , #' 'tre to py►ab1• i Souther m F , " ash f�� ai�ort��i�r, '�✓ �`.�,I11 GCS Atx Ate# Ott Sa 1wMmmdL 1 ►�I�l�ii�wllFllix,'�il�c7�a�'.�:�:�!'S'ra".:'1.' .. __ .. r�.r� —— — .��r..r� OM"W-1 -1.;0 r {{ 1• 7'S ram.'{ + ./4 wed Ir•, a: " •, - . l h 0•,.1, .01 .'�' itJl'�'T�� 1��* Miry ', ' �• � � � � F .. �+ 1 • r do y Nor w+r'rr,,�1. 'r/•��. A „�,.,},;. ,•'' :i. .. ' rM � '�'- ` }' ?fir�' � ). �'•. ' M1, •,� d ■♦ , y1(,T r f rn acMc 0 man Tlenerwle" vmVen 141�ww ,J� p�wrr��4r r�r 14�r�■rr , , 4 -a.W* well der y 9s 1996 R ' OAi 92647 Tran"PorUtion Comom ► pexulte �` Coo r MroaWgUr referxvd to as ft tte r ` " Pon VW latte r' s proporty at Winter • .Castos a �,.. sit C" attreh" aoinGeY ed drawer tor dro►tiix1g, i Irig ;10 !d t aM thmer of the property are herelftf*AW aasew ems Gar Leo sexy t6reed 00vnerN epsratlaa -%I d and ,vo*f UX e • �1�, 1 #,ertexenco or s 7 a apere�+��OW o .. s i 3t�fe. I Too , ►* od att o ► lie" '. ! fb a fil*d o � a m e IsiOudift sat M • A Woesq ;A; 'r t �11t 1l�rt► e to r tee 1 dd > �+a attorney too$ Quad a�n �b ein iwg'r* t �'+��►' Imo,; 4 `' {, ev. "Mot ��►e;. �r►t r ��rpanolbl�l y a� r 14we,. . � P"Wt ` ! to I"" '' lod ,ty, owner rf i �► lr► t +ca� sexpo for far o�C or d+ e to and 'for InJur• • to or dsatha of poreene �Saludlnd� not na l ted to therspot y Mployoee at each pa heretos, when arisift or rtaiati frogs , (a) Abe, ueo of "Id property by ftroI ttee, Its agents p onplop*s or l mlUes, or (b) brooch of the prar►1 slcne at this e"nt by rori qw"V low ,." ice► 'r�M � �r • •', ' , • . r JO � 'Fl,tin';-�..y,•�;,,. r M1 ` . . �• V 0 Randall May 90 1986 w6ther or not caused or contributed to by and act are as�iasion of mar, its employees, • ents, contractors, au Contractors, or fir►. their employees or agents, or any other person. � �.. ftruittee sholl provide satisfacta evidence of insurwwe co er Pemittee's Uabilit carder this ormit in •ma►unU of not less thm $2 eo00.00o Combed dingle Limit for bodily curryy pro rt p►aea e« in addition, �uthern Paeifio Transportation Compso-3 I be nomed as Additianal insured an Polity* The torn "Owner" as used in the above 0aragraph inoludes the successor , assigns and affiliated aompshies of Omer end affillotts thereof, and any company operating upon or over rall- road tracks with Ownerl s Ce rmisslon 200&ted adjacent to the sold Illustrated property end offioers a Mployeea g or agents of • any of the foregoing* In event an facilityan adjacent laerd of owner may be err- ered b Peralttee# Permittee agrees to give advance telephone �- nce to Owner. This permit may not be assigned without owner's written Y,. per�i s siarr. ', Any person, fire or- corporation performing work an kubjOct property as authbrite►d by Pormittee shall be deemod to be Poraritteee agort aw irhallr be subject to the terms hereof. This permit ie► granted Subject to the venders anding th+rt Y Pat6e dips.!cation to being pro4ressed to lease subject promises on a 'MWd-TO-14OM Tonacy oasis only, i s-e. , either party to the least (i: approved) may terninate lease by giveing thirty (30) &rz written notice* If both parties tail to agree on ,dust compensation after So days of the dote of this agreement, then, withLn 120 do s of this agreement RTO will file * oond*wAtion Action to acquilre eforementioned' propertye This permit will become e!leetive as of the date accepted, by Pereeittee rubSoct to rontaV -0 01757* .O per month, payable simthly In advance, plus propert taros o provided the executed original copy has been returned Zo this oftiose if* for any reason whatsoever, tonal Lease Agreement is not executed betwe*a owner Aid► Pernittee l Porn tte wJlJL vacate the p promises on ten ( 10) days notice* If the above is aaceptabl,e, pleas* endarso acceptance by Pernittee in space provided below and return oriSLnel of tkAs letter to the undersized* be To Melba Di strip t 861s8 `` or Vol.AM ° _ S r , q y � �'� S , by l.• . �1'I n•'y. +R 1•.. p: + y�y' �•`�, r, �, ��, i� 4YA +r ��iF'YT'i M�.�♦ "' , ��< :1-' ++,P4r + r_�' !.f � , 'h• "� w,,, �xA� `��E ✓tr 1 1 , f � . G � r �` �L . •S , 4" ,. �. :yeti },r!Y�. ri°J �µ, t ♦..4 , ..ice� � !' r• p �: L *. ..A i! �Y6.�4°: �>,�r.. 4,�,p rlr!�f�''�'l'`',r µJ .'0Y+1ri�,`...�� f wl: 'L�°,F�.��•� �1''d�•�ll':' .� r r„�.�,",, f>p,� ,.1eL2' .1 u ! r.•'��.ur —Lab. CTtglV Ow Aumt !9N M,•Y• �[t16 1•�'1 f'�••tx A �• '• h t r WbMrAwft ad unlaadki of tail cm for a . !1 ism thu yoom i rn Paci#tc Railtode out of lalal6le Street mm ISO r tibiah �Wptw Avg. -A U view of ft r dm ter ow w4M t11 r pilot and to flat + w im cud r, dV b* rani illy�.,,•/' I l,,fY•f'rf.,•�l�� A' ��,.r VI' ` , x. 4' + " I '; • • ' • `ate' ttlaA toed that the tla�9 Comm N %xvwl+ lop tPWIF - fidin that thr propatrd prs4�t wig nit haver a trrwr � t an t t. L , t►t5�0 MUM"" jdlj n�ducr pptetrtiri aan�t'Qlfrralltal ert'►rct�r Ids the pr"' Wdomm"m �rr�drd oatta Of rn1. t wp r moo 1. �ro A. i y►s. � ,p'' "d. �?1 ' �, go-• t /'� '• �i 1A �'ly�••.�•,;'�F, .. �;�.%•'I�' .q• .r.•L^rl; x �.r,,['M'.i .�'� r rn ,,y `' ,�,�. �r o7 "S and iw dootMoal *All Mee 6§6" 18 ,6t we 10+ioties of 410" 4kvor i' M . Mi l Mt $Ml1 lob $I~ IN at as 1olfatio w 01 "Ile taai11t/N# water www"s Mod io nre6MAIM "Its, �. tft "Poo Mob 1M11 be "so ow.-oil spigots amd water famets e �. fill! 1�0>� �ii1. otolMdl rs orwMablot 1�iere $$$doge pig. atlld ► sforNto>r� er oMhllfablot orst000�lai � snail St 4 M Oftittr fullity pow M Iwfe U". •�"' �. lfri� �1`'oM � '� porsNot�, attatMd of �rtoMlrAl. a1w11 be otoMptol'1�Red iw aofl�li'soo~to L. . 014b we State +polio+tltrl rtaoadardo set two tot ooswl is that 1 f o wI FAIS the ie CwL loat"re of the Plowtal, 1M lete`tor oats* 1we:11 of all dowelling units shall Not mood the Coiiforwia I"sulatis" r d� of 4 o9 • tvi*nce of eo pllwo, $hall oe"otit of soslo.ittal of an 4460stleal aona7I S ,.. %, irli►arod wwor tho supervision of a person experienced ire the field of scoottfool o wwtoring. VJ1A 1M atpliosotto n for iwilding porsrlt(e). All oreasures recommended to oMMOto "file to wopublo tf 1 10610 owl be i466voratad Into the doof f" of the pre,)eet. i. it 116%tioo is iowloided' in the parkin) lot andlor rocreatle>t 'area onerpil efficient lN*$ shall be usord (e.9, high pressure sodium vapor. natal halide). All outside lighting shall be directed to poro went E`•: wSolloge"oats adjacant proportirs. { 7. A ditoailed se11s smelysis shall be prepared by a registered soils errgirpeook. Tina analysis shall inludo a"itor fell 60pliks Aft& labaratory testleg of seteriels to provide detailed rrcawisnodations "rdint ! ogroMay. deal an$ fill properties, feowrdatfswse retainiong valise streotse vtliities. 7C N. E544001 86tw* troll on sites shall be retained cold incorporated fate the sito pion if feasible. Any oeslet%q mature troow that suit be v emew doll be rspl aced at a 1:1 ratio with NO boot -trees %&i•' sho11 be locorporatei frote, the pnjoct•s lasriseapo plan. r„e, i. =f 1611-typo iossuietieoa to to be esed„ oa fire retardant type shall he installed as enroved by Rhd Mo>wi14" iopsrtiw*t. � - W Am ooWmeorinl poplopist shall be engaged to submit a report Indicatiwrg the groywd soorfw4 atcilsration fwra ooar% w+r~t for thol subject pMerty. All struetdreot within this dwelepswwt shall ie tfn- otr`+wtod in OSVII&WO with the 9-faCtewi as iwdtcatosd by the V l"Istes report. Calaulatiw for forotlep and Ptnntteral s eAers to withstood aodticipatod g-hetors shell be Mwitted to the Cite for review prior to the Isswnce of 10114160 feralts. _ L 11. fHOP to the Isaowhca prof a grading pewWte a grading platy shall be srboaitted to the City's isporbmt of /wilie Weirs. A plrn for silt control for all vator runoff tram the property dirriS/ ae►.atorgirstioa and do ins initial "oration of two p►ryoot wW be "$rod till the iireetoar of P Al fe WNW it drwirod ■otowssary►• . 1L It. f000lref"tioM on "Wilmot or facil/ttoes Ibioeh M* gonorato air Poilstents shell be 1401tted to 111e , Coast Air Qwulfty Na%" swt Nlstrict haft for their Miew prior to the iMafeo of a Cirtificate'df floceup+ly for my one within the inr IMI*. 11. It aft hassrdws orwterials am to be wood an site. the 1w$ioaess west eossorply with Chopter 17" of .thoo City@* 1%aicipal Codt WNih requires, aq busioo'oosi that handles or sterol hast+ow t rotoria1ae 14000109 vssto. to Imagery the har<aftevs MteMals on site and por+epare a bouiliress ow$rowir plan 1w $ao1o1 of so aoctiddMrel release of teiie oo'orlstorlai+ Aodditiamlty, all hasardw! 14tortalse fraloudforry 'westee slow$! be Iraoadle�d sari stored It aeeor'dafee with the iMifersr Fire CoNo waste oil to Moldered a hasar►+dor$ Mrsta. .��`'••� .gay l i � ? �� i nJ� b rA� •'y ,..�.;� � ;t ��"�'� try J� �. r0.. r ''�.iti 4 +,1 F rMke #.►,�•f rl �1� at ( � �'� a� '�•f �i 7• 1 lv r• k° f rrK,4. 1 74, K W. irt^•�: � r ,'}may'' • � t k ��'�.. Al.7� i ' 1��;,j�\,j.I;�� S % MW tmc t 111�r tfbt� fhd come ct� r4w a 11t. 5 ' VA*C� h 0 t 10 V1. 1 0. Wa r t r' • r 1 ixlr 1 ti ,.r r , 6 rr r,z • .wr f L�•�t �� f v 4 � 4 Mhy, iY' ♦w ; 1' ''I°yy. A t"" G del , ,,��}•e y •y1 r . • '1 'V� 1 A ;ka, V t �,N ��. Vr'ti'f•.�','•�''� l �� .N. (to W COM04 d Sy Loud AWMA IL IIAM&Mir -`. cc r • �� ` gwft t; A -4 ttwfter of prepnnent t 1i�' bib-b S3 .; • ., y r P, , . �l arrr+r+. a J, e tat 1R .• 50 '��tiItfed Jul ; ginr; Requirim Chv*1W city of Vuntin3ton beach S. J.&SAW eI see oftalt if "W"CoMls 6 .24 Co"ditiMAIL Use Permit No. . -2.3 1 `� �. Fr�ri1`��1Mrti1� Irr��f� • (Edokowknt of all ' "' wW "oftybo~ Hers aye rtquired on aftauhad thoWL) (AL 1. farm W;V vhe wipawl rovAt im � { C. t k okftb* awO, kft• or In ,g6w"' ..� -� �. D�1Mt,gtl�rlr�, d�plrasrrM� torrpaali�n � ' of v�rri�rer��„al p+e �dt X 4' d. The dwSww1kM# cOrer.bV w rrrorliftefion of aw urn` W of fe'elyres? x ! ► pf+r► .Arm O1ttom,* — •,ot�� of � nr� "War, x I. s4es ih dse&lfW% ar N'oskn of beach dt erciim 011ie ,MW Ommik the eovoreisl of 4 riv-r ,4r of the ocean ear X gin) beyg We w lokq? Y . s d N/'T- ' 1r• . , 1,'�• + � . � � .. ,, '�°`• , ....'.'A .y aa. ,1 7r 't •�-, a+. ;��,,'�, � l; ;':,. ' 1 Z040% wound to a, r ap VOW ` `` t t�tW � ttNM EtMM AW Is C60otai X sow, 14CWk W. 40r. WIN. ttw preplaso! remAt W ;;,d e' a+'' ► ourrer►ts� ar Ow of d1- � , i'rk ' low " tom tot"$ t04, or the irate &W amvint e! SLOWS . : Aitemallwo to IN courst or Oew of (%W x � flot llii�llvjjft 'tl*''epvmWW1*1 owlete ureter In � anlp water beds? OodkrqR into qw[gCrt .oaten, or in aW 44104 6" of Sur face wgtet eiuooty, Mr+ 4xrgorr er twt�M I�d1l�►'� r "Aw At 'he n �r the /irectian at Cott or fWW 4 IW+Ww rjdttWn M tht► vt owd of ' wafer o"Mm emi le tv opubile wato" *WOW. . �vte of Otwk W O►epiarty I* motet re. btu' W Wdt vo* ea flmdW* or tidal %aves? .'*�Qwr • rf - Y •�+ . p,., ,.,•fir . . n•, r M !, a, M � ar� 111.,' . • YA w , lol#0. W;N Ike ptqmmW revAt Ow C*"* in ft divwsity 0 Wec;w, ,mr of Ow awo of Ants tlmkgbv � J � "Won, ,-��y �',i ,'FYI .y ^' + �\ i i , •r,WY��Y11D *mks,of its Mee 11 wtpww to low we rMn in acreap of dWkWWmI am—ru—bAb .. f t , , � •, the 4wwrsi� of tom, Ow �. two, Z0004 -- low WWK i W ion of It* m'bon of ram► ++n . °" wr d +q+mod ' �t 0+4mbi ..__..� ... ,�. ! ; Nd Ot Ostin of cnkmb Into reswit bwtiw I* Ow IL + to eulstk q fish or w1hPile tff WOW 0040 *Lty :Ewwww PIT TV I . #Irit 1 s rwn. Will we p gmml res►m ins • d6 W #fte in Mr Oast rf w0a of newiml x i0#� NJ •� N �' 1 •r , S i Jo ,. 7 e, ` , ' `1 ►I�t it arr�r n�l+te�+twM IW Ilk Yllt ll,'r/ :r a Ion ' ' s.ww� ,Ssr..�s• w•wsrwws• l f , r4q�grloI ollor the fit lane ,•. tj 4w Ir+ WIh ON Al •00 . . Ai ►n1 ergo? X •'t' 1 t 1�. M�auiE�+► ,�� t1 ' 444paol affect mist" . tar oddlt WW bon"? fi r w r ti+ T � C � ��1� try pro��a�rol wpyt��y��i�ttanr�ol o�diritM� . �': ►., �'1att . + i f .r. !i laoilfrsa, b+!' ''�''A1i$M+�'tliil` o do �? . � � • ' S+�i�t� iw'p+l�t '+e�il1 trran�p�ar� X to 062" oat it rlt ri�r� �rtr�r" . :{'s�. � � 'P• �� + Tylsw6 ii•Y�1ra �/SI` 1*4114tts hs WQIWbWft, Nil W Alt'frof Ile? X ;,`'r:{, r„., . . '. 14. : 1 i WIN "W 0960401 k0V a+ s �M1r ift toor f*w or �iilr+lll'�•�` Nrl ��r1r � '• �''t1r� 1�►1t�r ',aM�t � � AM. f'ir.q prbfllCf iq�� • w. P¢lice owelo fir' t x u 4k4-- • S¢ p h ftw 01". j + R#�+, " § ,.�r � •. r11 f iL1µ� a/� M,� lv 1t r a* �+ f O f/, r:. �� , �' �I�� 11: "��:�(r' �•_� iir PRi �y,�T �S�,',Y .. .`�, j i'i�l ' k fir. 5•!�'irf.Y+' � ,�,.,, � � t�,�,.,, k, ,� y r, ,. rr ;'�` .a '+�;��. ,�. 4 e or e tr r r 1i�1lMe1 1aCilslies? I� +'Yy1 11^'•' }� ' . \ 1��,'• f� d '•� �'' �Y,'.. ..r»»»�f✓a �R21� R4f�11•t1.� V, '•�f;y 3:;' � ... . �« a60141041 ""Mont o �►t �461 or MWOW .R .�.�.. Y'-�>� 'P�`,f61/�',+,. "'•' . � 4:� i4r•u,I 1';Ay.9�. '�,;� �: ", �r1 •,: •;. •. •, 1 :S 1 OX 1#� or topke tht { 1' 1, � • Ni. �i��WM1� ,,; iil 1h� i'Irt rewlt ih o Head +rt V�' # 1 •' ra^tlol eller�*02 f4 • tt�t rate ttti111ie�, 4. per,�� rai so? 000mon...a ..-.+h+..+. •!f. 4. Wa 6 0,'r � +,rfar.rrr �frwwta d. S41%,-at or wii ta*t3 r. Solid dil l'' 1 y, 1"I�rnarr I�rrM� r WiN the Ompowl ,revAl Ira. r , or W1h haprd, -or potential x hrra:lh hug dvckidirq nwo tat Melt W EWMMM�Of Pugh to polw4w , moommm000mmA Will the p0 ! ,000011 1"'.00 `� �ttfl�li� or ayr i� . t� ar haw :ip►� to , ��, � p�tiey: ar tr�N1 t� gaol laivtl irr MW • - e r -A'—, lot treSOMOCIAP Oto*rra site .+ 1lr. Pl wa*&6 Will Oo,vtopeW result lee an �41•.:::x in,1,#,,,r1 ttrr .�r,aMitr or gWM11ty of exittwq • I�ior�ti�er+al e�portr,r�iti�tt'� 14w 1Nii1 00 prRaeol row" in On elterotiar ' �, ear �rtn+c�ion �! • �r�ehisterio � x "larla re AAMISlogI" site? a to !�;- - ' � .... • ��.i!fit, +'xs'' . • r' i 0 • J �;.+. ! Sys . •: W '? n 4d J i 411 11 4 Iwo.;MMIt . f bb o �a1►,,�It1ioM a , ANT h.�� ,AY. l�rro��' '.��1��!° }I ��".��1Y� ��o.�j '�?R) � �• '.�� i � �� a. �� TPhUY Up" Ole f t4ve the polonflot to isoy+ MAW* the Wier of 0 is ;to 4W wilt» its M balew olf Ms. tO1M1 l li�w 14Fr"14 to 411nrJfMl10 10 owak"yi " # lip W rwtsWO Ito to" ## 0 ewe or tad #sd Plant W awmal got ORWAM" ifr a" o n voks of its NOW OWNWIs of C411swrr" glary Or ptrhist"?vfk ,,..� �_...�,., .�.... b� Cows ttw oreleet the 041anflal to O:�iR t.t yaY k�-tom+ er+rir � into hvqW t an the s1ruker"Nont Is 00 ' wiM&rh acRsrrs i� i ptl�tt�raMy �R �i�ira ' Owl" of HAW wWa tie va fa f � ' w 11l erwd►rrwr wai{ Into _.�.,. ....•..� ...,,,,,�,� { ,'� a4 err tirt pro t tw imm b ofikh r ked1wWANY N#vgtt4 bvt M as ` to Jot"? (A {MJvcf mov IMVP If an two r .rrwr�r *Owego taJON+c !! "W W"t �rT 014to 4W e*t e0 0i +ta ka o1 Own x k#vWh an Ito 0*401NOW11 is A411thmoi ri. Dar ft 0044Kt i W"Ifa'wr regal offetts *trite will #w►mi vistwrtiel admrse offwh or fw~ bompo ailhw directly ar WAMFOCHY? 1It. la►i+rw+*r of Cmirarmf !al Evelvatien 1#t. tAlatrfi�ar • (To is can%led by the Lead A tr) • , y 1 ' 1 1 l'j,��•� :1M 1''t4 }rr J4� R�'.yq.4,+��. 'yr* F • '.;l �� . a�7 �I�,.,,�,� N, 7f:S•`F 'y.�q r `rf �iJ�M�� . ..,1.� .i�yMM�A"' �♦ I.S 1' 1 �� * /� Ii �1., f.1 L •11 � S� °.°r,`�^ ••4�;Fi 1 ,M ( d c�IS n!'�r� P�,1 � f r•1 �:'L}Ii fir!�'i'r r+� �. r '!� ,�t��' 1*•gS N;1 ,1� + ' r a��. r + � 1 �j1�'i MJ' r ri �'I`�'M f!�, �rlr `�� yd�y•r`y � `,��I�j•i �Li�a i(. .1 1 rl y�1 j� •rJ . 77 40 Co" NOT h� * 64*11mt effect a ;; • �,' Nf11r �fq "**a gww two 1kgwt stoat AMMOL � k�5 ,ntiti`,q„ •„ ,. For t,t l ``,,�I I� ( Y••:1 ;it M•i °' . .1 � �,,,�y�1�tl I •y.• t t q 0., .�. t • .v ,r.n.r • fed twin. �o f ogre wf � t� !� -dov rat ��rr . k-f �? in their own .1 i I 1 p,I 1 , ��•1 ..to }•F� i Mh'plMi , ' j•, A .�+Jr�� 1•��7 y'•% A• N �,}1�; '�7a'' Q` ' a I ".�` '�„Mr P` 1:_,'•,�� .' „ r,,�, ., � ��r• J 4.1• , r , R r r i•� I 1 ,y ,'�'•'' ; rN' t!k .1`+ v "'' ,.( �iS"'3�;q�,o ,t ;, 7{ ,,, ' ,*" r' ' ' •' ''1 -"'y" I 1—VII JAI • . .r..... a 1fJN OF '"XU'MD 9"YMr �1l'11 .:'tV 'f/BNII� 1'1`A 1 . Cwl* is minimal �. tt salls will be soffi t tad. Ap atClsate 11U aubbs Pr* w111 be IN gmd to Woo ad vwwortad Cato dw alte. •004 at sire dlsmOmof 0& Dk=W of PWIO by � ,':!w►1��a t Cf,�wtrthrr ln*orlaatfON ear faelli�irhlefi a no to a poi Cants will be fired to be to 14 th C=-t AIr Qwlrty Managowmat District. ' M* dS dflPnt IM tit. However, the site Is curmtly u ndevelaped and with the ' t esthtr pavin$ to reum I� m, tw pro2ect.,wIII d1-0 cc rea:e Cite As a tesults the rwte MW Maecwt of rt C will itd waft. present and � grade sly from wort to east 'r , ; r ibv.d Croft. Accumaht�ilra$e will c mdnve to flow north wait Avon and will be aao mmcdated by the City's exdstirg starry bid►►'�t Impacts. "f1W pr!o�p�as pro ct is not located near tntmtial prop", and tiro farts"" vW tor. l+u�bsr wll�c�•eat�e mlidmal nobe. All activities duirt vW . , . *11 bia , sod amply with the City's Crone or re:s. �,61 NMI to W. a.m. to b:"" pent•+ ldanday thmugh SR yw p4mtrw000'v 06t ,allowed an Swidays and Federal ho'lkh". Idu end 'I No rit t►ht hmptNcts. Tba prapc sd p'o�e�t racy negttlte ii, tin$ l�aor a rity; howovor, the18 a .fter res: tfal Property and, therefore. only Industrial properties would be J aff4eted. Oita off clot 116blift directed to prwvent "spillage" will be required. No d t Wrjt Impacts. Proposed pro*t dolts not Include the sto*pe of haaankma materlsls. ap olWAnt decide to stove hazarftw ataterisls, the project Trill beAm re trod to iy with 1738 of the City's Uwdcipal C and thro dalform Fire >dC lad� peat. Alt the site is located 1n an arehsoolopic+ally sen ny ltive a , to r+ttrwtttrws an balm$ buds arOWY miWmrl will take . IU !mot 01MIUM be regWW IC Se US and notify t C q►'s Pami421vleian dmW any swrd irwftift-1 reraaies be flowde A reputable archa tlwn b� inmN itaetod for assessment. jo . k ': ' ' 1 -0•qf T Ail. 1' f-I �` "J A la r 99r .; F I II �1 1 . > r• •� s ,• AA'i, f+l } M 9 I rv1 I b � a „ Y .1 A 'r. � ( '1 + Ih�F �.. ,C F n� + ,�I byµ: I , I• N• s I s: i rs. ,L, T� �, � , , y `•r 1 .1 , y ' IIIy J P Yli q .1., 7rsA %,1 It t Ii{Y•�/9 .[f ,�:. .}•r4 '4 A.I'• l 1:. .,*`.li r I' �(� 11 41 Y . - 'I•I+ `FI {' ie�=s.t '�J.N�`•. I,'Y'1 �. yA'•i , }�a. .. 1 r Yn AV 9007-9632-24) � po 6TT'�w� rtatlon terminals Y. . . �. U. Utility facilities, public ar private, Including but not l i ni tsd to WAstewater, true#arnt plaatso paler generatift plants* and poop st4tior13 01 geer t, q�►verslcNn +s� ► pMlrsuant. to section 963329" . I.+,��sra',(,. r '' ,•��. .�� tpd��•My '�� /r S��rr�oA,°A ` L��—� �r, .�• 1 �� —�1� • wa I DOW Ahont'ri tpr't store! b e Mc~e t,ppyp � Mpro c ntmii s and mul 61 ng publlc or prvt be potted subject „, the 1n1�lai 1, shp11 by for a "'XIMM Of, two (2) YOM. The use shall bet"1 1111 for a maxi wA of three one year extdlltlons by the Planning + • At s it'1 .r"ply ulth parking, access and setback t{ ts Co11ta1ned In Article 9W. (2729-10/84, 9SW9186 �. -: Excawatiop, ofi. 1andf! i 1 s or laird dl sposal 4. • t es $ 9r ' d e reqqu!relents of this articles 1lwete provisions are rat Into leC"l, 1 r4di : end surchs►rpI" Mwrations emitted for Pon' k t w 01 the, On foi* Bu!1d!n CWC Peivi tt r grading an praoualy r level ant , ro ects., s 1 be subject to approyai at i ,;•; the Arbctor. MOM, tTd1-9/a�. 295741 � the foloui,r� words and phr`oltts fro cans trw , tbt 1 ned here h. un l,es s a di t'Zoolot Meaning Is apparent i I> fresh tip cattettt: (a)" Fxr3MYbti bn: :my actl vi,ty and/a iapr►asnt of material rh1 ch 'expooss ostd to the atmosphere. t ast st to. Ahy site' rherw I UA disposal of Groin S, I x or III i ►: woote Z do i d, py 'hhe CAI!gar kce to ��o: . hps p �d . , 111 1 iy otl bw r p, ! land InCM-100 t 1 1 or�dfill I ' C ,Vaxte p�1 os 14M di dins, and 'cOburlal 111th OWN I1041 reef use. (283$3196.9 1 rat),M Waft (a) No person she!1 condufct any excavation actsvitx at an land disposal site 1n the ci•4y of Huntington Beach Without f�l.`st su ittl to the city an operrtions plan qproved by the director. Such plan shall Include Ca0111te i ntorri cn regarding the identity, quantity and characteristics of the Niuterlal `sing excavated, including a che.lcal ltb9 rw � Opp- i 9530 , 14 _....9530 _ 15 issuance of any building permits . A recorded copy oba l l be submitted to the Department of Developtwat Services prinL- to occupancy of any building. Approval for content shall be the responsibility of the Depa r t;rreant of Development Se ry ices and ap�p royal as to form by the City Attorney. Any modifications to the approved covenanto , conditions and rentrictions must be submitted to the city for approval . 9) A person or agency shall be designated an u permanent liaison to the city under the covenants, conditions and restrictions of the mixed use project for the purpose of processing occupancy requests * resolving land use enforcement problems, and any other matters in which the city and property owner are involved. (2710-9f84) i 253241 outsidd 11terage. (a) The following industrial uses shall be subject to the � �peciel s:-reeninq requirements contained in this section: S. Building material storage yards C. Contractors ' storage yards D. arayi.ng , frelgt.Ling or buck yards and terminals L. Lumber yards, including milling and planing T. Transportation/transit equipmeot storage, except fteig4t classification yards. (b) Outside Storage Speciel Requirements : ( 1) The minimum setback for the front yard and extcrfor side yard of an out$ide storage site shall be fifteen ( 1'�) feet, all of which shall be filly landscapsO, pursuant to the Department of Public Works standard '' plans. (2) Outside storage Areas shall be parted or groveled and all circulation areas p:eall be paved. (3) All construction materials for ftences, walla anS gates shall be approved by the Director, 41/87 '`� i 1 .1 1 i �• 9510 . 15--9530 . 16 (4) All outside storage including, but not limited to, truc3a0 equipment , materials , luWMr or other products shall be sereoned from view of public street* by a solid six ` 6) ioch concrete block or masonry Nall a maximum of nine (9) feet high awasured from the tap of the adjacent street curbline. Any openings in the -well shall be equipped with solid gates equal in bright . Scre*ninV from adjacent: properties shall be provided by a slatted fetc*, wall or combination thereof, nine (9) feet high as measured from the r,,, highest ground surfece within twenty (20) feet of the common peoperty line (5) Storage of outside materials shall be limited to the F height of the nine (9) foot screening wail except that lumber may be stacked a maximum of sixteen (16: foot (+night units) high unless the parcel abuts propentr cones'! oar general planned residential, them a fifteen (15) foot landscaped buffer shall be provided adjacent to a thirty (ad) foot aide storage area on which 'f stacking shall be 11mike+d 'to nine (9) feet In height. (6) dereening walls abutting arterial bighways shall be +' architecturally compatible with suvrounding properties, constructed of a minimum six ( 5) inch wide decorative mason.-y block, *ad designed with landacape pockets at thirty -five (35) foot intervals along the exterior side sufficient in size to accommodate st least one (1) 15--gal:on tree. This Inadscaping shall be in addition to that which is required in Bection 9792 . 20 PelrCentOge of hAn4ls!Qao..., ,. ,approval of a use permit by the hoard of Zoning Adjustments shall be required prtior to construction of such walls . Tree specie and irrigation plans shall be subject to the � approval of the Departments of lievelopMent' garvices and Public Works . (2710-9/84 ) 9130 N 3 i tot uAlk2 121Aun�ng- 8 age adfiat Automobile Aismsntlinq, storage end/or impound y IMMaNd rasra�r be permitted subject to the approval of a conditional use petarit by the Planning Commission previded thet the outside storages t"U1etions are complied with as well as the follcming critects: (a) The site &hall not be located within 660 feet of propertr soned or genersl plannod residential. 11/67 w 1 e4` tr , i • f of mum r 1 s 14 Y A ww COPPORMeO" I►TT�"KftY• At %,Aw 7R1.��IIGNC lil�l ��•'1�00 4727 WILSM109 %OULEVMIIIJ T�4LCGQICMI {�lal >i�sl�lQ >tu17i too tA)PS ANOZLIN. CALIFOAKIA 90010 Januory 4, 2980 %.V. Randall N.N. Randall Lumber Co. 27332 Giothayrd Strait Huntington Beach, CA 92647 ate: Ideal. Pallet System, Inc Dear Mr. Ranr"all This firm represents Ideal Pallet System , Inc . and its owner, %*I Mo melatein. plaaso be advised that the Huntington reach Departmotnt of Comp: t'y Development and Huntington Beach Planning Commission have determined that ,ideal Pallet is to be given access to the area behind Ideal Pallet' s property. See sttc .:hed documents from tho XuntSvVton Ha&oh department of l:ommurity Developoent. *lease also be advised that ideal Pallebt end Fames Lumber Co. have Ontared into an Irrevocable access agreement, a► copy of which Is attaoAed hereto. lou are therefore advised to cease and desist from intex!ering with the access of Ideal Pallet to the area behind Ideal ),ft: let's property* pies 'e furl free to call me if ."u wish to discuss thin ��tt�r• , Sincerely, 85MUN, BLANCHARD,* MAUSNhR is K1ND!'M .7Ef!'RB`Y t1. MIAV$1rtSR Al1 t • 1 1 f VI�f 1 1 ly �'�! 11 qy' K + ' , � ., r t �roc .1 i +•,1 1r • k , , .` '_ ' 'fir• YJ{ 10. Ono 1 JAMES LUMBER co. 17311 NICHOLS STREET « P.O. BOX 1184 NUNTINGTON BEACH, CA OMI • (714) 847-8611 It: LRRIVOCABLE AGR EMENT BETwr.911 JM FES ,AND IDEAL Jim Urrington. owner of James Lumbar Company. on the one hand. Jointly referred to as (Jews) and Mel Xnraelstein, president and vane* of Ideal pallet Systems, pine. , on the otter 4ando jointly re:orred to as (Ideal) do hereby agree that James shall grant to ideal, full, complete and unlimited access, for Ideal's trucks and trucks **king deliveries to atd from Ideal's yard, north to Warner, AvRnue and South from Warner Avcnua to Ideal's backyard, through the two existing back gates,, for the purpose of ingress and egress, rbroughout the length of the 100 foot vide by 1,000 fact long parcel of land contained in block 1.0, of block "K", of the tovn of Wintersburg, Assessors 'Map. book 111, page Ol, of rho Counter of Orange, State of Californis, known as the Southern Pacific Public Teats TrAck, Winteraburg, California. See photocopy of map attached. In consideration of the above rights, Ideal agreez to co-operate and assist James with the purposed plans to obtain a Conditional Use Permit, fnoe the city of Huntington beach so that James can receive and unload railcars 4 lumbers and store its lumber on the above described site, uhare Ideal assarta its easement rights. James and Ideal also agree that Jaiess dill allomr all railcars of lurbair, destined for Ideal, to be spotted on its tracks, at the above mentioned described sits, which is leased to him, by the Southern Pacific Transportation Company, and agrees to assist, whenever possible, in the unloading of spotted rail-cars of lumber be- longing to Idea. This agreement was entered into, by both parties, an !Marsh 31, 1986. Agreed to by s .•00 ririegt Mel Norms stein a r any ly Jim Harrington Mee Messes stein y idoa a let Systama,Ine. r,a + w CITY OF HUNTIN Tli" N BEACH +' P.O. BOX 190 0EPARTMENTOF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES CALIFORNIA92648 au►I,aIPIo 0MIU0,4 t»4► KANNING DIV1110N (11 N1 October 12, 1981 Southern Pacific Transportatit)n Company 610 Main Street Loa Angeleal California 90014 Attn: M.T. L. X. Brown, District [tanager, Real Estate i Subjects tiwilroard iti9�ht Of way (2. 71 a6r00){ on the south side of Warner Avenue, � approximately 200 feet vast of Palmdale Street in the City of Huntington Beach, California AP f 111-0 2 3-10 Elul, ?ys*s� of thi .4 i ,ject propet ty Dear Siras . An inspection of the subject property conducted on October 7, 1981, by this department revealed many illegal uses of the property . The ninety-two (921 ) foot wide right of way is fem-ed off for approximately eighty (80) ' feet of its width an4 for approximately seven hundred add seventy-five (7751 ) feet of its length with some nine J9) lateral fence separatersa of va►ryIng lengths# This arei has beftlimee a storage area for trash, debris,, and inoperable care and trucks. There are Also house trailers stored in two of the fenced areas that appear to be lived in. please are all violations of Section 9531 of the Muntingtor Beach Ord i.n a nee Coda. Oses Permitted . in the N1 Atight lndusti�ial District. 3n a4di .,fon,, any user �+ermitted under this section is s>subjact tt .�;rty approval of an admir�sstrr.J.ve re- view by the Board of foain+i'•1;ulJustmencss, which as you kmw is'presmtly considering . an applicatiron{ sul nitted by the Quality Building gupply _Company. .fit to horoby roquelstod that t�`eaI illegal tenants and whatever ma- , teriarl they have st.,S y p ved on bur property, be removed and hg ro-- Votty aieared within thirty (30) days from receipt of this lettoc. . nr' bll73•Y r'< '' i k t , f T'r r fNx •T•�{ '. 'ALL 4 ,r 1 ,.. Y . 4.r ...•: ++` N ♦' art�. r Y +y. r•r �, ,i �,,y 1 1 jl• 1•a 1w1 I' +••, +,.+, • ,�' 'r•z • 1)1-I lam•' r3r•.r l'.'A:�'11 '`lit rfr lkl r>. 1 �1 ..1� �Y". i•..;Cv' •{ tt� 7� i r it1 � r iC Y l("• t r� Thank yoiA for your cooperation in this matter. If you hava any questions# Tease call the undersigned at 536-55I9* Sincerely, e i 1 riR�w Land Use Technician DSt jh {r f� i � { � . ��+. .�, �' �• •fir+ '�,r.` , � ., , � +' .. i, C� � �• 1\Sy~ig�!i •p � ra •.�+�+`yth �'il'r .r �... r�� ., � -• .! � .'a7:EiJ.fi/ 'lt•'�il� iv �.&I vi�:Xi,��r'+.+� r• 1~w„ •.'Y�r ..... r ' t�l�i.M�it,`1iM e�� -..$!1L�✓� t +u �r�b �� VY'il � �•P do ,,��I•fP{e nl I Southom Pacific 1 Land Company 6109*vih Ma n gu*n • Lot.R.Ngv1a. Cdolaana 9Wl4 9 12.31629.6602 � y.rattharM wir't1ttW ROAL+STAB 4Gtobor 20, 1981 2-14 8 2 5-Vintersburg { awK MAKON i��i aril i/+an■nrar+�r.rrr� . Mr. William Langley Ovallty Pvildtng supply. 7502 Sat nay )venue ft tington beach& CA , 92647 r j ! Das` Mir. L nploy �a t `i Bofors to ,your lowso of $jwthern Vacific Transportation Con ;Any � pw_opoxty (Audit Now ISS041) In Mantington Beach *or reoei.pt, rtoraq* �i�etrautioac► �� bt�i.�.ding tia,�r�rarie.' . �. Attar hod is' aE 06py of 14 for iron the City ' of iltantmigton mach vt+ri p. *x1st"oetbottzodgm n �iri.thin tyre leave oroa� ire'�iapt�h '$inaasOe r r Li rid ". . • + . . .to v1w*11y h �atiara "t i kegpeat " the use *f •f wOw1 .I.4RUP• r• ;;ft -,A• D .'. 1— ... • �� `• ��aa"ik� i� ia 5 M' 17 wOt"" a ' -yrcea 'tt* , y E:' 1"A '••#fJ.# r � gFfi �• e1r 'roe iy .'!+ ^,A'• .L'SDI . .1' .,. .. :.t �.. r a., r r,- �,.,•r w fl i► a Co so' *kh the ci.tr, i A*112 be ' ht� K'lo txJA f 41 tZl! ' lop- IX + � ae OIL a Sat please taot ! �` &-sit (211) Egg-�65 79 AU41 w:� '.� are . . .. • ..�•. : �..�• � � 44. . . ►# 1r • .W,�. .. r • . . Wil1 , , ��. I � +•��• .. � . * w i , 1 � r • a '• t, " • y,l t,- �. .:i. .." 4 �'� '�'.•�• +_ ..,dj ,• �% it soft P6c 00 Tram ...1� Ce"wny w"Pwfic lfw rft•Om mwW!teas+Sm Frwo*w,C&Nbrfft 94105 (415)541-lWd t►OCWgW%JNV A.MILLdiw vlkt.I.R M6R YT A`r0 Cif N[71A1 CCiAai!4 •1*IMII.0 A1y JOft^TMAN M.rIL IONW4.r. new Februa ry x 1 , 1.989 MMN"WOCWPO W4 ATrG" YV +-l [7A�Ip i.�AI(VRTT ��FOMV rr'►bIM��1 I�O�SRT'i.rATTRlRwg1V CrIvTFMA R.FIiM'TOM OEM�1 ATOiRVf : w Mlwnt yr ' w. WWWV"Wqam MM �►' drMrpar.,an, ,erM w+r.orw e..Nt N►+..4w,� r Hr. Mal Hermelstein Ideal pallet System, Inc . � 7422 C6dar street Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Dear Xr . Xermelsteine Thank you for your letter of January 9, 1989 , to Xr . Phil � Anschuts, southern Pacific' s Chairman. Mr. Anschutes has referred it to as for a reply. Virsslt, I mould like to emphasize that Southecn Pacific Transportation Company values its erstonars such as Ideal Pallet and intends to masks every reasonable effort to maintain good relations rich thin. We apprw--iate and desire to keep Ideal ps�slleL'■ business . However, the integrity of SPT' s rights-of- May is the -*life blood" of our business . Therefore, It is s ass enti.al that we resist every effort by local governments to ►she oanditi.ons , in excess of their Jurisdiction, that affect 8 's jand- our custonwre' ) long-term use of our rights-of-way.. Constse uantly, SP has no choice, but to oppose the conditions proposed by the Huntington Beach PlanrO ng Comssf sston, since t we conditions directly limit Sg' s futuLe use of its property. sAti.on to the conditions proposed by the Huntington IM doh planoi,nq ^ iseion is not dwrigned to prevent ideal Pallet trm gaining acceso to SP' • team track * Aathere it is for the broader objective of ensuring that Huntington Beach x*vaagqnnises and respects the exclusive jurisdiction of the California PubliC utilities Coessosis«ion to regulate those aspects r of rats operations Involved in the watt6r. t Very truly yours , � s '� uL, �+..fn`;Nat.' r�i.r';"�n� ��riV'hr 'r. '•.'fa��'. .' . iY 17• } 1'Yq' u: .M.'. •Ft tow 1 ju owe C Trans n tmny air taw►ei 8"M.8WW 6W•UN mows, caAam4 IM3.11M *&W M"Oluk Ass rr�t7h I January 20 , 1980 Jeffrey No KKusaer, Xr4- ORMUNs, SLOCHARO 4727 gilihire Blvd. Butte $00 UO dagel,et, CAS 90010 RX: IdlaL Pallet I Door Mir. Mausoarr: This lottor ' It in response to your letter dated January 18 , 19890 is vhlch You totally eischuractAerise our convereatlou. •I never Indicated to you that •*Mr. Mormeletein had planed off overyono from h*re to Jerusalem. " Furthermore, I nevor told you that "Aou►th*rn pacific dots not wa of to deal with ?fir. Vermelstein b*cauear he hss plowed aft sveryoas in this Company• " 8owever, to earrectly t*1terat4% aw statements to you , Routhero Pacific :Transportation Company has no obligation to deal with Mr. MormieloWn with respect to negotiating rights to access to the rallroad tract bebind his premises. I indicated to you durinM our tolophose co,�w v*raation that the public Utilities Comission has ruled that Mr. M4rmelsteib is not entitled to such rights. h8 I «fated to you to our aonveraurtIon v I hereby denwnd that, • you aoasm iaranoiag Southern Pacitle 's tenant, Randall Lumber Compoeay o by tbre►at'eaing to cue him if he Soes not give fir, Marrmelsto n &coos* across our property . It you should have any questions regarding this letter, phrase do so* call; coniloe $,our aDmsuatcations to tare In +writing. ? _. _ 'very truly yours, ' 00 DICK$ = .��I yl . � �,, �+' �..'� y ` • ...,�,11',, \ •\+" •, .,u • • -. .. 1� �w A.Y�a .•1 - .'1 1LSP, ' .,.,• _a • • .W Tv T e ,�•i� ,rM`;+:f`y��!Y�;�{�c� `�'MY, 'I.Inwy•�..w \.. rr.�.��. �\.t..t. 4 p 4.to •'. •�\_A �,•\ i1.i.►�j: .,,.I � ' � 1� f � `}/ yak i � �•y/7f,�# .7 " '� (A AM� 1�:y 'I.11 �,�1�, �::'. . fiyy •ii 7, .'if �/I'lfEasl�I'�w, � :.'fi 7Z�ril�..••wa i(P lkl.�.:�',. ..�ffi" 'w... .�'L v�r•b'i,..'� � ,. i ....r1�.ru�.Y.rW LLt A ,.r+7._�l• • ..'�.. tooTf , ;"rI�U1�R a f�d l � L U�z. • . cc: James Lumber Ideal Pallet l Septemtxsr 151 1980 Mr, Robert F :*nklin , Associate planner cue art, mie nt aft" Coax mun i ty Development j f0 0 da in Street H,jntiNton Beach, CA 92647 Tamar Mr . Fraiklin: I app:oci ated very much the opicrtunity of meat irrj with you and other men s of then Cam�..uni t. Devolo went Department ester- a t h'e !� r Y p � Y day and hope`ullV reeolving questions regarding the trick soutn of Warnst z;nd esat of Gothard which is being used by James LumL*r and will be used by Ra rdal l Lunbe r. E I *m, for y,)ur convenience, enclosing port Mons of the Gctotwr 16 , 1987 decision of the Pupli,c Utilities COMMlsaion of , the State of California. The portions include r.he Findings of Fact , Conclusions of Law, rtnd Commievion Order regarding this com- plaint which WAG filed by Ideal pallet Systems, Inc . against Southarrn Pacific Transportation Comanyr. J As we noted , the Comatission denied the complaint And re- 1 affirmed a cirriev 's right to detbrmins what customers can come + onto its rig,'it of way for loading and unloading purposes . As stated in LM decision, the track in question was discontinued as a public team track. On occasion , Ideal Pallet ham issed this former team track even though it is leased to other shippers. In order to a vr) �d future difficulties # we pare reissuing instructions advising All of our per. sonnol that the team trick does not exist and that shipmerts biVed to the area need to be For the account of aicher .Tames Lumber on their portion of the leased track or Randall Luabor on the remairder of the track which they lease . The t*r&m tracks in the arsa which are available to Ideal Pallet are t rie Smeltxer Team Track noto h of Edinger Avenun ,, and west of Heae t Boulevard In Huntington Faeach, the Westminster ream Ttr4ck locate ) mouth of Wes tNaf ns Gee Boulevard & d west of Hoover r in Noste+iAbLur, and the $oath Sent* Ana Team Track which is loca- ted on Main rout h of Warner i n South Santa Ana. ideal Pallet can, of oouml, •too use the services of •ny other receiver in the area who nivht be willing to unl o&d traffic for them. � r nr +:fl l ;'i*:�eo+ C� 1►+► .�i.:erio' .. �i (�•►",h ...,.••' : f Ilh'hl� hNT.!tir' A•6i 14 OAINd : 'FTC�F 1�F •'.} A 76631 o*Ltd +t Junr '%J S"ATE OF CALIFORNIA 0rc a 1951uvrtt o! I t�'e oun1� ittre�lS�lQ i�* vei 'r,e dge of G.gNeen •r a��. arld r'.',I �4. party to it-teresled in the be::)w , * , ► : "r-0 Tatar arr, a �;,►��a� r.;�+r► :)l the Orange ♦ Ej a Cc;ast dAl'-• �tLr' *111l whiCn .s trtie MEWS-PRESS a ne%Spap3r of general Circulation. ' print4i And published m the City of Cosla WeSe. AH" County of Orange. State ut CeNtornia, ano tnat t1 A :'• c:'�_'IE'CS "ureic, t!, a frut� Ana com hete anc tr, rrio ►.�esa, tiwµ�. ?:.Fa►.'1. II;,I.i •�niOt' Beach. Fciuntalr `vaocy .f- ti%nkjl' ;ommuntt+ei: and Lagw is In E.e4.r, ., jE.: sar; newspaper trtr 1 t' i.:n cc,'1,*BcX-ve %►E?k5 tV wit the issuwa) of i oacltlm, under penalty of perjury, that the I forogaing ie true and Correct. Exiecuted on �t:'ruar>',_� 4 81 t.OM Mean. Ch.A0r*,0P. f w PROOF OF PUDL10.`*A1';0r4 "� 1 k Iwomb Nl- Publish '124/89 BLIC HEARItiG DhUU01ft USE 1?1F 91-KQ.�. y r T1K DECLAR8 M N -ice NOTICE IS HERFBY CIVE`I that the Hun`in1tun Beach City Council will hold a { public hearing in the Counc, l Cham�er at the MuptioTton Beach Civic Center , 2000 Main Street, Huntington peach. California, on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. LAIE; Monday, March 6 , 1989 TM. 7 :00 PM Wes: Appeals to Planning Commission approval of Conditional Use Permit No. 88-,13/Negative Declaration No. 88--24 , j Randall Lumber Co. APPELLANT: APEEL n : Councilman Jim Silva LOCATION: Southern Pacific Railroad rinht-of-way on the west side of railroad tracks at the eastern terminus of Cedar Avenue (approximately 600 feet east of tha;.4ntersection of Goth?.rd Street and Cedar Avenue) . PROEML: Conditional Use Permit Nc-. 88--23 is a request to establish temporary loading , unloading and storage of lumber products for a maximum of five (8) years on leased property. Randall Lumber Co. and Councilman Jift, Silva have appealed the Planning Comrnission` s approval of Conditional Use Permit No. 58-23. Specifically, they have appealed Condition No, 39 which requires an irrevocable offer to dedicate access to abutting industrial users which depend on the lease area for access to the railroad, ,EVINMENTAL STATUS: Negative Declaration No. 88-24 will be heard concurrently with Conditional Use Permit No. 88-23. CCRSI&L JI&TU Not Applicable ALL: A copy of the proposed request is on file with the Departme,.', of Community Development, 200C Main Street, Huntington Beach , CA 92648 ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or s+ inl t evidence for or against the application as outlined above. All applications, exhibits, and descriptions of this proposal are on file with the ' . Oftite of the City Clerk$ 2000 Main Streit, Huntington Beach, California, for iftloontion by the public. HUNTINGTON BFACH CITY COUNCIL By: Connie Brockway City Clerk Phone. (714) WI-5404 Datod 2/22/89 y. T,I i v 1 leaCITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 200 AAAi": STREET CALIFORNIA 92848 OFFICE of THE CITY CLERK March 0, 1989 Randall Lumber Company 17332 Gothard Street Huntington Beach , CA 92647 The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach on March 6, 1980 1wtud ycir appeal relative to the planning Commission ' s approval of CUP 68-23, nd MD 88-24. Please call the Community Developmen�'- Department if you have any questions. �(Al w Connie Brockway City Clerk cc : Roy C. Dickson , Esquire Cox Dickson, Eto and Worley 417 S. Hi 11 Stre, t , #E650 Las Angeles, CA 90013-1121 Mel Mermelstp4n 7422 Cedar TO ee"' Hunti rigton Bach, CA - 92547 • tTM��:�1i71 ti�1LL � s s 1 doqWO .' +. II�, 5 5 • 1 • 't�,u a. �l 'w CITY Op NUNTANGTON WWACH INTER-DEPARTMENT COMMUNICATION r To Art Folger From CONNIE 8RCX;KWAY J Deputy City Attorney CITY CLE:ZK Subject Date Refund of Appeal Fee to 3/08/89 South pacific Transportation Co. 1 * As SPTC was not advertised as one of the appellants in the recent public hearing CUP 88-23, is there any reason why their appe-.1 fee should not be refunded? I/. it R fry ��r�•r 1 t i r r, rAlfl 1 ,0010, I., r yIi all 4 lly . VO ON �! C` _ `111A �r j,_g ��L1 ,Jed NOTICE Dr_j=jQ-z&NLUIg loTICB 16 BEREFT GT.VIVA that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber at thu Huntington B®arh Civic Center , 2000 Main Street, Huntington peach, Califrrnia , on the date and at the time indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who Irish to be heard relativo to the application described below. Monday, March 6 . 1989 s 7 : 00 -ON I� saw=: Appear to Planning Commission approval of Conditional Uza Permit No. 88-23/Negative Declaration No. 88-24 FLtmm+ Randall Lumber Co . Councilman Jim Silva Southern Pacific Railroad right-of-way on the Wiest side of railro&S tracks at the eastern terminus of Ceder Avenue (approximately 600 feet east of the intersection of Gothard Street and Cellar Avonue) . Conditional Use Permit No. 88-23 is a request to establish temporary loading, unloading and storage of lumber products for a maximum of five ( 8) years � on leased property. Itandel l Lumber Co . and Councilman Jim Si lv 3 have oppealed the Planning Commission 's approval Of Conditional Use Permit: No. SR-23 . Specif'icallpr taey have appealed Condition no . 3g which requires an irrov:)cable offer to dedicate access S to abutting industrial users wizich depend on the lease area for access to the rail lroa ` . : Negative Declaration No . 88-24 will be heard concurrently witn Conditional Use Permit NO . 88--23. A copy of the proposed request is inn file With the '. Department of CamWnity Ueveloprent, 2000 Main .' Street, Huntington Beach, CA 92648 i i R 4 u (�.9"ld •3) -r� 1 t WA ' �l ALL 7:5;'B OTED PF':ROBS 4rS invited to attend said hearing W axpress opinlcna or submit evidence for or against the applicatioix as outlined above , hll applications, ezhibitc, and descriptions of tuis propoaad are on file with the Office of the City Clerk* 2000 Kaju Street, muntington Beach, California , for inspection by the public. HUNT �TOIR BEACH CITY COUNCIL I By: c onnih Brockway City Clark, Arhone (714) 53C-5404 D�tat! k; CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH ` . CITY COUNCIL COMMiUNICATION • • • • Tp CWNIE BROCKWAY, CITY CLERK and PROM JXPI S rLVA HONORABLE MAYOR AND f'IT`l COUNCIL MP.��3r,q Councilman WSJ4QT ,APPEAL OP C.UP �3-2.3 and Negative DATE becerber 13, 1988 Declaration 88-21 I hereby appeal tha Planning Commission ruling as to Randall d4W Lun ber on December 6, ],9 8 8 . ,i ,� I feel the restrictions that: the Planning Commission placed upon Mr . Randa►ll r s prop,-ty pertaining to the access de+tication will be, detrimental. to his 3 =11.,er operation and request it be placed before tho Ci �y Council.. JS:bb xc: Paul C00Y. City P.dainistrator s •� A$Wk rjr,/Vf Ism, M • •%1 1 t ClMw of Ow City Clark rYwM+w+w gryW+w►.•. • � � �.. �r1 /'��1 Q� y ��> ,��'`��.'1�• �� '»�•r.1'y'1 City of Huntington Beach �,/�f ,, •, PA.roc:90 !: FORNIA 4?�i8 r` •` I '� I F M R S A `� ,�,�_•.�f ..:' it ��,t:� ; :'� , I 11 bo- 08 D t ` RDI , JOHN bRA LEE ST . ,J 13CH . CA . 92649 I ,1,lfill it Office of the City Clark �, T • City of Hunt-irgton Beach M.O.Box 1111 CAL{Fart�'itA'�2d48 �� •.'� � � �, '� 61A 11 - 3-07 ' Y D RDI Jc1NN j a NDRA LEE ST . NG.,ON 13 .H . , CAA 92649 �I i y , jM' r CITY OF HUNTINOTON INUACH •� INTE R-DEPARTMFNT CC"q,MUNICA"1`ION r�avt�c:rw craw Connie Broc:h ay, Mike Adam To City Cleric Front UirecLor Community Development Subject NOTIFICATION Lisr oN RANDALL 011te May 9, 19F.9 LUISER CO. APPEAI✓CUP NO. $3-_23 In re"nse to your memo dateci .Apri! 27, 1989, I have conferred with Deputy City Attorney Art Falger on May 9, 1 r:19. Art has stated that notification for the appeal is in "substantial compliances" with the City's notification procediret. Hopefully, this will '�e sufficient Information for you to complete this file. MA: (2657d4) J0 y , Ilk w 10 KI ' INTER-OEPARIMENT COMMUNICATION To Mike Adams, Director of Co,-.muni ty From Cnnnie Brock-way, City Clerk vevelopment S'J'40el NOTIFICATION LlS i' GN PANDALI. Cate April 27 , 1989 LUM8ER CO. APPEAL - CIIP 88-23 (Your memo 4/11/89 Thank yuu for your response to my mem). As I stated before the AP process between our departments has really improved in the past few months since you have provided the Title Company information, which in this case . was not done. However this Title Company affidavit and cover letter assures that the labels were accurate at the time of submission of application 4 months ago. That is why they contain extra parcels, omit parcels that were once there, and list a property owner who is different from the 6/88 rolls in your office which are the current rolls. I notice the Title Company affidavit and cover letter are undated which adds to the confusion, It is because of the type of hearing it was that it was important to determine why there were so many discrepancies on the Title Company list then on the current rolls. I do not believe your department has obtained the current maps from the County to use In checking against the 6/88 rolls either. At any rate if the Deputy CityAttorney determines that notification was proper because of "substantial compliance" as he has done before it may be reasonable, but riot that it was proper based on the current 6/88 rol Is being used. 1 ea s kno 1 If- 02 Doug vC- � ' ame lso I was able eforr the earin the notify one owner on the 6/88 rolls that wasnrt on tha T tle Co. list, as it was returned in time to located .him.on .the corrf-"ct 6/88, rolls in-your department. cc: Art Folger Paul Cook , City Attorney RECEIVED APR 2 7 198g CBi bas DEPARTMc t-i v: ,T r?'YS ",� i i' 44 CITY OF HUNTINGTON I&SACH INTER-DEPARTMENT COMMUNICATION �N 41� To Connie Brockway pram ike Adams, Director City Clerk Community Development Subject NOTIFICATION LIST' Ohl RAND►".LL. bats April ) 1, 1989 LUMBER CO. APPEAL -- CUP 88-23 Attached are the affidavit and cover letter from grange Coast Title Co. which assures that the public notification labels are accurate based or, the Current assessor tax rolls for the itendall Lumber Co. lease site . The pro{ect was advertised for public hearing before the Planning Commission in October and November of 1988 and none of the legal advertisements were returned "Insufficient address" therefore, staff did not perceive the need to recheck the public notification labels. During the Pianning Commission public hearings an abutting business owner and representitives from the Southern Pacific Railroad spoke and staff updated the notification list by adding their names to the list. i The notification list for Randall Lumber Co. reflects accurate property owners for the .Tune 1998 ownership rolls except for thtr nne. owner identified for A? 111-023-15. The June ]V)l ownership rolls do not reflect the recent sales of the parcel; that DeLeonardi has apparently recently sold. The Deputy City Attorney has determined that no±if Ica tion was proper and notification of the new property owners is not necessary. ATTACHMENTS: 1. AffidAvit and cover letter from Orange Coast 'Title Co. s� 3 2. Memo dated March 29, 1989. cc,: City Attorney City Administrator n .It Thank you for ,your posse to iTV memo. As I stated before the AP process between our departments has r,ad ly improved in the past few hly ,�s c � you have provided the Title is.� ol Corny infornp,94ono which in this case However this Title CoWany affidavit and cover letter assures that the labels were accurate at the time. of) submission application 9 months ago. That is why they contain extra parcel a "er er who is different from the 6/88 rolls in your office which are the current ' roi1a+ I notice the Title Company affidavit and cover letter are undated width adds to the con _ It is because of the�type�di~ hearing it was that it was important to determine why there were so any ,4Qr1 the Title Company list than on the current rolls. At Any We if the Depty CityAttorney determines that notification was proper because ," Untiil CoWlianeo" as the has done before it may be reasonableo but not that it i bd on the current 6/88 rolls bei used Also I was �blo� har4rop, to notify oae owner on the III that warn t an the (21660) ). t t was retu locatad him on the CITV OF HUNTIM43TON MACH ( WTER-DEPARTMENT COMMUNICATION To Connie Brockway From, &i1ke Adams, Director City Clerk Community Development Subject NOTIFICATION UST ON RANDALL pate A,)ril 11, 1989 LUMBER CO. APPEAL •. CLIP Attached are the affidavit and cover letter from Orange Coast Title Ca. which assures h public notification labels are accurate based on the current assessor tax rolls for than the pub not oe the Randall Lumber Co. lease site . The projec* was advertised for pr:blic hearing before the Planning Commission in October and November of 1988 and none of the legal advertisements were returned "insufficient address" therefore, staff did riot perceive the seed to recheck the public notification labels. During the Planning Commission public hearings an abutting business owner and reprei-entItIves from the Southern Pacific Railroad spoke and staff updated the notification list by adding their names to the list. The notification list for Randall Lumber Co, reflects accurate property Owners for the June 1989 ownership rolls a.cept for the one owner identified for AP 111-023-1 S. The June 1989 ownership rolls do not reflect the recent sales of the parcels that DeLeclrlardi has apparently recently sold. The Deputy Pity Attorney has determined that notifications was proper and notification of the new property owners is not necessary. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Affidavit and cover letter from Orange Coast 'Title Co. 2. Memo dated March 29, 1989. cc: City Attorney City Administrator MA:1b (236 ,S qP' w i6. ORANGE CC,7AST TITLE GC7M!"'AIVY ORANGE COAST TITLE COMPANY furnisher. ,you the fore~goinq information for your sole use and benefit, subject strictly to the understanding that this information has been obtained from THE CURRENT'". ASSEPSORS TAX ROLLS. On this basis , ORANGE GOAT TITLE verifies the information far- rix�3had and assumes no Liability in excess of the fue chart ed for this report. j Dated: Cust . Service Representative; FIi ' 40 N. TUM AVWJi it VE 1 ft SA►NTA AP A+ CMJFORM A 927C* 714/6WZEES Jn' 1 y a r. W, ��rr�r err "r 1 .y f 1,• ORANr;t_ COAST TITLE ""0, 1PANY TO : THE PLANNING COMMISSSION MY Or: HUM'INCTON DEACIT i LErAL DESC: AP# 1_11-023-I0 (subjec • ears ;oX OWNERSHIP . A list OBE the owners lands . located within a 300 iOOt Ladius o> .,e ubject ro ert together t s , p p 9 with a map showing siad land, is attached hereto. � AVI" $UITE 1�, $ANTA AN/�, Cr4L: R�t1A02706 , . Y'. M CITY CW HUNTINOUM WKUWH Cie INTER -DEPARTMENT COMMUNICATION M fN�1L1rV�1pr MACH �� i V Ig�� • afNA�r To Mike Adams From CoyinLe Brockway Community Development. Director City Clerk 'r SuNact Notification List on Randall pate Mcarch V ) 1989 Lumber Company Appeal - Hearing � held 3/6/89 The pror;,:duce for provision by the Planning Department to the Clerk of property owner notification lists has improved greatly since Art Fo1Rer helped with his advice . However on the Randall Lumber Comp,iny public hearing appeal the title company AP ' s were not used and notification was mailed to six ( 6 ) AP Numbers which are not Listed in the Assessor' s Parcel. Book in the Planning Department ( June 88 ) `hose addressed to DeLeonardi were all. returned "insufficient address" . Lxcept for this discrepancy and AP 111-023-15 (yellow highli.ted ) the list checked out with the 6 /88 rolls . This may havL- been caused because the application was submitted to Planning so long ago that t:h.., AP list submitted by the applicant was from the 1987- 38 rolls . Your department' s microfilm records on the missing AP ll :L-023-05 through AP 111-023-12 indicate `sec new parcel" #111-023-20 and #111--023-21 . AP# 111--023-20 is listed: Charles Lombardo , 9378 Shrike , FV 92708 . There are noc listings for AP ' s #111-023-21 . Also no AP# 11.1-023-13 . Please inform ine as to the discrepancies in the mailing list your department: provided to this office . Also , if you and the? Attorney ' s office believe it appropriate to notify Mr. Lombardo and possibly others of Council action and Planning Commission action as they were probably unaware of the Planning hearing as the same list must have beer. used. Prior to the hearigg�,,,,,this office requested that the list be �,hecked as it wasfiFbvided by a title company and we were informed it was . updated. I have made two informal requests to your office regarding the discrepancy and have not received a reply . So, I have copied what 1 could find . This may be important as the hearing subject matter seemed to involve the surrounding property owners . CC: City Attorney City Administrator E gar ,1 f1�W-70 15 � r 111 - 36U- 1l RODALI. 8 . WILL IAM WI _, L IAMS , G , C . HOHNSTEIN PHIL I 2 ,RUE DU P'ARC 7412 CEDAR ST . F . O . BOX 1026 NEWPORT BEACH , CA . 92660 HUNTIN — �, ,,,�..,=..o t' HUNTINGTON BC'H . 92646 s — 033 j1i:040va4v & H1 7 111 -010- 71 111 -0 2 - � ,, '' s`K It a y Dickson TEXACO INC . C/O TAX DEPT . MEL MERMELSTEIN 417 soutli Ntll 'Street . PU . BOX 54419 TERM ANNEX P . O . BOX 2300 sultu 650 LOS ANGELAS , CA . 90054 HUNTINGTON BCH • CA , . 92647 LOs Angeles , CA 9001 :1 111 - 023 - 03 111 - 023- 17 Mike KDIOdZiej Southern Pact icy Tranalior. Ca HOUNG , VONG LOUNG CUCAMUNGA INDUSTRIAL 610 Main Strr,at 866? RROOK,STnE DR . *FRCME INVESTMENTS Angeles, CA 90014 HUNTINGTON BCH . , CA , 92 646 2900 ••A BR I STOL ST • #2.01 COSTA MESA , CA . 92626 111 - 023- 04 111 - 024 - 07 Larry Enneman Natiorwide I'la,teriog Co. HOLING , CHONG LOUNG GYLDSTRANU , LEIF E . 17172 Palmdale Street, #-41 8662 BROOKSIDE DR , 17121 PALMDALE ST . Huntington Be,ich, ("A 9261i7 HUNTINGTON BCH . , CA . 92646 HUNTINGTON BCH . , CA . 92647 La 111 - 623-05 3-�10 , 111 - 024 - 08 HANSEN , JORGEN 0 . SLATER , RUTH 6 . TR . 554 STEWAkT CANYON RU. 171f? GOTHARD 5T , FALL BROOK , CA . 92()?R '� HUNTINGTON OCH . , CA . 92647 4 1f1-02-3- 06 111 -04 -09 HANSEN , JORGEN D . SLATER , RUTH D . 1R . 654 STEWART CANYON RD . 17162 GOTHARD ST . "fALLBROOK , CA . 92028 HUNTINGTON BCH , . CA , 92647 111 - 023 - 07 111 - 024 - 10 S!ATER RUTH B . TR . ODE LEONAROi , JOHN 17162 GOTHARD ST �17021 SANDRA LEE ST . HUNTINGTON 8CH , . CA . 92647 UNTINGTON 9CH . , CA . 92649 s 411 - 023-06 v 111 •' 024 - 11 �E LEONARDIs JOHN SLATER , RUTH B . TR . 17021 SA14DRA LEE ST . 17162 GOTHARD ST . U!1lW,TON BCH . , CA . 3,?F49 HIINTING i0N DCH • , CA . 92647 411 -023- 12 ✓ ✓ 111 - 340-49 DE LEONARD19 JOHN JAMES LUMBER CO 17021 SANDRA LEE ST . 17311 NICHOLAS ST . HUNTINGTON BCH. oCA . 92649 HUNTXNgTON 8CH • , CA . 92647 1��13 * Aat� 13 111-360-06 116LEONARDit JOHN JAMES LUMBER CO21 SANDRA LEE- ST. P . O. BOX 1188 0.#MTI'NaTON SCH . .CA. 92649 HUNTINGTON BCH . , CA . 92647 r ' 1�`�.ji..•.'�1'�,, ',''—.i..�tr11lM�•'��"'�.yy"�-�,.-...•�.�r��•�yn�•�,r�lf/�`.Z.ep-f'f"`i",C+Mi�1.'A'ti+�!'try„ YT'7•'lEv'1C�lli�fP.;'6'CEYr1N' :°`.*!•�FP`�'-- r 1r Public '-)24;' J`'P �IS . .A2.?R41L L 4E NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chambffr at the Huntington beach Civic Center , 2000 Main Street, Huntington Bea,:h, California , on the date and at the time idicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the application described below. Monday, March 6 , 1099 JIBE: 7 :00 PM �! Appeals to Planning Commission approval of Conditional Use Permit No. 68"-23/Negative Declaration No. 88-24 AP. PLIC'AK & Randall Lumber Co. APPELLAN : APPELLANT: Councilman Jim Silva J=JQN: Southern Pacific Railroad right-of-way on the west side of railroad tracks at the eastern terminus of Cedar Avenue (approximately 600 feet east of the intersection of Gothard Street and Cedar Avp,iue) . P,RON5AL,: Conditional Use Permit No. 88 -23 is a request to establish i temporary loading , unloading and storage of lumber products for a maximum of five (5) years on leased property. Randall Lumber Co. and Councilman Jim Silva hay. appealed the Flanning Commission ' s approval of Condit{ onal Use Permit No. 88-23 . Specifically, they have appealed Condition No. 3g which requires .an irrevocable offer to dedicate access to abutting industrial users which depend on the lease area for access to the railroad. ENVIRO iA LIMB: Negative Declaration No . 68-24 will be heard concurrently with Conditional Use Permit No. 88-2.3 . WTAL SIATUS, Not Applicable 9 FILE: A copy of the proposed request is on file with the Department of Community Development , 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach , CA 92648 ALL INTERESTED PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing and express opinions or submit evidence for or against the application as outlined above. All " applications , exhibits , and descriptions of this proposal are on file with the Office of the City Clerk, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach , California , for inspection by the public . HiIYTINGTON BELCH CITY COUNCIL. By: Connie Brockway City Clark k'P Phone- 014) 536-5404 ',, Wed 2/22/80 y , Mom. `�Jj A ALL -14; m y IMMI ALu7WOl'14r) �1f�A i yr +• • 10, lA —w—A -11 MU • A,M� 11� � L/1 f � A ALI. I� N w AMA v Iwor ! 911"-1/C 2— 9 !Ir► 1eAt�L/IM � i 1 ai� AT AR • KA► A A AY a* owl wl.r was-�rr�u .hr _--- __—,� 11 OW memo" $1 s?J; r 11-022-101 Insp AT 11OWWOR A Au -tot m OF n%q kur ,� •M�i�? flit 1M � � �'e0�,?�`''"1�J'iC'� Ili w1C•lAw► 1 `ad C -W mm no AU.[Y- �-i IMt Ow AMr so l.f FI i A*k 'AJI()'j _iO4% . _w_..'.wow..-..i..r.�_�- --r �...�...-�iyr..r r..��_..•_.�r__ ._.__ .r.-_ �._.._.. -... ...._._. .. r_r-..._.._-_.-.. -.. ..«• .�-_....,.. __ - r�WV a�► re PARCEL LIST 0 ' ' WUNTYORA _. _ ...�. _-•-__--__- ass i taM��a -._ .sic= y �eQl� ,EL -- �rp,,r; - i i�:� �-�y - .�. A rIMK'i A r l.ottt r' OCWiM�tT-A1 fOAK � MiA'� MIOOKAI M 9 17 7—023'"`/�'(� 11i YAK-,rlMw 1 �tl i� �K� 1 YWE 9014'eff C -lot m it NJ0 A A W. y d1NM E9 YAWL - 111-03-20 111-023-06 Aw mw mm CIIIY A "1MeEL 711-02-T-0 p�woMeo crL - 1 1 ts-x� 111-025-08 uv Am mmrt, tr cw r Mom - tlt-ors-171 111-025-+ 12 mrwwmmpie * • gar ` 111—d .T-16 AUUQ6 S-d, ' • AFL -0 V M It- �.� � FT or mcw%%ITN HCC�IRNfiIPA / —0� `�` ,/ 1 It fwio cm Was" cam �� 9 111+D . �-1$ 1 1 1 Fftm&l of MIN wit Ill*-025.49lm �M •ter �!�3mmou c Aw nut mu $ MIL $ � AI" 1 u �r M N7131 Nomm It #A "• 1 0, a + 111�U2in?i ' vim%�� r� f� � Mw.� w.W�i r�.w��w.w•.rw ...new M� i PARCEL LIST ORAMLr offJPUNTY 1 CITY OF HUNTI#dGlDM BREACH PITEF1'DFPARTMENT COMMUNICATION � N;JNTlydrfON 1lAG71 To Art Fol got` F.oln CONN I E BROCKWAY Deputy L'Aty Attorney CITY CLERK Sub-act Cate Refund of Apr.ai Fee to 3/03/89 South Pacitic Try nsportatian Co. i As SP"'C was not advertised as cne of the appellants in the recent public hearinq on C0 88--23 , is there any reason why their appeal fee shoild not be refunded? x ji �'{ggh•.ti mum 1 1 Il, Y�%�"'+'W•it; r 7� t i�' • r From the D *OE ARTHUR J. FOLGER bbwrty City Attatrwy jp 7�K &143 �. 1 ! _ � I 1' �}rY i' • �.jo 1• , 1 n Ljtnv Pod Ih ;'%oVk t A;:N•f s'..N, pt �airep W rrt 5-uL!rtlidl rGr.• 1Y (!'e '�!1 � ..�'.!ti +.:*• rgirll'F►Aia N,rrrP!• A-6., 14 Oftietl ' ; 'ernl7e 19F 5 RIG j -L7F C)G CA_IF:)4N11- a •--��---- •--* QNICE�rI HRAE/Y n . . I l MAR CenNerl Alm". Nuns• • _f' t t: it 11 C. d 'T,S i CG v^1 Of �+itaa Gr ltllr an toy 0wis and f`�t: '� tir dt�;r�51r11t:1 a'f wbr "it aye Of t~Ir�r1iLR�I �� .= et:it t0 tel IrR r + • `w • e �J�t+ r' � mart IG c'' i~!e-ested in the towio* ltwMd. P dto �N•"um boom: ' . f' ,',' c,r' -• �- jrT a , f '1�1�.9E r" !lf 1h* -/�r7noe 1 #fl G rkllf %'hiCh it �:oCT'i:,�i 1{j; 1'1e I % tR: to �I�WS-��►ESS a newsvaaef of general cixuiaittor• t�k al" 1��°"primecd Mr,,C puso,►sl;neC in (he Gfty of Costs R"eS? Ipant�io. �r2��-24• DOM. �.�uh,'r �,. ,r`i! �'• Crbte of Caoi�rnia anO t^ri1 d tr4ANY A 'AP- ' Cd F ',�?r+ELLAN*::Ctrurirllm!AI t�CATwW'.Soull,,v n Ps-I .. �,'rledlr rN�ht-b!•wRy; thA.vAel a1kJR Qf relfraad lticXO At the beeternl �farri+l*1 of Coder Avenuipl r r ' (I .pra�ckf►*I"ON to-t eARf - "' .� ....�'' . t: f. �.��. o 1 sit+rsoctlon hr c _' .1.1!i1;�.I" In• d 611 et uod radar A SAL: 14ridliknuM ► e I' `( Na, fS4-�3 I■ e r'.' two Mow 34AIW- tot of lWber productw G• ,': 't. v►'t I` ! c:6� G' ! jk almum of Mw (s; I1111 .N Pro�Y bIM C;�. aAd An strva NAvo the Plan Com- i 'e ,vpproval at Con- dttlonel U,%e Fdrmlt No. povIlcolly :hey hRw i Rnpebled lv()ndiflpn Nv.4 wlWch requirm an l,•- y= j r olhr to dvdk+to I r(PO dopfto on ,he for owwo to the ffiv7a� aN l�tENTAL 3 4 iNN bo tread _ to rbn i wltb Con- us t' TAL STATUS: Not .. • A % of the an mni D Be+Y =I, o., rraG:-are, kinder penalty of C:er jury. Mat tine ( fa ding (s true and correct.' r, 1 L 1 _..�..� r in + REOUE FOR CITY COUNCI ACTION D"I � F®bruary afto"4r1 Honorable Mayor and City Council Paul E. Cook, City Administrator Mike Ada►mn, Director of Community development Od z 111'PXAT►.j / �TO P�1 T� SS IOX'S APPROVAL OF t9 MUt CORDo VW ' NC. 88--24 00 0"06lsct:+r o C"Wl Ftmky7 [ 'fe [ i Now Policy or 5xQ*tion ` Ott of lsre, RtconrnnandatIon, Anolysia, Funding Uiros, Attemative Action, Attaahnkents: � 53KJAWAk Transtaitted for your consideration is an appeal by Randall Lumber Co . and Councilman Lim Silva to Condition No . 3g . which requires reciprocal access as pant of thu fi;,anning Commission ' s approval. of Conditional Use permit No . 88-23 and Negative Declaration No . 98-24 . Conditional Use Permit No. 8G-23 in a request by Randall Lumber Co . to utV ize a 1 . 25 acre site which is owned by the Southern pacific Railroad to unload, load and store lumber products for a period of five (5) years pursuant to Section 96311 'T=pQxarry Stora�aa Yards , of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code . The planning Commiaaion and staff recoramand that the City Council deny the appeal and retain; Condition No . 3q which requires Randall Lualber Co. to provide reciprocal access to abutting industrial users . 21amkia Q 9.fl Ctian_ and a.zompe'1ridation on 1paremher,_jfi. all : A NOTION MS MADH BY SLATES, SUCOND BY LE I PZ YG, TO APPROVE CDNDITrONAL UER PERMIT 90. 88- 23 XxD NZGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 88-24 , WITH IrINDIN05 AND WNDITIONS OF APPROVAL, BY THE f`OLL".)WTHU VO E: AYZB: Slaters, Williams . Livengood, Leipzig, Ortega, Higgins , Bourquignon NOSS: None ASEW t Mane A&S'!`AM: None r ("0 Atts Chzftnt No. S for Findings and Conditions of Approval) . rt w3 44 i, , F. �I V t Aan4a l7l Lumber Co. 17332 Gotherd Street XUatington Beach, CA 92647 t Councilman Jim Silva k t X1 (General Industrial) M: Conerail Industrial Common railroad loading and unloading area 1.25 acres On December 1988, the PlAnning Commission approved Conditional Use Permit Mo . 88-23 and Negative Declat:at!on No . 88-24 which permitted Randall Lumber Co . to use a 1 . 25 acre common area to load, unload and stoke lumber products. condition No . 39 . requires that Randall Lumber Co. provide reciprocal access to abutting industrial users its order to prov'.de accoas to the railroad and reduce the Impact of increen6d heavy -truck traffic on surface streets . Tho tvo major abutting industrial usern, James Lumber Co. and Ideal Pullet Co . , currently have a reciprocal access agreement between theta no as to allow for loading and unloading rail cars . Staff has maintained that the exclusiv& use of the existing "common" loading and unloading area will eliminate rail access and increase heavy truck traffic on local streets and arterials by Randall Lumber Co. Due to potential increased traffic impacts in an area not designed for frequent heavy truck trai fic , and lack of full-street improvements near the intersection of Gothakd Street and Warner Avenge .Zross from Oceanview High School , staff does not support deleting Condition No . 39. from Conditional Use Permit No . 88-23 . Randall Lumber Co . has sited in the appeal 'letter dated January 6, 1989 , that providing reciprocal access will be a disadvantage to their operation and would be disruptive and have an adverse affect on the temparary use. also, the e.pplicant states that providing reciprocal acteas wauld Cratate a security problem. This is the b821e tat Coun011m en fiat Ri lva 'n appeal. Councilman Si iva t s appeal '. . statta that the Planning Coaimissiongs restriction pertaining to the dedla ti*e at Momes will be detrimental to the lumber operation. tocurity for the lease area can be provided by a gate system whereby during working hours, the gates will be c los,ed taut not locked . If lumber it s to be unloadeed, the gate can be opened and them closed aft*V unloading has finished. At night, the gates can be looked and .t 00 04,100 on the following business day. Z/sal/gg -2� (2812d) ; �s1Y:l:u: .:,, . . ..Jar ..,.::.isa'Iyn.:,,.• ., _., _- 1 1 �• • 7 ftwff tools that the condition of dedicating reciprocal access is not unreasonable. Two existing major industrial users. James Lumber Co. and Ideal pallet, entered into a mutual reciprocal access 69 ro moiat botmeon their properties on March 31, 1986 . both bUsinouSes are still in operation and apparently the reciprocal seems is bcseficial to both their operational management and atalt`s intent to minimize heavy truck traffic on local, street$ and arte�rial+� i in addition to the appeal letters from Randall Lum.11)er Co. and Courwilwan Jim Pi,1va, the attorney for the Southern Pacific railroad j has submitted a document which supports the railroad• n poetition in tho spatter, The City Attorney has reviewed this document and it ii likeludsd in this report . nogativ►e Declaration no . 88--24 was approved on December 8, 1988 . No further environmental action is necessary. • Not Applicable. The City council may: a. Apgrove the appeal and delete Condition No . 3g . from Conditional Use permit No. 86--23 . b. Overturn the planning Commission approvel and deny Conditional Use permit No . 88-23 . nit-rr�►t*snn 1. vicinity asap 2. Site Man 3. Appeal letters from Randall Lumber Co. dated received January 6, 1989 4. Appeal mom f rom Councilman Jim Silva $6 iteciprocal access agreement between Ideal Pallet Co. and James Lumber Co. dated March 311 1986 so Letters fne edam 1 Pallet Co. Letter from Nationwide Plastering Co. dated November 29, 1988 d. pisdings and Conditions of Approval, p. Xl tee trom December 6. 1988 Plmnning Comaaission meeting ill. Planning Comission staff report dated Decefter +6, 1989 1t. Southern Pacific Railroad Document -` Mh:ItL1*:gbdt ' ... .. .. ... :R' ., ..,•a ' .. _i r.i.... .1'•.. i .,r.9r 'ii. rl tZ.it'at .,.c �`i lif�1Slet'�4a�.�aWIIN �.�1 po, 7 a WARNER AVE . R� CAIN AVEell r u awc {'Ir' sh �p CEDAR AVE. r DEAL, F I PALLET CO. JAMES LUMBER CO. ► NORTH JAMES LUMBER CO. RANDALL LUMBER CO; Y`4 dc 421 � •�`,� �^ 1 1.• Y, , ,IM y hWONa vv r , Sf � � � f ('Iw�► ,Mi�r��Llw'4rr'1�i'' .�:�1' � � � I 1 ru Qtt 7, 1, it th • � I � � " A I x it •� �I!i� ' � . . � CG 30AM� ALLILY P.11 rnI a. VA6WA9 �erv�r+1 as r r' r ` i ''. 1. ^• l P, Ik Yi 6 4's) R T N iB, •��a y ti iw( •Jp' yq, . �.1'. '` ,�,'�(yl'., �,i,. \•, Me:r'..�•.. ..� t.� _, Llf...1,. _,�i�,...Aer✓4'vw •�..wer r';dr.Ni�'di'9e'w.%h'.'.V�. .� a ' 0 r' Y . I mob I yy \ RECEIVED JaRm-f 50 1989 r A r 0=19 BROCIWA'Y, CITY CLERK AND 0011DWLE MAYOR AND CITY � 200 FAIN STREET cz clw HMI N N REACH, CALIF. 92648 SUBJECT: CHANGE IN OUR LETTER OF APPEALO WRITTEIN 12/16/88, RX: CUP 88-23 AND P.".GATIVE DECLARATION 88-24. WE WISH TO REl OVE OUR COMMENT MENTIONED IN THE ABOVE LETTER OF APPEAL CONCERNING ACCESS TO AND � FROM CEDAR AVE AND Y4 NDALE STREET, ITEM 7 PACE 4 OF STAFF REPORT DATED 11/1/88, AS THIS 75 THE ONLY PORTION THAT WE WISH TO 1 WITHDRAW THE BALANCE OF OUR LETTER WILL REMAIN j I AR WRITTEN. I '.A StNCnBLY Youn f SILT, Wput U04L LUMBHR CO I NC. ti' T' 8 IF *JW"7 ...�.,,.+�r.• t7'�4a ENR 6R8� r�t� " •"�,� " tie 19,. ,.� �r�+�-mot`-� .. G�'!�•+�w.+� —f t+.� •.• Y�� ,�,p�,`'•� �, CM t5 110=4%3. CITY CLERIC AND l MMALE N001 AND CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS 2000 MIX STUET RUlfx7M "Otw BEACH, CA 92648 803J=i APPM OF CUP 88-23 AND NEGATIVE DECLARATION 88-24 . x ' W9 IiE1 ZY APPEAL THE PLANNIN+IG XON KISIONS RULING REGARDINC OUR APPLICATION FOR CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO 88-2', NEf;ATYVE DSCLARATION NO 88--24, APPROVED AT LUE DECEKBER 6 , 1988 MEETING. WE ARE OPPOSING THE FOLLOWING: ITEM3-G, ITEM7 AM ITEM9, AS WRITTEN: IN REFERENCE TO CON!-DITIO➢ti U93 ITEM G, FAGF. 4, RUDALL LUMBER IS NOT IN AGREEMENT TO DEDICATE ACCESS FOR FUTURE INDUSTRIAL USES ABUTTiNC TO THE LEASE AREA. BY HAVING OTHER BUSYNESS ESTABLISHMENTS ATTEMPTING To USE FART OF THIS AREA AND RAIL FDOTAGIE WOULD PROVE TO BE A DIS"VANTAGE , TO OUR OPERATION, BRINGING ABOUT DISRUPTION AND AN ADVERSE EFFECT. IT IS NOr IN NCEEPING WITH IVR PURPOSE INTENDED, UNLOADING AND MOVING OUR MATERIAL. IN ADDITION, FOR SECURITY REASONS , THIS WOULD PROVE 10 BS A DISADVAIRPAGE POR US. IN REFERMCE TO CONDITION NO 7 LI*MITINC ACCESS TO VERGENCY USE ONLY, ItANiDALL LUMBER REQUESTS IS TO 12 CHANGED TO INCLUDE V'EHXCLBS OP RANDALL LUMBER COMPANY WT INC ON VoRD R AVE, NOT ALL OF OUR VEHICLES WOULD USE THIS pill : ACCRSS AND WOULD RE USED ON A LIMZT'ED TOTERMITIAttT BASIS. ITEK 0 SAD INCLMDNI ix"ING OF TUCKS . BIMC�.�P A4 w ; : #,.v. AM MONK CO r . 7 �� n; q r WA 4 v, ,V CITY OF H UNTINGTON CITY COUNCIL COMMUNICATION • • . x. . r j CONNIE 8R0C.XWAY , CITY CLERK and FROM JTF4 .STL" # OWORABLL MAYOR AND CITY COTINCIL MEMBERS Coutici.lman CUSACT APPEAL OF CUP 89-2 3 and Negative DATE December i1 , 1989 Declaration 88-21 I hereby 4ppeal the Planning Commission ruling as to Rondall Lumber on December 6 , 1988 . I fee) the restrictions that the plane ng Commission placed upon Mr. Randall ' s property pertaining to the access dedication will be detrimental. to his lumber operation aria request it be placed before the City Council . ,TS : b}; xr. : Paul (_-001, City Administrator y � I aaP bA ELM Am ES �sr£•,• r t r p.t 4 iI r LUMBIRR COS 17311 NICHOLS STNEET 9 P.O. BOX iW HUNTINATON SUCH, GA M? * (714)3474611 { ��i BLB A lUK SMMU JAMLtS AND IDEAL r� I■ �..rI��A— F -VLASton. oar of James Lumbar Company, on the one hand, jointly referred tas as (James) aalgsd Mal [Kentelvtein, president and ovtaer of Ideal Pallet Systems, 206is on tbo other head* jointly referred to as (Ideal) do heraby agree that James 9WU Smt to 14eal, full$, co"laete and ualla tad accateep for Ideal's trucks and make sakial deliverlae• to and tram Ideal's yard, north to Warner Avenue and South #tom W trier Avenue to Ideal's back,yardA through the two existing back ^Itess for the purpose of ingress and egress , throughout the length of �he 3.00 foot wide by 1,%000 foot long parcel of land contained io block 10p of block "K"t of the town of ilintorsburg, Asaeessore •ikp• book 111. Page t12, of the County of Orange, State: of California, lmovu as the Southern Pacific Public Team Track, Wintersburg, Califoralar. Bee Photo-copy of %ap attached, Its consideration of the above rights, Ideal agrees to co-operate and assist Janos with t14 purposed planes to obtain a Conditional U,ae Permit, f roan the cit;p of Huntington Saaeb so trait James can receive and unload rail-catraaa of lumber and store its luanber an the above deacribed site, where Ideal axsexts its easement Frights. ,lames and Ideal also agree that Jaa*s vill allow all rail-cara3 of lutwer, destined for tdiol, to be rpotted on its tracks, At the above mentfonod described site, vUch is leased to bias by the Southa rn. Pacific Transportation Company, and agrees to assist, Whanaver possible, in the unlosdtng of spotted railcars of lumber be- longlas to Ideal. Ws spo%roamt vas entered into, by both parties, an March 31, 1986. IIE red to bye ', o4irftO0t Me MermatlstRin k r Ns Webs pang► by Jim Harrington Hal Hormelstein by Ideal Pa let Systatas,Tne. 'R'tli, s IDEAL PALLET SYSTEM, INC. Mim- i •«, r 7422 CEDAR STREET AWW of HUNTINGTON aEACH, CALIFORNIA 92641 PHONE (213) 5926659 or (714) 847.9657 W. Mike Adams - Planner Huntington leach Planning Commission Sept. 1 , 1538 W. Ro rt 'Frankl inw Associate Planner DeparUwnt of Comunity Development This is to respectfully request the Huntington Beach Planning Commission that the Conditional Use Permit number 68-•23/Negativ€ Declaration numer 88-24, requested by the applicant, Randall Lumber Comparuy , not be granted on the groutids that It will displace the Ideal Pallet Company completely and totally and cause it to cease existing as a vlabie lumber and pallet operation . Since 1972, Ideal Pallet. Company has been dependent on having access to the Southern Pacific, Public Teary Track, at Wintersberg, }or the sole purpose of receiving and unloading its dir-gly needed raw material ( lumber ) , for its existence. ( See photo-copy of letter wh��re it specifically stipulates " The only access will be through Ideal Pallet' s adjoining property. " ) Lumber is Ideal PelletIc' main stay and without it becomes non-operable and ultimately non-existent. Ideal Pallet has been in continual operation since '1965 and has always paid its taxes and bills in a timely manner. See photo-copy of Lumbermans latest credit report enclosed. ) Approximately fifty percent of its lumber .;ost gotas towards freight and the major receipient from that freight is and always has been tt,e Southern Pacific Railroad Company, whose representatives are in concert with Randall Lumber Company to dislocate Ideal Pallet Company, its owner and its 12 employees, whose sole livelihood has been derived for all those years on a steady and secure basis. By Wocking Ideal 's access to the Southern Pacific Wintersberg Public Team Trek and by Randall storing lumber along side the narrow path adjccent to the Ideal Pallet's boundry, it will place Ideal Pallet inti an additional 'Fire hazard. Our trucks and numerous Southern Pac "ic Piggy-pack `,fans that owter our twain gate at Palmdale will not be able to egress unless access to and through the Southern Pacific right-away is left open as it always has been; A BRIEF HISTORY OF WHO WAS HERE FIRST: As you may be aware, Ideal Pallet was the first lumber and pallet manufac♦uririg Wmpany to locate its facility in Huntington Beach, along the Southern pacific Public Team "Track as early as 1971 -72. After goiuig through Ary,. ' 110 74 ••/ ` , apt the difficult legal process of eminent domain and relocation proceedings , with the County of Los Angeles and the Southern Pacific Railroad Company , Y Ideal Pallet finally located its manufacturing facilities to a com. prable location along the Southern Pacific Rail Line in Hunt.ingtun Beach. Having access to the Southern Pacific Wintersberg Public Team Track was the main reason Ideal Pallet located its facility from Los Angeles County to Orange County, in the City of Huntington Beach. It complied with every ordinance code,. ( See copies of letters 3114172 -.nd 4/6172, ) f and Ideal Pallet is hereby respectfully requesting that all parties along thO same strip and ►n the came type of operation be equally bound by the City of Hunting Beach ordinance code section and comply fully with the Huntington Beach Planning Department and the City Ordinance Sections. µ; James Lumber Company located its -facilities across from Ideal Pallet M during 1975-76, while Randall Lumber located its facilities next to Ideal Pallet not until •1978. Both James Lumber and Randall Lumber , with the cooperation of the Southern Pacific Railroad, constructed a spur track , which leads into their immediate facilities . Both James ind Randall do not have to depend on the existing team track , while Ideal Pallet System, con-A nuousl y , to this day, relies solely and almost exclusively on the Southern Pacific' designated team, track number 4892, for its raw material ( lumber ) to be shipped in , as well as their piggy-back system. As indicated before, fifty percent of Ideal ' s cost for the raw material goes towards freigh'ti and to be excluded from access to that freight would be tantamount to Ideal ' s demise. The City of Huntington Bench and many of its merchants and citizens would be denied accessibility ±o wooden pallets locally if Ideal were to cease to exist. Outside truck traffic would increase considerably as a result and by additior.ai heavy truck traffic to Huntington Beach, from the Southern Pacific's piggy-back traffic. What is also crucial fw, the Commission to consider is that if Ideal is " put out of business " by the action of the granting of this Conditional Use Permit to Randall , it will to the death of a 0 year old reputable L company and a loss of jobs to its employees whose employment at Ideal has been the source of income and their livelihood Reswcl= I subaUted Mel Mermistein - President MEAL, PALLET SYSTEM, I NC. �i 7 ` + %I 1 Novi. .ill„ R,'k',' / IDEAL PALLF. 7422 C90AR STREET f HUNT'INGTON BEACH, CALOui 141A 92647 ;4 fH ENE(213) 692-6556 or(714)647.985Y obw ISO -�' 3anuary 16, 1989 fr+n: Ideal Pallet System, Inc. - Mel Yigrmelstein, president and Mel Memmelstein and Janc Memelstein, Owners of a f parcel of land which directly at;uts to the Southern Pacific Wintprsburg 's Public Team Traci,, easement and railroad right-away. To: Connie Brockway - City Clerk Wes 8arrci star - Honor able Mayor Foew Cook - City Administrator Huntington Beach City Council Members Subject; Appeal of Conch ti on i1 Use Permit 88-23 and Negative declaratior 88-24. Please accept and include this photo-copy of the original 1 et �:er to Roy C, Dickson, Assistant General Attorney , Southern 0aG,f i L raps portetion Company, dated January 9, 1989, and all enclosures a Ideal pallet System, Inc 's resportse to the appeal of Conditional Use Permit 88-23 and Negative Declaration 88-24. I also respectfully request the Council to include and consider the fallowing points and authorities raised by Ideal Pallet agai;:st Roy Co Dickson's appeal to the Huntington beach City Council , which hL filed on behalf of the Southern pacific Transportation Company and Rindal`1 Lumber Company, tcj strike condition number 3.g. , which was reco�ended by the Huntington gerich Staff and voted unanimously by <: the Manning Commission. on Liecember 6, 19889 to be pert cf the total package for Conditional Use Permit Number 88-23 and dagati ve Declaration 88-24. 1 . no City of Huntia9ton Beach has full jurisdiction in all Hunters sw,h as City Ordinance number 9631 . Item 9631 of the City Or finance expressly inclodes " ACCESS " requirent to this appiicent 4ndlor owner to fully comply with the ordinance as a r•, wdition ft . a Use Permit. •; . W. Dickson insists that the City of Huntington Reach has no jurisdiction to impose sucli �ondi t:i ons and yet fir. Dickson a; , ai*,41 144., 4 i 1 ^ ', 1'4 h .y /yam • �. ., 1 ' ' . rr +'A'',.,r,, +'r+�"5' ,,,,.•_ .41'•f.�,` 7r*h!►'¢6y�1.Y .y1,11f1t�'1'h'J�+, .qy ,;•'T• j;1°.4: tigSlyf'T. rc . � AL PALLET SYSTEM., INCO HUNTINCIT M 81WK CALIFORNIA 02447 PHONE(91S) 609-65M or(?14)6474087 � r. 1 1 , Continued fails to note that the Public Utilities Commission, in their opinion, Ideal vs Southern Pacific, dated October 16, 1087, on page 17, expretsed the following: " Paving of leased portion of the right of way by Weal was a requirement y' imposed " by the City of Huntington Beach." The same wAy in relation to " ACCESS," the City of Huntington Beach is within its jurisdiction to "Impose" access, as well as paving on a portion of a Southern k, Pacific Wintersburg's Public Team Track, easee,vnt acid right of way as it imposed on ideal Pallet previously. 2. The storage of IwAer that blocks off the artery has great impact on traffic, especially when it occurs to an Witting property owner who, as a result of the blockage, is forced to revert to heavy truck use versus the rail line available to all other rail Customers in the area. Ideal Pallet is a customer in good standing and with the railroads knowledge and permission has entered into an Irrevocable Access Agreement with his neighbor across the railroad tracks, to Vo area in question. See photo-copy of "1 Irrevocable Agreewnt between des and ideal ." � w�� ,,�0os r c�a r,lointerferaef,nngedb ri Woouu icreazeify ` Just one wre Cause of Action in a court of Law. Does Nr. Dickson deny the existence of such access agreement between James and Ideal? That question arises here because W. Dickson, in his appeal to the Huntington Beach City Council , makes no mention of this mutual and legal agreement between two neighbors, across the railroad tracks, Moth customers in good standing with his employer. the Southern pacific Transportation Company, to give access and cooperation to each otimr, in a business like manner and to the benefit of all concerned, including the City of Huntington Beach and Its City Council ,, whose duty it is to protect the interest of the city and its ci ti ter►j, 1 .yJ,,, 1MJFllwti"�'G�iY�tIWIYYu1i..uN.1`.wl1r•,. __ .._..._. _____.. .�..__—,.. ._ _.� — :..1 d r r+I rI S r r '9. ', ,! F i r r„°I hR ju K n '� t •1 �. I ' yKL�i- !` �'�i, r " '� ' gyp ' +,. i��,f '}i I � Y•r1E► �'i � , (`� - t� rl!, Yr" ,!'` �4,'7�,•M lyIr , � ,' '..' A `f''1j ' ` • 'r;•e '• � illry'a ,t r.. ' 'V'x r y 1 '/� r�n1r QS •! . S II !�tr+r1 .1 rM ,y},1` {r Y J1r lylr ' . ' , *r} I n .l, 1 1� yt 1. nrr '1 1 , •.r 1 �k I ' j„t� ,. r r, P .p JYyr,` .�r'a' • ' ., . ', '� '� ,r�+may ' b y A�� , Doti I IDEAL SYSTEM, INC. LN J,Y HUNTINGTON IS M,CALIFMNIA @2647 PHONE(9131 $024 58 Gr(714)9474067 ry� y N y A 5 2. Continued Y� Furthermore, in the Public Utilities " opinion " dated Octclw 16, 1 7, on Page 15, wherein the' , Y quote the foll owing: ise, .blic -utilityservice or iacilititsSt ' red ��, non 41s ringfnatory � namer and Ike reo Serve customers ti Ca re _ MUM area." ;r and it goes on further to quote from section 453, on page 14, of the P. U. C. 's Opinion: No 11 utilit shall establi h main in a n- FACILIT or IN ANY CTO WIN" jOr or as and finally: " Aon©n, who has exhausted all administrative remedies with- i comrr� su i on ma ns u e a i n u ie rn can reasonable at orne Is ess in cases of an reasons and others, Ideal Pallet system, Inc. , Nil Nerwilstein, president, respectfully requests tt.;: Council to aftld the deci b ion of the Planning Commissions unanimous vote regarding Condi ti ona 1 , Use Permit nuaftr 88-23 and Negative Declaration 88-24, in its entirety. r' y j Y i rim (SS,,.�r,,��,y„#,, ,•}.,�� r rY '��'I ,,�{}j�p�i' y A'� �' '�'� r� Mf ti P ,f1� + �'•tiF.�+ r?S n + �r� �1�lTAY, 'N'r',wl,ti �r' "T•.r „IL i��y •1. .i R, , �f ' w+ �,��. � �i �r'�,�'�h�. �;•�,�ti�l � r i � ' r ♦,, Nil r � �1,r 4W 17 411 ru��s � .iJ� yQ,�'��i� r'♦ r Y + , r .+. .,. �� r i�:9�4 �H'i..''��'� r Y`' r:' � i �� 'i, `�r )�i,e��'t��,L � 4 .,} r♦, ,� � +♦ r, �'1 �' �`W+� 1.� �'�1 ,Ire ,�JM ♦. ., �!; yyy`�T��yrv��Y��LLl[ rN u' n •Y' ' r. � r, �ra � . e, rT�.. r , 4 IDEAL PALLEar SYSTEM, INC. 7424 CEDAR STREET HUNTINOYON BEACK CALIFORNIA 92447 PHONE to 1 a1642-ed68 or(114)641-M? Ideal Pellet System, Inc. , Mel Merrmelstetn, president, wishes to thank the Huntington Beach Staff, its Planning Commission, The Mayor, The City Attorney, and The City Council for its �. `a's .'.' tireless efforts and dedication to help bring about justice and equ4lity to its citizens and to The City of Huntington Beach. x reeei n; 4 ; Yours trul , S'r' Mel Mermel stet n - President IDEAL PALLET SYSTEM, INC. 71 I . co: Mr. Jeffery Mausner - Attorney at Lary - c/o Baran, Blanchard, Mausner 8 Kindem Gail Hutton - City Attorney's " 'Ifice - City of Huntington Beach Mike Strange - Senior Planner - City of Huntington Beach Robert Franklin - Associate Planner - Dept. Community development City of Huntington Beach Art Fol gdr, Esq. City Attorney's Office - City of Huntington Beach ' Mire Adams secretary, Planning Commission City of Huntington Beach ;r Jim Herrington - President - James Lumber Company, Inc. Philip Anschutz - Chairman of the Board - Rio Grande Western Railroad i '1 r� y ri, r, .,w }�`,4, 6 * ", NMI •r.7VI y �7'<'✓ r�, � � - r14' '�'' � Y!' t �r � .t r� � ^ii .lr... � ��1•� gl r� IY'rhj ry� ,,+C-, vi Y Ve M.1 titi . 41 M r 11II��17� ME$ ,.-s ,,,'• LUM' BKR CON • M BOX lies u�. . �vlr�'1K�1�w �tw, �A�� 1�)�T�e11 • DOT Jft A► astoss ower of James Lumber .Coapaayw on the out bands jointly referred it* 40 Psew) slid reel Ierwlsteins president and emery of Ideal pallet Systswo loco$ do tb* otbar bands jointly referred to as (Ideal) Ito beroby agree that James omit Pont to 14e419 full. Complete, oad unlimited access, for 1444114 tyruck$ and trucks as" dolirerlei to and prom ldsal's pads taortb to Warner Avenue and South Rose Warr Aver to Usal's bselyards through the two existiml back Satess for the prrpoio O ire*• and *peso* throughout the Iw,rlttr af-the 100 fact wide by 1*000 .toot JLMS partal of land contained in block 106 of block "X"« of the town r;. tt Widtsroburl. Asoosso :. *p,book Ill. Palo 02. of the County of, 0rango. $tata of C416forsi # town as the Southern Pacific Public Teats Track, Vinttrsburli California. Us Pbato'!-copy of WAP attatbode in etmeldorstlon of the reborn trIghtas Ideal agrees to co-oporats and assist Jame F. with the purposed plraw to obtain a Couditi.oaal Use Permit.- from the city of ■antimpon Seacb so that Janos can receive and oinload rail-Cass of lumber and stare its luabor on the abovo deacrib*d site, shore Ideal •*aoirta Its easement: Jsrrs and Ideal also agree that Jaws will allow all, tai]-ears of 2umbers dtatiaed for Ids4t to be spotted on its trac'kos at 'tho, above mentioned de'sc ribed site, tr1 Ith to Uas*d to blue by the Southern .tacific Transportation Company, and agrees to Assist,• r,0wwer possible, la the unloading of spotted rail-tare of iwabetr be- Fy; 10"14•t* Idea. This *groemaut *ns onte red into, by both pj�rtiess on Marib 31. 11166. Ag rosd to tram r tM1er i otein A.L -4 A, A—A 2WWkV AS Vorrington W2. Merre stoma by Ideal Pallet Sy*teeurtlas. w _ y 4'b ,17, ,,v' - • � a ,� -�.-��]�'r"�S y'd%� T 'r - �;' p, ��r ,,1• r Y� '(' + -rp�+�f '��.i"�1r!..' ��..n' �:� ��r ♦y � 4' w�t�u�tra• �� I, 't, +1��r � � �� ' � •';r 1. r, � i F fik'!/ F �1,'�� 1f� � ,r •f �� i IN 14i t ., ;�! �h4,-�y{¢", v�•,.' i•j�� '2r,r' �'1 :�' a[IAJ".y•' '1„/9d"�f'y4'i �,,, i•M �' 'T•`r4% '•7��,' � .� �• ',�'�i �'� M "VIP v ok • .� �, �.. ` M * ', .• .•�•- •• way •a.•• ' i is ape- 1 i •; � � • .••a•�•ems• • w ara. • _ r ■ � i i • w ' � + • �'.+LIIIrIWY Ir.. � Y �• • � � • w �� +■raw••. � 1 'tG ' • ri w • • wirr 4WD a .� '' • db •w• •r qm&b..W .�•. ., .+. •_. �« --pum6wm • f _ N d Z;•err f na r IY' , ♦�h p ;• S �vWN ,s. r r �.,i11Lw, y� 11 ,' r 'Ik 1, '!,1 r. t •�, i! yu 7 u µ 1 i�.• aw � qY� " 7 h e �r� . g+ i r r.f r i•'1 f r ' p� + � °t 4'b :YT f t'',h, `^' ' r r ( •xr+�yy}��1..,�., r .., r1.,, T+ ,*,.,, rl°•r•, �' K f¢��pE • �,M i 1 " h ' • }� yd rI +rj r t ti ✓ ,r M r I ' :.} ,.l�,rl/r '� r+�, a1 •S" �• ��,, 'W ✓ y,,,"� 1 INr'��',1 �' � 1• , `, rx`" � r.y I 1 Y ti+• JrY PM A.. �� r,rr �1.i lr, v + � �' ,lid' � ,'v (y :�" i I'', +A W'� � k L �yI r, � r� �v•� Y�'y�py�� IN •°t �r R, V \ � rl+ Irk "1 i � r A „ k �(�' •'y { .,A , 1° , 1 r � � �I r.,�t , r .!�� 7 ,r !", rr , K„r I � ♦ ,�, ri��L i � 'y I 1i '/fir•"•.' 'f r • • . •, . • ,-. � 1 i , r r.. IA Poeme dam pony yr_4., �rr'i'll, Cm"m . .. .- w ' �� M rb►M hilLf9 *area 90 Systeal Inc, �►�J'6-x�� rl�� 1 t�entr�al ��eger steer Inc. tl !"abs 6911fOrnia 92647 Pow ',► leofete3a: .. e r� l e discusSiox oz d,r,st+ IUDSea spur track ti• r. t of �1fic Prop y adjacent to a s 3: ert � your hard ^ Track 't► 3,eb was sent 3► the A li�oation for o 01W ZOO Angeles office. 1ID�D 170 we ViII have s rt draw � � , d a►tian Within the jae� rev weeks. We will �`o�r r; ca t u tt that tlZe to dete=ing it the su s Meets17 to`A +' 'r u a\�p • fir,. Y A � ''i •, r�_, + ..' _ ';;, a"r' �'� \•. L •1 • :�� ' 11� -� 1� J1r�y{; •�.� �• yS� f gar y• I 'i L' �, F�y:(l`d U "r�'1� �.I�.'. ' �,.1 ��\•k rr•r �. .. _. + ,, � .� r • • . ' , � .. ' 1�. I � ra y �\•'Sd%l��,r K+r�w yF,.L,r '.T7 `,r r.>-• I Sf'e.. ♦.^ - •i . '. , IP 4. IA 1 {�"f M�� '�� ;r l.. � 1 4 •• Y ;4 4;f .•r i a, . 1 .r � ' �\• 1 � Ntk.,Y 'YLL`+\ 4�r��,r� ,IF.Y't 1, �,.r P /.�`� 1( . . � •' �•r r r• • ,r ` Y, ' Ivy .�,+, �! •� 1�' ,, ^ , ali,+' ' : , - ' ',I , • 1 '; ` 1' l 'Wb�.RhY I\� .��u ',^.r� i r ,, r r ��, + F•,+ � ,'�,.�". 1 't>r �,1 � �, "' r•. yr ',• �1 �IS.� � 1��< .i '.�� ° hA t`A N�i,� ti • 4r i� � �' r r +►�Ma. ll �i •, cl ° v'�qj! i '.� r,YlM1.��•r �.L`;ill qll•,,, 1' ti,w, i�y 1 .r 1 ., .,,�i 1„ O' y r �!�' r I l i•� „fy '1,1rI1'f Y .� \ 1 `�r ," ^ �,' +� '� .,r y/r,l I1 ,�M' i • . �� ! .S ,..tip c•+i;%'dek•,' A � , 1.4 41 r � 1 �Ih 1 r it 'f: ',�. .1 r"•' -.y .�': ! y,, �T 4 1 I, C 19 .� i tp c• ih;i\. c .1 'r r ! J th b N r r A � Yy ill 141 44' '. la�,'�� r r�� f`A f'r P'1 d�', :{I�.'ki��ii�•.�,�C�,�:!,r;L.�4 �'� 'YI �.c��. ov t Till 1� 1 , 1�:+wrr............r.,...�......a.....�.r1�..tr.......+...rnr.r+++•.a�.rr..,-.�......•....�A Ja.i < 1{ R 1 17 ,YirIN r w,,r / ` '~ r+ S a � rr 'Q'Kp� a , �rr 1, "�• � � + A. � �• p' I 'Mb r, ��1�I'��i'll�ji��ti •,',r ��/ u�l �� , .r.,,1 ,� Reis � ! � � �.7r. �� .� � t,� jt 4f VA t ,• � tA��11iI r I. � � �;r� � � "• �� L r s .�� 'r' h�u„ti�Kk,�' •i��,.'•y •ply r,1�.,„��1 y". ��.�'��.. �'��'' ..'f,+ �i �r3��5��r: jr' ,�t�! �, �,�;-'1 i op J6, �,�p �" �I °'`�`'• Y: 'F •^ R :' "�W1 "r•f�,', j � •ate ,. ,•�� ',.A.�,.•��• • I, h on ti +r.�,k '� ,�' a 1�•� � ,fl - �� ...�! " �.to w •�•y u riAr, V 4 1. y�t Mon .t • f' r . �y • 1+ • �: , .fir 11 •,� .� ,I 1 ��. F b in OW mubvil� we" AwNd At !gym r� rift 'ale,' � � I � �i•� � � b�fL4 �,l st um tlrplraa ap « *i 1 won thm "so IM1, 04 aft low, 'b , .. , so vo iioi,twr Amwksway. ,�a take ; tfcL 1�wr q. Awd ti � I"' f 44 V' r (r1 A*,r ,'•L yr' v /' If • ;w • ' •' 1 • . TC4y '.� ",�.�. '�,.� ,w• r ,Y. '. it�,•1� ��1�.:11M.�k�r�^.�►�''�.'--vl wow,'�. �' �•r, • • 1 1 d f . Tli oy 4 .1 k 4,w 160 4 $AO) .A tO• 7.1 1 -J: Al. .�44, ft. I IA cct/92 PWI 0OPW 1W/?W r�MMW QWPNW U* xs tor See -a w �, ., boraft too d nelog '7--T'MWW bow ON of V "ft ids OW) ate of State Messa Also St ge 11P 4 farfrtf + t law 8ACRAMOM—TAft towX11 GOT. %=MK" W 661M-XA A-AAaab MvpDOWWWWW"� : ird -tors In big WMd oum OO"WS;;; bowme *D "be met kA W 40 were Reprdi If 111 41 R6 E!4 F", IZ 4t G IS011 WISY I coilgestion x N OWNWON r b �►tl+bp�tdatlal,aaovttMtM tr� �MMiM, MMI thwa now 0 he Mr41r ► lIM • 11� � � taM�R M t�Mi1�It�tb. !or'�r�MtMf� . ,;. � �M1 �ir1 affiMr ��t1Mti �obi Y � Mild � ' NY M� rri►►% 1Mt1M�1 tt+Nl' Mway P ,red rtrP wliiatttft, 1tM*YIM lot Itl! a t Now � t,1" "! dota't MM a lot of we on ow" mob 0 Adow go x0ou" WMAN go th"t WNTSOM !tk'd ffA#j4W M bievvy doprra 1101 M fadrerl tital a i rrwney ' 'ftlttd0 "do 9 . sr 11Mir ►�, and tbay �V94NE tt." wid fMrM Mwt pe�llditw ' � q*0 t • MW d�vitirn of 0"aH'ain dfewitor Itr t� htttdt that NM`t1�et ntQR'e+oat ttrtw a Cdlrasy '1'r�th+l mid do PWWW W" •'AJI 1hdM ho Mw dip kdard "W iresd 00W #WNW It oaU+t twhr h +� Mr•M pn MMttrra" p as wat 'hattw- dipeeertat, � tad ttrtrrrra�et 16ittaMt b�okiltd l�1D apd rrr b �- !+ �. wb� ttttl�a Mew Mimed Tbe blmr-ftboa � hu bfcotw a �► a �AadwM01 i h lb" antral lNi,ltrare m Oet1�eMM rW bpMl hr Myr on MWMW kdoft 1W landit at am* M MWOMM by bwwq heft- pe+ 1do yw$ oft ca, w►ity P Aaw Pry► ' WARLA n ara loa, aoatt ewautrUy be b roe teddt�itattd�morn ehaatiw- b� "Wreased 10 $100 WIN= A IOa4tw lyat AbW/Narir. bait tiMtait W44l Md W %sin bidgrs mW rodits ►e. CWrowly, the county M r►IralMiro� lat1 tam to That my be unliit*W,bbwerer, foam" with plaque. i il4N4d a► rp,tf ail�04 sivem the fedeaal t'a A" fpr three tali rolls tAit + Shtor Aat b caw ►�aieed for blgitw�tya. 4D tratAa-ebolced tebewri. lot U* bit d "pot MW &M low the am a mcc at Rim 111 eai a reed" � htrMda Ir . •prWam by been the w . In iddititat, Rowuy oLtiolsJtt acre r 1pw. how Saea lwo tar, hich each r bawd eaelitlat oaf - Inw r eper�al a000�utt embed the Mt aatnaetdar rail Owls aad rhmd�! 7lrart lalttaci, la recent aarvice an the ad+Wlng i"ot e p*M k Caye'wr iv drdt rears, Congress bu withheld ae-to-Aaa DWSO rail OW44 .L0 at the der A- y; O away rota ""way orlt etropey the ca plan, atwu a ism In ten oalt! �, +!rant ��ab► the UVM hind to be tnoa Yrvit r to atown LA* Art• i a1 Mfg now ftrpMWW for onset the nation's 155 blillaA pw or traySim Juan Cq*US" � wart tp dl�ltrihttt+pd b waft dab S.Gtirr+enuy,while$1d to dowatowrn$pout An& : r, lartrsr ateMtga attadwd r bil w is dbutbuted awauaily for To da w bowever,woWd Mqd Mtbtabr eaa ks"emw bidhwa v,tbsev� is an gnawwr- +o' Wove llmdblr ttae tpf ib do,Waind w4p a w- MIUS of about $136 btlt m b the mossy►-AvarW4 boway tww to .ibrirlwwt�i try. at tltea dew tabu iwrprt'- tsw %Wo d acid. Undee UM 1WM MiartCU J*MW "� be nats4 sew tl�iptar+tititte�p►�trar vrl ►rr it- �$Ad athrrs would Uke trnnrit atr grated toward IipY mahibilMan4obt Nvat. • to as Mat 11may hid up for Mrb�l+ealbul"IS M in do lbsta the � �M do ,fie.'• , ,,x �,ou►ti b�aar �i�w. h,1d UM lereic /hie COW Ala, But they have lot eeverai is"�oulta•a G`a!!larair.•nab ao�+e b wkwn aub- HtaM vows 60 exempt Ow high. aubta�M ttttve Ewa M►lihaW a rwrrdr,. syAebra d" War hutch 600 et cutlswk,. . M►K t owe, fbrrdl`dbv lt AAattter pots baMW W !n t • t tad and �W" vim. cel n d tran4w on Vending dL "It's ""her reamm why W� t110C'w h"aQf�OA1 toPON ' rictus be a bike in the • tedeital twr, t>vw beipa Hoare tttttrbl rt'arnd." ' La %MA Asdft dire m" by Me ob ro of Coheres ft"Hyt a MGM IWWW fetleati r t1 delitlt-fi¢htigs rpeaauY'e. Wlaw tit!0D6i� ' v low ► rdraattmt far that atrctt aeaer ' lurid p f1a fdp►Or+a tray►am ari hi RIO a In the d a w per Wice trafa flaw an her ortrriai atroe/t w cadets!to would dMroatt W many Mh W Aewh and Kam* , VOW" W A dw Son For. acute,� ys their own a- federal �r q Wte ums and thus ,retard the "Might now, growth of kawy WOOK W trWW- pragraa don't allocate arWh pads• Money to aucn test4 but it tbq ,yin CalNaraia.tranopoetstb offl- 44 you cyanid M.A e tlyr"Wada of ' tbia Claim me Wal ehi thtw blttip dacwW ," be ee►K i l j GNM wbberr WWQ can Iutt kes!► may. / do**tact it might be more itopw'- bet t�hew► nr to -wow gout M be monitarind teat to•ywiWont" trsttie Ana - peat t" acid Jim Badt a go Jose Canny cwWWly,to ere how thrr an amb Bat:levard thou oa , ty'tatateltmttn and raevtbt:r eE the abaaie the lebhwatr pr ram, an of your money an fteewyra.. ' ""i1�lrMtpartr OWN '"Mask farce.a said itdmt Bat. tUreCtar of Cal• Without thwse improvemdata uatittlal +Wu r areMed by trans, the na .ve's is taciaa smye traffic a . wn ull'trt;•44 to find new r4.:a.gy. '''ArliaL Y,hprx.>f la Wart►•. in Orange Q-way .arts UjW 61"Aa- ta1dW ivlm tR>e ttitutfic pcobienv."We htxe." mattes Valaatteit in ams wilt worsen 1dven"lly, sb%j t have W rpeW Ummy a loyal.slaw and federal*Mdmb WW ►pi►s pwt b oiaw two, the di¢ttts ti rtaa+d for Ka, iavt two work Woettter at ways to WW w �!Adwtou aapt Ibe �edetaMl. aloha MW beat! ofiigaM Bak haWag growth with tranapor- t' •� . Wee that the ettrrat►t hu►y► tatioa and plan htttlre cierdapaswt 00 .� h r tlu+oMptrut t riorh ib►bl►Iw�!►�,. M�' ild1 .Kits that of dsoy acid "y thWt the public is aotanrned tlyltB to drt W s1a # for 4WARt, jjjj,W6 hrt 1; 11 1 11 to, damblanjobs.M Ow 1ae1'JCyvAM *bout catgeetion, even Uwmgh theybwa M ita iiotwta airs+Qattter dlt er tilarw bat been ao s:plalvt grawt>s gnu ttiven'c yet pegged h at a in MWANand econamk fmpar- f9ranatiio�a+irl ,"acrid Ray 8or'nibtrt, take, Men w tht nalfm tutor d A in"Mrbs. way A hem c+!the F'tderal Mph. "him to Fie man tw i that !loam IM to l NW,t�tR`numbw of w" ut I f tti*trat li t .e tart Into i~w L%41 wdt )obe t eMod in UW subwbe Grew "But it fr+l 4on't �akN 4geigdNtl 11MM��"cold y'rf Aws 8, from li Mdi" t >y md1mmL a atapa ttmo rye's #or* to !te IoOk- &McWVe cantor 01 the than 23 rrWJMM M mute" drive on at • lc-s� Ware in La IaW:M hway aertd 7Ytrru�• *,very day from,%aa�+n hall*to Al&Ana ti* jw ovet' the'ma 10 �. "H utltra are 6U a nrbtwMft 1� r 3" at aft tnp.' yens• d re Rho rratlttpR !a eogralMd 4ttgaltl artyr wim het Wy, the etdlurb•ta- the sal d.1+':4 fir ,y ntlyht y� ... --t. aRRir O .e+W +*hyr bi0106 Ill 0 woo rural ta.'r ftft wo dew!►," �, f .�kit''�,p�� ' �,� r,� t "... t"7�yr. Q� f. i/J4r{ I,t.�i N�IM,`,y� r.l,w M.• •,1'.�{�l �y'_�'r"' ` _ t I. A � � '� y 4�,• ''*" 't,�, I„i�ri�•'h*9Y1"i��S frY �. f � "7�' * I � k 71 or "4 MY numd is �J Y i; r,✓ t, 'y' A 1 1 Ir UVi to Pr aa criers- , 70Wtie rt► .�d t" ',v!±! an rbr bb hale, 3' ar e �wes�i � dr r , wm bob bo dim , u C slat lu to of a , y L1 Y � ' '�5A: ,� ';'; ;;' ' ; �: �• pert,tee • ' ° to C�r� � + tt � Of �► ialenasoe w 1� � qrwWAY � �� AIM M�, A�JI� w� toy C ml� spparebwwd , doll 17 RAiL4J�D �tuchortty to determine the r enitb Ihr mV end the mmws, ow owdidm UrAw wweb to "owns $MR be emtpjcwd OW raawwn4 and mw Ax and =am the port ad , upon � i .i f"• r1• I �1 f . , r,l+f,Rx',l�Y/r' n A1A��I, d• M��1T"�1"�y (,.ThA>ti� 1 T :', A. 1'�H Xl� M/i � � � �. R` �9 '7T' �" 13'�f�ll 1'T`!}�Tj", �n�A r ` + Jk, •, r�' � IIF,, ^ f n + ' h ��,p�j ��l�. '7k4`lilwi 1 '` fty .,?� ' f n' , ' � + , r• , �:I�� +r AW irk„� ' f y� /f�t r'i,, •,'.r �' r I •• �M+ � 1'., - Y +� „��'I + / Zi� Q', y,'t��hr rf , 1„I}.+'• E, I i! { , I .rr � •,`,. � ".r. 4� �Ir f :r' ti r•r• � t r /� n Y{ t � e r I l✓• (. 1 • • 1rf y 1 Y / + •J j .i � yid) 1��{ P � 1 y r'r�t .' >.- 1' 11' fl• r •MlVeMy-i. r{' ti<'�^ •n 1. I ^/ ;'i•rR . .;Itr" _,.•.A. . . .. ;.Mi• rr•1N� ' 'y�rlr .,.r „ .;`r-• _ � ' • rM1hY 41( •r -I•Kt16M•.�{'- '\r 4•Y.', �Y .. r lr(4 f �Y.l F • y- as Lu' MS Cos ,g ,�+ M11NINO M BtACN, CA 1! • (?14)447-011 1 im t bf Jaw' limber CoMpaviy, on the one hand, johatly referred to as (JAN ) d x MsreeasteiA, prosidout and ovaer of Ideal Pallet Syotamss UK& s Oo► , otber hoWo jolatly referred to as (Ideal) do beva�y agree that James sbo d 8 ,1`016alb h1l, sopiste and unliseiled access, for ideal'a trucks and tnwks making deliverit►r to 'sad from 14as1's yards south to Warner AveAae sud South ` ts" Vatox •Avsaue to ideal's battkyurd, through tha two existing back oaten, for 1 ' t1 " of i Ott tmd a ess throe hoot the length of. 1C0 foot wide b + P�� it # S S p 1 loON lout loft pateal of log cont4ined in block la, of block "1110 of the tovn ' of vim' texAarg, AseassordIpp, book 111, pad• 01# of the County of Orange. State of Califomo4dp, k*m as the kuthern l eLfie Public Tesua Track, Wiutersburg, Y Cs itomila, 0*e Pbeto-cop, of sap attached. ` W CAW,&,tit tton of tho a&rve rfgbta, Ideal agreas to to-operate &ad assist Jams �7• 1t i� f.4f e►ith tit "so& plazo to obtain a Conditional Use Permits from the city of "tied Seacb so tUt Jonwo can receive and unload rail-care of 'lumbar wnd s Ord fee 106ar oa the abovs described sites where Ideal asserts its eases►ent Jmaa sM t4oal also agree. that Jsaes will allow all rail-+pare of Imaber.r destined for Idealp to be spotted on its tracts. at 'the rpove sectioned described site, ubltb ia,Awad to his# by the Boutbarn Pacific Transportation Company, and tgrass to assAiki•'aminever possiblo, to the unloading of spatted rail-oars of lumber be- 1o�lag ta,,�4a. . •. This agro~t no angered into# by both parties, ou March 31# 1986. Igerood to by s �rXitrg �4s llerura of eie� s y i. Ha�rriugtoe � firma �rtetn by xdeai Pa iat 8ysteses#Inc. �rJ1 " A r, } iI sue■•••yam�..� •-i•Y•• L� Y'a�i'rVE'A' �► /*ir14t+J14 ! •I�IN I sell 1fl�rllr • • } �V•1 Or M► ' .rwa oo • o • rr ..s r• , err • - 4D , 140M • ' r. i r ` 6t�1 rr N �. �. *• • • C��Al1 Aw#w . A#Av ,, ram• �■ vo do d . • r ' r •�Y w •sue r!��•f► • AIM � � � '' ' s4�",,.,•, • '`.''tio,•( • OD' • I • � � • Yak.;$;`;r!•yJaS+y'77,ccf/,,,y � �• din NI'i� r Y .s •, : y 'i ' "Y��i' � ,4 A10, t t I•r �a l` jl jr 1 ll ' y A. I t; '•p •{, �1 DIY i . •1 J. �' Jp VVV r h 1°- �� yh;{,r+._ '� `�lH � "y�1�'l i; :'l,.�i�rS ��: f. • L • ;�I 01. Ir AWANNN of r ' A � 'l• N •` . h,`��,�I ll ,'t ��f�,l t�n •`��19 ,�11 ;Q ' ti• I• � ltato Suite 1ls0. �i" lip 1 `, 1 I. �'i5p]Y •�. ` gy.t'� ec� r� �� tAl�^r n 'fl .% J`•�. 'i fj':1}r I�'•iR �• ' 1 �: r 1 t ! 1 Ah'. oisponse to your letter da tea t M d �nfi out telephone: c1*PV1 , --I,I art • 1�I� t• AMY . U yaw ifr abaly mioeh� rootoxlse tho a 0,11r.. drr'ir•!n tire' telt�►hoAs eo�werirnti Mn Z 44' ir tropf"ented to ou that Neuthern far.ific naps not went 40, Wariid4000 with Feel pallrrt, or hr. Ho rft�yattift f that , 4 Irawlsil*in had created *bad bl*od" tWtw+resft 83uthern ,00, h�,rur�elf. or tat fto Her, 6*18toln had 06 Pocit1c. i also 4S4 not state to you th; .1 othorn pacific did not like t set that ld*al p ,.0t A.bO 'Or. Mtraolste.ln films a Complaint with the Pub2lc , ,tIts t pmalssion. t find your untrue accusation* to be bras& Mad sor prisinoly 6nproftsoxoeral. fir., Hera9loteiin's busintse relationship with Southern V f!c Ttans ortation Company ryas hot the subject %af our lattlol teilsphone coav:ersatlea. low are, well *vote that the only issue t addressed with tespeat to xdtal Pol:et was your c1lent's erroneous claim of a proscriptive easement ever property No had loosed tram southern Pacific. You atkompteA to persuade we to caoivloce southern Pacific to reinstate dr. Mtoolott in's less*. Y informed ,you them and ' ' reposkedi thor4atter• that WhA,t*ver transpired •between tar. Wereelatoin and dosthern Pacific with tie Cespect to Mierrmelattirt's team* ACt Bement was betwten Southern Pr.cific's Real Notate personnel and Nor. !lwrrnfisteiA and that Y Would sot Otto t ersuode southern Pacific to '1e90tiate with Miroolst o Mir the rtaptet to the lease, or otherwise& ' S M '•d' rr , +�. r r i ti r y Jry �k"rlw :7 ��1� p r�• i,G•g1 i �r' s 11 '' It , Zrml M".= r 44 1f'�1�',*,?•I r , "'t !,it � • 5rrr' • �� Uq ` r 11r0 abrr160'41y attempting to sarlulactur6 --a coup* +`t +eft ' ��' xag.r client. whore A;vio exists. . I sinc roir �' r+ 0 ties and your clie6t0a, money would be better r 4 n"Oetion with this W$tt*W !t 1 ou would do 00 I 1 A. *0 steel r to wits Goo and visibl Inspect Koh "r�. McTwelstsitn elaiwa Ke has 0 Irou Drill bb able to see ciestely chat ; „ ►:~a � .y •� apr crating railroad ri ht-►oi-vsy and that lip the 666e 1►sap tl.Y . �. Mermelstel" 104404 from southern ot;$i'lq* . ipansequentilxx0 and 60coediw4 to existing case Iasi tfrat = hav►0 alriedy given to your %r. Merftolbtein ca"hot _ *AIol$K ,a prescriptive easement over the prooperrty. 4 1x V you Frith the oxistin es ;Ileh r 'a iootossrd ad are s ear• $t should have any lortherr questions regarbletig 1 h a iaa►ttb rr plotaseo Contins your o:aa+mnicetionsr to u i a . L� Yery -truly youtr& IP%OY C. DICKSON " an . � .• 'r r5r 1 • s, r i APO �Y ``i`• I cam•! �i• � �+'y� + � y 1� '� 1 , r� F 1 N x 1 r� 'I�V(n M �,• �A� ia•._ 7 • Y�, . • ;!, i r ''YC�71;"�,�y 4�yc? �h��"� ..��+ '�i�''y• ��C ll.� y�, M� � �4" �J. t t1 �} . �J'��'y�-S{,� any.=• 4vr; .q,'tY ,, 'A , �, '�R��'� jx y -r � +: ;� ', is"1'.W� k4 .Y.r ';�!r,r �„�,i.�' f• �W► rW� FA J' ♦ } J ��'F 1�1 `�te _r, • �� ■ / yii. • �. . W• ti.MA! �eNr.'_ '• u' ■Y��. .. ;.� .. . •�hf •w.. . . ",err IBSM * SICUARD XAUSNZR l rKY�1'• �i last s515•46ir +ewes gtNtwwv PA014 c&PT �c�s�e��cw �at�l io�•a.�a� i ' a LOO MCOs,Ase, GAWF RWIA raa.r� Decomber 17i 1947 , Oor » a a, pwitat Ion ca"rany is OW3 AW_ � 1 Y.& Southern PfiSril you lettor dated Vecea r Up 1487 s. , . in {, lra ' o'fv�r �•ia��a 1pt�.ex. au stated ghat 1 "siouai x . , In Rky letter of December lot 1907 the . , t*tt�t� t� ou Modo. t d cazweareaton sr � r Ma lateing, bas been placed In -an antanable tioa; ` th #Oak at ' Southern FaCifiVe U terminating the 0 h . ►# *cga** to loading and unloading rail caro at . .k.61 bohind ideal * ilat's . On10e dootat, a rucl tri,+rt 4 a: . kid -business. ',• ' vwa h thatou inq this situations r find your TM, t �. , ar4tivo 'as tt.at of your amployo r, I regrat the t her# Olt a lit thin casa. „ Vary truly youre i ' , gas �i �r��t�lh� �rasideat ••� and 6*0*rrti tt4889ar0 ideal Pellet dystdop rate F rl��, „ , ' � .•fir � 44 v.ti ', iq' i 14,y � 'l 4 ff Yr''A • . it+r ��d O. r '�1 fi�• +�...��..��•.mow.+.. �.h ...+... -..•ss• +rw....... �I. ,.,r .... e IDEAL PALLET SYSTEM, INC. tr a'• ra 3 cEOAA STAEET HU"NOTON DEACK CALIFORNIA 921W7im _ _ . .. .. . _ ''; '�� • PNQ11tE�11,�aa$-QrE��rllwr�iT-El�l��' 1 Ray Dioks+on Assistant 'Senerdl Attorney puthern Pacific Transportation Co. } 4, 17 South �it l Str'e:et -�Suits �ui is �65d . Los dl " a , 8 , 900 Dear W. Dickson: I have read, re-read and Studied, with 'particular interest, your app 4l of the Hunti ratan Beach Planning Commissions decision which was unaniziously reachad on Deceaaber 6, 1988. As I read and studied Stour reaasonin against their position, as well as your. points and � authorities, could not help but find your stance in this issue totaal l y 1 . M 13-Leading. 2. Inaccurate. 3. Inappropriate and most of all unfortunate. In your introduction segment of your brief you state the following: ; " Saatharrn Pacific. Transportation Company ("Southern Pacific*) ,appeals the: 00sion of the Huntington Beach Planning Commission t"Commission") Ifttw lW caber 99 1968 tv impose ceIlljo conditions on its approval of ,Mndh'i� Lu dm,- am 's► ("Randall L~ appilEation for Conditional use : . i t .No. 3 ("Permit"). While your objection In the appeal states onli ions " you seem to be fully and completely engrossed e esse wlUM one and only condition, namely; 3.9. which reads as follows: " al�ppl hart and/or property owner shall submit a aigpd and notorised irrevor aeble offer to dedicate track actess for industrial uses abutti the l ease . 0MI-. A copy of the .1*Sol instrum4nt shell be approved „b the Cit Attorney as to fore and content. A copy . _ shall be ffl ed with the 'Department of C tnity Deval cent." , : The local - point of• 3.g. ,•rel ates to Ideal -Pallet,, a Southern Pacific . f ral i Us like Randall, James and others in tlws general area along the am Southern Pacific rail line. + t Ideal Paal 1 et his been a 'Southern Pec i f i c ra i 1 road customer i n good ' standing since 106S.,a d x1sMs to continue having good relations. y of letter slated 3uly 199 1979. I•� yl •t{, I.r^�r,•'�••r•y ',SM, ••F,•YI : �.. (.. • - • • .+1 � r .. ; , _ , •, . • . a + ... . 1 �i l ',^ � �i}1■ylig:,/� L1JM�1 ,rjry�/w,.iq IWu`/ �LAY fyy j 11f .1 i,` l' r. + •'1 �1+• . } ` '� 5 ,•'� ,, ..'. r • ��1 aA�.il1:•iC_':�[YG'Y� �14':. I'k,'!11'R�4[i.I✓�_��.,"•� '/ . _`1._ J<�t_.•�_.F. •+' •;Y. Y . �. -l.2 l 'i•• � ti .r .•. _. • r./ ]DEAL PALLETSYSTEM, INC. � .: ;. .. ...; 7422 CEpAM STFIEET _,. HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA 92847 r Iowa"* MNE(213)827-8858 or(r i s)847- T As of late. b4cause of, Our two cw4mnles acrimonious differences, • Ideal Pallet had no alternative but to use your Piggy Sack •Syow which as jou op know' b now, grossly increased heavy truck traffic �. into .Ire i reets of Huntington Beach. Heise the Planning Comaissions 3 Justification for Conditions number .g. which you oppose on behalf of Randall . See photo-copy of one of many such Southern pacific Piggy Back Vans as it arrives in the Ideal Pallet yard for unloading. Also, see photo-copy of the Los Angeles Times article 1/08189 titled — Planners ; " seek solution to suburban gridlock. " Reducing Truck Activity." Moto-copy of L. A. Times item " Govornor Sets to Unlock Roads. " J: Your company, the Southern Pacific Transportation, which you represent reaps the benefit from the freight charges to Ideal for its raw material , namely; luabere regardless of how it arrives at its plant location which, ' by the way, abotts to the Southern Pacific Alintersburg Public Team Track, eamaent and railroad right-away. 14 Perhaps as the attorney for the railroad, a public utility, you should be aware of this aspect of our relationship wherein you have the upper r, hand and stand .to benefit either way, having aye as 'a customer or 'not... ;.• You can't 1 ose while Ideal suffers grossly The ralrol Ls Public j r',u MItTlUo The1 e her d r not. a applies -to " me- - owner t Und �pu�c u�iy, a 'taan car��i er i n your case, which is duty to serve -all shippers alike under 'subatantially similar conditions. Allow pp to quote from a law dictionary_ tuia definition i,nd the term., aubl is utility: Public Util ty: A privately owned and operated business *hose services are so essential to the general public air to ustify the grant of special franchises for the use of a pu . blic p_, y or.,Of. the right of eminent domain. .'1n cousider- ,_ f do of f eh tW ownert iaust -nerve all persons trha► a 1 Y ,�•�a ,-�`��.��' ��t'•�y �; iserllaii�tl+� It IS' * virtual oorraply.., .. iaer` deaiYpp1 lad before rtNi heroin.applies .again for per�ai alai on „ � y4 ~10 Wow 1ti tal -kar juleber� and fu�rtheroare received prior permission } ,lo to .e ilsl'tual•,agreement With his neighbor. dames LumW, 1o, .cross 'And (nload Ideari s 'ral l-catr loads of l udwr, 'Seephoto-copy of original agreement.blpned .be'two n Dames lumber and Ideal pallet. *� t r � � I i fY. �1 ,i` � ,, • ��1, • .!1 yy1�, ± . ' '�� ir.: �,,. ,` , r r+ r ' �\- , ] i .. r• •, • ', + -,1 ,+ 1 .'i i'j �w It��, • S. ,i°�. i iM /y,r r!''�••r ^ti'1'r,. i.l �' �. • ..- . • '. , ♦ .. 14 1 , ,. }.'7.ra+.. �j�a -..•w'. r+...-a- ,,"1lll.,.�" .,1�� r� ..r . :....`Y..•:, .� •. .. •ry.rl �,� '\ .... ,'>'■ '! ' �Y i �l�i��aa.NtK ,�H�ja,Y, r 'i''1 ' -If ' C'ih• ', • f,.a�. ` ,� �. , �l •. 1'• ' , 1 .l;,�r,` ♦ .� 1 r..' 0 +' r •• , , - ( Iy, �r'�( FI, ".'S•~ •', >N�,�' ,�`�^,� ,tl - i.. •.. i1 � 1' ,�:LA •• �,1,,•.� ,`�J ,�__ * . . ..1 '. I r - J'r1, !�,.i.,.,+•a.`i .L4•.. �`Y i + �' , rif r � y f f ,,k�_ '�.�! •`�' � C}1' ' F. 1,�'•i - 4 T •�. .4f :i , t ' y. �' rY, y T-• r '~ t,. 1• •' '! •• LI • \''+'• ' °M ! y��y �'' y:4 +#�&1�, _IW�'S�,,�.i �,R 1 �1 ,r1Ai f .ii � Nf• t ►4"f..' � 'J •1 �• .i!,li`h R�,.'. •'�'•' ,i�.r + I�a 'r r,F� ' . !f• t •..!1i r�- ", tr,•eN ri r +r .}}.. ;,�•,,p, ,f .6 . y�,,� jr' 'I',••' \.,, 1 r 'M. 1, . . �} �. L'� 1.• _Y'�' • �,,j t A\. Y I `� '� .��'_'.�w, ' ;=f�',"`�t�'J';1�4'�':f�►•r�r�.y_'. �:��ti c'1>�t�' L�` � ''�'��9G•��'."�'��° i � 4,.•��'r;�`� °k" '1° _ o war• `' 0"100; .d r k 1 1 y Ir I ti, .. I 1 " ' IDEAL PALLET SYSTEM, INC. 1 �• 7422 CEDAR STREET �,-,.. +., yM� MUNTINGTONNEACK CALIFORNIA 02847 � PHONE C13)592-6658 or(714)647-i1Od7 t _ 1irMrrM� r z. , zen 1 ; t .,s. P'ubi I Uti 1 i ty - continued L �y', ',?.. ,:• �trrrrrrrrrrtn r...�a�\� . A busirsess or service which is engaged in regularly { supplying the public with some commodity or service � which is of public consequence and ,need, such as ; eloctricity, gas, water, kl1NSPORT�1 oN, or tole- phone or telegraph service. Gulf States Utility Co. E v* State Tax Civ. App., 46 S. W. 2d 10181 1021 . Any agency instrumentality, business industry or service which ;s used or conducted in such manner as to affect the community at •large, that is, which is not limited or restricted to any particular class of the community. The test for determining if a concern is a public utility is whether it has held itself out as ready, able and willing to serve the public. The term applies the public use of an article, product, or service, carrying with it the duty of the producer or manufacturer , .` or one attempting to furnish the service, to serve the public and treat all persons alike, without discriminat- ion. It is synonymous with " public use " and refers to persons or corporations charged with the duty to , .' supply the public with the use of property or facilities owned and furnished by them. Buder v. first Nat. Bank in "St. (,.oui s e CA.i1. No. 16 f 2d 990,992. 'To constitute ts true "public utility", the devotion to public use must be of-such character that the 'publ is generally, ors' that' y part of It which has continued, with reasonable efficiency under reasonable charges. The devotion to public use must be of such character that the product and service is W* available to the public generally and indiscriminately, or there roust be the acceptance by the wti 1 i tr or, pub]i t franchi ses or ,ca 111 ng to its e i d the pot 1 ce power of -the ' �. "This !i _.few lraoii what you inner W �1n your a e1 :to the Hurrtl nopn eekh Cit 1 for consideration as a definition of a public utility. . `:1lq. the railroad, which is a " .Public Utility " is by.-no means •defined r o ." • 1; is quite specific In its tarns and role it occupies' , in a -and public ,sector and therefore It dwell not and crust not Vat I tted to discriminate. i know that the terse scri rat na ra i 'us 1 •e few a rows ,aM a questions to' all once again el10w1��uote z• }: fro the saw law .t'dic�'ti ry the definition of discrimination: �. or y.0 ti • is — .' �: .• " ' .� • .• •t .. l • ( ' r,. �' .fit � �. , Y '. .w t +,�• „•. (. ..;L I '. l' ';;' .4 j h' 1. ��N s�t:'I r'�rri,1� ',.. ,•` , {'. ; .. . , • . . ";' • .:+, i Y.`, ,..� ,I• + .1 • i l , k IflL3' • t• aALc ,..rllr'.ki '. t�� '�.�• .r.: �`i ' -J1''- ',�� : .rik'tir..i . ar'�: . �t_�'.. .�k:�.a..a._� ..� V`,✓,rFr , Gf I!'+4 ',11� " e ` 1 r [✓jJ r /� l � 19Y�II6+M•4�M�M+'r' ., .. _ .., , . � '+rM!',y•ilr ,1 ♦ 4 IDEAL PALLET SYSTEM., INC. k.� 7422 CEDAR 1, MEET i r1� HUNITINGTON REACH, CALIFORNIA 92647 I wrr��r PHONE(213)502-66M Or(714)847-M7 IliscriainettEns In constitutional law, the effect of y > a statue or established actice whit cone rs P r - , icul ar pri vi l tges on a class arbi trar�1 y. se ecte� tom . a large number or persons, all 6fYMhoat stand in the ` se ref ati on to the pri vi 1 eges granted and between whom and those not favored no reasonable distinction can be found. Unfair treatment or denial -of normal privileges to persons because of their race, aget nation+l ity, or religion. A failure to treat all persons squally where no reasonable distinction can be found between those favored and those not favored. baker v. California Land 'title Co., D.C. Cal . , 349 Supp. 235 n PSB. Federal statutes prohibit d'1 scrims nati o n 4 ont on basis of sex, age, race, nationality, or :. reliq on; e. g. Title VII of 1964 Civil Rights Act, Age Discrimination in Employment Act, Equal Pcy Act, Sex Discrimination in Employment Other federal acts, as sup o plimentedby court decisions,decisions, ibi discrimination in voting rights, housing, extens- ion of credit, public education and access to public facilities. " WITH REFERENCE• TO COMM CARRIERS, A BREACH OF THE CARRIER'S DUTY TO TREAT ALL SHIPPERS ALIKE, AND AFFORD 7NE14 EQUAL OPPORTUNITIES TO MARKET THEIR PRODUCT..•A CARRIER"S FAILURE TO TREAT ALL ALIKE UNDER SUBSTANTIALLY }` SIMILAR CONDIYIONS. I eras under the impression that a ro%i 1 road attorneys dutit Is to defend , r the railroid and not one customer against the other. Is not a breach of s tamn tarriar to defend as custoor and prosecute the other in a dispAie between them as neighbors and compel ti orsY I k1w that ywr �fe6se against o.ur' company's alleged di scHmination A. . r toe Idol Pallet arr� 1ie1 �rmalstein, owner will, revert bade to t F • so-called P.II.t. "AuIU94.9 1n ,the Pi il. 11S ,iopinico only the , . , d�lowno 1s state$ MAL PAW MS Wil WT ITS BURDEN OF PROOF -AS TO' AWFUL DISCRIMINATION 1 IT SWnM PACIFIC AND ,M CWLAINT MOULD BE DEN . -As m -1 Me rC u will agree that such bh opinion i s not In itself final or �: . as refer to I s as _RK,201c All.Tho P.U.C. f s irwrely +% moans 0 end +tnd 'pot final and cone u s ve. due p woss In this case has :; not Pet takrh its ful 1 .cc%jrse. IV dayA n 'court j: .lret to 4come, .i f need be Jlf 'r I ow .40 3 ,,r 1 h L'n••' . , fw e� 1t • 'J IDEAL PALLET SYSTEM, INC. 7479 CEDAR STREET *400 HU;NTINGTON REACK CALIFORNIA E7441 PHONE(21 3)EE2.8E50 ar(714)a47-IM? 3• ' nesctrr 0 ;"aIdelaf 0 v'stl�ieus$�►ut�'ernuracl$fc"�j�aanssportaation, and exam them thoroughly with an unbiased view. I am sure as a 1awywr, eu will find issues therein that are well defined as good causes of actions in a state or federal court. The administrative law Judge in the case said so himself.' See Volume 1, pages I through 164. As an Merican who fought for this country during the Korean Conflict, as a Sew who survived the infernos of Auschwitz-Birkenau and Quchanwald and wost of all as a free human being, I will never allow injustice to rule, defa stion, mockery and discrimination to go unpunished, 'wherefore, I urge you and your company to respectfully take a. good, look at whet initiated this dispute and perhaps among ourselvesr0 11 seek out and decida as to who is at fault. I am always prepared to talk 411C to negotiate rather, than to litigate. If you give me no choice but to ►} litigate I shall not hesitate to do so, even though you have threatened to sus me my lawyer, and his law firm for malicious prosecution, if I should fide a complaint against your client, The Southern Pacific Rail- road comoanr and Iose. the case» See photocopy of your latter dated Deco r 16, 1987 and my Attorneys response dated DeceWer 17, 1987. In his letter to me dated October 14, 19881, M. D. Kolodziej, Director I National A carats writes, among other things, the following: I might am thi+t I would hope that you can find a 'respl iti on to this natter quickly so that both our firms may address their attu+tion to the business they conduct rather than • . ,. t0 a 1�a7 alnrtanplewent." � '�, I Alvafor such words and W, Kolodtiej should be t nded for his cicfry tone, soon after his weed rtg with wa and my staff. at IV afficef an October II * 19880 ' >: Allow .-w, in conclusion to intend my WA to you and your company and see What we won of ntl y Jo to enhance the area to i mprovs our i at instead of throws ft rwAs at each other. Al i`FI a t• , ti • I I. t r . •{ r, i r', II, r•w!�7 •'"'r:f..', •;;�y''' 1 n. ____ .—... 1 r a . r •.M� ' t t ;; 1 f -'� � 1 It AL PALLET SYSTEM, INC. , . � . 74V CEDAR STREET M/e NUNTINGYJN EIACK CALIFQANIA 09647 r � •'r"r AMA ram► PHONE 4213)602,U56 or(714)547.4U7 AkW �I ; I*ok f�rd 0 hearing, fraiw you and o110w me to say that it was good not YOU pocaaber S, after our Pla Aiing Commission noting and hm"w" that we can not again In a more peaceful atmosphere. � � r Mel Nermelstain - President IDEAL PALLET SYSTENj INC. �• EMI:f ms encl . Saws Agreement and Various Others. cc: Wfory Hausner Attorneleach T Call Hutton - Hunting0m;n City Attorney N. 0. Ko►lodzlej - Director-National Accounts-Southern pacific Transportation Co. Philip Anschutz - Chairman of the Baard - Rio Grande Western Railroad R. U Stacy- - Assistant District Manager ,, Real Estate - Southern Pacific Land Co. i . James' Harrington - President - James Lung Company r ' ; •'Y Wes Bannister Mayor City of Huntington Beach i. Mayor Pro-Tom - City of hintir+Oton .Beach x r. Huntington Beach ' 3olm Erskine - Councilman 1- City of Huntington Beach Jim S11ra - Councilman - City of Huntington Bdath ' rw# 11ihOo11 - Counc i l wooaan - City of Huntington Beach F Boa MtAi 1 i r Counc i i ran Ci t of Hurst i ngton Beach �ittW . - Commission r C on State Government �rgani�tetion ' Y.a`r !',r.,•�� .',J) �fT�.Y�'�'.q lkr\Rr. � �1` ,+ ' 1• �6J,'+ .IP S And � .E ,�..,• . .., ,:: r1`y and Assemblymen Batlr Elder ` AM i"ii an SO HURti no0h Beams Use Tohnic#an"=�Cit,y 0 Ountin r ftacMkih ' 1 r4 Senior plefrfler City ot~ Huntir1h lAeach t al r •t i city of 1luntir tar► ft% ttn: 'Art'yoloar Esq . . e hd1 qkL ..S r6Ury. P1snninp Commission City Of "un ingtlo 6ac Yle� i'Pr,=4p•r�.ri \.• 1.. % r r 1'1•.W: •,p ^IL. i .•f.•/,� l.' . i• l• '1 a ,•I, " _ 1, rAf+lr l'i1•Y 7. • . '.' 1' . . - I 4 �� • •11(`F� µ �'�s! 1 Npb 11`a•i'�if. 1 _ .y�. W, , • ,• _ .„ .. . r .+ ,Y , ' A M .Ir�'r a ,1 7 I • �� 1 ' _ +. •, /•• � '. •. is 1k7, ,'�r�.y �• ,qF�° ice, ; r r R v y' ,I 1 �.• i�} ..� �rr4'n."fl(11a u.4.1,..,yN,. n,.•,i,: .. ,4,P •, ..a N.'. . L �LAA ,r"^'r'.� NATIONWIDE i MAST—F—RlNfj,, INC now w, November 29, 1988 � ItEICEIVED , t `, �t rt Franklin ,par1CaWt of COoftunity Development WV f 9 1.0 O1&=ing Uvis Loa y City of Huntington Tench 01"WMWO � 2010 Main Street _ Santington beaoht CA 92640 RE* Conditional Use Permit of Alleyway, Palmdale & Cedar Gentlemen, ft an I pucahased this property, my partner (John DeLeonardi ) and myself were informed that we had to relinquish 10' of land and, ve it to they City of Huntington Beach in order to obtain a pf�t. VbG City 441d that this 10 ' of land head to be used a fire lane-� An access crate was installed, but nothing n. tuxther has been done. ,lames Lumber was to improve the alley � + in order to obtain a land use pearnit. Was a permit issued o and whir? i We would like to inquire as to why the issue hasn' t been pur- auu*d with James Lumber about the improvement of the fire lane? Now that we are running into the rainy seasom, what will the City do if the lane in murddsd out and fire trucks cannot use the lane so intended. We WWOVOtand that Randall Luwber is now Applying for a land use por"i to st sc;k lumber and that in his "Conditions" he is 44iki4 tbr this fire lane to be improved as a street. It Lis opthion and recomendotioh that this fire lane should not be improved as a street as it would be a nuisance to gay may* !fie do have our business offices her* and haying di el.. fins driftingthru would not provide a healthy work *A `� #t r 1li+C / fir CaJtI reason there were an mergency, the ti. truck* night not be able to make it thru in timer. if It is improvod as a public streaty parking should bo mad* dvailabie to' as all* and curbs and gutters should be constructed, If this isn't improved as a street, why are we allowing special treatment, for another company? CoLtinued. . . . . . 4' t T + 'r vr♦Oqr- � sr'jM^ r 4 4g7j1Fw r. ��.y,�,a ¢ r � �y, I y } < p'� yam^ f e �, � � y'Y Af ty to R� � �►.r'' ,�,J- � R r � k ��, •1,!r�r��", M*'r.,; "'a�L� *��".s��'t �,'�'" A�•!E"�� "�Yl R'� i * � � ��{��,;v,�� .1��,; .V! rid. 7 1'rYj 2 I� �' t,• ��' # ��'� vr�r�Jtir� rat", r r ` Moat - to Public a r ' u , or 4are Very trU1 rive J JD L� Nxko �s Co.,, �O Attora d ri A p .r �o ' r ..��.•� R' 3 v 11 T i A y, t : '''•;fir- �: � ,�!. �: '!w y .a .,, ;'`T �. t•, _•, .,4ay VIXDtM AND CKMITIOxd OF AIPPiVAL rM t I?IJML M PZWT NO. d8-33 r'n^i1 i,• OM y I• Y , , •i R,• 1'IAr,Xr ., yak, maintenance sod operation of the proposed r • I e t ..V ; t rr tag, unloading and storage of lumber products for �•> W112 not be deatr i,menta l to r a, . The i9 tpebial welfare of parsons residing or wonhing in the b« pre rty aasd improvements in the vicinity of such use or .; ding , t0 ilisi'a the site for loading, unloading and storage of lumber it Mo. Lvmftr and providing future access for the adjaeot%t s'soo through the proposed storage area Mill Al ai a t ti.al increased vehicular impacts on local i�ai na*ter i a l s. ,y ; i ., Paving along the designated roadway portion of tho a sft.e• W AZ provide adequate support for fire appexat,us And sitedust CoAt rep . d. Tibo pfoposed loading , unloading and storage of lwaber on the site i8' conlsisteut with the t ity's General Plan which permits is'd t*181 use* of this types o l,, . site plan dated rewired September 18, 1988t shall be rn restwtti,t to depict the #ol lc"ing serif Icationts: 4. Lumber stack areas si►all be limited to 80 by 180 feseat with 18 fbot spacing an all sides of each lumber stack. b, turning radiup for fire lanes shall be designed to Fire ,., Depart mat 206cffications. All gatos shall open to full width with no center pasts . d� Paved OuVE roe an All fire lanes and veahicula)e travel lanes. 2. Prior to urea of the lease area for lumber storage, true applicant shall obtain a Certificates to Operates. h' ! y t 4,0 !6 Te `. . Prior to issuance of a Certificate to Operate, the applicant shall 000PIT with the following items : a. Two (s) fire hydrants see required and shall be installed sub eat to Fire Department approval of iocatioa wits a mxnieulm water flow of five thousand (5, 000) gallons per min to b. A paved surftce shall be provided for the fJ re lanes and vehicular travel lane$ which will be capable of supporting fire apparatus subject to the spprova: of the Fire Department, Comm city Development and Public Works Department. !.,.. a gist toot high fence shall be provided around the storage site. d. Cedar Avenue improvements per Public Works standards shall. be completed. e. " Smoking" signs shall be posted inside the storage area. f . A hire Department permit shall be issued for this storage facility upon completion and compliance of all Firer Department requirements . g. Applicant and/or property owner. skull submit a signed and ti'•' . notsrized irrevocable offer to dedicate truck access for industrial uses abutting the lease area . A copy of the l+tgal instrument shall be approved by theCity Attorney as tb form and content. A copy shall be filed with the Department of community Development. 4. Maxim height for lumber stacks shall be sixteen (16) feet. M• N Tire apparatus access shall be provided from the south through -� the e* leg Randall. Lumber Co . facility. V ( o, The opor*tion shall comply with all applicable provisions of the funtington Roach Ordinance Code, Building Division, Devortmant of public Works and Fire Department. ;, ! 7. 400004 to and',-fros Cedar Avenue and Palmdale Street to the subject site shall be limited to emergency access only. general the to en'd. Too least arts shall not be a r. P g public for retail salon* 4. The proposed use *hall be restricted to unloading and lauding of railroad cards and storage of lumber . lot Tim period of Conditional Use permit No. 55-23 shall be for a period of five (5) years from approval date. 11. The Planning Commission reserves the right to revoke CarAitional Use Permit No. 88- 23 if any violation of these ` widitious or the Huntington heath Ordinance Code occurs . At.,. a- .1 C r C-i iTt ems. ,ce= sir fit, K� es-23Z1rML_�►-T10V Nd � IUTiyE D �. � � ...� AWA ` M=x2_ ,I. 1999, _PLANK I DIn COMMr§A UM + APPIP1CANT s RAMW . LUMBZR Cu. 00k November It J9$Gv the Plannialp Commission continued Conditional +' "fit PC $8-35 at the appl Kenya request . Conditional Use a '{ t h -23 to a ro"Ost by itaridall Lumber Co. to utilise e act* site obiab is mma#: by the Southern pacific Railroad to ekia ,� toad and store lumber products for a period of five ( 5) arpurousat to Section 0631• , of the `+ *tington beach Ordinance Code. d applicant is requesting that the Cedar Avenue alley located adjacent to proposed storage area be opened up to heavy truck ' .,.: traffic. Staff stags not support the request . The Cedar Avenue alley is not adequate for heavy truck traffic and should remain as an worvemmaccess only. The City Rngineer, Planning staff , the Fire Deparrtawent and both abutting property owners to the ill* are opposed to opening up Ceder Avenue alley to heavy truck traffic. Also, staff Is still recot nding that the applicant provids an irrevocabler otter to access across the subject lease area. Although the applio*nt , dipposes the requirement, staff fools that the r Apr�oal access will alleviate. potential traffic impacts to public Woott and provide better open '-.ional management to industrial users 'that rely an the railroad ror shipping of bulk lumber products. -- shaft r*00ftiews that the Planning CommLsxion approve Negative IV lo�ritiloo' . 09 -24 and CondAtional Use Permit No. 86-33 with the faiva ,s Axed Esau tipris of approval as suggested 'in the November i, xS na;� i Caisafon staff 3r+6port. Roy picksOno pso. , Attorney for Southern pacific Transportation, *toted his *ppostition to condition 3.9 requiring irrevocable scares. He sold this . tic a railroad right of stay and against the 4 Poblic utilities corer&scion to require access . He said the offer erould not .occvmplish`,what staff was trying to resolve. He also said that the railroad (property owner) did not. sign they application . pill Randall, applicant, said if he is required to access he should not have to allow others to use his property, He further stated he only Manus Ingress on Cedar Avenue, with egress thr,7ugh the main yard and out Canto Gotharel. He fe*la the circuaatlOn Will not creaMte heavy truck traffic* He sold he has b trucks a day and cannot grunt access for others to use. �. +� r Y'. PC minutes 13rsres a JJJ : ; os� Hsl� c Mi ilisaa asked staff the width of the alley and the standard irdquited width of an 4110lr. atatf replied the alley was 30 ,; • feet 894 the standrtd was s0 last. Lei Xweas, Public lWorka, atate6 if other trucks war* going to use he old prefer widenInG the 01 ieY. la¢I ; fire e. toent, sold he would like to sow Cedar �#OM'W *""to is life GAtrence aae.9rs only. `t. rs �rteie, 14e01 Mallet, asked that his letter doted Qcx ober 251 19e8, becos%, port of the record. He said that Condition ,. , XO# 7 would coo" the Closure of Ideal Pallet and that hio wain f�rtrspce is adjacent le. the 811ey4 at �nsd ak. oM V o! business next to Cedar Avenue, said he �;.. ��• daestdd 16 feet of his property to the alley for fire access . no 41 ftEthor waid that the street is not improved and that if it beccwas y, a strort her wants parking spaces for his trucks. Thate wet$ AND other persons present to speak for or agvinst the ` rotoest the pUbllc hearing was closed. ►. :f NNSW X Hit CATS 0 S im BY LZIP'VIQ, TO "PEpYS r lIlORU MM VMWT 00. 68-23 AM MG&T 11 ONCLMTXOR NO. 38-240 9211 Vt*DIVR'is AIM CONDITIONS OF APMVAL.- AT THE VOL,�AWXNG AMU $latest Millium, Livengood, Leipzig, Ortopes Higgins. � daus�uig�non d� : bye 11vemas loon* k to' Thlo tabliabMent, eaiutenance, and operation of the proposed goadia as��►o+rding and storage of lumber products for � are w 11 riot be datrirrental too �� '' a• IU general weltare of persons residing or wor kilo in the -, ;� vldfwf art b. xo *tr and fo`'rov+s"nts in the vicinity of such use or building, I 2 . Utixlsing , the site tat loodinj, unloading and storage of lumber i br Maradsll Lunber one, providing future ancoss for too adjacent iaduatri l uses through the proposed atorago area will 611MUOte poteetial lacireased vehicular impacts on local .t s,• streets &Ad attorials, . v Now rVC x1butes I2/66ftd s WPM 17 w ', 3 . Vrav , Arsg paving along the designated roadway portion of the site 411 provide adequate support for fire apparatus and adc(� Late 'uect co,,�trol . 4 . The propose, ? loatzing , unloading aiid storage of lumber on the site it con. - ;stent with the City' s General Plan which permits industrial of this type. ' 1 . The site pv an dated received September 28, 19M small be revised 4,&Z resubmitted to depict the following modifications : a . Lumbor stack areas shall be limited to 50 by 150 feet with 15 feet spacing on all sides of each lumber stack. b. Turning radius for Zire lanes shall to designed to Fire Department specifications ,, All dates shall open to full width frith uo center posts . d . Paved surface on all fire lanes and vehicular travel lanes . 2 . prior to use of the lease area for lumber storage, the applicant shall obtain a Certificate to Operate. 2 . prior to issuence of a Certificate to ope ate, the applican': shall compig with the following items : a . Two (2) fire hyds_ntsa sre required and shall be installed subject to Fire Department approval of location with a minimum water flow of five thousand (5, 000) gaXlons peg' minute. b. A paved surface shall be prov idad for the fire lanes and vehicular travel loner which wJ ll, be capable of suppottinq fire apparatus subject to the approval of the Fire Department, Community Development and Public Works Department . c . A liar foot high fence shall be provided around th* storage site. d . Cedar Avenue improvements per Public; Worrks .f tandards shall be completed. e. ONo Wooking" signs shall be posted insldo the storage Area . f . A Fire Dopawrtmeut perwit shall bw issued for this storage facility upon complotibn and compliance of all Fire Department requireaaants. =- IIL2/6/88 � M -4- (1•005d) g . Applicant and/or property owner shall submit a signed and notsx;•sed i x revocable offer to dedicate truck access for indus!.rial uses abutting the lease area . A copy of the ►agal instrument shall be approved by the City Attorney as to form and content . A copy shall be filed with the �- Department of Com4u+nity Development . 4 . Maairmum height for l,umbor stacks shall be sixteen ( 16) feet . 5 . Fire apparatus eiccons shall be provided from the south through they existing Randall Lumber Co . facility. b . Tho operation shall comply with all applicable provisions of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Coda, Building Division, tlep.)rtment of public Works and Fire Department . 7. Access to and fence Cedar .Avenue and Palmdale Street to the subject site shall be limited to emergency access only. S. The 7-ease area shall not be open to the general public for retail sales . 9 . The proposed use shall be restricted to unloading and loading of railroad cards and storage of lumber . lo. Time period of Conditional Use Permit No. 88-23 shall be for a period of five (5) years from approval date . 11 . The Planning Commission reserves the right to revoke � -- Conditional time permit no . 88-23 if any violation of these conditions or the Kuntington Beach Ordinance Code occurs . -3.g APP FHP, INC. Conditional Use it Noe 88-30 is a request P, inc . to expand anroliment and hour operation at their Ling Senior Madical :enter . The facility ocated within tail, shopping center, and was originally approv the P ng Commission on February 11-' , 1887 , The applicant has requests t ditional Vse permit go. 88-30 be continued to the Jant,or 1989 P ing Comission meeting. The applicant requires ed oaal tium to ile information requested fir the Planning Cc Sion* z taf! r » • the Planning Comission continue itionel use 88-38 to January MY 2988. PC minutes 12/6/9$ 0.5- (1885d) � k; s h � nM• R huntington beach Opartment of community developrront ff REPORT TO: Planning Commission IrROK: Community Development DATE: December 6, 1988 SUBJECT: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 88-23/NEGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 88-24 (CONTIMIED FROM NOVEMBER 1 , 1988 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING) ARELIC M: Randall Lumber Co. D TA Z ACCEPTED: 17332 dothard Street 'Tuly 15 , 1988 Hunt . Beach, Chi 92647 KUM QCE86I NG D=: � gA02zj= Southern Pacific Railroad Waived by applicant QMR: 610 South Main Street j Lost Angeles, CA 90014 Y=: MI (General Industrl ai) RROURST: 10 allow unloading , load ing and storage of lumber GENERAL M?,j: General products for a maximum of Industrial 8 *ears on leased property. UISTING SSE: Common ION: Southern Pacific right-of- loading ana unloading area . way on the west side of railroad tracks located at a.JEAGE: 1 . 25 acres the eastern terminus of Cedar Avenue (approximately 600 feet east of the inter- section of Gothard Street and C,%Aar Avenue) . 1"0 SUGGE R ACT IOV.: Approve Negative Declaration :Yo . 88-24 and Conditionsl Use Permit No. 8e-33 with findings and conditions of approval . On Novemter 11 1986, the planning Coi=ission continued Conditional Use Permit No. 88-23 at the applicant' s request. Conditional Use Permit No', 68-•23 is a request b7 rcandali Lumber Co. to utilize a 1.35 acre ,,dice which is owned by the Southern Pecific Railroad to unload, lord rnd store lumber products for a period of fide (5) ` ! years pursusat to Section 9631, :81porary, fitseraSe Yards , of the Huntington 8e#ari Ordinance Code. —\to jP If,a .100 r The applicant in requesting that the Cedar Avenue alley located adjacent to proposed storage area be opened up to heavy truck traffic . Staff does not support the request . The Cedar ,Aver.je alley is not adequof:e for heavy truck traffic and should remain as an eatergency accean only. The City Engineer , Planning staff , the Fire Depa tntent €nd both abutting property owners to the alley are opposed to opening up Cedar Avenue alley to heavy truck traff3.e. Also, staff is still recoornending that the applicant provide arL irrevocable offer to acLI3sa across the subject lease area . Although the applicant opposes the requirement, staff feels that the reciprocal access will alleviate potential traffic impacts to public strRets and provide hetter operational management to industrial f risers that rely on the railroad for shipping of bulk lumber products . NDATIDN i Staff recommends that the Planning Commission approve Negative Declaration No. 130--24 and Conditicnal Use Permit No . 88-3 with the findings and conditions of approval as suggested in the November 1, 1983 Planning Commission .staff report . 1 . November 1, 1986 Staff Report . I I ! : Stott Report - 12l6/88 -Z- ( 1663d) '�t14'�tiM��.4i�slAi3:?'!in.�1�y'+N.; ' ,r,+v'.wn•, w� ..antington beech dfpartrhdoic of community develoornent _EPffAf f O TO: Planninq Coamnission noM: Community [development. DATE: November 1, 1988 SUBJECT: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 84-23/NBG;.TI'VE DECLARATION NO. 8$-24 ,(CONTINUnD FROM OCTOBER 4 , 1988 PLANNING COMISSIOid MEETING) Randall Lung Co . DATE �'ED: 17332 aotherd Street July 150 1988 Hunt . Beach, CA 52647 PIANOSTORY 9ROC$9§I39 D=: norm= Boutherri Pscifi:c Railroad Waived by applicant MAWR: 510 South Main Street Los Angeles , CA 90014 ,& : Ml (General Industrial) To allow unloading , load- ing and storags of lumber ZENERAL PLAID: General products for S maziAUM of Industrial 5 yews on leased property. EXISTIM Md: COMMOn ION: Southern: Pacific right-of- leading and unloading area . way on the west side of railroad tr&cks located at jjCRE=: 3, . 25 acres the eastern terminus of Cedar Avenue (dpprozimately 600 feet east of the inter- section of Gothard Street and Cedar Avenue) . ). . J �i1i41�S 1 ice, liLT,:li�i i Approve 'Negative De^.larati6n No . 88--24 and Conditional Use Permit No . 88-23 with findings a&-Ad conditions of sWOr.o'►a 1 . 2 __Q gE EM&L r NrQRI4A IOi1: On ActoLee 4, 1988s the planning Comair,sion .continued Conditional Urge Permit No. 88-23 at the a0plicant ' b re4uest : Conditional U!Ee b_.rxait No.' 88-23 to a request by Rent',A1 Lumber Co . to utilize e 2 .28 act* site which to ownad by the Southern pacific Railroad to unload, load and store lumber products ifok a period of five (5) rears Pursuant, to Section 9631# Xemeorary Btaraaa Yarda, of the Runtington Reach Ordinance Code. L-M.- Aft �,�aL1.1?.::Yil ll�arll�'`. Jii'i�F.'.• .1....'_:..:d_!LitS1�' .. _.. ._ - _ _.__.___. .. .._. _ mar ao.. The staff report dated October 4 , 1988 (Attachment 4) , coatains the i staff analysis of Randall Lumber ' s original request for permission to use a "team track" area for their exclusive use for temporary loading, unloading and stor ,.ge of lumber products . The applicant has reviewed staff ' s ri,commended conditions of approval and has in6icatad that: the condition requiring an irrrevocabl3 offer to dedicate access is a disadvaittage to his proposed operation (Attachment 1) . Also, the applicant has requested that ingress and egress to Cedar Avenue be open to heavy truck traffic . The following is a discussion regarding the applicant ' s concerns. 21rarec ble Df far for AccgX1 $toff is recormnding that Randall Lumber provide an irrevocable offer to dedicate access for cbutting industrial users adjacent to the leaks arse for use of the rail line. Thi^ requirement is reflected in Condition No . 3 .g . 8taV has maintained that the le3ge area that Randall Lumber Co . desires to use for the temporary unloading and loading of railroad cars and z %orfige of lumber should be available for other industrial users in order to alleviate traffic impacts on public streets . This condition mould not rreclude Southern Pacific Railroad from antering itito future lease agreements with abutting industrial users . To support the requirement of an irrevocable offer to dedicate access, an access agreement exists between ideal Pallet Co . and the James Lumber Co . lease area , immediately north of the proposed Randall Lumber lease area . James Lumber Co . was granLad the ' temporary use of a portion of the "team trae,;k" area in 1986 , As a result r,f the City' s approval , James Lumber Co . provided access over the &rob for ideal Pallet Co . (Attachment 2) . This is the same type of offer for access that condition No. 3 . b would require:. IhroUgh TKaf fic �an QdAr &,vanee Randall Lumber Co . is requesting that Condition No. 7, regarding � access from Cedar Avenue, be modified to allow heavy truck traffic. Staff does not recommend t►lat Cedar Avenue be used for ingrciss an4 egress for heavy truck traffic. Cedar Avenue cinnection between Palmdale Street and the lease area was originally designed as an alley. Staff rncowwnds that Conditio No. 7 remain as composed and that the Cedar Avenues ingress +end t :press adjacent to the Randall Lumbar Co. lease area be restricted to emergency access only. This in a r'wcounndation of the Planning Division, the fire Departrmeat and the Department of Public Plorka . further, a memo from the City Engineer (Attachmwnt 3) states that Cedar Avenue and local streets in tho IM0016te Vie-laity veto intended to serve a small +ndustrial ..'subdivision and not a lumber yard. r Staff Report 11r1r88 (1528d) i "qw t `,1 RECd �I4DAT Staff recommends that the Planning Commission approvs Negative Declaration No . 68- 24 and Conditional Use permit No . 98--23 with the following findings and conditions of approval : 1 . The est+ablishmant, maintenance and operation of the proposed temporary loading, unloading and storage of lumber products for five - 3) veare will not be detrimental to : a . The general welfare o.f persons residing or working in the 's vicinity; b. Property and improvements in the vicinity of su:-h use or building . 1 . Utilizing the vita for loading, unloading and storage of lumber by Randall Lumber and providing future access for the adjacent industrial uses through the proposed storage area will eliminate potential increased vehicular impacts on local streets and arterials . 3 . Providing paving along the designated roadway portion of the site will provide adequate support for fire apparatus and adequate dust control . 4 . The proposed loading, unloading and storage of lumber on the site is consis-*:ent ::ith the City' s General Plan which, permits industrial uses of this type. CQNDXTIQI13 OF APPBQM: 1 . The site plan dates received Septomber 28 , 1988, shall be revioed and resubmitted to depint the following modifications: a . Lumber stack areas shall be limited to 50 by 150 feet with 15 feet spacing on all sides of each lumber stack. b. Turning radius for firn 'laries shall be designed to Fire Department specifications . 1 C. All gates shall open to full width with no center posts . d. Paved surface on all fins lanes and vehicular travel lanes . 3 . Prioc to use of tle lease area for lumber storage, the +applicant rhell obtain a Certificate to Operate. Stiff Report - 11/1/88 -3- t 1528d) a , i 17 madh d•� 3 . Prior to issuance of a Certificate to Operate, the applicant shall comply with Lhe following items : a . Two (2) fire hydrants are required and shall be installed subject to Fire Department approval of locatioh with a minimum water flow of five thousand (5, 000) gallons per minute . b. A paved sur..'ace shall be provided for the fire lanes and vehicular trbvel lanes which will be capable of supporting firo apparoLus subject to the approval of the Fire k Department, Community development an:," Public Works Department . c. A six foot high fence shall be provided around the storage site. d . Cedar Avenue improvements per Public Works standards shall be completed . a . "No Smoking" signs shall be posted inside the storage area . f . A Fire Department permit shall be issued for this 6torage facility upon completion and compliance of all Fire j Department, requirements . g . Applicant and/or property owner shall submit a signed and notarized irrevocabla offer to dedicate access for industrial uses abutting the lease area . A copy of the legal instrument shall be approved by the City Attorney as to form and content. A copy shall be filed with the Department of L-ommunity Development . 4 . Haviamm height for lumber stacks shall, be sixteen (16) feet . 5 . Fire aparatus across shall be provided from the south through the existing Randall Lumber Co . facility. 6 . The operation shall comply with all applicable provisions of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, SuiVing Division, Department of Public Works and Fire Department . 7 . Access to and from Cedar Avenue and Pa'mdale Street to the suoject site shall be limited to emergency access only. 8 . The 'lease area shall not be open to the yanearal public for retail sales . 9 . The proposed use shall be restricted to unloading and loading Of r&lltOad cards and storage of lumber . 1 , staff Rapa j rt 11 110 --a- �� . 1.0 . Time period of Conditional Use Permit No. 88-23 shall be for a period of five ;5) years from approval. dato . 11 . The planning Cosioisslon reserves the right to revoke Conditional Use Permit No . 88-23 if any violation of these conditions or the Huntington Bench ordinance Code occurs . 4 . 9 ALIZIRMAMIYE ACT ION: The Planning Commission may modify Conditional Use Permit No . 88-23 or deny with fkndings. 1. Letter from applicant dated October 7 , 1908 2. Copy of access agreement between James Lauer Co. and Ideal Pallet Co . doxod Match 31, 1986 3 . Now from City Rngineer dated October 12, 1988 4 . Staff report dated October 4, 19e8 dH:RL.F: k 1 a 52ft 41 1 � �.*Awl Icy , vl�' 17'1At i��-d5�i3 17334 00TNAai2 AT. ' NtJUTWUTUM AEACM. CALIFORNIA OL ,y � IT'Ii1l� ddd-d5s0 i, ` OCTOBER 71 1SS88 f � ICI&TOR OF CtMUNITY DEVELOPKMiT MWIII►MIll BEACH PLANNING COMESION P.O. box 190 . IIO)NIINGTON BEACH, CALIF. 92648 ATTN: MW ADAKS AUB_tECT: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT N098-23 DSAR SIR: RANDALL LUMBER WISHES TO '.,'ATVE THE MANDATORY VROCE;; NG DATE. RANDALL LUMBER 19 REQbESTING A CONTINUANCE OF THE CONDIT+ONAL USE PELMIT NO 88-I3 UNTIL THE NFIT MEETING DATE, SOVEMBER 1ST. IN AEFSWOICE TO CONDITION NO 3 ITEM C, PAGE 4, FAMDALL LUMBER ;S NOT IN AGREE- NOT TO DEDICATE ACCESS FOR FUTURE XNDUSTRIAL USES ABUTTING TO THE LEASE AREA. BY HAYING OTHER BUSINESS ESTABLISHKENTw ATTEMPTING TO 'ISE PART OF THIS "M AND RAIL ,FOOTAGE WOULD PROVE TO BE A DISADVAN'TAGEs TO OUR OPERATION, BRINGING #,BOUT DISRUPTION AND AN ADVERSE EFFECT. IT IS NOT IN KEEPING WITH OUR ' PURPOSE I1�iTF:NDED, UNLOADING AND MOVING OUd haTERIAL. IN ADDITION, FOR SECURITY REASONS, THIS WOULD P16YE TO BE A DISADVAbITAGE FOR US. IN REVERENCE TO CONDITION NO 7 LIMITING ACCESS TO F14ERGENC-1 USE ONLY, RAWA 1Tj.L LUNDISR AMUESTS THIS TO tiL CHANGED TO INCLUDE VEHICLES OF XANDALL LUXBn COMPANY ENTERING ON CEDAR AVE. NOT ALL OF OUR VEHICLES WOULD USC THIS ACCESS AND WOULD BE USED ON % LIMITED EHTERMITTANT BASIS. THIS SRO= I78CMWE THE INCONVENTANCE OF THE PIESENT BOTTLENECXED TRAFFIC CONDITION, f1, WW APPAWT AT OOR NAtN ENTRANCE ON GOTHARD ST. IN ADDITION TO THIS { AMIC,ATION, WE WOM LIES TO MTIC*o THAT PSREAPS IPALIMALE STRIET, FROM � r'. WAIM TO CEDAR AVE CWW ES CONSIDER::D IN CARRYING SOW OF THE TRAFFIC � Lt1AI► EAU TW ALL TRAMC CONKING OM GOS'!lW STARES'. W," L1NQ Z& WISHES Td MNK THE 9TA" OF TRZ PLANNING OCWISSXON FOR THE *MtOmTuw or IF APON OM109M OMITIONS �+�► m, co in* 7 . t • w p ty I f •.. JA E LUMBER COB 1?311 NICHOL S STREET it R.O. EOX 1IN HUNTINGTOV BEACH, CA 92547 • (7i4) 947.851" RE; IP.REVOCA1LE ACFEEMES'i BETWEEN JAMES P_9D IDEAL Jim Harrington, awnet of J%smes Lumber Company , on the one hsrJ, Joirtly referred to as (Jaime #) utid Mal Meernalsteia, president and owner of Idaal pallet Systems, Inc. , on tie other hand, jointly referred to as (Ideal) do hereby agree that James ` sh411 grant to ideal, full, complete and unlimited arciias, for Ideal' s trucks and trucks making dsliverloo to and from Ideal's yard, north to Warner Avenue &nd South from Warner Avenue to Ideal' s backyard , through the two existing 43ck gates, for the purpose of ingress and sgress , Throughout the length of the 100 foot vide by 1,000 foot long parcel of land contained in block 10, of block "V, of the town of Wintorsbuzg, Assessors 11ap. bock 111, Page 02, of the County of Orange, State of I Callfornia, known as the Suutheru Pacific Public Team Track, Wi.ntersburg, California. Sec Photo-copy of mar crouched. In considoration of the above rights, Ideal agrees to co-operate and assist James � with the purposed Mans to obtain a Conditional Use Permit , from the city of Huntington Beach so chat Jaime r can receive and unload rail-care of lumber and store its luriber on the above described site, where Ideal assertr its easement j rights. James any! Ideal also agree that .Tames will allow all rail-tars of lumbers destined for Ideal, to be spotted on its cracks, at the above mentioned described bit*, Which is leased to him, by the Southern Pacific Transportation Company, and agraes to sasist, whenever possible, in the unloading of spotted rail-cars of lumber be- longing to Ida&. This agreement was bntesred Into, by both parties, on Marc? 31, 1i86. AgrAnd to by: Mel N:raield t*in d ny by .film iiiarririgto& Mat Mo rmel a teein by Ideal �- lit Syst*as s lr O o 4 .h y � ......•r.Y�.�• ■raw•+._.... .�.■/■.w.w.-tea...w,.w,.1�.�•r....�. 7 ■ .�.,.. ...■. . .. ..f�.. .r 4r f... :. oob , . , du WN •• " r f w� v ' R .411 .■ OA dtw ... . eM_ . .W. . __ i..i.... I �...•r..__■.-. t _ A b M •��. l r , ■ M � QED/�i 7; /1►�MN� + � +� j �+ + «•iits t 64 � � WI�NQ•A " Ie rllq�y+/ E�led#* Id 0. is • 1 . I a .� t 4 ; i rod • -+ ,��h Y AKIN lab Lam✓.�... OD • ' ', • .ti e . •�, a .armIk • ••ILI i � _+•.♦ •ram■•,. • t asIb ! N . M err •• '� ,• 00ib • - JR— .....nw• rr.- (_1 ' '"• CfP�N t wry �, w r y ,•• •.— ' T�rat T.•.{ .M.r� • y« K • r �► = ( 91 A s N �• `� : 4 r 1 r 1 � 7f;*MOW. i i -4 INTER-DEPAF'fMENT COMMUNICATION To Bob Franklin From Los Evans Asseclato Piarineew City Engineer guff; Randall Lumber - Conditional date October 12, 1988 Uses Permit 88-23 6; F3o69 we fool thgt condition number 7 limiting access to thi lumber yard from Avenue makes s lot of sense. Cedar .Avenue was never intended for lumber trucks or any twovy traffic. L dit turns onto Cedar Avenue from Gothard 5tre.4 would probably Increase If Ceder i?venue baceme+ an alte.nate access. Traffic on Palme+Ala aad Gain met also increase. These street* were Intended to se: ve a small industr!al bUbdivision rind noL a ,o:rnber yard. It Pandall Lumber cannot provide Internal circulation to hrrve• that expanded site, w:j not- encourage the use of City strseets as a aubatitute:. LE:dw O • k itj A I huntington heach d6partmen., of carnor_unity devosopmwnt E P 0 R T., TO, Planning Commi sNion rRON; romeu n i t y De w e 1 o PA1a n r DATE: October 4 , 19 P,8 SUBJECT ., CONDIT10HAL USE PERMIT NO . 88- 23/ ixiGATIVE DECLARATION NO. 8 8--s"4 (CONT 1 NLMD FROM 8I PTEMB t 7, 1 g 8 8 PLANNING COMMISSION MSETIVU) : Randla l l Lumber Co . 17,332 Goth+ard stream July 15 , 1908 Wit . beach, CA 92647 "ANDAMaY P2OCEB&jIIt .D : Southern Pacific Railroad Saptember 15 , 610 South Nair: Street I.os Angelev , CA 90014 JONZ: H1 (General Ir�duatrial) hA01113T To allow unloading, load'- inq and storage of lumbar ARAL PLC: General products for a Maximum of Industrial 5 yuarac on leaned property. WIO M: Cortmn lg l: Southern: Pacific right-of- loading and unloading area. wary on the wrest side of railroad tracks located at AQUINQ,$: 1 . 25 acres the eastern terminus of Cedar Avenue. 'approximately Ego feet east of the inter- i section of Gothard Street and Cedar Avenue) . Approve Negative: DeClaration No . 88-24 and Conditional Use Permit No . 69-23 with findings and conditions of approval . �.,,,�Sa�� x'�..3�1 CFx1KAT I flI� : • At the !applicant ' a request , this item was continued from the September 7, 1988 Planning Commission meeting in order for the applicant to revise, the site plan and discuss the suggested conditions of approval . Conditional Use Permit No . 88-23 in a request by Randall Lwaber Cad to utilise a 1 . 25 acre site which is owned by the Southern Pacific Rat licoad to unload, load and store lumber products for t period of five ( !) years pursuant to section 9631, T nZAry 1ft6g&qg „a,QL• of the Kuntington Beach Ordinance Code. ZWTVI�j .w Z Pursuant to t,ae environmental regu] atians in eaf fe ,--t at this time, -� the Department of Community Development punted dr;ixt Negative Declaration No. 88--24 for ten days , and no c omment:s , either verbal or written were rec.,Aved . The staff , in its initial study of the project , ham recommended that. a negative declaration be, issuer]. Prior to any action on Conditional Use Permit No . 88-23, it is necessary for the rlanningl Commission to review Lrid act on Negative Declaration No . 88-24 . ` �a0 lNBUEB In the staff report; dated September 7 , 1988 , staff re-iommended that an existing business, Ideal Pallet Co . , be provid ad access across Randall Lumber loans area . Staff assumed that the lease area wns a "team track" area which should be made available to all industrial users which are located adjacent to the pzopose'►d lease area . Can September 14 , 19361 staff met with a repromean: ative of the Southern Pacific Ra,ilrodel Co . and the applicant . At the meeting , staff received documentatj�n f*!& • a rublic Utilities Commission hearing whereby the Southern Pacific Railroad Co . is not required to provido a leeass area to Ideal Pallet: . In fact , the Put.ic Utilities � Commission determined that the Southern pacific Railroad discontinued the Warner Avenue public team track when it leaned a major portion of the right of way to James Lumber (see Attachment 2, page 21, No. 6) . i Therefore, staff has revised the suggested conditions of approval to require they applicant to provide future access to the railway subject to future Southern Pacific Railroad leare agreements with stertounding industrial uses . W�l Staff reco►tmendp that the Planning Commission approve Negative Declaration No . 88-24 and Conditional Ilse permit No . 88-23 with the following findings and conditifins of approval : . .ROM 1 , The eatablitehment , maintenance and operation of the proposed temporary loading, unloading and storage of lumber products for five! (5) years will not be detrimental to: a . The general welfarr of persona residinq or working in the. vicin'..}Y.• b. Property And improvements its the vicinity of such use or building. • oe 4ta9!' RM)PO:'t, - 10/4/88 -2- (13786) jj . f� M 2 . Utilizing the sitp for loadirig, unloading anI storage of lur&)er by Randall Lumber and providing future, access for the adjacent industrial uses through the proposed storage ar6s will eliminate potential increased vehicular impacts o:. loc&l streets and arterials . 3 . Pr >viding paving along the designated roadwal► portion of the site will, provide adegs�akte support for fire -;ipasratus and ` adequate duat control . I 4 . The proposed loading, unloading and st-orags of lumber on they site is consistent with the City' s Genera! Flan which permits industrial saes of this type . 1. The site plash dated resceivad Sept,4mber 28 , 1988, shall bo revised and resubmitted to depict the following modifications : a . Lumber stack areas shall he limited to 50 by 1.50 feet with h 15 feet spacing on all aides of each lumber stack.. b. Turning radius for fire lanes shall be designed to Fire 1:epasrtment specifications . c . All gates shall open to full width with no cents.- posts . r... el. Paved s!irface on all fire lanes and vehicular travLl hares . � 2 . Prior to use of the leaPe area for lumber storage, the � applicant shall obtai.r, a Certificate to Operate . 3 . Prior to issuance of a Certificate to Operate, the applicant shall comply with the following items : a . Two (2) fire hydrants are required and shall be installed subject to Fire Dopartment approval of location with a minimun Water flow of five, thousand (5 , 40O) gallons per minute. b. A paved surface shall be provided for the fire lames And vehicular travel lames which frill be capable of supporting fire apparatus subject to the approval of the Fires Department, Cot munity Development and Public Worts Department . c, A six toot high fence shall be provided around the storage site. d. Cedar Avenue improvements per Public Works stur'lards shalt ,be completed. ea. "He. Bftkiaq" signs shall be posted inside the storage $M. (1376 �4� n R 1 f� . A ?ire Depnrtment permit shall be issued for this storage facility apon completion alle. uompliance of all Flre Department reguiremebnla . �.- �i . Applicattt and/or property ownor shall submit a signed and notarized irrevocable offer to dedicate access for future ` Industarisi uses abutt .ng the lease area . A. copy of the legal instrument: shdl ' be approved by the City Attorney as - t to form and content . Acopy shall be filed with tho !^) department of Connunity Davelopmert . 4 . Mazimu-1 heigbt for li mbor Mt.ack:: shell be sixteen ( 1.5) feet . 5. Fire apparatus access shall be providcmd from th6 south through the existing Randall Lumber Co . facility. 6 . The operation shall. comply with all P-pplicabl.e provisions of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, Building Division, Department of Public Works and Fire Department . 7 . Access from Cedar kvenue shall be limiteA to emergency access only. i S . The lumber storage yard shall not he open to the general public For retail sales . 9 . The proposed use shall be restricted to unloading , leading and storage of lumber . 10 . Time period of Conditional Use Permit No . 88-23 shall be for a period o� five (5) years from approval date . 11 , The Planning Comrni ssi.on reserves the right to revoke Conditional Use permit No . 88-23 if any violation of these conditions or the Huntington leach Ordinance Code occurs . 6 . 0 ALTERNATIVE jACT10N: The Planning Commission may modify Conditional ;)se permit No. 89--23 or deny with findings . AT CKN : 1 . Revised sit3 plan date received September 28 , 2988 2 . Vicinity map 3 . Letter from Southern Pacific Railroad dated September 1.5, 1988 4 . Public Utilities Commission decision report S . Letter from ideal Pallet Co . dated September 1 , 1968 S . Staff Report dated September 7, 1988 8N:Mr: ka& moo state x9port 10/e/8e (1376d) 1 '' . ':1 ',.I ff �, 'h Y 'T, � i,/; Ira• 9 Y {� .. .. 1 � J ` •.Sf •, lT � � url�i�r� ,y�r ,.� t�J 1� t •AN„1'Rt wM�MGM� lr rgirlr.•��•.� dw 1 { , f• 1 } ��irli �, _ •.1 • I 1� pip • �� •'1'/P . - N • 4 r' 'fir♦ a wwr•�r �f.tew.A f a r r` Tt 1y y Y�• � f Jo WARNER AVE. . LAO `^ CAIN AVE. r I 1 1 oc w w W CEDAR AVE. �-- IDEAL PALLET Co. JAMES LUMBER CO. NORTH ,�Air1ES LUMBER CO. F�IW af�Ll LUMBER CO"; 0 ac t F- ra c� �I i i• A, I 1 �, • V,10 F •i, . M v"t s a ' 1 ROY C. D ICICSON , ES+,;,7. �;�+ CO X, DICKSON , ETCH & WORL8YA. 2 417 South Hill Street, Suit,;.- 650 � Lou Angeles , CA 90013-1121 � ! 311 (213) 629-6448 / J }} Att.orneya for owner 6 7 d BEFORE THE CITY COUNCIL ` 9 OF THE CITY oF HUNTINGTON BEA IH 10 11 RANDALL LUMBER C 014PANY AND ) APPEAL FROM DECISION OF SOUTHERN PACIFIC TRANSPORTATION j HUNTINGTON BEACH PLANNING 12 COMPANY, a Delaware corporation , ) COMMISSION RE CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL OF CONDITIONAL 13 Applicant and owner, ) USE PERMIT NO. 8 3-2 3 j 14 Vs . ) 15 HUNTINGTON BEACH PLANNING ) COMMISSION, ) 16 ) Cotnmis:3ion . ) 17 ) 19 INTRODUCTION 20 Southern Pacific: Transportation Company ( "Southern 21 Pacific") appeals the Decision of the F. ntington Beach Planning 22 Commission ("Co mission" ) ,' dated December 9, 1988 , to impose 23 certain conditions on its approval of Randall Lumber. Company ' s � 24 ("Randall Lumber" ) Application for Conditional. Use Permit No. 25 88-23 (^Permit" ) . The Farmit ,is a request by Randall Lumber 24 to utilize a 1 . 25 acre site ("Subject Area" ) it leased from 27 Southern Paci:ic to unload, load and store lumber products for $8 a period of S years . It should be noted that this lumber is ( n OV Ndh ;" _ Y ,'0 i' r ,4 1 1 ` 1 shipped Statewi..de . The Subject Area Is operating railroad ric►ht 2 of way and ie locited can thy- west s,ido of Southern Pacific: ' s 3 railroad cracks located at: the eastrc.r•n terminus of Cedar Avenue , 4 approximately 604 teat east of the intersection of Gothard St:r.get 5 and Ceder Avenue . A4tac:hed here-to as &xhibi t A. is a drawing► 6 not the scale , indicating the location of the: Px%�perry in the 7 shaded ;r•ea . TheRuntington saac:h De.par•tment. of Ccmmunity Development ( "Staffs' ) submitted a Staff Report, dated October 4 , 1988 , to 10 the Commission reco-. mending that the Commission approve the 11 Permit and Neganive Decl.ax:ticn No. 88-24 conditioned upon, 12 inter a1ia , Randall Lumber providing an irrevocable offer to f 13 dedicate 3ccesc across Southern Pacif:ic ' s right of way to abutting 14 industrial users adjacent to the leased area for use of the 15 rail line. This requirement .is reflected in Condition No. 3 . g 16 of the Staff Report. i 17 The. Staff maintained that the Subject Area that: Randall 18 Lumber desires to use for the temporary unloading and loading 14 of railroad cars and storage 7)f I=ber should be available for 2� other industrial users in order to alleviate traffic impacts 21 on public streets. As stated herei.nabove:, on December 9 , 1988 , 22 the Commission accepted the Staff ' s recommendation and approved 2`A the Permit with conditions. A true and complete copy of the 24 Commission ' s Notice of Action is attached hereto and incorporated 26 herein as Exhibit H. 26 Southern Pacific strenuously opposes Condition No. 27 3.9 imposed by the Commission and urges the City Coincil to $8 overrule the Commiss4,.ryri and strike the Condition on the following 26 a` �I ►,M 4r a�sic�'.Y.-S�`4°a'd ...1 1.._,. .. i. . All r , 1 grounds ,- 9 1 . The Subject Area constitutes operating i 3 rsil.tr),-ic: risilit of way and is within the exclusive 4 rejulatory .jurisd:wction of the Public Util`.tiea j 5 --Q,7un.-L:;sion 111PUO" ) . Public Util,ita.es Cody:, S5701 , j Q 216 , 229, and 7537 ; CJ ty_ of Mour?1-a i )i 'View V. 7 Southern Pacific Crom a (3 :�67) 67 :?t� .' 291 ; 9 City_ of Long- Peach v.- racific Electric Railroad g Company ( 1955) 44 Cai . 2d 599; moreover, access to 10 ra.ilr^ad rights of way for the purpose of loaning 11 and unloading lumber that is shipped Statewide is 12 a matter of. St%tewide cuncern and therefore 13 within the exclusive jurisdiction of the PUC . 14 Cal . Contt. Art . X11 , SR . 15 2 . The PUC , can October 16 , 1987, in a 16 case entitled Ideal pallet v . Southern 1 •, ,:ific JJ Transportatior._Cem any, et al . , Cass: No . 86-.12-028 , 18 .ruled that Southern Pacific has no legal obligation 19 to permit industria.L receivers of rail car 24 freight whose properties lie alonq a rail line to 21 come onto Southern Pacific ' s right of way for 2$ loading and unloading purposes without Southern 9.3 Pacific' s permission; 24 3. Even if the City had Jurisdicticri to �I 96 regula►tu the railroad ' s use of its right of way, Section 9631, temporgU. str�r�go yards, of the I 27 ' Huntington Beach Ordinance Code is not applicable { �� to this storage of lumber and therefore cannot Form ": 1 n' A SFr„' ' n 7n T •1 .y 1 r r ►� -tii ��rt;w ; '"` ' „Sy ,..'•I ,r ��1 �� ,_� ,yam ,y r P - !e J Y Y�. S IL 1 tha basis for the impoo .t{.on of Canditian 3 .g . 2 4 . The storage of li .itber in the Subject A-tea has absolutely no impact on traffic an the 4 surrounding public streets ; 5 5 . The Condition imposed by the Commission. $ constitutes an unconstitutional taking of private 7 property without just compensation in violation 9 of the 5t.h Amendment and the Due Process 9 Clause of the 14th Awr,%ndment ct' the United States 10 Constitution pursuant to Nolan v_.^Californi.a 11 Coastal Commission 1987 ) 97 L.Rd . 2d 677 . 12 6 . Randall. Lumber has absolutely no right 13 under the .Lease Agreement with Southern Pacific to 14 irrevocably convey and offer to dedicate access 15 across Southern PaL'ifi.c ' s property for abutting 16 industrial users . 17 18 zs . 19 DISCUSSION 20 1. The Subject Area Constitutee gating Railroad &i%ht of 21 wa and is Within the Exclusive Re!aulatory Jurisdiction !d$ of the . � E3 The California Constitution specifically precludes 1 ,24 Counties or other Pullin Bodies from regulating matters over 25 which the Legislature grants regulatory power to the POC. Article ,30 X110 SO provides s 29 "A +City$ County or othar Public body may stet regal to Mttere over which the Degislature 4 • r ' M kr'ff\\ lirYW �d�4r� i .J L1'Y�i r�x{k►k .��iru.sw.: ., . x,r.,,. .e .,. y� ra �� t yr r•' � rll r �� . �. 1�„y,•,, +rQ �Y�d,"idyY `1�1;'J,,'Vr � r, 'I rl��p: �i ' . 7 F • a.. n T} � M1 r i r 1' f , ll Y+ �u 70 1 grants regulatory power to the Conunission . This Section does not affect the power over 3 Public Utilities relating to the makµ.riy or 4 en2orcement of police , sanitary, or other 5 regulations concerning municipal affairs Q pursuant to the City t:be ter. existing on 7October 10 , 1911, unless that power had been 9 revoked by the City ' s Electors, for the right 9 of any City to grant franrhiees for a Public 10 Utiltity or other business on terms , conditions 11 and in the mariner prescribed by law. " 12 pursuant to Section 701 of the Public Ultilities Corte, 13 the PUC has the power to supervise and regulate Public OtXlities . la That Code Section providers. 15 °The Commission may supervise and regulate 15 every Public Utility in the State and may do all i 17 things , whether specifically designated i.n this is part. and in addition thereto , which are necessary 19 and convenient in the exercise of such power and 20 Jurisdiction. " 21 Public UtilitiesCode, 5216 includes railroad in the 2,2 definiti.ou of "F•. '.,tic Utility" . That Section provides in pertinent 23 part t 94 " (a) Public Utility includes evee co�crinor� _._ - -. 25 carrier where the services performed for or 28 the commodity delivered to the public or any 97 portion thereof. " c. Code lips utilitutilities�� ..�. �WrWI�_. ��.�.�f $229 defines railroad very � r n, ONO ik r a r• Mr .1� i , •r '•'��.' cr. i, 'y,4 n • 4 . 1 broadly. The definition includes : 2 11 , . . Every commercial , interurban, and 3 other railway , other than a street raiilroad , and 41 each branch or extenhi.on thereof, by whatsoever power operated , together with ;�11 tracks , bridgPt; , 6 trestles, _r i ihts of �a��, _g�it;w�� 1:anneln , 71 stations de ots., union, de2otqL forries , yards, aroun4s, -terininal4� terminal facilities , 9 structures, and equipment, and all other real 10 estate . used in connection therewith, owned , 11 controlled, operated , or managed for public use in 12 the transportation of pc:rt;ons of property . " 13 Public Utilities Code , S7537 specifically provides that private rrossings jr the railroad or railroad right of 15 way is within the regulatory jurisdiction of the PUC . That 16 Section provides in pertinent part: 17 "The owner of any lands alana or through 18 which any railroad is constructed or maintained, lq may have such private crossing over the 20 railroad and railroad right of way as are 21 reasonably rarr_essary or convenient for ingress to 22 or ingress from such lands , or in order to connect 23 such lands with other adjacent lands of the 24 owner 'The Commission shall have authority 25 to determine the necessity for any crossing and 88 the place, scanner, and condition under whicii they 21 cross:nq shall be constructed and maintained p and 2d shell fix and accons the cost and expense �4; i rl,' • J hM'� 11 r i • \`M{,,'"1 '' ', •�'�+'' ,t� fin'. ' At R 1 thereof . " (knphasis Added . ) 2 See also City of, Mountain View V. Southern pacific 3 C„ onpany (1967) 67 FUC 2191 ('wherein the Court held that the PUC 4 had regulatory jurisdiction over land owned by the railroad lying 6 adjacent to the railroad tracks that was leas-3d to a third party 6 and vined for a Peir-ki.ng lot ) ; see a 1so C:tt:lYof Long Bc,-.cn %Y. 7 Pacific Electric Railway._.Company (1955 ) 44 Cal . 210 599 (wherein i 8 the Court specifically held that a lumber yard was a proper and 9 pernu. L;ted use of a raiixoad right of way) 10 Additionally, there are numerous cases in California � 11 holding that a railroad is a matter of Statewide concern and I' 12 not a municipal , fair and thus, not a matter Zor local. regulation . 13 w ac.ib RailroadCo . Superior Court of. 1Humbolt See, Northwestern P is �.1 C ,�. 1?.. 14 CO, ( 1949 , 34 C&I . 2d 454, 458 (wherein the Court stated that i 16 interference with the use of a railroad facility is a matter 16 of Statewide concern and the PUC has exclusive jurisdiction over I 17 such matter) ; City of Union City _ Southern Pacific Co . (19.69) , 18 261. C$l.App. 2d 277 (wherein the Court stated that the jurisdiction 19 of the PUC to close a street over a railroad crossing within 20 the City is found in the Constitution and in the Statutes and 21 such matters are declared to be of Statewide importance, and 22 in the aid of health, safety , anu welfare of people of the State) ; ,:3 and 6 Os AttorntX _Gen. , 203 , 207 (19861 (wherein the Attorney $4 General stated that public safety on the sty:,Dtets and highways 95 o2 the State,, as well as with respect to the.. opez•wtion of trains 26 within the State, cannot be characterised as being merely a municipa 27 affair. • it. is a matter of Statewide interest and concern which the Logislature has addressed ir. the public Utilities gads) . } 70 ' 1 i'. kA r '1 1 Aa stated hereal n4bove , the reason for the COMMissio(I ' s 2 imposition of Conditiol, 3 .9 wa:i to alleviate tr of f ik: -impact" on 3 public streets . According Eti• the foregoing Attorney Ger o:.-ral. ' s 4 opinion, that is a matter of Statewide concern . ;Wditional.ly► 5 the Commission is requirinq Randall I:u, ber to convey an interest .in an opa- rata..,g railroad right of way t)ef-are it wi 11 w• that 7 right of way to bw used for railroad purposes. Thera cannot d be a clearer case of a violatiOrt Of PUC jurisdiction over operatinrj g railrotd rights of way . .A. foregoing au.thn:.ity unequi•voca ily establishes 11 that the Subject Area lying dirr,ctly adjacent to Southern Pacifir:' s 12 mainline track constitutes railroad right of way . Moreover , 13 since the Subject Area will be used by one of Southern :a,--ific ' s 14 freight customers for the purpose of loading and unloading lumber 15 (that is shipped Statewide) from freight czars , ca.id use is clearly 16 a railroad related aae of Statewide concara and constitutionally i 17 comes within the exclusive jurisdictional purview of the PUC. 18 As a result, the Comaission has no authority to require Randall a•$ Lumber or S:,uthe.rn pacific to irrevocably grant access across 20 said right of way to abut:ti_n; industrial users. Such a requirement 21 is a clear and blatant ueurpation of the PUG ' s jurisdiction over 22 operating railroad rAghts of way. 23 24 25 24 y . r x, A4 W. w`Y` I. Th* IYPUC, on October 16 , 1987 , ir, A Case Entitled Ideal Pallet v. Southern PaCifis Tra!?RRoEtation Compan ram_ et al . ,, n3 Casa No. 86-12-020, puled that Southern Pacific Has No 4 Legal QbliSLati.on to Permit Industrial Receivers of R.alI Car rreiyht, Nt►ode Properties Lie Along_ a Rail I_ i.rie to _ �_.. 6 Come Onto Southern Pacific ' s Rlq t- _of WM. for. Loadi_nq_and YP Unloadinq Purposes Without Couthern Pacifi.c ' s Permission. It should be noted that the PUC has already ruled ,A 9 that Southern Pacific has no legal obligation to -)ez•mit industrial 10 receivers of rail cr.r freight whose proper tins ns lio, along a rail 11 lime to come onto Southern Pacific right of way for io�ding 12 and unloading purposes without Southern Pacificlup permission. 13 This case involved Ideal pallet, the .game party that the C(7lw0j.38ion 14 is attempting to aid by the impositioli of Condition :3 .g . in 16 that ca,:P , ideal Pallet argued that it. :•.ust be given access 16 across Southern iNkc::ific ' s right of way in order to utilize the 17 adjoining team hack. . The PUC., hav:in-g jurisdiction ou•er said 18 right of wiy and 8ucject: A17aa , flatly denied Deal Pallet ' s 19 request . Now the Commi.ssiran has in e fetct -iverruled the PUC 20 by refusing to allow Southern Pacif. ic ' s L,easee to use the property -; 91 unless it gives Ideal Pallet a right of - c,casri . The Conemission has no such Jurisdiction to overrule decisions by thG PUC . An 23 a result, Condition 3.g should be voideC . A true and complete $ copy of the PUC ' s decision is attached hereto a5 Exhibit C . 4, r, r 97 NA 9 K 7 ' _ � ;�1 h'�'�i �N" ! � 1 ! .,�' i ,J•�',' .t j A w I� �f �'RFJe'1'' � ' � r�Y�'4� 'n" � � 't , Jet 4 x,��'n !�• i ' 'r "� S: 4 r� r M 04 i art 1 3. mv*n it the City had Jurisdiction to Regulate the Railroad' s Use of Its Right of Way, Section 9631, Temporary storage 3 Xardst off Huntington beach ordinance Code is Not 4 Applirabla to the Storage of Lumter and Therefore Cannot Form the Basis for the imposition of Condition 3. . The commission impo.-.,ecd Condition 3 .g pursuant to 59631, 7 Temporary Storase Yards, of the Huntington ?3each Ordinance Code. $ However , that Ordinance does not apply to the staring of lumber. 9 it spQ^i.fically applies to contractor ' :, storage yards in conjunc,t;ion to w,i Lh pub.].!(- facility improvement: contrzicts and :i►ulchinq operatioi�.3 11 or) uniiar)roved pub.l .ic os� private property . A true and complete t l copy of the foreq(;ing Ordinance is attached hereto and Iricorporat:ed. 13 therein as Exhibit- 1) . 14 Fiot�,ever , the applica,l_tJ_e o d finance is 9530 . 15 . A true 15 land corripl e't^e copy of t) ,at Ordinance is attached hereto and incror- 16 porated horein as Exhibit E. That ').'.:dinance contains several 17 onditions, erne of wlj,r:h. is a requirement concerning Lhe dedication .-8 6f access acr.o s the :lumber yard . 19 As a result if the foregoing, the Commission clearly .20 �'Ms no Statutory Authority for the imposition of Condition 3 .g. w Ttt�Storage of Lumber In the Sui�,act Area has Abeolutely 3 Na Y ,pact on Traffi- cn the Surroundigq Public Streets; $4 The purported purpose of the CommissiW a imposition 2 f Condi' '.on 3 . g was *to alleviate traffic impacts on public Md streets" . However, as stated herein ,,'.1jove, that is a mat tor of tatevide concern and therefore, as it relates to the opRration I f r;silroad rights of way, is within the exclusive luriddiction ' 10 . s Elm& a I i' Dg. AMRirdal l Luirber ro : 1%ees Lumber Ideal Pallet Page 2 Loan Angelo$# Sep't. ember. 15 , 1998 I w Dut int: our di ecussione r you irioui rad about the VO ILIM + of E t= aff .c ides. Pallet had re-�eived in the past. . our dit.cs indicates the tollowin i carloads have been shipped between :979 aril August, of 1980: YaAR "* 'l11 • Ufi f1986 1 1987 2 1986 14 a985 ,i 1 1984 a .983 16 1982 17 1981 40 1980 36 1979 65 Again , i would like to thank you for your consideration and � gsincervly ha 7e . that we can move on to other areas which will to beneficial byth to the community of Huntington 8each and this carapany. { Sincerely? M . Duo /KOLOD ZIl:J ��YY�,yy Direct or- Hat Tonal lhcc ants 1 1 At. toll. cea Mt • Roy Dicks-an - SPT Co. , Goa Anodes KOK :c 1e v 10 op- "WOW From tfteArXFq6!%sVk ofoo mF.L mERm IER I%wk%M and Qw. Mrt ,. January 1o, 1989 i ., BY ; Grace Winchell Councilwcmn fi ,, B AF` ALONS 14 '►�i The encl vse4 is for your information. i woijl d , g eatfully appreciate Your assisting me and my company, for this letter to become part of the recor6. Randa'1 [.wher Company and . Southern pacific Transporation Conpany,. ,a Delaware corporation Applicant and Owner � i vs Huntington Beach planning Commission, Commission `~ From my letter tG Roy C. Dickson, Attorney for Randall Lumber and The Southern Pad fi c, you can tell that the Ideal Pallet Company and Meal Mermelstein - ;sir, are vehemently opposed to Roy C. Dickson's appeal and it should be , respectfully denied. Sin , Mel Merw1 stet n DEAL PALLET SY TEK INC. 74n CEVAR 2TRe2T IN60W(2f21 (IK4WS w(7141 047-MV MIRI I ltlNE1.�l�NM • $Wvw er of A"WOM-94 c 41d 8vJwM4W- Ih 41"erl4a 1Mf P,3 II�RIar��1 s�wl ff. r i IR r.J. Lo' ui6m Pat-mc, Trenapcwr tion Company 5""Wr,pw&OtrN N•one Markq! PMLa+San frane3.;%C&Nfwr*61106 (*I$)541-10M ThW.4ML1Y.lA A..AI{-LrR Miit N'a�IpS NT AM?rfM'NAL G01/•:fLl w*WAVAL0 40"*. FebruaryL1 1969 PHa.W-A-WVAN / ANDWYAW WMiRAL•I-OMYNYO ��•�'�M"rP«Jit V #4w-•_ o0MiAAo nawrA *AVIV S.WtMP49TT 1�„i 11A ATTaiw•Iw� Au"O"A•'ATT[AOOK e rr f a s Nrtv.TON ATTOR w�rsawMw I.NAO M WAA61+j1 7 %WkJJ&M E.dk*WL OAVNW,►OPA 94PO4.A.KA040" 6M6AAW t.IPWYLAN 48"V A.►AAA MAO W.Pq^0AMW4 IPA!WAWMAW 1M7ML AYTO pdr*a M1 M @ OW CT OW.N�rZA Xr . Mel Mermelatein Ideal Pallet System, Inc. 7422. Ceder Street Huntington Beach, wA 92647 Dear Mr. Mimelsteine Thank you for roux letter of Janaary 9 , 1999, to Mc, Phil Arschuts, Southern Pacific' Chairman . Mr . Anschuts han referred it to me for a reply. First, Mould like to emphasize that Southern Pacific Transpert&tion Company values its custcmers such as. Ideal Pallet and Sntendc to make every reasonable effort to maintain good rely►tionk: with them. We appreciate and desire to keep Ide-% l Pallet' s ,busine;a . Howover, the integrity of SPT' s rights-of- way is they " life bloody of our businessl. Thorwfore, it ib essentir l that we resist every effort by local guAterwassits to ispose ck)nditione v In excess of their j13riodiction, that affect We (and our cuutomers' ) long-te:a use of our r4ghts-of-war . Consequently# AP has no choice but to oppose the condition] proposed by the Huntington Beech Planning Comdraission, since those conditions directly limit Ws future use of its property. $p's apposition to the cofiJitior ,s proposea by the Iiuntington beach Planning Coaxission it not. designed to prevent Ideal pall*t from gainina access to SP, s team track. Rather, it is for the ;aroader objective of ensuring that Huntington Beach recognises and respocts the exclusive jurisdiction of the California public Utilities Ccmissi.on to regulate those aspects of rail opera`�lons Lavolved in this matter. 4 Very truly yournr � �J�LAB 1i. B�EpHbli 0 , 56ut 1orn Pacific Transportation C pany pow ftw �00ma&*m ' 5-►�1 ; fit. R"(W11 Amber's 00. cc : Ideal Pallat i'luvia 11 d 1986 mo bilk. andall ISO*We moll Uabor "a 173 ,r ""lard at• ' �IItia6t� poaab� QJ. �2�? , poor biii i biters to out on-th"rounS aeotias last weot psrtaiuibs Y'our IMqusrt to 19"s JPPOPOA7 •t Wd2t0x'0r%v9 ' ram tftcka Attaabed In outline whiob to os1fs-eXP1mAt*r7 as to a:•ate An An poition to Offer 5 seat* per cntaare toot for area Ataded In red s 9$0 0 160i5o sgarV testa 3 sant e • .50 Por soothe fro taxes* . P ga 4#v 'to give -rou addi!ioo.id limleadi,rg -uoa mMI v .951 , MM ot; as:ao• am of UWd ft1let ban been nit 101- dog s Ilona be wed .for ator, e' as ,�aose 1�,ueba arsa� aor'� . must pow to re�►ab tuck"i *swims wbicb to sbowo 3a brown , � frame We r aloe to We 8e1 Hexme'lotsim, owner or ldaal pallot, A* ham vsa bit "r4i3*16r, for YOU *o *XU8$ his leRre MM& ' ►' to mob sroll for 1 ""M b • IM1*9o"Ing aroa' In bleak will vot bo ` good Ilut 3ra-� dam as opoe #or 470W WA ;*Moo U=bar 0*0 a VW*r . 00 Womb •trosomm . Mod e3Ss N, this As Us Somt :ram 40110,00 for 611 a +at bdp of yow •o:roptaMo. �' eme advtomo a .fir F ' w +jt • 1 . , JIf IL F� .,4�� y a 1 1 Y •. - g1 •fir.. .ai,M ,it J 1 . . Af l VV- 'N� �. r� ,�•� ' �t� ,. 41 .fit! e�y }�' ".t ,� "j, ,�, ; � .• �. ..� !' �*,'�.��,•� ''�`R I r'b t.,i•1i \a y� �} '� ..' '-•��I, 5, �,, •' .r �� ' ''r�`• .1,' �-�r'•a' � + l�. } k,�� i.4•� r'^` �•�, (` ��_a•f i I:i1�?'�[` ,'��"+yf i� '• �4 V., ' R '}r't ��},r 1 �+•� r r•r�'K,,, far ! l fA r iSF r- !•r '! � NI rF.I T � �: J s tF�i 4i: �' f'I f H r t 1 t .i` J J' •'�R'1 •'fl'. � ,, ;, •�♦••;',� r.� /e :r , .IP.. L. •�t' ,� , yam '��,•,��, lL r� 1 r Y • '•i �'•\•','•i� r�OLI• rrrr }��r� ti r y ir'��y�'r•^`i. - ! y.:•�. V/.�,�••`� 'fir+♦ �}��'�`F �, � I, ►. M fir'•' � �� '+ � ' 'fy'a� '�'r! 'tit• �•` r�� ^' �" +.�( • �` •I'•`°,y • �) Lw!- �� 1 .�. �' � �• ram. •�' _ J:�' '�.�. . �� , •�� f I�••�'L vim• ~� •'(. 'f Ja�I�yt ' .�•h`'� � .� 'Pir •• L �' '�' .r i r - t'.• ��•,+�,�• .ry_�`.ir,•,r,' :j-e ,+��y�K, r�y�fr.�►:.:��"!�`. ;5�+ J1 � ` �C: My '• � �•• :.+�.}Y••• .r'••5:,.� f!•:.j •.4�,�.,, 'I*si 1��,r '14�,�; '�� .j-�, I a f1t,.y�),��; J� �. � 1.t t r � 'lr� J�� t„r'. ,tS� �•.'.r4��W�+,��•��4 a•�i��.'5��1 ■i�f• 41 I•o��+•.� 4�t� ~ .'l�1y-�F✓ .'•, .�� , \ ` Ili •+' r ..ti - A•t ,• y j �� T. t. � ��!• �•• ,�� „ ,' tk�' •,t,:i•,Y r•'•J, lkirr 4 `!•�'sG "_ •� ''' r��l,� ( ~ �~ f• 9!. JT •j 11 ''i '• i N 14L g' .�' • ,h;�i f P i i t;s`•.rr••; '' ..'•� •. , •y'y� 'rrf; ,.. wa• � • ^�.1 •r �; • r.. •! Ter y ✓L.r•rh ��i •i:'i1' NIL,1, •��i+r� ^•+' `l r.'✓,!. I��i tit t' •� d 4.4.r i '�: r�a•r�7J 4t.f;tiy� f •'�tr ``� , '� y`' �• r �•,�• ,,, � � w � �IjFd� �'`•• �� i��'•� it y ��x.T1��irti'r ��• •�� pr° "i�)� ,••1�"�;�'-��*•�!�< :•� by 1j�'/ •��f.� •'ii�` r'� }' w ,. ! •�' • •� A,i 'Rty fir' ; ,•' • #, -111, rr ti¢ h Y � ' A 4��+ G4w�OwkTiGw ^TTONNC 'S AT L^W ' T[1.['rON[ 1i91 i�0�•�T.C�CJ 4�'ji WIL>6M1/IM. �r�u�[v�nr, T[�.f,Cr�vi[+� 1>fi]I I�tl6•�i/ G OUITk t uo IOS ANOKLIO, WAL111POANIA (00010 Januery 4, 1989 5,W. Randall R.W. Randall Lumber Co. f 27332 Gothard Street lRuntingt on. Beach, CA 92647 Re: Ideal Pallet System, Inc . i Dear Mr. Rbndallt This firm represents Ideal Pali5 t System, lnc, . until its Olwner, Mal Mer nelatein. Please be advised thw4- the: Huntington Beach Department o+ Community Development *not Huntington Beach Planning Commission have determined that Ideal Ballet in to be given access to the area behind Ideal Fal.let , a property. See attached documents from the Huntington Beach De"artment of Community bavelopment. Please also be advised that Ideal Pallet and ,7amee Lumber Co. have entered into an irrevocable access agreement:, a copy of which is attached hereto You, are therefore edvised to cease and desist from interfo ring with the access of Ideal pallet to the area behind Tdoal Pallet' s pro)perty. Please feed free to call me—if you wish to discuss this matter. Sincerely, EERMAN, SLAMCHARD, MAUSNEX S KINDEM ?#df 4. ;0&�i JEFFREY N. MUSNER inolosurs t Mr. Robert Irr&rjk).in be artmmt of Cc�unity Development 2OW Main Street ftntixVton Soacsh, CA 92607 0 WO* r any I Uj�, �'' , I • } i,� 4* i 4..7 �, w.d,• . }o 'Ai, ei} ,M1 ,1!'•'• 1 V 0 L i '•4� .'yam' ' MGM06 ' l ME . rr•.i o,, ' i LUMBER CO. 17311 NIC40LS STREET @ P.O. BOX I18F HUNTINGTON MACH, CAA 028,7 a (714) 847-dS I i sIRIZVOCABLK ACREEMENT SFANEEl:�ES AND IDEAL Jim barriagton. owner of James Lumber Company, on the on,m hand, jointly referred to as (,tones) and Mel Marmelstein, president and owner of Ideal Pallet Systems, Inc. , on the other hared , jointly iaferred !a as (Ideal) do hereby agree that camas shall Sta►6t, to Ideal, :ul,l. complet+a and unlimited access . for Ideal's trucks and trucks making deliveries to and from Ideal' s yard, North to Warner Avenias and South from Warner A\jaernas to Ideal's backyard, through the two existing back ga test for tho•purpose of ingress and agrotss, throughout the length of the 100 fact vide by 1.000 foot long parcel, of panel contained in block 10, if blocA 1106 of the town of Wintorakburg, Assessors Map, book 111, Page 02, of the Cci4n ty of Orange. State of California, known, so the Southern Pacific Public Teary Track. Winteraburg, Carl:.`ormla. See Photo-copy of map ar.tachei. I'a considecati.on of the above rights. Ideeal agreem to co-opera-? and assist James with the purposed planet to obtain a Conditional Use Permit. fsom ;he city of kuntington Beach ,�r- that Ja►%es can receive and unlood rail.-care of lumber and starer its lumber- on tho allo,.e described sites Oars Ideal asserts its *&resent rights. James and Ideal also a8res that James will allow all rail-cars of lumber, destined for Ideal& to be srotted an its tracks , at the above otentioned described site, which is Leased to him*, ty the Southern pacific Transportation Company, and agrefi;a to assisto whanevor possible, in the unlooding at spotted rail-caret of lumber be- longing to idea. This agreement was entered into. by 5ott, parties. on March 31. 1986. Ag-aad to byt 'L Nw�rr.rti�� r ingt Mel Mermelstein ar asr AWpafty Sy Jim Morrinbton Mel Mermistsin by Ideal pallet Sytttevosl tt. i I „ q 1 1 r '4M 1 WWAVW IM F6mc Tren UNK1y”P 1o"I.Oft M#*M INS:. Y aw Fa wom,t<.~t"105 (416)54I•wow TWO ~40 A. W.LL(1t Vlci rwKNpeert w�iRV�+IGr�lM'i_ ►sMa.COWMAN 1.?MrTMANM. Ini. .ew.,I•e��rr.w� Febria ry/ 421 19 8 9 mw.h«,Iti.4 V49 ftA A I I .�MuWtIWr CI�wIIkAL now►rtr4 ft&60Ow"M OVAVID&OWPW Il.TT CVPMirA F.NtHrTY7M Aly MAW aye ��►,IAII./�MIAI"/ M MAJAM 0,iMJL M AVr 1w,LA AM *ItilA 66 A,►��Ml�y ��lIIIA1� MOMMON IM�IMAi�w.•ItrJlpJliJJr� A. 40MMI M.RAdw A N !rMlMMrr.'Fl�1l� MMAr1�IMy�lCT�M1.M/�fM Mal Mermelet:ei�. Ideal Pallet System, Inn . 7422 Cedar ftreet Huntington Beach, CAA 92647 Dear Xr. Mermalsteins Thank you for your letter of January 9 , 1989 , to Xr . 2hil Anscf7utz, Southern Pacif ic 's Chaizman . xr . Anschutz has ra terred it to sae for a reply . Pirate t would like to *aphasize that Southern Pacific Transportation Ccsa"ny values its customers such as Ideal pallet and intends to 1aaka every reasonable effort to maintain good relations with them. we appreciate and desire to keep Ideal Pallet's business . However, the integrity of SPT'a rights-of- way is the "life blood" of our business . Therefore, -it is essential that we resist every effort by local governments to Impose conditions, in excess of their jurisdiction, that affect SPIN (and our customers I ) long-to= use of our rights-of-way. Consequently, SP has no choice but to^ oppose the conditions proposed by the Huntington Beech Planning Commission, since those conditions directly limit SPIN future umi of its property. $P's opposition to the conditioiin proposed by the Huntington beach i lami.ng Cc.-mission is not designed to prevent Ideal Pallet frm gaining access to BP' s team track. Rather, it is for the broader objective of ensuring that Huntington Beach reaop isms and respects the exclusive jurisdiction of the California Public Utilities Commission to requidte those aspects of rail, cporat.Lous involved in this matter. Very truly yours , DOMW 2. BTEP $4t1 yl Y, if 1 : r . r ' , N ' S, Ll A, CITYOF HUNTINGTON BEACH �.�.�.�.�.��Y4�H� 11• ■W.Iii11.1.1Y✓• F.0, BOX 190 IbEPARTMEN. ' OF DEVELOPMENT SEA V10EO CALIFORNIA u2648 ■uiLOINa DIVISION 0141 5W0241 i1.ANNl�l� �IWtf�Rl 11i�1 d7#-d?7! • r 1 y~'� t October 11 , 1991 Southern Pac i f iC Transportation Comp ny 610 Main Street Los Angeles, California 90014 Attn: Mr . L. K. Br•nwn, District Manager, Real Estate subject: Railroad Might of way (2 . 71 acres) ' ion the south side of Warner Avenue, approximately 200 feet east of Palmdale 5wreet in the City of Huntington Beach, California ' Ar #111-023-10 Plltqal uses of the subject property ! Dear Siral An inspection of the subject property conducted an October 70 1981 , by this department revealed many illegal uses of the property. The ninety-two (921 ) foot wide right of way is .fenced off for approximately eighty (80) ' feet of its width and for approximately seven hundred and seventy-.five (775 ' ) feet of its length with come nine (9) lateral fence separaters of veryi,rg lengths, This area has be,.Iome a storage area for trash, debris, and inoperable care and trucks. There are also house trailers stored in two of the fenced areas that appear to be lived in. These are all Violations of Section 9531 of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code. Uses Permitted. in the M1 Liynt Industrial District. In addition, any use permitted under this section is subject to City approval of an administrative re- view by the Board of toning Adjustments,, which as you krm is presently considering an application submitted by the Quality Building supply Company. It is hereby requested that the illegal tenants and whatever ma- terlal they have stored on your property, be removed and the pro- perty cleared within thirty ( 30) days From receipt of this letter . i '1L ;�', w , •• r d��4''�1"1��' _ ' , iq �v^•• 1',t 1M (� '°' ,.M 4.y� :.'?1. '! .d.(2��1�+1_' _ '� "w w Thank you for your cooperation in this matter . If you have any questions, please cell the undersigned at 536-5539 , sincerely$ ` I eon Shaw Land Use Technician DStjh . 1 A. i ,a, y �liMY��,o 1 � '.4�' ,.. iWr ..� S C ,.. .. r il •fa a_. ..,.. - .. „'•i.i 'i, l�u�� io- �. POW -7 �"p K • So'uttiern Pacif ic Land Carnponyv N10 SvV11i M§in SuM • Lot&.0910t. Colifixnw WW14 0 12191 G29.6502 ITEM.ESTATE KLSTACY October 20,' 1961 ip•UNly.YIYpaMI! 7E,K A.NAMK 460,f7AL*T ..Mft%L...,"Odwr, 1-14 Ra s -•Wintersbarg a K HANDON Af WN1.7 vT URTIFIRD M XL MITURN .� EIPT REQUESTED Mr , William L.ongle ► ,7A l i ty Puildl knq Eupply 7502 Warner Xvenue Huntington beach, CA 92647 •oar ■r o Longle l F' I; Before to your lease of Southern pacific Transportation Cwn.panj, ,property (tudit Not 198042) in Muntington Eeauh for receipt, atcarage+ and distribution of building materials , Attached is a copy of letter fron the C9 y of Euntirs3ton Beach dviaing 0. �istoui aathor1zed'j*uses :V_ i�th1n the lease area. in vtati*A, t ;�$eption 93 �.. Ehe' uriti'hgton uach 'drainanc+e Cady+. a $*'p't19 3 ,o9 .you 14ave"emu are �raguired �' . . . + + . Ao vomply . A• flier 1 , - - - i d" ul�t3ans grit a 'greapact to the use of r �1erie, �t c xe your ` xat t�a'e ini delaudi' rdi" tae m'iniatz tIra iies ffye. or eMMA 'XwAlumal Uses' obtaia 'on � � t extension frost the � iu • , r tf jMU_ w►�Ca�,# '►A0 t� reach i a'amp- romLsef afth the City, it vAll ble •' r0e5iiry M for *t6 re�t�+ava i1 "`�*i 6vGwdhtk, Vh1c�h -you otm fiom the , s iser rid later Vmw November il, 1981 if desire .to d1sapas this matter, please contact 'F . Aahuffeftmuar at (213) 429�-6617. I . h 1•f L i r y .1 r. . ♦ Attachment M r E 'a 00 0Mro Don -slater 4l" TOOMial�ra w.w.r..r.' " J� 1 ♦•��+,•'ti . ,y,r . .. . ..i' �' Mom}. Ipblift LM V, l '' I�'6 •r �� r� F1 1' 1 4• - 'y , ' 1 r• •'}r! 'Y, I, i ,t t A .ti 1 4 '1 a Jan 23 M 1 ? :27 No .90§ P .0;. V ,:. t6 h ` . �+� �+ ,�• �/' ` •��p,�T A�+ `may 1 � ,rw K�wr0�At14►1 ttr`I�rwgNi i� l1! c �rlleracr 4787 w1L�rrl�� >ua.11v.awn T��arr�t u��i h�►r• �1• LOS JLi01ti.199, Ch[. rORtNIA 00010 (11 January 16, i Roy C. Dickson COX, DiCkraon, Stu Worley 417 South Rill Street, Suit& 650 Las An9010h, CA 90013-1121 ' mot Ideal. Pollwt Dear Mr. DiCkson. This latt$r W117 oonfirm our telephone convrreati#if o today, Y�'9 t threat&nOd ms grkd my l awfiLm with a lawsuit 0ontin1jed to assert Mir. M0rm83,at•in ' a rights to access to the retira�awa! rack behind his promises. i asked you if Solithevn pa�►aigip was -to work out an acCa&a� ngrastaent', you stated � that Southern PeClfio was not, becrausa Nfr. Mexr�ilstpi�n ha�� pigSod off evex-yone from hence tO Jgrua�alsm. Y asked you What you meant by that, to which you .rponded that beaeus•uhaehasrn POcific piasa4 doom not w%At to deal with Mr. tl&rrn•l&'lei off everyone in the comPony. " • Please inform tr.& if I haveffithate�f you any �uetma or my our conversation. Also please be advia+ad jowfLrm, we will file & melicious proseoutiOn &CtIlOn 894inst YCub S incn xeXy, BERMAN, BLANCHAED, MAUSNRR & KYr1ULM 1 , 1, ► r JEFFREY N. MAUSNiR � a I � • • 1 IDEAL PALLEET SYSTEM, INC. 7`422 CEDAR STAEET HUNIINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA-92647 WW1 pW ah► nMQs� PHONE (213) ,592.55a8 or(714) 647•19657 la�lrino 3anuar3 27 1989 jqr. Roy C. Dickson Assi4tant General Attorney Southern Pacific Transportation Co. i 411 S. Hill Street Suite 650 Los Angeles , Californi a a 90n13-1121 Dear Mr . Dickson: I yam writing you in response to the remarks you made to my attorney , Jeffery Mausner, on January the l6th. ,1989, regarding me " Mr. Mermelstein hid pissed off everyone from here to Jerusalem. " Also, that 0 Southern Pacific does not want to deal with Mr. Merrmelstein because he teas pissed off every;neriey�eeby�'p�v�ryone�ee in photo- copy of letter dated WOW )OW ) p company," you miist include yourself as well . Enclosed are photo-copies of a number of previous letters of exchange between yourself and my attorneys , Jeffery Mausner and Rosa Berman, regarding me, my character and my business relations ,li th your employer, The Southern Pacific Transportation Company. I want to inforim you and your .employer, The Southern Pacific Transportation Company, that you are incorrect and highly insulting by your characterizaticn of me Lo my attorney and others as a hated man "from ohere to total l ysal em•" As an attorney and spokesman for a Publi Uy yu are completely out of line and '. want you to know that I resent it. For the record and for your information I want you to know that I am an honorable dawn 0W17H CLEAN HANDS." I am also a food and sensitive person. I am well liked and respected in the community and throughout the world, including aerusalem. See photo-copy of original letter to me dated July tth. , 1902, from the then Prime Minister of israel , Menachem Begin. S1 nc y IMI Dermal stein-Press dent IDEAL PALLET IY5TEMs INC. c #hjjjp AnsftU -Chairman of the kerd-Rio grand western Rai 1 road 311ffor IAreaner` - Attorney at Law M'IC1041 Perak* - Attorney at Lac 4 W1I0 Cox - Attomy Rt W .+ Attorney at Law , r lei r t -IIMk1anal 'Accvofts p 11�1 Tlradnepaa`tatIon Co. ,71 u�s$�5G'ilili.6tl'4`•• *' e_. . . .r,' d,,:LWi9x7:1'�'Lru_',`{8N•li•��y:_, •'y�r:', _...�lrl a ' r A'a 7 qffi*� �a ��N��d�IM•r�1�IC!' MEL MERMELSTEIN Sostat, Maaaahum0h Jute,49M "Corgrta tuMons on your Qlorlous vk:tory cam ref ttow 4y, cynical, psvry wed piou whokm who dare drr y that your idle" and *to hod boson irwanted, We wMh you word." Elie Wissai rarvtor Mlr hr The W hft Hoer ,1 III n WosrhlrWm, D.C. Juko 4 4m Nqrodrnber 21, 4993 "I hors h9M d vftn wsr public "Ass one who h e s hard ttmwgt) om of the moat aft M ree"spW Odw lr at Chow who hoM* mm mcdo he* of our car".you 1biow SM by+ bast the Mwh ai w A the ors.you how much ws raed to be reedy to work*to dacom wrw�ft ad ur cue. * 1.1r" rs�ht Ihi fbroAa or i�ataAtcxlar9rm." Ronald f3ftge'wr Montittrrrn begin Caft"00 L lahne 2ocrorner'rta lResokOlon . d kites Srtaiwr FebruW 23, 1"2 1Ak +ttieisrt, D.C. "Re:dwrd,Nt�rt Me! itile11, stn be horxred for C+s 1 AwWOf1tM Reetir�d hit vaN wO•IMo dwplh gyst perMorO on 91NO 24 490 and sacifto, In v OddkV the hush In a�iar that "I *c4wam*owa O d@r.11lO w a Meld OW all theme dmcttiw mov rWhw be MW%n" t o bml Nofto and who crppctI the DcW lObWN ~« Ikstdsrro pah cm Willie L. Srov^Jr. Mart Condon Cly of Lcx coy.Cow 4arlterrrbar 4 S,4"4 ''de If Uvw Okft 2 that m"I 61111T aMiwkt bo TV rMrrYtlrrttubsnrd a•a rYr*rt twrf P"WW " Ow WO In you►bait 11=04 OW ISM WN th*Q11MR�1 pt p vlaiorlM No dim Ow atsMwt Ih*It 10 a is �" n4Mtp t �tit Mrp Mort'a a � !llrMatd�.kofir ��wkriMr�"m now bar bmoktti" ` w; joy Vr t_ rr r , Southem Pacific Transportation Company 417 ttf%M No Strw, Suft W•tx ko t rt.Wf mo M13.1121 *eftwo m OWN"&%.a 01 4" 0 j January0 , 1989 i Jeffrey N. Hausner. Esq. BERMAN , HLANCHARD, VAU RSR & g I NDSK 4727 gilphire Blvd, Suite 500 Los Angeles, CA 9001O t r ItR t Ideal Pallet Dear Vr- iaauener: This letter is in response to your I*tter dated January 18, 19691 is which you totally mischaracterizee our conversation. 1 oevor indiested to you that 114r. Wermelateio had p9ssed off everyone from here to Jerusalem. " Furtbermore. I never told you that "Southern Pacific dotard not want to deal with Mr. wermalstain because he haw Visaed off ureryone in this Company . " However, to correctly reiterate My 4`t4te Z0nts to you . Southern Pacific Transportation Company has no obligation to deal with Wr. Uermolstsin with respect to negatieting rigbza to access to the railroad track behind his premiees. I indtcatad to you during our telephones conversation that the Publ,ie3 Utilities Commission imam ruled that Vr• Wermelatemp is not entitled to such rights. As I stated to you in our conversation , I hereby demand that you cease harassing Southern Pacific 's tenant, Randall Lumber Company , by thretktonirg to sue him if he does not gire Mr. - iiertsslsteis access across our property. If you should have any questions regarding this letter-, please do not sail ; Confine your mmmnl cat tons to the is writing. Very truly yours, ' r , P�7C . ROT C. DI CICSQN + .1 pry :_ ..♦. �.. .� ^. Y N�Y.� I ••A :yyi •, w �'...i• r� (•, `• r ref+r r '�((r >r '� r�^ r`'�Sd7 r •r- t Pik�,l .• 1,�'..�r.++�• .' .y , All •;��:(ry . , � , .. '•. , ., ,♦ IK. r •fit .,., ,, .,r�', •` y� 1 ''�SRT •,ys'd y�- r7 � : r v-t �y• 4. .fir.. . r :�.,. .Y r�. . `r;• i N i ♦j Y •,1 I swrawli,0004 ..1 ?Allot •TOO&O • r pl�r Or . Ikrb��tf!►, t rrw Nwr4 of Few cauratV4011 P&M it VAO wwt 'go 1�ret..►�s fra�t a<� MNt1b � �"T ita lap •lra last _ w . i fi�s1• 9r �t �, - � "w ftfg zip' t011� o ,wri,y�h ,r�+"T...ir••.1+-.�...1....4.•.��.•.-r+ri+a—�'Iti-~ .. , ... � �. .'... .• ..:...... , _ •_. •� •, the ffin dau:ws m 4 a ,r lt� � ., O 40 W-61 IL . - ' '� , •ice • '„. •• • ; S • • •,. •• •,.•. ' • . / , • • � ♦ • ' • •• .. � . •. ',•�•1 •�1 - i t�• dpp +� �,d. ,-r_ /•, _ 4�� ,r r •a1•. t • ,. .'• l r .. {) t��•� .jd Ms c Ott By Ao,"wrlwmalo DAvw ELoalt. PIcw.t111i Ai.AiraxaK. TO" Ui4c, Adpawsawwoo m M,44aA« Raacsi o"w, Assames Ymcft NawAIra L. lkp&4 m, Dsmmos L. Plrtawm. Pa rlis R. 04AC", �o�llwll: L. CawvA" , .AIM CQ*Yi%. i'**04w W. Gulrr�Y, Uo FAwN. GI6r1Z N. FgLAM00, yVML1AM �. F#o,,^t4jx, 1rl;"y rAnAA.Na. To4amAs M. Kamioaa. As""Lv awaa T'alkSAA P. Nus a . A"G"LV64694 CNA+.cs 1wNs1:aT. WAkTCls INGAILI.e, PA•T111G/t Jdw/tuaTMO, LAwatemcs KAmw#,, Rocln swa KATx. AwMPLYPPqMM+ MAI 401.ly L.Aft:.:..ATTsI A "a"wo" _ _....,.� .,.:�...- L.cow&oA, W-L Ley&*&. ll*k Locnvrcu, Austica MLAals Lm. A&,Ac.•"vwcu*" r Goo,so MAaiwit. Asr1`M"Itimc11 ?&Vmcv J. Not-aft. Laws A P,60,&s,. 0%w Ro"A.M. 64ri4axI6 Rao*, I' PISCa1tK R0*cMTl4^16' AIMi1;MltLrwwMIMM Maxus« RyAit. Ass cmobi vlaatl S#•ng Si,xw 1AM. Joftm f, Tnum4m, An? TQMIItILA. .J06w VAACW$ClLLL0*. FHA411 VICLOC4A. AiI%&w*LYwj61Aa MAM►INc WA•f%:**. ASLKMOLYNAM C1,1115191l 8. Y.'kav; Awwmui.rw,Mwum Ct%vmc PHoi- 'P D. Wvm&m ANC !4I+J<;6: Youmc SKMMTO S 140"Olt G. E3ZVV"LV.P.w1. GJ111ir$NTKR. RALM+ C. DILL6. Jim EL.A.&S. WAAZ GAIIC111. 13Aa«v 1(cwwic, ,iftcros MamfovA. Noco4aaAs C. PCYatsi. R06lKwT Q. Fl.i;al.lcr.O&WOl L. RA&kt. A1.A1r RcIMIema. Pwvia A. Rwxxn, A4-m 51cNom Ows Sri paw. '%MD P&APIS WaT cw RELATIVE TO CCWMENa1NG MFEL MERMELSTEIIt! ! , WHEREAS, Maa Abl,:MewaL*Tsur 16 DRAILIMIN G QF TM 1440 9ST 1400I0018 Art{M ClIMPI914GATM rldw; "IS COMPA"ONs I675'.'r:AINATION IN IICRyTW116 TM1S 4:01AIJAkItC MAIIIJI i r1Y VMS "IM&T11VT19 FOMMI' � MOVOI iCA& 0RVIAW"' -,Q '*P*QVC TMAT 1iW6 MI[AA, GAS"D IM QAf CH444PENS /N AWGi1#0iT9Mi 0.1191 �..:• �� :.� WHEREAS. a mw6voo OF THE rDCATM CA11tb OP AUSCN1072-1;11A1 gNAu, A140 BUCM9*wAL-P, AW16- '1•' ON MAy M. Isa. AT IMWK, SAW MAN IMOTMAO APO JVM •tS11118M, AM"G aT§d A .lrwlem wo+rli�+ 4:044LO0/11N rwoi,,, we 0019"TOW0. fQxcIOl,y as To ' nis S.r wan nacna"' AT Taa Auscj%wi s4k#Wl9P#* ATiMMfNATIWu cgmr * Am P1iANa:"a WMERLAS. True h*1ou1sAA INsnTuvw Fan Review main Ditic :,rcw. LVwls Gamma, tffFIR4AA0 now i. >jecim Ark.** a rcm rtlaor ANP vss" s Pis P10 00. TNL K014CATION W04462 Mw#t"T M4 /AtLNR9 To • PkPM CS ft*W TO TMC MAIiA IAILGIA; AND WMERCA4. Ma,. •Itoufam ime issue saFaRR TMC jua1C1A1r 1WsT1 m To FIGNT TH& " W W"' W no SJFCNIm COwnt or TNk U^vfe cw Cauoroomih Fox TMC CQUNTY of Las AmeaLas. AMO Af YiR LA110TNY A.'.D MI<ATiQ AMWMRNTs Irw "Tit 6806S, CM OCT0098 i. 1141, 714 Mcw0lARii Jua" Ttscoa" T. 10 t-Al"M OCCLA111119D TMAT "M tow*T `•Ir MKIR EVlalcelce coos. SaCY1c* 41(N) MOMS TMM AUDIGIAM. NOTICI; 40 TV4 /A91 THAT JAMS W190M W16640 '10 9WATN AT AAUSCHWIT* C06I09111TWATIC* CAW IM FMAX13" AND TOIAT TM MOLaCAucT 0 NOT 1119" NA"'N' Ijl,1MSOT TO RI11PVTs; MOW, TM&0Ml*p1`C� me It RMLV D BY THE JOINT RULAS COMMITUR OF THE SENATE AND TNIC ASSChifty r T.+rT Tr+c Mamaaas !1 xPaca s rr1kul wm)Ls44CA••tT9D CONAMPOPAY)OMS TO MCC MCNIMSLSMAN 004 IMPIPM4011MG 1s19 FALMIA Ah0 IMFLAMMATQ*V VOICUP GO T11001 Wx0 11I0u4G 01114416111 TMg *4FF%nWG 00 WVC4 OF NMLL40*4 11NITS01104D Afte C use Iry T`IrR NAm we4mi ;&no •R It FOR04 SA ' RESOLVED. TMAT MaL Ms/,'I USTICIN ns AW40140 FOR 105 vALIANT ItIFFwwTS, P46RTS strsAT SCIVbWAL A11GUMN ANTI SACRIFICC. .W VAI.400114 TITS 'MUT140 IN 0000411 TMAT T"*C AIMMIT146 44Y IMS rLM FOIiTrOYTCN;A1rq 11[ IT FN11t.+tA 1 LUXVE0. Tawr A s.MITA WV FMAJOARCIP slily OI/ Von PfiMxWTx M 09 111ASWIT" To , Mr u.afri�Yf'M, • �tsw.l+s+la11 tNw.M . Arrsawsa rT vm JgINT Ruiz#C "wrrMss Al- Do woo *iwpgovc 41AIMMAX COM J,PAIP60111,L"100 5 ,-faos MotAs Cawm"$$ Iti4im s w104 IwIN• j)ztW P#4*owsMr fir i„s lkisma ff FiAMmowM•r 1 w�r+11•l��v�l ec. sals 1 ' 1 Mr . del. karw�ll � �e�iri � J 7422 Ca-Jar Strad tr uAtinttou beach, Cali& ni# 94647 ; ti11 tt 11 ll N116111116111 �`/11114ij ' • i AI A"CH"5YON ° .yid1 W wIrok PC lei .a September 25+, 19d5 I ,f ' M�'. PI►s 1 M'013 lli��1i t a f ri �: ' Prdaiddnt and [Angral Managar a ldi-al Palloot System, Incorporoted 74022 Codar Street .. +�ubtiri ton beach# California 92647 Dear Ralf uay thahks for yaue note* I ras grsatly pleased to learn of your victafy# which I have ladaeas called to pry c011669044, *Lt,enticAs as roe will note from the encloasds � Please rtay in tauch. • Warn fawds, �4rrd is t � , • •'- � itR111 � � r • j C " ro,16510flal &, Card oll i"P 11 er«ai► d'dt +: 1�e�ly AND 4 T,5 Of TUS 99`6 aCiaNl-ai*% F1et1 r fitsuosi r rrt �i� WASHU GTON, T'UESUAY, Ankmb1 k 240 1*5 JV* Jjl NG Al ULCO D -w- U!''riATL "Whuram, Mr. parr e1iW1LRu� , D"ljl Ulp uoL.oc&usr that WA "tlkuw I" Mwartsw littvww www, at Atjewaw naffs Iejwwn,. Imm mt. Woo McIAtxln'S ietWr w the gajLV of tlg jSVAW idr. CHM1S'TON. Mr. PraaiW964 mm li-m *W, da&,-,d AujgwA t?. I" that Mt. of WC ma" VDUs 644 rcp"Owt NerlriW64411%eC41;1Lenaga lays raw ji mvive :of C&SUP 401b by home at L)w 1ur-irlYhw A:�a ►rv+i -lslr�oe:ju�u gild jlij"lar>Irrald: brat*, Afuuoa %a Uim c.4mwLty over the yeum or AhOW4 h4wis iiwwr►. Lher,t W. merama- Lljrar taxcl wn iaL4traupR to +deny the IiO AC1A conterwvd W" rib am"wv' "two "o- h" Wag aaa"d to deer A je.l Aubchai" Wid eCA"L. 1t to cYLraWdulortly 41111Calt Lea knew. Of AtawAlU 146vs LWQWeia. W tun ecwltta- em u prte fiend What tLiw fnaU MW t bLs U04 that " 414 w a an Aw a 11N14 As &0. rd l urt. 1L Iu 960 my 1O AAJ► ruaP1,Y Gh" o�MhO�aa�'�j�CL►l�il�r+1M.i�JjI N' sakW G�'t" 1 Ir�vienu� 114a►il uLiuiutl 6rrlerrl9 iehle +lhr K+» ecxaauaW rit at AuWhrrjl4 w0 11jyi[au " od � 1`j�'art3d ep�i la�rsc�4 lilrkrcrw►u, wietle:lt, tact f�er tl+rtor;uY�jrrliil la 4� hul, .gar iwh&Wvcr rorjeew. UW..vn 111 f �u. wh flu. s; awed Kre�lul]ei RI►aw PCr;.'sk 1'rrLit�uta►rly "when*. an G L S. 1"I. too parruss harruwW4 lum bmia Llicir eft c-L an in 4ugmw in she 14LlMUt•awa lllw Grp aaa- survivam of liliriW& wox iwjtdl3.lt We WW tw• au+s"Ary 1ehagR>ent tcmAWW io Jew" pcuyle wid Luke allrwriuer:r., the etl W16 Lwr Use kt4m&a %AW 7°rau(saL T. k%w mW re"on. it Is tacwtocn4►tl W • aOUISW. taakliW jeWU W61 rwlACC 86 1a►WW4• slaw Ltie rC"ja "Cti ua by & Cib►l "- "'U114T 9V1dC1WX G'IWW 4vcteon 663i1,I, run► l:utart La becvy dUW4 quad rxaaetxw a th a coun '14kch c*ae ,U Ucw no"" ed Lm Cuur L•arec•red M obey jgto-1 " ww tACA Lhla J9WA Wete NAWW 64 ft"A " t" Au4chwi" Cuwcj1LmUwi Cw aL! ut PWMW L1w.w CALr U44 %wr"L1 •M r lAwinX UA sufmawr eat 1 W4 . ww 1L )m" t► w auluna►ed 14 Putt 11 "Lhe HOW- jamWy is a lw:t illat fulls wig Lhet des`tLAI- c4tt"L•WA.v-wlit" a4arLest wwe afftruw two at le:vkwj jr Cad* `. wL.Wa t.'Li 41. it w omwlaaty rvwakr4A—wAwh they kaave j]Al tewkwu rly bubi ci, to erl-Q41 e. AAd u if Wert re>lubed to post—w AMYOM wrla c�l,a►t,le god iewja4:�►,,lts jerlO -Azuerwtet edecte�rjooJ• product* pr Uw lmww1 by rc#,UA w auurc" c,t rgoaac>aw la- curred. "vuw%le Accumcy• It IA,.W►ply x taea.,* i 'd'hW Cjahlorrt1� Owt 4"Adol a W At "W hcrg a. Mr. btcrawb oLcla&Ad ALW Ws- YlcLut duf who 1` a O.bDA1b Uwvlwam at Aux erg1►wlw aWbd L wA LWy NU'- lo,mO awwae ,cmaLlun&A 46Vr.%6 fCaiu41 W i Lrwva WW wlio GcptKoc Wit $tlflrU Q1 flum j1ek6l stward 011tr Urb Jwt"Quaau caa- 1 w.',t viseg a rirau&* W "u-;.w, pWA duct 41 Uw Lus4l1:►w of "le w movk * &IsJ impugn kiolooatuAL jtia mWoOem No I h'c#114M11atyr 6 i.t>e Lost of Lhe 1CLLeG1 of "WtWee" Lho I Atlw6e Sat >�UA"kM Myc►IuYy Aitr,411i1� 40 Lttet or�ia:f N by �- lirvicw anal i�a;lua ��r Srarrivld W �` 4urjjee:yi leaf um d.IGerLy �� A,i'il rtOljt Go�rarer�ad LtV►t In Oljrrl6W 1Sf� tewMriMfPs t;wte waw► no ULL411L to afdrwL rrmA or ra"ilweeiui+r Uw to LA6 Call& Carle cawu anral aaiwa to sayanc. larludkw There kwukg no eU0*won. Uw t w"- heir. uerm e6kin, a mwvlvat of A bcAw1w - rw wow atacrrd w Din 4wuuw 14 Um Lwwcw►u lakd bu htnwiA4 ocrt rurr�wer 1 t1al14awli; Crmso 21 world wsr i1, and a Pawn wlio iurl " ter. maiol of NW Lw4 Mli kft M1� weft 6wisLca of A ww;hrw1w 4TAT1►MNA1 Or hWADO0 AMD!&Tr%A W oWneertmav the Ina"twe 11w kiLmmirAd AOU"V to M"KLOAM"T" Review aw 1xtiurj Wr &avivi4 of Pram "W'hwfts- the Lee" $of JiAA"AVSJ Qf mould haven bcca **an UmA Um rawwred 1'p0'eCeaYfw. M�Id 1 liM}tjLitiie for l4tsy3erieMi alfe r womm efi ww bar. Ms� NMI IlerMerrlr. e1�Ctjl by ICU" d+rlxtl lrsw+r�rt' 1ef1. Wh�er rsurrNrprs of A�rrits W Wjtl9t+r IrMtr. +i1le+ctly La trA+eea Yrrtj►ee:L�tclelt. a iejetvl- revptof Igol�MlQr�a+eei e'�i�.trC+►�i ItbAcq aw lgrtl• vatWAeejA�dM�llrb•l/jr►�«u wra011owr�eAwrA4 LW� jeer dsli`lOt1�1 IieCirMerl � 4�MMA SW WIerjglw;11w te>•w�areL" alter 4► rN leti,x ernar'Ierra 1#+jrlllvievl of �recereell'w4 "w � is tra "'yervuowJ1`' jloWd leia►virwAcr 20. ie>*iw, ecart• +trcLl6hie j1n1a1eriY0 irk NOW" lIL MN lefuid Mr. kknnXisl as a 4.w,.Owl O:j aw.%►vt w/tiR. gv& chsaWe ra at 1►wCtNarrw r '•ArK1{ f e&ruwr tan AM .V Ai*WAKY to AdAA,hgb;�8 AO Swam am d Mr. hieetl'1!'aemAcw aw wt to . . tK acts of the A"w ertft dwelwai" do j, w6d 0 on swage 611 r -,very 60AW•'. he,rrby a titalamy AAA4 jars"Y W18141ja 1r Ica "UW lttrtllwW 16t Mtrl+uric+ew" UCVWW 0040 Mr. bw. a 6t'i1'v►vw egel Awb- 40"Hclid th&L 940 60 Vw m&w :�reta`. . . tl >IM�iir�l�i1MY MeM� IItO�i4111� f� � "Wt�nrer Yr. Merp�ertatellie iwnjc�AAY �. yl/� j5ekrilrroiwj` oI Ao�11wl1it 1:� t►1j� 1�1►Mar PIMrt jet #►rrlllitrll tstr►eMrs1 Ilt+'" Ss j1[1e11m" um bulleu'rsad bet 014 OI° ttlwl�#11 AjWhwua e►bnsvws 1:4ewr ftUAYit $a JAS i WAW reUrelrta a 41gr dljr pUd UW • d*PP GFF ERAL ASS b' ,1Ajjq4 r OHIO GNAT CONGRATULATING MEL MMEitURIATEIN ON RECEIVING THE JAN UEZ i(ORCEAJL HUMMITARIAN AWArw On b"t of the Intmberm of the Senate of the 117th General Assembly Cd Ohl% we are extremely pleased to oograWsts Mel Marmelstein an re**ivkg the Joauss Kornxu Humanitarian Award. One of the most horrerldous peril in world history aommencW in 1933 with the if rise to power of Adolph Hitler wW the funnation of the National Socialisto at Hmg, Party in Germany. By order of the heinous diatatcrr, Jews were penft-ute d oa thr sole besiw of their religlow wW cWtwal he, stage o As a survivor of the Ausahwltz- Birkenau dmth James, ,you will newer fwget this terrible a&%Wt as all that is good .. in mankind, but you can now look with peace to the life you have since artAted for yarraelf in America. I Admired wW respect[ ar os a dyiwmic business and civic leaner, you curve aovex byre content to take a passive ralo in life. ".Iwough lerctmrest, exhibits, uod yews bode entitlere:, '"by bread Alone," you have wAl4 gty shared your experiences, as a Holocaust wry var, wad ywr efforts to h,;--oaden public awareness have tmm erxtesied into the courtram. Due largely to your efforts, the Superior Caul of Los And►slew took judicial notice of the fact that Jews were gassed to death art the Auschwitz concentration namp in pcIand. C;ertairily, you have helped to make Yes AU elwan of ':he scope " horrors of this Wan-imrde tragedy. , . The world r.-.;st alweys remeadw the barbarity of the Holocaust, last mob howswty be meatvd. Yet we must still 104* to the futm with the Woe that pw haps a wiser, braver "okincd has learand from " tragic lemma &W thM do Poo& at ail countries can coadtrrse to strive to create a new world, tm fr" vWvwev bate and fort, ' bWh with Pat ple"We, w* coWem late you od receiving the JdaW Karoo* HWWWtU*W Awwd 4W adate you ar cat of AUWI*a's thMt e100r be liens tar FaW E. Minor Prop d at of the Ohio Boats ZS* Lt Fhhe litli O t*t ` i •ram ��.�.u.r-ter.-+w.... oil •M A USOWT'l011 OF CWWAt1OM FOR MEN R&PUSTLIN , far over o Cdaade until tM end of Wor 1 d Mai 14 six million Jews wre k i l led IM the sotastiC ' gowide of ;44 wt rlalogustt aad WHO"* taro $*ople of G&fden Grove should not forpt 944 j •t�ocitNrs corlt�d dw'ie1 t+a• Kolacawst, sd •' ,,.. that such harrars will nerrarr be rrpa'itad; sad ' } lai A69 Hal 1krad 1 x to ire rah a WOMW 00144 a 1"P with his fasilyo woflmw "o shipped to I Ausch"Iti+ulrkwu for &late rahor � ttt~t+��ly f W"use they Mrs a4w tsNe. "d ati ;c whai 1 ibwa ted by taro AW1,CM)s In l%$f 1 lier� ., Lein was tam only faelly mow who .• ' Sury ivad the Aus Owl U Grots-Rosen &Ad AS. docauas Of h l$ axper lencOS O ►w l h4rOl l sta in challearo,�a afld vm a art deC1slon agalast tbd Ror it ion 16 tip i la Is tmt tk* M010caust rya i JW ISk Acax; and Mai Mareelsteln's Naloc"st Exhibit Is vldaly s"1 aivad to br i atWorss to Norm Arrmr ica MGM* Tb UNkto K IT MOLVED Vwt the City of Gvdan Grove• does hereby r"6901e and honor Me 1 INWRA s to in four his achieve~ts and Holocaust EA"Ibit 6t the N111h ?1o"o Art Gallery, troy March 20-00r i 1 22, 11669 es part of the Grrdon G,ro~e Syepho4y's multi-rredto prosv La tion fW 1 srae l 's 100 Alnn iv er sary. , t } ' Y�iiI7 I t •. , ., Le -w4t sun scvj(iooCogo4i�� fzogwo? of f4caa4w pma tv :., 1 , fro i 4le /J.-n c 0 rtnelst tt tutw* n/ a") Sotcere Ay 'I1401W rrec oo ,Si t and o c s r pjvrt t • true l 1,V 07#zm� r 10hr 1 i iA r , � r a i .�,�.• �7�i1, '�:� ��cam• .��..�.�,. � .�,�.,�, V ' 7 r � h' goo .1 e Of , . , �. ma R.BSOLUTION r `A SURVIVOR OiPlrffrm CAM"OF AUS Z-BIRXENAU A BUC IENWAL D,WHO,IN 1944 MAY 7-0. "2ND AT DAWN,SAW HIS MOTM AND TWO SISTERS AM01VG OTHER JEWISH WOMEN • AND CiIILblil!?,N'FROM ME HOMETOWN,LURED AND DRIVEN INTO GAS CHAMBERS DISGUISED 1R AS SHOWER KOOM9 AT THE AUSCHWrrZ-BIRKF.N AU F XTERMINATTON CENTER IN POLAND;AND f A LE-1`I'ER SENT TO HIM DATED NOVEMBER 20, 1980 AND DELIVT.RED BY UNrMD AIL fROM A SO-CALLED REVISIONIST GROU[ :N'FORRANCE, CALIFORNIA ,KNOWN AS THE "INSTITUTE FOR H1S7'MUCAL REVIEW" CHALLENGED HIM TO COME FORT! AN!) "PROVE THAT JEWS WERE GASSED IN GAS CHAMBERS AT AUSCHWrl ,•";AND HE WAS TO RECEIVE A $50,000 REWARD FOR SUCH PROOF AND MiLESS HE DID SO, :� LITE FOR HISTORICAL REVIEW AND ITS DIRECTOR,I.EWSS BRANDON,WOULD PUB- LICIZE THIS FACT TO THE MASS MEDIA;AND • , l EL MLRMEISTEIN AS A WITNESS AND VICTLA OF THAT BARBARIC EVi:n,KNOWN A TWRAZI HOLOCAUST, DECIDED, ON HIS OWN,AGAINST ALL ODCS,TO LEGALLY FIGHT AGAINST THE PROMULGATORS OF THE "BIG LIE"IN THE SUPERIOP.COURT OF THE STATE OF CAUFORNLA FOR THL COUNTY OF LUS ANGELES;AND AS AFt'ER LENGTH'!AI I)HB TED AR(;UMENTS 8Y DO I'll SIDES,ON OC`t OBER 9, 1981, `' •' ' ORASL , JUDGE 1110MAS T, JO)HNSON I'ECLARED THAT HIS COURT, „UNDER ::VI- �• DENCE CODE SECTION 452(H)DOES TAKE JUDICIAL NOTICE OF THE FACT"THAT JEWS WERE i• GASSED TO DEATH AT AUSCHWITZ CONCENTRATION CAMP IN POLAND" AND THAT THE HOLOCAUST IS NOT REASONABLY SUBJECT TO DISPUTE: OW INEff B ITE BE T KAT 81' THE ADOPTION OC TIIIS REyOLLTIU HE ii3S C'i�Y COUNCIL CnWNENDS MEL MERMELSI EIh WITH HEAR'i'FELT EMOTION FOR HIS DI81ERMWd%71ON AND t LJP—AGE ON BEHALF OF THE MILLIONS OF PEOPLE THAT DIED AND SUFFERED AT THE HAN.)$OF THE NAT.I137 YEARS AGO;AND Eff F&Mfi U&d=THAT MEL MERMELTMIN BE REMEMBERED AS A MAN WHO, AT 6"AT PERSONAL EIFIrE AND PAIN, ROSE UP AGAINST THE CRUELTY OF A FEW, SSN- 1'EIhlCWC THEIR IGNORANT VOICILI TO A RESOUNDING SILENCE, 50 THAT THT TRUE STOIt1 OF AA..PEOPLE'S SUFFE4'NG MAY NEVER BE FORGOTTEN. t'�I O�tff�V I HEREBY CERTIFY t11at the formpim resolution wta adopted by the Council of the City of Los Anples at In mestird held Decembcr IS. 1981. tract President of tthic Cu scil Councilman 2w Dkukt r� OF 1�E01tY- CIIr+ m—i =r4 bktdct -i clert