Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutConditional use permit 85-34 - Nibal Sidhan - Warner's Mobil - 7 Authtxttod to Putrhttt Aawrhs#v++ont>}of sa*Ina +duo p++biK notices ay ascrea a,•' the Superior caurt allQru*96114unty. (:aafomaA. Numter A-4214, ditad 29 1j*0fSMD*r. ttid 1, artd 1 A•21t1J1, doted tt June. 1963 4IL STATE OF CALIFORNIA APPROVED BY CITY COW-SCIL County of Orange ...r,� •»t,w. •..:,d..y �..... �,� ,,,-� (� so ,... w..,. rr w pps,t I9.L.� I am a Citizen of the United States and a resident of cs f.CLSts the County aforesaid; I am over the age of eighteen y ilot a party to or interested in the below -�--=w et entitled matter, t am a principa.1 clerk of the O�inge ent e+al7ator :-V 'Coast' DAILY PILOT, with which is combined the •, AprmTo - NEWS-PRESS, a newspaper of general circulatiort, ,,= co"OrTN"OF printed and published .`n the City of Costa Mesa. r ►tertrrTtea County 'of Orange. State of California, and that a 1a11ro�A'ai' , Public Hearing Kottct=- t iWavav 'k,otice of � "'� •'a booth Cur CW""MW A hm"Ingo Cewn- at.Chw4w•st tns 1+wM- k66* Doom Oft OrAv aooa of which copy attached hereto is a true and complete 2wdit ;' - copy, was printed and published in the Costa Mesa, _1"emu,a so paaargr vow 0" ao be Newport Beach, Huntington Beach, Fountain Valley, nWa rotsthw to*a IN* dowimm Irvine, the South Coast communities and Laguna DAM �►1-; f a.t.lies t i:�a . � Beach issues of said newspaper for 1 M;L� : -MK..rlt4!!+R:c�'R4€lti, to wit the issue(s) of vae rim No.�sica+- Ohio+d EWaeNernNa WS1. - toc.atKift 9W Awni-, can Arena.,gad+ Ira of f "&moon al N"Wi Gtlwt ash' November 21 19H a ,' opm as by Wo ti Wd 06 xawe Aa�ansna and u - 198 -49W�none. t add %a" to an,w+uvq ofto 198 S" l ow" iar c R A+oS says WV rsrwuos k ti.tntain.sawing,jam, 198 Nn W ft�ad In� atVV A tat wtdo w«t rw planters M,kv of-/ toot Igo- " tTA11�k 1Tn nq�+at b t:M« ft at a:' ;., t+wror (imhon�e.ntal ! declare. un jor, penalty of perjury, that the � w ° ink A�.af Mr ''foregoing Is`true and correct. 41.9400111 spniont or�b W we an 1M%ins 0*- 6icuted an NovQs3taer 21 5 r m em V WAtta.rttR• ._,�...�.w.� 1�8 .� �rons:.r.�r,�tw to** ari�atlMrtry.srw St'Costa Mesa, California Kt trrrKardnMtM aM/r1M�IW tWv��l,'M MrO�F ; JA /uMliiflR:uM1Ml1r°tMw dw Signature cffy .' ca�ii+ta'f1orM+wnaflswM�lry lhtM�IrML Ago .. ... , ...._...... .........,. .., .+.w... rv-•-w .-•.,.,o:...•,..a^5 ,t ,.fOy:llli.• fCY� ' _. _. .. ..,.._... r.L wt y SURROUNDiNG LAtiD ',�JSE, ZONING AND GENERAL PLAN DESIGNATIONS: North of Subject�Prtperty; `1 GENMAI,: PLAN DESIGNATION: Gene"ai C•,Nmmercial ZONE: C4-Highway 'c om;nercial Mstrict LXND USE: Gasoline Servf.ce . Station East of Subject Propprt:y GENERAL PLAN DESIG14ATION: General,•Commercial ZONE: C2-community Ausiiiess District LAND USE: Gasol?.ne Service Station South of Subject Property: • GENERAL PLAN DESMNATION: General Commercial ZONE: r_q-Highway Commercial District LANK USt: Retail Establishments West of -,Ubject Pro ty: GENERAL PLAN DES,IGN:TION: General Commercial ZONE: C4-Highway Commercial District LAND USE: Liquor Store and Fast Fold Establishment 4 . 0 ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: TheL proposed project is categorically exempt ,pursuant to -I-Qction 15jol ,. from the provisions of the CalifornVa Environmental Quality Act. a 5. 0 ISSUES, AND AANPLYSIS: S T.ne, cenexal issue regLrding Use Permit No. 85-34` was the discussion regarding snack items displayed for retail sale in the office of the subject gasoline service station . The discussion at the dune 26 , 1985 Board of Zoning Adjustments (QZA') meeting differentiated between packaged snack items which can be legally consumed while in transit verso., be,pr or wine which cannot be legally consumed whil'6, in transit. The BZA determined that beer and wine sales are nit' appropriate for snack, shop operations . Also, ir. .thi4 case, ;,there is .a' very lar5e scale liquor establishment (Liquor Barn ) located adjacent t, acid another nei�ghbonc�od liqucr store" across, Springdale` Street to the east ' The close proximity of" off sale liquor, establishments° was taken into conbiderat,ion by the , BZA which further ju. tified' prohibiting the sale of beer and w1he in a snack s•hcpg , operation• within an existing - gasoline service station . Presently, beer. an3 - Wine •saleH are permitted at ,gab `rltations pursuant to `sfction ;9.430�: 8 ` (W o C2, �Co6miih!t ';Business 'District. Convenience marv,ets .combined with p j ' � gasoline stations are ern tte s,ab ect'- o� thy. t . review and approval of a conditional use- permit , The intent of this VS/85 5taf f' Re�nai•t p,.ot ision. Js�;b s e d an the'` rationale tha-:: convenience markctq, offer an , i;�creased_. p.�tray, of goods whicU�;`..re usually., nog c0sumed in, t'r'ansit but .r a rather : tznspost2a to a deatination for. consumpt'i��n ( i. e . `-a. home , picnic, or a similar . recreational; parsu*,t) . Snap':k :e"opa qffer a lini tad, amount of ,packaged goods and the inclusion' of beef and, vine sales. cannot he justified. 6 . 0 ".!RECOMMENDATfON: Staff recommends that the Planning Commission uphold the 'aaard .af . Zor:i.n- Ad juatments ijppr:,val of Use Perni r No. 85-34 which p ahi�i is ` beer and wine sales . I FI�NRINNGS FOR APPROVAL: t r I } . The establishment , Iraintenance and operation of the 'usE will . not be detrimental to : a . The general welfare of persons restdinq or working ,in the vicinity; b . Property and improvements i;i th\" uicirtity., cif such use or W. 1 ding. 2 . The prcp*gin 'l Is consistent with the Ci- ty 's rjeoer-tl. Plan of: Land Use. .r•., CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL: 1 . A revised site plan of suitable scale depicting the j modifications described herein stall tie submitted and approyeo prior to issuance or a building permit. a . Landscaping in compliance with 5. 948: . 1 . 1 . , I b. Mininum of 5 parking spaces in 'compliance with•`Article '979. 2 . Landscape and irrigation plan ;co the Department of DeJe3opment Services and Public works for review and approval . 3. 'scapinq shall be installed and approved prior to mew use . 4 . The development shall comply with all applzcak lc provlaiotts of the Ordinance Code, BuLiding Aivision, and Fire Department', .,_ 5 . T a major identification sign shall he removed ''or 'altered to comply with Article 948 'within `ninet`�' (90 : days. g p y eat• y F . All 9i ns shall 'cam 1 with Artie 'd8 and 976 .of 't�te Huntington . Beach +ordinance Code , 7. ,A revised Cerc.ifLcat4 ofaccupancy ,,ahaIl be i.pawid: 8. No beer and wine wiles are erm to P d $tiff RQpsart — �/S/85 --3- t29984 ) - , . rt..a+r r.rwipr.,tt -, ac:•.� ATTA�NTS .1 . Area Map ' ` ~� t 2. Site plan and floor plan dated June 6 , 1985 3 . Minutes From the .Tune 26, 1985 Board of Zoning Adjustments meeting 4 . - Letter dated July 5 , 1985 JWP: R : kla Sta'f -Report 8/Q85 4 i2998d) g: RI ± Ftt t� Ri Al t?1 RE •� 1 R! ' t R 1Rt t i •►c. ii it 1 -�"t � 1 Al ) • R t R l `rRl Rl RI R!Ri RE o RCS I � 1 �___•______ ! t �4 RI i R s , 4 1MH E:4�: R 3 Itl itI ca C2 ,R `—,r 3 1 a3 �. # R3 -} •.'`J 2 J RE 1 Ri J Rl Rl Rt i• L `_.�' 1 RE - R! Ri t.F �a� r► R } �.!i..�. pmm�u R2 Rl �. , I ! f _ f Rr 1 CF-R ✓ f / r RE I " l � Rl Rl C_ •?� IRI h' Rt Rl i ,_.� Rl RE - ac i t at rib RIB .; %/ -1 ' R7 m Rl RJ I i _ Rf P.! Ri s RI RI � t 1 � --- � R l R I 1te --'1 i s •� R! �••.r rr..;,_. ; Rt, 1 J�� RJ 8 L ►� RI R 1 R t R 1 R tCC, - fc' - x MLWTP%GtOA Eller - '"UNT1NGTOW !EACH PLANNP#G DIVISION � _ _ .. .i'ti r .�..�t;t4tif K+e►••'Ir•••••/r.�rtlr•1'4 .......�+..•+tlaMAIM'+r•.. ,...�"� ��k).l �.•K1 ING DALE •2 r2 FULL SERVE CLO 0=0 SITE ILI I . RCFLLC ~'4r""�;�r; ;;, .i: hLL GROP-.' NCE CODE "J*- r REQUIR'. i:t•i C5. f BY CIA i E i , a i f 1 •4 •• •4 UJ • i 1 •,,e��� l�`� � • ..• . • V l L/ v C + r . • W w ••r Ld /, • ! r uj r , >yh 1: ♦ .�41�r>� .'�5 r •/r )try t t 1 t A .1` .`I' t� � 1 I Y(mow +►.M.r�r�r.ar•+Y'1M++w.►I`. . �4. r.w�•.M *1` /�'�- .�::., .��.� �� -1�f�.i. �_ G .�}�.;`r?� �. .r i '�•i'�l '.ti 1 rr i 77=.r:4 'kr thntiled to P bl'Sh Advertistmonls of ail Mu1ds►nduda puGK notoGes by Day,.•• of the superior cowl of orange Count), CO-for•i,a, Number A.6114, dated :9 Saalembar. 19tft. And 110i�1C s A 11431, dated 11 June. 1963, �' � Olr3 •�,�`/ COMlfflii��'tl ,,111 STATE OF tALIFORNIA er'dposlorTM>w+?A.�*� �+c�•✓I` �v�+�..•� f.: County of Orange o ..owe ►tort. •c..n.W4 c .c.w ;.+1dhM Q +•' t{C ... .�,., .. .� N , .6A 14 PCs c:iarw+."� q;yC�r tA`tltw. // i am a Citizen of the United States and a res;dent of Nwtual0n' oof►' Cry the County aforesaid; I am over the age of f ighteen atf�s�wndetilr years. and not a party to or interested in the below oalecMtasnetswe�111111111110; entitled matter. I am a principal clerk of the Orang .0%00 a �' , Coast DAILY PICOT with which is combined NEWS-PRESS, a newspaper of general cir alto printed and published in the City of Cos Mesa, twp~tip" �%� "` talOM }i6M4 County of Orange. State of California, and at a ' L016A'fM1Mi Alt'tZ rriti►i*k Public Hearing r Aven�w'et lfta Notice of 9ort+sc,*,-W rrMr:.AvOus --. PI To wow ah'�tk lMrt'��fMMo�tt efNtio�•,oN•tyr +t 1�+we Owl- of which copy attached hereto is a true and complete 1 ti�e1111t, M we ttnwt 1tl xn copy, was printed and published ir. the Costa Mesa. dAleoR y�'i T M AfM�?1t+eM1 Newport Beach. Huntington Beach. Fountain Valley, r�s eC ttMwr ewe+.��.OA Irvine, the South Coast communities anti Laguna Beach issues of said newspaper for „1,,.*,'mc e anal �i ooxmft=14vgx*&akz to wit the issue s) of , aMtrf>tMe �i16 Al'IIMeM��►� October 10 198 5 q'tf�ItUcIR . .. •�!!�:P�t+�litlrptlL..rt•i� � � riot`: ON MW 19ff 'u�"t E,tMi, 1e�'A�rb�Mhdt�hA: 'ice nr sri>r1idl.�iA�. . 198_.._._ ?toe ar ttr>rMwr f� ,all o�etMhM tNow+M1 19a fW I declart;l. under Penalty ut perjury, that the id1"1►c � i foregoing is true and correct. f i.�' 1. 1 y 75+.+M.Y.r+..r.•M Executed on October 1 1 at Costa Mesa, aiitornia. r C,t Signature ,1 t usp - CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 2000 MAIN STREET CALIFORNIA 92648 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK November 18, 1985 Nibal F. Sidhom Warner Mobil 5972 'alarner Avenue Huntington Beach, CA 92647 The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at its reqular mret.ing hold Monday, November 18, 1985, denied your appeal to the planning Commission approval of Condition No. 8 of Use Permit No. 85-34. This is a final decision. You are hereby notified that pursuant to provisions of Section 11194.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure of the State of California you have ninety days from November 19, _1985 to apply to the courts for ,judicial review. If you have any questions regarding this matter, pleas- contact our office - 536-5227. Alicia M. Wentworth City Cleric ANN:CB:js Encloeure cc: '.City Attorney . Developmert, Services Director ti , . ITMy1w,�+t.J 1�49N2ifl REQUEST FOR CITY UN ACTlOh! ate October �?1 1985 Submitted to: Honorable Mayor and City Council Charles W. Thompson, City Administratorc.0 Submitted by: � James W. alxn Director , evelo ;Went Services Prepared by: � P � � D P Subject: APPEAL TO PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION TO UPHOLD CONDITION NO. 8 OF USE PERMIT NO. 85-34 WHICH PROHIBITS THE SALE OF BEER AND WINE AT AN EXISTING GASOLINE SERVICE STATION Consistent with Council Policy? [ 1 Yes ( l New Policy or Exceptioll Statement of Issue, Recommendation, Analysis, Funding Source,Alternative Actions,Attachrnents: The City Council , at a September 16 , 1985 public hearing , voted to uphold the Planning Commission 's action to require Condition tio, 8 of Use Permit No . 35--34 . The condition prohibits the sale of beer and wine at an existing Mobile Service Station at the southwest corner of Warner and Springdale. The applicant , Nibal F. Sidhom, did not receive an appropriate notice of the September 16, 1985 public hearing. Therefore , it has been determined that a second public hearing be conducted with complete public notification . This will provide the applicant an opportunity to represent: himself at a public hearing before the City Council , ATTACHMENT: RCA dated September lb , 1985 JWP: FW: kla II '' ( 3457d ) i • NO 9/0 September 261 1985 tt , City Council City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach , California 92645 { Re: USE PERMIT N0. 85 .,4 Gentlemen: This letter is to inform you that we were unable. to attend the City Council meeting on the 16th. of September due to the . date receipt of the notice and council agenda. When the notice arrived and it was apparent that woe wculd ,not be able to attend, we spoke to Mr. Bob Franklyn by- phone and he recommended that we send this letter of explanation and 4 request another date for the hearing of our ease . i We would appreciate a date by early November 1985. Should you have any ouest.ions or comments please call 842-8506 . sshank you for your cooperation. Sincerely, U1 r+ibal E?. Si om WARNER 'S M4 IL 5972 Warner Avenue Huntington Deach, Calif.orni,-, 92647 SEP 30 96 CITY,OF HUtMN ?ON 8J1GN CITr COUNCIL OF RCE RE10"06 T FOA CITY GOUN ACTION r. Date _ ^,r„September as 1985 Submitted to: Honorable Mayor and City Coun::i1 Submined bv: Charles W. Thompson, City Administrator e'w Prepared by: James W. Palin, Director , Development Services Subject: APPEAL TO PLANNING COMMISSION' S ACTION TO UPHO CONDITTCN NO. 8 OF USE PERMIT NO. 85-34 WHICH PROHIBITS THE SALE aF VEER AND WINE AT AN EXISTING GASOLINE SERVICE STATION Consistent wti th Gouncll Policy? Yes Kisw Policy or ExcWtion + Statement of Issue, Recommendation, Analysis, Funding Source, Alternative Anions, Attachnmts: STATEMENT OF ISSUE: Transmitted for your consideration is an appeal filed by Nibal Sidhan , owner of Warner 's Motile, to the Planning Commission 's action to uphold Conditiun No. 8 of Use Permit No. 1 5�-3d (Board of Zoning Adjustment approval ) which prohibits the sale of beer and wine in a snack shop operation within an existing gasoline service station . The appeal is based on the applicant 's assertion that there are other locations in Huntington Beach that combine the sale of gasoline with beer , wine and food at the same site . RECOMMENDATION: Planning Commission action and recommendation: 019 MOTION BY ERSKINE AND SECOND BY ROWE, THE PLANNING COMMISSION DENIED WITH FINDINGS AN APPEAL TO CONDITION 1.10. 8 OF USE. PERMIT NO. 85-34 WHICH PROHIBITS THE SALE OF BErR AND wrNE BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: AYES: Roue, Winchell , Schumacher. , Porter , Erskine NOES: Li!-engood ABSENT: Mirjahangir ABSTAIN: None Staff recorr..mendation: Deny the appeal and uphold the Planning Commission ' s acti-:n Lo prohibit the sale of beer and wine in a snick shop operation , within ' 'an existing gasoline service station. ANALYSIS:`.. On Jtine, .S`, 1985 , Nibal Sidhan, owner of Warner 's . Mobi'1 , applied , td.; the Board of Zoning : AdJustatenta for a use .'permit . to allow"a snack t , shop aeration in an existing gasoline service station located on thle southwest corner of Springdale Street and Warner Avenue. Use Permit No. 85 -34 was conditionally approved on June 26, 1985 . The applicant is appealing Condition Number 8 which states 0110 beer 'oi. wine sales are permit,:ed . " The Board of Zoning Adjustments differentiated between packaged Items which can i:e legally conBt-med while in transit and items that cannot be legally consumed while in transit. Packaged foods were determined by the Px=d of Zoning Adjustments to be appropriate items for a snack shop operation; beer and wine were determined to bf - i'napprorriate items for a snag; shop operation. Convenience markets offer an increased erray of goods which are usually not consumed in transit but rather are transported and consumed at ?some, a picnic, or similar recreational pursuit . Snack shops offer a limited amount of packaged goods generally consumed in tran�slt . Therefore, the sale of beer arad wine was determined to be inappropriate for a snack shop. The City Council has adopted a position to direct staff to process a code amendment that would exclude the sale of gasoline and alcoholic beverages at the same site . On August 5, 1985 the planning { Commission voted to uphold the Board of Zoning Adjustments exclusion of beer and wine sales at this location . The Planning Commission went a step further by voting in a motion to support the City Council 's direction for staff to process a code amendment which would prohibit the sale of beer and mine in conjunction with the .male of gasoline . There was a tie vote of 3 to 3 (1 absent ) on the motion , therefor , the motion failed. j ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: The proposed project is categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15301 from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act . i FUNDING SOURCE: , riot applicable. ALTERNATIVE ACTION: i Approve the appeal and allow the applicant to sell beer and wine within a snack shop operation at: the subject gasoline service station. ATTACHMENTS: 1 . Letter dated August 1,4 , 1985 2 . Staff Report dated August 50 1995 1 JWP:RLF: kla '(3202d ) Rc.N 9/ 6/a5 - - : August 14 , 1985 Honorable Mayor Ruth Bailey and Huntington Beach laity Council 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach , California 92648 ,�', ic'l�r�frfltra • � Jf �r� p�,Afi Re : USE PERMIT NO. 85-34 J f? F'4el Honorable Mayor Ruth Bailey: j� J �+ I would like to appeal the decision of the Planning Commission denying my request for use permit 0 85-34 . Had this denial been based on a law I would not continue in my appeal. However,. it was made clear that this was arbitrary decision and that I must appeal. I base my appeal on the following: 1. That there are other locations in Huntington Beach that sell gasoline , food , beer and wine all from one store/station Ue. Station on Goldpnwest and Bolsa Ave. ) . 2 . Since there are two liquor stores tone in the same shopping center were this station is located and one across the street• ) and a Thrifty Drug which all tsall bee: and wine close by it is 4 reasonable that we could have mutual customers shoping for gasoline then beer or wine on the same trip . My point is that ,'I;aking available snack foods , soft drinks , beer and wine at Warner' s Mobile creates no added risk to my customers and the public but only the same one stop convienance found already at other store/stations in H+an:ington Beach . It is also possible that new revenue sources could coma out of this as those one time customers on their way to a picnic or to the beach might purchase that last: minute item here when they wouldn' t otherwise ,make a special stop in rcute at a local store. obviously , I offerthe other local stores selling these items no serious competition due to the small nature of this convienar!ce/snack shop compaired Lo their large inventured stores . 3 . I would like to mention that the Chairman of the Planning Commiss- ion voted in my favor and cited it unfair to not give me the same kind of "use permit" that has been issued to other stations (allowing the same use that I am currently requesting ) . Other members of the Planning Commission turned down my request on an emotional and arbitrary basis . I now formally request this injus- tice to be righted in the interest of fair and equal treatment in view of past approval of this simular request made by :other` stations in Huntington Beach. Res a fully,, a ;. N1.bal F. Sid m WARNER'S "J. D lh 5972 Warnur Avenue H%i4itington Beach, California 92647 S huntington beach development services department ; z rl ET..r.wr■r�■rr�■■■rr �Mw �raw�rwrr�.�■g■r■r.� Planning Commission FROM: Development Services DATE: August 5 , 1985 SUBJECT: APPEAL OF CONDITION t8/UCE PERMIT NO. 85-34 I - (BZA. APPROVAL) APPLICANT: Warner 's Mobil DATF ACCEPTED: : Jury" 31 , 1985 REEOUEST: Appeal. of condition f8 MANDATORY PROCESSING DATE: of BZA approved Use Permit actober 1 , 985 Na. 85--34 which excludes the s•xle of beer and wine in an approved snack shop ZONE: C4-Highway operation within an Commercial District existing gasoline service station. -'� LOCATION: 5972 Warner Ave. G£tiERAI. PLAN: t;enera1 Commercial ACREAGE: 9 ,000 square foot lot EXISTING' USE: Gasoline.. Service . St tfon 1 .0 SUGGESTED ACTION: Up and condition 8 whi.cs, ro.�ibits tsale of beerPand w . ne Uphold the Board of 26ning Adjustments approval : ©5--34 ondi� an � `• P '� o d wine ', at an existing gasoline service statics based on the findings outlined . in Sectioli 6.0 of this report. 2 O CENERAG INFORMATION: . .. .. On,: June; 6, 1985, Warner s Mobile applied to the Board `of Zoe~ ' 'Adju,stments for a use permit to allow a snack sho operatio►tilin: an he -so+ .et tndVWaxneraAvenueocaUAe Permit Nou' 85-34 .wasnes of existing. gaso):i 5pr. ingdale Strp conditionil'ly Approved on - June 26, _ 1985 T)ie applicant '`ia :'Appealing condition 'number 8 which states 'No beer . and wine salea are permitted. " �.. COOP, Load :� - _ - n 0-1 E L.V_S r7 co VENOING RE IS y . s I tinute,, , H. B. Board of %oning Adjustments Pa o 7 ice.i . 2 1e granting �'," a conditional exception is necessary in uc er to pre1se ve the enjoyment of one o ore substantial pro erty rights . ! 1 3 . The g nting of Conditional Exceptign' No. 85-33 will not be materia ly detrimental to the publ. c weltare: , or injurious to grope y in the same zone �:la sifirations . _ The side yard is current y enclosed by a 6 fg6t high block wall which screens the side yard . a • The granting the condi�t�tonal exception will not adversely affect the Gene al Plan f the City of Huntington Beach . CONDITIONS OFAPPROVA G 1 . The site plan , `IC or --i)lans , and elevations received and dated June 6 , 985 sha'411 be the approved layout . w . The develolj1m nt shall cod ly with all applicable provisions of the G inanc:- ��ode , Uni ,rm Building Code, Building Divisi , and Hire Department,. 3 . The/3pplican't is encouraged to "provide additional nd,c_aping on the interior side of the block wa11 to buffer the proposed addition . j AYFr . Cranmer , Evans , Smith , Vincent N -5: Godfrey SENT: None USE: PERMIT 140 . 85-•34 ` Applicant : Warner 's Mobil A request to permit a snack shop in an existing service station , This request is covered by Categorical Exempt iun , Class 1 , California Environmental Quality Act , 1979 . Scott Ifess reported that staff recommends approval with conditions and recommended a revised site plan depicting the modif. icatinns be submitted. Glen Godfrey- suggested adding a condition to limit the size of'. the shelves and cooler; to what is nhown on the plan. t - " • Daryl Smith opened the public hearing . • r , • T AQh f Minutes , If . e. Board of Zoning Adjustments j June 26 , 1985 Page a 11iba.1 Sidhem, the appl i cAnt was present. He asked the -13bard wily, there was a condition that excluded beer or wine sales as other , service stations in Huntington Beach sell beer and wine . There was general discussion by the Board members regarding the problems that have occurred with this type of use and indicated that. the City Council has requested this be part of the conditions for approval . There were no other persons to speak For or against; the i t:em ..and the puh.lic hearing was closed. UPON MOTI.ON EsY EVANS AND SECOND BY CRANMFR, USE PERMIT NO. 85--34 WAS CONDITIONA-1,LY APPROVED, BY THE FOLLOWING VOTE: FINDINGS FOP APPROVAL : i . The establ ishmpnt , .maintenance and operation of the use wi I I not ' be detrimental to: : I a . The general welfare of persons residing or working in , . the vicinity ; I h. Property and impvovements in the vicinity of sucir usLl or building . 2 . 'The proposal is consistent with the City ' s General Plan of land Use . ` CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL: � i ti 1 ♦ A revised site plan of suitable scale depicting the � modifications described herein ,stall be submitted and i approved prior to issuance of a building permit . a . Landscaping in L-omnliance with S. 9482 . 1 . 1 ♦ b , Minimum of 5 parking spaces in compliance with Artinle 979 . , j 2 . Landscape and irrigation plan to the Department of, Development Services and Public Works for rv%view �and approval . 3 (.and:;capi nd shall be installed and appr ove'd Apr io"r ' t'o new use, ( 2811d ) _g� 6j26/85 5 Mtrsutes , H B . ,RoAr("' f honing Ad justmenrs ' June 26, 1985 Page g r 4 . The development shall comply with all applicable pravisions � =ti` . of the Ordinance Code , Building Division , and Fire ►r., Dep. > tmen t . .• - 5 . The major identification sign sha11 be r. e•moved or altered to .omtily with Article 948 wit:hin ninety ( 90 ) clay:', . 6 . All -signs :;hall roni ly wi t l) Ari icles 948 ana 916 of L1)v , Hunt i ndton Beach Ordirsanc,� Cocle . 7 . A revised Certificate of Occupancy shall be issued . j 8 . No beer and wine sales are permitted, 9 . :his Use Permit shall not become effective until an 'Acceptance of Conditions ' form has been signed and notarized by tbe -applicant and the property owner . 10. The Boa:-d of Zoning Adjustm`nts reserves the right to revoke " this. Ilse Permit if any violation of these conditions of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code occurs, 11 . The food area shall be in substantial conformance to these floor plans dated 6-6-85 and shall not exceed a floor area of 120 square feet . AYES : Crannier , Evans , Godfrey, Smith , Vincent NOES : None A0S114T: None. USE 'E:R M i T NO. 8 5-3 5 ���-��-� ,�• Applic t ; William R . EllisJSeacliff Village A request t rmi t a temporary (one clay ) outdoor event - July 41 1985. This request is covered by Categorical Exemption , Class 11 , California Environnen - 1 Quality Act , 1970. Staff recommended approval -with con:litions as presented . Daryl Smith opened the public hea•x,ing. William Fllis , the applicant was present . Re stated that all of the conditiops have been met . �. � 811d 6/Zb/85 - • • • C t :AQfi 7 f I Jury . 5 , 1985 Mr. Glen K. -Godfrey , Secretary ' Board of Zoning Adjustments '71 P. 4. Box 190 r, �'►'J Huntington Beach,. California 92648 j Re : USE PERMIT No. 85- 34 Dear Sir : I thank the board for approving the plans to incorporate a' snac.1 shop in Warners ' s Mobil . However, I am appealing the "Condition or approval 08 . No beer and wine sales, are permitted . " . If this condition is based on city law I Srill i accept it . If there is no legal reason for this condition please accept this letter as an appeal. . I base my appeal on the fact that there are other locations in Huntington Beach that sr:11 gasoline , food, beer and wine all from one store/statior►. Further , since there a e two liquor stores ( one in the same shopping center were my station is located and one across= the street) and a Thrifty Drug which all ,ell becr and ► ine close by it .is reason,ablo - that we could have mutual customers shoping for gasoline ; t.h(:rz beer o.,, wine on the sums trip. !Sy point is that mailing available slack foods , soft drip:ks , beer and Mine at earner' s Mobil creates no added risk to :ay customers and the public but anly the same one stop convieriance found at other store/stations in the Huntington Beach . It is also possible that new revenue sooces could come out of this as those one time customers on their way to a picnic or to the beach might purchase that last minute item hQre when they wouldn ' t other- wise make a special stop in route at a 2ocai store. obvious ly, I could offer the otter local stores selling thecae items no serious competition due to the small nature of this convienance snack shop c:ompaired to their large invelntored stores . Waiting your response on clarification and hopefully ► adjustment to condition 8, I thani: you for taking time, in reviewing this appeal . Respect f ul.l , Nibal F. Sxdhorn WARNER ►,9 14DBI L 5972 Burner Avenue Huntington Beach, '.California 92647 : I y f • CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH. ZDOO MAIN srREET. CALIFORNIA 926413 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK Cctober 22, 1985 i `libal F. 5 idhom Warner's Mobil Service 5972 Warner Avenue Huntington Beach, CA 92647 The City Council of the City of Huntington Brach at its regular meeting held October 21, 1985 .approved your reauetit for a continuance of the public hearing on your appeal to .1, ember 10, 1985. Please enclose $30.00 pursuant '11a Resolution Na. 5159 of the City Council to cover the costs For saic, runtinuance. Alicia M. Went—..orth City Clerk AM:CB:,j3 Enclosure + frai-hin+s 71443642vi "` ST,,TEMENT -,- IN ACCOUNT WITH CityHuntingtonof Be' kh lfuntins xs Beach, Calif. October 22 29 .85 l . Nibal F. Sidhcm Warner's &bil Service 5972 Warne. . Avenue Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Continuonce or Public Nearing $30.00 Plense make check payable to: CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK 2000 MAIN STREET HUNTINGTQN BEACH, CALIF, 92648 771 'j!j1�l.a��w.MI:!.��C•WL•+.,f,'..�:.ti...�:e�.;r•.+...trl��y;.-AFA h air j �� cF4 << � ./ Co Nu NT IA/ l _ vt � f F c a ab 1 SENT ��E 1..^1. 4 ✓ G j�o jTrj �JE r T if . AsP(�E�IA !F �'o c/ Plot C To lr rf ocioi3fl'� R c fRG fR tit Hax%� y r c w ,v r° j /DPP 0jo VC .-T sea Fie FL o +Y? E� t�I E� � Ri ✓ i T\ �✓F 7-1 d J. %° U lit? �E A N Y I r" �- Co v PE re A 7 / s1NcF� � �y sEr�� 'C� (�V G � .T /L/� 1 IaI l �Q p N i�!C x try R t .S .:l 1 OW LEGAL NOTICE'. NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING RE-REAM OF APPEAL TO PLANNING COMMISSION'S APPROVAL OF i CONDITION $8 OF APPROVAL Or Uyz Pmn 085--34 NOTICE IS RMBY GIVEN that the Huntington Beach City Council will hold a public hearing in the Council Chamber arc the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Hain Street, Huntington Beach, Gslifornia, on the date anal at the time indicated below to receive and consider the: statements of all persons who wiah to be heard relati,ee to the application described below. DATE: Monday, Octaber 21, 1935 TINE: 7:30 P.M APPLICATION NUMBER: Use Permit td5--34 LOTION: 597; Warner Avenue on the southwest corner of Varner Avenue 1 and Springdale Street. i PROPOSAL: To consider an appeal filed by NibaZ F. Sidhas; owner of Warners Mobil, to the Planning Co=ission's action to uphold the Board of Zoning Adjustment's approval of Condition $8 of Use Permit #85--34 which prohibits the sale of beer and wine at an existing gasoline service station in the C4 (Highway Commercial) zon-IrS district. Public hearing held 9/16/85 and is being r-i:eard as appellant, inadvertantly was not notified. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: The proposed project is categorically exempt pursuant to Section 15301 from the provlaions of the Califoroda Environmental Quality Act. ON FILE: Documents regarding the proposal Are on file in the Development Services Department. ;ALL INTERESTF.n PERSONS are invited to attend said hearing an,; express ' Opinions or submit evidence for or against the. application as outlAned above. All applications, ezhibita, and descriptiana of this p-,oposal,,'tre' oa file with the Office of the City Cleric, -2000 Main Street, HuntirAton Beach, California, for inspection by the public. HUNTMTON BEACH CITY COUNCIL By: Alicia M. Wentworth ,� f y Clty 'Clerk Y 1, Pitoae (714) 536'MOS.,, rr 1 ' r .. Y • NOTICE .OF •MLIC HEARINGAt p : •H WTICE 15 HEREBY GIVEN that the' n will hold a .,.' i'UE3LIC RINrG -In the Couni Chamber� .at the � °'`f•enter, fi e, u r, California. on the date and at the time- Indicated below to receive and consider the statements of all persons who wish to be heard relative to the- application described below. DATE: --ad-ay,, t APPLICATION', NUMBER: S ►�TM' '� APPLICANT: t LoWlON: �d�-�a�--{fi t - • ' PROPOSAL: At6,a4jddi ti onal 3000 square foot building to a preyjJ30. y 3 zpproved" J!r ' center plan. roposed to t provide a 20-foot setback from the Beach Boulevard right-ef-Wa _ as the t r Wnicipal Code requires a 3 nt .yard setback from Beach rd. A t�ofi{Ce of Fxc3.cu�•-� c indicating L'R' -th3s,, atian - sr�'r�rss is exer�tm enYironac�tnl impact d►�curnention. _ " - - aM Fit* oo Q , xp.re2s 000ORS v ALL If�(TERESTEiI:PER50�lSwnrre invited to attend said bearing and t 4 or subedit evidence for or._agalnst the a lication as outlirgd above , . { lic+rtlons e0lbits-.--and descriptions of this pebposal are on file Al ,� • •.•: �. ..., at 't i� i tr: .l:f 'Y'T. .Y a•,`.f » � `i+,r!�• 1 1.. .for-inspectlon by the public. < A -. 4Tl :+► ' s , rr •, r' i 7{ y..-•Xr�etr» r •` + 4��f��Cr�0. '� ' •` . _•• «4 r•,.. '+. ..,«.♦ wn'.slr�� .•dl 1*1���'''�',f�,N�•1r �' �� ..� M j'. ,� `., `.• W�+� y�~�"ii'��., '♦�3�' t�,yrx+(�"• � - ;:� w � ?�y.,`�,; �•.. "•'wttt�!•• ,.'��1.._ w'- 'r 1s4�1-�y�,.♦Pa^ �`u` ;+'�.h, �'-!�..i�r+a•h K,-'.�' e'r,•,� � Y��•r • �`•�����5 '�. T ."A�-'L� f'.�,;�+�•„ .,�" t "t� ���••.t'�.`'�','l.'i-jt`-►'::. r. _ I.w .' k,. �"�*•��+�'���',.����.r';: . �+��y`.r~`�'ti+3��y`y'��' ������+ .A ?�i+,•..J. �...a:.y�. �Tti.1Gi'y ''�' •. � .. .>.1- •t f► ', - � •, � �. .t :. .1 x,-4Y►", ..._ '� .°�i:R,a -,t .-�- -* :•. ♦ •...! ✓ ,. �� �1 �, ,•.t,��i.-� .e '�• � '•.�.� '+1^^`.• tr+r 4C.. -' t ,2i:� ,.!•�` .Isy "' •-:y�.�,• `�"�`�`�kj.a�° ,.,�w.y� R+-it'. F�+`.r[�.►*.�•r•���•". �t�'l+.f` �j".'�t:'» ��`+� i�►si�;. +M+ 1`.1 �,�+rf..••1'.ir.� �r�.�A•wiAt: �, iw,... �+n4r K..tir.,t....:::-1.i�a�tl±-'7fi ., k���F_s�ap','•.J�...."•'.�:��7 ''u�.r-..rl. ♦.� < ``ttl . .+��Ar.�flr�il'l ai.r- *,-•�la . !� �r -t ..A,.rf« ��� 'iy - wl.,:ut .�!_� t�Rl-iuf- ar�rr. 1.L Ff' .`k�_ .,.:.�`.': ;.:S1E ;•�'`w , f Authoruad 10 Pu0111 Advertisements of all kinds►ntludmp Dubl►c notices by Decree of the SUPe►+or Court of O1an9e Counlr, Calibrma, Number A•6214, dates! 29 September, 1961, and (4fi�' . A A A•24831. dated 11 June, 1963. STATE OF CALIFORNIA �I County of ©range w.«K pool" ,a..n" j mof "s a++aOa N r1 .n r Pa .{ "Risk WK Oa cohlom "dim 7 M I am a Citizen of the United States and a resident of y �" the County aforesaid; I am over the age of eighteen V yeas, and not a party to or Interestod in the below PUMC entitled matter. t am a pair-cipal cleric of the Orange F tA1t11C tI�AfMlMr} Coast DAILY PILOT. with which is Combined the t, Y: K fip y�, r.•yr, NEWS-PRESS. newspaper of general circulation, APPWVAC Of printed and published !n the City of Costa Mesa, r cavlarteN,rtt'. Cot►nty of Orange. State of California, and that a 'UH�IIM1 CW lea Public fring Notice of ..,_ « lydrfcs :la rt��leaY. ,?xoeh*dinMCVrcam- �ct Ina CM W"r►ftLO» � AlcAch, S In Ins OCvrit:tl J C:himtar o1; tho Civic 014:v��„�, ,►..�ii.a.' of which copy atiachac! hereto is a true and complete rerrer.;lt>an C++ ts; ... ' at 1ne tsxa 0 W F w copy, was printed anCl published in the Costa Mesa, na rpoot tlW*0ty of ofts- tc:i�s+:.r.+oRr�,th4 �cls t?ay i Newport Beach, Huntington Beach, Fountain Valley, Irvine, the South Coast communities and Laguna 0 WittYxwF$W• WWI. oknar: ru•;WW r4eZ( Beach Issues of said newspaper for 1 imp mw�y CCaOxEMjjyW.Wee#M-40 wit the i3su s) of ""06NofZP** itrrrr d l�r:erro wsrs ai,in �u�liscrgplrs�w*r,rtae t+ck�. September 5 5 Tim intFdpt+►vsr �'rt,444ts 07 �r�11 10 irx�tta al'.?71_lYact'�mr.A Wet A an Aa��togq t Lit t 199_____— rw et Kenwr. wryer Sind, bear rs+�:,r$tlon: q 196 mt��ot09 i h�l ,n >�it.: s;.tnsiaE 198 Old e1.atlanr0 t1rAt�t Me�ktit t 9 8 c�Mrtc?OiMi ea+, . declare, under penalty of perjury, that the ., foregoing is true and cori-act. p�rr+elreet:, E.�►@Cated on September 6 198 5 ; `" l [ at Cor's Mesa, Cal torn'$. Signature ` ' 5 1 / • . : CITY 0F ' HUW-IN00" T0M',I3EA C H . 2000 MAIN STFiEBT CALIFOA(�'A 9• 2648 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK; September 27, 1985 C Nibal F. Sidhom r garner Mcbi l 5972 Warner Avenue ` Huntington Beach, CA 92647 t J !�. The City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at its regular meeting held Monda , September 16, 1985, denied your appeal to the Planning Commission appro,al of Condition No. B of Use Permit No. 57-34. This is a final decision. You nre hereby notifieci that pursuant to '9 prnvisions of Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure of the State of California you have ninety days from September 27. 1985 to apply %n the courts for judicial review. If you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact our office - 536-5227. ;. Alicia M. Wenthorth City Cleric ,s Al Enclosure cc: City Attorney Qevelopmerwt .,Service3s 'Di.rnctor y Publish :- 9/5/85 } NOTICE OF PUBLIC FEARING 't APPEAL TO PLANNING COMMISSION ' S APPROVAL OF CONDITION #8 OF APPROVAL OF USE PERMIT *85-34 NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN That a public hearing will be hEld 'by the City Council of the City of, Huntington Beach, in the Council Chamber of the Civic Center , Huntington e,-,ach, at the hour of. 7 : 30 P.M. , or r, soon thereafter as possible on Monday, the 16th day of September, 1985, for the purpose of considering an appeal filed by Ni.bal F. Sidhom, owner of Warner ' s Mobil, to, the Planning Commission ' s action to uphold the Board of Zening Adjustment ' s approval of Condition #8 of Ilse Permit #85-34 which prohibits the sale of beer and wine at an existing gasoline service station in the C4 (highway Commercial) zoning district. The subject property is located at 5972 'darner Avenue at the i i southwest corner of War. .:er Avenue and Springdale Street. A .legal description is on file in the Department of Development I , services. All interested persona are invited to attend said nearing and express their opinions for or against said appeal . 1 Further information may be obtained from the Office of the City Clerk, 2aG0 Main Street, Hu Beach , Calf fornia, 92648 �- (714) 536 5227 OAZ'EDt ' September ?, 1985 CITY. OF HUNTINGTON ,HEACH: By . Alicia `M Wentworth City Clerk i:' .'L o .'n. K i ,it td • C `C J7wt on; Atlttnt c Rjchfleld Co. k , knda Anil Ve 0. x299a0Heat 679 TC= hnnrx Cd 90210 Los Angeles, CA 90051 t , +163-0g0-04' ? 246 313-09 1 9:11aem ,Lyon i Associates Evans Kitsigiania , .. .j orporate 'PYaz' a 3903 Ridgmnont 'Dii%re-C ,,Newport 'Beach; CA; 92660 ttalibu, CA 90265 fr 163-080 ZO ' Chen Shan-Chin 38 �3 Mistral Drive . 'Xuntington 'Beach, CA 92449 163-080-13 Samuel S1215 838 N.';. Doheny Drive #301 Lus Angeles, CA 90067 2�i3-090-14 Southwest S b L Association 2700 W. Manchester 3ng2ewood, CA 90305 Chen Shan-Chin J835 Mistral Drive Huntington Beach, C7, 92649 i 1I0-•301-32 :Bur ti s Co.,-pora ,-ion P.O. B= aF,00 Los Angeles, CA 90051 110-301-33 Gerald Sparks P.O. Box 1021 huntinaton Beacho Cal 92647 lot 0-301--3,: Cera2d Sparks P.o. Box 1921 Kurltittgtoli Dancl:, CA 92647 110-30.1-35 Gerlad Sj�ax-1cs ' P 0%Sax 1921 HuhC ny�ton:' Aeach� CA 9260 146-171' 13r qy CA 5��tf V��ri'i�s' Mj�od"a!1►�� t ��r f' `` , 1 r r i,;, . � + t+�t ° ti,E ,, •s �t •:at y.-;•r� #".. r .gin' ) i r r # `S+ ''� j 4 Yt h i,4; •��st k� S� k.:�: hi. ��M. / � .�.r' �.A+irY[i f,,.:k t Lk k1.:t•:• .vtfr .. _ '; .s .iJ 'rk;~ ,., L't , r'.. 1 `iA ;'k 'ia.;t'rr .T::Vfri=z rfay+e•'.Trs:•Yw..:=.....r.v.ra..,, ::. .". ..;.:Ma.e f..-....•ir.+ra-�iW•!• •v: :; .,1'.1'aMY9........a1'Y+1CeGn4'`:'ti JllMwa........ .wrriw.r..+..,.....-•....,. 1 Publish NOTICE OF PUt L I C HEARING � �o p'(, � ► t' t�t,�-1 th jt ra�-a 7 A, tOfA Op � rJt �P.lc�:�� ► �.T przids ��y �1y Pm04' NOTICE 15 HERI-13Y GIVEN tha t a public hearing will be held by the City Council o0, of the City of Huntincgton Beach , in titre Council Chamber of the Civic_ Center, Huntington Beach, at the hour of P.M. , or as soon thereafter as Possible of) 3k _�. the __ day of .�•� lg� for the purpose of considering ov.% AFFeal I.C4 Of �P( 1 } D M { hti 1 r^ y A44,rYl 't d i7A- P -�" r.;ti�•t.¢b!5- op ra ep 44'P_. l e, t.c. .. l 4 eAlv L&I t".0 �_ed a� J All interested persons are invited to attend said hearing ;and express their opinions for or against said _A� ��:�'c..•r--~ Further information may. be obtained from the Office' cf the City Clerk, 2000 Mv.in Street, if titin�ton Beach, ;.jlifor•nil1 . n2648 - (71.9) 536-5227 R UATEU CITY Or IM.DiT11;GTON fly: Alicia I'. Wentti or•th' City Clerk s S W)TICE tO 11LER}t TO SCREDULE PUBLIC NEARING P 2�7N t+ G► pw,J+V s 7"/K +1'�a A-P1 ft i��t.• c7 G l� f Piil ', ' CITY CLERK'S OFFICE DATE: " J PLEKSE SCHEDUIX A PtBLIC HEARING usm, THE ArrACIiED LEGAL NOTICE FOR THE /011 I.}Z,.. . DAY OF ' I SIP'a are attacbea .AP's will follow f NO A,Y'S Initiated by: 1 Planning Coaanieaion Planning Departzent ti It Petition I.Ppea4 Other Adoption of Environmental Status (x) YES NO { Refer to �Jk1T'- ._.� PlanningDepartment Extension 0 .,..... j. for additional information. * L1� Wiest please t;rnnsert� exact• vordIng to be required in the 'legal . • ....,-., .. . . 1. .,'. . . ,'.; ..:.`- VHla :{ Nuntington g�ach Manning Catn�aission ON ` Pao. COX' 190 CALIFORNIA $2948 August 61 1 ?85 Warner ' s Mobil _ 5972 -Warner Ave Hs. ntington Beach, CA 92647 SUAJECT: APPEAL OF CONDITION 18/USE PERMIT NO. 85-34 (BZA APPROVAL) REQUEST: Appeal of condition 18 of BZA approved Use Permit No. 85-34 which excludes the sale of beer and wine in an approved snack shop operation within an existing gasoline service station. LOCATION: 5972 Warner Ave. FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL: 1 . The establishment , maintenance and operation of the use gill ' not be detrimental to: a. The general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity; b. Property and improvements in the vicinity of such use or building. 2. The proposal is consistent with the City's General Plan of Land Use, CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL: 1. A revised site plan of suitable scale,- depicting the modifications described herein shall be submitted and approved = i prior to_ issuance -of a building permit. , a . Landscaping in compliance with 5. 94A2 . 1 . 1 . , b. Minimum of 5 pae king spaces in 'compliance with -Article -979. 2."`. ; . Landscape and - irrigation plan to ' ths, Department of Development Se r v.1 ces and Public Wo rks for review And ap proval , `. y r .. .. SS .J.• 7 J t". _ Y . : _ .'4 _ ,.�i.? r `., . .. . .. - ...'Y i —_ f . Yy v :/ 1 toi 4 y 3 . .-Landsc typing shall 'be . installed and approved prior to new Use. 4 .. , The -'development shall comp3y with all applicahAe provisions,, of `the'- Ordinance Code, Building Division# and :"ire -Department. _ 5 ; The major identification si n shall be removed or altexed to comply with ' Article .: 948 within ninety ( 90 ) 'days. i - 6 A11 '`signs shall comply with Articles 948 and 976 of the Nun tington - Beach Ordinance code. revised Certificate of Occupancy shall be issued. 8. No beer and wine sales are permitted . hereby certify--that Appeal- of-Condition- No.-•8 -of -Use-,.Permit No 85-34 . was denied by the Planning Commission of the City of Huntington Beach on August 5 , 1985 upon the foregoing findings. Sincerely, -,'James W. Palin `Secretary Planning Commission JWP: lp ? (3037d(11 ) , t , - i s = . 4F, dh , Huntington Beach Planning Commission r . • :'` P.O. aCX t90CALIFORNIA CALIFOR 52646 ' Date: AMUST 6 , 1985 NOTICE OF ACTION Applicant: WARNEI 'S MOBIL , 5972 WA-RNER AVE , Subject: A AI OF CQM 1 T l^PJ #8/11sE pF=`:MIT Nn . 85-y4 C g AppnOVAL 1 Your application was acted upon by the Huntington Beach Planning Commission on AIJ 5T 5 , 1935 and your request was: j� Withdrawn i ' Approved i.pproved with Conditions (See Attaened) Disapproved _ XX Y Tabled Continued until Under the provisions of the Huntington Beach Ordinance Code, the action taken by the Planning Commission is final unless an appeal, is ,filed to I the City Council by you or an interested party. said appeal nust' `be ' in writing and must set forth in detail the actions and grounds by and , upon which the applicant or interested party deems himself .aggrieved. r Said appeal be accompanied by a filing fee of o unfired snd , sixty--five *165 collars and be submitted to the � Clerk o :e. ;. within ten 1 j ays of the date of the Cos�nsisazon 's act on. r .f . In your case, the last da for filing an appeal and paying ,. tbe filing fee is AgGUST 15. 1. 85 Provisions of the Huntington .Beach Ordinance Code are suc31 that . any - app y after final aPProval. application becomes null and -void "one. (1 y 'year unless actual, construction has started. Very truly yours, Ja6es W Palin Secretary Y h c r i v r i r , i .l� _ i.:. r4 1� JAY• y 4tr . .'t.�,ft 4 �` . 4 f' .. r•' 1 ^ 1f 1' ( 'r ; ' {�, Al �' tt.M. k PC �1 r } ' �A .Ji++"s/. (� :«. x7r:niilwi++�.y..w.rw eJ+R�'.17N lid+' ,'}l%,Td7$4'.n ►Yr3Lb7P+W.t '^1 � .7 ✓� r �"iswxFrr.....•..+...•+.r.r.o.M._ �► Ax ttbrt Atlaen tj� R�c�`tfte'"d Co.. r t ` rs jf7.westkAnda Di3ve � # P':'0: 'Uti-a• ':6.?p Tc�. A r.,,ca• -' 'rI :Mii3 s C11 0 22 , iar Y . 9 0 Los A.•tgeles,, cA 90051 , 146 3 - 'Kllllae`toil S_ assoclat:e3. 1i'�ana Kitsi 'lanfa y I9 Corpora to P1a za. 3903 Ridgemon t Drive ,'Ke+rpvrt i;�A ' CA 92660 Nalibu, CA 90265 'Chen Shan-Chin %"'si+eht A Ve•- �t 3835 1llstral Drive uLA Huntington Beach, CA 92E49 ; coew Sam eel 51111 ;t1�• L�o�.n '-� • 63B-N. Doheny Drive 0301 Los .Angel Qs, CA 90067 e 263=080--14 &)u thwest S & L Association Nanchester ;:Inglowowl, CA 90305 t : 363--080-,I5 Chen Shan-Chia , 3$35 ,Histral Drive Huntington Beach, CA 92649 . ..110-3 D1-32 Surtis Corporation Pod. ;B= 7600 ? Los Angeles, CA 90051 l 110-301-33 f Gera I d Stu rks ; PC?_ "Bax: 1971 ttuntington Beach, CA 92647 110--301-30 6'or.a�1d Spy_ks PX ';Box -1921 Huntington Beach, CA 92647 ! 1Z ,, Gerlad S�rka .. P OD box '1922 ; CA 92647 flunt3ngton Beach, :F j StQ,Q+1`l1/1,'Alxt rows i ,. ,�.' • ' 7 1 , . „i t4t i'. tt 0 J .w •, .",.eA,.R`trrJ.v.r, .•._^-li ".'.:ru w�.: :., �.. * � '_ y ,. '� ' n � L�t�i .. 1 ...... .1, '. _. =0..t.•,._. ., r. 1a»,.tt. ,r .. ? :. ... "� ,��..::' "tr'° �a r :f <�i..�.6�.:5.,.�