The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutPresentation regarding current challenges related to homeles ,� rA Osil __ City of Huntington Beach q File #: 19-436 MEETING DATE: 4/15/2019 Presentation regarding current challenges related to homelessness in Huntington Beach and discussion on a potential Navigation Center City of Huntington Beach Page 1 of 1 Printed on 4/10/2019 Powered LegistarT Work Order: #151635 °Opened: Closed: ', s . a.x„ tU.11; By Chuck Burns Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email dad2st@aoLcom Phone 714-369-7384 SUP TYPE Device City Council Meeting sTeEET ADDRESS Media Submitted 1 Images ❑x � . COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES To all council members,PLEASE look at this map.My wife,who has to keep her personal feelings private due to her employment(can't afford to be fired),is absolutely LIVID you are even considering this location.She has worked over 16 years for the County of Orange Social Services Agency.She deals with clients such as these on a daily basis.There is not a more compassionate,giving,understanding person on the face of the planet.We are flabbergasted!I realize we all have to come up with a viable solution.It appears you have this area specifically targeted.I just feel if you all would be transparent for ALL people of Huntington Beach of where the current vetted sites are located,and all properties it owns that could be utilized,it would be done in open,balanced,honest,and fair way.Use the Rogers Senior Center with huge bathrooms,giant sleeping rooms,and a large kitchen for charity feeding with a fenced perimeter for safety on a temporary basis until a more appropiate site can be found!We here are just your average LOWER middle class family living paycheck to paycheck trying to make ends meet,with no political clout or money to influence such important DECISIONS that will be made.I URGE you,I PLEAD with you,WITHDRAW,OPPOSE this location.The unintended consequences are ENDLESS.PLEASE Respectfully,Chuck Burns 714 369-7384 Notes Added By staff:04/09/2019 11:21 AM Robin Estanislau Thank you for your feedback,It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: https://www.huntingtonbeachca.gov/serviceslhomeless-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/09/2019 9:03 AM Johanna Dombo 10 CEO gte Maps Proposed I-113 Homeless Shiettcr tS Praxnntty to Childrens Programs ocnc Raccw.rQ Qs.,t~t. Proposed Shelter 1r_t ne 200 Yards l2 min walk } Ito Rtnil) pF.S r.t - r rdf/3 min walk g mt Jf trt 1300 atria!12 minwalir krr r,u � s.rs- I <<4 Q(ry t.,,t R—a , It 1 �r+1tir,t ItV r"ar.A = Roe*Roe FAtxast 9 .7'mrta f 13 rain wok y}, I1.I:.,„,, ards/r','" p�r�yp t�� LL t r f1ft1D yard`/70 Arlo woo m..,,t s'Alk _�„ r 1 retie/15 l jj nin walk al.,: _. .",4, ,,,,:::"::::..;'..*::,QD ,.r....:''I..',',x.”.Q 11 Work Order: #151848 Opened: Closed: ' LV:ssci'l's'Ll:-'10tSskiii By Margarita Pourtemour Agenda & Public Hearing Comment Email mpourtemourilgmal.c om SUB`APE Phone City Council Meeting Device STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None El COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES I have a serious problem with the location of the proposed homeless shelter on Pipeline La. This is within one mile of where I live with two young children.We didn't pay more than half a million dollars to have a homeless shelter placed right in our community.Simply put,just because we are in the north end of HB,we are subjected to having the homeless shelter by our homes.We pay the same taxes for HB as the south HB yet it's placed in our backyard.There must be a better place to put this that is not so close to so many homes,schools and parks. This shelter isn't addressing the lack of homes we have,there is a DRUG and mental health issue that has to be addressed.Crime is going to increase with this here and it is not okay. Please seek out another place this can be.At least give your citizens some options instead of springing it on everyone last minute and that also goes with letting your citizens know of meetings with time. Notes Added By staff:04/09/2019 2:41 PM Robin Estanislau Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: https://www.huntingtonbeachca.gov/services/homeless-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/09/2019 2:08 PM Johanna Dombo Work Order#151848 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO 12 Work Order: #151500 Opened: Closed: � q:b�� i� x MA'MA 'AAM MoMAAMM- a By Jeff&Judy Burrows Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email . pinkpaddlerjudy@gmail .com SUB TYPE, Phone 714-785-0804 City Council Meeting Device STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None I1 COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Regarding Proposed Homeless Shelter on Pipeline:It seems to us that the rush decision to put a homeless shelter in Huntington Beach is compromising the consideration of all properties and limiting the selection to existing warehouses available for lease or purchase.The location on Pipeline will bring crime and more vagrancy to this area of the city and will no doubt cause a loss in property values to those of us who own homes nearby.It is near schools,recreational facilities(SCATS&The Rinks),and parks.We do not want an increase in homeless people hanging out in our parks and the former Railroad Easement.i no longer utilize Cascade Park in Westminster due to the vagrants hanging out there 24/7.While the homeless issue certainly needs to be addressed,a knee-jerk reaction is NOT in the best interest of Huntington Beach citizens,especially those of us who are parents,business owners,property owners and tax payers Let us remind you of the section from the Huntington Beach website about the city's General Plan;California State law(Government Code Section 65300)requires that each city prepare and adopt a comprehensive,long-term General Plan for its future development.State law permits cities to include optional elements in their General Plans,beyond the seven mandated elements,thereby providing local governments with the flexibility to address the specific needs and unique character of their jurisdiction.The General Plan is the fundamental policy document of the City of Huntington Beach.It provides the framework for management and utilization of the City's physical,economic and human resources.By providing a basis for rational decision-making,this document guides civic decisions regarding land use,the design and/or character of buildings and open spaces,the conservation of existing housing and the provision of new dwelling units,the provisions of supporting infrastructure and public services, the protection of environmental resources,the allocation of fiscal resources,and the protection of residents from natural and human-caused hazards.The General Plan acts to clarify and articulate the City's intentions with respect to the rights and expectations of the public, property owners,and prospective investors and business interests.Through the Plan,the City informs these groups of the community's goals,objectives and policies thereby communicating the expectations and responsibilities of all sectors in fulfilling the General Plan.In addition to the written goals and policies,the General Plan contains a Land Use Plan that is the prevailing determinate of land use in the City.The Zoning Maps and development standards function to 13 implement the General Plan.I urge you to OPPOSE this site and not cave in to pressure to make a rash,unsafe,and unfair decision.Sincerely Jeff&Judy Burrows 6111 Anacapa Drive Huntington Beach 92647 Notes Added By staff:04/09/2019 11:17 AM Robin Estanislau Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: https://www.huntingtonbeachca.goviservices/homeless-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/09/2019 9:07 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#151500 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/09/2019 9:07 AM Johanna Domho Workorder#151500 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda Si Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO 14 Work Order: #151514 00rona/2019 Closed: 1 4 k iq IG IPA _ �-" - By Ryan Needham Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email rcneedham@gmail.com Phone 415-246-3214 Sue'TYPE Device City Council Meeting STREET DR SS Media Submitted None El COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Please do not open a homeless shelter near my home and local schools!They are dangerous and I do not want nearly 100 homeless people near my family and local schools!This is the area in the industrial park near Marina High.Thank you! Notes Added By staff:04/09/2019 11:17 AM Robin Estanislau Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: https://www.huntingtonbeachca.gov/services/homeless-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/09/2019 9:06 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#151514 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/09/2019 9:06 AM Juliana Dombo Workorder#151514 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO 15 Work Order: #151626 Opened:40 / 019 Closed: By Krittima Arunmas Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email Karunmas@gmail.com Phone . SUB TYPE Device City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES I do live in Huntington Beach and a business owner located in Huntington Beach as well.The proposal for the homeless shelter is a bad idea and not appropriate at the industrial area around the Marina High School.1 can't imagine having to deal with the upcoming issues with school safety,students safety and resident safety.This will affect the community overall.There will be more people moving nut of the area.Businesses will leave.Everything will go downhill. Consider more north area where Boeing used to be.The other side of the road is empty.It seems more appropriate, Notes Added By staff:04/09/2019 11:18 AM Robin Estanislau Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: https://www.hunthigtonbeachca.gov/services/home]ess-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/09/2019 9:04 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#151626 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/09/2019 9:04 AM Johanna Dombo 16 Work Order: #151628 Opened: Closed:04/08/2019 By : Toni Seasock Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email toeknee782@aol.com Phone SUB TYPE Device City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES The Pipeline site is not suitable for a homeless shelter.There's a busy dance studio very nearby where young children up to teenage kids are constantly coming&going.The studio is open in the late evening&teens are walking to their cars,dance teachers closing the studio at night and this studio is open all hours of the day&evening 6 days a week WI occasional Sunday rehearsal hours.Kids are walking to&home from the local schools there.Too many child related sites close to the Pipeline location.Please consider safety first. Notes Added By staff:04/09/2019 11:19 AM Robin Estanislau Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: https://www.hunting tonbeachca.goviservices/homeless-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/09/2019 9:03 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#151628 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/09/2019 9:03 AM Johanna Dombo Workorder#151628 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and 17 Work Order: #151631 Opene2019 Closed: By : Debbie Meyling Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email debbiedeboss@aol.com Phone , 714-799-6868 SUB TYPE. Device City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL {OTES Homeless shelter on Pipeline,I oppose this shelter located on Pipeline or vicinity.I feel the city was dishonest when proposing the 50-bed site on Research.Knowing they would move forward with a larger shelter yards away.This is an industrial zoned NON-RESIDENTIAL area that should no have people housed pernthe cities own master plan,It is repeated multiple times the light industrial zone is non-residential.You are dumping the cities problem here illegally.It is the farthest away area from any police station and 24/7 rent a cop will do nothing for the safety of the surrounding area.We need a substation if this continues anyway. Notes Added By staff:04/09/2019 11:20 AM Robin Estanislau Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: https://www.huntingtonbeachca.gov/services/homeless-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/09/2019 9:03 AM Johanna Domba Work Order#151631 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/09/2019 9:03 AM Johanna Dombo 18 Work Order: #151324 0/07/2019 Closed: By M Tran Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email Mainctran@hotmail.co SUB TYPE Phone . City Council Meeting Device . STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None E COMMENTS SE ADDITIONAL NOTES Can you copy whatever Irvine is doing that they are able to keep the homeless from their city? I moved to hb 7 years ago,bought an expensive home in the Harbour and now you're going to open a shelter near my home?!?I have small children that I can't even take to the beach for early biking anymore because it is littered with homeless people who approach us.We have to wait until there are more people at the beach so we can go with a crowd.Please keep druggies and the mentally ill from us.We have worked hard all our lives to save so we can be in the Harbour,not next to a homeless shelter and put my kids at risk. Notes Added By staff:04/08/2019 11:34 AM Robin Estanislau Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: https://www.huntingtonbeachca,gov/services/homeless-solutionsl. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/08/2019 9:31 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#151324 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/08/2019 9:31 AM Johanna Dombo 19 Work Order: #1512 62 04/07/2019 Closed: By Chuck Burns Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email dad2st@aol.com Phone 714-369-7384 SUB TYPE Device . City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Navigation Center:City Owned Land:Do the right thing...For all people of Huntington Beach...Post a map showing all city owned property that could be used for this site...Be open, honest,fair and balanced...Post a map on the city's website...Social media pages...city owned property that could be used for this site...DO NOT WASTE OUR TAX DOLLARS leasing or buying new property to be used for this site..Be open,honest,fair and balanced for all people of Huntington Beach DO THE RIGHT THING Thank you for your time Chuck Burns 714 369-7384 Notes Added By staff:04/08/2019 11:33 AM Robin Estanislan Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: https://www.huntingtonbeachca.gov/services/homeless-solutions!. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/08/2019 9:31 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#151262 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/08/2019 9:31 AM Johanna Dombo 20 Work Order: #151078 Opened: 2019 Closed: By Chuck Burns Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email dad2st@aol.com Phone 714-369-7384 SUB'TYPE Device City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None .-1 COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Navigation Center:15311 Pipeline Ln.Seriously?This is the best next alternative site?Still within a mile of Marina High,Circle View Elementary and Marina Park,In my particular case as before,within 1 mile of where I live.Potential loss in property value due to proximity to Marina High 15%.Potential loss in property value due to proximity to where I live 12%.All of us including so many children are at risk.The potential fallout in realty values is a given.Look it up.l'll simply ask the same question John Briscoe,President of Ocean View School District Board of Trustees asked at the meeting last Monday night.Why DO YOU want to lease a property for this facility since the city still owns many properties that are vacant and not near any schools.Don't think we need to guess too many times where these properties might be within the city limits.I URGE YOU TO WITHDRAW THIS SITE.Thanks for your time Notes Added By staff:04/08/2019 11:26 AM Robin Estanislau Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic,For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: https://www.huntingtonbeachca.gov/serviceslhomeless-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/08/2019 9:43 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#151078 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO 21 Work Order: #151077 Opened: 04/06/2019 Closed: - 1 - :''''Ar4,:latiVAVgIVAlki:1'V100 By : Chuck Burns Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email : dad2st@aol.com Phone : 714-369-7384 SUB'TYPE Device City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None commENTs&ADDITIONAL NOTES Navigation Center:15311 Pipeline Ln.Seriously?This is the best next alternative site?Still within a mile of Marina High,Circle View Elementary and Marina Park,In my particular case as before,within 1 mile of where I live.Potential loss in property value due to proximity to Marina High 15%.Potential loss in property value due to proximity to where I live 12%.All of us including so many children are at risk.The potential fallout in realty values is a given.Look it up.I'll simply ask the same question John Briscoe,President of Ocean View School District Board of Trustees asked at the meeting last Monday night.Why DO YOU want to lease a property for this facility since the city still owns many properties that are vacant and not near any schools.Don't think we need to guess too many times where these properties might be within the city limits.I URGE YOU ALL TO OPPOSE THIS SITE.Thanks for your time Notes Added By staff:04/08/2019 11:25 AM Robin Esta nislau Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: https://www.huntingtonbeachca,gov/services/homeless-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/08/2019 9:43 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#151077 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO 22 Work Order; #151143 Opened: 04/05/2019 Closed: ' '011111011 Date:NdtVet,'m -- : By : Lisbeth Burns Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email : chazatbat@aol.com Phone : SUB TYPE Device City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Navigation Center 15311 Pipeline Ln,To whom it may concern,Although I'm the first one to admit this event doesn't have the same prestige and increase nearly as much revenue as others for the city,it is held annually every summer.2019 Outdoor Racquetball Championships Presented by Pro Kennex July llth-14th Marina Park,Huntington Beach California I intend to notify all officials and sponsors of this event,should the city decide to locate the Navigation Center within a 2 mile radius of Marina Park,I feel it's only fair and just all concerned with this event should he kept informed.I urge you all to OPPOSE this site Thank you https://www.r2sports.com/website/event-website.asp?TID=30444 Notes Added By staff:04/08/2019 11:27 AM Robin Estanislau Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: https://www.huntingtonbeachca.gov/services/homeless-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/08/2019 9:42 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#151143 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/08/2019 9:42 AM Johanna Dombo 23 Work Order: #151164 04 a ed�19 Closed: By Mark Tonkovich Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email 7 Marktonko@Gmail.com Phone 714-519-9555 SUB TYPE Device . City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES On April 1st,while at City Hall,a women in the audience told a few of us that Research was voted down and the new location will be several blocks North.When the Council meeting convened,it was announced that Research was voted against and 5 more sites would be reviewed.How did she know this selected site was a few blocks north back then?Was Pipeline already selected?What other sites were reviewed?We also went from a lease to a purchase and a capacity of 50 increase to up to 90.Why purchase?Why increase?Why have this so close to schools?Mark Tonkovich Notes Added By staff:04/08/2019 11:32 AM Robin Estanislau Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: https://www•huntingtonbeachca.govlservices/homeless-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/08/2019 9:40 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#151164 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/08/2019 9:40 AM Johanna Dombo 24 Work Order: #151181 Opened:/ / 019 Closed: By Tracey Thomas Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email Tlthomasz verizon.ne SUB PIPE City Council Meeting Device STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS EL ADDITIONALNOTES Homeless shelter in proposed location should be fine as long as it is run like City of Anaheim where people are checked in,screened,locked inside,no loitering etc. Notes Added By staff:04/08/2019 11:33 AM Robin E stanislau Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: https://www.huntingtonbeachca.gov/servlces/homeless-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/08/2019 9:39 AM Johanna Dambo Work Order#151181 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/08/2019 9:39 AM Johanna Aornbo Workorder#151181 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO 25 Estanislau, Robin From: Anissa Iseda <aiseda2l@yahoo.com> Sent: Saturday, April 06, 2019 7:14 PM To: Peterson, Erik; Semeta, Lyn; Brenden, Patrick; Carr, Kim; Delgleize, Barbara; Hardy, Jill; Posey, Mike; Lukehart, Catherine; Kelly, Michael; Roberts, Lisa; Yantorn, Hayley; Ricci, Gabriel; Chichester, Daniel; Estanislau, Robin Subject: Seattle Homeless Komo News Special Dear Huntington Beach City Council Members and Huntington Beach Homeless Outreach Team, I reach out to you in concern of recent discussions of a homeless shelter being placed in our city, near Marina High School. As a 20+ year resident of Huntington Beach and being born and raised in Seal Beach prior to that, I know what an amazing geographical area we reside in. I would like to maintain the beauty of these beach side communities for my son to continue to grow up in. For the past few years I have had to split my time between Huntington Beach and Seattle, Wa. for work and have experienced the homeless taking over some of the most beautiful areas in Seattle. It is heartbreaking to say the least. Komo News in Seattle aired a special in March regarding the homeless in Seattle. I personally found it eye opening from many points of view. I have volunteered a lot with the homeless and have always taken my son to volunteer with me over the years. So, I do not view this population as just a nuisance. 1 have tried to help and be compassionate to all different levels. I am also not typically one who politically gets involved to this level, but I felt compelled enough to reach out to each of you to share this Komo News special in hopes that you would view it. Understand that, I do understand there are levels of homelessness and our society is more taken aback and threatened by the homeless population that is viewed in this special. This population is a byproduct of their true troubles and addictions. Which, I believe, needs to be addressed in order to "fix" the homeless at this level. This population seems to be the "most offensive and invasive" level in our community and this is what has threatened Seattle. This population can detour tourism, bring down property value, scare young children, increase drug use, theft, vandalism and other offenses. As I am sure you all know. https://komonews.com/news/local/komo-news-special-seattle-is-dvinq I would hope that if you have not already seen this special that you would take the time to view it. Thank you in advance for your time and service to our community. Best, Anissa Iseda 1 26 Work Order: #150984 Opened: 04/05/2019 Closed: ''111 _4LNEN-N-LAL - . „ INN4 NEYEENNEE&N,,„ JEv.E By • Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email : Phone SUB TYPE Device City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None El COMMENTS&ADDMONAL NOTES Oh that Costa Mesa has bansleeping in vehicles these homeless people will probably he coming our way We must pass the ordinance stopping people from sleeping in vehicles in our city before we get invaded by these people Notes Added By staff:04/08/2019 11:23 AM Robin Estanislau Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto:https:/ .huntingtonbeachca.gov/services/homeless-so utons/ Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed;04/08/2019 9:45 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#150984 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/08/2019 9:45 AM Johanna Dombo Workorder#150984 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO 27 Work Order: #151069 Opened: 04/05/2019 Closed: 114 P11:' Or, [j141441.401:IFINV.iiin WZNVEZE14401 ' 0,140Mbirtfte4, '4')-• -Z1E' By : Dave Peters Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email : dave@scatsgymnastics. corn SUB ryTE Phone : 714-895-2909 City Council Meeting Device : STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None NI COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES I share the sentiment of many members of our community in expressing my incredible disappointment over the city's handling over this issue,now twice in less that one week.To not disclose this new location during Monday's city council meeting was at best dishonest.It is evident now that the original location of Research Drive was simply a smokescreen while the 15311 Pipeline location had already been secured.I have included for your reference here an updated map of children's programs and their proximities to the proposed(is it beyond this phase now and secured rather?)shelter.Thank you for your attention,Dave Peters CEO, SCATS Gymnastics Celebrating 55 Years"Skills for Sport,Lessons for Life"714.895.2909 Notes Added By staff:04/08/2019 11:24 AM Robin Estanislau Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: httpsillwww.huntingtonbeachca.gov/services/homeless-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/08/2019 9:44 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#151069 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/08/2019 9:44 AM Johanna Dombo 28 4/15/2019 tavigation Center Proposal • April 15, 2019 Overview O Who are the Homeless? O Oranae County Backdrop Rise in Homeless population Enforcement of Anti-Camping Ordinances Current Litigation O Navigation Shelter Proposal Summary of Proposal Safety and Security aecal._ Meeting Date: y' IS/7 Agenda!tern No.; &SS" / 1 4/15/2019 HOW DID WE GET HERE? y • The presence of homeless individuals - ' - is not new, nor is the issue confined to Huntington Beach _ �4. > ,. wt 1SR' • There has been a public outcry due �, , W ' a^ • to homeless encampments and � y '44 �� , ` " debris throughout the County k' I ., l , , ..., ,--, 0,=". ,7:, 4: )k, WHO ARE THE HOMELESS? 0 VET jr,i ., suPPOR7YOUR 1 r , "1"---r--'RO 0 P5 1 1 ...., Veterans Youth .w� Families 4 r k ,, AM97 %i , _4 y ` 140,000 - seriously mentally ill U^ �� go homeless 2 4/15/2019 Point-in -Time Census and Survey 2017 and 2019 2017 Results - Sheltered 2019 Point-in-Time Count • PIT count was ONE night only. Numbers were not • Volunteers attempted to get a true head count of based completely on an actual head count,but homeless individuals living in shelters and outdoors,as rather on a statistical data well as those in vehicles • 89 individuals are in Transitional Housing or • For Huntington Beach,the 2019 count occurred over Emergency Shelters;77%of those are female TWO days and nights-January 23rd and 24th, -from 3 a.m.to 10a.m and 6pm to midnight. The results have • 61%of the sheltered homeless population not been released consists of families • Council Members,along with 200 volunteers, 2017 Results - Unsheltered participated in the count • 119 individuals were counted as • Due to the more accurate counting method,there will unsheltered/homeless likely be an increase in the number of homeless,but the official count has not been released • 97%of the unsheltered are adults over the age of 24 Point In Time Survey How many? Who are they? 2015 • 2,200 Unsheltered Homelgss • (Including 360 Veterans) U.S.-born lived in QC live alone male • 4,500 Homeless citizens I 0 yrs or longer 52"/ 33a/o middle-aged non-hispanic experienced 2017 (SO or olderl white childhood abuse • 2,600 Unsheltered Homeless • 4,800 Homeless 3 4/15/2019 WHAT HAVE WE DONE ABOUT IT? ilk, , i or*;off f i ii, 419- 1 I 1,1:4: -' 1 ,, ax ri t. , , . . "ww4iiii_ $ I-; :-'4"I 7 1 I ....1 I ir 7P r 8^ Evolution of City Efforts -_ . _ October 2013 - HBPD identified 130-150 January 2016- HBPD November 2016- homeless persons and September 2015 - HBPD adds a second full- First Case officers attempt to assigns Officer Ricci as first time Police Officer to Manager hired to provide ancillary full-time officer dedicated assist with homeless assist with housing assistance to homelessness issues issues our homeless March 2015 - City November 2016- March 2016-The Council created Homeless Outreach Community Community Homeless Coordinator hired to assist Homeless Task Force Task Force Officer Ricci with housing presented 22 efforts for homeless recommendations to City Council 4 4/15/2019 Evolution of City Efforts 2017 Public works April 2018 April 2019 - 2017 City Council entered into contract Creation of City hosts two appointed ad- for encampment Homelessness open houses hoc City Council debris removal 3 days Solutions for Navigation subcommittee per week Coalition Center November 2017 - 2018 2"d and 3rd Case March 2019 OBD Library Services Managers hired to Staff and Case trained Librarian in assist Officers and Managers visit Mental Health homeless individuals numerous OC Intervention for and families with homeless patrons housing efforts shelters -40117 Homeless Task Force - Accomplishments I, 2015 - PRESENT • Off the Streets - 262 (with 70 being reunified with family) • Total Officer Contacts - over 2600 (many duplicative) • Officer Assistance - over 700 occasions • Case Manager Contacts (since May 2018) - over 1100 5 4/15/2019 Homeless Task Force414/ .` Accomplishments • Reunite individuals throughout United States with family • Engage in eviction prevention (11 people) • Attend weekly County Housing Match Meetings with other cities and nonprofits • Maintain open office hours at the South Police Substation for walk-ins • Conduct outreach twice weekly • Welcome citizen participation - outreach location suggestions, donations, client referrals, jobs, professional services • Act as Family Access Point for homeless families • Interact with local schools for issues regarding homeless and housing insecure children HB Homeless Demographic Information (Age, Race, Gender, Chronic Homelessness) AV Werke az! En Chmele Haarlem Demog. k(AdJa•HoH)Chart A•Ce 6 4/15/2019 HB Homeless Demographic Information Disabilities Disabled Demographic(Adults&HoHH)Chart Chunk Hank GdNlea Chan N i —hob.' ,.w.___....._.___.__._ Physical Disability Chart Meattl Health Problem Chit FM rail— so% U The City's Impact on a Life Kenny's Story of Restoration 7 4/15/2019 Challenges Y�_ . [Countywide 4114 11 • A massive encampment grew in Anaheim, along , i. \Y - the Santa Ana River Bed ., • Approximately 700 homeless individuals camped rsomm, + '-- there. The public grew upset at the appearance , I of the encampment and the loss of the public - rx.- r ...4b. space �y�ly fit • Santa Ana's Civic Center had an even larger , , y` homeless population, many of whom were j',. 0. 1 „ camping in the open space next to the .�,i, courthouse. , , . '�c„ I '- ,,v.; . ' 4, ) '.,tsi..:.e, [ Federal Lawsuits Filed Against County/Citiesiii ,,,,. .,. .,4„.,,,,, � �'... • . .......... .„,:.., .' �,� o When the County moved ,ft,`<it i to clear the homeless from the river bed, advocates w for the homeless filed �` • f- 4. � Federal lawsuits Ili o They claimed the homeless 111K , 1 - were were driven there when p rri•r surrounding cities started "� '° �� 1 enforcing their anti- camping and loitering I - ordinances 8 4/15/2019 Comments on Federal Authorities Federal District Court ., 1`` • The cases were consolidated .4 4' and assigned to the + Honorable David O. Carter 4)-A, At '` of the Second District Court r' in Santa Ana • Judge Carter has been till r working with all 34 Orange County cities to identify 3,41 1111 solutions to the challenges related to homelessness 9 4/15/2019 Limitations placed on Anti-Camping Ordinance by Court Judge Halts Clearing of Orange County Homeless Encampments • Soon after the cases were LIST. ' ° filed, Judge Carter issued a p '1 F Temporary Restraining Order prohibiting the County and named cities from clearing . the encampments until alternatives could be found. a • Which cities or entities have been sued? The County of Orange has been sued The cities of Anaheim, Orange, and Cost Mesa were also sued along with the County of Orange A second lawsuit has been filed against Irvine, Aliso Viejo, Dana Point, San Juan Capistrano, and San Clemente Huntington Beach has not been sued at this time 10 4/15/2019 Impact of Federal Lawsuits on Cities Anaheim, Santa Ana, and Tustin have opened homeless shelters Costa Mesa opened a temporary shelter and purchased a permanent shelter for $6.9M Shelter residents must have ties to those cities, so HB homeless cannot utilize them The above cities may now enforce their anti-camping ordinances, which may increase the homeless population in Huntington Beach What if We Do Nothing? ■ When Santa Ana, Costa Mesa, Tustin and Anaheim start enforcing their anti-camping ordinances and park closing hours, homeless can no longer camp in their parks, sidewalks and civic center • Enforcement efforts against those who refuse to sleep in a shelter could simply serve to push homeless into cities that do not have a shelter. ■ If the HBPD is to enforce anti-camping, trespassing and loitering ordinances, officers must be able to offer the alternative of a Huntington Beach shelter bed. Officers currently do not have that ability. ■ Potentially costly lawsuits against the City can be avoided with a shelter. 11 4/15/2019 -.... Huntington Beach Proposed_ Navigation Center` WHAT TYPE OF SHELTER MUST HUNTINGTON BEACH CREATE? To serve our HB homeless, an emergency homeless shelter facility should have low barriers to entry, be ADA accessible, and serve men, women, and couples. Other cities will not be permitted to place their homeless in the HB shelter. Per Judge Carter, the shelter should serve up to 60 percent of the City's last point-in-time count of Unsheltered homeless. As of the 2017, Point-in-Time Count the number of unsheltered was 119 homeless individuals 12 4/15/2019 WHAT SITES DID WE CONSIDER? TIMEFRAME? O Huntington Beach considered 28 separate sites -Sites located in Industrial "SB 2" Zone - 26 Industrial Zoned areas reviewed - Two City-owned sites O Evaluated sites, both for sale or lease O Judge Carter's status conference on April 2, 2019 with all 34 cities was the goal date for the identification of a site Ili :: Zoning - p■,'��`: 4 -- City of Huntington Beach f� „,,, i ,. i, - EA O P. Looked at ,, r "A -- -u ' �'A ,, Industrial areas '6 : � -- within the City �'� .a, ''__ b, ngD lg n '*'�' __ _ �� ____ �µY� 114,,, Y.. 4‘, -----.,:,;'',;,,p,, ,--t....,414,,_•,,,,_.„-4;,,Firk,,,,i, .^�7 t ��- 774' � , � ' k— Pi f i 11 h,9yi 4 2' �'?. i s • 4#y_,.- _.. ...,,_ :>� .1 ad 13 4/15/2019 Addressing jarik HOMELESSNESS in Huntington Beach FACT SHEET _ " "6•1 • HIGHLIGHTS .i� la • 75 to 90 Bed Emergency Shelter t'.; ✓ Women ip I4 ✓ Men I�� Milt �� l ,; ✓ Couples 1'' +rl • No Walk-in/Walk-out r rs- Fr A..., - 4' F x, ; ▪ By referral only , , 15311 Pipeline Lane,Huntington Beach • Clients must be pre-approved • Length of stay —90 days -N ww*el-1]W".',now.scrod 1.81.e:raves.pork'2.WO 11. -cM m Nr.sK,.ln ror x.n w."ep.on.w..."I n.x.,ro,,,rourr m repel�m • No open felony warrants -CWnb m W pe zeera0 era po Nragn.n.p"wv Ppce..Pmr m e"ng etteP..'a me Cenrv - m�P�b1^�� -�"^�aa�^ "�^� • • No registered sex offenders Se.,rni,avn6C emu.N.PPaM -LO aN o,M —V m..cnpapa DeevV^errtfenm t *Y po 011 -N.aru.mm.p.nl11l w","nP ay•ov.0 on.rw.P POaouv pum0PlYq py.01 u.s.pv P,ppp.v.IP a rpNy guelifie0 SM1v1"Opo*13 -Ope•.m,wl.zee m Pa3e.nk"e 1010...ro uv Tar agemem Commurny 00.m. ..I Own Mo,ee i..na0,lw Ia IY.✓a..&.,,,P13*n ab ve.ne on is.0ey.M^l p han e a e P.m. n Comrwrvy Open Haa I,,,aOenN wily d re10 Sauna,.Mn 13 Pr]0.m.b,w v l,.C.,t&Lb.Y W W WJMRMnTOI�fAC11CA.fiOI�NP..m.:asac Who Can Use the Navigation Center? III The Navigation Center will serve Huntington Beach homeless men, women, and couples with strong ties to the community, such as: 1 . Last Permanent Address in Huntington Beach; driver's license, utility bill, rental agreement, bank statements, car registration, or other documentation as such. 2. Children enrolled in Huntington Beach school (proof of enrollment), employed in Huntington Beach (proof of paystubs), graduated from a Huntington Beach high school (proof of graduation). 3. Huntington Beach Police Department verification. 14 4/15/2019 Shelter Examples 0., Blends with other AP Atigpsi industrial buildings w __ No processing of No signage clients outside the identifying the Center building SAFETY AND SECURITY THE SAFETY AND SECURITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH RESIDENTS AND BUSINESSES IS OF PARAMOUNT CONCERN. All decisions by the City and the shelter operator will be driven by this factor first. GOAL: To provide the most effective shelter system that has no negative impact on the well-being of any resident, business or visitor of Huntington Beach 15 4/15/2019 SAFETY AND SECURITY KEY COMPONENTS ENHANCED POLICE PRESENCE HBPD Officers will be working in the area surrounding the site to help ensure public safety 24/7 ONSITE SECURITY AND HOTLINE 24/7 on-site security will prohibit loitering around the facility and a 24 hour hotline will be provided HIGH DEFINITION DIGITAL SURVEILLANCE of the facility to provide supplemental security assistance and to identify any policy violations PERIMTER FENCING The proposed facility will be entirely enclosed within newly installed security fencing. The fence will be eight feet in height and installed around the entire perimeter of the site SAFETY AND SECURITY KEY COMPONENTS NO LOITERING Security guards will enforce a strict policy prohibiting loitering around the facility NO "WALK-UPS" Admission will be by referral only and the facility team will coordinate client transportation to and from the facility before any clients travel to or exit from the property NO "WALK-OUTS" Individuals exiting the facility must have a pre-arranged transportation plan (Those who violate that rule will be subject to loss of rights to return to the facility) GATES will be locked and access controlled 16 4/15/2019 SAFETY AND SECURITY KEY COMPONENTS STRICT HOURS There will be strict hours of ingress and egress during which clients may be admitted and discharged PROFESSIONAL SHELTER OPERATORS will oversee and manage daily operations with the guidelines and standards established by the City according to best practices and our specific needs EXCLUSION OF VIOLATORS Any individual who cannot abide by the rules of the Center, will be excluded from future services INTAKE SCREENING Each individual will be vetted by performing a personalized intake interview. Certain individuals - those with open felony warrants and sex registrants - are prohibited SAFETY AND SECURITY RECAP SAFETY AND SECURITY is #1 PRIORITY MANAGEMENT OPERATIONS PLAN The shelter operator will need to work with the City to develop its management operations plan. The security aspects of the plan will be reviewed and approved by the Police Department 17 4/15/2019 ...._........ City of - -" Huntington Beach - Community Invited! ADDRESSING HOMELESSNESS IN HB OPEN HOUSE The City is considering opening a shelter at 15311 Pipeline Lane later this year. We invite you to come and. •Share your thoughts and provide input _ •Hear from City.staff. law nforceme t,community partners and experts In shelter- x':a=d operations '' � •Learn more about the City's �� ,_ GEngage '"nt approach n dealing with th C complex ssue =� ��s w ,: : • Saturday.April 13, 2019 '' 10 a , to Noon bit Central Library 7111 Talbert Ave. Rooms C & D RSVP. 714 536 5577 `� � Open Houses and Community Meetings Tuesday, April 9, 2019- Business Open House Saturday, April 13, 2019 - Community Open House 0 If Center is approved, additional Open Houses and/or community events will be scheduled as needed O More information can be found on the City's website at: • www.huntingtonbeachca.govjlionielessness 18 4/15/2019 L . ... . .. ...... . . . Citizen's Advisory Board To assist with the oversight of the Navigation Center and to facilitate community engagement, a Citizen's Advisory Board can be created C The Citizen's Advisory Board could be comprised of various community stakeholders including: Residents Nearby businesses School District Representatives Other Stakeholders - ti . - .vfo..-frii-,)% ca eos e,�') -- 1 � / lea �� v A I A CASE STUDY THE LINK: IN SANTA ANA 19 4/15/2019 About The Link - Santa Ana • The Link is a 24-hour emergency homeless shelter. • Serves homeless men, women, families with minor-aged children women, and adult couples. • The shelter's primary focus is assisting program participants with creating a housing plan, making connections to housing resources and ending their homelessness as soon as possible. • The Link has 200 beds and dedicated office and meeting space for additional services. • U.S. District Judge David O. Carter has publicly labeled the creation of this shelter as a "role model"for the county, the state, and "maybe the nation." • The Link maintains a strict no-walk-up policy. Clients without personal vehicles must take the shuttle to and from the shelter. Bicycle racks are available on the shuttle and must be used for those who own bikes. 39 Recap The City has been addressing the challenge of homelessness since 2013 O The City's Homeless Task Force has been working on a daily basis to address homeless issues in our City O The safety and security of our residents and businesses is our primary goal O A Navigation Center helps ensure the City can enforce its laws O We will continue to keep the City Council advised of further developments with the Federal District Court 20 4/15/2019 QUESTIONS? Opened: Work Order: #152900 04/14/2019 Closed: This issue is assigned Est. Resolution Date: Not Yet Set By Tina Bily Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email : tbily@aol.com Phone . SUB TYPE Device City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None ❑x COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Homeless shelter.Please do not put a homeless shelter in our city!It won't stop the homeless crisis. Notes Added By staff:04/15/2019 8:25 AM Donna Switzer Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,go to: https://www.huntingtonbeachca.gov/services/homeless-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/15/2019 8:03 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#152900 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 8:02 AM Johanna Dombo SUPPLEMENTAL Workorder#152900 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and COMMUNICATION subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citize Date: q /5. / Agenda Item No•6S#/ (//- 4340) 4/15/2019 MY CIVIC CMS I I This issue is resolved Est.Resolution Date: • Agenda & Public Hearing #152871 New Received Assigned Referred Resolved Canceled Comments - Select Action Select Resolution sub type Select Action Select Resolution • City Council Meeting Add New Note COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Against the Homeless shelter near MHS.See attached. Opened: By: Phone: 04/14/2019 Carrie Criss!! 714-612-7683 10:59 AM Email: Device: Closed: cc@crisellcpa.com + Add Files —I—I— Share With Citizen Change Who's Notified Notify Department ,•„�,,,,.w ,,�,�,•••,•„ ,,h F Recommendations disturbed Mel were end should be snow lotionalnedeethey once were.before they were liberalised'In the Ws by the "homeless." Manyhomeless are mentallySubmit go.er�ether.(most)are arias addicted•who Puled their mlonellll. disturbed that were and should be insti- for whatever fantasy feelings that dru„ world..♦few are'economic homNes' who lost,h«r fobs and houses and end tutionalized as they once were-before 1"""s"Ve•w 'Won med111. theywere"liberalized"in the'80's bythe Issue SubType Lumping them ell,og.ther under lam"„f..o., dohU r rwork government. Others(most)are drug lor'homN„�can and will,n..„work if the ar.o bum.end drum..are City Council Meeting esp,nnodby society th"r number.will addicted-who traded their rational life continue to grow crime will lncr«s.esall for whatever fantasyfeelings that drugs l„M.wmm�hre lbws is one..as they 9 9 Support Worker have everywhere lher.n n„. Most horn"„...gr.nl.today receive provide.A few are"economic homeless" sympathy(torn the community"lowing Select Support Workers then to Weep wherever they want end who lost their jobs and houses and find to do wh„eeer lh.y weal•In eee.nce. thumbing their now etameaningful themselves without support capabilities. society.If the[Hy of MB welcomes one,the dly mum welcome them ell Lumping them all together under (dlecrlml„non). yh.be".n.wer for He r."der„(es "homeless"with programs and housing her...'l.ound.)is not to welcome ;d Donna Switzer •• for"homeless"can and will,never work. Add"eply If the street bums and druggies are supported by society their numbers will 152871 status has changed from new to (https://webaaq.mycivicapps.com/rai_upload/1555264 continue to grow;crime will increase at all levels within homeless facilities as they your feedback.It will be included as part In this topic.For new information on what have everywhere there is one. ig to address homelessness,go to: Most homeless vagrants today receive intingtonbeachca.gov/services/homeless- sympathy from the community allowing them to sleep wherever they want,and to do whatever they want-in essence, thumbing their nose at a meaningful society.If the city of HB welcomes 2019©MyCivicApps CMS. one,the city must welcome them all (discrimination). SUPPLEMENTAL The best answer for HB residents(as /+ harsh as it sounds)is not to welcome COMMUNICATION • any. Meeting Date:Add a reply... III 0 < Agenda Item No.. • /q— L43[, 0 Click here to chat https://mycity.mycivicapps.com/rai_v2/index/4300 1/2 4/15/2019 MY CIVIC CMS O Click here to chat https://mycity.mycivicapps.com/rai_v2/index/4300 2/2 Switzer, Donna From: Dombo, Johanna Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 8:18 AM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: FW: Please support the proposed shelter AGENDA COMMENT From: Christine Dittmer<christine.dittmer28@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday,April 14, 2019 5:48 PM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Please support the proposed shelter Dear Council Members, I've been a Huntington Beach homeowner for 30 years and like you, I've seen the homeless population grow exponentially in our community. I see homeless people when I walk on the beach, take my dog to Central Park and when I'm driving through our beautiful city. It's heartbreaking. Yesterday my husband and I attended the Homelessness Open House at the library. I learned that the police department employs case workers to help homeless individuals get the help they need to get off the streets. That is so impressive. I was already aware and frustrated by the fact that our police department can't enforce laws that would prevent overnight encampments because we don't have anywhere to send our homeless population.. This is a clear matter of what is right for our city. I know there are many fearful, hateful opinions out there about our fellow human beings who have no place to go and end up in our city, but I hope you will do what is right to help our city, our citizens and our homeless population by approving the shelter and allowing us to finally address this problem. In Hope for HB, SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting 11 . Christine Dittmer Date: • /v+ !� 5972 Kenwick Circle Agenda Item No.;(95#/ (i9^Lt3&) 1 Huntington Beach, CA 92648 714-244-6250 2 Work Order: #152908 04/14/2019 Closed: n ; This issue is assigned By : Taylor Duc Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email : taylorduc@gmail.com Phone 714-514-4754 SUB TYPE Device . City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES To Whom it May Concern:Let me start by mentioning that the time of the open house wasn't well thought out,many families couldn't attend because it's currently sports season(heard this from almost every parent on my daughters soccer team).Before I sent this email,I wanted to attend the open house so I could draw my own decision.While the open house was a courteous thing to do for the residents,I felt that it was a way to deliver a pipe dream.Many questions/concerns couldn't be answered,I'll list them here:1.It was mentioned that the site would be purchased,and that there may be a tax increase.If purchased this goes from temporary to forever?2.A lot of mention that property values won't decrease.After much research I've found that when located within about a 2 mile radius of a homeless shelter property values decrease 10-12 percent.While I could accept a down economy making my home less valuable,I refuse to sit back and not say a word when something like this can be catastrophic to a lot of residents futures.3.If this passes/built and there is a decrease in property value,will homes be reassessed for lower a property tax rate?It's a very valid concern,I know I'm currently paying almost$8000 per year.4.There apparently is a plan that when these residents want to leave,they are taken to the octa station.What guarantee can you give that they will indeed be getting on a bus to head out to do something productive?Do the residents that leave have to go through a process every time they return?Flow can the city guarantee that once dropped off at a bus station they will be doing productive things?Through my research I have found that our nearby cities that have a shelter location haven't been too successful with the rehabilitation of their residents.5.How can the city guarantee that homeless won't congregate near this area?Rules are broken every single day,I find it very shocking that the answer to this question is"nobody will loiter".The only other answer I have SUPPLEMENTAL NTALheard is that there will be an increase in officer patrol,which I feel had to be said because the city knows how this is going to go.A nearby park had its wooden overhang burned down by the COMMUNICATION homeless,and it has yet to be repaired.6.If you assess the location,there are many businesses Me./ � that are kid oriented.I've spoke with many people who have said they won't be taking their children to these locations if this idea passes.What action will the city be taking in helping a Y+ ,5• /9 with the loss of revenue to these businesses?7.There has been a lot of talk saying that this Meeting D811/ facility will be'secure'and that there will be fencing everywhere.Has anyone at all from the Agenda Item No.;(SAS`#J (i' — 1/431P). city visited the local schools?If so,you will find that many of them aren't fenced in.How can the city think about purchasing and building out this facility when they can't even build a simple fence around all of our schools?Many residents of the circle view tract are threatening to pull their children and send them elsewhere because of this.8.When will the city notify residents of the other vetted locations?It seems like there has been only one location targeted for this.What makes these industrial units so appealing?Thank you for the time,I look forward to a response.Taylor Duc 714-514-4754 Taylorduc@gmail.com Status Changed:04/15/2019 8:02 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#152908 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 8:02 AM Johanna Dombo Workorder#152908 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO Work Order: #152990 04/15/2019 Closed: By Elizabeth Eldridge Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email Eldridgee88@outlook.c om SUB TYPE Phone 714-625-3378 City Council Meeting Device . STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None ❑x COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES I am writing to oppose the proposed homeless shelter in Huntington Beach.This does not belong here.It will only bring an undesired result.This has been unsuccessfully tried in many cities both here in CA as well as other cities in the US.Cities such as Seattle,Baltimore, Chicago,Downtown LA,Oakland,Stockton,San Francisco,San Bernadino have all tried this in an effort to help get homeless off the streets and the only thing that it has served to do is create a more inviting environment for those who don't wish to conform to society and wish to ignore the rules,knowing there are no consequences and receive benefits.As the homeless task force told residents at a community meeting,if you feed the pigeons they will continue to come and bring their friends.We do not want a situation such as what has occurred in the cities mentioned above.Our City Council needs to stand up to the Sacramento politicians and take this to the Supreme Court if necessary and not build a homeless shelter in our city and mandate that our police department state enforcing the laws we have on the books.We have a strong City Attorney that was elected by the residents of Huntington Beach(a position that should always be elected by the residents and not appointed by city council in order to prevent a conflict of interests and ensure representation of the public)and he should be allowed to fight for our rights to not have a homeless shelter within our beautiful city.I urge each and every one of you to vote against this or any other homeless shelter in our city.I am submitting this email in lieu of my attendance at the 3:30 pm meeting as I am unable to attend this meeting in person due to the time it is being held at as it conflicts with my work schedule as I'm sure it does with many other tax paying residents in this city. Status Changed:04/15/2019 10:46 AM SUPPLEMENTAL 9 Johanna Dombo COMMUNICATION Work Order#152990 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO_„ e: y. 15, 19 M6@Dflg Agenda Item No.;Cf (/*'- y3Go� Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 10:46 AM Johanna Dombo Workorder#152990 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO Work Order: #152 946 04/14/2019 04//15 201 9 This issue is resolved Est. Resolution Date: Not Yet Set By : janet Edwards Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email jansgradenl@yahoo.co m SUB TYPE Phone 714-897-2214 City Council Meeting Device . STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES What email address can I use or is this the best way to correspond?Thank you for your response today.I was so glad to hear from you.I didn't go to the meeting yesterday.I'm so upset over this proposed site.Its 1/2 mile from my home.I had a homeless man sitting on my lawn just a few days ago.They pass my house all the time.I've been yelled at when they walk by.I was in the Habit ordering food and a homeless man grabbed me and kissed me!Not OK!! Erik PLEASE!!!This is going to ruin our city.If you want more evidence of this please talk to my husband who has to deal with them at work as a fireman in a large city close to us.Its so unsafe...90 beds?And all of those people will be wondering around during the day while they wait for a bed for the night.Then out on the streets again at 6:30am.I'm just sick about this.If we were helping families who need help I'm fine with that!!I would love to help.But not homeless people on drugs or alcoholics looking for their next fix!That will never change or get better.It will just bring crime. Status Changed:04/15/2019 8:16 AM Donna Switzer Work Order#152946 status has changed from assigned to resolved. Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,go to: https://www.huntingtonbeachca.gov/services/homeless-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Status Changed:04/15/2019 8:01 AM Johanna Dombo Meeting Date: y J3. !GJ Work Order#152946 status has changed from new to assigned. Agenda Item No.; / (/ I " Lf34) Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 8:01 AM Johanna Dombo Workorder#152946 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO Switzer, Donna From: Dombo, Johanna Sent: Friday, April 12, 2019 2:55 PM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Homeless Shelter AGENDA COMMENT The following residents called and are opposed to the Pipeline Dr. location: Vanessa Flores Yvonne Flores Nellie Flores SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date: / /5 . /9 Agenda Item No.; 6 / l/' I3(0) 1 Work Order: #152949 04/14/2019 Closed: This issue is assigned Est. Resolution Date: Not Yet Set By Darina Johnson Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email johnsondarina@aol.co SUB TYPE Phone 714-240-9925 City Council Meeting Device STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Are you guys kidding with this homeless shelter thing?You're just going to make the problem worse.This"solution"isn't going to fix what's going on-Huntington Beach,every day someone's car is robbed.Hire more police officers and lets take this to court.Whoever came up with this plan,resign.We all work very hard to live here and you're over developing and trying to pull stuff like this?You're going to cause irreparable damage.Huntington Beach isn't Huntington Beach anymore. Status Changed:04/15/2019 7:59 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#152949 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 7:59 AM Johanna Dombo Workorder#152949 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION __ Date: _ _ /s• IJ Agenda ► m SSA 1CI'- y3(i) Work Order: #152950 04/14/2019 Closed: -1 This issue is . -b6 6 6 aq By : Darina Johnson Agenda & Public Hearing Comments • Email johnsondarina@aoLco SUB TYPE Phone 714-240-9925 City Council Meeting Device . STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None Eri COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Per someone on Nextdoor app:"Seattle started with a plan like this.Look at their situation now.Baltimore started with a plan like this.Look at their situation now.Detroit started with a plan like this.Look at their situation now.Chicago started with a plan like this.Look at their situation now.San Francisco started with a plan like this.Look at their situation now.Oakland started with a plan like this.Look at their situation now.Downtown Los Angeles started with a plan like this.Look at their situation now.San Bernardino started with a plan like this.Look at their situation now.Stockton started with a plan like this.Look at their situation now.Pomona started with a plan like this.Look at their situation now.Inglewood started with a plan like this.Look at their situation now."Let's learn from the mistakes of those around us and make a better choice for our people and our community.Go watch interviews from the riverbed.Go watch the documentary Seattle is dying.Next we'll gave"safe injection sites."I grew up here,I have worked hard to stay here,fix the city-stop ruining it.DO BETTER!Can't even safely hang out on Main St anymore,so let's ruin things even more. Status Changed:04/15/2019 7:59 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#152950 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO SUPPLEMENTAL Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 7:59 AM Johanna Dombo COMMUNICATIONw Workorder#152950 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. ` _Data: (f /5. 1 ` Agenda Item CSSY#/ ( l9—y3(o) Work Order: #152654 0412/2019 Closed: This issue is assigned Est. Resolution Date: Not Yet Set By : Lisa Kavalesky Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email : LMD1028@yahoo.com Phone 714-781-9551 SUB TYPE Device . City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None Li COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES My name is Lisa Kavalesky.This is a very personal issue to myself and my family.My step daughter is 17,a junior at Marina HS and we live fairly close to this proposed location.My step daughters Mother is homeless in Santa Ana right now.She had been in these"90 day"facilities for almost 3 yesrs now.Before we even knew of the possibility of a shelter near us,she was talking about how she might have a place close to Marina HS.We thought it was an apartment, never imagined it being a shelter and we all started worrying.Now hearing a shelter may be still close by Marina HS we are worrying again.You see,our family is afraid her Mom will show up daily to Marina if she would be transfered to this location.My Step Daughter is now doing so well in school but,stresses about this.We also worry about her Mothers choice of friends shes made while in these shelters.We thought we were in the clear after the last location was rejected due to so many making it clear it was too close to Marina.This new location is only a few blocks away.We did have a chance to drive by it on Friday.It literally is a 2 minute walk.Hearing this again,we are worried again.We go to Santa Ana monthly to visit her Mom.We see the homeless in the streets,parks and businesses.We see the alcoholics, drug addicts,beggers,mentally Ill and we also see nothing can be done unless they have committed a crime.We dont want that so close to our schools,homes or community.Again,my step daughter and our family is personally effected by this.This location being so close to Marina is not a good solution.It should not be anywhere even remotely close to the HS I hope my message to you is personally being heard.Thank You Status Changed:04/15/2019 8:09 AM Johanna Dombo SUPPLEMENTAL Work Order#152654 status has changed from new to assigned. COMMUNICATION Share with Citizen:NO �' 'S. Meeting Date: Agenda item No.;(5S ! (1�—V31,) Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 8:09 AM Johanna Dombo Workorder#152654 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO Switzer, Donna From: Dombo, Johanna Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 10:59 AM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: FW: Homeless Shelters near Marina AGENDA COMMENT From: Lisa D<Imd1028@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 10:53 AM To: Peterson, Erik<Erik.Peterson@surfcity-hb.org>; CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Homeless Shelters near Marina To all concerned, My name is Lisa DeLuccio-Kavalesky. I am writing on behalf of myself, my husband Mark Kavalesky and our children, Katheryn Kavalesky, Jamey Kavalesky and Lukas DeLuccio. My husband and I attended the Open House last Saturday and came away with some information, but still scratching my head. I am all for helping out the homeless who want the help. However, I am not for that help to be located anywhere near Marina High School. Two weeks ago we all breathed a sign of relief when the first location of Research Dr was rejected. We all were happy you heard our voice. Which makes no sense why you move it 2 blocks away from the original location, still located 2.5 minute walk from the shelter to Marina, not to mention multiple other schools and children's facilities. Having said all that. This is a very personal issue for my family. You see I have a 17 year old step daughter who attends Marina, is a Junior this year. She has found herself at this school is happy. She went from a D-F student, no self confidence to a flourishing young adult since I married her Dad. Prior to this she lived with her Mom who was verbally and mentally abusive. Her Mom has been homeless in Santa Ana for 3 years now. She started out in Victorville, and was transferred to Santa ana. During her time in Santa Ana, she has lived in 3 "90 day shelters:" Never getting the help they claim they have. Her Mother is Manic Bi Polar, on and off medication and has not worked in over 10 years. We hear monthly how she will be getting an apartment soon, or a job soon. None of this ever happens, yet she continues to live in these 90 day facilities, this last facility has been almost a year. End of last year her Mother started telling us of a place that might open up soon in Huntington Beach, near Marina High School. We thought it was an apartment, not a homeless shelter. Hearing about the potential homeless shelter late March. We put 2 and 2 together and realize now what she was talking about. She wanted to be transferred to the location so she could be closer to her daughter and next year her son will be at Stacey which is about a 10-15 minute walk from Pipeline. My step daughter has been very nervous about this, as are we. If she were to be transferred or accepted she would show up daily at Marina or surrounding locations looking for my step daughter. We know her, know how she is and understand she would do anything to try to getrpftememsTAL COMMUNICATION 1 Meeting Date: '�' 15•f Agenda Item No.; (SO-*/ ( / -6 4/3#') Please understand, we don't keep the kids from their Mom. We, infact take them monthly to Santa Ana to meet their Mother for dinner. She's always welcome to call them. But we have a buffer right now since she is not close by and no way to get to them other than walking or the bus and from Santa Ana that's a far way to come from. We understand what we were told that, only the homeless will be accepted to this shelter. We also understand this to be true about the Victorville location, she was not a resident, she was passing through the city when she had an episode and the police placed her at that location there. She was only living there 90 days, was then transferred to 1 of3 90day facilities" here in Santa Ana. We also understand the preferred location is off Gothard, which we couldn't agree more and it makes more sense to have it in that location centralized to HB and the police station. We understand the struggles of finding a location in that area. However we know that Pipeline is not the correct location and cannot stress enough to please continue your search in the location that would be optimal for the city and police. Never in my life did I want to really know so much about how homeless facilities are run, but we've learned alot in these past 3 years from my husbands ex wife. We understand that a 90 day facilitie is not really just 90 days and can be expanded as long as the person is not causing problems. We know they are not prisoners and can come and go from 7am to 10pm 7 days a week. We understand during these times they are supposed to be out looking for work, doctors appointments, etc. We also know this does not always happen. We see how Santa Ana looks, homeless passed out on lawns of public buildings, loitering at grocery stores, liquor stores or just on side walks. We've seen them drunk, using drugs, being arrested, screaming, defecating, fighting, having sex, robbing, causing crime, etc all in the day time and in the public eye. Some things as you know cannot be controlled, do you want this near Marina High School, Vons, .99 cents store, 7-11 and Jack in the box just the closest businesses near Pipeline? We understand the rules of the shelter she is at, which are the same as the one's outlined you've given to the public for Pipeline. We know they are not shuttled to and from locations of where they want to go during the day 90 plus people can not be catered to in that way. We know they are given bus passes and free Lyft rides to get to their destinations during the times they are allowed out or simply can walk. I feel you are giving the public who does not know this a false sense of security thinking they are under the watchful eye 24/7 when that is not the truth. Having said all that, we'd like to thank you for allowing the public to voice their opinion so you may make a valid decision to not only the homeless needs, but to the homeowners, business owners, students and parents. Again, we cannot stress enough to please do not have a shelter located anywhere near Marina High School for our personal needs. My step daughter is scared her Mom will try to find her daily, interrupt her school and friends. We would take legal action if needed, however we would like for your to scrap Pipeline and find a different location all together. Thank you for your time Lisa and Mark Kavalesky 714-718-9551 2 Switzer, Donna From: Dombo, Johanna Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 11:07 AM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: FW: Homeless Shelter near Marina AGENDA COMMENT From: Lisa Mia <lukiesma27@gmail.com> Sent: Monday,April 15, 2019 11:10 AM To: Peterson, Erik<Erik.Peterson@surfcity-hb.org>; CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Homeless Shelter near Marina Dear City Council, My name is Kathryn Kavalesky, I am currently a Junior at Marina High School and I would like to please ask you to not put a homeless shelter near my home or high school. My Mom is homeless in Santa Ana and has said for months she wants to be transferred to a closer location so she can see me every day. I've told her no, I don't want her to and I will see her when I can. But she's persistent to be relocated to a shelter closer to the school. I am very afraid and worried she will find a way. I love my Mom, but the years I did live with her she was very verbally and mentally abusive towards my and my brother. She is Manic Depressive, Bi Polar and probably schizophrenic. She also is an alcoholic. It would be horrible if she tried to show up at Marina to find me or my friends. I am doing well in school A's and B's now, when I lived with her I was D's and F's and I was very depressed. Not just about my Mom, but I have seen the life of the homeless for 3 years she's lived in Santa Ana. I see homeless passed out on the streets and parks, infront of homes and businesses and much more. I do not want this near my High School where I feel safe, my school along with my home is my safe place. Please hear me please I do no want a homeless shelter so close to my safe places. Thank you Kathryn Kavalesky SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date: Lf• 15. 11 Agenda Item No.; ASS#l 11' 413U) 1 Work Order: #152963 04/15/2019 Closed: This issue is assigned Est.Resolution By : Jake Lou Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email jakelou1953@gmail.co SUB TYPE Phone . City Council Meeting Device . STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Homeless Shelter:The current proposed site is with a 1.2 mile driving radius of six schools(0.9 miles Marina),various facilities for children's activities and Marina Park.The distance of course is much shorter if one was to walk,skate,bicycle,scooter or skateboard.A more suitable site on city owned property can and should be utilized.I urge you all to OPPOSE this current location for the safety,security,well being of all our children educationally, emotionally,physically and spiritually.Thank you Jake Lou Huntington Beach Status Changed:04/15/2019 7:58 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#152963 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 7:58 AM Johanna Dombo Workorder#152963 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeong Date: q/• 15• 19 Agenda Item No.; 5 to («- Y&) Switzer, Donna From: Dombo, Johanna Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 1:44 PM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: FW: Homeless Shelter AGENDA COMMENT From: Patty Mandichak<pmaandi@gmail.com> Sent: Monday,April 15, 2019 12:15 PM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Homeless Shelter I am writing this to voice my concerns in regards to opening a homeless shelter in HB. First, I feel very strongly about keeping a shelter away from our young children and young adults. Opening one so close to schools enables a chance for lingering close to the schools. I know some of the homeless are goid, but there are many that are dealing with addiction and psychological problems. We do not need this close to our children. Second, I feel strongly that opening a homeless shelter in our area will only attract more homeless people. The homeless are only at the shelters at night. Where will they be lingering during the day? We owe it to our children to keep them safe! Therefore I am against a shelter so close to our children and in Huntington Beach. Thank you, Patricia Mandichak SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date: 41. 15 /�l Agenda Item No.; GSW'/ ( / 1— q3j,) 1 Work Order: #152957 04/15/2019 Closed: By David Manriquez Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email ghettocopr@sbcglobal. net SUB TYPE Phone . City Council Meeting Device . STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None ❑x COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES I am a resident of HB,living near Marina High School and Marina Park.My child attends SCATS gymanastics and other businesses in the area.The homeless Shelter being proposed at 15311 Pipeline lane,is a ridiculous proposal being so close to a high school and children facilities.I have already seen first hand what homeless people do in the park,such as use illegal drugs and start fires,burning down the picnic benches and pergola.I,and numerous of my neighbors are adamantly against this and as residents of this area,are offended that the city council would even consider this when childrens lives are at stake.I hope you make the right decision,and vote against putting a homeless shelter at this proposed site,as it endangers the public and most importantly the kids who attend the surrounding sporting facilities.Thank you,and God bless. Status Changed:04/15/2019 7:59 AM Johanna Dombo I Work Order#152957 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 7:59 AM Johanna Dombo SUP Workorder#152957 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and SU PL NTAL subtype City Council Meeting. COMMUNICATION Share with Citizen.M NO Meeting Dom: Agenda Item No.;35##I ( Y3&) Work Order: #152989 04/15/2019 Closed: This issue is a �:r .. a. � „ � _. By : Paula Redmond Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email psgirlie@aol.com Phone 949-280-6310 SUB TYPE Device . City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Homeless Shelter Opposition.Since I work I am unable to attend the meeting that will be held at 3:30pm on Mon Apr 15,I am submitting this email.This is extremely inconvenient to the many contributing taxpayers who work a full time job to pay taxes to own property and live in Huntington Beach.Any approval for this proposed homeless shelter is irresponsible and and shows lack of respect for the taxpayers you were elected to represent in Huntington Beach. This proposal is flawed in many ways and has been tried in other cities with very disastrous outcomes to property values as well as quality and safety of life to the residents.Seattle, Baltimore,Detroit,Chicage,San Francisco,Oakland,Downtown LA,San Bernardino,Pomona, Stockton and Inglewood all started with plans like what is being proposed in Huntington Beach.Look at their situations now.Overflowing with homeless,tents,human excrement, trash,biohazardous waste and disease.It is a public health travesty.Let's look around at these cities and learn from their mistakes before making our own.This will not help or fix the problem.The continuous handouts will only bring more.First it will be bus passes and ebt cards and a hot shower and meals.Instead of setting up this sham of a homeless shelter,the elected city council needs to stand up and fight against this rather than taxing the residents for something that has proven over and over in other cities to not only not work,but rather create a worsened situation.Look at the cities around us who are not hospitable to homeless,they do not have a problem.As the homeless task force of HBPD told us at a resident meeting,don't feed the pigeons,it only encourages them to stay and bring their friends.Most of the "homeless"in HB are not down on their luck needing just a handup.Most want to live their current lives with no rules,no consequences,doing their drugs and alcohol and not conforming to societal norms.Those of us who contribute to a functioning society should not have to pay SUPPLEMENTAL IV�®�� for this.I strongly urge each and every council member to say no to this plan,at this location �7 or any other in Huntington Beach and to fight for our rights as a city to not encourage this COMMUNICATION behavior and make the city safe for residents and tourists(where a large portion of city revenues come from)again.Homelessness should be a county issue,not a city specific issue in areas that are already fully developed.There are plenty of wide open spaces in other parts of • Date, . is. 1 the county that are not yet developed where something can be purposefully build for homeless ' that actually need and want to get into a better situation.This is what our city should be u Agenda item No.; / [ i i' /c31 i) pushing towards,not spinelessly caving into politicians mob scare tactics that we provide a shelter in our city or not allow us to enforce our laws to keep law abiding citizens safe.Thank you for your consideration and follow through on this. Status Changed:04/15/2019 10:47 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#152989 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 10:47 AM Johanna Dombo Workorder#152989 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO Work Order: #152469 04/11/2019 Closed: _. This lssu- .� ,=: - = i• , n By Joseph Stancato Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email j.stancato@yahoo.com Phone 714-330-0735 SUB TYPE Device . City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Homeless Options.Seems locating the shelter where it has the least impact on property values would provide the greatest benefit to the homeowners of Huntington Beach. Status Changed:04/15/2019 8:12 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#152469 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 8:12 AM Johanna Dombo Workorder#152469 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date: y 15• I4 No.; Ss1#/ ( 11- L/3(,) Work Order: #152572 04122019 Closed: This issue is assigned Est. Resolution Date: Not Yet Set By Denise Tilley Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email Denise.tilley@verizon.n et SUB TYPE Phone 714-901-3661 City Council Meeting Device . STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Navigation center in North Huntington Beach.I understand the need to open one due to the courts requirements.But why move them north?You will just be spreading the problem throughout the city.We have a few homeless here now,but they are not creating the problems you have in the south end of town.We have a great take force that are helping the ones who want help.But you want to bring the ones who don't,the druggies and mentally ill to our neighborhood with several schools and places our kids go within a mile of your choices so far. You are just trying to get them away from downtown where the tourists are for your revenue. Otherwise why are all of the buildings you are looking to lease or buy in North Huntington Beach?Explain how you can keep them from leaving on foot,it is not a jail.You have made a poor choice in this location.You work for us and can always be voted out.Do your job,show us where the other locations are and let us as a community have some input as to where it should go.You need to watch Seattle is Dying.At the end there is a State on the East Coast that locks them up,gives them the medication to withdrawal from the drugs,counseling,both one on one and group and the tools they need go get a job when they get out.They have over a 90% success rate in the 3 years they have been open.And several said if they had not been arrested and put in the program,they would be dead today.Your navigation center is not going to help them in anyway,other than trying to get them back to their families and or the states they are from.If they refuse to go to the navigation center,they will be arrested and released the next day.It will just be a vicious circle. Status Changed:04/15/2019 8:11 AM Johanna Dombo COMMUNICATION Work Order#152572 status has changed from new to assigned. COMMUNICATION Share with Citizen:NO Meeting Date: /5./9 Agenda item No.;L9&#I/ ( p '/- q3(0) Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 8:11 AM Johanna Dombo Workorder#152572 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO Work Order: #152948 04/14/2019 Closed: >y' This issue is assigned Est. Resolution Date: Not Yet By : Mark Tonkovich Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email Marktonko@gmail.com Phone 714-519-9555 SUB TYPE Device . City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS &ADDITIONAL NOTES I met with Lyn on Saturday and she asked I send this article I read.I will not be able to attend on Monday as I will be out of town but I do not feel purchasing Pipeline is a good solution,.You have not been transparent on the other locations.I feel a temporary solution can be found by trailers or tents on existing HB owned property until this can be properly vetted.See enclosed article on North OC and how they are handling this.Why are we a lone wolf? http://www.nocchamber.com/news/details/north-county-cities-move-ahead-on-homeless-shelter Status Changed:04/15/2019 8:00 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#152948 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 8:00 AM Johanna Dombo Workorder#152948 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date: If'/S' /`� Agenda Item No.; ssiii (i'- 1134 Work Order: #152489 Opened: 2019 Closed: By : Kandie Van Affelen Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email : kvanaff@aol.com Phone . SUB TYPE Device . City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES I am against putting a homeless shelter on Pipeline near so many schools and facilities where children are.My granddaughter goes to Scats gymnastics 300 feet from this proposed shelter. Huntington Beach does not need a shelter.Transport them back to whoever sent them here.I am just about done with this liberal State.Do not let Huntington Beach become another Seattle.The residents work hard to be able to live here.Let us not forget what happened at the sports complex where the police had to kill the homeless man that tried to attack parents and children. Status Changed:04/15/2019 8:12 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#152489 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 8:12 AM Johanna Dombo Workorder#152489 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meng Date: Y.15. 1.9 Agenda Item No.; SSIt I (I-I' q&) Opened: Work Order: #152686 04/13/2019 Closed: This issue is assigned - olut rs .i of By : Lisa Veal Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email Lisa@vealz.com Phone . SUB TYPE Device . City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Please think of the safety of our children.No homless shelter should be built at LEAST a mile from any school or field!! Status Changed:04/15/2019 8:08 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#152686 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 8:08 AM Johanna Dombo Workorder#152686 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date: yb/5. 1'] Agenda Item No.;(354#/ (i l: 1131 Work Order: #152791 04/13/2019 04/15/201 9 This issue is resolved Est. Resolution Date: Not Yet Set By : Rod Vickers Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email rodvickers@yahoo.com SUB TYPE Phone 714-891-4241 City Council Meeting Device . STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None x❑ COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Hello.I oppose the current plan to locate a homeless shelter at 15311 Pipeline.The city's plans have not been transparent,the plan appears rushed,and I get the feeling that the NW corner of the city has been unfairly targeted to shoulder the burden of risk that this facilitiy will bring with it.I vote.Thank you,Rod Vickers Status Changed:04/15/2019 8:22 AM Donna Switzer Work Order#152791 status has changed from assigned to resolved. Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: https://www.huntingtonbeachca.gov/servicesThomeless-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/15/2019 8:03 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#152791 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO SUPPLEMENTAL Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 8:03 AM Johanna Dombo COMMUNICATION Workorder#152791 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments anmeagng Date: y 15.11 subtype City Council Meeting. Agenda Item No.;ems#/ (1-- y349 Share with Citizen:NO Work Order: #152984 04/15/2019 Closed: By : Donald Walton Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email walotti@verizon.net Phone 714-717-5949 SUB TYPE Device . City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None ❑x COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Opposition to homeless shelter on Pipeline Lane(Letter Attached)City Council,I am writing this letter in response to the proposed homeless shelter that is being considered at 15311 Pipelane Lane,HB.I would like to put on record that I deeply oppose the location of the shelter.I attended the open house at the library on 04/13/19 and unfortunately it appeared nothing more than a fluff show to promote how safe and helpful this shelter will be.City Officials,Council and other attendees,in robotic form,repeated the same rhetoric praising what a great addition this will be to our City.Although I realize that the demands by Judge Carter are unreasonable,I believe the City is rushing this decision and not thinking it through clearly.Some facts that the City must take more seriously:1.Proximity to children.The proximity to Marina High School,Grace Lutheran School,Circle View Elementary,all of which are less than a 3/4 mile from the shelter.Scats Gymnastics and The Rinks are the closest.The Rinks and Scats are both.3 miles(or approx.1760 ft)from the shelter.These schools and businesses cater to children!For that reason alone,this location is unacceptable!2.Home Values.Realtor.com estimates that homeless shelters cause nearby neighborhoods to lose up to 12%in equity.It's the#4 reason potential buyers would have difficulty moving to the neighborhood.By the way,that equates to over$90,000 for my home.That is$90,000 that I won't be able to use for retirement(I'm 61 years old)and/or leave for my children.3.Saftey. Although it is said that there will be security guards on site 24/7,this will not be enough to offset violence or drugs.It is well know that our Police Officers are already spread thin.They oftentimes struggle to respond quickly to every call that goes out in the City.This ties their hands and causes them to only be able to be reactive rather than proactive to crime.If someone does leave the shelter in a non-acceptable way,they will quickly have access to SUPPLEMENTAL children and homes.Additionally,our homeless task force Officers are made up of two men COMMUNICATION work until the early afternoon hours on weekdays.This is not enough.4.Local Businesses. COMMUNICA 1T ION Businesses in the industrials are not for this either.Are we going to allow the loss of the vital taxes that business revenue generates?No doubt,some will leave the area for a location that (/ doesn't have the same riff-raff associated with homelessness.5.Lawsuits.If the City erects Meeting Date: a • /S this shelter in close proximity to children and something happens,the City will undoubtedly be sued.I've heard people already threatening this action should something happen.Finally,we l Agenda Item No.;&S#/ (I'?— '13ii) are the residents,home owners,tax payers and the majority in the area.We DO NOT want this. We have worked hard to buy a small piece of the American Dream in Huntington Beach.This should be considered and not ignored.As elected officials,you are placed in a position of trust to represent your constituents.I encourage you to look for more alternatives(work with cities that have more land)or fight this in the courts.These Judges have gotten out of control. Especially the 9th Circuit Court.It's time to stand up and not let them bully cities without fighting.The costs of buying a building,feeding,housing,staffing,medical,transportation, providing security for,etc.over the years will be harmful to taxpayers.Not only will house prices go down,our taxes will likely go up to fund this.We just cannot afford to risk our children's safety to appease a judge.I urge you to please say no to this location for the homeless shelter.It just doesn't make sense and I believe you are all vested enough in the community to know this.Sincerely Donald Walton 6032 Welde Cir Huntington Beach,CA 92647 714-717-5949 Status Changed:04/15/2019 10:47 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#152984 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 10:47 AM Johanna Dombo Workorder#152984 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO Switzer, Donna From: Dombo, Johanna _ Sent: Friday, April 12, 2019 11:32 AM r1Zl To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL 0_0 Subject: Homeless Shelter AGENDA COMMENT Victoria Bailey is opposed to the homeless center on Pipeline Dr. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date: 1/.15•19 Agenda Item No.; (c6 / I in- y341) i Esparza, Patty From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, April 09, 2019 9:17 AM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: FW: Homeless shelter AGENDA COMMENT From:Jeff Bratcher<cityguardian831@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday,April 09, 2019 7:43 AM To: Peterson, Erik<Erik.Peterson@surfcity-hb.org> Cc: Fikes, Cathy<CFikes@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Homeless shelter Mr. Peterson, I want to Express my strong opposition to the Pipeline homeless shelter. North HB IS NOT the dumping ground for a problem we did not create. Why not put it by the library instead of where the city receive a huge boost in the tax base from our vibrant businesses and Boeing. This homeless shelter WILL bring crime to MY peaceful neighborhood and is unwelcome. Jeff Bratcher (714) 329-3336 SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date: 7• /c5' 11 Agenda item No ()U*/ ( 147- Li* 1 Work Order: #151973 04 n 019 Closed: By Robert Dominguez Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email bobbydominguez@veriz on.net SUB TYPE Phone 714-846-4647 City Council Meeting Device . STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Homelessness.I support establishing the homeless shelter at Pipeline Ln.However,I DO NOT support purchasing the building outright.I feel we should lease with a contingent to purchase. Then,later if it works,the City can move to purchase it,or another permanent facility. Notes Added By staff:04/11/2019 5:32 PM Robin Estanislau Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: https://www.huntingtonbeachca.gov/services/homeless-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/11/2019 5:07 PM Johanna Dombo Work Order#151973 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/11/2019 5:07 PM Johanna Dombo SUPPLEMENTAL Workorder#151973 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and COMMUNICATION subtype City Council Meeting. Meeting Date: y. 15.161 Share with Citizen:NO Agenda Item No.; SSW/(1 q" 3(0) Esparza, Patty From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, April 09, 2019 10:45 AM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: FW: 50 Bed Navigation Center AGENDA COMMENT Original Message From: Stephen Einstein <Rebgiraffe@aol.com> Sent: Friday, March 29, 2019 9:35 PM To: Peterson, Erik<Erik.Peterson@surfcity-hb.org> Cc: Fikes, Cathy<CFikes@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: 50 Bed Navigation Center Dear Mayor Peterson, I write to you in my capacity as a Past President of the Greater Huntington Beach Interfaith Council, and as the Founding Rabbi Emeritus of Congregation B'nai Tzedek, a religious center of which a large percentage of members are Huntington Beach residents. On Monday, I will be in Cincinnati, participating in the annual convention of the Central Conference of American Rabbis. Otherwise, I would most certainly be attending the City Council meeting,and speaking in favor of Item #13. Many years ago, I viewed the remarkable play, "Man of La Mancha," based on the famed Spanish novel "Don Quixote" by Miguel de Cervantes. One line moved me then, and remains with me to this day: "When I look into your face, I see the face of God." This literary line echoes the profound teaching of Leviticus 19:18: "Love your neighbor as yourself." This scriptural verse is,truly,the basic rule of living that is at the heart of both Judaism and Christianity. Need I say more? Each and every person is a child of God, created in the image of God. What then, is expected of us— as individuals...and as a community?To treat each person with loving care. So, in light of this, I urge the Council to adopt the proposal contained in Item#13, and move us exactly in this direction. Respectfully yours, Si E Rabbi Stephen J. Einstein, DHL, DD HaRav Shalom Ya'akov ben Shaya Zalman v'Zelda Founding Rabbi Emeritus Congregation B'nai Tzedek Fountain Valley, CA "In every generation,we must all see ourselves as if we, personally,went forth from Mitzrayim." Haggadah shel Pesach "The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men (i.e., people)to do nothing." Edmund Burke SUPPLEMENTAL. COMMUNICATION Agenda lbw No.• SS# / ( ,°1- Lj&, Esparza, Patty From: Dombo, Johanna Sent: Monday, April 08, 2019 1:40 PM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: FW: 15311 Pipeline Lane AGENDA COMMENT From:Scott Johnson <scottj@pwsei.com> Sent: Monday, April 08, 2019 12:49 PM To:CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: 15311 Pipeline Lane I am an occupant of a property on Pipeline and have been so since 1992. I am skocked at the decision to turn a property on this street into a shelter.This area is not zoned for residential usage. PLEASE explain how you have approved a single property to be zoned for residential usage on this street. Sincerely Scott Johnson The information in this email is confidential and may be legally privileged. It is intended solely for the addressee. If you are not the intended recipient, any copying, use, or distribution of the information in this email is prohibited and may be unlawful. P.W. Stephens Environmental, Inc. disclaims all responsibility and liability for information contained in this email and attachment. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date: 11. /5: /9 Agenda Item No.; SSW/ ( 1' 430) i Esparza, Patty From: Dombo, Johanna Sent: Wednesday, April 10, 2019 2:30 PM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: FW: Homelessness Navigation Center 15311 Pipeline AGENDA COMMENT From: Lisa Miles<ochomesbylisa@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday,April 10, 2019 2:28 PM To:CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Homelessness Navigation Center 15311 Pipeline I am writing the council un regards to the new purposed site on Pipeline. This site is still too close to housing, schools and sports complexes. You have several kids activity centers in the area as well as residence. The city needs to find a place that doesn't have surrounding homes and kids centers. I already deal with homeless parking in the back of my house, drinking and causing problems. This is only going to make things worse. Kindest Regards, Lisa Miles 41444 BRE license #01848035 Direct (714) 313-2515 SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Date:Meeting Lt./5. /9 Agenda Item No.;615#/ t- / 1 - L13lo) 1 Esparza, Patty From: Dombo, Johanna Sent: Monday, April 08, 2019 4:59 PM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: FW: Pipeline Homeless Shelter AGENDA COMMENT From: Denis Morin <denismorin@mit-inc.net> Sent: Monday, April 08, 2019 4:56 PM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Pipeline Homeless Shelter Attn: City Council Good day, my name is Denis Morin and I've been a proud and happy resident of Huntington Beach for 35 years. I write today to strongly protest the recently announced plan to open a shelter on Pipeline Lane. My family owns a building on Pipeline and operates our business from that location. Many of our employees can be seen enjoying the clean safe neighborhood on their daily walks before work and during breaks. I fear this will no longer be the case should such a facility open down the street. While our city has its share of problems, like any other city,the industrial area is not one of them. It is a success story in high demand for these type of properties compared to many of the blighted industrial areas in other cities. This is the exact reason my family twenty three years ago moved our business out of the L.A. area and invested in our building. I've been told by employees and clients alike that our location has a definite positive affect when choosing employment or considering establishing a vendor relation. During the last recession our area sprang back much faster than many other industrial areas because to date it has not been burdened with the many problems associated with other areas. I again fear that a shelter here will only reduce the caliber of businesses drawn to the area as well as negatively affect rental and property values. More importantly I see the problems of crime, drugs and blight we sought to escape in other areas taking hold here and having a dramatically negative effect on the quality life we have worked so hard to establish. I respectfully request you stick by the long time business and property owners who have been loyal and invested in our city and reconsider this flawed plan. Best Regards, SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Denis R. Morin C A M.I.T., INC. Meng Date: '• /c7'1-/ 15202 Pipeline Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92649 714 899-6066 xt. 500 Agenda Item No V / 1�' 11 3(/) Tel: (714) Fax: (714) 899-6068 This message is a PRIVATE communication. This message and all attachments are a private communication sent by Morin Industrial Technology, Inc. (M.I.T., INC.)and may be confidential and/or protected as a trade secret. If you are not the intended recipient,you are hereby notified that any disclosure, copying,distribution or use of the information contained in or attached to this message is strictly prohibited. Please notify the sender of the delivery error by replying to this message,and then delete it from your system. Thank You. 1 Esparza, Patty From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Wednesday, April 10, 2019 9:33 AM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: FW: Homeless shelter AGENDA COMMENT From: berreprincess@aol.com <berreprincess@aol.com> Sent:Tuesday,April 09, 2019 7:57 PM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Homeless shelter After finding out that you are kicking out a business to put this shelter in place, I am BEYOND disgusted with our city council members. I don't give a hoot what this judge wants. He hasn't sued our city and no one is making our city put this in place. Yet you all on city council are telling this business to get out. If the owner of that auto business has no place to move his business you are then possibly creating homeless in that manner are you not if not one of them can find a new job?You are causing someone to lose their business then. Their lively hood and others that work there as well if a new location can not be found for that business. This is disturbing that you put homeless people over those that are trying to make a living. This is not ok and should not be happening at all. So now on top of risk of something happening in the area and more homeless coming along or moved to this side of our town you are pushing a business out of the town as well. Shame on you all! Anna Plewa SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date: Y• 15, !� Agenda kern No.; SAS##'/ l !q_h131.0) i Work Order: #152147 Opene : Closed: By John scharf Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email : JASCHARF@UCI.EDU Phone 714-897-8343 SUB TYPE Device City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Why is the city not filing a lawsuit to stop judge Carter's order for OC cities to provide homeless shelters?Where in the constitution or other legal precedent does he base this order? You and the city took the correct and hard line with the state on the sanctuary state order and this is exactly the same from an over reaching federal judge.I and many of my HB friends and neighbors will be at the city council meeting Monday to object to the shelter and hear your answer. Notes Added By staff:04/11/2019 5:32 PM Robin Estanislau Thank you for your feedback.It will be included as part of the record on this topic.For new information on what the City is doing to address homelessness,goto: https://www.huntingtonbeachca.gov/services/homeless-solutions/. Share with Citizen:YES Status Changed:04/11/2019 5:04 PM Johanna Dombo Work Order#152147 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/11/2019 5:03 PM Johanna Dombo Workorder#152147 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments an Date: '1 /5•11 Agenda Item No.; (S6 / 01- 11310) Esparza, Patty From: Dombo, Johanna Sent: Monday, April 08, 2019 4:58 PM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: FW: Proposed Navigation Center- 15311 Pipeline Lane AGENDA COMMENT From: Brian Waldbaum <brianwaldbaum@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, April 08, 2019 4:43 PM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Cc: Phil Gibson <phil@tmtlabs.com>; Kristin Burgett<kris@tmtlabs.com>; Mikki Waldbaum <mikki225@gmail.com> Subject: Proposed Navigation Center- 15311 Pipeline Lane Dear City Council Members, The proposed "Navigation Center" is inaccurately described as an "Emergency Shelter". Emergency shelters house people who are homeless or displaced due to an actual emergency, not those who are chronically homeless. An Emergency Shelter is a land use reserved for Public and Semipublic zoned property as established in Huntington Beach Zoning Code Section 204.8, Subsection C.4: "Emergency Shelters. Establishments offering food and shelter programs for "homeless"people and others in need. This classification does not include facilities licensed for residential care, as defined by the State of California, which provide supervision of daily activities." According to information published on the City's website on April 8, the proposed Navigation Center will be enclosed by a security fence, will house 75 to 90 men, women and couples for 3 months or longer, and will provide healthcare, counseling and job training. Residents will not be allowed in or out unless transported by vehicle.These activities clearly constitute "supervision of daily activities" which places the Navigation Center in a different category altogether. The Navigation Center meets all of the requirements to be classified as General Residential Care and/or General Residential Alcohol Recovery as defined in Section 204.8.C, Subsections 5 and 6. "Residential Care, General. Twenty-four-hour non-medical care for seven or more persons, including wards of the juvenile court, in need of personal services, supervision, protection, or assistance essential for sustaining the activities of daily living. This classification includes only those facilities licensed by the State of California." "Residential Alcohol Recovery, General. Facilities providing 24-hour care for more than six persons suffering from alcohol problems, in need of personal services, supervision, protection or assistance. These facilities may include an inebriate reception center as well as facilities for treatment, training, research, and administrative services for program participants and employees. This classification includes only those facilities licensed by the State of California." The City must acknowledge that the needs of our homeless population are not simply housing, food and clothing. The underlying issues of mental health and addiction must be addressed in a setting where there is access to medical care, protection by law enforcement, and in some cases legal representation.The proposed location on Pipeline Lane is a very 1 poor choice due to its long distance from any hospitals, mental health care offices and the Huntington Beach Police Department. Furthermore it poses the risk of violence,theft and disruption of daily life to the surrounding businesses, neighborhoods and schools.The fact that the City Council would consider placing a homeless shelter in such close proximity to residential neighborhoods and schools shows a severe lack of consideration for our the residents of our city and their children. It is misleading to label the Navigation Center as an Emergency Shelter. By providing these services to people for extended periods(3 months or even longer),the City is by definition providing residential care.The property at 15311 Pipeline Lane is zoned "Industrial Limited" and is not intended for this type of use.The City Council should openly state to the Public that the Navigation Center will provide Residential Care for the homeless and should choose a Public or Semipublic location as directed in the Huntington Beach Charter and Codes. Respectfully, Brian Waldbaum 5902 Nugget Circle Huntington Beach, CA 92647 (714) 951-1729 SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date: 41• IS•1'? Agenda Item No.;ZitO/ (,''WUD) 2 Switzer, Donna From: Dombo, Johanna Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 1:53 PM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: FW: NO HOMELESS SHELTER IN NORTH HB AGENDA COMMENT From: Brian <briandkn@yahoo.com> Sent:Tuesday, April 16, 2019 1:00 PM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Re: NO HOMELESS SHELTER IN NORTH HB From: Brian<briandkngyahoo.com> Date: April 16, 2019 at 6:48:32 AM PDT To: city.counccil(asurfcity-HB.org Subject: NO HOMELESS SHELTER IN NORTH HB City Council members, You were voted in to represent us,the people that have made HB our homes. I get up at 5:30 every morning and go to work so my children can live in a nice city. I urge you to please reconsider the homeless shelter on Pipeline. My daughter attends gymnastics at Scats and we play hockey at the Rinks. We do not want OUR City Council to drop a homeless shelter smack dab in the middle of our lives. Certainly there are alternatives. The first one should be to push back and sue the State for not letting us deal with the Homeless the way we think they should be handled. We are not a sanctuary city! We are a city of people who take pride in there family's,property and community. Please vote no on the Homeless shelter, Respectfully, Brian Dakin North Hb i Switzer, Donna From: Dombo, Johanna Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 11:27 AM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: FW: Homeless navigation center AGENDA COMMENT Original Message From: kara Lomon <superstars84@yahoo.com> Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 11:11 AM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Homeless navigation center As a resident of North Huntington Beach I am saddened that the only locations you could agree on are in this area, especially so close to schools. I understand that the upper echelon of this city do not live in this area, and want the homeless out of their parks and the tourist money making locations. But shame on this council for putting a shelter so close to schools, SCATS, outbreak,the rinks, and Robinwood Park. You realize that parents of these schools will be pulling their children out and requesting to attend other schools in the district. How will you deal with that? Will you deny our children once again? I'm angered, scared and saddened that the council choose so poorly. And what will happen with taxes once a shelter goes up? Will the county be helping or will it fall on the tax paying residents? Drug addiction needs to be addressed to help control the homeless situation. Stop allowing rehab houses in Huntington Beach that bus in addicts from all over the US. Where do you think they go once they relapse?And statistically speaking, most do because the halfway house system is a money making machine that could care less about recovery. I was born and raised in this City. Our leaders over the past few years have changed this once safe, small town charming, family friendly city. I thought I'd live out the rest of my days here but the current state of affairs disgusts me. Drugs, rehab houses everywhere, high density building, traffic from lack of infrastructure planning, horrible roads, cost of living, the disparity of funding amongst public schools in the city, putting more effort into tourism than helping out the citizens...please at least attempt to keep a glimmer of hope by not exposing the schools near Pipeline to a 75-90 bed homeless shelter. Keep our North Huntington Beach kids safe!!! We may not be the most affluent but our kids deserve the right to be safe while going to school. K Lomon 1 Switzer, Donna From: Dombo, Johanna Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 7:39 AM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: FW: Navigation Center Location AGENDA COMMENT From: Rayna Hamre <rayna_hamre@yahoo.com> Sent:Tuesday, April 16, 2019 7:39 AM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Navigation Center Location Please do not buckle to the folks who do not want this center. Where would a location be that they will accept?? No place. Please take a stand to make this happen. We don't have any'wide open spaces' in HB.This center needs to go somewhere. Thank you, Rev. Rayna Harare and Stephen Hamre (30 Year homeowners at Edwards & McFadden) 15602 Mayflower Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92647 714 898-7183 Sent from Mail for Windows 10 Switzer, Donna From: Dombo, Johanna Sent: Tuesday, April 16, 2019 7:30 AM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: FW: Homeless Shelter AGENDA COMMENT From: amber raemer<araemer@yahoo.com> Sent:Tuesday, April 16, 2019 6:31 AM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Homeless Shelter To whom it may concern, Please reconsider the location of the homeless shelter. This location is next to Grace Lutheran Preschool, Elementary school, and middle school. We have children walk to school. Also it is right next to the hockey Rink, soccer indoor field and Scats. There are SO many children in the area. Please attached picture Go CgIe Maps Proposed H13 Homeless Shelter & Proxwo4ty to cthatrirens Programs ot*R4c.`'"'` QStaff P'° 7 Proposed Shelter 10 i tMr,re glut.Wrote tnd...es 9 200 yards/2 min walk fi, ',Rs r, 9 ` A. arty s/3 min wa rk 1300 arils/12 min walk , r Lutheran Sc'- Thibm i Huntin 7 Ark a F,, a,a:�,c,�, •. ;. • firs i; on T4t0,t:,;Q / - ,@. .. n Lvmrart' . r'+y .7'n b eow..,ar, A,,,,>tKSU«..., "► I .,/ i r.. Ptabtrsh Brand ....rwr,r;. ,. K. LA?emir,.P 1 800 yards/9 min walk d �.r 1000 yard//10 mint walk 7 KO trt4 y 0 w Ydtt 4. ci 1 mi in walk ; ,a Pat'1 bl tieassbn .;,, vat Ytaxr ntir311..r 40,)r 'memory School Map d Thanks HB resident Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPhone 2 Switzer, Donna From: Dombo, Johanna Sent: Wednesday, April 17, 2019 9:50 AM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: FW: Homeless Shelter AGENDA COMMENT From: berreprincess@aol.com <berreprincess@aol.com> Sent:Wednesday, April 17, 2019 9:46 AM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Homeless Shelter I am disgusted that you are still going through with this and putting a vote to this location so quickly. Still many questions not answered at all. Where is the money coming from for this shelter?Who is paying for it all?Who is really running it and in the long run profit from running it?What about drug testing?Alcohol testing? What about the business(es) that are in that building now?Where to do those places go and their employees?What happens if they can not find a new location? That becomes loss of their livelihoods because you all on city council took their location(s) of business from them for a shelter that isn't going to help the majority of homeless. The lady from Mercy House couldn't answer the questions on Monday and only gave one business' feedback on it around them. Which what if she can't come back with others?What happens to those homeless that do not want help that are from our city?What happens to those homeless not from our city? How are things handled for when they want to go any place in the day?Will it only be allowed if its for certain reasons (doctor,job hunting, etc) and not just to camp some place in the city to do nothing or get a fix or beg?Who in the end is paying for all these trips they will take as well and make sure they are going to where they should be? As it is security that had been hired to patrol Central Park doesn't seem to be doing anything so who is to say that whatever security hired for the shelter will either?What about if something happens to any business(es) or residents near there or the schools?Who is going to take responsibility for that?There doesn't seem to be a plan in place for any of this from how everything has sounded so far. I don't see this helping do a thing about the homeless issues when what is really needed in the end is rehabs and mental hospitals for many to go into for the help needed. Until then we will never see the problem of homeless get better but only get worse. At this point, after reading how it has effected other cities I do not see how this will do anything but make things worse. I hope nothing happens because of this otherwise there will be major answers needed from many. I also hope our city doesn't go bankrupt because of it either. Anna Plewa 1 Switzer, Donna From: agendacomment@surfcity-hb.org Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 3:37 PM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Public Comments on Council Agenda Items AGENDA COMMENT Subject Study Session #1 (April 15th, 2019) 19-463 Name Steven C Shepherd Email steve@shepherdarchitects.corn Comments While I understand the NIMBY-istic"will of the people" in Huntington Beach, the attitude of many of my fellow citizens should not serve as an excuse for ineffectiveness and inaction by our elected officials in addressing homelessness in our city. The City of Huntington Beach has both a practical and moral duty to be a constructive participant in addressing local homelessness, and I would much prefer that we view the development of effective services, facilities and policies for our homeless community as an opportunity rather than a burden. Homelessness and a swelling homeless population in our region must be addressed, and Huntington Beach can either be part of the problem or begin taking steps to become part of the solution. For most in our community, there will never be an acceptable location for any new homeless shelter. Shelters as well as any manner of affordable or multi-family housing has been unfairly and incorrectly demonized in our community, and as a result, the Council should be prepared for push-back regardless of their ultimate decision. I support the new project on Pipeline Drive and would also support similar shelters in other locations as well. Remember: the longer our city waits to take constructive action, the more difficult it will become to do anything to address this pressing need. I would much prefer for the City of Huntington Beach to invest in homelessness programs than in pointless legal fees spent on defending against future lawsuits and inevitable court orders directing the City to take appropriate action. i Work Order: #153073 04/15/2019 Closed: This issue is assigned $'` r By : Mitchell Claman Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email Mitchellrclaman@aol.c om SUB TYPE Phone 714-721-5689 City Council Meeting Device . STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Homeless shelter concern As a current resident,past gymnast and current coach at SCATS gymnastics I AM very concerned about the proposed location of the homeless shelter.While I have volunteered time at shelters and advocate the benefits of shelters I just don't believe the location is fit for its surroundings.SCATS,the Rinks and many other youth organizations become very busy in the early day and remain active until late in the evening.This could pose a potential thread to the athletes,mothers,grandparents,siblings or individuals who watch, drop off and pick up their children at the said facilities.As I mentioned,I have previously volunteered at homeless shelters and I have seen and experienced run off of homeless individuals who were turned away or left the shelter leaving the individuals to loiter,and set up camp anywhere they saw fit.I strongly encourage and ask that you reconsider this location of the shelter and recommend a continued search that would result in an area with much less youth activities nearby!Thank you for your consideration! Status Changed:04/15/2019 4:01 PM Johanna Dombo Work Order#153073 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 4:01 PM Johanna Dombo Workorder#153073 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. • Share with Citizen:NO Work Order: #153108 04/15/2019 Closed: This issue is assigned - -• - et Set By : Bonnie McKee Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email bonmckee48@gmail.co SUB TYPE Phone 714-902-8438 City Council Meeting Device . STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None ❑x COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Proposed homeless shelter.I have lived near this location my whole life and can't believe that the city would ever begin to think that it is wise to put a shelter so close to children.I'm also a single female so my safety I will be in danger as well.My son will be entering junior high soon and has asked if he can start walking home with his friends.There is absolutely no way on this earth I would let him if this happens.In addition,the site is almost directly behind me.I live in the apartments near the racquetball courts. Status Changed:04/15/2019 4:01 PM Johanna Dombo Work Order#153108 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 4:01 PM Johanna Dombo Workorder#153108 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO Work Order: #153149 04/15/2019 Closed: This issue is assigned Est. Resolution Date: Not Yet Set • By Courtney Hoetker Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email jchoetker@verizon.net Phone 714-749-8992 SUB TYPE Device City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted None COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES We do NOT want the homeless shelter in North HB.It does not belong near Marina HS or in an industrial area.It is going to drag down our housing prices and is SO NOT FAIR!?!I work for a police department and deal with homeless people on a day to day basis.I don't want them near my home.Crime will go up for sure. Status Changed:04/15/2019 4:00 PM Johanna Dombo Work Order#153149 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/15/2019 4:00 PM Johanna Dombo Workorder#153149 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda Si Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO My name is Lisa Deluccio-Kavalesky This is a very personal issue to myself and my family. My step daughter is 17 and a junior at Marina H.S. and we live fairly close to this proposed location. My step daughter's mother is homeless in Santa Ana right now and she has been in these "90 day" facilities for almost 3 years. Before we even knew of the possibility of a shelter near us, she was talking about how she might have a place close to Marina H.S. We thought it was an apartment, but we never imagined it being a shelter and we all started worrying. Now hearing a new shelter may still be close to Marina H.S. we are worrying again. Our family is very concerned that her mom will show up at her school daily unannounced if she were transferred to this location. My step daughter has struggled while living with her in the past and is now doing very well in school but is very stressed out by this. We also worry about her mother's choice in friends she has made while in the shelters. We thought we were in the clear after the last location was rejected due to so many citizens making it clear it was too close to the high school. This new location is only a few blocks away from the previous proposed location. We had a chance to drive by the new building on Friday, it is surrounded by and mixed in with other active businesses and wonder how would a fence be possible? Plus, it is only a 9-minute walk or 2-minute drive from Marina, and we continue to be worried. We go to Santa Ana monthly to visit her mom and we see the many homeless in the streets, parks and camped out in the fronts and doorways of the local businesses. We see many consuming alcohol and begging for money and we hear of the drug addicts and mentally ill in and around the city and there seems like nothing can be done about it unless they have committed a crime. We don't want that so close to our schools, homes, businesses and community. This location being proposed so close to Marina HS, Circle View Elementary, Village View Elementary, Grace Lutheran, Schroeder Elementary, Stacy Middle School or Clegg Elementary is not a good solution. It should not be located anywhere close to these schools or any of the many children's facilities (too many to list)within short walking distance to it. I hope my message and concerns are being heard. Thank you. : 0 a I. ^* ,III • `a r Go Lyle Moo., ,. ,._ _, , , , W tYFawMr ' 1 8 nth"wAe* r1La arve. dine.wwa , 6 eaia rr < * .4. , A ' t - ..f. ; . , i ..... S4' ... ICV i ,'. 44'« t k - i-.C. i 1> i 4 t KN-- , - 14111 4 II- '' ' ,rriorrrimmorroo 4 . it at S 0 0, •,..-:. . ' (:), .t t*"., •I't t ====.•,, C t 1 am. .4,.. 4 ' •-• - -. • • 2 - # X -z, * 12, t i* X -41X g , er. .... . r't It I f## . #10-04 • 4 ' k 0' Clik , kf v , • A . , ..... .., i .. ...;e V, ,0 f' •. .. , ,. - . -• .. • ,. =, .. , .. „ , ., . ,.i f t ' ' • .W- ..,, ,.. i'ff' t''''' ''' ',:`I'''''L'-'''",:,-.',,,,,,-g-414, ,-,?Airr,..ti','''-'-, :-','",.';...,`.,',•':i',1., "'' A ,## •ttitlq##,V:1-#'‘,4itt.".t.t###:#'######•="tt #.,..-#t=ti A.. -,r •• I. . . _-#:# ,'•',..i'''',°-',.'''A'`,:'It.',- ::.1.',;*.t......t.,"4,'',A.7 ,;:,'.4",1!"--f'4i!riiicf-t..4,r-r.4,--!!'' ' .:‘,,, , , , ,, . ,,,, ,- 4 , ' ,•• ;-. ' Switzer, Donna From: Dombo, Johanna Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 2:18 PM To: Agenda Comment Cc: Fikes, Cathy; CITY COUNCIL Subject: FW: Opposition to proposed homeless shelter AGENDA COMMENT From: Kathy Carrick<carrick92647@hotmail.com> Sent: Monday, April 15, 2019 2:04 PM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Opposition to proposed homeless shelter Dear City Council Members: Here are a few of my objections to the current homeless shelter proposal in HB: 1) It is common knowledge that homeless arrive in HB from all across the country to take advantage of our mild weather and generous handouts. Why are you willing to allow this to continue to happen? We should not be helping and enabling more and more homeless unless we are going to address the way these people get here in the first place. 2) It is also common knowledge that the majority of homeless are either drug addicts or mentally ill. Why are you planning to provide housing for these individuals without addressing these issues? A plan needs to be in place to stop the flow of drugs to these people and treat the mentally ill. If there is such a plan, please make it public. Residents want to know the plan. 3) You are arbitrarily choosing a group of your own constituents to bear the burden for everyone in the community. What are you going to do for folks if their property values take a hit for being next to a homeless shelter? Have you considered that some people have lived in these neighborhoods for 30+ years counting on the equity in their homes to finance their retirements? And you say, "too bad, we rolled the dice and your neighborhood is the lucky winner"? These are only three reasons. There are many others. I hope you will take this item off the table until further research can be done. I would hope that you would look into ways that the county can come together to provide these shelters. After all, don't they have a full time homeless "czar"? What is that person doing? Why can't we work with other cities? Why does each city have to "do their own thing"? Isn't that rather inefficient? Kinda like reinventing the wheel over and over again? Where is the money going to come from for this? It's going to cost several MILLION dollars just to get it off the ground. That doesn't even consider ongoing expenses. There are just too many issues here. The list goes on and on. Bottom line is, this is a terrible idea all the way around and the residents and tax payers of HB want a better thought out plan. Thank you. Kathy Carrick 2 Huntington Beach Homeless Shelter Stipulations Live Exterior Web-Cam Network: The city will install and maintain an elaborate open to the public live web-cam system out front of any homeless shelter in Huntington Beach. We the citizens have been assured that homeless individuals will not be able to walk-in and walk- out of any Huntington Beach Homeless Shelter. We the citizens would like to make sure you are living up to your word. Trust but verify.There is no expectation of privacy on a public street so live web-cams do not violate anyone's right to privacy. Short Term Contract for Shelter Operator: Homeless Contractor will be granted a short term renewable contract with a term of no more than 12 months for any one term. Preferably six month renewable.To avoid from the city getting locked into a long term contract with a contractor who is violating the terms and expectations we the citizens have set forth the city will not enter into a long term contact with any shelter operator. Shelter operator staff ratio will be the highest in the county. Shelter operator will be required to publish their staff ratios at not only this facility but all other facilities they manage or run by them.The city of Huntington Beach will maintain current and accurate statistics of staff ratios at all comparable homeless shelters throughout Orange County.The Huntington Beach homeless shelter operator will be required to maintain at all times a staff ratio that is XXXX%higher than the current highest shelter in Orange County. Crime Statistics: City of Huntington Beach will make public current homeless and crime statistics for the area surrounding the Huntington Beach homeless shelter. IE: North Huntington Beach. Statistics will be tracked and publicized twice per year. If it is determined a rise in crime is directly attributed to the existence of a homeless shelter an alternative location not in the same general area will be sought within one year.The current location will be closed/relocated within one year. Citizen Accountability Committee: The city of Huntington Beach will establish a Citizens Accountability Committee made up of residents from the city who either: Own a Home or Business, Rent a Home, Rent an Apartment. No homeless person shall be permitted to be on this committee. Each city council member will be able to appoint two committee members one of which must be located in North Huntington Beach.The Citizen Accountability Committee will have the right and obligation to inspect the homeless shelter at any time.The Committee will meet no less that once per month. City officials will be required to provide all information deemed necessary by the committee to the committee as to the operation of the shelter. If the Committee finds the shelter operator is in violation of the terms of their contract with the City of Huntington Beach the Committee will have the right to force a vote of the city council to cancel the shelter operator's contract immediately. Prepared By:Jim Knapp of Huntington Beach A Generic Approach to Solving Problems Ralph Bauer April 14, 2019 A Problems that arise in society can be address by using an approach which has been found to work well. Problem Solving 1. Define the problem 2. Identify constraints and hurdles 3. Avail oneself of all information from all sources including comments by experts 4. Address each constraint or hurdle by identifying resources and developing a strategy 5. Apply the strategy, determine outcome and modify strategy as necessary to attain the desired outcome 6. 'Recognize reality and put emotionalism and prejudice aside Identifying constraints and hurdles of homelessness might look as shown below. Community leadership should develop the strategies. 1. Economic issues of the person 2. Lack of Housing 3. Mental illness 4. Substance abuse 5. Behavior modification 6. Short term needs 7. Patience and persistence 8. Recognition that the individual has constitutional rights The goal is to solve the problem completely not to sustain it through temporary fixes. Tempting solutions like driving the homeless out of town, arresting them, or withdrawing resources have all been tried and have failed. Trying them again is a waste of time. Work Order: #152594 Opened:2//2019 Closed: This issue is a ;, e °i By : Vannia Peirce Agenda & Public Hearing Comments Email vanniaap@gmail.com Phone . SUB TYPE Device . City Council Meeting STREET ADDRESS Media Submitted 1 Images COMMENTS&ADDITIONAL NOTES Re:Navigation Center/Homeless Shelter-15311 Pipeline Ln.HB The new proposed location is not viable for a Homeless Shelter and am completely against it.There are too many children and families around this area.Family gathering places,Elementary Schools 1 mile away and Marina HS less than a mile away,SCATS Gymnastics,Get Air Trampolines,Bounce U,The Rinks,Grace Lutheran School.Why are you guys obsessing over this area oh HB?Why not right next to the police station and city hall,that is a more appropriate place.City Council PLEASE DO the right thing.For all people of Huntington Beach.Post a map showing all city owned property that could be used for this site.Be open,honest,fair and balanced.Post a map on the city's website,social media pages.DO NOT WASTE OUR TAX DOLLARS leasing or buying new property to be used for this site.Be open,honest,fair and balanced for all people of Huntington Beach DO THE RIGHT THING. Issue Type/Subtype Changed:04/26/2019 3:12 PM Johanna Dombo Workorder#152594 Issue type changed from City Council to Agenda&Public Hearing Comments and subtype City Council Meeting. Share with Citizen:NO Status Changed:04/15/2019 8:10 AM Johanna Dombo Work Order#152594 status has changed from new to assigned. Share with Citizen:NO