Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutNo Action - Withdrawn - Adopt Resolution No. 2019-71 Establi IT&WI WITS AI City of Huntington Beach 1,vo 4o/o/AJ File #: 19-970 MEETING DATE: 10/7/2019 REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION SUBMITTED TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members SUBMITTED BY: Oliver Chi, City Manager PREPARED BY: Tom Herbel, PE, Acting Director of Public Works Subject: Adopt Resolution No. 2019-71 establishing Permit Parking District "Z" affecting residents along the Heil Avenue frontage road between Goldenwest Street and Gothard Street Statement of Issue: Residents along the Heil Avenue frontage road between Goldenwest Street and Gothard Street have petitioned the City to establish a residential permit parking district, Permit Parking District "Z" in Huntington Beach. Financial Impact: The provisions of Huntington Beach Municipal Code Chapter 10.42 requires that the residents choosing to participate in a residential permit parking district pay a proportionate share of the cost to establish or amend the district making the district cost neutral to the City. Typical costs include, but are not limited to, installation of signs, curb markings, which are initially funded in the General Fund Signs and Marking business unit 10085302, and staff time to issue permits, which are funded in the General Fund Transportation Management business unit 10085301. The total cost for this parking district is estimated at $1,121 or $59 per address. Recommended Action: Adopt Resolution No. 2019-71, "A Resolution of the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach Establishing Permit Parking District "Z" Within the City of Huntington Beach." Alternative Action(s): Deny the recommended action. Analysis: Residents along the Heil Avenue frontage road between Goldenwest Street and Gothard Street submitted a petition requesting a permit parking district be created due to commuter vehicle parking impacts and related issues. The frontage road is located on the north side of Heil Avenue between Goldenwest Street and Gothard Street and is shown in Attachment 1. Including the commuter vehicle parking impacts, residents expressed their concerns with associated issues of late night City of Huntington Beach Page 1 of 2 Printed on 10/2/2019 Powerelk5 Le-Ista•-' File #: 19-970 MEETING DATE: 10/7/2019 noise, littering, parking too close to driveways, and finding curbside areas to place trash bins on the street on collection day. The requested permit parking restrictions are 6 p.m. to 6 a.m. every day, including holidays Following procedures in Municipal Code Chapter 10.42, Permit Parking Districts, staff validated the petition, determined the concerns of the residents merit further consideration, and considered the proposed area to be reasonable. Staff prepared and mailed letters to the affected properties explaining the permit parking district requirements, boundaries, and included ballots for voting on the permit parking district proposal. Per code a minimum of 75% of the property units shall vote in favor of the parking district to move the request for further consideration. The voting results showed 79% of the properties along the Heil Avenue frontage road in support of permit parking. As required by code, staff investigated the conditions along the Heil Avenue frontage road to examine the parking conditions and related concerns. Field observations and discussions with the residents demonstrated that the street experiences recurring parking impacts from commuter vehicles, with the most significant impacts on the weekend. Although the noise and trash bin moving issues were not observed by staff, these concerns were mentioned by several of the residents as frequent commuter vehicle parking issues. Due to these conditions, staff believes findings can be made demonstrating that commuter vehicle parking unreasonably and regularly interferes with the use of available street parking for residents and their guests, and causes other related disturbances. These findings are consistent with requirements of the Municipal Code as a basis for establishing permit parking. The number of addresses that would comprise the permit parking district is 19 with permit parking established along both sides of the frontage road as shown in Attachment 2. Notices were sent to the affected properties and properties within 500 feet of the proposed district boundaries indicating the date and time of the City Council meeting Public Works Commission Action: None required. Environmental Status: The project is categorically exempt from CEQA. Strategic Plan Goal: Enhance and maintain infrastructure. Attachment(s): 1. Vicinity Map 2. Parking District Z Map 3. Staff Evaluation 4. Resolution No. 2019-71, "A Resolution of the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach Establishing Permit Parking District "Z" Within the City of Huntington Beach City of Huntington Beach Page 2 of 2 Printed on 10/2/2019 powered$§,LegistarrM Q� S 9 �G�'° PROPOSED �P B0LSA AVE. NCO PERMIT PARKING I DISTRICT Z 0� cni c/) Mc FADDEN AVE. Q U EDINGER z v Li-i cn AVE. J o o A z ¢ Q 0 Q > p �HEIL J Q Z o AVE. m o � cn m z0 v-: m 0 c w � J WARNER C/) AVE. Q SLATER Q AVE. U Lu ~o Lijm 405 ,0 � TALBERT w AVE. y� o PACIFIC �� ELLIS AVE. c� o GARFIELD _ AVE. Y \ cf) U) CO A (YORKTOWN AVE. ADAMS AVE. O,A D INDIANAPOLIS AVE. Y Q o OCEAN q�F J Of � ATLANTA Q oz = AVE. m _ CD cn U w m w Z HAMILTON AVE. m If yGjir BANNING A VE. CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH •J� VICINITY MAP ATTACHMENT PROPOSED PERMIT PARKING DISTRICT Z 1 87 r--Tl SUNLIGHT DR � z V / 1 ~ 7021 7031 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 `� '`� Q `r' cfl � L722.01 11 70017221 W z H E L AVE W 0 GOTHARD O 01 ST -� CD PROPOSED PERMIT PARKING ALONG HEIL AVENUE FRONTAGE ROAD N NO SCALE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH •J� ATTACHMENT PROPOSED PERMIT PARKING DISTRICT Z 2 88 Permit Parking District Request - Heil Avenue Frontage Road between Goldenwest Street and Gothard Street Residents on Heil Avenue frontage road have petitioned the City to establish permit parking due to parking impacts and associated issues from commuter vehicle parking. The request is located on the north side of Heil Avenue along the Heil Avenue frontage road between Goldenwest Street and Gothard Street. A vicinity map of the area is presented in the diagram below. �<� S PERMIT PARKING LOCATION REQUEST a5F SOLSA AVE. CO Cn L' a I yr cn cn Mc SADDEN ;AVE. U 3 EDINGER AVE. v~ p�o a c HEIL * AVE. m z � o o a z m q o WARNER a � Lo AVE. Ln SLATER Li = AVE. o W 405 o m TALBERT AVE. PACIFIC �cl';v i� ELLIS AVE. �"I o 7 GARFIELD AVE. C � L � COCA YORKTOWN AVE. ST A.DAMS AVE. � INDIANAPOLIS o a AVE. = p 0CFAN q�F z Q Ln D ATLANTA¢ AVE. m J U W N m Z HAMILTON AVE. I A/ y BANNING AVE. VICINITY MAP 1 Page 89 I LT�j SUNUGHT DR Ln L7 1)2 1 7 01.3 F, 7)L�--, Li---- ;, L201&11 7001 7221 LLJ HEIL AVE GOTHARD ST REQUESTED PERMIT PARKING ALONG HEIL AVENUE FRONTAGE ROAD NO SCALI Figure 1. Petitioned Permit Parking District Area Figure 1 shows the petitioned permit parking area along the Heil Avenue frontage road. The requested parking restrictions are 6 p.m. to O a.m. every day including holidays. Including the commuter vehicle parking impacts, residents expressed their concerns with associated issues of late night noise, littering, parking too close to driveways, and finding areas for placing trash bins on the street on the collection day as the reasons for initiating the process to establish permit parking on their street. As required by Municipal Code Chapter 10.42, staff reviewed the request, determined the petition and concerns of the residents were valid, and considered the proposed area to be reasonable. Staff prepared and mailed letters to the affected properties explaining the permit parking district requirements, boundaries, and included ballots for voting on the permit parking district. 2 | Pa ge 90 Per Municipal Code 10.42 a minimum of 75% of the property units (1 vote per unit) shall be in favor of establishing permit parking to move the request for further consideration. Of the 19 affected properties, 18 ballots were returned with 15 votes in favor of permit parking (83%) and three votes not supporting permit parking. The 75% minimum support requirement was satisfied to continue the evaluation. Table 1 summarizes the voting results of the Heil Avenue frontage road permit parking district request. PERMIT PARKING DISTRICT REQUEST VOTING RESULTS NUMBER PERCENT BALLOTS, TOTAL 19 - BALLOTS RETURNED 18 95% BALLOTS NOT RETURNED 1 5% YES VOTES 15 79% NO VOTES 3 16% Table 1. Voting Summary of Permit Parking District Request As required by code staff investigated the parking conditions and related issues on the proposed permit parking street. The code requires that facts exist that reasonably establish that unrestricted parking creates a situation in which the subject streets cannot be used for regular parking by residents or their guests, or creates a situation that commuter vehicles or their occupants produce significant sources of health, safety, or welfare concerns to continue the process for further consideration. Below summarizes the field surveys of the parking conditions in the requested permit parking area. Field Survey, Tuesday, 6:30 pm Street No. Parked Parking Percent Vehicles Capacity Occupancy Heil Avenue Frontage Road West Side 9 42 21% Heil Avenue Frontage Road East Side 7 21 33% 3 1 P a g e 91 Field Survey, Wednesday, 6:15 am Street No. Parked Parking Percent Vehicles Capacity Occupancy Heil Avenue Frontage Road West Side 21 42 50% Heil Avenue Frontage Road East Side 16 21 76% Field Survey, Sunday, 6:30 am Street No. Parked Parking Percent Vehicles Capacity Occupancy Heil Avenue Frontage Road West Side 31 42 74% Heil Avenue Frontage Road East Side 16 21 76% Field Survey, Thursday 6:15 am Street No. Parked Parking Percent Vehicles Capacity Occupancy Heil Avenue Frontage Road West Side 26 42 62% Heil Avenue Frontage Road East Side 14 21 67% Field Survey, Tuesday 9:30 pm Street No. Parked Parking Percent Vehicles Capacity Occupancy Heil Avenue Frontage Road West Side 27 42 64% Heil Avenue Frontage Road East Side 12 21 57% Field Survey, Monday 7:00 pm Street No. Parked Parking Percent Vehicles Capacity Occupancy Heil Avenue Frontage Road West Side 27 42 64% Heil Avenue Frontage Road East Side 11 21 52% 4 Page 92 Analysis: During the weekdays, parking impacts were observed between the evening to early morning hours. The most impacted field observation occurred on the weekend where a majority of the available on- street parking was occupied by commuter vehicles. These parking impacts could affect the availability of on-street parking for the residents and their guests. In addition to the parking impacts, the residents expressed concerns with trash left on the street and front yards, and late night noise attributed to the commuter vehicle parking. Although staff observations of the area did not witness occurrences of trash on the street or noise, these concerns were expressed by many of the residents as recurring commuter vehicle parking issues. Municipal Code 10.42 requires that specific conditions shall exist for a parking district request to move forward for consideration to the City Manager's office. These include: unrestricted parking creates a situation where on-street parking cannot be regularly used by residents and guests; or, unrestricted parking by commuter vehicles produces significant sources of health, safety, or welfare concerns. Based on the field evaluations and discussions with the residents, staff finds that the unrestricted parking creates a situation where the commuter vehicle parking regularly interferes with residents and their guests parking, and produces significant sources of welfare concerns. Staff recommends establishing permit parking along Heil Avenue frontage road between Goldenwest Street and Gothard Street as shown in Figure 1 affecting 19 addresses. 5 1 P a g e 93 RESOLUTION NO. 2019-71 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH ESTABLISHING PERMIT PARK DISTRICT"Z" WITHIN THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH WHEREAS, the City Council has adopted Ordinance No. 4051 allowi the establishment of parking districts in residential areas under certain conditions; and The citizens of the residential street frontage road along the north s' e of Heil Avenue between Goldenwest Street and Gothard Street have petitioned for establishment a permit parking district: The Director of Public Works reviewed the petition, sent a llot for further consideration to residents of the petitioned roadway, and cause an investigation w$ic reasonably established that: 1. A minimum of 75% of the Property Units along the ontage road on the north side of Heil Avenue between Goldenwest Street and Gothard S eet are in favor of establishing a Permit Parking District; and 2. Unrestricted parking creates a situation in whic the subject street cannot be used for parking by Residents or their guests because Commu r Vehicle parking unreasonably and regularly interferes with the use of the available stree parking; and 3. Unrestricted parking creates a situation ere Commuter Vehicles or their occupants produce significant sources of health, safety or elfare concerns. Therefore, the Director of Public Wor s has found the requirements of Ordinance 4051 to be reasonably fulfilled, and determined that the ermit Parking District will not affect other uses of on- street parking. NOW, THEREFORE, the City uncil of the City of Huntington Beach does hereby resolve as follows: Permit Parking District "Z" is hereby established to include the above mentioned roadway, everyday including holidays betw n 6:00 p.m. to 6:00 a.m. NO ACTION TAKEN 19-7987/212255 1 Resolution No. o 19-71 PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at a regular meeting thereof held on the day of , 201 c�/ i i Mayor REVIEWED AND APPROVED: APPROVEI'AS ORM: City Manager ity Attorney AM TIATED AND APPROVED: ire for of is Works 19-7987/212255 2 0 Aj CITY OF HUNTINGTON Interdepartmental Memo TO: Oliver Chi, City Manager FROM: rn Herbel, PE, Acting Director of Public Works fA DATE: October 7, 2019 SUBJECT: SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION: 19-970-Adopt Resolution No. 2019-71 Establishing Permit Parking District Z affecting Residents Along the Heil Frontage Road Between Goldenwest Street and Gothard Street The Public Works Department requests that Item 19 (19-970) be removed from the October 7, 2019 agenda. The review of comments received as a result of notification of the agenda item has revealed that a property owner in the proposed district has asked to have their vote changed from being in support to being opposed to the permit parking district. The change in voting has resulted in the proposed district not meeting the 75% property owner support level required by the Municipal Code. Staff will reevaluate the proposed district with residents and identify the appropriate next steps. c: Robin Estanislau, City Clerk Travis K. Hopkins, Acting Assistant City Manager SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Date: 192. Oi-• -2 6/2 Agenda Item No.: Sam, Darren From: Stachelski, Bob Sent: Monday, October 07, 2019 6:43 AM To: Sam, Darren Subject: FW: Permit parking Heil from Goldenwest to Gothard From: Mark Fowler<markcfowler@gmail.com> Sent:Saturday, October 05, 2019 7:14 AM To: Stachelski, Bob<bstachelski@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Permit parking Heil from Goldenwest to Gothard Mr. Stachelski, My name is Mark Fowler. My wife, son, and I live at 16382 Serenade Lane. I received your letter concerning the proposed establishment of a residential permit parking district on the Heil Avenue frontage road between Goldenwest Street and Gothard Street. I assume the residents of that area requested the district because of parking scarcity issues involving vehicles belonging to the residents of the apartments on the south side of Heil. I'm concerned that if the district does not include our entire tract,then those extra cars that used to park on the frontage road will, instead, be parking further inside our tract. That will decrease availability of parking spaces for our own vehicles and it will increase the number of non-tract-residents walking and driving into and out of the tract. It will increase the amount of automobile noise,too. Furthermore it will encourage car burglary in the tract due to the increase in the number of cars in the tract. Car burglary incidents have increased in this part of Huntington Beach in recent years. An increase in car burglary could lead to an increase in other types of property crimes and even worse. Thank you for taking the time to listen to my concerns. -- Mark Fowler SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Date:_ /D- J — � Agenda Item Pilo.•_ Sam, Darren From: Stachelski, Bob Sent: Monday, October 07, 2019 9:02 AM To: Sam, Darren Subject: FW: Permit parking Heil from Goldenwest to Gothard A follow-up e-mail from a resident. Bob From: Mark Fowler<markcfowler@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, October 07, 2019 8:57 AM To:Stachelski, Bob<bstachelski@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Re: Permit parking Heil from Goldenwest to Gothard Mr. Stachelski, I've listened to the neighbors of my tract who live on Heil and now I see why they need the permit parking district. I support the establishment of the proposed district. --Mark Fowler On Sat, Oct 5, 2019 at 7:14 AM Mark Fowler<markcfowler@gmail.com>wrote: Mr. Stachelski, My name is Mark Fowler. My wife, son,and I live at 16382 Serenade Lane. I received your letter concerning the proposed establishment of a residential permit parking district on the Heil Avenue frontage road between Goldenwest Street and Gothard Street. I assume the residents of that area requested the district because of parking scarcity issues involving vehicles belonging to the residents of the apartments on the south side of Heil. I'm concerned that if the district does not include our entire tract, then those extra cars that used to park on the frontage road will, instead, be parking further inside our tract. That will decrease availability of parking spaces for our own vehicles and it will increase the number of non-tract-residents walking and driving into and out of the tract. It will increase the amount of automobile noise,too. Furthermore it will encourage car burglary in the tract due to the increase in the number of cars in the tract. Car burglary incidents have increased in this part of Huntington Beach in recent years. An increase in car burglary could lead to an increase in other types of property crimes and even worse. Thank you for taking the time to listen to rrStWftEMENTAL COMMUNICATION --Mark FowlerMeelfin g Date: Agenda them No.' � �221-4 r Sam, Darren From: Stachelski, Bob Sent: Monday, October 07, 2019 6:44 AM To: Sam, Darren Subject: FW: Regarding Resolution 2019-71, permit parking Heil Frontage From: Rob Hamud <rahamud@gmail.com> Sent:Saturday,October 05, 2019 7:43 RM To:Stachelski, Bob<bstachelski@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Regarding Resolution 2019-71, permit parking Heil Frontage Dear Mr. Bob Stachelski, I'm writing to you on behalf of the residents across the street of the Heil fiotage. I am unable to attend the meeting and key points are being misrepresented. I respectfully park here regularly and see this street daily. First, I question the residents credibility. The residents are lying about trash and noise. There is no trash brought into the street by me or the very few others who park there and absolutely no noise(I've seen this street peacefully used for years now with no problems). Your report even notes "staff observation did not witness these occurrences." Honestly, these lies concern me as the residents will do anything to take over this area. For what? to put even more pressure on the already impacted less affluent townhomes? (I have helped out their own children who have been drunk and passed out in the middle of the street.) Second,there is always parking available there. Even in your own report the lot was NEVER full. These homes are two car garage homes with two car driveways. Please consider us, the neighbors of this frontage. Measure our "Percent Occupancy" it would be 100%,how is removing legal and available parking the recommended decision? 1 recommend drawing parking lines on our side of'the street (People often don't park properly leaving space) Final notes: In regards to Ordinance 4051 1. There is plenty of parking available for residents and your report shows this! They aren't even close to 100% occupancy. 2. There is no danger of health, safety, or welfare. This is totally fabricated. I've seen this frontage for years as a peaceful and calm area. Also, this request has already been denied by City Council before! It's laughable because taking this parking away from us adds unnecessary abundance to these homes. It's just a pure greed move from an already comfortable neighborhood. SUPPLEMENTAL Sincerely, COMMUNICATION Robert Hamud Ming Date: 3_ � i Agenda Item No.• C� «' Sam, Darren From: Stachelski, Bob Sent: Monday, October 07, 2019 10:52 AM To: Sam, Darren Subject: FW: Regarding Resolution 2019-71, permit parking Heil Frontage SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION From: Rob Hamud<rahamud@gmail.com> Sent: Monday,October 07, 2019 9:35 AM mewft Data: To:Stachelski, Bob<bstachelski@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Re: Regarding Resolution 2019-71, permit parking Heil Frontage / Agenda ream No.: l G!l lei—Gj :TU Dear Mr. Stachelski, I realized what bothered me most about this permit request. It's sad... it's sad that our own neighbors don't want us to exist in their world. Out of sight, out of mind. 15 homes voted 'yes'to make 63 parking spots require permits... Let me repeat that, FIFTEEN two car garage,two car driveway homes voted yes to remove 63 parking spots from the neighborhood. It's.funny how people want freedom and less intervention until they want something for themselves. The city proved it's clean, quiet and safe.., so what, they want it to be totally empty? How far do these homes property lines even go? I won't live in that area for long, but seeing how open that street is and reading the request is pathetic. It might read like I'm angry,but I just see the misrepresentation of facts. At least now you know another side of this story. Best regards, Robert On Sat, Oct 5, 2019 at 7:42 PM Rob Hamud<rahamudggmail.eom>wrote: Dear Mr. Bob Stachelski, I'm writing to you on behalf of the residents across the street of the Heil frotage. I am unable to attend the meeting and key points are being misrepresented. I respectfully park here regularly and see this street daily. First, I question the residents credibility. The residents are lying about trash and noise. There is no trash brought into the street by me or the very few others who park there and absolutely no noise(I've seen this i street peacefully used for years now with no problems). Your report even notes "staff observation did not witness these occurrences." Honestly, these lies concern me as the residents will do anything to take over this area. F'or what?to put even more pressure on the already impacted less affluent townhomes? (I have helped out their own children who have been drunk and passed out in the middle of the street.) Second, there is always parking available there. Even in your own report the lot was NEVER full. These homes are two car garage homes with two car driveways. Please consider us,the neighbors of this frontage. Measure our "Percent Occupancy" it would be 100%,how is removing legal and available parking the recommended decision? I recommend drawing parking lines on our side of the street(People often don't park properly leaving space) Final notes: In regards to Ordinance 4051 1. There is plenty of parking available for residents and your report shows this! They aren't even close to 100% occupancy. 2. There is no danger of health, safety,or welfare. This is totally fabricated. I've seen this frontage for years as a peaceful and calm area. Also, this request has already been denied by City Council before! It's laughable because taking this parking away from us adds unnecessary abundance to these homes. It's just a pure greed move from an already comfortable neighborhood. Sincerely, Robert Hamud 2 Sam, Darren From: Stachelski, Bob Sent: Monday, October 07, 2019 6:45 AM To: Sam, Darren Subject: FW: Permit Parking on Heil Ave Frontage Road between GW&Gothard From: Iheimkes@verizon.net<Iheimkes@verizon.net> Sent:Sunday, October 06, 2019 2:59 PM To:Stachelski, Bob<bstachelski@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Permit Parking on Heil Ave Frontage Road between GW&Gothard Dear Mr. Stachelski. I am one of those home owners that live on the Subject Sreet. I am on the Frontage Road, heading East from Sabot. Below are my comments in support of Permit Parking: When stopping at the Stop sign (heading West)on the frontage road meeting Sabot and waiting to turn left(or right)onto Sabot, I have to watch if any cars are heading West down Heil and going to turn right on Sabot. With the 3 ft. high cinder block wall, you can't see their signal light if they are turning right. What I do is look for the top of any car coming South and wait. Now, with all the parked cars along the frontage road (all the way up to the STOP sign), I cannot even see the tops of cars. So what do I do now? I have to drive out very slowly to see if a car is coming and going to turn right towards me. Keep in mind that I also have to watch for cars coming from two other directions. So it is a dangerous situation for everyone on the North end of the frontage road. Not to mention the"take out"trash left on the curb, radios playing loud on Fri. & Sat. night when coming home from the bars at 1:00am plus losing street parking for relatives and friends visiting. (I park both my cars in the garage.)The people parking here on the frontage road,jaywalk across Heil which is illegal. There is parking on Sabot with no homes facing it and they could cross at the intersection. I have lived here for 45 years and the problem started when rents went sky-high and 3 or 4 renters share one apartment at the four-plex apartments across Heil, We need Permit Parking. Sincerely, Leon Heimkes 7191 Heil Ave SUPPLEMENTAL NTAL COMMUNICATION Date:_/D - 2- c;JOl Agenda Item W.:_ Sam, Darren From: Stachelski, Bob Sent: Monday, October 07, 2019 6:43 AM To: Sam, Darren Subject: FW: Proposed Establishment of Residential Permit Parking District on Heil Ave Frontage Road between Goldenwest Street and Gothard Street From: esthelahrdz<esthelahrdz@gmail.com> Sent:Saturday, October 05, 2019 10:41 AM To:Stachelski, Bob<bstachelski@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Proposed Establishment of Residential Permit Parking District on Heil Ave Frontage Road between Goldenwest Street and Gothard Street Mr. Stachelski, Hello and good morning. I would like to know if the above subject will be rescheduled and if so,when? Thank you, Esthela Hernandez, H.B, Resident, 22 yrs 16541 Sabot Ln.,#4 Huntington Bch, CA. 92646 Sent from my Sprint Samsung Galaxy Note9. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION MWft Data: lO - 4--a?UI GI Agenda Item No., Sam, Darren From: Stachelski, Bob Sent: Monday, October 07, 2019 6:44 AM To: Sam, Darren Subject: FW: Comments on Proposed Parking Permit Zone on Heil Avenue From: Kevin Karuntzos<kevinkar@hotmall.com> Sent:Saturday, October 05, 2019 5:S1 PM To: Stachelski, Bob<bstachelski@surfclty-hb.org> Subject: Comments on Proposed Parking Permit Zone on Heil Avenue Mr. Stachelski, I live on Sunlight Drive in the subdivision behind the noted permit location and I am in favor of enacting parking permits as described in the proposal. I do however have a concern that the proposal does not seem to address and that is what happens to the commuter cars that are going to be displaced by the permits? When I leave for work in the morning, I have seen an increase in cars parked on Sabot Lane and have noticed this increase over the last year. This is likely related to the increase of commuter cars parked on the Heil frontage road resulting in the request to enact permits. So when commuter cars are displaced by the permits and Sabot Lane and Sunlight Drive are not included in the permit zone, won't those cars simply move to Sabot and Sunlight resulting in the same issue residents on Heil face? By placing permits only on Heil and not registering the entire neighborhood as a permit zone I feel like the City is simply pushing the problem to the other residents of the neighborhood. One of the reasons my wife and I moved here in 2002 was because Sunlight Drive did NOT have a lot of residents parking on the street and it looked clean and neat because of that(a good number of houses have 3-car garages which really helps.) If commuter cars are simply going to move from Heil to Sabot and Sunlight,that will definitely impact our quality of life on Sunlight Drive. Please consider adding the entire neighborhood to the permit zone so that the problem is not simply pushed inside to the other residents or at least also include Sabot and Sunlight in the proposal. Thank you for considering my input. Sincerely, SUPPLEMENTAL ENTAL Kevin Karuntzos COMMUNICATION 7052 Sunlight Drive Huntington Beach, CA 92647 Meetlng Date: > d kevinkar@hotmail.com G Agenda Item No.,. I Sam, Darren From: Stachelski, Bob Sent: Monday, October 07, 2019 10:56 AM To: Sam, Darren Subject: FW: Protest Statement against Heil residential permit parking SUPPLEMENTAL From: MLT W<mltnrn@hotmaii.com> COMMUNICATION Sent: Monday,October 07,2019 10:52 AM Meeting Date: /0_ To:Stachelski, Bob<bstachelski@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Protest Statement against Heil residential permit parking p, Dear Mr. Stachelski, Agenda Item No.: I am writing in protest of the proposed residential permit parking on the frontage road between Goldenwest Street and Gothard Street. I am a homeowner on Heil Street and have lived there for over 12 years. Unfortunately, I work full time and due to traffic commute, am unable to attend the 6:00 PM City Council meeting. I find the proposed residential permit to be restrictive and punitive to homeowners/occupants who have visiting family/friends and need/arrange home services (i.e.,repairs, lawn service, medical care/deliveries). The hours of 6:00 PM to 6:00 AM including the holidays is very limited and does not accommodate working people's schedule especially during the summer hours where the day light hours are longer. By implementing this restrictive residential permit, it negatively affects the ability of working homeowners to implement home repairs/services, have a social life, and in some cases,medical care (i.e.,home health or in-home support services, a sitter). Out of town family/friends cannot drop in and stay late both during regular weekdays/weekends but also during the holidays,a time in which people need their family/friends nearby. Depression and suicide is higher during the holiday season(feelings of isolation,feeling sad)which is more of a reason for family and friends to be able to visit and stay after 6:00 PM or overnight. The residential permit does not allow for last minute babysitters or in-home support services for medical and elderly care. The residential permit requirement does not accommodate last minute requests and emergency situations/care (i.e., plumbing repair, cable). Obtaining a permit during emergencies is not always a priority and on people's mind and to penalize them with a ticket during a stressful time is unfair and can be avoided. Even the act of obtaining the car registrations/permits as a homeowner on Heil would be an additional inconvenience as it would require me to take time from work and pay an additional expense. I understand the concerns of my neighbors having people from the apartment complex park in the residential area but implementing the restrictive permit is not the answer. It is so much more punitive and a hindrance than a solution. Let us be kind and understanding of working home owners who have family and friends who can visit only after 6:00 PM, who make unscheduled/unannounced visits after their work day or drive from far away and come late at night/stay overnight,who can only visit during the holidays and want to stay overnight because it's the holidays and want to spend time with loved ones. This residential permit is not a gift but rather a punishment. 1 Thank you for your kind consideration. Respectfully, M. Nguyen z Sam, Darren From: Stachelski, Bob Sent: Monday, October 07, 2019 6:45 AM To: Sam, Darren Subject: FW: NO Residential permit parking on heil Ave From:Sabrina Schreiber<sschreiberhb@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday,October 06, 2019 7:33 PM To:Stachelski, Bob<bstachelski@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: NO Residential permit parking on heii Ave Good Morning, First of all, the notice was very short it almost appeared was done on purpose!!! The second matter is people park in front of my house all the time Then we need to restrict everyone from parking in front or across from my house too. The is public parking area and citizens have the right to park temporarily anywhere!! we are very much against this proposal!! Thank you, S Schreiber SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meelft Dom• Agenda Kam No: �� l GI�Iv Sam, Darren From: Stachelski, Bob Sent: Monday, October 07, 2019 6:43 AM To: Sam, Darren Subject: FW: Parking permit on Heil From:tuyen tran <timvnus@hotmail.com> Sent: Friday,October 04,2019 8:56 PM To:Stachelski, Bob<bstachelski@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Parking permit on Heil Hello Bob, My name is Tuyen Tran, owner of the house 7201 Heil Ave. Why is it that I have to have a permit just to park in front of my own house?This neighborhood is not run by HOA. It is uncalled for that you want to limit my rights as a citizen. Taxes in California are high already. I pay everything I need to pay so having to pay any extra to park in front of my own house is unreasonable. I have big family. They come to visit me all the time. I feel that it is very unreasonable that the parking permit be required just to visit us for dinner? We don't have any problem with parking in front of our house. I also find it very odd the person requesting the parking permit does not even live in the area. Today is Oct 4 2019. 1 just received your letter sent out on Oct 12019, and you ask us to be there on Monday? Mail is normally 5 to 10 business day. I'm so tired with this unnecessary parking permit. Later on, our house value will also drop due to this permit. Will city of Huntington Beach compensate for that value? 8:55PM Oct 4 2019 Regards, Tuyen Tran (714)-234-0416 SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meang Date: /0- 1 A-)OM Agenda Rom No.- Sam, Darren From: Stachelski, Bob Sent: Monday, October 07, 2019 6:43 AM To: Sam, Darren Subject: FW: Proposed Establishment of Residential Permit Parking District-Heil Avenue Frontage between Goldenwest and Gothard From: Donna & Ron<rvanschijndel@verizon.net> Sent: Friday, October 04, 2019 6:27 PM To:Stachelski, Bob<bstachelslci@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Proposed Establishment of Residential Permit Parking District- Heil Avenue Frontage between Goldenwest and Gothard Hello Mr. Stachelski, I am writing in response to your letter, dated 10/1/19, addresses to the residents that would be impacted by the proposed residential parking permit district. My husband and I have lived in the impacted neighborhood since 1997. We have seen the problems of overflow parking from the apartments located on the south side of Heil Ave between Goldenwest and Gothard on our neighbors and neighborhood. The residents on Heil feel the brunt of the overflow parkers on a regular basis. However, once the Heil Street parking is full the parkers come into the track to park; first along Sabot,then to the north side of Sunlight between Magellan and Wishingwell as well as down Serenade. In establishing this parking district I ask that you and the City Council consider expanding the parking district to include all impacted streets within our tract and not just Heil Ave. Thank you, Donna Vanschijndel 16422 Magellan Lane H13, CA 92647 714-841-7712 Sent from,COL Mobile mail SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Medng Date: Agenda Item No.;