HomeMy WebLinkAbout2020-04-20Minutes
City Council/Public Financing Authority
City of Huntington Beach
Monday ,Ap ri l20, 2020
5:00 PM -Council Chambers
6:00 PM -Council Chambers
Civic Center, 2000 Main Street
Huntington Beach , California 92648
A video recording of the 6:00 PM portion of this meeting
is on file in the Office of the City Clerk, and archived at
www.surfcity-hb.org/government/agendas/
5:00 PM -COUNCIL CHAMBERS
CALLED TO ORDER -5:02 PM
ROLL CALL
Present: Posey, Delgleize (remote), Hardy, Semeta , Peterson, Carr (remote), and Brenden (remote )
Absent: None
ANNOUNCEMENT OF SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATIONS PERTAINING TO CLOSED SESSION
(Received After Agenda Distri but ion) -None
PUBLIC COMMENTS PERTAINING TO CLOSED SESSION ITEM(S)-None
Members of the public can submit one c ommunication per person of 300 words or less at
https:l/huntingtonbeachca.gov/HBPublicCommentsl. Comments re ceived before 4:00 PM th e day of
the meeting will be read aloud during the meeting.
RECESSED TO CLOSED SESSION -5:04 PM
A motion was made by Posey , second Brenden , to recess to Closed Sess ion for Item 1. The mot ion
carried by consensus of Council.
CLOSED SESSION
1. 20-1585 Pursuant to Government Code §54956.9(d)(2), the City Council recessed into
Closed Session to confer with the City Attorney regarding potential litigation.
Number of cases, one (1 ).
6:00 PM -COUNCIL CHAMBERS
RECONVENED CITY COUNCIL/PUBLIC FINANCING AUTHORITY MEETING -6 :00 PM
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 2 of 30
ROLL CALL
Present:
Absent:
Posey, Delgleize (remote), Hardy, Semeta, Peterson, Carr (remote), and Brenden (remote)
None
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE -Led by Councilmember Peterson
2. INVOCATION -Led by Councilmember Peterson
In permitting a nonsectarian invocation, the City does not intend to proselytize or advance any faith or
belief. Neither the City nor the City Council endorses any particular religious belief or form of
invocation.
CLOSED SESSION REPORT BY CITY ATTORNEY-None
ANNOUNCEMENT OF SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATIONS (Received After Agenda Distribution)
Pursuant to the Brown "Open Meetings" Act, City Clerk Robin Estanislau announced supplemental
communications that were received by her office following distribution of the Council Agenda packet:
City Manager's Report
Item #4 (20-1584) Update of the City COVI D-19 Response Plan and Actions for Review and Discussion
Twenty-one (21) communications received from:
Brian Faust Dawnn Taylor
Steven Nakase Anonymous (3)
Wendy Fochihara Melissa Zaiden
Damian Giatti Christopher Webb
Jen Garcia James Rea
Administrative Items
Sara Walker
Bobby F.
Perry & Cindy Dickey
Holly Conway
Barbara Nieto
Item #6 (20-1577) Request for Approval to Establish Payment Deferral Programs
One (1) communication received from:
Kelly Miller of Visit Huntington Beach
Item #7 (20-1578) Emergency Facility Use Agreement
Eight (8) communications received from:
Gigi Jackson Michelle Kerns
Jaclyn Sire Donald Pageler
MOU Items
Jean Folkestad
Annie Benington
#8 (20-1569) Resolution approving Police Officers' Association (POA) MOU
Rosa B
Jan Owen (2)
Jennifer Silkenson
Gina Clayton-Tarvin
Annette Berman .
#9 (20-1570) Resolution approving Management Employees' Organization (MEA) MOU
#10 (20-1571) Resolution approving Huntington Beach Municipal Teamsters (HBMT) MOU
Ninety-four (94) communications received from:
Chris Van Dellen Craig Frampton
Jen Bledsoe Linda Polkinghorne
Shawn Hedberg Patricia Pitts
Donna Dillon
Dee Wood
P.J. Garcia
Richard Thiel
Gino Bruno
Maria Spain
Ann Tarkington
Bruce Wareh
Jim & Lori Moseley
Regan Copeland
Terrry Ferguson
Cary Parker
Bill Saksa
Chris Perez
Eileen Harris
Brent N ichols
Kori Haug
Theodore & Rosalyn
Mahr
Margaret & Roy Arnold
Shirley Knopf
Mary Amendola
Gina Curry
Yvonne Mauro
Geri Di xon
Rob Pool
Bill Larkin
Larry Waterhouse
Taylor Haug
Sean & Kate Bonnevie
Lynn Schaertl
Barbara Shepard
Blake Rose
Sandy Thigpen
Cari Swan (2)
Phillip Bermis
Casey McKeon
Eric Barnes
Pat Quintana
Debra Keefer
Charles Daniher
Kari Fletcher
Robert F. Trout
Isabelle Karsh
Novak Business
Solutions
Peta-Gaye Hoskinson
Vanessa Martinez
Betty Englert
Taylor Haug
Item #10 (20-1571) MOU with HB Municipal Teamsters
Jaren Horn
Vicky
Mark Wexle r
C . Loftis (3 )
Clifford Enholm
Austin Edsell
Lynda Muir
James Seiler
Sally Neiser
Nancy Buchoz
Mrdi2003
Larry McNeely
William Butts
Russ Neal
Glenn Selvin
Greg Dillon
Sylvia Calhoun
Anna Plewa
Ray Raines
Gary Liggett
Margaret Bem is
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 3 of 30
M ichell e and Terry
Schomburg
Ed & Betty Murphy
Les & Sharon Messick
Stephanie Green
Linda Mccown
C . Smanny Dingus (2)
G ino Bruno
Paula & Michael
Hessley
Rita Barry
Taylor Jennings
Jerry Barry
Eugene Haberl
Sheila Gee
Steven Ferrell
Frank Householder &
Signe Howes
Ray Scrofield
Eric Dineen
Brian Burley
John & Roberts Ames
Memo and replacement Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) submitted by Assistant City Manager
Travis Hopkins updating the change in association name from Municipal Employees' Association (MEA)
to Huntington Beach Municipal Teamsters (HBMT) and signatures o~ta i ned on page 25.
Item #11 (20-1583) Proposed formation of an Economic Recovery Ta sk F orce
Communication from Carol Hansen, Superintendent of Ocean View School District
Item #6 (20-1577) Request to establish Payment Deferral Programs AFTER 2:00 PM DEADLINE -
communication received from John Gilbert
PUBLIC COMMENTS (all agenda and non-agenda items): Members of the public wishi ng to submit
comments on agenda or non-agenda items that will be read live during the Public Comments portion of
the meeting can submit one communication per person of 300 words or less at:
https://huntingtonbeachca .gov/HBPublicComments/. Public Comments must be received no later than
4:00 PM the day of the meeting .
The number [hh:mm :ss] following the speakers' comments indicates their approx imate starting time in
the archived video located at http://www.surfcity-hb .org!governmentlagendas.
City Clerk Robin Estanislau and Tania Moore, Deputy City Clerk, read aloud public comments received
as of 4 :00 PM:
Non-Agendized Items -2 Communications
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 4 of 30
A letter from the Greater Huntington Beach Interfaith Council communicated gratitude for the
opportunity to execute strategic humanitarian tasks to deliver needed services during the current crisis ,
and offered to do anything else that may be needed . (00 :08:14)
Wiley S. Drake communicated a statement of blessing . (00 :08 :56)
City Manager's Report -8 Communications
Item #4 (20-1584) COVID-19 Update
Tony Bisson , thanked the City for keeping sports courts closed. (00:09:37)
Amory Hanson , 2020 City Council Candidate and Historic Resources Board member, communicated
concerns regarding the mass cancellation of Huntington Beach deliberat ive assemblies, and requested
that deliberative assemblies be allowed to meet via video conferencing at minimum . (00:10 :54)
Amber, communicated her concern about beach visitors parking on residential streets and possibly
e xposing locals to COVID-19. (00:12:02)
Wendy Tochihara, communicated her opinion that it is illegal , and in v iol ation of t he State Constitution ,
to close the beach, parking lots and parks , and deny access . (00: 12 :52 )
Benigna Carrilo, communicated concern regarding the observed lack of proper social distancing and
use of masks at the beach. (00:14:04)
Pam Ponce , communicated concern regarding the open Downtown area hotels , and requested they all
be closed . (00:14 :31)
Susan Kadota, communicated disappointment that the Police Department did not enforce social
distancing at the Main Street protest held Downtown on April 17, 2020 . (00 : 15 :00)
Spencer Kelly, communicated opposition to the Main Street protest held Downtown on April 17, 2020.
(00:15:38)
Agenda Item #7 (20-1578) Emergency Facility Use Agreement-· 18 Communications
Jenny Braithwaite , communicated support for Agenda Item #7 (20-1578 ) Emergency Facility Use
Agreement. (00 : 16:48)
Jeffrey Rokos, a 25-year resident of Huntington Beach, communicated support for Agenda Item #7 (20-
1578) Emergency Facility Use Agreement. (00: 18:37)
Gina Clayton-Tarvin , a long-time resident of Huntington Beach and Pres ident, Board of Trustees,
Ocean View School District, communicated support for Agenda Item #7 (2 0-1578) Emergency Facility
Use Agreement. (00:19:31)
Gigi Jackson, a resident of Huntington Beach , communicated support for Agenda Item #7 (2 0-1578)
Emergency Facility Use Agreement. (00:20:31)
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 5 of 30
Galen Picket, communicated support for Agenda Item #7 (20-1578) Emergency Facility Use
Agreement. (00:20:56)
Francine Janousek, communicated support for Agenda Item #7 (20-1578) Emergency Facility Use
Agreement. (00:21: 19)
Annie Benington, communicated support for Agenda Item #7 (20-1578) Emergency Facility Use
Agreement. (00:21 :47)
Cathy Ryder, a 35-year resident of Huntington Beach , communicated support for Agenda Item #7 (20-
1578) Emergency Facility Use Agreement. (00:22:07)
Annette Berman , a resident of Huntington Beach, communicated support for Agenda Item #7 (20-1578)
Emergency Facility Use Agreement. (00:22:30)
Joclyn Rabbitt-Sire, a 21-year resident of Huntington Beach , communicated support for Agenda Item #7
(20-1578) Emergency Facility Use Agreement. (00:23:00)
Natalie Moser, a resident of Huntington Beach for over 40 years , communicated support for Agenda
Item #7 (20-1578) Emergency Facility Use Agreement. (00:24:42)
Linda Rose, a 38-year Huntington Beach homeowner, communicated support for Agenda Item #7 (20-
1578) Emergency Facility Use Agreement. (00:25:53)
Karen Carroll , communicated support for Agenda Item #7 (20-1578) Emergency Facility Use
Agreement. (00:26:23)
John Bostick, a long-time resident of Huntington Beach, communicated support for Agenda Item #7
(20-1578) Emergency Facility Use Agreement. (00:27:44)
Joe Sullivan, a resident of Huntington Beach, communicated support for Agenda Item #7 (20-1578)
Emergency Facility Use Agreement. (00:28:59)
Robert Banzett, a resident of Huntington Beach, communicated support for Agenda Item #7 (20-1578)
Emergency Facility Use Agreement. (00:29:24)
Pat Goodman, communicated support for Agenda Item #7 (20-1578) Emergency Facil ity Use
Agreement. (00 :29 :58)
Shevawn Ramsey, a 25-year resident of Huntington Beach, communicated support for Agenda Item #7
(20-1578) Emergency Facility Use Agreement. (00:30:37)
Barbara Robinson , communicated support for Agenda Item #7 (20-1578) Emergency Facility Use
Agreement." (02:54:00)
Item #8 (20-1569) regarding the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the Huntington
Beach Police Officers' Association (POA) (00:31 :29)
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 6 of 30
S ix hundred ninety-six (696) canned responses communicated support for adopting Resolution No .
2020-21 , the Memorandum of Understanding with the Huntington Beach Police Officers' Association
(POA) (00:31 :35):
Aaron Trump
Aaron West
Abby Moso
Adina N (2)
Adnan Ayoub
Adrian Alvarez (2 )
Adrian Silva
Adriana Mraz
Alan Caouette
Alan Partch
Alex Caouette
Alex Edwards
Alex Maslin
Alisa Adkins
Alpa Patel
Amelie Ballard
Amy Turpin
Anna Weiss
Andres Mancilla
Andrew Jamison
Angel Morales
Annamay Beekman
Anne Pritchard
Anthony Nocerino
Anya Popoff
Ariana Gonzales
Arlen Estrem
Arlene Domingo
Armando
Castellanos
Arvar Elkins
Ashley Flowers
Ashley Velazquez
Ashlynn Anderson
Austin Deuel
Austin Williams
Avery Rehak
Avia Reynolds
Axcel Calles
Aziza Tannous
Om ran
Barbara Flynn
Barbara Koehler
Beatriz Mandujano
Ben Anderson
Bentley Parrish
Bert Ekstrom
Beth Domingo
Beth Tennessen
Betsy Moeller
Betty Luna (2)
Beverly Harrison (2)
Bill Hume
Billy Baskin
Blain Tamaye
Bob Johnson
Bobbi Crawford
Bobby Kennedy
Brad Fowler
Brandon Drake
Brandon Reed
Brandy Franklin
Brenda Abe
Brenda Armstrong
Brenda Kirby (2)
Brenda McManus
Brent Gudorf
Brian Drake
Brian Pyle
Brian Schrieber
Brian Tid rick
Bridget Gorman
Bridgette Anderson
Brittany Flowers
Brooke Woodhouse
Bruce Martinez
Bruce Pollett
Bryan Nguyen
Cadi Knox
Ca itlyn Rainwater
Cameron Houlston
Camryn Smith
Cacimhe Chacon
Carl Shields
Carmen Forrester
Carol Abbott
Carol Davis
Carolynn Cuzynski
Casey Paholski
Casey Rominger
Catherine Geary
Cathie Ness
Cecile Boeh lert
Ceclia Aviles
Chad Cunningham
Charles
Goldwasser
Charles Ray
Charles Remington
Charles Reynolds
Charles South
Charlie Marti nez
Chelsie Berge
Cherie Smith
Cherrie Danks
Cheryl El ias
Cheryl Knox
Cheryl Swan
Cheryl Whitten
Chico Sanchez
Chris Donahue
Chris Feehan
Chris Filicicchia
Chris Ginocchio
Chris Hernandez
Chris Kuck o
Chris Rami rez
Christie Domingo
Christina Kampczyk
Christina Sakamoto
Christina Thomas
Christina Tolmasoff
Christine Ayala
Christine Nguyen
Christopher Brown
Christopher Clad
Christophe r Curran
Christophe r Delrey
Christophe r Parten
Christopher Roane
Chrystina Silvia
Chuck Wright
Cindy Barnes
Cindy Fitzpatrick
Cindy Gray
Clare Delle rm ann
Colleen Rowe
Colten Ivans
Courtney Lowry
Craig Abe
Crissy Te ichmann
Curtis Cope
Cyntha Hallock
Cynthia Belcher
Cynthia Boldt
Cynth ia Grabow
Cynth ia Healy
Cynthia
Vandemoortel
Dale Anderson
Dale Kuester
Dale Shields
Dan Bloom
Dan Feeney
Daniel Boldt
Dan ie l Flynn
Daniel Fornasa
Daniel Lowry
Daniel Miles
Dan iel Pratt
Dan iella Sh iba
Danny N ichols
Danny Thomas
Darin Ge rma ine
Darrell Fitzpatrick
Darrell Klopp
Darren Hudson
Dasha Samarin
Dau Tran
Dave Ballantyne
Dave Bunetta
Dave Dierking
Dave Mucha
Dave Roberts
David Kuntz
David Maae
Dayton Anderson
Dean Butler
Dean Maher
Deborah Dove
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 7 of 30
Deborah Fernandez Frank James Ill Janet Jackson John Kachirisky
Dedra Jackson Fred Ayala Janice Retz John Kuzmic
Delany Pratt Fred Furey Janis Kirkpatr ick John Rodriguez
Denise Gould Frederick Fontes Jaren Horn John Schneider
Denise MacAllister Gabriela Wiltrout Jason Melschau John Shaffer
Dennis Breckner Gail Hutton Jason Semple John Skulavik
Devon Pena Gannon Kelly Jason Wambaugh Jon Kuhn
Dewayne Brown Garry Shrum Jayson Lewis Jonathan Deliema
Diana Flowers Gary Giaconi Jeanne Criss Jonathan Jarema
Diane Harkey Gary Gasper Jeannie Tran Jonathan K ien
Diane Martin Gary Waymire Jeff Bock Jonathan Moore
Domenic l orfino Gemma Gishi Jeff Golden Jose M iguel Garcia
Dominic Capone George Nichols Jeff Jacques Ochoa
Dominic Rehak Gerladine Dirkse Jeff Kelley Joseph Ann igon i
Don Drake Germaine Davis Jeff Smith Joseph DeSa lvo
Don Emler Gerry Serrano Jen Schwartz Joseph Kelly
Don Howell Gil Dorado Jenn Abreu-Hart Joseph Marino
Don Jamison Gilbert Lascurain Jenn Torres Joseph Stephenson
Denae Weston Gilda Thompson Jennifer Broas Josh Mallory
Piper Jr. Glen Syfert Jennifer Carl Josh Mohr
Donald Kerr Glynis Spiegel Jennifer Co x Joshua Hyin k
Donnie Bruyn Grace Moso Jennifer Harvey Juan Munoz
Dorothy McCollom Greg Davis Jennifer McGrath JudiPossnack
Douglas Taliman Gregory Arnold Jennifer Pratt Judy Fowler
Drew Butler Guy Dove Jennifer Santillan Judy Kincheloe
Duane Greaver Hamza Aouini Jennifer Revard Juelene Taylor
Dustin McFarland Harlen Hanson Jeremy Tolmasoff Julian Beshore
Earle Robitalle Harold Graves Jerri Filicicchia Julie Kenny
Ed Macias Heather Lewis Jerry Goodspeed Julie McGrath
Edie Newmeyer Heather Reyno lds Jesselle Capone Jul ie Millan
Edward Deuel Ian Hunt Jessica Lamberto Justin Brooks
Edward Ryan Ibrahim Khali l Jill Jones Justin Collins
Elaine Maae Iris Shelton Jim Armstrong KaiRehak
Eli Veach Isaac Buan Jimmy Osuna Kameron Kalie
Elisha Knight J Kno x Jitu Patel Karen Challman
Elizabeth Jack Kamtansy Jo Lynn Perez Karen Emerson-
Backstrom Jack Paholski Joe Eyerman Roberts
Emily Gage Jackelyn Shaffer Joe Malik Karen Johnson
Enrique De La Cruz Jaclyn Strome Joe Sousa Karen Linson
Eric Esparza Jacob Fong Joey Aguilar Karen Provost
Eric Rackley Jacqueline Heyne John Antras ian Kari Moreno
Eric Raymond Jamene Utt John Sobie Karina Leon
Erika Franco James Armstrong John Borges Karla
Erin Dineen James Fouste John Brad Borders Westmoreland
Erin Wolf James Morgan John Bruce Kashmira Shirazi
Eugene Mulcahy James Pelleriti John Cave Kassie Pinegar
Fabius Rizk Jamie Gambardella John Domingo Kate Jordan
Faviola Guillen Jamison Power John Haney Katherine Holtsclaw
Frances Hoffman Jan McKean John Heusser
Kathryn Anacona
Deuel
Kathryn Goodspeed
Kathy Jamison
Kathy Valentino
Katie Thadi
Keli Borders
Kellie Krueger
Kelly Archer
Kelly Laney
Kelsey Spiegel
Kendall Warden
Kendra McKinney
Kenneth Emanuel
Kenneth
Kropidlowski
Kenneth Powell
Kenneth Small
Kevin Johnson
Kevin Kesler
Kevin La Pyrne
Kim De Jong
Kim Meyerowitz
Kimberly Engh
Kimberly Moso
Kirsten McCoy
Kortney Hobson
Kraig Kyle
Kris Corrales
Kris Garcia
Kris Russell
Kristen Mathews
Kyle Seasock
Larry Fellows
Larry Godfrey
Larry Porricelli
Laura Luna
Lauren Gonzalez
Lauren Smith
Laurie Miller
Leah Bratcher
Leanne Mulford
Len Damerow
Lee Arnold
Leo Lo
Leticia Rodriguez
Lillian Sobie
Linda Mendez
Linda Sancho
Lindsey Mehaffey
Lisa Bosalet
Lisa Evans
Lisa Haney
Lisa Laz
Lisa Pettigrew
Lisa Wheeler
Loraine Tooartzer
Lorenzo Spatola
Lori Arotcharen
Lori Diaz
Lori Pilatos
Lori Stanley
Lorre Bayer
Lou Vecchione
Louis Nguyen
Louise McCullough
Lynda Moore
Lynda Pavlat
Lynn Saleh
Madison Haney
Maggie Butler
Manual Delgadillo
Manya Mucha
Marc Domingo
Marc Hale
Marcela Lopez
Marco Perez
Marcus Munoz
Margaret Morris
Margaret Reed
Maria Lopez
Maria Roquelopes
Maribel Dorado
Marie Nevaroff
Marie Varvais
·Marja Selna
Marjorie Shaffer
Mark Johnson
Mark Spoelstra
Mark Thompson
Marlene Feddersen
Marlenene
Feddersen
Marti Lambright
Mary Becker
Mary Busche
Mary Harris
Mary Irish
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 8 of 30
Mary Jo Sobie
Mary Khouri
Maryann Dewees
Marylou Brooks
Matthew Nevarov
Maureen Geddie
Maurice Jaramilo
Max Werk
Ma x imillien
Seiersen
Mel Haughton
Melanie Cooper
Melissa Sobie
Melissa Houlston
Melonie Bloom
Micah Kazloff
Michael Dom ingo
Michael Couty
Michael Dean
Michael Garcia
Michael Gavar
Michael Hargis
Michael Jackson
Michael Janiel
Michael Johnson
Michael Kelly
Michael Smith
Michele A lberta
Michele Jensen
Michele Williams
Michelle Blumenthal
Michelle Melschau
Michelle Palafox
Michelle Pooler
Michelle Toyoda
Miguel Blanco
Mike Finn
Mike Maiocco
Mike Ogawa
Mike Ortega
Mindy Heusser
Mitchell Ortolani
Nadia Souetre
Nancy Crumpler
Nancy Deuel
Nancy Hanson
Nancy Meadows
Nancyann Hume
Natalina Santanello
Nate Bernal
Nathan Arnold
Nathan Phelps
Neal Holmes
Nestor Valle
Nicholas Hill
Nicholas Koehler
Nicholas Vella
Nick Jarvis
Nicole Kaprielian
Nico le Quijas
Nicole Spoelstra
N ikki Wright
Nina-Jo Anderson
Noah Capone
Noel Voorhees
Norann King
Paige Manfre
Patri ce Zappa-
Porter
Patricia Burns
Patti Kiehl-
Colacchia
Paul Goodman
Pau l Johnson
Pau la Amad io
Paulette Wolph
Perry Anthony
Peter Alpine
Peter Gruber
Peter King
Peter Teichmann
Phil Hunt
Phil ip Gray
Phil ip Scott
Preston Walrath
Prudence Tedder
Rachel Kozloff
Rafaelo Papale
Randall Abe
Randy Griffith
Randy Kuntz
Randy Salerno
Rashmi Patel
Raul Montes
Ray Kepper
Rebecca Saraf
Rebecca Volz
Rend Guerrero
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 9 of 30
Reyna Reyes Ryan Rustan Stacey Gramstad Tina Pham
Rhonda Peralta Sadhna Patel Stephanie Malchow Toby Monahan
Ricardo Sanchez Samantha Serna Stephen Edwards Todd Carpenter
Ricardo Zavale Sandra Bill Stephen Olah Tom Ga ines
Richard Backstrom Sandra Burhum Steve Brown Tom Wood
Richard Eidlhuber Sandy Humphrey Steve Gardner Toma Turner
Richard Grosvenor Santo Manfre Steve Knutsen Ton i Bristow
Richard Hulick Sarah Fond Steve McCartney Traci Fraijo
Richard Spencer Sarah Pechetta Steve Rife Travis Terich
Richard Tokunaga Savannah McKean Steven Fong Travis Yanagida
Richard Whitley Scott Adams Steven McDowell Tre Schwartz
Richard Zumwalt Scott Fahey Steven Will ard Trevor Jackson
Rick Morton Scott Ferguson SuAnne White Tyson Spataro
Rick Velasquez Scott Gump Sue Morton Umesh Patel
Ricky Nelson Scott Kansaku Sundeet Bedi Va lerie Garcia
Robby McGurr Scott McKean Susan Nakama Vanessa Baez
Robert Adams Scott Moso Susan Olim Vern Burton
Robert Donahue Scott Parker Susan Webb Veronica Logrecco
Robert Henry Scott Relph Susan White Veronica Pena
Robert McKean Scott Williams Suzanne Blackburn Vicky Malton
Robert Noonan Sean Alexander Tammy Martinez Vivian Boutdara
Robert Thompson Sean McDonough Taylor Godfrey Walter Franusiak
Robert Valdez Shannon Rackley Ted Huber Wayne Lonso
Robert Venezia Sharon Fischer Therese W illiam Boehlert
Robin and Jeff Sharon Mitchell BokSchmidt Will iam Browniee
Marsilio Shawn Alladio Thinh Dang William Edwards
Rochelle Zysk Shawn Boatright Thom Ferguson William Kirkpatrick
Roger Parker Shawna Thomas Wyatt McKean
Roman Altenbach Vanderveen Brenneman Yeong Song
Ron Privett Shellene Darling Thomas Nadolski Youlina Rehak
Ron Thompson Sheree Arkyns Thomas Rehak Yvette Krantz
Rosana Trenkle Sherry Kensinger Thomas Teichmann
Rose-Marie Spruill Sherry Sparks Tiffany Flynn
Ryan Deuel Shirley Partch Tiffany Nekritz
Ryan Houlston Shirley Salter Timothy Starn
Seventy (70) canned responses communicated support for adopting Resolution No. 2020-21 , the
Memorandum of Understanding with the Huntington Beach Police Officers' Association (POA)
(00:48:47):
Abby Olivarez
Adrianne Caouette
Anthony
Bentancourt
Arthur Villa Jr.
8 . Marchese
Blaine Gamache
Bradley Quaranta
Britt
Brooke Jordan
Cameron Houlston
Candace Higgs
Candice Jordan
Christine Tejedor
Connie Jordan
Crissy Teichmann
Curtis Grieder
Cynthia Villa
Danny Nichols
Dylan Villarreal
Erik Himert
Ernesto Villa
Gabe and Lee
HB Goodspeed's
Isabella Villa
Jamie Ortega
Jayson Lewis
Jeff Gance
Jerry Goodspeed
Jesse Crawley
John Sobie
Joni Nichols
Joseph Marchese
Josh Mohr
Joshua Cerda
Jtejedor
Kate Jordan
Konnor Armijo
Kyle Kunka
Lacey Marchese
Larry Jordan
Laura Castillo
Leo Ortega
Leonila Ortega
Leonor Tejedor
Madelynn Shepherd
Manuel Ortiz
Maria Rachel
Ortega
Melissa Sobie
Michael Gonzalez
Mike Wagner
Natalie Seward
Neil Ortega
Two hundred sixty (260) Communications received for
Nick Koehler
Nicole Villa
Rachel Shepherd
Robert Bowden
Ryan Burke
Salud Priscilla
Sean Biggie
Shari Shepherd
Son Lam
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 10 of 30
Susan Ville-Herera
T Tiechmann
Tim
Todd Bruno
Tommy Higgs
Tony Gonzalez
Travis Mossbrooks
Trini Marchese
Winhilke
Item #8, Resolution No. 2020-21 regarding the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) for the
Huntington Beach Police Officers' Association (POA);
Item #9, Resolution No. 2020-20 regarding the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) for the
Huntington Beach Management Employees' Organization (MEO); and
Item #10, Resolution No. 2020-19 regarding the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) for the
Huntington Beach Municipal Teamsters . (00:52:22)
Yvonne Mauro, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 for at least a year. (00:52:29)
Tony, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is known.
(00:54:09)
Tiffany, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is known.
(00:54:38)
Pat B., communicated support for Items #8, #9 and #10. (00:55:45)
Charlie Knoth , a 50-year resident of Huntington Beach , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and
#1 O at this time. (00:56:37)
Todd Lesko, communicated support for Items #8, #9 and #10. (00:57 :21)
Lynda Muir, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time. (00:57:43)
Laurie McAllister, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the economy has recovered
from COVID-19. (00:58: 13)
Norman Lawson , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time. (00:58:23)
Lori Davey , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known. (00:58:49)
Dave Sullivan , former Huntington Beach Council Member, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9
and #1 O at this time. (00:59:04)
Cheryl Escarro, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known. (01 :00:22)
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 11of30
Debbie Gardinier, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (01:01:12)
Ann Tarkington , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (01 :01 :32)
Melanie Hagstrom , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until Huntington Beach has
recovered . (01 :03:21)
Alina Clougherty communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time . (01 :03 :28)
Robin Krumholz, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time . (01 :03:46)
Kirk Brimhall, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until th e full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (01 :04:1 1)
Julie, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 for at least a year. (01 :04:22)
Marlene Shiner, a resident of Huntington Beach for more than 23 years , communicated opposition to
Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is known . (01:04:47)
Katheryn Clark, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (01 :05:28)
Claire Zansler, a 50-year resident, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full
impact of COVID-19 is known. (01 :05:54)
Ed Chanda , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVI D-19 is
known. (01 :06 :06)
Pam Walker, a long-time Huntington Beach resident, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10
at this time. (01 :06:43)
Bobbi Ashurst, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (01 :07 :13)
Jim Kirker, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the quality of service and
maintenance improves. (01 :07 :52)
Brent Nichols , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #1 O unti l the economy rebounds from the
impact of COVID-19. (01 :08:37)
Kristie Stewart, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 . (01 :09:04)
Juan Viramontes, President, Orange County Association of Deputy Sheriffs , communicated support for
Items #8, #9 and #10 . (01 :09:27)
Adel Hannah, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #1 O at this time . (01: 10:48)
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 12 of 30
Larry Dingus, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (01 :10:56)
Robert Dominguez, a 29-year resident of Huntington Beach, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9
and #10 until the economy has stabilized from the impact of COVID-19. (01 :12:18)
Richard Thiel, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known. (01: 13:22)
Anonymous , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this t ime . (01:14:38)
Jared Michael, communicated support for Items #8, #9 and #10. (01: 15 :49)
Laura McAllister, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the City's economy has fully
recovered from COVID-19. (01:16:31)
Eugene Haberl, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10. (01: 16:40)
Larry Elstead , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10. (01 : 16:47)
Janet Lovell , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the economy h as recovered from
COVID-19. (01:17:25)
Thomas Oberlin , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #1 O at this time . (01: 17 :42)
Monica Warthen , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 unti l the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (01 :17:52)
Marilyn Frick, commun icated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known. (01: 18: 17)
Ronnie Walker, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the economy has recovered
from COVID-19. (01:18:30)
Nicholas Mestanas, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time, and support for Item
#11 regarding the formation of an Economic Recovery Task Force. (01: 18:43)
John Birkhauser, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (01: 19:08)
Denise Kavanaugh , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19
is known . (01:19:56)
Kathleen Nutting, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known. (01 :20 :33)
Kathleen Torbick, a resident of Huntington for over 20 years , communicated opposition to Item #8 in
light of a recent incident she described as taking place in Huntington Beach . Only the first 300 words of
her communication were read . (01 :21 :22)
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 13 of 30
Susan Jervik, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (01 :23:23)
Norm Olson, a 40-year resident of Huntington Beach, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and
#10 at this time. (01 :23:49)
Cathi Crouch, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known. (01:24:11)
Katherine Won-Buerkle , communicated support for Item #8 . (01 :24 :37)
Chris Brosz, a resident of Huntington Beach for 35 years , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and
#10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is known . (01 :25 :32)
Mark Ellett, a resident of Huntington Beach for 30 years, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and
#10 at this time . (01:26 :12)
Sandra de la Fuente, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full recovery from
COVID-19. (01 :27:36)
Tyler Wong , communicated support for Item #8. (01 :27 :47)
John Borges , communicated support for Items #8, #9 and #10. (01 :28:06)
Bruce Bradley, a resident of Huntington Beach since 1976, communicated support for Item #8 .
(01 :29:52)
Michelle Vespe , communicated support for Item #8. (01 :30:28)
Bethany Webb, communicated support for Items #8, #9 and #10 . (01 :30 :51)
Max Werk, communicated support for Item #8. (01 :30 :59)
Russell Sager, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known. (01 :31 :22)
Sean Porter, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until full recovery from COVID-19.
(01 :31 :50)
Clay Allison , representing an online petition signed by 871 people as of noon on 4/20/20,
communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the crisis budget is approved . (01 :32 :29)
Robert Venezia, communicated support for Item #8. (01 :34:09)
Topartzer Family, communicated support for Item #8. (01 :34:31)
Sally Neiser, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (01 :34:58)
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 14 of 30
Tom Bilich, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (01 :36:47)
Elizabeth Esparza, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19
is known . (01 :38 :12)
Brian Tidrick, former Huntington Beach Police Department (HBPD) employee, communicated support
for Item #8. (01:38:41)
Nicole Teter, communicated support for Item #8. (01 :38:54)
Erik Wersching, communicated support for Item #8. (01 :39:15)
Erich Moreno, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (01 :39:40)
Kaitlin Tidrick, communicated support for Items #8, #9 and #10. (01 :40 :31)
Katherine Pham, communicated support for Item #8. (01 :40 :59)
William Peterson, a retired member of the HBPD, communicated support for Item #8. (01 :41 :28)
CJ Rems , a 15-year resident of Huntington Beach, communicated support for Item #8 . (01 :42:09)
Olga Reynolds , communicated support for Item #8 . (01 :42:43)
Daniela Smith, communicated support for Item #8. (01 :43:08)
Kelsey Spiegel , communicated support for Item #8. (01 :43 :30)
Glen Syfert, communicated support for Item #8 . (01 :43 :43)
Peter Teichmann, a communication expressing appreciation for the C ity's First Responders. (01 :44:15)
Mel , communicated support for Item #8 . (01 :44 :28)
Fred Nikitin, communicated support for Items #8, #9 and #10. (01 :44 :46)
Jason Melschau , communicated support for Item #8. (01 :44:56)
Robin Orozco, communicated support for Item #8. (01 :45:03)
Tiffany Nekrits, communicated support for Item #8. (01 :45:21)
Isabella Janus , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full recovery from COVID-
19. (01 :45:25)
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 15 of 30
Trina Bilich , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the fu ll impact of COVID-19 is
known , and requested a dedicated phone number for reporting adverse symptoms from the Ascon
emergency berm work. (01 :45:49)
Robert Brown , communicated support for Item #8. (01 :46:38)
Gary Joy , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this t ime . (01 :47:03)
John Gray, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (01 :47:11)
K31 sox, communicated support for Items #8, #9 and #10. (01 :48:27)
Ed Laird, communicated support for Item #8. (01 :48:36)
Nicoletta Marutsos , communicated support for Item #8. (01 :48:46)
Rob Pool , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time . (01 :49:40)
Eric Barnes, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 for at least a year. (01 :51 :45)
Sylvia Calhoun , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #1 O at this time. (01:52:10)
Scott Kansaku , communicated support for Item #8. (01 :52:47)
Lindsay Klick, communicated support for Items #8 , #9 and #10. (01 :52 :56)
Vanessa Knox-Veach , communicated support for Item #8. (01 :53 :20)
Cheryl Knox, communicated support for Item #8 . (01 :53 :35)
Justin Knox, communicated support for Item #8 . (01:54:13)
Brian Burley, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known , and support for Item #6 regarding Payment Deferral Programs . (01 :55 :08)
HB Resident, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time . (01 :57 :22)
Jennifer Ayala, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time. (01 :58 :21)
Shayna Kamlet, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time . (01:58:41)
Jo Ann Radzai , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time. (02:00:38)
Taylor Godfrey , communicated support for Item #8 . (02:00:45)
Gemma Gishi, communicated support for Item #8. (02:01 :04)
Sean Grange, communicated support for Item #8. (02:01 :08)
Kortney Hobson, communicated support for Item #8 . (02:01 :30)
Jared Horn, communicated support for Item #8. (02:01 :38)
Ryan Deuel, communicated support for Item #8. (02 :02:20)
Erin Dineen, communicated support for Item #8. (02 :02 :28)
Jed and Brenna Dineen, communicated support for Item #8 . (02:03 :12)
Cindy Fitzpatrick, communicated support for Item #8 . (02:03:25)
Tim Geddes, communicated support for Items #8, #9 and #10. (02:03 :32)
Kris Garcia, communicated support for Item #8 . (02:04:02)
Cynthia Curry, communicated support for Item #8 . (02 :04 :20)
Jennifer Bryant, communicated support for Item #8 . (02:04:37)
Tyler De Trinidad , communicated support for Item #8. (02:05 :24)
Amanda Abrego, communicated support for Item #8. (02 :05 :29)
Roman Altenbach, communicated support for Item #8. (02:05 :45)
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 16 of 30
Nick Anas, District Coordinator, Senator Tom Umberg , communicated support for Items #8, #9 and
#10 . (02 :06 :00)
Stacy Arnold , communicated support for Item #8. (02:06 :50)
Alan W. Barcelona , Chair, Orange County Coalition of Police and Sheriffs, comm unicated support for
Item #8 . (02:07:06)
Scott Baugh, communicated support for Item #8. (02 :09:14)
Amanda Blanco, communicated support for Item #8. (02 :09 :28)
Dewayne Brown, communicated support for Item #8 . (02 :09:45)
Ken Lynch, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 for at least s ix (6) months. (02: 10:01)
Ted Ross , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this t ime. (02: 10: 15)
Rita Barry, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (02 :10:36)
Raymond Raines , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time. (02: 11 :26)
Council/PFA Regul .ar Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 17 of 30
Jerry Barry , a 55-year resident of Huntington Beach , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10
at this time. (02: 11 : 50)
Scott Sanborn , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at th is time. (02 : 12:53)
D Stewart, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at th is time. (02: 13:48)
Cliff Petty, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time . (02 :14:03)
Rube Berman , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time . (02 : 14: 19)
Sandra Vidana , communicated support fc;>r Item #8. (02 :14:28)
Karl Fletcher, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time . (02:1 4 :49)
Mark Tonkovitch , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time. (02 :15:27)
Devin Dwyer, a former Huntington Beach Council Member, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9
and #10 at this time. (02:15:44)
Philip Bemis , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #1 O for at least one (1) year. (02 : 16:56 )
Lynn Johsz, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 unti l the fu ll impact of COVID-19 is
known . (02: 17:4 7)
Lee Ann Krueger, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time . (02 :18:56)
David Cicerone , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time . (02 :19:28)
Robert Ott, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 unti l the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (02 :19:47)
Vanessa Webster, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this t ime . (02:20:54)
Anna Plewa, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 unti l the full impact of COVID-19 is
known. (02:21 :00)
Kathy Carrick, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (02:22:43)
Patricia Pitts, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time. (02 :24 : 12)
Ted Ross , communicated oppos ition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at th i s time . (02:25:05)
Leiani Hedberg, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time. (02 :25:23)
Frank Daniels, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time . (02:25:59)
Shawn Hedberg, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time . (02 :26:08)
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 18 of 30
Roy Maters, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 unti l full recovery from COVID-19.
(02:26:41) (
Lowell Pierce , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time . (02 :27 : 18)
Chris Perez, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until t he full impact of COVID-19 is
known. (02 :28:08)
Shammy Dingus, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (02:28:32)
John Birkhauser, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (02 :30:07)
Mary, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this t ime. (02 :30 :53)
Alan Zimme, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (02 :31 :07)
Diana Blotzer Zimmer, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time. (02 :32 :47)
Margaret Colman, a 38-year resident of Huntington Beach, a communication requesting a survey of the
residents to determine if raises are appropriate at this time . (02:34 : 18)
Eric Halsey, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this t ime. (0 2:34:33)
Eric Smith, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time. (02:34:46)
William Hennerty, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #1 O at this time. (02:35:00)
Vanessa Martinez, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #1 O at this t ime. (02 :36:08)
Gino Bruno, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time . (02:37: 15)
Benay Moore, a resident of Huntington Beach since 1969, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9
and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is known. (02 :3 9 :14)
Bob Daniel , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 unti l the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (02:39 :47)
Heather Nolan , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time. (02:40:26)
Regan Copeland , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time. (02:40:43)
Milt Dardis, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at t his t ime . (02:40 :56)
Lou Calengelo, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this t ime. (02:41 :47)
Mallory Gorder, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time . (02:42:28)
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 19 of 30
Kevin Donahue, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time. (02:44:25)
Eric, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time . (02:44:51)
Jim Taniguichi, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time. (02:44:59)
Gary Cook, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known. (02:45 :56)
Darin Schou maker, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this t ime. (02:46: 15)
Al Arnold , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time. (02:46:27)
Donna Narthel, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #1 O at this time. (02:46:33)
Gene Marchioni, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time . (02:46:55)
Victoria Gray, a 27-year homeowner and resident of Huntington Beach, communicated opposition to
Items #8, #9 and #1 O until the crisis budget is approved . (02:47 :30)
Charles Daniher, a 54-year resident of Huntington Beach, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9
and #10 at this time. (02:48:23)
Alina Clougherty, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time. (02:50: 18)
Karen Sears, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time. (02:50:38)
Joe Provenzano, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known. (02:50:55)
Kevin Kron, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until full recovery from COVID-19.
(02:51:11)
Linda Harris , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #1 O at this time. (02:51 :48)
Eileen Harris, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time . (02:52: 12)
RoseAna Alcala, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time. (02:53:01)
Renato, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is known.
(02:54:07)
Isabelle Karsh, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known. (02:54:20)
Virginia Turner, a 17-year resident of Huntington Beach , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and
#10 at this time. (02:55:14)
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 20 of 30
Michelle and Terry Schomburg, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the fu ll impact
of COVID-19 is known . (02 :57 :38)
Steve Farnsworth , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full im pa ct of COVID-19
is known . (02:58:44)
Sherrey Hollander, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this ti me . (02 :59:36)
Bruce Wareh , commun icated opposition t o Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time . (03:01 :30)
William and Deborah Clay , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at t his time. (03:04:00)
Kevin Anderson , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time . (03:06:01 )
Ai my Royalty, communicated oppos ition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until t he c risis budget is approved .
(03:06 :22)
Mark, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is known .
(03:06 :49)
Judy Eastman, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time. (03 :07 :03)
Steve Whitmer, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #1 O at this time. (03:07 :27 )
Mary Harris, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time . (03:07 :33)
John Kachirisky, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at t his time. (03:07 :45)
Terry McCormick, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until t he full impact of COVID-19
is known . (03 :07:51 )
Linda Kalicki, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this t ime . (03 :08 :22)
Sue Porter, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at t hi s ti me. (0 3 :08 :42)
Cari Swan, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the fu ll impact of COVID-19 is
known . (03 :08 :51)
Mike Orr, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 a nd #10 at this t ime. (03:10 :39)
Deborah Pierce , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #1 O at this t ime. (03 : 10:54 )
Ann Tarkington , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at t his time . (0 3: 1 1 :28)
Frances Carr, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #1 O at this t ime. (03: 12:08)
Debb Clay, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time. (03 : 12:22)
Joan Kile, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this t ime. (03 :13:31 )
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 21of30
Michael Mengel , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (03:13 :53)
Sandy Thigpen , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #1 O until the full impact of COVI D-19 is
known. (03:14 :14)
Neil Graham , DDS, J.D., a Huntington Beach professional since 1968, communicated opposition to
Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is known . (03 : 16: 13)
Maria Spain , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at th is time. (03 :17:09)
Pat Quintana, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time. (03 : 19:03)
Jeff Luzadder, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time . (03:19:26)
Janet Doe, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time. (03:20 : 11)
Joti Ghuman, communicated oppos ition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time . (03:20:39)
Sandy Crabb, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this t ime. (03:20:48)
Blake Rose, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 for at least one year. (03:21: 11)
Dee and Kurt Wood, forty-year residents, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at th is
time. (03:21 :58)
Sheila Gee, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at th is time . (03:22 :47)
Jessica Fede, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10. (03 :23:57)
Janet Bean , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the crisis budget is approved .
(03:24:07)
Hilary Poole, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #1 O at this ti me. (03:25: 13)
Aaron Tse, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this ti me. (03:26 :42)
Lynn Unger, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time . (03:26:57)
Philip Thompson , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full im pact of COVID-19 is
known. (03 :27 :36)
PJ Garcia , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known. (03:28:13)
Taylor Haug , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known. (03:29: 15)
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 22 of 30
Dan Gooch, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #1 O until the crisis budget is approved.
(03:29:39)
Larry McNeely, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the crisis budget is approved .
(03 :30:15)
Kim Donnelly, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #1 O until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (03:30:54)
Gary Wolfe, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the fu ll impact of COVID-19 is
known. (03:31 :17)
Larry Fidance , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at th is time . (03 :31 :32)
Janet Cole, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #1 O at this time. (03 :31 :50)
Dorothy Newbrough, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-
19 is known . (03:32 :07)
Logan Haug, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #1 O at this time. (03:32:33)
Ray and Barbara Scrafield, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of
COVID-19 is known. (03:32:40)
Kris Carroll , communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time . (03:33 :33)
Michael Gioan, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #1 O until the cris is budget is approved.
(03:35:04)
Justin Richter, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 at this time. (03 :36 :03)
John Davis, communicated opposition to Items #8, #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known. (03:36:20)
Josh Mallory, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time . (03 :36 :47)
Kori Haug, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known. (03:37 :06)
Natalia Porter, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known . (03:37:27)
Cynthia Trupski, communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 at this time. (03:38:16)
Craig Frampton , communicated opposition to Items #8 , #9 and #10 until the full impact of COVID-19 is
known. (03 :38:36)
COUNCIL COMMITTEE -APPOINTMENTS -LIAISON REPORTS, AB 1234 REPORTING, AND
OPENNESS IN NEGOTIATIONS DISCLOSURES
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 23 of 30
Councilmember Posey reported moderating a speaker's panel for a Building Industry Association (BIA)
meeting regarding Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA); and speaking to the Huntington
Beach Police Officers' Association (HBPOA).
Councilmember Hardy reported two meetings with the Coastal Cities Group to discuss sea level rise,
short-term rentals, and ways to speed up the lo cal coastal process with the Coasta l Commission .
Councilmember Carr reported speaking to the Huntington Beach Police Officers' Association (HBPOA).
Councilmember Brenden reported presenting a City update via a Zoom meeting with the Chamber of
Commerce, and speaking to the Huntington Beach Police Officers' Association (HBPOA).
CITY MANAGER'S REPORT
3. 20-1485 Ascon Landfill Site Update
Assistant City Manager Travis Hopkins presented a PowerPoint communication entitled Ascon Landfill
Site Update, with slides entitled Current Status, Slope Failure Concern (2), Tension Cracks Identified,
Emergency Repair Work (4), How to Stay Informed, and Questions or Concerns .
Councilmember Carr and Assistant City Manager Hopkins discussed the project timeline , which starts
on April 20. The repair work could continue for a month or two, depending upon whether or not odors
are released, which will control how many cubic yards may be removed each day.
4. 20-1584 Update of the City COVID-19 Response Plan and Actions for Review and
Discussion
City Manager Oliver Chi provided a PowerPoint communication entitled City of Huntington Beach
2019120 COVID-19 Budget Response Plan, that included the following t itled slides: FY 2019120 Budget
Situation Overview, Revenue Projections -Then vs. Now, Budgetary Impact of Revenue Reduction,
Current FY 2019120 Budget Balancing Strategy, FY 2019120-Revised Revenue Assumptions, Revenue
Decrease Assumptions, Property Tax Assumption, Sales Tax Assumption, TOT Assumptions, Business
License Assumptions, Licenses & Permits Assumptions, Charges for Current Services, Fines &
Forfeitures Assumptions, Use of Money & Property Assumptions, Revenue Decrease Summary, FY
2019120 Proposed Expenditure Cuts, Proposed Expenditure Cuts, Supplemental Employee Retirement
Program Transfer Reduction, OPEB Retiree Medical Transfer Reduction, Section 115 Retirement
Transfer Reduction, Hiring Freeze, COVID-19 Reimbursable Expenses, Reduce Overstated GF Bond
Payment Transfer, General Liability Fund Transfer Suspension, Infrastructure Fund Transfer Reduction,
Equipment Replacement Reductions, Equipment Replacement Cuts -Prior Year Encumbrances,
Equipment Replacement Cuts -Current Year Requests to be Cance/led/Deferred, Equipment
Replacement Cuts -Current Year Requests Already Cancelled, Current Year Operating Budget
Reductions, FY 2019120 Proposed Budget Adjustment Summary, Overall Budget Adjustment
Summary, Updated FY 2019120 General Fund Budget Overview, and Questions?
Mayor Pro Tern Hardy asked, and City Manager Chi confirmed, that these projections are for the
current fiscal year, or through June 30. There was discussion with Chief Financial Officer (CFO) Dahle
Bulosan to define "other contract services." Mayor Pro Tern Hardy asked for more detailed
explanations moving ahead , and confirmed that part-time employees do not get cost of living raises in
step with full-time staff raises .
Coun cil/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 24 of 30
Councilmember Posey shared that he is happy to see that Reserves are not being touched in this
budget , and believes that the projections are fair. He and CFO Bulosan discussed the Federal CARES
Act which is expected to reimburse about $1 M in City COVID-19 related costs at least through the end
of this year. City Manager Chi ex plained that application will also be made to FEMA for reimbursement
of additional costs if necessary.
Mayor Pro Tern Hardy stated her support for continuing to place at least $1 M into the Trust 115 account
for the next several years to help meet the longer-term financial issue t hat is created by the COVID-19
crisis .
Councilmember Carr stated support for continuing the $1 M deposit into the Trust 115 account and
asked if lost revenue funds could be acquired through reimbursement. Mayor Semeta explained t hat
Federal guidelines define that only COVID-19 direct e x penses are el igible for reimbursement. City
Manager Chi stated there is talk that another Federal stimulus package may be directed to counties
and local municipalities to help make up for expected revenue losses.
Councilmember Brenden and City Manager Chi discussed further detai ls on presentation slide #9 ,
Sales Tax Assumption . Councilmember Brenden stated his concern about Q3 and Q4 projections, and
C ity Manager Chi stated he ex pects the FY2020/2021 Budget to be presented to Council in early May.
Councilmember Delgleize and City Manager Chi discussed the budget categories that wou ld be
impacted by COVID-19 reimbursements, and City Manager Chi confirmed that the $1M reduction in
infrastructure transfer will not impact any current projects. City Manager Chi also ex plained that the
MOUs being considered in this meeting have not been accounted for in this budget report; however if
the MOUs are approved , their $1.6M impact for the current year would become a re duction to t he
currently projected $2 .2M Net Position .
Mayor Semeta stated support for Mayor Pro Tern Hardy's comments regarding the Trust 115 account.
ADMINISTRATIVE PUBLIC HEARING
5. 20-1538 Conducted Public Hearing for 2020 Annual Weed Abatement Program and
authorized the Director of Public Works to proceed with abatement of public
nuisance
Assistant City Manager Hopkins presented a PowerPoint communication entitled Annual Weed,
Rubbish, and Refuse Abatement Program , with slides entitled Program Timeline (4).
Mayor Semeta opened the Public Hearing for this Item .
City Clerk Robin Estanislau announced that no public comments were subm itted for th is item .
Mayor Semeta closed the Public Hearing .
A motion was made by Peterson , second Hardy to open a public hearing for any objections and
protests to the proposed removal of weeds, refuse and rubbish; and following the hearing; and ,
authorize the Superintendent of Streets (Acting Director of Public Works) to proce ed with the
abatement of said nuisance.
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 25 of 30
The motion carried by the following vote :
AYES:
NOES :
Posey, Delgleize, Hardy, Semeta, Peterson, Carr, and Brenden
None
ADMINISTRATIVE ITEMS
6. 20-1577 Approved Resolution Nos. 2020-24, 2020-25, and 2020-26 to establish Payment
Deferral Programs for Business License Renewal Taxes and Fees, Transient
Occupancy Taxes, and BID assessments collected by the City in Response to
COVID-19
City Manager Chi requested that Resolution No. 2020-27 regarding the Tourism BID be pulled from
consideration due to a procedural change and introduced the item by ex pla ining this proposal is not to
forgive any payments due to the City, but only to defer payments for at least four (4) months .
Councilmember Brenden and City Manager Chi discussed the process which is intended to provide
maximum flexibility while ensuring that any monies due to the City will be remitted by the end of nex t
fiscal year, or June 30 , 2021 . City Manager Chi confirmed that the entities affected by these
resolutions have expressed their support for the program .
A motion was made by Posey, second Peterson to adopt Resolution 2020-25 related to the
establishment of a business license payment deferral program for renewals ; and , adopt Resolution
2020-24 related to the establishment of a TOT payment deferral program ; and, adopt Resolution 2020-
26 related to the establishment of a BID payment deferral program, wh ich would be instituted if the City
were directed to do so by each respective BID , as amended to postpone consideration of
Resolution No. 2020-27 to the May 4, 2020, City Council meeting.
The motion as amended carried by the following vote:
AYES:
NOES :
Posey, Delgleize, Hardy, Semeta, Peterson , Carr, and Brenden
None
At the eleven o'clock hour, a motion was made by Peterson , second Posey to continue the City Council
meeting . The motion carried by the following vote :
AYES :
NOES:
Posey, Delgleize, Hardy, Semeta, Peterson , Carr, and Brenden
None
7. 20-1578 Approved Emergency Facility Use Agreement between the County of Orange and
the City of Huntington Beach to Establish a Temporary Alternative Shelter Site at
17631 Cameron Lane to Respond to the COVID-19 Pandemic.
City Manager Chi introduced this item by explaining that the State of California has ordered that every
county has to provide emergency shelter to isolate their homeless population during the COVI D-19
crisis. He provided a PowerPoint communication entitled Orange County Efforts to Date, with slides
entitled Possible HB-OC Partnership, Potential Temporary Alternative Shelter Site, Temporary
Alternative Shelter Site -SPRUNG Tent Structures, Development of Shelter Site, Facility to be
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 26 of 30
Operated by Illumination Foundation, When the Shelter Order is Lifted ... , Outreach Plan To Be
Deployed, and City Council Options.
Councilmember Delgleize and City Manager Chi discussed the services that will be provided by
Illumination Foundation, such as oversight and management of the facilities, on-site medical care , and
security that meets local standards. The agreement was drafted by the City Attorney's office and is part
of this Item. City Manager Chi stated that it will take a couple of years to coordinate the affordable
housing project, and three to five years for completion at that site.
Councilmember Delgleize and Police Chief Handy discussed how this project will help the Huntington
Beach Police Department, including facilities to currently house potentially 50 identified individuals, and
down the road provide a means for comprehensively enforcing local camping ordinances and
reclaiming some of the City's public space .
Councilmember Carr expressed her support for this item, and thanked City Manager Chi for reach ing
out to the County for a workable solution . Councilmember Carr stated the importance of landscaping to
minimize visibility of this facility from the street.
Mayor Pro Tern Hardy confirmed that the physical address for the project is Cameron Lane, but ingress
and egress are off Beach Boulevard , and suggested that there be efforts made w ith both the Fire
Department and Post Office to get the address changed to Beach Boulevard . Mayor Pro Tern Hardy
asked that the landscaping address not only the Beach Boulevard portion of the project, but also
Cameron Lane .
Councilmember Posey stated his support for this plan which in his opinion provides a good partnership
with the County, a good tool for the Huntington Beach Police Department, and a good tool for the City
now and in the future.
Mayor Semeta, City Attorney Gates, and City Manager Chi discussed some of the specifics related to
the time when this location management will transition from the County to the C ity, including the
handling of active residents and managing company changes . City Manager Ch i confirmed that
anyone testing positive for COVID-19 will not be housed at this facility, but will be housed at other
County-managed facilities already set up for the proper care and confinement of those individuals.
A motion was made by Posey, second Hardy to authorize the City Manager to execute, in a form
approved by the City Attorney, the "Emergency Facility Use Agreement between the County of Orange
and the City of Huntington Beach" to establish a temporary alternative shelter site at 17631 Cameron
Lane to respond to the COVID-19 pandemic.
The motion carried by the following vote:
AYES:
NOES:
Posey, Delgleize, Hardy , Semeta , Peterson , Carr, and Brenden
None
8. 20-1569 Adopted Resolution No. 2020-21 Approving and Implementing the Memorandum
of Understanding Between the Huntington Beach Police Officers' Association and
the City of Huntington Beach for January 1, 2020, through June 30, 2023
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 27 of 30
9. 20-1570 Adopted Resolution No. 2020-20 Approving and Implementing the Memorandum
of Understanding Between the Huntington Beach Management Employees'
Organization (MEO) and the City of Huntington Beach for November 1, 2019,
through October 31, 2020
10. 20-1571 Adopted Resolution No. 2020-19 Approving and Implementing the Memorandum
of Understanding Between the Huntington Beach Municipal Teamsters and the
City of Huntington Beach for October 1, 2019, through September 30, 2020
City Manager Chi noted that these Memorandums of Understanding (MOU) are being brought back to
Council at this time to meet the requirements of the Meyers-Milias-Brown Act (MMBA). He reviewed
the history of discussions which began last year, with tentative agreements reached in late January and
early February this year, the introduction of the agreements on April 6, and tonight's decision of
whether or not to approve. City Manager Chi provided a summary overview of each MOU which is
estimated to have a total current year fiscal impact of $1 .6M, and $2.58M for next fiscal year, and which
propose that City employees pick up additional pension costs.
Councilmember Peterson expressed his concerns regarding the budget free-fall which has just started
in response to COVID-19 , and his need to also see FY 2020/21 1st and 2nd Quarter numbers for an
accurate crisis budget; referred to the majority of public comments opining that now is not the right time
to increase expenses; referenced the "circumstance of change" which is allowed in the MMBA; and
asked what will happen when the TOT and sales tax numbers don 't come in as projected .
Councilmember Peterson stated his need for a more accurate financial outlook before he can support
these MOUs .
Councilmember Posey stated his support for approving these MOUs, and explained that, in his opinion,
not only are budget cuts required but there is also a need to diversify the economy, and described
several scenarios to enhance diversification beyond just tourism to weather storms like this.
Councilmember Carr expressed her support for Councilmember Posey's comments and these MOUs,
and reiterated her opinion that these agreements are very fair in that both sides gave up things to reach
these agreements . She also stated that since the MEO contract will end on October 31, 2020, and the
Teamster's contract ends September 30 , 2020, it makes no sense to delay a decision until 2021.
Mayor Delgleize stated her support for the need to diversify the City's economy, and her decision to
support these MOUs is based on a year of discussions , and includes the employees agree ing to carry a
larger portion of their retirement plan, as well as the POA changing their t ime-off plan which both
benefit the City . She further stated her opinion that decisions should be based on what is happening
today , as well as looking to the future.
Councilmember Brenden clarified the issue raised by several public speakers that "City Council is
granting themselves a raise" and stated that City Council members, the City Manager, and department
heads are not part of these labor groups. He further expressed his concerns regarding the process that
keeps the public away from Council meetings, and suggested other options be considered to allow
meeting attendance by the public while also adhering to appropriate social distancing practices .
Councilmember Brenden explained his opinion that previous Council fiscal responsibility has created
the current situation of fiscal strength, and it is not possible to expect Huntington Beach to respond as
other area cities have because actual situations are not the same.
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 28 of 30
Mayor Pro Tern Hardy expressed support for Councilmember Brenden's concerns about how the public
is currently required to communicate with Council , and supports considering other options . She also
stated that these MOUs are good agreements; however, the economic future is not looking good to her,
and some of the savings listed in the current FY crisis budget will not be possible to e xtend into the
2020/2021 budget. Mayor Pro Tern Hardy believes that very hard decisions about what to cut from the
future budget will have to be made if these MO Us are approved now.
Mayor Semeta stated her opinion it is irresponsible to approve $5M in raises during th is time of
economic turmoil and loss of income, and read a statement from a recently publ ished article entitled,
"Huntington Beach Denies Pandemic Reality and Dispenses Pay Ra ises " to describe her thoughts.
A motion was made by Peterson , second Semeta to table Resolution Nos. 2020-21 , 2020-20 and 2020-
19 until next year (2021 ). The motion failed by the following vote :
AYES:
NOES:
Hardy , Semeta, and Peterson
Posey, Delgleize, Carr, and Brenden
A substitute motion was made by Posey, second Carr to adopt Reso lut ion No . 2020-21 , "A Resoluti on
of the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach Approving and Implementing the Memorandum of
Understanding between the Huntington Beach Police Office rs' Association (HBPOA) and t he City for
January 1, 2020 through June 30, 2023;" and, adopt Resolution No. 2020-20 , "A Reso lution of the City
Council of the City of Huntington Beach Approving and Implementing the Memorandum of
Understanding between the Huntington Beach Management Employees ' Organization (MEO) and the
City for November 2 , 2019 through October 31 , 2020;" and , adopt Resolu ti on No. 2020-19, "A
Resolution of the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach Approving and Implementing the
Memorandum of Understanding between the Huntington Beach Mun ici pal Teamsters (HBMT) and the
City for October 1, 2019 through September 20, 2020 ."
The substitute motion carried by the following vote:
AYES :
NOES:
Posey, Delgleize , Carr, and Brenden
Hardy, Semeta, and Peterson
COUNCILMEMBER ITEMS
11. 20-1583 Approved Item Submitted by Mayor Semeta -Formation of an Economic
Recovery Task Force
Mayor Semeta introduced this item by describing the government mandates which are producing
significant financial strain locally as well as around the world , and her interest in implementing a
definitive plan to support economic stabilization , recovery and resi li ency during and after the COVID-19
pandemic. Mayor Semeta stated her vision is to discuss and decide what should be done in Huntington
Beach to make the recovery as quick and robust as possible for businesses and residents.
Councilmember Posey shared his support for this item , and stated his opinion that government needs
to get out of the way and make City Hall more business friendly. He stated there are exi sting groups
like the Downtown Business Improvement D istrict , Visit HB , Chamber of Commerce, Orange County
Association of Realtors, Building Association of Orange County and the Auto Dea lers Association ,
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 29 of 30
among others, which are already focused on this issue , and his recommendation is for the Economic
Recovery Task Force to first help auto dealers find space to store their inventory.
Councilmember Carr expressed her support for this Task Force, and encouraged cooperation with the
Task Force being set up by the County , and confirmed with Mayor Semeta that developing best
practices for opening up businesses will be included in the discussions.
Councilmember Brenden suggested effort be focused on how to restore some sense of normal while
being mindful of the dangers that still exist. He and Mayor Semeta discussed that the initial purpose of
the Task Force will be focused on the COVID-19 recovery, but it could also become a more permanent
committee of business advisers in the future.
Councilmember Delgleize stated her support for this item, and stressed that businesses have ideas and
want to be heard and supported regarding their re-opening efforts.
A motion was made by Semeta, second Peterson to direct the City Manager to return in two weeks with
a prpposal for the creation of the Huntington Beach Economic Recovery Task Force; and , appoint two
City Council members to serve as Economic Recovery Task Force liaisons , should the proposal be
approved and adopted .
The motion carried by the following vote :
AYES:
NOES:
Posey, Delgleize, Hardy, Semeta, Peterson , Carr, and B renden
None
COUNCILMEMBER COMMENTS (Not Agendized)
Councilmember Posey recognized two Huntington Beach students who were nominated for vocal and
instrumental music categories in advanced competition: Daisy Tye , in Non-Classical Voice, and Ryan
Marinier, in Guitar, both seniors at Huntington Beach High School.
ADJOURNMENT -At 12:26 AM to the next regularly scheduled meeting of the Huntington Beach City
Council/Public Financing Authority on Monday, May 4 , 2020 , at 4:00 PM in the Civic Center Council
Chambers, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, California .
INTERNET ACCESS TO CITY COUNCIL/PUBLIC FINANCING AUTHORITY AGENDA AND
STAFF REPORT MATERIAL IS AVAILABLE PRIOR TO CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS AT
http://www. hun ti ngtonbeachca . gov
City Clerk arid ex-officio Clerk of the City Council of
the City of Huntington Beach and Secretary of the
Public Financing Authority of the City of Huntington
Beach , California
ATTEST:
Council/PFA Regular Meeting
April 20, 2020
Page 30 of 30
