Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
Orange County Power Authority (OCPA) Default Rate Selection
r ' . 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach,CA City of Huntington Beach Appkot� 6-1(P�,,,-!va) FaP— PEFW1tivr1 t/CAt1t102%AL � �� ,�• Ct.�TOf-1G-l2S TV Fi4L'l un ES File #: 22-074 MEETING DATE: 2/1/2022 REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION SUBMITTED TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members SUBMITTED BY: Sean Joyce, Interim City Manager PREPARED BY: Sean Joyce, Interim City Manager Subject: Orange County Power Authority (OCPA) Default Rate Selection Statement of Issue: In February 2021 , the City Council approved its Founding Member participation in the Orange County Power Authority (OCPA) (see Attachment 1 for accompanying staff report). The City finalized its decision and joined in Dec. 2020. In April 2022, OCPA is expected to launch service to municipal and commercial customers in the cities of Huntington Beach, Buena Park, Fullerton, and Irvine. In October 2022, OCPA will phase in all residential customers within its service territory. In December 2021, the OCPA Board of Directors approved the addition of the County of Orange unincorporated areas as its fifth member agency and anticipates launching its service to all customers in 2023. At full launch, OCPA's service territory will cover approximately 366,000 retail service accounts (governmental, businesses and residents), making it the sixth-largest community choice energy provider in the State of California. As a member of the OCPA, the City of Huntington Beach may select a default energy product offering prior to OCPA's distribution of its first customer enrollment notice describing the OCPA Program, informing customers of their opt-out rights to remain with utility bundled generation service in early February 2022. OCPA's energy product offerings include the Basic Choice product, which will include 38.5% renewable energy content in 2022 that increases over time; the Smart Choice product, which will include at least 69% renewable energy content in 2022 that increases over time; and the 100% Renewable Choice product, which will maintain a 100% renewable energy content. The "default product offering" is the power choice that will go into effect unless the consumer makes a different choice. All customers will have the option to upgrade, downgrade, or opt-out and return to service with Southern California Edison (SCE) at any time. Staff is seeking direction from the City Council on the most appropriate selection of a "default energy product offering" for all customers in the City. The following are the three energy product offerings: 1. Basic Choice: If the City selects 38.5% renewables as its default energy product offering, then City of Huntington Beach Page 1 of 4 Printed on 1262022 po ere(29j Legistar' File #: 22-074 MEETING DATE: 2/1/2022 all Huntington Beach customers will automatically be enrolled in the Basic Choice product (38.5% renewables) unless the customer opts-up to either the Smart Choice product (at least 69% renewables) or 100% Renewable Choice product or the customer opts-out of OCPA service altogether and stays with SCE. 2. Smart Choice: If the City selects at least 69% renewables as its default energy product, then all Huntington Beach customers will automatically be enrolled in the Smart Choice product (at least 69% renewables) unless the customer opts-up to the 100% Renewables product, opts- down to the Basic Choice product, or the customer opts-out of OCPA service altogether and stays with SCE. 3. 100% Renewable Choice: If the City selects 100% renewables as its default energy product, then all Huntington Beach customers will automatically be enrolled in the 100% Renewables product unless the customer opts-down to either the Basic Choice or the Smart Choice products or the customer opts-out of OCPA service altogether and stays with SCE. OCPA Status Report - Default Energy Product Offerings • Buena Park: Selected Smart Choice product (at least 69% renewables) as a default energy product offering for their residential and commercial customers on January 25, 2022. The City has not yet made a determination concerning the default energy product offering for City facilities. • Irvine - Selected Smart Choice product (at least 69% renewable) as a default energy product offering for their residential and commercial customers and is expected to take final vote on February 8, 2022. The Irvine City Council also decided that all City facilities will default into the 100% Renewable Choice product. • Fullerton - Will choose a default Energy Product on February 1 , 2022 • Huntington Beach - Will choose a default Energy Product on February 1, 2022 Low-income qualified customers (customers currently enrolled in the California Alternate Rates for Energy (CARE) and the Family Electric Rate Assistance (FERA) discount programs will continue to receive all benefits and discounts as an OCPA customer. Mayor Pro Tern Mike Posey serves as the City's member on OCPA Board of Directors; Councilmember Dan Kalmick is the City's alternate. As the City's representative, Mayor Pro Tern Posey has been integrally involved on the Board of OCPA since its inception. As such, Mayor Pro Tern Posey may wish to supplement this report with comments of his own and may offer a recommendation for action this evening. Financial Impact: The OCPA Board approved rate design set the 2022 rates for Basic Choice at parity to SCE, assuming all OCPA member agencies select Smart Choice as the default service offering. This approved rate design allows for a smaller premium for Smart Choice (estimated at SCE rate plus a penny per kWh or 3.7% above SCE for average residential customer) and 100% Renewable Choice (estimated at SCE rate plus 1 .5 cents per kWh or 5.6% above SCE for average residential customer). City of Huntington Beach Page 2 of 4 Printed on 1/26/2022 oowerc423 leg,star'" File #: 22-074 MEETING DATE: 2/1/2022 In addition, the OCPA Board also approved the Net Energy Metering enhancements from the SCE NEM program, as follows: 1. Set NSC rate at 10% above the incumbent IOU NSC rate 2. Provide monthly billing to NEM customers 3. Set all customers annual true-up period to April OCPA Board Approved Rate Design Bill Impacts For a typical residential customer, the bill impacts for the three OCPA product offerings are estimated by OCPA as follows: Estimated "I'ypical Residential Bill Comparison Basic Choice, 425 KWIC Per rtlonth Charge Type OCPA SCE. Difference Generation S41.51 S49.96 (S8.45) SCE SurchargeS8.45 S0.00 S8.45 SCE Delivery S64.44 S64.44 S0.00 Total S 114.40 S114.40 S0.00 0.0% Estimated "rypical Residential Bill Comparison Smart Choice. 425 KIVh Per Month Charge Type OCPA SCE Difference Generation S45.76 S49.96 (S4.2l1l SCE- SurcharacSS.45 S0.00 S8.45 SCE Delivery S64.44 S64.44 S0.00 Total S 115.65 S114.40 $4.25 3).7% Estimated Typical Residential Bill Comparison 100% Renewable Eger• • Choice, 425 KIVh Per Alm& Charge Type OCPA SCE Difference Generation S47.89 S49.96 (S_o7) SCE Surchame:SS.45 S0.00 S8.45 SCE Delivery S64.44 S64.44 S0.00 Total S120.75 S114.40 S6.JS 5.6% The detailed rate design analysis is included in the attached January 11, 2022 OCPA staff report (Attachment 2). In light of the lack of direct staff involvement in the development of the OCPA rate design analysis attached here, OCPA staff will attend our meeting to discuss the options and answer related questions. Recommended Action: City of Huntington Beach Page 3 of 4 Printed on 1/26/2022 PoHert424 Leti,siar'" File #: 22-074 MEETING DATE: 2/1/2022 Select Basic Choice, Smart Choice, or 100% Renewable Choice as the default energy product offering for residential and commercial customers in Huntington Beach, and consider the same or a different energy product offering (and corresponding rate and environmental benefits) for the City's municipal energy accounts. Alternative Action(s): The following options are available to the City Council: 1. Select 100% Renewable as a default energy product offering for all OCPA Customers in Huntington Beach; 2. Select Smart Choice (at least 69% renewables) as a default energy product offering for all OCPA Customers in Huntington Beach; or 3. Select Basic Choice (38.5% renewables) as a default energy product offering for all OCPA Customers in Huntington Beach. Staff has no specific recommendation. Analysis: The following is OCPA's rate design analysis in the attached January 11 , 2022 report. Under the approved rate design scenario (scenario 3), the cost impacts for each of the default product offering for the City's municipal energy accounts are estimated as follows: Cost Increase (VkWh) Cost Increase (S) Basic Choice 0 0 Smart Choice .01 Approx. $141k 100% renewable Choice .015 Approx. S212k Over the past decade, the City has worked diligently to reduce energy consumption. The cost spent on energy in 2019 was approximately $3.OM. This expenditure has been reduced from what was $4.7M in 2014. This was done largely through projects such as the LED conversion of City streetlights and the solar panels that were installed at City facilities. Even after paying for the debt service on these projects, the savings far exceed the cost increase of implementing renewable energy. This important policy matter before you represents an opportunity to extend the City's commitment to environmental stewardship. Environmental Status: Not applicable Strategic Plan Goal: Non Applicable - Administrative Item Attachment(s): 1 . February 1 , 2021 Request for City Council Action Report 2. OCPA January 11, 2022 Report City of Huntington Beach Page 4 of 4 Printed on 1/2612022 oowere425 Legis;aC City Council/ ACTION AGENDA February 1, 2022 Public Financing Authority offering for residential and commercial customers in Huntington Beach, and consider the same or a different energy product offering (and corresponding rate and environmental benefits) for the City's municipal energy accounts Approved 6-1 (Peterson-No) 100% Renewable Choice Alternative Default Energy Product Offering for Residential/Commercial Customers; and Approved 6-1 (Peterson-No) 100% Renewable Choice Alternative Default Energy Product Offering for City facilities COUNCILMEMBER ITEMS 19. 22-079 Approved Item Submitted by Mayor Delgleize, Councilmember Moser and Councilmember Bolton - Consider support of a Blood Drive in collaboration with the UCI Health Bloodmobile, and direct staff to coordinate with UCI Health to host the event at a City Facility Recommended Action: We are recommending the following 1. Direct staff to collaborate with UCI Health to host a blood drive at a City of Huntington Beach facility tentatively on March 5, 2022, and. 2. Direct staff to highlight and promote resources for additional opportunities for the community to participate in blood drives Approved 7-0 COUNCILMEMBER COMMENTS (Not Agendized) Comments provided by: Posey, Carr, Moser ADJOURNMENT - 9:39 PM A Strategic Planning Workshop has been scheduled for 9 00 AM, Friday, February 4. 2022 at Huntington Beach Central Library, Rooms C & D. 7111 Talbert Avenue, Huntington Beach, California. The next regularly scheduled meeting of the Huntington Beach City Council/Public Financing Authority is Tuesday. February 15, 2022. at 4:00 PM in the Civic Center Council Chambers, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach. California. INTERNET ACCESS TO CITY COUNCIL/PUBLIC FINANCING AUTHORITY AGENDA AND STAFF REPORT MATERIAL IS AVAILABLE PRIOR TO CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS AT http:/Iwww.huntingtonbeachca.gov City Council/ ACTION AGENDA February 1, 2022 Public Financing Authority Recommended Action: Approve and authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to execute "Professional Services Contract Between the City of Huntington Beach and Disability Access Consultants. LLC for ADA Self- Evaluation and Transition Plan " Approved 7-0 15. 22-069 ITEM WITHDRAWN Approwed and authorized exeGution 4a4 a-Pfe#essiertal- Adv Services Recommended--Artier: Between the Crty Of HURbRgtOR Beach and- K Street Consulting. LLC fOF Legislative y 16. 22.061 Approved and authorized execution of Amendment No. 5 to Agreement with Biggs Cardosa Associates, Inc. (BCA) for bridge design services in the amount of $301,857.00, for a total contract amount not to exceed $3,115,654.00 and extending the contract term 3 years Recommended Action: Approve and authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to execute Amendment No. 5 to Agreement Between the City of Huntington Beach and Biggs Cardosa Associates. Inc for Bridge Design Services. Approved 7-0 17. 22-062 Approved the purchase of 23 replacement vehicles from National Auto Fleet Group using lease financing and authorized the City Manager to enter into all documents necessary to lease finance the purchase of the vehicles Recommended Action: Approve the purchase of 23 replacement vehicles utilizing 5-year lease financing at an interest rate not to exceed 2 375 percent and authorize the City Manager to enter into all documents necessary to lease finance the purchase of the vehicles and take all administrative and budgetary actions necessary to complete the purchase and financing. Approved 7-0 ADMINISTRATIVE ITEMS 18. 22-074 Selected Orange County Power Authority (OCPA) Alternative Default Energy Product Offerings for Residential/Commercial customers and City facilities offered Recommended Action: Select Basic Choice, Smart Choice. or 100% Renewable Choice as the default energy product ,;• _ 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, CA '1 City of Huntington Beach 92646 File #: 21-085 MEETING DATE: 2/1/2021 REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION SUBMITTED TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members SUBMITTED BY: Oliver Chi, City Manager PREPARED BY: Travis K. Hopkins, Assistant City Manager Subject: Consider Maintaining Membership with the Orange County Power Authority (OCPA), a Community Choice Energy (CCE) Joint Power Authority (JPA) Statement of Issue: On December 10, 2020, the City approved the required Ordinance, Resolution, and JPA agreement necessary for Huntington Beach to join the Orange County Power Authority (OCPA), a Community Choices Energy (CCE) Joint Power Authority (JPA). The decision was made to join the CCE at that time for a variety of reasons, including the following: • The potential for ongoing electrical power cost savings when compared against rates charged by SCE. • By joining in December 2020, the City would be considered a Founding Party member, which places Huntington Beach onto the JPA Executive Board Committee. • The agreements expressly allowed for any participating agency to withdraw from the JPA for any reason and without any liability or cost by March 1 , 2021 (subsequently, the withdrawal deadline was extended to April 1, 2021 ). Given those factors, as part of the determination to join the OCPA, the City Council also directed that staff complete a full assessment of the proposed JPAs feasibility plan, and bring those findings back for review at the City's February 1, 2021 meeting. At that time, the City Council would make a final determination on whether or not to participate in the CCE. Subsequently, staff coordinated with MRW & Associates (MRW), an independent firm that was hired to assess the OCPAs implementation plan. A summary of MRWs findings (see attached report assessing OCPA) is as follows: • The OCPA CCE is expected to be financially feasible. City of Huntington Beach Page 1 of 6 Printed on 12/8/2021 powere426 Legista,'- File #: 21-085 MEETING DATE: 2/1/2021 • The MRW analysis confirmed that OCPA is projected to be able to provide power at rates lower than Southern California Edison. • The MRW assessment identified that the financial margins when comparing projected OCPA rates against SCE rates are the smallest during the first 2-3 years of operation, and that the margins increase over substantially over time. • The financial analysis found that OCPA's Implementation Plan is generally sound, developed utilizing reasonable and conservative assumptions. MRW did identify that the projections for the amount of initial working capital that OCPA would need could be slightly understated. o Of note, given that the City of Irvine is assuming all of the initial risk / start-up costs, this does not seem to of particular concern regarding the viability of OCPA. • The OCPA agreement helps minimizes potential financial risk for Huntington Beach by specifically stating that the agencies are not required to make any financial contributions or payments to OCPA, and that OCPA has no right to require a contribution or payment. • A benefit of remaining a member of OCPA is that the City of Irvine has agreed to provide up- front funding for implementation, start-up costs, as well as collateral funds in order to secure all of the needed initial financing. At this time, the City Council has the option to maintain membership with the OCPA JPA, or withdraw from the CCE organization with no cost or liability impacts. Financial Impact: There is no direct fiscal impact from joining the OCPA JPA. Per the JPA agreement, participating agencies are not required to make any financial contribution. Rather, the City of Irvine has agreed through the JPA agreement to cover all initial start-up costs associated with establishing the new OCPA entity. Those costs that Irvine has agreed to cover include the following: • OCPA agency start-up costs, which are estimated at $2.5M. • Initial working capital cash collateral of up to $5M for costs associated with procuring a working capital loan. Under the OCPA JPA agreement, Founding Party members have no financial obligation to the CCE entity being formed, which provides financial protections for Huntington Beach. The OCPA JPA agreement specifically states that the debts of the OCPA cannot be transferred to its member cities, nor can the OCPA compel a member city to financially contribute to the OCPA. Therefore, the City's General Fund should not be impacted by maintaining membership, nor will membership impact the City's credit rating. Recommended Action: The City Council has the following options: City of Huntington Beach Page 2 of 6 Printed on 1 2/812 0 2 1 n ,,e,L427v Legmiar- File #: 21-085 MEETING DATE: 2/1/2021 A) Maintain membership in the Orange County Power Authority Community Choice Energy Joint Power Authority, OR B) Withdraw from the Orange County Power Authority, and direct staff to complete all requisite documents necessary to terminate our participation in the CCE JPA. Alternative Action(s): Do not select either of the options and direct staff accordingly. Analysis: In 2018, the City of Irvine initiated a feasibility study to assess the possibility of implementing a CCE program for their community. Those efforts evolved over the past two years, and in 2020, Irvine extended an invitation to all Orange County municipalities, asking interested parties to consider joining them in forming a CCE JPA, which has since been named the Orange County Power Authority (OCPA). A total of five (5) agencies are currently part of the JPA, including the cities of Fullerton, Buena Park, Lake Forest, Huntington Beach, and Irvine. These five jurisdictions are considered the Founding Party member agencies in the JPA and will be placed on the JPAs Executive Board Committee. Also of note, per OCPA staff, there are currently up to 10 other cities reviewing participation in OCPA. CCE Background CCEs are a mechanism authorized in California in 2002 by Assembly Bill 117, whereby local electrical service customers are provided with options when it comes to determining from where they purchase their power. Under the CCE set-up, customers can continue to procure their electrical power through their current utility provider (in the case of Huntington Beach, that would be Southern California Edison), or they can opt to have a local municipal government (or a coalition of local governments) procure electrical power on their behalf. Typically, CCEs are established with larger environmental or social goals in mind, such as increasing the share of power procured from renewable sources. In addition, CCEs have been shown to provide slight cost savings (around 1-2% decrease) over traditional investor-owned utility operations. Of note, establishing a CCE does not mean completely severing ties with the investor-owned utility, given that the utility agency still owns and manages the distribution lines that transmit electrical power to homes and businesses. Further, the utility company still meters each customer's power usage, and continues to send customers their electrical bill. Under the CCE model, what changes is the entity which purchases electricity on behalf of the customer; rather than the utility company performing that role, the responsibility is transferred to the newly-formed local entity. The Orange County Power Authority The City of Irvine led an effort that in December 2020 to create a regional CCE Joint Power Authority named the Orange County Power Authority (OCPA). Currently, the OCPA consists of five (5) City of Huntington Beach Page 3 of 6 Printed on 12/8/2021 oo.vefc428 legistaf - File #: 21-085 MEETING DATE: 2/1/2021 founding member agencies; Buena Park, Fullerton, Irvine, Lake Forest, and Huntington Beach. Additionally, currently there are up to 10 other Orange County cities that are considering joining the OCPA. Of note, the original five members of OCPA, which includes Huntington Beach, are Founding Party Members and automatically placed on the JPA's Executive Committee. Any other agency that joins will be considered Additional Party member. Given the uncertain nature of which agencies are looking to join the JPA, it is difficult to model precise fiscal data for the proposed OCPA entity. However, Irvine has commissioned a detailed fiscal analysis to assess various possible scenario through a 10-year pro forma document, a copy of which is included as an attachment to this report. Per that assessment, the proposed OCPA was identified as being financially viable, with the following key summary findings: • OCPA would be able to repay the City of Irvine's start-up and working capital loans, and build up proper financial reserves, during the first 5-7 years of operation. • After initial debt service costs are repaid, it is estimated that a significant amount of net income will be available to the OCPA for use towards customer program or additional electrical rate discounts. OCPA Financial and Operational Analysis The City Council directed staff to provide a financial analysis of the OCPA and present to the City Council prior to the JPA no-risk opt out deadline. At the City's request, MRW & Associates (MRW) completed an independent analysis of OCPA's financial viability, reviewed the OCPA Implementation Plan, and provide an analysis of risks and benefits if of remaining in the OCPA. MRW's report found that OCPA provides a financially viable option for the City to participate in a CCE with lower risk than establishing a stand-alone CCE with the following key findings: Financial Analysis The MRW independent analysis performed found the OCPA program is financially feasible, confirming that the OCPA's projected margin between the OCPA operating costs to provide power is projected lower than the SCE energy generation rate. This means OCPA will be able to provide energy wither at a lower rate or competitive with SCE. The tightest margins will occur during the first few years of operation and will increase over time. The MRW model projects the margin between OCPA power costs and SCE power costs will start near 1 cent/Kwh, and will increase to over 3.0 cents/kwh over the next 10 years. MRW states that a CCE is feasible, but is not risk-free. OCPA will be participating in a competitive power market and subject to evolving state requirements and regulations. While an OCPA rate discount in the long run should be achievable, market prices and SCE rate volatility could combine to, in some isolated years, occasionally prevent the CCA from offering lower rates than SCE. Implementation Plan MRW found that the OCPA Implementation plan uses assumptions that are generally sound, confirming that the underlying customer phase-in, assumed power prices, operating costs, and City of Huntington Beach Page 4 of 6 Printed on 12/6/2021 p .ercQgl Leg,s:aCl File #: 21-085 MEETING DATE: 2/1/2021 CCA revenues are all reasonable or conservative. MRW stated that they feel the amount of collateral provided by Irvine is lower than what may be required when OCPA secures the financing. Opt-Out Risk Customers may choose to opt-out of a CCA service before, during, or even after a CCE is formed. Most recent CCEs launched have only experienced very modest opt-out rates of around 2-3%. MRW modeled a high opt-out rate of 30%, and even at that level, the CCE remained financially viable. Governance Model Options The MRW evaluation found that joining the a JPA such as the OCPA would provide benefits from increased negotiation and buying power for power purchases, access to better financing terms for borrowing, and operation efficiencies gained by combining management and operating functions such as billing and accounting. The tradeoff to the benefits of joining a JPA are that decision making will be allocated amongst the participating parties as opposed to a single agency entity. A benefit to the OCPA JPA, participating agencies are not required to make any financial contribution. Rather, the City of Irvine has agreed through the JPA agreement to cover all initial start-up costs associate with establishing the new OCPA entity as well as cash collateral up to $5 million for power purchase financing. If the City chose to form a stand-alone CCE enterprise they would be required to fund the start-up capital and financial guarantee. By participating with OCPA, these financial burdens are being met by Irvine and not required of Huntington Beach. Greenhouse Gas (GHG) In order for OCPA to achieve GHG saving, the CCE will be required to acquire energy above the state renewable requirements. This would include purchasing energy from hydroelectric facilities (which is carbon-free but do not qualify as "renewable" under state law) or increase the renewable content of its electricity supply above that required by the state. The MRW independent analysis confirms the OCPA studies and implementation plan is generally sound and that maintaining membership is viable option for the City of Huntington Beach should the Council choose to participate in a CCE. Additionally, maintaining membership in OCPA, will provide the additional benefits of no implementation costs, reduced financial risk and reduced administrative and ongoing management costs. Environmental Status: Not applicable. Strategic Plan Goal: Enhance and maintain high quality City services Attachment(s): 1. Community Choice Energy for the City of Huntington Beach and Review of Orange County Power Authority City of Huntington Beach Page 5 of 6 Printed on 12/8/2021 00vvere43q Legistar'w File #: 21-085 MEETING DATE: 2/1/2021 2. OCPA Implementation Plan 3. Orange County Power Authority Joint Powers Agreement City of Huntington Beach Page 6 of 6 Printed on 121812021 powert431 Leas;ar" ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY Staff Report — Item XX --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- To: Orange County Power Authority Board of Directors From: Brian Probolsky, Chief E%eentlVe Officer Tiffany Law, Chief Financial Officer John Dalessi and Kirby Dusel, Pacific Energy Advisors Max Bernt, NewGen Strategics & Solutions Subject: ADOPT RESOLUTION APPROVING INITIAL OCPA RATE. DESIGN: AUTHORIZE OCPA BASIC RATES ADJUSTMENTS EFFECTIVE APRIL 2022; APPROVE A NET SURPLUS COMPENSATION RATE FOR NET ENERGY NIETERING CUSTOMERS; APPROVE THE ESTABLISHMENT OF MONTHLY BILLING FOR ALL NET ENERGY METERING CUSTOMERS; APPROVE 'ITIE ESTABLISHMENT OF ANNUAL TRUE-UP PERIOD TO APRIL FOR ALL NET ENERGY METERING CUSTOMERS Date: January 11, 2022 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- RECOMNIENDED ACTION I. Approve initial OCPA rates contained in Attachment A (Scenario 3) such that OCPA's Basic Choice rates are set at parity to Southern California Edison ("SCE") rates and all OCPA member auencies will elect Smart Choice as the default service offering. 2. Authorize staff to adjust OCPA Basic Choice rates contained in Attachment A (Scenario 3) as soon as practicable after the SCE March 2022 rate change to maintain rate parity for OCPA Basic Choice customers effective April 2022. Staff-shall place a report on the agenda of the nest regular board meeting explaining the adjustment and requesting that the board ratify the adjusted initial OCPA rates. 3. Approve a Net Surplus Compensation ("NSC") rate for Net Energy Metering ("NENI") customers at 10% above SCE's NSC rate. d. Approve the establishment of monthly settlements and billing for all NEM customers. 5. Approve the establishment of annual true-up period to April for all NFM customers. BACKGROUND The Orange County Powcr Authority ("OCPA") will begin serving its first phase of customers in April 2022. These customers currently receive bundled (generation and delivery) electric service from SCE under a wide varietv of rate schedules, which generally vary based on broad customer end use classifications (e.g., residential,commercial, industrial, agricultural, etc.)and other service characteristics. A rate schedule or "tariff" specifics customer eligibility, describes service terms and conditions, and defines how customers will be charted for electricity consumption and the applicable rates. Each rate schedule includes one or more types of charges, which may include fixed monthly charges, charges based on the total kilowatt-hour ('` li") consumed in a billing period or time-of-use period, or charges based on the highest potential demand the customer could register re_ardless of actual consumption during a billing period. The rate structures applicable to SCE customers range in complexity, with generally simpler structures applicable to residential and other small commercial customers and more complex structures applicable to large commercial and industrial customers. 432 Customers are classified based on end-use and other service characteristics to represent groups of customers with relatively similar cost-of'service profiles. SCE has established 5 customcr classes that include: residential (D),commercial and industrial (GS), agricultural and pumping(PA), street lighting and traffic control (I-S and TC) end uses. Typical end uses within the customer classes are described belo%v: Rate Group Example End Use D General residential uses GS Commercial establishments, industrial factories, electric vehicle fleets, religious facilities PA Agricultural and water or sewage pumping LS Street lighting TC Traffic signals Each rate class has a number of rate schedules that provide options to customers and services for various requirements. In total, there are approximately 190 rate schedules under which customer within the OCPA area currently take service. Once the customers begin receiving generation service from OCPA, the customers will be charged OCPA's rates for generation service and SCE's rates for delivery services. To provide customers with cost parity in their monthly electric bills relative to SCE service, OCPA rates will be lower than the generation rates charged by SCE to offset the inclusion of"certain surcharges or"exit lees" (Cost Responsibility Surcharges) that SCE will apply to OCPA customer bills. These surcharges include the Power Charge Indifference Adjustment ("PCIA"), which is intended to allow SCE to recover certain above market costs of pre-existing generation commitments made on behalf of the customers, and the Franchise Fee Surcharge, which is intended to make SCE whole for reduced franchise fees that would occur when it no longer charges customers for generation services. These surcharges will be applied by SCE to monthIv customer electricity usage of OCPA customers and charged on per kWh basis. The surcharges are included in the monthly electric bill for each customer along with other SCE charges related to electric delivery services as well as OCPA generation charges. Consistent with good utility practice, OCPA rates must provide the revenue needed to operate and sustain a viable utility enterprise. Electric rates are typically designed to recover the revenue requirement projected for a twelve-month "test year." The fiscal year ending June 2023 was used as the test year for ratesettimg purposes, meaning that the rates were designed to recover a revenue requirement consistent with sales and expenditures for the period from July 2022 through June 2023. The proposed rates were designed to yield revenues sufficient to collect OCPA's projected annual power supply and other operating costs, debt service costs, and a planned Rate Stabilization Reserve contribution, which is intended to meet debt service coverage requirements specified in OCPA's credit agreement. The approximately 2% planned reserve contribution reflected in the proposed rates is the minimum necessary to meet debt service coverage requirements ("DSCR") on a pro forma (i.e., projected) basis. The minimum is being proposed to keep OCPA rates as competitive as possible during service commencement: however, setting rates to achieve minimum reserve levels leaves little room far contingencies, and adverse variances on power supply costs or sales revenues during the year could necessitate rate changes. As part of ratesettin_.OCPA must set rate policies for customers who generate their own electricity and participate in the \ENI program. In development of a NEM program recommendation. OCPA reviewed customers' status with the incumbent investor-owned utility ("IOU") and best practices 433 ofconununity choice aggregators ("CCAs") in the Caliliornia region. Financial projections shown assume OCPA follows current SCE NEM practices. In November 2021, SCE updated its Energy Resource Recovery Account ("ERRA") forecasts for CY 2022 electric generation rates and PCIA. These filings mean that implementation of the 2022 SCE rate chanties may be delayed until March 1, 2022. The initial OCPA rates for April 2022 contained in Attachment A are designed based on SCE's November 2021 ERRA forecasts. RATE DESIGN ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION This memorandum discusses three potential rate scenarios to recover the revenue requirement projected for the fiscal year ending .tune 2023, including the recommended scenario to set initial Basic Choice rates at parity to SCE, and all member agencies will be defaulted in the Smart Choice service offering. Each would yield sufficient revenues on a Rorecast basis with a 2% Rate Stabilization Reserve to insulate against market volatility and supply chain issues, but the\, differ in how the revenue requirement is allocated amoni-, customers taking service under the three product offerings. In each scenario, operating costs were projected based on contracts OCPA has executed to date and the expected cost of procuring energy and other wholesale services needed to supply OCPA's customers with the resource mix associated with three energy product offerings: these include the Basic Choice product, which will include 33.5% renewable energy content in 2022 that increases overtime: the Smart Choice product,which will include at least 69%renewable energy content in 2022 that increases over time; and the 100% Renewable Choice product, which will maintain a 100% renewable energy content. The sales projections are adjusted for expected customer opt-out rates and participation rates for each of the three product offerings. Staff recommends that OCPA adopt identical rates' for initial Basic Choice as those offered by SCE, net of surcharges and the PCIA exit fee, so that there will be no change in custo ner's electric bill upon transferrimti to OCPA service. This approach facilitates comparability and focuses the comparison on other factors such as local accountability, customer service, and decarbonization of the electric power supply. This rate design approach is typical for newly formed CCA programs and ensures compatibility with SCE's billing process. OCPA has designed its initial Basic Choice rates, as shown in Attachment A, by subtracting_ the applicable SCE surcharges from the generation service energy changes on each rate schedule. For purposes of this initial rate design, staff used the SCE generation rates and surcharges that are expected to be in effect as of April 1, 2022 when OCPA begins service to its customers. While we anticipate that revisions in SCE generation rates will take place on March 1, 2022, the new SCE rates will not be released to the public until February 2022 when SCE makes a consolidated rate filing with the Commission. Therefore, staff is seeking authorization to adjust OCPA initial Basic Choice rates as soon as practicable after the March 2022 rate change to maintain cost parity ['or OCPA customers. In addition, OCPA will have greater certainty regarding its power supply costs at that time as it will have largely completed its initial power supply contracting efforts. Staff will test the revised rates to ensure they are sufficient to recoverOCPA's revenue requirements. If'slaff assesses that the revised rates would yield sufficient revenues to meet OCPA's revenue requirements, the rates will be put into effect on April 1, 2022 or as soon thereafter as practicable. Otherwise, staff would recommend a rate design revision for the Board's consideration at that lime. OCPA would determine rate schedule eligibility and other general terms of service by mapping each OCPA rate schedule to an equivalent SCE rate schedule; customer contacting SCE to change 'SCE generation rates can be found at: https://www,sce.com/regulatory/tariff-books/rates-pricing-choices 434 rate schedules (e.g., selection of an optional time-of-use rate) would automatically be placed on a corresponding OCPA rate schedule. Other terms of electric service set forth the in otherwise applicable SCE tariff would continue to apply to OCPA customers. Scenario I Overvielc Scenario I sets the initial rates for Basic Choice at a level sullicient to cover OCPA's revenue requirement, with rates for Smart Choice and 100% Renc%vable Choice set at a cost-based premium associated with the additional renewable energy needed to supply these products. Based on current projections, Basic Choice rates would reflect a small premium relative to SCE rates. Scenario I reflects the assumption that the City of Irvine selects Smart Choice as the default product offering, while the other member Cities select Basic Choice as the default product offering. The preliminary rates designed for Scenario I would yield projected revenues of S41.9 million in FY 2022 and S281 .3 million in FY 2023 (the test year), using electric load forecasts reflective of the planned phased-in customer enrollment schedule. The pro forma projections of annual OCPA revenues and expenses for Scenario I are shown in Figure I. Note that the planned Rate Stabilization Reserve contribution is included as a component of the revenue requirement in Section III and that the surplus or deficit shown in section V is net of the reserve contribution. I-or purposes of the pro forma projections, the proposed rates are assumed to be held constant during the tilrecast period and only includes sales associated with the current OCPA member commn uities. Figure l Annual Pro Forma Projections Orange County Power Authority 28-Dec-21 Year Ending: 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 (. Revenue Base Rate Revenue 40,757,364 273,617,989 323,356,372 324,973,154 326,598,020 Product 2 Premium 1,130,262 7,188,705 8,125,434 8,166,061 8,206,891 Product 3 Premium 46,833 466,792 703,621 707,139 710,675 Total Revenue 41,934,459 281,273,486 332,185,427 333,946,354 335,515,586 II.Operating Expenses Power Supply 32,363,764 2.64,289,590 299,356,125 283,470,381 278,613,059 Staff 1,492,926 4,307,170 5,275,180 5,538,938 5,815,885 Mandatory Compliance Mailers 35,483 325,540 581,565 591,761 609,514 Other Operating Expenses 1,638,967 2,367,777 1,436,270 1,473,380 1,517,581 Data Management - 2,066,392 3,229,246 3,245,577 3,456,436 Service Fees 54,626 436,647 527,849 530,468 533,102 Uncol I e cti bl e s/Ocher 209,672 1,406,367 1,660,927 1,669,232 1,677,578 Subtotal Operating Expenses 35,795,438 275,199,484 312,067,161 296,519,737 292,223,155 Operating Margin 6,139,022 6,074,002 20,118,266 37,326,617 43,292,431 III. Financing Interest Payments 234,000 406,800 448,800 429,900 313,800 Principal Payments - - - 3,600,000 7,200,000 Reserve Contribution 838,689 5,625,470 6,643,709 6,676,927 6,710,312 Subtotal Financing 1,072,689 6,032,270 7,092,509 10,706,827 14,224,112 IV.Total Revenue Requirement 36,869,127 281,231,754 319,159,670 307,226,564 306,447,267 V.Surplus/(Deficit) S,066,332 41,732 13,025,757 26,619,790 29,068,319 435 Scenario I Rate Desire The initial OCPA rates for Basic Choice were desig,ned such that each rate component is an equal percentage ofthe corresponding SCE generation rate, after accounting, for the surcharges that SCE_ will assess on customer bills. For customers electing, the Smart Choice product, an additional charge of 0.5 cent per kWh will apply relative to Basic Choice rates. 'I'his premium includes the estimated incremental cost of offering a renewable energy mix of at least 69% in 2022 relative to the 38.5% renewable energy mix of the default Basic Choice product. For customers electing the 100% Renewable Choice product, an additional charge of 1.0 cent per kWh will apply relative to the Basic Choice rates. ']'his premium includes the estimated incremental cost to OCPA of' offering a 100% renewable energy product relative to the 38.5% renewable energy mix of the default Basic Choice product. Scenario / Rill Impacts Current estimates sueg,est that in Scenario I, despite OCPA offering lower generation rates. OCPA customers will face a small bill premium lot Basic Choice service clue to SCE's imposition of the Cost Responsibility Surcharge. I-or a typical residential customer, the bill impacts for the three OCPA product offerim-,s are estimated as follows: Estimated Typical Residential Bill Comparison Basic Choice, 425 KWh Per Month Charge Type OCPA SCE Difference Generation $44.06 $49.96 ($5.90) SCE Surcharges $8.45 $0.00 $8.45 SCE Delivery $64.44 $64.44 $0.00 Total $116.95 $114.40 $2.55 2.2% Estimated Typical Residential Bill Comparison Smart Choice, 425 KWh Per Month Charge Type OCPA SCE Difference Generation $46.18 $49.96 ($3.78) SCE Surcharges $8.45 $0.00 $8AS SCE Delivery $64.44 $64.44 $0.00 Total $119.07 $114.40 $4.67 4.1% Estimated Typical Residential Bill Comparison 100%Renewable Energy Choice, 425 KWh Per Month Charge Type OCPA SCE Difference Generation $48.31 $49.96 ($1.65) SCE Surcharges $8.45 $0.00 $8.45 SCE Delivery $64.44 $64.44 $0.00 Total $121.20 $114.40 $6.80 5.9% 436 Scenario 2 Overview Scenario 2 set the initial rates for Basic Choice at parity to SCE. Rates for Smart Choice and 100% Renewable Choice include a larger premium as compared to Scenario I. which yields revenues necessary [or OCPA to meet its revenue requirements while keeping the rates for Basic Choice at parity to SCE. Scenario 2 reflects the assumption that the City of Irvine selects Smart Choice as the default product offering, while the other member Cities select Basic Choice as the default product offering. The preliminary rates designed for Scenario 2 would yield projected revenues of S42.0 million in FY 2022 and S281 2 million in FY 2023 (the test year), using electric load forecasts reflective of the planned phased-in customer enrollment schedule. The pro forma projections of annual OCPA revenues and expenses for Scenario 2 are shown in Figure 2. Note that the planned Rate Stabilization Reserve contribution is included as a component of the revenue requirement in Section III and that the surplus or deficit shown in section V is net of the reserve contribution. For purposes of the pro forma projections, the proposed rates are assumed to be held constant durine the forecast period and only includes sales associated with current OCPA member agencies. Figure 2 Annual Pro Forma Projections Orange County Power Authority 28-Dec-21 Year Ending: 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 I. Revenue Base Rate Revenue 38,437,322 257,918,362 304,792,176 306,316,137 307,947,717 Product 2 Premium 3,503,811 22,294,987 25,188,945 25,314,789 25,441,363 Product 3 Premium 96,008 956,924 1,442,423 1,449,635 1,456,983 Total Revenue 42,037,142 281,160,272 331,423,444 333,080,561 334,745,964 II.Operating Expenses Power Supply 32,363,764 264,289,590 299,356,125 283,470,381 278,613,059 Staff 1,492,926 4,307,170 5,275,180 5,538,938 5,815,885 Mandatory Compliance Mailers 35,483 325,540 581,565 591,761 609,514 Other Operating Expenses 1,638,967 2,367,777 1,436,270 1,473,380 1,517,581 Data Management - 2,066,392 3,229,246 3,245,577 3,456,436 Service Fees 54,626 436,647 527,949 530,468 533,102 Uncollectibles/Other 210,186 1,405,901 1,657,117 1,665,403 1,673,730 Subtotal Operating Expenses 3S,795,951 275,198,918 312,063,351 296,515,908 292,219,307 Operating Margin 6,241,191 5,961,354 19,360,092 36,564,653 42,526,657 III. Financing Interest Payments 234,000 406,800 448,800 429,900 313,800 Principal Payments - - - 3,600,000 7,200,000 Reserve Contribution 940,743 5,623,205 6,628,469 6,661,611 6,694,919 Subtotal Financing 1,074,743 6,030,005 7,077,269 10,691,511 14,208,719 IV.Total Revenue Requirement 36,870,694 281,228,924 319,140,620 307,207,419 306,428,026 V. Surplus/(Deficit) 5,166,448 (68,652) 12,282,824 25,873,141 28,317,937 437 Scenario 2 Rate Design "I-he initial OCPA rates for Basic Choice were designed for rate parity such that each rate component is equal to the corresponding SCE generation rate, after accounting for the surcharges that SCE will assess on Customer bills. For customers electing the Smart Choice product, an additional charge of 1.55 cents per kWh will apply relative to Basic Choice rates. 'this premium includes the estimated incremental cost of offering a renewable energy mix of at least 69% in 2022 relative to the 38.5% renewable energy mix of the default Basic Choice product plus a 1.05 cents per kWh premium that is necessary for OCPA to meet its revenue requirements while keeping the rates for Basic Choice at parity to SCE. For customers electing the 100% Renewable Choice product, an additional charge of 2.05 cents per k\Vh will apply relative to the Basic Choice rates. "['his premium includes the estimated incremental cost to OCPA of offering a 100% renewable energy product relative to the 38.5% renewable energy mix of the default Basic Choice product plus the same 1.05 cents per kWh revenue sufficiency adder described above for the Smart Choice product. Scenario 2 Bill ltnpacts In Scenario 2, for a typical residential customer, the bill impacts for the three OCPA product offerings are estimated as follows: Estimated Typical Residential Bill Comparison Basic Choice,425 KWh Per Month Charge Type OCPA SCE Difference Generation $41.51 $49.96 ($8.45) SCE Surcharges $8.45 $0.00 $8.45 SCE Delivery $64.44 $64.44 $0.00 Total $114.40 $114.40 $0.00 0.0% Estimated Typical Residential Bill Comparison Smart Choice 425 KWh Per Month Charge Type OCPA SCE Difference Generation $48.10 $49.96 ($1.86) SCE Surcharges $8.45 $0.00 $8.45 SCE Delivery $64.44 $64.44 $0.00 Total $120.99 $114.40 $6.59 5.8% Estimated Typical Residential Bill Comparison 100%Renewable Energy Choice, 425 KWh Per Month Charge Type OCPA SCE Difference Generation $50.23 $49.96 $0.27 SCE Surcharges $8.45 $0.00 $8.45 SCE Delivery $64.44 $64.44 $0.00 Total $123.12 $114.40 $8.72 7.6% 438 Scenario 3 Overview (Recommended) Scenario 3 set the initial rates for Basic Choice at parity to SCE. All member Cities are assumed to elect Smart Choice as the default service offering. This allows for it smaller premium for Smart Choice and 100% Renewable Choice than in Scenario 2, while keeping rates for Basic Choice at parity to SCE. The preliminary rates designed for Scenario 3 would yield projected revenues of S43.0 million in FY 2022 and S287.8 million in FY 2023 (the test year), using electric load forecasts reflective of the planned phased-in customer enrollment schedule. The pro forma projections ol'annual OCPA revenues and expenses for Scenario 3 are shown in I=igure 3. Note that the planned Rate Stabilization Reserve contribution is included as a component of the revenue requirement in Section III and that the surplus or deficit shown in section V is net of the reserve contribution. For purposes of the pro forma projections, the proposed rates are assumed to be held constant during the forecast period and only includes sales associated with the current OCPA member communities. Figure 3 Annual Pro Forma Projections Orange County Power Authority 28-Dec-21 Year Ending: 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 (. Revenue Base Rate Revenue 38,437,322 257,918,362 304,792,176 306,316,137 307,847,717 Product 2 Premium 4,472,587 29,192,591 33,773,802 33,942,671 34,112,384 Product 3 Premium 70,250 700,188 1,055,431 1,060,708 1,066,012 Total Revenue 42,980,160 287,811,140 339,621,409 341,319,516 343,026,114 II.Operating Expenses Power Supply 33,350,068 270,731,553 306,654,750 290,460,773 285,297,989 Staff 1,492,926 4,307,170 5,275,180 5,538,938 5,815,985 Mandatory Compliance Mailers 35,483 325,540 581,565 591,761 609,514 Other Operating Expenses 1,638,967 2,367,777 1,436,270 1,473,380 1,517,581 Data Management - 2,066,392 3,229,246 3,245,577 3,456,436 Service Fees 54,626 436,647 527,849 530,468 533,102 Uncol I ecti bl e s/Other 214,901 1,439,056 1,698,107 1,706,598 1,715,131 Subtotal Operating Expenses 36,786,970 281,674,135 319,402,967 303,547,495 298,945,538 Operating Margin 6,193,189 6,137,005 20,218,442 37,772,021 44,080,575 III. Financing Interest Payments 234,000 406,800 448,800 429,900 313,800 Principal Payments - - - 3,600,000 7,200,000 Reserve Contribution 859,603 5,756,223 6,792,428 6,826,390 6,860,522 Subtotal Financing 1,093,603 6,163,023 7,241,228 10,856,290 14,374,322 IV.Total Revenue Requirement 37,880,574 287,837,157 326,644,195 314,403,785 313,319,861 V.Surplus/(Deficit) 5,D99,586 (26,017) 12,977,214 26,915,731 29,706,253 439 Scenario 3 Rate Desi,n The initial OCPA rates for Basic Choice were designed for rate parity such that each rate component is equal to the corresponding SCE generation rate, after accounting for the surcharges that SCE will assess on customer bills. For customers electing the Smart Choice product, an additional charge of 1 .0 cent per kWh will apply relative to Basic Choice rates. '['his premium includes the estimated incremental cost of offering a renewable energy mix of at least 69% in 2022 relative to the 38.5% renewable energy mix of the default Basic Choice product plus a 0.5 cent per kWh premium that is necessary for OCPA to meet its revenue requirements while keeping the rates for Basic Choice at parity to SCE. For customers electing the 100% Renewable Choice product, an additional charge of 1.5 cents per kWh will apply relative to the Basic Choice rates. This premium includes the estimated incremental cost to OCPA of offering a 1001/0 renewable energy product relative to the 38.5% renewable cnmv mix of the default Basic Choice product plus the same OS cent per kWh revenue sufficiency adder described above for the Smart Choice product. Scenario 3 Bill Impacts In Scenario 3, for a typical residential customer, the bill impacts R>r the three OCPA product offerings are estimated as follows: Estimated Typical Residential Bill Comparison Basic Choice, 425 KWh Per Month Charge Type OCPA SCE Difference Generation $41.51 $49.96 ($8.45) SCE Surcharges $8.45 $0.00 $8.45 SCE Delivery $64.44 $64.44 $0.00 Total $114.40 $114.40 $0.00 0.0% Estimated Typical Residential Bill Comparison Smart Choice,425 KWh Per Month Charge Type OCPA SCE Difference Generation $45.76 $49.96 ($4.20) SCE Surcharges $8.45 $0.00 $8.45 SCE Delivery $64.44 $64.44 $0.00 Total $118.65 $114.40 $4.25 3.7% Estimated Typical Residential Bill Comparison 100%Renewable Energy Choice, 425 KWh Per Month Charge Type OCPA SCE Difference Generation $47.89 $49.96 ($2.07) SCE Surcharges $8.45 $0.00 $8.45 SCE Delivery $64.44 $64.44 $0.00 Total $120.78 $114.40 $6.38 5.6% 440 RATE DESIGN RECOiAINIENDATION Scenario 3 allows for the lowest rate premiums that align with qualitatively superior product offerings (associated with the higher renewable energy content) in the Smart Choice and 100% Renewable Choice products, while allowing for all customers to choose a rate option that costs no more than what they would pay under SCE service. Staff recommends Scenario 3 as the basis of OCPA's initial rate design. with the understanding that rates would need to be revised if members do not choose Smart Choice as the default service offering. The proposed OCPA rates in Attachment A were designed with reference to the SCE generation rates and Cost Responsibilitv Surcharges expected to be in effect as of April 1, 2022 when OCPA begins service to its customers. These rates will be adjusted in March, once SCE published its generation rates that will be effective as of April I. 2022, in order to maintain parity for the Basic Choice product. If tile revised rates are projected to yield insufficient revenues based on the best information available at that time, staff would recommend a rate design revision for the Board's consideration. NET ENERGY METERING ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION Current SCE NEM customers are subject to rules set by the Commission. Under current SCE policies. NEM customers are billed once a year for their enemy usage and are either charged for any net usage or are provided a credit for surplus net generation based on their energy usage and Generation over the course of the prior year. Surplus generation is compensated at a net surplus compensation ("NSC") rate that is set monthly and is generally based on the market value of power. In 2021. the average SCE NSC rate was 3.034 cents/kWh. Initial estimates of OCPA's system indicate that approximately 25% of NEM customers generate more energy than they use. In 2019, it is estimated that 14,350 MWhs were generated in surplus by NEM customers that would be subject to NSC rates and would receive approximately S435.000 in NSC credits based on 2021 NSC rates. CCAs are not subject to the Commission NEM rules which arc strictly set for the state's IOUs. As a matter of practice, most CCAs support local renewable energy production and have adopted rules than replicate IOU practices and often provide additional benefits to NEM customers. The most common benefits include higher NSC rates and monthly billing. Higher NSC rates result in greater compensation to customers that generate surplus energy and represents a low-cost way to signal the CCA's support of local solar. Monthly billing provides better cash flow planning for both the utility and customers as opposed to annual bills which can result in unexpectedly high bills fur some customers. As part of monthly billing, most CCAs perform an annual true-up in April for all NEM customers as this month best aligns with NEM kWh banking procedures. NET ENERGY METERING RECOMMENDATION Providing NEM customers that generally replicates the current incumbent IOU NEM program allows for customer rate stability and an easier transition to OCPA and is defensible as the IOU NEM program has been approved by the Commission. Staff recommends approving the following improvements Irom the incumbent IOU NEM program which were discussed previously in the Net Energy Metering Analysis and Discussion section: I . Set NSC rate at 10% above the incumbent IOU NSC rate 2. Provide monthly billing to NEM customers 3. Set all custom u ers annal trot-up period to April StafTwill develop a prospective NEM Program consistent with the incumbent IOU NEM program in preparation for OCPA's launch in April 2022 for the Board's adoption in February 2022. 441 FISCAL IMPACT Adoption ol'ratc design (Scenario 3) mould ,yield projected surplus (nct of Rate Stabilization Reserve) of S5.1 million in FY 2022 and projected delicit of S26,000 (due to rounding) in FY 2023. Approval of the proposed 10% adder to the IOU NSC rate for the NE-M program will result in additional cost of appro.ximatcly S45,000/year once all SCE customers have enrolled into OCPA service. ATTACIIMENT Attachment A: Preliminary OCPA Rates EFfective April 1, 2022 442 DRAFT ATTACHMENT A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY I"OCPA") APRIL 2022 PROPOSED RATES Percent Rat. SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE•CCA Difference 3022 2022 TOTAL 2022 UNIT/PERIOD 2022 M22 CCA RATE RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNIT/PERIOD PROPOSED GENERATION 2022 FRANCHISE CCA ve SCE DESCRIPTION RATE RATE SURCHARGES CTC PCIA FEES SURCHARGES RESIDENTIAL CUSTOMERS DOMESTIC(0) DOMESTIC ID) ENERGY CHARGE IS/KV All Usage All Usage 0.09762 0.1175a 001987 (Oool 0.01899 OW107 0.1125A OW% 00MESTIC CARE TO CARE) DOMESTIC I GLARE) ENERGY CHARGE(SMV All Usage All UsuBo 0.0762 0.117!A 001982 (000019) 001899 OW107 0.11754 000% TOU-O-A(GF) TOU-D-A fGF) ENERGY CHARGE(S!K WH) SUMMER June 1 Inman Seplember 30 2.00 Pm.to 8.GO P an kd.0 except PEAK holWy, 0.26986 029133 002146 TO.OD019) 001899 0002W 0.29133 D.00% Al sother than Peak a upor OFF-PEAK Peak 0.07991 009962 0.01971 (0.00019) 001899 0OW91 000962 0.00% SUPER OFF PEAK 1000pm.10800am.allyeageveryaay 005248 0076N 001950 (0.00019) 0018% O.UD020 0.076M 000% J.rh ary I through May 31 aM Ooral 1 VJINT R threugn Decmmbm JI 21]0 p m,m 8 W u m.kaaye except PEAK wwa,a 0.15125 0.17212 002037 (000019) 0018W 000157 0.17217 0W% 15 Mm than P..L.aM upar OFF-PEAK Peak 0A6205 0086(i5 0(1959 (000019) 0.018W 0.00079 0.08665 000% SUPER OFF-PEAK 10 CRT an to a 00 a m.all,oat.over,day 0.OW72 0.02824 001952 (000019) 001899 000072 0.02824 000% BASELINE CREDIT - 000000 - - aDIVID, TOU O BOF) TOU-13.0(GF) ENERGY CHARGE ISIKWHI S MM' June I tnrouan Se0lember 30 2'.00 Pm.to 8 00 Pro aeekdeye e•Cept PEAK Mlbaye O.40M9 042659 002220 no ooci19) 0.0189E 000390 042859 a00% Pa,I of 20 Note.OCPA 2022 ProP05ce RateS have been designed based on SCE'a November 2021 Energy Resource Recovery Account(ERRA)forecasts for 2022 electric generation rates ano PCIA. DRAFT 443 OMIT ATTACHMCNT A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY I.00PA") APRIL 2022 PROPOSED RATES Percent R.I. SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE•CCA Differunco UNITIPERIO 2022 2022 TOTAL M22 RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNITIPERIOD PROPOSED GENERATION 2022 0 M22 2022 FRANCHISE CCA va BCE CCA RATE DESCRIPTION RATE RATE SURCHARGES CTC PCIA FEES SURCHARGES n ourel Nan eak am um OFF-PEAK Peak 0.07991 009962 001971 (0.00019) 001899 000091 0099(12 000%. SUPER OFF-PEAK 10 DO P In,to 8Do a m.all year,every day 0.02670 0N592 001922 1000019) 0010% 000042 0045W 0.00% January 10pmgh May 31 and O oPer 1 WINTER thlougPDecemhm 31 p m.17�o��m.wee ayaf e� PEAK hold., 0.11950 0.1399 002008 (0."19) 0018% 0 W126 0.13957 O W% YI901 tl! Jn ea aM u, OFF-PEAK Peak 0.06205 a 09005 0.01959 to 00019) 0.018% 0 00079 a 08665 a 00% SUPER OFF PEAK fO W p m.to 800a at ell year,every day 0.02245 004068 001923 (0.00019) 00iato 000043 aN668 000% IOU O-T(GF) TOU-D I(GF) ENERGY CHARGE ITIKWH) SUMMER Jura,1 thaudh 5voluralam 30 12'.00 p m.to 6 W If m.summer am mntm TIER I PEAK '.eekda,a except robeaya 0.13802 0.15826 0.02025 to 00019) 0.018% 0W145 a15826 000% TIER I OFF-PEAK All Wnm noun-all yur.everyday 0.12376 0.14W 0.02012 (0 00019) 001899 0W132 0.14388 000% 12.00 pm.In 600 p m.summer am vnntm TIER 2 PEAK xcekd.p except holidays 0.13802 0.15fln 0.02025 (0.00019) 0.01899 OW145 0.15826 a00% TIER 2OFF-PEAK Al inner Pours-all year.cyeryday 0.12376 0.14398 002012 t0.DD919) 001899 00002 0.14W 000% January 1 1N0ugn May 31 am Onaaer 1 WINTER through Decemayr 31 12 00 pm,to 6 Do p m.flair a and winter TIER I PEAK vw.royda,ceoe vt mtdaya 0.08272 010751 0.01978 tO00019) 0018N 000098 0.10751 0.00% TIER I OFF-PEAK AD other noun-all Ye al,everyday 0.0I805 009274 0.01969 to 00019) 0.018W 0OD089 00774 0.00% 12:W n m,to 6 W p In.summer am winter TIER 2PEAK vmckdays o.oed mlklaya 0.08772 0.10711 001978 t0.too 19) 001899 000096 0.10751 000% TIER 2OFF-PEAK All other mws-all year,overyday 0.07805 009774 0.01%9 to 00019) 0.01899 0OW89 0.08774 0.Go% TOU.D.PRIME TOU D-PRIME ENERGY CHARGE(32KW H) SUMMER Jura I through SnptomPer 30 Page 2 of 20 DRAFT 444 DRAFT ATTACHMENT A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY("OCPA"I APRIL M22 PROPOSED RATES P...am Rate SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE•CCA Dltfia nee 2022 2022 TOTAL 2022 UNITIPERI00 3033 CHAR RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNITIPERIOD PROPOSED GENERATION CHAR FRANCHISE CCA RATE CCA vs SCE DESCRIPTION RATE RATE SURCHARGES CTC PCIA FEES SURCHARGES 4 00 p m.to 9 00 0 al.gamma weekdays PEA, h.oept men., 0.26940 0.29066 002146 (0000191 001899 0.00266 0.29p86 000% MID PEAK 4:00 p m.to 9000 M.SUmmot wcaknwg 0.12801 0.14817 002015 (0.00019I 001899 000135 0.14817 000% OFF.PEAK All here ether than Peak am Mid Pak 0.04939 005882 0.01043 1000019) 0018% 0.D0063 006882 00D% January 1 through May 31 am OCtuMr 1 WINTER Nrou9h Deranimr]I 4. P m.l water weekdays am MID PEAK weekamS 0.22503 024W D02105 t000019) 0018N 0W225 024608 000% All hours Few,Than on n uper OFF-PEAK Peak 0.04421 0M359 001938 (0"19) 001899 000058 0.W359 0001c a.m.to 3:004 m.winta wuctd.,um SUPER OFF-PEAK weekeras 0.04421 aW350 001038 (000019) 001899 000058 0W359 000% TOU-04109 TOU.134to9 ENERGY CHARGE(LKWID SUMMER Jum 1 N'2 SePhmWer 30 4—bb a.m.m R4 p m.aummor woo da, PEAK e,eept mod., 0,20667 022755 0.020M (000019) a01899 000208 022755 0.0D% MID PEAK 4'00 p an.1.9:00 p an....,at we F.Fee 00301 0.11285 0.01983 (000019) 0018W 000103 0,11285 0.00% OFF-PEAK All mars other than PeaA am MO Peak 0,07027 0.00%9 0.01962 1000019) 0018�, 000082 008989 000% January t Un0ugh May 31 am OOt000r 1 WINTER IT Ducemcer]t 4' p.m.m pm,vnnta wee aya na MID PEAK w keens 0.13345 0.15305 002021 10000191 0018% OW141 0.15365 000% Ail inure otleaT than MW.NeaTaa ups OFF PEAK Peak (09155 011137 001982 to"191 001899 0W102 0,11132 000% an 3 00 pm.wmtor waeA ayes SUPER OFF-PEAK weekema 0,06592 0055W 0.D1958 (0.000191 0.018W 0.00028 0085W 00D% TOU.D.51o8 TOU-0-5to6 ENERGY CHARGE(LKWH) SUMMER June 1 through Salaornmr 30 Page 3 0120 DRAFT 445 DRAFT ATTACHMENT A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY I"OCPA") APRIL 2022 PROPOSED RATES Porconl Rate SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE•CCA Difforonco UNITIPERIO 2022 2022 TOTAL M22 RAT SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNITIPERIOD PROPOSED GENERATION 2022 D M22 2023 FRANCHISE CCA RATE- DESCRIPTION SCE DESCRIPTION RATE RATE SURCHARGES CTC PCIA FEES SURCHARGES 5'W p m.10 8.W p m.summer weekdays PEAK e.cept nandaye 0.33901 0.36111 002210 10"191 001699 0W3W 0.30111 0.00% Rm.10 8 00 P.m,mole,wee y5 arct MID PEAK summer mg!..let vee4ends 0.15650 0.17692 002 2 1000D10) 001890 000162 0.17692 0.00% p m.to D To summer weekdays OFF-PEAK AM ImWB 0.0037 0077H 001951 10.00019) 0.01899 0.OD071 002268 01%Ms January I poou0n May 31 and OcttTer I WINTER mrou nDec_ r31 p m.Ip p m,mnte,wee eaq a MID-PEAK summe,aw to, ,eeke" 0 M825 022914 0.02090 G oot 19) 0.01899 0 W210 022914 000% pm.to 8 00 a m. mote,weekdays arid OFF PEAK vsekends O.OS721 0.10699 001928 (000010) 0.018% 000008 0.1W99 000Y. a m.to 5.00 pm-motor weekdays am SUPER OFF PEAK x kcnds 0,05632 002561 0.01949 (O.DDO19) 0.01899 0.WW9 0.07MI 000% COMMERCIAL INDUSTRIAL AGRICULTURALN NSERVICE T M R TOU-EV.2 E TOU-EV T E ENERGY CHARGE(LKWH) SUMMIER June 1 mtamn Seplem0or 30 4'0)pm.W9'Wpm,Summerw kdays PEAK incept ndtlays 0.27244 029462 001723 (0 00015) 0.01469 0.W269 029462 000% MID-PEAK 4.Wpm.to9.Wpm.aunmerveekems 0.14083 0.15681 001592 (000015) D.01469 OW143 OASG81 OW% OFF-PEAK All(rows omer loan Peak am MO-Peak 0.09528 0.11063 0 01555 (000015) 0.01469 000101 0.11083 O W% January I Uecu9n May 31 and DpOSw 1 WINTER Imou9n D ter 31 PEAK All Wets emer Man MVYPeak am OB-Peak 0.16523 0.16143 001620 (00W15) 001469 OW1W 0.10143 000% 400pun.togWpnn,mnterwsckdayeam MID-PEAK weekends 0.08548 0.1W95 001546 (0 W015) 001469 0.WW2 0.1DD)5 000% p m.W 8 00am.mote,wee eyed OFF PEAK wvekams 0.04081 0D5586 0.01505 (0.00015) 0.01469 00 151 O06586 000% TOU EV4-D TOILEVd.D Page 4 of 2D DRAFT 446 DAM ATTACHMENT A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY("OCPA") APRIL 2622 PROPOSED RATES Parcunl Rate SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE•CCA 011l4mnco UNITIPERIOD 2022 M22 TOTAL 2622 2022 2022 CIA RATE RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNITIPERIOD PROPOSED GENERATION 2622 FRANCHISE CCA vs SCE DESCRIPTION RATE RATE SURCHARGES CTC PCIA FEES SURCHARGES ENERGY CHARGE($JKYJH) SUMMER June I lllrwon Semornwr 30 4100 p m.10 9 W p m.summer.l arlys PEAK mcePt heard., 0.27746 0.29467 0.01723 JO"151 001469 0W269 029467 OOOY. MID PEAK 4.00 p.nt.1p 900 p m.summer wnakenas 0,14083 0.15681 001592 10D 15) 001469 0W143 0.15681 000% OFF-PEAK All hours rather tnon Peak reW Mki Peak 0,09528 0.11083 001555 (0000151 001469 000101 0IIN3 000% January 1 0r0wh May 31 and Oclauer I WINTER through DecOmGer 31 PEAK All Mots oure(man Mia Peak are 0l6Peak 0.16523 0.18143 001620 IO OO 15) 00140 000166 018143 Owls 4.00 p m.Ip 9 00 pm.venter 67mkdays am MID-PEAK ka.. 0,mw a1()0()5 001548 (0OOD15) 001469 000002 0.10095 000% p.m.Io 8 00 a.m.winter weekd.,are OFF-PEAK rwek.hd. 0.04081 0.05588 0015 1000015) 0.01469 000051 0A5586 000% TOU EV-a TOU-EV-0 ENERGY CHARGE ISIKWH) SUMMER Jude 1 IhrMgth 5e9lemper 30 4p0 p m.to 9.W p m,summer weLkd., PEAK evwot hoedays 0.31522 039359 001832 10.00015) 0.01492 0W360 039359 010 MID PEAK 4Wpm.e9.00pm.vunrmor.wekonaa 0.087114 0.103G6 001522 (O 00015) 001492 0W005 0103M 000% OFF-PEAK All more carer man Peak are Mid-Peak 0.06101 008253 001652 (000015) 0.01492 000075 008253 000% January 1 through May 31 are Otlote 1 WINTER Ithrw9h Decemner 31 PEAK All hours other Ilan Mad-Peak anei Otl-Peak 0.13737 0.15354 0.01617 (0 00015) 001492 0 W140 0.15354 0.00% 4.00 re m.to 9 00 p in wmler weekdays are MID-PEAK k.we 0.07084 009448 001503 1000015) D01492 000006 01948 0.00Y. pm W800am.wvlara wee an are OFF-PEAK wegkene. 0.03241 004761 001521 (9OD0151 0.01492 000044 O04761 aim TOU-IsSEC.R OF) TOU41-SEC-R IGF) ENERGY CHARGE(W..NH) Page 5 a120 DRAFT 447 OflAIT ATTACHM IN A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY I-OCPA') APRIL M22 PROPOSED RATES Percent Ram SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE•CCA DlffOance 3022 2022 TOTAL 2022 DNITIPERIOD 2032 3023 RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNITIPERIOD PROPOSED GENERATION 2023 FRANCHISE CCA RATE CCA y.SCE DESCRIPTION RATE RATE SURCHARGES CTC PCIA FEES SURCHARGES SUMMER June I ihmrah Seotomoor 30 12 00.1.6 0o p an summer weekday. PEAK cxccpl hdll., 0.25762 028413 001631 (0 OW 14) 0111 W5 000260 0.28413 000% 8.W a.m.1.12:GO noon and 6 OD p m.to 11 00 p an summon vmok days excnpt MID PEAK holidaw 0.10229 0.11707 0.01478 (0WDI4) 001385 OW107 0.11107 0.00% OFF PEAK An hours other than Peak mat MW Peak 0,04964 006364 001429 IT"W) 001385 000058 006384 0.00% January 1 through MOy 31 arW Octpoer I WINTER through Decemeer 31 0 W a on to 9 M p on,winter weekdays MID PEAK .wept holiday. a0T345 0W797 001451 (0.000141 001385 000080 0.W797 000% OFF-PEAK All lwurs pmor than MW.Poak 0.(P037 00545E 001421 IO"141 001385 0.00050 00545E 0O TOO SEC E TOUE-SEC.E ENERGY @LARGE($JK\VH) MM R June I through Sepmrnder 30 4 W p an to 9A0 p an summer waekdays PEAK except holidays 0.37841 0.39372 001231 10"141 001385 0.00360 0.39372 00 MID PEAK 4 GO p.m.to 9:00 p an summer weekends 0.07570 0.09024 001454 1000014) 0.01385 0.00083 0M24 000% OFF PEAK All hours other dun Peak mW Mid Peak 0.04317 0.05741 001423 1000014) 001385 00W52 0.05741 0.00% January I through May 31..Ocmonr I WINTER (Wargo DecernMr 31 4'GO p m.to 9:W p an venter venkdaye and MID-PEAK w kohde 0.iow 0.12135 001482 111"14) 001385 owill 0.12125 0D0% All hour. me,than M.W Peak,am Super Off OFFPEAK Peak 0.04903 009332 001429 (000014) 0.01385 0.00058 0W332 0W% 800 a.m.W 300 p m,.tinter veeFdaye oho SUPER OFF-PEAK weekehos 0.02650 0p4058 00140E (0 O(014) 0.01385 00p033 0.0405E OW% 4:DO p.m.m 9:00 p m.vane,weekdays DEMAND CHARGE(LKY$UMMER TR PEAK excopt hcitlays 6.08 6.13 a05M 005609 6.13432 0.00% 4:0)p m.to 9:CD p m.wvnee rmakdayn aM WINTER TR MID�PEAK -weekends 1.14 IA5 001050 - 001050 1,14787 000% TOU-8 SEC-D TOU41-SEC D Page 6 0120 DRAFT 448 DRAFT ATTACFIMFNT A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY F'OCPA") APRIL 2022 PROPOSED RATES Percent Rate SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE•CCA Difference UNRIPERIOD 3022 2022 TOTAL 2022 2027 N22 CCA RATE RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNITIPERIOD PROPOSED GENERATION 2022 FMNCHISE CCA vs SCE DESCRIPTION RATE RATE SURCHARGES CTC PCIA FEES SURCHARGES ENERGY CHARGE.(III(WH) SUMMER Juno 1 through Seplemate M 4 W p re to 9 W p an,summer weakddys PEAK e.capl head., 0.08572 0.1W35 0.01463 (0000f4) 001M5 000092 D,IW35 0.M!mi MID PEAK 4:W pre to 9 W p.m,summer yeakereat O.D2520 0(YMM 001454 (DAD(I4) 0.DIM5 0 WW3 0OW24 0M`14 OFF PEAK All lours other than Peak am Mal-Peak 0"312 0M741 0.01423 (00W14) 001305 000052 005741 0W% January 1 though May 31 anal Celoaer 1 WINTER Ilvough Dacbmaer 31 4 W p m,to 9 W P m,wantor weekdays acl MID PEAK weekhm. D.06101 0.02641 0.01440 (0.W014) 00IM5 0D0069 0075I1 0M% All Mum wee,than MA-Peak aM Super Off. OFF PEAK Peak 0.04903 0063R 0.01429 (0 WO 14) 001W5 000058 006332 0W% 6:W a m.w 3 W P m.wnlM xCpkday6 dM SUPER OFF PEAK vmekeot, 0.026W 0040511 0.014M (0 MOW 00IM5 0000.P 0.04058 0W% .W pm.to 9 W p m.summer wp,kday6 DEI.WNDCHARGE(YK,SUMMER TR PEAK e.cepth Me, 27.53 22]8 0254D5 0.25405 22]8343 000% 4'.W pm.a 9 W P m.winter weekdays aM WINTER TR MID PEAK sa,ekohas 5,38 543 004966 - 004105(1 54W29 0W% TOU-&PRI-D TOU41-PR60 ENERGY CHARGE(VKWH) SU ME Juno 1 hrough Seplemcer 30 4 W P he 10 9.W p m.swam,weekdays PEAK e..Pt haoutye 0.W135 OWSW 001425 (000014) 001352 000062 0.W5W 0M,16 MID PEAK 4 W Pm.109:W p m.summon yeakenus 0.07181 OWS(8 0.01417 JO"14) 001352 0OW79 0.08598 0W% OFF-PEAK All hours almer than Peak and Mkt Peak 0.04099 a 0`a482 001388 (0.W014) 001352 000050 0.05482 O W% January 1 throuDh May 31 aM OCloher I 'NNTER hvough Oecemher 31 400 p.re to 9:W p an...far wvokda,a oho ACID PEAK veekends 0.05806 002210 0014(l4 (D.O(14) 0.01M2 0MM(l 002210 0M% All hours other than Mid Peak aM Super OIL OFF-PEAK Peak 0.04657 0OW51 001393 (D"14) 0.Dl3 2 0OW65 0"51 0W% 8 We an.to 3 W p re valuer weekdays aM SUPER OFF-PEAK reekenas OMW5 003829 001323 (000014) 001M2 0W035 003829 0.M`% Page 2 of 20 DRAFT 449 DRAFT ATTACHMI NI A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY I.OCPA') APRIL 2022 PROPOSED RATES Percent Rate SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE-CCA Difference 2022 2022 TOTAL 2022 UNICRIPTOD CTC 2022 CCA RATE• RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNIT(PERIOD DESCRIPTION PROPOSED GENERATION HA CTC PCIA FRANCHISE SURCHARGES CCA vs SCE RATE RATE SURCHARGES FEES 40D p.m.10 9 w p m...Amer ka., DEMAND CHARGE ILK\SUMMER TR PEAK except ndwaye 27.41 2767 0.252% - 025298 27 3652E 0.00% 4:00 p m.to 0 00 4 m,minor wAeknale am WINTER TR PAID PEAK vwnkcnos 5.79 585 005347 - - 005347 584245 000% TOU-PA 2-A IGF1 TOU-PA-2-A(GF) ENERGY CHARGE ILKV:H) SUMMER June I It...an SepAnnner 30 12:DO roan to 6:00 p.m.wm.,won d., PEAK e.m0l lWMaya 0.26115 D22242 0D1627 (0"14) OD1387 00@54 027242 000% B 00 a m.to 12 X roan anti 6.00 In m.Ip I IN p At bummer weakoays...Al MID PEAK Oolways 0.10040 0.11518 001478 R)00014) 00IM7 0.wim 0,11518 0.00% OFF PEAK A6 noms doer Nan Peak AM Mw-Peak 0.05 30 007269 0.01439 10000141 001307 0.0006E 0.07269 0.00Y. January 1 tnru M May 31 anti OFlooar 1 Y4N ER through D oar 31 800am.tol2.00romaM6.00pm.w I I'm p m...i.l weekdays excerpt MID PEAK Mina, 0.08303 0.O765 001462 (000014) 0.01382 0. 19 0.00766 DOD% OFF-PEAK All M.I.otlmr tan Mb Peak o.04986 0.06417 001432 G1=14( 001382 0.00059 0116417 000% TOU-PA-2 0(GF) TOU.PA4-13(GF) ENERGY CHARGE(LKWIR SUMMER JAM l lnrouan Sooernoer 30 12.00 noon to 6 GO A An summer w ,, ays PEAK MIT,ndway 0.066" 0080TT 0.01442 (000014) 0.01MI 000074 OOBOTT 000% MIT, . noon aM600pm.to 11:00 p m.summm wektiay6 o•cetH MID PEAK rmMaye 0.06026 002482 0.01441 10."14) 0013B2 000DFiB 007467 000% OFF-PEAK All nuns Who,thin Peak AM Mp-Peak 0.05830 0072% 001439 (0000141 00IM7 000086 007269 000% January I tnrou0o MAY 31 aM Odd1a 1 WINTER lnroe9n()a1Y116Br 31 B:90 A m.10 1200 noon an0li M p m,to 11'.00 p m summer wAnktiaya exmpl MID PEAK Iww.p 0.NW3 009766 001462 1000014) 001387 0.000B9 am7w 000% Page 8 of 20 DRAFT 450 DmrT ATTACHMENT A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY(-OCPA-) APRIL M22 PROPOSED RATES Percent Rate SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE•CCA Dltloronco 2022 2022 TOTAL M22M22 UNICRIPT 00 CTC 2022 CCA RATE RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNITIPERIOD PROPOSED GENERATION HA FRANCHISE CCA ve SCE DESCRIPTION RATE RATE SURCHARGES GTC PCIA FEES SURCHARGES OFF-PEAK AB!pure Wee Nan Mal Peak 0.(49B6 006a12 001432 IO W014) 001302 0M59 0.06412 0.00% l2:0Dmmlo6:Wpm.Sumnerw ,days DEMANDCRARGE(9 SUMMERTR PEAK p¢apt lWldays 11.69 llw 0.107M 0.107M 1179609 0.00% 8:00 a m.to 12.CO men am 6 W p of to 11:00 Pm.summer w udays except SUMMER TR MID-PEAK holidays 3.57 361 0W292 - 003292 3Wfil2 000% TOU-PA 2 E41a0 TOU.PA.2.E4to9 ENERGY CHARGE(5 Vll) SUMMER Jure 1 Nrugn Septemoei W 4: D m.to Rof wmmor wee days PEAK ..TcptnWdnya 0.409W 042%3 001263 (0.00014) 001387 0W390 042693 000% MID PEAK 4 W p to 10 SW p.m.Summer weektms OW439 009895 00140 1000014) 0.01387 0(WK) 0.09895 OW% OFF-PEAK All M1oes otter Non Peak am Mid-Peak 005236 0.06620 001434 (0000141 0013B7 000O(1 006620 000X January 1 InrMyO May 31 am OGOeer 1 WINTER tNougM1 Daanrtet]1 T wp,m.10 D.m.venter xce. ayA aM MID PEAK k.W. 0.W291 0.M753 0014U (0 01)014) 0.01382 000089 0W753 000% All urs otter Nan Mid.Pw an user OFF-PEAK Peak 0A6317 0.02261 001w4 (00(014) 0.0138T 000071 007761 000% m,to 3:00 p to ware! tclays a SUPER OFF-PEAK .wekceos 0.05193 0.06622 0.01434 (000014) 001382 000061 0D6622 000% TOU PA 2 04to9 TOU.PA.2.D41o9 ENERGY CHARGE(SIKYM) SUMMER Juno 1 Nrapn Septam0er 30 4- 9 PEAK e.wpl Ndidaya 0.09529 0.11W2 001424 100W14) 0.0138T OWIDI 0.1IM2 0 M MID-PEAK 4 W P m.to 9.W Pm.nunam,wdekes D.0S432 0.W895 00te63 (000014) 0.O13B2 0.00090 009895 000% OFF-PEAK All hours otter tlen Peak aid Mid.Poak 005236 0.06670 001434 (00W14) 001]B2 001=1 0.0(3670 0.00% Jamary 1 INIough May 31 and Octooer I WINTER through Decemoel 31 Page 9 of 20 DRAFT 451 ORA" ATTACHMENT A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY 1"OCPA") APRIL 2022 PROPOSED RATES Portent Rate SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE•CCA DIR,,,rnce UNITIPERIO 0 2022 N22 TOTAL M22 M22 2022 CCA RATE• RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNITIPERIOD PROPOSED GENERATION 2022 FRANCHISE CCA va SCE DESCRIPTION RATE RATE SURCHARGES CTC PCIA FEES SURCHARGES 4,00 p m,t0 9.00 p To,renter weekdpys am MID PEAK -eakeMs 006979 008429 001450 IO OOO141 DOt]8] 0000]] 004R429 000Y. All taws other than h1d ea am uppr OFF-PEAK Poak 0.05274 0.0t 0.0143a 10000141 00I387 000081 006708 a00% RI)Oam R,300por,morwee can am SUPER OFF PEAK weekem; 0.04301 005]2] 001425 10 Owl41 DOI387 00W52 005]2] a00% 4 OO Pm.to 9 CO p or summer weekdays - DEMAND CHARGE 151K4 SUMMER TR PEA K xcept Rubc.a 1547526 1562 0,14281 - 0.14281 1561807 0.00% 4 00 p.m.to 900 o.m.winter weekdays am WINTER TRMID PEAK weekends 2.71761 274 002508 002506 2742N 000% TOO PA 2-ESIoff TOU PA-2-E5to8 ENERGY CHARGE(MK H) SUMMER June t thr n SB temmr 30 pm.10bummer Kaml PEAK o.cept Wall, 0.66699 068700 0.02001 10.000l 41 001387 000626 0M700 00(% MID PEAK 4.00 p.m.10 900 p.m.summer weekema 0,14213 0.15730 001517 10"141 001387 0W144 0.157X 00096 OFF-PEAK All hWrb other than Peak am Mol Peak. 0.05278 0.M712 001434 10.00014) 001381 000081 0W712 000% January I through May 31 am Odo6or 1 VANIER Inrougn Oecem6o1J1 4-�D nt�to D m.wimer wee days am MID�PEAK mtekams 0.011 4 0.09803 0.Ota63 a00014) 001387 000090 0M803 0.00% nouns inner Nan 0 eak am uper OFF-PEAK Peak 0.0835(1 007800 0014. a00014) 001387 000071 0078M 0001,1, e or Io 3 00 am.meter weekdays am SUPER OFF-PEAK w0ekama 0,05227 006651 0.01434 aGOO14) 0.01387 0.00061 006661 O.00Y. TOU.PA-2.D51m TOU-PA-2-05toe ENERGY CHARGE(II H) SUMIAL June 1 fh,2 Sopfoq ML W 4 109�p or summer wMkdays PEAK encept hood., 0.16091 0.1]626 001534 10.000141 OOt 38] 0.W161 O.R626 OOOY. MID-PEAK 4 W p m.to 9'.00 p m.summer w krmas 0. 4213 0.157M 00151] 10.00014) 00138] 000144 0.157M 000% Page 10 of 20 DRAFT 452 ORATT ATTACHMENT A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY Y'OCPA'T APRIL M22 PROPOSED RATES Porennt Rate SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE•CCA Difference 2022 2022 TOTAL 2022 UNITIPERI00 2022 2022 RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNITIPERIOD PROPOSED GENERATION FRANCHISE LCA va SCE DESCRIPTION RATE RATE SURCHARGES CCA RATE CTC PLIA FEES SURCHARGES OFF PEAK AM are outer titan Peak aw 1,1041.1, 0,05278 0W212 001434 (00W14) 00IM7 0W0C1 0W712 000% January 10rough May 31 am Cnmour 1 'MNTER Ihp Decemoer 31 4 p m.to p m w+ntm woe ayeaya nit IAID.PE4K ' kems 0.07023 0(18423 001450 (000014) 001362 000022 008473 000% All fpurs arttet than MM Pa. ane umt OFF-PEAK Peak 0.05308 005242 001435 (00W 141 001381 000062 0W742 a(M m.to 3 00pm.winterwuek aye.t SUPER OFF-PEAK a kows 0.04331 005752 001426 (0.000141 001381 0.00053 0.05757 000Y. 4'.W p M.to 9 W In m.summer y kdaya DEMAND CHARGE($1K%SOIAMCR TR PEAK except holidays 15.47526 15G2 0,14281 - 014281 1561807 0(V% 4'.W p.m.to 9 W p.m.'earner weekdays am WINTER TR MID PEAK weefaw. 2.80568 2.B3 0.02M9 - 002589 283157 Ol%MA TOU PA S-A)GF) TOU PA-3-A IGF) ENERGY CHARGE($KWH) SUMMER June 11hrou9h Septum6pr M 12.W won to 6 W p in,summer y kdays PEAK except holidays 0.24265 0.2M26 OO1%1 10"131 0013M 0DI 025826 000X B.W a n.to 12.W noon aPd 6'.W p.m.10 11 W pan summery kdays exwpt M.ID.PEAK w'2 a 0.08495 0.090 001416 (0"13) 0 0000.013M 0. 1 0.09900 0Or OFF-PEAK All spun 90 other than wk amp Mq-Pock O"Boo 0W242 OO1M2 10."13) 0.013M 0. 7 OW242 000% January I through May 31 am Octoteer 1 WINTER t1ruou9h December 31 B.W a m.to 12.W noon pw 6:W p m.to 11.W p an aurwlel afeekGa,incept MID.PEAK lwlidays 0,06839 0W240 0014M 10"13) 0013M 000075 0.W240 000% OFF PEAK All We,.other than rare Peak 0.04164 a05550 001326 (0"13) 0.01338 0.00051 0.05560 000% TOU.PA.3 DIGF) TOU-PAJ.R OF) ENERGY CHARGE(SIMM1) SUMMER June 1 Ntmph swtemlaty w 12,00 rpm to 6 W D m.summer vicekd'ays PEAK e.wg ho4]ays 0,05542 OW93(i OO1368 D(MH3) 0.01338 000063 OW936 000% Page 13 of 20 DRAB 453 ORA" ATTACHMENT ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY("OCPA") APRIL 2022 PROPOSED RATES Percent Rate SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE•CCA DI(lerunca UNITIPERIOD 2D22 2022 TOTAL 2022 • RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNIT/PERIOD PROPOSED GENERATION FRANCHISE CCA vs SCE DESCRIPTION RATE RATE SURCHARGES 2022 2022 CCA RATERGES CTC PCIA FEES SURCHARGES 8.00am.Io1200r ano600pm.to 11.00 p m.summer vmekauya except MID�PEAK DOIk1aN 0,05013 0.063% 001383 0.DD0131 0.013M 0.00058 006396 000% OFF PEAK All twins oUR r Nan Peak aw Nei PeaM 0.04860 0 W242 001382 10"13) 0Ot338 0.00057 0 W242 0 00% January I mrou9tl May 31 and October I WINTER Itaougb OoxO oer 31 sm.. I0 1200 noun area 600 pm.to 11'.DO p m,summer veek4ays ex e l MID.PF.AK WA Y9 0.W839 0W24D 0014DO (0 DOOI3) 0013M 000025 0W240 000% OFF-PEAK All lours melee man Md.Peak 004184 0.05W 001326 (0 D0013) 001338 000051 005560 000% 12.130 0000 to 6 00 p m.summer wmkc., DEMAND CHARGE IL%1 SUMMER TR PEAK except hood., 12.52 12.63 0.11550 0.11550 12.63169 000% 6:GO a.m.to 12 DO noon are 6:DO p m.to 11.00 p m.summer rvaekd.,.,ce t SUMMER TR MID-PEAK Doleiays 3,40 343 003139 - - 0.03139 343M 000% TOU�PA 3 E4t09 TOU-PA-3-E4109 ENERGY CIIARGE($0KWH) SUMMER Jure 1 Nroauggn Seplamoer 30 p m.aummeayi PEAK ,rept bdioays 0.35677 037343 0.01F 1000013) 001338 aWG41 032343 000% MID PEAK 4:Wpm.m9Wpm.sumrner.kerras 0.07035 0.00437 0.01402 R)00313) 0.01338 000027 008432 000% OFF PEAK ABRours otMr Uten Peak aM MKI-Pok 0.04353 005731 001372 (000013) 0.01338 000052 005731 000% January 1 tNougn May 31 am October 1 WINTER Inr n Demmb.I 31 a p m.to p m.winter wee ays e MID PEAK Akergs 0.08475 0M91 0.01415 (0.00013) 001338 000090 009891 000% AllIReum Mber Ittan Ad Paa-.am Supm OR OFF-PEAK Peak 006482 002879 001392 (000013) 001338 000072 007899 000% a m.to 3 00 pm.w oww ek apa SUPER OFF-PEAK wookeMs 001511 0028M 001151 (0000131 0.013J8 0DOO26 0.028M 000% TOO PA 3 D41o9 TOU-PAJ-D41.9 ENERGY CHARGE(YMA'H) Page 12 of 20 DRAFT 454 ORA" ATIACHMENT A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY('CCPA'I APRIL 2022 PROPOSED RATES Percent Rate SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE•CCA Dlilaronco UNITNERIO 2022 2022 TOTAL M22 RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNITIPERIOD D PROPOSED GENERATION FRANCHISE CCA vs SCE DESCRIPTION RATE RATE SURCHARGES M22 2022 CCA RATE LTL PCIA FEES SURCHARGES SUMMER J9 1 mldu9h September 30 4 p m.b 9. pm.numm v'nee Jaya PEAK e.itap1 h01k1ays 0.07971 009382 001411 (0001 001338 000ODS 009382 0.00% MID-PEAK 4.00pM to 9.00 p m.SUMMM wcekews 007035 008437 001402 (000013) 001336 000023 008132 0.00% OFF-PEAK A8 hour.other Ilan Peak are!Mucl Peak 0.04363 005231 001377 t0.00013) 001338 0.00052 0.05731 0.00% January I through Me,31 ane Ootaber I N 4TER mP Dvicernber Jl 4 pm.b p m.wmler rwreken, w MID-PEAK weekaMa 0.06106 0025W 001394 (00D0131 001A 0.00069 0.075W 000% nIXrro anpt Ihdn Mq eak dad upn I OFFPEAK Peak 0,04937 006320 0.01383 (0.00013) O013M 0001 0D6320 0.00% a m.Ie 3 GO p m.venter w kdays ann SUPER OFF-PEAK weekends 0.02689 004051 001362 1000013) 001338 O.WO37 0.N051 0.00% 4-.GO p m.Ip 9.00 p m.nummm waakere, DEMANO CHARGE(SMI SUMMER TR PEAK 0.cept bmnayn 15A5 1529 0.13978 - - 0,13978 1528645 000% 4 OD p m.10 9.GO p m.winter weekdays am WINTER TH MID PEAK v raruls 2.62 269 002461 - 002461 2.691W 0.00% IOU PA 3 E510 TOU-PA-3 E51o8 ENERGY CHARGE IVKWH) SUMMER Ju I Inrou h Sppbmbar 30 4.nnB. 0 my PEAK p.wpt P.10un 0.64086 066024 001929 (O OOW 3) 0.01338 000604 066024 000% MID PEAK 40ppm.to 900p m.summerweekends 0.12531 0,13W 001453 (000013) 001338 OW128 0139M 000% OFFPEAK All hours other than Peak aM Mk4Peak 0.0402B 005402 001374 (000013) 0.01J38 0001 005,02 000% January I inrougn May Sl am Oclohcr I WINTER - 'Mu" 4a pr 3m1 wat,u�.nd.,0 MID PEAK vicekews 0.08677 0.10094 001417 (0 000 13) 00133E 0D0092 olp 000% All um ether t n ea aM upee OFF-PEAK Peak 0.06642 008041 0013% (0 000 13) 0.01J38 0.000]4 0G804I 000% am.W300,m.wmler wepktlays aM SUPER OFF PEAK meekems 001575 0029261 00IM2 (000013) 001338 000022 002926 000% Page 1.4 of 20 DRAFT 455 DRAFT ATTACHMENT A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY("OCPA-) APRIL M22 PROPOSED RATES Perdunt R.I. SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE•CCA Differerne UNITIPERIO D 2022 M22 TOTAL M22 RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNITIPERI00 PROPOSED GENERATION 20 FRANCHISE CCA SCE DESCRIPTION RATE RATE SURCHARGES M22 M22 CCA RATE ve CTC PCIA FEES SURCHARGES TOU-PA.3 D51o8 TOU-PA-3 D51o! ENERGY CHARGE(LKN:H) hIM' Juw 1 Nrou6h Spgomoor 30 a�p tn.m U p m.sump mt�mye PEAK e,wpt talI 0.14Ap 0.15668 0014M 1000013) 001338 OW143 0.15668 0.00: MID PEAK 400pm.109MPM sumn TIN Aknnoa 0.12531 0.13984 001453 1000013) 0.01338 000128 0.13984 000% OFF PEAK A6 fours other than Peak and MA-Peai. 0.04028 0.05a02 001374 1000013) 0.013M 0000a9 0054D2 000% January 1 through May 31 and OcIouAr I WNTER mrougn DecanDer 31 4-�4. o m.vnn� to vrenk.,aw MID-PEAK vicekcau. 0.05739 002130 001390 (0.00013) 0.013M 0.00065 0.071N 000% AD fount other than MW. 0a a uper OFF-PEAK POak 0.0466t 0.05984 001380 (0.00013) 0.013M 0.00055 0059P 0.00Y. 8 DO o m,to 3 00 p An,ammo,nee ,AM SUPER OFF-PEAK Weekends 0.02475 0.03835 001360 (0.00013) 0013M 000035 0.03835 0.00% 4 DO p m.to 9 DD p m.summer Weehwye DEMAND CHARGE(WM SUMMER TR PEAK o.copl WW.YS 17.28 12.43 0.15943 0.151)43 1743495 a00% AMP..1o900pnA Wanton.kwoand WINTER TR MID PEAK Wok., 3,65 368 003365 0.03365 362961 000% TOU GS-I A OF) TOU-GS 1 A JGF1 ENERGY CHARGE($JKWH) SUMMLR Juno 11Nugh Spptomwn 30 12:00 noon to 6 00 p m.eummpr WookW, PEAK d.wpt hobc., 0,14917 0.16522 001605 10"15) 001469 aW151 0.16522 0.00% 800 o m.10 12:00 noon and 6:00 p m.to 11:00 p m.summ Wer kwya except MID-PEAK MIRI.Y. 0.13892 0.15486 0.015N 10 IXID15) 0.01469 0.W142 0.15488 000% OFF-PEAK All fount other Nan Peak am Mid-Peak 0.1328D 0.14870 0015W 1000015) 0.01469 0.00136 0.14870 0 00Y. January 1 mmuDh May 31 ang Oetohen I WINTER through Dowmher 31 PA,1.1 of 20 DRAFT 456 DRAFT AtTACHMLNT A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY i OCPA") APRIL 2022 PROPOSED RATES Portent Ralo SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE•CCA DllTerence 2022 2022 TOTAL 2022 ESCRUNITWERIOO CTC 2022 CCA RATE RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNITIPERIOD DESCRIPTION PROPOSED GENERATION HA CTC PCIA FRANCHISE SURCHARGES CCA ve SCE RATE RATE SURCHARGES FEES 8 W am.to 12'.W nwe aM 6 W P on to I I M P re summer wCVkdaya mwpl MID.PEAK Acawya 0.08757 0.10305 0015,18 (0 OW15) 001469 aCOO'N 0.10305 0W% OFF PEAK All home PlSer than My!Peak O.O7735 0M274 001539 10 WO15) 001469 OWNS 0W274 000% TOU GS I TOU4 S.1-E ENERGY CHARGE(LKWH) SUMMER Juno I tnmu95 September W 4:00 pm.b 9 W pm.summer wackMp PEAK except Mlbaya 0.37476 0.39289 0.01813 DW015) 001409 OW359 039289 000% MID PEAK 4Wp.m.lo9Wp.m.summerwcekeM5 0.14083 0.15681 0.01597 10000151 001469 OW143 015W1 0W% OFF-PEAK A9 hares other Dean Peat aM Mel Peak 008396 009911 0.01545 10"151 001489 000091 009941 aW% Janes ry 1 tNw9b May 31 am OctMer 1 WINTER tivouch Dacmnbar 31 400 p m,IP 9.00 p m...Im.kpaye aM MID-PEAK weekeMs 0.16523 018143 0.01620 (0"15) 001469 OWN 0.18143 000% AL Hun other Nan NO Peak aM Seem OII- OFF-PHAK Peak 0,07182 0.W715 0.Dl53a 10000151 0a1469 000080 0W715 OD(Y% 8:W a.m.Ip 3W Pm.winter.k.,aM SUPER OFF-PEAK a tmaa 0.04081 005586 001W5 10 W015) 0.01469 aOW51 005586 OW% TOU GS 1-D TOU.GS-I-O ENERGY CHARGE ISIKWIH SUMfE[j June 1 thrpu9b Se,lember W 4IW p.m.to 9.W p an summer weakdays PEAK except bo00ays 0,10245 0.11807 001582 IO"15) 001469 OWIN 0.11807 0W% MID-PEAK 4 W p m.to 9:W p or summer warekanus 0.09147 0.INN 001552 10 W015) 001469 aOWN 0.1W99 0W% OFF PEAK All houra otearman Peak aM MlM1Peok 0.05434 0 W952 001518 10 00015) 0.014% 0 WOS4 a W952 O W% January 1 tbrou9b May 31 am OctoMi I WINTER IMw90 Decemisv 31 4:W P.m.1.9:W P m.winter swokoays aM MID PEAK vnxekeMs 0.09592 0.11137 001556 10"15) 001469 0W102 0.11137 0W% All hours oler uem MA Peak aM Sunor Otl OFF PEAK Peak 0.06431 001958 0.01527 10 OW15) 0.01469 0"73 0029M 0W% Page 15 o120 DRAFT 457 DRAU ATTACHMENT A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY("OCPA") APRIL 2022 PROPOSED RATES Percent Rate SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE•CCA Dlff tna ce 2022 2022 TOTAL 2022 ESCR CCA RATEERIOD 2023 2(122 RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNITIPERI00 PROPOSED GENERATION 2022 FRANCHISE DESCRIPTION RATE RATE SURCHARGES CTC PCIA FEES SURCHARGES CCA v.SCE 6 W a m,to 3 W P ne.w m.,weh4days aM SUPER OFF-PEAK weekexa 0.044112 0.05991 001509 (0 W315) 0.01469 000%5 005991 a00% 4 W p an to 9 00 p.m.summer wantke.ys DEMAND CHARGE(5 SUMMER TR PEAK eecppt rude., 18.13 IBM 0,1671, - _ 0J6234 1830WI 000% 4.W p m.to 9.W p.m.ranter weekdays ax WINTER TIT MQPEAK veekerMs 4.21 4.25 aOW86 - 003886 4.24963 0.00% TOU-CS.I-LG TOUGS 1-LG ENERGYCHARGE(LKWIt) SUMMER June I Inou9n Septemxr 30 4,W p m.to 9 W It m.summer mmk6nya PEAK except❑olklays 0.37476 039289 001813 10.00015t 001469 0W359 0.39289 a00% MID PEAK 4p0 pun to 9.W p m.aummrt kow, 0.14083 0.15681 0.01597 t0"151 001469 0 W 143 0,156111 0.00% OFF PEAK All hour.Other than Peak ax Met Peak 008396 009941 0.01545 10.00015) 001469 000001 0.09041 000% January 1 mrou0h May 31 and Octoher 1 WINTER tnrou0h D W.,31 4 00 p m.to 9 W p m.venter Meek W,a ax MID PEAK xeek., 0,16523 0.1B143 0.016M (0 WD15) 001469 O00I66 0.18143 000% All hours atxr than Mk Peak ax Supra Ofl- OPF-PEAK Peak 0.07182 0W715 001534 (0"15) 0.01a69 a00080 OW215 0W% 8.00 a.m.tP 3 W It ra raer weokeays ax SUPER OFF PEAK waokexa 0,04081 0.05586 001505 to"15) 001489 a WD51 0 05586 000% TOU G5 2 R(Grj TOU-GS-2-R IGF) ENERGY CHARGE($1KW H) SUMMER June I through Septemxr 30 12 00 root to 6 00 p an,summer vzokaays PEAK aned holet., 0.I7566 0.2311 001745 (0"15) 0.11492 0WIGS 029311 000% 8.Wam.1012.03noonoho6Wpm,to 11:00 p m.6ununer weekdays exnrot MID-PEAK fa.0ay. 0.12070 0.13822 001602 (000015) 0.01492 0W125 0IM72 0DIM OFF PEAK All hours other than Peak and Mxj.Peek 0,05939 0074M 001645 to.W015) 0.01492 000068 0074M 000% January 1 mrough May 31 am Octdwr 1 WINTER though D.mxr 31 Page 16 of 20 DRAFT 458 DRAFT ATTACHMENT A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY("OCPA') APRIL 2022 PROPOSED RATES Percent Rate SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE•CCA Difference 2022 2022 TOTAL 2022 DESCRIPTION 2011 IlII1 RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNITIPERIOD DESCRIPTION PROPOSED GENERATION 1011 CTC PCIA FRANCHISESURCHARG RATE RATE SURCHARGES FEESEESCCA RATEES CCA vs SCE 8 OD a m.10 12 00 noon ma 6 DO p m.to I I OD Pro.BUINne,woku.I B er[epl MID-PEAK IplgayB 0.08532 a 10101 001569 IO W0151 001492 0OOD92 0.10101 000% OFF-PEAK All hours Other than MA Peak O.04779 0W313 0.01535 I000015) 001492 000058 OW313 000% 10U.GS�2-E TOUGS.2.E ENERGY CHARGE(JaWil0 SUMMER Juno 1 through SeptemDar 30 4 DO p m.to 9 W p m.Bummer we0k0., PEAK e.cept no4MyB 0.41566 0.43440 001874 (10.OW15) 001492 0W392 043440 ODD% MID PEAK 4Wpm.tog Wp m.nummorwuokones 0.08794 0.103W 001572 JO.OW15) 001492 0ODDR5 0.10368 DOG% OFF-PEAK All mum olmrlhen Peak xM MM.Peai. 0.052W 0W239 D01539 (000015) 001492 000082 0.06739 0.00% January 1 trough May 31 am Octocer I WINTER thrwph December 31 4.DO p.m.to O W p m.venter neekf a,rural MID PEAK weekenaB 0.12379 0.13984 OO105 (0.00015) 001492 OW128 0139U OW% All hown other man Mid-Peek aM Super Off OFF-PEAK Peak 0.05886 0.07431 001545 (O OOD15) 001492 O000(f6 007431 D0006 8.W a or to 3 W p m.winter weekaayn anu SUPER OFF-PEAK wepkood, 0.03241 004961 001521 (0.OW15) 001492 000044 004261 000% 4 W p m.to 9 W p m.Bunamr weoka e, DEMAND CHARGE(W SUMMER TR PEAK except ndieays 5,32 532 004911 - 0N914 5.37407 000% 4 W p m.l0 9.W p m.winter neN aap.oT WINTER TR MID-PEAK weekends 1.03 1G4 OW042 000942 103537 OW% TOD GS 2.0(GF) TOUGS-2.B(GF) ENERGY CHARGE(LKWH) SUMMER Jum 1 mroegh Septamher W 12.W noon to B W p re summm wtgkaaye PEAK PxpeP1 holkUlp 0,W762 0W315 001553 (000015) 0.01492 000076 008315 000 800a.m.IP12.Wmmnam6Wpm.to 11:DO p or Bummer weekaxyn exmpt MID PEAK ImBaayn 0.06247 002795 001548 (0W015) 001492 0.00071 007295 000% OFF-PEAK All hours other loan Peak ane MA Peak 0,05939 00248n O0IO45 (0.00015) 001492 000OGII 007484 000% Page 12 of 20 DRAFT 459 DI AFT ATTACHMENT A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY I-OCPA-) APRIL M22 PROPOSED RATES Pomont Rate SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE-CCA 011tomnco RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNITIPERI00 DNNIPERI00 3022 2022 TOTAL M22 2022 M22 CCA RATE PROPOSED GENERATION CHAR FRANCHISE CCA VA SCE DESCRIPTION RATE RATE SURCHARGES CTC POIA FEES SURCHARGES January 1 tittougn May 31 aw Ocuaer 1 WINTER through De<em0nt 31 8 W a.m.to 12.CO noon one 6.W p ne to I I W p m.summer Neekaays ereept MID PEAK holidays DG8532 0.10101 001569 (a 0 l51 001492 0 W 2 0.10101 0 W% OFP.PEAK All horns other man Mio�POak H.04779 0.W313 0.01535 (0000151 001492 0W058 OOW13 O.W% 12.W noon to 6.W p m,summer v ikclay3 DEMAND CHARGE(SIK%SUMMER TR PEA e.cepl It w., 16.93 17 W 0.15621 - G IM21 17 MM2 0 W% 6.W a.m.to 12.CO noon aM 6 W p m.to 11 W p.m.summer v lkdays except SUMMER TR MID PEAK ndiaays 5.62 567 DW185 - - 0.05H15 566989 000% TOU GS2D TOUGS 2-D ENERGY CHARGE($JKWH) US MMER June I enough Septemoer W A Wpm.10 9.W Om.summer v eekaays PEAK e.cept holdoys 0.09942 0.11525 001582 JO"15) 0.01492 O.W1W 0,11525 0.00% 4110 PEAK 4W p m.to 9 W 0 m.summer weekends 0.08794 0.10360 001572 (0"15) 001492 0 00095 0.10366 0.009G OFF-PEAK AD Pours other man Peak and Mid Peak 0.052W 0W739 001539 (0 W0151 001492 0. 2 O.WAW 0.0% January I mrwgn May 31 am 04anen I WINTCR enough December 31 4I W p M.10 9 W p m,enter weekdays ana MID-PEAK weekends 0.U794 0M52 00155E (0D0015) 001492 0.WO81 0.W52 0.00% AA hours other man Md.Peak and Super O0 OFF PEAK Peak 0.05886 002431 001545 (0.OW15) 001492 01=68 0.07431 000% 8.W e m.m 3.W p.m.mnua veekaays and SUPER OFF PEAK weekends 0.03241 0N761 001521 (0.00015) 0.01492 0.W044 0D 761 000% 4 W p m.to 9 W p m,summer weei0ays DEMAND CIARGE(VK%SUMMER TR PEAK o,cePtnddays 24,11 24.33 0222a8 0.72248 24.33121 000% 4.W In m 9 W p or,wlntorveekd., no VANTER TR MID PEAK weakens 4,89 4.93 O.NS00 O.M5W 4.93034 O W% TOU-GS-3 R(GF) TOUGS-3-R IGF1 ENERGY CHARGE(9KWH) P.I,18 pl 20 DRAFT 460 DRAFT ATTACHMENT A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY("OCPA') APRIL M22 PROPOSED RATES Percent Rate SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE•CCA Difference 2022 M22 TOTAL N22M22 DESCRIPTIUNITIPERIOON CTC 2023 CCA RATE RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNITIPERIOD PROPOSED GENERATION 2022 FRANCHISE CCA vs SCE DESCRIPTION RATE RATE SURCHARGES CTC PCIA FEES SURCHARGES SUMMER lure 11Naugn SeWmmber W 12 W noon to 6.00 p m.aummm va' days PEAK a�,,,t Wet., 0.24632 0.20477 0.01645 10000141 001417 0W242 0.2E+77 0.DIM 8.00 a.m.0 12.00 men aM 6 00 p m.to 11.00 p.m.summel weekdays e..W MID-PEAK "afays 0.10E+0 0.1235E 0.01516 (0.00014) 001412 000113 0.1239E 0.0014 OFF-PEAK A9 Poore Wher than Peak aM Mad Peak 0.05689 007157 0.014M (0AW14) 001417 000065 007157 DOD% January 1 thfp h May 31 aM 0a r 1 =NT H mrou9h Omor W 31 8Wam o 12W men aM 6.00 p m.to 11M p m.sumrmr-ea"Ye eucpt MID PEAK lwhol., 0.07559 0.090a5 0.0148E (O OD014) 001417 0.OW83 0.090c5 000% OFF-PEAK AO hours Wlwr Man MW.Peak 0.154634 0.OB093 001a59 D1=14) 001417 0DDO56 0.06093 D.00% T0U.GS-3,E TOU-GS YE ENERGY CHARGE ITIKWI0 SUMMER June 1 Uvcdgh September M 4 W p m.to 9.W p m.summer wmkoays PEAK except hobdays 0.37543 0.393W 001762 (0.DG(H4) 001419 000359 0.3930E DOOM, MID-PEAK 4.00 IF m.to 900 IF M.summer wp argils 008417 Omit 00149r U)"14) 001417 0000D1 0D9911 0W% OFF-PEAK All loons ofher than Peak aM MO Pea. 0.05053 0W515 0014W (0.WOI4) 001417 000060 003515 000% January 1 IWou9h May 31 am Ocoeel 1 WINTER tivou9h Oocnmoor 31 4 W p.m.10 9 00 p m.winter wpekdaya aM MID-PEAK weekaMa 0.11084 0.12602 001518 1D OOO14) 001412 0.Got 15 012802 ODD% All Wore otlwr than Mid-PGk aM Super 00- OFF.PEAK Peak 0.05714 007183 001469 (0(M 14) 001417 00006E 007103 000% 8 W a .to 300 p m.winter weekdays aM SUPER OFF-PEAK karms 0,03163 ONSO(I 001445 100D014) 001412 DOW42 004608 000% 4.W p m.W 9.W p.m.summer x kdays DEMAND CHARGE(LKI SUMMER TR PEAK e.Cepl olata" 5.20 5.25 0CAW3 0N803 525242 ODD% 4'.00 p m.0 9 W p m.wmlei weekdays aM WINTER TR MID-PEAK w farafs 0.91 0.92 000839 - 000839 0917M 0DO% TOU GS-3 D T0U4S.3.D Page 19 of 20 DRAFT 461 DRAFT ATTACHMENT A ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY('OCPA"I APRIL 2022 PROPOSED RATES Portent Rate SCE CCA CCA SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE SCE-CCA Difference 2022 2022 TOTAL 2022 DESCRIPTIUNIT(PERIOON CTC 2022 CCA RATE RATE SCHEDULE RATE SCHEDULE UNITIPERIOO PROPOSED GENERATION HA FRANCHISE CCA vs SCE DESCRIPTION RATE RATE SURCHARGES CTC PCIA FEES SURCHARGES ENERGY CHARGE(LW4111) SUMMER June 1 mreugh suplonlUcr W 4:DO p rn.m 9 W p.m.s,noar wvs:kdpys PEAK e2epl holiday' a09518 0.11021 0.01504 (0ODD 14) 001412 OW101 D.11021 000% MID PEAK 4:OO p m.to 9 o0 p al.slmtmer weokends 0.08417 009911 0.014W (0.00014) 001417 0OOD91 009911 O.OD% OFFPEAK All hours other Ilan Peak and Mq+Poak O.OW53 006515 001463 (0000141 OO1417 000060 006515 O.OD% January 1 through May 31 am Ocloaer 1 WINTER Through Decem0er 31 4.W p m.W 9 W P m.wmlpr weekdays and MID-PEAK kam, 0.07076 0W552 001481 TO"14) 001417 000078 008557 000% All Waus Omer Van Mid Peak am Sup,Off. OFF-PEAK Peak 0D5714 007183 001469 1000014) 001417 000066 0.07183 000% 8:DO a tn.to 3.W p m,winlcr weekdays th. SUPER OFF PEAK tems 0.03163 0.04608 001445 (000014) 001417 00W42 0.04608 0OD% 4.00 p m.to 9 W IT m.summor weekdays DEMAND CHARGE(W SUMMER TR PEA ee,ept Ialtlaya 23.59 2381 021774 0.21774 2381202 0.00% 4:W pm.to 9.W p m.wins,.kw,s and WINTER iR MID PEAK xeckenoa 4111 4.32 0039M 003953 4.322W 000% STREET AND OUTDOOR LIGHTING AL 2,LS 1,LS-2.LS 3,OL-1 LS 1 ENERGY CHARGE ILKWH) 0.D4570 0.05822 001W2 (0 OO(13) 001266 000054 0.05822 DW% IC-1 TC-1 ENERGY Cl IARGE IS)KWH) 0.07389 008E 001411 (O.00014) 001345 0OD080 00"00 O.00% SMART CHOICE Basle Chace RRB plus The ldbnirg energy chtw, O.01OW 100%RENEWABLE ENERGY CHOICE Beau,C.mle plus me ldbwirg energy Uarge 0.01500 Page 20 pt 20 DRAFT 462 COMMUNITY CHOICE AGGREGATORS ( CCA) ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY RATE SELECTION LMHUNUNGTON Huntington Beach City Council February 1 , 2022 SUPPLEmkNTAL COMMUNICATION k%@*q Date: oZ 1/1.2.2- Agenda ftem No.: l i' l 2.2 D z: T WHAT IS A COMMUNITY CHOICE AGGREGATOR ( CCA ) ? • Mechanism authorized by the State in 2002 via AB 117, whereby electrical service customers are provided with an option of determining to procure power through a traditional investor-owned utility provider (SCE in our case) or through a local government entity known as a CCA (or CCE) alternative (Orange County Power Authority in our case). v Energy Purchased by the Energy Transmitted Energy Delivered to the CCA by the IOU Customer by the IOU z CCA BACKGROUND IN HB • The City explored the possibility of engaging a CCA program during the past few years — August 5, 2019: City Council directed that staff engage a firm to assess the feasibility of establishing a CCA program for Huntington Beach — February 23, 2020: MRW & Associates was engaged by the City to perform a CCA feasibility analysis, including an assessment related to Irvine's efforts to form a regional CCA JPA — December 10, 2020: City Council voted to join the Irvine-led effort to create a regional CCA JPA, called the Orange County Power Authority (OCPA) —January 26, 2021 : A virtual community informational meeting on CCA/OCPA was conducted — February I , 2021 : City Council elected to maintain membership in the OCPA JPA as a Founding Member ALTERNATIVE DEFAULT ENERGY PRODUCT OFFERINGS Basic Choice If the City selects 38 5% renewables as its default energy product offering, then all Huntington Beach customers will automatically be enrolled in the Basic Choice product (38 5% renewables) unless the customer opts-up to either the Smart Choice product (at least 69% renewables) or 100% Renewable Choice product or the customer opts-out of OCPA service altogether and stays with SCE. Smart Choice If the City selects at least 69% renewables as its default energy product, then all Huntington Beach customers will automatically be enrolled in the Smart Choice product (at least 69% renewables) unless the customer opts-up to the 100% Renewables product opts-down to the Basic Choice product, or the customer opts-out of OCPA service altogether and stays with SCE 100% Renewable Choice If the City selects 100% renewables as its default energy product, then all Huntington Beach customers will automatically be enrolled in the 100% Renewables product unless the customer opts-down to either the Basic Choice or the Smart Choice products or the customer opts-out of OCPA service altogether and stays with SCE Low-income qualified customers (customers currently enrolled in the California Alternate Rates for Energy - CARE program) will continue to see lower rates reflective of that program. ORANGE COUNTY POWER AUTHORITY MEMBER AGENCIES • Buena Park: Selected 100% Renewable Choice product as a default energy product offering for its residential and commercial customers.The City is slated to make a determination concerning the default energy product offering for City facilities in February 2022. • Irvine - Selected Smart Choice product (at least 69% renewable ) as a default energy product offering for its residential and commercial customers and is expected to take final vote on February 8, 2022. The Irvine City Council also decided that all City facilities will default into the 100% Renewable Choice product. • Fullerton — Expected to choose a default Energy Product on February 1 , 2022. • Huntington Beach — Presented for your consideration. BASIC CHOICE Estimated Typical Residential Bill Comparison Basic Choice, 425 KWh Per Month Rates set so total bill is same for OCPA and SCE bundled customer Charee Tyne OCPA SCE Difference Generation $41.51 $49.96 ($zi.45) SCE Surcharges $8.45* $0.00 $8.45 SCE Delivery $64.44 $64.44 $0.00 Total $114.40 $114.40 $0.00 0.0% ' SCE surcharges include rates that CCA customers pay to the IOU to recover costs that become stranded as a result of the customers' departure from bundled service. Almost all of the cost recovery surcharge is the Power Charge Indifference Adjustment (PCIA) that recovers the 'above market costs' of SCE's existing power supply portfolio. It also includes the municipal surcharge, which ensures SCE continues to collect franchise fees after customers depart bundled service. 6 SMART CHOICE Estimated Typical Residential Bill Comparison Smart Choice, 42.5 KWh Per Month At lea.0 69%renewable energy for l.0 cent4Wh over Basic Choice" Charee Type OCPA SCE Difference Generation $45.76 $49.96 ($4.20) SCE Surcharges $8.45 $0.00 $8.45 SCE Delivery $64.44 $64.44 $0.00 Total $118.65 $114.40 $4.25 3.7% * Based on current OCPA projections, rates subject to change. 7 100% RENEWABLE Estimated Typical Residential Bill Comparison 100% Renewable Energy Choice, 42.5 KWh Per Month 100%renewable energy for 1.5 cenvl if h over Basic Choice` Char¢e Tvae OCPA SCE Difference Generation $47.89 $49.96 ($2.07) SCE Surcharges $8.45 $0.00 $8.45 SCE Delivery $64.44 $64.44 $0.00 Total $120.78 $114.40 $6.3 8 5.6% ' Based on current OCPA projections, rates subject to change. e POLICY DECISIONS Residential/Commercial Default Rate City Facilities Default Rate Basic Choice (38.5% renewables) Basic Choice (38.5% renewables) Smart Choice (at least 69% renewables) Smart Choice (at least 69% renewables) 100% Renewable Choice 100% Renewable Choice Cost to customers differs by plan. Cost to City differs by plan. 9 Questions? Orange County PowerAuthoritX W Brian ProbolskyChief Executive OfficerTiffany Law Chief Financial Officer Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 12:27 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: item 18 (22-074) on the February 1, 2022 agenda (OCPA Default Rate) From: info amigosdebolsachica.org<info@amigosdebolsachica.org> Sent: Thursday, January 27, 2022 11:57 AM To: Delgleize, Barbara <Barbara.Delgleize@surfcity-hb.org>; Carr, Kim <Kim.Carr@surfcity-hb.org>; Peterson, Erik <Erik.Peterson @surfcity-hb.org>; Bolton, Rhonda <Rhonda.Bolton @surfcity-hb.org>; Posey, Mike <Mike.Posey@surfcity-hb.org>; Maser, Natalie <Natalie.Moser@surfcity-hb.org>; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org; Joyce, Sean <Sean.Joyce@surfcity-hb.org>; Dills, Ken <kdills@surfcity-hb.org> Cc: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Re: item 18 (22-074) on the February 1, 2022 agenda (OCPA Default Rate) Dear Mayor Delgleize and City Council. The Amigos de Bolsa Chica urge the council to select the 100% Renewable alternative as the default rate for Huntington Beach The Amigos de Bolsa Chica is one of the oldest environmental organizations in this area. with roots in Huntington Beach going back to 1976 We care deeply about this city. its people. and its natural riches For society to move quickly in the direction of renewable energy sources is one of the most powerful ways to ensure the health of people and wildlife alike Continued burning of fossil fuels pollutes our air locally and globally. with negative impacts on human health. climate, and ocean conditions As a coastal community, Huntington Beach must be especially concerned with sea level rise and its impacts. The Bolsa Chica Wetlands are especially sensitive to this threat. 100% Renewable energy is clearly the way of the future For a small extra increment on every monthly electricity bill, we could get there without wading' Mel Nutter President Shirley Dettloff Outreach Coordinator Amigos de Bolsa Chica info(oo)amigosdebolsachica orq www amigosdebolsachica orq 714-840-1575 5k:PPLEIIMENI AL d& eats' COMMUNICATION Meetng Date: 'ems Agenda Item No.,• t Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 1:51 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: CCE From: Ed Bush <ekbush@hotmail.com> Sent: Monday, January 24, 2022 9:32 AM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: CCE Members of the City Council of Huntington Beach, Is someone representing the City of Huntington Beach asking the question about the effect the CCE would have on city residents that have installed solar paneling? I paid a great deal of money to respond to the use of electrical power and the need to conserve. Because of the solar panels I have reduced the usage considerably, and as a result it has helped me ameliorate the amount that I paid for the paneling. Since so many of the citizens of Huntington Beach have also responded to the need to conserve by installing solar paneling, I hope the City Council is taking that into consideration in exploring this move to the CCE. Thank you, Ed Bush 714/842-4954 SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Mae" Date. �1 // Agenda Item ra. / 8 l .7 ;1 t Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 2:24 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: Fw: 100% renewable default SUPPLEMENI AL COMMUNICATION From: Michelle Ellison <michelleleahv@hotmaiLcom> /7 J Sent: Monday,January 24, 2022 9:22 PM Meeting Date:_ To: CITY COUNCIL<citv.council(@surfcity-hb.ora> ` Subject: 100% renewable default 4oenda Item No • /FC ZZ D�y Good evening, council. Congratulations on being a founding member agency of Orange County Power Authorityl My name is Michelle Ellison and I'm on the board of Clean Power Alliance, the CCA serving Los Angeles and Ventura Counties. Our communities are enjoying the many benefits of community choice energy like more local control and programs, choice, competitive rates, and renewable energy. I'm pleased to share that now 18 of CPA's 32 member municipalities have made 100% renewable energy the default and in so doing virtually eliminate electricity related emissions for nearly 2 million people. Huntington Beach now has the opportunity to lead the way on clean energy in Orange County. The 100% renewable default has proven to be one of the most significant, cost-effective, and immediate ways for cities to reduce their carbon footprint. With this one council action, your 200,000 residents can easily power their homes and businesses with clean energy. It'll take much more time, expense and effort to achieve this kind of progress otherwise. The optimal time to set the default at 100% is right from the start, when customers begin service with OCPA. Climate scientists recently issued an alarming code red for humanity in the latest UN IPCC report, warning us that governments at all levels everywhere must take immediate and unprecedented action to cut emissions. How you, as leaders of Huntington Beach, respond matters and has an impact far beyond your city boundaries. The good news is that there are solutions like the 100% renewable default to help us get where we need to go, and local governments are responding. To date, 27 municipalities in California have adopted a 100% renewable default so you would be in good company. Defaults have immense power to affect outcomes. Behavioral economics research shows that a vast majority of people stick with the default. If you set it at 100%, most will remain there. If you set it at a lower tier, most will remain there. There's very little movement up, down or out. That's proven true in Clean Power Alliance, all three of our default options have around a 95% participation rate. With regard to cost, OCPA's 100% renewable rate is currently projected to have just a 5.6% bill premium, the middle tier Smart Choice (69% renewable) a 3.7% premium, and the bottom tier Basic Choice (38.5% renewable) at parity with SCE's base rate. On a typical customer bill, the 100% option comes to just $6.38 more per month, a nominal investment for significantly more renewable energy and associated benefits. While Smart Choice has more renewable than Basic Choice, it still has 31% dirty energy and a bill premium. And it's important to consider the costs of externalities associated with more polluting emissions and unmitigated climate change. The perception of saving a dollar or two in the short term is a dangerous 1 illusion. for example, consider the billions of dollars in damages associated with our California wildfires. Industry studies reveal there is overwhelming public support for renewable energy. A wonderful benefit of community choice energy is that customers have more choices. The 100% default isn't forcing anything on anyone, it's simply a suggestion, and customers have the freedom to choose another plan according to their own preferences and priorities. It's easy to opt down or opt out. Customers will receive several enrollment notices so they are informed of their choices. I'm happy answer any questions or provide more information, as I've worked closely with many city councils in going to 100%, so feel free to call anytime. Regards, Michelle Ellison 414.915.4140 www.greenbydefault.org 2 Switzer, Donna From: Estanislau, Robin Sent: Monday,January 31, 2022 8:01 AM To: Switzer, Donna Subject: Fwd: Energy Comment Letter Attachments: 1-30-22 Energy Letter to HB.pdf Sent from my Wad Begin forwarded message: From: Michael Wellborn <mwllbom@socal.rr.com> Date: January 30, 2022 at 11:31:24 AM PST To: CITY COUNCIL <ciry.council@surfcity-hb.org>, "Estanislau, Robin" <Robi n.E stanislau@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Energy Comment Letter Greetings Mayor Delgleize and Council Members— The Orange County League of Conservation Voters (OCLCV) respectfully submits the attached comment letter for Tuesday's council meeting. Thank you. Michael Wellborn OCLCV SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION loserting Date: C2- / - o2o Agenda hem No.: t �^ ORANGE COUNTY 4 LEAGUE OF CONSERVATION VOTERS January 30, 2022 Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers: The Orange County League of Conservation Voters (OCLCV) seeks to protect Board of Directors our land, air, water, and the health of all California communities by supporting environmentally responsible candidates for election to local Denise Erkeneff office and holding policy makers accountable for combating the effects President of our catastrophic climate crisis. We have a strong commitment to Mark Bixby environmental justice for communities which are disproportionately VAcePresdent impacted by pollution and health issues, such as those in Huntington Beach. Kathleen Shanfield Secretary We are writing today to urge you to demonstrate necessary and heroic Linda Moon Treasurer action by making Huntington Beach one of the first cities in Orange County to make Michael Harley 100% clean electricity its default energy product. Fossil fuels burned for Greg Ridge electricity generation are the second largest source of emissions in our Michael Wellborn region, so it is imperative that the city stop their use as soon as possible. More than 25 cities and counties in California have successfully taken this step of making 100% renewable energy their default through a Community Choice program. Huntington Beach's environmental justice communities have historically and are currently shouldering disproportionate burdens of pollution under our fossil fuel-powered energy and transportation systems. This is an opportunity to address that injustice by reducing emissions. Thank you for considering this important step toward our clean energy future. Sincerely, �� Denise Erkeneff, President Orange County League of Conservation Voters The Orange County League of Conservation Voters is the Political Action Arm of Orange County's Environmental Community PO Box 1303, Huntington Bead),CA.92647. 714-525-5377. kshanfieldCdaol.com FAIR POLITICAL PRACTICES COMMISSION REGISTRATION 9 1223961 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 3:02 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my familyLeliustice for Huntington Beach OMMUNICATION Meabng Date. From: Kathleen Treseder<kath lee ntreseder@gmail.com> Agenda Item No.' Sent: Friday,January 28,2022 3:01 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara <Barbara.Delgleize@surfcity-hb.org>; Carr, Kim<Kim.Carr@surfcity-hb.org>; Peterson, Erik <Erik.Peterson@surfcity-hb.org>; Bolton, Rhonda<Rhonda.Bolton @surfcity-hb.org>; Posey, Mike <Mike.Posey@surfcity-hb.org>; Moser, Natalie<Natalie.Moser@surfcity-hb.org>; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc:Joyce, Sean<Sean Joyce@surfcity-h b.org>; Dills, Ken <kdills@surfcity-hb.org>; supplementakomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family+environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you for joining the CC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100% clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100% clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 3:33 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Subject: Item 18: Please choose 100% clean energy for Huntington Beach -----Original Message----- From: H Meyers<hmeybsan@gmail.com> Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 3:05 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara <Barbara.Delgleize@surfcity-hb.org>; Carr, Kim <Kim.Carr@surfcity-hb.org>; Peterson, Erik <Erik.Peterson@surfcity-hb.org>; Bolton, Rhonda <Rhonda,Bolton@surfcity-hb.org>; Posey, Mike <Mike.Posey@surfcity-hb.org>; Moser, Natalie <NataIie.Moser@surfcity-hb.org>; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean <Sean.Joyce@surfcity-hb.org>; Dills, Ken <kdills@surfcity-hb.org>; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Subject: Item 18: Please choose 100%clean energy for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake. Please choose 100% clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you, 5c;cJPLEMLN 1 AL Hildy Meyers COMMUNICATION Huntington Beach 4eetIng Date: J- // /aOZ Agenda Item No.• / 2 ' D iZJ4 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 3:33 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach From:suvangeer@sbcglobal.net<suvangeer@sbcglobal.net> Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 3:06 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara <Barbara.Delgleize@surfcity-hb.org>; Carr, Kim<Kim.Carr@surfcity-hb.org>; Peterson, Erik <Erik.Peterson @surfcity-hb.org>; Bolton, Rhonda <Rhonda.Bolton@surfcity-hb.org>; Posey, Mike <Mike.Posey@surfcity-hb.org>; Moser, Natalie<Natalie.Moser@surfcity-hb.org>; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc:Joyce,Sean<Sea n.Joyce @ surfcity-hb.org>; Dills, Ken<kdills@surfcity-hb.org>; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family+ environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air,clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 1000/6 clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meetktg Date: o2//122. Agenda Nam No.: t Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 3:33 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach From:suvangeer@sbcglobal.net<suvangeer@sbcglobal.net> Sent: Friday,January 28, 2022 3:11 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara<Barbara.Delgleize@surfcity-hb.org>;Carr, Kim <Kim.Carr@surfcity-hb.org>; Peterson, Erik <Erik.Peterson@surfcity-hb.org>; Bolton, Rhonda<Rhonda.Bolton @surfcity-hb.org>; Posey, Mike <Mike.Posey@surfcity-hb.org>; Moser, Natalie<Natalie.Moser@surfcity-hb.org>; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc:Joyce,Sean<SeanJoyce@surfcity-hb.org>; Dills, Ken<kdills@surfcity-hb.org>; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family+environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100% clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. Mrs. Suvan Geer SUPPLEMENT AL COMMUNICATION MWtIrg Date: V 1 /22—o 2-2 Agenda ttdm No.: 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 3:34 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach From: Jamie Perlman <jamieperlman@yahoo.com> Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 3:15 PM To:Joyce, Sean <Sean.Joyce@surfcity-hb.org>; Dills, Ken <kdills@surfcity-hb.org>; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL <city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you for joining the CC Power Authority to help bring clean air,clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%dean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family,and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 1001/6 will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually,which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year.This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic,Asian,and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs.The CC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach,and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy,you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice,providing clean energy jobs,and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. Jamie Perlman SUPPLEMENIAL COMMUNICATION l4W,ng Data: Agenda Item No.; t Switzer, Donna From: Patty Ebel <patty@ebelslock.com> Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 3:33 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie;dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org;CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, . Thank you, Patty Ebel SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION l mee*V Apndt turn No- 18(�2 . 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 4:01 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Item 18: OCPA Default Rate Selection (100% Renewable) From:keith linker<keithlinker@gmail.com> Sent: Friday,January 28,2022 3:59 PM To:Delgleize, Barbara<Barbara.Delgleize@surfcity-hb.org>; Carr, Kim<Kim.Carr@surfcity-hb.org>; Peterson, Erik <Erik.Peterson@ surfcity-hb.org>; Bolton, Rhonda<Rhonda.Bolton@surfcity-hb.org>; Posey, Mike <Mike.Posey@surfcity-hb.org>; Moser, Natalie<Natalie.Moser@surfcity-hb.org>;dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc:Joyce, Sean<SeanJoyce@surfcity-hb.org>; Dills, Ken<kdills@surfcity-hb.org>; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Item 18:OCPA Default Rate Selection(100%Renewable) Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, First I want to thank you for joining the OC Power Authority. In doing so, you are not only supporting the ratepayers of HB, but also the transition to sustainable energy. I appreciate the inclusion of this item on the agenda and strongly encourage you to please choose "10016 Renewable F.nerav" as the default selection. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100% renewable energy as the default for Huntington Beach to help ensure a climate safe future. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution resulting from the burning of fossil fuels. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can help secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our local economy. You have the power to make Huntington Beach a national leader and protect Orange County residents and visitors from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leadership on this critical item! Keith Linker Irvine resident and regular Huntington Beach visitor SUPPLEMENTAL Co mMUNICATION hm*V Date: 0211122- Agenda Ite T No..�l ` 'Z'2 — � �4 t Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 4:01 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me agQ gw4e(r&,g1!qJ CA0ental justice for Huntington Beach COM;RAUNICATION Meetvp Date: .2 �r /Z 2 From: Kirk Nason<kirk.nason1234@gmail.eom> Aren is Ibem No.: Sent: Friday,January 28, 2022 4:00 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara <Barbara.Delgleize@surfcity-hb.org>;Carr, Kim<Kim.Carr@surfcity-hb.org>; Peterson, Erik <Erik.Peterson @surfcity-hb.org>; Bolton, Rhonda <Rhonda.Bolton @surfcity-hb.org>; Posey, Mike <Mike.Posey@surfcity-hb.org>; Moser, Natalie<Natalie.Moser@surfcity-hb.org>; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc:Joyce, Sean<Sean.Joyce@surfcity-hb.org>; Dills, Ken<kdills@surfcity-hb.org>; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family+environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake. so I am writing to ask you to choose 100% clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. t Regards, Kirk J. Nason 714 321-7298 bM s:Hl inktr.ee/ILuvAmp Excuse brevity & typos 2 Switzer, Donna From: Estanislau, Robin Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 12:17 PM To: Switzer, Donna Subject: FW: Energy Comment Letter Attachments: 1-30-22 Energy Comment Letter to HB.pdf Robin Estanislau, CMC, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 714-536-5405 Please consider the HB City Clerk's office for your passport needs! -----Original Message----- From: Michael Wellborn <wellborn.michael@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday,January 30, 2022 11:06 AM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>; Estanislau, Robin <Robin.Estanislau@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Energy Comment Letter Greetings Council Members Friends of Harbors, Beaches and Parks (FHBP) respectfully submits the attached comment letter for Tuesday's council meeting. Thank you. Michael Wellborn, President FHBP SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Mwtng Date:_ Agenda Item No.: t of�dn r w January 30, 2022 Submitted via email to: City.Council@surfcity-hb.orq and Robin.Estonislou@surfcity-hb.org Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Subject: Agenda item 18—SUPPORT for Clean Electricity Dear Honorable Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers: Friends of Harbors, Beaches and Parks (FHBP) reaches out to you regarding Agenda Item 18 for your selection of a default energy product for residential and commercial customers in the City of Huntington Beach. We write in support of the option for 100%clean energy. Emissions from methane gas burned to generate electricity are the second-largest source of emissions in our region and a major driver of climate change, which threatens every person, plant, and animal in Orange County. We are already seeing the effects of climate change in the open spaces that FHBP has long advocated for and championed. The news is a constant reminder of these realities. With warmer and fewer storms, there is less snowpack to supply the water needs of our landscapes, making them more vulnerable to fires. We then use water to put out the fires, leaving even less water for daily uses. As landscapes burn, they lose their capacity for carbon sequestration. Healthy forests store carbon dioxide—a greenhouse gas. Burned forests release carbon. Without immediate reductions in emissions, the cascade of impacts spirals on. With this in mind, we urge the Council to seize this opportunity to support the natural environment we all cherish and choose 100%clean electricity for all of Huntington Beach. People who need to choose a different product can do that easily, but the City should make a choice that will protect the only planet we have for future generations. We need your leadership to take the swift action to stop this crisis. SUProLw1ENTAL COMMUNICATION Sincerely, f,1 �//� �/ Meeting (late: Agenda Item No.: /,72�2 Michael Wellborn, President CC: sean.joyice@surfcity-hb.orF, kdills@surfcity-hb.org,SupplementalComm@Surfcity-hb.org P.O. Box 9256 • Newport Beach, CA 92658 • www.FHBP.org Switzer, Donna From: Marilyn Palomino <palominoccrOgmail.com> Sent: Friday,January 28,2022 4:31 PM To: supplementalcommOsurfcity-hb.org Subject: 100%renewable energy Please vote for 100% renewable energy on February 1st. I have been a resident in Huntington Beach for 35 years. The city has a history of being slow to care for the health of the community and ignoring environmental issues,such as, rising sea levels due to climate change and methane leaks from oil wells that are no longer in service.. Many of you are consistently working towards changing that and have the well- being of our community in focus and I applaud you. Please continue your strong leadership and vote for 100% renewable energy. It makes sense! Marilyn Palomino SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeft Date: o2- /• 2.L l Agenda Item No.: a ��1. t Switzer, Donna From: Greg Walgenbach <gwalgenbach@rcbo.org> Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 4:43 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda: Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie, dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org;Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Letter re City Council Vote on Community Choice Energy and 100% Renewable Energy Attachments: CCE Letter to Huntington Beach City Council-1.28.22.docx.pdf Dear Mayor Delgleize and Council, Thank you for your efforts on Community Choice Energy. Please see the attached letter making a request that at your upcoming council meeting you consider making 100`Yo renewable energy the default for Huntington Beach in 2022. Sincerely, Greg Greg Walgenbach Director, Life, Justice & Peace I Vida, lusticia y Paz Director, Mission Office I Oficina de Misiun rcho.orWlifeiusticepeace © � rcbo.oWmiscion-off ice 714-282-3058 ROMAN CATHOLIC DIOCESE d ORANGE "Fear not, little flock, for it is your Father's good pleasure to give you the kingdom."(Luke 12:32) "No tengan miedo,rebaAo pequeflo, porque su Padre se ha complacido darles el rein."(Lucas 12.32) SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Gate: ///'2Z Agenda Herr No.: / L t ROMAN CATHOLIC DIOCESE of ORANGE VAS TODAL CENTED:0MCE OF LIFE,JUSTICE$PEACE '=s 13280CP A DM AN AVENUE.GA POE GROVE.CA 92840 1/28/2022 Subject: Letter re City Council Vote on Community Choice Energy and 100% Renewable En- ergy Dear Mayor Delgleize and Council, On behalf of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Orange County, we thank you for joining Orange County's first Community Choice Energy program and for considering a renewable electricity default for Huntington Beach. In light of the unimaginable human suffering that the cli- mate crisis will bring and is already bringing in many communities, we send this letter to request that you consider making 100% renewable energy the default for Huntington Beach in 2022. In Laudato Si', Pope Francis calls the Church and the world to acknowledge the urgency of our environmental challenges and join him in embarking on a new path. The challenges to our common home take their severest toll upon those most vulnerable in our midst. As Pope Francis has shared, "Both everyday experience and scientific research show that the gravest effects of all attacks on the environment are suffered by the poorest." Climate change will amplify hunger and poverty, and increase risks of resource scarcity that can exacerbate political instability, and even create or worsen refugee crises. Climate change will also worsen pollution, biodiversity loss, habitat fragmentation, and species extinction. These facts demand urgent action by everyone, particularly policymakers. Specific to the issue at hand, Laudato Si' reminds us of the urgent need "to adopt a circular model of production capable of preserving resources for present and future generations, while limiting as much as possible the use of non-renewable resources, moderating their consump- tion, maximizing their efficient use, reusing and recycling them. A serious consideration of this issue would be one way of counteracting the throwaway culture which affects the entire planet." By choosing 100% clean electricity, Huntington Beach would reduce emissions by 482,000 metric tons per year. We are not aware of any other action the city could take to so dras- tically reduce its pollution, which is driving the climate crisis. We pray for your wisdom to help prevent human suffering related to climate. Please let me know if I or our parishes can be of any assistance. Sincerely, / Greg Walgenbach Director, Office of Life, Justice, and Peace Roman Catholic Diocese of Orange CDEG WALGENBACN DIRECTOR OF LIFE, JUSTICE AND PEACE OFFICE;714-282-3058 E-MAIL:GWALGENBACH@RCBO,ORG Switzer, Donna From: Jerry Donohue <outlook_3F76BA7571D23BF1@outlook.com> Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 4:51 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean, Dills, Ken: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, This is an action that local jurisdictions need to pursue and federal efforts seem stymied. Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach.The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't Sent from Mail for Windows SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION MaetingDate: o,j1�/�� /8' (z2- 0�4) Agenda Item No.' 1 Switzer, Donna From: Karen Bender <karen.bender063@gmail.com> Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 5:00 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Can, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so 1 am writing to ask you to choose 100% clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100% clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeli Date: / /ate l8laa - 09 Agenda Item No.`r Switzer, Donna From: Teray Stephens <teray@stephensconsultinggroup.com> Sent: Friday,January 28, 2022 SA9 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara,Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken;supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org;CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you forjoining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air,clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake. so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION meetry Agenda I*M No.. I ( z-2 " Q Switzer, Donna From: v_bernal@sbcglobal.net Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 6:04 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce pollution. Please tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECS. Virginia Bernal SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION MeetingDFfe: /,22 Agenda nem No.: $ 1'.Z2- 0 7-q 1 Switzer, Donna From: Melissa Waters <msimply3@aol.com> Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 6:19 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history! Melissa Waters SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting DAte: e2// Aaenda'twm No.: 22— D �J I Switzer, Donna From: Gary Stewart <bertrandbartok@gmail.com> Sent: Friday, January 28, 2022 10:27 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100% clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic. Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100% clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. Gary M Stewart, M.D. Laguna Beach, CA 92651 bertrandbartokr&¢rttai l.com (714) 504-9582 SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Mseth Dete; oI "�^�-� Agenda Item No.: �( '� — 0 �y 1 t Switzer, Donna From: Andrea Alexander <andreaalexanderl2@ymail.com> Sent: Saturday, January 29, 2022 9:20 AM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie;dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic. Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date; ol/i/.2Z Agenda rem No.; t Switzer, Donna From: Fachko Denise <dfachko@yahoo.com> Sent: Saturday, January 29, 2022 10:12 AM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken;supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and the community + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Council Members, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic. Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. In addition, the OC Power Authority has not committed to not using un-bundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Un-bundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want un- bundled RECs. By choosing 100% clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. Sincerely, D. Fachko SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Mee ft Date: Agenda ttom No l8(zz -v �y t Switzer, Donna From: Tristan Miller-Mansey <tristan@mansey.com> Sent: Saturday, January 29, 2022 11:05 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL; Climate County Subject: Vote for 100% Renewable Default Rate - Item 22-074 Dear Mayor and City Council, Please vote for 100%renewable energy as the default rate -this is inline with California's clean energy target. The 100%renewable energy default is one of the easiest, most cost-effective, immediate, and significant ways for communities to act on climate and reduce emissions and provide a healthier future for residents. Here is the case for 100% default rate: https://,Aww.g=nbydefault.org/about Currently, 18 out of 31 Cities in LA Clean Power Alliance have chosen 1001/6. The UN IPCC issued a dire report, a "code red for humanity", warning that all governments, at all levels everywhere, must make rapid, far- reaching and unprecedented changes in all aspects of society to keep temperatures under 1.5°C. Plus it is good for our health and economy! 100% Renewable energy matters to me, to our community, and to our future! Thank you all so much! Tristan Miller OC Business Owner, Resident Vice Chair of Climate Reality OC SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeft Derr.___ 1o//i/ZZ /' Agenda ;ton No.: O C 'ZZ -a 74 1 Switzer, Donna From: Adam Chung <awchung77@gmail.com> Sent: Saturday,January 29, 2022 11:46 AM To: Delgleize, Barbara;Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken;supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject: Item 1 B: A safe future for me and my family . environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. Adam Chung, OC resident SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date: of 11120 Agenda Item No.; F ( 22 — 0 t t Switzer, Donna From: Gregory Tabat <greg@exceptional.org> Sent: Saturday,January 29, 2022 11:59 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL; climaterealityprojectoc@gmaii.com Subject: Vote for 100% Renewable Default Rate - Item 22-074 Dear Mayor and City Council, 1 am a self-employed businessman with a licensed office in Huntington Beach. I support 100% renewable energy as our default rate. The 100% renewable energy default is one of the easiest, most cost-effective, immediate, and significant ways for communities to act on climate and reduce emissions and provide a healthier future for residents. Currently, 18 out of 31 Cities in LA Clean Power Alliance have chosen 100%. 100% Renewable energy matters to me, to our community, and to our future! Thank you. Peace Gregory Tabat SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Mee"Dote: �, / ZZ Agenda Item No.: 1 Switzer, Donna From: Susan Hansen <su4han@gmail.com> Sent: Saturday, January 29, 2022 12:00 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so 1 am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Mseft Date: 2//12 Z Agenda Item No.: 1?( 22 — U 7-4) t Switzer, Donna From: Pam Kamps <pamkamps@gmail.com> Sent: Saturday, January 29, 2022 12:34 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike, Moser, Natalie; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org;CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, 1 am a 40+ year resident of HB. I am a mother, grandmother, involved citizen and environmentalist. I am writing today to ask you to choose 100% clean energy as the default when you vote on Tuesday. Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake. Choosing 1000/oclean energy as the default will help to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100% clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in historryy SUPPLEMENNT Pam & Brent Kamps C^i`i! MUNICATION 21861 Summerwind Ln Huntington Beach 92646 klgeting Gate:_ oL11 //22- Agenda ItemNo.• t Switzer, Donna From: Anna Donaldson <akdonaldson11206gmail.com> Sent: Saturday,January 29, 2022 328 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara;Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken;supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org;CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100% clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Let's keep Huntington Beach clean for all. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. Anna Donaldson SUPPLEMENTAL CCf,,W4V,► 1CAT10N Meeting Date: 02 /12 2 Agenda ftem No., t Switzer, Donna From: Andrea Alexander <andreaalexanderl2@ymail.com> Sent: Saturday, January 29, 2022 4:21 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara;Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100% clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 1001/o will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100% clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION mwft Det>a:_ J/,.Z2Z Agenda ftem No.: 8l 22 - 0 t Switzer, Donna From: Steven Klasky <steve.klasky@gmail.com> Sent: Saturday, January 29, 2022 9:18 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org, CITY COUNCIL, climaterealityprojectoc@gmaii.com Subject: Item #22-074: Vote To Support 100`Yo Renewable Energy Default Rate Dear Mayor and City Council, Thank you Council for your clean energy leadership in Orange County! Please vote for 100% Renewables as your default rate as it is the easiest, most cost-effective, immediate, and significant way for a city to act on climate and reduce emissions. 100% Renewable energy matters to me. Thank you! Sent from my ;Phone ,d/7/2Z I 2 _ 7 4/ 1 Switzer, Donna From: Jonathan Light <jlight88@aol.com> Sent: Saturday, January 29, 2022 9:55 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike, Moser, Natalie; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. I am writing to ask you to choose 100% clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for everyone. We need to prioritize economic development and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs) and I hope Huntington Beach to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy,you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. Jonathan Light SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION MeeSng Date: 1112 z AgerW_a Itnm No.: W.22 — D �- 1 Switzer, Donna From: dad2st@aol.com Sent: Sunday, January 30, 2022 1:55 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Energy Plan Rates All council members Let me know ASAP when I can OPT OUT of this ridiculous, unneeded, bureaucratic, expensive utility. Why would I think it'll be more beneficial when the city CANNOT fix the roads and alleys, control and manage the coyote and homeless problem in town. Sincerely Chuck Burns 714 369-7384 Hunt Beach CA SUPPLEMENTAL COF✓WIJNICATION t Switzer, Donna From: Paul Arms <paularmscorp@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday, January 30, 2022 7:14 AM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik, Bolton, Rhonda, Posey, Mike, Moser, Natalie; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family . environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Lets be leaders on renewable energy. Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. Paul Arms Huntington Beach, CA We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't Sent from Mail for Windows r i_:)PLEMENTAL C'': :`i X INICATION C,Z / r /zZ Agenda Itom No.; 1 Switzer, Donna From: Stephen Billard <stephen.billard@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday, January 30, 2022 2:25 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Cc: Szabo, Matthew Subject: H.B to select renewable energy rates Today I read an article in the Daily Pilot about the pending launch of the Orange County Power Authority. There are several concerns I have (and any informed citizen should have) with regards to this transition. None were addressed in the article and are certainly not covered on the OCPA site. First and foremost, it appears that I will have no initial choice but to be a customer of OCPA. This is the default opt-in decision. This choice will be made for me without any consideration of if it will impact my finances. Yes, I will have the option of overriding that decision after the fact, but will that happen as a multi-step process? If I leave SCE I will loose any grandfathered rates I may be on even if I return. That has the potential of doubling my electricity costs (based on my last comparison of my Tiered Use plan versus the current Time of Use plans.) According to the OCPA documents, its rate plans are likely not to include a Tiered Use plan. Will we even know the proposed rate plans before destiny is cast in concrete? Business will convert in April. That is not far off. Residential conversion is nine months away. In my experience this kind of operation will be hard pressed to be settled in that time frame. My second concern is the presentation of the clean energy options. Each purports to provide a blend of clean and (my words) dirty energy at varying percentages. Those wishing higher portions of clean energy would pay higher rates. But I really do not see how this can be made to work in practice. I may choose the 100% clean energy but my neighbor, due to his financial situation, may need to go with the basic choice--38.5% renewable. But we share the same transformer loop, so either he is getting 100% renewable with out paying the premium or I am being duped on what I am buying. (BTW, the delivery infrastructure is pretty much common up to the points where the energy is created. Everyone is essentially going to get the same mix of power generation sources.) Finally, the article states that the basic rate would likely cost the same as getting energy form SCE. So one can presume that this endeavor is not an attempt to provide a financial benefit to our citizens. Exactly why does our government want to implement this plan? -Stephen Billard SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION 1`4eeting Date: 4c'nC5 �Z2 - O fe4) "Unceasingly we are bombarded with pseudo-realities. Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away." - Philip K. Dick 2 Switzer, Donna From: Amir Baum <amir.baum@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday,January 30, 2022 3.48 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara;Can, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie,dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken;supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually,which is equivalent to taking nearly 105.000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100% clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs. and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. There is absolutely no reason why the City of Huntington Beach's cannot set an example and commit to 100% renewable energy at this time when these energy sources are plentiful and more than cost-effective. I have a four year old son and I'm concerned about his future with heat waves and wildfires only getting a lot worse if we do not commit to eliminating a fossil fuel usage and committing to 1001/6 renewable energy which is what we need to do at a minimum to solve our climate crisis within our 10-year window. So I urge you to take the lead and commit to 100% renewable energy now because we may not have a tomorrow if we do not do this now. We are counting on you to protect the City of Huntington Beach's future and that starts with committing to 100%clean renewable energy following the lead of the City of Buena Park that recently committed to that along with the City of Irvine for 100%carbon neutrality by 2035. These are the kind of innovative forward thinking initiatives that we absolutely must pursue when it comes to building a more sustainable equitable and just society for all regardless of what political side you are on these days. This is a human issue and it needs to be solved immediately because we are in a climate emergency affecting all of our livelihoods and futures and therefore it must be prioritized to that level with implementing effective solutions py r t uw. LZME Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. C':VV, UNICATION t MeeSog Date. ;-// 122 Agenda than No.- /�-7/zz - o �-q) Sincerely. Amir Baum 2 Switzer, Donna From: ashton gilbert <ashtonegilbert2000@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 12:10 AM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surf city-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers. am an Orange County resident and want the local government to do more regarding climate. I am writing to ask you to choose 100% clean energy as the default for Fullerton. We have sat back, watched, and kicked the bucket down the road enough. This is a fantastic opportunity to prioritize our environment and the lives of our future generations. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 311,000 metric tons per year, yes that much' Fullerton and other OC residents are already feeling the effects of climate change. it is NOT a distant threat Air quality, wild fires. droughts, these can ALL be felt night now, and we should address them to the best of our ability. We also need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach with local sources of clean energy that dnve local lobs The OC Power Authority has discussed using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs),which would send lobs and economic development out of Huntington SEach. and won't significantly reduce pollution. Fullerton needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unburdled RECs. Please use your power to create a livable future while protecting Fullerton families from unnecessary pollution, providing clean energy jobs and boosting our economy by choosing 1 DO% clean energy. Thank you for considering my future, Ashton Gilbert SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Agenda ftem No.: 1?1(2z-0 �/) 1 Switzer, Donna From: Ali Monge <ali@wave4all.org> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 8:00 AM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie, Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Letter in support of 100% renewable energy for Huntington Beach Attachments: Letter to Huntington Beach - OCPA.pdf Dear Mayor Delgleize and City Council Members, Please find attached a letter from the Executive Board of WAVE (Women for American Values and Ethics) regarding your vote on Community Choice Energy for the city of Huntington Beach. We would appreciate inclusion of this letter in the meeting packet for Tuesday, February 1. Thank you for your attention and consideration. Respectfully yours, Ali Monge Vice President WAVE (Women for .American Values and Ethics) www.wave4all.org SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Der: // 12Z Agenda Item No._ t WA* V � • • WOMEN FOR AMERICAN VALUES AND ETHICS January 31, 2022 Mayor Barbara Delgleize City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Dear Mayor Delgleize and City Council Members: WAVE (Women for American Values and Ethics) is a fast-growing grassroots force of more than 2,300 citizen-advocates, donors and others dedicated to advancing progressive values and ethics in Orange County. Environmental conservation, social justice, and systemic fair treatment for everyone are among our fundamental values, which is why WAVE worked for several years to help advocate for the creation of a Community Choice Energy (CCE) program in Orange County. We want to thank you for your decision to join the OC Power Authority, and we are excited to hear that Huntington Beach has reached the crucial decision of what its default electricity product will be. We, the members of WAVE's Executive Board, are contacting you today to ask that you choose 100% clean, renewable electricity as the default product for all Huntington Beach electricity users beginning this year to achieve not only a clean and secure energy future for orange County, but also a safer and healthier living environment for your residents. This Is a unique and powerful opportunity for the city to address the ill effects of climate change and of environmental injustice brought on harmful emissions. Huntington Beach's environmental justice communities have historically and are currently shouldering disproportionate burdens of pollution under our fossil fuel-powered energy and transportation systems. According to Cal Envlroscreen, areas of Huntington Beach range from the 74th- 92nd percentile among California communities in terms of pollution burden The only three census tracts in Huntington Beach that are predominantly Hispanic are the three census tracts with the most pollution burden. This is an opportunity to address that injustice by reducing emissions. Huntington Beach's Environmental Resources ano Conseraatlon element of the General Plan (adopted October 2, 2017) acknowledges the unhealthy, unjust, and unsustainable living conditions of many Huntington Beach families. Reducing emissions through 100% clean electricity would be a major and immediate step toward Goal ERC-13: to increase I N F03'WAVE4ALL.0RG * ZWAVE4ALL * WAVE4ALL.ORG 2525 OCEAN BOULEVARD, SUITE A2, new PORT BEACH, CA 92625 �WA* V • WOMEN FOR AMERICAN VALUES AND ETHICS both renewable energy sources within municipal and community-wide practices. Goal ERC-5: to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and Goal ERC-4: to improve air quality The most polluted area in Huntington Beach is in the 40th percentile among California communities for asthma and 35th percentile for cardiovascular disease. These can be symptoms of chronic exposure to pollution and can cause even more health risks and strain to the healthcare system if continued exposure is left unabated. Reducing emissions will put the health of Huntington Beach families first and address this health disparity. We hope you take this opportunity to set a strong example in Orange County and show your leadership in this very important matter. Please vote to provide Huntington Beach 100% clean and renewable energy today. Thank you for your attention. Respectfully submitted, Joanna Weiss, Founder and President Ali Monge, Vice President Kia Westhead, Secretary Danea Riley. Treasurer Arlene Joyce IN F04WAVE4ALL.ORG * ZWAVE4ALL * WAVE4ALL.ORG Switzer, Donna From: robandbruce@netscape.net Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 8:54 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org, CITY COUNCIL, climaterealityprojectoc@gmaii.com Subject: Vote for 100% Renewable Default Rate - Item 22-074 Dear Mayor and City Council. I support of 100% renewable energy as our default rate The 100% renewable energy default is one of the easiest. most cost-effective, immediate and significant ways for communities to act on climate and reduce emissions and provide a healthier future for residents Currently. 18 out of 31 Cities in LA Clean Power Alliance have chosen 100%. 100% Renewable energy matters to me, to our community, and to our future' Thank you for our planet 1111110 SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meaft Data: 2 //12z Agenda Item No.; —0 t / t Switzer, Donna From: Nathan Taft <nathan@stand.eanh> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 10:57 AM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org;CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100% clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. Nathan Taf, 92705 SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meetktp Date: /7 12 z Agenda Item No.; /8(2 2- eI 1 Switzer, Donna From: Cindy B <castle92648@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 12:10 PM To: CITY COUNCIL; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Renewable energy To: HB City Council Members From: Cynthia Bonnycastle, concerned resident, 715 April Dr, HB Comment re: Administrative Item #22-074: Please choose 100% renewable energy as the city's default power rate. Thank you. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date; cl///2 2 Agenda Item No.: ? '22 — 02,41 i Switzer, Donna From: John Miller <zenmastermiller@gmail.com> Sent: Saturday, January 29, 2022 7:45 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org, CITY COUNCIL, climaterealityprojectoc@gmail.com Subject Item #22-074: Vote To Support 100% Renewable Energy Default Rate Dear Mayor and City Council, Thank you Council for your clean energy leadership in Orange County! Please vote for 100% Renewables as your default rate as it is the easiest, most cost-effective, immediate, and significant way for a city to act on climate and reduce emissions. 100% Renewable energy matters to me. Thank you! SUPPLEMENTAL CC'4!41_INICATION A'eebn0 � Agenda "m No.: t Switzer, Donna From: John Miller <zenmastermiller@gmail.com> Sent: Saturday, January 29, 2022 7:44 PM To: supplementaIcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL; climaterealityprojectc>c@gmail.com Subject. Item #22-074:Vote For 100% Renewable Default Rate Dear Mayor and City Council, Thank you Council for your clean energy leadership in Orange County! Please vote for 100% Renewables as your default rate as it is the easiest, most cost-effective, immediate, and significant way for a city to act on climate and reduce emissions. 100% Renewable energy matters to me. Thank you! SUPPLEMENTAL CCU;ill-NICAT10N Meeting Date: l zg 1 Switzer, Donna From: Clay Sandidge <clay.sandidge@p2sinc.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 1:04 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik, Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie, Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Clay Sandidge I Senior Project Manager and Energy Market Sector Lead O 562.497.2999 1 C 714.321.3346 1 www,p2sln4.com PzSill CONFIDENTIALITY NOTE: This email message and its attachments contain work product or other information which is privileged,confidential and/or protected from disclosure. This information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you think that you have received this message in error, please email or phone the sender. If you arc not the intended recipient, any dissemination, distribution or copying is strictly prohibited. SUPP!EMENTAL Cry*,Iola INRCATION Arcn,^,3 ttom NO.' 1 Switzer, Donna From: Kathleen McGowan <kathleen.enve@verizon.net> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 1:31 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org CITY COUNCIL Subject: CC Agenda Item 18 for 111122 OCPA Default Rate Selection Good afternoon, Regarding City Council Agenda Item 18, 22-074 staff report on OCPA Default Rate Schedule, it appears there is a mistake in the staff report regarding the City of Buena Park default energy product offering. As posted on the City of Buena Park website here: https:/Zbuenapark.com/ T2 R158.php , on January 25, 2022, the City Council of Buena Park became the first member of the OCPA to choose 100%as the default tier for residential and commercial customers, whereas the City of Huntington Beach staff report 22-074 mistakenly states that Buena Park elected Smart Choice as the default. Best, Kathleen McGowan SUPPLEMENIAL COMMUNICATION Mee&V Data: ,2 1112 Z Agenda rs;m No.: /8(22— a � 1 Switzer, Donna From: Penny Wilton <pwilton05@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 1:36 PM To: Bolton, Rhonda; Delgleize, Barbara; Kalmick, Dan; Peterson, Erik; Carr, Kim; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie Cc: CITY COUNCIL; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; Dills, Ken;Joyce, Sean Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air,clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake. so 1 am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our communit% members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach. and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 1001/6 clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs,and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. null SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Mee*gDate: d�/�22 �)A{Jenda Item No. r Switzer, Donna From: Angel Hafer <angelhafer@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 2:04 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air,clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Anything less would be unacceptable in the fight against the climate crisis. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. Angel Hafer SUPPLEMENTAL COB M'LINICATION Meelirg Date: 'J �2 Agenda IMm No.: 1 Switzer, Donna From: Gabriel Amaro <gabeme2002@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 2:09 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org;CITY COUNCIL; climaterealityprojectoc@gmail.com Subject: Item #22-074:Vote To Support 100% Renewable Energy Default Rate Dear Mayor and City Council, Thank you Council for your clean energy leadership in Orange County! Please vote for 100% Renewables as your default rate as it is the easiest, most cost-effective, immediate, and significant way for a city to act on climate and reduce emissions. 1001/6 Renewable energy matters to me. Thank you! Gabriel Amaro Lake Forest SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION bleeting Date:r d I/122 Aacrtd3 rmrn No.: 7-41 t Switzer, Donna From: Linda Law <lindaklaw@aol.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 2:51 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda, Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean, Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION kles" Date: Agenda ttam No.: 1 Switzer, Donna From: Brittney Laver <brittney.laver@icloud.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 3:00 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim, Peterson, Erik, Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike, Moser, Natalie; Kaimick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean: Dills, Ken: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Maenng Date: Agenda ftm No, �` •2 2 - D T`i) 1 Switzer, Donna From: Brittany Gamboa <brittanygamboa4@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 3:26 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara, Carr, Kim, Peterson, Erik, Bolton, Rhonda, Posey, Mike, Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean: Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100% clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. Thank you, Brittany Gamboa SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION mwtkv cwa: e2 1122 _ cgenda (tow. No. /9 t Switzer, Donna From: Brittany Gamboa <pantheratigrisgrl@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 3:26 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda, Posey, Mike, Moser, Natalie, Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. Thank you, Brittany SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Me tg Date: Apride loam No: Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 2:42 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Agenda Item a 18 22-074 The rates we pick for our Misleading CCA Fraud. From: larry mcneely<Imwater@yahoo.com> Sent: Saturday, January 29, 2022 1:42 PM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Agenda Item q 18 22-074 The rates we pick for our Misleading CCA Fraud. Michael Posey came before our city council and claimed that by our joining the CCA our community would receive energy discounts of up to 9% Our City even paid $25,000 to a consultant to verity this? Can we ask for a refund? Now that we can see their plan there will be NO DISCOUNTS, what we will get is a Price Increase Regardless of what plan this council chooses we will receive the same energy mix as all the surrounding cities and who will pay less Our State passed SB43 that formed a choice for a mix of green energy tiers and is currently available without the extra cost of this overlapping CCA fraud which only adds costs of overhead and staff between the supplier and the end-user As Technology exists today we cannot separate what power or portion of that power is delivered to our community. There are no Magic filters that can separate the power on our energy grid to allow us 100% or any portion of power beyond the States Mandates of what portion SCE is required to provide We are currently using all the green energy being produced And then there will be the Fantasy that by our city going 100% or any portion of green energy it will inspire the advancement of Green Energy? The Only Thing that inspires Investments and Expansions is Profits. and as this technology is improved and cheaper storage advances have improved the price of this energy source will go down Lies and Misinformation will never drive our green energy goals I am a firm believer in the advancements of Carbon-Free Power but I will not be Deceived or Lied To by those who will only profit off these Fake CCA claims While I understand this council will ignore these realities and will likely vote to continue this Fraud because they were Duped by Michael Posey with the discounts and will continue this Fraud and Deception for their Green Energy Political Goals. The Truth will always overcome the Lies and Deceptions and your votes will only prove your ignorance. while we pay more for the same power mix Oh, and what happened to what Barbara Delgleize claimed that at the next city council meeting she would introduce an H-Item to dissolve the 'Trails to the Ocean' initiative because of all the negative input by the people who Irve on these channels? L.EMENTAL t".:ICATION l8(zZ - D�4 t Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 2:46 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Agenda Item 18. From: larry mcneely<Imwater@yahoo.com> Sent: Sunday,January 30, 2022 10:05 AM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda Item 18. It is one thing if you as a council want to Play Pretend we will be getting more green power with this CCA fraud But the city will be charging Real Money for this fantasy this while in fact we will be using the same energy mix as all the surrounding cities who will be paying less Prove Me Wrong SUPPLEtMENTAL INICATION maebna Dane. 02//122 Agenda ttom No.: t Switzer, Donna From: Mary Ann Celinder <macelinder@gmail.com> Swrt Monday, January 31, 2022 3:34 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara;Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike, Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org;CITY COUNCIL Subject Item 18:A safe future for me and my family . environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers. Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air,clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so 1 am writing to ask you to choose 100% clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic. Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100% clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION meeIN Date. 22 Agenda Item No.: Switzer, Donna From: Lamar Cox <lamar.kirchhevel@cox.net> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 4:03 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara, Carr, Kim, Peterson, Erik, Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family * environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. Lamar Kirchhevel PE SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date: eZ // /2 Z Agende nem No.: 1 S (Z 2— O 7-L/) t Switzer, Donna From: Diana <Diana.Light@rocketmail.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 4:06 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike, Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org: CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family t environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Council members, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100% clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100`Yo will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. Sent from my iPhone SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION kiowv Date:-a/l 12 Agenda Item No.: 122 t / t Switzer, Donna From: Patty Ebel <patty@ebelslock.com> Sent Monday,January 31, 2022 4:25 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers. Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100% clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 1001/6 will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that Thanks, Patty Ebel SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION MWO'Date: e11/12,z Agenda ttem No., -ZZ' 0 2: t Switzer, Donna From: Sheryl Martinez <sherylmartinez@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 4:54 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara;Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken;supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org;CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach and surrounding cities. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities. We need to prioritize economic development and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate- safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect our families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. Sheryl Martinez 714-393-1711 sherylmartinez@yahoo.com SUPPLEMENTAL COr4IMUNICATION Meeting Date. °Z Agenda rtem No:/8 ZZ - U �4 1 Switzer, Donna From: Alejandro <alejandrosobrera@gmail.com> Sent: Monday,January 31, 2022 5:02 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 1000/6 clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105.000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100% clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date. 2 i • 2 s Z _ a 71—,— Agenoa Mm NO- I O t Switzer, Donna From: Maria Sugranes <ladygracedem@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 508 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so 1 am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100% clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeang Date J 20 Agencia Item No., l8 ZZ ' t7 t Switzer, Donna From: Shelby Kliewer <sunshineshelbs@icloud.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 5:13 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you forjoining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach.The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually,which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year.This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy,you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. Shelby SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION r Det: ,2 _ Agenda nem iro. 1 Switzer, Donna From: HSB Chair <chair@hsb.surfrider.org> Sent: Monday,January 31, 2022 6:15 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org;CITY COUNCIL Subject Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Attachments: HB 100%Clean Energy.pdf Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air,clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake. so I am writing to ask you to choose 100% clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Please find attached a letter from us at the Huntington Beach/Seal Beach Chapter of the Surfrider Foundation asking that the Default be set at 100%. It is an easy step to have people change it to something else, if they would prefer something else. The awareness it brings will help people understand that we need Climate Action now. Thank You, KC Fockler Co-Chair HSB Surfrider SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Mes" DWo: a// /ZZ Agenda Item No., /$ ('Z2' 0�4 1 January 31, 2022 Submitted via email to: City.Council@surfcity-hb.org and Robin.Estanisiou@surfcity-hb.org Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers City of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Subject: Agenda item 18—SUPPORT for Clean Electricity Dear Honorable Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers: The Surfrider Foundation Huntington /Seal Beach Chapter reaches out to you regarding Agenda Item 18 for your selection of a default energy product for residential and commercial customers in the City of Huntington Beach. We write in support of the option for 100% clean energy. Emissions from methane gas burned to generate electricity are the second-largest source of emissions in our region and a major driver of climate change, which threatens every person, plant, and animal in Orange County. We are already seeing the effects of climate change along the coast with increased flooding near Sunset Beach over the years and indications that the proposed ocean desalination facility could be vulnerable to flooding. With warmer and fewer storms, there is less snowpack to supply the water needs of our landscapes, making them more vulnerable to fires. We then use water to put out the fires, leaving even less water for daily uses. As landscapes burn, they lose their capacity for carbon sequestration. Healthy forests store carbon dioxide—a greenhouse gas. Burned forests release carbon. Without immediate reductions in emissions, the cascade of impacts spirals on. With this in mind, we urge the Council to seize this opportunity to support the continued protection of the ocean, waves and beaches that we all cherish and choose 100%clean electricity for all of Huntington Beach. People who need to choose a different tier can do that easily, but the City should make a choice that will protect the only planet we have for future generations. We need your leadership to take swift action to stop this crisis Sincerely, KF Fackler, Chapter Chair, Surfrider Foundation Huntington/Seal Beach Chapter CC: sean.joyce@surfcity-hb.org, kdills@suf_f�it Ftpl—o1y, 190ecrieCtalComm@Surfcity-hb.org 5U TA COMMUNICATION Itom No.: Switzer, Donna From: marie-helene luebbers <mhluebbers@gmail.com> Sent: Monday,January 31, 2022 8:15 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken;supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Data: Agenda Item No.• �l 22Z� t Switzer, Donna From: Erin Spivey <erinisalibrarian@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 8:24 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara, Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean, Dills, Ken, supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers, As a born and raised Huntington Beach resident, the issue of our environment is very dear to me. HB would not the wonderful place it is if not for our world famous beaches, our astonishing ecological preserves, and our beautiful parks. I am now raising three children in our lovely city and want them to experience the gorgeous natural beauty HB has to offer. Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100% clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Sincerely, Meeting Date- Erin Spivey Agenda Item No.: 18(22 — 0 �y 1 Sent from my iphone, please excuse any typos 2 Switzer, Donna From: Azeem Syed <ASyed@instituteofknowledge.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 10:00 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie, Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean, Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL; Malek Bendelhoum; william.durso@charter.com; Benjamin.Brazil@latimes.com; mwisckol@scng.com; nbiesiada@voiceofoc.org; bpho@voiceofoc.org; tsheets@scng.com Subject: Request to consider 100% renewable energy default Dear Mayor Delgleize and Council Members, The Islamic Shura Council of Southern California is a nonprofit consortium of 80 Mosques and other Muslim organizations serving the Southern California community The Shura Council recognizes that taking action to care for the environment is part of Islamic ethics In 2015. Islamic leaders called on the world's 1 6 billion Muslims to play an active role in combating climate change The Islamic Declaration on Climate adopted at an International Islamic Climate Change Symposium called on the people of all nations and their leaders to phase out greenhouse gas emissions as soon as possible in order to stabilize greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere, and to commit themselves to 100% renewable energy and/or a zero emissions strategy as early as possible So we deeply appreciate the Huntington Beach council decision to join the OC Power Authority (OCPA) -- the first Community Choice Energy program in Orange County Thanks to that decision. you now have the opportunity to choose 100% renewable energy as the default choice for Huntington Beach energy users We are sending this letter to request that you use the power entrusted to you to choose 100% renewable energy as the default product for all Huntington Beach energy users. Our understanding is that like all Community Choice programs. OCPA will provide every ratepayer the ability to easily change their rate and energy product no matter what default product Huntington Beach selects We appreciate the flexibility this policy provides for Huntington Beach families and point out that because most people never change the default product selected by their city, your selection of a default product is of the utmost importance The Islamic Declaration on Climate calls on influential countries like the United States to recognize their "moral obligation to reduce consumption so that the poor may benefit from what is left of the Earth's non-renewable resources " Emissions created in Huntington Beach can affect our global environment By choosing 100% renewable energy now. you can create a meaningful reduction in emissions and provide a strong example to inspire other Orange County cities to do the same Thank you for your leadership on this critically important matter Azeem Syed SUPPLEMENTAL Board Chair, Islamic Shura Council of Southern California COMMUNICATION Strategic Planning Committee. Institute of Knowledge P. 562 713.2684 Email: asved(a)instituteofknowledge com y ZZ ivleeting Date._? Agenda Item 140.:_�8L t Switzer, Donna From: Sandra Smallshaw <sgsmallshaw@gmail.com> Sent: Monday,January 31, 2022 10:59 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org;CITY COUNCIL; Delgleize, Barbara; Michael Posey; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik, Kalmick, Dan; Moser, Natalie; Bolton, Rhonda Subject: Administrative item 22-074, in support of 100%default rate tier Dear Huntington Beach City Council members, Tomorrow, February I st,you'll take part in a historic vote which will decide the city's default renewable power rates. As a resident of Huntington Beach, I am writing to ask that you please vote for 100% Renewable Energy. The impacts of climate change will greatly affect us as a coastal community in the years and decades to come. Beach erosion and flooding are already threats in our city. Time is of the essence. By acting now with your vote to use renewable energy over carbon-based energy sources, you set the stage for carbon emission reductions in a meaningful way, and show your constituents that you support their concerns. I'm looking forward to talking with neighbors and other friends in Orange County about why I'm proud to live in Huntington Beach. With your vote for the 100%renewable energy default, I appreciate the hopeful message you're sending that - together- we can start to tackle this global problem. Thank you, Sandy Smallshaw SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION McMing Date. /2Z. AgerWa Rem No.: t Switzer, Donna From: Joclyn Rabbitt-Sire <joclynsire@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 11:32 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: City Council Meeting Agenda Item #18 Ik:ul itv ( 0uutcil Members. My name is Joclyn Rabbitt-Sire. and I have been a Huntington Beach resident for 23 grateful years I m writing to you today concerning the consequential vote on agenda item #18. the Orange County Power Authority (OCPA) Default Rate Selection. to be held at tonight's meeting I would like to voice my support for choosing 100% as the default percentage of renewable energy sources for residents. businesses. and even the City s municipal energy accounts I am cheered that Huntington Beach has already shown leadership by aligning itself with the OCPA, whose ideals work towards a more sustainable future The next step is for our city to make the bold choice to prioritize energy that lowers earth-warming emissions Frankly, I m very concerned about the earth we are leaving to our children and grandchildren. as I see evidence of a changing climate both locally and around the world with increasing frequency and seventy I personally know young people who are so fearful about the future of the environment that they are pessimistic about becoming parents Thankfully. we have an opportunity to quickly and easily reduce those earth-warming gases as a municipality, simply by opting for the 100% renewable energy default rate Showing bold leadership on this selection will have only positive effects for our city and the climate Along with reducing emissions, the 100% default rate will lead to competitive electricity rates, greater funding and implementation of necessary infrastructure projects. and more jobs for our local economy The most democratic part of it is that the city and all of its residents will continue to have choice! Because the stakes are so high and the benefits are so clear. I urge you to vote for the 100% renewable energy default rate for the good of our fair city and the world Thank you for your consideration Sincerely. Joclyn Rabbitt-Sire SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date: a-//2Z Agenda Item No.: 121(22 -7y t Switzer, Donna From: Sunrise OC <sunriseorangecounty@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 11:33 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken, supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org, CITY COUNCIL Subject: Our Youth Needs 100% Renewables Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers. We are Sunrise Movement Orange County, a youth-led movement working towards a future that is not threatened by the climate crisis We feel it is our duty to secure a livable planet for generations to come. Huntington Beach is a beautiful city full of children and families - taking a bold stance on renewable energy would show us your commitment to our youth Each year, climate change catastrophes grow more and more severe - fires. floods, and storms continue to worsen and break records across the nation We can't wait any longer to protect the future of our children There are so many things that make Huntington Beach stand out - wouldn't it be amazing to tout that we are one of the cleanest and greenest cities too? It's only a matter of time before more cities adopt policy to combat climate change. and right now you have the chance to stand confidently at the forefront of this transition as innovative leaders and heroes for your people. We are counting on you to make these critical choices and protect the livelihoods of future generations. Here at Sunrise, we fight to make sure that we. the youth of this country are heard, and right now we are all deeply worried about our future. Some of us struggle with anxiety, unsure of whether to have children given the bleak outlook that climate change has brought our generation But this decision can change that, and bring about a future we all can believe in. Please. fight for us Our community has just recently felt the impacts of unrestricted fossil fuel use with the huge oil spill off our coast. Right now more than ever we need bold action to protect us from further disaster Getting us 100% would prove to us that we chose our leaders correctly. This is the type of leadership we have been waiting for. Although 100% clean energy may come at a higher price, there would be a far greater price to pay if we leave any room for polluting fossil fuels Let us not stand idly by this growing fire. assuming it will shrink on its own, or assuming others will put it out. Let us come together and fight against this global threat Huntington Beach will be a leader not only to their own community. but to other cities in this fight, by demonstrating that we value the safety of our citizens, our planet. and our children. Please vote to move the city towards a 100% renewable option. Thank you. -Sunrise Movement Orange County SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting hare. d///22- Agenda Item No.: t Switzer, Donna From: S. Chartier-Grable <schartier-grable@ochabitats.org> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 7:3S AM To: Delgleize, Barbara;Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers. Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake. so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for all residents and species in Huntington Beach. Choosing 1009/6 will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105.000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. As a habitat conservationist in the Huntington Beach area, I see how urbanization has destroyed our precious habitats and how they struggle to rebound with the amount of pollution they have to deal with on a daily basis. We prioritize a sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 1001/6 clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. Sincerely, Stacey C. Chartier-Grable 949.697.8651 Schartier-arable(a ochabitate.ore SUPPLEMENTAL %%%.ochabitats.ora COMMUNICATION 0 Meatim Dabs:,..021//22 Aoenda Item No.: t Switzer, Donna From: Jacque Magner <jacann4@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 7:41 AM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik, Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike, Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history! Jacque Cunningham George SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date. °2 /'122 Agenda Item No.: F( .22 - 0 t Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 8:58 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Renewable Energy - Pro From: Bob Banzett<bob4change@earthlink.net> Sent:Tuesday, February 1, 2022 8:37 AM To:CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Renewable Energy-Pro I write to encourage you to opt for a default of 100%renewable energy for HB customers. I think that the arguments are obvious—we may or may not pay a bit more for power in the long run, but it is very clear that a shift to renewable energy will be good for our environment - both local SoCal air quality and the global carbon dioxide load will be improved as we shift to using less and less fossil fuel. This is something we can do, and seems to be a no-brainer. I would also urge that we purchase real renewable energy from local sources to encourage the development of local solar and wind generation, rather than energy `credits'. Lastly, I am concerned about leadership of OCPA and I hope we will keep a sharp eye on how it is run, as the CEO seems to be another under-qualified political insider. The client cities need to maintain pressure for transparency in this agency. Robert B Banzett PhD bob4change gOearthlink.nel SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date. Agerroa Item No., 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 5:46 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: I urge Huntington Beach City council Members to choose100% Renewal Electric. Power as our default From: Armida Brashears <armidahb@verizon.net> Sent: Monday, January 31, 2022 5:35 PM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.coun61@surfci1y-hb.org> Subject: I urge Huntington Beach City council Members to choose100% Renewal Electric. Power as our default I ask Mayor Delgleize, Council Member Carrr. Council Member Kalmick, Council Member Moser Council Member Bolton Please vote for 100 % renewable energy to be the default choice for Huntington Beach This will go a long way to reducing pollution and making our city more livable Thank you, Armida Brashears 55 year resident of Huntington Beach 21632 Hanakai Lane cell 714 330-3838 SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION McS*V Date: /2 /.2 Z Agenda Item No.: t Switzer, Donna From: Fran Delaney-Barron <frandelaneybarron@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 9:11 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Vote for 100% Renewable Energy Dear Huntington Beach City Council Members, 1 understand that there is an important item coming up for vote in Huntington Beach City Council which will address the percentage of renewable energy the city will provide to its residents,as a member of the Change County Power Authority. 1 strongly urge you to vote for 1001/6 renewable energy as our default percentage. As we face the realities of climate change and the environmental impacts it will have on our coastal city, I ask you to be bold in your vote in choosing the 1000/6 default rate. This is the easiest, most cost-effective, immediate, and significant way for a city to reduce emissions and help to mitigate climate change. For the price of one cup of coffee each month, every Huntington Beach home could be using 100% renewable energy for their electricity. As a coastal city, we have much to lose to the effects of climate change. Huntington Beach has stepped forward as leaders on many issues in the past and 1 ask that you choose the healthiest, safest and most effective means of addressing this crisis head on and supporting residents in doing the same. As a resident of Sunset Beach, in Huntington Beach for 31 years, 1, like everyone else, love the beauty of our coast and the healthy environment we continue to work towards. 1 am a retired educator of 27 years, and each day and year I worried about what the future would bring my students and their families. How do you prepare students for climate change?This is an opportunity for Huntington Beach to commit to a healthy future for our children,grandchildren, nieces and nephews, and students,and to stand out as a leader in what could be the crisis of our times if not boldly addressed. thank you. Fran Delaney-Barron 16391 S. Pacific #3 PO Box 298 Sunset Beach, CA 90742 SUPPLEMENYAL COMMUNICATION Mes"Dab: oZ r I Z Z Aoeraa►am No.: f 8 l Z 2 - D t > Switzer, Donna From: Nancy Curtis <nan.sea@earthlinknet> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 9:31 AM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick Dan Cc: Joyce,Sean; Dills, Ken;supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 1 B:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, It is very important that we are addressing the issue of climate change with transitioning to renewable energy. 100% renewable must be our goal if we are serious about providing a safe environment for future generations. If we cannot reach out goal, at least we will have given it our best try. It is time fora little sacrifice from easy economic gains. We can no longer plead ignorant. We must now transition to living on earth with respect and in reciprocity with nature. Coucilmembers please vote for tomorrow. Nancy Curtis na n.sea aea rth link.net SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION 3�r 12z ►+ieuDnG Date: — 2 2- D Agenda Item Switzer, Donna From: Greg Kordich <Ilk5@icloud.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 10:02 AM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim, Peterson, Erik, Bolton, Rhonda, Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean, Dills, Ken, supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org, CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach.The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100% clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. WE HAVE COME TO FAR DOWN THE PATH NOT TO CONTINUE TO 100%COMMUNITY CLEAN GREEN ENERGY. THANK YOU SINCERELY GREG & LYNN KORDICH 714 960-6264 SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Mw&V Dare: C1 l f -I2Z Agenda roam No.. t Switzer, Donna From: Marilyn Palomino <palominoccr@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 10:14 AM To: Delgleize, Barbara;Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik, Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken;supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Thank you for joining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100% clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meetkq Deft:_ 02 /1/2 2 Agenda Item No.: I F 6 22- 0 4/ 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 10:12 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: 211.2022 Agenda Item 18 From: Cathey Ryder<the4ryders@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, February 1, 2022 10:11 AM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: 2/1.2022 Agenda Item 18 Greetings to Mayor Delgleize and follow council members, As homeowners in Huntington Beach since 1985, we write in support of Agenda 18 Choosing clean electricity is one of the quickest, easiest, and most effective ways that a city can reduce emissions and fight the climate crisis. Huntington Beach has the opportunity to join Buena Park as a climate champion and leader in Orange County, setting a precedent for all other OC cities to follow. We recognize that there will most likely be hiccups along the way, but many cities in California have had success. Our granddaughters deserve our taking every effort to make sure that they will enjoy clean for all of their lives. Please adopt Agenda Item 18 with the safeguards that you have determined are necessary, Cathey and Bob Ryder Cathey Ryder " Optimism is the faith that leads to achievement. Nothing can be done without hope and confidence." Helen Keller SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Date. o2 IIA2 Agenda Item No., t Switzer, Donna From: Martin Schwab <marschwab®gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 11.41 AM To: Bolton, Rhonda; Delgleize, Barbara; Kalmickc Dan; Peterson, Erik; Carr, Kim; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie Cc: CITY COUNCIL;supplementalcommOsurfcity-hb.org; Dills, Ken;Joyce, Sean Subject: Item 18:A safe future for me and my family . environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers. Thank you forjoining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose I00°/a clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 1009/6 will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic. Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits(RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 1001/o clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeeng Date: agenda Item No.- t Switzer, Donna From: Linda K <lkteamtalk@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 11:46 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org, Carr, Kim, dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org, Peterson, Erik, Delgleize, Barbara, Bolton, Rhonda, Moser, Natalie, Posey, Mike Subject: Important facts in support of item 18, 100% Renewable Default Rate I r Huntington Beach! SUPP+EtNE11 AL COMMUNICATION Dear Mayor and City Council, Meeting Date: 1112 Z Please vote for 100% renewable energy for Huntington Beach. Agenda item Z� 4gea Item No.; With one simple vote Huntington Beach will save millions of lbs of fossil fuel emissions per year. Renewables are now the cheapest form of energy, and the prices continue to decline every year! https://www.wel'orum.orWapenda/2021/07/renewables-cheapest-energy-source/ Quick facts to remember the default rate: 1. The power default rate is what the city chooses - as a starting point. 2. Every single resident and business gets to choose if they want to stay with the default or make another choice. 3. A minimum of 4 notices will be sent regarding customers' choices, (it's required). 4. Residents/businesses stay (more than 90%) at the default rate where they start. S. Revenue from ratepayers (millions per year) stays local. After initial start-up, the revenue (no new taxes) goes back into local energy programs, NOT into the pocket of investors. Energy programs can and will save more money for customers. 6. Community Choice allows for competitive rates and clean energy choice instead of a MONOPOLY utility. Otherwise, customers have no choice, but to accept the yearly rate increases by SCE. 7. Cities are where 70% of emissions take place and cities are the 1st and most important place for cleaning up our energy. Other important information, financial and resilience facts: Community Choice Energy is a proven model with over 10 years of success, 23 CCAs, over 200 cities, counties and townships and 11 million happy customers (retention rate 93%). CCA increases opportunities for New Business in Cleantech (7/20/2020): Cleantech Companies Ride the Sustainable Investing Wave in LA htt ps://la business io u rnal.com/news/2020/iul/20/cleantech-com panies-sustainable-investing-la/ "Local government policies and incentives, however, would likely be key in determining where cleantech hubs eventually develop alongside the new investment, according to Hiatt." SCE Solar Rate Increase:Avg. 14.4% increase for residential customers for 2021-2024. https://www.sola rmaxtech.comZblop/p.2 002 2 4 000/southern-ca I iforn is-ed ison-sce-pla ns-144-rate-increase-in-2021/ CCAs are taking the lead to keep the lights on 24/7! https://ca1-cca.org/cca-resilience-initiatives/ 1 Programs like feed in tariffs and demand response programs help residents and businesses save even more: https://cal-cca.org/cca-programs, 6 CCAs have received increased credit ratings by Fitch and S& P: The latest is Sonoma Clean Power: https://cal-cca.org/sp-global-ratings-issues-a-credit-rati ng-to-sonoma-clean-power/ Here is the 100% Default information webpage https://www.greenbydefault.org/ Thank you so much for leading Orange County in giving us CHOICE in our electricity! For over 100 years, the large majority of Orange County has had NO Choice in their electricity provider! www.cal-cca.org for info. on Community Choice Energy! Thankyou! Linda Kraemer, M.S. Chapter Co-Chair The Climate Reality Project: Orange County, CA Chapter www.cl i matereal ityoc.com OC Clean Power- www.occleanpower.org LKTeamTalk d,'.ymail.com 0The Climate Reality Project ON %"k CUI�M1T\.�A WAVY!% www.facebook com/groups/climaterealityorangecounty wnyw instagram.com/climatereality orangecounty Twitter: @climateoc 2 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 12:02 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: SCE From:Taylor Haug<taylorhaug@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, February 1, 2022 10:59 AM To:CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:SCE Please choose the cheapest option. This was dubbed as a savings for HB residents, and is now, at the very least, just as expensive. This was a horrible choice in the first place, but don't make it worse. Thank you, Taylor Haug SUPPLEMENTAL Crt-lMvU1N1CATION Meeting Date. .2111.2.2, Agenda Item No.; g -Z.2 — /� t Switzer, Donna From: Alexis Hernandez <alexis@climateactioncampaign.org> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 12:19 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Agenda Item 18- Key environmental justice, rate, default and participation info Attachments: Pollution Burden in HB communities .png; Pollution Burden in HB communities 2.png; 2022-02-01 CAC letter to Huntington Beach re OCPA rate selection.pdf SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION CIIMAT fGGT110N "'w ft Date: C ♦ M i A 1 G N Agenda Item No.; Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, In advance of today's discussion of OCPA default rate selection for the City of Huntington Beach, Climate Action Campaign would like to offer information and resources that may be helpful. Climate Action Campaign is a nonprofit climate policy watchdog that is working to end the climate crisis and advance equity and justice through effective policy action. We worked for five years to build the community will for what is now the OC Power Authority because we know that Community Choice is any city's fastest path to 100% clean electricity. We would like to highlight and clarify key information about the environmental justice, rate, and participation impacts of the options before you tonight. ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE IMPACTS • Huntington Beach's environmental justice communities have historically and are currently shouldering disproportionate burdens of pollution under our fossil fuel-powered energy and transportation systems. • According to Cal Enviroscreen, areas of Huntington Beach range from the 74th to 92nd percentile for pollution burden among California neighborhoods. o This pollution is disproportionately impacting people of color in Huntington Beach. The only three census tracts in Huntington Beach that are predominantly Hispanic are the three census tracts with the most pollution burden. • Long-term exposure to air pollution can cause respiratory illness, cardiovascular disease, and impact brain development. o The most polluted area in Huntington Beach (between Talbert Ave and Warner Ave) is in the 40th percentile among California communities for asthma and 35th percentile for cardiovascular disease. These can be symptoms of chronic exposure to pollution and can cause more health risks and strain to the healthcare system if continued exposure is left unabated. 1 • Attached are multiple maps which show the pollution. health impacts. and demographics of the Huntington Beach communities that will benefit most from a reduction of emissions Additionally. you can use the Cal Enviro 4.0 tool to view pollution burden results across all areas of Huntington Beach. • Huntington Beach residents, especially those who are already the most vulnerable due to health concerns. would benefit most from the 100% renewables default and emissions reductions. This is an opportunity to correct environmental injustices in Huntington Beach by dramatically reducing GHG emissions RATES • OCPA's pricing relative to SoCal Edison and other Investor Owned Utilities will likely go down in the next few months SDG&E announced this month that their prices will go up nearly 8% on average. PG&E prices will go up around 9%. This is due in large part to the rising cost of "natural" methane gas. which the IOUs burn to generate much of their electricity • Like SDG&E and PG&E, SoCal Edison (SCE) prices are expected to go up in the next few months, but OCPA prices have been set. This means that what looks like a price premium relative to SCE today will likely go down in the near future, likely before OCPA commercial and industrial customers launch in April. •According to OCPA s Jan 11. 2022 rate design staff report (p. 5). if any OCPA city chooses less than 70% as its default then OCPA's 38 5% renewable product will be 2.2% more expensive than SCE minimum renewable product This does not account for the expected SCE price increase mentioned above . This means that if Huntington Beach does not select 70% or 100% renewable, then families in Huntington Beach already experiencing the worst air pollution and paying the highest proportion of household income on energy bills would essentially be paying to keep their communities polluted and financially strapped because energy will be more expensive for everyone DEFAULTS & PARTICIPATION RATES • 28 California cities and counties have selected 100% renewable as their default through Community Choice Energy—some since 2016 Buena Park voted to make 100% renewable their default on Jan 25. 2022 . Data from the Clean Power Alliance. the Los Angeles Community Choice Energy program, demonstrates that very few Community Choice Energy customers ever opt out, regardless of which product their city selects as the default •With Community Choice Energy, ratepayers always have a choice no matter what default product their city selects Individuals can always choose a different product if they want or need to Thank you for considering this information. Please let us know if you have any questions Sincerely. Lexi Hernandez (she/her) 2 Orange County Climate Equity Organizer and Advocate Climate Action Campaign (714) 381-4446 www dimateactioncampawn org Twitter �Isdclimateaction Instagram �sdchrnateactlon Facebook com/ClimateActionCampaign Like what we do? Support Climate Action Campaign today. Our Mission is Simple: Stop the Climate Crisis 3 L"-A Ca'lFm.'.vbtltlno S_.ctl.nrwOo � • wm mtb ol nG rmt�9eIdr.IM.b..". hcSMw".Mr.avrhrrebK".rbsru...44b[.glOr�9r2 Yr.c.l rrPrgorG.p.`4 9Ma5I I0l o ia SoA.M 40 W mnbW co gw 0 2I CMu �O 93 10 35 .tl 25 Lc M # .n0 wwM 90 rrlMc.dw 95 59 lb.d Iran Knvey 71 clwwsb. u <wtn.xa5a,..n.0 N•qn vdr.rwn.la Paµi.r.on (waN.wy.ilrn.b 50 119erEan Wu.. /d 4gwbd W. 12 S9ME W�wb Po 4.rhm. �0 I on B•nh 55'..gln )• (��tlro...cmn Pw« l5 FEucw•on 79 l•ryui.ec rwl.hon 51 Po.nY t0 Urwrrpbynrwn 3 lburrry Burtlni Po 3 N9c9/EMnicny Rolrb. .a...r.u'+.a..o...rn.rw.n«.pn•..+w«r.n r..✓wr....H .•9....•nw....•a row..m.r..wn. Ag9 N.M . rror w+•o•.r o.�m.9.arun w9+r.n«m.q .ncc 605909an,trcPd.bP:s..s,I bltn..,ex.wrr.o Itwl,. rq..wm rn.�.nwuw..r.•�.y a,«.n arw,eos.oavr� a10 rM1.'W.Yaal � rr >p p (.�I w•rnSaw.•Ohn mu4 •.. .M G � T. �i • h.l,.mn P...e..M1wr.n.' n.n q /3 a.roc ..f C#..Ya6er a0 Nyl.h W.w�s.'ap.r+.. Ed. .prmc eo,rrur. IMn, e: .burg h,ra.. N Itac./EMnrcny Pr44. Rq P,oRiw CLIMATE ACTION C A M P A I G N Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers. In advance of today's discussion of OCPA default rate selection for the City of Huntington Beach, Climate Action Campaign would like to offer information and resources that may be helpful Climate Action Campaign is a nonprofit climate policy watchdog that is working to end the climate crisis and advance equity and justice through effective policy action. We worked for five years to build the community will for what is now the OC Power Authority because we know that Community Choice is any city's fastest path to 100% clean electricity. We would like to highlight and clarify key information about the environmental justice. rate, and participation impacts of the options before you tonight. ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE IMPACTS • Huntington Beach s environmental justice communities have historically and are currently shouldering disproportionate burdens of pollution under our fossil fuel-powered energy and transportation systems. • According to Cal Enviroscreen areas of Huntington Beach range from the 74th to 92nd percentile for pollution burden among California neighborhoods This pollution is disproportionately impacting people of color in Huntington Beach The only three census tracts in Huntington Beach that are predominantly Hispanic are the three census tracts with the most pollution burden. • Long-term exposure to air pollution can cause respiratory illness cardiovascular disease and impact brain development. The most polluted area in Huntington Beach (between Talbert Ave and Warner Ave) is in the 40th percentile among California communities for asthma and 35th percentile for cardiovascular disease These can be symptoms of chronic exposure to pollution and can cause more health risks and strain to the healthcare system if continued exposure is left unabated. • Attached are multiple maps which show the pollution, health impacts, and demographics of the Huntington Beach communities that will benefit most from a reduction of emissions. Additionally, you can use the Cal Enviro 4.0 tool to view pollution burden results across all areas of Huntington Beach. • Huntington Beach residents, especially those who are already the most vulnerable due to health concerns, would benefit most from the 100% renewables default and emissions reductions. This is an opportunity to correct environmental injustices in Huntington Beach by dramatically reducing GHG emissions. RATES • OCPA's pricing relative to SoCal Edison and other Investor Owned Utilities will likely go down in the next few months. SDG&E announced this month that their prices will go up nearly 8% on average. PG&E prices will go up around 9%. This is due in large part to the rising cost of"natural" methane gas, which the IOUs burn to generate much of their electricity. • Like SDG&E and PG&E, SoCal Edison (SCE) prices are expected to go up in the next few months, but OCPA prices have been set. This means that what looks like a price premium relative to SCE today will likely go down in the near future, likely before OCPA commercial and industrial customers launch in April. • According to OCPA's Jan. 11, 2022 rate design staff report (p. 5), if any OCPA city chooses less than 70% as its default, then OCPA's 38.5% renewable product will be 2.2% more expensive than SCE's minimum renewable product. This does not account for the expected SCE price increase mentioned above. • This means that if Huntington Beach does not select 70% or 100% renewable, then families in Huntington Beach already experiencing the worst air pollution and paying the highest proportion of household income on energy bills would essentially be paying to keep their communities polluted and financially strapped because energy will be more expensive for everyone. DEFAULTS & PARTICIPATION RATES • 28 California cities and counties have selected 100% renewable as their default through Community Choice Energy—some since 2016. Buena Park voted to make 100% renewable their default on Jan. 25, 2022. • Data from the Clean Power Alliance. the Los Angeles Community Choice Energy program demonstrates that very few Community Choice Energy customers ever opt out, regardless of which product their city selects as the default. • With Community Choice Energy ratepayers always have a choice no matter what default product their city selects. Individuals can always choose a different product if they want or need to. Thank you for considering this information. Please let us know if you have any questions. Sincerely. Lexi Hernandez (she/her) Orange County Climate Equity Organizer and Advocate Climate Action Campaign (714) 381-4446 www.climateactioncamoawn.ora Twitter Asdci mateaction Instagram !dsdc6mateaction Facebook.com/ClirnateActionCampaian Like what we do? Support Climate Action Camoaian today. Our Mission is Simple: Stop the Climate Crisis Switzer, Donna From: Lisa Swanson clisainlb@ymail.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 12:24 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Feb 1 mtg agenda items 18 and 8 Dear Mayor and City Council Representatives, thank you for your service to our community and the opportunity to comment on the above listed agenda items. I am 12yr resident of Southeast Huntington Beach and a proud environmental activist and bike rider. Your decision this evening on Agenda Item 18 will probably be the most critical action that you take this year to address air pollution and climate change. Choosing a 100%renewable energy default is one of the quickest, easiest, and most effective ways that a city can reduce emissions and fight the climate crisis. Huntington Beach took a bold step in joining the Orange County Power Authority, and now we need to support the OCPA in its mission to source renewable energy at cost effective rates. Save our planet and save money; what a great opportunity! And the beauty of community choice energy is everyone can make their personal choice so that no one will be forced to support a 1001/6 renewable energy portfolio. Regarding Agenda Item 8, I am very disappointed with the decision to not open the Talbert Channel as a pedestrian and bike path. In my opinion,this would have been a major improvement in my neighborhood greatly improving the quality of life of our residents. I appreciate the City's commitment to improve pedestrian and bike safety and look forward to working with you on alternatives to the Talbert Channel project. Any improvements to street bike lanes will need to be combined with increased traffic enforcement to reduce the rampant speeding and running of red lights that has been getting worse every year along Hamilton Ave and cross streets leading into SE Huntington. Thanks again for your time and commitment. Regards, Lisa Swanson SUPPLEMENTAL CCi'ti911 UNICATION Mee"Date: a // )Z- Agenda Item No: /g 2'?- 0 r Switzer, Donna From: Paul Horgan <pchorgan@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 1:22 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: renewable energy Dear Mayor Delgleize, Mayor Pro Tern Posey and City Councilmembers: Please vote yes on item 22-074 to set the default rate @ 100% renewable energy for every Huntington Beach energy user through the Orange County Power Authority. Thank you. Respectfully, Paul and Flossie Horgan 5652 Castle Drive Huntington Beach, CA SUPPLEMEWAL COMMUNICATION Mea*V ogre: .2 // J°2°2' — Agenda Item No. ?122 0 L4, 1 Switzer, Donna From: Steven C Shepherd Architect <steve@ shepherd architects.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 1:40 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: AGENDA ITEM #18 - SELECT 100% RENEWABLE CHOICE AGENDA ITEM #18: OCPA DEFAULT RATE SELECTION My name is Steve Shepherd, and I strongly support selecting the 100% Renewables Choice as the default option for commercial, residential and municipal accounts in Huntington Beach. Many things have changed since I first began advocating for a Community Choice Energy (CCE) feasibility study for our community back in 2017. However, one thing remains very much the same: It pays to be a leader! Our community benefits when we take steps proactively to meet the challenges of tomorrow, and we must not hesitate in leading efforts to address climate change now. lust as joining the Orange County Power Authority (OCPA) as a founding member was aspirational in providing residents new options and opportunities, the decision before you today should be met with the same level of ambition and hope for a better tomorrow. Our actions today are critical to the ongoing viability of our community in the future. I urge you to act with a resolve to embrace a bold and innovative future for Huntington Beach. I encourage you to select the 100% Renewables Choice. Thank you. Sincerely, Steve Shepherd Huntington Beach 92646 SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meebgp Date. Agonda %m No.� t Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 2:28 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Renewable energy From: Randy Benton <rbenton@smardan.com> Sent:Tuesday, February 1, 2022 2:26 PM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Renewable energy I am a long time resident of Huntington Beach, and I VOTE. I am writing to encourage you to vote to have 100% of our energy come from renewable sources such as local solar, wind, and storage. This will help ensure that we have a livable future by ensuring that the sources are local and NOT unbundled renewable energy credits. Directing the OC Power Authority to purchase power from clean, local sources will ensure that we actually reduce emissions and, create jobs, and have a better future. The source of the renewable energy is also critically important. Thank you, Cynthia Benton 19577 Mayfield Circle Huntington Beach, CA 92648 i Switzer, Donna From: Ellen Garibaldi <ellenmgaribaldi@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 2:32 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik, Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean, Dills, Ken, supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and councilmembers. Thank you forjoining the CC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community_ at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100% clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me. my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100% will reduce emissions by 481.833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105.000 cars off the road every year. This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, .Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RLCs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100% clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energyjobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. Let'sjoin with Buena Park' Thank you. Ellen Garibaldi t Switzer, Donna From: Tomas Castro <tscastro0801 @hotmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 2:47 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Dills, Ken;supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Agenda Item 18 Dear Mayor Delgeize and City Councilmembers, My name is Tomas Castro and 1 am a 12-year resident of Orange County. I am also 20 years old. I would like to write to you today to urge you to adopt a 100%renewable energy default option from the Orange County Power Authority when you consider Agenda Item 18 in tonight's city council meeting. Doing so would not only reduce emissions at the local level, but it represents an opportunity for Huntington Beach to establish itself as a regional leader on climate, while safeguarding the future of myself and my peers. Please vote for 100% renewable energy tonight. Thank you, Tomas Castro Get Outlook for Android 1 Switzer, Donna From: Derek Gladstone <derekmgladstone@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 3:02 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; dan.kalmick@surfcity.hb.org Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me, my family, and future generations of Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and council members, I was shocked to hear that there is not unanimous support for 100%default clean energy, especially considering our community has just recently felt the impacts of unrestricted fossil fuel use with the huge oil spill off our coast. Right now more than ever we need bold action to protect us from further disaster. The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Right now you have the opportunity to make such a lasting impact on our community. We really are counting on you all so much to take charge and lead our city in the right direction. Please understand the urgency and importance of tackling climate change, not only on a local level, but globally, too. Please prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs.The OC Power Authority has still not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100%clean energy, you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and becoming champions for our economy and future generations. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families. Please make the right choice of being the innovative leaders we need in this urgent time. Thank you, Derek Gladstone 1 Switzer, Donna From: Newport Beach Women's Democratic Club <Info@ NBWDC.org> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 3:40 PM To: CITY COUNCIL, Delgleize, Barbara. Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik, Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike, Moser, Natalie, Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean, Dills, Ken, supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Public Comments: Agenda Item 18: Request to consider 100% renewable energy default Attachments: Renewable Energy Default_HBCC_220201.pdf Dear Mayor Delgleize and City Council Members. We urge you to select Huntington Beach's default energy as 100% renewable for the reasons we have outlined in our attached public comments. We thank you for making Huntington Beach a founding member of the Orange County Power Authority,and believe taking the steps outlined in Agenda Item #18 will provide the leadership incentive for additional communities to follow. eaz�au u ';7ku&Jt# President Newport Beach Women's Democratic Club Advocating for Democratic values in Newport Beach P O Box 11761 I Newport Beach. CA 92658 1949 423 6468 NBWDC ord I Facebooki rwitternnstagram @NBWDC Paid for by the Newport Beach Women Democratic Club. FEC IDN C00570168 Note Your donations and payments to political-party organizations. like NBWDC. are not tax-deductible 1 Newport Beach Women's Democratic Club Advocating for Democratic Values in Newport Beach and neighboring communities ' PO Box 11761 1 Newport Beach, CA 92658 NBWDC.org I Info@NBWDC.org 1 949.423.6468 Facebook, Twitter, Instagram @NBWDC February 1, 2022 OFFICERS Huntington Beach City Council sent by email PRESIDENT Catharine Hardesty Subject: Agenda Item 18: Request to consider 100% renewable energy default VICE PRESIDENT Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Kathleen Andrews The Newport Beach Women's Democratic Club (NBWDC) supports progressive values TREASURER and works tirelessly to seat Democratic candidates in our local, state and federal Mikelle Fish governments with a focus on climate action, inclusion and equality for all. CORRESPONDING SECRETARY We believe that Community Choice Energy is a powerful local tool for addressing the Deborrah Lugo emissions that are driving both the climate crisis and environmental injustice,and so we thank you for making Huntington Beach a founding member of the Orange RECORDING SECRETARY County Power Authority. Karen Tringali As you consider the selection of a default energy product for Huntington Beach, IMMEDIATE please remember that defaults are an incredibly powerful tool for change. Studies PAST PRESIDENT show that most people stay with the default. The default isn't a mandate, it is simply Laura Oatman a suggestion, providing customers the freedom to choose another plan at all times. FOUNDING The urgency of the climate crisis requires policymakers to transition to clean, PRESIDENT renewable energy immediately.The UN's IPCC report last year issued a "code red for Dr. Sue Savary humanity", warning that all governments everywhere must make rapid,far-reaching and unprecedented changes in all aspects of society to keep temperatures under 1.5'C.This means no more half measures and no more kicking the can down the road. In addition, Huntington Beach's environmental justice communities have historically and are currently shouldering disproportionate burdens of pollution under our fossil fuel-powered energy and transportation systems. According to Cal Enviroscreen, areas of Huntington Beach range from the 74th- 92rd percentile for pollution burden among California communities r\ NBWDC is affiliated with the Central Committee of the Democratic Party of Orange County Vand was duly chartered by DPOC in February 2008. Newport Beach Women's Democratic Club Advocating for Democratic Values in Newport Beach and neighboring communities ' PO Box 11761 ( Newport Beach, CA 92658 NBWDC.org ( Info@NBWOC.org 1 949.423.6468 Facebook, Twitter, Instagram @NBWDC February 1, 2022 Huntington Beach City Council Page 2 Air pollution disproportionately impacts people of color in Huntington Beach. In fact,the only three census tracts in Huntington Beach that are predominantly Hispanic are also the three census tracts with the highest pollution burden (see map below). Please use this opportunity to address environmental injustice and the climate crisis in Huntington Beach and everywhere by dramatically reducing emissions through the selection of 100% renewable as the default for Huntington Beach. The NBWDC Board and members thank you for your stewardship. Sincerely, Catharine Hardesty Catharine Hardesty President To: Huntington Beach City Council City.CouncilCa.surfcity-hb orq Barbara Delgleize. Mayor barbara delgleize(@surf city-hb org Kim Carr kim.carr(a surfcity-hb.org Erik Peterson enk Deters onta')surfcity-hb org, Rhonda Bolton Rhonda Boltonasurfcity-hb org, Mike Posey mike posev(a surfcity-hb.org Natalie Moser natalie.moser(&surfcity-hb org, Dan Kalmick dan.kalmick(cDsurfcity-hb org, cc Huntington Beach City Staff Sean Joyce sean loviceasurfcity-hb orq K Dills kdillsasurfcity-hb org Supplemental Commission SupplementalComm aaSurfcity-hb.org NBWDC is affiliated with the Central Committee of the Democratic Party of Orange County 6 and was duly chartered by DPOC in February 2008. Newport Beach Women's Democratic Club Advocating for Democratic Values in Newport Beach and neighboring communities t ' PO Box 11761 1 Newport Beach, CA 92658 NBWDC.org I Info@NBWDC.org 1 949.423.6468 Facebook, Twitter, Instagram @NBWDC Huntington Sexb X F) v+w� oso�aoo� 01,0' Mean Wk 6b lyra�lw I� .a law i f v� V.L.%GA USGS I Cx.I M rmub 64 % Co v a w Mpvn CaMan Su a►i,r.Ev 41M Grew,SaMpee .KTWOK IRK. e --a I rm M MM UEM /\ NBWDC is affiliated with the Central Committee of the Democratic Party of Orange County Vand was duly chartered by DPOC in February 2008. Switzer, Donna From: Craig Preston <craigp4444@gmaii.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 12:22 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Admin Item 22-074: YES for default rate tier at 100% renewable electricity Dear Mayor Delgleize. Mayor Pro Tern Posey and City Councilmembers, Some problems allow for lots of time to solve them. Oil spills and climate change are NOT those types. The timing of our actions matters Scientists agree that a 4 degree C hotter Earth is vastly WORSE than a 2 degree C hotter Earth Huntington Beach has an opportunity to be a leader in the clean energy future Let's harness the power of fresh sun, as well as the many other renewable sources. I ask for your YES vote of item 22-074 to set the default rate tier at 100% renewable energy for every HB energy user through the OC Power Authority Grateful for your urgent response to the need for ACTION. Craig Craig Preston Costa Mesa. CA 92626 Citizens' Climate Lobby, OC Coast Chapter, Co-Leader (714) 473-2798 Craig P4444(d)gmail.com Virus-free www avast corn 1 Switzer, Donna From: Margo Finlayson <margo.ipc@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 12:01 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL; Climate Reality Project Orange County Subject: Vote for 100% Renewable Default Rate - Item 22-074 Dear Mayor and City Council, I support 1000/6 renewable energy as the default rate for the . The 100% renewable energy default is one of the easiest, most cost-effective, immediate, and significant ways for communities to act on climate and reduce emissions and provide a healthier future for residents. Currently, 18 out of 31 Cities in LA Clean Power Alliance have chosen 100%. We appreciate your leadership on clean energy as part of OCPA. With emissions rising, I support going even further by making 100%renewable the default rate. The cost is about $2.13 per average household, and any household where this is a hardship could easily opt down to choose a lower rate. Thank you! Margo Finlayson, MBA Margo Allen Finlayson, MBA Co-Chair, Climate Reality Orange County CA Chapter www.climaterealitvoc.com facebook.com/proups/climaterealitvoranaccounty/ instagram.com/climatereality oran¢ecounty Twitter: @climateoc email: climaterealitvoroiectocrgmail.com direct email: margo_iK6&gmail.com t Switzer, Donna From: Climate Reality Project Orange County <climaterealityprojectoc@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 3:58 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org;CITY COUNCIL Cc: Climate Reality Project Orange County Subject: Item 22-074: In support of the 100%default rate tier Attachments: Huntington Beach-CRP Letter CityCouncil 02-01-2022.pdf Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, Climate Reality OC would like to express our commitment to 1001/6 clean, renewable energy for Orange County and urge you to vote for 100% renewable energy as Huntington Beach's default rate. Please see the attached letter in support of the 100%renewable energy default rate tier. Sincerely The Climate Reality Project Leadership Team: Linda Kraemer - LKteamtalkCd�gmail com Margo Finlayson - margo ipc(cDgmail com Tristan Miller-Mansey - tnstanCcDmansey com Lisa Swanson - lisainlb,a ymail com The Climate Reality Project www.climaterealitvoc.co climatereal itvoroiectoc(ccDgmail.com www.facebook.com/�Qroups/climaterealitvoran-gecoun www.instagram.com/climatereality Oranaecounty If you no longer wish to receive our OC Chapter emails please click'reply'and let us know 1 The Climate Reality Project ORANGE COUNTY, CA CHAPTER February I,2022 Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers: The Orange County Chapter of Climate Reality Project was founded to advocate for clean air, water, the protections our land, and the health of all California communities by supporting environmentally responsible actions in our community. The UN IPCC issued a dire report,a "code red for humanity", warning that all governments,at all levels everywhere,must make rapid, far-reaching and unprecedented changes in all aspects of society to keep temperatures under 1.5°C. Our Chapter of over 300 members, including members from the City of Huntington Beach, stands with our neighbors and friends in our commitment to environmental justice for communities which are disproportionately impacted by pollution and health issues, such as those in Huntington Beach. Many of our members have spent weeks, months,years advocating for this moment and to bring Community Choice Energy to Orange County. We are proud of your leadership as one of the first cities to join the OCPA. We are writing you today to urge you to vote for 100% renewable energy as the default rate. Not only is this in line with the state of California's clean energy targets, the 100% renewable energy default is one of the easiest, most cost-effective, immediate, and significant ways for communities to act on climate, reduce emissions and provide a healthier future for residents. Fossil fuels burned for electricity generation are the second largest source of emissions in our region, so it is crucial that the city stop their use as soon as possible. More than 200 cities,counties and townships in California have successfully taken this step of making 100% renewable energy their default through a Community Choice Energy program. Currently, 18 out of 31 Cities in LA Clean Power Alliance have chosen 100%. 100% Renewable energy matters to us,to our Orange County community,and to our future! Sincerely, Margo Finlayson Chapter Co-Chair,Climate Reality OC Linda Kraemer Chapter Co-Chair,Climate Reality OC Tristan Miller Chapter Vice Chair,Climate Reality OC Lisa Swanson Policy Chair,Climate Reality OC &glad chmatereaOtyDlolectoOODGmad corn - www camaterealityoc corn - fwebw k com/gmupslchmatematifyorangecounty mstagram coMc6matemality_orargecounty - Twitter @cbmatem Switzer, Donna From: Max Lyons <maxlyons47@icloud.com> Sent: Wednesday, February 2, 2022 12:34 PM To: Delgleize, Barbara; Carr, Kim; Peterson, Erik; Bolton, Rhonda; Posey, Mike; Moser, Natalie; Kalmick, Dan Cc: Joyce, Sean; Dills, Ken; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL Subject: Item 18: A safe future for me and my family + environmental justice for Huntington Beach Dear Mayor Delgleize and Councilmembers, I am writing to ask that you please vote to support 100%clean energy being used in our cities. We are running out of time to take drastic action to address the climate crisis and switching to renewable energy is an important first step. Please vote for a livable future. Thank you forjoining the OC Power Authority to help bring clean air, clean energy and environmental justice to Huntington Beach.The climate crisis has put the safety of our community at stake, so I am writing to ask you to choose 100%clean energy as the default for HB to ensure a climate safe future for me, my family, and everyone in Huntington Beach. Choosing 100%clean energy will reduce emissions by 481,833 metric tons of carbon annually, which is equivalent to taking nearly 105,000 cars off the road every year.This will also put the health and safety of our community members first by alleviating pollution that disproportionately impacts Hispanic, Asian, and working class communities in Huntington Beach. We need to prioritize economic development in Huntington Beach and create a thriving and sustainable economy with local sources of clean energy that create local jobs. The OC Power Authority has not committed to not using unbundled Renewable Energy Credits (RECs). Unbundled RECs will send jobs and economic development out of Huntington Beach, and won't significantly reduce emissions or pollution. Huntington Beach needs to tell OCPA that we don't want unbundled RECs. By choosing 100`Ya clean energy,you can secure a livable and climate-safe future while addressing environmental injustice, providing clean energy jobs, and boosting our economy. You have the power to make our city a national leader and protect Huntington Beach families from unnecessary pollution from emissions. Thank you for being the leader we need at this critical time in history. Your constituent, Maxwell Lyons 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Thursday, February 3, 2022 9:54 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: 'Renewable Energy Choice' From:Jean Habdank <jehabdank@earthlink.net> Sent: Tuesday, February 1, 2022 6:33 PM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: "Renewable Energy Choice" 1 don't understand why you're bothering with a selective choice of a "Renewable Energy Choice" when they can raise prices above SCE. You don't know how reliable or how costly this will be. You seem to be banking on the error people will make by NOT be"opting out". Everyone will "opt out"except people that don't read the material you send. This is a frivolous waste of your time and our money! See the news articles in the below website It's failed in the past and will in the future. It marks the first time a CCA in California has closed (Riverside. CA) due to financial pressure. After little more than one year in business, a community choice energy program serving about 113,000 customers in Riverside County has closed its doors for good in the wake of mounting debt obligations. https:,rwunv.go"ic.com'search'?a=riverside+cca*bankrupt*&client=satari&hl=en- us&ei=VXi5YdSOlaHHkPIP3YSroAM&ogziverside+cca+bankrupt+&¢s lcn=ChNtb2JpbGUtZ3dzLXdpejlz ZXJwEAM6Bw¢AEEcOsAM6CwgpE IAEEMcBEKBBOgUIIRC izAToFCCE0awl6C¢¢nEMcBEKBBEEM6B O E¢A IAEOgizIABCABBDJAzoICAAO¢AOOsOM6CA&uEIAEELEDOgsILhCABBDHARCvAToRCC4OeA OOsOMOgwEOxwEOowl6EOIzuEIAEE LEDEI MBEMcBEKBBOg41 LhCABBCxAxDHARCvAToHC AAOgA 0OCjoECAAOCjoHCAAOyOMOC joHCAAOsOMOC joHCC4OsOMOCj oKCC4OxwEOrwEOC ioECAAOD ToHCAAOYOMODToKCC40xwEOrwEQDToGCAAODRAeOgklABDJAxANEB46CAgAEA20DRAeOpII AEoECEEYAFCmCFiARmC9TmgBcAF4AYABhwOlAbkkkizEIMS4yNi4xLjKYAOC AOHIA 4AAOE&scl ient=mobile-gws-wiz-serp&fbclid=lwAR31 aJFM- npin6GR4CrBvOKzRPwJbsxnW2c9vL4oO12GchOYJKi26Ma 6wo Thank you, Jean Habdank iehabdanknn earthlink.net Sent from my Wad t Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Monday, February 7, 2022 10:57 AM To: Switzer, Donna Subject: OCPA Default Choice From: Gino J. Bruno<gbruno@socal.rr.com> Sent: Monday,January 31, 2022 12:00 PM To: CITY COUNCIL<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Cc:Joyce, Sean <Sea n.Joyce @surfcity-hb.org>; Hopkins, Travis<thopkins@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: OCPA Default Choice Council members: Regarding Agenda Item #18 . . . One of the options the City Council will consider at its meeting on Tuesday, Feb. 1 s' is to require all customers to receive "100% Renewable Choice" energy and pay a premium rate and price, unless they affirmatively opt out. For clarity . . . If the City Council chooses this option, and if I were to do nothing and thus be charged a premium price, but my next-door neighbor were to opt out (stays with SCE) and is charged a lesser price, will you guarantee that I will receive 100% renewable-sourced electricity since I would be paying more, and my neighbor, paying less, will receive different electricity? Thank you. Gino J. Bruno Huntington Beach t