HomeMy WebLinkAboutConsider and Direct Staff to Forward the 2022 Housing Elemen (2) PP1eo v D -O
0,mNGTA'' 2000 Main Street,
oF�a.,as4o„,s�?� Huntington Beach, CA
a F
: _ : 92648
City of Huntington Beach
afT
�?cF�UUN" CPlo
File #: 23-183 MEETING DATE: 3/21/2023
REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION
SUBMITTED TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members
SUBMITTED BY: Al Zelinka, City Manager
VIA: Ursula Luna-Reynosa, Director of Community Development
PREPARED BY: Nicolle Aube, AICP, Senior Management Analyst
Subject:
Consider and direct staff to forward the 2022 Housing Element Annual Progress Report to the
California Department of Housing and Community Development and the Governor's Office of
Planning and Research
Statement of Issue:
State law requires cities and counties to prepare a Housing Element Annual Progress Report (APR)
to track progress made on their respective Housing Element implementation efforts. The APR is due
to HCD and OPR by April 1 every year to provide data on the prior calendar year. City staff has
prepared Huntington Beach's APR for calendar year 2022 for the City Council's consideration. Filing
an APR is required in order to continue receiving Permanent Local Housing Allocation funds (PLHA)
for homelessness response programs, in addition to other regional and state funds. Pursuant to
Government Code Section 65913.4(4)(a), proposed housing developments are entitled to SB 35
streamlining (ministerial approval) if the City fails to submit the APR by the April 1 deadline for two
consecutive years.
Financial Impact:
There is no financial impact to filing the APR. By meeting this and other eligibility requirements, the
City may continue to apply for eligible state and regional grant funds.
Recommended Action:
Approve the 2022 Housing Element Annual Progress Report and direct staff to submit the 2022
Housing Element APR to the California Department of Housing and Community Development and
Governor's Office of Planning and Research.
Alternative Action(s):
Do not approve the 2022 Housing Element Progress Report and direct staff accordingly. Pursuant to
Government Code Section 65913.4(4)(a), proposed housing developments are entitled to SB 35
streamlining (ministerial approval) if the City fails to submit the APR by the April 1 deadline for two
City of Huntington Beach Page 1 of 2 Printed on 3/16/2023
powereW LegistarTM
File #: 23-183 MEETING DATE: 3/21/2023
consecutive years.
Analysis:
The Housing Element APR represents a state-mandated report that details the City's progress
implementing the Housing Element in a given year. The APR lists entitlements received for housing
projects, building permits issued, and associated affordability of the new units for the 2022 calendar
year. In 2022, the City issued building permits for the construction of 85 market rate (above moderate
income) housing units, 32 moderate income units, 39 low income units, and 127 very low income
units. Permits were issued in 2022 for the Project Homekey and Jamboree Senior Housing projects,
which assisted the City in making progress towards its lower income RHNA.
The City continues to see a year over year increase in accessory dwelling unit (ADU) permits, which
also assists the City in meeting its lower income RHNA targets. In 2022, the City issued permits to
construct 91 ADUs. ADU affordability is based on a HCD approved survey conducted by SCAG for
use by SCAG jurisdictions. As such, ADUs contributed to meeting a portion of the very low and all of
the low income RHNA units produced in 2022.
Staff has prepared the report utilizing the forms adopted by HCD in accordance with the California
Code of Regulations. A copy of the report is provided as Attachment No. 1. Upon approval by City
Council, staff would submit the APR to the Department of Housing and Community Development
(HCD) and the Governor's Office of Planning and Research (OPR), as required under Section 65400
of the California Government Code.
Environmental Status:
The Housing Element Annual Progress Report is exempt under Section 15061(b)(3) of the CEQA
guidelines, which exempts activities where it can be seen with certainty that there is no possibility
that the activity may have a significant effect on the environment.
Strategic Plan Goal:
Non Applicable - Administrative Item
Attachment(s):
1. 2022 Housing Element Annual Progress Report
City of Huntington Beach Page 2 of 2 Printed on 3/16/2023
poweret'b LegistarTM
0
N
T
as
J
c
Y
U a) —
N
O= O 0)
D 0'3 D T
asa
aa)iaca�.EY
n E -o c t-o
w 2 E c° m .a
.N a 2 E o 3
°I- o om
a Na=m -O a
-02 c o> E c
N r U C C a) C
N T a N N U O
T a O` C a
N E 0_-oE L E
O a) a) C
-t -0 E a`> o) c
°a ° o N cc
E r cn o >, I
C o N C 0
O y 3 co
45 o 0 3 o
LoyL .oa 3
U--2o >.a N -O
U
O V COw O
3 O co x._ a) a,
C N 0 L �I
O ° Y
.a L O.Q E N u �I
O 3 m o a E + u zz
C,
L
C)
2
co
(f)
C)
U)
CZ
a)
a
0
L
L O U
U Ca w O a) co) _T
a) a) To `t LC) U) m co
C (V C //�C11 C C V
Q) N O Q O V m 2 m NO
C z •C 9 V coC
O 7 CO ca U) O =
a+ I — a) C
COCIS
o v
o o C -a
N- Q
� 0)
co U _
ea
C.) 4, Ca
0
Q
I
Ca
cn
o co E r
-)) LI: J H W a_ W O N Q
Optional:This runs a macro which checks to ensure all required fields are filled out The macro will create two flies saved In the
same directory this APR file u saved In.One file will be a copy of the APR with highlighted cells which require Information.The
other file will be list of the problematic cells,along with a description of the nature of the error.
Submittal Instructions
Optional:Save before running.This copies data on Table A2,and creates another workbook with the table split
across 4 tabs,each of which can fit onto a single page for easier printing.Running this macro will remove the
comments on the column headers,which contain the instructions.Do not save the APR file after running in order Please save your file as Jurisdletlonname2022(no spaces).Example:the city of
to preserve comments once it is reopened. San Luis Obispo would save their file as SanLuisObispo2022
Housing Element Annual Progress Reports(APRs)forms and tables must be
Optional:This macro identifies dates entered that occurred outside of the reporting year.RHNA credit is only submitted to HCD and the Governor's Office of Planning and Research(OPR)on or
given for building permits Issued during the reporting year. before April 1 of each year for the prior calendar year,submit separate reports
directly to both HCD and OPR pursuant to Government Code section 65400. There
are two options for submitting APRs:
1.Online Annual Progress Reporting System-Please see the link to the
Link to the online system:httDs://apr.hcd.ca.Rov/APR/lo¢in.do
online system to the left.This allows you to upload the completed APR form into
directly into HCD's database limiting the risk of errors.If you would like to use the
online system,email APR(0lhcd.ca.aov and HCD will send you the login information
for your jurisdiction.Please note:Using the online system only provides the
information to HCD. The APR must still be submitted to OPR.Their email address
is opr.apr@opr.ca.gov.
2.Email-If you prefer to submit via email,you can complete the excel Annual
Progress Report forms and submit to HCD at APROhcd.ca.aov and to OPR at
opr.aorlfoor.ca.aov. Please send the Excel workbook,not a scanned or PDF copy
of the tables.
120
, ! ,. „3, „2, 2= 2 Z=ZZ
8 ,/!/)\)\ \
\2\!S�)).
\ ` \Dil
;t_
}.'` , FA
/}\/ /]\
- k §
-
' - : _
! ! -l'i
( ) !;!!
# |!!!
) ) « f { .
. / -a ` k }
) / io-
O \
f|^!
k On
-
LR47.
`! -��A ] )) ) )) )�)
m ; 77' , !k|° •. .4
W E V !; !
0 E . 0.000 00 0 0000
ii
ZE ` `
LIJ
2 _ _ , ° ; EE • EEEE
-J � _ , _
U .r :1
\ . .{§§ 2 ) \ )� ) ) f/
A. »�® ! )f \ !(/ }\|
R. / /, ;, ® : :;;
„r"6- ® , § §!!I
= - ( ' �0_0 __ \ - - / / /§\
}
7 - z ; §
l ,I E
'
IL
Ilthil
I
i !
— E
i
ill
I3ga_
Ill
II i
II
11 , i II 11 l I 1 1
ill i $ Oil. 1III k Mi I �0 ! 1 01 I i ! I
:i 10 € 4 I !
Ik! i! 1►4R ►ik it it f ' ' ] 1 dnk -
N!I E! b 1 ►
Il
11
Il
1 . . . . . . .. . . . . . ... ... . . . . ..
d . •I I - •.... • . . . a s a...a...a.a.a.
All II1111111 11 UPH
F
l � IIllli
111
I11 III
1 ID
I 111111111
IIIt,a
11 i t ; ! . L 'IIIII
11.1 1
1 11 1
!i ,11 1
}1 ,!I I
I
�l! 1�11 III I I I I 1 1
Mill
10111 II IIIIIIIIIIII I■IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
I 1111 ii [
lI1 lil'�1 ' 111111
1
w
III
i 1 .IEI . I _I_
1 - 11111111111111111!• • •Eiliiiitltlll lEE EIIEIEFFI Iiiiiil11i1!liliiFili111iF11i1!lllil !!!11lii11E11l11!l11iFiiFiFill!!1!!1
F l 1 .1 11'ilililli3MI, h i1;Il14,11 li111,1•1I'Elj!lg1`;1<il•ia-1ILI1l '11[1ll fil,ililltti'lill11:IIHEtlllillillllllillii Dill'
} ':1�. EiE�I11liE it MI, E EC' 9 [� ['s , 7 ;€It1� �yE[111 iiisl E11 ei it i!!is IC ! 1 !E€71!€€et!!l11Ele[!LE Iiill: Dill'
€F
iiiiilililiiliiiiiil 11li;iiililiiii it iiilii'}iii iliiiliiiililiiiiiiiiiiiiliiiiill ill'sillliillililiiiiliilliiiliiiillil
M
N
ii
f
-.
1
L�.
N
II
I
II I I
I I
,
i
1 lllt
�1 I
L.
fn
fV
I
I,/
I
I I I
{
8
CD
N
,!
a
1
E �� E
a IQl m , I.C.
7 N
r X r
tt N
a)
m 2 2 C
ii 0
�o I g
— a)
— , . da
0
m m
w a N
E O 3
o E
_ T^_
co
's E ~M
Q Cy W
w N ZQ OlO
co
@? = 0ID Ci r � OZUI? ma a) F "O p
u o oU `m °
4.g _ U c d E
C c a) T ..
c a 3 o E y N
m? r o c cr N
2 ce
m c o a
5.
C O
o u 3 c 6
a E `o 1 „_ N W 1. 0
�a E N 0 N
C m C -08 j -20
V d 0 n�O C U
�>, a — a '—.O a) E _
E O O.2 - 3 O
O a' c
N 3 N (�Oa0
o O-CC at= o N N N 3 T
ts N a O aa a m `a -a� t m E
Ce c ill c 6 - o
co 0 _ O a) n m N c T
W M O T N d
O
_ H E N 4 .D 3 L.. CO '
cc o N CO Q'C a) N L O w c-
ce N 42 d a - E E
G. C m d y -o $ o o c
1- E ~ Z N o m T. o_d a
Z —_ c-. rn - N30'a
W e 'Nm - N � N o ; c c
2 d O 13 (A T °)O �'
W E =2 s E o
Jig — o j o.p) 'D•O 'O
liiQ c c a M M @ Z 1.3 y a m
.2 o > = o a o
m y N N E o N
Z 3 ' = a) d a`) N
Z O v m E m n n m
< I .) o. y m o
un) c aa)) 3 c o'
E as .67
3
a) O-o y O_ >
CD
o H a) . .cFr a Uo c
a N N 3 p
n
EC 0 0 0- o
oO 0CS .2C L ac
3 o E a) E
22 a)
v o C Q
I G
= ` a 3-. cm Q., O
m r m E No m.
aa' Eo
N N 0- L L to o,-F., o-m a) O 1 o_N
g 5 3 a=m c a 'O3NO3- o s Z iii LT aN a p
z E °) U Nn
= 0E a) cYLE,K W O~ Tp
Lo O c G d
C y.N.
C O
r 9 cmO O a, N
c N T C
@'O U
°' �oo o m.- U E
rn
0E � Ti -0 N N) N C U` f, wr.. 6 Ca K o¢D0_13 a-6
J v Pi pv a0O . Or
3 m 0) 2avoZoZoZ
— a — .0 . O O L aoNLL m I- a)
OOa' Oa) O@
o ` o d ¢ mN E ci oc%
0, a Z COa1- ONC a o m3 m N 4' aNa) a 0
d a ` O O,> 2ctI-i W WZ9D oT0
\ CO
!
i |$
z/
|}
| )
| § `
\
% °
k ) $|
/ — | !
( /
wE 0
W3 } g
} \ \ a
« _ |
! �
) ,
) !
s
\i
A
\ a \
t g
. ! |
III /
Cr)
N
E -O O ° N O L > O
a) N
C - N a) O
NL a) O) N N _ 3 O_L L
O
O) 7 EO - .p+ N y co N a) o Co 3 0 L N p U Vr .- .� N co m
7 m c "O 0 � .0 -.E. O U U -o O Co C
o
co o K'- aa) (� O
a) E 3 U a coCo o c o o o
c oU ° Co LO. -LO L a N ° 2 C (o ((al
C C N p c d j 0) 0 Co C o
'p a) -p >`.c co a) Co _cU N '@0
� --(2O co O N L a) 7 d U CO a T�O a)
a) U Co N O Co N@ O C D L N (0 '°
N C -O a U >'73 Cl ° p a) >
co E a) co w :0 N N U O y (O L O "O N `d
y .° U N N L N E C (O
m G N O a) a) a) N L O V - C (0 C N C
° F- a co C
L ca E co fl.N (0 w 'O m-° s_ m 0 CO w U
a) w
45 as .L�. °i N a) a) 0) a) C p Z E O
o '- c _ OOa) a) 7a) c0aEa)
a U
d "-o
'.-ID —
D C ' O 2 a) E C C C cn O 0 co 0 5 Cl) p 2
o M C d - .@ L.. N 0 0 0 O co
oo 7 N C N N a o a. n 3 N w a) 0 E
a/ m No CO a E `° 3 O C o a 7 L E B O o c
O 'C (n N (O a) C C U 7 O O a) w Y
"O a s L .L.. C (n O a) (O > ` .0 O N
/� _ (0 C .0 c 0).0 3 a°i f° co °7 @ > c 7 U S 0
li O O C C d (0 n. N C al .>'+ — C -O Li E (A N N
/W/ _ v °' CDo)c9a)co To � � — c ca) a) oa) O1-o
cc a)cr) a) in N O CD L N (O 7 ° E C N O U a N C
�//�� imp > N o o m E L m E m E m U m ° u°i
V) W 0 'C E L.L L "O L• N L O "O @ U C O d Y «• co >' O
W N O a) L O L (o — .L.. O C O a)- N N O 7 7 N
CL C re m 3 �)G N U o U m a°i Y n o m L E o
/^ ^ CO y C a) O "O o L o L N a) N (O C ❑ EO 00.
v ii co -c as .c H 0 - (a 3 ._ 1- o.w U 2 (0 O
O y
L O a)
0
ea c
U ~ L E co co
a,Z ❑ cn OC m . OE (a
W r C a. o `"0 0)V R2 m
E o a
_ wCW N w C coNOU E N Nc, C O �
UO pW v
7 F= N N 7 N N
S c c 7 To
o o c
__ E E 0) o o C.) < o
a)..II .N c
Q > U °
p) Co m O L
Z N O N O N a
CO�, 2 N
Z ,C Q N L Q a O N O O C p
'CCN O) Co V C o -
foo
0 a
o a, C N c:, 0 o > 7 C O N > (0
CO CD > L C C Co7 0 E
C N p V N CO C O N O. O c
_ O L
O p N N d Co C U co n N
00)N O Q O a) a) C a) 7 N C
.0 U o c o 9 N O CU 0 a m
o
= 0) a) ( o oU N >o _
C 3 0 ° n N n c
a o `o E E aasi o -°c N 0
c N �' N C = (O C N ` (o
.N N ? .j -O N -p a) -pp a) 0 N
N C Q O !-- C O)'- 7
E co C U C O �0 d y N N
(6 < (O < N 7 O co
m
2 C
p. O
co E a as
R
C y '6 i C Co L N
O > N a1 O =co o N
S.. L.15 ' d J C 2 a
co E 2 O .c (7,• C O
7 °_ o_ a) „,0 7 Z a)
re a) m o) E QL n o
Z c m < °)o a
L
a x° a` 2 o 5
0
co
N Q 0 - O
000Q w ° a) 2 cc am
7 ° Q O c '- ... m 0 O 0 N
C QU 0 �_ ° 7 o ci ccc •c 0 c o t O y L
c ° < a) -0 L >, m a) ° L a) 0 '-
m o
° E 0 0 E m 2 o m H = n >
L X U E ch m -0 c 3 L c 3 a) F- vi T- 0 D o w
3 x @ L m o ,— 7 E c Y2 2 ) N E 0 0
7 CO 0 c O 0 o COm o
0_ -c N a) > L cO O3 L 0 N .O (.0
co -c
o_
co S 7 2 0 a) a) c co m coo > 50 a) C
a) 'C c N 7 >, CO a) 0 0 0 d O O d N N E cl C o N N
o a) r a aria E ° o E a°i aci � - c @ To @c
o a a m a) o..,_o 0 > 3 > t Cn c - E M CM E = 0 0 0
o n o a a c c N a > ° m o m L`0L c o m >, E cn
" c > O > 0 C 0 _c '" a) a) @ a) 0 '0 E 0 o Q U r O
a) '@ O w N M N c
0m „ Z o. ° ,_ a°) - O : o E E o Ta@) LH aa)) a°iw o
oLLa) a)) mc0_ E rupj ° Cc c ° LY E on
cif ay
>,F•gd ° C w d sQ .T a) "N0 , 3 0 = co NN � O E m
m 00
0 E >, 'n ° 13 m o 2 c o E o ,_0
>,m N
co t 0 CO a) > L c 7 C a) v)
c < E � o o -0 ' LOLL 3 0 m 0 E a) C 0N c 7
0 ..->'. ° .O N 0 co ° L '!7 7 N E M 2 o m} - N c L
E. 0 7 C a) CY)m m a m 3 o m o 3 -0 r _ X o N 0 C - U 0Nr al
3 - > o o m el- -o
CO
C W Cn O O-E « = L 0 a) H 0 ° Z+ cO T
7 m o) 0 m 'EQ m .N 0 0 nE a) ° 0 E c > o m m
2 U 'E C a) n E 7 o 2 C- 7 m a) C .0 O 0 LL V) @ C
.c m o c -.. o c c a CID E > o n cc O c L 5 -c ->o c > 'x
M f6 2 C @ (-°6 Q) c C7 W coW c c m ° ay Q CO 0 a)
7 U Yr Cam-. To cc O .N_, y 0 O N a) ° -° cO .N o 0 y cc C
N 7 L d—
Nw CDIL ? @Oo O) t 0 3C N 8° co E `r' ° :00_ 0 N
0 -0 >,'°- LL 0 C 2 c an o S 2 r- O) N 'O C N O -°O } 0 V) E o
E O) 0 5 H 0 o fO c ° > > .D - N c0 a) o C o C L `) i a)
a) x ° c m a) C a) O w a) a) 0 0
c CO C o o m� ° ^o 0 n- -J E •- 0 1 0 E 0 `m 0
7 `m o a m 2 0 ° 3 0 c a)
° c _ o
c w 0 w co L 1°] 0 n a C O CO 'O O C w Cn g 3 > a FL- o 2 o
E
ii!
-3 Q
>L asm
0 0 o H ,-
O 0 _ a3 LL)
°_ E op (NIC O O
U 'N o N a) (NI N
N M co )- A
C n U .. LL
U C co N C C N
0 c m
O (o O O
p_ C
U 'O X O iq U 0 a) p io
C a) 7 CO 65 0 C c N fo
C a) , ° 3 N m 0) d c < >
° -2 0 O 0 -0 O °) = w 0 'O C m a)
O
co r a2i is o i) 7 3 '- c O w c
c m a°i Z a�i c CO m o E w o o w c m
> wa) caca `oac) w f° 3 > •wo E
c y E 0) o d o
0 c Q n 0 Q o w'E ' > -o O o
cn o . c, 7, > 2 7 d C 0 C ct y
0 c) c c c °) 0 ¢ r m E U o d
o , -°°` as 0 m 0 O o) m w C -o d m c
E 2 f6 co c � L d m o@ O 2 0-o o cn
O -0 0 O E 0 s °) N > o r
C 0 -0 N 0 co
0 of C C
a)o 0, o w c o ° aa) . o co > E 0 < a . 3
7 cc 0) a) 0 a) o .N.. 7 C 'O o .0 E Q co' w N
C >' C 0 0.-0 O C C - ° N c > a) N ° C C 0
0 E 2 o O o 0 o O o �° CO 0) cc E 2 N o 0 0
C
o Q
0
a) a) m
N 0 H
y `
V)
Q a) cis
c c a_O as o a)
c y N E o
O w
co w m Q Q @
0 To.N To To0
N o a) a) o
a 2 oC w 2 2 a
7
EO `p
0 -00 CCD 0 C
o O N d a) LL �O a)
E > m
-c 0 cr) Cl)c X U a) "0 p_
Y T w a) L0]. a) O 0
T.,
o@ m C m E _ m m
U a) p E C O" O , cn -00
C N O a) U 0 U E y co �'
3 - m 0 n m E E 7 n
.c >+ 0- E o p c„..) 3 E E O E
O .— "0 @ �0
N 0 U a) 0 0- J a E 3
N - O Fm. u) O ❑ M U uI1
-0
0- c c Z, co TOp m W w 3 E O N
.7 7 0 7 0 a) m 0 coN 0 c.) 0
0 0 a) O w O C U c.)
a) 3 m c C 0 CO a) CO O` 0 L U
O d 0) N E ., ;0) E 0- O 0 L (� p_
cn6 � " -0 0 � 0 � c• a) 3
0 Z,7 w C a) N o d •
m32 o f ,m
E >
C C C -0 c0i N _c O a) OO C •�? d
a) > C c > c a) D o m 2 —
E c 0 m a) f0 U .—
c p o m ° ai o_ c_
mNE % t cc -0o � O0) E
a)
c 'N 0 QUNN_ EO3U N
-00 N 7 -.>'. 0) .-. c N 0 O c U 7 'C i0 a
O •— 7 U r` 0 0 0 0
m 'O = U O a) O '3 m (0 0 N d
U .c -c U • O n o' U > a) 0
a) 1— 0 O C M O Z+.c N —
L., o o cn m o c m e `a) a) 3 C
o O co a) 5, N T 0 C C >, O 3 r C
O a) N co La) 0 _7 N 0 3 0 p c E N 7
N '> C-) m a) .0 O a) X O L N o O co U
C N C m 'N C f— C ...2 a) J 1— 't1 No -o C
T O -00 -0
C N p 0
N 0 C C) U C
CD a) a) N -0
. - T E a) E c
cn .0 -cU 0 ` 75 CO (0 a)3 7 O W a) �.>'- • d L°
.> L U co :0 c U) O
a) 0)-0 a C > 0 - pN
ct• o .0 U = . W2 —1 'p.NO
N t n W = 0 N p 7� O N
o >, 0) m E o Cl) 7 >
N C .0 "0 0 '0 N O '0 .a
w a)
(h 7 C d L N M O i0 (0j 0-
• c m E . E N .� p o
N N 0 < 3 < oN - - n-co
D
a) _ 0 -.0._
721 a)
co c,
m• a) C a) O ..--" y o N 0 Q 7 N
C C N O D 0 C U coo E o C E -0
m CO o f O w cf.) o o 0_ 0 L On I f6 `o m
O y L .. N (00 c m U .N N co Q'- o 0 d -0
> m '3oZ` cm a) Cm 2 o0) C3 > m w � 5,
o N 0)2 0 C E >, c a) 'o U 'n O U .00 "O 0 7 w
c C c a m 0 a U
OO a) p 0 0 N0 N N N C o -7p 70 U 0 c< L cn U 0
E m > c 2 E > m m m L n o co Q m co o c
O al ` .0 ' 0) 0 0 — E N 0 a) n 0- o a) a) .- p_ o
C
m
C a) O - 0-�' 7 7 U - 0 0 \ .0 co N O > E
2 -0 > C CD O "O "0 c mO •— M p '.t= O o '0 a) CU 2) O
-0 -0 m 0 .0 2 C cn 0OU C '0L -0
U .Na) p O C E Q Z' O a) n a) o a) a) C '3 0) a) >
c @ CO E Z m w a E aLi d > > o w 0 >. y -Oo
- c E c = ch 2 -00 7 C - ' S •
'0 3 Lc Lu E >,
C "a) > O c7n N U ❑ O c 0 n C > N.. '> a) W 0 .
0 C O C a) 0 o E p W o U 'm COa) 'E o '> > "C 2 E
2 7 nc a) o w c Q U Q U m U C 3 .2 7 d 2 0 min w
0
CO
D E
-p m Cf
X p N
2 a co
m U
"0 N W O
c a)
m C
To0 0 m 0
co. 0 C 7
O▪ O co
= p co 0 '0
.0 C o" a) N C U
O
Q' C Q ❑ < d d
N
M
CT -
C O a) .-
Q M. N a> c O °
cn
_ > N _ 3 a)
C• 7 Q 3 a> (n ° C O a> C co .-
fo c d Q ((0 C 0 U c 2 0 a> C CO• o
m 7 a) ,La .> a) O a) L w o C 0 > F.
C
E a) as U @ c m o
CD L N > 'N N C f6 T U c o C 2 U N a) j
-° 0 'O 7 n 92 .° a7 c 0 w r n w
N c d 0 >,�o N o U j U7 O a> w O_ N a>
=
2 L C O)U N CNI .L°.•
C d 'O a) m U O. m cn
(NCo d L.7. .0 O N a L C 2 'NO o• 'C n
Cm 7 O ".' (n U a7 n L "O M -O - V) j T E N N C
co C 'O co w (/) n o E a) T O U) O L a) ` 0 - a>
d N c C m T o 0 0 a> -0 C N C . (0 a) a) S a)
a3 a> ._
a> L a) O)N a) a) C C n @ 0 .7 C Y >, (0 D7
C .0 •c a) C E. O c0 N -o N O coc a> 3 7 E n N ° .0
m U Q O T n N a) 7 0 C 3 CO-C ° ° O
O L° n mCLZw � 3 aoo -ow , m c)rNa
> N o 3 a> It o c . o) a> 0)Co c y ° to 'N m o
U m -o N a' o C O A C -o C L - c 0 a) 7 C L 0)
a) L -0 a) E vi E N O N o a) o c O O T c
-C a> S) CO Q a) -- a) 3 ° N a °) N 3 L ,o
c •' >,? N co ° U 0 2 N 0) c E o = o o co U c
▪ 4) O C N a) a) a) a> C O a) N
N a) X-.- E 0 > C > Q L 2 N L O o 0 N > (c0 0 o
c E a) m m m r 'y - E U L u) E
m o w -° o 0 o a> C m °-m co L E
° c N c 0- >. n o m m o
2 a) c a> r m 0-..-= n c L .3 N D = n O .5 d 0
E a7 0 E -0 U)) U U)) U •3 '0 N co a) LL a) T n N - 7
`m o n N a) °'° w r a m C N V > E o m as
n C 7 C1. c . C C C 7 0 "- (9 U a> co V) C
m 7 0 3 m o (o N O)_ o o E �' co 0
m N '0 N ° m m ° E c o c -° ° U
a) a) O O �T, c G m m'- N LL O cn >` (D9 _ ai
O L a Y 3 N c .N 2 N C (n 7 .� T= N 'O
4) a) w a) O O O N N N 7 a) L D 2 f0 7 (o 'O 3 (6
TO C w CO a> _c ..0 O L a) O N 0 0 I- O c Y Q d C >
N -O N m o a) 'O C N = N w N 2 U n .T. V) N a)
E E a)
• .... C ... O n'0Cal 0 •D1'DLL U N C C U co U@ N@ 1]
N V a> U a (0 0 > o co. 0) C a) co '00 OU U C a> O E O N
CC a) a) 0 O. a) CO Z m "0 C -) I- m a) 0 OM ,- I- n L O.w
N i C O
a) a) > 0)'0 a> o � >, r Eo m• jo - w Oo o) ` oUm c 0_0 co 0_ CO E N
oEN c > e
E Oc E o wo 0) s
0 o .c oo ) a EE . NoL
cc)2 w o mc _c >.5 E � 7 o ` 0L
_ o o •C ° a) usm• o n 3 co ° C c ° c > m m
as o oac) mocU •O wco00 > noyE
`> C c co 0 E O) m c 0) _ U m a) a) .•
CC n c "O (). c N 7 ° V a) c 3 . • 7 .O O .0 c a> L
asd_' O N C N coC (A C 0 .o C ` N N C L > °- N C E c
E O TO o 0 E o > O D U 7 o a) O `O j' p 7 0 °
d N L N C U a) Q L N L C C a L 2 n 3 n U) L 2 2 E
'D
0 >,
a)
.O N C + c O-as
o w 5> N O To 0- to
a) co C o .0 O)_0co CO a) C 7 co
O •
a)
> N N N L C a) ,-. C T E C >
o m `m = . 3 a) c . = r o u- m o > w >
O. f O ` N ❑ N O L o C -O 'D N ° O a3
c O
a�- a a) ` ° °) E - E a> co n a aa))
-No a) L a) c o m m o w a> .� a) CO c) n y C E
c 0 7 0 ,O C cc O C C '-▪ y0 C "O "O n o
O N N N C O w C C •C Y N (6 )) 00 N a)
To w c_ m N n a) ma >
O U - L 7 U () 2 N 3 2 o y ° a) of o ii' °o
rcw co 7-)) •3Eo) N � sa) > Uc � ° U � m
:c - O � c 0 511- � U > U w a 3 a) N m Q) ,,C_,
co C o a) a)
W a) L O_L O` (0 U N• a) a) u, > O
• L a7 O a) a) O V) = O
o E -° o -0i— 3o O, m 0 O o)
3 a) O O c co Y C N C L E a o .c O- C
• O) E r 0 10 a) L O N 3 0 0) cn C c) c) 7
'> N O O ._ U m N n'C C - a 0 N O U) O
a3 'O C C co m O >>O 7 - N 7 L
E a) c (0 O o N 0 0 > o w L o aa) L o
a` La• ° m 'v� m m n U ° 0
cc O To C
To N a)
c d E
c• 7 >
O
2 m ca.
O > .tq 0 N
E.
o m C 3
cn
c °• n 2 'V) N N
O 0 > N
N• V) ti 2a •L5
co
ro
c O C O o CO a) r C u'
CO2 U) E CO w 0 .2 w c a) m o .- I- CO S .N aa))
N a) N N a) )a a) , w O C
E o c o E a� c c ° v' m ° o o CO cc)
m ° E p) w 5 ° 7 3 u)L0 44 0
co E o 2 — co — iav ma? �
., a C m •- o .> c y c o a E . E a) c r > >_ c r N 2
al Q fa U o O 5 o 'r-' Q N V O> d o c U 0- a) ca O w V p-° ,_ C N N
O ° E °°- o a °- `o CO E Z > > L as ° 4- 0 o aE o •cc030w 03
N O c O c > 0 -O 0 C y o a) N - c w N N N N c a O :D
U w C .- o a U 8 C o O C '� coq C ° ?C a) a) m ° E c
mZ o o c o U •w ,= >> E o LL °0 -6 A o o c v u) r = E E8w0 .0 - 0'°
c oO n0 ` airi EU c` c m ) y ° o. d °' o o °C oc °'E .0 = `c°
c c .0 ayi co N U cl)• 0 a) o) 0, V N 0 U L j° > C ° y o C' E > a)
_ m _
E (a a) O a) N U Z @ o o C a' 'O a3 -p Fa L 'p -c C RD m a) •T a) L ° O u!
o E 2 E a r o c a O o c W E o o c - co O c c a) B E a CO E U o. c'd t
U o o O u) E L w o V Cr' a' •C O ° @ a) -C ° C
13 4-
o > r U) T Z a U o O u) o S u) y 0 U 2 C U '.-- O O 'a) C =0 •C co
U
C C o CO o C N cu = o S 3 o CO ` CO -' o N E a) O CO o o r... a`, N O C > > o
m •P Ca ao2 rn00 a E - m@ ) .0 mU w c � m 3 .0 CO E: a) o d Em
ai t m f0 c o '� v c a°i ° CO CO o o o co m o@ N 0 m c o c°� o
-o u) v ° ' E a) O '> ._ u) c r E o E a r a) 'u) >, ° E 0 2 > : uJ C)
cc
d C cCO V V o C 0`p. 0 C L C p. a) N N a; 50 ?•3 E d PE o m d 2 co y c
C `a u) m o a) °-_ E 'o)w a' a) a) c o u) N CO o C 3 -o E a i) -° r.. g a) c
o N d 2 u) U 6 a N•
C o o a) o o a`�i o U 3' a) Z 6 w 2 C „a)) o 0 c 0 O — 2
O. 0 C a - N o fO CO C o L Xa V U 1- C C U E= a) a °co 5 C -oa co>,N 0 d d.' a@ C)
° ° ° a) cTo a) N E ° . 1- a)a) 4. N CO O L o o C U F. a) C a) C o CO .7
a>im omQLc nozo me =.'5 ESE ,- Ec2c =_ a) c- y. u') c
0 a) o COm a-ow -° a) m y 0 CO > o « ._ 0 ar wCv) co._ E o .
�N r E 0 = c U c a) ,0 y O."; CO ; co Z > E -C -C > N m a 'O E p fa O U ; C
E o) '> as a 2 a) C o 4- O) > O 0 a) N " c O
@ ° y_. U N c OU au') - o ao) r iL .c E - r C)al o .o a a a) m .c ° - °.CD w o
EEa) cto > > Uc2co 12U •Xz .rgcppa) m� � > a 2ccocoa. E'
00 cai_ Eoc . co mg . 1 °' a) oL3.0 '7asomro �' 8E oo) a, oc2 �
U a) a 0 >,L r co N C as C-:° 0 C --•• O a) co) E fax ate) U C a) U c 2 "o' m CD ) r C)j
u' T. X 0 O O) a) C u) 0 a) a) O O 0 C O >, > u) a) r O O C CO O N . a) Q 2 O
° oU c E m o m m° °' o - m C 1i o a) �' E a ° a) > E E ar
U a o o ° ° m c� E y o n 0.. 0 na o ._ E c 3 w c` as C o m
roa°' o00 ooao0oo as) Xa°) mtasca°) uu)iS)' - aa) oco .�-..... 000 � o
- o co.0 CO E. as 0 r ca 0 U r co m a) o. as CO 1- ca a a) U E -o 0 _ 3 w a a m o
0
CO
O)
C
N T eh
a) CO C
E 7 7
76 C '"
U C C 0
'O O < m
•O O) aj0
a�o. oU c)
.�. 'E — N
'o O O U O
Q 0 U To CV
0)
C
a)
�' u, w w
C 2 O C o
O o E o T
O
C4 O `a r E C
7
c c N y 5 uO .0 m
ns
o 0 c m c a) o 0
C u) u) N
r if) V u) @ 2 d O
coO co)
•
r
m ? > ES � n m
C E 3 o m 6 N
•c E c a 0 5,
00 00 < -E. a00 0 Q
T
U C
C o
'U
as
W u)
co
Q w
a)
o CO
u)
a) U
a) a)
O
2 d
M
O C C
n O O O
a o N C L U
-o o E m 7 4
• c c m y �-00
O O a) a) W
4V �p N c U O O
C N
O .0 w C N a) c c� o
> a r E 2 -Ca co .E
o
N a)N O co
m o a) L7N E
o E > no
co a) O -O@ cEO3a
0° Co > N0m m 'oo = o
- w nn� m > 0ai o -o
(6 a) 0 L U _a CI) (6 a)
a7
c E C o)- H C 3 (, n
CZ
c O E 3 c o 0
o m > >. a) m c 0 >
-0 C a n'( N co -0 m a)
c a cc -o E N o _c -o
a) m o
• m
o>,) aEi m E n o o_m c0 3
• n O om
m E o a)
E .ca tn. ° o ° C. d a)
O
•
C
E
co a)
U 0 c
C CD (4 a
7 a) o_ 'O U
'� c c
c a) co O.
• o a) >,
c
> a)
L a a) a)
o E o
n3
E E 2 o
E Ea"0 c v
o OU — m N U 'U
C > N
C S • O
O C E m
- o co a) cn m n
n3 E .> > C
U• o_ o O N C O
c O '
a)
- L o a3
-o• N a) a) E Z n
• o n O a o -0 = O n UO C
d N L- c :
0
C
ca
m
5 L
co C
C '@
0
a) cn
0
N
M
co
!
|
11
!, !,
�! !|
U )
k !� 1 . .
! � !
E
k i�
ji . l . .
I \
| &
r
| . .
! .! . | i
jJ {
o
}/ }\ \
{ § ' >
CO ( w \
r - O\ & %
$® a <2
\ _
\ 1-6 \ \\ \\ |/ - \
Ek \\§ {
E) / / ] k
\ / \ .5 \\5 15
7 \ I. \[ e ; _ tt
_
§ 2\ _ 2
2
k \( \% /
G_ » \/
2 - »&a
a) \
E } \{_ • .1ƒ &
w _ /\ 13/\ � §
rn C a, \� }o (°� %k _ §63 W _ �a §0 a k .k0 0 r
$ § CO
< { \} \ \\ k%
z f � / k Eo
2 § § /
w E ' 7 ƒ \
2 !\ r
w f = )
k c ) \2z \
D _ «
z = $ ;,
Z 0 2 _ - )
\ )) a ®,
EoD . �k . \) �_ \\\ }\
_ ; CO
7 {{ §
2 ±\ _ {
2 k }7. - -
c[ 3 i
« \ §\ /}
\ f f E0
- - t
_ )] O o
® .� C.
k § J
00 « ) 2
« \
« a)
® ) E 0
_ COE. a ) - t _ a
_ 2 - \ \ \ n
C { / ` CO 3 0 3 /
\ ƒ ) E j ) \ $ j k
Nob.e..di0ee
Odd.. l�raennanegm ANNUAL ELEMENT PROGRESS REPORT naew dl
AmdmngPemd Wu un.1-bed.all Housing Element Implementation cells increy cad.e.oa'alo...a men
Plodded Padnd do Cycle 101152021-10/15202a
Table F2
Above Moderate Income Units Converted to Moderate Income Pursuant to Government Cade section 65400.2
For r0025peae.deluediaona modals-mode red.Musing meadabmem, plevint imencvmayarFde the runber or aeb in an want muddy deldlngeM werecornedb ded-raelitelad diet laud Immoderate-Wade baceenoltle bye»Img&clan M affordability saver..end re...10 th122 Relwe adding IMwmermm
clue Mde please ensue Musing developments meel.e requirement.dd.In Gaertner.Code WW2.
Project Identifier I Unit Types Affordability by Household Incomes Atter Conversion Unite credited toward Above Moderate FNMA Nola.
2 1Local D 6
Very det.
Pdnr APN M del Sdet Addmse Pm)an Nerve' ntt Cegory um vpen pgd ^r'a^ OeedRMr3na0 n Converted from_ Low.Income No... 1400.99- Total boded*Incom• la Dale ConvertedTea eq (2m{.5.) m RMdaraO �dctadg Restrnm ReatMed be. lams Moderate
Summery Row.ad Data Entry 6eMv
Boulevard1/31/3013
19218105 16761 ve po rune 113 79, 192 11/310022
139
g
! | t .
;
I: I -
| §. .! !
:al |
V! 7 . \!
gi I
! . !
!
NJ ;! , , \!
�q gE ` _ >
i V.1\ )) i;i
gfiq 2 i `2
`\!;! i "
//\! I \ /
m ! !
\ \ 1 I I
|
} ~ ( I I
` � . . ! \
; , -
i |i ! {
1 I }
Jurisdiction Huntington Beach NOTE:This table is meant to contain an invenory of Note:"+"indicates an optional field
(Jan.1-Dec. ALL surplus/excess lands the reporting jurisdiction Dells in grey contain auto-calculation
Reporting Period 2022 31) owns formulas
ANNUAL ELEMENT PROGRESS REPORT
Housing Element Implementation
For Orange County jurisdictions,please format the APN's as follows:999-999-99
Table H
Locally Owned Surplus Sites
Parcel Identifier Designation Size Notes
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
APN Street Address/Intersection Existing Use Number of Surplus Parcel Size(in Notes
Units Designation acres)
Summary Row:Start Data Entry Below
159-281-04 Holly Ln.and Garfield Ave. Vacant Exempt Surplus 0.08
Land
141
142
143
N
I
# P
1 €
.
i
m E .
w $
a g
o E
1 §i
'• E § E-
• cu• c A rl
w m g
• I $g e o
€ 3
Ei $ g 9
S
& ; - g
,na; of y d i� .
I
g I
w �
1
1
cl
a`
4
o
o
/ 0 « ) §
] )2- #
A
\ \�)
7 7
\ /)
;cn E. J�
|
2 ` \j}
u
CC c 0 -th . . .
$ 2 !,
ƒ 2 % ( o
o ° C
RI #
O ce 2 §�-
CLa C.
/
R I
Z /�!
w 2 « / §0o
0
w E /k3
—I
w E
/ ' co '7V
2 § i!
Z 0 } {C'
\\ 0 ` 0
2! ! E
§ )/6 ]
( « \2 E
§ 0. ,«
7{] | .E ,
70V ' \ CL D\
CD
9`2 2 t E .
00 -0 \\
() 0 o ] �
\ \ j }
vs
t
- _ . o
o
fzii _ /
co
rN k \ I
~ , 2
, 2
= 7 a- _ \
_ z
\ /
/ co [
# £ ƒ _ a <
Jurisdiction Huntington Beach
Reporting Year 2022 (Jan. 1 -Dec.31)
Planning Period 6th Cycle 10/15/2021 -10/15/2029
Building Permits Issued by Affordability Summary
Income Level Current Year
Deed Restricted 104
Very Low
Non-Deed Restricted 23
Deed Restricted 0
Low Non-Deed Restricted 39
Deed Restricted 2
Moderate Non-Deed Restricted 30
Above Moderate 85
Total Units 283
Note:Units serving extremely low-income households are included in the very low-income permitted units totals
Units by Structure Type Entitled Permitted Completed
SFA 0 0 0
SFD 0 27 0
2 to 4 0 2 0
5+ 0 163 0
ADU 0 91 0
MH 0 0 0
Total 0 283 0
Housing Applications Summary
Total Housing Applications Submitted: 12
Number of Proposed Units in All Applications Received: 142
Total Housing Units Approved: 12
Total Housing Units Disapproved: 0
Use of SB 35 Streamlining Provisions
Number of Applications for Streamlining 0
Number of Streamlining Applications Approved 0
Total Developments Approved with Streamlining 0
Total Units Constructed with Streamlining 0
Units Constructed-SB 35 Streamlining Permits
Income Rental Ownership Total
Very Low 0 0 0
Low 0 0 0
Moderate 0 0 0
Above Moderate 0 0 0
Total 0 0 0
Cells in grey contain auto-calculation formulas
146
Jurladttt)an Huntington Beach
Report&q Yeer 2022 (Jan.3 3)evi31)
ANNUAL ELEMENT PROGRESS REPORT
Local Early Action Planning(LEAP)Reporting
(CCR Title 25§6202)
Please update the status of the proposed uses listed in the entity's application for funding and the corresponding impact on housing within the region or jurisdiction,as applicable,categorized based on the eligible uses specified in Section
50515.02 or 50515.04 as ourlicahle.
Total Award Amount 5 500,000.00 Total owrro amount auto-oopuloted based on amounts entered in rows 15-26.
Task $Amount Awarded $Cumulative Reimbursement Task State* lr i( O( t yi'`—TM, xT
Requested : aa,
6th Cycle Housing Element Update $500,000.00 5109,846 50 In Progress None
Summary of enntiements,building pei bts,and certificates of occupancy(auto-populated from Table A2)
Completed Entitlement Issued by Affordability Summary
Income Level Current Year
Very Low Deed Restricted 0
Non-Deed Restricted 0
Low Deed Restricted 0
Non-Deed Restricted 0
Deed Restricted 0
Moderate Non-Deed Restricted 0
Above Moderate 0
Total Units 1 0
Building Permits Issued by Affordability Summary
Income Level Current Year
Very Low Deed Restricted 104
Non-Deed Restricted 23
Low Deed Restricted 0
Non-Deed Restricted 39
Moderate Deed Restricted 2
Non-Deed Restricted 30
Above Moderate 85
Total Units 283
Certificate of Occupancy Issued by Affordability Summary
Income Level Current Year
Deed Restricted 0
Very Low Non-Deed Restricted 0
Low Deed Restricted 0
Non-Deed Restricted 0
Moderate Deed Restricted 0
Non-Deed Restricted 0
Above Moderate
Total Units 0
147
Moore, Tania
From: Buffie Channel <hbbuffie@gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, March 21, 2023 12:16 PM
To: CITY COUNCIL; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org
Subject: Agenda Items - Meeting 3/21/23
To all HB City Council Members,
As a 34 year resident, I submit my opinion on the following Agenda Items:
Item 14 - Please APPROVE and direct staff to submit the 2022 Housing Element APR to the California Department of
Housing and Community Development and Governor's Office of Planning and Research. We need to move to
approve the housing element so we don't lose out on critical funds that help our community and so we
can move forward as a modern forward-thinking city focused on solutions and not political theatre.
Item 25 - Adopt Resolution No. 2023-14 approving General Plan Amendment
No. 2021-003 (Housing Element Update), adopt Resolution No.
2023-16 approving General Plan Amendment No. 2022-001 (General
Plan Land Use Element Affordable Housing Overlay), approve for
introduction Ordinance No. 4289 approving Zoning Map Amendment
No. 2022-002 (Zoning Map Affordable Housing Overlay), approve for
introduction Ordinance No. 4291 approving Zoning Text Amendment
No. 2022-008 (HBZSO Chapter 229 Affordable Housing Overlay),
adopt Resolution No. 2023-13 approving Zoning Text Amendment
No. 2022-009 (Beach and Edinger Corridor Specific Plan Affordable
Housing Overlay), approve for introduction Ordinance No. 4290
approving Zoning Text Amendment No. 2022-007 (Holly Seacliff
Specific Plan Affordable Housing Overlay), adopt Resolution No.
2023-15 approving Subsequent Environmental Impact Report No.
2022-002 with findings of fact and statement of overriding
considerations (Housing Element Update and Associated Program
Implementation Actions), and direct the City Manager to accept
applications for permits related to accessory dwelling units (ADUs)
and SB 9 development projects. Approve/Adopt all of the above in Item 25 so that we can have more
affordable housing in our city. This will help more people afford to live here including our own adult kids,
our elderly relatives, workers who serve our community, public servants who serve our community, and
young families that we need to benefit our local culture and feed our schools with students.
Item 28 - Proposed 90-Day Plan to Address Homelessness in Huntington
Beach. Please file the report and approve the plan. This seems like a no-brainer as you have now learned
how well the current process is working. Perhaps you should have educated yourselves on how well the
Navigation Center is serving people experiencing homelessness in conjunction with Be Well OC. Four of
you claimed you had some "grand solution" when in fact, you are approving the plan that was already in
place.
We will be monitoring your compliance and holding you accountable for results and to your campaign promises.
Sincerely,
Buffie Channel
SUPPLEMENTAL
COMMUNICATION
Meeting Date: 3 fri/,-2-3
1 Agenda Item No.;. /L/ (23 - I )