Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutRecommendations to Streamline and Restructure a Select Numbe 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach,CA 92648 _' Cityof Huntington Beach 9' Q g INDIVIDUAL COMMITTEE RECOMM— '� couNw�P�� ENDATIONS APPROVED BY MINUTE � ACTION INDIVIDUALLY AS SHOWN ON ATTACHED ACTION AGENDA File#: 23-641 MEETING DATE: 8/1/2023 REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION SUBMITTED TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members SUBMITTED BY: Al Zelinka, City Manager PREPARED BY: Travis K. Hopkins, Assistant City Manager Grace Yoon-Taylor, Principal Management Analyst Subject: Recommendations to streamline and restructure a select number of citizen-led Boards, Commissions, and Committees and Council Committees Statement of Issue: On May 16, 2023, the City Council approved the formation of an Ad Hoc Council Committee to engage in a comprehensive assessment of the City's existing Boards, Commissions, and Committees (BCCs) and their purpose, duties, and current relevancy to City operations. As such, the BCC Review Ad Hoc Council Committee ("BCC Ad Hoc Committee" hereafter) comprised of Mayor Tony Strickland, Mayor Pro Tem Gracey Van Der Mark, and Councilmember Pat Burns, met three times to deliberate and made nine recommendations to streamline the BCC structure, which are being presented for City Council consideration. Financial Impact: Not applicable. Recommended Action: A) Consider the Ad Hoc Committee's nine recommendations to reform, consolidate, and/or dissolve a select number of BCCs, as outlined in the staff report below; and B) Direct staff to work with the City Attorney's Office and develop the appropriate Resolution(s), Ordinance(s), and other documents necessary to implement City Council directed adjustments and bring them back to the City Council; and C) Direct staff to plan an appropriate event to recognize and thank citizen appointees who will be retiring due to this restructuring effort for their contribution. Alternative Action(s): Do not approve one or more recommendations, and direct staff accordingly. City of Huntington Beach Page 1 of 6 Printed on 7/26/2023 powered by LegistarTm File#: 23-641 MEETING DATE: 8/1/2023 Analysis: As part of the City Council's 2021-22 Strategic Plan, the City Council identified the streamlining of its Boards, Committees, and Commissions (BCCs) as a key priority and eventually incorporated ten recommendations made by the Ad Hoc Council Committee to dissolve, consolidate, and reformat a select number of BCCs in late 2021. As a result of the 2021 BCC Restructuring efforts, the total number of BCCs was reduced from 41 to 35 due to the dissolution and consolidation of six advisory bodies. Additionally, City staff formed an internal working group among staff liaisons to better coordinate its BCCs and advisory groups through on-going training, uniform policies and procedures, and centralized information. On February 21, 2023, City Council introduced ordinances to amend the Huntington Beach Municipal Code (HBMC) to ensure that all individual appointed BCCs have up to 7 members, with no more than 1 appointee per Councilmember. This codified policy resulted in the membership change for the CIAB/Public Works Commission and the Community and Library Services Commission from nine to seven. At the same meeting, City Council also introduced an ordinance to modify the Finance Commission's duties and meeting frequency. At a subsequent City Council meeting, all the ordinances were approved. On May 16, 2023, Councilmember Pat Burns introduced an H-item to request the City Council to consider another comprehensive review of all the citizen-led BCCs and Council Committees. Per the City Council's direction, the BCC Ad Hoc Committee was formed with the goal of streamlining the BCC structure to ensure the most efficient use of staff time and City resources while still maintaining an effective level of civic engagement in City affairs. The BCC Ad Hoc Committee subsequently met on June 5, July 17, and July 20, 2023 and carefully assessed all BCCs in conjunction with the City Manager's Office. After much deliberation, the Committee developed nine recommendations for City Council's consideration. These recommendations affect only a select number of BCCs and are recommended for one of three potential actions: 1) dissolution, 2) consolidation, or 3) reformation. A detailed summary of each recommendation is below. CATEGORY I: DISSOLUTION RECOMMENDATION 1: Dissolve the following Ad Hoc Council Committees as their tasks have been completed and/or are no longer necessary. • Short-Term Rentals Ad Hoc Council Committee: This Ad Hoc Committee was to provide Council input on the policy around short-term rentals (STRs). As its tasks are complete and Ordinance No. 4238 to amend the HBMC Chapter 5.120 Short-Term Rentals was approved on January 19, 2021, the Committee is recommending it to be officially dissolved. • Housing/RHNA Ad Hoc Council Committee: This Ad Hoc Committee was to provide Council input on the draft Housing Element prior to the Public Hearings. As its tasks are complete, the Committee is recommending this to be officially dissolved. • Cannabis Regulation and Policy Ad Hoc Council Committee: This Ad Hoc Committee was established to work with City staff to develop a commercial cannabis program. It is City of Huntington Beach Page 2 of 6 Printed on 7/26/2023 powered by Legistarrm File#: 23-641 MEETING DATE: 8/1/2023 recommended that City staff can undertake future, related tasks, if necessary, per the City Council's direction. Approval of Recommendation 1 would require the following actions: ➢ Approve the Recommendation via Council Minute Action. RECOMMENDATION 2: Dissolve the Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee (HBHRC). The Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee (HBHRC), formerly known as the Human Relations Task Force, was established in 1997 after the City's adoption of the Declaration of Policy About Human Dignity. This group was then reconstituted as a standing citizen advisory body to the City Council in 2021 with the mission of promoting mutual understanding, respect, safety, and well- being of all in our community through education and engagement. However, many of these issues are being addressed by the County of Orange (e.g. Orange County Human Relations Commission who publishes annual hate crime reports) and/or community-based nonprofit organizations. Dissolution will remove redundancy of effort and redirect staff resources to other City priorities. Approval of Recommendation 2 would require the following actions: > Adopt a Resolution to officially dissolve the HBHRC. RECOMMENDATION 3: Dissolve the Jet Noise Commission Born out of the Air Traffic Noise Working Group and established in 2018, the Jet Noise Commission acts in an advisory capacity to the City Council in matters related to commercial air traffic affecting the Huntington Beach community, including jet noise from commercial aviation traffic. The Commission has produced community information on jet noise matters for residents since its inception. However, air traffic is a federal issue, and the City has no/limited authority to regulate the altitude, speed, direction or location of aircraft flying over the City. Facilitation between Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), major airports, commercial airlines, and elected officials and monitoring local, state, and federal legislative actions related to jet noise could be accomplished by the Intergovernmental Relations Committee (IRC) and/or City staff if the need arises. Approval of Recommendation 3 would require the following actions: > Adopt an Ordinance to repeal/remove HBMC Chapter 2.104 Jet Noise Commission. RECOMMENDATION 4: Dissolve the Mobile Home Advisory Board (MHAB) The MHAB was established in 1996 to work in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the Huntington Beach mobile home community and to promote communication among park owners, manufactured home owners, and the City Council. City of Huntington Beach Page 3 of 6 Printed on 7/26/2023 powered by LegistarTM File#: 23-641 MEETING DATE: 8/1/2023 Any related conflict resolution issues between mobile home owners and park owners could be directed to the California Department of Housing and Community Development, which regulates mobile home parks. City staff can also connect residents to appropriate City and community resources. Additionally, the City's new Mobile Home Tenant-Based Rental Assistance (MHTBRA) program that provides monthly rental assistance to eligible very low-income Huntington Beach senior mobile home owners was successfully implemented earlier this year and is currently managed by City staff. Approval of Recommendation 4 would require the following actions: > Adopt an Ordinance to repeal/remove HBMC Chapter 2.112 Mobile Home Advisory Board. CATEGORY II: CONSOLIDATION RECOMMENDATION 5: Dissolve the Smart Cities and Technology Council Committee (standing committee) and the Environmental and Sustainability Board and transfer duties that may be appropriate, to the Citizen Infrastructure Advisory Board/Public Works Commission (CIAB/PWC) and remaining duties would come directly to City Council. The Smart Cities and Technology Council Committee is a Council standing committee established in 2021, with a goal of providing strategic policy direction towards the City's Smart City Roadmap and broadband master plan efforts as well as long-term innovative technology projects. The Committee and its duties could be carried out by City staff and/or the CIAB/PWC and remaining items would be brought directly to City Council. The Environmental and Sustainability Board (ESB) (formerly known as the Environmental Board) was created in 1979 to examine the City's Environmental Impact Reports and other related projects. Through the 2021 BCC restructuring effort, its primary purpose shifted to develop and monitor progress on the Sustainability Master Plan (SMP) and has a membership structure of five citizen appointees and chaired by two Council Liaisons. Its duties could be carried by City staff and/or the CIAB/PWC and remaining duties would come directly to City Council. Approval of Recommendation 5 would require the following actions: > Approve the recommendation to dissolve the Smart Cities and Technology Council Committee via Council Minute Action. > Adopt an Ordinance to remove/repeal HBMC Chapter 2.102 Environmental and Sustainability Board and amend HBMC Chapter 2.111 Citizen Infrastructure Advisory Board/Public Works Commission. CATEGORY III: REFORMATION RECOMMENDATION 6: Rename the Urban Design Study Ad Hoc Council Committee to the Downtown and Beach Front Ad Hoc Committee and broaden their scope of work The Downtown Urban Design Study Ad Hoc Council Committee was established to provide Council input to the City's Downtown Urban Design Study process to explore concept designs for Main City of Huntington Beach Page 4 of 6 Printed on 7/26/2023 powered by LegstarTM File#: 23-641 MEETING DATE: 8/1/2023 Street. There is need to address City Council's priorities to improve the Downtown and beachfront area, which includes the hotels and the numbered streets beyond Main Street; consider PCH relinquishment and beautification; beach restrooms improvement, etc. As such, it is recommended that this Ad Hoc Committee be renamed to the Downtown and Beach Front Ad Hoc Committee and broaden their scope of work accordingly. Approval of Recommendation 6 would require the following actions: ➢ Approve the Recommendation via Council Minute Action. RECOMMENDATION 7: Restructure the Huntington Beach Youth Board as a Huntington Beach Youth Citizen Leaders Committee, with specific goals. The Huntington Beach Youth Board was established in 1987 to serve as a voluntary advisory board to the City Council regarding youth achievements, concerns, and needs, and promote youth participation in community affairs. Over the years, their roles and duties have evolved, and given that their term is only 1 year, their ability to carry out various projects due to Brown Act compliance (e.g. restrictions on group messages, group texts, and collaborations outside of the meetings) has been limited. As such, the recommended changes include: a) Dissolve the Youth Board; in lieu of the Board, create a new non-Brown Act working group, named the Huntington Beach Youth Citizen Leaders Committee (YCLC - name pending). This new Committee shall be a select group of highly qualified high school students, not subject to the Brown Act; b) Their primary duty shall be to plan and coordinate the Annual Youth in Government Day and the Junior Citizens Academy with City staffs guidance, as well as other projects requested by the City Council; and c) The meeting frequency shall be determined by the Committee and City staff to meet needs of effectively planning and executing two primary events with the Community and Library Services Department staff. Approval of Recommendation 7 would require the following actions: ➢ Adopt an Ordinance to repeal/remove the HBMC Chapter 2.108 Youth Board; adopt a Resolution to create a non-Brown Act entity. RECOMMENDATION 8: Restructure the Fourth of July Executive Board to be named as the Independence Day Board with more clarified roles. The Fourth of July Executive Board was created in 1983 as an advisory body to the City Council comprised of 9 to 15 citizen appointees, whose main roles were to work with City staff and volunteers to coordinate the City's renowned Annual Fourth of July parade and celebration. However, over the years, the Fourth of July event scope and components have evolved and expanded, requiring extensive support from City staff. As such, the City hired and utilized outside City of Huntington Beach Page 5 of 6 Printed on 7/26/2023 powered by LegistarTM File#: 23-641 MEETING DATE: 8/1/2023 professional event productions firm, Soundskilz, Inc. and consultant Stacey Newton, to plan and execute Fourth of July celebration. As the City Council, the Executive Board and City staff are evaluating the 2023 Fourth of July events and past festivities, the Committee will bring forth more recommendations for this Board for continued improvement of the programs and events. It is also recommended to rename the Board as the Independence Day Board. Due to the expiration of the City's existing contracts with Soundskilz, Inc. and Stacey Newton, the Committee recommends City staff to initiate a new RFP process for professional event services per the City's procurement policies. Approval of Recommendation 8 would require the following actions: > Adopt an Ordinance to amend the HBMC Chapter 2.106 Fourth of July Executive Board. RECOMMENDATION 9: Restructure the Specific Events Executive Committee as a standing Council Committee to review Council's priorities for large-scale major specific events. The City utilizes the Specific Events Committee, as outlined by the HBMC 13.54.060, which is an internal meeting among staff members from various departments to discuss the permitting of and any logistical requirements for each proposed event. The BCC Ad Hoc Committee recommends that the Specific Events Executive Committee shall be formally adopted as a Council standing committee, comprised of three Council members to review and recommend City Council's priorities and review overall policy on specific events in the City. Approval of Recommendation 9 would require the following actions: > Adopt an Ordinance to amend HBMC Chapter 13.54.06. Environmental Status: Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15378(b)(5), administrative activities of governments that will not result in direct or indirect physical changes in the environment do not constitute a project. Strategic Plan Goal: Community Engagement Attachment(s): 1. PowerPoint Presentation City of Huntington Beach Page 6 of 6 Printed on 7/26/2023 powered by LegistarTm City Council/ ACTION AGENDA August 1, 2023 Public Financing Authority 26. 23-565 Approved a Sole Source Procurement Request with Cascade Pump Company for the servicing or replacement of mixed or axial flow pumps used at all 15 flood control stations Recommended Action: Approve the sole source procurement request with Cascade Pump Company to service the City's existing Cascade pumps at its flood control stations. Approved 7-0 ADMINISTRATIVE ITEMS 27. 23-641 Approved recommendations to streamline and restructure a select number of citizen-led Boards, Commissions, and Committees and Council Committees Recommended Action: A) Consider the Ad Hoc Committee's nine recommendations to reform, consolidate, and/or dissolve a select number of BCCs, as outlined in the staff report; (Individual Committee recommendations approved by minute action individually as shown below); and Committee Recommendation #1 - Dissolve Short-Term Rentals Ad-hoc Council Committee, Housing/RHNA Ad-hoc Council Committee, and Cannabis Regulation and Policy Ad-hoc Council Committee Strickland/Burns 4-3 (Kalmick, Moser, Bolton-No) At 10:59 PM, a motion was made by Strickland, second by Burns, to continue the meeting past the hour of 11:00 PM. The motion was approved 7-0. Committee Recommendation #2 - Dissolve Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee (HBHRC) Strickland/Van Der Mark 4-3 (Kalmick, Moser, Bolton-No) Committee Recommendation #3 - Dissolve the Jet Noise Commission Strickland/Burns 4-3 (Kalmick, Moser, Bolton-No) Committee Recommendation #4 - Dissolve the Mobile Home Advisory Board Strickland/Van Der Mark 4-3 (Kalmick, Moser, Bolton-No) Committee Recommendation #5 - Dissolve the Smart Cities and Technology Council Committee (standing committee) and the Environmental and Sustainability Board and transfer their duties to the Citizen Infrastructure Advisory Board/Public Works Commission (CIAB/PWC) Strickland/Burns 4-3 (Kalmick, Moser, Bolton-No) Committee Recommendation #6 - Rename the Urban Design Study Ad-hoc Committee to the "Downtown and Beach Front Ad-hoc Committee" to broaden their scope of work Strickland/Burns 7-0 Page 9 of 12 City Council/ ACTION AGENDA August 1, 2023 Public Financing Authority Committee Recommendation #7 - Restructure the Huntington Beach Youth Board as a Youth Citizen Leaders Committee, with specific, focused goals Strickland/Burns 7-0 Committee Recommendation #8 Restructure the Fourth of July Executive Board to be name as the Independence Day Board with more clarified roles (action to initiate a new RFP process removed from recommendation) Strickland/Van Der Mark 7-0 Committee Recommendation #9 Restructure the Specific Events Executive Committee as a standing Council Committee to review Council's priorities for large-scale specific events Strickland/Burns 7-0; and B) Direct staff to work with the City Attorney's Office and develop the appropriate Resolution(s), Ordinance(s), and other documents necessary to implement City Council directed adjustments and bring them back to the City Council; and C) Direct staff to plan an appropriate event to recognize and thank citizen appointees who will be retiring due to this restructuring effort for their contribution. Items B) and C) Approved 6-1 (Bolton-No) 28. 23-670 Considered and approved the City Council Charter Review Ad Hoc Committee's recommended Charter Amendments for placement as ballot measures at the March 5, 2024 Statewide Primary Election Recommended Action: A) As requested by the Ad Hoc committee, consider one or more Charter amendments for placement on one or more ballot measures for voter approval during the March 5, 2024 Statewide Primary Election approved individually by straw vote action, as follows: Section 300 (Term Commencement) Strickland/McKeon 6-1 (Kalmick-No) Section 303 (Regular Meetings) Strickland/Burns 4-3(Kalmick, Moser, Bolton-No) Section 612 (Measure C) — with additional suggestions shared a. Beaches and Parks (consider allowance of new bathroom facilities) b. Parks Strickland/McKeon 6-1 (Kalmick-No) Sections 601/602 (Annual Budget) Strickland/McKeon 5-2 (Kalmick, Bolton-No) Page 10 of 12 ArArAiirdirdaltdp- *11rAr se' sasses i No • oarCommission , s ' �! / flj�fCommittee ( BCC) rr J+ f / �'t il r ; — � - � , , ),„.,,,— % Reconfiguration � � _ , • . ....... � _ 0e -7:".-- . -....;..'4 ,,,„....:. ' ...'s .0 414.4k44 City Council Meeting�� 7, 0 � � �,��� � August 1 , 2023 e® e•ese ` , I V t ,,/' Background • On 10/19/2021 , Council approved the Ad Hoc Committee's 10 recommendations to reform, consolidate and/or dissolve a select number of BCCs. A total number of BCCs was reduced from 41 to 35. • Additionally, an internal Staff Liaison Working Group was newly formed to provide a more consistent, uniform interface with BCC members as well as internal support network/training opportunities. • On 11/16/2021 , Council introduced a series of ordinances to implement recommended changes by the Ad Hoc Committee. •.. *** CIO I 14, tt • On 12/21/2021 , Council adopted all the ordinances. '•••.,; , , 0 gyp4,` a ., �a o e c �© 1/4 '` ;.:a6� ! e(UNI'Yo�r Background • On 2/21/2023, City Council introduced ordinances to amend HBMC to codify that all individual appointed BCCs have up to 7 members, with no more than 1 appointee per Councilmember. • On 2/21/2023, City Council also introduced an ordinance to modify the Finance Commission's duties, meeting frequency, and other adjustments to include its original scope of work related to the City's financial planning. At a subsequent City Council meeting, all the ordinances were approved. • On 5/16/2023, Councilmember Burns introduced H-item to request City Council to consider another comprehensive review of all the citizen-led BCCs and,p d�, . „..... ,. gpilRORgp"o`' ma Council Committees, which was approved. • The BCC Review Ad Hoc Committee was formed and met three times kcjA----,,,,ries:4 .--4S on 6/5/2023, 7/17/2023, and 7/20/2023 for deliberation. \ c ••.,B JJ ;gag ko ,� Current BCC Structure by Number As of today, Huntington Beach has over 34 different formal BCCs, plus a dozen of outside agency groups on which the City Council members and/or staff serve. tea '" a `' e > x �x � �� k b �'x'.3m as* �.N '�.y K : •+3,. � aP �. �• ! Y a :n 's�.�`" .,=a„,, ° ,a',. .. 1 -x� .•3 3„,.: ..,: s` �.R • '`w. "�,„„: ,i,^' ` „.:. :", y >a _r'x �? Bca rd l o f rm . f c N pg rs 'with �� + \ t n,A • rn ,to �. x .,�, _u.x x. ..x .�..��sx H rx. "" . �. �x \ t. x x >,> ' , >. >,` x --- ' ply a' .<..,:� .,.at:..�\.x«r-�k>� ,,• >.�.:?�. •.. - .�: �Cvi,.,�,:,»" � ..>•: f,. :•.a. .- \i ..������\�?\ \:�\��-. zx°"xx.=�.Y.��.'.`��- �b's��>�:�. j City ouncil Stana ngNCommi tee y_ Tii a• Y � �� � \owe ��?� � z = ' �"' C ..s :;x'�... ..,,x's. frCitiCourcii*d4joc �x. i ...-xa �.3: z;�".,..1 . s.P' Nv.�£! �xx. v \��: 'x•"Yx�3 � ��'� 2.V: �� 6 C x: "s ` 6 : CoA ,�tte RE t wf o r City/Citizen Committees & Community:Stakehoid rA1,l eetings , \ 5 34 ": cT=, . 1'A L s, s,., �: ,. 5 g „ ..>,,:>.:x .:,.,' ..s » , „ ,.x. -,?x, x..:' <x..x ::.' :� - :.....tax..,.;<-"y- > ..`a\•�.:.. ,.'..�':e. $: ,mac. .,.. .,,� >.. _.. ..,.. ... ,. ..-....,»,.x ..s.-,<.;' ,�,°. ".:�`� �` -"�. �. ,....... .,k.... 6..... � ... : ,. n:...xss>x�x.' ''.E°c. \. ox,.x>x... .:.�.--.. t ,,,< „,<..."�<` „Sx�'k' a::Ya`-" ..�: x . . .. ..s -.-. -. ..�. .. ..- .. . .., -, .E ... ...� a "..'�:: vie . ,,.�' z�.�a.... , .. ,-, 9.x> a. a.. \\. x,9_,>�._.x.P�x,x -..\a�!Z .ac.?�.. .. '£: i,y'' .'s1 �:.. .: ........._........,.vw ,���.,xa..;...:,..,w..�:.au......°.Y,...:,x.. ..." 1:. .�ff.:...� ..�.....w�..�...�;� '.,.a,�,.�. ..,�� .. .`.,�..: . . ...,,;,,,,.,. _„�,,..,.. » ._:....>. ' �w .aa;,.s»x;; .._,,..,�..:..::�.,.�.� >u,�sa:•.�a.�•...N',. ..,.«.�,. ..�'>... ,....a».wad Current BCC Structure by Type ..._. .;.r. : ,�- . _.. _:a-. ., ., . � ,.-r - ..;� ... ......;: ,fit•..: "ttta. .�.. .:-�->r-�:.�_ .� vk�. .b ,.t'�a"'f ;_ ;::ta��:rt.>•:• it��` � i". ,.*' ;��;�a-•-�i== t"s,�- -"h:.:s:.---�"a-,-j Y-a`�,5; `` '.� w�.°3 .t,° `..� a' 'a.�': '��«k�t„ .:a'�`.�',<g. is,.... .:��� ._ '. _ �_=w .��_ ,try �.--.. ,"'.> ,'; °a ..-. .S'S`.,. .- s:w` ,...�:a ..r:.':....:.:---::W- ±��z-:y .,,.r. ...'�':� 4.3 �:�k,�5��- '°:z_��.ia�.�e•- �;:�-�',''��',�_,;.�,:� : �_. �©v n- ,3.,'Er. Ifs,, =„ r�ehmeir�t :.--� cus -- +� erit �, AIAA ..-;-- ,i<nelri �.__ �a`• wry . ��::.=.- � �-. �� ,y�c>F � P �-�.�_-: � ���. t•'�� .fir,,. :;� .. �:„5 3.� -. . `� �� s • ate.€: � .�.ti. " ., �..: c*��. '":�� - - .�...-:.:��� -= k. �_�',�� '" "-=-spa `` '" r • • Council 1Communications ,;' 1. Southeast Area: r '[ Economic•Development Y€.. ..[E_€ r ... - - EE EE i1P h;,,a,Ek„i;;,, a i : ..E v/. 71 F 4 lir Committee .... ,,,,Committee � E€,EE • �... ;,E,, EkkEtEE:,.:,:,,;: €,� � �! .Committee{I=G1C) Committees k:., ..r..- . - t, , 417,: v o <E ,�,,,__,,.%, , € e e each'.,re..-N,,6E:' EE,r,,3 .�,€€Er:, E ,E art G t es&E. r o.e , •Irttergavernmer►tal-.--.;.. 2 Syns.t.R �„� ��,�,-ft�=:� tEE�E� �2 5m � .�: ,�_� �,,, (Total 12) Relations Committee. lE E 7Com ttee FE• Technolo 9 ,i ;;E EE t- gp„xtea W:' ,' 3 Charter Review n " „ , E `�`f Pr Committee' , E +€ :Council Co rtittee* 3. egula � /'�C e`.�', --.- tag s� o ee...:4s BV�F�Re�'V.If� ,..� �� "�..-...•,.•,. ..e�.:,.: �v�`��S`�€ € �.:,:, �d :.: ... � € . p+i`x:.."E N k� �Mmm�t�irY E'� �,E` �y �"i E��� . i ig t :.a : ,. .., Ev1�N.t4I€t1 ttn1C•Et nx"1:� t=tE�Eii:F :•�.€E•tEt.`....E.,. ,-_�„i!. oE,,W. LtE , , Co na _ o rnittee � t=E� ,t�=ttE===__ _,__ _ ,..v._. ...,, �€� :'t E�•.,<<, ��`::::€.«I�Q1NrItQ tarba � x,� �,r .,,., ,,, ,.=s t..F.,:•,t-.,: : ... _', . �,,:3dtt.. ..�a...e.a...:..,..,.t.t•• .. /„�..:�4;, ..E, E:�' E ",€' >;¢ �yy,� '•t:E't .. .� ... �. .u..v.. ,r„ F...k- k.,RS=._:'.:k•�i„NG'.,.rr, e.,. ,,, .,.t... �..�.,,, .r� ..,,_�t..P ';:1 t�S�,. .F't%%. :`sµ- „ �. .,:.. :..,,.� i _.,.,. ., t,_,., .,,�-,. a t .�,j .,.t.t,:.� .?'' ..� � ice..,w.fit,. .. i''' ,_ ,Eu,E„€ _ , , »_ .. " ,} E�,o t a t E a€€t€t,= t€ ,••Er•,6: ,'.i d 1` ",n€N ..,t,E�'y 'dzx' ,3, E€€ ,€ s F,. €,, ,.(, Eattt. € .E..,�,{(fit; ryn ',. ,.•'_. ,'. •.- .; t ,E E ... ?". ::_,,< .` i-:;fie:,. 4Y � .TEt,.€.. €t d. ,tt6aE,.'iE` €�te `'x'4A.„ ,; . •? r t= Et.. - .,-,.Y ,€ ,4;., €,n tH €, ''' Da €_, E,,, ,P;, ` .90, ir, . /..Sa at'e€& alga '•V •EE A ,$. E €€ ,t .tt ,: - .-- ..sx., k't' � 4 ,,�"5, { ,,,ytt= ..; 'a.; ,,,,, €q. r,�„t.� -�. - ,nt{,.E, ,E EE, ,E` ,t �`�7,.!'7 ej�'I..c;.. �'3, p rr..«s;_x.: ...: ���-,a`ai E�,��. . �.::;: z ,,€E,,a.., t.. �..a `�t,.?�,�,., ,. .�. 't I. ., ';,y:: • :s ,t n�,€�.�ta� :-�: � ig,nE'-,3,E€r,€ €__ d, , t �t€ ,, � €F 5:°� Ft E� txaE t E €l.: .,. E;,,��o-1 � R: x55',�'e�.���`!" �'a'�' �`�C x 'n aiti �E Ea • y E€4E , '!€t',;EE€ R ,,,:: £'= f.: Committee* x s E. 4 «t E 3r" 3 E • • h- - hart Term Rentals , ..,,,; Citizen 1. Environmental& 1. Harbor Commission 1. Community& 1. Citizen 1. Citizen Infrastructure 1. Finance BCCs Sustainability Board 2. Jet Noise Library Services Participation Advisory Commission 2. Historic Resources Commission Commission Advisory Board Board/Public Works 2. Investment (Total 17) Board(HRB) 3. Mobile Home Advisory 2. 4th of July 2. Human Commission Advisory 3. Personnel Board(MHAB) Executive Board Relations 2. Design Review Board Board Commission 4. Sunset Beach Local Committee 3. Planning Commission • Coastal Program 3. Youth Board Review Board ` 0 1. E ©ak.View Community ,,,',1, ,'' Specific Events 1 . 'School District l' Other City& 1. 0� � �� p.....11 �'" EEC. . ('�' /"� p Citizen Meeting Executive Ekf City Co itteM :-,,,,Ay 2. =Hu tine ton Central Committee€ E €`� HomelessTas[�;'' ,E E E EE t , ••` rt 9 E Committee s��� � . ,.... � �;�5. � � � �-k n;€E ,�E 1 €€��."�'� e E� €E Par Col aborative :_i, ,- Force 4 , E E"° !i (Total 5)** , €t *Ad-hoc Council Committees not subject to the Brown Act **Community Stakeholder Roundtable Format, not subject to the Brown Act Proposed Committee Recommendations By Category 1101 Dissolution Consolidation Reformation aE • 3:Ad hoc Committees • (1) Environmental & an Design Study A0 _, U rb • ,short-Term Rentals Ad hoc . , Sustarnab�lity Board,and e. Hoc Couincil Committee �'. 2 4 A`2 n S:"' .'4---- ., mow .3 Council Committee 2 Smart Cities•and .} , the Downtown °and .Noy tng1RHN Ad hoc _ Technolo 3Co m ttee gy Beach Front Ad>Hoc Council�Cornrnittee �� � "�` Pu /ice om h`t CIAB/ b �VYorks z�� �G �rnatte�e wit he k •'Cannabis Regulat1on & Pohcy , , ron., � ' ,., .. �, t e ;. r Comm s broader�scope Hof work -!::: :',..,.,.'ii,',,1 Ad hoc Co nc I Gornmit a � , oaf s � Youth B -� the. Huntington Beach _ � ___ � �Y`outh���C�trzen�Leaders. g i. Human Relations Committee, inon Brown s E. £ >�. � < ram � `� a Act group Committee -L Fourth o Jul:` �xeaut�ve�a; Jet Noise Commission • Board independence Dav Board • Mobile Home Advisory . Specific Events B°oad �� � Executrve�Commrttee a ,,';u:,,::, � d ng Commi ,,,L,,,,.,,,,,,,i,...,i.•,,,, ,,,..!:!::;:,,,,,,,,,,,i,-,,E1,,ii, ttee Committee Recommendation 1 Dissolve the following Ad Hoc Council Committees as their tasks have been completed and/or are no longer necessary. • Short-Term Rentals Ad Hoc Council Committee • Housing/RHNA Ad Hoc Council Committee • Cannabis Regulation and Policy Ad Hoc Council Committee s 1 0VIN T \N�ORPOAATF O O.. ➢ REQUIREMENT Council Minute Action. e°' 1, °'.17 g®off k, o y •. o fin°•. ;F a oQ f o 4 COUN:T\ C®®\,CIO Committee Recommendation 2 Dissolve the Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee (HBHRC). Many duties HBHRC issues are being addressed by Orange County (e.g. OC Human Relations Commission publishes annual hate crime reports) and/or community-based nonprofit organizations. Dissolution will remove redundancy of efforts and redirect staff resources to other City priorities. d s>01. ruro ➢ REQUIREMENT Adopt a Resolution to officially ;� N ea7,RAa.., 1„1 dissolve the HBHRC 1.74 QUNTY�t ��r0Fs Committee Recommendation 3 Dissolve the Jet Noise Commission Air traffic is a federal issue and the City has no/limited authority to regulate the altitude, speed, direction or location of aircraft flying over the City. Facilitation between the FAA, major airports, commercial and elected officials could be arranged by the Intergovernmental Relations Committee (IRC) and/or City staff if the need arises. ➢ REQUIREMENT Adopt an Ordinance to remove/repeal p P 0<, : , roe HBMC 2.104 Jet Noise Commission t� ,,kc,o run,474....�q � � ,•:.moo -S77 a;eatsa;° � 0# c1411V ri CP O Committee Recommendation 4 Dissolve the Mobile Home Advisory Board Any conflict resolution issues between mobile home owners and park owners could be directed to the California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD), which regulates mobilehome parks. City staff also can connect residents to appropriate City and community resources. OWI N6f0;\P REQUIREMENT. Adopt an Ordinance to remove/repeal / & " \• HBMC 2. 112 Mobile Home Advisory Board ` _ vim : /� 4 GTE� a .' 4 00 •.,• �1 19�� °oUNT`l c / ' a►.au.®Aral'. Committee Recommendation 5 Dissolve the Smart Cities and Technology Council Committee (standing committee) and the Environmental and Sustainability Board and transfer their duties to the Citizen Infrastructure Advisory Board/Public Works Commission (CIAB/PWC). The primary duties and goals of the Smart Cities and Technology Council Committee and the ESB could be carried out by the CIAB/Public Works Commission and/or City staff, remaining items would come directly to City Council. ➢ REQUIREMENT Approve the recommendation to dissolve e,®ori Ncra °° �\ the Smart Cities and Technology Council Committee via O di V�C1�ORFO�tArE°0'°: Council Minute Action; Adopt an Ordinance to remove/repeal ; d1-12 :',_p p HBMC 2.102 Environmental and Sustainability Board and : �- °� ,�� -9' s. F:s o 0 amend HBMC 2.111 CIAB/Public Works Commissions °� s::lg09P ,<° ° DUN:TY Ga®1 Committee Recommendation 6 Rename the Urban Design Study Ad-hoc Council Committee to the "Downtown and Beach Front Ad-hoc Committee" to broaden their scope of work There is need to address City Council's priorities to improve the Downtown and beachfront area, which includes the hotels and the numbered streets beyond Main Street; consider PCH relinquishment and beautification; beach restrooms improvement, etc. pof It is recommended that this Ad Hoc Committee be renamed to the d4N11N`cr�ti 01 Downtown and Beach Front Ad Hoc Committee and broaden their a+ scope of work accordingly. " • \�pf••• ++ ➢ REQUIREMENT Council Minute Action. 0„ '.e8 17 1909 P \r" Committee Recommendation 7 Restructure the Huntington Beach Youth Board as a Youth Citizen Leaders Committee, with specific, focused goals • Restructure the Youth Board; in lieu of the Board, create a new non-Brown Act working youth group; • Their primary goal shall be to plan and coordinate the Youth In Government Day and the Junior Citizens Academy and other projects requested by the City Council; and • The meeting frequency shall be determined by the Committee and City staff to oft®��"�+► meet needs of effectively planning and executing two primary events with� O•• ifr-a�1TINGTOti` Community and Library Services Department staff. 4�a '(, •--,;;; •`..4, ➢ REQUIREMENT Adopt an Ordinance to `= o" remove/repeal the HBMC 2. 108, adopt a Resolution to W.. Y� .. ..*Fg create a non-Brown working group eo 0 ' ut6gctY Committee Recommendation 8 Restructure the Fourth of July Executive Board to be named as the Independence Day Board with more clarified roles As the City Council, the Executive Board and City staff are evaluating the 2023 Fourth of July events and past festivities, the Committee will bring forth recommendations for the continued improvement of the programs and events. • Direct City staff to initiate a new RFP process for professional event operator(s) per the City's procurement policies. U0TINCT ➢ REQUIREMENT Ordinance to amend HBMC Chapter , r % tk. 2.106 Fourth of July Executive Board. tc-, `. o -�yy P• Ntk. V •• 11'f$09.. .Ns'e lo Committee Recommendation 9 Restructure the Specific Events Executive Committee as a standing Council Committee to review Council's priorities for large-scale specific events. • It is separate from the Specific Events Committee, which is an internal meeting among staff members from various departments per HBMC 13.54.060 to discuss the permitting of and any logistical requirements for each proposed event. • The Specific Events Executive Committee shall be reformatted as Council standing committee, comprised of three Council members to review and recommend priorities and policies for specific events in the City. `, *, R,`' S fi\, ➢ REQUIREMENT Adopt an Ordinance to amend 1=•, HBMC 13.54 Specific Events „I9ngpo °4°°. Recommended Actions A. Consider the Ad Hoc Committee's nine (9) recommendations to reform, consolidate, and/or dissolve a select number of BCCs, as outlined in the staff report below; B. Direct staff to work with the City Attorney's Office and develop the appropriate Resolution(s), Ordinance(s), and other documents necessary to implement City Council directed adjustments and bring them back to the City Council; and/or C. Direct staff to plan an appropriate event to recognize and thank citizen appointees who will be retiring due to this restructuring effort 'for their contribution. i, ,o,p® °� . N- q • Questions ? ii.e.r.,............„, ,. .?., ;61:11m. ,..... .%.. :A.,: ,<$.... :,...„,„1:0)1,:...:, ..$w. ,cz:. .„.„..\wmtwomt.6..„,:.D.„,, ,.... i /l ' 1 ---i...,,L.--:..<(:;:s":".,;, M \09/� - COL/NTY -�`I From: Carol Berk To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF) Cc: suoolementalcomm@lsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: No on Agenda Item#27 Date: Thursday,July 27,2023 6:45:29 PM Esteemed Council Members, I have been a Huntington Beach resident and homeowner for 42 years. I am writing to urge you NOT to eliminate the Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee. We live in a time in which we have seen hate incidents and crimes on the rise. This committee has, for decades, been doing projects, events, and outreach to help people meet and listen to one another. It has organized dialogue panels, meet-ups, essay and art events, and multicultural cinema showings that bring together students and adults in order to foster a more understanding and inclusive community. As far as I am concerned this committee is a treasure and should be allowed to continue their good work. Thank you, Carol Berk SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION • Meeting Date: Fi Agenda Item No.; 3 7-(`'?3 — b 'w) From: Stephen Einstein To: 5upplementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.org Subject: Item 27 and Item 29 Date: Friday,July 28,2023 3:34:59 PM Dear Council Members, A prior commitment precludes my attendance at Tuesday evening's meeting. So,I will not be able to address you in person. Let this brief email serve as my formal communication to you. Item 27: I urge you to retain the Mobile Home Advisory Committee and the Human Relations Committee. Residents of mobile homes make up a significant segment of city residents. This committee provides them an excellent mode of expressing their needs and concerns. With the rise of hate in the city,county,state and nation,the work of the Human Relations Committee is more needed than ever. Item 29: I urge you to pull this item from the agenda. The Declaration of Policy on Human Dignity has been a beacon of light during times of darkness since the Council first adopted it. It is wonderfully worded and expresses what should be the ideals for the entire community. It does not need any reworking. Respectfully, SJE Rabbi Stephen J.Einstein,DHL,DD Pronouns: He/Him/His HaRav Shalom Ya'akov ben Shaya Zalman v'Zelda Founding Rabbi Emeritus Congregation B'nai Tzedek Fountain Valley,CA "The world will not be destroyed by those who do evil,but by those who watch them without doing anything." Albert Einstein Moore, Tania From: cherivatkinson@aol.com Sent: Sunday, July 30, 2023 5:57 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; citycouncil@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Fw: Item 27 Elimination of the HB Human Relations Committee and Item 29 Modification of the Declaration of Policy of Human Dignity Attention: HB City Council For the following reasons, stated to Nextdoor, I am asking you to Vote No on Item 27 and 29. It appears that you have already made of your mind, and this may be an exercise in futility, but I believe that you are going down a dark path by with Item 27 and 29. Cheri Atkinson LCSW Email to Nextdoor At the HB City Council Meeting on 8/1 at 6m, in the HB City Council Chambers, there will be -Item 27, a vote to eliminate the HB Human Relations Committee of 25 years. This group works with the HB Police to monitor hate incidents and crimes, which are on the increase this year. The HB Human Relations Committee inspires and promotes mutual understanding, respect and the well being of all in our community through education and engagement. Item 29- The Declaration of Policy and Dignity is a declaration of the value of all in our community, and our commitment to stand up against acts of hate.This was written by past mayors Ralph Bauer and Shirley Dettloff. I believe that we will be going down a wrong path if Item 27 and 29 pass. You can submit you opinion against Item 27 and 29 by writing to supplementalcommun@surfcity- hn.org and city.council@surfcity-hb.org (By Monday) or you cant attend the HB City Council and speak, on 8/1 at 6. Thanks for taking your time to read this. I have great faith in our community. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date: al 1 , _') Agenda Item No4 a?" (23- (ny I) Moore, Tania From: Karen Marie Carroll <dockaren44@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday,July 30, 2023 6:05 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Concerns regarding 8-1-23 agenda From: Karen Carroll To Mayor Strickland and Members of the City Council Following are my concerns regarding the unwarranted and unethical "recommendations" coming from the ad hoc "committee" that would dissolve or neutralize commissions or boards meant to ensure local input for effective intervention or mediation is needed to resolve local problems and complaints. You appear to be asking Sacramento to micromanage HB governing. Ironic! Item 27 Recommendations to streamline and restructure a select number of citizen-led Boards, Commissions, and Committees and Council Committees 1. Dissolution Housing/RHNA Ad Hoc Council Committee(for recommendations prior to public hearings)—reason given- "tasks complete"— • Hopefully, a committee for this purpose is simply paused until a responsible HB plan for housing is eventually advanced—at which time the council should consult with professionally qualified persons to outline a workable timeline for implementation of the plan. Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee (HBHRC). The City Council suggests that the County of Orange (e.g. Orange County Human Relations Commission who publishes annual hate crime reports) and/or community-based nonprofit organizations would suffice to address any citizen concerns about their civil rights. • The reality is,the County Commission must address human rights violation complaints that come up in all cities in the County as well as schools in the County. Further, the County Commission has a "cooling off'period for each case. This means that serious problems faced by HB residents could not be resolved immediately with the help of fellow citizens who are familiar with local circumstances and are sincerely committed to assisting their neighbors..The immediacy,of residents' concerns greatly outweighs any redundancy of mission statements on paper. This totally contradicts the city's stand on local control. Mobile Home Advisory Board (MHAB) The ad hoc committee suggests that conflict resolution issues between mobile home owners and park owners could be directed to the California Department of Housing and Community Development, which 1 regulates mobile home parks. Also stated,there are resources in the city to which City staff could direct mobile home resident complaints. • These resources are not specified. Does the staff currently work with individual residents and established agencies or organizations? Which ones?We commend the City's MHTBRA program for providing monthly rental assistance to eligible very low-income Huntington Beach senior mobile home owners, but there are other legal and civil rights that are better addressed by fellow citizens who are familiar with local conditions and who strongly committed to their neighbors. This totally contradicts the cty's,stand on local control. 2. Consolidation Environmental and Sustainability Board • The BCC Ad Hoc Committee recommends transfer of duties that may be appropriate to the Citizen Infrastructure Advisory Board/Public Works Commission(CIAB/PWC)with remaining duties going directly to City Council. * So staff and citizens who monitor and maintain our streets, roads, and public works in general are to take on the environmental concerns of the city? In denying approval of the Housing Element that was ready for submission to the State, Mayor Tony Strickland said that having to sign the statement of overriding considerations violated his 1st Amendment rights in that the statement forced agreement that mandated housing projects are more important than the impacts to the environment. "I can't in good conscience have my speech forced to sign a statement of overriding considerations because it goes against everything I stand for ... This is an easy vote for me".' If the environment is that important to the Council, why would we not prioritize a Board specifically committed to environmental quality? Is the City Council serious about doing our part to care for our planet? 3. Reformation Fourth of July Executive Board • The BCC Ad Hoc Committee recommends renaming the Independence Day Board(and providing clarification of roles). Existing contracts with Soundskilz, Inc. and Stacey Newton are expiring, so the Committee recommends City staff to initiate a new RFP process for professional event services per the City's procurement policies. *City residents are interested in possible relationships between the potential providers of professional event services and members of the City Council. Questions about the out-of-court settlement with Code 4 leads to questions about campaign assistance to recently elected council members by its CEO,Kevin Elliott. Specific Events Committee as a Specific Events Executive Committee • Possibly related to the Fourth of July Board recommendation, The Specific Events Committee as a Specific Events Executive Committee as a standing Council Committee to 2 review Council's priorities for large-scale major specific events as a standing Council Committee to review Council's priorities for large-scale major specific events. Item 28 Charter Committee Ad Hoc Proposals • Why is this Council wanting to change dates and requirements for City Clerk? The duties of a City Clerk are very specialized and the experience of our current Clerk, especially over time in the city, is unquestioningly as good as it gets. HB citizens fear that this is laying the groundwork for further cronyism, and possible nepotism. How far will the Council majority go in remaking the City's administrative infrastructure to serve their long-term agenda and special interests? • Assuring security and integrity of voting in the City seems a worthy goal. Need citizens .worry about the possibility of intimidation, discrimination or overlooking qualifications of personnel? 3 Moore, Tania From: Shirlee Krause <shirleekrause@yahoo.com> Sent: Sunday,July 30, 2023 10:33 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Is Huntington Beach attempting to become a "Dictator Government"? TO: Huntington Beach City Council I am a handicapped 80-year-old woman who has owned a mobile home for almost 23 years, as well as previously been a renter here. I've seen many changes--good and bad, but some of the items on your August 1st Agenda I consider disgusting and shocking, enough so as to make me ill--no kidding! It has come to my attention that there are four City Council Members (aka "The Fab Four") who are systematically trying every dirty trick in the book to strip us mobile homeowners of our rights,together with attempting to harass all our citizens who want to vote without hassles and/or threats. Specifically, the last agenda item which recommendations for potential charter amendments, one of which includes having the City control voting for local items, not the Orange County Registrar of Voters. This proposal includes voter identification and monitoring of ballot boxes. Come on! Are we becoming Big Brother here-OR-just becoming a communistic city? One interesting development that all our Huntington Beach residents should be made aware of is the City is hiring a new Chief Assistant City Attorney who, I've been told, was forced out of his last three positions, filed for bankruptcy twice(debts listed were malpractice claims), and was sanctioned by a judge because he received payments from his bankruptcy clients for court fees, but did not pay all the client's court fees until the clients learned he hadn't paid them. Yikes! Also, allegedly,this man went to a non-California accredited law school. This is important because the Acuity Charter requires that the elected City Attorney "MUST HAVE GRADUATED FROM AN ABA SCHOOL!" What? I guess this doesn't apply when The Fab Four has decided he's their choice! This entire situation is shameful, a travesty and a "black eye" for Huntington Beach and all of us residents! Clean up your act people or we're going to need to implement a new "Count The Silverware Committee" to monitor all the City's money! Respectfully submitted, Shirlee A. Krause shirleekrause@yahoo.com 1 Moore, Tania From: Debbi Parrott <debparrott@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday, July 30, 2023 3:58 PM To: CITY COUNCIL (INCL. CMO STAFF); supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Items 27-29 Esteemed Council Members, I greatly oppose the dissolution of the Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee, as well as the proposed election changes in item 28 as well as item 29. The HBHRC customizes its programs based on the community's needs, uses a relatively low amount of city staff resources and shows our city's commitment to the ongoing safety and freedom from intimidation for our citizens. They have no interaction with the county level Human Relations Commission and while Groundswell occasionally partners with HBHRC, they do not duplicate these efforts nor do they have the relationships with the police and city leadership that the committee does. The election portion of item 28 seems to be great overreach as there is no evidence of systemic problems with the county registrar and may be seen as election tampering and open up the city to lawsuits. In regards to Item 29, The Declaration of the Policy on Human Dignity shouldn't be altered without an understanding of intent, context and purpose. Thank you for your time, With gratitude, Debbi Parrott 1 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Monday,July 31, 2023 9:04 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Agenda#27 as it relates to HB Human Relations Committee From:Carol Daus<caroldaus@gmail.com> Sent: Friday,July 28,2023 8:19 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda#27 as it relates to HB Human Relations Committee Dear City Council Members, I am concerned about agenda #27 (23-641 Recommendations to streamline and restructure a select number of citizen-led Boards, Commissions, and Committees and Council Committees), particularly as it relates to the Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee (HBHRC). As a 27-year resident of HB, I have been impressed with the accomplishments of this fine group and I hope it will be retained despite this recommendation. Now more than ever, the HB Human Relations Committee, with its 25- year successful track record, is essential to strengthen and promote a sense of community, improve safety, and respect the rights of residents and visitors. In the past couple of years, I have seen my own neighborhood in south Huntington Beach deteriorate in terms of vandalism, unsupervised children on e-bikes, hate crimes (i.e., Pride flags destroyed in front of homes) and even neighbors no longer speaking to one another. It was never like this before and it's not like this in many other communities in Orange County. We are a rich and diverse community with residents from different walks of life, and as more people of different backgrounds move into the area we'll continue to experience this population trend. That's why a group like the Human Relations Committee plays a vital role. It can bring a wide array of community members together to identify common goals that can help make Huntington Beach a stronger community for residents and visitors. Please vote NO on Agenda item #27--especially if it involves abolishing the HB Human Relations Committee. Thank you, 1 Carol Daus ReplyForward 2 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Monday, July 31, 2023 9:04 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Agenda Item 28: Dissolution of Boards/Commissions Attachments: JNC Note for CC.pdf Original Message From: philburtis@gmail.com <philburtis@gmail.com> Sent: Saturday,July 29, 2023 12:05 PM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Cc: Gates, Michael <Michael.Gates@surfcity-hb.org>; Frakes,Sandie<Sandie.Frakes@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda Item,21r Dissolution of Boards/Commissions Attached is a short note. Thanks to everyone who has supported us in these past 6 years Phil 1 July 28,2023 To:City Council Re:Jet Noise Commission Fm:Phil Burtis,JNC Commissioner Cc:City Attorney It has been a privilege and honor to serve the residents of Huntington Beach as part of the activities related to jet noise over the City since the fall of 2017. If the time has come to dissolve the Commission, that's fine. However,over the next 3 to 7 years,there will be significant changes to the overall aviation industry country-wide,and there may be legislative and financial opportunities that will come as part of the"air taxi"AAM/UAM initiatives by the FAA, NASA,and others. It may be worth considering having some small ongoing staff capability to monitor these initiatives. Recall that part of the reason the Commission was created was due to being totally surprised by the FAA NextGen project. Similarly,there will be a day when someone comes into the City and wants to build what's called a"vertiport"to land their"air taxi". Where that can go,what it needs,what fees can the City charge (if any)are all issues not yet addressed. I would like to note,for the record,that the Jet Noise Commission did have several positive outcomes: - We held a public workshop attended by over 200 residents and presented information on what had happened in 2017 to increase noise overhead and steps we hoped to take to mitigate it. - Working with Congressman Rohrabacher,we actually got an agreement from the Jet Blue CEO that he would retrofit their A320 fleet with a "vortex generator"that reduces noise on landing. Of course,Jet Blue later left Long Beach entirely so it became a moot victory. - Working with Long Beach Airport and Southwest Airlines,we helped draft a proposal for a slight modification to the Long Beach approach over the City. Although ultimately rejected,it did establish an excellent working relationship with Long Beach and Southwest. - As a result of that relationship,Southwest has made a best-effort to have their pilots request a higher approach over the City instead of the default 1600 feet given by FAA air traffic control.As a result,since January 1,2023,over 80%of all Southwest over-land arrivals from the east have been at 2500 feet or higher when crossing near Goldenwest and Ellis,and over 70%of all Southwest flights crossing the coast from the north have been at 2500 feet or higher. I would like to thank all the other Commissioners who have worked together on the Commission these past few years for their time,commitment and expertise. Finally, I would like to thank the staff that has supported us with a special thank you to Travis Hopkins for his perseverance coordinating all our interactions with the airports and airlines. Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Monday,July 31, 2023 9:06 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: comment,#27,#28,#29, 8-1-23 council meeting From: Dan Jamieson<danjamieson4@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday,July 30, 2023 1:31 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: comment,#27,#28,#29, 8-1-23 council meeting Dear HB City Council: As a Huntington Beach resident, I appreciate the chance to comment in several items under consideration at the August 1, 2023 council meeting: --Item 27: Boards and Commissions I support retaining the mobile home and human relations committees. Both these committees serve vulnerable residents. The county's human relations committee is an important group,but it is not able to focus on the specific issues facing HB. Our city suffers from an unfortunate strand of hatred and bigotry, and we need the "local control" and oversight of our own human relation committee. The mobile home advisory board also serves some of our most economically vulnerable citizens, many of them seniors on limited incomes who face rising rents from aggressive mobile-home park owners. These wealthy owners, including private equity firms,have been squeezing mobile-home residents for their limited resources. (It is not lost on HB residents that mobile-home park owners have supported the current council majority.) While the current majority rails against the Calif. Dept. of Housing and Community Development regarding housing policy overall, in this instance, when vulnerable mobile-home residents are involved,the majority is content to punt the issue to HCD. But HCD is far removed from issues impacting local mobile-home residents, and our own advisory board can inform city leaders and HCD about HB-related park issues and violations. The council should do the right thing and retain the mobile home advisory board. --Item 28: Charter Amendments Please table this item for further review. It is unclear why the council majority wants to amend the city charter. We just had a detailed and costly charter review process that went on the ballot last year. Why this new effort? What is the cost? The prior charter commission developed proposals in an open,transparent process, but this proposal was developed by a handpicked group of like-minded council members meeting behind closed doors. The mayor's retort last June was that the recommendations would be debated at a council meeting. But that will be too late. Residents have no idea why the item proposes changes to a hodgepodge of charter sections relating to bathroom footprints, budgets, meetings, elections and city offices. How are residents supposed to comment? Some recommendations may be good, others bad. Some probably don't belong in the charter. Several appear to i give the mayor more power and open up local elections to political influence. But we don't have enough information. What we will get will come from a limited, late-night council debate AFTER residents have spoken. Please delay this item, and if pursued, do it correctly through an open and rigorous process with public notice and comment, and put any changes to the voters in a November general election, not the lower-turnout primary election. --Item 29: Amending the Declaration of Policy on Human Dignity Please vote NO on this item. The item does not state why we need to amend the Declaration,which is similar to the earlier 1996 version(both adopted unanimously by prior HB city councils). Perhaps it is the addition of "gender identity" to the newer text. The proposal looks like part of a continued culture war by the council majority against vulnerable people--especially trans people who are the subject of extremely vicious hate incidents and crimes. Perhaps I am wrong about the majority's motive;perhaps the council majority wishes to strengthen the Declaration. But the majority's actions to date do not inspire confidence. Please, do not pursue this item. Sincerely, Dan Jamieson Huntington Beach 2 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Monday,July 31, 2023 9:10 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Why? From:Carolyn Kanode<carolkanode@me.com> Sent:Sunday,July 30, 2023 7:12 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Why? My concern is this you were elected to represent the entire city of Huntington Beach not to foster a negative political agenda Where is this heading?Are you puppets for a certain political philosophy? We have always been a kind, caring community As a founder of the Huntington Youth Shelter there was support and guidance from the police department and city officials Today there is a dark atmosphere as the library is threatened, along with boards that represent an enlightened community So, I offer you a REAL project not filled with hate Build a Huntington Beach Museum!! Other surrounding cities have history museums Why not Huntington Beach? I offer this as a challenge Your legacy could be a positive one rather then the negativity which surrounds this city Use your leadership to better the city Create a history museum build a spot where where the youth can visit and learn to appreciate the proud history of Huntington. Beach Respectfully Carol Kanode 17382 Alta Vista Circle Huntington Beach, 92647 714-235-5889 Sent from my iPhone 1 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Monday,July 31, 2023 12:21 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: HB City Council Agenda 8.1.2023 Please Withdraw Items 27, 28, and 29 From: Pat Goodman<patgoodman@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday,July 31, 2023 11:55 AM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>; Fikes, Cathy<CFikes@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: HB City Council Agenda 8.1.2023 Please Withdraw Items 27, 28,and 29 Dear Mayor Strickland, Mayor Pro Tern Van Der Mark, and City Council Members, Please withdraw Items 27, 28, and 29 from the City Council August 1, 2023, agenda. I find them to be very troubling to the wellbeing of the city and its residents and voters. My first comment applies to items #27, 28, 29 and the use of Ad Hoc committees by the mayor. I appreciate the effort by the mayor to use Ad Hoc committees to study issues, formulate policy for the city, and try to move items forward in a timely manner. However, Ad hoc committees were misused for agenda items 27 and 28 on Tuesday, August 1 city council agenda. It is not too late to correct this issue for agenda item # 29. And, therefore, should be withdrawn from the agenda. In my mind, Ad Hoc committees ought to include citizens that try to reflect the impacted demographics of the issue under review, and/or folks with the experience and knowledge to add value to the discussion, and formulation of any policy recommendations. A city staff, and city attorney's office liaison(s) could be included for background as needed. The committee needs to engage the public, issue its report including, purpose, dates, times met, public comments, expert opinions, conclusions, and recommendations. A study session by the full council needs to take place for public input and discussion among the council in order to know how to move forward on the item. Couldn't three councilmembers meet periodically to brainstorm ideas without violating the Brown Act, and then bring an item forward this item on a subsequent city council agenda? Why do you need an ad hoc committee that meets behind closed doors? Is this what transparency looks like? Agenda Item # 27 The Human Relations Commission and the Mobile Home Advisory Board. They provide residents, businesses, police, and other first responders with an array of benefits and support when the situation calls for it. Here are some that I can think of: sounding boards for issues of economic and social policy, actions of discrimination, support to our police and victims of crime in the areas of human rights, community violence prevention, and i trust in our first responders. This commission and board promote problem solving through dialog, and, at their best, local control by the community to address issues in a timely manner. It is the job of city staff to connect residents to resources regardless of the role of a board or commission. So why have any board, commission, or committee in the first place? It is to engage the community in problem solving, and government oversight. Again, it's about local control, who are people most likely to turn to when they have questions or need services? I think we turn to local government. Certainly, we can find the funds to maintain this board and commission. As far as merging and streamlining these activities I'm all for it and if some other agency can field this work for the people of Huntington Beach, great! Have you met with the affected members of the boards, commissions, and committees identified for elimination, consolidation, renaming? I think they would have something to say to address redundancies, and ways to consolidate responsibilities. One of these mergers and consolidations I question is that of the Environmental and Sustainability Board with the Public Works Commission. Will the PWC membership increase to include members to address environmental reviews that come before the city council and promote environmental 86 sustainability programs? I do not understand Recommendation # 8 and 9. It is more of a transparency issue for you to identify why it is important to change the name of the Fourth of July Executive Board? Why would the city council have an events Ad Hoc subcommittee with only three members of the council on it? I'm concerned about public engagement and transparency and that this may be a tool to direct funding and resources to campaign contributors. Agenda Item # 28 This item recommends eight changes to the city's charter with the caveat for more. I understand that this is only a proposal. The estimated ROV's cost for each item is $300,000 plus whatever costs the city might incur. I am very concerned about all of these recommendations save maybe # 1 and # 3. I am not in favor of 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8. And have a few words to say about # 7. Our government needs to look at ways for more voter participation and not tinker with voter access to cast a ballot in California. Voter participation is a major issue in our Democracy. The City/County of San Francisco expanded voter participation for people who have children in the school district. These are people that pay taxes including property taxes. This expands participation in school board elections. Your proposal dilutes participation and is wrong for the voters in Huntington Beach. I do not know how you will segregate the city ballot items from the county, state, and federal elections to implement this item's proposals. 1. Are there any allegations, and actual documentation of fraud and abuse of the elections in Huntington Beach? 2. What is the purpose of this measure? 3. What are the steps we need to take to have greater participation in our elections? 4. Are you proposing separate ballots and drop off sites for city races and ballot measures? 2 5. Does this proposal add twelve new in-person polling sites in addition to the 13 ROV sites? Agenda Item # 29 I was here when that hate crime/murder occurred in our city at the McDonald's on Beach Blvd. in 1996. Subsequent city councils have adopted this Declaration on Human Dignity unanimously (except for 2021, one member did not sign it). The perpetrator was not charged only with murder but also a hate crime under federal law. It was a horrendous time in our city's history. We cannot forget it because, sadly, these types of crimes that target "people who do not look like me" are still taking place. As residents, we need constant education on these crimes so that when we "see something we can say something." Again, my comments regarding Ad Hoc committees apply to this agenda item as well. This statement is one step in our education. It is directional, aspirational, and sets a welcoming no nonsense tone for our city to tourists, businesses, city employees and residents. Please withdraw agenda items 27, 28, and 29. Rethink how to address these serious issues by engaging the public to come up with the best policies for our city as possible. Thank you. Patricia Goodman Huntington Beach, CA 3 Moore, Tania From: Judy Standerford <judystanderford@gmail.com> Sent: Monday,July 31, 2023 1:43 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Letter for August 1, 2023 City Council Meeting July 31, 2023 To the City Council In Re:Agenda Item 27—August 1 City.Council Meeting The reason for this item seems to be only to silence residents of Huntington Beach.The four council members in the majority do not want to hear any criticism of their actions. As the members of these committees are all volunteers any money saved by eliminating them is minimal. Agenda Item 28. Pertaining to: Section 310 This makes no sense at all. You want to elect a clerk who has no experience or skill in running an election and put this person in charge of a process which is complex and needs to be done carefully. Section 702. And once you have your incompetent clerk you want to add unnecessary restrictions on voting by Huntington Beach residents. Voter ID at the polls is only meant to repress voting turnout—it has nothing whatsoever to do with stopping voter fraud. There is so little voter fraud anywhere in the state of California or in Orange.County that putting this restriction on voters can only mean that you want to depress turnout.To allow for at least 12 polling places for in person voting is laughable. If you truly intend for all voting in Huntington Beach to be in person (and how else would this work if you want voter ID)then do your calculations again and this time allow enough time and space for this to happen.And what form of ID would be acceptable to prove residence?And when would the clerk's office be open to provide this form of ID?Also—mail ballots have proved to be very popular and very safe from fraud. Would you take this option away from the over 50%of voters who vote this way? Please keep Huntington Beach functioning as a democracy and keep in mind that you serve the residents of this city. Judy Standerford 19521 Sardinia Lane Huntington Beach,CA 92646 1 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Monday,July 31, 2023 1:50 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Agenda Item 27 From: Russell Neal<russneal@ieee.org> Sent: Monday,July 31,2023 12:53 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda Item 27 Item 27 Boards and commissions The boards and commission reduction and consolidation proposal seems reasonable. In particular,the Human Relations Commission is a one-sided policy advocacy group which is better suited for the private sector. Government should not lobby itself. I do not have detailed knowledge of the Mobile Home Advisory Board. I see it as mostly lobbying for rent control on behalf of park residents. However, mobile home parks are a ticking time bomb when ownership of the buildings and the land is separated. This is a private party problem that always somehow becomes a city problem. In my opinion, this arrangement should not be permitted in the first place. The right answer is for the residents to own the land through an association the way they do in condominiums. There may be innovative ways to finance a transition to this arrangement, given tax laws and various private, state, and federal housing programs. I would support a working group of some sort to investigate such a transition to hopefully defuse the unpleasant situation. Russell Neal Huntington Beach 1 Moore, Tania From: Cecily Gates <cecilygates@gmail.com> Sent: Monday,July 31, 2023 3:40 PM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF); supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Agenda items Dear Mayor Strickland, Mayor Pro Tem Van Der Mark , and City Council, My first comment applies to items #27, 28, 29 and the use of Ad Hoc committees by the mayor. I appreciate the effort by the mayor to use Ad Hoc committees to study issues, formulate policy for the city, and try to move items forward in a timely manner. However, Ad hoc committees were misused for agenda items 27 and 28 on Tuesday, August 1 city council agenda. It is not too late to correct this issue for agenda item # 29. And, therefore, should be withdrawn from the agenda. In my mind, Ad Hoc committees ought to include citizens that try to reflect the impacted demographics of the issue under review, and/or folks with the experience and knowledge to add value to the discussion, and formulation of any policy recommendations. A city staff, and city attorney's office liaison(s) could be included for background as needed. The committee needs to engage the public, issue its report including, purpose, dates, times met, public comments, expert opinions; conclusions, and recommendations. A study session by the full council needs to take place for public input and discussion among the council in order to know how to move forward on the item. Couldn't three councilmembers meet periodically to brainstorm ideas without violating the Brown Act, and then bring an item forward this item on a subsequent city council agenda? Why do you need an ad hoc committee that meets behind closed doors? Is this what transparency looks like? Agenda Item # 27 The Human Relations Commission and the Mobile Home Advisory Board. They provide residents, businesses, police, and other first responders with an array of benefits and support when the situation calls for it. Here are some that I can think of: sounding boards for issues of economic and social policy, actions of discrimination, support to our police and victims of crime in the areas of human rights, community violence prevention, and trust in our first responders. This commission and board promote problem solving through dialog, and, at their best, local control by the community to address issues in a timely manner. It is the job of city staff to connect residents to resources regardless of the role of a board or commission. So why have any board, commission, or committee in the first place? It is to engage the community in problem solving, and government oversight. Again, it's about local control, who are people most likely to turn to when they have questions or need services? I think we turn to local government. Certainly, we can find the funds to maintain this board and commission. As far as merging and streamlining these activities I'm all for it and if some other agency can field this work for the people of Huntington Beach, great! Have you met with the affected members of the boards, commissions, and committees identified for elimination, consolidation, renaming? I think they would have something to say to address redundancies, and ways to consolidate responsibilities. i One of these mergers and consolidations I question is that of the Environmental and Sustainability Board with the Public Works Commission. Will the PWC membership increase to include members to address environmental reviews that come before the city council and promote environmental & sustainability programs? I do not understand Recommendation # 8 and 9. It is more of a transparency issue for you to identify why it is important to change the name of the Fourth of July Executive Board? Why would the city council have an events Ad Hoc subcommittee with only three members of the council on it? I'm concerned about public engagement and transparency and that this may be a tool to direct funding and resources to campaign contributors. Agenda Item # 28 This item recommends eight changes to the city's charter with the caveat for more. I understand that this is only a proposal. The estimated ROV's cost for each item is $300,000 plus whatever costs the city might incur. Our government needs to look at ways for more voter participation and not tinker with voter access to cast a ballot in California. Voter participation is a major issue in our Democracy. The City/County of San Francisco expanded voter participation for people who have children in the school district. These are people that pay taxes including property taxes. This expands participation in school board elections. Your proposal dilutes participation and is wrong for the voters in Huntington Beach. I do not know how you will segregate the city ballot items from the county, state, and federal elections to implement this item's proposals. 1. Are there any allegations, and actual documentation of fraud and abuse of the elections in Huntington Beach? 2. What is the purpose of this measure? 3. What are the steps we need to take to have greater participation in our elections? 4. Are you proposing separate ballots and drop off sites for city races and ballot measures? 5. Does this proposal add twelve new in-person polling sites in addition to the 13 ROV sites? Agenda Item # 29 I was here when that hate crime/murder occurred in our city at the McDonald's on Beach Blvd. in 1996. Subsequent city councils have adopted this Declaration on Human Dignity unanimously (except for 2021, one member did not sign it). The perpetrator was not charged only with murder but also a hate crime under federal law. It was a horrendous time in our city's history. We cannot forget it because, sadly, these types of crimes that target "people who do not look like me" are still taking place. As residents, we need constant education on these crimes so that when we "see something we can say something." Again, my comments regarding Ad Hoc committees apply to this agenda item as well. Please withdraw agenda items 27, 28, and 29. Rethink how to address these serious issues by engaging the public to come up with the best policies for our city as possible. Thank you. 2 Sent from my iPhone 3 Moore, Tania From: Cecily Gates <cecilygates@gmail.com> Sent: Monday,July 31, 2023 3:41 PM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF); supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Agenda items. Dear Mayor Strickland, Mayor Pro Tern Van Der Mark , and City Council, My first comment applies to items #27, 28, 29 and the use of Ad Hoc committees by the mayor. I appreciate the effort by the mayor to use Ad Hoc committees to study issues, formulate policy for the city, and try to move items forward in a timely manner. However, Ad hoc committees were misused for agenda items 27 and 28 on Tuesday, August 1 city council agenda. It is not too late to correct this issue for agenda item # 29. And, therefore, should be withdrawn from the agenda. In my mind, Ad Hoc committees ought to include citizens that try to reflect the impacted demographics of the issue under review, and/or folks with the experience and knowledge to add value to the discussion, and formulation of any policy recommendations. A city staff, and city attorney's office liaison(s) could be included for background as needed. The committee needs to engage the public, issue its report including, purpose, dates, times met, public comments, expert opinions, conclusions, and recommendations. A study session by the full council needs to take place for public input and discussion among the council in order to know how to move forward on the item. Couldn't three councilmembers meet periodically to brainstorm ideas without violating the Brown Act, and then bring an item forward this item on a subsequent city council agenda? Why do you need an ad hoc committee that meets behind closed doors? Is this what transparency looks like? Agenda Item # 27 The Human Relations Commission and the Mobile Home Advisory Board. They provide residents, businesses, police, and other first responders with an array of benefits and support when the situation calls for it. Here are some that I can think of: sounding boards for issues of economic and social policy, actions of discrimination, support to our police and victims of crime in the areas of human rights, community violence prevention, and trust in our first responders. This commission and board promote problem solving through dialog, and, at their best, local control by the community to address issues in a timely manner. It is the job of city staff to connect residents to resources regardless of the role of a board or commission. So why have any board, commission, or committee in the first place? It is to engage the community in problem solving, and government oversight. Again, it's about local control, who are people most likely to turn to when they have questions or need services? I think we turn to local government. Certainly, we can find the funds to maintain this board and commission. As far as merging and streamlining these activities I'm all for it and if some other agency can field this work for the people of Huntington Beach, great! Have you met with the affected members of the boards, commissions, and committees identified for elimination, consolidation, renaming? I think they would have something to say to address redundancies, and ways to consolidate responsibilities. One of these mergers and consolidations I question is that of the Environmental and Sustainability Board with the Public Works Commission. Will the PWC membership increase to include members to i address environmental reviews that come before the city council and promote environmental & sustainability programs? I do not understand Recommendation # 8 and 9. It is more of a transparency issue for you to identify why it is important to change the name of the Fourth of July Executive Board? Why would the city council have an events Ad Hoc subcommittee with only three members of the council on it? I'm concerned about public engagement and transparency and that this may be a tool to direct funding and resources to campaign contributors. Agenda Item # 28 This item recommends eight changes to the city's charter with the caveat for more. I understand that this is only a proposal. The estimated ROV's cost for each item is $300,000 plus whatever costs the city might incur. Our government needs to look at ways for more voter participation and not tinker with voter access to cast a ballot in California. Voter participation is a major issue in our Democracy. The City/County of San Francisco expanded voter participation for people who have children in the school district. These are people that pay taxes including property taxes. This expands participation in school board elections. Your proposal dilutes participation and is wrong for the voters in Huntington Beach. I do not know how you will segregate the city ballot items from the county, state, and federal elections to implement this item's proposals. 1. Are there any allegations, and actual documentation of fraud and abuse of the elections in Huntington Beach? 2. What is the purpose of this measure? 3. What are the steps we need to take to have greater participation in our elections? 4. Are you proposing separate ballots and drop off sites for city races and ballot measures? 5. Does this proposal add twelve new in-person polling sites in addition to the 13 ROV sites? Agenda Item # 29 I was here when that hate crime/murder occurred in our city at the McDonald's on Beach Blvd. in 1996. Subsequent city councils have adopted this Declaration on Human Dignity unanimously (except for 2021, one member did not sign it). The perpetrator was not charged only with murder but also a hate crime under federal law. It was a horrendous time in our city's history. We cannot forget it because, sadly, these types of crimes that target "people who do not look like me" are still taking place. As residents, we need constant education on these crimes so that when we "see something we can say something." Again, my comments regarding Ad Hoc committees apply to this agenda item as well. Please withdraw agenda items 27, 28, and 29. Rethink how to address these serious issues by engaging the public to come up with the best policies for our city as possible. Thank you. Sent from my iPhone 2 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Monday,July 31, 2023 5:22 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: items 27,28,29 From: Flossie Horgan<horganf@gmail.com> Sent: Monday,July 31, 2023 4:53 PM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: items 27,28,29 Dear Council members The above mentioned items which appear on tonight's agenda should be withdrawn. The various constituencies that exist in our city offer expertise and interest on City issues. The City Council has opportunities to engage with the public to move forward on various complex issues facing our City. Increased citizen involvement can lead to a more vibrant Huntington Beach. Flossie Horgan i Moore, Tania From: Siegal, Joan <Joan.Siegal@aecom.com> Sent: Monday, July 31, 2023 7:27 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Cc: CITY COUNCIL (INCL. CMO STAFF) Subject: August 1st City Council Meeting, Comment on Agenda Item#27 Attachments: Public Comment Agenda Item #27.docx Please see attached comments. Joan P.Siegal Cell: 714-886-7056 1 Date:July 31, 2023 Comment on: Huntington Beach City Council Meeting, August 1, 2023, Agenda Item #27, Recommendations to streamline and restructure a select number of citizen-led Boards, Commissions, and Committees and Council Committees: • Adoption of an Ordinance to remove/repeal HBMC Chapter 2.102 Environmental and Sustainability Board and amend HBMC Chapter 2.111 Citizen Infrastructure Advisory Board/Public Works Commission. Comment by: Joan Siegal, Member Environmental and Sustainability Board I am writing to request that the City Council reconsider elimination of the Environmental and Sustainability Board (Board). As I understand it,the purpose of this Board should be to advise the City Council on policies and proposed actions pertaining to: (1) stewardship of the natural environment of Huntington Beach, including beaches and open spaces (that is,the environment) and (2) conservation of natural resources (that is, sustainability) including water and fuel, and reduction in waste streams to go into landfills. Stewardship and conservation issues may be quite different from infrastructure issues, so combining the Boards would not eliminate overlap to a significant extent. Also, there is real benefit in having citizen involvement in the development and implementation of environmental policies. Often policies are handed down from Federal,State and Local government with insufficient thought on how the policies will affect the average citizen or if the ratio of pain imposed by the regulation offsets the environmental benefit. This results in citizens complaining about governmental overreach. Conversely, not paying attention to issues raised by citizens will cause complaints about government neglect. Currently the Board (including myself) is made up of practicing environmental engineering professionals, educators, and people retired from those professions. Having people with these backgrounds is helpful in understanding impacts of actions that could adversely affect the environment. We are also good at spotting regulations that do not have the infrastructure to support them. However, I would recommend openings in the Board, including some leadership positions, be filled by people from other industries. This would provide a more balanced and inclusive Board. Lastly, it should be noted that the Board is filled with very enthusiastic and high energy people, who are volunteering their time because they love Huntington Beach. Put us to work in helping solve the City's problems and everyone will benefit. Moore, Tania From: berreprincess@aol.com Sent: Monday,July 31, 2023 7:27 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) Subject: NO to EVERYTHING Strickland, Burns,Van Der Mark and McKeon are trying to do!!! Funny that 4 (Strickland, Burns, Van Der Mark and McKeon) of you ran on NO changes to the charter but here we are with you 4 wanting to make changes that sound like you want to control the residents. These changes are not to better our city in any way, shape or form. Same goes for dropping any committees. As well as councilmember Burns wanting to change anything with Declaration of Policy on Human Dignity, just shows that you and your 3 fellow councilmembers (Strickland, Van Der Mark and McKeon) do not really care about such things and have shown you can not even understand what human dignity means by things you 4 have said and decided to do already. Its, also, beyond obvious on why you 4 are trying to change the qualifications for city clerk. Sadly we know that you 4 (Strickland, Burns, Van Der Mark and McKeon) have made up your minds before this even is for vote and do not really care what the residents have to say. Shame on you 4! Anna Plewa i Moore, Tania From: cherivatkinson@aol.com Sent: Monday,July 31, 2023 10:06 PM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF);supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Fw: Item 27 Elimination of the HB Human Relations Committee and Item 29 Modification of the Declaration of Policy of Human Dignity Attention: HB City Council Please respond that you received this. Cheri Atkinson LCSW Attention: HB City Council For the following reasons, stated to Nextdoor, I am asking you to Vote No on Item 27 and 29. It appears that you have already made of your mind, and this may be an exercise in futility, but I believe that you are going down a dark path by with Item 27 and 29. Cheri Atkinson LCSW Email to Nextdoor At the HB City Council Meeting on 8/1 at 6m, in the HB City Council Chambers, there will be -Item 27, a vote to eliminate the HB Human Relations Committee of 25 years. This group works with the HB Police to monitor hate incidents and crimes, which are on the increase this year. The HB Human Relations Committee inspires and promotes mutual understanding, respect and the well being of all in our community through education and engagement. Item 29- The Declaration of Policy and Dignity is a declaration of the value of all in our community, and our commitment to stand up against acts of hate.This was written by past mayors Ralph Bauer and Shirley Dettloff. I believe that we will be going down a wrong path if Item 27 and 29 pass. You can submit you opinion against Item 27 and 29 by writing to supplementalcommun@surfcity- hn.org and city.council@surfcity-hb.org (By Monday) or you cant attend the HB City Council and speak, on 8/1 at 6. Thanks for taking your time to read this. I have great faith in our community. i Moore, Tania From: Celeste Rybicki <celeste@celesterybicki.com> Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 12:59 AM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF); supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: No on item 27 -save the city's humanity Members of the HB City Council, I am writing to voice my opposition to item 27 on this weeks agenda. I believe it will be detrimental to the public good of the city, not to mention insulting to its citizens,to get rid of so many citizen-led boards and committees. It is particularly disheartening to see the Human Relations Commission on the chopping block after a recent report shows hate crimes are increasing in our city. In my opinion,this current city council majority has gotten more and more polarizing, stoking the flames of division in our city and getting rid of a group whose purpose is to work and inform on safety, respect, and human dignity is a huge mistake. Each week we learn of more blatantly political and one-sided decisions being pushed on our city and I'm sick of it. HB has never seemed less welcoming and less respectful as when these meeting agendas come out.There are so many citizens speaking out against these items, in emails, public comments, and on social media and for a moment I feel hope and pride in our city again ... and then you vote against us time and time again.You vote against the city you were elected to represent. Please vote no on item 27 and try and reconsider your motives on all these agenda items. Thank you, Celeste Rybicki 15 yr resident 1 Moore, Tania From: Ann Palmer <714anniep@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 1:16 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Cc: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) Subject: (Mostly) Support Agenda Item#27 and Agenda Item#3 All: This is to communicate a level of support for Agenda Item#27; however, I do have some thoughts and questions related or tangential to the proposals. That is followed with an observation about Agenda Item#3. It is always good to evaluate impact and efficiencies in our local government and pursuant to unanimously passing a balanced Budget fir HB, it is critical. So streamlining and consolidating committees, boards and commissions that employ staff hours and city resources is a good step. Thoughts regarding specific actions; • Human Relations Committee -Functions of this committee should be primarily handled by the city's Human Relations Department. For special community interests or gatherings,members of this group can still firm an informal citizens action group, volunteer for city events and organize outside activities. The particular Bauer educational/writing competition would actually be more appropriate for Youth Citizen Leaders committee or the Library to coordinate. Or they can form a not-for-profit and do this good work independently. Their voices will still be heard through the normal communication channels for the city council snd staff. • Jet Noise Commission-This commission was formed long after it should have been created as a Jet Noise and Air Pollution commission. Yes, it has been ineffectual so serves no purpose. But did you know a big contributor to the revamping of air traffic routes here stemmed from a study fielded and funded by Newport Beach? We haven't noticed the change as drastically because after months of it air traffic basically died during the shutdown and still has not completely recovered. But it's the increased pollution that will affect us and future generations. Articles from National Geographic and Science mag tell that sad story. So CC member will be assigned and act as needed and/or Intergovernmental Relations Committee will handle when necessary? OK but IMO, our city representatives should be on the job to know BEFORE we get the results if others' plans. Do we have updates in the SNA and LAX expansions?Did we ever truly consider a glide path study that the Pilots' Association told us they would consider?Your community supports you but we need to be kept informed of those things that affect our city. • Mobile Home Advisory Board—There is no issue with this group for which the city has means to take action. Their voices can be heard as independent citizens or they can form independent associations •Urban Design Study responsibilities are proposed to be moved to the Downtown and Beachfront Ad Hoc Committee which may include OCH takeover. Did the Urban Design Study include only downtown? It would seem that nearly every HDD development acriss HB lacked any design and certainly strayed from the promise of setbacks, open space and anything remotely attractive. The community first heard about launching a PCH takeover during the previous administration and I believe it was summarily rejected. The vision apparently is to beautify PCH for incoming tourists (?)which would be nice but is it a priority for new budget allocation?And I guarantee that more tourists heading to our hotels and downtown areas are traversing our boulevard corridors. Have you driven down Beach, Goldenwest or Warner from the freeway? If we have beautification dollars to 1 spend, out then there. And if the Coastal Commission is amenable perhaps the hotels could fund some beautification efforts along PCH. In the meantime,that's an unwise maintenance expenditure for which we have no city budget. Regarding Agenda Item#3,the appointment of a CC member to serve as voting delegate (& another as alternate) for the League of California Cities, it is understood that this is SOP and good for our cities. For this exercise, for SCAG and for the efforts of the Intergovernmental Relations Committee I believe there are elevated awareness opportunities and Notes/Cautions/Warnings to proactively evaluate. Once again,thank you for the opportunity to comment on the items in this vey full agenda for 08.01.23. Respectfully, Ann Palmer 30+year resident Huntington Beach 92648 2 Moore, Tania From: Van Der Mark, Gracey Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 1:17 AM To: cherivatkinson@aol.com;CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF); supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Re: Item 27 Elimination of the HB Human Relations Committee and Item 29 Modification of the Declaration of Policy of Human Dignity Thank you for your opinion. We will have to agree to disagree. Have a good night. Gracey Van Der Mark Mayor Pro Tern- City of Huntington Beach From:cherivatkinson@aol.com <cherivatkinson@aol.com> Sent: Monday,July 31, 2023 10:05:47 PM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org <supplementalcomm @surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Fw: Item 27 Elimination of the HB Human Relations Committee and Item 29 Modification of the Declaration of Policy of Human Dignity Attention: HB City Council Please respond that you received this. Cheri Atkinson LCSW Attention: HB City Council For the following reasons, stated to Nextdoor, I am asking you to Vote No on Item 27 and 29. It appears that you have already made of your mind, and this may be an exercise in futility, but I believe that you are going down a dark path by with Item 27 and 29. Cheri Atkinson LCSW Email to Nextdoor At the HB City Council Meeting on 8/1 at 6m, in the HB City Council Chambers, there will be -Item 27, a vote to eliminate the HB Human Relations Committee of 25 years. This group works with the HB Police to monitor hate incidents and crimes, which are on the increase this year. The HB Human Relations Committee inspires and promotes mutual understanding, respect and the well being of all in our community through education and engagement. Item 29- The Declaration of Policy and Dignity is a declaration of the value of all in our community, and our commitment to stand up against acts of hate.This was written by past mayors Ralph Bauer and Shirley Dettloff. I believe that we will be going down a wrong path if Item 27 and 29 pass. You can submit you opinion against Item 27 and 29 by writing to supplementalcommun@surfcity- hn.org and city.council@surfcity-hb.org (By Monday) or you cant attend the HB City Council and speak, on 8/1 at 6. Thanks for taking your time to read this. I have great faith in our community. i Moore, Tania From: Dianne <diannespeaksup@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 5:41 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Oppose Agenda Item#27, Recommendations 2,4, 5, 7, and 8 #2 -As stated in the recommendation, "many of these issues are being addressed by the County of Orange", which does not mean that all of the issues are being addressed. As cited by Matt Szabo in The Daily Pilot,hate crimes/incidences in HB have seen a significant increase since last year. It makes no sense to dissolve a committee that focuses on that issue, when this city is experiencing more hate. Turning a blind eye to these events and shirking the responsibility to the county is simply bad governance. #4 -Mobile home residents make up a sizable portion of the HB population. They have concerns that are unique to their living situation. Denying their voice because you don't like what they advocate for, is short- sighted. Citing one person who chose to resign from the Board, is not valid evidence that the Board should be dissolved. #5 -As we have seen nationwide extreme weather patterns due to climate change, it is irresponsible to dissolve the Environmental and Sustainability Board. To maintain the high quality of life in HB, it is imperative that the city continually update the city's Sustainability Master Plan and its implementation. As a coastal city with a treasured nature preserve, serious consideration of the environment is required. #7 - There is a purpose to include local youth in City Council considerations and that is the purpose of the Youth Board. If you want to have a volunteer committee to plan events,there is no reason not to add one, but dissolving a Board that serves a worthwhile purpose is not necessary to accomplish the goal of a youth event planning committee. #8 - There is no purpose in changing the name of the Fourth of July Executive Board. Even if the scope of the events surrounding the Fourth of July have evolved and expanded,the name change doesn't affect that and is simply busy work. Sincerely, Dianne Smith 1 Moore, Tania From: Douglas Von Dollen <dougvondollen@icloud.com> Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 7:06 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Opposition To Items#27, 28, and 29 I strongly urge the City Council to give up on its three-pronged fight to make Huntington Beach a white Christian nationalist city, most recently displayed through items#27, 28,and 29 on Tuesday's meeting agenda and the Mayor's selection of a Christian Chaplin to provide the opening invocation for the 14th straight meeting. The three prongs being used are: 1. Blockage of any affordable housing that may benefit non-white families from joining the community. 2. Erasing of"tolerance"gestures such as flying of the Pride flag, breaking ties with the Interfaith Council,watering down a statement denouncing anti-LGBTQ+and anti-Semitic hate,tonight's item#27 which includes a recommendation to disband the city's Human Relations Committee,and tonight's item#29 amending the city's Declaration of Policy on Human Dignity. 3.Changes to boards and election rules such as the voter ID rules proposed in tonight's item#28,which have been shown to disenfranchise people of color in past situations. This is an extremely dangerous path for the largest majority White/Non-Hispanic city in California to take and it should be abandoned immediately. Sent from my iPad 1 Moore, Tania From: Kimberlee Jarrah <kimjarrah@me.com> Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 7:57 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Opposition to disbanding MH Advisory Committee To Whom It May Concern, I would like to speak at tonight's board meeting to help the city council understand that people live in mobile homes for a variety of reasons and that we all need and deserve a safe place for people with modest means to live. I am a credentialed teacher with a Masters degree who had to move my two teenage children to a mobile home after my husband went overseas on a business trip and never came home in 2016.The only way I could stay in the city we love and grew up in and keep things as stable as possible for my kids was to move to a mobile home. Many young families are also finding this is where they will need to start out as home owners since prices have become so exorbitant. Mobile home residents need a place to voice their concerns, especially with many parks now being taken over by large corporations and prices are being jacked up. The city has the responsibility to support and help all residents,just like public schools need to support their diverse student populations. Please continue, in the spirit of democracy to be that voice for ALL the people,and don't let stereotypes or biases influence who you believe deserves representation. I appreciate your time and promise to be polite in my presentation. Respectfully, Kim King Cell (714)392-6966 (I got married last month,so I'm no longer Jarrah) 1 Moore, Tania From: Jeanne Paris <jeannemarieparis@yahoo.com> Sent: Tuesday, August 1, 2023 8:16 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Support Agenda item#27 and #29 To the City Council, My name is Jeanne Paris. My husband and I have been long time residents of Huntington Beach. I am writing today in strong support of agenda item #27 —to streamline and restructure a number of BCC's as I think less is always better to truly focus on our needs and help bring them to the attention of council. I also strongly support agenda item #29 — amending the Declaration of Policy on Human Dignity. If we dissolve the HB Human Relations Committee — which is full of virtue signaling and double speak this topic is moot. The activities can go on without sanctification from the council. The job of CC is to run the city not to gaslight our local citizens. However — as I read this declaration, I am struck by the appearance of who gets to decide what `hate speech" is. Do we not already have a Declaration of Independence and a system of rule of law? If I express my concern as a citizen about certain groups that wanted to burn down my city 3 years ago — is that freedom of speech or hate speech? If a certain citizen of this community continually harasses a member of council by calling her a Nazi — is that of freedom of speech or hate speech? It states in this Declaration of Policy on Human Dignity — that "every member of our community has the right to be treated with dignity and it is our collective responsibility to ensure this is normalized behavior. Participate at your places of worship, community meetings, wherever you are; lend your voice to opposing hate". I don't see anybody opposing "hate" towards certain council members. Regardless, I think the US Constitution makes the declaration of dignity irrelevant. Thank you. Jeanne Paris Moore, Tania From: Steven C Shepherd Architect <steve@shepherdarchitects.com> Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 8:27 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) Subject: AGENDA ITEM #27 - OPPOSED TO DISSOLUTION OF HBHRC Dear City Council Members - I oppose the dissolution of the Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee. Hate crimes in our community are not a "county problem." They are a Huntington Beach problem and should be directly addressed by the residents and elected officials of our community. The HBHRC has a decades-long record of service to our Huntington Beach community and is as necessary today as it was when it was formed back in the 1990s. To suggest that the HBHRC is redundant and that staff resources would be better invested elsewhere while locally reported hate crimes are on the rise is a woefully out-of-touch and mindlessly inept recommendation. I've been a homeowner in Huntington Beach for more than three decades and kicked around the beaches and streets of HB for a decade and a half before that. Countering hate and finding common ground has been a long- time struggle here, and that struggle continues to this very day. Dissolving the HBHRC would be little more than a direct concession to those who seek to divide our community and foster intolerance and hatred. I'd like to believe our current city council is better than that,but based on your action over the past eight and half months,perhaps you're not. Steve Shepherd Huntington Beach 92646 i Moore, Tania From: J C <qhlady@me.com> Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 8:35 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: City Council Meeting 8-1-23 I support Agenda Item 27 Seems to me there are an excessive amount of"committees". Jean Cloyd Resident of Huntington Beach 1 Moore, Tania From: robcloyd@me.com Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 8:41 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Agenda Item 27 With council meeting 8-1-2023 I support Agenda Item 27 This makes sense to me Rob Cloyd Huntington Beach Resident 1 Moore, Tania From: Mark Sheldon <surfcitysheldon@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 8:51 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Cc: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) Subject: City Council August 1, 2023 Agenda Item 27 Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council: As a Huntington Beach Resident for over three decades, I am writing to address the City Council Agenda Item 27 for the August 1, 2023 meeting. I urge caution in the restructuring of Huntington Beach's Citizen Boards and Commissions which serve an ongoing purpose. My comments are directed in particular at the Environmental and Sustainability Board(ESB), though many of their considerations also apply to the other similarly structured Citizen Boards. I had the honor of serving on the ESB's predecessor,the Environmental Board, from August 2013 through June 2019. In this position I had the opportunity to work with a number of citizen members, city staff, and City Council Liaisons. Each person brought their own expertise and perspective to the group. While the focus and actions of the Board changed to reflect new situations and changes in City Council priorities,the Board and its members have always stood ready to give their personal time and insight to provide the City Council a wider and better informed view of the issues facing the City and those who live and visit here. This cross-disciplinary expertise lends itself to creative thinking and improvements, while also addressing the more tedious but critical work of providing informed feedback for CEQA and other environmental review documents. The latter includes the yet-incomplete Sustainability Master Plan, for which the recent reorganization of the Environmental and Sustainability Board is designed to review and advise/assist the City in its ultimate implementation. I recommend that the City Council enable the Environmental and Sustainability Board to continue in its defined mission, in service to the City Council and people of Huntington Beach. Thank You Mark Mark Sheldon Huntington Beach Resident i Moore, Tania From: Vivian Bui <vb5177@princeton.edu> Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 8:55 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Supplemental Communication for August 1st City Council Meeting Hello, My name is Vivian Bui and I am an undergraduate student at Princeton University studying Public Policy. I am also an alumnus of Huntington Beach High School and former Chair of the Huntington Beach Youth Board. I am currently working a summer internship at Princeton as an advocate for civic engagement among the student body. I am sending this communication for the City Council to consider about Item#27, specifically about the dissolution of the Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee. Having worked personally with the HBHRC, I have witnessed first hand what it is like to be a productive citizen. The HBHRC's relationship to the Youth Board and youth committee,the HBPD, and city in general is one that I have admired for years. No radical political agenda has ever been associated with the HBHRC. The only agenda in this committee's mind is that our city should be kept safe from hateful acts, which is something I hope is something each Councilmember can agree on. I urge the City Council to not dissolve a committee that has large part of our city's history behind it. To dissolve the HBHRC is to say that the hate crimes in the 1990s that prompted the creation of the HBHRC did not matter at all. While the OC Human Relations Commission does exist, HBHRC is unique because of its founding history. Our city is not like any other city in Orange County and we need our own human relations committee to address our unique issues regarding hate crimes and safety. HBHRC continues to dispel stereotypes that Huntington Beach is not safe for minorities, a public assumption that no other city in Orange County has had to face. The annual CommUNITY picnic, where members of the community and politicians of both political parties attend,has created a precedent that Huntington Beach is indeed safe. Without the HBHRC, I would not have found my own voice as an Asian-American woman. If the HBHRC is dissolved, the legacy of our City Council will be tainted and the opposite message that you want about our wonderful city will be publicized. Without the HBHRC,people all over the county and state will once again believe that Huntington Beach is unsafe for marginalized communities. The youth of Huntington Beach will not trust this City Council to respond effectively to hate crimes without the HBHRC. I urge the City Council to not dissolve the Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee. Thank you, Vivian Bui 1 Moore, Tania From: V.C. Rhone <rhonevc@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 8:56 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) Subject: Opposition to Agenda Item 27 Dear Esteemed City Council Members, It is with a heavy heart that I write this email. Let me first say that I had hoped to attend the meeting this evening but am unable to due to unavoidable work conflict. I am the chairperson of the Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee. However, I offer comments here as a concerned resident of Huntington Beach. While I am deeply disappointed and shocked by many of the agenda items, I am writing today in full opposition to Item 27. The HBHRC met with their council liaisons Mayor Pro Tern Van Der Mark and Councilmember Burns on April 14th to discuss their goals and concerns for Huntington Beach. At that time, they indicated that safety was their number one issue. During a follow up meeting on July 6th, the HBHRC presented a proposal to address safety in all the neighborhoods and communities in Huntington Beach. During this meeting, the council liaisons revealed the BCC that uses the most staff resources. The HBHRC was not mentioned. However, the BCC that was, is not on this list for dissolution or restructuring. During the July 6th meeting, Burns also said the HBHRC does much more than just track hate crimes and reports. During the HBHRC meeting on July 11th, the liaisons were present as HBPD detailed a significant number of hate crimes and hate incidents within the last 31 days. On July 12th the HBHRC was asked by HBPD to help create a program in hopes of educating youth and families on hate crime prevention. It should also be noted that Huntington Beach has already seen double the amount of hate crimes and incidents this year, than in the previous year alone. On July 27th, just three weeks after hearing the HBPD's report and proposing safety programs to their council liaisons, and while their staff liaison was on vacation, the HBHRC discovered, through a public posting, that their committee was being put up for dissolution due to redundancy of programs and to reduce staff utilization. The HBHRC has no contact or relationship with the Orange County Human Relations Commission and has only hosted two events in the last year with OCHR (which is a completely different organization that recently renamed themselves Groundswell). The HBHRC's programs which are custom-tailored for the specific needs of Huntington Beach have been featured in the Los Angeles Times. Notably their Cultural Cinema Showcase 1 has received nearly 3,000 films to date, with a portion of these films being shown throughout the year on HBTV. It is generally understood that budget cuts are difficult. Everyone can agree on that. What is not understood is how a committee that has existed for over 25 years and has successfully worked with every city council and police chief and that helps all HB residents from the Harbor to Oakview to South HB to downtown and everywhere in between, could be dissolved while they are actively doing the work they were created to do and in the middle of them doing it. In fact tonight, a few of our members are engaging with the community right now at the HBPD's National Night Out. The Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee is a "flagship committee" for many other cities who later formed their own "HRCs." Other cities often call for advice or to simply model what is being done here. How can this council allow that legacy to end on their watch? I was able to speak with Councilmember Burns by phone yesterday, on July 30th at length about my concerns. I hope that this agenda item will be pulled and welcome the opportunity to sit with our liaisons and hear from them on ways in which they feel we can reduce staff utilization. Eliminating the committee without this conversation feels like a major misstep. The committee should remain in existence and operate under the banner of local government as an official city committee. I urge you to reconsider this item and reverse course on the elimination of this committee that has worked successfully with many other departments for over 25 years. Thank you, V.C. Rhone HB Resident Huntington Beach Human Relations Chairperson 2 V.C. RHONE �vAGTON&8�_ Chairperson Z.6 \ff Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee , Founder,Community Summit m Director,The Cultural Cinema Showcase E: rhonevc@gmaiL.com co, W:www.huntingtonbeachca.gov/HRC "Creating Connections" 3 Moore, Tania From: Cooper Carrasco <askcpr@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, August 1, 2023 8:59 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL (INCL. CMO STAFF) Subject: Agenda Item 27 Hello Council After reviewing the powerpoint presentation on streamlining citizen-led boards and commissions, having attended HRC and MHAB meetings myself, having spoken to numerous mobile home park residents, having spoken to the officer in charge of reporting the hate crimes and incidents to the HRC, in light of a quantifiable spike in hate crimes and incidents in huntington beach, in light of unprecedented Mobile Home Park ownership changes, rent increases, and threats of displacements for HB citizens, it would be undeniably wrong to dissolve the HRC and MHAB. The HRC and MHAB are the most needed they have ever been since their inception. Dissolving these will diminish our ability to address two great threats to Huntington Beach residents: hate & predatory corporate landlords. If the HRC gets dissolved, at least have the HBPD post their HRC hate crime /incident reports as press releases. To obscure that now, while we're seeing a spike this year is effectively a cover-up. https://voiceofoc.org/2023/08/huntington-beach-looks-to-can-human-relations-commission-as-hate- rises/ https://www.latimes.com/socal/daily-pilot/news/story/2023-07-28/huntington-beach-could-axe-2-lonq- standing-boards-and-committees-change-city-charter Do not dissolve HRC and MHAB. Sincerely, Cooper C. i Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, August 1, 2023 8:40 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:August 1st City Council Meeting, Comment on Agenda Item#27 Attachments: Public Comment Agenda Item#27.docx From:Siegal,Joan <Joan.Siegal@aecom.com> Sent: Monday,July 31, 2023 7:27 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Cc:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:August 1st City Council Meeting, Comment on Agenda Item#27 Please see attached comments. Joan P.Siegal Cell: 714-886-7056 1 Date:July 31, 2023 Comment on: Huntington Beach City Council Meeting, August 1, 2023, Agenda Item #27, Recommendations to streamline and restructure a select number of citizen-led Boards, Commissions, and Committees and Council Committees: • Adoption of an Ordinance to remove/repeal HBMC Chapter 2.102 Environmental and Sustainability Board and amend HBMC Chapter 2.111 Citizen Infrastructure Advisory Board/Public Works Commission. Comment by: Joan Siegal, Member Environmental and Sustainability Board I am writing to request that the City Council reconsider elimination of the Environmental and Sustainability Board (Board). As I understand it,the purpose of this Board should be to advise the City Council on policies and proposed actions pertaining to: (1) stewardship of the natural environment of Huntington Beach, including beaches and open spaces (that is,the environment) and (2) conservation of natural resources (that is, sustainability) including water and fuel, and reduction in waste streams to go into landfills. Stewardship and conservation issues may be quite different from infrastructure issues, so combining the Boards would not eliminate overlap to a significant extent. Also, there is real benefit in having citizen involvement in the development and implementation of environmental policies. Often policies are handed down from Federal, State and Local government with insufficient thought on how the policies will affect the average citizen or if the ratio of pain imposed by the regulation offsets the environmental benefit. This results in citizens complaining about governmental overreach. Conversely, not paying attention to issues raised by citizens will cause complaints about government neglect. Currently the Board (including myself) is made up of practicing environmental engineering professionals, educators, and people retired from those professions. Having people with these backgrounds is helpful in understanding impacts of actions that could adversely affect the environment. We are also good at spotting regulations that do not have the infrastructure to support them. However, I would recommend openings in the Board, including some leadership positions, be filled by people from other industries. This would provide a more balanced and inclusive Board. Lastly, it should be noted that the Board is filled with very enthusiastic and high energy people, who are volunteering their time because they love Huntington Beach. Put us to work in helping solve the City's problems and everyone will benefit. Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 8:43 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Remove Agenda Items 27, 28, and 29 from Council Meeting Agenda From: Mikel Hogan<mhogan072@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday,August 1,2023 8:30 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Remove Agenda Items 27, 28,and 29 from Council Meeting Agenda Mayor Strickland,Mayor Pro Tern Van Der Mark, and City Council, I am writing to request removal of Items 27, 28, and 29 from the August 1, 2023 Council meeting agenda. These items are extremely harmful to the city of Huntington Beach in that they do not serve the needs of our community and are grossly undemocratic. In addition, The use of secret ad hoc committee meetings that formulate city policy must stop as it is also harmful to democratic decision making process that our city needs in order to combat the increase in hate crimes, and current and looming social and environmental issues. I urge you to rethink ways to address the serious issues facing our city based on transparency and public participation. Mikel Hogan, Ph.D., resident of Huntington Beach for fifty years. 1 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 8:43 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: City Council Meeting 8-1-23 Original Message From:J C<ghlady@me.com> Sent:Tuesday,August 1, 2023 8:38 AM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: City Council Meeting 8-1-23 I support Agenda Item 27 It appears there are way too many meatballs in the spaghetti sauce. Jean Cloyd Resident of Huntington Beach 1 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, August 1, 2023 8:43 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Attachment to my letter, 7.31.2023 withdraw items 27, 28, 29 From: patgoodman <patgoodman@yahoo.com> Sent:Tuesday,August 1, 2023 8:42 AM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Attachment to my letter, 7.31.2023 withdraw items 27, 28, 29 Please include this important testimony by V.C.Rhone to my 7.31.2023 letter to city council. https://voiceofoc.org/2023/07/rhone-the-case-for-human-dignity/ Thank you, Patricia Goodman Sent from my Galaxy 1 8/1/23,9:20 AM Rhone:The Case for Human Dignity VOICE ofOL COMMUNITY OPINION Rhone: The Case for Human Dignity BY V.C. RHONE 9 hours ago Q Why youcan trust Voice of OC https://voiceofoc.org/2023/07/rhone-the-case-for-human-dignity/ 1/9 8/1/23,9:20 AM Rhone:The Case for Human Dignity T h e Case For 4011160 die 1 4 Y lir 40111.01111. 41.1 ;# ar v i I III I I I a r iiik, https://voiceofoc.org/2023/07/rhone-the-case-for-human-dignity/ 2/9 8/1/23,9:20 AM Rhone:The Case for Human Dignity The one thing he hated more than anything else was prejudice. Having previously survived a heart attack, there wasn't much that he allowed to get him riled up anymore. But prejudice and racism were non-starters. So on September 15, 1994 when skinheads hurled racial slurs at him,Vernon Windell Flournoy, a 44 year old Black man, stood his ground outside a Huntington Beach McDonalds on Beach Blvd and Knoxville. He was shot and killed. Just 19 months later, on February 3, 1996, George Mondragon, a 20 year old Native American man was stabbed 27 times by two White supremacists near a Huntington Beach lifeguard tower after being asked if he believed in"white power." He survived. But this near fatal stabbing tipped the scales. Shortly thereafter, then mayor Shirley Dettloff and the late Dr. Ralph Bauer, along with former Huntington Beach Police Department Chief Ron Lowenburg, started the Human Relations Task Force (HRTF). '• (-' i _ oho , . - Ilei.Lf a.'.r..-..r.0'. el rri y �i .. t } '. ` i LJ lam`'•r - �' ,..s . . r. ' "`' - 10- LS 7 ,,,' '' *4. ' :' . -, VI) ,c, j ,,,,..:.• ..., • ,,, i,r j . .. .. .. ,, . . .„ ,tv,‘ J r1 ,„, , / 4 4,. it ►, J /1110 ., i 11.! ‘ I 7 .. r f A viiit 1 r8 .1 .ice Co-founders and former Mayors Shirley Dettloff and the late Dr. Ralph Bauer speaking at the CommUNITY Picnic in Central Park https://voiceofoc.org/2023/07/rhone-the-case-for-human-dignity/ 3/9 8/1/23,9:20 AM Rhone:The Case for Human Dignity This was a call to arms, a promise by residents and elected leaders who were determined to right the reputation of Huntington Beach. They were collectively saying, "Not our city. Never again!" Now, over 25 years later and known as the Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee (HBHRC), the mandate continues. But for how much longer? The HBHRC is in danger of being eliminated by the Huntington Beach City Council on Tuesday,August 1st. The mission of the Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee is to inspire and promote mutual understanding, respect, safety and the well-being of all in the community through education and engagement. For over 25 years the HBHRC has maintained a partnership with the Huntington Beach Police Department tracking and monitoring hate crimes and hate incidents in the community. https://voiceofoc.org/2023/07/rhone-the-case-for-human-dignity/ 4/9 8/1/23,9:20 AM Rhone:The Case for Human Dignity thirep::000-1 4.., . — _ ' _....:4. si . ,a, .:\ i • t. Ilt- , .. -_ • 4. 16 NJ -. irr --4......:,...--,,,. nAr ...,,,, =, N. • •. 'e^..._ \\♦ '�+"'., 4 r r} • - .. = ` - • sa 1 r Y ,..��., ..ice - .." "°[ .�... vf �`1 4;1- • https://voiceofoc.org/2023/07/rhone-the-case-for-human-dignity/ 5/9 8/1/23,9:20 AM Rhone:The Case for Human Dignity Mayor Barbara Delgleize presenting a commendation to HBHRC Chairperson V.C. Rhone on behalf of the committee But the committee does much more than that. Seeing a need to engage more with the community, within the last four years the HBHRC has created numerous programs to address the diverse and varied needs of Huntington Beach residents. From the string of home robberies in the Harbor to the variety of issues confronting Oakview residents, the HBHRC has made itself available to everyone. Reasons provided by the City Council to dissolve the program include redundancy and need to decrease staff resources. This is especially disappointing because the HBHRC council liaisons, Mayor Pro Tern Van Der Mark and Councilmember Pat Burns, seem to support this action. I can personally attest that HBHRC executive officers met with the council liaisons on more than one occasion to discuss plans and ways to support their community goals because I am the Chairperson of the Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee. In the past the HBHRC has successfully partnered with the Vans Corporation to host community dialogues during the 2022 US Open of Surfing.Additionally, when Visit HB staff began receiving calls from prospective businesses who were concerned about doing business in Huntington Beach, they contacted the HBHRC. Prospective businesses and corporate sponsors referenced "Huntington Beach's low MEI score" (the Human Rights Campaign measure of how welcoming and inclusive a city is), as the reason they were hesitant to do business here. Published in 2021, Huntington Beach's 2020 MEI score was 59 out of 100. The HBHRC, along with the previous City Council understood the negative impact a low MEI score can have on tourism. With the many recent changes in city policies over the last six months, I expect this number will drop significantly. I believe in getting to know people for myself. Over the course of many conversations with Van Der Mark and Burns, I came to understand the depth of their own convictions and beliefs. During initial meetings with them, they revealed that their top issue for the community was safety. I felt encouraged by this because this is the HBHRC's number one goal, as well. https://voiceofoc.org/2023/07/rhone-the-case-for-human-dignity/ 6/9 8/1/23,9:20 AM Rhone:The Case for Human Dignity Although we have some fundamental differences, with this common ground now being well established, I was optimistic. How then, do we find ourselves here? How then, after less than 90 days of conversation, do Van Der Mark and Burns, along with the Boards Commissions and Committee Review ad hoc arrive at the decision that Huntington Beach would be better off without a committee whose primary focus is on the safety and wellbeing of the community? The reasons provided do not mirror the actual work that the HBHRC does. Even Burns himself stated in a meeting on July 6th with HBHRC executive officers that the committee does "much more than just hate crimes and reports." Eliminating the HB Human Relations Committee would be a misstep and a missed opportunity to work to further unite the community.As many policies have been reversed and changed by the new City Council, divisions and schisms within the community have deepened. This has become evident with the recent uptick in hate crimes and hate incidents within the last few months. Currently, as of June 30, 2023, the number of hate crimes and incidents are double the amount they were in all of 2022 and we still have five more months left in the year. This is especially alarming. HBPD has asked the HBHRC to help create programs for youth to address this major concern in hopes of educating families on hate crime prevention. This should be a priority for us all as in the case of the murder of Vernon Flournoy and stabbing of George Mondragon, teens were involved in those horrific crimes. If we can help educate and inform families and teens citywide, we have a chance to see a shift in these numbers and stop it before it becomes a nightmarish trend. https://voiceofoc.org/2023/07/rhone-the-case-for-human-dignity/ 7/9 8/1/23,9:20 AM Rhone:The Case for Human Dignity r1 ''I *$'. _ 'v.. 'Al..-.*40: i 1 , . .:, .i. ,,;„.74.;Hr.:: .*.* , ::. . . z,... , . 4:0_ : :.' : ;?: ; .4J t • 11 # S t�r , k % � 1 r • i h�i: k 1i ' . a Meit _ .. y r. On Cilirr HBHRC Member Dr. Elaine Bauer Keeley, the late Dr. Ralph Bauer Co-founder,with HBHRC Chairperson V.C. Rhone at the 25th Anniversary Celebration of the Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee I hope the HBHRC will be allowed to continue its mission and continue to offer their many programs to the community such as the HB Listens Dialogue Circles, the Student Day of Dialogue, the Community Summit, the Ralph Bauer Youth Voices Essay and Art Contest and The Cultural Cinema Showcase (recently renamed the HB Cultural Film Festival) which features short films from underrepresented filmmakers. To date, the festival has received nearly 3,000 films during its run and also provides content to HBTV throughout the year. We must all learn to leave one another with our human dignity intact. No matter how you feel about a different race or the LGBTQ+ community, or even someone who belongs to a different political party than your own, I think we can all agree that everyone deserves to live in Huntington Beach free from fear and discrimination. It is imperative that local government prioritizes human dignity, safety, and the wellbeing of its residents. Allowing the HBHRC to continue operating as an official committee of the City is a step in the right direction. V.C. Rhone is a Huntington Beach Resident and Chairperson of the Huntington Beach Human Relations Committee (HBHRC). Her thoughts shared here are her own and do not represent the HBHRC as a whole. https://voiceofoc.org/2023/07/rhone-the-case-for-human-dignity/ 8/9 8/1/23,9:20 AM Rhone:The Case for Human Dignity Opinions expressed in community opinion pieces belong to the authors and not Voice of OC. Voice of OC is interested in hearing different perspectives and voices. If you want to weigh in on this issue or others please email opinions@voiceofoc.org. ©2023 Voice of OC. Proudly powered by Newspack by Autornattic https://voiceofoc.org/2023/07/rhone-the-case-for-human-dignity/ 9/9 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 8:44 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: City council meeting for 8-1-2023 Original Message From: robcloyd@me.com <robcloyd@me.com> Sent:Tuesday,August 1, 2023 8:43 AM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: City council meeting for 8-1-2023 I support Agenda Item 27 Wanted to make sure my voice is heard. Rob Cloyd Huntington Beach Resident 1 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 8:45 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Human Relations Commission Original Message From: H Meyers<hmeybsan@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday,August 1, 2023 8:44 AM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Human Relations Commission I am a longtime resident of Huntington Beach. I urge you not to disband the Human Relations Commission.The reasons given for doing so are specious. Disbanding the Commission sends the wrong message to the community when hate crimes have gone up dramatically in recent years. Hildy Meyers 1 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 8:57 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Tonight's meeting Original Message From: Linda Rose<Irlindarose3@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday,August 1, 2023 8:55 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Tonight's meeting Mayor Strickland and mayor pro tern Van der Mark, how can you illuminate the Human Relations Committee? It has been in HB for 25 years and much needed in these divided city. Please do not make it more difficult to vote by changing the election rules.Are you unhappy with the last local election results? Linda Rose Sent from my iPhone 1 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 9:18 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: agenda items 27, 28, and 29, Council Agenda From: Lou Ann Hobbs<Ihobbsflorence@yahoo.com> Sent:Tuesday,August 1, 2023 9:17 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:agenda items 27,28,and 29, Council Agenda Dear Mayor Strickland, Mayor Pro Tern Van Der Mark, and City Council, Please withdraw agenda items 27, 28, and 29. These are very serious issues and deserve other ways to address them. I appreciate your willingness and work to keep Huntington Beach the wonderful city that it is. Sincerely yours, Lou Ann Hobbs 21042 Greenboro Lane, Huntington Beach, CA 92646 i Moore, Tania From: Sheila Ellis <sheila.ellis78@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 9:48 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL (INCL. CMO STAFF);Van Der Mark, Gracey; Moser, Natalie; McKeon, Casey; Kalmick, Dan; Burns, Pat; Bolton, Rhonda; Strickland,Tony Subject: Human Relations Committee Really?Abolish this committee when hate is on the rise in our city? It serves the most marginalized citizens and uses minimal city resources. Surely you have some form of decency although I have yet to see it. Your focus seems to be on taking away. Your values are skewered and punish those who are less able to stand up for themselves. How about cutting back on the lawsuits so we can save those costs? Sheila Ellis (She/Her) 1 Moore, Tania From: BETHANY WEBB <bethwebb711@msn.com> Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 11:58 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Cc: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) Subject: The attempted destruction of HB by the Fascist Four. Strickland, Van Der Mark, Burns & McKeon As a 45 year resident,and home owner of Huntington Beach, I thought I had seen it all, clearly I was wrong. HB has had city council members of mostly conservative values. I have disagreed on some of their decisions, and agreed on others. It is with great distress that I find myself believing my beloved Huntington Beach is under attack by unqualified, hateful, far-right lunatics! Here are my concerns on tonight debacle of an agenda. 1. The proposed dissolution of Human Relations Committee,the Mobile Home Advisory and Environmental & Sustainability boards. I disagree with any dissolution of these vital voices to our community! 2. The suggested "City Charter Amendments" are clearly designed to stifle voting in HB! I am against these violations of voting rights. 3. Finally the proposal to amend our city's Declaration of Policy on human Dignity will only further the destruction of Huntington Beach's reputation and cost our city vital tourism. I am also against this blatant attempt to turn our city into the bigoted Florida on the west coast..UGH! Sincerely. Bethany Webb 1 Moore, Tania From: Buffie Channel <hbbuffie@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 12:23 PM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF); supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Aug 1, 2023 City Council Meeting -Agenda Items 27, 28 &29 To Huntington Beach City Council: I am writing today to express complete astonishment and disapproval of your agenda items 27, 28 and 29. Regarding Agenda Item 27: OPPOSE It is clear by looking at the maximum donations given this year to Gracey Van Der Mark by the exploitive owners of the Mobile Home Parks of Villa Huntington Beach, Ranco Huntington, and Skandia why she is leading the change to ELIMINATE the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Why is this Board threatening to these 4 new members of City Council?Is it because they are organizing and gaining influence?Are they pandering to their donors?It is important for Mobile Home residents to have a voice in this city. They pay taxes and these new owners are trying to push space rents so high that veterans and retirees are in jeopardy of becoming homeless. This is unacceptable. Why would the 4 new Council members want to eliminate the Human Relations Committee? This group works with the police department and local groups to help bring awareness and lessen the amount of hate crimes in our city. Why would you want to send a message that HATE is acceptable here? This seems like a wink wink to bigots and white supremacists that Huntington Beach government does not recognize hate crimes. This is wrong. This is sad. This seems like a recurring theme from these 4 new Council members. I mean, you 4 hobnob with known Proud Boys. With hate crimes UP,this seems a bit out of touch and ignorant and sends a bad message to residents and visitors alike. Regarding Agenda Item 28: OPPOSE I thought the new members of Council were vehemently opposed to changes to the City Charter?Now you want to change it? Seems odd. The most alarming item to me is the change to elections. The OC Registrar is known state-wide with a stellar reputation. I have personally participated in the voting oversight and counting process as an observer. I can tell you that they run a tight ship over there and they have a well oiled and strict machine. TO LOCALIZE THE ELECTION PROCESS IS A VERY DANGEROUS MANEUVER. We should NOT remove Huntington Beach from the oversight and continued participation in the COUNTY election process. How will localizing elections work?How much will it cost?Who will monitor this? It seems to me we are opening ourselves up to questionable election outcomes and just more litigation. Why are you saying on one side of your mouths that we need to eliminate staff positions and in the other side of your mouth propose an enormous undertaking and cost and staffing of localizing elections? Regarding Agenda Item 29: OPPOSE Once again,Mr. Burns shows his true colors. Why would anyone be opposed to the verbiage on our city's Declaration of Policy on Human Dignity? The message coming from our city's government should be one of inclusion, acceptance, safety, and dignity. This should not be a flippant change buried in an agenda. This should have debate and wide public input. It is important that any messages from our city about human rights and human dignity have very clear messaging that brings people together and projects the welcoming and inclusive stance of our populace, our law enforcement.and our government. i Do the right thing and maintain the boards and commissions, stop political agendized changes to the Charter, and keep the Human Dignity declaration as it is. Keep Huntington Beach as a welcoming, democratic, dignified city. Sincerely, Buffe Channel 34 year HB Resident and Business Owner 2 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 12:23 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Opposition to changes in voting and dissolution of boards From:Adrienne Low<adrienne6372@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday,August 1,2023 10:42 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Opposition to changes in voting and dissolution of boards Dear City Council, I am writing to voice my opposition to any plans the city council may have to remove our city from reliance on State Elections Codes and plans to dissolve several pertinent boards. It is horrifying to imagine the city taking over control of elections.The state has systems in place which monitor voter verification, polling locations and of ballot drop boxes. The county and State have handled all of our elections without any major issues. I have been impressed at the wonderful job the county has done in expanding access to all eligible voters. I am floored by how well my votes are tallied and the wonderful system in place to report to the voter that their vote has been counted. I do not trust that our local city council is equipped to handle this sacred responsibility. I am perplexed as to why the current city council is trying to create new issues where there have been none. Please leave our votes alone. Also, it is concerning that you are trying to eliminate the Mobile Home Advisory Board, Human Relations committee and the Environmental and Sustainability Board. All of these boards are dealing with real life issues that are affecting the citizens of Huntington Beach. It seems that the city council is afraid of the truth and are afraid of the residents of Huntington Beach who do not agree with many of the city council members world view. Please try to serve the residents of Huntington Beach and stop making our city a joke. Sincerely, Adrienne Low Sent from Mail for Windows 1 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 12:23 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:AGENDA ITEM 27 From: MJ Baretich<mjbaretich@hotmail.com> Sent:Tuesday,August 1, 2023 11:37 AM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:AGENDA ITEM 27 Dear Mayor Strickland, Mayor Pro Tern Van Der Mark, and City Council, My name is Mary Jo Baretich. I have been a resident of Huntington Beach foe over 40 years. I am currently a member of the Mobile Home Advisory Board, first serving an 8-year term from 2010 to 2018, and then appointed to serve again in 2020. I was shocked to read the Agenda Item 27 regarding the dissolution of the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Over the many years that I have been involved, our Board has been able to solve many issues between the park owners and mobilehome homeowners and avoid costly court actions. Besides being set up to engage the community in problem solving, the Board members and attending homeowners have been fortunate that this MHAB was set up also as an educational tool by recruiting presenters from the State, business, and non-profit community to speak on matters affecting mobile home park owners and residents. The choice and content of the information presented is especially relevant for park owners and residents of mobile home parks within Huntington Beach. I would like to clarify some inaccuracies attached to Item 27: It is incorrectly stated in the PowerPoint Attachment to Agenda Item 27: "Any conflict resolution issues between mobile home owners and park owners could be directed to the California Department of Housing and Community Development(HCD), which regulates mobilehome parks" "City Staff can connect residents to appropriate City and community resources': To clarify, neither HCD nor the City Staff have anything to do with many of the issues that we have. Yes, we can go to HCD to resolve Health and Safety issues and Mobilehome Residency Law Violations by park owners or management. But, for resolutions of misunderstandings between mobilehome homeowners and their managers and park owners, our MHAB in the past has been able to have some very positive dialogs to iron out these misunderstandings and have helped to bring all parties in those mobile home communities working together to make safer and more congenial communities. The short time that our Current Council Liaisons (and their Ad Hoc Committee) have been involved with our MHAB, does not give them the knowledge and understanding about the importance of i bringing opposing sides together to discuss and resolve issues. Other Cities with Mobile Home Boards throughout California will be shocked to hear about this Agenda Item to dissolve the MHAB. Affected citizens with the experience and knowledge to add value to the discussion, and formulation of any policy recommendations need to be included in this type of Ad Hoc Committees so that all sides are heard. This helps to avoid legal remedies and confusion. I suggest that the Ad Hoc Committee members meet with the MHAB members and listen to their viewpoints and suggestions. Until that time, please remove Item 27 from this Agenda. Thank you, Mary Jo Baretich Mobile Home Advisory Board member HOA President, Cabrillo Beachfront Village Vice President, Golden State Manufactured-home Owners League (GSMOL) 2 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 12:25 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Tonight's agenda Original Message From: MEG ROBINSON <twokyu@aol.com> Sent:Tuesday,August 1, 2023 11:42 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Tonight's agenda The theme for tonight's meeting should be"how to tear down a city in 12 months or less". You want to get rid of the Human Rights Committee because it duplicates the Orange County committee and cost a small amount. But you want to take elections away from the Orange County which will cost a lot more? Makes no sense but I guess it does because 4 of you are probably MAGA election deniers. I would like to call 4 of you hypocrites because during your campaigns you surrounded yourself with "No change to the city charter" signs and now want all these changes to the city charter. However, I think the more appropriate term would be liars. You are damaging this city for the foreseeable future. It breaks my heart. Margaret Robinson 1 Moore, Tania From: Isabella Ford <issyford@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 12:42 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) Subject: What happened to "No changes to our city charter"?? Dear Council Members Strickland, Van Der Mark, Burns and McKeon, You are the city council majority and you displayed multiple campaign signs stating "NO CHANGES TO OUR CHARTER". You also seemed to be of the camp that was upset about how Council Member Bolton was appointed...even though the process was using what was outlined in the city charter. So, now that you've won, you want to change the city charter to your benefit? Your manipulation of our city is incomprehensible. You are constantly quoted as saying "you are listening to the majority of the HB citizens", but you are ignoring the citizens that are engaging through the proper channels, like sending emails and attending the city council meetings. You are public servants. You've chosen to serve ALL of Huntington Beach, not just the few that pat your back and think you are royalty. From Matt Szabo's article in the Daily Pilot: https://www.latimes.com/socal/daily-pilot/news/story/2023-07- 28/huntington-beach-could-axe-2-long-standing-boards-and-committees-change-city- charter?fbclid=IWAR1 CcIobTtfmignbBQOxcdOCkVV4NYVLgaOXMi-E-AUY2EEdraONXKlb7FY "An ad hoc committee consisting of Mayor Tony Strickland, Mayor Pro Tern Gracey Van Der Mark and Councilman Pat Burns, which met three times, has come back with recommendations to dissolve the Mobile Home Advisory Board and the Human Relations Commission, along with the Jet Noise Commission and three existing ad hoc committees. A charter review ad hoc committee,formed in June at Burns'request, also has made eight recommendations for changes to the city charter, including removing advanced requirements for the city clerk position and also removing reliance on state elections code for all aspects of elections. " So, three councilmembers are deciding all things in HB with no regard to other opinions or thoughts? What is your ultimate goal? It's most definitely not to create any sense of community as you continue to ignore anyone that might think a little different than you. You never attended one Community Cafe session at our fabulous library and voted to cancel the program that had the sole goal of bringing residents together. I become physically ill with each article detailing your actions that focus on your personal agendas. I used to be so proud of our city and how it's grown in such a wonderful way. There is no other geographically equivalent city and you have managed to make it such a breeding ground for hate and anger. Disappointed and heartbroken, Isabella Ford 714-308-0660 1 Moore, Tania From: Donald Miller <henwedge@aim.com> Sent: Tuesday, August 1, 2023 1:14 PM To: CITY COUNCIL (INCL. CMO STAFF); supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save the Human Rights Committee and Kill Taking Over Local Elections! Dear Council, It is URGENT that in the face of rising hate crimes we keep the Human Rights Committee which keeps people of ALL colors and FAITHS safe from hate crimes. HB has an abysmal reputation for welcoming Nazi's, White Supremacists, and Anti-Semites to our city which hurts us both personally and financially. Further, there are no worlds to express my deep resentment and concern over the idea the city has any rights to take control of our elections. First, there is no voter fraud and second,this will open us to even MORE expensive litigation we are sure to lose. Thank you for your consideration on these urgent matters of preserving our liberty, freedom, democracy and rights and saving our precious tax dollars for the community! We must not embolden hate, violence or conspiracy theories any longer! Sincerely, Don Miller . .. v[c CENTER 2000 MAIN STREET .•-, Huntington Beach Looks to Can Human Relations Commission as Hate Rises voiceofoc.org 1 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Wednesday,August 2, 2023 9:43 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:To the Facist Four From:Adam Kelly<adamscottkelly@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday,August 1,2023 8:30 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:To the Facist Four With every new city proposal you continue show your hatred and fascist inclinations. First you ban the display of flags because displaying a pride flag upsets your religious nut bag beliefs. Then you send your Sarah Palin wannabe to ban books she considers obscene, aka, anything to do with with sexuality or alternative life styles. Seriously, Grieselda makes Palin look like a Mensa member. At this point you think you'd just come out and say that you hate homosexuala and transgender people.Now you're trying to dissolve the hate crimes committee so you can further your hate-filled agenda? On top of that your amendments to the charter threaten free elections in Huntington Beach, cut off public discussions so you don't have to hear criticism. You want to lessen city clerk requirements to what? Get some of your uneducated friends and family into the position? Which one of you read How to Be A Fascist: A Manual? You have to be the most despicable representatives Huntington Beach has had. 1 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Wednesday,August 2, 2023 9:43 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Children's Needs Task Force Board; gone. From: Rockin' Mama<mrsrowlson@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday,August 1,2023 9:33 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Cc:Gomez, Charlene<cgomez@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Children's Needs Task Force Board;gone. Hello and good evening, City Council. Since tonight's topic is of AdHoc subject. Can someone on council PLEASE tell me who disbanded the CNTF? (names specially). What happened? Why? Who influenced this? Why wasn't a meeting had with the members to discuss this matter? If I recall we were told online during Covid closures that it was happening. It's so sad that aiding children doesn't hold a concern in the city anymore. The current youth board is not the same. It doesn't donate 1,000's of books to needed children groups in town nor hold the annual character awards. Dr. Phyllis Lembke started the board and she may have requested to end it, I'm not sure. Please tell me. She was having health issues and her email is no longer. I wish her well. In a time where kids need more positive role models more than ever, disbanding it was a horrible idea. My heart aches for the kids who could have been noticed and now won't be celebrated. This group was for highlighting the kid that isn't the star athlete or the A+ student but the child that fell in between. One who lived from their heart and gave back to their community and the people in it. Having the Character Awards a city event held a common unity. Consisting of the kids from all local schools to participate and be noticed was something to gleam about! It was a great pleasure to serve on the board for 8 years. I was terming out and enjoyed every minute of delivering books by hand, reading hundreds of nominations, etc. Sad, sad, sad day to end it without much of blink of an eye, as if kids were brushed aside. Please, I want to know how, why, and who was responsible for disbanding the CNTF? Please ease my curiosity and someone get back to me with this information. i Moore, Tania From: John Nguyen <johnnguyen1028@yahoo.com> Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 5:18 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Doi quyen !di cho nhiing ngu'6i gia ca Mu'an dat cua Mobile Home Du'gc girl tit iPhone cua to' 1 Moore, Tania From: John Nguyen <johnnguyen1028@yahoo.com> Sent: Tuesday,August 1, 2023 5:35 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Dal hoi quyen Idi cua ngudi mu'dn da"t Vol chu da"t cua Mobile Home Du'gc girl tit iPhone cua toi 1 Moore, Tania From: Nancy Bramet <nevonwb@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, August 2, 2023 3:36 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Aug 1, 2023 council meeting Hello Council, Please advise for those of you that voted to dissolve item 2 as to what your logic is on this. $8810 per year, seems like a very low number to have a group of people that work and partner w/the police is very cheap. I will admit I didn't know this group was even in place and now I guess it won't be since you voted to dissolve it. If you don't think this is needed now more than ever you are wrong. I have lived here 61 years and I can tell you without hesitation that I don't feel as safe in this city as I did before Covid. I would like an explanation as to why you 4 voted it down. Regarding the mobile home item... sorry I don't remember the number on that one. I think 27. Anyway.... yes, they could do this with a private sector. But was it even considered that many of these people are elderly in mobile homes. Doing what you are asking for them could and will be far more challenging for them than having a group they can go to that is connected to the government. They know then that their voice will at very least be hear... or hopefully heard. I don't live in a mobile home so I have no skin in this item but I do and have know many seniors that do and there may not be many of them in numbers but that does not make them any less important. Environmental board... every disappointed with your vote on this. This is the second city council meeting I have attended. I guess being retired allows me more time to do this. So far not impressed with what you are doing. In fairness I wasn't happy with what Delegalize group did as well but then I was working 16 hour days 5-6 days a week so getting involved wasn't a priority for me. I do believe that is the case for most residents of the city. To live in this city, you have to be working,plus family etc is alot. They do vote for you and hope that you will do the right thing and then you don't do what you ran on. I am not implying I voted for you 4 because I didn't. But not for the reasons you may thing. I didn't vote for 4 of you because your mailouts to the public when you were running, you flat out lied, if that is to harsh,then you were very misleading. Since I am now retired I was able to further research your flyers from the mail and was able to learn this. I am sure many citizens of HB didnot. Now don't come back to me and say that the public then needs to get more involved. Many have been and Monday night you got rid of that. Yes,they can do this on a private sector. But you and I both know that they will not be listened to as much if they are private vs tied to the city government in some way. I know I have only been to 2 meetings and that isn't alot so I will continue to attend and see what you do. But it does appear that many of you have your minds made up at the beginning and anything you hear doesn't seem to change anything. Please explain to me why you have a meeting, listen to the citizens and then vote on it. Yes, in theory this sounds great but if your minds are already made up then why are you wasting citizens time pretending you will hear them out? You do know you are working for the citizens of HB,no one else,just the citizens. You appear to listen but when the public makes the effort to come and tell you directly this isn't what they want,why are you not at minimum considering this. I may be retired but please don't waste my time. If you are going to listen to the citizens talk then that means your mind is still open to ideas and thoughts. So far haven't really seen that from 4 of you. And I sent emails before the 1st meeting I went to.. the banning of book. i Yes, I know you weren't"banning"them. Ha. At least you postponed that.. but have to say the impression that evening that was in hopes that people will forget about it and you will then move forward. Now this is for Kalmick, Moser and Bolton In Gates presentation regarding the lawsuit on the firing of 2 employee; was his presentation true? Was there "secret meetings"?Nothing would surprise me regarding Delegalize but I want to know from you if you agree with Gates recount of events that he presented on Monday night?I have hear much about this and would like to actually know the truth regarding Gates. Not sure I trust him, he is a lawyer and my experience is they are all about the $$$ and many of his comments have not made me think differently of him. In closing... it would really be nice if you would please leave alone what isn't broke and start working on the things that are broke. I know it is alot harder to work on low income housing and homelessness. But that is what our city needs. And just as an agreement to one of the gentleman that discussed the pier and e-bikes... have to say in complete agreement with him. Tickets need to be issued. I walk the boardwalk weekly w/dog and those e-bikes come blasting down at 15-20 miles a hour easy. I don't think they should even be allowed on the boardwalk or pier(which I actually thought bikes weren't allowed on the pier).Now I am not saying bikes not allowed on boardwalk just e-bikes. Thank you for your time and look forward to hearing your replies, Regards, Nancy Bramet 2 From: Estanislau.Robin To: Switzer.Donna;Moore.Tanis Cc: Yoon-Tavlor,Grace Subject: FW: Mobile Home Advisory Board Disbandment Date: Tuesday,August 15,2023 5:44:09 PM Attachments: jmaae001.onq Suoolemental Comm MHRC Letters to Council Liaisons 7-24-2028 MHAB Meeting.odf image002.png Hey ladies, Can you check the Council's August 1 meeting record on BCCs to see if we indeed have what has been shared by Grace? If not, please incorporate. Thanks, Robin Estanislau, CMC, City Clerk City of Huntington Beach 714-536-5405 • Please consider the HB City Clerk's office for your passport needs! From:Yoon-Taylor, Grace <grace.yoon-taylor@surfcity-hb.org> Sent:Tuesday, August 15, 2023 3:32 PM To: Estanislau, Robin<Robin.Estanislau@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: FW: Mobile Home Advisory Board Disbandment Robin, This came in after 9am on 8/1 but I know MHRC rep also spoke during Public Comment and handed over more letters at that time. Do you need to file this as administrative record?Just wanted to make sure we're following the protocol. Please advise. We received the same at the MHAB meeting so I'll upload it in the MHAB Minute. Grace Yoon-Taylor Office of the City Manager (714) 536-5910 From: Hopkins,Travis<thopkinsPsurfcity-hb.org> Sent:Tuesday,August 1, 2023 7:33 PM To:Yoon-Taylor, Grace<grace.yoon-taylorPsurfcity-hb.org>;Jun, Catherine <catherine.junPsurfcity- hb.org> Subject: RE: Mobile Home Advisory Board Disbandment Thank you From:Yoon-Taylor, Grace<grace.yoon-taylorPsurfcity-hb.org> Sent:Tuesday,August 1, 2023 9:14 AM To: Hopkins,Travis<thookinsPsurfcity-hb.org>;Jun, Catherine<catherine.junPsurfcity-hb.org> Subject: Fwd: Mobile Home Advisory Board Disbandment In case you haven't seen this... this came into my inbox regarding tonight's agenda. From: MHRC<sosmhrcc mail.com> Sent:Tuesday, August 1, 2023 6:02 PM To: hbts.ho.repPgmail.com <hbts.ho.repPgrnail.com> Subject: Mobile Home Advisory Board Disbandment hAIMPIC MOBILE HOME PESIDENT COALITION www.hbmhrc.org Dear City of Huntington Beach Representative: The Huntington Beach City Council recently appointed three City Council members to review the list of Boards and Commissions and recommend which groups should be eliminated and the Mobile Home Advisory Board (MHAB) will be one of these groups disbanded. As a result of our recent Mobile Home Resident Coalition (MHRC) newsletter and social media posts regarding the MHAB's potential elimination, we received (in only a few days) over 160 letters demanding that the MHAB not be disbanded. Since there are over 3000 MHC residents in this city, it is conceivable that many more are in agreement with our demand. The MHAB has been the agency MHC residents approach to voice their concerns about unscrupulous park owners, unfair city ordinances, and their needs for more assistance. MHAB publicized the need for • An extended lease for the city-owned MHC park • Low-income families to receive rental assistance, and • Assistance for residents to bring their homes up to code. There are at least 3 reasons you may have considered as justification for your plans: • Cost/Finances?No,the MHAB has no budget, and does not cost the City a penny. • Salaries?No, all members of the MHAB are volunteers • Too many meetings?No, they only meet 4 times a year The MHAB is the only place where MHC residents and park owners can voice their concerns and be on the public record. MHC homeowners have attended this quarterly meeting for several years and find them informative and useful. We've been encouraged to note that attendance at meetings over the past several years has significantly increased. Instead of quoting board deadlocks as a reason for the disbanding, perhaps you could consider the source and help us find resolutions. When the board reaches a consensus, City Council disregards those recommendations as well. Is it any wonder that we feel that you don't want to hear us? Teri Williams & Sharon Crabill MHRC Co-Presidents 714-349-3068 About the Mobile Home Resident Coalition The MHRC(Mobile Home Resident Coalition)is a coalition of manufactured homeowners who have organized to secure a rent stabilization ordinance(RSO)or rent cap that would cap annual rent increases, protect manufactured homeowners from predatory space rent-spiking and keep our homes affordable. In less than two years we have grown to over 1400+strong,with representation from nearly all of the 17-(both senior and all-age)-non-resident- owned manufactured home(MH)communities in Huntington Beach. Recently we expanded our outreach to connect with manufactured homeowners in Costa Mesa, Santa Ana, Bell Gardens, Fountain Valley, Carson,Torrance,the South Bay, Long Beach&Sacramento,who share our concerns and goals.Together we have united to lobby state legislators to support our struggle by proposing and passing a rent increase cap in the near future. Even if a community isn't owned by a corporation,there's a chance that could change in a very short period of time. Ask some of our coalition members who were never informed that their communities had been sold and in some cases are now facing rent increases of over 17 percent!As we continue to petition our representatives to support our cause,we're focused on expanding our coalition. Protect Affordable Housing-Prevent Homelessness-Preserve Health Teri Williams& Sharon Crabill Mobile Home Resident Coalition Co-Presidents 714-349-3068 https://www.hbmhrc.org VggrOb.,:e. MOBILE HOME RESIDENT COALITION www.hbmhr .orra Gracey Van:Der Mark and Casey McKeon, Representatives Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 Dear Ms. Van Der Mark and Mr. McKeon, The Huntington Beach City Council recently appointed three City Council members to review the list of Boards and Commissions and recommend which groups should be eliminated. We were informed by a reliable source that MHAB will be one of these groups disbanded, As a result of our recent MHRC newsletter and social media posts regarding the MHAB's potential elimination, we received(in only a couple of days)over 100 letters demanding that the MHAB not be disbanded. Since there are over 3000 MHC residents in this city, it is conceivable that many more are in agreement with our demand. The MHAB has been the agency MHC residents approach to voice their concerns about unscrupulous park owners, unfair city ordinances, and their needs for more assistance. MHAB publicized the need for • An extended lease for the city-owned MHC park • Low-income families to receive rental assistance, and • Assistance for residents to bring their homes up to code. The MHAB is the only place where MHC residents and park owners can voice their concerns and be on the public record. MHC homeowners have attended this quarterly meeting for several years and find them informative and useful. We've been encouraged to note that attendance at meetings over the past several years has significantly increased. We implore you, as representatives of the City Council sitting on the MHAB, to support the continuance of the MHAB in Huntington Beach. Sharon Crabill &Teri Williams Co-Presidents About the Mobile Home Resident Coalition The MHRC(Mobile Home Resident Coalition)is a coalition of manufactured homeowners who have organized to secure a rent stabilization ordinance(RSO)or rent cap that would cap annual rent increases, protect manufactured homeowners from predatory space rent-spiking and keep our homes affordable. In less than two years we have grown to over 1400+strong,with representation from nearly all of the 17-(both senior and all-age)-non-resident-owned manufactured home(MH)communities in Huntington Beach. Recently we expanded our outreach to connect with manufactured homeowners in Costa Mesa,Santa Ana,Bell Gardens, Fountain Valley, Carson,Torrance,the South Bay,Long Beach&Sacramento,who share our concerns and goals.Together we have united to lobby state legislators to support our struggle by proposing and passing a rent increase cap in the near future. Even if a community isn't owned by a corporation,there's a chance that could change in a very short period of time.Ask some of our coalition members who were never Informed that their communities had been sold and in some cases are now facing rent increases of over 17 percent] As we continue to petition our representatives to support our cause,we're focused on expanding our coalition. Protect Affordable Housing-Prevent Homelessness-Preserve Health Tuesday,July 18,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Paul Engstrom We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Paul Engstrom Signature A (4) Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free Jotforrtm Monday,July 17,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Ray Scrafield We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks o To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Barbara Scrafield Address 16444 Bolda Chica St.,108 • Huntington Beach,Ca,92649 Signature 1.2 .' • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ®4 Jot oI rn Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Rhonda Kline We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and O To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Rhonda Kline Address 80 Huntington Street,#208 Huntington Beach,California,92648 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jolform PDF Editor-it's free ©4 Jotform Wednesday,July 19,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Ada Hand We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Ada Hand Address 19251 Brookhurst St,#31 Huntington Beach,CA,92646 Signature OJT_ • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-it's free 64 J•,Hi,rr t Tuesday,July 18,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Andrea Hiser We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks 9 To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and P To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Andrea Hiser Address 21851 Newland Street,114 Huntington Beach,Ca,92646 Signature 441 0 + (Kir:4,---) • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ®4 J;ftf' rat • Tuesday,July 18,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Anita Thornton We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from Its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ▪ To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Anita Thornton Address 16444 Boise Chica St.,spc 150 Huntington Beach,CA,92649 Signature n' � Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free f4 Jot'fornl • Tuesday,July 18,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Barbara King We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Barbara King Address 19251 Brookhurst St Spc 19 Huntington Beach,CA,92646 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotforrn PDF Editor-It's free ®4 Jottform Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Betsy Crimi We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks 6 To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Betsy Crimi Address 19361 Brookhurst St HB,Calif,92646 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free d J®tforiVi Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Betty Cerillo We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Betty Cerillo Address 19251 Brookhurst St.,45 Huntington Beach,CA,92646 Signature ,n 00.f'tth Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free �4 Jotform Wednesday,July 19,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Brandy Young We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and 6 To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Brandy Young Address 20062 Midland Lane Huntington Beach,CA,92646 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free f J,•tt(•1131 Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Brenda Haig We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+ registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Brenda Haig Address 6268 Beachcomber Drive Long Beach,CA,90803 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-it's free 16 ;rrm Tuesday,July 18,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Brian and Melissa Papke We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington.Beach. Name Brian and Melissa Papke Address 16222 Monterey Lane,Space 304 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA,92649 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free fep JOth,h;G' 1 Monday,July 17,2023 • Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Burnel Patterson We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and O To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Burnel Patterson Address 16444 Bolsa Chica St spc 70 Huntington Beach,CA,92649 Signature ter ). „6„yi %mkt) Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ®4 Jof or'm Monday,July 17,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Carol Ann Newton We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks o To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Carol Ann Newton Address 16222 monterey lane,space 174 huntington beach,ca,92649 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ,43 Jotf, rm Tuesday,July 18,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Carol Raymond We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board, Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks m To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Carol Raymond Address 16222 Monterey Ln,Spc 351 Huntington Beach,CA,92649 Signature lam^- Q q_psz Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ®4 Jotforrn Friday,July 21,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Carol Raymond We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks O To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Carol Raymond Address 16222 Monterey Ln,Spc 351 Huntington Beach,CA,92649 Signature de z-rd Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-i1 s free ®®m Jotform Monday,July 17,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Carol Rohr We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Carol Rohr Address 16444 Bolsa Chica St Spc87 Huntington Beach,CA,92649 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free J©tft t•m Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Caryn Breeze We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and 6 To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Caryn Breeze Address 80 Huntington street,#358 Huntington Beach,CA,92648 Signature • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ®e9 Jot'forrn Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Cat Metheny We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. • Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Cat Metheny Signature • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotforrn PDF Editor-It's free ®4 J tforilii Monday,July 17,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Charlene Vejr I. We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks O To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council; and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Charlene Vejr Address 6241 Warner Ave,Spc 180 Huntington Beach,CA,92647-8020 Signature a./L, VolA Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ®4 J€tform Sunday,July 23,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Chris Selle We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ▪ To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Chris Selle Address 121 Pecan Ln Fountain Valley,CA,92708 Signature // / ,S (ti)L Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free A Jot' rm Wednesday,July 19,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Christopher9499222422 Moore We the undersigned are opposed to,any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Christopher Moore Address 20701 Beach Blvd,Spc 256 Huntington Beach,CA,92648 Signature Coa Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free f4 Jotform Friday,July 21,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Cynthia Kelber We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks O To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+ registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Cynthia Kelber Address 21752 PCH. #10 Huntington Beach,Ca.,92646 Signature (__• 1"4ts.— Createe your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free 04 Jotform Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Cynthia Loxsom We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks O To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Cynthia Loxsom Address . 19251 Brookhurst Street,Space 125 Huntington Beach,Ca,92646 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with.lotform PDF Editor-It's free fB J U.•Ertll Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Danielle Parks We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ✓ To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and e To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Danielle Parks Address 80 Huntington street,600 Huntington Beach,Ca,92648 Signature • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free 6o Jotform Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Debbi Crothers We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Debbi Crothers Address 6301 Warner Ave,#27 Huntington Beach,CA,92647 Signature Cx • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-it's free fe, JOtfor t Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Diana Simon We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Nome Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and o To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Diana Simon Address 23141 Pretty Doe Dr Canyon Lake,CA,92587 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotforrn PDF Editor-it's free ®4 Jotfor'na Monday,July 17,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board - Name Donald Hart We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Donald Hart Address 16171 Springdale#240,#240 Huntington Beach,CA,92649 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's fine 614 Jotform i Wednesday,July 19,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Donna Andrade We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. . Name Donna Andrade Address 21851 Newland St,Spc 153 Huntington Beach,Ca,92646 Signature 1. Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ,4 J•flown • Wednesday,July 19,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Donna Andrade We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks © To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Donna Andrade Address 21851 Newland St,Spc 153 HB,Ca,92646 • Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-it's free A J•tforrn Tuesday,July 18,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Douglas Lightle We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from Its tasks D To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and O To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Douglas Lightle Address 19251 Brookhurst St. Space 30 Huntington Beach,California,92646 Signature D 0,41/4441.. Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free 4 Jotform Saturday,July 22,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Douglas TAYLOR We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Douglas TAYLOR Address 16444 BOLSA CHICA ST SP 103,SP 103 Huntington Beach,CA,92649 Signature '~ Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free f4 J 'tforrn Monday,July 17,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Ed Howes We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board, Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks O To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and e To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach, Name Ed Howes Address 20701 Beach Blvd#76 Huntington Beach,CA,92648 Signature • Create your own automated PDPs with Jotform PDF Editor-it's free Jot far m 1 Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Grace Ortega We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks © To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks In the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks In Huntington Beach. Name Grace Ortega Address 16444 Bolsa Chica#37 Huntington Beach,CA,92649 Signature IAA ' is Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ©4 Jotform Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Heather Banker We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and O To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation? The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Heather Banker Address 21851 Newland St,#315 Huntington Beach,CA,92646-7641 Signature • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free a4 Jotform Friday,July 21,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name HEATHER EDGINGTON We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home. community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name HEATHER EDGINGTON Address 20701 BEACH BLVD SPC 2 HUNTINGTN BCH,CALIFORNIA,92648 Signature • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ®4 J otf*rat Tuesday,July 18,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Iris Mansilla We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Iris Mansilla Address. 19361 Brookhurst St Spc 59 Huntington Beach,California,92646 Signature \ ry rig Create your own automated POFs with Jotform PDF Editor-it's free ®4 Jotform Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Jana Jensen We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board, Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks O To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and 6 To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Jana Jensen Address 20701 Beach Blvd,Space 168 Huntington Beach,CA,92648 Signature A^ / • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-its free ©4 J ttf©rm Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Janie Avery-Rivas We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Janie Avery-Rivas Address 6211 E. Golden Sands Long Beach,California,90803 Signature • • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free Jotform Monday,July 17,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Jeanne Farrens . We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ©' To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and 0 To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Jeanne Farrens Address 16444 Bolsa Chica St.,Spc 86 Huntington Beach,CA,92649 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-it's free ,90) Jot or `I Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Jeanne Smolinski We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Jeanne Smolinski Signature j,(0.1,(,)\rvo • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free .� Jotforrn Tuesday,July 18,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Jill Green We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks O To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and O To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Jill Green Address 18601 NEWLAND ST SPC 30 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA,92646-1872 Signature A Vim" Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free 4 J'LtfOrrn Friday,July 21,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Jo Ann Hall We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and O To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation( The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Jo Ann Hall Address 18601 Newland St.,Spc. 113 Huntington Beach,California,92646 Signature )-4 6Lrv\, Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-Ws free 114 J•$form Friday,July 21,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Jorge Arellano We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks o To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and o To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Jorge Arellano Address 102 Crow In Fountain Valley,CA,92708 Signature • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-it's free �B Jotf rm Friday,July 21,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Joseph Tartaglini We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Joseph Tartaglini Address 16222 Monterey Ln Spc 82 Huntington Beach,CA,92649 Signature • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free J•tfor'rrn • Wednesday,July 19,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Karen Peterson We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Karen Peterson Address 80 Huntington Huntington Beach,CA,92648 Signature • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free f4 Jotfarm Wednesday,July 19,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Karen Schoenfeld We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks 9 To ensure the quality of life In mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Karen Schoenfeld Address 6301 Warner Ave Huntington Beach,CA,92647 Signature( C Create your own automated PIFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free t ab'?tf rrn Tuesday,July 18,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Kathy Ayres We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from Its tasks G To ensure the quality of life In mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and U To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Kathryn Ayres Address 21851 Newland St SPC 84 Huntington Beach,California,92646 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-it's free JOtt rm Monday,July 17,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Ken Klopp We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Ken Klopp Address 16444 Boise Chica St.,Spc 54 Huntington Beach,CA.,92649 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ®4 Jot'f>`orm Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Kenneth Palmer We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County, We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks e To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Kenneth Palmer Address • 17261 gothard,22 HUNTINGTON BEACH,CA,92647 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free Jotft9,rr Wednesday,July 19,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington_ Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Keri Carter We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board, • Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks a To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Keri Carter Address 9850 Garfield Ave,#82 Huntington Beach,Ca,92646 Signature • 9kg/i/7)/ Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free . ®� Jotforrn Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Kevin Kline We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks G To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and 6 To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Kevin Kline Address 80 Huntington Street,#208 Huntington Beach,California,92648 Signature \<)-/NA r\P- A Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free Jotform Wednesday,July 19,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Kim DeSante We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Kim DeSante Address 80 Huntington Street SPC 607 Huntington Beach,CA,92648 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ®t J 4 tform Wednesday,July 19,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Kristi Hampshire We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from Its tasks o To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and o To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in • Huntington Beach. Name Kristi Hampshire Address 18601 Newland Street Space 48 Huntington Beach,CA,92646 Signature rAj 4f4,- Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free Jotf rm Wednesday,July 19,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Laura Costelloe We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council; and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Laura Costelloe Address 20701 beach Blvd 163 Huntington Beach,CA,92648 Signature 1 / Create your own automated PDFs with Jotforrn PDF Editor-It's free ®4 Jotform Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Leeanne Laughlin We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks o To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and o To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. • We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Leeanne Laughlin Address 20701 Beach Blvd spc 38 Huntington Beach,CA,92648 Signature olax,0110.2_ Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform POF Editor-it's free ®et, Jotform Friday,July 21,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Lenny Catalano We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks O To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and O To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Lenny Catalano Address 20701 Beach Blvd,73 Huntington Beach,Ca,92648 Signature l c) C' Create your own automated PDFs with Jot(orm POF Editor-It's free ®B Jotfarm Wednesday,July 19,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name LOIS CHURCHILL We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life In mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name LOIS CHURCHILL Address 6241 Warner Ave,Spc 153 Huntington Beach,CA,92647 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ©4 Jotfonyi Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Lois Kelly We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing In Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and a To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Lois Kelly Address 16444 Bolsa Chica St,#143 Huntington Beach,CA,92649 Signature S yeA. Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-it's free Jstf orm 1 Monday,July 17,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Lorelei Lachman We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council; and o To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Lorelei Lachman • Address 17181 Twain Lane Huntington Beach,CA,92649 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free Jotform Wednesday,July 19,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Lorrie Runnals We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from Its tasks O To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Lorrie Runnals Address 19251 Brookhurst St.,Spc 11 Huntington Beach,CA,92646 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-it's free Jotform Sunday,July 23,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Horne Advisory Board • Name Luann Luann We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and O To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Johnson Luann Address 15215 Alondra Blvd La Mirada,CA,90638 Signature • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform POF Editor-It's free 694 Jotform Wednesday,July 19,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Maureen Dougherty We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board, Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks o To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and G To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Maureen Dougherty Address 6241 Warner Avenue,Space 41133 Huntington Beach,CA,92647 Signature • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free Jotform Tuesday,July 18,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Megan Farrens We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Megan Farrens Address 201 W Collins Ave Spc 108 Orange,CA,92867 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free f J tf•rrin Wednesday,July 19,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Melanie Redd We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and a To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Melanie Redd Address 21851 Newland Street,152 Huntington Beach,CA,92646 Signatureirk g altk()L, • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ,4 Jotf orm Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name M Holtman We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name M Hollman Address 16444 Boise Chica St 114 Huntington Beach,CA,92649 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free 14 Jotform Tuesday,July 18,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Michael Freitag We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Michael Freitag Address 21851 Newland St,Space 499 Huntington Beach,CA,92646 Signature i7)w • • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free Jotb rm Monday,July 17,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Michael McMahon We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks o To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Michael McMahon Address 19252 Brookhurst,#124 Huntington Beach,CA,92646 Signature � -gyp 1 Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-it's free JOth,9 Tfl Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Michael Zuganelis We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks o To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and 9 To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Michael Zuganelis Address 20701 Beach Blvd,Spc 264 Huntington Beach,California,92648 Signature • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ®4 J�r-tform Friday,July 21,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Mike Hiser We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and O To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Mike Hiser Address 21851 Newland Street,114 H B,Ca,92646 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free g Jai'ti innit Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Nancy Strand We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile-home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Nancy Strand Address 19251 Brookhurst St.,Space 88 HB,CA,92646-2959 Signature A , ilklaAtig � v 1 ` Create your own automated PDFs with Joiform PDF Editor-It's free Li; J 4 tform • Monday,July 17,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Natalie Pocino Mackie We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council op matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Natalie Pocino Mackie Address 19251 Brookhurst Street,Sp 16 Huntington Beach,CA,92647 Signature G�/v Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free Jotform Monday,July 17,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Patricia Goodman We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and © To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Patricia Goodman Address 92648 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-it's free ®4 Jotform Saturday,July 22,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Patty DeBaun We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks 0 To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and 0 To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Patty DeBaun Address 21752 P.C.H.4 Huntington Beach,Ca,92646 Signature • Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-Ws free ®4 JOf OYfl1 Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Stuart Blake We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing In Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life In mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and P To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Stuart Blake Address 6241 Warner Ave,SPC 191 Huntington Beach,CA,92647 Signature ...41Iesko Create your own automated PDFs with,Jotform PDF Editor-It's free J;"Moriin Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Sue Bleiweiss We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks 0 To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and 6 To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters In mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Sue Bleiweiss Address 19251 brookhurst t90 Huntington Beach,CA,92646 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free Jotform Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Summer Jeter We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act In an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Summer Jeter Address 21752 Pacific coast highway,14 Huntington Beach,CA,92646 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ®6 Jot form Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name susan garcia We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name susan garcia Address 2550 Pacific Coast Hwy#82 Torrance,California,90505 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free4 4�,,f orm Friday,July 21,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Susie Freestone We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks 6 To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Susie Freestone Address 21851 Newland St Spc 154 Huntington Beach,CA,92646 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ®4 J•tforrn Friday,July 21,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Suzanne Butala We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks O To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and O To act in an advisory capacity to the.City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Suzanne Butala Address 20701 Beach Blvd,277 Huntington Beach,CA,92648 Signature 1 ' Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ®4 JOt orm Monday,July 17,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Temra Hilliard-Watson • We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks In the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council; and 0 To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Temra Hilliard-Watson Address 21851 Newland St,Space 195 Huntington Beach,CA,92646 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's fret .4: Jotform Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Teri Olson We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks s To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Theresa Olson Address 19251 Brookhurst St#40 Huntington Beach,CA,92646 Signature. Create your own automated PDFs with Jotforrn PDF Editor-It's free fee Jotfor Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Thomas Anderson We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and o To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Thomas Anderson Address 16444 Bolsa Chica St Spc 22 Huntington Beach,California[CA],92649 Signature r--- Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free JOttO 'it Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Tom McCaw We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory.Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks O To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council; and e To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Tom McCaw Address 20701 Beach Blvd sp182 Huntington Beach,CA,92648 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PUF Editor-it's free e4 Jotform Wednesday,July 19,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Vanessa Masters We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Vanessa Masters Address 20701 Beach Blvd Huntington Beach,CA,92648 Signature KA • Create your own automated PIJFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free f &®M i rrn Friday,July 21,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name William Reitz We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County, We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks o To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park.owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council; and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents`voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name William Reitz Address 19361 Brookhurst St#1 Huntington Beach,CA,92646 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ®4 Jot'or rn Friday,July 21,2023 • Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name wynona grand' We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks o To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council; and o To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name wynona grandi Address 20701 Beach Blvd,#6 Huntington Beach,CA,92648 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotforrn PDF Editor-It's free ®4 Jotform Tuesday,July 18,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Sandra Halperin We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks a To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Sandra Halperin Address 1305 North Harper Avenue,Apt. B West Hollywood,California,90046 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free Jots'®ri' Friday,July 21,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Sandra Swaid We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks e To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council; and To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Sandra Swaid Address 20701 Beach Blvd. Spc.150 Huntington Beach,California,92648 • Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform POF Editor-It's free Jot form Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Serena Taylor We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks • To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Serena Taylor Address 16444 Bolsa Chica st,Spc103 . Huntington Beach,Ca,92649 Signature day-4 Create your own automated PDFs with Jotforrn POE Editor-It's free JotfortYi Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Sharon Amrhein We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks © To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and 0 To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Sharon Amrhein Address 16222 Monterey Ln.,Space 369 Huntington Beach,CA,92649 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform POF Editor-It's free ®% Jotform Tuesday,July 18,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Sharon Crabill We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks o To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council; and e To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Sharon Crabill Address 20701 Beach Blvd,#6 Huntington Beach,CA,92648 Signature OIN W , . Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ®4 JOtft rrn Tuesday,July 18,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Sherrie Carroll We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and 9 To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Sherrie Carroll Address 10201 Beverly drive Huntington Beach,CA,92646 • Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free Jot orrn • Wednesday,July 12,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Sherrie Dean We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and G To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Sherrie Dean Address 605 Balsa Lane Fountain Valley,Ca,92708 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotforrn PDF Editor-It's free f4 Jotf•r'im Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Sheryl Engstrom We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks O To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and O To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Sheryl Engstrom Address 16444,Bolsa Chica Space 88 Huntington Beach,CA,92649 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-it's free J+tform Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Shirley Miller We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks ® To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and • To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Shirley Miller Address 16444 Bolsa Chica St. #157 Huntington Beach,California,926f9 Signature l Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free „94 Jotform Thursday,July 20,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Sharon Petersen We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks 9 To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council; and 0 To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Sharon Petersen Address 18601 Newland St.#85 Huntington Beach,CA,92646 Signature 244w Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ®B J tf orria Monday,July 17,2023 Please don't disband the Huntington Beach Mobile Home Advisory Board Name Sharon Petersen We the undersigned are opposed to any efforts to disband the Mobile Home Advisory Board. Mobile Homeowners represent the only non-subsidized affordable housing in Orange County. We disagree with efforts to stop this Board from its tasks o To ensure the quality of life in mobile home parks and to review matters concerning mobile home parks in the City of Huntington Beach through healthy communication with park owners, manufactured home owners and the City Council;and ® To act in an advisory capacity to the City Council on matters concerning the mobile home community. We resent any effort to erase our residents'voices from being heard in local civic participation! The signatories below are only a small part of the 3,000+registered voters in mobile home parks in Huntington Beach. Name Sharon Petersen Address 18601 Newland St. #85 Huntington Beach,CA,92646 Signature Create your own automated PDFs with Jotform PDF Editor-It's free ®�"a J tforrn