HomeMy WebLinkAboutRequest for Transparency and Detailed Reporting on the Imple (2) �UNjIN6/0 2000 Main Street,
o e Huntington Beach,CA
, 92648
City of Huntington Beach FAILED 3-3 (BURNS,
Fi
V6„ , . ��a VAN DER MARK, STRICKLAND-
ur>rri NO;McKEON-ABSENT)
File #: 24-143 MEETING DATE: 2/20/2024
Item Submitted by Council Member Moser - Request for Transparency and Detailed Reporting on the
Implementation of Resolution 2023-41 Regarding Library Material Accessibility
I request City staff to prepare and present a comprehensive report on the various aspects related to the
implementation of Resolution 2023-41. This includes criteria for material assessment and relocation; list of
relocated materials; newly acquired materials; library access changes; community engagement and feedback
process; digital assets; and clarification on youth re-carding process.
This report is requested to be prepared and presented at the next available City Council meeting. In the
interim, staff is also asked to make (1) the criteria for assessment and re-location; and (2)the list of relocated
books and materials available to the public as soon as possible (available at each library location and via the
library website) to ensure ongoing transparency and community engagement.
City of Huntington Beach Page 1 of 1 Printed on 2/14/2024
powero l/ I LegistarTM
Y� E
CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH
CITY COUNCIL MEETING - COUNCIL MEMBER ITEMS REPORT
TO: CITY COUNCIL
FROM: NATALIE MOSER,CITY COUNCIL MEMBER
DATE: FEBRUARY 20, 2024
SUBJECT: REQUEST FOR TRANSPARENCY AND DETAILED REPORTING ON THE IMPLEMENTATION OF
RESOLUTION 2023-41 REGARDING LIBRARY MATERIAL ACCESSIBILITY
BACKGROUND
Following the enactment of Resolution 2023-41 by the City Council (4-3; Bolton, Moser, Kalmick voting No)
on October 17,2023,significant changes have been made to the accessibility of library materials based on
whether the materials contain "content of sexual nature."As I understand,the changes include the
relocation of certain materials from the Children's section and the Teen section to an"adult-only" section,
and the requirement for parental consent for minors under the age of 18 to access these materials.
'Additionally,the reorganization has led to the removal of signage for specific library areas, notably the
Teen Central area, and the introduction of new guidelines for library access based on age and card type.
RATIONALE
The implementation of Resolution 2023-41 has raised concerns among community members regarding
access to library materials and the criteria used for restricting such access. Providing clear,transparent
information and engaging with the community on these changes is essential to uphold the public's trust
and ensure that the library remains a welcoming, inclusive space for all users.
REQUEST:
I request the city staff to prepare and present a comprehensive report on the following aspects related to
the implementation of Resolution 2023-41:
1. Criteria for Material Assessment and Relocation:
A detailed explanation of the specific criteria used to determine whether a book or material contains
"content of sexual nature" as defined by Resolution 2023-41.This should include examples of content
that led to the relocation of materials to the adult section.
2. List of Relocated Materials:
A transparent,accessible, and readily available list of all books and materials that have been moved to
comply with the resolution.The list should detail the specific portion(s)of a book or material that
triggered each relocation (e.g. page#),which of the above criteria applied,the date when each
reshelving occurred, and the quantity of a book or material that was reshelved.
3. Newly Acquired Materials:
A description of how books and materials coming into the library's collection will be assessed,where
the books and materials will reside while awaiting assessment, and where such books and materials
will be located to comply with Resolution 2023-41.
V
CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH
CITY COUNCIL MEETING - COUNCIL MEMBER ITEMS REPORT
4. Library Access Changes:
Clarification on the physical changes made to library areas, particularly regarding access for teens and
young adults.This should include an explanation of the enforcement mechanisms for the new access
rules based on age, card type, and guardian presence.
5. Community Engagement and Feedback Process:
Description of the process for community members to provide feedback or contest the relocation of
specific materials, including the steps for completing a Material Evaluation Form and the review
process.
6. Digital Assets
There has been almost no discussion of how this process works with regard to digital assets the library
offers our residents. Provide a discussion of how new"Youth"cards will be able to access the
resources provided online.
7. Clarification on Youth Re-carding Process:
In light of the changes introduced by Resolution 2023-41,there is a significant need for a clear
understanding of the new youth re-carding process,which will affect youth library card holders and
their parents/guardians.
This section of the report should cover:
a. Re-carding Procedure:
A detailed overview of the process for transitioning current youth library card holders to the new
card system, including any steps that need to be completed by parents or guardians.This should
specify whether the process can be initiated by any parent/guardian or must be conducted by the
individual who originally signed the youth up for library access.
b. In-Person Requirements and Alternatives:
Clarification on whether the re-carding process must be completed in person at library facilities
and, if so,what alternatives exist for parents or guardians who are unable to comply with in-
person requirements(for example,due to logistical constraints or health concerns).
c. Dispute Resolution:
Guidelines on how disagreements between parents or guardians regarding the appropriate card
type for their child will be resolved by library staff.This includes scenarios where parents may
have differing views on the accessibility of certain materials for their children.
d. Impact on Library Resources and Services:
An assessment of how the re-carding process and the associated changes in library access will
impact library resources and services.This should consider both the logistical aspects of
implementing the re-carding process and the broader implications for library services available to
youth in the community.
m
f u
CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH
CITY COUNCIL MEETING - COUNCIL MEMBER ITEMS REPORT
TIMING
This report is requested to be prepared and presented at the next available City Council meeting. In the
interim,staff is also asked to make (1)the criteria for assessment and re-location; and (2)the list of
relocated books and materials available to the public as soon as possible (available at each library location
and via the library website)to ensure ongoing transparency and community engagement.
Environmental Status:
This action is not subject to the California Environmental Quality Act(CEQA) pursuant to Sections 15060(c)(2)
(the activity will not result in a direct or reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment)
and 15060(c)(3) (the activity is not a project as defined in Section 15378) of the CEQA Guidelines, California
Code of Regulations, Title 14, Chapter 3, because it has no potential for resulting in physical change to the
environment, directly or indirectly.
Strategic Plan Goal:
Non Applicable-Administrative Item
•
co
w
From: Cathev Ryder
To: suoolementalcommasurfcity-hb.orq.
Subject HB CC 2/20 Agenda Item 24
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 8:19:00 AM
HB CC 2/20 Agenda
Transparency and Accountability were promised during the 2022 election cycle by those who
were elected to the Huntington Beach City Council. Agenda Item 24 asks for transparency and
accountability. I expect there to be an unanimous vote for this agenda item.
If not,then we know that the council majority has no intention to be transparent or wants to be
held accountable.
Vote Yes on Agenda Item 24.
CJ Ryder
HB Homeowner and Voter
SUPPLEMENTAL
COMMUNICATION
2/20/2024
Mooting Date:
24 (24-143)
Agenda Item No.;
From: David Rvnerson
To: CITY COUNCIL aNCL.CM0 STAFF)suoolementalcommCla surfcity-hb.orq
Subject RE:REQUEST FOR TRANSPARENCY AND DETAILED REPORTING ON THE IMPLEMENTATION OF RESOLUTION
2023-41 REGARDING LIBRARY MATERIAL ACCESSIBILITY
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 11:58:40 AM
HB City Council-
Consider this my statement of strong support for Council Member Moser's request for transparency and reporting on
the implementation of Resolution 2023-41.
What the Council Member is asking for is straight forward common sense information and processes that should
have been thought out and presented at the time the resolution was initially passed. Instead,both citizens and
librarians have endured months of opaque,unclear,and frankly capricious decisions about what books can be where,
who can access them,procedures regarding new book acquisitions,rights of under age citizens,etc.
What the Council Member is asking for should have been all worked out before the resolution was even presented at
the city council meeting,once again highlighting the ineptitude and capriciousness of the council majority. The
classic,"Ready,Fire,Aim!"we've seen over and over again.
This request should be implemented with clear input from both librarians and citizens-not the unilateral desires of
one Council Member.
It's the least you can do.
David Rynerson
6272 Newbury Drive
Huntington Beach,CA 92647
From: Lindsay K
To: suonlementalcammCalsun`dtv-hb.orq
Subject: 24-143 Item Submitted by Council Member Moser-Request for Transparency and Detailed Reporting on the
Implementation of Resolution 2023-41 Regarding Library Material Accessibility
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 2:30:27 PM
As expected,the vague and unworkable Huntington Beach Public Library book ban resolution
2023-41 passed 4-3 by the HB City Council has resulted in upheaval at our beloved public
library. Useful books written for children and parents have been removed from the children's
area and relegated to a recently installed bookshelf wedged between the rotating art exhibit
and a quiet study area. So far the books include materials on potty training, puberty and
menstruation but more are soon to follow.
In addition the area formerly called "Teen Central" has presumably been folded into the adult
section with the removal of its demarcating sign.The message is that in society there are small
children and adults with no stage in between. I think most folks with any recent experience
with middle or high school students know they face a range of challenges-social, physical and
emotional -that are vastly different than those of small children. Books written for and about
tweens and teens should and do reflect those differences. It is up to parents, not library staff,
to determine what books are appropriate their family. Restricting materials severely limits
parents from using their own judgement and tells tweens and teens that books about their
lives are so dangerous or dirty as to need to be separated even from other adult materials.
The stated goal of the City Council's vague policy is to restrict all patrons under 18 from
accessing"sexual material". I don't understand why that is their decision now and not the
parent or guardian's choice.Traditionally libraries have arranged materials by age group using
interest level and comprehension as guidelines- usually kids (0-12),teen (13-17) and adult.
These groupings are to help the library user find what they are looking for but they are NOT
designed to stop anyone from checking books or materials out.That has always been between
the parent and child. Parents who did not want to give their children or teens "carte blanche"
could closely monitor their child in the library or opt out of getting their child a card at all and
instead use their own card. Parents who wanted to give their children entirely free range
would also be able to follow that approach provided they followed the library's unattended
minor policy and supervised their child under 11 in the library.
Restricting the checking out of public library materials by age is a form of book banning.The
American Library Association's Library Bill of Rights,Article V states "A person's right to use a
library should not be denied or abridged because of origin, age, background, or views."The
community is beginning to see what a farce Resolution 2023-41 is as evidenced by the books
moved so far. I appreciate Councilwoman Moser's request for clarity on the implementation
of the book ban resolution but have very low expectations that it will pass. My great hope is
that the library users themselves will witness what is happening and speak out for they are the
ones who will be most affected. I have seen no evidence the four members of the City Council
who voted for the resolution have used our lovely library in any other way than as a pawn in
their strange war on a welcoming society.The only responsible and logical solution is to return
to regular library practice and let parents determine for their families what their kids and
teens can and cannot check out. Free people read freely.
Sincerely,
Lindsay Klick
Mother, HB Resident, Children's Librarian, Reader
From: Lee Marie Sanchez
To: suoolementalcomm aC)surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: SUPPORT FOR COUNCIL MEMBER NATALIE MOSER Agenda Item 24-143
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 2:42:27 PM
Dear Huntington Beach Council Members N
This is to inform you that I am in total support of Council Member
Natalie Moser concerns regarding the TRANSPARENCY AND DETAILED
REPORTING ON THE IMPLEMENTATION OF RESOLUTION 2023-41 REGARDING LIBRARY
MATERIAL ACCESSIBILITY.
Your constituents absolutely need to know what is happening
regarding the relocation of books to the adult section, closure of
the teen section, volunteer parent review board committee, new
policies for library cards, and other restrictions.
My family has lived in Huntington Beach for over 52 years and we
have been huge supporters of our Huntington Beach Library,
Librarians and all staff members. We must have this information
to determine our further actions in these matters.
N Sincerely, Rev. Lee Marie Sanchez (Retired & Voting)
From: Linda Moon
To: suooIementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq
Subject Feb 20,2024 Agenda Item 24-143
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 2:52:17 PM
I am writing in support of Agenda Item 24-123, Resolution 2023-41,requiring disclosure and
transparency with regard to new regulations for access to library materials. Libraries are
essential to the support of a well informed and educated community. Any changes to current
rules for access to library materials should be made only after full disclosure to the public,
with opportunity for public comment and participation.
The minimally announced changes removing the Teen Section of the library,removal of
materials from the Children's section and limitation of access to materials for anyone under 18
are misguided and fly in the face of the purpose of libraries to provide community members
broad opportunities for education and enrichment. Restrictions for minor's access should be
imposed by parents and guardians, based upon their own values, not those of the City Council
Majority.
Linda Sapiro Moon
Huntington Beach
From: alumni.wedge OnCa)icloud.com
To: suoolementalcomm(alsurfcity-hb.orq
Subject: RE:Agenda Item 24-143
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 2:57:48 PM
I fully support Agenda Item 24-143 for complete transparency on library material accessibility and all city
government.
A 52 year resident of Huntington Beach
From: grin Spivey
To: suaolementalcommesurfcity-hb.orq
Subject Support Agenda Item 24-143
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 3:18:13 PM
To the City Council,
I heartily support Agenda Item 24-143.The library resolution passed in October was vague at best,malicious at
worst.This agenda item will provide some much needed transparency on how exactly the October resolution is
being implemented.As community members and Huntington Beach residents,transparency is the very minimum we
should expect for our city government.
Sincerely,
Erin Spivey
Sent from my iphone,please excuse any typos
From: rotund.highs0iCa)icloud.com
To: suoolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb,orq
Subject Agenda Item 24-143
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 3:20:44 PM
I urge you all to vote for Natalie's request for transparency regarding the relocation of books
to the adult section, closure of the teen section and new policies for library cards.
From: Carol Daus
To: CITY COUNCIL.(INCL.CM0 STAFF);suoolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Agenda Item 24
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 3:36:11 PM
Dear Council Members,
I am in support of Council Member Moser'sa Request for Transparency and Detailed
Reporting on the Implementation of Resolution 2023-41 Regarding Library Material
Accessibility.
Since the resolution was passed and implemented, library patrons and the community at large
have been confused about how the new library policies are being enacted. Council Member's
outline for identifying and communicating the steps is a step in the right direction,however,
I'm still very concerned about limiting books and materials to so many readers.
As an active volunteer at the library,I have lots of residents asking me questions and I don't
know how to answer them.
I look forward to attending the meeting to find out more.
Sincerely,
Carol Daus
HB Resident, 29 years
From: Barbara Van Ding
To: suoolementalcommAsurfcity-hb.orq
Subject Library Takeover
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 4:35:48 PM
Public libraries were founded in the United States to ensure that all people had equal access to all written material as
part of being a democracy.
The City Council majority's decision(without voter input)to overhaul the HB Public Library by banning books,
changing signage,moving books,changing library cards and controlling what books are purchased(all of which are
the duties of the head Librarian,a professionally trained individual in Library Science),defeats the purpose and
intent of a Public Library, No doubt the next step if they stay true to the national right-wing agenda,will lead to a
"majority"vote to privatize the library at the HB citizen's expense. This is nothing short of a gut punch to the First
Amendment and the freedom the citizens of the United States have to access information and to be a freely educated
people. What this is is a nationally-sponsored right-wing(MAGA)agenda to attack our constitutional rights and the
freedoms we are so proud of.
Barbara Van Dine
27 year resident of Huntington Beach
From: Vicky Shuttleworth
To: suoolementalcommesurfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Concerns on Resolution 23-41
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 5:03:52 PM
Dear HB City Council,
I have several concerns about Resolution 23-41 as it appears to contradict the Library Bill of
Rights:
1. What credentials will the parents/volunteers to the Review Board Committee present to
show they are qualified to review library materials?
2. What Standards will be followed by this Committee?
3. What restrictions will be placed on library cards?
4. Does this mean that everyone has to get a new library card? Have you considered the
cost this part of the resolution?
5. Why would you close the teen section when we need to encourage literacy in our youth
and community?
6. Where are you finding the funds to implement the costs of re-cataloging the books?
I hope you provide answers to these and other questions in a transparent manner.
Vicky Shuttleworth
HB resident since 1987
From: Diane Pavesic
To: suoolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Re:Resolution 2023-41
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 5:07:08 PM
Huntington Beach City Council Members,
I am writing to to inform you that I am in complete support of Council Member Natalie Moser's concerns regarding
the TRANSPARENCY ANDS DETAILED REPORTING ON THE IMPLEMENTATION OF RESOLUTION
2023-41 REGARDING LIBRARY MATERIAL ACCESSIBILITY.
The constituents who voted you in office have a right to know what is happening regarding the relocation of books
to the adult section,closure of the teen section,volunteer parent partner review board committee,new policy for
library cards and the additional proposed restrictions.
I have lived in Huntington Beach for 34 years and am no longer proud to live here.Please get on with taking care of
the actual needs of the City instead of creating problems that do not actually exist.Please allow the librarians to do
the jobs they were trained to do.
Sincerely,
Diane M.Pavesic
BSN,CCM,IAYT
Sent from my iPad
From: Ellie Johnson
To: supplementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Agenda Item 24-143
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 5:38:20 PM
To the members of Huntington Beach City Council,
I hope you will approve the Agenda item 24-143.As a member of the community and a
supporter of the wonderful library we have,we need to understand how decisions are being
made to effectively change the way our library functions. This agenda item details the ways in
which that transparency should be conducted. If you have nothing to hide, approve this
agenda item.
Respectfully submitted,
Eleanor Johnson
From: Harry McLachlan
To: suaolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)
Subject: Feb.20,2024 Agenda Item 24.
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 5:53:34 PM
Attachments: Huntington Beach City Council Feb,20.2024.docx
Please see attached comment.
Huntington Beach Special City Council Meeting February 20, 2024
Agenda Item 24, No. 24-143
My name is Harry McLachlan. I am a resident of Huntington Beach.
I am writing in support of agenda item 24, calling for a comprehensive report
on the implementation of Resolution 2023-41. I agree with request numbers 1
through 7 in their entirety.
I am hoping that the entire council will vote to approve this item in unified
support of the right of all our citizens to ensure detailed clarity and
transparency in the implementation of Resolution 2023-41.
Please vote yes on agenda item 24.
From: Paul Homan
To: sunolementalcomm(a surfcity-hb.orq
Subject Request for transparency/library material accessibility
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 5:54:06 PM
Greetings:
This e-mail is submitted in support of Council Member Natalie Moser's
request for transparency regarding Huntington Beach Library material accessibility,which I
understand is pending for consideration by the Huntington Beach City Council.
Council Member Moser's resolution is rational, concise. and timely. Please approve it.
Thank you.
Paul Horgan
Huntington Beach
From: Sue Welfrinaer
To: 5uoolementalcommCa)surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Supporting 24-143-REQUEST FOR TRANSPARENCY AND DETAILED REPORTING ON THE IMPLEMENTATION OF
RESOLUTION 2023-41 REGARDING LIBRARY MATERIAL ACCESSIBILITY
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 7:30:45 PM
Thank you, Councilmember Moser,for your Agenda Item,showing support for our librarians and
library patrons by asking for clarification on what is deemed "sexual content" in literature for
children. It is not a big ask to request specific instruction in this manner.
For example, last week I read a compelling YA novel by award-winning children's author Gary
Paulsen,titled NightJohn.The story made me uncomfortable, as intended. It is okay to be
uncomfortable in the safe space of literature.
The novel is classified by the publisher for audiences in the 10-13-year-old range. I read and
discussed it with an 8th grade student.This deeply touching novel is based on the true story of a
runaway slave who risked his life to teach other slaves to read and write. Regarding the question of
sexual content: In this story, 11=year Sarny, is dreading when her"troubles" start because it is likely
she will be selected as a breeder. Her mother was apparently a good breeder,too,and sold before
Sarny would ever get to know her. Sarny tells of what happened to another girl,Alice:
(p.42-43)...her body was all right and they in the white house decided she be a good breeder
and so they set her for that.
She didn't set well to it and fought and they tied her to make it happen, in the
breeding shed back of the quarters...
Breeding shed??? Does this make you uncomfortable? I hope so. But it is not simply that we are
reading a scene describing child rape that makes us want to vomit. It's learning that not too long
ago,white Americans thought"breeding sheds"were okay! It appears to me that your directive,as it
currently stands, does not want an 8th grader to learn about this.
NightJohn is only one of thousands of stories in any library collection that includes some reference
to "sexual content"while telling deeply important stories. When you take passages out of context
you are missing the true intent of the author. Worse,you are miscalculating how the story builds
empathy, compassion, and relevant human connections for the young reader(and the adult who
might read it with them.) I'm still thinking about this story!
If you are unable to be more specific in your"sexual content" directive to the librarians and library
patrons, I trust your constituents will understand if you decide to leave the library collection to the
librarians and the reading choices to the parents.
Based on the book titles already removed for the children's section,certainly we all agree that
clarification is required. Please make that happen.
Regards,
Sue Welfringer
27-year HB Resident&community volunteer
From: Tony Dau5
To: suoolementalcomm(alsurfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CM0 STAFF1
Subject: February 20 City Council Meeting-Agenda Item 24
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 7:43:05 PM
Council Members,
I am in support of Council Member Moser's Request for Transparency and Detailed Reporting on the
Implementation of Resolution 2023-41 Regarding Library Material Accessibility.
Since the resolution was passed and apparently implemented (with limited public notice), I have
been confused about how the new library policies are being enacted and I suspect that I am not
alone. I am not in support of the actions that the City Council's conservative majority, and
their obedient city attorney Michael Gates, have undertaken to screen and ban books and limit
access to minors. I raised three children who have grown up to be successful, honorable adults and
they had their run of the library. We encouraged it! I don't need the City Council to act as a
parent.
Sincerely,
Tony Daus
HB Resident, 29 years
From: Kathryn Goddard
To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq
Subject Agenda Item 24-143
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 8:59:19 PM
I write in support of agenda item 24-143 introduced by Natalie Moser,Council Member. I urge your approval of
this request for transparency in the changes which affect our library.
Citizens of all ages seek knowledge and share the library as both resource and as a place to engage with one
another. Librarians are a valuable resource for the education of all. The joy and journey of acquiring knowledge
and determining one's own position of what is real,what is true and what is good is best served by a broad selection
of thought.
Knowledgeable,trained librarians are an integral part of this journey. Members of the City Council are selected by
citizens to manage the affairs of the city to include concerns such as infrastructure,safety,appearance. They are
neither trained nor elected to manage the libraries.
The current Council majority has determined that the holdings of the library should be managed in a manner that is
not understood by the electorate. It is important to all of us that we understand what you are attempting to
accomplish by defining sexuality as the single measure of locating books in an area which is closed to many. What
is the goal of tasking educated librarians to use a natural human activity as a method of sorting knowledge?
Kathryn Goddard,resident over 30 years
Sent from my iPad
From: Pat Goodman
To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL CMO STAFF);suoolementalcomml@surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Vote Yes on Agenda Item 24
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 9:10:03 PM
Dear City Councilmembers,
Please vote YES on the February 20th city council agenda item # 24.
This item, a Request for Transparency and Detailed Reporting on the
Implementation of Resolution 2023-41 regarding Library Material
Accessibility would asuage residents' concern on the administration of
implementation of restrictions on availability of certain children's literature.
Councilmember Moser's agenda item would provide a level of credibility to
recent actions to relocate books from the children's and teen sections to the
adult library.
Patrons, especially parents and grandparents, of the library do not know how
to access these publications and why they have been moved.
I also wonder what happened to the implementation of the citizen panel to
review books for certain sexual content?
The procedures identified in agenda item #24 would help document the
rationale and publications moved to the adult section.
Thank you.
Pat Goodman
Huntington Beach, CA
From: Fran Delaney
To: supolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Transparency in Changes to the Library per Resolution 2023-41
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 9:22:47 PM
Dear Huntington Beach City Council Members,
I have great concerns about the implementation of Resolution 2023-41 and the proposed
changes to the library. The Huntington Beach Library system stands out in California as an
exemplary system of management and service to the community. We need to understand how
this resolution will affect the libraries that we support, frequent, and pay for.
Councilwoman Moser has put forth a request for full transparency in the workings of this
resolution. It appears that none of the structures needed to fairly and ethically carry out this
resolution are in place. The public needs to understand exactly what you intend to do to our
libraries and how it will affect our community.
I support all areas of Councilwoman Moser's request. This step for control over a system that
is effective and serves the community in such a powerful way should never have been
tampered with,but since it did pass on such a slim majority, it is time that you step forward
and explain what your true intentions are and how it will complicate the lives of Huntington
Beach citizens.
Fran Delaney-Barron
Resident
"Never underestimate the power of a small group of committed people to change the world. In fact, it is
the only thing that ever has."-Margaret Mead
From: Chris Kawahar4
To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.org
Subject: Support for Agenda item#24
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 10:05:10 PM
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to express my support for Natalie Moser's agenda item#24.
I definitely think that there needs to be transparency of the library restrictions/changes that are currently taking place
at the Huntington Beach Public Library.
I think that these restrictions are a violation of the 1st Amendment
and are politicizing issues unnecessarily.
Thank you,
Christina Kawahara
A resident of Huntington Beach for over 38 years.
Sent from my iPhone
From: Buffie Channel
To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF);suoplementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-143
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 10:28:39 PM
To City Council:
I am writing in support of Agenda Item 24-143.
We need to see the criteria for the books chosen that were moved into the XAdult section of
the library.
We need to see the official list of books that were moved.
We need to understand what will happen to the Teen Section of the library.
We need to be advised of any future plans, criteria, and method of moving books.
We need to be advised how we challenge a book that was moved and request it is moved back
to its appropriate section.
We need to be advised the status of the citizen committee and the process of how the members
are chosen,how they were chosen,why they were chosen, and the details of any personal ties
committee members.have to Council members. We also need to know the exact details of
when,how, and where this committee will meet and how the public can observe the meeting
under the Brown Act.
Sincerely,
Buffie Channel
35 year HB resident and homeowner
From: Melanie Tioleco-Chenq
To: suoolementalcommaa surfdty-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CM0 STAFF)
Subject: Keep our Libraries PUBLIC and free from book bans
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 10:30:24 PM
Dear City Council, •
As a 20 year resident of Huntington Beach and a pediatrician who also has the
pleasure and privilege of taking care of kids in our area, I respectfully support Natalie
Moser's proposal for more transparency in the new library committee. (Resolution
2023-41)
I was one of hundreds of HB residents who have spoke out at several meetings
opposing what is essentially a book ban. Since October 2023, several books have
been moved outside of the children's section into the adult section, including books on
toilet training and puberty. For example, one book in particular, The Care and
Keeping of You, which is put out by the American Girl company has shockingly been
made UNAVAILABLE to the young readers it was meant for. This book is
recommended for ages 8 and up with the sequel recommended for ages 10 and up
and I unequivocally recommend this book to my young patients as it talks about
friendship issues, body changes, good hygiene, and more.
This is just one example of many books which have been 'restricted', which means
access has been limited, which means these books essentially have been banned.
Why, I may ask, would this committee do such a thing? Is therir opinion more
important than mine, a mother of two kids?A pediatrician who has been practicing for
decades? Or more important than a librarian who has been trained in library
sciences?
Please let the rest of Huntington Beach, and the world, see what is actually
happening in this library committee.
The teen section signs have already been taken down. It makes me so sad to see
that the library in which I have been going to for 21 years--the one in which I have
taken my two kids for their whole lives--is being torn apart.
Allow us parents to CHOOSE what we think is and is not appropriate for our own
children to read. We do not need the government to tell us what to read.
Sincerely,
Melanie Tioleco-Cheng -
From: Erick Ruiz
To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF);suoolementalcommesurfcity-hb.orq
Subject: RE:Urgent Call for Transparency in Implementing Resolution 2023-41
Date: Monday,February 19,2024 11:34:04 PM
Dear Huntington Beach City Council Members,
I am writing to urgently express my adamant support for Council Member Natalie Moser's
agenda item 24-143, which demands transparency and detailed reporting on the
implementation of Resolution 2023-41 concerning library material accessibility.As a resident
of Huntington Beach and a staunch advocate for open access to information, I am deeply
concerned about the potential consequences of censorship and restrictions on library materials,
particularly regarding children's access.
Let me be unequivocal: the notion of shielding children from certain information by restricting
access within libraries is profoundly flawed and counterproductive.Keeping children in a
bubble only pique their curiosity further, and it fails to address the real issue.The real problem
lies in the widespread accessibility of harmful content and information on platforms such as
YouTube and TikTok,where many children spend a significant amount of their time.
Instead of imposing blanket restrictions on library materials,we should trust in the expertise of
librarians who are trained in research and obtaining materials.Librarians are adept at curating
content appropriate for different age groups and guiding children towards valuable resources.
Placing the power to make decisions about access to information in the hands of trained
professionals is far more effective and sensible than leaving it to the city council's discretion.
As a second-year law student,I am particularly attuned to upholding fundamental principles of
freedom of information and expression. Censorship and restrictions on access to library
materials infringe upon these principles and hinder intellectual growth and development.
I implore the City Council to reconsider the approach outlined in Resolution 2023-41 and to
prioritize transparency and open dialogue with the community.By doing so,we can work
together to address the root causes of concerns about children's exposure to inappropriate
content while upholding the principles of openness and inclusivity that are fundamental to our
society.
Thank you for taking a look at this urgent matter. I trust that the City Council will act in the
best interests of our community and uphold the values of transparency and freedom of
information.
Sincerely,
Erick Alexander Ruiz Jr.
J.D.Candidate,Class of 2025
LexisNexis,Law School Associate
Student Bar Association,2L Representative
Student Bar Association,Faculty Appointments Committee
Western State College of Law
Phone:(562)303-7393
From: diannef22(a)vahoo.com
To: CITY COUNCIL.(INCL..CM0 STAFF);suaolementalcommasurfdty-hb.orq
Subject: Support Agenda Item#24
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 4:27:01 AM
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers,
I am writing in support of agenda item #24.
As has become the MO of the majority councilmembers, agenda items, resolutions,
and ordinances are passed based on an emotional response to an issue without
much thought as to the practical application of the measures once.they are enacted.
A resolution was passed in October 2023 with regard to restricting access to library
materials if the items include "content of sexual nature". The resolution did not
include any direction that defines sexual nature. The resolution did not include any
objective rationale for choosing which materials were to be removed. The resolution
did not address the destruction of the "Teen Central" area, but it occurred
concurrently with the removal of a large number of books from the children's and
young adult sections of the library. Is there a plan for the teen area? Is there a plan
for the teens who would ordinarily hang out in the library? Where do you think these
teens will go if they no longer have a safe place to hang out?
All of these issues have caused a great deal of concern in the community and could
have been avoided if all of the questions and parameters requested in this agenda
item had been addressed prior to the implementation of the poorly written and
unneeded resolution from October 2023. If only some of the community members
would have raised these concerns back then, maybe this confusion could have been
avoided.... but wait, the community(spent hours and hours providing public comment
to warn the council of all of these complications that would arise from the nanny-state
book-restricting resolution.
Now that we are here and the resolution has taken effect, let's make sure it is the
least destructive as possible. Let's have complete transparency regarding the criteria
for books being removed and restricted. Let's get a list of all the books that are being
removed so parents/guardians will know they have to take their kids to the ugly/boring
locked up section instead of the relaxing and inviting children's section. Let's make
sure we have procedures for processing the new youth library cards, so
parents/guardians don't have to waste time when they try to comply with the new
hurdles their teens will have to overcome just to have access to books.
The best thing that can be done is to rescind this resolution, but barring that, let's at
least make it functional so our residents can enjoy the library as much as possible.
Sincerely,
Dianne
From: Andrew Einhorn
To: suoolementalcommi surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: I support item 24-143
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 4:54:04 AM
Dear HB City Council,I support item 24-143 and the development of a report on the implementation of resolution
2023-41.
Sincerely,
Andrew Einhorn
HB Resident
From: Levin.Shannon
To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Fwd:Item agenda 24
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 5:59:30 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
_.......... ..........._........... ...........
From: Barbara Shapiro<bshap2000@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 202410:50:52 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) <citly.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: Item agenda 24
I support item agenda 24 on February 20,2024 CC meeting.
Sent from my iPad
From: Levin.Shannon
To: suoolementalcomm(a surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Fwd:Implementation of Resolution 23-41
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:00:18 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
From:Sue Brewsaugh <sue.brewsaugh@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 10:19:53 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: Implementation of Resolution 23-41
Please pass Councilwoman Moser's regarding resolution 23-41. However you feel about the
resolution,it's critical that both the library staff and the community understand both the criteria its
implementation process.
Thank you,
Sue Brewsaugh
HB resident and voter
From: Levin.Shannon
To: suoplementalcommCa surfcity-hb.org
Subject: Fwd:Support for Agenda item#24
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:00:42 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
From:Chris Kawahara<kfamily@socal.rr.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 202410:03:45 PM
To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<citly.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject:Support for Agenda item#24
Dear Council Members,
I am writing to express my support for Natalie Moser's agenda item#24.
I definitely think that there needs to be transparency of the library restrictions/changes that are
currently taking place at the Huntington each Public Library.
I think that these restrictions are a violation of the 1st Amendment
and are politicizing issues unnecessarily.
Thank you,
Christina Kawahara
A resident of Huntington Beach for over 38 years.
Sent from my iPhone
From: Levin.Shannon
To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Fwd:Resolution 2023-41 Regarding Library Material Accessibility
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:01:15 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
From:sgschumann@aol.com<sgschumann@aol.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 8:28:57 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: Resolution 2023-41 Regarding Library Material Accessibility
Dear City Council Members,
As a mother of three adult children and grandmother of seven (ranging in ages between 9 and 27) , I am
outraged and grieved to live in community where some members of its governing body feels it is the city's
right to generate and implement Resolution 2023-41.
This Resolution hijacks the responsibility and privilege that parents have to monitor their children's
reading, leaving decisions regarding the appropriateness of books to complete strangers. It is not the City
Council's responsibility.
I highly support Council Member Natalie Moser's Request for Transparency and Detailed Reporting on
the Implementation of Resolution 2023-41 Regarding Library Material Accessibility, and urge you to
prepare and present a comprehensive report as requested.
It concerns me greatly that the Council initiated the process of removing and reorganizing books without a
thorough review of the impact this Resolution will have on our community. Resolution 2023-41 should
never have been passed in the first place.
Sincerely,
Susan Schumann
8933 Modesto Circle Unit 1214D
Huntington Beach, CA 92646
From: Levin.Shannon
To: suoolementalcomm aC)surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Fwd:Support for Agenda Item 24
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:01:27 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
From: Barbara Richardson<hblibrarylady@yahoo.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 8:21:08 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject:Support for Agenda Item 24
Honorable Mayor and Council Members
I am sending this email to show my support for Natalie's Moser's agenda item 24,
seeking transparency of library changes.
Because all the books in the children's collection have received positive reviews from
accredited review sources, without clearly written instructions, it is almost impossible
to determine what titles to relocate. The bathing suit rule is so broad and vague, it
could mean that all books that have a photo or drawing of Michelangelo's David, and
any book that had a drawing or photo of a Greek statue would have to be removed.
Volumes from the World Book Encyclopedia would need to be relocated and well as
reference books on diseases.
As for sexual nature/content; would all children's books that show hugging, kissing or
talk of kissing and love have to be relocated? Think of Valentine's Day stories, many
of those deal with kissing and hugging. Another example, what if the mother in the
story is pregnant, does that show implied sexual content? You can see how difficult
this can become.
To help fight the confusion, I believe the librarians should be given a written list of all
the titles that Council believes are unacceptable and need to be relocated.
Thank you
Barbara Richardson
51 year HB resident
From: Levin.Shannon
To: sunolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb,orq
Subject: Fwd:Library Transparency
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:01:41 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
From: Iori berberet<Iberb@hotmail.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 6:31:30 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: Library Transparency
Dear HB City Council Members:
I have been seeking what the changes are as proposed by the HB City Council to our library. I
have not been able to find anything in writing that shares the changes that have occurred
within that system.
It is time for the City Council to be fully transparent with the plan moving forward with the HB
Public Library. I am aware that there is an agenda item for tomorrow's meeting seeking
transparency.
As a citizen of HB for many years, it is your responsibility to offer any and all changes in writing
and making it clear to all of your constituents. I look forward to you doing what you have been
elected to do-being honest and transparent!
Lori Berberet
HB Resident and Concerned Neighbor
From: Levin.Shannon
To: suoolementalcomm(a)surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Fwd:Feb.20th HB Council Mtg.Agenda Item 24
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:01:52 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
From:gelliottl@socal.rr.com <gelliott1@socal.rr.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 6:09:06 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: Feb. 20th HB Council Mtg.Agenda Item 24
Re Item 24-143
How ironic that the Council majority has declared February "We Love Our Libraries Month"
after their concerted and successful effort to undermine and overrule the expertise of a stellar,
professional library staff. What next?Privatizing our public library?I support Item 24 and
urge any and all Council members who truly love our libraries to do the same. Cheryl Elliott
From: Levin.Shannon
To: suaolementalcommCa)surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Fwd:Library transparency
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:02:04 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
From: Debra Gala<debragala@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 5:34:34 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: Library transparency
Making potential banning and censoring of books should not be done Willy nilly in a free society.
Transparency is essential when decisions about limiting access to books at a public library.I urge all
members of hb city council to vote for transparency with the proposed changes and not let a zealous
few dictate a potential loss of information and knowledge for teens and other youths based on fear of
independent thinking.Thank you,Debra Gala 35 plus year resident,avid reader,parent and educator.
Sent from my iPhone
From: Levin.Shannon
To: suoDlementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.org
Subject Fwd:Library
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:02:29 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
From: Becky Weinthal<beckyweinthal@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 5:31:371 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: Fwd: Library
Begin forwarded message:
From: Becky Weinthal<beckyweinthal@gmail.com>
Date: February 19, 2024 at 5:10 122 PM PST
To: "McKeon, Casey" <Casey.McKeon@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: Re: Library
Thank you for responding Casey;. I'm glad to hear the remaining portion of
Hamilton will be repaved.However my larger point was,I would prefer our city
council concern itself with matters of infrastructure, maintenance and modern
function, not cherry picking books from the libraries, fighting over flag flying and
voter intimidation. Certainly you are aware of the history of banning books.
On Feb 19, 2024, at 3:53 PM,McKeon, Casey
<Casey.McKeon@surfcity-hb.org>wrote:
Thank you for your email Becky. The Western half of Hamilton was
repaved last year and the remaining portion will be paved this year.
Casey McKeon
City Council Member
City of Huntington Beach
714-536-5553
On Feb 19,2024, at 2:34 PM,Becky Weinthal
<beckyweinthal@gmail.com>wrote:
What makes our City Council the arbiters of what books
are in our libraries? Self appointed, self righteous,
political pandering? How about fixing the potholes on
Hamilton?
From: Levin.Shannon
To: suoolementalcomm@ surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Fwd:
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:02:53 AM
Get Outlook for
From:saka714@aol.com <saka714@aol.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 4:13:36 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject:
I'm very concerned about the new library policy of having the library review board to be
appointed by the MAGA members and reflecting their arrogance and ignorance. The HB
TAX PAYERS must have transparency in issues before the city council!!!
Irate tax payer,
Sharon Saka
Sent from the all new AOT,_app for iOj
From: Levin.Shannon
To: supplementalcommC)surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Fwd:Transparency at the library
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:03:04 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
From:Julie Hoagland<timetoprayjulie@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 3:40:10 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject:Transparency at the library
Please provide clear and transparent data as to the new protocols regarding adult book selections.
Teen and youth book choices are also needing the protocol to be made transparent
Julie Ford,DDS
Sent from my iPhone
From: Levin.Shannon
To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.org
Subject Fwd:Support for 24-143
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:03:26 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
From: Rayna Hamre<rhamre@uuma.org>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 3:25:19 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<cityI .council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject:Support for 24-143
Dear City Council Members-
I am in full support of Council Member Moser's agenda item 24-143.
Please provide transparency on the recent unnecessary changes to our local libraries. Voters
need full transparency regarding the logistics and costs for the relocation of books to the adult
section, closure of the teen section,volunteer parent review board committee,new policies for
library cards, and any other new restrictions on materials and changes to qualified library
personnel hiring or other human resources actions.
Thank you,
Rev.Rayna Hamre
49 year resident of Huntington Beach
Rev. Rayna Harare
Affiliated Community Minister VU Church in Anaheim
(949) 791-9144
she, her
From: Levin.Shannon
To: suoplementalcomm4surfcity-hb.orq
Subject Fwd:Agenda Item 24-143
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:03:40 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
From:shakes-09-dame@icloud.com<shakes-09-dame@icloud.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 3:23:55 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject:Agenda Item 24-143
I urge you to support Agenda Item 24-143 proposed by Natalie Moser.Providing clear,transparent
information regarding library policies is essential to uphold the community's trust!
From: J.evin.Shannon
To: suoolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq
Subject Fwd:Agenda item 24-143
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:03:51 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
From: letters-clumpy-Or@icloud.com<letters-clumpy-Or@icloud.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 2:55:16 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject:Agenda item 24-143
I support Natalie Moser's agenda item 24-143 for Transparency. We need transparency in all city
government.
A very concerned resident
From: Levin.Shannon
To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Fwd:Feb 20,2024 Agenda Item 24-143
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:04:02 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
From: Linda Moon <Isapiro048@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 2:53:13 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: Fwd: Feb 20, 2024 Agenda Item 24-143
I am writing in support of Agenda Item 24-123,Resolution 2023-41, requiring disclosure and
transparency with regard to new regulations for access to library materials. Libraries are
essential to the support of a well informed and educated community. Any changes to current
rules for access to library materials should be made only after full disclosure to the public,
with opportunity for public comment and participation.
The minimally announced changes removing the Teen Section of the library,removal of
materials from the Children's section and limitation of access to materials for anyone under 18
are misguided and fly in the face of the purpose of libraries to provide community members
broad opportunities for education and enrichment. Restrictions for minor's access should be
imposed by parents and guardians,based upon their own values,not those of the City Council
Majority.
Linda Sapiro Moon
Huntington Beach
From: Levin,Shannon
To: sunolementalcomm( surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Fwd:Library
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:04:11 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
From: Becky Weinthal <beckyweinthal@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 2:34:39 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: Library
What makes our City Council the arbiters of what books are in our libraries? Self appointed, self
righteous,political pandering? How about fixing the potholes on Hamilton?
From: Levin.Shannon
To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Fwd:Comment,item#24,2-20-24 CC mtg.
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:04:23 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
From: Dan Jamieson<danjamieson4@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 2:25:36 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) <city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject:Comment,item#24, 2-20-24 CC mtg.
Dear HB City Council:
Please support item#24,Request for Transparency and Detailed Reporting on the
Implementation of Resolution 2023-41 Regarding Library Material Accessibility.
Policies to restrict and ban books in our library are wrongheaded and embarrassing.If the
council majority insists on pursuing these policies,they should not be ashamed in detailing
exactly how they propose to go about it.
Support item#24. Thank you.
Dan Jamieson
Roxanne McMillen
Huntington Beach
From: Levin.Shannon
To: supolementalcommCa)surfcity-hb.org
Subject: Fwd:HB CC 2/20 Agenda
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:04:33 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
From:Cathey Ryder<the4ryders@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 2:21:40 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: HB CC 2/20 Agenda
HB CC 2/20 Agenda
Transparency and Accountability were promised during the 2022 election cycle by those who
were elected to the Huntington Beach City Council. Agenda Item 24 asks for transparency and
accountability. I expect there to be an unanimous vote for this agenda item.
If not,then we know that the council majority has no intention to be transparent or wants to be
held accountable.
Vote Yes on Agenda Item 24.
CJ Ryder
HB Homeowner and Voter
From: Levin.Shannon
To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq
Subject Fwd:Resolution 2023-41
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 6:04:49 AM
Get Outlook for iOS
From: Donna Ryburn <donnaryburn@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 1:36:50 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: Resolution 2023-41
Dear city council,
I have been very disappointed with the direction in which you are taking our wonderful city.
I'm writing to support resolution 2023-41.
Sincerely,
Donna Rybum
9842 La Cresta
Huntington Beach
From: Tim Channel
To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CM0 STAFF);suoolementalcommtsurfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Please PASS Agenda Item 24-143
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 7:16:02 AM
20 Feb 2024
Huntington Beach Council Members,
I am a 35 year resident and homeowner in Huntington Beach. I urge the council to
PASS item 24-143 "Item Submitted by Council Member Moser- Request
for Transparency and Detailed Reporting on the Implementation of
Resolution 2023-41 Regarding Library Material Accessibility".
This is a no brainer. We must have transparency in the implementation of resolution
2023-41. I vehemently opposed 2023-41 but now that it has been passed and is
beginning to be implemented, the citizens of Huntington Beach deserve to know the
details of the aspects of the resolution specified in the proposal.
Thank you for your time and consideration,
Sincerely,
Timothy Channel
Huntington Beach
From: kyogel1Ca)soca.rr.com
To: suoolementaicomm(asurfcity-hb.orq
Subject Agenda item 24-143
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 7:41:53 AM
City Council
My name is Faith Vogel, a longtime resident of Huntington Beach. I served on the
Library Board and the Community and Library.Services from 2007 to 2023. If there is
one thing, I learned in my years of service is that the citizens of Huntington Beach
love and support their library.
I am writing in support of Agenda Item 24-143.to be presented at the February 20,
2024, meeting. This action will provide the clarity needed to implement Resolution
2023-41.
The process of establishing a citizen's children's book review board selecting
children's books needs to be transparent and provide ongoing information to the
parents and citizens of Huntington Beach.
In view of the major impact on library users proposed by the resolution it is necessary
for the City Council to let this agenda item pass.
Thank you, for your consideration.
From: Elizabeth SanFiliopo
To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL,CMO STAFF1;supolementalcomm(a surfdty-hb.orq
Subject: Item 24-143 Support
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 8:02:44 AM
As long term residents who use and appreciate our library,we support the request for a report
on the implementation of last year's item regarding the library. There needs to be a report with
clarity and transparency regarding the criteria to be used as well as a list of the books
impacted.
Thank you for consideration.
Elizabeth San Filippo
From: Levin.Shannon
To: suoolementalcomm(a)surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: RN:Library Concerns
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 8:06:23 AM
From: Elliot Skolnick<eskolnick5@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2024 6:46 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: Library Concerns
Dear City Council:
Something is not right in Surf City! Changes are happening in our fine city, but it seems only a few
people know what those changes are.
Come clean, be transparent and share all information.You have not done this and that is reflected in
the chaos.
Bring honesty and calm to our city and library and do it now.
Elliot Skolnick
Concerned Citizen
From: buzz mccord
To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL..CMO STAFF)
Subject: Moser Transparency Initiative
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 8:22:54 AM
In every endeavor, from parenting to international business to medical device engineering, I
have never witnessed an occasion when transparent sharing of detailed information about
a team project was not essential.
In part, transparency starts with the oldest business wisdom: "Failing to plan is planning to
fail." The dramatic disruption of our very successful library surely is guided by a detailed
plan. What is the written plan?
The currently in-process re-location of books surely has written specifications. What are
they?
The Council decided to create a 21 person committee to review acquisitions. That size
group surely needs written, detailed, specific guidelines based on professional criteria.
What are the new criteria? Who are these people?
Councilperson Moser has provided a detailed framework on which Council could build
transparent public reporting. That 20 February memo addresses all the Council-created
issues that our heretofore highly popular, efficient, and economical library faces. I urge the
Huntington Beach City Council to vote to implement the means suggested.
For sake of simple good business practice and public transparency, this needs to happen,
not in two months, but immediately.
Buzz McCord
Huntington Beach
•
From: Cooper Carrasco
To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF);suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Support item 24-143
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 8:29:45 AM
Hello,
This agenda item,related to resolution 2023-41, is sorely needed by many concerned
community members. We want more transparency. I urge all council members to vote yes.
Show us that you respect the community enough to be open about what's happening to our
libraries behind the scenes.
Thank you,
Cooper Carrasco
From: Dina Chavez
To: suoolementalcommasurfcity-hb.orq
Subject Support 24-143 Request for Transparency
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 8:31:45 AM
Thank you, Councilmember Natalie Moser, for bringing forth agenda item 24-143-Request
for Transparency and Detailed Reporting on the Implementation of Resolution 2023-41
Regarding Library Material Accessibility.
I am deeply concerned about the lack of transparency regarding the implementation of
Resolution 2023-41.As citizens, we should have easy access to information about city policies
and decisions. I urge the council to provide transparency by documenting all decisions and
policies regarding the implementation of Resolution 2023-41 and making those documents
readily available to the public.
Dina Chavez
From: jodvkvlex a(�aol.com
To: suoolementalcomrraa surfcity-hb,orq
Subject City Council Meeting 2-20-2024
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 8:33:00 AM
Dear City Council Members,
I am writing today to express my concern and confusion over the lack of transparency
regarding 1) the new library policies regarding library material accessibility
(Resolution 2023-41) and 2) the apparent violation if the city flag policy on Feb. 19,
2024.
Regarding the new policy restricting access to children's' and teen library
materials (Resolution 2023-41), I don't understand who is deciding which books to
remove from the children's reading area and what they are basing their decisions on.
My understanding is that a citizen's committee composed 21 Huntington Beach
residents would be reviewing and deciding on which children's books should be
removed to the adult section of the library. The committee members would be
appointed by the seven city council members--three per council member. Since then I
have seen books being removed from the children's section apparently without any
review at all. The actual books being removed include books on potty training, Downs
syndrome, and other materials that aren't the least bit objectionable. Furthermore, I
haven't seen any mention of the citizen's library committee being formed or that it
exists at all. WHAT ON EARTH IS GOING ON AT THE LIBRARY?
Regarding the Flag Ordinance...On Feb 19, 2024 an event was held on the city beach
featuring two STOL aircraft that landed on the beach. City council members, the chief
of police, and event organizers then held a press conference. At this conference the
U.S. and Australian flags were flown, see photo below. The display of the Australian
flag was in direct violation of the Huntington Beach Flag Policy. My questions are 1)
who decided to display the Australian and 2) what penalties were imposed for
violating the flag policy. No one is above the law.
,�, •f*"r w :#ter/'," v y 3 • �v�>$' i . $ r g ,c s '4w ..i.
E
,"x°3`3 °ra ,*~ :.j. ... a o fix...e -
9"r
t x.
ry .,
�am aara
x "'� 0?'-`�' •
4e` ..,<.,,..>, ..
a ,u. _M�+.tq j. �t a,. .. .+ ....e fv ate,,, b r!'
.. max, . 7:-
' ' ' ! »` % e} 9J _—
a 're:w .--- - ,> 04;.wry,' " > 4447° � ,,...a, ;,,,,m. s 1.11 ''''''- —
I look forward to your response.
Mary Kyle
Huntington Beach, CA
From: Steven C Shepherd Architect
To: supplementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFFS
Subject: Support for Agenda Item#24
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 8:33:45 AM
Dear HB City Council-
I am writing to express my strong support for Agenda Item#24 (Transparency and Detailed
Reporting on the Implementation of Resolution 2023-41 Regarding Library Material Accessibility).
The simple fact that Resolution 2023-41 was approved without the mandatory transparency and
detailed reporting requested by Agenda Item#24 speaks volumes to the folly of this ill-conceived
and needless resolution and the utter incompetence of the elected officials who pushed through its
original passage.
Steve Shepherd
Huntington Beach 92646
From: flora pedersen
To: 5uoolementalcomm aasurfcity-hb.org;CITY COUNCIL(INCL,CMO STAFF1
Subject: Agenda Item 24
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 8:37:57 AM
I am a thirty-seven year Huntington Beach homeowner. I vote.
I support Agenda Item 24.
I've just learned that the foolish four members of the city council have
shut down the teen section of our library. Gone are the bean bags and
specially curated teen books. The new policy for library cards requires
their mommy's and daddy's permission to check out books of their
choice. Young adults will have a choice of sitting in the cute pirate boat
with little kids in the children's section or sitting at desks in the adult
section. I think they will choose neither and will be driven from the
library. The joy of reading and power to investigate new ideas will be
lost to them.
Secondly, do parents of small children want teens to sit with their kids
in the pirate boat? I say not!
Our teens represent the future of our city. We need to culture
divergent forward thinkers. To grow effective participants in society,
exposure, discussion, and contemplation of ideas are paramount. Public
libraries and freedom to read are sacred for this very reason.
The council majority is stifling the growth of youth in favor of lock step
narrow mindedness.
After asking for nearly a year, I still haven't received a list of books and
materials to be removed or recategorized in our library. Is there a
rhyme or reason for relocations? What are the criteria? What is the
background of the folks who serve on the parent review board? Why is
this information being withheld from the public?
Nora Pedersen
From: Celeste Rvbicki
To: CITY COUNCIL.(INCL.CMO STAFF);supolementalcomm(a surfcity-hb.org
Subject Support of agenda item 24 Library Transparency
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 8:41:46 AM
Hi,
I'm writing to voice my support for and urge you all to pass Councilmember Moser's request
for transparency and detailed reporting of how the city is handling implementation of
Resolution 2023-41. This controversial issue has felt convoluted and deceitful from the
beginning and I just don't think any regular citizens have a clear idea of what is actually
happening in our beloved library systems. I think this motion is well worth the time and
effort.
Thank you,
Celeste
From: Penny Hauoen
To: suoolementalcomm(msurfcity-hb.orq
Cc: Flossie Horgan
Subject: Library books removal
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 8:45:37 AM
We believe that removal of library books from the public library should not be at the discretion of a few hand
chosen people.The criteria for removing books from the public library's collection should meet the needs and will
or approval of the entire community.We live in a democracy with a two party system.A few hand chosen people do
not represent the public.
Respectfully,
Penny and Craig Haugen
Sent from my iPhone
From: Paula Schaefer
To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF);suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Resolution 24-143 re Library Material Accessibility
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 8:49:05 AM
Mayor and Council Members:
It is urgent that you approve this Resolution.
The confusion in the accessibility and location of library materials as a result of the previous
actions regarding the "sexual content" of library materials must be rectified as soon as
possible. It is unfortunate that this is even necessary and is solely as a result of the prior
actions that were taken without any serious plan for the implementation of that ill-advised plan
to "relocate" library materials.
I am in full support of Council Member Natalie Moser's detailed and thorough memorandum
regarding these materials.
Paula A. Schaefer
BB Resident and HBPL patron
From: )oclvn Rabbitt-Sim
To: suoplementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq
Subject: Agenda Item 24(24-143)
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 8:52:27 AM
Dear Mayor Van der Mark and Council Members,
I am writing in support of agenda item 24 (24 - 143), Council Member Moser's request
for transparency in the implementation of the new library policy. Several unwelcome changes
to our libraries have already sprung up unannounced since the implementation of Resolution
2023-41 began. The Huntington Beach Library system has a reputation in California as an
exemplary system of management and service to the community. I fear that our libraries will
suffer in their ability to live up to that reputation, and deliver the excellent service all
Huntington Beach residents and visitors expect and deserve. If this resolution leads to
changes in library policy and operation, we as residents should at least receive access to full
disclosure on operational changes to library function BEFORE they happen.
I'm pleased that Councilwoman Moser has put forth a request for full transparency in the
workings of this resolution. It appears that none of the structures needed to fairly and ethically
carry out this resolution are in place. The public needs to understand exactly what you intend
to do to our libraries and how it will affect our community.
I support all areas of Councilwoman Moser's request. I am disheartened that Resolution 2023-
41 ever passed, because our library system hardly needed fixing in the first place. But since it
did pass on such a slim majority, it is time that you step forward and explain what your true
intentions are and how it will complicate the lives of Huntington Beach citizens.
Sincerely,
Joclyn Rabbitt-Sire
Resident
From: Michael Bledsoe
To: suoolementalcommPsurfcity-hb.orq
Subject Library Restrictions
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 8:59:20 AM
Sorry for the late response.
I oppose the entire slate of restrictions that have been proposed and executed on Library
materials for youth. If there was proof that kids were viewing the materials and acting in
harmful ways as a result,I would feel differently. While I admit that the account of a certain
sex act including "proper technique"was a bit surprising,the great majority of materials don't
nearly reach that level. When we were young we went to the library to see if we could find
some spicy material we heard was contained therein. It wasn't sexy but I know I found some
books that WERE helpful to me to understand how intimate relations are supposed to work.
But they didn't prompt me to go out and try them. I don't think the current crop of kids,who
barely date, are going to be set loose in some bacchanalian reverie because of library books.
Online sources are MUCH more likely to do that.
Sorry to be so general in my references but this issue smacks way too much of a national
agenda about what some are afraid is happening in our schools. I encourage all who have these
concerns to visit schools, without entourages or official title, and see for yourselves.
And remember Footloose from the 80's?These types of restrictions encourage much more
wanton behavior that they stop.It's cliche to say that the police chiefs son is often arrested for
petty crimes and the ministers' daughter sleeps around but, in my experience those things are
much more likely to happen.
So, if you are really thinking of the children, do so without an agenda beforehand.
(ESPECIALLY if it's a MAGA one) and protect our kids in ways that really protects them and
helps them grow.
—Sincerely,
Michael Bledsoe
P.S.Like most of us who oppose these current council actions,I have raised children in this
district(3) and who have used the library.WE have seen how kids really use the library.
From: Levin.Shannon
To: suoolementalcommasurfcity-hb.orq
Subject: FW:Agenda Item 24-143
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 9:02:10 AM
From:Suzanne Hart<hb.diva@yahoo.com>
Sent:Tuesday, February 20, 2024 8:37 AM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject:Agenda Item 24-143
We are writing to you in support of Natalie Moser's Transparency Resolution 24-143. We feel reasonably
sure that you are all in favor of transparency and detailed, clear reporting in city governance! Who
wouldn't be? Please consider this to be a crucial component while contemplating your decision tonight.
Thank you,
Chris and Suzanne Hart
From: Levin.Shannon
To: suoolementalcomm aasurfcity-hb.orq
Subject: FW:Library
Date: Tuesday,February 20,2024 9:02:26 AM
From: Beth Fournier<bethnowbethnow@gmail.com>
Sent:Tuesday, February 20,2024 8:37 AM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: Library
Dear City Council Members,
As a mother of 2 young children I am outraged and grieved to live in
community where some members of its governing body feels it is the city's
right to generate and implement Resolution 2023-41.
This Resolution hijacks the responsibility and privilege that parents have to
monitor their children's reading, leaving decisions regarding the
appropriateness of books to complete strangers. It is not the City Council's
responsibility.
I highly support Council Member Natalie Moser's Request for Transparency
and Detailed Reporting on the Implementation of Resolution 2023-41
Regarding Library Material Accessibility, and urge you to prepare and present
a comprehensive report as requested.
It concerns me greatly that the Council initiated the process of removing and
reorganizing books without a thorough review of the impact this Resolution
will have on our community. Resolution 2023-41 should never have been
passed in the first place.
Signed,
Elizabeth Fournier
Moore, Tania
From: Scott Malabarba <scott@malabarba.org>
Sent: Tuesday, February 20, 2024 9:04 AM
To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF); supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org
Subject: in support of council member item 24-143
Dear City Council,
Once again, I have to than council members Moser, Kalmick, and Bolton for their ongoing integrity and courage. We
appreciate you!
I am writing in support of Councilmember Moser's request for a complete and detailed report on recent changes to the
library's content, physical structure,and policies.
Councilmember Moser's rationale and requests are very well stated-- I couldn't do better here, and every word has my
full support.
Voting this down out of spite will not accomplish anything except to slightly delay the spread of the requested
information. I'm not optimistic about this, but retain some small hope that the council will go forward with this and
maintain a functional, if crippled and censored, library system.
Sincerely,
Scott Malabarba
HB resident
.
Moore, Tania
From: Elaine Parker <epmmrpl @gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, February 20, 2024 9:05 AM
To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org
Subject: Support for Resolution 24-143
I want to thank Councilmember Mosely for her support of our librarians and patrons by asking for clarification of"sexual
content"when it comes to removing books from both the children's and YA sections of our library.
Sexual content is such a broad term. It needs to be better defined-does"sexual content" mean any book that mentions
the word sex,would the dictionary be moved, how about the Bible?
I have seen pictures of some of the books that are being removed and frankly,this is an overreach. Are you actually
removing"Everybody Poops"from the Children's Section-this is a fun and educating book for toddlers.
Please reconsider your term "sexual content" and define it more clearly. Please let the librarians continue to research
books.
Sincerely
Elaine Parker
32 year resident and proud volunteer
1
Moore, Tania
From: Flossie Horgan <horganf@gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, February 20, 2024 10:56 AM
To: Penny Haugen
Cc: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org
Subject: Re: Library books removal
a
On Feb 20, 2024, at 8:45 AM, Penny Haugen <pkhaugen@gmail.com>wrote:
We believe that removal of library books from the public library should not be at the discretion of a few
hand chosen people.The criteria for removing books from the public library's collection should meet the
needs and will or approval of the entire community. We live in a democracy with a two party system.A
few hand chosen people do not represent the public.
Respectfully,
Penny and Craig Haugen
Sent from my iPhone
i
Moore, Tania
From: Fikes, Cathy
Sent: Tuesday, February 20, 2024 1:52 PM
To: Agenda Alerts
Subject: FW: Communication in support of Agenda Item#24
From:Tim Geddes<timgeddes3@gmail.com>
Sent:Tuesday, February 20, 2024 11:00 AM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: Communication in support of Agenda Item#24
Dear Mayor and City Council,
For over a year, the current City Council majority has not delivered on its pledge to bring
transparency and accountability to our local government. It has operated in the dark on City
contracts and settlements. Many in the community may not understand financial and legal affairs
and the kind of disclosures we can expect. However, most, especially parents of school-age
children understand library operations and the impact on their families with what is going on at
our Central Library. They are appalled with new restrictions and restraints on what their families
must go through. They deserve to know exactly the motivations and behind-the-scenes moves
the Council majority is contemplating and implementing without their knowledge and consent. I
fully support Council Member Natalie Moser's Agenda Item #24 to foster the kind of transparency
and accountability that has been denied to the community to date.
As a former educator at the high school level with long experience in motivating and teaching
students about researching, studying, and reinforcing both through dedicated use of our library
and its resources, and as a father of an adult daughter currently working full-time in a well-run
library system (King County, Washington), I know the value of unfettered access and opportunity
to gain knowledge and insight through our library services. My two children attended and
graduated from our local schools (Eader, Sowers, and Edison). My daughter's reading and
studying opportunities allowed her to attend Chapman University and graduate with honors. She
is horrified at what is happening in her hometown.
Please vote UNANIMOUSLY to approve Item 24 on the Agenda this evening to bring the kind of
transparency and accountability we all should want in our planning and decision-making of our
leadership.
Sincerely,
Tim Geddes
Homeowner and Parent
40 Year Resident
i
Moore, Tania
From: Isabella Ford <issyford@gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, February 20, 2024 2:20 PM
To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)
Subject: Support Natalie Moser's request for Transparency and detailed reporting on the
implementation of resolution 2023-41
Council members McKeon, Burns, and Strickland-just be public about the fact that you do not care for any opinions that
might differ from yours. That you do not care to focus on issues that affect all residents like the sewers,streets,
bathroom facilities but instead prefer to divide our city and move books about potty training and puberty away from the
kids that would most benefit from them.
Mayor Van Der Mark has already said she agrees with our library using her personal definition of pornographic material
(using a bathing suit rule?) instead of the academic definition material that depicts erotic behavior
and is intended to cause sexual excitement.
Illustrations of a child pooping is not erotic behavior and is not intended to cause sexual excitement.
I don't understand why you enjoy stoking such negative energies? Why won't you focus on our streets? Talk with Public
Works and understand the budget required to maintain our aging infrastructure and focus your energies on addressing
those problems. Get a plan going for downtown. The lighting and bathroom options are pathetic for such a
destination. Drive our streets and see that even though we have a really good PCI average...note there are a lot of really
bad streets-just look at the small strip of Talbert between Edwards and Springdale which can be a main thoroughfare
for kids going to HBHS.
Stop silencing Moser, Bolton and Kalmick as they were voted in just like you were and represent HB residents as
well. They have raised valid questions and concerns but your solution is to just remove them from committees. Learn
to work with your peers/co-workers. I know Michael Gates has issues with them but remember, he reports to the City
Council. He should be taking direction from you. Not the other way around. It's your job to ask him questions and think
of the city's liability due to his actions.
Isabella Ford
714-308-0660
1
Moore, Tania
From: Judith Lewis <judilew22@gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, February 20, 2024 3:52 PM
To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL (INCL. CMO STAFF)
Subject: Feb 20 Council Agenda Item 24-143
Regarding Agenda Item 24-143 calling for transparency and reporting regarding accessibility of library material, I
support Councilmember Moser's request.
What happened to the citizen committee that was supposed to be making these decisions?Why have no reports
been made public to date as to what is happening?Who is actually making these decisions?
Council members voting for this were adamant this was not book banning. If not,why the precipitous actions
and absolutely no transparency? Huntington Beach City Council should not be an authoritarian government
where the leaders get to do what they want in secret.
You are rapidly earning the name of the "Rogue 4,"accountable to no one.This has got to stop.
Judith Lewis
Huntington Beach Resident
i
Moore, Tania
From: natalie rokos <nrokos28@gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, February 20, 2024 8:05 PM
To: Judith Lewis
Cc: CITY COUNCIL (INCL. CMO STAFF); supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org
Subject: Re: Feb 20 Council Agenda Item 24-143
Very well said.
On Tue, Feb 20, 2024 at 3:48 PM Judith Lewis<iudilew22PBmail.com>wrote:
Regarding Agenda Item 24-143 calling for transparency and reporting regarding accessibility of library material,
I support Councilmember Moser's request.
What happened to the citizen committee that was supposed to be making these decisions?Why have no
reports been made public to date as to what is happening?Who is actually making these decisions?
Council members voting for this were adamant this was not book banning. If not,why the precipitous actions
and absolutely no transparency? Huntington Beach City Council should not be an authoritarian government
where the leaders get to do what they want in secret.
You are rapidly earning the name of the "Rogue 4,"accountable to no one.This has got to stop.
Judith Lewis
Huntington Beach Resident
1
Moore, Tania
From: Lauren Lloyd <laurenashleylloyd@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, February 22, 2024 9:24 AM
To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF);supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org
Dear HB City Council,
I am a mother of two young children living in Huntington'Beach, and I am writing to you today to voice my concern of
Resolution 2023-41. Censoring our public library and the public's access to literary works feels like Nazi Germany,and I
cannot believe this is happening in America, let alone my hometown. It's downright shameful that you are wasting
valuable money,time, and resources on this pathetic attempt to "keep our children safe," or whatever it is that you're
doing.We all grew up in a world where we weren't shrouded from reality, and that's how the world should continue.
What you're doing is disgusting, and I hope you take to heart all of the community members protesting this sad agenda
of yours.
-Lauren Lloyd
310-460-8109
1
Moore, Tania
From: Fikes, Cathy
Sent: Thursday, February 22, 2024 3:15 PM
To: Agenda Alerts
Subject: FW: Mtg 2 20 2024 - Item#24 re "book re-location"
From: Paula Schaefer<pas92649@gmail.com>
Sent:Wednesday, February 21,2024 2:28 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: Mtg 2 20 2024- Item#24 re "book re-location"
Mayor and City Council Members,
I was unable to stay for the entire meeting,to my regret. It was absolutely shameful the way in which item#24 was
handled.
By voting against item#24,the Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem Burns,and Council Member Strickland neglected their duties to
provide the Community and Library Services staff with information to implement the "book re-location" process that
they adopted in Fall 2023.
•
Rather than accepting the information provided by Council Member Moser, Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem Burns,and Council
Member Strickland immediately cast item#24 as an attack or an attempt to attack the "book re-location" process.
Shame on Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem Burns, and Council Member Strickland for your failure of leadership to accept an offer
to assist in a process that is causing so much confusion in the City, is a drain on the Library Staff,and detrimental to the
patrons of the HB Public Library.
And, hats off to Mayor Pro Tem Burns for the "ironic"statement of the evening by asking why the City simply cannot rely
on the librarian's expertise in determining what books get relocated. Mayor Pro Tem Burns,that ship sailed when the
resolution was passed last year.
Paula Schaefer
1
Moore, Tania
From: Fikes, Cathy
Sent: Thursday, February 22, 2024 3:16 PM
To: Agenda Alerts
Subject: FW: City Council Meeting
From: Diane Amendola<diane@sandy-paws.com>
Sent:Thursday, February 22, 2024 8:00 AM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject:City Council Meeting
To City Council
I watched the last meeting and was astounded to see a person with a huge sign of a pedophile performing behind a
speaker at the meeting. The most astounding part is Council members McKeon, Burns,Strickland and the most fearful
of pornography Van Der Mark allowed that graphic display of perversion steps beyond freedom of expression tells me
you really don't care.And your library issues are nothing but grandstanding otherwise you too would have noticed and
stopped it,so I didn't have to turn the TV off until the kids were out of the room.
Diane Amendola
Get Outlook for iOS
1
Moore, Tania
From: Fikes, Cathy
Sent: Thursday, February 22, 2024 3:20 PM
To: Agenda Alerts
Subject: FW: Library Transparency
From: M Abbott<mabbott7437@gmail.com>
Sent:Thursday, February 22, 2024 2:18 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: Library Transparency
Why are you so afraid to detail the definition, method and list of books being moved? I would like to have a response
from any council member other than Casy McKeon.
Michele Abbott
1
Moore, Tania
From: Fikes, Cathy
Sent: Thursday, February 29, 2024 10:01 AM
To: Moore, Tania
Subject: FW: Response to Meeting of February 20, 2024
Attachments: Council Letter for Feb 20, 2024.docx
From:John Carser<jcarser68@gmail.com>
Sent:Wednesday, February 28, 2024 2:15 PM
To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>
Subject: Response to Meeting of February 20, 2024
Letter attached.
1
TO: Huntington Beach City Council.
DATE: February 28, 2024
SUBJECT: MEETING OF FEBRUARY 20, 2024
Once again, I am writing to the Huntington Beach City Council to voice my distain on how the "majority"
conducts business with a lack of civility and decorum. Since Mr. McKeon was absent from the meeting on
February 20, 2024, specifically I can only focus and direct my observations to Mayor VanDerMark, Mayor
Pro-Tern Burns, and Councilmember Strickland. As is the case recently in this city, political "snafus" are
the common practice of the "majority"when difficult issues are presented and even tougher decisions are
voted on. In particular, I would like to reference the Request for Transparency and Detailed Reporting on
the Implementation of Resolution 2023-41 Regarding Library Material Accessibility that were explained
by Councilmember Moser in a clear, concise and reasonable manner to provide a framework—especially,
when the city and its people are entitled to understanding any legal language, guidance and protection that
may be supported by municipal codes. My interpretation of the dialogue was that the "majority" of those
in attendance did not listen to the rational proposal presented nor to the community's consideration
expressed at the podium. In fact, the three "majority" members at the dais appeared bored, uninterested
and distracted. I strongly speculate that they decided before walking into the Council Chambers the
direction they plan to take-despite the community's input. (The only time Tony Strickland became
attentive to a presentation is when his MAGA promoters spoke.) When the brave high school students
who spoke so passionately about the library, you did not have the courage to hear or to respond or to
assimilate their concerns as sophisticated, mature young people who aspire for successful careers,
community vision, and embracing diversity. The only representation "the Fab Four" continue to display is
that of"smoke and mirrors"with the same rubber stamp!
In over fifty years, there's never been a problem with the books offered at any one of our libraries. What
might be next on your extremist agenda: burning books outside the central library to exhibit your power
and ignorance; visiting our six high schools to evaluate the curriculum being delivered; banning cell
phones for children 7-17 years of age? The Council cannot continue overstepping its boundaries by taking
on the role of a responsible parent. (I have personally experienced the actions of oppression in a police
state during visits to Iron Curtain countries years prior to the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989, and I also
observed the social control during visits throughout China under communist rule—preserve our freedom!)
I do not need a response from the "majority" rule because I have NO CONFIDENCE in their ability to
lead appropriately. Good local governance requires objective attention and action, compromise, fiscal
responsibility, efficiency, integrity, research, creativity, transparency and accountability. Instead, lies and
deceit appear to be your ruling mantra; and, you can't fool anyone with arbitrary and unverified numbers
that blast the audience from your bully pulpit! Leave your MAGA hats at home, silence your political
preference, get out of the way of State and Federal legislation, stop the frivolous lawsuits, and do what is
best for the citizens of Huntington Beach. Feel free to share this with our "overpaid" City Attorney,
Michael Gates, as I have NO CONFIDENCE in him either! His comments and explanations are
inarticulate, vague and self-serving which leaves the audience in a fog of confusion. The "Fab Four+
One" is a poor excuse for leadership in OUR city.
John Carser