Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
HB Public Library - Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsourc (2)
�NTINGr 2000 Main Street, o��-->�etip Huntington Beach,CA 926 �,„ City of Huntington Beach DENIED 3-4 48 k 9 s• 2 ��cFiQNNTY C�\�oe (STRICKLAND,BURNS, VAN DMCKEON-NO) File #: 24-350 MEETING DATE: 5/7/2024 Item Submitted by Council Members Bolton, Kalmick, and Moser - HB Public Library: Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsource (Charter Amendment) and Postpone/Terminate RFP Process Until After Vote Direct the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting: 1) A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2) An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting. City of Huntington Beach Page 1 of 1 Printed on 5/1/2024 powereeI 'LegistarTM 6..... CITY OF _; HUNTINGTON BEACH =�oUN.... City Council Meeting - Council Member Items Report To: City Council From: Rhonda Bolton, City Council Member Dan Kalmick, City Council Member Natalie Moser, City Council Member Date: May 7, 2024 Subject: HB PUBLIC LIBRARY: VOTE OF THE PEOPLE TO PRIVATIZE/OUTSOURCE (CHARTER AMENDMENT) AND POSTPONE/TERMINATE RFP PROCESS UNTIL AFTER VOTE ISSUE STATEMENT As City Councilmembers,we are elected to be stewards of the City,the People's Treasury and its assets. We serve four, maybe eight years, but the City continues on without us.We receive the baton, do our best and then pass the baton to the next group of resident-leaders.We should take great care when contemplating actions that would leave an indelible mark on the City's history. Over the last dozen months,we've documented more than a thousand pieces of correspondence from residents,and have had dozens, if not hundreds, of other conversations with concerned parents and library patrons about the future of our public library. We have very little actual information about what privatization or outsourcing library management would look like since Huntington Beach is unique in its current operation of its library system.We're not leaving a county library system to stand up our own system like almost all libraries that have explored outsourcing.We don't have a programmatically broken library with low circulation and low foot traffic. And with the discussion of outsourcing,which would mean loss or reduction of their pension and likely decreased wages, our award-winning library team members are already seeking jobs elsewhere or have resigned.Just the process of contemplating a change is directly and negatively affecting our library. Because privatization/outsourcing represents a monumental change to a City institution that has existed for more than a century before the current City Council majority came on the scene, and this is a wholesale change to how the most heavily utilized, public-facing portion of the City Government is managed,we propose asks the Voters this November what they want. We propose two items for consideration in November: 1) A Charter amendment that would require a majority vote of the people if this or any future council seeks to make a wholesale change to the library's management structure—in the spirit of Measure C for our parks and beaches; and, 2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach,CA 92648 I www.huntingtonbeachca.gov 911 2) An advisory vote as to whether the current electorate of the City of Huntington Beach wants a change to the library's current management structure under the framework proposed by this Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Because the election is less than six months away,we also request that the City Council table the requested and still uncirculated Request for Proposals(RFP) until after the people have spoken in November. RECOMMENDED ACTION Direct the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting: 1) A Charter amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library,and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2) An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL;a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP)as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting. 2000 Main Street,Huntington Beach,CA 92648 I www.huntingtonbeachca.gov 912 From: Sharon Cahoon To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF);suoDlementalcomm()surfdty-hb.orq;Parra,Eric(CM);Gates.Michael Subject Kalmick,Moser,Bolton resolution on May 7 agenda Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 5:22:23 AM Please vote for this resolution. Let the voters decide. SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION 5/7/2024 Meeting Date: 30 (24-350) Agenda Item No.; From: Tracy Luth To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF);suonlementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Agenda items Library and campaign signs Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 6:07:01 AM Let it be known that I support city council members Kalmick,Moser, and Bolton in putting the library privatization issue before the voters.Let the citizens decide how we maintain and manage our valued city resource. In addition, I support Councilperson Kalmick in retiring the practice of allowing campaign signs on city property. Sincerely, Tracy Luth Sent from the all new AOL app for iOS • From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject FW:NO to outsource the management of the libraries to a private company Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 10:24:23 AM Original Message From:Athena<kams24@gmail.com> Sent:Wednesday,May 1,2024 9:37 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>;dan@dankalmick.com Subject:NO to outsource the management of the libraries to a private company Hello city council members,I am not sure to whom I need to address this email to,but I am a Huntington Beach resident and have been going to the Huntington Beach libraries from the time I was child,going to the reading time, studying there as a high school and college student and even now as a 36 year old adult. I love the art,the selection of books,the tranquility of the whole place.Not only is the library beautiful outside,it is also beautiful inside as well AND clean(even in the restrooms).Please do NOT outsource the management of the library to a private company,there is NO need for the library management to be outsourced,who even brought that terrible idea up?! Please keep current management the same,they are doing a fantastic job.Also need I remind what happens when you have a private company manage,first they make sure THEY get paid,then they set up their own rules and then we the people have no more say on what they do,they start charging for things that could be free(or a low amount) and they are not transparent in most things and only look to one thing:profit first to themselves and THEN to the library.Outsourcing management will not save money nor will we be getting the same type of service we get now,it will just allocate money to different pockets and cause less money to go to library resources.I want my future children to be able to enjoy the library just as it is,please don't have a management company who doesn't really care about the people of Huntington Beach run one of the most beloved places in Huntington.Please don't change something that's already working,let the people vote on whether this should happen or not,We are the ones who use these facilities!I already know I will vote against this ridiculous idea.I agree that staff need to CEASE any further work on RFP to run HB public libraries until they have heard from the voters in November.I say NO TO PRIVATIZATION OF LIBRARY MANAGEMENT. Athena karns Karns24@gmail.com Sent from my iPhone From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alert Subject FW:Oppose Outsourcing Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 10:24:42 AM From: miguel reynoso<reynosomlj@yahoo.com> Sent:Thursday, May 2, 2024 12:35 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Oppose Outsourcing I hereby emphatically oppose your proposal to outsource the city of Huntington Beach public library's services, and fully support their stance on this absurd, ludicrous proposition. Attentively, Miguel A Reynoso From: Pikes,Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: RN:Huntington Beach Library Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 10:27:18 AM Original Message From:Linda Pohl<2travelinpohls@gmail.com> Sent:Thursday,May 2,2024 9:10 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Huntington Beach Library Our City Council has already shown how eager they are to put issues on the ballot for the public to vote on. Our Library has been and continues to be a major resource and help to many residents before most of you lived here. Literacy is the keystone of society and the fact that several of you have admitted they have never having gone to the library until recently speaks volumes about your ability to decide what is appropriate for our library. Also keep in mind that voting for three Council seats is coming in November and this will be a major issue for many voters.Do you want to be known as the Council that puts possible?profits above constituents? Let Huntington Beach residents use their Voices to vote for or against keeping their library controlled by Huntington Beach and not a private equity for profit company. Thank you, Linda and Walter Pohl Sent from my iPad From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Keep our libraries public! Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 1:11:03 PM From:Clara Mora<claraismora@gmail.com> Sent:Thursday, May 2, 2024 9:21 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Keep our libraries public! To Whom it May Concern, I am a resident of Huntington Beach and I would like to express my opinion in advance of the 5/7/2024 city council meeting. I am against outsourcing our public library and believe it should remain public. I am against privatization. Thank you, Clara Mora HB Resident From: CHERIE SLOAN To: suoolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 1:21:00 PM I support our wonderful library staff and am strongly opposed to the proposal to privatize the library. Sincerely Cherie Sloan Joseph Tabet Sent from my iPhone From: Trudy To: suoolementalcommV surfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 1:24:26 PM City Council Representatives, Here is an opportunity to prove to the people of HB that you are truly listening to the will of the people. Let them speak with their vote...much like the one you forced on the Match ballot regarding the Charter. Show you truly care about this city. So far it seems like you YOUR agenda is the only agenda. People are waking up to what's going on. Do the right thing! Trudy Roe Sent from the all new AOL app for iO$ From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Public Library Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 1:40:43 PM From: Kathleen Deemer<kdeemer@magnoliasd.org> Sent:Thursday, May 2, 2024 7:01 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Public Library City Council Members: As a citizen of Huntington Beach and an avid user of the library, I urge you to keep our library public. Myself and many citizens of HB do not want our library to be handed over to a private source. I have many concerns over this, as I am sure you are aware. Turning over the library to a for profit company will adversely affect the services provided by the library and adversely affect our community. I am very concerned that the library will have to shorten hours, lose librarians and do other things to cut cost and make a profit. The city needs to maintain control of the library and continue to make it a place were the community can learn and thrive. Please listen to the citizens of HB,who you represent and do not make the library private. Thank you. Kathleen Deemer From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject FW:Outsourcing Library Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 1:40:55 PM From: Melanie Audy<mrmochismom@gmail.com> Sent:Thursday, May 2, 2024 8:13 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Outsourcing Library Dear Representatives, I am in opposition of our library being privatized. My family& I love our central library so much that we brag about it to more family&friends,even inviting them to join us there as our guests. I've lived long enough to know that change is inevitable, necessary even.The balance to that is keeping precious&important things the same. Our library as it is now is a refuge in our ever-changing world, please keep it that way. Library Lover, Melanie Audy 3355 Tempe Drive Huntington Beach From: tikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject FW:I oppose library outsourcing Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 1:42:02 PM From: Krystal White<krystalwhite916@gmail.com> Sent:Thursday, May 2, 2024 9:29 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:I oppose library outsourcing I'll keep this email short-Stop meddling with the library, it's running fine as it is. Krystal White Downtown resident, parent, and library patron From: pikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject FW:NO!Privatization Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 1:42:29 PM From:Christina Skoski <chris.skoski@gmail.com> Sent:Thursday, May 2, 2024 10:27 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: NO! Privatization I'm a long time (49yrs) resident of Huntington Beach and am appalled at the idea of privatization of our public library. Our library does so much more than just lending books, it is a real asset to the community. There is no way that an outside, for profit company would offer anything close to these services. It is so obvious that the current city council is pushing this simly for political reasons and publicity. It has nothing to do with saving money. Their actions are bringing such bad publicity to our city's reputation. Shame of them. We will remember this at the next election. NO TO PIVATIZATION!! Christina Skoski MD From: Neill Kelly To: suoolementalcomm(a)surtcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 1:46:38 PM As a Huntington Beach tax payer I support the charter amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library,and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings.I also support an advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL;a replacement of the current management structure,as proposed by the City Council at its March 19,2024 meeting.Finally,I'd like to direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals(RFP)as it relates to the action taken at the March 19,2024 meeting. Kelli Kelly Kelli Kelly kelli@kelly.ws From: Natalie Zifcak To: suoolementalcommCalsurf ity-hb.org;Van Der Mark.Gracey;Kalmick.Dan;Gomez.Charlene;McKeon.Casey Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 1:48:22 PM Hi. I fully support Agenda Item 24-350-requiring a vote before there is an RFP for our library. I don't want to privatize it,and think it's important to decide that first! Before spending time and money on the RFP process. Please allow our city residents to vote on this matter. Thanks, Natalie Zifcak From: Steven Christy To: suoolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq Subject Support item#24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 1:58:37 PM Do turn our libraries over to a private company!! Sent from my iPhone From: Ron Maa$ To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.org Subject Don"t privatize the library Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 2:01:19 PM Stop the nonsense! Sent from iPad Ron Maas From: Claudia Ross To: suoolementalcommesurfdty-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 2:01:56 PM We have been residents of Huntington Beach for almost 50 years. We do NOT want our wonderful library privatized!! We want a vote!,m We support Agenda Item 24-350!!! Sincerely, Noel Ross Claudia Ross From: Ron Maas To: suoolementalcommesurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Stop wasting our money Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 2:01:59 PM Don't privatize the library! Sent from iPad Ron Maas From: Linda Clark To: suoolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq Subject Library Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 2:16:19 PM Leave the library to be operated as it is. I don't want any changes to be made in the operation of the Library. It provides many things to the community,not only to HB residents but also to the surrounding communities. Thank you. Linda Clark From: Gerald Donohue To: suoolementalcommesurfaty-hb.org Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 2:22:55 PM I am supportive of item24-350. If we can have a vote on hanging a flag, isn't it possible to have a vote of privatizing a public entity? From: JESSICA DQYLE To: suoolementalcomm(Msurfcitv-hb.orq Subject: Support our library Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 2:24:06 PM Hello Huntington Beach City council, I am writing to urge the council to NOT privatize the library. The library is a fundamental establishment in the community and provides countless resources for the youth of this city. I have spent countless afternoons here with my daughter teaching her how to read,write, and creating lasting memories of the beautiful storytimes in the children's section. It is sad that all of the funding and grants the library is receiving would be put at risk. It seems as if the city council does not really want to better the community;they only want to line their pockets. PLEASE KEEP OUR LIBRARY PUBLIC AND KEEP THE FUNDING AND VOLUNTEERS COMING!!!!! SIncerely, Life ling Huntington beach Resident Jessica Doyle From: Thomas Meisenhelder To: suoplementalcomm(thsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 2:25:43 PM Good Afternoon, Please rescind the Library RFP process until there has been a popular vote on the matter. Most of us love our library! Yours, Tom Meisenhelder 20271 Sealpoint Lane Get Outlook for iOS From: David Wetzel To: suoolementalcommC)surfcity-hb.orq Subject Please allow the HB public a say in the HB Public l ibrary"s business model Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 2:26:02 PM Dear Huntington Beach City Council Members, City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk, Good afternoon and happy Thursday. As a 50+year Huntington Beach residents, we would like to encourage the HB City Council to allow the residents of HB to choose the business model for our library. We feel strongly the Council is running at manic pace to enact a long term Library privatization policy that will undoubtedly have unforeseen cost and quality impacts, likely causing the City's taxpayers additional expenses to correct down the road. We respectfully ask the HB Council to allow the residents of HB to determine a best business model for our library. The agenda item 24-350, submitted by Council Members Bolton, Kalmick, and Moser-Calls of a vote of the people to privatize/outsource the Huntington Beach Public Library and postpone/terminate RFP Process until after the vote makes sense and gives ALL 7 Council Members the opportunity to listen to the voice of the residents at the ballot box. The HB Library should not be partisan political issue. David and Kristine Wetzel 9082 Bobbie Cr. HB CA. 92646 From: Ginnv Bean To: suoolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.arg;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAF9 Cc: Ginnv Bean Subject: Agenda Items 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 2:51:49 PM Dear City Council, I support the agenda item 23-350 shown below for the people of Huntington Beach to decide on the fate of our Library. You added Charter Amendments to the last ballot for Measure A/B/C because you felt that the citizens of HB should decide. This Amendment should be voted on by the citizens also. It appears that certain City Council members and our Mayor make their minds up before listening to the citizens that send in emails (like myself) and the people who attend the meeting or speak. All the emails and speakers seem to be falling on deaf ears. This amendment would allow the people to decide not the City Council. Sincerely, Virginia Bean 714-325-5240 Direct the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5,2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting: 1)A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2)An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party I contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP)as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting. From: Catherine Schwartz To: suoolementalcomm a(lsurfcity-hb.orq Cc: Dan Kalmick Subject Support Agenda item 24-350 library Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 2:51:56 PM I,Catherine Schwartz,HB resident,support the postponing till the people vote or terminating the RFP regarding the management of the public library! I am against privatization of the HBPL.I support agenda item 24-350.I have signed the petition to support the HB library.Three family generations in our family enjoy the current library.I saw the opening of this main branch and hope our city council keeps it open by our community volunteers(Friends of the Library)and professional staff& librarians maintaining it,not political appointed individuals or a private management company. Catherine Schwartz 722 Sandglass Dr. HB.,CA 92648 • From: Lou Ann Hobbs To: suoolementalcommPsurfcitv-hb.org Subject Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 2:57:55 PM TO: The City Council I support Agenda Item 24-350 requiring a vote of the people to privatize/outsource the Huntington Beach Public Library and postpone/terminate the RPF process until after the vote. The Huntington Beach City Council may lose the current oversight and direction of Library Services Under Privatization of the Library. I fear that the Council's ongoing concerns and influence over the contents of the library, appointment of Citizen Committees, and other such actions may not be allowed by a private company which contracts to manage all aspects of the Library. With grave concern, Lou Ann Hobbs. Huntington Beach resident From: Mary Thompson To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Privatization of the Library Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 3:01:10 PM While I am unable to attend the May 7th City Council meeting, I wanted to take this opportunity to voice my very strong objection to any changesto our current library structure of operations. I am requesting that the City Manager cease any further work on the Request for Proposals as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting. I further request that the city of Huntington Beach electorate have the opportunity to vote on any proposed changes. This should not be a council only decision. It's too important. Mary Thompson City of Huntington Beach Resident From: Betty Kanne To: sunnlementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Agenda Items#30 and#29 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 3:02:59 PM 5/2/24 Council Members, Vote yes to approve May 7,2024 City Council Agenda Items#30 and#29 These are reasonable, even handed solutions to two quite different issues that are extremely vexing to our beautiful, once tranquil community. Agenda Item#30 (Library management outsourcing-put it on the ballot) -Abandon the short-sighted push to cede operational management of our award winning municipal library to a venture-capital backed third party company whose mandate would be to squeeze 20%of our taxpayer dollars into their own east coast venture capital owner's coffers. If you feel there is"waste"of HB taxpayers' dollars in the library budget,then work with current management to identify where efficiencies could effectively be made. Interestingly, HBPL is currently one of the most fmancially efficient libraries in the state. Outsourcing its management is fiscally unsound. Let the voters' voice be heard on the November Ballot on this important issue. Do not ignore the voice of your constituents. Agenda Item#29 (Unfettered Political Election Signage equals Visual Blight) Literally: Clean up our streets! Deescalate the alarming arms race of defacing the public places in every corner of our city during each election season with inescapable,wasteful,misleading, incendiary, anger-banners. I, for one,avoid inviting out-of-town guests to Huntington Beach in the months leading up to an election because of the trashy,hateful, disturbing visual cacophony that is an eyesore to the observer and an acute embarrassment to our residents. It is an inescapable affront to our beautiful community.Further, as a vacation destination it severely erodes the visual aesthetic impact of our city to outside visitors to whom this chaotic visual clutter impacts adversely, leaving a highly negative lasting impression. It is greatly costing our city both directly and indirectly. Do the right thing. Make it go away. Submitted by, Betty Kanne Huntington Beach (40+year HB resident,homeowner, unfailing voter) bettykanne@hotmail.com From: Chris Hail To: sunolementalcommCalsurfoty-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 3:05:41 PM Please do not support Agenda item 24-350.I do not want this supported.I am a tax paying HB resident for 25 years and I would like my request to be counted! Christine Hall 21401 Pinetree Lane HB,92646 Sent from my iPad From: Jim Fivash To: suoolementalcomm4surfcity-hb.orq Subject: In Support of Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 3:07:12 PM Members of City Council: I urge you to: Direct the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting: 1)A Charter amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2)An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting.Additionally direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19. 2024 meeting, James C. Fivash, PLS 18601 Newland St#128 Huntington Beach, CA 92646 From: demartino To: suoulementalcommCThsurfcitv-hb.orq Subject Agenda 24350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 3:08:19 PM Please vote in favor of 24-350. The library is too important not to allow the public to weigh in. Thank you. Valerie Demartino Sent via the Samsung Galaxy S9+,an AT&T 5G Evolution capable smartphone From: nimannioneverizon.net To: suoolementalcomm aesurfcity-hb.orq Subject Library system of HB • Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 3:09:38 PM As residents of HB for over. 45 years, my husband and I would be very disappointed to see a change in the management and operation of our library system. It would be heartbreaking to lose the many services we now enjoy such as Makers Space, genealogy section, gift shop, gallery for local artists, and most importantly diminishing the research section and stacks of books we now enjoy. I'm sure the city can find a better way to conserve money in lieu of chopping at an asset that so many citizens of HB appreciate. Norma Jean and Jerry Mannion 6782 Spickard Drive Huntington Beach, CA 92647 • From: Barbara Shapiro To: suoolementalcommt@surkaty-hb.orq Subject 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 3:13:57 PM I support agenda item 24-350. Any changes ro our public library should be subject to a charter amendment. Let the people vote. Sent from my iPad From: Jennie Austin To: Puoo!ementalcomm4surfcity-hb.Qrg Subject Do not privatize the library management!! Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 3:15:35 PM Dear HB City Council members and City Manager, I agree with Council members Moser,Kalmick and Bolton.We need a city-wide vote to decide the future of our beloved public library!!Thank you! Regards, Jennie Austin HB resident Retired teacher Library volunteer FOTL member 10 years VOTER!! Sent from my iPhone From: dfarmer nx.netcom.corm To: suonlementalcommasurfcity-hb.orq Subject: I support HB LIBRARY Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 3:16:43 PM Sent using myEarthLink From: phil Collins To: suoolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 3:17:28 PM Please reconsider privatization of our public libraries.We have been using our library for many years and are members of"friends of the library".Our system works very well and we strongly support keeping our library the way it is.Phil and Sylvia Collins, 19217 Seabrook In,Huntington Beach,ca 92648 Sent from my iPhone From: Lisa Swanson To: supolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 3:37:07 PM Dear City Councilmembers, please let the City residents have a say on whether our beloved public library is privatized. I've been a loyal library patron for years and almost always have a book checked out. I am also a Friend of the Huntington Beach Library so this is a very important issue to me. Please give me a chance to cast my vote. Regards, Lisa Swanson 14+yr resident SE Huntington Beach From: Andrea Rousseve To: suoalementalcommCasurf ltv-hb.orq Subject: Support our public library Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 3:56:20 PM I support our Public Library and do not it to be private!! I have been a resident of Huntington Beach for 51 years and have used our Public Library during all those years with no problems. Sincerely, Mary Rousseve 20441 Clearwood Circle Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Sent from my iPad From: Diane Makas To: suoolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq Subject: not in favor Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 4:02:51 PM I do not support the privatization of our libraries as it is not a cost-saving move, it is a left- wing hidden agenda that is driven by personal opinions and beliefs. It is a total infringement of my constitutional rights and I cannot wait to vote you out of office! Diane Makas Resident and retired teacher HBUHSD From: Brian Kleeman To: suoolementalcommCla sur city-hb.orq Subject: Library propsal. Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 4:05:41 PM I still say no privatization. Sent from my T-Mobile 5G Device Get Outlook for Android From: LeeAnn Corral To: suoolementalcommaa surfcity-hb.orq Subject KEEP OUR LIBRARY PUBLIC Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 4:08:47 PM Why pick on our libraries?You should be inspiring community members not dividing them. LeeAnn Corral Sent from my iPhone From: Alexandra Adams To: supolementalcomm(alsurfdty-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 4:29:40 PM Hi there, I am a constituent and a mom who loves our library. I've always been a library lover and the HB libraries, especially Central,are exceptional. Story time is incredible, it's more than just a story being read. If you've never been,there are songs, educational interludes that focus on early math and literacy skills, and then an art project at the end that ties it all together depending on what that week's theme is. I am so proud of our library and it is considered one of the best in OC.Nothing should be done to change that.Libraries are about community and should reflect the community within which it resides and serves. Our current library has over 900 volunteers who joyfully give their time to make our library what it is. If the library becomes run by a for-profit,private company,I fear those numbers will significantly dwindle if not disappear entirely. I'm also a lawyer and I understand what the current council majority is trying to do. However, I request the city manager, city attorney, and city clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and all materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5,2024 ballot for the General Election. I also ask the agencies for a vote at the June 4,2024 City Council meeting these same items.These items are: 1.A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City council and a majority vote of the electors of HB to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and 2.An advisory vote of the electors of HB on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting. Privatizing our libraries will take away so much from HB. It has been shown that libraries run by companies like LS&S only focus on popular titles and get rid of lesser known authors or books. The whole point of the library is that it has everything! If you want the popular books, buy it on Amazon. I also have concerns for the library staff. While I know there is a law signed in 2011 preventing privatizing library operations from agreeing to contracts that would cause library staff to lose their jobs, wages,benefits, or hours, I have concerns with the history of LS&S,the leader in library privatization. In 2017 the company was penalized almost$70k for wage and hour violations. It is known to devalue staff and the skills librarians possess.LS&S also shows away from any discourse with the public which is a huge concern for those of us who regularly frequent the library. We want to be heard and we want our opinions to matter. Individuals who cannot afford fees or a private membership will completely lose access to the thousands of books in the library, and the growth and knowledge that comes with access. Libraries are a refuge, a place where anyone can go for some peace, or to find community, or to gain enlightenment. Our libraries are so vibrant right now. If the current majority got their way, it would dim the light within a huge portion of our community. Please don't do that to HB. While the city may save a pittance by going private,the community massively loses out. Be better. Alexandra Adams From: Sharon Cahoon To: suoolementalcomm(@surfaty-hb.orq Subject Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 4:29:54 PM I totally support this agenda item. From: Jeanne Whitesell To: suuolementalcomm@)surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 5:09:28 PM Dear City Council Members, I'm contacting you to advise you that I am in full support of the Huntington Beach Public Library and Agenda Item 24-350.\\ thank you. Jeanne Whitesell 17922 Shoreham Lane H B 92649 Virus-free.www.avast.com From: The Silversteins To: suoolementalcomm(alsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 5:40:34 PM Dear Members of City Council: As a 44-year proud resident of Huntington Beach,a mother and a grandmother,I would like to urge the acceptance of Agenda Item 24-350 to allow for a Charter Amendment that would require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the management of the library,and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor.Our library has been in existence for over 100 years.It is a wonderful system that meets the needs of all our residents.It's working well and I cannot see why ANY changes are needed. Thank you for your consideration. Deborah Silverstein From: Anna Morrison To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support for Huntington Beach Public Library and Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 5:59:40 PM I support the Huntington Beach Public Library and Agenda Item 24-350. Thank you, Anna C. Morrison From: Lisa Marin To: suoolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq_ Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 7:03:50 PM I am writing to express my strong support for agenda item 24-350 to allow the voice of the people of Huntington Beach to be heard. The privatization of the now public library is a serious concern that must be determined by those who use its facilities and services-and pay for its operation. Thank you. • Sincerely, Lisa Marin Huntington Beach, CA "The cure for anything is salt water:sweat, tears, or the sea." Isak Dinesen From: Jisa radvanskv To: suoolementalcommCa)surfcity-hb.orq Subject agenda 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 7:10:32 PM Please support this agenda.Leave our library as is. They do a fantastic job and shouldn't be subject to political plays. Thank-you,Lisa RadvanskyMosley.Mobile Registration Services. Business/homeowner since 2001. Respectfully yours.Lisa. From: Alyda Kuntz To: suoplementalcommCla surfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 7:16:22 PM To whom it may concern, Please do not privatize our public libraries. They are one of the greatest resources this city has. My children and I greatly enjoy going to the library to checkout books and all the supplemental programming they provide. I find it extremely hard to believe that privatizing them would leave this programming unscathed. Sincerely, Alyda Kuntz 8262 Darsy Dr Huntington Beach Get Outlook for iOS From: Patricia Frangente To: suoDlementalcomm(asurfoty-hb.orq Subject Public libraries Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 7:37:45 PM Sent from my iPhone Patricia Frangente From: Wendy Franked To: suoplementalcomm5 surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 7:59:05 PM Please do not privatize your fabulous libraries.Your libraries are an amazing asset in your community.The wonderful people that work in your library are needed to continue the great jobs they are doing in your community. The Friends of the Library want to continue to support your libraries. Thank you, Wendy Frankel Friends of the Huntington Beach Library Sent from my iPhone From: Rasha Conn To: suoolementalcomm4surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Hbpl Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 8:05:50 PM Dear city council members, I am writing to object to what you are doing to our public library.I support the library being public and not to privatize it.You should ask the community what they want.You are making a lot of changes that are not to benefit our city and I object to the job you're doing. Sent from my iPhone From: Barbara Scott To: suooiementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 8:44:59 PM I am a long-time resident of Huntington Beach and use the library at Central Park all the time. I encourage my students to read by taking out books for them because their parents don't have the time to take them. So, I truly hope that those of you wanting to privatize this wonderful library are doing everything you can to make sure it will benefit the most people. The library is busy all the time. so it is definitely an asset to our city. I've done some research on the internet to look at the pros and cons of going private. I read a survey done in Colorado about going private and this is what they came up with. An analysis of the survey comments showed that nearly three-fourths (73%) contained pro-public management sentiments, while close to one-fourth (23%) were either pro-private or discussed alternatives to the black-and-white, public-versus-private debate. For example, several respondents suggested incorporation as a private, nonprofit entity (such as the New York Public Library) or implementation of business practices into libraries' current management structures. I thought this was interesting about the NY Public Library. Perhaps this is the way to go with our library? There were also some cons to it such as becoming a 501C3. The NY Public library is a private, non-governmental, independently managed, nonprofit corporation operating with both private and public financing.1 • To,register as.a:nonprofit corporation,the organization typically needs art►c`les of 1 incorporation, by-laws, and;an initial group of trustees or officers. • "Once registered as a nonprofit corporation, an organization may become a 501©(3}..This is a federal tax status granted by the IRS. It allows donations to the charitable business;to be tax-deductible for donors s • The:process to become a 501'0(3)can be"cumbersome°"and""time consuming, often requiring legal assistance. • Public libraries that are government agencies can receive donations and these donations ._ >are tax-deductiblefor donors without needing"501©(3)statusl:. „? I watched a city council meeting on the television and heard our mayor say she had found some almost pornographic books in the middle school section.That really surprised me so was discussing that with several mothers who are very involved in their churches so want their kids to be raised in a faith based family. I was shocked when they said that most kids look up stuff worse than that on the internet, so it shouldn't be that big of a deal if it is in the library! I'm also surprised that the librarians would consider these healthy for that age. Have the members who want this change in how the library is run, interviewed the librarians and asked what their views are of these types of books? Perhaps they were bought many years ago and haven't been considered for their content in today's world.Any mention of censorship immediately creates havoc in our divided world. I think it would be more democratic to allow Agenda item 24-350 be passed and then the choice be on the ballot in November to let the citizens decide. Sincerely, Barbara Scott From: judo aaalionq To: suooIementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 9:06:04 PM I do not want "our"public library to be privatized. Leave my library alone!!! From: Frances Soencer To: suoolementalcommCla surfcity-hb.orq subject: Support Agenda Item 24350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 9:41:18 PM To start allowing people with an agenda decide what books we may read,what news we may watch, which religion we must follow is a dangerous path that leads to an oppressive, untenable society. Please leave our successful library alone. From: Carol To: suoolementalcomm(alsurfcity-hb.org Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 10:00:46 PM —Carol(sent from my iPhone, sorry for any errors!) From: Carol Shi To: suoolementalcomm(alsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Thursday,May 2,2024 10:01:01 PM From: )udv Standerford To: suoolementalcommCa�surfcity-hb.orq Subjeth Agenda Item 24-250,May 7,2024 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 5:15:38 AM I am writing in support of agenda item 24-350. Please vote in favor of this item. The Huntington Beach Public Library is too important to the community for a decision such as privatization to be made by four people who are not familiar with all that the library services provide. The library users—the taxpayers! —should have a say in this decision. The discussions and support thus far are definitely in favor of keeping the library public. To have this resource decimated by an uninformed, small minority of the citizenry is not democratic. To justify this action by saying we need to save money is completely indefensible. We can save much more money by asking the city attorney to stop filing unwinnable lawsuits. On a larger note —we live in a democracy governed by a constitution. The constitution guarantees free speech. Pulling books from the library shelves is NOT democratic or free speech. Free speech means free speech for everyone whether you agree with them or not. As has been explained over and over again —there are many safeguards in place to keep YOUR child from reading what you don't want them to read. But that does not mean that MY child has to live by your same exclusionary, divisive and fundamentalist views. From: Andrew Einhorn To: suoDlementalcomnasurfcity-hb.orq Subject: For City Council Members Date: Friday,May 3,2024 5:56:12 AM HB City Council I support Agenda item 24-350, Stop destroying our Library and do not privatize. Sincerely, Andrew Einhorn 40-year HB resident From: Lorri Woods To: suoolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.org Subject: COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 24-350 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 5:59:06 AM I support the agenda item to keep our libraries public! Lorri Woods HB citizen Get Outlook for iOS From: Eric Smith To: suoolementalcomm aasurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Public Library Support Date: Friday,May 3,2024 7:22:14 AM Hello, I want to voice my strong opinion that the Huntington Beach Public library should remain as is, handled by the city. Part of the joy of raising my children in this city is that our local libraries are staffed with folks that are part of our community. Hiring an outside staffing agency is a massive detriment to the community here in Huntington Beach. Sincerely, Eric Smith 805-794-4045 From: James Davis To: suoolementalcommesurfcity-hb.arg Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 8:00:50 AM Hello, My name is James Davis and I live a two minute walk from the main street library.I'm writing to ask you for your support to maintain our library system the way it is.When I first bought a home in Huntington I was so mortgage poor that I couldn't even afford Internet and the library was our family choice for entertainment.We love our library! Thanks for your consideration, James Davis Sent from my iPhone From: Shari Austin To: supolementalcomm(alsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 8:42:32 AM Dear HB counsel- I have researched other towns that have allowed privatization of their libraries,and see NO benefit for Huntington Beach to go this route. The financial impact is only part. Please don't spoil one of the best libraries in California. Leave it to our volunteers to continue the good work. Thank you! Shari Austin Sent from my iPhone From: Evan Oxhorn To: suoolementalcomm(alsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Don"t Privatize the Library Date: Friday,May 3,2024 9:41:56 AM I love the library as is. It is a beautiful space for all HB residents to enjoy,with a great selection of books and programming that directly improves the community. I'm also very concerned about the appearance of corruption with this proposal. It seems like a corporate handout for politically connected insiders.There is no need to privatize. At a minimum, this should be up for public vote. Evan Oxhorn evanoxhorn@gmail.com (760) 815-0929 From: Nancy Bioda To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcily-hb.arq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 10:47:18 AM I am in FULL SUPPORT of Agenda Item 24-350, that the PEOPLE should decide if OUR LIBRARY should be privatized and it should be put on the ballot on November 5th. Also the city manager should cease any further work on the RFP, Request for proposals. Nancy Bigda From: ddsorae@cs.corn To: suoolementalcomm@surfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 12:15:45 PM Honorable Huntington Beach City Council, The citizens of HB are the proud owners of our library, it is not owned by a small group of fleeting city council members who seem to assume sole authority. Privatization is a significant & impactful step; community consensus is paramount. In response, a critical and wide outcry has occurred, put it to public ballot measure and vote. The broad and richly diverse community of HB has the right & obligation to determine this major action. It is far too important to be maneuvered in quick impulse by a paltry few, particularly in view of the extraordinary long and fine duration of library operations. Better yet,wise up and end this foolhardy act. Our remarkable library and its varied resources are the wonderful realization of prodigious time & effort, cherished in vision &dedicated in excellence. It is a grand and admirable community asset where cultural enrichment is its only focus. Never was it intended to be managed as a private, for-profit enterprise, our forefathers would not be pleased. Now a contingent of entitled council propose to speedily toss library management to a private firm, likely non-local, a firm motivated by earning incentives, prime modus operandi - profit. Would staff excellence and dedication as it now exists continue under profit based private management, categorically not. Would staff enthusiasm, the natural joy of public service in sharing knowledge flourish under the repercussions of private gain? No,the quality of staff would diminish, it is a resistant force. Library funding is publicly resourced which is wholly transferred in quality and service back to our community. Enabling an intermediary profiteering will only squeeze public enhancement, over time the gears of private earnings would grind away its uniquely precious essence. The "public' library has evolved into a unique cultural oasis, like a grand social philanthropist selflessly & perpetually giving, its priority humanitarianism, altruism in its finest form. As a profit driven resource, it would regress below esteemed principled & practice ideals. Do not degrade the noble 1731 tradition of Benjamin Franklin and the uniquely unbiased norms held by libraries nation-wide & globally. Do not commodity and bastardize this precious jewel of the people. To be crystal clear, among our librarians many managerial and care responsibilities under their purview, foremost is simple yet profound, it is to increase well-being as much as possible and for as many people as possible. Our librarians meet this high standard & their commitment to fine public service is laudatory. The meager cost is well worth the richness given universally to all our residents, young, old, rich & poor equally, our most precious resource. Privatizing services compromises that, stop this action. David Sorge 8165 Dartmoor Drive, HB From: Isabella Ford To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CM0 STAFF)suoolementalcomrrasurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Please cancel the RFP to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL Date: Friday,May 3,2024 12:16:52 PM If you still want to explore hiring a third-party contractor to operate HBPL,then support council agenda item 24-350. Our library is amazing because of the people that have been working and volunteering there. Listen to those that work and volunteer and understand that this RFP the four have requested at the March 19th threatens so much that is positive about our city. Isabella Ford 714-308-0660 From: martha bergman To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.org Subject: Agenda item 24-350 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 1:22:20 PM I strongly support the Huntington Beach Public Library and Agenda Item 24-350. Please at the very least give the people of this city the chance to vote on whether or not we want a privatized library, or any significant changes to our library! Prove that you value the voices of your constituents. Sincerely, Martha Bergman Huntington Beach resident for 57 years From: Patricia Robitaille To: suoolementalcommCla surfcity-hb.orq • Subject: Do not allow library to be privatized • Date: Friday,May 3,2024 1:43:33 PM .We are teachers and are in support of libraries and are totally against switching to a third party. This issue has to be put on the ballot so all voters can make the decision one way or another.The HB council should not be allowed to make the decision. Rich&Pati Robitaille • From: Linda Moore To: suuolementalcomm4surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 1:48:08 PM I am emailing to let you know I enthusiastically support Agenda Item 24-350. From: SUSAN MORABITO To: suoolementalcommi surfdty-hb.orq Subject: I support a vote of the people on whether to privatize/outsource the Huntington Beach Public Library and postpone/terminate RFP Process until after the vote. Date: Friday,May 3,2024 2:14:55 PM Susan Morabito From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:In support of agenda item 24-350 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 2:29:27 PM From: Krystal White<krystalwhite916@gmail.com> Sent:Thursday, May 2, 2024 1:28 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) <city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: In support of agenda item 24-350 I'm another supporter of agenda item 24-350. I'm expecting another canned response from Casey and for the 4 to vote against it as they don't seem very interested in public input and likely have their minds made up.Writing to share my support of 24-350 anyway. From a parent whose kids have been enjoying the library since they were tiny, I want to thank those that do listen and that want to protect our city's most valuable resources. Krystal White From: pikes.Cathy To: agenda Alerts Subject FW:Agenda Items#30 and#29 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 2:32:09 PM • From: Betty Kanne<bettykanne@hotmail.com> Sent:Thursday, May 2, 2024 3:02 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda Items#30 and#29 5/2/24 Council Members, Vote yes to approve May 7,2024 City Council Agenda Items#30 and#29 These are reasonable, even handed solutions to two quite different issues that are extremely vexing to our beautiful, once tranquil community. Agenda Item#30(Library management outsourcing-put it on the ballot) -Abandon the short-sighted push to cede operational management of our award winning municipal library to a venture-capital backed third party company whose mandate would be to squeeze 20%of our taxpayer dollars into their own east coast venture capital owner's coffers.If you feel there is "waste"of HB taxpayers' dollars in the library budget,then work with current management to identify where efficiencies could effectively be made.Interestingly,HBPL is currently one of the most financially efficient libraries in the state. Outsourcing its management is fiscally unsound.Let the voters' voice be heard on the November Ballot on this important issue.Do not ignore the voice of your constituents. Agenda Item#29(Unfettered Political Election Signage equals Visual Blight) Literally: Clean up our streets! Deescalate the alarming arms race of defacing the public places in every corner of our city during each election season with inescapable,wasteful,misleading, incendiary,anger-banners.I, for one, avoid inviting out-of-town guests to Huntington Beach in the months leading up to an election because of the trashy,hateful, disturbing visual cacophony that is an eyesore to the observer and an acute embarrassment to our residents.It is an inescapable affront to our beautiful community.Further, as a vacation destination it severely erodes the visual aesthetic impact of our city to outside visitors to whom this chaotic visual clutter impacts adversely, leaving a highly negative lasting impression.It is greatly costing our city both directly and indirectly.Do the right thing.Make it go away. Submitted by, Betty Kanne Huntington Beach (40+year HB resident,homeowner,unfailing voter) bettykanne@hotmail.com From: Pikes.Cathy To: Aaenda Alerts Subject: FW:Agenda Item#30 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 2:32:34 PM Attachment: imaae6.onq From: Lily Jacinto<lilycabrera@msn.com> Sent:Thursday, May 2, 2024 8:27 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda Item#30 Hello Dan Kalmick, Natalie Moser, and Rhonda Bolton, I'm writing you about Agenda Item#30, do you feel these pornographic books (Gender Queer, Let's Talk About It, etc) are appropriate for young children? As a parent and grandmother, I do not think these pornography books should be available to young children! It's inappropriate for young children to check these out.These books should be in a separate secured area of the library.Just like movies have Ratings,these books should as well. R-Restricted, NC-17 No one 17 and under admitted,clearly adult,children are not allowed, PG-13 Parents strongly cautioned and PG- Parental guidance suggested. If a parent wants to check out one of these books for their child it's their right, but it should be the parent's discretion and NOT the librarians. So with that being said, if Kalmick, Mosser and Bolton believe these porn books are ok, I dare you to bring them to the meeting and read them aloud while showing the community some of the graphic illustrations.This way you'll get a feel for how the community feels about these books. Kind regards, Mrs.Jacinto PS: Even Facebook found these graphic porn illustrations (from the books noted below)offensive, took them down and said they contained: Nudity or Sexual activity a f 4 4 g d'' :'. ,rr ®xe E & r. r F P '" ----'-`-'"--. -- „"--,'",N,;4';lif-'. L ..w+un A tl,ram ti � d p ➢`^ e --....7A.m--i..:./FC-!'-:t i.,F.:;4,•--t.•.',.",kf!':.&*;i,1liw.i6i‘t*l:.:eltf.:fi".t.5i.:t!c-AtA.:..r::n4:-.,::.;.i 0i-t:i.,1.-:.ti..::-,.,1,1:..,1.,,1t„.,-.4,,,,1:„g'4,'v,,?4.4.".;„.„41,-,,!rd,i.-.n 1„',i„..,.iit,'-. -A-6I:',.•.,••.•,t1,P',,1-44!,f!T'"Pt1......i:i.t"'.i.iJ.:'..k....',,4.,„z-.*..„..i.l711:!it1-'..;:'-'..'4....x..:,,,i iv-..::„:,4:'..!:,-,o..\...r..:,-,,:',',,'(.:'-;.V'..!,.,.*.t..L,?,.g.,.,..,-,.-,:_-:.J..•:-:,o•AK'.1...:...--..,A,i:.,1.4.',0.:,l:.;,i1,..?::t,..il,0...,f,iI, 0:,,tt.0!,.,0:,-,P.,;.4!•..:4l-,i:fp.t)..-„:t;".:-,„,:,*.7:..,,:4i(.:i,',:,-,.;,°,',„1,7-,6..,7.',.-g,,"1:1,'.,,,,:.•,,77,,;,,7.-:,,i7:,'1o.:..;,,::':':';'''i,..,i.:.,..,t":.o'.4,,,-7:nit ii.:,,.4i.et,.,.,t..?t,;T.,,,:1..ft1Zr.:„1i:!P::„::,.,6,.i,fk,i3,A1,i41+,,4,.0;1-,1VM../5..:r...,::!'.::.:t-..; .. , 5\qy ,i; Ftit*1N111l,.R:-,;4:%i.'.!...:t1..:";.!::-..i-: j 4 6 � �. T 1 €k 1 1 ,�: k s F . 44. ; "' fr • iell • rr i4.` � y k e ....r w. � h a" _'a ,. .,..,..„.. „:„.,...„._ _ „, , _ ..,.,,,_, ,,,,,, .,"„,,,,,,.,,,"..4, .„:„..,,„ ., .,,:,,,;„„,,., y JiiillflF 41j 3 "� % ,',5 `•vi.1-8:4.le "%,;..!„° + _i s Ki•it%:::!.,4:41:1 'i' '.,:- • Ylz_ y 1 " 'ts- d i0_$� PF g V.T. .'+' iolli £ ken tx! lailatla CD �,� ° . z 1 A iz ��`...iiiiiilli l i 3 • at. D"� Yt' ! y a 3. �{ 11 g �' Y CC 711 } roppolvep g ai From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Please support putting privatization of our library on the ballot Date: Friday,May 3,2024 2:32:46 PM Original Message From:Julie Ford<fordsjjt@gmail.com> Sent:Thursday,May 2,2024 10:20 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Please support putting privatization of our library on the ballot City council As a 40 year citizen of Huntington Beach I strongly support our library system We value the opportunities provided as well as the services My sister lives in Escondido were privatization occurred. They are not happy If you continue to push this issue let the citizens you represent choose on a ballot Thank you.Julie Ford,DDS Julie From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:May 7,2024-Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 2:32:54 PM From:Judy Standerford <judystanderford@gmail.com> Sent: Friday, May 3, 2024 5:17 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: May 7, 2024-Agenda Item 24-350 I am writing in support of agenda item 24-350. Please vote in favor of this item. The Huntington Beach Public Library is too important to the community for a decision such as privatization to be made by four people who are not familiar with all that the library services provide. The library users—the taxpayers! —should have a say in this decision. The discussions and support thus far are definitely in favor of keeping the library public. To have this resource decimated by an uninformed, small minority of the citizenry is not democratic. To justify this action by saying we need to save money is completely indefensible. We can save much more money by asking the city attorney to stop filing unwinnable lawsuits. On a larger note —we live in a democracy governed by a constitution. The constitution guarantees free speech. Pulling books from the library shelves is NOT democratic or free speech. Free speech means free speech for everyone whether you agree with them or not. As has been explained over and over again —there are many safeguards in place to keep YOUR child from reading what you don't want them to read. But that does not mean that MY child has to live by your same exclusionary, divisive and fundamentalist views. From: Fikes.Cathy To: Aoenda Alerts Subject: FW:Support Agenda Item#30 for Charter Amendment Date: Friday,May 3,2024 2:33:17 PM From: Diana Lithgow<lithgownp@aol.com> Sent: Friday, May 3, 2024 10:03 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Support Agenda Item#30 for Charter Amendment Dear Huntington Beach City Council Members, I support Agenda Item#30 that would place a Charter Amendment on the November 2024 General Election Ballot to let voters decide whether they want to turn over management of our PUBLIC libraries to a PRIVATE,FOR PROFIT corporation. Thank you, Diana and Douglas Lithgow 19841 Flagstone Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Homeowner since 1984 Diana Lithgow,PhD,DNP,RN,FNP-BC, FAANP Professor of Nursing College of Graduate Nursing Western University of Health Science 909-469-5523(CGN Office) ,DLithgow@WesternU.edu From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:I Support Agenda Item#30 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 2:33:29 PM From:Clare Lithgow<clarekapin@gmail.com> Sent: Friday, May 3, 2024 10:13 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: I Support Agenda Item#30 Dear Huntington Beach City Council Members, I am in support of Agenda Item#30 which would place a Charter Amendment on the November 2024 General Election Ballot to let voters decide whether they want to turn over management of our public libraries to a private corporation. Kind regards, Clare Lithgow 8441 Dallas Cir. Huntington Beach, CA 92646 From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Proposal to have citywide vote in November on library issue Date: Friday,May 3,2024 2:33:42 PM From: Linda Peterson<linda17612peterson@gmail.com> Sent: Friday, May 3, 2024 10:18 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) <city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Proposal to have citywide vote in November on library issue This proposal should pass next Tuesday 7 to 0 as it is to the advantage of all. A citywide vote in November is important. This library issue is just as vital to the citizenry as the vote on building the Senior Center was a few years back. All the council members should exercise good sense on this one next Tuesday! From: Fikes,Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: RN: Library proposal for next Tuesday"s meeting Date: Friday,May 3,2024 2:33:48 PM From: Linda Peterson <linda17612peterson@gmail.com> Sent: Friday, May 3, 2024 11:12 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Library proposal for next Tuesday's meeting The library proposal for the meeting next Tuesday is a very good one that should pass 7-0 as it is to everyone's advantage. A citywide vote on the November ballot to settle the library issue absolutely should take place. This issue is every bit as important as the vote of the HB citizenry a few years back on building our Senior Center-probably more important. Let's have all our council members exercise good judgement next Tuesday! From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: RN:Comment for.Item 30 on May 7th,2024 HB City Council meeting Date: Friday,May 3,2024 3:19:07 PM From: Monika Goodwin<monikagoodwin@verizon.net> Sent: Friday, May 3, 2024 3:17 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Comment for Item 30 on May 7th, 2024 HB City Council meeting Dear City Council Members, As a Huntington Beach citizen and home owner I sincerely ask and request that you NOT plan on a Charter Amendment to privatize our public libraries, and also NOT to place this amendment on the Nov. 2024 election ballot. Thank you Monika Goodwin and family HB From: )aura sire To: suoolementalcommi surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 3:20:24 PM Dear HB City Council Members, This is Laura Sire, long time resident of Huntington Beach. I'm writing in strong support of Agenda item 24-350. The long-standing successful operation of our Huntington Beach Public Library System deserves a vote by the population of its residents. As our Public Libraries are a cornerstone of free speech and democracy, a political body should not decide what is clearly under the purview of the people. Please honor the citizens of Huntington Beach and place the matter of the operation of our Libraries on the ballot for the general election in November. Thank you for your consideration, Laura Sire From: Leslie Golson To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CM0 STAFF)suoolementalcammcasurfcity-hb.orq Subject Agenda Items 24-337 and 24-350 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 4:25:57 PM To Huntington Beach City Council, I am in favor of Agenda Item 24-337, the sign code update. Campaign signs have been a blight on our city for far too long. Please follow examples of other nearby cities by restricting the size campaign signs and limiting them to private property only. I am in favor of Agenda Item 24-350. Let voters decide whether they want to privatize the library on the November 2024 ballot, and postpone the RFP process until after the vote. I would also like to honor the life and work of Shirley Dettloff, who gave of herself tirelessly to the city of Huntington Beach. Thank you, Leslie Golson Resident From: Carlos Rubio To: suoolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Item 30 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:55:21 AM Honorable Mayor and City Council, Teamsters Local 911 and the Huntington Beach Municipal Teamsters (Huntington Beach City Workers) continue to be grateful for the opportunity to serve the constituents of the City. We are committed to continue to keep up the maintenance and improvement of quality of life that makes the City of Huntington Beach a great place to live, work and play! Today we recognize our dedicated, educated, and experienced library services staff members who serve this community day in and day out without interruption. We would like to remind you that our library services staff members are champions of intellectual curiosity, leaders of discovery and stewards of lifelong learning. Our Teamster library staff professionals continue to be committed to fostering a love of literacy and learning while serving diverse populations with a myriad of needs. Our members are residents, homeowners, taxpayers, voters, parents, and supporters of many community volunteer efforts. Today we urge you to do the right thing and vote yes to provide authority and direct the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at the June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting: 1) A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2)An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024, meeting. The time is now to show with actions honesty, dignity and respect for your hired professionals who serve this community excellently, our Teamsters Library staff professionals and the Library staff as a whole! Respectfully, Carlos I. Rubio President Teamsters Local 911 SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION 5/7/2024 Meeting Date: 30 (24-350) Agenda Item No.; From: Lorraine Gayer To: suoolementalcomm(a�surfcity-hb.orq Subject RE:Agenda Item 24-350,May 7 Huntington Beach City Council Meeting Date: Friday,May 3,2024 5:29:39 PM May 3,2024 Lorraine Gayer 16682 Lovell Lane Huntington Beach,CA 92647 Jgayer@a msn.coni To:Members of the Huntington Beach City Council Gracey Van der Mark,Mayor Tony Strickland Dan Kalmick Rhonda Bolton Casey McKeon Pat Bums Natalie Moser I am a resident and voter in Huntington Beach.I have lived(and voted)here since 1970. I am writing you to urge you to give the voters of Huntington Beach a voice in deciding whether it is in the interest of Huntington Beach to transfer/outsource management of our public library to a private for-profit corporation. It is my understanding that a charter amendment measure and an advisory vote/cessation of Request for Proposals action(Agenda Item 24-350)have been placed on the agenda for the next City Council meeting on May 7,2024.Those measures would give the voters of Huntington Beach a voice on this issue.I urge you to support those measures. Personally,I strongly oppose efforts to transfer the management of Huntington Beach's libraries away from local control.I find it ironic that a council majority(and the City Attorney)who normally couch their actions in local-control language now seek to transfer management of our Huntington Beach libraries away from local control to control by a for-profit corporation located far from our city. This is personal for me.I have spent countless hours in the Huntington Beach Central Library.I've read books there,graded student papers there,researched and written my master's thesis there,volunteered in the literacy program there,and on and on.This is my library. My connection to this library is personal. The Huntington Beach Public Library is the city's most beloved(and used)resource.It operates efficiently and economically.Our librarians and staff are respected and beloved by the community.I would remind you that it is your obligation to the citizens of this city to protect the library rather than to weaken it. Lorraine Gayer • SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION 5/7/2024 Meeting date: 30 (24-350) Agenda Item No.; From: )udv Brusslan To: suoolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq Subject Supplemental Communications for HB City Council Meeting on May 7.2024 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 5:42:34 PM Attachments: jmaae00l.onq jmaae002.onq I would like to comment on two agenda items. First, I urge approval of 24-337. I agree that non-commercial signs should be prohibited in our public rights-of-way.This would stop the competitive rush for wall space and resident complaints that force code enforcement when signs are placed in dangerous locations or are torn down or defaced. Non-commercial signs should be displayed on private property. Private citizens vote and are welcome to respectively share their opinions. Second, I urge approval of 24-350.The proposed privatization of the Huntington Beach library system has no clear justification and will harm our libraries while costing taxpayers more money.This decision should be brought to a vote by the citizens of Huntington Beach.The City Council does not take into account the voices of people who provide supplemental communication and/or attend council meetings.The ratio of comments opposed to privatization are 4:1 over those in favor. I support a vote of the people for our libraries. Thank you, Dr.Judy Brusslan Professor of Biological Sciences Bridges to the Doctorate PI California State University, Long Beach AAAS Fellow AV WELLNESS. AMBASSADORevertiAt : LTY,tay ' From: aelliott1Calsocal.rr.com To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Coundl Mtg.5/7/2024 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 6:06:47 PM I support Item 24-350.The management of our public library and its branches should not be outsourced to the highest bidder nor be further pressured to do so by partisan lobbyists and/or self-aggrandizing censors. I also request that the Council demonstrate a Policy of Human Dignity by moving the COMMENTS AND MOMENT OF SILENCE TO HONOR THE PASSING OF FORMER MAYOR SHIRLEY DETTLOFF to the beginning of the meeting following the invocation rather than tacking it on at the end as if little more than an afterthought. Mrs. Dettloff deserves better. Cheryl Elliott(Huntington Beach resident since 1980) From: Denny Family M To: suoolementalcommAsurcity-hb.org Subject Agenda item 24-350,submitted by Council Members Bolton,Kalmick,and Moser Date: Friday,May 3,2024 6:44:42 PM We vigorously support agenda item 24-350 and we call for the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting: 1)A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2)An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally,we want the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting. Marvin and Karen Denny Huntington Beach residents From: Michele Burgess To: suoolementalcommAsurfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL CMO STAFF1 Subject Agenda Items 29 and 30 for 5/7/2024 Meeting Date: Friday,May 3,2024 7:17:35 PM To the City Councilmembers: A man, a complete stranger, walks up to my 77-year-old friend who's attending a peaceful sit-in at Central Library and asks her to tell him about her vagina. Meanwhile, an obnoxious pony-tailed man wanders around with a megaphone bellowing that the protesters (many of them senior citizens) are pedophiles and perverts. When the police arrive, he loudly asserts his First Amendment rights, tells the officers he had a 3-hour meeting with Chief Parra, his wife works in the City Attorney's office, and he was assured that he can say whatever he wants. Apparently, he didn't mention it would be through a megaphone, which (according to the two officers) is prohibited. At a recent City Council meeting, several raucous people clap and cheer when a tearful long-time librarian announces her resignation due to ongoing harassment by ignorant people calling her pedophile, pervert, groomer. A candidate for City Council waves around an award-winning children's book and yells into the mic, loudly insinuating that a sitting council member is a pedophile for reading the book to his 4-year-old daughter. A Proud Boy verbally attacks a sitting council member in the audience at a Library Commission meeting, calling her names and shouting obscenities (and is not removed). This same Proud Boy rambles incoherently at other Council meetings, showing explicit visuals and flipping off people in the audience on his way out. Decorum? Not so much. These people obviously feel comfortable behaving this way because they're mirroring the intolerance, bigotry, and conspiracy theories perpetrated by the majority four on our City Council, and appear to have their tacit approval. Is that what you really want to be known for? Numerous articles in numerous news outlets seem to think so as we get an awful lot of awful coverage. You should read it sometime to see how Huntington Beach is really viewed now. It's not pretty. The so-called "press conference" certainly didn't improve our image. Gracey whined about how Mexicans are certainly smart enough to get a voter ID. Strickland seemed to be stumping for a California Senate seat. Burns ranted about "conc... reeducation camps" in our future if Governor Newsom has his way. McKeown was a no-show. And the minority three weren't even invited to participate. But Mr. Gates was there, bloviating about how we'll fight for our charter city rights on voter ID, now that we've once again been sued by the State. I live for the day when we're not making news for all the wrong reasons. Now to the two agenda items I'm most interested in. Agenda Item 29 — Amending the Sign Code. Let's not head toward November with yet another overabundant clutter of giant, brightly colored, distracting campaign signs plastered over every inch of open space along every street and highway. The months leading up to the primary election were the very definition of visual blight. Candidates for the November election should never have been allowed to put up signs in January. Mr. Gates clearly overstepped in a very weaselly manner by allowing this travesty, ignoring the true intent of the city code regarding campaign signs (stating it says an election, not specifying which election). I strongly urge you to pass Agenda Item 29 to update the sign code for non-commercial signs in the.public right-of-way. We've been talking about this for years, now is the time to finally do something about it. And while you're at it, revise that item to specify that campaign signs can be posted only 50 days before the event (election) to which the signs relate. That's a no-brainer. Agenda Item 30 — Privatization of the Libraries. There's no good reason to rush into library privatization, or even an RFP for it. Have you actually done any research? Hundreds of people have written opposition letters that you seem to totally ignore. For a step this large, it makes sense to put it to a vote of the people. You received positive input from only 26% of registered HB voters, in a primary election with very low turnout, which is definitely not a majority. The wise, prudent, fair thing to do would be to put it to a vote in November, and get everyone's opinion. Four people should not be taking it upon themselves to make such a drastic change to our library, against all common sense and certainly not to save a little bit of money or to punish people who don't agree with you on censoring what we can read, or allow our children to read. If you think you're doing the right thing, you shouldn't be afraid to put it on the November ballot. The cowardly way would be to stubbornly push ahead, ram it through, damn the consequences. Which will you choose? Ms. Michele Burgess HB resident since 1961 From: Jheaan Gibbs • To: suoolementalcommsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Please Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Friday,May 3,2024 8:10:23 PM To City Council Members: I am an elementary school teacher who grew up visiting the Huntington Beach library as a child. Libraries have always been, and should continue to be, safe community spaces where the public can access information. I strongly oppose privatization of the library and potential censorship of content by a private entity. Public librarians are trained professionals and should be trusted to do their jobs. The library is already operating at such a small percentage of the city budget, and the library workers are community members.Privatization removes our tax dollars from the local community and puts it in the hands of a profit driven,private equity firm with no obligation to transparency. Please support the Agenda Item 24-350. Thank you for your consideration in this matter. Megan Gibbs From: Taylor Jennings To: suoolementalcommCalsurtcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CM0 STAFF) Subject No 24-350 Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 7:08:56 AM I don't support the item submitted by Bolton/Kalmick/Moser. The Union sheep are out to scare people that privatization of a library means the library services will change.Nearly every aspect of business the private sector is far more efficient and cost effective than the public sector. The people have already voted for our elected representative officials. Thank you as well for protecting our children. Taylor From: Janelle Krulv To: suoolementalcommasurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 7:50:12 AM Dear City Council, I've been a Huntington Beach resident for 14 years.I'm 35.When I first moved here after graduating from Chapman,I found our beautiful parkside library to be so awe-inspiring.Look at all of this FREE knowledge,I thought.Since then I've used it as a place to meet my goals,studying for and preparing my presentation for a job certification,completing job applications,and perusing the book collection and artwork displayed as a means of comfort,solace and hope for opening me to new ideas.I've been so impressed by the seed library as well as the resources provided im the back room.I wish that I could volunteer with the literacy program.The theater is also so important to our community and I attended church there for years as well. The librarian staff have always been so friendly and helpful.They've also done a great job of improving digital resources and I was also so impressed that they did away with fines-just bring your book back when you are ready for the next. The library is SO valuable to our community.We are all willing to support it with our taxes.We don't need you to try and pinch pennies from this sale.I've also joined the Friends of the Library group and would be happy to contribute more to them to support our library if it needs it.I would NOT donate to a private company.The public commenters are right,we already have a book store.We need to keep our library a library. Please don't allow this bid for private companies.We know that it's a hoax to support the former mayor's company. There's only one service in the country.And no other OC city or county library is privatized.Let's value our librarians and our education and our community and not SELL this to a business.The change would hurt public library employees and cut off their pensions.Please don't take away important programs like the Makerspace,Vet Center,Literacy programs,and Geneology Lab. Please don't vote for this change.If you do,I promise you will not have my vote in the next election. Sincerely, Janelle Kruly From: Lyn To: suoolementalcommesurfcity-hb.org Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 8:01:51 AM Honorable City Council, I support item 24-350. To change our wonderful library from being public with access to the grants we have gotten and the grants we are applying for to private would not be a good choice. Some of the grants we have gotten are the seed library, state park passes, preschool busy bags, state park backpacks. in house chromebooks, hotspots to check out to name a few.A private library will not be able to afford these amenities. Our patrons tell us how much they love what we have to offer. In addition we provide programs through grants for all ages.We love being able to provide these special programs for the children,teens and adults.A library is much more than books. The current staff is welcoming and well trained in order to be helpful to all who come in. To make any changes to our beloved library should be put to a vote of the citizens of Huntington Beach. It is unfortunate that it can't be voted by the patrons who use it who live in neighboring cities and counties. Thank you for reading this. Lyn Scott. Abraham Lincoln. "It is better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to open ones mouth and remove all doubt." From: Irma Loper To: suoolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 9:02:38 AM Please vote in favor of Agenda Item 24-350. Save our beloved Huntington Beach Public Library! From: sumivataCalamail.com To: sunolementalcommCasurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Agenda Item 30 Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 9:39:58 AM I am a 44-year resident of Huntington Beach.I wholeheartedly support Agenda Item 30,submitted by Bolton, Kalmick,and Moser which would require a vote of the people to privatize/outsource the HB Public Library.It would also postpone/terminate the current RFP process until after a vote of the people. Please pass this Agenda item. Thank you! From: Helen McCaffrey To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 10:03:31 AM As a former educator and avid reader, I am appalled at the idea to privatize the library. Recent changes in the availability of reading material as well as the attempt to further control the readership of our community is a step back in time and an invasion to our civil liberties. From: ROSE SAYUIN To: suoolementalcomm( surfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 10:25:52 AM I support agenda item 24-350.Please do not privatize our wonderful libraries. Rose Saylin Sent from my iPhone From: Helen Lee To: suoDlementalcommfa)surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Do not outsource library staff Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 12:18:08 PM I have lived in Huntington Beach for over 15 years.The library and HB librarians have been a very positive impact on my family. I don't support the outsourcing of the library staff and support the matter to the Residents of Huntington Beach for a vote. Best regards Helen Lee 16818 Barracuda Lane HB CA 92649 Sent from my iPhone From: Doris Larson To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Cc: Van Der Mark.Gracev;Bums.Pat;McKeon.Casey;Strickland.Tony Subject: Privatization of our library Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 12:19:09 PM Dear.Mayor and CounciC3vlembers, As a citizen of Huntington Beach for more than 5o years, the privatization of our library has me very concerned Our library is a public institution and shouldremain as such. This move will decimate the volunteer program. 'Who will-possibly volunteer at a privately run institution. The library heavily relies on volunteers. Please put this poorly though out idea in front of the voters of Huntington Beach. Doris Larson From: Karen Chaney To: supolementalcomm(Thsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Privatizing our library Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 12:23:47 PM PLEASE do not go forward with this unpopular amendment. I am a 51 year resident of this city and in my opinion,this is THE most self serving and destructive action ever proposed by a sitting council. To go forward with this amendment without any input from the people you serve is unconscionable! It is obvious by the recent council meetings that the MAJORITY of residents do not support this! Additionally,the fact that it is financially beneficial to a former council member and friend of our current acting mayor reeks of collusion! From: Debbie Clark To: suoolementalcomnasurfcity-hb.org Subject Vote Yes for Agenda item 24-350 Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 12:46:20 PM I vote Yes to Agenda item 24-350, submitted by Council Members Bolton, Kalmick, and Moser- Calls of a vote of the people to privatize/outsource the Huntington Beach Public Library and postpone/terminate RFP Process until after the vote. A Thank you to Council Members Bolton, Kalmick, and Moser! Debra and Steve Clark From: Paula Schaefer To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CM0 STAFF)supolementalcomm(alsurfc!ty-hb.orq;Gates.Michael;citv.manager(@surfdty- hb.orq Subject May 7,2024;Agenda Item#30 VOTE YES on 24-350! Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 2:47:16 PM Mayor, City Council Members: VOTE YES on 24-350! As a 30+year resident of the City, consistent voter, regular HBPL patron,I urge you to vote unanimously to 1) stop the RFP process underway; and, 2) allow the City's residents decide whether to continue the current excellent management of the HBPL, or to privatize or outsource its management. In mid-April,I attended the Community and Library Services Commission meeting at which the RFP for privatization or outsourcing was discussed. Why this topic was agendized AFTER the City Council had already voted on the RFP was a source of confusion to everyone.It was apparent that the Commission members did not understand what would or would not be included in the RFP. If you haven't already done so,you should read the Commission's minutes where you will see that most attendees were against the RFP process by a significant margin! Last week,I spent several hours at the Central library asking patrons if they were aware of the possible "outsourcing" or "privatizing" of the library. Very few patrons were aware of this potential action by the City Council. When I explained that the staff could be replaced by employees of a private company,nearly all of the 25+people I spoke with were against the idea and mentioned how pleased they were with the existing management of the library and the staff. The City's residents have made it abundantly clear that they care deeply about the fate of the HBPL. The vast majority of the written communications and speakers have eloquently articulated their many wonderful experiences in the library and the continued value that it provides to the City and the surrounding community. You should consider it an honor to uphold the value of the HBPL and not simply look at the library as a "cost center" of the City. Do the right thing for the community and let the voters decide how the HBPL should be managed. Paula Schaefer From: H Meyers To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF), Subject May 7,2024,city Council meeting:Agenda Item#30 Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 4:57:48 PM I am a longtime resident of Huntington Beach. I urge you to vote in favor of Agenda Item#30, "Item Submitted by Council Members Bolton,Kalmick, and Moser-HB Public Library: Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsource (Charter Amendment) and Postpone/Terminate RFP Process Until After Vote". Our library is too important for a major change, such as contracting out the management of the library,without a vote of the people of Huntington Beach. The current City Council majority has ignored the outpouring of opposition to their proposal to move forward with a RFP for that purpose. It appears that the only way for those in opposition is to have a voice in the matter is for there to be a vote on the November ballot. The RFP process should be halted in the meantime, so that we don't lose any more of our valued library staff,who will,no doubt, seek employment elsewhere should the RFP process go forward. Thank you, Hildy Meyers From: 13ev Sansone To: suoolementalcommCa�surfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF) Subject: Agenda item#30,City council meeting 5/7/24 Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 5:43:14 PM I have lived in Huntington Beach since 1996 and have been appalled at how our excellent Public Library has been regarded recently. I have read about the proposed RFP to possibly relinquish our Public Library system to be managed by a private company. I have read about other cities which have hired this company to run their libraries and am not happy with the results reported. Our librarians are world class,along with our library,and I do not want to lose them. I urge you to vote in favor of Agenda item#30. I feel the citizens of Huntington Beach should be able to vote on how this very important issue is handled.I am afraid the city council members who make up the majority have already decided on this issue,and feel this is too important to allow it to go through without giving the citizens a right to express their opinion on the matter. Thank you, Bev Sansone,MD 201 20th St. From: Jkemaer6980aol.com To: unolementalcomm Dsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 5:43:40 PM Fair enough! You speak of having let the people vote on previous Charter Amendments.Let the citizens have input on a Charter Amendment that assures that the voters have input on issues impacting our library! Lawrence Kempee 9882 Saline Drive. Huntington Beach. Sent from the all new AOL app for iOS From: Maureen moviu5 To: suoolementalcomm4surfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF) Subject: Privatization of library • Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 6:07:04 PM As a 40 year resident of FIB,I am outraged and saddened to see that our city is moving backwards and is again becoming a haven for right wing extremists.Now privatization of libraries.As citizens we must resist this privatization because libraries are not just about books.Privatization will result in profit becoming the library's main objectives. Community connections will be lost,quality will decline and qualified staff will be in short supply. I am in support of Agenda Item 30 submitted by Bolton,Kalmick, and Moses. From: Teresita Diaz To: suoolementalcomm(alsurfi itv-hb.orq Cc: Teresita Diaz Subject: Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 6:43:39 PM I am writing to support the proposals submitted in Agenda Item 24-350 which request the following actions: 1. A Charter Amendment requiring a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve the proposal to operate the library with a private contractor with its own employees, a move that would reduce the costs of operating the library by paying them a much smaller salary and no benefits. 2. An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third- party contractor to operate the HB Public Library, as proposed by the City Council in its meeting on March 19, 2024. 3. To direct the City Manager and staff to stop working on the Request for Proposal (RFP), an action which obtained the "go ahead" on the meeting listed in Item #2. I respectfully request that these items be placed on the ballot for the November 5, 2024 election and that such a proposal be placed in front of the council for a vote on the council meeting of June 24, 2024. - Please consider the non-monetary value of the librarians and volunteers whose primary concern is to serve and thus educate the public by instilling in them a love of reading, creating a society which respects history and tradition, where individuals consider what is the path more likely to lead to serve one another and to unify the city and country. Respectfully submitted, Teresita de Jesus Diaz teresitadjdiaz@verizon.net From: Gabriela Peschiera To: suoolementalcomm(asun`dty-hb.org;parra.Eric(CM);Gates.Michael. Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 6:46:57 PM Dear Mayor, City Council Members, City Attorney and City Manager, I am writing in support to Agenda Item 24-350. Let the residents of Huntington Beach decide the future of our Huntington Beach Public Library System in the next elections in November 2024. Thank you so much for your consideration to this request. Sincerely, Gabriela Peschiera HB Resident From: Patricia Becerra To: supolementalcomm(aisurfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 6:47:47 PM I am support of city council Agenda item 24-350, To have the vote of residents of HB to decide the privatization/outsourcing and postpone/terminate RFP process until vote in Nov 2024,please let the residents of HB to decide the future of our public libraries Thanks Patricia Becerra Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPhone From: Claudia Locke To: Teresita Diaz Cc: supolementalcommasurfcity-hb,orq Subject: [SUSPICIOUS MESSAGE]Re:Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 7:51:45 PM This Message contains suspicious characteristics and has originated outside your organization. This is great,thank you! 0 On Sat,May 4,2024 at 18:43 Teresita Diaz<teresitadjdiaz@verizon.net>wrote: I I am writing to support the proposals submitted in Agenda Item 24-350 which request the following actions: 1. A Charter Amendment requiring a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve the proposal to operate the library with a private contractor with its own employees, a move that would reduce the costs of operating the library by paying them a much smaller salary and no benefits. 2. An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third- party contractor to operate the HB Public Library, as proposed by the City Council in its meeting on March 19, 2024. 3. To direct the City Manager and staff to stop working on the Request for Proposal (RFP), an action which obtained the "go ahead" on the meeting listed in Item #2. I respectfully request that these items be placed on the ballot for the November 5, 2024 election and that such a proposal be placed in front of the council for a vote on the council meeting of June 24, 2024. - Please consider the non-monetary value of the librarians and volunteers whose primary concern is to serve and thus educate the public by instilling in them a love of reading, creating a society which respects history and tradition, where individuals consider what is the path more likely to lead to serve one another and to unify the city and country. Respectfully submitted, Teresita de Jesus Diaz teresitadjdiaz(c verizon.net From: Nancy Garafalo To: suoolementalcomm(@surfdty-hb.orq Subject: Item 30 on 5/7/24 Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 8:18:57 PM I am in favor of approving this item so that it appears on the November ballot and Huntington Beach residents can decide for themselves if the library functions should be outsourced to a private company. Nancy Garafalo Sent from my iPhone From: Stacey Grosvenor To: suoolementalcomrlasurfcity-hb.orq Cc: Angeta Grosvenor Subject We should be allowed to vote on whether the library gets privatized or not Date: Saturday,May 4,2024 9:17:51 PM There is much uncertainty surrounding the effect that privatization of the library may have on the community. The people who live in Huntington Beach should have a say in whether or not the public library gets privatized or not. I am in favor of a Charter amendment that would require a majority vote of the people if this or any future council seeks to make a wholesale change to the library's management structure. The residents of Huntington Beach should be able to vote on whether or not the library will be privatized. Furthermore, I request that the City Council table the requested and still uncirculated Request for Proposals until after the people of Huntington Beach have spoken during the November election. Respectfully, Stacey Grosvenor 601 21st Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 (714) 733-3539 From: Georaiana Williams To: suoalementalcomm@ surfdty-hb.org Subject HB Library Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 8:15:59 AM I was a teacher in the Huntington Beach City School Distract for thirty nine years.I strongly support the decision of our library system to be voted on by the citizens of Huntington Beach.I do not wish the Prioritization of our Library System. Sincerely, Georgiana Williams Sent from my iPad From: Celeste Rybicki To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL,CMO STAFF;suoolementalcomm(@surfdty-hb.orq Subject In support of items 29 and 30 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 8:23:01 AM Hello, Please vote yes on agenda items 29 and 30. The campaign signs were absolute chaos this year so let's just get that under control.And the issue of privatizing the library,while just appalling to many of us, is undeniably being rushed through unnecessarily. Just slow this whole process down please and let the citizens have a say! I cannot believe that any of you would take a look at all the possible"benefits"and all the probable "cons"and still come to the conclusion that it's the right thing to do for our city.Please just slow it down. Thank you, Celeste From: pawn 0 Braithwait@ To: suoolementaicomm4surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 9:57:06 AM Dear city council members, the issue of privatizing the library has divided the city and done harm to the reputation and functioning of the city and city government. If you care about the constituents, you will support an initiative to put the decision-making about this issue into the hands of citizens of the city, as spoken to in agenda item 24- 350. Please listen to and respect the breadth of people who lives here and who you are to represent, Dawn O. Braithwaite, Huntington Beach From: Kim Cruz To: suoolementalcommAsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 10:23:32 AM Please do not vote to privatize the library...this is not in best interest of the FIB community or the employees that work there..it just helps a small faction control something that is public for a reason.Fair representation for all. Kim cruz Sent from my iPhone From: rnargaret IQ To: suoolementalcomm4surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 10:29:50 AM Hello, I am writing to keep Huntington Beach Libraries a part of our community. We DO NOT want privatization. Thank you! • Huntington Beach resident Margaret Lo From: vanessawebOaol.com To: suoolementalcommesurfcity-hb.orq Subject Agenda item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 11:07:11 AM Dear HB City Council Members, My husband and I have been Huntington Beach residents for about 40 years. I taught at Oka Elementary for 20 years. We served on the board for Waymakers Youth Shelter for years. We're writing in support of Agenda item 24-350. We the people deserve the opportunity to vote on the future of our public libraries that we have supported with not only our tax dollars, but with our donations of money and our time. Please place this agenda item on the general election ballot in November and let the residents make this decision. Thank you listening to your constituents. Vanessa and Jeff Webster From: Linda Law To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 11:33:27 AM Dear Councilpersons, Please support agenda item 24-350.My husband and I have lived in HB for twenty three years and we strongly believe that the public needs to vote on whether our libraries are managed publicly or privately. Private management invites corruption and the company the council is considering does not have a good track record. The City Council should stop or postpone the RFP process until after the public votes on this issue in the November general election. Thank you for your time. From: toneoi3eaol.com To: suaolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 11:53:43 AM To HB City Council, I support Agenda item 24-350, If the city wants to privatize the City Libraries, the citizens should vote on it. Patrick Tone 19342 Hickory Lane HB, CA 92646 From: Orly Levy To: suoolementalcommCa)surtcity-hb.org Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 12:11:46 PM Dear City Council Members, I do not agree with privatizing the library.I support agenda item 24-350 and would like to vote on this matter in the November election. Sincerely, Orly Levy Sent from my iPhone From: kavchildsCalaol.com To: suoolementalcommAsurf•city-hb.orq' Subject: library Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 12:15:22 PM I believe Huntington Beach is better served with a public library and support the measure to require a vote of residents. kay childs From: Diane Pavesic To: suoolementalcommOsurfcity-hb.org Subject: Against Privatization of the Library Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 12:58:03 PM City Council, I am adamantly opposed to privatizing the Huntington Beach City Library system. If you insist on moving forward with this agenda item which could be canceled in lieu of actually managing the City I agree with the proposal to require the citizens to vote on the privatization. Sincerely, Diane Pavesic Sent from my iPad From: maite aauilerq To: suoplementalcommasurfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 1:42:06 PM Hello I am a HB resident and I want to help keep the library public.Please do not make it private. Thanks Maite Aguilera From: ,Hilda Pope To: 5uDplementalcomm(S)surfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 1:42:08 PM Please do not change the way the library has been run ever since I moved to Huntington Beach in 1982.Why fix something that is working perfectly well.I would rather pay more in my taxes to keep the Huntington Beach library in house instead of having a conglomerate operate the library.Thank you Sent from my iPhone From: Arica Ciuciui To: suonlementaicommCaisurfcity-hb.orq Subject Anca Ciuciui RE:HB PUBLIC LIBRARY:VOTE OF THE PEOPLE TO PRIVATIZE/OUTSOURCE(CHARTER AMENDMENT)AND POSTPONE/TERMINATE RFP PROCESS UNTIL AFTER VOTE-Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 2:18:56 PM Hello, Please see below my vote regarding the proposed items for consideration: 1)I fully support the idea of requiring a majority vote from both the City Council and the people of Huntington Beach before making any significant changes to the library's management structure.It's crucial to ensure that such decisions are made with the input and approval of the community they affect. 2)I am not in favor of changing the current management of the library to a third-party private management.Given the lack of clear information about how privatization would impact the library,coupled with concerns about potential negative effects on staff pensions and wages,it seems prudent to maintain the library's current management structure.The library is a cherished institution with a long history,and any changes should be approached with caution and consideration for its importance to the community. Kind regards, Anca Ciuciui HB resident Sent from my iPhone From: Daniel Johnson To: 5uonlementalcommC)surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 2:46:04 PM Hi, I support this item.I grew up enjoying the library and I want to keep it in tip top shape! Dan Johnson 562-480-9094 From: Eileen Simpson To: suyolementalcommOsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Public Library Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 3:00:28 PM Dear City Council I have become aware that there is a proposal by city council members Bolton, Kalmick and Moser to transfer the management of the public library in Huntington Beach to a private contractor. I am whole heartedly opposed to this proposal. Do these city council members understand the first amendment of the constitution. Privitization of the library is in direct conflict of free speech. I thinks these council members need to have a lesson in history. Namely the burning of certain books in Nazi Germany in the 1930's. Please reconsider removing this proposal to the November ballot. Sincerely, Eileen Simpson Huntington Beach From: Terri To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 3:02:23 PM City Council- We vote. When we vote in our City Council we expect them to do what is right for our city. It is best for HB to have our public library system,and not to privatize something that is so important to our community. I want to state for the record that hundreds of other moms and dads who are friends,neighbors,all HB voters,all oppose the privatization of the library. I am one of those moms. We strongly support keeping our library as a public library. We have always loved the public library and its services. We are proud to have this big public library in our city. We will be voting for city council members in the next election that vote to keep our library public. It is the right decision for our city. Thank you. Sent from my iPhone From: David Rynerson To: suonlementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL,.CM0 STAFF) Subject Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 3:48:27 PM City Council– Item 24-350 on the May 7th agenda is a prime opportunity for the council to majority to honor their campaign promise to“increase civic participation”.It is,in fact,perhaps the clearest opportunity to either honor that campaign promise or consign it to the deep pile of broken political promises. The Huntington Beach Library system is one of the crown jewels of our city.People come from many surrounding cities,including those up in LA County,to patronize our libraries.Huntington Beach citizens are both proud of,and protective of,our.libraries. You have already received a sampling of how HB citizens feel about the proposals to change library operations –whether that be the citizens book review commission or the outsourcing RFP.At the recent Library and Community Services commission meeting supplemental communications ran at 4:1 opposed to the review board and 13:lagainst outsourcing.Public speakers ran16:1 opposed to both proposals. So,if you really believe in civic participation,approve Item 24-350 and let the citizens of Huntington Beach decide. Or,reveal yourselves to be cynical politicians who only care about the“civic participation”of those agree with them. Sincerely, David Rynerson From: mwselnaralgmail.conl To: suopiementalcomml surfcity-hb.org Subject Agenda Item 24-350 SUPPORT Allow Voters to Decide Whether Library Operations Should be Privatized Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 3:56:25 PM Honorable City Council Members: I am writing in support of Agenda Item 24-350. The Huntington Beach Library system has successfully served our City since 1909. Our library is staffed by trained librarians, many of whom have degrees in library science. Library volunteers contribute over 50,000 hours per year. There is a strong visible civic crusade that opposes the privatization of the library operations, a move that will likely cause a decrease in the level of service and loss of volunteers. The council was elected to represent the citizens of our city. When a strong visible citizen movement forms that opposes the path the council is taking,the council should reconsider its direction by allowing the electorate to formally weigh in on the issue. As a 50-year resident of HB, I believe the library transcends the current polarized City Council situation. Voters will remember this issue when it comes time to elect Council members. If you believe the Council is headed in the correct direction,why not allow the electorate to confirm(or oppose)your position by placing the issue on the November 2024 ballot? Respectfully, Michael Selna From: Brenda McDonough To: suoolementalcommesurfdty-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 3:57:25 PM Hello, I am opposed to privatization of our libraries.It is totally against what a democracy is supposed to do—protect access to books and information so we can make informed decisions when we vote.Our library is fantastic at providing access to print books and cutting edge online databases and apps that encourage literacy and education which is vital to ensuring our freedom of information. Privatizing our library system risks our access to be steered by people and institutions that are not held accountable by our voting power,and this type of move is proven in history to put democratic institutions in jeopardy. Sincerely, Brenda McDonough Huntington Beach resident From: LETITIA JOHNSON To: supnlementalcomm( sur city-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 4:40:00 PM Yes I am in favor of the agenda item.thank you. Regards Letitia Johnson Library patron and FOTL Sent from my phone.I purple. From: Sue Welfrinaer To: suoolementalcommlasurfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Item 24-350-HB Public Library:Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsource(Charter Amendment)and Postpone/Terminate RFP Process Until After Vote Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 5:07:35 PM Dear Mayor and City Council Members, This letter is in support of Item#24-350 submitted by Council Members Bolton, Kalmick and Moser regarding our HB Public Library. I am deeply dismayed and more than concerned by the year-long attack on our library system and highly qualified professional librarians. Hundreds and hundreds of letters have been written by library patrons and volunteers opposing the actions of the council majority and city attorney. From book restrictions—to politically assigned book selection committees—and now to privatization,the unfounded attacks on our library have been heartbreaking. I will not write another long letter today as these are clearly not being considered by those on council with a personal agenda. I support the motion to terminate the RFP process regarding the privatization/outsourcing of our library and I thank Council Members Bolton, Kalmick, and Moser for bringing this forward to keep the integrity and high-quality standards of our public library intact. Sincerely, Sue Welfringer HB Resident,27 years From: Paula Shawa To: suoolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.org Subject: Item 30-YES!Agenda/City Council Meeting/May 7 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 6:08:25 PM Agenda Item 30-yes, I support this and so do the majority of Huntington Beach residents:We strongly object to the City Council making any changes to the library's structure.Stop creating fake issues and ruining the city.Thank you, Dan, Rhonda and Natalie for listening to the residents. • Paula Shawa, Huntington Bech From: Dale Martinez To: suoolementalcommOsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support of proposal for Item 30 on May 7 City Council Agenda Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 6:56:00 PM Dear Council Members I urge you to support Agenda Item 30 regarding the proposal for a ballot measure allowing the citizens of Huntington Beach to decide on whether to Privatize the Huntington Beach Public Library. I have written before about this subject.I do not support privatization of our beloved Public Library system.I do not think that it is a well thought out proposal.You should be able to manage the budget and expenses. You should be ashamed of your ability to run our city because it seems that we are spending a lot of money on lawsuits and lawyers, but cannot support our beloved Library.Never mind that you cannot even fund the public art exhibit(the fountains) at the main branch,but that is another subject. Please allow for the issue to be decided by the ballot and not the Council majority. Additionally,as stated before, I do not agree with your Citizen Council for reviewing books, either. Let professional employee librarians do their jobs and quit trying to cancel our culture from your temporary positions on our City Council. It only took about 14,000 voters in Huntington Beach to elect you 4 members,which is hardly a mandate. Sincerely, Dale Martinez 714-717-7235 From: Sarah Kasravi To: supolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 8:20:09 PM We love our public library,we've grown up attending and have spent many school day afternoons and summers there.Please keep the public. Sent from my iPhone From: Autrina Kasravi To: suooIementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 8:22:59 PM Keep the Huntington Beach public library public please! Sent from my iPhone From: Barbara Richardson To: suoolementalcommesurfcity-hb.org Cc: citv.manaoer surfcity-hb.orq Subject: [SUSPICIOUS MESSAGE]Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 9:02:39 PM This Message contains suspicious characteristics and has originated outside your organization. Yes on Agenda Item 24-350, Honorable Mayor and Council Members I encourage all council members to vote yes on Agenda item, 24-350. Passing this item would halt the RFP process until after the upcoming election and would allow residents to be able to vote this November on whether the library should be privatized/o utso u rced. If the council majority honestly believes this is what the residents want, they should all vote yes on this agenda item. What better way to demonstrate to the public that you truly believe in democracy and the democratic process. You would allow people to vote on this important issue by putting it on the November ballot. It is obvious that the residents feel strongly about this matter. Why would you deny the people the chance to voice their opinion by voting? The council majority can claim the reason they want to hire a private company to run the library is to save the city money. However, the city has been through budget shortfalls before. Budget cuts are usually made across the board. An entire department is not gutted with all of its staff being laid off and not absorbed by the city into other departments. Having worked for the:city.for 32 years, I know how these things work. Laying off an entire department where employees may or may not be rehired by a private company, most likely at a greatly reduced salary, would be a first. What a horrible message to anyone who might be looking to work for the city now and in the future. Is this the legacy you want to leave? Let the residents decide the fate of their library. Give them the ability to vote on this issue. Don't go down in Huntington Beach's history as the council majority who decided, without input from its citizens, to turn our award winning stellar library with its specialized collections into a bargain basement, one size fits all, junk food library. Barbara Richardson Huntington Beach hblibrarylady@yahoo.com From: Seth Bartels To: suoolementalcommCla surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 9:24:41 PM Dear City Council Members, As a life long Huntington Beach(1974-present)I felt obligated to reach out in support of Agenda Item 24-350. Let the people of the city have a voice on this important matter.Put it on the ballot in November. Thank you for your time, Seth Bartels Sent from my iPhone From: Jtoseann Erwin To: suoolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 9:40:06 PM Dear Huntington Beach City Councilmembers, I am a Huntington Beach native, a kid who grew up at the Huntington Beach Library.Today I am a professional librarian, and I write to you in regards to Agenda Item 24-350. Access to information is crucial to children and young adults' understanding of the world around them. It is crucial to freedom.As a kid, I wandered the Banning Branch and all 4 floors of the Central Library looking for good stories, biographies, fiction and nonfiction. Being a young Library user made me who I am. Over the decades, the HB Public Library has become a beautiful monument to a city that values freedom and education. It is vibrant, bursting with programming for all ages, support for veterans and community members, all in a beautiful setting. We enjoy this gem of a Library system because of the hard work of dedicated volunteers, the expertise of professional librarians, and talented staff. This is why I am perplexed that city leaders would want to hand over control of the Library to a private company, who does not share the values of this community, and will surely put their own profits before considering decisions that benefit the public--the TAXPAYING public. I have lived all over California, sometimes in communities that had nothing but a small storefront for their public library. It's sad that a small group of ideological warriors are willing to sacrifice the beautiful HBPL system in an effort to force others to conform to their values. And to exact vengeance on the hardworking Library employees who are just trying to do their job. As a young Library Kid, nobody ever stepped in front of me to question what I was reading, or keep me from what I wanted to read. I had a mind of my own, and I could decide for myself. This is true liberty and freedom. Free people read freely. Yet the new City regime has forced books off the shelves and has made it clear they will stop at nothing to make their point, no matter what the cost. Are we really free? Respectfully, Roseann Erwin From: DAVID SANDIFE,R To: 5uoolementalcommCalsurfiity-hb.orq Subject: OUR library Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 10:03:10 PM We are contacting you to support a VOTE needed by the citizens of HB to privatize or outsource the library services.Additionally,please postpone or better yet,terminate the current RFP process until after a vote of the people. Sincerely,Nikki and David Sandifer Sent from my iPhone • From: Susie Ceram( To: suDolementalcommlalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: SUPPORT for Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 10:10:40 PM Dear HB City Council, It is clear that the overwhelming majority of HB residents want to keep our library public. It is something that we HB residents feel so passionately about. But sadly, it seems to be falling on deaf ears when it comes to you, our city council.A decision like this is about our city's character, our history, and what WE(the voters)want to invest in as a city. As such,I am writing to urge you to please place the following two items on the Nov 5th,' 2024 General Election ballot and agendize it for a vote at the June 4th meeting: 1. A charter amendment requiring a majority vote of the city council AND of the electors of .HB to make any changes regarding the library management; AND 2. Require an advisory vote by electors on whether to hire a 3rd party contactor to manage our city library. If you want what is good for our city, and if you care at all about the residents of our wonderful city,then you will at least vote to place the privatization question in the voters hands.Let the HB voters decide if the library should be privatized or stay public.A decision this big should reflect what the majority of the HB residents want,not just a small few. Sincerely, Susie Cerami (Longtime HB resident) From: J-Iilda Kasravi To: supolementalcomm(alsurfcity-hb.org Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 10:38:10 PM Dear Members of the Huntington City Council, I am writing to express my strong support for maintaining the Huntington Beach Public Library(HBPL)as a public entity.As a resident and user of the library,I have experienced firsthand the invaluable resources and services it provides to our community. The HBPL holds a special place in my heart as it has been an integral part of my life since childhood.The summer reading program fostered my love for literature and learning,instilling in me a lifelong passion for reading.As I progressed through high school,the library became my go-to study spot,offering a peaceful environment conducive to academic success.In addition,the access to tutoring facilities has been instrumental in helping countless young learners,including myself,achieve their academic goals.I,also,fostered my love for teaching while being a tutor at HBPL. Additionally,the library's used book sales not only offer affordable reading material but also contribute to the sustainability of our community by promoting recycling and reuse. Above all,the HBPL grants us access to a vast array of books and resources,enriching our lives and expanding our horizons.It serves as a beacon of knowledge and a hub for intellectual growth,welcoming individuals of all ages and backgrounds. As a member of this community,I urge you to prioritize the preservation of the Huntington Beach Public Library as a public institution.Its continued existence in this capacity is essential for the well-being and enrichment of our city. Thank you for your attention to this matter and for your dedication to serving the residents of Huntington Beach. Sincerely, Hilda Kasravi Sent from my iPhone From: To: suoolementalcomm(Dsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Public Comment Item 14&30,Tuesday,May 7,2024 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 11:08:00 PM Attachments: 1 dGLTI iXAAxSiea6nI6w4zA.onq 89fa9b129e14159f203d32f3aef62251.pnq download(19).ifif Trathnona maith City Council - Ben Pickens here, HB. resident I support Item 14 - Monthly Update of Activities for - Community & Library Services Commission - Meeting Date: 4/10/24: The results are in favor of Huntington Central Library. 44 against the implementation of a Parent/Guardian Review Board, & 10 in favor; 66 were against the Privatization RFP process, while 5 were in favor; 2 comments were undecided or opinion was unclear. This document pales in comparison to the overwhelming majority of residents in support of Huntington Central Library. I support Item 30 - Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsource (Charter Amendment) & Postpone/Terminate RFP Process Until After Vote: Surely millions of HB residents have long been dependent on their groundbreaking research at Central Library. Not having such a vote & postponement/termination, is not a protocol that is in accordance with the wishes of the constituency. Selling libraries to library companies is an absolute stupid idea from totalitarian developers; at such an important time for research, this is tyranny. These developers are terrified of people researching in libraries. A library company is nothing more than a political scheme that makes it easy for an executive to end the print of all paperback & hardcover books via digitization & exploit all paper to other countries, this will indeed be a mere computer lab. The books in question have identifiable, social disinformation in them & should have been thrown into the adult section, & be done with it. I think members of the city council & elected city clerk are at fault for not requesting this. Be mindful that misdirecting for private gain is graft. It is better to seek improvement to the library operations, if funds truly must be saved, not by selling it. I think the idea to sell is being rushed by private interests as a faint against the city. The details of Central Library have not at all, ever been adequately discussed, in conjunction with the overwhelming resident feedback that would occur, to make such a stupid sale. And I think selling has been propagandized & snuck in, which does not serve the purpose of the functions of city council. This is a great misuse of civic representation. The Huntington Central Library is also an epicenter for space travel research; there is a eugenicist phobia against this, from private interests, & an obsession to ban/censor & conspiracize this; instead of the government banning fraudulent products. Source: Google "oCa ita aau t fort: c`�4. _ i to nr i t.0raci ttat � .txK3 t:" K^ �+ - ,.s "Ch zs eb- 4 u<-3 .$a sr " + c of al asp bl' ar v t+ � to yf,e..a �tiiiii t � rtre arr4kae+ � 141ar alg+ot sa o t�rie � , a itSt o 3 f'i �� r '� arti3'aasirr- cat:" M cam,. .4,mcdtts tactano a fretps fitatafrt ia4 ±n►�s a z tcaep t !e ,ar s`tito mars .p e, i orate m p+ _ ;ice)frame ai %a�rsm i �' r ksf±: Y;� 88 -Ce • y; y e�: - �y .,3 r�••t 'Rv..i ray y► o -Me s t 4 & ",' k bG��,ya,,',�,,,. sau++zv R1t. Y a tg ! v �: '- rt.�< ',....T.I.-,--;7_,-,.--- -.7.„,-,,,,,.i.,,:zliT ,,:.,..-- . 4,..,..„:„.4,,,,,,, - �a gi, 61,'''..:4"' 4:47 ••:',,;,1A..11'i- ''''Z'f.'-_,;;;.:.•---..-- •-•g!,,,, .1 t4,•,;?. ..i•:•!4,11;';'.;:,.,' '--- •••;-:t ir . .i.ii.!#'::::,,,!,,..,0,,F. . :.,•:,., . c...nc' .4..'*;e,7 ....7... ':I•-.],'!-•:`-'-'-',%:•,-..:.• .,.?-,:'''.,,!.,',.,•" :e°••,• ..--k:-.* -1-.... .t,..e„,..-,.-„i ,„; '°".,• ,/• I-,,--1 y i f ti rt , $ n. L (ym ',i, # € cam' ff � fir" s r - ^' a ' a t " e + fit ^ o. ,/ , , . " . ^ . ' . \ • ° , \ \ . ` , . • i. }/ \a / T \! § \ \hI / d\• \\ ,, • \ sF li " ,.•` i R Sincerely, Ben Pickens From: louren Lloyd To: suoplementalcomm4surfcity-hb.orq Subject Support of Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 11:11:07 PM Dear Huntington Beach Council Members, I am writing to you today because I unfortunately cannot attend Tuesday's meeting. I do not support privatizing our beloved library. I do support Council Members' Bolton,Kalmick, and Moser call to leave this decision to the citizens of Huntington Beach,who overwhelmingly do . not want our library to go private. There is absolutely no good reason for us to change our library system. All this is doing is harming our library. We the people who use our library should be the ones voting on it. Thank you, Lauren -Lauren Lloyd 310-460-8109 From: Andrea J.Sward To: suonlementalcomm(alsurfdty-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Sunday,May 5,2024 11:25:55 PM I support agenda item 24-350 to require a vote of the people to privatize/outsource the Huntington Beach Public Library. Members of the public must have a direct say in a service that personally impacts them and their children. (It might be different if,for example,the accounting department were to be outsourced since the public rarely has face-to-face contact with their staff.) --Andrea Sward From: Melody Tokunaod To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.org Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:28:15 AM Dear City Council Members, We have been citizens of Huntington Beach for over 54 years. We have loved raising our family in Huntington Beach because of its PUBLIC schools,PUBLIC beaches and PUBLIC library. All three of these have provided excellent education,enjoyment and enrichment for my family and all citizens of Huntington Beach. Please let the citizens of Huntington Beach vote whether to privatize/outsource the Huntington Beach Public Library and postpone/terminate the RFP process until after the vote. I urge you to vote in favor of Agenda Item 24-350. Thank you, Melody and Lawrence Tokunaga From: kvooeIitsocal.rr.corn To: suuolementalcommC)surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Item 24-350 May 7,2024 City Counvil Meeting Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:42:20 AM City Council My name is Faith Vogel, a longtime resident of Huntington Beach. I served on the Library Board and the Community and Library Services from 2007 to 2023. If there is one thing, I learned in my years ofservice is that the citizens of Huntington Beach love and support their library. I am writing in support of Agenda Item 24-350,to be presented at the May 7,2004 City Council meeting.This action will give the citizens of Huntington Beach the opportunity of letting their voices be heard.The process of contracting out library services needs to be determined by the voters, and this agenda item will provide our citizens the opportunity to have their voice. In view of the major impact on library proposed by the resolution it is necessary for the City Council to let this agenda item pass. Thank you,for your consideration. Faith Vogel From: Greg Stattan To: suoolementalcomm(@surfdty-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:28:08 AM Huntington Beach City Council, My name is Greg Statton. I was born and raised in Huntington Beach, and have brought my wife and three kids back to this wonderful place I've called'home'to raise them with everything this City has to offer. I am absolutely shocked by the city's stance on privatizing resources, such as the Huntington Beach Public Library. I do not feel that a corporation has the people's best interest in mind when making fiduciary decisions that benefit outside entities. These resources were meant for the community, largely staffed by community volunteers, and meant to enrich the community it serves. I see no way a private entity can have the people's best interest in mind. I.do NOT support the privatization of public resources, and outsourcing our resources to the lowest bidder. Please reconsider this movement, as it will have a generational impact on this community which will be nearly impossible to reverse. Thank you for your time. Greg Statton Huntington Beach Resident From: Sue Brewsauoh To: suoolementalcammsurfcity-hb.orq Subject HBPL RFP Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:31:54 AM Please stop the RFP process to outsource the management of our library. It is already brilliantly managed. The only way to save money would be to cut programs,staff,and the collection. We would potentially lose the$300,000 donated by the Friends as well as the thousands of volunteer hours. The library was built by the community. It is supported by our community. We have the 8th most volunteer hours in California,despite having a smaller population than many library systems. Please consider how much our community loves our library. Outsourcing our library management would be a huge disservice to our community. If you go forward with this RFP it will be remembered in the next election. Sue Brewsaugh 38+year resident of HB From: Briaid McMahon To: sunolementalcomrr alsurfcity-hb.org;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF1 Subject: Library Privitaztion Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:38:27 AM I think privatizing the library is an absolutely terrible idea. It is completely unnecessary and will lead to a serious degradation of library services, as other cities that have tried it have found. That said, if the Council majority is determined to forge ahead with this very bad idea, it definitely should be put to a vote of the community,who are the users of the library. That just four people could drastically change this incredibly valuable and beloved community resource for years to come is outrageous;the community must have a say. If the idea is as popular as the Council seems to think,there is no reason not to schedule it for a vote of the people. Brigid McMahon bmcmahon275@gmail.com • From: Juana Mueller To: suoolementalcommAsurfcity-hb.orq;CITY COIJNQL(INCL.CMO STAFFI Cc: DonJuana Mueller Subject May 7 Coundl meeting Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:45:55 AM Dear HB City Council, Agenda Item 30: Please vote YES for putting the issue of privatizing our HB Library system on the 2024 November ballot. ALL citizens of HB should have a chance to vote on the library privatization issue. The HB library system is a foundational aspect of our city's cultural and educational offerings and is widely used and loved by our citizens. All should have a chance to weigh in on such a consequential step as privatization! Respectfully, Juana Mueller. From: dtekoalmer )verizon.net To: SuoolementalcommCla surfcity-hb.org Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:57:35 AM We have lived in Huntington Beach over 50 years, raised our children here, and have always used the wonderful library. We are opposed to any attempt to privatize/outsource the library's operations. We support Agenda item 24-350. Thank you. Christine and Richard Palmer From: Carol Daus To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq;Parra,Eric(CM).CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF) Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:58:10 AM To City Council Members and Chief Parra, I support Agenda item 30, 24-350,to require a vote of the people to privatize/outsource our public library operations and to terminate the RFP process until after an election of the people. Our highly respected public library is the community's asset and not the possession of a small group of city officials. The fact that there has been no public hearing about this drastic move is disappointing. The HBPL budget increased only 2% in 9 years, so a financial explanation for this move doesn't make sense. LS&S contracts increase at least 2 1/2%EVERY YEAR.Plus HBPL will lose $300,000 donated annually by the Friends of the Library and the Children's Friends of the Library. This cannot be given to a for-profit corporation. Why try to fix something that's not broken? There are many other ways to cut costs in our city budget. The library only represents 1.9%of the entire budget. Because of this financial analysis,privatization of our well-managed public library would be poor governance. Thank you, Carol Daus HB Resident, 28 years From: Beth Turner To: suoolementalcomnasurfdty-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:00:53 AM Dear City Council, An agenda item such as this must be determined by the city's citizens not by the City Council! Sincerely, Beth Turner Sent from the all new AOL app for iOS From: tjengland4iCa)vahoo.com To: suoplementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq Subject: HB public Library Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:52:03 AM Please,Please,Please,delay,&postpone this effort to privatize our wonderful HB Library!!.Stop this Request for Proposals to let Mr Posey and his disgraceful company invade our coty!Let the VOTERS decide with a Charter Amendment proposal in Nov.The voters and not 4 council members need to make this decision!!I guarantee you, this action on you 4 will cost you the next election.Believe it! Sent from my iPhone From: Peter Brunner To: 5uoolementalcommasurfdty-hb.orq Subject Please DO NOT Privatize our PUBLIC Library Date: Monday,May 6,2024 10:02:51 AM Dear Huntington Beach City Council Members, As a 27 year resident of Huntington Beach and a local business owner for 12 years I am urging you to NOT privatize our award-winning public library. This is a perfect example of, "if it ain't broke, don't fix it!" If you are confident that this is what the people want,then put it on the ballot and let the public decide. Our current library offers so much more than just books. These services will most likely be cut by a private contractor looking to maximize profits. A strong, free,public library is a cornerstone of a healthy community. This move to privatize might make sense in neglected rural communities but that is not the case in Huntington Beach. Please read this article from Literary Hub Nov. 22, 2021 https://lithub.com/why-the-hell-would-you-want-to-privatize-libraries/ Thank you, in advance, for setting your political agenda aside and acting in the best interests of the citizens of Huntington Beach. Sincerely, Peter S. Brunner Huntington Beach From: Norman Cain To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcitv-hb.orq Subject: Library Privatization Date: Monday,May 6,2024 10:12:34 AM Please consider very carefully the idea of privatizing the public library.This is an invaluable resouce for the entire community of Huntington Beach. This is not something which should be squandered for the benefit of a profit driven company. Thank you for your time. Norm Life's too short To make Puff pastry From: ).Weller To: suoolementalcomm(alsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 10:37:40 AM Dear City Council Members of the City of Huntington Beach, Subject: HB PUBLIC LIBRARY: VOTE OF THE PEOPLE TO PRIVATIZE/OUTSOURCE (CHARTER AMENDMENT) AND POSTPONE/TERMINATE RFP PROCESS UNTIL AFTER VOTE I propose two items for consideration in November of 2024: 1) A Charter amendment that would require a majority vote of the people if this or any future council seeks to make a wholesale change to the library's management structure — in the spirit of Measure C for our parks and beaches; and, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach, CA 92648 I www.huntingtonbeachca.gov 2) An advisory vote as to whether the current electorate of the City of Huntington Beach wants a change to the library's current management structure under the framework proposed by this Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Because the election is less than six months away, I also request that the City Council table the requested and still uncirculated Request for Proposals (RFP) until after the people have spoken in November. I request that the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at the June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting: 1) A Charter amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2) An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting. Sincerely, Jennifer Weller Huntington Beach, California resident • From: Nancy Phillip* To: suoolementalcommAsurtcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 10:37:46 AM To the City council, My husband and I both support Agenda Item 24-350.A decision this important should be left to the vote of the people in November. We do not,nor does anyone we have spoken with,favor the privitization of our lovely Huntington Beach Library.Our library is a crown jewel in our city.Please leave it alone. Nancy and Floyd Philips From: pablo asoa* To: suoolementalcomm(asurfdty-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 10:44:15 AM Dear City Council Members, I am a resident of Huntington Beach and I want to express my complete opposition to the privatization of the Huntington Beach Public Library system. If the City of Huntington Beach continues with the Request For Proposal process to outsource our library system's day-to-day operations, I am asking that you vote, "yes" for agenda item 24-350 - HB Public Library: Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsource (Charter Amendment) and Postpone/Terminate the RFP process Until After Vote. Sincerely, Pablo Aspas Mayoral From: Barbara Snider To: suoolementalcommCa�surfcity-hb.orq Subject City Council Agenda items Date: Monday,May 6,2024 11:07:58 AM I cannot attend and comment at coming City Council meeting,as I have several times in the past. I do hope voters are allowed to vote on turning over the library to a private company for several reasons: 1. There is a lot of discussion on this action throughout our community,in person and on local listserve. By allowing a vote in November,a consensus is more likely. Otherwise,I think in spite of any action taken by the City Council,there will be endless discussions at meetings. 2. This appears to be an ethical problem in that City Council members announced who would get the contract for privatization far ahead of the RFP. While the city may not have the legal strictures against this behavior,it is still highly suspect and people would and should be very open to lawsuits. putting off this decision to get a better understanding of the public's views is wise. 3. This privatization move goes far beyond general Republican/Democrat philosophies and it would behoove the City Council to get a better understanding of who they represent. 4. Not putting this issue on the ballot will mean continued endless conversations(as stated in#1). These conversations could escalate for the next few years-until 2026 when City Council members are up for re-election. Do they want to be re-elected? Do they have proof their stance is correct? Are they willing to risk fmding out? Or do they want to delay knowing and most probably have a larger fight on their hands. Better to know now. I could add many arguments against privatization,but have already done that. Thank you for reading my note. Barbara Snider Sent from my iPad From: marl beth vierra To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.org Subject HB Libraries Date: Monday,May 6,2024 11:27:29 AM Hello. I am a long-time Huntington Beach resident, homeowner and Realtor. I strongly request that all pertinent city employees do everything possible and necessary to put the library privatization issue on the November 5, 2024 ballot. Huntington Beach has a wonderful public library system with beautiful locations, collections and programs. It is essential that these remain public and not privatized. I have emailed the mayor and council members repeatedly expressing my concerns regarding their aggressive agenda. It is harming the city and will harm the city's bottom line. Thank you. Mari E. Vierra From: Kristin Evans To: suoolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.org Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 11:43:05 AM I support this agenda item. I do not support privatizing our amazing HB Public Library! We need to keep it public and continuing to operate with its dedicated and knowledgeable local staff, not outsourced to a third party contractor who is not part of the fabric of the community. Sincerely, Kristin Mascio Evans From: Julie Baker To: suoolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 11:46:12 AM To: Huntington Beach City Council Respectfully - enclosed are thoughts I'd like to share regarding agenda item 24-350. 1. A famous quote - "A library card is the start of a life long adventure" 2. Librarians today are nothing in not creative in finding ways to serve their communities 3. The design of the library going forward should build on this strength to invoke the power of learning and inspire the production of knowledge 4. We need to work together to inspire to dream big 5. Librarians help match people up with knowledge and information that is free to all Lastly, as a representative of"the people" you have been given a rare opportunity to act as guardians and protect was is sacred in our community. To quote Winston Churchill in 1906: "Where there is great power there is great responsibility". Julie Baker Huntington Beach resident for 30+ years From: Anne Cain To: suoolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq Subject Privatization of library services Date: Monday,May 6,2024 12:11:59 PM I am writing in support of the agenda item 24-350 regarding the request to allow the citizens of Huntington Beach to vote on whether they want the city's library services to be privatized or not. If you are remotely interested in allocating HB citizens' taxpayer dollars for library services as the MAJORITY of them (and not just those who voted for you!)want,this would be a legitimate way of confirming,or disputing, that you are on the right track. Even some of my friends who DID vote for you,are astounded and disappointed at the arrogant self-righteousness you have already shown in dealing with the library services,and the staff in particular,and this would be a gesture of good faith that you are executing the wishes of the majority of HB citizens,and not just engaged in a pompous, self-serving ego-trip. Sincerely, Anne Cain From: Barbara Van Dine To: suoolementalcommCa)surfaty-hb.orq Subject: Citizen Vote Regarding Library Privitization Date: Monday,May 6,2024 12:21:51 PM Mayor Van Der Mark and City Council, At tomorrow's council meeting,you will have a chance to do what is right put the future of the library to the citizens of Huntington Beach to decide. Your previous,unilateral 4-3 vote to control reading material,form a review committee of your own choosing and develop an RFP to privatize the library does NOTHING to benefit the citizens of Huntington Beach that you,Mayor and your three colleagues were elected to do., It is interesting that as I talk with more people about this,their response is,"I voted for them but that isn't what they ran on and I certainly won't vote for them again." Tuesday night you all can send a great message to the City of Huntington Beach with a 7-0 vote to put this to the vote of the people of Huntington Beach to privatize/outsource the Huntington Beach Public Library by putting it on the November ballot.and postpone/terminate RFP Process until after November vote. DO WHAT IS RIGHT! From: hooalucag To: suoolementaicomrrasurfci'-hb.orq Subject Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 12:31:50 PM I oppose the HB Public Library to be outsourced and become private. Thank you, Paula Lucas Apel Ln, HB 92649 Sent from my Verizon,Samsung Galaxy smartphone From: Lorraine Crawford To: suoplementalcommCa)surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 12:32:28 PM Dear Mr. Strickland and Ms. Van der Mark, As you have seen in the frequent protests and council comments, people are very upset and distressed on how you have decided to micromanage our outstanding library. As you have refused to acknowledge our wishes and moved ahead with fixing an excellent library that doesn't need fixing (so you can justify rewarding a former city council member's sales efforts), we hope you will listen to the will of all your constituents by voting in favor of Protect Huntington Beach and its. charter amendment request: 1. A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2) An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on. whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting. you for your consideration and showing your respect for our wonderful professional librarians and the parents who help their children choose the desired books for their needs. Sincerely, Lorraine June Crawford Former Literacy Volunteer Friend of the Library Retired Credentialed k12 Teacher 949-838-7824 Follow Crawford Marketing on Facebook From: Akemi Rover To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF1 Subject: YES for Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 12:33:49 PM Dear City Council Members, I grew up with the Huntington Beach Public Library and now have the pleasure of bringing my own family to the library to participate in a wide variety of programs offered and to check out books. I oppose the privatization of the HBPL because there has been a lack of transparency about how the City Council majority arrived at their decision to move forward with the RFP process on 3/19/24. There have been no meetings seeking community feedback (as the city is doing for Charter Section 612, formally known as Measure C). For that reason, I support agenda item 24-350 - HB Public Library: Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsource (Charter Amendment) and Postpone/Terminate RFP Process Until After Vote. Respectfully, Akemi Royer From: Armin To: suooIementalcomm(a surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 12:34:07 PM I have been a resident of HB for decades and I have been going to the Huntington Beach PUBLIC Library ever since I was a kid and my kids have been going there.It would be a travesty to privatize this wonderful landmark in our city.Please do NOT entertain this move. Thanks Armin Kasravi From: Samantha Baksic To: supolementalcommCa)sun`dty-hb.orq Subject: Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 1:01:01 PM Dear City Council Members, I strongly support the new agenda item 24-350 submitted by Council Members Bolton, Kalmick and Moser that requires a vote of the people to privatize/outsource the Huntington Beach Public Library and postpone/terminate the RFP process until after the vote.Please give the people of Huntington Beach the freedom to vote on this important issue. Sincerely, Samantha Baksic 714-330-2021 From: Julie Kimmel To: suooIementafcomm(alsurfcity-hb.org Subject: May 7 Meeting Agenda Item 30 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 1:10:30 PM I am writing as an alarmed resident about the plans being made in the City Council to privatize our library. This is NOT a decision to be made by the City Council. I am firmly against privatizing/outsourcing. I support the actions in Agenda Item 30 for the council to table the RFP process and put the decision to a vote of the people. Julie Kimmel. 611 11 th St. Huntington Beach,CA 92648 From: Lisa Marquise To: suoolementalcomm(olsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 1:10:52 PM I support Agenda item 24-350 to create a Charter Amendment giving HB voters the right to choose whether or not to privatize our jewel of a library. The majority on this City Council has outright ignored hundreds upon hundreds plus of community comments and emails to not hand our library over to a private,for profit business. The leading,predetermined`contender'being LS&S,whose owner President,Frank Pezzanite,has expressed outright disdain for libraries and librarians,including statements implying they do nothing but sit around and shouldn't earn pensions. His business practice is to gain enormous personal profits from taxpayer dollars by cutting book acquisitions,cutting staff,cutting benefits,including pensions,with a bare bones`management'system. In addition,as a private company,LS&S can refuse to disclose many operating records&costs,and refuse FOIA requests,and thus is not answerable to the community.This is however useful to Gracey Van Der Mark's quest to ban books,move/hide books from the children's,teen,or young adult section that violates her"bathing suit rule",including titles such as Once Upon a Potty,and skirt the communities broadly expressed wishes not to do this. With this system she can more easily hide this nefarious activity. Privatizing our long outstanding library,a MAJOR source of pride in the community,will unquestionably damage it,and further deteriorate public confidence that the majority on City Council will do what's best for Huntington Beach. Lisa Marquise From: )ill Bauer To: sunolementalcommCa�surcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 1:36:35 PM Dear Huntington Beach City Council Members, I'm writing to urge the City Manager, City Attorney, and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and other necessary materials to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at the June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting. These two items are: 1) a charter amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings, and 2) an advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third- party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. I also urge the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting. Please allow the people of Huntington Beach to vote on the privatization/outsourcing of our public library and postpone or terminate the RFP process until after this vote takes place. Thank you, Jill Bauer Resident of Huntington Beach From: Rocio Niezen To: suoolementalcomm(8surfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 2:02:15 PM Dear Members of Huntington Beach City Council, I am in support of city council agenda Item 24-350 to have the vote of residents of HB to decide the privatization /outsourcing and postpone/terminate RFP process until after vote in November 2024. Please let the residents of HB decide the future of our public libraries. Thank you Rocio Niezen Sent from my iPhone From: berreorincess(@aol.com To: suoolementalcomm(a)surfdty-hb.orq Subject: YES to.... Date: Monday,May 6,2024 2:28:06 PM Letting the residents of Huntington Beach have a vote on what happens to our public libraries. As residents of the city we should be the ones to have a say on keeping our libraries public or not. Enough of trying to ruin our public libraries more than you have already. There is to much that is important in our libraries now that will end up gone if a for-profit company comes in and runs things. Also I agree with the agenda item on the political signs as well. Enough is enough and close the loophole that also that allows political signs up when its not an election time for those signs. Anna Plewa From: Brian G.Saylin To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Cc: rsavlin(a)aol.com Subject: The intended destruction of our library Date: Monday,May 6,2024 3:12:30 PM 4 people have determined to besmirch anyone with different sexual preferences than themselves.They have denied parents the right to determine what their children should be able to read. They have determined that they need not follow State mandates relating to voting and housing—which has ended up and will end up costing our city hundreds of thousands of dollars. Now they want to rid the library of the professionals who have so well run it making it a library to be very proud of. Without any proof,the reason is that it will save the City money. Now,when it's to the advantage of the 4,they want to save money. It's time that the important decisions which affect the citizens now be decided by the citizenry. Put this issue up before the voters in November. It's the least the 4 can do. What are you 4 afraid of? That you're wrong? Brian Saylin Brian G.Saylin The Law Offices of Saylin &Swisher, LLP 2700 Newport Blvd.,Suite 172 Newport Beach, California 92663 t:949.577.9240 f:949.258.5250 BrianCThsaylin-law.com From: DAVID KUNTZ To: suoolementalcomm(alsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Agenda Item 24350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 3:28:41 PM My wife and I have been residents and tax payers in Huntington Beach for 36 years. We strongly oppose the privatization of the Huntington Beach Library and any action to restrict the books available through our public libraries. We are unable to attend the council meeting on Tuesday, May 7 but we want to put our comments on record. We strongly support Agenda item 24-350, submitted by Council Members Bolton, Kalmick, and Moser that calls of a vote of the people to privatize/outsource the Huntington Beach Public Library and postpone/terminate RFP Process until after the vote. That agenda item is recapped below: Direct the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting: 1)A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2)An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure,as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals(RFP)as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting. Thank you for your consideration David W. Kuntz Cynthia L.Kuntz 6401 Fallingwater Drive Huntington Beach, CA 92647 From: Estanislau.Robin To: Esauivel.Juan Subject: FW:Agenda Items 24-337 and 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 2:44:16 PM From: Fikes, Cathy<CFikes@surfcity-hb.org> Sent: Friday, May 3, 2024 5:04 PM To:Agenda Alerts<AgendaAlerts@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: FW:Agenda Items 24-337 and 24-350 From: Leslie Golson<Iesliegolson(averizon.net> Sent: Friday, May 3, 2024 4:22 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council( surfcity-hb.org>; supplementalcommPsurfcity- hb:ore Subject:Agenda Items 24-337 and 24-350 To Huntington Beach City Council, I am in favor of Agenda Item 24-337, the sign code update. Campaign signs have been a blight on our city for far too long. Please follow examples of other nearby cities by restricting the size campaign signs and limiting them to private property only. I am in favor of Agenda Item 24-350. Let voters decide whether they want to privatize the library on the November 2024 ballot, and postpone the RFP process until after the vote. I would also like to honor the life and work of Shirley Dettloff, who gave of herself tirelessly to the city of Huntington Beach. Thank you, Leslie Golson Resident From: Leslie Golson<lesliegolson@verizon.net> Sent: Friday, May 3, 2024 4:22 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) <citv.council@surfcitv-hb.org>;supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject:Agenda Items 24-337 and 24-350 To Huntington Beach City Council, I am in favor of Agenda Item 24-337, the sign code update. Campaign signs have been a blight on- our city for far too long. Please follow examples of other nearby cities by restricting the size campaign signs and limiting them to private property only. I am in favor of Agenda Item 24-350. Let voters decide whether they want to privatize the library on the November 2024 ballot, and postpone the RFP process until after the vote. I would also like to honor the life and work of Shirley Dettloff, who gave of herself tirelessly to the city of Huntington Beach. Thank you, Leslie Golson Resident i Subject: FW:Council Mtg. 5/7/2024 From:gelliott1@socal.rr.com<gelliott1@socal.rr.com> Sent: Friday, May 3,2024 7:51 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<citv.council@surfcitv-hb.org> Subject:Council Mtg. 5/7/2024 I support Item 24-350.The management of our public library and its branches should not be outsourced to the highest bidder nor be further pressured to do so by partisan lobbyists and/or self-aggrandizing censors. I also request that the Council demonstrate a Policy of Human Dignity by moving the COMMENTS AND MOMENT OF SILENCE TO HONOR THE PASSING OF FORMER MAYOR SHIRLEY DETTLOFF to the beginning of the meeting following the invocation rather than tacking it on at the end as if little more than an afterthought. Mrs. Dettloff deserves better. Cheryl Elliott(Huntington Beach resident since 1980) 1 From:shakes-09-dame@icloud.com<shakes-09-dame@icloud.com> Sent:Saturday, May 4,2024 9:41 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<citv.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda Item 30 I am a 44-year resident of Huntington Beach. I wholeheartedly support Agenda Item 30, submitted by Bolton, Kalmick, and Moser which would require a vote of the people to privatize/outsource the HB Public Library. It would also postpone/terminate the current RFP process until after a vote of the people. Please pass this Agenda item. Thank you! i Subject: FW: Huntington Beach public library ----Original Message From: elena uranga <urangamex@yahoo.com> Sent: Saturday, May 4, 2024 7:01 PM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) <city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Huntington Beach public library Huntington Beach City Council Members May 4,2024 My name is Elena Uranga, a Huntington Beach resident, user of the Huntington Beach library, and member of a Book Club organized by the Oak View Library. I am in support of city council agenda Item 24-350 to have the vote of residents of HB to decide the privatization/outsourcing and postpone/terminate RFP process until after vote in November 2024. Please let the residents of HB to decide the future of our public libraries. Your attention to this petition is greatly appreciated. Elena Uranga 20042 Harbor Isle Ln. Huntington Beach, Ca,92646 1 ---Original Message---- From: elena uranga <urangamex@yahoo.com> Sent: Saturday, May 4, 2024 7:04 PM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) <city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Huntington Beach Public Library Huntington Beach City Council Members April 10, 2024 My name is Jose Uranga, a Huntington Beach resident, user of the Huntington Beach library, and member of a Book Club organized by the Oak View Library. I am in support of city council agenda Item 24-350 to have the vote of residents of HB to decide the privatization/outsourcing and postpone/terminate RFP process until after vote in November 2024. Please let the residents of HB to decide the future of our public libraries. Your attention to this petition is greatly appreciated. Jose Uranga 20042 Harbor Isle Ln. Huntington Beach, Ca,92646 i Subject: FW:The people of HB should have the right to vote on privatization of the public library From:Stacey Grosvenor<stacevgrosvenor@aol.com> Sent:Saturday, May 4, 2024 9:20 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<citv.council@surfcity-hb.org> Cc:Angela Grosvenor<agrosvenor7715@gmail.com> Subject:The people of HB should have the right to vote on privatization of the public library There is much uncertainty surrounding the effect that privatization of the library may have on the community. The people who live in Huntington Beach should have a say in whether or not the HB public library gets privatized or not. I am in favor of a Charter amendment that would require a majority vote of the people if this or any future council seeks to make a wholesale change to the library's management structure. The residents of Huntington Beach should be able to vote on whether or not the library will be privatized. Furthermore, I request that the City Council table the requested and still uncirculated Request for Proposals until after the people of Huntington Beach have spoken during the November election. Respectfully, Stacey Grosvenor 601 21st Street Huntington Beach, CA 92648 (714) 733-3539 i From:Celeste Rybicki<celeste@celesterybicki.com> Sent:Sunday, May 5, 2024 8:23 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>;supplementalcomm@surfcity- hb.org Subject: In support of items 29 and 30 Hello, Please vote yes on agenda items 29 and 30.The campaign signs were absolute chaos this year so let's just get that under control. And the issue of privatizing the library,while just appalling to many of us, is undeniably being rushed through unnecessarily.Just slow this whole process down please and let the citizens have a say! I cannot believe that any of you would take a look at all the possible "benefits" and all the probable "cons" and still come to the conclusion that it's the right thing to do for our city. Please just slow it down. Thank you, Celeste From: Dan Jamieson <danjamieson4@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, May 5, 2024 10:30 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Please vote YES on item 30, May 7, 2024 CC mtg. Dear FIB City Council: Please vote YES on item 30 at the May 7, 2024 council meeting. Turning over management of our public library to a private operator would have a huge impact on every library patron. Such a momentous change should be voted on by residents, and the RFP process should be postponed until residents have spoken. Sincerely, Dan Jamieson Roxanne McMillen Huntington Beach • Original Message From:Cathy Thomson<cthomson@socal.rr.com> Sent:Sunday,May 5,2024 2:59 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Do Not Privatize or Censor the Library! Since 1983 I've been a volunteer at the Huntington Beach Public Library.I spent many years as a member and officer of the Friends of the Children's Library.I am also a member of the Friends of the Library. In 2015 I received a commendation from the President of the United States for volunteering for more than 4000 hours. Currently I am a tutor at the Family Literacy Program at the Oak View Branch of the Huntington Beach Public Library.I have taught two English classes every week to Spanish speaking adults for the last 15 years. I am proud to say that I have made a difference in people's lives in Huntington Beach. My two degrees in English and my MBA have helped me to share my knowledge and compassion with others. I do not earn a salary for all my work at the Library.I believe in what I do and in the Huntington Beach Library and that's payment enough for me. Leave the Library alone.Don't censor it,don't privatize it,don't harass the librarians,staff and volunteers like me any more.We are contributing so much to the city and refuse to be ignored. Cathy Thomson Sent from my iPad Original Message From:Cathy Thomson<cthomson@socal.rr.com> Sent:Sunday,May 5,2024 2:59 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Do Not Privatize or Censor the Library! Since 1983 I've been a volunteer at the Huntington Beach Public Library.I spent many years as a member and officer of the Friends of the Children's Library.I am also a member of the Friends of the Library. In 2015 I received a commendation from the President of the United States for volunteering for more than 4000 hours. Currently I am a tutor at the Family Literacy Program at the Oak View Branch of the Huntington Beach Public Library.I have taught two English classes every week to Spanish speaking adults for the last 15 years. I am proud to say that I have made a difference in people's lives in Huntington Beach. My two degrees in English and my MBA have helped me to share my knowledge and compassion with others. I do not earn a salary for all my work at the Library.I believe in what I do and in the Huntington Beach Library and that's payment enough for me. Leave the Library alone.Don't censor it,don't privatize it,don't harass the librarians,staff and volunteers like me any more.We are contributing so much to the city and refuse to be ignored. Cathy Thomson Sent from my iPad From:craig.karenl@verizon.net<craig.karenl@verizon.net> Sent:Sunday, May 5, 2024 4:34 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: I support Agenda Item#30 Dear Huntington Beach City Council Members, I support Agenda Item#30 that would place a Charter Amendment on the November 2024 General Election Ballot to let voters decide whether they want to turn over management of our PUBLIC libraries to a PRIVATE,FOR PROFIT corporation. Thank you, Craig and Karen Shimizu 8252 Tyler Circle Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Homeowner since 2011 From: Ron Rosenthal<ho_rrose@yahoo.com> Sent:Sunday, May 5, 2024 6:32 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) <city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Privatization of the Library Though I don't reside in Huntington Beach,I patronize and support the library. Privatization of the library will not save money but will result in a reduction of services. Experience has shown this is almost always the case such as in Medicare Advantage, Charter schools and,the California State Parks online reservation system. The real reason that privatization is pushed is almost always corruption-people and companies after public money. Please reject the privatization of the library. Ron Rosenthal Original Message From:DAVID SANDIFER<dsand47702@aol.com> Sent:Sunday,May 5,2024 10:08 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:OUR A library We are contacting you to require a vote to privitize or outsource the services of the HB Library.Additionally,please postpone or better yet,terminate the current RFP process until after a vote of the people. Sincerely,Nikki and David Sandifer Sent from my iPhone From:Gail Altimari-Brown<gailk.bro@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 2:10 AM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:agenda item 30 We support giving voters the opportunity to vote on our libraries. From: Nicholas Grey<nick.grey@att.net> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 8:00 AM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Adopt Agenda Item 30. (24-350) May 7, 2024. Citizens to Decide on Outsourcing Library Management My name is Nicholas Grey, a Huntington Beach resident for 28 years. I urge you to vote for the subject agenda item regarding the management of our libraries. I have used the libraries in our city a lot over the past 28 years and have found them useful, user friendly and one of the highlights of Huntington Beach. I cannot see any problem with the way they are operated now and don't see any need for change. So before you go down the path of conversion to private management and usin u our time to • do something that will be to the detriment of Huntington Beach, please allow the voters to decide if there is a need to change library management. Council Members, please vote for item 30. (24-350, May 7, 2024) regarding putting library management to a vote on the Nov 2024 ballot. Thank you for your time and consideration Regards, Nicholas Grey E Mail: nick.grey@att.net From: Brigid McMahon <bmcmahon275@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 8:38 AM To:supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity- hb.org> Sub'ect: Libra Privitaztion I think privatizing the library is an absolutely terrible idea. It is completely unnecessary and will lead to a serious degradation of library services, as other cities that have tried it have found. That said, if the Council majority is determined to forge ahead with this very bad idea, it definitely should be put to a vote of the community,who are the users of the library.That just four people could drastically change this incredibly valuable and beloved community resource for years to come is outrageous;the community must have a say. If the idea is as popular as the Council seems to think,there is no reason not to schedule it for a vote of the people. Brigid McMahon bmcmahon275@gmail.com From: Mireille Grey<mireille.grey@att.net> Sent: Monday, May 6,2024 9:20 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) <city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Huntington Beach Public Library Dear Council Members, As regards.item 30 "Code 24-350" to be discussed on May 7 according to your agenda, I strongly support the motion initiated by "Friends of the Huntington Beach Library" to direct.the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting: Thank you for your consideration. Mireille Grey 23-year Huntington Beach Resident From: HAROLD AND CHERYL COOK<ramstock1971@msn.com> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 11:35 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Opposition to outsourcing public libraries Our family strongly opposes outsourcing of our Huntington Beach libraries. We strongly support our PUBLIC Huntington Beach libraries. Our libraries are staffed with dedicated, highly knowledgeable and with many years of invaluable experience. It would be a disservice to the people of our city, and this includes people of all ages. We want to have the right to make our own personal decisions about what books we want and not left up to amateurs or narrow minded individuals. We would like to see this put on the November ballot so that we have the right to make our wishes known. We request that you do away with the practice of allowing campaigns signs in the public. rights-of-way. We request that this be added to the official minutes of the 5/7/24 council meeting. Original Message From:Sandra McGrath<smcgrath25411@gmail.com> Sent:Monday,May 6,2024 2:18 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:NO PRIVATIZATION OF HB LIBRARY. Keep our library for Huntington Beach!!! Sandy McGrath Kiwanis of Huntngton Beach (714)815-4249 From: rebeca indyk<indyk3@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 11:15 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda item 24-350 I am in support of city council agenda item 24-350 to have the vote of resident of HB to decide the privatization/outsourcing and postpone/terminate RFP process until after vote in November 2024. Please let the residents of HB to decide the future of our public libraries Thanks very much for your consideration Rebeca indyk Resident of HB since 1980 Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPad From: Gretchen Torres To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support of Agenda item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 3:41:42 PM Hello City Council- I am in support of agenda item 24-350. The citizens of Huntington Beach should have a say in how our beautiful libraries are managed. My family has used the library system for many years and it has been a wonderful resource for us. I am out of state helping my father recover from a health issue or else I would be at the Tuesday,May 7 meeting to voice my opinion. Thank you, Gretchen Torres 714 376 7805 • From: Susan Johnson To: supplementalcommi surfcity-hb.org Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 3:44:29 PM City Council, I am writing this email rather than attending the Council Meeting in person as I will be out of the country. I am disappointed that I will not be able to attend as I would like to support this agenda item in person. It only makes sense to put this to a vote of the public in November because many people both Republican and Democratic are still learning about the possible privitizing/outsourcing of our library. Wherever I go and whenever I bring it up with people I meet,many are hearing about it for the first time, and all are appalled that this would even be considered. A majority of Huntington Beach residents revere our brilliantly run gem of a library with all of its special programs, events and wide scope of available books. Individual members of the community are certainly capable of making their own decisions about which books their own children can read. We are a diverse community and our library should be able to provide access to materials and books for each unique person. Please vote in favor of this Agenda Item 24-350. Susan Johnson former HBCSD teacher and HB resident for 50 years From: DAVID KUNTZ To: suoolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Agenda Item 24350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 3:28:41 PM My wife and I have been residents and tax payers in Huntington Beach for 36 years. We strongly oppose the privatization of the Huntington Beach Library and any action to restrict the books available through our public libraries. We are unable to attend the council meeting on Tuesday, May 7 but we want to put our comments on,record. We strongly support Agenda item 24-350, submitted by Council Members Bolton, Kalmick, and Moser that calls of a vote of the people to privatize/outsource the Huntington Beach Public Library and postpone/terminate RFP Process until after the vote. That agenda item is recapped below: Direct the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5,2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4, 2024 City Council 11 Meeting: 1)A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2)An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure,as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals(RFP)as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting. Thank you for your consideration David W.Kuntz Cynthia L.Kuntz 6401 Fallingwater Drive Huntington Beach, CA 92647 From: Rick DUFRESNE To: suaolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq Cc: Bolton.Rhonda;Moser,Natalie;Fikes.Cathy Subject Vote YES—Agenda Item 24-350 HB Public Library Vote of the People to Privatizing/outsource Date: Monday,May 6,2024 3:49:16 PM Dear Council Members, I would strongly urge you top o gent tii%i24-350 and allow the citizens of Huntington Beach decide whether or not to privatize our library system. I strongly oppose the RFB to LS&S and was disappointed that it was passed. I believe it should have been RFI so the community would have very clear idea of what"privatization" would look like. For example how it would effect our librarians, library programs, hours of operation and the total cost saving potential. Respectfully, 33 year Huntington Beach Resident Member of Friends of the Library Rick DuFresne 17452 Valeworth Circle Huntington Beach CA 92649 Sent from Mail for Windows From: Chris Varga To: suoolementaicommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject City Council Meeting 5/7/24 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 3:57:44 PM Comment to City Council Meeting 5/7/24 Agenda Item 29 (24-337)—I support this item. Anything to reduce campaign signs I'll support. Stop trashing the city every election cycle. Agenda Item 30 (24-350)—Let the people decide! I support The Charter amendment to decide against outsourcing and terminate any effort on a RFP for outsourcing. Keep the Libraries public run. Thanks„ Chris Varga Huntington Beach From: adrienne low To: CITY COUNCIL QNCL,CMO STAFF);suoolementalcomm(a}surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support of Item#30 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 4:04:38 PM I do not understand why the city council seems to have decided it is a good use of our city's resources to privatize the PUBLIC library. It is frustrating the amount of time and energy that has already been wasted on this concept. Other cities that have "privatized" their libraries have found it to be a "loser" idea. If the city council believes it has a mandate for such an action, it should be comfortable putting the idea before the voters and residents of Huntington Beach. Show the residents of the city that you do respect their wishes, Adrienne Low From: Manny Huang To: sunolementalcomm4surfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 4:17:56 PM Dear City Council -I am a 30 year resident of Huntington Beach. I am a registered Republican, and I voted for some of you in the last election based on your platforms which seemed to consist of public safety, solving the homeless crisis,promoting business and responsible development. But now that you are in place, it seems like the focus is on a lot of political theater topics. An enormous amount of time has been put into this book banning (or restrictions or whatever you want to call it).I thought republicans believed in parental rights? So how about we as parents manage what our kids look at and check out?Is everyone no longer giving their kids smartphones?You want to seriously shelter high schoolers?Parent your own kids! Even more concerning is the move to privatize the library system. I understand that privatization is not always bad(look at what Elon Musk has been able to do!). But the privatization of the public library system here would be a bad idea. The libraries that LSS manages across the country are NOT in communities with standards, services and fiscal standing like Huntington Beach. The amount of savings is such a small drop in the bucket of the entire city budget that it just does not make sense and appears to point to alterior and possibly nefarious motives for this move. This is a big decision and community input should be taken. In addition, a VERY careful review of the contract and thorough understanding of the existing services (including those done by volunteer and non-profit groups which will disappear for a private company)provided by the current system and what would be provided by LSS must be done. Unlike many other city functions,the library is part of the fabric of the community. The services it offers are key to the community(e.g. citizenship test prep, language help, after school tutoring,veterans services, storytimes,writing contests, etc...). There are many areas of city services where money could be saved and pensions cut but that does not mean it is necessarily a good thing for our community's future. If people get to vote on what flags are flown,we should get to vote on what happens to our library system. Lily Huang From: Jean Peterson To: supolementalcomm(Tsurfcity-hb.org Subject: Agenda item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 4:31:22 PM Dear City Council Members Bolton, Burns, Kalmick, McKeon, Moser, Strickland and Van Der Mark; I am writing to express my strong opposition to the proposal to privatize the Huntington Beach Public Library. As a member of this community for 27 years, I believe that the Huntington Beach Library is a public community center that should remain under city/public control and supervision. Privatization would likely lead to reduced hours, decreased access to resources, and a loss of community programming. Our library is more than just a collection of books - it is an established community offering education, innovation, and community connection for all members of our city. It provides essential services to people of all ages, from children's storytime to assistance for students and programs for various adult groups within our community. Furthermore, privatization will take away from equal access to information and knowledge. Only information decided by a private, for-profit company will be available, rather than those that live here. Our librarians have library science education and understand the importance of trained knowledgeable individuals in place to help library patrons with their needs. Our library is a public library, that belongs to everyone, regardless of income or social status. Turning it over to a private for-profit company would end the diverse collection of books (on a variety of subjects) available to our community. I strongly support Agenda item 24-3 5 0, that calls for a vote of the residents of Huntington Beach to decide whether or not to privatize or outsource the daily services of our Huntington Beach Library, and postpones or terminates the RFP process until after the vote. Such an important issue in Huntington Beach belongs to all residents of our community, not just you, a very small minority of Huntington Beach residents. This issue belongs on the November ballot. I was going to end my letter there, but I just can't do that at this point. There has already been too much money and public resources spent on certain agendas. I drive around on streets in great need of repair, homeless encampments spread out around town, the financial issues facing the city, numerous unnecessary lawsuits that have been initiated, and the divisiveness spreading through the city of Huntington Beach; amongst residents as well as non-residents, ie tourists. I have read Social Media posts and read news articles lambasting the current climate in Huntington Beach. No, I'm not referring to the weather. Residents and non- residents alike are encouraging people to stay away from Huntington Beach with their tourism dollars. Is this the kind of city we want? Let's make Huntington Beach better, not worse. Please support Agenda item 24-350 for a start towards that ideal. Sincerely, Jean Peterson From: Thara Venkateswaran To: suoolementalcommCla surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Agenda#30 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 4:40:15 PM Good evening, I'm emailing as a concerned Orange County citizen to express my support for putting privatization of the HB Public Library on the ballot in November. The privatization process should be paused and the voters should decide. Thank you for your time and consideration. Very respectfully, MIDN 2/C Thara Venkateswaran Midshipman Executive Officer Rice University Naval ROTC Neuroscience and Cognitive Sciences 2025 From: Alvssa Warkentin To: suoolementalcomm(alsurfdty-hb.arq Subject Agenda#30 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 4:40:15 PM Good afternoon, I am sending this email as an Orange County resident to support for putting privatization of the HB Public Library on the ballot in November. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sent from my iPhone • From: Mark Baksic To: CitvCouncOsurfcity-hb.orq;suoolementalcomm )surfcity-hb.orq Subject Huntington Beach Public Library Date: Monday,May 6,2024 4:46:17 PM Dear City Council Members, I strongly support the new agenda item 24-350 submitted by Council Members Bolton, Kalmick and Moser that requires a vote of the people to privatize/outsource the Huntington Beach Public Library and postpone/terminate the RFP process until after the vote. Please give the people of Huntington Beach the freedom to vote on this important issue. Sincerely, Mark Baksic 562-400-6482 From: Anthony Dau* To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.org Subject Support Agenda Item 30,24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 4:53:57 PM Dear Council Members, I urge the Huntington Beach City Council to support Agenda Item 30, 24-350, to require a vote of the people to privatize/outsource our public library operations and to terminate the RFP process until after such vote can take place and the people have spoken. This is an important issue to the citizens of Huntington Beach and their voices need to be head before a decision is made. Thank You, Tony Daus Resident of Huntington Beach From: Elaine Parker To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Cc: Moser.Natalie;Bolton.Rhonda;Strickland.Tony;Kalmick,Dan;Van Der Mark,Gracev;McKeon,Casey;Bums, P Subject: Agenda Item 24-350 on Tuesday Agenda Date: Monday,May 6,2024 5:04:55 PM Please consider this item carefully and vote to approve this item. The agenda item seems to be a fair way to approach this problem.Let the voters, along with the city council, decide the future of the library. Why is the city council in such a hurry to outsource the library to a private company? Has anyone done a study to see how much money would be saved? This entire issue has happened so fast,that I seriously doubt any due diligence on the part of the city has occurred. Our public library has been a wonderful addition to HB for over 100 years and run by excellent librarians for all those years. Why change it now? What benefits will the population of Huntington Beach reap from this change? What does the RFP say?-To whom is it going? Will the librarians and staff be given a chance to keep their jobs at their present salary? Please don't say that to stay their salaries would be reduced. Some, if not all of the staff,have been there for several years and have families. To reduce their salaries and benefits would devastate them and be a rather cowardly thing to do. There has been so much ugly rhetoric regarding the Huntington Beach Library recently. This ugliness goes from condemning the librarians and calling them"pedophiles"and"groomers" to moving books that have sexual content(although no one ever explained what that entails)to now,without a good reason, you want to turn the library over to a private company for managing the library.Not a good idea. Sincerely, Elaine MacLeod Parker From: 7ov Vetterlein To: guoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.org Subject: Comments for 5/7 city council meeting re:library Date: Monday,May 6,2024 5:05:25 PM When my family moved to the HB area in 2017,we were lost.As a young mom,I did not know where to take my young children for enriching activities,until on a whim I googled"library story time near me"and found the Huntington Beach Central Library.I put the address in my phone and navigated there,with no idea what I would find. And what a library we found. We were in awe of the scale,the children's amphitheater,the architecture but,most importantly,of the incredible programming,specifically for the children's department.Over the last seven years we have stopped for every craft, sung along at story time,asked very patient librarians lots of questions about where to find that one next book in the series,and celebrated at their festivals.7 years later,my kids may have outgrown toddler story time,but they are both total bookworms and treat the library as their home away from home. The library is one of the last pure places where kids can go to feel like they belong,where they are protected from the greed of capitalism and special interests who see them as marketing targets,and not just as kids who like to read. It would be a tragedy to see this incredible landmark of the Huntington Beach Library fall prey to privatization,and to lose one of the things that makes this community home for those who live in it. Thank you. Sincerely, Joy Vetterlein Jeremy Vetterlein Ella Vetterlein(age 9) Simon Vetterlein(age 7) From: Ken Keller To: suoolementalcomm@surfdty-hb.orq;pat@oatbums4hb.com;casev4hbcc@amail.com;Van Der Mark.Gracev; Strickland.Tony Subject: Privatization of the Huntington Beach Library Date: Monday,May 6,2024 5:14:17 PM I have been a resident of Huntington Beach since 1976 and I would like to express my opinion that the voters of Huntington Beach should determine whether the HB library should be privatized. • We citizens of Huntington Beach should have a say about how the library is operated in the future. Please do the right thing. Kenneth Keller 19931 Rothert Lane From: Insakioka To: suoolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq Subject Agenda Item 24-350 SUPPORT Date: Monday,May 6,2024 5:16:46 PM I would like to voice my support for an amendment that would require a majority vote of the City Council and the electors of Huntington Beach in order to change the management of the library. Our library offers a wide array of materials that encourage independent thought and educate the minds of young and old. I don't believe that bringing in a third party contractor to operate our library system would benefit our community. If something is "broke" - fix it. If something works in a way that is admired and emulated - then don't foul up a good thing. Thank you for your consideration, Melinda Sakioka From: Jeanne Farrell* To: suoolementalcomm(asur city-hb.orq Subject: Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 5:31:42 PM Dear HB City Council Members, My name is Jeanne Farrens, and I am writing in strong support of Agenda item 24- 350. The Huntington Beach Public Library is a public institution, and the future of its operation should be determined not solely by a seven member city council but by the public which it has served successfully for 115 years. The founding of our public library system runs parallel to the founding of our nation. It is our oldest institution and nearly as old as the country itself, dating back to 1790 when Benjamin Franklin got the city of Franklin, Massachusetts to pass an ordinance allowing the citizens of the town to borrow books he had donated to the town hall. Public libraries are open to everyone; all races, creeds and genders, young and old alike are welcome. They are a foundation of free speech and a cornerstone of democracy. A political body should not decide what is clearly under the purview of the people. The future of the operation of our Huntington Beach Public Library System deserves a vote by the population of its residents. Please honor the citizens of Huntington Beach by voting yes on Agenda Item 24 and place the matter of the operation of our Libraries on the ballot for the general election in November and postpone the RFP Process until after the vote. Thank you for your consideration, Jeanne Farrens From: Jan Madnick To: suoolementalcomm(a)surfcity-hb.arq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 5:33:48 PM To the City Council, I am writing in support of the agenda item,24-350,being offered for a vote tomorrow evening. Although the majority of you have been jamming your agenda through with little thought towards the hundreds of residents opposing your votes,we would DEFINITELY like an opportunity to weigh in on this drastic change to our incredible library system. You had no hesitation about putting your changes to our Charter on the Primary Ballot. If you care AT ALL about how the HB citizenry feels about the library,then it's only fair you give us a chance to vote on outsourcing it. In addition,as stated,you need to STOP the RFP process until AFTER we vote. This is a good opportunity for showing HB that you value our opinions and votes--which you surely continue to say about the November results. It works both ways!! I've lived in Huntington Bear for over 40 years. I put my children through the schools;supported the sports teams (and still do for grandchildren);pay my taxes;and vote in every election. You need to pay attention to how the many citizens just like me feel about this issue!! Sincerely, Jan Madnick From: Linda Moon To: suonlementalcommCa)surfcity-hb.orq Subject May 7,2024 City Council Agenda Items 29 and 30 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 5:40:22 PM I am writing in support of City Council Agenda Items 29 and 30. Item 29 would allow a much needed(although still minimal)reduction of the election sign blight that has plagued Huntington Beach for the last 40 years. Since the city's sign ordinance was severely loosened in the 1980's,Huntington Beach has been among only a few cities in California to allow political signage in public right-of-ways. This allowance has created a situation in which signage has become not only annoying but a dangerous distraction to drivers. The signs often obscure traffic signage and distract drivers'attention from pedestrians,bicyclists and general traffic conditions. Restriction of signage as proposed is more than reasonable. Item 30 would require a public vote regarding any privatization or outsourcing of library management services. Huntington Beach's library system is the soul of our community. Its public management is critical to maintaining optimal services. Libraries are community resources and not profit making institutions. Their mission is to provide broad professionally staffed educational and information resources to the community. Residents of the city benefit from having the libraries providing diverse resources to the public. It is reasonable to require the public's assent to relinquishment of public management. Linda Sapiro Moon 50 Year Huntington Beach homeowner and business owner From: Alyce Hendrick To: suoniementaicomm4surfcity-hb.org Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 5:50:00 PM Hello I support agenda item 24-350 I would like the items moved to the ballot and also for all action to cease until so.This library is well run and a beautiful place that I personally do not want to see privatized. Alyse Hendrick Sent from my iPhone From: The Silverstein§ To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 5:53:55 PM We support 24-350. A referendum on changes to the library is necessary , not just a council majority. Stan Silver, PhD From: David Lawson To: suoolementalcomm(a)surfc!ty-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 5:54:13 PM I support Agenda Item 24-350 I support freedom Agenda Item 24-350 Item Submitted by Council Members Bolton, Kalmick, and Moser - HB Public Library: Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsource (Charter Amendment) and Postpone/Terminate RFP Process Until After Vote Recommendation: Direct the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5. 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4. 2024 City Council Meeting: 1) A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2) An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third- party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting From: sorolman To: sunolementalcomm aC)surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 5:54:28 PM Do not privatize our library. It is superb and doesn't require change of this nature. Repair what needs it like our streets and not mess with what is superb. Thank you. Sheila Prolman long time library member Sent from my T-Mobile 4G LTE Device From: Judith Wolfe To: suoolementalcomm4surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 5:55:24 PM Agenda item 24-350 I support this agenda item and the Huntington Beach Public Library. Don't mess with our beautiful library that services all ages. Judy Wolfe Huntington Beach, CA 92649 From: steohanie stichka To: suoolementalcommC@surfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 5:57:45 PM Hello city council members, My family and I are writing to you tonight in support of agenda item 24-350; let the citizens decide what to do with the library and not the city council. Thank you, the Stichkas From: Emilie Lairson To: Suno!ementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.org Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 5:59:01 PM No library privatization!! From: Larry Utsler To: suoolementalcomm(asurtcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:01:17 PM At 84-years-old and as a 52-year resident/homeowner in Huntington Beach, I urge the members of City Council to approve/adopt Agenda Item 24-350. My wife and our three children found a second home at our beautiful Central Library,and after retirement from our careers, she and I both volunteered with FOTL. My 9-10 hours per week were spent in the Used Books area while she worked in the Friends Gift Shop. We were proud to be part of the organization that over the past several years has donated so much manpower along with $250,000 per year to the library budget. Please give the voters in Huntington Beach the opportunity to vote on this ill-conceived privatization move by adopting Agenda Item 24-350. Respectfully, Robert L. (Larry) Utsler From: Bernadette Varua6 To: sunolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq Cc: tsanti664omail.corn Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:02:12 PM Good Evening, We are writing in support of agenda item 24-350.As residents and voters of Huntington Beach we do not support the privatization and outsourcing of the management of our public libraries. Leave our libraries as they are and leave book selection to the professional librarians the City employs. Thank you, Bernadette Vargas Marco Santibanez 16202 Chipper Lane Huntington Beach,Ca 92649 From: Marty Smith To: suoo!ementalcommCa�surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:03:10 PM I am 100%opposed to privatization of our well run beautiful public library.Shame on our city council members who would vote to replace our professional staff with a for profit organization.The fact that a former mayor is involved with the private company is an even further insult. Martha Smith Sent from my iPhone From: Elliott Kallick To: suonlementalcomm@lsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:03:57 PM Please support above item Elliott kallick From: Bonnie Ros To: suoo!ementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:04:09 PM Please add my support for Agends 24-350 on the May 7,3025 meeting.Privatizing our library is ridiculous and a waste of money and resources. Dr.B.L.Ross Sent from my iPhone From: Mary K Dane To:' suoo!ementalcomrrasurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:06:18 PM I wholeheartedly support Agenda item 24-350. Mary K Dana 20932 Queens Park Lane Huntington Beach CA 92646 From: Ameelia Ghareeb To: 5uoolementalcommAsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Agenda Item 24-350 Stop Privatization of our City Library Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:06:25 PM Good afternoon, I am writing to all members of our the City Council about the idea that we should privatize our Public Library. This idea is completely ridiculous. While I have heard some arguments that this will save us money (allegedly),the need has never been established and the loss of benefit and value to our City and its communities is just too great to even consider. If some members of the Council are so convinced this move is great for our city,Put it to a vote. Just like you put other things to a vote at the last election, put Privatizing the Jewel of our City Services to the voters before moving forward. I think you'll find overwhelmingly that people, from both parties, do not want this. I vote in every election, and I do not want this. Please do not move forward with this plan. Leave our Library alone. Thank you, Ameelia Ghareeb; 92649 From: Johnnie Ham To: suoofementalcommCla surfcitv-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:07:12 PM No privatization of our PUBLIC library!! Johnnie and Pam Ham Huntington St. From: Patricia Bray To: 5uooIementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:13:47 PM We are 40 year HB residents and HB Library Members who are very distressed at the possibility of losing our award winning library and personnel to an outside organization. We strongly support a city-wide question on this important change to be placed on our ballot for the Nov. 2024 election. All further activity pursuing the privatization of our library be set aside pending the results of that election. This will allow and ensure that this impactful change to our community reflects the majority of our citizens. Such a change calls for no less. Thank you, Patricia and Harry Bray P'trish (714) 969-2311 Home (714) 915-8971 Cell pmcbrayPgmail.com From: kitty rozenstraten To: sunolementalcommCla surcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:14:13 PM I strongly support item 24-350 on tomorrow agenda. I say NO to privatization of the HBPPL. Katharina rozenstraten 6221 hamshire drive Huntington Beach CA 92647 From: Sally Adams To: Kathy Abler;Sally Adam;suoolementalcommaa surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:19:55 PM We need to keep our public library Public-! Not privatized. Protect our rights from Government interference and control over librarians' Decisions on books that are age-appropriate. Other citizens may not even be trained in Libraey Science. Why should we pay more in HB for Restricted access by the public? Next there will be actual book burning and if U finished high school?U know who started that horrendous idea last mid-century in W. Europe! Or don't U??? Sally ADAMS, M.A. HB-92648 Retired French/W. History Educator 30 yrs at GGUSD From: Sally Adams To: Kathy Abler;Sally Adams;suoolementalcomm(@surfc!ty-hb.orq Subject Re:Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:21:21 PM "Library Science". Typo in 7th line; My apologies! On Mon,May 6, 2024 at 6:19 PM Sally Adams<sjkadamsl@gmail.com>wrote: We need to keep our public library Public-! Not privatized. Protect our rights from Government interference and control over librarians' Decisions on books that are age-appropriate. Other citizens may not even be trained in Libraey Science. Why should we pay more in HB for Restricted access by the public? Next there will be actual book burning and if U finished high school?U know who started that horrendous idea last mid-century in W. Europe! Or don't U??? Sally ADAMS, M.A. FIB-92648 Retired French/W.History Educator 30yrsatGGUSD From: Barbara Marrs To: suoolementalcommOsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:21:51 PM To: Mayor and City Council Members: I strongly urge you to support Agenda Item 24-350! Privatizing our libraries based upon the votes of 4 people is not only the death knell of our amazing libraries, but it is the death knell of democracy in Huntington Beach. An issue with such far-reaching consequences upon our community should be brought to the vote of the people. • Please postpone/terminate the RFP process until after a vote of the people in November! Be leaders who represent the majority of Huntington Beach, not demigods who are acting for the benefit of a few. I am sure this is not the political ditch you wish to languish in. Please do the right, moral, and honorable thing by supporting agenda item 24-350. Thank you for your consideration, Barbara Marrs From: Jane Iovine To: suoo!ementalcomm aAsurfcity-hb,orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:25:02 PM From: Christine Moore To: supo!ementalcomm(fturfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:25:41 PM To the Council of the City of Huntington Beach. It would be a shame to move forward with this without public support.Please allow these items to be voted on.I think you'll see how much the library means to the people in the community of Huntington Beach. Retired HBPL Librarian, Christine Moore From: Wally Medal To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.org Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:26:09 PM I support agenda item 24-350! Michelle Medal Sent from my iPad From: Jane Iovin@ To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:26:17 PM I support Agenda Item 24-350. Please listen to your constituents! Allow us to participate in your decisions! Jane lovine From: Jeanne Whitesell To: suoolementalcommesurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:27:50 PM Dear City Council Members, Please support Agenda Item 24-350, HB Public Library: Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsource (Charter Amendment) and Postpone/Terminate RFP Process Until After Vote. Thank you, Jeanne Whitesell 17922 Shoreham Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92649 From: Charlotte Emmons To: 5uoolementalcomm(a)surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:28:13 PM I urge you to not vote to privatize our wonderful library.Please leave it as it is! Charlotte Emmons Sent from my iPhone From: ianIcsvi aoLcom To: suoo!ementalcomm(Msurfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:33:24 PM I am writing this in order to express my support of Agenda item 24-350 which will come before the City Council meeting on May 7, 2024. As a resident of Huntington Beach for over 40 years, I strongly believe this item needs to pass in order to bring before the voting public the matter of the privatization/outsourcing of our public library system. Furthermore, I wish to postpone/terminate the RFP process until after this vote. The Huntington Beach Public Library has met the needs of the community for many years and it is not broken. It does not need to go through this drastic change. I firmly believe that this item needs to be approved. Thank you. Sincerely, Jan Murphy From: Gabv LA; To: suoolementalcommAsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:35:58 PM Sent from my iPhone From: JCurt Markus Clement To: suoolementalcommi)surfcit'-hb.org Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:36:03 PM Agenda Item 24-350 Item Submitted by Council Members Bolton, Kalmick, and Moser - HB Public Library: Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsource (Charter Amendment) and Postpone/Terminate RFP Process Until After Vote Recommendation: Direct the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting: 1) A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2) An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting. Sincerely, Kurt M. Clemens lirnclemens51@gmail.com "Football may be the best taught subject in American high schools because it may be the only subject that we haven't tried to make easy." Dorothy Farnan, English Dept. Chairman Erasmus Hall High School, Brooklyn,NY From: STEPHANIE ANDERSON To: suoo!ementalcommlaa surfdty-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:43:22 PM No privatization! Sent from my iPhone From: Meghan Wasson To: suoolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Support for Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:46:18 PM I am emailing to express support for Agenda Item 24-350. I was born in Huntington Beach and spent many happy hours of my childhood picking out books at the Central Library and the Helen Murphy Branch. I have nothing but fond memories of the HBPL, and its wonderful librarians who helped me find reading material I would enjoy. I would urge the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting: 1)A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2)An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19,2024 meeting. I would also urge the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19,2024 meeting. Thank you, From: Judith Ashby To: suoo!ementalcommCla surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:47:52 PM I believe the people of Huntington Beach have a right to decide how their library is run and by whom.I support Agenda Item 24-350! If it's not broken,don't try to fix it.Leave it as it has always been.It's perfect just as it is. From a resident of Huntington Beach for over 50 years. Sent from my iPhone From: Sarah Batts To: supo!ementalcammAsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:51:28 PM Hello, I am a senior member of the community that goes to the library weekly,both Central and the Helen Murphy Branch. I find the opportunity to engage with others in multiple programs provided vital for my socialization.If these programs are removed due to"privatization"I am worried that I will be isolated.Please don't change our wonderful library. Thank-you, Sarah Battis Sent from my iPhone From: Linda Masterton To: suoolementalcomm4surfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:54:02 PM I would like the HB City Council know I.support agenda item 24-350 and the Huntington Beach Public Library. Additionally, I would direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposal (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting. From: Gene Axelrod To: suoolementalcommAsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:55:14 PM Please add my voice to those who support the referenced agenda item.Any action to privatize the library by transferring its operation to a profit making business should be put to a vote of the residents of Huntington Beach. Sent from my iPad From: Kalee Rustvold To: guoolementalcommCaisurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:02:14 PM I am emailing to express support for Agenda Item 24-350. I would urge the City Manager,City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions,ordinances,and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5,2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4,2024 City Council Meeting: 1)A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library,and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings;and, 2)An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL;a replacement of the current management structure,as proposed by the City Council at its March 19,2024 meeting. I would also urge the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals(RFP)as it relates to the action taken at the March 19,2024 meeting. Thank you, Kalee Rustvold From: Ella To: suoo!ementalcoma alsurfdity-h•.org Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:02:35 PM Dear City Council Members, I am a 15 year old high school student who loves our Huntington Beach Public Library. Please vote to allow Huntington Beach residents to decide whether to privatize or keep our library public. Such a drastic change should be put to a public vote, and not just voted on by a few city council members. Thank you, Ella Cerami From: Laura Janssen To: suoolementalcomm(a)surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:07:15 PM Dear Council Members, I am writing in support of Agenda Item 24-350. Please don't outsource the operation of our beloved library. The library is a public institution and should be run and financed by municipal funds. This push to privatize the library is a mistake, plain and simple. In the end, privatization will not save the city money but rather dismantle an already well run and well-funded library. For what purpose? Our library is not a private bookstore, a place where you come in, get your books, pay, and leave,we have those already and they serve their purpose. A public library provides intangible essential services for the community beyond book lending. Research has shown privatization does not benefit a library or its community, but rather it's the corporation that benefits. The trained staff and collections are gutted. Again, for what purpose? I am saddened by the direction my hometown has been taking lately. I came back to Huntington Beach, after a 40 year absence, and was proud to take up the causes my parents championed to grow this city from an a mostly rural suburb into a thriving city while still maintaining its charm as a beach community. This assault against our library, and our city, goes against all the values my parents taught me and they would be horrified. An effective society is a balanced mix of private enterprise and community service. Let the library do what it does best by serving the people with no monetary agenda, our community deserves nothing less. Sincerely, Laura Janssen From: Carol Van Holt To: suoolementalcommt surfcity-hb.or4 Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:11:01 PM Please. Sent from AOL on Android From: pans F,Barraclouob To: supolementalcommCalsurfdty-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:11:52 PM Good afternoon: The Huntington Beach Library is one of the jewels of Orange County. The collections are inspiring;the Central Park building is an architectural landmark;the extraordinarily knowledgeable and dedicated staff are world-class; and,most importantly,the services that the library and its people provide to the community are unsurpassed. Please do not destroy this by trying to turn the library into a profit center. Thank you for your thoughtful consideration. Dana Barraclough From: Donna Skinner To: suno!ementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:12:05 PM Privatizing our public library is such a BAD idea. Having a public library is a very American thing. It is a point of pride for our city. Please listen to those of us HB residents who love our public library and don't want to lose it. Agenda Item 24-350 Item Submitted by Council Members Bolton, Kalmick, and Moser - HB Public Library: Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsource (Charter Amendment) and Postpone/Terminate RFP Process Until After Vote Recommendation: Direct the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting: 1) A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2) An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third- party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting. Thank you, Donna Skinner HB Resident since 1973 Donna Skinner DonnaSkinner.com From: Allen Field To: suoolementalcommralsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:15:20 PM Our library should be run by our existing professionals on behalf of our local citizens. Do not let outside interests who are dollar driven dictate how it should be run. Allen & Shirley Field From: G Wolff To: suoolementalcomm(a)surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:15:21 PM City Council Members; I completely support your efforts to make sure the Library is functioning properly and economically. Thank you for making sure the community has a right to review the purchases and placement of books within the Library.Thank for protecting our children. The question of how and by whom the Library is run is not a question to be decided by voters.That is a management issue.City Management should explore the options and make the best choice for us. Unfortunately during the pandemic the Library stayed closed much longer than the Newport Beach Libraries. During most of the pandemic Newport Beach Library staff was in the libraries trying at first to help by phone,then by bring books outside to patrons,then by allowing the public to enter and chose books,but not sit down,and finally being fully open. HB Library made different choices.No one worked at the Library,but they were fully paid.It does not surprise me that our Libraries have financial issues. Thank you for your common sense and service. Georgetta Wolff Sent from my iPhone From: buzz mccord To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Please pass Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:19:44 PM This is a sensible and simple step. This action will save you and the City time and money. It will also allow the public to have a voice in the future of the City's top civic resource. Thank you for voting to support Item 24-350. Buzz McCord BB resident. From: Kate Yznaga To: - suoolementalcomm )surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Our great city Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:23:05 PM Sent from my iPhone I am emailing to express support for Agenda Item 24-350. I would urge the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4,2024 City Council Meeting: 1)A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2)An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19,2024 meeting. I would also urge the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19,2024 meeting. Thank you Kathleen Yznaga A 40 plus year Huntington Beach resident From: Eric Bies To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.org Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:23:59 PM From: cindvberm To: suoo!ementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:27:03 PM We do not want the library to be privatized. It will reduce access to books and compromise its integrity to remain an independant body. Cindy Berman Sent via the Samsung Galaxy S10,an AT&T 5G Evolution capable smartphone From: Jessica Bensberq To: suoo!ementalcomm4surfcity-hb.org Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:27:20 PM Hi again I am writing in support of agenda item 24-350 submitted by council members Bolton,Moser and Kalmick. I am so frustrated that the majority council members continue to push items through attacking our beloved library despite public outcry.Put the issue to the voters! Jessica Bensberg Sent from my iPhone From: Lynne Deakers To: suoplementalcommC)surfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CM0 STAFF) Subject Agenda Item 30 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:28:15 PM I am urging the city council to allow voters to decide if they want our PUBLIC library to email PUBLIC.Please postpone any further investigation into this possibility until the voters have told you what they think about this possibility. Lynne and Tim Deakers Huntington Beach 45 year residents From: onewildart To: suoDlementaicomm(a�surfcity-hb.org Subject: Stop the Privatization/Book Banning Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:35:57 PM >>City Council Members, >>Seeing Huntington Beach highlighted on the John Oliver show on the 5th of May regarding banning/moving books was not a surprise,but certainly an embarrassment for our city.Between the attempt to privatize the library and control how it's run reflects how our leadership is failing. >>Elected on promises(not kept)and voting the will of the people(not)seem to be the ruling gang of four's MO. Our library is not up for sale and we the people will not put up with this nonsense without a fight!! >>I'm asking you to see the light and do what's right.Our city deserves better. >>Trudy Roe >>47 year resident >>Sent from my iPad From: Sharon To: suoo!ementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:41:59 PM As a resident for over 30 years, a user of the Library, and a Volunteer for almost the same amount of time, it is incredibly sad that we are at this point. To consider upending the public aspect of the Library and even considering turning to a for-profit company to manage a successful operation, makes no sense. This has nothing to do with saving money, since it is run so well with one of the lowest budget allocations in the entire city operation. This has nothing to do with making the libraries better, more efficient or to promote expansion. This has everything to do with one person's war on the libraries. The four majority members of the counsel for some reason think they have the power to do whatever they want, but the more they try to do, particularly against what they ran on, the more the public sees their true colors. It is time for any major initiative or change be given to the voters to decide, since the council majority cannot be counted on to listen to the public, have public hearings for discussion, or include the other council members who were also elected by residents of this city. I would rather not see money spent on ballot initiatives when this proposal to outsource the library operations should not even be up for consideration. However, in lieu of common sense prevailing, I urge support of Agenda item 24-350. Sharon Hathaway HB resident From: Carol Unehan To: gupplementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.org Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:42:33 PM I love our HB Library. I've been a library member for over 20 years It is great being able to get a book for free. Please do not close our library Carol Linehan From: Ellie Johnson To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:44:38 PM Dear Members of the City Council, I write in favor of Agenda Item 24-350 which directs the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances and any other material necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 general Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting: 1) A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2) An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP)as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting. Respectfully submitted for your consideration. Eleanor Johnson From: Danica Camooi To: supolementalcomm(asurfcitv-hb.orq Subject HBPL support for Agenda Item 24-350. Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:45:52 PM I am emailing to express support for Agenda Item 24-350. I would urge the City Manager,City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions,ordinances,and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5,2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4,2024 City Council Meeting: 1)A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library,and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings;and, 2)An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL;a replacement of the current management structure,as proposed by the City Council at its March 19,2024 meeting. I would also urge the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals(RFP)as it relates to the action taken at the March 19,2024 meeting. Thank you, Danica Campos From: irobev To: suvolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:49:48 PM I fully support agenda item 24-350.Please give it your careful attention. It represents the fair will of the citizens of Huntington Beach. Jeanne Robey Sent via Jeanne's mobile From: JCimberly BANOVIIZ To: suoolementalcommralsurfcity-hb.org Subject: Support Agenda Item 24350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:52:53 PM I support agenda item 24-350.My family and I are against privatization of our PUBLIC library. All efforts by the City Council to move toward privatization of our library should immediately stop. Kimberly Banovitz 33 year resident of Huntington Beach Sent from my iPhone From: Sue Fullerton To: suoolementalcomm aPsurfcity-hb.orq Subject; Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:55:16 PM I support agenda item 24-350. L. S. Fullerton From: Spencer Perzanowski To: suoolementalcommesurfcity-hb,orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:56:39 PM Hello, My name is Spencer Perzanowski and I was born in Huntington Beach, California and I have lived here for 22 years. 1)I do not want the HB public library privatized. 2)I wouldn't like any changes to the structure of the public library by the city council until approved by the Publix. Best, Spencer Perzanowski From: perzanowskidCalaol.com To: suoolementalcomm(@surfdty-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 7:58:37 PM I do not want the HB Public Library privatized and don't want any action taken by the HB City Council until this item is presented to the voters on the November ballot. Thank you, Deborah Perzanowski 15071 Hanover Lane Huntington Beach, Ca 92647 From: Marianne To: suoo!ementalcammCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:01:06 PM I am writing in support of Agenda Item 24-350. A consideration to privitize our exceptional public library should never have been an item but since this proposal has gotten this far I support the above agenda item. We the people need to vote. Thank you,Marianne Tobin. Sent from AOL on Android From: Marilyn Konowal To: suoolementalcommCla surfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:04:38 PM This email is a request for the Huntington Beach City Council to stop pursuing proposals to turn our public library over to a private company. Our Huntington Beach Public Library is the jewel of our city because of its outstanding staff,its countless resources, services and programs as well as its amazing volunteers who give thousands of hours and money to the library each year. After researching public libraries that have been taken over by private companies,it became clear to me that no private company could give us the high quality library we already find at the Huntington Beach Public Library. The City Council should take an old saying into consideration concerning this matter:"If it's not broken,don't fix it."Our library is not broken. Marilyn Konowal 51 year resident and property owner of Huntington Beach MS in Library Science and Informational Services From: Kathleen Abler To: suoolementalcomm( surfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Items#30 and#29 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:06:24 PM Council Members: Vote YES to approve Agenda Item#30. If four members of our City Council can blithely disregard the opinions of the vast majority of HB citizens regarding privatization of our library,what city property will be next on their political giveaway?Our parks?Our recreation centers?Our Senior Center? All voters must be given a chance to determine how our library should be managed. This issue should be placed on the November ballot. Vote YES to approve Agenda Item#29. The only signs on street corners that have inspired me are the memorials placed at scenes of accidents, where someone,often a child,has been killed or injured.Immediately I'm reminded to slow down and pay attention to my driving. But the unsightly mess of campaign signs that clutter our street corners before an election is unsettling. An agitated driver is not a good driver. Let's get rid of those annoying political signs. Kathleen Abler Huntington Beach voter since 1975 From: DAVID SANDIFER To: suoolementalcomm a()surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:09:51 PM Please place the unwanted privatizing of the library on the ballot and postpone or discontinue the process until the public has provided input via voting. Nikki and David Sandifer Sent from my iPhone From: Arvnn Noble To: suoolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Supplemental Communication for May 7,2024 Meeting Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:10:36 PM Members of the Huntington Beach City Council, I am submitting this Supplemental Communication in support of Agenda Item 24-350.I believe the idea to outsource the management of the library system to a private for-profit company should be put to a vote of the citizens of Huntington Beach before any further steps are taken.The Huntington Beach Public Library is a precious and invaluable part of our community,and any drastic and irreversible actions to change it should be taken only with the agreement of a majority of Huntington Beach citizens. I was raised in Huntington Beach and have many wonderful memories of the Huntington Beach Library system from my own childhood.I am now raising a child here myself and I bring my child(age 11)to one of the HB Library branches regularly and have since he was a young toddler.We are so grateful for our library and for the dedicated staff that make it the safe,welcoming.place that it is. Our community would not be the same without it.My true wish would be that this whole idea would be taken off the table completely,but since that doesn't appear likely we the citizens should at least be permitted to voice our opinions on this through the ballot box. Second,I would also like to state my support for Agenda Item 24-337. Every election cycle I am disturbed by the blight of election signage throughout the city.Huntington Beach is a beautiful place to live, and the pollution of election signage detracts from what makes Huntington Beach great. Let's follow the lead of cities around us and get these signs under control. Thank you, L.Brynn Noble From: Patricia Coenen To: suoolementalcomm(a surfcity-hb.org Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:15:57 PM We support agenda item 25-350. Patricia and Baron Coenen Sent from my iPhone From: taford3Ca�omail.com To: 5uoo!ementalcomm4sun`aty-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:16:47 PM To whom it may concern, The people of Huntington Beach love our library system.Please take all measures necessary to protect the services.I have lived in this city for over 37 years and we frequent the library and recently attended the ballet with my two children.These services that support the youth are amazing and I support every tax dollar that is paid. Please consider other measures to save money.Cutting back the library is not a community driven idea. Tiffany truitt High school teacher Sent from my iPhone • From: Lee Marie Sanchez To: suao!ementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:24:40 PM Dear Huntington Beach City Council N I am in favor of these recommendations: Recommendation: Direct the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting: 1) A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2) An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting I dearly hope you will be open and willing to listen to your constituents. As a member of a family who has lived in our beloved beach town for over 52 years, I'm counting on you to do your job. N Sincerely, Rev. Lee Marie Sanchez (retired and voting) From: Chris Ocannell To: suooiementaicomm(alsurfcity-hb.orq Cc: president(afot!hb.com;,Karen 0"Conneil Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:27:00 PM I do indeed strongly supportAgenda Item 2.4 350 • It is only fair to the people of HB to allow them to weigh-in in democratic fashion on a fundamental change to the way the public library system has operated for many decades. Allow the people,your constituents,to speak.That's the American way! Chris O'Connell FIB homeowner since 1965 From: j1catavamaPsocal.rr.com To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CM0 STAFF);suonlementalcomrraa sun`dty-hb.orq Subject: I SUPPORT AGENDA ITEM 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:27:36 PM I SUPPORT AGENDA ITEM 24-350. I am in favor of a vote of the people on whether or not to privatize/outsource management of the library.Put it on the ballot and let the people decide. Our library system should remain PUBLIC! It is a wonderful library system and a very small budget item.Leave our libraries alone! Thank you for your kind consideration. Julie Katayama 7115 Ashley Dr.HB 92648 From: Pamela Blake To: supolementalcommesurfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF Subject: Support for Proposed Action Regarding HB Public Library Privatization and RFP Process Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:35:21 PM Subject: Support for Proposed Action Regarding HB Public Library Privatization and RFP Process Dear Huntington Beach City Council Members, I hope this message finds you well. My name is Pamela Blake, and I am a resident of Huntington Beach, writing to express my strong support for the council's proposed actions regarding the future management of our beloved Huntington Beach Public Library. The action items proposed to be placed on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot, as detailed in the recent council proposal, reflect a thoughtful approach to ensuring that any significant changes to our library's management are made transparently and democratically. I am particularly supportive of requiring both a majority vote of the City Council and the electors of Huntington Beach before any privatization or outsourcing of the library's management can occur. This measure not only protects our local institution but also ensures that the voices of Huntington Beach residents are heard and considered in decisions that deeply impact our community. Additionally, the decision to postpone any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) until after a public vote demonstrates a commitment to public engagement and transparency. This pause is crucial to allow for a comprehensive community discussion and to ensure that all stakeholders have the opportunity to understand and weigh in on the potential impacts of such a significant change. The Huntington Beach Public Library is more than just a repository of books; it is a community hub that fosters education, connection, and enrichment for residents of all ages. The thought of it being managed by an out-of-state company, which might not prioritize our local needs and values, is concerning. I believe that maintaining local control over our library is essential to preserving its role as a cornerstone of our community. Please consider my support as you approach the vote on June 4, 2024. I trust that you will make decisions that best reflect the interests and wishes of our community. Thank you for your time and attention to this important matter. Sincerely, Dr. Pamela Blake 18802 Lister Ln, Huntington Beach CA 92646 Plblake17@outlook.com +1-562-650-3460 From: Grego Salerno To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:35:37 PM Do not let the Library go private. There is no benefit Sincerely Gregg Salerno Sent from my iPhoneX From: Ann Hernandez To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CM0 STAFFl;suoolementalcomm )surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Input about City council Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:42:47 PM I have lived in Huntington Beach since 1988 and have been a regular patron of the library. I took our daughters there when they were little,they volunteered during the summer reading challenge programs,they did research there during high school, I've done genealogy research there, and my husband and I check out books and audio books regularly. I'm ashamed to admit that I have taken the library for granted because it was always there,ready to provide what we needed when we needed it. Recently, I've become aware of the plans of the city council majority to outsource the management of the library to a for-profit company that has no knowledge of our community and what it needs. I do not want to see this library fail, as other libraries that are managed by LS&S have done. I want to bring my grandchildren to story time when they visit from out of state. I'm no expert on libraries. I don't think most of the council members are experts on libraries, either. I do have an MBA and understand the desire to cut costs, but LS&S has not proven in other communities to actually reduce costs. The HBPL budget is less than 2%of the overall city budget.Perhaps there are other areas that are more suitable for cost-cutting measures. I know that the council majority were duly elected, and I understand that they have their priorities.However, I do not think it's right for them to make such drastic changes to our library without an explicit vote from the community. When people voted for the council majority, I don't think most people envisioned that the library would be the target for such drastic action. What the council majority wants to do would be a major change... not a simple tweak. Therefore,I strongly urge the council to support agenda item 24-350 so that our city can properly evaluate the ramifications of the takeover of our library system. Thank you for the opportunity to share my opinion on this matter. Ann Hernandez From: Gary Dutra To: suoo!ementalcommCa surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:43:51 PM From: Carol Davenoort • To: suoo!ementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 8:55:05 PM As a property owner in Huntington Beach for over 20 years,I feel that major changes to our services should be on the ballot.Therefore.It would be up to the majority of the community how changes are made. Please address this issue with'a ballot measure that everyone can voice their opinion Thanks Carol Davenport :) From: Akira BladesRover To: sunolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:04:21 PM Dear City Council Members, I'm deeply saddened and enraged by the proposal to privatize our HBPL.As a Huntington resident and a Huntington Beach High School student,I use the library services often,including coding classes,summer reading programs, checking out books,movies,and using free access to the internet.I feel welcomed at Huntington Beach Libraries and by the helpful librarians.I am currently reading Fahrenheit 451 and it seems to me that we are going down the same path through censorship.I would hope to avoid that and keep our Huntington Beach Libraries PUBLIC(Not privatized now,later,and run by the city of Huntington Beach).I am strongly against privatizing Huntington Beach Libraries. Thank you, Akira Aspas Royer From: Marie Murphy To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:04:51 PM I am totally against the City taking over our public Library. It was perfect before the City got involved. At present all the Librarians are excellent,Knowledgeable, helpful, and friendly. Leave well enough alone, From: Elizabeth SanFli000 To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF);suoolementalcomm(a surfaty-hb.orq Subject Sign Code Update—Support Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:08:57 PM I am a Huntington Beach resident for over forty years and a homeowner. I am writing to express my support for having the recommended sign code update and clarification. This approach will address the issues that resulted in the most recent primary election regarding political signs. Thank you for your consideration. Elizabeth San Filippo From: Elizabeth SanFiliapo To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CM0 STAFF);supolementalcommesurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Vote of the People Whether to Privatize/Outsource Management of HBPL and Postpone/Terminate RFP Process— Support Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:11:30 PM I am a Huntington Beach resident for over forty years and a homeowner. I am writing to express my support for having registered voters consider whether to have Managed Library Services through a for-profit entity managing our public library and to cease the RFP process. My family has used the HB library for decades and appreciates it. We have an amazing library with talented,knowledgeable librarians, a comprehensive collection of books, and great services including Story Time for children,the seed library and the Genealogical Society services.All of this would be at risk if the City contracted with a private for-profit company. Other cities have contracted with LSS and have found that they have experienced a significant decline in services and number of books available. Thank you for your consideration. Elizabeth San Filippo From: Gerald Donohue To: suoolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:14:19 PM Please listen to the citizens of HB and withdraw the notion that taking our esteemed library personnel and substituting them with a for profit regime is anything but antithetical to a sense of community. Thanks, Gerald Donohue From: Stephen MacDowell To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:14:59 PM Please support these items. Stephen MacDowell 5601 Middlecoff Huntington Beach,CA Sent from my iPhone From: Lisa Colburn To: suaolementalcommi5)surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:20:50 PM Dear city council, Please respect the beauty and heritage of our amazing public libraries and consider NOT privatizing them.I am an occupational therapist who works with children with special needs and for several years worked for a public home schooling district.I met these students in libraries in cities such as Long Beach,Lakewood,Norco,Fontana, Riverside,Murietta,and Temecula.The HB libraries are second to none.The facilities,offerings,book selection, services,and inclusion are second to none.The volunteers are amazing and I couldn't feel more fortunate to live in HB and check out books,seeds,preschool packets,etc.I strongly feel that my tax dollars are worth every penny towards our libraries and hope you respect the constituents who voted you in. Sincerely, Lisa Colburn,MS,OTR/L Sent from my iPhone From: Barbara Swift To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:29:52 PM We the people of HB deserve a voice in decisions about our beloved library! Please support this agenda item. From: Lori Brunner To: suoo!ementalcomm(alsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:33:56 PM Huntington Beach City Council, My name is Lori Brunner I have been a resident of Huntington Beach for almost 27 years. I love this city and have always loved how our council has been able to communicate, work out compromises, listen to the people and keep this city the thriving, diverse and alive community it is. We have had ups and downs, but the transparency, open dialogue and diverse opinions have made this city great. Three generations of our family use the Huntington Beach Library and we would hate to see it privatized and possibly lose the services it is so famous for. I am requesting that the council have the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 202 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting: 1) A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2) An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third- party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, I am asking that you direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting. Thank you, Lori Brunner 18142 Vestry Circle Huntington Beach, California 92648 From: Martha Hamilton To: supolementalcommasurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:34:17 PM I am asking you to consider and support Agenda Item 24-350. In order to make sure you are serving and doing the will of the people about the library, please bing ut to the voters. Martha Hamilton Sent from AT&T Yahoo Mail on Android From: Deanna Nadalin To: 5uoolementalcommCa surcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:34:22 PM To the Huntington Beach City Council,City Attorney,City Manager,and City staff: I am writing to express my wholehearted support for Agenda item 24-350,and I urge the Council members to approve and implement the proposed recommendations.The future of the CIty's library system and the services it provides should be decided by the voters. Thank you for your consideration. • Sincerely, Deanna Nadalin Huntington Beach resident for 25+years Library patron and volunteer Member,Friends of the Huntington Beach Public Library From: MARILYN Boehm To: suoolementalcommPsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: In favor of Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:37:07 PM I support Agenda Item 24-350 which would postpone the vote on privatizing the library until AFTER HB residents have had a chance to vote on doing so, or rejecting doing so, in the November election. I am personally opposed to the privatization of the library, a decision which should be made by ALL voters in November. We are still a democratic republic wherein citizens make the choices of how their public library will be funded. IF the majority City Council usurps that democratic step, it will show itself to be the authoritarian form of government you claim it isn't. The Majority City Council has acted IN SPITE of the wishes of our community as if they are rulers of our wonderful city. Just for ONCE, do something that shows you listen to your oppositional CC members and put the City's needs ahead of your own. We're just asking that this matter be placed on the BALLOT. How could it hurt? Marilyn Boehm, 25 year resident of HB From: Mary Thayer To: suoplementalcommCa)surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:38:31 PM I support Agenda Item 24-350! Mary Thayer Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Sent from my iPhone From: ritariskCalaol.com To: suoo!ementalcomm(a)surfc!ty-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:40:43 PM Please Save our Library! It is not evil. If you are worried about crimes committed on children, Outlaw the Boy Scouts and Catholic Churchs. Rita Collins Sent from AOL Desktop • From: Hello.Terry; To: suoolementalcomm(alsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:41:10 PM From: perry.Michelle To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Support agenda item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:44:23 PM Dear council, I would like to support the agenda item 24-350 to allow the privatization of our public library to come to a vote for our residents,not just 4 council members. I want our public library to remain public and I expect our residents will say the same. Dr. Michelle Ferry Get Outlook for Android From: Carole Suzuki To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:47:07 PM Hello, It appears current city council members(some)seem to have forgotten the purpose of their role.Let me refresh your memory: As council members,you are to facilitate and support efforts to improve our city.You are also supposed to listen to your constituents. In light of these obligations,please cease your efforts to privatize our beloved library and stop telling me and others what you feel is acceptable reading material. Is any council member a librarian?An educator?A child development specialist?No?Then please stay in your lane. My father was a devoted librarian for 47 years. I am a child social worker and former pre-k teacher.I operate a little free library in front of my house.The arrogance to assume your personally appointed"screeners"and yourselves are qualified to determine what is"acceptable reading material"for children is truly disturbing. Please improve our roads and infrastructure.Please put much needed funding into our parks and rec programs and our tourism.Please give more money to our libraries!!!What you are doing will only tear away,not add anything to them. Please listen to me and so many others who are IN SUPPORT OF 24-350!!! Carole Suzuki Sent from my iPhone From: Ann Palmer To: Estanislau.Robin;Toledo.Julie Cc: suoalementalcomm(alsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Ann Palmer slides for HBCC meeting 5_07_24 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:52:18 PM Attachments: Ann Palmer CC May 7 slides multi 5-06-24.potx Attached are a few brief slides for presentation during public comments at tomorrow's City Council meeting in Huntington Beach. I hope that you are able to accept these; it has taken several days to read through the hundreds of pages of attachments and references for the many agenda items. It is very impressive to see this volume of work but it must make for long days at City Hall. Please note that a few of the slides are hidden due to the number of speakers expected. I do not intend to use those. Again,I appreciate any help you can provide and hope that we all enjoy a productive session. Very best, Ann Palmer 30+yr resident HB 92648 714anniep@gnail.com 310.982.8263 la Virus-free.www.avg.com Open Letter to s ur HBPL Librarians . • Submit ALA Study to CC • Oppose Agenda Item 30) 24-350: Library outsource Agenda Item #26) 24-299: Zoning Text s � � a k�a y AkIllki,lq' t. :;g1; 24,,i; • " !y 4 x _ r a y 4 x3: ' ; -saw ,e ,...,:,,,;;;:71 ./::',. ;,.!:',4,,,,':::,:i:,.z‘,,,,i.;:,,,4' ,1,.:::!:,,,,,..,:lt,„:,,,,,';',',:r:,,,!;'t.:>1,::).r;:j.,,,;4::,..; Que n • St10 S ? ,,,,,,,,,,. 3 °'ale ` .Ill .t d i , ram .� _ e _s�avn+r .,..,,AAA ir , - x9 7-:,:,,-.,:z•...,7.-A,i4,V,.,0•.,....4.'i.P.,.7,,,d..-1;i...-,'.I Zi g,. . . a: & YES • . . 3 ? .,,,„,,Pr, 4 - „W"t i � 'kWs Wk—g S • Support partially. g • Reco: Add I . Public session t :ti , d 4 • OPPOSE 4314: 241.22 Waivers r • Instances for no EIR, no CEQA? " ..-• t. • Stacked Commercial Parking? Agenda Item #15/24-310 - Support Applaud ! ► E l r Housing Element' _Y b co , li nce:Hod ± c u tabil t Act., (C) P E SB 450 Atkins) H u i -id ; lopmen art 'oval ', 01 OP OS S 4 37'4 .Wiener P1a n1ng an4 zoning: housing3`eler er : nforcement . P SE 1 � r .fir . ► � : mi prnv l xE P 2607,E 081 navies Su ence.a use: re o e and t eat en x rogram SUPPORT.� inPr°snai + � +► c n ' lam it 1 exclusion ! PAP A1. 4 C rifor aitom �ii�A s o o :then ites:St t sAe iqui-cen enr i • OPPOSE AB 2560 - " Decommissions Coastal Commission" for Dev. • OPPOSE SB 423 - Stacks on SB35: 50% buildout at 1/2 cycle required. • OPPOSE SB 1413 - We VOTED for DAYLIGHT SAVINGS (PDT) year-round. • SUPPORT AB 2361 - Exchange of Allocation, Regional Housing (Davies) From: Helen Tvelia To: guoolementalcomm(alsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 9:53:16 PM Dear City Council Members, I was embarrassed to see Huntington Beach on the John Oliver show for the silly business the majority of the HB council have been up to. HB looks foolish and short sighted, the Fab Four need to listen to the HB residents. I firmly support keeping the library public. I am in support of Agenda Item 24-350. Thank You, Helen Tvelia From: Lev MacD To: suoolementalcomm a4surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 10:02:58 PM Dear HB Council, I respectfully request that you support Agenda Item 24-350.Thank you. Luvina Mac Dowell From: Wendy Franked To: suoo!ementalcommCa)surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 10:06:25 PM Please do not proceed with privatization of the library.It is not a good thing for Huntington Beach. Thank you, Wendy Frankel Sent from my iPhone From: SUSAN DINKMEYER To: suoo!ementalcommCa surfcity-hb.org Subject Agenda Item 24-350-I am in favor! Date: Monday,May 6,2024 10:14:03 PM • Attn: Huntington Beach City Council Members, City Manager Eric Parra, City Clerk Robin Estanislau and City Attorney Michael Gates I support Agenda Item 24-350 as submitted by Council Members Kalmick,Moser and Bolton. Please keep our wonderful public library PUBLIC. The citizens of Huntington Beach deserve to have a say on the future of our library. Let's vote on it. We do not need a third party contractor to operate the HBPL. Please stop working on preparation of a Request for Proposal(RFP)for a private contractor to operate our library. This is a wasteful and unnecessary expense. Respectfully, Susan Dinkmeyer 36-year resident of Huntington Beach From: Pat Goodman To: CITY COUNCIL,(INCL..CMO STAFF);supoIementalcomm a(�surfcity-hb.orq Subject Yes on May 7,2024 Agenda Items 29 and 30 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 10:14:11 PM Dear City Council, Please vote yes on the May 7, 2024 City Council Agenda items 29 and 30. Item 29, Update Sign Code, clarifies that political signs are allowed to be posted 60 prior to the election the candidate/ballot measure will appear on the ballot, and not 60 days prior to any election. This appears to be a recent innovation by some candidates (2022). It is very confusing to the voters to post signs for an election that they do not appear on the ballot. I know it's a challenge to get their names out in front of the voter but cluttering up the city's parkways and intersections probably have no benefit to candidates. Item 30, HB Public Library: Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsource (Charter Amendment) and Postpone/Terminate RFP Process Until After Vote, is an excellent idea to give voters the opportunity to weigh in on a possible move to privatize HBPL operations. Thank you for your consideration. Patricia Goodman Huntington Beach, CA From: Gary Wilkinson To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 10:20:00 PM Dear, Council Members, I am a 35 year resident of Huntington Beach. I sincerely hope one of the crown jewels of our great city, the Central library remains as is, in the capable hands of the employees and wonderful volunteers who have given so much to our community over the years. Yes, I suppose we could go to neighboring libraries, beaches and businesses if this takeover occurs, but it would be a sad day in my opinion. I do hope and pray these action(s) are put to a vote by all citizens. I believe we know what the outcome would be. The HB Council has a distinguished record over the years incorporating diverse views from citizens to make our city proud. As a businessman, its been an honor for me to entertain clients and show off our downtown and other landmarks. Blessings, Gary Wilkinson From: Charles Spurgeon To: uoolementalcommAsurkity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 10:21:32 PM I am embarrassed and ashamed of our"Mayor"and her three henchmen for their even flirting with the idea of privatising our wonderful PUBLIC library! Please consider the consequences and be grateful for the library as it has been managed and enjoyed as a free support Sent from Gmail Mobile From: Lsabella Roethel To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq Subject: In support of agenda item 30 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 10:25:17 PM As a resident of Huntington Beach that has enjoyed the library for years,it should be up to the community not a handful of individuals to determine the future of the library. From: Anne Gollav To: suoolementalcomm(a surfcity-hb.orq Subject: I Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 10:41:16 PM Dear Council Members, As a 40+year resident of HB,I have used our public library in so may ways-as a parent,a fervent reader,and also as a literacy volunteer. The depth and breadth of the library's programs is a testament to the dedicated librarians and staff who have ensured that HBPL is a jewel of our city. There is nothing wrong with the library that warrants outsourcing. Surely there must be other opportunities for budget offsets to maintain the library at the level of excellence we have the privilege of enjoying. I feel strongly that the residents of the city should have the opportunity to decide on this matter. I urge you to vote to place this issue on the ballot in November. Respectfully, Anne Gollay From: }carry McLachlan To: supolementalcommasurfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF) Subject Agenda Item 30 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 10:49:10 PM Huntington Beach Special City Council Meeting May 7, 2024 Agenda Item 30, No. 24-350 My name is Harry McLachlan. I am a resident of Huntington Beach. I am writing in support of agenda item 30 (24-350). The citizens of Huntington Beach should be the ones to decide whether to permit an outside company to come in, lay off our excellent librarians and support staff, and hire inferior non-union replacements at a lower wage. Our citizens regularly use and benefit from our award-winning library. They should be the ones who decide whether or not to eschew years of institutional knowledge and experience and entrust a for profit corporation beholden only to their shareholders to come in and take over management of our public library. Once again the council majority is seeking to implement a solution to a non-existent problem, as they did with placing three totally unnecessary charter amendments on the ballot for March primary election. At the time their mantra was "Let's let the voters decide." What will it be, council? Will you let the voters decide this time as well, or will you show our citizens that your hypocrisy knows no bounds by refusing to do so? Please vote yes on agenda item 30 (24-350). From: Tamara Berardi To: suoo!ementalcommCla surfcity-hb,orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 • Date: Monday,May 6,2024 10:59:54 PM Dear HB City Council Members, I have been a resident of Huntington Beach for over 40 years. I remember visiting our beautiful Central Park Library for the first time and being so impressed by the staff, great selection of books and many things it offered. I am still in awe of what a great library we have. Lately,the library and it's staff have been under attack and I think this suggestion to outsource our library services is retribution for the pushback on having our Council try to make decisions that should be left up to the library. I don't believe outsourcing will save money in the long term and that it will negatively affect our library system here in the city. I urge you to table this bad idea. If you should decide to move forward then I believe this should be put on the ballot for the citizens to decide. This is too big of a change for-4 City Council members to decide for a city of our size and a topic that has us so divided. Respectfully, Tamara Berardi 19641 Lexington Ln,Huntington Beach, CA 92646 From: Tim Channel To: CITY COUNCIL,(INCL.CMO STAFF);suoolementalcommesurfcity-hb.orq Cc: Tim Channel Subject: In Stong Support of Agenda Items#29(24-337)and#30(24-350) Date: Monday,May 6,2024 11:04:39 PM Council Members, As a 36 year resident and home owner in Huntington Beach I urge you to Approve agenda items#29 and#30. I am particularly offended by the unmitigated gall at the majority's attempt intent to privitize the Huntington Beach Library System ignoring overwhelming public opposition at doing so. You brag in the press about how the"will of the voters"approved measure A,so let the voters decide!Approve agenda item#30(24-350).Approve this measure! If you win in a fair election,you can claim victory.Until then,many residents will hold you accountable for failing to listen to your constituents once again. Tim Channel 36 Year Resident,Homeowner,Tax Payer,Business Owner and Voter Sent from my iPhone From: iIs18762Ca)amail.conl To: suaolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 11:16:55 PM As a home owner and 30 year resident of Huntington Beach, I support Agenda Item 24- 350. Please stop the RFP until the entire budget gets the same attention as the small portion it takes to run one of the best libraries in the country. Regards, James Sutton From: Jacqueline Brodt To: sunolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq Subject Support for Agenda item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 11:17:22 PM Hello, My name is Jacqueline Brodt, resident of Huntington Beach. I am a former Board Member of the Friends of the Library and a current Board Member of the Huntington Beach Wetlands Conservancy. I am so proud to be a part of these two great organizations because they both do so much good for ALL of the residents of Huntington Beach and ALL who visit Huntington Beach. This is what Huntington Beach used to be about.Acceptance, Respect, Consideration of others, even if we didn't agree on things. It is a shame that we have become a city of hatred.A city with a lack of respect for those that do not think like you.A city that is divided.A city that has become a mockery for those that follow what is happening with our current City Council. I want to thank all the reporters who have been following and reporting what has been going on these past few months. I especially want to do a huge shout out to Tyrone Beason from the LA Times for last weekend's article about Huntington Beach,the LGBTQ+(Plus)community, and the ban of the Pride flag. I also have to mention the show, "Last Week Tonight with John Oliver". His last show was about books being removed from Libraries&Schools and the book bans that are happening across the country. He also mentioned Huntington Beach and it is sad to say it was so right on. Our city is definitely getting a lot of coverage nationwide and it is not the kind of publicity we should or would want. As for Agenda Item 24-350,THANK YOU to Dan, Natalie, and Rhonda for writing this. I know this is falling on deaf ears but I have to ask/beg you to let the residents of Huntington Beach to vote and decide how the library should be run. Please, I am begging you... PASS this agenda. Thank you, Jacqueline Brodt From: Buffie Channel To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CM0 STAFF);suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Agenda Items 29&30-Support Date: Monday,May 6,2024 11:17:32 PM To City Council Members: I aw writing today to express my support for Agenda Item 29 and 30. Agenda Item 29: I think all residents agree that the political signage in public thoroughfares and on public spaces has gotten completely out of control. It's a blight on our city and with wind and weather signs flying, coming loose, and turning into litter is not a positive way of supporting our candidates and is not a good look for a coastal environmental town. In addition, it seems some candidates have now taken advantage and put their signs up 8 months before their race. That is unacceptable and unethical.Let's keep signs for our favored candidates constrained to our own yards. I support Agenda Item#29. Agenda item 30: if the City Council truly believes in the input of the people and democracy, they will vote for Item 30. The tax payers of this city have paid for the libraries and their contents. It is not for Council members to have the power to change the management of OUR PUBLIC LIBRARIES to a CORPORATION.Present the facts of the RFP, all costs and analysis, all Pros and Cons, all history of other cities that have tried it, all details about Mike Posey's personal gain, all details about future staffing, all details about any hours or days that will be cut so the corporation can make a profit, and full transparency of how they will turn a profit—AND THEN LET THE VOTERS DECIDE. We the people should vote on it. Support Agenda Item#30. It will be interesting to see if Burns, Van der Mark,McKeown, and Strickland vote against this. If they do, it will be a hypocritical vote. Listen to the people. Your constituents have consistently and repeatedly spoken out against privatizing/outsourcing Library Services. IF YOU ARE TRULY CONFIDENT THAT THIS IS WHAT THE PEOPLE WANT,DON'T BE SCARED—PUT IT TO A VOTE. Sincerely, Buffie Channel 35 year resident From: Sharon Petersen To: suoolementalcomm(alsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 11:54:11 PM Dear HB Council members: As an educator,a long time Huntington Beach resident,and a Registered VOTING citizen, I am dismayed and disappointed at the series of recent actions take by the the 4-3 votes of the council.You obviously are not listening to the hundreds of residents who have called,emailed and written regarding the attacks on our public library. Public libraries are a cornerstone of our democracy! This dates back to the very foundation of this nation. If you want an authoritarian,dictatorship,get rid of public libraries. Libraries are In a place of safety where residents can explore ALL POINTS OF VIEW. It must be a welcoming place,with professionally trained librarians are available to guide and assist residents of all ages find information,resources and yes,inspiration in the books and other materials available. In a true Democracy,no one gets to decide what is good for someone else to read or research.Censorship gives some group of people the right to decide what other people can read and research. NO ONE HAS THAT RIGHT in a DEMOCRACY! Privatization smacks of taking a public service institution and trying to make a profit for an individual or some anonymous stockholders. What's next,privatize the police,the fire department and serve only a select,elite group of individuals?? This is a very dangerous path and could lead to many unintended consequences. Do you want an authoritarian government? Just look at history and read a few history books,if there are any left after the censors get through. Frankly,I find the involvement of a former council member a huge conflict of interest. Are Council members getting lobbied,getting monetary contributions,getting payoffs?? I would hate to see Huntington Beach in the headlines for having a corrupt City Council. Protect yourselves and our community. Support Agenda item 24-350 Sharon Petersen 30 plus years resident of Huntington Beach Sent from my iPad • From: Heidi Jung To: suoolementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 12:35:31 AM It is imperative that our Huntington Beach City Council protect our public library operations and librarians.As a mother of two school aged children who love the library,we do not want the library privatized or interfered with by outside entities.Please support agenda item 24-350. Thank you, Heidi Pallares From: Carol Carser To: sugnlementalcomm(a)surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Ubrary! Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 12:59:40 AM This banner message in front of Main Street says it all .... An institution is only as good as its people working for it! Our City Council majority could have gracefully ushered Michael Posey to the door some time ago -- but instead "took a bite of the apple" he was peddling only to disgrace the wonderful professionals, volunteers and residents who continue breathing life into a literary institution as chaos surrounds them. SHAME, SHAME, SHAME! Let the voices of the people decide what's best for their city! From: ,acgpelyn Jones To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 1:29:33 AM Please address the following: Direct the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5. 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4. 2024 City Council Meeting: 1) A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2) An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third- party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting It is important to maintain our city library system as it is. Deciding to privatize the management of the library will bring the elimination and/or slash library programs to such a degree that it will cause many people in our community to lose access to valuable resources that they need to support their lives. Yours truly, Jacquelyn Jones A Huntington Beach Resident Sent from my iPad From: Malu bautistq To: suoolementalcomm(a surfdty-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 2:30:30 AM Save our library.It's called PUBLIC Library for a reason-Maria Sent from my iPhone From: .LA To: 5uoolementalcommna surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 3:06:16 AM Dear City Council, My husband and I grew up here in Huntington Beach and the library has been everything to us. Since we were little we'd go there to enjoy and checkout books and the arts. As we got older it was a refuge, a place where we would go after school and study all night,the place that kept us out of trouble. The librarians experienced and quick to direct us to what we needed. Now the award winning story times, children's plays,trick-or-treat and other events that are our children's favorite time of day along with free play could be in jeopardy. With all the hiking of prices in Huntington Beach getting to the point of trying to drive us out of town, the library is our safe place, our anchor and refuge. The one thing that is for us,the community and now it could be sold, bought and taken away? If you sell it who knows what the "agenda" will be. Cut back hours, cut back employees salaries, cut back or cut out story time, children and adult plays,performances, events like trick-or-treat or the garbage truck and horses coming to visit the children. Will they charge for a private study room or get rid of them to use for themselves?What about free tutoring for children like mine who struggle with learning,the steam program,the book clubs with free books?The most important quality enrichment that the city provides its youth that's free is education, information and arts and the library cultivates that especially for low income families like ourselves. We are teachers and nurses and although we contribute and give back to our community are wages just barely get us by with our 4 children. Please don't sell to a private corporation. Who knows what their agenda might be. We are grasping at straws here, please don't take this away too. We have so much money living in our city. There must be other ways of getting more contributions to fund the few free things we really need like the public library system. Look at all the money the air show brings in. There has to be more alternatives to keep this essential resource to the community. Please please give us our libraries at the very least please give us this. Sincerely, The Alonso Family Jacquelyn,Alex, Joshua,Lucas,Alex Junior&Jackson 19521 Canberra In Huntington Bch, CA 92646 (714)878-5903 From: Lc To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF) Cc: suanlementalcamm 5)surfcity-hb.orq Subject: 5-7-24 City Council Meeting,6PM Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 3:13:20 AM Agenda Item 30 I do not support this agenda item. ' If costs need to be addressed now,make the changes now. Whatever the majority City Council Members feel needs to be done, then that's what should be done. Maybe even close some Library Branches Jean Cloyd resident of Huntington Beach From: Sue Wilkinson To: suoolementalcomm a4surfcity-hb.or4 Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 3:14:41 AM Dear City Council I urge you to support Agenda Item 24-350. I have been a resident of Huntington Beach for over 55 years.My mother worked hard back in the '70s to pass bond measures to fund our parks and libraries.Her work helped give us our beautiful Library and Central Park. It is my opinion that outsourcing the library services would destroy our library. Some services are appropriate for outsourcing such as trash and recycling but not Library services. Please support Agenda Item 24-350. Thank You Susan Wilkinson From: diannef22Ca)vahoo.conl To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF);suoolementalcomm()surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item#30 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 4:03:23 AM I am writing in support of agenda item#30. Fundamentally changing the operation of the city's library should certainly be up to the people of this city. The library and its assets were all paid for by the people of Huntington Beach and it should be up to the people to decide if the management of that asset should be handed over to an outside company. The Council majority claims that it has talked with lots of citizens that agree with the actions they have been taking. Putting the management of the library on the ballot is an easy way to find out if that is true. In the meantime, the RFP should be paused until the citizens have had a chance to vote if they want it to move forward. Thank you, Dianne James From: John Phibbs To: sugplementalcommCa)surfcity-hb.arq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 5:41:15 AM Honorable council members, I find it interesting that there is a drive to privatize the library.Have you been in the library lately?It's amazing how many people utilize that resource. If the intent is to save money, You should expand this endeavor to include other departments within the cities budget. Identify those departments,with the highest budgets and with low hanging fruit. Including police and fire departments. For example, sending pumper trucks to medical emergencies. Pumper trucks and paramedic trucks seems very expensive to assist someone out of the bathtub. LA county sends three people in an emergency transport.And with the savings,populate the city with more fire stations to improve response times. That's just an example,but I think that is worthy looking into. I've worked most of my life for two very large Southern California companies, including times when budgets were constrained, and we always looked for the low hanging fruit with the biggest impact. John Phibbs Huntington Beach Citizen since 1965 Retired Thephibbster@gmail.com From: Mark Dixon To: suoofementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 6:00:46 AM Good Morning - I am writing to convey my strong support for the VOTERS, and not the four-person majority of the Huntington Beach City Council, to decide whether the Huntington Beach Public Library should be operated by a hired management company. It's not broken -please direct your attention and the City's resources to areas that need fixing. Respectfully, Mark W. Dixon Huntington Beach Resident for 52 years (657)489-3719 From: Elizabeth Callaghan To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 6:44:58 AM I support agenda item 24-350. Keep our library PUBLIC. From: Patricia Kinq To: suoolementalcommCa)surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 6:48:10 AM I support agenda item 24-350 which requires a vote of the people to privatize/outsource the HB Public Library and postpone/terminate the RFP process until after the vote. Please do not discount this email. Patricia King 8642 Lowmead Drive,HB From: cornetto45aearthlink.net To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq Subject Put Privatization on the ballot Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 6:49:22 AM I love the airshow on one hand because the planes are so exciting, and it shows our great USAF. Having a USAF plane kick-off the Rose Parade shows the world what our Airforce can do. But on the other hand, it is not clear to me how much it costs the taxpayers of Huntington Beach. The city of Huntington Beach decided to privatize the airshow from the start. The city did not have the expertise in running the airshow. But since 1909, the city of Huntington Beach has had volunteers and staff that has resulted in the HBPL. Today, the "Friends of the HBPL", raises a lot of money, and allows volunteers to enrich our community. And the HBPL is an award winning asset for the City of Huntington Beach. Some people choose to live in Huntington Beach because of the library, and it increases property values. It was one reason I chose to move to Huntington Beach years ago. Right now, there is no "Friends of the Airshow". Maybe there should be a "Friends of the Airshow", that could involve volunteers and enrich the community. But volunteering to help a for-profit company is not a popular thing to do. But we do have a small committee of"Friends of the Airshow", the F5 on the city council. A lot of people attend the library all year long. How many people attend the airshow, not as many? No one ever forced everyone to attend the library, but for 4 days everyone in Huntington Beach is forced to hear the airshow. Some people like it, but some don't. Again, I like the Airshow, but how much does it cost? 2 million dollars a year is well spent on the HBPL, privatizing to save a million dollars a year is the wrong thing to do. How many tax dollars go to the Airshow? we don't know. Is it worth spending 5 million dollars for the Airshow? I'd rather spend it on the Library. Let's put privatization of HBPL on the ballot. Charlie Jackson 23 year resident of Huntington Beach From: Amy Black To: suoolementalcomm(1a surfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL.(INCL.CM0 STAFFI Subject: Add to November Ballot:library system changes Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:00:26 AM Hello HB City Council, I cannot make the city council meeting today but implore you all to add the privatization of our library to the November ballot.Let the people of our city decide what they feel is best for our library system.We as taxpayers have a right to decide what the outcome is. Thank you, Amy Black Taxpayer and concerned HB resident From: Natalie Croswell To: suoolementalcommaa surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:04:08 AM Hello council members, I am writing in support of tonight's agenda item 24-350, in favor of bringing the privatization of our public library and RFP process to a public vote by the residents of Huntington Beach. Specifically: Direct the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting: 1) A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2) An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting Best, Natalie Croswell HB born and raised and currently raising my family here From: )udv cawlev To: 5uoolementalcommi)surfdty-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:05:03 AM I support the approval of Agenda Item 24-350. The Public Library should remain Public. And it should be the Public that decides what happens to it. Judy Cawley 19572 Sardinia Lane Huntington Beach, CA 92646 From: Alan Pirinq To: suoolementalcomm4surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:06:11 AM HB City Council, My wife and I are long time residents of Huntington Beach and are writing in support of Agenda Item 24-350 and the HB Public Library. Thank you in advance for your consideration of this serious matter. Best regards, Alan and Cindy Piring 32-year residents of HB Sent from my iPhone From: dineka ringlinq To: crr COUNCIL(INCL.CM0 STAFF);supolementalcomm(@surfdty-hb.orq Subject: Opposition to Privatization/Outsourdng of Huntington Beach Public Library Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:10:16 AM Dear Members of the Huntington Beach City Council, I am writing to express my extreme disapproval of the proposed item 24-350 regarding the potential privatization or outsourcing of the Huntington Beach Public Library(HBPL).As a resident and avid user of the library,I strongly believe that libraries are a fundamental public resource and beacon of knowledge that should remain under public control and management. Libraries play a crucial role'in our communities by providing access to information, education, and cultural enrichment for people of all backgrounds and socioeconomic statuses.Privatizing or outsourcing the management of the HBPL could jeopardize the quality of services provided, - limit access to resources, and undermine the essential role that libraries play in promoting literacy and lifelong learning. The proposal to place a Charter Amendment and advisory vote on the November 5,2024, General Election ballot is deeply concerning. I urge you to reconsider this course of action and prioritize the preservation of the HBPL as a public institution accountable to the community it serves. Furthermore, I implore you to halt any further progress on the Request for Proposals (RFP) related to the outsourcing of library operations. Instead, I encourage the City Council to engage in meaningful dialogue with residents, library staff, and stakeholders to explore alternative solutions that uphold the integrity and accessibility of the HBPL for generations to come. Sincerely, Dineka Ringling HB Resident&Library Lover From: nora aedersen To: suoolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF) Subject: Agenda Item 30,24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:15:25 AM I support Agenda Item 30, 24-350. A vote of the people is necessary. We the people have spoken overwhelmingly against privatizing our public library. This institution has served us well for over one hundred years. Our precious library is not the possession of the city council majority extremists. If the extremist four listened to heart felt public voices, they would know that there is no mandate for privatization. If they did their research, they would learn that there are very little cost savings, if any, from outsourcing. If the extremist four actually read in public libraries, they would never support outsourcing of professional librarians. It is quite a disappointment to see that the majority four would rather sacrifice quality to line the pockets of our former and unpopular mayor who now is an agent for the East Coast private library corporation than sing praise for our public library and our dedicated professional librarians. Our library is a treasure that is vital to our community. Libraries foster critical thinking, education, creativity, and pure enjoyment. Please vote in favor of Agenda Item 30 for the people of Huntington Beach. Please direct the City Manager to stop any further work on the Request for Proposal until after the people have voted in November. Nora Pedersen 37 year resident, Huntington Beach From: Kristy List To: suoolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:17:46 AM To Huntington Beach City Council: As a resident of Huntington Beach, voter, and library patron, I strongly urge you to support the following: 1) A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2) An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting Let the voters decide what is best for our library! The library means too much to too many residents to allow it to be operated by a private contractor. Thank you, Kristy List From: Aoril Downs To: suoolementalcomm(a surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Let the People Vote Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:22:00 AM Hi City Council -I'm writing in support of Rhonda Bolton, Dan Kalmick and Natalie Moser's agenda item to put the highly contested privatizing of the library to a public vote. It's clear this change concerns a significant portion of our city's population so put the issue on the November ballot. Sincerely, April Downs Sent from my iPhone • From: Susan Turner To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFFL suoolementalcomm(a)surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Opposition to Library Outsourcing Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:23:33 AM Dear City Council Members, I am a 60 year resident of Huntington Beach. I strongly oppose the privatization of our City's awesome library system. I have used this library system since I was a young person. My children have used the library all of their lives. We have an amazing library with amazing staff. It is near impossible to understand why we would change the system that works so well. I strongly oppose City Council making any changes to the library system including outside group deciding what books will be available, what hours will be open, which branches will be opened or closed and which programs will be available. I understand that part of the argument is based on finances, but really? If finances were the issue of concern, the City Council would not have voted to waste money putting those three amendments on the last ballot, or paid off the Airshow. What about costs future lawsuits we will endure related to Voter ID requirements, and if we make it through those, the incredible costs of running our own elections. No, outsourcing the library to fund newsmaking priorities of the few over the majority of the citizens who spoke out against the wastes of our conservative council members projects is just WRONG! Please reconsider or at least allow the HB citizens to vote on the idea in November. Thank you, Susan Turner From: Mary Ann Celinder To: suDDlementalcomm(alsurfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFFI Subject: Library Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:30:35 AM I strongly support putting the outsourcing of the library on the November ballot for the people to decide. Staff should be spending their time on productive and needed issues,not this very unpopular proposal. It is wrong to privatize a perfectly functioning public resource. It is wrong to have to have 4 HB citizens put in place by 14%of the voters direct this crazy scheme to politicize our libraries. I also very strongly object to have a committee of non librarians judging what should be in our libraries. Librarians, with library science degrees, are far more suited to make these decisions. Mary Ann Celinder 21341 Fleet Lane Huntington Beach Ca 92646 studio 714 962 8361 cell 714 504 8361 www.customleadedglass.com From: Amanda Furches To: suoplementalcomm4surfcity-hb.org Subject Pro on 30 and 27 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:31:21 AM Please vote yes on agenda item 24-350 putting privatization on the ballot in November and yes on agenda item 24-316-approving weed abatement.This should be BEFORE weeds go to seed.These invasives-radish,mustard,cheeseweed,sow thistle,etc are fire hazards and have outcompeted our native plants species and many of the 1400 bee species bstive to CA Amanda herring resident 16707 s.Pacific ave sunset beach ca 90742 Sent from my iPhone From: Claudia Locke To: suoolementalcomm(a surfcity-hb.org Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:34:05 AM Dear City Council Members, As a family of more than 30 years of residence in the City of Huntington Beach, we are requesting your support to Agenda Item 24-350. Huntington Beach Public Library System should not be overseen and run by a private company. Our public libraries belong to all the residents (taxpayers) of the City of HB. The residents of HB are the ones who should make the decision of having the public libraries run by a private company or not. This decision will impact our next generation of residents. We would like to continue counting with the great services and programs that our HBPL currently is offering to its patrons. We would like to see our grandchildren enjoying these wonderful services and programs the same as our son did while he was growing up. Thank you for your support of this agenda item 24-350. The Locke Family From: Bye«+ To: suoolementalcommesurfcity-hb.orq Subject Support Agenda item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:35:45 AM To Huntington Beach City Council: As a resident of Huntington Beach, voter, and library patron, I strongly urge you to support the following: 1) A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2) An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting Let the voters decide what is best for our library! The library means too much to too many residents to allow it to be operated by a private contractor. Thank you, Ryan List From: sh000inotam(@aol.com To: suoolementalcommCa)surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:40:13 AM As a parent, grandparent, business owner in Huntington Beach, resident of over 30 years and homeowner of over 25 years, I am expressing my support for the library. Any changes should be voted on BY THE PEOPLE, and not changed by some crazy people on the council. Please stop this madness. My vote and voice will be heard next election against these uneducated members! Tammy Kist From: Alexander Kovalchuk To: suoulementalcomm(asurfcity-hb.orq Subject: liberty Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:40:30 AM Hello please don't make liberty private but rather let it be open to everyone so they can learn real truth. Thank you. From: Nadine To: suoo!ementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:41:35 AM I support agenda ITEM 24-350 THANK YOU Nadine Davis 5142 Stallion Circle Huntington Beach From: Virginia Kalb To: 5uoolementalcomm4surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:41:42 AM I support agenda item 24-350.it gives the citizens of Huntington beach the opportunity to vote for an issue of importance.Please vote in favor of this agenda item. Virginia Kalb Sent from my iPad From: Linda Fitch To: suoolementalcomm(lsurfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:42:41 AM Hi, I support this agenda item. Linda Fitch 16514 N. Pacific Ave. Sunset Beach, Ca 90742 From: Cathey Ryder To: suoolementalcomm(asurfdty-hb.org Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:54:59 AM Cathey Ryder " Optimism is the faith that leads to achievement. Nothing can be done without hope and confidence." Helen Keller From: Bruce Allen To: suoolementalcommt surfcil'-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:56:19 AM Huntington Beach City Council Members: I wholeheartedly support Agenda Item 24-350. While I won't be able to actually attend the council meeting, I'll be there in spirt and will be watching the proceedings online. • This MAGA-inspired madness against our wonderful HB library must stop! Ultimately, it will be obvious to the vast majority of the HB population that the heavy-handed tactics of the current HB City Council conservative majority was on the wrong side of history.The only question is just how much damage will be done in the interim and at what cost, not only financially but also to our democracy. Sincerely, Bruce Allen 5561 Serene Drive Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Virus-free.www.avg.corn From: John Carser To: supolementalcomm(a surfcity-hb.org Subject Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:57:39 AM Again, I am writing to the HB City Council to express reconsideration of outsourcing the management of our libraries to LS &S. Instead, I encourage you to support agenda item 24-350. Leave this important, very "public" and volatile issue up to our 200,000 residents to vote on at the General Election in November. Our "public" library system has successfully existed for 114 years without privatizing it, and there is no evidence that it is warranted now! Look elsewhere to cut corners by starting with the generous staffing for the City Attorney! You can also STOP the idiotic filing of lawsuits and the subsequent required responses that follow. It's time to hear the voices of the residents, the taxpayers and the stakeholders. John Carser Sent from my iPad From: Lfromca1, To: suns!ementalcomm(asurfdty-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CM0 STAFF) Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:00:48 AM Dear City Counc members, No, no, NO to privatization! Our Huntington Beach Library system is extremely efficient. In fact, it is the most efficient library system in the county. It uses only 1.9% of the budget. Our librarians are qualified professionals and they are an integral part of having a library that serves our community. Outsourcing library management would decrease the effect the library has on public education, and even our very democracy. This library system depends upon and works because of the 30o volunteers who give their time. The programs that would be lost because of the loss of volunteers would be very detrimental to the children and families in our community. Mayor Van Der Mark, Mr. Burns, Mr. McKeon, and Mr. Strickland,please, please, PLEASE do NOT vote to privatize our library! Regards, Lana Fossum HB Central Library Volunteer From: Greg Hansen To: suoolementalcommCa surfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:00:56 AM Dear City Council, Please pass Agenda Item 24-350. Let the people decide the fate of OUR library. Thank you, Greg Hansen Sent from my iPad From: ponna Rvburrl To: suoolementalcommPsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:01:40 AM Dear City Council, Once again,we are writing to say we are adamantly opposed to the privatization of our beloved city library.We are very disappointed that you,as our choose representatives,would consider this unnecessary idea. Sincerely, Don and Donna Ryburn 9842 La Cresta Huntington Beach From: Melanie Tioleco-Chenq To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF);suoolementalcomrresurfaty-hb.org Subject: In SUPPORT of Agenda item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:03:08 AM "The only thing that you absolutely have to know, is the location of the library." Albert Einstein "Libraries were full of ideas — perhaps the most dangerous and powerful of all weapons." Sarah J. Maas I could probably pull a million quotes about libraries that I love. I have grown up and also raised my kids on books. Books are a powerful tool and weapon, an escape, and, most obviously, a source of knowledge. Perhaps this is the most compelling reason for book bans--taking away our choice of knowledge. While there are several countries in which the government has control over what its citizens have access to, I never thought that the US would be one of them. Book banning--and selecting a 'committee' who has not been trained like our knowledgeable librarians--is the first step in taking away knowledge and choice and freedom. I have been pleasantly surprised to see many like-minded individuals here in HB-- every time I have written an email or attended a city council meeting, the vast majority of HB citizens have said that they do not support book bans. And while the council majority still won't call it a book ban, I think they just don't understand the meaning of the words. Or worse, they do. My point is that the PRIVATIZATION of our free and public library is WRONG. And I believe that the choice should go to vote, not decided upon by four people who may have special interests in the privatization of our libraries. We keep writing emails, showing up to meetings, and there are groups with peaceful protest walks and read-ins. When will our voices be heard? I support Agenda item 24-350. Stop telling me what my kids should and should not read. Leave this decision up to parents and guardians, not the government. Sincerely, Melanie Tioleco-Cheng Book reader, librarian supporter, parent of bookworms, writer, Pediatrician HB resident x 21 years, HB library patron x 21 years From: Judith Hendler To: suoolementalcomm(alsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:05:39 AM I stand with Bolton, Kalmick and Moser in support of Agenda Item 24-350 in support of the HB Public Library. Judith Hendler From: Susan Hansen To: suoolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:06:38 AM Dear City Council, Please support this agenda item and keep this wonderful community resource in its present state. Susan Hansen Sent from my iPhone From: Pat Seiler To: suoplementalcomm aC)surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:09:26 AM Honorable Council Members, 1) A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2) An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third- party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting Pat Seiler 714.397.4297 . From: Lisa Angela Gibilie To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Agenda 24=350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:17:07 AM I am requesting you consider the above agenda, The people should be able to vote in a general election about what happens to our libraries. It is not popular to outsource management of our libraries. There is no proof it will not add costs since the Friends of the Library will not provide donations nor volunteers to a private company. I ask that the City Council desist from considering additional RFP's regarding library management companies. Outsourcing library management may work well in smaller communities which don't have existing libraries. It has been found to be unsuccessful in areas where the outside companies damaged libraries like in Escondido and ended up costing more money as in Santa Clarita, Oregon, Fullerton and more. Our libraries are 1,9%of the City budget and the benefits to the city are immeasurable. Cities and states with the highest literacy rates also have good libraries available to their people. It is unimaginable that some on this City Council have listened to so many of our neighbors and callously dismissed them or threatened to kick them out of the room. Oregon county library report critical of LS&S-Escondido Times-Advocate Oregon county library report critical of LS&S - • Escondido Times-Advocate A report on a county library system in Oregon run by the same company the city plans to hire to run its library... Public-Private Partnerships Are Quietly Hollowing Out Our Public Libraries I Truthout Sincerely, Lisa Gibilie When I started counting my blessings, my whole life turned around. Willie Nelson When the power of love overcomes the love of power the world will know peace. Jimi Hendrix From: Le-Thu Phan To: suoo!ementalcomml@sur city-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:17:22 AM I oppose the private management of our public library. People need to manage their own life,not relying on the library to do it. Freedom to public library! LeThu Phan 8777 Coral Springs Ct,Huntington Beach, CA 92646 From: Ann Schoeff To: 5uoolementalcomm(a surfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:20:28 AM I support agenda item 24-350 and would like you to terminate the RFP regarding privatizing our library system until after the people of Huntington Beach have been able to vote on the issue. Our library system and our librarians are an amazing asset to our community. I am a 28 year resident that appreciates and uses this wonderful resource and I am astounded that you would even consider privatization. Please re-focus your efforts somewhere else;you are creating problems, not solving them. Ann Schoeff From: Parker Baughman To: suoolementalcommOsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Agenda#30 Pub.Comment Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:24:32 AM Id like to add a public comment regarding the library.Abridged version at bottom. Unabridged: I want to make an appeal for the hesitant folks considering the library's proposed fate.Every hour youth spend at this library is another hour that isn't spent doing what is considered by yourself as degenerate(I.e.drugs,unsafe sex, rotting in their secluded bedroom,et cetera).Many deride the dependency on the internet and solitary nature of teens yet shrug off pitching in to provide a place everyone benefits from at no extra cost.This is the largest library in the area and with the most amenities for reading about history,the arts,faith,and biology.All of this for what?A few bucks off your own taxes.What would you prefer them to go towards?I doubt a private equity firm has the best interest of youth living in a place that means nothing but chart numbers to them.Why not contribute yourself to help people be outside in the world and enjoying the company of a community?Where else do students have to go for studying?Schools often are closed before the evening arrives,and their libraries are even more scant.There are some who say"nobody even goes to the library anymore.Why does this matter all of a sudden?"Because this is one of the best ways to actualize that opinion. Abridged: The killer of any society is a fear of a weed that is nonexistent,crushing every plant in case one were a dandelion,or crabgrass.In your hubris and self centeredness you damn the youth you say you care for to unfeeling private groups that only serve to oust them in place of higher paying customers,striking the CENTRAL area of knowledge and accessibility.They become dumb,blind,and degenerate as you'd like to describe them.It's said the older you are, the wiser you are,and the clearer things become,but teenagers don't tend to get cataracts very often,do they?How embarrassed God must be of you. From: Gary Casamentq To: supolementalcomm ai surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:26:44 AM To: Huntington Beach City Council Members, My name is Gary Casamento and I have been a homeowner, resident and taxpayer in Huntington Beach for over 40 years. I am writing today to express my STRONGEST support for Agenda Item 24-350 Direct the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions,ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot and agendize for a vote at our June 4, 2024 City Council Meeting 1. A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the city's electors in order to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings 2. An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting I am outraged by the council meeting I attended in which the subject of removing the decision making power over which books the library contains was removed from the trained, educated professional staff of librarians.This after almost 6 hours of public comment where well over 95%of the speakers, Huntington Beach voters OPPOSED the action,the council voted along strict party lines to adopt the measure anyway. The Huntington Beach Library has been a point of civic pride for me and my wife for over 40 years and is one of the reasons I chose to move to this city in the first place.Your actions over the past 12 months and this proposed privatization have turned the library into a national point of humiliation for the city. You were elected to represent the will of the voters,yet you act in the interest of 5%and against 95%. I strongly urge you to place these items on the November ballot and hear,AND LISTEN to what the voters actually want. Regards, Gary Casamento gcasamento@socal.rr.com From: ghirleynixan(aolvmous.net To: suoplementalcomm(asurfdty-hb.orq Subject Pause further action on Library privatization RFP Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:29:07 AM Dear City Council Members, Please direct the city's management staff to cease work on developing a Request for Proposals to privatize the city library system. Please also support Agenda item 24-350 to allow the public at large to weigh in on this issue. Shirley Nixon Huntington Beach, CA 92646 From: midne hill To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CM0 STAFFI Cc: suoolementalcomm( surfcity-hb.orq Subject: 7-May Agenda,Item 30 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:30:00 AM Good morning Mayor Van der Mark and Council members, I have followed the story of the RFP process for bids to operate our city libraries, as well as the Parent/Guardian Book Review Committee. At this time,I am requesting a vote of YES to agenda item 30, being introduced at the council meeting this evening. I believe these topics have raised much response from your constituents of Huntington Beach. Our libraries are the most public-facing service to our city and therefore deserve more input from the broader spectrum of citizens by a vote of the citizenry in November. I hope you will work together, as a team, to ensure such a community-building service, such as the libraries,will continue to thrive in the best possible scenario. Regards, Midge A.Hill Resident since 1992 Virus-free.www.avg.com From: John Calcaano To: suoolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:40:14 AM SAVE OUR LIBRARY! John Calcagno, 38 year BB resident From: Jaime Kauffman Palumbo To: suoolementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq Subject Agenda Item 30 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:43:18 AM Hello, We would like to voice our support for agenda item 30.Our beloved library is a community asset that has been built up over the last century.It is a treasured part of our city.We do not think it is fair for a temporary panel of four people to give away that asset.It should be up to the community that built the library to decide if it should be outsourced to a private equity firm.Let us decide if we want to outsource our library and halt this process. Thank you, Jaime and John Palumbo From: Mark Finer To: suoolementalcomm(aisurfcity-hb.org Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:44:34 AM As a native born son of Huntington Beach and current owner of two rental properties I feel it is my civic duty to write in support Agenda Item 24-350.I am not alone in this support amongst my friends and family that still live in HB. Mark Finer Set Dressing Buyer Untitled Erin Foster Show 714-651-8113 markfiner@gmail.com From: starsstrioes(@me.corn To: CITY COUNCIL.(INCL.CM0 STAFFS Cc: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq Subject City Council meeting 5-7-24 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:47:16 AM Agenda Item 30 I do not support Agenda Item 30. If our costs are too high and need to be addressed, address the issue now. We elected this majority council to address these issues and that is what they should do now. If it means that we need to shut down some branches,then so be it. Rob Cloyd Resident of Huntington Beach From: Linda To: suoolementalcommesurfdty-hb.orq Subject Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:48:07 AM It is unfortunate that we have to be putting energy into trying to save something as important as our.public library-something that is working just fine as it is. There are so many other things in HB that are not ok and that is where the council should be focusing their energy. Please leave the library alone. As a volunteer there I have never heard a complaint, it is always praise for what a.great place with so many wonderful services. Thank you. Linda Mendelssohn From: tm.Ny.6tmok5 To: suolecomtelcomma utCca itD.om Subject: Please do NOT privatize the library Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:48:25 AM Attachment= (at all,R09 Imaa.002u2o9 InismQ03.ma o9®1=1909 UnaaeQ95.9oa SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICA,TIO Members;of to') j tb8c ;unable to personally Participate uY :the rg eettng •but: lrtte siear# In oommtintetalog with She iy Council on agenda. fated iieme are encot#uged ar submit $wrfUet {attpple itental) t~ro►ltjtrtt siicattert =to tttd -SuvolementarColnm txon Suppler'nentet Con+nlutnreadoas are P rt lic record.:t1d r�tuesf by 9fao AM a ttte da�i of,the teeting 1atA dtstribute�d to Ibe Citjr Council prior tp •consideration of .agenda.related ciana announced, but fQfi read ai tffie meeting titttrjtunrcatfi ns roved after the BOO AM deet3ltnp will be rncarporeted info tfre admmisba ro reclard it+lembers a #te pu fia ats !#o wetaame to communicate with the°City Conncii {and stag supporting,t ottrt gt,.trKy C until Dee Dee Zeek,RHU REBC CFCI Surf City Financial Group C&c Ha[a o S.EQrlt?E-41El.QFI?filsg to DK,Ong 0:714.698-6400 replaces 714.377-1400 x 103 M:949.456-1200 deedeel SurfCilyFnancIalGreuo.cam- CA License 0E55371 From: Deborah Harvey To: suoolementalcommCa)surfcity-hb.orq Subject Library Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:49:13 AM Please do not privatize the HB Public Library. I work in the private sector and have experienced privatization twice, both to poor eventual outcomes. Our library is well staffed by compassionate,professional people who care about the content of the materials contained therein and the budgets. We will have no true control over the content or the costs associated with privatization,regardless of what they tell you up front. Trust me,this concept is a fail. Best, Deborah R. Harvey Director The Caring Connection, Inc. 818 368 5007 Phone 818 368 5004 Fax From: Dina Chavez To: suoolementalcommCa)surfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CM0 STAFF) Subject SAVE OUR LIBRARY Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:49:13 AM Council Members, This push toward privatization represents a leadership failure unprecedented in our city's history. For over 114 years, our public library has stood as a beacon of knowledge and community. Despite financial challenges through the years, each city council, with the help of generous donations from non-profit groups, has managed to keep it afloat. However,the recent threats and proposals pushed by misguided individuals and their enablers are reprehensible. The inability of our city to safeguard this beloved institution is inexcusable. Our library should be celebrated, not treated as a disposable commodity for sale to the highest(or lowest)bidder. Privatizing a library will never be an,achievement, it will always be seen as the failure of local government that it is. The indifference to the quality of life of the citizenry that such a move represents will never be forgotten. One might assume that some level of basic research was conducted before placing this disastrous privatization item on the agenda. If so, the City would know that our public library is already the most efficiently run in Orange County, providing an exceptional return on investment for our community—especially considering the lack of support both financially and from City itself. Astonishingly, taxpayers contribute only $27 a year per capita for our remarkable Library, whereas the national average stands at $70 per capita. Given these realities, it is perplexing that our City, in its purported wisdom, chooses to target our beloved, underfunded library as a cost-saving measure. Squeezing the life out of this cherished institution to save a buck is nothing short of disgraceful. Let's examine the data: Our city library comprises less than 2% of the total city budget and has not received any budget increases over the past five years. In fact, since 2014, the budget has only experienced a marginal 2% increase. Given that the library operates on a modest five- million-dollar budget,this 2% increment amounts to a mere $100,000.Meanwhile,the Friends of the Library contributes more than double that amount annually. A contribution that will end if privatization were to occur. Interestingly, LS&S contracts receive a 2.5% increase every year. It begs the question: Is our City willing to grant a private equity firm a 2.5% budget boost annually while neglecting similar generosity toward our publicly run City library? It remains inexplicable why the City persists in pursuing privatization—a move that appears more like an embarrassing display of nihilism than a genuine cost-saving effort. The notion being floated that privatization will magically solve our city's self-inflicted problems is nothing more than a fantasy. In reality, it exacerbates our existing issues. Those who believe that so called `pornography and obscene materials' are exclusive to our public library will be surprised to discover that these same materials exist in privatized libraries as well. A quick search of online catalogs would confirm this fact. LS&S's flagship library in their vast portfolio of failures, Riverside County, shows so-called pornographic/obscene books such as `Gender Queer', 'It's Perfectly Normal' and the most offensive book ever published `Everyone Poops'available in the Children's and Young Adult portions of the library. Another question arises: Do criminal accusations made against librarians suddenly cease when the library is privatized? If so, it leads one to wonder whether the attacks on our library and staff were truly about the books or are perhaps fueled by personal vendettas and retaliation for unknown personal grievances. Alongside these accusations, we have witnessed threats, unfair practices, a hostile work environment, violations of municipal and ethics codes and overreach by the Mayor further complicating matters..Even if the attacks and criminal accusations from tie_counci� dins come to an end, 1t,remains,unlikely that certain segments,of the public will c stn s the assertions, presented as fact by some City Council members that libraries are peddling pornography to children and are full of groomers and pedophiles Once such ideas have teen released,they cannot be easi.lyTretracted Meanwhile, a committee of hyper-partisan citizens—representing 0.00000105% of the population—scrutinizing thousands of children's books. Their mission? To decide who might be sexually aroused by innocent illustrations. These efforts,masquerading as public policy, are supposedly to protect other people's children from books they deem objectionable. This entire exercise is an absolute insult to our experienced, educated,professional librarians. It is important that the workplace harassment endured by library staff, a situation created and enabled by the City, has been acknowledged by the Interim City Manager . I assume this information will be disclosed to any for-profit private equity firm planning to bid on this proposal. It is crucial for them to recognize that their librarians and staff will face the same unfettered, relentless attacks on their personal character, professionalism, and morality. Publicly labeling them as `groomers' and `pedophiles' by both members of the public and City Council should raise serious concerns for any company wishing to take over our library. One must wonder why any responsible company, having basic regard for its workforce, would willingly subject itself and its employees to such abuse and potential litigation. Additionally, it is essential to note that this harassment extends beyond library staff. It affects volunteers, non-profit support groups, patrons, educators, other council members and anyone who dares to defend the library. These attacks persist due to the City's tolerance and enablement, full disclosure of this fact is also imperative. Our public libraries, along with everyone in them deserve unwavering protection and support. Next year will be the 50th Anniversary of the Central Library, the iconic crown jewel of Huntington Beach. Volunteers like me should be planning a grand celebration, not a funeral. Fighting for our Library is always the right thing to do. Support Agenda Item 24-350. Dina Chavez From: Deborah Harvey To: suaolementalcommOsurfcity-hb.orq Subject Fwd:Library Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:52:59 AM Please do not privatize the HB Public Library. I work in the private sector and have experienced privatization twice, both to poor eventual outcomes. Our library is well staffed by compassionate,professional people who care about the content of the materials contained therein and the budgets. We will have no true control over the content or the costs associated with privatization, regardless of what they tell you up front. Trust me,this concept is a fail. PS. I have been a resident of Huntington Beach for over 25 years and do not support outsourcing. Please put it to a vote of the people. Deborah R. Harvey Director The Caring Connection,Inc. 818 368 5007 Phone 818 368 5004 Fax Forwarded message From: Deborah Harvey<deb@thecaringconnection.com> Date: Tue,May 7,2024 at 8:48 AM Subject: Library To: <,supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org> Please do not privatize the HB Public Library. I work in the private sector and have experienced privatization twice,both to poor eventual outcomes. Our library is well staffed by compassionate,professional people who care about the content of the materials contained therein and the budgets. We will have no true control over the content or the costs associated with privatization,regardless of what they tell you up front. Trust me,this concept is a fail. Best, Deborah R. Harvey Director The Caring Connection,Inc. 818 368 5007 Phone 818 368 5004 Fax From: sgschumannCa)aol.com To: suoolementalcommCa)surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:57:02 AM Dear City Council Members: I highly support: •Agenda Item 24-350 to let the people vote to privatize/outsource the Huntington Beach Public Library and postpone/terminate RFP Process until after the vote. Privatizing/outsourcing would be a huge mistake: costly and detrimental to the purpose of providing a community library for the benefit of the whole community,with a shared and felt relationship with the community. I am a lifelong advocate and patron of local libraries. I am a member of Friends of the Library. Privatizing our Huntington Beach library would cause irreparable damage to our community. I am the mother of three adult children and seven grandchildren, all of whom have spent countless hours enjoying local libraries. Our library system works incredibly well and enjoys strong local support. Please do not destroy such an excellent local resource. Thank you. Susan G. Schumann 8933 Modesto Circle Unit 1214D Huntington Beach, CA 92646 From: Lindsay K To: suoolementalcommCalsurfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CM0 STAFF) Subject: Supplemental Communication-Yes on 24-350,Yes on 24-337 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:57:58 AM I am writing in support of Agenda Item 24-350 "HB Public Library: Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsource (Charter Amendment) and Postpone/Terminate RFP Process Until After Vote." I have been working to get the word out about the potential outsourcing of library management services and everyone I have spoken to-friends, neighbors, strangers, family- thinks it is a bad idea. Most people had no idea it is even being considered.The over 100 year- old Huntington Beach Public Library owes much of its success to the community itself who use it heavily and through the support of community-led groups like the Friends of Huntington Beach Public Library. In comparison, your time on the council is short. Do you truly want your legacy to be "messing up the library"? Mayor Van Der Mark has made it clear from day one that that is her goal. ' Councilman Strickland,you have already declared your intention to run for state senate. Do you think moving forward with causing havoc and upheaval in one of the most beloved civic institutions in Huntington Beach is the way to get votes for higher office? I have seen no evidence presented by the council that outsourcing library management, which entails firing the entire staff, is going to save the city money in the long run.The arguments made by community members for privatization all seem to be based on the false accusations, made by Mayor Van Der Mark,that librarians have lost their way and are bringing porn into the library. In other words, it is not a financial decision at all but retaliation for not following the whims of the Mayor. I strongly doubt you will vote to allow the people to determine the fate of their library.At least in voting "no" it will be crystal clear who is to blame should the library be privatized, the staffing outsourced and the Friends of the Library discontinues their support. It will be the fault of the city council majority- Mayor Van Der Mark, Councilmembers Burns, McKeon and • Strickland. I will make sure people know how it happened and why-that the council majority voted to outsource to appease Mayor Gracey Van Der Mark, and possibly as a favor to former mayor Mike Posey who represents the library outsourcing company LS&S,to the detriment of everyone else. Sincerely, Lindsay Klick, HB Resident, Parent, and Librarian From: Cathy Enale To: suoplementalcomm(@surfcity-hb.orq Subject: Save Our Library!Support Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:58:02 AM I support this agenda item to allow voters to decide if the changes to library are necessary. • From: Scott Malabarba To: suonlementalcommtsurfcity-hb.orq;CITY COUNCIL(ZNCL.CMO STAFF), Subject in SUPPORT of agenda item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:59:09 AM Dear City Council, • Thank you,yet again,to council members Bolton,Moser, and Kalmick for your ongoing courage and for taking bold action to protect HB's future. I support agenda item 24-350. The initiative to privatize our public library was never in good faith. The claims that it is about saving the city money make no sense and have been soundly refuted by the people who actually know how the library works. Over and over,the council majority's malicious culture war antics have been met by a solid majority of speakers and correspondence voicing opposition.And over and over,the council majority disregards its citizens and panders to a small,vocal, and increasingly bizarre minority. HBPL library has been a treasured and vital institution for decades longer than any of us writing or addressed here have even been alive.By these repeated attacks you only cause destruction. Your legacy will be one of shame and future city councils will spend years repairing the damage you cause.But they will, because --surprise! --people like libraries. If there is any integrity remaining on the council majority,then the people of HB will have a true voice in this decision and will be empowered to vote on it in November. Regards, Scott Malabarba HB resident From: Fikes,Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject FW:Public library Date: Monday,May 6,2024 3:45:22 PM ----Original Message From:Susan Barnhill<slbhill@verizon.net> Sent:Monday,May 6,2024 2:52 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Public library Dear City Council Members I am opposed to the privatization of the Huntington Beach Community Library. Our library is a great public resource and community asset.Please keep our public library as is:PUBLIC. Thank you for your time. Susan Barnhill Registered voter,Huntington Beach,CA From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: RN:Library Date: Monday,May 6,2024 3:45:42 PM From: Robert E Moore<robtmoore1@verizon.net> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 3:11 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Library The audacity of you four, and you know who I'm referring to,who want to try and privatize our highly regarded PUBLIC HB LIBRARY is sickening. I've lived in Huntington Beach since 1987 and I've never jumped on a political bandwagon until now. I'm so disgusted with much of what you've tried to do thus far, but this is truly beyond belief!! Keep your hands and mouths off OUR PUBLIC LIBRARY. Carol Moore Sent from the all new AOL aoo for iOS From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject FW:Library Vote Date: Monday,May 6,2024 3:45:54 PM From:Cindy Miller<millercyn33@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 3:18 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Library Vote City Council members, Let the citizens of HB vote to decide if the library should be privatized.This is such a valuable resource in our community to let a change this big occur with out the direct decision coming from the voters Long time resident and lover of books Cynthia Miller From: Rkes,Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Support for May 7,2024 Agenda Item#30 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 3:46:08 PM From: Rachel Elaine Kadar<rachek2729@hotmail.com> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 3:30 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Support for May 7, 2024 Agenda Item#30 Good afternoon, I am writing to express support for May 7's Agenda Item #30: HB Public Library: Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsource (Charter Amendment) and Postpone/Terminate RFP Process Until After Vote. Libraries are a critical resource.The people should be allowed to decide whether they would like for this resource to be turned into a profit-making venture for a private firm.This is a decision that will affect hundreds of thousands of Huntington Beach residents and should be made democratically by the people of Huntington Beach, not unilaterally by 7 council members. I once again urge you to allow this measure to be put to a vote by the people and to refrain from privatizing the libraries until after the people have had the ability to make their voices heard. Thank you very much for your time and consideration, Rachel Kadar From: Pikes.Cathy To: Aaenda Alerts Subject FW:Agenda item 30 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 3:46:20 PM Original Message From:Janine Temple<janine2654@icloud.com> Sent:Monday,May 6,2024 3:40 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda item 30 I support agenda item 30 and want it put on the November ballot! Sent from my iPhone From: Fkes,Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject FW:Support Agenda Item 24-350 • Date: Monday,May 6,2024 4:36:25 PM From: Manny Huang<mannyawesome88@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 4:32 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Fwd:Support Agenda Item 24-350 Dear City Council - I am a 30 year resident of Huntington Beach. I am a registered Republican,and I voted for some of you in the last election based on your platforms which seemed to consist of public safety,solving the homeless crisis, promoting business and responsible development. But now that you are in place, it seems like the focus is on a lot of political theater topics. An enormous amount of time has been put into this book banning(or restrictions or whatever you want to call it). I thought republicans believed in parental rights?So how about we as parents manage what our kids look at and check out? Is everyone no longer giving their kids smartphones?You want to seriously shelter high schoolers? Parent your own kids! Even more concerning is the move to privatize the library system. I understand that privatization is not always bad (look at what Elon Musk has been able to do!). But the privatization of the public library system here would be a bad idea.The libraries that LSS manages across the country are NOT in communities with standards,services and fiscal standing like Huntington Beach.The amount of savings is such a small drop in the bucket of the entire city budget that it just does not make sense and appears to point to alterior and possibly nefarious motives for this move. This is a big decision and community input should be taken. In addition, a VERY careful review of the contract and thorough understanding of the existing services (including those done by volunteer and non-profit groups which will disappear for a private company) provided by the current system and what would be provided by LSS must be done. Unlike many other city functions,the library is part of the fabric of the community.The services it offers are key to the community(e.g. citizenship test prep, language help,after school tutoring,veterans services,storytimes,writing contests, etc...). There are many areas of city services where money could be saved and pensions cut but that does not mean it is necessarily a good thing for our community's future. If people get to vote on what flags are flown,we should get to vote on what happens to our library system. Lily Huang From: Fikes,Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject RN:Library Privatization Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:19:57 PM • From:Jim Proctor<jamesrproctor@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 4:47 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Library Privatization Dear City Council: I strongly oppose privatizing the library;the whole family does, and we vote. Best regards, Jim Proctor From: ekes.Cathy To: Aaenda Alerts Subject: FW:Library privatization for our HB libraries-Vote NO Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:21:01 PM • From:Shannon Paskin<s.paskin@verizon.net> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 4:57 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Library privatization for our HB libraries-Vote NO I am writing to speak out agains the privatizing of our Huntington Beach Public Libraries. We all know there is nothing wrong with our libraries and any supposed cost savings from outsourcing, which we have very little evidence of cost savings, is not worth sacrificing the high-quality programs and services our libraries currently provide. Me, my children, my friends and their children have enjoyed and love our amazing library and truly appreciate the wonderful volunteers and those people who are educated in managing our books and publications. I see no need to change our current system. Shannon Paskin Huntington Beach • From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject FW:Support for City Council Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:21:09 PM Original Message From:Maureen Bekins<maureenbekins@gmail.com> Sent:Monday,May 6,2024 5:06 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Support for City Council Agenda Item 24-350 To the Mayor and City Council Memberssipy r, I strongly oppose changing management of our Huntington Beach Public Library through outsourcing.Why in the world would we want to change an organization that works so well for this City?Our citizenry—of all ages—love this institution and its' employees for the education and enrichment provided day in and out,year after year.;SEA Although input on every single issue in city management is inconceivable,this is such a drastic proposal approved by so very few people and impacts every single resident,I believe it calls for input from all the citizens of our City, not just the council members.I support putting this issue on the ballot for an advisory vote by the people who use the library,the citizens of Huntington Beach. For the record,I am a 46-year resident of this city. Maureen Bekins 5752 Woodboro Drive Huntington Beach 92649 From: Pikes,Cathy To: Agenda Alert* Subject RN:Agenda 30 • Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:21:20 PM From: Diane Amendola<diane@sandy-paws.com> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 5:39 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda 30 For the Official Record Dear City Council Members, Please put the library privatization (Agenda Item 30) on the ballot on November 5, 2024. I do not support privatization of our City Library. I'm very disappointed in some council members I voted for,you as a group appear to be grandstanding because too much of what I've seen is not worthy of the discussions we've had to listen to. Mrs. Mary Amendola Homeowner Resident and Tax Payer in Huntington Beach Get Outlook for iOS From: Fikes,Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Agenda Item 24-350 No Privatization of our Library!Let us Vote! Date: Monday,May 6,2024 6:21:47 PM From:Ameelia Ghareeb<amghareeb@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 6:05 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda Item 24-350 No Privatization of our Library! Let us Vote! Good afternoon, I am writing to all members of our the City Council about the idea that we should privatize our Public Library.This idea is completely ridiculous.While I have heard some arguments that this will save us money(allegedly),the need has never been established and the loss of benefit and value to our City and its communities is just too great to even consider. If some members of the Council are so convinced this move is great for our city, Put it to a vote.Just like you put other things to a vote at the last election, put Privatizing the Jewel of our City Services to the voters before moving forward. I think you'll find overwhelmingly that people,from both parties, do not want this. I vote in every election, and I do not want this. Please do not move forward with this plan. Leave our Library alone. Thank you, .. Ameelia Ghareeb;92649 From: pikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject FW:Library Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:50:34 AM From:SUSAN WEXLER<sjwexler@msn.com> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 7:24 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Library Dear City Council, When have you ever seen hundreds of people protesting an action by our City Council members week after week? When have you ever heard of more than 600 letters protesting an action by our City Council sent in one week and the thousands that have been sent since last June? Don't you get it? NO ONE WANTS YOU INTERFERING WITH AN INSTITUTION IN OUR CITY THAT PEOPLE LOVE! OUR LIBRARY IS NOT BROKEN!!!! If you want to "protect your child" at the library,go there with him/her. If you don't want to go, don't give them a library card. But don't think you have the right to restrict what others read. If your"child" has a "Smart Phone,"chances are they are seeing much more questionable content than they will ever see in a public library. Stop this foolishness and concentrate on the real problems in Huntington Beach! Sincerely, Susan Wexler 44 year resident and library volunteer Get Outlook for!OS From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject RN: Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:50:56 AM From: Marilyn Palomino<palominoccr@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 7:30 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Dear HB City Council Members, This is Marilyn Palomino, long time resident of Huntington Beach and educator. I strongly support Agenda item 24-350. The long-standing successful operation of our Huntington Beach Public Library System deserves a vote by the population of its residents. My children, students and my family have spent much time in our libraries. They are well run and welcoming. I don't believe privatizing the libraries will support our citizens or help in resolving our city's budget deficit. As our Public Libraries are a cornerstone of free speech and democracy, a political body should not decide what is clearly under the purview of the people. Please honor the citizens of Huntington Beach and place the matter of the operation of our Libraries on the ballot for the general election in November. Thank you for your consideration, Marilyn Palomino From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject FW:Privatizing Library Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:51:01 AM From:tbradx2 personal <tbradx2@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 7:39 PM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Privatizing Library The council should not be making these decisions.This is a voters issue that should be on the ballot in November From: Ekes.Cathy To: Aaenda Alerts Subject: FW:Library Meeting Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:51:14 AM From:tjamesbradford<tjamesbradford@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 7:40 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Library Meeting This is an issue that belongs to the voters. Not 4 council members who may,or may not be able to read • From: Pikes,Cathy To: Aaenda Alerts Subject: FW:Stop the Privatization/Book Banning Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:51:29 AM Original Message From:onewildart<onewildart@aol.com> Sent:Monday,May 6,2024 7:52 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Stop the Privatization/Book Banning City Council members, Seeing Huntington Beach highlighted on the John Oliver show on May 5th regarding banning/moving books was not a surprise but certainly an embarrassment for our city.Between the attempt to privatize the library and control how it's run reflects our failing leadership. Elected on promises(not kept)and not voting the will of the people seem to be the ruling gang of four's MO. Our library is not up for sale and we the people will not put up with this nonsense without a fight. I'm asking you to see the light and do what's right.Our city deserves better. Trudy Roe 47 year resident Sent from my iPad From: Fkes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Agenda item#30 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:51:35 AM Original Message From:Holly Sjogren<playk9@earthlink.net> Sent:Monday,May 6,2024 8:09 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda item#30 I am writing to ask you to please pause library privatization and allow voters to decide in November. Thank you Holly&Bob Sjogren Sent from my iPhone From: Fkes.Cathy • To: Agenda Alerts Subject FW:Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:52:14 AM From: Kathleen Lueck<k_l_lueck@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, May 6, 2024 10:08 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda Item 24-350 I am strongly in favor of Agenda Item 23-350. I admonish you to pass it and to place it on the ballot for our November 5th Election. Save one or our city's greatest assets. Let the citizens of Huntington Beach vote! Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPad From: pikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject FW: No Library Privatization. Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:52:34 AM ----Original Message---- From:Connie Tomsick<connietomsick@gmail.com> Sent:Monday,May 6,2024 10:24 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:No Library Privatization. • To the Gang of Four on our City Council: congratulations for the recognition by John Oliver on his"Last Week Tonight"show on HBO. He pointed out Huntington Beach as being one of the cities who stupidly bans books,a;la Moms for Liberty. I wish he had spoken more about privatization and your disgusting ignoring of the popular wis to keep our Library free. So you are going to pay a corporation$$$to manage the already well managed Library. You still have to pay the bills and for the maintenance of the property,so all the profits for LS&S will be paid by HB and what,late fees? This must go up for a vote. If you MAGAs want to keep your positions of power,this will turn against you. A number of people who actually side with some of your actions do not want this privatization to proceed. The only reason many of us see as why you want this is for your personal profits. Shame on you. -Constance Tomsick From: Fkes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject FW:In support of agenda item 30 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:52:42 AM Original Message From:Isabella Roethel<izroethel@gmail.com> Sent:Monday,May 6,2024 10:26 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:In support of agenda item 30 As a resident of Huntington Beach that has enjoyed the library for years,it should be up to the community not a handful of individuals to determine the future of the library. From: pikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject RN:Do Not Privatize HB Libraries Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:53:03 AM Original Message From:Natalie Dassian<nataliedassian@gmail.com> Sent:Monday,May 6,2024 10:40 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Do Not Privatize HB Libraries Dear council, I implore you to listen to the majority of your constituents-do NOT change our libraries.They do not need privatization and book review committees.Council members that support the privatization are not true patriots and want to dumb down their voters.We are offended and appalled at these potential library changes.Do not change our libraries. From: Fikes.Cathy To: Aoenda Alerts Subject FW:City Coundl Meeting for May 7,2024 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:53:33 AM From: Larry Slonim <Iarry.slonim.80@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 12:27 AM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:City Council Meeting for May 7, 2024 My wife,Susan, and I strongly support the introduction and approval of items 29 (24-337) &30(24- 350) on the City Council's Agenda for May 7, 2024. Non-commercial signage (i.e. political campaign signs) needs to be better controlled in our.City, and we agree that following the City Of Irvine's code as a model for such signage would be desirable. We also believe that the potential privatizing of the City's Public Library System must be addressed in the same way that Charter Amendments A, B&C were, as a ballot measure to be voted on by everyone in a formal election, not solely by the vote of the City Council. We are NOT in favor of privatizing and gutting an excellent,well-run and well-respected PUBLIC library system to try to save a highly questionable amount of expenses in the short term, sacrificing the level and quality of existing services and community value. Sincerely, Larry and Susan Slonim 19792 Gloucester Lane HB, Ca. 92646 • From: pikes,Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FIN:Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:53:57 AM From: Melanie Bergeland<melbergeland@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 7:00 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) <city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda Item 24-350 Dear City Council, I am writing in support of agenda item 24-350. I believe the Huntington Beach community at large should be able to weigh in via the voting process. I do not believe 7 council members should be the only people weighing in on a community service that impacts all the community residents with a wide range of repercussions. The library currently is a: Safe shelter for the community and is used as a Cooling station in the heat of the summer for our Seniors and the Elderly. Study area for the students in our community that need access to the internet to study and complete school work. Community gathering place for the community at large to check out books, have a snack, purchase used books and a place to rest after a walk around the park. Place to learn how to use Laser machines, sewing machines, 3 D printers, Cricut machines. This is a very loved and popular service. Classes for all ages to meet, learn, exchange ideas, make friends and create support groups. For our special needs community members to hang-out, meet friends, study and learn new skills in a safe and supportive environment. Vets to come for free services in a safe and supportive environment. Resources to look and apply for a job. Tourists stop by and enjoy a resting place, chat with locals in a welcoming setting,take a class, and enjoy our community with their family. I feel public libraries are the heart and soul of a community and should be free and available to all community members. Privatization of libraries has proven to be negatively impactful to the communities that privatized their Libraries. I feel the whole community should be able to vote for the direction of the livelihood of the community libraries. Sincerely, Melanie Bergeland Long time resident HB volunteer throughout the city From: Fikes,Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Library privatization Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:54:13 AM Original Message From:BOB DEATON<bobdeaton@aol.com> Sent:Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:08 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Library privatization I strongly urge the City Council to put the library privatization proposal on the November ballot and let the voters decide.A lot of people in Huntington Beach feel strongly about this issue.It's too important for the citizenry not to be involved directly in the decision. Bob Deaton 19675 Seawind Cir Huntington Beach CA 92648 From: Pikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Reducing Trash Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:54:26 AM Original Message From:April Downs<thedownsfamily03@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:15 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Reducing Trash Dear City Council-I'm writing in support of Dan Kalmick's agenda item to prohibit political signs in public right of way areas.These signs are overwhelming,contribute to vandalism(they are tagged and more recently purposely altering the meaning),and increase trash.This proposal allows signs on private property so political advertising is still allowed. Thank you, April Downs Sent from my iPhone From: Rkes,Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Let the People Dedde Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:54:45 AM Original Message From:April Downs<thedownsfamily03@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday,May 7,2024 7:21 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Let the People Decide Hi City Council-I'm writing in support of Rhonda Bolton,Dan Kalmick and Natalie Moser's agenda item to put the highly contested privatizing of the library to a public vote.It's clear this change concerns a significant portion of our city's population so put the issue on the November ballot. Sincerely, April Downs Sent from my iPhone From: Pikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject FW:About Libraries Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:55:02 AM From: Pedram Kianfar<kianfarpedram@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 7:22 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:About Libraries Hello to whom it may concern, I would like to express my opposition to the privatization of our public libraries. Many people like myself use and rely on public libraries for research and information, and I fear that privatization is not the right way to go. Instead of privatization, I urge the city council to explore alternative solutions to support our public libraries. Thank you and have a good day. -A concerned citizen. From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject FW:Agenda Item 24-350 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:55:21 AM From:Samantha Baksic<sgbaksic@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 7:33 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda Item 24-350 Dear City Council Members, I strongly support the new agenda item 24-350 submitted by Council Members Bolton,Kalmick and Moser that requires a vote of the people to privatize/outsource the Huntington Beach Public Library and postpone/terminate the RFP process until after the vote. Please give the people of Huntington Beach the freedom to vote on this important issue. Sincerely, Samantha Baksic 714-330-2021 From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject FW:Agenda item#30 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:55:33 AM From:Sandra F<sandyfazio@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 7:46 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda item#30 I am writing in support of agenda item#30.The citizens of Huntington Beach should have the opportunity to vote on the possible change of library management. If the citizens have all the facts and figures they can decide if it is a good idea. Thank you, Sandra Fazio 21612 Bahama Ln Huntington Beach, CA 92646 From: Pikes,Cathy To: Aaenda Alerts Subject RN:Our PUBLIC Library Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:55:44 AM From: mtfbwy@socal.rr.com<mtfbwy@socal.rr.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 7:47 AM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Our PUBLIC Library Dear City Council, Please consider what you are doing. Our beautiful public library is a Huntington Beach icon, supported by the public's taxes and The Friends of the Library. Privatizing will not work,as noted from other failures from around the country.You might consider instead setting new guidelines for the length of time a person should work in public service,such as a librarian, before receiving a pension. Again, please consider that you are going against what the citizens of Huntington Beach,whom you represent,want--a Public Library. Respectfully, Norma Mazure • From: Fikes.Cathy To: Agenda Alerts Subject FW:Agenda Item#30 Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:56:05 AM Original Message From:Christine Amoroso<camoroso@yahoo.com> Sent:Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:26 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda Item#30 Dear Huntington Beach City Council Members, I have lived in Huntington Beach since 1969.I am a retired educator.I am a citizen of a city that is at the mercy of a council in which the majority of its members ignores the wishes of its residents. While I have addressed all members of the council,it is Mayor Gracie Van Der Mark,Casey McKeon,Pat Burns and Tony Strickland I am writing to specifically. Please listen to the voices,the pleas of the Huntington Beach Citizens you serve.Through peaceful protest,weekly marches,written letters and public comments,they are demanding that our beloved Libraries NOT be privatized. Like many citizens I have done my homework.Studies and reports from cities that have unsuccessfully privatized indicate that promises of cost savings and improved operations did not come to fruition.More importantly-THE CITIZENS OF HUNTINGTON BEACH WANT TO KEEP THEIR LIBRARIES PULIC.PERIOD. Honestly,I write this letter because I am a concerned citizen,because I want to be sure my words become part of our city's record.But I have absolutely zero faith in the council voting in favor of keeping our library public.Why would this vote be any different than all of the other 4:3 votes in which the citizens voices were ignored.I suppose I'm hoping for a miracle. I beg you to blow my mind,PROVE ME WRONG and actually listen to what the Huntington Beach citizens want- A PUBLIC LIBRARY. Sincerely, Christine Amoroso From: Fkes.Cathy To: Aoenda Alerts Subject: ;FM Agenda Item 24-350:HB Public Library:Cote of the People to Privatize/Outsource(Charter Amendment)and postpone/terminate RFP process until after vote Date: Tuesday,May 7,2024 8:56:29 AM From: Kathy Williams<kwilliams6071@yahoo.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 8:41 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda Item 24-350: HB Public Library: Cote of the People to Privatize/Outsource (Charter Amendment) and postpone/terminate RFP process until after vote I have been a resident of Huntington Beach since 1975 and I remember when the main library branch was built.I took my four children to the Main St.and Helen Murphy branches for many years and hope to continue that activity. A complete change to privatize the library should not be a decision shouldered by the City Council alone.This should be put to a public vote by the residents of Huntington Beach.I recommend that Agenda Item 24-350 be affirmed by the City Council and the charter amendment be available on the November 2024 ballot for Huntington Beach resident voters to decide on any steps to revise the current public library system. Kathy BW England RESOLUTION NO. 2024- A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA, CALLING FOR THE HOLDING OF A GENERAL MUNICIPAL ELECTION TO BE HELD ON TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 5, 2024, FOR (1) THE ELECTION OF CERTAIN OFFICERS AS REQUIRED BY PROVISIONS OF THE LAWS OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA RELATING TO CHARTER CITIES, (2) THE SUBMISSION TO THE VOTERS AN ADVISORY MEASURE ON WHETHER TO HIRE A THIRD-PARTY CONTRACTOR TO OPERATE THE HUNTINGTON BEACH PUBLIC LIBRARY AS PROPOSED IN RCA#24-194 ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL ON MARCH 19, 2024, AND (3) THE SUBMISSION TO THE VOTERS A QUESTION RELATING TO CITY CHARTER AMENDMENTS. WHEREAS,pursuant to the California Constitution,Article XI and the Government Code,Title 4,Division 2,Chapter 2(commencing at§34458) and the.Election Code Division 9, Chapter 3,Article 3 (commencing at§ 9255)of the State of California and under the provisions of the laws relating to Charter cities in the State of California, a General Municipal Election shall be held on November 5,2024 for the Municipal Officers; and WHEREAS, on March 19, 2024, the City Council, by a 4-3 vote (Bolton, Kalmick, Moser voting "No") , approved Request for City Council Action ("RCA") # 24-197 authorizing City staff to"issue a Request for Proposals["RFP"]for Managed Library Services for the Huntington Beach Public Library and return to City Council with an agreement for consideration;"and WHEREAS,"privatization"or"outsourcing"public library operation or management represents a monumental change to a City institution that has existed for more than a century without any assertion that the library does not serve the City's residents well, and the library is the most heavily utilized,public-facing portion of the City Government; and RESOLUTION NO. 2024- WHEREAS, there has been no demonstration that the library's current operation or management is inefficient,wasteful,or not cost-effective,and no evidence has been presented to the public demonstrating that outsourcing library operation or management to a third party would generate significant cost savings for the City; and WHEREAS, over the last dozen months, the City has documented more than a thousand pieces of correspondence from residents, and City Council members have had dozens, if not hundreds, of other conversations with concerned residents and stakeholders, nearly all of which object to outsourcing or privatizing the City's public library; and WHEREAS, the library's significance to the community, and the magnitude of the change presented by library management outsourcing warrants giving the city's voters an opportunity to weigh in on the Council's direction to staff in RCA # 24-197 and work on issuing an RFP should be suspended until voters have spoken; and WHEREAS, for the same reasons, going forward, if a future City Council contemplates library privatization or other wholesale changes in the library's management structure or operation, approval of such a proposal should require a vote of the people; and WHEREAS,the City Council desires to submit to the voters at the General Municipal Election an advisory Measure on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the Huntington Beach Public Library as proposed in RCA#24-194 adopted by the City Council on March 19,2024,or any future similar proposal; and WHEREAS,the City Council desires to submit to the voters at the General Municipal Election a question relating to city Charter amendments; and 2 RESOLUTION NO. 2024- WHEREAS,the City Manager should suspend work on RCA#24-194 until the people have spoken on these issues; and WHEREAS, the City Council is authorized and directed by statute to submit the proposed advisory Measure to the voters; and WHEREAS, the City Council is authorized and directed by statute to submit the proposed Charter amendment to the voters, NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH, CALIFORNIA, DOES RESOLVE, DECLARE, DETERMINE AND ORDER AS FOLLOWS: SECTION 1. That pursuant to the requirements of the laws of the State of California relating to Charter Cities, and pursuant to the California Constitution, Article XI and the Government Code,Title 4,Division 2,Chapter 2(commencing at§34458) and the Election Code Division 9,Chapter 3,Article 3 (commencing at§ 9255)of the State of California,there is called and ordered to be held in the City of Huntington Beach, California, on Tuesday,November 5, 2024, a General Municipal Election for the purpose of electing three Members of the City Council for the full term of four years. SECTION 2. That the City Council pursuant to its right and authority, also does order submitted to the voters at the General Municipal Election the following Measure: 3 RESOLUTION NO. 2024- " Huntington Beach Public Library Privatization/Outsourcing Advisory Measure: Shall the City contract with a third-party to manage and/or operate the Huntington Beach Public Library, Yes as proposed in Request for Council Action#24-194 ' adopted by the City Council on March 19,2024 or any other future, similar proposal?" No SECTION 3. That the City Council pursuant to its right and authority, also does order submitted to the voters at the General Municipal Election the following question relating to a City Charter amendment: "Shall the proposed Charter Amendment to: require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale Yes management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings, No be approved?" 4 RESOLUTION NO. 2024- _ SECTION 4. That the complete text of the Charter Amendments submitted to the voters is attached as Exhibit A. SECTION 5. That the vote requirement for the advisory Measures to pass is a majority (50%+1),and that the vote requirement for the Charter Amendment to pass is a majority(50%+ 1), of the votes cast. SECTION 6. That the ballots to be used at the election shall be in form and content as required by law. SECTION 7. That the City Clerk is authorized, instructed, and directed to coordinate with the County of Orange Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk to procure and furnish any and all official ballots,notices,printed matter and all supplies, equipment and paraphernalia that may be necessary in order to properly and lawfully conduct the election. SECTION 8. That the polls(vote centers) for the election shall be open at seven o'clock a.m. of the day of the election and shall remain open continuously from that time until 8 o'clock p.m.of the same day when the polls(vote centers)shall be closed,pursuant to Election Code § 10242, except as provided in§§ 14212, 14401 of the Elections Code of the State of California. SECTION 9. That in all particulars not recited in this resolution, the election shall be held and conducted as provided by law for holding municipal elections. SECTION 10. That notice of the time and place of holding the election is given and the City Clerk is authorized,instructed, and directed to give further or additional notice of the election, 5 RESOLUTION NO. 2024- in time, form and manner as required by law. SECTION 11. That the City Clerk shall certify to the passage and adoption of this Resolution and enter it into the book of original Resolutions. SECTION 12. The City Council authorizes the City Clerk to administer said election and all reasonable and actual election expenses shall be paid by the City upon presentation of a properly submitted bill. SECTION 13. The City Council directs the City Manager to suspend work on RCA #24-194 upon adoption of this Resolution 2024-_;directs that the City not issue an RFP or negotiate a contract as described in RCA#24-194; and directs that no privatization, outsourcing or other similar wholesale change in the management structure of the City's library system shall take place unless and until the voters approve such an action by answering affirmatively the advisory Measure described herein or authorizing such action in accordance with the Charter amendment described herein. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Huntington Beach at a regular meeting thereof held on the_ day of ,2024. Mayor REVIEWED AND APPROVED: APPROVED AS TO FORM: City Manager City Attorney 6 RESOLUTION NO. 2024-_ EXHIBIT A CHARTER AMENDMENT MEASURES PROPOSED ADDITIONS SHOWN AS UNDERLINED PROPOSED DELETIONS SHOWN AS STRIKETHROUGH Charter Amendment Measure Section 612A.PUBLIC LIBRARY No public library now or hereafter owned or operated by the City shall be operated or managed by a private contractor that employs library staff to achieve cost savings and/or any Proposal to that would change the wholesale management of library unless authorized by the affirmative vote of at least a majority of the total membership of the City Council and by the affirmative vote of at least a majority of the electors voting on such proposition at a general or special election at which such proposal is submitted • 7 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 10:19 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Put Library Privatization on the Ballot From:Jillian Fenton<jillianleighmartin@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 9:25 AM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Put Library Privatization on the Ballot Dear council members, I am writing to urge you to put it to the voters whether or not the library should be privatized.You all already know that this is not something the city(majority!)wants. It is your role as public servants to leave this to the people you represent.Put this on the ballot and leave it to the community to decide. Thank you, Jillian Fenton Lifelong community member 1 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 10:19 AM To Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Public Comment Agenda Item 30 From:Tomi Simmons<tsimmswrites@gmail.com> Sent Tuesday, May 7,2024 9:32 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Public Comment Agenda Item 30 Good morning, I strongly support Agenda Item 30 24-337.This would provide your citizens with the opportunity to vote for where our tax dollars would be going.This library was created by the community originally and it deserves to stay in the people's control, not a private company. Let the voters in Huntington Beach decide. Do not waste time in this RFP process, please start focusing on more pressing issues in our community. Furthermore,the parent committee needs to be disbanded.They are not professionals and have no business deciding what is appropriate for our children. Please let parents do their own parenting and let librarians do their jobs. Tomi Simmons. 1 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 10:19 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Support Agenda Item#30 From:Adam Kelly<adamscottkelly@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 9:47 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Support Agenda Item#30 Hello, I'm writing in support of agenda item#30. I support allowing the residents of Huntington Beach to vote on changes to our library rather than four fascist on our city council. It has been clear in the previous council meetings our mayor and her cohort are willing to ignore the voices of Huntington Beach to further their fear mongering agenda.We should keep the power to make drastic changes to city facilities in the hands of the people, rather than Gracey, her sycophants, and the pastors at Calvary.Chapel of the Harbor. Thank you, Adam Kelly 1. Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 10:20 AM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: No to privatization of our Libraries From: K B<joiphulll@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 9:56 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: No to privatization of our Libraries Vote.NO to any RFP's for our libraries! Vote NO to any more changes to our public libraries! Ms. LINGAN Of Huntington Beach 1 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 12:37 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Outsourcing the HB Public library Original Message From:Sharon Golding<sharongolding@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 11:14 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Outsourcing the HB Public library I vote NO on outsourcing the Huntington Beach Public Library. Libraries are meant for EVERYONE, not just those who an afford them. Sharon Golding Sent from my iPhone 1 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 12:37 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: privatization of HB public library From: Che Chereskin<ceceche78@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7,2024 11:14 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: privatization of HB public library Dear City Council Members, I am very concerned about the proposed privatization of our HB public library. I love the library and think that it is one of the shining stars of Huntington Beach. I always at least mention it to visitors-the wonderful Central Library in Central Park with its fountains and beautiful views of the park,the many programs for everyone from tots to seniors. I wish that this proposal would be dropped and leave everything as is, but at least put the issue to the vote in November so that the residents can choose for themselves. Sincerely, Che Chereskin 1 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 12:38 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Outsourcing public library From: Marcie5295<marcie5295@aol.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 11:16 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Outsourcing public library We are born and raised Huntington Beach residents who are NOT in favor of outsourcing the public library. We cannot imagine that outsourcing this or any other city/county department would have any benefit to residents of this city but it would definitely hurt the city/county employees who currently staff this department.As a retired city and county employee myself, I can see that you may be considering this option to reduce your retirement payouts, but at what cost? We who work or have worked for government departments chose this route as a professional commitment, but in outsourcing the library,you are making a statement that your dedicated employees are insignificant and unimportant to the greater good. What will become of those dedicated employees who have devoted so many years to Huntington Beach? Move to another department,you may say, but someone who selected the library has the experience and knowledge that is invaluable.And who will staff the library in the future? Someone with little or no knowledge of the library...so here you have it, a reduction in expertise.Thank you. Martine and Andrew Kasch Huntington Beach Sent from the all new AOL aoo for iOS 1 Moore,Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 12:39 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Stop outsourcing our library Original Message From: Kevin and Sandie Justen<kjusten@verizon.net> Sent:Tuesday, May 7,2024 11:33 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Stop outsourcing our library Dear.HB Council Members, I am writing to voice out my opposition to outsourcing our wonderful library to a private company. I do not know why we have to fix something that is not broken. My family and I have been very pleased with the Library's current management and staff. I am also opposed to the City council's(the majority) plan to censor books in our library. If anybody is opposed to a certain book,the library has a great process where a citizen can voice his/her opinion and request that this book be removed pending a library investigation. I do not agree with having a board (restricted to their own beliefs w/o getting my opinion) make this decision for me and my family. Please listen to the majority of HB citizens who want to keep our library managed by the city. Thank you, Sandie Justen 8861 Midbury Drive Huntington Beach,CA.92646 1 Moore,Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 12:39 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Support agenda item#30 From: holbunker@aol.com<holbunker@aol.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 11:45 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Support agenda item#30 HB City Council I am writing today in support of Agenda Item #30 that proposes putting library privatization to vote by the public inNovember. Thanks! Holly Haynes-Nicholls 1 Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 12:39 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Outsourcing HB public libraries From: mariposa sesma <mariposa42951@hotmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7,2024 12:23 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Outsourcing HB public libraries To whom it may concern I have been a HB resident for 55years and I have utilized the library services all this time. I am voicing_my opposition to outsourcing. I support the PUBLIC Huntington Beach libraries. Outsourcing our City libraries not only hurts the City but is a dangerous action that demonstrates a willingness to undermine public service, good jobs, and our community assets. If one service is outsourced, then others are next. The only way to preserve good jobs in the City of Huntington Beach AND Orange County is to stop outsourcing now! Respectfully Maria E Sesma I am a registered voter and Public Health Nurse and RN • Moore, Tania From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 12:40 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Public Comment Agenda Item#30 (24-350) From:Sean Drexler<drexler.sean@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7,2024 12:27 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Public Comment Agenda Item#30(24-350) Hello Mayor and City Council, My name is Sean Drexler and I am an Orange County resident. I urge you to vote yes on agenda item#30,which would allow Huntington Beach residents to have a say in the the process of privatizing the Huntington Beach Public Library by putting it to a vote in November. Sean Drexler 1 Moore, Tania • From:. Holden Ford <rmford100@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 9:01 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Don't do this to the library The Huntington Beach public library is one of my favorite places in the entire world. It has been since I was a kid until now when I'm 25.The librarians have always helped me out and made me feel welcome even if it was just to sit down on a hot day. I am highly considering moving out of Huntington Beach due to city council policies and this will be the final straw in my decision.That should be good enough reason not to change the library. If thats not a good enough reason, it's also been shown that when kids and teens don't have access to programs and places that the library provides,they are more likely to get into trouble and even start doing crime because they feel like their community isn't even worth it. I don't want the good kids of Huntington Beach to feel like this and turn to crime to fill their time instead of going to the library. Concerned Huntington Beach citizen 1 Moore, Tania From: Tony Chavez <tonyc@uscubed.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 9:00 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library! Support Agenda Item 24-350 Importance: High Good Morning Surf City, As a concerned citizen of Huntington Beach, I strongly urge the HB City Council and fellow community members to support Agenda Item #30 on Tuesday, May 7, 2024. The item recommends (2) substantial elements which seek to allow what is just and right in a civil, democratic society - the Right of the People to Vote and decide, by majority, what best serves the community. The fundamental rights of our citizens shall not easily be ignored or cast aside in pursuit of individual gain, nor shall institutions which serve the public good be turned over to profit bearing faculties which seek to weaken community core values. This City was built on the foundation of Public Good, Public Service, and Public Institutions offering the freedom for each citizen to expand, educate, and serve. Removing these core values only serves to halt this progress and replacing our hard-working, professional and accountable library staff disrupts a treasured community institution that has operated without impunity and above reproach. Please support our Library, our Library Staff, and denounce the idea that privatization of public institutions supports the community as a whole. Keep our library public and keep our community on the path towards progress, enlightenment, and service for all. Thank you, Tony Chavez CFO/Controller 601 N. Parkcenter Dr. Suite 209, Santa Ana, CA 92705 P: 714.542.1004 I F: 714.542.1332 I C: 714.414.8711 www.uscubed.com I tonvc@uscubed.com Please be advised that this email may contain confidential information. If you are not the intended recipient, please notify us by email by replying to the sender and delete this message. The sender disclaims that the content of this email constitutes an offer to enter into, or the acceptance of, any agreement; provided that the foregoing does not invalidate the binding effect of any digital or other electronic reproduction of a manual signature that is included in any attachment. 1 Moore, Tania From: Jenny Gardelle <jgardelle@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 9:03 AM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF);supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Plans to privatize Huntington Beach libraries To Whom It May Concern, As a long-time Huntington Beach resident, I'm reaching out to implore that you discontinue talks to privatize our city's libraries.This is an appalling move that can only result in less access to books and other resources the library offers and the community relies on.Additionally, I understand that the city will still be responsible for maintenance,which makes no sense at all. If LS&S Corp will turn a profit,they should keep up on the maintenance. The fact that you've decided to continue with next steps after hearing the countless arguments against privatizing the libraries at the last council meeting are shameful and a clear indication that you don't represent the people of Huntington Beach. However, I'm writing this today in the hopes that you have some dignity and will listen to the people you were elected to represent. Further, I'm very concerned that they'll end up closing some or all of the branches,which would leave them with very lucrative land to then sell and turn a huge profit.This will surely lead to building more unsightly and very unaffordable high-density housing,further complicating our current traffic and parking trouble. Again, I implore you to discontinue any talks of privatizing the Huntington Beach Library system. Thank you, Jennifer Gardelle 1 Moore, Tania From: GERALD MONIZ <dianjer@verizon.net> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 9:17 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library! Support Agenda Item 24-350 We support item 25-350 Gerald and Diana Moniz.The people should vote on this. Sent from my iPhone 1 Moore, Tania From: Julie Ault <jbas082005@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 9:46 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Support for Agenda item 24-350 Please accept this email communication as an expression of support for Agenda item 24-350 which is before the council at tonight's meeting. As a resident of HB, I am extremely concerned with the refusal of the majority of the council members to take actions that align with the majority of the residents viewpoints. Despite un-recedented public expressions of disapproval with the recent imposition of numerous initiatives which attempt to fundamentally change our community,silence free speech, and force an agenda of morality that is religious in nature upon this community,the council majority repeatedly votes against the will of the people in the city they allegedly serve. Given that the majority on the council has chosen to advance.a personal (inspired by a nationalist christian movement) agenda and not represent the people of HB, 24-350 will restore some control of our city to the residents. So long as the unconstitutional voter ID recently enacted is overturned, I, along with fellow residents,will be able to vote ! Thank you to the minority council members for presenting this agenda item. Sincerely, Julie A.Ault-Snyder • Moore, Tania From:. Pacificdzn <pacificdzn@aol.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 9:56 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library! Support Agenda Item 24-350 Good morning!.I would like to support the agenda item #24-350 to put on the ballot for people to vote for the library to remain public or to change to private. I think many people would prefer to keep the library public as it runs so well as it is now. Changing the library to private will only hurt the staff, volunteers and all of the people who use the library. I humbly ask that you would put this agenda item out to be on the ballot in November. Please stop any work on the RFP from the 3/19/24 meeting. • Lisa Allen 714 846-4885 i Moore, Tania From: Ralph Eastman <wholeanimal@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 10:06 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library! Support Agenda Item 24-350 Our Library is.FINE operating just the way it always has. Trying to change its agenda is an especially shoddy political tactic. Keep your hands OFF the Library. Ralph Eastman HB Resident(and Library user) of 45 years • Moore, Tania From: Lehrer, Joel E <JLehrer@goodwinlaw.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 11:25 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library! Support Agenda Item 24-350 I spent my youth biking down Newland to the city beach, participating the junior lifeguards, playing frisbee golf in Central Park and golf at the old Driftwood and Meadowlark courses, and attending the annual 4th of July parade. But some of my favorite memories are evenings spent at the Huntington Beach Library where I would meet friends to "study." The library became the epicenter of our schoolwork and social life and provided an enriching environment that stimulated and furthered my academic efforts. I have now been living on the East Coast for over thirty years, and my wife and I are starting to think about how we will enjoy the remainder of our lives free from the stresses of work, raising children, and snowstorms, while being closer to my mom (who still lives in the house she and my father bought in 1965). Huntington Beach seemed the perfect place for us for all the obvious reasons, and we routinely scan the real estate sites for our next home. Until now. The politics in Huntington Beach have always spanned the spectrum, and usually tilted somewhat conservative,which I never had a problem with being a registered Republican until relatively recently. But as I follow the current efforts of certain city council members to turn Huntington Beach into an intolerant dictatorship with a handful of individuals imposing their supposed "morality"on others—I just can't see myself proudly saying that I live there or contributing to the city tax base. The last straw was the pandering of these individuals to the lowest common denominator of historical intolerance—banning books—and worse yet, handing one of the city's greatest community assets to a private company to run, and run at the behest of these few intolerant people who are using a public institution as a weapon against those that disagree with their beliefs. Frankly, it is reprehensible. Shame on you. No one is forcing you, your children, or your grandchildren to read anything they do not want to read, so please stop forcing your purported morality onto others. Joel E. Lehrer Partner GOODWIN Goodwin Procter LLP 100 Northern Avenue Boston,MA 02210 o +1 617 570 1057 m+1 617 599 2596 f +1 617 649 1488 JLehreregoodwinlaw.com My Linkedln Download vCard Cal dX0 Founders Workbench I Digital Currency and Blockchain Perspectives I Diversity,Equity+Inclusion ******************************************************************* This message was sent from Goodwin Procter LLP and is intended only for the designated recipient(s). It may contain confidential or proprietary information and may be subject to the attorney-client privilege or other confidentiality protections. If you are not a designated recipient,you may not review, copy or distribute this message. If you receive this in error, please notify the sender by reply e-mail and delete this message.Thank you. ******************************************************************* 1 Moore, Tania From: Jolene Wicks <jolene_wicks@wycliffe.org> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 11:26 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library! Support.Agenda Item 24-350' As a life long and frequent user of the library, I would like to say that I support the current public nature of our library. The library has only gotten better and better over the last 5 years and is a place for community and resources. I support this agenda item 24-350 which puts on hold current attempts at privatization of our library and resources. Jolene Wicks Moore, Tania From: MEG ROBINSON <twokyu@aol.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 12:44 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Yes on agenda item 24-350 I am writing in support of giving us,the citizens of Huntington Beach,the final say in the management of the library.This library is one of the best if not the best in the county. It is an important part of every HB citizens life. Many have donated time and money to help it be the institutional jewel it had become. Citizens have the right to have a true voice in the future of this magnificent library.That is what this agenda item does. Please support this item and our democratic right to vote on the future of this library Margaret Robinson 19 year resident of HB 1 Moore, Tania From:. Taylor Haug <taylorhaug@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 12:47 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Vote Down 24-350 Please reject the item submitted by Moser/Bolton/Kalmick. There will be plenty of union representatives and fear mongers out tonight to scare the public that the world is coming to an end. By simply soliciting bids to run the library privately,the City is doing the fiscally smart thing to see where savings can POTENTIALLY be found. I appreciate the work the new city council representatives have done for the City. 1 Moore, Tania From: Jane Kling <jkling93et@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 2:03 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library! Support Agenda Item 24-350 Please support the above agenda item regarding the library or leave the library as is. Thank you Jane Kling 1 Moore, Tania From:. EMILY <eakeller@hotmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 2:06 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Cc: Van Der Mark, Gracey; McKeon, Casey; Burns, Pat;tonystrickland@surfcity- Subject: Agenda Item 24-350 This is to inform you that as a 48 year resident of Huntington Beach, I want to support Agenda Item 24-350 to allow the VOTERS OF.HB TO-GET THE OPPORTUNITY TO VOTE on privatizing the library services. I do not support the plan to turn over this service to an outside contractor. Please listen to the citizens of HB who DO NOT agree with you...they have a voice, too. Emily Keller 19931 Rothert Lane-92646 1 Moore, Tania From: Jill Thrasher <jthrasher09@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 3:11 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Support Agenda of Item 24-350 Good afternoon, I apologize for not getting my comments in prior to 9:00 a.m. today, but I still would like to say a few words supporting Agenda Item 24-350. A wholeheartedly agree with requiring a vote of the people to privatize/outsource the Huntington Beach Public Library and postpone/terminate the RFP process until after the vote. The city should not rush into a major change of our library system without a vote by its citizens. This would also allow more research between now and November 5, 2024 to make sure this is the best decision for our city. There is no logical reason to rush into major changes to our library without a thorough study. Sincerely, Jill Thrasher Library Director 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8, 2024 6:52 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Agenda Item 24-350 From:Sharon Cohoon<scohoon2@icloud.com> Sent:Wednesday, May 8, 2024 9:19 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org>; Parra, Eric(CM)<EParra@surfcity-hb.org>; Gates, Michael<Michael.Gates@surfcity-hb.org>;supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject:Agenda Item 24-350 Casey McKeon's response) last night to the Kalmick/Bolton/Moser proposal to put this issue on the ballot was weak. He claims seeking this proposal is fiscally responsible and that we don't have to accept the proposal and might learn something useful from it. That might have seemed possible once. But as, I believe council member Mosey said, we (that is the citizens of this city)can read. And nothing we have read about LS&S in the newspapers or found on the internet is positive. I don't know about the rest of the country but none of its California clients seems happy with their services,and some so unhappy they are suing to end the contracts early. So why do you think LS&S has anything useful they can tell us? Also,after having been to several council meetings and heard many speakers, it struck me that when your fan base is speaking,they only talk about their support of the book ban committee. I have yet to hear one person actually say they were in support of outsourcing the library. So why not make this a win/win? Retain the committee and keep those people happy. And leave the library alone and please the rest of us,too. I am not in support of the committee either, but a committee won't have a ten-year contract and can be disbanded. If you outsource the library,the damage may be permanent. Please reconciler. - 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8, 2024 6:53 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Library From: Kathy Dowling<kathyldowling@msn.com> Sent:Wednesday, May 8, 2024 10:21 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Library I find it very interesting that you claim to exercise your "Fiduciary" focus on the Library. In what universe does a company look for"low hanging fruit" in a City Department that represents less than 2%of the City Budget. This is why you are perceived as having an "axe to grind". Try looking at Departments that actually impact your Budget where real cost savings can be recognized. i Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8, 2024 6:53 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Letter in Support of Agenda Item 30 for 5/7/24 From: Rebecca Spongberg<rspong33@gmail.com> Sent:Wednesday, May 8, 2024 12:48 PM To: McKeon, Casey<Casey.McKeon@surfcity-hb.org> Cc:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Re: Letter in Support of Agenda Item 30 for 5/7/24 Casey, I'm not interested in your copy pasta responses. I would like you to start listening to the community instead of acting like some sort of overlord.You were happy to throw away over$400,000 of our tax money to ask people about a pride flag and now something as important as our library shouldn't be left up to the people...when it's a public library that belongs to the people in the first place? And no, it is not normal operating procedure to entertain outsourcing a treasured 100 year old institution.Your gaslighting of the entire community is appalling. On Wednesday, May 8, 2024, McKeon,Casey<Casev.McKeon@surfcity-hb.org>wrote: Thank you for your email Rebecca. We simply issued a request for proposals about potential costs savings to the Library system.The City performs these types of analyses all of the time throughout all City departments and is a normal operating procedure. RFP's go out to the entire public and then companies submit proposals if interested through an open bid process. I feel it's appropriate to perform research into possible cost savings for the taxpayers in any City Department. I completely understand the concerns and sensitivity and will be very judicious in my research and analysis. Nothing has been rushed in this process and careful and diligent review will take place. The Library will remain a Public Library free to the community except for the resident's tax dollars that pay for the$5 million annual Library Department budget. Thank you again for your email. Casey McKeon City Council Member City of Huntington Beach 1 714-536-5553 On May 7, 2024, at 4:35 PM, Rebecca Spongberg<rspong33@gmail.com>wrote: Good afternoon, I'm writing to you in support of agenda item 30 for tonight's meeting:HB Public Library: Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsource(Charter Amendment)and Postpone/Terminate RFP Process Until After Vote. We can't believe privatization of the library is even being contemplated, much less being actively quoted. Please reverse course and at the very least, let the people vote on it. The majority 4(Gracey,Tony, Casey, and Pat) like to pay a lot of lip service on the dais to having"the vote of the people" or even a "mandate." Ha! I'd sure like to see them put their money where their mouth is this evening by supporting this item. https://huntingtonbeach.legistar.com/LegislationDeta il.aspx?I D=6654101&G U I D=65103 F36-4F83- 4ECA-B23C-2DE217137DBA 2 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent Wednesday, May 8,2024 6:54 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Keep our Huntington Beach library public -----Original Message---- From:Susan Richter<letitbeme@me.com> Sent:Wednesday, May 8,2024 3:35 PM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Cc: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Keep our Huntington Beach library public Sent from my iPad 1 Switzer, Donna From: Chasity Nieto <hbchas@yahoo.com> Sent: Thursday, May 9, 2024 9:31 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Urgent Plea to Retain Public Ownership of Our Beloved Library I am writing to express my deep concern regarding the proposal to privatize our local library.As a member of this community and a frequent visitor to our library, I strongly urge you to reconsider this decision. Our library is more than just a building filled with books. It is a vital hub of our community, providing access to information, education, and resources for people of all ages and backgrounds. Privatizing the library would not only jeopardize the accessibility of these resources but also undermine the sense of community that the library fosters. Public libraries are symbols of democracy and equality, providing free and equal access to knowledge for everyone. Privatization could lead to increased costs, restricted access, and a loss of control over the services provided. It may also limit the ability of the library to serve marginalized and underserved populations. Furthermore, privatization could compromise the integrity of the library's collections and programming, as decisions may be driven by profit rather than the needs of the community. It is essential to preserve the autonomy and impartiality of our library as a public institution. Instead of privatization, I urge the City Council to explore alternative solutions to any financial challenges facing the library.This could include increased funding, partnerships with local organizations, or community fundraising efforts. Many of us are willing to do whatever it takes. Our library is a treasure that belongs to all of us, and it is our responsibility to ensure that it remains accessible and inclusive for generations to come. I urge you to prioritize the public interest and reject the proposal to privatize our library. Thank you for your attention to this matter. Please keep our public library public. Sincerely, Chasity Nieto Sent from my iPhone 1 Moore, Tania From: CHARLES BETZ <crbetz@aol.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 6:09 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library! Support Agenda Item 24-350 My wife and I are 35 year residents of Huntington Beach.The Huntington Beach Library System is,for us, among the most valued elements of Huntington Beach.Why would we want to change something that has been such a positive part of our city?Why would we want to turn it over to a firm from another state?Why do want to get rid of the current staff for people we do not know?Our Library system is not likely to be improved by this possible change, nor is it likely to be less expensive to operate. Naturally,there are some books on the shelves that we do not approve of, but many of the ones we prefer are disliked by others.The whole purpose of a Public Library is to provide for people of diverse viewpoints to find what they are looking for, and hopefully, enhance their knowledge. Charles and Carol Betz 1 Moore, Tania From: Tiffany Ng <hellotiffanyng@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024,6:27 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Support terminate RFP process until vote Hi, As a Huntington Beach resident, I fully support terminating RFP process until after the vote. Everyone's voice should be heard,acknowledged, and represented. I also fully support keeping the HB libraries public Thank you, Tiffany 1 Moore, Tania From: daune ff <dauneff@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 8:05 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Agenda item 24-350 Agenda item 24-350 I am requesting the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot for a vote. 1)A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, • 2)An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City.Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the.March 19, 2024 meeting. Daune Finke- Huntington Beach resident 1 Moore, Tania From: John Getsy <jgetsy@mac.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 8:14 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Agenda item 24-350 Agenda item 24-350 I am requesting the City Manager, City Attorney and City Clerk to prepare resolutions, ordinances, and any other materials necessary to place two items for consideration on the November 5, 2024 General Election ballot for a vote. 1)A Charter Amendment to require a majority vote of the City Council and a majority vote of the electors of Huntington Beach to approve any proposal that would change the wholesale management of the library, and/or any proposal to operate the library with a private contractor that would employ library staff to achieve cost savings; and, 2)An advisory vote of the electors of Huntington Beach on whether to hire a third-party contractor to operate the HBPL; a replacement of the current management structure, as proposed by the City Council at its March 19, 2024 meeting. Additionally, direct the City Manager to cease any further work on the Request for Proposals (RFP) as it relates to the action taken at the March 19, 2024 meeting. John 1 Moore, Tania From: Karen Lunsk <karensnh@aol.com> Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 9:09 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library! Support Agenda Item 24-350 Save our library!Vote yes Sent from my iPad 1 Moore, Tania From: Sharon Cohoon <scohoon2@icloud.com> Sent: Wednesday, May 8, 2024 9:19 AM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF); Parra, Eric (CM); Gates, Michael; supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Agenda Item 24-350 Casey McKeon's responsel last night to the Kalmick/Bolton/Moser proposal to put this issue on the ballot was weak. 'He claims seeking this proposal is fiscally responsible and that we don't have to accept the proposal and might learn something useful from.it. That might have seemed possible once. But as, I believe council member Mosey said, we (that is the citizens of this city) can read. And nothing we have read about LS&S in the newspapers or found on the internet is positive. I don't know about the rest of the country but none of its California clients seems happy with their services,and some so unhappy they are suing to end the contracts early. So why do you think LS&S has anything useful they can tell us? Also, after having been to several council meetings and heard many speakers, it struck me that when your fan base is speaking,they only talk about their support of the book ban committee. I.have yet to hear one person actually say they were in support of outsourcing the library. So why not make this a win/win? Retain the committee and keep those people happy. And leave the library alone and please the rest of us,too. I am not in support of the committee either, but a committee won't have a ten-year contract and can be disbanded. If you outsource the library,the damage may be permanent. Please reconciler. 1 Moore, Tania From: Roy Sakamoto <roytsak@yahoo.com> Sent: Wednesday, May 8, 2024 9:51 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library! Support Agenda Item 24-350 Roy Sakamoto Sent from Mail for Windows 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes,Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8,2024 6:54 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Keep our Huntington Beach library public ---Original Message From:Susan Richter<letitbeme@me.com> Sent:Wednesday, May 8,2024 3:35 PM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Cc: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Keep our Huntington Beach library public Sent from my iPad 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8, 2024 6:46 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Public Library Original Message----- From: Chris Ohlendorf<chrisohlendorf@yahoo.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 12:53 PM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Public Library I have been a resident of Huntington Beach for 53 years. I write to strongly oppose any action or proposal to privatize our public libraries,sending funds and control of our important local resource to out of state profit-making entities. A.G.Ohlendorf Sent from my iPad 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes,Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8, 2024 6:47 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:the library outsourcing From: Debbie White<manydebs2go@yahoo.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7,2024 1:32 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:the library outsourcing To Whom It May Concern, Please, don' t outsource your library. Libraries play a very important role in the community, especially during times of recession. And we are in a recession. The quality of service you get from your present library staff is much greater than what you will receive from the outsource . I worked in a library that outsourced a portion of the work that was previously done by library staff. The outsourced work was inferior in quality and over priced. People depend on the library as a safe place for their children after school . It ' s a source for books, movies, music and special events . Best regards from a library fan i Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8, 2024 6:47 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Protect Our Public Library From: Elizabeth M <emcd51@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 2:38 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Protect Our Public Library Good Afternoon, z This email is to voice my support for keeping the Huntington Beach library a public library. My family and I,years long patrons of the library,do not support outsourcing the library. Libraries are accessible and free educational and social centers.The HB library in particular is a public and safe gathering space for our community staffed by a professional and compassionate team. It has been instrumental as a resource for my high school and college research papers, as a fun and enjoyable story time space for my children. For the community it is a safe space for free access to learning including job searches, language learning,finding a great story,and more. A library is not a business. It is a public service,one we should treasure and maintain. Please do not support outsourcing the library. Cordially, Elizabeth Feck 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8, 2024 6:49 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: HB Library- Privatization From: keithdkeithd@earthlink.net<keithdkeithd@earthlink.net> Sent:Tuesday, May 7,2024 3:22 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: HB Library-Privatization Dear City Council Members, I am writing to you to voice my opinions with regard to privatization of the HB Library. I have been enjoying the HB Library,and the Central Library in particular,for 28 years now. It is one of the best libraries that I have ever seen. I am deeply concerned that if it is privatized,the library emphasis will shift(to some extent at least)from providing an excellent library experience,to cutting or de-emphasizing those things that make it as excellent as it is now for the sake of corporate profit. The library system as it is now run does a tremendous job of providing its services. Please do not privatize the HB Library system. Thanks, Keith Dyer 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8, 2024 6:49 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Vote in favor of Agenda Items 29 and 30 From:Christopher Rini<christopher.rini@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7,2024 4:05 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Vote in favor of Agenda Items 29 and 30 Dear Council, My name is Chris Rini, I'm a Huntington Beach native, substitute teacher, archivist, and I've been a library volunteer since about 2019. I urge you to Agenda items 29 and 30. Regarding item 29: public property should be neutral and allowing signs for or against one candidate reads as a tacit endorsement. Regarding item 30: On March 19, over 100 speakers and 600 emails came in saying "Don't privatize." Council voted to pursue an RFP, and Councilman Strickland made his infamous comment caught on a hot mike. Since then, city librarians have been slandered as pedophiles, the head librarian has left. Library-related shenanigans have been covered by Baron News at Fountain Valley High School (https://www.baronnews.com/2024/04/29/huntinciton-beach-city-councils-misconception-of-freedom-is-failing- its-community/), and the city made Last Week Tonight with John Oliver two days ago. Huntington Beach already has the nickname, "Fontana by the Sea," and this does not help. The RFP process has been cloaked with covertness that smacks of an inside job. The library is public, it is open to all and belongs to the 194,300 residents of Huntington Beach and their guests. Let the people vote in November on a matter that affects them all. Thank you, Chris Rini i Switzer, Donna From: Fikes,Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8, 2024 6:50 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Agenda Item 24-350 From: mattehaynes@aol.com<mattehaynes@aol.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 4:28 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda Item 24-350 My family and I support the proposal in Agenda Item 24-350. Huntington Beach voters should decide the fate of the library. We also offer our gratitude to the librarians that serve our city. It's unfortunate that the current leadership has facilitated the demoralization of our librarians that they want to leave. We ask you to do better. The Haynes Family 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent Wednesday, May 8, 2024 6:50 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Letter in Support of Agenda Item 30 for 5/7/24 From: Rebecca Spongberg<rspong33@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7,2024 4:35 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Letter in Support of Agenda Item 30 for 5/7/24 Good afternoon, I'm writing to you in support of agenda item 30 for tonight's meeting:HB Public Library: Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsource(Charter Amendment)and Postpone/Terminate RFP Process Until After Vote. We can't believe privatization of the library is even being contemplated, much less being actively quoted. Please reverse course and at the very least, let the people vote on it. The majority 4(Gracey,Tony,Casey,and Pat) like to pay a lot of lip service on the dais to having"the vote of the people" or even a "mandate." Ha! I'd sure like to see them put their money where their mouth is this evening by supporting this item. https://huntingtonbeach.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=6654101&GUID=65103F36-4F83-4ECA-B23C- 2DE217137DBA 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes,Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8, 2024 6:50 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Agenda Item 24-350 .----Original Message---- From: d.wada<denisewada714@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7,2024 4:37 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda Item 24-350 Van der Mark, Burns,Strickland,and McKeon, I am writing and will attend tonight's meeting in support of our current Library, Librarians,and library collection. I urge council members to hear the voices of those opposed to privatizing the library and allow us time to inform all residents of the actions considered and possible consequences. Unfortunately,if this were a good idea,those who are in favor of privatizing would take some time to defend their proposal with a cost benefit analysis. It isn't enough to say they want to save money in the face of a budget deficit after foolishly paying for Measures A, B,and C on the voter ballot. Not to mention,the costly increase to HB's legal department to fight Sacramento and further culture wars. Many residents have spoken to you facts in favor of maintaining the excellent status quo.Stop attacking the middle class with your union breaking tactics, keep our librarians and library staff.Stop wasting money on the wrong things. Sincerely, Denise Wada 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8, 2024 6:50 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Agenda item 24-350 Original Message From:d.wada<denisewada714@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7,2024 4:47 PM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Agenda item 24-350 Kalmack, Bolton,and Moser,Thank you for being a voice for more liberal governance where tolerance,compassion, and patience have been exemplified. I appreciate the chance to vote so the library doesn't get privatized by the council majority just for expediency and retribution. Sincerely, Denise Wada i Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8,2024 6:51 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Request for Proposal - library feedback Original Message-- From:Andrew Parker<aspmft@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 5:09 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Request for Proposal-library feedback Good afternoon, I am an Orange County resident,and I have heard that the city of Huntington Beach is considering proposals for outsourcing libraries. I want to write and urge you to reconsider. I have lived in Orange County since 1996 in the Rancho Santa Margarita area and have frequented many of our Counties libraries. My favorites are in Rancho Santa Margarita, Mission Viejo and the city of Orange. I am planning on visiting the library at Huntington Beach sometime soon. I think libraries are an important part of our community, especially given that they are a public benefit operated by the. County. I am concerned that outsourcing library services to an outside contractor will subject the library to political forces.Such a decision may lead the library vendor to restrict content based on the whims of elected officials. Furthermore, I am a father to a two year old son. I take him to our local public library and am amazed at the services they provide. Not just books, but movies, periodicals, reading nights,special events-the list goes on. Libraries are extremely important as they provide access to a wide variety of information and viewpoints. I think this is important for a healthy,functioning democracy. I want my son to be exposed to a variety of viewpoints,sources, books,articles-the list goes on. I would think Huntington Beach residents want the same. Again, please reconsider outsourcing libraries.Thank you for your consideration and taking the time to read. Sincerely, Andrew Parker 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8, 2024 6:51 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Agenda Item 24-350 ----Original Message---- From: d.wada<denisewada714@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7,2024 5:26 PM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Re:Agenda Item 24-350 I think it is very sad for HB residents that this agenda item is the only way to combat the power hungry council majority. with the assistance of Michael Gates.Where was fiscal responsibility when the known and unknown costs of Measures ABC was jammed into our deficit?This Republican majority is dismantling free speech,voter rights,education, and our middle class workers. I would urge all council members to consider allowing voters the opportunity to weigh in on a not at all frivolous matter since some of you recently avowed to put it to the voters. For the record: >Van der Mark, Burns,Strickland, and McKeon, I am writing and will >attend tonight's meeting in support of our current Library, > Librarians,and library collection. I urge council members to hear the >voices of those opposed to privatizing the library and allow us time >to inform all residents of the actions considered and possible >consequences. >Unfortunately, if this were a good idea,those who are in favor of 0 >privatizing would take some time to defend their proposal with a cost >benefit analysis. It isn't enough to say they want to save money in >the face of a budget deficit after foolishly paying for Measures A, B, >and C.on the voter ballot. Not to mention,_the costly increase to HB's >legal department to fight Sacramento and further culture wars. >Many residents have spoken to you facts in favor of maintaining the >excellent status quo.Stop attacking the middle class with your union >breaking tactics, keep our librarians and library staff.Stop wasting >money on the wrong things. > Kalmack, Bolton, and Moser,Thank you for being a voice for more >liberal governance where tolerance,compassion, and patience have been >exemplified. > I appreciate the chance to vote so the library doesn't get privatized >by the council majority just for expediency and retribution. Denise Wada Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8, 2024 6:51 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Public Huntington Beach Library From:Tommy Feck<tommy.feck@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7,2024 6:17 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.'CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Public Huntington Beach Library To whom it may concern, As a Huntington Beach voting resident, I am outraged at the request for proposal to outsource the Huntington Beach library.Our library is currently one of the top entities that give value to our city's community and property value.The city council has failed to give any adequate reason as to why we should give up our publicly-run community library to a private entity. Please end this attempt to outsource our public library,or at the very least add it to the November ballot so that the people can vote in their own interests. Thank you sincerely, Tom F. 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8,2024 6:51 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Keep HB libraries PUBLIC From:Tiffany Ng<hellotiffanyng@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7,2024 6:21 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Keep HB libraries PUBLIC Hi, As a Huntington Beach resident, I STRONGLY oppose outsourcing the library and I FULLY support keeping HB libraries public.The libraries are an amazing resource for everyone to access.A select few individuals should not be able to dictate what I can have access to. I hope my voice is heard,acknowledged, adn represented. Thanks and take care, Tiffany 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent Wednesday, May 8, 2024 6:51 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Huntington Beach Library Original Message From: karlee kirk<karlee_kirk1827@yahoo.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 9:05 PM To: CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Huntington Beach Library To whom it may concern, The Huntington Beach Library is an important resource for many students in the area. It's a quiet space and calming environment for those who may not have access to one otherwise. I'd be very disappointed to hear the Huntington Beach library is being outsourced. Best, Karlee Kirk i Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent Wednesday, May 8, 2024 6:51 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: 5/6/24 Meeting From: Kathy Dowling<kathyldowling@msn.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7,2024 10:32 PM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL.CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:5/6/24 Meeting You have caused the disruption in the City!Your ideas are not as pure as you contend. People know your MAGA agenda. is the Plan! You put 3 Charter Amendments on the ballot, now we want to put one on the ballot. Let the voters decide, not you. You don't know what you don't know! Good luck running for State jobs,they will know your story and your Agenda. 2026 can't come soon enough. Get Outlook for iOS 1 • Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8, 2024 6:52 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW:Agenda Item#30. 24-350 HB Public Library:Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsource From:Ashlie Brady<ashlie.brady0409@gmail.com> Sent:Tuesday, May 7, 2024 1:38 PM To:Supplementalcomms@surcity-hb.org Subject:Agenda Item#30. 24-350 HB Public Library:Vote of the People to Privatize/Outsource Hello City Council I am deeply concerned over the privatization of our libraries. Huntington Beach council has already restricted books, let's be honest here you have BANNED books. but call it what you want. It's disgusting, fascist, and SHAMEFUL! You have banned the pride flag, allowed the outing of trans and queer kids and now trying to take away safe PUBLIC libraries where kids can freely learn. You have restricted free speech from PUBLIC areas citing noise issues, I can keep going... I vote NO on the privatization of our libraries. There are 3 of you in the chamber that ACTUALLY care about the people and this city. The rest of you, well you know what you are. begins with a C ends with a T, but since Ms Gracey didn't actually graduate from HS she might not understand what that means. Eat rocks, Ashlie 1 Switzer, Donna From: Fikes, Cathy Sent: Wednesday, May 8,2024 6:52 PM To: Agenda Alerts Subject: FW: Privatization From: Pat Goodman<patgoodman@yahoo.com> Sent:Wednesday, May 8, 2024 8:49 AM To:Van Der Mark, Gracey<Gracey.VanDerMark@surfcity-hb.org>; CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) <city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject: Privatization Dear Mayor Van Der Mark and City Council, I hope that you find this definition of privatize from the Miriam Webster Dicitonary helpful: Privatize, verb, privatize 'pri-va-,tiz, privatized; privatizing; privatizes transitive verb: to make private especially: to change from public to private control or ownership, privatize an industry. Example: The mayor's threat to privatize trash collection shook things up. —Jeff Bailey I believe that last night's public comments relayed the concern that citizens have to go down this path toward privatization of HB Public Library. I do believe that staff could prepare a cost benefit analysis of such a move prior to floating an RFP from contractors to provide you and the citizens with appropriate decision making information. Patricia Goodman Huntington Beach, CA i Switzer, Donna From: Chris Oconnell <chrisoconnell57@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, May 13, 2024 11:55 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Cc: president@fotlhb.com Subject: Re: Save Our Library! Support Agenda Item 24-350 The HB city council voted against democracy and the people's voice. Shame on you for shaming HB and its people. On May 6, 2024, at 8:26 PM, Chris Oconnell<chrisoconnell57@yahoo.com>wrote: I do indeed strongly support Agenda Item 24 350• It is only fair to the people of HB to allow them to weigh-in in democratic fashion on a fundamental change to the way the public library system has operated for many decades. Allow the people, your constituents, to speak.That's the American way! Chris O'Connell HB homeowner since 1965 1 Switzer, Donna From: Marty Smith <martysmithhb80@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, May 13, 2024 3:09 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library! Support Agenda Item 24-350 I am very much in favor of Agenda Item 24-350.We must find a way to stop the 4 city council members who are acting illegally and riding roughshod over any rules. Our library is one of the shining jewels in our city.The privatization will destroy our well run professional library. No one is going to volunteer for a for profit organization.We will lose all the money donated by The Friends of the Library by that wonderful organization. How do we stop the privatization? Sent from my iPhone i Switzer, Donna From: David Rynerson <drynerson@earthlink.net> Sent: Sunday, May 12, 2024 10:25 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org; CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF) Subject: Double Standard? City Council and Chief Parra - There seems to be a double standard at play in city council meetings, especially in regard to police enforcement. Numerous opponents of the council majority have been warned and/or escorted from the building regarding yelling or using salty language.Yet,the council majority's supporters do not seem to get the same treatment.They curse and scream and threaten violence, and the police appear to do nothing. Similarly,when Butch Twining, a council majority supporter and candidate in the next election, sat vaping in the last council meeting in full view of the council and the city attorney-an action that is specifically forbidden by law- nothing was done. He should have been cautioned to stop or face eviction or a ticket, but in fact, nothing was done. How do you expect citizens to have respect for the police and cooperate with them when they see this kind of double standard at play?This undermines respect for police and engenders the belief that police are not applying the law equally, but are picking winners and losers base on their own biases or those of their management. I urge you to rectify this challenge immediately. Best regards, David Rynerson 1 Switzer, Donna From: James Davis <jamesclintondavis@yahoo.com> Sent: Saturday, May 11, 2024 10:21 AM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library! Support Agenda Item 24-350 Please support keeping OUR library public. Thanks, James Davis Sent from my iPhone • Switzer, Donna From: Beaux Thibodeaux <beauxthibodeaux@outlook.com> Sent: Friday, May 10, 2024 4:33 PM To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Support Agenda Item 24-350 Hope all is well! Writing this email to let you know how a special place has such a huge positive impact on making a difference in the community. As I sit here writing this email, I quickly counted over 86 people around me in less the 2minuties. This special place helps every single person here. It makes me tear up as I write this email thinking this wont be here tomorrow. I see babies to great great grandparents come here. Every time I show this place to anyone,they walk in breathless. I'm talking about the Huntington Beach Library. It makes one of the biggest positive impacts ever! Please just come here any day in the afternoon and look around. This place is so special. Please don't let anything happen to it. As I write this, I see a grandpa holding a baby and showing him books, students studying,family learning, engineers sharing stories while 3D printing and so much more all in one special place,the Huntington Beach Library. There is no other place like this in the world. Please save it. 1 Switzer, Donna From: thomas blanchard <tjbisoak69@gmail.com> Sent: Friday, May 10, 2024 3:29 PM • To: supplementalcomm@surfcity-hb.org Subject: Save Our Library! Support Agenda Item 24-350 Save Our Library!As a volunteer for 9 years-this is very personal-many lives will be affected- Volunteering feeds the soul---once taken away-can never be replaced.... 1