Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutApprove the Carr Park Reconfiguration Conceptual Plan as Rec (2) ��NTiN6To 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach,CA 92648 City of Huntington Beach APPROVED AS AMENDED \'�T.. ��F 7-0 TO INCLUDE A y�P PLAQUE AND FLAG POLE File #: 24-528 MEETING DATE: 8/6/2024 REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION SUBMITTED TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members SUBMITTED BY: Eric G. Parra, Interim City Manager VIA: Ashley Wysocki, Director of Community & Library Services PREPARED BY: Ashley Wysocki, Director of Community & Library Services Subject: Approve the Carr Park reconfiguration conceptual plan as recommended by the Community & Library Services Commission Statement of Issue: Staff has worked with David Volz Design Landscape Architects, Inc. (DVD) to conduct a public input process and to develop a conceptual master plan to make needed improvements at Carr Park. The Community & Library Services Commission (Commission) met on June 12, 2024, and approved the conceptual master plan. There is a need for the City Council to review and approve the conceptual plan. Financial Impact: Initial funding in the amount of$100,000 in FY 2021/22 and $355,000 in FY 2022/23 totaling $455,000 has been included in the City's Capital Improvement Program (CIP) for Carr Park conceptual design services, including the preparation of plans and specifications. To date, there is a remaining balance of$336,113 to continue into the next phase of design. Recommended Action: Approve the conceptual plan for Carr Park reconfiguration and authorize staff to move forward with initiating the development of the design and bid package for construction of the updated facility. Alternative Action(s): Do not approve the recommended action and direct staff accordingly. Analysis: Carr Park, located at 16532 Springdale Street, was constructed and opened to the public in 1972. Since that time, the 11.2-acre park has functioned as one of the City's largest passive neighborhood parks. City of Huntington Beach Page 1 of 5 Printed on 7/31/2024 powere'J$i LegistarTM File #: 24-528 MEETING DATE: 8/6/2024 Development Background Today, existing amenities at Carr Park include a playground structure, meandering sidewalks, picnic tables, and a 1.02-acre, approximately 8' deep man-made lake with an island. Carr Park hosts the annual Huntington Beach Police Department's "Fish with the Force" event and previously hosted the Community Services "01' Fishin' Hole Derby" for children with developmental disabilities. The Department of Fish and Wildlife funds the stocking of fish for these events. To assess the current biological environment at Carr Park, the project team has consulted with MNS Engineers to complete a biological resources assessment (Attachment 1). The results of the biological study can be found beginning on page 12. In general, Carr Park contains no sensitive communities, no native natural communities, and is predominately maintained as well-manicured parkland for recreational uses. The report explains no special status plants are known to occur or expect to occur at Carr Park due to the lack of natural habitats and surrounding development. The report further explains that the proposed project will not have significant direct, indirect, or cumulative effects on candidate, sensitive or special status species or on riparian habitat or other sensitive natural communities. Carr Park currently has 70 trees. The removal of the island and expansion of the lake will result in the loss of approximately 10 trees, however, 125 new trees will be planted, resulting in 185 total trees at Carr Park. Depending on tree health, trees proposed for removal may be transplanted to other areas of the park. There is currently an imbalance of wildlife and passive recreational use at the park. The island does not have a pedestrian path which provides a protected habitat for waterfowl, safe from predators, such as coyotes, who can only reach them by swimming across the lake. The increase in protected waterfowl contributes to a degradation of the lake water quality due to an increase in droppings that settle in the bottom of the lake. The lake cannot assimilate the volume of nutrients, which creates an abundance of algae. The lack of vegetation rooted into the soil of the lake plays a large part in the poor water quality. Many visiting the park bring food to feed the waterfowl. While this is a behavior that is ingrained in our society, feeding the waterfowl a non-native diet, often full of carbohydrates, begins to change the waterfowl's natural behaviors of migration and hunting for food. As a result, the waterfowl have found a permanent home at Carr Park, leaving behind a high volume of droppings across the park's greenspace, often leaving visitors with an unpleasant experience. Public Outreach Through its contract with DVD, staff has conducted an extensive community outreach program and met with critical stakeholder groups to establish a partnership with the community in the development of the conceptual master plan. To generate awareness of the project, 2,500 informational postcards were mailed to surrounding neighborhoods (Attachment 2) and large posters were displayed at the park. A project website (tinyurl.com/carr-park) was developed, which includes all of the project information, community meeting and virtual survey results, as well as the proposed conceptual designs. An email distribution list of 165 individuals has also been used to remind residents of upcoming community meetings, virtual surveys, and updates on the project. City of Huntington Beach Page 2 of 5 Printed on 7/31/2024 powereilca4 LegistarTM File #: 24-528 MEETING DATE: 8/6/2024 Two in-person design charrettes were conducted with community members, which were each followed with a widely distributed virtual survey soliciting feedback on the concepts discussed during the in-person meetings. The first in-person meeting, held on May 17, 2023, involved approximately 50 community members and was hosted at Carr Park. Attendees were taken on a tour of the park and then divided into smaller teams to discuss current conditions and desired improvements. Following the break-out sessions, groups presented their ideas to their peer community members, and DVD noted the proposed concepts. Virtual survey 1, which remained open from May 18 - June 1, 2023, was distributed to collect feedback from residents that were unable to attend the in-person community meeting. A total of 218 residents responded to the survey and listed tree preservation, maintain no restrooms at the site, provide educational signage on feeding wildlife, preserve the open grass areas, enlarge the lake, add walkways, and move the playground away from the lake, as priority items. Using both the in-person meeting and virtual survey results, two concept plans were developed and presented at a second in-person community meeting on July 20, 2023. About 50 community members attended this meeting, which consisted of a review of the input received at the first community meeting and virtual survey, followed by a presentation of two concept plans (Attachment 3). Feedback on the plans was noted, and a second virtual survey was sent out to allow comments from those unable to attend the meeting. This second survey was more open ended, allowing residents to indicate their preference on the concept plans and leave general comments. A total of 52 virtual surveys were collected from July 21 - August 4, 2023. While there was some concern expressed about the increased size of the lake, in-person participants were reminded that increasing the size was important for the health and quality of the lake. Participants expressed concern about the proximity of the playground to the lake and preferred the island in the lake be removed. In addition to community input, staff and DVD also consulted with a series of stakeholders, including the Department of Fish & Wildlife, the Huntington Beach Fishing Club, Ryan Winkleman, an E-Bird Administrator, and the Huntington Beach Police Department (HBPD). Each stakeholder has reviewed the proposed conceptual plan and appreciates the balance the plan will bring between wildlife and humans at the park, and the natural filtration enhancements to improve the lake's water quality. To preserve the balance of wildlife and human use, the Department of Fish & Wildlife recommends that the City provide extensive education on the impact of feeding wildlife and to provide enforcement, when necessary, to deter this behavior. HBPD applied Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) principals during their review of the plan, and do not see any design elements that would trigger further review. Proposed Improvements Based on the community input received and professional analysis, DVD has prepared a conceptual master plan (Attachment 4) that includes: • Removal of the island Increasing the size and depth of the lake to match the natural flood patterns at the park during heavy storms (Attachment 5) City of Huntington Beach Page 3 of 5 Printed on 7/31/2024 powere• 3lj LegistarTM File #: 24-528 MEETING DATE: 8/6/2024 • Replacement of the lake filtration system to a biological treatment system, which will naturally improve water quality and remove the need for chemicals • Piers for fishing • A connected approximate 1/2-mile walking path surrounding the perimeter of the park • Installation of fitness equipment • A concrete walking path around the perimeter of the lake to increase accessibility • A new playground relocated away from the lake edge, which will include a short perimeter fence, further enhancing safety for children in the park Most notable will be the improved water quality of the lake, which will be achieved through a holistic approach to water quality management in the design of the lake ecosystem and lake amenities that would result in a lake than can be managed without the use of chemicals such as algaecides/herbicides, insecticides, and artificial water colorants (Attachment 6). The proposed updates to the lake were designed by civil engineering firm J. Smith & T. Muli, Inc. These updates include upgraded aeration, a bio filter to control excess nutrients in the water and limit algae growth, skimmers, and the addition of specific species of aquatic plants to further remove excess nutrients. Water would be pumped, filtered, and returned into the lake through small, decorative streams and water elements that naturally follow the park's topography. Along the perimeter of the lake, it is recommended to create aesthetic aquatic vegetation planters. Aquatic plants help remove nutrients from the water column through root uptake and the plant's flowers attract dragonflies which eat mosquito larvae and help to suppress mosquitoes/vectors. To minimize the effects of solar warming, it is recommended the lake have a depth of up to 15'. At this depth, the lake will not have extreme temperature changes and will minimize wide fluctuations in dissolved oxygen due to solar warming, which is another natural way to promote a healthy lake environment. The lake will also be designed to have a 4:1 (H:V) bottom slope ratio for increasing the depth, meaning every four feet horizontally from the lake's edge the depth will increase by one foot. This bottom slope ratio is considered to be a safe slope for anyone who may inadvertently enter the lake to safely exit. To promote the establishment of fish and build a healthy fishery in the lake, it is proposed to create a fish habitat in the lake which includes artificial reefs. The artificial reefs can be made from upcycled materials from the demolition of the park, including crushed concrete or rubble. Spawning habitats could also be created, allowing for targeted species of fish to thrive at the lake to support the intended fishery and game fish. The proposed improvements will reestablish a balance between wildlife and passive recreational park usage. Project Development Process/Timeline Pending approval by City Council, the next step in the process would be the development of detailed engineering plans and specifications, including preparation of a preliminary construction estimate. A remaining balance of$336,113 in Capital Improvement funds are available to continue into this next phase. Any unused funding will be carried over into future fiscal years. Additional funds will need to City of Huntington Beach Page 4 of 5 Printed on 7/31/2024 powered LegistarM File #: 24-528 MEETING DATE: 8/6/2024 be identified and budgeted as the project proceeds into the construction phase. Given the lake's water supply is provided through storm water, this expands the opportunity for staff to seek grant opportunities to offset future construction funding needs. Environmental Status: The appropriate environmental process will be followed, as directed by the Planning Division of the Community Development Department once a conceptual plan is approved. Strategic Plan Goal: Non Applicable -Administrative Item Attachment(s): 1. Biological Survey 2. Informational Postcard 3. Proposed Concept Plans Based Off Community Input Meeting # 1 4. Proposed Concept Plan for Approval 5. Proposed Lake Redesign Overlay on Existing 6. Proposed Lake Filtration System Memo 7. PowerPoint Presentation City of Huntington Beach Page 5 of 5 Printed on 7/31/2024 poweret LegistarM City Council/ ACTION AGENDA August 6,2024 Public Financing Authority 16. 24-530 Received and filed the City Clerk's quarterly listing of professional services contracts filed in the City Clerk's Office between April 1, 2024 and June 30, 2024 Recommended Action: Receive and file the "List of Professional Services Contracts Approved by Department Heads and Submitted to the Office of the City Clerk during the period of April 1, 2024 and June 30, 2024." Approved 7-0 17. 24-550 Approved and authorized execution of License Agreements with the County of Orange to continue the operation and maintenance of official and secure Ballot Drop Boxes at the Huntington Beach Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, and the Main Street Branch Library, 525 Main Street, in Huntington Beach Recommended Action: A) Approve and authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to execute a "License Agreement"with the County of Orange for continued operation and maintenance of a Ballot Drop Box as identified in Exhibits A and B (License Area description and location) at the Huntington Civic Center, 2000 Main Street, Huntington Beach; and, B) Approve and authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to execute a "License Agreement" with the County of Orange for continued operation and maintenance of a Ballot Drop Box as identified in Exhibits A and B (License Area description and location) at the Main Street Branch Library, 525 Main Street, Huntington Beach. Approved 7-0 City Manager 18. 24-527 Took positions on legislation pending before the State Legislature and a statewide ballot proposition, as recommended by the Intergovernmental Relations Committee (IRC) Recommended Action: A) Support Senate Concurrent Resolution 165 (Nguyen) to Designate Portion of 405 Freeway as Surf City Highway. B) Adopt Resolution No. 2024-43, "A Resolution of the City of Huntington Beach in Support of Proposition 36, The Homelessness, Drug Addiction and Theft Reduction Act", which will set aside Resolution No. 4344 and Resolution No. 2024-23 for this action. Approved 5-2(Moser, Kalmick-Abstain) Community and Library Services 19. 24-528 Approved as amended the Carr Park reconfiguration conceptual plan as recommended by the Community & Library Services Commission Page 5 of 11 City Council/ ACTION AGENDA August 6,2024 Public Financing Authority Recommended Action: Approve the conceptual plan for Carr Park reconfiguration and authorize staff to move forward with initiating the development of the design and bid package for construction of the updated facility. Approved 7-0 as amended to include a plaque and flagpole near the corner of Springdale and Heil honoring Chris Carr, a World War 11 Medal of Honor recipient and longtime resident of Huntington Beach Community Development 20. 24-502 Approved and authorized execution of Professional Services Contracts for On-Call Plan Review Services with Scott Fazekas &Associates, Inc., CSG Consultants, Inc., and True North Compliance Services, Inc. Recommended Action: A) Approve and authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to execute a $1,500,000 Professional Services Contract between the City of Huntington Beach and Scott Fazekas & Associates for On-Call Building Division Plan Review Services for a three-year term; and, B) Approve and authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to execute a $1,500,000 Professional Services Contract between the City of Huntington Beach and CSG Consultants, Inc. for On- Call Building Division Plan Review Services for a three-year term; and, C) Approve and authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to execute a $1,500,000 Professional Services Contract between the City Huntington Beach and True North Compliance Services, Inc. for On-Call Building Division Plan Review Services for a three-year term. Approved 7-0 Fire 21. 24-533 Approved and accepted the Fiscal Year (FY) 2023 Assistance to Firefighters Grant, authorized the Fire Chief and Chief Financial Officer to execute documents, and approved appropriation of funds Recommended Action: A) Approve and accept the FY 2023 Assistance to Firefighters Grant awarded to the City of Huntington Beach; and B) Authorize the Fire Chief and Chief Financial Officer as the officials to execute and sign for the FY 2023 Assistance to Firefighters Grant award, agreement, amendments, and extensions; and, C) Approve the appropriation of grant revenues and expenditures in the amount of $161,745.16. Approved 7-0 Page 6 of 11 marcus@mcengland.com 0 mcengland.com englandecology englandecology (� englandecology (213)304-1826 Mt.Washington, Los Angeles,CA gi Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park, City of Huntington Beach, Orange County, California DRAFT Prepared for: MNS Engineers Santa Barbara, CA 93103 Prepared by: Marcus C. England EnglandlEcology, LLC Los Angeles, CA 90065 April 26, 2024 England Eco1o9y y7,•\ mcenglanorir4Aft Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Table of Contents Introduction 1 Project Site Location 1 Project Description 1 Definitions 2 Regulatory Setting 3 Federal 3 Federal Endangered Species Act 3 Migratory Bird Treaty Act 3 Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act 4 Birds of Conservation Concern 4 State of California 4 California Endangered Species Act 4 Fully Protected Animals 5 Species of Special Concern 5 California Rare Plant Ranks 5 California Fish and Game Code Sections 3503, 3503.5, 3513 6 California Environmental Quality Act 6 Methods 7 Definitions 7 Resource Status Designations Considered 7 Desktop Review 7 Occurrence Potential 8 Field Survey 10 Geospatial &Tabular Data Storage 10 Taxonomy&Nomenclature 11 Results 12 Biological Setting 12 Soils 14 Aquatic Resources 14 Vegetation Communities & Habitats 14 Page iA�1 Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Extant Vegetation Communities 15 Sensitive Vegetation Communities 17 General Conclusions 19 Flora 19 Floral Diversity 19 Special Status Flora 19 General Conclusions 20 Fauna 20 Faunal Diversity 20 Special Status Fauna 20 General Conclusions 21 Other Considerations 22 Nesting Birds 22 Wildlife Movement 22 Effects and Minimization Measures 23 Spatial Extent of Effects 23 Effects on Candidate, Sensitive, or Special Status Species 24 Effects on Riparian Habitat or Other Sensitive Natural Communities 24 Effects on State or Federally Protected Wetlands 25 Effects on Wildlife Movement and Nursery Sites 25 Effects on Local Policies or Ordinances Protecting Biological Resources 25 Effects on the Provisions of an Adopted Habitat Conservation Plan 25 Figures Figure 1. Project Location Map 1 Figure 2. Aerial showing Project Site and surroundings in 1927. The approximate location of modern Carr Park is highlighted with an orange rectangle. 12 Figure 3. Aerial showing Project Site and surroundings in 1962. The approximate location of modern Carr Park is highlighted with an orange rectangle. 13 Figure 4. Aerial showing Project Site and surroundings in 1977. The location of Carr Park is highlighted with an orange rectangle. 14 Page ii ��� Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Tables Table 1..Survey Dates, Times, and Weather Conditions 10 Appendices Appendix A. Floral & Faunal Compendia Appendix B. Desktop Review of Special Status Biological Resources Appendix C. Photo Log Appendix D. eBird Species List Appendix E. Resume Page iii 1, Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Introduction This Biological Resources Assessment ("Assessment") describes the known and potentially-occurring biological resources at Chris Carr Park ("Carr Park" or "Project Site"), located in the City of Huntington Beach, Orange County, California. As shown herein, while special status biological resources have been documented on the Project Site, the Project would not be expected to have significant effects on these biological resources. • Project Site Location Carr Park is located on approximately 11.2 acres of land on the southeast corner of the intersection of Heil Avenue and Springdale Street in the City of Huntington Beach, Orange County, California. On the Public Land Survey System, Carr Park is located within the La Bolsa Chica Land Grant of the US Geological Survey's 7.5- minute Seal Beach quadrangle. Carr Park's location is shown below in Figure 1. —118.06 —118.05 —116.04 —110.03 —116.02 —116.01 —118.00 —117.99 , . 1 n r s j 1 t w i i, __ � ,: �,i �Ai:is aE„ I ' �. s: z 4 r I, ,, . i, '' may` � r .r c0S --- _ t c 4E c'' 1." a4 t fa i t, ,f 1 'ear. „ 1 , i �� i p s 11 s. +'"k.' �"i'` ?� ' .^ Yf b .s i .. l E FN {�l 5` --,— 1 W Z iI 444.1/4 k4'4a ', t t i ; Y , t a. � �� �Ig-� a �.1- � ,ma`s'- s - �+ _fi 11 MLA" . "�' � ..fie°'r'� �i' c.� f n i, � -cr"`. �� -118.06 -116.05 -11:.04 116.03 —118.02 -11:.01 Figure 1. Project Location Map Project Description The proposed project involves the grading and construction of improvements to Carr Park, including reconstruction of the existing Carr Park Duck Pond, installation of new park landscaping and turf grass, and the construction of outdoor meeting space, fishing docks and decomposed granite walkways. The existing 1.02-acre duck pond would be drained to facilitate the grading and construction of a new approximately 3- acre duck pond. The proposed duck pond would incorporate water circulation and filtering design to improve and maintain pond water quality. Natural areas around the lake would be landscaped with aquatic and Page 1 �•1 Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 wetland plant species. Artificial reefs would be installed in various locations around the lake bottom to provide habitat for fish. The park will be landscaped with turf grass and include more natural areas with meadow grasses and trees. Existing native and mature trees within Carr Park will be preserved and incorporated into the landscaping plan. A "green buffer" incorporating vegetation that benefits local wildlife and birds will be installed along the east and south park boundary. The pond would be improved for public use through the construction of fishing docks at various locations along the bank and a walking path/bridge. An outdoor meeting space with seating would be constructed within the northern portion of the park. The park amenities will be accessed via a meandering paved walkway, which will include several neighborhood sidewalk connections along the east, west and north park boundaries. Definitions The following are key areas referenced in this Assessment: • Project Site: The Project Site is the 11.21 acres of Carr Park. The Project Site is also the Biological Study Area for this Assessment. • Regional Study Area: The Regional Study Area is the area for which taxa and habitat records were pulled from most biological resource databases. It includes the 7.5-minute US Geological Survey quadrangle the Project Site is located in and all surrounding quadrangles: Anaheim, Long Beach, Los Alamitos, Newport Beach, and Seal Beach. The Regional Study Area is depicted in the Desktop Review Report provided as Appendix B. Page 2 Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Regulatory Setting The following summarizes regulations and other resource protection mechanisms that are known to be or potentially are applicable to biological resources on the Project Site. Key species status terms and their abbreviations, used later in this report, are in bold text. Federal Federal Endangered Species Act The Federal Endangered Species Act (FESA) is the federal government's tool to protect rare and declining plant and wildlife species. It is implemented jointly by the US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS, terrestrial species) and the National Marine Fisheries Service. FESA protects species using the following status designations: • An endangered (FE) species is a species of invertebrate, plant, or wildlife formally listed under FESA as facing extinction throughout all or a significant portion of its geographic range. • A threatened (FT) species is a species of invertebrate, plant, or wildlife formally listed under FESA as likely to become endangered within the foreseeable future throughout all or a significant portion of its range. A proposed threatened (FPT) or proposed endangered (FPE) species is one officially proposed for addition to the federal threatened or endangered species lists. A candidate (FC) species is one under review for listing, often due to the submittal of a petition by an outside entity. "Take" of a federally endangered or threatened species or its habitat is prohibited by federal law without a special permit. The term "take", under FESA, means to harass, harm, pursue, hunt, shoot, wound, kill, trap, capture, or collect, or to attempt to engage in such conduct. "Harm" is defined to encompass "an act which actually kills or injures wildlife. Such an act may include significant habitat modification or degradation where it actually kills or injures wildlife by significantly impairing essential behavioral patterns, including breeding, feeding or sheltering" (50 CFR 17.3). FESA also requires the USFWS to consider whether there are areas of habitat essential to conservation for each listed species. Critical habitat (CH) designations protect these areas, including habitat that is currently unoccupied but may be essential to the recovery of a species. An area is designated as critical habitat after the USFWS publishes a proposed Federal regulation in the Federal Register and then receives and considers public comments on the proposal. The final boundaries of critical habitat are officially designated when published in the Federal Register. Migratory Bird Treaty Act The Migratory Bird Treaty Act of 1918 (MBTA) is a federal law governing the taking, killing, possession, transportation, and importation of various birds, their eggs, parts, and nests. The take of any number of a bird species listed as protected on any one of four treaty lists is governed by the MBTA's regulation of taking migratory birds for educational, scientific, and recreational purposes and requiring harvest to be limited to levels that prevent over utilization. The MBTA also prohibits taking, possession, import, export, transport, selling, purchase, barter, or offering for sale, purchase or barter, certain bird species, their eggs, parts, and nests, except as authorized under a valid permit (50 CFR 21.11). Page 3 =� Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act The Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act (BGEPA) (16 U.S.C. 668-668c), enacted in 1940, and amended several times since then, prohibits anyone, without a permit issued by the Secretary of the Interior, from "taking" eagles, including their parts, nests, or eggs. The Act provides criminal penalties for persons who "take, possess, sell, purchase, barter, offer to sell, purchase or barter, transport, export or import, at any time or any manner, any bald eagle ... [or any golden eagle], alive or dead, or any part, nest, or egg thereof." The Act defines "take" as "pursue, shoot, shoot at, poison, wound, kill, capture, trap, collect, molest or disturb." For purposes of the guidelines, "disturb" means: "to agitate or bother a bald or golden eagle to a degree that causes, or is likely to cause, based on the best scientific information available, 1) injury to an eagle, 2) a decrease in its productivity, by substantially interfering with normal breeding, feeding, or sheltering behavior, or 3) nest abandonment, by substantially interfering with normal breeding, feeding, or sheltering behavior." In addition to immediate impacts, this definition also covers impacts that result from human-induced alterations initiated around a previously used nest site during a time when eagles are not present, if, upon the eagle's return, such alterations agitate or bother an eagle to a degree that interferes with or interrupts normal breeding, feeding, or sheltering habits, and causes injury, death or nest abandonment. Birds of Conservation Concern The Birds of Conservation Concern (BCC) list "identifies the migratory and non-migratory bird species (beyond those already designated as federally threatened or endangered) that represent [the USFWS's] highest conservation priorities. The list is based on an assessment of several factors, including population abundance and trends, threats on breeding and nonbreeding grounds and size of breeding and nonbreeding ranges. Bird species considered for the BCC include: nongame birds gamebirds without hunting seasons subsistence-hunted nongame birds in Alaska ESA candidate, proposed, and recently delisted species.1" State of California California Endangered Species Act The California Endangered Species Act (CESA) is the State of California's tool to protect rare and declining plant and wildlife species. Plant and animal species may be designated threatened or endangered under CESA after a formal listing process by the California Fish and Game Commission. Implementation of CESA is by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW). CESA protects species using the following status designations: • An endangered (CE) species is a species of plant or wildlife whose prospects of survival and reproduction are in immediate jeopardy. • A threatened (CT) species is a species of plant or wildlife present in such small numbers throughout its range that it is considered likely to become an endangered species in the near future in the absence of special protection or management. A candidate (CC) species is one formally under review for listing. Candidates species are protected from take by CESA during the review process. 1 https://fws.gov/media/birds-conservation-concern-2021 pdf VAN Page 4 29 ,`1 Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Fully Protected Animals CDFW describes the Fully Protected (FP) animals,list as "the State's initial effort in the 1960's to identify and provide additional protection to those animals that were rare or faced possible extinction. Lists were created for fish, amphibians, reptiles, birds and mammals. Fully Protected species may not be taken or possessed at any time and no licenses or permits may be issued for their take except for collecting these species for necessary scientific research, relocation of the bird species for the protection of livestock, or if they are a covered species whose conservation and management is provided for in a Natural Community Conservation Plan.2" Species of Special Concern Species of special concern (SSC) is an informal designation used by the CDFW for some declining wildlife species that are not officially listed as endangered, threatened, or rare. This designation does not provide legal protection, but signifies that these species are recognized as vulnerable by CDFW. California Rare Plant Ranks While not a government agency, the California Native Plant Society (CNPS) is a statewide resource conservation organization that has developed an inventory of California's special-status plant species that is highly regarded by the agencies and biologists. This inventory is a summary of information on the distribution, rarity, and endangerment of California's vascular plants. Rare or potentially rare plant species are ranked using the following system (CRPR): • 1A: Plants Presumed Extirpated in California and Either Rare or Extinct Elsewhere. • 1 B: Plants Rare, Threatened, or Endangered in California and Elsewhere • 2A: Plants Presumed Extirpated in California, But Common Elsewhere • 2B: Plants Rare, Threatened, or Endangered in California, But More Common Elsewhere • 3: Plants About Which More Information is Needed - A Review List • 4: Plants of Limited Distribution -A Watch List After each rarity ranking, there is also a threat ranking: • 0.1: Seriously threatened in California (over 80% of occurrences threatened / high degree and immediacy of threat) • 0.2: Moderately threatened in California (20-80% occurrences threatened / moderate degree and immediacy of threat) • 0.3: Not very threatened in California (less than 20% of occurrences threatened / low degree and immediacy of threat or no current threats known) 2 https://wildlife.ca.gov/Conservation/Fully-Protected Page 5 `� Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 California Fish and Game Code Sections 3503, 3503.5, 3513 These California Fish and Game Code sections protect all birds, birds of prey, and all nongame birds, as well as their eggs and nests, for species that are not already listed as fully protected and that occur naturally within the state. Sections 3503 and 3503.5 of the CFGC stipulate the following regarding eggs and nests: Section 3503 states that it is unlawful to take, possess, or needlessly destroy the nest or eggs of any bird, except as otherwise provided by California Fish and Game Code or any regulation made pursuant thereto; and Section 3503.5 states that is it unlawful to take, possess, or destroy any birds in the orders Falconiformes or Strigiformes (birds-of-prey) or to take, possess, or destroy the nest or eggs of any such bird except as otherwise provided by CFGC or any regulation adopted pursuant thereto. Section 3513 states that it is unlawful to take or possess any migratory nongame bird as designated in the MBTA or any part of such migratory nongame bird except as provided by rules and regulations adopted by the Secretary of the Interior under provisions of the MBTA. California Environmental Quality Act Appendix G of the CEQA Guidelines is used by public agencies to determine whether a project may have a significant impact on biological resources. Under Appendix G (Section IV), a project may have a significant impact on biological resources if it would: • Have a substantial adverse effect, either directly or through habitat modification, on any species identified as a candidate, sensitive, or special status species in local or regional plans, policies, or regulations by the CDFW or USFWS. • Have a substantial adverse effect on any riparian habitat or other sensitive natural community identified in the City or regional plans, policies, or regulations by the CDFW or USFWS. • Have a substantial adverse effect on federally protected wetlands as defined by Section 404 of the Clean Water Act (including, but not limited to, marsh, vernal pool, coastal, etc.) through direct removal, filling, hydrological interruption, or other means. • Interfere substantially with the movement of any native resident or migratory fish or wildlife species or with established native resident or migratory wildlife corridors, or impede the use of native wildlife nursery sites. • Conflict with any local policies or ordinances protecting biological resources, such as tree preservation policy or ordinance (e.g., oak trees or California walnut woodlands). • Conflict with the provisions of an adopted Habitat Conservation Plan, Natural Community Conservation Plan, or other approved local, regional, or state habitat conservation plan. In addition, Section 15065(a) of the CEQA Guidelines establishes that a significant impact may occur if "[t]he project has the potential to substantially degrade the quality of the environment, substantially reduce the habitat of a fish and wildlife species, cause a fish or wildlife population to drop below self-sustaining levels, threaten to eliminate a plant or animal community, [or] reduce the number or restrict the range of an endangered, rare or threatened species." Page 6 � Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Methods This Assessment is informed by data from an expansive desktop review and a field survey, the methods for which are described below. From this section forward, the more biologically accurate terms taxon and taxa are used in place of the term species used in' most regulations because of the fluid nature of modern taxonomy, with special status assignments often being made for subspecies and populations instead of entire species. The term species is only used where applicable to the discussion. Definitions Resource Status Designations Considered A variety of agencies and respected non-profit organizations assess the conservation status of plant and wildlife taxa and habitats, however, not all are applicable to this report. The following special status designations were considered when determining special status taxa and habitats to be discussed: • Federal Status: Taxa listed as Endangered (FE) or Threatened (FT), as well as taxa Proposed as Endangered (FPE), Proposed as Threatened (FPT), Proposed for Delisting (FPD), and Candidates (FC) for listing under the Federal Endangered Species Act. Bald and Golden Eagles protected by the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act (BGEPA) and USFWS-listed Birds of Conservation Concern are also included. • California Status: Taxa listed as Endangered (CE) or Threatened (CT), as well as taxa that are Candidates for Endangered (CCE) status, Threatened (CCT) status, or Delisting (CCD) under the California Endangered Species Act. Also considered are taxa listed as Fully Protected (FP) and Species of Special Concern (SSC). • CNPS Status: California Rare Plant Ranks (CRPR) 1, 2, and 3. • NatureServe Element Ranks: NatureServe element state ranks were only considered for taxa when other criteria did not apply. Taxa were included with ranks of S1 (Critically Imperiled), S2 (Imperiled), and S3 (Vulnerable). • Vegetation Communities: All vegetation communities mapped by the CNDDB. Desktop Review EnglandlEcology conducted a review of literature and data sources to characterize biological conditions and to compile records of special status biological resources that could potentially occur on the Project Site. The resources used for this analysis are described below. • Soils: Soils on and in the vicinity of the Project Site were assessed using the Web Soil Survey tools provided by the US Department of Agriculture3. 3 https://websoilsurvey.sc.egov.usda.gov/App/HomePage.htm VA II Page 7 mL Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 • Water: Potential water resources were examined using the US Geological Survey's National Hydrography Dataset4 and the USFWS National Wetlands Inventory5. • Vegetation Communities: potentially-occurring sensitive vegetation community records were pulled from the California Natural Diversity Database (CNDDB)6 for the Regional Study Area. • Flora and Fauna: potentially-occurring special status flora and fauna records were pulled from the following data sources: • Designated and proposed critical habitat layers from the US Fish & Wildlife Service7. Taxa were included if critical habitat was proposed or designated within the Regional Study Area. • CNDDB records from within the Regional Study Area. • The California Native Plant Society (CNPS) Rare Plant Inventory8 records from within the Regional Study Area. • The USFWS-managed Information for Planning and Consultation (IPaC) databases for records returned when uploading the boundary of the Project Site. In addition, records were searched locally within eBird10 and iNaturalist11. Occurrence Potential EnglandjEcology assessed the potential for occurrence of special status plant and wildlife taxa and habitats based on data provided by the desktop review and observations made during the field survey. For taxa for which field observations could not definitively determine occurrence, the following information was considered: • Range: The Regional Study Area—from which records were gathered—is a large area capturing many taxa that would not be expected to occur in the Biological Study Area. In general, range determinations were made as follows: • Flora: The range of the taxon is based on an export of point records of that taxon from Calfloral2 with each record provided a buffer of 10km. If the Biological Study Area was within that mapped 4 https://www.usgs.gov/national-hydrography/national-hydrography-dataset 5 https://www.fws.gov/program/national-wetlands-inventory/wetlands-mapper 6 California Natural Diversity Database(CNDDB).March 30,2024.State and Federally Listed Endangered,Threatened,and Rare Plants of California. California Department of Fish and Wildlife.Sacramento,CA. 7 https://ecos.fws.gov/ecp/report/critical-habitat 6 https://rareplants.cnps.org 9 https://ipac.ecosphere.fws.gov/ 10 https://ebird.org 11 https://inaturalist.org 12 https://www.calflora.org/ Page 8 M Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 range, it could be considered outside of range if the elevations in the Biological Study Area were more than ten percent outside of the known elevation range of the taxon. If alternative sources are used they are included in the notes. • Fauna: The range of the taxon was determined differently based on the taxonomic group: • Invertebrates and Fish: An export of records of that taxon from the Global Biodiversity Information Facility13 with each record provided a buffer of 10km. If alternative sources are used they are included in the notes. • Amphibians, Reptiles, Birds, and Mammals: California Wildlife Habitat Relationships14 range data from the California Department of Fish and Wildlife. If alternative sources are used they are included in the notes. • Habitat: If the Biological Study Area was determined to be outside of the taxon's range, habitat was not assessed and is labeled "N/A". If the Biological Study Area was determined to be within the taxon's range, the quality of the habitats in the Biological Study Area to support any portion of that taxon's life • cycle was assessed and labeled as "Low", "Medium", or "High". The rational for that determination is provided in the Notes of the desktop review report. These occurrence potential assignments are defined below: • Present: Taxa or habitat/vegetation community is known to occur on the Project Site based on recent surveys, CNDDB (within 10 years), or other records. • High: Taxa with known recent recorded occurrences/populations near the Project Site and highly suitable habitat occurs within the Project Site. Highly suitable habitat includes all necessary elements to support the taxon (e.g., elevation, hydrology, soils, cover, habitat type, food resources). • Moderate: Taxa with known recent recorded occurrences/populations near the Project Site; however, habitat within the Project Site has been moderately disturbed, fragmented, or is small in extent. Moderately suitable habitat includes several elements to support the taxon (e.g., elevation, hydrology, soils, cover, habitat type, food resources). Furthermore, moderately suitable habitat may also be located at the edge of the taxon's range, or there are no reported occurrences nearby. • Low: Taxa with few known recent recorded occurrences/populations near the Project Site and habitat within the Project Site is highly disturbed or extremely limited. A low potential is assigned to annual or perennial plant taxa that may have been detectable during a focused survey in the appropriate blooming period but was not found; however, small populations or scattered individuals are still considered to have a low potential to occur. Additionally, taxa for which poor-quality habitat may support the taxon within the Project Site, but the reported extant range is far outside the Project Site and/or any species observations would anticipate being migratory (i.e., not likely to reproduce within the Project Site). 13 https://gbif.org 14 https://wildlife.ca.gov/Data/CWHR Page 9 ak Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 • None: Taxa or habitat/vegetation community are not expected to be present because focused surveys were conducted and the taxon or habitat/vegetation community was not detected, or the taxon was found in the desktop review, but suitable habitat (soil, vegetation, elevational range) was not found on the Project Site, or the Project Site is not within the known geographic range of the species. The potential for bird species were further distinguished into those that may: 1) nest within or near the Project Site; 2) forage within or near the Project Site; and/or 3) occur on or near the Project Site only as transients during migratory flights or other dispersal events. Field Survey EnglandjEcology principal biologist Marcus C. England conducted a reconnaissance-level biological survey on the Project Site on February 13, 2024 from 0845 to 1330h. Weather conditions were mild and appropriate for such a survey to be conducted and are summarized below in Table 1. The survey focused on documenting the presence/absence and condition of water resources, vegetation communities and habitats, and flora and fauna. , The Project Site, being small, was easily covered on foot walking transects of convenience to examine biological resources. Where necessary, observations were made with Leica Noctivid 8x42 binoculars and documented with a Nikon D500 camera paired with a Sigma 150-600mm lens. All other observations were documented using various applications and functions on an iPhone 15 Pro, including the Solocator15 app for photographic documentation of site conditions and the QField16 app for collecting spatial (e.g., photo and resource locations) and non-spatial (e.g., floral and faunal lists) tabular data. After the survey was completed, data in QField was synchronized to a geospatial database using QGIS17 3.36. In addition to the biological work completed specifically for this report, MNS Engineers completed work on the Project Site for a jurisdictional delineation. While the results of that report are summarized herein relative to water resources, we refer you to the jurisdictional delineation report for detailed information about methods and results. Table 1. Survey Dates, Times, and Weather Conditions n .,7, , ' • " `� ° ., • art co 0q, . Conditions r:. � � � � �� 5t ndt�o�s Eno co notions Date Biologist Time ;� � Temp •Clouds Wind Temp Clouds Wind .. . � .. y� _tee-.. _ T.:�. _n.._-•.....___ ..,�: -__ ,_�.M;,..,�.. � .. --,.' ,, 2/13/24 Marcus England 0845-1330h , 62°F Clear _ N/A 1, 67°F 1 Clear N/A 1 Geospatial & Tabular Data Storage All GIS-based resource analysis was conducted in QGIS 3.36, with either local data copies stored in a GeoPackage database or using a web service provided by the organization housing the data. Data specific to the Project Site is stored in a statewide GeoPackage database file. 15 https://solocator.com/ 16 https://qfield.org/ 17 https://www.ggis.org/en/site/ Page 10 2Q Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Taxonomy & Nomenclature It is important within a given report to use a consistent taxonomy for clarity in communication, especially as the various sources used in the research for a report may not use the same taxonomy and nomenclature. The taxonomic database underpinning EnglandlEcology's work is updated monthly from NatureServe18. NatureServe's taxonomy includes an Element Code for each taxon. These same Element Codes are used by a variety of agencies and organizations, including the California Department of Fish and Wildlife in the CNDDB and the California Native Plant Society in their Rare Plant Inventory. The Element Code provides a basis for linking records from disparate data sources. In all cases in this report, the taxonomic order and nomenclature are NatureServe's19, with the exception of the special status flora discussion which is linked to a monthly export of the Rare Plant Inventory. As such, while this report largely capitalizes common names consistent with the NatureServe taxonomy, tabular data exported for special status floral analysis does not use this convention, as it is not used by the California Native Plant Society. 18 https://www.natureserve.org/classifying-biodiversity 19 The author does not always agree with NatureServe's taxonomy(such as where it varies from that of the American Ornithological Society),but it provides a consistent basis for discussion across taxonomic groups. Page 11 LVALlik Carr Park Biological Resources Assessment DRAFT Results City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 This section discusses in detail what is known about biological resources in the Biological Study Area based on information from a field survey, 318 CNDDB records, 37 CNPS records, 29 IPaC records, and four critical habitat determinations in the Regional Study Area. It begins with a discussion of the Project's biological setting and habitats, and ends with a discussion of the floral and faunal taxa that are known to occur or potentially occur in the Biological Study Area. Photographs of site conditions during the survey are provided in the Photo Log attached as Appendix C. Biological Setting Modern Carr Park is a green space located within an urban setting. Of course, the region was not historically so heavily -urbanized. Based on historic aerial photography available from the UC Santa Barbara FrameFinder 20site, the area appeared to be predominantly agricultural in 1927 (Figure 2). Figure 2. Aerial showing Project Site and surroundings in 1927. The approximate location of modern Carr Park is highlighted with an orange rectangle. 20 https://mil.library.ucsb.edu/ap_indexes/FrameFinder/ Page 12 Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 By 1962 (Figure 3), agricultural land uses were still dominant, but several canals had been constructed and residential development had commenced to the northwest. Figure 3. Aerial showing Project Site and surroundings in 1962. The approximate location of modern Carr Park is highlighted with an orange rectangle. Only 15 years later, in 1977 (Figure 4), residential development has filled out the imagery. Carr Park is now evident, and appears much the same as it does now with its current manmade pond, island, and walking paths. i Page 13 2��1 Biological Resources Assessment DRAFT Carr Park City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 'J► e r Figure 4. Aerial showing Project Site and surroundings in 1977. The location of Carr Park is highlighted with an orange rectangle. Soils According to the Natural Resources Conservation Service Web Soil Survey21, all soils on the Project Site are Omni clay, drained. This soil has a parent material of mixed alluvium with a typical profile of clay or silty clay to 60 inches. Aquatic Resources The jurisdictional delineation prepared by MNS Engineers has identified 1.02 acres of state and federal jurisdictional non -wetland waters on the Project Site. These waters are associated with Carr Park's lake. The are no wetland or riparian habitats or other non -jurisdictional water features at Carr Park. Vegetation Communities & Habitats The following section discusses vegetation communities and habitats in the Biological Study Area, including known resources and the potential for occurrence of special status resources. 21 https://websoilsurvey.sc.egov.usda.gov/app/WebSoilSurvey.aspx Page 14 Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach �y t tt } jj ,} a April 26, 2024 �...{. '�h}fk' fib' i��• `q..v`�µegiFi SbY�4"�wash Fi ite t+�tx # 7-# ''''''Pt- ?#"t -i4d„t gi a PC}�u Ybf s_f.`. i..•f' ' . . . Ii 7�li' d 4'i,`I fi'11 `1a... 41i (} g :#tH ''" ltr =n; -r- rg4 '... �"y, .1 y 'i x rp'y, fm. 2 � S '�-c iII�.�!Si � k.� `�m, 1 : i s-rY.�. y i-•''',56i*.4 1i 11 J",S'.. *t F ..,` 3 -$"ffi'w-/ }A 4 Y' I �� "CAL +, k 4 x ,i'.{7 .y g "-4, s-,r,- 6 Y i " b 11 fT' 4 -°.1 3„s -f.eckt;'�h .Z �.. A Y r.'' II ` , w. ,u- ,,yy al - f"q;,.j E,3 ,x`-;4:Q;A:w. ft; ti . si ij 14'S` "`.-73 .v5 i ".5:5:5!.s 3-54-i„ir, i",4,- A t` ^*-r. 'r'e^, a. G»s"t'4;.r.ta`Liev ,�' 4 -"a w r` -K i z I ' 1 _"-5 i 1`4•5-": �1 i--w,t 55'4 w' w -,1,-l :.';1,y�, ,,. .i„ _..�,:�. ,, ...d'- 1 ,fir-•-1;_ s4r t kr }4-pe e„. ww'a ��fg. ,-v; r r" ,? s t a"`+- ',t :3:_-..i P1 l."`, _ c ,,,,.. L /1 t- �*a �r `� :: +, d 3 '�{ +,S'�> , )-g 3'-�a q ,g 9,r�c'y' .+,,".� � e.'.,�. n-+�sa 7i t�a^, ,�y y+.. y,i "A.^� �[ t`�S�y{ ...I %+'�v', tS.��. 4 gSYVMrcw� ""dt Y _'S 1 a^Y..��'a "'�W�.»4. I«A' Y{ ,k s`..^" .-^r� .z r- a tg._L' ti, d p =� '`6 ti ° '�q- ?` ,,fl;:-.r -. f �'7 Via„,-.. ,y r t .,,e. #. .. 'i.pr_ 'rx xs, g. ':. [s v- k2, i `�# C�$¢ `5' .45 m i� C, +.r.-r-e,,.�- r a .+L y -� .� ': 'Sx '§' ^i`1 }� � x+ r,.;.'._ "y t:,/ ..4 .1 Sj i i;}.14.,1.".y€i ..' , .b i 1 tt -, '1. r L--„ , Y`},ar �t f r`' c;4`1.' .'° I =�;,,,zi``-,. C,r` „ 'r * � t t 7y,s }} q''7 i; , "s. . s . a r Ct i, -t.%*7 .t�. E ,. tsz a }','- ..a s s-"t 4' : -.." -' - ,.,_ i i M; 3 S^i;c a3.1, 4 ,,. , j.."`::' '" .,. r t ''v, + i e'4' °� . -'44 E'�"�" t".4r s - ; ,.- e--',: 4t : ,11 -,e 1 'x L"-A,,,, + ,'6 < t .� ":r ".._}f : r''trnt.1 a�+ r 4 :1- ^r ea r '�^^�t L ._ ._: . -f`` " ." '` s i 5"' ':11 8 4 "IA:,,_„..,4 g€ ys w ms" x '� t� p S».k�4'w _{-t` 'l'. r' "". 4 t f i •+�. ., i1 i . :`, i¢' ,3 .-4rg !y r i , `„.. „tea.'. .5., . . - , '�` €t7xto'5. R A •f j, „.i...„ Y ,: „ , . 7 ",,- Fyttt.'fl r' °i _ "s -..r i ; '(-- 'tireni t, " ® , "`*1 �}a - - +tin i , .. es.�t '^�-} ,,...- .,- yieff. tea+"^.o:...,....,c*^ i w—,, . u € j� f , ,w,• . :„ 61 �. a.ii�s y'l�.,j g ��'4 I j d`�'M£ ^, r . . _� . r 'y ^e>•a Y '^zga°:L...., s ♦ '�'i 4"1 { ^s 7..i ^s t6 `�`€. =4"+"'S " "' 4 ` ,'tr "",� °' rt"`::: 4.. a"ih*s ' t.. 471,'i-6 "Y*-''-""mot -..,« ..c ...r . . eta low SS "1'-2 ' ' 1s fit; T• ` 4l" I„ :5 s`.,if�' y 'rw '' ,"'� -^,- -�"z 7.3..� ,,•� _ ..— 04. 1 `ti ;w'�'r a i) x. ,, s' ; . i''�Ti:' `i °---`"er ''3 - '-.. ;---i .,„-'` : -, - .&.`�4'=� I` — ! G`' C�.q 1% Ls r ,i r P ''r'"„r•rr' r1 t`i 4 ,ter 4,.- rry .1'", .--,f -- . A ���`j'�n''..,,� 1 .` `I' .'$-y,'/-45i"i ;<., ,q a R., ,t '1�a.,''A.-C,..i . 5e_ 9 t ``'t _r.'r ' r tJ' . "- 4'1 '_p i'•1'' 'y '' ') 4,,? it 5 •- M y p ' -4,4 - i ♦ `any'+ ,y., y y.y, S "# 7 s E "?�, -t rt. ^4w `d ,t ' , ,+re`r 'Yr t. ,a,%,.... 2%N""•.i p .^ ; rya {. AN r , '� +�qgtt,, : a. \ yy, °: ,,. ^� ., .t s �`, s^,.� r ^,"' .�3 v W!.4 s - mom^.aa+; '+.0..+5s`°. wc :° „ , i�2''i€ ,$r ,.r t+*@ i a s 'A 3,:3 ..,. !t ;,fir, a �a—,-.,. c,`� g ... ,4 t' "c . x x*- 1$ t« 1 p, '-;�..y t�q '}� x,N k `'^--- - y .yam---- !<,tMr - i a.j-'''_ . "' 1 1 "..3 `.. h`ki: -'"t",�.`C ." Y `,,. ,7. ,',#' t u 7c', ', M...., �4-' c1 _ 1. .,�..a _ ":_. ..4."'"...: .-4i, �' }ee' E �"f, w--- i.'&1 r,-+ �l..i 7 "`,'ta`„'°^;"t`°E,y_y ..'A. a. �°'%It-,"z a..C;;.M..?,"� 'd i, • Figure 4.Aerial showing Project Site and surroundings in 1977. The location of Carr Park is highlighted with an orange rectangle. Soils According to the Natural Resources Conservation Service Web Soil Survey21, all soils on the Project Site are Omni clay, drained. This soil has a parent material of mixed alluvium with a typical profile of clay or silty clay to 60 inches. Aquatic Resources The jurisdictional delineation prepared by MNS Engineers has identified 1.02 acres of state and federal jurisdictional non-wetland waters on the Project Site. These waters are associated with Carr Park's lake. The are no wetland or riparian habitats or other non-jurisdictional water features at Carr Park. Vegetation Communities & Habitats The following section discusses vegetation communities and habitats in the Biological Study Area, including known resources and the potential for occurrence of special status resources. 21 https://websoilsurvey.sc.egov.usda.gov/app/WebSoilSurvey.aspx r Page 14 ` he-4 Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Extant Vegetation Communities EnglandlEcology mapped vegetation communities and land cover types on the Project Site based upon recent aerial photography and field observations. This resulted in the classification/mapping of six community/land cover types in the Biological Study Area. These are discussed below and shown in Exhibit 1. Artificial Water Feature Artificial Water Feature comprises approximately 1.02 acres (9.1%) of the Biological Study Area. On the Project Site it measures approximately 1.02 acres in extent, or 9.1% of the site. Artificial Water Feature is not an official Manual of California Vegetation alliance. Artificial water features are man-made, typically small bodies of water. In the area covered by this Assessment, the only area mapped as Artificial Water Feature is Carr Park Lake. Disturbed - Impermeable Surface Disturbed - Impermeable Surface comprises approximately 0.68 acres (6%) of the Biological Study Area. On the Project Site it measures approximately 0.68 acres in extent, or 6% of the site. Disturbed - Impermeable Surface is not an official Manual of California Vegetation alliance. Impermeable Surfaces are parts of the built environment, including paved roads, sidewalks, walkways, and buildings. In general, areas mapped as this land cover type have little value for wildlife and are not considered habitat. Disturbed - Permeable Surface Disturbed - Permeable Surface comprises approximately 0.1 acres (0.9%) of the Biological Study Area. On the Project Site it measures approximately 0.1 acres in extent, or 0.9% of the site. Disturbed - Permeable Surface is not an official Manual of California Vegetation alliance. Permeable Surfaces are parts of the built environment, including compacted but unpaved areas devoid of vegetation, gravel, and unimproved roads. In general, areas mapped as this land cover type have little value for wildlife and are not considered habitat, though in some cases—such as unimproved roads—they may occur within habitat Landscape - Forb Landscape - Forb comprises approximately 8 acres (71.4%) of the Biological Study Area. On the Project Site it measures approximately 8 acres in extent, or 71.4% of the site. Landscape - Forb is not an official Manual of California Vegetation alliance. The "forb" landscape type includes all managed but typically artificially- planted areas of vegetation that are shorter than shrubs. This land cover type includes lawns. These areas have some value for wildlife, as landscape flowers provide food for hummingbirds and butterflies, and lawns can provide foraging areas for some birds and small mammals. Their overall habitat value, however, is significantly lower than any natural habitat they may have replaced. This land cover type is also typically dominated by non-native and often invasive plant species. Page 15 2,1♦� 1= . PA 1 � � `� III/■■■■!�■■■■■�■■■i� � ; . 1 1i: 1 INESE ■is■■■�� � ME■■■r "III Pol r - - - - - sl T Sp`rmgdele 51 � 1 .� IF— SOringd 1 Si �� _ ,% I Gr — r — — Sminpdele 51 SDnnq lele 51 -4 - / S,,r.—gd.11 SI SpOngd.lo St Sp,ingd.le St '� - - - - - - - L, 1 Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Landscape -Tree &Shrub Landscape - Tree & Shrub comprises approximately 0.97 acres (8.7%) of the Biological Study Area. On the Project Site it measures approximately 0.97 acres in extent, or 8.7% of the site. Landscape - Tree & Shrub is not an official Manual of California Vegetation alliance. The "tree & shrub" landscape type is a mix of taller vegetation dominated by non-native trees and typically set in a managed landscape environment. In some cases, native trees are included in this land cover type when part of landscaping and not a functional natural community. Habitat value of this land cover type varies significantly, however, urban environments with significant tall tree cover often harbor a large number of wildlife. This is particularly true of birds. Pepper Tree or Myoporum Groves (Schinus (molle, terebinthifolius) - Myoporum laetum Tree Semi- Natural Alliance) Pepper Tree or Myoporum Groves (Schinus (molle, terebinthifolius) - Myoporum laetum Tree Semi-Natural Alliance) comprises approximately 0.44 acres (3.9%) of the Biological Study Area. On the Project Site it measures approximately 0.44 acres in extent, or 3.9% of the site. The CDFW code for this alliance is 79.200.00. It has a Global Rank of GNA and a State Rank of SNA. It is described in the Manual of California Vegetation as follows: Species: Myoporum laetum, Schinus molle or Schinus terebinthifolius is dominant in the tree canopy . Layers: Trees < 18 m tall; canopy is open to continuous. Shrubs are infrequent or common. Herbaceous layer is simple to diverse. Habitats: Coastal canyons, washes, slopes, riparian areas, roadsides. Holland (1986) Crosswalk: Southern riparian forest, Southern riparian scrub The only alliance mapped on the Project Site, this community is found on the artificial island in the center of Carr Park Lake. While it is dominated by Myoporum, native willows (Salix sp.) are also present. Sensitive Vegetation Communities The four sensitive vegetation communities mapped by the CNDDB as occurring within the Regional Study Area are shown below. The maps show the centroids of the CNDDB records in order to spatially depict the occurrences relative to the Project Site. The accounts highlight determinations of their potential occurrence on the Project Site as well as their potential to be adversely affected by the Project based on field observations. Page 17 2 �1 Biological Resources Assessment April Carr26, Park2024 DRAFT City of Huntington Beach " - = r k "° • Southern Foredunes 4"` F • Global Rank: G2 ` State Rank: 52.1 ', w "` .. Taxon Code: CTT21230CA 1 . r s.---" ' ` CNDDB Records: 3 .- Taxon Group: Dune • Habitats: Coastal dunes ,x, • Notes: — ,.. - . NpwfY � ‘-t,^b , , a ,,td1uVMs Potential.doe,urren oaf None" Potential ForP,roject to Effect None Southern Dune Scrub " t " tom- Ti-", lobal Rank: G1 � ,fly State Rank: St1 .,, ..` a1, • ` Taxon Code: CTT21330CA ,«;,, a ` ., - ,,Y CNDDB Records: 2 s M.� • r• T• axon Group: Dune 9 i17 % Habitats: Coastal dunes �. i; "" t'• Notes: — Neaps" tL - '. .' s .wv ie. Potential Clccurrence'None s Potential For"Project'to'Effect None° SouthernCoastalSaltMarsh :, ''l'-4---":1'.:*.-'7:::--"7-:::-:":::-;:::;:::,, blRank: G2°,, `�" ' State Rank: 52.1 y { , -"" ww.T N a � Taxon Code: CTT52120CA ? �,�.�"` " .� ` .'"1 f,. - CNDDB Records: 7 & � ""�'4.PkV, ' Taxon Group: Marsh „; '` °- )1 ``s ..# ` Habitats: Marsh&swamp;Wetland '+1� E /0,t_ � r" Notes: — _'t �jy� ai N,,, Potentca[DcGurrence`None 9 r Potential Forl?roject to Effect-N4ne r 2Page 18 j4C111111k Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 '4'" i= 4 �� - 1' 7 :..:',.:- Southern Cottonwood Willow Riparian Forest . Ie- .. �* s^-°^ Global Rank: G3 s- 1 ; ,,r., \, .z State Rank: S3.2 r 1 `,, .� ..�..a� , ` Taxon Code: CTT61330CA -y� ,,,,,,,. a ^— 'W't ( [ 'r CNDDB Records: 1 .1 Taxon Group: Riparian .e�2u,^` a "'-` �`q � .-.» "' Habitats: Riparian forest , . +''`- `` Notes: — _ I .4i.Y{eH'� R yf Potential Occurrence:None, !e ', Potential For Project to Effect None, General Conclusions The Project Site contains no sensitive communities, no native natural communities, and is predominantly maintained as well-manicured parkland for recreational uses. Flora The following section discusses flora in the Biological Study Area, including known resources and the potential for occurrence of special status resources. Floral Diversity The list of ten floral taxa detected by EnglandlEcology is provided in the Floral & Faunal Compendium provided as Appendix A. No special status floral taxa from the Desktop Review were detected. The known or expected status of all special status flora analyzed for this report are described in the next section. Special Status Flora The floral literature review identified 37 special status taxa to be considered for their potential occurrence. This was based on records from the following sources: • CNDDB: 109 occurrences of 27 floral taxa in the CNDDB for the Regional Study Area. • CNPS: 37 floral taxa in the CNPS Rare Plant Inventory for the Regional Study Area. • IPaC: two floral taxa recommended for consideration by IPaC based on an upload of the Project Site boundary. • Critical Habitat: 0 floral taxa with proposed or designated critical habitat in the Regional Study Area. Because of the heavily-managed landscape of the park, no special status flora are expected to occur. As such, they are not discussed in detailed herein. All special status flora considered for this report are discussed in the Desktop Review Report provided as Appendix B. Page 19 2,6/ Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 General Conclusions No special status plants are known to occur or expected to occur on the Project Site due to the lack of natural habitats and surrounding development. Fauna The following section discusses fauna in the Biological Study Area, including known resources and the potential for occurrence of special status resources. Faunal Diversity The list of 25 faunal taxa detected by EnglandlEcology is provided in the Floral & Faunal Compendium provided as Appendix A. This list includes 0 amphibian, 0 reptile, 25 bird, and 0 mammal detections during fieldwork conducted on the Project Site. The most commonly observed taxa were American Wigeon (Mareca americana), Mallard (Anas platyrhynctios), and American Coot (Fulica americana). A total of two special status faunal taxa were detected. The known or expected status of all special status fauna analyzed for this report are described in the next section. A single site visit, however, does not capture the full scope of the fauna that occur at a site. Carr Park's status as an eBird hotspot provides a comprehensive understanding of the avifauna that occur there. Most commonly occurring taxa are those associated with urbanized areas and ponds. The list of 158 avian taxa and their abundance estimations, as exported from eBird, is provided as Appendix B. Special Status Fauna The faunal literature review identified 71 special status taxa to be considered for their potential occurrence. This was based on records from the following sources: • CNDDB: 196 occurrences of 54 faunal taxa in the CNDDB for the Regional Study Area. • IPaC: 26 faunal taxa recommended for consideration by IPaC based on an upload of the Project Site boundary. • Critical Habitat: Four faunal taxa with proposed or designated critical habitat in the Regional Study Area. Of the 71 special status faunal taxa analyzed for this report, two were determined to be Present, 0 were determined to have a High potential for occurrence, one was determined to have a Moderate potential for occurrence, 14 were determined to have a Low potential for occurrence, and 54 were determined to have no potential for occurrence. Single occurrences of unexpected special status birds in eBird records were not treated as "Present". These data are summarized in the Desktop Review Report provided in Appendix D. The accounts below summarize taxa determined to have moderate or higher occurrence potential. The maps show the centroids of the CNDDB records in order to spatially depict the occurrences relative to the Project Site (for taxa that are in the CNDDB). All data, including habitat descriptions, is directly from the CNDDB. 4 Page 20 �� • Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 , California Gull Larus californicus \ q ' ' M , } Legal Status: WL,S4,BCC r Source(s): IPaC ° »; Taxon Code: ABNNM03110 °= "4, "` t,I Natural History: LITTORAL WATERS,SANDY BEACHES,WATERS AND SHORELINES OF BAYS, 4-e 0 °, a * TIDAL MUD-FLATS,MARSHES,LAKES,ETC.COLONIAL NESTER ON ISLETS IN LARGE INTERIOR LAKES,EITHER FRESH OR STRONGLY ALKALINE. "^^ Range Notes: — 1:. Habitat Quality: Medium A -Y ' ` Notes: Occurs in the park during the winter months,even if inconsistently.Project effects would be limited to temporary habitat loss. •r Potential Occurrence:Present Potential For Project to Effect:Low Allen's Hummingbird S• elasphorus sasin #._ j` s Legal Status: BCC z M w„ IXu S• ource(s): IPaC - ; ° r; Taxon Code: ABNUC51030 j Natural History: No CNDDB habitat description available % Range Notes: — ` ', ', Habitat Quality: High "T: . Notes: Potential effects include temporary loss of foraging habitat and potential impacts to nests if work occurs during the nesting season. Potential Occurrence:Present Potential For Project to Effect:Low � ` �����' Silver-haired Bat t "° Lasionycteris noctivagans Legal Status: S3S4 "' z � « , Source(s): CNDDB(2) g l Taxon Code: AMACCO2010 VER _° 0 ` , ti Natural History: PRIMARILY A COASTAL AND MONTANE FOREST STREAMS,PONDS AND OPEN BRUSHY AREAS. E N HOLLLOW TING REES, BENEATH EXFOLIATING BARK,ABANDONED WOODPECKER HOLES,AND RARELY UNDER ROCKS.NEEDS DRINKING WATER. Range Notes: — • Q �~ ' Habitat Quality: Medium Notes: Value of area as foraging habitat may be increased by project. Potential Occurrence:Moderate Potential For Project to Effecti*e General Conclusions The Project Site provides or has potential to provide habitat to the following special status faunal resources: • Two fauna taxa determined to be Present: Allen's Hummingbird, and California Gull; • One fauna taxa determined to have a Moderate potential for occurrence: Silver-haired Bat; • Nesting birds protected by the Migratory Bird Treaty Act and California Fish and Game Code. Page 21 hl Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Other Considerations Nesting Birds Birds - including native species protected by the Migratory Bird Treaty Act and California Fish and Game Code- have the potential to nest in nearly any environment, including those heavily altered by anthropogenic activity. On the Project Site, trees and shrubs provide ample locations for potential nesting of many species that are regularly present at Carr Park. Publicly-available data do not provide any definitive information on nesting bird species in Carr Park, including birds associated with the lake. Wildlife Movement Wildlife movement corridors are important for maintaining population levels and genetic diversity. As such, effects on wildlife movement are an important consideration when discussing the natural resources of any area. At a small enough scale, any project or activity can potentially affect the movement of wildlife if any wildlife are present at all. In general, however, the term "wildlife movement corridor" means an area of habitat that is important for the movement of wildlife between larger habitat areas or cores. As a relatively small block of green space in a large urban area, Carr Park would not be expected to be important to wildlife movement or function as a part of a wildlife movement corridor. 172 Page 22 Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Effects and Minimization Measures CEQA describes three types of potential project effects that are pertinent to biological resources and are considered in this report: • Direct Effects: Section 15064(d)(1) of the CEQA Guidelines describes a direct effect as "a physical change in the environment which is caused by and immediately related to the project." In the context of the proposed project described in this report, direct effects include adverse effects that would occur to plants, wildlife, and vegetation communities within or immediately adjacent to the proposed Project footprint and other work areas. • Indirect Effects: Section 15064(d)(2) of the CEQA Guidelines describes an indirect effect as any "physical change in the environment, which is not immediately related to the project, but which is caused indirectly by the project. If a direct physical change in the environment, in turn, causes another change in the environment, then the other change is an indirect physical change in the environment." Indirect effects, also known as secondary effects, are reasonably foreseeable and caused by a project but occur at a different time or place. Examples of indirect effects pertinent to many development projects could include a change in drainage patterns that ultimately affect vegetation communities not otherwise affected by the project or a reduction in native wildlife species resulting from a decrease in habitat. • Cumulative Effects: Section 15355 of the CEQA Guidelines describe a cumulative effect as "two or more individual effects which, when considered together, are considerable or which compound or increase other environmental impacts." The CEQA Guidelines further state the following regarding cumulative effects: • The individual effects may be changes resulting from a single project or a number of separate projects. • The cumulative impact from several projects is the change in the environment which results from the incremental impact of the project when added to other closely related past, present, and reasonably foreseeable probable future projects. Cumulative impacts can result from individually minor but collectively significant projects taking place over a period of time. • Section 15064 (h)(1) of CEQA Guidelines states that "the lead agency shall consider whether the cumulative impact is significant and whether the effects of the project are cumulatively considerable." `Cumulatively considerable' means that the incremental effects of an individual project are significant when viewed in connection with the effects of past projects, the effects of other current projects and the effects of probable future projects". Section 15064 (h)(2) states that "a lead agency may determine...that a project's contribution to a significant cumulative impact will be rendered less than cumulatively considerable and thus is not significant." Spatial Extent of Effects Ultimately, implementation of the Project will affect most of the area of Carr Park. The expansion of the lake is the most significant portion of the Project in spatial extent and its biological effects, with the large numbers of birds that attracted to the existing lake. No aspect of Project implementation, however, would be expected to have significant adverse effects on sensitive communities or special status flora or fauna. 1 Page 23 nab, Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Effects on Candidate, Sensitive, or Special Status Species The CEQA Guidelines require an assessment of whether the Project will have a substantial adverse effect, either directly or through habitat modifications, on any species identified as a candidate, sensitive, or special status species in local or regional plans, policies, or regulations by the CDFW or USFWS. As discussed previously, of the 71 special status faunal taxa analyzed for this report, two were determined to be Present, 0 were determined to have a High potential for occurrence, one was determined to have a Moderate potential for occurrence, 14 were determined to have a Low potential for occurrence, and 54 were determined to have no potential for occurrence. No special status flora are expected to occur. The fauna that were determined to occur or potentially occur are reviewed below: • California Gull - California Gull is a US Fish and Wildlife Service Bird of Conservation Concern. A mobile species, it does not breed locally. Project effects would be restricted to temporary foraging and roosting habitat impacts. This is not a significant adverse effect and no minimization measures are required. Upon project completion, the value of Carr Park to this species as foraging and roosting habitat is likely to increase. • Allen's Hummingbird - Allen's Hummingbird is a US Fish and Wildlife Service Bird of Conservation Concern. This species likely breeds in the park and surrounding residential areas. Project effects include potential temporary adverse effects on foraging and nesting habitat, as well potential effects that could occur generally to active bird nests if work occurs during the nesting season. The latter of these is the only potentially significant effect of the Project. A measure to avoid impacts to nesting birds is provided below in the Effects on Wildlife Movement and Nursery Sites section. • Silver-haired Bat - Silver-haired Bat is an S3S4 species. While it is unknown if this species is present at Carr Park, if it is present Project implementation could cause temporary impacts to foraging habitat. This is not a significant adverse effect and no minimization measures are required. Upon project completion, the value of Carr Park to this species as foraging habitat is likely to increase. The proposed Project will not have significant direct, indirect, or cumulative effects on candidate, sensitive, or special status species. Effects on Riparian Habitat or Other Sensitive Natural Communities The CEQA Guidelines require an assessment of whether the Project will have a substantial adverse effect on any riparian habitat or other sensitive natural community identified in local or regional plans, policies, regulations, or by the CDFW or USFWS. The proposed Project will not have significant direct, indirect, or cumulative effects on riparian habitat or other sensitive natural communities. The jurisdictional delineation prepared by MNS Engineers has identified 1.02 acres of state and federal jurisdictional non-wetland waters on the Carr Park site. These waters are associated with Carr Park's lake. The are no wetland or riparian habitats or other non-jurisdictional water features at Carr Park. Page 24 �i Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Effects on State or Federally Protected Wetlands The CEQA Guidelines require an assessment of whether the Project will have a substantial adverse effect on state or federally protected wetlands (including, but not limited to, marsh, vernal pool, coastal, etc.) through direct removal, filling, hydrological interruption, or other means. The proposed Project will not have significant direct, indirect, or cumulative effects on state or federally protected wetlands. The jurisdictional delineation prepared by MNS Engineers has identified 1.02 acres of state and federal jurisdictional non-wetland waters on the Carr Park site. These waters are associated with Carr Park's lake. The are no wetland or riparian habitats or other non-jurisdictional water features at Carr Park. Effects on Wildlife Movement and Nursery Sites The CEQA Guidelines require an assessment of whether the Project will interfere substantially with the movement of any native resident or migratory fish or wildlife species or with established native resident or migratory fish or wildlife species or with established native resident or migratory wildlife corridors, or impede the use of native wildlife nursery sites. As discussed previously, the Project Site almost certainly has no value for wildlife movement at any level of consideration. As such, the proposed Project will not have significant direct, indirect, or cumulative effects on wildlife movement. To comply with the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, it is recommended that pre-construction surveys for nesting birds by a qualified biologist take place within 300 feet of all project work areas within one week of the commencement of project infrastructure construction if work occurs during the nesting bird season, which is generally accepted as February 1 to August 31. To avoid potential take under the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, construction activities should not take place in the vicinity of any active bird nests. The recommended construction buffer zone around active bird nests varies by species and would need to be determined on an individual basis based on the opinion of the surveying biologist as agreed upon by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife. With the implementation of this measure, the proposed Project will not have significant direct, indirect, or cumulative effects on nesting birds or other wildlife nursery sites. Effects on Local Policies or Ordinances Protecting Biological Resources The CEQA Guidelines require an assessment of whether the Project will conflict with any local policies or ordinances protecting biological resources, such as tree preservation policy or ordinance. There are no policies or ordinances within the City of Huntington Beach specific to biological resources. As such, the proposed Project will not conflict with local policies or ordinances protecting biological resources. Effects on the Provisions of an Adopted Habitat Conservation Plan The CEQA Guidelines require an assessment of whether the Project will conflict with the provisions of an adopted HCF NCCP, or other approved local, regional, or state habitat conservation plan. Page 25 �� Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 There are no adopted Habitat Conservation Plans, Natural Community Conservation Plans, or other approved local, regional, or state habitat conservation plans within which the Project Site is located. As such, the proposed Project will not conflict with an adopted habitat conservation plan. �i Page 26 1) Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Appendix A. Floral & Faunal Compendia Inserted after this cover page is a database-generated report summarizing floral and faunal observations. 1 Page 1 221 Floral and Faunal Compendia Carr Park This database-generated report summarizes the plant and wildlife taxa detected during the survey conducted on February 13, 2024 by EnglandlEcology. Documented during the survey was the presence of 10 plant taxa and 25 wildlife taxa, the latter including 0 amphibian, 0 reptile, 25 bird, and 0 mammal detections. Landscape plantings are not included unless of potential biological importance. The data presented here were collected in the field using the QField app on an iPhone 15 Pro. After fieldwork was completed, data were synced to QGIS desktop. All taxonomy and nomenclature follows NatureServe. The reference taxonomy from NatureServe was last updated in February 2024.This report was generated using QGIS 3.36. 772 225 Flora Group ,Common,Name. Scientific Name Abundance; Pheno1ogy' Notes Dicots j Peruvian Peppertree Schinus molle Common Active Growth — Dicots Jersey Cudweed Pseudognaphalium luteoalbum Uncommon Active Growth — Dicots Prickly Lettuce Lactuca serriola Common 1 Active Growth — Dicots Small Whorled Cheeseweed Malva parviflora Common Active Growth — Dicots 1 Chinese Elm Ulmus parvifolia Common Active Growth — Monocots j Kikuyu Grass Pennisetum clandestinum Common Active Growth — Other Other Other Common Senescent Celtis sp. Other Other Other Uncommon 1 Active Growth Fraxinus sp. Other Other Other Common Active Growth Eucalyptus sp. Other Other Other Common Active Growth Amaranthus sp. t P 1.41 4 226 _�1 Fauna Group Common Name Scientific.Nam Count Type °Notes Birds Double-crested Cormorant Nannopterum auritum 2 Observed — Birds Black-crowned Night-Heron Nycticorax nycticorax 12 Observed — Birds White-faced Ibis Plegadis chihi 10 Observed — Birds Canada Goose Branta canadensis 20 Observed — Birds American Wigeon Mareca americana 60 Observed — Birds Mallard Anas platyrhynchos 40 Observed — Birds Ruddy Duck Oxyura jamaicensis 4 Observed — Birds I Cooper's Hawk Accipiter cooperii 1 Observed — Birds i American Coot Fulica americana 20 Observed — Birds I Long-billed Curlew Numenius americanus 1 Observed — Birds 'Ring-billed Gull Larus delawarensis 10 Observed — Birds 1 Western Gull Larus occidentalis 1 Observed — Birds Rock Pigeon Columba livia 1 Observed — Birds Allen's Hummingbird Selasphorus sasin 1 Observed — Birds Black Phoebe 1 Sayornis nigricans 2 Observed — Birds 'Say's Phoebe Sayornis saya 1 Observed — Birds American Crow Corvus brachyrhynchos 6 Observed — Birds i Bushtit Psaltriparus minimus 10 Observed — Birds Ruby-crowned Kinglet Corthylio calendula 1 Heard Only — Birds 1 Western Bluebird Sialia mexicana 2 Observed — Birds Yellow-rumped Warbler 11 Setophaga coronata 8 Observed — Birds 1 Wilson's Warbler Cardellina pusilla 1 Observed — Birds i Red-winged Blackbird Agelaius phoeniceus 12 Observed — Birds I House Finch Haemorhous mexicanus j 10 Observed — Birds House Sparrow Passer domesticus 6 Observed — 227 _a Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Appendix B. Desktop Review of Special Status Biological Resources Inserted after this cover page is a database-generated report summarizing the results of EnglandlEcology's desktop review of special status biological resources. Page 1 ���. Desktop Review of Special Status Biological Resources Carr Park This database-generated report summarizes the potential for occurrence of sensitive vegetation communities and special status flora and fauna based on known occurrences within a Regional Study Area that includes the Anaheim, Long Beach, Los Alamitos, Newport Beach, and Seal Beach USGS 7.5-minute quadrangles. A map of the Regional Study Area is provided below. The desktop analysis resulted in 318 records from the California Department of Fish and Wildlife's California Natural Diversity Database (CNDDB), 37 records from the California Native Plant Society's Rare Plant Inventory, 4 records of critical habitat designated under the Federal Endangered Species Act, and 29 records from the US Fish &Wildlife Service's Information for Planning and Consultation (IPaC) database.This report was generated using QGIS 3.36. PRAD AM INGLEWOOD SOUTH GATE WHITTIER LA HABRA YORBA LINDA • • i BLACK STAR CANYON 110,To pir. TORRANCE LOSALAMITOS ANAHEIM ORANGE 11)1111 Pi 1 LONG BEACH -‘dilli 4111r*Ilikkik ' tal• •_ ,--''••-•-_--,' , , ,,,,_ I,t I I 1 AP 140141 110 I 11 I I 1 I L .-s''`,...,,,,...,_\.., -,,,k- %LilaSAN PEDRO SEAL BEACH TUSTIN EL TORO ,,,°,-‘` NEWPORT BEACH 5 4, � Zi 4. "r%•c'' AN JUAN CAPISTRANO LAGU BEACH a IOW DANA POII t 229 eAdk Vegetation Communities The section of the report summarizes the potential for occurrence on the - a' Project Site of 4 sensitive vegetation communities documented within the --ram ��v�' CNDDB as occurring in the Regional Study Area.The locations of CNDDB records are shown on the map at right (note: the CNDDB license SOUTH GATE WHITTIER LA HABRA YORBA `%% agreement expressly forbids showing records at scales where occurrences can be refound in the field based on the map). The columns in the table that follows this page are defined as follows: Eiji— Group I --� A logical grouping of vegetation community types applied by the CNDDB. ` • _s- Community The vegetation community or wildlife habitat mapped by the CNDDB. Currently, the CNDDB uses Holland (1986) for communities, which is considered an out-of-date classification system not otherwise used by CDFW. r LOSALAMITOS v ANAHEIM ORANGE State Rank A numbered sensitivity standard created by NatureServe and adopted by most state LONG BEACH agencies, including CDFW. Most important are S1 (Critically Imperiled), S2 (Imperiled), �. and S3(Vulnerable). e „t- CNDDB ijEJI; ,'''° -"' 6i F � The number of CNDDB records for that vegetation community or habitat in the Regional t •. \ t, 0 v%u Study Area. . Occurrence The expectation that community could occur on the Project Site. This is usually either "Present"or"None"if a survey has been completed,as communities are observable. . `SEAL BEA€ ' TUSTIN' Impact �_" The potential that implementation of the Project would impact that community. NEWP�}� 'T BEACH Notes Clarifying notes,if any are needed. e`- oft j LAGUNA CFii 230 �0A1+ Giio-ti- r eornmCinity e e State Rank °: CNDDB bccurrei be a Impact j Nooes , Dune Southern Foredunes S2.1 3 None None — Dune Southern Dune Scrub S1.1 2 None. None — Marsh Southern Coastal Salt Marsh S2.1 7 None'= ' None Riparian Southern Cottonwood Willow Riparian Forest S3.2 11 None None — 231 Flora The section of the report summarizes the potential for occurrence on the IV Project Site of 37 special status flora taxa documented by various I resource databases as occurring in the Regional Study Area.The locations of CNDDB records are shown on the map at right (note: the CNDDB4 SOUTH GATE ITTIER LA HABRA YORBA LINDA license agreement expressly forbids showing records at scales where occurrences can be refound in the field based on the map). The columns ', r in the table that follows this page are defined as follows: l� • -r '- N Taxon { The common and scientific names of the taxon.For special status plants,the taxonomy is consistent with that used by the California Native Plant Society(CNPS). CC.• Source(s) \ � , • • The database sources prompting the inclusion of the taxon. Options are: CNDDB °' T ,/ ca (numbers in parentheses are the number of CNDDB records in the Regional Study �o oh / 0 s ANAHEIM ORANGE Area), CNPS (CNPS Rare Plant Inventory), CH (Critical Habitat is designated for the 4 „L ���� r taxon in the Regional Study Area), and IPaC (the US Fish & Wildlife Service's \l�_ 0 Information for Planning and Consultation database). g LONG BEACH 0 pi L-1 :, ) Status 3-1 � ro The protected status of the taxon, which for plants includes its California Rare Plant .• 1 di1u; -- ik, ° H / r 0 Rank (CRPR) from CNPS, status - if any - under the federal and state Endangered ' , ` �4 �\ te o I Species Acts, and NatureServe state rank. The abbreviations used are defined in the " ti\\ e j' o Methods section of the report. ( - (17\‘ p About ' , ) / The habitat and blooming period of the taxon directly from the CNPS database. ck,\. TUSTfN SEALBE' iPs A o Range y �-. 9 Whether or not the Biological Study Area is within the expected range of the taxon. NEWP�,W H "Range" includes the distribution of modern records(e.g., iNaturalist and Calflora)and I o elevation.Options are Yes or No. `, 14,_ Habitat "'',_ b � The suitability of the habitat in the Biological Study Area to support the taxon. Options are None,Low, Medium,and High. If the Biological Study Area is not within the taxon's ?Y range,habitat is not considered and is listed as N/A. Occurrence �.,. .7 •• The potential for the taxon to occur in the Biological Study Area based on habitat and range.Options are None,Low,Moderate,High,and Present. • LAGUNA �� ;K /, Impact �" The potential for Project implementation to impact the taxon,considering its occurrence potential and the scope of the Project.Options are None,Low,Moderate,and High. Notes Clarifying notes,if needed. 232 _1 X Q C 5y a g' ��a. 0 " "a aC t "*% O e e„ i s San Diego Button-celery(Eryngium aristulatum CNDDB(1), CRPR 1 B.1, Coastal scrub,Valley and foothill var.parishii) CLAPS FE,CE,S1 grassland,Vernal pools(Mesic)from No N/A None None Range based on 164 Calflora records. 65-2035ft.Blooms Apr-Jun. Los Angeles Sunflower(Helianthus nuttallii ssp. CNDDB(2), CRPR 1A, Marshes and swamps(freshwater, parishii) CNPS SX coastal salt)from 35-5005ft.Blooms No N/A None None Considered extirpated. Aug-Oct. Marshes and swamps(margins),Valley Southern Tarplant(Centromadia parryi ssp. CNDDB(27), CRPR 1 B.1, and foothill grassland(vernally mesic), Yes None None None Range based on 166 Calflora records. australis) CNPS S2 Vernal pools from 0-1575ft.Blooms May-Nov. Decumbent decumGoldenbush(Isocoma menziesii CNDDB(2), CRPR 1 B.2, Chaparral,Coastal scrub(often var. ens) CNPS S2 disturbed areas,sandy)from 35-820ft. No N/A None None Range based on 112 Calflora records. Blooms Apr-Nov. Coulter's Goldfields(Lasthenia glabrata ssp. CNDDB(10), CRPR 1 B.1, Marshes and swamps(coastal salt), coulteri) CLAPS S2 Playas,Vernal pools from 5-4005ft. Yes None None None Range based on 217 Calflora records. Blooms Feb-Jun. Chaparral(openings),Coastal scrub, CNDDB(1), CRPR 1 B.1, Valley and foothill grassland(Clay, Lyon's Pentachaeta(Pentachaeta lyonii) CNPS FE,CE,Si Rocky)from 100-2265ft.Blooms No N/A None None Eliminated based on elevation. (Feb)Mar-Aug. Cismontane woodland,Coastal scrub, Lower montane coniferous forest, San Bernardino Aster(Symphyotrichum CNDDB(7), CRPR 1 B.2, Marshes and swamps,Meadows and Yes None None None Range based on 166 Calflora records. defoliatum) CNPS S2 seeps,Valley and foothill grassland (vernally mesic)(Streambanks)from 5-6695ft.Blooms Jul-Nov. CNDDB(2), CRPR 1B.1, Marshes and swamps(brackish, Gambel's Water Cress(Nasturtium gambelii) freshwater)from 15-1085ft.Blooms No N/A None None Range based on 51 Calflora records. CLAPS FE,CT,Si Apr-Oct. Coastal bluff scrub,Coastal dunes, CNDDB(2), CRPR 1 B.2, Coastal scrub(Gravelly(sometimes), Aphanisma(Aphanisma blitoides) CLAPS S2 Sandy(sometimes))from 5 1000ft. No N/A None None Range based on 75 Calflora records. Blooms Feb-Jun. Coastal bluff scrub,Coastal dunes, CNDDB(2), CRPR 1 B.2, Coastal scrub,Valley and foothill Coulter's Saltbush(Atriplex coulteri) CNPS S1 S2 grassland(Alkaline(sometimes),Clay No N/A None None Range based on 100 Calflora records. (sometimes))from 10-1510ft.Blooms Mar-Oct. CNDDB(1), CRPR 1 B.2, Coastal bluff scrub,Coastal dunes, Coastal scrub,Playas from 0-460ft. No N/A None None Range based on 183 Calflora records.South Coast Saltscale(Atriplex pacifica) CNPS S2 Blooms Mar-Oct. CNDDB(2), CRPR 1B.1, Chenopod scrub,Playas,Vernal pools Parish's Brittlescale(Atriplex parishii) CNPS S1 (Alkaline)from 80-6235ft.Blooms No N/A None None Eliminated based on elevation. -- — — Jun-Oct. — --- -- Davidson's Saltscale(Atriplex serenana var. CNDDB(3), CRPR 16.2, Coastal bluff scrub,Coastal scrub davidsonii) CNPS Si (Alkaline)from 35-655ft.Blooms No N/A None None Range based on 30 Calflora records. Apr-Oct. Estuary Seablite(Suaeda esteroa) CNDDB(15), CRPR 1 B.2, Marshes and swamps(coastal salt)from Yes None None None Range based on 199 Calflora records. CNPS S2 0-15ft.Blooms(Jan-May)Jul-Oct. CRPR 4.2, Coastal bluff scrub,Coastal dunes, Woolly Seablite(Suaeda taxifolia) CNPS S4 Marshes and swamps(coastal margins) Yes None None None Range based on 549 Calflora records. from 0-165ft.Blooms Jan-Dec. 233 I 7- �,..y., •.,-: �S• ebe w � at s u -g e Ha[�itat: enae 1 `••'-at,,,, ot6s �..�i � -,+� CiT � � �"�� �. Meadows and seeps(sometimes CNDDB(1), CRPR 1 B.1, alkaline),Riparian scrub(alluvial) Lucky Morning-glory(Calystegia felix) CNPS Si (Alkaline(sometimes),Loam No N/A None None Eliminated based on elevation. (sometimes))from 100-705ft.Blooms Mar-Sep. CNDDB(2), CRPR 1 B.2, Chaparral,Coastal scrub,Valley and Many-stemmed Dudleya(Dudleya multicaulis) CNPS S2 foothill grassland(Clay(often))from No N/A None None Range based on 73 Calflora records. 50-2590ft.Blooms Apr-Jul. CNDDB(1), CRPR 16.1, Meadows and seeps,Playas(Alkaline,�— — -- — Horn's Milk-vetch(Astragalus hornii var.hornii) CNPS Si Lake Margins)from 195-2790ft.Blooms No N/A None None Eliminated based on elevation. May-Oct. Coastal dunes,Coastal scrub,Marshes - Ventura Marsh Milk-vetch(Astragalus CNDDB(1), CRPR 1 B.1, and swamps(edges,coastal salt, No N/A None None Range based on 17 Calflora records. pycnostachyus var.lanosissimus) CNPS,IPaC FE,CE,S1 brackish)from 5-115ft.Blooms (Jun)Aug-Oct. CNDDB(2), CRPR 2B.2, Marshes and swamps(lake margins, Mud Nama(Nama stenocarpa) CNPS S1 S2 riverbanks)from 15-1640ft.Blooms Yes None None None Range based on 73 Calflora records. Jan-Jul. Chaparral,Coastal dunes,Coastal South Coast Branching Phacelia(Phacelia CRPR 3.2, scrub,Marshes and swamps(coastal CNPS No N/A None None Range based on 119 Calflora records. ramosissima var.austrolitoralis) S3 salt)(Rocky(sometimes),Sandy)from 15-985ft.Blooms Mar-Aug. Brand's Star Phacelia(Phacelia stellaris) CNDDB(1), CRPR 1 B.1, Coastal dunes,Coastal scrub from No N/A None None Range based on 53 Calflora records. CNPS S1 5-1310ft.Blooms Mar-Jun. Southern California Black Walnut(Juglans CRPR 4.2, CNPS Chaparral,Cismontane woodland, Coastal scrub,Riparian woodland from No N/A • None None Eliminated based on elevation. californica) S4 165-2955ft.Blooms Mar-Aug. P Chaparral,Coastal scrub,Lower Salt Spring Checkerbloom(Sidalcea CNDDB(3), CRPR 2B.2, montane coniferous forest,Mojavean Yes None None None Range based on 81 Calflora records. neomexicana) CNPS S2 desert scrub,Playas(Alkaline,Mesic) from 50-5020ft.Blooms Mar-Jun. Red Sand-verbena(Abronia maritima) CNPS CRPR 4.2, Coastal dunes from 0 330ft.Blooms Yes None None None Range based on 42 Calflora records. S3? Feb-Nov. Chaparral Sand-verbena(Abronia villosa var. CNDDB(3), CRPR 1 B.1, Chaparral,Coastal scrub,Desert dunes aurita) CNPS S2 (Sandy)from 245-5250ft.Blooms No N/A None None Eliminated based on elevation. (Jan)Mar-Sep. Cismontane woodland,Coastal bluff Lewis'Evening-primrose(Camissoniopsis scrub,Coastal dunes,Coastal scrub, lewisii) CNPS CRPR 3,S4 Valley and foothill grassland(Clay Yes None None None Range based on 212 Calflora records. (sometimes),Sandy(sometimes))from 0-985ft.Blooms Mar-May(Jun). Coast Woolly-heads(Nemacaulis denudata var. CNDDB(7), CRPR 1 B.2, Coastal dunes from 0-330ft.Blooms Yes None None None Range based on 153 Calflora records. denudata) CNPS S2 Apr-Sep. Coastal scrub,Meadows and seeps, Prostrate Vernal Pool Navarretia(Navarretia CNDDB(2), CRPR 1 B.2, Valley and foothill grassland(alkaline), No N/A None None Range based on 79 Calflora records. prostrata) CNPS S2 Vernal pools(Mesic)from 10-3970ft. Blooms Apr-Jul. CRPR 4.2, Coastal bluff scrub,Coastal scrub,Valley Seaside Cistanthe(Cistanthe maritima) CNPS S3 and foothill grassland(Sandy)from No N/A None None Range based on 72 Calflora records. 15-985ft.Blooms(Feb)Mar-Jun(Aug). 234 ®Ta,..Of St-z 4Yr * -.' " v s* $ ( " ", �O i r, ,' -Cf @ D lti f eflCeg �5a' " die et • t - x . •Salt Marsh Bird's-beak(Chloropyron CNDDB(6), CRPR 1B.2, Coastal dunes,Marshes and swamps maritimum ssp.maritimum) CNPS, FE,CE,Si (coastal salt)from 0-100ft.Blooms No N/A None None Range based on 27 Calflora records. May-Oct(Nov). CRPR 4.2, Coastal bluff scrub,Coastal scrub from Range based on 39 Calflora California Box-thorn(Lycium californicum) CNPS Yes None None None S4 15-490ft.Blooms Mar-Aug(Dec). records.Occurs in coastal scrub. CNDDB(1), CRPR 16.2, Marshes and swamps(shallow Sanford's Arrowhead(Sagittaria sanfordii) CNPS S3 freshwater)from 0-2135ft.Blooms No N/A None None Range based on 72 Calflora records. May-Oct(Nov). Small Spikerush(Eleocharis parvula) CNPS CRPR 4.3, Marshes and swamps from 5 9910ft. No N/A None None Range based on 147 Calflora records. S3 Blooms(Apr)Jun-Aug(Sep). Coastal dunes(mesic),Coastal scrub, Southwestern Spiny Rush(Juncus acutus ssp. CRPR 4.2, Marshes and swamps(coastal salt), CNPS Yes None None None Range based on 209 Calflora records. leopoldii) S4 Meadows and seeps(alkaline seeps) from 10-2955ft.Blooms(Mar)May-Jun. Coastal dunes,Coastal scrub,Valley and Vernal Barley(Hordeum intercedens) CNPS CRPR 3.2, foothill grassland(depressions,saline Yes None None None Range based on 434 Calflora records. S3S4 flats),Vernal pools from 15-3280ft. Blooms Mar-Jun. CNDDB(2), CRPR 1B.1, Vernal pools from 50-2165ft.Blooms California Orcutt Grass(Orcuttia californica) No N/A None None Range based on 124 Calflora records. CNPS FE,CE,S1 Apr-Aug. 235 Invertebrates The section of the report summarizes the potential for occurrence on the Project Site of 16 special status invertebrate taxa documented by various , resource databases as occurring in the Regional Study Area.The locations ® U. of CNDDB records are shown on the map at right (note: the CNDDB S$o Hill WHITTIER o � YOR;'° IA license agreement expressly forbids showing records at scales where occurrences can be refound in the field based on the map). The columns ° in the table that follows this page are defined as follows: (----) Taxon The common and scientific names of the taxon.Taxonomy is based upon NatureServe p v •® -"_,,, _ and is updated monthly. - / co Source(s) 0 0 ° 0 The database sources prompting the inclusion of the taxon. Options are: CNDDB o (numbers in parentheses are the number of CNDDB records in the Regional Study ANAHEIM ORANGE 0 lU Area), CH (Critical Habitat is designated for the taxon in the Regional Study Area), and `j15 IPaC (the US Fish & Wildlife Service's Information for Planning and Consultation database). ) Li' G BEACH a Status / .- � . � j� 0 • The protected status of the taxon,which for wildlife includes its status- if any- under '`' \t E,' -, _ • °' the federal and state Endangered Species Acts, Species of Special Concern status, �x v _ . g.her.--.. ,.„- - — ' !I ) Fully Protected status,and NatureServe state rank.The abbreviations used are defined pi i_",> y"-f ,a\ ,, �7 in the Methods section of the report. l_°. ji. ° About " , The habitat of the taxon directly from the Element Info table in the CNDDB. ° U ° Range a� TUSTIN Whether or not the Biological Study Area is within the expected range of the taxon. Options are Yes or No.Range includes the known modern distribution of the taxon and ©NEWPOfZT BEACH elevation limits of the taxon(if any)relative to the Biological Study Area. aA Habitat °A. :' °° II o L" The suitability of the habitat in the Biological Study Area to support the taxon.Options ' '' ,,7 o 5 are None,Low,Medium,and High.If the Biological Study Area is not within the taxon's �"___. . __ _ _ _.__ _ .. _ -.,/� r__rr, range,habitat is not considered and is listed as N/A. `� - Occurrence The potential for the taxon to occur in the Biological Study Area based on habitat and range.Options are None,Low,Moderate,High,and Present. Impact LAGUNA : ACV The potential for Project implementation to impact the taxon,considering its occurrence potential and the scope of the Project.Options are None,Low,Moderate,and High. Notes Clarifying notes,if needed. 236 'A p..,_ .. ,..., .. a. ,, ":.. ., a .-d..� , : ...: at{� �e . ,� y,}„ , .r.r ..>,, ��,.,- �, «-... k a +?.ea.. „s >:. c `..., v,r9 ..." ,`•a.. ;>, `.'„" . ,�,. :_...,: �...s....: .-_'9' ;_ y,'��,+. `zT w .Ta on .v4 4 ..e<. you ce s ,.,S at ., ,.,,, . f,-:fa e• .Ha•(t� ac rerace ;rr► aiet o � -. .:� � �. �� ��_,� - _- San Diego Fairy Shrimp(Branchinecta CNDDB(2), ENDEMIC TO SAN DIEGO AND ORANGE sandiegonensis) CH FE,Si COUNTY MESAS.VERNAL POOLS. Yes None None None Range based on 101 GBIF records. ENDEMIC TO WESTERN RIVERSIDE, ORANGE,AND SAN DIEGO COUNTIES IN AREAS OF TECTONIC SWALES/EARTH Riverside Fairy Shrimp(Streptocephalus CNDDB(1) FE,S2 SLUMP BASINS IN GRASSLAND AND No N/A None None Range based on 24 GBIF records. woottoni) COASTAL SAGE SCRUB.INHABIT SEASONALLY ASTATIC POOLS FILLED BY WINTER/SPRING RAINS.HATCH IN WARM WATER LATER IN THE SEASON. INHABITS ESTUARIES AND MUDFLATS ALONG THE COAST OF SOUTHERN Range based on 71 GBIF records.Only Western Tidal Flat Tiger Beetle(Eunota CNDDB(6) S1 CALIFORNIA.GENERALLY FOUND ON Yes None None None found in coastal estuaries and gabbii) DARK-COLORED MUD IN THE LOWER mudflats. ZONE;OCCASIONALLY FOUND ON DRY SALINE FLATS OF ESTUARIES. INHABITS AREAS ADJACENT TO NON-BRACKISH WATER ALONG THE COAST OF CALIFORNIA FROM SAN Pacific Hairy necked Tiger Beetle CNDDB(4) S2 ,FRANCISCO BAY TO NORTHERN MEXICO. No N/A None None Range based on 201 GBIF records. (Cicindela hirticollis gravida) CLEAN,DRY,LIGHT-COLORED SAND IN THE UPPER ZONE.SUBTERRANEAN LARVAE PREFER MOIST SAND NOT AFFECTED BY WAVE ACTION. MUDFLATS AND BEACHES OF COASTAL Range based on 491 GBIF Western Beach Tiger Beetle(Cicindela ESTUARIES FROM SAN DIEGO COUNTY records.Only found in coastal estuaries CNDDB(7) S1 TO LOS ANGELES COUNTY.TYPICALLY Yes None None None latesignata) INHABIT WET OR DRY SANDY BEACHES and rnudflats.Need to download AND MUD,SAND,OR SALT FLATS. records INHABITANT OF COASTAL SAND DUNE HABITAT;ERRATICALLY DISTRIBUTED FROM TEN MILE CREEK IN MENDOCINO Globose Dune Beetle(Coelus globosus) CNDDB(2) S1S2 COUNTY SOUTH TO ENSENADA,MEXICO. No N/A None None Range based on 300 GBIF records. INHABITS FOREDUNES AND SAND HUMMOCKS;IT BURROWS BENEATH THE SAND SURFACE AND IS MOST COMMON BENEATH DUNE VEGETATION. Dorothy's el Segundo Dune Weevil COASTAL SAND DUNES IN LOS ANGELES No spatial GBIF records.Range based CNDDB(2) S1 No N/A None None on CNDDB.Only occurrences near (Trigonoscuta dorothea dorothea) COUNTY. Ballona and Bolsa Chica. LONG-TONGUED;FORAGES ON A WIDE VARIETY OF FLOWERS INCLUDING VETCHES(VICIA),CLOVERS(TRIFOLIUM), No natural grassland habitats present American Bumble Bee(Bombus CNDDB(29) S2 THISTLES(CIRSIUM),SUNFLOWERS Yes None None None for wildflowers.Lawn areas of park are pensylvanicus) (HELIANTHUS),ETC.NESTS ABOVE GROUND UNDER LONG GRASS OR maintained and low cut. UNDERGROUND.QUEENS OVERWINTER IN ROTTEN WOOD OR UNDERGROUND. COASTAL CALIFORNIA EAST TO THE SIERRA-CASCADE CREST AND SOUTH INTO MEXICO.FOOD PLANT GENERA No natural grassland habitats present Crotch's Bumble Bee(Bombus crotchii) CNDDB(7) CCE,S2 INCLUDE ANTIRRHINUM,PHACELIA, Yes None None None for wildflowers.Lawn areas of park are CLARKIA,DENDROMECON, maintained and low cut. ESCHSCHOLZIA,AND ERIOGONUM. 37 - S'i=:.. i....- F -. S 1. .'., g' '�-•t.yfi.. :.,t ...4,, � �..:. }p,s3krr t g-,E 5t.' "�'.:�"b,.:..... .....,:. " «•-..;..'h ,+'.n„ `t- ':Y 'b.. 7.. y,_..f.., tea. .,,.3.., - F„ a „.,,w..,» i,: a• >»s ,v -, $ 7, >.-pro ,,, d ur�.:.c a', 'Taxo ,�.� � , ;, �. ..., b,rae s .�:�Y ,. ,:�., ; ° .�.,,,, .,, rRa�rts a=, H�ih�ta .ftba rr� a Im •of cs#`s � M-, ' ��°���� ��� a�_�aN,"�'�r'���` -. a -..-...��ta� . -,.. 'rwx .„.x tea,r ;.;�ia�.` ..� ,�--`• v x...: �:3.�'_ w. e _�'� _ _. °.<'�S` � p ;. � .� w, _".� _ . SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA COASTAL SALT Wandering Skipper(Panoquina errans) CNDDB(5) S2 MARSHES.REQUIRES MOIST SALTGRASS Yes None None None Found in coastal marshlands. FOR LARVAL DEVELOPMENT. RESTRICTED TO THE COOL, FOG-SHROUDED,SEAWARD SIDE OF Palos Verdes Blue(Glaucopsyche CNDDB(1) FE,Si PALOS VERDES HILLS,LOS ANGELES No N/A None None Range based on 48 GBIF records. lygdamus palosverdesensis) COUNTY.HOST PLANT IS ASTRAGALUS TRICHOPODUS VAR.LONCHUS (LOCOWEED). SUNNY OPENINGS WITHIN CHAPARRAL AND COASTAL SAGE SHRUBLANDS IN PARTS OF RIVERSIDE AND SAN DIEGO Quino Checkerspot(Euphydryas editha CNDDB(1) FE,S1S2 COUNTIES.HILLS AND MESAS NEAR THE No N/A None None Range based on 452 GBIF records. quino) COAST.NEED HIGH DENSITIES OF FOOD PLANTS PLANTAGO ERECTA,P. INSULARIS,AND ORTHOCARPUS PURPURESCENS. WINTER ROOST SITES EXTEND ALONG THE COAST FROM NORTHERN MENDOCINO TO BAJA CALIFORNIA, Monarch-California Overwintering CNDDB(9), FC,S2 MEXICO.ROOSTS LOCATED IN No None None None Range based on coastal zone limits. Population(Danaus plexippus pop.1) IPaC WIND-PROTECTED TREE GROVES (EUCALYPTUS,MONTEREY PINE, CYPRESS),WITH NECTAR AND WATER SOURCES NEARBY. PRIMARILY CREEKS AND RIVERS AND • LESS OFTEN LAKES.ORIGINALLY IN Originally found in most of state.Now Western Ridged Mussel(Gonidea angulata) CNDDB(1) S2 MOST OF STATE,NOW EXTIRPATED FROM No N/A None None extirpated from central and southern CENTRAL AND SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA. California. : I San Gabriel Chestnut(Glyptostoma CNDDB(1) S3 TERRESTRIAL. No N/A None None Range based on 285 GIF records. gabrielense) INHABITS COASTAL LAGOONS, ESTUARIES AND SALT MARSHES,FROM SONOMA COUNTY SOUTH TO SAN Mimic Tryonia(Tryonia imitator) CNDDB(2) S2 DIEGO COUNTY FOUND ONLY IN No N/A •None None Range based on 46 GBIF records. PERMANENTLY SUBMERGED AREAS IN A VARIETY OF SEDIMENT TYPES;ABLE TO WITHSTAND A WIDE RANGE OF SALINITIES. 238 Fish The section of the report summarizes the potential for occurrence on the Project Site of 1 special status fish taxa documented by various resource databases as occurring in the Regional Study Area. The locations of CNDDB records are shown on the map at right (note: the CNDDB license SOUTH GATE WHITTIER LA HABRA YORBA LINDA agreement expressly forbids showing records at scales where occurrences can be refound in the field based on the map). The columns in the table that follows this page are defined as follows: rrif Taxon The common and scientific names of the taxon.Taxonomy is based upon NatureServe Iry o - and is updated monthly. - Source(s) The bSein are the numberh lof'CNDDBh records inthe Regional Study LOSrALAMITOS` On' sources prompting Options (numbersparentheses9 Y ANAHEIM -ORANGE Area), CH (Critical Habitat is designated for the taxon in the Regional Study Area), and IPaC (the US Fish & Wildlife Service's Information for Planning and Consultation database). LONG BEACH Status P,,, , , The protected status of the taxon,which for wildlife includes its status- if any- under ,,., the federal and state Endangered Species Acts, Species of Special Concern status, „'-a`;a),' t '` ,, r Fully Protected status,and NatureServe state rank.The abbreviations used are defined N4-- —. , - t, � ti a in the Methods section of the report. ` -- - �{ " g About ,. The habitat of the taxon directly from the Element Info table in the CNDDB. v 3 , - Range SEAL BEACyFI TUSTIN ;� Whether or not the Biological Study Area is within the expected range of the taxon. Options are Yes or No. Range includes the known modern distribution of the taxon and ., NEWP0RT BEACH elevation limits of the taxon(if any)relative to the Biological Study Area. Habitat f The suitability of the habitat in the Biological Study Area to support the taxon. Options are None,Low, Medium,and High.If the Biological Study Area is not within the taxon's `�•., €f _ '' 4 tT l range,habitat is not considered and is listed as N/A. r\.. Y, �--< --,,,,,ti Wit$ Occurrence --'~- ' The potential for the taxon to occur in the Biological Study Area based on habitat and range.Options are None,Low,Moderate,High,and Present. Impact LAGUN ACH The potential for Project implementation to impact the taxon,considering its occurrence potential and the scope of the Project.Options are None,Low,Moderate,and High. Notes Clarifying notes,if needed. t7Y4 239 ♦� ; iKv' -M .;�' X.'��.t .kv .. v. Y u ',.r' nf•`�, :'S` war Sour a '5ta s o rEtn _-1 �bitatzOccuFl a ce lin r, ��.�".� „To. FEDERAL LISTING REFERS TO POPULATIONS FROM SANTA MARIA Steelhead-Southern California Distinct RIVER SOUTH TO SOUTHERN EXTENT OF Population Segment(Oncorhynchus CNDDB(1) FE,CCE, RANGE(SAN MATED CREEK IN SAN No N/A None None — S1 DIEGO COUNTY).SOUTHERN STEELHEAD mykiss pop.10) LIKELY HAVE GREATER PHYSIOLOGICAL TOLERANCES TO WARMER WATER AND MORE VARIABLE CONDITIONS. 240 Amphibians The section of the report summarizes the potential for occurrence on the - Project Site of 1 special status amphibian taxa documented by various resource databases as occurring in the Regional Study Area.The locations of CNDDB records are shown on the map at right (note: the CNDDB license agreement expressly forbids showing records at scales where SOUTH GATE WHITTIER LA HABRA YORBA LINDA occurrences can be refound in the field based on the map). The columns in the table that follows this page are defined as follows: to Taxon -- The common and scientific names of the taxon.Taxonomy is based upon NatureServe ,-r` and is updated monthly. ` r Source(s) J The database sources prompting the inclusion of the taxon. Options are: CNDDB (numbers in parentheses are the number of CNDDB records in the Regional Study ANAHEIM ORANGE Area), CH (Critical Habitat is designated for the taxon in the Regional Study Area),and L ;ALAMITOS IPaC (the US Fish & Wildlife Service's Information for Planning and Consultation ii database). LONG BEACH // Status The protected status of the taxon, which for wildlife includes its status- if any- under r '' „;�s, �" the federal and state Endangered Species Acts, Species of Special Concern status, ` '' '- Fully Protected status,and NatureServe state rank.The abbreviations used are defined \k__.,. L 7 . ,, 'ut ):.. in the Methods section of the report. ``,�„`` ' About °•"` The habitat of the taxon directly from the Element Info table in the CNDDB. Range SEAL BEACH ° TUSTIN Whether or not the Biological Study Area is within the expected range of the taxon. \ Options are Yes or No. Range includes the known modern distribution of the taxon and ''\ NEWPORT BEACH elevation limits of the taxon(if any)relative to the Biological Study Area. ,N. Habitat The suitability of the habitat in the Biological Study Area to support the taxon.Options . are None,Low, Medium,and High. If the Biological Study Area is not within the taxon's r " range,habitat is not considered and is listed as N/A. T Occurrence — '' The potential for the taxon to occur in the Biological Study Area based on habitat and range.Options are None,Low,Moderate,High,and Present. 0 • Impact LAGUNA i.):1/4,C.N,H,,,_ .? The potential for Project implementation to impact the taxon,considering its occurrence potential and the scope of the Project.Options are None,Low,Moderate,and High. Notes Clarifying notes,if needed. 241 )��1 Souirce s .. `#ifs , 9i�f- ' (ia ° ` ab)ta ,Jac reridd' �t s J � �f u� �tn�csf' .No� OCCURS PRIMARILY IN GRASSLAND HABITATS,BUT CAN BE FOUND IN ' 'F. VALLEY-FOOTHILL HARDWOOD Western Spadefoot(Spea hammondii) CNDDB(3) SSC,S3S4 Yes None None, None — WOODLANDS.VERNAL POOLS ARE ESSENTIAL FOR BREEDING AND EGG-LAYING. • 242 Reptiles The section of the report summarizes the potential for occurrence on the ' Project Site of 5 special status reptile taxa documented by various i a 4111 . resource databases as occurring in the Regional Study Area.The locations I of CNDDB records are shown on the map at right (note: the CNDDB SOUTH GATE WHITTIER LA HABRA YOR�A LINDA license agreement expressly forbids showing records at scales where d occurrences can be refound in the field based on the map). The columns in the table that follows this page are defined as follows: Taxon 0 The common and scientific names of the taxon.Taxonomy is based upon NatureServe and is updated monthly. r: . Source(s) i (n r.). The database sources prompting the inclusion of the taxon. Options are: CNDDB (numbers in parentheses are the number of CNDDB records in the Regional Study L•S •LAM ITOS ° ANAHEIM ORANGE • Area), CH (Critical Habitat is designated for the taxon in the Regional Study Area), and IPaC (the US Fish & Wildlife Service's Information for Planning and Consultation t database). LONG BEACH i Status " ,,'' • , Theprotected status of the taxon,which for wildlife includes its status- if anyunder / �- ▪r . .„ - �,� a � i"*.:')I the federal and state Endangered Species Acts, Species of Special Concern status, tes, ,) fl --...&:):, ,,,,,,,' <:. Fully Protected status,and NatureServe state rank.The abbreviations used are defined It, ,„= t• -- o j •) in the Methods section of the report. (fir--`4p- G. About 44 . .. The habitat of the taxon directly from the Element Info table in the CNDDB. • Range TUSTIN SEAL BEACH, Whether or not the Biological Study Area is within the expected range of the taxon. Options are Yes or No. Range includes the known modern distribution of the taxon and NEWPORT BEACH elevation limits of the taxon(if any)relative to the Biological Study Area. ®Q Habitat •, The suitability of the habitat in the Biological Study Area to support the taxon. Options are None,Low, Medium,and High.If the Biological Study Area is not within the taxon's range,habitat is not considered and is listed as N/A. — -,Vpv Occurrence ® o 0 The potential for the taxon to occur in the Biological Study Area based on habitat and r��e range.Options are None,Low,Moderate,High,and Present. (;e Impact LAGUNA' AE CH The potential for Project implementation to impact the taxon,considering its occurrence � potential and the scope of the Project.Options are None,Low,Moderate,and High. Notes Clarifying notes,if needed. N1 I 243 � e s fi gem sHa a o ranee rn ac ss p.ea CNDDB(1), MARINE.COMPLETELY HERBIVOROUS; Green Sea Turtle(Chelonia mydas) CH S1 NEEDS ADQUATE SUPPLY OF No None None None — SEAGRASSES AND ALGAE. • While the lake could serve as habitat, Southwestern Pond Turtle(Actinemys CNDDB(3), No CNDDB habitat description available Yes High None None this species gets displaced by pallida) IPaC Red-eared Sliders,which are abundant in the park's lake. GENERALLY SOUTH OF THE TRANSVERSE RANGE,EXTENDING TO NORTHWESTERN BAJA CALIFORNIA. OCCURS IN SANDY OR LOOSE LOAMY San Diegan Legless Lizard(Anniella SOILS UNDER SPARSE VEGETATION. No predicted habitat mapped in area stebbinsi) CNDDB(7) SSC,S3 DISJUNCT POPULATIONS IN THE Yes None None None by CWHR. TEHACHAPI AND PIUTE MOUNTAINS IN KERN COUNTY.VARIETY OF HABITATS; GENERALLY IN MOIST,LOOSE SOIL.THEY PREFER SOILS WITH A HIGH MOISTURE CONTENT. FREQUENTS A WIDE VARIETY OF HABITATS,MOST COMMON IN LOWLANDS ALONG SANDY WASHES Blainville's Horned Lizard(Phrynosoma CNDDB(6) SSC,S4 WITH SCATTERED LOW BUSHES.OPEN Yes None None None No predicted habitat mapped in area blainvillii) AREAS FOR SUNNING,BUSHES FOR by CWHR. COVER,PATCHES OF LOOSE SOIL FOR BURIAL,AND ABUNDANT SUPPLY OF ANTS AND OTHER INSECTS. INHABITS LOW-ELEVATION COASTAL SCRUB,CHAPARRAL,AND VALLEY-FOOTHILL HARDWOOD Orange throated Whiptail(Aspidoscelis CNDDB(1) WL,S2S3 HABITATS.PREFERS WASHES AND No None None None — hyperythrus) OTHER SANDY AREAS WITH PATCHES OF BRUSH AND ROCKS.PERENNIAL PLANTS NECESSARY FOR ITS MAJOR FOOD: TERMITES. 244 Birds The section of the report summarizes the potential for occurrence on the 17- Ii ( • o © , Project Site of 39 special status bird taxa documented by various resource !databases as occurring in the Regional Study Area. The locations of ,� / CNDDB records are shown on the map at right (note: the CNDDB licenseSOUTH GATE �uG1)InifC LAHABRAagreement expressly forbids showing records at scales where ` ;,�occurrences can be refound in the field based on the map). The columns1 rin the table that follows this page are defined as follows: Taxon /'� )Ylif‘97:1(.5C:Agr7N'';'61°.®.'": I.The common and scientific names of the taxon.Taxonomy is based upon NatureServe � �� �Land is updated monthly.Source(s)The database sources prompting the inclusion of the taxon. Options are: CNDDB i . c(numbers in parentheses are the number of CNDDB records in the Regional Study rd,.ALAMITOS AN Area), CH (Critical Habitat is designated for the taxon in the Regional Study Area), and 41 ; . IPaC (the US Fish & Wildlife Service's Information for Planning and Consultation database). II i L G BEACH Status ;;r- i ✓ The protected status of the taxon, which for wildlife includes its status- if any- under0;.-,?-7:-, ,�1 3� u 7:b � \I. � ��i- ` the federal and state Endangered Species Acts, Species of Special Concern status, k -c';- , -',- ,°`:#O , ..- ,, --- !t 12 Fully Protected status,and NatureServe state rank.The abbreviations used are defined fall q-,` fl ��_ �_ �� in the Methods section of the report. c �`=�fli.. / About . The habitat of the taxon directly from the Element Info table in the CNDDB. Range SEAL BEAC ;? TUSTIN Whether or not the Biological Study Area is within the expected range of the taxon. Options are Yes or No.Range includes the known modern distribution of the taxon and ''�. i� NEWPOT BEACH [ ,• o elevation limits of the taxon(if any)relative to the Biological Study Area. I (lme �,°• Habitat ' �,.� i � �'' © � The suitability of the habitat in the Biological Study Area to support the taxon. Options \�y ©ti� o are None,Low, Medium,and High. If the Biological Study Area is not within the taxon's �J - ���U� t range,habitat is not considered and is listed as N/A. (� c, • � � y` 4 Occurrence d , " o Q The potential for the taxon to occur in the Biological Study Area based on habitat and range.Options are None,Low,Moderate,High,and Present. a ••s• Impact LAGUNA'e� " The potential for Project implementation to impact the taxon,considering its occurrence 9 potential and the scope of the Project.Options are None,Low,Moderate,and High. Notes Clarifying notes,if needed. �� 245 ,AAVA b 4.:," y U _O@ S i 0' Re r , w` . 8 41 t8 C}C"L� C1C0 t�' D#zS ,:r�, xrr 1 ra Western Grebe(Aechmophorus IPaC BCC No CNDDB habitat description available Yes Low Low None Has not been recorded in park per occidentalis) eBird. Clark's Grebe(Aechmophorus clarkii) IPaC BCC No CNDDB habitat description available Yes Low Low None Has not been recorded in park per eBird. COLONIAL NESTER ON COASTAL ISLANDS JUST OUTSIDE THE SURF LINE. California Brown Pelican(Pelecanus j NESTS ON COASTAL ISLANDS OF SMALL Has been recorded once,likely as a CNDDB(1) FD,CD,S3 TO MODERATE SIZE WHICH AFFORD No N/A None None occidentalis californicus) IMMUNITY FROM ATTACK BY flyover,per eBird. GROUND-DWELLING PREDATORS. ROOSTS COMMUNALLY. OCEAN SHORE,BAYS,FRESHWATER LAKES,AND LARGER STREAMS.LARGE Has been recorded in the park a few Osprey(Pandion haliaetus) CNDDB(1) WL,S4 NESTS BUILT IN TREE-TOPS WITHIN 15 Yes Low Low None times per eBird,but does not occur MILES OF A GOOD FISH-PRODUCING regularly. BODY OF WATER. ROLLING FOOTHILLS AND VALLEY MARGINS WITH SCATTERED OAKS AND RIVER BOTTOMLANDS OR MARSHES NEXT TO DECIDUOUS WOODLAND.OPEN Has not been recorded in the park per White-tailed Kite(Elanus leucurus) CNDDB(1) FP,S3S4 Yes None None None GRASSLANDS,MEADOWS,OR MARSHES eBird. FOR FORAGING CLOSE TO ISOLATED, DENSE-TOPPED TREES FOR NESTING AND PERCHING. OCEAN SHORE,LAKE MARGINS,AND RIVERS FOR BOTH NESTING AND WINTERING.MOST NESTS WITHIN 1 MILE FD,CE,FP, OF WATER.NESTS IN LARGE, Has been recorded,apparently as a Bald Eagle(Haliaeetus leucocephalus) S3 OLD-GROWTH,OR DOMINANT LIVE TREE Yes None Low None flyover,on one occasion per eBird. WITH OPEN BRANCHES,ESPECIALLY PONDEROSA PINE.ROOSTS COMMUNALLY IN WINTER. BREEDS IN GRASSLANDS WITH SCATTERED TREES,JUNIPER-SAGE FLATS,RIPARIAN AREAS,SAVANNAHS, AND AGRICULTURAL OR RANCH LANDS Swainson's Hawk(Buteo swainsoni) CNDDB(2) S4 WITH GROVES OR LINES OF TREES. No N/A None None — REQUIRES ADJACENT SUITABLE FORAGING AREAS SUCH AS GRASSLANDS,OR ALFALFA OR GRAIN FIELDS SUPPORTING RODENT POPULATIONS. OPEN GRASSLANDS,SAGEBRUSH FLATS,DESERT SCRUB,LOW FOOTHILLS Has been recorded in the park once AND FRINGES OF PINYON AND JUNIPER per eBird.Not expected to occur Ferruginous Hawk(Buteo regalis) CNDDB(1) WL,S3S4 HABITATS.EATS MOSTLY LAGOMORPHS, Yes Low Low None regularly because of lack of GROUND SQUIRRELS,AND MICE. appropriate habitat. POPULATION TRENDS MAY FOLLOW LAGOMORPH POPULATION CYCLES. NEAR WETLANDS,LAKES,RIVERS,OR OTHER WATER;ON CLIFFS,BANKS, Recorded at Carr Park,primarily during American Peregrine Falcon(Falco CNDDB(1) FD,CD, DUNES,MOUNDS;ALSO,HUMAN-MADE Yes Low None None the winter months.Likely uses the park peregrinus anatum) S3S4 STRUCTURES.NEST CONSISTS OF A on occasion for hunting. SCRAPE OR A DEPRESSION OR LEDGE IN 246 AN OPEN SITE. .T,a G S S O a e t 8 72 a SUMMER RESIDENT IN EASTERN SIERRA Yellow Rail(Coturnicops noveboracensis) CNDDB(1) SSC,S2 NEVADA IN MONO COUNTY. No N/A None None — FRESHWATER MARSHLANDS. INHABITS FRESHWATER MARSHES,WET MEADOWS AND SHALLOW MARGINS OF SALTWATER MARSHES BORDERING California Black Rail(Laterallus jamaicensis CNDDB(2) FP,S2 LARGER BAYS.NEEDS WATER DEPTHS Yes None None None — coturniculus) OF ABOUT 1 INCH THAT DO NOT FLUCTUATE DURING THE YEAR AND DENSE VEGETATION FOR NESTING HABITAT. FOUND IN SALT MARSHES TRAVERSED BY TIDAL SLOUGHS,WHERE CORDGRASS AND PICKLEWEED ARE THE Light-footed Ridgway's Rail(Rallus CNDDB(4), FE,CE,FP, DOMINANT VEGETATION.REQUIRES Yes None None None — obsoletus levipes) IPaC S1 DENSE GROWTH OF EITHER PICKLEWEED OR CORDGRASS FOR NESTING OR ESCAPE COVER;FEEDS ON MOLLUSCS AND CRUSTACEANS. SANDY BEACHES,SALT POND LEVEES Snowy Plover(Charadrius nivosus nivosus) CNDDB(8), SSC,S3 AND SHORES OF LARGE ALKALI LAKES. Yes Low Low None Has never been recorded in the park CH,IPaC NEEDS SANDY,GRAVELLY OR FRIABLE per eBird. I SOILS FOR NESTING. I SHORT GRASSLANDS,FRESHLY PLOWED FIELDS,NEWLY SPROUTING GRAIN SSC,S2, FIELDS,AND SOMETIMES SOD FARMS. Mountain Plover(Charadrius montanus) IPaC BCC SHORT VEGETATION,BARE GROUND, No N/A None None — AND FLAT TOPOGRAPHY.PREFERS GRAZED AREAS AND AREAS WITH BURROWING RODENTS. Black Oystercatcher(Haematopus bachmani) IPaC BCC No CNDDB habitat description available No N/A None None — Willet(Tringa semipalmata) IPaC BCC No CNDDB habitat description available Yes Low Low None Has not been recorded in the park per eBird. Marbled Godwit(Limosa fedoa) IPaC BCC No CNDDB habitat description available Yes Low Low None Has been recorded in the park a handful of times in February per eBird. Black Turnstone(Arenaria melanocephala) IPaC BCC No CNDDB habitat description available No N/A None None — Short-billed Dowitcher(Limnodromus IPaC BCC No CNDDB habitat description available No N/A None None — griseus) LITTORAL WATERS,SANDY BEACHES, WATERS AND SHORELINES OF BAYS, Occurs in the park during the winter WL,S4, TIDAL MUD-FLATS,MARSHES,LAKES, months,even if inconsistently.Project California Gull(Carus californicus) IPaC BCC ETC.COLONIAL NESTER ON ISLETS IN Yes Medium Present Low effects would be limited to temporary LARGE INTERIOR LAKES,EITHER FRESH habitat loss. OR STRONGLY ALKALINE. ONLY KNOWN BREEDING COLONIES AT SAN DIEGO BAY AND THE SALTON SEA. Gull billed Tern(Gelochelidon nilotica) IPaC SSC,Si, NESTS ON LOW,SANDY ISLETS.KNOWN No N/A None None — BCC TO FEED ON FISHES AT MOUTH OF COLORADO RIVER AND ON GRASSHOPPERS IN ALFALFA FIELDS. 247 ,.r .......,_ .t:.. .: ... .. .. „..p ." c •:. ,;. .:�x� _➢xt.":^ y„ ..,1. ::9' .#' "e^i.. .i:us +tr n�j.,, >... �» s .,� J.w.;'q :3;' :.:,i .'Er:.: sr�C y_;e� �� '.-� " 11YC8$.�+:� .,. t.; NESTS ALONG THE COAST FROM SAN FRANCISCO BAY SOUTH TO NORTHERN California Least Tern(Sternula antillarum CNDDB(12), FE,CE,FP, BAJA CALIFORNIA.COLONIAL BREEDER Has been recorded once per eBird. browni)aliforCNDIPaC S2 ON BARE OR SPARSELY VEGETATED, Yes Low Low None Does not regularly occur and would not FLAT SUBSTRATES:SAND BEACHES, be expected to. ALKALI FLATS,LAND FILLS,OR PAVED AREAS. NESTS ON GRAVEL BARS,LOW ISLETS, Black Skimmer(Rynchops niger) CNDDB(1), SSC,S2, AND SANDY BEACHES,IN UNVEGETATED No N/A None None — IPaC BCC SITES.NESTING COLONIES USUALLY LESS THAN 200 PAIRS. RIPARIAN FOREST NESTER,ALONG THE BROAD,LOWER FLOOD-BOTTOMS OF Western Yellow-billed Cuckoo(Coccyzus LARGER RIVER SYSTEMS.NESTS IN Western us occidentalis) alis) CNDDB(6) CE,Si RIPARIAN JUNGLES OF WILLOW,OFTEN No N/A None None — ameriMIXED WITH COTTONWOODS,WITH LOWER STORY OF BLACKBERRY, NETTLES,OR WILD GRAPE. OPEN,DRY ANNUAL OR PERENNIAL GRASSLANDS,DESERTS,AND SCRUBLANDS CHARACTERIZED BY Burrowing Owl(Athene cunicularia) CNDDB(5) SSC,S2 LOW GROWING VEGETATION. Yes None None None — SUBTERRANEAN NESTER,DEPENDENT UPON BURROWING MAMMALS,MOST NOTABLY,THE CALIFORNIA GROUND SQUIRREL. COASTAL BELT OF SANTA CRUZ AND MONTEREY COUNTIES;CENTRAL AND SOUTHERN SIERRA NEVADA;SAN SSC,S3, BERNARDINO AND SAN JACINTO Black Swift(Cypseloides niger) IPaC BCC MOUNTAINS.BREEDS IN SMALL No N/A None None — COLONIES ON CLIFFS BEHIND OR ADJACENT TO WATERFALLS IN DEEP CANYONS AND SEA-BLUFFS ABOVE THE SURF;FORAGES WIDELY. Potential effects include temporary loss Allen's Hummingbird(Selasphorus sasin) IPaC BCC No CNDDB habitat description available Yes High Present Low of foraging habitat and potential impacts to nests if work occurs during the nesting season. NESTING HABITATS ARE MIXED CONIFER, MONTANE HARDWOOD-CONIFER, DOUGLAS-FIR,REDWOOD,RED FIR AND Has some potential to occur as a SSC,S3, I LODGEPOLE PINE.MOST NUMEROUS IN Olive-sided Flycatcher(Contopus cooperi) IPaC No N/A None None migrant,however,has not been BCC I MONTANE CONIFER FORESTS WHERE recorded in the park per eBird. TALL TREES OVERLOOK CANYONS, MEADOWS,LAKES OR OTHER OPEN TERRAIN. COLONIAL NESTER;NESTS PRIMARILY IN RIPARIAN AND OTHER LOWLAND HABITATS WEST OF THE DESERT. Bank Swallow(Riparia riparia) CNDDB(3) S3 REQUIRES VERTICAL BANKS/CLIFFS No N/A None None — WITH FINE-TEXTURED/SANDY SOILS NEAR STREAMS,RIVERS,LAKES,OCEAN TO DIG NESTING HOLE. i { z'. d R?`'._. d,W' } a,s „e ,t,.a•:, m4 _ �e* r.�: e ;.; .„ s , v �✓ +v"~3`=,. . 1'0. S $0t �k �`b'�a`{w '_u * sea ,:�c„�; ;, ,' v _:.�� @`,:__`�a�I�'d'* � +811C� ��^' Pa? Otf3S San Cactus Wren(Campylorhynchus SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA COASTAL SAGE Diego uniego illus sandiegensis) CNDDB(1) SSC,S2 SCRUB.WRENS REQUIRE TALL OPUNTIA No N/A None None — br CACTUS FOR NESTING AND ROOSTING. OBLIGATE,PERMANENT RESIDENT OF COASTAL SAGE SCRUB BELOW 2500 FT Coastal California Gnatcatcher(Polioptila CNDDB(12), IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA.LOW, californica californica) CH,IPaC SSC,S2 COASTAL SAGE SCRUB IN ARID WASHES, No N/A None None — ON MESAS AND SLOPES.NOT ALL AREAS CLASSIFIED AS COASTAL SAGE SCRUB ARE OCCUPIED. California Thrasher(Toxostoma redivivum) IPaC BCC No CNDDB habitat description available Yes None None None — SUMMER RESIDENT OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA IN LOW RIPARIAN IN VICINITY OF WATER OR IN DRY RIVER BOTTOMS;BELOW 2000 FT.NESTS Has some potential to be recorded in Least Bell's Vireo(Vireo bellii pusillus) CNDDB(3) FE,CE,S3 PLACED ALONG MARGINS OF BUSHES No N/A None None the park as a migrant,but has not been OR ON TWIGS PROJECTING INTO recorded in the park per eBird. PATHWAYS,USUALLY WILLOW, BACCHARIS,MESQUITE. I RIPARIAN PLANT ASSOCIATIONS IN CLOSE PROXIMITY TO WATER.ALSO NESTS IN MONTANE SHRUBBERY IN OPEN CONIFER FORESTS IN CASCADES AND SIERRA NEVADA.FREQUENTLY Has occurred a handful of times in the Yellow Warbler(Setophaga petechia) CNDDB(1) SSC,S3 FOUND NESTING AND FORAGING IN Yes Low Low None park per eBird.,but not during the WILLOW SHRUBS AND THICKETS,AND IN breeding season. OTHER RIPARIAN PLANTS INCLUDING COTTONWOODS,SYCAMORES,ASH, AND ALDERS. RESIDENT OF THE SAN FRANCISCO BAY REGION,IN FRESH AND SALT WATER Saltmarsh Common Yellowthroat SSC,S3, MARSHES.REQUIRES THICK, IPaC CONTINUOUS COVER DOWN TO WATER No N/A None None — (Geothlypis trichas sinuosa) BCC SURFACE FOR FORAGING;TALL GRASSES,TULE PATCHES,WILLOWS FOR NESTING. SUMMER RESIDENT;INHABITS RIPARIAN THICKETS OF WILLOW AND OTHER BRUSHY TANGLES NEAR Has not been recorded in the park per Yellow-breasted Chat(Icteria virens) CNDDB(1) SSC,S4 WATERCOURSES.NESTS IN LOW,DENSE Yes Low Low None eBird. RIPARIAN,CONSISTING OF WILLOW, BLACKBERRY,WILD GRAPE;FORAGES I AND NESTS WITHIN 10 FT OF GROUND. INHABITS COASTAL SALT MARSHES, FROM SANTA BARBARA SOUTH Belding's Savannah Sparrow(Passerculus CNDDB(8), CE,S3, THROUGH SAN DIEGO COUNTY.NESTS No N/A None None Belding's only occurs in coastal sandwichensis beldingi) IPaC BCC IN SALICORNIA ON AND ABOUT marshes. MARGINS OF TIDAL FLATS. HIGHLY COLONIAL SPECIES,MOST NUMEROUS IN CENTRAL VALLEY AND VICINITY.LARGELY ENDEMIC TO Tricolored Blackbird(Agelaius tricolor) Has been recorded once in the park CNDDB(3), SSC,S2, CALIFORNIA.REQUIRES OPEN WATER, Yes Low Low None IPaC BCC PROTECTED NESTING SUBSTRATE,AND with Red-winged Blackbirds. FORAGING AREA WITH INSECT PREY 249 WITHIN A FEW KM OF THE COLONY. `T—- Source(s) ta'thas About.• : ' 'i Range i abita± :Oocorrence U pact ,,Notes "" Has some potential to occur as a Bullock's Oriole(Icterus bullockii) IPaC BCC No CNDDB habitat description available Yes N/A .None x None migrant,however,has not been .& recorded in the park per eBird. J 250 Mammals The section of the report summarizes the potential for occurrence on the Project Site of 9 special status mammal taxa documented by various resource databases as occurring in the Regional Study Area.The locations of CNDDB records are shown on the map at right (note: the CNDDB SOUTH GATE WHITTIER LA HABRA n YORBA LINDA license agreement expressly forbids showing records at scales where .ml 1 occurrences can be refound in the field based on the map). The columns in the table that follows this page are defined as follows: I Taxon _ ; The common and scientific names of the taxon.Taxonomy is based upon NatureServe o e, and is updated monthly. rlr '� Source(s) " The database sources prompting the inclusion of the taxon. Options are: CNDDB (numbers in parentheses are the number of CNDDB records in the Regional Study LOSA`LAMITOS ANAHEIM • ORANGE Area), CH (Critical Habitat is designated for the taxon in the Regional Study Area), and IPaC (the US Fish & Wildlife Service's Information for Planning and Consultation l database). i LONG BEACH (--) Status The protected status of the taxon,which for wildlife includes its status- if any- under � �13���,, _ '' " the federal and state Endangered Species Acts, Species of Special Concern status, Fully Protected status,and NatureServe state rank.The abbreviations used are defined } ,,:V v' t _b rc. k in the Methods section of the report. About The habitat of the taxon directly from the Element Info table in the CNDDB. �' - : 1 Range SEAL BEACH TUSTIN Whether or not the Biological Study Area is within the expected range of the taxon. Options are Yes or No. Range includes the known modern distribution of the taxon and `, NEWPORT BEACH elevation limits of the taxon(if any)relative to the Biological Study Area. go Habitat The suitability of the habitat in the Biological Study Area to support the taxon. Options ' are None,Low, Medium,and High. If the Biological Study Area is not within the taxon's _ =. p range,habitat is not considered and is listed as N/A. -� ,,,,,,,„.„. ..,...,__, ,. ( }) Occurrence -. •V The potential for the taxon to occur in the Biological Study Area based on habitat and range.Options are None,Low,Moderate,High,and Present. Impact LAGUNA A `w. The potential for Project implementation to impact the taxon,considering its occurrence potential and the scope of the Project.Options are None,Low,Moderate,and High. Notes Clarifying notes,if needed. 251 �1 Ta.. .k •���r�.,r:r,�r,.. �y.- ce 6 mw_'221 Ab.oUvt�a. Habitat C �4wiren°e,;., pact:, otes Within mapped CWHR limits for species-level taxon.However,for S.o. salicornicus,confined to the coastal COASTAL MARSHES IN LOS ANGELES, marshes in Los Angeles,Orange,and Salt Marsh Ornate Shrew(Sorex ornatus ORANGE AND VENTURA COUNTIES. Ventura counties.Known occurrence salicornicus) CNDDB(2) SSC,Si REQUIRES DENSE VEGETATION AND No N/A None None extends from Point Mugo,Ventura WOODY DEBRIS FOR COVER. County on the north to the salt marshes around Anaheim Bay and Newport Beach in Orange County,on the south per https://sdmmp.com/upload/SDMMP_Re PRIMARILY A COASTAL AND MONTANE FOREST DWELLER,FEEDING OVER STREAMS,PONDS AND OPEN BRUSHY Area mapped as medium value Silver-haired Bat(Lasionycteris AREAS.ROOSTS IN HOLLOW TREES, predicted habitat by CWHR.No noc CNDDB(2) S3S4 BENEATH EXFOLIATING BARK, Yes Medium Moderate None apparent roosting habitat.Value of area ABANDONED WOODPECKER HOLES,AND as foraging habitat may be increased RARELY UNDER ROCKS.NEEDS by project. DRINKING WATER. PREFERS OPEN HABITATS OR HABITAT MOSAICS,WITH ACCESS TO TREES FOR Area mapped as low value predicted COVER AND OPEN AREAS OR HABITAT habitat by CWHR.No apparent Northern Hoary Bat(Lasiurus cinereus) CNDDB(1) S4 EDGES FOR FEEDING.ROOSTS IN DENSE Yes Low Low None roosting habitat.Value of area as FOLIAGE OF MEDIUM TO LARGE TREES. foraging habitat may be increased by FEEDS PRIMARILY ON MOTHS.REQUIRES project. WATER. FOUND IN VALLEY FOOTHILL RIPARIAN, DESERT RIPARIAN,DESERT WASH,AND Not mapped as predicted habitat by Western Yellow Bat(Lasiurus xanthinus) CNDDB(1) SSC,S3 PALM OASIS HABITATS.ROOSTS IN Yes None None None CWHR. TREES,PARTICULARLY PALMS.FORAGES OVER WATER AND AMONG TREES. MANY OPEN,SEMI-ARID TO ARID T'i HABITATS,INCLUDING CONIFER AND Area mapped as low value predicted California Bonneted Bat(Eumops perotis DECIDUOUS WOODLANDS,COASTAL habitat by CWHR.No apparent californicus) CNDDB(3) SSC,S3S4 SCRUB,GRASSLANDS,CHAPARRAL, Yes Low Low None roosting habitat.Value of area as ETC.ROOSTS IN CREVICES IN CLIFF foraging habitat may be increased by FACES,HIGH BUILDINGS,TREES AND project. TUNNELS. LOW-LYING ARID AREAS IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA.NEED HIGH CLIFFS OR Big Free-tailed Bat(Nyctinomops macrotis) CNDDB(2) SSC,S3 ROCKY OUTCROPS FOR ROOSTING No N/A None None — SITES.FEEDS PRINCIPALLY ON LARGE MOTHS. INHABITS THE NARROW COASTAL PLAINS FROM THE MEXICAN BORDER While within species range,outside of Pacific Pocket Mouse(Perognathus CNDDB(1), FE,SSC, NORTH TO EL SEGUNDO,LOS ANGELES No N/A None None subspecies range per longimembris pacificus) IPaC S2 COUNTY.SEEMS TO PREFER SOILS OF https://www.fws.gov/species/pacific-po FINE ALLUVIAL SANDS NEAR THE OCEAN, BUT MUCH REMAINS TO BE LEARNED. Within CWHR species-level range. TIDAL MARSHES IN LOS ANGELES, Subspecies occurs in tidal marshes at Stephens'California Vole(Microtus Point Mugo,Orange Co.,and Playa del CNDDB(2) SSC,S2 ORANGE AND SOUTHERN VENTURA No N/A None° None Rey and Sunset Beach,Los Angeles californicus stephensi) COUNTIES. Co. per https://sdmmp.com/ud/SDMMP_Re - 4...C..- _ .L .. ; �.L` .,.,,._ "� .,3sy^-,. ,aa��::+2x N ! _.5 .....wt. "+y W an• n6"�r�,.N'.". -k `z,P,^ Y.r :'3`+ c£.+,k-75 'a"�, ,m4�..6h d "� .t,. as' _ ..N ..,p .3 1•:^ ,.�°+..:: _ �- � b �S his ,.:�, a z ..,� �. �, ,x �. n,<.,. �, �,. .� . �r�M: : -;� b ia� •Ob' ':once fi. �:,� u��-, ��. �,�,� ._ 7axoh ...5 (1rc .s tat A� Yit _Ran ( iir I act, Notes ,. , . au uEN .,�.. _. _.> � :-� ,.., � �.. 4 �..,. c .._�. � Ems� =_ .,.._. '...�.......aa�_-� � .,,�aa � r , MOST ABUNDANT IN DRIER OPEN STAGES OF MOST SHRUB,FOREST,AND HERBACEOUS HABITATS,WITH FRIABLE No predicted habitat mapped in area American Badger(Taxidea taxus) CNDDB(1) SSC,S3 SOILS.NEEDS SUFFICIENT FOOD, Yes N/A None None by CWHR. FRIABLE SOILS AND OPEN, UNCULTIVATED GROUND.PREYS ON BURROWING RODENTS.DIGS BURROWS. • • 253 Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Appendix C. Photo Log Inserted after this cover page is a database-generated photo log. Page 1 Photo Log Carr Park This database -generated report presents a visual depiction of site conditions during the survey conducted on February 13, 2024 by England IEcology. The data presented here were collected in the field using the QField app on an iPhone 15 Pro. After fieldwork was completed, data were synced to QGIS desktop. The map below presents an overview of the photo locations in this report, with each photo shown on the ensuing pages. This report was generated using QGIS 3.36. 255 Photo Point 439 i NW NI NE E 0 300 330 0 I 30 60 90 . 1 . 1 . 1 . 1 • I •• I •• I •• I •• I •• I •• I •• I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I 0 6°N (T) * 33720581° -118.023996° ±45ft A 8ft i ,... , - , ti.ntf.Pth t,t‘ J t,,,,t, - '_4 • .4'.., „ \ t 'W..*;,)f t t It • . ( , :iit ,..: levo:, *.i % Olio, ..i• 11,100#?' 4 Itet"'cOE'ii't'*-- k. ,... .: ,... , ,,,,,, ....:4-40 A-... ... • '4114 1.-----:-.........:' <ix.,... . fWI 4._ 2- ±--4_, 7 ... .11.11111,r-74i-44::.V.::::: ":1' "-Nr.".7%'•.7.:141.":""..H. 111:7 ' "" ).‘"'1111"111111"""...1.--M15".".:::"f Cri . . .. . I o S • 7.: %„. ........,.. -.. ..._, . ' .•‘.., ^...,4,..:-1-1,..r., , • , .y.... -,.-..„_. '...t• .-:,, -.#1.3. - --4';4:, ". .."'-',-:vz, , - - ''- 40toiL••,-, ^ ' : '.;•:.• 1.7:v.:' . -4.`-",.;...- ., . •,. -s`r.:... ' , t•?4,.....; ....„,r - ""..' -' - ' • -,..";!..4"":.4"%,, •• '..". :-, 't.,..., `••,•:, • f,-,k,t, - . ' •,. 'Tee:, , - . '..:., ,., —-- '.4:: . * . ..*, *** ' ' '' * ......'. .' '',-**'.*, ' *',, • • • '''''",.,4%., „. . '*..:,, • .. , ' . ''..-"-,-•4.4,•• ta?:,,,;.*f„',1;.- 1,...,•••.1.1 4,- 4,1:4,. ...._.„._ e„. , , .. . , .,, ,,,,., -...,,*.t.4,,,„4...--,, Ap- .-r' -.. ..0 " -' " .- ::, . ' ,' ' • ' ' ' Carr Park 1., , . ,,...,„ ..,..:--, ',..1...*,,,,,-, -,.. ,;„*;*,...1.--1,4,-,1;-...,..- • • t- '',..: _ -..,'24 A.,:i'!,..,,-,:-.4,,,D4 6;1",,,r` '' • . EnglaridjEcology '': i-- .. '' ii..., :- ,,, . I '. " , a . • , 5 • 13 Feb-2024 10.05 11 - . . _ . P 0. g ' Photo Direction 0, I 1 . 1 - 71 TT, :, ,,),,,, _ . 1 15 I ! . 4 U) i I 1.I 1* 1 -9• I I c 0 I 1. 1.770. 1 i f . , : 5 I .,13 . ca. I ID 1 Fo— , co , .... I 1 III 1 1 11 , , 4.n 1 *,- - . s. i t. 1 ib It : ik - , ,-.4/6„. ;it 4.,,,,,'„ , 4.4 , . 1 .1,-1.... , .,.. , 1 ..;,r-t4--": . ..m. , . . rt,tiiitt , - 4 , - 4i, i., , . ' *4' ''4. ' , .. .......... • North Photo Description View along Springdale Street from the park's southwest corner. it ‘-.1— __,___.: „, 11 -...? .- - ,. .i 1 - t _ 4.- 1 u, 1 i .-...„ ,... % '..: 0 • D. °"1.1 41.."....‘...,,. „. ..: .6.... ''' ,.. • I ti3 CI. CD fa— , 1 • 41e \ • . , . - 256 y- - -- ' le IIII 1 a.7'1.. .. .di,^' Photo Point 440 JVV N NE I E SE 330 0 30 60 90 120 • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • • I • I • 0 48°NE (T) OO 33.720533°, -118.023907° ±13ft ♦ 9ft I'V Axi:I. viiii f -. _ �• TG Wyk 1 .. ' �F�'TP- J1' .- ..£`wn ...J 1w}' • Yw V+N+�+_:. .:. .w+vnMC1u1' M Vx` h..,8 ry,f' * �v-t '�2Y f < : 4' • '.%' r ''^' `":*er. -• a. maw 4 Xtt-w • fi" . �- 7 ,p _.., a; <'•-; ':. ,1.., , ,...,,..-: -,o.4.4*... .,....:..I..... gt....,11.40,''**4``,,, ''.*t 0',"44'=":t t.-Ankl-ila.,.:c ''' . ' '''''"feki4 '',•'"y °:e- - '.0 •,, ' y . -g 'i s " � • a ' "; 4 ° . sr• w '*fti4 .:,4, .'141 : d ; n7 +toma *#a w w,,r e * i _ 4 , 4 .L. ; s, r wi! .X - r 'A,, 'r ,— a -,s. , x�* . « t < ....1' a r>• J :.A a :ref . ', ti,, ••fis . i "'1P� ,,. . 3 .,r . , r¢ 4�i.wt a r, 2 r { ,w a, g t `, :t N vj �' t...a .µ t.i„' '..,i P - rY* ti ,' . . �. et• , �1 . Y' r xi..*'e..: ,.Su aay. ` 4 ! {1.' #%'.t.'.rCSCE .. b„,t,.,,0.T,,,st,t ‘4,-.. .-=."*,-.4.4*.44,..):t.,,,*: -4,- xy'• , of ,y i, , `� rM, N• • : �. * Carr Park .EnglandiEcology, • . - ; , • _� . . 13 Feb 2024, 10:05:28 *. I a j I - — 4t . M . Photo Direction - I i 1 4 * I _ � Northeast — _ # 1 Photo Description - I View into the park from the park's' .. " :, a Po southwest corner. I (A I R tS, ,m.. ' j5 ' '9. i wI 1 )I D. I. 1 # t Ia. CA I tt— -Pt : 4' ,. :ate. . ....:... - _ ti I I Ij II., ... -----,--------- = --=---=—... v, 1 • • ',: t N 4 - _ i 257 Photo Point 441 N NE E SE S 0 as 60 a 120 150 180 I 1 • I • ( • I 88°E (T) 0 33.720540o, -118.023915° ±13ft- A 1Oft r - . • • • '�`v"k.Fy^i3y aq q'* p,L *. s�" Y,,,f t. "`may "am�y..Y....'-i zrk '` '�$T ,j a• `< x"4.' s w, t * c am, i`3 ' y.,,�, ;'- y,,A..,. Y''4. Y!(l. Yam.. `W.srk' K * - - Carr Park w; . . , R a m Ecology 13 Feb 2024, 10:05:37 ., i , ,' . w 'a Photo Direction } �-s East +., n �.' . 1 �; :' . -- - Photo Description . s fi. a View along the park's southern ° _x boundary from the park's southwest •,.. 1 r I,1 �r , ;a _ '_ �& corner. I 'ice> * c, °.. , k. yy y,. 1 CA 2. 1 r. *,:.,1�.., -..y,,,,.1 .„...0,- . a �� ' 7.4 OW :S fir" 1. , Photo Point 442 V NE E i SE S 0 30 60 90 120 150 180 I • I • 1 1 I I I • I • I • I • I • I • 1 . I . I . I . I . I • 1 • 0 94°E (T) O 33,722620°, -118.023919° ±13ft A lift -- _ y '�6+:i�� r r fi' _ t l , T}+ r l vZ.y.iY - }} n - • - tea— • .‘Carr Park =En r d Ecolog • •y. 13 Feb-2024, 10:0.9:45 Photo Direction East • CI III — Photo Description Hen Ave View along Heil Avenue from the 1 _ park's northwest corner. - , 1 r �. 1 £ r : ,,,,,,4'. ., :s4i.04;21,,k..fit.„,„ 2.--:::::r,,,,,:i.,--,-,,,,.:::'4f4 259 Lv)\-41411‘‘LN Photo Point 443 NE E c = S SW 60 90 120 150 180 210 . I • I • I • i • I • I • I • I • I 0136°SE (T) OO 33.722590°, —118.023906° ±13ft ♦ 11ft ti €�,,,.... f. - ., l'e ..+ -e �s�" �}a `��1 tr'p"Y . . l: JJ 11 yA • Alr Y U T �, ps, j i ; .aa x _, R �. � 5, �.-mac,�,- ..[z..y '• ,� � •� l '" _ ,_,.;i`�``• � t"'` �,JL.�-��� '_'�{��'���!/y�l ,.. .. F gig. 'a ' .�,w ....nS e s� ' . rx. } ~le •. 4• . , - Garr Park` England�EcQIogy 13.Feb 2024, 10:09:52 Photo Direction . - , — — — — — _ Southeast Ili — Photo Description View into the park from the park's �. Heil Ave northwest corner. g I ....... -- - / . - i J k I� o I` a %" I ,1,,,,r-:._: .i - 1 g Y Photo Point 444 E SE isSW W 90 120 150 180 210 240 27C • 1 • 1 • 1 • I • 1 • I • 1 • I • 1 • I • I • I • 1 • 1 • I • I • 1 • I • I 0178°S (T) OO 33.722589°, —118.023922° ±13ft A 11ft ,_,,,,.„,,,__, ,,..-,;....---:,....- .. ..17,,,tri, ,,,„Tlr,fy,o,vtmi,,,;„ ,- ,-..----:,t4iiel:7-.- ,,,,:,:,,:,,,r.,:,,,,,,,:,,,,,,. .r.-.,;,,,,,,,,,„,,,,,,,"""7"-,ke,...,,,,,,vr _..,,.., ..„, ' j p 5 .� a • v.�,s !.,fir .e .- '.C.',, '}'jw �}♦lq 1 r'4!A�a,r81• f.. . ' o . ~ .. „pi ".` _,a ;k ". of , k+�Q" I da ylj '---• '� .. -+r r.ate i a ! r � ._ ,.--_ +ate.. g ' - '_ r' 1_ :a t'• � ,� ... a� - _ , t r J •4 Aa , -:Y • ..y Gam• K L- a • - - a . ..41• n •• ' f • • - • • r a . • - • - d Carr Park EngiandjEcology' 13 Feb 2024, 10:09:58 , - \ .�� 1 ' - Photo Direction _ Ti... _ — South it - —titill Photo Description View along Springdale Street from the s. ,r" Heil Ave park's northwest corner. idr r i i ,may ''`t V -� . . 7, a � 1 at _ v . 261 �I r_- � _Ill - ' '' �� Photo Point 445 S SW Ifki NW N 180 210 240 70 300 330 0 • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • i • I • I • I • I • I • I • 1 • I • I 0 268°.W (T). CD 33.722551°, -118.021943° ±108ft • 67ft ' .. -- .c :N .a 4 )57.‘ -r, -e- z.,,, ' ':1:49' — - • . .,'t. A4.- CN ' ' i I 4 -.A.A‘• - 1•0 ' ,... ... 4;11 • ... - . .. . - -...... cc.N, ...... ltz,,,k Nit ..` V. ‘ - . ,..... ' - ..t, -•,..i .,0., .A. , . -.... . ' - ; - "'.-- 'i. 0 _ k....t.:., .pi w.„.., t - ... ,_,:.--.- • .., .., ,o1 ----- - '.: —Art, ..--- •.t. . I ridirrirtrertlIMA:;, .,,,. ' .,,' .— 6." 1,...„1._......................................._. ."."'"....-- — ....r ,,I-- ...,..-,...,-......,.....-........ ...L.1 rt-,..,.,..,..... --, • . - figM2 4,1:.., -• , - "-.- - - ..-. /---7.7m4 - ... - .--.--••'•----*:t!-------5:7;,---;..--LL,,,,,,,• :;.---", . -------.- %- ..1.' -- • -----'.------.. .-**-- .. -'---"'..;;..-;":'.", • •-...-- i . -', ,- ,-- 111 A.7 . _. .. 7z7z-i-t-i%r""7:.- ---..--------- --- 1 iz.,-,-4.;, . , _ : -,_ ,.......---\01%.42. ...„ .f.' .. . ,„„,. ....„., . ... .. - - ..._.. ,-_-_-_-_-...11, _ .... ----.......„. - .. - '''.41!Itglael.. '-- -...z- . - - 1, 1 _ . ',;•lifilsr-44....., :::„,.•,.-.- - - . _ • -- - -----,---_-. .., - - • -- . .. ... , — • *,.. • :,. . • . . . - . " ' ' --,0,•• -. . .. -...,;7.t.-...',.....4.-.Y.:,4z'-o.-- -- - -,..., .--,, • - - - ... • . • . 7:,,..... .1."2" it-.' -..,. - - -.1...4--‘4.41-_--,-4.- -•---,,..4.---, - -.......,- - ---- • . ' -. - -'s'•-=..--- ' -`,-,,=-..-•-,-•:,-- •-- .,:__- --.4.,-., ',. -4•0... - •- -',.. - -,. ---- - .)' ••- - • ...,..- , - . .,-. , . , , ,, -.. ,.-- .4.• V - ' . . - . -'4* -k"---4.---;---- ," .... ....-, _ ve...,..x..,,,,,-;.„....g* ' . ,. .i . ,. !, _„.., -:,......-0.g0, . .„ , . ...•,.. ' . . , . . - '. , . 4,,,,:-.0 N*,:.. ,.:''''''. .' . ,.• ,...""....4.i...;.,4:'7Ar ' ..:...:ri.::-,...:.,..14„',,Tir:Tv.,..:. -..-,,,,,,7, . . ..N.i.:,4:,:';:-..41.;-'1',' ' ' Carr'_-°:'" '-'7''" . iPark'rAi.: - . , . , • - _. .. .... ...._.„,..., ..- EndlandlEcblogy .• • . - ' 13"Feb' '1036- - . 2024, •15• - . Photo Direction — — E West _ • • . . .Mb• •edmaime 11,mon•••••••••4 40 Heil Ave .. Hell Ave HeihAve. Photo Description — — View along Heil Avenue from the - ---- park's northeast corner. .--------- . — _ . —_ ----_---— • 4mll•Imll..•.... ....“li &Ira tio..to .................... "fl , 1 • ... . r : •,„ .'.. -.... ...., •, . . .. . 411 , . ; k •" 44 I .. ;.'..' 1 •0. .• ••••0 '' .11....• Ma ' '',..''••- , ,4 4, 'I ,, il• .' I • . 0 Ur I ‘ li I 1111111 . . . a 1 V . y • . .... :;, . . . k 14,.....,14,=$, .,..... • witiN444 . . ,. .. 44 I ! ,. . „. ' -- . ' A I. Aere"Orirk-t ;.'" .4144.- .,• . It"" Ii. : .0,e414,14016.1 a .. . ., . I . . . , At * . . 1 V *V * ' ar, , . 262 s, Nvj Photo Point 446 SE S 1W W NV\ 150 180 21 240 270 300 I. • • • • • • • • ' 0 224°SW (T) OO 33.722551°, -118.021943° ±9ft A 67ft r t ;s Yrj' '1 tx, 4 4• x ky r,:f� � .�� r. • -i T ~� .{ — • M• -err • :' . w .ter.+—' — rt .,.,�,.•..•,a;x�, - ,. �,ar�... '- =•�-�.a.� -- -. -- ,,.,. ,:' :� _ ,++a�,-:'"�'` �`r cam.: r sr .. _ _._.. �. _ter••. a „,. T,' ^'a may:`,.."7. 'j, :4- A-. ✓« W - +' • ,�,�w« .y�'•n.ti r+ x � �`- �""'—�•,.'.^, ,�,�ry►�eik.'Z"Ys`'`"" � � r ;:- v�''* + ,« . . � : � .rf. . a > ve- � f� p 4 . .... ra4pq: r y. * • ?,`r' 41x y""s.'T- r` ' y5 .✓����v'''-''.. "'' 4.{,Ai d".." 4 -. Ft '..„ "�' t. . ♦ .: 're. "'e 6 L :.'4--x '. 11, ^1r '"' '',,,, '#• b`? S✓yy a�.: ,,, . . ; S ',. •'S.#tr_u.r;'''' . �,y,u,• 4-:4 .'ar R*%.ta1 "" `cy., .;...4'. � ,,•;. w"« " . '' t• �y,p J-�1s 1-* p''.- • Y ..14 • • d r 1 T . F • ***:' EnglandlEcology 'I� Feb 2024, T0;�15: 2 ii - Photo Direction • 44 """"`, Southwest tI -- • --- -• - a Photo Description -- _ __ • View into the park from the park's ,r.r__,� - , northeast corner. Heil Ave ' Heil Ave '""'"`�^•Hei1«Ave, it - - " i I' • ._�.-_ cal ...ro: y , s ' i Lii Photo Point 447 E SE SW W 90 120 150 1 210 240 270 I I I I I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I 0181°S (T) O 33.722551°, -118.021943o :±13ft ♦ 67ft r ,Y.). 11'. : ' ''''''%;,.. '. .. t: .11 ( k { ' � .arm E . ill ire . . - --- ,, ,. ---1 ---T__ j{ T , : ,,...' : .,,,...414,7- -'• __.,- - -..._ 1. .,per ,'.r • trir`„;r` ,�y .'+?.1itt. :__."._,,,,,i.._,:iii...0,,,,olili:4":,„,",:.x-.1,,, ic . fi. . ,Carr Park EnglandlEcology 13 Feb 2024, 10:15:48 �_ . ... Photo Direction �"' l k South 44110 - - • Photo Description v • -- — -_ - View along the park's eastern • - • _„—� .,..........r.. boundary from the park's northeast Heil Ave Heil Ave ~�`�'�""—Heit.Axe.� corner. -----------------._.--- -_- ;—1- Y 1 ♦ . 9 1 s 1 e ' i • 1 zi - ♦ •y III 1 1 1 i 1111-0 Ilt . r hl p I. �` , 264 21 Photo Point 448 sw 1111 NW N B0 210 240 270 300 330 0 [ • I • I • I • I • --1 • I • I I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • O 274°W (T) Q 33.720476°, -118.021869° ±59ft A 11ft _ wtt a .. Q7 a t ; s 7 r •... �n� r -. .•1 `F Y, ..1, ice. . . � rs• .t tvy ';"t�5 I.. fit: tegik $� f r r 1 st- yqt < 1 .-....- •e^"5e ww*-. --...'"k.,,y„�,.:. — _ _ t x, :..;.. • e _ Carr Park_ EnglandlEcology 13 Feb 2024, 10:19:50 • • I -_T r Photo Direction n i • '�. West ,, . '' Photo Description i ..' ‘.a 4��' �. _ View along the park's southern ` boundary from the park's southeast k�yt .A.- ,-' corner. I �• : *maxis' 41 r � , i1 y •�• ; ! • -.. . �# Yf r p ! t�1 �s ,. � *v , 4 i , a w 't�� 'r ' ...T.y"., 5 265 ;,y� 3 Photo Point 449 3W W N1 / N NE 240 270 300 330 0 30 • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • I • 1 • I • I,,, • I • I • I 0 317°NW (T) • 33.720554°, .118 02,1921 ±9ft,• 12ft w. ' 'F%fK t•'�.�"Y+',. tr.1•`f�i`o�iti'`^- , _ }.` f. ,�"^'.,�.;'«+r. -.sa '�;t . is K • Ai fir ft '• f '' •=''h,dyf` Grp% ,�`��1{ ` `rr,tci� .. :' j i g { C j a •.''• ,.`.{° !' .•vt`.-''� r.! -„,yr: µ'y ;.,% y1•T„ � 5 3fi _; '.F x ..�T G- . �'� g if,''' r 4 s ,,d..r x '.,+,4 • �5r 3- * + 74,, .`. '„4* %i"4`"('c. -# '5„•T"st ait �,„pt.iY '�t".ri+ti,} 2..,` . yr:.n' *'4z '' p a�t�7, q�tr e,,,: r,.r�� S t- ram' .,. ,,, .3. *Ei yr` ,+P,t4i% * r". rf 0J144, /* - > T a f",e, •. 'c x-, t. 'rt L", ty'�'J'' s`t�,.n' ....�... _- .._ ... '14.^Y�f .3_` r `:r. ~i`ta.. . i' • ..il�- ` 93. �T•,'�'it � _ �YI M1'7.•'S s+. r • v t, �.l'- _: '<' �-.. L ?" x f" X yam 'f .(cr' r. _—•�� »rt 2+,, r r rR -p=4". , , '`.- ' ✓ . ' .. .'^ -w - ' ,,ry. r" r. iy ' - • r a ' "P `rt-r.-f. -..,fg , .,.- " `.I,5.�.aw"4 . ' I.m.a .e'xas,., q:u "rv`�,�+ c 4 u,d'w;, "<',. ,q ,y.am . . ... �,,i ,W ,,,;, v -" �z°" +'. '"' t ": . r �^^v � y. ti '• -" .'r S+rr ''G.: , at , xx3 . .,.•-•-•--_: C ,;.r"L , r: e" *sw Y� A "' ^. r l'"'cw : _.r � .nct-Z• . `"'.tc^ ,t-•' •,-."-- , ?4., - s �f . a ' • � , , i . r� r 1 « 'i •` ''x 4,'"4 ' �,.• •, c '" r - 5,ti • • ,gip ti a4� ,r t v _ j '}. Ai""�'�.� -m+""i •...` x' ^ - , "�q;`� nd'•� W 14- •-'. p� 1 . -^e' f. .. iq,-• , ` n `'- �tmL 4 r z •' a L•�' ^ " -7, >'kC" g�,"• • ,i .f 4i•4 x:+ L,p 5 47 3 1 ``fi r �. ,13 Feb 20240 7,EnglandlEcology �, ,- _R • Photo Direction ' " ' �-� �¢;a" �� Northwest xe•e�• Photo Description • r: • View into the park from the park's - southeast corner. 7,,,,,.-' ''..,:,,,i:,3;,-it, ';'.',..!..., ' .1.;,..f..1.4,.'4H,.•1'.",'„,,,.11,,.,-: rtisketliIreTt. • r ...' { • / fit. 1,.�- r , ? +� « .. _ i , ..‘ :is 4:�+,yP r�y•:f- ... ..s ue a 1.,,..,, , . �..,.. . �, • 266 r ,� ♦ S 4, . • s Photo Point 450 W NW N NE E 270 300 330 30 { 60 90 • I • I • I • I • I • I • 1 • I • I I • I I I • I • I • I • I • I • I ® 359°N (T) Q 33.720559°, -118.021:923 +13ft A 12ft �.rti., *-�t� e ,�"q .r,1yg" _y �{z i7"" .'§'U :.w'�' �§` � y�/rQr.1�j�}1} . .�."��v �'`,�,p,„; fl :,„ �tom�. ♦ `�, ,,,r•-'• { ^t ;- ,, `4 _ d X LC '"e r`*' f,. `ice: t .� •fin ' '^ - Y" x x 1 r• •�,' .i' 'a`s t h` •,.�. -p„t'.3 7.3: _ �•.. � '"• ..�w-id �,,,"-+"tt i� �+ °w,dlyr +3 a �� +r��'Z z�� a. .ai' .�+a <- tts e.«t' ' A r.T i *' `.9,SM ` w hi r!/' * �', ; , ,,.,.. .r i ---' 'in n 4. 444 �h� '"<.. ,, . . - �°'e' Ex3* `�-�'t` r '" -.:4 . �+ tr�fi �t' -.vJ� �_'- a •r -- 'r 1" `'•�_ _: c... "Y"'+..r� ;��h,.,'. s a ,d4,r _"4r i ,'_{•, + a ,4f^CF�S' ,} -�... F��'___. L ktybb"" ;i;- .� :ti "'-t -'l, !-ss 1 ft to ,..• �' ' ; -- '• f 71- I .t ..► . h .yeh'7 .,aas 4y� ye xt 5.{ ` �r."* �" {TM Y `45 ' +'�✓'.y '* "L, 7,- *`'"7, ' "' :44'44a"vawb ,s ` ty'l1'",V;.,,, +.`i•'4 Rro'�.-' T,./t�. i$ .r.vv�. : x� ,§�.X' 7 $ i ter .c ,� ig f" fi r `"-.. , '. ,4,, . x. . . „ , ,,'., a Carr Park En. and(Ecolog• y ,. 1• . -. - 13 Feb 2024, 10:20:05 - � .� - _,f •'• `•, , [ Photo Direction t , �• "-- • I _� North ' * '" " r i -,'T 4" , �' a Photo Description ' ' j '!� ; View along the park's eastern j .' 1 boundary from the park's southeast D�itr corner. ` j `Nl[t1l)- ,,, rr .„11 • 1 PSBR y 9 t r rAIX• t w.'a 't{ �" 4a4 _,.e-' r`�.-+ ,. 267 Photo Point 451 W NW N NE E 270 300 330 0 30 60 91 • 1 • I • I • 0 356°N (T) 033.721395°, -118.022956° ±13ft A 18ft ,_ ir . d • `f . J° kt' ,i. + . , , • .>i+), 4^ r k '1: I //•s ... 1114 }• �r ♦+, 1rrr am -, .z..,0.,01.,!J.:41A: t , �J�►•-�-. y ma e.y` y:' �. it ," --„ t'"4'7Ld. r .:u` xw - ;.j4r^..•ti«.nw.:47•••w"^ ^ ".�',:;-, xr�`e" p } �.. . �,. , x ;j , `' ' Cart Park . England;E ol•ogy . `• �'� 3 Feb.2424, 1 b�30:05`� Photo Direction ��� r, .' � North ,, ' // Photo Description ° . _= , From near the park's center. / ,... . 4-S-;_f- .,, „ .,:.,-...„.,.---,,..-„,,,- ..iiit:,'- li.,...--'„ 4.ry `- . • _ ate a° - -- II t, ,..: .. „a rya �.''^a '. `#» " ' 404' ^gam` 'di y r k,$w q,, ,9'�...: • i 1 it - • at; 1-• r4. r ,4 268 �� Photo Point 452 N NE E SE S 0 30 60 120 150 180 • I • I 0 90°E (T) OO 33.721396°, -118.022951° ±13ft ♦ 22ft w x • ,,,le,,bR' "` iie ;` .°c."4 t a4'y,. i k c"% .r'�C..-,�{ r'�"a.n:.v �. -_'w"°w - aYLX .,,.x ': dtY 3`wy"`.'4. >"" K 4.w.'sn.Y '. .Qy " N. 4- Y +ys. -M." �, .., M-` - ,, "a„*/'1.,' '+ - ^s..-" .,t„ .ice" Y.d y`:yw�.zP -.�r" + ` � . ',v,x f:� _, A� '�-. �. Pt ''ti A�..oaf M„T,N'?".-@. ,d^♦T% s-„ } , x l ..• '-'• ".': » ,3:"«�t � ^r'"-yam .k'•• 4--• lilts 7, :. Y rx ac 3', :2 d. _,y �. .Y.* —-• e,,^t -,t. ro.-•t,_A.ti1„,- a' ;� • - - '. k . : 1 °�L` 1-'., ,ew T ;. lgr.7•Yl } .4! w i.." ;. • :' - ,µ - L - '"Ra me, } W • Eng1andiEcology: .' * : 13-Feb.2024, 10;30:11 �' "� _ :� Photo Direction /r ,� * . ..' East .. ;;�� 6 ._ '., / � �" Photo Description a,, Y _ ...- -' ,, From near the park's center. <: � � IF «'. ,' • , , iiS IN' . 4.1: • • q1 Y , Photo Point 453 E SE Sw W 90 120 150 1 210 240 270 I I I I I . I • 1 • I • I • I • I • I • I • I . I . I • I • I • I . 0181°S (T) O 33.721392°, -118.022952° ±13ft ♦ 23ft - ------ *41, :;: t.41 - fir. ��. ; p �f — w: ' .wr `Oi 4, v .e , ♦ - =. rr 4%.* '` - ''. _":• Lam. • 4. 'R . .4' - V/ . ?.. —h ,;4. .:4 • - — t • ♦ Carr Park -Engiand�Eeology - 13 Feb,2024, 10:30:16 /''' ,,_ r , ' Photo Direction tr South /' • •• ` Photo Description . ,_�. /�/ • From near the park's center. / 1 »• tom r .: • �" 4R �AI . `ss» ,`. X , ._ . t � w $a fi+P 4 ., :^E ,�, »! 'a 7. a e .1/��f � in4 w -'. a. x 'a€ i• rS'..\,`,v''';--.\41 •E_ �� .I - _ Photo Point 454 SW 1N NW N BO 210 240 270 300 330 0 1 I i I • I • I • I • I I I I I •I I I I I I I • 0 274°W (T) 033.721392°, —118.022955° ±13ft ♦ 23ft .� ; . 1Y �t}a. ,tom ,,.. f . ; 't� j •, r1 _ f(e 1 . .°:` ,'..•S',r:•. ` . .., .>:. ... o ff_.-::r`1s •„ti• - -. .. 5 'kr't' •z � i t gi ,. t..' .yam' -_ +"`.X ♦fi-_ r ' `y. ' t� `3 '� f . issr '? r"�� i" .r . -.4 5.. " ic ,.- jF °� t Mr .. ' - u- 4 ;rp L. : .',_'!' ',>- a .ra'd ..w �.frs r .»*l4 i le s ° x .1A 4 r , „y`7i. }"' x,�` . _ -.+- ` -? .a"2 : i r . ; + '1' "' ww; .b., "••`, i� i�+�: ts.t'- �";v'' f, r+"4 i'! , 'i ' wtr'* 'L.' . ,M __,� _♦>!i _ ,. •c' t' ?r'N',3 ,sr :.w•x •,. .�,:; w ,. , :._ i ,, �.- :. r �.- _ Carr Park. . +; Wit, � X..�: ; -._ '. _ '' England{Ecology 13'-F�b21 4'w �:30:23 .. t (� S►'.fit y �. �,/ k Photo Direction f r .# ' * , �• West j /a a •1 Photo Description ' From near the park's center. Nr �4-s gw Y t r.. p � t� c, k �.;, mF *'a t k �; ro , Y:r' '4 .. {ff-- t fi -.r¥ n,1.-p" •' ... .. .♦ ♦ for , 55 qkF r'a ¢ .. .w p.. __, v�1 Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Appendix D. eBird Species List Following is the list of all 158 avian taxa reported to eBird for the Carr Park hotspot. The table includes the relative abundance information from eBird. The abundance data is color-coded for clarity: • Red - not recorded. • Orange - rarely recorded. • Yellow - not commonly recorded. • Green - commonly recorded. • Blue - recorded on most checklists. Pagel 241&% a s o 1 F" 5 '8 o a 215 @ 55 5 5 1 51 's 1 5'5 51 5'5 55 5 5 15 5 51 5 55 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 o 515 s 5 5 5 ! a 5 51515 • §:§ gi§:a 1§ § dig %§ @ § i § 4 @I@ a o o § § @ § § § § @1:�€ § $ 4,314 E �'� � �'1 E E 81E & $ ! E E E 4 E $'E E 8:� 4 4 E E 8 E ? a & E 41 o o _ o ' eL I 8 § �� � C5 I § o §3§,R § 55,5 1 5:@ 5 551 15 5 5 515I5 1 5 5 515 115 5155 5,5 5 5 o 15 5 5 1 @ 5 5 $ 15 515 §1 8 a si 1515 I.� m �'$ '155 18 5011515 § 581 ,15 5'5 151f5 ,� ! 81 ! 5515II51,11di1 _'@5 8 15 § § or@5B1r 0 0 o 0 0, 'N 8 515 5 § 55 151515551§ § § ,55 a 511. o5 $ $ 0 1555'� 5111'o § o,� 5 § 511115 11515 e 115115551 e o o e e • c �L 8 8 15 15 5 5 5 5 5:5A2.5 § €1@55 5 51 151 55115, ec e51551 1551 $ 5 55551 555 5 51 555 xg $ I o 0 55155oa515LL15 055,5'1 5,5 5 5115 5 5 5 5 5 5 51'515 5 55555 5155515 55111 55 15555:5'� '5 55 5551 55,5 o 15 515 5 5 a 115 5 5.5 5 5 5 5 5 5.5 5 5 5 5'5 15 5 5 5 115 5 5115 5.515 5 5 51515115o 5 5 15 5e n 5 155..' :@@ 55 a 1 555555 5 .15 ao5 455 5 5 55 8e 855 § 5155 =e 1 § § 8 5 1555151555555 555 5 58 .5.551i 55 & 1 §;� Id 11 � $ @ @ V ! ! @ II a �1 11 ! 5 5 5 5 5 551@ S • 5 55 . 15515 1o,155555.5,oil 1! 5555555 ! 5115 5 5,55:555 1555155 5155515 5 '5 55 5551,5551 ;515 5 5 15 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 51115o 1515 5 5 515 5 5 51515 o e � § § 555555 15555 § 55555555151555'51555151 1555555551 ! 5555555 5 55 5558555 v R F511 § E E I E E E E E E E I; RIE E § E §. § § § § § § §''R ,1 5. 511 �,of f16 § g El'E E o E,EE • 5,1 51, 11,15 51:5 5 & 5 5 1 1 5' 15 5 5 5 § 5 5 § § § 5 5 § 5 a 518 O115 5,151115 & 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5'5 o 5@ 5 ! @ 5 5 5 5 5.15 515 - 55' 55'5 151515 1e15' 55555515 :1 !', 5555555, 55 ! 51515551155 5511555555' 55555551515 5 55 5 5115, 51 - 5 1' 5 § 5 @ 1'5I5 gl�!@ 5 5@ 5 5 5 5 5 g,g 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 §'€15 $ 5115 5:5I 1 @ 5@ 5 5 5 § @ 5 5 5 § § @ 5 5 $ 5 § § 5 1 15 MI5 o0 10 0 0 ' o o _ _ - § § of 0 1@ 5 5•1 515 5 5 5 5 5 5 8 8 1:5 @ 5 5 5 5 5 o@ 5 5 5 5 5 1 1 5 $ & 5 5 ' @. 5 5I1a 5 5@ 5 5 5 5 5 § 5:5 5 5 5 5 55 5 5 5 a 5 5 51 515 5 5 15 5,1 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 115 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5.51 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5i 5 5 5 5 5 ! 5 5 5 5 5 5I$11 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 n e' § 8 §11 g § § § § a § § § g § g g g. gig 8',g g @ EI EI;', o 4 $ 4: E E g § g 8 g g § @ gi § @ � - $ $ g g g g g @,g g @ § $ g @ § § § § § 'gig § § @ $ §. $ § § g § $ g $,g11. g E § @ i-i @ E § i 4 § § § § § § § § § i 4 § §.. @ § §. 44 § § E § § $' 5,1515 1535 1155 5. 55e 5.15 M5 & $ 551s5 @5 $ 5o5, 555555 olao 8115 555 555551j551155 5 55 511555 . a55515 515 51:55555555 § 155555551555@5511555555 1' 55a § § 8§55555555555o'a5. 5 55 5815§ 5 o eee e oo oeoe o 00 oe000a _ _ , - 555f le§ 51:5 55555555555 § § 5 § § § § § § § § § § § 5iI § § § § 5 § g1 § § 55 § 5 § § § 5 § § § 5155 § 5 55 5555555' ' 5,55 55 1 5115 15555555555555551515555555 1551151a555:5515 155 5 55 5555555, ? .!1 ! a � � � ,el� � iai § § § § § § §'§!§ ! § § § § § § § § �' gi;qAa EE 4E444441 - 5 515 5 & § ,o§' 5'8!5 5 5 $ 5 5 & 5 5 R5 5 55 5 5 5 5 515 5 51515 5-� 5 o'5 5 5' 55115 I $ e 5 5 5 515 § 8 8 5 1.5 5 5 55 5 5 5 5 5 5'5 o 00 • 5 o 51,5 1 5 .15 R @ ! 5 5 115 11' 5 55 5 $ 5 5 115 1 $ 5115 0 5 5 515115 5 5 5 $ 5 5 5 5 5111115 5 5 5 5 4115 5 g $' a I • 51115 115 15 @ V1g 8 ! 8•1 5 & 515 5';11� I5 B,5 51515 5 5 1 51� 5 1 E 515 5 5,d 15,5 5, 5115 5 §I5,5 5 @ 5 @ 5,1 8 5 e,� 5 @ @ 5 5 @ 5 515 @ 5 §ie1@ 8@ 511 _1 5 e 5 5 § A 5 5,5 § :1 515 5 515 g's 1 151 5 5 5=115 5 51115 5 5:5 5115 5'5 5 5 15,5 5 515 5 5,15 5 55 5:5 5 5,5 5 5: • 5'555 115515 115515555,55 551 5155155115155585-51 5 5 5;55151551e555555515155 5 59 1 53815551 E o o a g p gig g g 4@. E. EI@ @ a m @. S � �� $ a g g g e g .� g $ 5 g;g'g g s g. g gLL� g@ d �•� E E g g a u'� g g',g g' 0 o e e a o 4 � • g e I8 8 8;§ ,§, a 8 §'§ § e Y, § $ '4 $ § 8 8 8'4 4 E § 4'4 4 § 8 18 4'4;§ § 8 a §!3IE 4 @ o@ § E 4 4 4 4 § ?;§ @ 4 @ § § § e o §'§ § me g 8 - 55515 g'?i@. 555 55 I5 vo Ig5v55@,'�I� � $'og'� � @ � e ? �,sl�°� el HI F ! HI p, n'ffi ,o 3 II § 3 a § § § § @ @ § § elg § § § § § § $ ffi & § @ m ;§ § § § o g @ $ �1� 's § § o e 3 $ § § $ 8 &, $ § § 0 1 1 § § 8 §I ^ § a § 5 $ 5 § § n '.5 @ 5 1 a.:e o 55 o d 5 515 15 51515 $ 5 0 0 0 511515 ® $ 5 511 0,55 5:5 15,5 55 515 5155 d 5115 515 $. 5 2 15 5. 5:5 5 5 $ 1,5 5,215 5 1' i 8 8 ° $ r 1 € 1 f 1 3 1 -i i 4 2 5 ' g 4 8 a n a 3 E .5 a F 1 $ t i s i €. 2 ! g g l �2 fi 9 _€ si � a � ' " ' r ` � a egg@ ` o e � i " y3 € a � e � o£ y � a • 9 . ppo q e 0 � a a@ g 56 i Ey 8 gtg Q f� S+¢, 7 Y 4 � g3 4 � � 2 � 3 4 4 E �� 5 J u � � :I s I` S I 1, 1 5 S 1.1 x 1 '1 I i i g1 6 3@ l i d F.l a f g 9 I1 7 [ ¢ 4 l i@ 11 ¢ rii y a i i i l l a f a l l 1s 1 s 1 1 i 1, " 1 'es i-m F I lBt g.- E '3 99 $ i f'7, +� Ilf ` s@ i n q 9 s 1 a ' a 8 a i s F i I i t 4 . ? - E v a •l ° a l i lli ll 3 S 3 i 1 £ e C Y R . I - Al E/ 2 5 1 _ 1 _ C i 3 . € j S i � 5 . L 1. .� 1 1 i ., - 5 6 _ 1 @ F s 33 ddd£ L. E d _ 3 _ 3 l i i a 5 6_ x - 1 iii 1 It @ t s 1 1. A g §l § § @ a §1i`§ § a it a a ' §'o g, ., g a g § §,s o § i ;II &lg g1H $ §i e § § g a g g §`E g . - 5 §;P o 5 § e s 5 E §,8 § § s a 8 a s;§ 51 § g § 5 §,§ 8 5 5,5 § § g a 5 5 5 g §i§ m § § § 5 § gl»i§ g`s § § § § wi§ '5 §;@ 5 § g g,a § § 01,5 § 8,-515 § 5 s @ s v §fin 8 5 3.i § § 5 § § 5 5 § §'m r iii 5 § §l §,g § 5 Vi o § § § 5 § iiij ri 5 § § 8 0 § § : 5 g § § 5 § § 5 5. 5 § rt. iiig §,§ z gfg §'s N e g,& § @ § §:o'.@ § § ''§;8 § e @ ':§ gio a § 8 g § a 8 e § g g g §jo ,gig @ g @s gig g § 8 @ @ §jo 2 1 § §;s o'§ @ § § § §;x '5 e 5 a GIs s 11 5kil8i § § i5;5@ii'5' 8@ 5 ; 155552- � E § 5 § §;l Fdi §'§'§ § §'sa § g §:gI i iliig § §,§ § § § § gP § § § s § § §'§'8 Pe § g § 8@@@g n' @@ § 8e@g'g @@ § e'§ ss@ §'m § n § § @@ § § @a•§ § @e iji 50185585@55 g@ 5 .'g § 5 g,i 55555 § S - 5:1 551,55 § § 8.1 § § §;555 § § § s §l § § § § § m § § § 5igiii5-5555i5ii § g § gg § gi888 § § @ g8 § § § § § § § m § sx i§ § §,§ P'§ 5 5 5'0 5 5 g!e HI 5 5 g 0 8 S § 5 §`§ 5 515 5 5 § 81 g 5'5 5 5 g E Ej:g s g'S g 5 5,5 515 5,5 g@ 0,51 5 5 a 5`5 §'e g; IS § 5 §10 @ 5. 51515 5 § 5 5 § s § 5 § 51e § 5 5 5 @'m a §,@ 5 § § §i§L@ § 5 5 § §is 5,5 § 5 5 § 5 g ss § § 55 § § 5 5 $ § @ § §tS 5 § 5 g '§;S a �5 5 § § s'§ § s § s § § § § §1s'@ § § § § § § § g § §Is § §.,§ § @ @ § s s s°g 5 § § g g4§ § § a g § § § § § 5 5 § 5 § § § '5 § 5'5 §;§ § § § §fig goo ooeeea•o�ooaoeePOPeoovoa a o 0 o a o e o 0 0 0 g § § g a g@ g@ g g g g g g,.: g g g g g g g g g g g g•e §,egg g g gimp§ § § § g g W c g "g § Egg § g g g g g g g g § egg § g; g g g g 8.n s 155 1505555555555,555555 . § § g § § § gggg @@@;g1555555I55 5555555 § gggggg s § g@ § § s § §'eagig g g @ rill's § § § s;§s 15 g s §ILi§ 15 §C g:§ § § § 5 §'5 s § § § s:§,'s;§ ggg § §;s g,§ § § g § ggg § s § g g § g g g g g § g o g°g g g s g:a !§ '5 §'§ § 5 § § § § § § § § § § § § §--§ 'g § § § § 5 § § § 5 § § § 555515 § § § § § §i§l § § § gggg '§ § § § § § § § § ggg §!§I§ § § § §4 " i g g §:§ § § § § § § §`m § § §'§ § S'§ § § § § .5 § § @ § § eggs §;5 5 @ 9 § § g 5 l e j 5 § § § § § § § g' § g § § § § § § § § § 5 5 § § § § § S v '§ § § § § s § § g g § § § g § § 50 § § §18,§ g § § § g'§ § 8'e 5 § 51'0 § § § § §'s'§;§ § r5.g § § § 5 § § § § § § 5 5 5 5 5'5 55 5 g 5§ s 55 5155555515555555555555555555515 gg §iC,555515555 55555555515555 555555555550 - f5 § 555515 § § § §§ § § § al § § § § § § §I § § § § § §' § § § §'§;§ § § § § § § §i§ 55555 § § § § §,§ 5 § 5 5 § § § § § gggg § §I0 - y g § § § § § § § 5 § § § § § § 5 § g §`§ g '§ § § § § § § § 5 § 01 § gj§g 5'5 @ 8 § 8 5 5ii §: 8 8 e @ @ 8 5.5 @ 8 @ e 8 § 5 § 5 § e 8 5 5 5 5 5I5 553 5,i:55h: g5555510o § @ggs § @0gm : § 9 5@r055. 5500 555155551,55555 55505555r,- 0 '§ § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § 5055555555 55515555555555 § § a § § § a § § § § § § - N (g § § § a § a § § a § § a § ala §'§jg § § § § § §;§ § § § § § § § ggg §`§ 5 § § § § §:gig §lgj5 g g g 51 § § § § § § § §`§ § a § § § § § § g_g 5 § 555555a § § § :§ § §�s § § § § § § § §:§ § § § § § § § s s § §t,§j § a § § § § § § § § § § § a § § i § § § § § a § § § § g@,s:gig l§ § § § § § § § § §s § § §,u's g'si§ § § '§ § § § § § § § §LLB § s § § §jg;§ § § § § § §J,ss' a:5 § § § § § 's g § § § § § § e'.§ i g § @8 s e'e' Ig 155 555 § § § § § § § § 5 § a § § § § 5'§ § 5 § § § § 55 § 5 § § § '§'§ gggggg § § § gggggg § § § § § § § § § § § § § gggg § 5 § § e o aP aeeooe o.eoo 'g5 ggg § § § § gggg § gggg,§ § 55 § 5555 § § § 5 § 5 555555555 § § 5 § 5 § 555 § § 151 § § § § § § § § § gggg § @-§i§ - ,. 1,0§ §'§ § § § § § § § § § § §I§ §Ii s § § § § a L'a s § § 5 § g;g! § § §1 e § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § g § § § § § § § § § § § § § § gig s i§i-§ '° 'ala § §105 § § § `§ § § R §;s,§ § § § §§ § § § § § § § § § §I§t § § § 0 § 4 § § § §,a1a' 5 § '§ 1 § § § § § § a § a § 5 § 5 § § § § § § '551515 - 41 § § § § § 5 § 5555 § 5 § § § § § 5555 § § 5 § § 55 § § § § 5g'515 § § § 55555: 551555 § § 5 § 515 § gggggg5555555 - Ia §' § § §Ig § a § g § § g g !: &'§ § § '§ a a § a;g,§ § § a;g;a § 8 § § a�$1a a1a § § § §`IJg § g § § § § § g g g § § § § g § § § § g § §_§§Ig §'S z MI gig; a;a §1§ a § gggg § § § g § a § § § a § § § § § § § § § g § § gala § § § §'§ § § a § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § §'§ § §1ga§ gggg § § " a I § a a § §;§,§ § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § a § § a a a § § § §:a § § 51§;§ § 5 g,§ ggg § § §;§ § g 5 § § § g 5 § § @ §!a a § §15 § § § a e;a § a'_§' § § § § § § § § § § a' a §'2g § §'§ 8 §°§,§ § gag § ] § § § V211. 2a § § § ai'§I§ § § § a § a a a_a § § § § agaaa;§ gg2 §' §,s ' Ig § § § s § g § g § § § § § §,g�a as g s g g 5 g § § g § g g § g'§ § § § § 5 5i5 g § § § g §I§�g 5 § § § g § g §is;§ g g § § g g 5 5 5 5'5 g 5'5 5:gig I§ 5 § §;§I§ @ g § § § § § aja a a a gja,,g a § § § §j§ § § g § § § gjg § § § 5 5 g 0 g 5 5 g 5 5 5 § a 5 § g § 5 §ila § § § § § § alg;aIa P 155 5515:55 § 5 § § § § § § § § § 5a § 51a;§ § § § § § §'aaa § § § § § § § § § § § 55 5 § 5 § § § 55 '555 § § § § § § a § § a,ag §`§ aa - {{§ :P P 510 §le,a_5 o 5 P 51,§:a a P P § § 5H5 § § P 1 P v § 5 P § e a 5 o ag ilj g,§ 15 a § § § § §'§ § a a § a §1:"§ 5:5 @,gig § § 015 m ig, a g s a a g a a a a a § 0 5 a _;§ § 5 § __'a a s 5,g a g § a a s §;m'§ g a a a a a •la g a § § § a a a a a a a a § a a a g aia a § § 5.g'g ^ I.§ g § a §'5a § § 0555555555 aa,gaaaaaaa § a aaa`Saaaa § ggg':§ as a a55555 § 5 § §,saga §'§ g § § sa'a ,a,g a 5 § § g a g a § `s g g,g s §'2'§ a s gig;§ ,g a :a'a § a,§ a s aj5 g a;g a a@ 5 5i§ g a § g g g a g a g §,a 5 g g 5 g §'g g m g g g'§.g'm s t§ g a a 5'§ g § §,8 a a § @ § Y ? ?la § § § a II § § el§ a § 5 5 §iss a a g § g a s;g 5 @ 5 5 5 a4'a 515;5,5 5 § 4'g § §,s S § 4 § s § s N 1 rA o r ; --j 1 -_I i oj 5 5 a shwiP 5,015115 g @ § s § § s § sa 5 s 5 0 a 5 a11a 5 5 5 5 § § s!a 5 5 § § a 5 5 55 § 5 § §1 5 5 § s § Pa a @ .g ? a , P5,.a. mggg §,a § § m § 5e5,a5gg §,5am § a §,§ 5.,a § 5 51 gig saa5aeag 551155555a § § 55a §'$.5@5155'a5a5515s e P § a g 5 § a a a a S s g 5 5 a a a a a 5 § °:a a a a a,m m@ 5 g 5 5 g i s,g g`g 5 § @ r e;§ § §,§'515 5 5 5 5 5 5 i a § g,S'5 55,m 5 5 5 i l l;3 n v e o g e a 5 5 515 g 15 §15 a § 5 p i 515 5 § s § sia 5 5 5 55 5i'0 5 e'a a g e s § § §Ise§ a § s'§ IN g g § 5 s 5'5 5 a'§ s § 5 s s 51 Y 5 a g'a s a 5 a 5 § 5 § § ala Ei,i1'5 § a §15;5 § § § a 5 151 a 5 §I§;§ §i§.§ 5 a § aka: 5 a.§I§ 5 5 a §Ia 'a 5 5 § a a,§ a ,a 5�§ § a 5 5`5 5;s':' 8 g g a s g'a a a @ _ �'§ a g'a ,a a a G, 'als e a § s x';a § a a §'s §'g gal§ a §'s g'g § §'§ a a e'a §'a § a . gig §'w'a g a'=' e a § § a a e 8,1 5.55515 § § 8 § § § § ggg,§ 85. m § s@ § iig@ § § § 5515;5 §'8'gg@,5 § § 551'5555 § 555185 5'51516a5g5:i-r,sa if i, 1 1 1 E -:i i r gt ,, e°e ' IIITiiasIIs—1 Iga "a i ii $ 1 $ 1 s =f$ 1Y iQ Qo la iiiiiigiiiiia i.IIIiiiiiIL - ig i § §Iiiii § I I I ILii@ $ #ia'- iiiiiiim illiiiiIIIH.HI iiiiii IiIIll - iIii IIiIi - IiIIIIIIIIII w i iiiiiiiiii - iILkiIiIf ƒ W - i_iiiiiiiIIII iiiiiiiiiiII § § § § § • § ii $iiiiiiiiiiii - ie1 1 1 1 1 1 1`i IJJI iiiiiiiiiiii - IIIIIIIIH`HI! iiiiiiiiiiii - § •§ § •§ § § i iiiiii i°i g 0 III 0101g3 $ iIII"Ii F` IbI I`•g $'g g. L e m,g II $$ & $ IhashiiI3IV r s `g ijh i i IJH`g'IJI e e Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Appendix E. Resume All fieldwork, report text, and maps were prepared by Marcus C. England whose resume follows. Page 2 �� Marcus ^ E n g I a n tit marcus@mcengland.com (V_ d■ mcengland.com 0 P n n c i a1 3 l o l o c 1st to 4 R englandecology® englandecology Marcus C. England offers over two decades of experience,with expertise ).�- ,t 213 304-1826 ig in avian biology,population ecology,project permitting, technical writing, ' ( ) and GIS and project experience in all industries. —a ' Mt.Washington,Los Angeles,CA 0 Summary Permits Marcus C.England is an experienced principal biologist with expertise in avian biology,population ecology, Recovery Permit TE-082233 project permitting,technical writing,geographic information systems,and database management.He has US Fish and Wildlife Service led teams on large and complex projects in all industries across the western United States. He has a fa Jan 2005-Present • recovery permit to conduct surveys for California Gnatcatcher, Southwestern Willow Flycatcher, and California Gnatcatcher,Southwestern Willow Flycatcher,Yellow- billed Cuckoo Yellow-billed Cuckoo and has extensive experience conducting protocol surveys for Least Bell's Vireo, Burrowing Owl, Swainson's Hawk, and Desert Tortoise. England has a thorough knowledge of the Scientific Collecting Permit SC-11354 California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and Federal California Department of Fish&Wildlife Endangered Species Act(FESA)and how these state and federal policies, as well as local land use and th Jan 2010-Present environmental policies, apply to the project permitting process. England has written biological resources assessments and biological assessments for some of the largest development projects in the state of Expertise California, including projects in Sacramento, Kern, Ventura, Los Angeles, Orange, San Bernardino, *Field Biology Riverside, and San Diego counties and has successfully supported project permitting under an array of Specialist in avian ecology and identification regional habitat conservation plans statewide. He has also written due diligence documents for large • Sensitive species surveys including Desert Tortoise,California projects in northern California,Arizona,New Mexico and Nevada.He currently sits on the Science Advisor Gnatcatcher,Burrowing Owl,Least Bell's Vireo,Swainson's Panel for the Clark County(Nevada)Multiple Species Habitat Conservation Plan. Hawk,Golden Eagle among many others Employment History • Large-scale vegetation mapping projects and impact analysis • CEQA,NEPA,FESA,NCCPs Independent Consulting Biologist • GPS and mobile field data collection systems dba EnglandlEcology(now EnglandlEcology, LLC) 6t Jan 2010-Jun 2011,Oct 2016-Mar 2020,Mar 2023-Present •Los Angeles,CA ®Geospatial • Author proposals,respond to RFP needs for teaming partners • Desktop software:ArcGIS,QGIS,GRASS • Conduct all aspects of fieldwork,data management,report writing,mapping • Server and geodatabases:PostGIS,Spatialite • Business planning,marketing,relationship development • Web mapping:Google Maps,OpenLayers ' le.._'Project Management Director of Biological Resources • Array of projects in many industries Bargas Environmental Consulting • Oversight of large multidisciplinaryteams Mar 2020-Mar 2023 •Sacramento,CA • Reliably on time and within budget • Corporate leader,department head,and project manager • Collaborate with clients,agencies,other stakeholders • Conduct all aspects of fieldwork,data management,report writing,mapping r i Office Vice President • • Operating systems:MacOS,Windows,Linux Mobile:iOS,IPadOS,Android Bloom Biological • Productivity Software:MS Office,Apple Work Jun 2011 -Oct 2016 •Santa Ana,CA • Data Management:MS Access,Excel,Ninox,PowerApps, • Lead development of corporate business strategy,obtain new work contracts PostgreSQL • Manage staff and biological data,conduct fieldwork,author reports,mapping • Server:SharePoint,Plone,Linux Director of Biological Services Education Natural Resource Consultants B.Sc.in EEO Biology Jun 2003-Dec 2009 • Laguna Beach,CA The Ohio State University Write proposals,manage staff and biological data Mar 1993-Jun 1998 • Conduct all aspects of fieldwork,data management,report writing,mapping • Conduct fieldwork,author reports Management Development for Entrepreneurs UCLA Anderson School of Management Chief Ornithologist Sep 2021-Jan 2022 Lamanai Field Research Center Certificate in Tropical Ornithology Sep 1998-Jun 2000 • Belize,Central America Estacion Biologica La Suerte,Costa Rica • Develop and implement ecosystem-scale research on birds Jun 1998-Jul 1998 • Manage volunteer biologists,lead birding tours,develop new tour clients t Below:contemplating the upcoming day's work during implementation of ., a contract with the US Bureau of Land Management to survey } 7 - r., i a _ "cri _r _, Pygmy Rabbits in a remote area of northern Nevada I i- ¢ Rr dt � ."„- _ _'''.4, in September 2017.England)Ecology led a ',,, ,,,r--+� , ,r _ three-person team that completed the t ... + .ti,. -. - s r ¢a work on time and under budget. E c -1-:-.4 we.. %. '. ,, ,'- - w . "k „ ' :4.. ", �- -t a1PF�•a i.I . -v -+r* , %:- . r ''h .' i' �F„Ci -`, r ¢. sti t ` Yv . • ;•, ' Marcus, C. g En an -.1, , Selectec Project History „ � �. 2017 to Present 2016 and Prior Upper Westside Specific Plan I Upper Westside, LLC High Speed Rail Project-Bakersfield to Palmdale ® Apr 2019-Apr 2022 As project manager and Director for Bargas, England conducted one year T.Y.Un • Sacramento County,California of Swainson's Hawk(SWHA)protocol surveys, managed SWHA and other ® Jan 2015-Oct 2016 species' survey efforts for two additional years, and authored a biological 9 Los Angeles and Kern Counties,California 0 Swainson's Hawk,Giant resources assessment addressing the potential effects of the proposed Gartersnake A Swainson's Hawk,Golden Eagle project on resources, including SWHA and Giant Gartersnake, within the• • PM,Surveyor,Author,GIS PM,Surveyor,Author context •of the requirements of the Natomas Basin HCP and the Metro Air Park HCP,collectivelyaddressing22 coveredplant and animal species. ▪ Biological Resources Letter Report • Biological Resources Assessment p Raptor Conservation Strategy Descanso Gardens Wildlife Management Plan I Descanso Gardens Guild Mitsubishi Cement&US Forest Service ®▪ Jan 2019-Dec 2019 This contract sought to provide solutions to some of the challenges of operating public gardens in a natural environment using guidance from ® Jan 2016-Oct 2016 • Los Angeles County,California nearby and similar facilities.The plan's goals were to increase the quality of • San Bernardino National Forest,California of Special Status Species,Wildlife native habitats for wildlife, minimize visitor-wildlife conflict, protect planted 0 Golden Eagle Habitats,Impacts garden areas and facilities from wildlife damage, promote environmental • PM,Surveyor,Author • PM,Surveyor,Author research and education,and promote a regional habitat linkage. Fieldwork for the plan included 10 months of diurnal and nocturnal surveys as well as El Biological Resources Letter Report B Wildlife Management Plan widespread camera trapping. Santa Clara River Riparian Surveys Harris Beach Management Unit Wildlife Assessment I Oregon Parks&Recreation Newhall Land ®▪ Jan 2018-Dec 2019 EnglandlEcology was contracted by OPRD to prepare a wildlife assessment ++ Jan 2010-Oct 2016 Brookings,Oregon report. Because of the size of the survey area,the field component lasted • Los Angeles and Ventura Counties,CA two weeks and included wildlife and habitat documentation (including Colonial Waterbirds,Marine remote camera trapping), hiking every trail available within the included 0 Least Bella vireo,Southwestern Willow Flycatcher Mammals,Spotted Owl parks,and camping with Harris Beach and Alfred A.Loeb state parks.Final 1 PM,Surveyor,Author • PM,Surveyor,Author deliverables included geospatial data and a report documenting what is B Biological Resources Letter Report known and not known about the wildlife and habitats of the park unit,with B Wildlife Assessment suggestions for future research and management priorities. Montebello Hills Conservation&Development Project Smith Rock State Park Wildlife Assessment I Oregon Parks&Recreation Cook-Hill Properties ® Jan 2017-Jun 2017 EnglandlEcology was contracted by the Oregon Parks & Recreation `•.`• Jan 2007-Dec 2009 • Deschutes County,Oregon Department to prepare a wildlife assessment report for Smith Rock State 9 Los Angeles County,California Park located in central Oregon.The project required extensive pre-survey 0 California Gnatcatcher,Coastal Sage Scrub Restoration 0 Special Status Species,Bald and research; five field days on-site with over 30 miles of hiking, wildlife and S PM,Surveyor,Author Golden Eagles habitat documentation(including remote camera trapping);and preparation ai B. Biological Resources Assessment,Biological Assessment • PM,Su veyor,Author of new geospatial data and an extensive report documenting what is known and not known about the wildlife and habitats of the park,with suggestions Terranea Resort lb Wildlife Assessment for future research and management priorities. Long Point Development Owyhee Roads Fuelbreak Project I US Bureau of Land Management Jan 2005-Jul 2008 ®▪ Jul 2017-Oct 2017 EnglandiEcology was contracted by the US Bureau of Land Management • Los Angeles County,California Humboldt County,Nevada (BLM) to conduct surveys for Pygmy Rabbit on 2,068 acres of BUM- , rat California Gnatcatcher,Coastal Sage Scrub Restoration managed lands.Two subcontractors were trained on survey methodology • PM,Surveyor,Author 0 Pygmy Rabbit and identification of Pygmy Rabbit sign. The survey was completed over •▪ PM,Surveyor two weeks, involving 114 miles of transect walking per surveyor in often ▪ Biological Resources Assessment adverse weather conditions and over rough terrain.Final deliverables to the Skyline Ranch Letter report,GIS data BLM included a report,photos,and geospatial data. Pardee Homes ® Jul 2003-Jul 2009 Below:conducting fieldwork in May 2018 at Harris • Los Angeles County,California Beach State Park,Oregon under contract to the Oregon Parks&Recreation Department. 0 California Gnatcatcher,Vernal Pools,SEATAC • PM,Surveyor,Author 15 Biological Resources Assessment —= CISee more at mcengland.com/projects •rt . r r ' � �rvn.7 m -- . . . g WE '11 t � � l' .1. ,WANT YOUR INPUT : f tJ . , . ,i,:- , .,,,_ .,1 igr...„ ., ,„„.„:1„„.......,..„,,...4. , „....t,.t., ,.... 1 A ,--,-" A i , ,,,,_*"t„i„.,:...,\,:::..:1:,,,,i:..:,,;yi::'v:'1::f'1:..,z..i,1,ie;:,ztL;t)':'-a:'::;;:T*::*:::::lo:;;j:;::t;,4?:':;L:_i..lv.i„-f:j\IL':::,;,...;-i-,..1< :_j : f).9:4;tr.....,1-0'1',,,r1_,:',1„-:\--7, .:, --":‘....,ti " _____...4'il I - '''' ',.'..A .,;j4.,k.,c : N.,,,tA.i., ------- ..,.‘---, - ,,4::- , , ---, -- _ R ,,,,..,, ,,,., , ., * _,. it )11 ). The City of Huntington Beach, in collaboration with David Volz Design, 1 /� -, __1,4 ... , .... , , 1 �� .ig. k 4 is hosting Community Workshops to provide updates and solicit further ,, i ��.� ,t T� ,1 community input regarding the Carr Park Conceptual Plan. i�, 7,, =p 1,T " ' e '' j ' 1 COMMUNITY MEETING 1 , f 0 4 . wl f °l Wednesday, May 17, 6pm, Carr Park(16532 Springdale St.) $ �rt��' t"` ips ti 1 .� �E L �,_ •���. II L VIRTUAL SURVEYi t. _ E "t'i Open Thursday, May 18—Thursday,June 1 at tinyurl.com�carr-park a 1 _ I : ' ii COMMUNITYMEETING2 t [ July 2023 (Official date to be announced at tinyurl.com/carr-park) .` - , if ik �. �'`r; Paper surveys also available by calling 714-374-5302. - �s El 4,1'. � Scan the QR code to visit the project website _ and add your email to the distribution list to :;,C- j; receive updates on the project. 14' ^� D .' ; ,.i x• To learn more and to provide your feedback,visit tinyurl.com/carr-park. ' For questions and additional information,call 714-374-5302. Cr,d 279 PRST STD WE WANT YOUR INPUT ECRWSS U.S.POSTAGE PAID HUNTINGTON BEACH, ON CARR PARK CA 92647 PERMIT NO.23 COMMUNITY MEETING 1 0 Wednesday, May 17, 6pm, Carr Park(16532 Springdale St.) ****ECRWSSEDDM **** VIRTUAL SURVEY Open Thursday,May 18—Thursday,June 1 at tinyurl.com/carr-park COMMUNITY MEETING 2 Residential Customer July 2023 (Official date to be announced at tinyurl.com/carr-park) OTo learn more and to provide your feedback, visit tinyurl.com/carr-park OFor questions and additional information, call 714-374-5302. ❑ :;•may ❑ t ti � Scan the QR code to visit the project website �, and RSVP for the community workshops. �F HEIL AVENUE w . iH }}} J^ II 1 ■ % P { a ■ it/ i r 4 t - U 7 s[ ,fxt� A. 101" PARKING ALONG _ 4W:�M1;r� ��}II" '�J a�. STRINGDALE STREET .I LA-21711/ • - �f __ A10-� - ✓ LKS __ __ /1.1. s �* --.- I, - ✓ _.. OUTLINE OF P /Y t EXISTING LAKE • l i ' `\�L f•�'- A AS +.f ice✓.. T/ } ``SC S4 ' 3 Jw. AD ■ 1• MI F 1c) ! A sr - lX f "-. .L� /-- _.. �. / 1 •; n 1 LAKE - • b �t�i' ,' X t- , EXISTING Y°[TER SURFACE SURFACE Tv B 869 t^--V -1 ,4,,, ),. y �,,;; EXISTING UNDBWATER SURFACE AREA 63.20 SF N AC R' fA OBI O`\`I ;• ,�q,1 3 - `• '#!' b" ,} Cf LK5 ,,,4 `\ � t . LA., tit ; ^, , �: +\ , I�.. .D 4 Q T: 4� , L f I� ° } � • ~�-A v k+I '' 1/0 L ~,~ STREAM R8 vegf AO ,,, ..., i— � r • .**,..=,f: til x-s L , w i jM1l`T{`T' }.• LK-0 t ,rJ'2.«+^-•..�.-/i»"i :r4 �f"'y4', _, \ w 1 pB % 41, �-• c -L LK-G . /r'l ''� 1 ^_-,„., / ryt� ^_ y �1 STREAM t12 l- +. ^-i _ s'` 1x" / i' 1 - e I`-'1C f '� ,, 4 - R T `_ t Y4 777 j � y' J { - ..;y > OA , ,;::% •MI M b �..4� LI #" " i s _ v} .{ T 'r.i V '���'°"` v ° �✓ STREAM R, Z E 71 si rE „y, e. I ,\\.,,,..,,.‘ .._101.,,_ ;,..t.f.i../.:. „7.‘ .H.,_ illieM.4 . T. 'i- T I LK 7 ,� Ll l ?-1-- �•�' ,Y <. PLA K'� ,�5 ; •'` ` y I, .. '- I \ ' ', j ' 1 4 0* t-, - i P 1A-z /�^y / Jam` ��I. ',. - "' "'., y 7 fi':F. y,y ... .��-;Y�'jF3'hJ' a iiirpso • • • LEGEND A-AMENITIES F-FITNESS STATIONS LK-LAKE IMPROVEMENTS W.00t LA-LANDSCAPE KEY 66244619244 r KEY BExRwTION el Al INFORMATION KIOSK FITNE595TATONS-ARFAt• U41 PROPOSED LAKES EWE PAVED YMLtW'AY,BNMe(AOACOMRINAT) F2 FITNESS 6TADONS-AREAS 1R.] AGUANG RANT StItF -' • VN MEADOW f-RAc5F5(NOH2TOWAf1LE) AS ADGER,.F LAKES EDGE 6 WALK FJ FITNESS 6TATIONS-AREAD LKS BRIDGE ( ,� IA42 NAT LORA55 D VNtE31DESEATBLOCKS FA PERIMETER WALKDIG 6 PERUSE PATH.;MLLE LOOP LLti FISSION DOCK .RU ryowABLEI n AS SEAM. 15.5 ARTIFICIAL REEF GREEN BUFFER-l9RHPUNTS A6 VEHICLE A^CE55 NOSE PL•PLAYGROUNDS LKE NEAR POND 6 B0FKTER VV4 PROVINNG VILLDIIFEVALUE AT PAVED SPADE lOACWWOOATE LAKELLf-1 LAKE EOUmMFM ENCLOSURE 6&PAR EVENTS SERVICE VEHICLES FOR PLA CRUMB.PLAYGROUND(AGES 2.1 51REA31st CE AND PARK EVEN _ �� Alt SEATINO.IOUNGING 650CAInNC PL.2 CHADREN PLAYGROUNDIAGE5621 STREAM b2 AB MEANDEfl WG 1RALLIOECOMPOSED PL. BARRIER FENCING STREAM 23 E%ISTWGTREE TO REMAIN GFUNMIE) PL< PLAYGROUND ACCENT COLUMN AtO T N.TUBE SSBE STEEL FENCE PL. PLAYGROUND SEATING PROPOSED TREE R M E SNADEO SEATING EA ci4 PL.? CONTROLLED POINT OF ENTRY AND EXIT CONCEPT A NORTH CART PARK J CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH 'S 0 'jT July2023 SHEILA AVENUE . _ � tag_ C ux , 11; ■ 1 , __./..,..,_., .. 1a , 1 { a i t 4 .B ems` tK-0 , Th,`'A• ,l �.' -Os '�- 0,... ..__ ),,,..)44001 ., . ..,,-:._ Ix,- H LK2 �--� __ , -- OUTLINE OF --=—'T r� "'y"? /e f EXISTING LAKE MI ' ;- ,A t,,An'., • a'. d ,k ay - ;Ili . -,,,.r LK-9 - < 1. yy _ £ '�'.aF I W`ti 1 t f. P. .ko= � / AS ■I E ; � ' 11X-4— �® 1L~-°( LAKE ' ~vaoPosmwaERsuRFA TJm " I EXISRNDLAX wArER simFADEAREA:RTAxsF J'I.K-s I Ic a r.- F ^ - AB l 'LJ - WATER LEVEL , ,L � "i 7 ,f _^VI _I Ai ■ � ? lmw i It,1,1,E1 EIEVi««IM_A9,+ 0 atl, ' 4§, "f/ .,_+vitt, PL 7,1 t £ ?, 1 -` -(•} 0 All : 3 tY d ei-s ;'y £ \ +'K T3. ..- of _`ill . (� PL 1 ELEv e< '-' S\; STREMI R7 z ice; .,+„ \� Fe }A { r �' isti r t cc d C 'j I i J ` LK•3 Lil 'e -1.1}. �,—LK-A J tAT F � Ty, �!, ' A9 LK-T I / ,r,AZ T'i'r I ` A` _ ,1k • G "I 1^ ,,,r v,F'.-. ,?, Y.k` 3 yp•,-l}t i 2 4 I PARKING ALONG .".._._'_ 1 ..Z- f '. C� F• .. \,ft�y�Y,,)-�'' Q 0. �.,,_. - LK-6 SPRINGDALE STREET p '1 �r �1--- e` �%r t„s,- A10 tMx +� e tiA �'wa-.a G '"� -: y \\ - o r- A6 ]y 71 as _ '� , i► I� � .- ML ± L± .--T = _ ; IN ( L ' „ Az n I LEGEND A•AMENITIES PL-PLAYGROUNDS LK-LAKE IMPROVEMENTS LA-lANOSCAPE Sm. or DESCP/TICN MONUMEM COLUMN wR;HRISCARR MEMORIAL PLAOJE P.1 RCHILDREN PLAYGROUND(AGES x?) LK-1 PROFOTaOLAKES EDGE 1I 1A.1 EASES GRASSES 1KONALOWABLEI Al WALKWAY.P.6.(ADAC01W ANIJ R-x CHADREN PLAYGROUND(AGES 64) la. '� LK2 AOUATK:PLANTS I,i� I A9 MEANDERING LAKE WALK.WIDTH VARIES,(ADA COMPLIANT) RJ BARRIER FENCING L.K. BRIDGEAx SEAT BLACKS Rd COLUMN All SEWN.DO. lAJ NATURAL GRASS MDwABLEi el n as SEAT WALL Ft, PLAYGROUND SEATING LK8 ARRFICNL REEF AB VEHICLE ACCESS DRIVE Rd SHADED SEATING AREA LK8 NEAR PAND6810FILTER Al PARKS UI�SERNCEAREA FOR VEHICLES FOR PL.? ADDITIONAL PIAY SPACE lK-T TAKE MOMENT ENCLOSURE PARK MAINTENANCE AND PARK EVENTS ONLY LXd LARGE ROCKS STACKED TO IMPLY JETTYISEA Wt. •• AS PASSIVE SPACE SFARNG,LOUNWNOS SOCIALIZINGlK3 ISLAND-NO PUBMCACLESS ;•`) EXISTING TREE TO REMAIN AS MEANDERING TRAIL(DECOMPOSED GRANITE SURFACE) - AID Y.N.TUBE STEEL FENCE PPOPCSm TREE A11 STAIRS CONCEPT B NORTH CARR PARK w,-L� fi CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH � 4`J A'. J" July 2023 HEIL AVENUE __ __ _ �u '," . �* .v1 \ f 1 ,e ! I '1 ' c * —rrt ,.Pt g ',1. 4 T kt'? PARKING ALONG . i�I e, A-11 ',I "X " SPRINGDALE STREET I IA-2 —I - , _� $ ....7,I ! j sG ,.. • J, ,,tteqd..5 a NEIGHSOPHOOD �, 44147 - �qy I : tJy 1 - �.. K F 1 1,..11 tav� ram." 1 # { OUTLINE OF EXISTING LAKE V; r O EXISTING LAKES WATER SURFACE I i( 1I AREA'S.SF t {{ i-/J} - �- I y O LAKE c, ucs f psi` .'y _. PROPoSED WATE j • SURFACE AREA 123.700S � t .'y'j, CD C y Iai' q� ciL'Y y�yp ,• a; r'd. CC ,. It 'mil rr:+�' '' r LK-3 �� It il.', '_ STREAM s2 f ,i� / + T f u-t ,ii Q �' /'�" d a '° `" ,.• f '1 a4�°V,..."......-4.L° � roar t t",' .� ^n.^,* IRE ,,, !• '^,. ' *�� AlE` a2 �'-2 LK-C � ,I; i� A-- �o (...9 1 `- - , ." / � i LA-7-7• el d • ` STREAM Pi N ,I1\ CK-�, :I A i .. '` M > . vT IlkA.` 43 LK-7-- tl Ly'=t1�LJ y w Z\ • p!-•3 - ax--"i" t t/�. , ci LK I 'k`'1S "! , LA-2". • .,a. 4,,-` tA" =1C '�, a y.._ , _ • A6 . jF a ��%y �A ."' ' t yr i ^rt�'--..{„JTY , "'. eilk itofyi 1� 1 ,@t t ) .. I I a�.4 s x 'rP. *� _ C' 7 ��, � t i t j LL LL �p ,� I }� i �; I i \ _ ;t_ r; LEGEND A-AMENITIES F-FITNESS STATIONS SYMBOL LX-LAKE IMPROVEMENTS LA-LANDSCAPE MEV. KEY DESCRIPTION KEY CESCIaPT.N CESCAPTION • s• KEY INFORMATION KIOSK FtY FIRJE35 STATIONS-MFA1 LK1 PROPOSED LAKES EWE rn LA-1 MEADOW GRASSES INONMOWABLEI AT PAVEDWNLOWAY,ALOSG(AOALOMPWNRN FT FITNESS STATON9-AREA] Ip�'r LK-2 AQUATIC PLANTS PS ACCESSIBLE WALK BLOCKS LAKES PERIMETER F3 FlTNESSEK WHG.9-MEAD AUG BRIDGE 9 M LAKESIDE SEAT BLOCKS F PERIMETER WPIKING6E%ERG9E PATH LOOP UL< FISHING DOG( I���� LA-1 NATUFULGRASS IMOWPBIEI n AS SEAT WALL LW9 ARTIFICIAL REEF PREEN EAFFER-WGHPLANTS AB VEHICLE ACCESS ORNE PL-PLAYGROUNDS LKE HEAD PONDS INSERTER - W2 BONDING WKMIFE VALUE AT PAVED SPACE TO ACCOMMODATE r LK-) IAKE EDWMEm ENCLOSURE LAKEA PARK SERVICE VEHICLES FOR CHILDREN PLAYGROUND(AGES 2-S) STREAMS MAINTENANCE AND PARK EVENTS PL-1 I� SEATING,LOUNGING A SOCIALIZING PL-2 CHILDREN PLAYGROUND(AGES St2) STREAM T2 I �• L OR MEMDERISSTRAR(DECOMPOSED PLJ PLAYGROUND SEATING EXISTING TREE TO REMAIN GRANITE SURFACE) 2. A10 TRNITESUEELFENLE 144 PROPOSED TREE OUTDOOTUBR SPACE FOR COMMUNm'EVENTS Al2 STAIRS AM PARK SIGN PROPOSED CONCEPT PLAN NORTH CARR PARK 0 IS CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACHIrDaTlitika September 2023 `r _ - - r 1� AUK -`_ s�.� — fi H� �1C+'� Ar At #W, IV 13 tArla Image Landsft'IW_C W us z , Data a S 10 -1 N OAIAI C.S_ IlaM;,l WNA,, G L b C 0 n, J. SMITH — JS&TM— T. MULI TECHNICAL MEMORANDUM DATE: May 30, 2023 TO: Mr. David Volz FROM: Jonis C. Smith, PE (JS&TM);Tim Muli, PE (JS&TM) RE: Carr Park Lake Concept Development JS&TM PN: 1018 JS&TM has developed a comprehensive lake design approach that creates a lake and lake ecosystem that mimics a natural lake system as much as physically possible. We include an eight (8)-stage biological treatment train in the lake design so that the lake can provide biological nutrient and pollutant control without the use of chemical inputs; similar to how natural lakes provide natural biological treatment. Our lake design includes the following treatment stages: 1. Aeration 2. Aerobic biofiltration 3. Anoxic biofiltration 4. Horizontal circulation a. macro trash filtration 5. Vertical circulation 6. Aquatic vegetation/wetland filtration nutrient removal 7. Fishery habitat (support biofilter flora) a. Sporting fish species specific artificial reefs b. Sporting fish species specific spawning beds c. Sporting fish species specific habitat and cover d. Fishery specific sport fish stocking plan 8. Waterfowl and Vector control measures Conventional/traditional lake design only includes aeration,vertical circulation and in some cases horizontal circulation. Conventional lake design does not result in adequate natural biological treatment and leads to lakes that must be managed using chemicals to manually adjust nutrient control. Thus, conventionally designed lakes typically have excessive algae growth and poor water quality. Our approach results in a lake that has abundant natural biological treatment that controls nutrients, algae, bad bacteria, spores, viruses, etc. Our lake design will not require the lake manager to use chemicals to manage the lake water quality. Instead, the lake management team will control circulation rates and aeration rates to adjust the system gradually, seasonally if needed. The system is self-adjusting and results in a healthy lake and lake ecosystem that is an asset to the community. Our lakes provide great viewing Carr Park Lake Concept Development Memo 1 285 opportunities, abundant fishing opportunities and are a pleasure to be near without the nuisance of too many waterfowl, insects, and vectors. A few of the ideas were discussed at the Community Meeting on May 17, 2023. Those ideas and a few other are listed below to consider/investigate to resolve identified deficiencies and issues with Carr Park Lake are listed below. A concept drawing was created to use as a starting point for laying out lake improvement/renovation concepts for the park (see Figure-1). 1. Natural bird feed dispensers 2. Information kiosks/signage 3. Adjust lake boundary to increase distance from road 4. Promote natural predation of waterfowl by supporting owl populations 5. Removal of some island vegetation 6. Provide pedestrian access to island 7. Remove island 8. Make lake larger 9. Provide increased aeration 10. Provide biological treatment a. aerobic and anoxic 11. Increase lake circulation 12. Introduce recirculating streams to the lake/park 13. Provide rooted vascular vegetation 14. Provide natural predation of vector by supporting mosquito eating fish, insects, birds, and bats 15. Improve fishing/angling a. enhance fish habitat b. enhance fish breeding/spawning habitat c. provide artificial reefs d. provide a fishing dock(s) e. create customized fish stocking plan Carr Park Lake Concept Development Memo 2 286 J. SM&ITH F T. MUM 33161 Corrrno Coptstrmq ake D Son ,um Ovistrmo, CA 92675 Fnaw_ 949.329,3639 Web:,C1MNCCOV (I 0 100 200 ft LEGEND Proposed Lake Footprint Fish Spawning Habitat Aquatic Veg Planter Artificial Reefs Aeration Pod Recirculating Stream 1 Recirculating Stream 2 Recirculating Stream 3 Skimmers Pump Station Vault Head Pond/Biofilter Fishing Dock Large Pump Intake Intake Line Aeration Tubing Discharge Line Carr Park Lake Figure 1.0 - Lake Features Concept Drawing • ......, ow- ..... i''''' ...0. 1.. 1N ' ' 0v4.,,\\tO \%NI , %4 T 0 .li,k, -.•'at0R P O RA7-•••• ... /.4.6 • _ ____.. ..._ _ _ I I 6 17 ilk __ __ _____,......._ _ _ _ �__ _ l� ___�__ . . Carr Par k • . - „ ....zQ Conceptual Plan ..,..--, , , _ , ,,,,,..7„ . _ ----- . • _ , ____ _______ . ., . . ______ _ _ _,• . , _ •.-, ol August 6 2024 •, F0- P. e Q ••...• / JUNTy...... ,1 288 Overview I Introductions 2 I Project Overview 3 I Project Progress 4 I Community Meeting and Virtual Survey No. 1 Summary 5 I Community Meeting and Virtual Survey No. 2 Summary 6 I Stakeholder Meetings Summary �NTING00 T <I <I �` ••ORPORq��• \ 7 Biological Study & Lake Improvements ���e.���N� Tfo�..% f� \ 8 I Proposed Concept Plan & Elevations - 9 I Next Steps =couNTY Oii 289 Project .,,,_.,..„, : ,,,,_._,,:f„,,,,::,,,,,:,,_ _i,.•_ 5.__;‘ , ,,,YI ti " 6✓la aob a Dr } i ' I! I .i 1_. Westminster Carr Park r ' i', � I f r% } ' \(St BLnaventure;t I Ii s�u.erAce Santa �I 1� 'Church _c, sPblvF , , = St, NATIONAL I L-_, I - \ r{DIY�Leriric____ • J�''^''_.J'i fj 4Y'.Ch WILDLIFE ^ �' ...- . „ i r N— ��l I. NE�UGE L..J ...• 11 r I I . - €j { I. 1 •ttm Drly. A. �..__.._....f II EGNGERAVENUE L..� I ,{ I C E I; b.v I - 5ur9s�L�PaGi I I :I I J 1 _. fie' Fountain Golf Course '�. .,nn o F a I i Sr nt Ch7 Valley ' Midd:e scno - •�. CENTRAL I \\ ee�,au�;' vARK ,.,t __ t single-Famlfy - e®n s�io ; ' Menrie. - -• iRegdentiall k.p e f L nNelg tborhood l I{ i r.;n I span i• I I - '. Huntington ! .: 1} r..T • Beach x ha lt7 v C do Grrxe,v yf•+ E . I I. ` t C x!n ,f.(ytri'$Yll S}• r '1 11, t. 0 twos h9 �, I I I �� a, �ii�N r— i 1� kz l w TIN N. N. 'Ali' -.N. i; /I O0(••�\N�ORPORgTFO•'•. \ �� ' v APPROXIMATELY 1a.7 ACRES , U: _ \ Newport �• i' ;; - 7.5C , Beach \�.9'�'.-- _mac y• %▪ -� � I. ' �2 _��NT`I �a,�� 290 Project Si „:„.„,„:„...„.„.„..„...,.„..,,,,,,_,, ..„...,.... ..,,, . _ . .. , .. . . . ._ . .. . ., ...... .. .. . . ,,, , „.......„........„. ....,,,,,,,,........„ .„_.,..,... . • . . . , . ,....,„.. , _____, . .. .. . .. s, .1k . . • __ _, . ., . , __. _— _� ".- _ r.,. _ _ , c., . .. ...„...., .. s. A� ... i .,..._„.. . . . ,. , ,, ,. , ' P.„-.*,4' r:-.7-'-'"'7..7.7.,,,t...-''.' ''' ,..'...,..,::::44,410,,t-ri ,,i,.'..,, — e.�.w...^ iY�a�,Imo}' 114�'.Ittl t1- �r', _ .c,'s�'-{mob tj IB 11�'�' k ''' U ,3 t�.tlie:-•-: v. ,E j V • r401‘, ayprt 4� , ice. t,,. _ ' ° }C6 -' k �re�t . $`w�'� r5 �t a �^'ii� a„a' • . ii 4f TC,1ey}. *'. t{€ .�` a .� '�:.'�" ..�� t. 'ti' t"'. :�" �-` � a. .,p�5,ir� +7 r.'. .+1�� d.� � b�� }. at 5 if t; 0� ., ' 1� - ! ,. II or k ,;� - n3� } --^'4ra�3 t� ,. �f �I ���� �pAPORAT 4.• �, - a� ,*: s ri � .n t e, , :WWII!!! '4:C t r x�, 5+ i g h t II4 p�\f.� I �J � �1) I 1 .-- \‘,;.'.,!„ ,,1 ���NT`( � i� 291 Project Project Initiated Community Outreach Meeting No. 2 March 2023 — Completed July 2023 — Completed Community Outreach Meeting No. 1 Follow-up Stakeholder Meetings May 2023 — Completed August/September 2023 — Completed Virtual Survey No. 1 Proposed Concept Plan Development June 2023 — Completed August/September 2023 — Completed Huntington Beach Fishing and Recreation Environmental Study Club Stakeholder Meeting February-April 2024 — Completed June 2023 — Completed �#1 NTINGT"— Community & Library Services Commission �•,,,,,,.,,,,•0� California Department of Fish and Wildlife June 12, 2024 for k ••� CORPORgrfo••••,•�F Stakeholder Meeting k June 2023 — Competed z _- -__ i • • 2-Concept Options Development ‘ •••..FB- � 9p9 o;.�'p� June/July 2023 — Completed ' 60UNT`i � ./ t 292 Community Outreach Meeting and Survey No . 1 OUTREACH MEETING SUMMARY NO. 1 VIRTUAL SURVEY SUMMARY NO. 1 Approximately 50 community members A total of 213 virtual surveys were in attendance on May 17, 2023 open from May 18 to June 1 , 2023 • Community introduction to project • Most respondents are long-time Huntington • Site walk around the park to discuss different Beach residents, primarily seniors (aged 55+) issues (47%) • Brief discussion/presentation from the design team • Most respondents do not visit the park often on challenges with the lake (41%) and tend to stay for less than an hour • Collaborative design discussion/charrette where (68%)feedback was was collected • Visitors engage in various activities, 0- 6....... ` '70RPORgT •..• including being with kids, walking dogs, 00 O :•`�N Fo •.��\ alone time, exercise, and relaxation 1I` :- �. c) \ it ; tinyurl.com/carr-park ; -__1 _- - s VISIT THE PROJECT WEBSITE FOR UPDATES AND STATUS ON THE CONCEPT PLAN y/ ? $ •..1e4Y *1' DEVELOPMENT FOR CARR PARK Is 9 Ao ❑ t. =�UUNT`! 0\7 f1 293 CommunityOutreach Meetingand Survey No . 2 1 J ^� HEIL AVENUE ,,,,,_,,, I' 0 m EIL AVENUE . ,\,),-- N_________. . -,,,,..,c -,,,,, J,c7--„..„ ...__ 10,, ),,y.,- ! l -,� , /,),4 OPEN ,r H , ,, , �vOPEN ..,C IQ OUTREACH MEETING SUMMARY NO. 2 t `, AAREA • '. A • Over 20 residents were in attendance on July 20, 2023 LAKE,, ..� t9. 1' ',k %' C'()''cP- ` i' • Presented two concept designs : rs, u, ttr, LAKE,- f : v� ' • Open discussion to provide feedback and input on the concept r,; a.NFaDGw 4 GRASSES f 1 l BRIDGE PLAYGROUND • "5 .j (7 I I ®STREAMS l designs 1r Z ,= .ki�G q : 6 - !u i:=701w U ti7 II*4. '!y iA tip '' N I GR,s9Es G W VIRTUAL SURVEY SUMMARY NO. 2 F ^:„N\-�.i � = r ,i 1, - �UV A total of 52 responses were collected while the survey was j - -- +----c open from July 21 to August 4, 2023 OPTION'A OPTION B • Option Preference s,�,-�%_ • 55.8% - Option A 11'1lNGTp OOAPORAT�' " +\ • 32.7% «OOhtion B er" 1I ---=_:-=�-�-��66.e' \� • Lake Preference 1 " :__` � • 55.8% - Keep an island ?,1--r -- Q t • 40.4% - No island \9 -4 `= - • 4% - "Other" �2..c r, '�. I?,19 P,,,:\ _o0/l = ..UNT`l �P,I 294 Stakeholder Meetings HUNTINGTON BEACH FISHING AND RECREATION GROUP MEETINGS. • Hosts annual fishing events at the park in May with 60-70 kids from schools across the City in attendance • Highest priority is improving the quality of the lake • Would prefer the island to be removed • Works in collaboration with the CA Department of Fish & Wildlife and HB Police Department during events • Would like better access into the park for events, with potential event space CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE MEETINGS • Evaluation of existing bird habitat and mitigation measures will be conducted during project environmental review. Will be reviewed by the departments Habitat Conservation Department #10ATINGt = • Department has resources for educating the public on bird feeding issue •0 0c�..••ojo P0RArFpq,. • Reviewed proposed concept plan, and are in support of removal of island and expansio of lake : --_ -g_ HUNTINGTON BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT \�9�''••.�Fa �. • Better Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) principals for security =COUNT`( CPS#' 295 Biological Su • �.o The CA Department of Fish and Wildlife recommended a biological survey be conducted at Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park to assess the impact of proposed improvements on special bird species and Carr Park,City of Huntington Beac,Orange County,California oFT vegetation. Sad.aaOYa CA9JItl! Methods • Desktop Review • Field Survey "1 26 2DZ' Results • The proposed Project will not have significant direct, indirect, or cumulative effects on - EnglandlE90199yeA candidate, sensitive, or special status species. Report prepared by England Ecology,LLC • The proposed Project will not have significant direct, indirect, or cumulative effects on under MNS Engineers. riparian habitat or other sensitive natural communities. • The proposed Project will not have significant direct, indirect, or cumulative effects on 0i1\\NTINO wildlife movement. 11 •,,.....•..,,,•0� `�Ns,OPPORAlF�•,• • No aspect of Project implementation would be expected to have significant adverse 1� : •• <<y\\ effects on sensitive communities or special status flora or fauna. ;; •_ • Recommendation for a pre-construction survey for nesting birds by a qualified biologist "s ''=_4 - • ;; ",• J - t to take place within 300 feet of all project areas within one week of commencement of \\ :,• F,y7 _= =11 project construction, if construction occurs during nesting season (typically February 1 to `c;CFe. ,:; �011 August 31). -_CUNT' 296 Lake Improvements The following are items that will improve lake quality, help alleviate the bird waste problem and initiate a `reset' to provide a healthy lake for long term use and enjoyment of the community. solutions ® Proposed Lake Footprint k -, r Information kiosks/signage 1-1 Fish Spawning Habitat „6 .'' p g �" y..,�. Az5 4�,., a a<< �w. �s Adjust lake boundary to increase distance from road 1 I Aquatic Veg Planter . • , Promote natural predation of waterfowl by supporting owl populations "" ° -owl box(s) i Artificial Reefs .k ,', , `1 s `° Remove island l .1 Aeration Pod `- • {, Make lake larger ® Recirculating Stream 1 _ #; ,Stream til rr Provide increased aeration ® Recirculating Stream 2 ! 'a • i li Provide biological treatment Recirculating Stream 3 r ;.•' ' ` I. aerobic and anoxic 1 Skimmers 16 , `�' 1, Increase lake circulation • 0 Pump Station Vault \' Introduce recirculating streams to the lake/park ; Head Pond/Biofilter • • fF ' Provide rooted vascular vegetation ® Fishing Dock '° , :` ;, Provide natural predation of vector by supporting mosquito eating fish, —Large Pump Intake ; insects, birds,and bats •� �+ /�i�i��! Improve fishing/angling —Intake Line 1 t. ,i .,., . s -� •''�P, ���/ �"�I N GT 4�,.Aeration Tubing .r ;, ° enhance fish habitat1 , p (yip -enhance fish breeding/spawninghabitat — Discharge Line ,g - «`. ; , tv+ r �(�• c,pRP0Rgl'•.. "14 -provide artificial reefs !Str , __ ________ - \ -create customized fish stocking plan v; _ + .,,-.. , • .„—, r.., ',4, '-+' .;vim - ' q Aeration. Aerobic biotiltratlon Anoxic biofiltration ° Horizontal circulation r„a a ' ' .. _ -1 • N,9%., z .QZ 0 ••'`Fe a°, O 1 �. Vertical 1flrcUlafion quafio veg i l Wetlan Fishery haabitat,e Waterfibw and Veotgt . ��C I) -. .,; ._. 1ttatl6 iiut ent'i o�fai . (support biofilter'him)az ., control measures ?"':' _�UUNTY C�,i0l 297 Lake im provements : Biological Treatment FISHING DOCK AQUATIC VEGETATION �`�` "�' *� *� .. :a i B'` ;, '' 3#+' 3 '-� :„. .`rip W h PS k :,q -f tx. PLANTER SHELF ' ' ' �� � -„,,,,,,J,,,,,,, ,,, .�r - • n * '`` Ai .:I,- �kIAX� I�'. � `' a�" '�„A, ,,,„,::: r ��I I I I I ,.L I I I I I I I I I I�'1 11 1 1 Li I t Air .dotar. Aim 0,e�� -r i Ncr o — ELEVATION 'D' ,,if 0�,,�\�,�oRPORgrfo••., �� \1100- \ LAKE IMPROVEMENTS ` > - •';n \ . ems, :; UNTN ��ii, 298 Proposed Concept HEIL AVENUE _. LEGEND m L� 1 'P,® AMENITIES Qi ® c,;,J ETREES ? � *.� , I (.. it A7 INFORMATION KIOSK r _ ,- , V , F�� �' a2 PAVED WALKWAY,10'wide(ADA COMPLIANT) I 1'' ' -. ' Ae 0 ' a" a3 ACCESSIBLE WALK ALONG LAKE'S PERIMETER J ti,.' 'T ''; y�j ' ,j C 0 : — O LAKESIDE SEAT BLOCKS «,a, w: �, / ( :ram f 1 - ® 3 as SEAT WALL fi t (-1-- I ( ' In`-,..OPEN GRASS " `.. r ;J,E x l', AREA m+ f• A5 V• EHICLE ACCESS DRIVE ••—. (k 1 \ SERVICE r 1 a7 PAVED SPACE TO ACCOMMODATE LAKE&PARK t \ VEHICLES FOR MAINTENANCE AND PARK EVENTS 'S PROPOSED .. �_ t' ,TREES �q�` A9 S• EATING,LOUNGING&SOCIALIZING SPACE F _ /, , • ;I 1 1 -. 1 ``��'' I, Ae MEANDERING TRAIL(DECOMPOSED GRANITE SURFACE) /, } 5, 1 ;t rf�a ' BARRIER FENCE BETWEEN STREET AND LAKE OFF SPRINGDALE w 9° \/ s , , r ^l1r' STREET H (r j LAKE ti t;' r '- cm OUTDOOR SPACE FOR COMMUNITY EVENTS w ../ �, KEEOGEy ( f, MONUMENT COLUMNW/CHRISCARRMEMORIALPLAQUE cp W--r "?�{�'<, Jam' t� �, o ,— f,,�v m4 ¢�; i4;^� -`4\ _ .• PLAYGROUNDS z . w• e ` ' ? • i l {' .; A9 n 9�`u't} 19 P7 CHILDREN PLAYGROUND(AGES 2-5) P ii i ` r - - P2 CHILDREN PLAYGROUND(AGES 5-12) cl- ri, :,to ?‘`, I �� � ., ` rzn GRAssEs � P3 PLAYGROUND BARRIER FENCING AND CONTROLLED ENTRY �� pl r ' "" f � , y_ � r/ P4 PLAYGROUND SEATING �/ ��+.............�O4j elk � � �f r ;'�' s (��( � 0I 0�4,\�COAPORATF...., (2 9 ' m ., m '- f , + - _ u• FITNESS STATIONS , .. •.-9 \ / " ': qk ; t=3 '' + FITNESS STATIONS-AREA 1 -- ' ..{� _' L Sri 7 . . t C I : C1:: Rass rz{ < I Jl F2 F• ITNESS STATIONS-AREA 2 \ S - _ N-1 )` L F �. R) RASS �v� �, � F3 F3 F• ITNESS STATIONS AREA 3 \\��. ' / 1 -• Cr } y o,r F4 PERIMETER WALKING&EXERCISE PATH-1/2 -( ••� 0 � ._ Y l ..�,FB gyp.••.'glib 0 ° 'l�' illF I , v- i > OOT Ci 299 Elevations PLAMalO AREA 7I/AK REGRRI WALKWAY GVEI . I m EGE STAGE GRASS PA PATKVAY AREA PLANTINOAREA , " (SPAS WIPER J TiS LAKE L. - ' ... X I-e '+'c1 t a . • d Q Y` �t `•. ELEVATION'A' STAGE,AREA FOR COMMUNITY F_VENTS KlEPGGN GRASSES , ANGRIPARIAN BRIDGE ELEV.102A0 (IT WATER ..I Y '` # . - 4,.,A FALL MVOAVIIR I0I. LAKE ELEV.IGI.GO •r/ Z�"T K- ;t Yjy s y �t POND WRIER LEVEL 1 zl . 1( tao.oO5 L f. 4 _it �; __ ,� N ELEVATION'B' ' RE-CIRCULATING STREAM Hl:SMALL POND TO LAKE EDGE /// I-! MEADtTY GRASSES N4. /0i�\NT I NGT°4., SIAAL MIDGEPOND ANJ RIPARIAN ( ) ElEY 1W.62 PIANTING WOUTFALL I .��,`pPPOR'�F�. �.HEAD WATER ` n lik k `..4 " ` Al a r LEA MD' ,I O .�_ C AT D• �v� SLIELL WATETFA11 • qq PGIm ":4, 1/'*.:J. y"'t?r' .r y .,A rA .'.4�6; .1 i �.� 1` ,,' ELEVATION'C' UUNTY C ,,1 ��RE-CIRCULATING STREAM#1:HEAD WATER TO SMALL POND //.001 300 Funding Initial funding in the amount of $ 100,000 in FY 2021 /22 and $325,000 in FY 2022/23 totaling $425,000 has been included in the City's Capital Improvement Program (CIP) for Carr Park conceptual design services, including the preparation of plans and specifications. To date, there is a remaining balance of $336, 113 to �� �NTT continue into the next phase of design . ING <c •`ORP"oRA••:/ Staff will seek out stormwater grant opportunities to Wok-.-- -q offset construction costs. Cp�NT`(CP 301 Recommended Approve the conceptual plan for Carr Park reconfiguration and authorize staff to move forward with initiating the development of design and bid package for construction of the updated facility. �,� ANT ........... 1. Off( .•\ �pPPORgTfO•• 6 .41110114 - � : Q1 � GF•' ••��F0l O�NT`( ; i 302 • A Nt� L Questions ?• ,,,,,..7%,, ,.. „., _ ..., , . „., . ... _ , ...„,... . ;. . ,i, , . ,,..,,........,..: et,...:r , . ‘..,,,,,i1 . .. .: , . ,i ,,, I .,,. .,p,.. ..,,t..... . .I'I--; rill �ll j trip:iii,. ,,, .1.,, _.. ,.....•.,, ,,,.,..,....,,k'c , .�y»{ , a ✓ }� "1 �({ eT$:_ eta - F� ` s ?•,y <smo h''"St, i"7� s x' nr $x : " . ''€ : g a .� (. � � d 4� yL Rd=Y-We 3 -tA 44'f .'M 1C } ,fit` 3 ,mot �y , / Y 303 From: Betty Kanne To: suoDlementalcommCa surfcity-hb.ora Subject: Carr Park renovation Date: Thursday,August 1,2024 7:26:41 AM Re: Item#19, 24-528 Approve the Carr Park reconfiguration conceptual plan I have lived close to Carr Park for the last 33 years and visit the neighborhood park quite regularly. I attended each of the on-site neighborhood outreach meetings that were conducted since the announcement of the park renovation a year ago. I was impressed by the quality of the options submitted, and I'm happy to see the project advance. I support the move to Approve the Can Park reconfiguration conceptual plan as recommended by the Community&Library Services Commission. I urge you to approve the ambitious design and engineering proposals that have been developed to address some serious long standing problems with the current lake configuration. The proposed solutions seem innovative and well conceived. The upgrades to the park are very appealing and I encourage you to approve the plan as described. Respectfully, Betty Kanne 16331 Woodstock Lane Huntingtion Beach, CA 92647 bettykanne@hotmail.corn Sent from my iPad SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION 8/6/2024 Meeting Date: 19 (24-528) Agenda Item No. From: Fikes.Cathy To: Aaenda Alerts Subject: FW:Carr Park renovation Date: Thursday,August 1,2024 11:45:33 AM From: Betty Kanne<bettykanne@hotmail.com> Sent:Thursday,August 1, 2024 7:26 AM To:CITY COUNCIL(INCL. CMO STAFF)<city.council@surfcity-hb.org> Subject:Carr Park renovation Re: Item#19,24-528 Approve the Carr Park reconfiguration conceptual plan I have lived close to Carr Park for the last 33 years and visit the neighborhood park quite regularly. I attended each of the on-site neighborhood outreach meetings that were conducted since the announcement of the park renovation a year ago. I was impressed by the quality of the options submitted, and I'm happy to see the project advance. I support the move to Approve the Carr Park reconfiguration conceptual plan as recommended by the Community& Library Services Commission. I urge you to approve the ambitious design and engineering proposals that have been developed to address some serious long standing problems with the current lake configuration. The proposed solutions seem innovative and well conceived. The upgrades to the park are very appealing and I encourage you to approve the plan as described. Respectfully, Betty Kanne 16331 Woodstock Lane Huntingtion Beach, CA 92647 betlykanne@hotmail.com Mr. Amory Hanson 8102 Ellis Avenue Apartment 121 Huntington Beach CA 92646 August 6, 2024 The Mayoress of Huntington Beach 2000 Main Street Huntington Beach CA 92648 My Dear Madam Mayoress, I would like to express my support for Item XIX. Sincerely Yours, Mr.Amory Hanson CC:The Honorable Patrick Burns CC:The Honorable Rhonda Bolton CC:The Honorable Daniel Kalmick CC:The Honorable Casey McKeon CC:The Honorable Natalie Moser CC:The Honorable Anthony Strickland SUPPLEMENTAL COMMUNICATION Meeting Date: 8/6/2024 19 (24-528) Agenda Item No. Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 By 1962 (Figure 3), agricultural land uses were still dominant, but several canals had been constructed and residential development had commenced to the northwest. f t . . ' ' ' 2....f.J.,,IN q '--r.t ''''',4 t ,' % 1-,. '' 4.• ^ ' ''. i; ' ' .rli;''''' S'''''''' 'a.. i t ��� ', i. , 'j"".. �F' Y . b x '- rt a � �p Y x r .:,,f,... �- ;,,N,,r,., .y .":?+,j ^'! , '-.,y, to A { G+.�t � y�#' m ..� I� �t M1�: 4 - I' e,Yt x�c „n 4`I 4 1'�( P f nc.' , g� .. fit m r* #I, s'.� Y"t A. ,, .4 , ,yam l;. a - « � ( s �r f� -'v Th ,� < # � t it i,rq _# +`� °i . . ..„; �y Y y {a 5..- 'r �y y} 4 • Fy' hY' ; P .a � M �,�� "�* }j 'gym. . �i�' 'L�`�.`S�X' a!�rj S 8 � 19.7'{ aF X` ' _ `- ' 'N . 35� ' e Figure 3.Aerial showing Project Site and surroundings in 1962. The approximate location of modern Carr Park is highlighted with an orange rectangle. Only 15 years later, in 1977 (Figure 4), residential development has filled out the imagery. Carr Park is now evident, and appears much the same as it does now with its current manmade pond, island, and walking paths. 7,,,,,,,. .. .. ,,,,,\ i Page 134 Biological Resources Assessment Carr Park DRAFT City of Huntington Beach April 26, 2024 Results This section discusses in detail what is known about biological resources in the Biological Study Area based on information from a field survey, 318 CNDDB records, 37 CNPS records, 29 IPaC records, and four critical habitat determinations in the Regional Study Area. It begins with a discussion of the Project's biological setting and habitats, and ends with a discussion of the floral and faunal taxa that are known to occur or potentially occur in the Biological Study Area. Photographs of site conditions during the survey are provided in the Photo Log attached as Appendix C. Biological Setting Modern Carr Park is a green space located within an urban setting. Of course, the region was not historically so heavily-urbanized. Based on historic aerial photography available from the UC Santa Barbara FrameFinder 20site, the area appeared to be predominantly agricultural in 1927 (Figure 2). _ .j l I. • . - y _ '1: 222a�r. t. • '- e }• \ ., ,1 Vj @ a '4 ::.1 i,''':''.; 4 � 'kz } 4 rW M ..4::,. ''1...C5;::": ,,:'t ' t: }' h Y yc f a� ! � - ,X '.�. lir .fie Figure 2.Aerial showing Project Site and surroundings in 1927. The approximate location of modern Carr Park is highlighted with an orange rectangle. 20 https://mil.library.ucsb.edu/ap_indexes/FrameFinder/ °,. Page 12 g��